Upload
doanhanh
View
218
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
21
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Assessment of Nurses Competency during emergency Management of Patients with
Acute Myocardial Infarction
Hassanat Elbashir Mohamed Mustafa, Prof Sideeg Ebraheim khalil, Prof. Mustafa
khidir Mustafa EL nimeiri and Prof. Ahmed Bolad
AL Neelain University, Faculty of Medicine and Faculty of Nursing Sciences and Alshaab
Hospital
ABSTRACT
Background: Nursing care is of utmost importance in survival of a patient with
myocardial infarction. The competence of the nurse in charge is very crucial in such
patient care. This study aimed at assessment of nurses‘ competence in management
of patients presenting with myocardial infarction at five Hospitals in Khartoum
State. Materials and Methods: Relevant data were collected by standardized
structured questionnaire from 139 nurses (participants) caring from patients in the
cardiac care units (CCU) and emergency departments. Results: The study enrolled
139 nurses (females 84% and males 16%); with various qualification degrees master
10 %, Bachelor 67% and diploma 23% randomly selected from the already
mentioned departments. About 55% of the participants had level of knowledge in
management of acute myocardial infarction below average while 42% of the study
sample had attitude below average. Moreover, 58% of the participants had below
average skill. By testing the factors that affect the competence components it
appeared that training, management guidelines, qualification, experience in nursing
and number of years expended in CCU and emergency department had got
significant effect.Conclusion: It was concluded from this study that the level of the
nurse competence in the management of patients with acute myocardial infarction
depends on the advanced level of training and setting of clear guidelines for
management.
Keywords: Myocardial infarction, Nursing, CCU
INTRODUCTION
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
22
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Cardiovascular disease remains a major healthcare problem and one of the most consumers of
the public health resources. Ischaemic heart diseases (IHD) remain the commonest cause of
death all over the world. As in statistical reports of the World Health Organization (WHO);
2011, the rate of death per 100,000 due to coronary artery diseases in Yemen was 238.5,
Sudan; 212.0, Bangladesh; 203.7, Libya; 199.3 and Jordan; 162.5[1]
.While 114.000 people
in UK are admitted to hospital with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) annually [2
ACS is
composed of unstable angina (UA), non ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction
(NSTEMI) and ST- segment elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) [3, 4, and 5]
. An acute
myocardial infarction (AMI) is an emergency situation requiring immediate diagnosis and
treatment; it is caused by complete blocked of the coronary artery due to a thrombus
attached to a ruptured plaque. In some instance acute myocardial infarction (AMI) occurs due
to physiologic stress [5,6,15].
Also there are a number of risk factors known to predispose to the
AMI . It is important that the patients presenting with acute myocardial infarction treated
promptly‘ [3, 7].
So initial therapy should focus on stabilizing the patient's condition, relieving
ischemic pain and providing antithrombotic; [8, 9, 10].
Some complications may occur immediately following the heart attack or may need a
time to develop [11].
The goals of care are to master any potential life-threatening
complications for instance ventricular fibrillation and to minimize the time to reperfusion. [12]
In the USA was reported that the incidence rates of STEMI decreased between 1997 and
2005 from 121 to 77; in some instances the management of acute myocardial infarction
continues to undergo major changes. Good practice should be based on sound evidence.
According to measurement criteria of American Association of Critical-Care Nurses
(AACN) acquires and maintains current knowledge and competency in the care of acutely
and critically ill patients. The nurse participates in ongoing learning activities to acquire and
refine the knowledge and skills needed to care and seeks learning opportunities that reflect
evidence-based practice in order to maintain clinical skills and competencies. So the nurse
engages in a self-assessment and formal performance appraisal on a regular basis own
nursing practice in relation to professional practice standards, institutional guidelines, rules,
and regulations to identifying areas of strength as well as areas where professional
development would be beneficial[13,14].
The word competency is wider meaning. ―According to Australian nursing and
midwifery Council (ANMC) ; national competency standers.‖ competence was described as
combination of skills, knowledge, attitudes, values and abilities that underpin effective
and/or superior performance in a profession/occupational area. Also it was being described
in the clinical practice as what an individual is able to do by ―Ottawa conference‗s
recommendations 2010‖ .Miller pyramid has been used over the last twenty years as a
framework to assessing clinical practice competence . This pyramid consists of these items
(knows, know how, show and does) .They use many tools for the competence assessment,
but Self-assessment has been reported as the most common form of competence
assessment. Evidence about the effectiveness of self-assessment in the assessment of
competence and cost-effectiveness .It assists nurses to maintain and improve their practice
by identifying strengths and an area that may need to be further developed and gives
individuals conscious control over practice accompanied by a decrease in quality of
care.(1,2)
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
23
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
The overall aim of this study is to assess the knowledge attitude and skills of the
nurses who work at CCU and ER during emergency management for patients with acute
myocardial infarction . In order to identify the gaps regard nursing care and to search for
solutions with expertise and policy makers to construct plans and strategies to fill the gaps
and to fulfillment high quality nursing care.
Justification:
Critical illness requires life-saving intervention and application of high technology
medicine and intensive nursing within a specialist critical care unit. An acute
myocardial infarction (AMI) is an emergency situation requiring immediate diagnosis
and treatment
Nursing competence has become a controversial issue in healthcare settings around
the world, as it affects many aspects of the nursing profession, including education,
practice and management. These are five stages of competence which include,
novice, advanced beginner, competent, proficient and expert (3)
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Research Design: This study was a descriptive hospital based one.
Study setting: The study was conducted in five hospitals in Khartoum State (Khartoum,
Alshab, Khartoum North, Ahmed Gasium and Omdurman) in a period from 2012 to 2013 at
Cardiac Care Units and emergency departments.
Study population: Any nurse working in the CCU and emergency departments in these
hospitals had an equal chance to be enrolled in the study.
The study population includes only nursing staff who work at public teaching hospitals at
Khartoum state; it is covers 139 of nurses from both gender (females 84% and males 16%);
with various qualification degrees (master 10.%, Bachelor 67% and diploma 23%) included
the Nurses whose experience was more than three months and any nurses with experience
of less than that period.
The Study sample and sampling: The study enrolled 139 nurses from the study population
by random sampling. The study included only nurses whose experiences were more than
three months in these departments.
Data collection:
Data were collected by standardized structured questionnaire in direct interviewing of the
participants.
The study variables included qualification, nursing experience and period of work, training,
knowledge: about definition of acute coronary syndrome (ACS), components of ACS, initial
management of acute myocardial infarction, thrombolytic agents, and defibrillators. Skill
assessment included monitoring criteria, administration of thrombolytic agents, defibrillation
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
24
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
and use of protocol and guidelines. The attitude included the nurse action when bleeding or
allergic reaction occurs.
The questionnaire consisted of 48 questions that covered the following domain;
demographic data, knowledge, attitude and how to practice. Most questions were multiple
choice, each question item scoring from very poor to very good modified based on multiple
Likert scale [17].
Pre- testing: The questionnaire was pre- tested twice before the conducting the survey and
all corrections and changes were done. The questionnaire also reviewed by expert for
information quality and legitimacy then necessary corrections were made. The internal
consistency of this questionnaire also was tested using Cronbach‘s alpha test which is the
most common test used to measure the internal consistency. This test follows certain steps
using SSPS software program. The volunteers who assisted in data collection were
adequately trained.
Data Analysis: The raw data were collected, cleaned and coded. SPSS version 19 statistical
computer software program was used for the data analysis; and excel microsoft program
used for graphs.[71]
The analysis reflects the competency among the study population. Firstly
assesses each variable of knowledge, attitude and skill individually, and then compute these
variables to give core level of these three items. Lastly we compare between them using
person chi-square test and spearman correlation, t-test and ANOVAs test. Data was
presented in figures which included level of knowledge, skill and attitude and tables
included cross tabulations and linear regression relationship.
Ethical considerations: Permission to carry out this study was granted by the Ethics and
Research Committee of the College of Medical and Health Sciences at AL Neelain
University. Also agreement was granted after written consents from authorities in the
ministry of health, hospitals, CCU and emergency departments All participants provided
verbal consent prior to beginning of the interview after thorough explanation of what the
study was all about by the interviewers and full information's of nurses' staff & their
agreement.
RESULTS
Competency of the nurses
Table (1) Level of the study sample competency regard emergency care of patient
with acute myocardial infarction (n=139)
s of competency Level below average Level at average and above Total
knowledge Account 77 62 139
% 55.4% 44.6% 100 %
Attitude Account 58 51 109
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
25
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
% 41.7% 36.7 % 78.4%
Skill Account 80 56 136
% 57.6% 40.3% 97.9
Miss=21.6%
Table (2): Competency of the study population regard emergency care of patient with
acute myocardial infarction
One-Sample Test
Items N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
t df Sig. (2-
tailed)
knowledge 139 16.9065 7.93807 .67330 25.1 138 .000
Attitude 109 8.3486 1.70715 .16352 51.1 108 .000
Skill 136 13.6103 3.36028 .28814 47.2 135 .000
Table (3): Competency of the study population regard emergency care of patient with
acute myocardial infarction
Non-parametric test
Items Chi-Square df Asymp. Sig.
knowledge 87.748 33 .000
Attitude 94.250 16 .000
Skill 50.606 8 .000
The one-way ANOVA test
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
26
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Table (4): Level of the study population competency regards management of acute
myocardial infarction versus. of advance life support training (ALS)
Training of ALS
Factors N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge Yes 30 20.2000 7.69415 1.40475 1 6.866 .010
No 109 16.0000 7.79601 .74672 137
Total 139 16.9065 7.93807 .67330 138
Skill Yes 30 14.8333 3.10820 .56748 1 5.260 .023
No 106 13.2642 3.36169 .32652 134
Total 136 13.6103 3.36028 .28814 135
Attitude Yes 24 8.5000 1.66812 .34050 1 .240 .625
No 85 8.3059 1.72533 .18714 107
Total 109 8.3486 1.70715 .16352 108
.
Table (5): Levels of competency of the study population versus uses of protocol and
guidelines
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
27
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Availability of protocol and guidelines
Levels N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge Yes 51 20.3725 7.42956 1.04035 1 17.16
.000
No 88 14.8977 7.55674 .80555 137
Total 139 16.906 7.93807 .67330 138
Skill Yes 49 14.734 3.44465 .49209 1 9.09
.003
No 87 12.977 3.15851 .33863 134
Total 136 13.610 3.36028 .28814 135
Attitude Yes 33 9.0606 1.49874 .26090 1 8.83 .004
No 76 8.0395 1.70834 .19596 107
Total 109 8.3486 1.70715 .16352 108
Table (6): Competency of the study populations about emergency care of AMI regard
streptokinase training
Training about streptokinase
Levels N Mean Std.
Deviatio
n
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge Yes 21 22.38
1
5.89471 1.2863
3
1 12.77
.000
No 11
8
15.93
2
7.87697 .72513 137
Tota
l
13
9
16.90
7
7.93807 .67330 138
Skill Yes 21 14.66
7
2.93825 .64118 1 2.48
.118
No 11 13.41 3.40789 .31779 134
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
28
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
5 7
Tota
l
13
6
13.61
0
3.36028 .28814 135
Attitude Yes 15 9.000 1.36277 .35187 1 2.57 .112
No 94 8.245 1.73940 .17941 107
Tota
l
10
9
8.349 1.70715 .16352 108
Table (7); Level of competency among the study population versus qualification.
Effect of qualification on competency of nurses
Factors N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge Master 14 8.5000 3.13172 .83699 2 3.55 .032
B.Sc 93 7.5591 2.47361 .25650 136
Diploma 32 6.4375 2.82771 .49987 138
Total 139 7.3957 2.67468 .22686 2
Skill Master 13 14.000
0
3.55903 .98710 133 1.20 .305
B.Sc 91 13.835
2
3.11721 .32677 135
Diploma 32 12.812
5
3.89737 .68896 2
Total 136 13.610
3
3.36028 .28814 106 .322 .725
Attitude Master 11 8.3636 1.91169 .57640 108
B.Sc 72 8.4306 1.61704 .19057 2
Diploma 26 8.1154 1.90425 .37345 136
Total 109 8.3486 1.70715 .16352 138
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
29
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Table (8) : Competency of the study population versus period of the work at CCU and ED.
Competency and Years of work at CCU
Factors N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge < 1 37 15.3784 9.00725 1.48078 3 2.25
.087
1-2 30 17.4667 7.38934 1.34910
3-4 18 21.4444 7.31817 1.72491 111
4+ 30 16.5333 8.70090 1.58856
Total 115 17.1739 8.41496 .78470 114
Skill < 1 37 13.4324 4.33680 .71297 1.20
.353
1-2 30 13.8667 3.25612 .59448 3
3-4 16 15.3125 2.67628 .66907 108
4+ 29 13.7586 2.92349 .54288
Total 112 13.9018 3.51563 .33220 111
Attitude < 1 33 8.0909 1.87689 .32673
1.20
.313
.
1-2 29 8.6552 1.79833 .33394 3
3-4 17 8.8235 1.13111 .27433 104
4+ 29 8.1034 1.67641 .31130
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
30
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Total 108 8.3611 1.71010 .16455 107
Table (9): Level of competency of the study population versus nursing experience
Level of competency and nursing experience /years
Items N Mean Std.
Deviation
Std.
Error
df F Sig.
knowledge <3 6 5.333 1.751 .715 3
134
137
4.58 .004
3 -5 2 5.500 2.121 1.500
6 -8 13 5.539 2.402 .666
9+ 117 7.744 2.637 .244
Total 138 7.399 2.684 .229
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
31
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
Skill <3 6 11.833 2.639 1.078 3
131
134
2.22 .089
3 -5 2 14.000 4.243 3.000
6 -8 13 11.769 3.346 .928
9+ 114 13.912 3.343 .313
Total 135 13.615 3.372 .290
Attitude <3 4 6.500 1.000 .500 3
105
108
2.24 .088
3 -5 1 10.000 . .
6 -8 7 7.857 2.340 .885
9+ 97 8.443 1.646 .167
Total 109 8.348 1.707 .164
DISCUSSION
These results showed that the majority of the study population had below average
competence in knowledge (55%) attitude (42%) and skill (58%).
By one way-ANOVAs test; to compare different factors that can influence the items
of competence such as training, protocol and guidelines, qualification, experience in nursing
and number of years expended in critical care unit (CCU) and emergency departments the
result showed that; there was significant effect of training on the level of knowledge and skill,
but insignificant effect on the attitude (P values.010, .o23, .625) [(table 4]
.
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
32
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
The advanced life support training has been emphasized by American heart
association guidelines 2010, for cardiopulmonary resuscitation; the evaluation and
management of acute coronary syndromes (ACS). They are intended to define the scope of
training for healthcare providers who manage patients with suspected or definite acute
myocardial infarction within the first hours after onset of symptoms. The healthcare providers
managing the individual patients are best suited to determine the most appropriate treatment
strategy [24].
The effect of training about streptokinase on the competency was highly significantly
on knowledge (p value .000), but insignificant effect on skill and attitude (p value .118,.112 );
this may indicate that they are some errors in the training program. But the effect of uses of
protocol and guidelines; had significant effect on all aspects of competence (p values .000,
.003, .004) [table 5,6].
The quality of medical care is largely contingent on educating health personnel to
provide continuous comprehensive care that is rooted in the concepts of the chronic care
model and promotes self-management. Adherence to clinical practice guidelines and the
reduction of unwarranted variability in medical practice were very important.
Adherence to guidelines recommended therapies improved in-hospital outcomes; for
mortality 2.2% vs. 3.9%, P=0.0008, for recurrent ischemia 13.7% vs. 20.4%, P=0<0.0001) [26]
There was significant differences of the level of knowledge versus qualification and
insignificant between skill attitude among the s study population respectively (p values .032,
.725, .305) this clear in linear representation; the level of knowledge was high and slightly
raise of the level of skill and fall of the level of attitude among nurses who hold master
degree while attitude slightly high among the nurses with bachelor degree. [table 7].
So the low
effect of qualification on the skill and attitude related to that; most of study population (80%)
their specialties differs than scope of care which they given. Most of their specialties are
pediatrics, maternity and community this means there is mal displacement.
Also there were insignificant differences on the levels of competence regarding period
of work at CCU and emergency department respectively (p value .087, .353, .087,.353) . This
was related to the low average of years of working at CCU and ED among the study
population (1.8 year, std .deviation . 1.08) .However there were (92.8%) their worked
period blow the average only 6.2% who worked above the average . This means all the staff
of CCU are junior and the number of expert staff are low ; When you look at linear
relationship you can see the competency starts to raise exponentially up to 3-4 years of
work then starts to decline again . This reflects the competency independent on the years of
work only and it was not enough to raise the competency of the staff unless there was
updating of knowledge. So international they constructed that renewed the license of work
every 5 years. [table 8]
There was significant difference between the nursing experience and the level of
knowledge ( p values .004), while the differences were insignificant with skill and attitude P
value (088,.089). The skill and attitude level were fluctuating on linear relationship. Also the
average experience of most nurses who were working there was 1.3 years (Std. deviation
.467), however 67.6% of the nurses staff their nursing experience below the average, this
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
33
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
means the nurses who work at CCU and emergency department have no enough experience
to take responsibility of care for the patients with acute myocardial infarction.
A similar study was carried out by Riitta-Liisa in 2012 at University of Turku,
Finland; to evaluate competence between graduating nursing students and nurses in intensive
and critical care nursing was self-rated as good by 69%, as excellent by 25% and as moderate
by 6%. However, graduating nursing students‘ knowledge and skills for working in intensive
and critical care were poor. The students‘ self-ratings of their knowledge and skill base were
also significantly lower than nurses‘ ratings. However, both groups reported the same attitude
and value base, which was excellent. So the level of the nurses‘ competence was better than
our nurses [27].
Study limitation
There are Limitations to assess others environmental factors that can affect the quality of
nursing care and performance.
Limitation to assess nature of the training and protocol which used
Suggestions for further research
According to the results study the following suggestions for further researches are
proposed to assess the factors interfere with nursing competence during critical care should
be studied further
To study how basic nursing competence develops during clinical practice in CCU And
ED.
To study how basic nursing competence develops during orientation programs.
Also suggestions of further interventional research to improving environmental work and
enhance quality care.
Conclusion
So the core competency of the study population was poor and there was low effect of
nursing experience, qualification, years of work at CCU or ED, protocol and training. Also
most of the study population had low nursing experience, in addition to lack of training,
protocol and guidelines for management patients with acute myocardial infarction.
REFERENCES
1. World health organization (WHO), 2011. Coronary Heart Disease /selecting cause of
death rate per 100.000 http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/cause-of-death/coronary-
heart-disease/by-country.
2. Louise Newson ,2012 , Acute Coronary Syndrome/ Document ;ID: 13357 Version: 3
EMIS; available at http://www.patient.co.uk/health/acute-coronary-syndrome
3. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines
Network ,2007, Acute coronary syndromes ISBN 1899893 741A available at /
http://www.sign.ac.uk/pdf/sign93.pdf JuneUpdated 2010
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
34
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
4. Danish M.INAM , 2004, Short Textbook of Medical Diagnosis and Management, 5th
edition JOKAR publications / provided by www.medicines.org.uk/guides Page 1 - 2
Last updated 2010
5. Lewis. S.M. Heitkeper. M.M., Dirksew .S.N, 2004, Medical Surgical Nursing,
Assessment and Management of Clinical problems, 6th edition, Mosby.
6. Braunwald Zipes , Libby, 2001, Heart disease a textbook of cardiovascular medicine
volume (1),Saunders, 6th
edition ( p :1040- 1063 )
7. Richard N .Figoros, 2009, Acute_cronary _Syndrome /411204/1 heart health centre
available web http:// www. Heart disease. About .com.
8. Hjermann .I; (1983): A randomized primary preventive trial in coronary heart disease:
The Oslo study. Perv Med 12:181-184
9. American Association of Critical-Care Nurses (AACN) 2008 Scope and Standards for Acute
Critical Care Nursing Practice , ISBN 1-929209-22- AACN #130300
10. Thomas J Ryan, MD, 2011),Initial Evaluation Management of Suspected Acute
Coronary Syndrome in the Emergency Department , Boston University School of
Medicine chest pain or discomfort.
11. Kristen J.Overbaugh , 2009, Practice Guidelines in the Care of Patients with
Cardiovascular disease/ American Journal of Nursing, volume109/ pages 42-52 website
THROMBOLYTICS.mht
12. Hans-Richard Arntz and etals, 2009, Contemporary Management of Acute St segment
Myocardial infarction, Thrombolysis and PCI as major treatment options. Edited by
Raderschadt ,Published by infill Kommunikation GmbH 2004-2006 web site at
http://www.health.state.ny.us
13. American Association of Critical-Care Nurses (AACN) ,2008 ,Scope and Standards for
Acute Critical Care Nursing Practice , ISBN 1-929209-22- AACN #130300
14. World Health Organization, 2009; Percutaneous Coronary Interventions (PCI) 2004-
2006 web site http://www.health.state.ny.us.
15. Wikipedia , 2011, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acute_coronary_syndrome last ST _
segment _elevation infarction ,Justification reference 71-79 ,last update 2013
16. ANN BRADSHAW SRN DIP N (2007) Defining ‗competency‘ in nursing (Part I): a
policy review (Lond.),Journal of Clinical Nursing/ Volume 6, Issue 5, pages 347–354,
September 1997avalable : http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-
2702.1997.tb00327.x/abstract
17. B.J Witcher. 2013, What Should a PhD Look Like‖,Graduate Management
Rsearch,5(1),summer 1990,29-36
http://www.griffith.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0008/137771/Guidelines_For_Phd.pdf
18. The University of Melbourne , (20130 stage program designed to assist PhD ,ABN:84
002 705 224 Graduate Centre Australia / available
http://gradresearch.unimelb.edu.au/writingcentre/
19. Florence S. Downs (2012) PhD Program in Nursing Research and Theory
Development /HANDBOOK FOR PHD STUDY /Ver. 33, 8-23-2012 / New York,
New York, 10003 http://nursing.nyu.edu/sites/default/files/PhD_Handbook v33 8-23-
12tt.pdf
20. NM Nachreiner et .als (2007 ) Perceptions of Violence and the Work Environment..
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA 2007 Industrial Health 2007,
45, 672–678 http://www.jniosh.go.jp/en/indu_hel/pdf/IH_45_5_672.pdf
NMJ November 2013 الثاني عشر العدد –ة مجلة النيلين الطبي
35
2013 Al Neelain Medical Journal vol.3 No. 12 ISSN 1858-627
21. Statistical Analysis (1-way ANOVA)/ Silicon Genetics (2003)
[email protected] | Main 650.367.9600 / IBM. Versions 16 – 20
http://free-doc-lib.com/lib/agile-online-tools.pdf
22. sQ Faryadi (2012) How to Write Your PhD Proposal: A Step-By-Step Guide/
Faculty of Science and Technology Department of Computer Science University Sains
Islam Malaysia (USIM). / American International Journal of Contemporary Research.
Vol. 2 No. 4; http://www.aijcrnet.com/journals/Vol_2_No_4_April_2012/12.pdf
23. Linda Campbell( 2013);
Components of a Biology graduate thesis. Format ... Ch.3: Materials and Methods ...
http://biology.queensu.ca/~gstud/guide%2006-07.htm. 4 .
http://www.dspguide.com/ch3.htm
24. . LR Ajeswaran, (2009),
Cardiopulmonary Resuscitations: Perceptions, Needs and Barriers Experienced by the
Registered Nurses IN Botswana /Health Studies, University of South Africa
http://uir.unisa.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10500/4925/dissertation_rajeswaran_l.pdf
25. Braunwald Zipes ,
Libby, 2001, Heart disease a textbook of cardiovascular medicine volume (1),Saunders,
6th
edition ( p :1040- 1063 )
26. Mohammad Al-Jarallah
etal Trends in the Use of Evidence-based Therapies Early in the Course of Acute
Myocardial Infarction and its Influence on Short Term Patient Outcomes Open
Cardiovasc Med J. 2011; 5: 171–178. Published online 2011 August
27. RL Lakanmaa etals (
2012) : Competence requirements in intensive and critical care nursing – TURUN
YLIOPISTO UNIVERSITY OF TURKU/ Turku 2012
http://www.doria.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/76824/Annales%20D%201014%20Lakanm
aa%20DISS.pdf