8/14/2019 21 Cervantes v CA.doc

1/5

8/14/2019 21 Cervantes v CA.doc

2/5

F. ID.@ ID.@ ID.@ CAS AT =AR. No#$#h'#a%+$% *AL>' a$0-r" #o ra$'" #h" +""%'" o0ac6 o a-#hor$#: o #h" 'a$+ *AL a"%#' $% $#' a%'"r or $% a ;o#$o% #o +$';$'', #h" o;$''$o%a' c-r"+ '$%c" #h" 'a$+ $''-" a' 0$#$a#"+ -!o%, a' 'ho% /: #h" #"'#$;o%: o #h"!"#$#$o%"r $% #h" co-r'" o #r$a0. TIHCcA5. CIVIL LA?@ DAMAGS@ MORAL DAMAGS@ NOT *RSNT IN CAS AT =AR. I% aar+$% ;ora0 +a;a"' or /r"ach o co%#rac# o carr$a", #h" /r"ach ;-'# /" a%#o%

a%+ +"0$/"ra#"0: $%E-r$o-' or #h" o%" r"'!o%'$/0" ac#"+ ra-+-0"%#0: or $#h ;a0$c" or /a+a$#h. *"#$#$o%"r 6%" #h"r" a' a '#ro% !o''$/$0$#: #ha# h" co-0+ %o# -'" #h" '-/E"c# #$c6"#,'o ;-ch 'o #ha# h" /o-h# a /ac67-! #$c6"# #o "%'-r" h$' +"!ar#-r". Sho-0+ #h"r" /" a$%+$% o /a+ a$#h, " ar" o #h" o!$%$o% #ha# $# 'ho-0+ /" o% #h" !"#$#$o%"r. ?ha# #h"";!0o:""' o *AL +$+ a' o%" o '$;!0" %"0$"%c". No $%E-r: r"'-0#"+ o% #h" !ar# o!"#$#$o%"r /"ca-'" h" ha+ a /ac67-! #$c6"# 'ho-0+ *AL r"-'" #o acco;;o+a#" h$; $#h #h"-'" o '-/E"c# #$c6"#.. ID.@ ID.@ M*LARY DAMAGS@ =AD )AITH IS NCSSARY. S-ch 6$%+ o+a;a"' $' $;!o'"+ /: a: o "a;!0" or corr"c#$o% or #h" !-/0$c oo+, a%+ #h" "$'#"%c"o /a+ a$#h $' "'#a/0$'h"+. Th" ro%-0 ac# ;-'# /" acco;!a%$"+ /: /a+ a$#h, a%+ a%aar+ o +a;a"' o-0+ /" a00o"+ o%0: $ #h" -$0#: !ar#: ac#"+ $% a a%#o%, ra-+-0"%#,r"c60"'' or ;a0"&o0"%# ;a%%"r. HCDAacD C I S I O N

*(RISIMA, !Th$' *"#$#$o% or R"&$" o% c"r#$orar$ a''a$0' #h" 25 -0: 1995 +"c$'$o% o #h" Co-r# o

A!!"a0' 1 $% CA GR CV No. F1F

8/14/2019 21 Cervantes v CA.doc

3/5

To r-0" o% #h" $r'# $''-", #h"r" $' a %""+ #o -o#" #h" $%+$%' /"0o. A' a r-0", co%c0-'$o%'a%+ $%+$%' o ac# arr$&"+ a# /: #h" #r$a0 co-r# ar" "%#$#0"+ #o r"a# "$h# o% a!!"a0 a%+'ho-0+ %o# /" +$'#-r/"+ -%0"'' or '#ro% a%+ co"%# r"a'o%'. FTh" ac#' o #h" ca'" a' o-%+ /: #h" 0o"r co-r# 5 ar", a' o00o'Th" !0a%" #$c6"# $#'"0 4h$/$# A or !0a$%#$@ h$/$# 1 or +""%+a%# !ro&$+"' #ha# $# $' %o#&a0$+ a#"r March 2, 199

8/14/2019 21 Cervantes v CA.doc

4/5

Co-r#, $' -%'-'#a$%a/0". Th"r"-%+"r, a$0-r" o a !ar#: #o !-# -! +""%'"' $% #h"$r a%'"r or$% a ;o#$o% #o +$';$'' $' a a$&"r #h"r"o. 00c+*"#$#$o%"r '#r"''"' #ha# #h" a00""+ 0ac6 o a-#hor$#: o #h" *AL ";!0o:""' a' %"$#h"r ra$'"+$% #h" a%'"r %or $% #h" ;o#$o% #o +$';$''. =-# r"cor+' 'ho #ha# #h" -"'#$o% o h"#h"r#h"r" a' a-#hor$#: o% #h" !ar# o #h" *AL ";!0o:""' a' ac#"+ -!o% /: #h" #r$a0 co-r# h"%N$cho0a' C"r&a%#"' a' !r"'"%#"+ a' a $#%"'' a%+ #h" +"!o'$#$o%' o #h" *AL ";!0o:""',

G"or$%a M. R":"' a%+ R-#h V$00a%-"&a, "r" !r"'"%#"+.Th" a+;$''$o% /: C"r&a%#"' #ha# h" a' #o0+ /: *AL>' 0"a0 co-%'"0 #ha# h" ha+ #o '-/;$# a0"##"r r"-"'#$% or a% "#"%'$o% o #h" &a0$+$#: o '-/E"c# #$c6"#' a' #a%#a;o-%# #o6%o0"+" o% h$' !ar# #ha# #h" *AL ";!0o:""' ha+ %o a-#hor$#: #o "#"%+ #h" &a0$+$#: o'-/E"c# #$c6"#' a%+ o%0: *AL>' 0"a0 co-%'"0 a' a-#hor$J"+ #o +o 'o.Ho"&"r, %o#$#h'#a%+$% *AL>' a$0-r" #o ra$'" #h" +""%'" o 0ac6 o a-#hor$#: o #h" 'a$+*AL a"%#' $% $#' a%'"r or $% a ;o#$o% #o +$';$'', #h" o;$''$o% a' c-r"+ '$%c" #h" 'a$+$''-" a' 0$#$a#"+ -!o%, a' 'ho% /: #h" #"'#$;o%: o #h" !"#$#$o%"r $% #h" co-r'" o #r$a0.R-0" 1

8/14/2019 21 Cervantes v CA.doc

5/5

*AL $00 $''-" #h" #$c6"#' o%0: -!o% #h" r$##"% a+&$c" o !0a$%#$ or co-%'"0. Th" #$c6"#$''-"+ $00 ha&" #h" 'a;" co%+$#$o%' a' r"&"%-" #$c6"#' o *AL, "c"!# #ha# '-ch #$c6"#' 'ha00/" '!"c$$ca00: r"'#r$c#"+ a' %o%7r"-%+a/0" a%+ %o%7"%+or'a/0". Th" #$c6"#4' $00 /" &a0$+ oro%" 41 :"ar ro; #h" +a#" o $''-a%c"@ 4*a" 1 o Ro00o, !a" 2 o CA D"c$'$o%4-%+"r'cor$% o-r' 3. -+" D$o;"+"' M. &$o#a o RTC7S-r$ao, =ra%ch 32.

F. Do%a#o &'. Co-r# o A!!"a0', 21 SCRA 19. 5. Ro00o, !. 15. . Ro00o, !. 1@ CA D"c$'$o%, !. 2. . 2