Transcript

Ϯϲ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

3HQJNDMLDQ�VLVWHP�SHQ\HGLDDQ�NHEXWXKDQ�EXQJD�NULVDQ��DQJJUHN��PDZDU�GDQ�VHGDS�PDODP�GL�ZLOD\DK�'.,�-DNDUWD

�7KH�6XSSO\�'HPDQG�,QIRUPDWLRQ�6\VWHP�$VVHVVPHQW�2I�&KU\VDQWKHPXP��2UFKLG��5RVH�DQG�3ROLDQWKHV�WXEHURXV�,Q�'.,�-DNDUWD�

1XUPDOLQGD����6XZDQGL����<XGL�6DVWUR���GDQ�$QD�)HURQLND��

�%DODL�3HQJNDMLDQ�7HNQRORJL�3HUWDQLDQ�-DNDUWD��-O��5D\D�5DJXQDQ�1R�����3DVDU�0LQJJX�-DNDUWD�6HODWDQ����������7HOS�����������������)D[��������������

�%DODL�3HQHOLWLDQ�7DQDPDQ�6D\XUDQ��O��7DQJNXEDQ�3HUDKX������.RWDN�3RV������/HPEDQJ���������-DZD�%DUDW�7HOS���������������)D[�����������������������

�3XVOLWEDQJKRUWL��-O��5D\D�5DJXQDQ�1R���$��3DVDU�0LQJJX�-DNDUWD�6HODWDQ����������7HOS������������������������)D[��������������

(PDLO��OLQGDJXQR#\DKRR�FRP

$%675$.

.HJLDWDQ� LQL� EHUWXMXDQ� XQWXN�PHQJNDML�VLVWHP�LQIRUPDVL�SHQ\HGLDDQ�NHEXWXKDQ� SURGXN� EXQJD� SRWRQJ�NULVDQ�� DQJJUHN�� PDZDU� GDQ� VHGDS�PDODP� GL� ZLOD\DK� '.,� -DNDUWD��.HJLDWDQ� GLODNVDQDNDQ� GHQJDQ�SHQGHNDWDQ� VXUYH\� GDQ� VWXGL� PHMD�PXODL�$SULO� KLQJJD� 1RSHPEHU� ������GL�'.,�-DNDUWD��&LDQMXU��GDQ�%DQGXQJ��+DVLO�SHQJNDMLDQ�PHQXQMXNNDQ�EDKZD�VHFDUD�XPXP�VLVWHP�UDQWDL�SDVRN�EXQJD�SRWRQJ� GL� '.,� -DNDUWD� GLGRPLQDVL�ROHK�SHUDQ�SHGDJDQJ�SHGDJDQJ�EHVDU��\DQJ� PHUXSDNDQ� SHQHQWX� KDUJD� GL�SDVDU�� VHGDQJNDQ�SHWD� NHEXWXKDQ� GDQ�NHWHUVHGLDDQ�NRPRGLWDV�EXQJD�SRWRQJ�FXNXS� SRVLWLI� MDPLQDQ� SDVRNDQQ\D��GHQJDQ� KDUJD� MXDO� \DQJ� PDVLK�WHUMDQJNDX� ROHK� NRQVXPHQ�6HODLQ�LWX�� LQIUDVWUXNWXU� SDVDU� WLGDN� KDQ\D�PHUXSDNDQ� WHPSDW� WUDQVDNVL� MXDO�EHOL��WHWDSL� MXJD� PHUXSDNDQ� ZDGDK� \DQJ�GDSDW� PHQJNRRUGLQDVLNDQ� EHUEDJDL�NHSHQWLQJDQ� SHODNX� DJULELVQLV��WHPSDW� XQWXN� VDOLQJ� EHUNRPXQLNDVL�EDJL� SDUD� SHODNX� DJULELVQLV� GL� GDODP�PHQJDQWLVLSDVL�EHUEDJDL�SHUPDVDODKDQ�\DQJ�GLKDGDSL��

.DWD� NXQFL� %XQJD� SRWRQJ�� UDQWDL�SDVRN��DJULELVQLV�

$%675$&7

7KH� VWXG\� DLPHG� WR� DVVHVV� WKH�VXSSO\� GHPDQG� LQIRUPDWLRQ� V\VWHP�RI� � FKU\VDQWKHPXP�� RUFKLG�� URVH� DQG�3ROLDQWKHV� WXEHURXV� LQ� '.,� -DNDUWD��7KH� DVVHVVPHQW�ZDV� XVHG� VXUYH\�DQG�GHVN�VWXG\�PHWKRGV�WKDW�ZDV�FRQGXFWHG�IURP� $SULO� WR� 1RYHPEHU� ������ LQ�-DNDUWD� PDUNHWV� DQG� VRPH� WUDGHUV�DQG�IDUPHUV�LQ�&LDQMXU��DQG�%DQGXQJ��7KH� UHVXOWV� VKRZHG� WKDW� VXSSO\�FKDLQ� RI� WKH� À�RULFXOWXUH� SURGXFWV� WR�-DNDUWD� ZDV� VWLOO� GRPLQDWHG� E\� ODUJH�VFDOH� UHWDLOHUV� ZKLFK� SOD\HG� ERWK� DV�FROOHFWHG� UHWDLOHUV� DQG� SURGXFHUV��7KH� PDSSLQJ� RI� VXSSO\� DQG� GHPDQG�RI� WKH� À�RULFXOWXUH� FRPRGLWLHV� ZHUH�JRRG� HQRXJK�� ZLWK� Dৼ�RUGDEOH� SULFH�E\� FRQVXPHU�)XUWKHUPRUH�� WKH�LQIUDVWUXFWXUH� RI� PDUNHW� ZDV� QRW�RQO\� DV� D� EDUJDLQLQJ� SODFH�� EXW� DOVR�DV� D� SODFH� WR� FRPPXQLFDWH� ZLWK�RWKHU� DJULEXVLQHVVPDQ�� DQWLFLSDWLRQ�RI� WRPDQ\� SUREOHP� WKDW� PD\� EH�HQFRXQWHUHG�

.H\V�ZRUG���&XW�À�RZHUV��VXSSO\�FKDLQ��DJULEXVLQHVV�

Ϯϳ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

3(1'$+8/8$1

'.,� -DNDUWD�� VHEDJDL� LEXNRWD�QHJDUD�� PHPLOLNL� MXPODK� KRWHO� GDQ�UHVWRUDQ� \DQJ� WHUEDQ\DN� GLEDQGLQJNDQ�GHQJDQ�GDHUDK�ODLQQ\D�GL�,QGRQHVLD���+DO�LQL�VDQJDW�EHUSHQJDUXK�SDGD�SHUPLQWDDQ�EXQJD�XQWXN�GHNRUDVL�KRWHO�GDQ�UHVWRUDQ���6HODLQ� LWX� NRQVXPHQ� SHUNDQWRUDQ� GDQ�UXPDK�WDQJJD�MXJD�PHPEXWXKNDQ�EXQJD�XQWXN� GHNRUDVL� UXDQJDQQ\D�� ZDODXSXQ�WLGDN� VHEDQ\DN� KRWHO� GDQ� UHVWRUDQ���7LQJJLQ\D� SHUPLQWDDQ� EXQJD� GL� '.,�-DNDUWD�PHQ\HEDENDQ�'.,�-DNDUWD�ELVD�GLNDWDNDQ� VHEDJDL� VHQWUD� NRQVXPVL�EXQJD� WHUEHVDU� GL� ,QGRQHVLD�� � 6HQWUD�SHQMXDODQ�EXQJD�WHUEHVDU�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD�WHUVHEXW�LDODK�SDVDU�EXQJD�5DZDEHORQJ��%HUEDJDL� MHQLV� EXQJD� \DQJ� EHUDVDO�GDUL� EHUEDJDL� VHQWUD� SURGXNVL�� VHSHUWL��-DZD� %DUDW�� -DZD� 7HQJDK� GDQ� -DZD�7LPXU�� VHEDJLDQ� EHVDU� GLSDVDUNDQ� GL�5DZD�%HORQJ���8QWXN�NULVDQ�PLVDOQ\D��-DZD� %DUDW� PHPEHULNDQ� NRQWULEXVL�WHUEHVDU� \DLWX� ������� WHUKDGDS�WRWDO� SURGXNVL� NULVDQ� ,QGRQHVLD� DWDX�VHEHVDU� ������������ WDQJNDL�� -DZD�7HQJDK� VHEHVDU� ����������� WDQJNDL���������� GDQ� -DZD� 7LPXU� VHEHVDU����������� WDQJNDL� ��������� �3XVDW�'DWD� GDQ� 6LVWHP� ,QIRUPDVL� 3HUWDQLDQ��������� � %XQJD�EXQJD� WHUVHEXW�� VHODLQ�GLSDVDUNDQ�GL�ZLOD\DK�'.,�-DNDUWD��MXJD�GLGLVWULEXVLNDQ� NH� EHUEDJDL� ZLOD\DK�ODLQ��VHSHUWL��%RJRU��'HSRN��7DQJHUDQJ��%HNDVL�GDQ�NH�OXDU�ZLOD\DK�-DERGHWDEHN��EDKNDQ� VDPSDL� NH� 6XPDWHUD�� %DOL��.DOLPDQWDQ�GDQ�6XODZHVL�

6HSHUWL� KDOQ\D� GHQJDQ� SURGXN�SHUWDQLDQ� ODLQQ\D�� WLQJNDW� SHQ\HGLDDQ�SURGXN� SHUWDQLDQ� VDPSDL� NH� OHYHO�

NRQVXPHQ�� GLSHQJDUXKL� ROHK� EHUEDJDL�IDNWRU�� GLDQWDUDQ\D� LDODK� SHQDQJDQDQ�SDQHQ� GDQ� SDVFD� SDQHQ�� WUDQVSRUWDVL��KLQJJD� VLVWHP� GLVWULEXVL� SURGXN�GL� ODSDQJDQ� �-RKQVRQ� HW� DO��� ������0DXODQD� GDQ� 6D\DND�� ������� +DO� LQL�PHQ\HEDENDQ� WHUMDGLQ\D� À�XNWXDVL�NHWHUVHGLDDQ�GDQ�KDUJD�SURGXN�SHUWDQLDQ�VHZDNWX�ZDNWX� GL� GDHUDK� SHUNRWDDQ�VHSHUWL� GL�'.,� -DNDUWD�� ,UDZDQ� �������PHQMHODVNDQ� EDKZD� À�XNWXDVL� KDUJD�NRPRGLWDV� SDGD� GDVDUQ\D� WHUMDGLDNLEDW�NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ� DQWDUD� MXPODK�SDVRNDQ� GDQ� SHUPLQWDDQ� \DQJ�GLEXWXKNDQ� NRQVXPHQ�� � -LND� SDVRNDQ�EHUOHELK� PDND� KDUJD� NRPRGLWDV�DNDQ� WXUXQ�� VHEDOLNQ\D� MLND� WHUMDGL�NHNXUDQJDQ� SDVRNDQ�� 0HQXUXW�$UGKLDQ� ������� WHUMDGLQ\D� À�XNWXDVL�KDUJD� DQWDU� ZDNWX� \DQJ� VDQJDW� WLQJJL�SDGD� SURGXN� SHUWDQLDQ� GLVHEDENDQ�NDUHQD� FLUL�FLUL� \DQJ� PHOHNDW� SDGD�SHQJHPEDQJDQ� SURGXN� KRUWLNXOWXUD��\DLWX� SHQJHPEDQJDQ� SURGXN� NXUDQJ�WHUHQFDQD�� SHWDQL�PHQJXVDKDNDQ� VXDWX�WDQDPDQ� OHELK� SDGD� LQIRUPDVL� KDUJD�SDGD� PXVLP�PXVLP� VHEHOXPQ\D��VHPHQWDUD� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� MXPODK�SDVRNDQ� GDQ� SHUPLQWDDQ� EHOXP� GDSDW�GLDQWLVLSDVL� GHQJDQ� EDLN�� � 6HODLQ� LWX�PHQXUXW�0D\URZDQL��'DUZLV���������WLJD� IDNWRU� XWDPD� \DQJ� PHQ\HEDENDQ�VWUXNWXU�DJULELVQLV�KRUWLNXOWXUD�WHUVHNDW�VHNDW� GDQ� NXUDQJ� PHPLOLNL� GD\D�VDLQJ�� \DLWX�� ���� WLGDN� DGD� NHWHUNDLWDQ�IXQJVLRQDO�\DQJ�KDUPRQLV�DQWDUD�VHWLDS�SHODNX� DJULELVQLV�� ���� VLVWLP� DJULELVQLV�\DQJ� WLGDN� H¿�VLHQ� DNLEDW� WHUEHQWXNQ\D�PDUJLQ� JDQGD�� VHKLQJJD� RQJNRV�SURGXNVL�� SHQJRODKDQ� GDQ� SHPDVDUDQ�KDVLO� \DQJ� KDUXV� GLED\DU� NRQVXPHQ�

Ϯϴ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

PHQMDGL� OHELK� PDKDO�� GDQ� ���� WLGDN�DGDQ\D� NHVHWDUDDQ� SRVLVL� WDZDU� DQWDUD�SHWDQL�GHQJDQ�SHODNX�DJULELVQLV�ODLQQ\D��VHKLQJJD� SHWDQL� VXOLW� PHQGDSDWNDQ�KDUJD� SDVDU� \DQJ� ZDMDU�� 3XJHO� �������GDODP�0LIWDK�HW��DO���������PHQMHODVNDQ�EDKZD�LQH¿�VLHQVL�SDGD�KDUJD�GL�WLQJNDW�SURGXVHQ�GDSDW�PHUXJLNDQ�SURGXVHQ�LWX�VHQGLUL� � NDUHQD� UHQGDKQ\D� GD\D� VDLQJ��3HUOLQGXQJDQ� KDUJD� SURGXVHQ� \DQJ�WLGDN�WHSDW�MXVWUX�DNDQ�EHUGDPSDN�SDGD�LQH¿�VLHQVL�WDWDQLDJD�VHFDUD�NHVHOXUXKDQ��$ODYL��������

6HFDUD�XPXP��WHUGDSDW�EHEHUDSD�NHNKDVDQ�\DQJ�GLPLOLNL�GDODP�DJULELVQLV�KRUWLNXOWXUD�� DQWDUD� ODLQ�� ���� XVDKDWDQL�\DQJ�GLODNXNDQ�OHELK�EHURULHQWDVL�SDVDU��WLGDN� NRQVLVWHQ��� ���� EHUVLIDW� SDGDW�PRGDO�� ���� UHVLNR� KDUJD� UHODWLI� EHVDU�NDUHQD� VLIDW� NRPRGLWDV� \DQJ� FHSDW�UXVDN�� GDQ� ���� GDODP� MDQJND� SHQGHN�KDUJD� UHODWLI� EHUÀ�XNWXDVL�� VHUWD� SDGD�VDDW� SDQHQ� UD\D� SHWDQL� EHUDGD� GDODP�SRVLVL� WDZDU� \DQJ� OHPDK�� 5DWD�UDWD�SHUXEDKDQ�KDUJD�GLWLQJNDW�SHWDQL� OHELK�UHQGDK� GDUL� UDWD�UDWD� SHUXEDKDQ� KDUJD�GL� WLQJNDW� SHQJHFHU�� VHKLQJJD� GDSDW�GLNDWDNDQ� EDKZD� HIHN� WUDQVPLVL� KDUJD�EHUMDODQ� WLGDN� VHPSXUQD� �,PSHUIHFW�SULFH� WUDQVPLVVLRQ�� �0D\URZDQL�� 'DUZLV� ������� 3DGD� NRPRGLWDV�DQJJUHN�� VWUXNWXU� SDVDU� \J� WHUEHQWXN�XQWXN� WDQDPDQ�EXQJD�DQJJUHN�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD� DGDODK� FHQGHUXQJ� PHQXMX�SDVDU� EHEDV� �IUHH� PDUNHW�� �,UYDQL���������.RQGLVL� WHUVHEXW�GLGXNXQJ�ROHK�EHEHUDSD� IDNWRU�� DQWDUD� ODLQ�� MXPODK�OHPEDJD� SHPDVDUDQ� FXNXS� EDQ\DN��WLGDN� DGD� KDPEDWDQ� NHOXDU� PDVXN�SDVDU��GDQ�SHWDQL�EHEDV�XQWXN�PHPLOLK�OHPEDJD� SHPDVDUDQ� GDODP� SHQMXDODQ�

SURGXNQ\D�� � +DUJD� GLWHQWXNDQ� ROHK�SHUPLQWDDQ� GDQ� SHQDZDUDQ�� � 1DPXQ�GHPLNLDQ�� PHQXUXW� 1XU\DWL� � )DULG��������� ELOD� KDUJD� WLQJJL� GDQ� WLGDN�VWDELO� SDGD� NRPRGLWDV� SHUWDQLDQ� DNDQ�EHUGDPSDN� SDGD� HNRQRPL� \DQJ� GDSDW�PHQXUXQNDQ� GD\D� EHOL� PDV\DUDNDW�VHUWD� PHPEHULNDQ� DQGLO� \DQJ� WLQJJL�WHUKDGDS� LQÀ�DVL�� 'DODP� PHQHQWXNDQ�NHELMDNDQ� KDUJD� DGD� EHEHUDSD� KDO�\DQJ� SHUOX� GLSHUWLPEDQJNDQ� \DLWX�SHPLOLKDQ�NRPRGLWL�SULRULWDV��NHELMDNDQ�SHQGXNXQJ��EX൵�HU�VWRFN��RSHUDVL�SDVDU�VHUWD�HNVSRU�LPSRU���VHUWD�NHOHPEDJDDQ�,OKDP� ������� GDQ� %HVDQNR� �%UDHXWLJDP��������

%HUNDLWDQ� GHQJDQ� KDO� GL� DWDV��PDNDSHUOX� GLODNXNDQ� SHQJNDMLDQ�\DQJEHUWXMXDQ�XQWXN�PHQJJDOL�LQIRUPDVL�NHEXWXKDQ� GDQ� VLVWHP�SHQ\HGLDDQ� GDQ�H¿�VLHQVL� VLVWHP� LQIRUPDVL� NHEXWXKDQ�SURGXN� NULVDQ�� DQJJUHN�� PDZDU� GDQ�VHGDS�PDODP�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD�

0(72'2/2*,

.HJLDWDQ� SHQJNDMLDQ�GLODNVDQDNDQ�PXODL� EXODQ�$SULOKLQJJD�1RSHPEHU�������)RNXV�NHJLDWDQ�DGDODK�SHQJNDMLDQ� WHUKDGDS� LQIRUPDVL� VLVWHP�SHQ\HGLDDQ� GDQ� SHPHQXKDQ� SURGXN�KRUWLNXOWXUD�� NKXVXVQ\D� EXQJD� NULVDQ��DQJJUHN�� PDZDU� GDQ� VHGDS� PDODP� GL�'.,� -DNDUWD�� 3HQGHNDWDQ� SHQJNDMLDQ�PHQJJXQDNDQ� PHWRGH� VWXGL� PHMD� GDQ�VXUYDL� SDVDU� \DQJ� GLODNXNDQ� GL� 3DVDU�%XQJD� 5DZDEHORQJ�� 6XUYHL� GL� WLQJNDW�SHWDQL� EXQJD� GLODNXNDQ� GL� GDHUDK�SHPDVRN�XWDPD�GL�&LSDQDV��6XNDEXPL�GDQ� %DQGXQJ�� -DZD� %DUDW�� 7DKDSDQ�

Ϯϵ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

VWXGL�PHMD�GLODNXNDQ�XQWXN�PHPSHODMDUL�SXVWDND�NDMLDQ� UDQWDL�SDVRN�NRPRGLWDV�WDQDPDQ� KLDV� GDQ� PHQHWDSNDQ� DUDK�SHQJNDMLDQ�ODQMXWDQ�

.HJLDWDQ� VXUYDL� ODSDQJDQ�GLNDNXNDQ� PHODOXL� WDKDSDQ� VHEDJDL�EHULNXW� �� D�� 3HUVLDSDQ�� PHOLSXWL��NRQVXOWDVL�� NRRUGLQDVL�� GDQ� VRVLDOLVDVL�GHQJDQ� GLQDV� GDQ� LQVWDQVL� WHUNDLW� GL�'.,� -DNDUWD�� SHPEXDWDQ� UHQFDQD�RSHUDVLRQDO� SHQJNDMLDQ�� SHQHQWXDQ�ORNDVL�GDQ�UHVSRQGHQ��VHUWD��SHPEXDWDQ�NXHVLRQHU��E��3HQJXPSXODQ�'DWD��'DWD�\DQJ� GLNXPSXONDQ� GDQ� GLJXQDNDQ�GDODP�NHJLDWDQ� LQL� DGDODK� GDWD� SULPHU��PHODOXL� NHJLDWDQ� SHQJDPDWDQ� GDQ�ZDZDQFDUD� GL� ODSDQJDQ�GDQ� VHNXQGHU��LQIRUPDVL� GDWD� SDVRNDQ� SURGXN��KDUJD� SURGXN�� GDWD� NRQVXPVL��� 'DWD�GDUL� SHQJDPDWDQ� ODSDQJDQ� PHOLSXWL�SURVHV� SURGXNVL�� SHQDQJDQDQ� SDQHQ�GDQ� SDVFD� SDQHQ�� VHUWD� MDOXU� GLVWULEXVL�NHHPSDW�NRPRGLWDVWHUVHEXW��6HPHQWDUD�LWX�� ZDZDQFDUD� GLODNXNDQ� WHUKDGDS�UHVSRQGHQ�GDQ�QDUDVXPEHU�\DQJ�WHUGLUL�DWDV� SHWDQL�� SHGDJDQJ� SHQJXPSXO��GDQ� SHGDJDQJ� SHQJHFHU�� :DZDQFDUD�GLODNXNDQ� VHFDUD� SDUWLVLSDWLI� GHQJDQ�PHODNXNDQ� )*'� � WHUKDGDS���� RUDQJ�UHVSRQGHQ�SDGD�VHWLDS�UDQWDL��F��$QDOLVLV�GDQ�3HQ\DMLDQ�'DWD�

'DWD� LQIRUPDVL� NHEXWXKDQ�SURGXN��KDUJD��GDQ�SDVRNDQ�NRPRGLWDV�GLVDMLNDQ�GDODP�EHQWXN�WDEHO�GDQ�JUD¿�N��GDQ�GLODNXNDQ�DQDOLVLV�PDWHPDWLV�VHFDUD�VHGHUKDQD� JXQD� PHQMDZDE� WXMXDQ�SHQJNDMLDQ�� � 'DWD� VLVWHP� LQIRUPDVL�GDQ� VLVWHP� SHQ\HGLDDQ� GLVDMLNDQ�GDODP� EHQWXN� JDPEDU� DWDX� LOXVWUDVL���6HPHQWDUD� LWX�� GDWD� KDVLO� SHQJNDMLDQ�VLVWHP�LQIRUPDVL�WHUVHEXW�GL�DQDOLVLV�GDQ�

KDVLOQ\D� GLVDMLNDQ� GDODP� EHQWXN� WDEHO�GDQ�LOXVWUDVL�

+$6,/�'$1�3(0%$+$6$1

3HWD� .HEXWXKDQ� GDQ� .HWHUVHGLDDQ�EXQJD�SRWRQJ�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD

%XQJD� SRWRQJ� GRPLQDQ� \DQJ�GLSDVDUNDQ�GL�3DVDU�%XQJD��3%��5DZD�%HORQJ�DQWDUD�ODLQ�DGDODK�NULVDQ��VHGDS�PDODP��PDZDU��GDQ�DQJJUHN��/DPSLUDQ������%HUGDVDUNDQ�GDWD�\DQJ�GLGDSDWNDQ��NHEXWXKDQ� PDV\DUDNDW� WHUKDGDS�NHHPSDW� MHQLV� EXQJD� SRWRQJ� WHUVHEXW�VHFDUD� XPXP� GDSDW� GLSHQXKL�PHODOXL�SDVRNDQ�GDUL�EHUEDJDL�VHQWUD�SURGXNVL�EXQJD� GL� SXODX� -DZD�� � 'DUL� KDVLO�SHQHOLWLDQ�� VHNLWDU� ���� EXQJD� \DQJ�PDVXN� NH� SDVDU� EXQJD� 5DZDEHORQJ�GLJXQDNDQ� ROHK� PDV\DUDNDW� GL� '.,�-DNDUWD� GDQ� VHOLVLK� DQWDUD� SDVRNDQ�GHQJDQ�MXPODK�NHEXWXKDQ�PDV\DUDNDW�-DNDUWD�WHUKDGDS�EXQJD�EXQJD�WHUVHEXW�GLGLVWULEXVLNDQ�NH�GDHUDK�ODLQ��VHSHUWL��%RJRU��'HSRN��7DQJHUDQJ�GDQ�EDKNDQ�NHOXDU� -DZD�� VHSHUWL�� 6XPDWHUD��.DOLPDQWDQ�GDQ�6XODZHVL�� �6HODLQ� LWX�VHEDJLDQ� VHEDJLDQ� NHFLO� PDUXSDNDQ�NHUXVDNDQ� VHODPD� SURVHV� SHQMXDODQ�GL� 3DVDU� EXQJD� 5DZDEHORQJ�6HFDUD�PDWHPDWLV� WLQJNDW� SDVRNDQ� EXQJD�SRWRQJ� \DQJ� DGD� GL� 3DVDU� %XQJD�5DZDEHORQJ� PHOHELKL� ���� GDUL�NHEXWXKDQ�PDV\DUDNDW� -DNDUWD� �7DEHO����� � %HUGDVDUNDQ� GDWD� SHQMXDODQ� GL�5DZD� %HORQJ�� EXODQ�EXODQ� SHQMXDODQ�EXQJD� WHUWLQJJL� SDGD� WDKXQ� �����������GDQ������EHUEHGD�EHGD���.KXVXV�WDKXQ�������SHUPLQWDDQ�EXQJD�SRWRQJ�NULVDQ�WHUWLQJJL�WHUMDGL�SDGD�EXODQ�0HL�

ϯϬ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

GDQ� 1RYHPEHU�� 0DZDU� SDGD� EXODQ�2NWREHU�GDQ�1RYHPEHU��VHGDS�PDODP�SDGD� EXODQ� )HEUXDUL�� 0DUHW�� $SULO�GDQ� 0HL�� VHUWD� DQJJUHN� SDGD� EXODQ�$JXVWXV��2NWREHU�GDQ�'HVHPEHU�

$OLUDQ� 3URGXN� GDQ� +DUJD� %XQJD�3RWRQJ

.ULVDQ� ��� 6HQWUD� SURGXNVL�NULVDQ�GL�-DZD�%DUDW�DGDODK�NDEXSDWHQ�%DQGXQJ�� &LDQMXU� GDQ� 6XNDEXPL���

%HUEDJDL� YDULHWDV� NULVDQ� GLWDQDP�GL� ZLOD\DK� WHUVHEXW� � GHQJDQ� ZDUQD�GRPLQDQ� SXWLK� GDQ� NXQLQJ�� � .ULVDQ�GLSDVDUNDQ� WHUXWDPD� NH� '.,� -DNDUWD��\DLWX� NH� 3%� 5DZDEHORQJ� GDQ� À�RULV�À�RULV� \DQJ� DGD� GL� ZLOD\DK� -DNDUWD��%RJRU�� 'HSRN�� 7DQJHUDQJ� GDQ�%HNDVL�� � 6HODLQ� LWX�� MXJD� NH�%DQGXQJ�GDQ� GDHUDK�GDHUDK� ODLQ�� VHSHUWL� -DZD�7HQJDK� GDQ�/DPSXQJ�� �5DQWDL� SDVRN�NULVDQ�GDSDW�GLOLKDW�SDGD�*DPEDU���

7DEHO����7LQJNDW�NHEXWXKDQ�EXQJD�SRWRQJGL�'.,�-DNDUWD�GDQ�SDVRNDQ�\DQJ�WHUVHGLD�GL�3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZD�%HORQJ�WDKXQ����������

-HQLV�%XQJD .HEXWXKDQ��WDKXQ

�,NDW�

7LQJNDW�SDVRNDQ��WDKXQ �

�,NDW�

���� ���� ���� � ���� ���� ���� �

.ULVDQ ������� ������ ������ ������� �������� ��������

6HGDS�0DODP ������ ������ ������ ������� �������� ��������

0DZDU ������� ������� ������ ������� ������� ��������

$QJJUHN��'HQGURELXP�GDQ�9DQGD�'RXJODV�

����� ����� ������ �������� ��������� ��������

.HWHUDQJDQ���� ��6XPEHU��3XVDW�3URPRVL�GDQ�6HUWL¿�NDVL�+DVLO�3HUWDQLDQ������� �������� ���'DWD�VDPSDL�1RYHPEHU�����

ϯϭ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

3HWDQL� NULVDQ� GL� NDEXSDWHQ�%DQGXQJ�� &LSDQDV� GDQ� 6XNDEXPL�PHQMXDO� SURGXNQ\D� ODQJVXQJ� NHSDGD�SHGDJDQJ� SHQJXPSXO� \DQJ� DGD� GL�ZLOD\DK�PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ��GDQ�SHGDJDQJ�SHQJXPSXO� PHPEDZDQ\D� NH� 3%�5DZDEHORQJ�� � 'DUL� 3%� 5DZDEHORQJ�GLSDVDUNDQ� NHSDGD� GHNRUDWRU� GDQ�À�RULVW�DWDX�SHUDQJNDL�EXQJD�\DQJ�DGD�GL� VHNLWDU� -DERGHWDEHN�� EDLN� PHUHND�VHQGLUL�\DQJ�GDWDQJ�NH�3%�5DZDEHORQJ�DWDXSXQ� GLNLULP� NH� WHPSDW� SHPEHOL��À�RULV����6HODLQ�GDUL�SHQJXPSXO��À�RULVW�DWDX� GHNRUDWRU� MXJD� PHQGDSDWNDQ�EXQJD�GDUL�SHQJXVDKD���'LEDQGLQJNDQ�GHQJDQ� NULVDQ� SHWDQL�� NXDOLWDV� EXQJD�PLOLN� SHUXVDKDDQ� OHELK� EDJXV� GHQJDQ�YDVHOLIH� ���� KDUL� VHGDQJNDQ� GDUL�SHWDQL� NHWDKDQDQQ\D� KDQ\D� �� KDUL���2OHK� NDUHQD� LWX� KDUJD� NULVDQ� GDUL�SHUXVDKDDQ�OHELK�PDKDO�GLEDQGLQJNDQ�GHQJDQ� KDUJD� SHWDQL�� � .ULVDQ� GDUL�SHUXVDKDDQ� GLMXDO� NH� À�RULVW�GHNRUDWRU�GHQJDQ� KDUJD� 5S� �������������� SHU�LNDW�� VHGDQJNDQ� NULVDQ� GDUL� SHWDQL�GLMXDO�NH�GHNRUDWRU�DWDX�À�RULVW�GHQJDQ�KDUJD�5S��������LNDW���6DWX�LNDW�EXQJD�NULVDQ�EHULVL����WDQJNDL�EXQJD���'DODP�SHQHQWXDQ� KDUJD� GL� WLQJNDW� SHWDQL�XPXPQ\D�EHUGDVDUNDQ�WDZDU�PHQDZDU�DQWDUD� SHGDJDQJ� GDQ� SHWDQL�� � 3RVLVL�WDZDU� SHWDQL� VDDW� LQL� VXGDK� VHPDNLQ�EDLN�� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ� EHEHUDSD�WDKXQ�\DQJ�ODOX�

3DGD� VDDW�VDDW� � WHUWHQWX� GL� 3%�5DZD�%HORQJ�WHUMDGL�NHNXUDQJDQ�DWDX�SDVRNDQ� EXQJD� NULVDQ�� � 3DGD� HYHQW�HYHQW� WHUWHQWX�� VHSHUWL� KDUL�KDUL� EHVDU��WDKXQ�EDUX��LPOHN��YDOHQWLQH��OHEDUDQ��PXVLP�PXVLP� SHVWD� SHUQLNDKDQ�� KDUL�NHPHUGHNDDQ� GDQ� QDWDO�� SHUPLQWDDQ�

NULVDQ� PHQJDODPL� SHQLQJNDWDQ���(YHQW�HYHQW� WHUVHEXW� XPXPQ\D� GDSDW��GLSUHGLNVL� ROHK� SHWDQL� GDQ� SHGDJDQJ��VHGDQJNDQ� NHMDGLDQ� ODLQ� \DQJ� MXJD�PHPEXWXKNDQ� FXNXS� EDQ\DN� NULVDQ��GLDQWDUDQ\D� PHQLQJJDOQ\D� DQJJRWD�NHOXDUJD�GDUL�NDODQJDQ�DWDV�GDQ�SHMDEDW�WLGDN� ELVD� GLSUHGLNVL�� � +DO� GHPLNLDQ�PHUXSDNDQ� VDODK� VDWX� SHQ\HEDE�WHUMDGLQ\D�À�XNWXDVL�KDUJD�KDULDQ�\DQJ�GDSDW� PHQFDSDL� ���� �� GDUL� KDUJD�ELDVD���

.ULVDQ� VHFDUD� XPXP� WLGDN�GLODNXNDQ�JUDGLQJ��+DUJD�EXQJD�NULVDQ�OHELK� GLWHQWXNDQ� ROHK� NXDOLWDV� EXQJD��EDQ\DN� VHGLNLWQ\D� SDVRNDQ� GDQ� QDLN�WXUXQQ\D�SHUPLQWDDQ�EXQJD��3HQMXDODQ�EXQJD�NULVDQ�GL�WLQJNDW�SHWDQL�GLODNXNDQ�GHQJDQ�VLVWLP�NRQWUDN�GDQ� MXDO� OHSDV��'DODP� VLVWLP� NRQWUDN� SHWDQL�PHQMXDO�SURGXNQ\D� NH� VDWX� SHQJHSXO� GHQJDQ�KDUJD�MXDO�\DQJ�VXGDK�GLWHQWXNDQ�ROHK�SHQJHSXO�� � 6HSHUWL� \DQJ� GLDODPL� ROHK�VDODK�VHRUDQJ�SHWDQL�NULVDQ�GL�&LSDQDV��KDUJD� EXQJD� VXGDK� GLWHQWXNDQ� 5S����������LNDW�� 'HQJDQ� VLVWLP� LQL�ZDODXSXQ�KDUJD�EXQJD�PHQLQJNDW�DWDX�PHQXUXQ�� KDUJD� \DQJ� GLWHULPD� SHWDQL�WHWDS�� � 1DPXQ� SHWDQL� PHUDVD� SXDV�GHQJDQ�FDUD�LQL��NDUHQD��GHQJDQ�VLVWLP�NRQWUDN�LQL��DGDQ\D�MDPLQDQ�SDVDU�VHUWD�DGDQ\D�NHSDVWLDQ�KDUJD��

3HQMXDODQ�GDUL� SHWDQL�GLODNXNDQ�VHFDUD� ERURQJDQ� NHSDGD� WHQJNXODN�GHQJDQ� VLVWHP� NRQWUDN�� � 3HQMXDODQ�EXQJD�NULVDQ�GLODNXNDQ�GDODP�EHQWXN�LNDWDQ�DWDX�JDEXQJDQ���6DWX�LNDW�EHULVL����WDQJNDL�EXQJD�GDQ�VDWX�JDEXQJ�EHULVL����LNDW�EXQJD�DWDX�����WDQJNDL�EXQJD���6LVWLP� SHQMXDODQ� DQWDUD� SHGDJDQJ�SHQJXPSXO� GHQJDQ� À�RULVW� PHOLSXWL�

ϯϮ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

VLVWLP� DERQHPHQ� GDQ� SHQMXDODQ�OHSDV�� � 3DGD� VLVWHP� $ERQHPHQ��WUDQVDNVL� GLODNXNDQ� PHQJJXQDNDQ�VLVWLP� NRQWUDN�� GHQJDQ� KDUJD� GDQ�MXPODK�\DQJ�GLSDVRN�VXGDK�GLWHQWXNDQ�VHVXDL� NHVHSDNDWDQ�� 3HPED\DUDQ� ELVD�GLODNXNDQ� VHFDUD� WXQDL� DWDX� GLED\DU�EHEHUDSD�KDUL�VHWHODK�EDUDQJ�GLWHULPD�ROHK� À�RULVW�� %LDVDQ\D� SHGDJDQJ�SHQJXPSXO� PHPSXQ\DL� SHODQJJDQ�WHWDS�� VHKLQJJD� WLGDN� EDQ\DN� EDUDQJ�\DQJ� WHUVLVD�� � 6HFDUD� XPXP� GDODP�VHPLQJJX� SDVRNDQ� NULVDQ� GLODNXNDQ�VHEDQ\DN� �� NDOL�� \DLWX� KDUL� 6HODVD��.DPLV� GDQ� 6DEWX� JXQD� PHPHQXKL�SHUPLQWDDQ� SDVDU� WHUXWDPD� SDGD� KDUL��-XP¶DW�KLQJJD�0LQJJX�

$QJJUHN� ��� $QJJUHN� 'HQGURELXP�

\DQJ� GLSDVDUNDQ� GL� SDVDU� EXQJD�5DZDEHORQJ� EHUDVDO� GDUL� SHWDQL�GDQ� � 37�� *XQXQJ� 6LQGXU� �%RJRU���VHGDQJNDQ� DQJJUHN�9DQGD��$UDQWKHUD�GDQ� 0DJJLH� 2LH� EHUDVDO� GDUL� SHWDQL�3DPXODQJ� GDQ� 7DQJHUDQJ�� � $QJJUHN�'HQGURELXP��$UDQWKHUD�GDQ�0DJJL�RHL�VHULQJ�GLJXQDNDQ�VHEDJDL�EXQJD�XQWXN�UDQJNDLDQ��VHGDQJNDQ�$QJJUHN�9DQGD�*HQWD� %DQGXQJ� GLJXQDNDQ� XQWXN�EXQJD� SDSDQ� XFDSDQ�� � 5DQWDL� SDVRN�DQJJUHN� XQWXN�'.,� -DNDUWD� GLVDMLNDQ�GDODP�*DPEDU���

3DGD� WDKXQ� ������ DQJJUHN�'HQGURELXP� GLSDVDUNDQ� GDODP� ��XNXUDQ��\DLWX�6��0�GDQ�/���3HUEHGDDQ�XNXUDQ� LQL� EHUSHQJDUXK� SDGD� KDUJD�DQJJUHN� 'HQGURELXP�� � 1DPXQ�GHPLNLDQ�� VDDW� LQL� 'HQGURELXP� \DQJ�

7DEHO�����+DUJD�EXQJD�$QJJUHN�GL�3%�5DZDEHORQJ

1R� -HQLV�$QJJUHN+DUJD�%HOL�5S�,NDW�

+DUJD�-XDO��5S�,NDW�

� 'HQGURELXP�,PSRU ������ �������

� 'HQGURELXP�ORNDO ������ ������

VHSHUWL���

$UDQWKHUD�-DPHV�6WRULH9DQGD�*HQWD�%DQGXQJ0DJJLH�2HL

������������������

��������������������

����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

ϯϯ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

GLSDVDUNDQ�� GLEHGDNDQ� DWDV� DQJJUHN�LPSRU�GDQ�ORNDO��GHQJDQ�KDUJD�DQJJUHN�OHELK�WLQJJL�GDUL�DQJJUHN�ORNDO��7DEHO����� � 0DKDOQ\D� KDUJD� DQJJUHN� LPSRU��VHODLQ� EHQWXN� GDQ� XNXUDQQ\D� \DQJ�VHUDJDP�� NHWDKDQDQ� VLPSDQQ\D� MXJD�OHELK� ODPD�� ELVD� OHELK�GDUL� VHPLQJJX�%HUEHGD� GHQJDQ� 'HQGURELXP�� XQWXN�DQJJUHN�$UDQWKHUD�� 0DJJLH� 2LH�� GDQ�9DQGD�*HQWD�%DQGXQJ�WLGDN�GLEHGDNDQ�EHUGDVDUNDQ� XNXUDQ�� �$QJJUHN�9DQGD�*HQWD� %DQGXQJ� VHULQJ� GLJXQDNDQ�GDODP�UDQJNDLDQ�SDSDQ�XFDSDQ

0DZDU� ��� %XQJD� PDZDU� \DQJ�GLSDVDUNDQ� GL� SDVDU� EXQJD�5DZDEHORQJ� EHUDVDO� GDUL� &LSDQDV�GDQ� 0DODQJ�� � 0DZDU� \DQJ� EHUDVDO�GDUL� &LSDQDV� PHPLOLNL� NXDOLWDV� \DQJ�OHELK� EDLN� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ�PDZDU� 0DODQJ�� KDO� LQL� WHUOLKDW� GDUL�SHUEHGDDQ� KDUJD� DQWDUD� NHGXDQ\D��0DZDU�&LSDQDV� GLKDUJDL� OHELK�PDKDO�GLEDQGLQJNDQ� 0DZDU� 0DODQJ� �7DEHO����� 0DZDU�0DODQJ� VHODLQ� GLSDVDUNDQ�GL� 3%� 5DZDEHORQJ�� MXJD� GLSDVDUNDQ�GL� 6XUDED\D�� 6HPDUDQJ� GDQ� %DOL���3HUPLQWDDQ� NRQVXPHQ� WHUWLQJJL�WHUKDGDS� PDZDU� WHUXWDPD� SDGD� VDDW�KDUL�KDUL�EHVDU���'DODP�SHQJJXQDDQQ\D��PDZDU�OHELK�EDQ\DN�GLJXQDNDQ�XQWXN�UDQJNDLDQ� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ�GHNRUDVL� GHQJDQ�SHUEDQGLQJDQ���������6HSHUWL� UDQWDL� SHPDVDUDQ� EXQJD�ODLQQ\D��UDQWDL�SHPDVDUDQ�PDZDU�MXJD�

7DEHO�����+DUJD�EHOL�GDQ�KDUJD�MXDO�EXQJD�PDZDU

1R� -HQLV�0DZDU+DUJD�%HOL�GDUL�SHWDQL

�5S�7.,�+DUJD�-XDO�WN�

SHGDJDQJ�5S�7.,�

� 0DZDU�&LSDQDV ������ ������

� 0DZDU�0DODQJ ������ ������

UHODWLI�SHQGHN��*DPEDU����

6HGDS� 0DODP� �� 6HGDS� PDODP�XPXPQ\D� GLSDVRN� GDUL� 3DVXUXDQ��$PEDUDZD�� 6XNDEXPL�� %DQGXQJ�GDQ� 6HUDQJ� �3DQGHJODQJ��� � 3HGDJDQJ�EXQJD� 5DZDEHORQJ� OHELK� EDQ\DN�PHQGDWDQJNDQ� EXQJD� VHGDS� PDODP�GDUL�'HVD�*UDEDJ� �$PEDUDZD��� \DLWX�VHNLWDU� ����GDQ� VLVDQ\D� GLGDWDQJNDQ�

GDUL�6HUDQJ�GDQ�&LDQMXU���3HQJJXQDDQ�VHGDS� PDODP� WLGDN� KDQ\D� XQWXN�UDQJNDLDQ� EXQJD� VDMD� WHWDSL� MXJD�GLSDNDL� VHEDJDL� EXQJD� NHWLND� RUDQJ�EHU]LDUDK� NXEXU�� � 3HQJJXQDDQ� VHGDS�PDODP�SDOLQJ�EDQ\DN�DGDODK�SDGD�VDDW�KDUL�UD\D�,GXO�)LWUL�GDQ�WDKXQ�EDUX�&LQD��,POHN�� GLPDQD� NHEXWXKDQQ\D� GDSDW�PHQFDSDL� ����� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� KDUL�KDUL� ELDVD�� � 0HQXUXW� VDODK� VHRUDQJ�SHJDZDL�'LSHUWD�'.,��SDGD�KDUL� UD\D�,GXO�)LWUL������\DQJ�ODOX��\DLWX�GXD�KDUL�VHEHOXP� OHEDUDQ� GDODP� VDWX� KDUL� VDMD�MXPODK� EXQJD� \DQJ� WHUMXDO� VHEDQ\DN��������� EDWDQJ�� � 5DQWDL� SHPDVDUDQ�EXQJD�VHGDS�PDODP�OHELK�SDQMDQJ�GDUL�

ϯϰ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

PDZDU��*DPEDU�����

+DUJD� SHQMXDODQ� EXQJD� VHGDS�

PDODP� GHQJDQ� NXDOLWDV� EDJXV� OHELK�

PDKDO� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ� NXDOLWDV�

\DQJ� NXUDQJ� EDJXV�� � 3DGD� VDDW�

UHQGDKQ\D� SHUPLQWDDQ� KDUJD� SHU� LNDW�

VHGDS�PDODP� GL� WLQJNDW� SHWDQL� KDQ\D�

5S� ���������LNDW�� VHGDQJNDQ� DSDELOD�

SHUPLQWDDQ� VHGDQJ� EDQ\DN� KDUJD�

VHGDS� PDODP� PHQFDSDL� 5S� ���������

LNDW��7DEHO������%DQ\DNQ\D�SHUPLQWDDQ�

PHQ\HEDENDQ� KDUJD� EXQJD� PHQMDGL�

PHQLQJNDW�

$QDOLVLV� 0DUMLQ� 7DWDQLDJD� .ULVDQ��$QJJUHN��0DZDU�GDQ�6HGDS�0DODP�

5DQWDL� SHPDVDUDQ� EXQJD�SRWRQJ�\DQJ�VDQJDW�SHQGHN�� WHUXWDPD�XQWXN� DQJJUHN� 'HQGURELXP� GDQ�PDZDU�EHUSHQJDUXK�SDGD�PDUMLQ�\DQJ�GLWHULPD� ROHK� SHODNX� SDVDU� EXQJD�

SRWRQJ�� � %LOD� GLOLKDW� GDUL� DQDOLVLV�PDUMLQ� SHPDVDUDQ� SDGD� NHHPSDW�EXQJD� SRWRQJ�7DEHO� ������ GDQ� ����GDSDW�GLNDWDNDQ�EDKZD�SHPDVDUDQQ\D�H¿�VLHQ��6HFDUD�WHNQLV��UDQWDL�SHPDVDUDQ�EXQJD� SRWRQJ� \DQJ� EHUODNX� PDPSX�PHQ\DPSDLNDQ�KDVLO�GDUL�SURGXVHQ�NH�NRQVXPHQ� GHQJDQ� KDUJD� PXUDK�� GDQ�VHFDUD�HNRQRPLV�PDPSX�PHPEHULNDQ�SHPEDJLDQ�\DQJ�DGLO�GDUL�NHVHOXUXKDQ�KDUJD�\DQJ�GLED\DUNDQ�NRQVXPHQ�DNKLU���%LD\D� SHPDVDUDQ� SDGD� VHWLDS� SHODNX�SDVDU�NXUDQJ�GDUL������GHPLNLDQ�MXJD�GHQJDQ� NHXQWXQJDQ� \DQJ� GLSHUROHK�ROHK� VHWLDS� SHODNX� SDVDU� WLGDN� WHUODOX�EHVDU�� � 8QWXN� NULVDQ�� SHUVHQWDVH�NHXQWXQJDQ� SHGDJDQJ� EXQJD� SDVDU�5DZDEHORQJ� DGDODK� ���� �7DEHO� ���GDQ�DQJJUHN������7DEHO����GDUL�KDUJD�WLQJNDW� NRQVXPHQ�� VHGDQJNDQ� XQWXN�PDZDU� ������� �7DEHO� ��� GDQ� VHGDS�PDODP� VHNLWDU� ������� �7DEHO� �����

7DEHO����+DUJD�EXQJD�VHGDS�PDODP�GL�WLQJNDW�SHWDQL�GDQ�À�RULVW�SHGDJDQJ

1R� ,WHP3HWDQL

�5S�,NDW�)ORULV�3HG��

%XQJD.XEXUDQ

� 0LQLPDO ����� ������

� 5DWD�UDWD ����� ������

� 0DNVLPDO ������ ������

����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

ϯϱ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

5HQGDKQ\D�NHXQWXQJDQ�\DQJ�GLWHULPD�SHGDJDQJ� 5DZDEHORQJ� XQWXN� EXQJD�PDZDU�GLNDUHQDNDQ�DGDQ\D�VXVXW�GDUL�EXQJD�PDZDU�GDQ�GLSHUNLUDNDQ�VHNLWDU���� ��� � 1DPXQ� GHPLNLDQ�� EDJLDQ�\DQJ�GLWHULPD�SHWDQL�NULVDQ��DQJJUHN��PDZDU�GDQ�VHGDS�PDODP�VHFDUD�XPXP�OHELK�GDUL��������+DO�LQL�ELVD�GLNDWDNDQ�EDKZD� SRVLVL� WDZDU� SHWDQL� EXQJD�FXNXS�NXDW����

%LOD�GLOLKDW�GDUL�SHUKLWXQJDQ�GL�DWDV��XQWXN�DQJJUHN�GDQ�VHGDS�PDODP�PHPSXQ\DL� NHPXQJNLQDQ� XQWXN�PHQXUXQNDQ� KDUJD� MXDO�� WHWDSL� WLGDN�OHELK�GDUL�������NDUHQD�ELOD�GLWXUXQNDQ�OHELK� GDUL� ��� �� GDUL� SHUVHQWDVH�NHXQWXQJDQ� \DQJ� GLWHULPD� SHGDJDQJ�DNDQ�VDQJDW�NHFLO�� WHWDSL�XQWXN�NULVDQ�GDQ� PDZDU� VXOLW� GLODNXNDQ� NDUHQD�NHXQWXQJDQ� \DQJ� GLWHULPD� VDDW� LQL�VDQJDW�NHFLO��\DLWX�NXUDQJ�GDUL�������

7DEHO�����$QDOLVLV�0DUMLQ�7DWDQLDJD�.ULVDQ�GDUL�%DQGXQJ��-DZD�%DUDW��NH�3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZDEHORQJ��'.,�-DNDUWD�

1R� 8UDLDQ+DUJD�5S�.J�

%LD\D�5S�.J�

0DUMLQ�3HPDVDUDQ

3HUVHQWDVH���

,� 3HWDQL

+DUJD�-XDO ��������� �����

,,� 3HGDJDQJ�3HQJXPSXO��5DZD�%HORQJ

���������

+DUJD�%HOL%LD\D.HXQWXQJDQ+DUJD�MXDO

���������

������������������

����� ����������������

,,,� .RQVXPHQ

+DUJD�EHOL ��������� ������

.HWHUDQJDQ�� �����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

7DEHO�����$QDOLVLV�0DUMLQ�7DWDQLDJD�$QJJUHN�'HQGURELXP�3RWRQJ��GDUL�3HQJXVDKD��%RJRU��NH�3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZD�%HORQJ��'.,�-DNDUWD�

1R� 8UDLDQ+DUJD

�5S�LNDW �%LD\D

�5S�LNDW�0DUMLQ�

3HPDVDUDQ3HUVHQWDVH

���

,� 3HQJXVDKD

+DUJD�-XDO �������� �����

,,� 3HGDJDQJ�3HQJHFHU�5DZDEHORQJ

���������

+DUJD�%HOL%LD\D.HXQWXQJDQ+DUJD�MXDO

���������

�������������������

���� ���������������

,,,� .RQVXPHQ

+DUJD�EHOL ���������� ������

.HWHUDQJDQ�� �����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

ϯϲ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

7DEHO� ���$QDOLVLV�0DUMLQ�7DWDQLDJD�0DZDU� GDUL� %DQGXQJ� �-DZD�%DUDW�� NH� 3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZDEHORQJ��'.,�-DNDUWD�

1R� 8UDLDQ+DUJD�5S�.J�

%LD\D�5S�.J�

0DUMLQ�3HPDVDUDQ

3HUVHQWDVH���

,� 3HWDQL

+DUJD�-XDO ��������� �����

,,� 3HGDJDQJ�5DZDEHORQJ ���������

+DUJD�EHOL%LD\D.HXQWXQJDQ+DUJD�MXDO

���������

������������������

����� ���������������

,,,� .RQVXPHQ

+DUJD�EHOL ��������� ������.HWHUDQJDQ�� �����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

7DEHO����$QDOLVLV�0DUMLQ�7DWDQLDJD�%XQJD�6HGDS�0DODP�GDUL�$PEDUDZD�NH�3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZDEHORQJ��'.,�-DNDUWD�

1R� 8UDLDQ +DUJD�5S�.J�

%LD\D�5S�.J�

0DUMLQ�3HPDVDUDQ

3HUVHQWDVH���

,� 3HWDQL

+DUJD�-XDO ������ �����

,,� 3HGDJDQJ�5DZDEHORQJ ��������

+DUJD�%HOL%LD\D.HXQWXQJDQ+DUJD�MXDO

���������

�����������������

������� ��������������

,,,� 3HGDJDQJ�3HQJHFHU ���������

+DUJD�EHOL%LD\D.HXQWXQJDQ+DUJD�MXDO

���������

�����������������

������� ���������������

,9� .RQVXPHQ

+DUJD�EHOL ��������� ������

.HWHUDQJDQ�� �����LNDW� ����WDQJNDL

.(6,038/$1�

��� 6LVWHP�UDQWDL�SDVRN�EXQJD�SRWRQJ�GL� '.,� -DNDUWD� VHFDUD� XPXP��GLGRPLQDVL� ROHK� SHUDQ� SHGDJDQJ�SHGDJDQJ� EHVDU�� \DQJ� PHUXSDNDQ�SHQHQWX� KDUJD� GL� SDVDU� � �DGDQ\D�

SHUDQ�JDQGD�VHEDJDL�SHGDJDQJ�GDQ�MXJD�SURGXVHQ���

��� ,QIUDVWUXNWXU� SDVDU� WLGDN� KDQ\D�PHUXSDNDQ� WHPSDW� WUDQVDNVL� MXDO�EHOL��WHWDSL�MXJD�PHUXSDNDQ�ZDGDK�\DQJ� GDSDW� PHQJNRRUGLQDVLNDQ�EHUEDJDL� NHSHQWLQJDQ� SHODNX�DJULELVQLV�� WHPSDW� XQWXN� VDOLQJ�

ϯϳ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

EHUNRPXQLNDVL� EDJL� SDUD� SHODNX�DJULELVQLV�GL�GDODP�PHQJDQWLVLSDVL�EHUEDJDL� SHUPDVDODKDQ� \DQJ�GLKDGDSL��

��� 3HWD� NHEXWXKDQ� GDQ� NHWHUVHGLDDQ�SURGXN�+RUWLNXOWXUD�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD��XQWXN� NRPRGLWDV� EXQJD� SRWRQJ�FXNXS�SRVLWLI�MDPLQDQ�SDVRNDQQ\D��GHQJDQ� KDUJD� MXDO� \DQJ� PDVLK�WHUMDQJNDX�ROHK�NRQVXPHQ�

'$)7$5�3867$.$

+DGL�� 3�� 8��� 0D\URZDQL�� +�� 6XSULDWL�GDQ� 6XPHGL�� � ������ � 5HYLHZ�DQG� 2XWORRN� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ�.RPRGLWDV� � +RUWLNXOWXUD���6HPLQDU� 1DVLRQDO� 3HUVSHNWLI�3HPEDQJXQDQ� SHUWDQLDQ� GDQ�.HKXWDQDQ� 7DKXQ� ����� NH�'HSDQ�� � 3XVDW� 3HQHOLWLDQ� GDQ�3HQJHPEDQJDQ� 6RVLDO� (NRQRPL�3HUWDQLDQ�� %DGDQ� 3HQHOLWLDQ�GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ� 3HUWDQLDQ���%RJRU�

,UDZDQ��%��1XUPDQDI��5��+DVWXWL���(�/��0XVOLP��&��6XSULDQD��<��'DUZLV��9�� � ������ � .HELMDNVDQDDQ�3HQJHPEDQJDQ� $JULELVQLV��.RPRGLWDV� 8QJJXODQ�+RUWLNXOWXUD�� � 3XVDW� 3HQHOLWLDQ�GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ� 6RVLDO�(NRQRPL� 3HUWDQLDQ�� %DGDQ�3HQHOLWLDQ� GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ�3HUWDQLDQ���%RJRU�

-KRQVRQ�� *�,��� .�� :HLQEHUJHU�� DQG�0��:X�� � ������ � 7KH� 9HJHWDEOH�,QGXVWU\� LQ� 7URSLFDO� $VLD��,QGRQHVLD� ³DQ� RYHUYLHZ� RI�

SURGXFWLRQ�DQG�WUDGH´��$95'&��6KDQKXD��7DLZDQ�

,UYDQL��%��������$QDOLVLV�3HQGDSDWDQ�GDQ�6WUXNWXU�3HPDVDUDQ�%XQJD�$QJJUHN�GL�'.,�-DNDUWD��6NULSVL��-XUXVDQ�,OPX�LOPX�6RVLDO�(NRQRPL�3HUWDQLDQ��,QVWLWXW�3HUWDQLDQ�%RJRU��%RJRU��

0DXODQD�� 0�� DQG� %�� 6D\DND�� � �������7KH� IHDWXUHV� RI� YHJHWDEOHV� LQ�,QGRQHVLD�DQG�WKH�FXUUHQW�SROLF\�LQ�WKH�IUDPHZRUN�RI�DJULFXOWXUDO�GHYHORSPHQW�� $QDOLVLV�.HELMDNDQ� 3HUWDQLDQ�� 9ROXPH� ��������������

0D\URZDQL�� +� GDQ� 9�� 'DUZLV�������� 3HUVSHNWLI� 3HPDVDUDQ�%DZDQJ� 0HUDK� GL� .DEXSDWHQ�%UHEHV�� -DZD� 7HQJDK�� 6HPLQDU�1DVLRQDO� 3HQLQJNDWDQ� 'D\D�6DLQJ� $JULELVQLV� %HURULHQWDVL�.HVHMDKWHUDDQ� 3HWDQL�� %RJRU� ���2NWREHU���������S�

�3XVDW� 'DWD� GDQ� 6LVWHP� ,QIRUPDVL�3HUWDQLDQ�� ������ � � 2XWORRN�.RPRGLWL� .ULVDQ�� � 6HNUHWDULDW�-HQGHUDO��.HPHQWHULDQ�3HUWDQLDQ���-DNDUWD

3XVDW� 3URPRVL� GDQ� 6HUWL¿�NDVL� +DVLO�3HUWDQLDQ���������9ROXPH��+DUJD�GDQ�2P]HW�3HQMXDODQ�%XQJD� GL�5DZD�%HORQJ���-DNDUWD�

5DFKPDQ� +�� 3�� 6�� � ������ � $VSHN�3HUPLQWDDQ�� 3HQDZDUDQ� GDQ�7DWDQLDJD� +RUWLNXOWXUD� � GL�,QGRQHVLD���)RUXP�$JURHNRQRPL���� ��� ��� �� ������� � 3XVDW�3HQHOLWLDQ� GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ�

ϯϴ

EƵƌŵĂůŝŶĚĂ�Ğƚ�Ăů�WĞŶŐŬĂũŝĂŶ�ƐŝƐƚĞŵ�ƉĞŶLJĞĚŝĂĂŶ�ŬĞďƵƚƵŚĂŶ�ďƵŶŐĂ�ŬƌŝƐĂŶ�ĂŶŐŐƌĞŬ�ŵĂǁĂƌ�ĚĂŶ�ƐĞĚĂƉ�ŵĂůĂŵ�Ěŝ�ǁŝůĂLJĂŚ��</�:ĂŬĂƌƚĂ

6RVLDO�(NRQRPL�3HUWDQLDQ��%DGDQ�3HQHOLWLDQ� GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ�3HUWDQLDQ���%RJRU�

6XGDU\DQWR�� 7�� <XVGMD�� <��� 3XUZRWR��$�� 1XNPDQ� .�� 0��� %ZDUL\DGL��$�� /LPERQJ�� :�� +�� � ��������

$JULELVQLV� .RPRGLWDV�+RUWLNXOWXUD�� � 3XVDW� 3HQHOLWLDQ�GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ� 6RVLDO�(NRQRPL� 3HUWDQLDQ�� %DGDQ�3HQHOLWLDQ� GDQ� 3HQJHPEDQJDQ�3HUWDQLDQ���%RJRU�

/DPSLUDQ����%XQJD�.ULVDQ��0DZDU��$QJJUHN�GDQ�6HGDS�0DODP�\DQJ�7HUVHGLD�GL�3DVDU�%XQJD�5DZD�%HORQJ


Recommended