SIGNCFF'

& Jb y/[[h --h - CMB Acc4al No. 29-R0218

3- St J t 3- N " "' b * '2. a . N u rn t'"'

" C[h*2 appp;on n 7 ()- 8 0 - 0 03 5FEDERAL ASSISTANCE Apohcant s Nos STgEh* I C' "2''' "1. Type of G Preapphcation I j - ^ * '

Acuon O Apphcation i i Mr lf ata h_., , Astgred 1379 05 04

h 4'% 4ru7e E Notification Of Intent (Opt.) tme f/M_,

bm> CReport Of Federal Action !L" A June 26.1970 / :oAnn Aun n iotm4. Legal Apphcant/ Recipent i 5. Federal Employer identific'ation No.

4 clear Rec Commissi onDivision o.Julater"$atety an33. Arpnca.u Name alteb. 0 ganaation Un. Environmental Analysis 6. Program

c. street <P o. ao, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation .r om a. Ember ! 7|7!e|3 g|9;

J. C.tv Washington e. Oc o n t y b. T. tie Unknownf. State D.C. g. Z p code 20555

'

h. Contact Person Dr. R. A. Gilbert, Environmental U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commis-3 /Seme a tc9rnone no ; Project Manager slon:

- rm) 492-8439y 7. Title and de scription of appucant's proiect

~~''

! 8. Type of apphcant/recioientPALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENEPATING STAT 7 a-sw. a -w.+ w o .a

"

DRAFT EN'v'IRONMENTAL STATEMENT - NU$.0N UUIPS 4 AND 5 M,%*0 m WZL'"7"$ EG-Ga2$5 Issuance of construction permits to Ac. Public Serv- E~57 ZZ,.

ice Co. for construction of Palo Verde Nuclear Staticn' w a'D** ' - * *j (PVNGS) Units 4 a 5, to be constructed on same PVNGS. Federal Agency

g site where Units 1, 2 & 3 are under construction; s IST""Mf y,y, ,, . o , ,.,,,, fg 7,, gg to ~e replicates of Units 1, 2& 3 which are pressur7

,

t;:ed wf ter reactors producing up to 3817 megawattsi 9. Type of assistance<

aerma each. St%m turbine cenerator will use *ilsbis ; B-seupier-enrat crant E-otner^-Basic Grant 0-insurance_

heat to orovide 12<d negawatta electric each. Tf *cj will be 'a jointly owned facilitv__by 11 entities. ; C- Loan Enter arprorrbte letterm W.L.1j 10. Area of proget impact /xames of ories. counties. states.acq 11. Estimated number | 12. Type of apphcation

15 Miles West of Buckeye, Maricopa Nn"e*f2n"g' | g_ Tee I-Cont 5u"ation E- Augmentatico' **'

County, Aricana| Enter :rprovera:e letter

13. Proposed Funding 14. Congressional Districts Of: ; 15. Type of change For 12c or /Jea F eaer al !$ 00( a. Appocant b. Protect A-Increase Dol!ars F-Otre Sgcify-

|' C ircrease Duration9 - C'c"85' 00 "'''b. Mont } 0 01 01 02 03 04 03

c State 1 00116. Protect Start i 17. Proget j 0-Cecrease Durat:on ,

, E-Cancenation nter:prvoDate > car montn Jav \ Durationi Locan 1 0 06 33 | g70n7w { pmte ldter|s/ | | | t

e Other | 1 00118. Estimated date year man't/r JJte 19. Existing federal identification numberto be submitted

t Tctai | $ 1 00 to federal agency 1920. Federal agency to receive request Ni ame, city, stete. rp crorm 21. Remarks added

[Yes 2 Noc 22. i a. To tr,e test or mv kncuecae and b. if recuired by OMB C.rcuar A-95 in,s appocation was sabrmtted. Xo Resnon se3 I uehef. data +n th>s preconcatron/ cursvart to instructons therein, to appropriate clear.ngcc+ses and- The j appocation are true and correct. the al remonses are attacr+d.

response attacned

.! ^"P"cd "' l. " c '"* " t h ' 5 b ** ' "'V'"'" '"'d ICartifies ;by the aowe ning body ot the acph- iliAricona State Clearinghouse C O,-

;; That ! cant w t e aponcant u como'v . i2) Regicn I Clearinghouse (MAG) O-

LJs mth the acnec assura"ces .f trem evea < n nw d_ t- U"p

ua- 23. a Tv ped name anc 't'e b. S gnatore c. Date signed| Cartif y mg Year month Ja vs represen-i tative 19

24. Agency name 25. } car monter aarApr'ication

! r eceived 79< 26. Organizational Unit I 27. Administrative office | 23. Federal apphcation

- I identificationi{ , 29. Address | 00. Seoeral grant

I identification,,

:

1, 31. Action taken 32. Funding War *to n tir dat '34. l ear " o n t er ;;vStartingI [ a. Awaraea IL Caca ai 5 00 33. Action date 19 date 19

$ ' T 9a:ected ;_o A a n ca n t j 00 35. Contact for additionas inforrnatior, ; 36. ! car *no nt 9 ;at

c % turn m 'crf c. State 00 i * #" "F"""""date 19

me n crre n t

- r -,d ,a. Local 00 < 37. Remarks added.

.e'er rac eZ | d, Ctner 30--2 , _e A thcra e

,

00 1 nyg No-,

' , tai is,c - L

i28. . a in taug iocve act:an, m orwerts acet.ea ' rom crev.n i c. cecerai Neocv A-35 crc.ai 7 [rFedera6 agency ye e esea Igm msu me s M ene &cos. orsi 'Ume araTc!cr m ne 4"ecr,ot Part 1. CMB C.rcwar A-95, t nas ceen er s ceing maae.

424a 01 ostarcard For m 424 Page 1 M 0-75) j!wsc+J n i;sa. resce:t nanacement c.,cutar x

790709 0 o' n~- e-a >

\'C: 1. 7Michael A. Ramnes, Director / star e sm. as:ms,c tsAn

Arizona State Parks Board f'

1688 West Adams , Rm. 109 i no.79-80-0035ggy 4, 1979 , , , , 3.::Phoenix, AZ 85007 .' Game & Fish Health

Ag. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

Fmm: Ari ena State Clea.ringhou.se Civil Rights Parks17CO West Wasi.ingten Street, Ecca 505 Archeological Res. Land

ASU Political SciencePhceni.::, Ari cca 85007Center for Public Affairs,

Energy Programs - S. DolinsOEPAD: D.PNs-

.,

'O'

% )'-

--Region I. .1-

s wa .

- s, . - ,5 ,

, . c-

'

. ..-

~, , - - a- , . 4. . ,v.- _ m , , - ,- ,, < - y-'

f:e; ja,w: -n_ ,

,

s ; ,, ...

<4 - -

. , . . , e -s' {, 4 =v *

hf; ' ' 8a~

;,. : , $ _' .~f4^

'+

3,, % ~; . r ;, ; >

. . : - ,,-

, a

* , , , . ,1s- y, y. -

4 , .9., e ,i,

"|Ms ;roject is refstred to you for :rriew ==d com=:est. P!r:rse crab.ata as to:'

'

4 4 ,', . - s

.. <- , .e(1) the pregnm's effect upon the phas and pos:aca of your ass::=y

. _ V sA'

G) 2,e imperance of!ts cons:2ndan to Stats and/cr areawtie scalsand obisceres - - '' ~,gp p.7

Q) Its accord =ith any appticable 1sw, ordererregnfa:ms witja whicit you are famEIar ~,

' 6.,

(4) additional anc.sudantf.0cs . *"' *

; ,- .

3{-:s q - , ,;

,

'r ,1 . >

, = ',(., ,, , ,._

. > .x3 . .;, .n,. , , ,

' '.,

c . y < . + ,- L, g- ,

.

s

.mu.remm THIS FOR 4 AND ONE XEROX COPY eg e,,li' (s.14::: hier h II worMnc days eee b. eat.noted.ab?! esse osonce :.be M euse if you nesci h:tter M-Ma or add,itmaaltims for rmswj s,m , - - - - J.'

.

i * h 4;. J:. r, .m .: ,

4 ,4- , g. s ' ' h 3 ~.L': " / ~> c 9 Y;" ' 2. Lf,p h -- ; . ,"

,

' . . . S**--(.~~*

c .,; sm . . . - J .'t , . : 1,, . . t . f,t'

.

- ; g'.<W; .'c

' ;fyq 'r & .. ; . ;,,,'j' .V-

eqi.p{.n.w,ay.7;.s - ;.-

.c .3-.

*:f,$ @ q p;.t], > g y. .

so.,R'f|,m. * '(>

..

a No comme:tt on thtc exoires - } j.. q : ^ *

. a~

,,

O Pmposails supponad 2s ette:r ;-M S ZT( 1.4.y$. - . . . ' .

. , ,

~

WeA ' ' ''. x, . ,/ . , J,O

,, _

,

N / 37p sC C.smments :s ir:dicztad b.fow ' . ' ' ' N ^f,~ i2

>

y,; -

i,..s --

.

L*,

m; ', L.

: *,.

's,- .

. c; = ,, .'j .. h+- '#'< - -m. .,

*.d

. (, 2,

- . . ; e.

. .. i

C,2mments- (Use additicnal sheets if =. ccc:sary)s ,y '4 k, . .y +. P j_ . . , . m $. , . -* '

,,

-i>,

. - ., , .,

.G.

,.

, '; < ,. .

y, . .. p, . 3, ^. . s, ,- - !'.,

_s -, 3

,

4.. el * f *%.M 1- . .. ux. '+ . ' , . ,2 - g g }g 3

, ,. +. ,. . , ,

-'j g. . i +. . --

y- ;,. . . , ...,,, ,

-

* ,

"n v- a - 'e

,,

v,

< .

<, ,r :c g ; , ,

i .

s .f - ,', *, - - * ,-.q. - . , - - w. . 4

,

s ,

+J - p ' ., 4th y ' ,' .'., , . 7.,

s'

. ,.

_ s.b || w. * .':q - < o ' ^ * ' . %',y ' > :|..[ 'l

< ., o *

v. . ~ + 7 m -- -,,

t',;, -

. , e. .

,. . ~y.r 4;:p- ,7 ,., e--s c;w . ' ; r,. . . , c

p. , ,><

.- c-q- ,

.,v*

, m .', , ,. . - > ' cs p fl .,

4t * , .. /,

, a

s J - ,

- f, , ..c y, ,f1 s^ . .

g.- - -

,

' ;, . . t . , rf y ' , . . ~ - , . e ,-

C .ms,y'h t;Sq ; 4 ' '. .

. n m - .o.3

' , , y ."

A. t x j.

-

-7, .,j,..: 1: .ch

s - * - -

%}.

,, , .r,s .

.- ,. c-3 ,", . - - ,' N- . .- >

9; ; ), Q-y 0 p\ s ',, ,

..gi g g. ,,

-< L 9 i ' x, ,

,

. , e. - n s ._ . , c . . , . g e.- . 4. m. g,

:V , .. , . e: , y , ", . - - , v t.y V,e. y - '

_ , t ,sst4 _-.

y v . N, , . . , ;. . ~a.. o, : .

g -

>a , .y (~ s.

.k.hh.y? N h,' '' '..

A Y.. ..}e > . . -,, ,

. - w, , ,-

- , - e-4-3 .

.

, ,

,

, . . ,.- , ,, ,

. , ,to a * < s

'. . , ,e,g,, #

*.

c' si,- - ~

4 %

4, 9(>

.,

.\LJ, , y ;,~., . .

...,

s -

.

.-,

R:vteweri S'ga:mt - /'. -

.* b bDva

4

_

, - a* t s. -- - '

t ^ b'

== iec..c s'. ,'. .

se*e

. . . ,*

- . .n.n . --

_ 4.<

+

2: - .< >

-1 ,

JcSn M. Li ttle, Acting Comm. j sme %cz,a us.re.n tsa.n.

state Land Department

No. 7 9- 8 0 - 0 0351(24 W. < Adams, 4th fI. - '

gay 4, 1979 sem Annoenix, AZ 85007r

i

A T''N : Jef f Yaeger ! N-[r&gg

'

Indian Affairs water7:om- A:irena St?.te Clea.ringhetse civil Rights Parks

1700- West Washingten street, Pcc::1505 Archaeological Res. LandPhcenix, Ari ena 85C07 '

ASU Political Sciencecenter for Public AffairsEnergy Programs - S. DolinsOEPAD: D. Moss

.,

.-

,,

' . ,f d,}, '% '

'' n .

_ r .

#' , ' ' ' . ',- -

2, n . ,: y-s' ' ,. , ; ,;; 1- ', "h g . RegiOG; I.':e,g> - 4. ..3 y , 1

,. y y.a . . , m, j . ; c..c hg a ,g- s < 4 e 's r 4m s

y, a_3x>. , . m c %,

Rc,gg,g, y . , ':g.n g fs. f y.. .. ,Q}y ; q,3, . c ; y,7 lufAY 7 ggy G

" .

y ., .

.f w!fy;Q. z.q;:+ . ,5 g M' y;.

,

w' & y ,.g y E UliD D y " " ,

~ ~^Nr :,

,,

3s , toiect is reie: red to you for revisw a::d on:::::cz::. ?ta:ss evaluata as toc_1 '. .

i*. . . ,u

.wq,,. ::q v.- s. - ,

m the nos=ms etres: =;oo es. Phns a:d nes:: m of your n==:crj..w..k 'O,',

~ Q' ga,

0 " ' ..,

g sb 1, '

, ' ' <'J, g / *g.9,CD the importzncs of its contz:budsn to State and/crarsawide goals and objec:!ves .' 1k,

,

Q its sc::=rd wid 2ny appfh:sble hw, order or:rguhdom wid which you ter fedy j"'.,

mw T,.,, ,, ,.

(4) additionalce=siders:i:ns ' #,/j. / . a . , .Oj 4. u g / '. , u ., ,

'' '

:#' ' '"- . ,

*

,/, ,-

.f e i

r -- * [ k ' .%* g * | ''.,] %. '' ' ': ; . f. R :~

*

r.m. .,t:mTHIS F0m AND ONE XEROX C0Fr f.,@,' ~ i,!.,Z, _s

~ {e, _.-v o - <

:, ; .,. , ./* q*^ ''$,,,.,r . % / i '- #

. , , , _ 3. . ; y

,

4

h* TI sarMna days esca tSS.bd'{e,

.=.en. crat:c: e. ~--e.ecs, tr you seed c:rcer **ar mulsionsa :fme for rmsw. w a. - o .. a.;.. w j.t.'

a' 1 m$Hf6AM.@p.4M. , / w . S.. ..Em : , y g. ,. M.. '@S~i%w.xv,

t" sps .

4n. .y..;n.ca y y.y {c*'%[%,s, ,.u, a>%, . ,g .@,77,7.fgM;.7 j t. ' ',,M. , n;. , _ ;',

ym.. . .

.f,.

_.m -,v :: . a., . , -

C .No otC2fCent QS this yrcicCT v ,, f '*f g,.f [.ma .I 8

V - l', -}, [h.qx .,','Q.Q "Yp'' A,

''

C P:oposalis supported as writtets %%Q :'[;, .

/ n'dEE' 5,g comu e:tts u indicued beio. ' ? M y 3 $p$ m|9 W 7 O W '.

3* ' Jnc ;'

.a - f. . y ~;. ; ,

a : .., ., s. w.,,

. - ,. 4 - - - ,

comments: 0;3. addadensisheetiif -y. s .q ,r.,ggy , , , , ,' y .p .L - v ' .v sy.' - g ._ .;4 gcc ., s-

,-, , , .

c c w. .- . -

.' ,nggg o . :.. ,. , - .,

The State Land Department'hast revieked the- Diaft EIS regarding the ccnstruction of Units A andi- ;.5 at the Palo Verde Nuclear' Generating Sta' tion.dIt-is the.cor ern of the Department that C7adequate safeguards are maintained' to insure: that.our adjacent. trust lands wil1 be safe from '

contauination and free for future'developmentO,, %.. ..g,

,"a1 - - ./>;- -(|J eNM 1 f. %'fiL;&,'< - ''., J . .' '?':' 2 '

,.

.C'. ..''c' y. -;g-- -'u -

f' ' . i r ,' ''A d : f h h 2:f : *d A '^' % ,'

'

| .., - s';L'?

' . c, $, V =, , . , ;. % ,.~r(%. @~ ,,..w ?Wf-)< - t'.> ,- - -

..a.

'

,. 'a* . t .?.

,,.

*'] '} $# * | '' . ,,, } [* ' #. ' 't '' ' #

o ,u, . e c,s1 a , n+ >. a p'.c.,.s u s } ,. a . 3,t h '/

3 3, m ., - o: 1 _ s, , .x..~

' *-.. /.6. ra s, .s1 - n ', +,'

wa

.<

. - ;< <.

t y m? <t,, .] -; q'-', _a

.._f|*. ,. *'z' ,

yLs , . g _

-

., , y, g* , . . , ,

- ,

*

m u.p , [g' N %e,y 4 g. ,

'; x5J.9 F K. . . .. T / \. 2 a.a.. .

1'

,

,-s m, . , f. y;.4. n.

,- : . u ,g . --

. .,. .

A,&p. ,, % .F F-

a 'y ., e, p ; x a * f. , s , ' h . . , , , va. . - (g .Q .m54 s - ,

p59- , . . s .; . r,

.m,y ., . g -

-

v.w. s,

.,.:n p sf s.

4 win , ,,

4 N' y. .q. .. 1 .i :s

>

-, ,

. .h

_a .s:3 4y:3; j, jg'a g+ . %... f, ..

p - ' . , , *

. . ;.

-w. .. ' . i , . ;4 ' y(,,,

_ .c w ., . ..

1, ,, ,s. o * ,- ,.

*-

,.

,

, E3 ,.'' ' .I*' % '

. .e *'

, '__

.i,;. a : - ~r . <~ ^_

r . . '', ,-' ? , _ 4.( '* ,t** e,

4s , . -

3 - *. , .

.r==*''

. 7.rr e-veri Signa:ut- - 8 ~~'~/ /M - 'A J Dwp v ''',, r.i. . . , ,

*

*

e ' e-. . .,,

,. . .Y g[.4

.'.,,,y*p ', ' F. aam.M e

\y , S * #1

,k*g ' '

6 * < *.%, ., }*g. g gi _

.

,c.i,.. . % ,. 4/w % wa~ ,s ( n ., ..; ..%.,<.u .s.- ~ - - - -& f 4.*" '' -- ,$ h ,S e 6. J''&ahe M WSem .sen6ee w f,bh k . m a i ah s.u, '#

'

# 1 I'

o:.Mr. James R. Carter, Director .

Agriculture & Horticulture Dept su ^"" #"421 Capitol Annex West g -.

Phoenix, Arizcna go,7bb0-003585007 p3y 4, 1979 S** '"', , ,

Came & Fish HealthAg. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

F:om: Arirena State Clea.ringhouse civil Rights Parks1.7CO West Washingter. Street, Rec::1505 Archaeological Res. LandPhcenix, Aracna 85007 ASU Political Sc.ience. 4

Center for Public Affa rs.

Energy Programs - S. DolinsOF. PAD: D. Moss

- .

.'- .

. . ~' ,, - <

*a ,. 2 Region I.'. - ,

. . .. , < ' .- : ,.' ,. -' . , ..; . ,.. -

, , - .. _ ., ,

, , f. 2;i. ; _..

s - s,

- , s._- t -

.

"

* ' '

(,7 v . ; y . -

This ;rciect is rat' erred to you for review 2::d comment. P!s:se evah: ate as to: '

' F,.', ; _. __ y -

, \ ' :<. .;;' *(D the prog:sm's effect :pon ths ; tans ami pros:ses of your ass::cy '

, , , . i ., . . if -(2) :ha importz:2csofRscom.'-w to Shte sed /or areawidescals arniobjec ves

- *

,. _..<r a

:1 s' ' - 'Y " - |'Q(3) i:s accord with any applicabis law, otdar errrgulation with whicit you 2rs 6- 4**

. s ,

', .-

''. ,.. ~ fyN*

(4) additionald-secs <7.

' ' *< .." y,' ~ (;;.s <,

g.- S, .

1 ,,',9- * *

> , ,' .c,

.'s

, ,t

r.ms. :,mm EIS FOR 4 MD GiiE XEROX COPY |ca -s[ es. ::o taar thm TT workinc days t::= t:=date above.P esse coarzer the s,.ycse if yois coed f::rther 1::for:nztion af additional time for ressew

'," [ - I , q , " yg'g[,.'.,, ,, ,

;- , - -. . . d'. )E., .

M;P if.( d C y ' .3,,

,'

'>a ~ " Y [,; j . ,*

s., y, 13 ,. p 9.nNo ccament oa 'this pr. oiect . 3:s ' ^ D;: M ': * Q ~ t .

...', < |;,- '

,,. ',;y

.t- , ;, . .;. , ;;;-+< -

' - ' .&. .' x,' . &n... F..'x - w. w , ,

7,i/; cly N .(3 '!.S M L 4C P:eposalis suppor.;aiaswritte: -, , . . , -7c ', . ,j , ,

? N ", ".' * .' " ;; i ? ' \ " ^< ' N ''P,. .,

., - a-, g.C Csmraants as tr:dicatai below ~ ,s,

7~.v.,. .a < a , ,- ^_

C.3mments: (Use additional sheets if :2cc : sary) .N ~. J'Q ['' , 2-(,, ., f ', r. jt*.

,,

- - ; * . f. . x - . .-*

'

'.

, ' , '..

' .? ,, 7

,i ,- (., .

.,- .

'

*% ~ '1 ' ~.. s: a

-

,''

-

r. , , r i

- '- *, q._,, p .

.c. -

, ,,

. -.. ,.

.

,., , ,., ..s '* '

,,, .r

'

, , , c._.t3.i ^ ' , . ,, . - n : e;y . , .c. , , . ",'r. _+ A.

. ,_9 j"

,

, - r w a, . , . .. . , y. - ; ,- ...,

, . . , ..

, . .- v --a . . . .~- a. ), ~ 4.,;; .' ;:, .

q f, _n : - p. : '. - . .,: ~ 4Q ~

.,. , ,

.. .. 9 g. &, .'

" y 7 , -:,. (,,;c

. [, f f g; a -~

.

, _ _

M _ M. ;,.., j a; % ,. $ q 'f g .: _ ,

~_J. .

,,;. .c .

.

,

s :.

y's .- : . h V - c .-,- *-

., ._ .,

. .

~ , , - '4 . . %4 .,*

'''i,. s

_, . . . -_e r '. Y 6 r

.- s %.

. Q '., y. , ,Q* , ,, .e;3 f: ' .4- r - *,

, e . ., . .. -t . 1. *, .4,; J . . . . , . _<

. s. y y.. p, ,Q . . . p

ys, <, ,s A-t. ,, v

\.3-

.. .- r,, . ,

n '. -e.. .

> .c,'' .

a\, 3... :. u, ,: -p

.

3 0 '. mi' ~. '-*se . <,

,. u ,e .- ,"-.

'

**>.a -m.p - i .;h. a,

.

e t' = * *.

--. :.'7 'o , y, a 4 -s , ,

' ',

* * '

'.; '

+ . .w.

,

-#

-4 +-'

}. \- - 'N - ' *

, ,,

--

<-. ,

'f f w g,,,.1 .: ::Q' ',

R: viewer's Sig :anzt- -5/8/79'

02.,v-

m. ' Director'#

.. ., .

4 e

)*

e =

255-k373,. s ' -

.c n ,i:: -a. _ , . .a ; 1 .. . . : _ > , w - . ~ ..w e ,-,

>'

O-_.

i -

Mr. Clinten M. Pattea . | /'= ,.

, stata A&m= Ic: ctst (3ADExecutive Secretary. ' '

Indian Affairs Com:nission 79-80-00351645 West Jefferson St. xxy 4, 1973 m u 30.

Phoenix, AZ 85007 | Game & Fish HealthAg. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

From: AriOna Stata Clea.ringhouse Civil Rights Parks1700 West Was * gten street, Recm 505 Archaeological Res. Land

ASU Poll:1 cal SciencePhcenix, n,r.,. ena 85007center for Public Affairs.

Energy Programs .S. DolinsCEPAD: D. Moss

, - .. -

,4 .j. ? .' k . , y- - r

m. , , ,. - Region I' --

,- b b _$ <_," ''- , - e, ')

"

'8 '' - 3

,

w,

'4 ,. ,*

W \

, p ''

,, b 4 e g 4

*' = . - i*y+N g . I. 'r

#-

j w74s'

' #..* .

t

{y;' g s

, ,- . ,g(.' * 's -=m'* ,,'

p, '. ' 1 *, , .,, ,

. ., ,,

4; '

7' '

.,

2h j b

M hM ,

e

_

34

I+D TC AD MCC 3703 $4 Ef223 a.*Ii; Tog 2 ||23 Of TOUT M '

-

T '< ' j'-

C) ths i=1por*.a=es ofits coscibutfon to 54ta and/ce arsawide geals azziobjec:fves ' '

9@'

Q) in accord wirfr any sgw,M.Inw onier orregulat!ca with whkh you s:a mer -',

-

s,

(4) addisonalconsdaraticas'' ' ~ '

' b. M$'r _ ,

'> '' 's _ -y- ,, -

S

- , . -*

. .m. e 4*

Y,.

Q

, ,%, - '.p'

,

'_ ,

*

reue rer=:2 THIS F0Dt AND ONE 'XERDI COPYg, 'y ' ' A ,,, wg.,, % g g y g g'. ),*

a ~* -. ^Q ', _ _ , . +

?:=u. con:2c: e. ++ pes, :: rw .mai aatter infonsaba os miditha 1 time for remw. o .,- n, . ,.a. .

-. ,. ~, a ,. -.a .-

.

< ;< . , se, %

' ,,: ;: . ;-

** a'

'

' [N '., g * I [

~ , .. -p B 3j % *.s , r' ' ( O ' ', ,. , , ..n., - . ,'

' ,' .-l+ W ,# J #4 A. ,*.*e*'t. } :,' ^ . d }, ,',*,

* '3'Corntnant on this project . r- . . '

'

;- - . + . . , ,, f. . y ' C, , - ,. I. .-

4 '-' '' t ',

-

; 6.

.

.-

m . .m - .'u'

2. g. , y I

< . ,

C Commeftts 11iftilcated below ' s.Q >.. -

..A, ,

<a ;

~ e % ** ' ' ' ' * '

\"

. p~ c. %!.. ,. c

- s ._. s ;

, ,

. . ~ , . . . , '< r v

, ,

1 , n,

n), "#

' ht 'emt3% 54 MM M d ""27),- y . 4 - " I,.-

s

,3-

,'f^ ,*

."

,=- e 1

, a, 4,r

" . $ Y4

,''y'. V ,.), ' *,,3

*a4

'. % _- 'k '

se

'*.

cg + *. ,

'% %

, .j4

, ,p , - e et 4

g g# I; - a . . * , D ,

'-

, ,

_ . s_ _ ; y, 7 ' *x.o..j-} 33 uf1 , v ; g[-. . -

., ? < -, .

$ hq py G:. c . h=.6 ,. - 4 , , , .1 p-, '

v D,Tj;'i-c v.s g .-

<- s,,

f, , , , ax . ;:.wa t b -

(- 4-. , .

r

:;,

.mp+ ,.g g , ,, - # , , s

r..., ,J , s.

, . -- '

, [ ' T - -* [ \., ,

_.

,,we ,-

' # '3 } ;f |, , , s.

.,. , % :;; g ' , . :.,; f i y . ( , .. .'f g ; :. i ~[ - ^ Q '

,

* ' " ~,* .i ,a ' -'

y, 1 ' . p,A .g., j. . ; ''

'

%.' ' '

.

,- ^ ., . J p u J 7 f *,,7,W y= ' '

s s '.. . .(sGa=

.,

# # ~ '. 1 ? g' t . j p , * ~.h,2 Yf, O.. . t |,

' | *('

"\3- ^ '

.t., 3,iw,#' ' ' ,

. , ' . ??"; h. . e, ,s

^''*

.,..e ., , c ( v., m -.M - , k, y,,,-4 .t4 ,,4D rp, ,, ~,W 3 . } f '-

. , , i, - !, j

'.

' i>4

t,: ..s1 /.. ...;'.. -

s

,

* h, ,, , = , . ' ' jk. Ng: ,- ~ , ,'

~ g. g . .-, ,

.

--. * .'

* , , ', ~, .

'

a5 a 1 <

N , e,

,-*.

,, w "

.

%

h,, ,

-g._

-

I 84 , e' I*eo__ * e - < - . ygj g.;g.C*' *._. _

% . 4. . <. . g ,. . ..m. % .. o m . a - _w ...A.---.

* [i+

Mr. Tobert Jantzen, Mrector ! s== ^me:n a use: ems ^n

Game and Fish DTt. ; '- k '

2222 W. Q:eenway MAY 4, 1979 sm, AZ No. 7 9-8 0 - 0 03 5!

R.cenix, Arizcaun 85023~ .

Game & Fis.a Healthi.. .. ,. . .v __ _ i Ag. & Hort. Power

Indian Affairs Water7:c m Ari:ena Stata Clearinghousa Civil Rights Parks

17C0 West Washingten street, Recs 505 Archaeological Res. LandASU Political Science

Phc%c' Ard ~~~a 85C0,' " '

Center for Public Affairs gEnergy Programs - S. Dolins(,

,

' OEPAD: D. Moss ,

.-

1.

' L .e . s

'- .,

,~, . ;i.

/ - m < c , .s p h., x . v - s. ..J, . a . neg' ion. I .- -- * ,

, c .. .. . . . , .,

.. , . , 2 s . ., . s.~ . .,

~

.h. - -

..-

-

.

. :y... .|.u *., 4 :.G..

* '.

' J*

.

;g }L( ,y' /.p , 's . ../..~' - ' d 'jy rt:'~ ? s "

'

,,_ . ,f, *-

e *.- ".,

. , ,- r s' * ,c- , _ G.. 2 - 'v *,

* ',a -. A. .t. ... .; , , ',,

.e > ,W',,

. ' ' * - ,L,

y, ,. 4 =y ; - f Q.- .%:.: 4 (+

.,. , . - n ,..: r .- ,

. .

& ,. > .e. . .c . >,c

..,,; . , x#.c. wh n+ u. u ; - u. a ,, . .- . ,

.;. ,..,

.e . , ,,

.

,, w , i < . ,

.a - -.~

*. ','Dma proint imfemd to ran tersee.ew m:d co' emeer.?ta nah:at. :: 6 ' -'

'

,-

u4i -1 < .. .

'

'a' j .a '*{, . L. ). . g,' '

',,(['[-8 Q g'j_ 'r .* , , t .,

W the prepm's stTsce upon the plans ani pawc:s,of focr ags=cy . ' ' *'-, ,

Q :he im;crtance ofits matdbu:fon to State sai/cr 2:sswide goalsamiebjec:hes . *; ;. , !4 - .J)- 'NNh.

m iaac=rd =itaany smicsun,creaor,futati....itew:icayud.g, m .j' n ? ,- ,' (f ' , t, . | , W

sJ 3 ? O(Q*

?c s:'

~ r

(4) additionalmrmamtfcas p .J . :b. ' ' (f A , ,

,'

.. m

2, .. 13

- W.u ,- ,'-M _ ,s *-

s e,.- #- x..., . . . a. ti

-

. . , - .

.

:. - ; %, .. . . , ;," ' y ;y. . ,

, . ,y

_.j, . . n,. ,

' ' ' '

?.ms. mem lHIS F091 AND ONE XEROX! C0FC''the ciaadnz!i==s= == hter thatIT >workine days s' om tse 4,t.not 4 wto. M

'!ase canzac: the efad:g: case it at need catt::r. t=fs=+a w **n' t etas car:cytew. *.

. ~ .a ,W. ww, -2SG &M WQhp 4,Mi; * y.N % N %:W J:mN *

3$

|s?m p;W :.?, . .

p m:m.;q.4j y;1 xy - :x., #:m m cqn y . , ,

C No ecmment on tus pai.et m. a@'t. a ..t- % <yi.,tt@%. ,.. h .G 9 a M - -- * W- ' ?! x _A' . - A- - 6n,, :-

, . . - .sO m, -.4 iverten 'M.%.x, m,. E. ,. ,?! w % G W m M N J'-a ,- w< e ,

. . < >

M;.W-

I . V" ~ M JM " ' a '. W ~ 1].P:eposal isc:mments 2:i:dicated below ' w;y+:mya Mi. g{ c S-N' t .ggq

'--

-

. A , . .

. M- h''- , . ' , t1 o.

. , - J OR. v , , . 4,- / 3 .;.

.7. ,

.: .

comm.ats: cuse addicica:I sheets it necessaryf]& '#g ;]. ,U ;^ f y g .;y: 4 ;; 73 - p <y, . . e - - %

>

Game and Fish Departnenticomments rega'rding. Pale Verde Nuclear Generating Station Units .!";4 and 5, DES-NUREG-0522, are inrthe'same vein 'as those comments and concerns provided for, .

PVNGS Units,1,'2 and;3_ (7980-0015),idated June _9,1975..

./-

.-

.

s

,,,,|"m . s ,' * '( ,,. U ' ~' : ~ '

Of particular*concerp is'theidiscussfori of water # diversion for P.VNGS'(Sectior. 5.5.1), and ..4 -r ,

, _

"

the long-tert' affect on the ripariarr habitat a.long the Gila River. - The total ' loss 'or at. e M.a

. significani:reductiary 'of'the' current: flow 'of' effluent into .the river would most certainly ,, WL''have. a negative impact on the existing habitat and its ' dependent wildlife.

,-

*, .

.c - r. . m....-- .,~

. <> ',.

#,t ' , '% _ ' , . f; ; ' _ } , % i : s'* q ry , " . p t ,, , j ^ % |*L.Y $.;< , a , f *|.b. % '1 ' ' ^

/ .? t"

,'.r- ,~'

....A...,s..s

y s n a m ; y :~ . , *'~:.x s ~s-+ ,,

r' >l N *e - ,t. >yt ;; a , . 47 '4,- * , | ', '

*, ~ . ' - ' '

r' <

?.'fh.~Q*,E-..

, , . *.g . - g g '.- {2.jV" 'g_'Q? *"

s 1

*- * / '. ', ,

' 'e ;;% r. .,jj -

y ) ' - * ? % ,. % . ,

, ,

e t! - y( i ' ,7, } ,;" w E

c._ . 3 ^*: 3 '- ~O ' L y ,n -,, , _ , .,,, ,

.

,[ q c j ' c i '1' 4 ,[ L'[ .fr - <

s c.; c t;g , ' .a t - ,, ,~F.I"! ,

'

''

. , ; 7..-. *

y,,xy 7 . A - q s .; . y sg 7 :,,-

, - O.4 .- n. 5-,. .,

~ ; e ,

w..

,- . . . _. .. .

+~, .. . .

/I pflq Al // w w.o J ' $,, &~ /;;76/79-.w mn ss. anw- ?

.

-.~ .,

- / /.-n y, ~w n. . ,

, .

U A [ nM:bl -. . _f _, f' f , 7,;,[g.,. ' kg EM..g. ...-. h ,.Jr

--. .

2:+ ohn J. . ,, o i , , # - E ec D

M aric " '

As s ' n o f G " * # '' * * " t 3 ~~

DE

1820 W n- -

79-80-00354, 1 :s 3, 22 so.Phoeni A Z 5007- Game & Fish Health-" ._ Ag. & Hon.- Power

~

Indian Affairs Water- .

Art:ena Stata Clea.ringhcusa Civil Richts Parksm m:

1700 West Was"' gten Street, F.cc= 505 Archaeological Res. LandASU P litical SciencePhce d r, Aricc a 85C07Center for Public AffairsEnergy Programs - S. DolinsCEPAD: D. Moss

Region I

h projec is refe:: d to you for review and esmment. ?! cue evalusta u to:

(1) the prog:sm's etTect . pen ths pis cs a=d programs of your age:cy

(3 2;3 importance ofits cont =huten to Stata a:d/or areawide gr.als and objec=ves(3) its ac:ctd vid a=y applicable law, order or:rgulation wid which you are (2= diar(4) additfor:21 asnzidersticcs

?. 2a et=rn DfIS FGFJ4 MD CNE XEF,0X CCFYto $s cies==ghousa co later ca:. U way b.na dayg f CC the ete uted 2%

?!*ue contact $s dar- stonsa if you coed further information or additional t:ne for revuw.

*

C No comment on this project.

C P oposalis scrarted as wntr.-n

C C.smments u indicated betow

Comments: (L'so addit:onal sheets if ae. _,.sary)..

The Arizona Public Service Company and the Salt River Project have entere into an agreementwith several municipalities using the 91st Avenue Wastewater Treatment Plant for the useof up to 140,000 acre feet of effluent per year. This effluent will be used in the operation ofthe Arizona Nuclear Power Plant (ANPP) generators. It is important to assure that sufficientwater is available for the proposed reactors. Therefore, close cooperation between localgovernments and ANPP is essential.

gg \28.

,

?..me ver s sgnatur. ,7% W; ~4. f/Cg,,

7cf e... ..

re: : :-.. ... . . . . . _ . .

@hh?hh$$$$$.W&fTa$$$$$dh .??IW$i'?!?Wy?$~Q @ D J' "' " rM%W vix:P aMc5 -y.*

w .p:. Y Y?$hY5$m w ons$EN Ny$ wNa r.

bk?$ $W/

!3"'' ^* ~"" " # " '8#Wesley E. Steine r,atr.

State Water Commis sion 79-80-00~5'

222 N. Central Ave. , Suite 800 # 4' 1 3'''' A *-

Phoenix, Arizona 85004 Game & Fish HealthAg. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

Ari ena. Stata Clearingh0csa Civil Rights Parksom:

1700 West Was'#-c::. Street, aces SC3 Archaeological Res. Land

ASU Political Science'

,hcenix, .,ci:0:2. 23CO ,' Center for Public Affairs.

r

Energy Programs - S. DolinsOEPAD: D. Moss

-

Region I

is p:ciec: S ::fe=:d to you fcr ::vi-s 2-4 : .=e::r. 7.-a w.ma 23 co-

W the ;;og==2's efi=:: pen de ;hes 1:1 ; eg::s=s of your ss:::cyQ *.hs i= porn =c:of hs cent:Qun:::s Stats ard/cr :::2#.de g .als and o' Meso

@ U3 '"'d wid 2:7 sp;1!c:h!=':w.c:d::or: gthrica wid which ycu : Tz=flhr(4) addidorniconside.: ices

2:a - - - T'" DIS CGF14 "'i10 0:10 XC00'' C''?Y to me cin:i= cot == == hte c2:t T7 werb.no days f:oc e,e2te;cted %-^ u-

us cos:2= ce a,9 css if you ::ed f:::ter infec=stio:s or tidition21:f=e for :: view. -

M No ec====t on this ; ojec: *

C ?::posalis sup;cr:=i ss writt =C Co== nts .sirdiezte de:ow

oc:n e ts: (L'se add 2ticnal sh: ts 18 ::_ .za:f)

i ~

w,%

dJ# ~ 6 #) ' k / ' / [c

- ,

:vic.ve:~t Sig.utur- - a

'

.., ,- _ --..- -- ~

-

Mr. James E. Ayres~

Asrociate Archaeologiet 3* * *"" " :' 2" '3 M

Arizona-State ttuseum 79-80-0025-The Universi ty of Arizona MAY 4* 1979 3ma x- no.Tucson' AZ 8572I Game & Fish Healtn-

Ag. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

Ari:::a Stata Clea.ringhousa civil Rights Parks=

1700 West Washingten Street, Ecc= 3C5 Archaeological Res. LandASU E01itiC"1 S#i*" *Phcenix, Arize:1 35C07 .

Center for Puclic A:: airsEnergy Programs - S. ColinsOEPAD: D. Mcss

.

Region I

2is prCject '.s referred to you ,'Or I Tiew 2::d cos::=ent. ?! casa evalt:sta as to:

(1) te prog::='s eff::ct :;on de ; tans 2 d ;;cgx::s of your agency7, ma i=;crtance of its centnbunca to Sts:: ard/cr 2reswuie scais 2nd sciec vesC) its 2M wid any sp;fic20!a !.2w, order or.egulacon wid wt:ic.4 ycu 2rs (2:::1!.2r(4) additfor:21 consMerstices

25e m=r= THIS FCFJ4 MD CNE XEROX COPY ,o de ezr=ghouse :o 12ter das 17 W0r''d Mc days from 2e date noted ab.

m23* can'.2c: ts +- shouse .f you 2eed heder infor=2 tion or additional:=.e for : view,-

.

' No comment on this project.

? cposalis :uppor*:d as wn ten -

C C.smments :s it:cicated befow

~

cmrnents: (Us.: add 2 conal sheets if sew---)

309 13D~

( '

*MAw everi Signatur- D2 - u," ' ' l ') ' '),

V_

(!e- 2MS.0Si0.EP. d.rchaeoloaist . , , , , .

. _. _ _ _ _ . _ _

Dr. James Becker -

Center for Public AffairsArizona State Universit 79-80-0005

i*

Te:npe , Arizona 85281 'W 4' 1979 3'" A UC-_

Gara & Fish HealthAg. & Hort. PowerIndian Affairs Water

Ari:ena Stata Clearingh 03e Civil Rights Parks2:

1700 West Washington Street, Ecc:2 SC3 Archaeological Res. I,and

Asu Political sciencePhcenix, Ari ena 85C07 ,

Center for Public A:,: airsEnergy Prograns - s. DolinsCEPAD: D. Mcss

.

Region I

;rojet:. S referrvd to yeta for review sad coc=*ct. T' esse evalusta as to:

;) ms prog:ss's effect span ce ; tans at:d pregues of your agency

3 de importzscs ofits cor.tnbutan to Stats arxt/sv sr=awide goals and objec=vesD i:s accord with any applic:ble 12w, order or: guf2 tics with wr.' cit you :: fam2iari9 additio::al a:cxdersdons

i ret:r= gIS .:GRM AND CME XEROX COPY .0 is dear:sshouse .o ! ster 22. 7/ WOf*dNC days 'rors :te date ea.g g: cor.'scr $s h ghcuss if yea :ced f::rther i::for= ados or additional rat.e for eme:r.

.

.

No ccm=ent on this projec*I ?:cpcsalis n:;poned ss wntter. ~

XC.:mments :s i-dicated be4ow

ir e.,a: (Use 2detional stects if ne==:sar7) The socio-economic costs of this project

are not fully expressed nor adequately appraised.

.

" A T (\ Q \/ s~ -

'j, ,,

ever%5snuur.D - h 1'' 0 $Q- 5~13~I9,

-

- ,ne

Prof. Center for Public Affairs965-3926

- - . . . . . . _ _ . _ _ _ , . . . , . .

'O:...

M r. Arthur Garcia, Exec. Dir.3 ;me,,13,u)

Assistant Attorney GeneralAZ Civil Rights DivisionM43 W. Jefferson Street MAY 4' 1979 8' ** A ,", 7o-80-0035,.

''' '

Phoenix AZ 85007 Game & Fish HealthAg. & Hort. PcWer,

Indian Affairs daterF-cm Ari:ena Stats Clearinghcuse Civil Rights Parks

1700-West Washingten Street, ?.ccm 5C5 Archaeolocical Res. LandASU Political SciencePhcenix,.tizena 85C07Center for Public Affairs

- Energy Programs - S. ColinsOEPAD: D. Moss

Region I

.

""his ;te!ect is referred to you fcr : view 2::d ecs==ent. F' esse crahmte as to:

(1) da preg 2=s's effect :pon es pl.arJ asi ;res:2m.s of your ag==cy

(D te !=;cru: ce ofits c:n:::butian to State az:d/cr arcawida goals LM objec ves(D is accord with any a;;tLs=le law, order or t gulacon wtta whica yc91:s fa:n:112 : *

(4) addi:ionalcar Mers:cas

rm. :et:r= n!IS F0FM AND CNE XEF.GX CCFY ,, e, e > o uter e2: 17 wor'd no days f:cr: ce d2t. seced ado.Phase esatsc: as Mase- gt:ouse I you ::a1 f:rther i=for=anoa or idditional =ne for v.ew.

.

.

N No comment on this ;rojectC F:oposalis supper:ad 2s wntres

C Cammants as trs1!cated below

Canme .ts: (L'se add:ccetal zuesti if ::e~W)

.

*Y\-sn9s -

NL2 ewe vers s.. gn:mi- ..a:s _ /_.nL7 acc -

Executive Director255-5263Ie e...

_ . . . . T- ::. .::- .

.

&....

Em *

MA2CO JA ASSOCTON O9GOVRhMh"e31520 TEST \TAstil5CTON PilOENIX. ARlZONA S OOT (eO2)254-e30S

DECFlVEDH ~Mr. Ron Ross, MAGTPOTO:

MAY 2 21979

FROM: Clearinghouse Staff Contact: Jack Tevlin

PROJECT NOTIFICATION AND REVIEhSUBJECT:

Applicant: Nuclear Regulatory Commission Div. of Site Safety

Project Title Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station Units 4 & 5

State Application Identifier: 79-80-0035

MAG Log Number: 0525

Date Due: (Efav 29.1973

A copy of an A-95 application form AZ-189 along with supporting project documentationis attached for your review and comment in accordance with requirements of OMB Circular

Please review the proposal as it affects the plan:: and programs of your agencyA-95.and register your reponse below. Please return ONLY THIS completed form by the date ~noted above.

O No comment on the above project2

Proposal is supported as written..

Project is unfavorable (Reason stated below)

Comments are attached

Please contact the applicant and advise the Clearinghouse should you desire a conferencewith the applicant, further information or need additional time for review.

|. b :'w -

N Authorized Representative

r$Cd/jCAgency

3h

Heiunur \wcmuen cf L cal Gevernments in Mancepa CeunLv

-

-

A-95 COMMENTSPALO VERDE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION UNITS 4 & 5

Due to time constraints, MAG staff has been able to conduct only alimited review of the Draf t Environmental Statement. 'de do offer,

however, the following comments for consideration:-

1. The radiological monitoring system to be used during plant operationshould be refined to incorporate any significant design improvementsthat may be forthcoming as a result of the Three Mile Island incident.

2. Somewhere within (Exhibit E, No. 2) there should be a discussion ofthe adequacy of future effluent flow frem the 91s+. Avenue sewagetreatment plant in meeting Unit's 4 and 5 cooling requirements. Thisissue is especially pertinent in that peak cooling water demands ofUnits 1, ?, 3 and proposal Units 4 and 5 of Palo Verde occur duringthe summer months when historically effluent flow from the 91stAvenue treatment plant are reduced.

3. It is suggested that a discussion of the communications system to be' .

used in alerting state and local officials of a plant accidentinvolving radiation releases be included within the Statement. Theaccident at the Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station pointsto the need for examination of such communication systems forNuclear power facilities.

These comments are informational and meant solely to alert governmentalagencies and the applicant of issues that should be examined.

__