18
21 2011 10 古代文明 October,2011 5 4 The Journal of Ancient Civilizations Vol.5 No.4 [拜占庭与欧洲中世纪] 拜占庭《农业法》译注 要: 《农业法》是拜占庭历史上一部重要的法典。它规范了拜占庭农庄中居民的生产生 活行为,内容涉及村庄组织、土地占有与使用、农民权益、对违法行为的惩罚措施等方面,反映 出拜占庭帝国中期农村经济生活的一般状况,是研究拜占庭农村经济制度的极为宝贵的原始资 料。自该法典被发现以来,国外学术界对其研究已有多年,其中阿什布尔纳的希腊文校勘本与英 文译本是现今学者们认可的权威文本。本文根据阿什尔布纳的校勘本为底本、并参考其译本对《农 业法》进行译注,意在提供更切近希腊原文的中文文本。 关键词:拜占庭 《农业法》 译注 拜占庭《农业法》是拜占庭帝国法律史上一部实用性的法律汇编手册。 1 它出现于公元 8 世纪左 右,由伊苏里亚王朝时期的法学家汇编成册。 2 关于《农业法》的成书年代与编纂者,是学术界争论颇多的问题。最早发现的《农业法》版本, 14 世纪拜占庭帝国立法汇编《法学六书》(ἑξάβιβλоς)的附录文件,据此学者们推测该法出自六 书编撰者——萨洛尼卡城大法官君士坦丁·哈门诺布罗斯(Κωνσταντίνος Αρμενόπουλος1320 年—1383 年)之手。德国学者扎哈利亚·冯·林根绍尔(Zachariä von Lingenthal)在《希腊罗马法律 手稿史》(Historiae Juris Graeco-Romani Delineatio)一书中最早提出,《农业法》成书于 8 9 世纪, 由私人编纂而成,其观点得到不少学者的支持。 3 后在《希腊罗马法律史》(第三版)中,他又将该法 的成书时间锁定为 8 世纪 40 年代,并归于伊苏里亚王朝皇帝利奥三世与君士坦丁五世的立法成果。 4 英国学者阿什布尔纳保守性地同意林根绍尔视《农业法》为官方立法的观点,但他认为该法出现于 8 本文是教育部人文社科重点研究基地项目“中古时期拜占庭立法文献研究与评注”(批准文号: 08JJD770102)的阶 段性成果。 1 《农业法》,希腊文原文为 Νόμος Γεωργικός,拉丁文为 Leges Rusticae,英文译文通常为 Rural Code 或者 Farmer’s Law但事实上,该《农业法》并非适用于拜占庭帝国从事农业生产的所有阶层,也并不用来调整帝国内所有农事关系。它 的适用范围,仅限于由耕种自有土地的农民组成的村庄。因此,将本法译为《农业法》,易产生扩大其适用范围的误导。 译者以为,译做《村庄农事法》似更适合该法的实际适用范围。但由于标题 Νόμος Γεωργικός 原文意为“农业之法”, 而学术界多年来也沿以为习,故本文仍使用“农业法”这一译法。 2 拜占庭法律研究方面的权威学者扎哈利亚·冯·林根绍尔认为,“这部法典是将査士丁尼立法中的部分内容与地方习 惯法的部分法规组合在一起的产物”,阿什布尔纳也称它“涵盖两个部分,民事的和刑事的。民事部分规范着一个特定 社会单元范围内的农民之间的关系„„这部分农业法在本人看来整体上似乎为新的立法,这是由帝国境内的新移民引 起的变化,至少是在某种程度上受到了新移民从他们的故地带来的习惯法的影响出现的新变化。„„农业法其他条款 构成了刑法部分,处理的是农业犯罪事宜。„„主要依据早期的法律资料„„这部分的农业法主要是罗马法”(Walter Ashburner, “The Farmer’s Law”, Journal of Hellenic Studies, Vol. 30 [1910], pp. 85-108, esp. p. 85,行文中简作“阿氏本 1”; Walter Ashburner, “The Farmer’s Law II”, Journal of Hellenic Studies, Vol. 32 [1912], pp. 68-95, esp. pp. 83-84,行文中简作 “阿氏本 2”)。 3 参见 Walter Ashburner, “The Farmer’s Law”, p. 85. 4 Zachariävon Lingenthal, Geschichte des griechisch-römischen Rechts, Berlin 3 1892, 249-250.

拜占庭_农业法_译注_王翘

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

-

Citation preview

  • 21

    2011 10 October,2011 5 4 The Journal of Ancient Civilizations Vol.5 No.4

    []

    1 8

    2

    14

    1320

    1383Zachari von Lingenthal

    Historiae Juris Graeco-Romani Delineatio 8 9

    3

    8 404

    8 08JJD770102 1 Leges RusticaeRural CodeFarmers Law

    2 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law, Journal of Hellenic Studies, Vol. 30 [1910], pp. 85-108, esp. p. 85 1 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, Journal of Hellenic Studies, Vol. 32 [1912], pp. 68-95, esp. pp. 83-84 2 3 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law, p. 85. 4 Zachari von Lingenthal, Geschichte des griechisch-rmischen Rechts, Berlin 31892, 249-250.

  • 22

    9 1Georgije Ostrogorski,

    2 E. E. Lipshitz

    8

    , ,

    , ,

    , 3

    8

    4

    5

    6

    11Paris.gr.1367 Marcianus

    gr. fondo antico.579

    111778

    Paris.gr.1383 12 Roe

    18 14Laurentianus. lxxx6 15 Vaticanus.gr.845 12

    1 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, p. 83. 2 Georgije Ostrogorskiber die vermeintliche Reformttigkeit der Isaurier, Byzantinische Zeitschrift 30, 1929/30,

    394-399 Georgije Ostrogorski, History of Byzantine state, New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press,1969, pp.90-91. 3 1999 6 118122 4 5 Walter

    Ashburner, The Farmers Law, pp. 85-108 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, pp. 68-951999 6 123128 6 1349 ZakonikThe Russkaia PravdaPskovskaia udnaia gramota D. Obolensky, The Byzantine Commonwealth: Eastern Europe, 5001453, New York, NY: Praeger Publishers, 1971, pp.402-409 Ferdinand Feldbrugge, Law in Medieval Russia, Leiden: Koninklijke Brill NV , 2009, p. 71, p. 81, pp. 109-111 7 Knigi Zakonnye 8 Bodleian

  • 23

    2425261

    96 10

    852

    Contardo

    Ferrini 13Ambros. M68sup.

    3

    4 11 2075Vaticanus

    gr.2075 11 4

    1910 30 1912 325 857000

    6

    7

    1958

    85

    1 Ecloga ad Prochiron mutate Ecloga privataEpitome legumProchiron 40 Ecloga Legis Mosaicae 2 8 76 11 Marcianus gr.fondo antico .579 83 11Vaticanus gr.2075 11Ambrosianus Q 25 8412Marcianus gr. fondo antico. 167 85 3 2001 82 Gustav E.Heimbach, Manuale legum sive hexabiblos: cum appendicibus et legibus agrariis, Leipzig 1851 Contardo Ferrini, Edizione critica del kByzantinische Zeitschrift 7, 1898, pp.558-571Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law, pp. 85-108 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, pp. 68-95A. Albertoni, Per una esposizione del diritto Byzantio con riguardo allitalia, Imola, 1927, pag. 50F. Dlger, Ist der Nomos Georgikos ein Gesetz Kaiser Justinians II ? in: Paul Koschaker (hg.), Festschrift fr Leopold Wenger II, Mnchener Beitrge

    zur Papyrusforschung und antiken Rechtsgeschichte 35, Mnchen 1945, 18-48E. Bach, Les lois agraires byzantine du Xe sicle, classica et mediaevelia, vol.5,1942, p.70-91 4 11 13 Marcianus gr, fondo antico 579f.191v-194v11 Ambrosianus Q 25 sup.f.5r-10v11)Paris gr.1367 f.97r-100v12) Paris gr.1384 f.128r-134r12 )Marcianus gr. fondo antico 167 f.37r-47r12 )Vallicellianus E55 f.241v13 5 Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law, pp. 85-108; Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, pp.68-95. 6 1 2. Alan Harvey, Economic Expansion in the Byzantine Empire, 900-1200, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989Warren T. Treadgold, History of the Byzantine state and society, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press,1997Adolf Berger, Encyclopedic dictionary of Roman law, vol.43, part 2, Philadelphia, PA: The American Philosophical Society, 1953Herbert Felix Jolowicz & Barry Nicholas, Historical introduction to the study of roman law, New York/London: Cambridge University Press, 1972 7 1999 6 2008 16 2008 8

  • 24

    1

    1 66

    2

    66

    66

    85

    3

    1. [1][2][3]

    [4]

    [1] colonus

    [2]

    [3]

    [4]

    1 1958 3942 1959 8395 2 3132 33 3

  • 25

    2. [1]

    [1]

    13152122

    2 71

    3.

    4. A

    B

    A A

    5.

    6. [1]

    [2][3]

    ()

    [1]

    [2]

    [3]

    7. [1][2][3]

    [4]

    [1]

    [2]

    Theod.ii.261

    de finede loco /de locis

    1 Theod. Codes Theodosianus

  • 26

    Theod.ii.26, 3

    [3]

    8 10

    1,

    [4] 384

    8. [1][2]

    [1]

    2 88

    [2]

    9. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    2

    9 10

    3

    [2]

    1 A. H. M. Jones, The Later Roman Empire, vol. 1, Oxford:

    Basil Blackwell, 1964, 479ff 2 Henry George Liddell & Robert Scott, A Greek-English Lexicon, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996, p. 1147. 3 See Walter Ashburner, The Farmers Law II, pp. 82-83 Paul Lemerle, The agrarian history of Byzantium, from the

    origins to the twelfth century: the sources and problems, Galway: Galway University Press, 1979, p.38.

  • 27

    10. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    11 3/4 1/4

    [2]

    11. [1]

    [2]

    [1] ,

    [2] 11 15

    12.

    [1]

    [1] 1213 1213

    13.

    14. [1]

    [1] 14 18 19

    21

    15.

  • 28

    [1][2]

    [1]

    [2]

    16. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    17.

    18. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    19. [1][2]

    [3]

    [1]

    [2]

    [3]

    20.

    21. [1]

    [1]

    2[1]

    22. 12 [1]

    [2]

  • 29

    [1]

    10 4% 6 111 1/2881

    [2] 122

    12

    [1]

    [1] 23

    1367Paris gr.1367 f.97r-100v

    23

    23. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    24.

    25.

    26. [1]

    [2][3]

    [1]

    [2]

    [3] ()

    27. [1]

    [1]

    28. [1]

    1 Philip Grierson, Byzantine Coinage, London: Methuen & Co. Ltd, Berkeley & Los Angeles: University of California Press,

    1982, pp.15-16. 2 Georgije Ostrogorski, Lohne und Preise in Byzanz, Byzantinische Zeitschrift 32, 1932, 297.

  • 30

    [1] 26 27

    29. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    30. [1]

    [2]

    [1] 41[1]

    [2]

    31. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    32. [1][2]

    [3]

    [1]

    1

    [2]

    [3] 2[1]

    33. [1][2][3]

    [1]

    [2]

    [3]

    1 See Alan Harvey, Economic Expansion in the Byzantine Empire, 900-1200, p. 18. Also see Jacques Lefort, The Rural

    Economy, Seventh-Twelfth Centuries, in Angeliki E. Laiou ed., The Economic History of Byzantium From the Seventh through the Fifteenth Century, Washington, D.C.: Dumbarton Oaks Research Library and Collection, 2002, p. 79.

  • 31

    34. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2] 33[3]

    35.

    36.

    [1]

    [1]

    37 52

    37.

    [1]

    [1]

    38.

    [1]

    [1]

    21[1]

    39.

    [1]

    [1]

    40.

    41. [1]

    [1]

    42.

    43.

    [1]

  • 32

    [1]

    44. [1]

    [1]

    45. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    1

    [2]

    47

    46. ()

    [1][2]

    [1]

    [2] 46 47 -

    47. [1][2]

    [1]

    [2]

    48.

    49.

    [1]

    [1] 53

    50. [1]

    [1]

    1 Alan Harvey, Economic Expansion in the Byzantine Empire, 900-1200, p.16.

  • 33

    51. [1]

    [1]

    52. [1]

    [1]

    53.

    [1]

    [1] 49[1]

    54. [1]

    [1]

    55.

    [1]

    [1]

    56. [1]

    [1]

    57. [1]

    [1]

    58. [1]

    [1]

    59.

    60. [1][2]

    [1] 1 3

    [2]

    61.

    62. [1]

    12[2]

    [1]

    [2] 22[2]

    63. [1]

  • 34

    [1]

    64. [1]

    [1]

    Dig.xlvii, 9, 91

    65.

    66.

    [1]

    [1]

    2

    67.

    [1]

    [1]

    3

    2 93

    28

    pignus

    hypotheca4

    antichresis

    68.

    1 Dig. Digesta Pandectae 2 Paris gr.1367 f.97r-100v12 ) Paris

    gr.1384 f.128r-134r12 ) 3 4 1993 199

  • 35

    69. [1]

    [1]

    70. [1]

    [1] 12 1

    121 24

    1.136 1 320

    71.

    [1][2]

    [1]

    [2]

    72.

    [1]

    [1]

    73.

    74.

    75.

    [1]

    [1]

    76.

    [1] 12

    [1]

    77.

    12

    78.

    30

    79.

  • 36

    30[1]

    [1]

    80. [1]

    [1] 6

    81. [1]

    [2]

    [1]

    [2]

    82.

    83.

    [1]

    [1]

    84.

    85.

    [(1978) 130024;

    (1982) ]

    [2010 12 5]

  • 110

    2011 10 October,2011 5 4 The Journal of Ancient Civilizations Vol.5 No.4

    Contents and Abstracts

    [Theories and Thoughts]

    Title: The Definition of Ethnicity about neighboring Peoples in History/2

    Author: Shen Jian, Professor, History Department, East China Normal University, Shanghai, 200241, China.

    AbstractIt can be found in European ethnic history studies that the distinction and definition of ethnic belonging is a complex issue. Besides the factor of ethnic origin, geographical position is also an important reason.

    Ethnic group were always adjoined with or surrounded by alien peoples and different cultures, so that they

    were effected by the neighbor for a long time, and a certain variation might be to take place, even some

    transitional and mixed type ethnic-groups shaped. The controversy about the ethnic belongings for above

    case should be treated tolerantly .

    Key words: Ethnicity neighboring Peoples in History The Definition of Ethnicity

    [Ancient Mediterranean Civilizations]

    Title: A Chinese Translation of Hieroglyphic Text of Amenemhab Autobiography with Commentary/7

    Author: Li Xiaodong, Professor, Institute for the History of Ancient Civilizations, Northeast Normal University,

    Changchun, Jilin, 130024, China.

    Abstract: There was much of warfare during the 18th

    dynasty of New Kingdom in ancient Egyptian history, and

    the details of the wars could not known to us if there was not inscriptions concerning to them. The

    Autobiography of Amenemhab is one of the important documents for us to revive the wars, especially for the

    reigning years of Thutmose III, providing us a precise time, which forms original documents hard to come by

    for the study of chronology of 18th

    dynasty.

    Key words: Amenemhab autobiographical inscription the warfare of New Kingdom

    Title: A Survey of European and American scholarship on Roman Roads/12

    Author: Feng Dingxiong, Associate Professor, Faculty of Humanities, Zhejiang Ocean University, Zhoushan,

    Zhejiang, 316000, China.

    Abstract: The research on history of Roman Roads made by European and American scholars characteristically

    undergoes three stages: from modern times to the 20th century, the academic community did not pay enough

    attention to Roman Roads although some scholars began to be involved in its content. The history of Roman

    Roads, as an important part of Roman social history, failed to obtain the due position and sufficient research;

    in the first half of the 20th century, western scholars began to attach importance to the study of Roman Roads.

    During this period, regional studies and case studies were conducted but the comprehensive studies were not

    carried out. Therefore, in this period, studies of the Roman Roads were still in the initial stage; during the

    latter half of the 20th century, regional and comprehensive studies occupied a prominent position. Meanwhile,

    many works began to be concerned about the relevant social life. Academic studies on the Roman Roads

    launched the further development. However, on the whole, in the study on Roman Roads, there are still many

    unsatisfactory areas for further in-depth study.

    Key words: Roman Roads the Regional Studies the Case Studies the Comprehensive Studies

    Achievement and Areas for Further Study

    [Byzantine and the European Middle Ages]

    Title: A Chinese Translation of the Byzantine Famers Law with Commentary/21

    Author: Wang Qiao, Doctoral Candidate, School of History and Culture, Northeast Normal University,

    Changchun, Jilin, 130024, China; Li Qiang, Doctoral Candidate, Department of History and Archaeology,

    University of Ioannina, Ioannina, P.O.Box 1186, Greece.

    Abstract: Famers Law is an important code in the history of the Byzantine Empire, which regularizes the

    behaviors in production and life of Byzantine villages. Its provisions covers the organization of villages,

    the occupation and utilization of the land, the rights and interests of the peasants, the punishment for illegal

    activities, etcsketching the economic life of the Byzantine countryside in the Empires mid-period, it has

  • 111

    been regarded as an extremely precious material to study the rural economic system of Byzantium. The

    abroad research on Famers Law has been for years since it was found, W. Ashburners Greek critical text

    with its English version are the most authoritative which received considerable recognition by scholars. This

    study, on the basis of W. Ashburners works, provides the Chinese translation and commentary .

    Key words: Byzantium Famers Law Translation and Commentary

    Title: Norman Conquest and Emergence of English Identity: An Interpretation by Dint of Philology/37

    Author: Wang Yunlong, Professor, Institute of the Middle Ages Studies, Northeast Normal University, Changchun,

    Jilin, 130024, China.

    Abstract: In the years surrounding the battle of Hasting of 1066, and the Norman conquest of England, the

    philological sources subdivided either in England or in Normandy, and therefore maintain an affiliation to

    one of the two identities. In the contemporary philological sources, William I is considered to be the personal

    symbol of English identity, and England changed from toponym into ethnonym, English.

    Key words: identity Norman conquest William I

    [Eastern Asian History and Culture]

    Title: The Print of Jiaxing Zang and Its Dissemination in Japan/45

    Author: Zhang Hongwei, Associate Research Editor, Institute of the Imperial Palace, Palace Museum, Beijing,

    100009, China.

    Abstract: Jiaxing Zang (, The Collected Buddhist Scriptures Accomplished in Jiaxing) is a Chinese version of tripitaka started to be produced as a private project in the Wanli period of the Ming Dynasty.

    Japanese scholar Osamu Oba () has contributed a book dealing with the grand exchanges of the Buddhist texts between China and Japan during the period from 1694 to1754. Based upon a study of Osamu

    Obas result of research, this paper argues that the judgments of Osamu Oba on the importation of Buddhist

    texts from China to Japan during the concerned period is rather conservative. Furthermore, this paper

    confirms that this period is the peak time of the history of Sino-Japanese Buddhist cultural exchanges, and it

    concludes that Jiaxing Zang has its unique historic significance in the exchanges of Buddhist texts between

    China and Japan.

    Key words: Jiaxing Zang Osamu Oba Sino-Japanese exchanges Buddhist texts

    [Studies of Traditional Chinese Scholarship]

    Title: A Study of Luo Mi's Pedigree and His Book Lushi/59

    Author: Zhu Xianlin, Ph.D. Candidate, Scholl of Literature, Northeast Normal University, Changchun 130024,

    China.

    Abstract: The Pedigree of Luo Mi () has attracted little research attention and many questions remain unanswered. This paper conducts a rather comprehensive investigation to Luo Mis family background. It is

    found that Luo Mi received very sound academic education from his family which contributed significantly

    to his later writing of Lushi (, Grand History). The version of Lushi that exists today was actually assembled by the later scholars based upon Luo Mis works. Luo Mi made great efforts to write Lushi, while

    his son Luo Ping() was a key assistant to him in completion of the annotation to Lushi. Taken all the disputes about Lushi in consideration, it is clear that this book and its annotation preserved rich materials for

    later scholars studies in Chinese literature, history, and mythology.

    Key Words: Southern Song Luo Mi Pedigree Lushi

    [Imperial China]

    Title: A Study of the No.F116: W98 Unearthed Yuan Document from Khara-Khoto/70

    Author: Su Li, Lecturer, School of History and Culture, Northeast Normal University, Jilin, 130024, China.

    Abstract: This paper studies the context of the No. F 116: W98 unearthed document dated to the Yuan Dynasty

    from Khara-khoto. It points out that this document is actually a lawsuit petition paper of the Yuan Dynasty.

    Both sides involved were Tuntian soldiers, meaning soldiers who had both military and agricultural duties of

    that times. Furthermore, this study discusses the concrete paper formulation and procedure to conduct such

    kind of lawsuit petition during the Yuan period.

    Key words: Khara-Khoto Documents Yuan Dynasty lawsuit petition