8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
1/25
INTERNATIONAL LAW
PARMA UNIVERSITYInternational Business and Development
International Markets and Organizations Law
Prof. a!riele "atalini
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2f/Flag_of_the_United_Nations.svg
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
2/25
CLASS ACTION:U.S. AND ITALYAPPROACHES
International markets and organisations lawProf. Gabriele Catalini
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
3/25
DEFINITION
In law, a class action or a
representative action is aform of lawsuit in whih a largegrou! of !eo!le olleti"el#
bring a laim to ourt and$or inwhih a lass of defendants is
being sued.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
4/25
%&'TO(&
) Meieval E!rope: England **+- reord of afew indi"iduals re!resenting a large grou! of!eo!le in legal suits.
) "irst S!it: */01 a Disart "s. Otes ase.) R!le #$: *2//- 3.'. law first introdued grou!
litigation) R!le %$: allowed absent !arties to be
re!resented as members of the !roseutinglass.
) R!le &%: (ule /2 beame (ule +/ and 4o!t out5
was introdued) Private Sec!rities Liti'ation Re(or) Act* o(
+,,-: new rules in seurities lass ationlawsuit.
) Class Action "airness Act o( &-: e6!ansion
of federal 7urisdition o"er man# large lass8ation lawsuits in the 3nited 'tates.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
5/25
3.'. FEDE(9: C:9'' 9CTION'
) Class ation lawsuits ma# be broughtin federal ourt if the laim arisesunder Federal (ules of Ci"il Proedure
(ule +/ and +2 3.'.C.9. ; *//+
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
6/25
5C9NT> C%9(9CTE(I'TIC'
+ Numerosity 8 the lass must be so large as to makeindi"idual suits im!ratial
& Commonality 8 there must be legal or fatual laimsin ommon
% Typicality 8 the laims or defenses must be t#!ial
of the !laintiffs or defendants# Adequacy of Representation 8 the re!resentati"e
!arties must ade?uatel# !rotet the interests of thelass
-.
ommon issues o!!osed to indi"idual fat8s!eifionflits between lass members and the defendants
/. lass ation, instead of indi"idual litigation, is asu!erior "ehile for resolution of the dis!utes athand
http://atlas.nrcan.gc.ca/sites/english/maps/reference/international/usa/map.jpg
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
7/25
'T9TE C:9'' 9CTION'
) 'ine *1/2, man# states ha"eado!ted rules similar to the F(CP
) %owe"er, some states ha"e i"il!roedure s#stems whih de"iatefrom the federal rules
) 'ome states, do not !ro"ide foran# lass ations, while others, limitthe t#!es of laims that ma# bebrought as lass ations.
http://atlas.nrcan.gc.ca/sites/english/maps/reference/international/usa/map.jpg
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
8/25
Ho0 oes a Class Action s!it 0or12
Step +- drafting a om!laint
filing it in ourt
4ser"ing4 on the defendants
Step &- defendants answer or
hallenge the om!laint
Step %- a !eriod of 4diso"er#4 takes !lae
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
9/25
Ho0 oes a Class Action s!it 0or12
Step #- the !laintiff files motion toertif# a lass ation.the defendants will file
ob7etions to ertifiation.
the Court will ha"e a hearing.
If !laintiffs win, the ase will be ertified.
Step -- Notie about member@s rights and deadlines for 4o!ting out4
Step /: Trial or 'ettlement
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
10/25
CLASS ACTION IN ITALY
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
11/25
E3(OPE' 9TTIT3DE FO( T%E C:9''9CTION
The European Consumer Commissioner:
5The old ontinent will ne"er 5go
down Athe 9merian lass ationBroad> with its 5to6i oktail> ofontingen# fees, !uniti"e damages,
and !retrial diso"er#>.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
12/25
#IST$RY
% &'() * t+e first Italian de!ate too, pla-e
% )&)/ 0anuar1 &st * t+e new onsumer lassation law beame effeti"e
% Italian onsumer assoiations announedthe# would launh lass ations for some0,000 small Italian in"estors who laimthe# ha"e been 5heated> b# banks whosold them 9rgentinian bonds
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
13/25
Other !artii!ants of lass ation
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
14/25
T%E TE('
The Italian law has no retroati"eeffet, The Class 9tion 9t allowslaims based on torts ourring
a(ter A!'!st +-3 &,
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
15/25
2IRST RESU3TS
In less than a #ear, si6 signifiant lass ationlawsuits ha"e been filed against both Italianand foreign defendants, making Ital#@s numberof lass ation lawsuits high in om!arison toother ountries with reentl# introdued lassation laws.
9t least two of the ases seek e6tremel# high
damages, totaling H.+ billion together
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
16/25
2EATURES
T+e -lass a-tion la4 is t+e first la4 in Ital1 to
provide for monetar1 dama5es in a -lass a-tion/ as
previous la4s onl1 allo4ed for in6un-tions/ mar,in5
e7traordinar1 -+an5e in t+e Italian liti5ations1stem.
T+ese la4suits are limited to four t1pes of -ases8
%-ontra-ts/
%produ-t lia!ilit1/
%anti*-ompetitive 9anti*trust: pra-ti-es/
%and unfair -ommer-ial pra-ti-es.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
17/25
T#E DI22EREN"E 2R$M T#E US 3A;
The law differs from the 3.'. Federal(ule of Ci"il Proedure +/- in a number of areas, e.g., more
restriti"e lass ertifiation !roess an 5o!t8in> basis no diso"er# absene of !uniti"e damages.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
18/25
NEATIVE TRENDS
Consumer assoiations are !roati"el# looking for lassation o!!ortunities and are ad"ertising to attrat and 5reruit> !otential !laintiffs. Jut the# are not atual!laintiffs.
'o it is not lear- %OK and 9T K%9T (9TE the onsumer assoiationswill be 5om!ensated> for their lass ation work
%OK and %OK 3C% the# will !a# the onsumers
Do the onsumer assoiations will ad"oate thes!eifi interests of the lass of !laintiffs the# re!resent,or will !ursue their own interests and$or the interests oftheir members as a wholeL
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
19/25
WHO MAY FILE?
Entities that can act on ehal! o!
the "lainti!! 8
% "onsumer asso-iation or -ommittee 4it+nation4ide presen-e
% "onsumer
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
20/25
The "roceeding
#$ %tage8 Admissi!ilit1The class action is dee&ed inad&issile i! 8
% T+e -laim is unfounded
% T+ere is -onfli-t of interest% T+e ri5+ts infri5ed upon are not
+omo5enous
% T+e lead plaintif is una!le to ade=uatel1represent t+e interest of t+e -lass
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
21/25
#$ %tage' Ad&issiilit(
T+e lead plaintiff must !e a -onsumer
T+e lead plaintiff must +ave >an interestin t+e suit?
The "hase ends with a co)rt decision
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
22/25
*)licit( and o"t+ins
% Pu!li- dissemination of t+e admissi!ilit1
findin5
% A deadline for optin5 in is settled
% Mem!ers must affirmativel1 opt in to t+e
-lass
% De-ision on lia!ilit1 and dama5es -annot !e -+an5ed after t+e optin5 in.
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
23/25
@ Sta5e' Liailit( and ,a&ages
% 3ia!ilit1 and dama5es are determined
The co)rt s"eci!ies8% Dama5e amount
% Uniforml1 appli-a!le -riterion for ea-+
individual -laim
% No provision for punitive dama5es
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
24/25
Final considerations
% Italian -onsumer asso-iation -is a -is US
plaintiff la4 firms
% Italian -onsumer asso-iation +ave t+e
possi!ilit1 to s+ape t+e la4
% What.s ne/t?
8/19/2019 09 Lezione (Class Action)
25/25