View
88
Download
8
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Nimertis Giotopoulou(Phil)
Citation preview
,
, /
-,
, /
,
, /
, 2012
2
5
: )
9
)
11
16
1
1.1. :
20
1.2. : 34
42
2
2.1. 44
2.2. 47
2.3. 49
55
3
3
3.1.1. 11 57
3.1.2 VIII 72
10610672
3.2 76
81
4
4.1. 82
4.1. , 82
123
4.2. 125
4.2.1. , 125
4.2.2. , 130
4.2.3 , 132
4.2.4. , 133
4.2.5. , 135
4.2.6. , 136
137
4.3. 138
4.3.1. , 138
4.3.2. , 173
4.3.3. , 178
4.3.4. , 181
4.3.5. , 184
4.3.6. , 185
186
4
5. , 188
210
212
1880 1930
2. 1. 218
2.1.1.
2.1.2. : 90 222
2.1.3 : 226
2.1.4 229
2.1.5 231
2.1.6 , 13 233
2.2. 235
2.3. . . 238
(400 .)
2.4. . 242
2.5. . 246
.
2.6. . 252
2.7. . 257
-
262
268
300
415
5
,
,
.1
.
,
.2
.3
,
.
,
,
1 . G. Durand, Les Structures anthropologiques de l imaginaire, 1969, 64.
2 : W. Righter, Myth and Literature, Routledge and
Paul, London, 1975 C. Lvi-Strauss, , . . ,
, , 1986 . -,
, .. (.), , . 1.
, ,1986, 241-303 .. , .
20 , , , 2004
R. Buxton, . , , , 2005.
3 . , .., .
, , 1994, 8.
6
,
(1935).
,
, ,
,
.
,
,
.
. ,
.
.
, , ,
1880
1930.
.
.
,
.
,
7
.
.
. .
.
,
. ,
. . ,
, .
.
,
. . -,
,
.
. .
.
. .
,
, ,
.
.
, .
. .
,
.
8
.
. .
,
.
,
, .
,
, . ,
,
.
,
.
.
9
)
.
.
Sabina Mazzoldi (1990)
Cassandra, la vergine e l indovina.4
: ) )
.
Dagmar Neblung, Die Gestalt der Kassandra in der antiken
Literatur (1997),5
.
(1994),6
, , . ,
Juliette
Davreux, La lgende de la prophetesse Cassandra d aprs les texts et
les monuments (1942),7
.
4 . S. Mazzoldi, Cassandra, la vergine e l'indovina: identit di un personaggio da
Omero all'Ellenismo. Filologia e critica, , 2001.
5 . D. Neblung, Die Gestalt der Kassandra in der antiken Literatur, Stuttgart, Leipzig
1997.
6 . . , , ,
, 1994.
7 . J. Davreux, La lgende de la prophtesse Cassandra d aprs les texts et les
monuments, Lige, 1942.
10
, , ,
, .
,, ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
,
.
11
)
, 8
, .9
, : )
-, ) -, ) -.
,
,
.
)
. , ,
. ,
, ,
,10
, . ,
,
.
, , ,
.
.
, .
8 . F. Spiro, Pausaniae Graeciae descriptio, , Teubner, 1903 (.
:1967), 3.26.3. , . .
9 , . P. Brunnel,
Dictionnaire des Mythes Fminins, Paris, ditions du Rocher-Jean-Paul Bertrand,
2002, 336-344.
10 . H. Erbse, Scholia Graeca in Homeri Iliadem (scholia vetera), De Gruyter,
, 1988: 44 .. . . . P. Grimal,
, University Studio Press, , 1991, 200-202.
12
,11
12 .
,13
.14
,
.
. , , ,
.
, , .15
,
.
11
.
( ),
.
. . , , 76 ' . .
, , , 10. , . .
- , . D. Matthew,
Kassandra: Mantic, Maenadic or Manic? Gender and the Nature of Prophetic
Epxerience in Ancient Greece, Essays from the AASR Conference, University of New
England, 2008, 3-4.
12 :
.
, ,
. . ., , 1.96.3.
13 ,
. . H.M. Parke, , 2000 [
Greek Oracles], . , , . , 38.
14 . , , 1202 ..
15. , , . 2, 952, 3. , . .
13
,
.16
)
,17
, .18
, .
.
, .19
.20
.21
16 ,
, 2, 247. ,
. ,
, , 2,247, . ..,
, , ( : J. Th. Kakridis, Kassandra,
Philos. Hist. Klasse, Wien 1928) , 1991, .48 , . . ,
, , 1994, 15-16.
17 , . , ,,
2,600,21 , , 923.
18 . , (, , 23, 261), , .,
1.15.2, 5.11.5, 5.19.5, 10.26.3, 10.31.2.
, . , , 12, 5, 6. , . .
19 . , , ( , 23). , .
.
20 . , .. 10.26.3.
21 . , , 12. 5. 6. , . . , . ..
, , , , 1986, 165.
14
)
.22 ,
.23
,
. ,
,
, , .
,
.24
.
,
. , , ,
.25
, ,
:
,
. , ,
.26
, ,
22 . , , 1072-1330. , . .
23 . , , 294-29. , . ..
24 . , , 360-382. , . .
, . . 1.
25 . , , 2.341.
26 . , , . 1107-1111, 1114-1118, 1125-1129, 1246-1285,
1444-1446 , , . 363-369, 404-405. , .
.
26 . , .. 2.16.6.
15
, ,
.27
28
. ,
,
.
. ,
,
.29
,
.30
27 . , .. 2.16.6.
28 . , .. 3.19.6.
29 ,
,
. ,
. . C. Belger, Agamemnon und Kassandra zu
Amykl und zu Myken, Philologische Wochenschrift 11 (1891), 1281-3, 1315-16 L.
Farnell, Greek Hero-Cults and ideas of immortality, Oxford, 1921, 329 .. B. Cohen,
The Anatomy of Cassandras Rape: Female Nudity Comes of Age in Greek Art, Source
12.2 (1993), 37-46 J. Larson, Greek Heroine Cults, Wisconsin, 1995, 11-12, 81-83,
116-121 D. Lyons, Gender and Immortality:Heroines in Ancient Greek Myth and Cult,
Princeton, 1997, 5-13, 98, 231 G. Salapata, Myth into Cult: Alexandra/Kassandra
in Lakonia, in V.B. Gorman and E. Robinson (eds), Oikistes: Studies in Constitution,
Colonies, and Military Power in the Ancient World. Offered in Honor of A. J. Graham,
Leiden, (2002c), 131-59 G. Salapata, The Heroic Cult of Agamemnon, Electra 1
(2011), 139-60, : http://electra.lis.upatras.gr.
29 . , , 10. , . .
29 APh.
30 . , , 10. , . .
16
31
A&R: Atene e Rome
AFC: Anales de Filologia Clsica
AJ: The Archaelogical Journal
AJA: American Journal of Archeology
AJAH: The American Journal of Ancient History
AJPh: American Journal of Philology
AncW: The Ancient World
APh: L Ann Philologique
APhQ: American Plilosoplical Quarterly
BMM: Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art New York
CJ: The Classical Journal
ClAnt: Classical Antiquity
CLS: Comparative Studies in Society and History
CPh: Classical Philology
CQ: Classical Quarterly
CR: Classical Review
CRS: Cultura e Scuola
CSSH: Comparative Studies in Society and History
CW: The Classical World
ECls: tudes Classiques
G&R: Greece and Rome
GRBS: Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies
HLB: Harvard Library Bulletin
HSPh: Harvard Studies in Classical Philology
HTR: Harvard Theological Review
ICS: Illinois Classical Studies
JCS: Journal of Classical Studies
JHS: Journal of Hellenic Studies
JPh:Journal of Philosophy
31 APh.
17
TIS: Anthropologie des mondes grecs anciens
MIET:
PCA: Proceedings of Classical Association
Phoenix: The Phoenix. The Journal of Classical Association of Canada
PhQ: Philologocal Quarterly
QFC: Quaderni di Filologia Classica
QUCC: Quaderni Urbinati di Cultura Classica
RCCM: Rivista di cultura classica e medioevale
REA: Rvue des tudes Anciennes
REG: Rvue des tudes Grecques
RevHist: Revista di Historia
RFIC: Rivista di Filologia e di Instuzione Classica
RIDA: Rvue Internationale des Droits de l Antiquit
RPh: Rvue de Philologie
SPh: Studies in Philology
StudClas: Studii Clasice
TAPhA: Transactions of the American Philological Association
TAPhS: Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological
Association
TrGF: Tragicorum Graecorum Fragmenta
18
19
-:
. 480-475 .,
. :
2422.
20
21
1
1.1. :
, , 360-382
366 .32
,
,
().
.
, ( ),
.
. ,
,
.
, .33
.
34
32 , . .
33 . , 370-382. , . .
34 (. , 124,
252
), .
22
. ,
(.. , , ),
,
. 699.35 ,
. Mazzoldi,36
364-365,
. ,
Mazzoldi,
: ,
, , .
, , , ,
.
37
,
( 697-706).
35 . , , 699 ' .
36 . Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 27-28.
37 : Ed. Fraenkel Aischylus Agamemnon I, Oxford,
1950, 468 , A. Carnoy, Les noms des dieux et des hros d
Homre, C 22, 1954, 344 A. Carnoy, Les noms grecs des devins et magiciens,
C 24, 1956, 103 J. L. Garca-Ramn, Homerico :vd. sa-sad-, proto-ario
*(s)cand-, IE *(s)Kend-hacerse visible, aparecer, Die Sprache 34, 1988-90, 54-57 J.
L. Garca-Ramn,Mycnien ke-sa-do-ro/Kessandros/,Ke-ti-ro/Kestilos/,ke-to/Kestr/:
Grec alphabtique A, , et le nom de Cassandra, in
Mykenaika, ed. J.-P. Olivier, BCH Suppl. 25, Paris, 1992, 239-55. Mazzoldi
, :
/.
.
,
,
23
-,
/ .
. , ,
, .
, 699,
.38
, ,
(II, 341-426),
, ,
.
, .
// ,
*-, , .
/ .
Mazzoldi ,
. ,
.
, . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 27-28.
. , . S. Maritanos,
, PAA 33 (1958), 168 J. Harmatta,
Aiyaw namesMycenaean names. In Atti e memorie del 1 congresso
internazionale di micenologia, Rome, 1968, 404.
/, . J. Davreux, .. (1942), 90-92
J. Harmatta, .. (1968), 402.
, . E. Surez de la Torre, Sibyles, mantique inspire et collections
oraculaires, Kernos 7 (1994), 189-190 179-205A. Heubeck, Weitere Bemerkungen zu
den griechischen Personennamen auf den Linear B-Tafeln, BN 8 (1957), 272-6 (268-
78) P. Chantraine, Dictionnaire tymologique de la langue grecque, Paris, 1968, 503
38 . , , 699: .
24
.39
,
.
Leaf40 ,
.
. ,
.41
, , .
,
. Finley42
,
,
39. .J. Richardson, : , (.
.The Iliad. A Commentary, Cambridge, 1993) , . ,
University Studio Press, , 2003, 228.
. I. Morris, The Use and Abuse of Homer, C 5 (1986), 105-15 A. M.
Snodgrass, An Historical Homeric Society, JHS 94 (1974), 114-125.
40 . W. Leaf, The Iliad, II, XIII-XXIV, Amsterdam, Hakkert M. Adolf,
1971, 30.
41
, , . 699-
706.
42 . M.I. Finley, Marriage, Sale and Gift in Homeric World, RIDA 2 (1955), 167-94.
25
.
.
, .43
Finley Lacey44 ,
, ,
.
, .45
46
, ,
.
. ,
,
. , ,
. , ,
,
.
43 Lvi-Strauss
,
. . Lvi-Strauss, The elementary Structures of
Kinship, London, 1969, 29.
44 . W. K. Lacey, Homeric and Penelopes , JHS 86 (1966), 55-68.
45 . 146,
,
.
, ,
.
46 , . . Scheid-Tissinier, Les usages du don chez
Homre :Vocabulaire et Pratiques, Nancy, 1994.
26
,
.47 , Seaford,48
,
. 364-365, :
(.364) ,
, .
47 . I.N. Perysinakis, Penelopes EEDNA Again, CQ 2 (1991), 299.
48 . R. Seaford, .
-, (. . Reciprocity and Ritual: Homer and Tradegy in
the Developing City-State, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1994), . ,
, , 2003, 49.
27
, 697-709
697-709.49 ,
,
, (. 704-
706). ,
, . ,
,
.
)
.
50 ,
,
.51 ,
,
. ,52
49 , . .
50 . ( 161-244),
381-403.
51 . . , .. (1994), 24-25.
52 (, , ), . .
, . . , . 697-
804. , , 2007, 52-59 Ch. Tsagalis, The
Improvised Laments in the Iliad, Cornell University, 1998, 7-10 (. . = Epic
Grief. Personal Lament in Homer s Iliad, Berlin-N. York, 2004.)
28
,
.
)
Atchity53 .
,
.
( 725-43).54
,
.
(, , ),
, ,
, .
.
236-529 718-776.
,
( 236-529),
( 718-776)
, .55
, ,
,
,
53 . K. J. Atchity, Homers Iliad-The shield of Memory, Southern Illinois Press, 1978,
81.
54 . , . .
55 , . . (M. Christopoulos),
/Views of Helen in Epic and Drama,,
, , , , 2007, 65.
29
56 .57 ,
. , ,
.
, (, )
.
,
.58
)
.
. ,
( 282).59
56 . H. Roisman, Helen in the Iliad. Causa belli and victim of war:
from silent weaver to public speaker, AJPh (2006), 1-36 N. Worman, The Voice of
Which is Not One: Helens Vrebal Guises in Homeric Epic in Making Silence Speak:
Womens Voices in Greek Literature and Society, Princeton, 2001 M. Suzuki,
Metamorphoses of Helen, Authority and the Epic, Ithaca, N.Y., 1989, 54-54 K.J.
Reckford, Helen in the Iliad, GRBS 5, (1964), 5-20 M. Alexiou, The Ritual Lament in
Greek Tradition, Cambridge, 1974, 10-14 G.J. Groten, Homer Helen, G&R 15
(1968), 33-39
57 . . , .. (2007), 67.
58 ,
, .
59 . 282 ' ' ' .
, 36-37 '
, 53-54 '
,
30
Taplin .60
, .61
, , ,
360-382). , ,
-
.
Mazzoldi62
,
,
. ,
,
,
:
,
.
, . ,
.
,
,
.
.
( ,
, ).
60 . O. Taplin, Homeric Soundings: The shaping of the Iliad, Oxford, Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 1992, 280.
61 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 18 .
31
) -
, Anderson,
.63
, .
: )
,
. )
,
.
) :
, , 64
) ,
.
,
. ,
,
.65
.
, ,
,
63 , .
J.M. Anderson, The Fall of Troy in Early Greek Poetry and Art, Oxford, Clarendon
University Press, Oxford, 1997, 52.
64 . , 370: ' ' .
65 , ,
.
.
32
.
.
,
.66
;
.67 , ,
, .
,
,
.
.
Mason68
699
. , ,
,
66 ,
. ,
. . J..
Anderson. .. (1997), 52.
67 Mazzoldi
.
, . S. Mazzoldi, .., (2001), 116-117 , . J. Davreux, .. (1942),
166.
68 . P. G. Mason, Kassandra, JHS 79 (1959), 81.
33
. ,
,
( 360-382, 697-
706).
, 59-64
,
,
. 59-64.69
.
. ,
, ,
. ,
, :
, ,
,
.
, (), . 62 '
70 ,
,
.
( , ),
69 , . .
70 ,
580 . 465 .
34
.71 , ,
: , ,
. ,
,
:
, .
35
1.2. :
, , ,
.
,
. ,
, ,
,
. 72
o
. (
)
. ,
Jones,
, ,
.73
421-423
72 . R.D. Dawe, The Odyssey. Translation and Analysis, Sussex, England, 1993,
452, . . 405 ..
73 . P. V. Jones, Homers Odyssey, Bristol, 1988, 106, . . 409.
36
,
,74 ,
. ,
,75 , .
, , 76
' (. 422-23).
.
74
. ,
, , . -
, ( 514).
(. 411),
. . . -,
, , , 1989, 146.
75 ,
(.412-430). , , ,
, (. 413-414).
'
, .
, ,
. . R. Seaford, .
-, (. . Reciprocity and
Ritual: Homer and Tradegy in the Developing City-State, Oxford, Clarendon Press,
1994), . , , , 2003, 116.
76
, :
(. 410), (. 422), , (. 424),
(. 427).
37
.
, ,
.77
' (
423).
: ) , ) , ) .
. , ,
, . 78
'
.
.
,
, , .
. Dawe,
.79
77 ,
, . , ,
, .
, . E. Schwartz, Die Odyssey, Mnchen, 1924, 319
78 Davreux ,
. B. J. Davreux, ..
(1942), 4.
79 . D.R. Dawe, The Odyssey. Translation and Analysis, England, Sussex, 1993
(1993), 453, . . 423.
38
, , :
,
.
,
( ).80
,
:
,
,
.81
( 421-423)82
. ,
.83
80. V. Berard, L Odyssey, Paris, 1925, 100 A. Severyns, Le Cycle pique dans
lcole d Aristarque, 1928, 400 S. Mazzoldi, ., (2001), 64 A. Hentze, Homers
Odysse, Leibzig, 1900, 156 , . Chantraine
., .. (1958, 1963), 171, . 2.
81 . S. West, A. Heubeck - J.B. Hainsworth, ., (2004), . 3, 269, . .
422.
82 423-24 Mazzoldi82 :
) ,
,
: i)
, ii)
. )
,
: ) ,
(
), ) , )
39
,
84 (. 424). 433-4 ( '
, ' .)
,
, .
.
-
. )
, .
, , ) )
, , .
,
, .
, ,
. . . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 64.
84 (.
180, . 145). , . . , .. (2007), 16,
. 5.
40
.85
Mason86
.
,
.
, ,
, . , ,
:
, .
: '
( 421-22). Dimock87
( 421-423)
. , ,
, ,
. 88
.
. , Petersmann,
85 . S. West, A. Heubeck - J.B. Hainsworth, .
, . , . , . ,
, , 2004, 269, . .422.
86 . G.P. Mason, Kassandra, JHS, 79, 1959, 81.
87 . G. E. Dimock, The Unity of the Odyssey, Massachusetts, 1989, 157.
88 . . , .. (1994), 30.
41
.89 Mazzoldi
,
, .90
, , 91
, , .92 Holst-Wahrhaft93
, ,
,94 ,
,
89. H. Petersmann, Congunal love as an expression of Homers Humanity,
, , , 1995, 77.
90 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 65
91 ,
( 411).
. ,
, , . 1125
.
, , [, , 774-858
, . 839-843 '
,
' , , Euripidis fabulae,
. 2, ed. J. Diggle, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1981]. Henrichs
,
. . B. A.
Henrichs, Drama and Dromena: Bloodshed, Violence, and Sacrificial Metaphor in
Euripides, CHS, 100, 2000. . M. Detienne, and J-P. Vernant, The Cuisine of
Sacrifice among the Greeks, Chicago, 1989, (French ed. 1979).
92 Henrichs, ,
.
93 B. G. Holst-Wahrhaft, Dangerous voices: Womens Lament and Greek Literature,
London, New York, 1992, 140.
94
, .
,
. , ,
42
, ,
, . , . . W.
Burkert, Greek Tragedy and Sacrificial Ritual, GRBS, 7(1966), 112.
, . . , . 1, 33, 1.1,
43, 1.2, 22, 7.2, 35, 1.3, 16, 7.7, 26, 5.9, 19, 6, . , 232, 1415 ..
43
, .
,
, ( 360-382).
, ,
.
, , ,
,
. , ,
,
.
59-64
,
,
,
.
, ,
.
. ,
, .
, ,
,
.
,
. , ,
44
.
45
2
2.1.
,95
,96 ,
,
, .
97 .
95 , . J. Marks, Inset Narratives in the Epic Cycle Classics @
Volume 6, E. D. Karakantza, ed. The Center for Hellenic Studies of Harvard
University, online edition of December 20, 2010 J.S. Burgess, The Tradition of the
Trojan War in Homer and the Epic Cycle, Baltimore & London, The Johns Hopkins
University Press, 2001 J. Anderson, .. (1999) D.B. Monro, On the Fragments of
Proclus Abstract of the Epic Cycle Contained in the Codex Venetus of the Iliad, JHS
4 (1883), 305-334 D.B. Monro, The Poems of the Epic Cycle, JHS 5 (1884), 1-41
T.W. Allen, The Epic Cycle (Continued), CQ 2, 2 (April 1908), 81-88.
, . K.W.
Gransden, The Fall of Troy, G&R XXXII, 1 (April 1985), 60-72.
96
3 . . . 5 . .., . M.Davies,
The Epic Cycle, Bristol 1989 M. Davies, The Date of the Epic Cycle, Glotta 67 (1989),
89-100 J. Griffin, The Epic Cycle and the Uniqueness of Homer, JHS 97 (1977), 39-
58 I. Holmberg, The Creation of the Ancient Epic Cycle, Oral Tradition 13 (1998),
456-478.
97
. ,
, . M. Davies, .., (2010) J. Marks, The Junction
between the Kypria and the Iliad, Phoenix 1-2 (Spring-Summer 2002), 1-25 M.
Finkelberg, The Cypria, The Iliad, and the Problem of Multiformity and the Written
46
,
.
, ,
.
: ,
. , 98 (
10.90-94)99 ,
, ,
.
,
, .
.
.100
,
.
Tradition, CPh 94 (2000), 1-11 J.S. Burgess, The Non-Homeric Cypria, TAPha 126
(1996), 77-99 R. Scaife, The Kypria and its Early Reception, CA 4, 1 (April 1995), 1-
35.
98
, : )
, ) , ) , )
, ) ,
, , ) , )
- , ,
) , ) , )
, ) -, ) ,
) , )
, ) - , ) , )
, ) , )
. ,
. . D.B. Monro, .. (1884), 2-11.
99 , . .
100 . E. Bethe, Kassandra, REX, (1917), 291.
47
.
(=)
- (= , , ),
,
.
, ,
.
48
2.2.
,
. 101
102 103
, , ,
, , .
.104
Mason105
.
101 . , .. 10. 27. 1, 11. , . .
102
. .
.
: ) , ) ,
) , , )
, ) ,
, ) ,
, )
. .
. D.B Monro, ..,
(1884), 19-27.
103 , , 2, 341. . G.
Scafoglio, Virgilio e Stesicoro: una ricerca sulla Tabula Iliaca Capitolina. Rheinisches
Museum 148, 2005, 113-125.
104
, , ,
.
105 . P.G.Mason, .. (1959), 82.
49
. ,
. ,
,
Tabula Iliaca .106
. , o
, , .
,
,
.
.
Tabula Iliaca.107
.
:108
Tabula Iliaca (),
.
106 . S. Mazzoldi, .., (2001), 118-119.
107 : ,
. , , . , . A. Sadurska,
Les Tables iliaques, Warszawa, 1964
108 Tabula Iliaca, . N. Horsfall, Stesichorus at Bovillae?, JHS 99 (1979), 26
48 , . B.A. Sparkes, The
Trojan Horse in Clasical Art, G&R, 2nd Ser 18, 1 (April 1971), 55-70.
50
2.3.
109
, .110
, ,111 ,
,
. .
,
( ),
( ) ,
, .
, .
109 .
. , .
: )
, )
, ) , )
, ) ,
, ) ,
, , )
,
) ,
, ,
) ) .
.
110 . , 4, 6-8 , .., 23, 261-265. , .
. , . . 527-535.
111 . , 6, 1-2. . .
51
. 112
.113
,
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
.114 , ,
,
.115
116
112 . , .. 10. 26. 3 5. 19. 5.
113 , . S. Mazzoldi, Cassandra, Aiace e lo
di Atena, QUCC 84, 1 (1997), 14-16
114 , ,
.
. , ,
.
, . . ,
, . J. Redfield, The Locrian Maidens: Love and Death in Greek Italy, Princeton,
N.J: Princeton University Press, 2003 C. Sourvinou-Inwood, The Votum of 477/6
B.C. and the Foundation Legend of Locroi Epizephyrii, CQ
24, 2 (Dec., 1974), 186-198.
115
. . , . , 69-71 (.
), .
116 , S.
Mazzoldi, .., (1997), 7-21 S.B. Matheson, Polygnotos: An Iliupersis Scene at the
Getty Museum, Occas. Pap. On Antiq. 3, (1986), 101-114 M. D. Stansbury, - O
Donell, Polygnotoss Iliupersis: A New Reconstruction, AJA 93, 2 (1989), 203-21
52
.117 ,
5 6 ,
, .118
: )
119 ) ,
.120 ,
.121
.122 123
.124
, .
117 Neblung
,
, , .
, ,
.
, . Neblung, .. 14, . 33.
118 Davreux
4, 11, 5 ,
. . J. Davreux, .., 139-211.
119 . C. Robert ( Mason), .. (1959), 82.
120 . D. eblung, .. (1997), 14.
121 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (1997), 18-19.
122
, . . A. Severyns, Le Cycle
pique dans l cole d Aristarque, 1928. Vellay
. . C. Vellay, Les Lgandes du
Cycle Troyen, Monaco, 1953, 277.
.
123 . . , 358, ( ).
.
124 . E. Bethe, .. (1917), 2292 Mason, .. (1959), 82.
53
, ,
, , ,
.125 (
66-70) ,
.
.
.
,
.
. , ,
.126
, , ,
. , ,
. (..
, )
.
.
.
127
, .
,
,
125 . , .., 23, 258-259. , . .
126 . M. Anderson, .. (1997), 50.
127 . 5.16
, ,
. , . . , 2, 246.
, . K.W Gransden, .. (1985), 62-63, 66-68.
54
. , , ,
,
.
.
, ,
.
55
: 450 .. Metropolitan Museum of Art, : 56.171.41
56
,
, ,
.
128 ,
, .
,
, ,
.
.
, ,
.
,
,
.
, ,
, ,
, .
.
.
.
.
, , o,
128 . , 360-382. , . . 1.
57
.
, ,
, .
. ,
.
58
3.1.1 11
11 129 Wilamowitz
.130
,
474 ..,
454 ..,
.131
129 , . .
130 . . U.von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, Pindaros, Berlin, 1922,
259. Gildersleeve
, . .
B.L. Gildersleeve, Pindar: The Olympian and Pythian Odes, London and New York,
1899, 357.
131
.
,
. 474
..
, .
454 ..
, 458 ..
474 .X.: U. von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, .. (1922), 262-263 F.
Dornseiff, Pindar, Leipzig, 1921, 112, 115 A. Puech, Pindare, 2 vol, Paris, 1922-1923,
156 G. Coppola, Introduzione a Pindaro, Rome, 1931,114 H. Gundert, Pindar und
sein Dichterberuf, Frankfurt, 1935, 83-86 R. Nierhaus, Strophe und Inhalt im
pindarischen Epinikion, Berlin, 1936, 71 G. Norwood, Pindar, Berkeley, 1945, 123 J.
Duchemin, Pindare pote et prophte, Paris, 1955, 252 B.A. Groningen, La
composition littrraire archaque, 2nd edition, Amsterdam, 1960,364 R.W. Burton,
Pindar's Pythian Odes, Oxford, 1962, 61, 72 G. Mautis, Pindare le Dorien, Neuchtel,
1962, 263 D.C Young, Three odes of Pindar: A Literary Study of Pythian 11, Pythian 3,
59
,
.
, ,
(. 10-16). ,
,
. ,
, ,
(. 17-25).
25-30
.
(.34-37).
and Olympian 7, Leiden, 1968, 7 S. Instone, Pythian 11: Did Pindar Err?, CQ 36, 1
(1986), 86. 454-3 ..
.
. ,
.
.
, 458 .. 454 ..
: C.M. Bowra, Pindar, Pythian Xl, CQ 30, 3-4 (1936), 134-140 L.R. Farnell, The
Works of Pindar II: Critical Commentary, Amsterdam, 1961, 221-223 J.H. Finley,
Pindar and Aeschylus, Cambridge, 1955, 160. , .
P. J. Finglass, Pindar, Pythian Eleven, Cambridge, 2007, 18-26.
60
(.1-12)132
.133
Newman ,
,
,
, .134
132
,
,
-,
. . R.B. Egan, On the relevance of Orestes in Pindars
Eleventh Pythian, Phoenix 37, 3 (1983), 193, 98-99. , . J.
H. Finley, Pindar and Aeschylus, Cambridge, 1955, 160-164 D.C. Young, ..
(1968), 19 . 2 S. Instone, .. (1986), 87 G. Mautis, Pindare le Dorien,
Neuchtel, 1962, 264 .. , , : ,
, 1994, 337, . 1.
133 Bowra
,
. ,
. Bowra
.
, ( ) (
, , ). . C. M. Bowra, .. (1936), 130-
131. Bowra . , ,
,
. . C. M. Bowra, .. (1936), 130-131.
134 . F. S. Newman, The Relevance of the Myth in Pindar's Eleventh Pythian,
31 (1979), 63.
61
135
.136
, ,137
, ,
.138 ,
135 , . M. I. Davies, Thoughts on the Oresteia
before Aeschylus, BCH 93 (1969), 214-260 R. Sevier, Un eroe in cerca d'identit:
Oreste nella Pitica XI di Pindaro per Trasideo di Tebe, Materiali e discussioni per
l'analisi dei testi classici, 43 (1999), 77-110 Cl. Calame, Clytemnestre et Oreste aux
jeux pythiques, Potique des mythes dans la Grce antique, Paris, 2000, 95-155
. -, H A H E,
Mtis 2 (2004), 82-83.
136 . R. B. Egan, .. (1983),190.
137 , . F. S. Newman, .. (1979), . 3, 50.
. W. J. Slater, Pindars Myths: Two Pragmatic Explanations, in
G.W.Bowersock et al. eds, Arktouros: Hellenic Studies Presented to Bernard M.K.Knox,
Berlin and New York, Berlin, 1979, 63-65 C. Eckerman, Pindar: Pythian Eleven, ed.
with intr., tr. and comm. by P.J.F. (Cambridge Classical Texts and Commentaries,
45), Mnemosyne 64, 2e, (2011), 299 301.
137 . W. H. Race, : , . , ,
2006, 232.
138 (. 16).
(. 180, 46)
.
5 . .
(PMG 216),
.
. 31-2,
, . . S. Instone, .. (1986), 87.
,
. ,
. . A. Stfos,
Apollon dans Pindare, Athnes, 1975, 83. ,
.
62
,
, ,
.139
, ,140 .
,
, (. 17),
, (. 16).141
,
, (. 12)
, ,
(. 35). ,
.
.
( 3, 19, 6).
, . G. Salapata, .. (1997), 246, 257.
139 , . G. Forrest, The first Sacred War, BCH 80, 1956,
51 J. Fontenrose, .. (1960), 222.
,
.
, ,
, , . ,
, , ,
. . Bowra, ..
(1936), 134.
140 - 11 , . Th.Hubbard, Pylades and
Orestes in Pindars Eleventh Pythian, Allusion, Authority, and Truth: Critical
Perspectives on Greek Poetic and Rhetorical Praxis, eds. P. Mitsis, Ch. Tsagalis,
Berlin/New York, 2010, 187-200.
141 . S. Instone, .. (1986), 87.
63
(. 9).142 . 9-10
, ,
.
.
.
, .
.143
,
.
.
, , , ,
, ,
.
, , ,
,
142
. Bowra
, . .
Bowra, .. (1936), 154 : Wilamowitz, 1922, 261
L. Illig, Zur Form der Pindarischen Erzhlung, Berlin,1932, 96.
, . R. B. Egan, .. (1983), 194. O Young
,
. . D.C Young, .. (1968), 19-20.
W. Race, .. (1980), 5 Nisetich, .. (1980), 47.
143 . R. B. Egan, .. (1983), 199.
64
.144
(. 16, 34),
.
, .
, ,
. Slater
.145
.
, ,
.
(. 19-22).
,146
144 14 . . R.W. Burton, ..
(1962), 60 , .. (1994), . 14, 339 E.Thummer, Die Religiositt Pindars,
Innsbruck, 1957, 52 Von der Mhll, .. (1958), 141-146. O Dring
, 474 .. 454 ..,
. Burton
:
.
,
,
.
145 . S. Slater, .. (1979), 63-65 F. S. Newman, .. (1979),51.
146 , ,
,
. ,
65
, .
(. 19-22). .147
, . 21-22,
( 412-414, 421-423). . 20
,
' ' .
.
, ,
.
(, , 307).
, .
,
(, , 877).
, . , , 1131 ..
. . , ,
556.
147 25 . ,
. . Fraenkel, Aeschylus Agamemnon, Vol. III, Oxford, 1950, 806-809 March, ..
(1987), 90, . 46 M. Davies Aeschylus Clytemnestra: Sword or Axe?, CQ 37, 1
(1987), 65-75.
66
11
1.1.1 1 (.21-22)
.
.148 Newman
,
(, .
17, 33 , . 1).
, (, . 6 .
33).
, .
- , .
, ,
. , , . 6
.
, ,
,
(. 16-20). ,
. . 21-22,
,
148 . F. S. Newman, .. (1979), 51.
67
.149
( 421-23).150
151
.152 H
153
.
,
, .
Slater
, ,
, .
, ,
149 . , , . 1160-1 Bowra, .. (1936), 141.
150
.
, .
, . . A. Stfos,
Apollon dans Pindare, 1975, Athnes, 82-83. ,
, (..
, , , )
,
.
151 Wilamowitz
. . Wilamowitz, .. (1922),
26. , . .
L.R. Farnell, .. (1961), 224.
152 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 68.
68
.
, .154155
,
.
.
.
.156 Guillon (. 25)
,
. , ,
, ,
.
.
,
,
.
154 Lefkowitz,
, , , .
. 41
, .
. . R. M. Lefkowitz, First-Person Fictions.
Pindars Poetic I , Oxford, 1991. , . S.
Instone, .. (1986), 87, 94 Slater, .. (1979), 67.
, . Kurke, L., The Traffic in Praise: Pindar and the Poetics of
Social Economy (Myth and poetics), 1991, Ithaca and London H. W.Race, .. (2006),
99
155 . S. Slater, .. (1979), 68.
156 . P. Guillon, Le crime de Clytemnestra et la Pythique XI de Pindare, AFLA 39,
(1965), 5-51
69
. 33-34
. 31-37
, ,
, .
,
,
.
. .. (.
21) (. 31)
(. 19) (. 33).157
. 33 ,
.
.
, . ,
,
. ,
,
.
. 33-34
,
, .
,
157. F. S. Newman, .. (1979), 49-60 Waltkins, .. (2002),435.
70
.
,
, ,
, .
,
.158
, ,
, .
,
, ,
159
.
, . ,
,
.
,160
.
, , ,
158 . . R. B. Egan,
.. (1983), 199. 11
, . B. Gentili, Polemica antitirannica (Pind. Pyth.11, Aesch. Prom, Herodt. 3,
80-81, Thuc. 2, 65, 9), QUCC 1 (1979), 154 F. S. Newman, Pindar, Solon and
Jealoysy: Political Vocabulary in the Eleventh Pythian, ICS 7 (1982), 189-195.
159 . R.W. Burton, . (1962), 65 J. Duchemin, Pindare, pote et prophte, Paris,
1955, 252.
71
, , . ,
, , ( )
,
.
,
, .
, ,
,
.161
-
, .
,
161 ,
. . .Stephos, .., (1975), Les amours d Apollon, . , 42-
85. ,
, .
, ,
. , . J. C. Kamerbeck, Prophecy and Tradegy,
Mnemosyne 18, (1965), 29-40J. N. Bremmer, Prophets, Seers, and Politics in Greece,
Israel, and Early Modern Europe, Numen 40, 2 (1993), 150-183 M. Detienne, Apollon
le couteau la main. Une approche exprimentale du polythisme grec, Paris, 1998 R.
S. P. Beekes, The Origin of Apollo, Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 3, 1
(2003), 1-21 R. Saloman, Cults, Myths and Religions, London, 2003 N. Bremmer,
Anaphe, Aeschrology and Apollo Aigletes Apollonius Rhodius 4.1711-1730, Caeculus
6 (2005), 18-34 F. Graf, Apollon. Gods and Heroes of the Ancient World, London/New
York: Routledge, 2009 J. N. Bremmer - A. Erskine, The Gods of Ancient Greece:
Identities and Transformations, Edinburgh, 2010.
72
.162
. ,163 ,
, .
.
.
,
, , .
162 . , , 46. 7 159,
8, 159 . . Salapata, G., The Heroic Cult of
Agamemnon, Electra, 2011, 139-60, : http://electra.lis.upatras.gr.
163 . , 3. 19. 6. , . . , . L.R.
Farnell, .. (1961), 225.
73
3.1.2 VIII ()
,
, VIII164 .
15 ,
.
, ,
, ,
,165 , .
,
, ,
.
.
. 1-2 , , ,
.
,
. 2 . Grenfell
164 , . .
165 ,
, ,
.
, ,
, , ,
.
. . , . 3, 12, 5.
74
Hunt, ,
.166
([ ),167
, (. 1),
.
(, . 3), ,
.
( , . 3),
.168
(. 3-4)
169
. (.
166 . . P. Grenfell A.S. Hunt, The Oxyrhynchus Papyri V, London, 1908, 64-67,
104-105.
167 Robert - ([ ,
. Robert
(. 2). .
C.Robert, Zu Pindars VIII. Paean, Hermes 49, 317 L.R. Farnell, Critical Commentary
to the works of Pindar, Amsterdam, 1961, 410.
168 . . , . 1072 ..
169 Rutherford
,
. . I.Rutherford, Pindars Paeans: A Reading of the Fragments
with a Survey of the Genre, Oxford, 2001, 236. . , . 93,
2, , ,
. , . H.Diels - W.Kranz, Die
Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, vol. 1, 6th edn., Dublin/Zurich, Weidmann, 1951.
75
4),170
.171
(.
1),172 , (. 2) (. 4)
(, . 2).
,
(. 5).
. ,
, ,
,
(. 6-7).
, [ ][]173 (.
5)
.174
,
(, .),175 ,
[ , . 9-10).
,
170 , , . A. Iriarte, .. (1990), 54.
171 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 125.
172
. 156, 201 . 535.
173 , . . P. Grenfell A.S. Hunt .. (1908), 65.
174 . , . 84-85 (
).
175 . G. Bona, Pindaro. I Peani, testo, traduzione, scoli e commento, Cuneo, 1988,
206.
76
.176
, , ,
,
.
,
( , . 9)
( . 1),
( [ , . 13-14).
[ ,
[ , 11-12
.
-
-
.
,
, ,
176 , . P.J. Finglass, Erinys or
Hundred-Hander? Pindar, fr. 52i (a). 19-21 Snell-Maehler= B3. 25-7 Rutherford
("Paean" 8a), Zeitschrift fr Papyrologie und Epigraphik 154 (2005), 40-42.
(. 10),
, , , .
(919 ..). ,
. D Kovacs, Gods and Men in Euripides' Trojan Trilogy, Colby Quarterly 33, 2
(1997), 167 R. Scodel, The Trojan Trilogy of Euripides, Gottingen 1980, 76-79.
, . . 4, , .
77
. Davreux177
,
, ,
.178
177 . J. Davreux, .. (1942), 23.
178 . , . 90-94 . , . A. Severyns,
Chrestomathia [Dub.] (epitome), Les Paris, Belles Lettres, 1963.
78
3.2.
,
, , ,
.
, ,179
(88-132)180 , ,
.
,
, .
.181
,182
,
,
(. 42,
, ' ).
179 . , , 12 (
, ). . G. Kaibel,
Athenaei Naucratitae deipnosophistarum libri xv, 3 vols., Leipzig, Teubner, 1890
(Stuttgart 1966), 521.
180 . D. L. Page, Supplementum lyricis Graecis. (Poetarum Lyricorum
Graecorum Fragmenta quae recens innotuerunt), Oxford, 1974.
181 , (De sera numinis
vindicta), 10c. , . . , . Pohlenz, De sera
numinis vindicta, M. Plutarchi moralia, Leipzig, Teubner, 1929, 555.
182 , . 527 . '
, .
79
-
.183 , ,
,
, .
,
( 246, 257),184 ,
185 ( 547)
, ' '
(, 929).186
, ( 549).
Roberts
.187 , ,
.
183 . . , : , , , , ,
, , , , , 1999, 308.
: , , , , ,
.
184 , . J. J. Peradotto, The omen of the eagles and the
of Agamemnon, Phoenix 23 (1969), 237-263 A. Lebeck, The Oresteia: A Study in
Language and Structure, Washington 1971 P.Vidal-Naquet,
J.-P. Vernant & P. Vidal-Naquet,
, . , . , , 1988, 155-82 J. Heath,
Disentangling the Beast: Humans and Other Animals in Aeschylus' Oresteia, JHS
119 (1999), 17-47 J. Heath The Omen of the Eagles and Hare (Agamemnon 104-59):
From Aulis to Argos and Back Again CQ 51, 1 (2001), 18-22
185 , . G. Devereux, Dreams in Greek Tragedy,
Berkeley, Los Angeles, 1976, 203.
186 . , . 246, 527, 549, 928, 993-5, 1047-50.
, 1232-6
(. 249).
187 , . D. H. Roberts, Orestes as Fulfillment Teraskopos, and
Teras in the Oresteia, AJPh 106, 3 (Autumn, 1985), 283-297: 290.
, . W. Whallon, The serpent at the breast,
TAPhA 89 (1958), 271-5.
80
,
. ,
Mason
. 188
.
,
.
, .
.
Bowra,189
, ,
.190
188 . P.G. Mason, .. (1959), 83.
189 . C. M. Bowra, : , , ,
, . 1, . .. (. Greek Lyric Poetry: From Alcman
to Simonides, Oxford, Oxford Univestity Press, 1961), , , 1997, 177.
190 ,
. .
.
, 194 . ( '
, ).
, . R. Merkelbach - M. L. West, Fragmenta Hesiodi opera (ed. F.
Solmsen), 2nd edn., Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1983. (. 3D=1(a) P., .
20-22 ] [ ] [] []
[] [])
. .
, ., 1569, 1602.
, ., .. (1999), 323, . 20. . , . . .
, ;, , , , , 1980,
81
, ,
. ,
.
, , ,
. , ,
,
,
8 . ..191
.
,192
.193
.194 ,
Bowra,
. 195
137-140 M. Papathomopoulos, Nouveaux Fragments d auteurs anciens, ,
1980, 137-140. , ., 1569, 1602.
191 . M. Croiset, Eschyle, Etudes sur l invention dramatique dans son theater, Paris,
1928, 170.
192 ,
. T. K. Stephanopoulos, Umgestaltung des Mythos durch Euripides, , 1980, 89.
193 . . . 3.
194 . , . 46 ' :
. ,
[frg. 39] [frg. 207] . , . De
Gruyter/ E.Schwartz, Scholia in Euripidem, (Scholia in Orestem), 1 vols., Berlin,
Reimer, 1891(1966).
195 . C.M. Bowra, .. (1997), 176-177.
82
11
.
. ,
(. 33).
,
.
.
, .
.
,
. 33,
.
,
.
.
. ,
,
.
83
4.1
4.1. ,
(. 264, 355, 524,
575) (. 810).196
,
.
.
, , ,
.
(.799-801).197
, 198
. Mautis,
,
.199
196 , . O. Taplin, The Stagecraft of
Aeschylus: The Dramatic Use of Exits and Entrances in Greek Tradegy, Oxford, 1990,
302-306.
197 , . .
198 , . O. Taplin, ..
(1990), 280-290.
199 , . G. Mautis, Eschyle et la Trilogie, Paris, 1936, 162-163.
, . F.M. Bennett-
Anderson, The Character of Clytemnestra in the Agamemnon of Aeschylus, TAPhA
60 (1929), 136-154 K. L. Komar, Reclaiming Klytemnestra: Revenge or Reconciliation,
Illinois, 2003 J. Mossman, Women's Speech in Greek Tragedy: The Case of Electra
84
.
.
,
, , 200 (. 950)201
,
, '(. 954-955).202
. 1035 ( , ).
, ,
.
.
,
950.
,
1039, 1054, 1070, ,
1075,
.
.
and Clytemnestra in Euripides' Electra CQ 51, 2 (2001).
, . M. Davies, Aeschylus' Clytemnestra: Sword or
Axe?, CQ 37, 1 (1987), 65-75 A. J. N. W. Prag, Clytemnestra's Weapon Yet Once
More, CQ 41, 1 (1991), 242-246.
200 (. 615-616, 1062-
1063).
201 950-955, . .
202 , , -
.
, .
.
85
(. 950-955).
. 1035-
1071,
,
, .203
,
,
1039, .
, (. 1035),
,
(1038, 1440,1041, 1045).
1075.
.204
203 Konishi .
,
. ,
,
. . H. Konishi, The Plot of Aeschylus Oresteia, Amsterdam,
1990, 108-109. ,
, .
204
, . . ,
, , , 1984, 196-198 O. Taplin, Aeschylean Silences and
86
. , ,
.
.
. ,
,
.
. 1075.
.
.205
Silences in Aeschylus, HSCP 76 (1972), 57-97: 77-78 S. Montiglio, Silence in the land
of logos, New Jersey, 2000, 213-216.
205 . . , .. (1991), 200.
87
(.1071-1330)206
-
.
, ,
, .
.
. 1071-1330. O Schein mad-
scene, . 1072-1177 1214
.. 207
.
206 , .
207 , . A. Bouch-Leclercq, Histoire de
la Divination dans lAntiquit, vol. 2, Paris. 1880, 50 W.R. Halliday, Greek Divination.
A Study of its Methods and Principles, London, 1913, 70, 82, 83, 90 E. Fraenkel,
Aeschylus: Agamemnon vol. 3, Oxford, 1950, 487-627 E. R. Dodds, The Greeks and
the Irrational, Berkeley, 1951, 70-71 R. Graves, The Greek Myths, vol 2,
Harmondsworth, 1955, 112[k], 158[p], 166[i], 167[e], 168[f] A.J.N.W. Prag, The
Oresteia: Iconographic and Narrative Tradition, Warminster, 1985, 58-60 M. R.
Lefkowitz, Women in Greek Myth, Baltimore, 1986, 44, 54 R. Parker, Miasma:
Pollution and Purification in Early Greek Religion, Oxford, 1983, 56-58 M. P. J. Dillon,
Girls and Women in Classical Greek Religion, London, 2002, 259-60, 362 .135 S.
Mazzoldi, Lo scotto di Cassandra mantis, QUCC 8 (2001), 93-98. S. Mazzoldi,
Cassandras Prophecy between Ecstasy and Rational Mediation, Kernos 15 (2002),
145-154 G. Hovenden, Speaking in Tongues. The New Testament Evidence in Context,
London, 2002, 9-13 M. A. Flower, The Seer in Ancient Greece, Berkeley, 2008, 89,
214-15, 224 M. Dillon, Kassandra: Mantic, Maenadic or Manic? Gender and the
Nature of Prophetic Experience in Ancient Greece, Essays from the AASR Conference,
University of New England, Armidale, 2008, 1-21.
88
.
.208
,
. 209
, .
, Goward,
.210
. Goldhill
-, -
.211
- .
, , , .
.
, .
, ,
, .
, .
, Mazzoldi,
. (.
1112-1113, 1130-1131, 1177),
208 . S.L. Schein, The Cassandra Scene in Aeschylus Agamemnon, G&R 29, 1
(April 1982), 11.
209 . B.M.W Knox, Aeschylus and the Third Actor, AJPh 93, (1972), 104-124.
210 . B. Goward, Telling Tradegy. Narrative Technique in Aeschylus, Sophocles and
Euripides, London, 1999 (. , :
, , . . , ,
, 2002, 156).
211 . S. D. Goldhill, Language, sexuality, narrative: the Oresteia, London, 1984, 81.
89
(. 1251, 1310, 1312), (.1099,
1247) ,
(.1120-1121, 1133-115).212
.
, ,
, ,
.
, .
Fraenkel,
.213
,
.
:
) (. 1072-1177)
) (. 1178-1197)
) (. 1198-1213)
) (. 1214-1241)
) (. 1242-1255)
) (. 1256-1298)
) (. 1299-1330).
212
, , . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2002), 147.
213 . E.Fraenkel, Aeschylus Agamemnon, .. (1950), 623.
90
) :
(. 1072-1177)
. 1069-1070, ,
.214
,
(. 1071) .
,
Goldhill,
,
.215
.216
,
. (.
1072-1073). , ,
, , ,
,
, .217
214 . . . 1069-1071, ', , . ',
, ' ' , ' .
, . . 1321 , ,
.
.
215 . S. Goldhill, .. (2008), 125.
216 . 1051, 1060 . , ,
, .
217 . S. Mazzoldi, .. (2002), 146. , . W.J.
Samarin, Variations and Variable in Religious Glossolalia, Language in Society 1
(1972), 121-130. , . L.J. Heirman, Kassnadras
Glossolalia, Mnemosyne 28 (1975), 257-267 S. Crippa, Glossolalia. Il linguaggio di
Cassandra, Studi italiani di linguistia teorica e applicata, 19/3 (1990), 485-508.
91
, 218
.
.
(. 1073, 1077, 1080, 1085).
.
.
.
,
. ,
. ,
.
.219
,
,
(. 1321-1325).
.
(. 1074)
,
. ,
218 1257.
. ,
. L.J. Heirmann, .. (1975), 261.
219 , . R. Mitchell-Boyask, The Marriage of Cassandra and the
Oresteia: Text, Image, Performance, TAPhA 136 (2006), 269-297: 271.
92
, .220
. , ,
.
, ,
.
( . 1081) .221
( )
.222
, .
, , :
(. 1080) (. 1081), (. 1082).
, ,
. ,
,
220 . , 975-976 '
o . 232 /
,/ .
221 , , ,
.
,
. .
, . L.R. Farnell, The Cults of the Greek States, . 5, Chicago, 1896-
1909, 148-151.
222
. Murray,
. 1071, . 1177. . G. Murray, Aeschylus, The Creator of Tragedy, (.
, , . . , ,
, 1993), Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1940, 221. Fraenkel
. 1071-1081
. 1177 . .
.Fraenkel, .. (1950), . . 1084. ,
,
.
93
( . 1081),
( , . 1082) 223 (
, . 1082). Fraenkel
, ,
.224
.
. 1080-1081 ,
. , ,
: ' ; ;.
.
( . 1088-1089)
. .
,
.
,
: -, -.
, ,
.
(. 1088)
. , , ,
, .
.1090-1092.
223 . 1211,
.
224 . . Fraenkel, .. (1950), . . 1082.
94
:
(. 1090), . 1091-1092
.
, , ,
.
, ,225 ,
226 (. 1091-1091).
. Goldhill
,
,
,
.227
(. 1093-1094),228
,
. (. 1096-1097)
225 .
, . , , 850 '
.
226 , .
.
Fraenkel, ,
. ,
. . Fraenkel, .. (1950), . .
1092.
227 . S. Goldhill, .. (2008), 126.
228 ( , . 1093).
, ,
.
95
,
.229
,
. . , ,
.
,
(. 1099 '
). 1099
.
,
, , ,
.230
.
.
.
.
(. 1100-1101 , 231;
229 1096-1097 :
. ' . . O.
L. Smith, Scholia in Aeschylum (Hypothesis et scholia), Leipzig, Teubner, 1976.
230 , . . Fraenkel, .., (1950), 497-498.
231 , ,
1100-1102.
. ,
( 199-200) ,
, ' ,
. , , 261 (
), .
96
;).
('232
, . 1102),
.
,
(. 1106).
,
.
,
, .
1107 .
;,
.
; (. 1109). , ,
, ,
(. 973).233 ,
Seaford, .234 , ,
, .
, . . , , , (, ,
), . 2, -, , 2000, 293.
232 ,
.
233 . , . 973 , .
234 1107 ;.
, . R. Seaford, The
Tragic Wedding, JHS 107, (1987), 127.
97
, ,
.
, ,
(.1110), .
.
. , ,
.
.
.
: ) (
, . 1108), ) (
, . 1109) ) (
, . 1110-1111).235
(.
1112) (. 1113).
. ,
, . . 1114
,
. 236 .
, .
235 .
: ) ,
)
, .
. . Fraenkel, ..
(1950) . . 1111 . , .. (2000), 294.
236 , ,
.
.
98
, ,
.
. . 1114 ..,
, .
:
(. 1116 , ).
,
,
, .
(1115),
.
,
(. 1116). Seaford
.237
237 1116 . Seaford
.
,
. , , ,
.
,
. . . R.
Seaford, The Last Bath of Agamemnon, CQ 34, 2 (1984), 250-251. , ,
. J.D.
Denniston D.L. Page
. , . J. D. Denniston D.L. Page Aeschylus Agamemnon,
Oxford, 1957, 170.
,
.
. 1223-1225. , ,
, .
99
1117-1118 ( '
)
,
. ,
,
, ,
.
.
.
.
; (. 1119).
, 1121-
1122 ( ,
).238 . 1120-1124,
,
,
. ,
.
,
.
238 Booth
. .
, . N. B. Booth, Two Passages in
Aeschylus Agamemnon, Eranos LXXVII (1979), 85-95.
, . J. de Romilly, La crainte et l angoisse dans le theater s
Eschyle, Paris, 1971, 30.
100
1125-1129 ,
.
,
, (. 1125), .
: (. 1125).239
.240
.
.241
(.
239 Fraenkel, ,
.
. , ,
.
. Fraenkel
, ,
. . . Fraenkel, .. (1950), . .
1124. . , . 421.
240 , .
R. F. Goheen, Aspects of Dramatic Symbolism in the Agamemnon AJPh 87 (I955)
II3-37 I. Zeitlin, The Motif of the Corrupted Sacrifice in Aeschylus' Oresteia," TAPhA
96 (I965) 463-508 I. Zeitlin, Postscript to Sacrificial Imagery in the Oresteia (Ag.
1235-37), TAPhA 97 (1966), 645-653 G. Ferrari, Figures in the Text: Metaphors and
Riddles in the Agamemnon, CQ 92, 1 (1997), 1-45 R. Seaford, Homeric and Tragic
Sacrifice, TAPhA 119 (1989), 87-95 P. Vidal-Naquet, .. (1988), 155-82 J. Heath,
.. (1999), 17-47
241 O Schneidewin
,
. . Schneidewin ( Fraenkel, .. (1950), 510.
, . P. Vidal-Naquet,
.. (1988), 155-82.
101
1126-11127)242
, , . ,
,
.
. 1130-1135 .
,
.
.243
,
. 1133-1135,
.
, ,
,
.244
.
.
. .
; (. 1138).
242 , . Denniston J.D.-Page, D.L., .. (1957),
170.
243 , . J.H.
Oliver, Athenian Expounders of Sacred and Ancestral Law, Baltimore, 1950, 6-17, 24-
25 J. C. Kamerbeck, Prophecy and Tradegy, Mnemosyne 18 (1965), 29-40 J. P.
Vernant, Parole et signs muets, Divination et rationalit, Paris, 1974, 9-26 H. A.
Shapiro, Oracles-Mongers in Peisistratid Athens, Kernos 3 (1990), 335-345 J.N.
Bremmer, Prophets, Seers, and Politics in Greece, Israel, and Modern Europe,
Numen 40, 2 (1993), 150-193 B. C. Deitrich, Oracles and Divine Inspiration, Kernos
3 (1990), 157-174 . -, , :
, , ,
1995, 29-61.
244 . . , .. (1994), 40-41.
102
:
;
. Fraenkel ,
.245 van Heusde ( Wecklein)
,246
.247
,
1138 1087,
.
,
,
(, . 1139).
, .
(, . 1140)
( . 1140) ,
.248
245 . . Fraenkel, .. (1950), 518-19.
246 1087,
() ;
247 Denniston-Page Fraenkel
. . Denniston J.D.-Page, D.L., .. (1957), 173.
248 , .
, ,
103
.249
(. 1144). , ,
, ,
, (. 1148).250 , ,
, ,
(. 1149).
.
, . 1140-1145,
. ,
, Headlam,
. , , 1148
, ,
.
.
,
. .
.
.
: ,
.
, . , . ,
3. 193, 3, , 60-67, , .
, . .
249 , . Fraenkel
,
, , . . . Fraenkel, . . (1950), 519-520.
250 . W. Headlam, Agamemnon of Aeschylus with Verse Translation, Introduction and
Notes, Cambridge, ed. Pearson, 1910, . 1148. . , .
, .. (2000), 308.
104
:
.251
, , .
.
. 1150-1155
. , ,
.
.
,
. . 1202 '
' .
(. 1156-1161)
. , ,
.252
, ,
.
, , .
. 251 Fraenkel Denniston-Page
. 1529
. 1011, . . .
, .. (2000), 309.
252 . Mitchell-Boyask
R. 1156 ,
. . 685-
762, . . R.
Mitchell-Boyask The marriage of Cassandra and the Oresteia, TAPhA 136 (2006),
269-297: 272.
105
.
1162
;,
, (.
1163 ). Grassi 1162
- ,
-.253
.
1164-1165 .
,
.
. Goward,
,
,
.254
.
(. 1167-1174)
.
, .
.
, .
253 . E. Grassi, Macht des Bildes: Ohnmacht der rationalen Sprache, Kln, 1970, 90.
254 . B. Goward, .. (2002), 161.
106
, .255
, . 1417.256
1172
. 257
, ,
,
,
1177 ( ' ).
1177 .
, ,
,
, ,
.
.
.
-
, -. ,
.
. , -
.
255 . . 1278, . . I. Zeitlin, .. (I965)
463-508 R. Seaford, .. (1989), 87-95 P.Vidal-Naquet, .. (1988), 155-82.
256 . . 1417, , , . 1417.
257 : ,
, ,
. . E. , .. (2000), 314.
107
,
.
.
.
,
.
.
) (. 1178-1197)
,
, .
.
.
, .
, , ,
. ,
,
.
'
(.1178-1179).
Seaford,
,
.258 ,
258 , Seaford, : )
(. 1277)
(. 783, 950), ) , (.
1322), ) )
,
108
,
.
.
, ,
, .
.
,
, ,
.
.
,
, .
.
(. 1178-1179).
. 1180-1183, 259 (
), ,
(1049, 1054), )
, (. 1048, 1063, 1066, 1071), )
,
(. 1178-1183). . R. Seaford, ..(1987), 128.
,
,
.
.
-, . R. Mitchell-Boyask, .. (2006), 269-297 R. Rehm, Marriage to
Death. The Conflation of Wedding and Funeral Rituals in Greek Tragedy, Princeton,
1994.
259 , . M.S. Silk, Interaction in poetic imagery,
Cambridge, 1974, 197 S. Goldhill, .. (1984), 85.
109
, .
Lebeck
,
,260
,
.
1180
,
.
(. 1183),
1181-1182 ,
, ,
.
,
,
.
1183, ,
, . ,
(. 1184),
. , ,
, ,
.
(.
1186). (. 1185),
, 1094-1095,
260 . A. Lebeck, The Oresteia: a Study in Language and Structure, Washington, 1971,
69.
110
. .
,
, ,
.
.261 ,
, ,
(. 1188). ,
(. 1190),
( , .
1187) (. 1190).
1190 ,
.262
. ,
,
. , ,
261 , .
,
, ,
,
. ,
.
. . E.
Fraenkel, .. (1950), 543-544.
262 , . N. G. L. Hammond, Personal Freedom
and its Limitations in the Oresteia JHS 85 (1965), 42-55 L. Brown, The Erinyes in
the Oresteia: Real Life, the Supernatural, and the Stage, JHS 103 (1983), 13-34 R.
C. T. Parker, Miasma, Oxford, 1983 I. Zeitlin Postscript to Sacrificial Imagery in the
Oresteia (Ag. 1235-37), TAPhA 97 (1966), 645-653. H. Bacon, The Furies
Homecoming, CPh 96 (2001), 48-59.
111
. ,
,
.263 De Romilly
,
.264
1192
,
.
, (. 1192-1193).
,
.
.
. ,
,
.
.
, ,
. , ,
. , , . 1195-1196
263 ,
,
, 763-771.
.
,
: )
,
)
.
. , . .
264 . J. de Romilly, .. (2008), 61.
112
,
. ,
,
.
(. 1198-1213)
(. 1198).
, ,
, .
1200-1201
. , ,
, ,
(. 1202).265 , ,
.
1150 1174. , ,
,
.
-
.
. . 1203
265 1202 : )
) .
, , .
113
.266
, ,
1204, (
). ,
.
.
.
(. 1206).
; (. 1207).
. Mitchell-Boyask
:
-.267
,
(. 1208).
,
(.1211)
,
(. 1212).
266 Fraenkel
. . . Fraenkel. .. (1950), 555. Neblung
. . D. Neblung, .. (1997), 27, .
26.
267 . Mitchell- Boyask, .. (2006), 277.
114
(. 1213).268
-
. 1202-1213
. , ,
.
.
1208 ,
() . ,
,
.
.
,
. ,
, .269
,
,
. , ,
268
. 1136 . 1256
1315.
269 . , 3, 151, 5. , .
115
.270
, , :
.
,
.
,
(. 1195).
(. 1208).
. Leahy,
,271
.
.
. '
; (. 1211) ,
.
,
.
270 , . ,
, . ,
.
. Barra 1206
-
, . . Barra, (1993),
Mazzoldi, .. (2001), 109, . 50.
271 . D.M. Leahy, The Role of Cassandra in the Oresteia, BRL 52, 1969, 152.
116
,
,
,
.
.
) (. 1214-1241)
1214 ,
.
1215 .272
(. 1216).
,
.
.
(. 1217-1218).
(. 1219).
.
, 1192.
,
272 . .
. 1195.
117
.
(. 1123).
. (. 1223-1224)