ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒè¡šæ ãšæ åè¡šçŸã«é¢ããç 究
ç波倧åŠ
å³æžé€šæ å ±ã¡ãã£ã¢ç 究ç§
2019幎03æå°æ± ãæ çŸ
ç® æ¬¡
第 1ç« ã¯ããã« 11.1 ç 究èæ¯ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 ç 究ç®ç . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.3 æ¬è«æã®æ§æ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
第 2ç« é¢é£ç 究 32.1 æ åã®åé¡ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32.2 æ åãšè¡šæ ãçµã³ã€ããç 究 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.3 è¡šæ ã«ãããç® . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.3.1 èŠç·æ¹å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.3.2 èŠç·éãç¬ç® . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42.3.3 ç®ã®éãå ·å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.4 ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã«ãããç®ã®ããŒãã«ããè¡šæ ã¥ã . . . . . . . 52.5 ãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.5.1 èœé¢ç 究 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52.5.2 æŒæãšããŠã®è¡šæ ã¥ã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.6 æ¬ç 究ã®äœçœ®ä»ã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
第 3ç« æ åæœåºãšéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ 73.1 ç 究察象 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73.2 æ åæœåºã®åºæº . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
3.2.1 ã¯ã³ã·ã§ãã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83.2.2 ã¯ããŒãºã¢ãã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83.2.3 äž¡ç®ãåã£ãŠããç®æ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93.2.4 ãã£ãã¯ã¹ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93.2.5 äŸå€ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
3.3 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93.3.1 éçŒåºŠã®å®çŸ© . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93.3.2 è©äŸ¡æ¹æ³ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103.3.3 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®çµæ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
第 4ç« æ åã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å® 134.1 å®éšç®ç . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134.2 å®éšåå è . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134.3 æ©æãšç°å¢ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134.4 䜿çšå°ºåºŠ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134.5 ã¿ã¹ã¯å 容 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134.6 åºæ¿æ å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 144.7 å®éšæé . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
i
4.8 å®éšçµæ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
第 5ç« çµæãšèå¯ 175.1 èŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã®ç·åœ¢ååž°åæ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175.2 仮説ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åã®å ±éç¹ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175.3 éçŒåºŠãè¡šçŸããŠããããš . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185.4 æ åã®æœåºåºæºã®åŠ¥åœæ§ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195.5 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®æ¹æ³ã®åŠ¥åœæ§ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 215.6 èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ã®åŠ¥åœæ§ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
第 6ç« ä»åŸã®å±æ 236.1 ç 究察象ã®æ¡å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236.2 ã¹ããŒãªãŒã®å 容ã«ããèŠéåºŠè¡šçŸ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236.3 éçŒåºŠã®è©äŸ¡æ¹æ³ã®èªåå . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236.4 èŠé床ã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ã®èªåå . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
第 7ç« ãŸãšã 25
åèæç® 27
ä» é²A 被éšè å®éšåææž 29
ä» é²B 被éšè å®éšæ瀺 31
ä» é²C äºåã»äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒã 33
å³ ç® æ¬¡
2.1 次å 説ã«ããæ ååé¡ã®æš¡åŒå³ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
3.1 æ åå ã«ããã被åäœã®ãµã€ãºã®æš¡åŒå³ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83.2 éçŒåºŠã®å®¢èŠ³çææš . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93.3 éçŒåºŠå¥ æ ååæ°ã®ãã¹ãã°ã©ã . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
4.1 ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã®éã«çšãã Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã« . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 144.2 äºåã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154.3 äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154.4 åæ åã«ããã枬å®ããŒã¿ã®ä»£è¡šå€ã®æ±ãæ¹ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164.5 瞊軞ã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«éçŒåºŠããšã£ãæ åã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®æ£åžå³ . . . . . . . 16
5.1 瞊軞ã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«éçŒåºŠããšã£ãæ åã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®æ£åžå³ . . . . . . . 185.2 éçŒåºŠã®å€ (p)å¥æ£åžå³ïŒå·Šäžããé ã«éçŒåºŠã (1)2.0以äžïŒ(2)2.0ãã 3.0
以äžïŒ(3)3.0ãã 4.0以äžïŒ(4)4.0以äžã®å ŽåïŒ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
iii
第1ç« ã¯ããã«
1.1 ç 究èæ¯
é¡ã®è¡šæ ã¯æ åè¡šçŸã® 1ã€ã®æ段ã§ããïŒäŸãã°ïŒç®ã®åã«ããçžæãšå¬ãããå ±æãããæã«ã¯ãã³ããšåŸ®ç¬ããïŒæã£ãŠããæã«ã¯ããªããšçšã¿ã€ããïŒãªã³ã©ã€ã³ã¡ãã»ãŒãžã«ãããŠãïŒè²ã ãªè¡šæ ã®é¡æåã䜿ãïŒãäºãã®æ åãäŒããã£ãŠããïŒæ åã®åé¡ã«ã¯ïŒæ åãã«ããŽãªãšããŠæããç«å ŽãšïŒé£ç¶çãªå€åãšããŠæ¬¡å çã«æ
ããç«å ŽãããïŒEkmanãã¯ïŒã«ããŽãªèª¬ããšãïŒãæãã»åã³ã»æ²ãã¿ã»é©ãã»ææã»å«æªãã® 6ã€ã®åºæ¬ææ ãšïŒããã«ããšã¥ãè¡šæ ã¯æåãåœç±ãåãã人é¡å ±éã®ãã®ã§ããããšãæå±ãã [1]ïŒRussellã¯æ¬¡å 説ã®ç«å ŽããšãïŒçžŠè»žã«èŠé床ïŒèŠéã»ç¡ç ïŒãšæšªè»žã«æ å䟡ïŒå¿«ã»äžå¿«ïŒããšã 2次å ã®ã°ã©ãäžã«ææ ãè¡šã圢容è©ãããããããããšã§ææ ãåé¡ãã [2]ïŒãã㯠Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãšåŒã°ããŠããïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã®ç 究åéã«ãããŠã¯ïŒå ã«è¿°ã¹ããããªæ¢åã®ææ åé¡ã¢
ãã«ã«åºã¥ãïŒããããã®è¡šæ ã¥ããè¡ãªã£ãŠããäºäŸãããïŒäŸãã°Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã¯ïŒMIT Media Labã®ç 究ããŒã ãéçºãã Kismetãšããããããã®è¡šæ ã¥ãã«ãããŠæŽ»çšãããŠãã [3]ïŒäžæ¹ïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³å Žé¢ã ãã§ãªãïŒã¢ãã¡ãæ ç»ïŒæŒåïŒãã¥ãŒãžã«ã«ã®ãããª
ãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããŠãïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãæŒè ã®è¡šæ ã¥ãã¯éèŠã§ããïŒäŸãã°ïŒç»å Žãã人ç©ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒïŒã®è¡šæ ãã¹ããŒãªãŒã®äŒç·ã«ãªã£ãŠããããšããããïŒç»å Žäººç©ã®ãªã¢ã«ãªè¡šæ ã«ãã£ãŠïŒèŠèŽè ã¯ããåæ ãå ±æããã£ãŠã¹ããŒãªãŒã«æ²¡å ¥ããããšãã§ããïŒè¡šæ ã¯è€æ°ã®èŠçŽ ã«ãã£ãŠæ§æãããŠãããšèããããŠããïŒäŸãã° Ekmanãã«ãã
Facial Action Coding System(FACS)ã§ã¯ïŒè¡šæ ãèšè¿°ããèŠçŽ ãšããŠïŒé éšïŒçïŒç®ïŒéŒ»ïŒé ¬ïŒåã®è¡åã«æ³šç®ãïŒããããåé¡ãèšè¿°ããã³ãŒããçšæãããŠãã [4]ïŒãããã®èŠçŽ ã®äžã§ãïŒè¡šæ ã¥ãã«é¢ããç®ã®è¡åã«ã¯èŠç·æ¹åãçŒã®åããªã©ãããªãèŠçŽ ãååšããïŒããããè€éã«çµ¡ã¿åãããšã§ïŒè¡šæ ã圢æãããŠãããšèããããïŒæ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ç®ã®åãã«ããæ åè¡šçŸã«çç®ããïŒãªããªãã°ïŒæ åè¡šçŸãæ åèªç¥ã«åœ±
é¿ãäžããèŠå ãæ€èšããæ°ã ã®ç 究ã®äžã§ãïŒç®ã®è¡åã«çŠç¹ãããŠããã®ã¯å€ãïŒçè èªèº«ã«ãèå³æ·±ãç 究é åã ããã§ããïŒãã£ãºããŒã®ã¢ãã¡ãŒã¿ãŒãïŒäººã®é¡ã®èŠçŽ ã芳å¯ãããã¡ã«ç®ã®åœ¢ã¯ãã€ãããã¯ã«å€åãïŒç®ã¯éåŒãªè¡šçŸæ段ã§ããããšã«æ°ã¥ãããšè¿°ã¹ãŠããïŒããããŒããŠã¹ã«çœç®ãã§ããã®ãïŒãã®è¡šæ ãè±ãã«ããããã ãšèªãããŠãã [5]ïŒãè¡šæ ãè±ãããšãããšïŒå€åœ©ãªè¡šæ ãæã£ãŠããŠïŒãããæ§ã ã«å€ããæ§åãæãæµ®ãã¶ïŒè¡šæ ãæ§ã ã«å€ããããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒã掻ã掻ãããšãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãçãŸããã®ã ããïŒå ã«è¿°ã¹ãïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãããŠæ åãåé¡ãããèŠé床ãã¯ïŒã©ããããã掻ã掻ãããšããŠããããè¡šãææšãšãèããããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã ãããïŒããã§æ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒéåŒãªè¡šçŸæ段ã§ãããç®ããšïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãããŠæ åãåé¡ããæŠå¿µã§ããïŒæŽ»ã掻ããšããæ§åã«å¯Ÿå¿ãããèŠé床ãã®é¢ä¿ãæ¢ãããïŒ
1
1.2 ç 究ç®ç
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ãã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ãããç»å Žãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã«ãããŠïŒæ åã®èŠé床ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã«ãã£ãŠè¡šçŸãããŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããšãã仮説ãæ€èšãããïŒãã®ä»®èª¬ãæ£ãããã° (1)ããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è¡šæ ããç¥èŠãããèŠé床ã倧ããã»ã©ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã¯å€§ããã, (2)ããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è¡šæ ããç¥èŠãããèŠé床ãå°ããã»ã©ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã¯å°ããããæãç«ã€ã¯ãã§ããïŒãã®ä»®èª¬ãç«èšŒãããã°ïŒRussellã®ææ ã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãããèŠé床ã®è»žã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠã«å¯Ÿå¿ããããšã«ãªãïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒ2013幎ã«å ¬éããããŠã©ã«ãã»ãã£ãºããŒã»ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã»ã¹ã¿
ãžãªå¶äœã® 3DCGã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çã[6]ããïŒã¡ã€ã³ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã§ããã¢ããšãšã«ãµã®è¡šæ ãèªèå¯èœãªã·ãŒã³ãæœåºãïŒæ ååºæ¿ãšããïŒæœåºããæ å矀ã«ãããéçŒåºŠãšïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã«ãã£ãŠæããã«ãªã£ãèŠé床ãšã®é¢ä¿ãç·åœ¢ååž°åæãçšããŠæ€èšããïŒ
1.3 æ¬è«æã®æ§æ
æ¬ç« 以éã®æ¬è«æã®æ§æã¯æ¬¡ã®ãšããã§ããïŒç¬¬ 2ç« ã§ã¯é¢é£ç 究ã玹ä»ããããšã«ããïŒæ¬ç 究ã®äœçœ®ã¥ããè¿°ã¹ãïŒç¬¬ 3ç« ã§ã¯ïŒç 究察象ãšæ ååºæ¿æœåºã®å 容ïŒéçŒåºŠã®è©äŸ¡ææ³ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒç¬¬ 4ç« ã§ã¯ïŒèŠé床ãæ å䟡ã枬å®ããããã®è¢«éšè å®éšã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒç¬¬ 5ç« ã§ã¯ïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã«ãã£ãŠåŸããã枬å®ããŒã¿ã®åæã®çµæãšèå¯ãè¿°ã¹ãïŒç¬¬ 6ç« ã§ã¯ä»åŸã®å±æãè¿°ã¹ãïŒç¬¬ 7ç« ã«ãŠãŸãšããè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
2
第2ç« é¢é£ç 究
æ¬ç« ã§ã¯ïŒæ¬ç 究ã«é¢é£ããç 究ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒãŸãæ åã®åé¡ã«é¢ããç 究ãè¿°ã¹ïŒã€ã¥ããŠïŒæ åãšè¡šæ ã®é¢ä¿ã«é¢ããç 究ïŒç®ã®é åã«ããæ åè¡šçŸã«é¢ããç 究ïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ãïŒãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ãã«é¢ããç 究ã«ã€ããŠçŽ¹ä»ããïŒæåŸã«ïŒæ¬ç 究ã®äœçœ®ä»ãã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
2.1 æ åã®åé¡
æ åã®åé¡ã«ã¯ïŒæ åãã«ããŽãªãšããŠåããŠæããç«å ŽãšïŒé£ç¶çãªå€åãšããŠæ¬¡å çã«æããç«å ŽãããïŒ
Ekmanãã¯ã«ããŽãªèª¬ããšãïŒãæãã»åã³ã»æ²ãã¿ã»é©ãã»ææã»å«æªãã® 6ã€ã®åºæ¬ææ ãæå±ãïŒããã«ããšã¥ãè¡šæ ã¯æåãåœç±ãåãã人é¡å ±éã®ãã®ã§ããããšãæå±ãã [1]ïŒ
Russellã¯æ¬¡å 説ã®ç«å ŽããšãïŒçžŠè»žã«èŠé床ïŒèŠéã»ç¡ç ïŒïŒæšªè»žã«æ å䟡ïŒå¿«ã»äžå¿«ïŒããšã 2次å ã®ã°ã©ãäžã«ææ ãè¡šã圢容è©ãããããããããšã§ææ ãåé¡ããïŒããã¯Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãšåŒã°ããŠãã [2]ïŒSchlosbergã¯çžŠè»žã«æ å䟡ïŒå¿«ã»äžå¿«ïŒïŒæšªè»žã«æ³šæã»æåŠããšãïŒæ¬¡å ã®ã°ã©ãã«é¡åçãããããããåç°ã¢ãã«ãææ¡ããŠãã [7]ïŒå³ 2.1ã¯ïŒæ¬¡å 説ã®æš¡åŒå³ã§ããïŒ
ã»æåãã
ã»å¬ãã
ã»é©ãã
ã»æºè¶³ãã
ã»ç©ãããª
ã»ãã€ããã
æãããã»
æã£ãã»
ããããããã»
æãã€ãªã»
æ²ããã»
ããããããã»
èŠéããã»
ç²ããã»
ã»ç ãã
å³ 2.1: 次å 説ã«ããæ ååé¡ã®æš¡åŒå³
3
2.2 æ åãšè¡šæ ãçµã³ã€ããç 究
ã«ããŽãªèª¬ãæå±ãã Ekmanãã¯ïŒFacial Action Coding System(FACS)ã«ãããè¡šæ ã®èšè¿°ã³ãŒããé¡åçã®ããŒã¿ããŒã¹ã®å ¬éãªã©ã«ãã£ãŠïŒèªèº«ããæå±ããæ åã®åé¡ãšè¡šæ ãçµã³ã€ããŠãã [4][8]ïŒæ¬¡å 説ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒSchlosbergã瞊軞ã«æ å䟡ïŒå¿«ã»äžå¿«ïŒïŒæšªè»žã«æ³šæã»æåŠããšãïŒ
次å ã®ã°ã©ãã«é¡åçãããããããåç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãã£ãŠïŒæ åãšè¡šæ ã®é¢ä¿ã説æãã[7]ïŒRussell㯠Schlosbergã®è«æãåŒçšãã€ã€ãïŒæ åãšè¡šæ ãçµã³ã€ããããšã¯ããŠããªããïŒRussellã®ææ ã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãå ã«ïŒè¡šæ ã®ãã¶ã€ã³ããããã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã®äºäŸãããïŒBreazealãã¯ïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããKismetã«é¢ããè«æå ã§ïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«äžã«è¡šæ ãè¡šãé¡åçãããããããããšã§ïŒããããã®æ åãå®ãïŒèŠèŠçãªè¡šæ ã«å€æããŠãã [3]ïŒ
2.3 è¡šæ ã«ãããç®
ç®ã®é åã«ã¯ïŒè¡šæ ã«åœ±é¿ãäžããæ§ã ãªèŠçŽ ãããïŒèŠç·æ¹åãèŠç·éïŒç¬ç®ïŒç®ã®éãå ·åãªã©ãæããããïŒæ¬ç¯ã§ã¯ïŒãããã®èŠçŽ ã®é¢é£ç 究ãè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
2.3.1 èŠç·æ¹å
èŠç·æ¹åã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒé»ç®ãçœç®ã®äžå¿ã«ããå ŽåãçŽèŠïŒé»ç®ãçœç®ã®ç«¯ã«ããå Žåãç®ããããšãïŒäž»ã«ãã® 2ç¶æ ã«ã€ããŠïŒç¥èŠãããæ åã被éšè ã®åå¿ã«ã€ããŠæ€èšãããŠããïŒçŽèŠã¯ãæãã»åã³ãã®ãããªèœåçãªæ åãè¡šãè¡šæ ã®èªç¥ãã¯ããïŒç®ãããã¯ãæãã»æ²ãã¿ãã®ãããªå¿é¿çãªæ åãè¡šãè¡šæ ã®èªç¥ãã¯ããããšããçµæãå ±åãããŠãã [9]ïŒãŸãïŒç°ãªã 2ã€ã®è¡šæ ãæ··ããé¡åçã«ãããŠïŒèŠç·æ¹åã®éã£ãå¥ã®åçã§ã¯ïŒèŠç·æ¹åã«ãã£ãŠç¥èŠãããããæ åãå€ãããšèšãçµæãå ±åãããŠãã [10]ïŒ
2.3.2 èŠç·éãç¬ç®
ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³å Žé¢ã«ãããŠè©±ãæã®èŠç·éïŒè©±çžæãã©ãã»ã©èŠãŠãããïŒãç¬ç®ã®åæ°ïŒãŸã°ããã®åæ°ïŒãïŒç®ã®åã®çžæã«ã©ã®ãããªå°è±¡ã圢æããŠããã®ãæ€èšãããŠããïŒCookãã¯ïŒäººéãïŒè¢«éšè ãèŠãéã«ãã£ãŠïŒè¢«éšè ããã®å°è±¡åœ¢æã«å·®ç°ãããã調ã¹ã [11]ïŒå€§æ£®ãã¯ïŒç¬ç®ã®åæ°ãå€ã話ãæã¯ç¬ç®ã®åæ°ãå°ãªã話ãæãããïŒè©±ãæã®å°è±¡ãåŠå®çã«è©äŸ¡ãããããšãå ±åãã [12]ïŒ
2.3.3 ç®ã®éãå ·å
ç®ã®éãå ·åã«ãã£ãŠçŒçã®è¡šåºããŠèŠããé¢ç©ãå€ããããšããïŒå°è¶ãã¯ïŒé»çŒã®åœ¢ç¶ãšç¬ãã®å€åããç»ååŠçã«ããè¡šæ èªèãè¡ãªã£ãŠãã [13]ïŒãŸãïŒç®ã®éãå ·åã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠãšãåŒã°ãïŒç¬ç®ãšãšãã«ç æ°æšå®ã®ç 究åéã§èŠé床ãææ¡ããããã«çšããããŠããæŠå¿µã§ãã [14]ïŒ
4
2.4 ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã«ãããç®ã®ããŒãã«ããè¡šæ ã¥ã
ãããŸã§äººéå士ã®ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ã«ãããŠç®ã®é åã®èŠçŽ ã«ããæ åè¡šçŸã»æ åèªç¥ã調æ»ãããŠããäžæ¹ã§ïŒè¿å¹Žã§ã¯ãããã®ææãïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã«é©çšããããããªäºäŸãããïŒããããã®è¡šæ ã¥ãã«ãããŠïŒããã«äººéããããšã¢ãŒã·ã§ãã«ãªè¡šæ ãã€ãããããïŒãšããããšã倧ããªããŒããšãªã£ãŠããïŒ
Mutluãã¯ïŒããããã®ASIMOã«æ§ã ãªèŠç·éãçšããŠè¢«éšè ã«ã¹ããŒãªãŒããªã³ã°ããããšããïŒè¢«éšè ãã¯ASIMOã®èŠç·éãå€ãã»ã©ïŒASIMOã®è©±ãããæãåºãããšãã§ãããšå ±åãã [15]ïŒ
Johnsonãã¯ïŒè¢«éšè ã«ããããã®è¡šæ ã¥ãã®ã¿ã¹ã¯ã課ãããšã§ïŒäººéãã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã®è¡šæ ã«äœãæåŸ ããŠããã®ããæããã«ãã [16]ïŒããã«ããã°ïŒäººéã¯ããããã«å¯ŸãïŒæã£ãŠãæãšå¯ããæã¯ãŸã£ããäžãèŠãŠã»ããããšïŒé©ããæãšå¬ããæã¯ãŸã£ããäžãèŠãŠã»ããããšïŒæ¯ããŠããæã¯å³äžãèŠãŠã»ãããšããããšã芳å¯ãããïŒ
2.5 ãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ã
第 2.4ç¯ã§ã¯ïŒã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ããããã«å¯ŸããŠïŒããã«è¡šæ ã¥ããè¡ãããšããå è¡ç 究ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒæ¬ç¯ã§ã¯ïŒãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã§ã®ç®ã®é åã®ããŒãã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ãã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
2.5.1 èœé¢ç 究
æ¥æ¬ã®äŒçµ±èžèœã§ããèœã«ãããŠïŒæšåœ«ã®èœé¢ã¯è¡šæ ãå€ããããšãã§ããªãã«ãé¢ãããïŒè¡šæ ãããããã«èŠãŠãšããããšãå ±åãããŠããïŒèœåœ¹è ã§ããå³æ¹ [17]ã«ãããšïŒèœã«ãããŠã¯ãããããã»ããªããããããã©ã¹ïŒç §ãïŒã»ã¯ã¢ã©ã¹ïŒæãïŒããšããæäœã§è¡šçŸããŠããïŒãã©ã¹ã¯èœé¢ãäžã«åŸãïŒã¯ã¢ã©ã¹ã¯èœé¢ãäžã«åŸããïŒãã®åŸãã«ããïŒæšåœ«ã®èœé¢ã®å°è±¡ãå€ããããšããïŒèŠ³å®¢ã¯èœé¢ãã€ãã圹è ã®è¡šæ ã®å€åãªã©ãæããïŒèœé¢ã«ããæ åèªç¥ã«é¢ããŠã¯æ§ã ãªç 究è ãå€é¢çã«ç 究ããŠãã [18][19]ïŒ
2.5.2 æŒæãšããŠã®è¡šæ ã¥ã
çŠç°ã¯ãŸã³ãæ ç»ã«ãããŠïŒãŸã³ã圹ã®æŒè ãããã«çŒå·®ããŠãããã«ã€ããŠå ±åããŠãã [20]ïŒã¯ã©ãã·ãã¯ãªãŸã³ãæ ç»ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒæŒè ãç®ãèŠéãïŒç¬ããå°ãªãããããšã«ãããŸã³ãã®äžæ°å³ããæŒããããŠããïŒãŸãïŒããäœåã§ã¯ïŒæ¯é è ã§ãããã©ãã¥ã©ã女æ§ã«åªè¡ããããŠãŸã³ããžãšå€èº«ãããã·ãŒã³ãããïŒããã§ã¯ãã©ãã¥ã©æŒè ã®ç®ã«å匷ããç®ããã®å ç·ãè¡šçŸãããŠããäžæ¹ïŒå¯Ÿç §çã«åªè¡ã«ããããã女æ§ã¯ïŒãã®ç®ã®èŒãã®ãªããåãã®å°ãªãã«ãã£ãŠïŒè¢«æ¯é æãæŒåºãããŠããïŒ
2.6 æ¬ç 究ã®äœçœ®ä»ã
ç®ã®è¡åã«ããè¡šæ ã«é¢ããå è¡ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒèŠç·æ¹åãèŠç·éãªã©ã®èŠçŽ ã«ããæ åè¡šçŸããã®å¹æã«ã€ããŠè°è«ãããŠããïŒéçŒåºŠã¯ç æ°è¡šæ ã«é¢ããèŠçŽ ãšããŠïŒèŠé床æšå®ã®åéã§çšããããŠããæŠå¿µã§ããïŒããããªããïŒæ åè¡šçŸã«ãããå¹æã«ã
5
ããŠã¯,éçŒåºŠãšèŠé床ã®é¢ä¿ã¯è°è«ãããŠããªãã£ãïŒããã§ïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠïŒRussellã®ææ åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãããèŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã®é¢ä¿ãæ€èšãããïŒãŸãïŒå è¡ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒããåæ»ãªã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ã®æ¯æŽããã®ããŒãºã®ããïŒ
è¡šæ ã䌎ã察人ã³ãã¥ãã±ãŒã·ã§ã³ã«ã€ããŠèªãããããšãå€ãïŒãã®äžæ¹ã§ïŒã¢ãã¡ãæ ç»ãªã©ã®ãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããŠãïŒç»å Žäººç©ã«ææ ç§»å ¥ãããïŒãã®äžç芳ãžæ²¡å ¥æãæãããããéã«ïŒç»å Žäººç©ã®è¡šæ ã¥ãã¯éåžžã«éèŠãªèŠçŽ ã§ããïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã¿ãŒã®æåæ¬ãæŒæã®æå°æžã«ãããŠèªãããããšããããã©ïŒåŠè¡çã«ç 究ãããŠããäŸã¯å€ããªãïŒããã§ïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒãšã³ã¿ãŒãã€ã¡ã³ãè¡šçŸã«ãããè¡šæ ã¥ãã«è»žãããïŒãã®äžã§éçŒåºŠãã©ã®ãããªæ åè¡šçŸã«å¯äžããŠããã®ãæããã«ããïŒ
6
第3ç« æ åæœåºãšéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡
æ¬ç« ã§ã¯ïŒç 究察象ïŒæ ååºæ¿ã®æœåºåºæºïŒéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ææ³ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
3.1 ç 究察象
æ¬ç 究ã®ç 究察象ã¯ïŒ2013幎ã«å ¬éããããŠã©ã«ãã»ãã£ãºããŒã»ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã»ã¹ã¿ãžãªå¶äœã® 3DCGæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çããšãã [6]ïŒãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãã®ããã€ã³ã¯ïŒã¢ã¬ã³ããŒã«çåœã®ç女ã§ãããšã«ãµãšãã®åŠ¹ã¢ãïŒãã® 2人ã§ããïŒãšã«ãµã¯å¹Œå°æã«èªåã®æ°·ã®åã§åŠ¹ã®ã¢ããå·ã€ããŠããŸã£ãããšããã£ããã«ïŒèªåã®åãé ãããã«ãªãïŒã¢ããšè·é¢ããšãããã«ãªãïŒãããã 13幎åŸã®ãšã«ãµã®æŽå åŒã®æ¥ïŒã¢ããšã®ä¹ ã ã®åäŒã§å¬ããããªè¡šæ ãèŠãããïŒãšã«ãµã¯ã¢ããšã®å£è«ããã£ããã§ïŒèªåã®æ°·ã®åãå¶åŸ¡ã§ããªããªã£ãŠããŸãïŒè¡ããå±±ãžéããŠããŸãïŒã¢ãã¯å§ã®ãšã«ãµãšå解ããããã«ïŒãšã«ãµãéããå±±ãžãšæ¢ãã«è¡ããšããç©èªã§ããïŒãã£ãºããŒã®ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ãéžãã çç±ã¯ïŒ 第äžç·ã®ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³å¶äœã¹ã¿ãžãªã§
ããïŒäžççãªãããäœãå€ãïŒãã®æ åè¡šçŸã¯äžçäžã®å€ãã®äººã«åãå ¥ããããŠããããã§ããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãã®æ¬ç·š 1æé 49åã®äžããïŒã¢ããšãšã«ãµã®ç»å Ž
éšåãããªãã³ã°ã«ããæœåºããæ åãæ±ãïŒè©³çŽ°ãªæ åæœåºã®åºæºã¯ïŒç¬¬ 3.2ç¯ã«ãããŠèšåããïŒæœåºããæ å矀ã¯ïŒãããã以äžã®èŠçŽ ãã¡ã¿ããŒã¿ãšããŠæã€ïŒ
⢠æ å id
⢠éå§æéïœçµäºæé
⢠ç»å Žãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒ
⢠ã·ãŒã³æŠèŠ
⢠éçŒåºŠã®ä»£è¡šå€
éçŒåºŠã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒç¬¬ 3.3ç¯ã«ãããŠèšåããïŒ
3.2 æ åæœåºã®åºæº
æ¬ç 究ã§çšããæ å矀ã®æœåºã«ã¯ïŒã¢ããããã¯ãšã«ãµã®ç»å Žã·ãŒã³ã§ããããšã®ä»ã«ïŒæ£ææ§ããªãïŒæ¢åã®è¡šæ ç 究ã«çšããããåºæ¿ãšãªãã¹ãè¿ãç¶æ ã«ããããã«ïŒä»¥äžã«ç€ºãåºæºãèšããïŒ
⢠被åäœã¯ïŒæ åå ã§ã¯ã³ã·ã§ããã§ããããš
⢠被åäœã®ãµã€ãºã¯ïŒã¯ããŒãºã¢ããã§ããããš
⢠被åäœã®äž¡ç®ãåã£ãŠããããš
⢠æ åã®é·ãã¯ïŒãã£ãã¯ã¹ã® 1ã€åã§ããããš
7
ãã«ãã£ã®ã¥ã¢ã
ããŒã·ã§ããã
ãŠãšã¹ãã·ã§ããã
ãã¹ãã·ã§ããã
ã¯ããŒãºã¢ããã
æ åæœåºã«ãããŠäœ¿çšããéšåã
å³ 3.1: æ åå ã«ããã被åäœã®ãµã€ãºã®æš¡åŒå³
3.2.1 ã¯ã³ã·ã§ãã
ã¯ã³ã·ã§ãããšã¯ïŒããæ åå ã«ãããŠç»å Žäººç©ã 1人ã§åã£ãŠããåºéãæã [21]ïŒåèãŸã§ã«ããŒã·ã§ãã㯠2人ïŒã¹ãªãŒã·ã§ãã㯠3人ã§ããïŒå è¡ç 究ã«ãããŠçšããããŠããé¡åçãªã©ã®åºæ¿ã¯ã¯ã³ã·ã§ããã§ããããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«
ãããŠãã¯ã³ã·ã§ããã®æ åãçšããããšã«ããïŒããããªããïŒç 究察象ã®æ ç»å ã«ãããŠç»å Žäººç©ãåäœã§åã£ãŠãããã®ã¯å€ããªãã£ãïŒããã§ã¯ã³ã·ã§ããã«ã€ããŠããã«åºæºãèšããããšã«ããïŒã¢ããããã¯ãšã«ãµä»¥å€ã«æ ã£ãŠãããã®ãèæ¯ãšã¿ãªããã°ïŒä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãæ ã£
ãŠããŠãã¯ã³ã·ã§ããã ãšã¿ãªãããšã«ããïŒå ·äœçã«ã¯ïŒä»¥äžã®ãããªåºæºãèšããïŒ
⢠ä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãäžç·ã«åã£ãŠããå ŽåïŒãããšãïŒäŒè©±ïŒèº«æ¯ãïŒææ¯ãïŒç®é ããªã©ïŒããªãå Žåã¯ä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãèæ¯ãšã¿ãªãïŒ
⢠ä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãšã®ããåããããã·ãŒã³ã§ãïŒä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®äž¡ç®ãåã£ãŠããªããã°ïŒç 究察象ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãšåã£ãŠãããããªã·ãŒã³ã§ãïŒä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã¯èæ¯ãšã¿ãªãïŒ
3.2.2 ã¯ããŒãºã¢ãã
ã¯ããŒãºã¢ããã¯ïŒæ åå ã«ãããŠè¢«åäœã®è©ããäžã®éšåãåã£ãŠããã·ã§ãããããã¯ã«ããã®ããšãæãïŒè¡šæ ã®å è¡ç 究ã«ãããŠïŒåºæ¿ãšããŠçšããããé¡åççã§ã¯ïŒéŠããäžãåãããã®ãå€ãããïŒãã®ãããªåºæºãå®ããïŒå³ 3.1ã¯ïŒåæžå ã«ããã被åäœã®ãµã€ãºã®æš¡åŒå³ãæ¹å®ãããã®ã§ããïŒãæ åå¶äœå ¥é: èŠããããšãžã®ãã¡ãŒã¹ãã¹ããããã«ããã被åäœãµã€ãºãšãã®å称ã®å®çŸ©ãåèã«ãã [22]ïŒ
8
100%75%50%25%00%éçŒåºŠ
åçã¹ã±ãŒã« 1 ïŒ ïŒ ïŒ ïŒ
éçŒåºŠ
åçã¹ã±ãŒã«
å³ 3.2: éçŒåºŠã®å®¢èŠ³çææš
3.2.3 äž¡ç®ãåã£ãŠããç®æ
å è¡ç 究ã«ãããŠè¢«éšè å®éšã«çšããç»ååºæ¿ãæ ååºæ¿ã«ãããŠïŒæ£é¢é¡ã®é¡åçãçšããããŠããããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã被åäœã®äž¡ç®ãåã£ãŠããç®æãåºæºãšããïŒ
3.2.4 ãã£ãã¯ã¹
ãã£ãã¯ã¹ã¯ïŒæ åã«ãããŠã«ã¡ã©ãå®äœçœ®ã§ããåºéïŒã€ãŸããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãã¡ãã¿ãŠããèŠç¹ãåãäœçœ®ã§ããåºéã®ããšãæãïŒå è¡ç 究ã®åºæ¿ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒã«ã¡ã©ã¯å®äœçœ®ã§ããåºæ¿ãå€ãã£ããããã®åºæºãèšããïŒæ åãæœåºããéã«ã¯ïŒåãã·ãŒã³å ã§ãã«ã¡ã©ã®äœçœ®ãåãæ¿ãããªãåºéãããªãã³ã°ããïŒ
3.2.5 äŸå€
åé ãŸã§ã§è¿°ã¹ãåºæºãæºãããŠããŠãïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒããã€ãããã¯ã«ç§»åããã·ãŒã³ã¯é€å€ããïŒãŸãïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è¡šæ ãæããã«ãã€ãããã¯ã«å€åããæ åã¯ïŒååãªé·ãã®æ åã§ããã°è¡šæ ãåãæ¿ããéšåã§ããªãã³ã°ãïŒ1ã€ã®æ åãè€æ°ã®å¥ã®æ åãšããïŒ
以äžã®åºæºãçšãïŒæ ç»ãã 75åã®æ åãæœåºã§ããïŒãããã®æ åã®é·ãã¯ãããã2 ⌠7ç§çšåºŠã®ãã®ã§ããïŒ
3.3 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡
æ¬ç¯ã§ã¯ïŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãããæœåºãã 75åã®æ åã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠãè©äŸ¡ããåºæºãšãã®æ¹æ³ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
3.3.1 éçŒåºŠã®å®çŸ©
éçŒåºŠã¯ïŒç®ãã©ã®ãããèŠéããŠããããè¡šã尺床ãšããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒæ ç»ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, 100%ã® 5段éã§å®çŸ©ããããšã«ããïŒéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®éã«åå è ã¯ïŒå³ 3.2ãïŒéçŒåºŠã枬ã客芳çææšãšããŠäœ¿çšããïŒãã®å³
㯠Akroutã [23]ã«ãããã®ãæ¹å€ããŠäœ¿çšããïŒéçŒåºŠã®è©äŸ¡æ¹æ³ã¯ïŒç¬¬ 3.3.2é ã«ãããŠèšåããïŒ
9
å³ 3.3: éçŒåºŠå¥ æ ååæ°ã®ãã¹ãã°ã©ã
3.3.2 è©äŸ¡æ¹æ³
éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã«ã¯ïŒå šäœã§ 5åã®æŽçŒè ïŒç·æ§ 3åïŒå¥³æ§ 2åïŒãåå ããïŒåå è ã¯ããŒãœãã«ã³ã³ãã¥ãŒã¿ (MacBook Pro 13ã€ã³ã)ãéããŠæ åãèŠèŽãïŒããŒããŒããçšããŠéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ãè¡ãïŒèŠèŽããæ åã¯ïŒèŠèŠæ å ±ã®ã¿ã§é³å£°ã¯å«ããªãã£ãïŒéçŒåºŠã®å®çŸ©ãè©äŸ¡æ¹æ³ã«ã€ããŠèª¬æããã®ã¡ïŒåå è 㯠10åã®ãµã³ãã«æ åã§ç·Žç¿ãããïŒãã®åŸïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠçšãã 75åã®æ åã«ïŒç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ãããããã«æ瀺ããïŒåå è ã¯åçãããŸã§ã®éïŒâpâããŒãæŒãã°äœåã§ãåºæ¿æ åãèŠãããšãã§ããïŒå
å è 㯠75åã®æ åã«å¯ŸããŠïŒæ åå ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã 1 ⌠5ã® 5段éããããŒããŒããçšããŠéžæããïŒè©äŸ¡å¯Ÿè±¡ã¯æ åã§ããããïŒéçŒåºŠãåçã«å€åããŠèŠãããã®ãååšããå¯èœæ§ããã£
ãïŒå€æã«å°ã£ãå Žåã«ã¯ïŒäžçªå°è±¡çã ã£ããã®ãããã¯ïŒäžçªè¿ããšæããã®ãéžæããããã«æ瀺ããïŒ
3.3.3 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®çµæ
æ ç»ããæœåºãã 75åã®æ åããããã«å¯ŸãïŒ5人ã®åå è ã«ããéçŒåºŠã®è©äŸ¡å€ãåŸãããšãã§ããïŒãããã®å€ã®å¹³åå€ããã®æ åã«ãããéçŒåºŠã®ä»£è¡šå€ãšããïŒè¡š 3.1ãšè¡š 3.2ã«ïŒæœåºããæ åã®ãªã¹ãã瀺ãïŒãŸãïŒå³ 3.3ã¯éçŒåºŠå¥ã®æ åã®åæ°ããã¹ãã°ã©ã ã«ãããã®ã§ããïŒéçŒåºŠã 50%以
äžã«è©äŸ¡ãããæ åãïŒå šäœã® 8å²ãå ããŠããïŒ
10
è¡š 3.1: æ åäžèŠ§-1æ å id åãåºãæé ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒ ã·ãŒã³æŠèŠ éçŒåºŠ
1 00:10:52:26 ïœ 00:10:57:27 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã®éšå±ãå°ããã¢ã 2.22 00:16:04:20 ïœ 00:16:05:20 ã¢ã åãé£ã³åºãã¢ã 5.03 00:18:05:28 ïœ 00:18:07:14 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåã«ã¯ã«ããã¢ã 5.04 00:19:23:10 ïœ 00:19:26:04 ãšã«ãµ æŽå åŒã§ç·åŒµãããšã«ãµ 3.85 00:19:34:24 ïœ 00:19:37:02 ãšã«ãµ æŽå åŒã§ç·åŒµãããšã«ãµ 4.66 00:22:11:28 ïœ 00:22:14:22 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµãšã¢ãã®ä¹ ãã¶ãã®äŒè©± 3.87 00:22:14:23 ïœ 00:22:18:08 ãšã«ãµ ãšã«ãµãšã¢ãã®ä¹ ãã¶ãã®äŒè©± 3.88 00:22:18:08 ïœ 00:22:19:20 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµãšã¢ãã®ä¹ ãã¶ãã®äŒè©± 3.89 00:23:14:04 ïœ 00:23:17:09 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåãšäŒè©±ããã¢ã 4.010 00:23:23:29 ïœ 00:23:25:07 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåãšäŒè©±ããã¢ã 4.011 00:23:26:26 ïœ 00:23:30:71 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåãšäŒè©±ããã¢ã 4.012 00:23:26:26 ïœ 00:23:37:20 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåãšäŒè©±ããã¢ã 3.413 00:23:39:26 ïœ 00:23:44:18 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåãšäŒè©±ããã¢ã 4.014 00:25:33:08 ïœ 00:25:34:23 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹çåã«ããããŒãºãããã¢ã 4.815 00:26:01:08 ïœ 00:26:02:25 ãšã«ãµ çµå©ã®å ±åãèããŠé©ããšã«ãµ 5.016 00:26:03:24 ïœ 00:26:05:09 ãšã«ãµ çµå©ã®å ±åãèããŠé©ããšã«ãµ 3.217 00:26:13:01 ïœ 00:26:13:27 ãšã«ãµ çµå©ã®å ±åãèããŠé©ããšã«ãµ 4.418 00:26:21:21 ïœ 00:26:25:03 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã説åŸããããšãããšã«ãµ 3.819 00:26:26:24 ïœ 00:26:29:25 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã説åŸããããšãããšã«ãµ 4.420 00:26:33:26 ïœ 00:26:37:20 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã®çµå©ãèªããªããšã«ãµ 3.021 00:26:39:20 ïœ 00:26:41:15 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã®çµå©ãèªããªããšã«ãµ 3.022 00:26:44:24 ïœ 00:26:49:14 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã®çµå©ãèªããªããšã«ãµ 4.023 00:27:02:01 ïœ 00:27:05:24 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã«èª¬åŸãè©Šã¿ãã¢ã 3.024 00:27:05:25 ïœ 00:27:08:20 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã«åãå»ãããšãäŒãããšã«ãµ 3.625 00:27:08:21 ïœ 00:27:10:25 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã«èšŽããããã¢ã 3.626 00:27:13:15 ïœ 00:27:15:29 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã«èšŽããããã¢ã 3.827 00:27:29:25 ïœ 00:27:31:18 ãšã«ãµ é ããŠããåãåºããŠããŸããšã«ãµ 5.028 00:27:37:25 ïœ 00:27:39:15 ã¢ã é©ãã¢ã 5.029 00:28:46:13 ïœ 00:28:48:03 ãšã«ãµ éããããšãããšã«ãµ 4.630 00:32:38:03 ïœ 00:32:44:08 ãšã«ãµ Let it GO 4.431 00:34:37:00 ïœ 00:34:43:18 ãšã«ãµ Let it GO 3.432 00:39:47:05 ïœ 00:39:50:03 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã説åŸããã¢ã 4.233 00:40:34:13 ïœ 00:40:41:14 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 3.234 00:40:59:18 ïœ 00:41:05:02 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 4.235 00:41:15:11 ïœ 00:41:17:29 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 4.636 00:41:27:29 ïœ 00:41:29:07 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 3.237 00:41:30:11 ïœ 00:41:32:29 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 3.638 00:41:35:13 ïœ 00:41:38:29 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«ç¶æ³ã説æããã¢ã 3.839 00:55:14:15 ïœ 00:55:16:18 ãšã«ãµ æã®ããšãæãåºããšã«ãµ 2.640 00:55:21:01 ïœ 00:55:22:29 ãšã«ãµ æã®ããšãæãåºããšã«ãµ 5.0
11
è¡š 3.2: æ åäžèŠ§-2æ å id åãåºãæé ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒ ã·ãŒã³æŠèŠ éçŒåºŠ
41 00:56:12:10 ïœ 00:56:17:17 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãã«å»ã£ãŠæ¬²ãããšé Œããšã«ãµ 3.842 00:56:49:05 ïœ 00:56:50:14 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ãããçå®ãèãããšã«ãµ 3.843 00:57:02:16 ïœ 00:57:04:28 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã«åž°ãããšèª¬åŸããã¢ã 4.244 00:58:01:18 ïœ 00:58:06:10 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ããè¿œãåºãããšãããšã«ãµ 2.445 00:58:10:00 ïœ 00:58:11:22 ãšã«ãµ ã¢ããè¿œãåºãããšãããšã«ãµ 2.246 00:59:31:20 ïœ 00:59:33:03 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ãããšååããã¢ã 3.247 01:01:39:01 ïœ 01:01:42:11 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã説åŸã§ããçŠãã¢ã 3.848 01:01:42:11 ïœ 01:01:43:14 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã説åŸã§ããçŠãã¢ã 4.849 01:01:59:20 ïœ 01:02:02:15 ã¢ã 髪è²ãå€ãã£ãããšã«æ°ã¥ãã¢ã 4.450 01:03:35:25 ïœ 01:03:39:00 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã®è©±ãèãã¢ã 4.451 01:04:30:20 ïœ 01:04:32:09 ã¢ã ãããŒã«ã«åºäŒãã¢ã 4.852 01:04:41:26 ïœ 01:04:43:05 ã¢ã ãããŒã«ã«åºäŒãã¢ã 5.053 01:05:04:28 ïœ 01:05:05:68 ã¢ã ãããŒã«ã«åºäŒãã¢ã 3.454 01:05:05:68 ïœ 01:05:07:08 ã¢ã ãããŒã«ã«åºäŒãã¢ã 4.855 01:06:48:00 ïœ 01:06:48:28 ã¢ã ã¯ãªã¹ããã«åŸ®ç¬ãã¢ã 4.256 01:07:36:04 ïœ 01:07:40:29 ã¢ã ãããŒã«ã®è©±ãèãã¢ã 4.857 01:13:02:25 ïœ 01:13:07:00 ãšã«ãµ éã§ç¹ããããšã«ãµ 2.058 01:13:09:28 ïœ 01:13:12:27 ãšã«ãµ éã§ç¹ããããšã«ãµ 3.059 01:13:17:29 ïœ 01:13:29:13 ãšã«ãµ éã§ç¹ããããšã«ãµ 4.860 01:15:26:03 ïœ 01:15:28:29 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹ãèŠã€ããã¢ã 3.661 01:16:12:04 ïœ 01:16:13:22 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹ãèŠã€ããã¢ã 4.462 01:16:45:06 ïœ 01:16:47:09 ã¢ã ãã³ã¹ãçšã¿ã€ããã¢ã 3.263 01:20:37:24 ïœ 01:20:41:12 ã¢ã ãªã©ããšè©±ãã¢ã 3.864 01:21:12:05 ïœ 01:21:13:25 ã¢ã ãªã©ããšè©±ãã¢ã 4.265 01:21:17:00 ïœ 01:21:19:03 ã¢ã ãªã©ããšè©±ãã¢ã 3.666 01:21:47:05 ïœ 01:21:49:29 ã¢ã ãªã©ããšè©±ãã¢ã 4.067 01:23:16:13 ïœ 01:23:18:09 ã¢ã å¹éªã®äžãæ©ãã¢ã 1.668 01:24:48:14 ïœ 01:24:50:18 ã¢ã å¹éªã®äžãæ©ãã¢ã 1.069 01:25:23:16 ïœ 01:25:28:10 ãšã«ãµ æŸå¿ç¶æ ã«ãªããšã«ãµ 5.070 01:26:08:19 ïœ 01:26:11:22 ã¢ã ãšã«ãµã®å ãžè¡ãã¢ã 3.471 01:26:39:03 ïœ 01:26:41:17 ãšã«ãµ æ³£ããšã«ãµ 2.272 01:27:54:09 ïœ 01:27:55:09 ã¢ã éæ³ã解ããŠããã®ãèŠãã¢ã 3.473 01:27:54:09 ïœ 01:27:56:02 ã¢ã éæ³ã解ããŠããã®ãèŠãã¢ã 5.074 01:31:24:29 ïœ 01:31:26:20 ãšã«ãµ æºè¶³ãããªãšã«ãµ 4.875 01:31:34:25 ïœ 01:31:36:07 ãšã«ãµ æºè¶³ãããªãšã«ãµ 4.6
12
第4ç« æ åã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®
æ¬ç« ã§ã¯ïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã®å 容ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
4.1 å®éšç®ç
æ¬å®éšã§ã¯ïŒæ ç»ããæœåºãã 75åã®æ åã«å¯Ÿã㊠Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«åºã¥ããææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãè¡ãïŒæ ååºæ¿ã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®å€ã枬å®ããïŒ
4.2 å®éšåå è
å šäœã§ 7å (ç·æ§ 5åïŒå¥³æ§ 2å)ã®æŽçŒè ãåå ããïŒèª¿æ»ã¯ 1åãã€è¡ã£ãïŒè¢«éšè ã«ã¯èŠå®ã®è¬éãæ¯æã£ãïŒ
4.3 æ©æãšç°å¢
ããŒãœãã«ã³ã³ãã¥ãŒã¿ïŒMacBook ProïŒãå€éšãã£ã¹ãã¬ã€ïŒ27ã€ã³ãïŒããã³å ¥åè£ çœ®ïŒããŒããŒãã»ããŠã¹ïŒã«æ¥ç¶ãïŒãã©ãŒãªã³ã°ããŠäœ¿çšããïŒè¢«éšè ã¯æ€ åã«åº§ã£ãç¶æ ã§ïŒæºäžã®ãã£ãºãã¬ã€ãéããŠåºæ¿æ åãèŠèŽããïŒåçããéã«ã¯ïŒå€éšæ¥ç¶ãããããŒããŒããšããŠã¹ã䜿çšããïŒ
4.4 䜿çšå°ºåºŠ
ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã«çšãã尺床ã«ã¯ïŒåœ¢å®¹è©ãçšããæ¹æ³ããåã³ããæãããªã©ã®ææ ã«ããŽãªããéžæãããæ¹æ³ãªã©ãææ¡ãããŠããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒåºæ¿æ åã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã«ããã尺床ã«ã¯ïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ãããŠææ ã次å çã«åé¡ããããã«çšããããèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãçšããïŒ
Russellã¯ææ¡ããåç°ã¢ãã«ãšåã次å ã§ææ ã枬ãããã®å°ºåºŠãšã㊠Affect Gridãææ¡ããŠãã [24]ïŒAffect Gridã¯ïŒåç°ã¢ãã«ã 9 à 9ã®ãã¹ç®ã«å€æããŠïŒãã¹ç®ã®äžã«å°ãæžãå ¥ããããšã§ïŒææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãè¡ã尺床ã§ããïŒããããªããïŒèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãåæã«ææ¡ãïŒåçããªããã°ãªããªãããšãåçã®éžæè¢ã 9段éã§ããããšãïŒ75åã®æ åãè©äŸ¡ãã被éšè ã«ãšã£ãŠè² æ ãšãªããšèããïŒããã§æ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãå¥ã®è»žãšããŠïŒãããã 7段éã§è©äŸ¡ããæ¹æ³ãæ¡çšããïŒ
4.5 ã¿ã¹ã¯å 容
被éšè ã¯ïŒã©ã³ãã ã«æ瀺ããã 75åã®åºæ¿æ åã«å¯ŸããŠïŒèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãããããâ3ãã 3ãŸã§ã® 7段éã§è©äŸ¡ããïŒå®éšè ã¯ïŒè¢«éšè ã«ãã£ãŠåçãããèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ïŒåçæé (s)ãšæ ååçåæ°ãèšé²ããïŒ
13
å¿«äžå¿«
é«æŽ»å
äœæŽ»å
ã»è奮ãã
ã»æåãã
ã»åãã
ã»å¬ãã
ã»æ¥œãã
ã»é©ãã
ã»æºè¶³ãã
ã»ç©ãããª
ã»ãã€ããã
æãããã»
æã£ãã»
ããããããã»
ç·åŒµããã»
æãã€ãªã»
æ²ããã»
ããããããã»
èŠæããã»èŠéããã»
ç²ããã»
ã»ç ãã
ã»å®å¿ãã
å³ 4.1: ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã®éã«çšãã Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«
4.6 åºæ¿æ å
被éšè å®éšã«çšããåºæ¿æ åã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã«ãããŠçšãããã®ãšåæ§ã§ããïŒããããããã 2 ⌠7ç§çšåºŠã§ïŒ1ã€ã®åºæ¿æ åã«ã€ãïŒã¢ããããã¯ãšã«ãµã©ã¡ãã 1人ã®è¡šæ ãèªç¥ã§ãããã®ã§ããïŒ
4.7 å®éšæé
被éšè ã¯æ€ åã«åº§ã£ãç¶æ ã§ïŒPC ã®ç»é¢äžã«è¡šç€ºãããåºæ¿æ åãèŠèŽãïŒ1ã€æ åãèŠèŽãã床ã«æ åå ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãè©äŸ¡ããïŒä»åã®å®éšã§ã¯èŠèŠæ å ±ã®ã¿ã§ïŒåºæ¿ã«é³å£°ã¯å«ããªãã£ãïŒåå è ã¯åçãããŸã§ã®éïŒâpâããŒãæŒãã°äœåã§ãåºæ¿æ åãèŠãããšãå¯èœã ã£ãïŒ
èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã¯ããããâ3ãã 3ãŸã§ã® 7段éã§ïŒããŠã¹ã¯ãªãã¯ã§åçããïŒå®éšã®åã«ïŒåå è ã«ã¯ïŒPCã®æäœæ¹æ³ãšRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ã€ããŠèª¬æãïŒPCã®
ç»é¢äžã«è¡šç€ºãããæ ååºæ¿ã«å¯ŸããŠïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã«åºã¥ããææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãããããã«æ瀺ããïŒä»é² Bã«ïŒåå è ãžã®èª¬æã«çšããå®éšæ瀺ãæ²èŒããïŒãã®å®éšæ瀺ã«ãããã°ã¬ãŒã®éšåãïŒãã«ã¹ã¯ãªãŒã³ã§ãã£ã¹ãã¬ã€ã«è¡šç€ºããïŒåå è ã¯èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®è©äŸ¡ãè¡ã£ãïŒåçã®éïŒRussellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãæ¥æ¬èªã§è¡šçŸãããã®ãåå è ã®æå ã«çœ®ããŠããïŒ
åå è ã¯è©Šè¡ã®éãã€ã§ãåç §ããããšãã§ããïŒå³ 4.1ã«äœ¿çšãã Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã瀺ãïŒç·Žç¿ãšããŠïŒ10åã®åºæ¿ã«ã€ããŠææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãè¡ãïŒæ¬è©Šè¡ã§ã¯ 75åã®æ ååºæ¿ã 1ã»ãããšããŠïŒäŒæ©ãæãã§åèš 3ã»ããå®æœããïŒå埩枬å®ïŒïŒå®éšéå§åãšçµäºåŸã«è¢«éšè ã¯ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã«åçããïŒäºåã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容ãå³ 4.2ã«,
äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容ãå³ 4.3ã«ç€ºãïŒ
14
質åé ç® è³ªåå 容 ã¬ã¹ãã³ã¹
1. ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåã® èŠèŽé »åºŠã«ã€ããŠ
1.1 ããªãã¯æ¥åžžç掻ã§ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåãèŠãæ©äŒãå€ãã§ããïŒ
3: é »ç¹ã«èŠã 2: æã èŠã1: å šãèŠãªã
1.2 質å1.1ã§ãé »ç¹ã«èŠãããããã¯ãæã èŠãããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸãã æ®æ®µïŒã©ã®ãããªã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåãèŠãŸããïŒ èªç±èšè¿°1.3 質å1.2ã§åçããã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåã«ã€ããŠïŒãªãèŠèŽããããšæããŸãããïŒ
2. æ ç»ã®èŠèŽç°å¢ã«ã€ããŠ
2.1æ®æ®µïŒæ ç»ãèŠããšãã¯ã©ã®ãããªç°å¢ã§èŠãããšãå€ãã§ããïŒïŒè€æ°åçå¯ïŒ
3: æ ç»é€š 2: èªå® 1: ãã®ä»
2.2 2.1 ã§ãæ ç»é€šããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸãã æ ç»é€šã§æ ç»ãèŠãéã«ïŒäœãéèŠèŠããŠããŸããïŒãŸãïŒåº§åžéžæã®éã«ã©ã®èŸºãã«åº§ãããšãå€ãã§ããïŒ
èªç±èšè¿°2.3 2.1 ã§ãèªå® ããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸãã èªå® ã§æ ç»ãèŠèŽããéã®ç°å¢ãæããŠãã ãããïŒãã£ã¹ãã¬ã€ã®å€§ãããªã©ïŒ
2.4 2.1 ã§ããã®ä»ããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸãã ã©ã®ãããªç°å¢ã§æ ç»ãèŠèŽããŠãããæããŠãã ããã
å³ 4.2: äºåã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容
質åé ç® è³ªåå 容 ã¬ã¹ãã³ã¹
1. å®éšå ã§èŠèŽããæ åã«ã€ããŠ
1.1 å®éšå ã§èŠèŽããæ åãåºãŠããæ ç»äœåã«ã€ããŠç¥ã£ãŠããŸãããïŒ
3: èŠãããšããã 2: èŠãããšã¯ãªããç¥ã£ãŠãã1: èŠãããšã¯ãªããç¥ããªã
2. ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã«ã€ããŠ
2.1ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã¯é£ããã£ãã§ããïŒ
2: ã¯ã1: ããã
2.2 2.1ã§ãã¯ãããšçããå ŽåïŒã©ã®ããã«é£ããã£ããèªç±ã«èšè¿°ããŠãã ããã
èªç±èšè¿°
3. ãã®ä» å®éšã®å 容ïŒæ ååºæ¿ïŒãã®ä»ã«ã€ããŠïŒææ³ãæèŠãèªç±ã«èšè¿°ããŠãã ããã
å³ 4.3: äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®å 容
15
被éšè A 被éšè B 被éšè C 被éšè D 被éšè E 被éšè F 被éšè G
枬å®ããŒã¿
被éšè å ã®ä»£è¡šå€
被éšè éã®ä»£è¡šå€
1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç® 1åç® 3åç®2åç®
å¹³åå€
å¹³åå€
å³ 4.4: åæ åã«ããã枬å®ããŒã¿ã®ä»£è¡šå€ã®æ±ãæ¹
èŠé床
ããžãã£ã床
å³ 4.5: 瞊軞ã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«éçŒåºŠããšã£ãæ åã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®æ£åžå³
4.8 å®éšçµæ
æ¬å®éšã«ãããŠåŸãããæ åããšã®è¢«éšè 人æ°åã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®ä»£è¡šå€ã 1ã€ã«å®ããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠè¢«éšè ã¯ïŒ75åã®æ åã«å¯Ÿã㊠3åã®å埩枬å®ãè¡ãªã£ãïŒãã®ããïŒãŸã被éšè å ã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®å¹³åå€ã被éšè ã®ä»£è¡šå€ãšããïŒããã«ïŒè¢«éšè éã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®å¹³åå€ãïŒæ åã«ãããèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãšãšããŠæ±ãïŒå³ 4.4ãïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®ä»£è¡šå€ã®æ±ãæ¹ã®æš¡åŒå³ã§ããïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ãã©ãã»ã«ã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãšåãããã«ïŒçžŠè»žã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«æ å䟡ãšããïŒ
次å ã®ã°ã©ãã«ãããããããšå³ 4.5ã®ããã«ãªã£ãïŒãã®æ£åžå³ããïŒ75åã®æ å矀ã«ãããŠèŠé床ãé«ãç¥èŠãããã®ãã®ãå€ãã£ãããšãèªã¿åããïŒãŸãïŒãã¬ãã£ãã ãšç¥èŠããããã®ãæ¯èŒçã«å€ãã£ãããšããã®å³ããèªã¿åããïŒ
16
第5ç« çµæãšèå¯
æ¬ç« ã§ã¯ïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ãããšã«åæããçµæããã®èå¯ã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒãŸãïŒæ åã®æœåºåºæºãéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã®æç¶ãã®åŠ¥åœæ§ã«ã€ããŠãèå¯ããïŒ
5.1 èŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã®ç·åœ¢ååž°åæ
枬å®ããŒã¿ãããšã«æ å矀ã«ãããèŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã®ç·åœ¢ååž°åæãè¡ã£ããšããïŒèŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã«ã¯æ£ã®çžé¢ã¯èŠãããªãã£ã (R2 = 0.0445)ïŒå³ 5.1ã¯ïŒæšªè»žã«éçŒåºŠã»çžŠè»žã«èŠé床ããšãïŒæ åããšã«åŸããã枬å®ããŒã¿ãããã
ãããæ£åžå³ã§ããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ãã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ãããç»å Žãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã«ãããŠïŒæ åã®èŠé床ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã«ãã£ãŠè¡šçŸãããŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããšãã仮説ãç«ãŠãïŒå³ 5.1ã«ãããŠïŒç¬¬ 1象éãšç¬¬ 3象éã«ã¯ïŒãã®ä»®èª¬ãæºããè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åããããããããŠããïŒç¬¬ 1象éã«ãããããããæ åã®äŸãšããŠã¯ïŒã¢ããåã®æããé£ã³ããã·ãŒã³ããšã«ãµãé©ãã·ãŒã³ãå«ãŸããïŒç¬¬ 3象éã«ãããããããæ åã«ã¯ïŒãšã«ãµãã¢ããç®ãçªããŠæ¶ãæµãã·ãŒã³ãå«ãŸããïŒããããªããïŒä»®èª¬ãæºããè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åãååšããäžæ¹ã§ïŒç¬¬ 2象éãšç¬¬ 4象éã«ã¯ä»®èª¬ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åããããããããïŒããã§ïŒä»®èª¬ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åã®å 容ã詳ããèŠãŠããããšã§ïŒéçŒåºŠãšã¯
ç°ãªãèŠé床衚çŸã®èŠçŽ ãçºèŠã§ããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšèããïŒããã«ã€ããŠæ¬¡ç¯ã«ãããŠèå¯ããïŒ
5.2 仮説ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åã®å ±éç¹
æ¬ç 究ã®ä»®èª¬ã«ããã°ïŒèŠé床ãäœãïŒé«ãïŒç¥èŠããããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠãå°ããïŒå€§ããïŒè¡šçŸãããŠããïŒããããªããïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èŠé床ãäœãç¥èŠãããæ åã®äžã«ã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠã倧ããè¡šçŸãããŠããæ åãååšããïŒå³ 5.1ã®ç¬¬ 4象éã«ãããããããæ åã該åœããïŒãã®äžã«ååšããæ åã®äŸãšããŠïŒã¢ããšãšã«ãµãèŠã€ãåãã·ãŒã³ãïŒã¢ããä»ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è©±ãèããŠããã·ãŒã³ãå«ãŸããïŒãããã®æ åã«ã€ããŠä»¥äžã®ç¹ãå ±éäºé ã§ãã£ãïŒ
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èº«äœå šäœã®åãããã£ããã§ãã
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è¡šæ ãéçã§ããïŒå£ã®ééãå°ãªããªã©ïŒ
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®è©ãšãããäžãã£ãŠãã
ãŸãïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èŠé床ãé«ãç¥èŠãããæ åã®äžã«ã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠãå°ããè¡šçŸãããŠãããã®ãååšããïŒå³ 5.1ã®ç¬¬ 2象éã«ãããããããæ å矀ã§ããïŒãã®æ å矀ã®äžã«å«ãŸããæ åã®äŸãšããŠã¯ïŒãšã«ãµãšã¢ããèªåã®ææ ã蚎ããããã·ãŒã³ãã¢ããä¹ãç©ã«ãã£ãŠç§»åãããïŒå¹éªã®äžã§æ©ãã·ãŒã³ãååšããïŒãããã®æ å矀ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒä»¥äžã®ç¹ãå ±éäºé ã§ãã£ãïŒ
17
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
3.02.01.0 4.0 5.0
èŠé床
é çŒåºŠ
å³ 5.1: 瞊軞ã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«éçŒåºŠããšã£ãæ åã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®æ£åžå³
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãå šèº«ã䜿ã£ãŠåããŠãã
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®é¡ã®ããŒããããåãïŒçã®äžäžãå£ã®ééãæ¿ãããªã©ïŒ
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ç©çç°å¢ã®å€åãæ¿ãã
仮説ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åã®ããããã®å ±éé ããŸãšãããšïŒä»¥äžã®èŠçŽ ãèŠé床衚çŸã«é¢ä¿ããŠãããšèããããïŒ
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èº«äœå šäœã®åãã®æéå€å
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®é¡ã®ããŒãã®åãã®æéå€å
⢠ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®çœ®ãããç©ççç°å¢ã®æéå€å
æ¬ç 究ã§çšããèŠé床ãšããæŠå¿µã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãé«æŽ»åãäœæŽ»åããè¡šãææšã§ããïŒæŽ»åéãå€ããã°é«æŽ»åïŒæŽ»åéãå°ãªããã°äœæŽ»åã§ããïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èº«äœãé¡ã®ããŒãã»ç°å¢ã®å€åãå°ãããã°ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æŽ»åéãå°ãªããšæããããããïŒèŠé床ã¯äœãç¥èŠãããã ããïŒå€åã倧ããå Žåãåæ§ã®çç±ã«ãããŠïŒèŠé床ãé«ããšç¥èŠãããã ããïŒ
5.3 éçŒåºŠãè¡šçŸããŠããããš
æ¬ç¯ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠãã©ã®ãããªæ åè¡šçŸã«è²¢ç®ããŠããã®ããèå¯ãããïŒå³ 5.2ã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠå¥ã«çžŠè»žã«èŠé床ã»æšªè»žã«æ å䟡ããšãæ åããšã®è©äŸ¡å€ããããããããã®ã§ããïŒpã¯éçŒåºŠã®å€ãè¡šãïŒãã®å³ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒ(1)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯éçŒåºŠã 2.0ä»¥äž (⌠25%)
18
ã®æ åïŒ(2)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯éçŒåºŠã 2.0ãã 3.0ä»¥äž (25% ⌠50%)ã®æ åïŒ(3)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯éçŒåºŠã 3.0ãã 4.0ä»¥äž (50% ⌠75%)ã®æ åïŒ(4)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯éçŒåºŠã 4.0ä»¥äž (75% âŒ)ã®æ åãããããããïŒãŸãïŒ(1)ã®æ£åžå³ã«ãããŠã¯ç¬¬ 2象éãšç¬¬ 3象éã«ã®ã¿æ åããããããããŠãããïŒ
ãµã³ãã«æ°ãäžååãªããïŒãããŸã§è£è¶³ãšããŠæ²èŒããã«çããïŒæ¬¡ã« (2)ã®æ£åžå³ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒç¬¬ 1象é以å€ã®è±¡éã«æ åããããããããŠããïŒãã®äž
ã§ã第 2象éã«ãããããããæ åãæãå€ãïŒèŠé床ã®è»žã«ãããŠã¯é«äœã©ã¡ãã®å€ãåããããïŒæ å䟡ã®è»žã«ãããŠã¯ã»ãšãã©ã®æ åããã¬ãã£ãããã®å€ããšãïŒ(2)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã 50%以äžã®æ åããããããããŠããïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒè¡šæ ã«ãããŠïŒç®ãããŸãéããŠããªãå Žåã¯ïŒãã¬ãã£ããªææ ãè¡šçŸãããããã®ã ããïŒ
(3)ã®æ£åžå³ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒäžå¿«ããã®å€ããšãæ åãå€ããã®ã®ïŒèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®ãããã«ãããŠãïŒæ£è² ã®å€ã®äž¡æ¹ãåã£ãŠããïŒ(3)ã®æ£åžå³ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã 50ãã 75%ã®æ åããããããããŠããïŒãã®ç¯å²ã®éçŒåºŠã¯ïŒç®ãéããããéããããã®ç¶æ ïŒã€ãŸããã¥ãŒãã©ã«ãªç¶æ ã ãšèããããïŒãã¥ãŒãã©ã«ãªéçŒåºŠã§ããããããïŒä»ã®éçŒåºŠã®ã¬ãã«ãããïŒæ åè¡šçŸã®å¹ ãåºãã®ã ããïŒ
(4)ã®æ£åžå³ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒç¬¬ 1象éãšç¬¬ 2象éã«ãããããããæ åãå€ãïŒç¬¬ 3象éãšç¬¬4象éã«ãããããããŠããæ å矀ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒèŠé床ãâ1.0以äžã®å€ããšããã®ã¯ååšããªãïŒã€ãŸãïŒé«èŠé床ããã«è©äŸ¡ããããã®ãå€ãïŒ(4)ã®æ£åžå³ã«ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã 75ãã 100%ã®æ åããããããããŠããïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ç®ã倧ããéããŠããæã¯ïŒèŠé床ãé«ãè¡šçŸãããããããšãããã ããïŒãããŠïŒãããã®éçŒåºŠã®æ£åžå³ã«ãããŠã第 4象éã«ãããããããæ åãå°ãªãïŒç¬¬
4象éã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æ å䟡ãããžãã£ãã§ãããïŒèŠé床ã¯äœããšããããšãªã¢ã§ããïŒããã«é¢ããŠã¯ïŒæ¬¡ã®ãããªè§£éãèããããïŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãã®ã¹ããŒãªãŒã®ç¹æ§äžïŒã¢ãããšã«ãµãããžãã£ããã€äœèŠé床ã§ããããã€ããã ããæºè¶³ããããšãã£ãæ åãæããããšããªãã®ã ããïŒå ã«è¿°ã¹ãæ ç»ã®ããããã«ãããããã«ïŒæ¬äœã§ã¯ã¢ããšãšã«ãµãäžæºãæ±ããŠããããããïŒç©èªãåãããããªäºä»¶ãèµ·ããïŒã¢ãããšã«ãµããæºè¶³ããããïŒãå®å¿ãããŠããŸããšïŒç©èªã¯é²è¡ããªãïŒããããªããïŒæ¬äœã®è圹ã§ããéªã ããŸã®ãªã©ãã¯ïŒã·ãªã¢ã¹ãªã·ãŒã³ã®å€ã䞻圹ã®ã¢ãããšã«ãµãšç°ãªãïŒåžžã«ã®ãã³ããšããæ§åãèŠããŠããïŒãããã£ãç¹ãèžãŸãããšïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æ§æ Œã圹å²ã«ãã£ãŠïŒéçŒåºŠã®ã¬ãã«ããšã®èŠé床ã»æ å䟡ã®ïŒæ¬¡å ã°ã©ãã®æ§åãç°ãªãå¯èœæ§ãããïŒæ¬ç¯ã§ã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠå¥ã«èŠé床ã»æ å䟡ã®ïŒæ¬¡å ã°ã©ãã«ããããããããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒåã
éçŒåºŠã§ãæ§ã ãªæ åãè¡šçŸãããŠããããšãããã£ãïŒéçŒåºŠããšã«è¡šçŸã§ããèŠé床ã®å¹ ãæ å䟡ã®å¹ ã«éããããïŒéçŒåºŠã®ã¬ãã«ã«ãã£ãŠïŒè¡šçŸãããæ åã®é åãããçšåºŠéå®ãããå¯èœæ§ã瀺åãããïŒ
5.4 æ åã®æœåºåºæºã®åŠ¥åœæ§
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ç¬¬ 3.2ç¯ã§è¿°ã¹ãåºæºã«åŸãïŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çããã 2 ⌠7ç§ã®æ å 75åãæœåºããïŒãã®æ å矀ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒå³ 4.4ãå³ 4.5ãããèªã¿ãšããããã«ïŒéçŒåºŠã倧ããæ åïŒèŠé床ãé«ãæ åãå€ãïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®åãããã£ãïŒè¢«åäœã®ãµã€ãºã«é¢ããåºæºã«ãã£ãŠïŒæ ååºæ¿ãšããŠäœ¿çšã§ããæ åãçµãããŠããŸã£ãããšãïŒãã®åå ãšãªã£ãå¯èœæ§ãããïŒ
75åã®æ åã¯ïŒæ ç»ã®æ¬æ¥ã®é·ã 1æé 49åãèæ ®ãããšã»ãã® 1éšã§ããïŒè¢«åäœã®ãµã€ãºãã¯ããŒãºã¢ããã ãã§ãªãïŒãã¹ãã¢ãããå«ãããšã«ããã°ïŒæ ååºæ¿ã®éãå¢
19
(1) 1 †p †2
èŠé床
ããžãã£ã床
èŠé床
ããžãã£ã床
(4) 4 < p †5(3) 3 < p †4
(2) 2 < p †3
èŠé床
ããžãã£ã床
èŠé床
ããžãã£ã床
å³ 5.2: éçŒåºŠã®å€ (p)å¥æ£åžå³ïŒå·Šäžããé ã«éçŒåºŠã (1)2.0以äžïŒ(2)2.0ãã 3.0以äžïŒ(3)3.0ãã 4.0以äžïŒ(4)4.0以äžã®å ŽåïŒ
20
ããããïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠãå°ããæ åãèŠé床ãäœãç¥èŠãããæ åãå¢ããããšãã§ããå¯èœæ§ããã£ãïŒããããªããïŒè¢«åäœã®ãµã€ãºã®çš®é¡ã¯ãç»ã¥ãããã«ãããŠïŒããããéãæå³ãæã€ïŒäŸãã°ïŒèŠèŽè ã«å¯ŸããŠè¢«åäœã®çœ®ãããŠããç¶æ³ã®æåããããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒå³ 3.1ã«ããããã«ãã£ã®ã¥ã¢ãçšãã [25]ïŒäžæ¹ïŒèŠèŽè ã«å¯ŸããŠè¢«åäœã®è¡šæ ãååã«ææ¡ããããå Žåã«ã¯ïŒç»é¢ã«ããã被åäœã®é¡ã®å¯åºŠã倧ããããã ããïŒãããã£ã芳ç¹ã§ã¯ïŒæ¯èŒçã«ç»é¢ã«ãããŠé¡ã®å¯åºŠã倧ãããªããã¹ãã·ã§ãããæ ååºæ¿ã«å«ããŠããã£ããããããªããïŒè¢«åäœã®ãµã€ãºã«ããªãšãŒã·ã§ã³ãå¢ããã°ïŒè¢«éšè ã«ããéçŒåºŠã®æž¬å®ã®è»žã«ãã¬ãçããã§ãããïŒè¢«åäœã®ãµã€ãºã«ãããç»ã¥ãããã®å¯èœæ§ãïŒè¢«éšè ã«ããéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®æ¹æ³ãèžãŸ
ããŠïŒæ åã®æœåºåºæºã¯åŠ¥åœã§ãã£ããšèããããïŒæ åã®æœåºåºæºãå€æŽããŠïŒ1ã€ã®æ åããæœåºã§ãããµã³ãã«æ°ãå¢ãããããïŒç¬¬ 6.1ç¯ã«ãããŠè¿°ã¹ãããã«ïŒç 究察象ã«ããã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ãå¢ããïŒãµã³ãã«æ°ãå¢ããæ¹ãé©åã§ãããïŒ
5.5 éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®æ¹æ³ã®åŠ¥åœæ§
éçŒåºŠã®è©å®æ¹æ³ã¯ïŒã©ã³ãã ã«è¡šç€ºããã 75åã®æ åã«å¯ŸããŠïŒããããç»å Žãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠãå³ 3.2ãåèã« 5段éã§è©å®ãããšããå 容ã ã£ãïŒåå è ã«å£é ã§éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®é£æ床ã«ã€ããŠå°ãããšããïŒã100%ã ãšè©äŸ¡ããéçŒåºŠã®æ åã®åŸã«ïŒãã倧ããç®ãèŠéããæ åãããŠããŸããšïŒèªåã®äžã§è©äŸ¡ã®è»žãã¶ããŠããŸã£ãŠé£ããããšã®æèŠããã£ãïŒéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã«ãŠçšããå³ 3.2ã§ã¯ïŒäººéã®ç®ã®èŠéãå ·åã瀺ãããã®ã§ããããïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã«ãããç®ã®æ倧èŠéã床ãšã®æèŠã®ãºã¬ãçããŠããŸãããçããåé¡ã ããïŒããã«ããïŒå€©äºå¹æãåããå¯èœæ§ãèããããïŒéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®æ¹æ³ã¯ïŒéçŒåºŠ 100%以äžã®éžæè¢ãèšããããšã§ïŒè¢«éšè ã®éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã«ãããæºãããæžãããå¯èœæ§ãããïŒ
5.6 èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ã®åŠ¥åœæ§
å®éšåŸã«è¡ãªã£ãã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã«ãããŠïŒèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®ãããããã®ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãé£ããã£ããå°ãããšããïŒè¢«éšè 7人ã®ãã¡ 5人ããã¯ãããšçããïŒãã¯ãããšçããåå è ã«ïŒäœãé£ããã£ãã®ãå°ãããšããïŒä»¥äžã®ãããªæèŠãå¯ããããïŒ
⢠ããžãã£ããã¬ãã£ãã¯ãšãŠãçŽæçã§éžã³ãããã£ããïŒèŠé床ã¯ããã§ã¯ãªãã®ã§ïŒæ £ããã®ã«æéãããã£ã.
⢠èŠé床ãå€æããã®ãé£ããã£ãïŒ
⢠ç®ïŒçïŒå£ããããã«å°ããã€åœ±é¿ãããããïŒé£ããã£ãïŒïŒ
⢠ã¯ãªããå ã§è¡šæ ãå€åããŠãããšå€æãããã®ã®å€å®ã«è¿·ã£ãïŒ
⢠å¹éªã®ã·ãŒã³ãªã©ã³ã³ããã¹ãããããã®ãèæ ®ã«å ¥ãããã®å€æã«è¿·ã£ãïŒ
⢠Russellã®åç°ã¢ãã«ã§ã¯æ²ãããäžã€ãããªããïŒéãã«æ²ããã§ããã®ãæ²ãã¿ã®æ¿æ ãªã®ãã¯å¥ã®ããã«æããïŒ
⢠軞ã®è¡šçŸãšå¯Ÿå¿ãèªåã®æèŠãšãããŠããããšããã£ãŠïŒã«ããæ¯ã®è©äŸ¡ã«èªä¿¡ããªãããšããã£ãïŒäœåºŠããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒãç»å Žããæã«ïŒãã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ä»¥åç»å Žæã®å°è±¡ã«å·Šå³ãããã¡ã«æããïŒ
21
èŠé床ãšããæŠå¿µãçšããŠæ åãå€å¥ããããšãé£ãããšããæèŠããã£ãïŒãããã«æ å䟡ã«å¯ŸããŠèŠé床ã¯æ®æ®µéŠŽæã¿ã®ãªãæŠå¿µã§ããããïŒè©äŸ¡ãã¥ããã£ãã®ã ããïŒä»åŸã®å®éšã§ã¯ïŒå®éšåã®ã€ã³ã¹ãã©ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã«ãããŠïŒèŠé床ã«ã€ããŠããæ·±ã説æããããšã§ïŒè¢«éšè ã«èŠé床ãæ£ç¢ºã«è©äŸ¡ããŠãããæ¹æ³ã暡玢ããå¿ èŠãããã ããïŒãŸãïŒè¢«éšè ã«ããæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã«æ¯èŒçã°ãã€ãã®å€§ãããã®ãååšããïŒæŽ
å åŒã®æ¥ã®ã¢ããšãã³ã¹çåãšã®äŒè©±ã·ãŒã³ããã®äŸã ïŒãã®äŒè©±ã·ãŒã³ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒã¢ããšãã³ã¹çåãïŒäžã®å åŒã¯æ¬åœã«ã²ã©ããšå ±æãå
ãã·ãŒã³ã§ããïŒã¢ãã¯ïŒå°ãå¯ãããã«ç¬ããªããïŒæã¯ãšã«ãµãšãšãŠã仲è¯ãã ã£ãã®ã«ããæ¥ïŒçç±ãããããå¿ãéããããŠããŸã£ãããšããã³ã¹ã«äŒããïŒãã®ã·ãŒã³ã«ãããŠïŒã¢ãã¯æã®ããšãæãåºããŠå°ãå¯ããããªé¡ãããŠããïŒããããªããïŒç¬ã話ã«ããããã«ïŒãã³ã¹çåã«å¯ŸããŠææ³ç¬ããããïŒãã®æã®ã¢ãã®è¡šæ ã¯ïŒéå»ã®æ åãšçŸåšã®æ åãæ··åšããŠããïŒäŸã®ããã«ïŒè€æ°ã®æ åãæ··åšããŠãããšïŒè¡šæ ããåããæ åã®å°è±¡ãè€éã«ãªãïŒè¢«
éšè ã¯å€æã«å°ããã枬å®ããŒã¿ã«ã°ãã€ããçãŸããã®ã ããïŒè¢«éšè ã«ããæ å䟡ã®æž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®ã°ãã€ãã«ãã£ãŠïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒè¡šæ ã®è€éããå®çŸ©ã§ããå¯èœæ§ãèããããïŒ
22
第6ç« ä»åŸã®å±æ
æ¬ç« ã§ã¯ïŒä»åŸã®å±æã«ã€ããŠè¿°ã¹ãïŒ
6.1 ç 究察象ã®æ¡å
æ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠç 究察象ãšããæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãããæœåºããæ å矀ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒå³ 4.4ãå³ 4.5ãããèªã¿ãšããããã«ïŒéçŒåºŠã倧ããæ åïŒèŠé床ãé«ãæ åãå€ãïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ã®åãããã£ã.ãŸãïŒåŸãããçµæã¯ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãã«éããã®ã§ããïŒä»ã®æ ç»ã«ãããŠãåæ§ã«æ åæœåºãšå®éšãè¡ãïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ãå¢ããããšã§ããåºãç¯å²ã§ïŒèŠé床ãè¡šçŸããæ°ããªèŠçŽ ãéçŒåºŠã«ãããããªãæ åè¡šçŸãçºèŠãããïŒ
6.2 ã¹ããŒãªãŒã®å 容ã«ããèŠé床衚çŸ
æ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒé³å£°æ å ±ã¯å«ãŸãïŒèŠèŠæ å ±ã®ã¿ã§å®éšãè¡ãªã£ãããïŒèæ¬ã®å 容ããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æ§æ Œã«åºã¥ããæ€èšãããªãã£ãïŒèæ¬ã®å 容ãèæ ®ããããšã§ïŒç»å Žäººç©ã®ã»ãªããæ§æ ŒãèŠé床衚çŸã«ããããèŠçŽ ã
æ¢ããå¯èœæ§ãããïŒèæ¬ã«ãããèŠçŽ ããïŒèŠé床ãå€æã§ããèŠçŽ ãèŠã€ããã°ïŒç¬¬6.4ç¯ã§è¿°ã¹ããããªïŒèŠé床枬å®ã®èªååã«è²¢ç®ã§ãããšèããããïŒãŸãïŒãã¥ãŒãžã«ã«ã·ãŒã³ã BGMã®é³æ¥œã®ãã³ããæ²èª¿ãå å³ããåæãããããšã«
ãã£ãŠãïŒæ°ããªèŠé床衚çŸã®èŠçŽ ãéçŒåºŠã«ããæ åè¡šçŸãçºèŠã§ããã ããïŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãã«ãããŠïŒãšã«ãµãæŒããŠããã®ã¯ãã¥ãŒãžã«ã«å¥³åªã®ã€ãã£ãã»ã¡ã³ãŒã«ã§ããïŒãã®å¶äœçŸå Žã«ãããŠïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã¿ãŒã¯ã¢ãã¬ã³äžã®ã€ãã£ããé²ç»ãïŒãšã«ãµãæãéã®èº«æ¯ãææ¯ããè¡šæ ã¥ãã®åèã«ããïŒããã¯ãšã«ãµã«ïŒãããªã¢ã«ãªã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ãäžããããã ãšèããããïŒé³æ¥œã®ãã³ããæ²èª¿ãšèŠé床ãéçŒåºŠã®é¢ä¿ãæããã«ãªãã°ïŒãã¥ãŒãžã«ã«ã·ãŒã³ã®ããã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã®å¶äœã«ãããŠïŒæ°ããªæéãäžããããå¯èœæ§ãããïŒ
6.3 éçŒåºŠã®è©äŸ¡æ¹æ³ã®èªåå
éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®æžå¿µç¹ãšããŠïŒæç³»åã§ããæ åæ å ±ã«ãããéçŒåºŠãéçãªå€ã«å§çž®ããŠããããšãããïŒãã®ããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æŒæã®è§£å床ãäœäžãããŠããïŒäŸãã°ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ç¬ãã®ãéãã®åãæ¹ã¯ïŒæŒæã«ãããŠæå³ã®ããè¡šçŸã§ãããšèããããïŒç¬ãã¯äººéã®ççåå¿ã§ãããïŒãç®ãã±ã¡ãããããããšããããšã°ãããããã«ïŒæ åè¡šçŸã«ãããŠãçšããããåäœã§ããïŒéçŒåºŠã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ã®åé¡ã«å¯Ÿããé©åãªè§£æ±ºæ¡ã¯ïŒæ åããã¬ãŒã ããšã«æžãåºããŠãã£
ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ç®ã®éšåã®ãã¯ã»ã«æ°ãæ°ããããšã§ããïŒããããªããïŒæ åããã¬ãŒã ããšã«æžãåºããšè«å€§ãªéã®ç»åã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãäžã«ïŒå¯Ÿè±¡ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã¯æ åå ã«ãããŠ
23
æ§ã ãªè§åºŠãåããŠããïŒãã®ããïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã«ãã£ãŠæç³»åã®ãã¯ã»ã«æ°ãèšæž¬ããããšã¯ïŒè¢«éšè ã®è² æ ã倧ããé£ããã ããïŒããã§ä»åŸã®å±æãšããŠïŒéçŒåºŠæž¬å®ã®èªååãèããããïŒãã¯ã»ã«æ°ãèªåã§èšæž¬
ããæ¹æ³ãšããŠïŒç»ååŠçã®æè¡ãçšããŠè¡šæ èªèãããç 究åéã«ããæè¡ã®å¿çšãèããããïŒäŸãã°ïŒå ã®é¢é£ç 究ã§çŽ¹ä»ãããããªïŒé»ç®ã®åœ¢ç¶ããè¡šæ èªèãããæ¹æ³[13]ã暪é¡ã®åçããè¡šæ èªèããæ¹æ³ [26]ãæããããïŒãããã®ãããªæè¡ã䜿çšããããšã«ããïŒèªåçã«å®¢èŠ³çãã€æç³»åã®éçŒæ å ±ãåŸãããã°ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã俳åªã«ãããéãã®ãããªæç³»åã®æŒæè¡šçŸãå«ããè°è«ãã§ãããšèããããïŒ
6.4 èŠé床ã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ã®èªåå
被éšè ã«ããéçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã®èªååã«å ããŠïŒèŠé床ã®èªåå€å®ã«ã€ããŠãæ€èšãããïŒç¬¬5ç« ã§ãè¿°ã¹ããšããïŒèŠé床衚çŸã«ãããŠïŒéçŒåºŠã ãã§ãªãæ åã®å€åéãå¹ããŠãããšããããšãèå¯ã§ããïŒæ åã®å€åéã¯ïŒç»ååŠçã®æè¡ãçšããŠãã¯ã»ã«ã®å€ã®å€åéãšçœ®ãæããããšãã§ãããšããã°ïŒèŠé床枬å®ã®èªååã®å®çŸãå¯èœã§ããïŒèŠé床枬å®ã®èªååãå®çŸããã°ïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã®å¶äœã«ãããæ¯æŽãïŒé 絊äŒç€Ÿã«ããæ ç»ã®è²·ãä»ãã®è©äŸ¡åºæºã«ç¹ããå¯èœæ§ãããïŒ
24
第7ç« ãŸãšã
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ãã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ãããç»å Žãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã«ãããŠïŒæ åã®èŠé床ã¯ïŒãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã«ãã£ãŠè¡šçŸãããŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããšãã仮説ãæ€èšããïŒç 究察象㯠2013å¹Žå ¬éã®ãã£ãºããŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çããšããïŒãŸãïŒå è¡ç 究ã«
ç¿ãåºæºã決ããŠïŒæ ç»ãã 75åã®æ åãæœåºããããšãã§ããïŒãã®æ å矀ã«ïŒè¢«éšè 5人ã«ãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠè©äŸ¡ã 5段éã§è¡ãïŒãã®å¹³åå€ãããããã®æ åå ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®éçŒåºŠã®å€ãšããïŒæ¬¡ã«ïŒè¢«éšè 7人ã«å¯ŸããŠïŒæ å矀ã«ããããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®èŠé床ãšæ å䟡ããããã 7
段éã§æž¬ã£ãïŒèŠé床ãšæ å䟡ãå¹³åå€ã代衚å€ãšããŠåæ åã®å€ãšããïŒè¢«éšè å®éšã«ãã£ãŠåŸããã枬å®ããŒã¿ããïŒèŠé床ãšéçŒåºŠã®ç·åœ¢ååž°åæããããšã
ãïŒ75ååã®æ å矀ã«ãããéçŒåºŠãšèŠé床ã«ã¯æ£ã®çžé¢ãèŠãããªãã£ã (R2 = 0.0445)ïŒæž¬å®ããŒã¿ãèŠé床ã»æ å䟡㮠2次å ã°ã©ãã«ãããããããšããïŒä»®èª¬ãæºããè©äŸ¡ã
åŸãããæ åãšããã§ãªãæ åã® 2çš®é¡ãååšããïŒããã§ïŒä»®èª¬ãšç°ãªãè©äŸ¡ãåŸãããæ åã«ã€ããŠè©³ããèŠãŠãããšïŒèŠé床衚çŸã«ã¯æ åå ã«ããããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®æ§åãåšèŸºç°å¢ã®æéå€åãå¹ããŠããããšãèå¯ã§ããïŒãŸãïŒéçŒåºŠå¥ã«æž¬å®ããŒã¿ãåæ§ã® 2次å ã°ã©ãã«ãããããããšããïŒåãéçŒåºŠã§
ãæ§ã ãªæ åãè¡šçŸãããŠããããšãããã£ãïŒéçŒåºŠã®ã¬ãã«ã«ãã£ãŠïŒè¡šçŸãããæ åã®é åãããçšåºŠéå®ãããå¯èœæ§ã瀺åãããïŒä»åŸã®å±æãšããŠïŒç 究察象ã®æ¡å ãšèæ¬å 容ã®èæ ®ïŒãããŠéçŒåºŠãèŠé床ã®æž¬å®æ¹
æ³ã®èªååãæããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããçµæã¯ïŒæ ç»ãã¢ããšéªã®å¥³çãããåŸãããæ å矀ã«ãããŠèšããããšã§ããïŒä»åŸã¯ä»ã®æ åäœåãç 究察象ã«å ¥ããããšã«ããïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããè°è«ã«èä»ãããããïŒãŸãïŒæ¬ç 究ã«ãããŠã¯èŠèŠæ å ±ã®ã¿ã®èæ ®ã ã£ãããïŒèæ¬å 容ãå å³ããåæãè¡ãããšã§ïŒæ°ããªèŠé床衚çŸã®èŠçŽ ãéçŒåºŠã«ããæ åè¡šçŸãçºèŠãããïŒãããŠïŒéçŒåºŠãèŠé床ã®æž¬å®æ¹æ³ãç»ååŠçã®æè¡ãçšããŠèªååããããšã§ïŒå®¢èŠ³çãªæž¬å®ããŒã¿ãååŸãïŒããå¹ççã«è©³çŽ°ãªè°è«ãã§ããã ããïŒ
25
è¬èŸ
æ¬ç 究ãé²ããã«ããã, æå°æå¡ã®å¯ºæŸ€æŽåå çïŒæ¬ç 究宀ã®å¹³è³è²å çã«ã¯æ¥é ããäžå¯§ãã€ç±å¿ãªãæå°ãè³ããŸããïŒäž»æå°æå¡ã®å®éå圊å çã«ã¯ïŒåŠéšçã®é ããæ¥é ããæ§ã ãªçžè«ã«ä¹ã£ãŠããã ã
æè¬ããããŸãïŒæ åç 究ã«ã€ããŠè²ŽéãªãæèŠãè³ããŸããæ¬åŠå³æžé€šæ å ±ã¡ãã£ã¢ç³»ã®èŸ»æ³°æå çã«æè¬ããããŸãïŒæ¬åŠå³æžé€šæ å ±ã¡ãã£ã¢ç³»ã®æ£®ç°ã²ãã¿å çã«ã¯ïŒå®éšææ³ã«ã€ããŠè²Žéãªã話ãè³ããŸããïŒå®éšã«å¿«ãåå ããŠããã ããçæ§ã«ãæ·±ãã瀌ç³ãäžããŸãïŒ
LSPCã®çæ§ã«ã¯æ¥é ããæ§ã ãªçžè«ã«ä¹ã£ãŠããã ããŸããïŒçã®ãããã§å€§å¥œããªç 究ãïŒèªåããã楜ããç¶ããããšãã§ããŸããïŒæ¬åœã«ããããšãïŒãããŠïŒç 究ç掻ãéãäžã§å€§ããªæ¯ãã«ãªã£ã家æã Digital Nature Groupåšç±æ代
ã®ä»²éã«ããšã£ãŠãæè¬ããŠããŸãïŒ
26
åèæç®
[1] Paul Ekman and Wallace V. Friesen. Constants across cultures in the face and emotion.Journal of personality and social psychology, Vol. 17, No. 2, p. 124, 1971.
[2] James A. Russell. A circumplex model of affect. Journal of personality and socialpsychology, Vol. 39, No. 6, p. 1161, 1980.
[3] Cynthia Breazeal. Emotion and sociable humanoid robots. Int. J. Hum.-Comput. Stud.,Vol. 59, No. 1-2, pp. 119â155, July 2003.
[4] Paul Ekman and Wallace V. Friesen. Facial Action Coding System: A Technique forthe Measurement of Facial Movement. Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto, 1978.
[5] Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston. The Illusion of Life: Disney Animation. AbbevillePress, 1981 (Transl: in ã¹ã¿ãžãªãžããªïŒé«çå²ïŒå€§å¡åº·çïŒéŠåã»å€§ä¹ ä¿ã»ããŒãã¹.,ããã£ãºããŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ çåœãå¹ã蟌ãéæ³ â The Illusion of Lifeã. 埳éæžåº,2001).
[6] Frozen, United States: Walt Disney Animation Studios, 2013.
[7] Harold Schlosberg. The description of facial expression in terms of two dimensions.Journal of experimental psychology, Vol. 44, pp. 229â37, 11 1952.
[8] Paul Ekman and Wallace V. Friesen. Pictures of Facial Affect. Consulting psychologistsPress, 1976.
[9] Reginald B. Adams and Robert E. Kleck. Perceived gaze direction and the processingof facial displays of emotion. Psychological science, Vol. 14, pp. 644â7, 12 2003.
[10] Reginald Adams, Jr. and Robert E. Kleck. Effects of direct and averted gaze on theperception of facially communicated emotion. Emotion, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 3â11, 3 2005.
[11] Mark Cook and Jacqueline M. C. Smith. The role of gaze in impression formation. TheBritish journal of social and clinical psychology, Vol. 14 1, pp. 19â25, 1975.
[12] 倧森æ å, å±±ç°åšçŸé, å®®ç°æŽ. 察人èªç¥ã«ãããç¬ç®ã®åœ±é¿. 瀟äŒå¿çåŠç 究, Vol. 12,No. 3, pp. 183â189, 1997.
[13] å°è¶åº·å®, äžæ©çŸå ž, å°è¶å²å, äžäºæ倫, æŸæµŠæ ä¹, èæšçŠå€§. é»çŒã®åœ¢ç¶ãšç¬ãã®å€åããã®è¡šæ èªè. ç¥èœãšæ å ±, Vol. 23, No. 2, pp. 218â227, 2011.
[14] ææ¬å€§æš¹, é«éåå², äžææž å®. G-004 ç æ°åºŠæšå®ã®ããã®ç¬ç®çŸ€çºãåç¬ç¬ç®ã®ç¹åŸŽè§£æ (gåé:çäœæ å ±ç§åŠ,äžè¬è«æ). æ å ±ç§åŠæè¡ãã©ãŒã©ã è¬æŒè«æé, Vol. 13,No. 2, pp. 375â376, aug 2014.
27
[15] Bilge Mutlu, Jodi Forlizzi, and Jessica Hodgins. A storytelling robot: Modeling andevaluation of human-like gaze behavior. Vol. 518-523, pp. 518 â 523, 01 2007.
[16] David Johnson and Raymond Cuijpers. Investigating the effect of a humanoid robotâshead position on imitating human emotions. International Journal of Social Robotics,04 2018.
[17] å³æ¹ç. èœãžã®ãããªã: èœåœ¹è ãäŒããèœã®ã¿ãã. 淡亀瀟, 2006.
[18] Hiromitsu Miyata, Ritsuko Nishimura, Kazuo Okanoya, and Nobuyuki Kawai. Themysterious noh mask: Contribution of multiple facial parts to the recognition of emo-tional expressions. PLOS ONE, Vol. 7, No. 11, pp. 1â9, 11 2012.
[19] Michael Lyons, Ruth Campbell, Andre Plante, Mike Coleman, Miyuki Kamachi, andShigeru Akamatsu. The noh mask effect: Vertical viewpoint dependence of facialexpression perception. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, Vol.267, pp. 2239â2245, 10 2002.
[20] çŠç°å®äœå. <è«æ>ãŸã³ãã¯ããã«çŒå·®ãã. ãã£ã¢ãã¡ããŒã¹ â èžè¡ãšææ³ =Diaphanes: Art and Philosophy, Vol. 4, pp. 71â94, mar 2017.
[21] é»ç¬æ¿ç·. æ åã¯ãªãšãŒã¿ãŒå ¥éâãã³ãã£ã¯ã·ã§ã³æ åãå¿ã人ãž. ç§æè, 2009.
[22] éŽæšèª äžé, åå€åè. æ åå¶äœå ¥é: èŠããããšãžã®ãã¡ãŒã¹ãã¹ããã. ãã«ãã·ã€åºç, 2009.
[23] Belhassen Akrout and Walid Mahdi. Hypovigilance detection based on eyelids behaviorstudy. iJES, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 39â45, 2013.
[24] James A. Russell. Affect grid : A single-item scale of pleasure and arousal. Journal ofPersonality and Social Psychology, Vol. 57, pp. 493â502, 1989.
[25] æ¥æ¬æŸéåäŒ.  æ®åœ±èªæ¬. æ¥æ¬æŸéåºçåäŒ, 1980.
[26] Maja Pantic and Ioannis Patras. Dynamics of facial expression: recognition of facialactions and their temporal segments from face profile image sequences. IEEE Trans-actions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part B (Cybernetics), Vol. 36, No. 2, pp.433â449, April 2006.
28
ä» é²A 被éšè å®éšåææž
å®éšåææž ç 究ã®ç®çã»æ¹æ³ æ¬ç 究ã®ç®çã¯ïŒïŒDCG ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ è¡šçŸã®èªç¥ã«ã€ããŠèª¿ã¹ãããšã§ããå®éšã§ã¯, è€æ°ã®ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ãèŠãåŸïŒæå®ããããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ãè¡ã£ãŠããããŸããæ¬å®éšã§ã¯, ã¿ã¹ã¯ã®çµæããŒã¿ãä¿åãããŸãã å人æ å ±ãšããŒã¿ã®åãæ±ãã«ã€ã㊠å人æ å ±ã¯å³éã«ç®¡çã, ãã©ã€ãã·ãŒä¿è·ã«ã¯ååé æ ®ããããŸããæ¬å®éšã§åŸãããããŒã¿ã¯å人ãç¹å®ã§ããªã圢ã§åæã«çšããŸããããŒã¿ã¯ç 究ãçµäºããæç¹ãã 10幎éãç®åŠã«ä¿ç®¡ãïŒãã®åŸïŒå®å šãªåœ¢ã§ç Žæ£ããããŸããåŠäŒã»è«æçã§çºè¡šããå Žå, å®éšããŒã¿ã¯çµ±èšçãªåŠçãæœã, å人ãç¹å®ã§ããªã圢ã§çšããŸãã å±éºæ§ã»å¥åº·ã«äžãã圱é¿ã«ã€ã㊠æ¬å®éšã¯å®å šã«ååé æ ®ããŠè¡ããŸããå®éšäž, äœèª¿ãæªããªã£ãç, å®éšç¶ç¶ãå°é£ãªå Žåã¯å®éšãäžæããŠæ§ããŸããããŸã, å®éšäžã¯ãã€ã§ãäŒæ©ãåãããšãã§ããŸããå®éšã®å 容ãæ¹æ³ã«ã€ããŠãäžæãªç¹ãããã°, é æ ®ãªãæ åœè ã«ã声ãããã ããã å®éšåå è ã®æš©å©ã«ã€ã㊠æ¬å®éšãžã®åå ã¯èªç±æå¿ã§ãããŸã, äžåºŠåæããåŸã§ãåæãåãæ¶ãããšãå¯èœã§ãã, ããã«ããäžå©çã¯ãããŸããã
ç 究è ãããã³åãåããå ã«ã€ã㊠æ¬ç 究ã«é¢ããŠã®ã質åããæ¬ç 究ã«é¢é£ããŠäœããã®åé¡ãçããéã®ãåãåãã
ã¯ãäžèšã®ç 究責任è ãŸã§ãé£çµ¡ãã ããã
29
åææž
ç§ã¯ïŒç 究課é¡ãïŒDCGã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ç»å Žãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ è¡šçŸã®èªç¥ãã«é¢ãïŒç 究ã®ç®çãç 究ã®å 容ã»æ¹æ³ïŒãã©ã€ãã·ãŒã®ä¿è·ïŒèº«äœé¢ïŒç²Ÿç¥é¢çãžã®
é æ ®ïŒäžå©çåã³å±éºæ§ã«å¯Ÿããé æ ®ïŒåæããªãèªç±ã®ä¿éçã«ã€ããŠèª¬æææžã«åºã¥ã
ååãªèª¬æãåãïŒãã®å 容ãååã«ç解ãçŽåŸããŸããã®ã§ïŒç§ã®èªç±æå¿ã«ããæ¬ç 究
ã®è¢«éšè ãšãªãããšã«åæããŸãã
ãã ã説æã«ããã£ãéãïŒãã®åæã¯äžåã®äžå©çãåããããšãªããã€ã§ãæ€åã§
ãããã®ã§ããããšã確èªããŸãã
å¹³æ 幎 æ æ¥
æå±ã»è·åã¯åŠå¹Ž
é£çµ¡å é»è©±çªå·å㯠E-mail
被éšè 眲å
30
ä» é²B 被éšè å®éšæ瀺
ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã®æ¹æ³ã«ã€ããŠ
å®éšãå§ãŸããšä»¥äžã®ãããªç»é¢ããã£ã¹ãã¬ã€ã«ç»å ŽããŸã
â
â¡
â è©äŸ¡å¯Ÿè±¡ã§ããæ åã®è¡šç€º ã»ææ ãå€å¥ããŠã»ãããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ã¯ã³ã·ã§ããæ åã衚瀺ããããšãªã¢ã§ãã ã»æ åã¯ããããïŒïœïŒç§çšåºŠã®ãã®ã§ãã ã»ããïŒåºŠèŠèŽããå Žåã¯ïŒåç»çµäºåŸã«âpâããŒãæŒããŠèŠãããšãå¯èœã§ãã
â¡ è©äŸ¡ãå ¥åãã軞 ã»ã©ãã»ã«ã®ææ åç°ã¢ãã«ïŒæ¬¡ããŒãžã§è©³çŽ°ã説æïŒã«åºã¥ãïŒèŠé床ãšããžãã£ã/ãã¬ãã£ã床ã®ïŒè»žã§ïŒæ åå ã®ãã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ ãè©äŸ¡ããŠãã ããã ã»äž¡æ¹ã®å€ãéžãã ã確å®ãã¿ã³ãæŒããŠïŒâspaceâããŒã«ãã次ã®è©Šè¡ãžé²ãã§ãã ããã ã»å šéšã§78è©Šè¡ãããŸãã
â確å®ãã¿ã³
31
ã©ãã»ã«ã®ææ åç°ã¢ãã«ã«ã€ããŠ
ã»ã©ãã»ã«ã®ææ åç°ã¢ãã«ãšã¯ïŒèŠé床ïŒé«æŽ»åã»äœæŽ»åïŒã瞊軞ïŒããžãã£ããã¬ãã£ã床ïŒå¿«ã»äžå¿«ïŒã暪軞ã«ãšã£ãïŒïŒæ¬¡å ã®ã°ã©ãã«ææ ãè¡šã圢容è©ããããããããã®ã§ãã
ã»ä»¥äžã®å³ã¯ïŒã©ãã»ã«ã®åç°ã¢ãã«ãæ¥æ¬èªã§è¡šãããã®ã§ãã
ã»ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã¯ïŒä»¥äžã®ã°ã©ããåèã«è¡ã£ãŠãã ããã
32
ä» é²C äºåã»äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒã
ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãçšçŽ æ·»ä»è³æ 1
1
äºåã¢ã³ã±ãŒã (被éšè çªå·ïŒ )
ã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³æ ç»ã«ããããã£ã©ã¯ã¿ãŒã®ææ è¡šçŸã«ã€ããŠã®ç 究ã«åå ããã ãã
ãããšãããããŸãã 以äžã®èšåã«ãåçããã ããŸããããé¡ãããããŸããæ¬å®éšã«ãããã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã®
åçã®å 容ã«ã€ããŠã¯ïŒå³éãªç®¡çãè¡ãïŒç 究ç®ç以å€ã«ã¯äžå䜿çšããŸããã
1ïŒãèªèº«ã®æ å ± 1.1æ§å¥ïŒ 1.2å¹Žéœ¢ïŒ 2ïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåã®èŠèŽé »åºŠã«ã€ã㊠2.1ããªãã¯æ¥åžžç掻ã§ïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåãèŠãæ©äŒãå€ãã§ããïŒ
ïŒ é »ç¹ã«èŠã ã» æã èŠã ã» å šãèŠãªã ïŒ
2.2 2.1ã§ãé »ç¹ã«èŠãããããã¯ãæã èŠãããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸããæ®æ®µïŒã©ã®ãããªã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåãèŠãŸããïŒïŒç¹å®ã®ç£ç£ã®äœåã§ãïŒã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³ã¹ã¿ãžãª
ã®å称ã§ãæ§ããŸãããïŒ
2.3 2.2ã§åçããã¢ãã¡ãŒã·ã§ã³äœåã«ã€ããŠïŒãªãèŠèŽããããšæããŸãããïŒ
次ã®ããŒãžã«ç¶ããŸã
33
ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãçšçŽ æ·»ä»è³æ 1
2
ïŒïŒæ ç»ã®èŠèŽç°å¢ã«ã€ã㊠3.1 æ®æ®µïŒæ ç»ãèŠããšãã¯ã©ã®ãããªç°å¢ã§èŠãããšãå€ãã§ããïŒïŒè€æ°åçå¯ïŒ
ïŒæ ç»é€š ã» èªå® ã» ãã®ä»ïŒ 3.2 3.1ã§ãæ ç»é€šããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸããæ ç»é€šã§æ ç»ãèŠãéã«ïŒäœãéèŠèŠããŠããŸããïŒãŸãïŒåº§åžéžæã®éã«ã©ã®èŸºãã«åº§ãããšãå€ãã§ããïŒ
3.3 3.1ã§ãèªå® ããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸããèªå® ã§æ ç»ãèŠèŽããéã®ç°å¢ãæããŠãã ãããïŒãã£ã¹ãã¬ã€ã®å€§ãããªã©ïŒ
3.4 3.1ã§ããã®ä»ããšçããæ¹ã«ããããããŸããã©ã®ãããªç°å¢ã§æ ç»ãèŠèŽããŠãããæããŠãã ããã
ãååããããšãããããŸãã
34
ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãçšçŽ æ·»ä»è³æ 1
3
äºåŸã¢ã³ã±ãŒã
ããããšãããããŸãããå®éšçµäºåŸã®ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã«ãååãé¡ãããŸãã 1ïŒ å®éšå ã§èŠèŽããæ åãåºãŠããæ ç»äœåã«ã€ããŠç¥ã£ãŠããŸãããïŒ ïŒèŠãããšãããã»èŠãããšã¯ãªããç¥ã£ãŠããã»èŠãããšã¯ãªããç¥ããªãïŒ
2ïŒ ææ å€å¥ã¿ã¹ã¯ã¯é£ããã£ãã§ããïŒïŒ ã¯ã ã» ããã ïŒ 3ïŒ ãã¯ãããšçããå ŽåïŒã©ã®ããã«é£ããã£ããèªç±ã«èšè¿°ããŠãã ããã
5. å®éšïŒæ ååºæ¿ïŒãã®ä»ã«ã€ããŠïŒææ³ãæèŠãèªç±ã«èšè¿°ããŠãã ããã
ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã¯ä»¥äžã§ãã ããããšãããããŸããã
35