Who Needs an Islamic State BY ABDULWAHAB AL AFANDI لمن تقوم الدولة الإسلامية؟ عبد الوهاب الأفندي

7/30/2019 Who Needs an Islamic State BY ABDULWAHAB AL AFANDI

1/145


2/145

Page

1

) (

.

:!" # !

www.minbaralhurriyya.org

2009


3/145

Page

2

.

*+1991- / # 3#

452008!7 3 ; !?@ />/ = B?/ C D/

www.malasiathinktank.org

!>/ # = >@ E7> ! !


4/145

Page

3

H


5/145

Page

4

IJ 3

K7

*

#L#

#L#

NDQ:!" *+= ND:#SH T ?T

U ND#SH V U!" W

E/ ND = X #SH

-#Y NDZN> > #:3?T?

T ND]S^

"?#1! 7 L!:V - ?"?#2 B# :; " # ! * L> eVH

N


6/145

Page

5

# = 7 L! < # = Q"# > !

< = SH 7 L! f# LT# = >T>T!. =2006NV

.@D = /h #SH ^ #S ? =/ !L> = 3 3DJ ! = i )200(

!L = Z B>l -?W = i m 200o = i* "

=/.3! 3?T QD# = i ! 3 Si/#Sl

SH 3# Y[= > 3# L! W# # -?W# = i

= > < # =#SH "?.> 5# !)?!(2006= i

3t = ST? = T -?W.7 )1961981(= "#

SW)19821989(#?/)1990199.(

> I v! #


7/145

Page

6

N6C

> 3# 45 >B 3L"?# ! #L# ?.=D

=> ? > ! "?V - > B

=+ A O A5 !199*# !" IJ L = "? = #

= *V7 => m @ V SND#19915 3# *+ #

>@.

3! Q T Z>@! = 3 w>@ 5* ! *.

5 ? # C?7 L> = >@)?!(2006#=3! Q

*># L 3># ? w L/ = w Q"# V 3# we*> / YT

f 3#3 = =>/ .>@ =*/ CiLw? y/ T4 w# C*>=> W.V 7 45 = / @! L/ l 5# C l

NL.

o = #SH @ V tL C #.45 = C t

H 3# V # / NYB =>?V

3?T ? #S.3 T / 5/ # 3# C 5 C =

#SH ? =LL" .V =#SH " = l ? ZN! => D@ 3 T C ] #SH N l Q 3# */

^ ?T t.


8/145

Page

7

= => ?K 3# ! ? / > L!.y/ =t w # ->L!

= !" #SH " ? 7 L! 3Q ^ # W#3L! ZW! #SH ".=t !@>V = " ?> l #SH "

S^ l SH TD.

! 7 L!/ !t "/ !oL !" ? 3! 7 * @

N/ >? / ! =7 L! #SH.3?T ? / 3#J!

!T l ?D - = X L" ? . !o@" => L

# w =#SH =T X!" = 4.

5 o 3 # 3 X / #SH T !X/ 3>* ? ZW!

>@. *V! => @ / L !/ = ! @ 5 E

SH = > Z ? i ?T Q 3# * 3@> => D@ V.

D

A !3

32 = ? R &


9/145

Page

8

3C

@ C#SH ^ 5 U!" =#SH ! > ?L T

Z?# 3!> 3?T ] *SL> #SH Z? C # 3!B

Sh # -y 3@! 3t. >T 3# ?T Q

T >

N# = 3?T ^H >T / = #SH W ] SH =

* 5 L"> *7.N EL =BV I l Z?W! o U" 5 3@.=

I?^ =T E #SH ?T >WV o " =

QD. # ?L KT @ 3/ - N KT @x 3@! # V

@ 3# #SH .

@ 5 @B/ N>Y 5 = IB@>T!

#SH >/ >#=/ =T @D = w? 5 ? i ?T

T ?T yT# E# #> #SH ! > * V => D@ ! o;. SY L

* X ! !.E>W# 3@ T ?T 3 SL>T# w "/ 3! >!

w@! o@V X #@V "/ 3!E>WB l 3#C"


10/145

Page

9

! 5

DN Z" 5# ?K 45 ? /H 3# ?Q! ?T #

).( *V7 => / C@/ 3! / t D?Y

L @t ? Q.V 3# ! ; *+ => D?Y !X C

= !? C ? E# #> = ? C *@ !X.

3# ?T? 3!t D?Y / >D = = 5 N/ T! # >V

@ 4 !. JT# *L D?Y !X y/ L> ZTV V ? !

#SH # 3 @B/:D@ "N ! o S]H C => =*

E# #>.

o "/ SH = T ?T V ] ST ".

w / #y ZW! ? Z # # 3;" 3!@D ]

t @ ZW! i/ =! 3 *# @ 3.#SH N ZTV37 ? ]Y JB/ ^> ? N " .*@"! /

Q E>W# 3# @> * =* 3!># >. T>! :3/ @! I

=Q# " ? QD QD. #SH " wV 5 W

Q!] :] # ! "! 3!5 o* 5/ QD E>W o o*

L >! ZW! 3!5 o Q.l I > ?> I 5 L

U!" =#SH ! > = i!.

# @? ! = ! >l = !I?^ @>! #SH !!

] # =.E#W 3# !! D]/ SH>7 #

" = 3X" i ! = ! B >W L !J#

/ D?# Z? o ? * #SH>l .3Q !! 45 EQ

D] ? N"> L !B V < > 7#S t.5


11/145

Page

10

/ @? 3# SH o/ C@V => ] E " ZT

!l T ! ! T >T B.

?^ "# >@ 5 = B!.D]/ SH N! V

* o>! > V N! w>T LD! w VSN ?> W f#/ !!

/5# ? S^/ *T/ "i>I7.=> Y 3 Si

o@"> V>D# =T I# w @! 5 =B X 3 B !! ND

] ^ = . TJ# V < > !! SH "

ZT" =S^ =L 4 >"# 3# wD! l] S]H W! #! # l

L/ =#SH ! > @D.=Q B> #SH T! #= 5

L>T 3# !YT Q" L>V = e = o*>!.QD 5 3# wW #

@ # / # # C"] ?B/ D? lW# *D]/ T C] #

? LL" 3# D L>. ZT"/ =#SH =T @D !

= y#D7 eN QD 3# !t e.

> *+ # # 1991e />

=#SH =T @D V ! 3# #y> T */ CV7 => L Q

L 3# !.

3>> 7 !W 3#>@? Te >>l 3#. L!

= "# 3?T ?3# *i = TH h "# S L/ #J!

@ . ZT" >l 3 L " L! l ZW! !H 5 3@

*e *>5.!SH ! TH L 45 ? EL#

?e*.L# 4 # = Ii 37 # 3# @ / >l ? =! 5.

*!/ # =t =! l @? / :< / L! S#t S - SH

B EW = l Y! l !B B# E ?T ? "! o TH


12/145

Page

11

N.W! w "! 3?T ? ZW! l S^ X# V/ L! SH

TH B EW /.=T T# SH !*/:?/ 3@! S3 E 3 > =?Y> !7.K7Y 4 @ ! > ? Z?> E Z?>! .

=" o* y# 3# ?T >W L w@! V =t J!:w

7 L! .W # C?] ?T# W# ! 7 L!=#SH E>

N o =LL".?T >W t *@! => = L 7 L! 3 Si

SH !"/ *>] SH Z# E>W B# o> UV.3 w

V ] Q @/ 3?! 7 L! Z?# W LV .

LL +.>W w>" # i/ w/ ! # 5

w ? ! UV Sh B ! ZW>> #SH=#SS^ 3#

T e 5 #.T SH 3/ ND 3@! l.> / WSH S ! 3# X>

SH o > / i! L w@ T/.

3! Q

!! )= (2008


13/145

Page

12

# = m ? = e > ! =L; E!5# Z 3! Q

=>.>@ 3# !?W# w>?^ ] L JB SH 3 R? !3Qi100!/ = =t @D#wy/ 5 I]=! o?T

L >.3# I0@S@ w *Q 3# />S 47&

+)199(+ 47&: 7 ?'H 4?T)198(Wh w/>

!UV # 3 3A )1998( # w/> 5?! 2 X!? )2002.(

# w 3# W# >!U )7& ?T # 3 3A +:\ 4

! 3)200(!AC :


14/145

Page

13

. A( 378

)1(

# /> Z>@! Z! =t >@5Y>! # # >! >@ U?! # o;

w/ ]^ V.=L!N ! iD 3@ =/ = >@ 5 @ C L

E @D 45 !"> JT ">! w Q o!L. #

H ?T? S7 "i =? >^.> 3# Q# V N /> Iy =?

EW ># = ?/ N > 3Q ]# #S @D/ ?>!.T/ =x#

>^ = 3# >#lQ##SH W? .

C? => D >T# 3 o? E#.o =y/ >l/ =? ZW!

Q V W tL ; C => 3# o/ W ; >@ Z>.L

*+ w>? # y/ 3# C l C 3# @ *?D => ?W eL" /?!7 >D.=D# *+ i! = 3@! o)= ] (o?T=

># 7t = UV)3! 3! (B>l We 45 3# w?.1

C?/ 5 -"> L>l 3@! o = >@ 5 3# w/

ZV EQ# L>l 5 3# o/ = / ! .= L

/ 3# V => #SH = ^/ #SH L

! >? TW o*D L#SH . S^ L> L lJ / 3@

L7* V @ EWt C = +./ L lJ 3# @ I!X 3#

I?>Y# @B/ # ! 3Q IN L S^ ?e* >.@ "! 3@!

# B > S^.

1 ?T# CT l>#= !/ w"DN o9200(


15/145

Page

14

)2(

"? l L w N 3# 3@! o wy/ T# = L @!

-e @B/ 3?T L? w# > = ?T> ** eT #SH.? 3@

# S/ 3@ -@./ l L X = # w IJ! #)! 5

LVl C(C V => @ 3# ?#@ eD = 3# " ? E#

*V7.? / 3 3 C = l# S/ / @B/ L>l ? 7 o

XVS ? 7 !L 3!L *>B E/ ".C>; 3" 5#

*>V7 => @ 3# @ >.

; * ? T = ?T !V #S V ] C;

>l = C?B ?T> ? t# Ci^ * =LL" ZT LLV

*Q => eN *>! 7 L! W / >@ 5. @/ CV7 L

7 L! !"? NL ! #SH >W ? ?eL @D Q

@B/ S^ v] S^ 3# !" 3# ?Y>? T. N ; @V ZT/ ! y#V>D C T = #SH " LL)? !X *>?@B =

(^ " Z? 3# 7 L! @ ?.2V W 3@ o

; ^ E#W.w / ! 3@ o / * L>l 45 ! 5

!D@.

)(

UV =#SH o = 7 L! 3#SH ? IN 3# !

wN/ 35# T >S !"Q Z = o*. *! "i >V E#

@! 3@! => Te Q V = "i 45 C ]N^;y> *

T > ? o".= 3?T ^H tH/ Q 3@!

2 X! #:& ' ()& +.:- / 1991.


16/145

Page

15

5 L Z? o *@ ? 5 = Q V => N#

=7 L! "> " L> = T? w? *? .To * = -e ZX Q V# 7 L! * Q E#W# ZT = W. 5*/

o " X # DQ *>? 3?T ^H V *>LLV => /Y>l VW.

o * 7 L! # Le 5 " C"]S>l t> ? 3@

?T)C"W = ?"# Q D D BY C *(C -D =

! / @B C l Q Z? # I" / ? C

! W. " W ; 45 =w># L/ T> ! o " X? "

3#S/ =y> 7 L! y/ Se 7 L! B7 L!? 3e #?T .

3#SH S/ / !L @# = # V */B># I 5

3# @ f> => ??i7 L! B w/ ? WV >T# y/.3@

o*eS# 3 3#SH 3# E ND UV = o >l 3! >

2001Z7 Z L/ > 7 L! / > T.B = B 3# !! 7 L! W C>D> W. = iD = =@! l

3# o ? E/ > o >@ 5 / L =? ZW! w199w

C L?> 3# @ wV B L 3# @.

)(

o; 3#11>)?!.(=@ C =y/ L =@! l

!L C.B lL 3# =?W# = *198=D"] L# = 5

1998)Q w/ =D? i! 5(5 = V @ / B/ * C

" / # N = LB J/ SH Q# V >@.3 @D

Z?! SH = N> / *V? 4< # = X = Z!

3 X! > !* / LB L>T# SHB?W1)1999(.19120.


17/145

Page

16

5 N> l "# y/ !5">=#SH !*> l. S@ i## W = L o3LLV B t = X = 3?T ^ o>! o

45 V C>; o>! >V.

@ Z 3# w LL"/ =? # / E#

>@ 3# S*>l T ZW!

; "? T! # ! S/L# W>! 3# >V @B/ S*>.l/

SL> ! 3# N/ = Y o ? o > * L * / o*.

Th @! 3?T ? = # 3 3 C =

> L # ! # S^ V! w/ 5>"! ? @?T!/!/ ?>L! o*TD WD 3 ?T I>!.

>T ?@B o V 3?T ? W! S # LD l ? E#

= X E# ?T >W f# =. L! = !N D> 3V =D

= ClV 3# @ C l 3* = X? #* 4 5 o?X? -e

3" 5# o?+ lV C@ !y> o L? =#SH o ? ;J => o?X.

5 @! #y > 3# > = lS>^l 45 > L>

ix. = 3># ?;# #SX/ /L l ZW! #SX 45 y/ L 3@

TVH/ 3# /L y/ =L #.L !y>/ ZW! # 3# @

o?X W >L 3?T ? y/ L => ZW! / o*? E 5

o V S]/ #> !.L 3# 3?T = y/ y> ? E#

L? Q / ? =S^ X t W# - ? =S^.


18/145

Page

17

= 3*>T L >@ 5 = @ # o " 5@D ?T L. Z @ 5 ? V l / E#

y>/ >T! 3!^ .^ 3# ! " L# @! ZW! wL # @ 5

5 o* K# >W#. E# =#SH " L>E# 3?T V ; "

C -D = * # >V = Z @ 5 ? 3@T => ^ >W.o/

B# ?Y! # 5 .

L!

X>/ 3@*# ?T BLLV ; "# = B 3# . # 5

/ ! # ? NL#3>E# 3! D o*y/ ? ;H !! 3!5

? o* L# 3?T W *X T! 3!5 3# oX T B >! / !#l

=] Wt @!.S">T# # LL" " SW 3> * ?K = W>)189190(5#

3# )*V C =>!L i# (5 #! = EQ# C l

3" 5# @ 3# o/ L# / ]>.3?T 3!@D 3@

3D># 3B*# 3! # ! o = B! 3!5 K ]N^ ! 45 =

oi^ = / 3= ?# !i/ >>! o*# @ V e Te lWT

o*NNY lW# = "] o*# / ! W>.o*# B 5

*S#" 3# "N / ! " S] = *# T# o!L>/)3#

# ?#B>l V L = 3# @ w?.(?@B C l E#

#SH !iL V L/ 3?B K 3/ ! / #! ET> => * !>T

" ?N ?@B# E TH JB.


19/145

Page

18

3# D>l >@ 5 = V L3! > 3tL f# 3# 3@> o* "> 5

/ V #.@D# 5 !; V YB @ Q LNYB = J! =! l ?T#.=> D?Y ZW! -@ ?

TV w !Ii! ZW! 5 C = I = o L w

T B =#SH ! >? w* ! N/ # S J# w

.

!X iV = * 5 W = W / CLLV = /?

V *V7 =>^ = D = .# w =t ! l

#SD^3#J * N! l.ZW ? *W Z 3# /

^m.wy/ wDN 7/ ^ !7 3 =>l o? 3T"

U!" =>l o? 3# > ^ !7 3 =#SH W >T# E =#SH.

*> LT DT?D Q >l 3# L# ?^ = !" 7 L! !X

!; #m *@> XVS !.>l/ !X 45 E#

o@" X NY/ " ?K / ? @B/ i ?T !" W> E#

=TH @D C?t ?K = L>T >l X W)@D=#SH(

3T lm.C l L 5# L>T 7 L! LLV W @! l

o!L W ^ !X 3W N ?# e *L => B? L SY V.? V CT3 "/ L?V oi! =@


20/145

Page

19

#SH N 3# 7 L!? !>?# !B)H B/ *B>l !7 3

(3# ^ @t >l ? Q/ iD# =7 L! o@" =*! 3# w! => oL N W V YB o@VSH o E# # oWT *

=SL ?T .y! o

o N # ? #>" B / */ 3# => oL 3 D?>Y# w/ ] oL/ SH

oL 45* y# ! D! L!. 3# "T ?# SH L

? oL/ H = B .3!^m ? >! l YB ? 3@! o? 5

w? >! 3!5 K 3 DN! ZT".@# w7# 3 V? = Q #

t w>/ !*> ZT/ w#? V 3@! o NL S/ w! J y/ #

w?> ! 3!5 K w? Z # E.3#J ? ] 3@! o? E#

? S^ ?i 3# / !.

!B ! = L NL =L T ZT"/! wy/ / I]!

/ 3# ?Y> D 3 @ w! 3@ o w ZT" w>! ZT/ l "/.

" 5 ? NL T/ L >T! :! I w! = U"! / w? U! w^ 3# 3# ]y =^ y 5 # ?!

)!m e 1.(

=> !m 45* =S^ :? B# S^ 3# B o?!

J 3 "3!^m B N 3# w?> @ .@#/

=> B 3# @ "! =7 L! o@" X B /W S^ 3# Q/

TH >W/ CDN)#SH >W * /( D 3T lm

CT =C IB>@ t *? ^ N

*!/ W X 45t>/ E# N @ SH E#:W! 3 ?! !

" 7 L! D /


21/145

Page

20

)6(

V !" tL / @H #S3! D?^ ? C!

=Q oX# i^ *t 5 ! >l L" *+ 3T# 3/ >#

* x t# W> 5 = L S>Vl 3?T

# / 3! SH " SYwY! =.@/ 3# 3@! o

#] * # y ? U! C L o W# C SY

3?T?.Yt #S E#W# *X ! ! ?T D?Y >

3?3?L>T# => ! ?T 5Y*TD/ *TD CN.# 5 = -

EW? - "# T? C SH = T ?T UV y^.?

? ?T> ! iD *y " 45 Z? = 3@ ?@B V

*L> => ! =.

@* #SH *D w>* 5 #3?T? .

/w L> "? ?/ !V #S -y SY >l l " B X

l Q 4W/ i 3#:Te #S -y .

"> !l w? 5 ? */B# Z? = 45 D+ @>

#? eL @!.-y N 3@! l SY 3# @/ yt = 45

!* = "l 5 # L *@ =/ "l ? #SH ? ".

o = 37>T Ql -e ZT 45 B B

/ 3/ -> Ql *+ V UV ! 45 = =#SH

D > !7 = -> 5 *T! => e 5 Z? #SH .


22/145

Page

21

L > => # 5 Z? *TD L => 3# !! W? ?/ 7 L! ?> = 5 Z? /? S J#"/ i/ L; V w ? ># !.

)(

=Q ? w? T 3@! l ?> l y/ # y o/

w ! 3 U".3 3!>B>! v w 3# Z = E 5

YB W => @" # D+ = NL @t 3# @t IT?D> E

* l / S Z?> l =* 4+y/ *t ?.V 3 @" D# N

l # S^ 3!?L> ? L7 i V =/ > 3TV = T =#SH @D 3/

= T 3 L ? S] *>*# C => *ei 3Q 3# => W? V

3!B L .E!B> V > =/ > 7 ? ! ZT"/y# #

>L y/ S L! =/ > 3# Z?! YB 5 o?> YB 5

yT! I" 3! E# t>! :@D 45 > =i! =/ > > ] w>?K @ = YB > 3@ N B o!L>3# V =/

y Zi :* = # => Z>@ V = 5.4

"Q e D ! >T! l 3!5 K V 5 # NYt

V #SH Z>@ 3# @ o@ 7 L!?.> o >V wy/ =@

V ?Kx / ! 3 * ? * = L => Z>@ E

W 5 = LD/ @S@ #SH / .# l # y E#

3!^m E# 47B =y/ >l =? 5 E 5 = ^. ZT 5*L"?# CDQ L

yT# f! >@ 5*D?Y*/.L ! "? 5 "!TJ 45*

W )W 45*/ D w!B>(@S@ L

4/ V> # EeB 3# =128= T =!Y ? * = L Z>@ 3# 3!S V

/ L E 3# @ Q.


23/145

Page

22

eVH B Z?.= => 3!] 3B>T 3# ! ? 3/.

=>B# >B# 5 = w> 5 f* -D = "? =

N SY 7 ! > Z? "! * >@ N L "

*?#@/ N T"/ 5 y t X !7 3.lWT = U"! l f* 5

? ?@B 5 X! / ZT" !> E!B> eT# ! T S^

; " # N = C* =>. 5t SY 3/ > ? < ! l *

?T N>/ U" >! / ZT" 3!# 3#3

=Y! X# = N EQ # *? B# Ei ^ Y! E# 5 * L!

E.

SY L l ZW! W> 3@ W l w? t

D# L> 3# @! = X/ 3 S / @ #

3>/W> >? 3# .w? CL?7 # = L 37 # X ? ZW!B# / ! L / *X! o 5 Z w# # E =

! 7 #H E ?># E# ^/ ?V Q E# D@>#.

)8(

5 W = 5 Yt 3# W =># 3 >Y =

/ ># o*i/ = D>@ 5 B / 5

w;V >@? ]D ="# 5/.= T w 5 i @t 5

>@? w"L> @ 5 .

!! )= (2008


24/145

Page

23

H A( 37

D] 3/ TL ^ Sh T Z W V =" Y ?@B# C

* iL 45 ? N D7 @D>.T>! 3 N 3?T

3V = L# > w>?## ?! =#SH =T >? o*> # 5"/

i ] 3?T 3# ! 4l>! # > 5* * ?">

SH 3# L>l T => Sh. 4 / W*>l 5

w? y/ ; !V 3!5 3?T 3# Q 3T w# ULf*#

Q V i/ "!.

Ql 3# KT L?" 45* V Ei # i 3# ] L m #

D7 eN.; oL *# o*L ? 5 y! ! m 3?T ?

=?Y> @B/ =#SH= > 5 C?@t => ? / ? l 3

* ? 37 5 ?## > 5 = NL 37 o*TD ?W! l C

L#.

L / >D Q ># "# >@ 5.X ei 3/ EW "!

l => / C/ l 3/ SH =e # ? @V X"? 45 >V C

? #SH.EW? *D# ?y/ L ] 7 5 >@ T!

V ? 3?T 3?T? Q ?y/ > #SH X * >D! 5

.V>D# W>/ = 3?T 3?T? L# @ =@ N# 5 = tL

D o*.7 V ^m ] L/ #SH V L /! 5/ >@

!" .

w # = *# ? => L ?Y D.@D?^ 3/ o?T

" = E ? 3/ > ?@B# = U"/ S? B E/ L = 5

T C"] => = !7 3 yT ?> SV W! V #SH T


25/145

Page

24

U!" @D? T / EL. = # = w U" l ZW! w?/ @!

L = / Y L y/ ? T => >l "? !!" 3

# 3# ## C L.

?> 3# >h *S> L T> D o? ! > o?

L # *QD! => L */ T => =S^ #X.@ = 45 #SH X * =D => = U!" =T @D Z Z? =

? E i^ T.X * 7 "! @D 45 >@ 5 E>>!

L> =#SH =T @D > Y# Ei! * ?! #SH] lWT ?

= X SH V SH V.

B / o*TD */ ?T o@"! ZW! => L! V W > L

L ?T i T^ = V 7 V U!" W 7 "! o =QU!" = X SH 3/ >./N? # 3"

oL ;S tL? N > ?">T L o V * = #@

!iL V =NYt X# 7 5 V ^/ *>> 3#

.4 N 37 # 5 =?# Q# L!/ w >@ 5 L"! o

3!@D E ? eD/ w@> wWWV V 4 L> ? 3!^m U">

*? !B ? !*/ 3?T.

L 3?T eD >@ 5 Z> o.3" C V Ly/ ?T

TH 3# # "D> EiY L># @ / = E>W# =

.? # B! 3!5 3!^m / = Ei ? ZW! Z>@ @D #

oV ]N^ 3 =?Y> 3#3/ 5^y ? ZW!

Q X# 3# => " L? >B - >l.


26/145

Page

25

3 ? o>"! TH Q o*D]/ o*TD ?T wQ>D! 5

B E **D! ?/ Q/ L>#.B LT/ 5 =Q = 5 L> *> "#.o = V N 3?T ]

> WTH E!. "! =?^ D 3 oW 5 B L E#

3?T? *#.l =B >l @?! l 3?T E#o? = # ?>"! o*

TH # >V 7 L! !".

! 5 Z! S/ "Q = Th / SH / 3?T

B/ Y! TD L> 3?T 3".3# Z W 45* = L> = C NYt

EQ!W/ @D> ! =@ o*# 3!@? L] Z # =? 3?T.^ l

!D@ w / t V ; l 3# B^ =@ y^ ? = ^m C! 3#.


27/145

Page

26

H 49D

?T+:.3 3 gJ

*V => ?i 3# W> *>7 3# ? 3?T ? !"

=S^.> "?N >l ? L / = !"

>/; oL/ > l.Z> 3V 5 3!>T@! Y :

>? D+ /W> C3# C = S#@># 5 E>W? W 3#

>/ T @ 3 SiE>W? ">3#

...NDl 0?"> 4 5 / TVH -@!

L X LD/ t 3# : ZVN! # >l " ] 5

=.! >l 3# W> = 2 ; " o =D=

! Q *@ C ! Q 45 C 0@B> ?V# =

# V LDB? # .5

3!>T@! X = EQ 5 Z! 5:

> ] = > 0#@>/ TVH L.=T X =DH 5 ; "? /T L>l ! 7 #H 3! @ 3# =y! TV

B *# ? 3@! ?@ 45 0 =7 X/

=S^ E>W. Z*# =t ! o? m #.6

53!>T Vo? =!I!Y )199(.16.

6/T N.1.


28/145

Page

27

L>D! 5 =S^ D 5 ? !" C/ 5@* ?Y> CL? !

*/ ]Y S^ oL ? ? C"] > =.! =D 5 "?N o@V ?L! o*? ] o; ? - 5 D EW

T => !W TJ? W.o*TD W T 3# / ?T

! ?Y 45 #Y! /J# @V o*? o@V #L ! # 3L#

*L ?V t ] 3# !] y^ =7=>#

EW .>V ! ow? = W! "/ "T! ?.L>l ]

?>L! ?>L w? = L! 5 ^ =t 3# oX 37 y/.ZW S

i/ 3# T ZT 5 =?@# o

?L! E = o*y/ # *T/ t w w! KT

! # => #T 3# - ?T 3# o*i/.3@ w> w @B B! 4Wl 5 =)4 N/ 3" # = *ll * D# 45

V 3#(? 3/ o?T @D?) >808W106S#.(3/ L

w? D o* ] >l ? =! / BS ?^:BTh o?.

3# ! 3# / Th =S^ / ? 3/ L 3!5 ? DSD

w 3 IB@ 5 3# TH !W> ?^ 3/ *!/ KtLL"".

o?? e *>LLV 3 IB@? X # = U"? " 45 CL/

* C?/E 3 CDB oX >V TH * C => T

4!^. # W / ! w = 3@! TH o ZW! . T !W> 3# ! L S^


29/145

Page

28

5 "L @T# ] w? ?7 t 5 /

wTD 3 IB@! ! + 5 ?> W 5 3 "/ wDL B.

KT ?#? Q>! IB> L ^ 3# ?^ 3/ ! C

EQ 5 3#@ ZT 3 IB@? T o/.w>Q ?

4 ) >l;" ? ZTV(# =

=>l X/. ! B > ? L! 5 =TH E>W

N ? L > V B)=?L 3#i>( D"! 5 / =

T ?T >l V.7! Q / = T ?T

E>W = W# l>! ZW! JB X> h.I?>Y

T ?T):??^ 3/ ZTV( L 3

)e(E >T# ? * H ? >B * =.

= # LT W 5@W# = EW> ! UV TH S

E = wB @! N! ? E> ZT ? L? eL W o * ?T # o?>T! =iD! 4 / 5 @#

/ L ?].! o;^ i / E / =y. w !* =

yB # => !V /t ! *?"# " o; 3# 3 LT S"l

! / 5 W# ! ?.

T 5 = !; S^ 3! @!.3!SW! # *@! S^

T ?T N =e* e = N 45 * N.3/

X 3! = ! 5 ?T ? DSD w 5 ?L> *D ?^

! > B# =>l! > * l B Z? 3/

7= 4 @ ? 3/ 737 = U!" N = B => ! > V w188= V 3>?ND# 3>/

! >! *LLV -! / = ^ =! " N *LLV L. l/ ?/ />@# V 7 3# ^y)/:! / @D.(


30/145

Page

29

W =>l E 3# 7 yB yB

!< # ? w oL o >T =? >L ZT/ #? >!.

e / o@" >T# W / BV L ? oeL = ?

# "?N L"> =SL = ? oeL =SL =T ? 5 3# ?.

3T 4 / 5 oTL!:w>?T/ XD>"# L D@/ >*# w o " @!

"?N 3# ! / o " w o>*! = eD w L" C 7 #

] V @/.B ? L => ?T = SY * #@" 3# U IN #

^m " = ? T L" * =*H.9

w ?^ 3/ I# =! 3# = *@# ! E

V.N 3# W ?/ o*@! l >V w L! * 3# *. !

L 45* V N = N L * o # l W 3.K @

L>! 3!5 3"?N * 3#y> * V = o* S^ L

o?X # L N 3!5 3# @ EWD N 3# Q y^ ?=@ o 3#y 3# y>! / "l.10>! ^ * 3# ?^ 3/ W @

3! / o !L =.y>! l ? o@V L! ?

L!/ lJ i^ ZN 3# w 7 =! H/ l.? E#

! L/)-! =(WB W>/ T> D o*>7 3# IDY E

?T? Nl >B >.11

i ;y C" ! W> l *X l X -D ?

T *@?> => L w/ @ Z?>! 45* -y .

5 3! l y> l L 45 #V W L! ?L V!.W>

8/ N# ?^ 3/..

9"DN /T N101201.

10"DN /T N129.

11"DN /T N11920.


31/145

Page

30

N L?> 5.123/ @D = / =? " W >V 3@

?^.L o Y LL" ?T S@B l iL S^ L 3!N =>.

>!L 45 ?^ 3/ @ = = @tH i.>l 3# ? #

D>l TH >l S o@" # 3 3 U" i/

@D> B => S^ Q >l=?S^ >> N )/l

S^("Q.L/ 7T/ =*>! T ?T ] ?^ 3/ B!

V ? L: =>" BD *? >@# N " o/ L # L "# !

wT# 3 4 D/ X 45 #C T

5V =#SH o 3!5? =BD> o?X ?"> ?#B ?T ! = *# S#

L 45 =Y>/ # o L E# !T>/ L ? ] *.

^y># C >V = o ? 3/ @ E#S?" @ l

=?@# @ T# = / */B#)19612( ! i! 5?^ 3/ 4X # ?!7 >D =T.?T Z?7 # ? wD? # =?@#

?L> S^ ^ EL = w/ ]Y 4 yB V 3! !.13 3#

? ! V)( =T w! >"! # w 3! T?)w?D!(>V

w>*# = W L"!.w!]# C#] =?@# */ ] => eN @>@> E#

@# VS S^ l >/ ? >l 3# D! o =?

w!B Q> ] Y! >.@>@> ? o w w/ #

L 5Q#*# ! X/.D] S^ l 5*

S^ l 3# L y o =?@#] w 3# i! / wD] w 5 o

# l w/ !N> ? V W! o w? 5 o =T /

3; y/ L ?T ?T ].

12"DN /T N12.

13# X=?@#........


32/145

Page

31

S# w!]# w w = =?@# T# = # o 3#LL"/ 4o* L"> e y/ ?>! o*"N o* o* #.=! 5 3@

w)4/ >l ? w? ?^ 3/ #(E S^ l ? w# ! ]

w#X y E 5 ?T# Y> w W/ wD] 5.S"l Q L! L

w"eN C 5* W 3@! l =>/ !B >W?# l 7 wD] 5

L 4 7 = N> *# !>? T i ? N>L.

= 4! o i! @D " 5 /)188169(

5? N# w#> Ql * BD > = w = wD?

L>l L" D.*/ Y *L# * ?T y/ w>V 7 = ?^ 3/


33/145

Page

32

& < !) 4AD:

D 3# >V L? ?T !*/ ! B/ Z>@ i"/.16 * => ! -D = >V 3@

# T Z"T> l@t #@" 3# ^ l@t /W!w>!X C" 3./ 5*

4]# w7 # #)16210(3V /W> Ee 3# D>

w/> =


34/145

Page

33

>l ? e ?T 45 C.# SL #@" > 5 3

Q ? eL.

^ >! wTD = ?]y># # L #@" @ C

" NYB @? # lW / = ? ? ! Q / l

NYB ?e. D/i ! Q C L? ?T y/ wTD L ZW! ?T 45 y/ > QD

@>Vl >?D.l ? !* D ? * @B! l lW# C

= W" 3!^lW 45 = w? >T ?T

B EW> E>W ? J# L 45 = !X C

L w? 5 @B! 5 = L ? oeL.Y ?

-@ - E>W .#@" W @ V /N ?^ L

3# / S w? W? # "?N # 3# l/ ]Y *Q *"N# #^ *

?T oTL>/ l T ?T L)*W -D !5D> !B> >?T S(#@" W ?Y/ ;ZB # JT#.

B *Q ? 3 5@

# D?>Y# fe> *# ? "# L">.Q ? > *

# TD B V = ? # =@

wi 5 TD>/ L =./L/LV CT Q


35/145

Page

34

5 Z = / L.= >T #@" E>W # = D+ C

/ ! 3@! l E>W? Q TJ 45 L.

5

= l / ? eL o 3# V LV ? D"? L

o*"N# EL 3! L! 3# V o 3!5 37 !V.= " ZW! w?

37 # 0@ !" 3# 3@# V N >! / * # = L *W#.17

=> D 3# w X 5 ! T?D yB

/ =! =!)18182(# > 45?)180618.(

? D" Q ? L# >/ D !V LV ? 45 ! 5

3! m 3 i E# X ? D".oTL #@" ? !" 3# / l H EW> !V "N X> ! /Y>l ?T.L> ?

L"> =T # * ? "# / *? # =* => # "?N

Yt 3# T 3# L" *y/ 45.

]y># ? *?] = >B Z 45 W @. y

3! m 3 i E# L 4 ! Jt = ^> ? # >

H Jt = ^> =>T! 3# T 3# L" Z?#

3!^m 3 i E# o*!V ? W".C i> 45 /

T *+ = ! "#.

17.?!" V !< # X *? # =.1.


36/145

Page

35

j 4k :

3/ w^ 5 @D " ;*K/ ! >l o? # ?i# ?^.

3 4 >^ S^ L !X D] !X 3/ ] ^ EQ we

3Te 3?? " 5 3i !X.= L >l Z!T>/ C# * T?^ E ? *D]=D?Y 3#.E = *LL" 3@! l / y/ o@" W

Q *i C? 45 C L !X y.? o@V ?^ 3/ W 5@

L ? 4 y S^ 3# =S^ > 3# W> w = /J 3WT/ TH=

> w@" o = *V o B" !iL ?/ wi ?

L L.QD? w!L Q > ? 4 y S 3# T# =D f* 5 N * ! => V #

3# W# 4 >/ o X =S^ 3# W Z W V X>

oL 3# =S^.S^ S EWB! 5* !*T/ .=> KT T 5*

>/ C?@wDN! 5 o = V T = 45 # / 3@ o

? lJ.

! ! o?* @ = w =/ =T @D 3# ZW 5 v?/

)10181(> ?Y> 5 "! l => V 3# ! i fe

# = S^ ? ? TW> *TD = =S^H

@ N! > K*/ L ?W> W>: w V 5 3e@ *


37/145

Page

36

wTD. 5 C =S^ # = L?# # o "/ L ZW! = / ZT" V / ?>! o@" CT

= / ZT" ] = CT V.= ?W L /

" L? =?W> = @ ! > ! = / ! >.

wTD 3# E t ^ ! > Z # .* =SL #

=SL * E # =18.@#H/ 3@! o " = L /

# l # i.

- # * I?>^ => L i/ = 45)1818188( E#w?

w>!X W/ D>V 3V = =! ZL ? .3# 3>V 7y/ - #

V 7:Y wL# E ? = !i V @B! o =

TH H i>L# ZTV 4 3@! l 5.E# I?>^ w@#x wL = .

SL E # )lL#(!X 3# ^ - # o*?>e * 5 4!; = wiL "! E # y/ L! 5 >@!? w#*D# .

= =V yB weS = i! - # o3# o/ w#X !i V

S^ E/ EQ^ =V y/ - # ? !i V @D/ w+D>V

-@ - B? ! X > @D ?.

N>l oX>/ #@"# T >l TJ / ZT" @D -

E>W?.L7 E>W TL CT@ D 3# L .= >H X o@"! 5 N =

L "?N# i/ Y => [email protected] + = E>> *

* L !* = Y ZW! * E 3@ ? "# #*/. w?

! L N# TW / o # @ H TW l .

18- )L"#(DT?" = .196.10.


38/145

Page

37

w>L => > V wV EQ 5 5 E#] w?^ = "!wD.l * "?N# l => # " ?# L = ! > L7 ! = X

X ? L N => = X = D#. * ? 45 L>

?Y! - 3@ !* = X ? E>W X:=B E>W.

?^ 4 ? "! w@ L">/ ?D@ e = X

N. ?Y V @ 3 ! > o@V o" E# 3@

3# =Y E>W @=*>> " l @# L.5 S>l =*>.

# ! W w? C# 5 =Q L S^ - # @ C?# L

!* = *?B C>; >l * =.^] >V Q 3# ] 3@

5>/ K !V N* y/ L>T = C L > y/ o

L 3# ^ E>W# NV # i/ L! 3 >V # 3@! o .

> # N eL" / TD 3@! >V T !> ! l "# L

? = X/ = B 7 yB B? ?# L V B.B/ eY# *V7 => @! > E# E/ * ? 45 C?/.

>l 7 L! C?t => > = *TD CT@ ?!7 C ? 3@

B!W T /.

53+ & 3A:

T?D >l o @ = w B 45 = 4> 5 @D " v?/

! - # =)1861920(U"/ @#H L>! V 5=?

!" .=L I!> - # V 3# 3@

*y/ !" # >


39/145

Page

38

)=?] = # y>(19.lw?] = =L >" 3 # I!> 5 =>T!

Q w"! w l.

N/ Q/ 3 3# t ! # = B L 5

3 X. *>t E# !" ? 4 " =DY! l 5 E# ! 3@

/ LD LeD *>7 .y/ > ! ? - # L ! w

7 ! = @B/ ?T / #@".B B / /W C>;

?"> 5 "] B/ # * = ^ B.* = >V 3# o/

>T /Y o K*/ 7 # >V @! > )=/ = =(/T

*!" 3@! l ! > " L> Z?L! =@ B/ .

! @ C L! N# / / = 7 L! W>

= ? @D =T @D 3/ L> CT@ => !W ! > ! >?.>

3# @>! 5 E>W - U!" =/ E>W y/ - # ?# ! >] 3! T># L ? oTL# E>W# / =# @B/ ? !X w

^ !#.N/ !< # 3@ o L TL> ? y> = ! o* l

! #L TL> # ^ TL X >D - # =>

*+L TL> E7L *y /. 3# D?>Y E#W 3/ T ? o@" o>!

T> N 3/ " => .5 3 f>!@ o@V.

>l !X 3! > *> 3# o ?

5#oL E 3/ S W = S# 3@! o *VW l ?^ 3/.45 I] W

W 3/ L 3# #@"# *y/ !" / 7 L!?

@V ] oL> = ! V 4 3@! l ! T>."N# I] 5*/

# D# >V C " 45 y/ 3!5 3! > 3!X 3/ /. E#

19! - #* T


40/145

Page

39

3! > / C* 3!B L > ^ 5# ? 7 L! C* => B

7 L! ? y> ?! 3" 5# "]y S?= L BD o ? "/ Di E#W C?# * / T ? 37 ?##.>

N/ ? 7 L! V W 3T 3# W ! >

;y * => LL" = !L ^ ?T E! L Y ?.

)SA 3:

V # NY w ? *+ !" T !X L

!> S?"> 45 3/ /! 5 " >l W Th V> Y

*e D *>D+ :S# @! =@ V - TH.C/ L

" w/ ! 3e TH / eL = *D 5 ? ? 3/ 5# !X

?iD.7S 5# 3T DSD C? => X 45 TL/ ?^ 3/ W 3 "!7 # @ Z # v?/ ?Q N w@" 5 =

?T? #T> # = " *"N/ >* W V wQ >. L N! E>W Jt H #7 ? ZW! l

=*H =V N# >! l 5 L E 4 L! ZW! / B @V

? "# B# l 3"?N 3# ?iD.L # w/ T! # l = # ?iD.

=?@# 3V =

o>* TH #?>! 5 w>"?N/=> ?T ? ?T S>#l L?L !/

E# l =*> l20w#X y.? w? D S/ T! D 5 #

? i/ L S W! # w t i^ 3!^m

N.45 C?#e>H ! D21! ? !X w? C# 5

V l 5 E# ! T # 3# T !X o #

20

@ 3# y# > 5e> ! D? T !X.


41/145

Page

40

D .D C !X 45 V D 3@)?^ 3/ 4 (i=

. W " !X 45 =) "?N L(D "#? = -e ZS *D]/.

V T 4W B E>W? W JT @ ! l 5

i! ! o*> ! w / ZT" 4 .*/ / 5 # "!

"# *D/ =el. *? *T 3# B ! 5

W! l N CL?7 VB = >V 5 ;.L

B # N 3Di>T? C# t C. C = >V

W J/ ! JT# !" o V w>/ ! *L

)*W( S^ 3# X ! =>W# e .W - !/ L! 5

!" @t.

LLV ?i# = 3?T Ei! 5* / L.SH = # *D# EW V ! / >B > l ? .# V=

> N eS V l >B# N# V.3?T = ^ iL 3@

^ 5 = E#.!" w>LLV 5 W! S

oL? =! S w 3# V E e> S^.= "

@B/ o @" Q 3# ?>! l / TH > ? TJ

wDQ 37 # 3# E>W V @ >l ? # .3@! o

J! X W Q = @" ei 5 #i @B/ w>D+.

3? / T X w? C# 5 =S^ = ! *# 3@

* / =#SH o = eL X Z? ? D> * = W E>T

! > * => T oX ? D t SY >/ =#SH

LVl *>V> => /.= 3#SH 3"?N 3# B> l 5 ]


42/145

Page

41

@D H # 4 "# = 3! T # 3# U!" N E?#

3?T 3/ J#.H 5 # 3/ L 3?T/ E oJ=> / Xx Q 3/ ; " N = 7 > 3# w>" V !

T 3# ! CV.W Q# ? ; 3@ 3# 3@! o

L! w* LLV =DY! DY l => */ > / 7

X o?+ 3# D! 3!5 3?T 3# 3!*i? #SH@ # =

/ / ].

LL" 45 * ! 3?T? L.=> m ; ">:

l *@ E V K7 Q > ? C/ * @B# S^ - ? C# /

V # W E# C.-y ? / =#SH 3! ^ * 3#

D 4? 3# !

3>/W> 3/ @.3# >T# L l 3


43/145

Page

42

. 49D

!:+ n ' & ()&

/ l t# N/ i ?T w ! o=.=T X

! => !?L> 3 I?>Y! * ! > = w 3# ! = w# 5

7 W w@ *# *# l *>? y/.7 W = !i 3@ o

? NYt 7Y# ? C * / ZT"i.= T C

# #) L">T E !@T S"? il #(3@ o i! 7= @B Q L e V C / L/ T 45 D ! ?

B 45 3# o*#V = o*el. L # L/ 3# #l/

D *#Y>T => !?L> / S!TL *>?.

TL 3# l/ =S^ ? i! ! ? eiL D+ > .

Wt 3# w ^! L?# @V =/ l LV #J# @! l YB L =

3!^m 3#J E# S^.23 5 3# o/o/ L; =

! D"]24?T Ie+ @>Vl o*@! 3?T Q! L W

t L ! eiL.o@"! ! = > ? >V

o*/.25

/ ! 5 N/ I? > EQ 5 3@L! Yt ! o UV =l Q TL ? > ? # # D ? 3# w / E>>! w#L#

*# D#.? W = ?T w J 3# ? S L = @

.^ S^ ; >V yT 45 oTV o #!W o " ? V. /

22!m /> L X8.

23 L!m e6.

24B 3/ > = X! T./:"DN = ?W ! / >10.

25!m e L2.


44/145

Page

43

V ^ SY L# / ! T #


45/145

Page

44

@/ / 3@ V o*>?L.26* I 5 >D#

= lL# @! 3@! #.? wTD ! @/ / 3@! o =

w/ ZS y/ L? > ?.

=/ = 3!5 3?T 3# 3# V X 45 CL

= * ! >/ y @/. l 3# => E

? SH / E T ? = N 45 . o

= 3@! o @/ / y/ EW ! 5# .w ^ 3# @/ /

w/Y> / w ^ = 3V 5*/ 3?T :o Y/ CT o@? C..E>#

>/ CT..=#L y^ =y C] .27

5 EQ "Q t !W > 3# ?T w*. we^ # eL w> W# 3@! o * =D3@! o >! *""NL t H 3?T ?.EQ 3@

T 3# y> o*TD B 3# S Z 3# ] UV I?>^ !W

=V */ => oL *H ! * E# oWT.>D 3# 3!B S lJ o 3#

@ 3@! l *W 45o!L> Z?7 5 w wTD D?Y.@/ / 3@

= >l/ 4"N 3!5 # "N L! o w L! o

o*# #>.w ? t 4! 4Q o@"! D?Y !.Z?! D?Y

"N# Z? V =? # 3# o*/ ; 3/L w! B>T#.= EW>

l !W T/ 4 o>! = / 3 ! = WT

*B! t 3 "! y/.W T #X C@V => !< @D 3@= !

26

=7T 3! S XD?Y ! ./:L1988"DN8 / #.27

/T N.2.


46/145

Page

45

w#L# L! 5 = // S D?^ L> TD V ?>! 5 TD D?Y

* # ! >! # JB =.

= D?Y 3# # **t => # N # " L ! 45 3# E# w# wTD E# B w w = W

T ? ]Y # w Jt = SH o w # ?y/ / wTD


47/145

Page

46

C* *? y/ # L ! y > 45. 5 SY X

I@> ? 3@! o = L# L! # = ? =T ZN t ?V " C/] i# ZN t w ! l EQ E#

L!7w# #>.>S ZN 5 t L! >T# 3@! o E>W [email protected]

45.* C> " ? e *TD => # ^ V 3#

B.

? / T> 3 E > 3# !D 45 ZL 5 N

B> y 3# ! 3# ! =? L/

l/ @T 5 ? L 5/ * o/ QD?Y? y >.#

^ @T 5 3@ S> ! LL" 45 > L ! # 4 5 - @T

w l SH # 3 @! # / 3?T 3# L / w >/

@T# / w = "Q @>#3# =! wTD ? #

E ?> i^ w# 3 E ! # T Q ? WD.

D 3#3# ! 3# o ? 4@T# =


48/145

Page

47

7

=#SH E>W " = B * = > 45* >" W> C

?^ 3/ ! 5 ? =?@ N> / B> y ! =

4!> / T!.3@! *l 3?T @D Y! o 5 i> =

! > 3 ? ?/ CL

*#.

L 3# Q UV B> 5 =T o* 3?T V

l w>!* v?! o 5 >l o; B> ? " ?+ t SY *>?/ =>

! 7 #H */! * o; 3# " L =

=/ >l ?"/.

@ # E 3/ * T C => >D t SY *t L/ wV wN = L "> N/ *>W! @" ?V ? =DC

L TD * / # ? = #.= *TD/ *>L; # C

T >l " = o*V EB! o*Q! # W! EW / !.E#

* o@" T D LB 5/ -D E# ST 5

.

= >L# CL => 3>D " 3 EBL V6)66(

! >l ! # ?T 3Q^ o*TD ?T )160661680.(>! o

?" o*@ !# B/ 3?T oX#.; QD> 45 *t

N>/ */ C*> !12)0.(Kt LL"! o 3 3@


49/145

Page

48

t SY / = S# 3!# ? 3!5 3 3#.w?

B 3# > L " = Y .

! = L / > / */ 3# o/ >D l

oN> / D?Y o*/ 3!5 L 3# 3BV 3!@T ) =>22

82.(@# ? L lJ NV = > >L# / 2860.

?N. C?^ >V EQ 5 >

/@ 3?T ! X * 3# Kt y B T L 3# / .

C / =T# 3V W# = 5 N SY ? T"> 3@! o

w>? => >l QD > 3 N UV 3# t SY * v?# ?! o ] # ND?Y*! # o y/ i! D ? l =#SH L #

? > = *>W! = # 3!N D?^ L */ >! C

B? DY# o*# *X l >V i! *W 5! o*! >V E>WL.

T JB = D # = # >/ 3# #.

+ 3 (C

?T 7 V D?>Y @ #y W! SH = T

@ T .? @/ / *Q => C)(Q

!L 35!)( o " 7 L V ? o "?.

L! E>W y/ L>l 3i>! 5 # = # E>! D?Y


50/145

Page

49

E>W / C e* ?T =!.! wy/ 5 3#J! ! @/ /

= ?./ C E>W? !X ?T 3# o/ e* ?T # 5 3iV Yt.! 3# V 3!e 3/ ?T oL = N >L @/ =/ 5

N 3# ^m !.

ZW> >V wD?Y! 5 YB =T! Z 3# @/ / Vl C =

= ZL 5 Ql #.LVl = w .! ?@B# *+ 3@

3V"! l ># SY y/ W>"# ZN 3 =?Y> w@ E>W L; L

w > l =?Y>. / * ? LVl W l L 45 C"]

.

/ T 45 ? C/ L LVS >D = ?> SY !X 5^ #

@.Z SY -y ? y> !X 45 ) tH/

t# y U!" L = tH t# W(5

V Yt 4l>! ZW! ZN)3! ># L l L @# S.(@! ZW!ZT = t w QH/ D o S^ o*TV 3?T i D?Y.

!B ?! w? =! D # L " o o " 3! 5

@ >V W! l 4# Nl w?^ "Q DY# Z.

@D# t SY * ZV] 5 C N ! W> C L

I / o*e? 3?T.*i/ ]Y> @T w w 5 C =D

N LL" 3 V E wy/ =! *# V >T# S

ST ? N"? *# ? # T?.##/ L! = E! l w 3?! ! # W

=? 3/ 3T" w/ / o@">/ i! ? W ?> ^ 5 o? =?

! # o@" B * # ! # E# D L/# B/ )/ 3T" wD?Y! ?

w.(# I V #? / l * ]> o>! o !T> 45 3@

T N oTV 3# I? W? 3# 5"! 3!@D # #.]


51/145

Page

50

B L " 7 tl B 45*/ ?! 5 o " ? o@"

L/ w>Q # W.l wy B 45 ?/ 3 =>.

=# D " = *+.W *+

! # =? 3/ " ; = Y *? ?7 => N >.lJ )

^("> w / =? ?3D] # L = o@)68( ]> o =>

3L!D 3/ N? oTV. !B 3 =?Y> =! o@"> y/ lJ f>V

3 ?Y o*y/ o*Q # * LVl o* >V *TV # oTV ?

SH.lJ # o X * I^ 3# / "/ 3# !T !.

o o* o* ?^ >V / ^ ] N> Y # ; #

*Q 3# ?L! => *H # >"# ? LD>!.> X 45 3@

] B ? # @B/! *V E#W 45 oN .

! # yB 3!5 > # 3 *yB = C => =? t

# => I ? 3@ wNYB l ! # Q =? Z*?. 3# > 5 3@

= > 5 N"./ l

@" - H 5 ?=? N UV ! # ! ? =; o

=; Q !X .w/ w!L ? W>Vl ? > 5 Q Zi

C w@V C* => ? -e ZT = *# Z] o*> # =/ 3#

?T =?/. =? >! o w 3# o ? wD?Y w/ =T! w

3?T 3# V @B/ w/Y> ?) .3# 3 B/ y/ 5 ?

w# / wV = *# Z]# = w/ .(


52/145

Page

51

DY# l B ##H Q# oT"! o =; > 3@o*.L

B # ? -> ? D?>Y# ;S; *+.3# 3T B !B 3# ! L/ -e > 3 CLB De7 = ! o 3# B = B W W 3 >/

L Ze i TL ? > C => ! # *T => L

] = TD.w? y/ =#SH o W* E/ L = # > =

> o *V yB => 3# ! 3@ =B o@" C" !L 3 * # = W 3# SH # 3 w # = / *i/ / * T T

L/T * "/ C.

.")A"?? !1 '

/ #SH !X Ci ZeN 45 3# o ?" E# !T !

5 * W# E>T o * 3# o ? .3/ * >V ?T @D + L

X! / D?Y */ ?">! ZW! => Z !">/ D>@! ?^DY# 4 >/ 5 ?/ 3 E = NLC" l *# !> 3T"! l B?

L X.! ; + !?L> #SH T !X !X 3#

" / L E E# !> *+.?T ZN> => >l Xy

@ * =! # L i t / @ l *@ ?>"#.wQD! *>V

l - *> 3 #SH T !X 5> @/ 3#

De7 *" # ?V# = B " I.Si 3#

TE# o*D7 DY! o / " *+ =? 4 5 = @T E# D 3?

=?." 3!5 3! > T/ Te #SH @D > ! # N> /

#SH o/ >T T ?T.


53/145

Page

52

>B > C UV 3# oeL X " >Tei! X 5 L C* / T.=D" Z 5 -J# DV / W S#)=>

106(3!!/ w#*l 3# *QS

S> wi= X 3Q ZN#.- 3/ # /) =19

9(H/ 5^ * ?7/ C D?Y? o*>/ y/ 3! > y/ o* w i .

=B -! 3/ "# #)=20819(w H o@V 5D 3# /Wy/ W L

l = ?i/ w#*.V 3/ V # L# CT) >218(

3@ V 3/l 3# @/ w CT wQ #y L 7 Y! 3#

4X * N> !* = .

=#SH E>W? /W> 3@3# =B/ L o* 3# 3!X/ C

. L V 3?T >@ 3/ ! / 5 3 f> .W! o*

Y N! l w? SH # -@ o ! # * 5# X ?.@! l

3# l # X 45*/ L? " QD ZW Q ?#. ! @ *> 7D# # / #@" 45 V H L!7.5 E#

=> S" D 3 3! 3! ># Y I i >! I

>l CL Y */ L>D! ^ > > S/ L.

# ?T 3V =D =#SH E>W = TD #ND EQ 5 ?^

? V 3# L !X V 3# ?.I? Z W Vy

V V> =#SH3?T " ^ Z W E# D> ! .o

E>W? V " !B ; * / ZT" E>W TD! !B? o?T>T

*D! .wl 3!@T w 5 "# = C

weD?^3!t= # ? ?#y * X!.t E# V ?

JB = ^ / E>W L LVS * = V

3?T Jt ? S^ ?T .] ?T o* / ?T o? 5@


54/145

Page

53

* o *V ?T! o o*@ >.L# 3 I?>Y o => "N ?

T :NL # N .J o # o " ! y/ 3?T ? N L 5N# w>7.> >! o U"/ wD! Q N I! 3@?T N

=] o;H e 3# =#SH E>W # = B N>.45 3@ o

= ?

3)7 !12 F?T

*>?V# = B 3# @ i! CL?^ #SH T !X C* ^y>.5 C*?> Lt SY *> => oL !X 4

L l I?>Y# E E# #>? i# *TD *@. *X # 3V/ E 5.L X! ? !X ]

^ w/ L! i>L# TD V SY C W

*W ? V 3"N 3?T Z 3# # ] S.

B? >V L/ ?T ? ZN># > ?T L 5

? " => # N YD w@V w># L# = 5" =^ ZW! w D+ 45* w>B?. Y 5 3 f> 3 o " " w/ L X #

t w> D?@ /L# "l 5 !.l ! + o@"

SH o !B/"Q DY# Z@ >V w>7 ZW w@V > ZW

!B?.L# *>D?@ C l */ N! l w> CX wDY# *#.

y/ >l w?# 5 >" 3/ ?Y !X C 5@

t SY # # 3# " ? 5 = " 3/ B? L

* ?T " @! # .w> 3# @ * V !X 45 @

o V * ?T N! 3# !X =#SH o@" V t H

=t.o@" UV = # ? X = ? 5 *+

w>B/ >l 3# / l / L w?" ZW! l >T.>T o " B/ > o ?


55/145

Page

54

#SH #x V >l "? =L *l.45* 5@!X

L>/ ?> V w? y/ =#SH t ? = > S # W>*# 3# w> /] ? o@" E# !B 3 4 >/ o " "l.

5^y! o 3!X = ^ Z 3# !?L> !X C D?Y

/ 3LVS >@ / ZT" T L 3!t

! # * ? 3 3!# D?Y. ? y/ 45 o*>L# lJ /

Q> 3!5 = /"] *LD ? 3# D iV = C ?

t 3@ o.28

5 3!t D?Y ! 5# "Q @! ZW! @ E#

= >T# -D/ 3@ o o D?^ 3!5.W! l = w>Q 5 /

yB => X 3 l*.S" f>>T 3@! S

# C = 4 = W t L Q [email protected] / l /

5 # * > => S^ !> Q " 3#.3!t D?Y XJT C> !.>> 5 w

L# .

# B 3# w ? w>SY @/ =/ t>/ *B>T! W S#

w>D?^ o " 3!.o @/ =/ t t LLV 3 # X N! IJ 3@

w 3# E3!5D> 3?T w 3# / ZT" Yt 45Y .5 D

BV L/ D?Y w/l ! # @/ =/ 3 3/ @ D.L 45

!X = IQ.

T ?T V W C/t => ^ B 3# @ ^/

* T eT 5 ! # "?N/ m 3 > ? ]H

28"DN X1.


56/145

Page

55

! tL ?/.] yT# = @ Z@! 5 YB @# C L

yT# = C #SH !@D 3/ SY.45 Y E 4!# 3 o* Y/ SH >/ o*Q 3# * iL.3# o*e 3@

o; w 3# o/ SH 3 Y! l o;H Z@!.SL 5Y )/ 3!5

/(@ Z@# L 3>KD 3/ D## Q V E>W 3# w>?eT# 3@! I+# W# - =?.

t @! o " ? ZW! YB 5 # UV DD ?># W

=t @! 5/ Z# o V .C D ]> 45 l

3/ W L = *Q => ! 3 I !> Y>T

E . 3# Sl 3# l/ #@"? ? Ie+ ? < !X

o " 3# Z?>! ! > ]> T! 3# / E = w l =#

*/ l.eL >>l 3# L>l *T 3# wL 3@! l # !" W# l@ y/ *i/ E# T> @ v? l => V y/ L ">T# .

Q" EQ = @ # S W>= 3@# EQ i .

> = t# T# C !X 45 ?Y>T 5 / />T# -?

V ] 5 #.4Wl 3 # !" ? 4D] 5 *?@B/ !X

S!/ L ? e # L Ci 3V S]h. 5

3 >! 3!5 # 3# ^ l w ZW>T! o ? w? 5 I 3# !5">

ZT# *W ! i .3!5 K i/ o 3"N ^ 3@

? "N 3>"# @! o S] SH o #?!. 3# L ?

V 3# V y/ ! eN/ */y! l .3V # 3/ ? 5

o@" w#S> / @# = w ^ Z^ := L! S E l ) (C/Q l

wLE# > "N !! l o* # Q 3# ?T @"


57/145

Page

56

#. E# #>? "Q ^ D# 45 L o ^ V 3#

"! @! o 3!5 #? ?T w>"! # i/ 5 o*]# 3# o*>* >V 3@! => " V / 3. ] !?L> !X 5

C -D = ! Q.

\

T X y/ E/ ? ZW!wy/ w? o@" 3@! ?L> =#SH =

l l T N/ ].X # V => ? w? T/ ] L / N >D > = wQ 5 =T.=T X X 3@

! w ^ ! 3# =#SHw] => @t ? D>. L# @

= W o@" L/ ?/ S>Vl NL >D S^ !N => =

/ 5 =? "# o@V * = N# ?/ wL!Q 5 * = N#

?/.3 3!5 3@ #SH o@" X 3# !.

o?X * BD ?X# N ?T >! => >D ?> X >V

W# = ^/ +"?# *t N * B CN>

=TJ.E# #> ? @" * < N C ?>L ? " E

!B IQ.? *?V # ? !B> W>! >D ? = L 5*

3T!L - 3! B 3 L i! oe


58/145

Page

57

3/ =B #H ! ! 3@! o w L -D/L" = 3!X

=T29

we # Q =#SH wLD ! e =B L.3# =B LH *D# 3# l/ =#SH E!B> = */ ; ! T @ ? ]

? D ^ o? 3# I?>Y! 5 DiDDN 45 T

"N ?T ?! ?# B >D QDiD.*Dt > L @

5 wL; w>/> # I!">? / L = S>^l >

# / ;y> /l D?>Y #SH >W # *? CT.

5D! o L @B Ix 7 *T o SY? !X -y> o 5 *W 3@

i .B = y^ CQ> W = 7 = !X 45 CQ 3V >"

L @)3T!L ? 3 B / o 3!5 @" = ]^( -@! 5

DT?D S^ 5 *Ty 5# !X 45 = ; 5 =B @D/ !X 45 ;y

B NY E# W.#H ? B ] L)eL(ZW! = Ze 5

= # #N# L @!.? L T 53?T @! ZW! o "

L )o " @! l ? !! 3?T i.(i/ = Q >l 45 3@

?@B.> # 5 DN S J l !" ZN 3# ?iD L

Q#.w> T# V 3# # "! D?Y i ? ]H ^ * 3#

= # # ?Y 5 i iD Z"! I@ w>"#

L> L L 3/ wNYt = EW! 5 YB X>5 E! / l

Y = o!*> L ?T E// @ # ">T? X>l.

# C * = * !?L> SY !X 3 L NY? 3@!

C -D = S 3# eB># S 3#.? >V * 3UV ; i#

E W> * E?> 3?T CV o "? # ] # 7 t C7>t.3#

29

= #SH T !X ]# o*/ o* B! 3!5 >@ Z?) =0W1111S#() 0W108S#( 3/)W1S#.(


59/145

Page

58

3# wLL"> =T W! # / L">! 3 5 y/ L>l !X ^ *

U.?#t # 3# / l L 45 W o>! =@!" * 3# !X 45* * 3# ? y/ #SH ! =#SH ! > = ?

*/ l ? ]H.S^ S ? V L>D # Z# !" .

H oL wQD Q !" 3# / l w? / T>! l U"/ =T W = #S

5 3 I?Y> = 5 .


60/145

Page

59

^. 49D

+ 3 0 3 3B

!< ; = @ l / SH V ] W WD

" = ."# S>Vl ! l

= SY V C V @B w f>1919.iL WD *TD =

ZT/?T =5 w X EL ! w>?T/ >T# *> = D?Y

+l = @ wT.3! > IN SH t 3# > ?T N> L

SH o/ o*>?L# D /.>l *t 3# !YT/ @ #SH

C = ?>V 3!5 3! ! = LL" = o ".

=# T 3@ ? # C?* wN# 3# L #V tL / @ 7 W C]

? ?> l ].^ L/ DN# 4 !>* V ?!7

=#SH ! > = wD o W!.31 @# *?B C>; SY TJ# y/

4 D/ E>T! l ! SQ *# .5 wTD w Se Q

3 w V D?^ 3! o 5! B> T?W#Z ?"> Yt > 3#.

5# SY C => L DN# i#9224 # o?T m Z - 5 = > ZB 3@ > = 5^ #

K / wTD/3!D3! 53!5o*V/ 4*+ ?L;.

ZB? LL" ?T.CL/ ZB ? ZW/ L * 3@! w SY/ ?>!

30

X2)1922("DN0 / #.31

= DN# Y / > B2"DN2 / #."DN -! /2 / #.


61/145

Page

60

37ST? LL" ?T Z ?T = L. LL" =

* @> !W SY*D ? IL *> *? y/ > .N>3?T @ ? # = *+ ?;# fW"/ i ! o fW" 45192o/

w @ 7 W# ? SY./ >@ 5 / 4 # 3/

l SY LL" SY/."/ D?Y E>W * >Y => =* LL" SY #

B @V #?# D@/ >># LL" ?T ZV] E>W @! w

= l # SY 3# .L! >@ QN = LLV S^ #

o ! 3# @! D?Y = D B o V l @# ! o 5

w/ @# !.l ! #@V # o* B? 3DY# @! l 3?T w?

D?Y ? "> ZT/ D?^ * !5 !=>TB.

# DV # = ! ? = * = ! CT SY.m #

L T #@V # / L ?> =* SY V !?L>.5 w/ E?i! 3@! TJ# w/ E?i 3@! Ze.? ? W E =

?T >! 3!^ 3D+# ZW/ = D?^ "N/ ? 3V !7 3# 5# 5*/

LL".

+ 4AD

=#SH o 3# Q # / @ */ 5 => fW" 45 o.=>l = D C #TJ# VH > *5Y => K!W Y/ B

>T @D =#SH @D ] > SY.S @ 7 W CL?

V ? *K* 3#t SY32.i> 3@? LL" / # 3@

yB/=#SH o = V SY ? *#


62/145

Page

61

/ D 3@ L CD @ *? => o*V 7.ZV] Q t ] ] 45 /

2@ E/>! + 5/ !t L Z?L U # w>?W# = 5V !y>/.

3V = SH ! wy/ ?T i # / = ] Q

w>#@V] ?>V 3!5 / C ? ST #

l C? => * C. ^ V 3# @ /

4y/ =#SH o I7 ST L/ 4# L! ZB? 3@# o?T.35

> ] / * >V ! 3@lH ()l l'L

L7 ! TJ# 3@ o SY y/ w => D.

?D SY l SY/ I] # 3/ @ = 5 I!> i! Q

L DN> 45 # ! o 5 =#SH @D ? S^ 5 >/

N>l ? oeL =B o@" =B o@" 3/.W >V3?T *

=> / w# # > L


63/145

Page

62

*Q. t SY / o@V X / eL Q w?

!> 45 S> t 3# ! =#SH o@" 3 =?Y>.oe W W !> ! 5Y> 3@! l 4 ^ =Q.

t ! 45 = ! 3# D?^ W! @# / 3@ Q V

>l/ 3!!W 3"t 3# !. => 3@ L# B/ i! Q

! ? SY)#@V W#(? ^ = X y/ * > @# =! #

! ? ? N".#SH !B > y/ i! L 3@# 5*/ ? ?

W! # LV !B / V ;=#SH o " L/ w ET l > = C =.

CW * =DSY Ve L = !X * T/ i! C SY >l

= lL# ?T?T B => SY V S@ / /> #l2 3# >/

1922.ZV] o ll2/ > @t ? LVl C7 lL 3# ?T?T/ 5

1A + 'L)192.(

o*/ ]^ !@ V -y SY Q # o* wTD C =.3# 3# / ! # ? 3!N ? V W @ 7 W > B^ = > B

192/ll? ll- ll+ = L# ] SY? w =D!

#SH. =? B IJ 5)1881966(f!^ !t =Q

> = wV 7 C :

36 /T N2.698 / #.


64/145

Page

63

l:B! o = l V w>? C .;:lL# w ! o@V X >Y! 3?T? 3@! o@"? 3# X "! o SH.

;:# S@t C =! ] ? o> o / yB => o@" X

o S7/ 4 W# 4SYw? ! t DQ NL/ w?.

/: >l !> Y> w =#SH o = B N# X 5

3?T ? "l.

=? !W #SH = L 3# D] >@ 5 ;

o 3# .3! > !?L> #SH L 3 Y/ =?

* 3# L E :

l:! CT 3# w/ V ^ y/ 4 .

;:SY V 3?T 3/ H 4 @.

;:o ? >" #SH !B y/ 4 3 ? >" l i"# V

Q./:? ! C weD?^ @/ / *T => SY y/ 4 .

i/ ! *i/ w/> = / f>V wTD 3 w =.4W S#

= ? L w!L># X CD?!T ?T C. V Vl C =

? 3?T wy/ 3V wDY# E# V N!

t X 5 @ o@"? Z SY X.t SY y/ >

? C# * !" t C3?T .o I 45 = 3@

t = !B # l 3?T y/ eL =?] wD# 3


65/145

Page

64

4 @ */ => tB N ZT/ C ; => Wi 3# ! "# >L C L>@:w/ 3@! o ?L> SY X t V 3?T w? ] @B/ !B ? >T! o w Q

?] w ! w ^ !/ >^.? >" o #SH !B =* L #

* !#! o* Jt = L# L!7 !y/ N> V 3?T C .

L C 3>L 3 3?T 3"?N 3# @ w 5 C =

/ D 3# w#N^ 3@ fWV IQ .yt 3#

B 5 = /W!l T L" 3# 4 @ * "!

W.I L !"/ ?>! l ; IJ Q I# ^ * 3#

we E# o*i/ S>^ o E# 3 ? 3# .o ; " 45 W>/

@ D 3# > E V !iL V 4! =#SH @D o.

Ii! o w we 3 w> w#! ^ = 3? / >V w 5/ !

!W wD# wVt S^ 3# W 5 =t.38

.3 + ! t=> >D C = = SY CL192T/ N >

3! Q # *S^ t 3?T?.* W! SH W 5# # 45 C L

L ! > !< # ? / o*TD ?T.X 45 # = V

=Q = N ? 3"?N 3# @ ; @/ TVH UV.

3TV w t N# # * => = 45 C)1906199(

3?T ^ V B/1928.^ V E# 3?T ^ *+ 3# SY "o " L/ = * = * 3# L?#

! > J# L C UV =#SH.V SY V

?# ? =#SH ZN L l "# C S">T# ] SY

38

"DN X28.


66/145

Page

65

C = 3! 3# o V. 3/ " -> ZT/ i! l " 45 C?B

V ! ? e> S J# ?>! o*# 3@! o 3"t.

?.# 45 C= o?T 5#

! = ? =T ZN622L / ! SH * @! S?

37 3 U". @B/ @t W ? > ! N ! / 5! 5

>D ? = 3! @" @/.

V > 3@! 5@BD - ?; S]H V 3?T ^

*/ 3#J V t = >W# #SH BD /.CT@ ^ V 3#

5 7H L - C"] => !" l ; " ;y i! " 45

" ? w C?-e .o /W! = # e "?N

o*7 w !# T! N# * 3# =#SH.o*e o*el !" o*@#/

" ?@B/ @D> ^ o V 3# o*>"N.3!5 3t? S">T# ] / o . *@ *>! 3# y># # = 3?T ^H V C

E>W S] = * NV L = !N# V *y/ > ?

3!N.39

L" >l / "# 3# S]H ?! / l 3?T ^ " T/

L"> T SH Ee t ? L * ! / N# SL>

!B ? =>l.*Ty !! => 7 S!7 I>! o 3@

E>W D S] w UV. w ? # L L!

?L V < * 5 3# E w # S] .40

39o?" "# Xn RA2- 30 )& UH L199 ?W.

40..


67/145

Page

66

#SH # L ?T 3# ?T ?Y o?T D ?^.41@>

wS L CT =VS]H f# 5 ; #SH .

w! o N X 4 @ @ I>@! 5 /

3T #@"? @> 3# V ] = Yl 3#

SH 4W o* JT/ SQl ? o*i".] / wV = Vl C =

> L #SH wVS] = ! "/.Q N w *+ L

! ? l y> 3@! l N>l L /> S] >l.5*

w C"] w?e 3# ! # W -e W

E#W.

#@" y/ L #@" @t ? 3# !! N# = w5Y 5 @B 3@ #SH E# oWT ! > /

S!>.# !D> 4 5 =/l X S] i! ? w>!i = S>B# L " E>W o.45 w! ZTV

E>W # JB = Y 3? J ? B L3! 3?".42

ZT/ " *# C => @>l

> = !< # i C"] *@ !X V 3# >T#.> W*

S^ l =@? X ! ? " * CQ =>3#198190! ? o;

= ] L/ X19196L/ C? *yt 3#

w# I# ? >! wTD oX>.

41"DN 881.

42"DN ^/ /T N162 / # / #.


68/145

Page

67

Z # 3!X 3# ] )1901966(=! ?

; ! T ?T t!7 3 Q E>W# @B> i/ @T>! != ^ .3# ?!7 T W!> #SH @B Z L

wQD! 5 3# !T y/ #SH W *S^ L o =V 3!@>

=T.T ??L> T B Z? 3# ^ y>/ @ w>#H T! 5 QD E>W

H >WQ" C = #S.E>W B# V " C? i w 5

SH *+ # # 3@! o 5.43

E L H 3# @! o *D# 3?T ^H ^ 3# o/

#SH >T / C V ND#)* = yB => 191(iL 45

!* L wt = =/ * ] => #L> ?V ZT/ @ =

! "# iL * =?T SL>T# 7 @ #S B i / 3 Si.

#SH W -J# ? w?/ o!L> 3# 3#7 "QyT 45*.

? TJ y/ L => #SH #L l /

= #SH !* = #S L 3@! 3?T? # !

? 3SY # ? ! 5 =#SH =T X = T ZV]

3. S7 3@!! 7 L!" theo-democracy45 # ?

>/ =*H L *@"! 7 L! .

@# ? @/ @ / "# / # * 45* = * #.

B t @ / l #SH 5 3# f>>

43! = o# Z X.


69/145

Page

68

tD./ !! i! =X! l L ? NV L! * 7 V

w>L7 * w># 37 - .!?L> Q >l y y SY ZN# >! ZW! E>W = L D L V C? =>.

= D?Y ! W V D?Y? 3@ E>W ! B> -?W# w#*#

-?W = ?.!iL = D?Y 45Y>! *?#@/ #x l -?W? -

*>L; L D?Y E?Y #x "! 3@ ! D.

E>W# ?^ 3# / l 45 # ? N"?@ l # = Q

* yB => >l Q x @ l. 3# L / l E>W 5 ?Y

w? y/ E>W ? oL 45* S^ LL"! >V *>W! ?Q SH oL 3#?

? EQ o>! 5@#SH.* EiY! => ^ IY 45 #

w?# TH TH)EQ 3# !X @ 3 L i^H !7 3 t# #

B( w" l T/ > l * .44

# 3 CW B# ! w !?L> !X 3/ "!" o D.@! y/ D?Y? T !7 3 =D> *? J! => E>W

>T#.@ 3 =* / #x ? JT ?> ZW! y/ w#*D#

? 45 "> i/ = C]Y Jt = ^> t .

o " @! Q V # S> Q >l 3 CW> ^ ?@B#

SQ >W# ? T! ZW! 5 E>W @! L >. QH

Q# " ? ?iD L>/ L?> DN !" /]#SH " W =

SN L> E>W# !">/ = *TD > # !". Q L>l 5 ZT

* #SH ?^ = D T ? 3?T V B>

3/ W 45 3/ L ?^ = W.

44 X!XSH = TV =. 5 X=#SH L....*.


70/145

Page

69

o #SH W? > X W ? => 5 L 3 =

W /W> V @B V *>#/ !" #SH " = e X 45 C?+ *+

T 3?T V C# UV 3!B L > = #

! =t t B *T => T> =#SH > V =/ > 3TV =>

?!/.D 5 =/ > 3TV > /> = l 5 / # = @D> 3#

=W*# X# 3# yT W* ? / *W .=/ >

i! ! W H 3@ SH = !< # !B # .

?L> >l =/ > )5 wL> 5(; H y/

3?T


71/145

Page

70

W ?.=t >@! o

w 5/ T #S f# / W 45 > 3# ^ 3#7!" #L . l ZB ? ] CT #SH " ! *

EL " L * "! # w?.# 5 4 >Y! # #

o*!.46

7 L! !"/ E>> 5 i/ >D! 5 [email protected]@

# I# w* # eV we wy / !" 3i! 5 3# L! o =t B

V @B/ !/ L/ "? T! l UV Q" C = - = ! 5.*L

=L 3# # "# / X y/ L 7 L! 3# "

!+ .

= @ W# #SH C?+ C? L SY L CL => >D =

=T =#SH o = *LL"> C"7 => " T" / .3!5 B #

* X>/ Ci# = " > L V ! ? SY/ >! o^ "N T 3# =y 5.N = 3?T w 5 U!" "> 3@

B >W =>T!./ =#SH ?N E =T U!" N =

? t yB = 3! .

4t 3! ] = !H o " E# 5 = )1881896(!

? E# I?>^ / ! 3#.L N>? B ? D> = / LVl Z

! ]= 4t 318911892!/ B = !H v> t @>V .5

3/ ! > " S^ >J# ! ;y o*"# o l

=#1901906. *t => 3 L = ? > .

46

?W# = =t t B 3 *>Q => N>Y "? X! ?/>198"DN06.


72/145

Page

71

@D Yl !X - 3# S7 + =B @D B 5 3# o/ 3

] > =/W!l=Y ! *+ 3".

= U!" ? o?> B =#> =#SH B E# =Y I]

*+ ? o !S;# 7B o .X Q @D =T w ] S^

T# L!/ =B @D ! 3# =Y 3@ ! = ?*.=B @D

!!( Q ? >/ S# J

o?X Q.3@ ^ "N JT# CV LVl C?^ => !X

Ze #.#H X>l UV 3D 3!5 3/ > =Y t

@ ;m B " =!.!> e D y ! l =B @D /)#

SNf"(T C" !t =? @D @ /> =Y T# i C?

) >19(> 5!X ?L> =B @D 3/ D ;J wL= !H B = oB* = !" ! .w/> =>!t @ C?#

L# > ? >T ! =Y 3# # ; " > 3/ TW

.

3#=Y E #SH " = ? S^

Ie+ ? t 3# 3@>> =B @D *] => L>l TJ ? 5

! >l:B=].wLD !l o/ => TJ 45 C?

# =>! !] H # B " = ! lW./ D 3B @

= w/ @! 5 ZW >l " = #H 3.

47=Y X.


73/145

Page

72

45 =Y ?T W 3# w? NV 5 l ##/

/=?@t # W# 3# Kt . QD D?Y V =?] *D y LJB = ? !L> @ Q T B e = L *D

!.t = 4L ^ =D)! (1988 "?N# y/ =Y ? ?

o =! Z #SH ? D" ^ #SH e D .48w/B

5 =7 @B/ =B @D Z *@ B = y/ =/ > *D# @D 45

! ?T N# * 5/ =? N# Ze #H ! @DL? .

oX T/ B# ! = #SH ! *W C* ? V 3#

? l# ?V #SH X B !H o* 3/ 3?T. #

?# 3T! ?QD ! *W 45 = @" l 37 lB/ / T 3# 3*

! L 3e^

lV V = / 3 [email protected] ^ @! 5

@" 3 D?>Y! o*?W! l 5 #e 3?T.L 3@! N>^/

!?L> #SH !X? > T !D V ?K 3# CV7 !H /W>S] # # ?QD #@"?.

!D #SH T !X = *# N !H /W> C/ L

!X ? = TJ / i.] W *> / 3@! => *T CDB L

*/ = ? l # o/ ?T @>".TW 4 >/ 3!@? *+ = !H X

# I?>^ * yW?! * E# o?T? 3@! o / >S@" E.l

> o>! o N #h @! >D 3# V oeS N >

>T #@" ? "N * 3@! => D@ yT# @B/.

NL L ZT/ !/ !H => lm *+ L/

ZW! =t y/ @B/ *+ SH ? ?! o* 3!5 =LQ

48X!?1988"DN1820."DN # 182.


74/145

Page

73

3?Q @! ZW! o*#@V @ 3 =?Y> ?T w?D!.t L

" =#SH o@" # -y>/ @B/ 3?B# ;" ?T?*! o*? 5>? / 5 W Q W!. #SH #@" @ T! 3# -

o/ o@" 5 ! Z? ? =#SH ! y> -!.

-U

L * = ? ] #SH X = Te ?@BU!" *D

L # w ? ?.wD]/ =T @? ] =#SH *D E# >! *D# 5 t !" #."# L 5 ^ U!" =#SH @D 5

*B!B *i !?L> !X y/.?T @Do*S # ]

/ 5 * wB! # / QD >T YB 5 V iD!

t T !y>/ = >T# ! X.Xx @ X 45 #

# # D l *@ eL >Tw N 5 3# *!L V 3.

#SH * ! => B wt 7 = ^ ?@B# L 7 ?iD !7 ? *D o # W ! .45 E ? N/ #SH W! w C# 5 " L =

@B/ #S l X 3# Z?/ !" 3# # "# = !" #SH " 3#

#SH "? 5 ! 3!^m !V ? i>? ].


75/145

Page

74

v ! 49D 3 12 + 3

! e V "/ ! 5 QD E>W? V 3@

@! ]>X=.L/ L">! 5 =Q =

*T# E# > *"# ? X 3# D ! 7 #.3# o ?5 #

@ = w V *l E! @! # w 3# o ? @ v?! 3@! o X

@t 3# @t = T/ w?@B ! w 3#.

? = ? L>l DV *# C Z! * >V 5 # =

3!@T# w? T! ^ @!# L/ / ?>@ w? T 3T>#

=>T "l. EW = ; 3!@T D 3/ WD = i! yB

w!" w# 4 L> o X !L ?> = "l. E#5#

1989C>D 4 3 =>T "l UV w? y/ X 5* * / *+

!L #@/.5 3@ / ?>@ = V ?>@ D e >J# o " 5@

* =L> EQ EQX >S / o Q# #! @B>.

3 12 ' )&

! V S = SH 5! #.

S = L?L ;y> -@! = = 5L X X!

49


76/145

Page

75

.45 >T DQZ?L w>? # C? / ?

" 3 ie ? ZL ? = X.

+L?L SH w# @ Y! m = X B

=#SH ;y> = -y . = w /3?T TV ? !" @B E.

] = X ^ L C => L ?

*>; o; St @ / *>l 3

>l 3# 5L! E/ S;t.

5 > " / o*SL> 3# Kt >T! ?T 5^ V

L B/= X/SL>l 3@! o eT"/ S#. L 5w/ ? */ >D! w?@B = ! * 3@ o "# 7 = #S. ! ?/ @

X !i *# ? E! "> o# oi! w?

3 L L= X = eT oL . / />T# 3@! o

!" / / = @ "?N "# X 5 @! 5

3!^m ? *> @!.

w S>#/ U o = Kt L/ 3/ 3# D =#SH o 3@# L#

X 5* ?^.o 3# ! W )* 3N / #(?] L>

L = #l @/ L w?N/ ? C l => = ?

#SH o oX# W D># / */B> !WH 5 / CL/ =

t.#l 5* =T = 3# *> => W /)! #

T (EL 3# @/ > -@ i VT 45 ? >S Q


77/145

Page

76

D * *i/.C V *@ > 3# i/ D" ^

/ w? ? > N o.# X / C l EQ 5 = >V 3@@ => >T / = XX 3#

T> Yi ! N>l !@TI N 5 = .

ZT # B L? =" = X = #SH # L!

/ *TD W o 45 = -e.SH i oT" " L ^ o

? 45 = .W DN# 5 /lW H =BV EL y

W V = we m L W! w? N> # / B VT 3# SH V

@ 7.50 S^ @/ 5V 5"! l / @" 3# *>

] / lJ 3#. iL 45 3@=D>Y / .W

>T / N# = !L !@D T #SH W / ! = #SH

iL 45 V W T .= iL 45 C"]

/ ZT" 3?T w l => ! " iL5 o .

#SH yT ? X " !* < .!* l

> / T !!h Q V T L SH C? B

?T >T ! *W *+ ; m */ ? *y/ ! L

= X? .=>T "l 3 ND # ?T >T ! *W? 3@!

>T ! *W " 3Q ;y N ! 7 #H * 3# W 5/

? ? X V W 5*/* = SH 3i.

3 12 w5 3

X V 3/ L? ; ^ 7# ! = @T SH /

# @ JB = SH w?! 5 @! BY! o* =" =.

?T / " 3@L> o*?L = X L> 3!5 3!V T E/ o

50


78/145

Page

77

#X wD]/ = X 3 L/ T ! > # 4T!.Z? L

5 >l lW# Y 3 "/ @T E> = X/o

w? y/ = X.51*>"] C>; => !X 45 ! ! /

TW > B / IN>.5 # 5 = #Z? >

* > l => TJ 3# 5 N# !" o? =!# Z

"/.52

!! 3# # 3@! 3!X 3# ^ W# 5 C

? o I] w! 3!>tX = =>

wNeN^ =.53= / = yB 5 = = N>l lJ

I] w? w? y/ o >V E B T L

X 5 3# *# X/ /.@ # 45*5 Z? !< # l

X)/ / / "> !l #(D e = C B# =

45 oi = N> C => *?>T *? T => EN> ? L! N>/ < >h = X * T! /

?# .? T! 5 l/ #* ^ * 3#

*# L e >! N>.B#* wt = ^ W# EL 3L 3/

=B#* 3# lSL> #L *@ < 3# lSL> #L .Z?

> # */ 3# = >tl @T 3!>t X ZT" => 45

< #* 3/ X?.

3 3# E# D>! >"! l! = X y/ o@"! >V 3X

N "?N => L 3# /.45 y/ >l 3# i! / l 3@

# !; ! N>l *>7 C? / L; CT> L.w ?

513.

52# CT! X!Ug !:...19.

533# S# X.


79/145

Page

78

X o ? X ! NY 5 ? =e !7 3 S#

N = W* ? T./ #! # ] T #L> L; ! ZT>@ C"] 5* / Q Y>T W* 3# "? !

ViD#. # 45 W S#!V = ! N>l = # *

# L; E#W# = ># NV E>W = * L #S./

3 IY! o 5 L! = /T N X " 5 ? #

/ w/W / = >w.3 I?>Y eT = X *@! => TL> 3@

l - S>^ N = .7*>7 = I?>Y l U o

3T? = 3KS Y# L! * => De ! / # @# =o# =# o

*?#@/.i = o*7 = 3T?D L! = N X X> l/ !.3# x ?Y> L" o * NV l # W! = X

i/ T 3!5 @T 3# 3!S * # = / ]V / = 3/ l

)e = " (# e N> #.

+

D?>Y# - ? 3 = X? #SH Q >T.3# o/ w

W # = o?X? !D #SH Q 3Q # 3?T

SH 3/ D "# l oeL = X *? => X -x i/

^ L = 3@! = X.X 5 3* X/ N! SH V !

L ! =#SH ! > w!B N> TW!#SH #x "l *?/ .


80/145

Page

79

w>! / 5# T/ SH o> i = X w.3? ! @

3/ T ? ! 7 # "]? # ! tm 3#C 45 o @ 3@ w? y/ o o@V = *# *# C

V >V V # B i^ ? e 3?T E 5 o* L? ?

=#SH =T X? [email protected] = @ Wl ! X" CQ L

=? X = NL L 3 =.Q = C! L LVS N = L #

# ! ? D> E# C *@ LL" #SH oLE/ # 5* T

*V 3# o? *>LLV => /W!l #*H/ Y @! l o?T#.

= > ^ # X =#SH =T X? = Y E> I CD

D@ 4 #@" #)o ?N .(] L? D@ E# #>! i =! # / ! o N?Y ?T

w? N" o@" =. = 3/ "> # # !l - L D@ E# 3?T # # ].L E

SL> !L> C o?T TV ? = "?N# C # = /

#SH .=#SH =T X y# C ? =#SH =T X C"># ZW S.

#@ i >l =>V @B/ # 5#SH SL>l .

Y Y> !7 3 >l # ! >l L" / = X "!

/L# / *>D+ J N.l !W L


81/145

Page

80

3 SH EL/ =" X 3# !!" 3# SH 3@>! # ^ = w

@B/ ! # D# 4y/ o 5Y>! V = wTD.l .

= # * 45 3# o/ wy/ wD] 3@! SH = ZW 5

l S^ = = SH.X L! L SH W.!

" 3 ?T i >V w S">T# =T >Vl*> SH =L o*

X 5 J! "t =" X? S^.W# = ->?! ZW! SH ? w?

@ 3 ^ / l !l @D.o >V ? L

l ! T w# "!

B.l / ! > 3# C " eL 45 3@

L/ L>! SH. =*>> * ! l.

)& !> ?

7 = 3?T f# W fe> / 3# V o* Z! = E>W#

! "# i Q>D# #S ^ = 3?T EQ " C *W

=T SH/ ?>! L =.3 3?T D# WV ? EQ 5 >T!

=! 5 #S = ?#@ T ? ?N"!i/ = #S

*>#/ T! l ZW! +.

o*@! l i! 3?T * = !# WV t S/ 45

=t w / ?@B w X! o 5 3@ #SH = ?# o*LV ? N"

=7.E = iL 45 yB!L C => ? !#l Y =

!7 3 >#l * 3# = = *#

/ L !V C" @! 3!5)/ 3i 3@ ? = 7 # o


82/145

Page

81

3?T 3?] @T(=#SH L? Nl 3# >T!.S>Vl ] E#

V = # w>#/ =#SH L o LVl >lNYBL L?>H S l l "# / E#

o SL>l *+3@! l 5* 3?T @# Q "# !B 45 *>Q #

* T.

w>?## = X Z? 3# e SH l/ 5 ? #SH

o*#S > ! > ; > N t 3#J .L o o!

Z 3!? Nl 3/ Y! 3#J SH / # = >V

LV o*"# 3#J / > SH .? o ]/ 3#SH /

>"# / #SH = #@ 7 V 3?T *? ! D"] w

#S = 3?T E# T = # V 3#.

# w/ 5 #5 L Q" C = 3#SH / Z 5!

"# @# 3?T)3# o >/(T .=! SY E# #SH *Vm Ze L =7. ? L! ZW! #SH -y w?

5 45 = 3 TJ# i *Q ? 3L 3?T > !

3?T E# T ? o*LV o* 3?# 37 # @!.54

=> W 3@ 5*/ E>L o 3?T 3# fW" 45 *>*>.

lJ lL# ^ CT o*LV # > = @ => ? >V #SH

Z]# = = "! o*T! l ? ]Y/ 3?T = o*>WV

#SH = ?= V 3# o*#"! # .

= TJ# EL/ @> SH/ 3!! l Yt *@"! #S LV

/ !.*TD !" / ?> * @B 45 W# 3# iL 3@

54X231! )t(1990.


83/145

Page

82

o 3# *#.# l / l ! L =@?= >l ? N" 3

L/ 45 L/ >! / = Y >H Q x L V QT N>l lW# = 3!;J = E>W i 3# D > ? *>#@V.

# *#V ! N> E!W o>! 3@!" # S "? ? N" 3

*Q ? *>? V *V.

?! 3?T #SH >W? Y EQ 3 X / Q 3#

U!" = X 3Q B*# ?. oi ZW! => #SH B *#

3 X / 3?T ] ?## D! 5 X 5 3Q *?V ZW! 3?T

o*>T.=7 # 3# # #S o@" => ! V Y 3@! l 5

E = E>W >l 3/ 5^ 45.?T ? @#yW?

?Y> oX S]H D o ? >l E>T E E>W 5*.L ?

# L ? = L? ? >V o !# y = /] W! 3#

3# D o 3# ?L l W! l = Y o 3#45 = ^ 7# = 3?T

".

W* = I 5 !?L> #SH /W>l C L/T N =

! L 3# ^ 3 / o*>W# -y 3# ?T 3@>! UV ! L#.

3# 5* lW# >! l =" = EQ 3@! 3 "/ W W*.L

W * Z>@! o => >T / -y /W = 5 3# 3?T? "# C

= *^ ZW! 3?T 3# ># ? C?+ UV #@.

7 3 +

/] # ? i>! TJ# 3/ > > #L

SH # !".XVS# / 4L =! L?# - o@" 5 3@.


84/145

Page

83

3# E! SH #L V =" L = -e / N# *

? o*D .L 3B>T - DL3!@ 3# @ >V / o oTL !">/ S = 3#*D# l w; = ! o SH y/ L!

L 3T:SH[Abode of Islam]"[Abode of War].5 3@

; K7^ ? l 5V ? .?N/ K7Y >

N/ w> 3@! 5 =! L[hostile territory]

* > ZT" SH 3 - " B! 3?T

)! => ?T L!N L =*/ *# .(

?N N! 5/"S? 3Q o*D ? S*

.CT * / !! L?# ZT/ - / "# ! # @ 7

L# l 5 L =#SH L @! UV #S L#E# !> =

S D ? 3?T.45 V tL Z? 3# * *D# 5V V

5 3# N> l

// N */ oT" => L! -D/ e E# * ] oT" *T! l =>


85/145

Page

84

/ 3/.55 / > 5"! E/ w o w/ 3@! 5 -D/ 7 CT e .o =*=! "> ? T> C /.y/ T

=/ *D# = YSH o = # ! Z!56@t =*

? 4B 5 B > ? L *.

Y> Y>/ ?>! w V l o* i! #l

ZT>@! T/ =! # ^ ?N/ >L! # w>#SH #. 3#

o; 3# #x ? l/ !! 3?T ? y/ / L? 4 ! 5 L

>T!.=! ZW! l o?T

*TD #x - # 7 = L 4 l.Z 5KV l 3 " #

EW ! >V "l 5 Q /SN/ EL - D

N. # TJ ? l l 3# 7H 5 = w ^ * 3#?L *TD 3 >? ! 7 W >T# ED / 37 Ii 3@! #

L? !W T 3Q.E = L7 ?L TL>/ > SH 5*

TJ# .

l 45 Y! Te i! YQ# = ND# @B/ C

. 3# o?T >V oV ?] >Vl t H L? #J

3#J 3! / ? o*V o 3#J. o L! 3# 5 !5"> L? o*@

!V ! 4W o* o*L ? # T o?T E>W .5 =LL" 3#J

L 3 =?Y>? * # L# = C/; w@ o w! / / @!.57

*/B / E 3# o?T I# ? ;y> *> 45 3#

55"DN @T/ X2.

56N -D.2.

57!m L L11.


86/145

Page

85

=" L ?L #) .= + = 3! T W CD? 3#

o >/ #SH =7 # 3# 3?T B! w/> .W INw>?## TV W >V Q ? >/ L EWB! SH = o*# IN

" / .(] T S 3;" 3#SH 3# ! X E =

*> 45 Q =. ^ U!" o?T Ei! 3TV B W S# X 5 3#

i/ *i/ i! / ># ?^ ># L?V:# D *)37(# o;

E)=/ E>W(=#SH o .

W /.7 = o# " TL> y/ ! =/ > 3TV

C -D = t. W ?*!L N/ w f# E>W = 5 l

7 = ] ^ 5 i45 5 =! l #S / V

V N ? .LD / @ = !i V = ^ 45*

*>]N^.58

o*> "# o*DT y^ *+ -// -! # 3# 3??"# i 3@X E# Q >! SH ; E# D> i/ =! l =

y/ L! 3!5 = D = =/ > 3TV # 3# 3!@D# 3# >

3 X ST/ i/ ?! SH.59m / E# *> L# 3# / l m 45*

# > *V7 =>@ 5 5 = !# 3# Z

X ST? E# SH WT.4 = 3!@D 3!5 ZTV SH

7 o?X Q >T# ; TH w^ TH > o?X L l ! ; L

3# E# = o.! w V = #SH L/ T> S W# /

/ l >@ l SH w T! w/ N/>! 3# o?X 37 Y#

w ? 3# 7 o?X >.

58 X4x"DN8 / #102 / #.=/ > =/ 37 = !L #SH "N

/> J# = L# U"/198.59

? =/ > ? = D #L# X. @ X =/ > @ NY/ #& &


87/145

Page

86

X SHB! => L >Y V / TH >! o; EL 3# T.60

*"> 3>? # ! 7 #H D ! 7 #H L l T! l

L = w>!V TH LV >V ? 7 L!? @ o ?T.

W* "LV l o*? LV ? ! =>/ > l 3> 3 # Q #

o D 7# = B! # = .!V B/ T ly/ / Z TH ?

5 ! = " Y X N L! X ! !"

! / 5/ ZT>.!"/ * E>>! => !" 7 L! *+ 7 E#W> => 3?T ? ! ?K 7 L # Y! t H 3# T

K! ! V>L/ *.

#SH > V o =t t Y>T! ?L> I!> T> =

?T * @! => 4 >/ SH3# Vo*! # >T!

3#


88/145

Page

87

?? Y T w! 5 =i >l ?!7 > 5# w> 5 +U!" = X? y =?T D>? # @D C? * => !" #SH.

SH y/ # * ?^ => W> ! l 5 3@N # m E#

/ ] 3 = X.62eT E# t> C /Y 45

=T SH # S ? 3N!V 3!5 3!B L > = >@?63

w o@V #3! # =e Z@ V ?.

y/ UV w@V y^ @V 45* 3#

?L>T S @B = *# S# @ SH."> wD]/ SH

V -e/

B #.o>">! => #SH ? ?L; JT# EQ 4 / 5

T ! E?> C Jt Z =?^ *yt 3# ?N l *?

= X L o.7 >D iY/ Z# =#SH o 3#> 3# ?!

VT ? = 4 / SQl w/ N! ?^.

62^ X S? #SH !X=> /.

63 B># > = *> ? X+ -+.


89/145

Page

88

jL 49D

O9A 2 :)&)

T /W>l W> yB # ! Q y/ 3?T !" L" C* L

C* X @# D V w> Ci =Q = .=!

@ o>"! ?T# YB @ Q 45 E# #> = /] 3# ?T

l "/ " /N 3@ #SH / #@"# X 45* /W>l

W = =#S X# 3#!" @/ U!" N CL # l =T

! L =#SH @D? LLV.i ?T ? T Kt U!" N L! o

*?# => > !" ?L> =T @D = *> / ?

# 3# @D#? 3/ .

w2 < v< @ L/T >D 3 X / 3?T? !" /W> L " 3#

oL S^ L w T >D! 5 E D>l 3>*

!.V T V ? ^ @B/ ! 5 3 L = #y> o>">! U)3#

7 >(E# t>! W 5 D !"> =>l W = o@"> =>

#SH ! ." 5 *>! ^ 3@= > ^

/ >/; 3 >l 3 L# = =>l W = > l !

" TH H . ? 3/ 5# >l ? X # L=


90/145

Page

89

* NV l i i/ 45 .5/5>! ?^ 3/ W S#

W = ^ ;J * EiY => * L N > 3/ >/# 3! > 3/ =T= ] E # = N i ! Q S

B W#.w? ?! l 5 ;J = ! D "?N

Q C> 3 C -D = >L! L# Y =>l W =

> 5 E>W ^ . @ i! Y V L - # #

!!" 3 L TH h l y/ w@ =TH ?T o@" =>

i *?! => L=^ ! # L7 3 ?ND o*eD?V ?# L?

==>l L" = .J 3 >l 3 L 45 H /

*>D+>D#*.

3 L / ?> eLV * * BD !X 45 ^ =

E ] / ;y 3# ?L *DN =>.?^ 3/? B L>

" = # T / " B ZT N W

E = ;y W *# 3@! .? B L# yt 3# ? .

= SY TH >l = 5 y = *?B ZT/ i! T !X *

4 *TD " 3# 3 @# # =>l =L> 3W

L 3 L 3 U" = 3?T? # 5 =E

l 4V iY 3# l/ 3 L 45* iY? D] "> =! l =>l

S^ #S ST>l !YT? .*B w> = 3@! S:

L# E # ? ?Y o;.# L/ L i! @! l o ? wy/ -

Kt w# ]S^ >> => = E 5 3 l @! ZW! - E 3#


91/145

Page

90

/.@ m E?> ? " TH L/ !H l T! l -@/ /.=D

L " ? - o* C; =Q*e *Q / ZT" >l 35.?e* !B @#H 45 ? ] =#SH ! > !.

L 3# wL/ - 3@ E * # 3# / l.D>V IB>@ o* 3

L! ! / ?L> =L!H =T @D 7

S! ?T? ?^ 3/ # /> = wy L? @??

3! > /> = ? 7 L! / tH ?L.=> >W C

L ?# L * # X? W# * / W.= o?T L

i E 3# *? w ! 5 @.

# 3 )&

E " 3T"#@/ e - *i! 5 = X !" #

#SH ?./ 45 C L45 L"> ! @# ? CL?^ "

.3 C? => SH # Y =LLV = E>W# ?Y V X! 5# *TD.oL E# # S 5 ! 7L# 4W/ Zy! > = # = =W Nl e =

#SH L o] = h = *D L" @#.*D 5* 3@!

L" = * ? N" = T! 5/ #L V >V !

=#SH E>W=.

= =? @B/ D>? E#W x !V 4W/ "

wV 3# o w>?L = w? 5 Z?? W i!: v?>/ w T

!V ST/ L? => ! T.V >W = ]^ 3?T= !

Z? = * ! # #SH o*L ZT"/ o*N ? * !

=Q = V.


92/145

Page

91

3?T 3/ > 3# @ ?Y 5^ !" > 45 -D ^ * 3#3!^m 3/ o*/ o*TD.> l => ! D !" @D4 4W E>W JT/

? ! @ = D? 4/ > l 3# T/ =B/ > D? =V

SH.!B? 4 =V SY L"> *>W! o?T E>W = >D 3

.3# " # ? o>"! X 5 #= S* wTD ? Z?W! = D !V

">l ] >W w/ " 5 L -D/ w!.

@B! !! 5 ? Q I# = o*TD ?T W! = W =

? SL; K w#X = E>W 5 # w ] ? = E>W"! 3?T

o *L! o*!V 3#. C# V ! ?/ Z! C # L

#SH.?T w ! Z! C B oX# ST! * =

>Y # eB / >V o?> = .

V ^ >T# =?T = B? "! S? ?T @! ! ?T ? N" 3# o* /V ?^! o*Q # o* ?/ = T

B 3T? W/ =.o*SL> L" = "W 5 ?T W #

V o*Q ? o* Q # * ! o* o*L ZT"/ o* V oX

T ! = ^J# V V.

# = / o o? T/ LL" 3@

S^ [email protected]"! =D@! 3? = E>W =


93/145

Page

92

o*D # o i!.W = =?T !> 3/ > SH w* ! 5 ">

SH / oL/ T> 3/ = "N ! TH w>. !N X 3# / o?X 3# ! - ? L! = X

o = ? oX E! >/ *> o*Q 3?T ? =?e H.3?T ? -

! l o?X 5 # y/ o L!*L ? L! w ]^ ZT" =?T !> E# oL>T

! i! SH ? / */ ># ? w l =S^ T# w - T

Y 4 X# 3# I!. = T 3T?D V / ?! l SH

X L L! Jt !iL 45 =" = .o*T! l ?T

# ] w* W =" = X L> o L E! / !

45 E! > = "?N# o* 3?T Y @ 45.? 3@! l

"t @!C -D = w? @V ?.

wy/ wTD ! E>W# ? t= ! 5 X 3# / S

JT 4W/ Li 5 "?N W ! / #.?L 5* >D

L">/ - = Y o ? @l? >l L">/ = 5 D> l3?T Q ST Y>T! 5 3!^m ! = / l = w ?Y> !B E/

# o* 5 @? EB! l * 7 o*#N^.V w?

= #L

.

= X ? 3?T @ / ^ V .=#SH VH

H B # 3?T? @ >/ > l ZT/ / yB U!" 3#S

? 4 >/ SH !T B >T# 3T"> o*# o ? SH Y>

* 5 L"> #.


94/145

Page

93

L 3T" = ! C w> Sh " 45 4t w> 5! 45 L" ^ oX E E>W? ^ N /./ V

Y! ?/L# V 7 o!L Z # 3!@D >@

Sh.L LL" o* # E# Z>! l eS> /? #Y> 3!@D 3!5 3@

B 3# B*# ] ". 3# / l w? = @ 45 @B ]

Th Q *D]/ #SH # I! !7 3 =S^.

=>l @D > ] I! V L = V L

=#SH. 3! Q !?L> T !X C !X D] 3!5 3;"

N = =? >/ ?>! ?N ! ? *?W! # tB# # *y/ SY

U!".3# >T# !X 45 T l ZW! l "N 3# ?Y! l L 5 E#

?> L l # /W? y># #@V i! -@ L?

# ! .5 3# # > >^ ? 3?T 3/ / 3 !X 45 L

# * E?> => 3# C/> C ! >.

3# LVS x ! W E#

l) >10120(

#y/ X) >622( 4W/ E =Y = >! #

W> ? N C => e L o.

3 J ? /H 3# / l 3?T w => ?i 7 o*D =@

* 3! "#:?T 5 45 7

*; * #/ w > 3 3T:TD o* = 3?T @D# y^ V =

#S#


95/145

Page

94

= !?L> !X B IB@! "D 3 JT 3/ ; /

= = ZT "N TD> 4TD o* *! w > 3 >V 4 # ? o>">!

># 3>W# o*??" = "N> 3!X lJQ >l 3# 3>i: * 3

@/ =/ # * *X! 3 / T = 45 3N?Y# L>!

= 3 Si.ZL D?Y? =D+ I] = *T! ?+ C -D = o*@

= -!L l @ l D] w? T!.

5 3#J! 5 ? 3/ X # l !Y i/

L/ l o L 3@! l ; *@" V B y/ / T! o*.lJ C* #

D45 y/ W>Vl/ o* 45 / CiV ] /W> " 3TV 3#

o 5 = 3@ 3# C>; !B 3# L# ? #@V L

#L>l. o / l @# N! o W> 45 ]> = D

i! #@" @" B> B B l E

3# ] " 7 S lW#.B>! =@!# -e 3# o/ w W 5

T@ 3> I! Y l *? ! > 5 # 7 # 3# VX *QD! => L ZT/ 3> w/? =@!#

! >l w#.

7Y L>l t SY? !?L> #SH X ^ 5*

3T!L/ wt 3!5 @" E# Z>> oN ZW! #@" y/T T!L


96/145

Page

95

V ! ? L "/.3# >> SY V o*#@V #SH X ?Y>

! = N>! 3!5 3T!L *B! 3!5 3!t D?Y #.// ?i WB/ N # ! Q L N

?i>/ oT> !?L> T !X 5 ZT 5 L> w> >"!

* 3T!L W! ZN 3# @! >W eS.

?Y #D?Y N TD> C * !?L> !X = =

X " 3 ^l ! = !X 45 B S# TD! 5

=? S^ T Q .L! C L

*/ N =>* w o 5 ? L w/ 5Y 5 ?x E>W

*L. ? @ #SH #@" I] D yY 3# L 5

!?L> !X C?B L 5^ L# / 3# C@ #@" ? V Q o V

5^y/T" =.!" 3@# >l = #* L ]D> 45 5^ !X ?

/W> 45 @ =>/ 3@! l @# t o@" C? => # > X S>^ E#.

w = "Q L 3# tH 3!X lJ E/ -W>

! E>W ^ Q * 4 # / 3/ L/ " S

L I?>Y# 3/ ] >)D?Y E# t# N ? ! = L! o*?(

e D?Y #

T ? = B! 3! L Yt @ .3@! o => D?>Y X =

V C !? ] ] > #! D?Y.

o V D?^ @ C E =^ * -?W# N * =?Y> 3@! V

Y Q !7 3 N L 3 !.


97/145

Page

96

^3 + J2 A6

L ] @ ?T x V ?@B# / H 5 w 3@! o 5 C =

I?>Y L U!" o = !5 @B/.3# i 3# ] L

!X ] 3# ?L> =#SH = # 3 IB@

!?L>.

3! T V 5# > ?T 3# ! ? 45*/ >t

4 "# 45? =B E> L 3# E/ = iL 45 *#>.

SY * 4 Y# C !" #SH " 3@

!* " 3 * = VS]HTJ ?^ " =W*. " 45 C L

TJ *l S 5 ? ! ? -y =#SH wLD ] TJ ? w? C# 5 @D !?L>.

=#SH @D = - ? i ? !" VS]H " 3@

?L>.# Ie+ ?L> @D L)L !V # #(*y/

3#!D@ .ZW! ^ = 3 3 I?>Y! =#SH wLD = !D@

D@ wLD ! / L/ ? 3 X / w/ ?Z wy/ !

3 3 L w/ 5. !D@ D N>/ V >! o 3@

/ w/ 3 @! !D@ = =! 5 3; @! 3?T

3?T o! w = o;H.! 45*/ yT 3@Ie+ 45 7 o* =T! L

@ # l yt 3# CT W Ie+ 45 # N! w W

C? l.3# - #SH # Z L>! m >V ?T + o*D 5*/


98/145

Page

97

" *# / 3?T yt?T L.N K /

*/ SQS ! > L " !" ? 3?T * 45L?# !/ ? = K#.

3# 5 = ;".3@

5/LV wB 5 -? LLV *+ EQ.3 =?Y> Z 3# 3@! o?

!D@# 3# /W! T# .

EW w# D! 5 =B#* I?@> - = !D@ I! ZW!

# Yt w/ .! ZW! 3# -@ ?3# y> E>W = Yt Z @

@B/ 3# y> o>! >V V D o>! l Z YB 3# 3# 5 I!> H X y*

W ? *T TJ# T / @#.!W ".


99/145

Page

98

Y >T ** = >! !" #SH "N = ?^ . L Y wVW ZT/ 4 = ?L> =#SH X ?T " L

Z @ # EB!> 3# 3?T V =BD> o?X SX/ =?# o

/ [email protected] 3# yB >V Y X 5 Z? = 5 # 3@

^m V !.# ^ * 3# * =?^ X = L 5^ * 3

o "?N# L/ 3 ^ ^ * o* T o/ eL oX.

X !J! #SH IQ T o*LV 3# = # 3"?N# W 5@

= X 3# i =#SH.3?T @T E# # T? > ? i!

=/ Y Q =#SH 37 !" # * @B> #SH =Q .

! ^ " *N Q N ! >l /W> i

4Wl 5 3# Sh.D >T X !J! 3;" 3#SH B W 5@

=e = SH 3# B># ^ 5Y> X 45 C# # >T / =/ o

T@ ; # o 5 3# o/ *.o > 5 W> 3# 5! N L"! o = X ? >B! =#SHwe ? .

EQ 5 => = 5/ X 45 7 E =.=> >T X

=@ o ?L! >D 3# 3!5 ? >l Q */t L; T^

?T = ?X!.WY *?W X 45 X C -D = N W

=S^ W = #o*Y! 3# / WY/ B! ?T ] 5/.

?/ 3 ^y => ] #SH >W " Z 3#

= 3# D@ w?/ # ?/ 3 C -D = N *! w 5. 45

=#SH VH ?> Ct Q L *>D?^ => ?" N # T

U!". m IY! ! > #X *# !J K TL! 3#SH W .

>l ?iD! ^ = !H >l !J! #S *X >V / T

= .4 N# >l / VN! 3!5 K # VT 3 Z!.


100/145

Page

99

Z >L L 3#SH 3t 45 =;! i ?^ VS]H/ = "Q." 7 T

5 Q " o/ * @T B ?] KY 37

N X>#! ! ! ?+ 3!5 3 Y Q T! /.v?/

!"> ZT/ *W C@t => ! = #SH EQ 5*

3 > 3LL" 3 Y L/ Bl ?^ .

+ H D J

#SH " = = > L TJ# >/ ? U!" *D?

*D# * >T! => ? ! D S^ ? D>l !" Q *?

!" . ? o ] = 3tD/ wt 3;" 3#SH 3# 5

o*> *D 3 #=T E>W V =?] =#SH *D? S^ .5 = !; l * Z?! o @> L V S] V #SH #

w? X" V>.o* *X ? N! 3;" 3#SH 3# 3@

?T 3 "!; L l.

T> #SH */ => *?> = >! ?i 45 V

EQ =T w? L! 5 @ ZW! 7 L! !" 3!5

m ?T w ! 5 y? Y#.>W Z? #*? 3@ o #SH

=t D l !" ?> l * =. @B/ *?B C>; => !?L>.

7/30/2019 W

Documents

Who Needs an Islamic State BY ABDULWAHAB AL AFANDI لمن تقوم الدولة الإسلامية؟ عبد الوهاب الأفندي