P A ~ Ii A I..(Ii 0 H H A SI B Ii 0 JI 0 r Ii SI. P A ~ Ii 0 :) K 0 JI 0 r Ii .SI

T.3S 1995 6b1n. 5

/l1Ov] /.- '

petf

\

OCOBEHHOCTH 6MOJIOrHQECKOro):( E A. C T B H SI M A 11hI X J1. 0 3 P A J1. H A I.J,11 H

Yl1K 577.391 ;577.346;575.224.23

© 1995 r. C. A. repacbKHH

KPIimQECKHA AHAJIIi3 COBPEMEHHbIX KOHI..(Enn:Iiit If nO,lJ;XO,lJ;OBK OI..(EHKE BIiOJlOrlfQECKOrO ~EAcTBIISI MAJlbIX ~03

IiOHIi3I1PYIO~ErO H3J1YQEHHSI

AManH3 COBpeMeHHblX KOHLlenLlHH H nOI\XOAOB K ou,eHKe 6HOJlOrn'leCKOro AeHCTBHH MaJlblX

A03 HOHH3HpYI01II.ero H3JlY'leHHH nOU33JI. "TO B HaCTO!!11.leeBpeM!! He CYUleCTByeT eAHllOH

061I1.enpH3HaHHoH KOHu,enu,HH 6HOJlOrn'leCKoro AeHCTBHII MaJlblX )103 HOHH3HpYlOILlero H3JlY­

'1eHH!!. HcnOJlb3yeMbie Mil OI~eHKH reHeTH"ecKoro pHcxa M8JJbtX A03 MOAeJlH, OCHOBaHllble

Ha JlHHeHHOH 6ecnoporoooH KOlHlenLlHH, HOCHT 3KCTpanomiLlHOHHblH xapaKTep. He HMelOT

npo'lHOro 6HOJlOrn'leCKOro OOocHOBaHHH H BXO)111TB npoTHOOpe'lHe C HMelO11.lHMHCSI3Kcne­

pHMeHT8JJbHbIMH )18HHbJMH. AMaJlH3 3KcnepHMeHTaJlbHO H36J1IOJlaeMbiX peaKLU1H KJleTKH Ha

06ny'leHHe n0300JlSleT CAeJl3Tb BblBOA 0 TOM, '1TO JaKOHOMepHOCTH BblXOAa reHeTH'leCKHX

HapyweHHH B 06J13CTH MaJlblX Jl03 xapaKTepH3YlOTCH IIpKO Bbtpa*ellHoll He/lHHeihlOCTblO H

HMelOT YHHBepca.nbHblH xapaKTep. pa3JlH'laIiCb AllII pa3HbtX OObeKTOB 3Ha4eHHIIMH A03. "PH

KOTOpblX npoHCXO)1HT H3MeHeHHe xapaKTepa 3aBHCHMOCTH H KOTOpblt! onpeAeJlHIOTCH HK

'1YBCT8HTeJJbHOCTblO K BHeWHHM B03AeHCTBHIIM.

Ma./lble iJo3bl, zeNemUlleCKlie noepexOeliWI., penQPQu,uSl. /l,HK.

CJlY'laHHblH XapaKTep npo5lBJleHH.Il reHeTH4eCKHX 3<P<PeKTOB MaJIbiX ~03, 06yc­JIOBJIeHHblH KaK npHHlJ,HnHaJIbHOH CTOXaCTHtfHOCTblO npoll,ecca B3aHMo~eHCTBHS/. HOHH­

3HPYIOII(HX H3JlY4eHHH C reTeporeHHOH 6H0J10rn4ecKoH CTPYKTypoH, TaK H CJ1Y4aHHblMxapaJcTepoM peaJIH3all,HH nepBH4HblX nOBpe~eHHH MOileKYJI .llHK B KOHe4HblH 6HOIIO­

ffi'lCCKHH ~eKT, a TaK~e ~0C7aT01l.HO BbiCOKHH (no cpaBHeHHIO C HlfJtYlI,HpoBaHHblM

MaJIblMH ~03aMH) cnOHTaHHblH ypoBeHb reHeTH'leCKHX lTOBpe~eHHH, ~eJIalOT lTpo­

6.11eMaTH4HblM nOJIY4eHHe KoppeKTHOH Oll,eHKH reHeTH4ecKoro pHCKa 06.11Y4eHHSI BMaJIblX .n03ax, OCHOB3HHOH HCKJllO'IHTeJIbHO Ha ,l1aHHblX 3KcnepHMCHTa. HCBblCOK351

CTaTHCTH4CCKaSi ,l10CT0BepHOCTb 3KcnepHMeHTa.llbHblX ~3HHblX 0 reHeTH4CCKHX 3<P<PeK­

Tax MaJIblX .n03 n03BO.ll5leT ~aTb npHeMJIeMOe HX onHcaHHe B paMKax npHHlI,HnHaJlbHOpa3.llH'lHblX MaTCMaTH4eCKHX MO~eJIeH II, 2 I, 1I.TOCTaBHT nOJI COMHeHHe HcnOJJb30B3HHC

JIlo6oH H3 HHX .Il.llSi OlJ,eHKH reReTH4CcKOro pHcKa. Ho JIa~e eCJ1H HMelO~a5/.CSl BHameM pacnOp.ll~eHHH HH!f>opMal.(HSI n03BOJJH.lla 6bl C~eJI3Tb Bbl60p B nO.llb3Y OJIHOH

H3 aJIbTepHaTHBHblx cPYHKlJ,HH, 060cHoBaHHc 33KOHHOCTH ee HCnOJlb30B3HH5I JlJ]SI3KCTpanOJISllI,HH Ha6.11lO,l1aeMblX 4aCTOT K HY.IIeBOH ;t03e Bce paBHO Tpe6YeT npHB.IIC4eHHS/.~OnO.llHHTeJIbHblX (BHe3MnHpH4CCKHX) CBe~eHHH.

3MlTHPH'ICCKYIO OCHOBY OLleHKH reHeTH4ecKoro pHCKa 06.11Y4eHHSI B MaJIbiX J103aX

COCTaBJI.IllOT pe3Y.IIbT3Tbl ~H06Ho.llorH4eCKHX 3KcnepHMeHTOB H 3nJf):(eMHO.llOrH4eCKHel{aHHble. TeOpeTH4eCKaSi ~e OCHOBa Oll,eHKH rcHeTH4ecKoro pHCKa ~OJJJKHa6a3HpoBaTbCSIH3 MO.rIeJIH .rI030BOH 3aBHCHMOCTH, C nOMOlIl.blO KOTOpoH OCYlUCCTB/lS1eTCSI3KCTpanOJlSlLlHSI

563

-~;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;o..------':-=--=""':-::"""';===::====~~~~~i!I!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I!IIiii!!!i!!!!;;;::;:;::;;;;;;;="~yW

~ '91 . fNj tm1 t.e 4- dt (;,t#li- /lieu 7 /12- o/nt/ /W 0/ -H. Wi,~-i1- luOJ1a/1 at- If)III - tt-v d ;tY'OuU a-lt'O/7 iiZ rittcl/O/l .

DClfa. ff-C'fYJ [{-f]

/lu mt~fv 0.1a6Uf'Q/-loM

0,005p.tl" 100 ails .

0, 00"

O,OOJ

IO,OOZ t-

1

O,Odl •...I 0

10

rig f.PHC. 1. qaCToTa BblX01\a 1\11u,eHTpI1KOB B KYJlbrype JlI1Mc!>oU,HTOB 'IenOBeKa

npl1 1\eHCTBI1I1 HI13KI-IX 1\03 HOIIH311pYIOlIJ,ero H3JlY'IeIlHSI. ,lJ;allllble H3 pa60TbI[II]

no OCI1a6cu.I1CC .:- 1\OJa 06J1Y'Ielll1S1, Mfp; no OCI10p1\HllaT - 'II1CJ10 a6eppau.HHlIa 100 KJleTOK

PHC. 2. qaCTOTa BblX01\a 1\Hl.leIlTpHKOB B KYJlbrype JlI1McpOU.I1TOB 'IeJIOBeKanpH 1\eHCTBI1I1 IIH3KI-IX 1\03 110llH3HpYIOlIJ,ero H3JlY'IeHI1S1. ,lJ;aHHble 113 pa60TbI[12]no OCI1a6cu.l1cc - 1\03a 06J1y',eIlHSI, Mfp; no OCH 0p1\HllaT - 'IHCJlO a6eppau.HHlIa 100 KJleTOK

3<PCPCKTOB, B03HHKalO~HX npH B03J:{ciiCTBHH 60JIbwHX J:{03 HOHH3HPYlO~cro H3JIY'lCHH5I,

BC,qY~HM Ha'l3JIbHhlM npon;CCCOM B nOpa)KalO~CM J:{CHCTBHH paJ:{Han;HH 51BJl5leTC5I

HOHH3an;H5I MOJICKYJI, TO M5I 3<P¢CKTOB, HH.D:yn;HpYCMblX M3JIblMH J:{03aMH H MO~HO­

CT5IMH, BCJ:{YIIJ;ee 3H3lJeHHe npH06peTaeT B036Y)KJ:{CHHe MoneKyn, He pa3pywalOIIJ;ee

HX CTPYKTYPY». O,qH3KO 3T0 B KopHe HCBCpHO. C1>H3H'lCCKHC aKTbI B33HMOJ:{ClkTBH5I

H3JIY'lCHH5I C BCru;CCTBOM Ka'lCCTBCHHO HC 3aBHCSlT OT BenH'lHHbI nornoru;cHHoH ;J;03bl,

n03TOMY 60JIbUlHC H M3JIblC ;J;03b1 HOHH3HPYlOru;Cro H3JIY'lCHHSI pa3JIHlJalOTCSI BOBCC

He 3HcprnCH KBaHTOB, 3 HX lJHCJlOM, ncpCCCKalOID.HM B e;J;HHHn;y BpCMCHH 'lYBCTBH­

TenbHbIH Om,CM (8 J. C cpH3H'lCCKOH TO'lKH 3peHHSI pa3nH'lHC MC)KJ:{Y 6o.nbWHMH H

M3JIblMH ;J;033MH HOCHT HC K3tJ:CCTBCHHblH, a KOnH'lCCTBCHHblH xap3KTCp B OTnH'lHC

OT 6HonorntJ:ccKHx 3cpcpCKTOB p33HblX J:{Han330HOB 3nCKTpoM3rnHTHoro H3JIY'lCHHII

(9 J, KOTOpblC ;J;CHCTBHTCllbHO 06YCJloBncHbi npHHIJ;HnH3JIbHblM pa3JIH'lHCM cpH3H'lCCKHX

McxaHH3MOB ncpC;J;3tJ:H 3HcprnH 6Honorn4ccKHM CTpYKTypaM. BMCCTC C TCM CYID.CCTBYIOT

CCpbC3HblC pa3JIH4HSI B pacnpc,qenCHHl-1' no KJIeTKaM c06blTHH nOrJIOILlCHHSI :mcprnH

npH 06JIY4cHHH 60nbUlHMH H M3JIblMH ,q03aMH (8].K H3CTOSlILlCMY BpCMCHH HaKOnHJ1OCb .D:OCTaT04HO MHOro cpaKToB, CBH;J;eTCllbCTBY­

lO~HX B nonb3Y HCllHHeHHoro xap3KTcpa ;J;030BOH 3aBHCHMOCTH no BblXO;J;Y reHeTH­

tJ:CCKHX nOBpC)KJ:{CHHH B 06JIaCTH M3JIblX 3Ha4CHHH 3Kcn03Hu;HH. HaH60JIcc nOJIHblC

.D:aHHblC HMClOTC5I B OTHOWCHHH 4aCTOTbi a6eppau.HH XpoMOCOM, HH.D:YIJ;HPYCMblX B

f:iy p, .tJ1fj1tehCE &;./ .ctl'wllm',u S ': (Yf.lc!. ) iYL ~65

ifl?nf hD~tk w T1JA\.E 61 fU/lVVI>Q41 DA· [,ow -·le IN~I Jrcvt/J.'cL/-IDill j )'} rill eli 011 . D OtfC( -fr.-o.yrl pa.~ [1J 7

~ (fUVJEP 1- akrrod/()}1g 1-oJ1rotJrloJoJ17iJ

, ~n PffmphDc-iff!W))-tHf a!- ~w-Ur;t!irra.diO f1 i 11. dft eND /11. DO!.:I-c1!r-oJIYI P a.p .t/'- [ 10 ] .

fU.t-1}t~tr (/1

aJ..u-/'ilvh'o i'\ J

p-e-r (Dt) tt~f.32

,o

2,3:10.1:20

ri8,L/. !kftncLvl~ 1- ~FL~dam~qM i h tih~1k1 g [(~

wad fyUdlt' WJ S ['J-J ~t

(-7 Hru-v[(aHI'Ji'l oLDv· fCliQ 4tcrr_-) ...•

pap.Qr L 6~_

~/2

1$IJ"97$J,20

30~oSO ~rp0.20,51,0~o

60

Q.G!) .PHC. 4 F!# itPHC. 3 ~i8·3

,.

PHC. 3. qacTOTa a6eppaLlHH XpoMDCOM B Kynbrype nHMqx,LlHTOB 'lenOBeKa npH AeHCTBHH UH3KHX )103

HOUH3HpYIOIl\ero H3J\Y'leUHH • .lI,auuble 113 pa60Tbl (10)no DCH a6cLlHCC - AOJa 06nY'leHHH, crp; no DCH 0pAHHaT - '1HCnO a6eppaLlHH Ha 100 KJleTOK

PHC. 4. 3aBI1CHMOCTb LlHTOreHeTH'IeCKoro nOBpe)!(AeHI1H 4JH6p06nacToB KI1TaHCKOro XOMHtlKa (1) H npopOCTXOB

KOHCKHX 606oB (2) OT A03bl j-06nY'leHI1H . .lI,aHHble H3 pa60TbI [16]no DCH a6cLlHcc - AOJa 06nY'leuHH, rp; no DCH 0PAHHaT - tlHCJlO MHKpollAep Ha 100 KJ1eTOK

JlHM<t>ou,HTax nepHlpepH'IecKoH KpoBH 'IeJIOBCKa HH3KOA030BOH paAHau,HeH. YHHKaJIbHOeCO'lCTaHHC CBoitcTB (10) 3aKOHOMCpHO BblABHHYJlO JlHM<t>oU,HTbl Ha ncpBOC MCCTO

cpe.z:\H TCCT-CHCTCM, npC.z:\Ha3Ha'lCHHblX .z:\}]SIou,eHKH rCHeTl{4eCKHX 3<t>¢CKTOB HH3KO­

.z:\030BOH pa.z:\Hau,HH. MMeHHO H3 :nOM otTheKTc 6blJ1H BblnOJlHeHbl HaH60Jlec MacillTa6H1>ie

HCCJ1C.z:\OB3HHSI<PoPMbl .z:\030BOH 3aBHCHMOCTH. AHaJIH3 MHoro'lHCJ1eHHblX pa60T pa3HblX

aBTOpoB n03BOJlSleT Bbl.z:\eJIHTb .z:\BaY'IaCTKa, B npc.z:\eJIax KOTOpblX A030BaSl 3aBHCHMOCTb

OTKJlOHSlCTCSI OT O)KH.z:\aeMOH J1HHCHHOH. Cym.cCTBeHHble OTKJlOHCHHSI 6blJ1H BblSlBJ1CHbi

B 06.naCTH .z:\03 HH)Ke 5 crp. Ha pHC. 1 H 2 npe.z:\CTaBJ1eHbl .z:\aHHblC HCCJ1CAOBaTeJIbCKHX

rpynn, B03rJ1aBJ1S1CMblX LI.)K. TIOJ1b-PeJIHHr (11] H LI.. JIJ10H.rlOM (12], KOTOpblMH 6wJIfBblnOJ1HCHbl HaH60J1ce Tm.aTeJIbHble HCCJ1C.z:\OBaHHSI.z:\030BOH 3aBHCHMOCTH B :nOM .z:\H­

ana30He. AHaJIH3 nOJ1Y'lCHHblX B :nHX 3KcnepHMeHTax pe3YJlbTaTOB nOKa3aJ1, '1TO

<pHKcHpyeMaSl npH .z:\03ax .z:\O2 crp 'IaCTOTa .z:\Hu,eHTpHKOB He npeBblillaeT KOHTpoJ1bHOro

ypoBHSI. nOJlee TOro, Bce illCCTb n0J1Y4eHHblX B TpeX He3aBHCHMblX 3KcnepHMeHTax(11-13) TO'lCK B AHana30He 0,3-1,0 crp Jle)KaT HH)KC (HHorJ:(a CTaTl{CTHtlCeKli

.z:\OCTOBCpHO(11 » COOTBCTCTBYIOm.ero KOHTpoJ1S1. Cxo.z:\Hble pe3YJ1bTaTbI 6b1J1H n0J1Y4CHbi

H B .z:\pyrnx 3KcnepHMCHTax :nHX HCCJ1C.z:\OBaTeJIbCKHXrpynn (13, 14).BTOpoH HHTepBaJI, B KOTOpoM Ha6J1IO.z:\aeTcSl cym.eCTBeHHOC H3MeHeHHe HaKJIOHa

.z:\030BOH 33BHCHMOCTH, BapbHpyeT y pa3Hblx aBTopoB B .z:\Hana30He 10-50 cfp. Ha

pHC. 3 npe.z:\CTaBJ1CHbl CBe.z:\CHHble Boe.z:\HHO npo¢. A. B. CeBaHbKacBblM (10) .z:\aHHble

pa3HblX HCCJ1e.z:\oBaTeJIeH 06 HH.z:\YKU,HH MaJIblMH .z:\03aMH HOHH3HPYIOm.ero H3J1Y'leHHst

a6eppalJ,HH XpoMOCOM B JlHM<t>ou,HTax nepH<pepH'IecKoH KpoBH 'IeJIOBeKa. BH.z:\HO, tlTO

4aCTOTa <pHKcHpyeMblx B ::ITOM .z:\Hana30He a6eppalJ,HH HeJIHHeHHO 3aBHCHT OT BeJIHtlJ{Hbi

A03bl. Em.e O.z:\HOHOCOOeHHOCTblO, npHcyw:eH npe.z:\CTaBJ1eHHblM Ha pHC. 3 3MnHpH4ecKHM

3aBHCHMOCTSlM, SlBJ1S1eTC5IHaJIH'IHe .z:\030He3aBHcHMoro Y4aCTKa (nnaTo) no BblxoAYreHeTH4ecKHX nOBpe)K.z:\eHHH. TIOCKOJ1bKY CXO.z:\Hble 3aBHCHMOCTH BocnpoH3BO.z:\SlTCSI e

Y.z:\HBHTeJIbHblM nOCTOSlHCTBOM B HC3aBHCHMblX HCCJ1e.z:\OBaHHSlXpa3Hblx aBTopoB (eM.

0630pbl no 3TOMY nOBO.z:\y B pa60Tax (10, 15», MO}KHO nOJlaraTb, 4TO TaKoe nOBeAeHHe

KpHBOH .z:\03a - 3¢<t>eKT onpe.z:\eJISleTCSI He cJlyqaHHblMH <pJlYKTyau,HSlMH, a 06ye-MeH­

J10BJ1eHO Ka4eCTBeHHblMH OCOOeHHOCTSlMH, npHcym.HMH aHaJIH3HpyeMblM 3KcnepH lI-TaJIbHblM .z:\aHHblM. TIpe.z:\CTaBJ1eHHble pe3YJ1bTaTbl co BceH 04eBH.z:\HOCTblO .z:\eMOHCTP

pylOT HenpaBOMepHOCTb JlHHeHHOH 3KCTpanOJlSlu,HH Ha6mo.z:\aeMblx npH .z:\03ax CBblIlIe

50 cfp 'IaCTOT K HYJleBoH .z:\03e. TIOCKOJlbKY 3aBHCHMOCTb BblXO.z:\a reHeTJ{4ecKHXnOBpe)K.z:\eHHH OT .z:\03bl B 3TOM .z:\Hana30He HOCHT CJ10)KHblH HeJIHHeHHblH xapaKTep,

, Ha-KoppeKTHaSl K0J1H4eCTBeHHaSl ou,eHKa reHeTH'IecKOro pHCKa 06J1Y4cHHSI B 3TOM,

566

~(#. c ( F~i.U..M U ~ fWJpfaM'e +/,{U1/1or7/Jah0i1 !il-yn(Cl f/ 8JVYf;;taA1-s a;f f) f1 ~ (1) ttnd f-tU!;/-/O IWvI-ed .' I!u?!-~

!/"rrvilailDIl I lJtUcr !ro?11 pap {Ig.] .

10

Dos-p J {~

B 3TOH CBSl3H HaM npe,Z:\CTaBJIXeTCX He06xo,Z:\HMblM ,Z:\aTbOTBeT Ha KPHTHKY B03MO>KHbC1'H

OObxcHeHHx 3KcnepHMeHTaJIbHO pernCTpHPyeMoro B conpe,Z:\eJIbHOH C 06JIaCTblO MaJIblX

.n;03 OJIaTO HH.D;YKU,HeH penapa~HOHHbIX CHCTeM. B pa60Te [15] BbI.D;BHralOTCSI TpH

.n;OBo.n;a npoTHB 3TOro YTBep>K.D;eHHSI. OTBeTHM nOCJIe,Z:\OBaTeJIbHO Ha Ka>K.D;blH.

1. «qrCYTCTBYeT 3aBHCHMOCTb OT MOID,HOCTH ,Z:\03b1,\{TO He xapaKTepHO ,Z:\JISInpo~eCCOBBOCCTaHOBJIeHHX nOBpe>K.D;eHHH». 3aBHCHMOCTb npo~eCCOB BOCCTaHOBJIeHHSI OT MOlD,HOCTl1

.n;03bl onpe,Z:\eJISleTCX npe>K,Z:\e Bcero KOHe\{HOH eMKOCTblO penapa~HOHHblX CHCTeM,

T. e. ax cnoco6HOCTblO BOCCTaHOBHTb It e.n;HHH~Y BpeMeHH He 60JIee onpe,Z:\eJIeHHoro

KOJIHtJecTBa nOTeHU,HaJIbHblX nOBpe>K.D;eHHH. n03TOMY <l>eHoMeH MOm,HOCTH ;:\03b1 Ka­

caeTCX B 3TOM CJIy\{ae He caMOro cym,eCTBOBaHHSI OJIaTO, KOTopoe, no HaroeMY

MHeHHlO, 06YCJIoBJIeHo MYTareHHblM xapaKTepoM HHH~HHPyeMblx B 3TOM ;:\Hana30He

CHCTeM SOS-OTBeTa, a ero rpmlH~, nOCKOJIbKY KaK MOMeHT HHH~Ha~HH, TaK HHC'IepnaHHSI eMKOCTH CHCTeM SOS-OTBeTa onp~.n;eJISleTCSI HHTeHCHBHOCTblO (T. e. KO­

J}H\{eCTBOM HHAY~HpyeMblx B e,Z:\HHH~Y BpeMeHH nOBpe>K.D;eHHH) BHemHero B03,Z:\eHCTBHSI.2. «qHCJIO a6eppa~HH B 3TOH 06JIaCTH ;:\03 60JIbme O>KH.D;aeMoro». B 3TOM 3Kcne­

pHMeHTaJIbHO Ha6JIIO;:\aeMOM MHornMH HCCJIe,!:\OBaTeJISlMH Ha pa3HblX TeCT-CHCTeMax H

6HOJIOrn\{ecKHx OObeKTax Q>eHOMeHe MO>KHO YBH.D;eTb npoTHBOpe\{He, nOCKOJIbKY «B3TOM ,Z:\Hana30He ,Z:\03 \{HCJIO a6eppa~HH 60JIbwe O>KH.D;aeMoro, Tor,Z:\a KaK a,Z:\anTHBHaSl

peaKU,HSI ;:\OJI>KHa npHBO,Z:\HTb K 06paTHoMY 3<l>¢eKTY, T. e. K CHH>KeHHIO \{HCJIa

a6eppaU,HH» [15]. Ha caMOM ,Z:\eJIeHHKaKoro npoTHBOpe\{HSI HeT, nOCKOJIbKY peaK~HH

a,!:\anTHBHoro H SOS-oTBeTa HHH~HHPYIOTCSI B pa3HblX ,Z:\030BblX ,Z:\Hana30Hax. rIpH3TOM a,!:\anTHBHblH OTBeT, HHHU,HHpyeMblH ,Z:\03aMH0,5-10 cfp [15, 19], ,Z:\eikTBHTeJIbHO

MO""eT npHBO,Z:\HTb K CHH>KeHHIO Bblxo;:\a a6eppaU,HH (CM., HanpHMep, pHC. 1 H 2).AKTHBaU,HSI >Ke MYTareHHoH CHCTeMbi SOS-OTBeTa, MSI HHH~Ha~HH KOTOpoH Heoo­

xo.n;HMa 60JIbmaSi HHTeHCHBHOCTb B03,Z:\eHCTBHSI, npHBO,Z:\HT B 06JIaCTH OTHOCHTeJIbHO

MaJIblX .n;03 K YBeJIH\{eHHIO Bblxo,Z:\a reHeTH\{eCKHX nOBpe>K.D;eHHH, \{TO H q,HKcHPyeTcSI

B 3KcnepHMeHTe KaK nO.IIBJIeHHe .n;030He3aBHcHMoro y\{aCTKa 3a npe.n;eJIaMH ;:\Hana30Ha,Z:\03, xapaKTepHblx MSI HHAYK~HH a,!:\anTHBHoro OTBeTa.

3. «PernCTpHPYIOTC.II KJIeTKH C MHO>KeCTBeHHblMH XpoMOCOMHblMH aHOMaJIHSlMH,

\{HCJIO KOTOpblX Ha nOp.IIAOK 60JIbme OJKH.D;aeMoro npH MaJIblX ,Z:\03ax». J],eHcTBHTeJIbHO,B HCCJIe.n;OBaHHSlX p.IIAa aBTOpoB npH 06JIy\{eHHH KaK in vitro [12, 13], TaK H in vivo

[20] 6b1JIo 06HapY>KeHo onpe,Z:\eJIeHHoe KOJIH\{eCTBO MYJIbTHa6eppaHTHblx KJIeTOK, q,aKTcym,eCTBoBaHHSI KOTOpblX (eCJIH HCXO,Z:\HTbH3 rnnOTe3bl 0 TOM, \{TO HX npoHCXO>K.D;eHHe

CB.lI3aHO C HH.D;YKU,HeH a6eppa~HH HOHH3HPYIOm,HM H3JIy\{eHHeM) He MO>KeT 6b1Tb

OOb.IICHeH ,Z:\a>KeB npe.n;nOJIOJKeHHH 0 cym,eCTBeHHOH HepaBHOMepHOCTH c06b1THH no­rJIom,eHHSI 3HeprnH B nonY;HI~HH KJIeTOK. CJIe,Z:\YeT OTMeTHTb, \{TO \{aCTOTa nOSlBJIeHHSI

TaKHX KJIeTOK He npo.IIBJISIeT 3aKOHOMepHOH H3MeH\{HBOCTH C pocTOM ;:\03b1 H, 60JIee

TOro, .no.n;06HblH q,eHoMeH Ha6JIIO,Z:\aeTCSl Y He06JIy\{eHHblx ;:\OHOpoB [13, 21] (TaK, 11.3

Tpex 06HapY>KeHHblX B HCCJIe.n;OBaHHH [13] MYJIbTHa6eppaHTHblx KJIeTOK ABe npH-

1h paf\t- v~

·-i:t-ancAo rmrJ:ttLI

{ CtW·\/rtB€17a,/1(

f

TO'J

lO-~0,7

PHC. 6. tJaCTOTa HeOl1JlaCTHQeCKOH TpaHccjxJpMa­

1J.HH B KYJlbrype II>H6p06J1aCTOB MblWH npH 0):1­

HOKpaTHOM (1) H <ppaK1.lHOHHpoBBHHOM (2) peH­

TreHoBCKoM ..06nyQeHHH • .[I.aHHble H3 pa60Tbl [18]ITa DCH aOC1.lHCC-):1038 06ny'leHHSI, rp; no OCH

Op):lHHaT ....:...):IOJlSl TpaHc<popMl1pOBaHKblx KJleTOK

568