-:

. . , , . . ,

II

2006

947(08) 63.3(2)

89

. .

: / .-. . . , , . . , , . II. .: , 2006

ISBN 5-91150 - 003 - 5 . . ,

.......................................................................................................... 7

10. .& 1480 ............................................................................. 9

. : 1690- ...........................................................................................81

. . XIX , ..............99

3. . . : XIX .......................................................136

. . . . ,| (1830/ 1831) .................................................................................. 157

11. . . -. 18541855 ................................................................. 193

A. . . . . ...............................199

-. .....................................................................................218

. , 1908J 9 14 .............................245

B. . . : .......................................................................................... 264

. () , . . . 293

. : . - ................................................................................................313

. II. . . .............................................................................................

5

. . . . . ...........................................................................................351

. : 1654 : . ., 2 0 0 3 .........................................................................355

. : . . . . , . ., 2 0 0 3 ................................. 362

. : . X. . . , 2 0 0 1 ...................................... 368

. : . . . . ., 2 0 0 4 .......................................................373

. : Antoni A. Kaminski. Apostol prawdy i milosci. Filo-zoficzna mlodosc Michaila Bakunina. Wroclaw, 2 0 0 4 ........................ 389

. : ). ]. - > , 19191922. , 2 0 0 4 .............................. 397

...........................................................................................402

, , , , , . , , .

, , , , , , - . , ..

- , : , , , , , , . , , , , .

, , . * , . , , , ( , ) , , , - w . , .

,

7

, . , , . , 1900- . , . , , .

, , , . .

. .

1480 .

1

1480 . - . 1480 . . , , (, , ) . 2, - 3, 4. , , . , , ( 1477-)> 5.

1480 . .

1480 . - . 1480 . , , , . , , , .

1 04 00392.

2 IIC P JI.T .25 .

:| IIC PJI.T .26 .

1 ..30. I |.: . . . ., 1989. . 4564.

9

, 6, . . . , , . . . , .

1480. . . , . . . . . . 1480. . . , - . . , 7.

- 1480. , , , . . 8.

1480 . . . . 9 .

III 70- . XV. : ( 473-)

. , , , . , , .

.

6 . . III // . . , . ., 1911. . 280298.

7 . . . XV. ., 1952. . 102168.

8 . . . . . . . ., 1951.

9 .. . . II. ., 1957. . 301.

10

. 1472 . .

- , ( ) .

, . .

1478 ., .

, 70- ., , - . 1479/80 . .

, 26 1479 ., , . , . 10. , , 1478 .

.

, 1480 ., , - 11.

: , 12.

- 13.

, , - -. 13 1474 . I -.

10 . 24. . 197.

11 1ICPJI. . 5. . 2. . 218.12 . . 5. 4 .2 . . 219.

13 . . 5. . 2.

11

(> ( , , , , , , , )14. - . 1475 . 15. , .

. . . , . , . . : , , , , , 16. , . , , : , - . . , : , , ?17 , . , . . .

- . 1475 . 18,

14 . . 25. . 303.

13 27 (. . 25. . 303). . . 23 ( . . . 4 1. 2. . 9).

16 . . . 4 1. 2. . .

17 . . .

18 , - X V

12

. 1475 ., . - .

21 1475 . . , , . , . , , 1475 . -, , : , , .

1476 . 11 , . -, , : 50, .

1476 . : -, . . , -, . : , , .

, III , , . , . , .,, - . , () , . , .

, 1475- ~ ,

XVI . ., 1984. . 74. . . , , . (. . . 41. 4 . . 16).

111 . . 25. . 303.

13

. ., , , - 1474 , - .

: , , . 6 20. 21, . , .

, , 22. - , , , , . , -, - .

, , ; .

, , , 77 - 1480 . 1478 . .

: 26 1478 . . . 2. . , -

20 . . 25. . 309.

21 . . , ( . . 109), .

22 14751476 . ( . . ... . 118 .; .. ... . 194). . . , , 70- . ( . . 114).

23 . . 25. . 323.

14

> () . . . , , - , -, ( ). , 1469 ., : . , , 24.

. , , . .

I 1476 ., . , 0 . , 1 |77 . , 25. .

(1 , . , 5 1477.26 , , , 1474 1475., . - , , : () . , , , .

1479- 27.

. . 196197.

..* . 75.

211 2 . . ... . 115 ; ... . 75.

15

30 1471) . 28. , , , - . . , () , , -, ( *,, ).

, ... . , , ^, - , . - : - , , .

3 16 1480 .29 - - . , . , . , .

, , , - , -, ... ... - , , . , 30.

1480 . , , , . , , , , . -

28 . . . 4 1. 4 . . 14 16.

29 . 5 . . 1624.

30 . . . 4 1. 5. . 1920.

16

:> , . , . 1480. .

- . 70- . - - 31. - . - , 32. , 708- . - , .

, , 33. , -, 1479., . 1480. 1479 1480 . : , ( 6 8 . )34. , -, .

- - . - , 1480. -

11 . . : ( ) 14771479. . ( . . 109, . 22.)

12 . . / / . , i960. . XI ( ) . . 269; . . . . 35.

1,1 - . - . 1473 - , ( I K1P.II. . 25. . 301). . . , , (. ., 1919. . 27. . 348). - . (.: .. - : ( ). ., 1966. . 217).

I :| . . . . 42.

17

'15, . . -, , , . -, . -, , . -, 36. , . ( ) .

- ( ) , . 47 9 - 37. 1480. 38. , .

, 1480 . : . . - . , . . , . 1480 . .

:

.: . . ... . 116 118.

36 , . , , - 1479 1480 . , ; , . (. . 27. . 329330).

. . . 4 1. 4 . . 1516; .: . . ... . 1 16 ,1 17 .

38 . . 25. . 327.

18

39. , , , .

, ( ), , , .

1480 .: , ( 20 5 , 15 , 40: 20 6- ), (23 ). , . , 3, 41.

1480 . , . . - : , , . : , 42. . -, : , 43. It , : , 44. -, : , 45.

30 . . 326.

10 . ., 1913. . 18. . 267.

11 , . . ( . . - ) 1480., XV. .: . . ... . 130; . . . . 88.

12 IICPJI. . 25. . 327.

1,1 . . 18. . 267.

1 . . 25. . 327.

45 . . 18. . 267. : . ( . . 25. . 327).

19

: , . -, : , , . -, : ... , . : , , 46.

, , , . . , . , , .

, , : - , 1395. , 47. , , , .

. , . . : 8 . , : .

, 8 , . .

: . , ( ) . , . - ,

46 . . 18. . 267; . 25. . 327. , , , .

47 . . 20. . . . 214.

20

, : 48.

, ; , , , . , . - - , , 49.

- , - , .

- : , , 50. . : ... . , , 51. . ( , ), , - , , , ( ), ( ) . , . , 52.

- . . : , .

| . . 24. , 198199. , - . , , .

* . .. 199.

1111 . 26. . 262.

, ., 263.

\

21

, , - .

, . , , . , , , , , 1471 1477 .

, , , 1471 1477 ., , . - , , , . , ( - ) , , .

, , .

(, ) . , , , . , 1472 . .

1382. , -, . , 53. , , .

, , 54. 55, , ,

53 . . 20. . . . 203; . 23. . 128; . 24. . 5 .\

54 , , . (. . 25. . 327; . 18. . 267).

55 . , 1468 . -

22

. . , , , , : 23 56.

23 . , -, . -, , , .

(, ), , ( ) ( ) 57. , -, , , , , 58.

. , . , -, . , , , - - (2 45 ). 1451. , - )59. (-, ) , 60.

1480 . -

, , , . (. . 24. . 187).

58 I. . 18. . 267. 23 , : 23 .

57 120 , 90 , 120 .

5* 120 , 8.

>" . . 25. . 271.

1111 1467 . , 1469 . . 1472 . .\

23

. , or ( ), . 1472., , , , ( ), 1480. , ( ) , .. - . , , , 61. - 1472., , , , , . .

, , , , , , . , -, , , . , 1408 . , , -, : , , 30 . 62. , , . , , , , 63.

. , , , 2 . , . ( 1382., 1408., - 1439 ., 14 51 .) , , , , . ( 1459.,

61 . . . ( . . 115 ) .

62 . . 25. . 238; . . . . . 225226.

63 . . , , , . . ( lira. . ). , 200 . . . . , 3040 . ( . . 29).

24

III, 1472 . ) .I hi , . , , , 64, , - , - . , , 1480 . . , .

. , , , , .

- , , .

- 1480 . , , , . , -- . , . . , . , -, , , , . 1480. .

65. 18 . III , ( ). , ( )66.

64 1. . . . . . 203; . 25. . 207209.65 . .

. , ... ( . . ... . 133). , . . , , , , ( . , 1879. . II. . 287).

66 . .2 . . 221.

25

. , , . 20 67. 68. . II , . III , , , ; . , .. 68. , - ( . , 12 ), 70.

, , . II , () 4- (. . 23 )71, III , 13 - (. . 21 ) 72. , , - . . , , , . , , , 73, .

67 .

68 , 1370 . (. . 2. . 2 8 ,10 4 105), 1393 . . ( . . 3 0 ,10 7 ) .

69 . . 2. . 222.

7 , , , . 1323., 18 . (. . 2. . 23, 89); 1370. . ( . . 2 8 ,10 4 105). , . , : 1407 . , . (. . 33).

71 . . 2. . 6.

72 . . 221. . 13 21-, 4- , II .

73 . . 6.

26

.I ( ). , -, . , , . II , , . , . . 1241., .I II , . . , , . , -, .

, . , , , . . . , , , (), .

. , , . .

II , , ... . , . , , 24 25 , .

. , ( 1477.) . , . . , . , , .

27

, .

, , . ( ) , ( ). , .

( )74. , , 1480. , , . , . , -, , , . , , 75.

, , 45 ( 220).

II , 3 , . , . , , . : , . , . , , 1450 . , . . , , , , , . , , , ... , . , ,

74 . . 6, 6 .

75 .

28

, : , , . : 13 ... . , , . 76, , , , .77 , , , . . , , , - . , , , . ( 200 , 5 ), 78. .

1480 . - . ( , . , , , , , 79. , 23 ( 8), .I , -

711 . 40 ( . .-- . , 1881. . 187).

77 . . 2. . 6162.

7N ' . , III . (. . 2. . 222). - - ( ). , , I , . ; ... I , . (. . 20. . . . 346). , 3 , 4 5 , . . 29 ;} . 25 ; , . - . . . . ( ... . 144145)-

711 . . 25. . 327.

29

, - : , 80. . ... ) 81. , , . .

, , . -, . , 82. , , . -, , (150180), . . 34 , , , . - , ( , ) : 83. . , , , 84.

80 . . 26. . 264. - : , , ( . . 20. . , . 346).

81 . . 25. . 327.

82 , , , . . .: . . , . . 98 . , (. ). .) . (. . 24. . 199).

83 . , . (. . 24. . 199). , , . ( 1490.) III, . (. . . 35. 12 . . 5 1) . , , , ( 8- .) ( ). , (- 1473 . ), , .

84 III , 1480 ., . .

30

. . , 30 ... . , , , , , , 85. - 86. , ( . ..) , , 87.

, , , ( , ... )88 , , . , , . ; , 89. ( ). , , , . . , , , , . 1480., , . ( ) , -, , : (,

. ( ... . 134). , , , , , .

85 . . 25. . 321.

86 . . 24. . 199.

87 . . 25. . 327.

88 . . 20. . . . 340.

89 .

31

, , ). , . , , , . , .

. , , .

. , - . . , ... . , . , - , 90.

, . , , 91. , .

- , , , ( , , , - ), ( )92. - - . , , , , . , ,

90 . . 25. . 327.

91 . . 24. . 199200.

92 . . 20. . . . 346.

32

. , . , , .

, , . - , .

, , -, , . , , , , , 93. , , , , , .

, , - - - ( ). - , 94. - , ( ), ( ... - ) 95. , , , . , - , ( , ), . , . , , . , 1382. , , . , , ( ) , ,

93 . . 25. . 327.

94 . . 26. . 264.

95 . . . . . . 346.

2 - 30)6 33

96. 14,08 . . , , , , , , , . , , , , , 97. 439- -, , 98. , , . .

, , , . 1467 ., , , , , , ' ; , 99. 1480 ., , , .

, , , . 67 . . , . , . , , , . , . . , . , . , - .

96 . . 25. . 209210.

97 . . 268.

98 . . 260.

99 . . 279.

34

. , -, ( ) . - - .

. . . . 100. 101. .I - , , 102. -I : , , , , . , , ... 103.

- . - , . . , , , .

I -, , . - 1 , . , , , 104.

100 . . . . . . 339.

101 (. . 26. . 264).

102 ( *.

111:1 . . 26. . 264.

101 , 1445., , : , , (. ..) ... ? . . . 20. . . . 258.

35

, .

- . : , , - , : , , , . , ' , 105. , , - ; .

- - . (, - ) . 106. , . - , , - .

, , , , . , -, , -, , .

: ? ?

. , , , , , ( ) 107.

105 I1CPJ1.T . so. . . . 345.106 , .

, 1480 ., , , .

107 , ,

36

. : - , , 108. , .

, , , , , . , , , .

XIVXV . 1382 . , 109. 1445., ( , ), ( - , , , , - )110. .

, . . . -, ; : , , . : , (.. , , ). -, ( ) - JI , , , . .: . . . . 117, . 59.

1118 . : - , , : , ; , . . IICPJI. . 37. . 94.

109 IICPJI. . . . . . 203; . 25. . 207. .: .. ... . 223231: . . .... 640646.

110 IICPJI. . 25. . 263; . . ... . 779784.

37

1480 . ? , : , . 1445. 1382. , . , , , 1480 . .

1480. , - , . - , . , 1480 . , 1382 1445., , , . 1480 . , 1480 . 1382 1445 . , , 1480 . : .

: , , , , . , .

? , 111, - , 112. -

111 .: . . ... . 8 7 7 ,88.

112 .: .. ... . 235; . . . . 120.

38

XV., , . , , , . ., , , . , . . . , , , .

, , 1480 . - , . , , -, . , 3 , , .

, , . , ( ), . . , . .

3 , , . (8 , 23 , 30 ), , , . , , 113.

- . , , , 114. , 14 -

113 . . 24. . 199.

114 . . 20. . . . 345.

39

5 J/|T;IK - . ?

(, ) , , 116, .

, , . (8 ) , . , ( ), 8 , 117.

- , ? .

- , , . , . : .

, ( ), , . , . -, - 3 , . . 1 |.

. . : . . 118.

116 . . 30. . 137.

117 . . , ( . . - . . 118 ; . ., . . ... . 287, . 17).

1 | - , , -

40

3 , , , ? . , , , 119. . , 4050 . >. , . , - - , . :> , , 120 . , , , 2 , 121.

I , , ( ). , , .

. I , , , , , . . , : , (. . 20. . 1. . 345 349). , , 1140. ( ... ), , , , . , - , , . , . .: : . . . . 1 16 ,1 18 ; . . . . 5051; .. ... . 233234; . . ... . 880881. . . ( . . 30).

1111 IICPJI. . 25. . 327.

120 , ( ) 670. .

121 ( ) , . , , . , , , . ' , , . , , 1480 . , , . . : , , (. : . . III . . 289).

41

, , . . - . , , . , , 6 . , , : 6 -, , , 122.

, , . ( 1479.) 123. 1480 . , , , , . - , , , , 124. , ( 1480.) . , 15 125. , - . , , . , 128.

, , , , , ( )|27. . . , , , 1480 . , 1471. . . , 128.

122 . . 25. . 327, 328.

123 . . ... . 148.

124 .: . . - .. . 217.

125 . . 27. . 332335.

126 . . 335336.

127 . . ... . 150 155.

128 . . X V XVI . ., 1963. . 192194.

42

, 129. , , , . , ( , , ).

: , , , 130. . : . , . , -, , ( , ) . , , . 1472 . . . . 1480 . , -, , 131.

, , . , . .

, , : , , 132. ,

129 . . , , , , . . . ... . 46.

130 . . 25. . 328.

131 . . ( . . 919 2 ,10 4 ), .. ( . . 52) . . ( . . 3435).

132 . . . . 130; . . . . 52.

43

: , . : (- 10. .) , , .

- . , 6 , , . 8 , , 13. : 6 134. , -, , 1471,1475,1477 ., . , - : 6 , , 8 135. , - , : 136. - , ... ... . , - , () ( , , ). , , (.. 8, 9, 11 ). , - . : , 137. , , , .

133 . .26. . 264.

134 . . 30. . 137.

135 .. . . 130; . . . . 52.

136 . . 26. . 264.

137 . - . , (-*-^ ) . , . ( ). . , , () , . - , -

44

- . , . , .

: , , . - , .

. , - , 138. , , , 139. , , , . .

, - 140. , . , , , , , .

, - , , - , , .

. , (6 , ).

, . . , ( . . . . 98102).

. . 26. . 264, 266.

139 , . , , . , . , XV . , 15 , . , , . 300500 . , . - . . - , .

140 . . 26. . 266.

45

: I (. . . ) 141. - , , , . , 142.

, .

1480 . ( ) , . . ( 1459 1472 .) . , , , . 1480 . .

, . . ; .

141 . . 30. . 137.

142 , , , . , , . , , , . . . , .. . . , ill , ( . ., . . ... . 287, . 17) , 3 ( ). I ( ). 1471. 20 34 , . , 120 4 5 , 180 7 8 . , ( ) ( ).

46

- , . : (. /. . ) , , , , , . , , , ... . , , , , -- . ?

, - : , , , . : , , .

, , . , 1476 ., .

, . , . , , -, , , . . , , . , , , :,, - , . .I , .

: , - . : ; . , .

I , , , ,

. , , , , . , , , , , . . ... . , . , . - , , , , .

- . , , . . . - - . . . , , . . : , , , , . , , , . ... 143.

, - , - . , , , , -. - , , , - , . - .

, . ,

143 . . 26. . 265.

48

. . . , , . . . . , , , 1472. . . 1474 147^ ^ , . 1480 . , , . , ( , ).

, - - , , 1480., . . , . , . , , .

, 70- . . . , , , : - , . ( , )144. -: 1480. , 145.

144 IICPJI. . 25. . 202.

145 XVI . . , ,

49

- ; : , , 146. , , . , : 3 , , 147. : , .

, , , . , -, - .

148. , - ... . , , .

. ( 13 , ) , 2025 . , , . . 30 3 , , . . 149.

, (. : .. - ... . 217). .. : . ( . . 2 17 218).

146 . . 20. . . . 346.

147 . , 26 , , .

148 . . 25. . 328, 329; . 18. . 268.

149 . . 20 . ( ... . 156). . . (. ., 1971. . 13. . 483), . . ( . . ). , . . 2627 ( . . 5455), .

50

, , . , , , . . . , - . - .

, , . , , . - 150.

. , , . , , , , 151. , , . . 26 , . .

. , ... , .

15 11CPJI. . 25. . 328; . 18. . 268; . 24. . 200. -- .

. . . . : , . ... ( . . ... . 158). . . , , , ( . . 5455).

51

: ( ) - ( , )152. ( 40) , . . , . , 153. . , , . , . , , , ; . , 154.

, , , .

- , , 155. (8 ) . - , -- , , , , .. 9 . , , 156.

152 . . 24. . 200; . 25. . 328; . 26. . 273.

153 . . , ( . . 55). , , . . , . . : - ; ( ... . 16 1) . ( ): . . (. . 30. . 137). . . . . . . ( . . 42).

154 . . , . . ... . .

155 . . 26. . 273.

156 . . 30. . 137.

52

, 157. . , * 158.

(1 , . : , , , . - 159. , , , : 160.I , , , . , (, , ), , , , 161. . . .

I , , , - , , . . . , ,

* . . 25. . 326.

, - I : (. . 26. . 273).

ICPJ1. . 25. . 328.11111 . . 24. . 200201.

" , , . . I , , , , , ... XIX . , ( . . III . ( 2(>). , , , . . . . , , .

53

112. 120 . , , - , . , : (... , )|63.

, . - , , , , , , .

, , , . , . , , , 164. - : , , , , , , . . , , ... . 163.

, XV. 166. . , , . ,

162 , , , , , - , , , , .

163 . . 25. . 328. . . , ( . . ... . 154

155)5,64 . . 25. . 328.

165 . . 26. . 274.

166 III (. 89. . 360).

54

. : 167.

- , , . , : , , , 168. , , , 169.

1480 ., , , , . , , , , ... - 170. . . 1480 . . . 1480 . . 1480 . , , .

, , - .

167 . ., 1851. . . . 72.

- : , , , (. . 20.. . 346). 150, 14 . si-4 , 68 . , 2427 , , . .: . . . . 4 142.

! . . , . ( ... . 16 1).

170 I ICPJI.T. 25. . 328. : 28 ( . . 30. fi. 137)- . 28 1480 . , . 28 , ,- .

55

- , 1480 . 1480. , . , , 1480 . . , , , , 171.

- (.. ) . , . 1480 . , . . . . , 1480 . , . , 1480 . . - , . 1480. . , . - , .

1480 . . . - , . , , . .

171 ; , , (. ., 1863. . 15. . 497).

56

1471 1472 ., ( , , ). , , , -, .

, . 1472 ., ( ) * , . - .

1480 . - , . 1480. - , .

. 1480.

3- . [ ] 172.

173.

. . , .

. 1480 . , , :

... [] , . - , , , 174.

. , , , . , ( ) . 1480. , , , .

1480 . -, .

. : ) ; 2) ; 3) - ; 4) ; 5) , , . . .

1480 . .

172 . . . 5.

173 . 5. . 2021.

174 . 5. . 20.

58

( ) .

, -, ( ).

( ) , .

( ) , .

- . , .I . , , . , (| .

.

- . : ) ; 2) .

.

. -, , , . .

. .

, .

59

. , ., - - , .

. , . , , . , - . - . .

.

. , , . , , . , .

, .

, . , . , , , , , .

, , . .

60

, -, - .

, . , , . , 26 1481. . . 175. , : , . , : , . , : , , . -. . , , , ... , . . ( ) ( ), , , 176.

, 1481 . , . -, , , ; -, .

- 1481. 1480 .

175 , , . (. ., 1851. . . . 107108).

|7

( , ). , , , . , - , .

III , .. , . , , , . , , 1480 . , , III .

, , . , 1481. , 1481/82 .

, , , : 1480 . . 1481. - : {) , , , , , . , , , , . , . : . , 177. , , , .

177 . ., 1910. . 27. . 340.

62

. (1480/81 . ^ . . ) ,

, . , (. . ) . - , . , - . . , , - : , . ( ) . , , , , , . .

, , , 1480 . . .

, , , . - . , 181. . , , , - . . . , , , - ,

181 3 . . . , i960. . in , 112 ; . ., . . XIVXVI . // . -, 1964. . 475503; . . . , 1986. . 82.

64

. 1480. , .

. , , - . , . , 1480/81 . - - , 182. , , , , 1480. , , -, , . . . , 183, , -, , 184 -- . . 185. 186.

, 1481. : .

I , , ... ... . .

182 . ; ., 1949. . 25. . 329.

183 , , . . , . (. . 20. . . . 348).

184 . . 25. . 329.

185 . . 18. . 269.

186 . . . . 7879.

3 3016 65

. 1481 . . 11 . . . . 20- 187, . , . , . . 18 25 .

, ... 188.

II , 189. 1 - (). . . . 50 , , . , . ( ); 191. . 2 . . . 192. .

( , , - )193 . , , , 194. , . 1480 . . . () . (), , . .

187 . . 1. . 79.

188 . . 25. , 329.

189 . . . .

190 . . 25. . 329.

191 . . 329. , ( . . 20. . L . 348).

192 . . 2. . 62.

193 .

194 .

66

. , , . , 2025. . 1820 , , 8 . , , 20 .

, , 200 1268 . 195. 1481. .

1481. - : , . , , - . , . , 1480., - 196. III.

, . 1482 . .

I - . 1482 . . , I 197.

: !>: . . : XV. ., 1952. . 234236; .. - -- :): XIV XVI. ., 1975. . 16 1163.

| !hx> III , 26 1481. . ., : , , , . (. . . 4 1. 6 . . 25).

1117 . . 20. .. . 349.

67

. : 198.

1482 . . , : , , , , - , , 199. , , . ?

1477 . , - , , . . , 200. , , , 1481. 201.

( ) 202, 1480 . 1482 . ( ) .

. , 203. ( ) . , IV, , III 204.

, , . ,

198 . , . (. . 37. . 49).

199 . . 2 4 - 2 5 .

200 . . 25. . 3 13315.

201 .. 11. . 695; . . 25. . 329.202 ... . 47; .: . .

XV- XVI . ., 1988. . 4356.

203 ... . 5557.

204 , (, 1506.) , , ( , 1521. -, ... . 57). .: .. ... . 9092.

68

. 1469 . 205. 1471. 206, 77- _ 207. 1482. ( ). /, 208.

, , , 209.

, 1482 . . . , . . . . 210. 1469., ( ) . , , . . . ( ) 1466 . 211, 477- 212. . . , 27 1471 . , . 213; 477- 214. , . . : 1478. 215. ( 1477 . , 216, 1478 . , 217. , , , , .

205 . .25 . . 282.

~01 . . 28. . 144.

207 ' . . 25. . 314.

aw . . X. . 93; . . . ., 1969. . 169 173.

20! ... . 59.

. . 25.211 IICPJI. . 37. . 91. -

( ).

212 . . 25. . 3 14 315.

21,1 . . 290.

. .21.

| ' IICPJI. . 28. . 148.

2111 . . 25. . 314.

217 . . 28. . 148.

69

1482 . , . , 16 1482. , , , . (. . ) 218.

), ), , , , , . : . , , - , , , , , , 219. , , .

. - , , : 16 1482 . -, , . , . -, ( , ). . , . . , 1481. . , , , . , . , , . , , 220. - , , , , 221.

1482 . 14 , . , .

218 1469 1477 . .219 . . 25.220 . . . 62.221 . . 6466.

70

, (. . , . . , ). , , . (, ). , 6- XV. 1463 . , ( , , ) . , , , ( ). , . , , 1482 ., .

, III (|. , , , 1482 . , .

, , . , . - , -, , . , ( 1478. - ), (, ) . .

, . 1483. - . - , : ( ) , , 222.

.'. 26. . 276.

71

. . . 25 . 29 . , , 6 . . 9 22.

. , . . (, , ) , . 224. ... , , . . 9 . , , - , () , ?25,

- , - , - . 1472 . , -- , . . 1483 . . , , , , , . . 2 . , , , , , . , , , ,

. 223 (. ( . ., '977- - -- 124)-

224 . . 37. . 49.

225 . . 95.

72

. 1483 - , , , . . . () . ... - , . ... 226.

, , . , , , - . , - . . , , 227. , , , . , 228. , , . . , . , 1483 . 229.

, .

1481/82 . : . :

226 . . 26. . 276. . ( . . 33. . 124125). ( . . 37. . 49, 95).

227 . . 37. . 49.

228 . . 33. . 125.

229 . . . . 8384.

73

, . . , - . , , . , , , .

, , 8- . . 406- ., . , . , .

- . 70- . , . 1471* 14 7 7 ,1480. . 70- . . , 1476 . . - . , . 1477- , , , , , .

-

, . ,

74

, , . : ( , ), , . , , ( ), , - . - 8- . -, , . 1484/85 . , ! ( )230. - , 8- ., . . . . , .

, ... 231. .

II , 1484/85. ... - , - , . 2 232. , , : . 1471- , : . , , . . ...

2:10 IICPJI. . 20. .. . 351.

' .

232 MJI. . 2. . 66.

75

( . . . ) 2*. . -, , . -, . -, - ( , ) .

1485. , 236. , . : , . , 1484/85. , * . , , . , .

. : (. . 1485. ~ ^0 . .) . , , , , . : , ., , . , , , . , ,

. . 20. . 1. . 351.

234 .

235 . 79 . . 295.

76

, . , , . , - , . , .

: , . .

, 1485 . . , , , ( ) . , . , 236.

, -- . 1485 . , , , .

. ( ). , . . . , : 237. .

I1CPJI. . . . L . 352. .

77

. ... ... . , . 2 , , , , , ... 238.

, , . , ^ , . 70- ., . , : , , , . , . , - . - . , , , , ^ 239. , , .

. 8 ... ... , , 240. , , 78 , . , , . , , , . 241.

238 . . 18. . 271; . 24. . 204.

. 239 . . 20. . . . 352; . 37. . 96.

249 . . 18. . 271.

241 , (. . 33. . 125). .

78

, , ^. . , ... 12 , , 243. : . , , , , , . 244,

. . - , , , , 245. , : , , , . , .

. , , . , , . , , ... , 246. , 15 , , , . , -, : , 247. 18 , 29 : , 248.

242 IICPJI. .33 . . 125.243 . . 18. . 271.244 ... (. . 33.

. 125).24 IICPJ1.T . 18. Qjqp.24 .247 .248 .

79

, , . ? , ( ), , ? , , : , , , . , -, .

, . - , . - III, .

- .

1693 . , , , . , , . , , [ ] . , , , , . : , 1.

34 , 16931694 . 2. . , , , , * . , . ,

1 . . 1202 (). . . . . 324. . 22.

2 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . 134.

81

, , - .

, . 32 34 7202 ( 1693 1694) , -. ( , ) . , , . 32 ; 18 , 4 - 3. , , , - . 1724 1726 . 15 4. 7202 . 31 ( ). 1678. 169 5. , 7202 . .

, . 7202 . , . 1695. ( )6. ,

3 7202 - . , , ; , . , 7202. , , . , , . : (. . 1202. . . . . 324. . 14) , , (JI.19 ); (. 15) (. 28 ,30) , .

4 . . 627. ( ). . 349. . . 1 . 1724. . 38; . . 2 .1726 . . 20.

0 . . XVII . - . ., 1977. . 280.

6 . . 1202. . . . . 366.

82

, .

, . , , . , : , , . , , (?). , , , , : [ ] . . , , .

, , . 7202 , , . , : , , - . , , , , ; , , , , 7. , , . 1690- . , , , . : , .

. , , , , ,

7 . . 1202. . . . . 324. JI. 4.

83

, . . , . , .

, . : ; ; ; ; ; ; 8. , , , . , 9. , ; . , . , . , , .

, , : , , , . : , , , , , , , , , . , XVII , . , , , XVII .

8 . . 1202. . . . . 324. J1. 16 ,19 , 20, 21, 22, 27, 29 ,32 .9 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . , , 15.

, , ( . . 24). . , , , , , , .

84

1690- . - , : . XVII , , , , 10. , . , , . 1688 ., 8 2 (25 ), 6 (3 ) , , 11. 1690- . ( ) 3 (10/2 ) - (25 )12. -, , . , 13. 1696. , , , 3 , , . , , . , .

10 , , , , .

11 . . , XVII //- . 1888. L . 72.

12 1696 . - (. . 1202. . . . . 502. . .) , 1696 . , 3 8 (. . 1202. . . . . 488). 1691. , , (. . 1202. . . 263).

13 . . . . 275.

85

, 14.

, , . , , . , . , , , , .

, , , , . 1692 . : 15. , . 1693 . , : - 16. , , .

, 17. 1693.

14 . . 1202. . . . . 499. , , . , , , . , 23 , ; , , . 1708 . , (. . . . 73).

15 . . 1202. . . . . 324. J1. . .: . . 2 ,6 , 25, 28.

16 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . 20.

17 , XVIII . (. . . 14. . . . . 2490. . 19 19 .) , . ,

86

. , 18. . , 19. , 20. , ; , , , , , , , .

, , - , . 1696 . , ; , , 21. , , 22. , 23. , XVII ( ) , 3 , , 8 , 37 24.

3 , (. . 1202. . L . . 265).

18 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . 20; . . 265.

19 . . 1202. . . . . 451. . .

20 . . 1202. . . . . 502. () .

21 . . 1202. . . . . 499.

22 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . 12.

23 . . . . 274285. XVII . , 1686 1,5 ( 3 ), 1688. 2 . 20 . , . 1690- . 88 , . 40 . ( , , 95 .), . , .

24 Richard Hellie. The Economy and Material Culture of Russia, 16001725. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999. Pp. 4 19 ,4 50 451.

87

, , .

, . , - . , . , , 25. , , , , , , .

, , . , ( , , , , . . 30 ), , , ( )26, ; , , , , , 27. , , , , 28. , 29.

, . , , , , . , , ,

25 . . 1202. On. . . . 324. . 88 .

26 . . 1202. . . . . 264; . . 324. . 23.

27 . . 1202. . . . . 4 1 1 ( 1691 . - ). , , ( . . . 324. . 3 1).

28 . . 1202. . . . . 324. . 31.29 . . 1202. . . . . 264; . . 224 ( 1690.

, ; ).

88

. XVII , . 1693 ., , 30. , , , , . 1690 . , 2 4 (12 ) | 31. 1691. - , 32. 1694 . , , , ; , . , , . , , 33.

, . , . . , .

, XVII - . -, . , , , . , , ( ) .

30 . . 1202. . . . . 224.

3 .

32 . . 1202. . . . . 265.

33 . . 1202. . . . . 4 11.

89

, , , . , . , : - , , , , ; , . , ; , 34.

. 1691. , - , , ; , , - 35. - : 1693 . , 36. , . , , , , .

, . , 37. , , , , . , . , , , ,

34 . . 1203. . . . . 224; . . 262; . . 264; . . 265; . . 297; . . 325. . 1 3 ,2 3 ,3 1 ; . . 4 11; . . 451.

35 . . 1202. . . - . 265.

36 . . 1202. On. 1. - . 324. J1. 23.37 . . 1202. . . . . 263. - . 324. JI. 22, 31.

90

38. , XVII , . - , , , , , .

, , . , , , , , . , , : , . , , , . , , , .

, , , , , . , , , . , , , . , , , . 1693. , , , [ ] 39. , , . : , . , ; , . 1695 . , [ ] , 40. : , .

38 . . . . , . . 324. . 3 1.

39 . . 1202. . - . 324. . 2.

40 . . 1202. . . . . 451.

91

. , . , , , , , 41. . , , 15 42. , . , . 1693 . 15- 30- , 43. , , . , , , - 44. , , . 1693 . , , , [ ] 45.

, , , 1693 , . , , , , . . , , , , ,

41 . . 1202. On. L . . 324. JI. 34.

42 . . 1202. On. L . . 324. JI. 25 .

43 , , .: . . 1202. On. L . . 324. . 33J34. .: . . . 361. , , , , 15 - ( . . . 324. . 8 ). , .

44 . . 1202. On. L . . 324. . 12.

45 . . 3.

92

. , , . ( , , ). , , 46. . , . . , , 47.

' , . , , , , . , , , . , , , , ? , , ( , ), ; . , , . , , .

, , . 1694 . 15- 30-, , 48. 1692. , , , , , 49. 1693. , . ,

46 . 9. . . .

47 . J1. 17 17 ., 18.48 . . 1202. O11. . . . 361.

40 . . 1202, . 1. . . 246. . 15.

93

, 30. , , , : , , 51.

, , , . 1695 . , , , . , , , . . , , , , , . , 52.

, , , - , , , , . , , : , . . , , .

, ? : . , - - . , , . , , . , , , .

50 . . 1202. . . . . 324. JI. 13.

51 . . 2406.

52 . . 1202. . . . . 366,451.

94

, , : , , . , . 8 , 7202 , , , , , . , . , , , . , , , . , , , , . , .

, , , , , . , , . - ; , . 12 18 , , , , , 53. , 1694 .: 1693 . , , , , ; , , 54. , , .

, , , , , . ? ? , ,

. . 1202. , . . . 324. . 4, 5, 8 ,1 3 ,1 4 ,1 8 ,1 9 , 2f 26, 27, 28, 29.

54 . . 29.

95

. , , , , , . , , .

, , , . , , . - , , . ; , .

, , , . , . , , 35. 56. , , , , . , , 57. , , , , , 58. .

. , , , , , -

85 . . 1202. On. L . . 8, 79, 86, 91, 99, , 164, 275, 3 13 , 314 , 316, 376, 384, 4 2 1,4 9 5 ,4 9 9 ; . 4. . . 18, 26.

56 . . 1202. . . . . 376,392, 500.

** . . 1202. . . . . Eh 43- 53> 85. 232, 284, 3 17 ,3 3 8 ,3 3 9 , 340, 352 ,4 22 ,4 4 7 , 485, 490, 505, 506.

58 . . 1202. On. 1. . . 53, 268, 297, 458.

96

. , . , , : , , .

, , : , . , , . ' , , , ; , . , ; , . , XVII , , , . , : .

1690- . , . 17801790- . 50 ( ), 59. XVIII. , , , , . , , XIX. ( ) 60.

59 . . 14 (). . . . . 2484. . 64, 6868 ., 7 1 .; . . 2487. . 26 ., 29; . . 3490. J 1. 1920, 31, 3435.

60 (): . , // . 1898, 22, 28 ; . ( )// . 1845, 14, 5 ; . . , 1876. . 19.

4 - 3016 97

, XIX. , . , . , , , . , , . XIX , , , , 1690- .

, XIX , . , : ... ? - ; , ? , , , , ; , , , 61. 1690- . .

61 . . . 16., 1865. . 20.

XIX

, , , , .

. , (1776)

XIX . . - , . , , , , , , - , 1. , , .. , , 2. , ,

1 1897 , 14 ( 150 . ), , . 40 . , 20 . .: . // . . 1913. . 757763. 14 ,1 . : Bilal Eryilmaz. Osmanli Devletinde Gayrimiislim Tebanin Yonetimi. Istanbul, 1990. 81.

2 E. H. ? ., 1891. . 4.

4* 99

. , - II , - - , , 3.

, - , , , , , , 4. , , . . , , - , , .

XIX . , , , , , . , , , , , . , - - () 88- . 5.

3 .: 1893. / / ( ). . . .2. .9251. JI. . - .: Selim Deringil. The Well-Protected Domains: Ideology and the Legitimation of Power in the Ottoman Empire, 18761909 (London, 1999).

4 . : , . 1881 (: Oxford, 1985). . 29.

, , : J . G . Zaynullin. XVIII ydz XX yoz bashi'n- da tatar rukhani adabiyati. Kazan, 1998.45; Azade-Ayse Rorlich. The Volga Tatars: A Profile

100

, XIX , . II, . . () . 6. , , 7. , , , , ,

in National Resilience. Stanford, Calif., 1986. .: Edward J.Lazzerini. Beyond Renewal: The Jadid Response to Pressure for Change in the Modern Era // Muslims in Central Asia: Expressions of Identity and Change/Jo-Ann Gross, ed. Durham, N. C., 1992. P. 15 1166. , , , . Stephane A. Dudoignon. Qu est-ce que la ,qadimi- ya 1 Elements pour une sociologie du traditionalisme musulman / / Islam de Russie et en Tran- soxiane (au toumant des XIXe et XIXe siecles): L Islam de Russie: Conscience communautaire et autonomie politique chez les Tatars de la Volga et de I Oural depuis le XVIIIe siecle/Stcphane A. Dudoignon, Damir Is haqov, and Rafyq Mohammatshin, eds. Paris, 1997. P.207225.

6 , , .: Peter Holquist. Count, to Extract, and to Exterminate: Population Statistics and Population Politics in Late Imperial and Soviet Russia / / A State of Nations: Empire and Nation-Making in the Age of Lenin and Stalin/Ronald Grigor Suny and Terry Martin, eds. Oxford, 2001. P .1 1 1144; .: Moshe Gammer. Muslim Resistance to the Tsar: Shamil and the Conquest of Chechnia and Daghestan. London, 1994; Anna Zelkina. In Quest for God and Freedom: The Sufi Response to the Russian Advance in the North Caucasus. New York, 2000; . : Rudolph Peters. Islam and Colonialism: The Doctrine of Jihad in Modern History. The Hague, 1979.

7 , . .: Firouzeh Mostashari. Colonial Dilemmas: Russian Policies in the Muslim Caucasus / / Of Religion and Empire: Missions, Conversion, and Tolerance in Tsarist Russia/Robert P.Geraci and Michael Khodarkovsky, eds. Ithaca, N. Y ., 2001. P.229249; .. : , , . ., 2002. . 4651; . // / . . . . . . ., 2001. . 108 125. .: Michael Khodarkovsky. Russias Steppe Frontier: The Making of a Colonial Empire, 15001800. Bloomington, Ind., 2002. P .3739.

101

, . XIX .

- , , . , , , , . , 8. , . , . , , , . XVIII , , XX , , , , . - , 9. ,

8 . , : Yuri Slezkine. Arctic Mirrors: Russia and the Small Peoples of the North. Ithaca, N. Y ., 1994; Mark Bassin. Imperial Visions: Nationalist Imagination and Geographical Expansion in the Russian Far East, 18401865. Cambridge, 1999; Robert P.Geraci. Window on the East: National and Imperial Identities in Late Tsarist Russia. Ithaca, 2001; Theodore Weeks. Nation and State in Late Imperial Russia: Nationalism and Russification 011 the Western Frontier, 18631914. Dekalb, 111., 1996; Austin Jer- sild. Orientalism and Empire: North Caucasus Mountain Peoples and the Georgian Frontier, 18451917. Montreal, 2002; Andreas Kappeler. Russland als Vielvolkerreich: Entstehung, Geschichte, Zerfall. 2d edn. Munich, 1993.

9 : Andreas Kappeler. Russlands erste Nationalitaten: Das Zarenreich und die Volker der Mittleren Wolga vom 16. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Cologne, 1982; Allen J . Frank. Islamic Historiography and Bulghar Identity among the Tatars and Bashkirs of Russia. Leiden, 1998; Paul W. Werth. At the Margins of Orthodoxy: Mission, Governance, and Confessional Politics in Russias Volga-Kama Region, 18271905. Ithaca, N .Y ., 2002; Christian Noack. Muslimischer Nationalismus im

102

. , , , .

, , , , ( ). , 10. XVIII , .

, , . . , . , . , , , . . , , - , (). , ; , ,

Russischcn Reich: Nationsbildungund NationalbewegungbeiTataren und Baschkiren, 1861 1917. Stuttgart, 2000.

10 Nancy Shields Kollmann. By Honor Bound: State and Society in Early Modern Russia. Ithaca, N .Y ., 1999.

103

. . , , , .

. , . , , . 1839 1856 ., ()11. , . , , , , . XVIIIj- - XIX., , , ,

, , . ; , 13. ,

11 .: Bruge Masters. Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Arab World: The Roots of Sectarianism. Cambridge, 2001: Giilnihal Bozkurt. Gayrimiislim Osmanli Vatandaslarinin Hukuki Durumu (1839- 19 14 ). Ankara, 1989.

12 .: Talal Asad. Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam. Baltimore, 1993. Lois . Dubin. The Port Jews of Habsburg Trieste: Absolutist Polities and Enlightenment Culture. Stanford, Calif., 1999.

13 , ,

104

, , 14. XIX , , - . , . , , 15. , , , .

. , , 16.

1863 . . .: Peter van der Veer. Imperial Encounters: Religion and Modernity in India and Britain. Princeton, N. J . , 2001. P .2123.

14 Paula E. Hyman. The Jews of Modern France. Berkeley, Calif., 1998. P.3752; C.T.M c- Intire. Changing Religious Establishments and Religious Liberty in France, Part I: 178 7 1879 // Freedom and Religion in the Nineteenth Century/Richard Helmstadter, ed. Stanford, Calif., 1997. P.233272; Dubin. Port Jews; Avigdor Levy', cd. The Jews of the Ottoman Empire. Princeton, N .J . , 1994; Kurt Nowak. Geschichte des Christentums in Deutschland: Religion, Politik und Gesellschaft vom Ende der Aufklarung bis zur Mitte des 20. Jahrhun- derts. Munich, 1995. S .6493.

15 ., : Bozkurt. Gayrimiistim Osmanli Vatandaslarinin Hukuki Durumu. 24; David C. Itzkowitz. The Jews of Europe and the Limits of Religious Freedom // Helmstadter. Freedom and Religion in the Nineteenth Century. P.150171; Lata Mani. Contentious Traditions: The Debate on SAT1 in Colonial India // Cultural Critique. 7 (Fall 1987). P.119156. , : Martin Cha- nock. Law, Custom and Social Order: The Colonial Experience in Malawi and Zambia. Cambridge, 1985; Ronald Robinson. Non-European Foundations of European Imperialism: Sketch for a Theory of Collaboration / / Studies in the Theory of Imperialism/Roger Owen and Bob Sutcliffe, eds. London, 1972. P.117142.

16 XVIII ; , -

105

1788. ( ), , , , 17. , , , , , . , - , , , .

II , , . . , , , , , 300 18. , , , . , . ,

. .: . . . ., 1769; . , : . ., 1784. XIX , . .: Shihabetdin Marjani. Mdstafadcl-akhbar I'i akhvali Kazan va Bolgar ( Kazan ham Bolgar khallere turinda faydalanilgan khabarler) /. N. Khayrullin, cd. Kazan, 1989. 209.

1* .: . . XVIII _ XIX. , 1999. - ( ), ( ), ( ). , 1794., XIX . .: Mostashari Colonial Dilemmas. , 1865 .

18 ; ( ). .8 2 1. On.8. . 1078. . 4 4 5445 . , : XIX // 5070- . M .-JL, 1936. . .

106

. , . , , 19. . , - .

II, , , , . . (Polizeistaat) *. ; . , , 21. ,

| .: Werth. At the Margins of Orthodoxy; Geraci and Khodarkovsky. Of Religion and Empire.

20 .: Marc Raeff. The Well- Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 16001800. New Haven, Conn., 1983. P .57; Karl Schwarz. Vom Nutzen einer Christli- chen Toleranz fiir den Staat: Bemerkungen zum Stellenwert der Religion bei den Spatkamer- alisten Justi und Sonnenfels / / lm Zeichen der Toleranz: Aufsalze zur Toleranzgesetzgebung des 18. Jahrhunderts im Reichc Josephe II, ihren Voraussetzungen und ihren Folgen/Peter l\ Barton, ed. Vienna, 1981. S. 8689; Ole Peter Grell and Roy Porter, eds. Toleration in Enlightenment Europe. Cambridge, 2000.

21 , . , (.: . . . 4 . 1. ., 1857. . 6). , , & 1839 .; 1875 . .: Theodore R. Weeks. Between Rome and Tsargrad: The tJniate Church in Imperial Russia // Geraci and Khodarkovsky. Of Religion and Empire. P.7-91.

107

22. , . - , 23. , , . 1803 . . , I, , , , 24.

I , , ail peoples inhabiting Russia praise Almighty God in different languages according to the creed and confession of their forefathers, blessing the reign of the Russian Monarchs, and praying to the Creator of the universe for the increase of the prosperity and strengthening of the power of the Empire.25 , , , , , , , , , 26. , I

22 1 , ... . , , , , . . : William A. James. The Jesuits Role in Founding Schools in Late Tsarist Russia // Religious and Secular Forces in Late Tsarist Russia: Essays in Honor of Donald W.Treadgold/Charles E.Timberlake, ed. Seattle, 1992. P.59. ( .)

23 , . , . . : Laura Engclstcin. The Dream of Civil Society in Tsarist Russia: Law, State, and Religion // Civil Society before Democracy: Lessons from Nineteenth-Century Europe/Nancy Bermeo and Philip Nord, eds. Lanham, Md., 2000. P .234 1.

24 M.M. . ., 1961. . 9294.

25 . . . ., 1832. . XVIIXVIII.

26 . .X V I; . . . . . ., 1857. . 5. 1858. ( 14 . ) . , ,

108

. , , , , 27.

, , , 28. , , ' , , . , 18301831. , .., - , , 29.

, : . . X IX .: . ., 1992.

27 Laura Engelstein. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom: A Russian Folktale. Ithaca, N .Y ., 1999. P.5051. . , , , . , . .: . --: / / . 26 .19 9 7 . . 7 1104.

28 I , , , . . . . , , , , . 1 1817 . 95 ; , , . .: JI. . : . ., 1999; Albert . Ammann. Ahriss der ostslawischen Kirchengcschichte. Vienna, 1950; Igor Smolitsch. Geschichte der russischen Kirche. Vol. 2/Gregory L. Freeze, ed., Forschun- gcn zur Osteuropaischen Geschichte. Vol. 45 (1991); E. . : . , 1997. . 138; Erik Amburger. Geschichte des Protestantismus in Russland. Stuttgart, 1961. S.68.

29 1848 , I , . [], , [], , , (. . . 8 82, 238239). , 1863., ;

109

to explain to Jews their law... and make them understand... [its] true meaning and to direct Jews to observe moral obligations [and ] to obey the general state laws and established authorities.30 , , , ( ) , .

, , , . , , . , , , 31. , , 32. , , , 33. , , , .

, . -

( 18 6 1,18 6 2 1863 . ., 1865. . 187188).

30 . . . . . 201. 1836 , , ( Russia and llic Armenians of Transcaucasia, 1797 1889: A Documentary Record/Trans, and commentary by George A. Bournoutian. Costa Mesa, Calif., 1998. P.359. ).

31 . .: Bournoutian. Russia and the Armenians. P.359- . .: Ruth Harris. Lourdes: Body and Spirit in the Secular Age. New York, 1999; David Blackbourn. Marpingen: Apparitions of the Virgin Mary in Bismarckian Cermany. Oxford, 1993; : Werner Conze and Helga Reinhart. Fanatisinus / / Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe: Historiches Lexicon zur politisch-sozialcn Sprache in Deutschland/Otto Brunner, Werner Conze, and Reinhart Kosseleck, eds. Band 2. Stuttgart, 1975. S.303327.

32 . . 5. ., i960. . 563566.

33 , , . , - , , , (. . . .. . 34).

110

ne , XX -, , 34. , . , . , ; , , . , , . , , . , . , , , . , , , , . , , , 35.

, . , ,

11 , [] XIX , - | (Kappeler. Russland als Violvolkerreich. S .137).

;,!i : ( ). .6 . .3. .4744, 2411, 3277. . : Bournoutian. Russia and the Armenians. Ip. 7477, 197198, 342343; H. . 4 .2 . . . ., 1859. . 4 1 1414 . ' . , , - (Ainmann. Ahriss. S.467).

I l l

. 8. I . ( ) 36. . , , , 37. (, 1804 .) . 1827. , , , , , , , , 38. , , .

1817 . , ; 1832 . : Erik Amburger. Geschichte der Behordenorganisation Russlands von Peter dem Grossen bis 1917. Leiden, 1966. S .176177; . . .: Michael Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrte in Tatarien und Baschkirien, 17891889: Der islamische Diskurs unter russischer Herrschaft. Berlin, 1998; Werth. At the Margins of Orthodoxy; Eli Lcderhendler. The Road to Modern Jewish Politics: Political Tradition and Political Reconstruction in the Jewish Community of Tsarist Russia. New York, 1989; Amburger. Geschichte des Protestantismus.

37 . 1835 . , ; , ( , ). 1853 . . , ( . . . . . 203,206 ). : . . ( '- XIX ). , 1971; . . . . 2. . 483; Lcderhendler. Road to Modern Jewish Politics. P.49; H. / / -. . . 1895. . 740. , , . .: . (17991855 .). 116., 1909. . 520523.

38 Lederhendler. Road to Modern Jewish Politics. P.4850; Michael Stanislawski. Tsar Nicholas I and the Jews: The Transformation of Jewish Society in Russia, 18251855. Philadelphia, 1983.

112

I , . , () 39. , , , 40. , , , 41.

, . , 42. , , .

39 1815 1818 . , , , (. .6 . .4. .8085. J1. 4949 ., 69 .) . : , 18361903 . , 1905.

40 Slanislawski. Tsar Nicholas 1 and the Jews. P.29.41 Cm.: David W. Edwards. The System of Nicholas I in Church-State Relations / / Russian

Orthodoxy under the Old Regime/Robert L. Nichols and Theofanis George Stavrou, eds. Minneapolis, 1978; Paraskevas Konortas. From Taife to Millet: Ottoman Terms for the Ottoman Greek Orthodox Community // Ottoman Greeks in the Age of Nationalism: Politics, Economy, and Society in the Nineteenth Century/Dimitri Gondicas and Charles Issawi, eds. Princeton, N. J . , 1999. P .169 179.

42 He , . , 1773 . , . 1815 . , 1820 . ( ), . - . VII , , , - : . . : . . 2. ., 1876. . 157; . . . 156 158; . Abriss. S. 4404 4 1,4 5 7 458, 461466; Smolitsch. Geschichte der russischen Kirche. S.365; Judith Cohen Zacek. The Russian Bible Society and the Catholic Church // Canadian Slavic Studies. 5, no. 1 (Spring 197 1). P-3550.

113

, , , , . , , , 43.

, . 1832 ., , . : - , 44. 1832 ., , . I , 45.

1820- . , , 46. , , , . , , , , , .

43 Bournoutian. Russia and the Armenians. Pp. 7677, 456461. , , . 18 11 . (Nikolas . Gvozdev. The Russian Empire and the Georgian Orthodox Church in the First Decades of Imperial Rule, 18011830 / / Central Asian Survey. 14 , no. 3 (1995): P. 407423).

44 Amburger. Geschichte des Protestantismus. S.888 9 ,178 179.

4 1840- ., . , ; , 1879 . (Amburger. Gcschichte des Protestantismus. S.8895; 1835 . ., 1836. . 4 9 -5 0 ) .

46 . : Werth. At the Margins of Orthodoxy.

114

1853 . I 47.

, . , , , . . , , , . , . , , . 1848 . , . , , . , , 48. - , , , .

47 , , , ; . .: . . - XIX XX . -, 1957; . . . ., 1998. . 44; Dittmar Schorkowitz. Staat und Nationalitaten in Russland: Der Integrationsprozessder Burjaten und Kalmiicken, 18221925. Stuttgart, 2001; . . . 3. . 2 .18 62. . 256259. .: . ? , 1889.

48 -- . , , , . , () . , , . 1829 . 129 (Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrte. S .4 3 ) . . 1857 . , - .

115

, . , ( ), , , 49.

, , , , , , 50. . , - , , , , . , , , , 51. , , , , , 52.

. , , -

49 . : Rizaeddin Fahreddinev. Menasib-i diniye. Orenburg, 1910.

50 Simon Dixon. The Churchs Social Role in St. Petersburg, 1880 1914 / / Church, Nation, and State in Russia and Ukraine/Ceoffrey A. Hosking, ed. London, 1991. P .167192; Adele Lindenmeyr. Poverty Is Not a Vice: Charily, Society, and the State in Imperial Russia. Princeton, N. J . , 1996; Amburger. Geschichte des Protestantismus, 166 170; Heinz-Dietrich Lowe. Von ,MiIdtatigkeit zu ,Sozialpolitik : Jiidischc Selbsthilfe in Russland 18601917 // Aufbruch der Gesellschaft im verordneten Staal: Russland in der Spatphase des Zarenreich- es/Heiko Haumann and Stefan Plaggenborg, eds. Frankfurt am Main, 1994. S.98118.

51 Isaac Levitats. The Jewish Community in Russia, 17721844. New York, 1943. P.200204.

52 ., , , 1849 . : ( ). . - 295. .2. .43. . 755756 . .: Levitats. Jewish Community in Russia. P.213 214; Gregory L. Freeze. The Wages of Sin: The Decline of Public Penance in Imperial Russia // Stephen K. Batalden, ed. Seeking God: The Recovery of Religious Identity in Orthodox Russia, Ukraine, and Georgia. Dekalb, III., 1993. P .5382; Laura Engelstein. The Keys to Happiness: Sex and the Search for Modernity in Fin-de-Siecle,Russia. Ithaca, N. Y ., 1992. P .17 55; : . . : . ., 1905.

116

53. , , , , , , . , , . , 54. , , . , , 55.

, , |) , , , , 56. , - , 57. , : , .

, , , , , . . -,

53 Gregory Freeze. Bringing Order to the Russian Family: Marriage and Divorce in Imperial Russia, 1760 1860 //Jou rnal of Modern History. 62, no. 4 (December 1990). P.709746. ( 1857 . .

51 . : . .8 2 1. .8. .951. : ChaeRan Y. Freeze. The Litigious Gerusha: Jewish Women and Divorce in Imperial Russia// Nationalities Papers25, no. 1 (1997). P.89101.

5.1 ., , , 18 2 1 . (. .6 . . 4. . 7601).

5.1 . . . . . . 203.

57 . ., ., 1871. (. .-295. .2. . 122. JI. 5906. 6).

117

, . 5**. , , , . , .

. , , . : , . - 1819 . , , 59. 1823. , ( , ), 60. . XVIII

58 (. .6 . .2. . 724, 1026). , ( . . . . . . 203). , : , , , , (Levitats. Jewish Community in Russia. 202203).

59 , , , . , , , 1820- . , . .: - . . 4 .2 . . 3. . , 276.

60 Andre Arvaldis Brumanis. Aux origines de la hierarchie latine en Russie: Mgr Stanislas Sies- trzencewicz-Bohusz, Premier archeveque-metropolitain de Mohilev ( 17 3 1 1826). Louvain, 1968. P-333336; . . . 162.

118

, . , , 61. , , , , , 62.

. , , 63. () , , , , 64. , 65.

.: ! . . . . ., 1925, . 103 113; .: . : . - , 1994. , , , , . .: // . . 15. 1846. . 49, 28 2^ 309 ; . . 1846. . 500580. , 1850- . . : Benjamin Nathans. Conflict, Community, and the Jews of Late Nineteenth-Century St. Petersburg// Jahrbiicher fur Geschichte Osteuropas. 44, no. a (1996). S .178215,

. . . 9.

, , , . .: Elisheva Carlebach. The Pursuit of Heresy: Rabbi Moses Hagiz and the Sabbatian Controversies, New York, 1990; . . . 2021.

1,4 Paul Mendes-Flohr and Jehuda Reinharz, eds. The Jew in the Modern World, 2d edn. New York, 1995. P 385. , , , ... [] , ! (. : Michael Stanislawski. For Whom DoI Toil? Judah Lcib Gordon and the Crisis of Russian Jewry. New York, 1988. P .30 ). : Steven J . Zipperstein. The Jews of Odessa: A Cultural History, 1794 1881. Stanford, Calif., 1985. P .4 169.

1870 . -- , , , , , , (Lederhendler. Road to Modern Jewish Politics. Pp. 9091, 9510 0 ,19 5).

119

, . , . , , , . , , , . , , , , . , , . , . , , . , , .

- , . XV., , . . , , . , . , , , , , 66.

66 .: Roy P. Mottaliedeh. Loyalty and Leadership in an Early Islamic Society. Princeton, N. J . , 1980; Ira M. Lapidus. Muslim Cities in the Later Middle Ages. Cambridge, Mass., 1967; Richard W. Bulliel. Islam: The View from the Edge. New York, 1994. XVIII . .: Frank. Islamic Historiography. P.2146.

120

, XVIII . , , , , , 67. , , , 68. I , , , . , (), , , . , , , ( ) 69. , - , - () . I? 1862 . , , -

,|7 . . .; IsmailTiirkoglu. RusyaTiirkleriArasindaki Yenilesme Hareketinin Oneiilerinden Rizaeddin Fahreddin (1858 1936). Istanbul, 2000. 8384. * - : : .{ , , / . . . . ., 2001.

1,8 1835 . 3036 4781 , 1034976 16 ( 1835., ). 1849 . 3255 5397 !!, 1858. 3750 , 1569 2 . ( . .8 2 1. . 999. JI. 5 .-6; Marjani. Mostafadel-akhbar, 210).

1,11 , Allen J. Frank. Muslim Religious Institutions in Imperial Russia: The Islamic World of Novouzensk District and the Kazakh Inner Horde, 17801910. Leiden, 2001; Noack. Muslimischer Nation- alismus, , . , . 1802 . , . , . .: . - // : . . . ., 1998. . 27. , .

121

: - - >> ()70. , , , , .

, , ( -) , 71. , , , , . , () , , . . , . , . , , . , , , 1831. , 1832 . , . , , 1836., , , 72. , , , .

70 . . -295. -- . 5048. . 99 .

, . . 1801. - : . .6 . O11.2. .724; .: , . , 1891. . 4041.

72 Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrle. S.7073; ... . 34.

.

, - . - , , . , , , . , , , , ( ), ( ) . . - , , , , . , ( ), , , : ! ?74 , , XIX , it , , .

I? , . , , , , , . - 1871., , [] 75. .

7,1 . , : . . -295. . 3. . 5567. . 113 06.-115 .: Marjani. Mostaf- iidel-akhbar.

Marjani. Mostafadel-akhbar. 3001310.

I P U H L . -295. On. 3. . 122. JI. 4 3 1 . . - , , , -

123

, . , ^. , . -, , , , # 77. , . , , , 73. - . , , , . , , - .

, . , ,

. . : . -295. .3. . 830; .: . -295. .3. - 5^9 -^

76 () () . .: Stephane A. Dudoignon. Djadidisme, mirasisme, islamisme / / Cahiers du monde russe. 37, nos. 12 (1996). P. 1340; Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrte. , , , , (Wael . Hallaq. Authority, Continuity, and Change in slamie Law. Cambridge, 2001).

77 Fahreddinev. Menasib-i diniye; Terbiyeli khatun. Kazan, 1899. 6. . (Marjani. Mostafadel-akhbar. 312- 3 14 ) .

78 .: Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrte. S. 5061, 6670, 290299: 1 U 'HAPB. . 295, On. 2. . 43.

124

, , 70. , , . , 80. , , . , , , . , , , , .

, - , . , , , , , , , , , , 81. , , , , . , , , . , , , , , , , 82. ,

7!) Lawrence Rosen. The Anthropology of Justice: Law as Culture in Islamic Society. Cambridge, 1989. P.17.

80 Rosen. Anthropology of Justice. P .18.

81 , , . .: Michael Cook. Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong in Islamic Thought. Cambridge, 2000.

82 ., , , - (. . . .3. .7615. J1. 1212 .; . .8 2 1. .8. .775. JI. 18; . 1078. JI. 445f*447; . 614. . 1582). .: David Moon. Russian Peasants and Tsarist Legislation on the Eve of Reform: Interaction between Peasants and Officialdom, 18251855. Basingstoke, 1992.

125

. , , , 83.

, , 1849. I , . , , : , , , , 84. , 85.

1833 . I , , , , , . , , , , . , , , 86.

1832 . , , , . , -

83 X IX .: . .6 . .2. .724. J1. 135135 .. . 1850- .: . . 821. . 8. . 995. 1159 1164 ( . . 20. 19 2 8 3 ,15 1845. ., 1846. . 8 17818). I ( , (., : . . . . 46).

84 ..-295. .2. .43. . 121506 .-1216 .

85 . . . .3. .7615. J1. 12 .86 . . -295. -- 6 2 5 . J1. 5 15.

.: . .8 21. .8. . 615; . . -295. .3. .910, 5^ 5 5698; Frank. Muslim Religious Institutions. Chap. 4.

126

. , , , . , - . . , , , 87. , ; , , 88.

, , 88. , , , 1863. [! ]90. , , . , 91.

87 Dudoignon. Djadidisme, mirasisme, islamisme; Kemper. Sufis und Gelehrte.

88 ..-295. .3. .910. JI. 1206.-13.

811 M . .: David S. Powers. On Judicial Review in Islamic Law // Law and Society Review. 26, no. 2 (1992). P. 315341; : Fariba Zarinebaf-Shahr. Ottoman Women and the Tradition of Seeking Justice // Women in Ihe Ottoman Empire: Middle Eastern Women in the Early Modern Era/Madeline C.Zilfi, ed. Leiden, 1997. P.253263. , 1860- . , , , (. . . . 154166; Robert D. Crews. Allies in Gods Command: Muslim Communities and the? State in Imperial Russia (PhD dissertation, Princeton University, 1999. Chap. 5).

. . 166.

" 1 (1., : Michael R. Anderson. Legal Scholarship and the Politics of Islam in British

127

. , , .., . , . ( )