55
cLqi1 JUCJflqpJ © UO!C !2 ACU O tpc 2OflLCC Jcxe uo io cxcccq iio b uuibp wiA p dnocq iiporn QxbJ!c! bi.wiou bLoAiqQq 4p jpjj © I2 pA CA W IAIIJU JUq X1QL yjj LIJU2 LQJq 2P014 CIiOU2 O IG1LCP ob!uioua QxbLGGq JW O2G O{ qJG IUJJO12 nJq IJO JJJO2G O I,4!0UJ B1JLGII O ECOUOW!C MBEB WIh flJ CEbI LP! bbcL i bu o MBEK bLow ! QLOtAjr ynA QUJT1J12 91 IjJQ flU!AQL2!Q2 O1 CP!O Coin WP! bowbn EP' MAfl Ai LAIE '-q JJC cp wuc oJcGA iJcu. L!Ju' joqq yJMAu AOflU uq bi.ijcibu ri OMUOAJC bCL KUIGii JOPL rnc A!L JWIUcIWIC KCA!U AjfIthpA DQLQJ( I'1Ti O11!U bgI E!PGL BJCIe B!!! gUq) 1oLq OI! 1!UJ HCIW.JU HJIO H0bQUPAU DJG 1OLLJOU B0AflJ tz.cp JJJ2 puqiq pow qJcn2Jou 14tJJ JOpI4 BLLO QLA BCCI(GL BGUPP!P EPth9LA 1ôô2 cwpJ_!q viv oJ 1020 CPfI21t AQUfIQ WLLIOMVr' BflIEVfl Oh ECOWOHC BE2EVICH JOLjUIJ bbCL 4O 20W X!GL 2J-!-VI!' CA B' LAIflhI!11 HflVM CVbLLVr' NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE WBEI MOM(1W3 bYbEB 2EIIE

NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

cLqi1 JUCJflqpJ © UO!C !2 ACU O tpc 2OflLCCJcxe uo io cxcccq iio b uuibp wiA p dnocq iiporn QxbJ!c! bi.wiou bLoAiqQq 4p jpjj© I2 pA CA W IAIIJU JUq X1QL yjj LIJU2 LQJq 2P014 CIiOU2 O

IG1LCPob!uioua QxbLGGq JW O2G O{ qJG IUJJO12 nJq IJO JJJO2G O I,4!0UJ B1JLGII O ECOUOW!C

MBEB WIh flJ CEbI� LP! bbcL i bu o MBEK bLow ! QLOtAjr ynAQUJT1J12 91 IjJQ flU!AQL2!Q2 O1 CP!O Coin WP! bowbn EP' MAfl Ai LAIE '-q JJCcp wuc oJcGA iJcu. L!Ju' joqq yJMAu AOflU uq bi.ijcibu riOMUOAJC bCL KUIGii J�OPL rnc A!L JWIUcIWIC KCA!U AjfIthpA DQLQJ( I'1Ti O11!U bgIE!PGL BJCIe B!!! gUq) 1oLq OI! 1!UJ HCIW.JU HJIO H0bQUPAU DJG 1OLLJOU B0AflJ

tz.cp JJJ2 puqiq pow qJcn2Jou 14tJJ JOpI4 BLLO QLA BCCI(GL BGUPP!P

EPth9LA 1ôô2cwpJ_!q viv oJ

1020 CPfI21t AQUfIQWLLIOMVr' BflIEVfl Oh ECOWOHC BE2EVICH

JOLjUIJ bbCL 4O 20W

X!GL 2J-!-VI!'CA B' LAIflhI!11

HflVM CVbLLVr'NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE

WBEI MOM(1W3 bYbEB 2EIIE

Page 2: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

uqCP!CO if' QOQ3 MGM HAGU Ci OQ5OJ JSQ E21 JJ 21' 58 HHJPOGflUJAGLTA OJ CP!CO J.JJQ flIJJAQI2IUtDGbJUIJJGUf O ECOUOUJC DCbUUIIJGU O COUOUJ1CCGA B W''IJ!" XA!CL 2"J-!-V('4!

G w!2jG1qJu

JJ& (1J1J JJQ AGLC AGn2 O CpOOjJU OL IJJG QUJbJUCJ nqA Oj GXL1 LOlAJJ moqGJ wX

/AGIJ nb qrnu qJQ Jg2 (Mp!JG qjbGL2ou O CJJOOJJ 14GJJ) JA COIJCJJJqC

LQM /AiCG 2 LbJqJA I2 iJJG AGLJG AGL2 O 2CpOOJJU Uq 1JJ JJf1UJU cbij IJGdflJiOt CLO

2OUJG OJ JG QWbILJCJJ uqu2 gLQ flJ JQ OCJC O pnurnu CbTWJ JU IJJG fluJlGq 2WG

G2IW!OU GLLOL fip1cci O OWG GJLCJJ COUjU2

&bbLocp pA Mp!Cp lAG COO2G fG pc GI uqGx UfJUJPGL2 pA UflU!uJTiIJ JJG GxbGCIGq

JOL IJJG COU2UJC1OU O JUqCX U1IIJJG12 Iii buj qw 2G2 OlIL UJGJJO i piq 013 1U 0b!UJJ

2WQ2 JOL Gcp CGUfI2 AG9L 2tWU JU lu OLCL o qo lAG bLobo2Q UGtA wGqJ0qoJoA

JU Jfl2 JMthGL lAG COULflC Ii 0J JJJ1WIJ C1b!WJ UqcxG OL O JJG flUJtGq

VBLKVC1

HflIAIV4 CVbLLVI'EV2f1Kll4O VOOJEOV1E

ECPLr1LA

4BE1{ J10LpU bbGL 2OJQ

Page 3: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

1!JG MGJp2 n.c pc Acn2 o cpooJiu (p i qic IACLIG Acm. o cjJoopiJ)MO4CI2 (ipu pc icic cwbjoAwcu oi. iPo oLcc) iuq jic mcijucq nw oi ii MO4GI2 MJJGLG

JJJG CX12fHJ 1!LULG Oil GCOUOUJJC LOThIjJ }JJ2 ncq MO AcLA iuibjc Lcuo: pc pu nm o j

J!curflLc 1JG pcr WG2fJLG oI pnwru crbii tocic

qi2upnriou2 JJJOM pcw O COULf1C f WCflLG O AGLG AGJ12 O COOLJ MpJCp i fjJGIJ ncq JUjJG

1HUWGIJ qJLipnroiJ OL JJLG CLO-GCfiOU O COflhJIJG OL 1J1G bcuoq JÔQO-Jôôo LPG 151 !UUJGLJI

If pcucpwmjc AG15L uq pc ciwc o cpoo cutoflwcu B15LLO IflJ GG [j] cowbfuc cqcic&uowij

(2cc 1OL cxIruJbJc B111.L0 [JJ]) icuio [j] cwb o cpujic 15ACU1G ?ci2 o cjoopu p? uI2JIJ

jjic ctjA cwbJucIq ccouowi nq 2CPOOI GULOIIWGUI bwx?. OL fpc ocj o ffWI1U c&bij

IJJG crUC1JOuIq OLW O luG ItJIG 15 LG151OL i flJJJCUOMU

if JJOIJJOGUGOI1 O qGLGG OUG O11L bLoplem i o uci.c ciwc oj fG rocc o UJIHi cIfbJWJ MGU

qic 15nwbfiou 11Jf IPGLG GX1f2 If f15JG If LGIffOL flUCJiOU MpOG riUCf1OUI OLW ! IIUJCUOMIY ccbf fIff

LGIffG fG j2f fIfG o 1511 GIJJbILJC15I fnqA Wf1f IfLGIffG IJJG GfGLOG1JOfl MOLj(GLJ MG MJJJ uJriuInu

&LG G LOGUOfI Ifuq pic qqcLcu bLoqncfrAific flf ou fG oqJGL puq Ipe IpGOLGIIC15J woqcj COIJIGL I15POL

!ubr1f wqrn ic cqj iticii cs fpc !ubnf If2OC!IffGq MIfp IJJG JIfOL OLCG BGCIfflG 011 OUG pIwq M04(G12

bLoqncpou nucpou o liii ccouowA cu pc cxbLGcq i pc nuciou oi IfLG15fG wbn uc o pcc

Ac15L 1IJI4IU Hi JJ MG 1OIJOM fG fpcOLcficIfj IIfGL15UILG pA IJ11UJ11J luJLOflPOflf fpG brbci. IPIU fjJG

flWIfU cIfb!fIf! focp If Gf O; GfIWIffG OI ricp 4OCJC 1OL IJiG fIffG OI. fG fluifGq W1G TOL G15CP

ocj oi pnuiiu cIfbfIq pecome If1iJIfpjc jpi bbci. bLobo2c If 11GM wcfpoqooA OL fG coutuicuou o

jpc pepIfAIoL o pGG moqcj cIfuuof pe G1iuiIrfGq IfiJq ccq cwbiucIfJJA nuq ooq WGIfflLG oi Ipe

If GLJCLIfJ woqc o fJfl oLf)

qccJTou fO IUAGf iii pcit OMU poqJc If MGJJ iii bpAicIf1 cf (cG vInhIIfu Ifuq If1If-!-IAIi4!U [j]OL

couurccq WIIIIJGC1OL15I LOMf woqcj o rnqA ipe qAulnrnc pGJJ15A!OL oi ipe ccououiA M}JGIJ IfGUf JIfcc IJJG

bLocc oj ccouowic LOMf iuq qcAGJobwcuc hoJJoM1u ['ncIf2 [j] If unwpcL o IffI1OI2 IfAG

LPG LGCGUf LOMfP JIIGL15IflLG If2 cmbpIf2Jscq IJJG !UJbOLI15JJCG OI Gq1ICIffOU Iwq pflUJIJU CIfbUIfj !U IjJG

upoqnqou

Page 4: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

Io i3h13v £ ioI I1iiq13 nBmud 1o 31U3 boos i Ihon Ion i nitoorb2 10 1E3( 31fl3V orfT

1li lo ihow iol a3iu1iidu io3hoq 3113 (to3ii3) noi1Eub3 f1E3 lo ihow Ififil mun Ii iwti9

13v31 1n313Thb duiw io*iow riomi 113i1n313Thb 'iivii3ubo1q fli iidi 3fflhJE ii ,bno3o .hoi& iodio

I fihiw io*iow i iirI1 mu ii 3IqmEx3 ioI .niIoofb lo ibth ol 1inoinoqoiq 3113 noi 33ub3 lo

oIii oiw iiodi b 223Ibm31 anh1oof1Q lo no (111w io*iow 13 213 3vii3ubolq 213 miI I i nuIooth2 lo

InilJ2no3 3d 01 bomu i quoi 1n313Thb lo 21o*iow os noiluiii2du2 lo 1i3iia13 oth biir1T .2hiinoIoThb

iwIE Hb12 iii oo13rii 3ffl132 3111 I3viIob ol bomu13 21 niLoorb2 lo io ono jhiuo1 .oior1wiovo bni3 2f3w1E

bni 2131b1331 oth lo '1iIsup 3111 bns bu1a lo bloil odi lo o1bmei o 23011 Ii 1L1u3iru3q ni .313r1wI3vo bnE

.31u331n12011n1 noilB3ubo orb

d 2m3Idolq o3r11 3v1o2 01 boiqmoflE ow ([QQf] nih13M-i-131132 bnl3 rmi11uM) oqiq uoivoiq i nI

(1213 13 lo 1iI13LJp orli 113(11 w noiliuini 1130 .3mo3ni ioclnl no bod 1J3Jiq133 rmmufl lo 31U213O nrt3tr1i2no3

b3vi330l noioq noiiiijbo lo oqi orb 11 .33131q13*u3m orb ni ovi&oi oii o1rr ow 3111 oi boi1131 3d bliow

01 llo2rnzrI b3iovob noioq LII hs1imi2 .3SW did i (111w mid blLwol bluow 210)1mm orb juIo2lJ 1ov w flIfIO2L31 ILlom (I1JJno3 IVX (13132) W3Iv lo Jnioq noil3ubolq

13 mofi 11113213 \(IOV Ion w rbirlw bIofl i bu12

bni$ wo1 od bluow noioq 113th lo 11$flqllo nl3rnurl 3vr1)ubo1q 3(11(13(11 (imono33 th3iloloorti lo 23q1 111131103 lo

.o2 311331bn1 bluow 01131 0i$W 2i11

2nJqni 3in31s 13(110 lo lnuomB 3(11 no bnoqob o2lil bluow 3EW 2'lothoW 13113(11 nw Jnioq 3)1 odT

'1no Ion OQI ni nEfli 13wo1 313W O4QI iii 23LW 31qm13x3 1o1 .2*10w Of! 113111w ni monooo 3112 iii OIdEIillvi3

310W '01onr1331 lo [ovol oi11 bus lEhiqso 1s3i2(1q lo Inuoms orb 32u133od 0215 lud 13wo1 010W 211iA2 o2U1$33d

bobivib 3W 31E1 313W 2'ILubivibni 3(11 ff011 231d13flSv 31L31E 3(1110 130113 3(11 o1snimi1 01 13b1o nI .iowo!

31o1313dT (111)12 0(1 213(1 jioilinilob d odw) 13*10W 11D12-013S 3(111031131 313W 0(11 d 31131 313W 2'no2loq (13130

313W 2If1t3W odI 313(1W 213*1ow us lo mu bo1r1iw 3(11 213W monooo ns iol 1131iq133 nf3rrlurl 10 01132133ff luo

013W 31f3315 3111 01 1fi31viup3 21 2iIIT .13)110W 11311q133-nsmufl-o13s 3(11 lo 31$W 3(11 ol 3BW li3fIi lo 01151 oflI

.13)110w ni1o0f132-013 3111 lo 0i3W 3(11 d bobiv'ib hid

Page 5: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

[P1 If 12 UJOIJO[OUJC r1Jq [LU21[JAG G[C 2CC D!GMCI4 [Jj 0L ii GXCGJJGIJ[ GXbO2[J0U 0 MJJJCp UflWCL2

qG2iurpJG ,[C2[21 (oL Gx1wbJc OUG IJJ ThIJ[ [0 CJiCJC 1JJ[ U IuqGx 1J(1UJCL !2 JUA9LJ&U[ 10 CJiHiJG2 1i 2C&fG

C01IL2G 0J CCU[fIl.A fiG PG2[ [PCA CU qo 12 [0 CJJGCJ( MG[GL bmcnj !1JqGx UfIIJJpGL b22c2 W1WGL 01

GX12[1JJ uJqGx UfHJJGL 11[GL1flLG 1LG flUJC [0 CJJOO2Q HiJJ0U [JiG 2COLG2 0J fHJC1J01JI I0LUJ2 bLobo2cq OAGL [JiG

pnujru c1JbJ[J iuqcxc 1LG cowbn.cq GCOUOUJJG2 DGMCU [1 oxI boiu 0f1[ [JiG ffifJi0L2 0J [JiG

JuqGx UIIWpGL UI [JJJ[ MC CJJOO2G [PC fflGX UflUJGL2 [P[ WIU!UJIC JfIIJC[IOU 0 [JiG CxbCc[cq CLLOL uiqc MJJCU

LGbLG2GU[2 COIuupn[I0U [0 [JIG JUGX W1UJPGL J1[GL7WLG flUJIJCG OflL bLGqGCG220L2 MG bLobo2G u

O4 iCI ICL7 fPf IJ0M JOL CL022-2GC[IOrnJJ 72 MCII 12 [IWC-2GUG2 couJbiu2ouw flGUCG [l2 b1bGL

J0lJ MJIJJ JJf1UJ1U cibigij G2[I1JJ[G2 JU[Ji12 bibGL MC bLG2GU[ 11GM wCqi0q0J0A JOL [JiG COU2ILfIC[IOU

GqnC[i0U f1[HiuJWCU[ 0 [JiG 1P0L JOLCG MC [JJIIJJC [P[ 11 LC2OJAC7 [G 2Ji0L[COW1U2 0 [JIG bLCAion2 OLJC

[GIJ [0 UJIC[flJ[G fl1iUGCC22lUJA 111 [p12 bbcL MG bLobo2c qiGLGU[ WCT2flLC o pnuiu cbJ[J 011 [JiG

WOACWCU[2 Ui [G 2[0C 0J JJfIUJI1J c&bij pi CIJ2G2 MJ.JCU IJJG2G bucC2 CJJJ1JG 2flp2[HIJ[H7JJ) 0(71. WGJ2fILG M011J

cprncq JOI. LG20U2 0[JJGL [Ji1U 1GCJJU0J0ICJj 2JIOCjC2 [G1J 0(71. WCI2flLG2 MonJq 111JLCJJ12[1CqJA LG[JGC[

2[L0UJA IiU2[ [JJG7G 122flhJJb1J0U2) '' 2GCOUq bLopJcw MJ2 [JJ1[ MJJGIJ [JIG LGJII[IAG M1G2 uiou MOLJ(GL2

[JIC2C rnmb[ioU2 qo 1101 pojq Hi [JIG q OIIL UiG2flLG2 M!JJ G pii2Cq (ruq 2OWG GCOUOUiJ2[2 MIII JLflG

OIJJCI2 (&j[p0flp MG jJ0MC J0L iuX qCCc O 2flp2[JWWP!JJIA 71JJ0U JJ [JIG 0[JIGL [ThC2) jo [JJG GX[GU[ [J1111

7JG [0 112G p1111 J2 UIIWGUHLG MG JJ7O piq [0 122flWG [JJ1[ [P!2 MOLJCGI. MI2 J bGqGc[ 2flp2IJ[flIG 10L IjJ [G

(Mplcp MG [00J( 2 [JIG HU2JCJJJGq MOLJCCL) pq [JiG 2IUJC HJJOIIU[ OJ 2JqJ1 1MUA2 uuq GACI.AMJIGLC Hi OLCJGL [0 JiG

fiG UJU bLopJGuJ M1[JJ [JIG FIB WGJ21ILC MI2 [JI[ MG JIJ [0 22fIWG [JJ&[ [JIG CL0-2CJJ00JiU M04(GL

LCJ1IAG bLoqncfiiu[1G2 OAGL fJWG HiJq CLO22 GCOUOUJIG2

JiIJ 7[nqJGq qipGLGU[ [PUJ2 [JJGIL bLoqnc[IAI[1G2 MGLG IJJOMG 10 qujGL) If jO IJJ0ThGq JOL CJJHJG2 111 [JIG

if qiq UO[ IUJbO2G JJ MOLJ(CL2 MI[JI [JIG 2IIJJG W0f1U[ 0 cqnC1[i0u [0 J11IAG [JiG 2WG HJJOfIIJ[ 01 2J(IJJ (20 !l [JICA

IAflJ[C 0JG1U C0U212[GUI M1fJI MILH1JG GJi12[IC1[1C2 0 2flp2[i[fl[IOU JCL072 [)bC2 0J MOLJ(CL2 EIII.[PGLW0LG

.LP2 WG2flLG MJJICJJ MG CIJG (fifi) WG2flLG oj pnuiru cibii piq [JiG

Page 6: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

iodmun rbirfw bni 'oJEhqoIqqE 0Th ioi rbirlw :iovoworl othi mo1doiq owT (.oii1oqorq rl3idw 1ii Vioi o1diniob orb q JEdi ono orb norrm biq ow ob

irrft nur gu d iodmun xobni nomi nioorb lo moldoiq orli 01 noiiu1o £ irioo1q ioqq IrET

d iobi idi inomolqmi oW .noFIoih3 iono bol3oqxo ifs oiminim rl3irlw ono orb i iodmun xobni hmiiqo orb

iso unoD ifs ml oisi bolinU orb lo 2oisi orb aos oxobni 1siiqs nsmud lsmiiqo 3nii3inino

lo 1oiomslsq orb niismiio d xobni 1siiqs msmurl s ioini2noz ow I noii3o iii ob ow oio1o8 .O4Qf ni

o1o1$ bris omii iovo oxobnI si2iviU odiioob ow E bns noii3o ru .ioisois 3imd1i1soLrus1i E

xobni Ismiiqo orb iol ri31so 111w ow doiriw iovo r1oiisiui1no3 lo io orli odi13ob noiio .oimono3o

111w noiioih ir1i lo noiisiminim oriT .noiuoiho -uo ioii ns ooqoiq ow noiio2 ruT .iocfrrnin

.omorb iodrnun xobni noiisv orb 10 orb omqmo noti3o .iodmuri xobni Ismiiqo orb iovilob

Isriil odT .omiJ iovo brus oJ5i OI35 oxobni Isiiqso nsmwl oiiiovsl iuo lo ioivsdod orb odhob V noii3o

odhob ow wiodmrin xobni orb Its iIr1i2fro3 11sui3s ow lull noilnom b1uorI oW .obubno noiio

015 mull lo Ifs iol oiiiisi oviiqi13ob omo .'libi1sv iioth bolol ow rluodi novo ioqsq orb iuoduoirli

.xibruoqqs orli ni bolioqoi

.dnoiqqA nok3SI A :1osg91A okninT 3fIT (1)

1 \çIoois3 lo noii3slI orb i thX oiorlw) 1x iodmun inomnisils Isnoiis3ubo lo loi3ov orb od X I0J

iodmun lsiiqs3 ruirnurl s olni boisgois od 1153 iuqrui lo 10i30v orb isdi omus oW (.s monoo rui ioAiow

ni 1siiqs rismud 1o boi lls ow lsdw i ..1x}9 = H iodmun ouT .[XI noil3nul 1oisoigs orb niu

oluqmo3 oi ( )I noii3mil ioisois us ou ol i Iso iuo noii3uboulni orb ni bonoiinorn ow A .A monoo

213 bns Isioqmoiioini diod lol 2woIiB rloirlw sw s ni 2oimonoo lo lonsq s ni Isiiqs3 rusmurt lo 13o12 orb

9W noiioe2 airfl iii Isenep iii nwon)lnu ai ØR mio srIoiionu en! r1uor1iIA .nothsqmoo Isnoil3o

:oimdllhspoIen-i! ed ol nwonl ciii lenD emuces

lo oq'i ruiIoorl32 lo mo' :1o*iow osnoois3 oi sw lo iodmun o1bno us ois oiorfi o1qi3nnq nI 2loAlow osi1ooisD ow noil3o ioisl nI .oitiIidioq omo 0Th 03i bus ,os xo iiubni noiisqu33o niIoorb

.iobno bns inornriisiis Isnoiis3ubo d sisb o1si uno oisl botinU moil

Page 7: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

(1) , Ø(riI))(nI) -! (nI) 'D = ni = ni

hiomm .1H]='H oimono33 M ioI ioc1mun 1IiiqE3 nl3mufl 31 OIi3 lo ioloov oil) i H oiorlw

bns 13J3mB1Bq ii f1uodib3 - nworol oil ol bornIJ22s i miol E&Ioii3nJñ odi won ioI .3ifl3ijE1o lo xnIEm

iirii o1iupoi ()'1 okrIffI1 i lo noiiqmu odi d boilqmi iionoomod iionil lo noiiqmu22E odT ion 316

J3oqo1 1111w (1) nith3noio11iU .oios lJ3upo i2um q lo mu nmuIo3 oil) bits I ol qu bbs i2uiri x lo nmuloz) odi

:qid2noiisloi niwo1to1 oil) )o ow (x ni) ol

() (xnI) + J) =

oodi noi1iioqmo3 l3ohoq modE 2aoiiqmuas Lsuu odi iobnU .aoifl3iiE1o OfflO3ni 10 lo)3oV odi i i 31311W

£fl3b ov&1 ow oni .1 iooisz lo ioAiow oil) d borriso otu iti\ odm oi bnoq2orIo3 oii3iiB13

noi)rnip3 ii q bits 1o1oms1Eq oil) ([x...1x]) noiiudhiib Inomnisims odi no s how s oisr1 oodi1o his no

b1uo ow bo)smu12o oiow () ni q bus n 13i3ms1sq oill o3nO .sisb oldslisvs niu bomsmimo od bhuo3 () .mono33 ibso ni hsmiqs nsrnud lo lovol orli omsmi1o ol (I) ow

noil3nul noimuboiq ns ol noiismixolqqs 1oIsT iobio bno3o s i noilorwl noilouboiq o1nsii ouT

32o13 i iuqni1o onin oil) noriw how Aiow 01 hohi1 i bocJiioob mu1bodJom oilJ oonoH (.[VQII tiowolU oo)

fl3ffW iovowoH .oilsibsup moil mnoioThb ooi ion i noiiontiI noiiouboiq otni orlh 10 mnioq fIoiisfruxolqqs oil) ol

oil 111w ii s) omi 1o borioq no1 s IOVO oimOno3o lo 3fI131 12Ev 5 2O135 2)boi2 IJ$flqEo nsmud oismii2o OW

..U 8 oios Isiiqso nsmurllo 2)13012 oil) ofliqinoo 01 mqmoils Iliw OW 01011W ioqsq irlo2oIq oiii ni oso oil)

3200113 ow iloiriw bnuois )nioq oil) 01 "o2ob" od 2swIs 111w ow oil) isdi lo)1i1nu i ii (OQQ 1 ol O4Q I moll oisi

ovoilod ol nosoi on i oioili isdi i rlosoiqqs noiJsmii2o 2111) ni2u iniss inomugn3 bnooo2 A .olsfnixolqqs 01

ni)Emii2o iol borliom n0!225131 on 1ooiioH .(335q2 gol orli ni) iiibup 21 notionul 1o)sgolggs odi isdi

.lsliqso nsmud 1o 2lovoh oil) 1o 2oismui2o ojEiuoosni olslonog a) '1o)1i1 i 2lomsgolggn goh2nsli

Page 8: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

boi 3111 lo oi&nii boos l3vil3b bluow borll3m noi1imii ii1i 1&1i Anirli ion bib 3w rIuoufi n3v3

boil3q 3r11 iol ii bolinU 3111 lo ii r1i o1 () ui noi1nup3 1o m3i ciii b3lnmi13 3w jB1iq3 fu3mud 10

iol l3bnog 'd nwob noloid hol in3mniEili3 1Bnoilub3 xi no EIEb un&) 2.U b3u 3W .OQ I -OQI

lond A . xibn3qqA ui bdhzb rn LiEb 311T .ol3 uouiinoo 8 rf1 iol bni3 3bf3b xi 3111 lo r1i .1 xibrl3qqA ui biioqi i i1u31 3r11 lo ikrn

3iiiMiJ$I3 noibuboiq i11 nw13c1 qirf2noiif3I3l 3111 uo1 noii3ib5Iq gnoii ri noil ffiq goIrmi1 3rlT

niU .3i113mm2 ni rI1 bnu3 () ui as 1J$3nul 1i3nx3 i noilnI3l 3111 :aluqni lo boi 3r11 bru

d b3oqrni noii3ni31 3111 b313i 3W , I xibrl3qqA ni biioqsi 31si b3iinU 311110 31s1 3111 iol 31Efni3 3111

\13V i ion i noil3rWI o12ns1t 3111 mdi bnuol 3W 33f13H .fn3rIi 113133131 1!as3 bun noimnfli33q aoIrIs1i 3111

b3iinU 3111 ui 1as31 is b1iow 1531 3113 ui sisb Isiiqso nsmurl 31n13n3g rloirlw 33o1q 3r11 lo noilqrlD23b boo

.boil3q b3noiin3m3loln 3111 iol 31J31

9ffliT 19,0 X9b111 ski',iU () bus I boh3q n33w13d 1nriqn ru3murl lo Aooi 31ss1n 3r11 lo 3fl&13 lo 31n1 3111 3iuqmo3 01 iobio uI

1iuprr1ofIT 33) noiisIu3In3 niwoI1o1 3111 rbsoiqqs x3bn! niiviU 3111 mOrIO3o 153iq1 £ iol 1+1

([VQI] 113W31U brim {E1I

(; OI goi

x

owl 3111 lo sumi1 3513VE 3111 niu d i13rIi 3io4 .3mo3ni iodsl lo 31nr1 I boil3q 103is3 dii 3(11 2i 11V 51311W

3111 lo gnicrnid 3(11 is sir1 3(11 2321J rloirlw) x3brri o1'3q2sJ 3111 Ia 3E13VE 3111 x3bni siiviU 3111 boh3q

;v boiioq 311110 bn3 3111 Is sinr1 3(11 3U rlDirlw) x3bIll odoass 3111 ban ([1V81] siqasJ o ;11v bon3q

(J4V8t1 3dq 33

Page 9: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

lo 3iEmii3 lo oh i iI3no £1umIo1 x3bni fii2iviU 3rIi no2hEqmo3 IEl3isLid oAi$m ii w3EI

thiiini di xi1&rnon w 11 .A 'mono33 iol lEiiqE3 nmud lo bo 313 odi lo 3WIsrb lo oiii 3r11

.Liiqi nmud lo 13v31 lo iio omil i oiuqmo3 ol b3u 3d 11i oiin diwoi lo i 3mii 3111 no ol boi

31613r13g fl3 3w boiioq vixu 1133wi3d noi1i3qmo3 lsloiEIid lo ii gnuc1iIdi3 d biow iotho aT

li13i61ii1um iol 2wo11 113111w mono d3 lol 1iiq& nismud lo 13vo1 bnE ?3iE1 r1twoi 10 3EI3 3m11 6

lo ono 3l1si3n !3lqi3nhq Hi j1633W .3mil l3vo 'fflOflO33 311010 I1$1iq133 nismud lo aboi 3111 lo no2h6qmo3

3111 111 no ol b3xihsrfnon od 111w omii odi lo fb1 16111 13v3wo11 iioM .mono 11363 iol rk)u2

3d ionnJs3 bodi3m i11i ur1T .1gnins3m 3d Iliw m311i nom noimqmo3 flO -O13 3111 o bohoq liiI

.no2fl$qmo3 16fl0iJ33-013 11i1dEi3 ol b3u

13b10 12111 £ 3113 3fL1 16111 21 23X3bfli 3r13213131o 2313qa1sJ 3111 lo 321J 3111 iol noilJs3ffil2ulrlornmo3 3110

?3fI6f13 lo 3161 3113 lo 3361111323 X3bfli Ei2iviU 311T .1oi31E (11 lo 3gnJI13 lo 31131 3111 01 noiiEmixrnqqfs

iotuio bn0332 £ 21 233thfl1 3nisd3 lo 3161 311366dI bnB 231'3q2I3J 3111 lo 3613V13 3Iqmi2 311) 32U 21 Ii 32LJ1333d

3do6q 2313q21sJ 3111 n33wi3cJ 33(131311th 3A A 1.1ois3iis lo 3gn6r13 lo 31131 3111 ol noiissmixoiqqls

231b13oIqqls 13111101 orli IBIII i !no11302 2uoiv3lq 3111 111 b3nhliuo bodi3m flOt22313l 3111 bins 23x3bn1 £i2iviU io

3111 lo 31131 r1iwo1 3111 3iIJqmo3 3W (1311w 3IqfflEX3 ioI .2inioq floitltmixolqqls 3111 tcs O4Q I bnuoiis noilEmixolqqE ioIisT

13 3)16m 3W x3brn s13qei3J 3111 ni2u I 4Q I b1113 O4Q I n3owi3d mono

3111 usd1 2woIlol II .Q8QI brnioits 3lItmixolqqlt 3W !OQQI-Q8QI boil3q 3(11 iol 3ffl112 3111 ob 3W 11311w Jud

IlsliqE3 fIBmud 3iuqmo3 01 iqmOilE 3W Ii fl3V3 biIBv 3d 111w 2noiismixolqqls £i2iviU 10 311326isq 231\3q2&I

Jisfil oe !116q13 1131 001?! ion 5113 231mof1o33 owl 'ff16 211 noI 213 !231mono331o 3fl61 121w 13 13V0 boi2

f133w13d 33fu3i21b lo 1q33no3 3(11) b31oni 131132 3d (1133 23fl32 not2nlsqx3 io1isT 3(11 lo 2m131 l3blo i311iñ 0(13

(. noii33 ni 321331q olom obisin od IIiw 231ffl0fl033 owl

5113 '3c1i 113111 niwod2 d 131)10 12111 316 2noliBrnlxolqq13 3d321ns bins 2313q2nJ 16(13 1h3v nso 13b1331 3dT 21 noi)6mixolqqs lsI2IvIU 31ff .noiJ3nul 2s1uoU-ddoD 11 21 noilonul 1oi631E 3(f) 311)11 1no bnB Ii 10)13 tuorltiw

.noiionijl o12n61t £ 21 noii3nul 1ol6516 3uii 311111 '1no bins 1110113 luodliw 2111 32u630d l3bIo bno332 3d ol biB2

33S2 o1 3111 fIt (10113(1111 o12fl131i 3111 lo flOiiltmixOlqqE 163(111 13b10 12111 is i noii3nul 21s1uoG-ddoD 3(13 321(J03 10 (.O= 113(1w (1) lo 3263 161U3t3113q 13 21 2fs1uoU-ddoD 3(11 !21 11311))

V

Page 10: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

x3bnI tkiviU anoit-oiD () i di 3iuqmo3 bluo3 w fl bim A 3imono3 lo 1Enqs nEmud lo aboi iIi iiqmo oi l3frio iii

w&v lo nioq b33irIqfno3 £ moil noii in3I3Tlib 5L H bni A 31311w) H bnE A n33wJ3d H 10

:(€) lo noi2l3v 1Enoii3-o i ni1qq d (3mi 111 Jnioq 1n313111b owl 3 monoo 3m 3111 nEfli -13111131

•v !—got s" ' 1x

3111 rioowlod on&b lo 31111 3111 113111 no ol 'mono "v1' 3(11 1o 113iiqE n13mu(1 lo 13v31 3111 3silJlrrnon w II

3111 n3owl3d 3nnd lo 31131 3rlT .'mono to dt iol 13v31 1i l13fl 3imono bni iii1

imono 3111 1113 iol 3lub3Dolq ir11 nh1B3q35I no o bns ffI0flO33 SYU1\ orli iol 13V31 3111 13Vi13b tw11 bnl3

1131311111d ni1qqE d biow 13(110 nI .Isliqs3 nilmuft lo 13v31 lo noilo3-oio Ilul i i31nlno3 rn 3W

11313fl$IrlIum lo m3i2' 13 113 3VITIII Iliw 3W 3tffIO11033 1o 2iiBq 3Vi2333tJ n33wl3d noniqmo

.norinqmoD 1EfIoii3-O13

3111 113311W 111 13b10 3111 'lEf1W 11f1I3f13 510M c3fIo V%1\,3f1l i 'f110fl033 (131(1W :i noi13up '3)1 311T

ol (31d13rIoil3upnu 1om113) 11IuI11n 233 ii 3fl3 311111 nI cb3luqfno3 3d b1uoii 1131 f11Wo1 3V13331J

11311w 3irnono33 lo l3blo 3-vo 3(11 i 11111w luff 31o13d 1)1113 O1Q1 131111 3(1103 bkiod 1lQ1 113111 3fflJJ13

111U1313 3111113(11 mo rrrn1 II 113flEm nn3b1o 3111 3ob 1lf1J3t1oqmi 3lom qsrhI c1101j33 O1O 11 3V13f1 3W

3111 'iw 3111 ol bi13q 3d 01 boon (10111131113 30I3 33fl3H ((a) 110f133 33) 1lf1 flini -I3nf3m fiu13b1o

.b3loblo 3111 231111011033

ni fflOflO33 3213d i biq ol i )13r11 3111' .13dJ3o11n r1i13b1o biovE ol 2! m3ldolq 3111 3v1o2 ol 'w 3110

3211d 3111 bni 'f110fl033 (13133 f133Wi3d lJliiqB3 nErnud lo 3ns3r13 lo 31131 3111 31111U3li13 113111 b1111 -1f13(; n3Vig 13

113311 ol 11113w w i&11 2uoivdo Ion 2i 11 13dl0 113113 01 1x3n t1113io1offo1f13 3113 OQ I bnn I Q I r1uor11 n3v3 1Er1l 3U111 111w 3W boh3q owl 323(11 n33w13c1 11111q133 nnmud lo 31131 dtwoi 3(11 3luqmo3 3W n3rlw w 21111 m3111

2311(1011033 owl 3111 lo 2tuqnI 3111 1ot133113 3[J1l 3111 ol noilsmixolqq13 boos 13 3d ol x3bni £i2iviU 3111 iol I3blo ni

310rn 3113 21B3' 3v11u332no3 owl ni 2luqni 'smonoo3 3(11 31J-r1 1hn ton i II .'lsIirni2' 3d t2um b3-Isqmoo n!3d n3rlw 135no3 3d ol bn3t Iliw Ii 11uo11i111) l3blo I33TIoo 3111 V22333fl Ion 21131)10 Ii33io1ono3d3 oth 3-1o1313dT .-ulIimi2

(.3mil 13V0 311111 31111f13 -1o133v luqni 311110 2ln3noqmoo 3(11

8

Page 11: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

o

O qc CpOiCc Oi,. pc AcI2ciiour jJc ciuirjcq i iuctA o pcw cuq onnq pc LC2Jf io pc AcI.A nuwJJpjc w ipcA cw AcI.A cuiiiccowbiuou 01. iic conjq cowbnc pc CL02 cqiou OL j1J 01. J() 01. JQo CL 1Ô8O iuq IVCU qJC !WG ?CU 0Lcuc ioi. uq uJ!u0 L MG conjq couibnc (G CLO2 2QCfJOU OL jçf MIC onq 9j0M 0L qiLGq

citow uq JJJIuo1 w MG conjq cowbnc r CL022 cqiou o pnwu cbwj oi oto uq (ECU JJG WGiJ ipci.c Ic °i oi boipjc MA o qoiu joi cxuibjc ill OLGL 0 cowbLG rpc iocj o, pnuiu cb!1J

cowbiuoua 0L bn.icnjn. ?cL rnq pcu combnc fG imG GuG OL Gcp ccouowA Jpc bwpcw Mitp tpcouibriu pG CLO cct!ou oi U11W12 OL pG bcuoq nu tpc wit. (Mplcp II0M JOL CLO-GCtJ01JJ

jtaeq o niu qc wetpoq MG conjq cou2p.nct bucj qit o pnwrnj cbi urnnpci pA

o pc obpwrj OLGL i to LGWGWGL i9 DJA! iuqex cu pe tponpt o & COUUUflOr1IA nbqrtiu ccouq

v ccouq MA jo qc MIqJ rpc oLqcuu bLopjcw to cpooc MPit MG Cijj tpc 1P JCGA

pi iu 2Gctiou

crc ccouomA jijci qcijinu obiwjiA w cctiou ic MIII combntc pnww cbiwj iuqcxc niu obtiirnij

LcboI.f 2oijjc combaifjAG 2nwwT.A rn ybbeuqix j yuotpcL boipiitA i to tI.A to uq tpc obnci

MG Gtiwitcq ir priwu cibii Iuqcx niu tpi2 cs% 'ci. niq cn'csi?c 2cI%. wGtpoq MG

ccouiscq tp& rpc iwbjc MA o cpiGAiu Auiwci.A M to 1AGLG pc-bccqic luqGxG2 OAGL JJ boipjc

nbGLL) ccouowX D!II.GLGIU CJJ0iCG 4OL tJJG pJc GCoUoIJJA MIII IAG LJC ID IGLGUt iuqGxG EIIJGL [io]

OcOflLG qic bLop jew Mitp ipe i it jcjc oi iuMaJ&lJcc to ipe cpolcc oi tpc pc (awL OL

qj bcuoq: ijj Gcouowic2 oi t!uJc c couibacq to it uq to 't iouc

wctpoq pccrnc qic pc ccouowA i uo oujA pc tL OL 0/lw tiwe bcuoq pnt it i tpc 491.

AcrI2 uq cvQo' 1P! orijq GUGLIfG ouc pnwu cibij iinwpc JOL c&cp LtG flJq ?GJL MG CTJ1 tJJj IJJG

pc ccouowA MG conjq tpcu cowbntc fiG LEItG o cpuc pctiiccu cicp o qic g ccouounc 191. GJCjJ oj qic

ccouow'c GXJI it i4GLGUt boiut ill tiwc Ju OqiGL M0L MG coriq bic CI!0LUJ "J TÔQO (cYQo) fiG

r GICJJ bojut !u tiwcy MG conjq iwbjA pc &wc wctpoqojoA pA IJGJGCtJU tpc ict tprt qi4jGLcut

R MG m9ut to cowbntc r bmcj oj pnwcu cbitj tocj (tpit JIJ Juqcx LJfIUJPGL 191. GiJCp ccoiiouiA

tpI tpc wcrpoq pccrnc qic pc ccouowA bjX n.uu LoJc: ccp LCJOU i cowbacq to it uq it qouc

CL0-GCfj0U OJIJJCf1LG o pnwu cibitq Mp!Cp JJOM2 491. wnItiIiJtcLrI cowbiuou 11A! [jg] ccq

ccouowA BA tpc pc ccouowA tocj o pnwru cbitj to ouc tpi2 bLoccqnLc GIJGLtG

Page 12: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

io1T B OU ow noriw oABrn ow ioiio odl ifiril woml oW .(X) rioilnul 1o1io1E ffB 01 notamixoiqqi obio

01 iobto ni oio1oiodT .o1Bmixo1qqJ ow ibidw bnuon3 lnioq olil ol o\ OlE ow nodw i noiil3mixolqqE

ol oIdioq oob niEmol 01 boon ow xobni IBliqs3 nEmufi iuo 10 noilBiuqmo3 ofil ni ioiio oth oximinim

o3nJ3iib lo oiuom £ onilob 01 boon ow ob ow usd1 o1U oABm o1 lnisw ow ii lull .noLBr xoiqqi lo lnioq oth

is (1 3U lo noil3nu1 omo oiminim 113111 ono orIi od Iliw niloblo lisinilqo oriT .luqr1i lo ioiov noowiod

21uqn1 o2odw ono odi i A monoo oi od bluod2 rl3irIw monoo ofli bodiom 2iffi o1 nibiozA .o3nfsl2ib

iliw 2q51 2 owl Ixon odT .A monoo iii oodt ol ofIl 0113 (iodmun inomnrlsflE 10 loloov 02011w i iisrtt)

.o3nisl2ib f13U2 3iffliniffl IIrw OW d3ifIW IOVO 102 £ bnis oornsl2ib lo oiuom 13 onifob 01 od

xobni bcioflslillum lo noilisoio odT .lnioq lnBtloqmi 1113 oAisrn 01 oAiE bluow ow boo3o1q ow oiololl

0111 4 113111) 2oimono3o owl idI 2oxobni ortI oiisqmo 01 BW 123d 0(13 IBril 212ou2 oiod bo2oqolq 1102 orli lo

nhBqmo3 nodw o1qmExo ioI .2oimonoo iorllo no slisb 02U 03 21 (no2ilBqrno3 IBloiBtid is oAsm ol \13W i2od

2oimono3o no noiilsmiolni 0213 01 boog od idim Ii dEiU bins EmodEblO ni 11311q133 nismufl lo 2A3o12 OQ I odi

disiU bnis EmortEblO noowiod no2illsqmo3 odi dguorluls biow iodio iii .2311312 owl 320111 "noowuod ni" 0113 odw

oiqmo 01 ioliod od 1f1iin Ii ) p3 ni islumiol xobni lisiolislid orli 10 noiils3ilqqls 1oiib d onob od bluoD

ow hum no o bnis ixon 0111 rIliw fflOfl0DO "ixon" 21(11 01Bffl03 nodl bnis ,rnonoo 'lxorf' 211 i111w EmoftEbtO

lisnoilB3ubo lo lol3ov orlI 11 :inihimisl od won d bhuod2 lEu2ol lnssuioqmi 21(11 iol noiiiulni oriT .disiU rbsoi

3ilBlbBup l3oiib d o)Itsm ow 10110 odi nodi ,inoioThb iov 0113 dislU bnE ismodisblO iii 2inomnulSiiE

odl his lo ioiio lo mu odi nBrli ioiis1 ibum od 1fIim Ii ,ls1 nI .ogml vmov od 1dim no!lBmzxoiqqE

.2no2i1Bqmo oiisibomiolni

.I9 to 9iOdD MIT (1)

Mthn\3

2uoivoiq orb ii! .oimonoo lo 2iiisq noowlod aAniL InloIBlid lo noil3ohlo3 213 onffo(J

noii3u1i2no odi ni bo2u nollo ono odI 21 notiBiuifno3 onO .oimonoo Anil oi 2BW wol is i2ou2 ow noi13o2

01

Page 13: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

odi iifl omo monoo O4Q1 o(1J o1qrnBxo io1 .2OlfflOfl033 lo inomogrIl3Tu monil i - oxobni 23n32 omiiIo

.io monoo S4Q! offi oi boAnil i 'mono33 11Q1 oil monoo I4QI oi1i 01 boiniI i mono33 O4I

'1i3o1ib 3113 2OifflOn033 iorlio lli thiriw ol monoo orb .o.i) monoo 3213d 3(11 21s monoo 31ni2 A

i3Lufrno1 xobni li3lolslid £ qulo2 diod nI .[48QI] 2ivnl){ 10 mol2 11312 odi - noi1i31uiIno3 iorlions iii (bsAnil

isonil oil iortfion ,iovowoH .2)1511 2201313 xobni oil lo oiit r1iwoi orli oiuqmo3 01 b32U 21 £i2iviU 213 rbu2

omo 2onuIob noilo 2idT .oimonoo )1nil 01 sw o1dEviono3 1no 3(11 om mi 2ivsl)I orIJ ion Jnomon13Tu3

.2lrIom3nJrru3 oldi22oq

lo io iobi2no3 '1no Iliw ow jBhiq13D nisrnuil lo 231U21$Offl it diiw qu 3O3 ol insw ow 33fli

rf3u2 LIE lo 102 oi1i onfloU ô.oluol o1dioq 13

r1uoii11 231f50fl030 owl flB Anil usd1 2rIoii1s1ui1no3

-M odu oionob ol (M) noiilon odi 3213 oW ".132 bobon-M" orb od ol 2oimono3o Mb 2rIoiifrIui1no3

.102 bobon

3111 bo 2unomoLo 3(1110 (13133 2W0fI2 £1 oiuiq .olqmsxo ns ni boifsii2uIli od nszi ,(4)Q ,132 thtn A

(olqmllxo 2irll ni ooidi) 1-M 213 itsffl 213 ol boAnil Ii3o1ib od n 2oimono3o mob odi bo rbiso :132 Ariilinu

iriomolo its od ol noiis1IJibno3 is mol ,iovowoH .(Li3o1ibni 1isoL Us) boAnil omis 2oimono3o 1113 bins 231ffl05030

modlo nI .oimonoo owl nis noowiod 2502 flJ3fflO3 bsiolslid bo m&b ono 'hio od i2Um 310111 lo2 \tU\II oril lo

iii bosLqib rioi1is1uflno3 0111 ,olqrnisxo loVi .oupinu od 12um 201150(1033 owl 'nis rib1ni1 "oluom" odi ,2blow

(I) :sw owl ni bomqmo3 od n D bnis A oimonoo 32U133Od 132 oil lo lriomolo its ion 21 cli omuiI

no2nisqmo3 lisiolistid s (ii) bits D bins H norisqmoo [inoislid is diiw modiogol H bins A no2imqmo3 Isiouslid is

.D bits U nonsqmo Isioiislid is riliw morliogol (I bins A

3flET1f3 01 2\BW flSffl '1mo13 11112 3113 513(11 ,2flOIuisiUgibnO3 omo2 mo 2olirl 132 &ri\itw 0(11 dgiioriulA

.xobni Ismoislid isi2iviU 3(11 gIIiU boioull2noo od riso no2nsqmo3 LisioflsLilhim lo m3J22 13 113111 02 2OifrlOflo3o

113111 ogml 02 21132 orli ,iovowoH ''noiiisiugibnoo lEmilqo odi bnil 01132 ogml v13V 21111 111 r131532 ol 21 lisog mO

gnoinis 3200(13 mobsom orb lol bits norusqmo lisiolislid bo xnhi11n 88 d 88 is iloqom bluoo ow ,Ioviismoi1A .nornsqmo3 linolishtlum oldi22oq lo modmun ogmis! '1gniboo3xo orb

.() 5011302 ni bonibob i ismiiqO

II

Page 14: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

lobniErnol oriT 83 Anilinu ocfi 1o 2iodu2 11u3iiiiq ni1obino3 d flo11o rbmo no osimonoo o boon ow

.iodu omo onflob oioloiocli noii3o idi lo

lo Anuit 111w ow ait (TD) rii \cio ocli H ow idw i iodu iii1 ouT

how niiobio ouli ooorb n oH .ii i\wii ii oimonoo orb lo ff3Bo oi o oi tir1 oriw nEmo1

bnE ono unonoo viovo cii qoi 01 Ed oil 113111 i inu1$1ino 1no iH .qhi ir1 im1 on 113111w cii monoo orb s .noii1nu11no3 01di2oq !84' om oiorhi noii3o2 oi ioI .o3rio 1no

.noii3o-o13 nirhiw boiobio ois oirnono3o 1irb 'w orli ni ii1ib n io TD orb lo 1nomoi

.boAnul 0113 rIoi 0-013 inoiollib orli 113n11 'w orb ni i ioThb nro io TD odi lo inomo1o isrii 'w iorlionA

ono iodionA .Bcn13d13IA 1+1 bonoq rhJiw iu3ii3onnoD 1 boiioq 1n11 13w1E 'i3m noiif3ltIgfino3 ono o1qm13xo ioI

i io TD orb lo inomob n lo oLqmisxo nA .iobio 1133io1onoirb ni oimonoo iqqiiiM xi 1113 AniI vjm

. omgil ni boi3iqob

d noiinu1 io £ osirriinim 111w ow io TD orb niu o1oborbom iuo inomolqmi ow noriW

11311w lo nioiisii13v i moldrnq tEnoii1iuqmo3 idT .ioa TD orb lo noiiEwno3 io inorno1o iovo nin1mo

nood 3v1311 ii1noi loluqrno3 bnl3 n13i3ii1modhI$M .rnoldcnq nI3mo11 ni1ovE1T orb 11& 2nEiDiiEmorliEm

2 o113O bns [88I] 113 Jo 01q ooa) 113O iol rno1doi rnmo1i nuIov131T orb ol noiiu1o orb bnil ol nivji

thorhiom Ii3noiiniuqrno3 lo iodmun 13 boiovoib nood ion 1$d noiiu1o brxo ni riguonlilA .([QVQI] no2nnlot

noiiov £ ou ow ioqiiq irhi nI .([48QI] 113 io ?bhil3qhiA oo) noi1imixo1qqE oob bIoi' oi bnuol nood ovl3rI

mo lo ono nn ni 2oimono3o 8.P orhi ioI .[881] 113 Jo 01q ni bol-toqom borhiom gnulEonnls bo1E1umi orb lo

(hoinmixomqq13) ol omb moiuqmo3 'muiinoq i lo o1unim oiiupor mrfihoglB orb rIoI13o-o13 2'olqnn13xo

\1oi13fnIixo1qqI$ 01 bomiupom wnso lo 2bn132uorb onli ol booqqo ai - (8.h-) movo noii3nul io3 13 oiminim

.(84)Q io Anulinu oiiino orb iovo noii3nul io3 13 osiminim

-io lo noi11id OAI$i bluo3 102 lnilinu orb lo 20r1n1302 oLqmExo -ito ni oimono3o bo-ibnuri wol i illiW

zrso lo 2bn132uorIi boon 2mrlthogh13 lotuqmo3 i2od orb nov3 .loJuqmo3 i131 V-IOV i rhliw novo

Page 15: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

(%) nimzi 'rnt lo n%

wotll3 ion oob lud is lBIu3irIsq no ni noii lls oi bvisii oi nm1 I1J wollE i TO 3fIT

dT .OPAM ol bd bni O)IO 01 Ot'TD moil o ol b3wotEE ion i 3ff 31qmSx3 io1 .3mii vo bvisii ol miff

TOM fl21$31 on i 313111 3lqi3nnq nI .qhi bnoqm3n8lni di io1 wo1li i mxz%

31311w) "1ilimi2' iov i OIW i&1i 3111 3d 113w V13V bluo3 ii :qh1 IEloqm3il3ini 323111 io1 wo1Ii 01

wolIJ3 ol 3)111 bluow w 3111 21 idi II .OAM bn13 OVJA ol (3h13m 33n1ib d b3ni13b 3d 111w 'l13limi2"

II3ioi £ 3v13f1 3w boi13q 3fnui a bri13 iE12 84 3VI3f1 3w 33ni .l3fIio fbB3 01 ix3n od ol 23111100033 323111 iol

r1iaoor13 ir1 lo a3imono3o oviiu332no3 owl 11E ii2iv ol nJ3m2oli$2 fn13v1r1i 3111 wo11i 3W .nifnono 88 lo

3111 wo11i o2113 3W .( 31uiI oo) 3d 01 n3qq&1 imonooo owl oor1i 113111w ni boil3q smil sf11 lo a.s1bisi

ebBs iol oirriono3s 88 won 3v1311 3W 33ff! .qhi 2111 lo inioq thilini 3111 s2oofb 01 n13ms11 niIsvJ31J

.2noii131ui1no3 !88 su sisiIT .21n3m313 \V8*88 21111311103 noii3rnñ 1203 sf11 noii131ui1no3

sill Anil 12um TI lo 21113m313 32111333d io TI orlilo is2du2 13 ion 21 Q 132 TD sth ii11i o3iioT4

sib lud noirk1 isni1 £ ni 11011332-22013 rbis LniI i2um TD lo 21n3m313 .noid1 ilIsnil 13

ni

.(132 )lmhinu srIl lo rl13q i noiiis1ui1no3 sill 213 no1 ) iw ni bsAnil sd n 21101332-22013 3113113q32

s? i. siV

11133 Q 132 11312 3111 lo 21n3m313 jni11iU . no1i33 111 b3di1323b bortiom io sib 2wollol 132 2idT

.11011332-22013 113133 111 3101 gI11T113i2 3(11 i3Iq 23im0n033 ifl3l3llib sVEfl \13 si1i i21iI .2no213s1 owl 101 13Thb

isthonA .0011332-22013 \03V3 ni 3101 aniTuli2 3111 nPE1q £morllllAO 213ff noii131u11no3 sno 31qm13x3 ioI

O I 3(11 213 Bi1O3D 1Ei2 O4Q 1 sf11 213 2ionhIlI 213(1 ff0iiE11Ji1fl03 13(1101113 bY .11312 3111 213 *toY woM 213(1 lnsmsls

213 J3biloFl bn13 u312 08Q 1 3111 as sinigiiV 123W rni2 OVQ 1 3111 213 sirnolilis) 113i2 OQ 1 3(11 213 noirihIasW 113i2

.11312 OQ1 3(11

.2110i1332-22013 3111 Anil '(5(11 iloirlw flj '(13w 3111 21132 11312 3f11 10 21113m313 2201313 sonsisThb bnoos2 A

3110 isrilonA .13mEdEIA 1+3 bohsq illiw iuoibo3nnoD I bonsq Anil 2'(llwlil '(13 noii131IJi1no3 3110 s1qrnsxs io1

Page 16: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

bJ3iq3b 21 i2du2 2irli lo noifliuflnoo kiqi A .iobio ioIono1fb flu icnono iqqii22iM x12 1113 AffuL m A iui1 iii

Efl$b [I Q I] noiH bns 213mrnu th d bos.iliiu mi 2'2ivE1) 2uorn11 i1i icrIi i imoq niioioini nA

w1 nI .m3122 if1 1f33idq131o3D 2111110 fl01213V i 232U 2nOill3n 2201313 no sqmo uo 1131i13liuIiJm lo io

LIE lo 3Lbblm dJ flu i io O1ffl 21 Anidi 2iorIflJE oth rbidw cnonooo m12 A3iq noioH bni rommu biow

noowiod boilqqE noflt 21 rioanqmoa £i2iviU IslotElid A .oloi nrn13J2 orb 2s1q 'monoo 2icIT .oimonoo orb

xobni uo lo oi,o Isnoit -22o13 s o tono ot wtothus orb 2woIls 2irtT orb bris monoo rioso

°.21odmiJrI

%'ISt 88 orb lo us ioT .E fI0ii33 ni r% orb b311133 ow isriw no bo2sd 21 io 2irtT

o1qmsxo ioI .itvc lo oloi orb \131q 111w rbiflw monozo o213d 13

biq 2O1fflOflO3O 2ono2-omri-n01302-22oy)

ioThb Q Jo lsi2ioqu2 orb lo 2lnomolo irioiolliU .(OHO) OQ1 iii oirlO 21 monoo lsialoqu2 orb oiuiI ni

.2inomolo M 2511 (M)1Q oanoH .'mono3o nrnoi2 orb lo o3iorl3 out :sw ono rio ru

:atuqnl to 1ot9V f199wt9fl orniU to uiIVI () doiqqA noitmu"! 3oD A

:2qo12 oo-irli 213f1 borliom 3125d iuO

21 F noito2 flu bodhzob mo1 u312 'ivsi)I bru$ siod bodiioeob ow borbom orb noowtod onoio11ib oA odT 'morioo o213d io ist2 s niaoqmi 1i1i311iths nsrb r1is1 floliOflul 1203 out oirninim rbiilw 11312 orb bnfl ow 51011 isrli

.oimonoo isi oIdi22oq us iol lsiiqso nsmurl OE1OVE orb nu1uqmo3 1iiin1idis d 10

bluo3 ow ,olqmsxo io1 .iso oms oft niritiw 21s12 1s3ir1qsoo trioioThb iol wolls bIuo3 ow ,olqiortnq ru

bluoo oW 231512 moJ2oW bns 1253 towbiM orb us iol fiidi oms orb bits ,1512 ono ni 2oiEi rnothuo orb ils AniI

boos -iov iovilob bluow oisi12 21111 IsrIt oiutooLnoo oW J203 oirniruirn 113111w 201512 owl orb d 1512 d3133 LruiL riouit

21512 olqiilum 020111 lo n01131n12n03 0111 isrb 21 moldoiq ofT .wol 'uov od bluow t2o3 iiorli 113r11 021102 orb ni 2oxobrii

orb 1o o3iorf oriT .1no 2noio1 iuol otni 2.U orb griblsoid iol 1102501 on i oiorll 5iorunor1fliR .bo1siIqmo3 13V 21

.11 ovlo2 ot 'ti1ids iuo bnood rnoldoiq orb ots3ilqmo3 bluow isi lo iodmun

M

Page 17: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

() l Anilknts 3rh lo inm13 10 noils1ui1no3 E oooff oi) oimonoo oIl gnirnA (I)

3r11 oluqmo3 ol l3LurrnoI l3dmun xobni 1J1lEIid E U mono 31i1Iomun rtliw ninrn5H (ii)

.imofIo33 ii1lo Ofil lo f13& b 1f3liq13 nl3mtJft

.bnuol i noilfnui1no3 'id' 3r!l Iilrnj (ii) (i) lsq5I (iii)

".l3d" nfl3b rioii irIT

iodmun xobni lElolElid dl l&Il OUifi oW .lod lo noilinibob i ogim noiIJ32ib uoivo1q iuO

o1dioq onO .lo luqni 3111 fli 'ior1iooi oob" OlE lull oimonoo owl ioI olEilqolqqE lom ohs 2lsIumlo1

o3noloTtib olli bo omup lo mu boirIiow odi i H bms A oimonoo boAnil owl noowlod o3nlsl2ib lo noiiinibb

:H bnis A oirnonoo iol 2iuqni I (IoolIs3 noowlod

() —---QoI px

osiminim ol od lrIim golfcil2 A (.(4) iii bonilob ) oimonoo owl 3111 iob 0J313VE orli ohs adiow ofIl 31311W

.() oq'i lo 2o3nlSl2ib bo mu is

bi lisill 2l2ou2 ii o1qmisxo ioI .2OitIoqolq niLisoqqis omo isd oonsl2ib lo noiliniTlob 2idl lull oloM

.oios i o3nislib iiorli norli (i LIE iob i. = M luli o2) 2noilUdihi2ib inomniisilis Iis3ilnobi ovisri 2oimono3o owl

owl 11 .131110 113150 01 Ixon high oimonoo owl 023111 ooisLq 01 ovisrl oioloiorLl 111w gnnobio Lismulqo odT

2i lull) 1115m2 oiis x bus r ,20115112 oril 113111w iol 2ohogols3 lo bnomniislhis odi ni Lno ioThb 2oimono3o

i oimono3o owl 323111 noowlod oonsi2ib ouli null (t'lfffihloqminu' \11is3imono3o od oh moqqs 113111 2ohogoJis3

2idl bnsr1 iodlo oill nO .olihiI boinuoo o 2ohogols3 lrlistloqminu ni 233n313Thb thiow ioflio nI .1113m2 11112

.ogisl ohs 2oilogols3 hnsrloqrni 3111 ui H bus A noowlod 2o3noloThb 3111 nodw 33nisi2ib ogint is 2ng12215 noihini1b

Page 18: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

iood 1dioq bnE oviiimoi1s nA '1.1i31iidls i oniib lo noiiinilob 2irli oIdinooi iiuodi1A

LEiiqE flEmuff OrE) oiuqmo3 ow noriw o)1J$m 0) iaoqXo ow iono off) lo noiiniminim oth 1iiino bluow rI3EolqqJ3

no bod flO2flfflO3 hnoii3lid 'flE nOii3fluI io)ois oiril oth womi ton ob ow 33n12 biow iorflo iii .xobni

i xobni 2A monoo t&fi Jioqol idgim ow 31qmExo ioT .ioiio ni od 111w btn)noD ow i&fi iodmun xobni n .loIIEm2 1n33loq ai 2'A monoo ii1 iii ndw 'H monooo nir1i logiEl Jno3loq 01

i61 nouElugifno3 moi bovhob 1iiq rrnmurl b 2oxobni boimii2o oth od (c)k b ()k ioJ

33n3H .8H bns AH d novi 21 a bn A oimonoo lo osi ovi)1oi oint oriT .'oviboq231 a bn A 2OlfflOflODO

:d novi i osi oviiEo orb oirnj1vo ow nortw oAim ow iono orb

(w) () —oI - oI (w)b (w)-

1Biiq1 nJ$rnurl orb worE 2onimloiob noiifnuimno3 off) 32u33d &1) oirfqmo oi w aobuloni noiision mO

.noi1I$1uImnoD orb no 2bnoqob ioiio orb boinmbo 3113 2oxobni

noniqrno orli rbiw 2OlfflOflO3O lo 21!Bq ow) flE oiqmo 0) 2U woIIi3 111w xobni Inloi13tiflum iuO

riii1u2o1 2flOthEO 1J31ofid lo 1i1Bup orb b oiueom A .(ô) oAiI mb) 10110 ni niv1ovni li13q rfo noowiod

:ioiio 1inoii1id bolf$up2 off) lo oiov orb d novi i 2lodmun xobni lo o2 i mo1

(V) (w)_!_

.2mb) 1b orb lo rbo lo oulEY orb wonl Ion 230b ono jnoldoiq iodmun xobni orb lo noiiinilob d o21uo31O

orfi Iuod13 ()ll ionq 10 102 13 0) 330q201 rfiiw (V) noilimpo 10 2noln3i3oqxo rIi)uqrno3 d boo3olq oW

noifl31ui1no3 orE) lo 1203 orb 21 (c)D noiini3oqxo nii1u2o1 oriT . wiorxo noiif$mixolqqE orfilo obu1inm

gniir1iow 1113ff) 1od131 oq o1 orb ni Diliom oonI$i2ib nl3obiIou3 oLqmi2 orE) 0211 tr1im ono oEqmBxo ioI " .() flOli13Upo (Ii 213 20113112 OfflO3fli (IooJf$3 d o)gi r1Jwob (Ioo)133

Page 19: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

+ (p!Dpei. OL6L tGLW)

+ (i:x'(io x) (joe' - io -

') = Io E()) + E O - x B)+ (pipoL OLGL 4eLwe)

- -

IO = IO (v) + - Io x' ')

cxbniou o qic luqex nuciiou j ouc ccououA y cuqomcut boiu uq OIJG ccououi?

jpc bbLoxiwpou JuAoJAc 2bccujcpou o c bI.!oL u( couqcL itio jAjoL

Con flLtJO1J

cxpnicjA c nct ic bbLoximiou2 Mpicp &JoM fl O IJJAC t JJ GtIUJtC Oj IJJC OblJUJ&j

wuhrnqc o piJtcL1j LLOI2 t.c nubccicq ccouq We 'i'i et AGLX JJLG Gt - too pn.c to ecp

vt tpi boiut qic obtiwj couunurtou uot cowbnwpjc 1OL tio Lcou IIL1 b4oL poni flJG

D!A2! -uq qiG ObliIJJ1J C0ULjf1L&1i0U

obiurnj wnJtiItGL&J Atcw o iuqcx IJf1WGL i cowbnicq niiJ S IJSfGLSJ Juqcx LJJ1WGL 0LWfl1S -ncpS

ipc cxbccsjou mc MGII qGiucqa S IJJUJiJJfIIJJ CjGS4? Gx!2t GCSflG qiG '!H' Gt UIJUG JJJG

(€O /(I). 9WU (o)

ccc 12 qiG GJGWGUt O tJJG 2Gf JJS1 WJIJ1W1G2 c021:

O1L 1JOtt!OU 5110M2 1OL We bo22IpJpf) qisi b4oL2 spont cquisqou cu.o urn) qcbcuq ou qic couniqow

WE

c(c') Ei(uOu(n))

(2)

Page 20: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

J8

SGL0 VBbL0X!UJfG fiG C0M1UUCG UJfLIX MJfp i qioUq wfL1x iuq fIWG fPf fiG tJJffL1X J & CJL

ybbtocnrnrtiou j0L GC ba oj GC0U0WIG jGf fG buoL2 T0f1f fiG qJiLq OLGL COGILJCJGUf2 JJ&AG WGU

ILIbJG nw (io)

combnfGq 0L GCP b9u 0j Jq1JCGLJf GC0UOUHG j VbbL0X!1JJ11!0U wbpjj fiG cowbniiou LGflJfW Hi fiG

M[JGLG GC0U0UJIG V wq B 9LG UGJJJp012 IU C0UUf1LfI0U C') JJJI Gf 01 1X flW p fGLIJJ wq Wfff G

Eioa (x'4 x' ] Eioa (x''4 x I [boa (x'4 ] [boa (x'4 \ ' )1 [joa (xu'4 W )] [iofl (x''4 \

v(x'4xBVtwu)

= E ba - boa — = E E E5

VbbLoxiwWou j MG C1IJ couibnfG biGcG 0 fiG C0f jfiUCfIOU (g) 0L f IAGU C0Ujf1Lf10U '):

ft MG GAf1f1fG E(x) GfPGL X 01. fJjG fiG AGU1G 0j fiG fMO J1?q0L GXb1JJ0U ruq UA0JCG

9 (boa X 9 (ba x) 9 (boa x') (boa x')

95boa %Ioa

VbbL0xJmf10u j jJOM2 jOL i iwbjG LGbLG2Guff1ou oi fiG ccouq qGLjA1fAG (GuJJ:

GC0U0WCfL1CJHJ p buol2 MpiCJi JLG qifupn1Gq 201Uf 1JJfl1IThU1fG U0UJJ11 M!fJ WGU GLO

qIftGLGUCG PGfMGGU GJC oi fJGEL Gcouq qGuAf!AG2 J.pG obG fGLIJJ { A} 1LG nujuotiu pflf fiG

VbbL0XUif0U T h0L GJC b&a oj GC0U0UJIG V ruq B C0U1qGL 1 Gcouq-oLqcL 1bbLOXiUJf1OU fO fIG

MGLG ,JJ1JJGL OLfGL fGL1JJ11 lliCjflqG qJJLq uq p1pGL 0LGL fGLIJJ2

Page 21: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

13i3mswq l3blo biirfi odi iuodE iniEtIonu lo o31b 'nEi3i1i3monoo &IT .xninm iiin3bi 3th b 3IqiiIum

.b51qmo3 gniod imono lo iiiq orli lo in3bn3q3bni i

gol] x) gol] [(x\x) gol] [(y)J3 =

r— r—i (01)

x\x)gooI]%x\x)goI] [y]3 =

ion i noibnul 101 31i3 3trli rli isdi worrA nfii3hi3mono33 3d1 iriI .nirIi owl noiiEmixolqqA

rfnoi b1o biiftT .3iislbrnip cnoil noiiiivob 1o noiiüb 3di iuodE 31U ion i iud (3oq oI di in) 3i11$lbEup

3111 111 2noii3sl3ini l3blo biirli nisfl iuo Itn noiirrIixo1qqI3 bnooo .3viii2oq io oviion 3d \(1ff1

.xlii3m 33fl1$F1J3V03 1BnoBib E lo noiiqmuE di lo oDnni2du2 3111 2i 2ith - noii3ntñ 1oiB31E

3113 H bn13 A imono ii [(CO)aAb]a b noifliuqmo3 dl 1iq2 ion ob 11i12 bni 1 2noiii$rnixolqqA

:q 2ith 21111 F noiiBmixolqqA nol iui1no3 3111 ni b3?LniL 1i331ib ion

bnE) D (fflOflO33 blirli 13 01 b3Anu1 '1liib 3113 i&li El bn13 A imonooo owl ioT F noii&nixotggA

b3133qx3 iiodi (ior1io d31 01 boAnil 1ioiib ion ,i di 10 noiiinfl3b 3111 01 nib1o3313 o1o1313fIi

:(o)t bnB ()1o ffiU2 3111 213 b3i13mixolqql3 3d n iono nornqmo 1iol1id bolsup2

[((.)]3 + [()3}3 = [(w)]3

.210T13 nothBqmo3 lEl3iEIfd 3111 lo ?i\ oi 2fl0ii1313T103 iuo 231U1 E noiil$mixolqqA

1203 3111 lo ff1131 113133 .()D noli3nul 1203 3111 lo noiiEiuqmoa 3111 1hq2 ll1ñ F2 - I 2noii&rñolqqA

(01) floiirnJp3 01 nibio b3iuqmo3 21113111w (w)t 10113 l1O2fll303 IBlOiilIld b3inupeE 23VIoVffl noii3flLil

noiif$siminim 3rfT .231m0n033 in33E1bl3non iol E noilEmixolqqA 01 nibioxn 10 231111011033 3n33131b13 iol

lo 3S12 2uobn3m3li 3111 lo 32uEod t3v3woH .w bmw1o1-t11i131i2 13 111 b3iuqmo3 3d WOfi I$3 (Q) m3idolq

Page 22: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

ili isiiIi31 oi bbnini 51E bnE 4 noiiEmixo1qqA .1B3ii1qmi ii noiiiuqmo3 thu2 (M) di .3lub33olq noiiEiminim

di iovo 10 noisiminim £ uiliw i i\n ouli iovo noiiiiminim di 3i1qo5I 4 noliErnixoiggA : bnI3 Q 1Q lo noiruj

(w)O nmpis U O U U O) a

(H) (w)3 'iim (cü)3 aim , (w)3 aim ()3 aim nmis =

LOa) OaCI)

ouli idi i 1IIJ3fl1ib 3dT .m3Ldoiq noiiEiuqmo3 1dbimio1 £ In31q 11ii (II) m3ldolq noiiuiminim i1T

bn. (01) rIoiuwp3 d b3dh3b noij3nul io3 ouli bnE usI hiE1 1Iii ( bni 1Q) 2T1 bni TD

3rb ndw boiBiiliosl i w! iovo noiisimi1qo lin3mun woH .bE3i1qmo3 oliup i E noiiEmixolqqA

no n0113nu1 io 3rb lo noiiu1Bv3 3di 1i1qmi 01 iqrn3iii3 noiiimixrnqqA ,3113uliw3 oi i noii3nul toD

:i TI bni TD 3ub

IE13iIid b31Bup b133qx3 3d) lo mu 3d3 3d 01, (c ) ,noiioniñ 1o3-obu3q £ 3nh1U noii&nixoiggA

3f11 lo noii&irninim 3ff) iobinoD iovo nAE1 fflU 3d1 ulhiw ioTio noi1Eqmo3

:\13imq3 bni vo noii3nul 1o3-obu3q

(c&3 nimts a W

(w) cAmis a

Page 23: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

odi idi3w ii isili w 3111 uk noii3nJñ io3 1Eui3 orb moil ioThb noii3niñ 3oD-obuoq orb L3vii33T13

L1B3nhI bonirn.a ou oimonoo iuo1 orb nodW .oIqrnl3xo 'monoo luol £ 1obinoD ,ir1r oo oT .thiil inoioThb

o1B Dab ouEcod i irLT .UDb 10 aAb s IivBo11 a 2omii iuo jb 21rIi3w noii3nuI 1o ouii orb U-D-fl-A

(HA) orli io1 '1no 1oiiEm aAb oiodw (GA) bnE (U) (DA) iiiq i61 ioiio noriqmo orb olni ioino

iidi &ñion o1A .1IEup3 AriiI ioiib rko idiow brt&1 iodio orb no noii3n1ñ io-obuoq oriT .nohiqmoo

bni ioD-obuoq ioe TI bn TD orb ioI .io orb rio bnoqob io3 brIE 1o3-obuoq noowiod oDnoloThb odi

SIB io3 brIE lo3-obuoq bnEr1 iodio orli no 1o 1Ei1oqua orb b inomolo ru ioI .inoioThb oiiup od n io 113i orb b Inomolo rIB iob 1B1imi oliup o1J3 oii io3 burn 1o3-obu3q .(M\(I-M) irrn1no3 orb ol qu) IE3iinobi

.(Ani1 1J31oqrnoioirIi moil ohB oDnoloThb 'nE) lo

rio orb no oimonoo oi noiinu1 Jo3-obuoq 3111 OIJ noiil3lUgflfIoD li$miiqo or!) lo oiBmiio mO

:lo TI burn TO orIi lo

(SI) (w)3 nim ,

()O nim ("6)O ('G)O ntms

0111 iol uioi1Eiui1r1o iO3 muminim oiEmilo 01 noliDnul 1203 ISLJI3E 311) 0215 3W 153rD 2olIqrrll noiismixoiqqA

io3 rnuminim oiBmii2o ol noii3nuI 32o3-obuo2q orb 021J 13vii3oq2o1 iic bnE i) io bnB Q

Q ) 1o orb rioowiod ooorb 01 noii3nul )o 1Eui or!) ou bnE Q bna lo or!) iol 2noii1rwñno3

.) brrn

Itfl,O 110 ZZWZÜ 0ITh

2moiorrrnll3q oI2 fEB11 orb 0113 ff1123 ol 13113b orb lo 1113 1I12U o12ns1i 013W noii3nuil 1OiE31B13 oirii or!) 11

boni&b lo 3211 .13n13q £ 10 2On32-3mhi floIi332-22O13 £ mob 2lOdmUn xobrii i31rI)no3 01 'w 2od or!) or! bluow

orc ?l 1Y fli\ icii i'o 5101010111 21 (go1mJ2 131110 311102 io) xobni £i2iviG

i nul$r13 £i2iviG 011110 Anil 113533 lud O12rIE11 21 10iEgomE oul) orb floriW J3Ixo i £i2iviU or!) OUiT .irrri (-M) iorbo odi mol BiEb odi nhi3313n mol rIOiiO3ihi2ul odT .oiunonoo owl '1no molt Bifib r1i2u boiuqmo3

Page 24: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

n3iIqx3 3d ol nd &1 do1qqE iuO .o1nE1i ion i noii3nul 101 51E in1 odi 113111 3d ium imono3

c,\ci i&1i wod2 01 bnE noiiEmixoIqqB oI2nhr1i 3111 lo 3n1ox3 3111 iuodE iduob iuo 1uo1113

r1i 13ri ion i 3iIi1i I13miiqo 3111 113111 bn13 iodmun x3bni niiuqmo ioI \cc, .irnonoo lo nh3b1o 3orl-b13 1113 01 boiIqqB ni&b £i2iviU b32u '(Inommo3

b 3W .imono lo no1iL$1IJi1no3 thmiiqo 3111 3200113 ol iud niEd3 J$i2iviU 13 3211 01 oqoiq 3W

noil3nu1 B boiuqmoz 3d 11 sh3ih3 i&11 wod work bnis iono nothsqrno3 hi31J31id b3iqx3 3111 iminim 01

bluork 131131113 11i 113111w 13V0 i Anilinu orli enoi1J31uitno3 lo i i oqoiq 3W .231d1$vlo2do lo

.b3ximinirn

.bnuol 3d 101111133 m3ldolq rroiisiminim IUO ol 2noiiuLo2 1313x3 go1onrk3i loluqmo3 JR3TDJ3 3111 rIjiW

wol3d () noii33 .m3ldolq 3111 01 noiiulo2 13 gnuiBmixolqql3 iol mrliiiogls 31d121331 1$ oqoiq 3W 13v3woH

x3bni b32u (1nommo3 noqu 3volqmi 11th1n13i2dua 11133 3W noitu1o2 iuo lo 223ni313x3r11 3111 3i1q23b i&11 2wo112

.23ig3313112 i3dmUfl

33n13121b lo iq33no3 3111 01 lniq2 ni lElimi2 i noii 21111 nI b3vh3b 5V1311 3W fIoii3IlIJl 1203 3111113111 3io4

2! 2fflU2 3111 lo f13E .2311o3iS3 noiiJl3IJb3 11! 233f1313Thb lo 2113112 iwoq 3111 23v1ovn1 ii :() ni b3iEliJi2oq 3W

23211 110113111111203 3111 11331ib iirk 3111 23211 () 31112133111 33fl1112ib 3111) i&12 311110 3E13V13 311i d b3ifii3w

23v10vfl1 (01) 110113111111203 3111113111 21 21q33no3 owl 311) r133w13d 33n313Thb 1111311131ff .(231&12 orEt lo 51J3112 3111

1203 3111 lo 3211 113111 iuo 2niui II .2i3ubolq oi 113w 213 (211r131 3iil3lbllup '1no null 13111131) 211113) 13WO iii

3W 4 31di3T xibn3qqA ni inioq 2idi lnoInu3ob oT .3IiiiI 213i11$m () 331113121b lo 31112133ffl 3111 lo bB3l2rIi (01)

sf11211 b3luqmo3 1s1iq133 11131111111 lo 31U2S3ffl 33110V131 iuo f1i3d qa bn3 Iliw 11311W n33w13d (101)131311033111 iloq3l

.() iii boii1uioq noii3nul 1203 3011-bE 3111 11121J 31U21331uI 1E[imi2l3 bnll noii 2ifli ni b3v'n3b noii3nul 12033111

OVQI 101 bnE Q0 iobnu IidiI2 21)! 0.Q1 io1 .4Q0 3VOds 21 noiilll5rlo3 3d) 01 bus 081 0ôQ1 0PQI ioI

1313X3 3f11 ilIflI iuo 2111111 ii 33ft3H .VQO 13V0 2! 1101113131103 3111 3ffui 3111132 3111113 23b1333b 1113 3211 3W 11 .48.0 21 ii

3d 0) luo 2111111)1311W .1133b i1331 £ 131113(11 ion 230b 23X3bfIi blflqE3 nEmull nu113mii23 iol b32u rioflonul 1203

X3b(Ii 5111 111 b513b!2 1103 133311 SyBIl 113111 2noils1ui1no3 31qm12 3111 lo 311102 bno3d 1131532 0121 ininloqrm 310(13

.311111313)11 l3dmlJn

Page 25: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

.) bns bod)9M 911) to d3&I to toD () bofLJom odi lo do riliw boii3o 1o-obuoq bni3 21o3 odi floqoi I o1diT lo 1oniq iii1 odT

orb i iid1) 2bodiorn IErnilqo iuo niu oJBmiio ow tuiom orfi riomA .rioibo uoivoiq orb ni boniliuo

ow nodw i1uoi 123d orb bnfl ow ,(Io omo iovo rIonoJn3 io3 i lo noiIiiminim orli ovlovni JEdi O1UEOffl

orb ni bnuol ow iirb Io3-obuoq IowoL oriT (TO) Io orb iovo rbiio

odT od ol mo boniui noiIiuflrioo niiminim io3-obuoq orillo 303 thjn oriT w 1o TD

ow i&Iw bnuol oW .. I lo Io i dliw (TI) i\wwi orb od ol moqq iod bno3oa

Iod orb ;noiloth3 io-obuoq orb rbiw riirb1Eo 'd io TI orb moiI noiflrrui1no3 boos £ od ol lrlguorb

lo 1o3 ru rliiw ivc orb w Io 1210w oriT ..QQF w 1o2 2irIl no ovoirbr b1uo ow rf3irlw 12o3-obuo2q

3203 11u2o1 o1ibomiomni fiB boovi1ob 1o 1B12 odT .(T[) orb 213 ovi2noqxo at 2omii V.O i rl3irfw)

nBmLJd lo lori13q I2od orb il3rb I23u2 211u231 o2odT '.(TD lo 32o3 orb 2omii Q n&1I oiorri) n&b oiomlo

.mo1a TD orb d boisiono ono orb 2i 2lodrriun lBIiqB3

w 11312 orb 1! .li203 viov i o\o i 2'2iv131){ fl3dI i I oIdjT moil nibni1 nii2o1oini nA

.(TD lo 1203 orb 2ornii Q nErfi oiorn) nsrb oiom od binow 12o3 tli$lovo orb foil l1J$rnilqo no2oib od 01

2ouE3I1o3 bn13 2ivlsl.){ d b32u borfiom orb lo 1203 orli 02 '(llismilqo no2orb Ion 21 monoo od orb llErrnoVI

ol 'o1oborl1om 2irIl 202U io BiEb noi2oH bnl3 21ommrJ oil il3rlJ iodmocno$1 .i&lI nl$rli iorIirl od 01 IoAil 21

2noi1131u31133 iuO .lrtomi2ovni bns noiiqmu2no3 1uq1uo 3mo3fli lo 2lovol lo 2flO2flB3 h$noiiEmoirn OAI$m

.ioiio bol3oqxo lo mu orb riiimiriim lo woiv lo illioq orb molt Inoi3flloni 21 oloborbom iiorli 113± 12su2

IBmiiqo-non no bo213d oiuom iuol boIEi3o22s 212o3-obno2q orb 2noqol I oldisT lo (H) lon1

12111 ouT .(1o2 omo iovo noil3rlul 1203 oil lo noitEimurIim ouli ovlovni Ion ob 113111 oiuisom 21 usd1) 2guthoblo

oisd s ni2ood3 2ovlovni borfiom 2irb 113± iodrnorno$1 . noiJo ni bodho2ob i i'rn orb 21 OfO

orb niriliw monoo d3iss noowiod no2rlBqmo3 Iino1i1id orb nimuqmo3 bnE borioq rIDES iol 'mono3o -11312 io

.102 1s12 orb molt 1203 murninim orb no bnuod iowol is Iuq ot oldis nood 1no ovisri oW

Page 26: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

84' b31s3q3i ei 31uboo1q IT .b1uqmo3 i xbni lo noi1ze O13 A .mono d r11 brn boil3q mi naIii i noi1 8I 111$ lo I3V oil bn (oono nonoo od boA3iq i 'rnonooo ff3Io) ornii

lo3-obiJ32q oriT .AniI i2o3 muminim oil r!uo1fIl bohoq 113130 boAnit noil oW .li3liqE3 nErnud lo xobni 1od

L1$miiqo iuo lo io3-obuoq orb nl3rIl oom omil 41 i 113111w QV&Q i bofilom 2idl riliw boi1$i3oJ3

.O•UJi3om

boittom 2irlT ivw oil iiiw bolth3o loa-obiioq orb l1oq31 woi bnoo ouT

11$lolI$Iid V8 thiqrno3 ow monooo oEd do iol l&1l lqo3xo fnol n3r oiov orIl 01 isLimi i 1x88 s l1c1ono iu1T .wuo' uno a oil lo &no iol ois1 84 oril b fbio 01 nibnoqoiioo nohsqmo3

od orb oimonoo 88 oil lo 131o niu d olubo3oiq orb li$oqol oW .11311q133 nl3rnufl a)!3ol lo iolov

omil I Vô i rbirlw OO88 II i borliom thll lo 1o3-obuoq 1i1ol odT .i1uoi oril O1fl0V13 fiorD bris monoo

.lo TD orb riliw borilom Lf3miiqo iuo ovi2noqxo 1$

lo lo3-obuoq oil i lifl odT .niiobio mobnsi owl niu lo lo3-obuoq odi lloqoi ow 11sni1

\1io3 oiom omiJ 4) VV od 01 boiEmil3 i rbidw vum'1 wk OlI d nnobio

1o3-obuo2q oil omil VVI) OOa1 I i 1o3-obu3Eq lI .gniiobio ni \\c i bnoo ofiT (.TD n&tl

.(TO1o

Ifiril ono oil ni (TD) n13mo1f nu10v131T 1133iiqE1ooD oil i oiuiom iod oil l&Ii obubno3 oW

-obuoq Islol oil ooqmo3ob ow oldsT nI .(OI) io (8) ni bonIob s 10TI3 bol3oqxolo mu 0111 os.iminim Ii

noii33 OQI oil bns V.QI J2o3-obuoq noil3o 0i3 O4QI or1T .AniI d bas iso d TD lo io O13 OV1 oil rtliw bo1si3os i2o3-obuoq orb i otdsi irti lo l3oq13 rnloiolnz nA .8O.81 1o—obuoq

OVQI orb moft 20fiO3 TD gniluqcno3 lo 1o3-obuoq ilinovo orlilolisri orio n&11 oiom i lndl O.88F :noil3o

oil lo doso fir Juq b1uor1 OW o3flobimflo3 orb 01 boi1oi 0Th alo3-obuo2q oor11 lsth ovoilod oW .noil3o o1D

nsrnijrl orb 3U OW nodw o3noH (.ioiio lnomoiu.som orb lo o3asi-113V oil 01 boisloi i 1o3 eu i lsdi) oiiisom

13113b OVQ I oil oiusom ow rl3iliw rlliwloTIo orli 113r11 bnim ni qooA bluork ow noil3o irIi ni bovnob slsb Isliqs3

.obEDob iorllo us oiusom ow rlDtdw dliw ioiio orb nEil iois1 i

Page 27: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

n-iui ii .aAnil h1oqm3rIoni 1i lo d3i filiw biiDo o3-obuoq 3rli tioq1 oEI3 3IdsT 1IEftiI

OM oi 0H ,(010O.O=io-obuq) 0A oi O1AM :niwo11o1 3r1 it a1ni1 1inoqmiini di iuIi iuo

bnE 110.0 =i2oo-obu3q) O8JA oi OVAD (0O.0=o3-obuoq) OVAJ oi OH (400.O=io3-obu3q)

(.VQO.O=io-obu3q) 0XT oi O8AD

IsliqBD ntmuH to 91uR9M A :flu9$I (V)

nibvE1T li33idqi1o3D di Jir1i i1Eni 1o bolli3rn iuo noio uoiv31q th ni biibni A

nimiJrt lo iuim mo a TO ffi Jqobfi iohidi 111w 3W .iorio b3iqx3 i3wo1 dJ b1oi (TD) mmli .3x3bni 1iiiqi n&nufl lo I3nBq b3uqmo 3r1i lo mr1Jhso1 3di Jmoq31 E 31dsT .moqEq 3th 10 ioi oth mol hiiq&

mol l3dmun 3viJ3n nH .1iiqE3 nirnur1 lo iinu 08Q1 LimolilED ni bmqxo i xbni dJ lo rbi1

di mdi o 08Q1 Bifno1i1ID ru bvL di nidi 1 i 'mono lull iol nimur11o 10v31 orli lull nm imono

.3viin3n i ol d bo1313vE liiiqi fmmud lo ium muo lo o1 di lo omil m3vo lo loivuI3d 3111 Iqib ô 31uiI

noiom 3r11 0Q I iii mull lon 3W 3IdET lo wom wol 12131 r1l iii b3tloq3m omn iuiI 1313x3 3111) noi3m 2U2fl33

3rlT .dluo 3111 bnE lndfloT4 iwbiM odi cJ bowollol ioW odi aw 1f3iqE3 nnmurl lo )boi2 Jodifl orb diiw

au lo1 bi$1i JoW 3111 0Q1 8 .rtid olkip w 2noio1 uno muol orb oi 11liq13D nunud lo noi2loq2ib

2noio1 muol lull oiijiI orb ni oo ns oW .12131 11112 w dluo orb olirlw l2odt1oT4 orli ol noimi2oq nibEo1

.01Q1 ni otow or1i nuli 0(QI ni modiool to2ob d3um otow

1siiqi ru3rriurl lo A3o12 0f31013 orb li lo ltiI .nilHgi1dgid dutow 0113 auzsl nilomoini lo olquo3 A

bo3noiloqxo loW orb ONI orb niiub lull 21 21111 mol nooi ofiT .0Q1 bni 01Q1 noowiod 1131 loW ofil tol

2floiii2oq ovill3bl odi lull olon ow bno33 .gni[oorb2 wol 1111w 23113m311o rIoiiBqi3iilsq 3111111 oJo13ni biqf3l 13

oil )lool iorltioM orb 0V 1 dm nhuU .OVQ I bns 01Q I noowlod ln13l2no b3nhl$mol 2noiom tuol orli lo

nimuU .120W orb molt noili2oq nibEo1 odi Aooi ii 08Q1 0111 nhub bnis lowbiM oil molt noiii2oq bnoo

nirth1mo1 odi lo lull null modal11 11EilnEl2du2 w i21odrioM odi mol olin rliwoia oil Juli oo ow 081 orb

Page 28: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

thmwoi oIqo3q botlbk lo noiiim bi3Hduq fkum 3th 10 noibf1oi iii d bluo3 ifIT .\(Iinuo3 di lo 2noi1

.O8Q1 orb niiub bnBIn3 woM

oii 84 orb b rbto o1 LBuiqc nEmurl lo bo oiov orb lo ioiv&Iod orb osiiiminu V o-iuiI

IEiiq& nl$murL lo Iovo1 gnioirri d boLnEl ii 84 odi id ixs lEiriosilod odT .OQQI briE O4QI rioowiod

rtitjo bowolEol ,iqqkiaiM aw EEiiqi nimud lo boi iowo( orb riliw '(monoo odi i&b oo oW .OtQ I iii

B) rioignirksW briE thmoliLED bEvo14 j{EIU OvEu! ow brio loqqu orli JA .thiooO bnB EmEdEIA jsnu1o1BD

.( o1dT ni boiioqoi i ai lo niArni 11J3os oioIqmo3

noii3u1ino d bns Q1 I ru LBiiqs3 nEmurl lo lovol odi ol thnoqsrIo3 iiup diiw bo*mm onE oriT

oion oW .iogcb d boinooiqoi i O I uo1 onul nibnoqoiioo ordi odT .niqok bmwqu briE 3inoionom i ii

nb1nB1 oviiEIol orli i&Ii 2oi13ibni ir1T .inoionom iognol on OlE niEb 2OQI odi iiiI .3iiil3i3Ir1Brb ooirii

ovsrl oiis1 d iorfio i1uoi B 2f bni rioiiioq ovilElol iiorli bovoiqrni ovir1 oini omo) bon1sr13 aIr1

orb isril oiszibrui idT .OtQ I iol onil orli risili qooi o1 od 01 rnoo bnoii Ilinovo odi bno3o (.bonoiow

.Isliql$3 rusmurl lo )boi 3111 ni olsi r1iwo ior1ir1 s bo3nohoqxo ovJ3rI IsiiqE3 ru3mud o1 ovsrl 01 bou isdi oini

orb is1uoiiiisq nI .OQ I bnis O8Q I OV I OQ I ni aboi odi iol boviodo od n £nomonorlq orb oms oriT

orli moil inoiollib -iov i OQI ni nb1nsi orli isuli &isom ii1T .zinolonom ion bnn isfl oliup i Oc?(?I iol onE

i0g1E1 orli rliiw 0i13i orET .OIQ I in 03fUH1EV 0111 flEili l011Eff1 i OQ I flu 03ft1311EV odi bns OQQ I ni ruiAni3l

1o 2lfluJoms isoE oiLI riliw 3IR12 OILI 31111w 'OiOT. WOM ban iu3iioonruoJ 4iour1osj3M 310W OI ni aboi

.sioAsU diuo ban srisAiA iqqikiM 513W OQI flu !nhiqs3 rismijri

.1If$OffI Ofb 01 02510l Isnqs3 risrnurf lo 0lU2E3ffl mo 113111w is booq orli os'1siijs 01 ruioioini 2i II

oIqms olorlw orb O1J OW 11011W 33fi310VflO3 lo booq boismui2o oriT .i1uoi orb lo omo thoqol OIdBT

1o booq2 boinmi1o odi nsrli mor1ir1 i oonoiovno 1o booq idi isdi oloM .( I OO.O=.o.) 8f0.O i boi-ioq

-i-s1s ban orma olqmsxo iol oo) iso ioq ino3loq ol oo13 i doidw siiqs3 moq omo3ni 1o oriomovno

odi ni oJEm diwoi inoupo2du2 orb ban lovol 1iiini odi noowiod noilsiom ovilEgoru rtbIiii oriT .(.[QQI] riii-uM

.8 oiuiI ni boisi3omqqs od o1E 1153 Isiiqs3 nismuri lo )I30i

Page 29: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

GXbJ1uioLJ 1OL pJ pip bcq 01; COUAGLGUCG01; COflLG qic GX!fGIJCG 01; Gwboun.A wGntwci cuo u pc pnwu cbwj c!wG conjq pG

PGIMGGU TXO Jq JO D!bGL10U iUCLG1Cq qflLiU JJG TÔ802 JJJX2 !UCLGG !U qibcL2ou O1;CIJ

qi qnuu qiG to uq j qibcL2iou iuciccq iii wc i ôQO jpc bLocG o1; COIJAGLGUCG nwcq

pu pc qithGLiou 111 ii dni c: pc wuqq qcAiiou o tpc jo 01; H /1 ØO V1;fGL i quJwuic

h!nLc o fG pGp1AiOL o qJG qthcLJou 01; fG roc o pnuiiu cbtq OAGL 11WG MG U0G

bctouq iucoui oi. io tc bwqncr13

on ipi bcGq ! npu1jA JGL prn jpc bGGq 01; COUAGLGUCG o C0UAGUP0UJj WGflLG onbrr ncp

LG41JCLG o jrnc pc wc CO CJGUt JJJGpuicqbcq oo' (G=ooo) jj juc G1Ju o boiuj

jjic LOM o1; jpjc LcboI4 pG ciuirq bccq oj COuAGLGUCC MGU npbG4oq LG

cxbjnucq pA fG GIJOLWOfl JUCLGG lu pc ocjc o1; pnurnu cbij u woI.pcr --uq G2bGciJ1A J4CM

GCOUOUJIC OGLAGI2 fAG 11GfG flif1 PGIJfA!OL 01; fG fUG GCOUOWJG qnuu tuG !8O CJU pG

CJUU0 pG 0JGJA GxbJ1iuGq pA tJJG J4OLtJJGtGLU GXbGLICLJCG (tJJ! i GbGC!JJA IIJtGLGtIU GCJf1G r jot oi

mi cxt12oLqIuJLA BiCLG9G qnuu tpc I ô8O tG tOLA pcjuq tpG JJCjC 01; COUAGLG1JCG qnuu JJJ &WG bcuoq

opAi0fl P' OtJJGL M0L2 GAGLJ tJJOfljJ ! ILTIG tPU tPG OCj 01; pnuJu crbij JU tJJG M0LtPG2t GxbGucucGq

Uj0 2GG JU fG EIf1LG GAGU 11; MG PtUJCt 1;LOLU tJJG MOL PG2tGLU 2fJfG pG UGtIAG LG1tjOU I 1;91. 1;LOUJ

LUfG qnLJU tpc jgj qcthitc tjic rct ipu fG coLLcbouqiu 2tOCj(2 lu MGLG UO Wjj flOMGAGL MG

o1.qJG ( JCfl2Gff C0IJIJGCt!Cflt GM GL2GA #i.Aiuq ruq MGM A0L1() GXbGLIGUCG IIJG 1iLt LOMfP

pc jo ibbLccJrtGq w jirac MG UOIG iu pi hIf1LG fp tpG ocjc o pnwm cbiwj 1;OL qic ttc iii tpc

(G=ooJo)] IPG U0LGJU!0U PGtMGGU L0Mf Jq pG 1Jf1J t0CJ( 01; pnwrn CbWj qrruu qJG jgç

MG UOfG tP&t tIJG bL0CG2 01; COIJAGLGUCG pjtcq qflLiu 1]JG [we ctiuJtcq thccq oyj

[ooJi (2G ffoJx)] jpc jJLG 2bGGq O1;COUAGLGUCG 0GLAG iu OIIL &wbjc OCCfIL2 Hi qiG [oiiOOt4Q (c=ooo) iii lpG tpc bccq 01; C0UAGLGL1CG ¶JCjJCACCj LGJfl1AG1A JOM Aj11C IU we JôO2

qcrqc V1;tGL fMO qecqc 01; 1LG beeq 01; C0LJAQLGUCG [=y(j (=ooo) 1;OL ipe jto iuq =

JpG LGt 01; tJJG L0M 01; JpG ?flGt tIflJI qJG bccq 01; C0UAGLGUCG p M 1;fl 1;LOW COU2WUI ICL02

Page 30: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

ol niioio1ni i 11 .mo' nioM oth rrhub b5nuxo tbidw s1iliJponi orno3rli ff1 ooini otli illiw boko13

o1 01 oiuiI .gni1oorf3 lo iio' ogtnovi odi lo ioiv&fod oi11 riliw 1J1iqi3 nimuii lo loivi3rIod offi oll3qmo3

noH .1113ino1onom 11i1 ii lEdi oiioM .omii ovo ni1oor1o lo OE1OVE odi lo noiioqib oth wod

.i1uoi nib1331im 1o ol bnoi Iliw 1IiiqJ3 nEmufi iol xoiq i u ni1oof13 ou oriw iod tEOO1 i

rn Vizü *n'"1

odi ni bodiiob nood ov&1 Jir1i oiuom orb 1k iol i1i1ii lo 1Emmu2 i 1nooiq ow 1 xibnoqqA iii

orb b noiiximinim 0111 01 bnoqorIo3 i&11 omom i 3d3) oiUaom kmilqo lo mi1o Dioqoi oW .ioqiq

omo ol bnoq311o3 rl3irlw) oiuom li3milqo-non bns (3o lrtilinu orb lo oq-du omo iovo noii3nlJl 3o iol ho iuo ow nofiw oii3mi1o h3miiqo odi iobinoz ow oiuom thmiiqo orb nomA .(iiioth 3o11-bE \i& 0 rw \io :ao gniwollol off) iii noiis1ugiTho3

iv iol oU$mi1o 0113 hoqoi ow borI1om lumiiqo-rion odi riomA bnu 0 -u Q

oitjom -X-iocX orb noiJ3niñ rioibuboiq w orli lo noilimi1o 11c1 v( io1\ orb bru3 [QI] ni11EM-i-131s bni nii1IuM lo

ol rb1o1qqE lEmilqo ni odi 0U 01 1nw ono ii 1iiI .xibnoqqE orb mrnl ont 20E0ffl 3iEd ooufF

orb nhEqmo3 'd idi oo ru oW .Ioi1Em nriobio l3Exo orb iodmun xobni 1Enoil3o-oI3 nu1uqrno3

01 oio1oio11i inithoqmi i II 2T0 orb O1U2E3rn 1od mo 1111w gniiobio auohrw off) niu oflsmiio IEmIiqo

bod1om Ismilqo-non ou ol 2obi3ob ono 11 bno3o .ioiio bol3oqxo off) nis.icn1n1m d obio 1&niiqo orb bnib

moldoiq iodmun xobrii 1E3il3I3 orb i idT .boiqobs borliom 0111 1111w VIEV '1Juoi 111w o1Emu1o ono norli

11$dl i noo1 biirb odT iodmun xobni ovilsmoils nornE o200fl3 ow ob woil :[V81] iiowoiU d bociiiob

2olE12 olli oi 2oxobni liiiiqED nEmurl lo fIO!13J1i2no3 orb Eonisn) ioqEq 21111 lo noi1f3i1qqE lElu3iilf3q ofli iol

Iurnilqo -tuo 01 11311mi2 iov niod qu thno 132 ui orb d boiovilob 23fl3m112o lo 132 oil) (2o1Ei bolirtU of) lo

rIuorio boos iovilob ldim 21s12 hEos iii 2oimono3o lo riwobLBold orb lurli o1dioq Iov i ii oDr1oH .oiuom

lnomolqmi ol 1012E0 fbum i mo12v 1Ei orb o2uE3od nu12oo1ni 21 11u201 2ifIT .2noilE3ilqqE iorfio th 2olErr 123

boo1qmo ono 0111 21 goLobod1om 1E1 orb Isril fLiEE iodrnomoi) niim2o1u gnhlovElT 1ii1qrnooD ofli nuril

8

Page 31: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

1ir11 i ir1i 1Ii lo u1Ioio A (.oxobni qUO 1o i&niio (IinuoD-22o13 iir1J 31n5!3 01 no1oH bnl$ iommti d ui2 oifi d bo1ionog iJ3miiao iodmnn xobni ofil noiil o1$d 10 ii ¶11 nbbiq 1i boo i n13i31 lofnono3o oth 11

.bnd ool ocJ Ion im bodiorn

V1OIJJDY1OD

oth iol 23xobni Ifthqs3 nEmufi lo to LIEb Ioni$q j 10 noJi3Lrli2no3 orli i ioqq 2irli lo 1iog niim ouT

lol o1ubo3o1q inoiollib LIfIi12 luril bull oW .OQQI ol O4I bonoq oth ml o1i1 bolinU orIl b 1E12

ooqoiq ow lEfil r1oo1 21111 iol 2111 .2lodmun lo 2102 inoiolIib viov b1oi' 2oxobni IEtiq& nnmurl gnii3JrIi2no3

niAnir11 12i2o1 fnE3 ow 212imono3o 2A .2lodmun xobni lo quoi i lo noii3oIo2 orII iol o1obodiom won £

01 i (lollEm 1idi iol o1i1 ni niftI'nE ob 01 'w i2od oriI io) 2lodmun xobni oiEmujeo 01 'Ew I2od oril 1irt1

lo noiiE1ui1no3 limilqo oril ooorb 01 iobio ni lud niErb Ei2iviU n ou ol ooqoiq ow onoH .oimi1qo

od ni Eilolh3 lEd) wod wofI2 bnJ3 10110 no2hBqmo li$lolsIid boi3oqxo 3111 osiminim ol Aoo2 ow oimono3o

odi 113111w iovo Q 102 Anhlinu orli noi1InugitnoD1o 102£ ooqoiq oW .2oIdIwIo2dolo noiI3nhil £ boluqmo3

.bosiminim bluorI2 noth3

.bnuol od ionns3 moldoiq noiiEsiminuln 1UO 01 2noiIuLo2 l3Exo o1onf13ol loluqfno3 InomJ3 odi riliW

woloci () rroiI3o .moldoiq odi ol noiltJlo2 £ ni1Emixo1qqE iol mthu1o1E oEdi2sol E ooqoiq ow iovowoH

xobni b02u 1nommo3 noqu ovoiqmi I1i$iinJs12du2 ni ow noiIuIo2 iuo lo 22onID1xom odi oliq2ob flrLt 2work

.2oioiE112 iodmuri

22013E bsflqEo nEmufi lo A3o12 311110 2311$mil2o IEmiiqo orli lu ovrru ow o1obor11orn won 2111) nr2U

.211u2o1 ni1231oini omo 212ou2 231sm1123 023111 lo 2i2'b3n13 113311!qmo mO .2o1E1 bolinU o111 lo 231E12 odi

fliI00d32 lo 2ThO OE13VE off) 2E 1biqE1 2E 031w1 woig IEIiqEo nErnurl lo A3o12 of) lErli bnll ow o1qrna3xo ioI

o2IE oW (.oluIEloIiI dlwoig won orE) ni IEIIqEO nEInhid iol xomq boog £ od 01 no11 'CllEu2u 21 lEd) omuom odi)

2irIT O8 I orli gnimub bo2soioni 2o1si bolinU ortJ 22013E IE)iqEo ifErnild lo bo12 od) lo noi2loq2ib oth lull) bnil

OffIE2 oull gnnub bo2Eol3ob gnhLoofI32 lo 2iE0 3E13VE orli 1o noi2moq2ib orli o2uE3od gnibnil gnil2omolni nu 21

IEnqE3 nEmurl lo bo12 orfilo oIEmiJ2o odi E gulf oodo2 lo iuo 3E13VE oil) 1II2U I2imono3o 116 o3rIoH .bohoq

Page 32: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

iUqcXc 1;OL J bucj 01; COfluJLIG ID pG flG E1JOU MIrp IJJG 211WWG12 iuq HG10U qWJ GV

Ui 011L LGG1LC rcuq i 0 I1G IpG 0bfJUJf1 mcipoqooA bLoboGq iii pi bbcL 1o coui.nc pnw,u cibiiij

CLG1;f111A IpGU 1G UJGX UI1IJJGL GJWG GUGLG pA pc WL wcfpoq wA U01 pc 00 prq JJJG UGXI cb

WG2flLC uiq IJG 21R. wcqioq 1LG AGLA iwiji. MJJICp nGf rpu 11; ouc bicja fC tui. (oL pc) ccouomA

GXbGcIDq GLL0L H0MGAGL 1;OL IJJG fUG 01; JJG flUJGq UG JJG fCfl1 GUUJG2 qGIIAGLGq pA IpG obimq

WfIIJpJIGLIJ cowbcuou2 01; 0Db fCL022 C0flULJG MU AGIA coqA iii 11JG 2GUG 01; CUGL!IJ }JJJ f1W 01;

MG KLAI 2. ncq pA fIWWG12 niq flCf0U [Jfl fo CLGUG

bLocG 01; pnuiu cibiuij rccnwnjiiow

uiA mLouJA coucjnqc ipr pG WCLGG iii HJCOIJJG wcdnpfA occriq qf1LU qiG j pq U0fUJ o qo iqi

Page 33: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

9x9buI hiiqsD wmuH nutuqmoD to 3oD :1 9IdtIT

2H5IUAa1V1 JAMFNO :(A) JIT4A

TD oi .b51 ioD joD-obu3q i I O.P1 nm31i2 niIovinT li33idqino3D

E.4 1 .

1 nma1E nu13vlT IE-Ioqmi131nI

8011

OVV4 (1Iiiqu i OV){O) iiiioqu2

?5ITJAM JAMrPIO-MOM :(8) J3VIAq

TD oi .b$I joD-oub3q

Oe.41 OO.QVEQ (E1vA) m3' O I V 00.0088144 (B13vA) fnt 1Ei13qu

OO2EVV niIoorI3 lo uY g1$1vA 04 I

OI.VVt 00.QOàôII li3iidJdqIA

:1 31dIT oi oioM

(ibn owi 3mii niIood lo Lov31 xi) ahois3 I irIT (I)

IEcniiqo-noi4 .i in13v1 di ivo noij3nul io 3rIi nisiminim d boi3tnino3 ii rndmun li3miiqO () .noiiiiminim on 3vlovrn noii3nul

12o .(1iBup InuI rIz niidiow) noiiinuflno lo Ariil do lo io3 di lo mu 3Iqmi Ii i i2o3-obu3q (E)

M\(I-M) ioi1 3r11 d ioThb owl di (M)Q i 3111 iol .10113 noruqmo i13iEIid b31nup 1$13vi 3111

Page 34: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

iwY d TJ lo noitkoqmo3U oD-obu9q : 9IdRT

joD-obuq

oi O1.84 OQ1

OQ OQI

O.88E OVQI

O.QE 08Q1

OQI

joD-objjq aLniJ 1inoqmoJ-inI

0100.0 0Aq-04AM

00.0 0M-0FI 00.0 OVAJ-0FI

El 10.0 08JA-OVAD

VQ0.0 OQXT-O8AD

JATOT

Page 35: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

OJTQ -0J30 -O0T 0055 000Q 0013-oix -ou -oo -oo -oos -oootOffljJ -0305 -o53 -0J33 -00o 00cf3 -OOJQ

MOLP O1 -0TQ3 -OJ0 0O 0034 0'050

ff088 003 0O3 if 0tQ ff033 003nW -oso -oJ -O.0ô -00Qf -ff038 (1000

t8 MA -01Jô -0•J30 -004ô -0I0 000J 001QMI -OSOQ -OTQX -OJOQ -oo:i -0'03ô -000

4Q fAA -(1533 -050 -00ôX -00ô3 -0•04J -0030MV -008 -0T53 -0038 00U -000'zt 003

44 AV -0380 -0Jô -(1118 -00Q 001Q (105843 Ad. -0J8 -0U0 -010J -00ô8 0•038 -0003s i-a -oos 00ô8 0030 (1043 0•ø0ô (103041 .LX -0•J4 -0Tô -0•0 -0080 005 000840 LI'1 -(1 5 -0531 -01Q5 -013X -0'01 -0053ô D -(1305 -OUQ -0J33 -005 -(1043 -0•03ô38 2C 040Q -00Q 0'J80 0Jt -0•03 -00333X I�I -0333 -0J5 0138 -0•153 -00t\ -0•003 bY -030 -01Q.X 0103 -0•083 -003Q 000Q32 OI� -0104 -0144 -003 -0•00 0004 00J434 OK -0JJ -OJQO 0•02 0•OQO 001Q 001333 OH -0U3 -OUJ 0•08 00XQ -005Q -000433 1.4D -053Q -0J -015Q 0•05 003Q -001Q31 MC -0331 -05 -OJQ8 -013X -0•00 -003030 MA -0184 -0•U5 -00X 0044 00J0 (10315 L.41A1 05U -0•JQ -(1044 -0051 -00Jô (105158 1.41 -(1510 -0U3 0J00 -00J -000 0'033 ME! -018 -OJQS -(1113 -00ô1 -(1043 000QSQ MA -008 -O1QO -0•08 00QT -005 00315 ME -0•T4 -0U0 -0•OQÔ 005 -001 00054 lAid. -(1158 -(1100 -00ô 0•04Q -(1008 001353 lAb -0551 01Q8 -010à -00U 004J -(101155 LAI -0431 -(1335 -01X8 -0•114 -00Q -00351 LAIM -(1188 -01Q -0083 -000 0055 00IQ50 LAII -O1QS -0•14 -003 -0•0H 0050 -(10041 1/bY -0•1X4 -0J4ô 0•0 -0•04 0001 00318 1/ID -0•345 -0T -0•0ô 0080 0011 00i1. IALE -010 -(1181 -ff103 008Q 003 (1001IQ ['V -03 00 -0141 -00ô 003Q -00WU KA 030ô -055ô -0•J4ô -0118 -00Q -003ô14 1(2 -OJSQ -0153 -(1048 (lOLl 0053 (101813 IV -0•J -0J4 -008Q 0008 004Q -00113 1W -0•JQI -0148 -00ô3 -0083 -004ô -00111 IF' -010 -0T5 -004 -00XQ 0055 (105310 ID -01(11 -0131 -0•0J 0•0X5 0003 -00L1

OV -0388 0580 -O1QQ -0113 -005 -(10118 LI' -050 -OJQ3 -01(11 00Q -003l -00T0l DE -030Q -01Q4 -(1 0ô0 -0•0 0005 -000QQ Cl -0301 -0U8 -0101 004 0005 003CO 01J -0138 -0040 003Q (1003 003X4 CV -00ô0 0133 -0•00 003J 0000 (10333 YK 0343 -0•3ô0 -0U1 -O1LI 0OQ8 -00415 V -0U1 -0130 -00lQ 003 00JJ 0014I VI' -030 -05X0 -0U1 -00ô8 0•00 -0018

WLV..LE 1ô40 Jô0 JÔQO 1ôi0 1ô80

J)P16 : HIIWUU CbWJJ p? iuq AGJL

Page 36: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

mY d nb1n&L :4 9IdRT

OQQI 08Q1 OVQI Oô1 0Q1 0Q1 AM TU TM TU TU TIJ

TD OD TU AW TM VT4 WI AM OD OD YW AD OD YW 2)1 MM A AW (EM <-AD AW 2)1 AW 510 AD TD VIM YW 2)1 (II YM (IT Al AD (H OD V AV 3(1 OM (II AD YW 8 AW 510 MM 510 OD 2)1 Q

JI AW (WI TM 510 TM 01 MM T.VI <-AD 3M MI 3M 11 TU TM A )10 IM A 2)1 YM YVI A AM HO El

MM GM TD VIM Al Al 11 YW A AM VM 3M MI 510 )10 $10 Al HO IM

AV LVI HO ii <-AM VI TM MM )IO 30 YM YM 81 3M 3M VT4 MI LVI VIM

XT<- IM AV IM GM TV 0 Aq MM J9 dl (12 dl H14 dl IM AM TD 3M ElM 2)1 (12 YM XT NO TV XT (H VW NO XT HO HO 3(1 XT VVI HM IM VVI HO GM HM (12 151 Ad JI LVI <J9 Aq

3(1 GM GM TV 3(1 1W 8 1W A<- XT TD MM 3(1 J'1 JT Aq Aq MM TD OE

OM 3M VII ElM 1W LVI AD TV 1W 1W A<- MM NO 1W 3M <-J1 OM OM Ad YW HM OM TV VW 4E (TM OM 3M HM 151 (WI (II (12 VW AV AV IS!

JA HM AJ<— (12 GM GM VII Al JA GM 3M dl 8E Al 151 TV 151 VW AV

MT VII YW Ad YN MT 0 VW JA AD YN MT YN ft DVI AD 2M dA Ad DT'I VM MT MA MA JA MA D2 2M 1>1 MT DVI Ad 1)1 MA 151 AD AD AD (12 YN MT DVI MA JA MA DVI DVI 2M<- D2 D2 2M D2 D2 D2 2M 2M 81

Page 37: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

(ooot)jcucgcq o.o

(ooii) [000w]180-Jô0 0.00ô (103

(oojx) [ooou]10-Jo80 0118 0..\8

(ooJ) [ooo5]JQ0-]0 (1015 ff03

(ooo8) [oooio]J0-JQ0 004 05

(oooQ) [ooosolIt0-J0 0.08 080

(ooo) [oooot11t0-10 0.0ô 0ô5

(2) ['c]buOq b

UJPIG: COUA6L6UC6 °L HHWJU CbPi

Page 38: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

iu9IVi uoiisV 9fIt b itinA 19nfl A :1 XIUj'aqqA

bni thodi3m iohv orli niu 1Eikq nmuñ niiimii 1o iIu2o1 oili mqmo w xibn3qq ifti nI

.31u3m niwoILo1 1i rIoq3l 3W .loqEq Ii iuorIuoidi b3di13b J32

.(ixoi 3di ni bnl$ noiio ni b3dil32ob) i rmmo1i ni13vJ$1T I&ñdqno3D orli vo ioD muminiM (I)

.31u3m 31i10v131 1U0 2i if1i 1x3i Ofli ft b32U3ib th .TD b311& i iuam iriT

.(ix3i odi iii bni 4 noiiz b3cJi1323b) i nm1i niIovniT tEloqm3il3inI 3iIt ivo ioD muminiM () .2T1 b311& ! 31UL3ffl 1f1T

.MAT2 b31ID .(lxoi odi ni bnE 2noi133 ni b3dh33b) i mi 3d1 l3vo ioD muminiM () .$IAT5IdqU b3IIED .(1x31 3f11 lii bn noii3 ni b3dh3b) 13 1kiwI3qu 3f11 13V0 ioD muminiM ()

.(VA) 5IAT b31liD .(ix3i f1i ni E f!Oii33 ni b3dh3b) ini lJ3rnhiqO noi4 () .(VA) sIaqU b3LIiD .(ixoi o1i iii E no!i3 ni b3du13b) m3i 11i13qIJ 1miJqO-noM ()

.(ix3i orli ni I n011332 ni b3di13ob) 2ifI3i3ifl3oD noii3auI noiiuboiq o1nitT lo 3iJrnIJ3 n0i3135I (V)

.DOJkIA5I1' b311u3 2i 31U?i3ffl 1f{T

dflw 231UJ33ITI fl3V3 323f11 31BfflO3 3W

lond £) [1QQIJ nui1uM-i-BI bn nsi1IuM d b3tIoq3l 3Th23f1 i1iiqn3 nl3mud b3asH-omo3nI-loth3J (8)

.811 51Ua135111 tf1i 11133 sW .(noiluboiini sf11 ni ii3qq boiliom 2i111 lo nonqn3ob

.JOOHD ii 11ii 3W .niloor13 lo 1B3Y SJ313VA () oiBi rbJ$s iol 1131iq133 nsmud lo oi13muio sill lo rk&s iloqol ion ob SW 33E no osimonos 01 isbio iii

.3iiii1$i '(u1mrnu f1i15I3ifli srno rloqSl OW bE3iflI .2311J?i33fn srli lo dzo 101 1133\ bni$

113133 ol gnibioxii sis•iovis .

.U sill lo loivEllOd sill 2rIoqsl I o1diT xibnoqqA lo lonf$q owl iiiI silT

Isnnq bno33 silT .3ldEnuv sill lo lovol (sill lo mrllimgol) sill iioqsi Isnuq iifl siff 231Ui33ffl 3(1111 sill lo

boiisq sIqmE2 Iliriovo sill iol 31131 ittwoi Sf11 bni 3b1333b i13s 101 31131 rtiwoig If3unn13 sgsisvo 3111 lioq3i

1.O 01 so1o 'is'i i bohsq oIqms2 llnisvo 3111 13V0 31131 iftwoi In ff11111 3E13VE Sf11 lilfIl olon sW .OQQ I -OQ I

TI TD ol gniblo33n olin f1lwo1 sJno1n sill i inriT .sxobrn niiviG gnivlovni oiuom 1113 iol lfls3lsq

Page 39: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

nimud Io iin diwo li3unnl$ dT .is1imi v i (VA) 5IAT5IN1J brm (VA) SIAT2 5IAT$I3J1J 5LAT

iriv w ii woi 31uIffl ELIJ 3dT .in&il3q i noi1Emii DOJ4AMT 331ib r1i oi nib1o33B 1Enqfo

ioq in313q 8.0 i niJOOHD lo uY ivA th 10 oiii r1iwoi oili 3lirlw in3iq . I to fli onoI lodE! is binU 3di lo nh1ood3 to 2IsY 3g13vA 3rli f1uor1i nvo Jith ion w 33n3H

08 to osini 1li13vo its iEqmi ibiriw) '(ru1n s Ilsit lo IU03 3111 13V0 is q 1n3313q 8.0 lB bil3ni

OI lo 3asoloni Eliiovo its iIqmi 113111w) 1n3313q 1.0 Lno lo 31131 13 Ji b13ni !i$1iqi ru3murl (iniq (.1n3313q

313(11 1&1J olon oW .obB3ob d 3biob 231JJ2S3 orli lo ibso lo olin d1woi odi 2floqol oth o1diT oriT

.omii iovo ovsilod aoIdEiuv 2uohlw odi w odi iii 2&noloThb !i3iin112du2 5U3

lo noill$ivob bubnEi2 I13noil3o-ol3 oth lo roivBd3d odi wod I o!diT xibnoqqAlo Ionl3q biidi odT

311312 84 odi lo noilBivob b1i3bn1l 3(11 1133' fbEO ioI 2r1oq5I Ionsq 2ifIt 2! lisdi) ofilil 1OVO 251tJ2133ffi odi lo r133

i noi2loq2ib lo oiuom orli ot ni bolu2Bom II oi 2oIdfthisv mo ouisoH (.oiuisom (13133 iol 23J13m!123

.o1d13i113v odi lo 2!ovol oth ni 2on13d3 !isnoiiioqolq 01 Inirniwni i ii Jir11 ni noJEnBv lo irloi3iflooD odi 01 lJ3IiIni2

Aoo1 ow II .oiuisom 01 oiuisom molt Jo! is ohsv ioivisdod orIi iisrIi i Ioriisq 2iffi Juodis lnioq lnsrioqmi ouT

JOOHD iBr(i oo ow 08Q I oril niiub noiI3q2ib lo ioivisdod 3111 Io noil3ib5lq 3111 Is oIqm13x3 ioI

biup is ismrnu a! .oioini as liboiq 231U2E3 orli lo ioi rIT .onibob B iiboiq TI bns DOJI'LMIT

2loIIsm ii isdi 21 OU2 2O1U2EO Isliq& nscnud odi 1li3 ioI ou!sV ohs is .2.U odi lo loiVElfod ouU is AooI

.3211 OW 31U2BO (131(1W Jot £

bo131312 21 modi lo ono do noriw oiuaisom onin LIE lo noiIEI5rIo3-o13 3111 Jioqoi oIdiT xibnoqqA

ovodis) iiir1 13v ois 2noilEIollo3 3111 hull i oldish 21(11 fliodis lnioq inisnoqm oriT .loiov nmulo3 ogisi ono no

nOuis!5r1o3 ouT .HIJ has TI 0111 ois 2noiJqooxo oIdi22oq owl orfF (.aolu2som Its l2omIs ioI lno3loq OQ

1oi odl bas Ut! noowiod 2noiiisbnoo odT .o21S3 this ni Q0 woloci 21 231UEO odi lo ioi ouli bits TI rioowloci

.(Iooiio) .0 bits (TI) E.0 molt onin odl bits 1o!113m2 ibum 21 ohdsiiiu', odi 10

oliup 21 2noIlsIoTloD 10 nloilEq odT .obs3ob d 2noiisblio3-22o13 oull 2o2oqmoob oldisT xibnoqqA

Io lodmun 3(11 bno3oa .wol oliup 3113 flU bns TI niv1ovni 2noilisIollo3-22o13 3111 321iI .gnii2ololni

Page 40: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

b1oi iuim 1li dguodl novo 2b1ow 18db nI .3miI iovo 1L1 oi cno2 OQO 3vodE inoi3i11oo3 noiIi131io3

rhifiw lol i wiollEm ii n3H .OQ(I io 08Q1 iol 31n1 Ion i dl OI io1 xobni Ln1fqf3 nnmurf iilimi i ni QO moil 11r1 JOOHD2 bnl$ TO iunm othoviil iuo nwl3d noilnbiio3 3dT .oofb 3w

.OQ1 ni 8.O 01 qu Ad Ii n3111 bni OVQI iii 8.O wol i ol OQ1

dbiw 3lInoi13l8b iuioni dJ b bi 3111 bnn oldsrmv DOJMA5IT orli noowloci noiJEI5noD ofli brir1T

orlT .oIdEi1nv omo io1 oiox ol 3o1D viov oi OQQI brin 08Q1 iol no1IB1oTIo3 r1I 1EIu3iriq nI .omhI

..O :wol iov o1n i OQ(?I iol JOOHD bni OOJ2T4A5IT noowlod noiif13TIoD

bnE 5IAT5I3U) nFiobio 5IAT5IU anivlovni oiurom owl 3111 1J3' iobiE oril o1 4fluo9

.oLdsru3v orli 10 ioi odi duiw bobsIono3 Liooq oin ((VA) AT5INU

o!dioq Ino orlT 1Ii io1 TD riliw bolfdollo3 '1ov i noilJ31uflno3 inl b3miiqO ofli llRniq

32013 2i noilsfoTlo3 odl ino' odi lo 1231 orIb ioI .E8.O i noi111o11o3 o2orIw 0VQI odl od 01 moo noibqo3xo

.Q0 01 ovodE 10

ino nol 3111 iovo bolnmii2o 2oId1thiv orb lo rI3Io iol 2noill3loTI030ius orb 2wofk oldnT xibnoqqA

lo WIE3' og1ov orb lol noiInIoTio3oluE orb lEril 21 olon ol nir1l 12111 ofIT .l3lnb ov&1 ow fbidw iol 2boiloq

novo o1qmEx3 ioI .OIEm!I2o 131110 'flB iol oinl Ion 2! 2irIT .2obE3ob HE ioI Q0 ovodn 10 32013 2! ni[oor132

noilf$IoTlo3 oriT .obl3Dob 12111 odb ni Q0 ovodn 1no 21 Ii on1 oliup 21 TO iol noiIJ1oTIo3obuE odl duor1i

boiioq o1qmn orb lo obn3ob I2n1 oril iii briE 40 2111 08Q1 bni OVQI noowlod $8.0 21 OVQI bns 0QI noowbod

.QQ.0 bns OIOS noowiod onni 231Ji2EOffl iodlo odI LIE iol 2noiIEI5no3oflJE oriT .21 Ii

231112130ff! 2UOflEV odi i&ii 21 201U2E3ffl 2UOfUW orb lo 2i2'IJ3n1s Inornqmo 21111 moil noi2uI3no3 odT

2! noiI131uf1no3 Lsmilqo odi gnibnil IEdi briE Irio1o11ib VIOV oii ioqq orli Iuorlguoirll bodh32ob bnn bo2oqolq

.loqllq 2i111 ni ob 01 bolqmons ow 11311w 21 21111 briA .in13lloqfni

8

Page 41: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

suiA ..U to IoivRlI9fl :1 9IdRT xibn9qqA

.91ut3II uohiV MIt ot nibioA

OQQI 08Q1 OVQI 0f OQ1 O11 oJ 000.0 80.0- 4O.0- QQO.0- V1.O- Q0.0- TD 11.O- QàO.0- 811.0- O1.0- Q1.O- VQ.O- TI ô0O.O 0.0- 00.O- 40.0- Q1.0- 181.0- $IAT 0.0 .E0.0 810.0- 0.0- 101.0- V1.O- 5IAT25I3 .PO0.0 O.0- 0.O- QVO.0- 1.0- O.0- (VA)5IAT

010.0- 110.0- E0.O- Q0.0- 880.0- &1.0- (VA)5I32 NO.0 1.0- V.o- 1V.o- OQV.0- OQQO- OOJ2VIA5IT

1V8.E .E V8.E 8E.E IOV.E ifU JOOHD2

0Q-01.Q1 OQ-08Q1 08-OVQI 0V-0Q1 0ô-0Q1 0-011 ij51 thwoiO

00.0 Q00.0 00.0 00.0 V00.0 400.0 TO E00.0 Q400.0- 00.0 000.0 V00.0 010.0 2T1

V00.0 Q00.0 V00.0 000.0 ô00.0 00.0 MATE

Q400.0 100.0 00.0 100.0 Q.00.0 8V00.0 $IAT25I32 1400.0 00.0 FA00.0 U00.0 4V00.0 Q400.0 (VA)5IAT

O0.0 1000.0 00.0 100.0 00.0 00.0 (VA)5I3 100.0 VMO.0 V10.0 10.0 000.0 DOJMA51T

810.0 Q00.0 00.0- 00.0 81F0.0- fflJ 800.0 F.'.400.0 1010.0 à00.0 Q010.0 IQOO.0 JOOHD

0Q1 08Q1 OVQI 0ô1 0Q1 0.1Q1 .vUi 0.0 0.0 0.0 Q0.0 0.0 880.0 TO 0.0 010.0 810.0 80.0 V80.0 4Q0.0 TI 0.0 00.0 0.0 tEO.0 t0.0 QVO.0 5IAT 40.0 0.0 E0.0 040.0 0.0 001.0 MAT5I3R 10.0 00.0 V0.0 E0.0 R0.0 180.0 (VA)5IAT

&0.0 V10.0 0.0 t0.0 0.0 880.0 (VA)5I3 01.0 1E1.0 01.0 VI.0 t81.0 DOJV1A51T

88.0 M.0 flIJ 0.0 0.0 00.0 0.0 0.0 Ff11.0 JOOHD

Page 42: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

(9Idth1fV b3A3st) noisInioD-oiD : 9IdfT xibn3qqA

JOOHD HTJ ?1A$IT $I31U 5IAT 5IdqTJ 5IAT TI TD DOJ (vA) (vii) 5IAT

VQ.0 1.0 tQ0 OQO 8Q0 Q0 8Q0 8.0 00.1 TOAH

8.0 VE.0 àV.O V8.O V8.O 48.O à8.0 00.1 TDIH óQ.0 0ô.O QO Q0 00.1 Q.O 00.1 IM5IT)IH

14

QO 0.O fQ0 Q.0 8Q0 00.1 MIM2AH

VQO 1ô.O Q.O EQO 00.1 VA5ITaXH 0

ô8.0 08.0 00.1 0VA?AH

8Q0 00.1 OJ14A51T 0

ô.0 00.1 OWAH

00.1 JVAHD

04

Page 43: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

c_c%

_l-1

)-

1 C

(\-

(CiF

- C

%f-

1 C

%-1

I-

I-

%)O

i C

C

s '0

0 4C

010C

C

CtO

OO

C

1-O

O

. ' Q

IQ1O

'OIc

O

O,V

OdO

,C

141O

CO

C-

-Q-

QQ

QQ

- &

&

oooo

ocoi

c -O

/0/o

1 O

OIO

1QdC

4t

O-.

VO

1(

4.O

O

- oi

&'

r—

04-C

,-

4.

(4

0/1—

,o

o —

,O

'4

,00

oOC

ci

c (4

C

,o

o C

t.)

r.)(

4

occ-

O

CC

Q

QQ

Q—

C

CC

C

&

oo&

&&

ooc

C/O

OO

CO

CC

1OO

O

1I/O

O

L-00

00fO

0 tO

Ct—

O(.

- 0

C-4

4

JQ1O

od

)1-0

C

'.)

'00

—1c

CC

CC

QC

QQ

—Q

QQ

QQ

—.1

Q

000C

O—

0o

C1—

O/)

C

©O

4C

I--I

JOIO

/c'J

O

-(4O

ai

cioo

-C

0000

1004

.

'4

CO

CC

CC

QQ

CO

QQ

CC

CC

Q

C

C

0 0

0 0

Page 44: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

100100 OQQ

J00 OQ 0t4100 og o o100 O'ôt O4 OQ O3

100 04 Oô0 0X0 0R8 030Jt0 Jô0 JQ0 JÔX0 I8O Jà0ribcLniL (wrniuinu)

100100 08g

100 0100 O 08QToo o'gg ot o ojoo ooo og oo o.w ooJO JQO Jôi0 1ô80 1ôô0

(ujnnuinui)00

100 0•100 0O O•

100 OtT -O'JO100 0Q 03Q O0 0'100 084 OR Ofl OI O1ô'tO J0 IQO TO 180 1O

Iu.cuJboLJ ILAG1I1J100

1•00

10 0 0Q4 031•00 0•W O•8: 0•

100 o•g oe o o100 0ô3 0O OQf O3 OtIctO TÔ0 TQO JO 1ô0 JÔOQCoLbpJc JI/cJiu ijcuiuOkLWfflV'IEVflI�E

ybbGuqlx JflJG : ynro-coLLJou

Page 45: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

J •00

T00 O0100 0ô1 OQ

1•00 Oo1 0•3100 0ô. 08,X 08Q

100 oog oo ot ow oIt0 Jà0 JQO 1ô.0 J80 JÔÔO

VAGL ACL2 O1 cpoop1J100

100 0QQ100 0Q 0Q8

100 0.XJ 0.s2 OQ100 0I 041 00 00

100 O.O 00 0tQ 05 0tJO 1Q0 10 JÔ80 1ô0

rpoL-ucowc-cq HnWIJ Cb!JJ100

100 08100 08 OQQ

100 0I O8 ffQ100 O ff83 O8't ORà

100 0ô. O 083 O8Jô'f0 JÔ0 JQO J0 1ô80 JÔO.LLHJ21O JIJJ1fG

1•00 0.1 0•3100 0'.W 0100 0ô 0Q0 0J8 -001

100 04 08Q 0R5 ff08140 1ô0 1Q0 J0 1ô80 10nbcLa (&AcL)

TOO

100 08Q100 ff80 OQX

100 08't 08 0Q100 03 OX. O.X.X ffQ5

100 04 0ô0 0.X1 0t 0.XIô0 JÔQO 1ô.X0 JÔ80 1ô0

jt (uct.c)OWObLWIWI1"IEVfl{E2

ybb6uqlx ILP1G : ynO-cOLLGpJou

Page 46: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

puc bi.ou iLow LM io qGJJ-MG!p1!U flJJbJG uoiu pu MG GX1LIC1 ij bcLou FLOW '-' i oto q jc uq OIJIX rwbJGMG (LG11G 1GW ncp u OfIL cowbniou MG IO 1LGf OUL cxtwc o IPG IôfO uq jo bflIAI2

yccoLquJ io rpc CGUfl flflLGJfl IpG JØ jo iuq ioo bflI"J LG rwbjc uq

MOG npimbjc UflWGL pq i ouc qiii cdrrj 10On. jgj ruq j íj npswbjc ici.c coup.nqcq LOW w ICL rwbJG p? iquu oujA poc poncpoqi ooo IP npwb1G ti bioiiqq pA pc jncrn MJJO qcuAGq i pow IIJG!Luiuqow flp2Jwbjc2opG iri flyj pjyj wbic OL iuq J\Ø mbJG 0L

JJJG Jô'tO JO JQO bflLAI2 1fG J\JOff 10 GCOU0WiG ou cowbnjiu LGOflLCG MG MOLE MJIJJ

GC OfG CGIJfl AG912 1ô40 JO TÔO IôXO J8O 1Jq

oi (bLcric&JJA bGciu) wuqow rwb1G O LOfIIJ1A OUG Ouif O GAGLA OUG pnuqq WGI4C11J Lu

wJcLouwb1G2 iucjnqc ruouJJJ1iou ou 1G cpoopu G1UJLU2 ponL uuq MGGJC2 MOLycq uuq GWbI0AUJGIJI

AG912 21JLI1U LU Jf MG fRG qJG flpJiC flG ALcL0q bLoiuqGq pA IPG CGUfl BIILG11 JJJG

jo cowbnlc pnuiru cbij LUqGXG CL0 11G 0 fJJG flwlGq 21JfG MG flG CGUfl D1' J0L qj

VhhEWDIX : DGcL!b!oD auq O1ILCG

I óôO

1ô80 0ôQ1

I ôXO

IÔQO Oô8

I O

1to o.oo1

flIJ yq-oc rniqLapc CO EIIIJc4!011 (2) JIJ DGJ4AGq CO EIIUCOU ()

ybbGuqIz LJPIG : C0LLGPW0U P6t!1GCIJ HDWIJU C1b!I1i E!WJG

Page 47: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

10 01TJU 1G PICPG1OLI2 qGLGGopwiucq r JCGJ0L qGLGG uq t1OLJCGq 0L 1Th0 ?GJL2 0L J P!PGL GLGG OL MJJGIPGL JiG MOLJ(G 2 AGI2

flUfil If J7 IJOf CjG1L MJJGIJJGL J LG2bOIJ2G 211CJi A& oi co1JG WU2 fp pc bcL2ou

Lc2iqnq2 MJJGLG cp bGL2ou,2 LG2iqfrnj i MGiJJfGq p? fG !UAGL2C o pt ubiu bLopppt?qiG bou LGcoLq) EOL cxniibjG LLcaaroi cufGLJi 12 fo WIIJIIJJIG 1 MGiJucq 211W o IJiG 2dnaGqP fG CGUI12 BflLJfl G211UJIfC 0 {JJG IUAGL2G OGCJJ bcL2ou12 wbpu bLoppqIfA (coJnwu2 Jg-5J o

JYG j oo bflW2 i ccq? uoç & 2Gfl-Mcipfcq uibj 20 jJ o OflL couibrrfWou2 OL f&f AG91 MGIf

tc oprnucq pom 2npmb}c o 1[JG Gq cJAJpmJ JP0'- 0LCG (1p12 2np2IWbJG MijJ pG LGGG fO 2

IJiG Ac buoi. fO IJiG cGu2n2) fO pc pi 01. JJGL wnJuJ bLoqncfiAifA E2f!wfG2 o fAGLG MGGqA c&unu

MG MIJJ WJCG i MOLJCGL2 JAGLG MGGJqA GJUJ1U2 (uun GIUJJU2 quiqcq pX MGGJ(2 MO4(G pofp OL

!UqGLJLfGU 01. GAGU !1 JIG IffG1JG - pnf qrq UOf COIJJbJGIG - UL LIqc

conhJfGq f2 12G2 o u nJqiArquriJ drwjqjc2 0L on 110 2cp0oJiU cuoQ q pc I11GUG UIIL2GLA 2C00 OL

4AG12 0 2Cp00JiIJ LGGL2 fO IJJG JJJJC21 uqc cowbJGfGqJQ MrIL2CLA 2CJJOOJ ruq j(JuqcLLfGu TLG flOf

Q' COI1 L&qrnuG

J- ACL2 0C0JJGG

4 H!P 2CJJOOJ LJfl1G

J- AGL2 0JJJ1JJ 2CJJOOJ

-g AGL 0 GJGWGLJWLA 2CJJOOJ

1 04 AGL2 0J GIG WGUjL? 2CJJOOJ

0 MO 2Cp00j1U

Gq 3-Q lUfO 2GAGU 2CJJ00J!U cfcoLJG2:

FCP 2W1G2 GqflCfiouJJ ¶IffJJUWGUf qI2ILIPIUIOU 12 G2111JJf1Gq p? qiAJqiU 112 C1A1J!U I1P0L 10LCG

q1fG

0L GJCJJ 2WIG If GICP 0 IJJG 21X qiUG2 uq qJG IAGLG MGG1(j? GILIJ!U2 J0L GJCP 2CIJ00IU L0flb f GICJJ

ELOUJ IJJG WJCLO MG cowbric ipc Gq11C110U1J Iff11U1JJGUf qI2fL!pnfiOU (iwou C!AI1J1U2 &cq 5-Q)

Page 48: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

tQ

n.uiu uJbjc

GCOIJOWJC &0MIJli s bi XGJL ycq -Q CJMJ1IJ /!jJ0 V IP°' CLJGLJ j0LW OflL

JGuqrn cpoo 01. 1 OU AGLG ipcA ciuicq i JJrnJ Q qoi bci. MCC q1nGq 0L

rpc ccun2 dnctiou iii ipi i M0LGL MCLG cxcjnqcq pow fpc LUU2 wibjc !1 ip MGLC CnLLGLJqA

1J0I1L bcL ccy (lu fG AGJL o fG GUn 01. rn pc ?C1L bLioL o pc ccun qcbcuqiu ou pc OLJGUWIIOJJ 0

AGL J0L MJJ!CP GJUJHJ2 LG LGboI4Gqy Mpo iicc uo cj-cmbjoAcq rnq mjio MOLJC WOLG fpu o ni0111. GUJI1J2 2UJbjGj Gmbo7cq cuipu Mpo MOLJCG j TU fpC A1L buoL o w CGU2112 (pc

Page 49: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

JQ: j-gJQLudni F .LPc 3fUj( O 1JJuq2 C0Uflmbi!0U W4CG juqcx, boa

C0111L!2011 ØJgga o\osc boQa 5i VI1X loor2flWWCL K JU v Hcfouh JiG bGUU pjoq ipi jac : u pbmqcq 2G1 o

flLJ!AGLIfA bLG j•WG2 1MPJuJ H.a G f UC \J O\'CC C' CwpL!qG: CnJJpLqG

jg4: jg-bcpca H 1flP qic LGiGUlMiCqflU qGL I'J PL IJCP qcu HJUJPnLGL BQ0111

flujAGL!Aa OCOPGL J4nllua C iiq X 11!Ja V FPOL 1UC0UiG Bq tIG1ffLG 0t CW1aa WiJJJGOUfbp A1IG

iC2a jgi inIllua C uq x jwuwouI W LM0-2GCOL joqcj O uqocuon QLOMtp,a

jgg •FflC W E' O' IpG LAIGCIJJJ1C O ECOUOUJ!C DC I0MG1Ua OflLUJ O4 1AOUGiLA Ecouow!c 3iJQi jgj:

bcAic E 1D BGLGCPUflU GBJGL UJIUIGLGIJ f ubLCi2icuju44CWF11 JOLU bbcLi CGULI B'I O CAbLn .4OAGwpGL J3

ICALconh OGOLG V V CLo-CoflIULA f!uJJUOU O JU VLG bL0V1CU0U Lf1UCJOU MJqJ HI1WUjg:

KL1A1 lB ,1C0m UJAG fnqJG O 4POUJ IUC0WG wq bL!CGI V-'U-hJ OI!UJ!"OIJ pA iwnjq V1JuCfI!u.1 (to8Y VAi

hLGGWUa j•GAa rw uq D2 opuow 1°-L1PCLa Ia 3Y kW B°f°' HOflPfOU I!U!U

r'oucrou: /rcuJipw1 jogs: -goD!GMGLI IKE IUqGX MnuJpcL1 rn opu EThGIIa GV cq• y \J cc \DJGMGI4i IKE ,IEXJC1 iuq 2flbGLJ&JAG juqcx 4nuJpcL41 oc cuc JQ: JI-f

I.B0a I� y uq x bOa i ybLJ I ÔÔ 5

3i 3a DGCGWPGL Iô3aBLL0a if 1 &uq FGG IUCW!0U1 C0mb110U cj EqncuoU

j,AB0a K 1 COUOUJiC QLOMflJ JU CL0 GClJ0IJ O C0 IJIG2 a ccc QQa i

KGLGLGIJCG

Page 50: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

C

E!anLG j (p): Q1 4)J6 flU!I!U) 2b9C6

C B 0 V

V B D C

0 V B C

C V B D

D B C V

V B C D

BC V

C D___ BV D B

V___ D C

V C B

V C D

(toni GCOUOWIG2)

E!anLe .j (g): JuG flU!I!Uy 2bsCG

B C D V

VC

B

D

B

C B V B C

V

Page 51: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

eM

JA

AM

oee O8t over oeer

A3

w $TU

oe r

nsmeels2 griilevrnT Is3irIqs,p090 : 9lugiR

Cu

38

SA

Aq JR

TM

Tu

oee

nsmeels8 gnilevs,T Is,oqmehenI :C siugiR

C

oeeu 88

OTU 98

O8A O

O9AM

OT3 88

Page 52: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

4840

I4EO &eo

E!ãnLG 2: jpe 2flbGI29L 2X2GW

4020

bY2O

4600

hlH OH CI/ vr

hA Ci

E!anLG 4: eGoOLsbp!csI 29L 2X2GW

ciao

vr40

Page 53: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

• r0 + 0 9 v O x 90 60

-05

-0•1

• 1- 0 IN!W4 V

-0.I-058-ose-034-0•55-05

-0•1 9

-o i e-0 14-015

-0•1

-009-009-004-005

0005004

E!änLG e: HflWSU C9b1191 P1¼ CGU2fl2 bGö!OU

-04

-03

0

E!anLG : HflWSU C9b!9I VCLO 2G2 9uq QAGL .L!wG

40 20 eo 90 80

Page 54: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

EIRIILG a: couA6LGUc6 o Cb!cJ Ta8o-ao

2CK O HnWSU CSb!9I (ioay .iagO

C U

Cto

-OOOJ - - -Ca .U DE

QoiiA ____U U

o aD OK

OO04 MAU

UU

CQQoo5-

-— vu

CI)OH

Oooo3 ----_- -— 1(1 •ii vio. UMi IX U

IU — COIii Ai —

viE Ii-24IC • Ilvi VA

0) AV U

O0O2 i1l

C? -0)CI

o °°° ___ ____ —___

8 COUA6L6UC6 O H'-'' Cb!I TfO-O

-023fOCK O HI1WSU C9b!9I (1oã .16tO

0 4II I I I

CCoo0J-

90000.o I-.o.o00 _O_YYcOO0O9. —

U.,-0.o02 u-it—. iiI

KAIIi

._uuiC •AY

0)_0,00xoth ___________0009

Page 55: NEV2flKII4O VCOIEOVJE - NBER

*0

i2+

l:120005

0.0

0'O*

002

002

C.,)

009

ooa

01

011

0JE!öflLG .10: D!2bGL2!ou 01, HflWSU C9b!SI suq 2CP0OI!U QAGL JJWG