16
34567 Š9 6>5: /1 Z*ybS db1j1ZS1H

Где найти утешение?

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Мы все нуждаемся в утешении, особенно в трудные времена. В этих статьях объясняется, какое утешение может дать Бог.

Citation preview

Page 1: Где найти утешение?

34567Š 9 6>5:

�/1 Z*ybS db1j1ZS1H

Page 2: Где найти утешение?

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) Issue 13September 2016 is published monthly with anadditional issue published in January, March,May, July, September, and November.� Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- undTraktat-Gesellschaft, Selters/Ts., V. i. S. d. P.Manfred Steffensdorfer, Selters/Ts.� 2016 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Societyof Pennsylvania. Printed in Germany

�\/`*3*yb1 Sf ,1`1w'b\ P +Sb,* �1-\,mx =

�ab`1h* ˙*,S/* a �\WS*e\YD�mW\ WS ob\ Z* a*Y\Y /1W1H 57�S+WSq Y1Zq1b 3S4Zn) +mW \4W\+W1ZZmY S 31ab\VSY 58

�b\ -\,\`Sb �S+WSqH 5:

�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

���•�˚ �˝˚

�/1 Z*ybS db1j1ZS1H�b1j1ZS1 Zd3Z\ V*3/\Yd 7

�b1j1ZS1E V\b\`\1 /*1b �\- 8

�b1j1ZS1 , b`d/Z\1 ,`1Yq :

34567Vol. 137, No. 13 RUSSIAN

�S`*3 V*3/\-\ ,m]daV* , `*4Zmfe\`Y*b*fB 9<=<;>>>˙\abd]1Z Z* 6;8 )˛%� No. 5 2016���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

˝� �� w�b\`\31,*q +*jZqx ]`\OaW*,Wq1b �\-* �1-\,d P �`*,Sb1Wq�a1W1ZZ\yD 'b\b 3d`Z*W db1j*1b WpO/1y +W*-\y ,1abnp \ b\YE hb\ �\3n1Z1+1aZ\1 �*`ab,\ ,aV\`1 ]\V\ZhSba\ ,a1Y 4W\Y S ,aq 41YWq ab*Z1b `*O1YD �Z dV`1]Wq1b ,1`d , �Sada* �`SOab*E V\b\`my dY1`E hb\+m Ym Y\-WS\+`1abS ,1hZdp 3S4ZnE S V\b\`mya1yh*a ]`*,Sb V*V �*`n �\3n1-\�*`ab,*D 'b\b 3d`Z*W S4/*1baq Z1O]`1`m,Z\ a 5<;= -\/*D �Z ]\WSbSh1OaVS Z1yb`*W1Z S ]\WZ\abnp \aZ\,*ZZ* �S+WSS

�1a]W*bZ\D 'b\ S4/*ZS1 P h*abn,a1YS`Z\y +S+W1yaV\y ]`\a,1bSOb1WnZ\y /1qb1WnZ\abSE V\b\`*q]`\,\/Sbaq f`SabS*ZaVSYS �,S/1Ob1WqYS �1-\,m S ]\//1`3S,*1baq/\+`\,\WnZmYS ]\31`b,\,*ZSqYS

˚aWS ,m f\bSb1 a/1W*bn ]\31`b,\O,*ZS1E ]\a1bSb1 a*yb www.jw.org/ru

˚aWS Z1 dV*4*Z\ SZ*h1E +S+W1yaVS1 gSb*bm,4qbm S4 w�,qk1ZZ\-\ �Sa*ZSq P �1`1,\/*Z\,\-\ YS`*x

˝1W*1b1 WS ,m ]\WdhSbn +\Wnj1SZe\`Y*gSS SWS f\bSb1E hb\+ma ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\an +1a]W*bZ\1/\Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 �S+WSSH

�\a1bSb1 a*yb www.jw.org/ruSWS Z*]SjSb1 ]\ \/Z\YdS4 dV*4*ZZmf ZS31 */`1a\,

s ���•�˚ ���•�

���˚�% � ˙ ���˚����˚•��˚ ��� ��%

�\h1Yd Zd3Z\ Y\WSbnaqH�d/1b WS �\- YZ1 \b,1h*bnHL�Y\b`Sb1 ,VW*/Vd ����˚•��˚ ��˚��) ˛

���˚�% � ����˚•��˚ ��� ��%Mr

��� �% ˙�˚�˚H

� 3S4ZS V*3/\-\ S4 Z*a 1abn a,\Sb`d/Z\abSD V\YdE ]\O,*j1YdE Y\3Z\\+`*bSbnaq 4* ]\Y\knp S db1j1ZS1YH

� �S+WSS -\,\`SbaqBw�b1g a\ab`*/*ZSq S �\- ,aqV\-\db1j1ZSqDDD db1j*1b Z*a ,\ ,a1fZ*jSf +1/*fx L6 \`SZeqZ*Y 5B7E 8MD

� ob\Y ,m]daV1 w�b\`\31,\y +*jZSx\+lqaZq1baqE V*V\1 db1j1ZS1 Z*YY\31b /*bn �\-D

Page 3: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: 7

�\YZSb1 WS ,mE V*V ]*/*WS , /1bab,1H �m Y\-WS]\g*`*]*bn `dVd SWS `*4+Sbn V\W1ZVdD �a]\YZSOb1E V*V ,*a db1j*W* Y*Y*D �\4Y\3Z\E \Z* ]`\YmOW* `*ZdE * ]\b\Y 4*VW1SW* 11 ]W*abm`1YD �m ]W*OV*WSE Z\ 11 \+lqbSq S Yq-VSy -\W\a ]\Y\-WS ,*Y+mab`\ da]\V\SbnaqD � b\b Y\Y1Zb ,m Z* a1+1Sa]mb*WS aSWd db1j1ZSqD

�\ ]\ Y1`1 b\-\ V*V Ym ,4`\aW11YE 3S4Zn daOW\3Zq1baqD �`\+W1Ym ab*Z\,qbaq ,a1 a1`n14Z11E* db1j1ZS1 Z*ybS ,a1 b`d/Z11D � a\3*W1ZSpE]`\+W1Ym ,4`\aWmf `1/V\ `1j*pbaq a ]\Y\knp]W*abm`q S Y*b1`SZaV\-\ \+lqbSqD �\b WSjn Z1OaV\WnV\ ]`SY1`\,D

˙ �b*WVS,*WSan WS ,m a ]\b1`1y `*+\bmH �dWS*Z-\,\`SbE hb\E V\-/* 1-\ d,\WSWSE d Z1-\ aW\,Z\]\h,* djW* S4O]\/ Z\-D w�*V q +d/d V\`YSbn a1OYnpH P ]1`13S,*W \ZDP ) ab\WnV\ W1b ]`\`*+\Ob*W , ob\y V\Y]*ZSSE * b1]1`nE \V*4m,*1baqE q SYZ1 Zd31ZIx

˙ �\4Y\3Z\E ,m ]\/*,W1Zm S4O4* `*4,\/*D w�\-O/* ]\Wb\`* -\/* Z*4*/ Yd3 Z1\3S/*ZZ\ +`\aSWY1ZqE q +mW* , \bh*qZSSD �\1 a1`/g1 aW\,Z\ `*4O+SW\an Z* Vda\hVSI P ,a]\YSZ*1b �*V1WnDP �Z1+mW\ +\WnZ\ V*VeS4Sh1aVSE b*V S oY\gS\Z*WnZ\D'b\ ]d-*W\ Y1ZqxD

˙ hb\E 1aWS d ,*a a1`n14Z*q ]`\+W1Y* a\ 4/\`\O,n1Y S dWdhj1ZSy Z1bH �\`\y ,m Y\31b1 hd,ab,\O,*bn a1+q V*V d]\YqZdbmy , S+WSS \,E V\b\O`my aV*4*WB w�]`\bS,1W* YZ1 3S4Znx L\, ;B5:E�SZ\/*WnZmy ]1`1,\/MD �\4Y\3Z\E ,*Y +WS4VShd,ab,* dSa*E V\b\`\Yd 4* <>D �Z ]`S4Z*1baqBwZ\-/* q ]`\ab\ aS3d S 3/d aY1`bSxD

˙ �WS Y\31bE ,m \ab`\ Zd3/*1b1an , db1j1ZSS]\aW1 aY1`bS +WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*D w�\-/* YZ1 aV*4*OWSE hb\ Y\y amZ ]\-S+ , *,S*V*b*ab`\e1E q Z1Y\- , ob\ ]\,1`SbnEP ,a]\YSZ*1b �\+1`bDP˛*b1Y]`SjW* +\WnE b*V*q +\WnE V\b\`*qE V*V aV*4*Z\ ,S+WSSE ]`\Z4*1b Z*aV,\4nE aW\,Z\ Y1hx L dVS6B79MD

�\+1`bE dSaE �*V1Wn S �dWS*Z Z*jWS db1j1OZS1 /*31 , ab\Wn bq31Wmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*fD �ZS\a\4Z*WSE hb\ 1abn �\bE Vb\ Y\31b /*bn Z*ab\qk11db1j1ZS1EP �a1Y\-dkSy \-D �*V db1j*1b \-H Y\31b WS \Z db1jSbn WShZ\ ,*aH

�˚� � ����˝�

��˚"˚��˚ ��˝�� ˝˙���

Page 4: Где найти утешение?

�]\ab\W �*,1W aV*4*WE hb\ 1-\,*� P w\- ,aqV\O-\ db1j1ZSqE V\b\`my db1j*1b Z*a ,\ ,a1f Z*jSf+1/*fx L6 �\`SZeqZ*Y 5B7E 8MD �*V S+WSq 4*,1`qO1bEhb\ \- Y\31b ]\Y\hn V*3/\Yd S hb\E V*V*q +mb`*-1/Sq ZS ]`\S4\jW* , Z*j1y3S4ZSE \Z a]\a\O+1Z Z*a db1jSbnD�\Z1hZ\E hb\+m ]\WdhSbn db1j1ZS1 \b \-*E

\b Z*a b\31 \3S/*pbaq V*VS1Ob\ /1yab,SqD �*4,1,`*h aY\31b Z*Y ]\Y\hnE 1aWS Ym Z1 ]`S/1Y V Z1OYd Z* ]`S1YH � S+WSS aV*4*Z\B w�\y/db WS /,\1,Y1ab1E 1aWS \ZS Z1 /\-\,\`qbaq S Z1 ,ab`1bqbOaqHx L�Y\a 7B7MD �\ob\Yd �W\,\ \-* ]\+d3/*O1b Z*aB w�`S+WS4nb1an V \-dE S \Z ]`S+WS4SbaqV ,*Yx L*V\,* 8B<MD�\ \bVd/* Ym 4Z*1YE hb\ \- f\h1b ]`S+WS4SbnO

aq V Z*YH �\O]1`,mfE \Z a*Y YZ\-\V`*bZ\ 4*,1`qO1b Z*a , b\YE hb\ 31W*1b Z*Y ]\Y\hnD L�Y\b`Sb1`*YVdDM ,\O,b\`mfE d Z*a 1abn ]`SY1` b1fE Vb\Z* a1+1 \kdbSW \3n1 db1j1ZS1EP ob\ `1*WnZm1Wp/SE 3S,jS1 , ]`\jW\YE * b*V31 Z*jS a\,`1OY1ZZSVSD

� �\-W*aZ\ S+WSSE 1-\,* P ob\ SYq \-*D

�\/\+Z\YZ\-SY Wp/qYE V\b\`m1 a1-\/Zq Skdb]\Y\kS d \-*E g*`n ˙*,S/ b\31 ]1`13SW Z1Y*OW\ +1/D w�aWmjn -\W\a Y\Sf Y\W1ZSyE V\-/* q,4m,*p V b1+1 \ ]\Y\kSxEP ]`\aSW \Z \/Z*3/m1-\,dD �b,1bSW WS 1Yd \-H ˙*D ˙*,S/ aV*4*WBw) ]\WdhSW ]\Y\knE S Y\1 a1`/g1 WSVd1bx L�a*OW\Y 6<B6E ;MD

�� & ����� ������ � �˚"˚��������)#��\- \b,1W Sadad �`Sabd VWph1,dp `\Wn , b\YE

hb\+m db1j*bn Wp/1yD �*VE \/Z* S4 ]`ShSZE ]\h1OYd Sada ]`Sj1W Z* 41YWpE 4*VWph*W*an , b\YEhb\+m wSag1Wqbn a\V`dj1ZZmf a1`/g1Yx S wdb1OjSbn ,a1f aV\`+qkSfx La*Sq :5B5E 6MD �*V S +mW\]`1/aV*4*Z\E Sada ]`\q,WqW \a\+\1 ,ZSY*ZS1 Vwdab*WmY S \+`1Y1Z1ZZmYx L�*be1q 55B6<P7>E�\,`1Y1ZZmy ]1`1,\/MDSada db1j*W Wp/1y `*4ZmYS a]\a\+*YSB /*O

,*W Yd/`my a\,1bE ]`\q,WqW /\+`\bdE * , Z1V\Ob\`mf aWdh*qf /*31 Sag1WqW +\W14ZSD �/Z*3/m\/SZ ]`\V*31ZZmy ]\]`\aSW Sada*B w˚aWS bmb\WnV\ 4*f\h1jnE bm aY\31jn Y1Zq \hSabSbnxD

��˚"˚��˚E ��� �˚ ˙˚� ���

Page 5: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: 9

a]\WZ1ZZmy a\ab`*/*ZSqE Sada \b,1bSWB w�\OhdD �hSabSanx L�*`V* 5B8>E 85MD ]`\V*31ZZmySag1WSWaqD�\bq Sada* d31 Z1b Z* 41YW1 S \Z Z1 Y\31b

db1jSbn Z*a WShZ\E 1-\ �b1g 1-\,*E w\- ,aqV\O-\ db1j1ZSqxE ]`\/\W3*1b ]\Y\-*bn b1YE Vb\ Zd3O/*1baq , ]\Y\kS L6 �\`SZeqZ*Y 5B7MD �*aaY\bO`SY h1bm`1 a]\a\+*E V*V \- Y\31b Z*a db1jSbnD

˙ �1`14 �S+WSpD w�a1 Z*]Sa*ZZ\1 ]`13/1+mW\ Z*]Sa*Z\ /Wq Z*j1-\ Z*ab*,W1ZSqE hb\+m+W*-\/*`q Z*j1y ab\yV\abS S db1j1ZSp S4 �Sa*OZSy Ym SY1WS Z*/13/dx L�SYWqZ*Y 59B8MD

˙ �1`14 a,\y a,qb\y /dfD�\aW1 aY1`bS SadOa* f`SabS*ZaV\1 a\+`*ZS1 \h1Zn aSWnZ\ Zd3/*OW\an , db1j1ZSSD �*V ,S/Z\ S4 S+WSSE \- db1OjSW f`SabS*Z h1`14 a,qb\y /dfE a,\p Y\kZdp/1yab,dpkdp aSWd L˙1qZSq =B75MD � ]\Y\knpa,qb\-\ /df* \- Y\31b db1jSbn Wp+\-\ h1W\,1OV* , Wp+mf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*fD

˙ �1`14 Y\WSb,dD w�S \ h1Y Z1 +1a]\V\yOb1anxEP aV*4*Z\ , S+WSSD �Z* ]\+d3/*1bB w�bOV`m,*yb1 a,\S ]`\an+m \-dE S YS` \3SyE V\b\O`my ]`1,\af\/Sb ,aqVdp YmaWnE a\f`*ZSb ,*jSa1`/g* S dYmx L�SWS]]Syg*Y 8B:E ;MD

˙ �1`14 /`d-Sf f`SabS*ZD \Wnj\1 db1j1ZS1Z*Y Y\-db ]`SZ1abS Z*ab\qkS1 /`d4nqE V\b\`m1`*4/1Wqpb Z*jS d+13/1ZSqD �]\ab\W �*,1W aV*O4*WE hb\ 1-\ +`*bnq ]\ ,1`1 ab*WS /Wq Z1-\ \-`\YO

Z\y ]\//1`3V\y S db1j1ZS1Y , b`d/Zm1 ,`1Y1Z*L�\W\aaqZ*Y 8B55C 5 �1aa*W\ZSVSyg*Y 7B;MD�\ ,\4Y\3Z\E ,m a]`\aSb1B w�*V ,a1 ob\ ,m-WqO

/Sb Z* ]`*VbSV1Hx ˙*,*yb1 `*aaY\b`SY ]`SY1`mb1fE Vb\ ab\WVZdWaq a ]`\+W1Y*YSE d]\YqZdbmYS,Z*h*W1D �\/\+Z\ obSY Wp/qYE ,m aY\31b1 d+1O/SbnaqEhb\ \- S , Z*j1 ,`1Yq Sa]\WZq1b a,\1 a\O-`1,*pk11 /djd \+1k*ZS1B w�*V db1j*1b h1W\,1OV* 1-\ Y*bnE b*V q +d/d db1j*bn ,*ax La*Sq ::B57MD

˙ w�mE \ �1-\,*E ]\Y\- YZ1 S db1jSWY1Zqx L�a*W\Y <:B5;MD

˙ wt�b1j*yb1E db1j*yb1 Y\y Z*`\/rEP-\,\`Sb ,*j �\-x L�a*Sq 8>B5MD

˙ w*V db1j*1b h1W\,1V* 1-\ Y*bnEb*V q ��1-\,*� +d/d db1j*bn ,*axL�a*Sq ::B56E 57MD

˙ w�h*abWS,m aV\`+qkS1E ]\b\Yd hb\\ZS +d/db db1j1Zmx L�*be1q 9B8MD

˙ w�a1 a,\S +1a]\V\yab,* ,\4W\3Sb1Z* Z1-\ ��\-*�E ]\b\Yd hb\ \Z4*+\bSbaq \ ,*ax L5 �1b`* 9B;MD

˙\V*4*b1Wnab,* b\-\Ehb\ �\- f\h1b Z*a db1jSbn

Page 6: Где найти утешение?

: ��� �˝˚�) �"�)

���˚�) �����%

w�m a 31Z\y \/Z\,`1Y1ZZ\ ]\b1`qWS `*+\bdEP,a]\YSZ*1b �1b�DP ˙,* -\/* Ym 3SWS 4* ah1b]\Y\kS `\/ab,1ZZSV\, S ]1`1+S,*WSan aWdh*yOZmYS 4*`*+\bV*YSD � Sb\-1 Y\q 31Z*E �`SaaSWW*E,]*W* , dZmZS1E * YZ\y \,W*/1W\ hd,ab,\ ZSVh1YOZ\abSD�*V Ym a obSY a]`*,SWSanH �`SaaSWW* ]\ab\qZO

Z\ Z*]\YSZ*W* a1+1 aW\,* Sada* S4 �*be1q :B78D�Z aV*4*WE hb\ Z1 Z*/\ +1a]\V\Sbnaq \ 4*,b`*jOZ1Y /Z1E ]\aV\WnVd 4*,b`* +d/db a,\S +1a]\V\yOab,*D ˝1Z* -\`qh\ Y\WSW*anE S ob\ ]\Y\-*W\ 1yZ1 a/*,*bnaqD �1Zq 31 db1j*WS aW\,* S4 �a*WOY* 99B66D �\/\+Z\ ]a*WY\]1,gdE q ,\4W\3SW a,\S4*+\bm Z* 1-\,d S \kdbSW 1-\ ]\//1`3VdD �\bqa1-\/Zq d Y1Zq 1abn `*+\b*E Ym ab*`*1Yaq ,1abS]`\abdp3S4Zn , a\-W*aSS a a\,1b\Y Sada*E 4*]SOa*ZZmY , �*be1q :B6>P66D � Sb\-1 Ym ab*WS 1k1+WS31 V \-d S /`d- V /`d-dxDw�\-/* Z*j Y*W1ZnVSy a1Y1yZmy +S4Z1a ]`\-\O

`1WE YZ1 ab*W\ ab`*jZ\ 4* Z*j1 +d/dk11EP ]`SO4Z*1baq ˙3\Z*b*ZDP 4O4* oV\Z\YSh1aV\-\ V`S4SOa* Ym \ab*WSan ZS a h1YD ob\ ]\aW1 6> W1b bq31OW\-\ b`d/*I �m a 31Z\y ab*WS aa\`Sbnaq S4O4*/1Z1-D �m /*31 Z1 Y\-WS ,\a]\Wn4\,*bnaq V`1/SbOZ\y V*`b\yE ]\b\Yd hb\ +\qWSanE hb\ ]W*b13 +d/1b\bVW\Z1ZDW*-\/*`q S+WSS S a,qb\Yd /dfd Ym aY\-WS

]`SZqbn Yd/`m1 `1j1ZSqD ) Z*dhSWaq +`*bnaq 4*Wp+dp `*+\bdE S Ym a\V`*bSWS ,a1 Z1Zd3Zm1 `*aOf\/mD �*a b*V31 ]\//1`3S,*WS Z*jS /`d4nqE V\b\O`m1E V*V S YmE�,S/1b1WS1-\,mD �\-/* +mW\ \a\O+1ZZ\ bq31W\E \ZS ,a1-/* ]\Y\-*WS Z*Y S Z1 /*,*OWS ]*abn /df\YxD

� �1V\b\`m1 SY1Z* , ob\y ab*bn1 S4Y1Z1ZmD

��˚"˚��˚ � � �˙��˚ � ˚�)�a1f +1/ Z1 ]1`1hSaWSbnD *aaY\b`SY WSjn h1bm`1 aSbd*gSSE d]\YqZdbm1 `*Z11D�+`*bSb1 ,ZSY*ZS1 Z* b\E V*V Wp/SE Z*f\/qan , b`d/Zmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*fEZ*jWS Z*ab\qk11 db1j1ZS1 \b �\-*D

w) Z*dhSWaq +`*bnaq 4* Wp+dp `*+\bdES Ym a\V`*bSWS ,a1 Z1Zd3Zm1 `*af\/mxL˙3\Z*b*ZM

Page 7: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: ;

��˛��˙

w�\-/* Yd3 Z1\3S/*ZZ\ +`\aSW Y1ZqE ]1`,\y`1*VgS1y +mWS -Z1, S \+S/*EP ,a]\YSZ*1b �*OV1WnDP) +mW* V`*yZ1 ]\/*,W1Z*D �\ q SaV*W* ]\/O/1`3VS d \-*E S \Z db1jSW Y1ZqD ˚31/Z1,Zm1 Y\OWSb,m ]`SZ1aWS YZ1 /dj1,Zmy ]\V\yD ) ]\hd,Oab,\,*W*Ehb\ \- Sag1WSW Y\1 S4`*Z1ZZ\1 a1`/g1DW*-\/*`q 1-\ �W\,dE S+WSSE q aY\-W* ]\+\O

`\bn -Z1, S \+S/dD �Z1 \h1Zn ]\Y\- a\,1b *]\ab\OW* �*,W* S4 �SYWqZ*Y 56B65B t�1 +d/n ]\+13/1Z4W\YE Z\ ]\+13/*y 4W\ /\+`\YrD�/SZ /df\,Z\ 4`1Wmy f`SabS*ZSZ ]\Y\- YZ1 ]\O

ZqbnE hb\ Zd3Z\3Sbn /*Wnj1D �Z ]\V*4*W YZ1 aW\O,* S4 'VVW14S*ab* 7B: S ]\O/\+`\Yd Z*]\YZSWE hb\]\`\y Zd3Z\ tYS`Sbnaq a ]\b1`1yrD �`SZqbn b*V\ya\,1b +mW\ Z1]`\ab\E Z\ SY1ZZ\ , Z1Y q Zd3/*OW*anD�1]1`n , Y\1y 3S4ZS ]\q,SWSan Z\,m1 g1WSxDw�\-/* +`*V `*a]*/*1baqE bm \h1Zn Zd3/*1jnaq

, ]\//1`3V1EP -\,\`Sb 'WS4*+1bDP � Y1Zq 1abn+WS4V*q ]\/`d-*E V\b\`*q ab*W* /Wq Y1Zq V*V `*4b*V\y ]\//1`3V\yD �Z* ]W*V*W* ,Y1ab1 a\ YZ\yEdb1j*W* Y1Zq S /1W*W* ,a1E hb\+m q hd,ab,\,*W*a1+q Wp+SY\yE * Z1 \b,1`-Zdb\yD ) d,1`1Z*E hb\h1`14 Z11 1-\,* Sag1WSW Y\S /dj1,Zm1 `*ZmxD

�� ˚˛�& � �������&

� dSa*E \ V\b\`\Y d]\YSZ*W\an ,Z*h*W1E a1O`n14Zm1 ]`\+W1Ym a a1`/g1YD ˙,* `*4* \Z hdbn Z1dY1`D �1-\/Zq dSa Zd3/*1baq , SaVdaab,1ZZ\y]\/*h1 VSaW\`\/* 5: h*a\, , adbVSD w) ]\ab\qZZ\Y\Wpan 1-\,1EP -\,\`Sb \ZDP �\Y\WS,jSanE qhd,ab,dpE hb\ \- ]\//1`3S,*1b Y1Zq a ]\Y\knpa,\1-\ /df*D �\WSb,* /*1b YZ1 Yd31ab,\ +\`\bnOaq 4* 3S4ZnE ]\b\Yd hb\ q b,1`/\ 4Z*pE hb\ \-1abn S q 1Yd Z1+14`*4WSh1ZxDw) +m YZ\-\1 f\b1W* /1W*bnE Z\ Z1 Y\-dEP -\,\O

`Sb �1b`*E V\b\`\y 4* <>DP �q31W\ a\4Z*,*bnE hb\aSW ab*Z\,Sbaq ,a1 Y1Znj1D �\y \`-*ZS4Y Sab\Ok1ZE S q Z1 Y\-d \+f\/Sbnaq +14 W1V*`ab,D ) h*Oab\ ,a]\YSZ*pE V*V Sada ]`\aSW a,\1-\�bg*E 1aOWS ,\4Y\3Z\E S4+*,Sbn 1-\ \b Sa]mb*ZSqD �\ ,Y1Oab\ ob\-\ 1-\,* dV`1]SWSada*D \- dV`1]Wq1b SY1ZqD �\WSb,* P Y\1 131/Z1,Z\1 W1V*`ab,\D �\aOW1 `*4-\,\`* a \-\Y q hd,ab,dp a1+q -\`*4/\ WdhOj1x L�*be1q 6:B7=MD

w�\`\y Zd3Z\ tYS`Sbnaq a ]\b1`1yrD �DDD��1]1`n , Y\1y 3S4ZS ]\q,SWSan Z\,m1g1WSx L *V1WnM

w�\Y\WS,jSanE q hd,ab,dpE hb\ �\-]\//1`3S,*1b Y1Zq a ]\Y\knpa,\1-\ /df*x L�dSaM

Page 8: Где найти утешение?

< ��� �˝˚�) �"�)

� obSY a\-W*a1Z �dWS*ZE V\b\`my d31 ]\hbS7> W1b 3S,1b a `*aa1qZZmY aVW1`\4\Y�D w) aY1OZSW /S`1Vb\`aV\1 V`1aW\ Z* SZ,*WS/Z\1EP -\,\O`Sb \ZDP �\ Y\q 3S4Zn Z1 ]\b1`qW* aYmaW*E ,1/n\Z* ]\a,qk1Z* aWd31ZSp /`d-SYD �\-/* ]\Y\-*O1jn Wp/qYE a*Y\Yd ab*Z\,Sbaq W1-h1D ) d+1/SWaqEhb\ 1-\,* ,1`1Z a,\1Yd \+1k*ZSp dV`1]Wqbn Z*a, b`d/Zm1 ,`1Y1Z*D �*V S *]\ab\W �*,1WE q Y\-daV*4*bnB w�a1 YZ1 ]\/ aSWd +W*-\/*`q b\YdE Vb\ Y1OZq dV`1]Wq1bx L�SWS]]Syg*Y 8B57MD

� �*aa1qZZmy aVW1`\4 P ob\ `*aab`\yab,\ g1Zb`*WnZ\y Z1`,Z\yaSab1YmD �`S ob\Y `*aab`\yab,1 ]\ab1]1ZZ\ dfd/j*1baq a]\a\+OZ\abn ]\//1`3S,*bn `*,Z\,1aS1E \bV*4m,*pb `dVS S Z\-SC SZ\-/*Z*`dj*1baq 4`1ZS1E `1hn SWS a]\a\+Z\abn ]\ZSY*bnD

���˚�) � �˛����

w�\-/* q d4Z*WE hb\ Y\1-\ \bg* a+SW* Y*jSZ*Eq ,Z*h*W1 ob\Yd Z1 ]\,1`SWEP ,a]\YSZ*1b �Zb\OZS\DP 'b\ +mW\ b*V Z1a]`*,1/WS,\E ,1/n ,a1 aWdOhSW\an Z1 ]\ 1-\ ,SZ1I �\ q ZSh1-\ Z1 Y\- S4Y1OZSbnD �qbn /Z1y \Z ]`\+mW , V\Y1E * ]\b\Y dY1`D�Z1 ab\SW\ \-`\YZmf daSWSy a/1`3*bnaq ]`S Y*OY1E Z\ V*V b\WnV\ q \ab*Waq \/SZE q `*4`m/*WaqDt�d ]\h1Yd ob\ ]`\S4\jW\HIrP ob\b ,\]`\a Z1 ,mOf\/SW d Y1Zq S4 -\W\,mD� b\ d3*aZ\1 ,`1Yq q dY\WqW 1-\,d ]\Y\hn YZ1

a]`*,Sbnaq a oY\gSqYS S \+`1abS /dj1,Zmy ]\OV\yD �\ ,`1Y1Z1Y YZ1 ab*W\ W1-h1D ) Z*]\YSZ*Wa1+1 +S+W1yaVdp SabSZdE hb\ t,`1Yq S aWdh*yrY\31b ]\abShn V*3/\-\ S4 Z*aD ) 4Z*pE hb\ \-Z1 Y\31b W-*bnE S ]\ob\Yd d,1`1ZE hb\ Y\y \b1g,\aV`1aZ1b S Ym aZ\,* ,ab`1bSYaqx L'VVW14S*ab=B55C \*ZZ* 55B69C �Sbd 5B6MD� �\+1`b*E \ V\b\`\Y -\,\`SW\an , ]1`,\y ab*O

bn1E b*VS1 31 hd,ab,*D �Z /1WSbaqB w�m a 31Z\y\kdbSWS , /dj1 YS`E \ V\b\`\Y -\,\`Sbaq , �SOWS]]Syg*Y 8B:E ;D ,a1 ob\ +W*-\/*`q Y\WSb,*YV 1-\,1D �d,ab,dq ,Zdb`1ZZ11 a]\V\yab,S1E YmaY\-WS `*aaV*4*bn 3d`Z*WSab*Y \ Z*j1y Z*/13O/1 Z* ,\aV`1a1ZS1D �\bq *,S*V*b*ab`\e* dZ1aW*3S4Zn Z*j1-\ amZ*E d Z*a \ab*W\an YZ\-\ b1]OWmf ,\a]\YSZ*ZSy \ ,`1Y1ZSE ]`\,1/1ZZ\Y ,Y1Oab1D �* ZSf Ym S ab*`*1Yaq a\a`1/\b\hS,*bnaqD�*jS /`d4nq S4 f`SabS*ZaV\-\ a\+`*ZSq d/S,SO

WSanE d,S/1, ]\ b1W1,S4\`dE a V*VSY a]\V\yab,S1YYm -\,\`SWS \ a,\1y ,1`1D �m \+lqaZSWS SYE hb\ob\ ab*W\ ,\4Y\3ZmY b\WnV\ ]\b\YdE hb\ YZ\-S14* Z*a Y\WSWSanD ) d+13/1ZE hb\ 1-\,* ]\//1`O3*W Z*a h1`14 ,a1f obSf ]`1V`*aZmf Wp/1y S SfaW\,* db1j1ZSqxD�*V ]\V*4m,*pb ]`S,1/1ZZm1 ]`SY1`mE \-

Y\31b db1jSbn , a*Ymf `*4Zmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*fD� Y\31b WS \Z db1jSbn WShZ\ ,*aH d/nb1 d,1`1OZmB a V*V\y +m b`d/Z\abnp ,m ZS ab\WVZdWSanEdb1j1ZS1 `q/\Y�D �*V ]\h1Yd +m Z1 ]\]`\aSbn 1O-\,d \ ]\Y\kSH �\YZSb1B \Z w\- ,aqV\-\ db1j1OZSqx L6 �\`SZeqZ*Y 5B7MD ˇ

� ˚aWS ,m f\bSb1 ab*bn +WS31 V \-d S ]\WdhSbn db1j1ZS1E \+`*ObSb1an V �,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m , ,*j1y Y1abZ\abS SWS Z*]SjSb1]SanY\ , +WS3*yjSy eSWS*WD

w�\bq *,S*V*b*ab`\e* dZ1aW* 3S4ZnZ*j1-\ amZ*E d Z*a \ab*W\an YZ\-\b1]Wmf ,\a]\YSZ*ZSy \ ,`1Y1ZSE]`\,1/1ZZ\Y ,Y1ab1x L \+1`bM

Page 9: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: =

˙��˙ ]mb*1baq ]`\bSaZdbnaq aV,\4n b\W]d+1-dkSf Z* Z1-\ ,\SZ\,D �f,*h1ZZm1 ab`*O

f\YE obS Wp/S , ]*ZSV1 \babd]*pb a ]\Wq a`*31OZSqD �b\ 31 Sf b*V Z*]d-*W\H �a1 ,\SZm , d3*a1]\,b\`qpb \/Z\ S b\ 31 aW\,\D 'b\ SYq h1W\,1V*D ,\b , /\WSZ1 ˙*,S/ ,S/Sb b\-\ a*Y\-\ h1W\,1V*D�Z ab\Sb a /1`4VSY ,S/\YE 4*Y1bZ\ ,\4,mj*qanZ*/ ,a1YS \ab*WnZmYSD �\4Y\3Z\E ob\ a*Ymy ,mOa\VSy h1W\,1VE V\b\`\-\ V\-/*OWS+\ ,S/1W ˙*,S/D'b\ �\WS*eI �1]1`n ]\ZqbZ\E ]\h1Yd ,\SZm +mO

WS b*V Z*]d-*ZmD �\WS*e +mW Z1,1`\qbZ\ \-`\YOZmY P Z*ab\qkSy h1W\,1VO-\`*I ˙*31 +14 a,\OSf dab`*j*pkSf /\a]1f\, \Z ,1aSWE ,\4Y\3Z\E+\Wnj1 /,df V`d]Zmf Yd3hSZD � b\Yd 31 \Z +mWf\`\j\ ,\\`d31ZC ob\ +mW Z1\+mh*yZ\ aSWnZmyE\]mbZmy ,\SZD ob\b -`\4Zmy ,1WSV*Z +`\a*1b,m4\,D �`1/ab*,nb1E V*V 1-\ Y\-dhSy -\W\a of\Y`*4Z\aSbaq ]\ ,a1y \V`d-1E V\-/* \Z -WdYSbaq Z*/S4`*SWnaVSYS ,\SZ*YS S Sf g*`1YE�*dW\YD�Z Z*OaY1jWS,\ ]`1/W*-*1b Wp+\Yd aY1Wnh*Vd ,mabdO]Sbn ,]1`1/ S a`*4Sbnaq a ZSY \/SZ Z* \/SZE `1OjS, b1Y a*YmY Saf\/ +Sb,mI L5 �*YdSW* 5;B8P5>MD4`*SWnbqZ1 b`qadbaq \b ab`*f*D �*`n �*dW Z*O

]d-*Z /\ aY1`bSD V*V d4Z*W ˙*,S/E b*V*q *bOY\ae1`* , W*-1`1 g*`Sb d31 +\Wnj1 Y1aqg*I ˙,1*`YSSE *`YSq eSWSabSYWqZ S *`YSq S4`*SWnbqZEab\qb Z*]`\bS, /`d- /`d-* S Z1 a/,S-*pbaq a Y1Oab*E , b\ ,`1Yq V*V �\WS*e /1Zn 4* /Z1Y ]\,b\`qO1b a,\S d-`\4mD ˙*,S/ \h1Zn `*aab`\1ZD �*V 31dZS4Sb1WnZ\ a\4Z*,*bnE hb\ S4`*SWnaVSy g*`n S1-\ ,\SZmE ,VWph*q b`1f ab*`jSf +`*bn1, ˙*,SO/*E b`qadbaq \b ab`*f*I ˙*,S/ ,\a]`SZSY*W Z*OaY1jVS �\WS*e* Z1 ]`\ab\ V*V \aV\`+W1ZS1 S4O

`*SWnaV\-\ ,\yaV*E * V*V \aV\`+W1ZS1 \-* 4O`*SWqE 1-\,mI �\ hb\ Y\- a/1W*bn ˙*,S/E ob\b]`\ab\y pZ\j*H h1Yd Ym Y\31Y Z*dhSbnaq Z*1-\ ]`SY1`1H L5 �*YdSW* 5;B55P58MD

w���˝& ˚��E ���� ��� '�� ��Ix

˙*,*yb1 d4Z*1YE hb\ ]`\S4\jW\ 4* Z1aV\WnOV\ Y1aqg1, /\ ob\-\D �*VOb\ ,1h1`\Y ˙*,S/ ]*a\,1g a,\1-\ \bg* Z* -\`Sabmf aVW\Z*f Z1]\/*W1OVd \b �SeW11Y*D � b\ ,`1Yq ˙*,S/ +mW 1k1 \h1ZnY\W\/D �1`1/ Z*YS ab*bZmyE `dYqZmy pZ\j* aV`*aS,mYSE dYZmYS -W*4*YSD � h*am \b/mf* \ZWp+Sb S-`*bn Z* *`e1D �`*a\b* \3nSf b,\`1ZSy,/\fZ\,Wq1b 1-\D �Z YZ\-\ d]`*3Zq1baq S a\ ,`1OY1Z1Y ab*Z\,Sbaq SaVdaZmYYd4mV*Zb\YD �\ , b\b,1h1` 1Yd ]`SjW\an \ab*,Sbn ,a1 a,\S 4*ZqbSqE]\b\Yd hb\ 1-\ a`\hZ\ f\b1W ,S/1bn \b1g L5 �*YdOSW* 5:B56MD�`S/q /\Y\yE \Z d,S/1WE hb\ 1-\ \b1gE 1aO

a1yE +1a1/d1b a V*VSYOb\ ab*`g1YD 'b\ +mW ,1`OZmy ]`\`\V �*YdSWD 1-\,* ]\`dhSW 1Yd ]\Y*O4*bn \/Z\-\ S4 amZ\,1y 1aa1q Z* g*`ab,\E hb\+mb\b ab*W aW1/dpkSY g*`1Y 4`*SWqD �*YdSW d31,ab`1bSWaq a a1Ynp ab*`jSYS +`*bnqYS ˙*,S/*EZ\ 1-\,* qaZ\ /*W 1Yd ]\ZqbnE hb\ Z1 ,m+`*W ZS\/Z\-\ S4 ZSfD �\-/* 31 ]`Sj1W ˙*,S/E 1-\O,* aV*4*W �*YdSWdB w�\Y*3n 1-\E ]\b\Yd hb\ ob\\ZIx �* ,S/d d ab*`jSf amZ\,1y 1aa1q �*YdSW\bV`mW `\-E Z*]\WZ1ZZmy \a\+mY Y*aW\YE S ,mOWSW Z1YZ\-\ Z* -\W\,d ˙*,S/*D 'b\b Y\Y1Zb ab*W]1`1W\YZmY , 3S4ZS pZ\jSD � S+WSS -\,\`SbOaqB w� b\-\ /Zq /df 1-\,m ab*W ,\4/1yab,\,*bnZ* ˙*,S/*x L5 �*YdSW* 5:B5E 9P57MD

��˙ ˝•�˚ �� �˚ ˚ � ˙��˙

w'b\P+Sb,* �1-\,mx

Page 10: Где найти утешение?

5> ��� �˝˚�) �"�)

�aV`d3SWS WS ˙*,S/d -\W\,d YmaWS \ g*`aV\y,W*abSH �1bE \Z +mW -\b\, 3/*bnE ]\V* /df 1-\O,m Z1 ]\V*31b 1YdE hb\ ]`SjW\ ,`1Yq Sa]\WZqbn\+q4*ZZ\abS g*`qD � ]\V* \Z ,1`ZdWaq V a,\1YdaV`\YZ\Yd 4*ZqbSp S ]`\/\W3SW ]*abS \,1gD ˙*O,S/ \bZ\aSWaq V ob\Yd /1Wd a +\Wnj\y ]`1/*ZZ\OabnpSYd31ab,\YD ˙,*3/m ab*/* 1-\ \bg* ]\/,1`O-*WSan \]*aZ\abSB \/SZ `*4 Z* ZSf Z*]*W W1,E */`d-\y `*4 P Y1/,1/nD ˙*,S/ Z1 ]`\ab\ \b\-Z*W/SVSf 4,1`1yE Z\ ,abd]SW a ZSYS , af,*bVdE 4*kSOk*q +1a]\Y\kZmf \,1h1V a,\1-\ \bg*D \+* `*4*\Z -\WmYS `dV*YS d+SW obSf a,S`1]mf fSkZSV\,IL5 �*YdSW* 5;B78P7:C a*Sq 75B8MD�1`14 Z1V\b\`\1 ,`1Yq ˙*,S/* aZ\,* ]\4,*WSD

�\W,* \ Z1Y /\jW* /\ g*`q �*dW*D �\bq �*dW ,a11k1 +mW \b,*3ZmY ,\SZ\YE \Z ]\b1`qW \/\+`1OZS1 1-\,mE ]\y/q Z*]1`1V\` 1-\ dV*4*ZSqYD 1O-\,* WSjSW �*dW* a,\1-\ /df*E S ]\ob\Yd g*`1Yh*ab\ \,W*/1,*W 4W\y /dfB -Z1,E ]\/\4`1ZS1 S 31Oab\V\abnD � b*VS1 YSZdbm 1-\ Y\-W* da]\V\SbnWSjn Yd4mV*D �`S+WS31ZZm1 �*dW* d4Z*WSE hb\˙*,S/ P f\`\jSy Yd4mV*Zb S aY1Wmy ,\SZD �\oOb\Yd ˙*,S/* ]\4,*WS V g*`pE S ,aV\`1 \Z ab*W]`S/,\`ZmY Yd4mV*Zb\Y S \`d31Z\ag1Y L5 �*YdOSW* 59B6:P6=C 5:B58P67MD�a1 YmE , \a\+1ZZ\abS pZ\jS S /1,djVSE Y\O

31Y YZ\-\Yd Z*dhSbnaq Z* ]`SY1`1 ˙*,S/*D ˛*OY1bnb1E hb\ a,\1 a,\+\/Z\1 ,`1Yq \Z ]\a,qk*W 4*OZqbSqYE V\b\`m1 ]`S+WS3*WS 1-\ V 1-\,1D �`\OY1 b\-\E \Z b1`]1WS,\ \a,*S,*W Z*,mVSE V\b\`m1,]\aW1/ab,SS ]\Y\-WS 1Yd +mab`\ dab`\Sbnaq ,3S4ZSD �\ a*Y\1 -W*,Z\1E \Z \bVWSV*Waq Z* `dOV\,\/ab,\ /df* 1-\,mD 'b\ ]`1V`*aZmy ]`SY1`/Wq ,a1f Z*aI L'VVW14S*ab 56B5MD

w���& �� ���� �˚ ˙����˚� �˚�˙�˚x

�\bq ˙*,S/ +mW Z* aWd3+1 d �*dW*E \Z h*ab\,\4,`*k*Waq /\Y\yE SZ\-/* Z* /WSb1WnZ\1 ,`1YqEhb\+m ]*abS \,1gD �*V `*4 , \/SZ S4 b*VSf ]1O`S\/\, 1aa1y ]\]`\aSW ˙*,S/* ]`\,1/*bn b`1fab*`jSf +`*bn1,E V\b\`m1 aWd3SWS , ,\yaV1 �*dOW*D �4q, a a\+\y ]`S]*am /Wq a,\Sf +`*bn1,E ˙*O,S/ ]\aWdjZ\ \b]`*,SWaq , /\WSZd W*D �*Y 1-\d/S,SW\ S4,1abS1 \ b\YE hb\ /,1 ,`*3/dpkS1 *`OYSS Z1 ]`1/]`SZSY*pb ZSV*VSf /1yab,SyE V*V \+ob\Y -\,\`SW\an , Z*h*W1 ab*bnSD �ZS ,mab`\SO

WSan /`d- ]`\bS, /`d-* Z* ]`\bS,\]\W\3Zmf +1O`1-*f jS`\V\yE S4,SWSab\y /\WSZm L5 �*YdSW*5;B5P7E 59P5=MD�*V\1 ]\W\31ZS1 /1W ,\4YdbSW\ ˙*,S/*D �*V

Y\-W* *`YSq 3S,\-\ \-*E 1-\,mE , d3*a1 d+1O-*bn \b \+mhZ\-\ h1W\,1V*E ]`Sb\Y q4mhZSV*HI˙*,S/ ,\a]`SZqW Z*aY1jVS �\WS*e* V*V \aV\`+OW1ZS1E Z*]`*,W1ZZ\1 ]`\bS, a*Y\-\ 1-\,mD �\Oob\Yd \Z ab*W ,1abS `*4-\,\`m a ,\SZ*YS \ b\YEhb\ Zd3Z\ a`*4Sbnaq a �\WS*e\YD �+ ob\Y daWmOj*W ˚WS*,E ab*`jSy +`*b ˙*,S/*D ˚WS*, \b`d-*W˙*,S/*E \+,SZS, 1-\ , b\YE hb\ \Z ]`Sj1W ]`\ab\`*4,W1hnaq S ]\-Wq/1bn Z* 4`1WSk1D �* ob\ ˙*,S/aV*4*WB w�b\ q b*V\-\ a/1W*WH �*4,1 q Z1 Y\-da]`\aSbnHx ab*W aZ\,* -\,\`Sbn a Wp/nYS \ b\YEhb\+m \/\W1bn �\WS*e*D �+ obSf `*4-\,\`*f /\OZ1aWS �*dWdE S ˙*,S/* ]\4,*WS V g*`p L5 �*YdSW*5;B67P75MD�\b V*VS1 ,\\/dj1,WqpkS1 aW\,* ˙*,S/ aV*O

4*W g*`pB w�dabn ZS d V\-\ Z1 /`\-Z1b a1`/g1xD� /1yab,Sb1WnZ\abS 31 a1`/g1 �*dW* S 1-\ Wp/1y/`\-ZdW\ ]1`1/ �\WS*e\YD �V\`11 ,a1-\E \ZS ]\O]*WSan , bS]ShZdpW\,djVdB ab*WS a`*,ZS,*bn a1O+q a obSY Sa]\WSZ\YE ]\ZSY*qE hb\ 1/,* /\ab*pb

�ap h1abn 4* ]\+1/d Z*/ a,S`1]mYS fSkZSV*YS˙*,S/ aV`\YZ\ ,\4/*W �1-\,1

Page 11: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: 55

1Yd /\ ]\qa*D � a,\1Y ,\\+`*31ZSS \ZS d31 ,S/1OWSE V*V ob\b ,\\`d31ZZmy /\ 4d+\, ,1WSV*Z `*aO]`*,Wq1baq a ZSYS \/Z\y W1,\yD �\ ˙*,S/ YmaOWSW ]\O/`d-\YdD �Z aY\b`1W Z* ]`\Saf\/qk11 ,a\,1`j1ZZ\ SZ\Y a,1b1 S ]\ob\Yd ,m4,*Waq a`*O4Sbnaq a �\WS*e\Y L5 �*YdSW* 5;B76MD�*dW ,\4`*4SW ˙*,S/dB w�m Z1 Y\31jn ,mybS

]`\bS, ob\-\ eSWSabSYWqZSZ* S a`*4Sbnaq a ZSYD�1/nbmPY*WnhSjV*E * \Z Sa]mb*ZZmy ,\SZxD �\b*VSY WS d3 pZmY +mW ˙*,S/H �1bE ]`\ab\ \Z+mW aWSjV\Y Y\W\/ /Wq ,\1ZZ\y aWd3+m S V b\OYd 31 ,m-Wq/1WE aV\`11 ,a1-\E Y\W\31 a,\Sf W1bD�/Z*V\ Z* b\b Y\Y1Zb d ˙*,S/* d31 +mW* `1]db*OgSq f`*+`\-\ ,\SZ* S 1YdE ,\4Y\3Z\E +mW\ \V\W\/,*/g*bS W1b L5 �*YdSW* 5:B5<C 5;B77E �\,`1Y1ZOZmy ]1`1,\/MD˙*,S/ 4*,1`SW �*dW*E hb\ a]`*,SbaqE `*aaV*4*,

\ b\YE V*V d+SW Wn,* S Y1/,1/qD �,*ab*Waq WS \ZH�1bD ˙*,S/ 4Z*WE +W*-\/*`q h1Yd \Z \/1`3*W ]\O+1/dD �\b 1-\ aW\,*B w1-\,*E S4+*,S,jSy Y1Zq \bW*] Wn,* S Y1/,1/qE S4+*,Sb Y1Zq S \b `dVS ob\-\eSWSabSYWqZSZ*xD 'b\ d+1/SW\ �*dW*E S \Z Z*V\OZ1g aV*4*WB w/S S ]dabn a b\+\y +d/1b 1-\,*xL5 �*YdSW* 5;B7;MD�\b1W\an +m ,*Y SY1bn b*Vdp 31 V`1]Vdp ,1`dE

V*V d ˙*,S/*H �\-/* 4*Y1bnb1E hb\ ˙*,S/ Z1 +mWZ*S,ZmY Y1hb*b1W1YD ˚-\ ,1`* , \-* \aZ\,m,*OW*an Z* 4Z*ZSS S \]mb1D �Z 4Z*WE hb\ 1-\,* PZ*/13Zmy ˛*kSbZSV S a]\WZSb1Wn a,\Sf \+1Ok*ZSyD ˚aWS Ym f\bSY `*4,Sbn b*Vdp 31 ,1`dEZ*Y Zd3Z\ +\Wnj1 d4Z*,*bn \ \-1E \ V\b\`\Y -\O,\`Sbaq , S+WSSD 1aWS Ym +d/1Y 3Sbn , a\O-W*aSS a ]\Wdh1ZZmYS 4Z*ZSqYSE Ym aY\31Y Z*a\+ab,1ZZ\Y \]mb1 d+1/Sbnaq , \3n1y ]\//1`O3V1E S ob\E , a,\p \h1`1/nE dV`1]Sb Z*jd ,1`d L˚,O`1qY 55B5MD

w�˚���� ��˙��� �˚�) � �� ���x

�*dW `1jSW \+W*hSbn ˙*,S/* , a,\S /\aO]1fSD�ZS +mWS a/1W*Zm S4 Y1/S S ]\f\3S Z* /\aO]1fS �\WS*e*D �V\`11 ,a1-\E ˙*,S/d b*V31 /*WS+\Wnjdp V\Wnhd-dE SWS `d+*jVd S4 Y1b*WWSh1OaVSf ]W*abSZD ˙*,S/ ]\]mb*Waq ]\f\/Sbn , obSf-`\Y\4/VSf S bq31Wmf /\a]1f*fE Z\ +mab`\ ]\OZqWE hb\ ZSh1-\ f\`\j1-\ S4 ob\-\ Z1 ,my/1bD �ZZ1 +mW \+dh1ZZmY ,\SZ\Y S ]\ob\Yd Z1 ]`S,mV

Z\aSbn +\1,m1 /\a]1fSD �1Y +\W11 hb\ /\a]1fS�*dW* +mWS 1Yd ,1WSVSE ,1/n �*dW +mW a*YmY ,mOa\VSY h1W\,1V\Y , 4`*SW1I L5 �*YdSW* =B6MD ˙*O,S/ aZqW /\a]1fS S Z*/1W a,\p ]`S,mhZdp \/13O/dE , V\b\`\y ]*a \,1g L5 �*YdSW* 5;B7<P8>MD˙*,S/ ,4qW ]\a\fE ]*abdj1aVdp adYVd S ]`*kdD

�1-\/Zq ]`*k\yE ,\4Y\3Z\E ZSV\-\ Z1 Z*]d-*1jnEZ\ , b1 ,`1Y1Z* ob\ +mW\ -`\4Z\1 \`d3S1D �`*k*]`1/ab*,WqW* a\+\y /WSZZmy `1Y1j\V SWS ,1`1,OVd a Z1+\WnjSY wV*`Y*jV\Yx ]\a1`1/SZ1 S +mW*S/1*WnZmY \`d3S1Y ]*abdf*D �*abdf ]\Y1k*W ,wV*`Y*j1Vx V*Y1Zn S `*aV`dhS,*W ]`*kd Z*/ -\OW\,\y /\ \-`\YZ\y aV\`\abSD ˛*b1Y \Z \b]daV*W\/SZ V\Z1gE S V*Y1Zn W1b1W b\hZ\ , g1WnE Z* ]\`*O31ZS1D �`*k* +mW* Z*ab\WnV\ oee1VbS,ZmY \`dO3S1YEhb\ , Z1V\b\`mf *`YSqf +mWS g1Wm1 \b`q/m]`*kZSV\,Db*VE ,\\`d3S,jSanE ˙*,S/ +mW -\b\, ,ab`1O

bSbnaq a ,`*-\YD �\3Z\ a1+1 ]`1/ab*,SbnE V*V -\O`qh\ \Z Y\WSWaqE f\/q ]\ adf\Yd `daWd `1VS , /\OWSZ1 S ,m+S`*q ]qbn Z1+\WnjSf -W*/VSf V*YZ1yD˛*b1Y \Z ,mj1WE aV\`11 /*31 ,m+13*WE Z* ]\W1+Sb,mD�*V \b`1*-S`\,*W �\WS*eE d,S/1, a,\1-\ ]`\O

bS,ZSV*H �Z wa ]`14`1ZS1Y ]\aY\b`1W Z* Z1-\E]\b\Yd hb\ b\b +mW Y\W\/E `dYqZ S V`*aS,xD �\WSO*e ]`\`mh*WB w) hb\E a\+*V*E hb\ bm S/1jn Z* Y1OZq a ]*WV*YSHx �h1,S/Z\E \Z d,S/1W b\WnV\ ]\a\f˙*,S/* S Z1 4*Y1bSW 1-\ ]`*kdD �\WS*e ]`\VWqW˙*,S/* eSWSabSYaVSYS +\-*YS S ]\VWqWaq aV\`OYSbn 1-\ b`d] ]bSg*Y S ]\W1,mY 4,1`qY L5 �*YdOSW* 5;B85P88MD ]\ a1y /1Zn aW\,* ˙*,S/* \ab*pbaq ]`SY1`\Y

]`\q,W1ZSq ,m/*pk1yaq ,1`mD�\WnV\ ]`1/ab*,nOb1E V*V pZmy ˙*,S/ V`ShSb �\WS*edB w�m S/1jnZ* Y1Zq a Y1h\YE V\]n1Y S /`\bSV\YE * q S/d aSY1Z1Y 1-\,m ,\SZab,E \-* ,\yaV* 4`*SWqEZ*/ V\b\`mY bm Z*aY1f*1jnaqxD ˙*,S/ ]\ZSY*WEhb\ h1W\,1h1aV*q aSW* S \`d3S1 Y*W\ hb\ `1j*pb, ob\y +Sb,1D �\WS*e \aV\`+SW \-* 1-\,dE S1-\,* \+q4*b1WnZ\ \b,1bSb Z* ob\b ,m4\,D �*VaV*4*W ˙*,S/E wob\ P +Sb,* 1-\,mx L5 �*YdSW*5;B89P8;MD˙*,S/E V\Z1hZ\ 31E ,S/1W `*4Y1`m ob\-\ ,1O

WSV*Z* S 1-\ \`d3S1D �\ \Z Z1 ]\4,\WSW a1+q

Page 12: Где найти утешение?

4*]d-*bnD �Z Z1 ]\]*Waq , W\,djVdE , V\b\`dp ]\O]*WSan �*dW S 1-\ ,\SZmD ˙*,S/ Z1 a`*,ZS,*W a1O+q a �\WS*e\YD �Z a`*,ZS,*W �\WS*e* a 1-\,\yD�\ab\Y ]\hbS b`S Y1b`*E �\WS*eE V*V +*jZqE ,\4O,mj*Waq Z*/ ,a1YS \ab*WnZmYS ,\SZ*YSD �\ V*OVSY \Z +mW , a`*,Z1ZSS a �W*/mV\y �a1W1ZZ\yH�*V S Wp+\y /`d-\y h1W\,1VE \Z +mW /Wq 1-\,mZ1 +\W11 h1Y Z*a1V\Y\1E V\b\`\1 W1-V\ `*4/*,SbnI˙*,S/ `SZdWaq Z* a,\1-\ ,`*-*E /\ab*,*q S4 adYO

VS V*Y1ZnD ˛*`q/S, ]`*kdE \Z ab*W Z* +1-d `*aV`dOhS,*bn 11 Z*/ -\W\,\y /\ f*`*Vb1`Z\-\ a,Sab*D �\OWS*e /,SZdWaq Z* ˙*,S/* ]\/ ]`SV`mbS1Y a,\1-\\`d31Z\ag*E V\b\`my /1`3*WkSbD�-`\YZmy `\ab�\WS*e* am-`*W a ZSY 4Wdp jdbVdD ˚-\ \`d31Z\Oa1g +mW \+mhZ\-\ `\ab* S Z1 Y\- ]\/ZqbnkSb b*VEhb\+m ]`SV`mbn -\W\,d ,1WSV*Z*D � SY1ZZ\ bd/*˙*,S/ S g1WSWaq L5 �*YdSW* 5;B85MD˙*,S/ Y1bZdW V*Y1Zn S4 ]`*kSD �\\+`*4Sb1E V*O

V*q ,\g*`SW*an bSjSZ*E V\-/* V*Y1Zn /\abS- a,\O1y g1WSI 1-\,*E +14 a\YZ1ZSqE a/1W*W b*VE hb\ ˙*O,S/d Z1 ]`SjW\an /\ab*,*bn ,b\`\y V*Y1ZnD �*OY1Zn ]\]*W ]`qY\ , q+W\hV\E ,\Z4S,jSan , W\+

�\WS*e*I �1WSV*Z a,*WSWaq Z* 41YWpE WSg\Y,ZS4D �`d31Z\a1gE aV\`11 ,a1-\E +`\aSWaq Z*db1VD˙*,S/ ]\/+13*W V �\WS*edE ,4qW 1-\ Y1h S \b`dO+SW 1Yd -\W\,d L5 �*YdSW* 5;B8<P95MD�*V\Z1g �*dW S 1-\ ,\SZm \+`1WS aY1W\abnD

� -`\YVSY +\1,mY V`SV\Y \ZS dab`1YSWSan Z*eSWSabSYWqZD �a1 4*V\ZhSW\an SY1ZZ\ b*VE V*V SaV*4*W ˙*,S/ �\WS*edB w1-\,*DDD \b/*ab ,*a , Z*OjS `dVSx L5 �*YdSW* 5;B8;E 96E 97MD�1-\/Zq aWd3Sb1WS \-* Z1 dh*ab,dpb , +dVO

,*WnZmf ,\yZ*fD 'b\ \ab*W\an , ]`\jW\Y L�*bOe1q 6:B96MD �\ Ym Y\31Y ]\/`*3*bn ,1`1 ˙*,S/*D1-\,* /\W31Z +mbn /Wq Z*a `1*WnZmY P 1/SZOab,1ZZmYE V\Yd Ym /\W3Zm aWd3Sbn S ]1`1/ V1Yb`1]1b*bnD �\`\y Ym Y\31Y hd,ab,\,*bn a1+q Y*OW1ZnVSYS S Z14Z*hSb1WnZmYS , a`*,Z1ZSS a Z*OjSYS ]`\+W1Y*YSD �\ ,*3Z\ ]\YZSbnE hb\ Z*jS]`\+W1Ym P Y*W1ZnVS1 S Z14Z*hSb1WnZm1 , a`*,OZ1ZSS a +14-`*ZShZ\y aSW\y 1-\,mD ˚aWS 1-\O,* P Z*j \- S Ym ,1`SY , Z1-\E V*V ˙*,S/E b\-/*ZSV*VS1 ]`\+W1Ym S b`d/Z\abS Z1 4*]d-*pb Z*aD˙Wq 1-\,m Z1b ZSh1-\ Z1,\4Y\3Z\-\I ˇ

˙*,S/ 4Z*WE hb\ /*31 ,1WSV*Z , a`*,Z1ZSS a �1-\,\y P Z1 +\Wnj1 h1Y ]mWSZV*

Page 13: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: 57

5 � �1d31WS `\ab h1W\,1V* Y\31b/\abS-*bn 6E= Y1b`*H

� �S+WSS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ `\ab �\WSO*e* +mW wj1abn W\Vb1y a ]q/npxL5 �*YdSW* 5;B8MD �\V\bn a\ab*,WqW88E9 a*ZbSY1b`*E * ]q/n P 66E6 a*ZObSY1b`*D ˛Z*hSbE `\ab �\WS*e* +mW\V\W\ 6E= Y1b`*D �1V\b\`m1 db,1`O3/*pbE hb\ h1W\,1V Z1 Y\31b +mbnb*VSY ,ma\VSYD �\ ]\/dY*yb1B , a\O,`1Y1ZZ\y Sab\`SS a*Ymy ,ma\VSyh1W\,1VE ]\ \eSgS*WnZmY /*ZZmYE+mW `\ab\Y +\W11 6E; Y1b`*D �*VZ1d31WS �\WS*e Z1 Y\- +mbn ]`SOY1`Z\ Z* 6> a*ZbSY1b`\, ,mj1H �Z+mW S4 ]W1Y1ZS `1e*SY\,E V\b\`m1aW*,SWSan a,\SY \-`\YZmY `\ab\YD� 1-S]1baVSf /\VdY1Zb*fE /*bS`d1OYmf XIII ,1V\Y /\ ZD oDE d]\YSZ*pbOaq 3S,jS1 , �*Z**Z1 -`\4Zm1 ,\SOZmE `\ab V\b\`mf ]`1,mj*W 6E8 Y1bO`*D �\ob\Yd /*ZZm1 \ `\ab1 �\WS*e*Ef\bq S Z1\+mhZmE ,]\WZ1 ]`*,/\]\O/\+ZmD

6 � �mW WS ˙*,S/ `1*WnZmYh1W\,1V\YH

*Znj1 dh1Zm1 ahSb*WS g*`q ˙*,S/*YSeSh1aVSY ]1`a\Z*31YE Z\ a1-\/OZq Sab\`ShZ\abn ob\-\ S4`*SWnaV\-\g*`q d31 b`d/Z11 ]\/,1`-Zdbn a\YZ1OZSpD �1 b*V /*,Z\ *`f1\W\-S Z*jOWS /`1,Zpp ab1WdE Z* V\b\`\y ,ma1O

h1Z* Z*/]San a d]\YSZ*ZS1Y w/\Y*˙*,S/*xD �\W11 b\-\E �Sada �`Sab\a-\,\`SW \ ˙*,S/1 V*V \ `1*WnZ\Yh1W\,1V1 L�*be1q 56B7C 66B87P89MD�*V31 /,1 ]\/`\+Zm1 `\/\aW\,Zm1E]\/b,1`3/*pkS1 Y1aaS*Zab,\ �SadOa*E ]\V*4m,*pbE hb\ \Z +mW ]\b\YV\Yg*`q ˙*,S/* L�*be1q 5B:P5:C �dVS7B67P75MD *V ,S/Z\E ˙*,S/ +mW `1O*WnZ\y Sab\`Sh1aV\y WShZ\abnpD

7 � ˙1yab,Sb1WnZ\ WS adk1ab,\O,*W\ b\ Y1ab\E V\b\`\1 \]Sa*Z\, `*aaV*41H

� �S+WSS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ a`*31ZS1]`\S4\jW\ , /\WSZ1 �W*D �\ , a\\+Ok1ZSS dV*4m,*1baq 1k1 S /\]\WZSOb1WnZ*q ]\/`\+Z\abnB eSWSabSYWqOZ1 `*a]\W\3SWSan W*-1`1Y Z* f\WY1Y13/d -\`\/*YS �\f\ S 41V*D �4`*OSWnbqZ1 31 ab\qWS Z* /`d-\Y f\WY1EZ* ]`\bS,\]\W\3Z\y ab\`\Z1 /\WSOZmD ˙1yab,Sb1WnZ\ WS ob\ `1*WnZm1-1\-`*eSh1aVS1 Y1ab*H�+`*bSb1 ,ZSY*ZS1 Z* aW\,* h1O

W\,1V*E V\b\`my Z1/*,Z\ ]\+m,*W ,b\y Y1abZ\abSB w�*j -S/E V\b\`my /*OW1V \b `1WS-SSE ]`S,14 Z*jd -`d]]d ,/\WSZd �W*D �m ]\/ZqWSan ]\ b`\O]1E V\b\`*q ]`S,1W* Z*a Z* ,1`jSOZd f\WY*D �*j1Yd ,4\`d \bV`mW*an,aq /\WSZ*D �S/ ]\]`\aSW Z*a 4*hSO

b*bn 5 �*YdSW* 5;B5P7D ˛*b1Y \Z dV*O4*W `dV\y Z* ]`\bS,\]\W\3Zdp ab\O`\Zd /\WSZm S aV*4*WB t�\Z b*YEaW1,*E Z*f\/qbaq `dSZm �\f\D a]`*O,* P `dSZm 41VSD �SWSabSYWqZ1`*a]\W\3SWSan W*-1`1Y Y13/d obSOYS /,dYq -\`\/*YSE -/1Ob\ Z* b1f f\WOY*fE Z*]`\bS, ,*aD �\ob\Yd Ym a ,*OYS ab\SY Z* b\Y Y1ab1E -/1E ,\4Y\3OZ\E Z*f\/SWaq W*-1`n S4`*SWnbqZrD) ,\\+`*4SWE V*V 4/1an V\-/*Ob\ ab\OqWS �*dW S ˙*,S/D ˛*b1Y Ym a]daObSWSan , /\WSZd S ]1`1a1VWS `daW\`1VSE ]\ +\Wnj1y h*abS ,ma\fj11D�Z\ +mW\ dam]*Z\ V*YZqYSD ) a`*O4d 31 ]`1/ab*,SWE V*V ˙*,S/E a\-Zd,OjSanE ,m+S`*1b 4/1an ]qbn -W*/VSfV*YZ1yE \/ZSY S4 V\b\`mf \Z S d+SW�\WS*e*xD �\/\+Z\ YZ\-SY /`d-SYEob\b bd`Sab +mW -Wd+\V\ ,]1h*bW1Z]\`*4Sb1WnZ\y b\hZ\abnp �S+WSSD*V Ym d,S/1WSE Z1b ZSV*VSf a1O

`n14Zmf \aZ\,*ZSy a\YZ1,*bnaq ,/\ab\,1`Z\abS ob\-\ +S+W1yaV\-\a\+mbSqD �Z\ ]`\Saf\/SW\ , V\ZVO`1bZ\Y -1\-`*eSh1aV\Y Y1ab1E S ,Z1Y dh*ab,\,*WS `1*WnZm1 Wp/SD �\a*Y\1 -W*,Z\1E ob\b `*aaV*4 P h*abn,/\fZ\,W1ZZ\-\ �\-\Y �W\,*D 4Z*OhSbE \Z Saf\/Sb \b �\-* SabSZmEwZ1 Y\-dk1-\ W-*bnx L�Sbd 5B6C 6 �SOY\e1p 7B5:MDˇ

����˚�� ˙���˙� � �� �����mW\ WS ob\ Z* a*Y\Y /1W1H

�1V\b\`m1 /dY*pbE hb\ `*aaV*4 \ ˙*,S/1 S �\WS*e1 P Z1 +\W11 h1Y YSeD˚aWSE hSb*q ]`1/m/dkdp ab*bnpE ,m b\31 a\YZ1,*WSan , ]`*,/S,\abS ob\y Sab\`SSE,ZSY*b1WnZ\ `*aaY\b`Sb1 \b,1bm Z* aW1/dpkS1 b`S ,\]`\a*D

& ˙\WSZ* �W*

�+mhZmy,\SZ

5E; Y1b`*

�\WS*e

6E= Y1b`*

Page 14: Где найти утешение?

58 ��� �˝˚�) �"�)

��˚˙%�����)D ) `\/SWaq , �np/*/O�*Zb1E V`*aS,\Y -\`\/1, jb*b1 �*Y*dWS]*a L�1VaSV*MD � +\WnjSZab,1 a,\1Y Y1abOZm1 3Sb1WS +mWS k1/`mYS S /\+`mYSD �\ V a\3*W1ZSpES4O4* ,ma\V\-\ d`\,Zq ]`1abd]Z\abS 3S4Zn , -\`\/1 +mW*Z1+14\]*aZ\yD) +mW ,b\`mY S4 h1bm`1f amZ\,1y , a1Yn1D �\/Sb1WS V`1O

abSWS Y1Zq , V*b\WSh1aV\y g1`V,SE S ]\4/Z11 q ab*W ]1bn ,g1`V\,Z\Y f\`1D ) f\b1W d-\3/*bn \-dE ]\b\Yd hb\ \h1Znab`*jSWaq \3n1-\ ad/* S +\qWaqE hb\ +d/d ,1hZ\ -\`1bn ,\-Z1D�\-/* YZ1 +mW\ ]qbn W1bE \b1g +`\aSW Z*aD ˙Wq Y1Zq ob\

+mW* Z*ab\qk*q b`*-1/SqD �\aW1 1-\ df\/* , Y\1Y a1`/g1\+`*4\,*W*an ]dab\b*D ) Z1 Y\- ]\ZqbnE ]\h1Yd \Z \ab*,SWZ*aEP Ym 31 1-\ b*V aSWnZ\ Wp+SWSD�b\+m ]`\V\`YSbn Z*aEh1bm`1f Y*WnhSj1VE Y*Y1 ]`Sf\/SW\an YZ\-\ `*+\b*bn ,Z1/\Y*D) ]\Wn4\,*Waq obSY S ]`\-dWS,*W jV\WdE hb\+m ]`\,\/Sbn

,`1Yq , V\Y]*ZSS +\W11 ab*`jSf `1+qbD �ZS Z*dhSWS Y1ZqaV,1`Z\aW\,SbnE Vd`SbnE ,\`\,*bn S /`*bnaqD �Z1 Z`*,SW\an,\ ,a1Y +mbn ]1`,mYE ]\ob\Yd q 4*ZqWaq +\Va\YE +\`n+\y S+\1,mYS SaVdaab,*YSE * b*V31 Z*dhSWaq \+`*k*bnaq a \`dO3S1YD ) ab*W 31ab\VSY ]\/`\abV\YD �1`1/V\ q dh*ab,\,*W ,]1`1ab`1WV*fE S Z1aV\WnV\ `*4 ,a1 4*V*ZhS,*W\an b1YE hb\ q\ab*,*Waq W13*bn Z* dWSg1 , Wd31 V`\,SD �V\WnV\ 31 +\WS q]`ShSZSW a,\1y Y*b1`SI �\-/* \Z* Z*f\/SW* Y1ZqE ]\Wd3SO,\-\E b\ ]\/ZSY*W* S a`\hZ\ ,14W* , +\WnZSgdD�\-/* YZ1 +mW\ 5: W1bE V Z*Y /\Y\y ]`Sj1W /`d- Y\1-\

/1bab,*E �\`f1D �Z aV*4*WE hb\ \Z �,S/1b1Wn 1-\,m S f\h1b]\/1WSbnaq a Z*YS ,*3Z\y SZe\`Y*gS1yD �\`f1 `*aaV*4*WE,\ hb\ ,1`SbE ]\/b,1`3/*q ,a1 +S+W1yaVSYS abSf*YSD �*Znj1q ZSV\-/* Z1 hSb*W S+WSp S \h1Zn \+`*/\,*WaqE d4Z*, \b\YE hb\ d \-* 1abn SYq S ]`1V`*aZmy 4*Yma1WD �\`f1 ]`1/OW\3SW Z*Y S4dh*bn S+WSpE S Ym a\-W*aSWSanD

�� ���) �˛�˚ ����(˝�˛ &D ) ]\hd,ab,\,*W \-`\YOZ\1 \+W1-h1ZS1E V\-/* ]\ZqWE hb\ dh1ZS1 \+ */aV\Y \-Z1 PZ1+S+W1yaV\1 L�a*W\Y 58:B8C 'VVW14S*ab =B9MD ) ]1`1ab*W

�����) �˚�)˚� ˝�˛�&

) +mW \4W\+W1ZZmYS 31ab\VSY

��˛�

�˙���� ˙˚ � �'��˚

��˙ �˝˙˚��)5=;8

�� � �˝˙˚��)˚�����

� � �"����������� � ���%� ˙�����

Page 15: Где найти утешение?

Š9 6>5: 59

]*ZSh1aVS +\qbnaq \-*D �1]1`n q ,\a]`SZSY*p1-\ V*V Wp+qk1-\ �bg*E V\b\`my 31W*1b a,\SY/1bqY a*Y\-\ Wdhj1-\D�\ Y1`1 S4dh1ZSq S+WSS q \a\4Z*WE hb\

YZ1 Z*/\ Y1Zqbn a,\y f*`*Vb1`D �Z1 Zd3Z\ +mW\`*4,S,*bn aYS`1ZS1 S ]\+\`\bn bq-d V Z*aSWSpD�h1Zn ]\Y\- abSf S4 5 �\`SZeqZ*Y 59B77E -/1-\,\`SbaqB w�W\f\1 \+k1ZS1 ]\`bSb ]\W14Zm1]`S,mhVSxD ) ]\ZqWE hb\E 1aWS f\hd S4Y1ZSbna,\y f*`*Vb1`E YZ1 Zd3Z\ ]1`1ab*bn \+k*bnaq aWp/nYSE V\b\`m1 ]W\f\ Z* Y1Zq ,WSqpbD �\ob\OYd q ]\`,*W a\ a,\SYS ab*`mYS /`d3V*YS S ab*WSaV*bn /`d41y , f`SabS*ZaV\Y a\+`*ZSSE a`1/SWp/1yE V\b\`m1 `1j*WS `*4Z\-W*aSq Z1 VdW*V*OYSE * a ]\Y\knp +S+W1yaVSf ]`SZgS]\,D˙`d-\1 Y1ab\ �Sa*ZSqE V\b\`\1 YZ1 ]\Y\-W\E

+mW\ �SYWqZ*Y 56B5;P5=D �*Y aV*4*Z\B w�SV\YdZ1 ,\4/*,*yb1 4W\Y 4* 4W\D �DDD� �*aV\WnV\ ,\4OY\3Z\ a ,*j1y ab\`\ZmE +d/nb1 , YS`1 a\ ,a1YSWp/nYSD �1 YabSb1 4* a1+qDDD ]\b\Yd hb\ Z*]Sa*OZ\B t�k1ZS1 4* YZ\yE q ,\4/*YE -\,\`Sb 1-\O,*rxD ) ]\ZqWEhb\1-\,* a*Y `1jSbE V*V\b,1bSbnZ* Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abn S V\-/*D �\ab1]1ZZ\ YZ1d/*W\an dV`\bSbn a,\y 31ab\VSy Z`*,D�SV\-/* Z1 4*+d/dE hb\ ]`\S4\jW\ \/Z*3/m

,1h1`\Y ]\ /\`\-1 /\Y\yD ˛* YZ\y d,q4*W\anZ1aV\WnV\ ]*`Z1y S4 -`d]]S`\,VSE a V\b\`\y q`*Znj1 ,`*3/\,*WD f -W*,*`n b\WVZdW Y1Zq ,a]SZd S V`SVZdWB w˛*kSk*yaqIx ) V\`\bV\ ]\Y\OWSWaq 1-\,1 \ ]\Y\kSD �\bq d Y1Zq +mW\ \h1ZnaSWnZ\1 31W*ZS1 \b,1bSbn Z* ,m4\,E q aY\- a/1`O3*bnaq S a]\V\yZ\ dybSD �* aW1/dpkSy /1Zn qaZ\,* ,ab`1bSW b\-\ -W*,*`qE Z\ d31 +14 1-\ wa,SObmxD �\ YZ1 ,a1 ,aVS]1W\E S 4*f\b1W\an ]`\dhSbn1-\E Z\ q aZ\,* ]`\ a1+q ]\Y\WSWaq 1-\,1 S ]\O]`\aSW \ a*Y\\+W*/*ZSSD � Y\1Yd d/S,W1ZSpEob\b ]*`1Zn ]\/\j1W V\ YZ1 S aV*4*WB w4,SZS 4*,h1`*jZ11D ˛Z*1jnE q f\hd ab*bn b*VSY 31E V*VbmD ) +m f\b1W S4dh*bn S+WSpxD �*V 31 q +mW`*/E hb\ b\-/* a/1`3*WaqI W*-\/*`q ob\Yd b\b]*`1Zn b\31 Z*h*W S4dh*bn S+WSpD� a\3*W1ZSpE , b\ ,`1Yq /`d-S1 hW1Zm Y\1y

a1YnS ]`1V`*bSWS S4dh1ZS1 S+WSSD ) 31 `1jSO

b1WnZ\ Z*ab`\SWaq ]`\/\W3Sbn S4dh1ZS1 S Z1]\4,\WSbn ZSV\Yd S ZSh1Yd ]\Y1j*bnYZ1 Wdhj1d4Z*bn \-*D �+k1ZS1 a Z*`\/\Y 1-\,m ]\Y\-OW\ YZ1 4*W1hSbn oY\gS\Z*WnZm1 `*ZmD �`SabSO*ZaV\1 a\+`*ZS1 ab*W\ /Wq Y1Zq a1Yn1yE , V\Ob\`\y q b*V Zd3/*WaqD ) ]`\/\W3SW `*abS /dOf\,Z\ S , 5==5 -\/d V`1abSWaqE ab*, �,S/1b1W1Y1-\,mD

�� ����"���& ��) ˝�˛ &D �*Znj1 q +mW]\W\Z 4W\+m S 31ab\V\abS S ab`1YSWaq ,\ ,a1Y+mbn ]1`,mYD �\ �W\,\ \-* ]\WZ\abnp S4Y1ZSOW\ Y\p 3S4ZnD �1]1`n q /1Wpan YS`Z\y +S+W1yOaV\y ,1abnp a\ ,a1YSE Vb\ f\h1b 11 daWmj*bnD �\OaW1/ZS1 67 -\/* q ]\a,qk*p ob\Yd /1Wd \aZ\,OZdp h*abn a,\1-\ ,`1Y1ZSD�*V\1Ob\ ,`1Yq q aWd3SW /\+`\,\Wng1Y , eSO

WS*W1 �,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , �1VaSV1D �*Y q ]\O4Z*V\YSWaq a �W*d/S1yE 3S4Z1`*/\abZ\y S oZ1`O-ShZ\y f`SabS*ZV\yE S , 5=== -\/d Ym ]\31OZSWSanD �*V 31 q `*/E hb\ 1-\,* ]\/*`SW YZ1b*Vdp ,1`Zdp a]dbZSgdI�Y1ab1 Ym aWd3SWS , 31ab\,\Y a\+`*ZSSE ]\O

Y\-*q -WdfSY d4Z*,*bn \+ 1-\,1D ˛*b1Y Z*a ]\O]`\aSWS ]1`11f*bn , 1WS4E hb\+m `*aaV*4m,*bn\ S+WSS Y1abZmY 3Sb1WqYD �\bq 4/1an Ym ab*OWS 3Sbn Z*YZ\-\ aV`\YZ11E d Z*a 1abn ,a1 Z1\+Of\/SY\1E hb\+m +mbn ah*abWS,mYSD �m ZS Z*hb\ Z1 ]`\Y1Zq1Y b*Vdp 3S4ZnI�\ ,`1Y1Z1Y Y\q Y*Y* ,\4\+Z\,SW* S4dh1O

ZS1 S+WSS S V`1abSW*anD �*V31 Y\y ab*`jSy+`*bE 1-\ 31Z* S Sf /1bS ab*WS �,S/1b1WqYS 1O-\,mD �1V\b\`m1 Y\S +m,jS1 /`d4nq S4 -`d]O]S`\,VSE V\b\`mY q ]`\]\,1/\,*WE b\31 a1yh*aaWd3*b 1-\,1D� a\3*W1ZSpE V\-\Ob\ S4 Y\Sf `\/ab,1ZZSV\,

d31 Z1b , 3S,mf S4O4* b\-\E hb\ \ZS Z1 4*f\b1WSS4Y1ZSbn a,\y *-`1aaS,Zmy f*`*Vb1`D ˚aWS +m q]`\/\W3SW S/bS ]\ b\y 31 /\`\3V1E Y1ZqE aV\O`11 ,a1-\E b\31 d31 Z1 +mW\ +mD ) +W*-\/*`1Z1-\,1 4* b\E hb\ \Z ]`S,W1V Y1Zq V a1+1 S a,\OSY aWd3Sb1WqYE V\b\`m1 b1`]1WS,\ S ]\O/\+`\OYd dhSWS Y1Zq ]`SY1Zqbn , 3S4ZS +S+W1yaVS1]`SZgS]mD ˇ

Page 16: Где найти утешение?

wp

16

.5-U

16

05

25

�1Yd Z* a*Y\Y

/1W1 dhSb �S+WSqH

s�1a]W*bZ\ aV*h*yb1ob\b S ]`1/m/dkS1,m]daVS

�Sb*yb1 �S+WSp\ZW*yZ ]`SY1`Z\Z* 57> q4mV*f

˛*y/Sb1 Z* a*ybwww.jw.org/ru SWS\baV*ZS`dyb1 V\/

no

p

�b\ b*V\1 �*`ab,\ �\-*H ˚�����%˚ �˚�)�E hb\ �*`ab,\ �\-* P ob\a\ab\qZS1 a1`/g*D ˙`d-S1 ahSb*pbE hb\ ob\`14dWnb*b h1W\,1h1aVSf daSWSy ]\ /\abS31OZSp ,a1\+k1-\ YS`* S 1/SZab,*D hb\ /dOY*1b1 ,mH

��� ������� ���)

w�\- Z1+1aZmy dab*Z\,Sb g*`ab,\E V\b\`\1ZSV\-/* Z1 +d/1b `*4`dj1Z\D �DDD� �Z\ a\V`dOjSb ,a1 obS �h1W\,1h1aVS1� g*`ab,* S ]\W\O3Sb SY V\Z1gx L˙*ZSSW 6B88MD �*`ab,\ �\O-* P ob\ `1*WnZ\ adk1ab,dpk11]`*,Sb1Wnab,\D

��� ˚#˚ �˝�� ˛���& �˛ ��� ��

˙ �*`ab,\ �\-* Z*f\/Sbaq Z* Z1+1 L�*be1q 5>B;C�dVS 5>B=MD

˙ � ]\Y\knp ob\-\ �*`ab,* �\- Sa]\WZSb a,\p,\Wp Z* Z1+1 S Z* 41YW1 L�*be1q :B5>MD

\-/* ]`S/1b �*`ab,\ �\-*H�� % �% ���˚����H

˙ �1S4,1abZ\˙ �V\`\˙ �SV\-/*

��� ������� ���)

w'b* +W*-*q ,1abn \ g*`ab,1 +d/1b ]`\]\O,1/*Z* ]\ ,a1y \+Sb*1Y\y 41YW1 /Wq a,S/1Ob1Wnab,* ,a1Y Z*`\/*YE S b\-/* ]`S/1b V\OZ1gx L�*be1q 68B58MD \-/* +W*-*q ,1abn+d/1b ]`\]\,1/*Z* , ]\WZ\y Y1`1E �*`ab,\�\-* ]\W\3Sb V\Z1g ob\Yd 31ab\V\Yd YS`dD

��� ˚#˚ �˝�� ˛���& �˛ ��� ��

˙ �SVb\ Z* 41YW1 Z1 4Z*1bE V\-/* b\hZ\ ]`S/1b�*`ab,\ �\-* L�*be1q 68B7:MD

˙ �S+W1yaVS1 ]`\`\h1ab,* dV*4m,*pb Z* b\Ehb\ ob\ �*`ab,\ ]`S/1b \h1Zn aV\`\ L�*be1q68B7E ;E 56MD

��� ���� �� �����)H

�\3*Wdyab*E ]`SjWSb1 YZ1 VZS-dw�1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb �S+WSqHx

�\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS Y\3Z\ Z*ybS, <Oy -W*,1 ob\y VZS-SE S4/*ZZ\y�,S/1b1WqYS �1-\,m

�*V31 /\abd]Z* Z* a*yb1 jw.org

)˛%� �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

��� ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�˙�˚� ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�]Sa\V */`1a\, aY\b`Sb1 Z* ab`*ZSg1 6