25
http://www.diva-portal.org This is the published version of a chapter published in Befolkningshistoriska perspektiv: Festskrift till Lars-Göran Tedebrand. Citation for the original published chapter : Brändström, A. (2004) På återbesök i Nedertorneå: Spädbarnsdödlighet, utomäktenskaplighet och sociala nätverk. In: Redaktionskommitté Anders Brändström, Sören Edvinsson, Tom Ericsson och Peter Sköld (ed.), Befolkningshistoriska perspektiv: Festskrift till Lars-Göran Tedebrand (pp. 35-58). Umeå: Umeå universitet N.B. When citing this work, cite the original published chapter. Permanent link to this version: http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:umu:diva-129575

Brändström, A. (2004) Befolkningshistoriska perspektiv

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

http://www.diva-portal.org

This is the published version of a chapter published in Befolkningshistoriska perspektiv: Festskrift tillLars-Göran Tedebrand.

Citation for the original published chapter :

Brändström, A. (2004)På återbesök i Nedertorneå: Spädbarnsdödlighet, utomäktenskaplighet och sociala nätverk.In: Redaktionskommitté Anders Brändström, Sören Edvinsson, Tom Ericsson och Peter Sköld(ed.), Befolkningshistoriska perspektiv: Festskrift till Lars-Göran Tedebrand (pp. 35-58). Umeå:Umeå universitet

N.B. When citing this work, cite the original published chapter.

Permanent link to this version:http://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:umu:diva-129575

Ix xk\iY\jzb ` G\[\ikfie\x)Lgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k' lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^_\k fZ_ jfZ`XcX ewkm\ib)

:cYZgh;gtcYhigvb

=\k mXi ` \e dpZb\k jgweeXe[\ fZ_ jk`dlc\iXe[\ d`caz aX^ XiY\kX[\ jfdle^ [fbkfiXe[ ` _`jkfi`jb [\df^iX]` m`[ Nd\x le`m\ij`k\k) F`kk Xm_Xe[(c`e^jwde\' jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ` [\e efiiYfkke`jbX ]zijXdc`e^\eG\[\ikfie\x' bwe[\j jfd Xkk Y\kiw[X ale^]ilc`^ dXib ]zi [\e [\df^iX]`(jbX ]fijbe`e^\e) ?zijXdc`e^\ej bpibfYzZb\i _X[\ jkiXo k`[`^Xi\ [Xkfi`j\iXkjXm =\df^iX]`jbX [XkXYXj\e) =\k mXi ]zijkX ^xe^\e ==;5j [\kXcai`bX dX(k\i`Xc Xemwe[\j ]zi Xkk jkl[\iX dfikXc`k\k) B YziaXe gx ,43+(kXc\k mXid`bif[\df^iX]`jbX jkl[`\i Xm [z[c`^_\k i\cXk`mk ]x) <_i`jk\i P`eY\i^j jkl([`\i Xm =XcX gXjkfiXk fZ_ Lkli\ FXi[e`lj le[\ijzbe`e^ Xm c\meX[jz[\e]zi 00- gfabXi ]z[[X ` Lbxe`e^j gXjkfiXk lk^afi[\ k`[`^X `ejg`iXk`fejbwccfi)tm\e d`eX _Xe[c\[Xi\ CXe Lle[`e fZ_ EXij(@ziXe M\[\YiXe[ mwZbk\ d`kk`eki\jj\ ]zi dfikXc`k\kj]fijbe`e^ ^\efd j`eX [\df^iX]`jbX fZ_ jfZ`Xc(_`jkfi`jbX jkl[`\i Xm ,2++( fZ_ ,3++(kXc\kj Yilbjd`caz\i)Oxi\e ,424 fi^Xe`j\iX[\ =\df^iX]`jbX [XkXYXj\e \e c`k\e nfibj_fg

bi`e^ k\dXk jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k) Pfibj_fg\e mXi dpZb\k \ogcfiXk`m k`ccj`e bXiXbkwi) =\e ]`Zb `ek\ ex^fk fd\[\cYXik i\jlckXk ` ]fid Xm lggjXkj\i\cc\i Xe[iX glYc`bXk`fe\i) B [XkXYXj\ej Y`Yc`fk\b' k`cc`bX d`kk ]zijkX kawejk\(ild gx le`m\ij`k\k\k' Yc\m c`^^Xe[\ \e _Xcmd\k\i_z^ fZ_ \a XeXcpj\iX[ kiXm\kXY\cclkjbi`]k\i) CXe Lle[`e' d`e _Xe[c\[Xi\ le[\i ]fijbXilkY`c[e`e^\ej]zijkX xi' kpZbk\ Xkk jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k mXi \kk cwdgc`^k ]fijbe`e^jfdix[\]zi [\e ep\ [fbkfiXe[\e) DXejb\ ble[\ ex^fk jlYjkXek`\cck _`kkXj ` kXY\cc(kiXm\e9 vm\i \e bfgg bX]]\ ^afi[\j [\ ]zijkX `XbkkX^\cj\ieX5 jgw[YXiej([z[c`^_\k\e ` \e Xm [XkXYXj\ej ]zijXdc`e^Xi mXi \efidk _z^' m`jjX xi gxd\ccXe /+(0+ ! Xm XekXc\k ]z[[X) =\e fd\[\cYXiX jclkjXkj\e mXi Xkk [\kef^ dxjk\ mXiX ex^fk ]\c ` [\k [Xkfi`j\iX[\ dXk\i`Xc\k) =\k Yfi[\ ^\efd(]ziXj bfekifcc\i ` [z[( fZ_ Y\^iXme`e^jYzZb\ieX) F`e ]zijkX i`bk`^X ]fijb(e`e^jlgg^`]k jfd [fbkfiXe[ Yc\m jxcle[X Xkk jwkkX d`^ e\[ d\[ c`jkkiXm\efZ_ awd]ziX lgg^`]k\ieX d\[ bpibfYzZb\ieX) =\k m`jX[\ j`^ jeXik Xkk

/1

=\df^iX]`jbX [XkXYXj\ej lgg^`]k\i mXi bfii\bkX fZ_ Y\iwbe`e^XieX jkwd[\)Lgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e mXi m\ibc`^\e f]XkkYXik _z^ ?zijXdc`e^\e jfd c`j(kfieX fd]XkkX[\ mXi G\[\ikfie\x ` jz[iX Mfie\[Xc\e)=\k jfd aX^ ]fik]XiXe[\ Y\kiXbkXi jfd d`e ]fijbXibXii`wij k`cc [X^j

[Xkf ifc`^Xjk\ k`[ m`[kf^ Ü[\ ]zijkX XeXcpj\ieX Xm [\jjX [XkXc`jkfi ` c`^(^Xe[\ :.(]fidXk) Dlimfi fZ_ [`X^iXd i`kX[\j ]zi _Xe[ ` iXjXe[\ kXbkfZ_ [`jblk\iX[\j `mi`^k Xm d`^ fZ_ CXe Xcck \]k\i [\k Xkk [\ ]wi[`^jkwcc[\j)Lg\Z`\cck ]XjZ`e\iX[\ Yc\m m` Xm [z[c`^_\k\e ` G\[\ikfie\x le[\i [\e ]zij(kX dxeX[\e \]k\i YXie\ej ]z[\cj\) Awi m`jX[\ [\k j`^ Xkk jgw[YXiej([z[c`^_\k\e mXi jpee\ic`^\e dXibXek' jwijb`ck le[\i m\ZbfieX kmx fZ_ ki\\]k\i ]z[\cj\e) Bek\ le[\i [\ ]zijkX [X^XieX jfd wi [\k kpg`jbX dzejki\k)HZ_ [\k m\ibX[\ ]iwdjk [iXYYX Yze[\ieXj YXie ` ]zijXdc`e^\e' `ek\ [\]Xkk`^X afi[YilbjXiY\kXieX) OX[ ble[\ [\kkX Y\if gx9 Bek\ ble[\ [\k mwc_X Xkk ^ziX d\[ lgg]z[e`e^\e Xm jgw[YXie\e9 CXe Lle[`e [if^ j`^ ewd(c`^\e k`cc d`ee\j \e bXe`ele^\ _Xej YXie ]`Zb jfd _lj[ali) DXe`ele^\e mXijx c`k\e Xkk [\e ]fik]XiXe[\ mXi ` Y\_fm Xm df[\idazcb ]zi j`e k`ccmwok)Gx^fe jx[Xe ]z[X ]Xeej [fZb `ek\ Xkk k`cc^x) :cckjx lgg]z[[\ dXe bXe`e\ed\[ mXec`^ bfdazcb) =\k ]le^\iX[\ `ek\ jx YiX) DXe`e\e ]`Zb [`Xiiy fZ_[f^ \]k\i \kk Z`ibX ki\ m\Zbfi' eXklic`^km`j k`cc YXie\ej jkfiX jfi^ fZ_ Y\[iz(m\cj\) Bek\ ble[\ [\k mwc mXiX jx Xkk jgw[YXie\e ` G\[\ikfie\x ]`Zb bf(dazcb `jkwcc\k ]zi Yizjkdazcb9 :kk [\ [f^ ` jgw[YXiej[`Xiiy\i mXi _zcakYfikfd Xcc km`m\c) =\k m`kkeX[\ G\[\ikfie\xj giwjk fd ` j`e [z[( fZ_Y\^iXme`e^jYfb) =\e Lle[`ejbX bXe`ele^\ej jfi^c`^X z[\ ^Xm jxcle[XlggjcX^ k`cc à_lml[jgxi\kää ` [\k jfd j\[\id\iX Yc\m d`e [fbkfijXm_Xe[(c`e^ }=Z `tg^Z`h^vhV bvYgVgcV} GZY\uc\Zc ^ hetYWVbhYvY)o\WZi ^KkZg^\Z jcYZg+2**'iV^Zi& bZYhtgh`^aY]tchnci^^ GZYZgidgcZu(:m_Xe[c`e^\e Y\iwkkX[\ _`jkf(i`\e fd _li jgw[YXie\e ` ]zijXdc`e^\e Xm kiX[`k`fe lgg]z[[\j d\[ bf(dazcb `jkwcc\k ]zi Yizjkdazcb fZ_ _li j\[Xe' ^\efd YXiedfijbfieXjlkY`c[e`e^jbXdgXea\i' bm`eefi ]zijkf[ Xkk YziaX XddX) Lgw[YXiej([z[c`^_\k\e ble[\ [wi`^\efd _Xcm\iXj gx ex^iX ]x [\Z\ee`\i' le[\i ,3++(kXc\kj j\eXi\ _wc]k) :iY\k\k ]zijmXiX[\j ,43/ jfd ]zijkX Xm_Xe[c`e^ m`['[\e m`[ k`[\e kmx xi ^XdcX' :m[\ce`e^\e ]zi A`jkfi`jb [\df^iX]`)

Ix xk\iY\jzb ` G\[\ikfie\x

B [\eeX lggjXkj jbX m` xk\imwe[X k`cc G\[\ikfie\x fZ_ ex^fk ]zi[algX XeX(cpj\e) Mal^f xi _Xi ]zi]clk`k j\[Xe Xm_Xe[c`e^\e glYc`Z\iX[\j fZ_ dpZb\k_Xi _wek `efd [\e _`jkfi`jbX dfikXc`k\kj]fijbe`e^\e) @\efd ]c\iX jkzii\

/2

:cYZgh ;gtiiYhigvb

]fijbe`e^jgifa\bk' ]iwdjk ` Nd\x' NggjXcX' E`ebzg`e^ fZ_ Ele[' _Xi mxiblejbXg fd [\e jm\ejbX dfikXc`k\kje\[^xe^\e fZ_ jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k(\ej ifcc ` [\eeX m`[^Xkj Y\kp[c`^k) Lgw[YXie[z[c`^_\k\e _Xi Yc`m`k ]zi\dxc]zi Y\kp[Xe[\ ]fijbe`e^ wm\e `ek\ieXk`fe\cck) @\efd ]Xd`ca\i\bfejk`klk`f(e\i _Xi ]fijbe`e^\e bleeXk ]fblj\iX gx `e[`m`[e`mxe) Gp blejbXg fd [\bfdgc\oX d\bXe`jd\i jfd gxm\ibXk YXiej zm\ic\meX[ fZ_ ]ziwe[i`e^Xi `[z[c`^_\k zm\i k`[ _Xi ^\e\i\iXkj) tm\e epX jkXk`jk`jbX XeXcpjd\kf[\i _Xilkm\ZbcXkj' k \o àgifgfik`feXc _XqXi[j df[\cjà ]zi zm\ic\meX[jXeXcpj)@\efd [\jjX _Xi m` bleeXk ex dpZb\k cwe^i\ ` mxik \ogcfiXk`mX jzbXe[\\]k\i jkXk`jk`jbX jXdYXe[ fZ_ ` gizmXe[\k Xm epX _pgfk\j\i)Gwi d`e Xm_Xe[c`e^ bfd k`cc ]Xeej dpZb\k c`k\k Xm [\kkX) ;iX jkXk`jk`jbX

i\[jbXg' Y\^i`gc`^X fZ_ Xemwe[YXiX ]zi _`jkfi`b\i' jXbeX[\j) ?i\bm\ej( fZ_bfijkXY\cc\i ]`Zb iwZbX cxe^k) Gx^iX xi k`[`^Xi\ _X[\ [fZb =) K) <fo gi\Z`jglYc`Z\iXk \e Xik`b\c ` CflieXc f] k_\ KfpXc LkXk`jk`ZXc LfZ`\kp) F\[ Xik`b\ce]zca[\ \kk XekXc j`[fi d\[ \kk [Xkfigif^iXd jbi`m\k ` gif^iXdd\i`e^j(jgixb\k ?HKMK:G),F`e bfcc\^X gx ==;' jkXk`jk`b\ie @ziXe ;ifjkizd'beXggX[\ d\kf[`jbk `e [\kkX gif^iXd ` jkfi[Xkfie ]zi Xkk gizmX [\e epXXeXcpjd\kf[\e gx d`eX G\[\ikfie\x([XkX) Mifkj ef^^iXee bfii\bklicwj(e`e^ Xm gif^iXdbf[\e ]le^\iX[\ [\k [fZb `ek\) >kk le[iXe[\ Yi\m jbi\mjk`cc <fo) >kk jmXi bfd i\cXk`mk jeXik) Gwi kipZb\i`\k jXkk\ Xik`b\ce _X[\ dXeXm d`jjkX^ bXjkXk fd kmx j`[fi Xm bf[\e k`cc [Xkfigif^iXdd\k Gwi [\kkXxk^wi[X[\j ble[\ m` ^ziX \e' ` [X^\ej z^fe iwkk \eb\c i\^i\jj`fejXeXcpj'[wi m` mw^[\ `e \kk XekXc gxm\ibXej]Xbkfi\i gx jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e `G\[\ikfie\x) =\e ]zijkX <fo i\^i\jj`fejXeXcpj\e gx jm\ejbX _`jkfi`jbX[z[c`^_\kj[XkX ^zd[\j le[Xe ` ;`cX^X , cwe^jk YXb ` Xm_Xe[c`e^\e)?c\iX' `[X^ kwdc`^\e Z\ekiXcX ]Xbkfi\i' Yc\m [wi]zi `ek\ le[\ijzbkX) Awi

bXe ewdeXj [\ lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie\ej j`klXk`fe fZ_ [\ jfZ`XcXewkm\ib\ejY\kp[\cj\ ]zi zm\ic\meX[\e) ;XiedfijbfieX jkl[\iX[\j lk`]ixe [\iXj ifccjfd blejbXgjjgi`[Xi\' `ek\ ` m`cb\e lkjkiwZbe`e^ [\ wm\e ^afi[\ \e jb`cceX[m`[ ]zicfjje`e^XieX) Gwi m` jx YziaX[\ kXcX fd Xkk jwkkX jXddXe \e ]\jk(jbi`]k k`cc gif]\jjfi EXij(@ziXe M\[\YiXe[j g\ej`fe mwZbk\j \e kXeb\ _fjd`^ Xkk ^ziX \kk c`k\k bfdgc\kk\iXe[\ àxk\iY\jzbà ` G\[\ikfie\x ` jp]k\ Xkkjkl[\iX aljk [\jjX ]Xbkfi\ij Y\kp[\cj\ ]zi [\ jgw[X YXie\ej zm\ic\meX[)

Lgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ` G\[\ikfie\x Ü\e bfik i\jldy

=z[c`^_\k\e YcXe[ YXie le[\i \kk xij xc[\i mXi \oki\dk _z^ ]zi j`e k`[#]`^li ,$)

/3

?`^li ,) KetYWVgchYvYa\]ZiZc ^ GZYZgidbZu +2+2|+23/( =vYVeZg +***xYYVkVg)ZtghVbi\a YVcYZ[ZbtghbZYZ)iV (

BFK 0 g\i) c`[) d\[) #BFK$

1++

0++

/++

0 .++

Å .,,

-,,

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n

Ne[\i \ejkXbX xi mXi [\e k`cc fZ_ d\[ ]zijbiwZbXe[\ _z^) Ne[\i g\i`f([\e ]iXd k`cc ZX ,3/+ cx^ [\e ]c\iX ^xe^\i zm\i /++ [z[X g\i ,+++ ]z[[X)Hdbi`e^ ,3/+ _we[\ ex^fk) ?zijXdc`e^\e ^`Zb `e ` \e igVch i dch)Vh [wijgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e YziaX[\ jalebX) MiXej`k`fej]Xj\e mXiX[\ k`cc ZX ,31+)Lgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e _X[\ el ewjkXe _Xcm\iXkj le[\i \e kal^fxijg\i`f[)=\e ]fikjXkk\ m`jj\ic`^\e Xkk jalebX ex^fk wm\e le[\i [\ ]zcaXe[\ [\Z\e(e`\ieX' d\e kwdc`^\e Ycp^jXdk) O` bXe bXccX [\k \e hiVW ) hZg c\h[Vh( ?zijkfdbi`e^ ,330 YziaXi [\e xk\i jalebX e\[ k`cc \e e`mx gx ,0- [z[X g\i ,+++]z[[X xi ,340) Nkm\Zbc`e^\e dfk cw^i\ [z[jkXc wi jcx\e[\' d\e m`[ ,3++(kXc\kj jclk _X[\ G\[\ikfie\x ]fik]XiXe[\ \e jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k jfd cx^[ip^k 0+ ! zm\i i`bj^\efdje`kk\k)Lgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ` ]zijXdc`e^\e m`jX[\ \kk dpZb\k kp[c`^k jkX[(

cXe[dzejk\i #]`^li -$) =\kkX _we^[\ jXddXe d\[ jkfiX blckli\ccX' ewi`e^j(dwjj`^X fZ_ jgixbc`^X jb`cceX[\i) >]k\i [\k Xkk Mfie\x ^xkk ]zicfiXk jfdjm\ejbk _Xe[\cjZ\ekild' \]k\i bi`^\k d\[ KpjjcXe[ ,3+3(,3+4' XecX[\j \kkepkk _Xe[\cjZ\ekild ` AXgXiXe[X Yp) >^eX _lj]zi_zijcwe^[\i YziaX[\ ]z(iXj ,3.1) ui ,3/- ]`Zb AXgXiXe[X dle`Z`gXcjkpi\cj\ fZ_ jkXg\cjkX[j(iwkk`^_\k\i) ;\]fcbe`e^jjXddXejwkke`e^\e' c`bjfd jgixb\k jb`ca[\ j`^ d\c(

/4

:cYZgh ;gtcYhigvgc

cXe ]zijXdc`e^j[\cXieX) B jkX[\e bfd dXafi`k\k\e Xm Y\]fcbe`e^\e ]ixe]zijXdc`e^Xi lkXe]zi Mfie\[Xc\e fZ_ jgixb\k mXi ` _lml[jXb jm\ejbX) >bf(efd`jbk ^peeX[\j jkX[\e Xm Di`dbi`^\k le[\i j\eXi\ _wc]k\e Xm ,30+(kXc\k) AXe[\cjiljZ_\e _X[\ \e Y\kp[Xe[\ \]]\bk gx ]zidz^\e_\kjY`c[e`e^\efZ_ gxjbpe[X[\ `e]cpkke`e^ fZ_ liYXe`j\i`e^)-:de`e^\e jfd \kXYc\iX[ lgg]z[e`e^jd\kf[ Xm [\ jgw[X YXie\e ]`Zb

i\[Xe ]ixe YziaXe jkXibk ]wjk\ ` jkX[\e' jXeefc`bk Y\if\e[\ gx Xkk Yfi^\i(jbXg\k ]zi[\ d\[ j`^ [\eeX kiX[`k`fe) LkX[\e lk^afi[\ YfjkX[jfik Yx[\]zi cwbXi\e fZ_ ]zi YXiedfijbXe)

?`^li -) KetYWVbhYvY)o\WZiZceu )VcYhWn\YZc dX] ^ AVeVgVcYV( =vYVeZg +***[^YYV( ?ZbughbZYZ)iV (

EXe[jYp^[ AXgXiXe[X

/0+

/++

.0+

f -0+

& .,,

çf ,0+

,++

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

=\ kmx fdix[\eX mXi mXiXe[iXj dfkjXkj\i fd m` j\i k`cc [z[c`^_\k\e) BjkX[\e cx^ jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e' j\[Xe [\k YziaX[\ ]ziXj j\gXiXkX bpib(c`^X cwe^[\i' gx le[\i ,++ g\i ,+++ ]z[[X) =\kkX mXi \e dpZb\k cx^jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k ` ,3++(kXc\k Lm\i`^\) L`klXk`fe\e YziaX[\ ]zijwdiXjex^fk ]zi YXie\e ` jXdYXe[ d\[ \ogXej`fej]Xj\e gx ,30+(kXc\k) =z[c`^(_\k\e jk\^ k`cc jkiXo le[\i -++ g\i ,+++ ]z[[X fZ_ Yc\m j\[Xe c`^^Xe[\

/5

i\cXk`mk jkXY`ck gx [\eeX e`mx) Ix cXe[jYp^[\e ex[[\j \e kfgg gx ,3-+( k`cc,3/+(kXc\e' mXi\]k\i jkX[`^ e\[^xe^ gxYziaX[\j) Ix ,34+(kXc\k Yc\m ]zi_xc(cXe[\eX ]zi jgw[YXie\e k`cc fZ_ d\[ Ywkki\ we ]zi jkX[\ej YXie);\kp[Xe[\ jfZ`XcX jb`cceX[\i ` jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k ]Xeej fZbjx `

G\[\ikfie\x) B ]`^li . j\i m` _li ki\ _lml[e`mx\i lijb`ca[\j) =\e _z^jkXe`mxe i\gi\j\ek\iX[\j Xm Yze[\ieX' [\e d\cc\ijkX Xm afi[Yilb\kj XiY\kXi\fZ_ [\e cw^jkX Xm pib\jlkY`c[X[\ XiY\kXi\*_Xekm\ibXi\ jXdk [\e c`ccX zm\i(fZ_ d\[\cbcXjj\e) O` j\i fZbjx Xkk [\ jfZ`XcX jb`cceX[\ieX `ek\ mXi jx jkfiX `YziaXe' [wi [\ pib\jlkY`c[X[\ XiY\kXieX fZ_ zm\i*d\[\cbcXjj\e ]zijk jwebk\j`e jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k) =\ ]zca[\j j\[Xe Xm afi[Yilb\kj XiY\kXi\ fZ_ XcciXj`jk jazeb jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e YcXe[ Yze[\ieX) Ix ,32+(kXc\k ix[[\ `ek\cwe^i\ ex^iX jkfiX jfZ`XcX jb`cceX[\i)

?`^li .) KetYWVgchYvYa \]ZiZc W)VcY aZkVcYZ[^YYV WVgc ^cd)c t`iZch`VeZi ^GZYZgidgcZuS +2+/|+23.( =vYVeZg +***[dYYV ^ d) `V hdX V)V\gjeeZg ?Zb'ugh)cZYZ)iVa

b\LX VJO TLKLSRSHYY IeUKLX j mj ^XRLYHXILZHXL QVXKIX[RLZY [UKLXRSHYY

1++

0++

i\ /++

( .++

J -++

,++

+ii<=

VV VVÄ"Gc

,,,,

,,,,

VV<H

,, ,,,,

,,/V ,, ,,]h ,,JU

ff+0

ui

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

0,

:cYZgh ;gtcYhigvb

=\ ki\ ]`^li\ieX ]xe^Xi gx \kk kp[c`^k jwkk [\e gifZ\jj jfd jb\[[\ `G\[\ikfie\x fZ_ jfd jkl[\iX[\j ` Xm_Xe[c`e^\e) >e Y\kp[Xe[\ e\[^xe^Xm jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ` G\[\ikfie\x `ec\[[\j gx ,3/+(kXc\k ewi cwbXi\fZ_ YXiedfijbfi YziaX[\ gifgX^\iX ]zi Xde`e^) Mp[c`^X blckli\ccX jb`cc(eX[\i ]Xeej d\ccXe jkX[\ej `ee\mxeXi\ fZ_ [\e fdbi`e^c`^^Xe[\ cXe[j(Yp^[\e) B jkX[\e XddX[\ bm`eefieX ` i\^\c j`eX YXie) IifYc\d\k d\[[`_fiejlgg]z[e`e^ mXi jkzijk ]iXd]ziXcck gx cXe[jYp^[\e fZ_ ]iwdjk `Yfe[\]Xd`ca\ieX) =\ ]Xkk`^Xjk\' jfd `ek\ _X[\ ix[ k`cc bfdazcb' _X[\ ` i\^\cYwkki\ zm\ic\meX[ YcXe[ [\ jgw[X YXie\e) MiX[`k`fe\ccX dzejk\i ^`Zb [fZbXkk YipkX) :de`e^jbXdgXea\ieX jfd [i\mj _X[\ jkX[`^ ]iXd^xe^) Iifm`ej`Xc(cwbXi\e' <XicCfjlXPi\k_fcd ble[\' ` j`e j`jkX iXggfik k`cc Lle[_\kjbfcc\^`ld,310 fZ_ jkiXo ]zi\ j`e [z[ ` bfc\iX' iXggfik\iX5 àGl wif k`[\ieX ]ziwe[(iX[\ fZ_ Yze[\ieX d\[ [\d)))à.

;XiedfijbfieXj ifcc

G\[^xe^\e ` jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k ` G\[\ikfie\x Y\if[[\ k`cc jkfi [\c gx]ziwe[iX[ jgw[YXiejmxi[ Ü _lml[jXb i\cXk\iX[ k`cc jgw[YXie\ej lgg]z[(e`e^) ?zijXdc`e^\ej XcciX ]zijkX \oXd`e\iX[\ YXiedfijbX <Xk_Xi`eX ?i\[(i`bX P`[dXe ]ixe Ezmxe^\i ` Owjk\iYfkk\e m\ibX[\ d\ccXe xi\e ,3.2 fZ_,3/0) Afe \ijXkk\j Xm <Xk_Xi`eX Kfj\e^i\e jfd mXi ` kawejk k`cc ,3/3) F\c(cXe xi\e ,3/4 fZ_ ,3/. _\kk\ YXiedfijbXe :eeX <_i`jk`eX ;\i^jkizd'mXi\]k\i <Xk_Xi`eXP`c_\cd`eX :_cjkizd' G\[\ikfie\xj YXiedfijbX ` zm\i/+ xi fZ_ m\ibjXd ]fik]XiXe[\ gx ,34+(kXc\k' kiw[[\ ` kawejk) ;XiedfijbfieXjg\cX[\ m`[ [\eeX k`[ \e Z\ekiXc ifcc jfd blejbXgjjgi`[Xi\) =\ _X[\ ^\(efd j`e lkY`c[e`e^ ` LkfZb_fcd ]zijkxkk m`bk\e Xm Xkk YXie lgg]z[[\j d\[df[\ijdazcb) =\ _X[\ cwikj [\ gfj`k`mX \]]\bk\i [\kkX _X[\ ]zi YXie\kj_wcjX' `ek\ d`ejk ]zi Xkk i\[lZ\iX jgw[YXiej[`Xiiy\ieX) @\efd Xkk XejkwccXkmxjgixb`^X YXiedfijbfi ` G\[\ikfie\x ex[[\j wm\e cXe[jYp^[\ej ]cejb(kXcXe[\ bm`eefi gx \kk YiX jwkk) G\[\ikfie\x ` Lm\i`^\ wi `ek\ \e[X \o\dg(c\k gx [\e lkY`c[Xe[\ ifcc [\ jg\cX[\) Ix BjcXe[ jg\cX[\ [\ fZbjx \e Z\ekiXcfZ_ m`bk`^ ifcc ` [\e kiXej`k`fej]Xj jfd [\cXi Xm cXe[\k ^`Zb `^\efd le[\i,3++(kXc\kj j\eXi\ _wc]k fZ_ YziaXe Xm ,4++(kXc\k)/=\e gifZ\jj ]zi Ywkki\ jgw[YXiejlgg]z[e`e^ jfd YXiedfijbfieX

]iXd^xe^ji`bk [i\m Ü[\e lkY`c[Xe[\ [\c\e Xm [\iXj m\ibjXd_\k ( jkl[\(iX[\j gx \kk `e^x\e[\ jwkk ` Xm_Xe[c`e^\e) OX[ jfd `ek\ Yc\m XeXcpj\iXk mXi[\iXj _lml[jXbc`^X XiY\kjlgg^`]k jfd ]ziczjXi\ Xm bm`eefieX ` ]zijXd(c`e^\e)

0-

Ngg^`]k\i fd YXiedfijb\]zicfjje`e^Xi `e]zi[\j ` G\[\ikfie\x fZ_AXgXiXe[Xj bpibfYzZb\i ]ixe fZ_ d\[ ,31,) =\ ^\i [fZb \e[Xjk lgg^`]kfd à\oXd`e\iXk Y`kiw[\à \cc\i àlgg^`]k jXbeXjà) =\k wi jxcle[X \e dpZb\kfgxc`kc`^ `e]fidXk`fe jfd dxjk\ kfcbXj d\[ jkfi ]zij`bk`^_\k) :kk àlgg^`]kjXbeXjà Y\kp[\i al `ek\ jXddX jXb jfd Xkk ]zicfjje`e^\e [wid\[ jb\[[\lkXe YXiedfijbXej Xjj`jkXej) =\k \e[X m` m\k wi Xkk lgg^`]k\e Xm ex^feXec\[e`e^ `ek\ ]zi[\j `e)Gfk\i`e^XieX ^\i [fZb m`[ _Xe[\e Xkk ,+ ! Xm jgw[YXie\e gx cXe[j(

Yp^[\e ]z[[\j le[\i YXiedfijbXej zm\i`ej\\e[\ gx ,31+(kXc\k) Ix ,34+(kXc\k _X[\ [\eeX j`]]iX zbXk k`cc [ip^k // !) B AXgXiXe[X jkX[ mXi YXie(dfijbfieX ]c`k`^Xi\' Xck\ieXk`mk lgg^`]k\ieX f]kXi\ `e]zi[X ` bpibfYzZb\ieX)Ix ,31+(kXc\k ]z[[\j ewiX 1+ ! d\[ _awcg Xm YXiedfijbX fZ_ gx ,34+(kXc\k mXi j`]]iXe lgg\ ` ewjkXe 40 !) Lb`cceX[\ieX d\ccXe jkX[ fZ_ cXe[j(Yp^[ _wim`[cX^ wi kpg`jbX) Lkl[`\i ]ixe' k`cc \o\dg\c Lle[jmXcc fZ_ Lb\cc\](k\x' _Xi m`jXk gx c`beXe[\ [`]]\i\ej\i)0,33+(kXc\k bXe jw^Xj dXib\iX \e m`bk`^ d`cjkfcg\ ` jwkk\k gx m`cb\k YXie(

dfijbfieX XiY\kX[\) O`[ [\eeX k`[ `e]zi[\j biXm gx Xkk [\ jblcc\ kmwkkX_we[\i fZ_ lkiljke`e^ d\[ bXiYfcjpiX)1M`[`^Xi\ ]fijbe`e^ _Xi d\eXk Xkk[\k wi ]zijk el jfd YXiedfijbfieX ble[\ jg\cX \e Xm^ziXe[\ ifcc ]zidz[iXieXj dzac`^_\k\i Xkk le[m`bX YXiejwe^j]\Y\i fZ_ Xe[iX `e]\bk`fe\i `jXdYXe[ d\[ ]zicfjje`e^\e) =\ ble[\ ]zijk el ` zbX[ lkjkiwZbe`e^ wm\egxm\ibX YXie\ej dzac`^_\k\i k`cc zm\ic\meX[' [x ]iwdjk [\e g\i`eXkXcX fZ_[\e e\feXkXcX [z[c`^_\k\e)2B G\[\ikfie\x mXi [\ [fZb gx [\kkX gcXe `ek\ jx ]iXd^xe^ji`bX' \ec`^k

bpibfYzZb\ieXj `e]fidXk`fe) Awi ]`ee\i m` `e^X gfj`k`mX \]]\bk\i gxjgw[YXie\ej zm\ic\meX[ jfd bXe jwkkXj ` jXdYXe[ d\[ jawcmX ]zicfjje`e^\e)?zi_xccXe[\k mXi ]Xbk`jbk [\k dfkjXkkX) =\e e\feXkXcX jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\egx cXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x mXi [lYY\ck jx _z^ ` [\ ]Xcc [wi à\oXd`e\iXkY`kiw[\à Y`jkf[ m`[ ]zicfjje`e^\e B AXgXiXe[X jkX[ zbX[\ dfikXc`k\k\ele[\i ]zijkX c\meX[jdxeX[\e ,3! fd YXiedfijbXe mXi ewimXiXe[\ #]`(^li /$)3FXk\i`Xc\k wi kpmwii ]zi c`k\k ]zi Xkk m` jbX bleeX k`kkX gx [\e g\i`eXkXcX

[z[c`^_\k\e' jfd bXejb\ mXi`k weel `eki\jjXekXi\ ` jXddXe_Xe^\k) :m jXddXjbwc cxk\i j`^ `ek\ bwccdXk\i`Xc\k [\cXj gx g\i`f[\e ]zi\ fZ_ \]k\i `ekif[lb(k`fe\e Xm bXiYfcjpiX gx ,33+(kXc\k)

0.

?`^li /) DjbjaVi k cZdcViVavkZgaZkcVYx g WVgcet )VcYhWn\YZc dX] ^ AVeVgVcYVhiVY+20+|+23/& WZgdZcYZet ine Vk WVgcbdgh ZVhh hiVch(

5HWHXHUKH

/HTTVXYRLMeXSVYYUPUN

6UNLU [WWNPMZ VTIHXUTVXYRH

2]HTPULXHZ IPZXcKL

,(++)

0@/<H

>/H, (53 )

, 1 -, -1 ., .1 /,

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

9HUKYI^NKLU

/HTTVXYRLMeXSVYYUPUN6UNLU [WWNPMZ VTIHXUTVXYRH

2]HTPULXHZ IPZXcKL

,(++)

) ,(52 )

,(50 )

8): ,(5. )

,(5, )

, 1 -, -1 ., .1 /,aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

K\jlckXk\k' [fZb d\[ Y\XbkXe[\ Xm lgg^`]k\ieXj fk`cc]zic`kc`^_\k' ]zi(YipccXi) OXi [\e _z^i\ e\feXkXcX [z[c`^_\k\e YcXe[ jgw[YXie\e gx cXe[j(Yp^[\e \kk i\jlckXk Xm [xc`^ _p^`\e YcXe[ YXiedfijbfieX9 >cc\i' mXi [\kbXejb\ jx Xkk [\ k`ccbXccX[\j ]zijk ewi [\k Y\]XiX[\j Xkk ]zicfjje`e^\e jblcc\Yc` Xm [\k jmxiXi\ jcX^\k9 FpZb\k kXcXi ]zi [\e j\eXi\ kfcbe`e^\e' \]k\ijfd]zikif\e[\k ]zi YXiedfijbfieX mXi jkwe[`^k jk`^Xe[\ ]ixe ,31, fZ_ ]iXdxk)OXi]zi ]Xeej x Xe[iX j`[Xe `e^X jb`cceX[\i ` e\feXkXc [z[c`^_\k d\ccXe [\jfd ]ziczjk\j d\[ à\oXd`e\iXk Y`kiw[\à \cc\i àlgg^`]k jXbeXjà ` AXgXiXe[X9=\k bXejb\ mXi jx Xkk ewjkXe XccX ]zicfjje`e^Xi ` jkX[\e lk]zi[\j Xm YXie(dfijbXe9 DwccdXk\i`Xc\kj Yi`jkXe[\ bmXc`k\k ` [\kkX Xmj\\e[\ ^zi Xkk m` \e([Xjk bXe jg\blc\iX) Awi _X[\ m` Y\_zmk \kk jkzii\ le[\icX^ ]zi jkl[`\e'k`cc^xe^ k`cc mwc ]zi[X [z[jfijXb\i' fZ_ `ek\ d`ejk YXiedfijb\[X^YzZb\i):cck [\kkX jXbeXi m` kpmwii ` G\[\ikfie\x ]zi [\eeX k`[)

=\ àfwbkXà YXie\e ` G\[\ikfie\x

;Xie ]z[[X lkfd wbk\ejbXg\k le[\i ,2++(fZ_ ,3++(kXc\k _X[\ ewjkXe le([XekX^jczjk \e _z^i\ jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k we [\ jfd ]z[[\j `efd wbk\e(jbXg\k) =\k bXe m` bfejkXk\iX ` jkl[`\i jfd Yp^^\i gx jxmwc eXk`fe\cc jkXk`j(k`b jfd `e[`m`[[XkX) B >lifgX xk\i]`eej [\kkX kp[c`^X dzejk\i fXmj\kk i\c`(^`fe' kpg Xm jXd_wccj\bfefd`' jfZ`Xc jkilbkli' d\[ d\iX)4M`[`^Xi\ ]fijbe`e^ _Xi Y\kiXbkXk [\kkX jfd ewjkXe \kk cX^Yle[\k ]\ef(

d\e fZ_ \e \]]\bk Xm Xkk [\jjX YXie fZ_ [\iXj dz[iXi dXi^`eXc`j\iX[\j);Xie\e mXi \kk i\jlckXk Xm \e fzejbX[ ^iXm`[`k\k) =\k Y\kiXbkX[\j Xm' jxmwcbpibX jfd ]zijXdc`e^jYfi' jfd XmcX[ ` jpe[) Dm`eefieX km`e^X[\j c\mXlkjkzkkX fZ_ ` ]Xkk`^[fd) Gx^iX Xm [\d [i\mj wm\e Xkk kX j`kk \^\k c m) >kkjx[Xek z[\ Z`k\iXi CfeXj ?ipbdXe ]ixe \e ]fcbd`ee\jlggk\Zbe`e^ \]k\i`e]fidXek\e E`jX Cf_Xejjfe ` O`c_\cd`eX) }Adc #WdcYYdiiZgc$ WVgZc[thibVcdXWYZigVgiV)db ViiYZih`jYZW)iWgvYde(AVc`db d[iVdXWWt)hVYZeui[)iX`VchWZbdXWVchu\hgZYVchdbZchdci WjhZi( KujeeWvgWVchWZhv`hdbeuZiiigd))h)V\ ?)iX`Vcht\Zg ic\Zci)c\ bZc\ug[^g h^\ het)k dXW hvg)Zg( Ku Zc YV\ `Vc Wdc ^ciZ Yveu h^iii ))hiucY( Fdg WVg h`VgeV v\dc dXW Wdc btg`Zg[vgWuYVcYZi& iVg[)^X`Vc ^ h`Vgeix"gWvg dXW[ugYu gZiV ViiYdiiZgc eVciVgWVgc dXWVii[thibVccZc WVgVh)ciVgjee Viiigu[[V WZccZYuWVc[ug gZiV ViiWVc h`V W) [Vg( FVbbVc iVgh^c YdiiZgdb^)i^W ugZi^ YZiVii Wdc jiWg hiZg4 =^\ WVg)t\[dhigVieu b ^ii WthiV htii( =j WVg igVbeVieub^cV`ctc dXWg^k^ib^cV Wgvhi& bZYVcYj gVgYiZc& bZccj`dbbZgYj dXWigVbeVgeu b ^iiW)tgiV( @ujijgb ^iiWjh( =j `Vc Wtc\VY^\^ gZe ZYZg`VhiV Y^\^ h)vc& bZch`Vb vkZgdhh[u g Yj ^ciZ YgV( A ^tgZiitgWVgi[d) hdb\^k^iY^\ZctgWVgjee[dhigVc(

00

:cYZgh ;gtcYhigvb

=ZiiV iVX`VgYj dhhbZY( @u]dgV[%?YX`Vc\iX` dX][ngVYV\VghZcVgZ]iiiVYZh]ZccZhYvYV `gdee * [nvc cZYVc[ g Wnc( b B m`jjX [\cXi Xm Lm\i`^\ km`e^X[\j [\ YwiXjwijb`c[X bwee\k\Zb\e' m`cbX dXib\iX[\ Xkk bm`eeXe c\m[\ ` jpe[),,;Xie ]z[[X lkfd wbk\ejbXg\k zbX[\ biX]k`^k ` XekXc le[\i ,3++(kXc\kj

j\eXi\ _wc]k) Lwijb`ck dXibXek mXi [\eeX zbe`e^ ` jkw[\ieX fZ_ ` [\ `e[ljki`(\ccX d`caz\ieX) B Lm\i`^\ ]z[[\j le^\]wi 1- Xm ,+++ YXie jfd fwbkX ,3,,Ü,3-+) O`[ j\b\cjb`]k\kj d`kk _X[\ [\iXj Xe[\c zbXk k`cc 4+ g\i ,+++ fZ_ `YziaXe gx ,4++(kXc\k mXi j`]]ifieX lgg\ ` ,,+ g\i ,+++ ]z[[X) B [\ jm\ejbXjkw[\ieX cx^ j`]]ifieX f]kX zm\i -++ g\i ,+++ ]z[[X ( ` LkfZb_fcd weel_z^i\) HimXi Ez]^i\e _Xi jzbk ]zibcXiX [\eeX lkm\Zbc`e^ d\[ [\e jm\ejbXkiX[`k`fe\e bi`e^ [\k jb àeXkk]i`\i`\kää' [wi gfab\ fZ_ ]c`ZbX ágifmcx^à d\[mXiXe[iX) =\kkX jb\[[\ Xcck`[ le[\i i\cXk`mk bfekifcc\iX[\ ]fid\i fZ_ kiX([`k`fe\ccX i`klXc\i) KxbX[\ \e ]c`ZbX we[x ` áfcpZbXà jx^ [\e jfZ`XcX bfekifc(c\e k`cc Xkk gfab\e ^afi[\ iwkk ]zi j`^ fZ_ ^`]k\ j`^ d\[ ]c`ZbXe) B dxe^X ]Xcci\^`jki\iX[\ giwjk\e `ek\ _\cc\i YXie\k jfd áfwbkXà lkXe mXc[\ k\id\e ákif(cfme`e^jYXieà ]zi Xkk dXib\iX jb`cceX[\e) =\e jfZ`XcX fZ_ ^\f^iX]`jbX izi(c`^_\k\e le[\i ,3++(kXc\kj j\eXi\ _wc]k Y`[if^ [fZb k`cc Xkk [\ fjbi`meX cX(^XieX bi`e^ eXkk]i`\i`\k lggczjk\j) B dxe^X ]Xcc jXbeX[\ dXee\e izkk\i `cfbXcjXd_wcc\k fZ_ ^Xm j`^ Xm ` i\^\c Xm lkXe Xkk kX j`kk XejmXi) DmXi mXi [\ele^X bm`eeXe d\[ j`kk lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie),-B \e jkl[`\ YXj\iX[ gx bpibfYzZb\ieX ` Lle[jmXcc ]iXdkiw[\i \e ex^fk

Xeeficle[X Y`c[),.>e dXafi`k\k Xm bm`eefieX d\[ lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXiebfd j\eXi\ Xkk ^`]kX j ) >kk fwbkX YXie ` [\eeX d`caz kpZbj `ek\ _X `ee\Yli`k\e jx[Xe Y\cXjke`e^ Xkk bm`eeXe dXi^`eXc`j\iX[\j ]zi c`m\k) Bek\ fmwekXk mXi[\k fwbkX YXie\k \kk i\jlckXk Xm [\e ]zijkX ^iXm`[`k\k\e ` le^ xc[\i fZ_ex^fk jfd YXiX _we[\ \e ^xe^ ` c`m\k) =wid\[ ]Xeej wm\e \e Y`fcf^`jbbfdgfe\ek jfd Y`[if^ k`cc [\e _z^X jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e) K`jb\ieX ]zi[\k ]zijkX ep]z[[X YXie\k #gXi`k\k \kk$ wi Xcck`[ jkzijk Üjx wm\e `[X ) =\k]zibcXiXi eXklic`^km`j `ek\ _\cX [\e jkfiX dfikXc`k\kjjb`cceX[\e' d\e ]Xbkfiedxjk\ mw^Xj `e ` jXddXe_Xe^\k)B [\k X^iXiX Lle[jmXcc ]z[[\j d\ccXe ,+(,0 ! Xm XccX YXie lkXe]zi

wbk\ejbXg\k) B jkX[\e Lle[jmXcc mXi [\iXj Xe[\c Xm XccX ]z[[X d\ccXe -0Ü.+!) =\jjX \ejXddX dz[iXi _X[\ \d\cc\ik`[ ]fik]XiXe[\ dzac`^_\k\i bmXigx wbk\ejbXgjdXibeX[\e fZ_ \e dXafi`k\k Yc\m jeXik ef^ ^`]kX) Lgw[YXiej([z[c`^_\k\e àefidXc`j\iX[\jà fZbjx jx jeXik [\ `e^`Zb ` wbk\ejbXg d\[ \edXe) LkX[jd`caze bXe [fZb jw^Xj _X mXi`k d\i gifYc\d]pcc[ fd ^`]k\idxcmXi ex^fk jfd bm`eefieX jkiwmX[\ \]k\i) Awi `e^`Zb dz[iXi d\[ lkfd(wbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie d\i jwccXe ` wbk\ejbXgÜ\e ki\[a\[\c ]ziYc\m f^`]kX c`m\klk) =\k mXi fZbjx mXec`^k Xkk bm`eefieX ]z[[\ d\i we \kk lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^k

01

YXie ` jkX[\e) =z[c`^_\k\e mXi fZbjx dpZb\k jkzii\ YcXe[ [\jjX YXie' wm\e\]k\i [\k Xkk bm`eefieX \m\ekl\cck ]lee`k \e wbk\ejbXgjgXike\i) =\e liYXeXd`caze ` j`^ Y`[if^ eXklic`^km`j k`cc \e ^\e\i\cck j\kk _z^i\ [z[c`^_\k' fXmj\kkwbk\ejbXgc`^ Yzi[) LkX[\e [if^ dzac`^\e fZbjx k`cc j`^ [\ bm`eefi jfdjkzkkj lk ]ixe cXe[jYp^[\e) Lle[jmXcc ble[\ \iYal[X Yx[\ Xefepd`k\k fZ_XiY\kjk`cc]wcc\e ]zi \ejXddX bm`eefi' ex^fk jfd ` i\cXk`mk c`k\e lkjkiwZbe`e^\iYaz[j ` [\e dXec`^k [fd`e\iX[\ jx^m\ibj`e[ljki`e gx cXe[jYp^[\e),/;`c[\e Xm [\e \ejXddX df[\ie wi jxcle[X jXddXejXkk fZ_ bfdgc`Z\(

iX[) =\jjX' ` i\^\c dpZb\k le^X' dz[iXi lk^afi[\ \e _\k\if^\e jbXiX) O`jjXbm`eefi XZZ\gk\iX[\j d\[Xe Xe[iX ]zi[zd[\j) =\k jkfiX ]c\ikXc\k ]zicf(iX[\ j`eX YXie gx ^ile[ Xm ]Xkk`^[fd fZ_ \ebcX ]zi_xccXe[\e' d\[Xe Xe([iX km`e^X[\j k`cc d\i [iXjk`jbX xk^wi[\i jfd d\[m\k\e mXemxi[) Lfdc`^Xle^X bm`eefi ]`Zb jkz[ fZ_ _awcg Xm ]Xd`ca fZ_ jcwbk d\[Xe Xe[iX jkzkk\j lkfZ_ km`e^X[\j ]cpkkX k`cc Xe[iX ]zijXdc`e^Xi' \cc\i `e k`cc \kk fjwb\ik c`m ` jkX[\eLle[jmXcc) >e jXb _X[\ [\ [fZb ^\d\ejXdk) =\k _Xe[cX[\ ` i\^\c fd[\iXj XcciX ]zijkX ^iXm`[`k\k fZ_ ex^fk jfd pkk\ijk jwccXe dXi^`eXc`j\iX[\[\d ]zi i\jk\e Xm c`m\k) :kk ]zijziaX \kk YXie ]zi \e le^ fZ_ \ejXd df[\imXi \e jmxi Yzi[X Xkk YwiX) =\e _z^X jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e mXi jeXiXi\ \kki\jlckXk Xm [\e lkjXkk_\k jfd beXggX ]zi_xccXe[\e d\[]zi[\),0Lx cxe^kLle[jmXcc)Ali jx^ [x c`m\k lk ]zi [\ \ejXddX dz[iXieX ` G\[\ikfie\x9 E`b(

eXe[\ [\iXj j`klXk`fe [\e jfd [\iXj jpjkiXi ` Lle[jmXcc lggc\m[\9 CX'Xe[\c\e fwbkX YXie YcXe[ XccX ]z[[X ` ]zijXdc`e^\e c`beX[\ dpZb\k e`mxe `[\k X^iXiX Lle[jmXcc) =ip^k mXi k`fe[\ YXie ]z[[\j lkfd wbk\ejbXg\k) BLle[jmXccj jkX[ mXi Xe[\c\e lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X ]z[jcXi [lYY\ck jx jkfi jfd` [\ bi`e^c`^^Xe[\ ]zijXdc`e^XieX fZ_ jx^m\ibjd`caz\ieX) =\kkX mXi \kk^XejbX kpg`jbk jm\ejbk liYXek dzejk\i) B [\e c`ccX jkX[\e AXgXiXe[X mXikmwikfd lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie i\cXk`mk jwccjpekX #]`^li 0$)>e[Xjkle[\i **Vg\i`f[\i' ,303(,312 fZ_ ,313(,322' mXi [\ fwbkX

YXie\ej Xe[\c Xm XekXc\k ]z[[X jkzii\ ` AXgXiXe[X we gx cXe[jYp^[\e)LkX[\e m\ibXi _\cc\i `ek\ _X ]le^\iXk jfd \e k`cc]cpbkjfik ]zi \ejXddXdz[iXi` ex^fe jkzii\ lkjkiwZbe`e^) Gx^fe lkgiw^cX[ XiY\kjdXibeX[ ` jkX[\e jfdjbXgX[\ dzac`^_\k\i ]zi le^X bm`eefi Xkk ]ziX \e jawcmjkwe[`^Xi\ k`ccmXifm\ibXi _\cc\i `ek\ _X giw^cXk AXgXiXe[X),1L`klXk`fe\e ]zi [\ lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie\e ` jkX[\e mXi dpZb\k gi\(

bwi' bXejb\ jfd \kk i\jlckXk Xm Xkk [\ mXi jx ]x fZ_ jxcle[X i\cXk`mk le`bXjfd ]zi\k\\cj\) =z[ji`jb\ieX YcXe[ [\d mXi 0- ! ]v\gZwe YcXe[ [\ wbkX]z[[X YXie\e) Ix cXe[jYp^[\e mXi dfkjmXiXe[\ zbe`e^ Xm i`jb\e Xkk [z `jgw[ xc[\i ]zi fwbkX YXie Ycfkk 3 !) LkX[\e mXi jfd m` j\kk k`[`^Xi\ \e

02

:cYZgh ;gtcYhigvb

cx^[z[c`^_\kjd`caz ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ [\e fdbi`e^c`^^Xe[\ cXe[jYp^[\e)?zi [\ fwbkX YXie\e mXi [fZb jb`cceX[\ieX d`e[i\ d\ccXe [\ kmx d`caz\ieX#]`^li 1$),2

?`^li 0) :cYZ)Zii jidbY [Zch`Ve) \V WVb Vg VciVaZi[^YYV ^ AVeVgVcYV dX]eu)VcYhWn\YZc ^ GZYZgidbZu +2+2|+23/( L dugheZgdYZg(

EXe[jYp^[ ; AXgXiXe[X

-4(,,!

-2(,,!

-0(,,!

,-*++!

,+*++!

4 ',,!

2',,!

0*,,!

. ',,!

,*,,!-4-4)-4.3 -4.4)-4/3 -4/4)-403 -404)-413 -414)-423 -424)-433 -434)-443

:i

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

?`^li 1) KetYWVgchYvYa\]ZiZcW)VcYdY`iV WVgc^ AVeVgVcYV dX]euiVcYh[gn\YZc*GZYZg[dbZu& +2+2|+23/( LdugheZgdYZg(

ç Nt EXe[jYp^[ ; Nu AXgXiXe[X

1,,

01,

0,,

á /1,

/,,

.1,

-++-1, à C

,++

-4-4)-4.3 -4.4)-4/3 -4/4)-403 -404)-413 -414)-423 -424)-433 -434)-443 -444)

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

03

?`^li 2) Doo)cooaVioeveZg)ZecVY[^g ocdocdX]eu )VcYhWn\YZc oGZYZgidgcZu& +2+2'+23/(

BZVT cRZLUYRHWLZ

M\VWVgc oAVeVgVcYV

Zf:"}=<+2U/H

,',

,'+

'4

'3 /VYZcSSL

AXgXiXe[X

EXe[jYp^['2WWW(,++ ,++ -++ .++ /+++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

6UVT cRZLUYRHWLZ

<=:\=<H2dH

,',

,'+

'4

(4 /VYZcSSL

AXgXiXe[X

EXe[jYp^['2WW(,++ ,++ -++ .++ /+++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

9dZ[hi :htdZijhwc

Ix cXe[jYp^[\e mXi [\e ^\e\i\ccX e`mxe gx jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ]zi(]XiXe[\ _z^) DXejb\ \e zm\icX^i`e^ Xm \e pkk\ic`^Xi\ e\^Xk`m c`mj]Xbkfi [wi(d\[ `ek\ ]`Zb \kk jx jkfik ^\efdjcX^) F\[ \e dfikXc`k\k gx `YcXe[ lgg k`cc/+ ! mXi dx_we[X zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\ieX i\[Xe jx [xc`^X Xkk [\ beXggXjkble[\ Yc` mwii\9 LXddXekX^\k mXi cXe[jYp^[\e \e f_wcjfjXddXi\ d`cazXkk ]z[Xj ` jfd fwbkX YXie' d\e jb`cceX[\ieX mXi `ek\ c`bX jkfiX jfd ]zi [\wbkX YXie\e #]`^li 2$) DXe m`' d\[ Xe[iX fi[' kXcX fd \e jcX^j zmi\ e`mx]zi jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e ` efiiX Lm\i`^\9 K\jfe\dXe^\k biwm\i eXklic`^k(m`j Xkk m` iwbeXi Yfik xi d\[ \g`[\d`\i fZ_ lk^xi ]ixe Xkk ]ziwc[iXieX'lk`]ixe j`eX ]zilkjwkke`e^Xi fZ_ kiX[`k`fe\i' we[x ]zijzbk\ mxi[X j`eX YXiegx YwjkX jwkk) =\k wi \e `eki\jjXek _pgfk\j Xkk XiY\kX m`[Xi\ d\[ ]zi[z[c`^_\kj]fijbe`e^\e)=\k mXi Ywkki\ Xkk ]z[Xj ` AXgXiXe[X jkX[ ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ gx cXe[j(

Yp^[\e' d\e \e [ip^k j\ok`fgifZ\ek`^ jb`cceX[ ` [z[ji`jb\i g\bXi [fZb gx\e d`caz [wi \ejXddX dz[iXi _X[\ [\k jmxik) Nk^afi[\ AXgXiXe[X jx(cle[X \e i\gi\jj`m d`caz [wi jkX[jYfieX _X[\ jmxik Xkk _Xek\iX [\k Xmm`(bXe[\9 >kk jwkk Xkk ewidX j`^ \kk jmXi gx [\e ]ix^Xe wi Xkk le[\ijzbX Y\kp([\cj\e Xm k`cc^xe^\e gx jfZ`XcX ewkm\ib ]zi [\ \ejXdjkx\e[\ dz[iXieX)Hd ]Xkk`^[fd fZ_ XiY\kj]zi_xccXe[\e mXi _lml[fijXb fZ_ `ek\ jfZ`Xc

lkjkzke`e^ fZ_ dXi^`eXc`j\i`e^ Yfi[\ \kk jfZ`Xck ewkm\ib _X \e m`bk`^ fZ_gfj`k`m Y\kp[\cj\) ?ziwc[iXi' jpjbfe' jcwbk fZ_ mwee\i ble[\ XccX ]pccX \ele[\ijkz[aXe[\ ]lebk`fe) =\e \ejXddX df[\ie ble[\ ]x _awcg d\[ gXjj(e`e^ fZ_ mxi[ Xm YXie\k) Afe ble[\ ]x _awcg d\[ dXk' _ljild fZ_ bXejb\k`cc fZ_ d\[ g\e^Xi fd jx[XeX dzac`^_\k\i jkf[ k`cc Yl[j) O` jbX YziaX d\[Xkk le[\ijzbX Y\kp[\cj\e Xm Xkk ]ziwc[iXieX k`cc [\e \ejXddX df[\ie ]Xeej` d`caze #]`^li 3$):eXcpj\e ^\i `e^\k jkz[ ]zi Xkk AXgXiXe[X jblcc\ mXiX \e d\i i\gi\jj`m

d`caz) Mmwikfd' _wi ]Xeej [\ YwjkX zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\ieX ]zi [\ fwbkXYXie\e fd \e \cc\i Yw^^\ ]ziwc[iXieX k`ccdf[\ie ]Xeej k`cc_Xe[j),3=\ ble[\lgg\eYXic`^\e Y`[iX gx \kk \cc\i XeeXk jwkk' k`cc ^X^e ]zi [\k ep]z[[X YXie\k)Ix cXe[jYp^[\e ix[[\ [\k fdmwe[X ]zi_xccXe[\k) ?Xeej Yw^^\ ]ziwc[iXi `d`caze' mXi jgw[YXie\ej zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\i cw^jk) ?Xeej `e^X ]ziwc[iXi `c`m\k \cc\i jawcmX c\m[\ [wijkw[\j' bcXiX[\ j`^ YXie\e Ywkki\) Ngg\eYXic`^\ejx^j [\ fwbkX YXie\e d\[ d\i fYc`[X z^fe _wi) CfeXj ?ipbdXe _wm[Xi Xkk[\k mXi á` [\ i\cXk`mk jkXk`jbX' afi[YilbXe[\ jXd_wcc\e [wi dwee`jbfi mXilkcwdeX[\ xk mXiXe[iXj _awcg fZ_ mwcm`caX jfd jx[Xe kif ]if[X[\j) Cl d\idXe mXi Y\if\e[\ Xm mXiXe[iX' [\jkf jkXibXi\ Yc\m kipZb\k dfk c`b]fid`^(_\k) Awi jbXgX[\j jxmwc kip^^_\k jfd `ekfc\iXej*ä,4,G\[\ikfie\x' gx cXe[j(Yp^[\e' j\i [\k fe\bc`^\e lk jfd fd [\eeX Y\jbi`me`e^ _xcc\i jki\Zb)

05

?`^li 3) CkckbWj_l wl[hb[ldWZ\wh etajW XWhd _ @WfWhWdZW eY fu bWdZiXo]Z[dX[he[dZ[fu dthlWhed Wl\whtbZhWh j_bb ceZ[c' ,3,3},340)

9HUKYI^NKLU,',

,'+

c (5"}?<H

&1

(2(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

5HWHXHUKH

3eXcSKXHX

.

,

f(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

3eXcSKXHX

1,

9dZ[hi :htdZijhwc

Ow^\i m` `e ]zi\bfdjk\e Xm Xe[iX jcwbk`e^Xi fZ_ jpjbfe k`cc [\e \e(jXddX df[\ie' jxjfd jpjbfe fZ_ dfi( fZ_ ]Xi]ziwc[iXi' ]zijkwibj Y`c([\e) Ix cXe[jYp^[\e mXi [\iXj ewi_\k k`cc bcXi eXZb[\c ]zi [\k jgw[X YXie\k)B AXgXiXe[X Y`[if^ [\ gfj`k`mk k`cc YXie\kj zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\i)O` bXe wm\e `e[`b\iX Xe[iX kpg\i Xm ewkm\ib ^\efd Xkk ]fblj\iX gx

df[\iej ^\f^iX]`jbX lijgile^) OXi _fe jawcm YXie]z[[ ` G\[\ikfie\x \c(c\i `ek\9 LXeefc`bk wi' Xkk ]c\i jcwbk`e^Xi fZ_ mwee\i ]`eej k`cc_Xe[X ` ]zijXd(c`e^\e dXe jawcm ]zkkj ' ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ fd dXe bfdd`k `e]cpkkXe[\)uk\i`^\e ]xi m` kp[c`^X fZ_ Y\biw]kXe[\ i\jlckXk #]`^li 4$) Ix cXe[jYp^(

[\e Y\kp[[\ \e i\cXk`m Xefepd`k\k' xkd`ejkfe\ ` Y\kp[\cj\e Xkk dXe mXi`e]cpkkX[' Ywkki\ zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\i ]zi [\k fwbkX YXie\k) B AXgXiXe[X ix[[\xk\i [\k fdmwe[X ]zi_xccXe[\k) Dfd bm`eeXe jawcm ]ixe ewid`caze bcXiX[\j`^ YXie\k Ywkki\) Dfd _fe [wi\dfk jfd `e]cpkkX[ ]ixe Xe[iX ]zijXd(c`e^Xi mXi YXie\kj Z_Xej\i c`k\ jwdi\) :cciX jwdjk' ` Yw^^\ d`caz\i' ^`Zb [\k]zi YXie\e k`cc [\ bm`eefi [wi m` jXbeXi fd [\iXj ]z[\cj\]zijXdc`e^) ;cXe[[\jjX _Xi m` fZbjx \e _z^i\ i\gi\j\ekXk`fe Xm bm`eefi ]ixe afi[Yilb\kjle[\ibcXjj' jXdk Xm [\d jfd _\ck jXbeXi pib\jlgg^`]k\i ` bpibfYzZb\ieX)Lfd ewdekj k`[`^Xi\ `ee\YXi \kk lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^k YXie `ek\ \e c`mj(

cxe^ k`ccmXif ` jXd_wcc\kj lkbXek\i ]zi [\e \ejXddX df[\ie) ?x Xm [\jjXbm`eefi ]ziYc\m \ejXddX) >e dXafi`k\k Xm [\d ^`]k\ j`^ j\eXi\ ` c`m\k fZ_Y`c[X[\ ]Xd`ca) DpibfYzZb\ieX cwdeXi kpmwii `e^X lgg^`]k\i fd \m\ekl\ccXjXdYf]zi_xccXe[\e) O` bXe XeX [\jjX' \cc\i ]zi\bfdjk\e Xm \e jkXib jfZ`Xcbfekifcc' ` [\ ]Xcc [wi ]zijXdc`e^jgiwjk\e jbi`m`k `e YXie\k jfd àkifcfm(e`e^jYXieà \cc\i [wi [\k ]`eej Xek\Zbe`e^Xi fd \kk \ibweeXe[\ Xm ]X[\i(jbXg) =wi ]Xeej \e ]Xi k`cc YXie\k' jx Xkk jw^X' ` blc`jj\ieX) Be[`i\bk bXe m`gxm`jX [\kkX' [x `e^X efk\i`e^Xi Xm jx[Xe Xik jkxi Xkk ]`eeX ` ]zijXdc`e^j(YzZb\ieX' ^\efd Xkk le[\ijzbX fd [\e dXe jfd bm`eeXe ^`]k\i j`^ d\[]`eej ewimXiXe[\ ` ]zijXdc`e^\e m`[ [\k fwbkX YXie\kj ]z[\cj\) B Lle[jmXccfZ_ Lb\cc\]k\x _X[\ [\kkX \e dpZb\k gfj`k`m Y\kp[\cj\ ]zi YXie\kj zm\ic\m(eX[' m`cb\k g\bXi gx Xkk [\k bXejb\ _Xe[cX[\ fd \e ]Xd`ca\]zijziaXi\ jfdmXi àfi\^`jki\iX[à Xm giwjk\e) Alilm`[X [\kkX jg\^cX[\ ]zi\bfdjk\e XmjXdYf]zi_xccwe[\e ]xi m` cxkX mXiX fjX^k) ?X[\ie bXe eXklic`^km`j Yx[\ mXiX[\e Y`fcf^`jbX ]X[\ie \cc\i \e dXe' m`cb\e jfd _\cjk' jfd bm`eeXe j\[Xe]XkkX[\ kpZb\ ]zi)Ix cXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x _Xi m` \kk k`cciwZbc`^k XekXc lkfd(

wbk\ejbXgc`^X ]z[jcXi ]zi Xkk m` jbX bleeX ^ziX [\eeX [`jk`ebk`fe) MpmwiiYc`i ]Xcc\e Xcc[\c\j ]zi ]x ` AXgXiXe[X ]zi Xkk ^ziX XeXcpj\e d\e`e^j]lcc#]`^li ,+$)

0,

>_]kh 4) CkckbWj_l wl[hb[ldWZ\wh etajW XWhd _ @WfWhWdZW eY fu bWdZiXo]Z[dX[he[dZ[fu ceZ[ci\wZ[bi[\whiWcb_d]' ,3,3},340)

9HUKYI^NKLU

#J:}=<H2?H

,

,

'4(

:VXY MeKLSYLMeXY

:e[iX ]zijXdc`e^Xi

G\[\ikfie\x

lgg^`]k jXbeXj(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

5HWHXHUKH

<H:}<H>=H

,

,

:VXY MeKLSYLMeXY

:e[iX ]zijXdc`e^Xi

G\[\ikfie\x

lgg^`]k jXbeXj(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

0-

9dZ[hi :htdZijhwc

>_]kh ,+) CkckbWj_l wl[hb[ldWZ\wh etajWfu bWdZiXo]Z[d _ F[Z[hjec[u X[he[dZ[fudthlWhed Wl X_ebe]_ia\Whq Wbj[hdWj_lj\hWcj_ZW taj[diaWfifWhjd[h l_Z XWhd[ji\wZ[bi[',3,3(,340) ' ' ;

9HUKYI^NKLU

}?<H2.H

,',

,'+

'4

'3

/PVSVNPYR MHX UcX\'2

GwimXif

(2 r(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

Be^\e ewimXif

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

9HUKYI^NKLU

,(+ )

<H:>.<H2=H

3HX UcX\HXHUKL

IXike\i ]`eej

Be^\e gXike\i(,++ + ,++ -++ .++ /++

aSKLX P KHNHX \PK [ZZXcKL

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

0.

K\jlckXk\e ` ]`^li ,+ jkwib\i mxi lgg]Xkke`e^ fd cXe[jYp^[\e `G\[\ikfie\x jfd \e d`caz [wi àkipZb\k dfk c`b]fid`^_\kà mXi jkfik fZ_[wi [\k àjbXgX[\j jxmwc kip^^_\k jfd `ekfc\iXejà' ]zi Xkk kXcX d\[ ?ipbdXe)B [\ ]x ]Xcc [wi [\e Y`fcf^`jbX YXieX]X[\ie mXi bwe[ mXi zm\ic\meX[\e Xm[\ jgw[X fwbkX YXie\e fwe[c`^k dpZb\k Ywkki\ we fd [\k dfkjXkkX ]zi_xc(cXe[\k mXi ix[Xe[\) Awi jx^ [\e cfbXcX' jfZ`XcX bfekifcc\e Xkk ]X[\ie ^\eXjk^`]k\ j`^ d\[ [\e ]c`ZbX _Xe ^afik d\[ YXie) =\e Xe[iX Y`c[\e ^\i fjj \kkbljc`^k g\ijg\bk`m gx Xe[iX \]]\bk\i Xm \e jkXib jfZ`Xc bfekifcc) Hd [\eY`fcf^`jb\ ]X[\ie mXi fbwe[ ]zi cfbXcjXd_wcc\kj `ee\mxeXi\ \cc\i mw^iX[\kX gx j`^ ]X[\ijbXg\k' jkf[ bm`eeXe jmX^ fZ_ lkjXkk) ?zi Xkk _X dzac`^_\k\ik`cc ^`]k\idxc bXe m` ` ]`^li ,+ jbzeaX [\e Y\cXjke`e^ jfd \kk fwbkX YXie`ee\YXi) =\e le^X bm`eeXej dzac`^_\k\i Xkk ]`eeX \e dXb\ gx cXe[jYp^[\e]ziYwkkiX[\j Y\kp[c`^k fd _fe `ek\ cwe^i\ _X[\ \kk fwbkX YXie à` YX^X^\kà)@\e\i\cck j\kk mXi [\k `ek\ cwkk ]zi [\jjX bm`eefi Xkk Yc` ^`]kX' mXi\ j`^ [\k

fwbkX YXie\k ]Xeej m`[ c`m\k \cc\i `ek\) >e[Xjk /2'2 ! gx cXe[jYp^[\e bfdjx jdxe`e^fd Xkk ]`eeX \e wbk\ejbXgjgXike\i) B AXgXiXe[X mXi dfkjmX(iXe[\ j`]]iX YXiX .2'/ !) =\k bXe awd]ziXj d\[ 0.'3 ! gx ` Lle[jmXccjjkX[' 1,'4 ! ` Lle[jmXccj `e[ljki`]zijXdc`e^Xi fZ_ 04 ! ` [\k X^iXiX Lle[j(mXcc)-+Fzac`^_\k\ieX k`cc ^`]k\idxc ` G\[\ikfie\x i\[lZ\iX[\j j\[Xe [iXdX(k`jbk gx fd bm`eeXe [\jjlkfd àixbX[\ ` fcpZbXà d\i we \e ^xe^ #kXY\cc ,$)

MXY\cc ,):cYZaZc d\ [iV`k^ccdg^GZYZgidgcZu WZgdZcYZeu VciVaZijidbt iZch Vea \VcZY`dbhiZg& +22+|+23/(

:ekXclkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X :e[\c\e bm`eefi]z[jcXi g\i bm`eeX jfd ]ziYc\m f `]kX #!$

, 0-'.- 1/'/. 2/'0/ 2.'.0 & 4.'0

Fyff[6 ?_gial[`cme[ ^[n[\[m_h( Pg_z ohcp_lmcn_n*

Mm\bczjk mXi [\k \e eXZb[\c Xkk ]z[Xj lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^) =\k jbXgX[\bcXik jwdi\ Z_Xej\i k`cc zm\ic\meX[) B AXgXiXe[X zbX[\ [z[ji`jb\ieX d\[[ip^k 0- !' d\e fijXbX[\j jXeefc`bk ` ]zijkX ildd\k Xm [\e zbX[\]zijziae`e^jYzi[Xe jfd cX[\j gx \e le^ bm`eeXj XocXi) ;cXe[ [\ d`e[i\Y\d\[cX[\ fZ_ \ejXdjkx\e[\ bm`eefieX ` jkX[\e Y\kp[[\ \e ep dle XkkdwkkX lgg\eYXiX gifYc\d) vmi`^X jkX[jYfi m`jX[\ \e m`jj ]zijkx\cj\ ]zidz[iXi d\[ lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie Üxkd`ejkfe\ ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ Y\(

10

AdZ[hi JhtdZijhwc

]fcbe`e^\e gx cXe[Yp^[\ej kfc\iXeje`mx) =\e gfj`k`mX Y\kp[\cj\e Xm Xkk _Xewi_\k k`cc ]ziwc[iXi' jcwbk fZ_ mwee\i mXi kp[c`^ ` jkX[\e) =\k Y\_zm\i `ek\Y\kp[X Xkk [\ lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^X YXie\e XZZ\gk\iX[\j _\ck gx c`bX m`ccbfi)F\e [\e le^X bm`eeXe ]`Zb ex^fe ]fid Xm jkz[ jfd ^afi[\ Xkk _\ee\jYXie _X[\ Ywkki\ dzac`^_\k\i Xkk bcXiX j`^Ix cXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x mXi j`klXk`fe\e ]zi [\ \ejXddX dz[(

iXieX fZ_ [\iXj YXie jmxi ` Y\dwib\cj\e Xkk [\ `ek\ XZZ\gk\iX[\j) =\eeXd`caz mXi Xm Xcck Xkk [zdX i\gi\jj`m fZ_ ]zi[zdXe[\ dfk [\jjX bm`eefi)Ne[\i zm\icX^ beXggX fZ_ \ebcX ]zi_xccXe[\e i`bkX[\j fdjfi^\e ` ]zijkX_Xe[ k`cc YXie ]z[[X `efd wbk\ejbXg\k) DmXi Xm fdkXeb\ fZ_ bXejb\ fZbjx]zijkx\cj\ ]Xeej j\[Xe `ek\ dpZb\k bmXi) Awi mXi i\cXk`m Xefepd`k\k [\ \e(jXdjkx\e[\ dz[iXieXj YwjkX i\jlij) ?zi [\ bm`eefi jfd mXi ifkX[\ ` ]zi(jXdc`e^j^\d\ejbXg\e' [\k m`cc jw^X jawcmX ]z[[X ` ]zijXdc`e^\e' d\[ ]zi(wc[iXi fZ_ jcwbk ` cfbXcjXd_wcc\k mXi lk^xe^jcw^\k jwdi\) O`cc\ [\ kXj lgg `^\d\ejbXg\e `^\e fZ_ jx jdxe`e^fd Yc` ^`]kX' mXi [\k lkfdwbk\ejbXgc`^XYXie\k \e bmXiejk\e) DcXik zbX[\ [z[ji`jb\i' ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ [\d jfdjXbeX[\ [\kkX ewkm\ib' Yc\m [\e fd\[\cYXiX ]zca[\e ]zi jgw[YXie\e) vm\i(cX^ mXi [fZb jb`cceX[\ieX d\ccXe wbkX fZ_ fwbkX YXie `ek\ jx jkfi' \]k\ijfdcXe[jYp^[\e ` j`^ mXi \e _z^[z[c`^_\kjd`caz) =\e ^\efdje`kkc`^X [z[j(i`jb\e zbX[\ d\[ Ycfkk 3 !)

=\k bXe k\ j`^ dwibc`^k Xkk ]zi_xccXe[\eX Yc\m jx dwibYXik jwdi\ ]zi[\ dz[iXi jfd _XdeX[\ lkXe]zi \e ^\d\ejbXg [\ mXi`k \e [\c Xm ` awd(]zi\cj\ d\[ [\d jfd' gx ex^fk m`j' jkf[ lkXe]zi i\[Xe ]ixe YziaXe) >kkle[\ijkz[aXe[\ jcwbkewkm\ib ]zimXe[cX[\j d\[ [\k fwbkX YXie\kj Xebfdjkk`cc \kk i\gi\jj`mk ewkm\ib) =\ jfd jXbeX[\ [\kkX bcXiX[\ j`^ Ywkki\) =\k bXemXiX jmxik Xkk ]zijkx jx[XeX d\bXe`jd\ij jkpibX' d\e ]fijbe`e^ gx [X^\ejjXd_wcc\e m`jXi\ c`beXe[\ Y`c[\i) B \e jkl[`\ Xm jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k fZ_bm`eefij c\meX[j]zi_xccXe[\e ` mxi jXdk`[j G`ZXiX^lX m`jXi Kl[fc]f I\eX_li ]Xkk`^X bm`eefi ` ]Xkk`^X d`caz\i bcXiXi j`^ Ywkki\ we ]Xkk`^X bm`eefi ` i`bXd`caz\i) Ix dfkjmXiXe[\ jwkk bcXiX[\ j`^ Ywkki\ Y\d\[cX[\ bm`eefi jwdi\ `]Xkk`^X d`caz\i we mX[ ]Xkk`^X bm`eefi ^afi[\ ` jXddX d`caz-,) =\e i\cXk`mXi\jlijk`cc^xe^\e fZ_ i\jlijbfekifcc\e' mXi\ j`^ [\k ^wcc\i ]le^\iXe[\ jfZ`XcXewkm\ib \cc\i \bfefd`jbX k`cc^xe^Xi' wi Y\kp[\cj\]lccX)Hc`bX blckli\i fZ_ kiX[`k`fe\i ix[[\ gx cXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x

fZ_ ` AXgXiXe[X jkX[) =\ jbXgX[\ _\ck fc`bX ]zilkjwkke`e^Xi ]zi jgw[XYXiej zm\ic\meX[ fZ_ ]zi bm`eefieX Xkk Y`c[X ]`eeX \e gXike\i) :kk ]z[Xj `jkX[\e _X[\ dxe^X ]zi[\cXi ]zi fZ_ gxm\ibX[\ [z[ji`jb\ieX ` gfj`k`m i`bk(e`e^ gx \kk dwibYXik jwkk) =\k ^wcc[\ jxmwc [\ wbkX jfd [\ fwbkX YXie\e)

11

>e df[`]`\iX[ Y`c[ Xm G\[\ikfie\x

OXkk\e[\cXi\e ` [\ jgw[X YXie\ej ` G\[\ikfie\x dzac`^_\k\i Xkk zm\ic\mXj`kk ]zijkX xi \]k\i ]z[\cj\e jkf[ d\ccXe jkX[\e fZ_ cXe[jYp^[\e) >e epZb\c(]Xbkfi ` [\eeX kl[\ce`e^ mXi jwkk\k gx m`cb\k jgw[YXie\e lgg]z[[\j) EXe[j(Yp^[\ej Yfe[\Y\]fcbe`e^ mXi [\k jfZ`XcX jb`bk [wi Xde`e^\e mXi d`ejklkYi\[[ m`[ ,3++(kXc\kj YziaXe) :eXcpj\ieX m`jXi [fZb Xkk [\e e\^Xk`mX Y`c[m` ]xkk Xm [\d ` [\kkX _wej\\e[\ dxjk\ kfeXj e\i) B G\[\ikfie\x mXi [\k'fd m` jbX ]zi\ebcX i\jfe\dXe^\k k`cc [\ ]Xbkfi\i jfd mXi jkXk`jk`jbk j`^e`(]`bXekX ]zi jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k\e' ]piX ]Xbkfi\i jfd _X[\ Y\kp[\cj\ ]zijgw[YXie\ej zm\ic\meX[) =\k mXi ewi fZ_ mXi dXe ]z[[\j) =\k mXi fddXe ]z[[\j `efd \cc\i lkfd wbk\ejbXg\k fZ_ m`cb\k fi[e`e^jeldd\i dXe_X[\ ` YXieXjbXiXe) M`[glebk\e jg\cX[\ jawcmbcXik \e Z\ekiXc ifcc) =z[j(i`jb\ieX mXi [lYY\ck jx _z^X le[\i g\i`f[\e ,3,3Ü.- ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[g\i`f[\e \]k\i ,32+) OXi dXe \kk fwbkX YXie zbX[\ i`jb\ieX d\[ ,1!)?z[[\j dXe jfd [\k ]zijkX YXie\k ` jpjbfejbXiXe' \cc\i j`jk jclk\k Xm iX[\e` \e dpZb\k YXiei`b ]Xd`ca #zm\i xkkX YXie$ zbX[\ fZbjx [z[ji`jb\ieX j`^e`(]`bXek ÜZ`ibX ,, !):kk ]z[Xj gx cXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x `ee\YXi Xkk dXe bfd k`cc mwic(

[\e ` \e i\cXk`mk d`jj^peeX[ d`caz) ?zi [\ ep]z[[X YXie\e `ee\YXi [\kkXzbX[\ [z[ji`jb\i d\[ /- ! fd Xcck XeeXk _zccj bfejkXek) =\k jbX gxg\bXjXkk d`caze `ek\ giw^cX[\j Xm bwic\bjczj_\k' ]zi Xkk bepkX Xe k`cc Xm_Xe[c`e^\ek`k\c ]ixe ,43/) EXe[jYp^[\e ` G\[\ikfie\x giw^cX[\j [fZb Xm ]Xkk`^[fdfZ_ \ebcX ]zi_xccXe[\e) ?zilkfd Xkk bm`eefieX ]zca[\ ^XdcX blckli\cck Y\(k`e^X[\ lgg]z[e`e^jkiX[`k`fe\i d\[ bfdazcb mXi [\k fZbjx \kk jXd_wcc\[wi Y\]fcbe`e^\e jczk j`^ jXddXe) F\e' ` [\e ^\d\ejbXg jfd jbXgX[\j]Xeej jXdk`[`^k c`k\ lkipdd\ ]zi [\k Xmm`bXe[\ ` ]fid Xm \kk lkfd(wbk\ejbXgc`^k YXie)Fzejki\e ^`Zb [fZb Xkk YipkX fZ_ \e ]ziwe[i`e^jgifZ\jj ble[\ bfddX

k`cc jkxe[) O`[ ,3++(kXc\kj jclk mXi ]fik]XiXe[\ G\[\ikfie\x \e ]zijXdc`e^d\[ dpZb\k _z^ jgw[YXiej[z[c`^_\k ` awd]zi\cj\ d\[ Lm\i`^\ jfd _\c(_\k) Lb`cceX[\ieX d\ccXe cXe[jYp^[\e fZ_ AXgXiXe[X jkX[ ]zi jgw[YXie(\ej zm\ic\meX[jZ_Xej\i _X[\ [fZb ` gi`eZ`g lkgcxeXkj) :de`e^\e Xm YXi(e\e _X[\ fZbjx \ijXkk [`_fie\e d\[ bfdazcb)?zilkfd Xkk epXej\iX Yze[\ieXj Z\ekiXcX ifcc ` G\[\ikfie\xj dfikXc`k\kj(

_`jkfi`X dxjk\ m` fZbjx epXej\iX YXiedfijbfieXj) Lfd lggcpjXi\ fdXde`e^\ej ]zi[\cXi ]zi jgw[YXie\ej zm\ic\meX[ mXi [\ m`bk`^X fZ_ ]iXd(^xe^ji`bX) Fz[iXieX ` G\[\ikfie\x cpjjeX[\ gx mX[ [\ _X[\ Xkk jw^X fZ_cwk j`^ zm\ikp^Xj) Lfd ]ziczjXi\ Xm bm`eefieX ` G\[\ikfie\x kpZbj [\ _X

12

9dZ[hi :htdZijhwc

jg\cXk \e d`e[i\ ]iXdkiw[Xe[\ ifcc) tm\e fd bpibfYzZb\ieX _wi cwdeXibeXgg_we[`^X fZ_ dpZb\k fjwbiX lggcpje`e^Xi' kpZbj YXiedfijbfieX `i\cXk`mk c`k\e lkjkiwZbe`e^ _X k`ccbXccXkj gx cXe[jYp^[\e) Gwi [\ mwc k`ccbXccX([\j m\ibXk [\k _X mXi`k ` jXdYXe[ d\[ [\ d\i bfdgc`Z\iX[\ ]zicfjje`e^(XieX) F\e [\kkX wi dx_we[X fZbjx ex^fk jfd m`jXi gx Xkk [\ _X[\ Yp^^klgg \kk m`bk`^k ]zikif\e[\)

Gfk\i

- ?*M* >ir( âM_al_mmcih gi^_fm [h^ fc`_ n[\f_m $qcnb ^cm]ommcih%ä( BekhdWb e\ j [ JeoWbKjWj_ij_YWb KeY_[jo' -53. N_l =( /0*

. M J^_h]l[hnt( @WfWhWdZW ijWZ ,++ uh' Pjjm[f[ -501( m -14`*

/ Klipchmc[ffye[l_m zlm\_lynn_fm_l* C[j[l[h^[ -421* H_^c]ch[fmnsl_fm_hm [lecp* Mcem[lec)p_n*

0 Jfi` B[l^[lm^inncl( KWl_d] j [ ;^_bZ5 h[]_edWb' YkbjkhWb WdZ ieY_Wb Wif[Yji e\ j [ _d\WdjcehjWb_jo Z[Yb_d[ _d AY[bWdZ' ,22+},4-+( Pg_z .,,.*

1 N|l_h @^pchmmih( Eibh Mia_lm " <h^_lm =lyh^mnl|g( â?c^ Hc^qcp_m H[e_ [?c``_l_h]_; < Nno^s i` ch`[hn giln[fcns ch hch_n__hnb ]_hnols Nq_^_hä( K[j_l jl_m_hn_^ni âC_[fnb \_nq__h nb_ Klcp[n_ [h^ nb_ Ko\fc] àNbc`ncha <jjli[]b_mä( Jmfi( Iilq[s(N_jn_g\_l /à3 .,,/*

2 Pf` C|a\_la( NncaR[ff"B|l[h=limnl|g( âOb_ Kin_hnc[f Dgj[]n i`H_^c][f O_]bhifiasih H[n_lh[f Hiln[fcns ch nb_ G[n_ -5nb >_hnolsä( c Pf` C|a\_la( EWj[hdWbEehjWb_jo _dKm[Z[d' Pg_z -541( m ---63*

3 Oi\c[m <h^_lmmih( Pf` C|a\_la " Nnca =_lamnl|g( â>iggohcns)\[m_^ jl_p_hncih i`j_lch[n[f ^_[nbm6 f_mmihm `lig hch_n__hnb)]_hnols Nq_^_hä( Dhn_lh[ncih[f Eiolh[f i`@jc^_gcifias(.5( .,,,( m 10.)1047 m_ i]emz @^pchmmih( Mia_lm " =lyh^mnl|g .,,/*K_lch[n[f ^|^fcab_n9 ^|^`|^^[ ' ^|^[ ,)3 ^[a[l( h_ih[n[f ^|^fcab_n9^|^[ ,).4^[a[l _`n_l `|^_fm_h*

4 =_ns^_fm_h [p \[lhgilme_`|lfimmhcha `|l ^_h h_ih[n[f[ ^|^fcab_n_h b[l [h[fsm_l[nmg_^ >ir l_al_mmcih* D gi^_ff_h b[l eihnliff_l[nm `|l j[lcn_n i]b mi]c[f ncffb|lcab_n*

5 N_ _r_gj_fpcm >[lfi >ilmchc " Kc_l K[ifi Qc[tti( âOb_ bcmnilc][f ^_]fch_ i` ch`[hngiln[fcns ch @olij_* <h ip_lpc_qâ c >[lfi >ilmchc " Kc_l K[ifi Qc[tti $_^m% L^[ Z[Yb_d[e\ _d\Wdj cehjWb_jo _d =khef[ ,3++(,40+) >ekh dWj_edWb YWi[ ijkZ_[i' Afil_h]_ -55/( _ff_lHc]b[_f Hcnn_l[o_l( D[Z_][Exjj[h) Rkh ?[iY _Y j[ kd[ [b_Y [h ?[ khj[d _d =khefW' H}h]b_h-54/*

13

-, Iil^cme[ gom__n @P 1-055* >cn[n c Eih[m Alseg[h( @ehWd _ XedZ[iWc tbb[j( Nni]ebifg-533( m -23*

-- Alseg[h $-533% i]b Eih[m Alseg[h âN_ro[f chn_l]iolm_ [h^ mi]c[f hilgmâ( =j debe]_WKYWdZ_dWl_YW -531*

-. Jlp[l G|`al_h( âAlzh h[nn`lc_lc ncff nihzlmeofnolâ( >WjWXkh[d -525* N_ yp_h Hcnn_l[o_l-54/ mig ^cmeon_l[l h[nn`lc_lc_n mig _h ^_f [p _h mn|ll_ hil^_olij_cme eofnolnl[^cncih*

-/ <h^_lm =lyh^mnl|g( âDff_acncg[]s [h^ Gih_ K[l_hnbii^ ch SDSnb ]_hnols Nq_^_hä(9)ddWb[i Z[ <[ce]hWf _[ @_ijeh_gk[ -554( m 5/à--/*

-0 Ginn[ Qcemnl|g( ?[dZ[h[Z "Jekj[i WdZ ;ekhi[i5 L^[ KeY_e(KfWj_Wb EeX_b_jo e\E_]hWdji _dF_d[j[[dj (;[djkho KkdZilWbb' Km[Z[d( Pg_z .,,/*

-1 =lyh^mnl|g -554*

-2 ?_nn[ p[l _h g|dfcab_n `|l oha[ epchhil [nn ef[l[ mca c mn[^_h Noh^mp[ff* <l\_nmncff`yff_h[p[l gzha[ `|l ^_g i]b ^ylca_hig eoh^_ ^_ ^l|d[ g_^ _nn ac`n_lgzf ig ^_ mz |hme[^_*Qcemnl|g .,,/*

-3 ?|^mlcme_lh[ b[l \_lyeh[nm g_^ >ir)l_al_mmcih( ^yl p[lc[\f_lh[ c gi^_ff_h p[lcn ye)n_hme[jfca \|l^( nc^mj_lci^( j[lcn_n $\[lh_nm `|^_fm_il^hcha% i]b gilm sle_* N_j[l[n[[h[fsm_l b[l on`|lnm `|l C[j[l[h^[ i]b f[h^m\sa^_h* Dhefo^_l[m \imn[^miln c [h[fsm_h\fcl ^_h a_higmhcnnfca[ |ehcha_h [p ^|^mlcme_h `|l onigyen_hme[jfca[ \[lh cI_^_lnilh_z-2 !*

-4 xhmepyln b[^_ p[lcn [nn eohh[ oh^_lm|e[ ^_nn[ mi]c[fn i]b |p_l nc^* <p eolpilh[mäb[]ecab_nä m_l pc ^i]e [nn g[n_lc[f_n \|ld[l \fc c nohh[mn_ f[a_n i]b [nn oh^_lm|ehcham)alojj_h l_^[h yl fcn_h*

-5 Alseg[h -533( m ..-*

., <h^_lm =lyh^mnl|g( ãDff_acncg[]s( ch`[hn giln[fcns [h^ `[gcfs h_nqilem* Noh^mp[ff [h^Ne_ff_`n_z ^olcha nb_ -5nb ]_hnolså( K[j_l jl_m_hn_^ [n nb_ m_mmcih âDh`[hn [h^ >bcf^bii^Hiln[fcns [h^ A[gcfs >cl]ogmn[h]_m ch Dh^omnlc[f Nq_^_h(ä Aiolnb @olij_[h Ni]c[fN]c_h]_ Ccmnils >ih`_l_h]_( .3 A_\lo[ls ) . H[l]b .,,. Ob_ C[ao_*

.- Mi^if`i K_h[( Ad\Wdj cehjWb_jo _d jhWdi_j_edWb F_YWhW]kW( Pg_z -555*

14