105

8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

����������� ������������ �������������

� ���!�������#"$�&%������(')�*�+�,�-�,���#���#�

�/.���0� ���1�+�2�3�� �4����53')��3����.4���������������"����6� �7������.��������� �4� �$���������3���������"7�0��8���#���(�

8�-������.�8.3��(�9�+� �:�����;.#�(������<�,�. �,���� �*� �7����8"+�,�0� �����

.#���=���1�'>�����/� ��')�2�����(')�2�3��3�

5(�5!�#��+�4.����#?@���3�A�,��8.���"B

��������C�EDF8"G"B8�#�#��.#�(���('>5�����DGHJIKIML

Page 2: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

N;OQPSR/TVU WEXZY\[^]_XZR\`ba

Bc�dKe0fhgifkjklKm�nod�mqp�r0stmvutu2w�xEg0mvmyrzmyu{n2nt|F}K~0l�u1ntd0�+wCx�}Kg ��jhu{dMs2"G�Ku{�yfk�,5�}K�F}Kj���dMs�jh~�nos{d�g e0�yjk~0�w�mntd�nt|0m��=my}Ke n�x�&|0}J�Km��dKe0~0g�jh~���dMw��0jk~F}�ntdMstjk�yuvD���dKs(�vdM~�nojk~�eF}Kfkfkx�my~ �ydMe0st}K�Mjk~0��w�m�D }�~0g��dMs�}Kfkf�dK� no|0m!|0myfkri}K~0g��Me0jkgF}K~0�vm�|0m!��}��Mm�w�m!nt|0stdKe0�M|0dMe�n1�Mst}Kg0eF}�nom(ut��|0d�dMf���')dMut| m3�dKutmy~����myfkg�}�~0g$� mydMs{�Mm��,fh}Ke0�zmys{w�}K~���dMs,w�}K~�xQ|0myfkr ��e0f(�ydKw�w�mv~�ntuE}K~ gbg0jkut�ve0utu{jhdM~ uy����fhmvw�mv~0u5�st}K~0g@D2��~0g0so��u�� xM�Ks{����uyD&�<jkfk��s{jhmvg��w�s{jh��|@D(}K~ g$mv�Mmvs{xKdM~0mZjh~�nt|0mZ'>}�nomyw�}�ntjhl�}Kj��,e�n�}�nt��~�no�v�ymvnyD@��dMs�ntm�}K��|0jk~0��w�m�}K~0gVjk~0u{r0jhs{jh~ ��w�m��+��dMr0| jhm�"G}Kr0fh}K~�nom�D���dMs#| mys#u{mv�Mmvso}Kf1stm�}�g0jh~ �MudK�=wCxEnt|0myu{jhu!}K~0g��Md�d�gig0jhu{�ye0u{utjkdM~0u!dK��w�}K~�x�dK� nt|0m�stmyu{e0f¡nouy� � }K�0jkd,�dMu{utj0��dMs�}�fkc�}�x�u(�zmyjk~0�stmy}Kg x)}K~0g)m�}K�Kmys�nod¢g jhu{�ye0u{u w�}�no|0mvw�}�nojk�yuy�@')my�¢��stw�u�nostdK~0����dMs�}KfkfG|0mysmy~0�vdMe0st}K�Mmyw�mv~�ny�wCx�rF}Kstmv~�nou5�dM�Z}K~ g)5�}Kst�F}�so} D0w�x�utjku{ntmys�1}�w£D0}K~0g£}Kfkf@dK�+wCx���}�w�jkf¡x¢��dMs�nt|0myjks3fhdJ�KmC}�~0gute r0r=dKs{n�¤

@}Kw:�Mso}�ntmv��e0fMntd3no|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��rzmydKr0fhm2c�|0d�|0myfkrzmyg,��e0~0g�w�x,myg0e ��}�ntjhdM~��+w�x,rF}Ks{my~�nouvDno| m¢�~0jk�Kmys{utj¡n�xbdK����|0jh�y}K�Md0D+8��2%¦¥��~�ntmyst~0}�nojkdM~F}Kf!��myutmy}Kst��|�§¨�1p ��|0}K~0�Mmvui5�d�}Ks{g ©qD1���ª��+�#� �¥«��dMw�r0e ntmys�}K~ g£��e nodKw�}�nojkdM~��~0u{ntjknte nom d��Bno|0m,�e0~0��}Ks{j¬}�~��3��}Kg0mvwCx�d��&���yjkmy~0�vmyu�©ªD}K~0gZno| m���e0u{ntstjh}K~>')jh~ jhu�nos{xZd��2���vjhmv~0�ym�D ��st}K~0utrzdMs�n�}�ntjhdM~�D }K~0gZ��s�nouy¤

jkj

Page 3: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

`EN^­�W�X T$® O$T$R\`VXZR\`ba

����,�#�3�¯"+��. ��'>������ ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ jhj�#5���������� ¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ��������2���(�

HM¤°8�����3� .#�����3��,� ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HHM¤hH 5�stjkmv�1mqp�rzdMutj¡nojkdM~>d���nt|0m,ute0��±�mv�vn)¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HHM¤³² ��jku{ntdMs{x ¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ L

HM¤´²�¤hH ��dKw��0jk~F}�ntdMstjh}KfB�Mmvstute u�u{r=mv�vnost}KfBr0s{dMr=mvs{ntjhmvu�dK���Mst}Kr0|0u ¤C¤�¤�¤ LHM¤´²�¤³² �1p�nos{myw�}KfG�Mst}Kr0|�no|0mvdMs{x:¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HJµ

HM¤´¶ �2e0�0fkjh�y}�nojkdM~>u�n�}�nte0u�dK�+no|0m,stmvute0f¡noujk~£nt|0m,g0jhu{utmvs{n�}�nojkdM~ ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ H·²²�¤¦�(���"B�')8�����8�(� ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HJ¶

²�¤hH 5�}Ku{jh���Mso}�r0|�no|0mvdMs{x¸¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HJ¶²�¤³² �,st}Kr0|Zutrzmy�qnost}Z¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ H·¹

¶ ¤°�������#"G�����-�,���#���#���<����/')8���'>��'º�2��,�(���1��"G���<� �#� ¤�¤�¤ HJI¶ ¤hH �~�nostd�g0e0�qnojkdM~Q¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ HJI¶ ¤³² �#e nofkjh~ mCdK�+no| m�r std�dK� ¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ²Kµ¶ ¤´¶ �1}�nt|���fkjklKm�u{nos{e0�vnte0stm¸¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ²K¶

¶ ¤»¶ ¤hH ��mvc�jkstjk~0��nod��Mmvn}�rF}�nt|���fkjklKm,�Mso}�r0|¼¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ²M¹¶ ¤»¶ ¤³² �3| m�c!myjk�M|�nou�}Kstm,u�nostjk�vntfkxZg my�ys{m�}Ku{jh~ � ¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ²KI¶ ¤»¶ ¤´¶ ��dKfhfh}Kr0u{jh~0��f¬}�st�Mm �0fkd���l�u)¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¶Mµ

¶ ¤»½ �#~0fkxZu{w�}KfhfB� fhd���l�u�d��y�ve0s3jh~Zno| m�w�jkg0g0fkm ¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¶ H¶ ¤³¹ ��|0d�dMutjk~0��no|0m,dMr ntjhwCe0w¾�zmvn�c!mymy~£n�c�d���}K~ g0jhg0}�nomvu ¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¶K½

¶ ¤´¹�¤hH ¿ÁÀ\Â4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ)Ç�Ȩ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¶�¹¶ ¤´¹�¤³² ¿ÁÀ:ÉAÃ�Ä�Å�Æ)Ç�Ȩ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ½�²

¶ ¤´L �3|0m��Mso}Kr |)Ê@Ë�|F}�uw�}�p�jkw�e0w¾g j¬}Kw�mqnomys ¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ½�L½0¤Ì� ���!�������#"$�&%������(')�*�+�,�:�2%���"G��.#��.6� ��5������#���#� ¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ½�Í

½0¤hH �~�nostd�g0e0�qnojkdM~Q¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ½�ͽ0¤³² ?@}Kso}�~0l�jhmqc�jh�v�Cr0s{dM�0fkmyw ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹K¶

½0¤´²�¤hH �2s{myfkjhw�jk~F}Ks{x£g0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~0uQ¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹K¶½0¤´²�¤³² Ï�Ð{Ñ ÒÓ����s{mym �Mst}Kr0|0uÁ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹M¹½0¤´²�¤´¶ Ï�Ô8Ñ Ò¬�«��stmvm��Kso}Kr0| uQ¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹MÕ

jkjhj

Page 4: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½0¤´¶ ��e so�K~@Ö×u�no|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹Kͽ0¤»¶ ¤hH �2s{d�dK��dK�+no|0m,u{r=mv�vnost}KfG��e so�K~�no| mydMs{myw ¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ¹KI½0¤»¶ ¤³² ��dK~0utmvØ�e my~0�vmyu<¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ L�²

½0¤»½ �2stg0ÙMu8����ntdM~0mª����jkw�dM~0dJ��jkntu��3|0mvdMstmvw ¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ LK½½0¤³¹ ��n�}��0jhfkj¡n�xZdK��nt|0mC��rzmy�vntso}KfB�+e0st�K~£nt|0mydKstmyw9¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ LMI

½0¤´¹�¤hH �+stjh}K~0�Kfhmª����stmvm,�Mso}Kr |0u ¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ÕKµ½0¤´¹�¤³² � my~ myso}�fBw�mqno|0d�g>¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ Õ�H½0¤´¹�¤´¶ Ú���rF}Ks�noj¡nom,�Mso}�r0|0u>¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ÕK¶½0¤´¹�¤»½ � so}�r0|0u�~0dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0��Ï�Û4¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ Õ�½

½0¤´L �,st}Kr0|0u3c�j¡no|£|0mys{myg0j¡n�}�stjkfkxZ�zdMe0~0g myg)}J�Kmyst}K�Mm�g0my�Ms{mymº¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ÍMµ½0¤»L ¤hH �2s{d�dK��dK�+no|0m,s{myute fkn ¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ Í H½0¤»L ¤³² ��dK~0utmvØ�e my~0�vmyuÁ}�~0g<}Kr0r0fkjk��}�ntjhdM~ u�nod$�Mst}Kr0|0u�mvw��zmyg0g0}K�0fkmQdK~

u{e0s{��}��ymyuܤ�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ Í�¹½0¤»L ¤´¶ �3g g0my~0g e0w ¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ ÍML

¹�¤Ì�,�����-���3� 5�"G�!'>� ¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ Í�Õ��(�1�(����#���(�ݤC¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤,¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤�¤�¤�¤C¤�¤C¤�¤�¤ I�²

jk�

Page 5: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

N^­7a3`ßÞàN;O�`

�2jh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0mvuZdK�C}bÎF~0j¡nomV�Mst}Kr0|<}Ks{mÁg0mvÎ0~0myg¯}Ku�nt|0mÁmyjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mvu£d��Cj¡nouZ}�g�±{}K�ymv~0�vxw�}�nos{j¡p=¤��;�Ms{d·c�jk~0���=d�g x�dK�0mq��jhg0mv~0�ym3fkjk~0l�u&u{ntste0�qnoe0st}Kf }�~0g�u{r=mv�vnost}Kf�r0stdMrzmys�nojkmyu&d��F�Mso}�r0|0uy¤�3|0jku�no| myutjku#w�}Kl�myu �ydK~�ntstjk�0e ntjhdM~ u�nod�n�c�dZ}Ks{m�}Ku�jh~)no|0jku�ÎFmvfhg@¤�5�dKnt|Á}Ks{m�}Ku }�stm��ydM~0�vmys{~0mygc�j¡no|Emvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m3mªp�nostmvw�}���dMs1�vmys�n�}Kjk~E�yfh}Ku{utmyu2d��F�Mso}�r0|0u&}�~0g�no| m�u{ntste0�qnoe0s{m�dK�Fnt|0m�mªp�ntstmvw�}�f�Mst}Kr0|0uv¤

"Bmvn�á4�zmC}EÎF~ jkntmC�Mst}Kr0|£}K~0g£fkmvn#âzã�ä\â0Ð�zm jkntu3n�c�d�f¬}�st�Mmvu{nmyjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0myuv¤�#e0s3ÎFstu�n�u{e0��±�my�qn�jku�no|0m,u{ntste0�qnoe0s{mCd��&�ydK~0~0my�qnomvg)nos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n��Mso}�r0|0u3c�|0jk��|>w�jh~ jhw�jk�ym

no| m�mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m¢��}Kr$âzã(å¯â0Ðy¤��3| jhu�jh~��Kmyu{ntjh�M}�nojkdM~�jkuCw�dKntjk��}�ntmygQ��xßmqp�r=mvstjkw�my~�n�}Kf(dM�0u{mys8���}�nojkdM~0u�w�}Kg0m�n�c�d)g0my�y}Kg0myuE}K�Md£��x�5�e ututmvw�}KlKmvsimvn�}Kfæ¤�dK~b�ydK~0~0my�qnomvgbnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�nE�Kso}Kr0| uc�j¡no|�ç�è)dKs#��mvc!mys,�Mmys�nojk�ymvuy¤Z� my~0mvso}Kfkjk�yjk~0�£nt|0myjks,myw�r0jkstjk��}Kf��vdM~0�yfke0u{jhdM~ uyD�c!m�g0myu{�ystjk�zm�no| mmqp }K�qn�u�nos{e0�vnte0stm�dK��nt|0m�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf(�Mso}�r0|0uy¤¢�#e0s,stmvute0f¡n�u{e0r0rzdMs{ntu�nt|0m�jh~�noe jkntjk�Km¢jkg0m�}�no|F}�nno| mEmyjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0mi��}KrVjku#s{myfh}�nomvgÁnod¢nt|0mEu{nte0stg jh~0mvutu,dK��jk~�nomys{�ydM~ ~0my�qnojkdM~0u c�jknt|0jk~ßnt|0mE�Mst}Kr0|@�no| mjk~�nomvst�ydK~0~0my�qnojkdM~0u�c�jhfkfF�zm�no|0m�w�dMu{n2��st}K�Mjkfhm���dKs&dMe0s2fkdM~0�0D�é�rF}�nt|���fkjhl�mqê�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf �Mso}�r0|0uy¤

�#e0s utmv�ydM~0g�ute0��±�my�vnCjku,nt|0miutrzmy�qnost}Kf2�Mmy~ myso}�fhjk��}�ntjhdK~�dK�!�ymvs{no}Kjh~ß�vf¬}Ku{utjk��}Kf�s{myute fkntuCjk~mqp�ntstmyw�}Kf2�Kso}Kr0|Vnt|0mydMs�xM¤i�3|0m��vf¬}Ku{utjk��}Kf2s{myu{e0fkntuC�vdM~0�vmyst~ßno| miØ�e0}K~�noj¡n�x�ë{ì+Ã�¿1ítîÁÈoDGg0mvÎF~ mygnodi�zm#no| m w�}·p jkw�e w¨~�e0w��zmys3dK�+mvg0�Mmyu�jk~��Mso}�r0|0u�á*dK~£¿)�Mmys�nojk�ymvuc�|0jk��|£g0di~0dKn3�vdM~�n�}Kjk~}Ku�}iute �0�Mso}�r0|£}K~�x��Mst}Kr0|£ï°��stdMw9no|0m u{mvn�îߤ2��~0}KfhdK�MdMe0u{fkxKD c�m,g0mqÎF~0mEð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ2nod��zmno| m�w�}�p�jkw�e0w¾u{r=mv�vntso}KfBst}Kg0jke0u#â=ãvÃæáiÈ(dJ�Mmvsnt|0m,uo}Kw�m,�yfh}Ku{u�dK���Mst}Kr0|0uá�¤

�~Eno|0m3u{r=mv�vntso}Kf }K~F}KfkdM�Me0m�dK� ��e so�K~@Ö×u&no| mydMs{mywZDMc�m3u{|0dJcànt|F}�n�}�w�dK~0�#�Mst}Kr0|0u&|0}J��jk~0��yfkjkØ�e m�~�e0w��zmys1}�n+w�dMu{n+ÚªDKj�¤»m�¤hD�~0dKn+�ydK~�no}Kjk~0jh~ �#Ï�Òkò=ãB}Ku�}u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|@D���e0st�K~@Ö×u1�Mst}Kr0|�ó�Ãæ¿1í{ÚoÈ|F}Ku�w�}�p�jkw�}�fButrzmy�vntso}KfBst}Kg0jke0u�}K~0g�no|F}�n�jknjku�nt|0m,e0~0jkØ�e0mCmªp�nostmvw�}KfG�Mso}Kr |@¤

�njhu�m�}�u{x�ntd�u{mym no|F}�nÂ#ô ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�õ�¿Vö:ð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿�ítîÁÈ�í Ã�÷�È

}K~0g�no|F}�n!no|0mvstm }�stm��Kso}Kr0| u3ïø��dMs�c�|0jk��|Znt|0m#u{mvn#ùMð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�íyù�ï�úMÈ ô�¿@õ�ë{ì�Ã�¿1íyù�ï�úMÈ2û�¿Qü;ý�újku�~0dKn��=dKe0~0g0mvg@¤&�bm�ut|0dJc,D | d·c!mv�KmysvD0no|F}�n�jk�Bî¼g d�mvu�~0dKn��ydM~�no}Kjh~¢�0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm#�Mso}�r0|0uyD�no| my~

Page 6: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

no| m,n�c!d�utjkg0myudK��Ã8÷�È�}Kstm,}�u{x�w�r nodKntjh�y}KfkfkxZmvØ�e0}Kfæ�Fc!m,g0d�nt|0jku��x�r stdJ��jh~0��no|0}�n

þkÿ ÄË�� � ð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õ�¿��-çå^çJõ�Ú

c�|0mvstm�Ú+jku&dM~0m!fhmvutu&no|0}K~�no| m�w�jh~0jkw�e w*��|0s{dMw�}�nojk�3~�e0w��zmys1dK� �Mso}�r0|0u1jk~Eîߤ1�3| m���}K�vn�no|F}�nno| m�stjk�M|�n{��|F}K~0g¢utjkg0m#jku�myØ�eF}�f=nod�no|0m�fhjkw�jkn�dK�Bno| m�mqp�ntstmyw�}Kf=g0my~ utj¡n�x þkÿ ÄiË�� � ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õ�� Ë Ð�jku�nt|0m��2stg0ÙMu8����ntdM~0mª����jkw�dM~0dJ��jkntunt|0mydMs{mywZ¤

�3|0m#�y}Kutm#d��B�0jkrF}Ks{ntjkntm�mªp �vfhe g0mygZute �0�Mso}�r0|0u�jku�~0dKn!~0my}Kstf¡x�}�u!c!myfkf�e0~0g mystu�nod�d�g�� mv�Kmy~��dMs,�ydKw�r fhmqnom¢� jhrF}�s{noj¡nom��Mst}Kr0|0uCÏ¢Ô�Ñ Ò�D�jk~bw�dMu�n��y}Kutmvu�no| m��vdMsts{my�vnCdMs{g0mys�dK��w�}K�K~0jknte0g0m�dK�no| m)��e0~0�qnojkdM~*ë{ìGÃæ¿�íyù�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò�úMÈ�jhu�~0dKn�l�~ d·c�~�¤:�mv�Mmvs{nt|0myfkmyu{uyD�c!m>u{|0dJc¼no|F}�n�no| m>dMs{g0mys�dK�w�}K�M~0j¡noe g0mCd��!ð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�íyù�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò�úMÈ!jhu~0dKn�Ms{m�}�ntmys�no|F}K~Zno| mC�vdM~�±�my�qnoe0s{mygÁdKstg0mvsd��&w�}K�M~0j¡noe g0mdK�&Â#ô ë{ì+Ã�¿1íyù�Ï�Ô8Ñ Ò�úMÈ8õ�¿Á��dMs3�vdMw�r0fhmqnom��0jkrF}Ks{ntjkntm,�Mso}Kr |0uy¤

�mqnoe0s{~0jk~0�#nod�nt|0m��y}Kutm�d��Fî�-ù�Ï�Òkò=ãªú�D�c!m3r0stdJ�Km3}#u{no}K�0jkfhj¡n�x�s{myu{e0fkn2��dKs�dMe s���rzmy�vntso}Kf�+e0so�K~Cno|0mvdMstmvw-��dKsGnt|0m��y}Kutmvu1Ú��SÂ�í � D�c�|0jk��|Eut|0dJc�u1nt|F}�n�jk�Fnt|0m(utrzmy�vntso}Kf�so}�g0jhe u1dK� }�Mso}�r0|~0dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0��Ï�Òkò=ã3jku��yfkdMutm ntd�nt|0m,�=dMe ~0g@D nt|0my~Zno|0m,�Mst}Kr0|£jhu��vfhdMu{m nod���e0st�K~@Ö×u��Mso}Kr |@¤

�#e0s�f¬}Ku�n¢s{myu{e0fkn�u{no}�nomvu�nt|F}�nEé8�Kso}Kr0| u�c�j¡no|à|0mys{myg0j¡n�}�stjkfkx��zdMe0~0g0mvg�}��Mmvso}K�Km)g0mv�Mstmvm|F}��Mm£utw�}Kfkf3utrzmy�qnost}Kf3so}Kg jhe0uv¤ êÜ�3| m£ntstj¡��jh}Kf3�zdMe0~0g7��dMsEnt|0mZutrzmy�vntso}Kf3st}Kg0jke0u�jh~7nomvstw�u�dK�no| mE~�e0w��zmys dK��mvg0�Mmvu��¸jhuCâzã�ö�� Â��VDzc�|0jh��|ßw�}�xÁ�zm�jkw�r0stdJ�Mmvg�e r=dM~>dM~0f¡x>u{fhjk�M|�nof¡xÁjk~�Mmv~0myst}Kfæ¤+�bm(ut| d·c,D�|0dJc�mq�MmvsyDMno|0}�n+jk�0nt|0m��Mso}�r0|�|F}�u�|0mvstmvg0jkno}Kstjkf¡x,�=dMe ~0g0mygE}J�Kmyst}K�Mm(g0my�Ms{mym�Dno| my~)nt|0jku�w�}�xZ�=m�jkw�r stdJ�Mmvg>nod � �Ì}�u{x�w�r nodKntjh�y}KfkfkxKDzc�|0jk��|>c!mCu{|0dJcÝnod��=m ntjh�M|�ny¤�')dMs{mutrzmy�vjkÎ0��}KfkfkxKD�c!m�ut|0dJc�nt|F}�n(jk���·ítÚ���� �Q}�~0g¢á\jku(} �Mso}Kr |�ut}�nojku{� x�jk~0��� �¢Ã«ïßÈ���ö�Ú����¢Ã«ïQÈ�� �!���dMs3mq�Mmys�xZute0� �Mso}Kr |ÁïÌö<á�D�no|0mv~

â=ãqÃæáiÈ!ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�È8õMÂ"�$#�Ã{ç�È%� � Ú8¿'&�3|0jku�s{myute fknjkw�r fhjkmyu�no|F}�n

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ)(Sç*�$#�Ã{ç�È%� � �K¿�í��dMs��Kso}Kr0| u�myw��zmyg gF}K�0fkm�dK~<}$Î�p mvgSu{e0s{��}��ymKD�jhw�r0s{dJ��jk~0�7e0rzdM~<r0stmq��jhdMe u£�zdMe0~ g0uZ��x�}�ydK~0u{no}K~�n��}��vnodKsy¤

�*~�e0wC�=mvs�dK�1r0stdK�0fhmvw�u�}Ks{jhu{m���s{dMw nt|0myu{m�stmvute0f¡nouv¤3�3|0mvx)}Ks{m,g0jhu{�ye0u{utmvgVjh~£no|0m,ÎF~F}Kf��|F}Kr�nomys�dK��no|0jku3no|0mvutjkuy¤

��j

Page 7: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

O,+SN.-ß`VX£Þ /0 R\`VÞàT7Y21\O�` 0 T7R

/�34/ ­,57698;:<8%=?>A@�BC6EDF69@HGI@H:JD7KL8MBCNPO"QR8;STD"Bmvn�á°�zm£}ß�Kso}Kr0|$dK~�¿^�Kmys{ntjh�vmyu�}K~0g7fkmvnJU�VM� ÃXWZY\[yÈ��=mZj¡nou�}Kg�±{}K�ymv~0�vx$w�}�ntstj p=D

}K~V¿^]Q¿bu{x�w�w�mqnos{jh��w�}�nos{j¡p>�Mj¡�Mmv~V��x_WZY\[`� ç�c�|0mv~0mv�KmysiùbatíXcFú�jku }K~Ámvg0�MmidK�(á�D@}�~0gßýdKnt|0mys�c�jhu{mK¤��3|0m#mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0mvu#â=ã�ä:âFÐ�äÝôJôJô0ä:â�Ë�d��dU�VV}Ks{m���}�fhfkmyg�nt|0m#myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mvu3dK�+á�Dno| myjkswCe0f¡nojkutmvn�jku�y}Kfkfhmvg)no| mfeEgih jlknmpoCq¾d��&á�¤�â=ã�uo}�ntjhu�ÎFmyu âzã�är�»âCYs����dKs�}Kfhf%a!}�~0g)jku���}Kfkfkmygno| mfeEgih jlknm4tZu�m4tRvZwxoye�dK�1á�¤

�~Qnt|0jku,nt|0myu{jhuvDBc�m�jh~��Kmyu{ntjh�M}�nom�utdMw�m�mqp�ntstmyw�}Kf2r stdM�0fkmyw�u,stmvf¬}�nomygßnod�nt|0m�utrzmy�vntste0wdK�!}��Mst}Kr0|ßá�DB�Mjk�Kmy~ßno|F}�n,á ut}�nojku{ÎFmvu,utdMw�m��ydMwC�0jk~F}�nodKstjh}Kf&�ydK~0g0j¡nojkdM~0uy¤E��rzmy�yj¡ÎF�y}Kfhf¡xMDBc!m�ydK~0utjkg0mys!n�c�d�n�x�rzmyu�d��Gr0stdM� fhmvw�uv�&no|0m�w�jh~0jkw�e wzhlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih"{ytlgb¥�â=ãzåßâFÐq©&��dMs(�ydM~0~ my�vntmygnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n¢�Mso}Kr |0u�}K~ g;�zdMe0~0g0u�dM~ànt|0m>u{r=mv�vntso}Kfso}Kg jhe0u�dK� �Mst}Kr0|0u�c�jknt|�stmvu{ntstjk�vnomvg^ute0����Mst}Kr0|0uv¤

�)���x�7�i���������T�b�7�'�'�����x�b����� ���n�,�������n�T�����7�7� �d�����F�*� �+stj¡��}Kfkmy~�n(�Mso}Kr |0u2}Ks{m3stmy�Ke0f¬}�s�Mst}Kr0|0u�dK��g0my�KstmymC¶ ¤��FdMs�nt|0myu{mKD jkn3��dKfhfkdJc�u�my}Kutjkfkx�nt|F}�n#âzã���� ¤&�bm,g0mqÎF~0m,no|0m�hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih{ytlgbdK�(stmy�Ke0f¬}�s#�Mso}�r0|0u#nod��zmEno| mig0j��=mys{my~0�vm�â=ã�å^â0Ðy�Bno|0mi��}�rVjhu rzdMutj¡noj¡�Mmij¡��}K~0gVdM~0f¡xÁj¡�á*jku��vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg@¤(�3|0jhu3Ø�eF}�~�ntjkn�x�c�}�u�ÎFstu�n3jh~��Kmyu{ntjh�M}�nomvg)��x���jhmvg0fhmvs3jh~VH�I�ÕK¶ D�c�|0di��}�fhfkmygZj¡nno| m<tZu\{Ch���m4tZw j�j ¡�}i}%h jlk wx~�wxkn¢�dK�(á�¤��n�jhu#jk~Áu{dMw�mEutmv~0utm�}�w�my}Kute stmidK�&nt|0m�u�nos{my~0�Knt|VdK�2no| mjk~�ntmys{�ydM~0~ my�vntjhdK~0u�dK�1á¾¥��v�8¤!��my�qnojkdM~QHM¤³²�¤hH�}K~0g£stmq��mys{my~0�vmyu�no|0mvstmJ©ª¤

�~)��|F}Kr ntmys�¶ D�c�m,�ydK~0utjkg0mys3nt|0m#myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m,��}Kr�d��+ntstj¡��}Kfhmv~�n�D0�vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg)�Kso}Kr0| uy¤��~HJI�Õ�L D 5!e0utu{myw�}KlKmvsyD�£�dM�zmyf ±�j�¤KD �!�Kmvnol�dJ��j�¤KD }�~0g£��myjkg0mvf¦¥¡HJI�§=my~�e0w�myst}�nomvg)}�fhf=L�²�H��ydM~0~ my�vntmygnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n�Mst}Kr0|0u�c�j¡no|)}�n�w�dMu{n�H�½i�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuv¤!�3|0mqxZdMstg mystmvg£nt|0m,�Mso}�r0|0u3fkmqp�jh�vdM�Mst}Kr0|0jk��}Kfkf¡x��x�no| myjksu{r=mv�vntso}¢}�~0gZstmyw�}Ks{lKmvg)no|0}�n��

é{�#e0s�n�}K� fhm�u{|0dJc�uEno|F}�n�no| mystm¢jhui})u{nos{dM~0�Ás{myfh}�nojkdM~$�zmvn�c!mymv~7nt|0m�u{my�ydK~0gmvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m,}�~0g�no|0m��ydM~0~ my�vntjk��j¡n�xZdK�+}E�Mst}Kr0|@¤&�3| jhu3jku3~0dKn3u{e0str stjkutjk~0��jh~���jkmvc

H

Page 8: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²

dK�L¥×�1jkmyg0fkmys�¥ ½�L�§�§æ¤C5!e n#no| mEjh~ myØ�eF}Kfkjkntjhmvu,jh~¨¥ ½�L�§&}KstmE~ dKn ut|0}KstrVjk~Áno|0mi�y}Kutmid���ve0�0jk�C�Mst}Kr0|0u�}�~0g£nt|0m c�|0dMfkm,Ø�e myu{ntjhdK~>~0mvmyg0u���e0s{nt|0mys��vdM~0utjkg0mvso}�ntjhdM~�¤ ê

�3|0jku�dM� utmys���}�nojkdM~£jhu�no|0m,w�dKntjk��}�ntjhdM~Z��dMs3dMe s�c!dMs{l�jh~��KdMfk��jk~0�¢ntstj¡�K}�fhmv~�n�Mst}Kr0|0uv¤�"BmqnÊ@Ëi�zm��vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg)ntstj¡��}Kfhmv~�n��Kso}Kr0|£dM~Z¿ßäÝçJýE�Mmvs{nojk�ymvu��Mj¡�Mmv~>��xz�

©©

©©

©ª ª ª ª« « « «¬ª ª« « ©

©©

©ª ª« «�ª ª

« « ©©©

©ª ª« «�ª ª

« « ©©©

©ª ª« «¬ª ª

« « ©©©

©©ª ª

« « ª ª ª ª« « « «c�|0mv~0mv�Kmys�¿ÁÀ:Â4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�D }�~0g

©©

©© ©ª ª ª ª« « « «¬ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «¬ª ª« « ©

©©

©©

©©ª ª

« « ª ª ª ª« « « «c�|0mv~0mv�Kmys�¿ÁÀSýAÃ�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�¤

�~�no|0m>my~�e0w�myst}�nojkdM~^dK��5�e ututmvw�}KlKmvs£mqn�}Kf�¤kD�nt|0m)Î0stu{n��Mso}Kr |^}Kr0rzm�}Ks{jh~ �b��dMs¢my}K��|¿ßäÝçJýijhuÊ@Ë�¤(�~)��|F}�r nomvs�¶Ec!mCr0s{dJ�Mm no|0m,�vdM~�±�my�qnoe0s{mCjkw�r0fkjh�vjkn�jh~�nt|0myjks�rF}Krzmysy�

�­�d�y®T����� ¯��n°�± ¡�m�¿�äAç�ý�²*k�³ih�{´m4tlgi³�Ê@˵w¶e­kx³ihJj ¡�}i}%h jlk9hv¬knmpwx~�tZu¶hl}ik·{´m4tlgi³µ¸·wxkx³�qfwx}iwx¹qfo�qºhlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh"{ytlgi²*tZ}�v¬wxk*w¶e»k�³ih¼o�}iwn½�oTh»eloij ³J{´m4tlgi³F¾

�bm�}�fhu{d�w�}Kl�m3no|0m3dM� utmys���}�nojkdM~ino|F}�n(ÊBË�|F}Ku2w�}�p�jkw�e0wAg j¬}Kw�mqnomys(}Kw�dM~ � �ydM~0~ my�vntmygnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n!�Mso}�r0|0u�dM~�¿QäÝç�ý,�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuvD0}K~0g�no|0}�n���dMs�¿VÀ:Â*ÃæÄ�Å�Æ£è�È�j¡n!jku(e0~0jkØ�e m�c�j¡no|�no|0jkur0s{dMr=mvs{n�xK¤

¿ ®��'��À���®��M�b�d�Á���·��ÂZ���b�i���b�iÀ�� ���Z� �3| m�u{r=mv�vntso}Kf2st}Kg0jke0u,uo}�ntjhu�ÎFmyu�no|0mE��dMfkfkd·c�jk~0�£jh~��myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�xz�

Â��¿ ö:â=ãªí

c�|0mvstm�¿�jhu�no| m�~�e0w��zmys�dK�&�Kmys{ntjh�vmyu }�~0gµ�Ìjku�nt|0mC~�e0wC�=mvs#dK�1myg0�Mmvu�jk~Vá�¤3�~V��|F}Kr�nomys�½c!mVjh~��Mmvu{ntjh��}�nomße0r0rzmys��zdMe0~0g u�dM~�no| mVutrzmy�vntso}Kf�so}Kg0jke0u�d��C�Kso}Kr0| u��Mj¡�Mmy~^nt|F}�n�nt|0mvx;g0d~0dKn¢�ydM~�no}Kjh~^�vmys�n�}Kjk~�ute �0�Mso}�r0|0uy¤Ý�3| mÁjh~ myØ�eF}Kfkjkn�x�}K�zd·�Km>no| my~^ut| d·c�u�nt|F}�n¢dMe0s¢s{myu{e0fkntuu{ntstmv~0�Kno| my~>�vf¬}�ututjk��}�f+s{myu{e0fkntu�jk~Zmqp�nos{myw�}KfG�Mst}Kr0|�no|0mvdMs{xK¤

"Bmvn�î_�=m�}Zutmvn�dK���Kso}Kr0| uy¤Z"BmvnZë{ìGÃæ¿1í{îÁÈ#�zm�nt|0m�w�}·p jkw�e w ~�e0wC�=mvsEdK��myg0�Mmvu�jk~�Mst}Kr0|0u�á/c�j¡no|�¿>�Kmys�nojk�ymyu3~ dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0��}K~�x¢�Kso}Kr0|¢jh~¢îø}Ku�}�ute �0�Mso}�r0|@¤2��~0}KfhdK�MdMe0u{fkxKD

Page 9: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

c!m g0mvÎF~ m�ð�ñ ë{ì+Ã�¿1ítîÁÈ&nodi�zm�no|0m�w�}·p jkw�e w¨utrzmy�qnoso}�f@so}Kg jhe0u�dK�+�Mso}Kr |0u�dM~�¿>�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�dJ�Mmvsno| m)ut}Kw�m)�vf¬}Ku{u�d��#�Mst}Kr0|0u�á�¤\¥����î � ù�ï�ú�D�c�m£c�stj¡nom$ë{ìGÃæ¿1íoïQÈ�}K~0g¯ð�ñ ë{ìGÃ�¿1í�ïQÈ���dMsë{ì+Ãæ¿1ívù�ï�úMÈ(}K~0gVð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�íyù�ï�úMÈ�¤´©��3|0m�Ø�eF}K~�noj¡nojkmyu�}Kstm,fkjh~ lKmyg)��x�no|0m,jk~0myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�x

Â#ô ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�õ�¿Vö:ð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿�ítîÁÈ & Ã�÷�È

�bm�u�n�}Ks�nCdKe0s,jh~��Mmvu{ntjh��}�nojkdM~�c�j¡no|Qno|0m���}�utm�ï �9Ï�Òkò=ãqD+j�¤×mK¤kD��Mst}Kr0|0u,|F}���jk~0�)�vfhjkØ�e0m~�e0w��zmys�}�nBw�dMu�nGÚ�¥���dKs@�F}Ku{jh���Mst}Kr0| no|0mvdMstmqnojk��g0mvÎF~ jkntjhdM~ uyDKu{mym!��mv�vnojkdM~E²�¤hHJ©q¤G��e so�K~@Ö×uG�Mso}�r0|ó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈBjku&g0mqÎF~0myg�}Ku�no|0m�e ~0jhØ�e0m3�vdMw�r0fkmvnom�Ú���rF}Ks�noj¡nom��Kso}Kr0|Cc�|0mys{m�}Kfhf�Ú+�ydMfkdMs��yfh}Kutu{myu(}Kstm!dK�utjk�ym(myj¡no| mys»Ã ¿Bõ·ÚXÄ�dMs»Å ¿@õ�ÚXÆ�¤+��e so�K~@Ö×uGno|0mvdMstmvw\u{no}�nomvu+nt|F}�n�ë{ìGÃæ¿�í�Ï�Òkò=ã�Ȧ�Ç� �¢Ã�óCÃ�¿1ítÚoÈ{È��´D�}�~0gno|0}�n�ó�Ã�¿1ítÚoÈ�jhu�no| m�e0~0jkØ�e0m�mªp�nostmvw�}Kf��Kso}Kr0|�¤��bm�r0stdJ�Km�no|0m,��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�¢u{r=mv�vntso}Kf�}K~F}KfkdM�Me mjk~Á��mv�vntjhdM~£½0¤»¶ �

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊÉÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i�����d�bÏi�$�b�d��®T�b���ÑÐ�Ò hlk á �lhÓt_{´m4tlgi³Ñ¸·wxk�³�¿Ô~Zhlmpknw j h eµ}%¡�kj ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ�Òkò=ãAt�e­tfelo7�X{´m4tlgi³F¾JÕ�³ihl}

â=ãvÃæáiÈ(ö:âzãvÃæó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈtÈÎ&Ö�½�o7tZu�wxkn¢f³i¡�u�v�e`w ×AtZ}�vØ¡�}iu�¢Jw ×�áÙw¶e¼kx³ihØÕ7o�m4ÚZ}<{´m4tlgi³�Ï$Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈl¾

�3|0jkuiu{nos{my~0��no|0mv~0u�}Ástmyu{e0f¡n�dK���<jhf¡�A¥»ÍMIb§«D2c�|0dVu{|0dJc�mvg�nt|F}�n¢âzãqÃæáiÈ�ö¸Ã�çCåÝç·õ·ÚoÈ�¿1¤�3|0jku��zdMe0~ g)}��Mstmvmyu�c�jknt|)dMe s�nojk�M|�n��zdMe0~ g£j¡�2}�~0gZdM~0f¡x�jk��Ú�� ¿�¤

�3|0mys{m(}Kstm2my}Ku{x mªp }Kw�r0fhmvuGdK���Mso}Kr |0u@��dMs@c�|0jk��|�nt|0m2utmqn2ùMð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿1ívù�ï�úMÈ�ô»¿Bõ�ë{ìBÃæ¿�íyù�ï�úMÈ(û¿ßü�ý�ú�jku&~0d�n&�zdMe0~0g0mvg@��c�m�ut|0dJc,D�|0dJc!mv�MmvsyD�no|0}�n&j¡�Fî�g0d�myu&~0d�n&�ydK~�no}Kjk~i�0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm��Mso}�r0|0uyDno| my~Zno|0m n�c!d�u{jhg0mvu�d���Ã�÷�È�}�stm,}Ku�x�w�r ntdKnojk��}�fhf¡xZmyØ�eF}Kf�¤(�~Á��mv�vntjhdM~£½0¤×½ic�m�r0stdJ�KmK�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊÉ�ÉÌËÎÍ��·��ÂZ���b�i�HÛ���À�Ü��lÝlÍ���®����´ÝlÍ;�n�Þ®���®��d�x�b�­�b�d��®T�b���ÑÐ,Ò hlkzîß�lh�t­e�hlk·¡9×à }%¡�}%hlq�g�kn¢pá¼{´m4tlgi³Re ²*tZ}�vJu¶hlk+Ú·�¯Ä ÿ¶âTã·ä�åJæ ëïßÈ+å�çy¾�Õ�³ihl}

þkÿ ÄË�� � ð�ñ ë{ì�Ã�¿1ítîÁÈ8õ�¿!�*ç�å�ç·õ·Úp&�3|0m,��}K�vn�no|0}�n�no|0m�stjk�M|�n{��|F}K~0g£utjkg0m�dK�1nt|0m,myØ�eF}�ntjhdM~>}K�zd·�KmCjkumyØ�eF}KfBnodint|0mCfkjkw�j¡ndK�

no| m�mªp�nostmvw�}KfGg0my~0u{jkn�x þkÿ Ä�Ë�� � ë{ì+Ãæ¿�í�ïQÈ8õ � Ë Ð � jku�nt|0m��2stg0ÙMu8����ntdM~0mª����jkw�dM~0dJ��jkntunt|0mydMs{mywZ¤

Page 10: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½

�3|0mß��}Ku{mßdK���0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntmQmªp��yfke0g0mygSute0� �Mso}Kr |0uZjhuZw�e ��|Sfkmyu{u£e ~0g0mys{u{ntd�d�g@��mv�Mmv~S��dMs�ydKw�r fhmqnom£�0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm)�Mst}Kr0|0u�ïbD(jk~;w�dMu{n��y}Kutmvu�nt|0m)�vdMsts{my�qn¢dMs{g0mys�dK��w�}K�M~0j¡noe g0m)d���no| m��e0~0�qnojkdM~àë{ì+Ãæ¿�í�ïQÈ�jhu�~0dKn�l�~ d·c�~�¤ ��mq�Mmys�no|0mvfhmvutuvD@c�mEu{|0dJc-no|F}�nno| m�dMs{g0mys�dK�2w�}K�M~0j¡noe g0mdK�(ð�ñ ë{ì+Ã�¿1í�ïßÈ(jhu~0dKn�Ms{m�}�ntmys3no|F}�~£nt|0mC�vdM~�±�mv�vnoe stmyg)dMstg mys�dK�&w�}K�K~0jknte0g0m�dK��ë{ì�Ã�¿1í�ïQÈ(��dMs�ydKw�r fhmqnom��0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm��Kso}Kr0| uy¤�� ÙJ�K��stj�Dz���MuyD }�~0gZ��e0st�K~^¥»LK½�§But|0dJc!myg>nt|F}�n

Â#ô ë{ìGÃæ¿�í�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò«È�õ�¿Qö-Ã{Ã�Ú�å^ç�È ã ç�Ô �$#�Ã{ç�È{È�¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &�~>��my�qnojkdM~)½ ¤³²�D�c�m�r0stdJ�Km�nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ��u{r=mv�vnost}KfBu{ntstmv~0�Kno| my~0jk~0�¢d���nt|0myjks��=dMe ~0g@�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�êé$ËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i��ë�Ü��7Ï7���êÝìÍ%í��lÝÎ�����bÏi�$�����y®T�b�C�¨Ðð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿�í�Ï¢Ô�Ñ ÒæÈ!ö-ÃtÃ�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ô �$#�Ã{ç�ÈtÈ�¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &

�2stg0ÙMu`¥×¶MÍ D0¶MI�§G}�~0g£��jkw�dK~0dJ��j¡nouA¥»ÕKI�§Bjk~0g0mvr=mv~0g0mv~�ntfkxZu{|0dJc�mvg£nt|F}�n��+e0so��~@Ö»u�nt|0mydKstmywjku�u�n�}K�0fkm�jk~Zno|0m,��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�¢u{my~0u{mK�3j¡�2á6jhu�}��Mso}Kr |)c�j¡no|>�vfhjkØ�e0m�~�e0wC�=mvs#}�nw�dMu�n�Ú3|0}J��jk~0�}Kfkw�dMu{n�}Ku�w�}K~�x�myg0�Mmvu3}Ku�nt|0m��+e0st�K~��Mst}Kr0|�ó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈ�D�no|0mv~���x¢s{myw�dJ��jh~0�idK~0fkx¢}���mqc¯myg0�Mmvu��stdKwAá�D�jkn2�y}K~��=m3w�}Kg m�}#u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|�dK�zó�Ãæ¿1í{ÚoÈ�¤���m�r0stdJ�Km�nt|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�,utrzmy�qnoso}�f �MmvstutjkdM~dK�+no|0jku3��dMs�Ú��:Â�í �Ejk~Á��mv�vntjhdM~)½0¤´¹��

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊîÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i���ì���Fïð�n� �x�pñ��b�d�y®��b���ÑÐ�± ¡�m!tZuxu¦ò�üøýÌtZ}�v�×�¡�miÚ<� Â2¡�mJ��²kx³ihlm h�h4ó´w¶elk?j ¡�}FelkXtZ}ikxe�ôP�õô·Ã�ÚoȼtZ}�v�öº�÷öbÃ�ò�í{ÚoȲ�eloTj ³�kx³FtZk%×�¡�mAtZuxu�{´mtlgi³Re�á�¡�}�¿bä�ö~Zhlmpk w j h e»¸·wxk�³_jlu�wn½�oih`}io�qJ�lhlm­tZkHq¬¡�elkBÚAtZ}�vJeEgih jlk m4tZu�m4tRvZwxoRe»e�tZk w¶e�×p¢�wx}y{

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ�ä-Ã�ç�å�ç·õ�ÚoÈ�¿&Ã{ç�å�ò�È�íáÇjtZ}��lh*qJtRv�hGÚp¹¶gFtZmpk wxkEh"��¢�mÎhlq¬¡�~�wx}y{`tZk%q¬¡�elk7ô ò�¿ Ð hv�{Ch e ²;tZ}�v�wxk'jtZ}J�lh*qJtRv�h�t�eloF�X{´m4tlgi³¡9×�ó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈ`��¢JmÎhlq¬¡�~�wx}y{<tZkHq¬¡�elkðô � ò�¿ Ð hv�{Ch e�¾

�bm>~0dJcø�vdM~0u{jhg0mvs��Mst}Kr0|0u�c�jknt|^fhdJcÜg0my~ utj¡n�xM¤-�FdMs�Î p�myg<r=dKutj¡noj¡�MmÁjk~�nomy�Kmystu�Ú�}�~0g��D#fhmqnZî�ÒÓÑ ø£�=mßno|0mßu{mvn)dK�i}Kfkf �Mst}Kr0|0uZdM~S}�n£fhmy}Ku{n£Ú¢�Kmys�nojk�ymyu£c�jknt|Snt|0mßr0stdMrzmys�n�x^no|F}�n����ëïQÈ���ü;ÚBôy�\��ëïQÈ���^��¤&��m#jk~��Mmyu�nojk��}�ntmið�ñ ë{ìGÃ�¿1ítî�ÒÓÑ øqÈ�D0u{|0dJc�jh~ ��nt|F}�n!no|0m#ntstj¡��jh}Kf=�=dMe ~0gdK� � Â��6��}K~��=m!jhw�r0s{d·�Kmyginod»ô�Ã�ÚªíÎ��È�� � �A��dKs+nt|0myu{m3�Mso}Kr |0uyD�c�|0mys{m"�ù�<Ú8¿¢jhu+no|0m�~�e0wC�=mvsdK��mvg0�Mmyu#}K~0g�ô·Ã�ÚªíÎ��È3jku#}��ydM~0u�n�}K~�n g myrzmy~0g0jk~0��dM~)Ú�}�~0gÓ��¤��~ß��mv�vntjhdM~V½ ¤´L�c!mEr0s{dJ�MmEno| m��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��no|0mvdMstmvw£�

Page 11: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊúûÒ hlk!Ú¬�ü� �ÇtZ}�vØ��ä°å¬� Òkò=ãл� ¾�ý¶×Cáßw¶eØtØ{´m4tlgi³þ¡�}ß¿ÿ~Zhlmpk w j h e�¸·wxkx³�kx³ihg�mΡ gihlmpk ¢Jk�³FtZk?����ëïQÈ���ö�Ú1ô7����ÃæïQÈ��l�¨�¼×�¡�mAtZuxu�eloF�X{´m4tlgi³Reï ¡�},tZkHu¶ht�elkGÚ`~Zhlmlknw j h e ²�kx³ihl}

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ(ö*Ã�Ú1å;ç�È�õMÂ?��� Ã�Ú��¯ç�È�Ú��;Â��?� � Ú8¿�í

tZ}�v�t�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw jtZuxu�¢�²â=ãqÃæáiÈ!ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�È8õMÂ"� � Ú8¿��$#�Ã{ç�Èoí

¸ð³ihlmÎh»kx³ih�#�Ã�ç�ÈPmÎh�×�hlm e»k9¡,¿�� � ¸ð³�wxu¶h?�!tZ}�v�Ú`tZm h���óChvR¾ ± o�mpk�³ihlmpq¬¡�mÎh ²·kx³ihAt�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw j�l¡�o�}�v�w¶e¼k w|{�³�k ¾

�bm�}Kfkutd�ut| d·cSno|F}�n3no|0m,e0~0jkØ�e0m�mqp�nos{myw�}KfG�Mso}�r0|���dMs"�`�*å¬� Òkò=ãÐ�� jku3no|0m,�Mst}Kr0|�c�j¡no|Ú��Kmys�nojk�ymyudK�1g0my�Ms{mym,¿�å^çMDF}�fhfBdKnt|0mys��Kmys�nojk�ymyu�dK��g0my�Ms{mym,Úª¤

��u}��ydM~0u{myØ�e0mv~0�ymCdK��nt|0jkus{myu{e0fknyDFc�m,dM� no}Kjk~£nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ���zdMe0~0g uy�� ®T��®��n�n�F�bñ¨Èd�n°�üÒ hlkBá�lh`t`{´m4tlgi³�hlqJ�lhvRvRtR��u¶h»¡�}µtfelo�mx×ìt�j hA¡9×?Ö*oCu¶hlm`j ³FtZm4t�jlk9hlmpw¶elknw j æ ¾Õ�³ihl}

â=ãqÃæáiÈ*(Sç)��� É0ëÂ#å æ È%� � �K¿�ítZ}�v�t�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw jtZuxu�¢�²

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ)(Sç*� � ��¿J�$#�Ã{ç�Èoí¸ð³ihlmÎh`kx³ih�#�Ã�ç�È�mÎh�×�hlmÎe¼kE¡�¿� � ¸ð³�wxu¶h æ w¶e���óChvR¾

�3|0jku(jkw�r0stdJ�Kmyu�e0rzdM~�r0stmq��jkdMe0u��zdMe0~0g u2�Mjk�Kmy~���x���dK~0��¥»LKµ�§F��xi}#�vdM~0u�n�}K~�n���}K�vntdMs1��dMs}KfkfBute0s���}K�ymvu�d�no|0mvs�nt|F}K~Zno|0m,r0fh}K~0m��F��dMs�no|0m�r0fh}K~0m�D0c�m�jhw�r0s{dJ�Mm�| jhu�stmvute0f¡n���x£}�~>}Kg g0jkntjk�Km�ydK~0u{no}K~�n�¤

�S~�e0wC�=mvs�dK��r0stdM� fhmvw�u�}Kstjkutm���stdMw6dKe0s!s{myu{e0fkntuy¤��3|0mvutm#}�stmg0jhu{�ye0u{utmvg£jk~���|0}Kr nomvs3¹�¤

Page 12: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

L

/�3 � +M6sBRDC@H5����������� ���������� "!$#%��&'�(!*),+.-/&'0'12030%4�-65�#7&6!$)84�&6�94�-/&�#7�:-/0;�=<?>�&6!94�@.0�3|0mu{noe g x�dK�=stmyfh}�ntjhdM~ u(�zmvn�c!mymv~�utrzmy�qnost}KfFr0stdKr=mvs{nojkmyu(}K~ g��vdMw��0jk~F}�ntdMstjh}KfFr0s{dMrzmys{ntjhmvu

dK� �Kso}Kr0| u¢|F}Ku��=mvmy~;nt|0m>u{e0��±�mv�vnZdK� |�e0~ g0stmvg0u�dK� r0}Kr=mvstuߥ c�m)stmq��mys�nt|0m>s{m�}Kg mys�ntdbno| mw�dM~0dM�Kso}Kr0| u�¥»²K¶ D ²KÍ D�¶Mµ�§æD�nt|0m#ute s{�Mmqx�}Ks�nojk�yfkm#��x�����|�c!my~ l�}K~0g��<jkfhu{dM~�¥»ÕKÍ�§æD0}K~ g¢no|0m��0jh���fkjhdM�Kso}Kr0| jhmvu�no|0mvstm�©q¤(� so}Kr0|¢utrzmy�vntso}�|0}J�Km g0jkstmy�qn�}Kr0r fhjk��}�ntjhdK~0u�nodE'>}Ks{lKdJ����|F}�jh~0uvD0so}�~0g0dMw�Mmv~0myst}�nojkdM~@DB�BA0��lKmvf1no| mydMs�xÁjk~Áw�dMfhmv�ye0fh}Ks Ø�eF}K~�nte0w°w�my��|0}K~0jk�yuyDG}�~0gÁnod�w�dM~ dMw�mys���g0jkw�mvsu{x�u�nomyw�u�jh~Zno|0mvstw�d�g x�~F}Kw�jh�vu­¥×¶M¶ DF¹Kµ D ¹�½ Dz¹KL�D L�²�DzÕK¶�D Í�H�§«¤

�3|0m utrzmy�qnos{e0w dK��}��Kso}Kr0|Zá/my~0�vd�g myu3w�}K~�x�r0s{dMrzmys{ntjhmvu3dK�Bno| m#�Mso}�r0|@D xKmvn�}K~�x¢r0stmª��yjkutm�my~0�vd�g jh~0�Cu{ntjhfkf=s{myw�}Kjk~0u�mvfhe utj¡�MmK¤(�e0w�mystdKe0u�s{myute fkntu�|F}��Mm��Mj¡�Mmy~¢mqp�r0fkjh�vjkn3s{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jkr0u�zmvn�c!mymy~Q}��Mso}Kr |@Ö»u�utrzmy�qnoste w°}K~ gÁ�ydMwC�0jk~F}�nodKstjh}Kf�r stdMrzmys�nojkmyuyD=ute0��|ß}�u�~�e0w��zmys�dK�2myg �MmyuvDw�}�p�jhwCe0w g my�Ms{mymKD ��|0stdMw�}�ntjh��~�e w��zmys`¥»²MÕ�D�¶�¹�D ¹MÕ�D�ÍMÍ�§æD �yfkjkØ�e m#~�e0w��zmys`¥×ÍMI�§æD0��}Kw�jhf¡nodM~ jh�ª�j¡n�xÁ¥×ÍML DGÕM¹�§«D@ntdMe0�M| ~0myu{u�¥×¶ D&HJ¹b§æDBmvno��¤i')dKstmistmv�ymv~�n�g0mq�MmvfhdMr w�mv~�nou�mq�Mmv~b�ydK~0~0my�qn,utrzmy�qnoso}�fr0s{dMr=mvs{ntjhmvu�dK�Bw�}�ntstjk�ymyu3s{myfh}�nomvg¢nodCno|0m�}Kg�±{}K�vmy~0�qx�w�}�nos{j¡p�ntd�nodMrzdMfkdM�Mjk��}Kf r0s{dMrzmys{ntjhmvuyD0u{e0��|}Ku�r0fh}K~F}Ks{jkn�x_¥´²M¹b§G}K~0g£fhjk~0l�fkmyutu�mywC�=mvgF}K�0jkfhj¡n�xZjk~Þ� C*D­¥×LMI�§æ¤

�3|0myu{m�s{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jhr u�myu�n�}K� fhjkut|0mvg>nod�gF}�nom�ut|0mvg>fkjh�M|�ndM~Zno|0m�u{ntstdM~ ���vdMsts{myfh}�nojkdM~£�=mª�n�c!mymy~<�Mst}Kr0|0u�}K~0g;nt|0myjks�utrzmy�qnost} �#w�}K~�x�dZ�=mys�jh~ utjk�M|�n�jh~�ntd�no|0mÁfh}Ks{�Mmys�ut��|0mvw�mVd�� no|0jku�ydKststmvf¬}�nojkdM~@D�xKmvnCno|0mvstm¢jku�u{nojkfkf!wCe0��|bnod)fhmy}Kst~�¤£')dMu{n�jh~ myØ�eF}KfkjkntjhmvuyD1c�| jhfkm¢nojk�M|�nCjh~�w�}�~�xjk~0u{no}K~0�ymvuyDz}Ks{m,�Kmys�x�c�my}Kl�jh~£dKnt|0mys{uy¤

��u�}K~�mªp }Kw�r0fhm,dK�+u{e0��|Zstmyu{e0f¡nouyD }�~£jkw�r=dKs{n�}�~�n�no|0mvdMstmvw dK�+��¤:E ¤o�dZ��w�}K~,¥»¹MÕb§@r0std����jhg myu�no|0m ��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��fhdJc!mys��=dKe0~0g£dM~£nt|0m,��|0stdKw�}�nojk��~�e0wC�=mvs æ ÃæáiÈ(dK�1}��Mso}Kr |

æ ÃæáiÈ!äÝç�å;â=ã�õ�â ËC&�3|0jku�stmyu{e0f¡n�jhu¢stmyfh}�ntmyg^nodbnt|0mÁs{myw�}Kstl�}K� fhmÁrzdMf¡x�~0dMw�j¬}�f¡�«nojkw�mÁ}Kfh�KdMstj¡no|0w �Mj¡�Mmv~<��x

� s(FKntut��|0mvfæD�"GdJ���Ku{�KD�}�~0g�����|0stj ±8�MmvsÓ¥»¹�H�§3nodß�vdMw�r0e nomZno| m£��| stdMw�}�ntjh�£~�e0w��zmys�dK��r=mvs{��my�qn�Mst}Kr0|0uv¤!�d�r0e0stmvfkxZ�vdMw�� jh~F}�nodMs{j¬}KfG}�fh�MdKstj¡no|0w jhu�l�~0dJc�~@¤

Page 13: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

Õ

Í%�·�CÂZ�����7�*�b�iÀ�� ���Z� �3| m utrzmy�vntso}KfBst}Kg0jke0u3dK�+�Mst}Kr0|0u3�y}K~Z�=m#nt|0dMe0�M|�n�dK��}Ku3u{dMw�m,utdMs�n3dK�}��Mmvso}K�Mjk~0��dK�+no|0m,g0mv�MstmvmyudK��nt|0m �Mmvs{nojk�ymvuy¤!�n�uo}�ntjhu�ÎFmyuno|0m,jk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡nojkmyu

ç¿HG�I J ÐY%K ã ç�Ð ö:âzã�öMLON�PRQð&

�2Ø�eF}Kfkjkn�x�dM~Cnt|0m�stjk�M|�n&jkw�r0fkjhmvu1no|F}�n2á<jhu�stmy�Ke0f¬}�sy¤&�2Ø�eF}Kfkj¡n�x�dM~Cno|0m!fhmq� n&|0dMfkg0u&j¡�z}K~0g�dM~0f¡xCj¡�no| m�Kso}Kr0|�jku!mvjknt|0mys�stmv�Me0fh}Ks�dMs�jk��jkn(jku��0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm�}K~ g�nt|0m�g0my�Ms{mymdK��},�Kmys{ntmqp�jku(g mvnomvstw�jk~0myg��x�j¡nou��ydMfkdMs��yfh}Ku{u�¥ no|0m,jk~0myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�x£dM~�no|0m,fkmv� n�c�}�udK�0utmvs{�MmvgÁ��xZ��d���w�myjku{ntmysA¥´¹�Í�§ ©ª¤

�3|0mZutrzmy�qnoso}�f�so}Kg jhe0u�}Ks{jhu{myuijk~$nodMrzdMfkdM�Mjk��}Kf!g x�~F}Kw�jh�vuyD(c�|0mys{m£j¡n�jkuistmyfh}�ntmyg$nodVno| mmy~�ntstdMr�x<dK�E}$ntdMrzdMfhdK�Mjh�y}Kf#u�x�u�nomvw �Kjk�Kmy~:��xS'>}�stlKdJ�<u{|0jk� ntu�¥��v�8¤`¥×Í�Õb§Ó©q¤9�~<nodMrzdMfkdM�Mjk��}Kfg x�~F}Kw�jk�yuvD3dM~0m£u{noe g0jhmvu�nt|0mÁ}Ku�x�w�r�nodKntjh�£r0stdKr=mvs{nojkmyu�dK�#�vdM~�nojk~�e0dMe0u�w�}�r0uy¤^�Üu{no}K~0gF}Ks{gutjkw�r0fkjk� x�jk~0��nos{jh��l£jhuno|F}�n#dK�2u�x�w��zdMfhjk�ig x�~F}Kw�jk�yuv��s{myg0e0�vjh~ �¢nod�}�stmvf¬}�ntjk�Kmyf¡xÁu{jhw�r0fkm�nodKr=d��fkdM�Mjk��}KfBu{rF}K�ymC}K~0g)}��ydM~�nojk~�e0dMe0uw�}Kr@¤(�-rF}Ks{ntjh�ve0fh}Kstf¡xZjh~�ntmystmvu{ntjh~0�¢�yfh}KutudK��w�d�g0mvfhujhu�no| m'>}Ks{lKdJ�Zut| jk� ntuy¤("BmvnTSû�-ù�ý í�çKí�&�&�&@í=U�å;çKú�D0c�jknt|£nt|0m,g0jkut�ys{mvntm�ntdMr=dKfhdM��xMDF}K~ g£g mvÎF~0mV � ò �Wè �

S(íc�j¡no|7no|0m£r0std�g0e0�qn�nodMrzdMfkdM�KxM¤$�3| m)u{|0jk� n�ó¸û"V � V �Kjk�Kmy~;��x7ó�Ã�ù6X0Ë�úJË�ÈJ� ù6X0ËJò=ã�úJËg0mqÎF~0myu¢}QntdMr=dKfhdM�Kjh�y}Kf3g x�~F}Kw�jk��}Kfu{x�u{ntmywZ¤¯"Bmvn�Uø�zm>}YU,]ZU$w�}�ntstj p7c�jknt|;my~�ntstjkmyu�jk~ù�ý í�ç�ú�¤2.�mvÎ0~0m V\[!�-ù6Xµ�]V û�W/^`_JÑ ^ _:a'b �-çMí c=¿^�dedGúy&V\[�jku,}��ydMw�rF}K�qn�ute0�0u{rF}K�vmKD+jh~���}Kstjh}K~�n,e0~0g mys#no| m�u{|0j¡� n,ó�¤C�3|0mistmvu{ntstjk�vnojkdM~QdK�(ó*ntdfVH[jku���}�fhfkmyg$}ZnodMrzdMfkdM�Mjk��}Kf(')}Kstl�d·�Q��|F}�jh~@¤Z��m�u{mym¢nt|F}�nC}Kg�±{}K�vmy~0�qxbw�}�ntstjk�ymvu�dK��¥�g0jkstmy�qnomvg ©�Mst}Kr0|0u�c�jknt|gU��Mmvs{nojk�ymvu!x�jkmyfkg¢nodMrzdMfkdM�Mjk��}KfF'>}Kstl�dJ����|0}Kjh~ uyD�}Ku(nt|0myu{m�w�}�ntstjk�ymvu�|F}��Mmmy~�ntstjkmyudM~0f¡x�jk~Qù�ý�í�çKú�¤

�3|0mÁmv~�ntstdMr�x;dK�,g x�~F}Kw�jk��}Kf�u{x�u{ntmyw�uZ|F}Ku¢w�}K~�x���dMstwCe0fh}�nojkdM~0uߥ��v�8¤Ý5!d·c!my~ÿ¥¡HJ¶�§Ó©qD}K~0g;}Kuino|0mvjhs�g0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~0u�}�stm£Ø�e jkntm)jk~��MdMf¡�Mmvg@D3c�m£stmq��so}Kjk~à��s{dMw_}K~�x7�Mmv~0myst}Kf�g0mvÎF~ jkntjhdM~�D�0e n�w�my~�nojkdM~>}K~)jkw�r=dKs{n�}�~�ns{myute fkny¤3"BmvnPU/�zm�}K~$¥�jhs{stmvg0e0�yjk�0fkmJ©#ù�ý í�çKú���w�}�nos{j¡pØUCD }K~0g)fhmqnó:ûhV\[3�iV\[��=m�}C')}Kstl�d·�Eut|0j¡� n�¤&�3| my~ino|0m�ntdMrzdMfhdK�Mjh�y}Kf mv~�nostdKr�xHj@Ã�ó#È+dK� no|0m3g x�~F}�w�jk��}�fu{x�u�nomyw¾jku�Mjk�Kmy~£��x j�Ãæó#Ȧ� þ Åhk3â=ãqÃnU�Èoí

Page 14: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

Í

c�|0mvstm¢âzã�jhu�no|0mEu{r=mv�vntso}Kf&st}Kg0jke0u#dK��UC¤#�+dMr=dKfhdM�Kjh�y}Kf&')}Kstl�d·�>��|F}Kjk~0u,}Ks{m�jkw�rzdMs�n�}K~�n,}Ku�}utdKe0st�vm¢dK�3w�d�g0myfku���dMs�stmvfhmq��}K~�nEg0j|��mvdMw�dMstr |0jhu{w�uyD�}K~0g�}Ku�})w�d�g0mvf���dKs�c�|0jk��|�no| m�nodKr=d��fkdM�Mjk��}Kf=my~�nos{dMr�x���}K~��zm �ydKw�r e nomvg@¤��3|0mvx��Kjk�Km,}Kg0g0mvg£w�dKntjk��}�ntjhdK~�nodiu{nte0g x�no|0m mªp�ntstmvw�}�f��}Kfke0myu�dK��â=ãq¤

')e0��|\s{myu{m�}Ks{��|:|F}Ku£�zmymy~Sg0dM~0mVnts{x�jh~ �ànod�dM� no}Kjk~Se0r r=mvs)}�~0gSfkdJc�mvs>�zdMe0~0g u£��dMsno| m�utrzmy�qnost}Kf1st}Kg0jke0u#e0~0g mys���}Ks{jhdMe u��ydKw��0jk~F}�ntdMstjh}Kf+�ydM~0u�nost}Kjh~�ntuy¤,�1p�nostmvw�}Kf1�Mst}Kr0|0u�e0~0g0mvs��}KstjkdMe0u��vdM~0u{ntso}Kjk~�nou|F}��Mm,�zmymy~)��|F}Kst}K�vntmystjk�ymvg@¤

��rzmy�vntso}bd��#nos{mymyu�c�mvstmÁu�noe0g0jkmyg^��x���dMfkf¬}�nt�Á}K~ g^��jk~0dM�MdJc�j¡no�Á¥»²KLb§«D��myjkfhw�}K~0~<}�~0g"Bjhmv�Á¥»¹KL�§æD�"BdJ���Kut��}K~0gÁ�+myfkjhl��K~¨¥×LMÍb§«D=}K~0gÁd�no|0mvstuy¤��3|0mqx>u{|0dJc�mvgVno|F}�nno| m�u{no}Ks�}KfhdK~0m�|F}�uw�}�p�jhwCe0w utrzmy�vntso}Kf�st}Kg0jke0u�}K~ gàno| m)rF}�no|�}�fhdM~ m)|F}�u�w�jk~0jhwCe0w utrzmy�vntso}Kfso}�g0jhe uy¤^�3|0jkuu{nte0g xàc�}Ku�nt|0my~^n�}�lKmy~¯}�u�nomyr^��e0s�no|0mvsyD�nod$�Mst}Kr0|0u�c�jknt|/Hß}�~0gS²b�vx��yfkmyuvD }K~0g<}Kfkutd�ntd�ydK~0~0my�qnomvg��Mso}�r0|0u�c�jknt|�¿��)Ú&myg0�MmvuyD���dMs2Ú&Î p�myg@¤(�FdMs2no| jhu(f¬}�u{n!�yfh}Kutu!dK�@�Mst}Kr0|0uvD0�!�KmvntlKdJ��jʤ}K~0g���dJc�fhjk~0utdK~µ¥×¶ H�§F�vdM~ ÎFs{w�myg�},�vdM~�±�mv�vnoe stm�dK�=5�ste0}Kfhg jF}K~0g���dMfk|0mvjhg�¥kH�Í�§0no|0}�n2��dMs&¿�fh}Kst�Kmmy~ dMe0�M|@D�no| m��Mst}Kr0|�|F}���jk~0�Ew�}�p�jkw�}Kf=u{r=mv�vntso}Kf so}�g0jhe u�|F}Ku(dM~0m�Mmvs{nomªp�dK�Bg0mv�Mstmvm�¿�åQç#}�~0gdM~0m �Kmys{ntmqp£dK��g0mv�Mstmvm�Ú��;ÂZ¥�nt|0m,stmvw�}�jh~0jk~0���Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�|F}��KmCg0mv�Mstmvm�HCdMs²�DF}Ku�stmvØ�e jhs{myg ©ª¤

�FdMs }��Mj¡�Mmy~Q~�e0w��zmys¼� dK��mvg0�Mmvu¢¥�}K~0gß~0dZ�ydK~0g0j¡nojkdM~ßdM~Vno|0m�~�e0w��zmys,dK�(�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�©ªD5�s{eF}Kfkg0j@}K~ gZ��dZ�=w�}K~�¥kHJÕ�§@�vdM~�±�my�qnoe0s{myg�no|0}�n�nt|0m �Mso}�r0|�dM~�Ú��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuyDFc�|0mvstm � ÒÐ � äÌ�°ü� ÒêèFãÐ � D0�vdM~0utjku{ntjh~ ��dK��Ï�ÒêèFã�}�~0gZdM~0m,}Kg0g jkntjhdM~0}Kf=�Kmys{ntmqp£dK�+g0mv�Mstmvm»��åõ� ÒêèFãÐ � jhu�nt|0m,e0~0jkØ�e0m�Mst}Kr0|�c�jknt|)w�}�p�jkw�}KfGutrzmy�vntso}KfBst}Kg0jke0uy�0nt|0jku�c�}Ku�ydM~�ÎFstw�myg)��xZ�dJc�fkjh~ utdM~Þ¥´ÕMÕ�§«¤

��dM~ � ¥»¹KI�§��zdMe0~0g0mvgCnt|0m!u{r=mv�vntso}Kf�so}Kg jhe0u+jk~Cnomvstw�u1d�� no| m!~�e0wC�=mvs1¿�dK�G¥�~0dM~���jhu{dMf¬}�nomygF©�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu#}�~0g�no|0m,~�e0w��zmysL�°d��1mvg0�MmyudK�1áA}Ku3��dMfkfhdJc�uv�

â=ãvÃæáiÈ(ö � Â�� å�¿��<çZ&�3|0jku��zdMe0~0g¢c�}Ku�e utmyg¢��x���}Kdi}�~0g¢�#jk~0�vmf¥´²�Hì§=jh~¢nt|0myjks��zdMe0~ g0u�dM~�no|0m#u{r=mv�vntso}Kfzso}Kg jhe0u!dK�r0fh}K~F}Ks�}�~0g)dKe nomvsr f¬}K~0}Ks3�Mso}�r0|0uy¤

�3|0mEu{r=mv�vnost}Kf1st}Kg0jke0u�d����Mso}Kr |0u�c�j¡no|Ás{myu�nostjk�vntjhdK~0u dM~>nt|0m���|0s{dMw�}�nojk�E~�e0wC�=mvs æ ëáEÈ|F}��Mmi�zmymv~Vu{nte0g0jkmygQ}Ku�c!myfkfæ¤ �<jkfk�P¥×ÍMÍ�§1ut|0dJc!mygVno|F}�n æ ëáEÈ�ö4âzãvëáEÈ;�:çM¤,�!�Mmqnol�d·��j�¤µ¥»²MÕ�§r0s{d·�Kmyg�nt|F}�n�â=ãqÃæáiÈ!ö-Ã�ç2åbç·õ æ ÃæáiÈ{È�¿1D�c�|0jk��|¢c�}Ku�fh}�nomvs!jkw�r0stdJ�Mmvg���x��<jkfk�8D�c�|0dEs{myr0fh}K�vmygæ ëáEÈ���xmlÃæáiÈoDGnt|0m��yfkjhØ�e0m�~�e w��zmys�d��3á�¤��~�nt|0jhu,no| myutjkuyD�c�m�jhw�r0s{dJ�Mm¢e r=dM~Q�<jhf¡�vÖ»u�stmª�ute fknyD�dM� no}Kjh~ jh~0�Qno|0m£nojk�M|�n¢�zdMe0~ g�}K~0gàg0mvntmys{w�jk~0jk~0�$}Kfkf�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf�Mso}�r0|0uy¤^�!�MmvntlKdJ��jʤ�Ö»u

Page 15: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

I

stmvute0f¡n£c�}Ku£jkw�r stdJ�Mmvg:jk~:}K~ dKno|0mvsZg0jhs{my�qnojkdM~:��x¯�2fhr |0jh��lÿ¥×¶�¹�§ c�| dàu{|0dJc�mvg:no|F}�nÁâ=ã7ö� Â��ßÃ{ç�å^ç·õ æ ëáEÈtÈtD�c�| mystm»�¼jku3}K��}�jh~¢nt|0m#~�e0wC�=mvs3dK�Gmyg0�Kmyuy¤(�dM~0�Ee0u{myg�no| jhu�s{myu{e0fkn}�~0gno| mC�m�}�c!d�d�gÁ��dKfhdMs{jh~ ���3| mydMs{myw¨nod��Mj¡�Mm��zdMe0~0g0u�dM~Zno| m�u{r=mv�vntso}KfBst}Kg0jke0u�dK�1�Kso}Kr0| umvwE��zmyg0gF}��0fhmCdM~>u{e0s{��}��ymyuE¥��vdMw�rF}K�vn#²·��g0jhw�mv~0utjkdM~F}Kf+w�}K~0j¡��dMfkg0u�©ª¤3�~V��mv�vnojkdM~Á½ ¤´Lic�mCjhw�r0s{dJ�Mme0rzdM~Zno|0mvutm,�=dKe0~0g0uv¤

�FdMs���e0s�no|0mvs�jh~���dMstw�}�ntjhdM~;dM~�no|0m>utrzmy�vntso}Kf�so}Kg0jke0uvDnt|0mÁstmy}Kg0mvs�jhu�s{mv��mvststmvg^nod�no| mute s{�Mmqx7��x7�!�Mmqnol�d·��j�¤Á}K~ g7�dJc�fkjh~0u{dM~�¥»¶�²�§�}K~0g$nt|0m�¶Ks{g�mvg0j¡nojkdM~7dK��no|0m�w�dM~0dK�Mso}Kr |$��x�!�Mmqnol�d·��j�¤Emvn}�fæ¤d¥×¶Mµ�§æ¤Û»���T�C���7�i�n���Ø�T�7�H� �ÝrF}Ks�nojk�ye0fh}Ks{fkx¢jh~�nomvstmvu{nojk~0�¢}Kr0r0fkjh�y}�nojkdM~ZdK�+�Mst}Kr0|Zutrzmy�qnoso}i|F}�u3�=mvmy~}Áfkjh~0l�jk~0�QdK��no|0m�mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0mZ��}�r�c�jknt|7nt|0m�jk~�ntmys{�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg0~ myutu¢dK��á�D(}K~$jk~�noe0j¡noj¡�Mm�D!xMmqnjkw�r stmy�vjhu{mKD �vdM~0�ymvr n�¤���mßnt|0jk~0l�dK�C�Mso}�r0|0u£}KuZ�=mvjh~ ��é�|0jk�M|0f¡x^jh~�ntmyst�vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg�ê�j¡��fh}Kst�Kmute �0utmqnou&dK��no|0m(�Mst}Kr0|���}K~0~ dKn1�zm(�ye n�dZ����stdMwSno|0m(stmvu{n���xC}�utw�}Kfkf�~�e0wC�=mvs1dK� myg0�Kmyuy���Kso}Kr0| uc�j¡no|�no|0jku3r0s{dMr=mvs{n�x¢|F}��Mm,utw�}Kfkf@g0jh}Kw�mvntmysy¤!�#~�no| m dKno|0mvs�|F}K~ g@D no| m jh~�nomvst�vdM~0~0mv�vnojkdM~0u�}Ks{mé�c!m�}�l�ê�}�~0gVé���so}K�KjhfkmqêEjk�!no|0m��Mso}�r0|�jku�m�}Ku�xVnod£utr0fkjknyD1}�~0gb�y}K~��zm�g0jhu{�ydM~ ~0my�qnomyg�}�n�w�}�~�xr0fh}K�ymvuy¤���e0��|£�Mso}�r0|0u�|F}��Mm�f¬}�st�Mm g0jh}Kw�mvntmysv¤

��dMw�mEjk~�nomys{myu�nojk~0��stmvute0f¡nou mªp | jh�0j¡n,}¢s{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jkrV�=mqn�c�mvmy~Vno|0mvutmi�vdM~0�ymvr nou#}K~0gÁno| mmyjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m$��}�r@¤Ì�3|0m�ÎFs{u{nVs{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jhrÝc�}KuÁ~0d�nojk�ymyg-jk~6HJI�ÕK¶à��x:�1jkmyg0fkmys¨¥ ½�Lb§«D�c�|0d�zdMe0~0g0mvg¢no| m��ydK~0~0my�qnoj¡��jkn�x¢dK�Gá-}K�zd·�Km }K~0g��=mvfhdJc¯��x���e0~0�vntjhdK~0u�dK��no|0m�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m#��}Kr�dK�ᦥ�jh~Á��}��vn�D�|0mi��}KfkfkmygVno|0m���}KrÁno| m!tZu\{Ch���mtZw jJj ¡�}i}%h jlknwx~�wxk ¢ZdK�!áC©q¤,��fkdM~ß}K~0gQ'£jhfkw�}K~Ñ¥×½Z§}K~0gZ��}K~0~0mvs¼¥»ÍK½�§B�=dKe0~0g0mvg£nt|0m,��}Kr£}K�zd·�Km�}K~0g£.�d�g0�yjke0l�}K~ g>� my~ gF}Kfkf·¥»¶�½Z§«D0}K~0g£��fkdM~,¥´²�§�zdMe0~0g0mvgQnt|0m���}KrV�zmyfkdJc,D���xÁ��e0~ �vnojkdM~0u,dK�(no| mijhu{dMr=mvstjkw�mvnos{jh��so}�nojkd£d���á�D+}�w�dKstmi�MfkdM�F}Kfw�m�}Ku{e0stm¢dK���vdM~0~0mv�vnoj¡��jkn�xK¤V��jkw�jhfh}KsCstmyfh}�ntjhdM~ ut|0jkr0u���dMs nt|0m�}K~0}KfhdK�MdMe0uvD�no| dMe0�M|�utdMw�mvc�|0}�ng0j|��mvstmv~�n¢rF}Kst}Kw�mvnomvs�d��¬hlu¶h jlk mpw jtZuPj ¡�}�vZoijlk tZ}%j h>d��#�Mst}Kr0|0u�c�}�u¢ut| d·c�~;��x;��jk~0�vf¬}Kjks�}�~0gEKmys{ste0w ¥»ÍM²�§«¤Q�3|0mvutm£stmyu{e0f¡nou�w�}Jx�}Kfkf��zm��ydM~0u{jhg mystmvg�}Ku�g0jhu{�ys{mvnom��Kmystu{jhdK~0u�d��#��| mymy�KmysyÖ×ujk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�xZjh~£g0j|��mvstmy~�ntj¬}KfG�MmvdMw�mvnts{xM¤

��u)}$r0stdK��dKe0~0gS}Kr0r0fkjh�y}�nojkdM~¯dK��nt|0jku£s{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jkr@D,"Be0�=d�noutl�xKD �2|0jhfkfkjhr0uvD�}K~0g:� }Ks��~F}Kl�¥»ÕKµ�§æDz}K~0gÁ'>}Kst�Ke0fhjkuA¥´ÕM²�§+�ydM~0u�nos{e0�vntmygÁmªp r fhjk�yj¡n#��}Kw�jkfhjkmyudK�&�Kso}Kr0| u�|F}���jk~0��fh}Kst�Mm,�Mjks{nt|}K~0gbf¬}Ks{�Mm���|0stdMw�}�ntjh�¢~�e w��zmysyD&nt|�e0u�é8g myso}�~0g0dMw�jk�yjk~0��ê¢})�vmyfkmy�0st}�nomvg$r0stdM�0}K�0jkfhjku{ntjh��r std�dK�

Page 16: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

HJµ

dK��mªp jku{ntmy~0�vm�dK��ute ��|��Kso}Kr0| u���x��2s{g0ÙMu<¥×¶�Õ�§æ¤>�+dÁmyu�n�}K� fhjkut|$no|0}�n�nt|0m¢�Mst}Kr0|0u�|F}��Mm�fh}Kst�Km��|0s{dMw�}�nojk�,~�e w��zmysyDFnt|0mvxZe0u{myg>��dZ�=w�}K~@Ö×us{myu{e0fknw�my~�ntjhdM~ mygÁ}��=dJ�Mm�¤

�3|0myu{m#stmvute0f¡nou�}Kfkutd�r stdJ�Mmno|0m�mqp�jhu�nomv~0�ym#d��BmOn��yjkmy~�n�}�fh�MdKstj¡no|0w�u���dMs�so}K~0g dMw6�Mmy~ myso}·�nojkdM~@¤��bm3c�}K~�n(ntd,r0stdJ�Mm�no|0}�n(}�st}K~0g0dKw*c�}Kfhlid���rzdMf¡x�~ dMw�j¬}KfFfkmy~ �Kno|�dM~��ymys�n�}Kjk~��Mso}Kr |0u2dK�mqp�rzdM~0mv~�ntj¬}�f=u{jh�vm�c�jkfhf �ydK~��Kmys{�Mm�ntd�}K~¢}Kfkw�dKu{n!e0~0j¡��dMstwAg jhu�nostjk�0e ntjhdK~@¤(��jk~0�yfh}Kjks�}K~0goEKmys{ste0wut| d·c!myg)no|F}�n�nt|0mCmvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m���}KrZ��dMs3no| mC�Mst}Kr0|0u3nt|0mvx£e0u{myg>jkw�r0fkjhmvu�no| mCs{myØ�e0jkstmyg>�=dMe ~0gdM~�nt|0m myfkmy�qnostjk��}�f@�ydM~ g0e0�vno}K~0�vmK¤(��u3}E�vdM~0utmvØ�e0my~0�vmKD no|0mqx�u{|0dJc�mvg£nt|F}�n�nt|0m#rzmystw�}K~ my~�n�dK�})g my~0u{m>ù�ý í�çKú���w�}�nos{j¡pQw�}�xQ�=m�myu{ntjhw�}�ntmyg$m=n��vjhmv~�nof¡xM¤7¥ �bm�stmv��mvsCntd)no| m¢w�dM~0dM�Kso}Kr0|�dK���jk~0�yfh}Kjks¼¥»Í Hì§G}K~0gZno|0m�}Ks�nojk�yfkm,��x�"GdJ���Ku{�¬¥×L�Õb§æ¤´©

��|�e0~0�Ó¥»²M²�§æDz')dM|0}Ks¼¥´Õ�½�§«DF��fhdM~)}K~0gÁ')jkfhw�}K~^¥×½�§«Dz}K~0g)��}�myw�mys{u­¥»¹M¹�§G|F}��KmC�zdMe0~0g mygno| m�g0jh}Kw�mvntmys�d���á�}K�=dJ�Km���xZ��e0~0�vntjhdK~0u�dK�1no|0mC��}Kr@Dz}K~0gÁ"+}�~0gF}Ke>}K~0gV�#g0f¡x��yl�d�¥»LML�§1}�~0g')�y��}�x�¥�utmymJ¥»Õ�½Z§Ó©�|F}��Mm��=dKe0~0g0mvg£nt|0m,g0j¬}�w�mqnomvs�dK�1á4�zmyfkdJcÝ��x���e0~0�qnojkdM~0u�dK�1nt|0m,��}Kr@¤

��~ ��dKs{noe ~F}�nomvfkxKD+}Kfhf�no|0mvutm�stmvute0f¡nou�w�my~�nojkdM~0mvgb}K�zdJ�Mmix�jhmvfhgQfkjkn{nofkm�jk~ ��dMs{w�}�nojkdM~ßjk�(no| m��}KrZjku3�Mmys�xZutw�}Kfkfæ¤

5�e0u{utmyw�}Kl�mys�mvn�}Kf�¤hÖ×u�n�}��0fhm�w�my~�nojkdM~0mvg£dK~�rF}K�MmCH#ute �M�Mmyu�nou�nt|F}�n�nt|0jku�stmvf¬}�nojkdM~0ut| jhr�jkuw�e ��|�u{ntstdM~0�Kmys2no|F}�~�nt|0m�mªp�jhu�nojk~0��s{myute fkntu!jk~0g0jk��}�ntmK¤2�~0g mymyg�D�no| m�Kso}Kr0|�c�j¡no|¢u{w�}Kfhfkmyu�n��M}Kr|F}Ku�no| mfh}Ks{�Mmyu�n�g0jh}Kw�mvntmys(jh~�m�}���|¢dK�=no|0mvjhs(fhjku{ntuyD�}K~0g�}KfkfF�Mso}Kr |0u(c�j¡no|�w�}�p�jhwCe0w�g0jh}Kw�mvnomvs|F}��Mm¢��}Krbfkmyu{uCnt|F}K~bnt|F}�nCdK�3�Mst}Kr0|0u,c�jknt|�utw�}Kfkfkmys�g j¬}Kw�mqnomysv¤Á�#e0s�stmvute0f¡nouvD2g0mvntmys{w�jk~0jk~0�no| mi�ydM~0~ my�vntmygßnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n,�Mst}Kr0|Ác�j¡no|ßw�jh~0jkw�e w¦��}KrÁ��dMs�}Kfkf&¿1DB}�~0gßut|0dJc�jk~0��no|F}�n#jkn,|F}�uw�}�p�jhwCe0w¾g0jh}Kw�mvntmysyD u{e0r0rzdMs{n3nt|0jhuu{ntstdM~ �Mmys3fkjh~ lz¤

��������� prq�#7&9-/�s!*)�>�&6!94�@t#�@u-6��&/v�1p�ntstmvw�}�f@�Mso}�r0|�no|0mvdMs{x¢jhu�nt|0m#u�noe0g x¢dK�Gno|0m,}�u{x�w�r nodKntjh� �zmy|0}J��jkdMs3dK�G�Mst}Kr0|�jk~��K}�stj �

}K~�nouv¤���m�g0d~0dKn1}�n{nomyw�r n�nodg0d(±�e u{nojk�ym!|0mys{m!ntd�mªp�ntstmvw�}�f �Mst}Kr0|,no|0mvdMs{xKDM}Ku+no|F}�n+jku1�zmvxKdM~0gno| miut�ydKr=midK��nt|0jhu#nt|0myu{jhuv¤���mistmv��mvs#no|0mijk~�nomvstmyu�nomvg�s{m�}Kg0mvs#nod£5�dMfkfkdM�F�KuvÖ»u w�dM~0dK�Mso}Kr |¨¥»Í�§}K~0gZ|0jku3ute s{�Mmqx,¥»I�§«DF}�u�c�mvfhfG}Ku�ntdino|0m u{e0s{�KmvxZdK�1��jkw�dM~0dJ��jkntuA¥×ÍMµ�§æ¤&��m w�mv~�nojkdM~)| mystm dK~0fkxno| dMutm,stmvute0f¡nou�c�|0jk��|>s{myfh}�nom,g0jkstmv�vnof¡x�nodint|0jhu3nt|0myu{jhuv¤

�1p�ntstmvw�}�f!�Mst}Kr0|ßno|0mvdMs{xßu�n�}Ks�nomvgQc�j¡no|���e0st�K~bjk~;H�IK½0HMDG}Kf¡no| dMe0�M|�dM~0m��ydMe fhgb}Kst�Me mno|0}�n�2e0fhmvsyÖ×u�s{myu{e0fkn��dMs3r0fh}K~F}�s3�Mso}Kr |0uy�»����ëáEÈ���ö2� ô7�\��ëáEÈ��·å7É D�c�}Ku�no| m,Î0stu{nmªp�ntstmvw�}�f

Page 17: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

HMH

�Mst}Kr0|�nt|0mydMs{mvntjh��nt|0mydKstmywZ¤&�+e0st�K~ijh~��Kmyu{ntjh�M}�nomvg�nt|0m�~�e0wC�=mvs&dK� myg �Mmyu�}��Kso}Kr0|Eá¯�y}K~i|F}��Mm�D�Mj¡�Mmv~¢no|F}�n!j¡n(g0d�myu(~0dKn!�ydM~�n�}�jh~¢Ï�Òkò=ã�}�u�},ute0� �Mso}Kr |@D },utrzmy�vj¬}�f=�y}KutmdK��c�| jh��|ߥ Ú��\ÂK©2|0}Kg}Kfkstmy}Kg x£�=mvmy~Vu{dMfk�Kmygßjk~�HJIMµ�Õ���xÁ')}K~�nomyf)¥´Õ�H�§«¤�+e0so�K~Vu{|0dJc�mvgÁno|F}�n#~0d�u{e0��|V�Mst}Kr0|ÁdM~>¿�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyui��}�~b�ydK~�no}Kjk~�w�dMstm�myg0�MmvuCnt|F}K~�nt|0mþÕFoCm4ÚZ}�{´m4tlgi³�ó�Ãæ¿1í{ÚoÈ�D&}�~0gbno|0}�nCnt|0jku�jkuCno| me0~0jkØ�e0m�mªp�nostmvw�}Kf��Kso}Kr0|�¤��3|0jku��Mst}Kr0|>|0}KuÚ�utmvntu�dK���Mmvs{nojk�ymvu#dK��}�fhw�dMu�n�mvØ�e0}KfGutjk�ym�¥�myj¡no|0mvsà ¿@õ�ÚXÄ�dMs_Å ¿@õ�ÚXÆ�©ªD&}K~0g�myg0�Kmyu��ydM~0~ my�vnE}Kfkf2rF}Kjkstu�dK���Kmys{ntjh�vmyuEjk~Qg0j��=mys{my~�nEu{mvntuy¤���jh�M~ mys�¥kH�§|F}Ku}i~0jk�ym�ute0s��MmqxZdK�1u{mv�Kmyso}�f�jk~�nomys{myu�nojk~0�¢r0s{d�d���u3dK��nt|0jku�nt|0mydKstmywZ¤

�~�HJIK½ML DM�2stg ÙMu&}K~ g���nodK~0m�¥ ½�¹�§�c�mvstm3}��0fhm(nod#mªp�nomy~ gi��e0st�K~@Ö×u�nt|0mydMs{myw-nodno|0m��Kso}Kr0| uÏ�Òkò=ãvÃn��ÈoD�nt|0m �ydMw�r0fkmvntm�Ã�Ú��;ç�Èæ��rF}�s{noj¡nom��Mso}Kr |�c�jknt|!���Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�jh~Zm�}���|£�vdMfkdMs��yfh}Ku{u�¥ no|0jku�jkuó�à ��Ã�Ú;�:ç�È�ítÚ;�:ç�È3jk~ÁdMe s�~0dKno}�nojkdM~V}��=dJ�Mm�©q¤��3|0mvx>ut|0dJc!mygVno|F}�n�nt|0mE~�e0w��zmys�dK��myg0�Kmyu#jk~�Mst}Kr0|0u�~0dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0��Ï�Òkò=ãvà ��È�D g0myrzmy~0g u�}Ku�x�w�r�nodKntjh�y}Kfhf¡xZdM~0f¡x�dM~ZÚ3}�~0gZ¿1DFj�¤»m�¤hD

���¢ÃæáiÈ���ö-Ã{ç�å^ç·õ�ÚoÈw ¿ Â�x �$#�Ãæ¿ Ð ÈÎ&�2stg0ÙKui}K~0g���jkw�dM~0dJ��jkntuØ¥×½�²�§�~0d�nojk�ymyg�nt|F}�nEnt|0jkuEuo}Kw�m��zdMe0~0g$| dMfhg u���dMsE}�~�xb�Mso}�r0|bc�j¡no|��|0s{dMw�}�nojk��~�e0wC�=mvs£Ú"� çMD�}K~0g¯|0my~0�vm���dMsZ}�st�0j¡nost}Ks{x���}�w�jkfkjhmvu)dK���Mso}�r0|0u�î ��dMs�c�| jh��|Ú��¯ç��¯Ä ÿ¶âTã·ä�åJæ ëïßÈ�¤

�3|0m�mªp�nostmvw�}Kf �Mso}Kr |0u(��dKs!},�Mj¡�Mmv~���}Kw�jkfkx�dK��mqp��yfke0g0mvgVÃ�Úy�bç�È«����|0stdMw�}�ntjh���Mst}Kr0|0u!}Ks{m~0dKn�l�~0dJc�~�jk~��Mmv~0myst}Kf�}�~0g�j¡nijhuC~F}�nte0so}Kf�nodÁ}Kutlßc�|0mvnt|0mysEnt|0m�u�noste �vnoe stm�wCe0u{ni�zm��vfhdMu{mnodi�+e0st�K~@Ö×u��Mso}�r0|�ó�Ãæ¿1í{ÚoÈ�¤��2stg0ÙKu»¥»¶KÍ D0¶MIb§B}K~ g£��jhw�dM~ d·��j¡nou¼¥»ÕKI�§�jh~0g myrzmy~0g0mv~�nof¡x£}K~0u{c!mys{mygno| jhu Ø�e0mvu{nojkdM~Qjh~Ánt|0m�}'n�stw�}�ntjk�KmK¤C�~ß��}��vn#nt|0mvx>mv�Mmv~�u{|0dJc�mvgQnt|F}�n#nt|0mimqp�ntstmyw�}Kf2�Kso}Kr0| u}Ks{mCu�n�}K�0fkm�jh~£no|0m�utmv~0utm�nt|F}�nj¡��á6jhu�}��Kso}Kr0|)~0dKn��ydM~�no}Kjh~ jh~0�¢})Ã�Ú��¯ç�È«����| stdMw�}�ntjh���Mso}�r0|ï }KuE}Zute0� �Mso}Kr |@D2}K~0gbá¾|F}KuC}Kfhw�dMu�nE}�u�w�}K~�xQmyg0�MmvuE}KuC}K~�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf(�Mso}Kr |@D+nt|0my~b��x}Kg0g jh~0��}K~0gÁu{e0� nost}K�vntjh~ ��dM~0f¡xÁ}¢u{w�}Kfhf+~�e0w��zmys d��2myg0�Kmyu#nost}K~0u���dMstw�u#á�jk~�ntdZ}�u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|dK�+no|0m,�+e0so��~)�Mst}Kr0|Zó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈ�¤

�-�0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntmC}�~F}KfkdM�Me0m nodint|0mCr stdM�0fkmyw �ydM~0u{jhg mystmvgÁ��x��+e0so�K~Zc�}Ku�rzdMu{myg>��x£?@}�so}K~��l�jhmqc�jh�v�!¥»IMµb§&jk~$HJI�¹�HK¤��3|0mEr stdM�0fkmywøjhu�nod�g0mqnomvstw�jh~ mEno|0mEw�}�p�jkw�e0wø~�e0w��zmys dK��mvg0�Mmvu }�Mst}Kr0|�w�}JxE�ydM~�n�}�jh~��Mj¡�Mmy~�no|0}�n�jkn�g d�mvu(~ dKn��ydM~�no}Kjh~�no| m�vdMw�r0fkmvnom��0jkrF}Ks�noj¡nom��Mst}Kr0|�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò�}�u}�u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|@¤�3|0mCr0stdM� fhmvwÜ|0}Ku��zmy�vdMw�m�l�~0dJc�~ß}Ku�nt|0mHy'tZm4tZ}{z�w hl¸·w j(|?g�mΡZ��u¶hlqi¤3�~�H�I�¹�½0D

Page 18: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

H·²

� ÙJ�K��stj�D0���KuyD0}�~0g��+e0so�K~�¥×LK½�§���}��Km }K~�e0r r=mvs��=dKe0~0g@¤&�3| mvx�u{|0dJc�mvg�no|F}�n(��dMs�}K~�x¢u{e0��|Zá�Dno| m,��dKfhfkdJc�jh~0���zdMe0~0gZ|0dMfkg0uv�

� �¢ÃæáiÈ���ö/à }å;ç�È ã ç«Ò ¿ Ð4èFã ç«Ò õKÂC&�3|0mvstm(g0d�mvuB~0dKn�}Kr0rzm�}�s@nod��=m�}3u{jhw�r0fkm!mªp�nostmvw�}Kf��Mso}Kr |C}�uBjh~,no|0m��y}Kutm�dK����e so�K~@Ö×uBno|0mvdMstmvwZD}K~0g���dMsu}��<Ú�üÌ� D�nt|0m�Ø�e0mvu{ntjhdM~�dK�0c�|0mqno|0mvs&dMs+~0dKn+no|0jku1jku�nt|0m��vdMsts{my�vn1dMstg mys+dK�Fw�}K�M~0j¡noe g0mjku(u�nojkfhf dMr=mv~@¤&�n�jku��ydM~�±�mv�vnte0stmvg�nt|F}�n2no| jhu2�zdMe0~0g�jku�}Ku{x�w�r nod�nojk��}Kfkfkx��vdMsts{my�qn2��dMs�}Kfkf$}�}K~ g�Úª¤

�<|F}�n�jhu!l�~ d·c�~�jku�nt|F}�n(no|0m�dMstg0mvs�dK�@w�}��M~0j¡noe0g0m�dK�@no| jhu!�=dMe ~0g�jku��ydMs{stmv�vn���dKs,}��SÂ}K~0gQ}Kfkf�ÚE¥æ� fkmyjk~@DG}Ku s{myrzdMs{ntmygß��xß�2stg0ÙMu�¥×¶ML�§Ó©qD2}J�r��}K~ g�}�fhf+Úi¥�5�stdJc�~Ñ¥kH�L�§ ©ªDG}K~0gß}Kfkf~}}K~0g�Ú!uo}�nojku{� x�jh~ ��Ú�ät}��ì��ç�¥æ� dMfkfh�KsyD �dM~�xM}KjæD }�~0g£����}��=�Ø¥×LM¶�§Ó©q¤��Fe0s�no|0mvstw�dMstm�D no| m �=dMe ~0gjku�}�u{x�w�r nodKntjh�y}Kfkfkx�ntjh�M|�n���dMsB}��<Ú��\ÂZ¥æ�2s{g0ÙMuyD ���y~�x�j�D����Mu¼¥×½0Hì§+}K~0g£5�stdJc�~Þ¥kHJLb§ ©3}K~ g£��dMs}��SÂC}K~0g�}KfhfFÚ�¥��uA0stmvg0j�¥×½�Õ�§ ©ª¤&�~��vdM~�noso}�u{n�D�no|0m�zmyu{n�l�~0dJc�~�fhdJc!mys��zdMe0~0g uyD�g0e0m�ntdE�2stg ÙMu}K~0g>��rzmy~0�vmys¼¥ ½�¶�§æDFe0utjk~0��}�r stdM�F}��0jhfkjku{nojk�C}Kst�Me w�mv~�n�DF�Mj¡�Mmvu�dM~ fkxg� Ã�¿ ãEè�ÐEç7�¡Ô«ò Ò�� È�¤/�3�� -�NLO��s6sS.�·DF69@HGBRD��¦D7NLBÁ@�:�DFKP8÷5C8;BFNT�EDCB¨6sGùDFKP8t��69BCB�8;5�D��¦DF6s@HG

��fkf�w�}�±�dKs�stmvute0f¡nou�}KstmCjh~)no|0mCr0std��ymvutu#dK�&r0e0�0fkjh�y}�nojkdM~Ájk~Áu{r=mv�yjh}Kfhjk�ymvg¢±�dMe0s{~F}Kfkuy¤�3|0mg0jkutu{mys{no}�nojkdM~)jh~0�vfhe g0myustmvute0f¡noudM� no}Kjh~ myg£jh~£�ydMfkfh}K�=dKso}�ntjhdM~�¤

��my�qnojkdM~�¶ ¤´¶#s{myr0s{myu{my~�nou(jh~ g0jk��jkg0eF}Kf�c�dMs{l�c�j¡no|0dMe�n��yd�}Ke�no|0dMs{u�}K~0gi|F}�u2�=mvmy~�}K�y�vmyr ntmyg��dMs�r0e0�0fkjk��}�ntjhdM~;jh~;nt|0mY�F¡�o�mp}�tZu�¡9×f��u\{Ch���m4tZw j��*¡�qJ��wx}�tZkE¡�mpw j eØ¥»¹K¶�§æ¤<�3|0m>s{myw�}Kjk~0g0mys�dK���|F}Kr�nomys¶�stmvr0stmvutmy~�ntu�±�dMjk~�n�c�dMs{l¢c�j¡no|V��fkmyw�mv~0u�5!so}K~0g)}K~0g��<jkfk��s{jhmvg>�w�stjk��|�¥¡H�½�§«¤

��my�qnojkdM~ݽ0¤»¶às{myr0s{myutmv~�noußjh~ g0jk��jkg0eF}Kf�c�dKstl<c�jknt|0dMe n>�yd�}Ke�no|0dMs{u�¥»¹M²�§æD�}Ku>g0d�myuV��my�ª�nojkdM~�½0¤»L ¤à�3| m)s{myw�}Kjk~0jh~ ��s{myute fkntu¢jk~���|F}�r nomvs�½ßc�mvstm£dM� no}Kjh~ myg;jk~��ydMfkf¬}��=dMst}�nojkdM~$c�j¡no|no| mC}�e no|0dKsyÖ×u�}�g ��jhu{dMs"+��ut�yfk��5�}K�F}Kj¦¥»L DzÕ�§«¤

Page 19: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

O,+SN.-ß`VX£Þ �-VÞàX£W 0 ] 0 RSN�Þ 0 XÁa

��34/ ­��HBC69St��5{��>�KùDFKP8;@�5���~$no|0jkuEno|0mvutjkuyD�c�m��vdM~0u{jhg0mvsiÎF~0j¡nom�e0~0g jhs{my�vntmyg��Mso}�r0|0u�c�j¡no|0dKe n�fhd�dMr0uidKsEw�e0f¡nojkr0fkm

myg �Mmyuv¤!�3|0m,g0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~0u�=mvfhdJc:stmO�0my�vnno| jhu��ydK~��Kmy~�nojkdM~@¤�*�Kso}Kr0|>á��6à��í �iÈ��vdM~0u{jhu�nou#dK�&}��Kmys{ntmqp>utmqn`��}K~0gÁ}�~>myg �Mm�u{mvn���D c�|0mys{m�mv�Kmys�x

myg �Mmi¥�myfkmyw�my~�n�dK�d��©(jku3}K~�e0~0dMs{g0mys{myg�rF}Kjks�d��Bg0jku{nojk~0�qn��Mmvs{nojk�ymvuC¥�myfkmyw�mv~�ntu3dK���C©q¤(� so}Kr0| ug0mv~0dKnomvg>��x�nt|0m,fhmqntnomvsá4c�jhfkfG}Kf¡c�}�x�u�|0}J�KmC¿V�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuvD��øö � Ë Ð � myg0�MmvuyD }K~ g£nt|0myjks3�Mmys�nomªputmqn�c�jhfkf@��dMs3utjkw�r0fkjh�vjkn�x£�zmC}�utute w�mvg)ntd��zm no|0m,u{mvn,ù�çMíªÂ�í�&�&�&@ío¿+ú�¤

�bm,ut}Jx¢no|F}�n��Kmys{ntjh�vmyuLa(}K~0gJc�}Ks{mJtRv���t�j hl}ik�j¡�!ùba{íEc0ú­����¤2�~£nt|0jhu��y}Kutm c!m�}Kfkutd�ut}Jxno|0}�nHa1}K~ g cE}Ks{mA}%hlw|{�³F�l¡�mÎeq¤G�bmg0mv~0dKnomno|0jku(��x�a��þcF¤1��m�g my~0dKntm���x á\no|0m j ¡�q�g�u¶hlq¬hl}ikdK�1áAg0mvÎ0~0myg>}Ku3no|0m��Mso}�r0|ZdM~£nt|0m,uo}Kw�m,�Mmvs{nomªp£utmqn�DFc�|0mys{m�n�c!d��Kmys�nojk�ymyu�}Kstm,}�g�±{}K�ymv~�n�jk~á4j¡�2}K~ g£dK~0fkxZj¡�+no|0mqxZ}Kstm,~0d�n}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�njh~)á�¤

��~Ìw¶e�¡�q¬¡�mXgi³�w¶elq¸dK�3n�c!dV�Mso}Kr |0uEjkui}>�0j ±�my�qnojkdM~$�=mqn�c�mvmy~7no|0mvjhsC�Mmys�nomªp$utmqnou�c�| jh��|r0s{myutmvs{�Kmyu)}Kg�±{}K�vmy~0�qx^}Ku�c!myfkf }Ku�~0dK~��8}Kg�±{}K�ymv~0�vxK¤*�Gc�d7�Mst}Kr0|0uZáº}K~0g<ï }Ks{m�w¶e�¡�q¬¡�mp¹gi³�w j�j¡��no| mystm�jhu�}K~bjkutdKw�dKstr0|0jkutw �zmvn�c!mymy~�nt|0mywZ��jk~�no| jhuC��}Ku{m�c!m�c�stj¡nom¢á �� ïb¤£��myf¡�Ó�jkutdMw�dMs{r0|0jkutw�u�d��2}i�Mso}�r0|£}Kstm,��}�fhfkmygÞtZoCkE¡�q¬¡�mXgi³�w¶elq­eq¤

�3|0m<v�h {´mÎh h�dK�&}��Kmys�nomqp�a(jhu�no| m�~�e0wC�=mvs�dK�1~0myjk�M|��zdMstudK�¦a!}K~0g)jhug0mv~0dKnomvg>��x J à a8ÈdMs J Y«¤2�3|0m w�}�p�jhwCe0w¨g0mv�Mstmvm dK��}��Mmys�nomªpZdK��á*jku3g0my~ dKnomvgYLON�PRQ�ÃæáiÈo¤2�3|0mJtZ~Zhlm4t�{Ch¼v�h {´mÎh hdK�1áAjhu L�P��7�vÃæáiȦ��� Y ä�� J à a8È¿ � Â��

¿ & ¥«²�¤hH·©

�3|0m�v�hl}Felwxkn¢�dK�1á4jhu3nt|0m,so}�ntjhd��£õ � Ë Ð � ��L�P��7�vëáEÈ�õ Ã�¿�å^ç�È�¤�6�Mso}�r0|Vjhu�mÎh {´o�u�tZm¢j¡��}�fhf1�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�|F}��Mmint|0miuo}Kw�mig0mv�MstmvmK¤E�ùknmpwx~�tZu¶hl}ik��Mst}Kr0|Vjku,}

stmv�Me0fh}Ks2�Mst}Kr0|idK�=g0my�Kstmym�¶�¤25!xEmvØ�eF}�nojkdM~>¥«²�¤kH·©ªD�} stmy�Ke0f¬}�s&�Mso}�r0|�dK�zd�g0g�g0mv�Mstmvm�w�e0u�n!|0}J�Km}K~Zmv�Kmy~Á~�e0wC�=mvs�dK�1�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuv¤

HJ¶

Page 20: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

H�½

�Ô¸HtZu�z�dK�+fhmv~0�Knt|3U��=mqn�c�mvmy~Z�Mmys�nojk�ymvuLa�}�~0g�c�jku3}Eu{myØ�e0my~ �ym`a'�t�$��í:�@ãªí�&�&�&@í:�*�"�$cdK���Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�ute0��|$nt|F}�n �iY¶èFãC}K~ g¡�TY�}Kstm¢~0myjk�M|��=dKstuE��dMs a¼�¸çMí�&�&�&@íOU ¤ß� gFtZkx³$jkui}>c�}Kfhlc�j¡no|0dMe�n�stmyrzm�}�nomygZ�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤���m,��jkmvcSno|0m rF}�no|0u�Ã��$�ví:�@ãªí�&�&�&�í:�*�JÈ!}K~ g�Ã��*��í�&�&�&Bí:�@ã�í:�$�vÈ!}�ujkg0my~�nojk��}�fæ¤

�3|0m<vZw¶elk tZ}%j h,�zmvn�c!mymv~_a!}�~0g�c¢jku�no|0m�fhmv~0�Knt|>dK�&}�u{|0dMs{ntmyu�n�rF}�no|£�=mqn�c�mvmy~_a(}K~0g¬c �no| m�g0jhu�n�}K~ �ymZjhuijk~ ÎF~ jkntm�jk�no|0mvstm�jkui~0dVute ��|àrF}�no|@¤Q�3|0m^vZwntZq¬hlk9hlm£dK��no| m��Mso}Kr |�jkuEno| mw�}�p�jhwCe0w g jhu�n�}K~0�vm �=mqn�c�mvmy~ZrF}Kjkstu�dK�Gjkntu��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤(�3|0m#�Kso}Kr0|¢jhuAj ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv¢j¡�Gmv�Mmvs{x¢rF}KjksdK�G�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�|F}Ku�ÎF~ jkntm g0jhu�n�}K~ �ymK¤!��jk~0�vm,nt|0m#�Mst}Kr0|0u�c!m �ydK~0utjkg0mys}Ks{m�ÎF~0j¡nom�D0no|0jku3u{no}�nomvw�my~�njkumvØ�e0jk��}Kfkmy~�nnod�no|0m g j¬}Kw�mqnomys�zmyjk~0��Î0~0jkntmK¤

�^utmqn£¢¥¤2�\jku�uo}Kjkg�nod �ye�n(nt|0m��Mso}�r0|�á:jk�1ÃX�2í ��¦�¢EÈ+jhu�g0jkut�vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg@¤��~ino|0jku���}Ku{m¢:jku�}¬jlo�k ¹ e�hlk�¤&�Ôjlo�k ¹hv�{Chjku(}K~�myg0�Mm¨§3dK�B} �ydK~0~0my�qnomvg¢�Mst}Kr0|�ute0��|�no|F}�n3ù'§�ú�jhu(} �ye�n{��u{mvny¤�3|0mµhv�{Chl¹j ¡�}i}%h jlknwx~�wxk ¢�d��(}¢�ydM~ ~0my�qnomygQ�Mst}Kr0|Ájku�no| mEw�jh~0jkw�e w¦utjk�ymidK��j¡nou��ye n���utmqnouv�@no|0jku~�e0w��zmysjku�vmys{d�j¡�&}�~0g)dK~0fkx�jk�+no|0m,�Mst}Kr0|£jhu�g0jkut�vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg@¤

�jlu¶¡�e�hv�¸HtZu�zZd��&fkmy~0�Knt|©U�jku#}�c�}�fhlQÃ��$��í(�Bãoí�&�&�&Bí(�.��È�ute0��|>nt|F}�nT�$�L�ª�*�·¤3�jl¢Rjlu¶hdK��fhmv~0�Knt|«Ubjku�}Á�vfhdKutmyg�c�}�fhl�d���fkmy~0��no|«U^ä �Vc�j¡no| dMe n�stmvr=my}�nomvg��Kmys�nojk�ymyu�dKno| mysEno|0}K~�$�^� �*��¤*�3|0mß�vx��yfkmyu�Ã��$��í:�@ãªí�&�&�&@í:�*��È�D�Ã��*��í�&�&�&@í:�@ãªí(�*�qÈ�D�}K~0g*Ã��@ã�í:�zÐyí�&�&�&Bí:�*�Jí:�$�vÈ�}Ks{m�ydK~0utjkg0mys{myg)jhg0mv~�nojk��}Kf�¤!�3| m­{´wxmpkx³ZdK�2}i�Mst}Kr0|Zjku�nt|0m,fhmv~0�Knt|)dK��j¡nou�ut|0dKs{nomvu{n��vx��yfkmK¤

�3|0mÌj ¡�q�g�u¶hlk9h<{´mtlgi³<Ï�Ë7|F}KuZ¿Ý�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuÁ}�~0g:}�fhf#nt|0m�� Ë Ð � rF}KjkstuZdK���Mmys�nojk�ymvuÁ}Ks{m}Kg�±{}��ymy~�ny¤���dKw�r fhmqnom��Mso}Kr |0u�|F}��Mm�g0my~0u{jkn�xßHK¤

�Ì�Mso}�r0|^jhu,��w gFtZmpknwxk9hÁjk�Cj¡nou��Mmvs{ntmqp<u{mvnZ��}�~^�=mVg0j¡��jhg myg¯jh~�nod$n�c!dbé8�ydKfhdMs��yfh}Kutu{myu8ê¥Óé�stmvg�ê3�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu3}K~ gié��0fhe mqê��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuyD�uo}�x ©qD�ute0��|�no|F}�n(�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�d���no| m�ut}Kw�m��ydKfhdMs(}Ks{m�~0mv�Kmys}Kg�±{}��ymy~�ny¤(�-�Mst}Kr0|Zjku� jhrF}�s{noj¡nom,j¡�&}�~0g)dK~0fkx�jk�1}KfkfB�vx��yfkmyu|F}��Mm�mv�Kmy~>fkmy~ �Kno|0uv¤

�3|0m�j ¡�q�g�u¶hlk9h`��w gFtZmpk wxkEh?{´m4tlgi³£Ï�Ô8Ñ ÒGjku3g0mvÎF~ myg)}Ku���dMfkfhdJc�uy�2j¡n�|F}KuB}���Ú(�Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�}�~0g}yÚ�mvg0�Mmyuv�0no|0m¬}yÚ�mvg0�Mmvu�±�dMjk~Zm�}K��|£dK��no|0m#ÎFs{u{n¨}��Kmys{ntjh�vmyuc�jknt|)my}K��|)d���nt|0m,f¬}Ku�n�Ú��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤�Ôelo7�X{´m4tlgi³£ïÙ�4Ã�ó3í%¢iÈ(d��&áÿ�/ÃX�2í ��È!jku�}i�Mst}Kr0|Zute ��|)no|0}�nó­¤ �6}K~0g]¢®¤2��¤�3|0mEmvg0�Mm�ùba{íEc0ú��Þ�9jhuAwx}�vZoTj hv£��xZnt|0m�u{e0�0utmqn ó¯¤ÿ�9j¡�·a{íEc!�Qó,¤��3|0m�u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|

wx}�vZoij hv£��xZno|0m�ute0� utmvn�ó¯¤÷�6jhu�no| mC�Mst}Kr0|bÃæó3í%¢EÈ�D0c�|0mvstm°¢±¤��9�vdM~0u{jhu�nou�d��2}KfkfGmyg0�Mmvujk~0g0e0�vmyg>��x�ó,¤

Page 21: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

H·¹

�Ýute0� utmvnót¤ �4jhu»wx}�v�hEgihl}�v�hl}ik(jk�+~0dimvg0�Mm jku3jh~ g0e0�ymvg)��x�ó,¤1��m uo}�x�nt|F}�n3ót¤ �jku3}�jlu�wn½�oTh#jk�Gó¯jk~0g0e0�vmyu}��ydKw�r fhmqnom �Mst}Kr0|@¤2�3|0m¬jlu�wn½�oih�}ioCqJ�lhlm~lëáEÈ2dK�+á/jhu!no|0m#u{jh�vm dK�no| m�fh}Ks{�Mmyu�n��vfhjkØ�e0m�ó­¤ ��¤

��u¶h {ytZu;j ¡�u¶¡�mpwx}y{�dK�+}��Kso}Kr0|¢jhu�}K~Z}Kutu{jh�K~0w�my~�n3dK��é��ydMfkdMstu8ênodEmy}K��|��Mmvs{nomªp�u{e0��|�no|F}�n�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�dK�Gno|0m�uo}Kw�m �ydKfhdMs�}Kstm�~0mv�Kmys}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n�¥�m�}K��|Z�ydKfhdMs��yfh}Kutu3jku3}K~�jk~0g0mvr=mv~0g0my~�nutmqnª©ª¤��dMfkdMstjk~0�Mu2d��znt|0m��Mmvs{ntmqp�utmqn2c�jhfkf no}K�yj¡nof¡xE�zm�}Kutu{e0w�myg�nod,�zm�fhmv��}KfF}�~0gino|0m�}Kg�±�my�vntjk�Km�é8fkmy��}Kf êc�jkfhf �zmdKw�j¡ntntmyg@¤1�3|0m�j ³�mΡ�qJtZknw j?}io�qJ�lhlm æ ÃæáiÈ+d���no| m�Kso}Kr0|�á:jku(nt|0m�w�jh~0jkw�e w9~�e0wC�=mvsdK�!�ydMfkdMs{u#��dMs#c�|0jk��|Qnt|0mys{m�jku�}�fhmv��}Kf&�vdMfkdMstjk~0�0¤E�3| m��Kso}Kr0|Qá jku,�0jkrF}Ks{ntjkntmijk��}K~0gQdM~0f¡xÁj¡�æ ëáEÈ!ö¯Â�¤

�3|0mZ�ydMw�r0fkmvntm£Ú���rF}Ks�noj¡nom��Mst}Kr0|�Ï�Ë b ѳ²³²³²�Ñ Ë�´�jku�}ÁÚ����ydKfhdMs{myg��Mso}�r0|$c�jknt|�¿÷� � ÒY¶µ=ã ¿�Y�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu,ute0��|ßno|0}�n�nt|0mi�ydMfkdMs#�vf¬}�ututmvu,|F}��Mmiutjk�ymvu,¿+ãªí�&�&�&Bío¿=Ò�D@stmvutrzmy�vntjk�Kmyf¡xMD�}K~0gVmy}K��|ßrF}KjksdK�!�ydMfkdMs,�yfh}Ku{utmyuCjh~ g0e0�ymvu�}Z�ydKw�r fhmqnom��0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm��Kso}Kr0|;¥�u{d£nt|0m�~�e0w��zmys�dK��mvg0�MmvuCjku`� �� ã�·yY¹¸�[`·�Ò ¿�YÓ¿7[q©q¤

��3 � [.5{��>�KÙBC>¼8;S�DC5{���u�Mmy~ myso}�f+s{mv��mvstmy~ �ymyu��dMs3w�}�nos{j¡pZnt|0mydKs{xMDFc!mCs{mv��mvsnt|0mCs{m�}Kg mys3nod�no|0m�w�dM~0dM�Kso}Kr0| u

��x���}�~�ntw�}K��|0mys�¥×½MÍ�§=}K~0g���x¢�dMst~�}K~0gfEKdM|0~0u{dM~Ó¥×L Hl§«¤&�~�no|0jku�no|0mvutjkuyD��Kmy�qnodMs{u!c�jkfhfz}Kr0rzm�}�sjk~)e0r stjk�M|�n��zdMfkg£��}K�vmKDFc�|0mvstm�}�u�j¡n�}Kfkjk�yu�c�jhfkfG�=m,e0u{myg)��dKsu{��}Kfh}Ks{uy¤3')}�nos{jh�vmyu�c�jhfkf+}Kfkc�}�x�u��zmstmvr0stmvutmv~�ntmygÁ��x��y}Kr0j¡n�}KfBfkmvn{nomvstuy¤(�3|0m�}Kfkf@dM~0mvu�Kmy�qnodMs3c�jkfhfG�zm#c�stj¡ntnomv~»ºP�*Ã�çMí�çMí�&�&�&@í�ç�È Ò ¤

5�mv��dKstmstmyfh}�ntjh~0�C�Mso}�r0|0u�nod�w�}�nostjk�ymvuyD�c�m�stmy�y}KfkfzdKe0s!w�dMu�n!��s{myØ�e0mv~�ntfkx�e0u{myg¢ntd�dKf0��stdMwfkjh~0my}Ks}Kfk�Mmy�0st} D nt|0mC��dMe0so}�~�n��8�1jkut| mys3no|0mvdMstmvw¾dM~Zu{x�w�w�mvnos{jh�Cstmy}Kf@w�}�nos{jh�vmyuv¤

�­�d�y®T����� É��n°¨Ë � ®����b�i����Ý%¼"�n���d�y�¬�b�d��®T�b���ÑÐ�Ò hlkLUß�lh!tZ}Q¿þ]7¿õel¢�qfq¬hlk mpw j¬qJtZk mpw|ó¡�~Zhlmf� C�²PtZ}�v!u¶hlk�âzã äAâ0ÐCä�ôJôJôBä6â Ë^�lh­wxk�e¬hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh e�¾ Ò hlk�½%Y»�lh�tZ}¨hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlkE¡�m*×�¡�mkx³ihLa¹Ekx³_hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh�¾fÕ�³ihl}

â´["� ÄH¾6¿À�Á�À b ѳ²³²³² Ñ À:Â7à b ½ Ò UB½Ä ½ Ä Ð Ã�çCö¨c¢ö^¿GÈ�í

Page 22: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

HJL

tZ}�v�k�³ih­qJt�ó´wxqfo�qÙw¶e tZknkXtZwx}%hv­g�mÎh jlw¶e�hlu�¢P×�¡�m�hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlk9¡�mÎefj ¡�mpmÎh eEgi¡�}�vZwx}y{�k9¡�âR[�¾¼ý }�gFtZmp¹knw jloCu�tZmβ

âzã·�SÄ\¾9¿À ½ Ò UB½Ä ½ Ä Ð &�2jh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0mvu�mv~�ntmys��Mst}Kr0|Zno|0mvdMs{x���jh}Eno|0m�tRv���t�j hl}%jl¢�qJtZk mpw|óM¤�3|0mPtRv���t�j hl}%jl¢?qJtZk mpw|ó�dK��nt|0m��Mso}Kr |,á�D·g0mv~0dKnomvgC��x»U���U�V1D·jhu@nt|0m�¿"]!¿iu�x�w�w�mqnostjk�

w�}�nos{j¡p�U �4ÃXWZY\[�È2c�|0mvstm¼WZY\["�/ç jk�G�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu?a2}K~0gJc�}Kstm#}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n�}K~0g�WZY\["�Sý�dKno| mys{c�jkutm�¤�~�rF}�s{nojk�ye f¬}KsvD7WZY Y%�¯ý���dMs!}Kfkf�a�����¤&�3|0mJhlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih e»¡9×�á/}�stm�no|0m�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0myu�d��;U:}�~0gno| myjkswCe0f¡nojkutmvn�jku3��}Kfkfhmvg)nt|0m­eEgih jlk mpo�qº¡9×�á�¤2�3|0mCu{r=mv�vntste0w¨d��&á4jku�jh~ g0myrzmy~0g my~�n�d��1|0dJcno| m,�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�dK�1áA}Kstm,fh}K�zmyfkmygb¥�jkutdMw�dMs{r0|0jkutw¾jk~���}Ks{j¬}�~�n�©q¤

�bm�~0dKntm�no|0}�n�u{jh~ �ym�U jhuCu{x�w�w�mqnos{jh��D�nt|0m¢mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe myuEdK�?U }Ks{m¢stmy}Kf!}K~0g�c�jkfkf��zmg0mv~0dKnomvg)��x

â=ã�ä:â0ÐäÝôJôJô0ä:â�ËC&�3|0m nost}K�ym,dK�'U-jhu��vmystd D0no|0mvstmv��dKstm � ËY¶µ=ã âCY��:ý ¤

�^�Mmy�qnodMsŽµ�4Ã�X�ãqí�&�&�&@í:X0Ë�È Ò �Á� C Ë �y}K~¢�zm3��jhmqc�mvg�}Ku!}K~¢}�ututjk�M~0w�mv~�n�dK�Fé�c!myjk�M|�nou�ê�ntdno| m#�Mmys�nojk�ymvuy�£X7YGjku3no|0m#c!myjk�M|�ndK�+�Mmys�nomªpØat¤("BmvnÇÆ_��UT½2D�c�|0mys{m�Æ_�*Ã�È�ãªí�&�&�&Bí:È�Ë�È Ò ¤2�3| my~È�[)� I Y¶ÉR[ X7Y ��dMs cf�-çMí�&�&�&@ío¿ð& ¥«²�¤³²M©

¥��3| m�ute w�w�}�ntjhdK~�mqp�nomv~0g0u�dJ�Mmvs�no| m�~0mvjh�M|��zdMstu!dK�TcF¤´©i�~¢rF}Ks{ntjh�ve0fh}Ks!j¡�2½Ájku�}�~�myjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMs�ydKststmvutrzdM~0g0jk~0��nod�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0miâ�no|0mv~£c!m�|F}��Mm

âÊXy[?� I Y¶ÉR[ X7Y ��dMs cf�*çMí�&�&�&@ío¿'& ¥«²�¤´¶�©

�3|0m�Ø�e0}Kg0so}�nojk�,��dKstw˽ Ò UT½b}Kfhu{d�|F}Ku}i~0jh�vmCjk~�nomvstr0s{mvn�}�nojkdM~@�½ Ò UB½_� I Y¶ÉR[ X7YÌXy[�& ¥«²�¤»½�©

�3|0mi��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��c�mvfhf2l�~0dJc�~ß��}K�vntu#��dMfkfhdJc/m�}Ku{jhf¡xÁ��s{dMwÜnt|0m���dMe0st}K~�n{���1jhu{|0mys#nt|0mydKstmyw}K~0g£myØ�eF}�nojkdM~�¥æ²�¤»¶�©q¤¥æ��mym ��dMs3mªp0}�w�r fhm�¥´²�I�§G}K~0g^¥ ½�I�§æ¤³©Í �C�Þ�Þ�^É;�ÊÉ à w ábâzã�äÔ�»â´[R��×�¡�m¼tZuxuyc�¾

Page 23: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

H·Õ

à wxw ábâzã�³Ft�eAt¬}%¡�}i}%h {ytZknwx~Zh­hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlkE¡�mì¾à wxwxw áÞý¶×�á w¶e�j ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv�k�³ihl}Áâzã w¶e`elwxq�g�u¶h à ³Ft�eAqfoCu�knw g�u�w jlwxk ¢3Î á�²"tZ}�v�k�³ihJj ¡�mpmÎh eEgi¡�}�vZwx}y{

hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlkE¡�m,½Ìw¶eAtZuxu�¹¶gi¡�elwxknwx~Zh�¾à wx~á Ò hlk�½ �lh­tZ}�tZuxu�¹¶gi¡�elwxknwx~Zh hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlk9¡�m'×�¡�m¼kx³ihfj ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv­{´m4tlgi³�ᬾ�Õ�³ihl}µk�³ih j ¡�mpmÎhl¹

eEgi¡�}�vZwx}y{<hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh`w¶e�â=ã­tZ}�v�½.w¶e¼wx}i~�tZmlwntZ}ik�o�}�v�hlm»k�³ih­tZo�kE¡�q¬¡�mEgi³�w¶elq­e­¡9×�ᬾà ~áÞý¶×3áIw¶e¼��w gFtZmpknwxk9h»k�³ihl}�wxk�e�eEgih jlknmpoCq w¶e�el¢�qfq¬hlk mpw jtZu�Ï�âFY%�*å â Ë�èyY¡ò=ã,Ãna'�/çMí�&�&�&@ío¿GÈl¾à ~�w á��*¡�}i~ZhlmÎe�hlu�¢�²�w ×�áw¶efj ¡�}i}%h jlk9hv�tZ}�v�â=ã·�/å â Ë�kx³ihl}ZáÙw¶eA��w gFtZmpknwxk9h�¾à ~�wxw á�L�PÐ�7� ö4â=ã#ö±LON�PRQZ¾�ý },kx³ih£��mÎelk"wx}%h½�oFtZu�wxk ¢�²�h½�oFtZu�wxk ¢¬³i¡�u�v�eJh4óyt�jlknu�¢<w ×#á w¶e­mÎh {´oCu�tZm:Ñ

kx³ih�e�tZq¬h�w¶e¬k mpoih�×�¡�m�k�³ihJe�h j ¡�}�vÓwx}%h½�o7tZu�wxkn¢Ów ×Jwx}$tRvRvZwxk w ¡�}¨¸)h<t�e eloCq¬h�kx³FtZk3áßw¶ej ¡�}i}%h jlkEhvR¾

à ~�wxwxw áÞý¶×�áùw¶e¼m h {´o�u�tZm­¡9×¼v�h {´mÎh h J kx³ihl}>â=ã·� J ¾�Õ�³�w¶eAhlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh`w¶e�elwxq�g�u¶h`w ×¼tZ}�vØ¡�}iu�¢�w ×áw¶e j ¡�}i}%h jlkEhvR¾��u}K~£jhfkfke0u{ntso}�ntjhdM~�DFfhmqn�e ur stdJ�Mm�jkntmyw¸¥ ��jhj¬©q¤�FdMs�no|0m ÎFs{u{njk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�xMDF��stdMw no|0mC��dMe0st}K~�n{���1jhu{|0mys3nt|0mydMs{myw c!m�dM� n�}�jh~�no|0}�n

âzã�ämº Ò U�ºJõ Ä º Ä Ð �:Â��£õ�¿��®L�PÐ�7��&���myØ�eF}Kfkjkn�x£|0dKfhg0uvD0no|0mv~°º,w�e u{n�=m�}K~£myjk�Mmv~��Kmy�qnodMs�}K~0gZno|0mvstmq��dMstm�á4jku�s{my�Me f¬}Ksv¤

�FdMs&no|0mutmv�ydM~ g¢jk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�xMD�fhmqn"½µ�4Ã�X�ãqí�&�&�&@í(X0Ë�È Ò �zm�} ~0dK~0~0my�M}�noj¡�Mm�myjk�Mmy~��Mmv�vntdMs!��dMsâzã�}K~0gVfkmvn�Xy[`�/ÄH¾6¿CY6X7Y�¤#�3|0my~�DB��x)myØ�eF}�nojkdM~५²�¤»¶�©qDGâ=ã�Xy[`� � YÒÉR[ X7Y(ö J [%Xy[Eö±LON�PRQ�Xy[�¤�3|0m,��}�utm�dK�1mvØ�eF}Kfkjkn�xZjku�m�}Ku{jhf¡x£}K~F}Kf¡x��ymvg@¤ Ó

�bm,g0mvg0e0�vmCdM~ m�w�dMs{m,jhw�rzdMs{no}K~�n��ydMs{dMfhfh}Ks�xM¤Í �C�Þ�Þ�^É;�ʯûÒ hlk&ïÙ�Aà��í%¢EÈ»�lh­t¼g�m ¡ gihlm�eloF�X{´m4tlgi³Ó¡9×áû�4ÃX�2í ��ÈA¡�}_k�³ih»e�tZq¬h»~ZhlmlkEh4óe�hlk à ¢®Ô2�`áZ¾�Õ�³ihl}

à w ábâzãqëáEÈ!ä:â=ãªÃ«ïQÈp¾

Page 24: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

HJÍ

à wxw áÞý¶×�áÙw¶efj ¡�}i}%h jlkEhvJkx³ihl}>âzãqëáEÈ!ü¯âzãvëïQÈp¾à wxwxw ábâzãqëáEÈ+å;âzãqëïQÈH( � Â�� �զǢ<�|¾

Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ;�nomyw�ub¥swk©�}K~0gA¥swxwk©�}Ks{m�jkw�w�myg0jh}�nomß��stdKw no|0m���dMe0st}K~�n{���1jhu{|0mysZno| mydMs{mywZ¤¸¥æ�FdMsj¡nomyw ¥�jhj¬©qD�e0utm>"Gmvw�w�}�²�¤³²�D�j¡nomyw ¥�jhjkj¬©q¤´©¼�FdMs�j¡nomvw ¥�jhjkj¬©qD�fkmvn�Ï � ÃX�2í �צr¢iÈoD3}K~0gàfhmqnØÌ�=m�nt|0m£}Kg�±{}K�vmy~0�qx$w�}�nos{j¡p�dK��Ï�¤��3|0my~���x�no| m>��dKe0so}K~�n��8�1jkut|0mvsEno|0mvdMstmvwZDâzãqëáEÈ�öâzãqëïQÈ%��â=ãªÃ«Ï�È�¤!')dKstmydJ�KmysyD*�ªâzãvëÏ�È � Ð (ÚÙ:Û(¾/Ü�ÝKÃRØ Ð Èð�\ÂT���¢ÃæÏ�È��´¤ Ó

�3|0m Ò tlg�u�t�jlwntZ}µqJtZknmpw|ó�Þ7dK��á4jku�g0mqÎF~0myg)}KußÞÁ�Õà*å^U�D�c�| mystm�à¨jku�no|0m�g0j¬}��MdM~F}Kfw�}�nos{j¡p�c�|0dMutmàà a{íÎa�È�mv~�nos{x<jku�no|0mßg0mv�Mstmvm�d��C�Kmys{ntmqp a{¤ËÞ jhuZutjk~0�Me f¬}KsvD#utjk~0�vm;Þ$º.� áG¤')dMs{mydJ�MmvsyDuÞ\jhu�r=dKutj¡noj¡�Mm�utmyw�jkg0mvÎ0~0jkntmK�»½ Ò Þ�½.� � Y¶ÉR[ Ã�X7YBåZXy[�È Ð ¤¢�n,��dMfkfhdJc�u,no|F}�n¬Þ\|F}�uso}�~0l�¿)å<çCjk��}�~0g>dM~ fkxZj¡�(á6jhu�ydM~ ~0my�qnomyg�¤�"Bmvn�no|0m�myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mvu#dK�~Þ��zmEýf�ªâh� ö­â�ã�öôJôJô0ö�âKË�èFãq¤1�n�jku(my}Ku{xCnod,utmvm3no|F}�n2��dKs&stmv�Me0fh}Ks2�Mso}�r0|0uyD�â�ã·�Ýâzã�å£â0Ð�¤&�3|0jku�jhu&nt|0m3utd�����}Kfkfkmyghlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oihL{ytlg�d��&á�¤2��r0r fhjkmyg£nod\Þ3D0no|0mC��dMe0st}K~�n{���1jhu{|0mys3nt|0mydMs{myw¨ut}�x�u�no|0}�nâ�ãvÃæáiÈð�¯Ä ÿÊâÀãÁ/ä ½ Ò Þ�½Ä ½ Ä Ð &

Page 25: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

O,+SN.-ß`VX£Þ �`VÞ 0'å N�WEXZR:` [�Þ;N.-_+-a U 0 `_+ ] 0 R 0 ] 1<]

X 0 [^XZR å N;W 1<X [�N.-

�?34/ 0 GHDC5F@Ç��NLS�DF69@*G�~àH�I�ÕKL DG5�e ututmvw�}KlKmvsyD�£�dM�zmyf ±�j�¤KD1�!�MmvntlKdJ��jʤ�D2}K~0gb��mvjhg0mvf�¥4¥¡HJI�§æD�u{mym�}Kfkutd^¥´²�µ�§ ©�mv~�e��

w�myst}�nomvg�}Kfkf��ydM~0~ my�vntmygbntstj¡��}Kfhmv~�n��Mst}Kr0|0u,c�j¡no|�}�nCw�dMu�n¢Hy½)�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤��3| mvxQdMstg mystmvgbno| m�Mst}Kr0|0u3fkmqp�jk�ydM�Mst}Kr0|0jk��}�fhf¡x���x�nt|0myjks�myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mvuy¤(�3|0m dMstg mystjk~0��jku3jh~�nomvstmvu{nojk~0��jk~Znt|F}�n3�vmys8�n�}�jh~��ydMwC�0jh~0}�nodMs{j¬}�f!r0s{dMrzmys{ntjhmvu���|F}�~0�Mm��Mst}Kg0eF}�fhf¡xà¥�m�¤»�0¤£g0jh}Kw�mvntmysyD1�ydM~0~ my�vntjk��j¡n�xMD2�Mjks{nt| ©q¤� so}Kr0| u(c�|0dKutm�u{my�vdM~0g�fh}Kst�Kmyu{n(mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m�jhu(f¬}�st�Mm�D�ntmy~0g�nod��=mfhdK~0�0D�rF}�nt|���fkjhl�mK��no|0mqx�|0}J�Kmfh}Kst�Mm�g0jh}Kw�mvntmysvD�u{w�}�fhf �Mjks{nt|@D�}K~0g¢w�}K~�x��ve n{��myg0�Mmvuy¤(')dJ��jk~0�Eg0dJc�~�nt|0mfhjku{nyD�}�u(nt|0m�u{my�vdM~0gmyjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�g my�ys{m�}Ku{myuvD�nt|0m�g j¬}Kw�mqnomys1g0my�vstm�}�utmyu&}K~0gE�zdKno|��ydM~0~ my�vntjk��j¡n�xi}K~ gE�Mjks{no|Cjh~ �ystmy}Kutm�¤�3|0dMu{m���dKs�c�|0jh��|£no|0m,u{my�ydK~0g>mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m�jkuu{w�}Kfhfkmyu�n }Ks{m#�Mmvs{xZ�ydKw�r0}K�vnyD nt|0mvx�|F}��Mm�utw�}Kfkfg0jh}Kw�mvntmysyDFfh}Ks{�Mm,�Mjhs�no|@D0}K~0g£|0jh�K|)�vdM~0~0mv�vnoj¡��jkn�xK¤

�FdMsZ�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg\�Kso}Kr0| u>á�D�c!mbg0mqÎF~0mYâ�ã,� âzã�å6â0Ð�nod;�zmVno|0mÌhlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih!{ytlgdK�#á�¤��3| m>myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m)��}Kràc�}Ku�ÎFstu�n�jk~��Mmyu�nojk��}�ntmyg^��x��1jkmyg0fkmys�jh~SHJI�ÕK¶ D�c�|0d���}Kfkfhmvg�j¡nno| m�tZu\{Ch���m4tZw jµj ¡�}i}%h jlknwx~�wxkn¢�dK� á ¥�utmym^¥ ½�L�§Ó©q¤���jhmvg0fhmvs¢}�~0gàd�no|0mvstu�|F}��Mm>u{|0dJc�~�}ßg0jkstmy�qn�ydKststmvf¬}�nojkdM~��=mqn�c�mvmy~£no|0m ��}�rZ}K~0g���}KstjkdMe0u��Mso}Kr |£r0}Kso}Kw�mqnomys{u3g0myu{�ys{jh�0jk~0��no|0m�u{nos{my~0��no|ZdK�no| m3jh~�nomvst�vdM~0~0mv�vnojkdM~0u!jh~�á6¥�utmvmr0}K�Mm3I�©ª¤&�3|0mvjhs�stmvute0f¡nou��Mj¡�Mm�fkjkn{nofkm3jh~���dMstw�}�ntjhdM~ic�|0mv~oâ�ã�jkuw�jh~ jhwCe0wZ¤�~£no|0jku��|F}Kr ntmysyD c!m��ydK~0utjkg0mysno|0jku��}Ku{mE}K~0g£g0mqnomys{w�jh~0mCno|0m�e0~0jkØ�e0m�mªp�ntstmvw�}�f�Mst}Kr0|0uv¤

�3�y�vdMstg0jk~0�¢ntd�5�e ututmvw�}KlKmvs mvn }�fæ¤kDznt|0m��ydM~0~ my�vntmygÁntstj¡�K}�fhmv~�n��Mso}�r0|0u�c�jknt|Áw�jh~0jkw�e wmyjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m���}Kr���dMs�¿!�*çJý D ç·Â�D�}K~ g)ç�è��ydKjh~0�vjhg m�c�j¡no|�nt|0m��Mso}�r0|0u(r0jh�qnoe0s{myg��=mvfhdJc,¤2�3|0mvutmr0jk�vnte0stmvu�u{e0�M�Mmvu{n�}��Kmy~0mvso}KfBrF}�ntnomvst~@¤&��m,g0mvÎ0~0m�nt|0m,�Mso}�r0|£ÊBË�}�uy�

©©

©© ©ª ª ª ª« « « «¬ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª« «¬ª ª« « ©

©©

©©ª ª« « ª ª ª ª« « « «

HJI

Page 26: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²Kµ

c�|0mv~0mv�Kmys�¿ÁÀ:Â4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�D }�~0g

©©

©© ©ª ª ª ª« « « «¬ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «�ª ª« « ©

©© ©ª ª

« «¬ª ª« « ©

©©

©©

©©ª ª

« « ª ª ª ª« « « «c�|0mv~0mv�Kmys�¿ÁÀSýAÃ�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�¤

�3|0m�w�}Kjk~$stmvute0f¡nidK�3nt|0jhu���|F}Kr ntmysE�vdM~ ÎFs{w�uEnt|0m�~F}�noe0st}Kf!�vdM~�±�mv�vnoe stm�u{e0�M�Mmvu{nomvg7��xno| m�mªp�r=mvstjkw�mv~�n�}KfGstmvute0f¡noudK�15�e0u{utmyw�}Kl�mys#mqn}Kf�¤h�

�­�d�y®T����� ¯��n°�± ¡�m à hl~Zhl}Z᣿6ä_çJýy²fkx³ih�{´mtlgi³�Ê@Ë$w¶e!k�³ih!o�}iwn½�oTh�j ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv^knmlwx~�tZu¶hl}ik{´m4tlgi³Ø¸·wxkx³!qfwx}iwxqfoCq hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih?{ytlg%¾

�~���my�vntjhdK~�¶ ¤»L�c�m�ut|0dJcAnt|F}�n�Ê@ËZjku,nt|0m��ydM~ ~0my�qnomygQnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�nC�Mso}Kr |QdK~�¿$�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuc�j¡no|£w�}·p jkw�e w¾g0j¬}�w�mqnomvsy¤

�?3 � TÑN"D{�46sGP8�@H:JD7KL8÷>�5C@"@�:��dMw�m,r0stmvfhjkw�jh~0}Ks{xZg0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~0u�}Kstm,s{myØ�e0jkstmyg�¤æ ��ç¦�������n®��.¯��n° �Ýnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n�Mso}�r0|Zjhu�uo}�jhgZnod��zm»gFtZkx³�¹Eu�wèzRh�jk��jkn|F}�u�no|0m ��dMs{w£�

c�|0mvstm�m�}K��|£my~0g£�0fkd���l�jku�dM~0m,dK�+no|0m ��dMfkfkd·c�jk~0�0�

©©

©©

©ª ª ª ª« « « «¬ª ª« « dMs©©ª ª ª ª« « « « ©

©©©ª ª« « © dMs

©©ª ª ª ª« « « « ©

©©©

©©ª ª« « ©

¥�nt|0mEs{jh�M|�n���|F}K~ gVmy~0gV�0fkd���l)jku#no|0m�w�jksts{dMs�jkw�}K�MmEd���dM~0mEdK�2nt|0mE�0fkd���l�u u{|0dJc�~ ©#}K~0gVmy}K��|w�jhg g0fhm��0fkd���l¢jhu�dM~0m,dK�+no| m,��dKfhfkdJc�jh~0� �

© ª ª« « ©

©ª ª« « © dMs © ª ª

« « ©©

©©ª ª« « © dMs © ª ª

« « ©©

©©

©©ª ª« « ©

Page 27: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²�H

�bm�c�jhfkf@��}�fhf=my~0g��0fkd���l�u�c�j¡no|£¹C�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�}�~0g�w�jhg0g fhm �0fkd���l�u�c�j¡no|�½E�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�elqJtZuxu�Dmy~ gÁ�0fkd���l�u�c�j¡no|ÁÕ��Kmys{ntjh�vmyu }�~0g>w�jkg0g0fkm��0fkd���l�uc�jknt|ÁL��Kmys�nojk�ymyu­q¬hvZwxoCq£Dz}K~0gÁ}�fhfBdKnt|0mys{uu�tZmn{Chq¤

�nGc�jhfkf��=m��ydK~��Kmy~0jkmy~�n&ntd��ydM~0u{jhg mys�nt|0m("G}Kr0fh}K�yjh}K~¬ÞÁ�­Þ�V�st}�no| mysBno|F}�~�nt|0m�}�g�±{}K�ymv~0�vxw�}�nos{j¡p�U�V&¤+�3|0m("G}Kr0fh}K�yjh}K~,dK��á;jku+g mvÎF~0mvgE}Ku�Þ�V��­à�V1å�U�V&DJc�|0mys{mHU�V�jku@no| m!}�g�±{}K�ymv~0�vxw�}�nos{j¡p�}K~0ggà�VVjhu�nt|0m g0jh}K�MdM~0}Kf�w�}�ntstj p�c�|0dMu{m�à a{íÎa�È(mv~�nts{x¢jhu�nt|0m g0my�Kstmym,dK�Gnt|0m��Mmvs{ntmqp!at¤Þ<jhu u{jh~0�Ke0f¬}�syDG}KuéÞ$ºf��áG¤�')dMs{mydJ�MmvsyD�Þ¯jhu#rzdMu{jkntjk�Km�u{myw�jkg0mvÎF~ jkntm�}�~0gß|F}Ku�nt|0mE��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�jk~�ntmys{r0stmqn�}�ntjhdM~Z��dMs3�Mst}Kr0|0uv��½ Ò Þ�½_� � Y¶ÉR[ Ã�X7Y å;Xy[�È Ð ¤2�n3��dMfkfhdJc�u3no|F}�nBÞ;|F}Ku3st}K~0l�¿�å;ç�j¡�}K~0g£dM~0f¡x�j¡�2áAjku��ydM~0~ my�vntmyg@¤�"Gmqn�no|0m,myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mvu�dK�uÞ��=m�ýA�­âh��öÕâ�ã�ö/ôJôJô ötâKË�èF㪤(�njkumy}Ku{x�ntd�utmym nt|F}�n���dMs3stmv�Me0fh}Ks3�Mst}Kr0|0uvD$â�ãH�Ýâzã1åàâFÐ�D0}Ku�g0mvÎF~ myg>my}Kstfkjkmysy¤

5!x�nt|0mC��dMe0so}�~�n��8�1jkut| mys3no|0mvdMstmvwZDzj¡n3��dMfkfhdJc�u3no|0}�nâ�ã·�SÄ ÿ¶âÀãÁ/ä ½ Ò Þ�V.½Ä ½ Ä Ð &��m,c�jkfkfBw�}�lKm�e0utm,dK�+no|0jku���}K�vn�mªp�ntmy~0u{jk�Kmyf¡xM¤

�3|0m�r0std�dK�+dK���3|0mydMs{myw¼¶ ¤kH,jhu�jk~£nt|0stmvm,rF}Ks{ntuy¤2�~>��my�qnojkdM~)¶ ¤´¶Ec!mCu{|0dJc\no|0}�n�jk�1á4jku},�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg�ntstj¡�K}�fhmv~�n!�Mst}Kr0|�c�jknt|�w�jh~0jkw�e w9mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m���}Kr�D�nt|0my~�á\w�e0u�n��zm�rF}�no|���fhjklKm�Dc�j¡no|Z~0d�f¬}�st�Mm#� fhd���l�uy¤(�~>��my�vntjhdK~)¶�¤»½Ec!m no|0mv~£u{|0dJc:nt|F}�n�á4�y}K~�dM~0f¡x�|F}��Km utw�}KfkfB�0fhd���l�ujk~�nt|0m�w�jhg0g fhm�¤&�3|0jku�Î0~0jhu{|0myu(dMe0s2r std�dK� c�|0my~�¿ÁÀSýAÃæÄ�Å�Æ)è�ÈoD�}Ku�Ê@Ë jku&no|0m�e0~0jkØ�e0m��Mso}�r0|c�j¡no|ßno|0jku,r0stdMrzmys�n�xM¤i���¿àÀ9Â4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�D@nt|0my~ßc!m¢}Ks{mifhmq� n,c�jknt|ßn�c!d£��|0dMjk�ymyuvD1mvjknt|0mys�Ê@Ë DdMsno|0mEr0}�no|���fhjklKm��Mso}Kr |êË�c�|0jh��|ß|F}�u�n�c�d�w�mvg0jhe wømv~0gß�0fhd���l�u }K~0gVdK~0fkx)utw�}Kfkf1w�jkg0g0fkm�0fkd���l�uv¤!�~>��my�qnojkdM~)¶ ¤³¹�c!mCu{|0dJc:nt|F}�n�Ê@Ëi|F}Ku�utw�}Kfkfkmys�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m���}KrZno|F}K~?ê�Ë ¤

��fkf3no|0s{mym£rF}Ks{ntu¢}�stmZr0stdJ�Kmyg�e0u{jh~ �butjkw�jhfh}Ks�w�mvno| d�g0uv¤;��m)fkmvn¢áÌ�=m£}ß�ydM~0~ my�vntmygnos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n �Kso}Kr0|VdK~V¿b�Mmvs{nojk�ymvu c�jknt|Vw�jk~0jkw�e0wø��}Krmâ�ãªD@}K~0gVfkmvn�½7�zmi}K~Vmvjh�Mmv~��Mmy�qnodMs ��dMsâ�ãvëáEÈ�¤��bm�}Kutu{e0w�mEno|F}�n#á jku#~0dKn�jh~)no|0mEs{myØ�e0jkstmvgß��dKstwZD@}K~ g>no|0mv~Vg0myw�dM~ u{nost}�nom�}�~0mvc�Mst}Kr0|ZïÌdK�Gno|0m g myutjkstmvg£��dKstwZD0j�¤»m�¤hD0r0}�no|���fhjklKm c�j¡no|0dKe n�f¬}�st�Mm#� fhd���l�uyD }K~0g�nt|0my~Zut| d·cSno|F}�nno| m Ø�e0}Kg0so}�nojk����dMstw9�Mj¡�Mmv~£��xZïømv��}KfkeF}�nomvg£}�n,½ßjku3~0dKn3fh}Kst�Kmys�nt|F}K~gâ�ãvëáEÈ�D�ut|0dJc�jk~0�ino|F}�nâ�ãvëïßÈ(jhu�}�nw�dMu{nTâ�ãvëáEÈ�D }�~0g)jk~Z��}K�vn�no|0}�njk�&áìë�Sï¸nt|F}�njknjku�u{nos{jh�qnof¡x£fhmvutu�no|F}K~]â�ãvëáEÈ�D�ydK~�ntso}Kg jh�qnojk~0��nt|0m,w�jh~0jkw�}Kfkjkn�xZdK�uâ�ãvëáEÈ�¤

�~¢no| m�ÎFs{u{n!rF}Ks{nyD�c!m#g0d�no|0jku�mv~�nojkstmyf¡x���x�fkd��y}Kf w�mvno| d�g0uv¤&�bm�}Kutu{e0w�m�no|0}�n�áÝjku�~0d�nrF}�nt|���fkjklKmKD+}K~ gQg mvÎF~0m�}�utmvØ�e0my~0�vm�d����Mst}Kr0|0u,á �6á��yí�áiã�í�&�&�&Bí�á Ë�dK� n�}Kjk~0mvgQ��s{dMw°á ��x

Page 28: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²M²

w�dJ��jk~0��mvg0�Mmyu�nod�r0e�n,á9jk~�nod�r0}�no|���fhjklKmC��dMstwZ¤��3| mi�Mso}Kr |Vá`Y1jhu�rF}�no|���fkjhl�m���dMs�no|0m�Î0stu{n�a�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤(��n�m�}���|£u�nomvr@D0c�m u{|0dJcSnt|F}�n3j¡�1á`YBjku3rF}�nt|���fkjklKm dM~0f¡x¢��dKs!no| m#ÎFstu�n?a1�Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�}�~0g~0dKn!no|0m�à aC��ç�È�u{nyD�nt|0my~¢c!m#�y}K~�stmqc�jhs{m á`Y=nodE�Kmvn3á»Y¡ò=ã2c�| jh��|Zjku!nos{jk��}Kfkmy~�n�}�~0g��ydK~0~0my�qnomvg@D}K~0g�c�|0dMutm�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m#��}Kr¢jhu!~0dEfh}Kst�Mmvs(nt|F}K~�á»Y�Ö×uy¤&��m��zdMe0~ g¢no|0m�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m ��}Kr¢}K�zd·�Kme0u{jh~0��no|0m��}�x�fkmyjk�M|)Ø�e dKnojkmy~�n�Dze0u{jh~0��no|0m,�Mmv�vntdMsB½&¤(��mC��| d�dMu{m�nt|0m�stmvc�jkstjk~0����}Ks{mv��e0fkfkxZu{dno|0}�nC¥æ}Ku{ute0w�jk~0��nt|F}�n Ä ½ Ä �/ç·©ª�â�ãvëáEÈð�Õ½ Ò Þ�VÊí(½Q䫽 Ò Þ�V b ½Qä-ôJôJô 䫽 Ò Þ�V _ ½bä�â�ãvÃæá,Ë�È &�<|0mv~£c!m�}�stm ÎF~0jkut|0mvg@DFc�m,|F}��Km�}irF}�nt|���fkjklKm��Mso}Kr |Zc�j¡no|£~0d�f¬}�st�Mm �0fkd���l�uv¤

�bm,no| my~£ut|0dJc\nt|F}�n�no|0mvutmCstmvc�jkstjk~0�Mu�}Ks{m�~ dKnstmv�Kmys{utjk�0fhm�D�j�¤»m�¤hD0nt|F}�nj¡�2á Ë�jhu�}irF}�no|��fkjhl�mE�Mso}�r0|>c�j¡no|V~0d�fh}Ks{�Mm��0fkd���l�uvD�no| my~ß}K~�x)stmvc�jkstjk~0��d��2no|0m�n�x�rzm�c!mEg0jkg7¥�s{mv�Mmvstu{jh~0�ZdMe su{ntmyr0uo©3c!dMe0fkg£jh~0�vstmy}Kutm,no|0m,mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m���}Kr�D0|0my~ �ymâ�ãvëáEÈ(ü«â�ãqÃæá,Ë�È�í}i�ydM~�ntso}Kg0jk�vntjhdK~@¤

�bmint|0my~Qut|0dJcAnt|F}�n�á¨�y}K~�dK~0fkxÁ|F}��Mm�utw�}Kfkf2�0fhd���l�uCjk~Vno|0m�w�jkg0g0fkmK¤��3|0m�w�mqno|0d�g|0mvstm�jhu,utmvw�j¡��fhd���}Kf�¤��bm�é8w�dJ�Mmªê�no|0m��0jk�M�Mmvs,�0fhd���l�u�ntdJc�}Ks{g0u,no|0m�dMe ntutjkg0m�my~0g0uv¤�� j¡�Mmy~b}�Mst}Kr0|�áøc�j¡no|à}ßw�mvg0jhe w_�0fhd���l$}Kw�dM~ �ßnt|0m�w�jhg g0fhm£�0fkd���l�uvD��yfkdMu{mZntdVno|0m¢é8�vmy~�nomvs�êoD(c!mr0s{d�g0e �ym)}��Mst}Kr0|�ï c�|0jk��|�|F}Ku�~0dbw�mvg0jhe w � fhd���l�u¢utd��yfkdMutm£nodßno|0m)�ymv~�ntmysv¤¯�,j¡�Mmv~^}rzdMutj¡noj¡�MmCmyjk�Mmy~��Mmv�vntdMs¨½�dK��â�ãvÃæáiÈoD c!m�w�}�lKmE}�fkd��y}KfG��|F}K~0�Mm,nodî½$}�~0g)nt|0my~>}��MfkdM�F}�f+u{|0j¡� nnod�r0s{d�g e0�ym�}i�Mmy�qnodMsÇÆbute0��|£no|F}�nâ�ãqëáEȦ��½ Ò Þ�V�½�üsÆ Ò Þ ã Æ1õ Ä Æ Ä Ð &�3|0miu{|0jk� n,jku�ntd�my~0u{e0stm ÆÚïÚºiutd�nt|F}�n#nt|0mEstjk�M|�n{��|F}K~0gVu{jhg m�d��2no|0m�}K�zdJ�MmimvØ�e0}�nojkdM~Vjku,}K~e0r0rzmys��zdMe0~0g7��dMsîâ�ãvÃæïQÈ�¤$��m£w�}�x�nt|0my~�stmvr=my}�n�no|0jku�r std��ymyu{u�d���w�dJ��jh~0�ßno| m)w�myg jhe0w�0fkd���l�uE��s{dMwÌno|0m�w�jkg0g0fkm�nodJc�}Kstg u�no|0m¢dMe nou{jhg mK¤V��~�x�f¬}�st�Mm��0fhd���lbw�}�x��=m�jhw�w�myg0jh}�ntmyf¡x�ydKfhfh}Kr0u{myg�jk~�nod)n�c!dÁu{w�}�fhfkmysCdM~0myuv¤���� ntmys,no|0jku�u�nomyr�D�no| mystm¢}Kstm�dM~0f¡xßutw�}Kfkf(�0fhd���l�u�jk~bno| mw�jhg g0fhm�¤Z��3¿<À ýAÃ�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�D+no|0mv~�c!m¢wCe0u{n�my~0g�e r�c�j¡no|$Ê@Ë�D1}K~ gbc�m¢}Kstm�g0dM~ mKD&}�u�c!m��}�~0~0dKn|F}��Mm�w�myg0jke0w¨� fhd���l�u�}�n��zdKnt|)mv~0g0u���x�no|0m ��}Kfke0m,dK�1¿�¤

Page 29: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²K¶

�bmZ~0dJc �ydMw�m�nodßrF}Ks�nino|0s{mymZdK�no|0m�r std�dK�8D2c�|0jh��|�c�mZdM~ fkx7}�ststj¡�Mm£}�ni��dKsi¿-ÀÌÂÃæÄ�Å�Æ)è�ÈC¥æ}K~ gV¿àä�ç�è�©ª¤,�FdMs�nt|0myu{mE�K}�fhe0mvu dK��¿1D=c�m�}Ks{mEfkmv� n#c�j¡no|Vn�c!d£rzdMu{utjk�0fhmi�Kso}Kr0| u

}K~0gß~0mvmygQdM~0f¡x>ntd£g mvnomvstw�jk~0mic�|0jh��|�|F}Ku u{w�}�fhfkmys,myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m���}Kr�¤��3|0jku,jh~��MdKfk�KmyuE}¢�Kmys�xg0mvfhjk��}�ntm�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0mZmyu�nojkw�}�nomK¤��FstdMwº}K~$mvjh�Mmv~��Mmy�qnodMsi��dMs»êË�D&no|0m�dKnt|0mys���}K~0g jhgF}�nomKD2c!m�ydK~0u{ntste0�qn�}Á�Mmv�vntdMs�u{e0��|ànt|F}�n�no| m)�}�x�fhmvjh�M|�Ø�e0dKntjhmv~�n���dMsîÞ�ðQjhu�utw�}Kfkfkmys�no|F}K~�â�ãvÃæïiË�È�¤��e0s{r0stjkutjk~0�Mf¡xMDFnt|0jhu�jku3no|0m,w�dMu{n�ntmyg0jkdMe0urF}Ks�n�dK��nt|0m,my~�nojkstm�r0s{d�dK�8¤

�?3�� -g�¦DFKÇñ'�s6�ò·8MByDC57NLS�DFNP5C8�~$no|0jku�utmy�qnojkdM~@D�c�m�c�jkfhf�ut|0dJc nt|F}�nij¡��áø|F}Ku�w�jk~0jhwCe0w mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0mZ��}�r@D2no|0mv~àá

w�e u{n��=m rF}�no|���fhjklKm�¤(��m,stmyu�n�}�ntm no|0m,�yfh}Kjkw¨|0mvstmK¤Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�ÊÉûÒ hlk2á��lh tµj ¡�}i}%h jlk9hv�knmpwx~�tZu¶hl}ik¦{´m4tlgi³�¡�})¿Ì~Zhlmpknw j h eEÃ�¿$ä4çJý�ȲHeloTj ³µk�³FtZktZq¬¡�}y{!tZuxu¦j ¡�}i}%h jlk9hv�knmlwx~�tZu¶hl}ik¦{´mtlgi³Re�¡�}Z¿Ì~Zhlmpk w j h e ²&áÙ³Ft�eAqfwx}iwxqfo�q�hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oih�{ytlg%¾Õ�³ihl}�áw¶e�gFtZkx³�¹Eu�wèzRh�¾

�bmßw�}Kl�m�dM~ mQw�dMs{mßmyfkmyw�my~�n�}�s{x<g0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~\}K~ g<nt|0my~SdMe ntfhjk~0mVno|0mßr0s{d�d��Cd���no| mr0s{dMr=dKutj¡nojkdM~@¤���u3c!mCw�my~�ntjhdM~ myg>jk~Zno|0m,r0s{mv��jhdKe0u�u{my�qnojkdM~@DFc�m,c�jkfhfBr0s{dJ�Mm,no|0jku���x�s{mvc�jkstjk~0�no| m��Kso}Kr0|�¤2�3|0m���dKfhfkdJc�jh~0��g0mqÎF~0j¡nojkdM~>g myut�vstjk�=mvu�| d·c:c�m c�jkfhfG}K��| jhmq�MmCnt|F}�ny¤æ ��ç¦�������n®��.¯��ÊÉ ��~Þhlu¶hlq¬hl}ik tZmp¢ el¸·wxk9j ³�jk~£}E�Mso}Kr |�jhu3}Eu�c�jknt��|0jk~0��d���r0}Kso}Kfkfkmyf@mvg0�Mmyuv��fhmqnWs�ôó�}�~0gþô�� J jk~;á�D�Wªë�zô·í\óõë� J ¥�|0mvstm��°}K~0gMë�Üg0my~ dKnom)}Kg�±{}K�vmy~0�qx�}K~0g7~0dM~��}Kg�±{}��ymy~ �vxÁjk~ßáC©qD�nt|0my~Vno| mEmyfkmyw�my~�no}Ks{xVu�c�jknt��|@�,���<������¥ W0í%óJípôJí J ©�stmvw�d·�Kmyu,no|0m�myg0�Mmvuù�W0í%ó�úi}K~ gßù�ôJí J ú�}K~0gZstmvr0f¬}��ymyu�no| myw¨c�j¡no|Zno|0m,myg �Mmyu ù�W0ípô�úE}K~ gQù9óJí J ú�¤

© � © g© } © � ö

© � © g© } © �

�bm�c�jkfhf(e0utm�dM~0f¡xßmyfkmyw�mv~�no}Ks{x�u{c�j¡no��| myu�ntd>stmqc�jhs{m¢á¨ntd)r0e�n�j¡n�jk~br0}�no|���fhjklKm���dMs{w£D��|0d�dMutjk~0��no|0mß��dMe0s��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuÁ�y}Kstmq��e0fhf¡x<utd�no|F}�n>á_s{myw�}Kjk~0u)�vdM~0~0mv�vntmygÝ}K~ g:g0e0s{jh~ �àno| mu{c�j¡no��| myu�nt|0mCmvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m���}Kr)~0mv�Kmys�jh~0�vstmy}Kutmvuy¤3�bm,c�jkfhfBno| my~>u{|0dJcÝno|F}�n#}K~�xZmvfhmvw�mv~�n�}Ks�x

Page 30: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²�½

u{c�j¡no��|�dM~�}�rF}�nt|���fkjklKm(�Mso}Kr |Cmvjknt|0mys+fhmy}��Mmyu�jkn+rF}�no|���fhjklKm(dMsGu{ntstjk�vnof¡x,jk~0�ys{m�}Ku{myu�nt|0m(myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m��}Kr�¤&�bm,w�}�x�no|0mv~>�vdM~0�yfke0g0mvg)nt|F}�n�j¡�&áA|F}�uw�jk~0jkw�e0w¾��}�r@D0j¡n�wCe0u{n�zm,rF}�no|���fkjhl�mK¤

"Bmvn°½��=m¢}K~�myjk�Mmv~��Kmy�qnodMsE��dMs¬â�ãqD1�vdM~0u{jhg0mvstmvgà}�uE})c!myjk�M|�nojk~0�VdM~bnt|0m��Kmys�nojk�ymyuv�!��dMs÷ �ÿ�øc!m�c�stj¡nomøXÊù���dMsCnt|0m�c�mvjh�K|�n�dK���Kmys{ntmqp ÷ ¤Q�bm�}�utute w�m�nt|0m��Mmvs{nomªp�utmqn�jhu3ú ¿.ûP�ù�çMíªÂ�í�&�&�&=ío¿�ú�}K~ g¢no|F}�n�no| m��Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�}Kstm�~�e0w��zmys{mygZutd�nt|F}�n£X�ã�ä�X Ð�äÝôJôJô0ä«X0Ë0¤1��m#�y}Kfhfno| jhu}­g�mΡ gihlm¼u�tR�lhlu�wx}y{ dK�+no| m,�Kmys�nojk�ymyuE¥�c�j¡no|£stmvutrzmy�vnnod ½+©ª¤

�bm���}�~�~0dJc6�vf¬}�stj¡� xVno|0m�stmqc�jhs{jh~0� ¤��<j¡no|bs{myu{r=mv�vn�nod)}£r0s{dMrzmys�f¬}K�zmyfkjk~0�0DGc�m�ut|0dJcno|0}�n&c!m�y}K~�stmqc�jhs{m�nod,�Mmvn1�Mmys�nomªp£H�}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n2nod#�Kmys{ntjh�vmyu�²�D�¶ D�}�~0g�½0¤���m3��}K~int|0my~�stmqc�jhs{mnod��Mmqn�²�}�g�±{}K�ymv~�nntd�¶�}K~ g£½ ¤2�3|0jhu~0dJc\fkd�dMl�ufkjklKmK�

©©

©©H

²

½ª ª ª ª« « « «oü üý ý

�bmCut|0dJc-no|0}�n�c!mE�y}K~Á�ydK~�ntjh~�e0m�jh~>nt|0jku�c�}JxKD@�Mmqntnojk~0�¢}¢rF}�nt|���fkjhl�m��Mst}Kr0|@D c�j¡no|Áno| mfh}K�=mvfhu�jh~0�vstmy}Kutjk~0�i��stdMw�fkmv� n�ntdEstjk�M|�n�¤2�3| m�nos{jh��l�jhu�~0dKn�ntdEg0jkut�ydK~0~0my�qn3no|0m��Mso}Kr |¢c�|0jkfhm#c!m}Ks{m¢stmqc�jhs{jh~ �0D2}K~0g�~0dKnCnod>jk~0�vstm�}�utm¢nt|0m¢mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m¢��}Kr@¤���m¢my~ ute0s{m¢no|F}�n�no| myutm¢g0d>~0d�n|F}Kr r=mv~���x¢��|0d�dMutjk~0�idMe0s!u{c�j¡no��|£��}Ks{mv��e0fkf¡xM¤&��m#|F}��Mm#nt|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�ifkmyw�w�}ic�| jh��|£}Kjkg0u�jk~~0dKn�jk~0�vstm�}�utjk~0��nt|0m,myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0mC�M}Kr@¤Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�ʯûÒ hlk2áº�lhft<knmlwx~�tZu¶hl}ikð{´m4tlgi³_tZ}�v¬½M�lh tZ}�hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlk9¡�m�×�¡�mTâ�ã�¾`ýê×¼kx³ihlm h tZmÎh~Zhlmpk w j h e�W0í%óJípôJí J wx}£áeloij ³!k�³FtZk¦WH�ªóJípôT� J í W�ë�ÿôJí%ó ë� J í(X�þ�ä�X�ÿ�²�tZ}�v°X��3ätX � ²)kx³ihl}���<�����CÃXW0í%óJípôJí J È<v�¡�h e¬}%¡�k�wx}%jlmÎht�e�h¬k�³ih!hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh­{ytlg%¾Þýê×��l¡�k�³Ñ¡9×�k�³ih�wx}%h½�o7tZu�wxknw h etZmÎh»elk mpw jlkx²Hk�³ihl}µk�³ihP{ytlgÓelknmpw jlk u�¢�v�h jlmÎht�e�h e�¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ+�bm�w�}�xE}Kutu{e0w�m�no|F}�n Ä ½ Ä �*çMDKnt|0my~îâ�ã·�Õ½ Ò Þ�½2¤1"Gmqn~Þ����zm�no|0m�"+}�r0f¬}��yjh}K~iw�}�nos{j¡pdK�&nt|0m��Kso}Kr0|>}�� nomvsnt|0m�s{mvc�jkstjk~0�0¤�~>fkjh�K|�n�dK�&nt|0mE�}�x�fkmyjk�M|ÁØ�e0d�nojkmy~�n�D=jkn�ute{n��vmyu#nod�ut|0dJcno|0}�n ½ Ò Þ � ½Qö«½ Ò Þ�½·&

Page 31: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²M¹

�3|0jku��dKfhfkdJc�ujkw�w�myg0jh}�nomvfkx���s{dMw½ Ò Þ�½£åY½ Ò Þ � ½Ó�Õ½ Ò Ã�Þ � åõÞ�ÈR½_�:Â'X�þ`X��;�;Â9X � X�ÿ�å�Â'X�þ=X � å7Â'X���X�ÿ�\ Ã�X�þ�åYX�ÿ�ȪÃ�X���å¡X � È(ä¯ýF& Ó

�bm,|F}��Km,nt|0m ��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��fkmyw�w�}inodi|0mvfhrZc�jknt|)l�mymvr0jh~ ��no| m��Kso}Kr0|Z�vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg>g0e stjk~0�stmqc�jhs{jh~ �0�Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�|È�Ò hlk=á �lh�tJj ¡�}i}%h jlkEhvAknmlwx~�tZu¶hl}ik�{´m4tlgi³<¡�}]ú ¿.ûð¸·wxk�³Jqfwx}iwxqfo�qõ{ytlg\â�ã ²Tg�mΡ g�¹hlmpu�¢­u�tR�lhlu¶hv­¸·wxkx³�m h eEgih jlk'k9¡ tZ}Óhlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlkE¡�m~½.¡9×"â�ã�¾"��e elo�q¬hPk�³FtZk�áY¦£ú �6û¦w¶e�vZw¶e�j ¡�}i}%h jlkEhvtZ}�v<k�³FtZk�ht�j ³,¡9× wxkxe¬j ¡�q�gi¡�}%hl}ikxe¼³Ft�e�tZ}¨hv�{Ch­¸ð³�w j ³µw¶ef}%¡�kLt_jlo�k�hv�{Ch�¾,Õ�³ihl},¸)h qJtZ¢mÎhl¸·wxmÎh`k�³ihP{´m4tlgi³ØoRelwx}y{�hlu¶hlq¬hl}ik tZml¢ el¸·wxkEj ³ih e`kE¡<j ¡�}i}%h jlk�á�¦¬ú �9û�²H}%¡�k"j ³FtZ}y{´wx}y{°â�ã�¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ(�nute{n��vmyu�nod�r0stdJ�Mm nt|0m,fhmvw�w�}�c�|0my~)át¦¬ú �6ûB|F}Ku3n�c!d��vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg>�vdMw�r=dM~ my~�nou�ï}K~0g�Ï�¤��bm�c�jkfhf r0stdJ�Mm�nt|0m3fkmyw�w�},��xi�vdM~�nost}Kg0jk�vnojkdM~@¤1��utu{e0w�m3no|F}�n1c�m���}�~0~0dKn2s{mvc�jkstm3no| m�Mst}Kr0|Enod�}K�v�ydMw�r0fkjkut|�dMe0s&�MdM}Kfæ¤1"Bmvn3ù6�@ãªí:�zÐqú��zm�}#~0dM~����ye n�mvg0�Mm3jk~�ï¾}�~0g�ù ÷ ãªí ÷ Ðyú�}#~0dM~���ye�n,myg0�Mmijk~QÏ�¤�5!my��}�e0utmino| myutm�mvg0�Mmyu�}Ks{mE~0dKn,�ve n mvg0�MmyuvDG�=dKnt|Q���<�����E¥Ð�@ãyí(�=Ðqí ÷ ãqí ÷ Ðo©}K~0g����<������¥��@ãví:�zÐyí ÷ Ðyí ÷ ã{©�c!dMe0fkgbfkm�}��Mm�á¨}K~0gQ᪦ ú �6û2�ydK~0~0my�qnomvg@D1u{d£j¡n,w�e u{nC�=mino| m��}�utm�no|F}�n�nt|0myu{m�u�c�jknt��|0myu�jk~0�vstm�}�utm�â�ã�¤25�}Ku{myg¢dK~�no| mr stmv��jkdMe0u!fhmvw�w�} D�no| jhu�dM~0f¡x�|F}Kr r=mv~0uj¡�(nt|0m�c!myjk�M|�nou dK�(dM~ mErF}Kjks#}Ks{mE�zdKno|Áu�nos{jh�qnof¡xÁ�Ms{m�}�ntmys�nt|F}K~Áno| dMutmEd��(nt|0mEdKnt|0mys�rF}Kjksy¤#��mw�}�x<}Kutu{e0w�mQnt|F}�ngX�� b í:X�� � ü XÊù b í:XÊù � ¤�"Bmvn�°�=mQ}K~<myfkmyw�mv~�n)jk~ ú �6û,}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�nZnod�Ï}K~0g�fkmvn£Ã ÷ ãqí ÷ Ðyí ÷ D í�&�&�&Bí ÷ ÒæÈ��zmZ}Vut|0dKs{nomvu{n�rF}�nt|�jk~àá�D ÷ Ò`��Ì¥�c!m)w�}�x$rzdMutu{jh�0f¡x7~0mvmygnod�u{c�j¡no��|\nt|0mQstdMfkmyu£dK� ÷ ãZ}�~0g ÷ Ð�©q¤¨� dKsQçSö a^( ÚªD����<�����E¥��@ãqí:�zÐyí ÷ Y«í ÷ Y ò=ã{©£}�~0g���<������¥��@ãqí:�zÐyí ÷ Y¡ò=ãªí ÷ Y�© c�dKe0fhg$�vdM~0~0mv�vn�ï }K~0g$Ï�D2fkm�}���jh~ �Áno|0m��Mso}Kr |��ydM~ ~0my�qnomyg�D(u{d��x�jh~0g e0�vntjhdM~�D�X�� b í:X�� � üÚXÊù b í(XÊù � í�&�&�&@í:XÊù�´'�ÕX���D��0e n(no|0jku!jku�},�ydK~�ntso}Kg jh�qnojkdM~@D0}�u"X��ßä«XÊù��dMs�}Kfkf ÷ �Áïb¤ Ó�2� � ��� �\-��r��&'�� >Ú#%�©>2-# !34u!$#7@���)�����-3>$&ã!'4�@

��u{ute0w�m�nt|F}�n!áÝjhu!}��vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg¢ntstj¡�K}�fhmv~�n��Mso}�r0|�dK~�¿Z�Mmvs{nojk�ymvuyD0¿ßäÝçJý�¤1�bm���e0s�no|0mvs}Ku{ute0w�m>nt|F}�n�}�w�dK~0��}Kfkf�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg�ntstj¡�K}�fhmv~�n¢�Mso}�r0|0u¢dK~�¿S�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuvD�áÌ|F}Ku�w�jh~0jkw�e w

Page 32: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²KL

myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mi��}�r@D�}�~0g>no|0}�n á�jhu�r0stdMrzmys{fkx)fh}K�=mvfhmvg@¤#.�e0stjk~0��no| mEstmqc�jhs{jh~0� D=c!m�c�jhfkf1g my~0dKntmá4��x£á���nod�jh~ g0jh�y}�nom,no|0}�n3no|0m ÎFs{u{néU��Mmys�nojk�ymvu�}Ks{m,jh~£rF}�nt|���fkjhl�m ��dMstwZ¤

�������������! �"� ®��'�d��ÂZ�b� �d�õ°^��®2É�� ��#ç�ë� Â�no| my~ßno|0mvstm�jhu�}Zut|0dMs�nomvu{nCrF}�no|àÃ{çKíÎa�ãªí�&�&�&@íÎanø�íªÂ�È���stdMwH�ntdÁ²�¤�"BmvnîUV�zm¢}Z~0myjk�M|��zdMs�dK��H¢u{e0��|bno|0}�n U�ë� a8ã�}K~0g¡U�ë� a øyD+nt|0my~�c�m�w�}�xQ}Kr r0fkx���<������¥�çMíOUFíªÂ�íÎanøª©qD�~0d�nijh~ �ystmy}Kutjk~0�ßno|0m�mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m£�M}Kr7}K~0g$fkm�}���jh~ �àHZ}Kg�±{}K�ymv~�nintdQ²}K~0g)á4�vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg@¤� ®��'�d��ÂZ�b� �d�Ô°Ñ��®ÿ¯�� ���çsë� �>nt|0my~�fkmvnfU ë�¦ÂÁ�=mZ}Á~0mvjh�K|��zdMsidK��HM¤b5!x$}Vu{jhw�r0fkm�ydKe0~�nojk~0��}Ks{�Me0w�my~�nyDzmy}K��|Á�vdM~0~0mv�vnomvgÁ�ydKw�rzdM~0mv~�n�dK�&át¦�ù�ç�úE�ydK~�no}Kjk~0u#}��vx��yfkmK¤!�bm�w�}Jxno| mystmq��dMstm�e0utm#"Gmvw�w�}�¶ ¤»½�nod�}Kutu{e0w�m�no|F}�n�ᡦ!ù�ç�ú jhu!�ydM~ ~0my�qnomyg�¤!"Bmqn Ã7UFíÎa�ãªí�&�&�&BíÎanø�í ��È1�zm}¢u{|0dMs{ntmyu�n#rF}�nt|>��stdKw U¢nod�¶�~0dKn�rF}Kutu{jh~ ��no|0s{dMe0�M|�HM¤�"Bmqn$#C�=m�}�~0mvjh�K|��zdMs�dK�(¶�u{d¢no|F}�n#\ë�2a ø�}K~0g%#îë� anøJD no| my~>���<�����E¥8çMíOU í ��í&#�©q¤� ®��'�d��ÂZ�b� �d�û°¨��® Èd� ¥��3|0jkuEjkuEjhg my~�nojk��}Kf(nod£no|0m�r stmv��jkdMe0uEs{mvc�jkstjk~0�0¤´©S��,ç¡ë�¨è)no| my~fkmvn UÁ�zm�no|0mino| jhs{gb~0mvjh�M|��zdMs,dK�#HK¤���m�w�}�xQ}Ku{ute0w�m>¥���xQ"Bmyw�w�}>¶ ¤×½�©ªDGnt|F}�n�᪦Cù�ç�ú¢jku�ydK~0~0my�qnomvg@¤("Gmqn Ã�U íÎa�ãqí�&�&�&@íÎanø�íoè�È2�zm#}Cu{|0dMs�nomyu�n3rF}�nt|¢��stdKw UEnodE½E~ dKn�r0}Kutu{jh~0�Ent|0stdKe0�M|ÁHM¤"Bmvn'# �zm�}i~0myjk�M|��=dKsd��1½�utd�no|0}�n'#îë��anø}K~0g%#\ë� a øyD0no|0mv~Á���<������¥�çMí=U íoè0í&#�©ª¤� ®��'�d��ÂZ�b� �d�<É���®Ø¯�� ��m!w�}�xC}Kutu{e0w�m�no|0}�n&áf¦ ù�çKú3jku1�vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg@¤�"Bmvn�Ã�Â�íÎa�ãªí�&�&�&BíÎanø�í ��È�zm�}�u{|0dMs{ntmyu�n�rF}�no|�jh~iág¦�ù�çKú�¤1"Bmvn"U �=m�nt|0m!nt|0jkstgi~0mvjh�M|��zdMs1d��=²�}K~0g(#(nt|0m�no| jhs{gi~0myjk�M|��=dKsdK��¶ ¤i������ Â�DuU��Ôa�Ð�D+}K~0g,a�ãé�)#KDBnt|0my~¡UÁ�y}K~0~0d�n,�=m�}Kg�±{}��ymy~�n,nod*#��zmy�y}Ke0u{m¢á ¦�ù�çKújkuC�vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg@D2utdÁ���<�����E¥æÂ�íOU íÎ� í&#�©,�vdM~0~0mv�vntuiÂZntdµ��D&}Ku�stmvØ�e jhs{myg@¤)��no|0mvs{c�jkutm�D&myj¡no|0mvsU�ë� a ø�}K~0g)���<������¥«Â�íOUFí � íÎanøq©qD0dKs"a�ãrë�+# }K~0g>���<�����E¥æÂ�íÎa8ãyíÎ� í&#�©q¤

Page 33: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²MÕ

� ®��'�d��ÂZ�b� �d�$ɨ��®ÑÈd� ���no|0mvstmijku,}¢�Mmvs{nomªpYU>}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n nod£Â�D;� DB}K~ gVè0D@fkmvn,#��=mEnt|0jhs{g~0mvjh�M|��zdMsidK�è0D&nt|0my~ZU ë�-#�}K~0gà���<������¥«Â�í=U íoè0í&#�©ª¤���no| mys{c�jkutm�D(c!mZw�}Jx�}Kutu{e0w�mZ��x"Bmyw�w�}Q²Ánt|F}�n�á�¦Hú è/û�jhu��ydK~0~0my�qnomvg@¤7"BmvnfU��=m�nt|0m�no| jhs{g�~ myjk�M|��=dMsid�� ²�D�#�no|0m�nt|0jhs{g~0mvjh�M|��zdMs�dK��¶ D#}�~0g<fhmqng�\}K~0g ÷ �=mÁnt|0mÁn�c�d�dKnt|0mys�~0mvjh�K|��zdMs{u£d���½0¤4�� �­� è�no| my~���<������¥«Â�íOUFíoè0í ��©ª¤#��nt|0mys�c�jhu{mKDBj¡�£U;ë�M�ß}K~0g�UYë�ª�+D no| my~ß}Kr0r fkx>���<������¥«Â�íOUFíoè0í:�=©q¤��(dM~0midK�2nt|0myu{m�stmyfh}�ntjhdM~ u g0d�mvu#~0dKn#|0dMfkg@D@nos�x)nt|0miuo}Kw�mE��dMs ÷ jk~0u�nom�}�g�dK�~�G¤,��(no|0mEut}Kw�mstmvf¬}�nojkdM~0uE|0dKfhgb��dKs ÷ D1nos�xßnodÁ�Mmqnf�©�¨èÁ��xb�vdM~0utjkg0mvstjk~0�߶>jk~0u{ntm�}Kg$dK��²)}K~0g�fkd�dKl�jk~0�V}�n�£}K~0g ÷ ��no|0mv~£���<�����E¥æÂ�íOU íoè í ��©�c�jkfkf=c!dMstl ¤���G~0dM~0m�dK�@no| myutm,}�stm#}�fhfkdJc�mvg@D no| my~Zás¦Bú è/û|F}Ku!},�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg��vdMw�r=dM~ my~�n��vdM~0u{jhu�nojk~0�EdK��±�e0u{nùhU í&#�í:�Gí ÷ ú�DMno| jhu(utmqn�|F}���jk~0�i²,dMs�½CrzdMjk~�ntug0mvr=mv~0g0jk~0�idM~¢nt|0m#myØ�eF}�fhj¡nojkmyuvDF}K~0g��zmyjk~0�ig0jkut�vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg���stdMw6nt|0m�s{myu{n�dK�Bno|0m��Mso}�r0|@¤2�3|0jku�ydK~�ntso}Kg jh�qnou�no|0m#��}K�qn�no|F}�ná�¦¬ú è/ûBjku��ydM~0~ my�vntmyg�¥�jk~£��}K�qn�D0jk~Zno|0jku���}Ku{mCá*|F}Ku}i�ydM~0~ my�vntmyg�ydKw�rzdM~0mv~�nCc�j¡no|bL£dMs�Í��Mmvs{nojk�ymvuyD&�vdM~�nost}Kg0jk�vnojk~0�£no|0m���}K�vn,nt|F}�nCá¨jhu��ydK~0~0my�qnomvg�c�j¡no|�}�nfkm�}Ku�nCH�µi�Kmys�nojk�ymyuo©q¤

���.�/�.0214365����.7/8�bmß~0dJc°jh~�nos{d�g e0�ymß�Mmv~0myst}Kf#u{ntmyr0uZno|0}�nZg0m�}�f�c�jknt|¯nt|0mVstmvw�}Kjh~ jh~0�7�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuy¤���m

}Ku{ute0w�m�}�n�no|0jku�r=dMjk~�n�no|F}�n2nt|0m�Mso}Kr |¢�¯|F}Ku2no|0mg0mvutjkstmyg��ydM~ ~0my�qnojkdM~0u!}Kw�dM~0�,no|0m3�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyuú �9ûæD@j�¤»m�¤,c!m�|F}��Mm�á»ø�¤,�3|0mi~0mªp�n no|0s{mymiutmqnou dK�(�Mmv~0myst}Kf1u�nomvr0u,ut|0dJc*|0dJc/ntd�stmqc�jhs{m�á`ø#ntd�Mmqn�mvjknt|0mysá»ø8ò=ã!dMsá`ø�òFÐy¤9 ����� � �n�Á®;À�ÀH� 5�}Kutmvg<dM~�dMe0s¢�ydM~0u�nos{e0�vntjhdM~�Dc!mVdM~0f¡x�}�ststj¡�Mmß}�n¢no| jhu��y}KutmÁc�| my~�f�Ô�Bå�Â�}�~0g��ø�ü�Bå�çMDBu{d�no|0mvstmijku dM~0f¡xÁdM~ mimyg0�Mmifkm�}���jk~0��no|0mEÎFs{u{n`���Mmys�nojk�ymvuyD�}K~0gVj¡nfkm�}��Mmvu��s{dMw ��¤&�bm ~ mymygZnod��vdM~0~0mv�vnL��nodf���<çK¤�"Gmqn�U��=m no| m#no|0jkstgZ~0mvjh�M|��zdMs�dK���i}K~0g*#�zmC}i~0mvjh�K|��zdMs�dK�ð�?�¯ç no| m,��e s{no| myu{n�rzdMutu{jh�0fkm,��stdMw ��}K~0g)���<�����E¥��·íOU íÎ�L�SçKí&#�©q¤2�3|0jku�Mj¡�Mmvu�e0uá»ø8ò=㪤

Page 34: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²KÍ

9 ����� � � �Á�R���C� ��� nomvs�stmqc�jhs{jh~ ��no|0m>Î0stu{n¬�.�_Â�U$�Mmvs{nojk�ymvuyDno|0mvstmV}Ks{m>n�c!d$myg0�Mmvu�ydK~0~0my�qnojk~0��no|0mvutm �Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�ntdEno|0m,stmvu{ndK�Gno| m��Kso}Kr0|�¤�5!x�dMe0s�stmvc�jkstjk~0�0D0nt|0mvx��ydMw�m,myj¡no|0mvs�zdKno|���stdMwü��D�dMs2dK~0m3��stdMwÔ�,}�~0g�nt|0m�dKno| mys2��stdMw��&åVçM¤1��m3nostmy}�n�no|0mvutmutmvrF}Kso}�nomyf¡xM¤���jhs{u{n�Dfkmvne0u��ydM~ utjkg0mys�no|0m,�y}Kutm c�|0mvstm,no|0mqx��=d�no|£�ydMw�m ��stdMw ��¤Í����y�ÿ°T� ��dM~ ~0my�qn���ntd��"�¯çM¤("BmvnéU¢�=m no| mC~0mvjh�K|��zdMs�dK�'�i�yfkdMutmvu{nnodJ�?�¯çC}K~0g£fkmvn'#,�zmno| m�~ myjk�M|��=dMs�dK�'�?�<ç,��e s{no| myu{n���s{dMwI��¤(���<�����E¥���í=U íÎ�L�¯çKí&#�©q¤Í����y�ûÉ;� ��dK~0~0my�qn­��nodØ�»�<Â�¤i��m�w�}�xß}Ku{ute0w�m�no|F}�n�᯦ ú �»�\ç�û�jku��vdM~0~0mv�vntmyg@¤�"Bmvn U�zm�nt|0m�nt|0jkstg£~0myjk�M|��=dKs�dK�ð��¤�"Gmqn'#��=m no| mC~0mvjh�K|��zdMsdK�¦�L�;Âi��e0s�no|0mvu{n��stdMwìU�jk~ÁáÕ¦¬ú �6û«¤���<������¥n�·íOU íÎ���<Â�í&#�©q¤ �3| jhu g0d�myu ~ dKn#g0jkut�vdM~0~0mv�vn��zmy��}�e0utmino| mystm�jhu,}¢r0}�no|V��stdKw UZntddM~0m,dK�+no| m�d�no|0mvs3~0myjk�M|��=dKstudK�ð�"�;ÂE~0dKn�e0u{jh~ ��no| m,n�c!d�stmyw�dJ�Mmvg>mvg0�Mmyuv¤Í����y�.¯�� ��dK~0~0my�qn?����ç�nod­�·�bÂ�¤&��m�w�}�x�}�utute w�m#nt|F}�n�á�¦Tú ����Â9û�jku��vdM~0~0mv�vnomvg@¤��3|0mys{m}Ks{m,��dKe0s3��}Ku{myu�nod��ydK~0utjkg0mysv�:<;�=?>@BA �;�Vç�}K~0gJ�;�£Â�ut|F}�stm}Kfkf no|0s{mym�~0mvjh�M|��zdMstuv¤(��}Kfkf no|0m�~0mvjh�K|��zdMs{uÇU�}K~ gC#�¤&���U\�+#KDno| my~�¿����H��èi}�~0g�c�m#}Kstm#g dM~0m }Ku!no|0jku�jku3á,Ë�¤(��no|0mvs{c�jkutm�Dz���<�����E¥��)��çMíOU íÎ�·�$Â�í&#�©q¤�3|0jku�fkm�}��Kmyu�á`ø8òFÐv¤�¥æ��mym,r0jk�vnte0stm��zmyfkd·c,¤´©

© ª ª« « ©©ª ª ª« « « ©

© ö© ª ª« « ©

©©©

:<;�=?>D@ @BA g0jku{n V�EGF ø H Ãn����çMí���bÂ�Èð���E}K~0g��zdKnt|�~0myjk�M|��zdMstu�d��d����ç }�~0g<���bÂC}Kstm�}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�nnod�m�}K��|Vd�no|0mvsE¥ no|0mv~Á¿��õ�L��É�©q¤"BmvnrUZ�zmCno| m�utw�}Kfkfkmyu{n }Kw�dM~0��nt|0m�s{myw�}Kjk~0jk~0�¢�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu¥�j�¤×mK¤\UØ�����.�M©qD@u{d?X$�Ejku fh}Kst�Mmvu{n,}�w�dK~0��no|0mis{myw�}Kjk~0jk~0���Mmys�nojk�ymvuy¤�"BmvnI#�DKJ��zm�no|0mEn�c!d~0mvjh�M|��zdMstudK�ÅU�}K~ g>fkmvn$�M�M�"�SçCdKsL�"��Â�D0c�|0jk��|0mv�Kmys#jku�}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n�ntdL#,}K~0gMJ�D=}�~0g>�y}Kfhfno| m�dKno| mysON�C¤Á�3|0mv~����<�����E¥P��í&#�íOU íQJ�©�stmvg0e0�ymvuEno|0m¢�Mso}Kr |bnodÁ�y}Kutm @ @ @ ¤�¥æ��mym¢r0jh�qnoe0s{m�zmyfkd·c,¤´©

©� ©U ©#© N�© �

©© JR R R R RS S S S Sª

ª« «T TU UU UT T ö

©� ©U ©#© N�© �

©© JR R R R RS S S S S

ª«T T TU U UU UT T

Page 35: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

²KI

:<;�=?>V@ @W@BA g0jhu�npV�EGF ø H à �»�ÝçMíÎ���¯Â�È�� Â�¤����c!m�}�ststj¡�Mm�}�n,nt|0jhu���}�utm�no|0mv~Þ�»�Ýç�}K~0g^���¯Âut|0}KstmCdM~0m�~0myjk�M|��=dKsi¥��zmy�y}Ke0u{m�dK� :<;/=�>X@ ©ª¤��}KfhfBnt|0jhu�~0myjk�M|��zdMs�U�}K~0g>fkmvnY#C}K~0gDJ¢�zmCno| mdKnt|0mys3~0mvjh�K|��zdMs{u3dK������ç�}K~0g<�)�7Âis{myu{r=mv�vnoj¡�MmvfkxK¤��3|0mv~Zmyj¡no|0mvséU3ë�Z##}K~0g)���<�����E¥��"�çMí&#�íÎ���;Â�í=U�©qD0dKs¨Uë�OJ�}K~0g>���<�����E¥��L�¯çMí=U íÎ�"�àÂ�í[J�©ª¤��3|0jhufkm�}��Mmvu�á»ø8òFÐy¤:<;�=?>\@^]_A "Bmvn°U)}�~0gD#C�=mE~ myjk�M|��=dMs{u dK���P�:ç�}K~0g_�P�^Â�s{myutrzmy�qnoj¡�MmvfkxKD�u{e0��|Vno|F}�n�U¡ë�`#}K~0g£dM~0m d��1no| myw¨jku�dM~£}�rF}�no|���stdMw �?�¯ç ntd����;Â�¤!���<������¥n�L�¯çKíOU íÎ���;Â�í&#·Èo¤

�3|0jku��vdMw�r0fhmqnomvunt|0m,��}Ku{m�c�|0mv~)�zdKnt|£mvg0�Mmvu��vdMw�m,��s{dMwI��¤�bmC~0dJc\nos{m�}�nno| mC�y}Kutm�c�|0my~>nt|0m,n�c�d�mvg0�Mmvu�fkm�}���jh~0��no|0m,ÎFstu�n��E�Kmys{ntjh�vmyu }�stm,��stdMw

�i}K~ g��#å;çM¤&�bm,~0d�nom no|F}�n�jk��c�m�}Ks{stj¡�MmC}�n3no|0jku���}Ku{mKDFno| my~!�¬� �#å^çM¤Í����y�º°i� ��dM~0~0mv�vn���å/ç£ntd^�A�AçM¤��bm£w�}Jx�}�utute w�m£no|F}�n¢á®¦øú �9û�jku��ydM~0~ my�vntmyg^}�~0g|0mv~0�ym�nt|0mys{mEjku#}¢rF}�no|>��s{dMwù�,å¯çCnod¬�P�Sç�~0dKn#r0}Kutu{jh~0��no|0s{dMe0�M|Ó��¤�"Gmqn¬UZ�zmCnt|0m�nt|0jhs{g~0mvjh�M|��zdMsdK�·� å<ç�}�~0gÁfkmvnY#��=m,no|0mC~0myjk�M|��zdMs�d��·�L�Sç,��e0s{nt|0myu�n���stdKwù� å^ç�jk~Vá`ø�¦�ùb��ú�¤���<������¥n�å�çKíOU íÎ���;çKí&#�©q¤&��+j¡n�jku�}Kfhu{d�no| m ��}Ku{m�no|F}�n"�¬� �*�àçMD�no|0mv~�no|0jku3jhu�á`ø8ò=ã!}�~0gutl�jkr)nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ��u�nomvr0uy¤Í����y� É;� ��dM~0~0mv�vnP��nod��?�àÂ�¤2�3|0jku�jku3no|0m,uo}�w�m�}Ku�u�nomyr>²�}K�=dJ�KmK¤Í����y� ¯;� ��dM~0~0mv�vnP�?�¯ç nod��?�àÂ�¤2�3|0jku�jku3no|0m,ut}Kw�mC}�u���dKs3u{nomvr>¶�}K�zdJ�MmK¤

�2� � ��� a,@u-D� -h��>�@2#70�!�&6-�0�#7&/�(5#()¹v+b -65�&6-9!{0/�� �>�~bno| m�r0s{mv��jkdMe0u�u{my�qnojkdM~bc!m¢stmqc�jhs{myg�nt|0m��Kso}Kr0|Qnod£r0e n�jknCjh~�rF}�nt|���fkjhl�m���dMs{w°c�j¡no|

no| mEc�mvjh�M|�ntuC�Mj¡�Mmv~ß��x3½à~ dM~���jk~0�vstm�}�utjk~0����stdMwøfhmq� n nod�stjk�M|�n�¥���dKs�no|0mir stdMrzmys fh}K�zmyfkjh~0��c!m�ydK~0utjkg0mys{myg ©ª¤E��u{ute0w�mino|0}�n no|0mi�Kso}Kr0|Vjku g0st}Jc�~ß|0dKstjk�ydM~�n�}�fhf¡xVfkjhl�mEno|0midMs{jh�Kjh~F}�f&mqp }Kw�r0fkmjk~£nt|0m,g0mvÎF~ jkntjhdM~)dK��rF}�no|���fkjhl�mKDFc�jknt|£nt|0m �Mmvs{nojk�ymvu�~�e0wC�=mvstmygbH,ntd�¿1D jh~ �ystmy}Kutjk~0����stdMw fhmq� nnodVs{jh�K|�ny¤Q� e s{no| mysyD(}Ku{ute0w�m�nt|F}�nEnt|0m�c�mvjh�K|�ntu�dK��no|0m¢�Kmys�nojk�ymyu��Mj¡�Mmv~à��x�}K~$myjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMs½<dK�Bâ�ã�}Ks{m�~0dM~���jh~ �ystmy}Kutjk~0�Á��s{dMwºfkmv� n�nodÁs{jh�M|�ny¤ß��m¢c�jkfhf�ut|0dJc9no|F}�nCno|0mvutm�c!myjk�M|�nou�}Ks{mjk~Á��}K�vn u�nos{jh�qnof¡xÁg0mv�ystmy}Kutjk~0�Z��stdMwÜfkmv� n#ntd�stjk�M|�n�¤ �bm�w�}�xÁ}Kutu{e0w�m�nt|F}�n#�Kmys�nojk�ymyu c�j¡no|Vno| muo}�w�m��Mmvs{ntjh�y}Kf!rzdMu{jkntjhdM~b}Ku,no|0mvstm�jhuC}£�Kso}Kr0|b}Ke ntdMw�dMstr0| jhu{wÌjh~�nomvst��|F}�~0�Mjk~0�>no| myw ¥æ}ZutmqndK��rzdMjk~�ntui}Ks{m¢jk~�no|0m�ut}Kjkg�nodÁ|F}��Km�no|0m�ut}Kw�mÓ~Zhlmpk w jtZu;gi¡�elwxknw ¡�}Ájk��nt|0mvx�fhjkm�dM~�no|0m�ut}Kw�m

Page 36: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶Mµ

�Mmvs{ntjh�y}Kf fhjk~0m_cE��dKs&�Mmys�nojk�ymvu�dKnt|0mys2no|0}K~Zç�}K~ g�Â�DMnt|0jku!jku�myØ�e0j¡�K}�fhmv~�n(nod�uo}�x�jk~0��nt|F}�n��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu}�n�no|0m�uo}�w�m�g0jku{n�}�~0�ym¢��s{dMw ç¢}Kstm�jh~�no|0m�uo}Kw�m��Mmys�nojk��}Kf(rzdMutj¡nojkdM~ ©ª¤£��utu{e0w�m�no|0}�nCnt|0mys{m}Ks{m�n�c!d�}Kg�±{}K�ymv~�n��Mmvs{nojk�ymvu#jk~>g0j|��mvstmv~�n��Mmvs{nojk��}�f�rzdMutj¡nojkdM~0u�c�j¡no|)nt|0m�ut}Kw�m�c!myjk�M|�n�¤����no|0jkujku�no|0m���}Ku{mKD2no| my~bc!m���}K~�ÎF~0g�n�c!dVute0��|��Kmys{ntjh�vmyu�ô�}K~0g J ¥ ôEnod)no|0m�fkmv� n�dK� J ©�u{d>no|F}�nno| m }Efhmq� n{��w�dKu{n3~0mvjh�K|��zdMs�d��'ô·D0�y}Kfkf�j¡nLW0D |F}Ku��Mstmy}�nomvs�c�mvjh�K|�n3nt|F}K~Z}Es{jh�M|�n���w�dMu{n�~0myjk�M|��=dKsdK� J D+��}Kfkf2no|0jkuCd+¤�"Bmvn°ó�}�~0g¡§��zm�no|0m�dKno|0mvsC~ myjk�M|��=dMs{u�dK�"ôi}K~0g J D�stmyu{r=mv�vntjk�Kmyf¡xM¤£�n�jkurzdMutu{jh�0fkm�no|0}�niutdKw�m�d��nt|0myu{m��ydMjk~0�vjhg0m�D��0e n�|0mvstm�}Ks{m�utdMw�m�jkw�r=dKs{n�}�~�nEdM�0utmvs{��}�ntjhdM~ uy�ØW��}�~0~0dKn��=m�ntd�no| m#stjk�M|�n�dK�'ôJD�d£��}K~0~ dKn��zm�ntd�no|0m�fhmq� n�dK� J DÊó3�y}K~0~0dKn��=mnod�nt|0m#stjk�M|�n�d�� J D}K~0g�§���}K~ ~0dKn#�zm,nod�nt|0m�fkmv� n�dK��ôJ¤���e0w�w�}Kstjk�yjk~0��c�|F}�n�c!m�l�~0dJc*}K�=dKe n�no|0m�c�mvjh�M|�ntuyD�c!m|F}��MmoX�þ>ü±X4e�}K~0g¡X�þ£ä�X � ä�X��A� X�ÿZä X�f�ä�X4eM¤>�bm�ut|0dJc�no|0}�n���dMsCutdMw�mg¢ü9ý Dc!m�w�}�xßjh~ �ystmy}Kutm\X�����xhg,}K~0gQg0my�vstmy}KutmHX�ÿ���xhg¢¥�lKmymvr0jk~0�)nt|0mi�Mmy�qnodMs�rzmystrzmy~ g0jh�ve0fh}Ks�ntdºJ©�nodZg0mv�ys{m�}Ku{m�nt|0m���}�x�fhmvjh�K|�Ø�e0dKntjhmv~�n�DGno|�e0u,ut|0dJc�jk~0�)nt|F}�n nt|0m�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m��M}KrVc�}Ku,~0d�nw�jh~ jhwCe0wZDF}K~0g�|0my~0�vm#}Ks{stj¡��jh~0�E}�n�}��ydM~�ntso}Kg0jk�vntjhdK~@¤&�bm�}Ku{ute0w�m�nt|F}�n Ä ½ Ä �/çMD�u{dC��dMs�no| m~0mqc:�Mmv�vntdMsyDFno| mC�}�x�fhmvjh�M|£Ø�e0dKntjhmv~�n�jku

â0Ð'�àÂ�gyÃ�X�þH��X � ��X�ÿ�å;X���å¡X�f2åYX4eåigªÈç*�;Â�gyÃ�X��1åYX�ÿ¦�jgªÈ í

c�|0jk��|>jku��Mstmy}�nomvs�nt|F}K~Áâ0Ðj¡� X�þ��õX � å¡X�f1å¡X4eCüÝÃ�âFÐ��¯ç�Èkgì&�3|0mEfkmv� n#|F}K~0gÁu{jhg mijhu#�Kstm�}�nomysno|F}�~Á�ymvstd0D@u{d���|0d�dMutjk~0�Z}K~�ò�u{w�}Kfhf�my~0dKe0�M|@D�c!mi}Ks{stj¡�Mmi}�sno| m�g myutjkstmvg>�vdM~�noso}�g0jh�qnojkdM~@¤

�2� � � � ���*)�) !'4�0'�� >Z)Ð!Ê&%> -;��) ��5l�{0�bm|F}��Mm~0dJc^u{|0dJc�~�no|0}�n�c�mw�}Jx�s{mvc�jkstm�á:nod�w�}KlKmjkn(rF}�no|���fhjklKm�c�jknt|0dMe n(jk~0�ys{m�}Ku8�

jk~0��no|0mimvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m���}�r@¤��~ßdMs{g0mys�ntdZut|0dJc4nt|F}�n,á w�e0u�n,|F}��Mm��=mvmy~QrF}�nt|���fkjhl�mEnodZ�zmy�Mjk~c�j¡no|@D0c!mC~ mymygZnod��Mmqn�stjkg)dK��fh}Kst�Mm � fhd���l�uy¤

�bm���}K~i�vdMfhfh}Kr0u{m3}K~�xC�0fhd���l,no|F}�n&jhu&fh}Ks{�Mm ¥�utmym�rF}K�Mm�²�H·©q¤�5!x�}Kr0r0f¡x�jh~0�����<�����E¥n�i�çMíÎ�*�Á� íÎ�*�7Â�íÎ�)��è�©�}Ku3d�� nomy~Z}�u3r=dMu{utjk�0fkm,ntd�ᨥ nodE�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyudK�Gno|0m#��dMs{w jk~�no|0m g j¬}K�Kso}Kw�zmyfkd·c�©ªDzc!mC}Kstm�fhmq� n�c�jknt|V}��Kso}Kr0|Zc�|0jk��|Á|F}Kumy~ g>�0fkd���l�u�}K~0g>w�jkg0g0fkm��0fkd���l�udK�&nt|0m ÎFstu�n

Page 37: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶ H

n�c!d�n�x�rzmyuC¥�u{mym�rF}K�Mm�²KµM©q¤�5!x�nt|0m r0s{mv��jhdKe0u�u{my�qnojkdM~@D0c!mCu{mym no|F}�n3no|0m no| m myjk�Mmy~��Mmv�vntdMs���dMsno| m stmyu{e0f¡nojk~0���Mso}Kr |�w�e0u�n|F}��Mm u{ntstjk�vntfkx¢g0my�vstm�}�utjk~0���vd�dKstg0jk~F}�ntmyu,¥�fhmq� n{��ntd���s{jh�K|�n�©!}K~ g£u{e0��|}iu{c�j¡no��|>c!dMe0fkg£u{nos{jh�qnof¡xZg0my�vstmy}Kutm¬â�ãq¤

©m©n

©o©p

©rq©s ö

©m©n © p © o ©rq

©sª ª« « ª ª« «

��d>�ydMw�r0fkmvntm¢no|0m�r0std�dK��nt|F}�nEáÜwCe0u{ni�zm¢r0}�no|���fhjklKm�D&j¡nEute�n��vmyuEntdÁut|0dJc�no|0}�nE}�~�xmyfkmyw�mv~�no}Ks{x�u{c�j¡no��|�dM~7}ÁrF}�nt|���fkjhl�m��Mso}�r0|�c�|0jk��|�g d�mvui~0dKnis{myute fkn�jk~7}ÁrF}�nt|���fkjhl�m��Mso}�r0|w�e u{n�jh~0�vstmy}Kutm,no|0m��}�x�fkmyjk�M|£Ø�e0dKnojkmy~�ny¤

��2c�mE}Kr0r0f¡x>���<�����E¥ WFí:ó·í ô·í J ©ntd¢s{mvc�jkstm�c�j¡no|0dKe n#g0mv�ys{m�}Ku{jh~0��nt|0mi�}�x�fkmyjk�M|ÁØ�e0d��nojkmy~�nyD!c!m)wCe0u{n�ÎF~0g���dMe0sE�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu<W0í%óJípôJí J u{e0��|ànt|F}�n¬Ws�ôóJí¬ô� J í¬Wªë� ôJíoóõë� J D���<������¥ W0í%óJípôJí J ©�g0d�myu�~0dKn�g0jkut�vdM~0~0mv�vnZá�D�}K~ gÚX�þ�ä X�ÿ·í\X��)ä X � ¤��~�}ßrF}�nt|���fkjhl�m�Mst}Kr0|Vfh}K�=mvfhmvgßutd�no|0}�n#no| mi�yd�dMstg0jk~F}�ntmyu dK�~½�}Ks{mEu{ntstjk�vntfkxVg my�ys{m�}Ku{jh~ �Z��s{dMwÜfhmq� n nod�stjk�M|�n�Dno| myutm���dMe0s#�Kmys�nojk�ymyuCdM~0f¡xVmqp�jku{n�c�|0my~ÞW>}K~ g;óE}�stmijk~Qnt|0m�uo}Kw�m��Mmys�nojk��}Kf2rzdMu{jkntjhdM~�DðôE}�~0gJ }KstmCjh~)no|0mCuo}Kw�m��Kmys{ntjh�y}Kf1rzdMu{jkntjhdM~�D;Wø� J D=}K~0g�ór��ôJ¤��~Ánt|0jhu���}Ku{mKD@s{mvc�jkstjk~0��fkm�}��Mmvu,}�Mst}Kr0|¢jkutdKw�dKstr0|0jk��ntdCno| m�dMs{jh�Kjh~F}�fæ¤2�3|0jku��vdMw�r0fkmvnomvu�no| m�r0s{d�dK�=no|F}�n3áÝw�e0u�n��zm�rF}�no|���fhjklKm�¤

�?3�t TÑGT�7� Bvu �Å���AO��9@"SÊò�B¨@"S�S�NP5þ6sGùDFKP8wuÇ6��T���98�bmCl�~0dJcÝ��stdMw¾no| mCr0s{mv��jkdMe0u#u{my�vntjhdK~Áno|F}�n�á6w�e0u�n �zmCrF}�no|���fhjklKm�D@}K~0g)jh~)��}K�vnno|F}�n

dM~0f¡x�u{w�}�fhfG}K~ g)w�myg jhe0w¾� fhd���l�u�w�}�x�d��y�ye sy¤2�bm#c�jkfkf+~ d·c:r0stdJ�KmK�Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�yx ý¶×�áÙw¶e tÓj ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv¬k mpwx~�tZu¶hl}ikð{´mtlgi³�¡�}Z¿ à ¿�ä*çJý�á�~Zhlmpk w j h e ²*kx³ihl}£áÙ³Ft�e¡�}iu�¢felqJtZuxud��u¶¡�j%z�e`wx}Ókx³ih¼qfwnvRvFu¶h�¾

�3|0m�jkg0my}�dK��é�r0e0u{|0jh~ ��ê�w�myg0jke0w¼�0fkd���l�u�ntdJc�}Ks{g0u�nt|0m�dKe nou{jhg0m�c�|0jk��|>c�mCr0stmq��jhdMe utf¡x}Kfkfhe g0mygZnod�jhu�jkfhfke0u�noso}�nomyg£jk~£nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ��r0jk�vnte0stm��

Page 38: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶�²

©m©n ü ü ü üý ý ý ý © z ©z|{$}ü ü ü üý ý ý ý ©z|{_~

©z|{��© o© p

� ���.� �����|����� �©m©n

©z|{$}©z ü ü ü üý ý ý ý © z|{�� ©z|{_~ü ü ü üý ý ý ý © o

© p

�3|0m3�0fkd���lC�ydM~�no}Kjh~ jh~0� �Kmys{ntjh�vmyu*ô!}�~0g J �zmy�vdMw�myu2u{w�}�fhfkmysvD�}�~0gEno|0m3� fhd���lC�vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�WÁ}K~ gYói�=mv�ydMw�mvu��0jk�M�Mmvsy¤��3|0jkuCn�x�rzm¢dK�3s{mvc�jkstjk~0�Á�y}K~0~0dKnC�zm¢}K�v�ydMw�r0fkjkut|0mvg$��xno| m�dMrzmyst}�nojkdM~����<����� e0u{myg�jk~�nt|0m�r0stmq��jkdMe0uCutmv�vnojkdM~@¤£�FdMs no| m¢�}�x�fkmyjk�M|�Ø�e dKnojkmy~�n�ntdg0mv�ystmy}Kutm�DFc�m�~0mymvg£ntd¢}�fkntmys�no| m,�Kmy�qnodMsv¤

��+á/jku3}�rF}�no|���fkjhl�m#�Mso}�r0|¢c�j¡no|Z}Cw�mvg0jhe w �0fkd���l�jk~�no|0m�w�jhg0g fhm�D no|0mv~¢no| m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�fkmyw�w�}Ew�}�x��=m#}Kr0r0fkjhmvg�nodimvjknt|0mys�nt|0m#mvjh�Mmv~��Mmy�qnodMs,½ßdKs!no| m#myjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMs åß½QntdEw�dJ�Mm#no| mé8mªp�noso}·ê myg �Mm,dMe n�c�}Kstg@D g0mv�ys{m�}Ku{jh~0��no|0m mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe mKD=}K~0gZ�ydM~�ntso}Kg0jk�vntjh~ ��w�jk~0jhw�}Kfkj¡n�xM¤Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�y�ûÒ hlkBáù�lh�mÎhvZoTj hv�gFtZkx³�¹Eu�wèzRh�{´m4tlgi³!¡�}�¿Ñ~Zhlmpknw j h e à ¿QäÝç�ý�á�²¦¸·wxkx³<t�q¬hvZwxo�q��u¶¡�j%zµt�e¬vZwnt�{´m4tZqfq¬hvÓtR�l¡�~ZhJwx}Ákx³ih¬o�gRgihlm»gFtZmlk»¡9×Jk�³ihß��{´o�mÎh�¾ Ò hlk"½ÿ�lh<tZ}$hlw|{Chl}i~Zh jlkE¡�mtZ}�v¬t�e elo�q¬h»kx³FtZk X$�,üsX$�oò=ã�üZX$�oòFÐ3ä¯ý à ¡�kx³ihlmp¸·w¶e�h»oRe�h,åB½�áZ¾�Õ�³ihl}µkx³ih hlw|{Chl}i~�tZu�oTh"{ytlg¡9×`kx³ihL{´m4tlgi³_¡Z��kXtZwx}%hv���¢»gihlmx×�¡�mpqfwx}y{�kx³�w¶e�� g�oye ³��?w¶e�elqJtZuxu¶hlm»kx³FtZ}_k�³FtZk"¡9×�á�¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ��bm�u{|0dJc nt|0jkui��xbg0myw�dM~ u{nost}�nojk~0�ß}>�Kmy�vntdMs»Æÿ� Ã�È�ãªí:ÈMÐqí�&�&�&Bí(È�Ë�È,rzmystrzmy~ g0jh�ve0fh}Ksnod�no|0mǺ��Kmy�qnodMs#c�|0jk��|ß�Mj¡�Mmyu,}�utw�}Kfkfhmvs#�K}�fhe0m�jh~Ánt|0mi�}Jx�fkmyjk�M|VØ�e0dKntjhmv~�n nt|F}K~Ánt|0mEutw�}Kfkf �myu�nErzdMutj¡noj¡�Mm�myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0m¢d���no|0m�dMs{jh�Mjk~F}Kf��Mst}Kr0|@¤¢�3|0jhu�ut|0dJc�uCnt|F}�n�no|0m�utw�}Kfkfkmyu{nEr=dMu{jkntjk�Kmmyjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0mC}Kutu{d��vj¬}�nomygZc�j¡no|Zno|0m,~0mqcÝ�Mso}�r0|Zjhu�utw�}Kfkfkmys�no|F}K~�nt|F}�ndK�+no|0m,dMs{jh�Mjk~F}Kf��Mso}Kr |@¤

"Bmvn�á¦�=m�nt|0m)dKstjk�Mjh~0}Kf��Mst}Kr0|@D�}K~0g�fhmqn�nt|0mZw�myg0jke0w �0fkd���l��zm£f¬}K�zmyfkmygà}Ku�jk~àno| me0r0rzmys�rF}Ks{n#dK�2no|0m�g0j¬}��Mso}KwZ¤,"Bmvn ï �=m�nt|0mE~0mqc4�Kso}Kr0|)c�jknt|ßnt|0mEfkd��y}Kf+��|F}K~0�Mm£¥¬é8r0e ut|�ê8©

Page 39: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶M¶

�Mj¡�Mmv~b}K�zdJ�Mm�¤��+dZg0mvÎ0~0m�nt|0m�~0mvc*�Mmv�vnodKsrÆ(DBc!m���|0}K~0�Mm�dM~0f¡xÁn�c!d)�vd�dKstg0jk~F}�ntmyu,dK�~½�}�~0gno| my~£ut|0j¡� n�no|0m,my~�ntjhs{m��Kmy�vntdMs3nod�lKmvmyrÁj¡n�rzmystrzmy~ g0jh�ve0fh}KsntdBºK¤

È�Y���������� �������X7Yzåi� j¡�'a(ö U�dMs"a�ä­U»�þ��íX$��åi� j¡�'að�ªU»�<çMíX$����X$�tòFÐ(å¡X$�oò=ã�åi� j¡�'að�ªU»�àÂC&

¥æ¶�¤hH·©

c�|0mvstmI�»�: Ã�X$�GåøX$�tò=ãoÈ�õ�¿Zmv~0ute0s{myu(no|F}�n � È�Y��:ý D�j�¤»m�¤hD�no|0}�n~ÆÁjku!rzmys{r=mv~0g0jk�ye0fh}Ks�nodźK¤&��mw�}�xZ}Kutu{e0w�m no|F}�n�no|0m#�Kmy�vntdMsǽQ|F}Ku3~0dMs{w°H,}K~ gZnt|0my~Zno| m utw�}Kfkfhmvu{nr=dKutj¡noj¡�Mm,myjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMsdK�1á�D$â�ãªÃ«áEÈ�DFjku�Kjk�Kmy~>��x â�ã·� I Y¶ÉR[ Ã�X7Y å¡Xy[�È Ð &�3|0m��}Jx�fkmyjk�M|>Ø�e0d�nojkmy~�n���dMs�no|0m,�Mst}Kr0|)ï¸}K~0g��Mmv�vnodKsBÆbjhu

��}�x�fhmvjh�K|)Ø�e0dKntjhmv~�n"� � Y¶ÉR[ Ã�È�YFå¡È�[yÈ ÐÄ Æ Ä Ð � â�ãqÃæáiÈÄ Æ Ä Ð &��m�dK~0fkx�~0mymvg)nod�u{|0dJc:no|0}�n Ä Æ Ä ü:çK¤I È ÐY � I Ã�X7Y åi�KÈ Ð å^Ã�X$�oò=ã&å\�MÈ Ð å^Ã�X$�oòFÐ�å��MÈ Ð

�SÃ�X$��åi�MÈ Ð �¯Ã�X$���õX$�oòFÐ(å;X$�oò=ã&å\�MÈ Ð� I X ÐY å�Âl� I X7Y7�7¿�� Ð �SÃ�X$�3åYX$�tò=ãoȪëÂ'X$���;Â'X$�tòFÐ(å�è|�MÈ�*ç*� è

¿ Ã�X$��å¡X$�oò=ãoÈ Ð �¯Ã�X$��åYX$�tò=ã�ȪÃ�Â9X$���;Â'X$�oòFÐ2å Ç¿ Ã�X$�3åYX$�oò=ã�È{È

��m�~ mymygZnod�ut| d·cSno|F}�nnt|0jkujku��Mstmy}�nomvs�no|F}�~�HMD |0my~0�vm�nt|F}�nè¿ Ã�X$�3åYX$�oò=ãoÈ Ð �¯Ã�X$��å¡X$�oò=ãoÈ�Ã�Â'X$���àÂ'X$�oòFÐ2å Ç

¿ Ã�X$��å¡X$�oò=ãoÈ{È(ü^ýdMs3e0u{jh~ ��nt|F}�nBX$��å¡X$�oò=ã�ü�ý�}K~0g£g0j¡��jkg0jk~0��nt|0stdKe0�M|@D c!m�~0mymvg£ntd�u{|0dJc\no|0}�n

è¿ Ã�X$��å¡X$�tò=ãoÈ%�SëÂ'X$���;Â'X$�tòFÐ�å Ç

¿ Ã�X$��å¡X$�oò=ãtÈtÈ!ü�ýdMs3mvØ�e jk��}Kfkmy~�nof¡x X$����X$�tòFÐü Â

¿ Ã�X$��å¡X$�oò=ãtÈc�|0jk��|bjku �yfkm�}Ks{fkx>noste mKD+}Ku#c!m�}�utute w�mvg�nt|F}�nrX$�¢ü¯X$�oò=ã�ü¯X$�oòFÐEä4ý�}K~0gQ¿;ä ç�ý ¤E�3|0jku�ydKw�r fhmqnomyu�no| m�r std�dK�1d��&"Bmyw�w�}�¶ ¤´L�}K~ g)|0mv~0�ym�dK�1"Bmyw�w�}�¶ ¤´¹�nod�d0¤ Ó

Page 40: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶K½�?3�� O^KL@"@HBC6sGT�üDFKP8�@�>LDF6&uûNIu O¼8%D��^8;8dGID��^@rS��HGB��67�¨�¦DC8;B�bm�|0}J�KmZ~0dJc¨ut| d·c�~7no|0}�n�á°jkuirF}�nt|���fkjhl�mKD(|F}Kuiu{w�}�fhf�dKsiw�mvg0jke0w �0fkd���l�u�dM~$no| m

my~ g0uyD1}K~0gbdK~0fkxßu{w�}Kfhf��0fkd���l�u�jk~�no| m�w�jkg0g0fkmK¤���3¿�À ýAÃ�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�DGno| my~�á¨wCe0u{n��=m�no| me0~0jkØ�e0m��Mst}Kr0|7Ê@Ë ¤ß��¿\ÀøÂ4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ£è�È�D&nt|0my~$c!mZ}Kstm�fkmv� n�c�jknt|7n�c!dß��}K~ g0jhg0}�nomvuE��dMs�no| mw�jh~ jhwCe0w¼��}Kr@¤!�2jknt|0mys�no|0m��Mst}Kr0|£|F}Ku�}�w�myg jhe0w¾� fhd���lZ}�nm�}K��|)my~0g�DzdKsj¡n�|F}Ku}KfkfButw�}Kfkf�0fkd���l�uv¤!�3|0m,�Mst}Kr0|0u}Ks{m,g0so}�c�~£|0mys{mK�

ÊBËT T TU U Ul« «ª ª ª ª« «

« «ª ª ª ª« «« «ª ª ���r� ª ª« «

« «ª ª ª ª« «« «ª ª ª ª« «

T T TU U U

êËT T TU U U « «ª ª ª ª« «« «ª ª ª ª« «

« «ª ª �r��� ª ª« «« «ª ª ª ª« «

T T TU U U�3|0m��Mst}Kr0|bÊBË)|F}KuCg0jh}Kw�mvnomvs�à �K¿VåÝçJý�È8õ�è0DGc�|0jhfkmøê�Ë>|F}�u�g0jh}Kw�mvntmys�à �K¿VåÝç�è�È8õ�è0¤

�~�noe0j¡noj¡�Mmvfkx�c!mc!dMe0fkg¢mªp rzmy�qn!nt|0m�Mso}Kr |�c�j¡no|�f¬}�st�Mmvs(g j¬}Kw�mqnomys�nod�|F}��Mm�no| m�u{w�}�fhfkmys(myjk�Mmy~����}Kfke0m°â�ã�¤��3|0m�~0mqp�n�fhmvw�w�}��ydM~�ÎFstw�u�no|F}�n�nt|0jhujku�jk~0g0mvmyg>ntste0m�D0c�|0jh��|)c�jhfkfG�ydMw�r0fkmvntmCno| mr0s{d�dK��dK���3|0mydKstmyw¼¶�¤hHM¤Í �C�Þ�Þ�^¯;�êéõÒ hlk+¿VÀ:Â*ÃæÄ�Å�Æ£è�È`tZ}�vC¿ßäÝç�èT¾ ± ¡�m�k�³�w¶e¿d²8â�ãvÃRÞ�ð _ È*(Zâ�ãvÃRê�Ë�Èp¾

�3|0m�jhg m�}�dK�(no|0mir0s{d�d���jku utjkw�r0fhm�� c�m�w�d�g jk� xÁ}K~ßmyjk�Mmy~��Mmv�vntdMsCd��,ê�Ë�nod��Mmqn�}�~0mvc�Mmv�vntdMsyDu{ntjhfkf�rzmys{r=mv~0g0jk�ye0fh}Ks�ntdøºK¤S��m>nt|0my~^u{|0dJcÜnt|F}�n�no|0mV�}�x�fhmvjh�M|^Ø�e0d�nojkmy~�n���dMs¢ÊBËc�j¡no|�no| m¢~0mqc�fkxbg0mvÎF~ myg��Mmv�vntdMsEjkuEfhmvutu�nt|F}K~bnt|0m�mvjh�Mmv~��K}�fhe0m¢dK�BêË�D1no|�e0u�ut|0dJc�jk~0�Áno|F}�nno| m¢myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�dK��Ê@Ë£jhuCfhmvutu�nt|F}K~�nt|0m¢mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m�dK�Çê�Ë0¤��3|0m¢jhw�r0fkmyw�my~�no}�nojkdM~$dK�!no|0jkujkg0m�} D2| d·c!mv�KmysvD�jku��Mmvs{x$g0mvfhjk��}�nomK¤Q�3|0mvstmZ}Ks{m¢n�c�dVg j��=mys{my~�n���}Ku{myuinod>�ydM~0u{jhg mysE��dMs�c�| my~no| m�g j¬}Kw�mqnomys�dK�1Ê@Ë�jhu�mq�Mmy~>}K~0gZc�|0my~)jkn�jku�d�g g@¤��3|0m,r0std�dK��u�}Ks{m,�Kmys�xZutjkw�jkfh}KsyDF�0e�n�my}K��|stmvØ�e0jhs{myuutmvrF}Kso}�nom�}K~F}Kf¡x�utjkuy¤

Page 41: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶�¹

�2������� ���¡  ¢Q£Z¤¦¥Z§¦¨© �|ª��/������«��+«�¬I­®14�/¯+°²±

�bm(c�jhfkf�mqp�r0fkdMjkn�no|0m!u{x�w�w�mvnos�xEdK�FÊBË�}K~ g êË�nod�stmvr0stmvutmy~�n2nt|0m!mvjh�Kmy~��Mmv�vnodKs&�Mmy�qnodMs�dK�êË#}K~0g�nt|0m��Kmy�vntdMs&��dMsuêË�¤1�3|0m3�vd�dMs{g0jk~F}�nomvu&dK�Fnt|0m�myjk�Mmv~��Kmy�qnodMs2��dMsuâ�ãvÃRêË�ÈBjku2}�c!myjk�M|�nojk~0�dK� no| m��Mmys�nojk�ymvu�nt|F}�n2g myrzmy~0g0u�dM~ fkx�dM~Eno|0m��Kmys�nojk��}KfFrzdMutj¡nojkdM~idK� nt|0m��Mmvs{nomªp=D�c�j¡no|int|0m3�Mso}�r0|g0st}Jc�~�}Ku2c!m�|F}��Km�g0st}�c�~¢j¡n�¤25�mv��}Ke utm�no|0m��Mst}Kr0|�|F}Ku(}Ku(}K~�}Ke ntdMw�dMstr0| jhu{wAno|0m�stm=�Fmy�qnojkdM~}K�zdMe n3nt|0m �ymv~�ntso}Kf@�Kmys�nojk��}KfG}�p�jkuyD0c!myjk�M|�noudK�+�Mmys�nojk�ymvu�jk~�nomys{��|F}K~0�Kmyg>��x�nt|0jkus{mO�Fmv�vntjhdM~)}Ks{m~0mv��}�noj¡�MmdK�=m�}K��|�dKno| mysy¤1�3|�e u(c!m�w�}�xiu{r=mv�yj¡� xino|0mmyjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMs(��x�} �Mmv�vntdMs�½>|F}���jk~0��dM~ m�yd�dMs{g0jh~0}�nomE��dMs�m�}K��|V�Mmvs{ntjh�y}Kf2r=dKutj¡nojkdM~@DB�ydKe0~�nojk~0�£��s{dMw¼no|0miw�jkg0g0fkmK¤E��(no|0mvstm�jku,}¢�Mmys�nomªpdM~£no|0jku }�p�jkuyD=c!m�u�n�}Ks�n#dMe s�fh}K�zmyfkjh~0�¢dK��½�c�j¡no|Vý�D�}K~ g>~0dKntmCnt|F}�n���x)u{x�w�w�mvnts{xÁj¡nou��}Kfhe mjku�µ��0jk�&}K~Zmyg0�Km�jku�jh~Zno| m�w�jkg0g0fkmKDFc!mCu�n�}Ks�n�dMe0s3fh}K�=mvfhjk~0��c�jknt|)u{e0�0u{�ystjkr n�HM¤

5�my�y}Ke0u{m�¿ÁÀ:Â4Ã�Ä�Å�Æ)Ç�È�D�jk~�nt|0jku!�y}Kutm3c!mu�n�}Ks�n(dMe0s2fh}K�=mvfhjk~0�,c�jknt|)çK¤1�3|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�ÎF�Me stmut|0dJc�u�dK~0m�|0}Kfk�@dK��nt|0m��Kso}Kr0|�}K~0g�myu�n�}K�0fkjkut|0mvu�no|0m~0dMw�mv~0�yfh}�noe stmK¤(�FstdKw4no|0m��Mmv�vntdMs½2D�c�m£g0mqÎF~0m)}V�Kmy�qnodMs ÆÝjk~;}Vu{jhw�jkf¬}Ksic�}�x$��dMsEno|0mZ�Mst}Kr0|�Ê@Ë ¤��dKnom�nt|F}�n���dMs�Ê@Ë�D!no| mfh}K�=mvfhjk~0��u{no}Ks{ntu�c�j¡no|)ý ¤

&�&�& ª ª ª« « «

åBX D « « «ª ª ª

åTX Ð åBX�㪠ª ª« « «

X�ã « « «ª ª ªX Ð X D

ª ª ª« « «

X0Û « « «ª ª ªX4³

&�&�&X�´

ª ª ª« « «

T T T T TU U UU UX$�pèFã X$�

&�&�&åTÈKÐ

ª ª ª« « «

åBÈ�ã« « «ª ª ªÈ/� È�ã

ª ª ª« « «ÈKÐ

« « «ª ª ªÈ D È�Û &�&�& ª ª ª

« « «« « «ª ª ª ª ª ª

« « «Èh�pè�ÐT T T T TU U UU U

Èh�lèFã È/�

Page 42: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶ML

�3|0m,�ydKw�rzdM~0mv~�noudK�8Æ$}Kstm g0mqÎF~0mvg>jk~£nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ��c�}�x=�È'���¯ý í È�ã·�tX�ãªíÈKÐ)��X D í È D � X D ��X0ÛÂ#åõâ�ã í È�Û)�tX0Û·íÈl³)��X�´Jí Èl´)� X�´ð��X4µÂ#åõâ�ã í ÈlµH�tX4µ�í &�&�& íÈh�p足)��X$�lè�ÛJí È/�lè�Û)� X$�lè�Ûð��X$�pè DÂ#å¡â�ã í È/�lè D �tX$�lè D íÈh�pè�Ð)��X$�lèFãªí È/�lèFã¦�\Â'X$�lèFã�åYX$�pè�Ð�í È/�?�tX$����X$�lèFã1åYX$�lè�Ðì&

��jk~0�ym»½�jku }K~ßmyjk�Mmy~��Kmy�vntdMs ��dMs�â�ãvÃ�êË�È�D�c!miw�}�xV}Ku{ute0w�m�ý�( X�ã»(ªX ÐA(6ôJôJô;(ªX$��¤��dMs{stmyu{r=dK~0g0jk~0�Mf¡xMDzý¼�tÈ/�L(ÚÈ�ã�(sÈMÐ?(\ôJôJô7(ÚÈ/��¤

�3|0mZ�Mmy�qnodMs{u\½:}K~0gõÆ\c�jkfhf3�zm�n�}K�vjkntfkx$nt|0dMe0�K|�n�dK��}Kuino| m£¿<g0jkw�my~0u{jhdK~F}Kf3�Mmv�vnodKstuc�|0jk��|)nt|0mvx�s{myr0s{myu{my~�n�D=}K~0gZc�m c�jkfhf@c�s{jkntm½ Ò Þ ã ½Ä ½ Ä Ð }K~0g Æ Ò Þ�V.ÆÄ Æ Ä Ð &

�bm�c�jkfhf�myu�nojkw�}�nom�no|0m(~�e0w�myst}�nodMs�}K~0g,no| m!g0mv~0dMw�jk~F}�nodKs�dK��no|0mvutm!��}�x�fkmyjk�M|�Ø�e0dKntjhmv~�nouutmvrF}Kst}�nomvfkxKD=}�fhf@jk~Znomys{w�ud���X�ãªD�X$�lèFã�D }K~0g?â�ãqD }K~0g�ÎF~F}�fhf¡xZut|0dJcSno|F}�nÆ Ò U¨ð _ ÆÄ Æ Ä Ð ( ½ Ò UI· _ ½Ä ½ Ä Ð �Õâ�ãvÃRêË�È�íc�|0jk��|>u{|0dJc�unt|F}�nBâ�ãvëÊ@Ë�È*(Zâ�ãvÃRê�Ë�ÈoDF�ydMw�r0fkmvntjh~ ��nt|0m,r0std�dK�8¤

¸ �.3W1�����«¹�/82º/��7/8�14»�«��¦�¼��º/�D½¾«�«¹0�¯��W�/1����.8.±�1jkstu{n�c!m�mvu{no}K�0fkjhu{|�} ��mvc�s{myfh}�nojkdM~0u{|0jkr0u�}Kw�dM~ �,nt|0m�yd�dMstg0jk~F}�ntmyu�dK�*½2D�e0utjk~0��no|0m3��}K�qn

no|0}�n,jkn�jku�}K~�mvjh�Kmy~��Mmv�vnodKsy¤���fkf2dK�!nt|0myu{m¢}�stjkutmi��stdMwøno|0m�myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�myØ�eF}�ntjhdK~;Þ�Æ.�Ëâ�ã�Æ¥æ}���}Kjk~£| mystm ��dMs�nt|0m �Mmv�vnodKs�}Ks{jhu{jh~ ����s{dMwËÆ1©

�bm,�y}K~�c�stj¡noméX Ð�jh~�nomvstw�u�dK�8X�ãqDÊX D DF}K~0g?â�ã!��stdMw�no| m�mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe m�mvØ�eF}�nojkdM~QåTX�ã��Â'X Ð�åYX D �Õâ�ã�X Ð�¤2�bm g0d�no| m�ut}Kw�m ��dMsÇX4³�D;&�&�&vDÊX$�lè�Ð�¤X Ð)� X�ã;��X DÂ#å¡â�ã í X4³*� X0Û¦��X�´

Â#å¡â�ã í &�&�&Bí X$�lè�Ð*� X$�lè D ��X$�pèFãÂ#å¡â�ã & ¥æ¶�¤³²M©

Page 43: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶�Õ

�bm,w�}�x�c�stj¡nom�X D jh~Znomvstw�u�dK�uX�ã3}K~0ggX0Û#��x�u{dMf¡��jk~0��no|0m,myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m,myØ�eF}�nojkdM~0uy�

åBX�ã;�;Â'X Ð�å¡X D �tâ�ã7X0Û }K~0g å7Â'X Ð'�þ�/X D å¡X0Û��­â�ã7X4³�& ¥æ¶�¤´¶�©

�3|0mvjhs�utdKfhe ntjhdK~£x�jkmyfkg0u X D � Â'X�ã��Së åõâ�ã�È X0ÛÃæè,å¡â�ã�ȪÃ�ç�åõâ�ãoÈ

��dMs�c�|0jk��|)c!m,c�jhfkfBe0utm nt|0m,jh~0mvØ�eF}KfkjkntjhmvuX D ü Ã�Â#åõâ�ãoȪÃ�X�ãd�õX0Û�ÈÃæè,å¡â�ã�ȪÃ�ç�åõâ�ãoÈ ¥æ¶�¤»½�©

}K~0g X D (  Ã�X�ã;��X0Û�ÈÃ�è,åõâ�ã�ȪÃ{ç3åõâ�ã�È í ¥æ¶�¤³¹M©

c�|0jk��|>|0dKfhg)}Ku�fhdK~0��}Kuý�(Zâ�ã�(\çK¤(��dMsts{myutrzdM~0g jh~0��jk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡nojkmyu�| dMfhg���dMsÇX�´Jí�&�&�&Bí:X$�lè�Û�¤�bm���}K~Qc�stj¡nom�no|0m���}Kfhe myu�dK~�no| m�mv~0g0u�d��3�=d�no|b�Kso}Kr0| uCjk~�ntmystw�uCdK�ßâ�ã�}K~ g;X$�lèF㪤

��dM~0u{jhg mys�no|0m,myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�my�eF}�ntjhdK~0uy�

åBX$�lè�Ðð�Ñ�/X$�lèFã�å�Â'X$�?�­â�ã�X$�pèFã }K~0g å�Â'X$�lèFã��àÂ'X$�L�tâ�ã�X$��&��dMf¡��jh~ ��nt|0myu{m�}Ku3c!myfkfG}Ku�ute0� u{noj¡noe�nojk~0�¢jk~£nt|0m,g0mvÎ0~0jkntjhdK~0u�d��uÈ/�lèFã�}K~0ggÈh�#�Mj¡�Mmvu

X$�lè�Ð*� Â#å�¿/â�ã;�sâ Ð ãÂ#åõâ�ã X$�pèFãªí X$�P� Â

Â#åõâ�ã X$�lèFãªí ¥æ¶�¤´L�©Èh�lèFã¦� Â?�þ�/â�ã1åõâ Ð ãÂ#åõâ�ã X$�pèFãªí Èh�?� Â?��è�â�ã1åõâ Ð ã

Â#å¡â�ã X$�lèFãl& ¥æ¶�¤³ÕM©

�3g0g0j¡nojkdM~F}�fhf¡x�e0u{jh~ �7nt|0mÁmvØ�e0}�nojkdM~<�ymv~�ntmys{mygS}KstdMe ~0g«X$�lè�Ð�}K~0g^u{e0�0u�noj¡noe ntjh~0�7no| mV}K�zd·�Km��}Kfke0myuvD c!m,w�}Jx¢c�stj¡nomX$�lè D �*åBX$�lèFã;�SÃ�Â#å¡â�ã�È X$�lè�Ð*�*Ã{ç�åi¿/â�ã;�sâ Ð ã È�X$�lèFãl& ¥æ¶�¤´Í�©

Page 44: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶MÍ

À 8Á���W»i1��������¼��º��ÃÂ�«¹0�»Ä±�bm c�jkfhf@c�s{jkntm Ä Æ Ä jk~�nomys{w�ud�� Ä ½ Ä D{X�ãqDÊX$�lèFãqDF}K~ g]â�ãq¤2�3| m�~ dMstw�u�dK� ½b}�~0gøÆ$}Ks{mÄ ½ Ä Ð �\ Ã�X Ð ã �àÂ'X ÐÐ �õX ÐD �õX ÐÛ �àÂ'X г �¯ôJôJô��õX Ð�lè D �;Â'X Ð�lè�Ð �àÂ'X Ð�lèFã È%�àÂ'X Ð�lèFã ��è�U Ð� íÄ Æ Ä Ð �\ Ã�È Ð� ��È Ðã ��È ÐÐ �;Â'È ÐD ��È ÐÛ �¯ôJôJô��àÂ'È Ð�pè�Û ��È Ð�pè D �õÈ Ð�lè�Ð È%�àèhÈ Ð�lèFã ��èhÈ Ð� &

�3|0mvjhs�g0j|��mvstmv~0�ymCjhuÄ Æ Ä Ð å Ä ½ Ä Ð �¯èFÃ�åTX ÐÐ ��È ÐD å¡X г �<ôJôJô���È Ð�lè�Û åYX Ð�lè�Ð È%�¯ÃæèhÈ Ð�lèFã ��èhÈ Ð� å�Â'X Ð�lèFã å$èhX Ð� È &¥æ¶�¤´I�©

��}Kfkf1no| m�n�c�dZu{e0w�w�}�~0g0u(Å+ã�}K~0gÃÅ@ÐyDBs{myutrzmy�qnoj¡�MmvfkxK¤i�1jkstu{n�c�m��ydK~0utjkg0mysÆÅ+ã�¤E��e �0u{ntjknte nojk~0�no| m�g mvÎF~0j¡nojkdM~0u�¥æ¶�¤³²M©�d��uÈ D D�Èl´�D%&�&�&yD�È/�lè�Û�DFw�dMu�ndK��nt|0m,utØ�eF}Ks{myu��}K~ �ymyf�D �Mj¡��jk~0�0�

Å+ã·�SèFÃ{åBX ÐÐ ��È ÐD å;X г �<ôJôJôb��È Ð�lè�Û å¡X Ð�lè�Ð È� è

Ã�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð �qå�Ã�X�ã���X D È Ð �SÃ�X D ��X0Û�È Ð å;ôJôJôb�SÃ�X$�lè�Ûð��X$�lè D È Ð å�Ã�X$�lè D ��X$�lèFãtÈ Ð �� è

Ã�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð � åTX Ð ã �;Â'X D Ã�X0Û!å¡X�ã�È%�<ôJôJô��àÂ'X$�lè�Û·Ã�X$�lè D å;X$�lè¾´yÈ+å7Â'X$�lè D X$�lèFã&å;X Ð�lèFã � &��mCw�}�x�~0dJcÝjk~0utmvs{nno|0m��zdMe0~0g0u���dMsÇX D jh~£nomys{w�u�dK�8X�ã�}�~0g3X0ÛJDz}K~ g£nt|0mCu{jhw�jkf¬}�s�zdMe0~ g0u��dMs~X�´JD�&�&�&yD�}K~ goX$�lè�Û!nod��Kjk�Km�}��=dMe ~0g���dMsÇÅ+ã1��stdMw6�zmyfkdJc,¤2�3|0m��zdMe0~ g¢�Mj¡�Mmvu3},ntmyfkmyu{�ydMr0jk�ute w£D�c�|0mvstm#}�fhf0nt|0m�w�jkg0g0fkm�ntmystw�u(��}K~ �ymyf dMe�n�¤1��m�}�fhu{dCc�stj¡nomBX$�lè D jh~�nomvstw�u�dK��X$�lèFã���stdMw}K�zdJ�MmK¤2��m,|F}��MmK�

Å+ã·� èÃ�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð � åTX Ð ã å7Â'X�ã�X D �;Â'X0Û�Ã�X D åYX�´yÈ%�<ôJôJôb�;Â9X$�lè D Ã�X$�pèFã1å¡X$�pè�ÛyÈ+å¡X Ð�lèFã �

ü èÃ�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð_È åBX Ð ã å�Â'X�ã�X D � è

Ãæè,åõâ�ã�ȪÃ�ç3åõâ�ã�È G Ã�X D ��X�´yÈ�Ã�X D å¡X�´yÈ%��SÃ�X�´ð��X�ÉqȪÃ�X�´(å¡X�ÉyÈ%�¯ôJôJô��SÃ�X$�lè�Û·�õX$�lèFãoÈ�Ã�X$�lè�Û(å¡X$�lèFãoÈ K å¡X Ð�lèFãWÊ

ü èÃ�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð_È åBX Ð ã å�Â'X�ã�X D å¡X Ð�lèFã � è

Ãæè,åõâ�ã�ȪÃ�ç3åõâ�ã�È2G X ÐD å;X Ð�lèFã�K�Êü çË G à ��Â#å�¿MÂ/â�ã;�;Â�Çhâ Ð ã å$è�â D ã È�X Ð ã �SÃ�å��MÂL�7è�ýhâ�ã1å�è�â Ð ã È X Ð�lèFã7K &��mvstm c�m�fkmvn Ë �*ëÂ#åõâ�ã�È Ð Ã�è�åYâ�ã�ȪÃ{ç�åõâ�ãoÈ(ntd�w�}Kl�m�nt|0jk~0�Mu�utjkw�r0fhmvsy¤

Page 45: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¶MI

�bm3~ d·c;�ydM~ utjkg0mysÇÅ@Ðy¤2�utjk~0� no|0m3mvØ�eF}�nojkdM~0u2��dMe ~0g�}K�=dJ�KmKD�c�m�w�}�xEc�stj¡nom3mq�Mmvs{x�no|0jk~0�jk~£ntmystw�u�dK�uâ�ã�}K~ g?X$�pèF㪤2�bm,|F}��Mm��

Å@Ð*� çÃ�Â#åõâ�ã�È Ð G èFÃ�Â?�þ�/â�ã1åõâ Ð ã È Ð ��èFëÂL�7è�â�ã1å¡â Ð ã È Ð å7 ë åYâ�ã�È Ð å�èFÃ�Â�È Ð K X Ð�lèFã

� çË Ã ��Â"�àÂ�è�Çhâ�ã1åÁ��ÂKÇ/â Ð ã å7ÇKÉhâ D ã �¯ç2ÌMÇ/â Û ã å�ÍKÂ/â ³ ã ��Çhâ ´ ã È�X Ð�lèFã &�bm,w�}�x�no| my~>�zdMe0~ gZnt|0m,~0dMs{w¨dK� Æ���xz�Ä Æ Ä Ð � Ä ½ Ä Ð �VÅ+ãd�VÅ@Ðü Ä ½ Ä Ð � çË Ã ��Â#å�¿MÂ'â�ãd�àÂKÇhâ Ð ã å$è�â D ã È�X Ð ã �

� çË Ã�ÂKÇMÇ/â�ã1å¨�Z��Â/â Ð ã å7ÇMÉhâ D ã �¯ç�ÌMÇhâ Û ã åiÍMÂ/â ³ ã �àÇhâ ´ ã È�X Ð�lèFã &Î Ï «¹Ð/��¯+¬k«¹0L°$ÑGÒÔÓy°C±

��mvstmic�mic�jkut|Qnod�ÎF~0gQ}K~ße0r0rzmys,�zdMe0~0gß��dMs¨Æ Ò Þ ã Æ�jk~Qntmystw�u,dK�~½ Ò Þ�V�½2D2X�ãqD�X$�lèFãªD}K~0g]â�㪤

�bm,|F}��KmK�½ Ò Þ�½Ó�\ G  Ã�X�ãoÈ Ð �; Ã�X Ð2å¡X�ã�È Ð �; Ã�X D å¡X ÐvÈ Ð �SÃ�X0Û!å¡X D È Ð �<ôJôJôb��à Ã�X$�p足�å¡X$�pè¾´vÈ Ð �; Ã�X$�lè�Û(å¡X$�l足qÈ Ð �¯Ã�X$�lè D åYX$�lè�Û�È Ð

�; Ã�X$�lè�Ð2å¡X$�lè D È Ð �à Ã�X$�pèFã1å¡X$�pè�ÐqÈ Ð ��èFÃ�X$��åYX$�lèFã�È Ð KÆ Ò Þ � Æ_�\ G  Ã�È�ãtÈ Ð �¯Ã�ÈKÐ�å¡È�ãoÈ Ð �à Ã�È D å¡ÈKÐqÈ Ð �à Ã�È�Û!å¡È D È Ð �<ôJôJô���¯Ã�È/�l足2åYÈh�lè¾´qÈ Ð �; Ã�Èh�lè�Û(åYÈ/�l足qÈ Ð �à Ã�È/�lè D å¡Èh�pè�ÛvÈ Ð

�SÃ�Èh�lè�Ð&å¡È/�lè D È Ð �à Ã�È/�lèFã+å¡Èh�lè�Ð�È Ð ��èFÃ�Èh��å;Èh�lèFãoÈ Ð K &

Page 46: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�µ

��d�nojk�ymCnt|F}�n�no|0mC�ydM~�nos{jh� e nojkdM~V}�n�no|0m��Mmvs{x)�ymy~�ntmys#dK�&m�}K��|Vjku�nt|0m�ut}Kw�mKDB}Ku�jhuno|0mC�ydM~�ntstj ��0e ntjhdK~)dK�+no| m�fh}Ku�nn�c!d�nomys{w�ud��1my}K��|@¤���e0� ntso}K�qnojk~0�0D0c!m��Kmvn��Æ Ò Þ � ÆÁåY½ Ò Þ�½Ó�� G Ã�ÈMÐ2åYÈ�ãoÈ Ð �; Ã�È D åYÈKÐqÈ Ð �; Ã�È�Û(åYÈ D È Ð å

å� Ã�X Ð�å¡X�ã�È Ð å� Ã�X D åYX ÐvÈ Ð å^Ã�X0Û�å¡X D È Ð K �<ôJôJôb��; G Ã�Èh�l足&å¡È/�lè¾´qÈ Ð �à Ã�È/�lè�Û�å¡Èh�p足ªÈ Ð �;Â�Ã�Èh�pè D åYÈh�lè�ÛvÈ Ð å

å� Ã�X$�l足2åYX$�lè¾´yÈ Ð å� Ã�X$�lè�Û(åYX$�l足vÈ Ð å<Ã�X$�lè D å¡X$�lè�ÛyÈ Ð K�; G Ã�Èh�lè�Ð&å¡È/�lè D È Ð �à Ã�È/�lèFã+å¡Èh�pè�ÐªÈ Ð ��è0Ã�Èh�!åYÈh�lèFãtÈ Ð å

å� Ã�X$�lè�Ð2åYX$�lè D È Ð å� Ã�X$�lèFã�åYX$�lè�ÐvÈ Ð å$è0Ã�X$��åYX$�lèFã�È Ð K &"Bmvn no| m�n�c�dZrF}�s{nou d��(nt|0jku �=mEóBãqD�nt|0mirF}Ks�n �ydM~�no}Kjh~ mygßdM~Áno| mEÎFstu�n ��dMe0s�fkjk~0myuvD�}�~0g

ó=Ð�nt|0m,rF}Ks{n3��s{dMw nt|0m,my~0g0uvDF�ydM~�no}Kjh~ myg>dK~Znt|0m,f¬}�u{n�n�c�d�fkjh~0mvuy¤�1jkstu{n c!m�jh~��Kmyu{ntjh�M}�nom�óBãq¤i��dMw�rF}Ks{jh~ �Znt|0mi�ydK~�ntstjk�0e ntjhdM~ u��zmvn�c!mymv~;X�ã�}K~0gmX0Û,c�j¡no|

no| dMutm ��stdKw�È�ã!nodîÈ�ÛJDFe0utjk~0��no|0m,u{e0�0u{ntjknte nojkdM~0u�c!m���dMe ~0g>}��=dJ�Mm�D0c�m�|F}��Mm��

Ã�ÈMÐ2å¡È�ãtÈ Ð �; Ã�È D å¡ÈMÐªÈ Ð �; Ã�È�Û(å¡È D È Ð åå� Ã�X Ð�å¡X�ã�È Ð å� Ã�X D åYX ÐvÈ Ð å^Ã�X0Û�å¡X D È Ð �

� â Ð ãÃ�Â#åõâ�ã�È Ð Ã�X0Û�å¡X�ãtȪÃ�X�ã;�;Â9X D �õX0Û�È &

��m�|0}J�KmCu{jhw�jkf¬}�smvØ�eF}�nojkdM~0u���dMs�nt|0m,dKno|0mvs�nomvstw�uyD �Mj¡��jh~0� �

óGã·� â�ãë åYâ�ã�È ÐÖÕ Ã�X0Û�å¡X�ã�È�Ã�X�ã;�;Â'X D �õX0Û�È%�SÃ�X4µ�å¡X0Û�ȪÃ�X0Û·�àÂ'X�´ð��X4µqÈ%�<ôJôJôb�

�SÃ�X$�lè D å¡X$�lè¾´vÈ�Ã�X$�lè¾´ð�;Â'X$�pè�Û¦�õX$�lè D ÈW×� â�ã

ë åYâ�ã�È Ð Õ X Ð�pè D åYX Ð ã �;Â9X D Ã�X0Û!å¡X�ãoÈ��;Â'X�´JÃ�X4µ(å¡X0Û�È%�<ôJôJô���;Â9X$�lè�Û·Ã�X$�pè D å¡X$�pè¾´vÈ ×y&

Page 47: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½0H

��e0� u{noj¡noe�nojk~0��nt|0m,�=dMe ~0g0u3��dMsÇX D DÊX�´JD;&�&�&yD c!mC|0}J�KmK�óGã)( â Ð ã

ë åYâ�ã�È ÐÖÕ X Ð�pè D å¡X Ð ã � èÃ�è,åõâ�ãoȪÃ�çåõâ�ãtÈ G Ã�X�ã;��X0Û�È�Ã�X0Û!å¡X�ã�È%�

�SÃ�X0Û·�õX4µvȪÃ�X4µ�å¡X0Û�È%�<ôJôJô��¯Ã�X$�lè¾´ð��X$�lè D ȪÃ�X$�pè D å¡X$�pè¾´vÈ K ×( â Ð ã ÃæÇ åi¿/â�ãd��â Ð ã ÈË Ã�X Ð�lè D åYX Ð ã È &

��stj¡nojk~0�HX$�pè D jk~Znomys{w�u�dK�uâ�ã�}K~0g?X$�lèFã(��stdMw¾}��=dJ�Mm�D0c�m�|F}��Mm��

óBã)( â Ð ãË Õ Ã�å�ÇP�j¿/â�ã�åõâ Ð ã È X Ð ã ��SÃæÇ#å7Ç|¿/â�ã;�;ÂKÉ|Í'â Ð ã å$ÂMÂ�¿/â D ã �àÇ|¿'â Û ã å^ç2¿/â ³ ã �sâ ´ ã È�X Ð�pèFã ×y&

�bmC~0dJc/�ydM~0u{jhg mys#ó=Ðy¤�� dKs��zdKno|>Ê@Ë�}K~ gêË�Dznt|0m�fh}Ku�n�n�c!d¢nomvstw�u }Ks{mCmvØ�e0}KfæD�|0my~0�vmno| mvx��y}K~0�ymvf+}K~0gZc�m�}Ks{m�fkmv� n3c�j¡no|��

ó=Ð*� G Ã�È/�lè�Ð2å¡Èh�lè D È Ð å� Ã�X$�pè�Ð�å¡X$�pèFãoÈ Ð K� G Ã�X$�lèFã1åYX$�lè D È Ð å� Ã�X$�lè�Ð2å¡X$�lèFãtÈ Ð K &

��u{jh~ ��no|0mCute0�0u�noj¡noe ntjhdK~0u�}Kfhs{m�}Kg�x)w�mv~�ntjhdK~0myg@D@c!mE�y}K~Ác�stj¡nomi}�fhf+dK�&nt|0jhu�jh~Ántmystw�u#d��~X$�lèFã}K~0g]â�ãª�

ó=Ð)� â Ð ãË Ã�Â�ÍK å�Ç´�MÉhâ�ã;�VÌ|¿�Éhâ Ð ã åi¿�ç�¿/â D ã �¯çyè0çãâ Û ã å^ç2Ìhâ ³ ã �sâ ´ ã È X Ð�lèFã &��m�w�}�x�~0dJc:�ydMwC�0jh~ m�nt|0myu{m�ntd��Kmvn�no|0m,g0mvutjkstmvg>�zdMe0~0g@�Æ Ò Þ � Æ_�Õ½ Ò Þ�½¬��óBãd�7ó�Ð?(Ú½ Ò Þ�½¬� â Ð ãË Õ Ã{å�ÇP�V¿/â�ã1åõâ Ð ã È�X�ã;�

�¯Ã�ÂKÇKý#å�Ì�Â�çãâ�ã��¯çJÂZ�´�hâ Ð ã åiÍ�è�ý/â D ã �àÂMÂKÉhâ Û ã å¨�|Í'â ³ ã �àÂ/â ´ ã È�X Ð�pèFã ×y&

Page 48: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�²

Ø º/� ¸ 1.Ù¦3W�.�P��ºÄÚÐ/«����W�.���¾±��dJc\�vdMw�myu�no|0m,my}Ku{xZrF}�s{n�¤&��m,�ydMwC�0jk~0mCjk~0mvØ�e0}Kfhj¡nojkmyu�¥æ¶�¤hHJLM©�}K~0gb¥æ¶ ¤kH·ÕM©ª¤Æ Ò Þ�� ÆÄ Æ Ä Ð � ½ Ò Þ�½<�7óGã;��ó=ÐÄ ½ Ä Ð �jÅ+ã;�jÅ@Ð

(Úâ�ã Ä ½ Ä Ð Ë ��â�ãvÃ�ÂKÇKý#å�Ì�Â�çãâ�ã��¯ôJôJôªÈ�X Ð�lèFã ��â�ãvÃ{å�ÇP�V¿/â�ã;�¯ôJôJôqÈ X Ð ãÄ ½ Ä Ð Ë �sâ�ãvÃ�Â�ÇMÇ#å¨�´��Â/â�ã��<ôJôJôqÈ�X Ð�pèFã �¯Ã ��Â#å�¿KÂ/â�ãd�<ôJôJôqÈ X Ð ã(Úâ�ãl&

�3|0jkuif¬}�u{nijk~0myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�x$�ymvs{no}Kjh~ fkxb|0dMfkg0u�c�|0mv~0mv�Kmys�ýF&kçQü�â�ã�ü¨ý ¤V�3|0m¢utw�}Kfkfhmvu{n�r=dKututjk�0fkm�Mst}Kr0|��vdM~0utjkg0mvstmygZ|0mvstm#jku�¿��*ç�Ç D }�~0g�}Kfkstmy}Kg x�¿µ�-çJÇ D{â�ãqÃRê�Ë�È*(^ýF&»ý|¿�D�utdCno|0jku�jku�}Kf¡c�}�x�u��}Kfkjhg@¤ Ó�2������� ���ÜÛ ¢Q£Z¤¦¥Z§¦¨© �|ª��/������«��+«�¬I­®14�/¯+°²±

�3|0jku>utmv�vntjhdM~SjhuZ�Mmvs{x¯utjkw�jhfh}KsZnod7no|0mQr0s{mv��jhdKe0u>dM~ mK¤¨��u>}K�zdJ�Mm�D#c�mQmqp�r0fkdMj¡n>no| mu{x�w�w�mvnts{xM¤�½�jhu,}K~Vmvjh�Kmy~��Mmv�vnodKs,��dKséâ�ãqÃRê�Ë�È�}Ku,}K�zd·�KmKDBdM~ fkx>~0dJc/c!m�|F}��Mm�}��vdMw�r=dM~ my~�nX���}K~0g£~0dîÈ/��DF��x�no| m u{x�w�w�mqnos�xM¤

&�&�& ª ª ª« « «

åTX�ã « « «ª ª ªX�� X�ã

ª ª ª« « «

X Ð « « «ª ª ªX D X0Û

ª ª ª« « «

X4³ « « «ª ª ªX�´

&�&�&X4µ

ª ª ª« « «

T T T T TU U UU UX$�pèFã X$�

&�&�&åTÈ�ã

ª ª ª« « «È�ã

« « «ª ª ªÈMÐ È D

ª ª ª« « «È�Û

« « «ª ª ªÈl³ Èl´ &�&�& ª ª ª

« « «« « «ª ª ª ª ª ª

« « «È/�lèFãT T T T TU U UU U

Èh� È/�oò=ã

Page 49: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�¶

�bm,g0mqÎF~0m,no|0m,�vdMw�r=dM~ my~�noudK� Æ$}KuÈ�ã·�ÕX�ãqí ÈKÐH� X�ãd�õX ÐÂ#å¡â�ã í È D �tX Ð�íÈ�Û��ÕX0Û·í Èl³H� X0Û·�õX4³Â#å¡â�ã í Èl´*�tX4³�í &�&�&Bí ¥æ¶ ¤kHJµ�©È/�lèFã¦�ÕX$�lèFã È/�?�\Â'X$�lèFã�å¡X$�lè�Ðyí Èh�oò=ã¦�tX$���õX$�lèFã�å¡X$�lè�Ð�&

À 8Á���W»i1��������¼��º��ÃÂ�«¹0�»Ä±�3|0m�~0dMstw�u�dK� ½�}�~0gøÆ$}Ks{mÄ X Ä Ð �  Ã�X Ð ã ��X ÐÐ �;Â9X ÐD �õX ÐÛ �<ôJôJôb��X Ð�lè D �àÂ'X Ð�lè�Ð �;Â'X Ð�pèFã �àÂ'X Ð� ÈoíÄ È Ä Ð �  Ã�È Ðã �;Â'È ÐÐ �sÈ ÐD ��È ÐÛ �¯ôJôJô��õÈ Ð�lè�Ð �õÈ Ð�lèFã �àÂ'È Ð� �àÂ'È Ð�oò=ã È &

�3|0m,g0j|��mvstmv~0�ymCjhuÄ È Ä Ð å Ä X Ä Ð �Sè0Ã�È ÐÐ å¡X ÐD �õÈ Ð³ å¡X д �¯ôJôJô���È Ð�pè D å¡X Ð�pè�Ð È+å�Â'X Ð�lèFã å�èhX Ð� �7èhÈ Ð� �7èhÈ Ð�tò=ã &¥�¶ ¤kHMH·©

��dMf¡��jh~ ��nt|0m,myjk�Mmy~���}Kfke0mCmvØ�eF}�nojkdM~0u

åBX$�lè�Ð'�þ�/X$�lèFã�å�Â'X$� � â�ã�X$�lèFãå�Â'X$�lèFã;�;Â'X$� � â�ã�X$�

��dMsÅX$�lè�Ð�}�~0gfX$��D�c!m�w�}�x�mªp�r0stmvutu�}Kfkf my~0g��vdMw�r=dK~0my~�nou�dK�@no| m�Kmy�vntdMstu�jh~¢ntmys{w�u!dK��â�ã(}�~0gX$�lèFãª� X$�pè�Ðß� Â#å�¿'â�ãd��â Ð ã åõâ�ã X$�lèFãX$� � Â

Â#å¡â�ã X$�pèFãÈh� � Â?�Ñ�hâ�ã&åYâ Ð ã åõâ�ã X$�lèFãÈh�oò=ã � Â?�7è�â�ã&åYâ Ð ã åõâ�ã X$�lèFãp&

Page 50: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½M½

�3|0mv~)no| m�fh}Ku�n3nomys{w�u�jk~)mªp�r0stmvututjkdM~�¥æ¶ ¤kHMH·©�}Ks{m

å#Â9X Ð�lèFã å$è/X Ð� ��èhÈ Ð� ��èhÈ Ð�oò=ã �  Ã�èP�àÉMýhâ�ã;�þ�Z�hâ Ð ã å�ÂKÇhâ D ã ��è�â Û ã ÈÃ�Â#å¡â�ã�È Ð X Ð�lèFã

�FdMs�ý�(Zâ�ã"(:ç��vmys�n�}Kjk~0f¡x!�´�hâ Ð ã å7ÂKÇhâ D ã ��è�â Û ã ü�ý ¤��3|�e0uvDzg stdMr0r jh~0��no| myutm,nomvstw�u�x�jkmyfkg0u�}fkd·c!mys�zdMe0~0g@D

å�Â'X Ð�lèFã å$èhX Ð� �7èhÈ Ð� ��èhÈ Ð�oò=ã ü Ç0Ã{çH�<ç�¿/â�ã�ÈëÂ#åõâ�ãoÈ Ð X Ð�lèFã & ¥æ¶ ¤kH·²M©

��d;g0m�}Kf�c�jknt|\no|0m�stmvw�}�jh~0jk~0��ntmystw�uÁdK~:no|0mbstjk�M|�nÁutjkg0m�d���myØ�eF}�ntjhdM~9¥�¶ ¤kHMH·©qD c!mw�}KlKm�X D mªp�r0fhjk�yj¡n�jh~Zno|0m�myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�myØ�eF}�ntjhdK~båBX Ð¦�;Â9X D å¡X0Û"�­â�ã�X D D }K~0g)}K�y�vdMstg jh~0�KfkxKDX�´Jí�&�&�&@í:X$�lè�Ðy¤ X D � X Ðð�õX0Û

Â�åõâ�ã íÅX�´�� X4³'��X4µÂ#å¡â�ã í�ôJôJôBí~X$�lè�Ð*� X$�lè D ��X$�lèFã

Â#å¡â�ã & ¥æ¶ ¤kHJ¶�©

�3|0mv~@DKu{e0�0u{ntjknte nojk~0��nt|0m�g0mvÎ0~0jkntjhdK~0u3¥�¶ ¤hH�µ�©�dK��ÈMÐyí:Èl³yí�&�&�&Bí:Èh�lè D D�w�dMu�n+dK� nt|0m�utØ�eF}Ks{myu1�y}K~0�vmyf�D

èFÃ�È ÐÐ åYX ÐD ��È Ð³ å¡X д �<ôJôJô��õÈ Ð�lè D åYX Ð�lè�Ð Èð�� è

Ã�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð �vÃ�X�ã;��X ÐvÈ Ð å^Ã�X Ðð�õX0Û�È Ð �SÃ�X0Û¦��X4³ªÈ Ð å^ôJôJôKå<Ã�X$�pè D �õX$�lèFãoÈ Ð �¥æ¶ ¤kH�½�©

� èÃ�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð � X Ð ã �àÂ'X ÐJÃ�X�ã1å¡X0ÛyÈ��;Â'X4³yÃ�X0Û!å¡X4µvÈ%�¯ôJôJô��àÂ'X$�lè D Ã�X$�lè�Û(å¡X$�lèFãoÈ+å¡X Ð�lèFã � &

�2fhjkw�jh~0}�nojk~0�\X Ð�}K~0ggX D ��stdMw9no|0m,myjk�Mmv~���}Kfke0m�myØ�eF}�ntjhdK~0u

åTX�ã;�þ�'X Ð(å�Â'X D � â�ã�X ÐåBX Ðð�àÂ'X D å¡X0Û � â�ã�X D

x�jhmvfhg u X Ð � ë åõâ�ãtÈ�X�ã;�;Â'X0ÛÃæè,åõâ�ã�È�Ã{ç�å¡â�ã�È (  Ã�X�ãd�õX0Û�È

Ãæè,åõâ�ãoÈ�Ã{ç�åõâ�ã�Èc�|0mvstm�nt|0m�jk~0myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�x�|0dKfhg0u�}Ku�fkdM~0��}Ku�ý�(Zâ�ã�(:çM¤(��dMs{stmvutrzdM~0g0jk~0�ijk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡nojkmyu�|0dKfhg���dMsX4³�í�&�&�&@í:X$�lè D ¤(�dKnom#nt|F}�n3no| m�g j��=mys{my~0�vmyuCÃ�X�ã1åYX0Û�È�íJÃ�X0Û(åYX4µvÈ�í�&�&�&@íJÃ�X$�lè�Û(åYX$�lèFãoÈ�}Ks{m,}Kfhf

Page 51: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�¹

~0mv��}�noj¡�Mm�¤���u{jh~ �£nt|0myu{m¢�zdMe0~0g0u,��dMsrX Ðyí:X4³�í�&�&�&@í:X$�pè D jk~�ntd)mvØ�eF}�nojkdM~�¥æ¶ ¤kH�½�©ªDGc!m�dM� n�}�jh~�}fkd·c!mys�zdMe0~0g@¤2�3| mCu{e0w¨jku�ntmyfkmyu{�ydMr0jk�K¤(�bm,|F}��KmK�

èFÃ�È ÐÐ å¡X ÐD ��È Ð³ å;X д �<ôJôJôb��È Ð�lè D å¡X Ð�lè�Ð Èü è

ëÂ#å¡â�ã�È Ð_È X Ð ã � èÃæè,å¡â�ã�ȪÃ�ç�åõâ�ãoÈ2G Ã�X�ã;��X0Û�È�Ã�X�ã1å¡X0Û�È

� Ã�X0Û·�õX4µvȪÃ�X0Û�åYX4µvÈ%�<ôJôJôb�SÃ�X$�lè�Ûð��X$�lèFãtȪÃ�X$�pè�Û�åYX$�pèFãoÈ K å;X Ð�lèFã Ê� èFÃæÇ,å\¿/â�ãd��â Ð ã È

ëÂ#å¡â�ã�È Ð Ã�è åõâ�ã�ȪÃ{ç�å¡â�ã�È Ã�X Ð ã åYX Ð�lèFã ÈÎ& ¥æ¶ ¤kH·¹M©

.�s{dMr0r0jk~0��X�ã�jk~bno| m¢fh}Ku{nC��}K�vntdMs�g0d�myuC~0dÁ|F}�stwÌnod£no|0m�jh~0mvØ�eF}Kfkjkn�xK¤ß��dMw�� jh~0mvg$c�jknt|�jh~��myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�x�¥æ¶ ¤kH·²M©!c!m,�Mmvnjk~£nt|0m,my~0gÄ È Ä Ð å Ä X Ä Ð ü è�â�ãªÃ{çMç�¿�å^çyè|Ìhâ�ã��þ�Mý/â Ð ã È

ëÂ�åõâ�ã�È Ð Ã�è,åõâ�ãoȪÃ�çåõâ�ã�È X Ð�lèFã ü â�ãvÃ{çKç�¿�å^ç�è|Ìhâ�ãtÈÃ�Â#åõâ�ãoÈ Ð X Ð�lèFã &

¥æ¶ ¤kHJL�©

Î Ï «¹Ð/��¯+¬k«¹0L° Ñ Ò Ó °C±�3|0m��ydM~�ntstjk�0e nojkdM~0u ntdf½ Ò Þ�½���s{dMwønt|0mE��dMe0s�myg0�Mmvu,�=mqn�c�mvmy~;åBX�ã#}K~0gmX�ã�jh~QÊ@ËZ}Ks{m

myØ�eF}�f@nod�no|0m,�ydK~�ntstjk�0e ntjhdM~£jk~?Æ Ò Þ�� Æ���stdMw9no|0m,myg �Mm,�=mqn�c�mvmy~�åBÈ�ã�}K~0ggÈ�ã�jk~3ê�Ë ¤��dMw�rF}Ks{jh~0�£no|0m��vdM~�nostjk�0e ntjhdK~0uC�zmvn�c!mymv~¡X�ã }�~0g;X0ÛCc�jknt|Qnt|0dMutm���stdKw È�ã�nodgÈ�Û�D+c!m

c�stj¡nom

�»�:Â�Ã�È�ã�å¡ÈKÐqÈ Ð �;Â�Ã�ÈMÐ2å¡È D È Ð �SÃ�È D å¡È�ÛvÈ Ð å^Ã�X�ã1å¡X ÐvÈ Ð å� Ã�X Ð�å¡X D È Ð å� Ã�X D åYX0Û�È Ð &�~0u{mys{ntjh~ ����stdKw myØ�eF}�nojkdM~0u�¥æ¶ ¤kHJµ�©�}�~0g�¥�¶ ¤kHJ¶�©��0s{jh~0�Ku

�»� åTâ Ð ãë åõâ�ãtÈ Ð Ã�X0Û!åYX�ã�È�Ã�X�ã;�;Â'X Ð'��X0Û�ÈH(^ýC&

�~^no|0mVut}Kw�mÁc�}�x<}�fhf#d�no|0mvs�myg0�Mmvu��=mqn�c�mvmy~tX0ÛÁ}K~ g«X$�lèFã�w�}�x^�zmÁ�vdMw�rF}Kstmvg@¤6�2g0�Mmvu�zmvn�c!mymy~�X$�lèFãC}K~ g¡X$�¢�ydM~�ntstjk�0e nom�}KuEw�e ��|;}Ku�myg0�Mmvui�=mqn�c�mvmy~õÈh��}K~0g¡È/�oò=㪤V�3|0m�dK~0fkxmqp��vmyr ntjhdM~7}�stm�nt|0m¢mvg0�MmvuE�=mqn�c�mvmy~¡È/�lèFã,}K~ gYÈh��}K~0gQno|0mvjhsEw�jksts{dMsCjkw�}K�Mmvu�dM~bnt|0m¢d�no|0mvsmy~ g)dK�uêË�D0c�|0jk��|Á}Ks{m,~0dKn��ydKe0~�nomys{�F}Kfh}K~0�vmyg>��xZmvg0�Mmyu�jk~>Ê@Ë�¤2�3|0myjks�ydM~�nos{jh� e nojkdM~£jhu

èFÃ�È/�lèFã�åYÈh�JÈ Ð � è�â Ð ã Ã�è åõâ�ã�È ÐëÂ#åõâ�ã�È Ð X Ð�pèFã &

Page 52: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�L

��dJcS��dMs�no|0m,g0j|�=mystmv~0�ym�dK�+no|0m,Ø�eF}Kg so}�ntjh� ��dMs{w�uvD0c�m�|F}��Mm,no| m��zdMe0~ g@�Æ Ò Þ � ÆÁåY½ Ò Þ�½^( è�â Ð ã Ã�è�åYâ�ã�È ÐÃ�Â�åõâ�ã�È Ð X Ð�lèFã ( É�è�â Ð ã

ë åYâ�ã�È Ð X Ð�lèFã ¥æ¶ ¤kH·ÕM©

Ø º/� ¸ 1.Ù¦3W�.�P��ºÄÚÐ/«����W�.���¾±��dJc\�vdMw�myu�no|0m,my}Ku{xZrF}�s{n�¤&��m,�ydMwC�0jk~0m�nt|0m,jh~ myØ�eF}KfkjkntjhmvuE¥�¶ ¤kHJL�©�}K~0gb¥æ¶�¤hH·ÕK©q¤Æ Ò Þ�� ÆÄ Æ Ä Ð ( ½ Ò Þ�½�� ´�ÛBÝ � b�¡Ð4è.Ý b � � X Ð�lèFãÄ ½ Ä Ð � Ý b �¬ã�ãW³4èFã�ÛÞÉ�Ý b ��kÐ4è.Ý b � � X Ð�pèFã

� â�ã Ã�Â#åõâ�ã�È Ð Ä ½ Ä Ð ��ÉKè�â�ã�X Ð�lèFãÃ�Â#åõâ�ãoÈ Ð Ä ½ Ä Ð �sâ�ãvÃ{çKç�¿�å^ç�è|Ìhâ�ãtÈ�X Ð�lèFã (Zâ�ãl&

�3|0m£f¬}�u{n�jh~ myØ�eF}Kfkjkn�x�|0dKfhg0u�}Ku�fkdM~0��}KuZçMç�¿iå*çyè|Ìhâ�ãZüÜÉKè�}K~0gsâ�ã£üÜý ¤7�3|0m)u{w�}Kfhfkmyu�nrzdMutu{jh�0fkmi�Mst}Kr0|Á�vdM~0utjkg0mvstmygß|0mvstmEjku���dMs�¿^�9ç�è0D�}K~0gV}�fhs{m�}Kg x3â�ã6ß*ýF&hçJÂ�ÍKý�Ì �z��dMs�fh}Ks{�Mmys�¿no| m�mvjh�Kmy~���}Kfhe myu�c�jhfkfG�=m u{w�}�fhfkmysv¤ Ó�?3Wà `�KP8ª��5��H>�Kâá�ã2KB��BVu �¦=L6kuüN$u ��67�ÖuÇ8%DC8;5

�~£nt|0jkuu{my�qnojkdM~@DFc�m�w�}KlKm nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ ��dM� utmys���}�nojkdM~@�

ä ��®T�·®����x�b��®��þ¯��Êî ��q¬¡�}y{�tZuxu·j ¡�}i}%h jlkEhv<knmpwx~�tZu¶hl}ik·{´m4tlgi³Re�¡�})¿Ì~Zhlmpknw j h e ²2Ê@˵³Ft�e­qJt�ó´wx¹qfo�qÙvZwntZq¬hlk9hlmì¾ ± ¡�m3¿ÁÀ:ÂAÃæÄ�Å�Æ)è�È4²�wxkHw¶e¼k�³ih¼o�}iwn½�oTh?{´mtlgi³!¸·wxkx³ØqJt�ó´wxqfo�qvZwntZq¬hlkEhlm�¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ1"Bmvn�á<|F}��Mm3g0jh}Kw�mvntmys J }K~ gEfhmqn~à �*à ÷ �Jí�&�&�&@í ÷ ÿ�ÈB�zm�}�g0jh}Kw�mvntmys�¥�}�c�}KfhlCdK� fkmy~0�Knt|J ©q¤(�3|0my~£no|0mvstm,��}�~0~0dKn��=m�}K~ dKno|0mvs�myg0�Mm��zmvn�c!mymy~)n�c�d��Mmvs{nojk�ymvu#dK�uà>¤!�2�Kmys�x£�Kmys�nomqp)|F}�ug0mv�Mstmvm<� D2}K~ gbno|0mvstmq��dMstm�no|0mvstm�}Ks{m J ���>mvg0�Mmyu�fhmy}J��jk~0�mà>¤£�3|0m¢�Kmys{ntmqp ÷ �iwCe0u{ni|0}J�Kmn�c!d�g jhu�nojk~0�vn�~0mvjh�K|��zdMs{uyDF~0mvjknt|0mys3dK�Bc�| jh��|£jhu�}�g�±{}K�ymv~�n�nod ÷ D D0}Ku�nt|0jku�c�dKe0fhgZ�vdM~�noso}�g0jh�qnBà�zmyjk~0��},g j¬}Kw�mqnomysvD }�~0g��=dKnt|�dK�=c�| jh��|�w�e0u�n��zm3dK�=g0jku{n�}�~0�ym}�n�w�dMu�n J ��stdMw ÷ ÿ�¤��bm�}Kr r0fkxno| m�uo}�w�m�}Kst�Ke0w�my~�n�}�n(no|0m�dKno| mys�mv~0g@¤2�3|0m��Mmys�nojk�ymvu ÷ D í�&�&�&@í ÷ ÿÎè D |F}��Mm��ydMfkfhmv�vntjk�Kmyf¡x J å>Émyg �Mmyufhmy}���jk~0�oà>D0no|�e0u�no|0mqxZg0mvntmys{w�jk~0m�}�nfhmy}Ku{n�à J å7É�È�õZ�E�Kmys{ntjh�vmyu#~ dKndM~3à)¤(�+dM�Mmqno|0mvsno| jhu�jku

Å J ��èL�Sà J å7É�È8õZ��ÆCö^¿ð&

Page 53: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�Õ

��m�}Ks{so}K~0�Kjh~0� D c�m��Mmqn J öIÃx�0Ãæ¿Zå7Â�È8õ�è�Äy&�3|0mvutm�}KstmEntjh�M|�n,��dMs,Ê@Ë�D@��dMs,}Kfkf&¿1¤i�+d)g mvnomvstw�jk~0m���dKs�c�|0jk��|b�Mst}Kr0|0u,myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�xß|0dMfkg0uyDBc!m��}�~Ág0so}�c*}¢g0jh}Kw�mvntmys#| dMstjk�ydM~�no}Kfhf¡xMD�g0so}�c-dM~0m�myg0�Mm�r=dMjk~�nojk~0��e0r)��stdMw¼m�}���|Á�Mmys�nomªp�¥�n�c!ddMe n#dK��no|0mimv~0g0u�©#}�~0gV�ydM~ ~0my�qn�nt|0mywøjh~Vu{e0��|�}¢c�}�x>nt|F}�n mv~0g0u,�Mmqn jhg my~�noj¡ÎFmygQjk~ßnt|0stmvmyuvDno| m�n�c!d,��stdMw*m�}K��|�my~0g�g0d,~0dKn(�Mmqn�jhg my~�noj¡ÎFmyg�D }K~ g�mv~0g0u�g0d,~0dKn��Mmqn(jhg0mv~�noj¡ÎFmyg�no|F}�n2c!dMe0fkgut| dMs{ntmy~bnt|0m�g j¬}Kw�mqnomysv¤��3|0mys{m¢jkuE}Ze0~0jkØ�e0m¢c�}Jxßntd)g0d£no|0jku�j¡��¿^À¨Â4ÃæÄ�Å�Æ)è�È�D&}�~0g���dMs¿ÁÀSýAÃæÄ�Å�Æ)è�È�DKc!m3�Mmvn&r0stmv�yjkutmyf¡x�}Kfkf�rF}�no|���fkjhl�m3�Mso}Kr |0u1c�j¡no|�}Kfkf �0e�n2dM~0m�� fhd���lCd��=u{w�}Kfhfkmyu�nutjk�ym�D0no|0m,s{myw�}Kjk~0jh~ ��� fhd���l��zmyjk~0��dK�1w�mvg0jhe w¨utjk�ym�¤!�3|�e0u3no| mystm�}Ks{m�Ãæ¿�å�è�È�õ�è�� fhd���l�u�}�~0gÅ8Ã�¿£åbè�È�õKÇbÆ�g j��=mys{my~�n��Kso}Kr0| u�c�j¡no|£w�}�p�jhwCe0w¾g0jh}Kw�mvntmysy¤ Ó

Page 54: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

O,+SN.-ß`VX£Þ ta"-VXÁO�`VÞ;N�WºX%å<`VÞ;XZ]_N ®�T7Þ X%å�OQW 1<Y<XZY

a�1¯­7[^ÞàN.-_+/a

tL34/ 0 GHDC5F@Ç��NLS�DF69@*G'>}K~�x��vf¬}�ututjk��}�f@stmvute0f¡nou3jk~�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf@�Kso}Kr0|�nt|0mydKs{x�u{noe g x¢nt|0m#w�}�p�jhwCe0w ~�e0wC�=mvs3dK�

myg �Mmyu>ë{ì+Ãæ¿�ítîÁÈ�}Kw�dM~0�Á}Kfhf!�Mso}�r0|0uiáÜdM~$¿;�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�c�|0jh��|7g0dV~ dKni�ydK~�no}Kjk~7}K~�x�dK��no| m�Mst}Kr0|0u�ï �-î }Ku�}Vute �0�Mso}�r0|@¤$�~7no|0jku���|F}Kr ntmysic�mZ�vdM~0utjkg0mvs¢}Áu{r=mv�vnost}Kf�}K~F}�fhdM�Ke0m�dK�ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�D2~F}Kw�mvfkx�c�m£}Ku{lQ��dMsCno|0m�w�}�p�jkw�e0w u{r=mv�vntso}Kf�st}Kg0jke0u�ð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿�ítîÁÈ,dK��Mst}Kr0|0uiádM~�¿^�Mmys�nojk�ymvuyD3dJ�Mmvs�nt|0mZuo}Kw�m£utmvn�dK���Mso}�r0|0uy¤:¥����î �_ù�ïQú�D�c!mZc�stj¡nom$ë{ì�Ã�¿1í�ïQÈC}�~0gð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�í�ïQÈ��dMs�ë{ì�Ã�¿1ítîÁÈ#}K~0g$ð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�D+stmyu{r=mv�vntjk�Kmyf¡xM¤´©:��rzmy�qnoso}�f(s{myu{e0fkntuE}Ks{m�u�nos{dM~0�Mmvsno|0}K~Eno|0m!�yfh}Kutu{jh�y}Kf0s{myute fkntuy�1��s{dMwÝno|0m���}��vn1nt|F}�n�no|0m3}��Kmyso}��Mm3g0my�Kstmym�uo}�ntjhu�ÎFmyu&nt|0m�jk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�xL�P��7�vÃæáiÈ!ö\â=ãªÃ«áEÈ�D0c!mCu{mym,no|F}�n ð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ!jhu�}K~£e0r0rzmys��zdMe0~0gZ��dMs3no|0m,mªp�ntstmvw�}�f�}��Kmyso}��Mmg0mv�MstmvmÁÂ�ôBë{ì+Ãæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õ�¿1D(dMs�myØ�e0j¡�K}�fhmv~�ntfkx7nt|F}�n�¿bôFð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õMÂÁjku¢}�~�e r0r=mvs��zdMe0~ g���dMsë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�¤,�bmig0mqÎF~0mino| m¬eEgih jlk m4tZu�v�hl}Felwxkn¢£ntd��=m¢âzãqÃæáiÈ8õ�¿1DG}K~ gQs{myw�}Ks{l)no|0}�n no|0jku jku,}K~e0r0rzmys��=dKe0~0g>��dMs�no| mCg0mv~0utj¡n�xÁd���áÜ¥�stmv��}KfkfGno|F}�nno| m�g0mv~0utj¡n�xÁdK�2}��Mst}Kr0|)c�j¡no|>¿��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu}K~0g!�Ümyg0�Mmvu�jku?�£õ � Ë Ð � ©q¤

�bm(�ydK~0utjkg0mysGn�c!d���e0~0g0}Kw�my~�n�}Kf���}Kw�jkfhjkmyu+dK� mqp��yfke0g0mvgEute0� �Mso}Kr |0u+îß�Bnt|0m(Î0stu{n+jku+c�| my~î �ydK~0utjku{ntuidK�3no|0m¢�ydMw�r0fkmvntm��Mso}�r0|$Ï�Ò8�2nt|0m¢u{my�ydK~0g$c�|0my~�î �vdM~0utjku{ntuidK�3no| m��ydMw�r0fkmvntm�0jkrF}Ks�noj¡nom��Mst}Kr0|$Ï�Ô8Ñ Ò�¤)�~$�=d�no|�dK��no|0mvutm���}�utmyuvD2no|0m¢}Ku{x�w�r nod�nojk���=dMe ~0g0uCc!m��Mmqn���dMsC¿Vôð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õMÂ�}Ks{mEno|0m�ut}Kw�m�}�u#no|0dMu{mi��dMs�ë{ì+Ãæ¿1í{îÁÈ�¤E�~Q�Mmy~ myso}�fæDGj¡n,jhu,~0dKn nt|0mi��}�utmino|F}�nno| mu{r=mv�vntso}Kf so}�g0jhe u(d��@} �Mst}Kr0|�}K~0g�jkntu!}��Kmyso}��Mm�g0my�Ms{mym�}Kstm3nt|0m�uo}Kw�mK��no| mu{r=mv�vntso}KfFst}Kg0jke0u��}�~$�=m�dK�}>fh}Kst�Mmvs�dMs{g0mys�dK��w�}K�M~0j¡noe0g m¢no|F}�~�jkntui}��Mmvso}K�Mm¢g0my�Ms{mym�¤ß� dKsCmªp0}�w�r fhm�¤Qj¡�3î�ydK~0utjku{ntu�dK��æ D D�nt|0m�r0}�no|�dK��fhmv~0�Kno|���}KfhdK~0mKD�j¡n!jku�m�}Ku�xinod�utmvmnt|F}�n�Â�ô�ë{ìBÃ�¿1í[æ D È�õ�¿��SÂ�¤1xMmqnð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�í[æ D È?� � ¿Zå�çM¤,��mEc�jhfkf1no|0}�n,�Mso}�r0|0u�c�j¡no|ßno|0mèç¼hlmÎhvZwxkXtZmpwxu�¢èé�¡�o�}�v�hvøÖ*mΡ gihlmpk ¢æ+ÒÓÑ ø�g jhu{�ye0u{utmygVjku���my�qnojkdM~£½0¤´Li�vdM~0u{ntjknte nomC}K~0d�no|0mvs3mqp }Kw�r0fkmK¤

½�Í

Page 55: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

½�I

�~$HJIK½0HKD@�1}�e0f&�+e0so�K~¨¥×Í�¹�§&g0mqnomys{w�jh~0mvgQnt|0mEmªp0}��vn ��}Kfke0mEdK�#ë{ì+Ãæ¿�í�Ï�Òkò=ãoÈo¤���m���dMe ~0gno|0}�n�nt|0m�e0~0jkØ�e0m�mqp�nos{myw�}Kf!�Mso}Kr |$jhu�nt|0m¢Ú���rF}Ks{ntjkntm��Mst}Kr0|�ó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈ c�|0dKutm�Ú,�ydKfhdMs��yfh}Kutu{myu|F}��Mm¢utjk�ym.Å ¿@õ�ÚXÆ£dMs^ÃÓ¿Bõ�ÚXÄ�¤Á��g �MmyuE�vdM~0~0mv�vn�}�fhf(rF}KjkstuEd����Mmvs{nojk�ymvu��=mvfhdM~ �Mjh~ �>nodÁg j��=mys{my~�n�ydKfhdMs��vf¬}Ku{utmvuy¤��3| mCg0mv~0utj¡n�xZdK�1óCÃ�¿1ítÚoÈ(jku�}Ku{x�w�r nod�nojk��}Kfkfkxßç�å^ç·õ·Úª¤(�~Z��}K�qnnt|0m,~�e0w��zmysdK�myg �Mmyujhu�~0mq�Mmvs�w�dMs{m,nt|F}K~QÃ{ç�å^ç·õ·ÚoÈ�� Ë Ð � ¤

�<jhf¡�=r0stdJ�Mmvg¢} u{r=mv�vnost}Kf �Kmystu{jhdK~�dK�z�+e0so��~@Ö»u�s{myute fknyD�u{|0dJc�jh~ ��nt|F}�n&nt|0m3g0my~ utj¡n�x��=dMe ~0g�Mj¡�Mmv~>��x��+e0so�K~�Ö»u�no|0mvdMstmvw¨|0dMfkg0u3no| m�u{r=mv�vntso}KfBg0mv~0utj¡n�x)}Ku�c!myfkfæ�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�n°¨Ë 9 �n��êÔë�îTúvì9Ð,Ò hlk1áÙ�lhAt¼{´m4tlgi³Ó¡�}�¿Ñ~Zhlmlknw j h e`}%¡�k�j ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{�Ï�Òkò=ã`t�eAteloF�X{´mtlgi³R²·k�³ihl}>âzãqëáEÈ!ö-Ã{ç�å�ç·õ·ÚoÈ�¿

�bm!myu�n�}K�0fkjkut|ino|0m(��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�#utrzmy�qnost}Kf��Kmys{utjkdM~�dK�F�+e0so�K~�Ö»u1nt|0mydKstmywZDKntjh�K|�ntmy~0jk~0���<jkf¡�yÖ×ustmvute0f¡n�}K~0g£g0mvntmys{w�jk~0jk~0��nt|0m,mqp�nos{myw�}KfG�Mst}Kr0|0uv¤

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊÉÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i�����d�bÏi�$�b�d��®T�b���ÑÐ�Ò hlk á �lhÓt_{´m4tlgi³Ñ¸·wxk�³�¿Ô~Zhlmpknw j h eµ}%¡�kj ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ�Òkò=ãAt�e­tfelo7�X{´m4tlgi³F¾JÕ�³ihl}

â=ãvÃæáiÈ(ö:âzãvÃæó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈtÈÎ&Ö�½�o7tZu�wxkn¢f³i¡�u�v�e`w ×AtZ}�vØ¡�}iu�¢Jw ×�áÙw¶e¼kx³ihØÕ7o�m4ÚZ}<{´m4tlgi³�Ï$Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈl¾¥«�#e0s3s{myu{e0fkn��ydKjh~0�vjhg myu�c�jknt|£�<jkfk�vÖ×u��zdMe0~0gZj¡�2}K~ g£dK~0fkx�jk��Ú�� ¿1¤´©

��dMut}KfBr0s{d·�Kmyg>}�w�dMs{m,�Mmy~0mvso}KfBs{myu{e0fkn���dMs�nt|0m,��}Ku{m�Ú·�:Â��

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ʯÌËkí!®��ì�i�,ë¶é���ìEÐ ýê×áw¶eAt¬knmlwntZ}y{´u¶hl¹ ×pmÎh hL{´m4tlgi³Ø¸·wxkx³J� hv�{Ch e ²�kx³ihl}âzã�ö � �_&

��u{jh~0�)'>}�~�ntmyf�Ö»u nt|0mydMs{mywÜno|F}�n }¢nostjh}K~0�Kfhmª����stmvmi�Mso}�r0|ßá �y}K~ß|F}��Mm�}�n w�dMu�n_à ¿ Ð õ�è�Ämyg �Mmyu�¥�nt|0jhu�jku���e0st�K~@Ö×u3no|0mvdMstmvw ��dMs�Ú��:ÂM©qD c!m�utmym nt|F}�n

â=ãqÃæáiÈ!öª� à ¿ Ð õ�è�Ä»�Ýâ=ãqÃ�ó�Ãæ¿1í�Â�ÈtÈÎ&�2stg0ÙMu8����ntdM~0m­¥×½�¹b§�}�~0g��2stg ÙMu��8��jhw�dM~ d·��j¡nou»¥ ½�²�§z�Mmv~0myst}Kfkjh�vmyg��+e0so��~@Ö»u!no|0mvdMstmvwAnodE}�~�x

~0dM~����0jkrF}Ks�noj¡nom(mqp��yfke0g0mvgiute0�0�Kso}Kr0|EïbDM}K~ g�jk~C��}K�qn�ntd#}K~�x�utmqn1î6dK�0~0dM~����0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntm!mªp �vfhe g0myg

Page 56: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹Kµ

ute �0�Mso}�r0|0uy¤��3|0mqx���dMe0~0g¢nt|F}�n(no|0m�}Ku{x�w�r ntdKnojk��g0mv~0utj¡n�x�d��@no|0m�Mst}Kr0|0u!~0dKn!�ydM~�n�}�jh~0jk~0�i}�~�x�Mst}Kr0|)ï �Áî¸}Ku}�ute0�0�Kso}Kr0|)g0myrzmy~ g0u�dK~0fkxZdK~)no| m�u{w�}Kfhfkmyu�n#��|0s{dMw�}�nojk��~�e0wC�=mvs�}�w�dK~0��Mst}Kr0|0u�ï �\îߤ$"Bmvniî �=mZ}Vutmqn�dK���Mso}Kr |0uyD!}K~0g7fkmvnLî�Ã�îÁÈ�g0mv~0dKnom�nt|0mµelo7�lj ³�mΡ�qJtZknw j}io�qJ�lhlm�dK�!îßD+dK~0m�fhmvutuCnt|F}K~Vno| m�w�jk~0jhwCe0wÌ��|0s{dMw�}�nojk��~�e0wC�=mvsCd����Mst}Kr0|0u,jk~Qîߤ��3|0mvxr0s{d·�Kmyg@�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�|È Ë9Û���ÀdÜ��lÝìÍ���®��d�RÝlÍ�� �Þ®��d®C�d�x�b�­�b�d�y®T�����ÑÐþkÿ ÄË�� � ë{ì+Ã�¿1ítîÁÈ8õ�w ¿ Â�x �*ç�å�ç·õ�î�Ã�îÁÈÎ&

��zî¨�ydK~�no}Kjk~0u�} �0jkrF}Ks�noj¡nom��Mst}Kr0|@DMnt|0my~�no|0m�mªp�ntstmvw�}�fz�Kso}Kr0| u2|F}��Mm�ý�g0mv~0utj¡n�xMD�}#��}K�vn2c�| jh��|}Kfkutd���dMfkfhdJc�u3��stdMw9no|0m�� ÙJ���Kstj �����Ku����+e0st�K~�no|0mvdMstmvw¨�=mvfhdJc,¤

�bm�ut|0dJc�no|F}�n1no|0m�g my~0u{jkn�xie r0r=mvs&�zdMe0~0gidK�=�2stg ÙMu��8��nodM~ mq����jhw�dM~0dJ��j¡nou2stmvw�}Kjh~ u&�K}�fhjkg}Ku�x�w�r ntdKnojk��}�fhf¡x�}Ku�}�utrzmy�qnoso}�fzg my~0u{jkn�x�e0r0rzmys(�=dKe0~0g@¤2�3|0jku�s{myu{e0fkn!u{ntstmv~0�Kno| my~0u�nt|0m���s{g0ÙMu8���ntdM~0mq�8��jkw�dK~0dJ��j¡nou�no| mydMs{mywZ¤2�bm,u{no}�nom,dMe s3stmyu{e0f¡n�¤

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�yxÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i�)Û���ÀdÜ��pÝìÍ���®����´ÝlÍ;�n�Þ®��d®C�d�x�b�­�b�d�y®��b���ÑÐþkÿ ÄË�� � ð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁÈ�õ�¿��-çå^çJõ�î�Ã�îÁÈ &

�-�0jhr0}Ks{ntjkntmC}�~F}KfkdM�Me0m nodint|0mCr stdM�0fkmyw �ydM~0u{jhg mystmvgÁ��x��+e0so�K~Zc�}Ku�rzdMu{myg>��x£?@}�so}K~��l�jhmqc�jh�v� jh~VH�I�¹�Hf¥×IMµ�§æ¤���m#}Kutl�myg���dMs ë{ì�Ã�¿1í�Ï�Ô8Ñ Ò«È�¥�|0m }��vnoe0}Kfhf¡x�dM~0f¡x�}Ku{lKmvgZ��dKs�¿Vö¯É�©q¤1�3|0mr0s{dM�0fkmywÜ|F}Ku��zmy�vdMw�m�l�~0dJc�~Q}Ku�nt|0mHy'tZm4tZ}{z�w hl¸·w j(|Lg�mΡZ��u¶hlq£¤�~bHJI�¹�½0D=� ÙJ�K��stj�D@���KuyD@}�~0g�+e0so�K~£��}��Mm�}K~£e0r0rzmys��zdMe0~0gZ��dMs�ë{ìGÃæ¿�í�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò«È�¤2�3| mvxZut| d·c!myg)no|F}�n

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�y�ÌËsë!ÜC�7ÏF���êÝlÍ�í��lÝÎ���d��Ï7�ïëy�7È�ìEÐ^Ò hlk3áß�lh�tØ{´m4tlgi³Á¡�}ß¿÷~Zhlmpknw j h e¬}%¡�k`j ¡�}i¹k tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ¢Ô�Ñ ÒLt�eAtJeloF�X{´mtlgi³F¾�Õ�³ihl}

Â#ô7����ëáEÈ���ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ô ¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &�3|0mvstm�jhu,~0d£utjkw�r0fkm�mªp�nostmvw�}Kf��Mso}Kr |�}�u jh~ßno|0mi�y}Kutm�dK�(�+e0so�K~�Ö»u,no|0mvdMstmvwZD�}�~0gßjkn�jku u{nojkfkf}K~£dMrzmy~£r0stdM� fhmvw¨��dMsB}��SÚ��Kstm�}�nomys3nt|F}K~)¶ D0c�|0mvnt|0mysdMs�~0dKn3nt|0jku�jku3no|0m��ydMs{stmv�vndMstg mys�dK�w�}K�M~0j¡noe g0mK¤2�n!jhu!�ydM~�±�my�vnte0stmvg�no|F}�n!nt|0jhu!�=dKe0~0g¢jku�}�u{x�w�r nodKntjh�y}Kfkfkx��ydMs{stmv�vn���dKs�}Kfkf.}#}K~0g¢Úª¤

�bm,r0s{dJ�Mm,no|0m ��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��utrzmy�vntso}Kf@�Kmys{utjkdM~>dK���3|0mvdMstmvw¾½0¤´L��

Page 57: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹�H

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�êé$ËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i��ë�Ü��7Ï7���êÝìÍ%í��lÝÎ�����bÏi�$�����y®T�b�C�¨Ð ý¶×á w¶e­tf{´m4tlgi³Ó¡�}Z¿$~Zhlmp¹knw j h e ²�}%¡�k?j ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ�Ô8Ñ ÒLt�eAtJeloF�X{´m4tlgi³R²�kx³ihl}

âzãvëáEÈ(ö-ÃtÃ�Ú&å�ç�È ã ç�Ô �$#�Ã{ç�ÈtÈ�¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &�#e0s �=dKe0~0gßjhu u�nos{dM~0�Mmvs#no|F}K~Vnt|0m�� Ù·���Ks{j¡�8���Mu8���+e0so�K~ß�zdMe0~0gQ}K~ gQjku dK��no| mi�ydMs{stmy�qn

dMs{g0mys,dK��w�}��M~0j¡noe0g0m�}K~ gb}Kfkutd)}Ku�x�w�r ntdKnojk��}�fhf¡xQ�ydMs{stmy�qn,c�|0my~0mq�Mmvs�no|0jku�jhu nos{e0mi��dMs,�3|0myd��stmvw¨½0¤»L ¤

�2stg0ÙMuJ¥×¶MI�§�}�~0g���jhw�dM~0dJ��j¡nou�¥´ÕKI�§2jh~ g0myrzmy~0g my~�nof¡xQut|0dJc!mygbnt|F}�n,�+e0so�K~�Ö»u no| mydMs{myw¦jkuu{no}K�0fkmEjk~>no|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��utmv~0utm���j¡��á�jhu }��Mso}Kr |)c�j¡no|V�yfkjkØ�e mE~�e0w��zmys#Ú�|F}���jk~0�Z}Kfkw�dKu{n }�uw�}K~�x£myg0�Mmvu }Kuno|0mC��e0st�K~Á�Mst}Kr0|)óCÃ�¿1ítÚoÈoDznt|0my~>��x£s{myw�dJ��jk~0��dM~ fkx)}���mqc-myg0�Kmyu���s{dMw¼á�Dj¡n3��}K~Z�zm w�}Kg0m,}Eute �0�Mso}�r0|ZdK�+óCÃ�¿1ítÚoÈo¤&�bm r stdJ�Mm no| m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��utrzmy�vntso}Kf=�Mmys{utjkdM~£dK�Gno|0jkustmvute0f¡n���dMs�Ú��:Â�}�~0gµ��¤�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊîÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i���ì���Fïð�n� �x�pñ��b�d�y®��b���ÑÐ�± ¡�m!tZuxu¦ò�üøýÌtZ}�v�×�¡�miÚ<� Â2¡�mJ��²kx³ihlm hPh4ó´w¶elk�e"tfj ¡�}Felk tZ}ikTô"�÷ô·Ã�ÚoÈ4²�eloij ³ kx³FtZkR×�¡�m"tZuxu´{´m4tlgi³Re&á ¡�}C¿�~Zhlmpknw j h e�}%¡�kðj ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{Ï�Òkò=ã­t�e¼tJelo7�X{´m4tlgi³R²�w ×�áI³Ft�e»eEgih jlknmtZu%mtRvZwxoRe»e�tZknw¶e�×p¢�wx}y{

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ�ä-Ã�ç�å�ç·õ�ÚoÈ�¿&Ã{ç�å�ò�È�íkx³ihl}$mÎhlq¬¡�~�wx}y{�tZk»q¬¡�elkPô�ôyòiô�¿ Ð hv�{Ch e�jtZ}$qJt9zRhiá°Úp¹¶gFtZmlknwxkEh�tZ}�v,mÎhlq¬¡�~�wx}y{�tZk»q¬¡�elkô!ô � ò#ôJ¿ Ð hv�{Ch e jtZ}ÓqJt9zRhá tJelo7�X{´m4tlgi³Ó¡9×`kx³ih<ÕFoCm4ÚZ}<{´m4tlgi³�ó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈl¾

�#e0s�fh}Ku�n�jk~��Mmyu�nojk��}�ntjhdM~)n�}Ks{�Mmvntu�Kso}Kr0| uc�j¡no|^³ihlmÎhvZwxk tZmpwxu�¢��l¡�o�}�v�hv<tZ~Zhlm4t�{Ch�g0my�Ms{mym�¤"Bmvn�Ú^� � �A}�~0g2�:ä å¬� Òkò=ãÐ�� ¤/��mV�ydM~ utjkg0mysZ�Mst}Kr0|0uZáºc�| jh��|¯|F}��MmVno| m¼çAhlmÎhvZwxk tZmlwxu�¢é�¡�o�}�v�hvîÖ*mΡ gihlmlkn¢(æ+ÒÓÑ ø��

����ëïQÈ���ö�Ú1ô7����ÃæïQÈ��l�¨�·í c�ï ö<á�íf�\�¢ÃæïQÈ��Mä�Úp& ÃWæ+ÒÓÑ øqÈ��,no|0m>utmvn¢î�ÒÓÑ ø��ydK~0utjku{ntu�dK�C}Kfhf�Mst}Kr0|0u�Ï dM~<}�n�fkm�}Ku�n�Ú��Mmys�nojk�ymvuZ��dKs�c�|0jk��|r���¢ÃæÏ�ÈVüÚ3ô;����ëÏ�È��´�M��D2no|0mv~7�Mso}Kr |0uic�jknt|7nt|0m£�2stdMrzmys�n�x�æ+ÒÓÑ ø�}Ks{m�mqp }K�qnof¡x�no|0dKutm�c�|0jk��|àg0dß~0d�n�ydK~�no}Kjk~�myfkmyw�my~�ntuidK��î }Ku�})ute �0�Mso}�r0|@¤Á�dKnojk�ym�no|F}�n)ë{ìGÃæ¿�ítîÁȼ� Ú8¿!� ��D�c�| mystmy}KuEno| m�Mst}Kr0|£Ï�ÒÓÑ Ë�è�Ò1|F}�u�nt|0m��2stdMrzmys�n�x�æ+ÒÓÑ �}K~0g£|F}Ku�utrzmy�qnost}KfBso}Kg jhe0u�� Ú8¿£å�Ú Ð ¤

Page 58: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹M²

�3|0m,nostj¡��j¬}�fBe0r0rzmys��=dKe0~0gZdM~Vâ=ã�jhu

âzã�ö � Â��°ö � Ú8¿¬�¨��íc�|0jk��|>�y}K~)�zm,jhw�r0s{dJ�Mmyg>}ifhj¡ntntfhm,e0u{jh~0��}�stmyu{e0f¡n�d��&�dM~0�!¥´¹�I�§Bnod��Mj¡�Mm��

â=ã�öª� ëÂ�Ú1å;ç�È�¿��¯ç�&��m ut|0dJc:nt|F}�n���dKs��Mso}�r0|0u�c�j¡no|Z|0mys{myg0j¡n�}�stjkfkx��zdMe0~ g0mygZg0mv�MstmvmKD0no| m �yd�mOn��yjkmy~�ndK� � ¿V�y}K~�zm�u{jh�K~0jkÎ0��}K~�nof¡xZjkw�r stdJ�Mmvg@¤

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊúûÒ hlk!Ú¬�ü� �ÇtZ}�vØ��ä°å¬� Òkò=ãÐ � ¾�ý¶×Cáßw¶eØtØ{´m4tlgi³þ¡�}ß¿ÿ~Zhlmpk w j h e�¸·wxkx³�kx³ihç¼hlm hvZwxk tZmpwxu�¢Lé�¡�oC}�v�hvîÖ*mΡ gihlmpk ¢(æ+ÒÓÑ øl²Hk�³ihl}â=ãªÃ«áEÈ(ö*Ã�Ú1å;ç�È�õMÂ?��� Ã�Ú��¯ç�È�Ú��;Â��?� � Ú8¿�í

tZ}�v�t�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw jtZuxu�¢�²â=ãqÃæáiÈ!ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�È8õMÂ"� � Ú8¿��$#�Ã{ç�ÈÎ&

Õ�³ihAt�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw j­�l¡�o�}�v�w¶e¼k w|{�³�k ¾�bm�}Kfhu{d#ut| d·c�no|0}�n1nt|0m�e0~0jkØ�e0m3mqp�ntstmyw�}Kf��Mso}�r0|���dMs'�`�*å � Òkò=ãÐ � jhu1nt|0m��Mst}Kr0|E|0}J��jk~0�

Ú��Kmys�nojk�ymyudK�1g0my�Ms{mym,¿�å^çMDF}�fhfBdKnt|0mys{u�dK�1g my�Ms{mym Ú,¥�jk��¿ßö<ÚªD�no|0mv~£nt|0jhujku2±�e u{n�Ï�ËM©q¤��u)}��vdM~0u{myØ�e0my~ �ym�dK��no| jhu£stmvute0f¡n�D#c!m�dK� n�}Kjk~<no|0mß��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�à�zdMe0~ g0u£��dKs£�Kso}Kr0| u

mywC�=mvg0gF}K� fhm�dM~)}Kst�0j¡nost}Ks{x¢ute0s���}K�ymvuy¤� ®T��®��n�n�F�bñ¨Èd�n°�üÒ hlk&á �lh tf{´m4tlgi³_hlqJ�lhvRvRtR��u¶h ¡�}^t¨��óChvJeloCmx×ìt�j h�¡9×�Ö*oCu¶hlm�j ³FtZmt�jlkEhlmp¹w¶elknw j æ ¾�Õ�³ihl}

â=ãqÃæáiÈ*(Sç)��� É0ëÂ#å æ È%� � �K¿�ítZ}�v�t�el¢�q�g�k9¡�knw jtZuxu�¢�²

â=ãªÃ«áEÈ)(Sç*� � ��¿J�$#�Ã{ç�ÈÎ&�3|0jku�jkw�r0stdJ�Mmvu�e0rzdM~Zr0s{mv��jhdKe0u��zdMe0~ g0u3��dMs�}KfkfBute0s���}K�ymvudK� n�}Kjk~0mvg)��x£��dK~0�!¥»LMµ�§«¤

Page 59: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹K¶

tL3 � ð���5{�HGBò"6s8��þ69S�ñ�>�5C@HO¨�s8Ku�bm,mvu{n�}��0fhjkut|£no|0m ��dMfkfkd·c�jk~0��utrzmy�qnoso}�fG}K~F}KfkdM�Me0m,dK�+no| mC� ÙJ���Kstj �����Mu�����e0st�K~�no|0mvdMstmvwZ�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�êé$ËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i��ë�Ü��7Ï7���êÝìÍ%í��lÝÎ�����bÏi�$�����y®T�b�C�¨Ð ý¶×á w¶e­tf{´m4tlgi³Ó¡�}Z¿$~Zhlmp¹knw j h e ²�}%¡�k?j ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ�Ô8Ñ ÒLt�eAtJeloF�X{´m4tlgi³R²�kx³ihl}

âzãvëáEÈ(ö-ÃtÃ�Ú&å�ç�È ã ç�Ô �$#�Ã{ç�ÈtÈ�¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &

ò"������� ó»&9-�)¹���Y�� "!Ê&/v+b -Þô� ���#��(�Ê u0�1jkstu{nyD0c�m,�vdM~0utjkg0mvs�}K~£m�}�u{x��y}Kutm,c�|0jk��|>jkfhfke0u{ntso}�ntmyu�no|0m,jkg0m�}idK�+no| m�r std�dK�8¤

ä ��®T�·®����x�b��®��¨Èd�n°�° ý¶×áùw¶e$õ�Û�¹ ×pmÎh h ²Hk�³ihl})âzã�ö �  Ã�¿�å^ç�Èl¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ�"Bmvn¬à �øÃRà Y Y�È��=mino| m�g0jh}K�MdK~F}Kf&w�}�ntstj pQdK��g0mv�Mstmvmyu�dK�3á�DKö>no| m�¿¨]Q¿7jhg0mv~�noj¡n�xw�}�nos{j¡p=D�}K~0gV÷�nt|0m�¿�]b¿7w�}�nostj pQdK��}Kfhf�çMÖ×uy¤¢��dKntjh�vm�nt|F}�n�no|0m)à a{íEc È�my~�nos�xßdK��U Ð jhu,no| m~�e0w��zmys!dK�B�vdMw�w�dK~�~0myjk�M|��zdMstu!dK��a1}K~0g cZ¥�jk��að�ÑcFD�nt|0my~�j¡n!jhuB±�e0u{n!no|0mg0mv�MstmvmJ©q¤&��m�|0}J�KmU Ð ö�àû�SÃk÷�å\öFÈoD c�|0mvstm,no|0m,jk~0myØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�x)jku��yd�dMstg jh~F}�nomq�«c�jhu{mK¤��n���dMfkfhdJc�u3no|F}�n��

â Ð ã �Ýâzãvà U Ð È!ö:â=ãªÃRà£È%��â=ãqÃk÷ZåXö0È�ö-Ã�¿�å^ç�È%�SÃ�¿�å�ç�ÈÎ& Ó5!x�}�w�dMs{m��y}Kstmq��e0f myu{ntjhw�}�ntm�dK��â=ãqÃnU Ð È�c!m���}�~�dM� no}Kjh~ � ¿Zå�ç�}Ku!}K~¢e0r r=mvs��zdMe0~0g@¤

��m,c�jkfkfBe0utmC}iw�dKstm,��}Ks{mv��e0fG}�~F}Kf¡x�u{jhujk~Znt|0m,�Mmy~ myso}�fB��}Ku{mC�zmyfkdJc,¤�bm(e0u{m!no| m(��dMfkfkd·c�jk~0��~0dKn�}�nojkdM~�¥ ��dMs�ø Ô\ù�çMí�&�&�&@ío¿+ú�}K~0gr½Ó�4Ã�X�ãqí�&�&�&@í:X0Ë�È Ò �Á� C Ë ©q�

Å<ù û � IY ä ù X7Y«íÅ øù û � G IY ä ù X7Y K ø

í

æ/ùZÃn��È(û � IY ä ù X øY &�#w�jhu{utjkdM~>dK��ø jk~0g0jk��}�nomyu�no| m�mv~�nojkstm,utmqn�j¡nou{myf¡�8¤

�bm�~0dJc�myu�n�}K�0fkjkut|$utdKw�m¢fhmvw�w�}KuCc�m�c�jhfkf!~ mymyg�¤>�3|0m�r0std�dK��u�d���no|0m�ÎFstu�n�n�c!dV}Ks{mu{ntso}Kjk�M|�nt��dKs{c�}Kstg@�0c!m�stmv��mvs�no|0m,s{m�}Kg0mvs3nod�¥»L�¹�§«¤

Page 60: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹�½

Í �C�Þ�Þ��È��n°�Éû± ¡�m"�µt¼gi¡�elwxknwx~Zh`wx}ikEh {ChlmAtZ}�v²ø Ô\ù�çMí�&�&�&@ío¿+ú´²H¸)h�³FtZ~Zh

G°IY ä ù X7Y K øöÔ�úø � ø4èFã IY ä ù X øY í wn¾nh�¾�² Å øù öÔ�ûøI� øèFã æ�ù�à ��È &Í �C�Þ�Þ��È��n°�¯ûÒ hlk2½ �lhAt�}%¡�}i}%h {ytZknwx~Zh�~Zh jlkE¡�mβ*tZ}�v W_tZ}�v°ó }%¡�}i}%h {ytZknwx~Zh»mÎhtZu�}io�qJ�lhlmÎe�¾

Õ�³ihl}

G¬IY ä ù X þY�K G¬IY ä ù X �Y7K öÔ�úø � IY ä ù X þtò �Y í wn¾nh�¾�² æ/ùZÃXW�ÈBæ/ù�ÃRóyÈ!öÔ�úø � æ/ù�ÃXWP�sóyÈ &�bm�c�jkfhf�~0mvmygbnt|0m¢�éFJ���Kstj �����Mu�����e0st�K~Qe0r0rzmys��=dMe ~0gbdM~ßno| m�w�}�p�jkw�e0w ~�e0w��zmys�dK�

myg �Mmyujh~£}�Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò¬����s{mym �Mst}Kr0|�nod�dM� no}Kjk~£nt|0m ��dMfhfkdJc�jh~ �0�Í �C�Þ�Þ��È��n°RÈ�Ò hlk�á �lh!tØ{´m4tlgi³$¡�}Q¿û~Zhlmpknw j h e<}%¡�k­j ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{ZÏ¢Ô8Ñ Ò9¾bá ³Ft�eØtZk»q¬¡�elkÃ�Ú�å^ç�È ã ç�Ô ¿ ãEèFã ç�Ð�Ô ~Zhlmpk w j h e­¡9×Av�h {´m h h¼tZk*u¶ht�elk+¿ ãEèFã ç�Ð�Ô ¾Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ2��+áÝ|F}�g¢w�dMstmno|F}�~¢no|0jku�w�}K~�x��Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�dK��no|0jku�g0mv�MstmvmKD�no|0mv~�jkn!c�dKe0fhg¢|F}��Mm#w�dMs{mno|0}K~bÃ�Ú1å;ç�È ã ç�Ô ¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô õMÂEmyg0�MmvuyD w�dMstm nt|F}K~£}Kstm�}Kfkfkd·c!myg)��x��3|0mydKstmyw¾½ ¤´L ¤ Ó

�bm c�jkfhfG}�fhu{d�~0mvmyg£no|0m#��dMfkfkd·c�jk~0��jh~ myØ�eF}Kfkjkn�xz�Í �C�Þ�Þ��È��n°¾xûÒ hlk V tZ}�vrS �lh`vZw¶e ��¡�wx}ik'eloF�le�hlkxe­¡9×�ù�çKí�&�&�&@ít¿�úC¾ ± oCmpkx³ihlmβ¦u¶hlk�W_tZ}�vróf�lhgi¡�elwxknwx~Zh`wx}ik9h {ChlmÎeAtZ}�vJe�hlku}��MW��só�¾�Õ�³ihl}

G IY äýü X þY�K G IY ä�þ X �Y K öÔ� V.� þç�Ô �³SØ� � ç�Ô IY äÁü�ÿ?þ X ÔY íwn¾nh�¾�² æ ü ÃXW�ÈÞæ þ Ã�óyÈ�öÔ� V.� � ç�Ô �³S<� þ4ç�Ô æ�à }�ÈÎ&Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ(�3|0jku��dKfhfkdJc�umy}Kutjkf¡x���stdMw �TFMfkg0mysvÖ»u�jk~0myØ�eF}�fhj¡n�xMD c�|0jk��|>jk~)dMe s3��}Ku{m�jkw�r0fkjhmvunt|F}�n

æ ü ÃXW�È!öÔ� V.� � ç�Ô æ ü ÃR}KÈÎ&

Page 61: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹M¹

ò"������� � ��� Ñ �è<'&9-9-]>$&ã!'4�@�0�bm�u{n�}�s{n&��x��ydK~0utjkg0mys{jh~ �,nt|0m��y}KutmÇ}��:Â�DK~F}Kw�myf¡xCnt|0m��y}Kutm�dK�F�Mst}Kr0|0u&~ dKn1�vdM~�n�}Kjk~0jk~0�

no| m��vdMw�r0fhmqnom#� jhrF}�s{noj¡nom�Mst}Kr0|�Ï�Ð{Ñ ÒB}Ku!}Cu{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|@¤&��m�c�jhfkf=r0}Jx�u{r=mv�yjh}Kf�}�ntnomv~�nojkdM~�ntdCno| mmys{stdMs ntmystwZ¤��~ßno| m�~0mªp�n�u{my�vntjhdK~bc�m�c�jkfhf��ydK~0utjkg0mys�no|0m��y}Kutmf}£ü�ÂZ}K~0gßc�m�c�jhfkf�~0dKn��zm�ydK~0�ymvst~0mvg)c�j¡no|£fhdJc!mys���dMstg mys�nomys{w�uy¤

�bm,r0s{dJ�Mm,no|0m ��dMfkfhdJc�jk~0��no|0mvdMstmvw£�

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�n°¶�ð�ñ ë{ìGÃæ¿�í�Ï¢Ð{Ñ Ò«È*( � Ã�Ú�å^ç�È ã ç�Ð �$#�Ã{ç�È � ¿ ã ç�Ð &Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ���m,c�jkfkfG}K�vnteF}Kfkfkx�r stdJ�Mm,no|F}�n

ð�ñ ë{ì�Ã�¿1í�Ï�Ð{Ñ Ò«È*(\Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð � ç D ç«Û Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç«Û ¿ ã ç«Û � ç

 ã ç�Ð &��m�fkmvn�á¨�zm�}Z�Mst}Kr0|QdM~�¿$�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuC~0dKn��ydM~�no}Kjh~ jh~0�>Ï¢Ô�Ñ Ò�D�}K~0gQfhmqn�½;�=m�}Z~0dM~0~ my��}�ntjk�Kmmyjk�Mmv~��Kmy�qnodMs���dMs3âzãvëáEÈ�¤&�3|0m�no|0mvdMstmvw9��dMfkfkd·c�u!��x¢�zdMe0~0g jh~0�Cno|0m#mªp�r0stmvututjkdM~Áâ Ð ã � Y X ÐY ¤&��mw�}�x�stmqc�stj¡nom,no|0jku}Kuy�

â Ð ã I Y X ÐY � I Y Ã8âzã�X7YæÈ Ð � I Y G I[(ÉFY Xy[ K Ð � I Y J YèX ÐY � I Y��µR[ J Y\[`X7YÌXy[ ¥�½ ¤hH·©

c�|0mvstm J Y=jhu(no|0mg0mv�Mstmvm�dK�=�Mmys�nomªp�a�}K~0g J Y\[�jku�no|0m�~�e w��zmys�d��B�ydMw�w�dM~�~0myjk�M|��=dKstu�d��;a1}�~0gcF¤1�+d�u{jhw�r0fkjk� x,nt|0m�~0d�n�}�ntjhdM~C}�fkj¡ntnofkmKD�c�m(c�jhfkf�e utm�æ÷� � Y X ÐY }K~0g²æ ü �Oæ ü ëÂ�Ȧ� � Y äÁü X ÐY ¤��m���}�~Ájhw�w�myg j¬}�ntmyf¡xÁ�Mmqn }¢s{m�}Ku{dM~F}K� fhmC�=dMe ~0gVdM~)nt|0jku#e0utjk~0��dK~0fkx£no| mC��}K�qn�no|0}�n J Y·(S¿}K~0g J Y\[�(;Ú åVçMD���xi��jks{nte0m�d��=nt|0m��}��vn�no|F}�n�á\g d�mvu(~ dKn(�ydM~�n�}�jh~¢Ï¢Ð{Ñ Ò�¤2�utjk~0�E"Bmvw�w�}�½0¤hH�¶c!mCw�}�x�jkw�w�mvg0j¬}�nomyf¡xZ�ydK~0�yfke0g0m��

â Ð ã æ÷� I Y J YèX ÐY � I Y��µR[ J Y�[`X7YÌXy[�(;¿<æ.�SÃ�Ú�å^ç�È�¿<æ�(;Ú8¿�æ3íjkw�r fkx�jk~0��no|F}�n�âzãL(¯Ú ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð ¤C¥��3|0jku#jku#}K~F}�fhdM�KdMe0u�nod��2s{dMr=dKutj¡nojkdM~Á½0¤kHMHM¤´©���d��vdMsts{my�qn�no| m�ydK~0u{no}K~�nntd>Ã�Ú1å;ç�È ã ç�Ð D0c!m,~0mymvg)nod�mªp0}�w�jk~0m,no|0m n�c!d�ntmys{w�u�}ifhj¡ntntfhm,w�dMs{m��y}Kstmq��e0fkfkxK¤

�bm�c�jhfkf=r0}Ks{ntjkntjhdM~�no|0m��Kmys�nojk�ymyu3d��+á/jk~�nodi}�u{mvn��\dK�B�Kmys�nojk�ymyu�c�j¡no|�| jh�M|¢g0my�Ms{mym }�~0g}iutmqn�dK�+�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�c�jknt|)fkdJcÝg0my�Kstmym�D }K~0g£utr0fkj¡n�dKe0s�nomvstw�u�e r)jk~�nod�w�e0f¡nojkr0fkmCr0}Ks{ntuy¤

"Bmvnßà � �  Ã�Ú@å7ç�È�¿ � ã ç�Ð }K~0g����-ù6Xµ���Aû J Ã�X�È(ü«à£ú�}K~0g�ø �M�Z¦��C¤&��m�no| my~�yfh}Kjkw no|0}�n�/��}K~ ~0dKn��zm,ntd�d��0jk�0¤

Page 62: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹KL

� �n�7� � Èd�n° ��J��ö ��Â�¿@õ Ã�Ú�å�ç�È � ã ç�Ð ¤��d�r0stdJ�Km)no| m>�yfh}KjkwZD�fhmqno�÷� �����1}K~0g;}Kutu{e0w�m)nt|F}�n¢á¸jku�f¬}K�zmyfkmyg;utd�nt|F}�n�� �

ù�çMí�&�&�&@í:�Bú�¤¸"Bmvn,ö`YYÔ ú ¿*ûE�zm�no|0m�u{mvnßdK��~0mvjh�K|��zdMs{uVdK�JatDCnt|0my~Ýnt|0mb��}Kw�jkfkx:dK��utmvntuù�ö�ã�í�&�&�&Bí öÔ��úZ|F}KuEnt|0m�r0s{dMr=mvs{n�x�no|F}�ni}K~�x�n�c!dßw�mvw��zmys{u�jk~�nomvstutmv�vn�jk~7}�nEw�dMu�n£Ã�Ú�åÝç�ÈrzdMjh~�ntuy¤��3|�e0u3no|0m e0~ jhdM~£dK��}K~�x3U�u{mvnou�wCe0u{n�ydK~�no}Kjk~>}�n�fhmy}Ku{nTàõ�<ÃRà4åQÚoÈ��^ôJôJô��^ÃRàAåÃ7U�å-ç�È�ÚoÈ,myfkmyw�mv~�ntuyD�c�| my~0mq�MmysgU^ö Ã�Â�¿Bõ�ÚoÈ ã ç�Ð ¤��3|�e0u�nt|0m���}Kw�jkfkx$d���u{mvntu��y}K~0~0d�n�|0}J�KmÃ�Â�¿Bõ�ÚoÈ ã ç�Ð w�mywC�=mvstu�}Ku

G  Ã�·Ú8¿+È ã ç�Ð å<ÃtëÂ�¿Bõ·ÚoÈ ã ç�Ð å^ç�È�Ú K Ã�Â�¿@õ�ÚoÈ ã ç�Рü;¿'& Ó��dJc�}Ks{w�mygßc�jknt|�no| m�w�}�p�jkw�e0w¸~�e0wC�=mvsCdK�(�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�c�j¡no|Qf¬}�st�Mm�g0mv�MstmvmKDGc�m�w�}Jx

�ydKw�r fhmqnom#no| m r0std�dK�8¤1��m utr0fkj¡n�no|0m#Î0stu{n�u{e0w�w�}�nojkdM~ZdM~�no| m#stjk�M|�n{��|F}K~0g�u{jhg0m,dK�!¥�½0¤kH·©!jk~�ntdn�c!d�rF}�s{nou

I Y J YÌX ÐY ö^¿<æ� ���à*æ/ùö^¿<æ� ��à ã ç�Ð Ã�Ú&å�ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð æ�ùZí

c�|0mvstmCnt|0m,ÎFstu�n�ntmystw¾jku�no|0m�g0dMw�jk~F}K~�n�ntmys{w£¤���dJc,D=e utjk~0��nt|0m���}��vn�no|F}�n J Y\[#ö<Ú2å^çMDFno| mutmv�ydM~ g>ute w�w�}�ntjhdK~)�zmy�vdMw�myuy�

I Y��µR[ J Y\[%X7Y Xy[�ö-Ã�Ú1å�ç�È IY¬Ñ [ ä X7YÌXy[·�SÃ�Ú1å^ç�È IY¬Ñ [ ä�� X7YÌXy[·�; Ã�Ú1å^ç�ÈkÅ� <Å �ö-Ã�Ú1å�ç�È ��æ�ùM�¯Ã�Ú�å^ç�È�¿�æ� ��;Â�Ã�Ú�å^ç�È%� � ¿<æ� �Ã�Â�ÈBæ/ù�Ã�Â�Èö-Ã�Ú1å�ç�È�¿<æ/ùM�; ã ç�Ð Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð æ� ��SÃ�Ú&å�ç�È � � ¿<æö-Ã�Ú1å�ç�È�¿<æ/ùM�; ã ç�Ð Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð æ� ��; ã ç«Û Ã�Ú&å�ç�È D ç«Û ¿ D ç«Û æ3í

c�|0mvstmino|0mEÎ0stu{n ntmys{w¦|0mys{mijhu�}Kfkutd�nt|0m�g0dMw�jk~F}K~�n nomvstwZ¤���m�}Kstmi~0dJc*g0dM~0mij¡�(c�m�jk�M~0dMs{mnomvstw�u2dK�zfkd·c!mys2dKstg0mvsyD�}Ku2¿�æ� )�ÁÃ�Ú�åZç�È�¿�æ/ù¨ö-Ã�Ú�åZç�È�¿�æ\}K~0g�}Kfkf d�no|0mvs&nomys{w�u�}Kstm�d��=fkdJc�mvsdMs{g0mysv¤!�dJc�mq�MmysvD ��x���e s{no| mys}K~F}Kf¡x�utjkuyDFc!m�w�}�x�g0mqnomvstw�jh~ mCno| m�mvsts{dMs3w�dMstm,r0s{my�yjkutmvfkxz�

â Ð ã æ4ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�È�¿<æ$�Õ�  Ã�Ú�å^ç�È�¿�æÌ�; ã ç«Û Ã�Ú1å�ç�È D ç«Û ¿ D ç«Û æö G Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð � ç

 D ç«Û Ã�Ú1å^ç�È ã ç«Û ¿ ã ç«Û � ç�  K Ð æ"&

Page 63: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹MÕ

�3|�e0u�c�m�|F}��Mm�ut|0dJc�~Zno|F}�n,âzã)(\Ã�Ú1å�ç�È ã ç�Ð ¿ ã ç�Ð ���¢Ã�Ú ã ç«Û ¿ ã ç«Û Èo¤ Óò"����� � ���

� Ñ �è<'&6-'-?>$&ã!'4�@.0�­�d�y®T����� Èd�n°7é

ð�ñ ë{ì+Ãæ¿1íoÏ¢Ô8Ñ Ò�È*(\ÃtÃ�Ú&å�ç�È ã ç�Ô �þ#�Ã�ç�ÈtÈ�¿ ãEèFã ç�Ô &Ö*mΡ�¡9×OÏ&��mstmyu�nos{jh�qn�dMe0s{utmvfk�Kmyu�ntdCno| m��y}Kutm�}Cü^Â�D�}Ku�no|0m��}�utmé}��:Â�jkuB±�e0u{n!�3|0mydKstmyw9½0¤kHJL ¤

â Ô ã æ�ÃR}KÈð� ËI Y¶µ=ã Ã8âzã�X7YæÈ Ô � ËI YÒµ=ã G I[(ÉFY Xy[ K Ôö

ËIY b µ=ã ôJôJô ËIY�� µ=ã J à a8ãqí�&�&�&@ía�ÔoÈ�X7Y b ôJôJô�X7Y �c�|0mvstm J Ãna�ãªí�&�&�&@íÎa«Ô�È�jhu�no| mC~�e0wC�=mvs�dK�1�ydMw�w�dM~>~ myjk�M|��=dMs{u�d��1no| m»}�¥�~0dKn�~0my�vmyu{uo}Ks{jhf¡x>g jhu8�nojk~0�qnª©��Kmys�nojk�ymyu?a8ãªí�&�&�&Bía�Ô�¤2��Bno|0m�Mmvs{nojk�ymvu}Kstm�g0jhu�nojk~0�vnyD�nt|0jhu�jhu3}�n�w�dMu�n�Ú�åbçMD dKnt|0mys�c�jhu{m#j¡n��}�~¢�zm�}�n!w�dMu{n!¿1¤��bm�c�jhfkfzut|0dJc^no|0}�n!c!m~0mymvg�dM~0f¡x��ydM~0u{jhg mys!nt|0m��}Ku{m�c�|0mv~¢no|0m¨}v��nte0r0fkmà a8ãqí�&�&�&�íÎa�ÔoÈ(jhu�g0jku{ntjh~ �vn�D u{|0dJc�jh~0��no|F}�n

ËIY b µ=ã ôJôJô ËIY � µ=ã J à a8ãªí�&�&�&@íÎa�ÔoÈ�X7Y b ôJôJô X7Y � ö-ÃtÃ�Ú&å�ç�È%�$#�Ã{ç�È{È�¿ ÔEèFã æ�à }�È�í ¥�½ ¤³²M©

}K~0gZno|�e0u��vdMw�r0fhmqnojk~0��nt|0m,r0std�dK�+dK�+no|0m nt|0mydMs{mywZ¤�bm��0s{m�}Kl�nt|0mCu{e0w¼e0r>jk~�nod�n�c�d�rF}Ks{ntuy¤��3| m�ÎFs{u{n�rF}Ks�n�jku�}�fhfBu{e0w�w�}�~0g0u���dKs�c�| jh��|

no| m�}v��nte0r0fkm��ydM~0u{jhu�nou!dK�2}g0jhu�nojk~0�vn!�Mmvs{nojk�ymvuyD }K~0g�c�m��}Kfkf0no| jhu �������������! "� ¤2�FdMs&nt|0myu{m�}v��nte0r0fkmyuvDno| mE~�e0w��zmys#d����ydMw�w�dM~V~0mvjh�M|��zdMstu�jhu }�n#w�dMu{n�Ú�}K~0g>nt|0jhu�ute0wÜw�}Jx)�zm��zdMe0~0g0mvgß}K�zd·�Km��x

I�!���#�#���� $� ö-Ã�Ú1å^ç�ÈËIY b µ=ã ôJôJô ËIY��Rµ=ã X7Y b ôJôJô X7Y��3ö-Ã�Ú�å^ç�È�¿ Ô9èFã æ�à }�Èoí

��x)"Gmvw�w�}�½0¤hHJ²�¤��3|0m�rF}�s{nc�|0jh��|Vs{myw�}Kjk~0u�c!m��y}Kfhf � �!%&�!'(������������ $� ¤��3|0jhu�w�}Jx)�zmC�zdMe0~0g myg}K�zdJ�Mm,��x

I��%&�!'(�!���#�#���� $�ö w } x ËIY b µ=ã ôJôJô ËIY � à � µ=ã ËI[(µ=ã J à a8ãªí�&�&�&�íÎa�ÔEè�ÐyíEc È�X7Y b ôJôJô X7Y � à � X Ð[ &

Page 64: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹KÍ

�3|0jku�jku��vfhmy}Ks��zmy�y}Ke0utmCjk�2nt|0m°}y�«noe0r fhmCjhu�~0dKn�g0jhu�nojk~0�vnyD=nt|0mys{m�jku�}�n�fkm�}Ku�n#dM~0mCmyØ�eF}Kfkj¡n�xMD@}�~0gno| jhu!��}K~�|F}Kr0rzmy~�jk~ � ÔÐ � c�}�x�uy¤2��mc�jkfhfzut| d·c<nt|0jhu(jku"#�Ãæ¿ ÔEèFã È�D�no|�e0u!�ydMw�r0fkmvntjh~ ��no|0m�r0std�dK�8¤

"Bmvn)�/�=m no| mCu{mvn�dK�1�Kmys{ntjh�vmyuc�jknt|>g0mv�Mstmvm�}�nfkm�}Ku�n�à �:¿ ãEèFã ç�Ð�Ô D }K~0g>fkmvn��6�=m,no| mutmqn�dK��s{myw�}Kjk~0jk~0���Mmys�nojk�ymvuy¤�5!xß"Bmyw�w�}£½ ¤hH�½ D�c�m�utmvmino|F}�n<���J�Bö¨Ã�Ú�å:ç�È ã ç�Ô ¿ ãEèFã ç�Ð�Ô ¤E��m~0dJc<utr fhj¡n�my}K��|�dK�@nt|0m�u{e0w�u�e0r�jk~�nod�r0}Ks{ntu��ydKststmvutrzdM~0g0jk~0�Entd*�:}K~0gØ��D }�~0g¢no| my~�e0u{m�no| m��}K�qn3no|F}�n�jk�1}�n3fkm�}Ku�n�dM~0m#�Kmys{ntmqp£jku���stdMw ��D nt|0my~�nt|0m ~�e0w��zmysdK�+�ydMw�w�dM~Z~0mvjh�M|��zdMstu��y}K~�zmC}�n�w�dKu{nTà>¤���mv~0�ym,no| m�u{e0w¨jku��=dMe ~0g0myg>}K�zd·�Km,��x

ËIY b µ=ã ôJôJô ËIY � à � µ=ã X7Y b ôJôJô(X7Y � à � ËI[(µ=ã X Ð[ ö�à%Å Ô9è�Ð æ�Ã�Â�È���¿�Å ÔEè�Ð æ� 1ëÂ�È &�3|0m ÎFs{u{n�nomvstw¨jku��zdMe0~ g0myg£��xà%Å ÔEè�Ð æ4ö�ࢿ Ô9è�Ð æ�à }�Èð�M#�Ãæ¿ Ô9èFã ÈBæ�ÃR}�È &�3|0m,utmv�ydM~ g)nomvstwZDF�ydK~0utjku{ntjh~0��dK�1}KfhfBmvfhmvw�my~�nou���stdMw+��DFjku��=dKe0~0g0mvg)��x

¿�Å ÔEè�Ð æ� +Ã�Â�È!ö^¿�� ÔEè�Ð æ� +à }�È!ö #�Ã�¿ Ô9èFã ÈÞæ�à }�È &�3|0jku��vdMw�r0fkmvnomvunt|0m,r0std�dK��dK�+no|0m no| mydMs{mywZ¤ ÓtL3�� `fNL5-,HG/.�B�D7KL8;@�5F8Ku

�bm,s{myu{no}�nom�}K~ g)r0s{dJ�Mm�dMe0s3utrzmy�qnost}KfG}K~F}KfkdM�Me m�d��1�+e0so��~@ֻu3nt|0mydMs{myw

�­�d�y®T����� Èd�ÊÉÌËÎÍ%�·��ÂZ���b�i�����d�bÏi�$�b�d��®T�b���ÑÐ�Ò hlk á �lhÓt_{´m4tlgi³Ñ¸·wxk�³�¿Ô~Zhlmpknw j h eµ}%¡�kj ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{EÏ�Òkò=ãAt�e­tfelo7�X{´m4tlgi³F¾JÕ�³ihl}

â=ãvÃæáiÈ(ö:âzãvÃæó�Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈtÈÎ&Ö�½�o7tZu�wxkn¢f³i¡�u�v�e`w ×AtZ}�vØ¡�}iu�¢Jw ×�áÙw¶e¼kx³ihØÕ7o�m4ÚZ}<{´m4tlgi³�Ï$Ãæ¿�ítÚoÈl¾

�bm c�jkfhf@Î0stu{nr0s{dJ�Mm,no|0m no| mydMs{mywZD0no|0mv~)c!m,g0mys{jk�KmCu{dMw�mC�vdM~0utmvØ�e0my~0�vmyuv¤

Page 65: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

¹KI

ò"� � ��� ó»&6���O<©�O<#�@u-�0%4�-65�#7&6!$)La 1�&10Ê ¥#�@u-6��&6-h��bm�}KgF}Kr�n�?=x�lKdJ�zÖ»u�r0std�dK�BdK�@��e0st�K~@Ö×u�no| mydMs{mywÙ¥»I�Hì§&¥�utmvm }Kfkutd<¥×ÍMµb§ ©ª¤���m�u{|0dJc�mvg�no|F}�n

j¡��á9g d�mvu�~0dKn��ydK~�no}Kjk~VÏ�Òkò=ã}�u#}�u{e0�0�Mst}Kr0|@D no| my~>nt|0mys{mEjhu�}�Ú���rF}Ks{ntjkntmC�Kso}Kr0|>ï c�j¡no|V}�nfkm�}Ku�n�}Ku#w�}K~�xÁmvg0�Mmyu�}Ku#á�¤���mie utmygVnt|0mijhg m�}�dK�(u{x�w�w�mvntstjk�yjk~0�0�#n�c!dZ�Kmys�nojk�ymyu,jk~Qá }Ks{m��}�fhfkmyg$el¢�qfq¬hlk mpw j�j¡�3no|0mqxb|0}J�Km¢no| m¢uo}�w�m¢utmvnEdK�3~0mvjh�M|��zdMstuv¤ß��x�w�w�mvnos{jh�vjh~ ��}£�Mmys�nomªp ÷nod¢}��Kmys{ntmqp��Áw�m�}K~0u�nod¢s{myw�dJ�Mmi}�fhf+myg0�Kmyu���s{dMw �ß}K~0g)nod�}�g0gV}KfkfGmyg0�Mmvu��zmvn�c!mymv~��ß}�~0g�Mmvs{ntjh�vmyu�}Kg�±{}K�vmy~�n3nod ÷ ¤2���á4g0d�myu3~0dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~£Ï�Òkò=ãqD nt|0my~£}�� ntmys3u�x�w�w�mvntstjk�yjk~0�0DFno| m ~0mvc�Mst}Kr0|£ïÌ}Kfkutd�g0d�myu3~0dKn��vdM~�n�}Kjk~)Ï�Òkò=㪤!?=x�lKdJ��u{|0dJc�mvg)no|0}�n3j¡n�jhu�rzdMutu{jh�0fkm nod�u{x�w�w�mvntstjk�ymute �y�ymvutu{jk�Kmyf¡xbnodZr0s{d�g e0�ym�}��Mso}�r0|Qï jk~Qute0��|b}�c�}�xÁno|0}�nCï jku Ú���rF}�s{noj¡nom�}�~0gQï |0}Ku,~0d��mvc!mys mvg0�Mmvu#no|F}K~ßá�¤(2V�+e0so�K~�Ö»u#nt|0mydMs{myw¼no|0mv~V��dMfhfkdJc�u#��xV}K~Vmy}Ku{xÁ}K~F}Kf¡x�utjku dK�(�ydMw�r0fkmvntmÚ���r0}Ks{ntjkntm �Mso}Kr |0uy¤

"Bmvn~½>�zm} ~0dM~0~0mv��}�ntjk�Km�Kmy�vntdMs!}Kutu{d��vj¬}�ntjh~ ��} c�mvjh�K|�n"X7Y nod,m�}���|��Mmvs{ntmqp�at¤1��m�ut|0dJcno|0}�n�jkn(jku�r=dMu{utjk�0fkmntd�u�x�w�w�mqnostjk�ymnod,dM� no}Kjk~¢}#Ú���r0}Ks{ntjkntm3�Mso}Kr |¢ï¨c�j¡no|0dMe�n!g my�ys{m�}Ku{jh~ �Cno| mØ�eF}Kg0st}�nojk� ��dMstw }�nß½2D0j�¤»m�¤hD ½ Ò U ã ½�äZ½ Ò U�V.½¦&�#e0sZ��rzmy�qnost}Kf#�+e0so�K~^nt|0mydMs{myw c�jkfkf�no|0mv~^��dMfhfkdJc°��x�}K~F}Kf¡x��yjk~0�$no|0mV�vdMw�r0fhmqnomVÚ���r0}Ks{ntjkntm�Mst}Kr0|0uC¥æ"Bmvw�w�}�½0¤kHJI�©q¤

"Bmvn­ö­V&à ÷ È��zm�nt|0m�utmvnCdK��~0myjk�M|��=dKstu�dK� ÷ jk~bá�D�}K~0g¼�?V1à ÷ È�� � Y ä�354 �Òù � X7Y!�=m�no| mc!myjk�M|�nomyg�ute w4dK� no| m3~0myjk�M|��=dKstu2dK� �Mmvs{ntmqp ÷ ¤���m�c�jkfhf r0stdJ�Mm3nt|0m���dMfkfhdJc�jk~0�,fhmvw�w�}�D�utjkw�jkfh}Ksnodint|0m�}Kr0r0s{d�}K��|£dK�2?=x�l�d·�zDFc�j¡no|Zno|0m,dM�0u{mys��K}�nojkdM~)d��&�2stg ÙMuC¥�utmvm���d�dKnt~0dKnom dK~Znt|0jkur0}K�MmJ©ª�Í �C�Þ�Þ��È��n°�îûÒ hlk�áß�lh<t<{´m4tlgi³,}%¡�k¼j ¡�}ik tZwx}iwx}y{�Ï�Òkò=ã�t�e�t�elo7�X{´m4tlgi³R²»tZ}�vµu¶hlk"½ü�lh�tgi¡�elwxknwx~ZhL~Zh jlk9¡�mì¾�Õ�³ihl}<kx³ihlmÎh`h4ó´w¶elk�e�t�j ¡�q�g�u¶hlkEh�Úp¹¶gFtZmlknwxkEh�{´m4tlgi³Cï kx³FtZk·v�¡�qfwx}�tZkEh e(á ¸·wxkx³mÎh eEgih jlkAkE¡^k�³ih!¸)hlw|{�³�kEhv,elo�q ¡9×Ø}%hlw|{�³F�l¡�m e!wx}Ìkx³ih<e�hl}Fe�h!kx³FtZkI� ã à a�È£ä�?V1à a�È4²�×�¡�m�tZuxua�����²*tZ}�v ½ Ò U ã ½�äZ½ Ò U�V.½¦&Ö�½�o7tZu�wxkn¢f³i¡�u�v�e`w ×AtZ}�vØ¡�}iu�¢Jw ×�á �� ïÁ¾687:9<;>=@?BA CED1FG=<=>H-IEJ>C�FLK8M1NOCLPQ=@?RKSFLK8MUT<9WVXFLM1YRC[Z \R]�^E_�CGKSK`J>aOCG=Zb�c!^ed:fEg1K8=>FLKShji�k lnm&doI�g1=phpJ>M�K[qLg1K`JRM1M�Nr

qGNO=>soJtau=>ToC�K8FG?@J@qLN=RsUqLgvJ@qxwyM�KSzRFGK8KQr$M�=>h�NOsvJ@qLK8C�{|d1N�k KRkd on}`~������*on�E~#��� d�H�=RF�JtaOa ����� k

Page 66: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� µ

�3|0m�utrzmy�yjh}KfG��}�utm�dK�u½_�;º:� jhw�r0f¡x�jh~ � J Y;�Ä�?V&à a8È3}K~ g?½ Ò U�V.½��:Â,ô7� �¢Ã«áEÈ��O�0��}�~>�zmjk~�ntmys{r0stmqnomyg>}Ku��=x�lKdJ�zÖ»ur0std�dK��dK����e0st�K~@Ö×unt|0mydKstmywZ¤Ö*mΡ�¡9×`¡9× Ò hlqfqJtW��¾�Îo�Ï��3|0mutmy�vdM~0g��vf¬}�jhw6dK�=no|0m�no| mydMs{myw6��dMfkfhdJc�u(jhw�w�myg0jh}�ntmyf¡x���s{dMwAno| mÎFs{u{n�¤���~0g mymyg��$½ Ò U�V.½Ó� � Y X7Yr�?V&Ãna�È�¤

�bm,r0s{dJ�Mm,no|0m,fkmyw�w�}���xZjk~0g0e0�qnojkdM~@¤`�FdMs�Ú��-ç�j¡njhu3ntstj¡��jh}Kf�¤�BmvnÚ�ü/ç:�=}�~0gÁ}Ku{ute0w�m�no|0m�fhmvw�w�}�jhu�nos{e0m���dKs�}�fhfBÚB��(^Úª¤p�Bmqn ÷ �#�zmC}��Mmvs{nomªpÁu{e0��|

no|0}�n �?V&à ÷ Èjku w�}�p�jhwCe0wZ¤��BmvnA���,�=mEnt|0miutmqnCd��!~ myjk�M|��=dMs{u dK� ÷ �<�G}�~0gßfhmqnA�@ãP�r�ª¦��$��¤� x�w�w�mvnos{jh�vm�}�fhf0~ dM~���~ myjk�M|��=dMs{u2dK� ÷ �2nod ÷ �J¤[��}Kfkf nt|0jhu��Mst}Kr0|�Ï�¤��3| m�Kso}Kr0|�ϼg0dMw�jk~F}�nomvuá*c�j¡no|)stmyu{r=mv�vn�nod�no| m,c!myjk�M|�nomvg>u{e0w¨dK��~0myjk�M|��zdMstuv¤���~0g mymyg��c��µ������û ö­V1Ã��@ÈŤ ö/��Ã��@È�í c�|0jk��|>jkw�r fhjkmyu �U��Ã��BÈ(ä+�?V1Ã��@È@� ¥�½ ¤´¶�©}K~0gZ��dMsÇ�����@ã@���|�)�X <¡B�o¢Ç�U��Ã��@Èð�O�U��à ÷ �yÈð�O�?V&à ÷ �vÈ!ä+�?V&Ã��BÈ�£

���R¤Cá��¦¥��§¤!���*¨!©�¥�ª:«� :¬��®­:¯�° ±�²�³�©�´R�n³µ¥u¶®·���¸G·$�¹ :º�¨!­»±#²-³�©�´n�R¨/¼r�¦±#²½¼*�� :¨�¤��-��n³-ªB�n¨[±�²*·$�� o«!��©�²-´@�X :²�ªB�R³5¾>£�¼r�[³�­¿�n¨�²-­:¤[�X <¡B�U°§À� :¨[ W¨8©�¥�ªB«! :¬��E�u­:¤!���n«S�U±#¨8�p�U±�¤!� ÷ �[¤��-�ªB«! :¬��Á¼Â��­B©�º�³Á´n­B²u¤� :±#²®°§À�Ã�Ät£¹�p�Å©�¨�¥u¶�±#²�³-©�´R¤!±#­B²Æ¤!���n«8��±#¨) Ç´R­Bȧ¬�º��R¤��»É"Ê�ËÍÌoÎGÏ&¬X o«8¤�±�¤��ªB«! :¬��µÐ �¦­B²½¡:�n«S¤��>ÑÒ¨!�>¤�·��¹¯"­:«)�U�-±#´@�X�UÓ í ÉGÔQιծ�UÖ í ÉGÔQÎW¯"­B«¦ :º�º�Ô¹×Ø·$�<£Ù���>¤ÚÐ ¥��§¤��-�´n­:È*¬-º#�>¤���ÊÛÏ&¬X o«8¤�±�¤��)ªB«! :¬���­B²�¡B�R«8¤!�>Ñ»¨!�>¤W·$��Ü�·EÄ>�-¯"­:«!ȧ�n³�¥u¶� :³oÝS­:±#²�±�²�ª* :º�ºE¡B�R«8¤�±�´n�R¨�­o¯[·��¤�­Ú :º#º5¡B�R«8¤!±#´R�n¨U­:¯�·�Ät£�¸GÐ+±#¨�¨8±#ȧ±�º� o«!º�¶Ù­B¥-¤� :±�²��n³Ù¯"«8­BÈ°ޥŶ߫!�R¬�º# :´n±�²�ªÚ¤��-��n³�ª:�n¨pªB±�¡B�R²�¥Å¶¼r���U±�¤���¤����)�R³�ªB�n¨U¯"«!­:ÈàР�<£O¾

�p���¦ªB«� :¬-�áÐâ¨! o¤�±�¨8ãX�R¨�¤!���)´n­B²-´nº�©�¨!±�­B²�­o¯�¤!���)º#�RÈ*È* -¢�UÓ�É��EÎ�äO�U�WÉ���Î�äZ�U�WÉ ÷ �nÎ�äO�UÖ�É ÷ �RÎ�ÕØå5Ö[É��EÎ@æ ¯"­B« ��×Á·EÄ@æ :²�³»º��R¤!¤!±#²-ª��/ÉÛ·�Ä�Î�çèä ��é�ê �>ë å é �5 :¨p�X <¡:��UÓ�É��EÎ�äO�UÓ*í<É���Î�ì��ÚÉL·EÄ8Î|Õ+�UÖÊí<ÉGíEÎ�ìi�/ÉÛ·�Ä�Î`ÕZ�UÖ�É�í�Î�æ ¯"­B« í�×Á·Xî�ï

�Û¯��nðÅ©X :º�±�¤&¶Ú­ñ´R´n©�«8¨n�B¤��-�n²§�nðÅ©X :º�±�¤&¶Ú­¿´n´n©-«!¨[±�²��R¡B�R«8¶�±�²��Rð¿©� :º#±�¤&¶B�¿±�²�¬X :«8¤!±#´R©�º# :«�±�²»¸�ò�£óu¾>��U��±�´@�ô±#ȧ¬�º�±��n¨Ú¤��� o¤Ú oº#º�¡B�R«8¤�±�´n�R¨�­:¯�·Xî� :«!�Ç :³oÝ8 :´R�n²u¤/¤!­Æ :º�º`¡:�n«S¤�±�´n�n¨�­o¯�·EÄ�±#²ô¼§£öõ��n²�´R��nðÅ©X oº#±�¤&¶���­Bº�³�¨p¯"­B«U¼)î��X :²�³��|�¹ :«8��³�­B²��)¥u¶�±#²-³�©�´R¤!±#­:²E£ ÷

ø�¶» :¬�¬-º�¶¿±�²�ªß¤!���¹º��nȧÈ* *¤!­Ç o²��n±�ªB�R²Å¡:�n´>¤�­B«�­:¯�ù�Ä>ÉL¼ÚÎ@�X���¹«8�nÈ* :«8úÙ¤��X o¤U¤!���¹º��nȧÈ* ±�È*¬-º#±��n¨U¤��X v¤

ù�Ä>ÉL¼ÚÎ�ûyù�Ä>ÉGЮÎ@æ

Page 67: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

�-ü

 :²�³»�nðÅ©X oº#±�¤&¶���­Bº�³�¨U±�¯� :²�³»­B²�º�¶�±�¯�¼ý±�¨� �´n­Bȧ¬�º��R¤!�¦ÊÛÏÛ¬X :«8¤!±�¤!��ªB«� o¬��E£þÒ�)²�­��ÿ :²X :º�¶��n�)¤����)´n­:È*¬-º#�>¤��)ÊÛÏ&¬X :«S¤�±�¤���ªB«! :¬���¨R£������������ ��������)¼ ������������! "���#�ßÊ%$"�&�('%�*)+�,�.-/'0���213��46587(��'%��)9����:<;>=?12��4Øù�Ä>ÉG¼�ήû

ù�Ä>É*@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!ÎA�(4!B.�DC<E&�( F)+�*GH12�� IB�:A) JK�(4!B.��42 FGL) JU¼M)":N�O12�.=&E�'0P(4Q-/'0���21R@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!Î%;ST'U�V�#JXW`�Û¤�±#¨U�n :¨!±�º�¶Ç¡B�n«8±�ã��n³ ¸"´R¯Q£ZY\[(]_^*`?a�bñï\cu¾�¤��X v¤p¤����)´@�X :«! :´R¤!�n«8±#¨S¤�±�´¹¬�­Bº�¶ñ²-­Bȧ±� :º�­o¯�¼ý±�¨

ù&d�e�fhgÅÌUË fiékj Ä 5 éù¦ìl5 éDm fn

ékj Ä É&ù¹ìl5&o�Î�æ :²�³»���R²�´n��ù�Ä�±�¨p¤����)©�²�±�ðÅ©��¦¬�­B¨8±�¤!±�¡:�¹«8­ñ­o¤U­:¯

ÌUË fiékj Ä 5 éù¦ìl5 é ïp ­B²�¨8±#³-�n«U¤�����¯"©�²�´>¤�±�­B²E¢q*Ésr<æRù�Î�ä 5�Ä�Ëlr

ù¹ìl5�Ä�Ëtr ì f�e Äiékj2u 5 éù¹ìv5 é ì 5 f ìwrù¦ìl5 f ì6r ïx�­o¤�±�´n��¤��X v¤yqßÉ*z-æRù�Ä�Î�ä{z-£ p ­Bȧ¬�©ñ¤�±�²�ªß¤!����³��n«8±�¡o o¤!±�¡:�¦�U±�¤��á«!�R¨!¬��n´R¤U¤!­|r}`-���¹�X <¡:�:¢q�~nÉsr<æRù�Î�ä ùÉQù¦ìl5xÄ�Ëvr:Î u Ë ù

ÉQù¦ìl5 f ì6rBÎ u�U��±�´@�DZ�¨�²��nªu v¤�±�¡B�U¯"­B«�ù.��z) :²�³�zH��r��ÿÉ�5xÄ-Ë|5 f Î#�/bñ£xþ��U´n­:²�´nº�©�³��Z�U�2����±�¯h5xÄpÕ�5 f ì�b�`�U�&�n²�³��R´n«D�<�:¨!±�²�ªH�U�&��¨!±I�<��­:¯��D���º��:«!ª/�R¨0�p¨0�X�p¥u¶ ü �:²�³�±�²�´n«0���:¨8±#²-ªR�D���¨8±��X��­:¯��U����¨8ÈL�:º#ºI�n¨��¨D���¥u¶ ü ±�²�´R«D���o¨D�n¨��U���¹¨!¬!�n´X�!«U�:º�«D�:³�±�©�¨<�Z���Å©�¨��D���N��©�«D�:²öªB«D�:¬��á±#¨Z�U���¦©�²�±�ðÅ©����tÑ��!«D�RÈ��oºªB«D�:¬��?`2�o¨�±k�U±�¨Z�D����­B²�º�¶ÙÊÛÏÛ¬2�:«0�!±I�D��ªB«U�o¬��Q�U±I�D�áº��:«!ª(�n¨0�y�o²�³á¨8ÈL�:º#ºI�n¨���¨D�X�!¨�³-±I�h�n«8±#²�ª§±�²á¨8±��X�¥u¶.�_��ȧ­B¨0� ü � ÷

Page 68: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� [�T�9�?��� �N�2 �¡�¢¤£}¥¦¢/ ¨§(¢_¡

þ���²-­¤� ³����U�n«8ȧ±#²��|�D����¨!¬!�n´���«D�:º�«U�o³�±#©-¨�­:¯Z@¦É*5�æ8Ê�ÎN�:²�³ ¨D�-­¤�©�U���_�H�����R­B«D�RÈ ò��ª[±�È*¬-º#±I�n¨y��©-«U�:²?«�¨��U���R­B«D�RÈ.�`þ¬�­�U±#º�º�¬�«!­V®(�N�D����¯"­Bº#º�­V�U±#²-ª�¯°N±�²´³¦²!µ�¶+·¤¶O²h¸v���¹´º¼»"J�¼ )":�¬-/'0���21½��46587(��'���)9����:�1&�(7V)+4¾-¿:,�2������'D�( �'0�}B()+E¾:À:<�(�*)":OJ%G�)+4¾-ù�Ä>ÉL¼ÚÎ�ûyù�Ä>É�@¦É*5�æ8Ê�Î!ÎDÁ¨�+12��4� ÃÇÉL¼ÚÎ�ÂÅûÄ ÃÇÉ�@¹É�5�æ!Ê�Î8Î�ÂF;x�Å(�D���D�2�_�N�Æ�ß³�Å�²�Å_�/ÈL�:ú_�Q�:²u¶Ç�(ÈDÈ0É�ÈRÊ&��±IÅB²�È�ÅB²��U�&�ß´Rº#±�ð¾É��Ù²¾É�È�Ë!�<Ì�Å(Íp¼R�.�����ÍOÅBº�º�ÅV�U±�²�Î*´<Å/Ì0ÅBº#º��(ÌS¶Ù±IÈy�D���n²»±#ȧÈR�n³-±"�_�D�(¯Ï ²´±�²!Ð�Ð��&±¤Ñv���¹� Ò=?12����'U���ÔÓ!;"ÕQ)+���! F)9��:­�+12�H�DB�-��K����E�4!BÖ�#J|=�E�'0P(4Ø× :A�+12����'����L;�����yÊ�ÌDÅ�Å(Í!Å(ÍØÙ�Ì0Å/Ê!Å/È!±k��±IÅB²*ò��Ú[_Û)±IÈ�È0�DÌU�:±IÎ/�}�DÍOÅ/Ì��Ü�_Ì!³?`u¶/���Ü�­Ë�±k���U�R³�±�Å(É�È<��þ¬�U´��:º�´<É-º"�_�D��U�&��ÈDÊ!�n´��UÌD�:º�ÌD�:³�±IÉ�ÈLÅ(ÍÝ�U�&����É�ÌU�:²6Î/ÌU�_Ê��?�������ÞÈ0Êh�R´X�DÌU�:ºyÌU�:³-±�É�ÈLÅ(ÍA�ÇÎ/ÌU�_Ê��wÎB±k®/�XÈß�U�&�Ë!Å/É�²�³�àLù�Ä#5?�/b¤áNÅB²|�D���²¾É�È�Ë!�<Ì�Å_Í��n³�Î/�XÈ<�[þ¬�ÝÈD��ÅV�3�U�2���Æ�U�-±�È�±IÈ��nð¾É2�oºh�UÅK�U���²¾É�ÈKËh�XÌ�Å(Í�n³&Î/�<È�±#²Q�D���A��É�ÌD�:²ÖÎ/ÌU�(Ê&�?`X´<ÅBÈRÊ�ºI�X�!±#²&ÎL�D���AÊ�ÌDÅ�Å(Í#�

þ��­�U±�º#º�É&ÈD�A�U���)²�Å(�U�_��±IÅB².5áäãâuÊ�ìlä�`2z§û�ä��jʨ�U��Ì0Å/É�Î/��Å(É&���å ²Ö���(ÈS¶�´��:º�´<É-º"�_�!±�Å:²ÀÈ0��ÅV�ZÈy�D�2�_�ÂæÃßÉ*@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!Î<Âoäèç äb_é É#â�ì ÌvÎ u ìÒç Ê�Ëtäbêé â u ìläñÉ�Ê�Ë¿äuÎDâ�É,âì ÌoÎ�ï ¸�ò&�òž�����<Ì0�Ç�(ÌD�ëÅB²-º�¶6�,�ÆÅvÅ/Ì0Ë�±I�DÈQÅ(ÍA�U���Þ®(�<Ì���±�´<�<È.É�²-³��<ÌQ�U�&��(É&�UÅ:ÈLÅ(ÌDÊ���±IÈ!È Î/ÌDÅ(É�Ê�Å(Í@¦É*5�æUäÅÎU`´�:²�³Ö���n²-´<�K�D���A�n±IÎ/�n²}®(�n´X�DÅ/Ì­�(È0ÈDÅ¿´n±��_�U�R³À�DÅ�ù�ÄRÉL¼ÚÎT�2�(ÈZÅB²�º�¶Q�,�TÅdz�±IÈ0�!±#²�´��W´XÅBÈRÊhÅvϲ��R²¾�DÈ<�¨���¾É�È)ù�Ä|±�È��U�&�¦º��(Ì0Î/�<È����R±�Î(�n²}®_�:º�É&�KÅ(Í��U�&�¦ÈL�_�DÌ!±(Ñh¯ìí É�äWËØÌoÎ@É#âì ÌoÎ É"Ê�ËtäuÎDâä-É,â�ì ÌoÎ É"Ê�Ë¿äWËØÌoÎDâ}îï ïð ÅBºk®¿±#²&Î�`��Æ�N�2��®/�

ù�ÄRÉ*@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!Î�ä Ìb g âuÊ�ìväËvb¾â¹ËØÌ�ì�ñ â u Ê u ìwb¾âBÊ#äUìwb¾âBÊ�Ëtò�â}äUìlä u Ëvb_äUì Ì m ïósÍ)¼â±�È��:²u¶lÎ/ÌU�_Ê��6�U±k�U��´nº�±#ð¾É��á²�É-È�Ë!�<ÌQ�_�*ÈRÅ/È��ßÊ%`Æ�D���n²w�����<Å/Ì0�nÈ ò��ª[¬�:²-³6�U�&�Ë!Å/É�²�³vÂæÃßÉL¼ÚÎ�ÂÅûôà+5�ù�ÄRÉG¼�Î#�/b¤áKÎB±k®/�<ÈZ�U�&�AÍOÅ:º#ºIÅV�U±#²�ÎRË!Å/É�²�³ÖÅB².�U���)²¾É�ÈKËh�XÌyÅ_Íõ�n³&Î/�<ÈX¯ÂæÃßÉL¼ÚÎ�ÂÅûèö 5 ò g âuÊ�ìväËlb¾â¹ËØÌ`ì ñ â u Ê u ìwb¾âuÊ#äpìwb¾âuÊ�Ëtò�â¾ä�ìlä u Ëlb_äUì Ì m?÷ ï ¸�ò&�ÚøB¾

Page 69: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� óþ��Ý�U±�º�º?ÈD��ÅV�½�U�2�_�Æ�U���­Ë!Å/É�²�³&È�ÎB±I®(�n²�±�²½É�ò�ïùò¿ÎT�:²�³ÁÉ�ò�ïªúÅΨ�(Ì0�Ý�nð¾É2�:ºhÍOÅ/Ì��:º�º?5ë�:²-³�Ê%�

þ¬�¦ÈL�<¶Ö�(È0ÈDÉ�ÈR�A�U�2�_�ZäH��z&`´�(È�ÍOÅ/Ì�ä¦ä{z��U�&�A�,�TÅÇð¾É2�o²¾�!±I�!±��XÈ��_ÌD�A�nð¾É2�:º��U±k�U��Å(É&�Z���:úű�²�Î�U�&�¦±�²}�U�XÎ/�<ÌZÊ2�(Ì����¨û��X��r�ä�5xù�ÄRÉ*@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!Î#�/bWËüÂæÃßÉ*@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î!Î<ÂÚ`�±��\�_�r�ä Ìò É#âBÊ�ìväÅÎ@É#âuÊEìläËlb}â/ËjÌoÎ�ì

ì Ìò É#âBÊ�ìläuÎ�ý É#âBÊ�ìlä�ËØÌUËlb¾â�Î u Ëtò�â5É#âì ÌoÎ@É�Ê�Ë ÌoÎxË

Ë Ìb ä-É�äË ÌoÎ@É#âì ÌoÎ u Ë Ìb É�Ê�ËtäÅÎ@É�Ê�Ë¿äËØÌoÎ0â u Ëtä-É"Ê�Ë�äÅÎ0â�É#âì ÌvÎ@ï

þ¬�¦²&�<�n³.�UÅLÈD�&Ť�½�U�2���ÖàOr�á�ä½z&`X±��ù�(�¦�U�2����r��yÌ/� ð Å:ºI®¿±�²�ÎLÍOÅ(ÌÜ�U���AÌU�o³�±#´<�:º?�T�KÎ/���r|ì Ìò â u Ê u ì Ìb â¾ä1Ê�ì Ìò âuÊ�Ë Ìb â¾äUì Ìò ä u Ë Ìò ä)ää Ìò É#âuÊEìläuÎ�ý É#âuÊEìläËØÌUËvb}â�Î u ìlò�â5É#âì ÌoÎ@É�Ê�Ë ÌoÎ�:²�³.�U�&�n²ÖÈ!ð¾É2�(Ì8±#²�Î&`2È!±�ÈLÊ-º#±kÍ$¶¿±#²�Î&`h�o²�³áÈRÅV®¿±#²&Î���®/�<ÌS¶¾�U��±�²�Îß�DÅR�D���)º���Í+�Z�Æ�A�2��®/�r u ì Ìb É,â u Ê u ìwb¾âuÊ#äpì�âuÊ�Ëlb¾â¾ä�ì6ä u Ë¿äuÎ�r�Ë Ìò â�É,â)ì ÌoÎ,äñÉ�ÊxËtäuÎ�ä{z-ïû��X�Z�U�&�N�tÑ�Ê�ÌD�XÈDÈ!±IÅB²ÀÅB²Ö�D���)º���Í+�yËh�Nþ�É9rBÎU��þ��AÈ0�<�A�U�2�_�þ�É9zÅÎ�ä Ë Ìò â�É#â�ì ÌvÎ,äñÉ�ÊxËtäÅÎ`û�zñï

¸*ÿ[ð¾É2�:º�±k�&¶.��ÅBº�³�ÈZÅB²�º�¶|�Z���n²Àä)ä{z&�O¾ å ³�³�±k��±IÅB²2�:º�º�¶/`2�Æ�A�2��®(�þ�É8ÌoÎ�ä Ìò Ésb}â u Ê u Ëwâ u ä1Ê�ì���âuÊ#äUì6b¾âuÊ�ì�â u ä u ì�â¾ä u Ë�ò�â¾äUì6b_ä u Ëlb_ä�ìlòñÎT�wz-ï����±IÈAÈD��ÅV�ZÈ­�U�2���Kþ�Ésr:ÎZ�2�(È­Å:²��HÊhÅ(È!±k��±k®/�RÌDÅ�Å(��`?�:²�³Þ�U���_�)±I�±�ÈAÈ0�DÌ!±�´X�!º�¶�º��XÈDÈA�U�2�:²ôÌ(������±IÈ´<Å:ÈLÊ-º����U�<ÈZ�U�&�NÊ&ÌDÅ�Å(Í Å_Í��D���AÊ�ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/È8±I�!±�ÅB²Ø� ÷

Page 70: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� ��� ������ �������������������������� ���!�� #"%$��&����� �

þ��AÌ0�<È0�U�_�U�N�:²-³ÀÊ�Ì0ÅV®/�NÅ/É�Ì�ÌD�XÈDÉ�ºk�yÍOÅ/ÌZ�(ÌDË-±I�DÌU�(ÌS¶ßÍ��:ȧ±�º#±I�<ÈyÅ(Í��>Ññ´nºIÉ�³��R³�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�')( �¾²´±���� ���¹!¹+*-,?³¦�/.(·V±¤�2Ð�0ݱ2143!µ656,h·V²!¸��756,�¶���²!¸�²/8�¶+·¤µ ')( �¾²!±¤����9Ç�����;: ���¬�l:V����#Jy-/'0���21}:Ý:�E2��1.�O1&�(�4<>=@?5Ó êBADC ÉLÐÁÎ�ä Ê�ì ̾;�=?12��4

E =@<dGF�HJILKNMPO É�5�æQ:öÎ#�_5»ä ÌUË Ì¤�1Êtï�����Z��É&ÌU�:²RÎ/ÌD�(Ê��H@¦É*5�æ!Ê�Î��2�(È[´��&ÌDÅBÈL�_�!±#´U²¾É�È�Ë!�<Ì[Ê��:²�³H�D���<Ì0�XÍOÅ/Ì0�p³�Å��XÈ[²�Å(�[´XÅB²}���:±�²Ð���R².�U���­Å(�D���<ÌZ�2�o²�³?`

E =S<dGF�H ù�Ä>É�@¹É�5�æ!Ê�Î8Î��_5áä Ì�ËØÌV�vÊtï����±IÈ�±�ÈRÊ�º�±��XÈE =S<UTPVXWdYF�H ILKNMPO É�5�æ@ÐÁÎ��_5ÆÕ ÌUË Ì¤�1Êtï

þ¬��²��<�R³Ç�DÅÖÊ&ÌDÅV®/�H�U�&�HÌD�X®(�<Ì0ÈD�*±#²��Rð¾É2�:º�±I�&¶ëÍOÅ/Ì E =S<Z=S?[��¦þ��HÌ0�XÍOÅ/Ì8È�É�º��_�D�R�D�X\IÈ­È0�����U�nÈR�^]¾�<`�Z�X\�´�� ´<Å7]�È��-\k�UÉ&�D�<È��D���_]�Å`]¾�DÌQ\k®/\"�:ºKÊ2�(Ì��ÞÅ(ÍHÅ(É�Ì�È0Êh�R´X�UÌD�:ºK®(�<Ì0ÈQ\IÅ7] Å(Í��U�&�tÿ¦Ì!³Xa/ÈQÏ ð �DÅ7]��tÏð \�ÈRÅ7]�ÅV®/\I�DÈy�D���<Å/Ì0�nÈ.�')( �¾²´±���� ���¹cb�������Ðê�����Ý-/'0���21Q�#JÝ��1�'����L�(��)9�Z42E��L����' C ÉGЮÎ�ä ÊBì®Ì¾;H=?12��4ÝJ���'Ý��7(��'�Gd � zt�O12��'U�Ö�Pe/)":��O:)f ägfÒÉGÐáæ d ÎH:�E´��1��+1&�(�K��7(��'%GQ-/'0���21ö¼ih¦)+�O1�5ÿÕjf 7(��'%��)9����:ß4Ø�������42�9�()+42)+4¾-ÚÐ ��:K�L:�E&�s-/'0���21|:<�(��)":lkÜ��:

ù�Ä>ÉG¼�Î#�_5Æû ÌpËØ̤�vÊEì d ïm2Å/Ì­�|Î/ÌD�(Ê��on½�p]�³Ç�|ÊhÅ/ÈP\I�Q\I®(�q\S]}�U�XÎ/�<ÌAä�`Ø�T��³��Rãr]&�R�D���HÎ/ÌD�(Ê��%nUÉ*äuÎyËu¶ÞÌD�XÊ�º��:´B\s]�Î���o´���®/�XÌ0�U�tÑHÅ(ÍrnËu¶Nä�\S]-³��<Ê!�B]�³&�B]}�¦®/�XÌ0�-\�´<�XÈ<`��`]�³KÌD�XÊ�º"�o´B\s]�ÎÝ���o´��H�n³�Î/�TÅ(ÍNnëËu¶K�W´<ÅBÈRÊ�ºI�X�D�ËX\IÊ2�(Ì��-\k�U��Î/ÌD�(Ê��HË!�X�,�T�<�B]R�U�&�p´<Å/Ì0ÌD�<È0ÊhÅ`]�³X\s]�ÎAä1Ï9�UÉ�Ê�ºI�<ÈX�U¸tnUÉ�äÅÎ \IÈõ�U�&�­ "�Pe/)9���0-/'D���21�)9���!'U�<B(E´���Å(Íun6��\k�U� vDw�� p Í#���_�\Î���Y\ø�^*`�Ê2�(Î(� ü ò �/� �O¾m2ÅBº#ºIÅV��\S]&Î�ÿ¦Ì8³Xa/ÈSÏ ð \�ÈLÅ`]�ÅV®�\k�UÈKY ò¾[�^?�T�x]&Å(�U�Ý�D�2�_��\k�ZÈDÉy*´<�XÈ��DÅLÊ&ÌDÅV®/�A�����XÅ/ÌD�RÈ ò��Ú[oóÍOÅ/ÌÝ�D���ß´<�(ÈD�ßÐ äzv§À�Ã�ÄRÉ*äuÎ�`�ä.�`]�³ÁÊWãñÑ&�R³?�ßó!]-³��<�R³?`�ÍOÅ/ÌA�p]Ŷ®Ð ºI�X�NäQËh�H�D���§È��1Ñ\�È�É-ÈÈQ\I�<�AÅ(Í �`]{\s]�³��XÊh�^]�³��B]}��ÈD����Å_Í�Ð �`]-³»ºI�X�pÊ[ä C ÉLЮÎEË Ì/��RÝË}®/\�Å/É&È!º�¶/`5Ð|\�ÈZ�HÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê��.Å(Í

v*À�Ã�ÄRÉ�äÅÎU�

Page 71: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� ø�����QÊ�Ì0Å�Å(ÍZÅ_Í����&�<Å/Ì0�nÈ ò&�Ú[:óÀÌD�nºs\I�<ÈRÅ7] ð �X�nÈR�<ÌP}n³X\�«\ÈRÊ!ÅV�Æ�XÌ0ÍOÉ�ºÜÉ]X\IÍOÅ(Ì!Èq\I�&¶Òº��RȧÈ����

øÆ��ÍOÅ/ÌD�AÈ0�U�_�-\s]�ÎH�U�\�È�º��RȧÈ���`��Æ�~]��X�n³�È0ÅBÈR�)³��Rãr]\I�Q\�Å7]&È<�û��X��� �p]�³�� Ë!��³X\IÈ�Ý�Å7\s]}�ZÈDÉ�Ë&ÈD�X�DÈZÅ(Í�·ÇÉL¼ÚÎ���û��X���BÉ���æ�� Î�Ë!���U����]¾É�ÈKËh�XÌZÅ(Í��n³�Î/�XÈË!�X�,�T�<�B]À�U���AÈD���UÈ����`]-³��Ä�����>ãr]��A�U����B���4&:�)+��GßÅ(Í��U���AÊ2�p\�̦É���æ�� Φ�DÅRËh�^�� É!��æ�� Î�ä �BÉ���æ�� ÎÂ��LÂ"Â��Ò ï

þ��TÈU�<¶A�U�2��� �U�&�TÊ2�p\�Ì|É���æ�� Î�\�È|É��¿æ%r:Î�$,E�42) J���'���\kÍ2ÍOÅ/Ì��:º�º�Ê��`\�Ì0È Å(Í�ÈD�X�DÈ��������|æ������� ÈD�_�-\IÈ0Í$¶/\s]�άÂ����9¿Õ3r2Â��LÂ��`]�³vÂ����9ÂÅÕ3r�Â��ÒÂ/�T�K���V®(�Ö � É���æ�� Î�Ë � É����$æ�����Î�Â������

þ��)ÈL�<¶{]�ÅV�ãÈ����_�D� ð �<�nÈR�XÌQ}n³\*«ùÈ�Ì0�<ÈDÉ-ºI�<�')( �¾²´±���� ���¹2�*-,��}�����¾±��/1�¶��Iµ>�.¸�¶l�s²´±��¿¶O·%Ñv�����¿�����s NbX¡!9£¢Ü)+7(��4¤����zÞ�(4!B|�(4Þ)+42$�,�*-���'>¥�Á��+12��'U�.)":Ö�(4#¦ ä|¦ É��¿æ-¥�ÎL:�E2��1v�O1&�(�A�+12�Q7(��'%�,�PeÇ:V�����#JÀ��7(��'%GÖ-/'D���21_h¦)+�O1ë57(��'%�*)9����:�Á�5µÕ§¥�Á��D�(4¬���Z�&�('%�*)+��)9��4Ø�DB|)+42�#�Ö�� I��:�:V��:W·Xî<æ<ï<ï<ï�æ@· f Á¨h 12��'U��¥ û�â»û�¦ ÁT:�E2��1�+1&�(�yÂ�·5î(¿û+��5�ÁZÂ�·EÄ<ÂBä8 · u Â:䪩G©G©Åä©Â�· f Â\ÁÆ�(4!B|�( + ��<E��Æ�(�Æ�ß�V:��&�¬« f u�­ �#JA�+12���&�()+'�:)ÉÛ· é æt·¾onÎDÁÌ)û Ô¨�¯®Çû{â¬�('U�¦Él�ñæP�ÅÎU$,E�42) J���'%�L;ST'U�V�#JÜ�#JN=?12����'U����Ó!;"Õ±°/¯ m²\�Ì0È0���Æ��³��XÈQ´XÌQ\IËh���U����\s³�����\s]&ÍOÅ/Ì!ÈL�:º�º¶µ/��þ¬��´<Å7]&ÈQ\s³��<Ì�� ð �<�RÈL�XÌQ}^³X\Ê2�(Ì��-\k�-\IÅ7]ëÅ(Í|·ÇÉG¼�Î�\s]}�UÅÞâÖË�ºIÅ�´@ú¾ÈX`�ÍOÅ(ÌÝÈDÅBÈR�ßâ�ÿÊ/¸sâÀ��\�º�º�]�Å(��³&�<Ê!�B]X³ÇÅ7]ë5�¾%�¹þ¬���U�&�B]ÌD�RÈRŤ®(�A�:º�ºØ�B³&Î/�<ÈÆÍOÌ0ÅBÈ ��\I�D�X\s].�D����Ë-º�Å/´@ú¾ÈÜ�U���RÈLÈ0�nºk®/�XÈ<`´Å/Ë&�U�`\S]\S]�ÎR�RâBÏ,Ê2�_Ì0�-\k�U��Î/ÌU�_Ê��?`��p]X³ÌD�RÈRŤ®/\s]�ÎA�:ºIÈDÅ��D��Å/È0�Ü�B³�Î(�<È�º¶µ/\S]�Î�Ëh���,�Æ�X�B]RÊ2�`\IÌDÈ�Å(Í´Ë�ºIÅ�´@ú¾È �D�2�_�¦�_ÌD�·]&Å(��Él�¿æQ�uÎLÏ,É]X\IÍOÅ(Ì!È.`_ÍOÅ/ÌÈDÅ:ÈL�~��º��(ÌDÎ(�<ÌÜ�U���`]ÀÈ0ÅBÈR�N�D��ÌD�XÈD��Å:ºS³?�Tó!]À�D�X\�È��Æ�Yµ/`h�:º#º?�D���AÌD�RÈ��p\S]X\s]�Î��B³�Î/�XÈ��_ÌD�AËh���,�Æ�X�B]®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È­Å(͸³\I�h�<Ì0�B]}��´<Å:º�Å/Ì�´nº��(ÈDÈ0�<ÈX`��`]X³�\kͦ�U�&�<ÌD�x\�ÈÝ�_�WºI���_È0�ÝÅ`]����^³�Î/��Ë!�X�,�T�<�^]�,�TŤ´XÅBº�Å(Ì´nº��(È0ÈD�<ÈD�ô�p]X³#�Ä`��D���B] � É���æ�� Î�\�È��(ËhÅV®(���U�&�ßÊ�Ì0�B³����U�<Ì8Èq\S]��^³¿�U��Ì0�<È0��ÅBºs³t�`]X³Ç�U����Ê2�`\IÌÉ���æ�� ÎU`X\�ȦÉl�ñæP�ÅÎGÏ,ÉX]\IÍOÅ/Ì8È.� p �:º�º?�U�X\IÈZÌD�<È0É�ºk�-\s]�Î�Î(ÌU�(Ê��º¹¦�

þ��Þ��\�º�º�]��<�^³{���D�B´��X]\S´<�:º)º��RÈ*ÈL� ¸�Å_Íx\s]X³��XÊh�^]X³��^]¾�º\s]¾�D�<Ì0�<È0�@¾ß�Z�X\S´��3È0�U�_�U�XÈ|�U�2���ÉX]X³&�<Ì�´<�<Ì����`\s]�´<Å7]X³\I�Q\�Å7]&È<`N\IÍu¹¯´XÅ7]}���`\s]�È��Dv§À�Ã�Ä�`��U���^]�¹o´<Å7]}���p\S]�È��qv*À�Ã�ÄRÉ�äÅÎU`´�`]X³Ö���B]X´X�ÈDÅ»³�Å��<ȼR�����¾É�È�¹_´<�`]X]�Å(�¼´<Å7]}�U�`\S]Jv*À�Ã�Äy�p]X³��T�/ÈL�Yµ��_Ê�Ê�º¶µµ¸O�����<Å(ÌD�nÈ ò�� ü ¾Ü�UÅ�ËhÅ/É]X³\k�UÈÆÈ0Êh�^´X�DÌU�:ºhÌU�`³X\IÉ�ÈX��þ���É�ÈD��û��RȧÈ���[��Oó�`�\k�U�RÈÞ¸l\S\s\e¾%`��DÅ�È0��ÅV�3�D�2�_�T�U�����B³�Î/�XÈT�T�ÝÌD�RÈRŤ®(�B³´��p]X]�Å(��´<Å`]¾�DÌQ\IË�É&�D�¦ÈKÉX´��À�DÅL�D���AÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�oº�ÌU�`³X\IÉ�ÈX�½P¾�¿�À�ÁtÀQÂ6ÃGÀPÁ·Ät¿�Å^Æ�ÇÈûÉ`À�Ê�Â�ÁËÀ�Ìt¿pÂ�ÌÎÍ�Ï»Ìt¿2ÍÈÄÎÄtÀPÐ�ÌtÍÈÅ6ÏÑÊ�À�Â�ÁËÀ�ÆpÄ�ÍÈÏ�ÒÔÓ)ÌtÅÔÃGÀ�Ï�Å6ÌtÀ�ÃGÀPÏ2Ä�Í�ÌlÕ>ÁLÂ�Ìt¿2À�Á·Ìt¿2Â6ÏÃGÀPÒ6ÁËÀ�À6Ör¾�¿�ÀQÄ�À¸Â6ÁtÀ^×G¿�Å�Ê�ÀPØ6ÀPÁP×BÀPÂ^Ä�ÍÈÇ�Õ�ÃGÍÈÄ�ÌtÍÈÏ�Ò^Æ�ÍÈÄt¿�ÀQÃ�Ù¶ÁËÅ6ÚZÀPÂ6ÐL¿�Å�ÌË¿�À�Á&ÉYÕ�ÌË¿�À�ÏYÆ�Ú�É`À�Á Å6ÙÂ6ÁtÒ^Æ�Ú¨À�ÏBÌËÄPÖ

Page 72: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

�/������ÚÈL�`\s]��TÅ/Ì!úÖÅ(Í�Å/É�Ì�Ê�ÌDÅ�Å(͸\Iȼ´XÅ7]}���`\s]��^³Û\S]��D����ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ��\s]�Îß�D�B´��X]\S´<�`ÜuÜI�nȧÈL�&�qÝ åÈQ\�Èq\SÜ��(ÌÎÜI�nȧÈL�&`&��\k�U�Ö��È0�DÌDÅ7]&Î/�<ÌδXÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]Ö�`]X³.��È��UÌDÅ`]�Î/�<ÌδXÅ7]X´^Ü�É�ÈP\�Å`]?`´�(Ê�Ê!���(Ì0ÈÎ\S]Y\[oò(^*�O¾������������¹NÞj¢Ü)+7(��4Þâ5æUä1æQß-æQ�¿æ%r|:�E2��1��O1&�(�4�ß�+ß´��ò f �(4!BRrL� É�ßßË6b f �ÅÎ f w ÁÜ�+12��'U�L�Pe/)":��+:�(4�à ä�à�É,â5æUä1æQß�æP�ñæ�rBÎy:�E´��1À�+1&�(�T�+12�¨J��� + "�2h¦)+4¾-L12�� IB�:<;�» J�¹�)":���-/'0���21ë��4ë�O12�K7(��'%�#�Pe�:V���á ÌBæ<ïnï<ïEæXârâ/Á�¼ô)":N��â´$"�&�('%�*)+�,�Z-/'0���21���4ÞB()":äãV��)+42��:V���+:�å�Ä>æ<ï<ï<ïEæ�å f ÁÜ�D����1L:V���Æ�#J�:�)sæ��N�(�¦ "�D��:��fÁ��(4!BAJ���'R�( + á Ô!æL®râ�×lÃßÉ˹�ÎDÁy�+12�Ý�&�()+'§ÉLå é æ�å�onÎ�)":§É��¿æ%r:Î�$,E�42) J���'%�çh¦)+�+1ÇB���4&:�)+��GÀ�(�y "�D��:��

ßhÁ¨�+12��4�¹�É*äuÎ�� ¼ß;ST'U�V�#JXW�þè\k�U�&Å/É&��Ü�Å/È0È�Å_ͦÎ/�B]&�<ÌU�pÜS\k�!µ.�Æ�¹È��YµÖ�(È0ÈDÉ�ÈR���D�2�_��¹_\Iȼ´<Å:ÈLÊÜ����U�(��ó!]³��<�^³?`¬\kÍ�¹¯\IÈ]�Å(�;´XÅBÈRÊXÜ����U�_`uÜI�X�¹¼ � Ë!�H�U���LÎ/ÌU�_Ê��¬Å(Ë&���`\s]��^³ÇÍOÌ0ÅBÈâ¼ôË�µÇ�`³X³X\s]�ÎÀ�`Üsܦ�B³�Î/�XÈKË!�X�,�T�<�^]éå é�`]X³Jå¾o��Z���B]&�X®/�XÌ á Ô8æ!®Xâ/×ëÃßÉ ¹�ÎT�`]X³À�(Ê�ÊÜsµ|�D���~Ü��RȧÈ��R�UÅ�ãr]X³ºv*ÀSÉ�äÅÎ�\s]»¼ � �¦���X\�È�v*À&É*äuδ<Å`]¾�U�`\s]�Èy�D����³��XÈQ\IÌD�B³�¹`É�äÅÎ�\s]»¼L�

þ�����\SÜsÜ��`´��UÉ2�`ÜsܶµßÊ�Ì0ÅV®/�Ý�U�&��Ü��RȧÈ���É]X³��<ÌÜ�D����ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ��\s]�ÎHÈPÜS\IÎ/�}�-ܶµß�T���:ú_�<ÌδXÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]Å7]Àr}¯ r��ÿÉ�ß*Ë_�uÎ w É�ß*Ë#�2�ÅÎ w ©G©G©<Élß*ËØÉsb(f�ËjÌoÎL�uÎ w ï Ý�ò&� � ¾øÆ�XÍOÅ(ÌD�H�Æ�LÊ�Ì0Å�´X�<�B³��\k�U��U���RÊ�Ì0Å�Å(Í#`?�T�*È��oú(�H�,�ÆÅáÈRÅ/ÌD�>³��>ãr]X\k�-\IÅ7]�ÈX�ßû��X�¹¼ÒË!�L�Î/ÌD�(Ê��?`�ê���ÈDÉ�Ë�È0�X�AÅ(ͦ�D���K®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<ÈAÅ(Í`¼R`h�`]X³ÆåÇ��®/�XÌ0�D�>ÑëÅ_Í�¼L�Ýû�����fxë�É�å�Î�\IÈ��U���KÈD���­Å(Í®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ȼ\s]Jê6�`³oÝ0�p´<�B]}�Z�Uŧå���ósÍ4ìí\IÈy�RÈ0�X�yÅ(Í�®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ<`´�U���^]Jfxë5É�ìÒÎ�ä�î4ï ê^ð fxë�É�å�Î�������NÊ�ÌDÅ�Å(Í4\�ÈZË�µ�\s]X³�ÉX´��-\IÅ7]ÀÅ`]â´��m2Å/Ì�â�ä Ì(`��U���~ÜI�nȧÈL�D\IÈ��UÌDÉ&�A��\k�U�

à�É8ÌBæUä1æQß-æQ�¿æ%r:Î�ä½ä1ïþ¬���(È0ÈDÉ�ÈR�N�U�2�_�y�U�&�xÜI�nȧÈL�Ñ\IÈy�DÌDÉ��AÍOÅ/ÌÝâßäyÊ;ÝO��\k�U�Ö�U���N�Æ�<�:ú(�X̼´XÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]éÝ"ò�� � ¾ÜÍOÅ(Ì�rv¾�`�`]X³ÖÊ�Ì0Ť®(�~\I�ZÍOÅ/ÌÜ�D���~´��(È0�Hâ�ä ÊEì Ì/�û��X��â�ä ÊxìÿÌ/`Ø�`]X³�(È0ÈDÉ�ÈR���U���_�Ýä�`���`�r}`¬ßØ`��(ÌD��Î7\I®(�B]?`?�`]X³Þ�U���_���D���^µ�ÈU�_�Q\�È�Íäµ��U�&���µ�ÊhÅ(�D���<È0�<È­Å(Í��U���xÜ��RȧÈ���Ý*�(Î}�p\S]?`2ÍOÅ/ÌZ�U�&�K�T���:ú_�<Ì�´XÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]ÞÅ7]Þro¾%��þ��NÍOÉ�Ì0�D���<Ì��(È0ÈDÉ�ÈR��U���_�;ñj\�È­Î`\I®(�B]�Å`]ÇÈ0�X�DÈÔå�Ätæ<ï<ïnï�æ�åXÀ�Ã�Ä�È0ÉX´��¬�D�2�_�*ÉLå é æ�å�onÎ�\�È*Él�ñæ�rBÎGÏ,ÉX]X\kÍOÅ/Ì8È ��\k�U�o³��B]&ÈQ\k�!µ�_��ÜI���(È���ß?`´�`]X³À�`ÜsÜ?ÈD���UÈy�2��®/�NÈQ\I�<�K�_��ÜI���(È���¦�`´�Z�&�<ÌD�

¦ ä§<Dò2óxô�ä(�õPöÎ÷lr`ø w æ�f «Pù æDävæPßq÷_�ñæ�b2�¿æ%r_��õ�ß>÷¯��ø w ­ �õlßD÷¯��ø wpú ï

Page 73: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

��ûþ¬�T��\sÜSÜ¿ãr]X³Ôì ä á å¬ütæ<ïnï<ï�æ�åXwBâx�§årýsþ�ü�`/ÈDÉX´����D�2�_�u\IÍ�å �é �èfxÿ���õlì¯ø�`_ÍOÅ/Ì���äªö:æ<ï<ï<ïEæ ù `_�U�&�B]�U�&��´<Å7]³X\I�Q\�Å`]�ÈÜÅ(Í��D���¼ÜI�����L�H�(ÌD���L���ÆÍOÅ/̨�U����Î/ÌU�(Ê&�{ñ � \S]³�ÉX´<�^³.Å7]ß�U�&�ÝÈD���UÈ�å �ü æ<ï<ï<ï�æ�å �ý ������^]�ÈD����ì �DÅ/Î/���U���XÌZ��\k�U�.�U�&�xvqý�õ*ä�ø�ÍOÌDÅ��©�U���~\s]X³�ÉX´��-\k®/�KÈ0�U�Xʺ\IÈ��U���~³��XÈQ\IÌD�^³�vDýsþ�ü^õ�ä±øU�û��X�x� äªåXýsþ�ü%�Uþè\I�D�X\s] �K`h�T�K��\sÜSÜ�ãr]X³ë��ÈD�X��Å(͸Ü��(ÌDÎ(�KÈP\��X��ÈDÉX´��Þ�D�2�_���`ÜsÜ��^Ü���L�^]}�UÈ�2��®/�)Ü"�(Ì0Î/�;³��<Î/Ì0�<�x\S]À���`´��ÞÅ_Íõ�U���Ôå é ��m2ÌDÅ��ô�D�X\�È�ÈD�����T�)´���Å�Å/ÈD�¹å¬ü��pþ��A�U���^]ÞÌD�XÈ0�DÌQ\s´X���DÅ�U�&�;]&�B\IÎ/�¾ËhÅ/Ì0ÈZÅ(Í�å¬ü�`´�p]X³ÀÌ0�<Ê!���_���D���AÊ�ÌDÅ/´<�^³�É�Ì0�(`Xãr]X³X\s]�Î��`]�å u `2�X�Q´(����RãX]X\S]&ÎL�D����³��XÎ/ÌD�X�­Å(Í���®/�<Ì��U���å�\S].��È0�X��ê¿�UÅHË!� � ërõGå¬ø�ä©Â á�� ×%ê�çuå� � â2ª`��T�ÜI�X��� ü ä á�� × � ç � ÿ ë õGå¬ø�Õ õ�ßq÷_��ø<Â�å¬ü�ÂÈâ��`]X³ � ü ä������ ü �¨x�Å_�-\s´<�­�U�2���

� õ � ü æ�å�üQø¨�  � ü  õlßq÷_��ø�Â�å¬ü� � ü Â�Â�å¬üV äèß»÷ ��Z�X\s´��_\IÈ���´<Å7]}�UÌD�`³X\s´X�Q\�Å7]¬Å(Í�õl�¿æ%r7ø��,ÉX]\IÍOÅ/Ì��q\I�!µëÅ_Í�õ���æ�å¬ü-ø��Z���B]&�X®/�XÌ� � ü Â��8r�Â��Lª�ß���¾É�È�T�K�2��®(�NÈ0��ÅV��]���r.(·L��* ÔÂ�� ü ÂÅÕªõ�öÎ÷lr7ø<Â��LÂÚ�m2Å/Ì���ä{bñænï<ï<ïEæ ù `rÜI�X��� é ä á�� ׯ� é e ü ç � ÿ���õGå¬ø�Õ õ�ßD÷_��ø�Â�å é þ�ü<ÂÈâ¾� å È��_ËhÅV®/�_`2�Æ�A�2��®/����r.(·L��"¹ Â�� é ÂÅÕ õPö�÷lr`ø�Â�� é e ü Â}ÍOÅ/Ì���äübñæ<ï<ïnïEæ ù �þ¬�»]�ÅV� ´���Å�Å/È0�Çå¬ü�×�� ý �_ÌDËX\k�UÌD�(ÌQ\sÜsµ(�oÝ"þ¬�»]&Å(�U�R�U�2���K�D�2�_�q� ý �2�(ÈNÈQ\I�<�ßÈ0Å��R�Ñ´XÅ7]�È0�U�`]}�ÍOÌU�p´X�-\IÅ7]QÅ(Í��D���­ÈQ\I�<�­Å_Í���`´�p]X³Q�2�(È����ÎÜ��<�(È0�ÜäK®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈZË�µ|Å/É�Ì·\S]X\k�-\��`ÜØ�(ÈDÈ0É��RÊ&�-\IÅ7].Å7]�¦¼���

þ���Ü�����å üé ä�fxÿ��Põ�å¬ü-ø��p]X³ßÌ0�<Ê!���_�T�U���yÊ�ÌDÅ/´<�XÈDÈÆ��\k�U���U����å üé «ùÈÆ�`]³ß�U����ÈU���R�~����û����� oü Ë!�A�U���KÈDÉX´^´<�<È0ÈQ\k®/�RÈDÉ&Ë�ÈD���UÈÝÅ(Í��ÔÅ(Ë&���`\s]��^³�ÍOÅ/ÌZ�U���KÈD�X�DÈ�å üé�� ´���Å�Å/ÈD�¹å u ×é� wü ³\I�h�<Ì0�B]}�ÍOÌDÅ��Âå¬ü���þ��ÝÌ0�<Ê!���_�T�U�X\IÈÜäA�-\��R�<Ȩ\s]Q�`ÜsÜ*`¿ãr]X³X\s]�ÎÚå¬ü�ï<ï<ï�æ�åXwV`�Î/�X�0�-\s]�Î�ÈD���UÈ�å �é ä�å wé `��Z���<Ì0�å wé � ©G©G©X��å üé ��å é �`]X³Jå wé ä�f)ÿ���õ á å¬ü@æ<ï<ï<ï�æ�åXw^â7ø���Ý å Î}�`\s]?`��T�~´��`]À�`Ük�Ü�Yµ�È�ãX]X³Ö�D���<È0�Kä®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È Ë�µ­�D����\S]X\k�-\��`ܾ�(È0ÈDÉ��RÊ&�Q\�Å`]�Å7])¦¼���/ø�µ­Å/É&Ì��R���U��Å/³�È<`¤�T�T�2��®(�NÂ�å oQþ�üé  �ªõlß ÷¼��ø�Â�å é Â

Page 74: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

��!ÍOÅ/ÌÜ�<�`´��»®��`]³Ö�&�B]X´X�.Â�å �é Â���õ�ß>÷o��ø w Â�å é ÂÚ�¦���&�­ÈD�X�DÈ�å �ü æ<ïnï<ï�æ�å �ý �_ÌD�>õl� � æ%r � ø"�sÉX]X\kÍOÅ/Ì#�8��\k�U�³��^]�ÈQ\k�!µÖ�_��Ü��<�(È0��ß � ÍOÅ(Ì Â�å �é ¾��õ�ßq÷_��ø w Â�å é Âèæ� � äüb2�¿ær � ä rõ�ßq÷_��ø w æ

ß � ä�ßq÷_�¿ïþ¬�NÅ`]XÜsµ¤]��<�^³Ö�DÅLÈ0��ÅV�ü�U���_���U���XÈD�;]��X�½®_�`Ü�É&�<ÈZÈU�_�Q\�È�ÍäµQ�U���A��µ�ÊhÅ_�U���XÈD�<È�Å(Í��U���~ÜI�����L�LÍOÅ/Ìâ�ä ù � ós��\�È�\��$�R�^³X\"���U�A�U�2�_�Î���!�Zß2�/b ý `2�_È

�H� ßò ýsþ�ü ä ß � ìé�ò ýsþ�ü���^]X´<�~���Uß � �õ�ò ýsþ�ü ÷+öpøT�`]X³Q�T�x´XÅ7]X´BÜIÉX³��� � ä{b2����b�© ß �ò ýsþ�ü ÷+ö � ß �ò ý ï�����AÈD�^´<Å7]³���µ�ÊhÅ(�D���<ÈP\�È�\�Èy�`ÜIÈDÅLÈ0�DÌU�`\IÎ/�}�DÍOÅ(Ì0�Æ�(ÌQ³?¯

r � ä rõlß»÷ �±ø w � õ�ßD÷¯��ø w õ�ßq÷é�2�±ø w ©G©G©Yõlßq÷èõsb ýsþ�ü ÷£öpøË��ø wõ�ßD÷_��ø wäªõ�ßD÷#�2�±ø w ©G©G©YõlßD÷+õsb ýsþ�ü ÷+öpøË�±ø wäªõ�ß � ÷_� � ø w õ�ß � ÷é�2� � ø w ©G©G©Bõ�ß � ÷èõ9b ý ÷+öpøL� � ø w���¾É�ÈZ�Æ�%�L�Gµ¤´���Å�Å(ÈD�

à>õ ù ì�öBæUä1æQß-æQ�¿æ%r`ø�ä öõ�ßD÷¯��ø w à>õ ù æDävæPß � æP� � æ%r � ø�`]X³.�U�&�;ÜI�����L�q\�È��UÌ0É��AË�µ{\S]³�ÉX´X�Q\�Å`]?� ÷ST'U�V�#Jß�#J�=?12����'U���ÒÓ!;"Õ}Õ�;�û����%& ä vDýsþ�ü^õ�ä±øU��ós�AÌD��L�`\S]&ÈA�DÅQÈD��ÅV�¼�U�2�_�­ÍOÅ(ÌÝ�X®(�<ÌPµ d ��z�U�&�<ÌD�A��\IÈ0�DÈÝ�`]�à>õ ù æUä1æ d ø¨È0ÉX´��À�D�2�_� ILKNMPO õ*5�æ�vDýsþ�ü^õ�ä±øPø¨��õPö�÷£ö¤� ù ì d ø,5��

Page 75: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

� ]þ��yÉ�È0��û������L�¹ò&�Ú[/ø��('~\k®/�^]ßä1æ ù æ d `�Ü�����ßØ`/��`��`]X³ßr�Ë!���(Ì0ËX\k�UÌU�_ÌPµHÊ!Å/ÈQ\k�-\k®/��´<Å7]&È0���p]¾�DÈÈU���-\IÈ0Íäµ/\S]&κßv� d u �`�&`&���ªß´��ò ý `��`]X³�rÀ� õlß�÷�b ý ��ø ý w �Lû��X�)ñÒËh���QÎ/ÌU�_Ê��¬Å`]¬5�� à ä

à>õ ù æDävæPß�æQ�¿æ%r`øÆ®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È~]�Å_��´<Å`]¾�U�`\s]X\S]&Î{vDýsþ�ü^õ�ä±ø��(È­�ßÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê��?� ð �X��¥Þä <>=S? á*) ö¤�2ß,+Åæ ù â�`]X³��U�:ú(�Ü� ð �<��R�<ÌQ}^³X\2Ê2�(Ì��-\k�-\IÅ7]HÅ(Ícñè\S]}�DÅ�-ÜÊ2�_Ì0�UÈX`(�Z���XÌD�Î¥è�.-A�+¦ªõt¥ÆæQ��ø��0/y��LÅV®(�Z�`ÜSÜ�B³&Î/�<È���\I�D�H�`]��^]X³Ô\s]��U���¨Å7]��TÈD���õÅ(Í2È��L�`ÜSÜI�<Ì�ÈQ\I�<�~Ý��_���LÅ(È0�u��5 u �B³�Î(�<È��%`/ÌD��RŤ®(�Ü�B³&Î/�<È�ÍOÌDÅ����\k�U�X\s]ÈD�X�DÈqÝ*���1�RÅ/È0�­5 u �¾âÖ�^³�Î/�<È2��`?ÍOÌ0Å��MËh���,�Æ�X�B]ÇÊ2�`\IÌDÈÝÅ(Í�È0�X�DÈÝ�U�2�_�Ý�(ÌD�)]�Å(���3�,É]X\IÍOÅ(Ì#�Ý*�����RÅ/È0�¨��5 u �B³�Î/�XÈ��%`2�`]X³|ÍOÌ0Å�� Ë!�X�,�T�<�^]ÀÊ��`\�Ì0ÈÜÅ(Í�ÈD���UÈÜ�D�2�_���2��®(��³��B]�ÈP\I�!µ¤Ü��XÈDÈÜ�U���`]¤ßoÝ*����RÅ/È0��ß�5 u �B³�Î(�<È��%�¦���¾É�ÈÆ�T���2��®/��ÌD���RÅV®/�^³.�_�4�LÅ(È0�¼õsb2��ìJß�øs5 u û d u 5 u �(bN�B³&Î/�<ÈX� p �`ÜSÜ´�U�&�ÌD�XÈDÉXÜk�-\s]�ÎLÎ/ÌU�_Ê��J¹¦�

¹o³&Å��XÈÎ]�Å(�δXÅ7]}���`\s]�vDýsþ�ü�`�Ë!�B´<�(É�ÈD��\kÍ4\I��³\S³?`��U���^]ÖË�µ|û��������ò��ª[/ø)\k�Z�`]X³Q�&�B]X´X�xñ�TÅ/ÉXÜs³º´XÅ7]}���`\s]�vqýsþ�ü6õ˹uø��`ø�µÇþè\SÜkÍ<«ùÈ��U���XÅ/ÌD�� Ý����&�<Å/Ì0��� ò�� ü �·\k��ÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈy�D�2�_�ùcü6õ˹uø�û õPö�÷£ö¤� ù ø,5�ï

5ÀÅ/Ì0�<ÅV®/�XÌ<`�ÈQ\s]X´<�R�T�D³&�BÜI�X�U�^³����6�LÅ(È0� d u 5 u �/b|�B³&Î/�<ÈX`��T�q´<Å7]X´^Ü�ɳ��R˱µÇû���$�L�Ö[��ó&`&\k�U���Ý�\s\s\7�%`��U�2�_�

ù�ü6õtñ>ø�ûyùcü6õ˹uø�ì d 5Áû õPö�÷£ö¤� ù ì d ø,5�ï ÷

���98 ���;:(<¼��=��!�?>j�(@q�X$��ª��A;�*Bc���C:4=q"ED��;F��g�$��&����� �þ��%]�ÅV�ç´<Å7]�ÈP\S³&�<ÌÖÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��È|�U�2����³�ÅZ]&Å(��´<Å7]}�U�`\S]§vDýsþ�ü|�(È.�tÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��{�p]X³½���V®(�ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`Ü&ÌD�`³X\IÉ�È�´BÜIÅ/È0�Æ�UÅy�U�2�_� Å(Í2�U�&�Ü�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Î/ÌU�(Ê&��@;õ*5IH ù ø���þ��Æ��\sÜsÜ&Ê�Ì0Ť®(�Æ�U�&�ÆÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�ÎÌD�XÈDÉXÜk��´<Å7]´<�<ÌP]X\s]�Î��D���AÈ0���_ËX\SÜs\k�!µ.Å(Í��D���A�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�

')( �¾²´±���� ��S +*-,س¦�/.(·V±¤�2ÐܵX·V�;J ¶�Ð*¶+·%Ñ¿· ( �¾²!±¤����9LK���'Ö�( + ���� z��(4!B�J���' ùNM b���'D��Á�+12��'��¬�Pe/)":��ß����4&:��s�(42�+:NOYü M OBü6õ ù øÞ�(4!BPO u M O u õ ù ø0ÁR:�E´��1��O1&�(�ÜJ���'�( + Æ-/'0���21}:{ñ ��4657(��'%�*)9����:­4Ø���Z����42�9�()+42)+4¾-ÔvDýsþ�üN��:��L:�E��s-/'0���21}Á�) J�ñô1&��:Ý:,�2������'0�( �'D�}B()+E}:Ý:<�(��)":OJ%G_)+4¾-ù�ü�õËñÔøQ� õ�ö�÷£ö¤� ù øs5�õPö�÷_��ø�H�+12��4!WSRs)�TQ'U���ß��7V)+4¾-Ö�(���ß�V:��(OYü���5 u �DB�-���:L�D�(4¬�L�VU}��ñ ù $"�&�('%��)+�#��WXRs)+)�Tß'U���ß��7V)+4¾-À�(���ß�V:��

O u � ü�Y u 5 u �DB�-���:��D�(4Þ�L�VU}��ñè�R:�E&�s-/'0���21Þ�#JA�+12�.=�E�'DP(4|-/'D���21H@xõ�5IH ù ø%;

Page 76: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û Ûþ��HÌ0���L�(Ì8úÖ�D�2�_��\k�U�� Ý�\s\Z�yÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈÝÍOÌDÅ�� \k�U�� Ýl\7��Ë�µÞ�|È0�UÌD�`\IÎ/�&ÍOÅ/Ì��Ü�(ÌP³�`]2�`ܶµ�ÈQ\IÈ­Å(Í

ù �,Ê��(Ì0�Q\I�D�­Î/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈxÝ*Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/ÈP\I�Q\�Å7]»ò��ó/Û[�%�þ��Ü��\sÜsÜC\2Ì0È0��Ê�Ì0�<ÈD�^]}�Æ�ÝÊ&ÌDÅ�Å(Í´Å(Í´�U���·´��(È0� ù(M b�`¾�(È �U�\�ȦÊ�Ì0Å�Å_ÍN\�ȦÌ0���L�(Ì!ú��(ËÜsµKÈQ\��RÊXÜ��_�

þ¬����\sÜSÜ!�U���^]¤³X\IÈQ´<É&ÈDÈZ�K�D�B´��X]X\�ð¾É��Ý�U���_�¨´XÅ/ÉXÜs³|Ëh�Ý�(Ê�ÊXÜs\��^³ß�UÅK�U����Î/�B]��XÌU�`Ü�´��(È0�(��þ¬�Ý�(Ê&ÊXÜsµ�U�\�È��U�^´��X]X\�ð¾É��K�DÅLÊ&ÌDÅV®/�A�U���­�D���<Å/Ì0���ÒÍOÅ(ÌÜ�U���~´��_ÈD� ù(M ����T�9]Ø�_^ `ba�c#d� �egf�¢�hZi?a�¢�¢jeka3d?l0mØ¡

þ��ÆÊ�ÌDÅV®/�Ü�D���ÆÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ��\s]�ÎÝ�D���<Å/Ì0���.`}ÌD�XÊ�ÌD�XÈD�^]¾�Q\S]&ÎA�D���Î]�Å7]}�DÌQ\k®�\��`Ü�Ê2�(Ì0� Å(Í!�����<Å(ÌD��� ò�� !ÍOÅ/Ì ùnM b��')( �¾²´±���� ���¹poqK���'���7(��'%G�����z�Á�) J�ñ©)":�����'%)��(4¾-/ "��$ÚJ%'U���T-/'D���21ß�(4!B�ù�ü^õtñ>ø�� üu 5�õ�ö ÷Ñ��øDÁ�+12��4�ñM)":��(�¨�ß�V:�� �_5 u �DB�-���:K�`h¨�(G�J%'U��� ����)+4¾-Q�<)ª�&�('%�*)+�,�<;ST'U�V�#JXWNû��X�1rlË!�R�{]�Å7]X]��XÎ}�_�Q\I®(���^\�Î/�^]}®/�B´��UÅ/ÌAÍOÅ/̹ùcü6õtñ>ø��`]³¬�_ÈDÈDÉ;�L�R�U���_�;ñ \IÈ�Ü"�(Ë!�BÜsÜI�B³ÈDÅK�U�2�_�¨®/�XÌ0�D�GJö��2�(È��L�V�\s�KÉ��8�Æ�^\�Î/�}�<`X\*�ù�(�I`,t¬ü�\�È4�L�V�\s�KÉ��.`2�`]X³ß���RÅ7]�ÎK�D���¼]&�B\IÎ/�¾ËhÅ/Ì0ÈÅ(Í�ö(`It u \IÈu�L�V�\���É��.�áþ¬�ѳ&Å7]}�U�ßË�µ ��v �D���ѳ��XÎ/ÌD�X�ßÅ(ÍÆ®/�<Ì��U��w�0�Jm2ÌDÅ�� �U�����B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ���nð¾É2���-\IÅ7]�È��_��®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ)öN�`]X³�b�`&�D���­ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�λ\s]��Rð�É��`ÜS\k�-\I�<Èy��Å7Üs³?¯

ùcüxt¬ü M i vzy ü t v û � ü{t u û � ü_t¬üGH Ý�ò&� û �ùcüxt u M i vzy u t v û � u t¬ütï Ý�ò&� ! �

5ÀÉXÜk�-\IÊXܶµ/\S]�ÎL�U���XÈD�A�,�ÆÅR�UÅ(Î/�X�D���<Ìy�`]X³.ÈP\s�RÊXÜs\IÍäµ/\s]�Î�`2�T�K�2��®(�(¯ùcü�û ý � ü � u û õ � üEì � u ø#�/bñï Ý�ò&�ª][�ós�ZÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈ�ÍOÌDÅ��|Ý�ò��\][�T�U���_�Z�U���XÌD�N�(ÌD�N�_�|�RÅ/È�����5ë®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ȼ]&Å(�y�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�y�UÅR�B\k�U���XÌxöNÅ/Ìyb �´��pÜSÜ!�U�X\IÈÜÈD����~ß�n/Z���RÅV®/\S]&Î��pÜSÜ!�B³�Î(�<È��`³V}0�`´<�^]¾�Æ�UÅH�K®(�<Ì��U�G¤\S]�~�`\��\�_��`&�_���RÅ/È��¨��5 u �B³&Î/�<ÈX`ÜI����®/�XÈÝ�HËX\IÊ2�(Ì0�Q\I�D�AÎ/ÌU�(Ê&�.��\k�U�ÖËX\IÊ2�(Ì��-\k�-\IÅ7]ÀÎ`\I®(�B]�Ë�µÛöN�`]³Þb�� ÷

Page 77: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

ûñü�T�9]Ø��� �ߢ/ Æ¢�a�dkf��w¢ �_m��,�

RÝÉ�ÌZÎ/�B]��XÌU�`Üb�R�X�D��Å/³ÀÉ�È0�<ÈK "�Pe/)9���0-/'D���21�)9�D�( ��� F)�C<E´��:��¨û��X�|r¬Ëh�N�`]Ö�B\IÎ/�B]}®(�B´X�DÅ/Ì�ÍOÅ(Ì�ñ�`]X³DÜI�X�¼õ���ü�H������*H#�2w�ø�Ëh����´BÜs\s�¾É�� � �U����´^ÜS\��¾É��¼\IÈZ "�Pe/)9���0-/'D���21�)9�·\kÍ#¯I��ü¸\IÈÆ�Ý®/�XÌ0�D�GL��\I�D���L�V�\����É;�Ô�Æ�^\�Î(�¾�¨Î7\k®/�^]�Ë�µXr��?�LÅ`]�έ®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XȨÅ_Í�ñ � � v \IȨ��®/�XÌ0�U��LÅ(Íp�L�V�\s�KÉ��Ô�T�B\IÎ/�}�Æ�?�LÅ`]�δ<Å��$�RÅ7]q]��^\�Î(��Ë!Å/Ì0ÈõÅ(Íp�±üGH�������H2� v e ü%`/ÍOÅ(ÌI� M bCH�������HUä � �U�&�δBÜs\s�¾É��Î\IÈ� "�Pe/)9���0-/'0���21�)9�D�( + FGÝ�L�Ye/$)+�L�( \kÍõ�D���<Ì0�x\IÈ�]&ÅÑÜI�G�\S´XÅ/Î/ÌD�(Ê��X\s´)´^ÜS\��¾É���Å7]Àä��§öN®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XÈ�´<Å7]}�U�`\S]\S]�Î á �±ü�H������*H2��w6â¾`c\��ù�(�I`�U�&�A®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È��±ü�H������*H2��wZ�2��®/�;]�Åq´<Å��$�RÅ7]�]��^\�Î/�¾Ë!Å/Ì<�

þ����L�:ú(���D����ÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV��\S]�Î�Å/Ë�ÈD�XÌ0®_�_�Q\�Å7]Ø`��Z�X\s´���\�ÈÆ�KÈQÜs\IÎ/�}��È0�DÌD�B]&Î(�U���^]X\s]�ÎHÅ(Í�Å/É&Ì ð Ê!�B´���UÌD�`Ü?��É�ÌU�p]Ö�D���<Å/Ì0��� ÝO�����<Å(ÌD�����&�Ú[��%�°N±�²´³¦²!µ�¶+·¤¶O²h¸v���¹��ã������ñ©������-/'0���21ß��4�5Ç7(��'%�*)9����:�4Ø���¦����42�9�()+42)+4¾-¼vqýsþ�ü���:��A:�E&�s-/'0���21&;�����Ir{���R�|4Ø��424Ø�*-¾�(��)+7(�R��)k-���427(�����#��'¦J���'¦ùcü6õtñ>ø0ÁZ�(4!B| "��� á ��üGH�������H2�2w^âë�����Q "�Pe/)9���0-/'0���21�)+$�D�( + FGL�L�Ye/)+�L�( ��� F)�C<E2�<;L=?12��4áùcü^õËñÔø`ûyù�ü^õ�@xõ�5IHUä�øQø%;ST'U�V�#JXW�þ¬�%�q\��q\S´­�U�&�NÊ&ÌDÅ�Å(Í�Å(Í ���&�<Å/Ì0�������ª[���û��X��å v Ëh�­�D���AÈD�X�yÅ(Í �`ÜsÜØ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È��`³?}0�`´X�B]}��UÅ���üGH�������H#� v e ü�H2� v þ�üGH�������H#�2ý,`�ÍOÅ/Ì6� M ö�H�������H ù �Ñm´Å(Ì%� M ö�H�������HUä)÷§ö/`²ÜI�X�q� v Ë!�H�U���LÈD���Å(ÍÜ®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È)]�Å(�H�p³?}0�`´<�^]}���UÅj� v `õ�`]³¯]�Å(���`³?}0�`´X�B]}���DÅÞ�_�xÜI���(È���Å7]&�ßÅ(Í�� v þ�ü�H������*H2��w���þ¬��U�&�B]�È�µ,�$�R���UÌQ\I�<�|�`ÜSܦ®(�<Ì0�Q\S´X�<ÈÔ\s]�� v �UÅ�� v �Uź´<Ì0���_�D�ß�`]¬ä��sÊ2�(Ì��-\k�U�RÎ/ÌU�_Ê��¯ñ6���Çþ¬�D´BÜ��`\s��U���_�R�U�X\IÈѳ�Å��<ÈD]�Å(�»³��^´<ÌD�<�(ÈD�Ö�U�����¾É2�`³�ÌD�_�-\s´ÀÍOÅ(Ì#�ê�_��r¦� å È»\s] ð �B´X�Q\�Å`]����ó&`Æ�T�Ö�ZÌP\I�D�r ý�� r M���� t ��� õ��Xø�`��Z���<Ì0� � õ��Xø M�� vzy � t v ��m´Å(Ì��S�%å v�� � v �Æ�N�2��®/�

��� õ��rø�û ��� õ���ø�û ����  õ���ø2H�U�&�ÀÈ0�B´<Å`]X³£\s]����¾É2�`Üs\k�!µ6ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ�ZÈLÍOÌDÅ�� �U���ÖÍ��`´X�R�U���_�¤f � õ���ø�� f ��  õ���øU`Æ�U����\2Ì0È0�LÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈË!�B´��_É�ÈD� á ö�H�������H2�Pâx\IÈ��_È��>ÜI�G�\s´<Å/Î/ÌD�(Ê��X\s´;´BÜs\s�¾É��_�T���¾É�Èù�ü�õËñÔø|ûyùcü6õtñ%�Bø`ûyùcü^õ*@;õ*5�HUä�øQø�� ÷ós�ZÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈ�ÍOÌDÅ��©�U�X\IÈZÊ�ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/ÈP\I�Q\�Å7]Q�D�2�_��\kÍ`ùcü^õËñÔø¨��õPöÎ÷Uö¤� ù ø,5uõPöÎ÷_��ø¨�`]³�����ö¤� ù u `�U�&�B]À�`]�µ{Ü����\S´XÅ/Î/ÌU�_Ê��X\s´��`ÜsÜsµ��L�V�\����pÜ&´BÜs\s�¾É��N�2�(ÈZÈQ\I�<�K�_��ÜI���(È�� ù �û��X� á ��ü�H������*H2��ýLâHË!���»ÜI�G�\s´<Å/Î(ÌU�(Ê��\S´<�`ÜSܶµj����\��L�`Ü4´BÜs\s�¾É��_�Ýû��X��å v Ëh�A�U�&��ÈD���ÝÅ(ͦ�`ÜSÜ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈH�`³V}0�`´<�^]¾�K�UÅ��±üGH�������H2� v e üGH2� v þ�ü�H�������H2��ý#`�ÍOÅ/ÌX� M ö�H�������H ù �Q���&�ßÈD���UÈÔå v \S]³�ÉX´<�ß�

Page 78: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û [ù �,Ê��(Ì0�Q\I�D�ÝÎ/ÌU�_Ê��{ñ6�V� p �`ÜsÜh�U�&�­ÈD�X�ÜÅ(Í�ÌD����p\S]X\s]�ÎH®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È|~ß�(/Z���RÅV®�\s]�ÎR�`ÜsÜØ�^³�Î/�XÈÜ��\I�D�.�`]�B]³o\s]L~jÜI����®/�XÈK� ù �,Ê2�(Ì��-\k�U��Î(ÌU�(Ê��Ø�)RÝÉ�Ì�Î/�B]��XÌU�`ܲ\S³&���¤\IÈÝ�UÅ|È0��ÅV�¼�D�2�_�6~j´<�`]Û]��X®(�<ÌAË!��UÅ�Å)Ü��(Ì0Î/�(`�Î7\k®/�B]|�D�2�_��ù�ü�\IȨÜ��(ÌDÎ(�(�õ���X\IÈÜ��Å`ÜS³�ÈTÍOÅ/Ì ùnM b�`&�(ÈT�T��È0��ÅV�Æ�^³Ö�(ËhÅV®(�(��m2Å/Ì ùnM �&`�T�KÈ0��ÅV�{�U���_��\I�y�`ÜIÈDÅL��Å7Üs³�ÈX`2Ë�É&��³�Å��<È�]�Å(�ZÈ0�<���ô�DÅHÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�ü�<�(ÈQ\sÜsµÖ�_ÈÎ\I��³X\s³ÖÍOÅ(Ì ù(M b��

m2Å/Ì.�_Ü����\S´XÅ/Î/ÌU�_Ê��X\s´��`ÜsÜsµ¡�L�V�\��L�`Ü�´BÜs\s�¾É�� á ��ü�H������*H#�2ýLâ¾`��`]X³3�`ÜsÜÔö ûêäÿû ù `��T��G&���q\s]��A�U���A�B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��N���¾É2�_�Q\�Å`]�È������U���1\2Ì0È0�yä�®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È<¯ùcü6õ�t¬ü*��©G©G©3�¢tXw^ø M i vzy ü t v �è©G©G©�� ivzy w t v ������­ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�ÎDÜ���$�L�R��\SÜsÜ����BÜIÊ�\S].�ÆÅ(Ì!ú±\S]&ÎL��\k�U�.�U���A���É��_�-\IÅ7]Þ�_ËhÅV®/�_�������������¹N �������t¬ü���©G©G©��£t d ��z�ÁÆ�(4!B|��:�:�E��ß�ù�)":K�ß42E��L����'�:<�(�*)":OJ%G�)+4¾-ù�õ9¤�ü���©G©G©��¥¤ d ø`û�¤�üxt¬üb�è©G©G©���¤ d t d �»��¨�+12��4�J��� + "�2h :A�+1&�(�

ù�ûè<Dò2óxôk¤�üGH ¤�ü*��¤ ub H�������H ¤�üb�è©G©G©3�¥¤ d5 ú �ST'U�V�#JXW¦���&��Ê�Ì0Å�Å(ÍhÉ�È0�<È��­�U�^´��X]X\���É&��´��`ÜsÜI�B³N¦­���� ´'U�D�('%'0�(4¾-����ß��42�*�um´Å(Ì�´XÅ7]}®/�^]X\��^]X´<�_`r³��\X]��t d þ�ü M z&� ð �X�0�-\s]�Î)¦ M <Dò2ó á ¤�üGHGõ"¤ü���¤ u ø��/b,H�������HYõ9¤�ü��%©G©G©"��¤ d ø���5²â¾`/�T���2��®(��¤�ü��Û©G©G©9�¤ f û{â)©2¦ ÍOÅ/ÌZ�`ÜsÜ�â´�������~´XÅ7]X´BÜIÉ�ÈP\�Å7]ÖÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈ�\s���R�B³X\��_�D�BܶµQÍOÌDÅ�� ÌD�X�ZÌP\I�Q\S]&ÎL�D���AÈDÉ��.¯

ù&õ"¤ü��è©G©G©���¤ d ø`û�¤�üxt¬ü*��©G©G©3��¤ d t dM di v j ü õ9¤�ü*��©G©G©3�¥¤ v ø�õ�t v ÷§t v þ�ü-øû div j ü �L¦ õ�t v ÷wt v þ�ü�øM ¦ õ�t¬üb��©G©G©��¢t d ø ÷

Page 79: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û�¨�T�9]Ø�9� ©�h"lId�a[�xc{�%¢ªeka3d?l0mØ¡

þ����R�^]¾�Q\�Å`]��B³ß�(ËhÅV®(�Ü�U�2�_�¦�D����ÈD�^´<Å7]³»´^Ü"�`\��ÔÅ_Íh���&�<Å/Ì0���«��� ! ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈõÍOÌDÅ����D����\2ÌDÈ����\k�U��`]ë�p]2�`ܶµ�ÈP\�È­Å_Í ù �,Ê2�(Ì��-\k�U�KÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��È<�Wþ¬�u\2Ì0È0�­È0��ÅV� �U�2�_�¼\IÍT� ù �sÊ2�(Ì��-\k�U��Î(ÌU�(Ê����2�(ÈÝÅ7]&�Å(Ͳ\I�DÈ�´<Å7ÜIÅ/ÌδBÜ��(È0ÈD�<Èy�UÅ�ÅqÜ"�(Ì0Î/�(`��U���^]Ö�D���AÈDÊ!�B´X�DÌU�`Ü�ÌD�`³X\IÉ�È�\�ÈZÈ#�L�`ÜsÜ��������������¹´�������¬ñ©�����L�������! "���,� ù $"�&�('%��)+�#�T-/'0���21|��4�5¬7(��'%��)9����:�Á �(4!B���:�:�E��ß���O1&�(�¦��4Ø����� "��'��� I��:�:Ý1&��:­:�)sæ��Z5 ü M õPö¤� ù �wr`ø,5�Á2J���'Ý:V���ß��r���z�;�=?12��4ùcü^õËñÔø`û õPö�÷+ö¤� ù ø,5�õ�ö�÷vr u � ù ø��ST'U�V�#JXWTós�ZÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈyÍOÌ0Å��Ò�D���N�(ÌDÎ/É;�L�^]}�UÈ�\S]Ö�U���AÊ�Ì0Å�Å(Í Å(Í û�������$��� ü ]>\S] ð �B´��-\IÅ7]ª��� ¨ �U�2���ÍOÅ/ÌR54üu\;��B³Z\S]w�o´XÅ��RÊXÜ����U� ù �,Ê2�(Ì��-\k�U�.Î/ÌD�(Ê��?`¨�U���ÖÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜyÌD�`³X\IÉ�ÈD\�È$�L�V�\s�KÉ��êÍOÅ/ÌL�`ÜSÜÅ(�D���<̨´XÅ7ÜIÅ/̨´BÜ��(È0ÈD�<È����V®/\s]�ÎR���¾É2�`ÜØÈQ\I�<�(�[þ¬�¬�L�Yµ|�(È0ÈDÉ��R�N�`ÜsÜ ù ÷�ö­Å_�U���X̨´BÜ��(ÈDÈ0�<ÈZ�2��®/�­ÈP\��X�5 u M ©G©G© M 5cý M õPöV� ù ÷lr��õ ù ÷+öpøPø,5Ç�`]X³ÖÎ/������¾É2�`Ü?�T�B\IÎ/�}���Æ���¾É�Èy�U���AÈ0Êh�^´X�UÌD�`Ü�ÌU�`³\�É�È�\IÈË!Å/ÉX]X³��^³��_ËhÅV®/�NË�µ|�U�&�;Ü��(Ì0Î/�<È����^\�Î(�B]}®_�`Ü�É&�KÅ(Í��U�&��bE­ëbE�L�_�UÌP\zìí z õ ù ÷+ö2ø�õPöV� ù ÷lr_�õ ù ÷+ö2øQø,5

õPö¤� ù �6r7øs5 õ ù ÷lb�ø�õPöV� ù ÷lr_�õ ù ÷+ö2øQø,5 îï �û��X�Æþuõ&ù�ø�Ë!���U����´��2�(ÌD�`´X�D�<ÌP\�È��-\s´�Ê!Å7ܶµ�]&Å��q\"�`Ü2Å_Íh�D�X\�È��L�_�UÌP\zh�õ���\�È�\�Ȩ�1�¾É2�`³�ÌD�_�-\s´���\I�D�ßÅ7]&�Ê!Å/ÈQ\k�D®(��ÌDÅ�Å(�������&��Ê�Ì0Å/ÊhÅ(ÈQ\k�-\IÅ7]J\IÈ��D���B]ÞÊ&ÌDÅV®/�^³ë˱µÖÈ0��ÅV��\S]�Î��U�2�_���U���NÊ!Å/ÈQ\k�-\k®/��Ì0Å�Å_��\IÈ��DÅ�U�&�;ÜI�XÍ+�yÅ(Í·õPö�÷£öV� ù ø,5uõPö�÷+ö¤� ù ø#r u `\*�ù�(�I`2�U�2�_��þ²õQõPöÎ÷+öV� ù ø,5uõPö�÷£ö¤� ù ø#r u øÆ��z&��þ��A�2��®(�(¯þuõPõPö�÷£ö¤� ù øs5�õ�ö�÷lr u � ù øPø M r u 5 uù_® g ù ® ÷ ùx¯ � ù u ÷é� ùx¯ r��wb ù u r�� ù u r u �wr u m H�Z�X\s´��J\IÈZÎ/ÌD�<�_�U�XÌZ�D�2�`]Öz�ÍOÅ/ÌZ�`ÜsÜ ù ��öN�`]X³ÀzH��r���ö(`2�(ÈZÌD���É\�Ì0�B³?� ÷

þ��6�L�Yµ{]�ÅV�ãÉ�È0�­�U�X\IÈ��UÅLÈD��ÅV�{�D�2�_��\s]À���&�<Å/Ì0������� ! �U�2�_�xÝl\S\Z�¨\s�RÊXÜs\I�<È)Ý�\Z���°N±�²´³¦²!µ�¶+·¤¶O²h¸v��Sb´º¼�����&ñô���­�­-/'0���21.��4R5¿7(��'%�*)9����:�4Ø���T����42�9�()+42)+4¾-�vDýsþ�üÝ��:Ý��:�E&�s-/'0���21:<�(��)":OJ%G_)+4¾-�ù�ü^õtñ>ø�� õPö�÷�ö¤� ù øs5�õPö¼÷���ø�;������(rã�����.4Ø��424Ø�*-¾�(�*)+7(����)k-���427(�����#��'¨J���'/ù�ü�õËñÔø�(4!BÇ "��� á ��ü�H������#��ý!âv���.�Ç "�Pe/)9���0-/'0���21�)9�D�( + FG��L�Ye/)+�L�( ��� F)�C<E´�<;§¦�:�:�E��ß�Q�+1&�(�N�+12��'U�Ö�('U�Ö�(��ß�V:���rV5t7(��'%�*)9����:�4Ø�����}B�ã<������42���,� ù ÷oöR7(��'���)9����:A�#Jy�O12�� "�Pe/)9���0-/'0���21�)9�D�( + FGN�L�Ye/)+�L�( ?�� F)�C<E2�<;=?12��4Ö'����ß��7V)+4¾-��(�¦�ß�V:���õsrI� ù ¯ Y u � ü�Y u ø,5v7(��'%�*)9����:�Áõ)�;��<;IÁ¨�(�¦�ß�V:���õsrI� ù ¯ Y u � ü�Y u ø,5 u �DB�-���:�Á&ñ�D�(4���N�L�}B��K�H:�E��s-/'0���21ë�#J|=&E�'0P(4Ø× :y-/'0���21R@;õ*5�H ù ø�;

Page 80: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û �ST'U�V�#JXWAû����%~MË!���U�&�HÈD�X�AÅ_ÍÜ�_�¬�LÅ(È0�KrV5¿®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XÈx]�Å_�N�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�­�UÅ ù ÷§ö�®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XÈKÅ(ͨ�U�&�´BÜs\s´<É�� á ��ü�H�������H2��ý!â¾�Zû��X��ñ6��Ë!�K�D��� ù �sÊ2�(Ì��-\k�U�NÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��Å/Ë&�U�`\s]��B³ÖÍOÌDÅ�� ñ8Ë�µÀÈ�µ,�$�R���UÌQ\I�B\s]�Î��\k�U�|Ì0�<ÈDÊ!�B´��Ü�UÅ á ö�H�������H ù â~\s]��U�&��ÈU�?�L���Ü�Yµß�(È�\s]ß�D����Ê�Ì0Å�Å_Í�Å(Í�Ù¦ÌDÅ(ÊhÅ/ÈP\I�Q\�Å`]S���ª[ û `±\S]��U�X\IÈ´��_ÈD�AÅ7]Xܶµ{´��2�`]&Î7\S]&Î��U�&�A�`³?}0�`´X�B]X´^\��XÈ�Å(Í�®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ�\s]j~ß�[þ��A�2��®/�

ùcü6õËñ6�Bø��yù�ü^õtñ>ø�� õ�ö�÷+ö¤� ù ø,5uõPö�÷¯��ø��Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/ÈP\I�Q\�Å7]���� ¨ Û��D���B]LÈD��ÅV�ZȦ�U���_��]�Å~´<Å7ÜIÅ/Ì�´^Ü"�_ÈDÈ�\S]Dñ6��´<�`]RËh�ÎÜ��(Ì0Î/�<Ì �D�2�`]�õPöV� ù � ñ ù ��ø,5 ����¾É�ÈÆÌ0���RÅV®/\S]�Î��_�Q�RÅ/È�� ñ ù ��5Ö®(�<Ì0�Q\S´X�<ÈÆÍOÌ0Å��Ä�<�`´��¤´<Å`Ü�Å/Ì�´BÜ��(È0ÈTÅ(Í&ñ%��`��`]X³L�U���Z®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È�~ß`�T�N�DÌU�`]�È�ÍOÅ/Ì#� ñ \S]}�DÅ��RÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��ÀÅ_Í ��É�ÌU�p]?«\ÈZÎ/ÌD�(Ê��?� ÷

�T�9]Ø�k� �°a�dVlnmh¡ T�p�R§��2 n��d±c, Ic, �e§².³õ��XÌD�­�Æ�NÊ�Ì0Ť®(�N�D���­ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�ÎL�D���<Å(ÌD���.¯

')( �¾²´±���� ��Sb� �K���'À��7(��'%G¤�v�Mzv�O12��'U�.)":.�´OÖ:�E´��1t�O1&�(����7(��'%G�ñ ��4�5�7(��'���)9����:Q4Ø�������42�9�()+42)+4¾-Ôv ® ��:N�L:�E��s-/'0���21À�(4!BR:<�(��)":OJ%G�)+4¾-ùcü6õËñÔø�� b� 5�õ�ö�÷_�±ø Ý���� ü Û[�)":��(�¨�ß�V:��IO-��5 u �DB�-���:N�`h¨�(GyJ%'U���M� ù $"�&�('%��)+�#��-/'0���21&;ST'U�V�#JXWßþ��ß��\sÜsÜ��`´X�DÉ2�`ÜsÜsµ�ÈD��ÅV�©�U�2�����U��� ù �,Ê2�(Ì��-\k�U�|Î(ÌU�(Ê��tÎ`\I®(�B]vË�µt��ÜI�G�\S´XÅ/Î/ÌD�(Ê��X\s´��`Üsܶµ

�L�V�\s�L�`Ü ´^ÜS\��¾É��{Ý+�U���­®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈÝÅ(Í��U�X\IÈ��(ÌD�N�`ÜsÜ?®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈÝÅ(Í�ñ �`³?}0�`´X�B]}���DÅ ù ÷+öN®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È�Å(Í�U�&�;´^ÜS\��¾É��3�δ<Å`]¾�U�`\s]�Èy�_��Ü��<�(È0�y5�õ�ö�÷.O���ø¨®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È<`´Ê�Ì0ÅV®�\s]�ÎL�U���Ý�D���<Å/Ì0���.�þ��AÊ�Ì0ÅV®/�A�U���­�U�&�<Å/Ì0���ÒÍOÅ/Ì|O M b(z&��m2Å/ÌδXÅ7]}®/�B]\��^]X´<�_`¬ÜI�X��r M b(z2��������QÊ�Ì0Å�Å(Í�\IÈHË�µ_´XÅ7]}�UÌU�p³X\S´��-\IÅ7]?�¬û��X�qñ �2��®/�|®/�XÌ0�D�GvÈ0�X� á ö�H�������HU54âÖ�`]X³v�(È0ÈDÉ��R�

\k�x\IÈ~Ü"�_Ëh�^Ü��^³�ÈDÅ.�U���_�»õPö�H%b,H��/ø�\IÈ��{ÜI�G�\s´<Å/Î/ÌD�(Ê��X\s´��pÜSܶµµ����\��L�`Ü�´BÜs\s�¾É��R��\k�U��Ì0�<È0Êh�^´X�N�UÅÖ�]�Å7]]��<Î}���-\k®/�|�^\�Î/�^]}®/�B´��UÅ/ÌEr¦�_Ý�ósÍ��D���<Ì0�¤\�È)]�Å�ÜI�G�\S´XÅ/Î/ÌD�(Ê��X\s´��`Üsܶµ �9�L�V�\s�L�`ÜÎ���!´BÜs\���É&�(`õ�U�&�B]Ë�µ.Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/ÈP\I�Q\�Å7]����ª[ û `&�T�A�ÆÅ/ÉÜS³À�`ÜIÌD���p³µQ�2��®/�K�>´<Å7]}�DÌU�`³X\s´X�Q\�Å`]?�¶�

þ����(È0ÈDÉ��R�Z�U�2�_�¨Å/É&̦È0�UÌ0Å7]�Î/�XÌ�´^Ü"�p\s� \IȦÍ��`ÜIÈD�(`/\��\�_��`}�U�&��È0�X�4~�Å_ÍØ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈÜ�p³?}0�`´<�^]}�¨�DÅ�_�4�RÅ/È0�ÆÅ7]���®(�<Ì��U�G|���RÅ7]�λö�H%bCH-�N�2�_ÈQ�RÅ/ÌD�y�U�2�p].r¤5.®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È<��þ¬����\sÜSÜc³��<ÌP\I®(�­�KÈ0�<ÌP\��XÈÜÅ(Í´<Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]�ÈyÅ7]�ñL`2��®/�B]}�Q\"�`ÜsܶµÖ�(ÌDÌP\I®/\s]�Îß�����U���~´<Å`]¾�DÌU�`³\S´��-\IÅ7]®ùcü6õËñÔø¨��õ�ö�÷Uö¤�`�/øs5�õPö�÷¯��øU�

Page 81: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û øm2Å/Ìn� M ö�H%bCH-�&`�Ü����4~ v Ëh���U�&��È0�X�¨Å(ÍØ®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<ÈÆ�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�¨�UÅ6��Å`]XÜsµH���RÅ7]�Î á ö�H%bCH��/â � Ü����~��ÝË!�A�U���KÈD�X�Ý�`³?}0�`´X�B]}���DÅÑ]�Å`]���Å(Í á ö�H%bCH��/â � �U���^]·~ M ~��0¸� ~~üb¸� ~ u ¸� ~ ¯ �yû����¬¹ v�M º~ v ÂÚ`�`]X³»¹ M º~À M ¹��;�j¹Bü[�j¹ u ��¹ ¯ �¦x�Å(�Q\S´X���U�2�_��¹ M 5�÷Ûõ � ü u � � ü ¯ � � u ¯ ø�`}�Z���XÌD� ��v o·³��^]�Å(�U�XÈ�U�&�;]¾É��KËh�XÌ�Å_Íu´XÅ����LÅ`]º]��^\�Î(��Ë!Å/Ì0ÈyÅ_Í ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È|�T�p]X³Ñ®2��þ¬�A�2��®/�(¯

ùcü{t¬ü�û � ü u t ¯ �§õ � ü²÷ � ü u ø9t u M�� ü u t ¯ �§õ � ü ¯ �¢¹Yü�ø9t u Ý���� üBü �ùcü{t u û � ü u t ¯ �§õ � u ÷ � ü u ø9t¬ü M�� ü u t ¯ �§õ � u ¯ �¢¹ u ø9t¬ü Ý���� ü [��ùcü{t ¯ û � ü ¯ t u �§õ � ¯ ÷ � ü ¯ ø9t¬ü M�� ü u t ¯ �§õ � u ¯ �¢¹ ¯ ø9t¬ü Ý���� ü3¨ �°N±�²´³¦²!µ�¶+·¤¶O²h¸v��Sb!¹�»"J|¹��3rV5�Á¨�+12��4

� ü�� � u � � ¯ û½b_5{÷ rb 5 M b_5 g öÎ÷ rò m �ST'U�V�#JXW 5�÷ ��v o�û õ*5�÷ ��v ø���õ*5{÷ � oBø M*¼ ��v o�� ��v � � o�÷¿5I�� ü u � � ü ¯ � � u ¯ �3bõ � ü*� � u � � ¯ ø²÷#�(5I�rV5®û¡¹ M 5{÷èõ � ü u � � ü ¯ � � u ¯ ø�û�ò/5{÷lbõ � ü�� � u � � ¯ øå ]³À���^]X´<�� ü�� � u � � ¯ û½b_5{÷ rb 5 M b_5 g öÎ÷ rò m � ÷Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��� � ü�� � u � � ¯ ��b_5�õ�ö�÷tr_�_ò/ø��ST'U�V�#JXW�ø�µ|�D���AÊ�ÌD��®/\�Å/É&È�Ê�Ì0Å/Ê!Å/ÈQ\k�-\IÅ7]?`r\kÍ��D�X\IÈy�T�<Ì0�x]�Å_���UÌDÉ&�(`��U�&�B]j¹Ý��rV5 `´�`]X³ÖÌD��RŤ®/\s]�Î�`ÜsÜ��^³�Î/�XÈß��\I�D���`]��^]X³�Ê!Å7\S]}�{\s]¡~ß`Î\��\�_��`y�_���RÅ/È0�ÖrV5 u `yÌ0�<È0ÉXÜI�DȤ\s]��¯�V�L´<Å7ÜIÅ/ÌU�_ËXÜ��ÀÎ/ÌU�_Ê��

³����U�<Ì��q\S]��^³�Ë�µ á ö�H%b,H���â¾� ÷�����AÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV��\S]&ÎR�,�TÅÑ´XÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]�È�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ�½ÍOÌDÅ�� Ý���� û �Ü�`]³_Ý���� û ���Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6���¹ � üÜ��õsb_5?�`�/ø�õPöÎ÷_��ø��Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��Sb � ü�� � u ��õ*ò/5?�`�/ø�õPö�÷¯��ø��

Page 82: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û(�p Å7]�ÈP\S³��XÌQ\s]�ÎßÅ`]XÜsµß®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XÈ)öN�`]X³�b�`&�T�K���V®(�5{÷ � ü u û3b_5{÷èõ � ü�� � u øÆ��b_5{÷ ò/5� õPö�÷¯��ø M b_5� õPö4�wb2��ø2������AÈD�^´<Å7]³J\s]����¾É2�`Üs\k�!µÖÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈyË�µ p Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]j�&� ¨ �þ��­��\sÜSÜ?�ZÌP\I�D�x³&Ť��].�U�&�6\�ÌDÈ0�Z�D��ÌD�X�N�^\�Î(�B]}®_�`Ü�É&�K���É��_�-\IÅ7]�ÈZ�UÅ/Î(�X�U�&�<Ìy�(È<¯

ù�ü6õ�t¬üb�.t u �.t ¯ ø M i v�y ü t v � i vzy u t v � i vzy ¯ t v û½¤�ü{t¬ü*��¤ u t u ��¤ ¯ t ¯ H�Z���XÌD�À�T�ÖËhÅ/É]X³w�<�`´��wÈ0É������p]X³�Ë�µt�U���ÖË!�<È0�»t v ÊhÅ/È0ÈQ\IËXÜI�(`�� M ö�H%bCH-�&`¨�`]X³£¤ v \�ÈR�U�&�]¾É���Ë!�<Ì�Å(ÍZÈDÉ����L�`]X³&È��U�2�_��Î/�X�K�U�X\IÈ�Ë!Å/ÉX]³?�ëx�Å_�-\s´<���D�2�_�)]�Å´t v ´<�`]X]�Å(���(Ê�Ê!���(Ìx\S]¿�`ÜSÜ�U�&ÌD�<�AÈ0É��������-\IÅ7]�È<`!�(È��D�X\�È��TÅ/ÉXÜs³J\��RÊXÜsµQ�Dv ® ��þ��A�2��®(�(¯

¤ü|û3bõ�5{÷ � üQø4÷èõ"¹ u �¢¹ ¯ ø¤�üb�¥¤ u û3bõ�5{÷ � ü u øu÷w¹

¤�üb�¥¤ u �¥¤ ¯ M�� ü�� � u � � ¯ós�ZÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV��\����L�^³X\��_�U�^ÜsµQÍOÌ0Å��ôû������L�����Ú[ ! �D�2�_�°N±�²´³¦²!µ�¶+·¤¶O²h¸v��SbcbqK���'Wùcü�Á�hÆ�­1&�(7(�ùcü|û+<»ò�ó ô ¤�üGH ¤ü*��¤ ub H ¤ü*��¤ u ��¤ ¯� ú Ý���� ü � �

þ�����\SÜsÜ�]&Ť�3����?�D\s]��­�pÜSÜ´�U��Ì0�<�ÝÅ_Í?�U�����U�<Ì��RÈ·\s]X³X\k®�\s³�É2�pÜSܶµ/��þ��y�ÆÅ(ÉXÜS³{Üs\�ú(���DÅ�ÈD��ÅV��U���_�Z���`´��º\�È��DÅ�ÅHÈ����pÜSÜ�`N\*�ù�(�I`r\s�RÊXܶµ/\S]&Î��U���_�ù�üÆ��õ9b/�`�/øs5�õPöÎ÷ �±øU�m2Å/ÌÜ�U���­�D�X\�ÌP³Ö�D�<Ì��ôÅ(Í·õ*ò��sö�ò/øU`��Æ�A�2��®(�(¯

¤�ü���¤ u ��¤ ¯� M � ü�� � u � � ¯� û b_5� g ö�÷ rò m � b_5� õPö�÷_��ø�HÍOÅ/ÌZ�`ÜsÜ�ru��ò`���¾�ÈP\S]�Î p Å7]X³\I�Q\�Å7]���� ¨ `��T�NÈ0�<�A�U�2���

¤�ü*��¤ u û3b�õ*5{÷ � ü u ø²÷§¹Wû ò/5� õPö4�wb��±ø#r¤5¤�ü*��¤ ub û b�5� ÷ g(r�÷À¿ �� m 5Ç� b_5� õ�ö�÷ �±ø2H

Page 83: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û7ûÍOÅ/ÌZ�`ÜsÜ�ru��öVz2�/�p�&�ó!]�Üs\�Î/�}�­Å_Í�Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!Å/ÈQ\k�-\IÅ7]´�&� ¨�¨ `!�T��ÈD�X���U���_�6¤�ü��KÉ�È0�­Ë!�ÔÜ��(ÌDÎ(�<ÌZ�U�2�`]_õsb/�`�±ø,5�õ�ö�÷#��ø�����¾É�ÈZ�Æ�%�L�GµQ�(ÈDÈ0É��R�(¯Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��k � üÜ� b_5� õ�ö4�é��ø��ST'U�V�#JXW¨ósͲ]�Å(��`��T�­�ÆÅ(ÉXÜS³À�2��®/�_¯

¤ü|û½bõ*5{÷ � üQø|û3b 5 � õPö�÷lb2��ø2� ÷

Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��SÞÁ¹ u �¢¹ ¯ �ÃÂ� �_5��ST'U�V�#JXW¨ósͲ]�Å(��`��T�­�ÆÅ(ÉXÜS³À�2��®/�_¯¤ü|û3bõ�5{÷ � üQø4÷èõ"¹ u �¢¹ ¯ ø��b g 5{÷ b_5� õPöÎ÷_��ø m ÷ÀÂ� ��5

M b_5� ÷ �_5 ÷

m2ÌDÅ��©�U���XÈD�;´<Å7]X³\I�Q\�Å7]&È<`´Å(�U�&�<ÌDÈ�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ�A¯Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��so�t u ��t¬ü^õPö�÷vb2��ø2�ST'U�V�#JXW¨ósÍ�t u û£t¬ü^õPö�÷vb��±ø��D���B]ù�ü_t¬üpû � üxt u û � ü6õ�ö�÷lb2��ø_t¬ü

�`]X³Ö���^]X´<�ù�ü|û � ü6õPö�÷lb2��ø� b_5� õPö��#�±ø�õPö�÷vb2��ø� b_5� õPöÎ÷_��ø�HÉ�ÈP\S]�Î p Å7]X³\I�Q\�Å7]����Ä��� ÷

Page 84: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û�!x�ÅV��´XÅ��R�<ÈZ�U���~´XÅ��RÊXÜS\s´����U�B³ÀÊ2�(Ì����¦ós�ZÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈ�ÍOÌDÅ��çõ*ò��sö7ö�HDò��SöVb,HUò��söG��ø�`&�D�2�_�

ù�üxt u ü û � ü u t¬ü{t ¯ ��õ � ü²÷ � ü u ø_t¬ü{t u M�� ü u t¬ü{t ¯ ��õ"¹Bü*� � ü ¯ øù�üxt uu û � ü u t u t ¯ ��õ � u ÷ � ü u ø_t¬ü{t u M�� ü u t u t ¯ ��õ"¹ u � � u ¯ ø

ù�üxt u t ¯ û � ü ¯ t uu ��õ � ¯ ÷ � ü ¯ ø_t¬üxt u M�� ü ¯ t uu ��õ"¹ ¯ � � u ¯ øå ³X³X\s]�ÎR�U���XÈD�A�U��Ì0�<�­�UÅ(Î/�X�D���<ÌX`��Æ�N�2��®/�ù�ü g t u ü � t uu �¢t u t ¯b m û

û£t¬ü{t u gV¹Bü*� ¹Büb�¢¹ ub � � ü ¯ � � u ¯ m � � ü u t¬ü{t ¯ � öb � ü u t u t ¯ � öb � ü ¯ t uuM t¬ü{t u g 5{÷ � ü u ÷ ¹ u �¢¹ ¯b m � � ü u t¬ü{t ¯ � öb � ü u t u t ¯ � öb � ü ¯ t uuM t¬ü{t u g_5{÷ ¹ u �¥¹ ¯b m ÷ � ü u t¬ü^õ�t u ÷Åt ¯ ø

� öb õ � ü u � � ü ¯ ø9t uu ÷ öb � ü u t u õ�t u ÷wt ¯ øû£t¬ü{t u g 5{÷ ~ b m ÷ � ü u õ�t u ÷§t ¯ ø g t¬ü*� t ub m�`]X³Ö���^]X´<�

ùcü¾g�t u ü �¢t uu ÷ öb t u õ�t u ÷wt ¯ ø m ûû£t¬ü{t u g¤5{÷ ¹ u �¢¹ ¯b m ÷ ¹Büb t uu � � üb t uu ÷£õ�t u ÷§t ¯ ø � ü u g�t¬üb� t ub m/Z���(Ì0ÌU�`]�Î`\S]�ÎL�>Üs\I�0�-ÜI�(`��T�K�2��®(�

ù�ü^õ�t u ü �.t uu ø`û£t¬ü{t u g 5�� � üb t ut¬ü ÷ ¹Yüb t ut¬ü ÷ ¹ u �¢¹ ¯b m ÷÷èõ�t u ÷Åt ¯ ø � ü u õ�t¬ü*�¢t u �(b±ø��Øùcüxt u õ�t u ÷§t ¯ ø��(bû£t¬ü{t u õ*5$� � üb ÷+õ�ö�÷lb��±ø ~ b m ÷èõ�t u ÷§t ¯ ø g � ü u ��t ub ÷ ù�üb t u mM t¬ü{t u õ*5$� � üb ÷èõ�ö�÷vb2��ø ~ b m ÷ t u ÷§t ¯b ©3t u õt� � ü u ÷jùcü-ø

û��X��ê M ïGÆ e ï�Çu ©�t u õË� � ü u ÷Òù�ü-øU`\��\�_��`��U����Ü"�(È���ÈDÉ;�$�L�`]³�\s]ß�D���Ý���¾É2���-\IÅ7].�(Ë!Ť®(�(�[þ¬��L�Yµ{]�ÅV�Á�L�:ú_����®/�XÌPµ.È��UÌDÅ`]�Îß�_ÈDÈDÉ;�LÊ��-\IÅ7]�Å7] � ü u �

Page 85: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

û ]Ï ²!¸²1�¶O·V¶�²!¸6��7� � ü u � uÈ 5 �ST'U�V�#JXW�R��U�&�<Ì0��\IÈD�K�Æ�N�ÆÅ/ÉÜS³ë�2��®(�>� � ü u �ãb_5?�`�&`´ÍOÌDÅ��ô�Z�\S´��Û\k��ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ�ZÈy�U�2����ê£�ãzß�p]X³���^]X´<�_¯

ùcü6õ�t u ü �.t uu ø|û£t¬ü{t u g¤5$� � üb ÷èõ�ö�÷lb��±ø ¹b m H�Z�X\s´��J\��RÊXÜS\I�<Èù�ü|û öb g 5»� � üb ÷èõPö�÷vb2��ø ¹b m �

ø�µ p Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]j�&�É�H�T�K�2��®(�ù�ü|û öb g 5»� õ9b_5��`�±ø�õPö��#��øb ÷+õPö�÷lb2��ø rV5b mM b_5� g ö�÷ ö

¿õË�}r�÷lb2���6rG�(�/b�ø m� b_5� õPö�÷¯��ø�� ÷

þ��~]�ÅV�{�2��®/�� u M�� ü u ��õ � u ¯ �¥¹ u øT� ú_5

Ê � b2�� ©V5�`]X³ÖÉ�ÈP\S]�Î p Å7]X³\I�Q\�Å7]���� � ¯ù�üxt u û � u t¬üpû � u t u õ�öQ���p��ø

�`]X³ù�ü|û � u õ9¤¬���p��ø¨� ú_5

Ê õPö4��O-��ø�õ�ö��Z�p��ø¨� b� 5uõPö�÷¯��ø���X\IÈÎÜ"�_È0��\s]����¾É2�`Üs\k�!µQ��Å7Üs³�ÈÜÍOÅ/Ì·����z;�\z}b/ú�� ósÍ4�°��z;�ªz/b/ú�`��D���B]�ñª\I�DÈD�BÜkͲ´��`]X]&Å(���2��®/�6�RÅ/Ì0��U���_��r�©V5 u ��5 u �(bH�^³�Î/�XÈÔÝ+�Æ�A�UÅ�ÅBúQr M b(z[�%`����B]´<�A�U���AÌD�XÈDÉXÜk�Z�UÌP\I®/\��`ÜSܶµQÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈX����¾É�Èy�T�N�2��®/�;´<Å��RÊXÜI�X�D�B³À�D���AÊ�ÌDÅ�Å(Í�Å(Í������<Å(ÌD�����&� ¨-ü � ÷

Page 86: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

! Û����Ë Ì£�;:(A�$� .ÍZ�L�$ $��&��&¼�!�C:��X�{=x>Î<;�4D�����&Ï: ���&�;:(Ð�����*Ð����&�ó!]Ö�D�X\IÈ�ÈD�B´��-\IÅ7].�Æ�;´<Å7]&ÈQ\s³��<ÌZÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈÜ��\k�U�.�U���uÑN��'U�DB()+�s�('%)+ FGEÒÝ��E�4!B��DBHST'U���2��'���GXÓ4ý7Ô w��å Î/ÌU�_Ê���\�ÈZÈU�p\S³.�UÅR�2��®/�A�U�&�EÑN��'U�DB()+�s�('%)+ FGEÒÝ��E�4!B��DBRST'����2��'%��GuÓ ý7Ô w�\IÍÂæûõ"&oø<ÂÅû ù ©�Â�å»õ�&oø�ÂG�vä�H Õ�& ûèñ�HHÂ�åÑõ�&oø�Â�� ù � õ�Ó4ý7Ô w6ø

m2Å/Ì ä°��z�`(�Æ���L�YµKÈU�_ÍO�^ÜsµKÅ��q\I� �U���TÌD���¾ÉX\IÌD��R�B]}���U�2�_��Â�åDõ"&oø< � ù �.â´`/�(Èõ�`ÜsÜ&Î(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈÅ7]ÍO�X�T�<Ì­®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈK�DÌQ\k®/\"�`ÜsܶµëÈU�_�Q\�È�Íäµë�U���q´XÅ7]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]?�Dm2Å/Ì�]��XÎ}�_�-\k®/�Lä�`?�U���RÌD��¾ÉX\�Ì0���R�B]}��Å7]�U�&�HÈQ\I�<�RÅ(ͨå»õ"&%ø�\�È�\��RÊhÅ/Ì����`]}�<`��(ÈÝ�U���>\s]����É��`ÜS\k�!µëÍ��`\sÜ�ÈÝÍOÅ(Ì­ÈDÉ�Ë�Î(ÌU�(Ê��&È­Å7]ëÍO�X�Ô®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È ��U�&���U�<Ì�� ù Âæûõ"&oø<Â3��ä»\�È~]��XÎ}�_�-\k®/�_��ø�µJ³��\r]\S]�Îëâº\S]ë�D���H�Ü�YµÞ�T�q³X\S³Ø`��`]X³�2��®/\S]�Î.�U�&�ÌD��¾ÉX\�Ì0���R�B]}�N�U�2���|Â�åDõ"&oø<Âg� ù �½â�\s]�D���>´<Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]?`Ø�T�L�(ÌD�Ô´XÅ7]�ÈP\S³��XÌQ\s]�ÎÀ�`ÜSÜ�ÈDÉ�Ë&Î/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈÍOÅ/ÌÜ�Z�X\s´��À�D���~\S]&���¾É2�`Üs\I�!µ��L�:ú_�<È�ÈD�B]&ÈD�(�������È0�X�­Å(ÍõÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��È�ÈD�_�-\IÈ0Íäµ/\s]�Î.Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µ´Ó ý7Ô w�´��p]ÞËh�K���(ÈP\Sܶµº\S]}�U�XÌDÊ�Ì0�X�D�B³%\S]�Å/É�Ì�Ü"�`],�Î/É2�_Î/�ÜÅ(Í´ÍOÅ/Ì0ËX\S³³��B]HÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX��û�����:¤ý7Ô w¦Ë!�Æ�D����ÈD����Å(Í!�`ÜsÜ&Î/ÌD�(Ê���È�v Å7]R�_��Ü��<�(È0� ù ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È�2��®/\S]&δ�RÅ/ÌD�R�U�2�p] ù ©?Â�å»õtv ø�ÂV��ä.�B³�Î/�XÈ<`�\��ù�(�I`��U�&Å/ÈD�L��\I�D�_Ü"�_ÌDÎ/����®/�<ÌD�(Î/�»³��<Î/Ì0�<�_�Ö���&�B]Î/ÌD�(Ê���È�ÈD�_�-\IÈ0Íäµ/\s]�εÓ4ý7Ô wR�_ÌD�|����p´X�-ܶµ��D��Å/È0�|�Z�X\S´��é³�ÅÛ]&Å(�>´<Å`]¾�U�`\s]v�`]�µ¿Î/ÌD�(Ê��#\s]_: �_ÈH�ÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��?�þ��~]�ÅV�{ÌD�<È����_�D�KÅ(É�Ì�ÌD�XÈDÉXÜk��¯

')( �¾²´±���� ���������� ù �wÖ ×��(4!B�äE��÷ « ýsþ�üu ­ ;�» J�ñ8)":��Ý-/'0���21Q��4H5�7(��'%��)9����:�h¦)+�O1­�!'U���2��'%�*GÓ4ý7Ô w�Á¨�O12��4

ù�ü�õËñÔø`ûªõ ù ÷Uöpø��/b���ý õ ù ��ö2ø ù �wb_ä�� ñ ù 5�H�(4!B|��:�G����!�#����)9�D�( + FGVÁù�ü6õtñ>ø�û õ ù ÷+öpø#�/b�� ñ ù 5»��رõPöpø2�

KØE�'%�+12��'��ß��'U��Á��+12����:�G����!�#����)9�K����E�4!B�)":N�*)k-_1��9;x�Å(�Q\S´X�y�D�2�_��\kÍ ñ%��\�ÈT�AÈDÉ�Ë�Î(ÌU�(Ê���Å(Í&ñ{ÍOÅ(Ì��Z�\S´��ß�D���y�B³�Î/�yË!Å/ÉX]X³»\�È��-\IÎ/�}��`}�U�&�B]|�p]±µÅ(�D���<Ì�®/�XÌ0�U���Å(Í ñ�´��p]ßË!���`³V}0�`´<�^]¾�¨�UÅ��_���RÅ/È0� ù ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈÆÍOÌ0Å���ñ6�V�õ�����¼\s]}�UÉX\k�-\IÅ7]»\�È��U�2���\kÍ�5º\IÈ·Ü��(Ì0Î/�(`��`]X³Ññ�\�ÈÆ�NÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈU�_�Q\�È�Íäµ�\s]�Î��D�X\IÈÆÊ�Ì0Å/Êh�XÌ0�!µH��\k�U�S�L�V�\���É��©ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`Ü´ÌU�`³X\IÉ�ÈX`�U�&�B]£�RÅ/È0�ßÅ(ÍÝ�D����®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È.�(Ì0��Å7]Xܶµ6�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�|�DÅ��U��� ù ®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ|�U�2���|�2��®/�ª����\���É;��T�B\IÎ/�}�>ÝOÎ7\I®(�B]ÖË�µÖ�`].�B\IÎ/�B]}®/�^´X�DÅ/Ì��%��þ¬�A��\sÜsÜ�ÈD��ÅV�ü�D�2�_���U�\�È�\s]¾�DÉX\k�-\IÅ7]º\IÈ�´<Å/Ì0ÌD�^´X���

Page 87: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

!-ü�T�xÙ!�_^ Ú°a¤���i¬�i·�_m ¢·a¤¢(¡_¥�f7�

þ����B]é³X\IÈQ´XÉ�ÈDÈP\S]&Î�Ù¦ÌDÅ(Êh�XÌ0�!µÅÓ4ý7Ô w�`¸\k����\sÜSÜTËh�Ñ´<Å7]}®/�^]X\I�B]}�R�UÅëÈD���$Û M « ýsþ�üu ­ ��ä�`��_È�U�&�J´<Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]�ä£� ÷ « ýsþ�üu ­ ´��`]w�D���B]wËh�ÀÌD�<Ê&��ÌU�(È0�B³��(ÈSÛ¥�>z&`Z�`]³��(ÈL�Æ����\sÜsÜ�È0��ÅV�A`�U�&������DÌD����pܨÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈN��\sÜSÜ��2��®(���U�&��Î/ÌD�(Ê�� ¹�õ*5IH ù ø¼³&�\r]��^³_\s]¬�U�&�D]&�G���Ê2�_ÌU�(Î/ÌD�(Ê��¬�(ÈN�ÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��?`���\k�U�.�U���N�`³X³\I�Q\�Å7]ÖÅ(Í0ÛK�B³&Î/�<ÈX�û��X�)¹�õ�5IH ù ø�Ë!�L�D���LÎ/ÌU�(Ê&�¬Å7]®/�XÌ0�D�G�ÈD�X� á ö�H�������HU54â¾`�®(�<Ì0�Q\S´X�<È»ö�H�������H ù \s]X³�ÉX´^\S]�Î��´<Å��LÊÜ����U��Î/ÌD�(Ê��?`¾�`]³R�`ÜSÜ�Å(�U�&�<Ìõ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<Ȩ�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�¦�UÅ á ö�H�������H ù â¾� ósÍ!5Áû ù �Jö/`/�U�&�B]D¹�õ*5IH ù ø\IÈ�}�É�È0�Îv d ��x�Å(�Q\S´X���U�2���ι�õ*5�H ù ø¦�2�_ÈÆ�U����Ê�ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µSÓ ý7Ô wÜÍOÅ/ÌÆ�`ÜSÜ�Û/��m2Å/Ì�Û M z&`��Æ�Ý��\sÜSÜhÈD��ÅV��U���_�ι�õ*5�H ù ø¸\IÈÆ�D����ÉX]\s�¾É��­����DÌD����pÜØÎ/ÌD�(Ê��?��m2Å/Ì�Ü"�_ÌDÎ/�XÌT®_�`ÜIÉ��<ÈÜÅ_Í�Û}`��U�����G��UÌ0���L�`Ü?Î(ÌU�(Ê��&È��\sÜSÜ��2��®(�)¹�õ*5�H ù øÆ�(ÈZ�RÈDÉ�Ë�Î(ÌU�(Ê��À�`]X³.�2��®(�°Û��p³X³X\k�-\IÅ7]2�`Ü?�^³�Î/�XÈ<�

Γ(n,t) Π(n,t,s)

t +sKt Kt

t +s

+

+

t

t

t

n

t

n

Ks

t +

1

1

2 1

1

+1

���\X]��µÜ)õ*5�H ù H�Ûpø��DÅtËh�À�U���ÞÎ(ÌU�(Ê��wÅ7]�®/�XÌ0�U���ÈD��� á ö�H�������HU54â¾`Z��\k�U�è¹�õ�5IH ù øL�_ÈQ�ÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��?`��`]³��`³X³\S]�ά�`ÜsÜZ�B³�Î/�XÈ�Ë!�X�,�T�<�^]�Ê2�`\IÌDÈLÅ(Í�®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<ÈÑ\S] á ù � ö�H�������H ù �ÀÛ`â¾�wósÍ5Áû ù �¥Û/`��U���^]ªÜxõ*5IH ù H�Ûpø�\�Èn}�É�È0��v d �û��X��Ý�õ�5IH ù H�Û`øKË!�Q�U���QÈ0�X��Å(ÍÝ�pÜSÜÜÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈLÅ`]l5�®(�<Ì0�Q\S´X�<È��2��®�\s]�Î�U���.Ê�Ì0Å/Ê!�<Ì0�!µ§Ó4ý7Ô w�`�`]X³oÜI�X�1Ý*Þ¼õ*5IH ù H�ÛpøyËh�q\k�UÈAÈDÉ�Ë&ÈD�X�x´<Å`]¾�U�`\s]X\S]&ÎÀÅ7]ÜsµÞ�D��Å/È0�LÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈÝ��\I�D�¯¥ �B³�Î/�XÈ<�D���G\r]��ß)õ*5�H ù H�Ûpøy�UÅ.Ëh�H�D���RÈD�X�NÅ(ÍTÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê���È%& Å_Í�Üxõ*5IH ù H�Û���ö2ø���\k�U��U�&�LÊ&ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µLÓ4ý7Ô w<`��p]X³�2��®/\S]&Î|�_�|�RÅ/È0�¬Û��B³&Î/�<È����RÅ7]�ÎR�U���A®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È á ù ��ö�H������*H ù ��Û���öpâ¾�Üû��X��ß|Þ�õ�5IH ù H�ÛpøTË!�\k�UÈZÈDÉ�Ë&ÈD�X��´<Å`]¾�U�`\s]X\S]&Î�Å7]Üsµ|�D��Å/È0�NÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈZ��\k�U��¥è�^³�Î/�XÈ<������AÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV��\S]&ÎL�D���<Å/Ì0���j\IÈy�HÈ0�UÌ0�B]�Î_�U���^]X\S]&ÎßÅ(Í������<Å(ÌD�����&�ª]R�(Ë!ÅV®/�(�������NÈ0�DÌD�^]�Î(�U�,��B]\S]�ÎD\IÈ�\s].�U���AÈD�^]�ÈD�A�U���_�Z�Æ�AÎ7\k®/�K�HÈ0�UÌ0Å7]�Îq´��2�(ÌD�`´X�D�<ÌP\��<�_�-\IÅ7]�Å_Í ����DÌD����pÜ�Î(ÌU�(Ê��&È<�

Page 88: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

! [')( �¾²´±���� ��Sb2àK���'N�( + rñ«�ªÝ¼õ*5�H ù H�ÛpøDÁ¨�+12��'U�H�Pe/)":��O:N��-/'D���21q¹Å�¥ß)õ*5�H ù H�ÛpøõJ���'�h 1�)9��1

ùcü6õËñÔø�ûyù�ü�õ˹uø�������RËhÅ(ÉX]X³�ÈAÎ7\k®/�^]¯\s]Ç���&�<Å/Ì0���á���\]ß�U���^]ÇÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV� \��$�R�^³X\"���U�BܶµëÍOÌDÅ��è�<È��-\��L�_�U�XÈNÍOÅ/Ìùcü6õ"Üxõ*5IH ù H�Û*�¯öpøQøU�õ�����yÍ��`´X���U���_�T�D���yËhÅ/É]X³ßÎ7\k®/�^]¤\IÈÆ�(È�µ,�LÊ��UÅ(�Q\S´<�`ÜSܶµR�-\IÎ/�}��Ý+��\I�D�X\s]�Ø/õ�öpø{�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�ZÈ�ÍOÌDÅ�� �U�&�A®_�`ÜIÉ��AÅ(Í�ù�ü^õt¹�õ*5IH ù øQø���þ¬�­��\SÜsÜ&´��pÜS´XÉXÜ"���U�A�U���XÈD�AËh�^Ü�ÅV�A�

þ��ßÌD���L�(Ì8úë�U�2�_�ÚøÆÌDÉ��`ÜS³\Ü�`]X³ ð Å7ÜI���B\s³�Y ü�! ^TÊ�ÌDÅV®/�^³t�U�X\IÈ��U�&�<Å/Ì0��� ÍOÅ/Ì ùuM ö/`¦�p]X³�U���_� p ®/����ú(ÅV®/\�â|�`]X³µ/ZÅV��ÜS\s]�ÈDÅ`]�Y ¨-ü ^¸³&�X�U�XÌ#�q\s]��B³Ç�U���R�G��DÌD���L�`ܦÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈAÍOÅ(Ì­�`ÜsÜ(Û/`��p]X³5Ü��(ÌDÎ/�T�B]�Å(É�Î/�?`p´<Å7];\�Ì#�q\S]&ÎA��´<Å`]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�ÜÅ(Í�øÆÌ0É2�`Üs³X\&�p]X³ ð Å7ÜI���^\S³?�������Ü����DÌD����pÜ&Î/ÌD�(Ê���È �`ÜSÜ�2��®/�x¹�õ*5�HYöpø�`��U���AÈ0�U�(Ì<`��(Èy�RÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê�� � ÍOÅ(Ì|Û M �&`��D���N�`³X³X\k�-\IÅ7]2�pÜ?�B³�Î(�<È�ÍOÅ/Ì#�ô�H�DÌQ\��`]�Î7ÜI�(`�`]X³.ÍOÅ/Ì|ÛA�+��Ý*�`]X³Ö5ÛÜ��(ÌDÎ/�A�^]�Å/É�Î/�±��`��U�&�^µ|ÍOÅ/Ì��ô�RÈ0�U�(ÌÜ��\I�D�º´X�B]}�U�XÌ���� ù ��ö(�å È�\s]Þ�U�&��Ê�ÌDÅ�Å(Í�Å(Í����&�<Å/Ì0���ã�&�Ú[�`!�Æ����\sÜsÜõÈD��ÅV� �U���_�ÝÍOÅ/Ì��`]�µÀ®(�B´X�DÅ/̬r¦`Ø�D���<Ì0�Ô\IÈ­�Î/ÌD�(Ê��Û\s]�ßÔõ�5IH ù H�Û`øZ�Z�&Å/ÈD�E�¾É2�`³��UÌU���-\s´�ÍOÅ/Ì#� �_�¬ré\IÈA�_��ÜI���(È��Ý�U���_�­Å(Í�ñR«\ÈX�K�������D���<Å(ÌD����(Ë!ÅV®/�­�U���^]ÖÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈ�Ë�µ{ÜI�X�0�-\s]�Î$r¬Ë!�A�`]À�^\�Î(�B]}®/�^´X�UÅ(ÌyÍOÅ/ÌWùcü^õËñÔø��')( �¾²´±���� ��SbcÞqK���'���7(��'%G°r£�½Ö ä d Á(t¬ü%� ©G©G©b�åt d �Äz�Áy�(4!BAJ���'R�( + &ñ��.Ý*Þ�õ*5IH ù H�ÛpøDÁ�+12��'��N)":N��-/'D���21q¹Å�¥ß|Þ�õ�5IH ù H�Û`ø�J���'~h 1�)9��1

r ý � � rÒû�r ý ��æ r0�ST'U�V�#JXW¦���&��Ê�Ì0Å�Å_ͬ\IÈTË�µq\s]X³�ÉX´��-\IÅ7]|Å7]L5 � �����y�D���<Å(ÌD����\IÈ�´BÜI���(ÌPÜsµH�DÌDÉ��ZÍOÅ/Ì�5Áû ù � å È0ÈDÉ��R�5� ù �p]X³)ÜI�X�uñ%��Ë!�¨�D���TÎ(ÌU�(Ê��NÅ/Ë&�U�`\s]��B³NÍOÌDÅ���ñ�Ë�µ~³��^Ü����-\s]�ÎÝ�`ÜsÜ � d �B³�Î/�XÈ Å7]A®/�XÌ0�D�GK5ß�p]X³ÈD����r*� M õ�t¬üGH�������H2t d�e ü-ø ý �¦�����^]ÀË�µÑ\S]X³&ÉX´X�Q\�Å7]Ø`��U���XÌD��\IÈZ��Î/ÌU�(Ê&��¹b�|��ß|Þ e,çxè õ*5»÷Uö�H ù H�Û`øÍOÅ/ÌÜ�Z�X\s´��r ý � � ��  r*��û�r ý � ��æ   r����������´<Å7]}�DÌQ\IË�É&�-\IÅ7]ß�DÅN�D���|��É��`³�ÌU���-\s´yÍOÅ/Ì�� Å(Í&ñüÅ_ÍØ�U�&� � d �B³&Î/�<ÈÆ�`³?}0�`´X�B]}�T�DÅK5�\IÈTË!Å/ÉX]X³&�B³�(Ë!ÅV®/�AË�µQ�U���~´<Å`]¾�DÌQ\IË�É&�Q\�Å7]ÖÅ(Í��B³�Î(�<ÈZÍOÌDÅ�� 5�DÅH�U���1\2Ì0È0� � d ®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ<`c\*�ù�(�I`ivzy d t v t d û õ�t¬ü*��©G©G©��¢t çxè ø9t d �û��X�)¹uüAËh�R�U�&��Î/ÌD�(Ê��¯¹b�N��\I�D���U�&�|�`³X³\I�Q\�Å7]¬Å(ÍÆ®(�<Ì��U�G�56�`]X³¬�D���ß�^³�Î/�XÈKÍOÌDÅ�� 5l�DÅÀ�U�&�

\2Ì0È0� � d ®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ<�`þ��A�2��®/� r ý � � r½û�r ý ��æ3é rn�

Page 89: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

!�¨ós��\IÈ�Ê!Å/ÈDÈP\�ËÜ����D�2�_��¹uü�³�Å��<ȼ]�Å(�Ý���V®(�HÊ�ÌDÅ(Êh�XÌ0�!µªÓ4ý7Ô w�`hË�É&��\kÍ�\k��³�Å��<È<`�\*�ù�(�I`�\kÍ � d û ù `h�U�&�B]¹uü��¢ß�Þ¼õ*5�H ù H�ÛpøT�`]X³.�T�K�_ÌD�~³�Å7]��_� ð ÅH�Æ�%�L�GµQ�(ÈDÈ0É��R�N�D�2�_� � d � ù �û��X��q¸ü¨Ëh�y�U����ÈD�X�ÜÅ(Í��B³&Î/�<ÈÆÍOÌ0Å��85��UÅN®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ á ù �éö�H�������H � d â¾��þ¬����\sÜsܬ´<Ì0���_�D���U�&�³��XÈQ\IÌD�B³.Î/ÌD�(Ê���¹Å�¢ß�Þ¼õ*5�H ù H�ÛpøõÍOÌ0Å��z¹�ü¨Ë�µ��LÅV®/\s]�ÎH�U���Ý�^³�Î/�XÈÎ\S].q¸ü���þ���³&Å��U�X\IȨ\s]ÖÈ0ÉX´�����Ü�YµQ�D�2�_��¹Å�¥ß|Þ¼õ*5�H ù H�Ûpø�`2�p]X³ÀÈ0ÅL�D�2�_�

r ý ��æ�é rÒû�r ý ��æ r Ý���� ü ø����Å7Üs³�ÈX`��D��É&È�Ê�Ì0Ť®/\s]�ÎÀ�D���H�U���XÅ/ÌD��.�Çþ��H��\sÜSܦ®(�<ÌQ\kÍäµUÝ���� ü ø����^³�Î/����\�È0�(`�\��\�_��`�ÍOÅ/ÌA���p´����B³&Î/�á �#HD5²âN�Z�X\S´��.�T�%�RÅV®/�A�UÅ á ®�H�ârâ¾`��Æ�~³�ÅRÈ0ÅD\s].ÈDÉX´��À���Ü�Yµ|�D�2�_��®Çû£���p]X³D®ß��5 `&ÈDÅH�U�2���t v t d ûÁt¾oGt f ��þ¬�X\�ÌDÈ0��ÌD�XÊXÜ"�p´<�H�`]�µÖ�B³&Î/�)\s]ëq�ü�˱µ��`]�µÖ�B³�Î(�u�q\�È0ÈQ\s]�Î{\s]Û¹�õ*5IH ù ø��q\�È0ÈQ\s]�ÎÍOÌDÅ��ç¹uü%�AósÍ��Æ�>´<�`]ëÌD�XÊXÜ��`´<�R�`ÜsÜ��B³�Î/�XÈÝÍOÌDÅ�� q�ü�\s]Þ�U�X\IÈ��Æ�Yµ/`?�T�R�(ÌD�Ô³&Å7]��(�xR��U�}�T�<Ì���\�È0�(`´��pÜSÜ?�D���AÌD�<È0ÉXÜk�-\s]�Î�Î(ÌU�(Ê��º¹ u �`]X³.�U���AÈD���yÅ(Í Ì0���L�`\s]X\s]�Îß�^³�Î/�<Èyq u �������Î(ÌU�(Ê��¤¹ u �2�(È·¹�õ�5IH ù øõ�(ÈÆ�KÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��?`&È0ÅK�D���<Ì0�Ý�(Ì0�Ý�(Ì0���_�4�RÅ/È0��Û��B³�Î(�<ÈÜ�?�LÅ`]�Î�U�&��®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È á ù � ö�H�������HD5²â¾`õ�p]X³¬�D���<È0�¤´��`]��`ÜsܨË!���RÅV®/�^³��UÅÖ��\I�D�X\s]��U���$\2ÌDÈ��EÛ�� öLÅ(Í�U�&�<ÈD�|®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<ÈX`�\S]tÊ2�_Ì0�-\s´<ÉÜ"�(ÌX`��`ÜsÜT�^³�Î/�<È�ÍOÌ0Å�� q u ´<�`]tËh�ßÌD�<ÊÜ"�`´X�B³tË�µ¿�^³�Î/�XÈ á ù � ö�H2�Pâ¾`�Z���XÌD�%�`û ù ��Û4��ö/�����X\IÈ�]��X�üÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��\IÈ�¹¦`�ÍOÅ/ÌÜ�Z�X\s´��À�U�&�A�D���<Å(ÌD���Ò��Å7Üs³�È<�å ÜsÜ!�D�2�_�ÆÌD���L�`\s]�È�\�Ȩ�UÅÔ´����^´@ú��D����Ë!Å/ÉX]X³&È<��þ¬�¼³�ÅN�U�X\IȨ\s]ß�U���yÍOÅ/Ì#� Å_Í?�,�ÆÅ>ÜI�����L�(ÈX������������Sbko =?12�Ý:,�2������'0�( �'D�}B()+E}:��#J�¹�õ*5�H ù ø­)":<W

ùcü6õ˹�õ*5�H ù øQø M ù ÷+ö4� ñ ò ù 5{÷é� ù u ÷vb ù ��öb M ù ÷£öb � ñ ù 5»�¥Ø/õ�öpø��ST'U�V�#JXW�������®(�pÜ�É���Å(Í�ù�ü�õ˹�õ*5�H ù øQø�\IÈÜ�<�(ÈQ\sÜsµ»´<Å��LÊ&É&�U�^³À�_ÈÆ�U���XÌD�­�_ÌD��Å`]XÜsµL�,�TÅ�®/�<Ì��U��.Å/ÌDË\I�DÈÉX]X³&�<Ìy�(É&�DÅ��RÅ/ÌDÊ��\�È��LÈ��`]X³Ö���^]X´<��ù�ü�õ˹�õ*5�H ù øQø�\IÈ��U���~Ü��(ÌDÎ/�XÈ0�y�B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��NÅ(Íìí ù ÷£ö 5{÷ ùù z îï � ê

å ]�µNÎ/ÌU�_Ê��)ñå�¥ß)õ*5IH ù H�Ûpø?�2��®/\s]�Î��L�V�\����pÜXùcü6õtñ>ø!�T�Q�L�YµAËhÅ/É]X³��_ËhÅV®/�¨Ë�µA�ZÌQ\k�-\s]�Î\k�­�(È��D�����^³�Î/�Ô³\�È�}�Å7\S]}�­É]X\�Å`]ëÅ(Í��ßÎ/ÌD�(Ê�����\k�U�µÛ��^³�Î/�<È>Ý*���RÅ7]�Î��U����È0�X�;ê(�y�`]X³Û¹�õ*5�H ù ø�����¾É�Èy˱µÖÙ¦Ì0Å/Êh�XÌ0�!µÖ[�� ¨ Ý�\s\s\7�%`r\I��ÍOÅ7ÜsÜIŤ�ZÈZ�U���_�

ù�ü^õt¹�ø¨��õ ù ÷+öpø��/b�� ñ b�Û4� ñ ù 5I� Ý���� üV� �

Page 90: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

! ���Åx\s�RÊ�Ì0ÅV®/���D���y�<ÌDÌ0Å/Ì��U�<Ì��.`��T��´XÅ7]�ÈP\S³��XÌT�D����Î(ÌU�(Ê���Ü)õ�5IH ù H�Û*�¯ö2ø���¹�\IÈT�NÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê��Å(Í?�D�X\IÈ<`�ÈDÅ)\k�UÈTÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜhÌD�`³X\IÉ�È�\IÈÆË!Å/ÉX]³��B³Q�_ËhÅV®/��Ë�µL�D���yÈDÊ!�B´X�DÌU�`Ü!ÌU�p³X\�É&ÈÆÅ(Í�Ü)õ*5�H ù H�Ûb�_öpø��

þ¬�;´XÅ��RÊ�É&�D�A�D���­®_�`Ü�É&�NÅ_Í`ùcü^õ"Üxõ*5IH ù H�ÛQ�èöpøQø�\s]Ö�D���­ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�ÎqÜ���$�L�&¯�����������Sbg�M=?12�Ý:,�2������'0�( �'D�}B()+E}:��#J|Üxõ*5IH ù H�ÛpøÝ)":<Wùcü6õ"Üxõ*5�H ù H�ÛQ�èöpøQø M õ ù ÷+öpø��/b�� ñ ù 5»��رõPö2ø��ST'U�V�#JXWÇ�����XÌD�ë�(Ì0�À�D��ÌD�X��®/�XÌ0�U���Å/Ì0ËX\k�UÈßÉ]X³��<Ì��U���ë�_É&�UÅ��RÅ/Ì0Ê��X\IÈ#� Î/ÌDÅ(É�Ê?`����^]X´<���D��ÌD�X���\I�<Î/�}�UÈZÍOÅ/ÌÜ�D���A�B\IÎ/�B]}®/�^´X�DÅ/Ì<`h�`]X³öùcü^õ"Ü)õ�5IH ù H�ÛQ��ö2øQø�\IÈZ�D���~Ü"�_ÌDÎ/�XÈ0�y�B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��NÅ(Íì

ëëëëí ù ÷+ö Û4��ö 5{÷ ù ÷¢Û�÷£öù Û zù z z î{ììììï�`]X³Ö���^]X´<�A�U���~Ü��(ÌDÎ(�<È0�ZÌ0Å�Å_�ZÅ(ÍqDõQùcø M ù ¯ ÷èõ9ÛQ� ù ÷+ö2ø!ù u ÷èõ ù 5{÷ ù u ÷§Û ù ��Ûpø8ùX��Û ù õ*5�÷ ù ÷¢Û�÷£ö2ø����ÅÀÈ0�<�R�U�2�_�­�D���DÜ"�(Ì0Î/�<È��NÌDÅ�Å(�~\�È~]�Å_�X�RÅ/Ì0�H�U�2�`]ôùcü6õ˹�õ*5�H ù øQøb��رõPö2ø�`��Æ�$�L�YµëÈDÉ�Ë&È0�-\k�UÉ��U�

õ ù ÷+öpø#�/b�� ñ ù 5o\s].ÍOÅ/ÌWùÀ�(Ë!Ť®(�(�[þ¬�N���V®(�qDõQõ ù ÷¤öpø#�/bk� ñ ù 5²ø M öò g � ù{í Y u �ßb ùx¯ Y u ÷ ù ü�Y u m 5 ü�Y u � ö¿g � ùx¯ ÷�c[Û ù u ÷ ù u ÷¤ö¤b�Û ù ÷>� ù �ßb�Û;��ö m ����X\IÈÔ\IÈ�ËX\IÎ/Î/�XÌN�D�2�`]¿�X�<ÌDÅÀÍOÅ/ÌK5�Ü��(ÌDÎ/���B]�Å(É�Î/�èÝ�Û|�`]X³ ù �_ÌD�»\C&�^³k��`��Z�X\S´��#\��RÊXÜs\��XÈ��U�2���

ùcü6õ"Üxõ*5IH ù H�ÛQ�èöpøQøT��õ ù ÷+ö2ø��/b�� ñ ù 5 `2Ê�Ì0ÅV®�\s]�ÎR�U���~´^Ü"�`\��.� ê�����NÊ�ÌDÅ�Å(Í�Å(Í������<Å/Ì0�������\]>\�È��D���B]º´<Å��RÊXÜI�X�D�NË�µ Ý���� ü�� �Ü�`]X³Öû������L�$�&� ¨�û � ê

Page 91: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

! ø�T�xÙ!��� �N�2 �¡�¢¤£}¥¦¢/ ¨§(¢_¡µd� 4�£d?lgl4fscD§Vdp�xcD�2  ¡Å���Peka3d?lnmh¡¿¢��¢î(¢����gd�î,fO¢��2 ü¡_¥baxi dا_¢(¡Ï ²´±�²!Ð�Ð��&±¤Ñv��SbN  =?12�y-/'0���21D¹�õ*5�H ù ø­)":N�+12�AE�42)�C<E´�H�Pe/��'U���L�( 2-/'0���21­J���'�Û M z2;ST'U�V�#JXWÆx�Å(�Q\S´X�N�D�2�_�ZÍOÅ/Ì�Û M z&`��D���<Ì0�x\IÈ��LÉX]\s�¾É��NÎ/ÌU�_Ê��J¹w��ß)õ�5IH ù H�z±ø��ÆósÍ�ñ«�·Ý�õ�5IH ù H�z±ø\IÈT�p]±µRÎ(ÌU�(Ê��R��\k�U�L�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü´ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜ!ÌD�`³X\IÉ�È�ù�ü�`/�D���B]LÍOÅ/Ìõ�U�&���^\�Î/�^]}®/�B´��UÅ/Ì(rÀÅ(Í�ùcü6õËñÔø�`}�T��2��®/�¦ù�ü^õtñ>ø`û�r ý���æ�ï d Ô ý�ðñr¦�¦�����¬�L�V�\����pÜS\k�!µßÅ_Í�ù�ü^õtñ>øu\��LÊÜS\I�<È����É��`ÜS\k�!µß�`]X³|���^]X´<���U�2�_�4r\IÈ��`]Q�B\IÎ/�^]¾®(�B´��UÅ/Ì�ÍOÅ/Ì·¹�õ�5IH ù øU�¦�����Ý�^\�Î/�^]}®/�B´��UÅ/ÌZ���É��_�-\IÅ7]QÍOÅ/̨¹�õ�5IH ù ø�È0��ÅV�ZÈÜ�U�2���Æ�U�&��\2ÌDÈ��ù ®(�<Ì��-\s´<�<È|��É&È0��Ëh�N�`³?}0�p´<�B]}�Z�UÅR��®/�<Ì�µÖÅ(�U���XÌÜ®/�XÌ0�U��h`Ø�`]³Ö�&�B]X´X�N�D�2�_��ñ M ¹�õ*5�H ù ø�� ê

þ���2��®(�ÇÈ0Å��R�%\s���R�B³X\��_�D� ´XÅ/ÌDÅ7ÜsÜ��(ÌQ\I�<ÈX� �����·\2ÌDÈ��º\IÈ�³�É��Þ�DÅ p Å`ÜSÜ��_�U�Ç�`]³ ð \S]�ÅV�Î/ÅV��\k�U�LYª[ � ^��`]X³.�UÅLû�ÅV®_�(ÈD�N�`]X³ÀÙ��^ÜS\�ú��`]¿Y ��! ^9�Ï ²´±�²!Ð�Ð��&±¤Ñv��Sb´��������@ ���K�ß��'U����Á¨�O12��4�ùcü�û ñ 5{÷+ö_Á�h¦)+�O1��DC<E��( F)+��Gß) JK�(4!B.��42 FGL) JZ@ )":�+12�­:��s�('X;ST'U�V�#JXW¨���X\IÈyÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV�ZÈZÍOÌ0Å�� p Å(ÌDÅ7ÜsÜ"�_ÌPµN��� ¨�! �`]X³Öû������L����� ¨(� � êø�µÖÿ¦ÉXÜI�<Ì<«ùÈ�ÍOÅ(Ì#��ÉÜ"�RÍOÅ/ÌZÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��È����Ë!�B³X³��(ËXÜI��Å7]ÖÈDÉ�Ì�Í��`´<�XÈ>Ý�´XÅ��RÊ2�`´��­[��L³X\��L�^]�ÈQ\IÅ7]2�pÜ

�L�`]X\kÍOÅ7Üs³�È��%`��T�ß�2��®/�ÇÂæûõËñÔø�Âxû �hÂ�åDõËñÔø�Â�÷+� C `��Z���<Ì0� C \IÈK�D���ßÿ¦ÉXÜI�<Ìx´��2�(ÌD�`´X�D�<ÌQ\IÈ0�Q\S´�Å(Í�U�&�NÈ0É�Ì0Í��p´<�(�����X\IÈyÎ7\I®(�<ÈyÉ�ÈÏ ²´±�²!Ð�Ð��&±¤Ñv��� ¾º¼�����&ñM���A�A-/'0���21À���L���DB}B}�}�< "�­��4��H:�E�'+JX�����K�#J�òTE� "��'A��1&�('0�����#��'%)":���)9� C ;=?12��4ù�ü6õtñ>øT�§öQ��ý cXõ9b�÷ C ø�� ñ �(5�H�(4!B|��:�G����!�#����)9�D�( + FGVÁ

ù�ü�õËñÔøÆ�§ö4��ñ �_5$��رõPöpø2Hh 12��'U�A�+12��Ø/õ�öpøÝ'U�OJ���'U:N�,�N5·ó ô h 1�)+ "� C )":¸k4e��DB};

m2Å/Ì��`ÜsÜ?ÈDÉ&Ì0Í��`´X�<ÈZÅ(�U�&�<ÌÜ�U���`]Q�U���­ÊXÜ��`]��_`�Å/É�Ì�Ë!Å/ÉX]³�\��RÊ�ÌDÅV®(�<ÈZ�U����´XÅ��6y»´^\��^]}��Å_Í ñ 5\s]�Ê�Ì0�X®/\�Å(É�È�Ë!Å/ÉX]X³&ÈKÎ7\k®/�^]¿Ë�µµõ�Å7]&Î�Y � Û_^*�Nõ�Å`]�ÎÀÈ0��ÅV�Æ�^³��U�&��Ë!Å/ÉX]X³wOYü0� ñ O u 5õ`��Z���<Ì0�OBü���zR�`]X³ªO u �è�R�(Ì0��´<Å7]�È����`]}�DÈ�³&�<Ê!�B]X³X\s]�Î�Å7]Xܶµ|Å7] C `2�`]X³QÍOÅ/ÌZ�`ÜsÜ?È0É�Ì0Í��`´X�<ÈyÅ(�U�&�<ÌÜ�U���`]�U�&�NÊÜ"�`]&�(`pO u �+���

Page 92: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

!/�m2Å/Ì�ÊXÜ��`]2�_ÌÝÎ/ÌU�_Ê���È<`h�Æ�Ô\��RÊ�ÌDÅV®(�R�D����Ë!�<È��­Ê�ÌD��®/\�Å/É&È­ËhÅ/É]X³?`?Ë�É��Ý�U���)\s�RÊ�Ì0Ť®(���R�B]}�

\IȨ]��<Î`ÜS\IÎ7\IËXÜ��_��R­É&ÌÜÌD�XÈDÉXÜk��Î7\k®/�XÈ�ön� ñ �(5 `��Z���<Ì0���(È�Ê�Ì0�X®/\IÅ/É�È�Ë!Å/ÉX]X³�ÈÜ�T�<Ì0�­ò�� ñ �(5ÞÎ`\I®(�B]Ë�µ p �(Å��`]X³�ö�\s]X´<�LY\[ ü ^*`X\��LÊ&ÌDÅV®/�^³��UÅ�b ñ b|� ñ �(5ëË�µ�õyÅ7]�ÎÖY � Û_^9��T�xÙ!�9� ÷N���?¢( 4�2¥b�ð \s]X´<�A�U���­�ZÌP\I�Q\S]�ÎLÅ(Í��U�X\IÈ�´��2�(Ê&�D�<ÌX`!��Å���õ��Yµ/�<È��`]X³ÖóÆ���V®(�x\��RÊ�ÌDÅV®(�B³�É&ÊhÅ7] p Å/Ì0Å7Üz�Ü��(ÌPµN�&� ü Û�`�ÈD��ÅV��\s]�ÎR�U�2�_��\kÍ�ñ \IÈZ���KËh�^³X³2�(ËXÜI�NÅ7]��°\;��^³ÀÈ0É�Ì0Í��`´X�°ø�`��D���B]

ùcü^õËñÔø`û{ñ b_5»�¥O�H�Z���XÌD�§OJ\IÈÀ��´XÅ7]�È0�U�`]}�J³&�<Ê!�B]X³X\s]�Î6Å7]Xܶµ�É�ÊhÅ`]½�U�&�ÇÈ0É�Ì0Í��p´<�§ø��Âþ��Ç�2��®/�¬�`ÜIÈDÅ6ÈD��ÅV��]�U���_��ÍOÅ/Ì�5ÛÜ��(ÌDÎ/�­�^]�Å/É�Î(�?`��U���A����DÌD����pÜ�Î/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈZ�2��®/�­�,�ÆÅR®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<È�Å_Íu³��XÎ/ÌD�X�A5{÷£ö/�¦���X\IÈÉX]X\��¾É��Bܶµ>³����U�XÌ#�q\S]&�<Èõ�U�&���G��UÌ0���L�`Ü&Î(ÌU�(Ê���ÍOÅ(Ì��U�&�ÜÊXÜ��`]��~Ý+ÍOÅ/Ì 5¤Ü��(Ì0Î/�Ü�B]&Å/É�Î/�k�%`7´<Å`];\2Ì#�q\s]�Î��´<Å7]?}��^´X�DÉ�ÌD�¨Å(Í p �_Å��`]³Xö�\s]X´X��Y\[ ü ^}�D�2�_���U���¨�G��DÌD���L�`ܾÎ/ÌD�(Ê��;\�È�Ó u3ù Ó d�e u ÊX\s´X�DÉ�ÌD�^³�Ë!�BÜIÅV�A�

p �(Å­�`]³Xö�\s]X´X���`´X�DÉ2�`ÜsÜsµ;´XÅ7]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�B³��D�2�_���U���TÎ/ÌU�(Ê&���(Ë!ÅV®/�Æ���(ÈI�L�V�\���É���ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜÌU�p³X\�É&È����RÅ7]�ÎH�pÜSÜ!ÊXÜ��`]2�(ÌTÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈÜÅ7]|5À®/�<Ì��-\s´<�XÈ<`�ÍOÅ/ÌT�`ÜsÜØ5 ��þ¬��È0��ÅV�½�D�2�_�T�U�X\IȨ\IÈ·]�Å(�Æ�UÌDÉ&�ÍOÅ/ÌTÈ#�L�`ÜsÜØ5 `�ÍOÅ/ÌÆ����?�LÊÜ��Ý�Z���^].5 M ¿ `��D���ÝÎ/ÌD�(Ê��QË!�BÜIÅV�½���(ȨÜ��(ÌDÎ/�XÌÜÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`ÜØÌD�`³X\IÉ�ÈÆ�U�&�B]p �(ÅL�`]X³�ö�\s]X´X�(«ùÈ�Î/ÌD�(Ê��?�

Page 93: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

úµû�ü�ý "Û��þ 8ÿ.ý ��� ý þ ÿ���� ��� �

õ��XÌD�­�T�xÜs\�È��yÈD�X®(�<ÌD�`Ü�Å/Êh�^]ÀÊ&ÌDÅ/ËXÜI���RÈyÌD�^Ü"�_�D�B³.�UÅH�U�&�A�TÅ/Ì��¤\S].�U�\�È��U�&�<ÈQ\IÈ<�ú ���¼���*Bc���& Ð��C:�A¼$� ÅÍZ�L�$ � ���¼���åD�� Ð�:(A°N±�²kJ�Ð���� Þ?�� �ósÍy5èz õ�<��� Öò�ø�`¦�U�&�B]t�U���|�DÌQ\k®_�`Ü��^]}��Î(ÌU�(Ê��¿��\k�U�¢�q\S]\s�KÉ�� Î}�(Êv�2�_ȳX\����R�X�D�<Ì�� M �Xõ�5�÷tò�ø��_ò&�T�����XÌD�K�(ÌD�à�õ�5�÷tò/ø�� ¿ á�Î/ÌD�(Ê���È���\k�U�J³\"���R���U�<Ì����¨ó,È�\k�y�UÌDÉ&��U���_���U���AÎ/ÌD�(Ê���È���\k�U���L�V�\s�L�`Ü&³X\����R�X�D�<Ìy�2��®/�NÎ}�(Ê.È#�L�`ÜsÜI�<Ì��U�2�p]��`ÜsÜ?Å(�D���<Ì0È��°N±�²kJ�Ð���� Þ?��¹{ós�QÈD�X���RÈ��¾ÉX\I�D�%]2�_�UÉ&ÌU�`Üy�UÅv�(È��wÍOÅ/Ì|�tÎ/�^]��<ÌD�`Üs\��<�_�-\IÅ7]�Å(ÍNÅ/É�Ì|Ì0�<È0ÉXÜI�.ÍOÅ/Ì´<Å`]X]��B´��U�^³ � �,Ì0�<Î/ÉXÜ��(Ì�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�

�ÆÅ?}0�`]·5ÀÅ/�2�(Ì��`]X³Þó�È0É�Î/Î/�XÈ0�A�p]�Å(�U�&�<Ì�Î(�B]��XÌU�`Üs\��<�_�-\IÅ7]ÞÍOÅ/ÌZ�U�&��Ê�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���.¯�´<Å7]X]&�B´X�D�B³Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈyÅ(Í0�q\s]X\���É�� ³��XÎ/ÌD�X� � ÌD�_�U���XÌ��U�2�`] � �,ÌD�XÎ/ÉXÜ��(ÌZÎ/ÌU�_Ê���È<�`þ��;³��G\r]�����ü�`2�D���KÈ0�B´XÅ7]X³È#�L�`ÜsÜI�<È0�Ý�B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��HÅ(ͦ�U�&��û��(ÊXÜ��`´B\��`]´�L�_�DÌQ\�ÞÅ_Í�ñL`!�UÅ|Ë!�K�D�����^\�Î/�^]}®(�pÜ�É���Î}�(ÊéÝ���ü�\�ȼ]�ÅÜIÅ7]�Î/�XÌÝ���¾É2�`Ü��UÅ��cü�÷�� u �%����ü�\s]X´<Ì0���(È0�<È­��\k�U�ë�U���R�p³X³X\k�-\IÅ7]ëÅ(ͨ�B³�Î(�<È<`��p]X³Þ�U���XÌD��ÍOÅ/ÌD�HÅ7]&��TÅ/ÉXÜs³Q�G�Êh�^´X���RÅ/È��Ü®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈÜ�UÅ����V®(��³��<Î(ÌD�<� � ��Ý�¾�]XÜs\��(�­Ë!�XÍOÅ/Ì0�(`��Z�&�B]|�U�&��³��<Î(ÌD�<�¼\�ÈÜÅ/³X³?`�T�S�L�Gµ¯]�ÅV� ´<Å7]&ÈQ\s³��<ÌR�`]�µ¬5Á�«Ö ר`õÌU���U���XÌ��U�2�p]j}�É�È0���X®/�^]v5 ���{ós�Ô\IÈÔ]�Å(�)\s���R�B³X\��_�D�Bܶµ´BÜI���_Ì��U���_�­�`]À�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Î/ÌU�(Ê&����\SÜsÜ��2��®/�Ô´XÉ&�Ý�^³�Î/�<ÈX`��`]X³º\S]³��<�^³ëÌD�<Î(ÉXÜ"�_Ì�Î/ÌD�(Ê���È�Å(ͦ�X®(�B]³��XÎ/ÌD�X�;´<�`]X]�Å_�����V®(�x´XÉ&�y�B³�Î(�<È<�Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?�� ¡¦Ý:�:�E��ß�A5 z õt<!�� � ��öpø�;¬=?12��4Ç�+12�|����424Ø�����#�DBR-/'0���21���4À5�h¦)+�+1�H)+42)+�HE��MB��*-/'U��� � 1&�(7V)+4¾-ß�H)+42)+�HE�� ��)k-���427��( FE´�Z-¾���"��üA)":��!)9����E�'U�DBQ���� "�2h¨W

!�û

Page 94: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

!�!

1d -KKd 1d -K Kd

Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?��¹������xñ ���Ç������424Ø�����,�DBÇ-/'0���21{��46587(��'���)9����:��#J��H)+42)+�HE�� B��*-/'U��� �1&�(7V)+4¾-��H)+42)+�HE�� ��)k-���427��( FE2�N-¾������ü^õtñ>øR�(�ß��4¾-Þ�( + Æ����424Ø�����,�DBß-/'0���21}:|��4Þ5{7(��'%��)9����:|�#J�H)+42)+�HE�� B��*-/'U��� � ;v=?12��4Jñ )":Ý�&�(�O1�$, F)ZU}��Áy�(4!B�Pe����,�!�?J���'�:V���ß�L�< "�V��UV:R4Ø�D�('L�D����1¿��4!B�Á�( + ��< "�V��UV:��V����E�'%'%)+4¾-|)+4Þ�O12�N�H)�B}B& "�N�('����#JA�O12��J���'%�LW1d -K

ý ��(<�=�� �� ¯���b={:����&g�� �X$��ª��A;�*Bc���C:4=q"ED��;F��g�$��&����� �å Î/�^]��<ÌD�`ÜS\I�����-\IÅ7]¿Å(ÍZ��É�ÌU�p]?«\ÈK�U���XÅ/ÌD��Ö`¸´XÅ7]?}��^´X�UÉ&ÌD�B³vË�µ�ÿ�ÌP³Xa/ÈX`��`]X³¿Ê�Ì0ÅV®/�B³é\s]X³����Ê!�B]X³��^]}�-ܶµ6Ë�µ��ÆÅ`ÜSÜIÅ/Ë2�(ÈL�`]³w����Å��L�(È0Å7]üY$#VÛ¤^y�`]X³�ÿ¦ÌP³Xa/È��`]X³ ð�% ÈÖYÄ���(^�\�ÈLÎ7\k®/�^]U\s]6�U�&�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV��\s]�ÎR�U���XÅ/ÌD��Ö�')( �¾²´±���� Þ?�Sb+*'&�²!Ð�Ð�²kJ)(2µ+* ')( ²h�¬�2µ<²!¸,*u0ݱ2143!µ+*õ��¸²1§,.-!µ29�������ñ ���Þ�-/'D���213��4l57(��'%�*)9����:��(4!Bt��:�:�E��ß�.�+1&�(��ñ 1&��:���:Ö�L�(42Gv�DB�-���:Ö��:Ö�O12�l=�E�'0P(4t-/'0���21Ç@;õ*5IH ù ø�;Ò=?12��4��)+�+12��'�ñ M @;õ�5IH ù ø0Á¨��'Z�+12��'U��)":���7(��'%�,�Pe1��h 12�V:V��4Ø��)k-_1&����'�:�f¯õ��XøZ)+4!B(E2�����Ý-/'0���21H1&�(7V)+4¾-�ß��'U���DB�-���:A�+1&�(4Q@;õ � � H ù ÷+öpø�;ósÍ�ñ �2�(È%�RÅ/ÌD�L�B³�Î(�<ÈK�D�2�`]Ç�U���L��É&ÌU�`]¬Î/ÌU�(Ê&�?`��D���B]/�ÆÅ7]X³µ6Y$#0#X^¨È0��ÅV�Æ�^³¿�U�2�_�N�U�&�]��^\�Î/�¾Ë!Å/ÌDÈLÅ(ÍÝ�`]�µ¿®/�XÌ0�U��¥����\I�D���L�V�\���É�� ³��XÎ/ÌD�X�À�2��®(�j�RÅ/Ì0�Ö�^³�Î/�XÈ��U���`]l�D����´<Å/Ì0ÌD���

Page 95: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

! ]ÈDÊ!Å7]X³\S]�Î���É�ÌD�`]|Î/ÌD�(Ê���@xõ21436587VH ù ÷¯öpøU�(õ�\IÈQ�R�X�D��Å/³|É�ÈD�XÈ���Ì0�\r]���R�B]}��Å(Í)9�µ��_Ť®!«ùÈ�Ê�ÌDÅ�Å(Í#�þ¬�;´XÅ7]?}��^´X�UÉ&ÌD�A�U�2�_�ZË!Å(�D�ÖÅ_Í��D���<È0�KÌ0�<ÈDÉÜI�DÈ���Å`ÜS³�\S]Q�D���AÈDÊ!�B´X�DÌU�`Ü ´<�(ÈD�N�(È��T�BÜsÜ*¯Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?�kÔ�����rñÄ���Æ��-/'0���21H��4A5Þ7(��'%�*)9����:Æ�(4!BA��:�:�E��ß�¨�O1&�(�:��ü^õtñ>ø��;�cü6õ*@;õ�5IH ù øPø�;=?12��4¬��)+�+12��'�ñ M @;õ*5IH ù øDÁÜ��'­�+12��'U�N)":K��7(��'%�#�PeX�Ûh 12�V:V�A4Ø��)k-_1&����'U:�f¯õ��Xø­)+4!B(E2���N��-/'0���21ñ6�.:<�(��)":OJ%G_)+4¾-<�cü^õËñ6�^ø$�=��ü�õ*@;õ� f¯õ��Xø<¶H ù ÷ öpøQø%;§KØE�'%�+12��'��ß��'U��ÁÝ) J>�cü6õËñÔøL�?�cü6õ*@;õ�5IH ù øPøDÁ�+12��4Q�O12�A����4Ø�� FE}:�)9��4�12�� IB�:�J���'��(42GK7(��'%�,�Pe¬�.1&�(7V)+4¾-��L�Ye/)+�HE�� hÆ��)k-_1��h-/)+7(��4Ö�<G����2�V:�)+��)+7(���)k-���427(�����,��'õJ���'@��ü<;ó!]A#V] û Û&`ØxyÅ/ÈU�pÜÆY û(� ^�ÈD��ÅV�T�B³ë�U���_�¼\kͨ�ßÎ/ÌD�(Ê��Ûñ�³�Å��<ȼ]�Å(��´XÅ7]}���`\s]ë���DÌQ\��`]�Î7ÜI�(`´�U�&�B]�cü6õËñÔøCB ñ ¥ë�T���X\Iȼ\��RÊXÜs\��XÈ�Å/É&Ì ð Êh�^´X�UÌD�`Ü���É&ÌU�`]Ö�����<Å(ÌD��� ÍOÅ/ÌÜ�D���;´��(È0� ù�M b�`2Ë�µ.É�ÈQ\s]�Î��É�ÌU�`]Ø«\Èy�U���XÅ/ÌD��MÍOÅ(ÌZ�D���%����\���É;� ]¾É��KËh�XÌ�Å(ͦ�^³�Î/�XÈ<�Z�����K�D���<Å(ÌD��� \IÈ�È��UÌ0Å7]�Î/�XÌ�\s]��U�&�ÈD�^]�ÈD�Ý�D�2�_�¨ÍOÅ/ÌÜ�pÜSÜ´�UÌP\"�`]&Î7Ü����sÍOÌ0�<�yÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��Ȩ\k�ÜÎ7\k®/�XÈ���Ë!Å/ÉX]X³|Å`]��U�&�ÝÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜhÌD�`³X\IÉ�Ȩ\s]ß�U�XÌ#�RÈÅ(Í��U���~]¾É��KËh�XÌ�Å(Í��B³&Î/�<ÈX�ÿ¸Ü�Ê��\S´��ÇY ¨ ø�^�Ý�È0�<���`Ü�È0Å�Y � Û_^7�ÜÊ�ÌDÅV®(�B³À�D���AÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV��\S]&ÎßÌD�XÈDÉXÜk��`2�Z���XÌD� C õËñÔø¨\IÈ��U���;´���ÌDÅV��L�_�-\s´~]¾É���Ë!�<ÌX�')( �¾²´±���� Þ?�SÞ������²ñ ���K��-/'0���21�h¦)+�O1D¥ �DB�-���:N�(4!B.��1�'U���L�(�*)9�A42E��L����' C õËñÔø�;L=?12��4

�cü6õtñ>øDBãý b2¥%õPö�÷+ö¤� C õËñÔøQø#�þ���´<Å`]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�Ö�D�2�_�R�U�X\IÈRËhÅ(ÉX]X³l��Å7Üs³�ÈL��\k�U�l�U����´^ÜS\��¾É��J]¾É��KËh�XÌ»\s]6ÊÜ"�`´X�ÀÅ_Í��U�&�

´���Ì0Å��L�_�-\s´~]�É;��Ë!�<Ì<¯Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?�so������&ñ ���­�A-/'0���21R1&�(7V)+4¾-­5t7(��'%�*)9����:Ý�(4!B�¥ �DB�-���:�1&�(7V)+4¾-ß�� F)�C<E2��42E��H$����'FE�õËñÔø�;H=?12��4��ü^õtñ>ø,Bãý bp¥%õPö�÷+ö¤��E�õËñÔøQø#�

þ��AÌ0���L�(Ì2���U�2�_�ZÍOÅ/ÌCE�õtñ>ø M b��U�X\IÈ�\�È�x�Å/ÈD�`Ü�«\È��U�&�<Å/Ì0���.�ó!]lÍ��p´X��`¨�Æ���L�+�_�Ö�D���ÖÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV��\S]�ÎÇÈ0�DÌDÅ7]&Î/�<Ìq´<Å`]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�(`T�Z�\S´��?`T�UÅ/Î/���U���XÌH��\I�D�6�U�&��U�&�<Å/Ì0���ôÅ(Í ÿ¸Ü�Ê&�X\S´��´`´�ÆÅ(ÉXÜS³�\��LÊÜsµQ�D���AÊ�ÌD��®�\IÅ/É�È�´<Å`]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�(�

Page 96: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]/ÛÏ ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?�7�ã������ñ©���Z��-/'0���21�1&�(7V)+4¾-Z5¬7(��'%��)9����:y�(4!BÎ¥ �DB�-���:�4Ø��� ����42�9�()+42)+4¾-�vDýsþ�ü��:���:�E��s-/'0���21}ÁÜ�(4!B| "����r{�������2�V:�)+��)+7(�K7(�����#��'X;Ö=?12��4ë�+12��'U��)":�� ù $"�&�('%�*)+�,�Ý-/'D���21»& h¦)+�+15w7(��'%��)9����:K�(4!B)¥ �DB�-���:�Á2J���'�h 1�)9��1

r ý �HG rP��r ý � � r0�

Ì+�C:(A�$� wÍZ�L�$Ï:«A���& ,B¬��{<;�&ç�QD¼�À<x�&�é�(@¤�&�Ð��& m´�(Ì)ÜI�<È0È��ÆÅ/Ì����2�_È�Ëh�X�B]#³�Å`]��|Å7]¿�D���S�q\S]\s�KÉ�� È0Êh�^´X�UÌD�`ÜÆÌD�`³X\IÉ�ÈHÉX]X³&�<Ì�È0Êh�^´B\z\2�B³

´<Å`]X³X\k�-\IÅ7]�È<`¨�(È)´<Å��RÊ2�(Ì0�B³t�UÅ·�L�V�\���É�� ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜÜÌU�`³\�É�ÈX� p Å7ÜSÜ��_�D�Q�`]X³ ð \s]�Å/Î/ÅV��\k�U�ëY\[ � ^�`]X³Àû�ÅV®(�_ÈD�N�`]X³ÀÙ��^ÜS\����`]¿Y ��! ^ ³����U�XÌ#�q\S]&�B³��D�2�_�y���RÅ7]�Î��`ÜsÜ?�UÌ0�<�<ÈyÅ7].5ë®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ<`!�U���AÊ2�_�D�\IÈÆ�U����ÉX]X\���É&�NÎ(ÌU�(Ê�����\I�D���q\s]X\����pÜØÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`Ü?ÌU�p³X\�É&È<��þ¬��³�Å>]�Å(�¨³2�(ÌD���L�+�(�A�Ô´XÅ7]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0��(Ȩ�UÅ��D��������p´X��Î/ÌD�(Ê��ßÍOÅ(ÌÜ�`ÜsÜ�¥M�p]X³|5 `/µ/���Ü�Æ�¼³�Å°�L�+�(���U����ÍOÅ`ÜSÜIÅV��\S]�Î)´<Å7]?}��^´X�DÉ�ÌD���Z�\S´���TÅ/ÉXÜs³ÀÎ7\k®/�%�¾ÉX\k�U�N�LË\I�ZÅ(Í È0�DÌDÉX´��UÉ�Ì0�A�DÅH�U���A�G��DÌD���L�`Ü�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?�S ������&ñ ���­�A-/'0���21.��4L5t7(��'���)9����:�h¦)+�O1x¥ �DB�-���:�1&�(7V)+4¾-R�H)+42)+�HE��Ä:,�2����$��'D�( ¾'0�}B()+E}:<;Æ����� ù ����:�E2��1N�O1&�(��Âæûõ*@;õ*5�H ù ÷)öpø�¾�Z¥=B Âæûõ*@;õ*5�H ù ø�ÂF;K=?12��4~ñ¼)": ù $D���� "��'0�}�< "�<;ós��\�È�Å/Ë}®/\�Å(É�Ȩ�D�2�_�¨�`]�µHÌ0�<Î/ÉÜ"�(Ì�Î/ÌD�(Ê��H��\k�U�R�U���ZÌD��¾ÉX\�Ì0�B³»]�É;��Ë!�<̨Å(ÍØ�^³�Î/�XÈ���\sÜsÜ!���V®(�³��XÈQ\IÌD�B³�ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜ2ÌU�`³X\IÉ�ÈX`&�`]³R�D�2�_��ÍOÅ/̸¥ M Âæûõ*@;õ*5�H ù øQø<ÂÚ`/�D���JIx�RÅ/È0�¨Ì0�<Î/ÉXÜ��(ÌLK�Î/ÌD�(Ê��q\�È��U�&���É�ÌU�`]ÖÎ/ÌD�(Ê��?`&�Z�\S´��º\�È��U�&�NÉ]X\s�¾É�� ù �!´XÅ7ÜIÅ/ÌU�(ËÜ��AÎ/ÌD�(Ê��Q��\I�D�À5ë®(�<Ì0�Q\S´X�<È��`]X³�¥è�^³�Î/�<ÈX�Ì+�C:(A�$� wÍZ�L�$Ï<;��D¼����& :4���&�C:�Ð�����*Ð���&�

þ��ZÌ0�B´��pÜSÜ�ÍOÅ/Ì ù �§Ö ×�`]X³Rä°� ÷ ýsþ�üu `/�U�2�_�¨�­Î/ÌD�(Ê��Dñ{�2�_È��D���|õ��XÌD�B³\I�U�(ÌQ\sÜsµM�ÆÅ/ÉX]X³&�B³Ù¦ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µNÓ ý7Ô w¨\kÍy ÃÑõ�&oø,B ù ©�Â�å»õtñ>ø<Â�läAÍOÅ/ÌÜ�`ÜsÜØÈ0É�Ë�Î/ÌD�(Ê���È�&NBèñ�Å7]Q�_�ÎÜI���_È0� ù ®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<ÈÝ�È0�<� ð �B´��-\IÅ7]Å��� � �%�ßþ¬��Ì0���L�(Ì2�_�B³��D�2�_� p ®/���O�_Ť®/\�â.�`]X³P/yÅV��Üs\S]&ÈDÅ7]�Y ¨ #<^�Ê&ÌDÅV®/�^³��U�2���KÍOÅ/Ìù(M öA�`]X³.5ÞÈ0ÉyD´B\I�B]}�-ܶµ�Ü"�_ÌDÎ/�_`&�U�����G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Î/ÌD�(Ê��{´<Å`]�ÈQ\IÈ0�DÈyÅ_Í���È0���_ÌZ�`]X³QÅ7]���®/�<Ì��U��.Å(ͳ��XÎ/ÌD�X�Ýä(�¿b���þ���´XÅ7]?}��^´X�UÉ&ÌD���D�2�_�Æ�D���ÝÈ��UÌDÉ´X�UÉ&ÌD�­Å(Í�����UÌD��L�`Ü?Î/ÌD�(Ê���È�\�ÈÜÈP\s�q\sÜ"�_Ì<`���®/�B]QÍOÅ/ÌÜ��(ÌDÎ/�XÌ ù ¯

Page 97: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]P#Ï ²!¸��<�/.(·���±¤�ÛÞ?���qK���'��( + ù � Ö × �(4!Bßä´� ÷Ñ« ýsþ�üu�­ Á��+12��'U��)":ß�(4%f :�E´��1Ç�+1&�(��) J;ñ>)":ß�-/'0���21v��4¬5ü�zf 7(��'%�*)9����:Ñh¦)+�O1��+12�K�!'U���2��'%�*GSÓ4ý7Ô wÀ�(4!B{ñ 1&��:ß�L�Ye/)+�L�( ¦:,�2������'0�( �'D�}B()+E}:�(�ß��4¾-.�( + ?:�E´��1ß-/'0���21}:�Á¨�+12��4ºñ )":K�O12�KE�42)�C<E´��-/'0���21.1&�(7V)+4¾- ù 7(��'%��)9����:R�#J�B��*-/'U���y5�÷+ö_Á�(4!B.��4Ø�N7(��'%�,�PeÖ�#JKB��*-/'U���Zä�� « ýsþ�üu ­ ;

þ��tÈ0��ÅV�Æ�^³ \s]ã�����<Å(ÌD��� ��� ¨ ø6�U�2�_�Ûñ ��É�È���2��®/��¹�õ*5�H ù øÀ�(Èë��ÈDÉ&Ë�Î/ÌU�_Ê��zÝ�ÈD�X�Ê2�(Î(� ! #���`H�p]X³��D�2�_�%\k�µ��É�È����2��®(�6ä�� « ýsþ�üu�­ �`³X³X\k�-\IÅ7]2�pÜ��B³�Î(�<Ȭ���RÅ7]�Î��U���t®/�XÌ0�Q\S´X�<Èù �èö�H�������H ù �¥ÛQ�§ö(�·RÝÉ�Ì�´XÅ7]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�KÈ����_�D�<ÈZ�U�2���yÍOÅ(Ì�5oÜ��(Ì0Î/�A�B]�Å/É&Î/�?`2�U���XÌD�~\IÈ��RÉX]X\��¾É���G��DÌD���L�`Ü�Î/ÌD�(Ê��Q�Z��Å/È0���p³X³X\k�-\IÅ7]2�`Ü?�^³�Î/�XÈyÍOÅ/Ì��ô�HÈ0�U�(Ì<�

RÝÉ�̨]�����ÜÊ�ÌDÅ/ËÜ��� ´<Å`]�ÈQ\s³��<Ì0ÈZÙ¦ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µNÓ4ý7Ô w<`��Z���XÌD� ù �`]X³QäK�(Ì0��]�Å(�ÆÌD���¾ÉX\IÌD�^³Q�UÅHË!�\s]¾�D�<Î/�XÌDÈX�¨RÝÉ�Ì�Ì0�<ÈDÉÜI�DÈ�È0��ÅV�ü�U�2����¯

�cü^õËñÔø,B½O�õ9Û�H ù ø��3ý ) ù +¤5��°N±�²kJ�Ð���� Þ?�Sbüû��X� ù HUäu�§Ö ä�` ù ��zH�p]X³�ÛX��÷ «RQ ýsþ�üTSu ­ �¦ó,Ȩ\k�Ü�UÌ0É����D�2�_�Î\kͲñ¼�2�(ÈÜÙ�Ì0Å/Ê!�<Ì0�!µÓ4ý7Ô w<`��U���^]

�cü6õtñ>øDB½O�õ9Û�H ù ø�� ñ ù 5VUÙ��XÌD�2�_Ê�È���®/�^]À�U�\�ÈZÈ0�DÌDÅ7]&Î/�<ÌZÈ0�U�_�U��R�B]}���L�YµQ��Å`ÜS³?¯�cü6õËñÔøDB½O2õ"Û�H ù ø��3ý à ù á¤5VU

þ��ª���Yµ��`Ü�È0Åt�(È��6ÍOÅ/Ìß��Î/�B]&�<ÌU�pÜS\I���_�Q\�Å`]�Å(Í­�U�X\IÈ|Ê�Ì0Å/Ê!�<Ì0�!µ(`y�Z�&�<ÌD�Þ�D���Þ���XÌD�^³X\I�U�(ÌPµË!Å/ÉX]X³ÖÅ7]Q�U���~]¾É��KËh�XÌ�Å(Í��B³&Î/�<È�\�È�]�Å_��ÜS\s]����_Ì<�°N±�²kJ�Ð���� Þ?�kãósÍÆÍOÅ/ÌN�.Î/ÌU�_Ê��¯ñR`ZÂæÃÑõ�&oø�Â6B O�©ØÂ�åDõ"&oø< u ��Å7Üs³�ÈAÍOÅ/ÌN�`ÜSÜ�& B ñR`²³�Å��<È;\k�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV���U�2���W��ü�õËñÔøXBÔb�O�©´Â�åDõËñÔø�ÂY� þ����_�~´��`]Ë!�HÈU�`\s³%\IÍ��D���H�G�Ê!Å7]��B]}�NÅ(ÍÆb¤\�È­Ì0�<ÊXÜ��`´X�B³Ë�µQÈDÅ��L�NÅ(�D���<ÌδXÅ7]�È0�U�`]}�¼ÜI�<È0Èy�D�2�`]À[0�þ��D]�Å(�D�L�D�2�_�M�cü6õËñÔøVB ñ b�O�5 u \�ÈK�Q�UÌQ\k®/\"�pܨÉ&Ê�Êh�XÌKË!Å/ÉX]³?` �p]X³Ç�D�2�_��b�OK�TÅ/ÉXÜs³¿Ë!�Ë!�<È0�AÊ!Å/È0ÈQ\IËXÜ��_` �_È­ÈD�<�^]¬Ë�µáþè\SÜkÍ<«ùÈ­�U���XÅ/ÌD��.��ósÍ��U�X\IÈ6��É&�<È0�Q\�Å`]Ç�T�<Ì0�R�DÌDÉ��_`?�U���^]Ç�D��� ð Ê!�B´���UÌD�`Ü�ÿ¦ÌQ³Xa(È{� ð �UÅ7]���� ð \��RÅ7]�ÅV®/\I�DÈ��U�&�<Å/Ì0���ô�TÅ/ÉXÜs³�ÍOÅ7ÜsÜ�ÅV�üÍOÌ0Å��Ò�U�&��ÿ¦ÌQ³a/È{� ð �UÅ7]&�G� ð \s�RÅ7]�ÅV®/\k�UÈ�U�&�<Å/Ì0��� �`]³»þè\sÜIÍX«ùÈZ�D���<Å(ÌD��� �ÆÅ/ÉÜS³ÖÍOÅ7ÜSÜIÅV�{ÍOÌ0Å��Ò��É�ÌU�p]?«\È��D���<Å/Ì0���.�

Page 98: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]}[þZ��ZÑ��þU��� ú ���

Y$#<^X5¬� å \�Î`]��<ÌX�2��É�ÌD�`]?«ùȦÎ/ÌU�_Ê����U�&�<Å/Ì0���.�g¦��ß��'<;\[ë�(�+1&;][��42�O1� FG�`^#VÛ/[XÝ*][�%¯ ! Û !�_C! # � `�#�]/]}ø��Y\[�^NxK� å Ü�Å`]?�¨ÿ�\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��XÈ��`]³À��&Ê��`]X³��XÌDÈ<��`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'�)9�D�(` � Ý9[���¯ !�¨�_ ] � `.#V] !(� �Y ¨ ^NxK� å Ü�Å7]Ø����Å(É�Î/��/y���RÈD�6µlÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈL��\k�U�&Å/É&��ÈD��Å/Ì��Ñ´6µ/´BÜI�<È<�a�;�¦� -��<�<'0�()9��`T���L�<)+4!;"`��¯�# ! ] _ #V]}ø�`b#V]/]}ø��Y �(^NxK� å ÜIÅ7].�`]X³Sö��X���k5�\SÜ��L�`]?�,�cü�`\IÈDÅ(Êh�XÌQ\��L���UÌP\S´�\s]����¾É2�pÜS\k�-\I�<È�ÍOÅ/ÌÜÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&È<`2�`]³QÈDÉ�Ê!�<Ìx�´<Å`]X´<�^]¾�DÌU�_�DÅ/ÌDÈX�@a�;C`T���L�<)+4!;�=?12����'�G!c?��'X;bÒZ` ¨�! Ý'#��%¯ û?¨�_C!�! `b#V] ! ø��Y\ø�^Nû¦�0�Ü�_Ë2�`\�� å É��UÅ��RÅ/Ì0Ê��X\IÈ#��Î/ÌDÅ/É&Ê�È<`7\IÈDÅ��LÅ(ÌDÊ��X\IÈ#�.`}Ì0�B´<Å`]�È0�DÌDÉX´��-\IÅ7]?��ó!]�/A��û���'­ÌU�(�2�?�Ö`5¬�4'­Ì2d(�DÈQ´����^Ü*`Æ�`]X³6û���û�ÅV®��(ÈD�_`Ü�B³\I�DÅ/ÌDÈX`|Ñ­�(4!B}���V�3U¿�#Je`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'�)9��:�`¦®(Å7Ü�É;�L�ÖóDó�`´��2�(Ê��U�<Ì�[ û `&Ê2�(Î/�XÈV#���� ûf_ #Vø?�}Û&�&x�Å/Ì��U��õ�Å7ÜsÜ��`]X³?` å �LÈ��U�XÌQ³2���.`6#V]/]/ø��Y � ^Nû¦�F�Ü�(Ë��`\Ý�`]³�����'­ÉX\S³&ÉXÜS\�� ð Êh�^´X�DÌU�`Ü��G��UÌ0���L�vÍOÅ(ÌßÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈQó0ó�¯Æ�����g9?�(ÌD�`]^�±\�����\S´X�Ê�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���.��5À�`]¾É�ÈQ´XÌQ\IÊ&��`6#V]/] � �Y û ^Nû¦�^�Ü�_Ë2�`\h�`]X³�����'AÉX\s³�ÉXÜs\�� ð Ê!�B´��UÌD�`ÜØ����DÌD�����ÍOÅ/ÌTÎ/ÌU�_Ê���ÈÜó0óDó�¯���É�ÌD�`]|�!µ�Êh�Ý�D���<Å(ÌD���RÈX�ó!]ÖÊ�ÌD�XÊ2�(ÌU���-\IÅ7]?`h#V]/] � �Y ! ^V���:�ÆÅ`ÜSÜIÅ/Ë2�(ÈX��ò�e/��'U���L�( ¸¢Ü'0���21v=?12����'%G_� å ´<�`³����q\s´�Ù¦Ì0�<ÈDÈX`!û�Å`]X³�Å7]?`h#�] û�! �Yù]_^V���i�ÆÅ7ÜsÜIÅ/Ë2�(ÈX� ÿI��DÌD����pÜNÎ(ÌU�(Ê��3�U���XÅ/ÌPµ(�Òó!]�/N�yû¦�|'AÌD�(�2���.`65Ç��'­Ì2d_�UÈQ´��&�BÜ�`K�p]X³û¦�Üû�ÅV®��(ÈD�_`��^³X\I�DÅ/ÌDÈX`6Ñ­�(4!B}���V�3Uv�#JA`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'%)9��:�`Æ®/Å`Ü�É��R�ëó0ó�`·´��2�(Ê��U�<ÌÖ[ ¨ `�Ê2�(Î/�XÈ#¤[ ¨ # _ #¤[(]/[���xyÅ/Ì0�D�jõyÅ7ÜsÜ"�`]³?` å �RÈ0�D�<ÌP³2���.`6#V]/]}ø��Y$#VÛ_^V���h�TÅ7ÜSÜIÅ/Ë2�_ÈA�`]X³µ'H�Ø����Å��L�(È0Å7]?�)���B]�È0�»]&�B\IÎ/�¾ËhÅ/Ì0��Å�Å�³�ÈÝ�`]X³��É&ÌU�`]?«ùÈÝ�U�&�<Å/Ì0���.�ja�;`T���L�<)+4!;y=?12����'%GMc?��'X;�ÒZ` ¨ #/¯�#0#0# _ #0#���`]#V] ! #/�Y$#0#<^�k&� å �F�ÆÅ7]X³�µ/�¼û��_ÌDÎ/��³&�B]�È0�Û]��B\IÎ/�¾ËhÅ(ÌD��Å�Å�³&È.�`]X³���É�ÌU�`]Ø«\ÈQ�U�&�<Å/Ì0���.�la�;!`T���L�<)+4!;=?12����'%G�c?��'X;bÒ�`2Ê2�(Î/�XÈV#�Û/] _ #0#+#/`b#�] !�¨ �

Page 99: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

] ¨Y$#¤[�^�k&� å ���TÅ7]X³µA�p]X³u¾N��/N� ð �V5ÀÉ�Ì��!µ/�4¢Ü'0���21.=?12����'�G�h¦)+�+11¦Æ�}�! F)9�D�(��)9��4&:��/x�Å(Ì0�U�,�xõ�Å`ÜSÜ��`]X³?`x����;m¨Å/Ì��!`h#�] û(� �Y$# ¨ ^%/A�Øÿ��]�ÆÅV�Æ�^]?�1ò�C<E�)+ F)��<'%)+E��nc´�9�(�#��:��(4!B|�+12�XòT'�-��<B()9�.=?12����'%GÖ�#J�¦�4Ø�V:V��7�oA) pÝ�����ß��'%$�21�)":���:�� ð Ê�ÌP\S]&Î/�<Ì�ö��<ÌPÜ"�_Î�`\�Æ�XÌQÜs\S]?`6#V] û ø��Y$#��(^ p �:�ÆÌD�`]X³?`\���k'AÉ\S³�ÉÜS\�`´�`]X³�þ ��ó_�RÌQ\s´��?� p �2�(ÌD�`´X�D�<ÌP\��<�_�-\IÅ7].Å(Í��UÌQ\k®_�`ÜI�B]}�ZÎ/ÌU�_Ê���ÈÜ��\k�U�

�q\S]\s�L�`Ü��B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��NÎ}�(Ê?��5À�`]¾É�ÈQ´XÌQ\IÊ&���Y$#¤ø�^ å �hÿ��.�TÌDÅ/É}�T�<Ì<����Å(É�Î/�X]��XÈDÈA�`]³À�U�&��ÈDÊ!�B´��UÌDÉ;� Å(ͦ��Î/ÌD�(Ê��?�­��)+4Ø�D�('¬¦� -��<�<'0��¦Ü�}�! I;"`[/[ �f_ [/[ ! ¯ª[ ��ûq_ [ û #/`]#V]/]/ø��Y$# � ^�þ �g'R�^�ÆÌDÅV��]?�¨R�]ÖÎ/ÌD�(Ê���È��U���_��³�Å»]&Å(��´<Å7]}�U�`\S]��L���&Å��RÈD�B]ÀÎ/ÌU�_Ê��?��`��(4!�}B};)[ë�(�+1&;ÒZE� + I;"`´]&¯ª[ ! # _ [ ! ]&`]#V] �/� �Y$# û ^%/A� å �J�ÆÌDÉ��`ÜS³\Ý�`]X³ å �Fk&�Qõ�Å(�g�L�`]?� R�]w�D���ÞÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`ÜÝÌU�p³X\�É&È|Å(ÍDõ9zCHYöpø"�9�L�_�UÌP\S´X�<È<���)+4Ø�D�('�¦� -��<�<'D�u¦Ü�}�! I;"` � ø�¯r# ¨�¨�_ #�� � `.#V] ! ø��Y$# ! ^%/A� å �s�ÆÌ0É2�`Üs³X\Ü�p]X³tÿ�� ð � ð Å`Ü����^\S³Ø�ÛR�]��U�&�ßÈDÊ!�B´��UÌD�`ÜÆÌD�`³X\IÉ�È�Å(ÍδXÅ7]X]��^´X�D�B³vÎ/ÌU�_Ê���È<�STE��V;�»U4&:��s;t[Þ�(�+1&;"` ¨ ]rÝ*ø ¨ ��¯Ä�¾ø _ ø?��`.#�] !/� �Y$#V]_^;mÆ� p �:�ÆÉ&ÈDÈD��L�+�(�XÌ<` ð �]uÆÅ/Ë!�Bܺ}�\sâ_`N���p5¬� p ®/���O�_Ť®/\�â(`Ø�`]X³�k&�:k&� ð �B\s³��^Ü*� p Å��RÊ�É&�D�<Ì�\S],�®/�XÈ0�Q\�Î}���-\IÅ7]QÅ(Í�´XÉ�ËX\s´ÝÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�����^´��X]X\s´��`Ü�/y�XÊhÅ/Ì���/Z�<Ê!Å/Ì�� û_� �Ûþ ðPv �,ÛP#/`¾���^´��X]�Å7ÜIÅ/Î7\s´��pܾ�]\I®(�<ÌDÈP\I�!µ�ÿ¸\S]³���ÅV®/�^]?`t#�] û(� �Y\[(Û_^;mÆ� p �]�ÆÉ�È0ÈD����R�(�<ÌX` ð �buÆÅ/Ë!�Bܺ}�\�â(`c���p5¬� p ®/���O�_Ť®/\�â(`��p]X³<k&�]k&� ð �^\S³&�BÜ�� p É�ËX\s´�Î(ÌU�(Ê��&ÈÅ7]�B�ö�òH®/�XÌ0�-\s´<�XÈ<�@a�;C`T���L�<)+4!;�=?12����'%G!c?��'X;�ÒZ`2[ ¨ ¯ª[ ¨ � _ [ ¨ ø�`.#�] û7û �Y\[�#<^;��� p �(ÅQ�`]³ å �kö�\s]X´X�(� ð Êh�^´X�DÌU�`Ü�ÌU�p³X\�É&È�Å(Í��LÊXÜ��`]2�(Ì�Î/ÌU�(Ê&�?����)+4Ø�D�('¬¦� -��<�<'0��¦Ü�}�! I;"`# !�û ¯Ú[/ø�# _ [/ø û `.#V]/] ¨ �Y\[/[�^;mÆ� p �¾ÉX]�Î&����\"���R���U�<Ì0È��p]X³À�^\�Î(�B]}®_�`Ü�É&�<È<��a�;*¦��ß��'X;)[ë�(�+1&;tc?�V�<;"`´[�¯�# !�ûq_ #V] � `b#V] ! ]��Y\[ ¨ ^;mÆ� p �¾ÉX]�Î&��`�ÒC[wc���������E�'U�yxN���#��:H��4�c/�2������'0�( ¸¢Ü'0���21v=?12����'%G_� å 5 ð `2��Åß�(Ê&Êh�<�(Ì<�

Page 100: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]��Y\[?�(^1ö�� p �}®��_�U�`Ü��`]X³¬ÿ�� ð �<��L�XÌQ}^³X\*�ÑR�]ë�U���Lÿ¦ÌQ³Xa(È{� ð �UÅ7]��H�D���<Å/Ì0���.�"a�;�����4!B���4/[ë�(�+1&;

c?�V�<;"`´[�¯ª[(Û ûq_ [�#���`b#V] ! #(�Y\[/ø�^HmH� p Å7Üs\s]�³��·ö��<ÌP³X\�z<ÌD�_� ð É&ÌÀÉX]�]�Å/É�®/�BÜ;\s]¾®_�(ÌP\"�p]¾�º³��XÈÀÎ/ÌD�(Ê����XÈ.�X�ÀÉX]§´XÌQ\k�OzXÌD�o³��ÊXÜ��`]2�(ÌP\I�Q}(�ia�;C`T���L�<)+4!;Z=?12����'%G!c?��'<;*ÒZ`´ø(Û&¯�#0# _ [�#/`.#�]/]/Û&�Y\[ � ^Nû¦� p Å7ÜsÜ��_�U���p]X³�¾K� ð \s]�Å/Î/ÅV��\k�U�(� ð Êh�4�¾�DÌD�^]L�^]X³XÜs\S´��&�<Ì4'AÌD�_ÍO�B]Ø�±¦­��1&;:[Þ�(�+1&;]c?���L;,{�42)+7�;Ñ­�(�L�<E�'�-/`![�#/¯ ��¨�_�û7û `.#�]}ø û �Y\[ û ^;��� p ®/���O�(ÅV®/\�â(� p ��Ì0Å��L�_�-\s´¨]¾É���Ë!�<Ì �`]X³��D���¨ÈDÊ!�B´X�DÌDÉ���Å(Í´�yÎ/ÌU�_Ê��?�2SÆE&�< I;&»�4&:��9;\[Þ�(�O1&;"`#��NÝ*[ ! �%¯Ú[/ø _C¨�! `b#V] û [��Y\[ ! ^;��� p ®(�X�2�(ÅV®/\sâ_`05¬�¬��Å�Å/Ë?`Øó���'AÉ��2�L�`]?`��p]X³ å �h��Å/Ì0Î}�+|0�X®!��c/�2�����*'0�Þ�#J¤¢Ü'0���21}:�� å ´����³���D\s´KÙ�Ì0�<È0È<`!x����;m¨Å/Ì2�´`h#V] ! Û&�Y\[(]_^;��� p ®(�X�2�(ÅV®/\sâ_`�5¬�X��Å�Å(Ë?`��`]³jõN� ð �p´���È<�Jc/�2������'0�.�#J>¢Ü'0���21}:�� å ´��`³���q\S´NÙ¦ÌD�XÈDÈ<`´xy�X�m¨Å/Ì��!`h#�] ! Û&�Y ¨ Û_^;��� p ®/���O�(ÅV®/\�â(`Q5¬�u��Å�Å/ËØ`õ�`]X³wõK� ð �`´���ÈX��c/�2������'0�¬�#JJ¢Ü'0���21}:��wk(Å/�2�p]X] å ��Ë�Ì0Å/ÈQ\IÉ�È�Ü�(Ì��U��ö��<ÌPÜ"�(Î&`±õ��^\S³��^Ü�Ë!�<Ì0Î�` ¨ ÌQ³.�^³X\I�Q\�Å`]?`6#V]/]}ø��Y ¨ #<^;��� p ®(�X�O�_ÅV®�\�âÝ�p]X³RÙ��[/ZÅV��ÜS\s]�È0Å7]?�¬R�]q´XÅ7]X]��^´X�U�^³�Î(ÌU�(Ê��&Èõ��\I�D�»�L�V�\����pÜX\S]³��Gh��SÆE&�< I;»�4&:��9;t[Þ�(�O1&;"`±���rÝ9ø ! �%¯Ú[_] _C¨ ��`]#V] !�! �Y ¨ [�^;��� p ®/�X�2�(ÅV®/\sâ��`]X³Ù���/ZÅV��ÜS\s]�È0Å7]?�A�����ÔÜ��(ÌDÎ(�<È0�Ý�B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��HÅ(ͨ�ßÎ/ÌD�(Ê��?�N� )+4Ø�D�('��(4!B[ÀE� F��)+ F)+4Ø�D�('�¦� -��<�<'D�(`2[ ! ¯ ¨�_C¨�¨ `b#V]/]/Û��Y ¨�¨ ^�k&�°/A�x�¼\"�_È<� [�� "����E� I�('~}Ü'X�<)+�s�( �`��( "��E� I�(��)9��4&:�{�:�)+4¾-�`�12���H)9�D�( �¢Ü'0���21M=?12����'%G_�ð Ê�ÌP\S]&Î/�<Ìx�9ö��<ÌPÜ"�_Î�`:�Æ�<ÌPÜS\s]?`h#V](] ¨ �Y ¨ �(^�k&����Å/³��B\IÉ^���`]X³ þ � ð � v �B]X³��`ÜSÜ�� p Å���ËX\s]2�_�DÅ/ÌQ\��`ÜNû��(ÊXÜ��`´B\��`]�ÈÖ�`]³�\IÈDÅ/Ê!�<ÌP\s�R�X�DÌQ\s´\s]����¾É2�`Üs\k�!µ/�¿ó!] v �¸��� ÿ¸ÜI�TÅ/Ì0�D��µ/`Æ�^³X\k�UÅ/ÌX`QK?'U��� ���V�D�( A=�)+�ß��:ß�#�#¢Ü "�(���( �¢������ß����'�GVÁ`T��42��'��� ¨�(4!BQS¨1�GV:�)9��:�`�®/Å7ÜIÉ��R��#Vø(ÛQÅ(Í�ST)+���L�(4g�Z��:<;,xK���,��:L)+4A[ë�(�+1&;Dc?��'%)9��:�`�Ê2�(Î/�XÈ��!�_�û ���2û�Å7]�Î����p] ð ´B\��2���^´��?��`gõ��_ÌQÜIŤ�A`h#�] !/� �

Page 101: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]}øY ¨ ø�^ p �gõK�!ÿ¸Ü�Ê��\S´��´�Xc?��12�V�� Ü=�)+�ß���s�}�< F)+4¾-|�(4!B%¢Ü'0���21/`T�� "��'%)+4¾-/�ÜÙ¦�r�¼�D���<ÈP\�ÈX`�¾�]X\k®/�<Ì0ÈQ\k�!µÅ(Í��·\�Ì��q\S]�Î(�2���.`h#V] ! #(�Y ¨/� ^NÙ��?ÿ�ÌP³Xa/ÈX�ÔR�]ëÈD��¾É��B]X´X�<ÈKÅ(Í�\S]}�U�XÎ/�<Ì0È�]�ÅQÅ7]��HÅ_ͨ�Z�\S´��%³X\k®/\S³��XÈ­�U���HÊ�Ì0Å�³&ÉX´X�AÅ(ͦ�,�TÅÅ(�D���<Ì0È­�`]X³ÞÅ`]ÞÈDÅ��R�KÌD�BÜ��_�D�B³ëÊ�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���RÈ<�A»D:�7(����) ã<��x­�(E��O:�1�4Ø��$9»0:�:� I; »U4&:��s;�[Þ�(�s;¦),[��1&;=h����:�U�`�[�¯ û � _C! [�`�#V] ¨�! �Y ¨�û ^NÙ��´ÿ¦ÌP³Xa/È<�4'­ÌU�(Ê&�.�D���<Å(ÌPµÖ�`]X³.Ê�Ì0Å/Ë2�(Ë\SÜs\I�!µ(�V`��(4!�}B()��(4�a�;)[ë�(�+1&;"`h#0#/¯ ¨ � _,¨�! `.#�]}ø(]&�Y ¨�! ^NÙ��(ÿ¦ÌQ³Xa/ÈX� ð Å��R�TÌD�B´X�B]}��ÌD�XÈDÉXÜk�UÈ Å7]H�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Ê�ÌDÅ/ËÜ���LÈu\S]�Î(ÌU�(Ê��K�U���XÅ/ÌPµ(��ó!]RÙ��?/yÅ(ÈD�B],�È0�Q\��X�XÜ�`!�^³X\k�UÅ/ÌX`Ü=?12����'�G|�#JD¢Ü'0���21}:�`�Ê2�_Î/�<Èy#0# ûq_ # ¨ Û&���ÉX]�Å/³?`´Ù��(ÌQ\IÈ<`6#V] �7û �Y ¨ ]_^NÙ���ÿ¦ÌQ³Xa(È<��R�]�È0Å��R�Ñ]���� \S]&���¾É2�`Üs\I�Q\��XÈÔ´<Å`]X´<�XÌQ]X\s]�ÎÞ����DÌD����pÜTÊ�Ì0Å/Ê!�<Ì0�Q\��XÈKÅ_Í�Î/ÌU�_Ê���È<�ó!]ÇÙ���ÿ¦ÌP³Xa/È­�`]³Å'H� v �_�DÅ7]2�&`h�B³X\k�UÅ(ÌDÈ<`Ý=?12����'%G��#J¤¢Ü'D���21}:�`hÊ2�(Î/�XÈ û7ûf_C! #/� å ´<�`³���D\s´Ù¦ÌD�XÈDÈ<`hx����~m¨Å/Ì��´`h#V] ��! �Y �}Û_^NÙ��!ÿ¦ÌQ³a/È<�¨R�]Ö�U���NÎ/ÌD�(Ê��.�U���XÅ/ÌD�� Å(Íõ��É�ÌU�p]_Ýl\S]ªõ�ÉX]�Î/�(ÌQ\��`]k�%�i[Þ�(�s;��?���2�3U�`![�#/¯ª[?�}] _[/ø�#(`�#V] û Û��Y �^#<^NÙ���ÿ�ÌP³Xa/ÈX` å �C/�}^]�µ�\�`´�`]X³Sö��&�­� ð�% È<��R�].��Ê�ÌDÅ(ËXÜ��� \s]QÎ/ÌU�_Ê��|�U���XÅ/ÌPµ(�Dc´��E�B()��M[ë�(�+1&;

c?��)�;�Ñ�E�4¾-¾�('X;"`�#/¯ ¨ # ¨f_C¨ [(Û&`b#V] �/� �Y �¾[�^NÙ���ÿ¦ÌQ³a/ÈÆ�p]X³S5Ç� ð \s�RÅ7]&Ť®/\k�UÈX� å Üs\��D\k���U���XÅ/ÌD���\S]�Î/ÌU�_Ê��H�U���XÅ/ÌPµ(�sc´�*E&B()��Wc?��)�;b[ë�(�+1&;Ñ�E�4¾-¾�('X;"`h#/¯ªø�# _ ø û `.#V] �/� �Y � ¨ ^NÙ��õÿ�ÌP³Xa/ÈR�`]³�k&� ð Ê!�B]X´X�<ÌX�vST'U�(���}�<)+ F)":��*)9�>[���O12�<B�:ß)+4;`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'%)9��:�� å ���`³}��q\"�p\v \"�p³ % `:�ÆÉX³��(Êh�XÈ0�<`h#V] û ���Y ���(^NÙ��_ÿ¦ÌQ³Xa(Ȧ�`]X³%ö����­� ð�% È<�rR�]H�yÎ/�B]&�<ÌU�pÜS\I���_�Q\�Å`]�Å(Í2��É�ÌU�p]?«\È Î/ÌU�(Ê&�C�s�D���<Å/Ì0���.��ó!]�c´�*E&B()9��:)+4�STE�'U�y[Þ�(�O12���L�(��)9��:�`�Ê2�_Î/�<Èy# ! # _ # ! ø��P�·\IÌ2�¾�\�(É�È0�<ÌX`b�Æ�(ÈD�^Ü*`6#V] !�¨ �Y �¾ø�^NÙ��&ÿ¦ÌQ³Xa/ÈÜ�`]X³ å �CõK� ð �UÅ`]��(�uR�]ß�U����È0�UÌ0ÉX´X�DÉ�ÌD�­Å_Í&ÜS\s]��<�(ÌÜÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�(ÒZE� + I;�¦��ß��'X;�[ë�(�+1&;c?�V�<;"`´ø/[�¯Ú[(] !�_C¨ Û}ø�`.#V]�� � �Y � � ^X5¬��m²\��^³XÜ��XÌ<� å Ü�Î/�XË�ÌU�p\S´¨´XÅ7]X]��^´X�Q\I®/\k�!µHÅ(Í!Î/ÌU�_Ê���È<��` æ�����12�V:� "��7��VU@[Þ�(�O1&;ba�;"`}[ ¨ Ý*] ! ��¯ª[(] !�_¨ Û}ø�`�#V] û�¨ �

Page 102: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

] �Y � û ^�9 �4ms��Ì0�B³X\��Öx��X�©�_ÈPµ,�RÊ&�UÅ(�Q\S´XÈ�ÍOÅ/ÌNËX\IÊ2�(Ì0�Q\I�D����É�ÌD�`]_]¾É���Ë!�<Ì0È<�ga�;y`T���L�<)+4!;A=?12����'�G

c?��'X;*¦A` û øXÝ'#��%¯r#��^# _ #�����`b#�]/] � �Y � ! ^;mÆ� /A� 'A�`]}�2�L�`´����XÌ<��=?12�R=?12����'%GH�#JF[ë�(��'%)9����:�`/®/Å7ÜIÉ��R�yóõ�`]X³LóDó�� p ���^Ü�È0����Ù¦É�ËÜS\IÈD�X\s]�Îp Å��I`´x����;m¨Å/Ì2�´`h#V] û ���Y �}]_^ p �g'AÅ/³�ÈP\SÜ���¦� -��<�<'0�()9�!`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'�)9��:�� p �2�(Ê��L�`]w�«õ��pÜSÜ�`2x����;m¨Å/Ì��!`.#V]/] ¨ �Y\ø(Û_^ å �C'­ÌU�(ÅV®_�`´_`�ó��C'­É&�2�L�`]Ø`��p]X³|xN����ÌQ\s]2�V}�È��-\�â(��'­ÌU�(Ê&�L�D���<Å/Ì�µ��`]X³$�LÅ`Ü��^´<ÉXÜ��(ÌÆÅ(ÌDËX\k���`ÜIÈ<�=?12����'U���s;C`�1�)+�L;�¦Ý���9�(`2Ê2�(Î/�XÈ ��ûf_û�! `.#V] û [��Y\ø�#<^X5¬��'AÌ�d(�UÈP´����BÜ�`2û¦�&û�ÅV®��(ÈD�_`2�`]X³ å � ð ´���ÌQ\º}#®/�XÌ<��¢������ß����'%)9��¦� -���'%)+�+1���:A�(4!B"`T���L�<)+4!�($�,��'�)��( �}��!��)+�H)sæV�(��)9��42� ð Ê�ÌP\S]�Î(�<Ì<`põy�B\s³��BÜIËh�XÌDÎ�`h#�] !�! �Y\ø/[�^V���p'­ÉX\s³�ÉXÜs\*� ð Ê!�B´��UÌU�pÜ��G��UÌ0���L�RÍOÅ(Ì�Î/ÌU�(Ê&��ÈZó�¯2��É�ÌD�`]?«ùÈ��U���XÅ/ÌD��Ö�45��p]�É&ÈQ´<ÌP\�Ê���`)#V]/] � �Y\ø ¨ ^V��� '­ÉX\s³�ÉXÜs\*�´�����ZÈ��UÌDÉ´X�UÉ&ÌD�ZÅ(Í´�UÌP\I®_�`ÜI�B]}��Î/ÌD�(Ê���Èõ��\k�U���q\S]\s�L�`Ü��^\�Î(�B]}®_�`Ü�É&�yÎ/�(Ê?�)a&��E�'%$4!�( �#J|¦� -��<�<'0�()9��`T���L�<)+4!�(�,��'%)9��:�`&��Åß�(Ê&Êh�<�(Ì<�Y\ø?�(^Aó���'­É&�2�L�`]�`]³¯R���ÿ���Ù�Å7Ü��`]�È2��µ(�j[ë�(�+12���L�(�*)9�D�( J`T��4Ø���,�!�O:�)+4�}Ü'�-¾�(42)9��`�12���H)":���'%G_�ð Ê�ÌP\S]&Î/�<ÌX`b�T�<ÌQÜs\s]?`h#V] !/� �Y\ø/ø�^�þ �,õK� õ��(���R�<Ì0È<��ÿ¸\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��<ÈÆ�`]X³R�U����³X\����R�X�U�XÌTÅ_Í?Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX����)+4Ø�D�('Ý�(4!B�[ÀE� F�*)+ F)+4Ø�D�('¦� -��<�<'0�(` ¨ ]&¯ ¨�¨�_ ����`.#�]/]}ø��Y\ø � ^xR��nõ��^\SÜ��L�`]X]l�`]X³lÿ��nõN�õû&\��XË?�Ç�����<Å/Ì�µtÅ(Í|�RÅ7]�Å��R�XÌ{�!³\s�R�<ÌHÈ�µ�È0�U��RÈ<��`T���H�HE��L;�L�(�+1&;�S¨1�GV:<;"`´[/ø�¯r#V](Û _ [ ¨ [�`.#V] û [��Y\ø û ^ å ��k&��õ�Å(�g�L�`]?��R�]A�B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��XÈ �`]³;´XÅ7ÜIÅ/ÌQ\s]�Î/È�Å(Í�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�(ó!]V���3õ��(ÌDÌP\�ÈX`_�^³X\I�DÅ/Ì<`c¢Ü'0���21�+12����'�G|�(4!B�)+�+:����}�! F)9�D�(�*)9��4&:�`�Ê2�(Î/�XÈ û ] _ ]P#/� å ´��`³&���q\S´�Ù¦ÌD�<È0È<`!x����~m¨Å/Ì��´`h#V] û Û&�Y\ø ! ^X5¬��õ�Å(Í��R�^\�È��U�<ÌX� ð Êh�^´X�DÌU�`ܨÌU�`³\�È��`]X³¯³&�<Î/Ì0�<�ßÈ0���¾É��^]X´<�_�g[Þ�(�O1&;Dx­����1�'<;"`D# ¨ ]&¯ ¨�ûf_ ����`#V] !�! �Y\ø(]_^HmH��õ�Å7]�Î&� å Ë!Å/ÉX]X³�Å7]��D���ëÈDÊ!�B´��UÌU�pÜÝÌU�`³\�É�È.Å(ÍNÎ/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�©��)+4Ø�D�('N¦� -��<�<'0�µ¦Ü�}�! I;"`#VÛ ! ¯r# ¨ ø _ # ¨ ]�`.#V] !�! �

Page 103: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

] ûY � Û_^HmH�bõyÅ7]�Î��DR�]�U���RÈ0Êh�^´X�UÌD�`ܦÌU�p³X\�É&È��`]³�D���RÎ/�B]¾É�ÈNÅ(ÍTÎ/ÌU�_Ê���È<�"a�;@`T���L�<)+4!;­=?12����'�G

c?��'X;�ÒZ` � ø�¯Ú[ � [ _ [ ��! `.#V]/]/ø��Y � #<^%/A� å ��õ�Å/ÌP]�`]X³ p ��/A�6k(Å/�X]&ÈDÅ7]?�![Þ�(�*'%)¶eS¦�4!�( FGV:�)":�� p ����Ë&ÌQ\s³�Î/��¾�]\I®(�<ÌDÈP\I�!µÇÙ¦Ì0�<ÈDÈX`p ���KË�ÌQ\s³�Î/�_`)#�]/]/Û&�Y � [�^NÙ��¿þ � v �(È��U�BÜI�^µ/]?�n'AÌD�(Ê��ß�D���<Å/Ì�µ|�p]X³{´<Ì�µ�È����`ÜhÊ���µ�ÈQ\s´<È<�¦ó!]�mT�;õ��(ÌU�(Ì�µ/`��B³X\k�UÅ/ÌX`�¢Ü'0���21=?12����'%G|�(4!B=?12����'�����)9�D�( hS�1�GV:�)9��:�`�Ê2�(Î/�XÈ�� ¨�_ #0#�Û&� å ´<�`³����q\s´�Ù¦ÌD�XÈDÈX`hû�Å7]³�Å7]?`�#�] ��û �Y ��¨ ^�k&� v Å7ÜsÜ"�(ÌX`�û¦�±/ % ]�µ}�`\�`´�`]X³.�­� ð ���(Ë % ��x�Å/Ì�� Î/ÌD�(Ê���Èy�`]³ÖË\�Ê2�_Ì0�-\k�U�­��É�ÌD�`]�]�É;��Ë!�<ÌDÈX�5��`]¾É�ÈP´<ÌP\�Ê&�<`t#�]/]}ø��Y � �(^NÙ�� v a(®��(ÌQ\�`pö��h�­� ð�% ÈX`?�`]X³ÞÙ��!��É�ÌD�`]?��R�]Þ��Ê�Ì0Å/ËXÜI��� Å(Í v �.9?�_ÌU�`]^�±\I�X��\s´<�_��`T�� + "�<CV;[Þ�(�O1&;"` ¨ ¯ªø(Û _ ø û `�#V]/ø?���Y � ø�^�k&� v ��Ì0ÈQ´��2�R���`]X³Mk&� ð É�ÌD�`]�µ/\*�.[Þ�(�,���L�(�*)ZU(�()C�!��'�:V��42G������#�� "��U��&ÿ�d_�D®0d(È�û�Å(ÌU�`]X³E5��_�U��°��_�Q\r���`\��XÈ�m²\��^\r���`\����(ÌDÈ0ÉXÜ��_��`h#V]/[(]&�Y �/� ^%õK�hk&��û��`]X³2�(É�p]X³ å �b5Ç� R�³XÜsµ��4�(Å��W�ÆÅ/ÉX]X³&ÈÝÍOÅ/ÌÝ�B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��XÈNÅ_Í�´X�<Ì����`\s]È0�UÅ/´��2�(È��-\s´�L�_�UÌP\S´X�<ÈX�Z��)+4Ø�D�('|¦� -��<�<'0�°¦Æ�}�! I;"` ¨�! ¯ªø _ #¤ø�`b#V] ! #(�Y ��û ^Nû¦� û�ÅV®_�(ÈD�_�´/y�`]X³�Å��>�Æ�`Ü��¾È�Å7]¿Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX¯L�ÀÈDÉ&Ì0®/�6µ/�ëó!]#�K�05º\��±Ü % È<`0ö����­� ð�% È<`¦�p]X³�­� ð �Ba`]±µ/\�`��^³X\k�UÅ/Ì0È<`�`T���L�<)+4!�(�#��'%)9��:�ÁÜSÜ�(E� �òT'DB��V:H)":EòÆ)k-_1���G�`�®(Å7ÜIÉ��R�|[�`�Ê2�_Î/�<È ¨ ø ¨f_¨ ] û �\�ÆÅ7ܶµ}�`\ ð Å�´^\����!µ/`]�ÆÉX³2�_Êh�XÈ0��`h#�]/] � �Y ��! ^Nû¦��û�ÅV®&�_ÈD�R�`]X³�k&�ØÙ��^ÜS\����`]?�>R�]Þ�D���H�B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��<ÈAÅ(Í��DÌD�<�XÈ<�HSZ��'�)9�<B};�[Þ�(�O1&;(Ñ�E�4¾-¾�('<;"`Ê2�(Î(�<ÈV# û ø _ # ! [�`]#V] û�¨ �Y � ]_^Nû¦��û�ÅV®��(È0�Æ�`]³ å � ð ´���ÌQ\º}#®/�XÌ<������� p Å7ÜS\s])³&��ö��XÌQ³X\�z<Ì0��]¾É��KËh�XÌ Å(Í�ÜS\s]^�±ÜI�<ÈDÈPÜsµK���KËh�^³2�(ËXÜI�Î/ÌD�(Ê���ÈX�Q5À�`]¾É�ÈQ´XÌQ\IÊ&��`6#V]/] � �Y û Û_^ å ��û�É�Ë!Å(�UÈ���µ/`�/A��Ù¦�X\SÜsÜs\�Ê�ÈX`��`]³|Ù�� ð �_ÌQ]2�+�´��ÿI�ÊXÜs\S´^\I�Æ�G�Ê2�`]³��<Ì0È��`]X³L�U����/��?���p]�ÉV}0�`]´<Å`]?}��B´��UÉ�Ì0�<È<�Ló!]tSÆ'U�V�<;��R�/�+1j¦�4242E&;0¦�`s[ c´G_���Ø;Z��4½=?12����'�G��#J"`T�����!E���)+4¾-/`?Ê2�(Î/�XÈ[?�}Û _ [?� � `&x����;m¨Å/Ì2�´`h#V] !/� � å p 5Ç�

Page 104: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

] !Y û #<^�þ �b5��p]¾�D�BÜ��NÙ�Ì0Å/ËXÜI��� [ ! `ØÈ0Å7ÜIÉ&�-\IÅ7]Ë�µ·õK��'AÅ(ɾ�T�B]}�U�+�´`Eþ �*5��`]}�D�BÜ�`)k&�Ø���B\�&�^\�ÌD�{³��

5��_�0�U�XÈ<`cmÆ� ð ´��¾É��Ø`h�p]X³»þ � å ��þ+µ¾�U��Å(�����Q)":�U�E�4!B()k-���}��_-¾�(7(��42`.#VÛ&¯ � Û _�� #(`.#V]/Û û �Y û [�^X'H� å � 5À�(ÌDÎ/ÉÜS\IÈ<� å ÌP\I�D���R�X�Q\S´ZÎ/Ì0Å/É�Ê�È��`]³LÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&È ��\I�D��Å/É&�¨È0��Å/Ì0��´6µ/´BÜI�<È�Ý�\s]$/yÉ�È0ÈQ\��`]k�%�ó!]|ST'��V�<;h���O1�»U42�s;\c´G_���Ø;���4L»�4�J���'%�L�(��)9��4Ç=?12����'%G��è=´��:�1[U}��42��`_®(Å7ÜIÉ��R�X#/`/Ê2�(Î(�<ÈF#¤[ ¨f_#¤[/ø�`�#V] ! �&�Y û�¨ ^%/A��5º´Rþ¬�<�^]±µ¬�`]³/�����­� ð ��É��-´BÜs\k�Ø�_�"[���O12�<B�:Q�#JW[Ç�� "����E� I�('��ÜE��(42��E���[Ç����1&�(42)9��:��å ´��p³����q\s´�Ê�Ì0�<ÈDÈX`!û�Å`]X³�Å7]?`.#V] � ]&�Y û �(^V����5ÀÅ/�2�_Ì<��ÿ¸\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��<ÈX`�³X\����R�X�U�XÌ<`¾�`]³°�R���`]Ô³\�È����`]X´X�¨\s]�Î/ÌU�_Ê���È<�u¢Ü'0���21}:X`T���L�<)+4!;"`û ¯ªø ¨�_�� ��`�#V]/]�#/�Y û ø�^V����5ÀÅ/�2�_Ì<� å ³�Å��L�`\s]´�RÅ7]�Å(�DÅ7]X\s´B\k�!µÖ�D���<Å(ÌD��� ÍOÅ/ÌyÎ/ÌD�(Ê���È��`]X³ªõ����q\sÜI�DÅ7]X\s´B\k�!µ/�XoA)":�$��'U���#��¦Æ�}�! F)9�DB>[Þ�(�O12���L�(��)9��:�` ¨/� ¯�# � ] _ # û7û `]#V]/]/[��Y û(� ^Nÿ��´x�Å/ÈD�`Ü��Tÿ¸\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��<ÈyÅ(Í0'AÌD�(Ê���ÈX�45��(È0�D�<ÌX«\ÈZ�U���XÈQ\IÈ<`p¾�]\I®(�<ÌDÈP\I�!µÖÅ(Í p �`ÜIÎ}�(Ì�µ/`h#V] û Û&�Y û7û ^NÙ���/ZÅV��ÜS\s]�ÈDÅ`]?�+R�]6�D�����L�V�\s�L�`Ü�\s]X³��G6Å(Í�Î/ÌU�_Ê���ÈH��\I�D���Ê�ÌD�XÈQ´XÌQ\IËh�^³£]¾É���Ë!�<ÌLÅ(Í�B³&Î/�<ÈX�Z��)+4Ø�D�('|¦� -��<�<'0�°¦Æ�}�! I;"`h#0#VÛ&¯Ä� ¨�_ ø ¨ `b#�] !�! �Y û�! ^ å ��k&� ð ´��}�T�B]^�L�`]X³�/A��k&�oþè\SÜIÈDÅ7]Ø�cR�]H�D���Ü�B\IÎ/�^]¾®_�`ÜIÉ��XÈTÅ(Í!�ÝÎ(ÌU�(Ê��Ø�2ó!]�û¦�vþ ���Æ�B\s]��4�(��`]X³Å/N�tk&�Eþè\sÜ�È0Å7]?`��B³X\k�UÅ/Ì0È<`,c?�� "�����#�DB6=!���!)9��:H)+4è¢Ü'0���213=?12����'�G�` ´��2�(Ê&�D�<Ì>#0#/`�Ê2�(Î/�XȨ Û ûq_C¨�¨/� � å ´��`³&���q\S´�Ù¦ÌD�<È0È<`!û�Å7]X³�Å`]?`�#V] û?! �Y û ]_^X5¬� ð \��RÅ7]�ÅV®/\I�DÈ<� å �R���U��Å/³NÍOÅ(Ì�È0Å7Ük®�\s]�Îy�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Ê�ÌDÅ(ËXÜ���RȲ\s]KÎ(ÌU�(Ê��A�U�&�<Å/Ì�µ/`(È����(Ë\SÜs\I�!µÊ�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���RÈ<�hó!]ßÙ��¾ÿ�ÌP³Xa/Ȩ�`]X³»'H� v �_�UÅ`]2�&`/�^³X\I�DÅ/ÌDÈX`¦=?12����'�GH�#J;¢Ü'0���21}:�`}Ê2�(Î/�XÈT[ û ] _C¨ #V]&�å ´��p³����q\s´�Ù¦ÌD�XÈDÈ<`!xy�X�~m¨Å(Ì2�´`h#V] ��! �Y ! Û_^X5¬� ð \��RÅ7]�ÅV®/\I�DÈ<�6ÿI��DÌD����pÜ�Î/ÌU�(Ê&�v�D���<Å(ÌPµ/�tó!]6û¦��þ ���Æ�^\S]��4�(���`]X³¢/N�,k&��þè\SÜIÈDÅ7]Ø`�B³\I�DÅ/ÌDÈX`Jc?�� "�����#�DB6=!���!)9��:R)+4è¢Ü'0���21�=?12����'%G_`²´��2�(Ê&�D�<Ì � ` Ê2�_Î/�<È�# � # _ [(Û/Û&� å ´<�`³���D\s´Ù¦ÌD�XÈDÈ<`hû�Å7]X³�Å`]?`�#V] !�¨ �Y ! #<^ å � ð \s]X´^Ü"�`\IÌ<�S¦� -���'%)+�O1���:�J���'R'0�(4!B���� -���4Ø��'0�(��)+4¾-g�ô����E�42��)+4¾-/���·\IÌ2���(É�È0�<Ì<`s�ÆÅ/È��UÅ7]?`#V]/] ¨ �

Page 105: 8- . 8.3 ( 9 + :;.#( < , . , * 7 8+ , 0people.cs.uchicago.edu/~laci/students/guiduli-phd.pdf · ½0¤´¶ e so K~@Ö×uno|0mvdMstmvw ¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤,¤C¤ ¤C¤ ¤ ¤C¤ ¤C¤

]/]Y ! [�^ å � ð \s]X´^Ü"�`\IÌÀ�`]X³�5¬��k(�<ÌDÌ0É��.� p Å7]³�ÉX´X�U�`]X´X�¿�`]X³��U�&�¬ÌD�(ÊX\s³��q\�\s]�Î6Ê�ÌDÅ/Ê!�<Ì��!µ�Å(Í

5��(Ì��(ÅV®�´��2�`\s]�È<¯T�U���K�(Ê�Ê�Ì0Å�\��L�_�-\IÅ7]ÞÅ_Í �U�&�KÊ!�<Ì����p]��B]}��ÌD�<È0Å7Ük®/�B³Ø�­ST'U�V�<; ÕP���+1N¦�`s[c¦=,}X`õ`�Ê2�_Î/�<È�[ ¨ ø _ [?����`b#V] !�! �Y !�¨ ^Nÿ�� ð �<��R�<ÌQ}^³X\��»/Z�<Î(ÉXÜ"�_ÌNÊ��(Ì0�Q\I�Q\�Å7]&È­Å(ÍÆÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&È<��ó!]/k&� � p �h�Æ�XÌ#�RÅ7]X³?`sk&�º� p �&m2Å/É�ÌP]X\I�<Ì<`5¬�´û¦��ö��<Ì0Î7]2�(ÈX`´�`]X³º��� ð Å(�0�U�<�(É?`��^³X\I�DÅ/ÌDÈX`?SÆ'U�(�< ����ß��:M`T���L�<)+4!�(�#��)+'U�����A=?1\����'%)9�KB���:¢Ü'0���212��:�`2Ê2�(Î/�XÈ ¨ ]/] _ �/ÛP#/��ÿ¸³X\k�-\IÅ7]�È�³�É p x�/ ð `´Ù��(ÌQ\IÈ<`6#V] û?! �Y ! �(^%/A��5Ç�����`]X]&�<Ì<��ÿI�ÊXÜs\S´^\I�u´<Å7]X´X�B]}�UÌD�_�UÅ(ÌDÈ�ÍOÌDÅ��üÎ(�B]��XÌU�`Üs\��X�B³�5k�,Î/Å`]�È<�^c�»x¦X[�a�; ¦� -��<�<'0�()9�oA)":V��'U���,�y[Ç���+12�<B�:�`´ø�¯ª[ !�ûf_ [(] ¨ `b#V] ! ���Y ! ø�^NÙ�����É�ÌD�`]?�qR�]Ç�`]�G��UÌ0���L�`Ü�Ê�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���ç\s]ÇÎ/ÌU�(Ê&��D���<Å(ÌPµéÝl\S]Põ�É]�Î}�(ÌP\"�`]±���>[Þ�(�9;�K�)sæV;�?���2�3U�`�� ! ¯Ä� ¨/�f_ �¾ø/[�`b#V]��^#(�Y !/� ^�k&�?®_�`]%³��B]Põ��XÉ&®/�^Ü*�$õ����q\SÜk�UÅ7]%´6µ�´^Ü��XÈ��`]³Ç�^\�Î(�B]}®_�`Ü�É&�<ÈNÅ(ÍÆÎ(ÌU�(Ê��&È<����)+4Ø�D�('%¦� -��<�<'0�¦Æ�}�! I;"`![/[ ûf_ [([ ! ¯ û [ ¨�_û?¨ Û&`:#V]/]}ø��Y !�û ^NÙ��vþ¿�pÜI�D�<ÌDÈX�p¦�4ß)+42��'U�<B(E´����)9��4ß�,��òT'�-��<B()9��=?12����'%G�� ð Ê�ÌP\S]�Î(�<ÌIö��XÌQÜ��(Î�`/xy�X� m¨Å/Ì2�´`^#�] ! [��Y !�! ^%õK� ð �xþè\SÜkÍ#�À���&�|�B\IÎ/�B]}®_�`ÜIÉ��<È�Å(Íy�ÀÎ/ÌD�(Ê��t�p]X³_\k�UÈ)´��&ÌDÅ��L�_�Q\S´¤]¾É��KËh�XÌ<�/a�;Æ����4!B���4[Þ�(�O1&;sc?�V�<;"`;�}[XÝ'#��%¯ ¨�¨ Û _C¨�¨ [�`.#V] ��û �Y ! ]_^%õK� ð �ñþè\sÜkÍ#� ð Ê!�B´��UÌD�`ÜØË!Å/ÉX]X³&ÈÆÍOÅ/ÌT�D����´^ÜS\��¾É��A�`]X³¤\s]X³��XÊh�^]X³��^]X´<�~]¾É���Ë!�<Ì0ÈZÅ(Í�Î/ÌU�_Ê���È<�a�;C`T���L�<)+4!;y=?12����'%GMc?��'<;�Ò�`��}Û&¯�#0# ¨�_ #0# û `]#V] !/� �Yù]/Û_^ v �]9?�(ÌU�p]^�±\�����\S´X�(�TÙ�Ì0Å/ËXÜI���ôÅ_ÍõÙF#VÛP#(�y`T�� + "�<CV;)[ë�(�+1&;"`![�¯ ¨ ÛP#/`b#V]}ø�#(�Yù]P#<^ å � å ��9�µ��(ÅV®!�²R�]ßÈDÅ��L��Ê�ÌDÅ(Êh�XÌ0�-\I�<ȨÅ(Í&Üs\s]����(Ì�´<Å��LÊÜ���&�XÈ~Ý�\s]N/ZÉ�ÈDÈP\"�p]k����[Þ�(�s;�ch����'%42)ZUx­;�ch;"`2[?�NÝ �(� ��¯�# ��¨�_ # !�! `]#V]��}]�� M å �R�XÌ<�p5��_�D�?� ð Å/´(����ÌU�p]�ÈQÜ����2�?`�#�]}ø/[��