Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
1
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
The Key Role of a Leader (Frontperson)
in the Process of Change Management.
,,Nie odkryjesz nowych lądów,
jeśli nie zgodzisz się stracić z pola widzenia
brzegu na długi czas.”1
mgr Anna Głowicka
Białystok 2013
1 W. Bridges, Zarządzanie zmianami. Jak maksymalnie skorzystać na procesach przejściowych., Wydawnictwo
Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, Kraków 2008, p. 42
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
2
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
Introduction.
The process of change management is a very complex one, involving many stages and
engaging a number of entities, not only within an organization but also in its proximal and
distal environment. The multitude of participants of the change process, as well as the
complexity of the very process, result in the necessity to appoint a person to manage the
process – to coordinate, motivate, lead, organize and plan – in other words, to manage the
whole process of changes at the organization level. The person needs to be able to effectively
lead the organization through the process of introducing changes and strive to make it
successful.
Selecting such a person within the organization or appointing a person “from the outside” is
definitely not an easy task. It requires thorough consideration of particular candidates on the
part of managers, as that choice is decisive for the success of the whole enterprise of
implementing changes in the organization. It must not be forgotten, however, that the leader
of the change process may naturally emerge from among the members of the organization,
which will definitely be very beneficial for the process to be implemented.
The article presents basic issues related to the role of the leader (foreperson) in a broadly
understood process of change management. It will be an attempt to answer the question of
whether the leader really plays such a significant part in the process of changes, what
determines that, what qualities the leader should have, what tasks they have to fulfill and what
is really expected of them.
1. The subjective character of the process of change
The process of changes has both the objective character (meaning what the change refers to)
and the subjective one (meaning who it refers to, or – in a broader meaning – who participates
in it). In literature, there are many different classifications of the subjective structure of the
process of changes, but presenting all of them is not necessary. Below, only those will be
presented which complement each other, thus presenting the discussed issue in a
comprehensive way.
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
3
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
First of all, the three basic groups of actors of changes (regarding the role they play in the
change process) are the following:2
strategists (they take decisions concerning the initiation of the process of changes and
actually start the process);
implementation officers (they plan, prepare and carry out the whole enterprise
connected with the implementation of the change);
users (the persons in whose environment the process of changes occurs and who will
have to function in the changed conditions).
Another classification mentions four groups of entities, slightly different to the above-
mentioned ones: initiators of the changes, promoters of the changes, agents of the changes and
addressees of the changes.3 That classification is just an extension of the previous one, adding
the role of promoter (as the name suggests, they are responsible for the promotion of changes
both within the organization and outside). The other entities are identical with those in the
first classification.
There is also another classification of the participants of the process of changes, including:4
the leader of changes (they are in the lead of the change implementation);
the manager of changes (they direct and manage the process of changes in the
organization);
the promoter of changes (the person involved in the process of changes and promoting
it at the particular levels of the organization);
the performer of changes (they implement the change disregarding the opinions or any
resistance on the part of the organization members, mainly using force instead of
arguments or even resorting to dishonest strategies).
2 W. Daniecki., Strategie zmian. Refleksje nad praktyką., Wydawnictwo SWPS Academica, Warszawa 2004, p. 75 3 K. Grzesiuk, Zarządzanie zmianą w aspekcie funkcjonowania człowieka w biznesie. [in:] ed. K. Machowicz, Newralgiczne aspekty współczesnych relacji między człowiekiem a biznesem., Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin 2010, p. 140 4 T. Wawak, Lider i przywódca zmian., pp. 4-5, http://tadeusz.wawak.pl/content/lider-i-przywodca-zmian, 20/08/2013
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
4
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
In that case, only the “key” entities implementing the change were mentioned when
distinguishing the participants of the process of changes, disregarding the users (addressees)
of the changes.
In order to draw up a coherent and complete list of the participants of the process, it is
necessary to refer to the three above-mentioned classifications. On the basis of them, we can
enumerate elements of the subjective structure of the change management process: strategist
(initiator), leader (foreperson, performer, agent), promoter and addressees (users) of the
change. This list does not include the subject of executor, but it is so due to the fact that this
role should be treated as a specific form of exercising leadership by the change leader.
2. The leader of the change management process.
The available literature sources present various definitions of the term 'leader', list different
qualities and tasks ascribed to them and indicate numerous functions and roles the leader
plays in the process of changes. Very often, terms synonymous to it are also used, such as e.g.
spokesperson, moderator, educator, promoter, facilitator or agent of changes. For the needs of
this study, let us assume that they are identical and use them interchangeably.5
Most generally, the leader of the change process is an entity participating in the process of
changes, responsible for the performance of particular goals, coordination of actions and
monitoring the whole process; moreover, they are the guarantor of the efficiency and
effectiveness of the process (understood as the achievement of the set goals with care about
the rational management of the allotted resources). They are responsible for the establishment
of mechanisms protecting from the occurrence of potential risks, which might pose a threat to
the performance of the set goals. Their tasks also include ensuring efficient communication
between the participants of the change process and the participants of other processes taking
place within the organization, so that no disturbances occur in information channels.6 The
leader of change may be a member of the organization or the management, or an expert
5 E. Drabek, Źródła oporu wobec zmian oraz sposoby jego przezwyciężania., http://www.profesor.pl/publikacja,2627,Artykuly,Zrodla-oporu-wobec-zmian-oraz-sposoby-jego przezwyciezania, 20/08/2013 6 R. Batko, Zarządzanie procesami w organizacji publicznej., in: ed. R. Batko, Zarządzanie zmianą w organizacjach publicznych. Projektowanie i wprowadzanie nowoczesnych metod i narzędzi zarządczych w Wojewódzkim Urzędzie Pracy w Krakowie., Wojewódzki Urząd Pracy w Krakowie, Kraków 2011, p. 25
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
5
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
employed from the outside for the needs of implementation of a particular change.7 It is
determined by the needs of the organization in that regard, the quality of human capital, the
financial resources owned by the organization and the specificity of the implemented change.
To sum up, it must be mentioned, however, that in the context of change manager process, the
leader is a person who influences the environment of the organization, including its members,
and a person who within their specialization wants and is able to introduce changes,8 has the
necessary skills and is capable of using the available tools.
3. The leader of changes as a frontperson.
The leader of changes does not always play the role of a frontperson in the organization,
yet for the change management process to be accurate and effective, they should be perceived
as such both by the organization members and its closest environment. It is extremely
important if the organization wants to achieve the intended objective: to implement the
change. Unfortunately, it is not so easy.
It would seem that if the leader manages, directs the process of changes in the organization,
coordinates it, manages people and distributes the resources at their disposal, it automatically
means he or she is the frontperson. But in change management, real leadership means that
through the leader, the participants of the process strive for the achievement of common
objectives – not only the objectives of those who support the change being introduced but also
the objectives of the whole organization. Thus, what is essential is the ability to notice and
achieve the common objectives, to perceive the potential lying dormant in people and to direct
the talents, knowledge and abilities of the organization members towards the previously
established results,9 continuously aiming at the set objective: the vision assumed at the
beginning of the process. Achieving the status of the leader is not very easy; sometimes it
requires great effort on the part of the leader. The leader needs to prove to all the participants
of the process that he or she is a trustworthy person who will lead them through the process of
changes in “the least painful” way, and that the changes are inevitable despite the negative
effects they may sometimes carry with them. 7 Nowoczesne przywództwo w organizacji publicznej na rzecz zmian – rola wyższych stanowisk w służbie cywilnej w ramach Planu szkoleń centralnych w służbie cywilnej na 2011 r., Kancelaria Prezesa Rady Ministrów, Wydawnictwo Gamma, p. 27 8 Ibid., pp. 7-8. 9 J. MacGregor Burns, Władza przywódcza, we władza i społeczeństwo., Wydawnictwo Naukowe Scholar, Warszawa 1994, p. 266
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
6
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
Here, it is worth noting that the role of a leader / frontperson cannot be identified with the role
of a manager. The frontperson is not a manager, although a good manager can be the
frontperson. The fundamental difference is that the manager induces the organization
members to do the right things, whereas the frontperson additionally makes people want to do
those things. Thus, the frontperson is actually a higher role than the manager. The frontperson
aims at changes, and the manager basically concentrates on keeping the balance within the
organization.10 Hence, as far as deep changes are concerned – ones that occur in the whole
organization and involve many areas – the frontperson (leader) of the organization should step
into the breach, and in the case of changes regarding particular organizational areas (specific
segments of activity), the manager should become the agent of changes, as the manager is the
expert in a given area and is knowledgeable about the process subject to change.
4. Authorization of the leader of changes as a frontperson.
The source of authorization of the leader of change plays a significant role in the effective
realization of the process of change, as it determines the kind of interactions between the
leader and the other participants of the process. Most literature sources indicate five kinds of
authority ascribed to the foreperson. These are:11
formal authority (results from the hierarchical structure existing in the organization
and from the necessity to subdue to superior entities; however, having that kind of
authority does not make anybody a foreperson; in the process of changes, the person
may have been assigned by the unit's management to serve as the leader);
the power of rewarding is connected with granting or withholding rewards, both
material and immaterial ones, such as commendation; a person can only be called a
foreperson if the inferiors also care about being rewarded in an immaterial way;
the power of exerting force refers to the use of mental, emotional or physical force in
order to make people meet certain requirements (e.g. in the case of strong resistance to
changes);
charismatic authority is legitimized by the leader's qualities, thanks to which the
members of the organization admire and trust them and are willing to express loyalty
and devotion;
10 Nowoczesne przywództwo w organizacji publicznej na rzecz zmian – rola …, pp. 7-8. 11 R. Mrówka, Przywództwo w organizacjach. Analiza …, pp. 16-17
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
7
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
expert authority results from the competence and skills one has; the greater the
conviction among organization members of the opportunity to learn something from
the leader, the greater the authority.
In the process of change management, the best solution is for the leader to have all the above-
mentioned kinds of authority, which will ensure them the effective management of the whole
process, although the most desirable is of course the charismatic authority.
The adopted style of managing the whole process is a derivative of the kind of authority the
leader (foreperson) of the change process represents and their approach to the tasks
performed. It may be one of the following kinds:12
prescriptive style (the foreperson establishes the directions of activity and clearly
determines their expectations regarding the participants of the process, members of the
organization);
supportive style (the foreperson demonstrates care for the organization members, is
not patronizing, is an equal partner in the process and displays understanding and
friendliness);
participation style (the foreperson takes part in the process of changes, knows its
vision, objectives and strategy, and at the same time aims at involving all the members
of the organization in the process, among others by consultations and asking others for
advice);
task-oriented style (the foreperson determines ambitious targets and consistently aims
at achieving them, so as to finally achieve the ultimate objective: implementing the
change in the organization).
The selection of the management style is reflected in the course of the whole management
process; just like in the case of the source of authority, mixing particular styles is
recommended in order to achieve a better effect thanks to the use of an appropriate style
depending on the existing situation and the emerging needs.
5. Expectations towards the leader of changes versus the tasks they
really perform. 12 J. A. F. Stoner, R. E. Freeman, D. R. Gilbert, Kierowanie., PWE, Warszawa 1997, p. 469
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
8
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
Expectations towards the leader of changes, both on the part of the participants of the process
of changes and of the whole organization and its closest environment, are relatively high. The
leader is perceived as the guarantor of effectiveness of the implemented process, responsible
for each of the areas within the process.
A few main expectations directed at the leader of changes are, among others:13
higher probability of the achievement of the set objective, and thus minimization of
the risk of failure;
increasing the speed of process implementation;
integration of the organization members around a common goal and increasing their
involvement;
reducing the resistance towards changes and promoting the process of changes in the
organization;
care for employee development;
building and maintaining a high level of trust among all the participants of the process
of changes;
the ability to balance the business benefits and the personal ones.
Undoubtedly, meeting such expectations is to a great extent dependent on the leader's
personal qualities, particularly communicativeness, honesty, charisma, empathy, seriousness,
realism, the ability to make decisions and being trustworthy. 14
Regardless of whom expectations and requirements concern, they are usually excessive. There
is a popular belief that it is better to expect too much than too little of someone. But the reality
will verify them anyway by means of confrontation with the properly fulfilled tasks. As for
the leader, the catalogue of their tasks is the following:15
to be the author and at the same time guarantor of carrying out the realistic vision of
the change, whose primary goal is the good of the whole organization;
13 R. Wendt, Zarządzanie zmianą w polskiej firmie. Jak w praktyce wykorzystać szansę na rozwój bez porażek., Dom Wydawniczy Zacharek, Warszawa 2010, p. 33 14 Ibid., p. 33. 15 R. Wendt, Zarządzanie zmianą w …, p. 34 and J.W. Moran, B.K. Brightman, Leading organizational change., in:: K. Grzesiuk, Zarządzanie zmianą w aspekcie funkcjonowania człowieka w biznesie. [in:] ed. K. Machowicz, Newralgiczne aspekty współczesnych relacji między człowiekiem a biznesem., Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin 2010, pp. 142-143
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
9
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
to develop a clear and realistic plan of implementation of the change;
to confirm the belief in the success of the conducted process among all the participants
of the process of changes;
to balance the benefits for the organization and for the people engaged in the process
of changes;
to organize project groups as part of the implemented project, to assign leaders and to
coordinate their activities;
to provide the resources, tools and action plans (strategies) necessary to implement the
change;
to take responsibility for organizing and ensuring effective communication as part of
the implemented process at all the levels of the organization;
to establish control indicators and to measure and analyze them systematically;
to solve the problems occurring in the organization as they arise as a result of the
carried out process of changes;
to report to the decisive person and sponsor of the change;
to build the organizational culture by introducing new initiatives and taking up certain
“improvements”;
to ensure continuity of the change process and the appropriate speed of their
implementation.
Of course, it is not a closed catalogue of tasks assigned to the leader of changes; it is rather
the tip of the iceberg of what their tasks really involve. Together with the changing
management conditions, the scope of their tasks also changes.
6. The impact of the leader on the effectiveness of change management
process.
If the leader demonstrates a higher level of effectiveness in their activities, the process they
manage will probably be successful too and will be have the proper level of effectiveness. An
effective leader is one who:16
takes the initiative and evokes positive energy;
16 A. Dębowski., Manifest Instytutu Liderów Zmian., 2013. s. 5, http://adamdebowski.pl/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/manifest-instytut-lider%C3%B3w-zmian-2013.pdf, 20/08/2013
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
10
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
supports the group arrangement process;
helps others to discover their own value;
motivates them to action;
skilfully manages conflicts, objects to “mad” competition among the members of the
organization;
accepts learning by mistakes;
openly communicates with the environment;
ascribes the achieved success to all the participants of the change process, not only to
themselves.
The achievement of success by the leader as regards the implemented change, taking into
consideration external factors (not directly dependent on the leader), is an interaction of three
interpenetrating variables, i.e.:17
the relation between the leader and the group;
the work breakdown structure, including: the transparency of the goal, the multiplicity
of potential ways of its achievement and the specificity of the task;
the authority position of the leader.
The leader who wants to effectively and efficiently manage transitions in an organization
should be governed by the following principles:18
promotion of the attitude of dialogue, mainly based on open vertical and horizontal
communication;
implementation and teaching of respect within the organization, both with reference to
the participants of the change process and to their ideas, but also to the reliable
solutions which have contributed to the achievement of success;
initiation and promotion of cooperation between particular members of the process
considering the fact that the change process is complex and multidimensional;
encouraging organization members to present their own initiatives and actions with
respect to the ongoing change management process.
17 W. Daniecki, Strategie zmian. Refleksje …, p. 93 18 R.M. Kanter, Leadership and the psychology of turnaround., in:: K. Grzesiuk, Zarządzanie zmianą w aspekcie funkcjonowania człowieka w biznesie. [in:] ed. K. Machowicz, Newralgiczne aspekty współczesnych relacji między człowiekiem a biznesem., Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin 2010, p. 142
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
11
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
To sum up, the leader plays a significant part in the process of effective change management
on the part of an organization. They are supported in that process not only by their own
predispositions to assume leadership but also by particular principles giving a certain
framework to the whole process.
Conclusion.
With reference to Heraclitus' adage “panta rhei”, it must be noted that in the face of
ever increasing changeability and complexity of the environment, the leader / frontperson, as
the person managing the organization, including the processes of changes occurring in it, must
be ready to use new ways of forming the reality, have the ability to create the vision of the
future and to implement it effectively.19 It is the leader that guarantees the success as regards
the introduced change and shapes the process of managing it, thus he or she undoubtedly
plays the key part in the change management process at the organizational level. Having
particular predispositions, abilities, resources and instruments, they can do it effectively.
Literature:
1. Armstrong M., Zarządzanie ludźmi. Praktyczny przewodnik dla menedżerów
liniowych., Dom Wydawniczy REBIS, Poznań 2007
2. Batko R., Zarządzanie procesami w organizacji publicznej., in: ed. R. Batko,
Zarządzanie zmianą w organizacjach publicznych. Projektowanie i wprowadzanie
nowoczesnych metod i narzędzi zarządczych w Wojewódzkim Urzędzie Pracy
w Krakowie., Wojewódzki Urząd Pracy w Krakowie, Kraków 2011
19 M. Kurtyka, G. Roth, Zarządzanie zmianą. Od strategii do działania., Wydawnictwo Fachowe CeDeWu, Warszawa 2008, p. 212
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
12
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
3. Bridges W., Zarządzanie zmianami. Jak maksymalnie skorzystać na procesach
przejściowych., Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, Kraków 2008
4. A. Dębowski., Manifest Instytutu Liderów Zmian., 2013., http://adamdebowski.pl/wp-
content/uploads/2013/08/manifest-instytut lider%C3%B3w-zmian-2013.pdf
5. Daniecki W., Strategie zmian. Refleksje nad praktyką., Wydawnictwo SWPS
Academica, Warszawa 2004
6. Drabek Źródła oporu wobec zmian oraz sposoby jego przezwyciężania.,
http://www.profesor.pl/publikacja,2627,Artykuly,Zrodla-oporu-wobec-zmian-oraz-
sposoby-jego-przezwyciezania, 20/08/2013
7. Drucker P.F., Menedżer skuteczny., Akademia Ekonomiczna w Krakowie, Kraków
1994
8. Griffin R. W., Podstawy zarządzania organizacjami., PWN, Warszawa 1998
9. Grzesiuk K., Zarządzanie zmianą w aspekcie funkcjonowania człowieka w biznesie.
[in: ed. K. Machowicz, Newralgiczne aspekty współczesnych relacji między
człowiekiem a biznesem., Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin 2010
10. Kaczorowska B. (ed.), Przewodnik lidera. Portrety, inspiracje, pytania.,
Stowarzyszenie Szkoła Liderów, Warszawa 2009
11. Koźmiński, Zarządzanie. Teoria i praktyka., PWN, Warszawa 2006 Krupa K.,
Ewolucja procesu zmian organizacyjnych. Wybrane poglądy i koncepcje., Łódź 2003
12. Kurtyka M., Gerard R., Zarządzanie zmianą. Od strategii do działania.,
Wydawnictwo Fachowe CeDeWu, Warszawa 2008
13. MacGregor Burns J., Władza przywódcza, we władza i społeczeństwo., Wydawnictwo
Naukowe Scholar, Warszawa 1994
14. Moran J.W., Brightman B.K., Leading organizational change., in:: K. Grzesiuk,
Zarządzanie zmianą w aspekcie funkcjonowania człowieka w biznesie. [in:] ed.
K. Machowicz, Newralgiczne aspekty współczesnych relacji między człowiekiem
a biznesem., Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin 2010
15. Mrówka R., Przywództwo w organizacjach. Analiza najlepszych praktyk., Oficyna
Wydawnicza Wolters Kluwer Business, Warszawa 2010
16. Stoner J. A. F., Freeman R. E., Gilbert D. R., Kierowanie., PWE, Warszawa 1997
17. Wawak T., Lider i przywódca zmian., http://tadeusz.wawak.pl/content/lider-i-
przywodca-zmian, 20/08/2013
Projekt „Partnerski System Zarządzania Zmianą Gospodarczą na Obszarach Natura 2000” nr POKL.08.01.02-20-027/11
13
Projekt współfinansowany przez Unię Europejską w ramach Europejskiego Funduszu Społecznego oraz Budżet Państwa
18. Wendt R., Zarządzanie zmianą w polskiej firmie. Jak w praktyce wykorzystać szansę
na rozwój bez porażek., Dom Wydawniczy Zacharek, Warszawa 2010