- 1 -

: 2015 1 29() 14:30~17:00 : 2

- 2 -

( : )

1 ( )

2 ( / )

3 ( / )

1 , ( )

2 ( )

3 ( / )

PROGRAM

- 3 -

01. ( ) 4p

02. ( ) 18p

03. ( ) 25P

04. ( ) 42p

05. ( ) 51p

06. [] ( ) 56P

CONTENTS

- 4 -

1

1)

1.

2013. 8. 28. 33 . .

, , 3 2013. 9. 25. ( 2013620), 2013. 9. 26. ( 2013624), STI, , 2013. 10. 24. ( 2013699). 7 .

1 2), 4 50 . , , 2014. 2. 17. 12 10, , , , 7 7, 6 6, 4 4 [ 2014. 2. 17. 2013620, 624(), 699(), 851() 3)]

1) . , 322 .

2) , , 12.3) 1 . 2013851 2013. 12. 16.

. .

- 5 -

1 . . 1 . 4) 2 16 . 1 . 9 7, 5 5, 4 4, , , 3 3, 2 2 ( 2014. 8. 11. 2014762 5)).

. . . 1( ) , ( ) 2015. 1. 22. , . ( , , ) , ( , , , ) ( 2014. 1. 22. 201410978 6)).

2.

2013. 5. 10. 5. 12. , . RO . .

4) , , 9.5) .6) .

- 6 -

.

1. . . RO (1) RO (2) RO (3) () () (4) (5) (6) (7)

.

2. . . .

3. 3 RO . 3 . .

4. , . 2013. 5. 10. . 2013. 5. 12. .

- 7 -

RO . RO , .

, RO , RO 2013. , , RO 2013. 3. 3 , 2013. 3. , 2013. 5. 8. 2013. 5. 10. , , 2013. 5. 12. 22:00 .

3. RO

. 1

1 RO . , , , 2013. 5. 10. 5. 12. . . , , , . RO .

1 . 5. 10., 5. 12. . , 7), , RO . , 2013. 5. RO

7) 1 . . . 1 . .

- 8 -

.

(2013. 5.) , 130 , RO 8). RO .

1 RO , . RO .

.

1 RO .

, RO , , RO RO ., , RO ., RO .

, RO .

8) 1 , , .

- 9 -

, , 5 . (3 ) .

RO , ,RO . 1 RO 2013. 5. RO .

.

.

: RO , , , , , , , RO , 316 1 2 , , , , , , , , RO .

: , , RO .

- 10 -

: RO , RO .

.

4.

. 1

1 , RO , , , , 5. 12. , , , . , 5. 10., 5. 12. , , , , , , .

RO . , . . 2013. 5. RO , RO .

.

.

,

- 11 -

, , 9) . , . , , . .

, , , , , . , , , , , . , .

, , , , . .

9) 1999. 11. 12. 993801 .

- 12 -

, , , . . , .

5. 12. , ( ) .

.

, 2 , , , , , . ( ) , .

: 2 , . , , .

: , . ,

- 13 -

, ,

: , , , , , , ,

5.

. 1

1 , RO , 2013. 5. , 2013. 5. , , , , .

RO , , 2013. 5. 10. 12. , , , , .

.

- 14 -

. .

- : , , . .

- : , . , , , , . , .

- : , , , , , .

, , , , , .

- 15 -

10) . .

.

.

: , . , , . , , , . , , .

: , , , , , , .

10) , 3 2014. 12. 15. .

- 16 -

, , . , .

. .

: , , .

: , , , , .

: , , , , , , .

.

6. -

, . .

- 17 -

, , . . .

, . , . 9 7, 5 5 . .

* - ()

- 18 -

2

( )

I.

1. (29). (28). . ( ) . 2 . 2 (, ) . 2 , . . .

2. ( 1999. 11.12. 993801 ). . . ,

- 19 -

. , . . ( 1981.1.23. 802756 ), , . . , . . . , , , , ( 1991.5.14, 91542).

3. 2 , , 2 . . . ( ) . . . , , . ( 1981.1.23. 802756 )

- 20 -

. , , .

4. 2 . . , . . . . . . .

II.

1. 90 . , , , . , . () . . . , . ,

- 21 -

30 2 3 . . . . . . , . . . . . , . () ( , ) . .

2. . . .

- 22 -

. . . . . . . . , , . . . .

III.

1. . .

- 23 -

? ?

2. (). ? , , () . , ? 1 .

3. () () . . . .

IV.

- 24 -

. ( ) . . . . . .

- 25 -

3

11)12)

( )eclaw@daum.net

.

1 22 2015.1.22. , 201410978 13) , . . . , . , . , , , . ? , . . , ? , ? .

* 2013 () (NRF-2013S1A5A8022736).

** 2015 1 29 .

13) 2014.8.11. , 2014762 , 1 2014.2.17. , 2013620, 624(), 699(), 851() .

- 26 -

, . , ? . . . , .

.

1.

. , 1 . 1 .

1.1.

1 .

OO -828~838, 840~843 . OO , SD , . -830~836 , -837, 841, 843 OO . -828~838,840~843 ,

- 27 -

. , OO , . : (OO , OO ; ).14)

, , ,15) , , . . . . , . , . , SD () . .

, . .

2012. 8. 10. 15

14) 1 , 150.15) OO ,

SD , , 2012. 8. : 1 , 147.

- 28 -

, , , .16)

, ( ) . , . .

1.2.

1 .

OO -839 -844~874 . , , , , , , , 2013. 5. 12. OO 4 , 3~7 , , OO

16) , 2014762 (2014.4.10), 26.

- 29 -

, , , , , OO , OO OO . , , , , OO , , , OO , , OO , OO OO . , ( ).

, . , ,

- 30 -

, 4 3-7 . . , . . , ? , . , , . . . . .

2.

2.1.

.

, (Hash) , ., , ,

- 31 -

, OO, OO, OO, OO, OO , , , I-839, 844~850, 866~869 , I-851~865, 870~874 , ( I-839, 844~874) . ,

, ( ).

, , , , , . , 3 and or . , . .

2.2.

. ( ) . ,

- 32 -

, , 2007.3.15. 20068869 2012.9.13. 20127461 .17) , , . .18) , . , , , . , , ,

17) 44-45.18) 45.

- 33 -

.

.

1.

1.1.

1 . .1 . , . . 1 , . , . , . .19)

19) . , , (, ) , , (: ) , , : , , 22-23.

- 34 -

1.2.

? , . 1 ( ) , , 1 , , 20) . , . .

1.3.

. , , , 3 .

. 20) 2005.12.23. 20052945 .

- 35 -

, ( ) . , ( ) , () . ( ) . ( ) . . ?

2.

2.1.

. 2008. 12. 24. 20089414 . 1 , , , " . (dubbing) . . , .

- 36 -

. , . ,21) .

2.2.

, . , . 2013.7.26. 20132511 . , (Hash) , , , , , , . , , , , ,

21) 9, .

- 37 -

. , , .

2.3.

. , . , . . . SD , . , ( ) (Hash) . . ? , . . . . . ?

- 38 -

. . . . 1 ( ) .22) 23) , , , , . , . . , . , . , .

.

. . .

22) . : , 47-51.

23) , 49.

- 39 -

. (Uniform Electronic Evidence Act) (authenticity) (integrity) (CanadianEvidence Act) 31.1 31.8 .24) .

31.125) , . 31.226) . (the electronic documents system) , (consistently) (manifestly) .

, 31.327) .

24) , 2013 () NRF-2013S1A5A8022736 .

25) Authentication of electronic documents 31.1: Any person seeking to admit an electronic document as evidence has the burden of proving its authenticity by evidence capable of supporting a finding that the electronic document is that which it is purported to be.

26) Application of best evidence rule electronic documents 31.2: (1) The best evidence rule in respect of an electronic document is satisfied (a) on proof of the integrity of the electronic documents system by or in which the electronic document was recorded or stored; or (b) if an evidentiary presumption established under section 31.4 applies.(2) Despite subsection (1), in the absence of evidence to the contrary, an electronic document in the form of a printout satisfies the best evidence rule if the printout has been manifestly or consistently acted on, relied on or used as a record of the information recorded or stored in the printout.

27) Presumption of integrity 31.3: For the purposes of subsection 31.2(1), in the absence of evidence to the contrary, the integrity of an electronic documents system by or in which an electronic document is recorded or stored is proven(a) by evidence capable of supporting a finding that at all material times the computer system or other similar device used by the electronic documents system was operating properly or, if it was not, the fact of its not operating properly did not affect the integrity of the electronic document and there are no other reasonable grounds to doubt the integrity of the electronic documents system;(b) if it is established that the electronic document was recorded or stored by a party who is adverse in interest to the party seeking to introduce it; or(c) if it is established that the electronic document was recorded or stored in the usual and ordinary course of business by a person who is not a party and who did not record or store it under the control of the party seeking to introduce it.

- 40 -

. ( ) (at all material times) () , , . , .

, 4 . 4 , 3~7 , , .

. , . 3~7 , , .

, . . . ,

- 41 -

( ) . 4 , . . . . , . , ., ?

, 2015.1.22. , 201410978 ., 2014.8.11. , 2014762 ., 2014.2.17. , 2013620, 624(), 699(), 851() ., 2014762 , 2014.4.10.

- 42 -

1

28)

( )

1.

. . . .

. , . 1644 (John Milton) , 1869 (John Stuart Mill) (On Liberty), 1919 Abrams (Oliver Wendel Holmes, Jr) .

. ( ) .

(On Liberty)

28) 9 1 13 3 . .

- 43 -

. (harm principle) . .

1917 29) (context) (clear and present danger) . . ( ) . . .

Whitney 30) .

, Dennis 31) . (Fred Vison) , . . . (gravityof the evil) (probability) . . , . .

Dennis

29) Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S. 47 (1919)30) Whitney v. California, 274 U.S. 357 (1927). (California

Criminal Syndicalism Act) . . 6 .

31) Dennis v. U.S., 341 U.S. 494 (1951)

- 44 -

. 1957 Yates 32) (John Halan) (Smith Act)33) 34), . , (incitement test) .

Brandenburg 35) (incitement test) . (Criminal Syndicalism Statue) . . (advocacy) (imminent) (inciting) (producing) (directed) (is likely to) . . . (advocacy) (incitement) . (is likely to) (imminent) . Brandenburg 1) , , 2) .

32) Yates v. U.S., 354 U.S. 298 (1957)33) 1940

. 34) 33 .35) Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444 (1969)

- 45 -

Brandenburg Hess 36) . Hess . 100 , Hess . . , . , . . Brandenburg . .

Brandenburg NAACP v.Claiborne Hardware . NAACP . . NAACP . Brandenburg .

36) Hess v. Indiana. 414 U.S. 105 (1975)

- 46 -

, , , , . (14)

.(15)

, ,

. . . .

1)Hess , 2)NAACP , 3) .

2. 2015. 1. 22. 201410978 ( )

.

.

, 1) ,2) , .

- 47 -

. , , , . , , .

.

, .

, Dennis . Dennis Brandenburg 1)Hess , 2)NAACP , 3) .

Hess . NAACP .

.

- 48 -

2012. 12. 12. 3 , , 2013. 1. 25. , , 2013. 2. 12.3 . , 2013. 3. 5. , 2013. 3. 30. , 4. 9. . 1 , 2013. 5. 7. 5 , 2013.5. 18. 20. 5 .(17)

.

7 1 "", "", "", " ", " " 37)., , . [] .38)

1991 7 1 1990. 4. 2. 89113 , , ,

37) 1990.4.2. 8911338) 1996 10 4 952

- 49 -

. . , [] .

. .39) .40)

. . - - . Dennis , . , .

39) 2007.12.13. 2007725740) 2008.4.17. 2003758

- 50 -

. , . . . .

Dennis 1951 . . , , . . . 1950 . . -- .

1950 . , .

- 51 -

2

( )

1.

2015. 1. 22. 201410978 , . . , . , .

, , , .

2.

, . , . , .

.

- 52 -

. , , . .

. . . , , .

, , .

. , , . 10 , IT 3.3 , .

, 2009 IEEE . , IT .

, .

- 53 -

, , .

, .

, . , , .41)

, . , .

, , . , , .

, .

, , , . , . ,

41) 308 .

- 54 -

, .

, , , . 0, 1 , .

, , . , .

, . , , IT , .

, , , . , .

3.

- 55 -

, . 1 , 1 .42)

, , , .

4.

. , , .

, . , .

42) 3082 . 2007.11.15. 20073061 . , .

- 56 -

1.

2.

3.

3.1. : . : . : . : . : " "

3.2. . . . . .

4.

: ( )

- 57 -

1.

1985 30 , . , . , , . 2.

( ) , - - . . ( ) . .

3.

3.1. :

. :

( ) . , , ( ) ( ( ) ( ) .

- 58 -

.

, , . (1998. 5. 28. 965) , 10 (2004. 6. 24. 200227) . . . , , () . . (incite) . .

. :

. . . . ,

- 59 -

.

. ( ) , ( ) . ( , ). . . , - ( ) - (context) , . .

. ! ( ) ( ) , ( ) , .

( ) . . .

- 60 -

~ ~ , ( ) .43)

. . .

. :

(imminent) . , (Doctrine of Clear and Present Danger) . (presence) (nowness) . Whitney v. California(274 U.S. 357(1927)) L. Brandeis . Brandenburg v. Ohio(395 U.S. 444(1969)) .

43) ( 1969. 9. 17 69780 ) . , , . (, 60 10 16, 46() 1799() 1920).

- 61 -

. (advocacy of action) (incitement of action) 44) .

. , , 45) . - - . . 46) - - . . 47) . , , , , .

. :

44) Whitney v. California, 274 U.S. 357(1927)45) , 30 2 28 .46) (), 60 3 4, 44() 260,, 44() 441, 44

() 5266, 45() 146, 45() 104747) , 60 10 16, 46() 1799() 1920

- 62 -

. . , ( ) .

. Brandenburg () .48)

. ( 2008. 4. 17 2003758), ( 1990. 6. 25. 9011) .

. , . , .

, .

48) , 1987 [62]36 1232 43

- 63 -

. .

3.2.

.

49) , . , . , , .

, . .

.

. . - 7 - ,

49) . .

- 64 -

.

. , . , . , , .50)

. , . . .

.

, , , , . , .

50) ,1990. 4. 2. ,89113; 1990. 6. 25. ,9011; 1992. 1. 28. ,898; 1997. 1. 16. 926 .

- 65 -

.

, . , . , . . : ( ). . , , . , .

, , , , , - . , , , .

.

, .

- 66 -

, . , . R.O. . , .51) . - - . . .

, . , . . . , . .

51) . , ( ) . ( ) , ( leadership) , . . R.O. .

- 67 -

, .52) , (nowness) . . . . .

53) . , , 3 3 . .

, . (, ) (, ) (, ) .

54)

52) . 53) . 54) .

, (advocate) (incite) , . . , , , , , ,

- 68 -

, , . . , . .

.

, . . . . , .

. .

, , , . , .

- 69 -

4.

. , . , . . - , - . . . - , - .

. .

- - . - . .

- 70 -

- - .

. . . . .

2014 12

()