PROGRAMA ACADEMICOASIGNATURA MTODO Y ANLISIS COMPARADOCODIGO2015196 - 1NIVEL ACADEMICOQUINTO SEMESTREDOCENTE: PEDRO ELIAS GALINDO LEN PhDUNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE COLOM!IASEDE!OGOT"ACULTAD DE DEREC#O$ CIENCIAS POL%TICAS Y SOCIALESDEPARTAMENTO DE CIENCIA POL%TICASEGUNDO SEMESTRE ACADEMICO DE 2015Mtodo Comparado - 0METODO Y ANALISIS COMPARADOTabla de ContenidoPROGRAMA ACADEMICO.............................................................................................2PRESENTACIN...........................................................................................................21. OBJETIVOS.........................................................................................................22. METODOLOGA.................................................................................................23. CONTENIDO DEL CURSO:...............................................................................34. EVALUACIN.....................................................................................................46. SESIONES DE TRABAJO..................................................................................5. !ORMA DE CITAR.............................................................................................5". TE#TOS DE RESE$AS......................................................................................5%. LECTURAS B&SICAS........................................................................................610. LECTURAS SUGERIDAS..................................................................................Mtodo Comparado - 1UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE COLOM!IASEDE!OGOT"ACULTAD DE DEREC#O$ CIENCIAS POL%TICAS Y SOCIALESDEPARTAMENTO DE CIENCIA POL%TICAPROGRAMA ACADEMICOS&'()*+ ,&-&,./& *& 2015MTODO Y ANLISIS COMPARADODOCENTE: PEDRO ELIAS GALINDO LEN PhD.'()*+*,-,(.'-/-0-201512.-*).,(.Cuando un fenmeno vara de alguna manera particular, es causa o efecto de otrofenmeno que vara de la misma o de otra manera, pero concomitantementeC-3(3 V. M4+(0( 05 )-6 V-/*-,*(356 C(3,(.*+-3+567 0+h) S.(1/. M233 R&,+3(425) 61572010 8 C+),&9+ *& S&*& : &3 A/. 2; *&3 A4(&/*+ 00< *& 200)2-+ *&1,2,.&)4212015196P/&'/1*+C2&)421P+3>.241D2,42=32)1/M?.+*+ :1)@32,2,4+-=1/1*+; 90APRESENTACINL- '()8+*,- ,(.'-/-0- 56 .4+(0(05 56+90*(6*6+5.:+*,(;,(.'-/-0( 05 6*6+5.-6 ;/528.5356 '()8+*,(67 056,-36- 53 93- /5-)*0-0 (/2-3*56+*2-0(/ ; 69 '/('?6*+( 56 5) 56+-=)5,*.*53+( 05@(.()(28-6 56+/9,+9/-)56 '()8+*,-6 5,(3?.*,-6 ; 6(,*-)56. L- -')*,-,*?3 05) .4+(0(,(.'-/-0( 53 )- C*53,*- P()8+*,- +*535 =-65 +/-363-,*(3-).1. OBJETIVOS E) ,9/6( +*535 ,(.( (=A5+*>( '/('(/,*(3-/ )-6 =-656 B930-.53+-)56 05 )- P()8+*,-C(.'-/-0-7 5) 5C-.53050*B5/53+56.4+(0(69+*)*56+*2-,*?3.2. METODOLO!AE) ,9/6( ,(36+- 05 32 656*(356 53 16 65.-3-6 05 +/-=-A(. C-0- '-/+*,*'-3+5 65 ,(.'/(.5+5 -/5-)*56+*2-,*?3 F95 /5-)*,53 )(6 2/9'(6 )(6 56+90*-3+56 A68 .*6.(7 F9*5356 -6*6+53 ,9/6(-05)-3+-/:3 93- *3>56+*2-,*?3 6(=/5 93 +5.- 56'5,8B*,( 05P()8+*,- C(.'-/-0- ; '/5653+-/:3 93 ')-3 05 +/-=-A(7 F95 ,(3+-/: ,(3 -656(/8- 09/-3+5 5)Mtodo Comparado - 265.56+/5 '-/- 69 056-//())(7 65 .,(.')5+-/: ,(3 )- /56()9,*?3 05 )(6 '/(=)5.-6 '/:,+*,(6 05*3>56+*2-,*?3 F95 65 ')-3+553 - '-/+*/ 05 )- '/5653+-,*?3 'G=)*,- 05 )(6 '/(;5,+(6 05 )(6'-/+*,*'-3+56 53 )(6 -6'5,+(6 05 0*65H(7 ,-.'( ; -3:)*6*6 05) +/-=-A(.E) *3B(/.5 B*3-) 65/:53+/52-0( -) +5/.*3-/ )- G)+*.- 656*?3 05) 65.*3-/*(.". CONTENIDO DEL C#RSO$ E6+5,9/6(56+:56'5,*-).53+50*/*2*0(-56+90*-3+5605C*53,*-P()8+*,-,(.('-/+505)&/5- 05 I3>56+*2-,*?3 05) C(.'(353+5 05 !(/.-,*?3 D*6,*')*3-/-P/(B56*(3-). E3 5) ,9/6(65'/5653+-305B(/.-6*6+5.:+*,-)-6 (/*53+-,*(356 .5+(0()?2*,-6 535) 056-//())(05),(3(,*.*53+( 53 )- C*53,*- P()8+*,- E) ,9/6( +*535 +/56 ,(.'(353+56: 1E I3+/(09,,*?3 - )- P()8+*,- C(.'-/-0- 2E E6+90*( 05 )(6E3B(F956 +5?/*,(6 B930-.53+-)56 3E U3 ,(.'(353+5 '/:,+*,( 05 -')*,-,*?3 - )( )-/2( 05),9/6( 05 )- M5+(0()(28- 05) -3:)*6*6 ,(.'-/-0(. IntroduccinL- '()8+*,- ,(.'-/-0- ,?.( .4+(0( L- *.'(/+-3,*- 05 )- ,(.'-/-,*?3. L- '()8+*,- ,(.'-/-0- I(=A5+( ( .4+(0(J E) -3:)*6*6 ,(.'-/-+*>( 6*6+5.:+*,(. L- )?2*,- 05 )- *3>56+*2-,*?3. D*65H(6 ; 56+/-+52*-6 05 )- ,(.'-/-,*?3. L- 65)5,,*?3 05 ,-6(6: F94 ,-6(67 ,9:3+(6 ,-6(6 I3>56+*2-,*?3 ,(.'-/-0- 6*3,/?3*,- ; 0*-,/?3*,-. V53+-A-6 ; )*.*+-,*(356 05) .4+(0( ,(.'-/-0(Enfoques tericos 1. E) E6+90*( 05 )- P()8+*,--. D*>5/6-6 ,(3,5',*(356 05) E6+-0(=. L- ,(.')5A*0-0 05) -'-/-+( E6+-+-),. C(3,5'+(6 05 /42*.53 '()8+*,(0. !930-.53+(6 05 )- 05.(,/-,*-5. C(36()*0-,*?3 05 )- 05.(,/-,*-2.E) 53B(F95 6*6+4.*,(3. D56-//())( '()8+*,( ; ,(30*,*(356 5,(3?.*,-64. T5(/8-6 05 )- 05'53053,*-5. T5(/8-6 05) D56-//())(6.E) 35( *36+*+9,*(3-)*6.(. L-6 +5(/8-6 05 )- 5)5,,*?3 /-,*(3-)". L- ,9)+9/- '()8+*,-%. P)9/-)*6.( ; 35(,(/'(/-+*>*6.(Metodologa del anlisis comparado10. .I3+/(09,,*?3 - )(6 '-6(6 05 )- *3>56+*2-,*?3 ,(.'-/-0-: )- 5)5,,*?3 05) +5.- 05 *3>56+*2-,*?3.11. .!(/.9)-,*?3 ; ('5/-,*(3-)*56+*2-,*?3 ( ,?.( ,(.'/(=-/ @*'?+56*613.E)-3:)*6*6 05 )(6 0-+(6.14. .L-6 )*.*+-,*(356 05 )- -')*,-,*?3 05) .4+(0( ,*53+8B*,( 53 ,*53,*- '()8+*,-Mtodo Comparado - 3%. EVAL#ACINL- 5>-)9-,*?3 (+(/2- 93- 3(+- -) B*3-) 05) '5/*(0( F95 ,(//56'(305 -) '/(,56( 05 0565.'5H(; -'/530*56+*2-,*?3 -68,(.()-'/5653+-,*?305) +/-=-A(B*3-). E) ,/*+5/*(055>-)9-,*?3+530/:53,953+- 93-'/('(/,*?3 05 )-6 ,9-+/( '-/+56 05) '/(,56(: P-/+*,*'-,*?3 D10KE7 R565H-6 D30KE7 A>-3,56 05)T/-=-A( D30KE7 T/-=-A( !*3-) D30KE L(6 +/-=-A(6 '/5653+-0(6 65 ,(.'(353 05 0(6 '-/+56 '-/-69 5>-)9-,*?3: +/-=-A( 53>*-0( ; 69 696+53+-,*?3 ,('9)-+*>-.53+55 PROGRAMA DE TRA!A0O M?.+*+, C+-=1/1*+,"EC#ASESIN TEMA AVANCES ENTREGAA'. 11 1 S(,*-)**09-) 242B 23 S96+53+-,*?329 24 S96+53+-,*?3 I3B(/.5 !*3-) 05) G/9'( 31N+C; 25 S96+53+-,*?35 26 S96+53+-,*?310 2 S96+53+-,*?312 2" S96+53+-,*?31B 2% S96+53+-,*?319 30 S96+53+-,*?326 31 S96+53+-,*?3 D+4(-&).+ D2)13 232 C*5//5 05 3(+-6* No se recien correos envia!os !es"u#s !e $a %echa & hora esta$eci!aMtodo Comparado - 4&.SESIONES DE TRABAJOL(6 +/-=-A(67 ,(3 5C,5',*?3 05) D+4(-&).+ 05 M-;( 227 05=53 65/ 53>*-0(6 -) ,(//5( 05),9/6( 53 )- B5,@- 56+-=)5,*0- -) ,(//5(=+32.2414+-=1/1*12015E'-1234+-&3 *>1,@F1*+ANTESDE31,1B:00#+/1,E) 0(,9.53+(B*3-) 05*3>56+*2-,*?32/9'-) 6553+/52-/: *.'/56( 5) 08- 26 *& O4.(F/& ANTES *& 31, 12:00 -&/2*21)+'. (ORMA DE CITARTOMADO DE:R&C2,.1 C2&)421 P+3>.241$=(F3241425),&-&,./13 *&3 D&=1/.1-&).+ *&C2&)421P+3>.241 *&31U)2C&/,2*1* N142+)13 *& C+3+-F21INSTRUCCIONES PARA LOS AUTORESGHI L1, )+.1, *& =2& *& =@'2)1 : 31 F2F32+'/1D>1 '&)&/13 *&F&) ,&'(2/ 31, ,2'(2&).&, =1(.1,: 'Cita !e $iro en (enera$ M(/53(7 L9*67L-B505/-)**6+-902Q/9231Q0(66*5/3.@+.). !5,@- 05 ,(369)+-:6:=-0( 1 05 B5=/5/( 05 200.S5.65;7 V*R+(/*-. T/-36*,*?3 '()8+*,- 53 L932/8-7 1%"%-1%%0. E3:@++':QQMMM.9,..56QBUCMQ/5>*6+-6Q2@*Q0214400CQ-/+*,9)(6QCLCO%3%311015A.PD!. !5,@- 05,(369)+-: >*5/356 16 05 B5=/5/( 05 200.). TE*TOS DE RESE+ASResea crtica comparada !o"#1IM(/)*3(7 L5(3-/0(: P/(=)5.-6 ;(',*(356 05)-C(.'-/-,*?3.FIS-/+(/*7 G*(>*-3*:C(.'-/-,*?3 ; M4+(0( C(.'-/-+*>(.E)$M(/)*3($L5(3-/0( ; S-/+(/*7 G*(>*-3*DE0*+(/56E I3+/(09,,*?3 - )- I3>56+*2-,*?3 C(.'-/-0-. T/-09,,*?3 M-/8- L5/3:305< D8-5 S+90*56 *3 S(,*5+; -30 L*6+(/;7 V(). 227 N(. 2 DA'/.7 1%"0E7 C-.=/*025 U3*>5/6*+; P/566. P:26. 14-1%.FI B-0*57 B5/+/-30 ; L5/.5+7 G9; D1%%3E. P()8+*,- C(.'-/-0-. !CE. M4C*,(7 2010. P:26.-%6. 4IM((/57 B-//*32+(3. L(6 O/825356 S(,*-)56 05 )- D*,+-09/- ;L- D5.(,/-,*-. E0P538369)-. B-/,5)(3-7 1%6. P/()(2(.P:26. % - 21Resea crtica comparada !o"%1INOLLEN7 D*5+5/. C*53,*- P()8+*,- C(.'-/-0-. E) 53B(F95 @*6+?/*,(-5.'8/*,(.B535.4/*+- 93*>5/6*0-0 -9+?3(.- 05 P95=)-7 M4C*,(. U3*>5/6*0-0 05) R(6-/*(7 C()(.=*-.B(2(+:7 2014. P:26.1 S 106. FICAMERON7 M-CM5)). LUNA7 J9-3 P-=)(. D5.(,/-,*- 53 )- R52*?3 A30*3-.U3*>5/6*0-005)(6 A3056. I36+*+9+(05E6+90*(6 P5/9-3(6 IEP7P/(2/-.-05N-,*(356U3*0-6 '-/- 5) D56-//())( PNUD7 I36+*+9+( I3+5/3-,*(3-) '-/- )- D5.(,/-,*-; A6*6+53,*-E)5,+(/-) IDEA. I36+*+9+( N55/)-3046 '-/- )- D5.(,/-,*- M9)+*'-/+*0*6+- MIND. E0*,*(356U3*-3056.B(2(+:7 2012.P:26. 13 - 27 514 - 537 33 - 420,. LECT#RAS B-SICASA).(307 G-=/*5) ; S*035; V5/=-. L- C9)+9/- C8>*,-. !930-,*?3 !(566-. M-0/*0. 1%0. B-0*57 B5/+/-30 ; L5/.5+7 G9;. P()8+*,- C(.'-/-0-. !CE. M4C*,(7 1%%3. B*+-/ S5/2*(. L-6 +53053,*-6 .930*-)56 ; 5) B9+9/( 05 A.4/*,- L-+*3-.N-,*(356 U3*0-67S-3+*-2( 05 C@*)5. 2014B(*C C-/)56 DE0*+(/E7 S+(R57 S96-3 C. 6 DE0*+(/E. T@5 OCB(/0 L-30=((R (B C(.'-/-+*>5P()*+*,6DOCB(/0L-30=((R6(B P()*+*,-) S,*53,5EV OCB(/0U3*>5/6*+;P/5667 N5MU(/R7200%.C-/-.-3*7 D-3*5). E0*+(/. C(.'-/-+*>5 P()*+*,6. S5,(30 50*+*(3. OCB(/0 U3*>5/6*+; P/5667N5M U(/R7 2011C-/0(6(7 !5/3-30(. L. ; !-)5++(7 E.D5'53053,*- ; D56-//())( 53 A.4/*,- L-+*3-.S*2)(##I. M4C*,(7 1%6%C())*3*7S+5B-3. W*3,@7D(3-)0. B9//(M7 J@(3. L- P()8+*,- C*53,*- N(=)5.!CE. M4C*,(71%".E-6+(37 D->*0.C-+52(/8-6 '-/- 5) A3:)*6*6 S*6+4.*,( 05 )- P()8+*,-. E37 D*5< T5C+(6 B:6*,(605 C*53,*- P()8+*,-. A/*5)7 B-/,5)(3-7 1%%2.I32)5@-/+7 R(3-)0 M(05/3*-67A)*-3-+*-S(,*50-07 C-/-,-67 V5355 P()*+*,6. OCB(/0 U3*>5/6*+; P/566 INC. N5M U(/R7 2011.Mtodo Comparado - CAIS7 J(/0*.E) -3:)*6*6 @*6+?/*,( ,(.'-/-+*>(. E37M.5+(0()(28- 05) A3:)*6*6C(.'-/-+*>(7 C9-05/3(6 M5+(0()?2*,(67 CIS7 3G.. 21. 2011.C(+-/5)(7 R-.?3. S(=/5 )- T5(/8- P()8+*,-. R5>*6+- E6'-H()- 05 C*53,*- P()8+*,-7 3G.. 17(,+9=/57 200.C(+-/5)(7 R-.?3G. O=A5+(7 M4+(0(;T5(/8-. E37 M. P-6+(/D,(.'.E7 C*53,*-P()8+*,-7M,G/-M-L*)). M-0/*07 1%"%.D-@)7 R(=5/+ A. \94 56 )- C*53,*- P()8+*,-.7 53 S+5'@53 Z. B-*)5;7 C?.( 65 G(=*5/3- 93P-86. L(6 )*=/(6 05) M*/-6(). B953(6 A*/567 1%6". D-@)7 R(=5/+ A. A3:)*6*6 P()8+*,( M(05/3(. !(3+-35))-. B-/,5)(3-7 1%6. E-6+(37 D->*0. C-+52(/8-6 '-/- 5) A3:)*6*6 S*6+4.*,( 05 )- P()8+*,-. E37 VV.AA7 D*5< +5C+(6B:6*,(6 05 C*53,*- P()8+*,-. A/*5). B-/,5)(3-71%%2.Z*327G-/;7 R(=5/+ O. Z5(@-35 ; S*035; V5/=-.E) D*65H( 05 )- I3>56+*2-,*?3 S(,*-): )-I3B5/53,*- C*53+8B*,- 53 )(6 E6+90*(6 C9-)*+-+*>(6. M-0/*0: A)*-3-6,(.'-/-+*>-6. T(.( 2. E) ,-6( 05 L-+*3(-.4/*,-7 M-0/*07 A)*-35P()*+*,6. E37 G((0*37 R(=5/+ E. -30 Z)*325.-337 L-36-D*5+5/. E0*+50. T@5 N5M L-30=((R(BP()*+*,-) S,*53,5. T@5I3+5/3-+*(3-) P()*+*,-) S,*53,5 A66(,*-+*(3. OCB(/0U3*>5/6*+;P/566. N5M U(/R71%%"M-3@5*.7 J-/() B. ; R*,@-/0 C. R*,@. C(36+/9,,*?3 05 93- T5(/8-: C(3,5'+(6 5 L*'?+56*653 C*53,*- P()8+*,-. E37 A3:)*6*6 P()8+*,( E.'8/*,(. M4+(0(6 05 I3>56+*2-,*?3 53 C*53,*-P()8+*,-7 A)*-35/6*0-0 T5C+(6. M-0/*07 1%"6.P-35=*-3,(7 A325)(. C(.'-/-,*?3 ; EC')*,-,*?3.E37 G. S-/+(/* ; L. M(/)*3( D506.E7 L-C(.'-/-,*?3 53 )-6 C*53,*-6 S(,*-)56. A)*-356+*2-,*?3 P()8+*,-. E37 G. P-6F9*3( D5+ -).E7M-39-) 05 C*53,*- P()8+*,-7 A)*-35/6*0-0 T5C+(6. M-0/*07 1%%6.P-6F9*3(7 G*-3B/-3,( D2000E. L- ,)-65 P()8+*,-. A,53+( E0*+(/*-). M-0/*0.R-2*37 C@-/)56 C.7 B5/2-S,@)(665/7 D*/R ; D5 M59/7 G*6])5.L- M5+(0()(28- 53 C*53,*-P()8+*,-: M4+(0(6 C9-)*+-+*>(6. E37 R.E. G((0*3 ; L-D. Z)*325.-33 D506.E7 N95>( M-39-)05 C*53,*- P()8+*,-7 T(.( II. I6+.(. M-0/*07 2001.S-/+(/*7 G*(>-33*. P-/+*0(6 ; S*6+5.-6 05 P-/+*0(6. A)*-3-33*. IL-,*- D?305 >- )- C*53,*- P()8+*,-J E37R5>*6+- E6'-H()- 05 C*53,*-P()8+*,-7 3G.. 127 2005.S-/+(/*7 G*(>-33* ; M(/)*3(7 L5(3-/0( D506.E: L- C(.'-/-,*?3 53 )-6 C*53,*-6 S(,*-)56.A)*-3