Upload
sxcmikey
View
74
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
University of Sydney WORK1003 Lecture
Citation preview
3/9/14
1
Foundations of Work & Employment WORK 1003 Lecture 2 | Employment Relations Theories | 10 March 2014
Work & Organisational Studies Stephen Clibborn
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
1. Admin & questions 2. Short Essay Preparation 3. In the news 4. Employment Relations Theories
- What is theory? - Why do we need it? - The key theoretical perspectives on ER
5. Conflict 6. Conclusion
2
Todays Lecture
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
3
1. ADMIN &
QUESTIONS
3/9/14
2
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
4
1. Admin. & Questions
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
5
2. SHORT ESSAY PREPARATION
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Some Logistics
Read the UoS Outline NB:
Essay due before 12 midday on 2 April Submit essay online via Blackboard (Assessments tab) Word limit: 1,000 words (including in-text references; excluding reference list) See standard Business School policies for penalties for late submission and for exceeding
word count here: http://sydney.edu.au/business/currentstudents/policy Dire penalties for plagiarism
Essays returned and feedback given online
6
2. Short Essay Preparation
3/9/14
3
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
A Rough Plan
Read question Read question again Work out what the question is asking you to do Read article at least twice Read another two articles from articles reference list Write essay plan Draft answer Re-write answer Check referencing; structure; argument; sense (read it aloud)
(NB - see reading for next week by Pauk)
7
2. Short Essay Preparation
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
How to find journal articles
http://www.library.usyd.edu.au
Catalogue Databases (WOS resources) WORK1003 section
8
2. Short Essay Preparation
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Methodology
How knowledge is found and formed How did the authors find out the information, answer the questions they
set? Is it appropriate, rigorous, reliable? Types of methodology: oQuantitative oQualitative
- Interviews - Case studies
oReview
9
2. Short Essay Preparation
3/9/14
4
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Good WOS sources Peer-reviewed academic work is the key to all research in WOS: Some examples of good journals relevant to WOS
Industrial / employment relations journals / labour law / labour history: Journal of Industrial Relations , Labour and Industry, Industrial Relations Journal , Economic and Industrial Democracy , Industrial and Labor Relations Review, British Journal of Industrial Relations, Work Employment and Society, Labour History (Australia), Labor History (US), Australian Review of Public Affairs , Australian Bulletin of Labour, Labor Studies Journal (US) , Australian Journal of Labour Law
Organisational behaviour / HRM / Management journals: Academy of Management Journal , Academy of Management Review , Administrative Science Quarterly , Asia Pacific Journal of Management , Australian Journal of Management , Business and Society , Human Relations , Journal of Business Ethics , Journal of Management , Journal of Management Studies , Organization, Organizational Dynamics , Organization Studies, Public Administration , Group and Organization Management , Human Relations , Journal of Applied Behavioural Science , Journal of Applied Psychology, Journal of Managerial Psychology , Journal of Organizational Behaviour , Journal of Occupational Psychology , Organization Studies, Work and Occupations
10
2. Short Essay Preparation
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
11
3. IN THE NEWS
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Coalition MPs plot to strip workers' weekend and holiday penalty rates Swan, J., et al, SMH 8 March
12
3. In the news
3/9/14
5
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
13
4. EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS THEORIES
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Recruitment & Selection
Pay & Reward
Performance Management
14
E/ers & E/er Associations
E/ees & Unions
The State Context
Theory
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
We have defined ER: The study of the formal and informal rules which regulate the employment relationship and the social processes which create and enforce these rules
(Bray, Waring and Cooper, p.9)
Now we need to look at ways to examine ER
. . . but first, the what and why of theory and ER?
The employment relationship is a central concern in all employment relations theorisation - so what is it?
What is theory and why do we need it?
15
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
6
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
The employment relationship is: An economic exchange in the labour market
But: Labour is not (necessarily) a commodity in the same way as other commodities Employees bring their labour power or capacity to work in return for wages Employers hire this capacity to work, not actual work effort The management process is crucial to turning labour power into labour effort
and productivity or commitment, effort and compliance Employment is a power relationship employee submits to authority
Thus the employment relationship is an open ended relationship and an inter-dependent one
16
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
The employment relationship is also: A legal relationship or contract between an employee and his or her
employer; A psychological contract between an employee and his or her employer;
"The perceptions of both parties to the employment relationship, organisation and individual, of the reciprocal promises and obligations implied in that relationship" (Guest, 2007)
A social contract that sits within a range of - contextual factors (society, economy, ideas) - and institutions (organisations themselves, employer associations, governments,
courts, unions etc)
that regulate the employment relationship and some of the many issues that arise in that relationship (e.g. recruitment, pay, performance etc).
17
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Theory What is theory? Why do we need theory? Theories are essentially frames of reference They:
1. Bring order to our thinking 2. Allow us to abstract - or think at a higher level about events and
processes
3. Allow us to explaining the causal logic of events and processes and to explain why empirical patterns were observed (rather than simply describing what happened)
4. Allow some predictive capacity
NB: theories are not guides to action they are not how to
18
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
7
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
4. Employment Relations Theories Theories can have a significant impact on scholarship and thinking in a given field including:
Helping shape the scope of a field (eg they can help construct disciplines)
Allowing the construction of definitions of fields and their terrain
Allow us to build on, and to challenge and overturn, our understanding in a field
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Informed Description Surge in disputes under Fair Work (AFR, 9 March)
20
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
21
4. Employment Relations Theories
Source data: www.abs.gov.au
Informed Description
http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/3720658.html
3/9/14
8
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
22
E/ers & E/er Associations
E/ees & Unions
The State
4. Employment Relations Theories
Taxonomy
A taxonomy to assist us re actors and Institutions
The parties to (or institutions of) the employment relationship
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Recruitment & Selection
Pay & Reward
Performance Management
23
4. Employment Relations Theories
Taxonomy
A taxonomy to assist us re processes
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Recruitment & Selection
Pay & Reward
Performance Management
24
E/ers & E/er Associations
E/ees & Unions
The State Context
Theory
A little like Dunlops IR Systems model
3/9/14
9
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Theoretical approaches to (ways of looking at) ER
There are three distinct perspectives of the origins and nature of ER, each leading to a distinct approach (or analytical tool) to explain ER:
1. a unitarist perspective (which informs human resource management (HRM))
2. a pluralist perspective (leading to neo-institutional approaches) 3. a radical perspective (which enables a labour process approach).
Largely differ Re: 1) conflict; 2) power; 3) trade unions; and 4) the state
25
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
UNITARISM Assumption of a common purpose and shared goals, with no
fundamental conflict of interest between labour and capital. - Conflict is an aberration resulting from poor communication or poor
management (bad fit)
Power even - all part of one team, but management has authority Trade unions are viewed as an unwelcome intrusion, competing for loyalty
of employees
The state has no role
26
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
UNITARISM
Criticisms: What are the criticisms of unitarism? A narrow approach that neglects causes of conflict. Fails to explain the prevalence of conflict within organisations. Does not account for uneven distribution of power among employees and
employers in the decision-making process
27
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
10
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
UNITARISM
Approaches within unitarism: - scientific management (Taylorism):
- work study and the one best way - establishment of work rules.
- human relations (Mayo and the Hawthorne experiments): - emphasis on work groups and social relations at work - less importance given to economic incentives
28
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
UNITARISM
Approaches within unitarism: Human Resource Management (HRM) is often viewed as a modern form of a
unitarist approach, that is: the management of the employment relationship primarily from the perspective of the
employer.
This can be seen in the main focuses of HRM: plan human-resource requirements recruit and select employees train and manage employee performance reward employees dismiss or retire employees.
Hard and soft HRM
29
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
PLURALISM
Key post-war writers Dunlop (US), Clegg, Flanders and Fox (UK). Very influential in Australian writing (eg Dabscheck) - Conflict is inevitable: competing interests between the parties. Power is diffused among the main bargaining groups within the employment
relationship: no-one dominates.
Trade unions are viewed as providing a mechanism that legitimates employees rights to bargain within the workplace.
The state is regarded as an impartial entity, whose primary function is to protect the public interest.
30
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
11
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
PLURALISM
Criticisms: What are the criticisms of pluralism?
Theory of pluralism is unclear Power is not evenly diffused in reality:
- it is is typically weighted towards management in the workplace - Emphasis upon rational approach to conflict management:
- a form of managerialist thinking that obscures true conflict - The emphasis on rules and regulations neglects process
31
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
PLURALISM
Neo-institutionalism
Neo-institutionalism is an extension of pluralist thinking about the role of rule-making in the employment relationship.
It sees that the employment relationship as governed by two types of rules: 1. formal/informal rules 2. substantive/procedural rules.
These rules are made in a broader context: as a result of the forces and imperatives of capitalist social relations, in society and in the workplace.
32
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
RADICALISM What are the common features of the radical perspectives?
- Conflict - fundamental and inherent conflicting interests between management and workers
- Power - uneven distribution of power between bargaining groups, within the workplace and society
- Trade unions their role is to challenge managerial control - The state - protects the interests of capital
Marx argued that capital social relations are based on a fundamental divide between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat
Labour possesses labour power - essentially the potential effort that each employee offers. Potential labour does not always equal actual labour. Managements task is to convert this labour power into actual work and effort, in order to make a profit.
33
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
12
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
RADICALISM
Labour Process
The labour process debate (arises from the radical tradition). Central theme: How does management maximise the conversion of potential
labour into actual labour? - Labour is not always compliant in this process, resulting in conflict between
management and labour. - As this relationship is open-ended, management seeks to establish methods for
ensuring control, to maximise actual labour effort. They seek to explain how this occurs.
34
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
RADICALISM
Criticisms
Preoccupied with conflict: - obscures any cooperation or shared goals between management and workers
Class struggle not part of modern capitalism - Capital is not homogenous: competition and capital - Under-estimates the independence of the state
35
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
GENDER ANALYSIS IN THE 3 PERSPECTIVES Many critics of the three traditional approaches to employment relations argue that
they are gender blind ER is inherently gendered in both historical and contemporary senses.
- male breadwinner ideology - Gendered labour market
- vertically - horizontally
Without understanding and incorporating these issues into our analysis we have at best a partial explanation of the world of work
36
4. Employment Relations Theories
3/9/14
13
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Theoretical perspectives of the 2011 Qantas dispute Unitarist / Pluralist / Radical Qantas has collective enterprise agreements with 3 key sectors of its
workforce 3 unions bargaining on behalf of the 3 groups of e/ees:
Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association Transport Workers Union (e.g. baggage handlers) Australian and International Pilots Association
Industrial action by e/ees (some strikes) Industrial action by Qantas (lockout) Fair Work Australia ordered end to industrial action 2014 - mass redundancies
37
4. Employment Relations Theories
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
38
5. CONFLICT
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Conflict can be overt; or covert
Overt conflict oStrikes / lockouts oboycotts osabotage opickets osit-ins owork to rule obans onot wearing required uniform
These are collective and can be either pro-active or defensive
39
5. Conflict
3/9/14
14
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Covert conflict owork to rule oabsenteeism osabotage - Qantas acted to avoid sabotage (AFR, 30 Oct 2011) oturnover otheft oindifference oslow performance ofailure to share knowledge owhistle blowing
Can be collective or individual, pro-active or defensive
40
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Explanations for workplace conflict
Interests of employers and workers may collide ocontradictory and antagonistic
(Edwards 2003, p.16)
oemployers exert control and demand productivity improvement oemployees are likely to expect:
increased compensation for their effort interesting work opportunities to develop themselves
41
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Explanations for workplace conflict
Hymans summary of the causes of industrial conflict oincome distribution ojob security omanagerial control
42
5. Conflict
3/9/14
15
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Three types of industrial conflict
Strikes The Australian Bureau of Statistics defines an industrial dispute as:
a withdrawal from work by a group of employees, a refusal by an employer or a number of employers to permit some or all of their employees to work, each withdrawal or refusal being made in order to enforce a demand, to resist a demand or to express a grievance (ABS Cat No 6321.00).
Note: this definition includes both employer and employee initiated action
A strike is an employee-initiated work stoppage A lockout is an employer-initiated work stoppage
43
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Three types of industrial conflict
Absenteeism Defined as:
the proportion of employees on an average day, who were away from work on sick leave without being approved in advance (Morehead et al. 1997, p. 72)
Absenteeism can be seen as an early stage in the progressive withdrawal leading to voluntary turnover:
individuals engage in a hierarchically ordered sequence of withdrawal ranging from its most minor form to a complete break from the organisation [that is, quitting]
(Rosse and Miller 1984, p. 201) 44
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Absenteeism
Research has been particularly interested in: oabsence culturea normative belief in the legitimacy of absence taking ojob designthe larger the work group, the higher the absenteeism
autocratic workplace = higher absenteeism
Absenteeism reflects sick organisation (AFR, 7 Feb 2012)
45
5. Conflict
3/9/14
16
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Absenteeism
Managing absenteeism oDrago and Wooden (1995, p. 131) have identified several management
activities that can act to reduce voluntary absenteeism: allow for flexibility and discretion in managing absenteeism job enlargement and multi-skilling participation in decision-making, fair treatment, good pay and job security improved communication to clarify expectations of employees ensure employees have career paths create cooperative workplace relationships
46
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Three types of industrial conflict
Turnover
Defined as permanent withdrawal from the organisation Voluntary labour turnover is associated with absenteeism:
owork withdrawal => absenteeism ojob withdrawal => turnover
47
5. Conflict
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Turnover Factors affecting turnover
operceived desirability of leaving the organisation: key variable = individual job satisfaction
operceived ease of movement from the organisation: state of labour market (availability of alternative jobs)
opsychological variables predictive of quitting employee dissatisfaction low level of commitment to the organisation contextual issues, such as training, supervision and job content, more important than
pay levels
oworkplaces with trade unions have a lower quit level 48
5. Conflict
3/9/14
17
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
49
6. CONCLUSION
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
The employment relationship is more than just an economic exchange Theories recognise that different people look at things in different ways Three different theoretical perspectives, or ways of looking at, ER
a) Pluralism b) Unitarism c) Radicalism
Related to each of these respectively is a key analytical approach: a) Neo-institutionalism b) HRM c) Labour process
Each of these approaches are competitors in seeking to explain the nature of the employment relationship: Each approach is based on different value judgments Each approach emphasises different aspects of the employment relationship Each sees a different role for parties and of their relative power
50
6. Conclusion
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
The employment relationship typically involves both conflict and cooperation. This is reflected in owageeffort bargaining othe conversion of labour power into actual labour
Industrial conflict takes many forms othere are many more days lost to absenteeism than striking/lockout
51
6. Conclusions
3/9/14
18
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Critical Analysis in Essay Writing
Beyond descriptive writing Making an argument Setting out your answer . . . and more
52
Next weeks lecture
Foundations of Work & Employment | WORK1003 Lecture 2
Bray, M. Waring, P. and Cooper, R. (2011) Employment Relations: Theory and Practice, 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd, Sydney, Australia
Dabscheck, B, (1983) Of Mountains and Routes Over Them: A Survey of Theories of Industrial Relations, Journal of Industrial Relations, December 1983 vol. 25 no. 4 485-506
Dunlop J, (1958) Industrial Relations Systems, Henry Holt, New York Flanders, A (1970) Management and unions, Faber and Faber, London Guest, D (2007) HRM: Towards a new psychological contract, in (eds) P Boxall, J
Purcell and P Wright, Oxford Handbook of Human Resource Management, Oxford University Press, Oxford
53
References