54
新田宗土/Muneto Nitta (慶應義塾大学/Keio U.) Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BEC 基研研究会「場の理論と弦理論」@京大基礎物理学研究所 2012724

Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

新田宗土/Muneto Nitta (慶應義塾大学/Keio U.)

Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BEC

基研研究会「場の理論と弦理論」@京大基礎物理学研究所

2012年7月24日

Page 2: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

① MN, Phys.Rev.D85 (2012) 101702 [arXiv:1205.2442 [hep-th]]

② MN, Phys.Rev.D85 (2012) 121701 [arXiv:1205.2443 [hep-th]]

③ MN, arXiv:1206.5551 [hep-th]

Hiromitsu Takeuchi (Hiroshima U.)

Kenichi Kasamatsu(Kinki U.), Makoto Tsubota (Osaka City U.)

① Phys.Rev.A85(2012)053639[arXiv:1203.4896 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

② arXiv:1205.2330 [cond-mat.quant-gas]

③ J.Low.Temp.Phys.162(2011)243 [arXiv:1205.2328 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

④ JHEP 1011 (2010) 068 [arXiv:1002.4265 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

Field Theory

Bose-Einstein Condensates(BEC)

Page 3: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Pair annihilations of particle and anti-particle (hole)

turn to energy.

In string theory, pair annihilations of D-brane and

anti-D-brane were studied extensively. A.Sen etc

Dp-brane + anti-Dp-brane → D(p-2)-branes

How about extended objects?

How about extended objects in field theory (& cond-mat)?

Page 4: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

closed string production by brane pair annihilation

brane

anti-brane

2nd component inside vortex p -p

Brane-anti-brane

annihilation in BEC Simulation

by Takeuchi

Takeuchi-Ksamatsu-MN-Tsubota,

J.Low.Temp.Phys.162(2011)243 [arXiv:1205.2328 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

Page 5: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Plan of my talk

§1 Introduction (2p)

§2 Domain wall annihilation (12+3p)

§3 Monopole-string annihilation (6+1p)

§4 Knot/Vorton/Knotted instanton (4+3p)

§5 Conclusion (1p)

Page 6: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Plan of my talk

§1 Introduction (2p)

§2 Domain wall annihilation (12+3p)

§3 Monopole-string annihilation (6+1p)

§4 Knot/Vorton/Knotted instanton (4+3p)

§5 Conclusion (1p)

Page 7: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

O(3) sigma model

equivalent to

CP1 model

Vacuum

Vacuum

13 n

13 n

Stereographic

coordinate u z

yx

n

innu

1

1. (Truncated model of) 2component BECs

2. Ferromagnet

Target space = S2

n(x)=(n1,n2,n3)

N

S u

u

0u

domain

wall

Page 8: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Single domain wall

x1

x2(3)

un ,13

0 ,13

un

Wall solution U(1) phase

Arrows

viewed from N

Page 9: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

WT

u

uuuum

u

muudx

u

umudxE

22

*

11

*

22

2

11

22

222

1

1

2

1

2

1

Bogomol’nyi completion for domain wall

1

1

2

2

2

2

1

1

22

**1

1

1

1

1

1

2

x

x

zzW

u

um

u

udxm

u

uuuumdxT

01 muu

BPS equation Topological charge

Page 10: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

A pair of a domain wall and an anti-domain wall

phase p

x1

x2(3)

un ,13

0 ,13

un

Approximate solution

Page 11: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

A pair of a domain wall and an anti-domain wall

Unwinding

Fix

x1

x2(3)

phase p

un ,13

0 ,13

un

Approximate solution

Page 12: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u
Page 13: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u
Page 14: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

? ?

4 possibilities of

domain wall ring

Page 15: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Unstable to decay

Domain wall

rings

Page 16: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Topologically

stable lump Z )(1 2

2 Sp Z )(1 2

2 Sp

Domain wall

rings

Page 17: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

L

xyyxyx

T

u

uuuui

u

uiud

u

uMudE

22

**

22

2

22

222

11

1

r

r

k

u

uuuuixdT

xyyx

L

p

2

122

**

2

Lump topological charge

Bogomol’nyi completion for lumps

Z )( 2

2 Sk p

0uiu yx

BPS equation

Page 18: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Wall annihilations in 3+1 dimensions

Vortex-loops formed

Page 19: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Mass matrix

Fayet-Illiopoulos parameter

U(1) Gauge theory with Nf =2 (extended Abelian-Higgs model)

Lumps = Vortices

This can be extended to U(Nc), Nf

Page 20: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

T-dual

Hanany-Witten(‘97)

Embedding into String theory Eto,MN,Ohashi,Ohta&Sakai,

Phys.Rev. D71 (2005) 125006

[hep-th/0412024]

Page 21: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Kinky D-brane

for a domain wall Kinky D-brane

for wall-anti-wall Vortex!!

Eto,MN,Ohashi,Ohta&Sakai(th/0412024)

Page 22: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Kinky D-brane

for wall-anti-wall Vortex!!

Hanany&

Tong(‘03) Kinky D-brane

for a domain wall

Eto,MN,Ohashi,Ohta&Sakai(th/0412024)

D1

Page 23: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Plan of my talk

§1 Introduction (2p)

§2 Domain wall annihilation (12+3p)

§3 Monopole-string annihilation (6+1p)

§4 Knot/Vorton/Knotted instanton (4+3p)

§5 Conclusion (1p)

Page 24: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Non-Abelian Gauge theory (Non-Abelian-Higgs model)

U(2) gauge theory NF =2

in d=3+1, 4+1 or 5+1

real adjoint Higgs

NF =2 fundamental Higgs H

Mass matrix

Fayet-Illiopoulos parameter

2v

vacuum 2

21vH

MColor-flavor

locked vacuum

U(2)C ×SU(2)F

→SU(2)C+F

Page 25: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Non-Abelian vortex

This solution breaks SU(2)C+F → U(1)

The moduli space of Nambu-Goldstone modes:

0

)( ,

)( 0

ANO

12

12

0

ANO zzFF

v

zzHH

)( ),( ANO

12

ANO zFzH

21FC

)1(

)2(SP

U

SU CCCC

Translation 0z Internal symmety

0m Hanany-Tong,

Konishi et.al (’03)

We can embed the ANO solution

Page 26: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

The effective theory is the model 1PC

“vacuum state” fluctuation of zero modes

vm 0

2

0z

Page 27: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Tong(‘03), Hanany-Tong,

Shifman-Yung (‘04)

Eto,Isozumi,MN&Sakai(‘04)

Confined monopole

Kink on a NA vortex = monopole

Domain wall

tension Monopole

mass

Numerical solution

by Fujimori

Page 28: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

d=4+1

Monopole string

in vortex membrane

Monopole-anti-monopole

in vortex membrane

Page 29: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Twisted monopole-rings are created in d=4+1

What are

they??

Answer: Yang-Mills instantons (particles)

Lumps in NA vortex

= YM instantons in bulk

Eto-Isozumi-MN

-Ohashi-Sakai

PRD72 (2005)

[hep-th/0412048]

Page 30: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Embedding into String theory

monopole

anti-monople

Instanton!!

vortex

vortex

vortex

Page 31: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Domain wall and Anti-domain wall

Monopole and Anti-monopole

Strings (anti-)vortices (anti-)Yang-Mills instantons

Sheets (membranes)

Closed vortex strings

Closed instanton strings

Summary up to here

String theory

Page 32: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Plan of my talk

§1 Introduction (2p)

§2 Domain wall annihilation (12+3p)

§3 Monopole-string annihilation (6+1p)

§4 Knot/Vorton/Knotted instanton (4+3p)

§5 Conclusion (1p)

Page 33: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Brane-anti-brane with stretched string

Approximate analytic solution

Page 34: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

A B C

Untwisted loop

Twisted loop

Knot (n=1)

Twisted loop

Knot (n=2)

Page 35: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Twisted loop

Page 36: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Faddeev-Niemi, Nature 387 (1997) 58

Knot soliton (Hopfion)

Linking number = 1

Knots in Spin 1 BEC

Kawaguchi-MN-Ueda

PRL(‘08) [arXiv:0802.1968

[cond-mat.other]]

Page 37: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Y2

Y1

brane

anti-brane

-p p Phase of

Pair anihilation

stable vortex ring(vorton)

Y2

Y1 Y2 has superfluid flow inside a vortex ring of

Fundamental string

Y1

Simulation

by Takeuchi

Vorton creation in BEC

MN-Takeuchi-Kasamatsu-Tsubota

Phys.Rev.A85(2012)053639 [arXiv:1203.4896 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

= 3D Skyrmion

Page 38: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Watching Dark Solitons Decay into Vortex Rings

in a Bose-Einstein Condensate

B. P. Anderson et.al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 2926–2929 (2001)

(JILA, National Institute of Standards and Technology and Department of Physics,

University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado)

Dark soliton

removing (Untwisted)

vortex ring

Experiments in BEC

decay

Vorton!!

Vorton creation in BEC

Page 39: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

3D Skyrmion unstable or at most metastable

Artificial “SU(2) gauge field”

stabilizes 3D Skyrmion Kawakami,Mizushima,MN&Machida

Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 015301 (2012)

advertisement

Page 40: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u
Page 41: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Plan of my talk

§1 Introduction (2p)

§2 Domain wall annihilation (12+3p)

§3 Monopole-string annihilation (6p)

§4 Knot/Vorton/Knotted instanton (4+3p)

§5 Conclusion (1p)

Page 42: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Domain wall and Anti-domain wall

Monopole and Anti-monopole

Strings (anti-)vortices (anti-)Yang-Mills instantons

Sheets (membranes)

Closed vortex strings

Closed instanton strings

Sheets with stretched strings

Knots (Hopfions) Knotted instantons

① Brane-anti-brane annihilations in field theory

Page 43: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u
Page 44: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

massive O(3) sigma model

2221

4

1zSMSdE

r

stereographic coordinate

u Sx iSy

1 Sz

u for Sz 1

u 0 for Sz 1

E dru

2M 2 u

2

1 u2

2

Reu

Imu

×

S

D-brane-like object in Field Theory

Page 45: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound

VW

zzz

xyyxyx

TT

u

uuuuM

u

Muu

u

uuuui

u

uiud

u

uMudE

22

**

22

2

22

**

22

2

22

222

1

2

1

2

11

1

r

r

TV = 2 p NV

vortex charge

TW = ± M, 0

domain wall

charge

Page 46: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

00

2

1

0 2

0

1

)2(

1

)1(

izzM

Wz

N

j j

N

j j

Vyx

euMuu

uuiuk

k

BPS equations

u ,z emM zz0 i 0

j

(1) j1

Nk1

j

(2) j1

Nk2

x iy

vortices

domain wall

vortices in

vortices in

y1

y2

¼ BPS

solution

Y.Isozumi, M.Nitta, K.Ohashi, N.Sakai

Phys.Rev. D71 (2005) 065018 moduli (z0, 0) ∈ R x S1

localized U(1) Nambu-Goldstone mode

½ BPS solutions

I 2 d3 det gij Fij

i0 ijk jAk DBI action endpoints of vortices are electric charges

BIon

duality

J.P.Gauntlett, R.Portugues,

D. Tong, P.K. Townsend

Phys.Rev. D63 (2001) 085002

Page 47: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

O(3) sigma model

CP1 model

Vacuum N

Vacuum S

un ,13

0 ,13

unAdding 4 derivative term

= Faddeev-Skyrme model

Page 48: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

All exact(analytic) solutions

of ¼ BPS wall-vortex states Y.Isozumi, MN, K.Ohashi, N.Sakai

Phys.Rev. D71 (2005) 065018

[hep-th/0405129]

Exact analytic solutions

Page 49: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

0 2 4 6 8

z

r

Y1 (z > 0)

Sz

vortex

domain wall (z = 0)

domain

wall

Y2 (z<0)

monopole

(boojum)

Sz

z

x

y vortex

Wall position

(log bending)

sigma model

BEC

Sz =0

Kasamatsu-Takeuchi-MN-Tsubota

JHEP 1011:068,2010[arXiv:1002.4265]

D-brane in a laboratory

Page 50: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

(a)

Y1

Y2

z

x

y

(b) (c)

y = 0 plane

Sz

z = 0 plane

monopole

anti-monopole

Sz

z

x

y

z

x

y

vortex lattice

Page 51: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Analytic (approx) solution of brane-anti-brane with strings

Page 52: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Untwisted loop Unstable to decay

Page 53: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Phase of 1Y

Phase of 2Y

Vorton

Vorton creation in BEC

MN-Takeuchi-Kasamatsu-Tsubota

Phys.Rev.A85(2012)053639 [arXiv:1203.4896 [cond-mat.quant-gas]]

Page 54: Brane-anti-brane Annihilations in Field Theory and BECsoken.editorial/soken... · Bogomol’nyi-Prasad-Sommerfield bound W V z z z x y x y y x T T u M u u u u u u Mu u i u u u u u

Inside a NA vortex in d=5+1

4 derivative correction Eto-Fujimori-MN-Ohashi-Sakai

PTP(2012)

[arXiv:1204.0773[hep-th]]

Knotted instanton MN,arXiv:1206.5551 [hep-th]