485AC - VIV

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    1/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    VIV Application toDeepwater Risers

    Steve Leverette

    Atlantia Offshore Limited

    December 2-3, 2003

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    2/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Thanks to:

    Thanos Moros, BP Owen Oakley, Jim Stear, Hugh Thompson, Chevron

    Kim Vandiver, MIT

    Guy Mansour, Atlantia

    T. Sarpkaya, Naval Postgraduate School

    Don Allen/Li Lee, Shell Global Solutions

    Rodney Masters, AIMS

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Introduction

    Risers and tendons

    Steel Catenary Riser: SCR

    Top Tensioned Riser: TTR

    Flexible Riser

    Free Standing Riser: FSRHighly Compliant Riser: HCR

    Tendons

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    3/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Perspective from the industry:

    The offshore industry has been made painfully aware of

    what may go wrong, how VIV may affect operations.

    The industry is having to be conservative because of

    uncertainties in environment and in engineering

    prediction tools.

    For water depths to 5000, we can proceed with

    reasonable solutions. For 10,000, we cannot afford

    high levels of conservatism and still afford to makemoney producing oil.

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    VIV is a resonant feedback

    phenomena

    Engineering in uncertainty:

    Risks not generally in getting

    design numbers wrong,

    but in not designing for new

    phenomena.

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    4/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Risks and Cost Impacts

    Risers and Tendons represent critical structural and oil

    containment systems

    Uncertain environment new phenomena being discovered

    Uncertain response highly non-linear, stochastic in nature

    Failure has high cost

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    5/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Environment

    Geography

    Mode experiment

    Types of Ocean Currents

    Typical and extreme magnitudes

    Durations

    Uncertainties, unknowns

    Combination with other events Ratio of environmental forces, shallow to deep

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    6/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    7/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MODE Experiment

    WHOI - 1970s

    Weather in the Oceans

    Fronts, temporal variation

    Large scale turbulence

    Vertical Structure

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Ocean Currents

    Tidal Currents (how they exist in deep water)

    Loop

    Eddy

    Storm (wind stress model) Inertial

    Slope

    Bottom Boundary Current (Sigsby Escarpment)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    8/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Ocean Currents

    loop current / eddy current

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Cold Core Current Profile

    0.0

    500.0

    1000.0

    1500.0

    2000.0

    2500.0

    3000.0

    3500.0

    0. 000 1. 000 2. 000 3. 000 4.000 5. 000 6.000 7. 000Velocity

    Depth-feet

    Ocean Currents

    Cold Core Eddy

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    9/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Inertial and Slope currents

    Morpeth

    Hurricane Earl

    Neptune

    Hurricane Georges 1.8 2.2 kts in 2000

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Sigsbee Escarpment

    Currents

    identified frombottom

    furrows

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    10/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Current profiles

    Allegheny

    Current Profiles

    0.0

    500.0

    1000.0

    1500.0

    2000.0

    2500.0

    3000.0

    3500.0

    0.000 2.000 4.000 6.000 8.000

    Velocity (ft/s)

    Depth-

    feet

    Orig. WarmCore

    New WarmCore Profile

    New ColdCore Profile

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    11/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Environment

    Insert DW Currents presentation

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    12/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    13/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    14/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    15/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Types of Risers:

    TTR - top tensioned riser

    SCR - steel catenary riser

    Flexible riser

    HCR - highly compliant

    FSR - free standing riser

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    16/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Typical dimensions

    4 flowline SCR

    4 flowline SCR with 9 buoyancy

    21 drilling riser

    48 drilling riser with buoyancy

    18 export SCR

    120 aircans

    8 tieback risers

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Effects of End Conditions

    Taper Joint

    Flexjoint

    Keel joint

    Tensioner/Gimbal

    Guide frames

    Cantilever wellhead

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    17/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    18/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    PRT at Full Extend, Null, Full Retract

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    19/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    20/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Buoyancy, cladding, strakes, etc

    Touchdown point

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    21/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    KingKong riser with Buoyancy

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Static response

    Vessel Offset

    Increased drag due to VIV

    Interference analysis

    Touchdown trench effects

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    22/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Dynamic response Modal analysis (string, beam models)

    Bending vs axial modes

    Finite versus infinite transmission models

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    TLP production Riser

    Modes 1-2,11-12,22-23

    TLPProduction Riser Lateral MotionMode Shape

    0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    0.7

    0.8

    0.9

    1

    -1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    Mode shape

    Relativeposition,x/L

    Mode 23

    Mode 22

    TLP Production RiserLateral Motion Mode Shape

    0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    0.7

    0.8

    0.9

    1

    -1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    Modeshape

    Relativeposition,x/L

    Mode 11 Mode 10

    TLP Production RiserLateral Motion Mode Shape

    0

    0.1

    0.2

    0.3

    0.4

    0.5

    0.6

    0.7

    0.8

    0.9

    1

    -1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    Modeshape

    Relativeposition,x/L

    Mode1

    Mode2

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    23/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Typhoon TLP Tendon Lateral Motion Natural Frequency

    (Pretension = 1917 kips)

    0.0

    0.5

    1.0

    1.5

    2.0

    2.5

    0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

    Mode Number

    Frequency,

    Hz

    Mode No Frequency, Hz

    1 0.090

    2 0.1803 0.271

    4 0.363

    5 0.456

    6 0.552

    7 0.650

    8 0.750

    9 0.853

    10 0.959

    11 1.069

    12 1.183

    13 1.301

    14 1.423

    15 1.549

    16 1.680

    17 1.816

    18 1.957

    19 2.10320 2.255

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Illustration of SCR Inplane Modes

    -3.0E-04

    -2.0E-04

    -1.0E-04

    0.0E+00

    1.0E-04

    2.0E-04

    3.0E-04

    4.0E-04

    0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500

    Node Number

    Cur

    vature(1/ft)

    Mode 1

    Mode 5

    Mode 10

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    24/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    -2250 -1750 -1250 -750 -250 250 750

    LOCAL-3 AXIS ; VP=(0.00,0.00,1.00)

    -

    500

    0

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    LOCAL-1AXIS

    Mean Position

    Mode No. 32

    -2250 -1750 -1250 -750 -250 250 750-500

    0

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    LOCAL-3 AXIS ; VP=(0.00,0.00,1.00)

    Mean Position

    Mode No. 2

    LOCAL-1AXIS

    Examples of SCR Mode Shapes

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDIllustration of Axial Modes Influence

    0.0E+00

    1.0E-03

    2.0E-03

    3.0E-03

    4.0E-03

    5.0E-03

    6.0E-03

    7.0E-03

    8.0E-03

    0 50 100 150 200 250

    In-plane Mode Number

    MaxCurvature(1/ft)

    -1000 -500 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

    LOCAL-3 AXIS ; VP=(0.00,0.00,1.00)

    -500

    0

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    3000

    350

    0

    LOCAL-1AXIS

    MeanPosi tion - G68_mean_2D_XY_110ModeNo.50 - G68_mean_2D_XY_110

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    25/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 400-1

    -0.5

    0

    0.5

    1

    excitation

    -400 -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 4000

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    xresponse

    amplitude

    Steady Flow Response for an Infinite Beam with

    Finite Length Excitation

    = 4.5

    Standing wave excitation

    power inL

    Traveling waves

    Standing wave response

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Matterhorn Production

    Risers

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    26/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Matterhorn production riser from

    main deck

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    27/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Jolliet Single Piece Tendon

    Provided by

    Steve Leverette

    Atlantia Offshore Limited

    Steel tendons 24 indiameter.

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    VIV response characterization

    Strouhal number, Reduced velocity

    Cl (AOD, Re, Vr)

    Pre-lockin, Lock-in, lock-out

    Power in, versus damping and radiation

    Effects of damping on response

    Power balance solution

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    28/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    VIV Characteristics

    stf DStU

    =

    r

    st

    UV

    f D=

    Strouhal Number

    Reduced Velocity

    St=0.2, Vr=5

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Historical Shear7, Clift Formulation

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    29/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Pre-lock-in, Lock-in, Lock-out

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Dynamic

    Response

    Power Balance

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    30/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Power Balance

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    31/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    In-line vs

    transverse

    Single-mode vs

    Multi-mode

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

    Bending and increased drag effects

    Spectral approach to response

    Uncertainties in response

    Typical hot spots

    Types of currents that are problematic

    Effect of increased tension (decrease mode,

    reduce bending)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    32/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fatigue caused by VIV

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    33/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fatigue

    log N = log a m log

    log N = log a m log [ (t/tref)k]

    API, AWS

    DOE, DnV

    1

    k

    i

    i i

    nDN=

    = Miners rule

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fatigue

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    34/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED Fatigue

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    (Kips)2/Hz

    0.01

    0.1

    1

    10

    100

    1000

    10000

    100000

    fre

    quency(Hz)

    Allegheny

    01/01/0100:00

    02/2612:00

    04/24 06/1912:00

    08/15 10/1012:00

    12/06 01/3112:00

    Date

    Tendon 1

    0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1

    1.2

    1.4

    1.6

    1.8

    2

    orr 03/25/02 17:13:52Confidential Property of Atlantia

    One Year of Tension Spectra

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    35/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Safety Factors

    Depends on application

    Typically 3 for structures

    Typically 10-20 for risers

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fatigue

    Fracture Mechanics

    Frequency Sensitivity: mode, curvature, no. cycles

    Ways to combine response modes Rainflow

    Spectral approach to fatigue (Wirsching, Dirlik)

    Sensitivity to assumptions

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    36/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Tendons in VIV

    OTC Paper

    Leverette, Rijken, Thompson, Dooley

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    37/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    38/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    The FIX

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    39/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Shel l Global Solut ions

    Fairings for drilling riser

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fairings for TLP tendon

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    40/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Fairings in moonpool

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Half strakes for pipelines

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    41/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    42/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    43/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    44/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Engineering tools, not simulators

    Summary of how they work

    Comparisons

    Why they vary so much

    CFD

    Wake models and other approaches

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    45/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Flow diagram of

    Shear 7 Analysis

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Riser Response to Currents

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    46/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Figure 8: Shear7 4.3 defines a smoothed lift coefficient curve by fitting two parabolas to

    three points defined by four user-specified values.

    1

    2

    4

    3

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    47/78

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    48/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Example Shear7 Analysis

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    49/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Shear7, Viva, Vivana, Vivarray

    Engineering tools, not simulators

    Summary of how they work

    Comparisons / Example

    Why they vary so much

    CFD

    Wake models and other approaches

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    50/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    The LiteratureReview Papers

    Parkinson (1974, 1989)

    Sarpkaya (1979, 1995)

    Griffin and Ramberg (1982)

    Bearman (1984)

    Pantazopoulos (1994)

    Books

    Blevin 1990

    Chen 1987

    Naudascher and Rockwell 1994

    Sumer and Fredsoe 1997

    Au-Yang 2001

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    51/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Recent Model Tests and Data Sets

    Deepstar St Johns, CFD, Lake Seneca

    Stride (2H Allegheny and model tests)

    VIVA

    PMB HCR Lake Pend Oreille

    BP

    Exxon

    Shell

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    52/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Other Issues

    Wake effects, riser arrays

    High Re performance of fairings/strakes

    Issue of low mass systems, frequencyindependence

    Directionality of currents, resulting stresshot spots

    Directionality of response amplitude Trenching

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Trenching

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    53/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Areas of Research and

    Development Empirical

    CFD

    Fairings

    JIPs MIT - VIVA MIT - Vandiver JIP and Shear7

    Deepstar (ARA CFD, Principia CFD, Lake Seneca, St.Johns)

    Several CFD proposals out

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    54/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Slides from Chevron (O. Oakley)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    55/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    riser undergoing hydro-elastic response; mesh and vorticitycontours in the wake are shown; note the difference in the shed

    wake pattern between the nodes and the anti-nodes of the structure

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    56/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Vortex Dislocations Visualizations

    Remax=1000 R-DNS Simulations

    Remax=100 R-DNS SimulationsRe=100 Experiments C.H.K. Williamson (1989)

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Re=100k

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    57/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Re=600k

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Re=4MM

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    58/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Grid for cylinder

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Strip theory approach to riser

    modeling (J. Kallinderis)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    59/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDConstant Contours of Spanwise Vorticity (non-dimensional)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    60/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Numerical Modeling

    SMC,

    ..

    k-..

    k-S-A

    S-AS-ASmag

    .

    none

    Turbulence

    Model

    DESRAN

    S

    LESDNSCFD

    Approach:

    CFD = computational fluid dynamics, solution of

    Navier-Stokes equations for fluid flow

    )(

    1)(

    0

    jjj

    ijjj

    i

    xxxj

    xx

    i

    xx

    ij

    x

    U

    UUU

    U

    =

    =

    =

    DNS direct numerical solver

    LES turbulence model spatial

    filter representation of turbulence

    fluctuations

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    CFD Spars2dof Modeling Straked Cylinder

    No chains, pipes or anodes

    S-A turbulence model

    Re = 34MM

    Navier-Stokes Solution:

    URANS - time averaging

    LES space averaging

    DES RANS in boundary

    layer & LES outside

    RANS Grid

    DES Grid

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    61/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED Displacement History

    Genesis spar, strakes only

    Pressure PressureVelocity Mag.

    30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120-90

    -80

    -70

    -60

    -50

    -40

    -30

    -20

    -10

    0

    Eastings(ft)

    Northings(ft)

    041707SES 04/17/01 07:00:01

    DESRANS

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Lock-in Slope

    Locked in

    Lock-out Slope

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    62/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Objectives and Challenges for High

    Mode Number, Flow-Induced VibrationModel Tests in Sheared Flow

    Prof. J. Kim Vandiver

    MIT

    June 3, 2003

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Principal Issues for High Mode Number VIV

    Response Prediction

    Does lock-in occur at high mode number in

    uniform and sheared flow?

    What are the statistics of single versus

    multi-frequency response in sheared flow?

    What are the statistics of in-line and cross-

    flow response?

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    63/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Principal Issues for High Mode Number VIV

    Response Prediction

    Do hydrodynamic damping models needimprovement?

    What fairing or strake coverage is required

    What is the effect of Reynolds number on St, C

    Ldamping and suppression effectiveness.

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    ( )6. , Reynolds number

    e

    DU xR

    =

    ( )2. , Reduced velocityR

    v

    U xV

    f D=

    25. ,

    2

    Modal damping and wave attenuation

    ss t t

    n

    r Land n

    m

    = =

    23. Reduced damping

    ( )

    n n

    f in

    R

    U x L

    21. mass ratio

    f

    m

    D

    Important dimensionless groups

    4. What about

    correlation length?

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    64/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    How is lock-in affected by mass ratio

    versus reduced velocity bandwidth?

    Is the response different if the wake adjusts itsfrequency to match the cylinder or the natural

    frequency adjusts to match the wake.

    21. mass ratio

    f

    m

    D

    R

    v

    V( )2. , lock-in bandwidth

    f the vibration frequency

    R R

    v Rc

    U xV dV

    f D V

    = = =

    =

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDA/D versus Reduced velocity (based on

    a fixed natural frequency)

    mr=34

    mr=0.78

    R

    Rc

    V

    V

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    65/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Castine field experiment in

    uniform flow(1981)Uniform flow on short lengths(75 feet)

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Site layout

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    66/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Cable, pipe and wire rope properties

    Cable was PVC plastic tubing with accelerometers,wires, strength members and potting compound,

    D=1.25 inches., s.g.=1.4

    Pipe was 1.631 inch steel tube with the cable pulled

    inside as the measuring instrument. S.g.=2.4

    Wire rope was polyethylene coated oceanographicwire, 3x19 construction. D=.28 inches, s.g.=2.5

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDCastine pipe response, L=75 ft, D=1.63

    inches, specific gravity = 2.4

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    67/78

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    68/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDStable lock-in events are aided by isolated

    natural frequencies with no overlap.

    Pipe, s.g.=2.4

    Tension

    FrequencyHz

    Cable, s.g.=1.4

    Ca= 0 and 1.0

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDAn example from Helland Hansen:Peak frequencies versus time. What is

    going on?

    From Robit Helland Hansen Report

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    100

    Date[Y

    Y-MM-DD]

    Power Spe ctra, Helland-Hansen, DACOS 2 (x-acc )

    98-05-04

    98-05-05

    98-05-06

    98-05-07

    98-05-08

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    69/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Wire rope: L=75 ft, D=0.25 inches, specific gravity = 2.6

    Steady beating around 6th mode, components 0.6 Hz apart

    Reduced velocity bandwidth of +-20%=+-2.6Hz

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Does lock-in occur at High Mode Number ?

    Increasing Overlap with Mode Number

    +/- 20 % Bandwidth

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5

    Uniform Flow Speed (m/s)

    ModeNumber

    Increase in Uniform flow speed Increasing overlap of competing

    modes

    Reduced velocity bandwidth of +-20% would include many modes.

    Can just one respond in a uniform flow? What happens in shear?

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    70/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Wire rope: L=900 ft, D=0.280 inches,

    specific gravity = 2.5

    Nearly uniform flow on a 900 foot long sample.

    +- 10% flow variation along the length

    Lock-in at 50th mode

    Conclusions:

    High mass ratio provides stable sharp resonances.

    VRbandwidth allows for some spatial tolerance toflow variations. Single frequency dominance ispossible in nearly uniform flows, even at highmode number.

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    2 2

    2

    2

    Two forms are equal:

    8 - Griffin

    Vandiver

    s et s

    f

    s ng

    f n

    mS

    D

    rS

    U

    =

    =

    The role of damping in uniform flow?The role of damping in uniform flow? The reducedThe reduceddamping is a statement of dynamic equilibriumdamping is a statement of dynamic equilibrium ..

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    71/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    ,

    A useful property is that:

    2 , the equation of an

    hyperbola for lines of constant lift coefficie t.n

    nL n u

    qC S

    D< > =

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    10-2

    10-1

    100

    101

    10-2

    10-1

    100

    101

    Lift Coe fficie nt in Phas e with Ve loc ity at Loc k-in

    Re duced Damping, Sg

    Peakres

    ponseA/D

    Cl =0.01

    0.02

    0.05

    0.10

    Cl =0.2

    0.5

    1.0

    Cylinder Data

    Cl=2S g*A/D

    Peak

    Response

    (A/D)

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    72/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    in

    ,2

    ,

    A flexible cylinder in a n on-uniform flow

    with a power-in reg ion of length L has a resonant

    m odal response given by:

    2 2

    In red are 3 key parameters in prediction pro

    L n in

    n

    L nn w n

    n u

    Cq

    D R

    UC L

    S

    = =

    u

    ,

    2 2

    u 2 2

    grams.

    They form a dimensionless group S and

    Average modal lift coefficient

    8 S

    L n

    n n t n n

    w in w in

    C

    R S M

    U L D L

    = =

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Consider a simple slab flow problem

    first to illustrate the example of limited

    power-in length.

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    73/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITEDShroud created a still water damped region

    Shroud covers this

    length, creates still

    water around the

    cylinder

    Uniform flowpower-in region

    U

    L

    Lin

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Example Experimental Data for a Slab

    Flow

    Tsahalis, D. T.,Experimental Study of the

    Vortex Induced Vibrations of a Long Model

    Riser Exposed to Uniform and Nonuniform

    Steady Flow, Houston, Texas, WesthollowResearch Center, 1985.

    Thank you to Shell Global Solutions for

    allowing me to publish these results.

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    74/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Experiment Details Steel pipe, O.D. = 1.5in(3.81cm)

    I.D. = 1.334in(3.39cm)

    U= 0.33 to 6ft/s(0.1 to 1.83 m/s) in steps of0.33ft/s(0.1m/s), modes 1 thru 3.

    Biaxial accelerometers at 5 points: L/8, L/4,L/2, 5L/8, AND 5L/6.

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Shrouds used to simulate slab

    flow cases.

    Exposed length of cylinder in 7 steps

    100%

    87.5%

    75.0% 62.5%

    50.0%

    37.5%

    25.0%

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    75/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Reduced Velocity versus Mode 2, peak A/D

    for various fractions of exposure length

    0.0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1.0

    1.2

    1.4

    1.6

    0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 10.0

    Vr, based on vibration frequency

    PeakresponseA/D,mod

    e2

    Lin=25% Lin=25% Lin=37.5% Lin=37.5% Lin=50%

    Lin=50% Lin=62.5% Lin=62.5% Lin=75% Lin=75%

    Lin=87.5% Lin=87.5% Lin=100% Lin=100% Lin=100%

    Delta Vr =0.42

    r

    v

    UV

    f D=

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Jump to DS 6402 presentation

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    76/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusion

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Industry Experience(interesting bits of history)

    BNOC West of Shetlands

    BP Scheihellion experiences

    Exxon Brazil

    Andaman Sea

    West Seno Risers and Tendons

    Auger Top Tensioned Sales Riser

    Allegheny SCR clashing Allegheny trenching

    Matterhorn (effects of cantilevered wellhead, strakes help installation,cold core re-fit)

    Typhoon SCR design and cold core issue

    Discovery of cold core/submerged current events

    Atlantis (and Thunder Horse) Sigsby Escarpment, high bottomcurrents, full straked riser 7200 WD, 12 deg top, ~10,000 for 2export, 6 production

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    77/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    AgendaIntroduction

    Environment

    Riser Response to Currents

    Fatigue

    Tendons

    The FIX

    Analysis Methods and Programs

    Model Tests and Data Sets

    Other Issues

    Areas of R&D

    Industry Experience

    Conclusions

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

  • 8/14/2019 485AC - VIV

    78/78

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUP

    ATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    MEMBER OF THE IHCCALAND GROUPATLANTIA OFFSHORE LIMITED

    Summary and Conclusions

    VIV is significant design issue in deep water

    Highly non-linear in excitation and in damage

    Instability of wake, not easy to predict

    Industry addressing problem through many studiesand investigations