View
344
Download
2
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Table of Contents 1. Introduction……………………………………………………………………….2
What is MUN?.......................................................................................................2 WarMUN…………………………………………………………………………………3
2. United Nations Committees…………………………………………………4 The General Assembly……………………………………………………………...4 United Nations Security Council………………………………………………..5 The Economic and Social Council………………………………………………6 The International Court of Justice……………………………………………...6 External Committees………………………………………………………………...7
3. Chairs, Delegates and the Secretariat……………………………………8
4. Country Research and Position Papers…………………………………9 How to approach Country Research…………………………………………..9 How to find UN resolutions………………………………………………………11 How to find country speeches…………………………………………………..11 Position Papers………………………………………………………………………..12
5. Rules of Procedure and MUN Jargon………………………………..…..13
6. Caucusing………………..............................................................................17
7. Conference Procedures and Flow of Debate…………………………19
8. Working Papers, Draft Resolutions and Amendments………….21
9. Resolution Writing……………………………………………………..............23 Structure of a Resolution………………………………………………………………23 General Tips…………………………………………………………………………………25 Sample Resolution………………………………………………………………………..26
10. Public Speaking and Debating………………………………………………29
What to Include in an opening speech……………………………………………………29 What to include in a speech during debate……………………………………………..30
11. Dress Code and Awards……………………………………………………….31
12. Surviving Your First MUN……………………………………………………32
13. References and Resources……………………………………………………33
14. Acknowledgments………………………………………………………………..34
-1-
1. Introduction
What is Model United Nations?
Model United Nations (MUN) is an academic simulation of the United Nations that aims to educate
participants about current affairs, pertinent topics in international relations, diplomacy and the
agenda of the United Nations and its member countries. For any particular MUN conference, a
participant is assigned a country and allocated a UN committee. Each committee usually has two
topics on its agenda for any conference and the participant acts as a delegate of his/her allotted
country and tries to forward its economic, political and social agenda and views on those issues.
This is done through debate and discussion with other delegates. It may sound easy, but it requires a
skillful application of diplomacy, tact, political force and charm to achieve a solution that is favoured
by all countries. The solutions take the form of resolutions drafted in accordance with the UN
format. At the end of a conference, each committee aims to pass at least two resolutions (one from
each topic). Although MUN may just appear to be recreational, it teaches participants the
importance of cooperation and compromise and renders them with crucial negotiation skills, which
are transferrable to real life. But remember, MUN isn’t just serious and academic.
Most university level conferences are known for their after parties and socials
and are a great opportunity to make new friends from all over the world!
How MUN Works at Warwick: Usually there are one
or two head delegates from the exec who apply for a
delegation place in a particular conference. They also
request certain committees or countries they would
like to represent. Once the Secretariat in-charge
organizing a particular conference gives them the
delegation size and country + committee allocations,
the conference is opened up to the whole society on a
first come first serve basis i.e. members can chose the
conference, committee and country they would like depending on availability. However, it is
ensured that every member gets the chance to participate in at least one conference every year.
-2-
WarMUN
WarMUN is the Warwick MUN Society’s
flagship conference that takes place annually,
around the first weekend of March. This year,
WarMUN will take place from 2nd-4th March
2012. The conference is different from others
around the UK because it is a Crisis MUN. Firstly, instead of having traditional UN committees with
different topics, WarMUN revolves around a single area of conflict between two or more countries
and consists of cabinets of countries and committees relevant to that issue. The cabinet for each
country is comprised of prominent political entities of that country. For example, last year’s
conference focused on the border dispute between Venezuela and Colombia and involved the
cabinets of these two countries and other stakeholders such as Brazil, Argentina, the South
American Defence Council, USA and the Security Council. In a Crisis MUN, delegates are faced with
rapid real life developments that revolve around the issue at hand. These developments are created
by the Crisis Room (a group of selected Warwick MUN Society members responsible for regulating
the crisis and giving it direction, with the aim of keeping delegates in their feet) and communicated
to the various cabinets and committees through a live blog and through Warwick TV news bulletins.
Confused by all the information and the process of how a Crisis MUN works? Don’t worry! WarMUN
will be discussed at length during our weekly meetings closer to the date and we will let you know
how you can contribute towards this conference. Just remember that the whole society will get a
chance to participate in WarMUN and contribute towards the conference by either being a
part of the Crisis team, the logistics team or Warwick TV.
-3-
2. United Nations Committees
The United Nations has a number of functioning committees with diverse roles and responsibilities.
In this guidebook, we will discuss the nature and role of the key UN committees delegates are likely
to encounter in MUN conferences at university level. Most conferences also include a few external
non-UN committees like ASEAN, IMF etc. If you would like to gain additional information on the
United Nations and its committees, please refer to the reading material and websites suggested at
the end of this guidebook.
The General Assembly: The General Assembly
(GA) is the main deliberative organ of the United
Nations composed of all UN member states, with
one vote each. Decisions on questions regarding
peace and security, admission of new members
and budgetary matters require a two third
majority while all other decisions require a simple majority. The exact functions of the General
Assembly are outlined in the UN Charter, however, the important thing for delegates to remember is
that the GA can only make ‘recommendations’ and none of its resolutions are binding or enforceable.
In other words, it does not have the power to take actions against States who do not comply with its
resolutions. An exception to this rule exists in a scenario where the Security Council fails to act due
to lack of unanimity where there appears to be a serious threat to international peace, breach of the
peace or act of aggression. The GA is also responsible for appointing the non-permanent members of
the Security Council, the members of the Economic and Social Council, to jointly elect with the
Security Council the judges of the International Court of Justice and on recommendation of the
Security Council, to appoint the Secretary General.
-4-
At the beginning of the first GA session each year (Tuesday, 3rd week of September), a debate is held
where Heads of State deliberate which international issues to include in its agenda. These are then
divided amongst its six committees for discussion:
Disarmament and International Security (First Committee)
Economic and Financial (Second Committee)
Social, Humanitarian and Cultural (Third Committee)
Special Political and Decolonization (Fourth Committee)
Administrative and Budgetary (Fifth Committee)
Legal (Sixth Committee)
The Security Council: The United Nations Security
Council (UNSC) has the primary responsibility of
maintaining international peace and security. It is
important to remember that the UNSC is the only UN
committee with the power to enforce its decision upon
Member States. While all other committees can only
make recommendations, the UNSC has the ability to undertake enforcement measures, including
economic sanctions, arms embargoes, financial sanctions, travel bans or collective military action.
The Council has fifteen members: five permanent-China, France, the Russian Federation, the United
Kingdom and the United States of America-and ten non permanent members elected by the GA for a
period of two years. Decisions on procedural matters (structure of meeting, order of debate etc.) are
made by an affirmative vote of 9 out of 15 whereas decisions on substantive matters are made by an
affirmative vote of 9 out of 15, without any negative vote of any of the five permanent members (P5).
Each of the P5 possesses a Veto power, which means that if either of them votes against a resolution,
it cannot be passed. However, if any member of the P5 abstains from voting and the resolution gains
the required majority, it can be put in force.
-5-
Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC): ECOSOC is the principle organ that coordinates the
economic, social and related work of the United Nations and its specialized agencies and institutions.
Through its discussion of international economic and social issues, ECOSOC plays a key role in
fostering international cooperation for development and in setting the priorities for action. The
council has a number of subsidiary bodies including: 8 functional commissions who make
recommendations regarding issues in their field of expertise (Statistical, Population and
Development, Social Development, Status of Women, Narcotic Drugs, Crime Prevention and Criminal
Justice, Science and Technology for Development and Sustainable Development) and5 regional
committees (Africa, Asia and the Pacific, Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean, Western Asia).
Voting procedures follow a simple majority and resolutions have the authority to make
recommendations only.
International Court of Justice (ICJ): The ICJ is the principal judicial organ of the United Nations
and is located at The Hague, in the Netherlands. Its function is to settle legal dispute between states
and it also gives advisory opinion on legal matters to United Nations and its specialized agencies.
Only states may be parties in contentious cases before the Court and submit disputes to it. The GA
and the UNSC can ask the court for advisory opinion regarding any legal questions. Other UN organs
may do the same if permitted by the GA, within the scope and jurisdiction of their activities. The
Court is composed of 15 judges elected by the GA and the UNSC, voting independently. They are
chosen on the basis of their qualifications and care is taken to ensure that the principal legal systems
of the world are represented in the Court. Each judge serves a nine-year term and may be re-elected.
Furthermore, no two judges may be from the same country.
In MUN conferences, ICJ is considered to be a specialized committee, which entails that it is not
suitable for first time participants. In order to participate in the ICJ sessions, it is important that
delegates are familiar with its procedures, rulings, history and have knowledge about international
laws, treaties etc.
-6-
External Committees: External Committees are international organizations and coalitions, which
delegates may encounter in an MUN conference. Some of these bodies are affiliated with the United
Nations while others are regional military or economic coalitions. Given below is a list of external
committees that may be encountered during a conference. For more information on each committee,
please refer to the reading material. But if you want a brief general overview, Wikipedia does the
trick.
ASEAN (Association of South East Asian Nations)
The Arab League
The European Union
NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization)
IMF (The International Monetary Fund)
WTO (World Trade Organization)
UNDP (United Nations Development Programme)
UNHRC (United Nations Human Rights Comission)
UNEP (United Nations Environmental Programme)
WHO (World Health Organization)
Historical Security Council (This committee simulates historical decisions and conferences
conducted by the UNSC, especially those that occurred during WWII. Strong historical background
knowledge required).
At times, conference organizers get innovative and create new committees. For example, Cambridge
MUN CUIMUN 2011 has a Facebook Executive committees where delegates will simulate the
facebook board of directors (Mark Zucherberg et al) and address issues regarding online security,
business threat from google + and so on.
-7-
3. Chairs, Delegates and the Secretariat
-8-
Secretariat
The Secretariat is the highest level of UN staff and is its administrative branch. It consists of the Secretary General, Under Secretary General, Chief of Staff etc. In an MUN conference, the Secretariat is responsible for organizing all the logistical, technical and thematic aspects of the conference, including the committees that will be involved, number of delegates per committee, the overall theme of the conference etc.
Chairs
and Co-
Chairs
The chair is the person who presides over a committee and executes debate according to the rules and regulations of that specific committee as well as the MUN conference the committee is a part of. Usually, there is a chair and a co-chair in every committee. The co-chair is like an assistant to the chair and lower in hierarchy. There may be more than one co-chair. Chairs usually set the agenda for their committees and are in charge of writing study guides to help delegates. Chairs and Co-Chairs are in charge of resolvingpersonal issues and those regarding rules as well. They also decide the delegate awards.
Presiden
ts and Director
s
Certain conferences have Presidents or Directors in their committees instead of chairs, although they have the same responsibilities. However, in a committee with two or more presidents or directors, they are referred to as co-presidents or co-directors. Unlike co-chairs however, they all belong to the same hierarchy. So essentially, its like having more than one chair.
Delegate
A delegate represents a particular country in a committee.
4. Country Research and Position Papers
Country Research
One of the most important aspects of a Model United Nations conference is country research. The
socializing aspect of MUN will come to most of us naturally (everyone knows how to party) but in
order to have a fruitful committee session, its important to have adequate background information
on the country you will represent, the issues you will discuss and the administrative powers and
jurisdiction of the committee you have been assigned to.
How to approach country research: It is important that you approach country research in an
organized and systematic manner to ensure that you have covered all aspects. The following
template may prove helpful:
1. Country -Begin by reading up general facts about your country on the CIA World Factbook
website ( https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/ ). Make sure you
are aware of the political and governance structure of your country, key political leaders,
military powers etc. Next, briefly read up about any major conflicts or international issues
that your country has been involved in. Check out news media sources for any recent
developments. Thirdly, interpret what the major strengths of your country are, i.e. what
power do you have over other nations (example: OPEC countries control a majority of the
world’s oil supply, USA/India/China/France/UK/Israel etc. are nuclear powers and so on).
Also ensure that you know any significant weaknesses (for example, energy dependency on a
single country or a small group of countries). Lastly, make a list of all your countries allies.
This will be extremely helpful when you are trying to find sponsors and signatories for your
resolution.
-9-
2. Topic - After you have completed background research on your country, move on to
researching the topic/s you will be discussing in a particular conference. While researching,
keep in mind the following questions: What is the issue and how does it affect your country?
What has your country done to combat the problem? What are the various “sides” of the
debate and who are the key players? If your country is not directly involved, how can it
shape the debate at the conference and be involved? What arguments will other countries
make and how can your country support or counter those arguments? In order to gain in
depth knowledge, don’t just rely on Wikepedia. Visit the websites of the UN, Governmental
Organizations and NGOs involved with the topics and try and access reports that they may
have published. Try and memorize some key statistics relevant to the topic, you will sound
all the more impressive and knowledgeable. You can also access previous UN resolutions on
the issues and speeches that delegates of your country may have made on the topic.
3. The UN System and your Committee: Make sure you have adequate knowledge about how
the UN works and the particular powers and jurisdiction of the committee you are more
involved with. Nothing will be more embarrassing than say producing an ECOSOC resolution
that calls for sanctions on a country for neglecting its cultural heritage. In short, KNOW
YOUR POWERS AND POSITION.
-10-
How to access UN Resolutions: Go to UNBISnet at unbisnet.un.org. Under the heading "Bibliographic
Records," click on "New Keyword Search." You are presented with four optional search fields:
Enter a topic or keyword next to "Subject (All)."
If you want to refine your search to one specific body, such as the Security Council, select
"UN Doc. Symbol / Sales No." in the second drop-down menu, and enter the appropriate
resolution code. (For instance, all Security Council resolutions begin with S/RES; all General
Assembly resolutions begin with A/RES; all ECOSOC resolutions begin with E/Year where
year is the year in which the resolution passed. Or leave it blank to search all committees on
the topic).
To limit the search results by date, scroll down to the "User Defined Limits" and select "Year
of Publication," the appropriate delimiter, and enter the year of the resolution.
All the resolutions passed by the UN on that subject will appear in a list.
How to find speeches: Go to UNBISnet at unbisnet.un.org. Under the heading "Index to Speeches,"
click on "New Keyword Search." You are presented with four optional search fields:
Enter the country's name next to the drop-down reading "Country/Organization." If you
would like to limit the topic, enter a keyword next to the drop-down reading "Topic."
To limit the UN body in which the speech was given, enter the appropriate code next to the
drop-down reading "Meeting Record Symbol." Enter A for the General Assembly, S for the
Security Council, E for ECOSOC or T for the Trusteeship Council.
All speeches given by your country on this topic will be listed. Click on the link to display the
full text of the speech if it is available.
Other useful information, links and research suggestions can be found on the United Nations
Association of the United States of America website (http://www.unausa.org/munpreparation ).
-11-
Position Papers:
A Position Paper is a short essay
(one to one-and-half pages long)
detailing your country’s policies on
the topics being discussed in your
committee. Writing a position paper
will help you organize your ideas so
that you can share your country’s
position with the rest of the
committee. Some conferences may
require you to write a position paper
but even if it isn’t a requirement, you
should consider writing one since a strong position paper will help you focus your arguments and
also make a good opening speech as well as a working paper (see section 8).
Your position paper should include a brief introduction followed by a comprehensive breakdown of
your country's position on the topics that are being discussed by the committee. A good position
paper will not only provide facts but also make proposals for resolutions. To communicate strongly
and effectively, avoid flowery wording and stick to uncomplicated language and sentence structure.
Give each separate idea or proposal its own paragraph. Make sure each paragraph starts with a topic
sentence. Try not to let your proposals become lost in a sea of information. For speechmaking,
create a bulleted list of your proposals along with your most important facts and statistics so that
they’re accessible during debate. Certain MUN conferences like LIMUN require that you submit
a position paper. Chairs will then take your position paper into consideration (and often
grade them), along with your performance at the conference to decide awards.
-12-
5. Rules of Procedure and MUN Jargon
The rules of procedure may vary across MUN conferences; however, there are a few universal and
common points and motions that a delegate must be familiar with.
Motions: Think of motions as an action word. A motion is usually raised to take some kind of
action and in order to decide whether that action will be taken or not, the motion is put to vote.
There are different types of motions, but the basic ones are referred to and explained in the table
below. Remember, all motions must be seconded by another delegate to be passed. Voting only takes
place when a delegate raises an objection. However, in certain conferences geared towards fresher’s
voting takes place for every motion to familiarize new delegates with voting procedures.
MOTION VOTING PROCEDURE
Motion to Open Debate Simple Majority
Motion to move into Moderated Caucus: This is a way of
focusing the debate to specific issues regarding the topic
at hand (explained in detail in the section ‘Caucusing’).
Simple Majority
Motion to move into Un-moderated Caucus: This is a
chance to communicate your ideas and consolidate your
views with other delegates in a more informal manner
(explained in detail in the section ‘Caucusing’).
Un-Moderated Caucuses can only be
introduced after the first 30 minutes
of debate. Simple Majority, although
chair can deny this motion at his/her
discretion.
Motion to Extend Debate/Caucus: This motion can be
used to either extend debate on a particular topic OR to
extend the time for a moderated/un-moderated caucus.
The motion can only be used once per topic/caucus.
Simple Majority. Although it can be
denied at the chairs discretion
(especially in un-moderated caucus).
Extension time cannot be longer than
original caucus time.
-13-
Motion to Introduce Resolution: Once a resolution has been
finalized in an un-moderated caucus, it must be given to the
chair for approval. Once approved, delegates must bring up
a motion to introduce the resolution. Usually, the chair will
indicate the order in which resolutions will be debated and
inform delegates, so that they can motion for their
resolution accordingly. NOTE: You cannot discuss a
resolution or its contents until it has been formally
introduced as a draft resolution.
Simple Majority
Motion to Introduce Amendments: Resolutions are open to
amendments while being debate. If a delegate has an
amendment, he/she must submit it in written form to the
chair. Once submitted, the delegate may raise a motion to
introduce that amendment.
Two-Thirds Majority. Two speakers
speak for and two speak against the
amendment before it is put to vote.
Motion to Adjourn the debate: In the UN, adjourning the
debate ends the committee session until the following year.
In conferences, this is simply a break for lunch/coffee. You
won’t usually need to use this motion unless you want to be
let off earlier than scheduled. Chairs usually adjourn the
debate for pre-allocated lunch and coffee breaks.
Simple Majority
Motion to Close debate and move into Voting Procedures:
Caucusing and note passing is not allowed once this motion
has been passed.
To end debate on a topic and vote on
related resolutions. Simple Majority.
Motion to table the debate: A way of ending debate on a
particular topic without passing a resolution and moving on
to the next one, usually when the debate is getting
redundant. Try and refrain from using this motion unless
absolutely necessary.
Two-thirds Majority. Two speakers
speak for and two speak against the
motion before voting takes place.
How to Introduce a Motion: After every speaker is done speaking, the chair will ask if there are any points
or motions on the floor, before resuming with the speakers’ list. At this point, say “The delegate of (country
name)/(country name) would like to raise a motion to…(state your motion).”
-14-
Advanced Motions Used During Voting Procedures:
Divide the Question- This motion calls for certain operative clauses to be voted on separately from
the resolution. The delegate proposing this motion must name the clause to be questioned. The chair
calls speakers (2For, 2Against). The body then votes whether the clause should be divided (Voting-
Simple Majority). If this passes, then the body votes whether this clause should be included in the
final resolution (Voting-Simple Majority). Thus, 2 votes actually take place: the first is procedural,
the second is substantive.
Roll Call Vote- Each country is called out loud. Delegate answers yes, no, or abstain. Roll call vote is
granted at the discretion of the chair (Voting-none).
Right to Explain Vote- Delegate can explain vote on a specific resolution–used to clarify a vote
against normal policy. You can either request to explain an unusual affirmative vote (yes with rights)
or against vote (no with rights). Requests must be submitted in writing to the chair prior to voting
procedures. Accepted at the discretion of the chair.
Question the Competence-This motion is used when resolutions are not within the scope of the
committee or authorizes things the committee cannot authorize (Voting-Simple Majority).
Points: Think of points as questions addressed either to the chair or to another delegate. Points
aren’t usually put to vote and are accepted at the chair’s discretion.
Point of Information: This is basically a question addressed to a delegate. After a delegate
has finished his/her speeches and has time remaining, he/she may yield to ‘points of
information’, allowing other delegates to ask questions. Once the floor is open to points of
information, the chair asks delegates to raise their placards if they have a question and picks
a few at his/her own discretion. If a delegate wishes to only answer questions regarding
his/her speech, he/she must yield the floor to ‘points of information pertaining to the
speech’. Certain conferences don’t entertain points of information. Please check appropriate
rules. Each delegate has a maximum speaking time per speech and points of information are
only allowed if the speech is shorter than the allocated time frame. Remember, there are no
points of information during a moderated caucus.
Point of Personal Privilege: This can be raised if for instance a delegate cannot hear what
another delegate is saying, the room is too hot etc. It is okay to interrupt another delegate’s
speech if there are audibility issues. However, for personal enquiries like whether you may
use the toilet or the room is too hot, it is better to pass a note to the chair.
Point of Parliamentary Enquiry: This is to ask the chair to explain a procedure if you are
ever confused.
-15-
Point of Order: This point is raised if the chair appears to have made a procedural error or if
a delegate said something that is offensive towards your country. This point is not allowed to
interrupt speeches. Additionally, delegates should avoid correcting the chair unless the chair
has made a significant error, which could affect the final outcome of the debate. If you do
think the chair has made a mistake, you may want to make a Point of Parliamentary Inquiry
and phrase your doubts or obligations in the form of a question. In this case, the chair will
correct you and say that you should’ve used a Point of Order, but at least you will be less
offensive and not challenge the chair’s authority in an outright manner.
Right to Reply: Special request when a country’s sovereignty has been slandered–not for by
another delegate. To obtain permission, a note should be sent to the chair. You may also
request a formal apology from that delegate.
How to Introduce a Point: After every speaker is done speaking, the chair will ask if there are any
points or motions on the floor, before resuming with the speakers’ list. At this point, say “The
delegate of (country name)/(country name) would like to raise a point…(state your point).”
Other things to consider:
Third Person: Remember, when speaking in an MUN conference, you cannot refer to yourself
as ‘I’. You are representing a country so always say ‘The Delegate of (Country Name)’. You
may also refer to yourself as the country.
Note Passing: During a conference, you will be given notepaper. Use this to pass notes to
other delegates to garner support for your ideas etc.
Never direct address a delegate during debate. Address him/her through the chair.
Yielding: After you have finished a speech as part of the speaker’s list or as part of
introducing a resolution, you may do one of three things:
a) Yield the floor to the chair (so that the chair can continue with speakers’ list/debate)
b) Yield the floor to another delegate (usually an ally or co-submitter of a resolution to
consolidate the points your speech has made)
c) Yield the floor to Points of Information.
-16-
6. Caucusing
Caucusing, or informal debate, is an integral part of MUN conferences as it gives delegates the
opportunity to collaborate, negotiate and formulate draft resolutions. There are two types of
caucuses, Moderated Caucus and Un-moderated Caucus.
Moderated Caucus: Moderated Caucus is when delegates
discuss a specific issue regarding the topic being
discussed for a fixed amount of time. The procedure to
move into moderated caucus is as follows:
Raise your placard and once you have been recognized
by the chair, say: “The delegate of (name) would like to propose a moderated caucus of ‘x’
minutes, speaker time ‘y’ minutes/seconds on the issue of ‘xyz’.”
Example: If the topic for your committee is human trafficking, one of the moderated caucuses
that you could propose could be “the security issues concerning cross border human trafficking”.
It is best to keep the moderated caucus time between 10-15 minutes. Speaker time usually
ranges from 30 seconds to 1.5 minutes.
Once you propose the moderated caucus, someone has to second it. If there are no objections,
then the moderated caucus will be in order. If there is an objection, the chair will ask one person
(usually the person who suggested it) to speak for the motion and one person to speak against
the motion. Then the motion will be put to vote.
If the motion to move into moderated caucus passes, then the person who suggested it speaks
first. The other speakers are picked by raising placards.
-17-
Un-moderated Caucus: This is the time when you can talk to your fellow delegates more
informally, get to know them better and start forming alliances and draft resolutions. A lot of
committee time is spent in un-moderated caucus. The best time to introduce this motion would be
when the speakers’ list and the debate is getting repetitive and unconstructive. The procedure to
introduce an un-moderated caucus is the same as moderated caucus except the total time is usually
longer, there is no speakers time and the issue is usually to start working on draft resolutions (once
the debate has gone on for at least an hour or so) OR to discuss any issue that a moderated caucus
would address in a more informal manner, so as to form alliances.
Most delegates prefer to speak during caucuses. It is also a good idea to try and move into a
moderated caucus if your country is far down on the speakers list and you wish to speak sooner. For
new delegates, it is less daunting to speak during a moderated caucus because its for a shorter time
and its not necessary to go on a podium to speak, you can say what you want from where you are
sitting (although you do have to stand up), without being watched by the entire committee.
As for the un-moderated caucus, think of it as a party where you don’t know anybody and need to
make new friends. Just like in a party you would look for a friendly face, in an un-moderated caucus
look for countries that are known to be your allies. Make an effort to talk to delegates about your
views on the topic and your key ideas for the resolution. It is also important to listen to what others
have to say. A good delegate will be able to assert himself/herself without neglecting the ideas of
others and would be able to create a holistic resolution that incorporates diverse perspectives (of
course that does not mean that if you are the USA and writing a resolution on Disarmament, you
incorporate North Korea’s ideas, no matter how hot the delegate of North Korea might be).
Remember, it is important to be flexible without compromising your country’s views on the
topic.
-18-
7. Conference Procedures and Flow of Debate
The order is which events proceed during an MUN conference is known as ‘flow of debate’. The chart
below shows the various stages of a MUN conference, outlining and explaining the key procedures.
-19-
1. Roll Call: Chairs call out
countries in alphabetical
order
Either: "Present and Voting" (no
abstentions allowed)
Or: "Present" (your country may abstain
from voting for or against a resolution)
3. Debate: The style of
debate alternates
between formal and informal.
Formal Debate:a. The chair opens the speakers list and asks delegates who would like to address the committee to raise their placards. The chair then choses delegates to be on the list and begins the session with the first speaker. The opening speeches of delegates are a chance to state country positions and recommend action.b. During the speakers list, delegates may call for moderated or unmoderated caucus to discuss bloc positions, form alliances and create draft resolutions.c. Delegates may then continue with the speakers list OR present their draft resolutions.d. Delegates garner more support for their resolutions through formal speeches.e. Other delegates may make statements for or against a resolution.f. Throughout this process, delegates send formal amendment sheets to the chairs. They may then raise their placard and request to present their amendments to the house.
Informal Debate:a. Informal debate consists of discussions outside the speakers list in the form of moderated or unmoderated caucus.During moderated caucus, the chair may call delegates one by one to address the house in short speeches on the topic of the caucus.Sfter several countires have stated their views, delgates may call for an unmoderated caucus to form alliances and resolutions.At this stage, delegates hsould try and incorporate friendly amendments into their resolutions and try and get as many signatories as possible.
2.Setting the Agenda: usually a committee has two or more topics to discuss. After role call, a delegate must make a motion setting the agenda-essentially deciding the order in which topics will be discussed. Then according to the chairs discretion, some delegates speak for the proposal and some against before voting on it.
4. Close of Debate: There are two ways to close the debate and move
towards voting.
Speakers' List: Once the speakers' list is exhausted, the committee will automatically move towards voting procedures.
Motion: If a delegate feels that there are enough resoultions on the floor and adequate debate has ensued, he/she may call for a motion to move to voting procedures. There must be a second to this motion. If there is an objection, the chair will call for a vote to detrmine whether the motion passes or not.
5. Voting Procedures: Delegates vote for or against a particular resolution according to voting
procedures of their committee. Then the committee moves on to the next
topic.
-20-
8. Working Papers, Draft Resolutions and
Amendments
Working Papers: A working paper is essentially a list of the key ideas and solutions presented
by one or more delegates, regarding an issue, in the format of Operative Clauses (explained in the
next section). Remember, it is usually possible to transform position papers into working papers
and hence it is advisable to write position papers before attending a conference. The author(s) of a
working paper must obtain a required 10% of signatures within a specific committee (the chair will
notify delegates of the exact number) before sending it in for approval. Once this has been achieved,
the delegates must submit the working papers to the chairs/directors/presidents for their
respective committees for approval. Approval is usually based on a) correct format, b) correct
number of signatures and c) subject matter that proposes actions within the scope of the committee.
Approved working papers are copied and distributed to the entire committee. Once approved,
delegates may refer to working papers and the ideas they contain during their speeches.
Draft Resolutions: Usually, during un-moderated caucus, two or more working papers are
combined and re-written in the UN resolution format, including both perambulatory and operative
clauses (explained in the next section). Once the working papers have been combined and re-typed
in the correct format, signatures representing 20% of the committee need to be obtained, after
which the document can be send to chairs/directors/presidents for approval. The approval
requirements are similar to that of a working paper and once approved, the document is referred to
as a Draft Resolution. These are then copied, assigned a priority number (which determines the
order of debate) and circulated to the committee. Delegates may only refer to draft resolutions in
their speeches once they have been approved.
-21-
Amendments: The amendment process is used to strengthen consensus on a draft
resolution by allowing delegates to change certain sections of the draft resolution, as its
debated. There are two types of amendments: friendly and unfriendly.
Friendly amendment. A friendly amendment is a change to the resolution that all sponsors feel is appropriate.
The amendment must be signed by all of the sponsors, and approved by the Director. After this, the
amendment is automatically incorporated into the resolution. Friendly amendments can also be made
informally amongst delegates during un-moderated caucus, before submission of the draft resolution for
approval.
Unfriendly amendment. An unfriendly amendment is an amendment that the sponsors of the resolution do
not support. In this case, the author/s of the proposed amendment must obtain the same number of
signatures, as they would need for a working paper. After the appropriate number of signatures has been
obtained, the Director must approve the amendment. Unfriendly amendments are voted on in order of
severity (established at the discretion of the Chair).
Once the debate is closed and the body moves into formal voting procedure for a draft resolution, the draft
resolution(s) and unfriendly amendments, if any, are voted upon in the order determined by the Chair.
Note: Amendment sheets will usually be provided to delegates to formally request
amendments.
Once all amendments have been incorporated and the draft resolution passes, it is then
referred to as a resolution.
-22-
9. Resolution Writing
The final result of discussions, debates and caucuses during an MUN conference is a resolution.
During un-moderated caucus, delegates should gather their allies and begin work on a draft
resolution (refers to a resolution that hasn’t yet been debated). A draft resolution must have a
certain number of sponsors (the delegates who directly contribute towards its creation and agree
with its content) and a certain number of signatories (delegates who don’t necessarily agree with all
of its content but would like to see it debated to propose amendments). The required number of
sponsors and signatories varies from conference to conference. There are three parts to any
resolution: the heading, the preamble and the operative section. Each draft resolution is one long
sentence with sections separated by commas and semicolons. The subject of the sentence is the
body making the statement (e.g., the General Assembly, Economic and Social Council, or Security
Council). The preamble and operative sections then describe the current situation and actions that
the committee will take.
Structure
Heading: The heading shows the committee and topic along with the resolution number. It also lists
the draft resolution’s sponsors (main submitter, co submitter) and signatories.
Preambulatory Clauses: The preamble of a draft resolution states the reasons for which the
committee is addressing the topic and highlights past international action on the issue. Each clause
begins with a present participle (called a preambulatory phrase) and ends with a comma.
Preambulatory clauses can include:
References to the UN Charter; Citations of past UN resolutions or treaties on the topic under discussion; Mentions of statements made by the Secretary-General or a relevant UN body or agency; Recognition of the efforts of regional or nongovernmental organizations General statements on the topic, its significance and its impact.
-23-
List of Preambulatory Phrases:
AffirmingAlarmed byApprovingAware ofBearing in mindBelievingConfidentContemplatingConvincedDeclaringDeeply concernedDeeply consciousDeeply convincedDeeply disturbedDeeply regrettingDesiringEmphasizing
ExpectingExpressing its appreciationExpressing its satisfactionFulfillingFully alarmedFully awareFully believingFurther deploringFurther recallingGuided byHaving adoptedHaving consideredHaving considered furtherHaving devoted attentionHaving examinedHaving heardHaving received
Having studiedKeeping in mindNoting with regretNoting with deep concernNoting with satisfactionNoting furtherNoting with approvalObservingReaffirmingRealizingRecallingRecognizingReferringSeekingTaking into accountTaking into considerationTaking noteViewing with appreciationWelcoming
Operative Clauses: Operative clauses identify the actions or recommendations made in a
resolution. Each operative clause begins with a verb (called an operative phrase) and ends with a
semicolon. Operative clauses should be organized in a logical progression, with each containing a
single idea or proposal, and are always numbered. If a clause requires further explanation, bulleted
lists set off by letters or roman numerals can also be used. After the last operative clause, the
resolution ends in a period.
AcceptsAffirmsApprovesAuthorizesCallsCalls uponCondemnsConfirmsCongratulatesConsidersDeclares accordinglyDeplores
EncouragesEndorsesExpresses its appreciationExpresses its hopeFurther invitesDesignatesDraws the attentionEmphasizesEncouragesEndorsesEmphasizesStrongly Condemns
Further recommendsFurther requestsFurther resolvesHas resolvedNotesProclaimsReaffirmsRecommendsRegretsRemindsRequestsSolemnly affirms
-24-
General Tips for Resolution Writing:
Create a detailed resolution. For example, if you are creating a new programme or governing body,
think of how it will be funded, what its objectives will be, which UN body will it work under/with,
where will its jurisdiction extend till etc.
Try to cite facts as much as possible. But remember to include new ideas.
Make sure the action suggested by your resolution falls within the jurisdiction of your committee.
Use appropriate Operative Clauses. For instance, the GA can endorse, request or urge etc., but only
the Security Council can condemn or state clauses that imply binding action.
Try to find multiple sponsors. A resolution is more likely to pass if many delegates have contributed
towards it.
During un-moderated caucus, try and incorporate friendly amendments so that there are minimal
objections to your resolution.
At the end of the day, remember that although you want to have a holistic resolution, it is not
possible to please everyone. Don’t lose your stance in an effort to placate everyone. A resolution
with concrete suggestions, which may create dissent amongst the committee, is better than a meek
resolution with flimsy suggestions, even if it garners support.
On the next page, you will be able to find a sample resolution. Additional resources have also been
suggested at the end of the handbook.
-25-
Sample Resolution
Main Submitter: BoliviaCo-Submitter: AfghanistanSignatories: Brazil, India, South Africa, Germany, JapanCommission: General Assembly 5Agenda: The question of equitable representation on and increase in the membership of the United Nations Security Council
Acknowledging the importance of fair and equitable representation of UN member states in the UNSC in
promoting responsible decision making within the council,
Aware of the widespread global impact resolutions adopted by the United Nations Security Council are
capable of having,
Promoting the analysis of UNSC resolutions through a multi dimensional perspective before they are
adopted,
Denouncing the prevalence of the hegemony established in the post World War II era in a democratic
organization like the UN in modern times,
Approving of the efforts made by the Open Ended Working Group to create consensus amongst member
states in response to solutions for this issue since 1993,
Bearing in mind that the lack of equitable representation and power imbalance within the council has led
to distress amongst a majority of the UN member states,
Emphasizing the need for compromise and unwavering commitment from all member states in order to
achieve the goal of restructuring the Security Council,
Fully Aware that the current permanent members of the Security Council who also possess veto power
include the United States of America, the United Kingdom Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the
Republic of France, the People’s Republic of China and the Russian Federation,
Noting with approval certain propositions made by the G4 nations, the African Union and the former UN
Secretary General Kofi Anan in response to the call for the restructuring of the Security Council;
-26-
Proposes the expansion of the permanent membership of the Security Council from five member states to
ten member states in order to promote the goal of equitable representation in the following manner:
a) Inviting the G4 countries that include India, Germany, Japan and Brazil, to form a part of the
permanent membership of the council since they have displayed increasing initiative in addressing
issues of global conflict and have contributed greatly towards UN peacekeeping,
b) Adding one state from the Africa Union as a permanent member, determined by a election held under
the supervision of the Office of the United Nations Secretary General, in a regional delegation vote,
c) Altering the Geopolitical and regional distribution of the UNSC membership as follows:
i) 3 permanent members from Asia (India, China and Japan) instead of 1,
ii) 1 new regionally elected permanent member from the AU,
iii) 1 new permanent member (Brazil) from the GRULAC,
iv) 4 permanent members (USA, UK, France and Germany)
v) The continuation of the Russian Federation as the sole permanent representative of
Eastern Europe;
2. Calls for an increase of the non-permanent membership of the UNSC from ten member states to include
fifteen member states, wherein membership is determined by a two third majority win in a geopolitical
regional vote supervised by the Office of the UN Secretary General, to increase the geopolitical
representation by 1 in each of the five regions, changing the original distribution in the following manner:
a) 3 representatives from Asia instead of 2,
b) 4 representatives from Africa instead of 3,
c) 3 representatives from GRULAC instead of 2,
d) 3 representatives from WEOG,
e) 2 representatives from Eastern Europe instead of 1;
3. Suggests the regulation of the existing veto power possessed by the P5 through the following
approaches:
a) Making it compulsory for two negative votes by all veto powers in order to fail a resolution instead of
one, which may reduce a countries ability to fail a resolution entirely on the basis of the vested
interests of that country in doing so and obliging P5 representatives to take in to consideration the
greater good,
b) In the case of a single veto, the resolution in question must be re-debated and reconsidered by the
UNSC, after the country which vetoes the resolution presents an official statement elaborating upon
their reasons for doing so;
-27-
4. Recommends the creation of a Collective Veto for the new permanent members proposed in clause 1,
which would entail the following:
a) The ability to collectively veto a resolution if a four fifth majority of the permanent members of the
UNSC, other than the original P5, deem it favourable to vote against a particular issue,
b) The promotion of healthy dialogue, cooperation and cohesiveness within the council since new
members will need to work collaboratively in order to access its veto power,
c) The validity of individual votes of all permanent members when voting in favour of a resolution;
5. Further recommends that the duration of the non permanent membership of the UNSC be increased
from a two year rotational term to a three year rotational term to promote stability within the UNSC,
wherefore each member state has the right to get re-elected after the end of a four year term provided that
they are supported by a two third geopolitical majority within their respective regions;
6. Urges for the implementation of the above mentioned measures within the next five years, so as to
achieve efficient and evenhanded working conditions within the UNSC as soon as possible, under the
supervision of a Legal Committee for the Restructuring of the Security Council (LCRSC) set up by the
General Assembly, with the approval of the current P5 members of the UNSC, which would consist of two
legal representative from the UN to provide guidance regarding UN conventions and laws while
restructuring the council, along with one representative each from the P5, G4 and prospective AU
countries, so as to ensure a smooth transition;
7. Endorses the creation of a document elucidating upon the formal guidelines and qualifications for the
induction of elected non permanent members of the UNSC, by the LCRSC, which would include in depth
explanations about matters such as but not limited to:
a) The contributions of member states towards global peacekeeping and conflict management which
would make them favourable candidates for intake into the UNSC,
b) The human rights records of member states over the past five years, as reported by the UN Human
Rights Commission, which would impact their chances of entry into the UNSC,
c) Involvement in and management of recent or ongoing conflict by a member state as a criterion for
admission as a non permanent member of the UNSC,
8) Strongly hopes that the above mentioned clauses, in lieu with the will of all member states, will be able
to emphasize the significance of collaboration, compromise and cooperation within the United Nations
Security Council, restructuring it in a manner with reflects fair, equal and sensible representation and
decision making.
-28-
10. Public Speaking and Debating
What to Include in an Opening Speech:
First, you should thank the presiding official by saying "Thank you Mr./ Madame/ Honorable
Chair/ President…"
Then begin by providing a brief history on the issue as it relates to your country.
Speak about how the issue is currently affecting your country.
Provide your country's position on the issue. Include an explanation for your country’s stance,
such as economic or security concerns or political or religious ideology.
You may choose to give an explanation of how your country's position relates to the positions of
other member states such as the major powers or countries in your regional bloc.
You should discuss some of the past actions taken by the UN, member states and NGOs to address
the issue.
Present ideas for a resolution, stressing your country’s objectives for the resolution.
Talk about the role that NGOs or regional organizations have to play in addressing the issue.
Indicate to the committee members whether your country is willing to negotiate.
-29-
What to Include in a Speech During Debate:
Again, you should thank the presiding official by saying "Thank you Mr./ Madame/ Honorable
Chair/ President…"
Encourage collaboration among member states by proposing ways that your country would be
willing to work with other member states.
By referencing what other delegates have said, you can show support for your allies or indicate
which proposals your country does not favor.
Present ideas for draft resolutions.
Explain why your country does or does not support other draft resolutions.
-30-
11. Dress Code and Awards
Dress Code: The dress code for all MUN conferences is formal office wear. For boys, it’s the standard
suit with a shirt. Although a tie is a good addition, it is not a must. There is a bit more flexibility for
girls: they have the option of either wearing a proper suit, a formal dress with a cardigan, a
shirt/blouse and skirt with a cardigan etc. Just ensure its nothing skimpy and something you would
be comfortable wearing for a job interview. Remember, flip-flops, sneakers and sandals are not
allowed. Boys must wear formal shoes while girls have the option of heels or ballet flats etc. But
remember, closed toed shoes are more advisable.
Awards: Each MUN conference usually presents its most promising delegates and chairs with
awards at the end of the conference. There are two types of awards: internal-informal awards and
external-formal awards.
Internal-Informal Awards: These are also known as ‘fun category’ awards which is decided by a
majority vote within a committee. Chairs of a committee will usually put up categories such as
‘hottest delegate male/female’, ‘most likely to be a dictator’, ‘best chair’ etc. and delegates within the
committee will nominate delegates/chairs who best fit the category through ballot form. These
awards are just for fun and are used as a way of ending the conference on a lighter note.
External-Formal Awards: These are the serious awards based on the performance of a delegate
within his/her committee. The secretariat of a conference will usually provide chairs with categories
like ‘Best Delegate’, ‘Special Commendation, ‘Honourable Mention etc. and chairs will then nominate
one person for each category from within their committees. These awards are then presented to
delegates during the formal closing ceremony of the entire conference, usually in the form of
certificates and public recognition.
-31-
12. Surviving Your First MUN
If you are a first time MUN delegate, surviving a university level conference can appear to be a
daunting task. But life can be a bit easier for you if you keep in mind the following things:
1) Know your stuff. Without having had any MUN experience, this will be your biggest asset. Make
sure you research your topic well, not only from the perspective of your own country, but also
through the perspective of other key countries involved in the issue. You may find it helpful to
write a position paper to organize your thoughts, even though it may not be a requirement.
2) Try and start a Moderated Caucus. Before going for the conference, think of certain sub issues
related to the issue, which you are comfortable discussing. Then try and raise these sub issues as
a moderated caucus. It is much less daunting to speak during a moderated caucus than giving a
formal speech through the speakers’ list. At the same time, caucuses will give you an easier way
of getting noticed and putting across your views.
3) Speakers’ List. Of course, if you’re confident enough to go on the speakers’ list than that’s
brilliant! But remember to raise your placard early on when the speakers’ list opens. If your
country is far down on the list, it is unlikely you will get a chance to speak.
4) Be pro active during un-moderated caucuses. You don’t have to have an entire resolution
prepared, but make sure you do have a few detailed and concrete points to add to resolutions
which your allies might be working on. And make an effort to speak in support of resolutions you
are a co-submitter/signatory to, it will make the chairs notice you.
5) Involve everyone. If you are a delegate who does have a resolution prepared, be a bit flexible.
Incorporate the points of other delegates as well even if it isn’t exactly what you had in mind. A
one-man resolution NEVER passes.
6) Learn all your points. Even if you are unfamiliar with some of the motions, you will survive
because other delegates will raise motions. However, not knowing what points to raise could
hamper the quality of your debate.
-32-
13. References and Resources
The United Nations Today, United Nations Department of Public Information,
New York, 2008: This book provides all the information you will ever need about
the UN, its committees, administrative process and procedures.
United Nations Association of the United States of America: This website provides
an extremely comprehensive and holistic view of MUN and you may refer to it if
you still require additional information after reading this handbook:
http://www.unausa.org/munpreparation
The United Nations Association of the United Kingdom: Similar to the UNUSA
website. Pay special notice to their rules of procedure document. The first link
below leads to the website whereas the second is a link to the rules of procedure
document:
http://www.una.org.uk
http://www.una.org.uk/mun/19.pdf
United Nations Website: For a general overview on the and more information, visit
the following link:
http://www.un.org/en/
-33-
14. Acknowledgements
This MUN Delegate handbook was written and compiled by Athena Sharma (Vice President
Warwick MUN 2011-2012) with invaluable inputs and additions by Veronika Lipinska
(President Warwick MUN 2011-2012).
Note of thanks by the author: Without the corrections and suggestions made by Veronika,
which are backed by her years of MUN experience, it would not have been possible to make
this handbook as precise and informative as it is at present. Her constructive criticism and
encouragement really helped me along the way. Thanks, also to Vassia Poppova (Publicity
Officer), for designing the cover for this handbook.
Cover Page Photo: Soh Kuok Ming
We hope that delegates, both new and old, will find this handbook useful. If you have any
suggestions or find any information missing, do not hesitate to contact us because we are
always keen on improving the MUN experience for our society members.
-34-
Recommended