1

. .

2

"" 1989

. . . . - . - . 3

. .1 1 . " " . " " . . . . . . . - 1 . . 1969 1971 . . : 1988 . . 1978 . . 1982 . . 1983 . . 1975 . . 1983 . . .. 1987 . . 1982 . . 1973 . . 1982 . . 1985 . . .1986

4

. . . . . . . . . . . . . .5

. . . . . : . . - - " " . . ) (Authorities . . . 6

. . . . . . ) (.Pfleiderer O ] [ " " " : ... ".1 " . " ) (.Hirsch Em " ".2 * . . . " - Pfleiderer O. Geschichte der Religionsphilosophie. Berlin, 1893. S. 30. - Hirsch Em. Die Geschichte der neuern evangelischen Theologie. Bd. 1. Gutersloh, 1975. S. 175.1 2

* - )( )( "" -. 7

.1"... . ) (.Collins J - 1730 -1830 " " . . . " . - - . ".2 -2 . . . . .

- 1 . . 4 .445 2 - Collins J. The Emergence of Philosophy Religion. New Haven; L., 1967. P. 8

8

. ... . . . . . : .. . . . " " " " .. . .1 " " "" "- " "" "" "" . " " - Die religise Dimension der Gesellschaft: Religion und ihre Theorien. Tbingen, 1985. S. 1-5.1

9

." " " ". . " " " " . * .

) (.Penelham T " - " " ".1 - - " ".2 ) (.Van Buren P. M " " .3"" " " * - ) (Theism -. 1 - Penelham T. Religion and Rationality: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Religion. N. Y., 1971. P. 199. 2 - Penelham T. God and Scepticism: A Study in the Scepticism and Fideism. Dordrecht, 1983. P. 169. 3 - Van Buren P. M. The Edges of Language: An Essay in the Logic of a Religion. N. Y., 1972. P. 1. 10

. . " ".1 . . . * . ** . . . . . 1

- Ibid. P. 2.

* - "" "" -. ) ( ) (secular ** - -.

11

. )(. . . . ) (Internationalization - . . " . - ) - (.Barbour J . . ".1 . . " ". * . - Barbour J. Myths, Models and Paradigms: A Comparative Study in Science and Religion. N. Y., 1974. P. 2.1

12

. . . * * *

. . . " : . . ".1 . . .* - " " . - " " . 1 - Schaeffler R. Religionsphilosophie. Freiburg; Mnchen, 1983. S. 14.

13

"" . "" . . . . . . . . " " "" . . ) (Theism . . .

14

. . : ... . . . . . "" . . . . . . : .

15

* . . . . . * . . " "**. . ...* - ( ) Hermneutique -. * - ) (Fideism -. ** - "" -.

16

. * * *

. . . . . " "" " . . . . . .

17

. . . . . . . -3 . . . . . . .1 . " : " 2 ) (.Charlesworth M. J - 1 : . . .1985 2 - Charlesworth M. J. Philosophy of Religion: The Historic Approaches. Macmillan, 1972. 18

" : " " " " " " ". ) (.Schaeffler R " : " " " " " " " " " . . . . ) (Typology . . . . ) (.Pailin D. A " : ".1 " " " " . .1

- Pailin D. A. Groundwork of Philosophy of Religion. L., 1986. P. 24.

19

" : " " " " " . . " " . " " . . . . . . . " " . . . 20

. * )A . (pology " " . "" "" . . . . . . . . . . * * *

* "Apology" - " "apologeomani -.

21

. . . . . . * * *

. - -. - . . - . . .

22

. ..1 . . . . . . - . . . - : . - - - 1 : . : . - : .1985

23

- . . . - .

. .

24

. . . . : - .1 . "". . . . "" - - .

) (.Burtt E. A " : " .2 - " - - 1 . .2

- Burtt E. A. Types of Religious Philosophy. N. Y.; L., 1939. P. 6. 25

".3 " " . . . " " . "" . . . . . . . * * *

. " " " " " " .3

- Ibid. P. 7. 26

. . . . - - . ) ( . "" . . - - . . . . . . 27

. . ) (.Wiebe D" : ) ( .. "" . " " ".1 . " " . . . . " " " ". ) (.Dupre W " ) (Metatheory " .2 "" " " . . . .

1 2

- Wiebe D. Religion and Truth. The Hague; P.; N. Y., 1981. P. 185. - Dupre W. Einfhrung in die Religionsphilosophie. Stuttgart et al., 1985. S. 9. 28

. .

29

. " -1 " . . . " " " . - ) (.Hennigfeld I " " - " .1 . ) (.Kuhlmann W " " " -* " .2 " : * " . . - . . . - Hennigfeld I. Sprachphilosophie des 20. Jahrhunderst. Berlin; N. Y., 1982. S. 1. * - - )(Intersubjectivit -. 2 - Kuhlmann W. Reflexive Letztbegrndung: Untersuchung zur Transzendentalpragmatik. Freiburg; Mnchen, 1985. S. 16. * - " ) ( " ) 1989 -(503.1

30

- . . . " ". . " " ) ( . . . . -. " " . " " . " " " " . " " . . 31

. . ) (.Bochenski I ). (Neo-Scholasticism . . " - - " .1 " " . . " " . "" . . ) (Synthesis . " -" . : .. . . " " . . . " ". . - Bochenski I. Erffnungsrede zum achten internationalen Wittgenstein Symposium 1983 // Religiosphilosophie Philosophy of Religion: Akten des 8. Intern. Wittgenstein Symmp. Wien, 1984. S. 22.1

32

. * * *

. . . . . . - - . " " " " . ) .(.Donovan P " . - - "" ".1 . . . " ".21

- Donovan P. Religious Language. N. Y. 1976. P.1. - 2 . : . 1983 .11 33

. . . " " . . "" . . ) (Factual ) (Apriori . . . . .

34

)Logical (Positivism . . . . ) (Logical Atomism . . . . . . - ) Just W.- (.D " " " ".1 . . ) (.Schrdter H " " " " . " 2 " .- Just W.- D. Religise Sprache und analytische Philosophie. Stuttgart et al., 1975. S. 46. 2 - Schrdter H. Analytische Religionsphilosophie. Freiburg; Mnchen, 1979. S.50.1

35

" " . . " " . * * *

. . . . . -2 * . . - .* - -. 36

" " ) .(.Wittgenstein L " " . " " . " " . . " " . ** - . . " " "" . . . . " " 1 ) ( . . . . . ** - ) (Isomorphism ) isos morphe ( . -1

- Wittgenstein l. Werkausgabe in 8 Bde. Bd 1. Frankfurt am Mein, 1984. 37

. . . " : ".1 " " . ) ""(. " " ) ( "" ) .(Mystical " " .2 ."" " " "" . . "" """ " " " . "" "" . "" . "". . . " " "" "" . "" .1 2

- Ibid. S. 84. - Ibidem. 38

" " . "" . "" . ) (Transcendental "". . " " . . ) (Esoterism . "" " " . - - . ) (Apology "" ) (.D`hert I " " .1 " " .2 " " " : " . "" . 1 2

- D'hert I. Wittgenstein's Relevance for Theology. Bern; Fankfurt am Mein, 1975. - Ibid. P. 22. 39

" " ".1 " " . " " "" .2 . " " " ". " " . " " "" . . . . * * *

. " " . .1 2

- Ibid. P. 180. - Ibid. P. 33. 40

"" . "" . . " " "" . . " " " " " " - . )(Paradigm ) .(.Rudolf C " : " " ."Erkenntnis . . . " " "" "" . . " " ) Sadaba Garay (.J " 41

. . ".1 . - ) (.Dahms H.-I . . " " .2 . - - . ) (Verification . " ".3 . . ) (.Ayer A . - Sadaba Garay J. Lenguaje religioso y filosofia analitica. Madrid; Barcelona, 1977. P. 28. 2 - Dams H.. I. Versuch einer Charakterisierung des Wiener // Philosophie, Wissenschaft, Aufklrung: Beitrge zur Geschichte und Wirkung des Wiener Kreises. Berlin; N. Y. S. 22. 3 - Ibid. S. 24.1

42

. . . . " " " ... " .1 ) * (Tautology . . . . " " " : ".2 .3 - Ayer A. Language, Truth and Logic. L., 1936. P. 174. * - ) (Tautology -. 2 - Ayer A. Language, Truth and Logic. N. Y., 1952. P. 13. - 3 . .1

43

. . ) (.Flew A . " ". " " . : . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . " 1 " . - - .- Flew A. theology and Falcification // New Essays in Philosophical Theology. L. 1955. P. 97.1

44

. . . . " " .. . . ] [.. . " "" "" " " " . . " " . . . " " .1 " "" : ".2 : )Factual (assent " " : . 1 2

- Ibid. P. 98. - Ibid. P. 99. 45

. )( . . . . . " " . . . ) (.Nielsen K " ". . . " * " " ". " " . : . * - ) (Anthropomorphism -. 46

. " " " " .1 . . . . . . . ).(Doctrine " " .2 . " ".3 . . - Nielsen K. An Introduction to the Philosophy of Religion. L.; Basingstoke, 1982. P. 141. 2 - Ibid. P. 146. 3 - Ibid. P. 171.1

47

. . . . . . . . . ) (Factual . . . . . . . . . . 48

. . . -3 . . . . . . . " ". . . .

49

. . V (.Braithwaite R ) 1 ) (erification : . . . . . . ) Hare (.R. M . " " .2 . - - . . . . " " . " " . - Braithwaite R. An Empiricists View of the Nature of Religious Belief // Philosophy of Religion. N. Y. et al., 140 163. 2 - Hare R. M. Theology and Falsification (B) // New Essays in Philosophical Theology. L., 1955. P. 99.1

50

. " " . " " . ) (non-cognition " " . *. ) -(Expressive .. . . . . " " ) (Theism "" . "" )(Perspectivism - - ) .(.Jones H. O ""* - ... . - * - -. 51*

. " - " : -" - . . ".1 - . . . . - " " . . . " " . : * " ". ) (Surrogate . " " - Jones H. O. Die Logik theologischer Perspektiven: Eine sprachanalytishe Untersuchung. Gttingen, 1985. S. 11. * - -.1

52

. . . . . . . . . . . " " . " " " " . ) (.Alston W. P " ".1

- Alston W. P. The Christian Language Game// The Autonomy of Religious Belief. Notre Dame; L., 1981. P. 139.1

53

" " " " . . " " " " . . . . . . . . " ". " ) *(Fideism" . . " : " " " . . * - ) (Fideism -.

54

. . . . . " " . . " "" ".1 " " " " . . . . . . " " ) (.Haikola L " " " ) .(Intelligible

1

- Ibid. P. 1. 55

".1 " " . ) (.Hick J " ".2 . . . " " " " : . . . . . . . - Haikola L. Religion as Language-Game. Lund, 1977. P. 14. - Hick J. Seeing-as and Religious Experience// Religionsphilosophie; Philosophy of Religion; Akten des 8. Intern. Wittgestein Symp. P. 46.1 2

56

. . ) .(.Phillips D. Z " " . " ".1 " " . )(Paradigm . " " " " .2 "" ) (Fideism . . : : : : : . . 1 2

- Sadaba Garay J. Op. Cit. P. 68. - Phillips D. Z. Belief, Change and Forms of life. L., 1986. P. XI. 57

. . " " .1 . . . . " " ) .(External . " " ) .(Internal " " . " . . ".2 . . .

1 2

- Ibid. P. 79. - Ibid. P. 83. 58

" " " ".3 " " . . . " " " " . -4 " " . . . " " . . . " " .3

- Ibid. P. 109. 59

: ) (Theism ) (Agnosticism . ... . . . . . . . . . ) (Apology . . ) .(Expressive 60

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

61

. . " ". " " . . . ) (.Ferm D. W " ".11

- Ferm D. W. Contemporary American Theologies. N. Y., 1981. P. 3. 62

. . ) (.Iandell K. E " ) ( . ".1 . . . . -1 . . . . . - Iandell K. E., Some Prolegomena to the Epistemology of Religion // Intern. Journal for Philosophy of Religion. Vol. 12. N.4. The Hague, 1981. P. 214.1

63

. ) (.Adams E . " " " . - - " .1 . . . " " . . . "* " " ". - Adams E. The Accountability of Religious Discourse // Intern. Journal for Philosophy of Religion. Vol. 18. N 1. Dordrecht, 1985. P.3. * - ) (Agnosticism -.1

64

. " ". ) .(Cognition ) " (.Wiebe D ".1 . " . : ) (Transcendent " .2 . ) .(Alter . . . . . " " . . .1 2

- Wiebe D. Op. cit. - Ibid. P. 15. 65

" . " .1 " " . " : ".2 . . " . : " .3 ) (Doctrine . . " . . ".4 . " " . ) (- Ibid. P. 3. - Ibid. P. 5. 3 - Ibid. P. 35. 4 - Ibid. P. 185.1 2

66

. " ". . " . " .1 . . . 2 . . . . . . 1 2

- Ibid. P. 188. - Christian W. Meaning and truth in Religion. Princeton, 1964. 67

. " " . . : . . .. . . . . -2 . . ) (.Whittaker J. H " ) ( ".1- Whittaker J. H. Matters of Faith and Matters of Principle: Religious Truth Claims. Their Logic. San Antonio, 1981. P. 50.1

68

. . . .

" " - ) (.King-Farlow J ) (.Christensen W. N . " " . 1 - " " " " ) .(Dogmatism " " . - . " " . . . " " " . "" "". " " .- King- Farlow J., Christensen W. N. Faith and the Life of Reason. Dordrecht, 1972. P. 3.1

69

" ".1 . " " ." : " .2 " ". " " . " " . . " " .3 . . " " . " . ".4 . .

- Ibid. P. 16. - Whittaker J. Op. Cit. P. X. 3 - Ibid. P. 3. 4 - Ibid. P. 138.1 2

70

. . . . "". . . ) (Non-cognitivism . . " " . . . . . "" ) (Non-cognitivism .71

. -3 . . . . . . . . . . . 72

) (Fideism . . . . . . . . . . . . ) (Paradigm . )(Cognitivism . 73

. ) (Non-cognitivism . . . . . ) *(Apologetics . . . . . . . . ) (Demarcation * - ) ( -. 74

- . . . . . . . B " " 1 ) (.arbour I . . " ".2 . " ".3 " " " " . ".4 . . .- Barbour I. Op. Cit. - Ibid. P. 2. 3 - Ibid. P. 30. 4 - Ibid. P. 48.1 2

75

. " " . . . . ) ( . " ".1 "" "" : (1 * (2 (3 . (1 (2 (3 . "" "" " . - - 2 " "" "" .

- Ibid. P. 113. * - ) (Paradigm " " ) 168 (23 ) (Incommensurability . -. 2 - Ibid. P. 145.1

76

. " ". " " " " " ) .(Instrumentalism " " " . " ". " " . . . " " " " . ) (.Schoen E " " .1 " " " " . . . " - - " .2 " " - - - Schoen E. Religious Explanations: A Model from the Sciences. Durham, 1985. P. IX. 2 - Ibid. P. 21.1

77

. " " .1 . " " . . " . . ) ( ".2 . . . ) (.Stansby D . " " . . . " " .3 - Ibid. P. 62. - Ibid. P. 30. 3 - Stansby D. Science, Reason and Religion. L, et., al., 1985. P. 28.1 2

78

. . . . . "" "" "". . . . . . " " .1 . . . . 1

- Ibid. P. 195. 79

. . . . . . . . - - . "" . "" . "") . (Foundationalism

80

"" 1 . "" " " . . ) (.Plantinga A . . . " " " ) ( - " 2 . " : ) ( " .3 " ".4

"" . - 1 " "Foundationalism "" "" ) (Fundamentalism . 2 - Plantinga A. God and Other Minds. Ithaca, 1967. P. VII. 3 - Plantinga Alvin. Dordrecht, 1985. P. 33. 4 - Ibid. P. 34. 81

: * . " " . " ".1 " . " "" " . : " .2 " " . " " . ... . . . . * - ) (Circle . : ) 2000 .(351 -. 1 - Ibidem. 2 - Ibid. P. 59. 82

. " " . . . . . . . Contingency "" . * . ** " ."Fideism " "Subjective "."Autonomy ) .(.Malkolm N " " . " " .

* - -. ** - . -. 83

" " " " . . " : ".1 . . . "". . . . " " . " ".2 " " " " . . " " ". . ".3- Malkolm N. The Groundlessness of Belief // Reason and Religion. Ithaca, 1977. P. 145. 2 - Ibid. P. 148. 3 - Ibid. P. 156.1

84

*

*

*

. . . . . . . . ) .(Existential "" "" "" . . . ) (Genetic . . ) (Socialization . 85

" "* . .

" " . . " " . . . - . . * - ) (Reductionism ) 2001 855( . - . 86

. . . . . . "" "" . " ". . " ". -1 " " ) (.Crosby D " " . " . " . : " ".11

- Crosby D. Interpretive Theories of Religion. The Hague, 1981. 87

" " . " " . . . . " " : . . )( * . . . . . " " . )( . * - -. 88

) (Model . " " " ) (Causality" . . . . . " " .1 . . . . "" . . . 1

- Ibid. P. 17. 89

. "" . . "" . . . "" " " . """ "" "" "... " ". * . " " . "" . "- " " -" . - . . - .* - "" "" - 90

" " . . . " " . ) (Characters . ) (Attributes . - . . " . ) (Subject" -"" "" "" " "" .1"... -. "" . "" . . 1

- Ibid. P. 22. 91

" . . 1 " . "" . . . . """ "" "" "" "" ". "" . . "" . """ "" "... . . . " " . " " . " . " " .2 "" "" "...1 2

- Ibid. P. 234. - Ibid. P. 244. 92

""" . . " .1 """ "" "" "" "... "" . . . . """ "" "... "" . . . "" " "" "... ) ( . . . . . . * * *

1

- Ibid. P. 251. 93

. . . . . . "" . . . . . . . . . .

94

-2 " " . ) (.Burke T. P " " . " ". : . . . - - " " . " - - ".1 " " .2 . "". " ". . .

- Burke T. P. The Reluctant Vision: An Essay in the Philosophy of Religion. Philadelphia, 1974. P. 19. 2 - Ibid. P. 3.1

95

. . "" . . " ".1 )( . . . " " . . " " . " " . . " 2 " . " " " ". . . . .1 2

- Ibid. P. 39. - Ibid. P. 41. 96

) (Fact . . . . " " . . )( "". . "" . " ".1 . "" "" . "" . " " "" . . - - . " " " " . ) "(A Priori " .

1

- Ibid. P. 13. 97

. . . " " . ) .(Relativism . " ".1 . . . . . " ".2

1 2

- Ibid. P. 50. - Ibid. P. 130. 98

. . " " " . " " . . . " " "" . " "" " . . (1 : . (2 . . (3 . . . . .99

. . " ) (Positive ". . " " . " " .1 . . . . . " " . . . - . . . . 1

- Ibid. P. 112. 100

" " . . . . -3 . . . . : . . . . . - . .

101

. - . . . . . . . . . " " . "" . . . . .102

. .

" " " " .

103

. . . . . . . " " . . . "" " " )(Intellectualism . . " " . " " " " 104

" " . .

" " ) (.Heinrichs M " "" : . ".1 " " . " " ) ( . " . - - ".2 . . . : .

- Heinrichs M. Christliche Offenbarung und religise Erfahrung in Dialog. Paderborn et al., 1984. S. 25. 2 - Ibid. S. 18.1

105

) *(Pantheism )Panent **(heism . . "" "" "" . - - . . ) (.Gill J. H " " 1 . . . . . . . " " . " : " " "* . * - " " ) 2000 -(938. ** - " ) .1828 1989 -(459. 1 - Gill J. H. The Possibility of Religious Knowledge. Grand Rapids, 1971. * - ) (Secular Theology 106

. "" . " : " .1 " " . . * * *

. . " " . .

: " " . " " . . ) (1945 -1906 " . " " " . " " . ( ) -. 1 - Ibid. P. 119. 107

- . . . . . . ) (.Louis D " . " " : ".1 """ " "" ... . . " " " " . . -1 : - Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Vol. 5, 6. N. Y., 1972. P. 284. 108

1

. . . ) (.Webb M " " . " . . . ".1 : . . . . . . .

- Webb M. Religions Experience as Doubt Resolution // Intern. Journal for Philosophy of Religion. Vol. 18. N 2. Dordrecht, 1985. P. 81.1

109

. . : . . . . . . . . . " ".1 )(Doctrinal . . .1

- Gill J. H. Op. Cit. P. 92. 110

. . . ) (.Mcpherson Th " " " : . . 1 " . " . " . ) (.Clark R " ".2 " " . . . . - Mcpherson Th. Philosophy and Religious Belief. L., 1974. P. 4. - Clark R. The Evidential Value of Religious Experiences // Intern. Journal for Philosophy of Religious. Vol. 16. N 3. Dordrecht, 1984. P. 18.1 2

111

. . . . ) (.Proudfoot W " ".1 "" . " : " " ". " " . . . . . " " . . " " .2 . . 1 2

- Proudfoot W. Religious Experience. Berkeley et al., 1985. - Ibid. P. 197. 112

. . "" "" . " " . " " . " . 1 " . . . - ) (.Brakenhielm K.-R " " .2 "" . " ". - " " " ".3 "" ) (Conceptual .- Ibid. P. 235. - Brakenhielm K.- R. Problems of Religious Experience. Uppsala, 1985. 3 - Ibid. P. 111 2

113

" : ) (Intentionality ".1 " " " " . . " . - - ".2 . . . . . . " " . . " (1 : (2 1 2

- Ibid. P. 26. - Ibid. P. 35. 114

) ( (3 ".1 " -" " " "" . " " " " . . . "" " " . . " " " -" . . - " - " . . " " . . . . . ) (.Davies B " ".1

- Ibid. P. 31. 115

" " " " . " " . " " . . . " ".1 " " ) (Presence . . " " "" . . . . " " . " " . " " . -2 ) (Mysticism "- Davies B. An Introduction to the Philosophy of Religion. Oxford; N. Y., 1982. P. 71.1

116

" . . . " " . . . . . * . . : . . . * - . 117

. . . . "" " " " " " " "" . . . . - . . . . . . 118

. . " " . . . . ) ( . . . . " : .1"... . . - 1 : .361 119

. . . . . " " ) .(Autobiography . - . . : . . ) *(Ecumenical . . . . * - ) (Ecumenism -. 120

" " . . - - )(Specification ) ( . - . .. . " " . . - . "" . . . "" "" . .

121

1 .2 . . . . . . . . ) *(Non-intelligible . . 1 2

- Die Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart. Bd 4. Tbingen, 1960. S. 1238. - Scholem G. Die judische Mzstik in ihren Hauptstrmungen. Zrich, 1957. S. 8- 11. * - ) (Non-intelligible ) (Irrationalism - 122

. . . (.Staal F ) 1 " " " ) (Irrationalism" . . . . " " .2 . . " ". " . 3 ". .- Staal F. Exploring Mysticism: A Methodol. Essay. Berkeley et al., 1975. - Ibid. P. 33. 3 - Ibid. P. 59.1 2

123

. ) (.Stace W. T . (1 : ) ( (2 ... (3 (4 (5 . " " .1 . . . ) (affective . . . . . ) (.Streng Fr . " "(1 :2 (2 (3 ) (transcendent (4 - (5 . - Stace W. T. Mysticism and Philosophy. L., 1960. P. 132. - Streng Fr. Language and Mystical Awareness // Mysticism and Philosophical Analisis. L., 1978. P. 142.1 2

124

"" . - . . . . ) ( - )( . ) (.Keller C. A : " . : ".1 " " " " . ) (.Ellwood R. C " " . . " " " " . . . " : ) .(Ecstasy 1

- Keller C. A. Mystical Literature // Mysticism and Philosophical Analysis. P. 77. 125

".1 " " . . . . )(Doctrinal . " :" "" "" "" "" "" " " "" "" . "" . . * . . " " " : ) ( ) ( ** ".21

- Ellwood R. C. Mysticism and Religion. Englewood cliffs, 1980. P. 69. * - ) (1327 -1260 . ) 820 -788( - . 126

. (1 : (2 (3 - . . " " 1 . . " ": " " " " " " . : . ) ( ".2 " " . . . "". . "" .

** - ) (Mahayana ) (Hinayana - 2 - Suzuki D. T. Mysticism Christian and Buddhist. L., 1957. P. 12. 1 - Otto R. West-stliche Mystik. Gotha, 1926. 2 - Ibid. S. 53 54. 127

""" . * ".1 " " . : "" "" . . "" . . : (1 . (2 . . . "" . .2 . . ) (Monism "" ) .(.Zaehner R. C * - -. 1 - Ibid. S. 56 57. 2 - Stace W. Op. cit. P. 79. 128

" " 1 : ) ( . . . . . " " . " " - - . * . . . . . ) (Pantheism . . " " . ) (.Smart N ** " " )(Noumenon1

- Zaehner R. C. Mysticism, Sacred and profane. N. Y., 1961. * - ) - - ( - ** - ) (Noumenon )= (Phenomenon 129

. ] -[ . ) (Monism . . . ) (.Almond Ph " " " " . . " . - : - "" "" "" ".1 " " "" . . . " " " " " " . ) Wainwright W. (.I . "" "

. -. 1 - Almond Ph. Mystical Experience and Religious Doctrine. Berlin et al., 1982. P. 7. 130

" .1

(1 : . )( (2 . (3 . . *. . . . . . "" . . . ) (Duality . . . . . : 1

- Wainwright W. I. Mysticism. Brighton, 1981. P. 41. * - " .. . "" " ) 1989 -(331. 131

. . . . ) -(.Moore P " " - " . ".1 . "" " " . . . . . . . ) (.Katz S - Moore P. Mystical Experience, Mystical Doctrine, Mystical Technique // Mysticism and Philosophical Analysis. P. 108.1

132

" " ".1 " . " " . . . . . . . -1 : )(Doctrinal . " ) -Retrospective). 2 . " ) -Reflective). 3 . " " :( ... ) ( ( " " ) ( (4 . . " ". . - Katz S. Language, Epistemology and Mysticism // Mysticism and Philosophical Analysis. P. 128.1

133

. -1 : . -2 . )( -3 . -4 . . -5 .1 . " " . . . . . . .1

- Almond Ph. Op. cit. P. 128. 134

. ) (Perception . . . . . . . . . . . . "" " " . . 135

. * * *

"" "" . . . . : . . . . .

136

. "" . . . .

137

. "" . "" "" " "" "" ". - ) (Theism . . " ". " -1" - - . ) (.Kellenberger J " " 1 " " . " " . "" ).(Existential " " " " . - Kellenberger J. Three Models of Faith // Intern. Journal for Philosophy of Religion. Vol. 12. N4. The Hague, 1981. P. 217- 234.1

138

. . . . .*

. . . . " " . . . . . " *" . . . . " " " " " " . " " " " . .

* - -. - * - ) ( Absurd . 139

. .1 . " " ) .(Paradox " " .2 . . . " ". . . . " " "" " . ".3 ] - .[. " " . . "" " ." " ".4 " " . " " " "... .- Ibid. P. 220. - Ibidem. 3 - Ibid. P. 221. 4 - Ibid. P. 225.1 2

140

" " . . . " . " .1 " " - " . " . "" . . . . . ) ( . . "" 2 P ) .(.enelham T "" " " . . 1 2

- Ibid. P. 231. - Penelham T. God and Scepticism: A Study in Scepticism and Fideism. 141

. . " " " " . . " . - - " .1 . . " ". " " "" ) .(Emotion ) (Affective . . . " " . " " . . . " " . . - Ibid. P. 177. 142

1

. " " . " : ".1 . . " " . . ) (Fideism " " .2 . ) (Argumentation . . : " " )Non- (dogmatic * . . . 1 2

- Ibid. P. 180. - Ibid. P. 1. * - ) 270 -360 .( )( -. 143

. " " . . ( "" ) . . . . . . " " . . . .

144

. .

) (.Runzo J . " * " 1 . . " " . " " . . "" . "" * . " " . - " " . )( . " : ... ) ( ".2

* - ) (Relativism -. 1 - Runzo J. Reason, Relativism and God. Basingstoke; L., 1986. * - )( )( ) (Conceptions. 2 - Ibid. P. 212. 145

. " " .1 . " : 2 " . " " . . . . . . ) ( . ) ( . " " . .3- Ibid. P. 17. - Ibid. P. 81. 3 - Ibid. P. 35.1 2

146

. . "" . " " . . " " . . " " " " . - - . * * *

- . - "" . "" ] - .[. . " -2" - .

147

) (.Sayre K . . . . " " .1 "" " " . . . . . : . . . . . .- Sayre K. A Perceptual Model of Belief in God // The Autonomy of Religious Belief. P. 108- 127.1

148

. . . " " . . " " . " " . " " . "" "" . . " " " . - - " .1 . . " " ) (Intentional )(.1

- Ibid. P. 122. 149

. " " . . . . " " . "" " " . " ".1 . . "" . . . * * *

. "

1

- Ibid. P. 126. 150

".1 . " ". . "" "" "" ) (Tradition . . . - " " . . . . " " " " . . . " :

1

- The Worlds Religions Traditions. Edinburgh, 1984. P. 3. 151

".1 . . " " .2 . " " ) .(Intellectual " " " ". " " . ) (Transcendent . . . " "" ".3 - . - . . . " " . - Ibid. P. 11. - Ibid. P. 8. 3 - Ibid. P. 168.1 2

152

. . . . . " " . . . * * *

. . : . - . - )(Subject . 153

. : ) ( . . .

154

. . * . . " " 1 .

) (.Whaling F . " " .2 - - " " . " ) (".3 . .

* - -. 1 - Contemporary Approaches to the Study of Religion: In 2 Vols. Mouton. 1984. 2 - Whaling F. Introduction: The Contrast between the classical and Contemporary Periods in the Study of Religion // Ibid. Vol. 1. P. 14. 3 - Ibidem. 155

. . . . . . . ) (.King U " " .1 "". . . : . . . . "" . 1

- King U. Historical and Phenomenological Approaches // Ibid. Vol. 1. P. 35. 156

. . . . . . . . . . . : ... . " " " " . . . . 157

. . . . " " . " - - " 1 . . . . . . . . .- Additional Note on Philosophy of Science and the Study of Religion // Whaling F. Ibid. Vol. 1. P. 385.1

158

. . . . . . . . . - . . . . . . . . . .159

. -1 . - - . . " " ) ( " " ) .(1887 . "" ) .(1917 . ) - .(1985 " " . 1925 " " 1933 " " . . .160

. * . . . . . . . " " ) (Epoche . . " " . . . " " "* - ) ( System " " " " " " -. 161

" . ) (Empathy . - - " . " " - " - . " ". . . "" "" "" ... . . ) (.Schaeffler R " : - - . . ...

162

" " ".1 . . . . . -2 . " " . " " ).(IAHR - - - . " " . . . 1

- Schaeffler R. Reigionsphilosophie. S. 108. 163

. . . - . )( - . . ) (.Davies D " : ... . . ".1 . * . 1

- Davies D. J. Meaning and Salvation in Religious Studies. Leiden, 1984. P. 1. * - ) (Animism -. 164

. . . : . - - . . )(Reductionism . . . . ) (.Wilson E " "" . ".1 -3* 1

- Wilson E. On Human Nature. Cambridge (Mass. ); L., 1978. P. 3. * - ) (Hermneutique ) ( - . 165

. . . . " " . ) (.Bollnow O . . : " " . : - - : )( ) ( ) ( . - . . . ." - - ".1 .

- Bollnow O. F. Religionswissenschaft als hermeneutische Disziplin // Bollnow O. F. Studien zur Hermeneutik. Freiburg; Mnchen, 1982. S. 300.1

166

* . . . " . " .1 . "". . . . . " " .2 . . . . * - ) ( " "" . " . ) (1834 -1768 " : ". )( : ) . : 1991 76 2001 -(229. 1 - Ibid. S. 306. 2 - Ibid. S. 308. 167

. " )( . . . ) ( . ".1 " : ".2 )( . . )( . -4 - . ) .(.Smart N . " " 1 2

- Ibid. S. 311. - Ibid. S. 313. 168

. " *" . " " . . " " . . . : " - - . . ".1* - ) ( . "" . ) ( : " " ) .(1981 2001 -638. 1 - Smart N. Worldviews: Crosscultural Explorations of Human Beliefs. N. Y., 1983. P. 1. 169

" : )( . "" . * ".1 : ) (Plural ) (Systematical " " : - )( .2 " " . " . ".3* - ) (Projection -. - Ibid. P. 17. - Ibid. P. 15 20. 3 - Smart N. The Philosophy of Worldviews: The Philosophy of Religion Transformed // Smart N. Concept and Empathy: Essays in the Study of Religion. L.; Basingstoke,1 2

170

" " . . . " " . . " ". " 1 " . " ".2 . " " . . * * *

. .1986. P. 85. 1 - Ibid. P. 74. 2 - Ibidem. 171

. . " " . . . . . .

" " .

172

. - - . . " " . . . . . . . . - ) .(Affective . . " ". . .173

. . . . . - - . . . . ) (Cognitivism ) (Non-cognitivism : . " " -174

. - - . . "" "" "" "" . . : . . "" "" .. . . : . . . . . - . .

175

* . . . ) (Cognitivism . ) ( . . . . . " " . . .

* - -. 176

. . . . . . . ) (Interpretative . . . .177

. .

*

-1

" " " : "" * - ) (Confessional ) (Non-confessional -. 178

"" "" "" "" "" " . " " . " " . " " . . " " . " " " " . " " . " " . " " . " " " " . " " . . . . " " 179

" " . . . " " " " . *. " " . " " . " " . " " " ". "" " " . " " . " " . .

* - ) (Neo-Scholasticism ) ( -. 180

" " . )( . . * * *

. . . . . . " ". " " . . " ". . . .

181

" ) "(confessional . . ).(non-confessional . . . . . """ " . ) (.Kremer K" : . ".1 . . * - Kremer K. Die Problemsituation // Um Mglichkeit oder Unmgtichkeit natrlicher Gotteserkenntnis heute. Leiden, 1985. S. 2. * - " " " " non a ) (non = 1

182

. . . . "" . . )( . . . . . * . . . . . - . * - . . 183

. "" . . . . . . . . " "* ) (De-Hellenism . . "" . . . . . - * - 184

.. . . )( ) (exegetical . . . . . - - . . * * *

" ". .185

. " " . . . . " " . . . " "" " " " . . . . " " . * * *

.186

. . . - - "" . . . . " " " ." . "" ) (Hierophany . "" )(Theophany . "" . "" 187

. " " . "" . "" . "" . "" . .. . "" . -2 . . . . . 188

. . . . . . . . * * *

. . . . .

189

. * * *

. . . . . . . . . . . . " . - ) -(.Mller I ".1- Mller I. Einleitung: Der unbewltigte Gott der Philosophen// Der Streit um den Gott der Philosophen. Dsseldorf, 1985. S. 7.1

190

. .1 . " " . . . . . . . . . )Neo- - 1 : 19 312 -309311 -307 22 .474 -473 191

(positivism . " " ).(Onto-Theo-Logic " " ) (De-objectivity " " " " . . " " . (.O`Leary J. S ) 1 " " . . " " . " " " "" " . " " . " ".- O`Leary J. S. Questioning Back: The Overcoming of Metaphysics in Christian Tradition. Minneapolis et al., 1985.1

192

" " . . " . . " .1 . " ". . " ". . . " " . " . . " .2 . . " )( " .3 - Ibid. P. 203. - Ibid. P. 5. 3 - Ibid. P. 57.1 2

193

" " . " " " " . " . " .1 " " . . . " ) .2" (Ontotheology . . . . . " ". 1 2

- Ibid. P. 7. - Ibid. P. 13. 194

. 1 . . " " . . . -3 . . . . . . . - 1 .Heidegger et la question de Dieu. P., 1980 : 195

" " . . . ) (Dogmatic . . . . . . . . . . . . . .196

. . . . . . " " . . ).(Neo-Scholasticism . . . ) (Balthazar H. U. von " : ".1- Balthasar H. U. von. Regagner une philosophie a partir de la thologie // Pour une philosophie chrtienne. P., 1983. P. 175.1

197

. . . . . . * * *

).(Discursive . . "" . . . .198

*

*

*

. . . "" "" "" . . " " . "" "" . . (.Milet J ) 1 . - . . )( . . - Milet J. L'existence de Dieu Un problme mal pos. Quelques rflexions methologiques // Dieu. P., 1985. P. 42 58.1

199

. . . . . . . . . ) (Dogmatic . " : " .1 . .- Summa theologiae. I, 2, ad 1// Doctoris anagelici divi Thomae Aquinatis opera omnia. Vol. 1. P., 1895. P. 16 17.1

200

. . - ) (.Albert H - " ".1 . . . . . . . ) .(intelligibility . . . 1

- Albert H. Traktat ber kritiche Vernunft. Tbingen, 1980. S. 119. 201

" . - - . ) (Radical agnosticism ".1 . (.Cahn S . . " " .2 . " " . . .

- Albert H. Die gemeinsame Problematik christlicher Theologie heute und der kumenishce Austausch // Handbuch der kumenik. Paderborn, 1987. S. 14. 2 - Cahn S. The Irrelevance to Religion of Philosophic Proofs for the Existence of God // Philosophy or Religion / Ed. By Steven M. Cahn. N. Y., 1970. P. 240.1

202

. " . - - ".1 . . " ". . . . * * *

. . . . . -1

- Ibid. P. 242. 203

- . " " . . " " . - . . " " . - . * . " " . . " " )(Tritheism . * - ) (Christology -. 204

. . ) 215 (219 . "" " " ) (vestigia trinitatis . . . "" . . . . . ) (Exegetical . . . 205

* . )( . . . . . . . "" . . . . . " " . "" . . * - . 206

. "" . " " "". . . ) (. * * *

. "" "" . . . .

207

. . . . : . : ) (Pantheism ) (Dualism . . . "" )(Theism " " ) (Pantheism" " ).(Panentheism . . . . " " . . . . 208

. .

. . . : .209

. " -" . . . . " " . . . . . 1 . . . (.Beck H )1 - Beck H. Natrliche Theologie: Grundri plilosophischen Gotteserkenntnis. Mnchen; Salzburg, 1986.1

210

. " " . . . . . . : " ".1 . . . . . . . " " . . . - " " " " " "" . - -1

- Ibid. S. 11. 211

. 1 " . . . . . " : ) ( ".2 . . " " . . " " .3 . ) (existential " ".- Ibid. S. 8. - Ibid. S. 16. 3 - Ibidem.1 2

212

. " ". . - . "" "" . 1 " " " . " " . . . . . " " .2 " . 3 " . . . " " .4 . . " ".- Ibid. S. 112. - Ibid. S. 102. 3 - Ibid. S. 113. 4 - Ibid. S. 107.1 2

213

" " . " " . . . . . . : . . " ": . " ) ( . " " ) ( . : "" ".1 )( . . " " " " . . 1

- Ibid. S. 116. 214

" " . " ". " " . . . " " " " . . " " . " " ) . " " ) ( . " " ) (. "" . " - (1 : " - . (2 (3 . . . . 215

. . . . . . . . " " . " : ) : ( ". . . " " . ) ( . . . - . . .* ." - - ".1

* - ) ( " " . ) (Personalism " " . 1989 472 313 -. 1 - Ibid. S. 131. 216

" " : (1 (2 . (3 . - "" . . )( . . . . - . . " : "" " (1 "" "" (2 . (3 . . . " " . . . . . . . 217

. . . . .