Sivil Toplum ve Nurculuk.docx

8/20/2019 Sivil Toplum ve Nurculuk.docx

1/30

T.C.

GALATASARAY ÜNİVERSİTESİ

SİYASET BİLİMİ ANABİLİM DALI

DOKTORA PROGRAMI

TÜRK SİYASAL HAYATININ SOSYOLOJİSİ ÖDEVİ

SİVİL TOPLUM VE CEMAAT: FETHULLAH GÜLEN’İN SÖYLEMİNDE DEVLET

VE TOPLUM

ERTUĞRUL ZENGİN

1192!1"

ÖĞRETİM GÖREVLİSİ

Y#$. D%&. D#. Ö'()# ADADAĞ


2/30

Giriş:

199!*+, -,++# T)#/0-*$ 0#&%/ -30 45+303 %#6- &,/6,7,8 50-50 6%:+;45+

:#%+4+#03 $# $+, K)#6

>#/60303 >,' /'3$,7,8 S0-5+ İ5+4*,3 0# 0/60$# +6#360?0 %+#/ %#6- &,/6,7,8/%3%40/ +0#+0'5-%3 :%+060/+#,3,3 0?+5,-+ ## 4#/' 57 5%+ :#60+#03

6%:+;45+ 7,#+,/+#,3, /-64- =+$,7, ; $;++> G)+3 @460303 /3$0 5;++> G)+3*03 6+0? 5#+#0 #;++> G)+3 >#/60303 0# 500+ 6%:+;4 >#/60 %+#/ + +,3,: +,34-@7,

5%#;35+, 0# /#4 %+#/ 500+ 6%:+;4 ;3 >4 B6, A#;:*$/0 4@#5,3, >4 $ ;

4@#3,3 T)#/ 50-5+ $)=)3@503$/030 -35,45,3, + +4-, (#/60#@/60#. D+6

500+ 6%:+;4;3 5,3,#+#,3 $0# ; 5%#;=6;#4 (3+$ T)#/ 50-5+ $)=)3@503$


3/30

45+ %+38 $+603 $,=,3$ 0# 500+ 6%:+;4;3 #+,7,-%/+;7;* 5%#;35+,3 (3(0 /53+#$ 6#6,=,+$,7, ; 6#6,=4$3 3 (00 5%3;&+# &,/#,+$,7, +

+,3@/6,#. D;++> G)+3*03 5


4/30

B; $;#;4 0# $)=)3@ - $ 4 /50/

>4 $ 04/35,' 0# &- 0=#6 $#. B; &3,3 04/35,'+,7, B6, 50-5+ $)=)3@50303

(+0=04030 +0#+-3 '0>30-6 $)3-5,3,3 /50/50' 0# )6)3 %+#/ 0&03$ ;+;3$;7;4;'

'43 4/3$ /#345,3,3 04/35,'+,7,$,#. R03>#6 K%5++@/*03 0?$ 66070 )'#

5$0-%#5 ># '43 4/3$ +0#+0 0# (#&/+07 6/)+ $@/

#35++07 /;=0+0#. A3@/ /#4, polis*03 -:,5, 0&03$ +0#+0 0# -# %6;#6;-%# - $

/#4,3 (#&/+070 0&03 0# ;#; 5,3,?,3,3 #+,7, (#/ =#6 %+#/ %#6- /%3;-%# 05 %

3$ /#4,3 #35+ &,/+-,@, ()@) %#6$3 /+/#. K#4,3 #35++070303 %#6$3

/+/45, 0# -3 B6, $,=, 6%:+;4+#$ /#4 0# -%/*+;7;3 0=#60 %+#/ +(,+3,#. E7#

1 R03>#6 K%5++@/8 Kavramlar Tarihi: Politik Ve Sosyal Dilin Semantiği Ve Pragmatiği Üzerine Araştırmalar İ563;+ İ+60=04 Y-,3+#,8 2!!98 5.9.

2 A.(..

3 A.(..85.91.

4 A.(..85.9.


5/30

0# ;#; 5,3,?, -%/5 500+ 6%:+;4$3 $ >5$4-0'* ?%#4)+) 3 5,3,?+#,3 3 $ 500+

6%:+;4;3 %+4$,7, $5:%60/ -/+,+,/

:-, 0# /3# ,#/,+$,7,3$ 03$0#(3450 %+;#.

B+0#+0 0# 6#0>0 @%7#?-$ +0#+0 45++#03 0&03 $%74;= 0# 5+

6%:+;45+ =#6+#, 0&03$ $+603 $,=,3, $)=)34/ 0&03 500+ 6%:+;4 /#4,3,

/;++3$,7,4,'$ ; $;#;4 /#4,3 )6)3 0# -)/)3) (3 K38 İ563;+A-#,36, Y-,3+#,8 1998 5. ".

6 K%5++@/8 5. 91.

7 J%>3 K38 5. .

8 N%##6% B%0%8 G#45@0 S00+ 6%:+;4 K#4, Sivil topl!m ve "evlet : Avr!pa"a yeni yaklaşımlar #$%&'#(%&8 $. J%>3 K38 İ563;+ A-#,36, Y-,3+#,8 1998 5. 9".


6/30

B; (+3/5+ 500+ 6%:+;4 /#4,3,3 0&#070 1. Y)'-,+,3 %#6+#,3$3 060#3

$70=4- =+$,. K#4 -3, $3 K3*03

+0#66070 )'# $+03 #$0/+ %+;45;'+3,=, %+#/ $+660#. B;

4%$+ H%5 R%;55;*3;3 6%:+;45+ 5+03 4;6+/ 0#

%+;45;'+345, %+#/ $70+ $%7+ 6%:+;4;3 4)/44++=60#0+450 %+#/ ( -)/5/ 0# /,+5++,/

$)'-0 %+3 $+66 /:53,#. H(+*03 >;/;/ ?+5?503$ $-33 ; $)=)3@ 500+

6%:+;4;3 4%$#3 3+4,3 /;=45,3$ 3 K38 5. 9.

10 C4+ B+0 A/+8 )kti"arın *+ y*z*, A3/# D%56 K0608 1998 s. .

11 A.(..

12 B%0%8 5. 929.


7/30

H(+*03 500+ 6%:+;4 3+-,=, /#4,3 0&#0703 $0# :#$0(4 /,#,+45,3, 0=#6

$#. H(+* (+3 /$# H%58 L%@/8 R%;55; (00 5+$ -=4 4$30 %+4 $0/%6%4050 0&03$ ; $)=)3)#+#

?+5?+#030 0&04+3$0#0#.1 D%7+ >+03 =,+45, 50-50 - $ 500+ 6%:+;4$;#. B; 0/050

0#0#03$3 -,#6 $0+4'. O-5 /0 H(+ 3606'03 0/0 /;6;3 $+6 500+ 6%:+;4;

-#+=60#40=60#. D+6 %3;3 ?+5?503$ 3 -)/5/ /,+ $)'-03 0=#6 $#. S00+ 6%:+;4 ;

$;#;4$ 50-50 6%:+;4; 0-##=0 %+#/ 50-50 6%:+;4;3 -30

D+6*03 (#0503$$0#. B; >0-##=0/ /%3;4+3$,#4 500+ 6%:+;4;3 $+6 /+, 6#?,3$3

$)'3+3450 (#/3 /#,=,/+,7,3 $)'350'+0703 +3, %+#/ 63,4+345,3, (#/60#0#.

N%##6 B%0% ; $0 4& $70+. O )6)3)

$70+ ;#; 5,3,?,3,3 &,/#+#,3, 5;3;#. M# H(+*03 /503 500+ 6%:+;4; :5$0:8

#35+0 500+ 6%:+;4$3 #4,=6,#. Y5*3,3 >)/)4#3+,7,3$38 50-5+ %+3$3

>5$0+@/5 ; #$0/+ %+#/ H(+*03 50-56 ?+5?503$ %#6- &,/#. M# 50-5+%+3,8 -5 #35+ #-,=,3, $+603 +3,3$3 &,/#,: 500+ 6%:+;4 $#640=60#.

B)6)3 ; /#45+ 6#6,=43,3 -:,+45,3,3 508 T)#/ 50-5+ $)=)3@503$ 500+

6%:+;4 /#4,3,3 >3(0 3+4+#, 0>60 $@/ =/0+$ /;++3,+$,7,3, $=0?# 64/60#.

13 A.(.8 5. 9.

14 A.(..8 5. 99.

15 A.(..8 5. 9.


8/30

K#4 0?$ $0+4- &+,=,+$,7, )'# 506 0# 43-, $)=)3@ 6#0>0 %-;3@ 6=,44,=6,#.

Z43 0&03$ 6%:+;45+ 50-50 =#6+#,3 /%=;++3$,#,+45,-+ /#4,3 0&#0703$

$70=0/+0/+# %+4;=6;#. A3@/ 6)4 ; $70=04+# 0&03$ /#4 5)#/+0+07030 #3 %#6/+,/+#

;+;34/6$,#. T)#/ 50-5+ $)=)3@503$ /#4,3 0'030 5)#4/ 0&03 /#4 6#?,3$ ++0

0# 3+4 $0#50 %+;=6;#4/ (#/0-%#$;. B; 6%#0/ 6#6,=43,3 /,5,6+, 0# =/0+$

-:,+45,3$/0 4& =/ 0# 6#6,=4- 04/3 #0+4/ 0&03$0#. O 6#6,=4$ T)#/

50-56 $)=)3@503$ 500+ 6%:+;4 $)=)3@50303 3 =/0+$ %#6- &,/6,7, (+0=6070$0#.

C) T/r0 Si%,.et D/ş/#1e.i#de Si&i To(*

M0@>+ +'#*,3 0353 6%:+;+;/+#,3,3 >0&0# ()& 6#?,3$3 '%#+34/5,',3 0&03$

>#/6 $0+@/+#08 /3$030 +0#+-0+@/+#0 +3,3 $,1 %+#/ 63,4+$,7, 500+

6%:+;4;3 $)=)3@ $)3-5,3$ 6/## 6/03 0# =/0+$ %#6- &,/45,3,3 3$30 3$0#

+'#* (#/6+34 D%7; A#;:+, 50-56 $)=)3)#+#0

6#?,3$3 (+@/60. S


9/30

/+$,#,+4,=6,. D4%/#50- (&0=6 500+ 6%:+;4;3 6/## @3+3$,#,+45, (#/6070 $)=)3@50

># 70+04$3 -$,3+#,3 %#6/ 54%+) %+4;=6;.19 Ö-+ /08 12 E-+)+ 19! 5%3#5, $+$3 4$30

>+ (&0=6 4$30+=4-+ )/)46 :#6050 ANAP*,3 500+ 6%:+;4; 03= $@/ 0# ;#;'0 5,3,?, %+;=6;#@7,3 $0#

033&+ :/0=0-%#$;. D6,#, 5-,+, 0# /4;%-;

%+;=6;7;3; 5;3;#. 03508 N4,/ K4+ (00 -$,3+#,3 ('6@0+0/ --,3 &+,=4+#,-+

%#6- &,/3 /4;%-; 3; B6, A#;:*$/0+#$3 -,#3 ++0 0# 6%:+;45+ 5,3,?

19M3$#5 F,3#8 F%/ H;/;/+; T%:+;4 K4;5+ A+3 V$ M, O6360/ K04+0/ P%+060/5, M,/0 K*reselleşme sivil topl!m ve )slam : T*rkiye *zerine yansımalar 8 $1 E. ;6 K-438 A. Y=# S#,-8 A3/#V$0 Y-,3+#,8 5. 2222".

20 A+0 Y=# S#,-8 Postmo"ernite, Sivil Ttopl!m ve )sl2m, İ563;+ İ+60=04 Y-,3+#,8 1998 5. 119.

21 A.(..8 5. 12!

22 A.(..8 5.12.


10/30

$-34,-%# %+45,$,# .2 O543+, İ4:#6%#+;7;*3$ B6, A#;:*- 5+ %+#/ %#6- &,/44,=6,#. B;

5:+ B6,*$ 40++0 &,/# $3$070 '43 /0=0 (#;: # '43

#$,# D+6*0 /%#;4/ /$# 033@,3 5?+,7,3, /%#;4- 4&+-3 0# /,4 ># '43

M)5+)43 # %+(+40=60#. M#$03* (


11/30

0+ %+5 5>0: %+0+40=60#. C++0 İ5-3+#, 6#', 19. -)'-,+ +/ -/+34+#,3, 500+

6%:+;4;3 0# 564/ ()&6)#. D> #/5 0&03 ;-(;+3@/ Y5*3,3

-)#)#+)7 /%345, 0&03 $ /;#;@; #/ -30 $+6 0>60-& #$,#.

#0? M#$03 500+ 6%:+;4 )'#03 -'$,7,3$ 6#0> >3)' 19*6). D#303 -%/ 66070

500+ 6%:+;4;3 6/## 0/450303 4)4/)3 %+;: %+4$,7, 3 )-)/ 45+-$0. S00+ 6%:+;4

0# 5,3,?5+')4#0 /446 M$03*- (+0# (+4' 0# 3)?;55-,4, -:6,#$,. N)?;5 5-,4,3 (;$0+#$3 6=//)+ 64/6-$0. P-(4# M$03 =>#0 0&03$ $)'3057+4/ /0+ 5=+#,3 5%3 #4/ 4@,-+ M//*0 :;6:#56 A#:+# Y>;$0+#+ ## "4$$+0/ V50/*-, 04'+$,. B/,3,'8 A+0 B;+&8 M$03 V50/5, H//,3$ G3+ B0+(0+#8 -irikim8 3%.9H'0#3T44;' 19928 5. 1!211!.

29 A+0 B;+&8 D03+#03 4-$3 %/;-;=; E36(#0'4 ?;3$436+0'48 -irikim,3%."8 M-,5 19928 5. 22".


12/30

64+03$ &%7;+@; 0# 6%:+;4 -:,5, /040-60 $70+8 /6,+,4, -6 (&0##/8 >#/5 ># 6%:+;+;7 0# #$ -=43,3

4)4/)3 -%++#,3, ()/)4+#0 0>60 64/6$0#.2B;+&* (/040-6 /;#44,=6,#. H#/5 /3$0 0:60#

V50/ %/60? >)/)4+#0-+ )6)3 $03X 5%5-+ +%/+#,3 )56)3$$0#. Y308M)5+)43+#8 Y>;$0+# M)=#0/+# %3;3 (3+ &#&50 $,=,3 &,/4'+#. B;

30 A.(..8 5. 2".

31 A+0 B;+& M$03 V50/5, H//,3$ G3+ B0+(0+#8 5. 1!.

32 A+0 B;+& M$03 V50/5,*3,3 $03 ?#/, (44$ 6#?,3$3K;#-=+0 Y5#0+0 4)*403+# M)5+)43+# ;3+# 60 %+3+#+ -03 %3+# 5%3#$3 0+60>/

640= %+3+# %3+#+ ## @0>$ $3+# 0&03 %+4/ )'# 63'04 $0+40=60#. 2. M$$ İ=6 ;3+#8 $07# 0353+#$3 -#, 0# )446 @40* 6=/0+ $#+#. 1. M$$ Y>;$0+#$3 0' 60%+3+#8 ';+4 ;7#4/5,',3 %3+# 4;#,' %+3+#+ -#$,4+=,+4/5,',38 -#$,4 4)'>#6040' >/ /'3@/+#$,#. 2. M$$ B3 A? Y>;$0+#08 4)*403+#+ 0#+0/6 İ3H0=4*$ ;8 4* [ 0+ %+#/8 E U-$*$ 05 403 [ $3 %+#/ '0/#$0+0#\ 0# )446 @40* 6=/0+ $#+#. Y>;$0+#03 $03+#0 /3$0+#038 4)*403+#03 $03+#0 /3$0+#03$0#. B;3 (#/4++#, (#/5 0''6 /3$0+#0 $>0+$0#+#. B/,3,'8 .(..8 5. 1!1!"

33 A.(..8 5. 1!.

34 A.(..


13/30

3+4$ /#=,+,/+, 3+=4 5%3;@;3$ %#6- &,/4,= V50/8 K;#*38 T#6 -#+=0/ 46

İ35+*$3 (+$0. İ35+8 İ5+4 (+370 0&03$ $40 4#/'0-6&0 &%7;+@; 0# (+3703

#+,7,3, 05:6 64- &+,=3 B;+&*,3 &5,3,3 3(0 0# 6%:+;+;/ $70+$0# % ># =-$3

35 A.(..8 5. 1!9.

36 A>46 İ35+8 T%6+06#'048 M$03 V50/5, Ö'()#+)/8 -irikim8 3%. "8 M-,5 19928 5. 1.

37 A+0 Y=# S#,-8 5. 12".

38 A.(..


14/30

0: 0# 6%:+;4$;#. S#,-* (0: %+4-3 0# 6%:+;+;7;3 500+ 6%:+;4;3 :#&5, %+#/ (# 3 /$# D+6* /#=, 0# ()& +3,3,

6450+ 64 /:50650 %+5 $8 -3, @46 -:,5,3,3 0# 5%3;@; %+#/ -#/6

4)3$40& %+3 4& -#, 0# 40++0 $+6 %+;=6;#4/6,#. S#,- ># 40++0-6&0 >#/603

5+,3$ 6%:+;4;3 /3$0 /3$03 6:,345,3 -%+ &@7,3, 0$$0 $#/8 K)#6 >#/60303 500+

6%:+;4 # 6)#+)

İ5+40 >#/6 İ5+4*,3 $%75,3$ %+3 %6%#06# T>0$ 3+-,=,8 ># 6)#+) 630/ - /)+6)#+

6+:6 ;+;33 (#;:8 40++0-6&0+0703 $%75,3$ %+3 +6#360? $+6 6>--)+) 50-+ 500+

6%:+;4;3 $,=,3$ ,#/,+@/5 500+ 6%:+;4 %+#/ >3(0 (#;:+# /;+ $0+@/60# B;#$

%#6- 0#/& 5%#;3 &,/,-%#. B;3+#$3 0+/0 7# 0# /0=0 ># >3(0 0# @46 - 50-5+

>#/6 435;: %+4$3 /3$05030 İ5+4@, - K)#6 40++0-6&050 %+#/ 63,4+,-%#5 /3$0033@, - 40++0-60 0+ 0+(0+0 ;+;3@7, >#>3(0 0# 6+:8 45+ /6,+@7, 0# 04'

/4:3-5,8 500+ 6%:+;4 /600650 %+#/ /;+ $0+4-@/ 40*S303 0$%+%03 -

033@,3 $%75, (#70 %6%#06#$0#* $30+#/ ; /0=0+#$3 (+@/ 6+:+#0 500+ 6%:+;4;3

39 A.(..8 5. 11.

40 A.(.8 5. 12.

41 A.(..


15/30

$,=,3$ (+0/$3 5/,34-

7+, %+$;7;3; 0$$0 $#.2

G++3#* (# 6)#+) 033@ 5>0: /3$030 %

033@ (#& $0+450 (#/60#$07030 $)=)3$)#)# /0

;3;3 $ 0# 6)# +0/ %6%#06#0'4 -%+ &45, 4)4/)3$)#. Ö#3703 T)#/0- C;4>;#0-60303

6/ :#60 $#>3(0 0# $030 033@ 5>0: %+4-3+#, /3$050-+ =06 (#>3(0 0# -#,4

42 E#356 G++3#8 5on"itions o6 7i8erty: 5ivil Soiety an" 4ts 9ivals8 L%3$#8 1998 5. 1!!.

43 A.(.8 5. 9.

44 A.(..8 5. 1.


16/30

-:4$3 /4;5+ +3$ ; /0=0+#+ =06+0/ 3+-,=, 0&03$ 0+60=04 >+03$ %+4/ =/+03$

63,4+3,#58 % '43 /0=0303 /3$05030 M)5+)43 - $ H#0560-3 %+#/ 63,4+45,3,3 500+

6%:+;4;3 %+;=;4; &,5,3$3 >#>3(0 0# 5/,3@5, %+4-@/6,#.

İ5+4*,3 $4%/#50- - 500+ 6%:+;4 /#4,3 ;-(;3+;7;3; 6#6,=3 E#356G++3# A+0 Y=# S#,-* /,-5+ %#6 -%+@; $)=)3)#+# $ 4@;66;#. B; $)=)3)#+#

50-50 İ5+4*+ 0#-5+ 033& %+3 İ5+4*, -,#6 $#. B554 T00 $4%/#60/+=4 5$@

B6, A#;: 4#/'+0 %+#/ + +,34-@/5 /0 ; 6;6;4 %3 (0> %+44/+ 5;&+45,$,#. A3@/ ; &+0=/0+0 $;#;4 5%3 6>+0+$ -3, 033@

5>0: %+$;7;3; 5 V/?, Y;#6 Y-,3+#,8 H'0#3 19998 5. .

46 A.(.. 5. .


17/30

M$03 V50/5, 3,3 &%7;+@; 0# 6%:+;4; %#6- &,/#@/ 0# 4%$+ %+;: %+4$,7, 5%#;5;

-3,6+34$,. A>46 İ35+*03 A+0 Y=# S#,-*,3 +=60#0+#0 ># 3 /$# 6#6,=43,3

&,4+345, 0&03


18/30

B)6)3 ; 6#6,=4+#$3 5%3# 45+- 35,+ /4+,-,' Ö3@+0/+ 0# $;#;4

65:060 -:,+45,3$ ?-$ #. İ5+4500+ 6%:+;4 0+0=/050 /%3;5;3$ $#>3(0 0# @46 0$0-6 $;-4$,7, (008 50-5+ İ5+4* $ 0$%+%0/ %+#/ -/,3

$;#4-3 3@/ 0# 6%:+;45+ /04+0/ %+#/ /3$05030 M)5+)43 %+#/ 63,4+-3 /0=0+#03

$;#;4;$;#. İ/03@050 0+/ $;#;4;3 /#=,6, %+#/ >4 @46 435;; %+;: >4 $ İ5+40 0#

#04 #';+-3 /0=0+#03 $;#;4;$;#. Ü&)3@)5) @46 435;; %+445,3 #743 İ5+4*,3

50-5+ 0$$0+#,3, 5;33 /0=0+#03 $;#;4;$;#. D4 0# @46 435;: %+;: >4 $ İ5+40 0# #040 #';+-3 /0=0+#03 4 $ >#>3(0 0# @46 7+, %+4-3+# /0=0+#03 $;#;4;$;#.

E7# ; /0=0+# ($?030 (#&/+=60#4/ 0&03 >#>3(0 0#


19/30

5%3# /0 ;++> G)+3 @460303 500+ 6%:+;4;3 0# ;35;#; %+#/ (;++> G)+3 *>0'46* >+030 =; =/0+$ 63,4+4,=6,#

N4; 30=3 3$0# 0+4'8 4/4 435, -++> 64'+#. İ&+#03$6;6;=6;#$;/+#, 5%35;'+;/ 6=08 %3+#, ># =-$3 4)56730 /,+4,=6,#. B0# 4;4 (00#0-3 3+0/+#03$8 @0>3+# -$,3+,7 /;=;# 48 %3+#,3 (5,3 /;++34/ 0564'.1

G)+3 (+@703 404#+#, 054030 #$070 ; /0=0+#$3 0#-5+ 5-,+0+@/ >#

6)#+) 056/8 #'; $)=)3@-0 0# /3# ,#/4+#,3, 0560-%#. S$@ =/+#, 0&03 -=-@/

;3; -:#/3 $ 0&+#03$ ># >3(0 0# (;#;# %+;=4-@/6,#. K3$0 3+0/+#030 6443

%#6$3 /+$,#45, 05633 ; /0=0+# 3@/ ; =/0+$ +-,/,-+ >0'46 -:0+0#+#

K3$0 5$6+#03 /#=, -3@, +0+$0703 $07#(4$,#+#. N))603 &%/ =/+#,3,3 +''6 @,+#,-+ $%+; %3+# 0&03#$,#+#.2

G)+3* ( (#0+3+#] B03 4;=6; %+5;38 =>50 >' '/+#030 0&03$ -=$,/+#, 6%:+;4 ?$ $3+#

51 A$)+?66> >038 ağ ve ;esil 8 İzmir: T.Ö.V. Yayınları, 1985, 58 11!.

52 A.(..8 5.111.

53 A.(.. D-3,/+,$,#+# $#,+4' 0+4'+#. M)54> 64%5?#03 &#:3 /03


20/30

G0: 0# 0#-

3+-,=, -%/6;#. C46 435;; /3$05030 6%:+;4 - $ @46 ?$ 64+0$0#. O3;3

6%:+;4 >#0@03$ 0# 6;6;4 6/,345,8 /0=05+ 0# 6/,4 056/+#03 :=03$ /%=45, 0-0

/#=,+34'. S%3 $#@ 0$+0' $0+40= 0# -/+=,4 5>0: %+3 G)+3*03 /+360+#0303 3

/$# /#=,+30+@70 +66 6#6,=4- &,/6,#. A3@/ 6)4 ; 0?$+#0 3 ',3$3 0# '0>03

-:,5,3, %#6- /%-45, /,4,3$3 /;=/;5;' ;++> G)+38 Asrın


21/30

H)+58 4)403+#8 043 K;#*3 >0'460 $,3 -:@/+#+#, ># 45+-0 4=#6$@/8 360@$ 45+-0 0# >)/4 7+-@/+# 0# 5+?6 -:4 04/3,3 5>0: %+@7, 4&>;+$)#. M=#603 >3(0 /;#++#

;-(;3 %+#/ -:,+45, (#/60708 /##+#, +,#/3 3 (00 ;5;++# $0//6 $0+450303

0563$070 (00 3%/6+# G)+3*03 5?' 648 %3; /%#;4

/%++4 >5550-60 7,# 54/6$,#. A3#=0 0&#0503 $)=)+0+@/ 3 /;+> G)+3*03 0#- /%3;5;3$/0 ; 6;6;4; 3+=,+,# ;+;30+0#. Ö-+ /0 @46/#4,3,3 /3$050303 0#-5++0/63 ?#(6 64-0 0&#$070 &,/6,#. A3@/ G)+3*03 0?$+#0

?#(6 - $ ?$/#+,/ (00 /#4+#,3 >038 5. ".


22/30

B0#-+#03 056/+#03$3 #,3$,#,+4,=8 >#/503 0#0#0 0&03 -=$,7, ; 6%:+;4 4%$+0

;+=,+45, /+33 )6%:-$,#. G)+38 A5#, S$6 6%:+;4;3;3 (+@/6 $ %#6- &,/45,3,

/+4/6$0#. E7# >#/5 0#0#0 0&03 -=# 3@0++0/63 ;'/ $;#;#5 /+33 >;';#

6%:+;4; ';>;# $@/60#

B; 060#+8 40++6& )6)3 &,#:,3,=+#,4,'8 0353,4,', ;';# 6%:+;+;7; >+03(60#4 0560/4603$ %+4+,$,#. H505 5?0+ $;-(;+#$3 #,34,=8 -)@ +4+#$%7#; :#' $3 0# >;';# 6%:+;+;7;^ A5;$ 0@$3+, ?#6+#0-+8 430-6 5$6(4'$3 0++#0-+Q 5;+> 5)/;3 *$$3 40++60-+ 0# >;';# 6%:+;+;7;^.9

#60+6%:+;4 0#+070 ()+3 $)=)3@50303 3>6# /#4,$,#. B0#- 0+$ 0-0 0#

70604 +@/8 6%:+;4 0+$3 =+4/ )'# 0#+0/ )6)3+)7)3) ># '43 /%#;-@/6,#.

İ=&0 :6#%3 #5,3$/0 0+0=/0 0+ 0+ ?#$,3,3 0+0=/050 (00$0#

B40+ 64'. İ=&0 058 % $ 0=03 -3,3$8 0= #303 -3,3$Q 5#6

:6#%3 $)=43+,7,3$3 ;'/8 5*-03 (-#603 405+0 %+4 -%+;3$$,#. İ=03 3 0-05030#0#/38 /36# 0&03$ @>$$0: %7;=;#/38 -)@+# +403$ /3$0503 +/,=6;6;+$;7;3; H/ /6,3$ 6@0+ 6/$0# $0+$07030 0+0#8 -:6,7, ># =-0 (%=3;6+;7; 0&03$ -:#.!

G)+3 0=&0303 :6#%3;3 0=030 0# 0$6 >;=;5; 0&03$ -:45, (#/607030


23/30

B46+0 0# &%38 =?/6+0 0# (008 5$6 >;';'6,3,8 ()$$)7) -$$070303 5$6 >;';#;3$ ;+;# .1

G)+3* (/ 64-3+#03 +03 (&40= %+0+0#. B; $;#;4$ >+/

%+;45;' 4;4+-+ $ /#=,+=0+0#. A3@/ ;3;6;+44+,$,# /0 $+6 0# =>5, 4308 0# 6)'+ /0=0+0/ %+#/8 H(+@0 6#04+#+ 0?$ $#5/ 0# 4;6+/ /,+ %+#/ 4;>?'

$0+4+0$0#. O3;3 ()@)3)8 4=#;0-6030 '? ;7#6@/ >#>3(0 0# >#/66 ;+;34/63

/&,34/ (#/0#

B38 $+60 6=/0+ $3 4)555+#03 50'8 0'8 ?+38 ?0+3 /#=, %+$;7;/3603$ $70+04. B', 4)555+#$ &,7,#6/38 5)#/+0 55030 -)/5+63

=/+#,3, 55 %738 ()#)+6)+#0 ?+0-6+#0303 &%/ -60 >440-60 %+3 &%/ /04

0# ;35;#$;#... ; 060#+$,# /08 0$#@0+#8 $030 >-6, 40++603 >-6, 0+#/ %3;4*=#0 0@$3$ >: $0#0 6;64- &+,=4+,$,#+# .63

G)+3* (#

'43 $+6030 433 $56/+4+0 $+66 $0303 0#+=60#0@0 $050:+03 $0@0


24/30

-##+34+,$,#. Ö-+ /0 $+6 4;>+0?8 $+603 0=+#03 /#,=3 $03 /;#;4; -%'+=4

70+0403$$0#

D030303 #;>;-+8 $+60-+ )6)3+=4-3 4$#5 >0&0# '43 4$#5 %+4$,7,

(00 6// $ 6// %+44,=6,#. İ+04 -:4-, ,#/,: $030-+ $+60-+ ;7#=34)555303 $, 3 %+;#5 %+5;38 >/0/0 43$ % 4)555 0&63 0& %';+4-;7#4,= $%+-,5,-+ 6/## /3$05030 -30+-0: 5/0 >)0-603 $#/603 435;:+#,3$3 5)#/+0 $> -)/5/ 0# /,+5++,7 ;+=4+#,3,

/+4/6$0#. B; $ 30>-603$ $+603 /,+5++,7,3 #60%3+06- (


25/30

Ö3@+0/+ 6>;++> G)+3*03 -',+#,3 /,+$,7,3$ (3+ 0?$+# =;##/ @46+# )56) 0# >06: $0+0

/3$0503 5&#. B6,+,+# 0+ 0+(0+0 -%#;4+#,3$ ; $;#;4;3 -,#$,3 #4/ 4)4/)3$)#. O

B6,+,+#, 5# $0#$ $)3-4;'3503$ 0# 7,#+,7, #$,. H#/5 %3 /,-%# /3$05030 %3 (+)/ (# =-0>/0# (*, $04 0#03@0 :+3$ 4)6+ 648 ; -)@ $8 -)@4?/;#303 $+050 %+4 5-503$ C3, H// 5,3,#+#,4,', $04 /%#;$;8 0' $'0' %+#/ -=$,/. B; #;>; /-$03@ $ 0'0 $56>56 &)#)6): #;>;4;'; +$,+#. E6 0' + #;> :+3,3$ ?0+#030 + (&0#3 0# 5)#'040 /+0+ ( $047+#,3, @0350-6 7+, (# =-0 =>663 0# $)3- 0&03$&;++> ()+38 Asrın


26/30

(008 0&63 0& &%/63 /+ 4;>6=4 ()#)+ ()#)+(#50' 6;?-+0+#$0# .

B; 0&63 0& /+ 0+04 6/30/6 İ5+4

4$30-60303 05 6506 0&038 /3$0 (&40=040'8 /3$0 >#5,4,' /3$0 $7#+#040'03 4-$3 (60#@70 /3$0 g?k k!88emiz0 5,7,34+,-,'.D)3-3,3 ># 6#?,3$8 ?#+# >+03$ ?,=/,#3 0+04 0#?3 06 ()'++0/+#0 +,:8

7#,4,'$ #064+08 >'464+0 5)6 (;$$+#03$3 (&40= 4-0 >+03 (60#4+085%3# 0353,4,' 6/$04 64+0-0'.9

G)+3*03 B6, /#=,5,3$/0 ; 6/ 6#?+, 03$0#(-0@0 566 0353+,7,3 %#6/ :#%+4+#0303

&#/50 /3$0 /%3;4;3$ /;++34 $4/ 5+,3$ P-(4# E?3$040'03 M$03V50/5,*3, 0# /# $> 55+3$0#40= %+4/6,# ; 0# 43$ M)5+)43+# )'#03$ 0# '0?$0r.70

G)+3*03 M$03 V50/5,*3 6,? -:#/ &%7;+@;+;7 -:6,7, ;#(;- %3;3

5


27/30

3+=,+45, (#/3 0# 4;>6: %+#/ /;+ $0+0-%#. B; $70=040 35,+ $7#+3$0#4/

(#/0# Ö3@+0/+ /#%3%+%0/ ?#/+,+,7 $0//6 &/0+4+0$0#. G)+3*03 /%3; >//,3$

4;>?'/# $)=)3@+#030 %#6- /%-$;7; F7 N50+ /06, 19 6#0>+0-/38

D0-+%7;3 D030 T#0>0 T4++#0 5#0 2!! 6#0>+0$0#. 2! -,+, =/,3 0# '43 ?#/, ++0

$)=)3@+#03 '43 0&03$ $70=0+@7030 (


28/30

@46038 ; &+,=4$ + +,3$,7, =/+0-+ 6>;++> G)+3 @460303 500+ 6%:+;4;3 0#

:#&5, %+#/ $7#+3$0#4303 4)4/)3+)7) 03@+3$0. C46 0&#0503$ 5,3,#+, $ %+5

0#-5+


29/30

B##-8 N%#43. 1999. _S00+ 6%:+;48 D03 İ5+4`. I&03$ )slam, Sivil Topl!m, Piyasa .konomisi8 A3/# L0#6 Y-,3+#,.

B%0%8 N%##6%. 199. _G#4@0 S00+ T%:+;4 K#4,`. I&03$ Sivil topl!m ve "evlet : Avr!pa"a yeni yaklaşımlar #$%&'#(%&8 İ563;+ A-#,36, Y-,3+#,8 :. 9111.

B;+&8 A+0. 1992. _D03+#03 4-$3 %/;-;=; E36(#0'4 ?;3$436+0'4`. -irikim "1"2.

aaa. 1992. _M$03 V50/5, H//,3$ G3+ B0+(0+#`. -irikim 9 1!211!.

F,3#8 M3$#5. 199. _F%/ H;/;/+; T%:+;4 K4;5+ A+3 V$ M, O6360/ K04+0/P%+060/5, M,` I&03$ K*reselleşme sivil topl!m ve )slam : T*rkiye *zerine

yansımalar 8 A3/# V$0 Y-,3+#,.

G++3#8 E#356. 199. 5on"itions o6 li8erty: ivil soiety an" its rivals. Nb Y%#/8 N.YP3(;03 B%%/5.

G)+38 6>;++>. 199". Asrın 46. 2!11. =eth!llah 3. 199. _D5:%60'4 D4%/#50 S00+ T%:+;4 0+ D+6 A#5,3$/0 A-#,4,3

K#6. 2!!9. Kavramlar tarihi: politik ve sosyal "ilin semantiği ve pragmatiği*zerine araştırmalar . 156 $. İ563;+ İ+60=04 Y-,3+#,.

M#$038 #0?. 1991. T*rkiye@"e topl!m ve siyaset makaleler: 4 . M)46'*# T)#/


30/30

Documents

Sivil Toplum ve Nurculuk.docx