28
'l'l'Ylliftm1"ll l!:lrf.rt..t A'V .. 'Lo' ""' d 'U.l !J 'U.l GlJ 'U. "HI !JlL nl 'Yl GJ l!J A IV 'U.l!J'U."lli.'l 'Yl d m u 'l 'l'l1on! L lj''U.'il 'U. 'Yl f ®j 'l"ll !J " .l 'YJ G)O 'lmim <i)GJ "I <' < d 'U.l !J u 1:: lj' .J 'l'l TV\ :IJ <111 n'l,j< 'Yl GJ l!:J At <O.l 'U.l !J lj'1 !J 1 fl <il:: :IJ 'Yl <i)"' ' 'U.1mn1n 'l011im GJ<i:' 0 .-d 'U.ltl<ill"i".Jlli L"'lti:IJ1<iltl 'Yl ,_,ct '

คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

fll<n.Jn~r~D\Jmn\1

1-u.~ ltfi~em i-u.11~:u 'l'l'Ylliftm1"ll l!:lrf.rt..t

A'V .. 'Lo' ""' d 'U.l !J 'U.l GlJ 'U. "HI !JlL nl 'Yl GJ

mum-:~'l'li.'l ~GlJ'U.L"llu ~ l!J

A IV ~.d 'U.l!J'U."lli.'l ~i.'I~'U.'Yl1 'Yl d

'U.1!Jln1L~<il

m u 'l 'l'l1on!

L lj''U.'il 'U. 'Yl f ®j 'l"ll !J ~ ~ " .l

<111~\'1111 'YJ G)O

mu~1m~ 'lmim ~ <i)GJ

"I <' ~ < d 'U.l !J u 1:: lj' .J ~ 'l'l TV\ :IJ <111 n'l,j< 'Yl GJ l!:J

At <O.l 'U.l !J lj'1 !J 1 fl <il:: :IJ 'Yl <i)"'

' 'U.1mn1n 'l011im ~ GJ<i:'

0 ·~ .-d 'U.ltl<ill"i".Jlli L"'lti:IJ1<iltl 'Yl ,_,ct

'

Page 2: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

tl ... .. t d U1.:1~11j1 U LlJ1l.:J f1'111 'Yl lj)el

... tl d U1.:1~111HIIfl1llJ 1 fllJ 'Yl l!:lo

' v ~ """ d ~ d

U1!.Jfi.:J'VIU '1'\iihllJ"l.:Jfl 'Yl \!Jij)

U1.:1'1'111Uih Li:iEJ.:J Lf1~1 ~ 1!:11!:1

CIJA~At .,j U1!.J'l!!.J1'Yl!.J LlJ1l.:J f1~1 'Yl l!:lm

t .f.. d U1!.JliU1'Yl1 YlliLlJ1l.:J 'Yl !!Jet

.. ... d U1!.J~lJYI.:Il:t L~'l!lJ11 'Yl l!J.t

1.\1!.Jnl.1.:J~ urumtl ~ 1!:1..! • v

... f{' cv d U1!.J~1~.:1'1'1 lil.\1.\'Yl1 'Yl mo

' ~ d 1.\1!.J~nl.l. ~1lU1.\1fl 'Yl mlj)

' 1.\1!.J'Ilu~ l11a1 ~ ml!J

m1l'l'lvh~1!.J~~~LLvl.:Jtl1~l'Yll'll'Yl!.J ~ lj)

f1 m~m111 m1u tum !.J VI <1.:~.:~11-l.LL vi.:J'l!1~

Page 3: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

m

fl ~ d' ~ YJ B -.1 fl ~ ,f -.1 <n lJ a 1J L ~ ~ fl '11. YJ B -.1 l l ~ YJ B -.1 fl ~ ,f -.1 HllJ a 1J L ~ ~ fl '11. ~ ~

Ltlmh::'lfl'lf'll.~~n Blfi'umi1uvi'u~ ~ i-.lvrl'~1lJ~-.1Lu.iJl l-n-.1 'l~LLTi i-.l'VIl~L .:nun1u ~

Q,oo .......... Q.; ..... Q...,S ......................... .....

'il-.l'VI'l~Lt'l£1 'ii,'I'VI'l~'VI'Il.B,'JfllU 'il-.l'VI'l~U-Jnl'', 'il-.l'VI'l~Ufl"il'l'll.lJ 'il-.l'VI'l~lJnill'VIl'i 'il-.l'V\1~ • eh'll>l'iiL 'il'iru LLt'l::i-.l'VIl~Buan'lfmit 1~ utl1::'lfl'lfU 1 'll>nci lJi-.l'VIl ~~-.1mh111lJJ-.1 ~Yl B-.11'1~

"" 1 't 'U

J-.lallJaU L~~fl'll. l~1'llJ<il'lriB~-.l Lfl1B"lh UU1::'lfl i-.lfllJL'Yl £JL vi BLL:J.iJ11'1J-.1 Ld BU1::lJl rn

,.. • .. tid d !'I ,. • tJ ~ ~ · .Y' 1 u 'VU'L l!:Jclclm l?lBlJllJnl1L t'I£JU'lfBLumfi1B"IJ1£J 1::'lfl'lf'll. ~ 'il-.l'VI'l~t'l:lhi>l "IJ-.1 • 1~ £J ij-)1;) {] ti1:: H -.1 rfl '11. nl11'llJ 'i11 n '11. L U U'lflJ 'lf'll.L vi B tJ n iJ B -.1 B '11. 1 n H ~ '11. ~ 'lflJ 'lf '11.

'l 't 'I 'U 't

'111'1'1 £Jlndll11lJ'lfl ~ ~-.1 LL'l ~ ~ B lJ 1 '11. Yi'u ~ alJJ11 "IJ-.l"IJ B.J L 'Y1 £J 1~ £!~ LL:J.iJ11"1J-.1 L UULL:J.iJ1 • ~ijfl'lllJ ~l ~ ru LLt'l:: Ufl'lllJ ~ n ~u~ B11'lfBl rn1i n;'l 'Y1 u in lll1rn 1vtl;::'lflntl'l~ u

~ ~ ~

ti;::'lfl'lf'll.t'll'l n'lfBl nni mn IJ'I'I'lfl LLG'I::alnl1ru.1vi-.lfllJil.UlJL l £J~UllJ LLG'I::LU'Il.LL'VI a.JJ1 ~ ~

~ umllJ~lv1ru 1 uniimfl LBL -1i u ~::1uB B muu-.1 1~ <fr-.11'vul a"IJ B.,,r., a-: ti1::L '111'1 MLLri ~ ~ ~

LL a:: H1lll 1 rn 1v i.J fllJU£1 lJ L l £J ~'11.1 :1J l~ i ~rh'Jl B ~ n a -.1 l1 ~1 U nl111 lJ 5j B nl1~011 '11. 1 ~

alJLL:J.iJl1'1J-.lLLUU!T-.l nu 'VI1B "ml :IJ~nt'l-.lLL:J.iJl1 "IJ-.1" el'll.LU'Il.nl1rl B~-.11'1 rn::m;mnm; • LL:Iht11"1l-.l <ft.,tl;::nBU~'l£1 flrn:::~.~u~11'1ru.::nnlJnl11'llJ'illnti;::L'Yli'IHlJl~n LLa:: ~1li'n-.1lULa"lllnm;fl rn::m1lJlnnTml.i J11"1l-.1 6ft"~ B m fl rn:: m;m1fm1LL:J.iJ 11"1l-.1

'l~ ri B<k-.lfl rn::m;m1fm1LL:J.i J 11"1l-.1 LL vi-.l'lfl~-1fu L vi m~li'u 'm um;n 'il"ll B-.11'1 rn::mnn1fm; '

LL:J.i J 11 "IJ-.1 flnL:::IJUIP\1 LL vi-.l'lf1~ LLa::!'lrn::nTI:IJnlTI'J:IJ"IJ1l-.lLL~ a::ti1::L '111'1 t~ujj LiJl'VI:IJl£J11:1JTl '11.

L vi B ai'l-.1 fl'lllJ L 'Jl :lJ LL iJ.J~1U nl111lJ jj B t~ £J nl 1HU1J HU U. fill :lJ i:IJ ~u.1h:: '1'\ll -.1 • "'rn:: m1 :1.11nm1 ul.i J 1 b-.1 LL a ::1vm <HL vi-.1'Jf1 ~ t~ u m ;tl ;:: a1 U.-.llu.1 u. m •~h L ii. u.

~

n'ilm1:1J~l" 'J "ll B-.lfl rn::m;mnm1LL:J.iJ1 t "ll-.1 1 u.;::iu'lfl~~mm.,ai'l-.1 LLa:: B-.lfi"tl;::n Bu

"IJ B-.lfl rn:: nd1lJllfnl1 LL:J.i J 11"1J-.1 LL vi -.1 'lfl ~~ LL~ n ~l-.1 n u.1 U.LL ~ t'l ::ti;:: L 'Y1 1'1 1 ~ U ~l 'VIf1J

1l'liill rn l..ij mll1 !J jj n1lJl11'1'l !Jl mJ l~-.1 L Utm 1-b !J -.ll '\1, 1 '\1,.r -.10 WI"!J il .,j ~ (] nYJ il .,j 1'1 ~ .y\ cr ~~

'Yi1'VIthr! dhfflU n Li1"1lllfnl11'1 rn:: n11:1Jllfnl1LL~-iJ 11 "IJ-.lLL vi -.l'li1~ l 'Y1 U ~ B:IJlU1::L Ylflft:IJl~n M t'l-.1\.l.l:U 1 u'll B ~ n i1-.lll ~l £J fill :1.1-il:U jj ElL vi B nl1~\lll U.1 ci :lJ Jl LL~-iJ 11 'lJ" 1l ~l" tt., n u.

'

Page 4: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

L~a1u~ rt. L~l!f1EJll. l!Jrt.md m i~VI1~L-nEJ~11EJ 11'lHJ1m1in11:rm 1~EJ'li't~~mH~.Jmh1 i1wn::tl"i::nt~u~1EJmt~um.Jn!)VIlJ1rJ ~1'\.I.Ti1V1'1t1~'lJtJ.Jm1m~m1 m<nTV\'\.I.~VI~nm"i LflrJ1JltJ0111'J!J1'il1nLL:J.hf11'lJ.J 011rl1'V\'\.1.~1ULLtJtJtl.J~m n11L~'\.I. LL~::011tJ1'V111

~

dd ~ ~ tl 'tl ~ ::.r d1~~ ~ ~ YlLOrJ1'lJtl.JOtJ011 1::<'1'1'\.I..Jl'U."i::V\11.J "i::L'Yli'IL'I'lJl'll'n Yh'l'\.1. L'l'ltl VILO<i1011tl'\.1.10H

' ~.JLL1<il~ tllJ 011~<nl'\.1.1 tlUl.J tT.JU'\.1. 1<ilrJi1fl11lJ11lJi1 tlLLtJtJfl ihm1 L vi t~lii:i fl11lJL rilL .yj rllJll'\.1.

" 1 'U.9Jl'U.LI'1dl.Hifl'il LL~::a.JfllJ L vl tl ~.J LL'I'1lJfl ill111'1'l:j\i <il~ ~'lJ tl.Jl.h::'Jl'10d 1utilJJ1 'fi tllJl

d ' '

"''~ 1""!'VJv.o:::~-=o.dQ..O.d flill:lJ'U.<i1111<i11rJLL~'\.I..Jl'\.1.011 'Jl''\.1.1 L~lJlJ<i1LlJtl1'\.I.'Yl G)d <il~lfllJ l!J<foc'l!J LL~::

' fl m::m<:JJm111:JJL9i'i:i:JJ~1'1-1.fln1m11h::'ll':JJL~ t~'l-l.n lJm~wti l!:J<fc;:'\;) i <11Yh1:: Lu vuu nu'1i

' ' 6.1

L~tl.J011LLi.J m<u1nM1VI11t~<i1.JVI'!!1 LL~::'li't~<iln~.J (Procedure for Notification Prior

Consultation and Agreement: PNPCA) LvlmllmL'\.1.1'Yl1.JUfiu~!t1VIfuti1::L'Yli'!Gi'lJ1onn Lfl [.J1JltJn1d'illL it un 'ilnd"i:IJ 1<11 <] 1'U.LL11J11 'lJ.J 1<11 EJ"i::LU [JtJ~.Jn<i11 M ~1'\.l.flll:IJL ~'U.'ll'tlll 'illnflru:::JJW3111'1-1.m1U1::'ll':JJflf.J~ 0)0 Ldt~l'\.1.~ rno 'l'l(]l'l'iimvu l!J<toc'\J rn m.J'I'l'U.lJLUru

' ' . "il'll't~lrnlimnm.:J'll'l ~n::Lu uu~.Jn<i11 'l9ln1VI'I-I.<il hlm1 HJ11<11 <J 'llt~.Jf~<'~':JJl-lln 1<11 <J

~.Jm'ilii ~ ~m::'Ylu t1 r.i1.J i1 uv&t1~ ru<;i tlfl rnm'I'IJ 1'1'11 t~1::uum1 'l VI ~'lJ t~.J<11J1 <'1'1 vu1::1nu . ' "JJ tl.J1::u mLllJ11'll.J fl rn:: nT):JJ m1-i1:JJiJ i'hm'il'Ylum mLl.l::u1u u1.J LlJ m:: u:: '1 m:JJ~

' L ~wihd'J '1-1. 1<11 rJ f-.1 ~011o11 L it'l-l.m"i..J.J n ri11 LU'\.1.~ ~m'il1nm1t11n Mlvn1 t1 ft1.JVI'!!1

LL~::U1::LiJ'U.011 HJ1~011Lf;f'U.fl1<il ') elULU'\.1.011~'\.1. Jl'li'l:JJ <i:JJJ11 '\.1, 1::ll'il.J(] <ilJl ' "

m'illn<11Jl<'~'lrJt11::1l1'1-1. d1:JJ~.Jm1 HJ11 'l-l.ti:JJJ1L~rJ1n'l-l. Vl1t~m1~'1-1. J1'1i'1:JJ<i:JJJ1 ' '

1 '\.1. 1::'1'\ il.J (] <i1 U ~.J ~.Jf'ii1:JJ ~.J LL1JJ'11<11 EJ fl ru:: Od1:1J1li011LL1JJ'11'1J.J LL V:.J'Jl'l ~~ L fl EJ1'Jl tl.J ~ ~

iJV1'!!1~u i.J 'lu U.Jfl m::m1:JJm1-i1:JJ ~1'1-1.~1Un.Jl'I-I.Li.l'lJ1lim1fl ru:: m1:JJ11im1uliJ11 "JJ.J

ri tl'\.1. ~ 'il:: i1 m1o11 Lit '1-1. m 1 L d t1 iJ m 1 LL i" fl rn:: 011 :JJ m1"i1:JJ 1<11 u ~1 '!! n.Jl'I-I.L i.l'lll 15 011

flm::m1mlim1LLliJ11'1J.J'il::~.JLt~n<'~'11lu u.J1~<'~':JJ1onn ~'1-1. <J L vi mtl<i11t~m<'~' hlf2"m-lln I 'V I I 'V

1:JJi1.JLL1l'l1,1 ~'\.I.') iJ~'Ylli'il::t~fitl11 rJLLi.l::U1::dJ'U.f..l~ m::'YltJ'lJ tl.J 0111 'J!Y\ LL'I''U.tl'3i eJ 0111 'Jl'\1,1

LLi.l:: ~ ~nd::'YltJ ~ '\.1. ') 1<11 U ~ Y1 eJ .J fl ~~.J f;fl:IJ ~tJ L ~ <il fl'\.1. LcoJftJ flll:IJ L~ eJ <111 tl'\.1. '1'11 eJ L ft EJ'V\1 EJ ~

'ill n m 1~ <'~'11111 rn 1'iiu 1::'D'1 liu'l<il u u1::'ll'l'll''l-l.i.l11 i1 n1 'VI '1-1.<11 n11'il:: <'1'11-J L ~ 11 '1-1. '1'1 thnu d

'lvlvh'lonv::u1 nl~.Jm1~i1<il'lvlY1l'lJ'I-I.l<il OJ,kl.t<t L:JJn::i<il'il :fiuumLl.iJ1 b.J u1L1rn '

i.Jw1., L'llu::u1 <'~'11l11m1'iiu1::'ll'1Titl'l<iluth::'lll'll'-'i.l11 101md 11iu~ oc 'l'l'JMfllfi:JJ l!J <ttto ' d

f'iiulmL V:.JL'I'lll11rn1nb::'ll'1TIUL<il utl1::'l!l'l!Ui.l11LL~::u1B''Yl '1!. n11'1i1.J -;hn<il (:l.I'V\l'l!'\.1.) ~ ~

Page 5: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

b "'"' n.n, U,t"~rlrl_!! ?'J'J'Gt N:~U:!l£> i"'Gt ~tl..F~ L~tvt~rJLI!.Cl}'LilllllllLl-'~1 <!.> ~~~~(J~Ul1~~~11

"'"' ?'J'J'"'l N:~LWN: <!.><!.> ~'tl~(J~1rl(Jlt.t1.~1~rtg: J' ~~~~Cl~Ul1~~V: N:~1N:~1rl(Jlt.'tl~1N:LW n.n. ....... b "'"

N L 'I1J l.L"-~ ;p ~~~~CJ ~u l1 ~ N L~tvt ~ rJ Lll.CJ }'Lru rull c-~ _:t ~ l,.ll1H.LU L~ t£> t£> 1 Lru n CJ ~m ~

~(J ll.tl.l~'tl ~ LIIW_? 1(J \hrl(llt.'tl ~ 1N:Ll~_:t ~~ 'ltL~~~M 'ltt111~~11rlLrlrll 'It 'ltL~U_!tL~ULH~I.I.rl Lll b

nuL"-UCl'lt rlU.~ LHLll'tll}1tl.lkl \h~l.LU'tl '!}1L~N ~ll11 'ltlk'! \!>1l.LU~(Jfl.~~ ~'ltl}1l.~'tlLI.I.N:MU 1~l.U ~ ~·

b ...... b "'"' Z,l,..l.l. ~ rJ l£>ll.LUL~ 1£> l£>1 LIU'ItCll.LUtl.lrl::l.U rJ l£>l~rl (J Z,LI.I._:t ~ L~tvt 1 rJ Lll.CJ}'Lill lUll U L"-l£> ~ 1~

[, l£>~ ULM~Clffo (?' ::'11Jl.L!Ilk'!Cl\h~~(Jfforlt11l£>Q1~(J~ <!.> ~~~~(J~UU~~ll11 ("MM) 'ltLC'~~M'Itt111

"'"' :: ~ 11 rJ L rl rJ 111.11. L ~ U _!1. L~ ( u:> ~ _£. ~ U g ft 1.1. ~ rl (J lt. 'It~ 1 ;p ~ ~ ~ ~ (J ~ U l1 ~ _:t ~ (J 11. k'! 1 ~ (J ~ ft 1 ~ . "' b n. "' "'

Ill~ L~ ~ l.Lk'! 'Itt fl. \J 11l.LU g: ft1 U Ll.l. 'lt(J ~ rl(Jk'! "-ll.l£> l£>1'! ~k'!l.LU rJ lJ _:t ~ L~ tvt 1 rJ Lll.(Jf! LIU fllll

~L~(J'tlk'! 1 ~(J ~ ( G\ P w;p Gt • W M ~1!.1 Lj;1.ft11 ~I'!U 1£> N: LW rl_!!~(J ,.\'! ~l£>(Jk'! ~Lfl Cll.LU'tl'!} 1 L~ ~(J ~ ~

~fl ~ rlJ!.1 11. (J ~ 1 l.LUC'l.~l ( <!.> _? ~~ 1!.1 'lt(J ~1~t rl Lll ~k L~ lvt ~ rJ Lll.CJ}'LfU fUll 'It ~N: L 'It ~I'! n. n. .... lo n. n. l'l:>lb

C!J U.l£>~~(JMUL1t·:111,1 l£>Lfll'lt(JU. W U.l£>~C'(JMUL1t1~(Jfl.(Jtl.k'!l(Jfl.N:Ll£>l£>N:N: G[ U.l£>~~(JMUL1t1 F' F" L1." "" "" t. F F' F" 1.1.~ "' ..... ... F" f" p 1..1." .....

b

l_llll~rl~rll!.l., 'tl(J ~ 1~L_tkll.LU'Itt 'tlllA.f1N:_.¥'1tL~'It~ ~I'!Ul£>N:Ll~N:L'tl~l'!l.LU U:~l., l£>_!!L\' }Cl l1lLM b ~ ~

~ rl~ rl !!.1., U.!;l [;_r1:: 1'!11lLI'!tl.lt.Llt.~l. f1 rJ l£>l..f1~ Llt. ~l.f1 ~ _£. 'I1J l.Ul Lhl ~ )<1.111'! Lr1l<_£. ~l.LU U LH ~ l.l.rl Lll

b "' "' n. ~ rt:: rJ l!.k 'tl(J ~ 1 L~ tvt k rJ Lfl.(J }'Lill Ill_¥ rtL 'tlC'I'!l.LU~ f11 L j;1. 'tllJtl._\;1 c-q.~<~.::l. "-t Lffo 1rt LW U ~ 11. _;1'11. t

rtL'ItC'I'!~l.. ('tl.I!.LI.I.rt) l£>_l!L!' c-qr.l.LU ".1!. U,t"~rl::l'!n <!.> ~~~C'Cl~UU~ w;p;pt:ij rt~LIJUW ;p

~'tll(J ~1Lf1:(J !!> ll:lJ>JlG\ rt~L'tlU: WG[ ~tl.~(J ~llL~UC'~"-t Lffo 1N:LWU ~ tl._.ClC'L~rlLl.Url_£-~rt U:~1

"'"' ;p U.l£> ~ C' (J M U l1 t1 C'l!. rJ U 1 LH LlJ'Itf11'tllk'! 1£> 1 l.LU 'It 'It 1 Ll£> 1.1.1 :: 1'!11 'tllk'! 1£> 1 !. LU C'(J fl. I:!£> U 'ltf"1 1 F" "" L;." ,... f"' L1. 1; , 1.\ """ o ..... [, , Lo!, ~ F' 1; b b A lo t.

l.~'tlL l.l.rt M U 1 c-l.UZ.,l,.l.l. t rJ l£>1 l.LU Ll'! lh~l LIU tl.Cll.LU nw::w fl I!> l~ rJ (J _ll.LI.I. _:t t L~tvt 1.. fl Lfl.(J }'

LfU fUll U L"-1!> ~ 1'1tlJ [, l!>t U.LM ~(J _l1. ~lh ~::u rt1 o G\ G\' C!J 'ttl 'It L\' 11.1!> 11 rJ L.l!. 'I1J L~ tvt l..rl Lfl.(J }'

f.LU[;Srl~l ('lt.I!.LI.I.rt) lh1!L\' C'LJl.!.LU ".1!. U.,t"~rlfl_\;1 C!J ~~~C'(J~UU~c-q.~<~.::r.~fl::fll!.l..'lt!l~1

"'"' !. LU C'!. ~lLM M 1 (J li. flf.f. LU "-1 LIT. 1 rt Lt~ U U 11. rl C'Lf.fl (J .1!. '11.1.1. 1 ~1 Gt U. ~ ~ C'(J M U l1 t1 Lrt (J ~ C'l!. k"l'"k _,.. ..., (, ,.. r;:t ... • ~ ..... k f"... L;" ,.. ' p

• (t1..1!.L1.1.rt) 1!>1!L\' c-qr.r.LU ".I!. U!L~fl~11f.LUC'f.~l L'lt~~~U.~N rl~l ~fl::fll!.l.. 'ItO ~1f.LUC'Wl

L~tvt k L~ Lf.~ lJ::I'!11 L~tvt l..rl Lfl.(J'tlk'!1 (J ffo 1:0~1 (rllAl,.) 'ltL_.Cl'lt!l ~ 1~U.1::!.f1r11!L~tvt k 'tlLC'C' ~M 'ttL~ . ~

(J ~ rt t ~ rt LW 'It Lk'! ::r. f1!.LU rt f.!.U 'It (J ::'11J ~ (J \!> c-~ 11~ k t Ll'! 'ltJ].L.I!.::!.f1 rJ ~ kfl:! L.l!.::!.f1!:_£. 'I1J!. UI Lk'! ::I'! 11

t fl:: rJ l!.l.. 'It (J ~ 1fl ~ 1.1. L~!. L U C'!. ~ 1 L t1. ~ ~ 1:1'! U ~ rt L t ~'It~ rt L 'It 1:1'! ~ 1.. ('It .1!. L 1.1. rt) I!>_\;! L ~

C'Lfl.!.LU ".1!. U.,t"~fl ::1'!11lLI'!'It.I!.L.I!.::!.f1rl~l.f1!L.I!.::r.f1£_£.'11Jf.L!lLk'! <!.>;p;pG\ 'tlrJLU~~UM J'G\

~ 11.10 ~1 Lrt !l \!> tL~ UC'~f.LUC'Wl C'!lll.~l.flk 'ltr,!lrtLW LHU~!l ~ 1 "-t L_ll.lllLWU~ 'tl£lLl-'~1

;p

Page 6: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

~ ... ~ o ~ ~ tl Atl~ tl d ~ .r '1.,1.':1 L'IH.J::lJ; 'YiTJLlelj ~1n<il 'llel~tnli1;ru,;:;! ;::"l!T!i L<iiU ;::"Jl1"l!U.OI1l L'YieljlJ'Ifel Lrn'f1~1n . ~

d ~ .. • ~ ~ ' ~ .':1 .. d '1 "' ~ ~ L'llelltL'IfU::u; ~1U.lU. GJ,l!ll!lo L:un::l<il<il <ilel:IJl~nnnel.Jfl<ii'Yl rf. L<iiL'I'Ifll1:1JL'VIU."llellJ ' ~ ~

L fi Ul nlJ aUJ UJ1 n1;nu lJ L~ U. aru ru1 mwhtl;:: n U. LLOI:: iru ru1 'i11U.n1; L~U. 5u. ') -.oQ,/ '1.1 QIQI .,...,

d d ~ ~ 1 d '1 .. '1 • ~ d ~ d mnUl'llel.JnlJ fld.JnljL'IJelU. L'lfU::lJ; 'llel"lfU.1flljnd~ L'YlU ~1n<il (:IJ'I'\1"l!U.} LLOI::LlJellU.'Yl

' ' <i!l:i L:IJM1UU. ~rf.<l.rf. 1J1H'Yl "ll.m;'lh.J ,j1n<il (:1J'1'11"l!U.) L'ii'LLi~71el<i1011<il'l'lfln'Yl1'1'1U

LL 'Vi.Jtlm 'Yli'IL'Y1Ui1 'l<ilii m;OI-\IU.1lJ 1u.aUJUJ1ri el.q1.J L~ elU.~.Jmhlttf-\ILL71 L~ elU.iiU.1fi:IJ ~ rf.rf.rf. u v

.. ~

<il rf. :IJ 'U1 fl :IJ ~ rf. rf. rf. LL 011

u.eln~1 mf u. 1 u. ;::w:h~m•~hL ii. u.m;~~nci1l'll1.J'ii' u. tnli1;rn1 'iitl;::"l!1~tl'l<ii u d

tl;::"l!1"l!U.OI11 'l<il~1 L ii. u.m;L~U.el 1m.Jm•L ~ elU. L'lfu::u171 elfl rn::m;m~m;uli J11'11" '

L~el1iL'll11im::mu.m;LLi.J t11nM1'1'11'1el LLOI::-ilel'ilnOI.J (Procedure for Notification ~

Prior Consultation and Agreement: PNPCA) 'il1:1J'liel'ilnfi.Jm;1iJ1LL1iJ11'1J.J '1'1.1'1. ~rf.rn<i l<ii um::mu.m;'l'ii'L~:IJ~1L ii. u.m;L~ ellU. ~ GJ <il fl1fi:IJ ~ rt.rf.m LLOI::~:: HL 1 011~1 L ii.u. m;

' "' L~ elU. <fl el:IJ1 fl rn::m;m~m;LL1iJ1 h.JLL 'Vi.J"ll1~L'Yl u l<ii u m:u'Yl1w £.nmJ1;fr, ii'ii1U.::

d

dJWI'I1-brmu.1u.a,n\il'llel"~ nnw el"fl&i~ r>: 'l<ili'il h\iJm;1uYr,ml:J..Jfi\iiL V:u~iJ <hu ML~!'J ~~ ~

LLfl::~~ m'ilil~:: 'l<il1u I'J 01m::'Y1m1 nm•~f1" L ~ell.\ L'lfu::u1 ~,m,~1L ii. u.m;'il,n ci11 ~ '

:'1 ' d t '1 ~ 0 A ~ .r ~ d d ~ d LuU~ll.\'1'\U.~'llel·Jn;::lJlU.nl; PNPCA .<iiU L\il\ii1LUU.n1;'il,U. <i!) flj"'Yl <i! L:IJellWYl

0 d ~VIVA ~.J _d.....,..J ~~ :1Jnd1fi:IJ ~rf.rf.r>: ill el1L11elL"l!U~'IIel" ~"'l'll'ilL"llU.Jd1U ~) fld"'Yl ~ L:IJellU.'Yl GJO

,._, 6" o A ,._. a.,.. ,t_ d d .,... .J n:JJ11l'I'IU.lf ~rf.rf.r>: rn el1L11eJL"Jlu~mu. ~"'1'\l'ilLOIU m) flj"'Yl rn L:IJellU.'Yl <il~ ' IVf' 0 A IV.._. :::.,; ...;.._.d

n:JJ111'YiU.lf ~rf.rf.r>: ill el1L11eJL:IJel-\IUfld'ViU:IJ ~"'1'\l'ilU.fld'I'IU:IJ LLOI:: r>:) m"'Yl r>: L:IJellU.'Yl <i!'ol '

n :umwu. TI ~ rf. rf. r>: rn m" L 'Yl'Yi :IJ'I'\11.\fld T<ii m llu.m;tl1n Ml'l'\11 elil :IJ nu ,X nl"ll1 nTi" ' '

L ~ell Lm1 ::~ I'J Olm;ti;::"Jl:u rn flf,~ e.i1U.:IJ1 ~" 1 um;~>~ti1::"Jl:u~" nci11 iJ m; 1'11 LLU" ' '

fl 'ilfl1 U. ·:h"Ji el :IJ 01 ~1 i :IJ1 LU Il n 'ii' el -\1 LL fl:: LU f\1 el lJ fl fl :IJ 71 el n11 L ~U.el fill :IJ L v; U.L fi U l n lJ ~ ~ '

tm,m;1u:fi el 'lvlw1 LLfl::m;ri el.q1-\IL~ elU.L'Ifu::u1 71 el:IJ11'iiu1mL'Vi ""'li1•rn1'iith::"lll~tl'l<ilu ' d d

th:: "1!1 "llU.flllL<il;:: wh m ;riel ~1'1" L ~ el u. L'lf u ::u1 u~ 'tli L ~:u 'ii' u. ~ u n-h m:: u 1 u m1 ' '

PNPCA ~:: LL~l L ~1~ 1 \il !'J m:::lJlU n11<fl" n kn L<flLL<il L ~1~ ~lJlJ'HUL ~ tll U y\ lD lD ~

iJ IlUlUU. lD<l.<l.r>: LLtfl L ifu,~ln!J,jj"Ji tlll.Jlfl'll tl"th::L 'Ylf1~:1Jl:an3 UL~ mn um;~1L ii, U 1m,m1 '

L ~ uu L'lfu::u15u.L lim 'l'l\il1 'l'llli~1m;nm;flu u. m :u~'l<il ~u.m::~.Jtl;:: L 'Ylfl ~m:nn'll u" ' ' '

<8'-

~ ~- ~ ~fJ.Jf'G\"

Page 7: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

~ ru.::m1mlinTlLL1hh 1"ll..:~ii:~.~ ~L ~um1iim1"JJ::aam1riaaf1..:~L ~au L'JHJ::u1 LLa::Laua '

1iiinl1ftmf1L ~:I.IL~:I.IL~ £J1n1Jj:.lfln1::'t11J'Jl1:1.1'1'l1:1.1 LL~mfi aum1fi aaf1..:1 LLwJf~1J1fl ~

LL v:" i.1'1li11 ru. fnh::"JJ1 itlL'tl m.h:: "1!1"1!\l. fl1l11fl uu1~'t1 L'll u:: 1.1~ 'l'l1l L l a f '\i1 n lfl ~ '

LYiiim1a..:IU1111~runnfiai.'ft1..:1L~aU~..:Im'l1li..:~LL'iiL~a~m~:l.ll!:Jrl.cU. numH't1 "JJ. mri1..:1 vv

•hnlfl (:1.1'1'11"JJU) "llaJ11"1Ja1 nt1imL 't1U LLa::ML~:I.Inl1ria af1.,J L ~ au~..:lnfl1l i..:~LLwi1u ~ .. ~

,., rl. :1.1 m f1 :1.1 l!:J rl. rl. rl. LL a 1

~~a..:~fi~J..:~a1 :~.~a-uL~IflflU.L ~wh m1~1L itum1riaah.n~ au L'llu::u'i ~ '

ii LLm 1 'lt':~.~ri a ltKLnlflm1:1.1Lffu'l'l1umh.J11mL1..:1'ii m::uuitn~"lla.JLL~J11"ll.J awil::ri .Jf.lam::nu

wi a~ w a.J~~ J.Ji.1'1:1.1a-uL~ 'tlflu 1 u~~f-l"l'li~h 1Yi ~~ a.Jfl~ J.Ji.1'1:1.1a-u L ~ 'flflULLa::a.J~ mLan~~ u 'II "" 'U ltl

't~m m1 lfl 'VI :1.11 mLa::a an LLn a.J m1rnti'lflti'1u.m1~1 L itu. 1~1" m1L ~au L'll u::u'i'ii a • v

fl ru.::m1:1.111in11LL~ \411 "ll.J f~1.11 aLL V:.J i.1'1li11rn.f;Jl.h::"JJ1itJL'fl UU1::"JJ1"JJUfl1l LLa::f;J1J1 a ~ ~ ~

LLV:n1"JJS1 ru.1i m'tn u L v1 s1iiim1'Yil.l't1lULLa::1::ru1m..:~m1~.Jn fi11 LL'ii m1~1 L itum1

~" n fi11 't~Mfu nl11fl a 1.1 aua.Jil1 nf;Jm aLL V:" i.1'11i11 ru.f;Jtl1::"JJ11itl'1.1fl utl1::"1!1"l!Ua1l ~ ~

LLa::1;Ju1 mL V:.J11"1Js1 ru.1i m't 'YI uLL'ii s ci1.J 1'tl ~..:1'1'11n11"1Ja1ru.1im'tn u '1.~1u~s '1. y.jw1 ~

'\i1mut sur~:: -.irl. 'JJS..:I'I'l~mu '1.ww1~ f.lfl'fl L~il1m~ su L'llu::u1 1m.Jm1~.Jnfl1l r.i sm:X u'hJ '

L tts..:~il1 n i.1'1li11 rn.1'iitl1::'Jnlitl't'tl utl1::'l!1'lma11ii m1:1.1Yi' s..:~ m1 H'l'l ~..:I.J1U '1.vJ~1 hi :l.ll n'l'l a ~

.d a L Yi u 1.1 n mh fl.,j nT'if.lfl'fl '1. W~1'JJ a..:~ L ~au LLOI:: Lrl Ell'lil11nt1 fll1 :I.IYl El.J n11 H1 vJ ~1 "llEl.J i.1'11i11ntf;Ji.Jfl:l.litU:IJ Ll UlflU1 :1.1 LL.rlL ~U l1 iim1LUWJ.Jfll1:1.1 L ~UwJaYl1U tm..:~m1d

~

ov<vd d ~.d •"-' A~,... El U1.J"JJ'fl LL il .J L U a.Jil1 n :1.1 fl11 :1.1 n.Jl <I L 1 El.J f.lrlm::'YilJ<il a'Yl1'1'l U1 n11i11:1.1"JJ11fl LL<I::i.'f ..:1 LL llfl <I El :1.1

'll a.Jtl1::L 'Yl~ 1 u~1u::tl1:: L '11~'111 m ~au 1u'llru.::~ m1ri "'1. vJ~1 'ttl rJ.J i.1'1li11nt1;Jtl1::"JJ1'll'U~ u ~ ~

nii1:: m:m..:~ Lnr!Lbr!::ii Yl'U 'Yl'U:!Jln 11"JJEl1nt1i mL'Yl U~.Jb U'Utl1::L 'YI ~·~ Ul~fl.l~El '1. y.j~1 '

il1n L ~au~" nfi11 ~" t m.J mw].J n a11 L llu tm.J n11~ a1ilii f.l r~ m::'Yl1J~1u~..:~ LL llfl.r s :1.1

'li1 :l.l'l'l1:1.1 LL'fl u a ci1.Jf1 u LL 1" 11"l!El1 ru.1i m't 'YI u 1 U'ii1U:: ~1u~a '1. v-!~1 LL<~:: ~ auu au u .u 'U 'U q

Y11..:1 ~1'U nl1L~U.1 U.nl1 afl.J L ~ ElU.~.J n ol1l ~.Jii'l'l '1t'1~Yl a.JtJl)u'1\ lfl1 :~.~vru.lim rn 'VI <11 U mrn

J..:~lfl1:1.1n£J'I'Imumu lutl1::L'Y1~ LLr~::n£)'1'1:1.11£J1::vd1..:~tl1::L'Y1~ 1'flu~m1rhi~~1~mnu'l.vJw1 "!JD.J~{l nw El.J~~~ Cil LiJ 'Un11~1Ll\ u.1m..:~m1"!JS.J1<i!ti1::Lll'YI'I'\\1..:1'\i.,J,.) s..:~tJn~ lfl1111'iili11:1.11.4rU

'IJ'U .U 01,1 .U 'lJIII

LL V:..:~11"1Ja1 ru.1im 1 'YI u ~ ri1'1'\ u.'tl1 ~ 1.1 ~ ~ <~LLa::'ll:l.l'l!u.ii a-'Ylli~il:: M1u'll a :1.1 <~ LL r~:: ii <h u 11 :1.1 ' ' ~

1 u. t m" nl1'1'1 1 a nil m1:1.1'JJ s" L -;l1 'VI 'It 1 ~'ll a ..:~1'il~ El1il ti" f.l r~ m::'Yll.l wi s 'Ylf'l'l u1 miT11:1.1"1!1 ~ ~

Page 8: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

b nn 1\1\ .!:.f1~rll!.1 '11.1311, 1.!:.LUnl!!lULI'-LMM 1 fJLit,l3l!.Lmm.ll.!:.LUnl!!l'l1. '11.1 L~ (0) IA~l!!t'l3 MUUI':I'A 1 "" lA F' L;,"l.'"k ..r ..... '=' 0 f""" !,.;," """'"

b "'"' 1\1\ ~'11.13.!:.W'I1.F' ~~l!!t'13~UU,tJt'13it,~rt~tm Ci\ ~~l!!t'I3~UU,tJt'131t,~rtU\!1Url~L ·w

~f1~rll!.1, '11.13~ 1.!:.LUC'.!:.l!!l ULI'-L~tA 1, (l~~~.!:.LUf1_\;Jlrl ~ 1 (. ~L .!:.LU'It U 1L!f>~l'-~ 'lt(l!J

'11. ~11 rt.!:.MrtL!Lrl L.!:. ~'t\£l U Ll'-f1U.~W111111~,.\!J1, ~I'. I:'~ 'ltL,(t"-(l ~ 1k> U.1 ~.!:. f1 ::1111 rl U.1, t'~'t1 t 1:'~

• rt l!!t' » ::1111 M LlJ lt,ll rt (l ~ ~ l m ~'ltL,.\!J 11U::W 111':1'11. ~ 1 ::J:.f1.!:.LU ::1111 1:'~1:' ~!'.:: 1111 G M t'rl ~ 1 t'L~ (l ~ ~ ~

'11. ~ 1~~rtLll!!l.'f::\11~.!:.LU rtll::Lrt'A 11.'L~(ll1 ft(l!L~M 11rli11.!:.LU::Il1111 ft(l!LI.'~11.!:.LU l.'~rtU. 11LI1ll:~l.'(llt, ~

~rt::ll11 rl Lrt'AU u IMi.rtH!l~~rtL~~L,!I'A~_[IQ f1L~I.'~IA~l!!l.'l3 ~ u u ~~'At . "1 ~ ~~

lL~UI.' ~.!:.Wt'.!:.l!!l U \!1Urli.'»L~~~t ::1111 rlLrt'AliUf"ll,.\!JI1(ll!.ftl.~Wt'.!:.l!!l't11J1 (0) ~~\,!1.'13 ~U U ,tll.'(llt, ' ' '

• A A

~11::rll!.1, 't113 ~ 1.!:.Lm.!:.l!!l ULI'-L~tA1,flLit,(l~Lmm»J:.LUnl!!l Lf .. L-HULM~~t . (0)

_l:I.'~I.'~L~~G~'AL-HULM~L~~I1Lkl~t (lit,

11Lk\(l ~ 1.'13 ~Lrt ~l!! L !1.1.'-~M~ ~ mg rtLill.' ~ ~l!!t'G ~ ~ rl Lrt'AUUf"ll,.\!Jf113l!.ftl. .!:.LU't1 U 1 L!f>.!:.LU't1Q11.' ~ ~

~-

lL~ U t'~.!:.LU't1 U 1L!f>.!:.LU 't1~ 1 ~~rtLWI.'~Il11.!:.LUG ~13 Mt'rl ~ 1::111111.llll1.!:.l!!\l1,11ft (l,ll-11~,.\!>1, ~

'ltl!.LlT. ::.!:. f1 ~ t Ll-'o rll~~M 11rl1':11 Lrt L~!'A 1,13 ~11~.!:.LU t'.!:.k\111~ lrl ~ 111 rt (l!LL !l.!:.LU ~ f!1, ::1111

• ,.\!>1,111A~W 111':1 t'(l ~111.~ 1~.!:.f1't1 t rl» 1:' ll 1311-13 ~'Art LU L~ f1 (l ~ U!.Lrt Lfl f!1., 1:'~ '11. J1-L!A 1~11::fll!.1., '11.13 ~ 1 ~ ~

I.'L_:M 13 !J!.LUC'!.l!!l t'Git,f1'L.l~l1rt (l,llol.'fl ~ 1'1tQ1'1t ~ 1 ~~ rtLll!! l.'f::\11~Lrt L !1. ~11 rt (l,ll-::1111 I.' I: l~IA\l'L. ~

'11.~1~~rtLWt'f::t11~tLU~tLlA ~_!-'At'~ P 'lt~t'~t'lt,lLr\l11~~~G~~_!..'At'~~~t'~ ~_!-'At'~"" 'Itt

• 1:' ~l!! "" 1.' rl ~ 1rtlT.::!.f1 ~ ~!. LU'It U 1 Lifo ,.\!>1., rl U.1., ~ LlT. 1:' f.1.11 I:' It, 1 L !1.f!11!.. LU~Lrt !.W ::m k\.!:. LU~ Llt,l11 ~ ~

~

't1Lc-li_!l.L~~'t1Lll:"-t L!l.WLilM~U.rtW 13~lL~U ~tt'L~G~11 P,"!'O"Ci\ "k\"M '11.l!.LlT.::tf11.'(llt, A

" '11. ~ 1 ~ ~ rt Lll!! 1:' f::t11~.!:.LU fJ l,.\!>L~ ~lt>'t1 rtll:~U rl L 'ltU _!1. L~ 11fl [} 1::1:.::1111 rl U.1., W ~L 'lt1 LGlf.L.!:.t'!<io 11 A ~ W

m 't1 rt U!lll:~rt Lit> f11., "-IJ 1~ \1.' 11 U ttl 1311-::1111 (l ~L'A LH U~f1 1:' ~ 11.!:.LU 't1ll1 ::w 1.' (lit,

• 1.''11111. 'It lll nrr 1 t'l!.'tllf.Llf.::trr 1.'1311,"-Ill 1 lt>kl rt Llk\ I.'M 11.!:. 13M 1 rtlJ.::!. rr ~ l'-tt>1 rt L 'tl.!..U Lrl MtU.rtW p , I~ p I" , v J.;.. • .., p I" ""'"' Ltv ,.: ...,. ~ ~ (j

fl~l ,"!' ~~k\Nl~UU,tJL~ UL.!..f1 'ttJ1' P""O"Cil "WM 1.'11,1 Lr\l11Lr,H.!..LUC'11Ult>13!LrtL!t>

('v':)dNd : tuawaaJ6V pue UQlle}JnSUO:) JO!Jd UO!le::l!l!lON JOJ ampa:x>Jd) 1.' 11 U ~(lit,:; 1111 ~

(l.t.L'AL-HUJ:.ri I:' I'-11.!:.LU"-l11::.t.Urt L~.!:.LU'It'lt 1L~.t.LU'ItUl't1t 'ltULI'-U13'11. rll~::'IUtL!lLil(llt> liP' .,..1 ... .... .... 0 • .f' .... . l1o

11 rtG ,l!-rl 1':11~j11t'(l ,.\!>::1111 P""O"Cil ·w M 1.'11,1 L !1.ft11t'I1Ult>rtLlkll1l!t'G ~kl~Gilt'L~ G.!..LU't1 U 1L~I.'I3 ,.\!> A

• ~ l1o .t.l1::fll!.1 '11.G1t,1.!:.LUI.'.!:.k\111lt~'I1.111.LUU l' u::1111 Ci\ U~k\I.'GMUUI':II.'Gft,~fl'tll'-lLMI.'fl I.'UUG "" k p j,i 0 F' F' F' "" V.." .... ""' lp. 1," , -;:: .....

• ~t t'L~ G ~11lL~Ut'~.!:.LU'ItU 1L!f>.!:.LU~,.\!>'L.~~I1::rll!.1., "-G~ 1U Ll'-L~!'A 'L. GJ!Il~.!:.LUI.'.t.k\1 't1U 1L!f> . .. . .!:.LU ~ 11 'tllf.rtlf.t' Gil.~ G nL!P.!:.LU ::1111 'ttl!. Llf.::tf11.' Gil.~ !)!:I.' .!:.L!f>.!:.LU rt G ~ttl l111.' ~ MLlJ'IU k\

p

Page 9: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

m&~t.lnm~mn..:Jii~1k..:Ja.ri''l4~ <i!d'. mJrrm'l.\i l!ld'.~·Ui1u~1Vl~1lw'il1"Hll.1 • ~ w EJ..lfl~ J-.1 ffl:JJau L ~ ~fl'" 1~ EJ 'Yllf'itU~1k..1 lil..1n o.hl'ii EJft1&~t.lnmEJ..:Ja ..1 ail ft1&~t.l nmEJ..:J a ..1 a~ 'll 'I 'U " 'U 'I

ii~1 tf.J&~-.11'" ~ <i)rr/ L:JJ'It1Em l!J d'.d'.ll"l LLn~1 i..1'll EJ..:Jft1&~t.lnmEJ..:Jn &~1-J Lll'l.\ 1 ifu~1VlEJ.J 'll El-.1 ~WEJ..lfl ~J-.1 a1:JJ au L ~ 'ilfi'ULU vn::"Ji' 1l'I'I1~Yl1l..l'll EJ1i ~tl nWEJ..lfi~J.Ji1t.l 1i u1i VI '1t1~

'll 'U'U ~ a,.. A <l.o' ~ .... .... I ...

'il1lJ1~liTI:IJ'I.\ ru n 1lVI:IJ1!J Ufl:::JJ~"'J 1J.,)1~U1fl 11:1J'Yl.,)n11U 'iJ.,)"'J El:IJ fiLLfl::n11Lf.J !JLL Vl1'll El:IJ fl .u cuou:d "' 'U 'U

1l U1.,)L VI:JJ1::a:JJ n111UVf.,)fi11:JJti ~ L ~ '1.\El 01-JL Vi !J..lVIEJLLfl::'il1.,)i.J Ufl::n11U1::L~ '1.\f.Jflm::'YlU

~1'1.\~.JU1'ilaEJ:JJ a'lJtnVI Ufl::a..:JfllJllW'il11nt.1 • ~W El-.1 fl ~J.J a1:JJ aUL ~~ fl'l.\ii~1'll Elfl.,)l'U ~ <il d'. 'il fllfi:IJ l!J d'.d'.ll"l 1 it'll fl v •

ii~1i..1'Yl L&~1m1u..:JI'i'm::rum1~1L ii '"m1l~.., 'il1:JJaruru1:5EJ'll1 u i. WW1'il1m ~ EJu. L'llu::u1 , J Q,/ ., 'I

'1.1 LU wnr-t1fl111ri EJ'Um&~ii ~1w mn1t1 m&~t.lnmEJ..:Jnffl..:Jii ~1tf ..:J&~-.11 '"~ l!llii 'il fflfi:JJ l!l d'.d'.rri • i.l.ifu ~1"1J 1l L ~ !J1 nui~nwt1 fl111'll EJ.,j ~w EJ.,jfi~J.,j a1:JJau L ~~fi'U LlW'il11nt.1

" ~ ~ ~

~tlnWEJ..lfi~Yl..:Ji11i nwi1 1m.Jm111.JlvJVl1VI5..:Jt.b L'llu::u"i<>i'.J 1l ci1 u 'U'U 'I 'U

LL"'J1.,) L'llu::u1 fflli11nt. 1~t.J1::'111~t.li.'il ut.l1::'111'll'l.\fl11 (at.lt.l .&~11) LU'I.\m1rl1.J L ~ EJU 'Yl'illh • d

U'iiLLl.iJ 11 'll ..1 L ~ 1l !J m:: lfluJ 1L i a .J:ff'U t~ !J Ll.i jj 011~ U ,i 1 eJ EJO'il1 n LLl.iJ 11 'll-.1 LLfl:: Ll.i jj "

n11LrlUnmi'1L Vliim.U~el'U~jj eh.JL nuJ1J1 LU n11Bf1..1L~em mni'1'il::Yh 1 i1::1fluJ1

1 '1.\ LLl.i ,i 11 'll-.1 a ..1:ff '1.\L\l. Vll ::'Jil ..1 LL 'll1..1 L 'II U:: U 1i.t.J ii ..l'il1l'l4 1~'ll eJ ..1 L jj El..lVI &11..1 '1'11:: Ul-.1 1<fl !J jj " . 1::<>i'uJ1Lmi'L~ !J-.1 nm::<>i'uJ1a..1a'i11 'l.\{]tfl,i1VIfl1nli11:1J'll1~ ~1'14'il1l'l4fh.J'll eJ..:JLLl.iJ11"1J..1

v • "

,-,::ih::<>i' uJ 1'ill:JJU n~ 1m.Jm11 1..1 '1:vJVlTv~5 ..1J 1 i. '!lu::u 1 ii 5 n'ltnt.::Lll '14L~ eJUfleJ'I4n1'il LtTI:JJ LVI~ n • m1 oi<i)o L:JJ'il"l m1:JJa..1i1J1 H..11U l!J<i.d'. L:JJ'il1 iim1~'il.#..1t.l1::m::m uJ1L via H

" v

f.J ~ tfl m:: LLa lvJ Vl1 'ii1 '"1'" <i) o Ul'l4 1<fl u~<fl.#-.1 L fl~ EJ.J n1 L ii<fl i. WWl'll'l4 1tfl <il ""'r1 L :JJ n::1 'il 'ii"

'ii1'14l'il rr1 Lfl~tl-.1 Lvl1lf.J~'ilVI5.J.JlU.LvlW11iLLrit.J1::L'YlftL'Yl!J LLfl::'ll'Ultfl \:>o L:JJn::l<fl'ii"

-;'il'141'U. <il Lfl~tl-.1 L vJEJf.Jil'il'V'l5;mu.i.v-Jvh liLLri at.Jt.l.fl11 Lfl1..1011<>i'..:Jmh11l1lnLLUU1iii

U1::'ilJ1i.tlVIfUL1eJinJ'il"l~tflrlUL~El'U.~l'U.'ll110ll..l <i!l!:l L:IJ<fl"l Ul1 <i!l!:lo L:IJ'il1 " ~

L ~ 1l 1 El-.1 fu nl"l iry -;J 1'Yll.J ,i l i.t1 Vli'UL 1 El'll '1.\ ~ .J'll 'U.l tfl d'. o o ,.)' U. LLfl:: jj 'Yll.J tJ fl1 f·h U.

L~afmnvru.it.l&~lni'l..:J <i)o L:JJ'il"l ~<flnUL:JlEJu.~1wn1u u.am1n-d' u.JaamLuu1iii '

'Yll..:J1::m uJ1 rl'u.u m5. m vi a'li1 m::m uJ1 Lrl a Li'i<fl aYJnnu 1 U.{]tflJlV\ &~1 n Lrl a hm nTi ' . "

af1.J LLrl'1 L a1,-, 'iJ:; tJ ti eJ uJ 1 LVI fl ~1 u.1 'U.LL'ii fl ::1 'U.L Yl1 rl U t.J1m nt. J1 ~'].VI fl L "Ji' 11<fl !J Ll.i jj q, ..... q, .... Q.l

n11n m ihJ'Ib '1.1 <>i'..11X u t.J"1:JJ1 rn 1.b 1 uti lJ ul.i1.b b..:J'il::Lll u. i.t.J 'il1:1Jli11:JJ'll1 ~ tfl fl a 'ilYJ..:JlJ •

Page 10: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

<i)O

hr~~m,-ci\'.ma11'il::ri~'t~w1litl,-::L 'Yli'IL'Ylmhv.1'U. ..,,1!1 l!!o LlJn::1~'ii' ~'il~a-a:~-Hlu 't~w1 '

"Jl1[.JLL~V.L'Yl£J- ~11 LllV.1::£J::mn l!l~ n <t~LL<iitl l!lc&I!J Lll'U.ii'U.'l.tl ~~Llll4Ylt~~1'U.L~W1 d • I !;'I ~ ' " ~ ' ~ •• 1.~ d~ ' • I ,.j • I

L'il.&Wu1::lJ1tu.u~:: \J,~I!J~ ~1WI'\'U.1[J lJfl~11m Lrn'llfi~'Yl LlJLu~[J'\4LLu~~~1lJ11fl1

L :A'm Yl~~ 11.1.~~1~ 1~n LL~::il~Lll'U.eiln~il L~W1~ LL'll~oJJ'U. MLrl mm [JlJL ri [JlJJllJ'Yll.JL~ f) n~'U. mh1~fl iJem1fhl~W1L'il.;EJ ru. "l!1£JLL~l1. -;i11.1.11.1. 1!1 . ..,\J tn'Yl'iifln1~1tn..f- i1 tlJ~

~~fltnfl1EJiruru1 I!!~ tl 'lltu.::~h~L~W1'Yl1-:JL~fln1v.tl1::L'Yll'l ~fl h-:JL~W1tiTu.~l1.LL~:: ' u u

h~'t~w1 HL:A'm Yl~-:Jn1'111!111J"ll1~m~' (LPG) iiavm~h 't~w1L'il.;[Jfl u1l1.·Jh-:Jlh::lJ1ru. "

I!J.~o 1J1'Yl ti-:~ a:'.mo ll1'Yl'iiflii1~1tn..f- i'11lJ-:J 1tnEJ~tlnWfl-:lfl~~ I!J l'U.n11lh::"J!lJ " " ' .t.J .t..J .dvd v '1"'.:;:~..,.,~ "

fl1 ~ 'Yl a:' /l!J d'. d'. m ( fi1-:J 'Yl GJ m m ) L lJ Ell 'U. 'Yl m o 1!1.1. 11 fllJ I!J d'. d'. m L <?! lJ lJ <?! 'VI fl11lJ L '1-\ 'U. "l! flU

' ~ .r ~ .. 1.~ 1 ~ .. ,.j ~ -~ .. ,.j • , ~ 11~tlllilli1'11fl'li1£J Lrnn fi1-:Jn11 L'IIEJ::lJ1<?11lJ'Yl~tlnnfl~fl<n'Yl "' 'U.1Lfmfl LL~:: L'VI

.... ... " 'U 'U

~ -~ .. ,.j ~ .r ~ .. 1.~ 1 . d ~ ' 1 ~ .. ~~nnfl~fi~'Yl GJ ~-:Jl1.1lJ!ftyty1'11fl'li1£J Lnn1 ~[Jnl'VI'U.~L~fl'U. L'll11 (Wl) fi1.Jn11 L'II£J::tp

1'i1 ~1l1.n11'Yl'il11tu.1'llfl-:Jflru.::m1lJ1ITn11~ lJ.J11'11~ (Mekong River Commission : MRC) '

<n1lJm::m1.1.m1'li fl <n n ~\I'll fl~tl,-::L 'Yll'llllJ1iin l1.1.amuj.J1 t 'll~"hti'l £Jm1w~m alJ.J11 'll-:1 , ' ' ' ~ ..

fl£J1~£J·HJ'U. (Agreement on the Cooperative for the Sustainable Development of

MeKong River Basin r1. April .,~rid'.) lL~1 LL~:: (l!l) i1-:Jityty1<fifl'li1£Jl~W1Lfl'l.Jn11l'lltJ::l.l1 L.J'~·hl<.n11<?111'il'Yl'il11tu.1'il1n~Titn~1l1.BUnTHH!f~ rf~i{ L~~tlnWfl.Jfl~fi "' LL~::~ GJ

'U " 'U'U

:;'1 ~ 1 .f' d ' ~ .':1 ,.,.j , .I .d ~ d Lu~L~[J'll fllJ~ fld.Jn111<.<?1 fl~11!11tu."l!'U. 'll~<n fllJ1~tlnn fl~fi~'Yl d'. Ll1.n11u1::'ll:J.HlJ Ell U 'Yl

'1.1 'U'U 'I

GJW) lJn11fllJ l!lcUa:' 'tciliJlJ~L~U'llfllJLL~::1um1u<n1lJlJ~'llfl~~nnwfl~fl~fi "" ~~na11 ""

1<n £J~tm.Jm1L ~W1Ylt~.J1L'!lu::u1'll fl~ ~tltl.~11 Lllu1m~m1w~u1um~1.J11'li.J '

Ill utl1::1!1u 1 ULL 'lll.J 't '!lu::u1 fl ru.::m1lJn11LLl-i .J 11'li.J LL 'I'I.J'll1~ ~11 Mii '1'\l.t.J ~ fl~ a:'<>' oi/LNMCS '

i.'l.Jll<. ~ GJ"' rl'U.U1 UU 1<J rl.d'.m n.J~1in.J1'U.l~'ll1~n11fl ru.:: n11lJ1ITn11LL1i.J11'li.J L yj flL~lJ n11tl'1n l:f1'1'111 fl al.J'VI '1:\1 mt\t1m-a n11 l ~W1Yl t.J.J 1 l'llEJ::u'1cil1 £J n11ff .J L fl n tl11L ~ £J1 n u

' 1m -am 1 'l ~ w1 Yl t.J .J 1 L'll £J:: u1 'lcilLL ri 11 U.J1 u m 1i'i n l:f1 f111lJ L 'VIlJ1:: ~ lJ 1m .J m 1

' 11 U.J1U n11tl1:: Lijl\~ ~ m::'YlU.J'1l1.~ .J LL 1 ~ ~ fllJ 11 U .J1'U.n11U1::Lij 1.1.~ ~ m::YJlJ ci\'1'U.i.JfllJ

LL~::"Jl fl ~ ~<fi1.J ") ~ L ~ tn"Jl fl.J I yj ul ~tJ 1:: L '111'1111 i'j ~lJ1iin Lci\'iJ n11tl'1mn·1n'1u rl Uri flU

LL<l::Lrlu1u-t1lo:Jo <ni.'l1fl1l l!lci'Ci"m ~TUn.J1ULt'l'li1Tin11flrn::m11liTinl'HL1iJl b.J '

M ti .J-5 fllJ ~1m .J m1 't ~ w 1 Yl t .J.J 1 't '!l u ::u 11 ~ LL ri fl ru.::m1lJ n11 LLl-i J 11 'li.J 'll fl.J tl 1:: L '11., " '

mi'i~lJ1iin 5u ") L v1 ElL ~tl1::L 'Yll'l~lJ1iin'Yl'i111tu.1U1::Liju~~m::'Ylu~mwhii::L n'il'il1n

Page 11: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

"' .4 '1 ..,. d d o "' ~ l .d "" "" .J.,. I nT'H1"'l1-3L 'll !llH'II!.J::lJ"i'll~lJn1~'14~L1GI1LU'I1U1"'fil111!.J '14 'o> L~ !1'14 '141Jv1nl'l4 'Ylu"i::L 'Ylfl

' ~111-nntJ·m 'Ylfl~~fh u 1v11u L!ln ~11 ( t~ utJ1::L '111'11 'Yl u 1v11u L !l n ~11LU'14l.J;:: L 'Yl f1 ~~'1'11 u . ' d"".d A 0 AI 1~"'

LlJ!l1'14'Yl l!:Jl!J ~GI1fllJ l!:Jcl.tm) 'll-3fi11Jn1~'14il 'o> Lfl!l\4 '141'1\'Yl l!:Jl!J LlJl!f1!.J'I4 kl.t.t.r • ~unV1D~fl~~ .r til umlJ'Yl1'V'l u1mJ11 '14~1'14::~1'1!n.J1'14LG~'ll1'14nT'ifl m::m1mlim1 'U ... ... 'I

Luhh t 'li.JLL "'.J'll1ii1 'Yl utvl ~h L u'l4m1L ~ u1n1lm7tJ1nl!f1~1'11l l'i1.Jw1t'1mrntm ~ m1

lvlV11ViN-3J11'l!u::u1~L~'14!l lfl u 11'UU.N11 ~v::lf·hJL~!l'l4tt'I4LUjJ11'li·Hn !.JU1::li11-t '

1wrl1.J~!l ci1" 14'"~'11 D.J lfl.Jl.J. a11 1flu1v!i~L 1n11K'li D1la1m.Jm11 vlf11ViN.JJ1 'l'llu::1l1 " " '

.t .J A "" .d • ..,. "" "" ..,. t " fi1-3'Yl GJ LlJ!l1\.t'Yl l!Jl!:J lJn11fllJ l!:J.t.t.r m !l1L1l!JL'li!.J.J'll!l.J v.J~1~L'li!.J-311!.J fi!.JlJ

~L 'li111111'u..:S~m• 1 tK'li !llJ 01~1" 1'14 <i'o> fl\4 l.J1:: n!lllvl1 utJ;::'ll1'll'l4 ~mwhv:: 1v11u " " .J ..r .Jq,.. "".... ~.J d Q,; .d Q,; ft ~an7::'YllJ'YllJ1v1n'Vil-t'Ylv.J~1~L'll!.l.J11£J fl"i.J'Yl l!J LlJ!l1'14'Yl GJo n1ll'l1Vil-tli kl.t.t.r

' m !hLnmii£J.Jfl1'14 i.JWJfiLGI!.J 1fluii~L'li1111l1'1lVf.Jm1LlK'li!llJG1~1'141'14 GJ!.JG'll fll-t

" " .J'.JQ...-"" .dl .t.J .,J,q.,.J ..... 6'

v1n'Vil-t'Yl'il~~1fiLGIU ~1-t!l~fllU LLGI::1J.Jn1'VI' fi1.J'Yl m LlJ!l1'14'Yl GJ'i!:J nlJl'l1Vi'l4li !.J.t.tcr '

m ihLnmii !l.Jl-tfi1Vi'l4lJ i~WJfll-tm'Vil-tlJ 1Y~uii~L'li111lJ1uVI'.Jm71lK'li !llJ 01~1'141'14 " " ..r .JQ,; Q.; 0 .... d

GJkl.t fll-t v1n'Vi'I4'Ylv~~1f1'14fi1Vil-tlJ 1lnfl1~11 !l11-t1vLv1ru ua::!l1JN11'llli11-t ' ~ '

1fl U ~L 'li11111 L 1fi n11l lK'li EllJ GI~.J m LL vi.J Lvl11J'li !llJ Gl Lu'Vil:: ~1'14~ L U fl L ~ U L'ii " " "

;;) El 1m.Jnl1Lvlf11Vi~-3J1ll-tm.ilh 1'lJ.J~l UU1::lil\.t 11UGI::La Ufl'll!l-3 PNPCA LLOI::a;tJ ~01 '

tm.Jm1Lvlf1l'V'l ~-3J1 1'11u::u1'll!l.J MRCS ~11-tn ua::L~ UfiLLOI::L!ln~1'll !l.J 1m.Jnl1 1 vlWl '

Vi ~.JJ1 1'11u::u111i ~l1Jl1tl ttl fl L~ u 1vl'Lta:: L U'I4L !l n ~'Yllf'll !l.JU1:: L 'Ylfl L 'ill'll !l "1m" m; '

d~~· 1~~ ~v .I .I d~d ~.-'JI.JU.J LlJ!l\.tllil~ '1'\LufiL~U Lfl LLOI::u1::'li1J11'1u~aL1J!l1\.t'Yl <ilb nlJl'l1Vi'l41i kl.t.tcr , ..... , , , m m11'Yl1-wu1mti'1 tvl!la7tJ~a~1vlvlmTn~""' fl.f.J~~1'141ll t~m-nru'VI'IbU.J11-t

' v .d.d .... """"' ""' ""'A ..... A

m n U1'll !l.J 1-tn1'll1 n11!l ~•:: alJ1'1lm lilJ an1 LLa::fl m:: ~'ll11-t 1ru n11Vi'ill1m 111 U.Jl" ' " ~

nl1l L fl1l:: l\ ~a n<::'YllJ ~ .J LL 1 fl i.t EllJ 'ii1 '14nl1~1ilJ '14 l LL 'VI fi.J J l L .yj Ell i'li !l fi ~ L {'; 1-t I t,- .... ..,

'li !l Ll1'\.t!lLL 1-t:: L VillL~lJ 111ln.JLL '14 1'Yl1.Jnl1<iil L U 1-t.Jl\.t 1 1-tfli'.J<ii !l LU 1fl UndlJ'Yli'Vi Ulm'\b

'l'iiii'VIU.J~!l ~ obob/<i)OJ!.tl!:J a.J11-t~ <i)l!J Llll!flU\4 !.J.t.t.r U.J~lUn.JlULWllllim;

fl rn::m;mlim<LL1iti'11'li.JL vl !l LL'il.Jm1lJL {';" ~l'iiv1nm<ifiL 1Yi1 tK'li !llJa 1m.Jm;'lvlwl "

Vi~.JJ1 L'llu::u'i <A .J~i1 km 'l<ii'L~ tJ'll!l.Jth::L nl'llnui1'li m'l.J'"la<ii !l tm.Jm< 'lvlwl'Vi~.JJ 1 L'l!u::u1 ' " '

;:i!l (<il) m;tJ7::dJ1-t~am::nu~.JLL'"lfla!lm-n.Ju'Yllil'll<Hrf (SEA) LUULfl~s.JiJu '

~i1th:: 1u'llu1 um1 1 i'li ulJ am.Ji'lllm;uri~ii ~. "'lvlbi~u <A .J i:im1 m v;,. 11 SEA " "

Page 12: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

m1mauflllllm1th::Li:iu.fjllm::nu,.1n tm.Jm'l""lwvh'rla.JJ,,f" lu.u.:UJ1 t'll.Jmvtl'l"::Inu. • u.a::a1J1a1'1J1LLliJ1 l"ll.J u.am1nif SEA fl11"ii'liallaihmYuL~B.Jn11" H~~u.1ll~.J

" ' o.r J. .J' .JA !1 o.r ~ --~ " .I .fl • LLll ~1 L 'Utl.J';J1 n'rl'U 'Y11ll H.J LLll J.\1 L~'l"U fj an'l"::'YJU";J1n n11<11"1.J L 'lJ 1l U.L u U. ';11 U.1'\.tll1 n

(l!l) ti1"::L~u.i1U.!.h::ll.JLLil::m1B'rl£JWU1 £J riu.'lJB.:Jtla1 ~"Mii~1u. "liL~uiim1llL ~u. i1 "

., d • 1 " " .I ,¥ .I o !' .I • ~.I o o !'I o n11a-1"1.JL'lJ BU.B1';1";J:;'YJ1 VI aruLa"!.JuS1U.a::wu. 'Yl'llll'U 1'Yl';I::U.1 Lu<lfjSm::'YlU'il Bf111:1JLu 'U1l [J v w , v v

.I .1.1 ~ 1 o!'1 "l: ~~.I t .I ~"• ~ 'lJ1l.Ju'l"::'ll1'li'U'YlW.JW1tl'l"W!.J1n1 'UU.ll'U1 'lJ.J Bn'Yl.J lJ'U L'ilua1 ';1'\.t'YlBBnLLUU b1<11VI11J

lm.Jm'l"i.Jmh1 LliLif B~am1Bwuwri1uriu.'lla.Jtla1 i.JJu L vlB'Ji1 £Jll11"L m fj!lm::'Ylu

d ,¥ " ~~.It 1 o .I "" ""o ~"" L11l.J'U fl11"lln111l1lnLLU1J1J'U L~ua1 ';1'\.t VI:IJ (m) u'l"::L~'Uiii1'U'il::nBU fj:IJ<Il'u. L'ilL<I!.J "

L a-ua1 ~i 'il a-11" u tl1:: :u1 nu vl B m1;!iu w1.J tl a11 U.LLl.iJ 1 1'1J.J~1.J1u fj ll m:: 'Yl m1 n "

m1nu tnJ'lJ B.:J'il::n 11'\.t (<I.') L1iiim'l"n1VIU'il~on'il L ';I 'UL ~ !.Jl rllJ :IJ1 'il1n11"1J11 L 'Yl1 fj Gl m::'YJU

U!ln";J1nd n11"U1::Lii'Ufj am::t11J~.JU.1 <;)a 1l :u"l:U"li B~1J1 !.JU.J fjS m::'YIU ~ El1::uuih 1 fl

ua::1::uum1 "l VI a'lJ <J.JJ1 hLLl.i J1 1 'lJ.J 11 :u rf, fj ll m::'Y1u"JJ1 :U'rl1:1JLL 'il u ~ ii <il <JU'l":: L 'Yl f!Ll'l £J

i.J ,f 'U 1m.J nl'l"L WYl1 'rl a.JJ1 L'll!.J::U1fl11"i'il <111.J u 1..11:: :IJ1 nt.L vi B :" n B.:J'Yl u.lt1 w~'u • • 'll'il L 'li£Jf111 :IJ L ~£JV11 !.J ~ L fi'il';l1 nm1fi tl tihJ L ~ tJU.LLa::m1'111 Lit '1-t 1m .JnTl"i.J n tl11 ~ mf.J

i a .Jiinwrmn H~ .:1 tl1m rn m1Ll'l a~1 <~W~1 U.LLl-1 J11'll.J L'il mu 'rl1:: ath" ri "1 u. q 'il LL<i'.J ' ~

(If) m1ii nl'l"L lJ WI L fj tJ"lJ B:IJ a 1 wn £J·J1U. tf.JVI :IJ'il'lJ <J.J 1m .J n11 11 :urf.J 11 !.J.J1UU1:: LiiU. "

fjam::'Ylu~ -m 1'il ti <J:U~ uti ad] umtt1 "l 'YI £J LLa::LL ,.mh £J11£J.J1U1 ~ tl'l"::'lf1'11U. m1uti1.JV11l' 1

Ti <Ju.m'l" Mm1:1JL V:u.'ila <J'il";JU.n11Lll 'ilLfj u"JJ a:u am1~1L ii u. 1m.Jm11 ~ ti1::L 'Y1f1am.:nnm1u "

(~>) ~ii~1u. ML;mT.Jii"JJ<Jn.J1a1uL~a.Jm1~~u1 tm.Jm1mh.JtT.Jtiu L rt<J.J'il1 nii"JJmJa " ~

"l:U L i'l !.J.JW a~ <J m1Vl';l11nt.1tl1::dJufj a m::mJ oi'.JJ u ~.J'll tlL<IU<J 1 ~ii n11'll £J1 £JL 1 a1

.I" .. ' " ~.I J. ~ -~ A " d~ " 0 • I n11u1n lt1 Vl11 <J a1 .J VI 'u.1 <J tl n Lu 'II.J fj a n111U Yi .J fl11 :IJ fl WI LVI '1-t 'YI L WI ';11 nLL 'il a:; u 1:: L 1'1 f1

'il::\t1LU uu.li n 111 U1l1flfj\.t1 n'll tl.Jn £J.J1'\.tn11mntt1VIi1 <J 1m.Jn11LWYl1'rl a.JJ 1 L'll u::u1 '

<il <J 111 fl rn:: m1 :IJ n11·h :u "litl1::'1f11 <1 !Tui 011 IT ru L d <J 1u. ~ "'Iii L :u :1!11 £J u. l!J If If ct . "

L vi <JVl';l11nL1<11U f..llln11U1::dJufjam::'Ylm1n t~n.Jn11LWYl1'rlH.Jli1L'li£J::u1 tl·nn ni1 • ' dJ

" 0 '

jj,Y tl rl.Jl a 'il1 n U1:: L 'YI f1 <I:IJ1.:nn '1'11 !.JU 1 L'i <J .J f..l an 1::'YI1J ft .J LL 1 'il a <J :u"JJ1 :IJ W1:1J LL'il U.

LLa:: H a WJ::'YlU <1:: <I :IJ 1 'ULL l.iti'11 'lJ .J:A.J'il:: ~ .J 1'1 a oj <J 1 n -711 'il"ll <J.J 'If :IJ'l!l.L'il a <l 'il G11 ti'1 'il U n .J • d .I .!'t ' .. 1 .I ,.,.~.1 A

<11:1JLVIa!.J:IJu1nLL:IJU1 'lJ.J LL'il11£Ja::L<J£J'il fl1.Jn111'1L<IU.tlLVI'Ylu"l::'Jf:IJW'il1"llli1 '

iJ "lliiii nl"l~ n :1!11 ua::ti1::Liiu.1 UL~ <J.J<tl.Jn tl11 LLa::~ U1::'Jf :IJ "ll-1 <11 :IJTH1V11'll tl <11U"h :IJ n u M . '

Page 13: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

.... ::, .J .. I ... ... ..... , fl.~ 0 .-!1 J" " .... I "I A

~hl'U 'U 'Ylu1::'Ji1Jv~ 1JlJ91 L '1'\'U l L 11l~'ULi.meHHL 'Yl'UfHU::lJ'U<ild'JJ 11~ LLttl a::u1:: L 'Y1 Pl~vl1llil . ~

1ifllllJL'i":u.~eJ'hJ flrn::nnlJm1Luhh l'll~u'Vi~~m11~ii'VIu~ffemnu.~ l!Jkl L:Ul!fltm klctctct

ri"Ltltt'mlu.La'lllnm•flrn::m1mirm1ul.itll t 'JJ,'J LLi,'J 1imluml:UL V:u.'ll B,'J .,-l.J u. a11

-;hm::u1 u.m;mnl!fl'VIl~mh ~'VI 1!1 d'J u. 1tJ ttll :u'li' mh'VI U.ttl'll eJ,'Jflll :u ttln a" ci multi' 1 t '1l ,') • d • q .. "" d (l..o G.,oo

fl. Pl. li1 Ill ill ct LL<l:: n Bll n;::u 1 u. m1 L <1'"".iv <1':1JlJ1tu.LL a1 '1J rn:: L ttl rn nu. n1::Y111 ,"J ~a ..l ..ll u. ~

LLa::t.lmL"i'lleJ,"J .,-tJtJ.all 1~ii'VIu..la1l a..li'U~ l!Jkl L:Ul!flt.m klcfctct LLi..l1uu..lcY~<UJU.l ~

t m>~ nw:i 1 m::m u.m1mn l!fl VI 1~ 11 li1 >~'VI tt 1 L .,-1v HlJlJ 1mttll :u'li' 11 rh'VI U.ttl'll 11 ..l fill :u ttl n a>~ "

GllJLLl.itll1'1J.J fl.PI. 1i1fllli'!cf LLawJiu.nu. ctw<UJu.l tm.Jnl1~~Mii'I-IU.Ja1l <l,'Jll-1.~ ' "

li'! iinu.1rm l!Jctctct LLi>~:ulu"cYnnY1eJ>~fl~~ 10) -h .,-l.Jl.J.all 'l~flu.uwi1m::mu.m1 . ~ " tJ1n l!fl'VIl11l Gll.J'I'\ UlL<1'1v <1':1J1JdmLLal cYW<UJU.l tm,'J nl1~fm.J~'il::fl,"J U.l :IJ inHUl nu

'U 'U "'"'

ern nY11l.Jfl ~~ li) iu. rhd eJLtlUmlU.el [Jnl1<1','J <1'ttl ttl1l'iljl.J iru rulof1l'lll !.J 1 WY1l LLal L .,-h 'U'U 'U't ..,..,

1ttl u •h ,X n ..ll u.e1 u m 1<1'" <1''fl1~ ll.1 ci ,') ~" m1Yl 'ill1 rn 1 'fl1l 'il i1 ,"J i ru ru1 of eJ '1l 1 u 1 v-1 Y11 'U , ..., ....

1m,"Jm11WY1l~~"tll1'llu::u1h1uricYnnY1eJ..lfl~~ 10) Ld11iu.~ klct iinu.1uu. kl<fcfct 't 'U'U ,

~11Xm1u. u. tum mLa::LL~u.~~.J..lll-1. m::m1,'J~~,'J,'JlU. 1~L~ mL ~i'li'eJ:ufi hmm11 v-IY11 "'

~~..lJl1'llu::u1uu.LllJL'llol www.eppo.go.th LdeJiu.~ kl<'ll nu.u1tm kl<f<f«.' '

d ~<>t Q...< VI "'.-ot o:v ~ .d <v d ...... vU.Cl,'JU'ilvlJU.LL<l:: L'lllJ'VIU...l<1'eJ 'Y1 ~u. o'olo<f./m<>iiO)IiJ fi,'JlU.'Yl mo nU.!.Jl!.Jl-1. kl<f.<f.oc'

' '1l eJfllllJ BU.Lml::"IKL~ !.l LL ~jiJ B lJ au U.L 1u 1'll~'ll eJ..l ~lUn..llU.U ~'fl ~1unu.1 u nf~:uw11'1 ' ~ ~

L Yl11L i nl1~l L ii. U. nl 1L i'J U. LU Oil :1J :IJ ~'JJ 1J,'J cY Cl n YJ1l..l fl ~ ~ <f. LL fl:: L i'J U. nl1 LL i ,"JojJ B :IJ fi " " "

LLfi::L~u LL ~jiJeJ:ua1iu1::'li1'l!U. ml1Jttll:U1::Lii !.llJ~ltt'nm !.lnf~:uu.ttl'1'il~l um1fuYl','J ~ ~

flll:Uf1'f1Lv;u.'JJB,"Ju1::'l!l'l!U. ~.Pl. kl<f.ct<>~ cYnnY1eJ,'Jfl~~ "-' i.~ii'I-IU,'JffeJ l)ilu.mn "" d ....... ,d 1<!.,1"" ,.... '

'Y1 'Y1<1' o'olmo/l!:J<'llklm fi,'JlU.'Yl """' ttl<llfl:IJ l!:J<f.<f.cs:' Cl..lufl'fln1::'Y11l,'J~fi,'J,'Jll-tll m::'Y111,'J '

'Ylf~ u1 mli11:1J'lil~ LLa:: ~,'ILL 1 'fl ~ 11 :u'JJ 1),') .,-uu. a11 1~ii'VI u..l fffl1l !.J,'JlU.mll.l n11'V\ 1X1

'1J eJ ..l n l 1 ~ n l!fl L .yi :IJ L ~ l.J 1 fl1 ,'J n l 1 l v-J YJ1 ~ ~ ..l J 11 'll !.J::: lJ 1 ttlll.J ~ U 1:: L Yl PI H l.J 1.:n n '

fl rn:: m1 :u1 irm 1 LL l.i J 11'1l..1 f eJ ,') '1J eJ f-l1 U.fl rn::: rll ,'11 U.'ll eJ ..l fl rn:: m1 :u m 1i ll.l rn !.l 1 ~ m:::mu.m1u1nl!fl'VIl'1mh,"J'1-1Ul tttl u .,-l.Jl.J. fill Mi1..lu1M''Yl~u1nl!f1Yl'ill1rnlYllJYJTu "Ji e1f1 'fl L ii: u.LLfl::"Ji m <1'U.eJLL U.::"JJ eJ,'J m~::Yh,'Jll-1. "lJ eJ ,'Jfl rn:: n11:1J nl"".iil:IJ LLil:: <1'1U l11fl·n m·:i't~

' ~1 L ii. U.nl1<1'el 'fl fl ~ 1J,'J rllJ ~ jj eJ U lj U~ ,'Jl U.'JJ eJ,'J fl rn:::m1:1Jlifnl1LLlJJl 1 '1J ,'J LLfi::: <1'U U. fill

.. • I .. d • A t d • ~ ~ ~ ·'" .. d :IJfll1:1Ju1:::<1',"Jfl'Ylv:::'fllLU.U.nl1 fl1,"Jnl1'fl1:1JLL~U.'Ylnl'I-IU.'fl Ll ~ClnY'IeJ,"Jflttl'Yl "-' " "

Page 14: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

Yl'il17nt.1 LLGl1 L ~ui1 a-th.J. a11 'l~£huT'.l.m7 H'Lon ~'Yljf~,.::i11 L it'.l.m7 lm-m11'l vJVl1

wa-.1J 1 'l 'l! EJ::u 1m l-1 1l1 '.1. Til o~tl'l~ EJ'Il o-.1~ '.l.ua:: ~ '.l.tJ '.1. i 1 m::m '.1om 1m n :~:t1 vn1 o ci 1-.1 ~,X 1 '

'l~'1fl\a-~LLGl1 m::m1.JWa.J-.lll\L<iliivn!.J~fl ~ Wl\ o'oJooi«!GJ'•JO fi.Jl\1.~ t.J~ ~fl1fllJ t.J<l<lr£ ' '

LLi.J~t;jnfl fl.Jfl~~ GJ i1m::m1.JWGl-.l.J1'U Lirl'il11nt.1 LLGl1i1~l-h EJ.J1'U. ~ L ~ EJ1i <J.Jnll

t 'loolo':1 ~ .i 'l .. , ~ 0 A "" 'l A ~ .':1 .. "" .j f11.Jn17 Yn"11Wfi.J~1 'I!EJ::U7 ~~1L'.l.'U.n11~1lJL-.lfl'U. '!JlJ~'IJ<J.J~t1nl"'fl.Jfi~'Yl <l LLI'I::'Yl t.J ' ~~

fl71ltl1'U.LL!i'1 fi o (G)) a-th..l. a11 'lmill!lum7 Hton~nif~,.::'ii1L it'.1.1m.Jm;'lvJYl1wa.JJ1

L'l!EJ::t.(1~1lJ eJ1'U.1'il o~tl'l~ EJ"ll o.J~u Lta:: ~'U.U\1. i1 m::m u m7tl1n :~:t1~1'1o ci1-.1~ 1X1

hiilla-~ LLH1 ml-1~ m::m1.J'Yli'w EJ1nn17l-1'111 ~ ua:: ~..., LL 1 ~Gi' <Jl-1 LL ,r..., m Ld o1'.1. ~ '

t.J'oJ ~fl1fllJ t.J.t.toc (t.J) ~1Un.J1'.1.eJEJm;a-.Ja-~ 'li~11'ilVl'il11nt.1LLa:: Mm1l-IL ~'.1.h1iruru1 'I '\1'1 OUIU

.¥ , •. 1.':1 1 ~ .. 1.':1 ~ !' ~ .. ~ ~ .':1 .. .I • ~ 'IJ<J"JJ1EJ nn1 fi1.Jn11 Lnn1Wfi.Jl\1 L'IJEJ::1J1LL1'11 (m) ~nnn<J.Jfi~'Yl GJ LLa::a-1'.1.n.J1'.1. ' ~ ~

'.1. tmnmLa::LL~l\wa.J.J1u 'li'ii1L itum;L~mLwi"ll olJa tm.Jm;'l'I'JYl1wa.JJ1'l'liEJ::u1 ~ '

hL iu L'll~ LL a:: 1 '.1.7::11 u L r~1 o'll1 EJ a-11a"'.l. L Yll'l~ ~1 ,r n -.11 u tl il ~ ~1 ,r n u 1 EJ n f ~ lJ u~ 1 d

w.l'l. t.J<loc~ LLH1 ~.J1ri'irnnYlo.Jfl~~ GJ 'ii1LU'.l.n17fi.J'U.1lJiruru16fto"JJ1EJL'I'JYl1 tm-.1n11 'U 'U "" ...,

'lvJYl1wi1'.JJ11'1JEJ::u1<ilo'ltl tfi.JirnnYlo.Jfl~.yj GJ LLi1::il'vY~m tm-.1m1 u1B''Yl L'I!EJ::u1 'I 'IJ '\1 'IJ 'I

W11L 1of 'ii1n ~ 'li i1.JU1l-linnU16ft EJ"ll1EJ 'lvJYl1 1m.JnT'iL'I'JYl1wil...,,h L'I!£.J::u1t1um(1 £.J.Ji u Ylf ~ ~ '

ml-lfU71lJ'U.nJLL'Vi.J11'llfl1n1,1,)ml'YlEJ W'Ylll~n11'11 t.J<l<lo ~lJl'il m ~'YlihLfi::La-1mw .U 'IJ IU 'I

"JJ<J.J'II'.l.'II11LYIEJ ci1-u.i1 GJ 1J'Y1~1LU <hU~ GJo ff'YlTI1-u.iol-la'll11a'11LLi1::n11f<J.JL1EJu ~

~1lJll1~11 <l'oJ lJ1~11 <l<>J LLa::ci1'U.~ GJO LL'U.1U1£.JlJ1£.Ji1Un11jjci1Ui1lJ"JJ<J-.11h::'II1'11U

lJ1 'il11 ~ <>J 1 'il EJ irn n Yl fJ .J fl ~ ~ GJ Ll.i L fl EJ 1 ri''Ji fJ lJ a .yj ii fll1 L Vj EJ -.'IW fJ L 'VI lJ1:; ~lJ n lJ Gln :~:tru.:; ~~ ~

1 ~ .r ~ .. 1.':1 "" ~ .. d .. • .,; v "lJ o-.1 fi1.Jn11a"nJ ru1'1! <J"JJ1 £.J L nn1 L "lJ ou L 'I! EJ::lJ1'Yl 01 'ill-!~ an 1::Y11J'il EJ fl ru.111W ~ -.1 LL 1 'il a o lJ

Q.l .... 'I 'I

~"JJ f) u 12T !.J fl ru.m w:n1 'il 'VI 1 f) Li1 u 'liL ~ mhr'l ru ~ u L<il ~ L ~ !.J 1 n lJ 'il'U. 'VI1 0'11 jJ '11'.1. Yi' El-.'1 ~ u , 'I .... ,

LLa::i'fl1ri'iim::u1um;fuw.Jm1lJ~'il L ~'U."ll o.Jtl7::'111"l!'U.<J r.i1.J~1ii.Jnou1ht itunT'i

LLfiil'Yl<J.Jfl&i n11l ri'"Jl<J lJ a 1'fl !.J n11L~ !.J LLW~Yil-.'1 L llJ l'IJ<;)Ju i:iio 'ill n'il El r.h.J lJ1 n ~ ~

1 un·m "ll1 ii..., LLa:: u-.1 'll.i m <JlJ fl i1lJ 1 u1h:: vilu<h r1 ru il'Yl o-.1 fl &i'l'ii'L fl £.J &\ 'il Iii EJ LLI'I::"ll Ell i ' u ~

irnnYl<J.Jfl&i~ GJ ci.JL<Jna-17L~lJL&imv1m11m1m"ll1hL~EJ1ut1 1!1~ 'fla1fllJ l!i<t<tu: ~ ~ '

Page 15: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

hi'LLri 11 U.Jl'U. m1timmn111L '1'1111:: i.1'11 lm.Jm1'l wvhl'l.r.Jttl 'l'llu::u1LLll::m fl (:em 1n , 11 U-31 'U, n11l.h:: dj 'U.f-Jllm::'YllJ ~.,] LL 1 ~Hl!l 11 ~ UlJ L ~ !l'U.n 11111 ~ wrf l!J cl cl m LL ll:: , L~1l'I4~.J'V11fl11 l!Jclclm LLiil::m1tin'lt1LLU1i.1'1Uli.J'il1n'Jf1ULL'11'14L'YlU- ll11- i.1'W.

' t ~ -~ .. .I i. ~ ~ ~-~ .. d ~ .I ~ .. Ll'IU- 'lJ!l'U.LLn\4 'fiU(:C.I{Jnn!l.JflOI'Yl <il OILL'il.Jf-Jn1l.Jf!OIL111l1'U.'Yl <il n111l1\'l'U.li l!Jclclcl

'\1 'U "" 'I

i1 Ll.i i.1'11111!l Lll"' Lf-J u'lla11ll1 'VIL~'il'U.nil'il:: Ml'mm11L ~waam1mi iruru1ofa'll1 u i. wvh 'U '\1 ......

Ill a,.,. I I 0 A dOV I I .:... iL' .,toa,; Q,.oo I

LLll:: n1 iii.J 1l U1::'V\11.J 011 L 'U,'U, n11n 1 nt'fi.J n ii111 LLOI 'iJ '14n1::'Yl.J 1J 01'14'11 1l 11 iii OI.J n ii111 ~ ~

nLl.i Lfl u i.~fu n11L tl 01 Lf-J u.,; 1l i.1'1li11nt:: ut>i 1l Ul.J 101 L tJ 'U,L 'VI 011 ~ m1-;l 01 L 1 ri1 ~'lla 11 iii , ~

LLiil::fuw.Jm111~01L ~ U'll!l.J~ii li1'U. L~L~Ut>i 1l lm.Jn11LW~1\'l~.Jtt1 L'IIU::u1~1'U.1'U, m f){.,] ~ ,

i.1':: tl!l 'U. L ~ U .J 'lJ !l.J'li 11 'JJ'U. 1 n tlL ~ U.J rl 'U. i 1 Ll.i'ti-i'u '11111J'Jl!l 11 ll ~ L flU .J \'l!l L -;)1 'VI U 1 ~ , ~

n111'Yl'l\'l t11mtt1 LLiil:: L i1'VIU1~thun.Jl'U.Liil'll1fin11fl ru.:: n11111fin11LL!.ith t 'li.J Ll.i ii'Ji' 1l 11 iii ~

~ LU'U. urnhi ru 'll.i i.1'1 1111!l1ln1J1 u~ 111 11 u iii:: La u 01 tm.J n11 1~m1 L n u'li' 1l 11 iii ~ ~

LLt'l::n11ftnl!ll 1 mh::L~'U.f-Jiilm::rt11'li'111\'l111LLOI'U.~i'O!L'il'U. M ~mr.J n11iOIL 1Yihhl 1l11t'l ~

'lJ1l.Jn111'11-i'l'lU1n1tt1l'hLflU.J m ,).,:J'V\lOILrll,f\4 'il1n~1'U.1'U. <i ,).,:J'VIlOI~~OILLl.ittll'll.J LL iii:: 1 'U. m -;).,:J 'VI 101 ,f 'U. ni. l.i 1l1 'il '111111 L ~ i Tl'h n11 L :U ru tb:: 'lll 'll'U.f-JL~f11 f-J t1 n 1:: '1111

~ ~

LLiil::ii a1 'U. Md~ u 1 u.1 fl"i.J n11iru tul of <J'lll u 'l Wvh·h 11111 w.,] n11 h\'li' 1l :u t'l tt, n.,] 'VI 1a 'll.i ~ ~ ~

LLt'l ::il (:C.! t'l11 u .Jl u.nTliLL 'iJ.,] -if 1l 11 iii LL t'l:: n111'11W.,] fill :u ~ 01 L il 'U. n 'U. El Ul.J L1 (:C.! t'l i.1'1lh1 n ~ '

m1-;l01th::'JJ:ULU -u,acil.J h lm.Jm1 'l W~ll'l ~.Jttl L'l!U::111L ~ Elf-Jfi 01 'l W~l LL~ 'il:: 'll.iMLii 111if u. ' '

1 'U.l.h::L ml'l '11 u LLt>i rHi ail LU'U. tm.Jn11'll a.Jf;[~ii (:C.! iiln1::'1111'ii m.h::'JJl'lJ'U.EI Ul.J1mm LU 'U. ~ '

H1'U.TI:U'fil:UU UllJ"'J EI.J1::Li'i £111 ~lU nm unf;[:U'U.'fi1 i 1~ 1 u n1TI11W .Jfl1111~ 01 L ~ 'U,'lJ!l.Jtl1::'JJl'JJ'U. ~

~ ~ d t Q..ooA .d l'l.~- J.Jclcs:'<>' 'll!l a:' LLll::'lla tl111f!i.1'EI.J LU.!l.J'illn fi1.Jn1101.Jnll11Ln'fi'il1nn11Yl

~nn~ EJ.Jfl~~ <i) ML 'Jll 'ltlrhiruru1i1'il::ofa 'lw~1~f-Jfl'fi 'l~'illnL~ au. L'IIU::111n.Jfaull:: G'l<f 'U'U QIQI ,

'illn~ (:C.! fllfi M~.J'VI 1101 H.J (:C.! iil1 ~iim1ri 1l i.1'11.J L ~ El'l4'li'U.101L 'VI niku.LLl.itt11 'li.J i.1'1 U'VI or n ~

5u. 'il:: a.,] f-1 ll m::'YllJ 1l Ul.J1'U.LL 1.J ~.,]iii El ~.,] LL 101 ~ El 11LLll::tl1::'Jl1 'll'U.EI Ul.J 'll.i Ell 'iJ 'VI~ n L ~ u.,] 'l~ , L tJ1 U 11 L i.1' jj 1l 'U. n111 ~ 1J fl fill Ill U'U.EI n G'h Lit 'U. n11 L ~ 1l tl1:: 1 U 'l!U'll !l.J ~ !l n Yl EI.J f! ~ .yj <il ' ~ ~

~n nYl EJ.Jfl~ Yi <i) ~.Jii;[lu.::Ltl u.Lil'll!l.J 1m.Jm1ii wlt1~ mm::Lu u11~1u n'U.1unf;[:U'U.'fi1<il.Jmhl '\l 'U .., oU

.I ~ 0 A d 1 ~ ~-" .. . I 'l ~~ ~ ' ' 'Yl'il::'fi <J.J 011 L 'U. u.n11 L ~ <J 'VI ~n tJ .Jfl'fi LLt'l::u1::'JJ1'JJ'14 01111 'Yl1111'JJ tJ :U t'I'JJ11 i.1'11LL t1:: 11 :U LLi.1'01.J ~ ~

m1:u~01L ilu.'fi1:uri ril'VI\101 Hlm::Lu u11~1unmun1;[:uu.'fi1<il,moh1 LL'ii ~nnYltJ.Jfl~.yj li)

~ " " 'll.iM~h L il.u.m-:;u'ii 1l Ul.J 101 ~1'1'1111 ~nnYl EI.Jfl~~ l!J LLll::Yi cl ~ !l.Jii a1Wi1 :u111 i'l01'JJ<J11

~~

Page 16: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

, 1 v ..f ~ •• 1.';1 d 'I .. d !'I v A 'I. , "'' I 1.\ WhlnTHUlJW1'1Hl"IJ1 !.J I l"H'tl L "II Ell\ L'll!.J::1J1L UEJ;r;n nLuU~HI.Jllil Un11EIUW1'il L Vlll

IIV "' , 'U , 81

. 1 v ..f 'I •. 1.';1 d 'I .. 1 v .';1 .. d d n11l11 fl1;1n11aruru1'11El"ll1!.l Ll"tl"t1L"IItJUL'll!.J:::u1 'il!.lf-Hlnl"tD.Jfl'ill'l l!:l LLfl::l'l cf. "'"' , 'U'U

ir~ 'tli't~tl n u~ Vlli'1 ~ 'il1lJ -r~ linll 1.\ ru LL a :::n n VllJ1 !.J LUI~ tl ~ n111 ~'li' tllJ a'li11 a11 dJ or..tl "'"' :q 'U

mi ~1i11ru:·nuar.i1-Jmmhu 11ll.J.Jm1i'il1 ~iim:::mum,-'i'url.Jm1llfl'il L ~uri au ~v::: iim,-l'lv11nnull~ L ~w·nau 1 ~ ~ nnVl D.Jfl~~ G) fi..J\1.1ll 1 uiruru1:fia 't wVl1 LL~ D r.i1-J L'il

'U 'U "' "'

I '1,.<1 R':1 .... d ~ "' I d , "'.... a ... I' a1u~nnl"tD..lfl'ill'l "' LLllv:::EJ1-J11lln11 LVI"IItlllfll11-JL11J L'll'il www.eppo.go.th uanv1n

~~ ~

v::V11'li' Ell;J<~ 'l~D r.i1-J"\hn'i1LL<~::L"li'1ii..J 1~ tnn LLa1 u.Jtl11n!J'li'Elm1lJ'i1Lihm,-1. ~u1m,-

L :n.J'Ji' a~<~ 'tli a1ll11fl H•h~ ii.Jm.Jn!)VI ll1 u't~ ~1VI'i'umlll1-i'Vi u1m\.h 1 ui~n 'il"ll a..1

~n nVJ El~fl~~ cr lu~1u.:::~1U n~1\1.Lfl"ll1\tn11fltu.:::m1mTim1LL1iJ1 1"11~LL y;.JtJ1:::L l'l~Ll'l !.J 'U'U ~ ,

r.iallu'li'Dllfl~'t~1uv1n atltl.<111 'illll~L~il1~ 1uf'h tim,- 'l~LLri 11 !.J.J1\tn11~mn ~

m1lJL Vlm::all 1m.Jm1 11 u~1um,-tJ,-:::d.iu~<~m:::l'lu~1U~..JLL1'ilatJlJ LL<1:::11 u~1u m,-tl,-:::d.im.J <~m:::l'lu~1ui~flllLL<~:::'li'Dll<~~1~ 'l ~ ~~ u1'li' D~ LL~nnau'tliiim,-,b'll m.J <~

~ ~

~L~'i'u lJ1 L ~ !.J LL w11 ~tJ1::: "1!1 "l!U Lifu l1111J'Ji' Elll Gl El r.i1~lt'1 n~ ~fl n fl tl~ fl ~~ cr ~ ~ ~

h;;1u::: ~)j 81u1vr'hnu"' tw m1vh~1U"IIEJ~m~.mf'Vl u1mi1LL<1::: 1 u~1u::: t"' u 'il1~ "" 'U 'U or..tl

~~ EJ.J tll)u1i nT1'il1ll nlJVI m u L ~ DL~iinTJL~ u LL vd"ll D~ <1"li11 "11'1. ~ "11i11ffi'll\t 1u m1u

LL Gl::: n 1 .. i 'ill ~)j n .. ::: 1J l \1, n 1 .. r 1J VI~ f\111.1 ~'ilL~ u. "II El ~ tl .. ::: "1!1 "]j 1.\ LL Gl::: n 1 .. f) llJ f) jJ '

1~wliltJ~1u.'tui~n'il'titll)u1iV1tt"1~Dr.i1~;Jn~D~'il1ll.ffwnDu.Lt~nau't1i~1Lii.u.m1t>1~mh1 LL~mh~1'il

~nnVla~fi~.J~~11~m1LvillL~lll1 11u~um,-~nH1fl11lJLVIm:::alJ tm~m• ~~

d1 t1~1U.n11tl1:::dJ U.~ Gl m:::l'llJ i1'U.~ ~ LL 1 'il a tllJ LLGI:::11 tl~l\1. m1tJ1::: Lii \1.~ Gl m:::l'llJ i1Uff ~ fl lJ

dhtDna11"11EJ~ 1m.Jm1't wVl1Via~J1 L'llu:::u1 ~~u1'ttl1~~Yllu.1 tm~m• ~D u1'!tl1 ' ~

L'll u:::u1 Y-111 n eJ{ -;h n 'il ~ .. JL jJ 1.\ ii.~lJflfl Gl~v'ill'l::: L u tl\t'illlJ n nVIlJ1 ti'JJ El~ atltl. Gill ' ' :.J

'ti11-;i1~1J1Bl1~ mnHlL~ i 'ilvl111 tl~1\tt>1~mhl.:fi U.L ~ miJ 1.\ 'ttlmlJL1 Ell\ L"IJ111 tl M n!JVIllltl

'll D~ atltl. Gill L'il m1 u~1u. .J~ ~lJmJ ut>1~mh1 'tii'il'Y11.:fi U.L ~ mhi ~VIU 1 u~1U."II D~f;;ulfl ~

"tltl. Gill L ~El'Y11n11'ildlv aeJu LLGI::: 'lt>11um1DmNil'il !.JVIU1 u~1U."11 D~'i';;m <~ atltl. <111 ' ~

rifu el'il"l!EllJ Lm.J m• J.Jif 11 tJ.J'mJ.J"lumTu L umD na111.h:::n DU ~ru ru1 ~m.lm'\.1 u ~

1:::'1'111.J'i';;m<l atltl.G11l nuu1'!tl1~~YllmLm.JnTi ~.Ju'li'mi1VIU.'il ~El~ m1fnH1fl11llaU ~ ~

L'il uu1'!tl1 ~~w.~u.1 1m.Jm1'ti~.JLDna11.J.J"1lJUJ.JU 1 ~~nni'ID.Jfl~ri G) 'illll~Du. L'll ~ ~~

Page 17: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

iru ru1:f 1l"ll1 U hiV11 er t1 nV11lH1 ~~ l>l ~-.l ~~h~11111t1U1111 L 11 'ilL~ U LL ti erw €1-.l fl ~ .... ... 'U'U 'U

oft-ln111'Yl1'1'l U1n1J11 U1i1\.L::thunn\Hiil"ll1nn11Atu.::n1111n11LUi.J11"JJ-.l LL ~-.l'll1~~'Yl U ~

n~~ L1'11111tl L 11 fl L ~ U11 U iii:: La U f!'Ji' €111 !ilL '1-L L 1l n L1'11J-.l 'l'o 11 fl ~ 1l 11'1 TI11tu.'ll\.L ~olL '1'111:: "

th::L'Ylf1Li1"ll1J-.lltmm1 ~1) L1'th..l.ii111 U-ll~1JUtu191LiLiJfiL~Ulol err~nW€1-lfl~~ 10) " .., 'U '1.1

LU\.LL l'l !.J.,j er:fa ~vlY1Ti!1n tm-ln11l YIV11'1'la-l.J1 ~'l!u::u191111iruru1:f1l"ll1 u~ vlV11nU 'll , .......

u11f'Yl ~'llu::u1 'l'l11na{ -;hnfl ~~iiv.ll:1~fl1111'11n111UruL~U1num11uw-.lm111~f~Lv;u , 411 'U"'

(111<il11 '<>"") LLiil::n111h::d:iU~iiln1::'YlUol1'1-L~-.lLL1fl~1l11 L1'"llfl1'1'l LLiil::i-lfl11 thv.1u '

lm-lm11vlV11'1'la-.l.J1 ~'l!u::u1uGi m.h-.l Lfl L '1'111:: lm-.lm171'-.lmh1 ~~1~\llu t~mm1 '

'JJt~-.lerr~nVla-.lA~~ 10) LL~Lllutm-.lm1~u11f'Yl ~'llu::u1 'l'l11L1a-f -;hnfl M1'ui11umu "" '

-;nn1'1iU1iil L1'UU.iil11 LLiii::Lllu1m-.lm1~~-.lau1u L1'UU.iil11 J-.ll1'1l-.l~-.l ~-.l~~L'li'1'lhu d "

L 11 u 1m -.l m1~ au m u M1'11n-1111U ru~71'a-.l 'l''h m11UW-.lfl1111 ~fl L v; '1-L'JJ tl-.l u1::'ll1'llU 'll ... 'U ....

V111l,) €1-.l U lJ U~ <;11 11 nlj"V\ 3J1 U L ~ U1 flU n111.h:: dju~iil m::'Yl U 'i\"1\.L~-.l LL 1 fl i €111 ~"ll111'1'l LLiil:: ~-.l fl11 er t1 n V11l-l fl ~ ~ l>l ~ -.l ~~ ii V\ \l: 1~,) €1-.lU 1i U~ 91111fH1111 '1-L ru LL iii:: n 1l 'l'o 111 U

'\I'll c.J ... 'U"' OcJ

L~U1nUm1fUW-lrl1111~m};u71'-.l~erV1a-.lA~mh1B1-.l n11L1If~L~U'Ji'1l11ii11m-.lm1~vlw1 " "

'l'l a-.l J 11'l! u::u1<;i 1l L1'11l11nt'll\.LLU\.LL~ au 'l"JJ~ err~ nW€1-.lA~~ 11'. ii :w ~ L v;'I-L'llillJ ll1'1-\Uf!li ' " "

ernn-rlil-.lfl~~ l>l unu~tiil'I-Liil-.lU13J~turu1:fa"ll1U~vlV11 oft-.lernnWil-.lfl~~ l>l 1'ii"iflrh 'U'U ~ "'"' V'U

'Ji'iJ:Wiil L ~ U1 flU n11fu:fil l vlvh111n 1A1-.ln1111-.ll vlV11'1'l a-.l.J1 ~'l!U::U1L~ U LL 'l'li " . ' <;i 1l 11'1 ll11 rn 'll'U,~1\.L 'Yl1-.l L l U 1 'l!'ii"'JJ €1-.l er tl nV11l-.l fl ~ ~ l>l 'l'l"l il11 LL-;) -.l "Ji €1-.l 'Yl1-.l 1 \.L nTH 'lh n -.l

"" ,r €111 iiiL yj 11 L~ m ~ U1 n 1J 1m-.lm11 vlV11'1'la-.l.J11'llu::u1 ~1\.L 'YJ1.,j L 1 u '1. 'l!'ii"'JJ1l-.lU1 H"YI 1'1lu::u1

" ' ' '1'111 L 1 ilf ,j1 nfl LLiii::'JJ iJ.,jfl rn::m1mnn11LL~J11 'JJ.,j oft.,j LU\.Ln11L11fl1 iln1 (1" 1 i erV11l-.l "~

"

1 m-.lm171'-.l n ri11~-l 1~1 'li1m-.l n11'JJ a-.lf2~11:: Iii" tl.Jul)u~ ~nm::dJ uu ~1u n u 1 u nf2 :wwn1

··h'i\"1Un1T:rUW-.lfl1111~f!Lv;U'JJil-.llh::'ll1"lf\1> 'l'l.f1. l!Jd'.<L'.t LL<;iernnW€1-.lfl~~ l>l n1'i\"u1 ""

"'"' .: .~ "" ..,. 0"'"' "'"' 601<1..' •

LL U1'Yl1-.l<ii13JV\iilnLnrn'Y\ n11L~ULL'I'l1"ll 1J3J iillil111'JJ il <:J! '1Jil-.l1::LU UUL1'1U nU1Un11i11UiilWl-.lnii111 " ~

m L lluu u 1m-.l 1 um1ifi"Y11"1T il11iil 1m-.l m1'1. vlV11'1'la-.l.J11'1lu::u1L Yl il hrt um1Lr-~ u LL 'l'li " '

Page 18: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

'li'1l1lil lm.:Jm'ii.:Jmh1 ~n,f.:J ~nnV!a.:Jr~~fliO) Miim1li'li' 1l1JaLvi1lLfi1lLLa::GJau'll a'li'nm11 ~ ~~ ~

'IJ1l..1~~au h lm.:Jm1~11l~~flmi1u lm..1n111~ tJ LtlunTHhL Uum1m1J LL u 1'Yl1.,j ~ ~

~~h~Uil H GJ11J'Vl1::11'l!U ru rufi'li' mJ <l'li11 a'11'1J fl.,)11'Jln11 Vi. fl. l!:J If eta lJ1 Gl11 10) 10) ~ ~ "

~1l'li"u~nnf:l1l.,jfl~~ .r 1iltJm1lni"'VltJ1mi11wnu::~11Xn.,j1ULil"lnnm1r~ru.::m11lm1 "" ~

Lu.iJ11 'IJ.:J LL vi..1'1!1 ~L "Yl !JL~fm1 !J..11Un11~n'l!t1ri111JL l'\1J1::a1J lm..1 011 11 !J·:J1U

m11l1:: L ii 1.1.1-1 <In 1:: "YllJ ~1 1.1.~ ..1 LL 1 Gl a 1l1J LL <1::11 !J ..11 U n11U1:: L ii 1.1.1-1 <In 1:: "YllJ ~1 U a ,'I rill

LLil::'li'1l1Ji1~1..1 ') ~L~ tJ1'li'nJ 1~w lum1i~nYih~''li1l1lil~1l'li"u 1r~1..1m11'1'JVI1'VlLl..1J1 1'lltJ::u1 " " '

J., m r~f..1 111JJ..1m11l1::'1!1Ji.nlle-~a m1l"YlfYw1mJ1u..1Ll.ia11J11t1LU~LI-l!J11!J<I::Lfl!J~ ' '

:; .,j~ "~ .1.1 ~ ' d .1.1 d !'I .1 'IJ!l..1L1lmn1"Yl.:J~1J~"Yl L~11J'il1n auu.<l11 il..10<111 LU1l..1'il1n auu.<l11 'll.:JLuUu1::L"Ylf1

Li1'1leJ.:J 1m.:~m1!T-:~1l.i1luru1GJliL11GJLe-~tJM mh.:~ 11nGJ11J Li11'11X1~~11Xn-:~1uL<~"lnnm1 ' ~ .. . rl ru.:: n11lnnn11LLl.i \t 11 'IJ.:J 'hill 1 La'U eJ L 1l n a'111l1'Vl111J 1-1 iln11U1:: Lii 1.1.~ .:J LL 1 Gl a 1l1J

1:: iu !.J"Yllif\1 aGJf'll !l.:J 011~~1.1.1 L yJ f:l1 Vi ti'.:1J11 1-l.LLl.i J1 t 'IJ.:J a1 !JU1::1i1 UGJ eJ Uih ,'J '

.. .. Vlti'.,jtt1'l'lltJ::u11GJtJ1'ii'Le-~tJLL'Vliwna11i.:~na11m..1LllJ't'l!'11'1l1l.:Jrlru.::nnmnm1LLl-ill1 hJLLa1

' mmm1.! ~ L 1Yi1 i'll eJ 1J il tm.,jm11Ull1:: L"Ylf1L "Yl mhwm m r~f.,j dh 'lll <i111J 1J ~'ll eJ .,j

" rl ru.:: i\ 1,'1 1 u PN PCA Working Group ~,) il ~ ..1 ;j u m !J 1'ii 1:: Lfj !J 1J 1l ~ u~ PN PCA

m1Jm'Vlmn-ni'1 'l'ii'L:nru~iJ ~1u 'l'ii'L~ tJ'il1n r;i .J.:~w)GJ~ ~~ul.i J11'1J,'JL'li'1i11lnYi1i'li a11 nlm..1m1 ~.. "

L vi eJ L'lf'Jl eJ ~<ilL i':ULL<I::'Jl elL a'U!l LL U::L .yi1J L~1J t~tJ n11l"Ylf'Vl !J1n""i,r1 L~\t 1 ~.:J'Ji' eJ La'U!l LL 1.1.::

LL<I::'li' 1l a.:J L n GJ~Mfm1 n 111::'1!1'1!1-l.~i:i ~1U L~L ~[J~ L 'li1i11J L 1Yil i'li !l1J n1m.:Jn11L 'li1 ~ " " "

m1i'l'il11lli1'll !l..1flru::r'\1,'J1U PNPCA Working Group L via lii1m1i'l'il11ru1 L~ !J1 nu .. .. lm ..1011 t~ tJ a111:nn'll a..1 r1 ru::m11l1lfn11LLl-ill1 t 'll..1 ~a 'lll l<il !Jn11l "Ylf'Vl !J1 n•ll1

'l'ii~hL Uum1Y1 !JeJ !Jl.t1'll eJ1lil lm.:~m1L rh~'l'iii'uauru1GJ1 'lfLll~LI-l!J'il1nf~m<~ allll. 1111 '1.1 'I.... "'

11..1 Ll-l tJ LL Vi 11 u L 'lu L'll'1i''ll a-:1 fl ru.:: m11l1lfn1dLLl.i J 1 t 'll..1 m 1l"Ylf'Vl tJ1 mJ1 'l'iiiJ 'VI ,r., ~a d <V.d d 0 <V A ""'

"Yl obob/IO)OJI<fl!:J il..11U"Yl "'"" L1Jl!I-1!JU l!J<f<f~ t1..1a'11.1.0..11UL<I'll11in11rllli::m11l11in11

LLl-ii1 t 'IJ.:JL vi eJ LL i ..1'Jl !l~ ~ L i': 1-l.LLil::'Ji' eJ rl..11 <I'll eJ.:JU1::'1!1'l!U~iJ ~11.1. L'ii'L~ !J~ L 'Ji'1i111 m1.J ~ L 1 n "

1 i iJ il1l <~1m ..1 n1 "l L v.J vhv~ ti'..1 J 1 L'll tJ:: u1.J..1 m I'A'., LL <1:: m 1J n1vHJ1 mJ 1 L'il 'll <1 1 i " '

~1,X n..11ULil'IJ1lfn11rlru.::m11J1lfn11LLl.iJ 1 1'li,'JLLi..1 autl.il11 oE..1Li'J mh::L "Ylf1L i1'1JeJ.,j lm..1n11

Page 19: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

LLa::m~1nTHU!Jl !.Jl tH.Jm mur.J 1~iim1LLi;~'Jim.m 1m;, nl1Ltl U;JU1::L 'Ylfllll~a'lJl'in 11

mu l~m::mum1'JJ8;JfnllJ~na;~LLl.lti'l L'JJ" vu1. l!lcfm<t atltl.al1 L'll[ju!Tm.hum;,

fflUO;Jl'l.tL a'JJl~nl1~ rn::m1m ~nl1LLlJJl l 'JJ.J LL 'l'i;~'lll ~ alTllm::tn 'l.tnl1tl1n l!ll'ln18

1i1.Jl'l'14l'JJ 8-J tm.:~m1 '1. 'l'li'hVIt.JJl L'llu::u11~La-1"alJmrn~llJ"ll mhl'IU'Il'JJ 8-JmllJ~n a.J ' "

LLl.lti'll'JJ;, Vl.fl. l!lcfm<i LLth LLa::1;iUla athhl1 uuuum1H'L8n~'Ylif~';J::<ihLiiu ~

1m;, m1~" n1il1 'llllJ ~l'l.tl';J 8~1..11~ E.J'JJ 8;J~u ;1..:~m1i <11 L 1ril '!K'Ji 811 a 1m;, m1L 'l'lvh "

VI t.JJl L'llE.J::u1'JJ 8.Jn1lJ'Y11VI E.Jl mti'lii 8L~·hii1ll~Hl'l.t Ll.l LL~ n <iil;J';Jl m:: LU uu ' ~

u 1um tJLLa::LLf.l'l.t Vlt.J.Jl'l.t '1.~-m nl1Lf.l tJLLVIi'li 8lJa~.Jnal11 m 'lu't'l!Gi' www.eppo.go.th "

ri 8u ~';I:: 1~ii m1a.:~u llJ hiru rul 11 m~.J filun.Jl'l.t u 1 u m u LLa:: LLf-1 u VI t.J;Jl u v ~

~ 'l.<d Q..o ..:I d ...... d ...... "' L'lllJVIU.J<1"8'Yl VIU o'bocf/m<i(i)fi) a.J1WYl mo nli.!.Jl!.JU J.Jcfcfct 'JJ8~1llJ8UL~1l::'l'l

' Lf.lf.JLLVIi-ll 8lJ aUULl1J L'l1Gl'JJ8.J~lir n.Jlutlt<llohunmun1:omt'll1 n 8llnl1~lL u 'Unl"l~Jmhl " ~

Md:J um<LL'il.J'li 811 mLa::Lf.ltJLLVIi'li 811 aM tl<::'lll'liU'Y11lU'IlllJlJ~ ~rn.,~:olJu'll1~ rll'I'\'U'IlL~ 8'U L'JJ " " ~

1iLf-ltJLLVIi-ll 811 a Lm.Jm<Luh LLa::n 8llLtl um<~lL it um1Lf-ltJLLVIi'li mJ amh.JL'I'IlJl::alJ " "

L Vl".il::m<Lf-IE.JLLVIi"ll81la 1 UL 'iu L'l!Gl'l'h 1 i-ll 8lJa~.Jnril1 LL Vl-:fm::';Jl u1~ mh.J<1 <11 L 11 n·h " "

1Jlm,5u ') ua:: 'tl.l-;hn'll<:: u::nalLUm<Lf-1 E.JLLVIi'!i8lJ a "

~i'J8.J~~~.J<1"llJ~1JL~'Il~UrlufllLLC1L'l.J a.Jl'U~ rno Vlr]l'l~nlf.Jl-1. l!Jcf.cf<i "

:fiLL'il.JL ~ lJL~ lJmrn~ {1 ni'l8.Jf1~ ~ rn L~'l'llLLf.I'U ~\illmnlt.J f-1~ '11., 'l'li'll'JJ 8.JU1!:L 'Yli'IL 'Y1 tJ (PDP ""

l!:Jo ..,ct) iim1L ~lJL~lJL ~81-I.L'lltJ::u,1m1umu'l'l t.J';Jln~l.<ilii nl1~lL it 1-l.nl1'thitytylsfi'8

., 'l'li'll 'ttl LUll mrnf.lam::'YlU'lillJVI"llJLL<ill-l.oi 8U"l::L 'Ylf1~ LLl.lti'l t 'IJ;J L'l'\ a1.h1-1 m rntnl!lrn::

'IJ 8-J L~ 81-I.L'll u::u1~ii t nl!lrn:: LLU1J L~ f.J1 nuL~ 8U5u 1ua lJJl L'JJ.J~';):: .,-·h.,] nl1 ' '

L tl ~ umLtl a.J 8 Ul.J1ULL 1-J <ii 8~ rnmVI'JJ 8-Jti' ·wil u L ~au ' '

~nnW8.Jf1<ii~ ct flmilLLna.J a.Jl"uf1 rno Vlr]l'l~mr.ru klcfcf<i :fi'u'il.Jnl1 "" I 'l-' I o

0 "" d ..... "' ...... Q..< .:!! ...... 0 d ...... .:oJ

<illLU1-I.nl1LntJ1n1J'Il8n.Jla'llllJ'I'\1-I..J<1"8 n1lJ'Y11VItJln11-l.l 'Y1 o'bo'b/<0)<.'11cfkl a.J11-I.'Yl <0)\!J

Page 20: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

\!:lo

fi1G'11l1lmt,1Wv11"fU1fl~Lrla1u~ mo VH)fl~n1U'U ~cUd l~UL~fuVf-.1 a1ti'Ji 8 L nvv1..:J'll 8-.1~~1 n11Li1'lJ 8..:1 ~1'1.1.11-1. ~1:}LL'il-.l~1 U11'il1'lJfl'lll'fml fllJ ~11-1.1 'il'il1n

' ' " 'Va':1 ..,.,t A~ "".':1 .... .J .J V .,';1 a.J o.J' 'V

~na..:Jflil'YI.JallJalJL'il~ ~na'lfl~'YI 1i> 'YI md LL~::~nnna-.lfl~'YI «! U~::f11'11LL'il-.l~1U11'il1 'll 'U \I'U

1.h::n il1J~1 Lm ~-m11mdJ1.1. v.\i..,aa"JJ a'lf1~1m11l'Lm ~"fl~~. v LLa• ' "

fl1~ 'l~m1vViv11tu1LanaT'i~-.lVI:IJ~ 1u~1U1Ufl~ n!JVI:IJ1 EJ 1::Li:i EllJ 'VQ..o' ..... .J.J ""tl ~ v

LL~::"Jl illJ'IfllJ'YIL n El'l"ll 8-.l 1::n au~1 EJLL~'l

'li a L;; 'il v1" 1u vr "'ti i1 Lf11" nT'i t "i "'vi Vl1 VI~" Jl l'Jl [J:: u1 i.., a cih ' "

LL"ll'l-.1 L'Jlu::uJ <n1i11rn1_2tl1::'lnntl'lilutl"i::"lf1"lfU~11 (atltl.~11) Lilum1af1-.1 L ~au n~J1 umLllJ 1 t,.., L Vi a EJ m::~mi 11 i a ..,:flu 1~ EJ 'tll ~ m1eru J1 a anv1 n utiJ 11 ,.., LL ~:: 'tti ~

" n11L nu nnJ1 LVI i:iauL ~ fl'U ~ij a1-.1 L nuJ1~1 Ltl n11af1-.1 L ~ il'U 'YI~J1v::r'i11 i1::~1JJ1 ~ .!'y .r ' ~ "~tl .. ~" .. mLL :IJ'I\1 L 'lJ ..:1 a -.l"ll 1-I.L 'il. '1'11::"lf1 -.1 LL 'lJ 1-.l L'Jl El:: 1J 1 L {l -.1 ~ 81-1. L~"ll 8-.1 L:IJ a -.1 Yo ~1 -.1 '1'11:: 1J1 -.1

" ' 1~ uih::~u\h 1mi'L~ El-.ln m::.luJ1a-.1a~ 1 uq~J TV\~1 mf'i1lJ"lf1~ ~11.1.~1mri1-.l"ll a-.lLLli J11 'll-.1

" ' " v::iJ1::.luJ1f11:1Jtln~ 1m-.lm'lh..:~'tvlVl1'1'1~.:JJ1't'l!EJ::u1ii~m!trn::Lilm~auflemn1~unlJLVI~n

' U11 <ililo L:IJ'fi1 fl'll:1Ja..:Ji1J1hi'-.111.1. l!ld.~ L:IJ'fi"'l ~n11~'fii..:Jtl"i::m::lJluJ1Lyjflh!

" " ~i1'fim::LLaLvlVl1'iilU1'1.1. <ilO lJl'l.l. L~U~'fii-.lLfl~a-.lrl1LU~lWVl1'll\tl~ <ild~ LlJn::l'fi'il

'iilU'l'll. d Lfl~il-.1 Lyjil~i1~'1'1Gl-.l-.ll'll.LvlVl1LiLLritb::L'YlfllrlU LL~::'lJUl~ \>o LlJn::l'fi'il

'ii1m'll. <i) Lf11a" L Vi a ~a'fi'l'l Ll-.1-.ll'll. 'l vlVl1lvhLTi atltl. ~11 1m-.1m1.1'-.1n ri11 a amLuu

1iiit11::~J11l1V11m1aaruv"i~~nm~ll"i1'1l."ll11n11..:~ li)~ LlJm v11 <i)\!lo L:IJ<fi"i " ~

L Vi a1a..:~1'u m1atyv1m..:~J1 ~1V11UL18'llu~ -.1'11'1.1.1~ ~ oo iu LL~::~m "t1 iil1 ~-hu Lvi81mnwwrrtll.'llni'l-.1 <i)o L:IJ'fi1 ~'finut~8'1l.~lwrrlu u8nv1nif tJ..:J88nLLuu1iii

' 'Yl1-.l1::1Jl uJ1 ti''ll.un LU m ~ 8'lh U"i::muJ1 L~ 8 L ii~ 8'Yl n.il u 1 'll.{]~JlVI~ln L~ 8Lm-.ln11

q q "

af1-.l LLti'1 La1v'il:: tl ;;i 8 uti 1 LVI~ fil 1-1.1 1-I.LL'ii ~ ::1'1-i.L 'Yh nu t1'1:1J1 m J1~LVI ~ L 'li11~ u 'lti 0 .... ... .... .... ....

n1"iflnL nl.J'Ib 11 .J-.1\i 1-1. ti1:1Jl ill \b 1 u<imLli ih 1'lJ-.1v:: Li]u LU~1lJ1i11lJ"lf1 ~ 'fi iil E1 ~'i1-.1lJ '

1m-.lm1.1'-.ln<i11'il::~" 'lvlVl11 iti1::L 'Ylf'IL 'YIU'iilmu <il, l!ll!lo LlJn::1~'11 ~,~ ~-.l:IJ 8l.J 'lv!Vl1 '

'lllULL~UL'YIU- ~11 dJm::U::L1iil1 ~Iii iJ ~-.lLL'iilJ kl~kl LlJ'Il.iULtl ~!fidJo\.I,'I'IGl-.l-.111-l.lvlVll LU~ tn .. h::mrn.l'J iil:: \>, .O:kl"" tflWV\1.bU iJ rl q]Tll'h l vlYllfl-.l.y1la .. htJ~ U'll.LLUI.'l-.l'illlJTlfnb :fm '1'1~ -.1

1 1 ~ !'I ~ ' ~ •. 1.':1 d ' ~ ~ ~ d tJ" " ~ ., d \l,q] !ill~ iil nLL iil:: U -.1 L u 1-l.il qJ 'll fll L nnl YlLL '11-.l'JJ U ~~ LlJ ilL 1 U 1J L 'Yl Ul.J n lJ 'Yll -.1 L ~ il n 8 'll.

mil1~a iJrl!fi1ll'hlvlVllLU~U ill "lflULL'fi'l.l. 'ii1U1U l!:J.<i)\> 1Jlmi8nLI.'ll'fi'if- i'1 1lJ-.l

Page 21: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

. . ~ .. 1l !.l 1 ~ !.l ·HI u (Agreement on the Cooperative for the Sustainable Development of

MeKong River Basin .t April fi)fli<i<f.) LLLtl LLi'l:: (1!1) ·h.Jityty1tEa'!nu1rlvh1m~m1L'll!.J::tf~ 1~~hUn11WI1l'iJVl'i111mTil1mh~n~1Uel!.Jn11~.J~Wi J.Jd Li~rlnVlfl.Jfl~~ m LLGI::~ OJ

'U " '\1 'U

LiJ<ilL~w'Il mJi'l tm.Jm1U'iia~T!i11m'liu ~.J'iimmYn nVl fl.Jfl~~ r1.1 um1tl1::'limd al'u ~ 'U 'U'\1 q

fi)fi) :JJm1fllJ l!!.t..t..r L.iii:JJ~L~U'lifllJLLG~::1um1uW~1:JJ:lJ~'llfl.J~nnV1a.Jfl~~ I!! ~.Jnci11 ~~

1<il u~1m.Jm11rlV11'V'lll.Jtt11'llu::u1'lla.J ~tltl.i'11l Lilu 1m.Jm1viw.Jmuuil1J11'1l.J~1 u '

th:::lilU 1 ULL'lll.J1'llu::u1 Ttm::m1:JJn11LL:J.iJ1 1'li.JLLvi.J'll1~i'l1lL~ii'VI~.J~fl~ cr<i<i/LNMCS '

i'l.Jl'U~ OJm nU!.l1!.JU I!:Jrlrlm n.J~1~0.J1ULfl'll1~nl1flm::m1:1J1~nl1LL:J.iJ11'lJ~ L .y1 fl L~:IJ n11mmn'VI11fl al.J'VIll' 1 mrn1m.Jm11 rlYJTI'lll.JJ1L 'll!.J :::u1~l !.J n11ti.J L 8 n ~11

' L~ u1nu tm.Jm11rlV11'V'lll.JJ11'llu:::u11~mi 11 !.l.J1Un11~mnm1:JJL 'VIm::~:JJ tm;~m1

' 11 !.l.J1Un11U1:::dhu.J i'lm::l11J~1U~ .J LL l <il fK 1l :lJ 11 !.J.J1Un11U1:: dJ U~ i'l m::111J ~1U a;~ fl :lJ

<a.- I .d d 'V d 1 ~tl d A .., 'lo'd tl4 ~ <V 1

LLi'l:::'llfl:JJ<l<il1.J 'J mnul'llfl~L'V'lfl 'VI 1::Ll1~fl1fl~:JJ1'lin t<il:JJn11 1nl!f1'V111flnunflu "'

LL<l::LdfllU~ I!:Jo Wifl1fl:IJ I!:Jrlrlm ~1~n.J1UL<l'll1~nl1flm::n11:1J1~nl1LL:J.iJ11'lJ.J '

M ci .J'Ilfl:JJ <~ tm.J m11 rlV11'V'lll.JJ11'll u::u11iLLri flm::m1:JJ m1LLliJ1 b.J'll a.Jtl1:: L 11~ ~ '

fl1~ t'llJ11in 5u '] L .y1 a1itJ1::L l1~fl:IJ11inVl'i111m1U1::LiJu~ <l m::l11J~fl1<ili1'ii::L nW~'il1 n

m1flf1.J L ~au L'llu::u1~.Jiiii1'VI U<il L 1 i'l1 LLiKl Lfl1'ilm u 1 u ~ L~ au ~m1 nl'u ~tl1:: L 11ft '

~m1intl1::L 'Yl~t'l<ilrl1 ul.i1uLfl nt'l11 ( tW~ utl1::L 11~111 u1~1u LeJnt'I11Lllutl1:: L l1~t'l<ilrl1 u ' '

Lna1uf1 "'"' W~<llfl:JJ I!:Jci'<i"m) ~~munl'VIU<il ~ L~em 1u1urll!l"' L:JJMluu l!:lrtrt..: '

~nnVl fl.Jfl~~ .r l<il um:JJ111'V'l rnmJ11mnu::~l~n.JlULi'l'lllUnl1fl m::m1m~m1 'U '\J "' "

LL:J.i J 11 'li.J LL vi.J'lll ~111 !.J 1~ .JlL ii Un11 L ~ !.Jl nu nl1tl1 nl!fl'VIl11l Bl.J'VIU l mru1m.Jn11 1 vlvh

Page 22: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

~ !' ~ ".I 1 .1.1 .I " .I ~ •.t 1 .I YHI~U1 L'IH.J::l.J"i'YlL"UEI 1/i!.l "uu.GI11 'Yl'\J::""i1.:JL'IJEIUfiULL1lll>1 'll.:J"1!.Ju"i::ll1U

' ~ 1 u 'lh.:~~ t~r.il u ~u ~'II D.:J "uu. a11 1'11 u t<ili'llniili'li D11 a1~m m~ t vlvh Yl ~.:~lh 1'11 u::u1

~ ~ ' .t.J .d Q,;.J o A ~ Q,; d

ft"i.:J'Yl ~ Lllti1U'Yl l!Jl!J llfi"i1ftll l!Jclcl<i m EI1L11EIL'II!.J.:J'IJEI.:J '\J.:J'I'o1'11L'II!.J.:J"i1!.J

1'11 !.J ii w'L 'li1·h llfl.J Vt.:~ fi1"j 1 i'li EllJ GI~1U 1U ~ ... ftU U"i::nEJ 1.J .11 !.JU"i::'II1'11U ~ m 'lll1 ~ ~

.., ... ""' ..J ..¥ .J~ .... d .t.J .d .... .J Q,; f' '\1:: L'll"i1.J~am::'Yl1.J'Ylll1'\11fiYlU'Yl'\J.:J'I'o11/1L'II!.J.:J"i1!.J ft"i~'Yl l!J L1JEI1U'Yl ~o nlJ111YlUlll!Jclcl<i

' m !hLnm.:au.:~mu i.:~v.i'IILa!.J 1'11uii~L'liThlli'UW.:Jn1"iLi'liD1la~1U1U ~l!l!rl mt

~ ~

,.¥ ,d...., ""' A ~ ..J ,d QJ .J "-" f' '\11nYlU'Yl'\J~'I'o11/1La!.J 'l'oUEI.:Jftl!.J LLa::l.J.3n1'11 ft"i.:J'Yl m Lllti1U'Yl ~l!J nll111YlUll l!Jclcl<i , m !JlL11 ElL~ EJ.:JUft"iYlUlJ i.:J'I'ol'IIUft"iYlUll 1'11 !.J iiel'L "JiTi1lJfUVf.:J n1"i Li"Ji EllJ <1'ihU1 U

~ ~

..f .J....,. CV 0 A d

~l!Jcl ftU '\11fiYlU'Yl'\J.:JV\1'11Ufl"iYlUlJ lJn'll1'1'o1"i EI1U1'\JL'\J"illi LLGI::EJ1.JGI"i1'llll1U ' u '

hw W'L 'liTh 1lL 1 Yi m"i 1 i'li till aJ.:~ m LL vi.:~ "1.ifu'li DlJ a L'il. Yl1:: ff1 u ~ L Ul/1 L ~ !.l 'l<il fi D ~ ~ ~

1m.:~m"i1vlVl1Yl ~.:JJ1LuLLl-ilh 1'11~"1!.JU"i::ll1U "i1 ua::Le !.JVI'll EI.:J PNPCA LLa::""itl ~a '

lfl"i.:JnTi 1v1Vl1Yl ~.:JJ 1 1'lltJ::U1'1J EI.:J MRCS ~1U"i1!.J<I::Le tlV!LL<I::LDn ~"i'll EI.:J lm .:1 n1"i 't 'I'!Vl1 '

Yl ~.:1\i, 1'11u::u1ll-i "1ll1"irH U VIL~ u"1.<ilLLa::LUULEifi aYii'll EI.:JU"i::L 'Ylfl L 'ii'1'1J EI.:J lm .:1 n1"i '

~" u.:~ "1.3-i t1Uru1 V~L iL il VI L ~ u 1.1 LL<~::u"i::'llll ""ill~ <1 Lrl Diu~ ~ \l n ll m ~ wtf 1!1 ct ct .r , ... " " .. rn n"i!-l'Yli'YlmmJ1 tvlmntl~<~~1i'\11m1YiJ.:~"' fl~.:J~t-hum1V~m1lruwl-btJ.:J1U

' w o:J ..,{ V Q,; A A A A .._.,o A

mn tJ1'11 D.:J un1'1!1n1"iD "1:: "ll1'l!n1<ill "111 LLa::mu.::~'ll1 u1 ru n1"iYl'il1"irn 111 tJ .:11u ' ~ u

n1"il Lfl"i1::~ f.J <I n"i::'Yll.J ~.J LL 1 VI a Dlli1 Un1"i~ <ill U1 LL 'l'o ri.:J J1 L yj ElL i"Ji El ~VI L ~ U

"Ji EIL"UEILL U::L yjllL~lJ "i1llJ.:JLLU 1'Yl1.:Jn1"i~1L itU.:J1UL Ufl~.:J'i\ El "1,1.] 1V~ tln"ill'YlfYl tJ1mJ1

i.<iliim!.:~aEJ ~ o'olo'ol/!il<"llcll!J <I.:Jl'U.~ <ill!! LlJl:l-1tJU l!:lclcl<i fi.:~a1Un.:J1UL<I'll1lfn1"i fl rn::m"imlfm"iLLl-ii11 'll.:JL v1 eJLLi.:Jm1ll L ~u~1'ii'il1nm"i'ii'V~L 1-Yili'li Dlla 1m.:~ m"il '1'1Vl1

~

Yl i.:~J 1 1'11 tJ:: u1 oi1.:~ erii ~1 u 1.1L a tJ'll El" U"i:: L 'Yl fl1 'Yl tJ ii'li El n.:J 1 a'i\ Ell m .:1m "j 'l y.j Vl1 Yltr.:J J 1 ' ~

l'llu::u1 fi E1 ( <il) n1"iU"i::dJU~am::'Yl1.J~.:JLL1VlaEillL !ft.J !.J'Ylllfi1"V~f (SEA) LlJULfl~D.:Jii El ' '

~ iitl1:: l !.J 'J!,r), 'U. n1"i 1 i"Ji till a'Yl1.:Jl'l!1 n1"iLL ri ~jj ~1 U 1..i La !.J oi1.:~ ii fl1111 L ~ U i1 SEA ~ ~

fl1 1 fl 1 au fl all m "iU 1:: Lil u~ a m::'Ylu 'il1 n 1m.:~ m 1 '1. '1'1 Vl1 Yltr.:J J 1 J" 1 u LL l-i J 11 'li.J '

~utl"i::ll1ULLa::ihJ1~'111LLl-ii11'11.:~ ut~m1nd' SEA m1ii'li DllmJ'il'\JUU~D.:Jm"i H~~lt ~ '

'1ll ~" LLl-iJ 1 L ita.:J'illn~u ~'1ll ~ .:~ LLl.iJ 1'tfi1fu f.J a m::'Ylu 'ill n m1~1'1.:~ 1 ~ ElltL tJ u -.11 u 1 mJl n

(1!1) ti1::L~lt<il1lttl1::ll.:J Lw::m1BYl!.JYl£i1 u~lt'll a.:~tl a1 ~.Jii~ii ~1"\t 'l<ilL~uiim1 m ~u 11 ~

~ d o 1" " .I .f .I • ~ .I o ~.1 ' • !'I ' n11""i1.:JL '11 ElUEl1'il'il::Yl1 'VI (HUL"tlu<11LLa::vm 'Yl'l!ll"\1. 1Yl'il::lt 1Lu~~am::'Yl1.JG1 Elfl1111LuUEl !J 'U"' , '1.1 'U

Page 23: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

1mn

.I .l.d ~ , ,:'1 '"~~'I .I 1 .J ..,,, ~ 'lltl.:Ju1::"ll1"ll'U.'Y1'1'1.:J'I'I1'Y11'1'1U1n"i L'I.UL2Jm 'll.J anm ll'U. L9lu<l1 'il'U.'Yla amLllll n 11'1VI11J

1m.:~m1i.:~mh1 'l.a.iLta'iiam1a'l'l U'I'IU1 u~"U.'lla.J1.l<l1 i.:~J1.1. L vi a'li1 um1L m r-t<lm::nu

L~a.:~d' m1iim1aanuumT1.1. L91U<l1 h1.1. 1VIli (m) 1.l1::L~"U.~1'U.<;l::n a1.1. ~i:i~11.1.L~L~u 'II

, "~ • I .d ffl •. 1 ~ • I , '• ~ 1 d\1 "~ L 11'"U.a LVI 'il" 11'11 .:1 u u 1:: 2J1 t\I.L '1'1 a n1 1n 1.1. n1.:J u <l1L 'I.I.LL2J "1 'll.:J 'Y1 191 11l r-1 <l n 1:: 'Y11l 'il1 n 'II

IV l\ lA 0 .J G; .J fV

m1nu t12J'll a.:J9l::n a1.1. ( <£) L2J2Jn11n1VI"U.W~'Y1'11W~ L 'ilm n u1 nu 111mm1u11L 'Y11 r-~ <lm::nu

1.1.amnnU n111h::Lii"U.1-1am::nu~.JLL 1 WI a a 2JLliL~ a~m U~.:J r-.~a m::Ylmi a1::uuiiL 1 1'1

LLa::1::uu n11L VI <l'll tl.J\h L 'U.LLli\h 1 'll.:J 112J~.:J ~o~a m::'Y11l'lll2J'I'I12J LLWI'U. ~ii'ii al.l1:: L 'Y1 I'll 'Y1 !.J

~.:~J" 1m.:~ m1'1. vl Y11'1'1a.:~J1 L'l!u::u1r~11-;ij" 11'11.:Ju1.l1::m mL vi a .t.:~ n a.:~ n 1.1.r:hwru . ' 'II WI L "ll!.Jfl112J L ~!.JV11 U~ L nW~';11nm1fi a ~f1.:1 L ~ 8'U.LLa::m1ih Lit '1.1. 1m.:~m1i.J n fi11 ~ n~.:J i1 a.Jiim1i'mt1 H<i1-:~tl'1mmm1ha~1~W~ hLL1iJ11'll-:~1W~ mu'l'l1::a th.:~D.J 1 "U.rJW~LLa.:J

' 'II

( <l} m1iim1Lll W~Lr-tu'li'a2J a 1m1U.:J1"U.~.:JV12JW~'lla.:J1m.:~m1 112J~.:J 11!.l-31"U.ti1::Lil"U.r-t<lm::nu 'II

~ .:1 LL 1 WI a a 2J ~ LLU GIL tJ 'U.ll1 M1L 'Y1 U LL a:: LL 'il mh U11 U -31 '1.1. 1 i U 1::'1!1'1!\.1 'Y1111J fi 1-3 VI U 1

ri aum1 1im1m ~ Ut;Jf!EJW~';J\.Im1LUW~Lr-t!.J'li' alJ <m11~1L ii. u1m.:~m'i 1i u1::L 'Y1fl~m-nnm1u 'II

('->) ~ii"1"'l~~~uu.:~ii'li'm1.:~1<lL"U.L~a.:~m1wtnJm hmm1aci1.JrT-:~1'i" Li'ia.:~'il1nMam~ 'II 'II

Lli L vh.J.:J '1'1 a 'ii a m"iVl';l11t\1.1U"i:: Lilur-t a m::YllJ ~.J,r \.1 ~.:I'll tlL r:mtJ1 iiJ m 1'll EJ1 EJ L 1 a1

m;u1nM1VI11 tJ ri1-:~V11X1 a tJ n 'l.u <i1.a r-~ am1i'uw.:~m12JfiW~ LV:" ~L~'il1 n ~~~ a::u;:: L Y1 ~'~ 'il::'lln 'lthT" ri n Hl "U.mr~~o~mn'll an1U.:J1"U.m1mnM1VI11a tm.:~m1'1. vlY11'1'1a.:~J1 'l.'l!u::u1

' 'ii tJ2J1fl m:: m111 m1'i111 'l.~u1::'112J t1'lT ui ~1lT ru Lrl al'1.1. ~ .., oo1 L 2J '1!11 u" 1!1 ct ct <£

' u

L viaVl'i11"it\1.1~1Ur-l<ln1"iU1::Lil"U.r-tam::'t11J';I1n 1m.:~m1LvlY11'1'1a.JJ1 L'I!U::u1 U11n ni1 ' ' :..1

;j,j' a tl-31 a-;J1 ntl 1:: L Ylfl a2J1-nm11 U J1 L ~ a.:J r-1 a n1::'Y11J ~ -3 LL 1 WI If tl2J'Jl12J '1'11:1.! LL'fi \.1

LLa:: r-~ a m::YJu a:: 11'2J 1 "U.LLliJ 11 'll.J<i1-:~'il:: ~ .J r-~ <~ ~ ai ~ .:n1 <;l'Jl a .:J"ll2J"ll"U.Wt <~a 'fi a1 J 1'il 1.1. ~ .:1 '

a12J LVI~ U 2J U1 n u1i.J1 1 'll-3 LL'ii11 U <1:: L ~ U <filfl"l-3 n11~ L \1''U.a 1 i~ U "i::'lllJ vh11 t\1. 1 '

ij 'l.~i:i m"ii'i nM1 LLa::U"i::Lii\.1 1 'U.L~ tJ.Ji.Jnri11 LLa::~ U"i::'ll:IJ 'l.li ~12J11t1VI1'li' a r:nlli12J n" 1.ii ' '

IV ::. d .. I d .d ..,., .... 0 .d ..t .... .,. . " I A

'fi-3 '1.1. '1.1. Y1 u1::'ll2J ';I -3 2J 2J <;] IV\ '1.1. 1 L "i tl-3\.1 L au tl r-1 LL Y1 'U.fl t\1.:: lJ'U.t;J"i'Jl tl-3 LL <;]<I:: u 1:: L Y1 \'1 '1'1 'il1"i t\1. 1 ' 'II

1 i fl112J LV: 1.1.'ii a 1. u fl m:: m12J n11 LLU J 11'll .:1 LL vi.J'll1 ~ a11 'l.~i:i v. u.:~ ff tJ <~.:~1 u ~ 1!1 1!1 L:IJ '1!11 EJ'U. 1!1 cf eft£ n.:J ~1Un-31\.1La'll1 Tinl "ifl rn:: n "i"i2J1 Tin1"i LLU,r1 1'11.:~ Lb i.:~ 1 im11J

m1m ~"'ll a.J ~uu .a11 i1m::JJ1"U.m1u1nM1v.11ari1-:~v.1X1 Ltl"U. LU'i112J'li' tJrhv."U.'fi

'll tJ.:J m 12J t;l n a.:~ <l2J LLuJ11 'll" r~. fl . .., oo1 oo1 ct LLa:: i'i tJ'h m ::u 1 u m1 L ~1" ~2J JJ ;mLL<f 1 ' 'II

Page 24: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

'lJ m:: L ~ [J1 n" m:: 'Yl11" Vi a.,"hl1'1.HL fl:: ti eJ Ld'JJ eJ" (iU t.l. fl11 1..Jii VI U.:J if eJ fl" 1" rl 1!31!:1 UJ1:t1!JU l!:lclclci LL~.JLt.l El.J~~~Ul Lt11"·:JnT"l'.hm::1J1"\.\n11"tl1mnVo11mh.:JVIlt'1

'II

L (i1U1.11J1mvt1lJ'Ji mill'\ 1.\Vl'JJ eJ.:J fl11lJ il n fl .J ~ 1.1 Ul.hi 1 L 'JJ.J fl. f'!. WJ G'l wl cl LL Lt1 L "Ji"\.\ n "\.\ " '

eM~m 1m.:~m1~.JL!il~VoU.:J~eJ fi.:Jl"\.\.;1 w1 iinmvu l!:lrlrlci LL~.JlJ1rJ.J~nnVleJ.Jfl~~ WJ 'h 'U " 'll "U

at! t.l. a11 1~iiuri'u-h m::mum1t11nlf1Vo11 e1 ~1-:Jl'l 'll'1 L (i1"il (i2J1J1mLL Lt1 ~ ~~ "1 'II 'II

tm.Jm1Vii'eJlJ~"iJ::fi.JmlJaru nn nu~nn¥1 e1" "~~ W) nwrhd mhl!n.J1"\.\D v m1(i.J a<t~ ... .... 'U .., 'U "

'il11"il"i1.:~ iru ru1:A' !1"111 v hl Vl1 LL Lt1 L ah L'il u ~1 ,r n .J1" 5 u m1"a.J a<t~1~i\h ~" ~ fl ... "" '1.1 "'

n11W "il11n41 'il11 "il"i1" aru tlll :A' !1"111 [J 'vl ¥111m" n11L vl Vl1 Vi a.J ,..rl L'lf [J:: u11 iLL ri w w '

~.':1 .. .~ .d~.l A .~ t ~ ~tlnYieJ.Jfl'ill1 G> LlJeJ1WI1 l!:lci lJtlUl!JU l!:lclclci (i1"\.\n.J1"\.\U U1J1!JLLfi::LLe.I"\.\Wfi.J.J1"\.\ 'II 'II '

m::m1.:JVia.J.:J1"\.\ L~Le.l u LL Vii'li eJ lJ a 1fl1" .:Jn11"L vlVl1Vi a.:J ,..r 1L'lf u::u1u UL iu L'lfGl ... '

,d ...... .J a.; d _""'( IV \1 Vd <V All

www.eppo.go.th L lJ 1l1WI1 1!3 G'll n 1.\!Jl UU l!:l cl cl ci "il "\.\ tl.:J u "il "il1J 1.\LLCI:: 1'111.1 VI 1.\.:J (i eJ ' . ' d Q,; d Q,; t( I 0V

'11 W"\.\ o'o>ocl/m>iG>WJ a.J1'1.H1 mo n"\.\Ul!JU l!lclclci 'JJ1lfl11lJ1l"\.\LW.i1::'V\L~ULLW1"111llJa ' 'II

1JUL iuL'lfii''lleJ.:J~1Un.:J1"\.\tla<t~i.hltnu1!ln1;ilJU'il1 L vluli n11~1L itum1"LUU Lt.! 'i11lJlJ~ a

~ .':1 .. .1 fl ~ ~ ·~ , ~t.l "'lu.:J e.l tl nl'i 1l.:J fl 'il '11 cl LLCI:: L u U n11 LL "il.:J'JJ eJ lJ aLL fl:: L e.l !JLL W1""111llJ fll 'V\ 1"::"ll1 'lJWY1111J

'IJ'IJ 'U 'U

W.f'!. l!Jclci>i ~nnVlu.:Jfl~~ ci L~~VIlt'.:J~eJ ~1UlJ1n ~ YJ(i o'o>mo/l!JO"Jil!lm fl.:rru~ ...... l!J'o> Vli.'llfllJ l!:lclclci rl.:JUa<tlm::'i111.:JWa.:J.:J1Ul1 n1::YJ11.:J'Yli'ViU1n11i1dlJ"ll1~

' LLi.'l::~.:JLL1'1taulJ'JJ eJ.:J (iUU.i.'l11 L~iJ'V\1!.:J~eJ11 !l.:J1Ufl11lJfll1'V\lt1"111l.:Jn11~mm yjlJ L~lJ 1m .:Jn11"L vl¥11 W a.:JJ1L 'If u::u1vt1lJ ~t.l1":: L 'i1ft(ilJ1']n mll.:: n11"lJ1lin11"LL~J11 "11-:Jf 1l .:J"'I 1l

' ~1Ufl ru.::ii1.:J1U'll u.:J fl ru.::m1lJn11i1lJm u 1~ m::m"\.\m1"t.!1n 'j,J-1'1'\11 eJ ~1.:J'V\U1

Lciw (iU tl.a11 L~~1.:J1J1MYJ~t11nj,j-1W"il11"ni.1'111J'i11"\.\'Ji u~'il L V:uLLa::'Ji 1lL a"\.\u LL U::"'l eJ.:J

fl ru.::'Y11.:J1U"'J eJ.:J fl ru.::m1lJ n11""h lJLLa:: (i1"Ul1 1m.:J n11" Lctl ~1 L itu n11 (i 1l 'il fl i.i' 1l .:J n 1J '

~ 1i e1 t15 uii .:J1 u"'J e1"" ru.:: m1" lJ1lim1LL~,..r 11"11" LLCI:: (it! u. a11 i1 m1lJ tl•:: fi" .1 ~":: ~1Litum1"hmm1'i11lJLL~"~ri1'VIU<tlH ~nnVleJ.:Jt~~fl ct W"il11m1LLa1LV:wi1 fiul.J.a11 ...... 1<iliiuri' Un11L iLeJn ~YJ~fi"il::~1 Lit Un11 1m.:Jn11l vlVl1W a.:JJ 1L'lf!l::u1mlJ el1U1"il eJliUL'il u

' "'J eJ.:J '11ULLa::1imTu 11 m::u1u nTlu1nJ:tTvn1 EJ ~l.:J'V\UlL<il~'"i;j''~~lla'l m::rrn "~ t1.:J.:Jl'"

' ~vdvA~d ...... ,d vv"'i;'l ,.,J • l'lllJ'V\,..:J(ieJ Yl WU o'o>oolciG>'o>o fi.:JlUYl 1!1>1 VlalfllJ l!:Jclcfoc' LL"il.:Jm1n11'1El.:Jfl'I\Yl G> ll

' 'II 'II

m::Yl11.:JVia.:J.:J1"\.\ L~W"il11nl.lLLi.hl1VIlb U.:J1UriL ~ U'l'Ji El.:Jrl1J 1m.:Jn11L vlVll~ t1.:JJ1

Page 25: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

" "" ~ • ~ d " ~ ~ .':1 .. d d "' "' L 'li!J:: 1J 1" L <11 <111 L 'U. \1. n I 1" 'illlJ L ~ El 'U. L 'lJ lJ 'il 'lJ El ·HHln l"t El ~ fl <11 'Yl r1. LL fl:: 'Yl 'I!:J fl "ill !11 'U. LL fl1 . ~ .. ti B ( li)) !itltl. a11 't~flu!lum"l Ht Bn ~'Ylf~'il::ih Lii. u 1m~ nT'i1 v-lVlTvnl',ntl 't'l!ua(~ 'illlJ !h\1.1 'il B~tl't<il !J'll El~ 'il\1. LLfl:: fl UUWh m::m U n11"mmnvn 1 mh ~ l'\ U I '1. rufu !f<?l LL~1

' .J Ll ""'...,: "" ... ..dg,..o.J fl1lJ'Yln"i"!:'Yl1"1.:J'Yl"i"'l'l !J1 n"l'll'"l"i"lJ'l!l 'il LLfl:: !f.:J LL1<11 fl EllJ LL'il.:JlJ1 LlJ El1'\l. 'Yl 'I!:J \> 'il fl1 fllJ 'I!:J r1. rt.c£

' (l!:J) ff1ll'n-:~1mi' um,.~~ ~<11 't~ 'il"i"Wrlnmnua:: 1 imllJL v;wi1.:J ity ty1'if B'ln u't v-lvh

1m.:~m1"'1. v-lVl1w a.:J'\i'. L'l!u::u1LLtt1 ("') ~n nVl B.:Jfl~~ li) LLa::a1un.:J1u u1 um u LLa:: ' " ..

ur.~u wa.:J.:J1U 't~ ~1 L il um"i"Lr.~ u LL wH BlJ a 1m.:~ n11"L v-lVl1wa.:~J1 L'li u::u11 UL 1 u L'li~ .. ' 1 A .... t .J 0 a..o .. I Ll 0 cv "-"' d cv 'I 'io'A ..r

LLil:: \1. 1":: U U L fl 1" B-v 1 !J !f1 1" !f'U.L 'Yll'l 'Yl !fl \1. n .:JI U 1J f1 <11 !flU n 'U.l !J n "j"';j lJ U <11 1" 'il <11 L l'\ lJ 'lJ \1. ~

mlJ 1:: dj u u a1 ,r n u 1 u n i';j lJ u'i\1 11 ~ 1 u m"li'u v.l.:J fl11lJ ~ <11 L v; u 'lJ B.:J tl 1"::'1!1 'l! '14 ~

'1'1.1'1. I!Jr1.c£<t Lut1 ~.:Jli~nnVlB.:Jfl~~ lil ~1LU'U.n11fi.:JU1lJirunn'ifB'lli!JLv-lVl1 'U '\1 ... ...

1m.:Jn11"L v-lVl1wa.:~J1 L'liu::u1'ii B 'ttl oi1.:~ ~nnVl B.:Jfl~~ li) LLa::~w<n~m1m.Jm"l u1,;''Yl 'I 'IJ 'll 'IJ

L'l!u::u1 '1'111 L 1 Bf -;'hn<fl Ma.:~m lJ iru ru1.Jf B'll1 u't v-JVl11m.:~ m1'l v-lVl1wa.JJ1 L'l!u ::u1 \ ..... .... \

d .. ~ .. .1.1 d ~ d 'Y1 um n u .:J 'il u 'Yl,. "u u . a11 L lJ B1 u 'Y1 1!:1 .1 'il a1 fllJ 1!:1 r1. r1. c£

' fl ~ i:i tl 1:: L~U~ B.:Jl U'il uu11 ~n n Vl B.:lfl ~ J.:~ ~~a:: La u ~ B v. 1!1 ~

""' 'illlJ~ n!Jv.m !Jfhv. u<11l~ ~ B.:Jtl5uG1mmm1'i11 Lit umiity 'll'-lfB'll1 u 'l v-lvh L ~ <m 'l 'll!J:::l! 1 v.1BL3J

LL v\.:111'1! Ell nni n"i"L 'Y1 !J 'I'I'Yl'll'~n"i"l'l! l!J r1.r1.o U ru ruGi-J1 U flfl fl rJ EllJ ij ~'Yl ~L~fu,) EllJ il \ .... .... 'I 'll

0 ..r I I "-"VA A ~ m'l! LL 'il.:J LLa:: L v. 'il r.l a 'illnl'l u 1 u 11'l!n11 v. u1 !J.J1 U'll El.:J"i";i 1;i1 "' v. n 'il v.,. El11 'l!n11 ' ~ ~

~1u '11 B.J~ '14 ri BUn11BUrul (j]v.1am"l'i11L itu hmm1v.'1an'ilm"llJ 1(j]~ Bl'ili:i r.lam::'Ylu ' v

Iii El fl llifll '1'1 ~ .:J LL 1 <11 ~ EllJ !f'll Jl1 '1'1 El Ull.J !J fl ffifll Will 'il v.1 El ~1 'U. LiLii !J a1f1 ru 5 u1<11 q q 't ....

.d d q,.. o<'ll 'V ..,: dA A A ~ I I

'Y1L n !J 1 n U 'il 'U. V. 1" El 'l! lJ 'l! 'U. 'Y1 El.:J tl 'U. LL a:: lJ !f 'Y1 1l' LL !f <11 ~ fl11lJ fl (il LV. 'U. 'lJ El.J 'il 'U. 'il El V. 'U. 1 !J .:J 1 '\4 '

~ dl !J1,) El.:J L ~ EJ'I.h Ltl tl 1":: n El U n11Yl 'ill 1 ru.1lUL ~ El.:J i~ mh 1 lJI 'i\11 c£\J 111fl V. tt.:J

0 CV ~~ A Q..O A '1.1 I A V ~~

LLV\~'1'11::11'l!u ru ru 'il ".:JL!f"i"lJ LLfl::1mt1fl ru.mw !f.:J LL1<11 a BlJLL v..J'l!1'il w .1'1. 1!:1 rt.rn r1. u ruru m1 ...... q .......

L ~Btl1:: 1tJ'l!u1 um1~-:~w1lJLLa::fmt•flmmw~~ LL 1(ilaEllJ Mi';jlJ'\l.<il'11<11 !Jfl11lJ L v;u'l!Bu ' ~

'lJEl.:Jflffi:n11lJnl1~.:JU1(iliEllJUv\.:J~l~i:irll\l.l'ilU1:nl~lU1l~fi'il'illULUnHl '

rhv.u<?lti1::L11'Y1LLfl::'lJ'U.l<1l'll El.:J lfl"l.:Jnl"i"l'\'1 Bn'il n11'll El.:J~1\l. 11'l!n11 i'1ll !fll'\ n 'il VI 1 ElL El n~u ~

d,e~ ,.,:, OJ,; .::4 .... Ll 0 A 6" ~ V

'YllJ J;J fl n1 :'Yl U !f .:J LL 1 <11 a EllJ 'll.:J 'il El.:J'il <1l'Y1111 !J.:Jl'U. n11"1 L fl"i"l:: 'V\ J;J fl n 1:: 'YlU i.1' .:J LL 1 <11 fl EllJ

Page 26: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

- .

Lvl BLLmil"llflm111LV:u."lm1l~11:m'iln ~~ :m'ilrl ~>i LL<~::1l1'ilrl ~.~ Lrl a'li m fhr\11 ~-i'uw~'t'ili1 v .":1 .. .J, tl l:.J l:.J .d ~.J ~ ~nnY1fl..lfl'il'Yl I!! LU.nTi 1::'1f11fl'i..l'Yl ~~rlctm (fl'i..l'Yl Glmm) L11fl1U.'Yl mo llU.11fl11 l!!ct<fm ~~ , ~ Vd A, ~ "' 0 ~ .!' ~.,l."j t ~ d d V 0"j d d L'il1111'il L'l'lfl1111 L 'VI U.'lffl1J11.J L'fnlnl1'llfl'JJ1 !.l 11'11'11 fl'i..ln11 L'II!J::1J1'il111'Yl ~ n nl"'11-.l fl 'il'Yl m

.... "' " 'U \1

• ! , v v .":1 .. .J ~ .!' ~ •. 1.":1 t . .d ~ ' J.\1LL'fU.fl LL<I:: L'VI~nnY111-.lfl'il'Yl Cil iil..lU.111L'fnJnJ1'llfl'JJ1!.l Ll"'l"'1 'il!.ln1'1'1U.'ilL..l11U. L'JJ11

'V \1 ... "'

(G)) 1m..lm1L'IIu::u1't..l j:hu.m1Viv11rn1'JJ 11..1flrn::m1mnm1a11J11 'll..l (Mekong ' '

River Commission : MRC) 'il1l.lm::mu.m1'li a'ilniii.J'll a.Jti"J::L 'Yli'IL'f1l1in 1 u.a 11m.iJ1 t 'll..l ' v '

i1'il1!.ln11oW~U.1ft11U11'll..lati1-.lti..luU. (Agreement on the Cooperative for the , Sustainable Development of Mekong River Basin 5 April 1995) mh LL<I:: (1!!) 11-.l«qjty1

:} 11'!11 u't vlVI1Lm.Jm1l'llu::u1't..l ~hu.m1'il11vVi v11ru.1v1 n ~11! n..11u.Ei u m1a .:J a 'il ' ~ ' ::.r,.,., .":1 .,.J .J ~ " L .r, .4" .";1 ,..J

'Yl..lU. L'l'l mlnl"'11-.lfl'il'Yl m LLG'I::'Yl Gl Lu 'ilL~!.l'll a11 l'l m.Jm1WiHlL'flll11ru.'lfu. 'II.J~ n nl"'11-.lfl'il 'Yl ct \I'll 'U \I'll

1u.m1tl1::'lf11 Lrl 11-lu. ~ G) G) 11n11fl11 I!! ctct~ 't'il~11~h V:u.'lf111J LL<1::-i'um1u 'il111 11 ~'!I !l..l '

~ n n Y1 a..1 fl ~ ¥1 I!! <fl.J n a11 ~1 tt n;,1u.Ei !.l n11a ..1 L'f'il 't..l tt 1 ~ ..1 ~ l'l m1Viv11 rn 1 'il11 'ili1-.l 'U'U \I 'I

~ .r '1.,1.";1 t ~.,1.":1 ~ !' ~ d1V o ~ .";1 dd A ~ d L'fnJnJ1'llfl'lJ1[J LY1l"'1 fl1-.ln11 Ll"tl"'1'1'1fl..lU.1 L'll!.l::1J1 'VIbLn~nnl"'11-.lfl'il'Yl Cil L11111U.'Yl

"'"' , 'U'U

I!!~ iinm uu. l!!ctrl~ ~n nv:l fl..lfl~~ G) LLii1::~1un..11U. u. L!.l1J1 mLa::LL~u. 'I'IR..l-:nu.1 u.ti.:Jn'il ' '"'

'll il.:J ~n n Y111.:J fl ~~ m L'ii'L N !.IlL '1'1-hi il11 flLm.:J m1't vlY11 '1'1 i.:JJ1L'IIu::u1u m 1u't'll~ \1'\1 'U 'I

d "-" d ....., Vi v""' "-' ~ d www.eppo.go.th L11il1U.'Yl I!!~ nu.!.l1!JU. l!!rlrl~ LLa:: L'il11'1'\U..:JL'ffl 'Yl 'I'IU. o'oJocl.lrn>iGlOJ

........ d Q.; I( '"" ~ \1 I(

fl-:J1U.'Yl mo nU.!.l1!.lU. l!!ctrl~ 'll11fl1111flU.Lfl11::'VIL~!.lLL'1'11'll1111flUU.L11J L'll'il'li11.J ' ~

~1Um1u.tlti''il~1unmunf'ii11U.'il1L vl !!li m1~1L ii u.m1Li'l u.'ttlml.l11Gi'll 11-:J ~ n nVI11.:Jfl~ ¥1 ct ~ ~~

LLfl::Li'J U.n11LLi .:J'Ji 1111 flLLfl::L~ tilL '1'11'Ji 1111 a ti U1::'1f1'1fU. 'Yl11U'il1111::Lij !.lU~1U nu.1 unf'ii1JU.'il1 ~ ~ ~

i1'il1um1fuw.:Jm111fimV:u.'li11.:Jtl1::'1f1'lfu. v-~.1'1. l!!ct~>i ~nnVI11.:Jfl~.yl rn 't..lii'VIU.J~11 ~~

d "-"' .d V '&I n'I;'J .c1.d I V n":J d.d 'Yl l'IU. o'olooi~OJ'bo fl.J1U.'Yl I!!"" 'ilfl1fl11 l!!rl.t~ LLv..l~nnY111.Jfl'il'Yl OJ 11~nnY111-.lfl'il'Yl rn

'I \I'll \I'll

't'ii'Viv11rn 1 LL<hi1'1'1 '-' 1 u-:nu. ¥1 Li~ u1'li 11-Jnu 1m~ m1't 'l'lYI1'1'1 ti'..1J1't'll u ::u 11.1 ~1 L iht. m1 '

'il111L~au.L'li1J~'ll11~~nnY111-.lfl~~ <f. LLa::~ I!! mmhmL~1 ~~1i~nnY111-.lfl~~ OJ \I'll \I'll

'111L it u.m1a..1m11iruru1:l11'JJ1 u 'tvlVI1Lfl"l.:Jm1L 'l'lY11l'IR.JJ 1L'llu::u1 'ii 11'ttl ~ n nVI11.Jfl~ ~ OJ .... .... 'I \I \1

~ .:JL'il fl..lu.11Jirunn:l fl'lJ1!.l'tvlY111m"nTI 'twV11'1'1R.JJ11'llu::u1numB''Yl 't'!lu::u1 m1L1m -;hn 'il .... .... 'I 'I

L~il1u.'Y11!!o< 'ilfl1f11J l!!<t<t~ 'il1n"nmilv1l1~'fl..lnft1l~..l'V1'il1'lm1L.l'--.h m'lr1~nnv:la..lf1~.yj "" ' ~ ~ d d A1 V" .";1 .. .J d ~~ " • A ~ J:' '1.,1.";1

LLfl::'Yl ct 1111'il 'VI~nnY111.:Jf1'il'Yl OJ LLfl::'Yl m Lu'ilLN!.l'llfl11fln1'l'il1LUU.n1'lL'fnJnJ1'll11'JJ1tJ LY1Y11 'U '1.1 \I "' ...

.; '1 dA ~ .":1 .. .J .J '1 ~ • " • A ~ J: L 'lJ iJU. L'll U::U 1'11-:J j:.Jn nl"'11.:J fl'il 'Yl OJ LLfl::'Yl r;n L'il L~ tilL '1'11'JJ il11 fln11'il1LU U.n11L'fnJ nJ1'll il'JJ1 U

'I 'U'U 'U ........

Page 27: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

i. vlV111 ~ 8'11. L'll !.J ::u11J'IU iu L'lli www.eppo.go.th ua::mu 1ui.'l!.l'll8~ aTit"n.J1'U.U atj) '

a1 ,Zn'\.11 !.J nf~11'U.tj)1 fi 8 LYli1 i.iiim"'iL~ !.J II vd'Ji 811 anT'i~h I it 'U.n11HtUru14f8'lJ1 !.J L vlv:l1 ~ 'U fU'V

L ~ 8 '11. L'i! u ::u1tj)111111 "11 rl. ~ 1 ,.,. fiVI it, 'll 8.Jfu1111 '11. ru LL vi n1'11 81 m 1-;l m'l. rw " ... 'U "'

..... ... ... _"j .... .,J ,J A \L!i..... . .... .J ..... w 'Yllil'l nn"lf l!:l rl.rl.o mn ~ n nn 8-Jfltj) 'Yl l!:l ILa::'Yl rl. -;J~ IJJ tj) a: LOI !.Jtj) 8VI '11.1'Yl tj)111"'inTI11'11. ry

" ,.,. "' 'U

• ~ ~. .. • A ~ .f ~ •. L":1 d " .. ~ .":1 .. .J LLVI.Jn'llmnn~ m I'Yl!.J mmffi"'itj)1L'U. 'U.m"'i~tUtU1'i!B'IJ1!.J 1Ym11'1l 8'U.I'ii!J:1.11 Llfl::~ t1 nn tl.Jf\tj)'Y\ WI

.. ..., " 'U'U

.J .. i. 'i. 'V I .... .J A 'V ,.,"j d .J Q.oo

ua::'Yl m 'il.J 11 tj)OI::IOI£.Jtj)8VI'I1.1'Yltj)11111tj)'IJ8-J~nn.,8-Jfltj)'Yl rl. ua:::tj)111"'i~li"'i"'i11'11.tU 'U'U "' ,..,

LL vi.J11'1181 nn-;1 mi. 'Yl u mnlm1~1 L it"U.m1iru ru1~8'1J1 u i. vlV11 L ~8'11. L'i! u:::u'11 'll"U.n'\.1 ~ ~ '

'\.18 n'il1 nd n11~11 it '\.1 m"'iiru ru1418'1l1 !.J '1. vl V111 ~ 8'\.1 L'i! u:u1i.!-i1 'lllm;, nl"'iVI 18 n'il nl"'i ~ ~ '

.J"" OV o A s" .;. .... .d 'r1 tj) 8 .J 'il tj) 'r11 11 !.J .J 1 '\.1 n1 111 fl"'i1:: VI~ am:: 'r11J ~ .J IL 1 91 01 8 11 tj) 111111 tj)"'i1 <L''o> 111 fl VI '\.I ..:I .

I Q..; IVA I A CV A .... I A

IL VI .J Yl 1:::11 "lflJ ru tU tj) a' .J L ff"'i llLL<I :"'in '1!1-1 fl t\4111 Yl a' 'I Ll1 tj) 01 81111 VI '1'111 91 Yl.l'l. I!:J rl. m rl. ~ ~ '

'V n':l d .d 4 \llj I d .... ...I '1.1 IIV 0 Q .. ,d .... ~ t1 n n 8-J fl tj) 'r1 lil 'il.J 111lJVI '\.11 'Yl tj) 8 .J 'il tj)'Y\1 11 !.J '11 '\.1 n111 L f\11:: VI~ 01 n1::'r11J ~ .J U 1 tj) 01 8 lJ ~~

m nt m 1 <i'i1 Lit '11. m1 i ru ru1 <fi 8'1l1 u '1. vl V11 L ~ 81.1 L'i! £J:: u1 LL 01::: i.l-i'ti 01:: L;;, u <;i em l1: 1 ~ ~ ~ '

L1.1mnl~..:~n~11

a1 VI fum m'll 8 .J ~ t1 n V1 8 .J fl ~ ~ <L' Ltj) U m lJ'YlfYI !.J1 mJ1 l'\.1 ~1 '\.1:: ~ ~ ~

a1Um1'U.L<1'1l1'11.n11fl m::m"'ilJ1lim1ul.iJ1L 'll.J LL vi~'111Gll 'r1 !.J Lrl 8'Ji m Vlll'il1..:~fm~.J Lii1 '

n'ilJ'r1f'W Ul mJ1 L~<ii1 L it"U.n111 ~ !.J1 nu n11t11nH1VI11 8 ~1.JVIU1n"'i mm1<ii1 Lit '\.1

tm..:~ m1i. vlV11wa..:~J 1 L'i!£J::u1ttj) £]-;) tj)nYil i'li 81l 01 1m..:~m1l vlY1Tv>~a..:~J11'11£J::u1"{"~ li)

' ~ ' Lrl81'1.1~ l!:ll!:l lJn"'ilfllJ l!:lrl.tf<L' m rhnmi!u.J'Il8.J -;I..:~VIltj)liiu..:~11£.J ttj)uii~L'lhh1lfm'!J'..:~

~

, ..... "' 0 ..r .J ..... Q.oo d ~ .J .d ..... .J ..... 6'

m11V1 'll 811 <1'il1'\.11'11. """ "'~-~ -;nnw '11. 'r1 'il.JVI1 tj)l '11 !.l.J"'il!.l m .J'Yl l!:l llJ 81 '\.l'r1 li)o n lJ111W '\.Ill l!:l rl. rl.ct ~ '

m ehLnmiiu..:~m"U. -;I..:~VIltj)IOI!.J ttj)uii~L'li11l1lfuw..:~m11i'li8lJOI-;llm"U. li)I!:JOJI "'~-~ ~ ~

.¥.d.......... d ~.d ,d ...... .d ..... ,. 'il1n'WWYl'il.JVIltj)LOI!.J VI'IL8.Jf\1!.JIL<1::lJ.Jn1W f\"'i.J'r1 m LlJ8l'U.'r1 W!l!J nlJ111'W'U.li I!:Jtftf<i:'

' m !'hLnmi:i8.J'U.fl"'i'W'\.IlJ -;I..:~VIltj)'\.lf\"'iVl'U.lJ Ltj)£.Jii~L'li11llJf1lW·:In11 1i'li811<1-;l1'11.l'U. Oli!:Jrl. fl'\.1

~ ~

.f .J ~ ~ • A .. .I .I 'ill n YI'U.l'l 'il .JVI 1 tj)'\.lfl"'iVl '\.llJ 11 n tj)1VI11 81'\.11'il L 'il"'iru ua:: 81J <111'11li1'\.l LLt~::u;::'ll11 ff'lu 1-1 a

.. ... 'I 'I "

Lrl81'11.~ lil'-' nlJmW"U.lf l!:lrl.rl.<L' m m11'r1fwmmJ1 ~~8a1t11-!0I~LilllnLlYiJ..:~ "' ".f" ' '

~~11.1111 ttj)m:nrum-il£J.J1'\.I~Lrhn'li8..:~ 1Z'n1'llln11Ba"'i:: ~lJ1iim~~m LLa::m\1:: ~ '

• v 'Vo A A fi' A oa,.. ..... ...... I 0

~ 'lll 'U.llli nl"'i'W 'il1"'int111 U.Jl'U.nl"'ill fldl:::VI ~ an'l:::'YllJ ~ .,j LL ltj) <l <I lJtj)lUnTi'W <1ll Ul LL '\1\ <1 .J'\.11 ~ ~

L ~ fl L i'Ji fl fi m ~ '11. 'Ji fl L ff'\.1 flLL '11.:: L yj lJ L Gl lJ 'lllJ J .J IL 'U.l 'r11 .J n1 1 'ill Lit U.Jl 'U.fl {.J <;i fl LU

1tj)£.Jn"'ilJ'r11'W£Jln"'iJ1'tiiiVI,Z.J~fl ~ o'o>o\l/lildrl.l!J <l.Jl'\.1~ Oli!:J LlJ'I!l-l!.J'\.1 I!:Jtfrl.<i:'

Page 28: คำพิพากษาปกครองคดีเขื่อนไซยะบุรี ดำ ส.493/2555

ii~ ~1\t'm1ULfi'IJ1~nTH1 tu.::n113J1~n1'HU.hl11 'IJ~ L .yl tl LL ,)~ m1lJL ~U ~,~~1 n n11i ~ L 1fi

1..X'll tl3Jfl1rmm1t wvhv-n~·~.J1 t'llu::u1 5n-#., nwn1w !.l1n1lh '~~1L Uunw • .b-lltl:IJ fl " ' "

1m~m1lwvhw ;.,,r1 l'llu::u1L 'l'h~tY11uemru1~ 1iLli~Lj:.l u~1n1'~u1 fl 1n.hl.fl11 " " "" "'

tHlj:.l!JLLWihLllJl'll<i\'JJv~~m::m1lJ1~n11LLlJJ'11'll~ L~Ui1 ~rtnYlv~~~.yj ~ ""

1~ unmrrl'wu1m.J1 t~~1L Uum1il13J1i1m~~'ll'1~~13.11::Lu uutllju'1i L~tl~ n11LLi"

m1tl1n'l!i1~11mh~~'ll'1LLfl::"llvilnfl.,) (Procedure for Notification Prior Consultation

and Agreement: PNPCA) Lrlu1num1mm:t1~11mh~~'ll'1mrnm1~1L'itu1m~m1lWYl1 w&i'~.J1l'llu::u1LLti'11~utllt~fi::Lfl!.l~tJ~'It'1~1umtit~~mh1

'

Q.- £ I D

m u .,. 3J '1 "Ylll v v u m

~;;nm1i1~'1t'1~m::mm.Jnmv~nfl1~ '

1-nuin'1u 1"fi'f)fl'l~ ff A 1tl~tl~u~~1fltln~1tl~nfl1~

"'" """Q..o fi' u1mmnr]~ n~~10l.JU

~fl1n11~1fltlnmv~nfl1~ '

W"Wlf'll "'i13JVi;JJ%~0lJU::

~fl1n11~1fltln~1tl~nfl1~ '

~fl1nl1iTI'IU1~m:: '