8/11/2019 3. Montilla vs Hilario
2/2
0+e b3 te 'o&te;t o* "e't%o& 1< o* Art%'(e , "+pr!,
!& te pro'ee%&" o* te Co&"t%t+t%o&!(
Co&$e&t%o&, te re(!t%o&
bet=ee& te 'r%me !& te o**%'e 'o&temp(!te b3 te
Co&"t%t+t%o& %", %& o+r op%&%o&, %re't !&
&ot !''%e&t!(. To *!(( %&to
te %&te&t o* te Co&"t%t+t%o&, te re(!t%o& !"
to be "+' t!t, %& te (e!( "e&"e, te o**e&"e '!&
&ot e;%"t =%to+t te
o**%'e. & oter =or", te o**%'e m+"t be ! 'o&"t%t+e&t
e(eme&t o* te 'r%me !" e*%&e %& te "t!t+te, "+' !", *or
%&"t!&'e,
te 'r%me" e*%&e !& p+&%"e %& C!pter T=o to S%;,
T%t(e Se$e&, o* te Re$%"e #e&!( Coe.
#+b(%' o**%'e %" &ot o* te e""e&'e o* m+rer. Te t!%&
o* +m!& (%*e %" e%ter m+rer or om%'%e =eter o&e b3 !
pr%$!te '%t%?e& or p+b(%' "er$!&t, !& te pe&!(t3
%" te "!me e;'ept =e& te perpetr!tor, be%& ! p+b(%'
*+&'t%o&!r3, too
!$!&t!e o* %" o**%'e, !" !((ee %& t%" '!"e, %& =%'
e$e&t te pe&!(t3 %" %&'re!"e.
B+t te +"e or !b+"e o* o**%'e oe" &ot !ere to te 'r%me !"
!& e(eme&t8 !& e$e& !" !& !r!$!t%&
'%r'+m"t!&'e, %t"
m!ter%!(%t3 !r%"e", &ot *rom te !((e!t%o&" b+t o& te
proo*, &ot *rom te *!'t t!t te 'r%m%&!(" !re p+b(%'
o**%'%!(" b+t *rom
te m!&&er o* te 'omm%""%o& o* te 'r%me.
&'%e&t!((3, t%" m%t "er$e !" ! =!r&%& !!%&"t
%">+!(%*3%& ! (!=3er-(e%"(!tor o& te b!"%" o* =!t %"
!((ee !& &ot
o& te &!t+re o* te o**e&"e %t"e(*. 7ere te
pet%t%o&er"6 propo"%t%o& "+"t!%&e, te re"+(t =o+( be
t!t %& e$er3 '!"e %&
=%' te !''+"e %" ! p+b(%' o**%'er or emp(o3ee, te
pro"e'+t%o& 'o+( !t =%(( eep ! member o* Co&re"" *rom
e&ter%&
!& !ppe!r!&'e !" !ttor&e3 *or te e*e&"e. Te
pro"e'+tor 'o+( o t%" b3 te "%mp(e e;pe%e&t o* m!%& te
&e'e""!r3
!$erme&t", e$e& to+, !" ! m!tter o* *!'t, tere =!"
&o e$%e&'e t!t te o**%'e e( b3 te e*e&!&t !
!&3t%& to
o =%t te o**e&"e.
B3 te "!me toe&, te *!'t t!t, !" !((ee, te e*e&!&t"
m!e +"e o* *%re!rm" =%' te3 =ere !+tor%?e to '!rr3 orpo""e"" b3
re!"o& o* te%r po"%t%o&", 'o+( &ot "+pp(3 te re>+%re
'o&&e't%o& bet=ee& te o**%'e !& te 'r%me.
)%re!rm"
o=e$er !& =ere$er obt!%&e !re &ot !&
%&re%e&t o* m+rer or om%'%e. Te 'r%me %&
>+e"t%o&, *or e;!mp(e, 'o+(
!$e bee& 'omm%tte b3 te e*e&!&t" %& te "!me or
(%e m!&&er !& =%t te "!me e!"e %* te3 ! bee&
pr%$!te
%&%$%+!(" !& *%re =%t +&(%'e&"e =e!po&".
M+rer" or om%'%e" b3 pr%$!te per"o&" =%t +&", (%'e&"e
or +&(%'e&"e
!re te e&er!( r+(e !& b3 p+b(%' o**%'er" te
e;'ept%o&.
Te"te b3 %t" 'o&"e>+e&'e", te pet%t%o&er"
'o&te&t%o& o& t%" po%&t %", (%e te
'o&te&t%o& %"'+""e %& te pre'e%&
p!r!r!p", +&te&!b(e. L%tt(e re*(e't%o& =%(( "o= t!t
b3 t%" 'o&te&t%o& te r%t o* (e%"(!tor" to !ppe!r !"
'o+&"e( =o+(
epe& o& =eter te =e!po&" +"e =ere te o**e&er"6
propert3 or p!rt o* te%r o**%'%!( e>+%pme&t8 !&
"%&'e t%" m!tter
%" e;tr!&eo+" to te e*%&%t%o& o* te 'r%me o* m+rer,
te !ttor&e3"6 >+!(%*%'!t%o& or %">+!(%*%'!t%o&
=o+( (%e !t te mer'3
o* te pro"e'+t%& o**%'er. S+re(3, %t 'o+( &ot !$e
bee& te %&te&t%o& o* te *r!mer" o* te
Co&"t%t+t%o& to m!e te
oper!t%o& o* te pro$%"%o& %& >+e"t%o& !&
o& ! *!'t+!( 'o&"%er!t%o& "o "(e&er !&
+&'ert!%&8 o& ! 'o&t%&e&'3 t!t
'o+( o&(3 be eterm%&e !*ter te tr%!( =!" o$er, =e&
te !ttor&e3"6 "er$%'e" =ere &o (o&er &eee.
Te pet%t%o& %" e&%e =%to+t 'o"t".
#!r!", C.0., )er%!, #!b(o, Be&?o&, #!%((!, Re3e", 0+o
!& B!+t%"t! A&e(o, 00., 'o&'+r.
C o p 3 r % t 1 9 9 4 - 1 9 9 9 C / T e ' & o ( o % e " A "
% !, & '.
