10

1875,7,21 ,1 1(3$/ - HERD · 2017. 3. 23. · February 12 to March 13 (Falgun 2073 BS). We collected various stories by conducting daily media monitoring of national mainstream and

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 一唀吀刀䤀吀䤀伀一 䤀一 一䔀倀䄀䰀

    䄀 䴀伀一吀䠀䰀夀 䴀䔀䐀䤀䄀 䴀伀一䤀吀伀刀䤀一䜀 刀䔀倀伀刀吀Ⰰ 䘀愀最甀渀 ㈀ 㜀㌀  

  • Cover Photo: A child being provided polio vaccine.

    Source:

    http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-03-

    06/18-officials-booked-for-disrupting-polio-drive.html Study Team Dr Sushil Baral Rajesh Ghimire Sudeep Uprety Kritagya Regmi Bipul Lamichhane

    This report is produced by Health Research and Social Development Forum (HERD) as part of monthly media monitoring study conducted by Research Uptake and Communications Unit at HERD. The media monitoring exercise will be conducted for a year from Mangshir 2073 BS to Kartik 2074 BS.

    http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-03-06/18-officials-booked-for-disrupting-polio-drive.htmlhttp://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-03-06/18-officials-booked-for-disrupting-polio-drive.html

  • EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    Malnutrition is a serious health problem in

    Nepal. According to Nepal

    Demographic and Health Survey 2011,

    41% of Nepali children are suffering from

    chronic malnutrition. As a result, there is

    high prevalence of death of children

    due to malnutrition especially in remote

    areas of Nepal.

    Nutritious diet is vital for development of

    children and can help to prevent many

    diseases in the long run. Meanwhile, the

    impact of malnutrition is as such that it

    reduces immunity and impairs their

    mental and physical development.

    Consumption of poor nutritional diets has

    affected proper growth and

    development of children, caused many

    related illness and has resulted in many

    casualties among children particularly in

    rural areas of Nepal. In a macro

    perspective, malnutrition has affected

    the national economic growth in Nepal

    due to loss of productive labour resulting

    in lower GDP.

    Both under nutrition and over nutrition is

    a serious problem in Nepal arising with

    vulnerable groups either consuming

    more or less than what is required.

    Malnutrition in Nepal can be ascribed to

    poor feeding and care, insufficient

    nutrient intake, high rate of infections

    and complications during pregnancy.

    People from rural areas of Nepal are

    affected by a triple threat: food

    insecurity, low access to health services

    and poor financial ability. Furthermore,

    low level of literacy and awareness in

    Nepal is also adding to the severity of the

    problem.

    This study was conducted through a

    systematic investigation and analysis of

    16 print and online media sources; to

    identify the current scenario of nutrition in

    Nepal and the current activities along

    with efforts that have been made to

    control and reduce the level of

    prevalence of malnutrition by several

    government and non-government

    agencies. We sought to recognize the

    current trends and issues associated with

    nutrition as illustrated by the media

    sources. We attempted to capture a

    valid picture on nutritional situation in the

    country particularly focusing on the

    current situation, vulnerabilities, efforts

    and progress made with regards to

    nutrition in Nepal.

    It is evident that prompt and immediate

    actions are required by both the

    government and the non-government

    sector to deal with the problem of

    nutrition in Nepal. Better polices to ensure

    food security and quality of diet is crucial

    in reducing if not eliminating the extent

    of problem that persists in modern day

    Nepal. More direct and concentrated

    effort is required to see off the problem

    anytime soon.

    INTRODUCTION

    Malnutrition is a serious condition that

    occurs when a person’s diet does not

    contain the right amount of nutrients as

    needed by the body. A malnourished

    individual lacks strength to undertake

    routine activities and has reduced

    concentration levels among children.

    Good nutrition is prerequisite for the

    national development and for the well-

    being of individuals. Although problems

    related to poor nutrition affects the entire

    population, women and children are

    particularly vulnerable because of their

    unique physiology and socio-economic

    characteristics. Nutrition plays a critical

    role in child’s growth and development

    and the period from birth to age two is

    important for optimal growth and

    development. However, in Nepal,

    children falling under this age group are

    found with severe micronutrient

    deficiencies resulting in childhood illness

    such as diarrhoea and respiratory

    infections.

    Malnutrition and diseases seem to work

    in a deadly cycle. A malnourished child

    is more likely to suffer from diseases, and

    http://dhsprogram.com/pubs/pdf/fr257/fr257%5B13april2012%5D.pdf

  • 1 | P a g e

    the more they suffer from disease the

    more likely they are to be malnourished.

    Likewise, a woman’s nutritional status is

    also important as this determines not only

    her health but also the health of her

    children. Malnourished women are

    economically unproductive and are

    more likely to get infected and recover

    slowly from illness and have increased

    chances of complications during

    pregnancy. Their children are also likely

    to give birth to children with low birth

    rate, and this cycle continues. It is quite

    obvious that the problem of malnutrition

    is still being overlooked and it requires

    immediate attention by all relevant

    stakeholders at all levels.

    This media monitoring involved tracking

    down of relevant media stories with

    respect to nutrition and food security in

    order to identify the current state of

    malnutrition and the attempts that are

    being made to improve the situation. We

    aimed to take a closer look on the

    context of nutrition in Nepal and to track

    down nutritional campaigns, identify

    trends, discover the prevalence level, to

    understand how agencies aid and

    donors are engaged in it, and to

    understand how media and other

    agencies are responding to it. This study

    also attempts to the draw attention of

    concerned authorities and researchers,

    to explore further and acquire more

    information regarding the nature and

    extent of problem which can be helpful

    in revising the current approaches and

    in achieving the goal of eradicating

    hunger and malnutrition from Nepal.

    METHODOLOGY

    This media monitoring study was carried

    out for the period of one month from

    February 12 to March 13 (Falgun 2073 BS).

    We collected various stories by

    conducting daily media monitoring of

    national mainstream and online sources

    viz.: The Himalayan Times, Republica, The

    Kathmandu Post, Kantipur, Naya Patrika,

    Rajdhani, Annapurna Post, The Rising

    Nepal, Gorkhapatra, Nepali Times, Himal

    Khabar, Online Khabar, Setopati,

    Pahilopost and Nepal Khabar. In

    addition to that, random search was also

    carried out in the internet with the

    keyword ‘nutrition’.

    During this period, we managed to

    gather a total of 24 media stories related

    to nutrition. The collected stories were

    recorded in Microsoft Excel detailing the

    date, title, sources and links to the story.

    The stories were then synthesised and

    categorised into various themes and

    sub-themes. Therefore, three-step

    process was followed: information

    finding, information recording, and

    analysis. The major findings from out

    media monitoring study are as follows;

    MAJOR FINDINGS

    The major finding from the stories in

    media have been broadly categorized

    into the following categories; Current

    Scenario, Issues and Efforts Made.

    CURRENT SCENARIO

    According to the stories presented in the

    news sources the situation of malnutrition

    in Nepal seems critical. A story in Naya

    Patrika reports that a 2.5 months old

    infant from Lamjung has been suffering

    from malnutrition due to financial crisis in

    her family. She is the first daughter of 16

    years old Anju and Govinda Budaprithi.

    Her mother neglected taking proper

    food during her pregnancy and despite

    of her awareness on importance of

    nutritious diet during pregnancy, she was

    deprived from it due to her financial

    inability.

    http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/02/12/125388/http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/02/12/125388/

  • 2 | P a g e

    Source: Naya Patrika, February 14

    Similarly, according to a story in

    Annapurna Post, Dadeldhura’s Sarathi

    Budhair, was deprived of nutritious diet

    during her pregnancy as she was unable

    to afford the diets recommended by the

    doctors. Her twin daughters are both

    malnourished now. Similarly a 20-month

    old Ayush Roka of Kalikot is also

    malnourished. Her mother gave birth at a

    very young age and did not have much

    knowledge about food intake or

    pregnancy during the time.

    The level of ignorance on nutrition and

    healthy food among Nepalis is

    unbelievable according to an article in

    My Republica. It suggests that lack of

    awareness is the main reason behind

    Nepal’s malnutrition problem. The article

    suggests that most kids are fine until they

    are breastfeeding and start developing

    deficiencies as they start going to school,

    this is particularly true in urban areas

    where little children have to walk for

    hours to reach school and don’t eat

    anything during their day. Even when

    they return home, in most cases, their

    parents tend to be so busy and they

    don’t have time to cook meals in the

    afternoon, and children have to wait till

    dinner for a decent meal. Another

    important issue is the type of food Nepali

    people tend to consume. People do not

    follow a balanced approach to their

    diets in Nepal and emphasise on eating

    large amount of rice, dhedo or potatoes.

    As long as their belly is full, they don’t

    seem to care much about the vital

    nutrients they are missing out on.

    A news report on The Himalayan Times

    mentions that a recent report released

    by DPHO in Bajura has revealed that

    malnourished girls outnumber the boys

    by a huge margin in the district. In the

    district 727 girls out of 135 children were

    reported to be suffering from

    malnutrition. DPHO has also claimed that

    many mothers tend to actively

    participate in breastfeeding only if their

    child was a boy. Another story involves a

    six year old girl named Om Maya Mijar of

    Dhading who has been battling

    malnutrition from birth. She is the third

    daughter of 26 years old Juthi Mijar who

    is both underweight and much shorter

    than normal for her age and has

    problems with sitting and waling

    properly. Juthi has 5 children and is

    currently pregnant and all her children

    are reported to be malnourished. Juthi

    says that they have very little food and

    can barely manage one mean per day.

    In Dhading, more than 100 children are

    malnourished particularly from the Dalit

    and the chepang community. Although

    the government and various non-

    government organizations have

    reportedly launched nutrition

    programmes here, no results have been

    reported. More than 700 children are

    known to be malnourished in the district.

    Another story in The Himalayan Times

    involves a 14-month-old boy has

    succumbed to malnutrition in Pajaru of

    Jajarkot district on Wednesday. Anegat

    Nepali who was first son to Hira Nepali

    and Karna Bahadur Nepali. The child

    weighed only five kg and was receiving

    treatment. However, he breathed his last

    while being taken to the district

    headquarters for further treatment last

    night. It has been learned that the child’s

    parents were busy taking him to shamans

    for treatment rather than going to a

    medical facility earlier.

    http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/02/12/125388/http://www.annapurnapost.com/epaper/detail/271#&gid=1&pid=11http://www.myrepublica.com/news/15781?categoryId=117https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/malnutrition-afflicts-girls-boys/https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/malnutrition-afflicts-girls-boys/https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/14-month-old-dies-malnutrition-jajarkot/

  • 3 | P a g e

    In Hetauda, over 8% children have been

    found to be malnourished, and most of

    them are victims of the April earthquake

    and belong from areas where food

    scarcity prevail. It has been found that

    people living in temporary sheds are

    prone to be malnourished. In the district

    about 500 children have been found to

    be severely malnourished and 2400

    children to be suffering from mild

    malnutrition.

    ISSUES

    The major issues reported through media

    stories on nutrition for this month is the

    obstruction of immunisation programmes

    in several districts from Terai regions. A

    report in My Republica has covered the

    story of polio vaccine administration

    programme has been obstructed due to

    protest of health workers in various

    districts. A programme which had not

    been interfered during the 10 years of

    insurgency, has been barricaded by the

    health workers themselves. In Kailali, the

    immunisation programme has been

    obstructed due to protests of the health

    workers. The protest had delayed the

    arrival of necessary vaccine affecting

    116, 846 children below five years of age

    in the district and the case is similar for 15

    other districts.

    In Nepal, malnutrition is caused by a

    series of underlying factors ranging from

    cultural beliefs and superstitions,

    widespread poverty, poor health

    facilities, sanitation, early childcare

    practices and agricultural investments..

    Political instability and frequently

    changing government has affected the

    nutrition programmes and nutrition

    specific policies.

    EFFORTS MADE

    It has to be acknowledged that several

    efforts have been made to improve the

    nutritional status in Nepal by both public

    and private agencies and noticeable

    progress has been made in this regard. A

    news story in The Himalayan Times, a

    nutrition programme to eradicate

    malnutrition in children from Ramechhap

    district has become successful, with

    almost all children successfully treated.

    The programme was launched with the

    help of UNICEF after the 2014 earthquake

    to identify and treat malnourished

    children. According to District Health

    Office, Dhading, in a survey among

    28,682 children, most were found to be

    malnourished in varying degrees. The

    DHO said that shelters have been

    established to treat severe malnutrition in

    11 places, and mild malnutrition in 32

    places in the district.

    Source: The Himalayan Times

    A story in Naya Patrika mentions that

    upon hearing the story of Anju and

    Govinda Budaprithi’s 2.5 month old

    daughter from Lamjung, an employee

    from Naya Patrika, Deepak Adhikari had

    provided 10,000 Rupees as help to the

    couple. The money was provides to buy

    and feed proper food to the infant

    daughter. Such small contributions could

    prove to be invaluable to the couple

    and their daughter.

    http://kantipur.ekantipur.com/news/2017-02-22/20170222082000.htmlhttp://www.myrepublica.com/news/15882?categoryId=24http://www.myrepublica.com/news/15866?categoryId=24https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/nutrition-drive-yielding-results-ramechhap-vdcs/https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/malnutrition-afflicts-girls-boys/https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/malnutrition-afflicts-girls-boys/https://thehimalayantimes.com/nepal/nutrition-drive-yielding-results-ramechhap-vdcs/http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/02/13/125484/

  • 4 | P a g e

    Source: Naya Patrika, February 13

    Some positive stories have also been

    reported. According to a news story in

    Gorkhapatra, the cases of malnutrition

    has been declining in Kavrepalanchowk

    district. The number of children suffering

    from malnutrition has gone down to 500

    from 3535 within the past two years

    according to the DHO in Kavre. The

    cases were extremely high during the

    time of the earthquake as much children

    were deprived of proper food. However,

    the situation has improved a lot in the

    district.

    Furthermore, according to news stories

    reported in The Kathmandu Post,

    Nagarik, Annapurna Post, Gorkhapatra

    and Naya Patrika, the Ministry of Health

    has decided to book 18 government

    officials, including chiefs of three district

    health offices for obstructing the polio

    vaccination campaign. They have

    Source: Annapurna Post, March 5

    been asked to provide a written

    clarification within three days why

    departmental action should not be

    taken against them which could affect

    their career prospects.

    According to My Republica the Ministry

    of Health is also planning to relocate the

    some health staffers after their protests

    reportedly affected the polio

    immunisation program in 15 districts. A

    day after the two-day polio vaccination

    programme obstruction, the

    government on Monday launched door-

    to-door polio administration drive in 15

    districts of the country to ensure that

    children are not deprived of regular

    immunisation according to The

    Kathmandu Post.

    Source: My Republica, March 5

    In addition to it, WHO office for South-

    East Asia has called for a healthier future

    for newborns and mothers in several

    countries including Nepal. They have

    concentrated their attention and have

    designed strategies to help support

    nations in overcoming the problem of

    malnutrition. In the South-East Asia

    Region, each year birth defects are

    responsible for an estimated 90,000

    newborn deaths, said the UN health

    agency. WHO office in SEA has called for

    a healthier future for newborns and

    mothers in several countries including

    Nepal. They have concentrated their

    attention and

    http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/02/13/125484/http://gorkhapatraonline.com/epaper/showimage?img=uploads/epaper/2017-02-16/1b87f3e6e720972c351327d70f00f04f.jpghttp://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-03-06/18-officials-booked-for-disrupting-polio-drive.htmlhttp://www.nagariknews.com/news/15511http://www.annapurnapost.com/news/65804http://gorkhapatraonline.com/epaper/showimage?img=uploads/epaper/2017-03-06/89a338ce7206e106de934031e63c392e.jpghttp://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/03/06/129879/http://www.enayapatrika.com/2017/03/06/129879/http://www.myrepublica.com/news/15844?categoryId=24http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2017-03-07/govt-starts-door-to-door-drive.htmlhttp://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/printedition/news/2017-03-07/govt-starts-door-to-door-drive.htmlhttp://www.myrepublica.com/news/15882/?categoryId=24https://thehimalayantimes.com/kathmandu/who-calls-for-healthier-future-for-newborns-and-mothers/

  • 5 | P a g e

    DISCUSSIONS

    This report suggests that the threat

    malnutrition bears on infants and

    mothers in Nepal is colossal. Even today

    we find news of children dying from

    malnutrition and related diseases. Infants

    and children have continued to die over

    the past few decade just because of

    inadequate diet. Nepal is one of the

    poorest countries in the world with many

    people living under the poverty line.

    Many mothers have been deprived of

    nutritious food during pregnancy and

    new born infants are not fed adequately

    during their first years of life. Even in cases

    where the mother is well aware about

    the importance of nutritious food for her

    and her baby’s wellbeing, there are

    cases where proper food is inaccessible

    to them either due to geographical

    contains or financial inability.

    Furthermore, girls marrying at early and

    giving birth at an early age is another

    underlying factor behind malnutrition

    and child mortality in Nepal. Women

    from rural part of Nepal are widely

    engaged in the practice of child

    marriage. They are likely to have up to 4

    children before they reach age of 20.

    Without any sort of financial soundness

    and income source, they keep giving

    birth to more and more children. This has

    resulted in the children being

    malnourished and leaving them

    vulnerable to many illness. Such parents

    usually are illiterate and unaware of the

    importance of nutrition for their and their

    children’s wellbeing and belong to the

    rural parts of the country.

    Even among the children who are

    breastfed well are likely to suffer from

    malnutrition as they start going to school.

    Schools in Nepal do not provide food

    and are located far away from the rural

    villages. Children walk for hours each

    day to reach school and spend a lot of

    energy in doing so but their food intake is

    not proportional to the calories they

    waste during the day. Even when they

    eat, they may not eat healthy. Nepali

    people seem to have irregular diet

    patterns with tendency to eat large

    amount of rice and ignore other nutrients

    that they are missing out from their diet.

    Health seeking behaviour and

    availability of quality and accessible

    services at health facilities is also

    prevalent in Nepal. Although the

    treatment and facilities for treating

    malnutrition has become more efficient

    in Nepal, most patients, especially from

    rural areas, have little or no access to

    formal health services and do not visit the

    health facilities.

    There is existing belief on shamans and

    traditional healers. Lack of education

    and knowledge particularly in the most

    rural areas have contributed towards

    people believing that illness is a

    consequence of making the Gods and

    Goddesses angry. They prefer sacrificing

    animals as a remedy for malnutrition

    than seek professional medical help.

    Several protests and strikes in many

    districts of Nepal obstructed the

    administration of polio vaccines. The

    protest delayed the arrival of medicines

    and had halted the immunisation

    programme in several districts.

    Thousands of children and mothers were

    sent back home without vaccination.

    This is violation of people’s right to access

    health services. Policy makers and

    national leaders are preoccupied with

    their own agendas and have shown

    lesser regard to the substantial problem

    of malnutrition in Nepal.

    Causes of maternal and child

    malnutrition in Nepal constitute of

    poverty, socio-cultural, geographical

    and economic factors, among others

    while the underlying causes are lack of

    quality diversified diet, poor caring, lack

    of education and low utilisation of

    available health services. Many

    programmes and activities have been

  • 6 | P a g e

    undertaken by several national and

    international agencies in Nepal. Results

    have also been obtained but not up to

    the mark. The government and agencies

    have been trying to eradicate the

    problem in coordination with several

    international donors and agencies.

    Responsibilities need to be taken by all

    relevant stakeholders if we aim to reduce

    the burden of the problem anytime soon.

    CONCLUSION AND

    RECOMMENDATIONS

    Addressing malnutrition among children

    is pre-requisite for all social and

    economic development, and is vital for

    achievement of all Sustainable

    Development Goals (SDGs). Good

    nutrition provides a strong base for

    development of the country and

    provides the much needed structure to

    ensure that people physically and

    mentally capable to achieve their

    potential. This would require attention

    and effective actions by all relevant

    stakeholders. Investing in nutrition has

    great benefits from improving an

    individual’s health to economic

    prosperity in the long run. Effective

    polices and interventions must come into

    play if they ought to bring changes at

    the grass-root level of the community.

    Government and non-government

    agencies need to take responsibilities

    and work in coordination to derive

    impact and reduce the burden imposed

    by malnutrition to the individuals, their

    families and the country as a whole.

    Adequate nutrition is a fundamental

    right. Nutrition plays vital role in the

    growth and development of the children

    not just physical growth but also mental

    and cognitive capacity of mind

    develops in between conception to

    second birthday of a child also called

    first 1000 days. Nutrition advocacy, promotion and support efforts should be

    ensured to reach the needy and

    marginalised populations. Mere policy

    and strategy cannot yield foreseeable

    results, they have to be effectively

    implemented. There is a strong need to

    improve the health service delivery

    systems which can ensure the desired

    change.

    The programmes on nutrition needs to be

    integrated with livelihood activities to

    reduce the extent of children suffering

    from acute malnutrition. Better

    communication mechanisms needs to

    be set up for an effective two way

    communication to occur which could

    prove vital in raising the awareness level

    and dissemination of life saving

    information to the vulnerable people.

    Furthermore, the government needs to

    encourage the agricultural production in

    order to reduce poverty and food

    scarcity. By investing in nutrition-sensitive

    agricultural programmes, there can be

    sustained impact on health and

    productivity of families.

    Women’s access to adequate nutrition,

    including folic acid and iodine must be

    guaranteed through supplementation or

    food fortification. The enjoyment of an

    environment free of harmful chemicals,

    too, should be assured. And vaccination

    coverage that can protect pregnant

    women and their unborn babies from

    defect-causing diseases such as rubella

    needs universal access. All concerned

    sectors such as local development,

    agriculture, health, education are

    responsible for improving nutrition for

    mothers, newborns and children under

    the age of 5. Long term nutrition goals of

    the country to be oriented towards

    significantly reducing malnutrition to the

    point that it is no longer an impending

    factor towards development.

  • HERD is a dynamic national non-governmental organisation,

    promoting evidence informed policies and practices for

    sustainable development in health, environment and social

    sectors to improve quality of life.

    Cover final2Media Monitoring Report on Nutrition - Falgunlast page