10.2307@2742946

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    1/7

     University of Chicago Press and Wenner-Gren Foundation for Anthropological Research are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Current Anthropology.

    http://www.jstor.org

    Environmental Variation, Agriculture, and Settlement Processes in Coastal Ecuador (3300-1500B.C.)Author(s): Jonathan E. DampSource: Current Anthropology, Vol. 25, No. 1 (Feb., 1984), pp. 106-111Published by: on behalf ofUniversity of Chicago Press Wenner-Gren Foundation forAnthropological ResearchStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2742946Accessed: 26-12-2015 15:10 UTC

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/  info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/publisher/ucpresshttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/wennergrenhttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/wennergrenhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/2742946http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/2742946http://www.jstor.org/publisher/wennergrenhttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/wennergrenhttp://www.jstor.org/publisher/ucpresshttp://www.jstor.org/

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    2/7

    Environmental

    ariation,

    Agriculture,

    and

    Settlement

    rocesses in Coastal

    Ecuador

    (3300-1500

    B.c.)'

    by

    JONATHAN E.

    DAMP

    1911

    51 St., N.W, Calgary,

    Alta., Canada

    T3B ICl.

    11 vii

    83

    The

    Early Formative Valdivia

    culture appeared

    on the Ecua-

    dorian coast around 3300

    B.C.

    (Damp 1979) and became well-

    known

    because of the precociousness

    of the

    Valdivia ceramics

    in

    the

    Americas. Some researchers

    e.g., Lathrap,

    Collier, and

    Chandra 1975, Zevallos

    et al. 1977) contend

    that Valdivia cul-

    ture

    developed

    in

    northwestern

    South America

    in a context

    of

    tropical-forest,

    riverine-oriented

    agriculture.

    An alternative

    position (Meggars,

    Evans, and

    Estrada 1965)

    is that Valdivia

    ceramics

    were introduced

    to the New World

    by Neolithic Jap-

    anese

    fishing olk who encountered

    shellfish

    gatherers and fish-

    ermen ivingon the seashore. The

    work of Estrada (who

    named

    Valdivia),

    Meggers, and Evans (Meggers

    et al. 1965)

    and Zev-

    allos and Holm

    (1960; Zevallos

    1966-71) laid the basis

    for the

    study of the

    Early Formative of

    southwestern

    Ecuador and

    outlined

    these alternative

    positions. Because

    this early

    work

    was

    done on the coast,

    it was first ssumed

    that Valdivia

    was

    maritime-oriented.ubsequent researchby Norton (1971, 1972)

    demonstrated

    that the

    earliest dated Valdivia

    sites lay

    inland.

    Norton's

    excavations at

    Loma Alta (12 km

    inland from

    he

    type

    site

    of Valdivia)

    and more recent work

    there Damp 1982)

    and

    at

    Real Alto (Lathrap,

    Marcos, and Zeidler

    1977; Damp 1979,

    1982), as well

    as survey

    in

    the Guayas

    Basin (Raymond,

    Mar-

    cos,

    and Lathrap 1980),

    call into serious

    question

    the

    notion

    of

    a

    coastally adapted

    Valdivia.

    The evidence

    fromValdivia sites,

    both on the

    coast and well

    inland,

    includes the remains

    ofwhat appear

    to have been

    set-

    tled

    agricultural villages,

    some with

    ceremonial

    structures

    (Marcos

    1978). The villages

    of 3300

    B.C. were

    U-shaped,

    and

    this configuration provided

    the basis for

    the subsequent

    con-

    struction of

    ceremonial mounds

    (Lathrap et al.

    1977). Agri-

    culture s indicatedbyfindsof corn Zevallos 1966-71, Zevallos

    et al.

    1977,

    Pearsall 1978) achira

    (Pearsall 1979),

    Canavalia

    plagiosperma

    (Damp,

    Pearsall, and Kaplan

    1981), bottle gourd

    (Lanning

    1967a), and cotton

    Marcos 1973),

    and Pearsall (1979)

    has

    used most of this evidence

    in modeling

    the operations

    of

    various possible

    agricultural systems.

    Discussion

    ofsettlement

    patterns

    and settlement

    systems is,

    however,

    rarely incorpo-

    rated

    into any examination

    of Valdivia, and

    this omission

    has

    led

    to some interpretive

    rrors.For example,

    Roosevelt (1980:64)

    says

    that it was not until

    Chorrera times

    (ca. 1100-300

    B.C.)

    that there was "a notable

    expansion of habitation

    sites

    n

    inland

    areas along rivers," but

    it is now known

    that significant ex-

    pansions

    in

    these areas

    took place long

    before the

    1st

    millen-

    nium B.C.

    The question

    of settlement processes

    tends to evoke

    reexaminations of the problem of trans-Pacificorigins (Mc-

    Ewan

    and Dickson 1978)

    or searches for the

    very first eramic-

    bearing settlement" (Raymond

    et al. 1980:701).

    As

    Flannery

    (1973:308)

    has pointed out, however,

    first vents

    will not do;

    instead, "we need settlement

    pattern data;

    well-excavated

    liv-

    ing

    floors with the plants left n

    situ; and samples

    of 100 spec-

    imens with a mean,

    standard deviation, and

    a range of

    variation." Some evidence

    of this order is now

    available

    for

    Valdivia.

    Settlement-pattern

    ata exist

    for at least three

    valleys

    of

    coastal

    Ecuador

    (Zeidler

    1977,

    Damp 1979, Damp

    and

    Clarkson 1980)

    and for the

    Santa

    Elena Peninsula

    (Lanning

    1967b). Real Alto and Loma Alta have yielded house structures

    (Lathrap et al. 1977; Damp 1979, 1982), and although seeds

    do not yet number

    in

    the hundreds they do exist with good

    provenience from San Pablo (Zevallos et al. 1977), Real Alto

    (Damp et al. 1981), and Loma Alta (Damp 1982). This report

    will

    present

    and

    offer

    n

    interpretation

    of some of the settle-

    ment-patterndata.

    The three coastal valleys I shall report on here are the Chan-

    duy, the Valdivia, and the Blanco-Ayampe (fig. 1). The Chan-

    duy Valley, formed by the Rios Verde

    and

    Zapotal

    and

    their

    tributaries,was first urveyed systematicallyby Zeidler in 1975

    and

    by Zeidler

    and

    myself

    n

    1976

    under the

    auspices

    of the

    Real Alto Archaeological Project of the University of Illinois

    (Zeidler 197 7, Damp 1979). The survey focused upon accessible

    transects adjacent to the river bottoms. It was essentially non-

    probabilistic in approach because of logistical problems and a

    desire to inventorythe Formative-period settlement.The Val-

    divia

    Valley has been looked at

    in

    several ways since the work

    ofEstrada, Meggers, and Evans. Bischof (1975) contributed a

    survey near the coast, and Norton was instrumental n opening

    up the interior.An incomplete survey aimed at cataloging the

    entire sampling universe was begun by the University of Cal-

    gary'sLoma Alta Archaeological Project (see Damp and Clark-

    son

    1980).

    The tabulations of

    this

    report

    are based on the

    somewhat conflictingresults of these surveys. The Blanco-

    Ayampe Valley and

    that of the Rio Pftal were

    surveyed

    in

    conjunction

    with excavations

    by

    Marcos

    and

    Norton

    on La

    Plata Island. Again, logistical problems

    dictated

    survey

    strat-

    egy.

    The

    Pftal

    Valley

    bottom

    was traversed

    completely

    because

    of the lack

    of

    vegetation,

    but

    in

    the

    thickly

    forested

    region

    of

    the Colonche Hills the

    survey depended upon establishing

    ac-

    cessible

    transects along

    the

    valley

    bottom

    and

    up

    the tributar-

    ies; for the most part, existing roads were employed

    for this

    purpose. Of

    the three

    valleys surveyed,

    the

    Blanco-Ayampe

    was

    the most

    difficult o

    survey

    but

    yielded

    the

    largest

    number

    of Valdivia sites. The utilization of transect

    samples (Flannery

    1976a: 159) allowed the reliable sampling of areas of dense veg-

    etation. Plog (1976:158) suggests

    that "for

    surveying

    unknown

    areas, the simplest sampling designs well may be the most

    practical" and considers transect samples

    useful

    for standard-

    izing survey data.

    In

    any case,

    the results of these

    various

    studies do not

    support

    the contention that

    the

    densest Valdivia

    occupation

    was

    along

    the coast.

    If

    survey strategy

    was biased

    by

    the

    greater

    ease

    of

    surface

    inspection along

    the

    dry coast,

    this is

    certainly

    not reflected n the

    results.

    Three periods of Valdivia settlement are employed here to

    illustrate the

    evolving pattern

    from 3300 to 1500 B.C.

    Period

    A

    extends from about 3300 to

    2300 B.C. and

    ends

    with

    the

    construction of ceremonial

    mounds at such sites

    as Real

    Alto;

    it includes Valdivia I and

    II

    of Hill's (1972-74) eight-partse-

    quence.

    Period

    B,

    from 2300 to 1850

    B.C.,

    includes Valdivia

    III, IV, and V; during

    this

    time the main villages had their

    largest populations. Period C comprises Valdivia VI, VII, and

    VIII and ends about 1500

    B.C.

    with the transition nto Mach-

    alilla;

    this

    period

    witnessed the establishment of satellite com-

    munities around sites such as Real Alto and the

    dispersion

    of

    population away

    from

    the

    ceremonial centers.

    The Chanduy Valley.

    The

    Chanduy Valley

    lies on the

    south-

    east

    edge

    of the

    Santa

    Elena

    Peninsula,

    where

    the terrain

    is

    relatively

    flat nd broken

    only by

    the

    occasional

    range

    of coastal

    hills. Rainfall

    is

    less here than

    in

    areas

    to the north or east.

    Centinela

    (OGSECh-19)

    and Real

    Alto

    (OGSECh-12)

    are the

    two

    earliest settlements

    n

    the

    valley (fig. 2). They

    lie 30

    km

    apart

    and

    have

    sequences spanning

    Periods

    A, B,

    and C. Two

    sites between

    them

    date to Period

    B;

    OGSECh-11

    and

    -91 lie

    about 10 km from Real Alto and Centinela respectively. Since

    5 km may, according to Vita-Finzi and Higgs (1970), be pre-

    sumed to be the distance village agriculturalists would walk

    to their fields (productivity n terms of energy consumed

    and

    CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY

    I

    ( 1984

    by The

    Wenner-Gren Foundation

    for Anthropological

    Re-

    search,

    all rightsreserved 0011-3204/84/250

    -0006$

    1.00.

    I

    thank

    Persis

    Clarkson,

    Maria Isabel

    Silva de Zeidler, Don Lathrap, Jorge

    Marcos,

    Presley Norton,

    Scott

    Raymond,

    Mike Schott,

    Jim Zeidler, the

    Ford

    Foundation, Earthwatch, the Explorer's Club, the Social Sciences and

    Humanities

    Research

    Council

    (Canada),

    and the administration

    of

    the

    University

    of Calgary.

    106

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    3/7

    derived dropping off

    eyond that distance),

    the new settlements

    of

    Period

    B

    seem to lie at

    the point where a

    new 5-km-radius

    catchment area could be

    developed while

    at the same time

    remaining close to the

    parent village. The

    rule of colonization

    apparentlygave priority

    o the opening up of

    new farmlands.

    A third

    Period

    B

    site,

    OGSECh-80, is less than 5 km

    from

    Real

    Alto, and its

    location gives the

    impression that it lies

    within

    Real Alto's

    catchment area. However,

    it is actually pro-

    pitiously

    ocated on a different

    iver drainage, that of

    the Rio

    Perere. The

    farmlands adjacent to

    this river were

    sufficiently

    far

    removed

    from Real Alto to

    preclude their use by

    the

    in-

    habitants of that

    village, the most important Valdivia

    occu-

    pation

    in

    the

    lower part of the valley.

    Period C settlements

    include four satellites

    of Real Alto

    (-16a, 17, 20,

    and 22); Engomala (OGSECh-7), almost

    exactly

    halfway between OGSECh-11

    and -91; and OGSECh-108 and

    -117, about 10 km upriver, overlooking

    the floodplain from

    elevated positions

    on an inland savanna. The Valdivia VII

    and

    VIII and early

    Machalilla settlements closely adjacent

    to Real

    Alto indicate

    an evolving settlement ystem. By

    this time Real

    Alto was a center for administration

    and ceremony. Marcos,

    Lathrap, and Zeidler (1976:4) describe

    Real Alto as regulating

    MANA8I

    0

    Z5

    so

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    4/7

    farmsteads dispersed along the river valley and

    controlling

    some 600 acres of agricultural bottomland. They

    assert

    that

    a

    stratified ociety

    is

    implicit

    in

    the presence of a control

    center,

    Real Alto, with satellite

    settlements. Engomala's location

    is

    predictable in that it is situated on an expansive

    floodplain

    below the juncture of the Rio de

    Azucar

    and the Rio

    Zapotal

    and

    below the Chanduy

    hills.

    It

    was also the only place left

    along the river bottom

    between Centinela and Real Alto where

    a

    catchment area with a 5-km

    radius could be carved out.

    OGSECh-108 and -117 are

    slightly nomalous because of their

    10-km

    distance

    from

    Real Alto. This distance

    may reflect n

    unidentified ite in between, the conditions of the first xpan-

    sion

    up the Rio Verde of the

    Chanduy Valley, or the increased

    aridityof this area (see Pearsall

    1979: map 5). By this third

    stage of the Valdivia

    colonization of the Chanduy Valley, sat-

    uration was

    complete; there

    were

    no longer any unused 5-km-

    radius catchment areas. The

    settlement patternclearly shows

    this. The rule that governed

    the system was no doubt engen-

    dered

    by

    the

    availability

    of

    farmland. Flannery (197

    6c: 180)

    has

    suggested that new

    Formative settlements

    n

    Mesoamerica will

    be

    located

    according to processes of symmetrical

    expansion,

    settlement

    packing, and ultimate saturation when

    a certain

    spacing is

    reached. Such processes seem to have

    taken place

    during

    Valdivia times

    in

    the Chanduy Valley.

    The

    Valdivia Valley. The Valdivia Valley is a

    short valley (20

    km) opening onlyto the coast; the hills riseprecipitouslyto the

    east

    beyond

    Loma

    Alta. The

    valley encompasses

    a

    drier coastal

    region and

    almost

    impenetrable

    hilly

    forest.

    Two Period

    A

    sites

    are known from the

    valley

    (fig. 3):

    the

    Valdivia

    type site,

    G-31

    (Meggers

    et

    al.

    1965),

    and Loma

    Alta

    (Norton 1971, Damp 1982). These sites

    lie about 12 km

    apart,

    with Loma Alta at the base ofthe Colonche Hills and Valdivia

    on the coast. Four sites represent Period B: Loma

    Alta

    (OGSEMa-182), Valdivia (OGSEMa-17 2), OGSEMa-1 13,

    and

    an unrecorded site, revealed to pot hunters after activity by

    heavy machinery,halfway between Loma Alta and Valdivia near

    the modern town of Barcelona.

    All

    of these sites continue

    into

    Period C and are joined by eight others.

    The positioning of

    these sites recalls the placement

    of

    the Valdivia

    sites

    in

    the

    Chanduy Valley;

    an

    infilling

    f

    settlement

    s

    obvious. OGSEMa-

    55 is subordinate to Loma Alta; OGSEMa-62 lies between

    Valdivia and Barcelona; five sites are 'atellites to Valdivia.

    There is, thus, a distinct parallel between

    the Valdivia sites of

    the Valdivia Valley and those of the Chanduy

    Valley

    in

    the

    evidence

    they present

    of settlement

    nfilling

    nd clustering

    of

    satellite

    communities

    around

    important

    centers.

    The Blanco-Ayampe Valley. Survey

    in

    southern

    Manabf prov-

    ince located 19 Valdivia sites along the Rfos

    Pftal and Blanco-

    Ayampe (fig. 4).

    All

    but

    2

    of these sites are packed

    into a space

    of

    only

    8

    km

    from north to south

    along the

    Blanco. There may

    be

    many

    more

    Valdivia

    sites

    in

    the area

    (some

    15 linear km),

    but

    dense vegetation precluded their dentification.

    The Blanco

    is close to the 500-mm isohyet, and the

    area is rugged and

    heavily forested. The Rfo Pftal area is rather

    dry because of

    the rainshadow of the Colonche Hills,

    and

    except

    in its

    upper

    reaches no Valdivia sites were found in it.

    There

    are

    three Period

    A

    sites

    on the

    Blanco-Ayampe:

    San

    Jacinto OMJPLP-37),

    El Triunfo

    OMJPLP-40),

    and

    El Achiote

    (OMJPLP-48).

    These

    sites have

    large

    ceremonial

    mounds

    (up

    to

    4 m

    high)

    similar to those

    excavated

    at Real Alto

    (Lathrap

    W)

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~entLnela

    10~~~~90

    0m

    km.

    /

    RealAo(

    AL* Eno ()

    C; :A

    T

    Pemod

    A,B,

    aA

    C

    OCea4m

    *

    PerLodis

    and

    C

    *

    PerLod

    C

    FIG.

    2.

    Valdivia

    sites

    of

    the

    Chanduy

    Valley.

    108

    CURRENT

    ANTHROPOLOGY

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    5/7

    et

    al. 1977). San

    Jacinto,

    at

    least, spans

    the entire

    Valdivia

    sequence;

    the other

    two

    may

    have

    equal longevity,

    but

    diag-

    nostic sherds from theirdisturbed deposits

    are

    not

    sufficient

    o

    include Phase I. There

    are six sites

    that

    belong

    to Period B

    and

    eighteen

    that

    represent Period C. The extreme

    packing

    of Val-

    divia settlements

    n

    this

    region s

    not

    yetduplicated

    in

    the other

    valleys. The most

    economical explanation

    for

    this pattern is

    that this region is

    better watered than the others, more

    closely

    resembling the Guayas Basin that some

    researchers

    (Lathrap

    et

    al. 1975, Damp

    1979, Raymond et

    al.

    1980) consider the

    homeland of the coastal

    Valdivia cultures. The rainfall

    gradient

    that Momsen (1968) has described for southwestern Ecuador

    seems to be reflected n

    the Valdivia settlement system.

    Momsen

    (1968:101-4)

    has

    pointed out

    that the

    coastal

    strip,

    the

    Colonche Hills, and the

    Guayas Basin vary widely

    in

    pre-

    cipitation as a result of

    the interaction

    with

    the

    topography

    of

    the Peru

    current, which

    brings a cool, low-humidity air

    mass,

    and the

    Equatorial air mass, which

    brings warm, moist air

    southward. The Colonche Hills halt the flow of

    the Equatorial

    air

    mass and make the

    Pacific coast near the Santa Elena Penin-

    sula much

    drier than the

    Guayas Basin. This difference s

    made

    less

    extreme from outhern Manabi

    province northward by the

    proximity of the Colonche Hills to the

    coast. Thus the envi-

    ronments of

    southwestern Ecuador

    vary from the desert-like

    conditions

    of the

    Santa Elena Peninsula to the

    tropical forest

    ofthe Colonche Hills. The relative distance of ndividualcoastal

    valleys

    from the

    500-mm isohyet has

    profound archaeological

    consequences,

    since

    the 500-mm isohyet

    marks

    the

    effective

    penetration of

    the rain-bearing Equatorial

    air mass

    in

    normal

    years. Thus, the area

    southwest

    of

    the

    line receives

    less pre-

    cipitation. I believe that it was amount

    of

    precipitation

    that

    modulated adaptations in southwestern Ecuador and influ-

    enced the colonization pattern

    of

    Valdivia

    from the

    Guayas

    Basin to the Pacific coast.2

    The most conspicuous phenomena of the settlementpatterns

    examined

    here are an

    infilling

    f

    sites

    during

    the course of the

    Valdivia

    occupation

    and

    a

    clustering

    of settlements

    n

    certain

    locales. All three valleys are clear examplesof Flannery's

    Form-

    ative-type

    settlement

    pattern:

    a

    linear and

    symmetrical expan-

    sion of settlement and

    infilling

    ver a period

    of time

    between

    established

    communities

    Flannery

    1976c:173-80). The Blanco-

    Ayampe data further ttest to a greater density of settlement

    in

    better-watered nd

    more

    heavily

    forested reas. This density

    2

    There has been

    some suggestion hat paleoenvironmental

    ircum-

    stances ffected

    ettlementncoastalEcuador.

    A

    seven-year

    eriodicity

    seemsto influencehe arrival of the rainy eason typically

    anuary

    throughMay).This s a function

    f the northernxtensionf thePeru

    current long the Ecuadorian coast

    before

    t

    moves west.

    In

    the dry

    years hecurrent

    tays n itsplace during he rainy eason

    ratherhan

    withdrawing

    s usual to the Gulf of Guayaquil (Momsen

    1968:101).

    Some

    researchers(e.g., arma 1974)suggest

    hat his

    ycle

    s

    part

    ofa

    larger ycleof aridity nd pluviality.

    he extent f this ruth s com-

    plicated y many actors. arma garners

    is data from heSanta Elena

    Peninsula, n area

    always marginaln rainfall, nd bases

    his conclu-

    sions on certain aleoenvironmental

    actors including hellfishbun-

    dance

    in

    archaeological

    ites)

    which

    are

    in factthe result fhuman

    activities ndpreferences,hecontext fwhichwas probablymodifiedby physiographic hanges brought bout by coastal uplift Ferdon

    1981). Pearsall 1979),however, elieves

    hatthere s no evidencefor

    a major vegetation

    hift

    xcept

    for hat

    which

    can mostprobably e

    attributed

    o humandegradation

    f

    the environment

    hrough ree ut-

    tingfor uel nd

    for he clearing f agricultural lots.

    *113

    *~ ~~~A

    /cel

    rcto

    l

    %l4SLodr;Vi-3twUsgtt

    ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U11)

    l

    A

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~'~ J

    OceoAt

    , /

    buenA

    peno&s A,1Oa&

    Cl

    *

    TerPLOdS

    ar

    C|

    *

    ?eotd

    C

    HB

    Bischof survey (iS95)

    0

    2.

    5

    FIG.

    3. Valdivia sites

    of the

    Valdivia Valley.

    Vol.

    25

    No.

    1

    February

    984 109

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    6/7

    may be considered as support for the argument that Valdivia

    settlement

    was guided by rules derived

    from the

    practice

    of

    tropical-forest griculture (Lathrap 1970).

    A

    comparison of site densities

    in

    the three valleys reveals a

    south-to-north

    line (table 1). The matrix

    for

    density

    over time

    indicates sequential infilling or each of the valley areas when

    sites

    per

    linear

    kilometer re considered. Density plotted against

    time

    shows

    an exponential relationship which is more than

    fortuitous.

    feel that the spacing and relative density of set-

    tlement are determined by the amount of

    rainfall. The densest

    settlement

    ccurred

    in

    the wetter

    Blanco-Ayampe area and the

    more dispersed settlements n the drier Chanduy Valley. The

    steep precipitation gradient noted by

    Momsen (1968) models

    the relationship between the three valleys

    surveyed. The sig-

    nificance of the precipitation gradient is that

    more fertile and

    was accessible in the northern and interiorregions of south-

    western

    Ecuador. The implication is that rainfallwas a reg-

    ulator of

    Early Formative settlementspacing.

    TABLE 1

    VALDIVIA SITES

    PER LINEAR KILOMETER

    IN

    THREE

    COASTAL

    VALLEYS DURING

    THREE

    TIME PERIODS

    SITES

    PER

    LINEAR

    KILOMETER

    VALLEY A

    B

    C

    Chanduy

    .

    ...........

    07 .13

    .40

    Valdivia .

    ............

    .10

    .20 .60

    Blanco-Ayampe

    ......

    .20 .40

    1.20

    In thisexample

    from rehistoric cuador,

    suggest,

    much

    as

    inLeach's (1961:17)Pul

    Eliya, water upplydetermines

    he

    "limit

    o the area of and that

    may be cultivated

    nd henceto

    the size

    of the population

    whichmaysurvive hrough

    ubsis-

    tence

    agriculture." settlement-pattern

    nalysis

    of Valdivia

    sites

    n southwesterncuador

    indicates hat rainfall

    was

    im-

    portant

    n

    setting

    he imits f ettlement

    acking

    n the

    Chan-

    duy,Valdivia,and Blanco-Ayampe alleys.

    The relationship

    between

    ainfallnd patterns

    f ettlements highly

    uggestive

    that iteswerepreferentially

    ocated or

    arming urposes. his,

    combinedwith he

    growing umber f

    paleobotanical emains,

    lendsfurtherredibilityo the belief hatValdivia was an ag-

    riculturalociety.

    he measurementf

    prehistorichenomena

    is imperative or

    an increasedunderstanding

    fthis culture,

    which

    was pivotal

    n

    the

    transition o a settled gricultural

    way

    of ife. hope thatfuture

    tudywill address his uestion.

    ReferencesCited

    BISCHOF,

    H. 1974. El Machalilla temprano

    algunos itios ercanos

    a Valdivia Ecuador).

    Paperpresentedt the41st nternational

    on-

    gress f Americanists,

    exico City.

    DAMP, J. 1979. Betterhomes nd gardens:The life nd

    death of the

    early Valdivia community. npublished

    Ph.D.

    dissertation,

    ni-

    versity f Calgary,

    Calgary,Alta.

    . 1982. Structure s house, house

    as structure:arly Valdivia

    social and economic design. Paperpresented t the 47thannual

    meeting f he ociety orAmerican

    rchaeology, inneapolis,

    inn.

    DAMP,

    J., and

    P.

    CLARKSON.

    1980. Preliminary eport

    n the Loma

    Alta Archaeological roject.MS,

    Program or cuadorianAnthro-

    pology, uito.

    DAMP,

    J.,

    D. PEARSALL, and L.

    KAPLAN.

    1981.

    Beans forValdivia.

    Science

    212:811-12.

    km

    | . 9

    ) *~~~~~~~~~~

    ~~~~~~~~~

    an

    JTQLrntol

    ocea.r&

    A Periods

    A,B,

    C

    .

    ^

    I

    C

    S

    Pertis

    B

    and

    C

    *

    P

    riodt

    C,

    FIG. 4. Valdivia sites

    of the Blanco-Ayampe

    alley.

    110

    CURRENT

    ANTHROPOLOGY

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/17/2019 10.2307@2742946

    7/7

    FERDON,

    E. 1981. Holocene

    mangrove formations on the Santa

    Elena

    Peninsula, Ecuador:

    Pluvial indicators or ecological response

    to

    phys-

    iographic changes?

    American

    Antiquity

    46:619-26.

    FLANNERY, K. 1973.

    The origins of agriculture.

    Annual Review of

    Anthropology2:271-310.

    . 1976a. "The

    trouble with regional

    sampling,"

    in The

    early

    Mesoamerican

    village. Edited by K. Flannery, pp. 159-60.

    New

    York: Academic

    Press.

    *

    1976b. "Evolution of

    complex

    settlement

    ystems,"

    n

    The

    early

    Mesoamerican village. Edited by K.

    Flannery, pp. 162-73.

    New

    York:

    Academic Press.

    . 1976c. "Linear stream

    patterns and riverside settlement

    rules,"

    in

    The early

    Mesoamerican village. Edited by K.

    Flannery,pp. 173-

    80. New York: Academic Press.

    HILL, B.

    1972-74. A new

    chronology of the Valdivia ceramic

    complex

    from

    the coastal zone of Guayas

    province, Ecuador. Nawpa Pacha

    10-12:1-39.

    LANNING, E.

    1967a.

    Peru

    before

    he

    ncas.

    Englewood

    Cliffs: Prentice-

    Hall.

    .

    1967b. Archaeological

    investigations on

    the

    Santa Elena

    Peninsula, Ecuador. Report to the

    National Science Foundation.

    LATHRAP, D.

    1970.

    The

    upper Amazon.

    New

    York:

    Praeger.

    LATHRAP,

    D., D. COLLIER, and

    H. CHANDRA. 1975. Ancient Ecuador:

    Culture, clay, and

    creativity, 000-300 B.C.

    Chicago: Field Museum

    of

    Natural History.

    LATHRAP,

    D., J.MARCOS, and J. ZEIDLER.

    1977. Real Alto:

    An

    ancient

    ceremonial center.

    Archaeology 30:2-13.

    LEACH, E.

    1961. Pul Eliya: A

    village

    in

    Ceylon. Cambridge:

    Cam-

    bridge University

    Press.

    MARCOS,

    J. 1973.

    Tejidos hechos en telar en un

    contexto Valdivia

    tardio.

    Guayaquil: Casa de la

    Cultura Ecuatoriana.

    . 1978. The ceremonial precinct at Real Alto: Organization of

    time and space in

    Valdivia society. Unpublished

    Ph.D. dissertation,

    Universityof Illinois,

    Urbana,

    Ill.

    MARCOS,

    J.,

    D.

    LATHRAP, and

    J.

    ZEIDLER.

    1976.

    Ancient

    Ecuador

    revisited. Field

    Museum Bulletin 47.

    McEWAN, G.,

    and D.

    DICKSON.

    1978. Valdivia, Jomon

    fishermen,

    and the

    nature

    of the

    North

    Pacific: Some nautical problems

    with

    Meggers, Evans and

    Estrada's (1965) transoceanic contact thesis.

    American

    Antiquity 43:362-71.

    MEGGERS, B., C. EVANS, and E. ESTRADA.

    1965.

    The

    Early

    Formative

    period of coastal

    Ecuador. Smithsonian

    Contributions to Anthro-

    pology 1.

    MOMSEN, R. 1968.

    Precipitation patterns of

    west-central

    Ecuador.

    Revista Geogrdfica 69:91-105.

    NORTON, P.

    1971.

    A

    preliminary report on

    Loma

    Alta and the

    impli-

    cations

    of nland Valdivia A.

    Paper presented

    at the Primer

    Simposio

    de

    Correlaciones Antropol6gicas

    Andino-Mesoamericano, Salinas,

    Ecuador.

    .

    1972. Early Valdivia

    middens at Loma Alta, Ecuador. Paper

    presented at the 37th annual

    meeting of the Society for

    American

    Archaeology, Bal

    Harbour, Fla.

    PEARSALL, D. 1978.

    Phytolith analysis of

    archeological

    soils:

    Evidence

    for maize

    cultivation

    in

    Formative

    Ecuador. Science 199:177-78.

    . 1979. The application of ethnobotanical techniques to the

    problem of subsistence in the

    Ecuadorian Formative.

    Unpublished

    Ph.D.

    dissertation, University

    of Illinois, Urbana, Ill.

    PLOG,

    S. 1976.

    "Relative efficiencies of

    sampling techniques for ar-

    chaeological

    surveys,"

    n

    The early Mesoamerican

    village. Edited by

    K.

    Flannery, pp. 136-58. New

    York: Academic Press.

    RAYMOND,

    J. S., J. MARCOS,

    and

    D. LATHRAP.

    1980.

    Evidence

    of

    Early

    Formative settlement n the Guayas

    Basin, Ecuador. CURRENT

    ANTHROPOLOGY

    21:700-701.

    ROOSEVELT,

    A.

    1980.

    Parmana: Prehistoric maize and

    manioc sub-

    sistence along the

    Amazon and Orinoco.

    New

    York:

    Academic Press.

    SARMA,

    S. 1974. Holocene

    paleoecology of

    south coastal Ecuador.

    Proceedings of the

    American Philosophical

    Society 18:93-134.

    VITA-FINzI,

    C., and

    E.

    HIGGs.

    1970. Prehistoric economy

    in

    the Mt.

    Carmel area of

    Palestine: Site catchment

    analysis. Proceedings of

    the Prehistoric

    Society 36:1-37.

    ZEIDLER, J. 1977.

    Early Formative settlement n

    the Chanduy Valley,

    southwest

    Ecuador.

    Paper presented

    at the

    42nd annual

    meeting

    of

    the Society forAmerican Archaeology, New Orleans, La.

    ZEVALLOS, C.

    1966-71. La agricultura en el

    Formative temprano del

    Ecuador

    (Cultura Valdivia). Guayaquil:

    Casa de la Cultura

    Ecuatoriana.

    ZEVALLOS,

    C., and 0. HOLM.

    1960. Excavaciones

    arqueol6gicas en

    San

    Pablo:

    Informepreliminar. Guayaquil.

    ZEVALLOS, C., W. GALINAT,

    D. LATHRAP, E. LENG, J.

    MARCOS, and

    K. KLUMPP.

    1977. The

    San Pablo corn kerneland its friends. Science

    196:385

    -89.

    Referees,

    anuary-July

    983

    The following ersons erved as referees f contributionso

    CURRENT

    ANTHROPOLOGY

    betweenJanuary 1

    and July 15,

    1983:

    JoanAblon U.

    S.A.), William

    Abruzzi U. S.A.),

    AttilaAgh

    (Hungary),

    AnneAkeroyd

    England), John Alden

    (U.S.A.),

    Paul

    AlexanderAustralia),Alan

    Almquist

    U.S.A.), Alan B.

    Anderson

    Canada), Lawrence

    Angel U.S.A.),

    Michael An-

    grosino U.S.A.),

    Donald Attwood

    Canada),

    Anthony veni

    (U.S.A.), Daniel

    Aycock Canada).

    Paul Bahn

    England),Ch.

    J. N. Bailey

    F.R.G.), Paul

    Baker

    (U.S.A.),

    A.

    J.

    Barnard Scotland),

    Brad Bartel

    U.S.A.), Ami-

    tabha Basu

    (India),

    Brenda Beck

    (Canada), Harumi

    Befu

    (U.S.A.), Robert E.

    Bell (U.S.A.),

    Antonio

    Beltran Spain),

    Abdulbari ener

    Saudi Arabia),J.

    W. BennettU.

    S.A.), Leon-

    ard

    Berkowitz

    U.S.A.), Riva

    Berleant-Schiller

    U.S.A.), Cath-

    erineH. Berndt Australia), ernardBernierCanada),Marian

    Binkley

    Canada), Valda

    Blundell Canada),

    Nicholas

    Blurton-

    Jones

    U.S.A.), Bernhard

    Bock (F.R.G.), Jeremy oissevain

    (The

    Netherlands), alph

    Bolton

    Norway),Batsheva

    Bonne-

    Tamir Israel),

    Silvana

    Borgognini-Tarli

    Italy),JohnR. Bower

    (Kenya),

    VictoriaBricker

    U.S.A.), Harald B.

    Broch (Nor-

    way),David

    Browman U.S.A.),

    Judith rown

    U.S.A.), Alice

    Brues

    (U.S.A.), Jean

    Burton (Belgium),

    Michael Burton

    (U.S.A.), W. F. L.

    Buschkens The

    Netherlands).

    Gabriel

    Camps (France),

    Elizabeth

    Cashdan

    U.S.A.),

    Sally

    Cassell

    (New

    Zealand),

    Gast6n

    Castillo G6mez

    Chile),

    L. L.

    Cavalli-Sforza

    U.S.A.), Lynn Ceci

    (U.S.A.), Anne

    Chapman

    (France), Karen Mohr

    Chavez (U.S.A.),

    Michael

    Chibnik

    (U. S.A.), M.

    Chlenov U. S. S.

    R.), Andrew

    hristensonU.

    S.A.),

    Monica Cira-SalemmeArgentina), enriJ.M. Claessen The

    Netherlands), J. Desmond

    Clark

    (U.S.A.), Michael

    Coe

    Vol.

    25

    *

    No. 1

    *

    February

    1984

    (U.S.A.), Erik

    Cohen

    (Israel), Ronald Cohen

    (U.S.A.), Ben-

    jamin

    Colby U.S.A.), JohnR.

    Cole (U.S.A.),

    Donald Collier

    (U.S.A.), J. Collman (U.S.A.), E. S. Crawcour Australia),

    Ross Crumrine

    Canada), Fernando

    ruz-Sandoval

    Honduras).

    GrahamDann

    (Barbados),

    Regna

    Darnell

    Canada), Pierre

    Dasen (Switzerland),

    Richard Davis

    (U.S.A.),

    Jacquelinede

    Durand-Forest

    France), Julesde

    Leeuwe (The

    Netherlands),

    BernardDelfendahl

    France), Henri

    Delporte France),

    Gisele

    de Meur

    Belgium),Ari

    de Ruijter

    The Netherlands), hlomo

    Deshen Israel), Paul

    W. Dixon

    (U.S.A.), Marlene Dobkin

    de

    Rios

    U.S.A.), Phyllis

    Dolhinow U.S.A.),

    Frederick . Dunn

    (U.S.A.), Denis

    Dutton

    U.S.A.).

    JohnEarly

    U.S.A.), Jeffreyhrenreich

    U.S.A.), Jule

    Ei-

    senbud

    U.S.A.),

    GordonF.

    Ekholm

    U.S.A.), Frederic

    ngel

    (U.S.A.), BruceErlich

    U.S.A.).

    LindaFedigan

    Canada), Valerie ennell

    U.S.A.), Gabriella

    Ferro-Luzzi

    Italy), eonardoFigoli

    Brazil), aul Fish

    U.S.A.),

    Alan G. Fix (U.S.A.), K. Fladmark Canada), StanleyFreed

    (U.S.A.), D. G.

    Freedman

    U.S.A.), Milton

    Freeman Can-

    ada), Regula Frey-Nakouz

    Sierra

    Leone),

    A.

    E.

    Friday

    En-

    gland),StephenFuchs

    (India).

    Baldur Gabriel

    F.R.G.), Stanley

    M.

    Garn

    U.S.A.),

    Lila L.

    Gatlin

    U.S.A.), Nils-Gustav

    Gejvall

    (Sweden),VicenteGian-

    cottiTassone

    Brazil),

    Allan S.

    Gilbert

    U.S.A.), Marija

    Gim-

    butas

    U.S.A.),

    A.

    Ginsberg

    Brazil),MarcusGoldstein

    Israel),

    JurgenGolte

    F.R.G.), Nelson

    Graburn

    U.S.A.), J. A. Gray

    (England), dward

    C. Green U.S.A.),

    Edward Gross

    U.S.A.),

    AmyraGrossbard-Shechtman

    Israel),David

    Guillet

    U.S.A.),

    Christian

    Guksch

    F.R.G.),

    Ranjan Gupta

    India).

    Per Hage

    (U.S.A.), B. G. Halbar

    (India), WilliamJ.

    Ham-

    ilton II

    (U.S.A.), Eugene

    Hammel U.S.A.),

    JawaharlalHan-

    doo (India), P. J. C. Harries-JonesCanada), Brian Hayden

    (Canada),

    Dwight

    B.

    Heath

    (U.S.A.), Hermann

    S.

    Helmuth

    111

    This content downloaded from 137.120.4.50 on Sat, 26 Dec 2015 15:10:33 UTC