167
{Q ntscnr, 2 3 [1 fl, 2538 ___9 .{ { u - s n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr rendrl Ta z rn r rnrifi rurlrrfru a"urifi ruua nTa rrn r r lt : nra'lurrauurfiuilu trE{rrninnrf,uffla{rlr frearrrtr I isuicefiarrii I TIIE COI{PARATIVE STUDIES OF SOCIO-ECONO}IIC OF FOREST VILLAGE PROJECT AND WITSOUT FOREST VILLAGE PROJECT CASE STUDY : IN BUFFER ZONE OF HUAI KUA KHAENG WILDLIFE SANCTUARY UTHAITHANI PROVINCE in0n a arnr'trad 0n 0bb1n a5fi t n a T irudfi , ft Crundr r a t n r rllnrr n undnrfn ziliir5lrina rcrdnrunrfrf,n curiilT r naTltaiinrruinr rdou.ni"n sqqe--- uililn?na1aa l|n1?na,latrnnl r.c.2538 360? 5 4J.U9'o 2

n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

{Qntscnr,

2 3 [1 fl, 2538

___9 .{ { u - sn.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr rendrlTa z rn r rnrifi rurlrrfru a"urifi ruua nTa rrn r rlt

: nra'lurrauurfiuilu trE{rrninnrf,uffla{rlr frearrrtrI

isuicefiarriiI

TIIE COI{PARATIVE STUDIES OF SOCIO-ECONO}IIC

OF FOREST VILLAGE PROJECT AND WITSOUT FOREST VILLAGE PROJECT

CASE STUDY : IN BUFFER ZONE OF HUAI KUA KHAENG

WILDLIFE SANCTUARY UTHAITHANI PROVINCE

in0na

arnr'trad

0n

0bb1na5fi

t n a T irudfi , ft Crundr r a t n r rllnrr n undnrfn ziliir5lrina rcrdnrunrfrf,n

curiilT r naTltaiinrruinr rdou.ni"nsqqe---uililn?na1aa l|n1?na,latrnnl

r.c.2538

360? 5

4J.U9'o 2

Page 2: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

{-a?na1uuutr

, {ro-9.dqltt--n1?cnr1 r ilrar r frau6'rur crrgile-frtnr zsfl ,jr{Tnrtnrrrarifirurlrlfr

aV$flur4lg114uanTnttnrrI

nrfrifinrr nra'tur nnuuzfiudu sa.s r roinrrfiufaqirl-rfirasrut.r9oeedc{u,leonafl1u

t{oH11At

I

,!*' 0^4-^r?od-uI|UBT lAdr8rU.lt. ,t-

dn|l|ileuqqoUJI?|0?na1n8

Ph. D.

-erbD{ .Q^--

ruru.rf s{Ida,no.u., ?n.r.tJrcs run r xil n l rn ?unu?na rilcJufJ \>J..m,r6...W*.6fierl ilild, ?n. u. , r,r. s.

{-Cil?na1u$ilg

-".-'.....:. ..... ......rlrsduila u1ra1$nfi1, Dip. FS. , ?n. u.n ? Tiln'l rn r unrina riluufI

. .(.zy:,.iL . y:t{.y:. ... . . . ....ee{ae e 'l?aa n8{uU,l{. P. H.

ilrsrrunflcn ? lrn 1 ?ilrcirudn6fe rtnarcrdotnarfisiq

I

drlri/r r nnTuTnin trr?ur rd.ru refrar-i.tuanuu 6t{B ?ea arua!, nira r n rCr afe i

Page 3: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

inariuu#, {ro

nr:finrr r rjiar r fisufrru r cmgfir-f,.rnl zsra.jrtTnrsnr:uriilrurhrfi

nrfidn'r : nra'ru, JlilffiT:l:;JllJ.*anq{rrrfieanruff.,r{.,ruTaafiarril

1 fr iun r r0c r rru'r aufrfi rfrfiu r fudeuHfi t n a r n r rfinrr n rrrafin dq ru?rururinarcrdnrsuirrir drnridr r nnTuTnir.r;;;;;;;;ilr"

-d?un 23 $qrR.lar w.d. ZS38

lrq qat'l1aI

I

,' ,"'!..t /--'. . ),/a/{ ,-/lnuur tltS{ul|urB.A.,}1.D.,l{.p.H.,Dr. P. H.

ilrcsrun r rrn r rdouina rfinud

\tfr, ?n. U. , l{. S.-a8',lllgufr

o{-uruq5 1n6tilEr U. il. , Ph. D.9-

nruud

fiuioinarfia ru.rinarilarfiea

J <-z,@xr^a*l al lv>-,aaaaaa..aaa

euu.,rf rt'lda, na. u. , tn. il.

s.rdfisri

ntTt|n,l

allr rinsIt tnt:tnr:a[

/

,. '7,a.a.aa..aa aaaaa

ilrsrdsila u1ra1Tnt1, Dip. FS. , tn. u.

lnsuil riiatururB.A., r{.D.,M.P.H., Dr.p.H.

{ntIile

narrfr .,1r 2qfr aru acniua rn r*rde {uurinardaufiaa

(

Page 4: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

ilt

. sQlr-uu?!r2fl3t?18

ureinih aralndar

iu riau ilrftc rg rq$din,rau zsoc

lnruilrfin unrzrftrr rlrurnf,lnr

ilrgiinrr?nnr lrtriialrlrti f,lninuri, r.d. 282o.-26282

rlrg n rcitrfie riirn r rrleli

Cninardadlru?i, r.c. 2529-26312

inercrcodnin t Cl I lilneniadrrn.tr I Rtrnr )

rnrinrrdalfine, r.C. 2534-2638:

inarcrdnrunT fficur r nn1u1eiinrruinr riru enfrnu

irundrdo"r,ilti.o"u r.c. 2536 - ilrcfir:drurhlfifinnal

irurnir: rirdnttulrtfi a

nucfi udunn r rri ri n a tinrf u r s Cenll

ffininaria unrina, daufinn, r; c. 2536

alonu2ltI

Page 5: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

QAnnnrrrrltcntC

- - J o 4. Cina'riruisfirn:iC1 r icederlrliead deanrrudea r nlatfid'rrlinnr

uusdr recer2llfitr inariru{urtnarneerln aT crziluro$ ltrila

inarirui idracrlct"."ri crn

e*rzirtr"rlr"

rtrsmunrrrn,trn?ilnuinaT iruf ererrinfried ilarrr{ nflun,tan'runrlr{.raRn8{ ntlun,|tnluauznt,tuf||t

rrsnsriiuarirrltrl E tanreiltt

I

Ittttt t

u1ra1rnr1 nrriln,|rnrunlinarirui fli{alenr.|utauIrl

!aflf1utrautlcne aartCrCnzrrtta cr. u'ttufnatnrur t$a{ttru

".od".odruzninruasnirarn zttec,i rnrinariaufine drfirfi"""untruri

iiiaauulunfirlarenr,trnr,nrrorif,ese unsdrnrrr fiuiauettt

trnaa'rureufrsne ffinina'rda unrinaeiarfice dtfiirrrcrrfiI

nldfiucuunrrririnariruf,urrCru uriffiiatl

tranzlr[eilrtsnr ieairrmran reig-urseic aldnri inrt-t

lu1rc1 rarfri{a caaclutra[eunenrrr.t una raofial.l nncr dnattfiarruItlt-!

dratuiaras?fitirdl?c urifri{aurrcarean

trElaurrsnuilrariflila aanriisr tirrfinttnlrri s Ctfintru

rlrrfi{.lrricafiarrii rirrnirilrhlsTnrrnrnliurl!trhllruuritrtri rhfiea--r

fiurla.r-fiunena21r (z) du{cnrrdiurlrlrzunrirrri Crfintrurtr1$t m

unrcrrtd oru 3 irnfirdr minrT f,uf,fu{rlT firarrsis lnrirudrfitfinrruI

eur az"oriiufirutarn ulscorr,il r."..udruranrrucunrnhnlr r filfre1er--it

laleuracq{rnriilru uanirefitr nrifirunirillurd ndfrrlr lrtr?1{ ndfirurtrtiar iluazsdr irtnrerufln {lninefiatTii priru dffr

iruzanrudsnrnrastfinnriru;lelunrreeuuuuceuo,tutn{{ii" r iluadrlii

lar'urzlrnar irnfird"rodon"niau uesnirarntl.m{ priruilarr dariarfiun,rricderlrcrhurrurnr{iia Tnr I lttsadrtCsrf'ranrrinrr il

-.t2t|tlnt

t frtfin e T ucsn rnlun r ried n I e in{etun r zriT ina rinrf

nre.lnri

Page 6: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

n

ef 'l1at

dainarilsu{ nrrilnyr r rlf sil r fiardrur cr5ir-f,tnl rcudr{Tnt{n1r

rarifi rurlr'1fi un"urifituuontnr{fl 1r

nrdfrnrr : nralurrnuurfiudu tattlninrrfiuff,n{rlTtAtusu{u?ar1tl[{ 1{u,ta8nat1u

I

inin azrutudtt

il?rUrU.r inarCrdntlrarfiruin ( t nnTu'taiinT zu?urzdourafral I

eilsn ??$n r zn euntina rirufaugtf rtIia, no. u. , ?n. r.srtdfi*rl ilarn.d, ?n. u. , t{. s.

drr rinss, dd. u. , tn. il.

ilrcdsfa il1ra1snsr, Dip. FS., ?n. u.

{uddrrfrnrzfinrr 2z sqrn'lnrt r.c.2538

uaunncEa

nrzilnrrriliaurfiau frT urOtr1fir-f,tnl zcr,l'ir{Tnz.rnrzH{ilru

rl,r'tfi un"udffruusntn:.,tnrr nrdifinrt nratut lquurfiudula'c r nntnrrfru{,r

ln{rlrfiratrutr {.ruicafiasril dr riunrrle snrtttuuudaunu t fiur.ut.n

taua r"ra,i'r.riud 1-10 "Uu.."u

zsae drnrrdaunu crnfieufirnraunir{'-li rurrniludtnrrnrr{marifirurlr'tfr firuniudcugt,ii'lt ?uro{T1soTna1f,ata r --,--,---lq4l

1?4 e1 tdntuuiaaau 9E.oBl uasfirufirnralnir la{l.rr0tdarHaa{uan

r roTnrrnrziararifirurlr'lil fia radilrut rrrrrti'luxu ?o qil tfic riutaaa"

sz. LL, uarradilT ut lr t iiarilu'lu 104 nu t fic r flu{aaag 97 .2ol udrriru q ' ,- -go-.--- ^---) a rr c- --..:X--^-ofl-oarr.Jad J 'rs!ora r.l? r nr.uJTe attlrlrunrlCr r irnlCruiu'truiianrtf,tnucrdoi ddd

drfftunrri r nr.rrritaua 'tfiuri n.lruln$1o...od irisaat ir r tda ir, d,o r uuyrnrt.u n.lnrdauuurfi'taadruuc'lfiiifiadrf,sunrtaifidtsfiu o - os

r fluudntun r zn51daldulf Iru u asn r zi t n t."rin r rnno a srU

Page 7: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

!

Hnn.rzflnr.trud,l r""grdu"flaailurrrTnrtnrr'r ilnrruunnirl

nrrdrurczrtiq fiurtordarflae{uan r rnrarln,rr'r edrtiifiaCrf,flnrtlfii

nirriia zrngz?utlnTnttnt:r iinatdeniernn'rrilrrrneua rih r sdadail

r rirfiu 14, 1s9 . s t il'ln 1ln'irzrrgtuan t nntnrtn"r. ioiitraf frlni, od"

iaitrrirfiu rr,gg6.er u.n zrro:luranTnrrnrrr iiaruu.ni"in.lf,rurf.lq1g-{.a9!'deio

n.l ro an a a tnnunrtuafinu a g ilr rfin fiuruatuen r lnTa t tn r rra d r riifi adrftlI

nrrtfifi ni.rriia nno:lu r rcTnrrnrniinT tiia"ttodat f;l?uednunrile1fiu

rrnn.irzporuan r lnTnrrnrrr Taartroflur rntarrnttt iidiutenzar?u{{edn rsdanrauniras 9.zg Id unsluilrefiurcdanrauairas 21.og Id

nruirf,u CrlnroruanI rnTarlnrtn iideuo'anrartuain, oi""r"onfres

T.oL'ti ualr'luilcriiutodr"r.u"ieau 10.69 ld nrud'rf,u drunruHat

n1:neunllEd-{<t.-t-roiliuilriarrsstinrrdtdn rrit l1ltot?ullnTnrlnrn ine{R.|tnnrn.|n|l.lr.-

J o -r t - , u & . ttoaanzaunr?as z5.Tz \i CrurrraruaflltnTnz{n1n SatnrriCnrirdn

.lersean?aunr?as 25.26 li

frrudnrrnr.rf,las ru'ir rrnottutlntnr{n1n itnrzririzufir

n:rui1{1 uT nn'ir z'trgtunfl l tnT{nrrr firun,trilnrrzrr3rlut !fltat{n1r.r ilt:r I iaurlrui'rnrifiT u Crurrtozrsn r lnTntlnrzlrriii uenrugrtu

r lnTn rrnrrritar run rcniltunr rilnrrunz lrndt tlrotreR I rn1crtn.tn

n i r u ii e r rrArlu MTn I { n 1 rrCrutrui'lfrfr rn e "trn

rcnillun r rilarl I e {ur tfra cuzsrf,ua,rilrilnrr ClrzrroruaRr!e'[nr{R1r'r Currrmifrsriiia ruzsf,u

rlrgardntn fi,ruunirirllnrrarllna uilnn r,trottrt lnTnt{tt'ln tfirtfi rilrsilrq

"n, Crrdilincir r'1fi

'C.r,r."otunn Mlnt {n r tr If,ttfir arltan

ui1an crnfirdu uarrudirilnaa{ rrrgffurlntarsntrr sasrrtgfuafl

1 trntnr{n1z.r iifiguniianrzauinifln{rh nrrnlinfrlr'tfi nrnllnrlr{liluIt

ualrln z rn r rinndfi rurlr'tfr Cunnd r r fiua d r tiifi aCrf,qnr tlii ni r ziin t'rrot

lur lnTn:{n1r.r iffiguniilddanrrntinff,n{tl" nrzarlTnfrhlfi Tann,rzin

nrifirurl.rlfiuarr;ifiguci?lrodurlruna r tianrtrlandrtliln Crurrlotusfl 1 !e

Tn zrn r zr iifiruairursf,urtrunarri en r:auinfln'trlr ue"iificunfi drddia

nrzilanilriliu uarz1ntsnrr{nnifitulrrfr-----a-- - 'nrzauinfrlrrfi

Page 8: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

Thesis Title

Nane

Degree

Thesis

The Conparative Studies of Socio-Econonic of

Forest Village Proiect and without Forest

Village Proiect

Case Study : in Buffer Zone of Huai Kua

Khaeng I{ildlife sanctuary uthaithani Provinee

Yipusit Arunnai

Master of Science (Technology of Environnent)

SupervisorY Connittee

Sonpong Thongchai' M- Sc-

Pongpit Piyapongse, B. Sc., H. S'

Sukun Phuthong, B. A.' l{- Sc.

Prasopchai Nanlabudha' Dip. FS.' B. Sc'

Date of Graduation 22 l{ay B.E. 2538 (1995)

ABSTRACT

The conparative studies of socio-Econonic of Forest

village Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case

Study : in Buffer Zooe of Huai Kua Khaeng l{ildlife Sanctuery

Uthaithani provinee HBs conducted by neans of queetionnaire

during Decenber 1-10,1993 fron L74 case of population in Ban

Subsonbun Tunbol Rabam Anphoe Lansak Uthaithani Province in

Buffer Zone of The Huai Kua Khaehe ttitdlife Sanctuary' or

insid.e Forest village Proiect ( IFP) and L7 4 c&se of

population in outside Forest village Proiect (oFP) (7O case

fron Ban Khoakhang and 104 case fron Ban Khoakhuaw).

Page 9: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

The dat,a lrere analyzed by means of the SPSs/Pc+ and.

statistic used Uere frequency , precentage ' neans ,standard

deviation , t-Lest , BUltiple regression analysis and set

statistical significant at 0.05.

The results show that the different in Econonic are:

average incone per year (IFP show higher than OFP)' past and

present land owner (IFP nore than OFP).

The different in Social are:ioin in Eovernentproiect

(IFP nore Lhan OFP), education (IFP nore than OFP) , chidren

educat,ion expected (IFP higher Lhan OFP) and water resource

( IFP better than OFP).

statistical different in attitude of wildlife

conservation , forest conservation , public forest plant and

forest village project are : IFP show highly attitude of

wildlife conservation , forest conservation and forest's

viIlaEe project and nodurately attitude of public forest

plant but OFP shott nodurately attitude of wildlife

conservation and lowly at,titude of forest conservation'

public forest plant and forest's village proiect'

Page 10: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

drrfiru

un6nianrrrrna

unfie ianmrdtnqr

r{r:firu

drrfirunrtrt

bt1

iln

It4u1

n

a

1

n

alUfUR'ls{n

t unri'r

"l1. 1 nr,tuacn?rudtfiflrasilrlur

t.2 {nnrlrcg.td

1.3 dutfigrulasnlri{ae{-r.4 sruurntff'tunrrifa

1. s lBln rnnrri{a1,6 ilairfietunrriiat.. 7 ilarlf,sf,d'tfl'tunrziie

1. I rltcrar{dnredlrc'tfiiu?unrrilnnri{a

2 nilil?u??TfInTtr.{ dr

2. t dr t uqnrraaa{ra{iiuirlrlfr

z. z nluuunrr{ourifirurlT ril. z.g nqriluaouurfie'tunr:iia

2.4 sruiiad,da.frao

L

7

7

I

13

13

L4

16

t7

2I

22

26

Page 11: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

o

-ua5['ltufll ( q0 )

Juu1

{unn

Adr { {s3 ?fle1[UUn1T?14

3. I rlzsirnt r ilrulta 35

3.2 nrtCrfrrairtuaorule tra{ndilfieoa'r.r 35tl

8.3 ,"{roiirdltlunrziia 35

qdas. a idnrrilnrr 3T

qs4 arafl11'l1a

d-lv'{lnauil r nrri t ntrctitaln t fiarfruinrrusfir'til [0{tltcil1nr 46

nriuf,rairsurifi rurlrrfr ilruntsiatuz,i ua"u{firu--i--'---- t I t

uanlnr\iflrtudfirurlT 1frfiT ur n1r?1\t ilrut rr t if arI

rdrilnrcdr drtnaaruf,n itu{eafialrfiI

,uud z nr:i,nzrtriilauardarfiualnrutctr5fielo{rlruilr- 57I

nrneilf,rsirs nriilrurlr'lfi ilT uniui*outti uasruri'---'i-- | t I

ilruuanrnt.rnrnarifirurlT tilfirut rM1\i firut lrt

g,- -t[41 n'luatsil'l a'l[flan'lufln a{ r

,rud g nrti,nr.otirurrrluluratnrrlihfiufrura'ir.rfrruilt 68

6dzuunrgfrrfir zratdenilo'snir r iaudail ro{

rrrazlut rqTntsnr:u{firurlrrfr firuniuieogtt$

uao r,rrifiruuon1nz',tnrzurifirurlr'til ilrur D1r?'l{railrut lr r tar siruatt li'l dr tnaaruf,n ituTa

o<a0nag'luI

{ { lqt - 4-^g-nauii a nrrirnrrrfitotatfiarfiudnrsnrtf,tnurotiltcdr- 77

nrniuf,radrt radfirurlr'til ffrunisd*nltri uatr,rd'- ---i- -- 1 | t

firuuanTn:.rnr:udfirurlrlilfiruMr11\i u'tut lrtfiar siruatsril l.,nr..uf,n {.ru{aqfiarT il

Page 12: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

il

naud 5

qaud 6

qaud 7

drrfiru < oia I

- ( . qr u !- . -!r----r-n 1T? [ n T'lsrl4l.r1TilUUUsA {A ?'lilfiilfiUdtsU'j't {d?uil?

g

idrvua 1 afr rfiua r 1ile 1 or4d{1un T rfrnr1 s a { uo ? ! o {I

?lrartur DCITa?{nT :r,rdfiT urh'tfr firunf;urdauutol

unr railfiT uuanTnztnrturifirurl'r'til ilrut rltr?1\tt!u

firur sr t tar oiruatsilr eir tnoaluf,n i'-rraTe

s{anafl1uI

nrri , ur.od r iltal r fiaudnrunrztdrt.rtin luadn

fililqcfiu ro{ilrcdrntneiufirari'r'rra{fiT urlT rfr ff'ru99t|

n ffu d aru u tnl u n "uil fi 1 uu a n 1 R I .r n r traq! fi rurJ r t fr fi T u

srt

r n'1tr?1{ firur rr t tar eilunrsrilr dr tnoaruf,neud1{r4',loangf,'lu

I

nrri, nr.rfrt.un r dsrfiufieunfi fl4.iil?cd,tnznringl

94

Ivtu.l

LOz

108

dilnn

ilTtlu.luflTtlI

alnalu?fl fl

n,lnruu?fl !

q . au | ,,ug s t , -.-t rufi r o d r r uriururl r't nuruniua6lilurtll uasu{tl,tuuafl

a!l!l

Tnttnrturifirurlrri ilrur r1n11{ firur !'l r iia?

sirila:cdr" n.rnaarufln i.rr,tioafialrfi

drileranr tiiauas fr a t duauue

5. 1 dzrlwanrtiia

s.z ffn t duouusc'lnaran.rtiisu

s. g fia t duouucdruiunrtriri{ant'rsia'til

E.L oiilrrawan, ri{a

116

L22

1,2,3

t24

t26

130

131

Page 13: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

n

dq1?'l{n

alru firl|nttrt

dr rnaaruf,neooq1{U?AAnAfl'lU

d

vt4u'l

q ls { o q,----- !i^n1?i I nl1cuisila I naxfiilf,nr$lrfrr'til !0{il?sd1fl?I

I e . .e t -!, 7t L !, I tsnriu6radr{u{tl1uil1'tu u'lun11la6[rurru unsu{u1u

rtl9

uon1nt{tn'rzrarifirurh'tfffirur f, 1tr'l'l.t firur !1 t iia?

sirunrsdr air tnaaruf,n {tuTeafrasru

n r ri r n t r rri ta I a r d a r fi udR ru r dtrtn' q r a'$ il ?s d'l -t

nrnairfi'lair.r uriil'rurlr'tfi fiT uniniaultnl uasurigltt

firuuan1nrsnrtudilrurlrtfrffrut !'lt'11'l ilrur lr!!

{ ' '!- drtnanrudn isuiaofiarrfit f,a? n,luaTsu'l a1[ flan'luail 'l\t r

Bdn.lernfl1tne aloun?rtunndIttt u'i'l.ri. r sda ta{

:T a'tfrcniro{exailniedail na'ru{firulu1nztnrtst

n{ fi rurl rr fi il'run tn ieu o t,$n utnri il ruua n1n r'*r n r tt

rarifirurh'tfi firur !18?'l{raofiru t lr r ilart

uda.rarantrile af aila1ruunndttznra'iItdr t "dt !a\t

f{{Hunnanra{ D0{?"rrarlurnztnrzra{firurlr'|fi firu9

oatnruanrutiluas r ,trarusnrn r{nrru{ilrurlrrfi fi rut-l

Ud[ 11[?1\i llnsil'lil[ [1[ trA?

ude.ifl an'l ?neblailn ?'liluond 1 {tou'i't sci r, "du

! a {

fit dfi r o t t.,tluo dn a o "t z tg :lu'tn t's n t :u{ilrurl rr fiI

u e t . I rv 'firuniwicililTtit uacrltra?udfrru uan'[nx{n1lutl

fi rurlrlilfi 1u r tr1!t'l tuatil'tu t r1 r fi a?

G u6fe{Hanltnedalnrruunnsirttsu'i'l'lgir,odt !o{e dq . q - -------o 'Dnx'lr6a{nT rilduriT fiu [f, {I1s6ltu1n?{n'l?w'[1u

rl r't fi fi run is 6 *l u tdu acu{ fi ruua ntn t'0 n 1 n4ri il'lu-i ------' t I

rjrrfifirur rltrt1\i unofi'tut lr t ilsa

46

57

64

65

66

67

Page 14: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

0l

de1?1{n

drziiilnr:r.t t eia I

udo.suanrri r nrrorioe naasr4e$ r dorfin"uuu?14It

'tfrenis a.,rnzaun f rsiailr attrr4ttuTnrtnr tu{ilrut--t|

rJrrff firuniuiauutui uasr,rtro?uan1nr'cnrt nooI

rJ9,d['tut [1t?'l{ unsillut B'l I n8'l n.tuatsu,t a,t rRa

arufrn i.ru{oafiarril tfiufieurlrnru loara'an'ttI

o d d<- t 1, -,-!36 ?ua 1n ?fu t ou1Enrua6t1efln1 {flnq

u de si r f, r r.l s"lnf rrafltfiud tvu'i r.rf, ruil zB et" dn n

<lartrr aon r ['16[ultu11afl{t

a tltt { un 1 ?1 r n i1cr4! arn t fl g ?nu5tn1$n1 {f, {nI r a {il?ctr-

t

nzneildrairt rarifiT urlrlfr firunindglltr$ uauu{tr!|l

ilruuanTnr.,rn'rtradilrurlr'tfffirur tr1!?'l{ fr'tut lr{.qt-a,-eo-J!riiar druazurir drtnaaruiln {suTeafiarrd

ude .gc|an1ti r nt'rtrinanBasun$ r dalfinuuuun?1r

n 1 au i{'lufl 1 iAnyl um n, o r.iaz'tuTn z t n r zrad fi ru

rlr'!fi firunisdgutltr$ rasr,rtratuanTn?{n'l? 6a

9.t',<lfrrur !1r'11{ uasrl"tu[ ['l I f a? o1ilarcil'l g1[no

n1u6lfl i.ruioafiasT ii t flufrrurltqru Ie a t iionrtg

fi rus r n rd, **. o difi adrdrunr',r efi fi

u do.ri rf,r rt trRnf, eraf,lfiud tsu'i r sf, ru I tiatudqn

r a'on r frrCuuuilao{

vl,tu1

75

95

101

68

77

10

11

Page 15: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

fu

drtfirunrtrt <sial

dq1T1{nI

14111

LO2

108

109

110

111

tt2

rz nT ti, nrrtri r rliau t fiaudn'rnnT ttf ru 'rtin luadq

fiuilecfiu ro{iltcd,rnznriruffrarirsradfirurlrrfr firuo I I tu 'at t -uY

n iu d dil I zrir u a curi I .tuua nTn s { n 1 Tu{ u'lutJ 1'( rll'lu

;;;;;;: fi.;, nl, t,. cirunrsdr "ui.,o,u.unn

tuodq{ul0anaf1uI

13 uda.ralawfiqsiolisosfifdlgnfur nqTnttn'rtrariilT u LA7

rlr'1ff uacuofl t nq1n:tn r:ndfi rurl'r'tfr

t4 udo.ttsfiufidunfi rasr.tartiroz'snrzrarifirurlrrff

ua!, r'ltaxuafl t snTntsn."radil.urlrri danrz

oufn{f,o{ilr

1b uJoor^n.rne daunrratnnnq',.."t tou'ir"rri' ada

fi dun fi n a I z r ro t1 ur n t t n I tr'r { fi r url r t fr u n s t'l lto r

ua n I rora r',r n 1 narifi rurl arfi i rn., oqinf f,n {rlr

16 ude'0zcfiutr..arr-z*aztul"ron.l*'ifirur6'tfit!flu rlratuan r rntnttn.nn,ifiT u'ltri e'ionrt

ouinfrlrrfi

rr udo{o,afl,..tnodauqrruunneirt eor'r'irsir t *dt

fi cun fi r a .,r t ,trg zluT n r t n r ruri fi rurl r1 fru n e t 1ro T

uafl t rnTntsnrtudfirurJ, lfi danrtaqfn{rlrrfr

1B udo{tsfiui-..tt.-r."artu,"'onti"ifirurlr'tiu a s I 1ra ?uo n t r nt n t t n r nari fi rurl rr fi nl a n t :rtn n

rhduduI

19 udot,anrrne daunrrruumneir.o rsu'irtir t*utt 113

fi aunfi u o',1 t rratt uT n t s n r rra{ il rurl rr fr u a u r 'lito ?I

uon r !oTnr{n1zradfi'rurlr'tff rdanrtrl4nrlT {ulu

Page 16: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

a

drtfiilnr:rt t sia I

d0111 {n

Il{u'l

20 udq{trdufiOunfisa.,rtrrqtlulnttnrturifirurl'rf ff IL4

' uac ?'lrarilon t nnTn t s n r turifi rurltrf i lr*' {n 1 r

ioradil'rurlTrfr

ZL udoraranrrnodauorruuoneirs rtra'ir.reir t odu 115

fi aunfi r o t : lr4ttuTn z t n r rra{ilrurl r't ffu at t rro t

u o fl r f, oT n r,! n 1 *a ri fi .rurl.rr fi J or n r.r n r r io raqi ff ru

rlrrfi

Page 17: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

a

gild

d'r:iirunrs

Histrogran-Standardized Res idaul ude{finrils

fl 1Tnrcl1aua.0irnr1!n.te r adtta !o.tuuui'lao',ttjt!,

lruir rratfianirs{nrailairdail so{t'lrar'lut ln

Tnrtnrtrarifirurjrrfi firunind*ult,$ uas'11ro?uon

r rsrnrtnrzrarifi'rurlrrfi fitur r1t't'l\i firur rr t f,aa

siruazcdr airtnoaruf,n i.ruieqfiarT il

udar Nornal Propability',"-r) Plot la'sdr

standard ized, Residaul ratuuui'tno{rlrt'ilrilir

r r s'(fr*nif, a {n I aun ird ail [ a { I 1r0?'tu t rnrnt'{n'l r

udfirurlr'tfr firuniuirtrurr$ uae?'lr0luanllqTnrs

nrmdilrurlrlfi firur r1t?1{ firur lr t ilae tf run

:lrilr rit t naatuf,n i',rraic qfiarT il

udet standard,ized s..t]te"prot rsu'irtf,ruilr

o1u1'lfln1tiltctrluri1 (PREDI fiuirnr,trtnn.te,tdtu

( RESI D ) ! a \iuuui ra a {ilsslt'tuirzr 41fi enin a'rn rail

ntrdail ra{?,rrorlutlnTnrtnrzra{fi'rurlrlfi ffru

niwdcr pt,$u ar r.ro?uan t rnI n zn t tud fi rurl r'tfi fi rutod

r n'lt'l1{ ulut rl [ trE? qruatcdr dr tnaaruf,n

ooed1{r{?e anafl1u

Dt4u'l

73

T4

72

Page 18: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

5

..1rilnt

dr:firunrw < sio )

Histrogram-standardized Residaul ude'{frnrils

111s1ue1aEa.0fi1nx'lrn1a,""ttu Ia{uuuf'lna{il?s

il1ilei1 n21iln1or4l.rtunrrfrnr1unl ro{11rAllut ln

rnttnttrariil'rurlr'tfi firuniud*rUt,$ uau?1tr4?u8fl

r rCIlnttnrrurifirurlrtfi firur tr1r2'l.l firur lr t iise

oiruazsrdr ui. lnr*.uf,n {',ru{aqfiarrfi

ude t NornaI Propability 'a"-")

Plot ra'rir

Stand.ardized Resid,aul rasuuuiraatrlt"urmir

n ?'r r n 1 nu 1.r1un r tfi fl r 1 ilq ? [ o t r tg z'lu t ln1n r's n r t

urifirurlr'til firuntn,$a"irfi $ac?ltraruonr lnTn:t

nrturifiT url'rrfr ffrur tr1tr't1\i ilrur rr r iiar sirun

rsrir drtnonruf,n itvrlcafiamfi

udos standard, ized.sc"t]t""prot ztcudr'ifiruilt

o'lrur'Iflfl1tilrlrrlild1 (PREDI fiuirar,trna,ta r"dt*( REsrD ) [ a{ttuttira o',ttJ:cu rui 'tn rrln rnuTt'tun'lr

finrrunt ro{1lrorlutln1nzsnrzu{fiT urlrrfi firuniuderu zulu at r."o ruon r tq1n zn r :radfi rurl rr i ff ru

u{M[?1.t ll'lUt ['11[E?sosd1{U'le Enat'lu

d'tuazuiir d'r tnoaT ufln

U1.1u1

100

98

99

Page 19: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

und 1

unu.l

$u.uu"o,l rudrfirut o'cilruur

rtrs r nclna , f,r,rlrr r ngderiluui r ra r rn r iuXu{1nr itii4ia, n'rc

* oui"r.ilr. ir r iiuutri sdanreuu "do."

r ila irue a?fiiin r trna 1nile 1 t tr a tdtii

tinlrnrT a r liiauufil I f,uCuinart urilazuua.ttile'tanrtilenrr (Eio

d ive rs 1y ) iiirf,u{rl rt iu ns f, n {rl rne u trin r fi nlsua {u d{n run r zdrlrt fr I n r

rJzs, I nftnaiuiteliiu d'riulzsdufiuilrlnrnrzanatad'l{zle r irluteu zo ild

cirurr n"r,inn*r.re.rrlrstrnz rirrfiiliirrcnrzu:irnnnira"nr,infr,, ut"

ic.rru'r r rliau r fi auf,nCrur rn fisrrnrz r Cuiurn srltsdrnt fiunrr, iuft n t o

nira rn zlurs aouds iin rruunnir.rfiua d r{r1n ruri, lfi innCru t liaian"z

rtnira rn riiuurtfiuroa {na an r re 1 uasil'lnirururltsilrn zfi la I r iulsu'tu

Snrrdllneac'trl ?ldlnuundfi"oo."n".t dodi. r iuCrniunrrdlrtilin luile rncrcaunir;rnr' ' " -'-iaonrclfi uecluileeffutrrrfiuililn,rn.trtr,tgunaunirarn:inuinqClfrunirilan.tcl. llatl'l r

nrftffdfiu,dro",Iornr .tdlaT af,rarirtrrar ir,dro".nn."i'""'innrrn 1 ? I nrnz r a rtna f rttiiln r z r Cu,rn,ri.nono" "rird

I rr.rrlgnitfr r iusasin

tn attn rrinrtnrl r naTuleii n.,, ior"sinnrtn'lt I flDnzls a rflan I rl|nln

f, ,.d.r rri i r n r rr tl r sr a rddiuildnrse f, r ni r r r !, ri a?fi r i n ilrnr "

n ",

on, nir,il

rlrIfiileefiurudr

I

ilrs$rs sg 5'luld nia iaaeo 25-80

uas irueuiliuf;lr,unilrtrun'lttflrrnl

nroilt Ctl.ctrutrililrf, f;tilrs tn*

rrzr;r,raieaes so ,fl"iliudrtiii

iir torun zn I irlrhirfil tu t n.f,t dtl"nt rulriIlri

r anarrlnf irrilurarfimrorrr.n"rnlnfililu"o uastdiiunrrtr.tunrt

rl Turlr rrir z.rfiu $a3f inilrditiiuuerfirenr{ do., r Crilqnrn .r run rnrira r arlrll

t Crfin r rucern I tun r z r Czntrfi ruasf, lnlurili ri' 26 30 )

Page 20: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

2

t.

Tc Es r{q'lnn 1rn1a1 Etl'l

n? ,tuua ,tnnaranr til2n.tr

fluiu{rrladruir I lanra

tcnri, 2r;3e.l ntrrirararhlfi rintfitficnrrgrrlla

(Bio-diversity) ruarerir?fi dliiilicu'ttilin

f; odiioililindrqf,ufrilfiun r ciiilzsrclii emaruri

nirarnnlrlfi ui'irc" t iiunirarnz rlz" lnnd lfin?ninnunulfr

uififia.r.tt zravr ?a181?rT u nrrufrrnrlrirararlr tilulrltulrluuulalnrr

nrorir$irrirrridrnrrd Bacrqnurcsd, ara,d"o..nrfiuurirlrttairiCeunu

r filnin ilrprrnrrrira'rarlr'tilrirlfi r fteannfia Bacnl,rrtlfituit iulrncr,lu

dnilr. ri.r?finrrrnrrnrnrrrrrirdse,fr.ilrrr"ilufilrlHarn do,ilt *.ntsnu

adrrunrcre finihinar."nnrrd'ir tutanrrrfiiiiiriitinurnlrrauaralru

rridr o.o1 r dfininareren{rfillnrlrasnzrcdauilflnsalf uen ngdrdar.

r fiurtrsr ar{i airn rrri r t1 n. orq"6 " "n

ilrlailiia {tliteliruriruan d'rludr-alrl

, a"iuuilr. iidtililinrrrlrtru F udutia r ri"fiu ilrHiunrrilnrtnrudn

inarcrcn{ rzrdaraauiunrurivir nT zgrf,uflatdtiiilintcannrnnru

rrrutrfi ,f,r.dodrinrdarrrifiu ludrtreasrrn1 eoo druildri"t n. itn'rzrfrl

f,udr a rdtiiiilic d, inf;r.n.udarrn r r r ildaulrla { ! a {trrtlrri saoitu rnian

..r, sdailz"rraita" 1 dilt{ uiilqcfiurudr nrrlrriufrardriiilirrfi ricrsu

nrucRlnrr r ildauuilar n.odon""f auqntnri uet r finiu?ldnrrdrz. , i"euc.

r rluueta:atue'talul n1 rarilnzrnrtgrrfldluailnnre cslllnnlHdrnrr

$uf,u{arir{zrn r ir rinf;ufurzn*arf,aa;itur rnrhiauilu Tna I crrtadrtCt

.lurlrs r ngdaaf,nrr uasilzs I ngdrird.rinn zrrfitilr!, r nclnr t rrfrra t dnfru

finidrnrzlHrtrs rirf,nrrnrret5sudratdriiilin'iritrlz"luiue' r rlin tu

dxil n.C. Le?o n.n ,iotfll*rfulat r rtin tudxil n'C' 1s8o urndnm

n,rrcrrf,uf r tutrnudnrru r dufi fi , fl*d. ilafiu'irar atuf,uailncnrzrrd ro il

.riinrrg,riu{raodoiiilinrrifiaandr zo-so r raoiitiiilinliniror dii.drt

r"ofi ueo'tuiru"udgrf,u{Iilfi qra r f,unrrCfl I laq'rndrtlr rniasil*.ode"

r rr rsiininiruucn rrfi r fiuf,a r cu,i r iin r rri're rarlrtitu t n.f "r.ilr."d

ru .ln

{r{ r

rfin uidrfif,n*rfiunuuininarrren{iia{riiar z frrurfin rrirfru reoitriar

lratudes zo n.iritdiruu.r tursuuirr*dllnni nrrcqrladriiilinrinrn

Page 21: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

3

rinuira.rcii$anrrnufisdtiiiilinrindur arirtia,d"o rfiulnrd lrnfirtiaa

firrufeuinrdi fintrinar'tfiilrsrrsnrrdti'ir nrrrtrrf,u{rarirrinnfit

drurznCrganzsnutfiiinr:1rrrilauuat ua"f,*{dur luzcuuitrnriaefiulfi

rlnulrila.ralin arqurnds so rinfirf,urd ari'rttrfinusonrsnua'rcrd

rtnnalfirfiutn r qutufiudrtfi ?urtuuit rediufiau

ilecfiun1zun znrireI Irlriidntr1In'rc'irrl.dfnutd" r I niarlzrel'ts--i---- - | t t

r .U,- .-- rt, c-^^ -. {- u u 'rarartr?urilerlnafrtiiu10 I rrirfiu uasesiiiurianntttnal n'ranlT n.ttn'

Irlarirrilc1fiufi rlrii, zszil d,rrnncrHqratnrrriraradr,inrdasern

dn r rn r r r il r a.r irururlrsrdrn r a dlurrf,ucsrirlfirn r ii a tfi s t t ".

tdti.irrturi

irrih;arunrnr6rfi r.n..nil r..rqr.doncrlurHailtlrtaliCrsnurl'|nfl,|r---------- t -,..-r^B-i.i..qfi.1

' -ir,rilurrlf,nIfilra fi tiluertnnCrf,{drirtfirftIfrnnrirera nrrunrnrirnrailri

adrlnirlr?1{ ufinrrfi.rtuuit,lutrnanatuurilirfi tlninrriudfln{rlr

,nrilr,dil.fiufirir*r is,fuuiruConrcugrd ruilrlfiurhcrruurirtri

un r audr r ui e Hlr fi n d r ihi ruruia a r,.nfir,, rld aunluuun r 11 ilrlr"rrriiliurrl

ilrc aferilanracrnnrzriterailr ilrirffirlT liacetei,ruiltrurafiu rltrng

lfirfiuudr riarudir.rriii{de"lfi'tredrre?sfrrrirfiu rllruurait 2531 Be!,

rtrrnAiiirrizl rfiaf;uodrsurnl.tfirlnnrnnatilrs I nf,tna fitt iiuI

#on dn"oa

2592 tlf,|floru1n2rtllntrua

fi asdrri r naiiirrirurrrieu I a a

nfin fitaru r ilanraifiurirtrs r nctrB r flladrrl'rn ?uaurnnnz1rlulll{!a{,..n..oil ruililriruurit rfinnrrsduuiladrl

itrn*6rni r r csf, a.rntn.nC of;t e d r rsriunr n12cn 1 rdrlrrsru I ii a srnafiu'i T

crfr{rninqBuir uififi.rfriltarfiuufinrndzuu:tdru.1efiuqnCra nrllen

dir rdrurl., firo " rufiilrnmdm1 a I ilq r ri'rffu

rrunf,ndr rrq"Hasdrafiu Tna r srrsad.rrCrrh?ur rnnnrrnuririlri 3 !n

inrrf,udfln{rlr,n.irdil"flufirir'r do,fl"i"drlraqinf artilarfiuillfi

iinrzun rnf rararlr arirs r i.n."It

{r-qof lnt triaaDe'3xtl1ttuu-rt

,dro."o, fit il"iltl.rfrdiiaeuaauruurd il

nT zritpir1srtrd r uiiaaiil r f,u

Page 22: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

utaurailrrrn""ri. diEurariT lrlil'tunrrufrIlillnrrnrr1nln

rirarailr 6a nr:rlandirrrlrurlT ?uadnntnllnrlirtrlrurlr rdf,eniiilrrur

aildrra r rir?e,.r."irilrhdnnrireraiilrilrnfin uasilzst'lntfitoiii.andr

ileqiiuurn uiIdarlr"dtnr,irr.nf;r. nr,rudalnr:ftludln"illnfi ,Cnn"nt

v { { e rr .l r, -.. 3---^--r^--!-----.-l^ X..J {-t-:r--f;t ?uarrs r duirt ra r rymrr'rn r rrtli't riunrrrllndirlcrurlr dl r duiiriT fru

1 rluaif sir r ft nn r u f,aB Hrfruz rrgrllilud, rt.r r ilu r eilnun r rf;ur ilfi trrar

,.n""nilrrdd r narirfi ua{ r u{a r fi cft1rr., dt fi ranrt,rnesri, lfin rnlencir lcru

irrir'tfi rficn?..rrnnuanzsu'irt r tT sfirdilr1fi fiu1tor?urlr rdrfrcauiru{lsna{nann?t

q1flru?nlrufindrir1aaardnT ragc,runtrtrlrlfi ( irura' 25.2t,

rudr nrrilandi.rtdruilr uar{niliuririutfinrorlrlllnrrrrCaefiu dre"

r f,uif,nrzd,rrr,""ende.tr,, tar uasdo"r,n"rd, ilr.f, io.t lin""if;o?ufiTr

u"",*r ri. inr"iludilrril ua"nadfiurrtar?ufi.odt Tnanrrf,surrhlfr

nruirrlfiunrrinnnrtHrurcnrtfic uerallnula{z,rrrotlufiatdu f;oil,ihd

nr,1uuasraniufiu.i.r r1porlndr.und, f,rlrlrlnlnufirnrlrirerarlr Cru?uriii

ilrn*nrr;rurcrutfiq uauf,rnr rdu arncu rriiidiurirfiu n:iaiifina ii"il3"

rrnnrzilnr.r oRr arinr arril{au rrirfiiuuintrctlructr nrrdrlfiil't3{n

tfiiitnrrnrrndil.rurlrrfifirtuit zslB uesir tiunrria rdaor..uililerfrr

rnrrnrrfandfi,rurlrri ilrunirdlluzd iHot{rt,ln1nttnrr

rliurtruhdr ruurisilri'runtn{ilrurlrril rlrfi r afiu t de r-fi ran ann 2 1 t lo, il,

Ta^nrzCrir*olsrr,Cnnrzauinf {utnirsrnrrlrtfitu, n.ilt iltl"arlinf iia

r re in'rf,r.f a, irl"fi r a r ru tr n zudrrlfiun rzir:urilinn zu I flua d I n s r.|xat

txiilC r da lr rncnrrrlrui r 3lrHon r,'roriln rn r f, r{ur a riuil, ia'rt, ilt dtl.fit

rirffi riueilCrrnian'rrn?unrnuenira,rnllrfi uetdn{rh ?ul lninrtitt{

itn {rl,rfi z a r ru f, r r f,un d r .rrr rn n zurh'tiirrHfe?fi rT rozur a d rzufiu I ihnin

unir s,1rurt t lnfiuilnlcrteul lrinrrf{3n{ rhfizalrutl tieff irada

Page 23: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

n.lreusiudrhauini 1calfi:rtAzdea , f,r,q l f,uar?unrzdanCalnua rldc"t I r 'l t

I f,r'trlina euf,ntfrrirarailT uaorirf,e{ .lu t lcinrr;l{anirlT firal'rufr{ rar

r iarfinrrrtanrtir.,rrtrurhiu r n"ir.dil. r dauTnrr Id I iluunu I ilrnrrtdfro

t i riaur iu, ilr,n " rinnduunrrrllf, rinn'xuirfi

" a

Tnzlnrr{nnrifirurl,rti fi.runirirnqzd ffrdrriunrz{nudfiru

rfrtfi l.Hssdil zssl TnarfrararrrratnirfiTutrlrtrttllan ua"ndufrru

rlrfiuunt futlnnrid o druarcfr irtnaaruln {tuieqfimTii {ruru-ar

rs1 nfauniz Tca'lHriudrriunrr,daiud s iiurnu z5s4 uasteicf,t rie

iud z rrr'1ar z5;sr rnarfrintfiztozcrn z nilfirudtnirr rf,rarinrfla

.tuzrtnrifirurlrril dfirunirieuxzd u{d a iruazcrir rittnaarudn {tnTn---t I t t

afialrii inerrdadtfinreuairnc z {1u n.tdit ti.fiuaraunires 14 I'jz r ru {clfi , rrrsrf; oilrl r i aua d?uui r ea r 6a rfiuiltnr iruduiion."der.ti"fi t

u an a riduriordo drrdrna a an'hl ilT u r t'"*"ofr o ad edr.r I il*to r ilau I ial rra

n uda r ir {n,l { t'r !iluuu r dufiirrfirsn rnlunt rf, ni ada ri r r r,rnd r te zauc irnralltutr.nrioi i.'rfi ,fi""r'uotincuunartnilaz riluilnuriuriarfiu luu{

*u,rln dunrnudnrzlfiuinrtnrsfirlduT rgrlTnai, sl rdu i"dtrfiT ft trlriau n1{cru'tnu nrrilrsrrduftd rar uilric'crnurir'tror dfi".ttiunrl.trtrirri riru,rrnal firu drnrrrrric"nrniriluriatrtnitu4lruruunfirrrl

d.rrporfinialarifiurihnriur riroqrndiufrfiulawu fnnstfirrtiiarual

el'riilnndfirurlrtsriali.rsiaut.r{n'r?f fieilrurirfiratfi rilsuf;o tnitf;t {{ iit

tfrnlfiT uI

il r iludnre"firut ian tnadrlflu/uun l Rlnzlatlna nitnrfiru

Ceu?nrir;siltn"il

d r r n ae trin Bonsr," ruilrsn rc! n {fl isnt z t$nrnlna I u'n ild 1 3

nrng,.nr zsz4 ti Iil Iiluiruendrratir rnefirnldiiaur, orludni,1{121{

yrnn,.{f.'tnrriitrdrruafrrrf,ufiqi'rrnaatrln riaiud 13 nt..nr 2520

u uirrsilrutlrn,niiet nrid t iruaeruln rflsntrfllrilnarnlilld{nCrt

turtrcrrn tfieirril.irnrrdta"rrnaaruf,nf;u dfi"r.t rldldar ndd z irun

a.'rfln rirl"rnd.irntrirrnati' tfi'rilrnlnilnt)ilfsr1e S fitnlurt

Page 24: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

6

cn,rrniC'l.fn{

1!n5t ar I Raatudnnteannrul oaulls I nt'i

z9 ri, rqrnitnieafiasrii ,fir""t"o'l{ 54 filallnrI

iudCrufuritilurnrrilrunont lrii,il.dilrtn.t 1' o8o. ?/t5 n111{

fiTa r rnz

figruila qc irrnad,irou."rd i.rninqfiarrit unsi'llRae,rn

are iurieunzdrr:C

iffH en drdrtnafirrnn ungi'ttnafirul'i {lninefiasrit

icnsiuaan in irrnafirfiu rirrnenue{o'l{ {rnina.fialrit

iCnsiunn en itirtaefiransuasirrnafirlld {crinqfialrii

nrtrlnnrel urilaan,flt s irue +s nrifiru iie

f . iruneruiln ii e uifiTu tlzsdrnr 14'655 nu z'ogs nfl

nrrlau iruru 2,r51 nilriauZ, iruarlrr{iiu ii S ndilru rltcdrnr 7'145 nu 1'CZZ nf,'t

nrriau {ruru 1,ss' l;.,;rr. I

B. druerlT ta ii rc n{firu rlrsillnr 14'310 eu g'2t4 ufi'r

nrriau {rueu 3,3o3 airliau4- druairrnu it ro udilru ilrcil'tnt 9,4?1 nu l,?sc nf,s

arriiau ituru 1,844 nfrriauS. i.unrcfr ii e uifiru rlzcdrnz ?'113 n1. t'tsa ndl

nrriiau iruru 1,553 nirliauii{rururlrofrnrf;si$ s2,894 nu urilarn,ihf"t 25'356 eu

nfis zZ,3gB nu arifu riT1d 80 t rirur 15 t iuiTre'ut S * rfllirrna

ill"aq lunrrf,enrr r darfiurhuurfiurfrrn{ r rninrrf,u{flc{rlrfiun"ntoft il

ilrfi iir ""ozne

r af rninna r anrn lHnrar r iru ,rrlrsn nue rilrqnlnrlrri're r adr

i rfln i irrir.rfiiiikprlldru r da efiunirr 1narz rudrfi onire r a, f,r.r"o totttt

rirtfirfiafiarrrutri rdu rJuuds irriru ..an ntrilrfllrscrfiurrnnil

Page 25: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

nt,runr,rr t iiuurlrafin nru r fiuad'tuilerfiu uacuurrfind"" r ilurrltuail,tnn

tdariT rfenrri{adrfr rrhrruurnrriunrrsfrrrilflrr n,rrunzfl iniia nrnu

s I a { f,uCil r auini r" "r.xn'r

r ?'r {usu?un 1 rfrr.riuiu ruluddr elinia{uttl

diigo..n..r r crutfi iu a s f, snr diintu uudnrageir aai.rfilrHruT an r ci nlrl

Tnnrlzce .,rd

n r ri {afiiiicnil:ucrd, du

f. ilnrrrrliaurilariT urctlfir-flrnu luileefin rnrclrilnud

ilrurlrlilffruniril$1"d d'rrursri'l drrnaarufln {ruicqfiamii uecr.rnor

da rf,a a riuanTnz rnT rndilrurl'rtil'r-rdotilaritur rnuurfiudu rlr rianrzauinrtt

z. ilnrrrrliaurfiaufigunfi trs\rrlrar?uflecfiu ianrr arlinf

nirarnrflr{tl" rl'rIfr nrzilenrhilrilr uesficunidn.tnzrnrz{nndilrurlT rfr

o r aruf,uiluur iluf,u r rn inrrf,lf e. irl"rfi ', a r ru tr

durfigrura'rnr:i{a

-{n{lr

e rsf,unr.n,Crfir. gs rrla{rru{ (rr=.oEl E?{aHrcurilruri

1. r"*ardr"flandturarrnrmifiT urlrri iicntnru r;iundnrr

7

nrtilnrrcnrr r crugfir ltnu rardurilnudfirurlrtififi ,Crfr"{n1r

Hlrr czrtfte in'ir r."o"dr.flaadlanTnrtnrrn{fiT lrl, lilndrziia iinarddnicrnnrnltranauarih dsndr rT rorileduantntlnrtr

z. r""o"ilr"f,aod'tur rnTarrnrrnifirurlrrfr rf,iulicinrrnrrflrnu dio'i" r.rgrd."f,aariuanTnr{n1r.r nirrfia r.rord".f,aa{lutrn

lsrsnrn iinzrrnrcuit?unrrilnrraatgrr ?urcduclndt r""grC""flend

uaaTnt.tnrtr

Page 26: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

I

{qs. t'rrorne.rnsaitut lrTnr{n,rrHifilulrtfrriififunidd nireiia

3. 1 r'rtiordalHaa-ri lutleTarurzu{firurlrtfrr ii;glntsdd

ianrreuiufe"{tl. tuz"f,rddndT r."grdr"flaaiuanrcl{n1t'l

s. z r."o"du.flaad llt rntnr.rnrrn{firurhrfir {c - q.l<t|nf,rnnnc

ienrrauinirlrrfr rursf,uddn'irdq

s. B r,rtrorna,rsand'lurlnTarrnrnr{fi'rurlrlfrr iifiglnidd

ianr:rl1nrft{urfu'tur"duddn'ir r.rg"du"f,aaduanTnr{fl'lt'llr

s. 4 r.1rorda,1f,aa{ lur rnTnrrnrrn{fiT lrlrtfir iifisuaiilfi

iaTnrsnrz{endfirurlr'afi ruz"f,udiin'ir """utduiflaariuanTnr{n11n

firulzdrflunrtiia

f,rurlrdecdlrrilnrrrrliaurfiau nrtHT utC6tic ilsnl uas,

figunfi iaTartnrn lHurif,rurlrdldnlrlil

1. f,nrflcfietr|la{rlrsilrnz lf,uri trc ara CrCur nlrilnrr

nrrdruufirila coturrrrfuzd {ruruunr iruruazeunirilarflasd'tufiru

{rutuduriilnluaiet:ieu niirturtiu nrriralilr{d"tr.*"r.rfiun'iT ; rialr eardnrf,aa{'run{fi..ii*,r"""C, f,T,T ndluulfi"r,m"fr. raonrufiaI

nrtirafiu'tuau,tne

2. CRrrrCrrtfiualrlzetrnt lnlri dnmsnrrtduT sa.rdBl

neufiernrr#uruilrafiu nrrufiarn.tn""dfir.ttntofi arilrnf,n?uilr1ffl

" ""ord r.f, a a riuanTnz {n 1 t'r

tI

a rihras'tuilccim fnreonr r?ilu rs t'ru irlti'ullnrrsin nrrirnrirasf a

rin r {rufirdrrtfidruuerir r ndarfiunrrnilnzrt rilr fiutuilr1fil lerarralfi

dnirnraraunirinilg. cnlflrat'tduri fl'rrrf,rdrnienrnrniudrt'1 latctrin?u

nfe r iau n,rzlfiiudrrtinrr r deiiilrrnrirtt rrnilluriln?unir riaul iurha

.turauitiluir aorilerrfialuniiru nrrinrua,ril,re,iaiin"t,iurha trlI iauilrsirnrifiru nrr I iunrr'lrt r iaunfitflelelclrtn?ucie r ilnl n21rn1t

Page 27: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

I

fnrslrihr.i.ilr Trdc orfiue r I :' aunfi .rla nri ofi .dr tlun rz qrlrna uiTne

f t nrrifieu'tff ilnru"fiudtf nT tittfrtil uiauuir?fiucltf'irrtut rar

fla1{RU l nIa{1trU4&fl{a1U?4fr2'lutEn2il lr-rz 1;' rddin"" rfiunrsril r"nurdtilriunrraanuannifi'u cnrrI lun'rlnrrriunrt

, ile,riod?illrnrnrrHr uuir r ila rritrlir,rsr ila rrittuilelfiu undtdrr1l

drr uecnrrufiatnrzrfiinnfitoit4. dnrrnrtirztilintrliautfiau:"ui, tein uauilelfin rfruri

ntnrrlal1zsriau Cnrrlesdo.turt'ru1a dnruottilunrlnlu,tell Cnt

lasie dnrrraruniri'rftu daruaruudtfirrt dnrtletnrrrdtrlun{fiT u

rratfrlnfi tr a{crEUnfz uassaatinnrlnrt I nrnr

n ?auuurn r rlfi edrfllun r ti{g

farasfiz'ttl

tnrrnrtfcnrifiruilrrfi

Cnrrnrlrczrtficrlrgilni3ra

rnrTn:l

n,|zncnunrllran

ndfiT uuanTnrlnrrI

cnrrnrrdrrsilin

fieuaiaara,rrot

Page 28: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

10

i

^''r\I

\-r+c

IIIII

t\

rr\\v \-rr

\z

) .':. ,- (/|,\t, \.J -',

, f'---r'4-r I I

,r-----l'( ,^dli

Locat ion : ral{n1:iorarifirurlrtfifiaunf,nialurd

District : firuniudeugtr$ n' ts'd'l o'a1uf,n e' qfianrfi

uaudnirjtsrtnd 1 : soolo tr?1\t 4840 rrftfie 1?181 N 5479 E

l{ean sea level z I2O lilnt Aspect : I{est-Ease

f,rurufinrri

: laanr,l

Page 29: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

11

ra

i )lr \\'\\ i

Location t udfiruuon1nztnrriora{firurlT rfiDistrict : firur !1!?'l\t n. tlrdr l. u.rrfin q. afiasrfi

dquuufrn-il?srrnC 1 : SOO00 Tc'l'l\r 4840 IIfifiq tzzaz N E3s9 E

l{ean sea level : 16O lilqt Aspect : I{est,-Ease

N

II

oua6fJUsUAnril

a6 3 rtaf,nr.lI

= Ull? [ Dn

o o dq t Ifn$1uuaf,o?u1I

Page 30: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L2

\\. i

Location : urifiruuon1er{n1z{eudfirurlr'tfr

District . firurD'rr;sx q.lurir l.u.uf,n r. ofianriid q.

uo.fufrndil?ctnC 1 : 50000 1!r'11{ 4840

fifin Llzss N E3s8 E

Hean sea level : 18O lilaT Aspect I l{est-Ease

N

II

qoA6trufuanrfr

6 3 leanr1

= UU?l[Se e lq t 1

1nE1UUflflO1U1

Page 31: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

13

qsIau [ [6n11?q8

ri.rnrzfnn.,dro".udldnrrnrttCtrtir illau saanlug2ufin

r fiuratdrrilnndfirurfi'lfr uesmiilrulnfr r dat i nnT rf,nrT rlrtfrtulrluurrla ITnzlnrr{nndfirurlrtfi 'tnr lnfiuiularr rninrr;u{EnirlrfiralT uf,I fialil

I

firunirieruzri iruarsrrir drrnaarufln iwieafiatri riarirfraladrf,lr

ic r rsrufir ril[nrn r zrn znrir e r arh uasrf,nrlnan T rilin f; snr ofr ru t czrtfi e

uac;frnu tra{r.1rorffidfu naaequtlittllr t1{ltrunlzicnlrnirarnrrlrlfr

uacn r :.lilrlrst ar{diurlrf if fi I rllr rscri acarln rrinrualrlrr I nctrfi i atl

fiairfiolunrtiia

nrrilnrT'tr."*of, ,fun'rzilnnrfitdnrrIgrrtfic itnl ua"iafin rfi1

ra{r.11ordarf,aa{.tun{firurlrr$ drfrinfiofrt utrurlnfiuilu lelIlninrr

f,uff,n{rlrfirarruf,r drriluurifi.t d{.f;of;t turiilrsurr z-3 il lnrnrtarar

,."ord, ilrr rtun rnilr r darirfiltu r tn innrf,u{f,c{rhfi r a I ru it rfi a anu r a dil

ui r rr r tnfiudu do, fir.t"rsnrricndilrurh'1il la tnrlrlrf i fltfiui{a11r0{

,fi*"..rnnnirrntlfiturCzrtfir flln1 naeerudnlrn2,1uliluad r$udrl

nrrarf,aaddriu rturrnrl.rfirarrufrr, n"tdrdarHalnri tuitralar{fl11

ndilrurlrtill re{,1.1rozrdrritnrcufin,ir...nnrr{nudil'ruilrli frrirrfi

rj r *iciudluzdn,rllnrrnrrr drfiu isnrriin'rriiatlinros I dufiia,duo

qrnnrriirfi;n"?oriio,i.itorriirdnrrnr,rr r rldaruder

uasirar re{r,lr}Orilarflaadtunrifirurlrffril dafrnrar1nl

nrsf,rutcrrgfie

Page 32: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

T4

ilauf,srldtttunrzi{s

1. TRf{n1rilrifirurlrrfi usrafir udil"udfnfro".ot"ttnrrin

uriilrlrlrril rarlnrrn.lliurlrorhlrruurirdri nzrilr'lil rudilnlTafir

Tnzrnrrinudfirurlrlfr firunirieoptd druatsrir drtnaarufln {*rTn

sfi an 1fi do a dlurn rrn r zililrt, nrl"ei.uuritrrBrhfi r afiu t ca r-fi raa enn 21 Eirl

z- Au.rinndfirurftli utrafir r.*g"dr"f,aa{tufnrurrfau{

ff.rurlrrfifi.,.nrriuo; ,;;"""0. rirrnaaruln iruinri"u.i r

s. nirzrroruanTerrnrrndilrurlrrfi nlradot."atdrritdaT f,a

a dtula rsn r rfnnriilrurlrtifi T unir{llqrd i T ua ttrirrt.l

qfiarrfi Co, flrr."ardarflaairur rndrauini tudf,ruradr

drrnaaT uiln ilnie

"."ord,tT'hliln!n infia nlouara{dar,'rr., rodruurfiudu tra{ I lninrrf,#f,n{rlrfiratl

J{tl! 1u tr { r ra aa a rdaniarlrsn auarih r ntrnrntzurfiuri z rrazdarHa adtunriilru

I

t!.rr?'l{ uaondilrurlttiiar iruarsfr drlnaaruf,n f*rinqfimriil-'"- I

r { u a =-4. rlrrrantzautfllt ur180{

ilt dtt.d;oiinrruanrdluzd nru

rrruilri ua"nzurhrirfifr riun'rzdrtre uasilrun,rg,f,"f,"dttrnuinfsdr

drn ruus$f,our r c1rtfi eu acfl reiluri'rrrisfiud z Ifi ri rrnnlfiiiit dil" tqinf

zs t nrofr,dil.rfif;rilzcrnc isrl*il ru"air rh'turrninniu{fln{rlrfirg

rrutr sirr,ilr.di.uursdr rir r naarufln fwicefiarrit Tnaiirrczrlnqrilnr

.tfiinfrr r f,ut lninn,rfuifln{frt "*onrn ntriltsnrflurrdfir'r'rrll unD'1

d sg "ur.

rgz aliud + fiuaT Eu 2515 nf"d 1'631 rrrrlfiTelrn1

Ifiil:snr6rCurfiufurrilfirrrutunplrdufl 1o3 rauSz etind 21 lqrn.1a{

zszs iinrf,uiru"t ft C e,44 n1r1tfitalrrtz2tr,il*fudf;nir. r'5?5 r1r1{

Ila||

tlas

fiTarunr riurrninrriudfln.irlT fiuf,ld 4 rerilrr:tnftna tlntnnrf,u{f,r{

rlrfi rar rrf, o, ilr.irdiim,nrh qcurulrd r f,uunirfrufi "dC.Hrr

r du irfiratruasi'lfirafirtcnr irfiralrauf,nlalilurl'rufrr irfira'tdtt'tu irfiraurid uasi'lfirafirt

urirf,rotuaa lCuriir$dnna t uatrdirlsunnil

unlr I ernlficfirrdt r lalrfridriisz'ucT f,fldanrr I nrnr

Page 33: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

15

s. ur?fiut'u ilr1gfi{ i"dd;tri,ilr.n*.tlnztudrt rlT eqinfilu

ilr.drt. r dauTn:u dorudfiuu rafi I uurfiudur a t I rninrr;u{ln irhfieaarutt{ 4 .o o u.!g-!-t- t s { u?rriluuur adfrertnuu?1!nla{llninnriuqdnzil't il?a!1ut{ rte2'tufllT {-tl

rlrsurs s firarrer E1?flaanzeuuur r rera{ r rninnrf,u{f,n{rhfiralrutsI

B. dnrscnrziir"taodiu uurafis zrluuudrrtrariidiuad?unrru{

"rn'rrrntrerflrzu niaariarfla dt{nurit'tfrrflt c tlzsrtnnlinnraunza{ tt. anrnlz I nttn5flf zll ,, 1 riur irraodar. nlradriiifrudrfliianzsr rdadrilzsrTail{

u a c r flr.$arrdt."atfi,, ilu r tu a rrn a iinfi tlau dn rn z rnlnf,"i raniia z aua r a IG.z rflufildturlCru nlrafrs ld;r.drAfi En I e { r dari rrlr"

I

tarrl Tnanrrrd.rrrnfiduurrCru Balr tf,tn"o"t, alurtCru

6. 3,fr,fi ,d"f;.rule rurafiriiCildrdiiaararriarirrlzcrsiti

rn an r z r drr rnfiduuas r lai-r r d-r r iili rn asunu f; oi"o, f,rn., r drdtrfu I ilu

arafinnddnrzulardfi""u

e . t .tdiin"rn?nfdar. urrafir det il".tazlf,rirlrliciia

RreilnfD{ru$udrlrrfi rdeadarf,auilariT nrrlflrntflrfr lnarrianfre{n1r

nour1a rudfir.o"afi. ilt dtl.auinidrlrozrdr f,r'trlinntat ?uI lnuurfiudu

o e 'ft{tl"fi.alrufr'l!a{[[n?nlt1Tua, ,

T. neT uluqnisra (Ef fectivenessl nurait aruCtlt't1o[a{

aoCn, f,udq"uiiurzrrutfiurra{carlror116rHadrli ?ldrt,.""ilri."r.". -- . { ' - l---v--

neuiluqnf,"", fir.o"rutnrzr" asa12uasia t iiaI t du nrruf,l0nfisa t iiatiut '{nrz iia nrrucu'rraluRrtrrldaugilet rlturlrt irriu!8{e{nn.|Infle{efl1znen.|-|l|--|||-|zl|tbf||.1||.-----_-t{ --- *-nilredsd uarilnlrlifiiialfi; i'ti1 ' arruf,lonf,*" 'fl1f trailzze?n r

iin rrururalni r n'a rfiui ti r " rlrsrilnint' ( Ef f ic iencv ) iitdrdrrlz"ilrfi

nrrieldc rnn I uCril 1 ro ! E { n l6n r:lun r z?ilnira 1n t?urg atfru te a r rlf au

tiiauilciarirrir (Input) uagt'1aira fiuilriariraan (output)ues1a1f,

ii.r o r cni r erd.i r n r ri r r iu.r.rr.diirrrsilninrutu:r a"f,u a trriiin r.nfln q#

rfa rurgasarrfirH uinrrirriun"rdiinerrf,rqnf".t""trrr Hat,f,r,n"t

ir riurrudiirtz"lninrrrrrBfrtudx, ""ti't 1ue5n

Page 34: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

16

ilzurarddn ro'irqc'lfriutun T tfinu, i{a

1. rir'tfinzru3tanrtirtiunrr inTnrtnrzu{ilrurlrffr ilT uniri

aluzd iruazsfr dr taaatuiln frninariatril'irgurrndrarir'lfidnrrnrl

firur c1115fiesacifunr !a{llnoziuTnzrnrr. fif;uniard naancutil'lfinrru

firitruHr uasaildtrc .lunrr{nrattRrznrifiruilrrfr

z. rirtfinrrudrfiguaila{f1rot f;.r?utnrtn'11'r uasuan1az.l

n1z.r Ciii"f"ronrmrifirurftlfi nrrrlqnilr{utu nrraqinSln{ utcn'11

autnfrlrrfig. 3f artlnflliilnnriia r dazfiuilcianrs r Crulfir uaullnr

:1rgrlur lnTnz{n1:n{firurlrffi rda I iliaul iiaufiu t,trgruanTnz.rnrr

r ilurlrsrTafd d e n r z,l 1 {uu?11 ltln r tiliurlz u r rf,nr'1nr sfr ru I Ctrtfi c u a!'

f,.rnl lunrrfnnrifirurlrlfi ua"nrriletfiuauinfnirarnzrlrlfr ,Ct,f,t n"t

anrgfiune"n,flr.rd !a{z.rtrozdadarHa nttTntlnrnrrifirurlT fi ffidf;u

4. rfaq.rfln'rrilnnrifa drrrrrnrirrrlraratta'tundfiT urlrrildur

r1adratunrzufirrftp* n..filnrR iniia nraunra{iluilrl.et rnfdt r rritfi

raraf,riolrt,dr. ir,drnninnrf,uifln{rlr iud.lnqna'ruuririri it il,n.

rlrfiuira'urr r fiuHu

E . sf tq,rnn ,trllnrrif accc,lurtnd"fi aurfi r fiusaur lilrtntd t fi "f;uern1nrlnrr{nnifirurlrffr dsqoCrurzntillihf,aqefunrtiliurlrt ufrIl

Tnrtn r:Ccsi'l r iun'r r'tufudd"r luT anrci nril

tro{

1s

Page 35: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

,nd z

nun2u?lrcnllr|

-- . { | !- -C---.---zso, o0o n 1 I'1.rlfr Ta r rnlusi r ilascrn r vda J?a ,tgior 1 dn I 1n 11 r $uilruilrn td{

It

af 1 r Hnn'ltaan{rD.tfiudrlrrfi

rlzu I n*fnaliiludf;ouuert:E1'1fl 519, 953 n'111{fi14 r ilqluTdil1a

rdufiarnrr'ffiiin'r:d.rruinrriludrlrffrfi 50 * otniluf;orue u:ia iltsilrot

uaun 1 x r .i.r Tefigu1ilrs r nc r fiulrlad r.o t rn r {r itrirtfifin r ruir r ilu'lunr ztt

tilrdanrrriar?r.r ua!, ridfiutdail:"nauarts'tudnrT dl.rf;usru'trlfrra

ulauratrr rjdaulrle.rn rfil 6a ritauerfiiinrzdtruinr.iludtJ.'tiriat 40 *

nrofir.df;ouuc ilist1?ss'l.u z00,ooo nrtrtfilnrrn?uanrilurlraqinf zs x

HlsilzuurE 1zs,o0O ntzrtfilalrsz drran'adn 15 * niailtlrt|,lol ?5'ooo

nr:rsfiTa r unr 'tfir flurlr I dzrtfic t drfin.rrun$snz?rnrr r ctntfiruaudtnu

urirr.rfi , zs 3 F l n r zrliurlz turaurad.rni r r rn adruuetfirt ruin*"fit iltl.rfi

ncascrnrfrr 10 * fi,drauuonrrufiatnrz'tttil u.tdf,un,'ttj:uirntdtiin

f;u.rfifirilril unrdfiuilzunauortnaiT .rrfiawa ud,da{crnnrrtfflfr o"od6t

r fiurrla ri r utr r iln a Te a r reufinnrr uag irula'tddu rrnnruqldnrun r tdtfi

r f,u r un.tfiilr,dil"nnunrndrara rnc l rJdau'trl, ft fi"d r ntsn?nt?il ua"dtniro

.ir.r r rlair r flui'ruruurnrirrfiiludrlrrfinafiailaandr 40 t nrrrurgurtdti.nt "rT <tuid, zsz1l i{srcndrr'tf irilruuri.rtrani uaodr6ruddndT uiuficnlr

rhIff lo.rilru rnc.lnaluflcqfiu'tfiurinrrunrnufirnrtrtr uosniauRt"odit

rlrffi ,drn',rnilflttlt lT?'rcn,rrnrcdrf,tnd'lr $8nl1n'rurilun'rtgrUrila

niuarntrh.tfiadrsnfir r ilaeraufir i{nrsnunru r fiautdadonrofrtl r fiuadr"

'rndndra r du rio.lfi r icnrrfirnntaratdu rir'tfifinrrnuatntdutltdrru r dn

nruufisufs uao r daahnnufinqs r ficfirriersrir.rfiurfiutfi ira r iiufiu ilrrng

n.rr$,rairfi iaursdsuanisnuflzcrfiau iaer'1uduatnrtfirurctrtfir uac

drnllntil:!,tnd r.uf;ofr.uin'telatrlrct'riu eirtiltgUT ariritfi

Page 36: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

n in a r n r rl'rt fr r fl un itf a 1 fl Is r rlrdrfi din e tr fl Ifiu$ fi un is a r n r du'l

rdu fiu udr.n ir f,e{rJr uror,rrrinir'rrnfrie

Eirurailrctarrluriluri fion.orro rduriflc{ad

n r z inrrduruin o ou:rrrilrfi ouodoo refi ar il""fiu#sarn trh'tfinnrira I aa',t

r fluiruruu rn f;oilf,u, d, ou...nn1r r dui'ruruilrcirnrarir'rrre r f r il:cdr

du drurrnfiarilcnr? I nrnr t.rrirlfiiinrrufiatnrtdat iis r iiuilr{ailutrulu

nlrilrsnaur.t*o.nfru t dailro r nCfinT rfi.n,.fft R1?!rn1{ tgzrtfir uas

f,rnl r rlndauurJa.rlrl tris,atfinrrtffnirrarntrlr'tfi ualriu1d tuilrcdrt riatfi

rfieilrurarnradilnadstzlilrfi uaodturefiau llaranrunu'tunrs r ctrtfir f,.rnl

u.o"..rfiun.,rrartrfi tnadnisarntrlrtfifineT uf,uf,l{ fiufltnltert.u,flt

a d.r r u r n r e afi a'i r r iiun iu a rn t dA. arufii s il z c i r dunn nuq ofi a I iufi e i ou d r u fiu

lunrrtffrl rvl,aili uncilnilsrHlnratniuarntrlr'tfi r danirur grJrsladduti

rtrs dr ilu1e a drur rrr'tfiwa a i r td a r da t uas il sunrr r alfiurir a t rul o s iliiufi rd

n runuila rfiun r zunzndrnr aniua rn ril'r'|fiufi rfi e rl fi dsrrieT l rrnfiuHtn rr

un rn drn r ail.r r s sd rfi xu:rluurdr.,rt rfi f; d r dn tr rnilrsdrduCru'turtfi .tfr a.l

n.rdiu f;.,rrdsrirfiu uaerdun.rd*t tea'trilfiirfi'rfitrttilau nauura Rni

af nrf rst adrh a.rdrurrr uauHan r&nud, itf;ur rnnr tdtn ladr t srii, 25,92.l

ruadsfiudrlrffi iioirltulr*"*orfioostiludtJ:"rne uaurzst.rd

firufifi r5.rfi ri ruun't id r rl.r uu r afi odar,d;oirfiiiifi tlnanlfiu rnunano. tdfit

d rfiu 1 lnsrs r.rrfirufi0f, .r n,{ r. ilr,dilrrfitr r ilul a'r irudfi r da r iriirafi rdtu

n r ruiu.rzuasicn r ulrrfif;.,rrau, iio, ft oau t scdn ir o r fiun'iT ifnnrrucrl rtn

d;gro ilo ofiu u ac fnrtl rrfirfi a i'tudnrndrfi n r tila tfiun r :un rndra r arh'tu

fi nrflcd r tr .tdcru'r rnd.r r fiun I zufi't l'tfi a i r t c?.t {l n r rfisurn iua rn tlrtfr

rud r.r dsi tur rt df,c n' a uu r n r t ilr n d r r u rn a s e Te a t fiul r n tn r zfr run r rn 2 ue r

flesfiuinr.ilr,dtl. dsfiuisfin,trau r aaunu,rnnrtfiru t crr!fiqlatil'l'tfi uan

rrnfiurj:rdrdu u"ruodnr'turoHufissdu lriiidrudeutun,trficurniuarnr

rlrrfiutdarirr.le nrrfilurilrtfi'rufinnngfirnrire i.,rrrirtzsduoadrrirdner

18

ndren'o niuarnrilr'tfrrs,

u as iltcT a grin r.r ta r't fi uri

Page 37: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

19

n i'r efi oiludilrrfrfruurTfiraea.rqa oe rc Ee, .".doi.uu. fi rfiuturcassi ariln r rd.t or., o au t lnn 1 rfisurniua rn nl'rlil'rfifin r rruCr6rgnr.ofiru r drugfi r uau

o I tonrrauin*e euiilu'trl t drfin trunrusnrrilfl tr r Czrgiruauf,.rnluri.rirfi, 2530 )

luilr c iiu t da.r q r nn is a rn rilr'l friii T ueun nfi a a a.,r u aoiidnrs, dru

lnsu niuarnrsz:udrfi drnarttaa ra.tilrsirluiifiaansnudrdu rdu

rJz" I r rudun rfl r trl uriru rurfi u?u, orfiudil.d.r auuri.r il,rfi d.,r'lutraru?n'ltt

rJrcd'rdu r ua'rfiuii51ucnr1il r fiuadiautr.,rd f;of, , dr.,..nd6u'tuu? r rorfir'I

.u4atrt-!.f{dona1 ? a{rn2'lilaeudru?$loau'Ifl un'tutsracqar'lgz'lltaauduuttu lotuundtrttta

nriT rrirfi.,lr.uelrloiroree r ir, f*rrrr t ra'rfiasiafiuraarsilte atrifin'rrrirr.rinrtafiT fiut.rnnfic rtrofi{nn1a

araarfin0iolit.rnqn{ nrrrirdu uasi.,rris'tfirfieilruurdod{uaafrar frruf,.rnr

rnu r e zr!fiq tuiludfi.,rndrrfinfira fi.rfiu uanerntanrat'lunrrurr r nrilffnr

R?'lila'1fllu uanrrnniuarnrdrliroaearufir'tuuT sfiudrfirfiailrun1n118l

r daulnrlro.tniwarnrrlr'rfi d.rarrrirtfiilruu'rnrrra,tnlu ro{rl?sd'trunt

r tr'trl'tur nrfit dil.

aufnf rfiuri rrqilrfiufir rrqinrrfiudf,n{rlr uacrrnanaluur,i..rdrfi ,dro

rrndr rundrfrndrelrufrrfrr.,rfiu iia n.r,duf;urs.{ilrsdrnr nrrufia.tnrrd

fiurirfiu n.ror.rfirrd, dr r fiuuaerfi n r.. iiodfiutu r reilrauin$6oi"..nuru

elu:dail,rn is, flufit drl.urir'rrad drlrsdrtucs r tr'ttliafianraun?o{ unrnrt9t

drnrailr d.,rfir, i.,rir r flufra.,ruursrnrr'runrzilarfiu unsu'tuu?n'rruil'ar

ilnnlrn r run zndra r arlr auinftuaurnod aId-ttt

n r nla ndir rdrurh1a a ri uuuliilT urjrrfi , flr,n.""nrrsdrdrr'til

tun T rufii n qnn. rdilrr fi d.,ruan ,r 'rn.rs, ilr.n " rtr,flnira'rn rrl r'tiu ncfiru1 n 1 r

'tf;rlrctadrida", d.n., r nrn zufr r fi t r f,un rrdr a r ufi a zrraztfiiddurirfi u r f,u

rdo.,rr.nfinrr'ttrlrsrsl{dfiu rdanrrilanfir

UsR?'.lt|TUUr{[U

Iu au'luilq qffufirlzr I rdu'tfr r Cur,.

"ur, rnttt

uru4-rovnanunar 6utsrrlunrzdra?nnanltg$t1art

Page 38: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

I nt't|. "3 {, "- 4tilUUilUU{nn0O.t !U

t|

20

t Y ' ' 'v rrlr'tfitfiuTntrn1tfi$u1lun?Un2 (2522) nA1??',I l{ltU1u44-sr.

[ flo I ijun1l?autol|flu 1sru21{nx'l!aa10e !a{t,lro: Ruolon1?au?flrnzua1n?sxrrd.rA uns, I fiu'irf nz.rn1? I duf,f .u.rnilrafisurt'uun

rfi r f,uaiT {d rfinruiriindrrduun uasr'tfrrlrril'rfifiududu

nirura ufiri'rri (zlzsl nai'rrfr.rTnarl:sd{6 tra{n,rzierariilru

rjr'lfi rif,d1. r*tur'rur.ilt1?duundtrrd,druur, iln?nfianrao rfiedil.rfifi

do riu.uiddrr rurfi un 1'r I f; ofi , du, f,r.n.rila tfiunr :iln?nd1a 1 ad'r

9l

z. r dotfi r iluur,trirr"ailu?{{1u

rta nilrf,uuniua r n rilr'tila a.,rrJtu t nef

s. rdafilu'rruiln anxlucerrlr riiuaira-reuriln'tfidfrurfiiizrardgo-qer.-qre

ilaraa{oura{ oaoalufl1rrreil?n,trd.rnuSrudrtt uri*grin rdu n1:le

uinrrHrun'rrilnu'r n1?in$1na'lu1n nrziofirdrfirrff nrrCttdirnrtI nrnf

{U.l-edlyr{{4. Iuauaea{ u10taon,l?E,llnuM6ttrott|0{ lrDu,l{1ufl1!a{

b. r dado r dilnrz r nrnr'tilniaut fiunrtilQnrlr'tfiarrinitrra'tHau

tunrauntr r0lf;u

T n r t n r r il iurl :.r rh d.0 ?uuri { d 1 fi 'tu z rluri fr rurl T 1 fi r f,utn:.,rnrzd

te#tfu nlrrantsBflruqi ,daiud zs rilr1su zsla nra'tfrnrrtfrtiu.t'tu

n a rn a r{en. tdAr.rl.d.,r ruudtdrfi Teacudliurtr',rrhdt ruuritilrfi rrrl s et ittl

uaurlT rfir rs Taaslla{cnr:dfiurlT ril rru zr l to nzu{nnrsl'taDi'luI En

rlrdrruuritlrfifirrlrr r nd < nar{cnrtdat tl.goruuritlafi ,zszl) s.rrugu

firnrT rd:rgfiruacf,{nuudsdrfi ofiud s <2525-2529)uaco,tuufinnrfguuni

,dait d zz inurau zszs rirrauntfinrurh'tfrdrriunrticudilrurhri'tfinru

1oo uri.,r tifia,zszll d.,rstraCrrrquncl't{ut{u natienrzdfit tl.g.t.uuril

grfi (zszal r1a{'lufi.rgfan'rtieuriilT urlrri ff.rutiil 2r.ra'2527

tl

(Source of Labour) 'lun1T

dredurn

rcUt21rn{f,u

Page 39: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

2T

7T lnrrnrr drrrrn{oddutfiorit'lua?r?$ 23, Lzg nraunir ,iltd199,043'td rirueu r++ u{firuroafiTnron.tdd.rilunrriltsdunllrd.,i"

iruru I lnt{n1? t?lt fa uriffTu unsaitur'ittnrrdrtfiunrr 69 tel\t

n.r? r?r r so udfirud.rts r'sn.rdf da., fiui., r eicf;uilrcdugad'l r ietrlufie

rfruTnrsn'rrdrfiriafr.rierir froudrdrdrrfiunrt 6adr.,ril zE18 fr.ril zsza

fiur fiutnrtnrriuu:n drutnrtn"rd*r dti.fiod.,ilunrrfiu fiiif;.rtnz.rnT tdfiuurrfil.irc!rrttsduarndr r irfir.,r uns'ldiltsdlaadr r ieilrt ru rfiu'irtnr.t

nrrdtrirtrurduruadrric ilruuT oildrrnfnni 6a tuatdttirfiufrra uacnnaa\t

tnaffrriuita' rirnrrdafrru1e rrnrr < nf radrzrquae'r'l\tuau natie n.td6t

rlrgsruurirdrfi, z1zyl nrrfinrrfr.{dnrrs, r cmr!fieuasf,{e il naae ?un1rl6a

qude alfiaru r rnlil t fluf, alnriT u ru fr't lilruu'rcePl,

oa oe?il r iluilalafruSrulun r zfittur t rua 1un'l ?

iandfi 'rurlr1fr ua!,nT tfioururifirurlr'tfrdarrJal

r ilu uun r t ierari il rurlrrfiT-..-....--

tuilrcfiunrz{euriilrurlrtfiturlrsrnd'tnaii 3 uuu tna',r{enrtd

iurlr*.rruuri.rf 16 ,2s.281 6a

- | d. qr fiur a t rrrazlufrufr ir t ilun r z

uau arldz tn I a tTn r tn r zId

rfiu 1E l-j

"l ' *{s-'--- ' 4 d'iarf,a n"tdtiafittrufiuufre'tduuun 1 iefieu'al,lufl?1rof [ilunat

ouud z ie dfiu'tfiudtrror, **.tdri.fiu'tur leilrdtruur'itr'rfi 'td

'td, nrroildaiarHaaiufiruan t lsdr

ie r onT odrirlHrrr.,lril.noruuritdrfi 'rfiud rsasairt15

3

r dar r urr&dnrsfiu'tri r Hrrrurinrrnlnzru dzurrrorfiiiartn t fiunutruilQn

t fiunzauniras{

UUUN

airtdrurlT

Page 40: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

22

' { o ' ' e rffoilatrr'au'tff 2 finrilcn'lr?rjuilun 1 8{5t1tl1tnuil{nntriltsn1'tud-t...q'l

( nE.trte fl11ncuil1d{ruuri.rdrfi ,25281 dO

1. daiarf,aurn".ndfir.rirfiu eruTinutiaunraunirqradrrufiuat

rudufi ruao dri.iu." a i r rufiudndrads rirtficca rnurinr q rrdn r t'lunr tfilur

u i fi u z rra z ri r'rfi r ri es n r n u ti n r t r 6un r t't rrddfi t th fi u

z. doriardauu"dti'tfiutifrrafiur fluf,cCrutuusiauntaunflrir'tfi

udarnrauniroinrc{e ntscrafiuf Urudrirfiulatnut a.r'luueiacu}i'.1 *.rdoe rn

urirrr0zutdrirtfia'rnurinrr r tr'trtfisu'r uasrn?'ru r fiuilnuciuilaan'iT frnt*rd I

c1nnx111drf,rUilrtfruil firurntdC.o.toduoilatfiufnrrfirdafd

tfifiwantrnufl?c r fiau'tfr n?1il r taurars rfief;uadr{u'tnrlauurCra nur, f,t

n 1 1r, fl ru" rdi.rtunir o.ru. " u*rd ts ir r f,ufr a trirr 1n ?n 1 t?un 1 rins1ila.rfiu

'rfi n'r a ri rrufi u r fluu to n 6uf; r i rilud arrl

nqriua"uurfieiunT ri{a

ed d rt o qs1. nqpan t n8?!8{nU{1U'lrlA

s rnuurfin r darfrunT r r ildauurlatnr tf,.tnn

tHr.,rfi.rluein dfintnrr 2518 t32 I dnirrfit

f, ruuudrH tuHnnr f, .-rn uI nate a tr rfi .,rfinf, tnrina rtun aiutn r tai'r t oa"rufi .d

(Structural-Functional Theoryl Ua.rf,'onu'i't,f,r,rouurilO (Social

systenl dtilrcnaufizgrruuioatirtt (subsysten) iitiarudarfiuoduaot

r'nluf,ufiudd.rfiuuaofiu n1r r ldauurlata13 r fiaf;ututoul'lntuuundt uac

Crgra'trlfi.rCauduf tn:rdirrn,t{f,{nu ( Social Structure) tt ihunaufrea

drudr.rr iisffiurienriiunrriknrdrt't (social rnstitution) doil"."o

f,ufiui uasfia r radaefiuari udasdnrfiurrriT rnfiT dta.rfir , uo dofi"T rui,t r ilu

nr sfr snldd r au fi ilruurd.r 11 d r i ef;urun r r a qi d r ufiur a'.r iltauoqtd r flu r liiau

(Social Change)

iin r rilnra f, .,r n ulurifi u

nnlndrir -r ru r d arJr"T addr a.rfl t ar Te ailnfi n r rdr t'ltl! s {na'ln r u,i rf,fi I datfi

Page 41: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

23

f,.rnrad'tudnruduani,"drt d (Hoving Equilibiuml n'a nnCauraiadnrfiu

nrrfirnrrliufir t ilT urfiun1iln't'llt r rldauur.tnod, fi ofu'rueniuurrdrof;on. o

fl'lEn1t{ ilrnrnua"f,.rnu usiat dnrfiuct ti'lufirdororu, uo do r flun."duosu-{

n ? 1r0 0{n1Ttra{6tn'luuausl

qfio fiirurn (zszz: 118 ) tfrn ei T rfr .rn1 r r rjdauurln.rnr'rfl tnI'i r

riarrfieffurfiratra 'tdilf,.,rnlredrlrrorT nfl1?rrla{auurjat fllttldauur.la.rfirir

tfin r ru f,ufiudr o.runnnunnd r t".nd r n a t fiua dlr rud I 6ujtl

rlflrfi }fiilur (zszs:146-148) tfindrefitruxn?'lraedaitrra

fi .r d r I Hs r a { n 1 : I rlad auu rja .r fi a iu a r a nqrfifr r a fiut!|

nqriitn r retr.,runcufi rd

, fiunqrddfinf,snrcr*n{Crutunir Cafia le aua-rf,tnr r iiutsuuHuudt ,tuufi

ir r f,ufia r r f,uaid sriluf irf,runnaiinr: r rjdauurln t t dua , duo."nnosttldrfi

natnrrrie uri rtu *., n."df,o"urrdT r.raqitfi f,.rqufrasillnt..rcir.rrda

ufi.dd.6ru.l 1uf,snu

1. uurie r darfiurnt{n1r

.lupaul Oaddis tilr.rfrs'tulilfa alnts:rdl 252833) tnarfru

r nnfinnrr?1{ug,u unuilrs riuaf a'ir Inttnrt r fluuriraaodn.t"fi.dri.rn:orir

n'lr rdo'trafis t ilrHlra ratnrrfinurnudtdriruueri

ilrurrru uaunrzdr tfiunlr

f;rlufrT ur enr \til

Albert o.Hirscbnan tilrtfrstugifila arntstsdr 252833)

nri r r d r Tnr rnrr, flr,, {u on a {n'rra {4urileuil.rda, flr.n. r" onulilct t erdii-- --a r

finrsuriutafirinnrlzcd{d ril1e dHn iiuurnrrlfic'trad unofinndanrtfisur

daIrJ

sirta atn:ltcdn (252822,q . - do,g .

nttilzgriiuwair fnt{n,ttne.tatrn tnr rn r zddrs r rndr'trtrtififi rfr ri.r

. ity ) uac l darirlrlrlififiufirqutfrsanauunuf;uir niauzra

ceri.ouu r a r n tn r :fisurrfidddc

ro-neirrar t nnunn,t?11{ulfll uau

Page 42: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

24

3.q.luu

uu?n? 1ilno I n 42fl ufl 1 1fleru'l

afia fiiruTn (zlzz.tg4l'tfrndrr'tiluufinf,tnlinart:aa',rnrt

fi1urf,.rnt.ir n1Tfisul ( Developnent ) uil1afi{ n'l1t rJdauurln.rtuuui;

n1r1ilc.ln r6ruilufialalfifi.r rfie arrr r e?q rlrsradrluiiadf;un'ir rfiu nlcu?u

n. rdri.trtdn r rt r c?rufiufiun'la a i 1 { r dun e'rlfr r rufi 'r ( Progess ) n 1 x ra1 Efi ?

tnxpansilnl nrrrJi:rJ (Refornation) n1?rfiu1e (Grouthl fi'rfiunT t

fiourf, .,r nui.rfi ar :" d'rfirua i dn r rfiourau d.r n'l ?fisu1nufiuu' a ;i z il rr n r tn' a

( 1 ) ficurtfinudr r fiuerrr?nnaril.re ,, ilr,oudruur,$"fi"'rrudrlttn

*.rf ff efi flrUrUrfi eluflrUu'l r o {fi ? t o t u a c flruu I ilu t da r fiudrur e1't fr

<2, fiour'tfinuifinro drlrtnrir rilufirnrtlatf,tnt'lfitcacuurri

t{ostafa Kanal Talbe (1982!33)'tfrnairrfr..r uf,ntunrrfisura-t

d.rlnrtnrrdrueofralurirdurlrsdrdrfi (united Nation Environnental

prosran or UNEPr 6orfluurr.n.ttunrtinn.rdon.rfiollifi-rilfia8oB 4 . v '( 1 ) dudutuTanil t de i'uur t nadua tn 1'lrna{n'l?r a{rilrs

tl

( Z t n 1 f fisu.ln e riirari.ru1'l s I d o dua tn e rufi a'o n r rilug.tqq

u tLt l .- - - -C -.. - -!---fl zrru?un1 tEeurn a td'l t atrlnun"t$6t{u ,laa erud-an a.oiin r znen 1iluafl xsnut I {fl 11sstl1

r d a u r rn Tq 61 fl 1 u d.r 6 ! a { fl 1 rfi$ur Ic al ri itn r tri r a r a il ;s a "l fl rtl

4. uu?Ac t dgefiunrz r rlndauurla',1

uula e n 1.t d run r r r rJd auu ila oilfi fi ni I. n'l 1r4a 1 I d T u161fi n r 1 rilll 1 f,

't Trrnr rafitdsIilfi

(3)

(4)

(5)

fir1ild1a

dfin dfinrnrt (2625=2t'lfinrrurlll'ran,ttrrldauurlas'irtilt n..u

unndr.rd r fie f;udo I dattudr o , .".rfior o o s.dnrtrdoiiofr.rntfir ari

Page 43: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

25

inar drrruda ' (zszr: bG-E? I 'tfinrrrur.1a1a{n11[ ildauurln.ra , d q I , 4 o ! 4 ^-t^---.-,{--.Un'lBn{n?1IunflCI'l{n t flenUZcH21\t t ?A1UU{nUOn [ ?n1UU{ UTAnI? t UAgU

u ila.riia n 1 x r rliau r fi autfi t fiun r ruunnei r.,t r a {d'rufr .r'tu t xn'ld 1 {fiu

s. $u?Ao r darfiunrt r rjdau$ila\tn'l{ t cruIfir

ilfirfinrT uur1a!s{n'rr r ildauuilatnrt t czr5fic't{;.riln'a

rAs{ uiu (A.o.Hirschan 1958:24} nirrdr n.ttlldau

urla{n1\i r drp5fi inil1afi{ n?'lrfla1a1ild1 r a,tniut,tntutaflq{anrzclRndii

a iufr rud irn rs ien ro c r a a i fr .rrri4nriru r'ttuiapnltair tfi nr du lrnrirurst|tt

'tffairt, fiu, fi" r filr,rrira

f,rurUr f,rUfg'liTfld (2520s 15)'tfinrrurau.1an.1lrildauurla{n'l{

r orr5fi r r a \tiluiln ur rafi r n'rrdd'r aduuniin r nninuactna rn rtdfratradlrn

f* o^" rnniln rrd"f, il1r1nn'l{trdnrrrfludruruni

diilruf1'l rruTnun (2527 zLLTI tfinrun1.1Enllrildauurla{n1{

r czrtivi., fr.n.r r rldauurlat'luRrrs6eei,',ltrrtd lr..t.udr daefiut nnia

n r rruin uac n 1 r? 1 {rraru r darfirfirf; n?ua rn rdr.r1 ariT tiirlrolninrsl rnd4t

G. uurfie r darfiunr: r ildauurlatnrtf,tnn

f fiilfif fiuurfie t darfitnrt r rldauurlatnItf,tnu'tiuararlzonrrdtil

fi.,re rai (David Kingsley 1949:662) 'tfii1f1fianru'ir n11

rildauurlarnrrf,rnr ur1afit n'tzrrta{auurlatdrfinf;uruzcuuflsnufiu uiu

fl 1 I r rJ d auu rl a .r'tu1 n t'r d i I s u a n rafi r d r o "r

H''r n u

finar drau (2518:2581'tfiaiuranl1ilull1g[g\tn.tlrildauurlas

nrsflsnuri.ir n1? r ildauurla.,rnrsH.rnu , fl*n., r rJdauurjatfrtruuunr,ru

fr ufiu{ r a.runnad a i d r lfiu'tufl 'onl

Page 44: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

26

rotau.rnd 11dfir1;{fnf (252L274-75) Ifilfin?1}ll4u18!0{fl1?

r il*auurjnsnrrf,rnr r,ru'rafir n'r? r ildauurlaqd r fie ffuru1nrsdir.rf,.rnl

rduri :o r iisu na, n*fr uuilalrlfrlfiudnrtf,tnt nnae rudnluRltt ilnuln

airurqufird finrrusnrru,da.trofinsrrorf,afiursfidr{unna ndru uncdnrutl

nrnrdr*r1 luf,1nt fl.rntinardu'trfrnyrfl 'l? t rjdauurtnsfinruofi do, f,t n.t

r r1adauurJa{lurcuuf,{nu iirunntonunrs t fiaunrrt r fluoqitatduT inluf,tnuduo

un& I ilariasfiunrrrlitf,rlosunna'tufinr$udr{"1 uncdnrfiudrtl'tfi r trfiu

dn 1fl u rofi ar,d r ildauurJn.r't rl

dzrlqrnnqrfi uaruurfia'tunrriia r ri.dt.urrutfr dtndrrf,'r.rfruf,

ilifaittiquurnrrufiedqtfrnur rdsil:ctiueranrsfiT uretrgfiq-fi{nu !0{

i.ron.rieudilrurlrf fi ilruni*ddlgzri eiruatsd'l eir tnaaruf,n i'rraTe

ofiasrfi re sdrnrrfrnrr r rjiau, firioo.* r ozrsir-f,.rnt ua"ficunfida1nzs

nrrratndtffrarir.r z n,iu rda.rern*R1srfir uasnrrlrf,uodla',rndlf,tnn

' . - - -!-s-e' ilndauur1nrle ailnrr{e trluuun'rta;iaT f,aou"n.lur"niur.il*nflilU|{\innn1-(fi [ UA8U$UA{ lnEilll' r r

o.urfinlo rn r ru uuturi na aosuiin r tiatc iludrsr rurllnnuasu?n rrdr.rt lfi

dr a rsd rlfi r r a'tfi r r a.i r g $as n ? 1r r iiua ;in otn{lnu1uf, o.ufiuiin. t r rtarsull

uiln {.1 ilq rn r fi r u€a a rcuensi 1 {e rndnn{urdoda{uanTn z',rn'r r{era{ilrurh

1ilfisnri're aardaairur nnilr, dr".;;;;;; rdoir,.fiudunot , orilt.mfr -t I

fln{rl-rfieauruf,r f fruri ilrur !1r?1.t unrilrut nr I tae tirunrsd'l dr tna

nruf,n i.,ru{e afiasrfi

o-ddv{1tt'llanl ntztD{

fiiia'tfifinn1a?,rruqndr.rrs.rdeurlzdrtl driT r"iiBniuasialnrl

n.r :{cudilrurlrtfiufi r utd srui{ad r da r ta tfilfi rudrdr.rt o u ou.*.dudrfrrir

nrri{a'tiufirfiuiioifioa r rirdfiunt'rrnadcndru., ilr,uu.fieuntH.raulfigru

n s sn r ri{oo *of,rfiir " niln'rur iionttrtud.r.d, ndarf, a sfiu1nt snrtfi$ur

d.r.rt d,dr.tuofiilnilrlrclrnrdarflaai'tutntsnrrdtnaitr diiEadagnau

tCfiEfi1-f,.rnl uat fidunfidaTnttnrt1asudtarn,flu 3 ilrsl6u fia

Page 45: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

27

1. n.l?niln?u?r?ruflx?il r ndarfiunrzfisu'luacd.r r e?unrior."at dli

aradadnru r grp5fiq

z. n.lxniln?u?rrrunrril r daefrunrrfifluruasd',r r e?ln{ur.rat dli

runsiadn'luf,.reu

3 . n 1 rniln ?u? rriln rru r da efi uficunfi n a t nri u r.tatdiidarn z ln rt

fiuu'rtdrt'l

do"u".nn.rrnunru?rrunrrofio, il:srfiufi.rnrir,ltr''rfru rttrna

-8a{u

rnoo filiilrnr (252?l 'ffiuri.rnrttirarailroan,f,u Z n'l'l n'a

il1 {n 5\i'tfiuri lrfrl'r nrtdnaaufieifu'tfi nrtun tndlarsd'l' d'""u"'uodfit'

uasnrzrirnrarlrrdarirrdrdrrrur" nr.,rHn* 'tfiuri n.ticdiurudilT c''r,,uuri'r

il r fi tfi r 10 iu a s, fl 'l I ie f; tfi n 1 Ai'r s qu t a { n o { n r r il r ra d r d t t n : I orl

,orod aia{ed (zszsr uu'irnrrdnicarntrh'tino'lirfineat

orirstro r 6r iidrur ndarfiasfiuiltsrilrntduun fianrt tdurn'riltcdtnl Rx''ll

fi ,on.rdfiuririu nr rlfiatnT ztfif t*oa'tunir r tau nrzass$fi t'i* t ilT Irlrir

fiufudrS*reuur,i.rilrfi qna'ruudtilrfi r nntnrT fit df,n'irl'r uasn'r?!,raunau

, i.rafirf,runrrilasfiu

ilia r ta.rurfid ( 251? )

n r ru{r au I { n o {n1 lrirn r arlr't {f, sfi

tfrnrirefrtnrrdrararlr'til lesdr6ild't

nrzdnaaufie'tfi rae I rurrirararlT r dariT

.rirdaunaa nrrdrarailrrdartiludrsr"ilan nr:finaauf,e'tfirdariT ilu uar

rsrrdru nttdnnauf,effiiiirrdanrtfi" uia'tfldruf,r nrrdfltiladurduottn

lrlrlrtud e tOgufi t nr tdra rar s tlznunvuua'rf,n giid naaacufi ssrrudrfi duf

nilsflzzrnrzfisur rCzrtrir unsilsailuritlra (26211 nrirrir

i r n r r d r a r ail T s d r t 1uu :..tfi ri tf fi r fi c itrUra T d a n iu a r n zfl I rfl

HA11fln1?Untflu&l?o1{ rl'l'd-lEU'rs- I

r,rd uaof riiaanrsnulrlfi.rd',rorcfiaute afietrtfira t fiudtitflo t nn'i.rgaflie

n1{n11, n*"rd,duf;r. t inqrnnuo"'ilud t $tsdanrrnn'irdro t fi"n"' tfi*

rJrr?nfinT u'Lunrtufin

Page 46: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

28

e;ed Tut <zlzlr nriT tir n r zdrJrrd'', n,, fi nu.nf;uu notfdfiu.e!^.e334--Odrsrroe'lrti n?1ilturtr glqnltrirztinyl eurl.l[5[AIQiln'lsaA'l{??e

-tl9a { { q -ua { dt a

[ ? ? r sro r wtaraareiq uns T1a'tdd{ra 1a t iloilrirnr: t llrurl4n aan'til t tJuil5 [ xnlI

n Tr.,rTe aunrnufi rn r {ilrda irnfi r 6a',r9t!I

{ --rrurir'tfifiudtl.rfr""&l nn0,lull'luanl1f

nradrtrre r *rufrrfis r flu"^nronurrjfi'rniur.nrdut r du fln{rlr rasrlruac

dnruursfialTcafir'trJ

Haquet, L. (1983)

es dtluu?, .*dfi on tnn 1ilqen'la

nrire'ir lcafirIrln1rta1af,'llatttarfrn

uasrdruttadrnrrt nrnr'tfi doiludrud.f,

drur rn't fi il 1 1 1 n n 1 run 1nuilr n r t ilr rl rrfifiudil rt il r fi a n r tdruu r a't il ad r's r rna u ,U{d{S {

t r? CI'llrn21ilna{fl 'lrl'lunn IsrDul Taa'l

Kunst adLer, P. uasrnilc (zg1u neirrdr t.tatdiitrtunrro. --ul r | { . q I __,-___-__CS g {.

r nrs riirra'tddrn'i T t.tairs uaudi5ruun.t.l I Crrtnrfi rn?1T1EAtnIa1ilT0u

' 8=--" 'qlunrtnirt ila nrrra"tiludtl.fiurtr'trjT'lnOT n4a tUc {wE 1a 1uf, 8 1 afl ,ltHA

.tur rnilr rda rfiurra'tfiil1cur ianzaunir ,.rn".nf,fi{ua't41il rdltra'tfite aI

if;a"u tdu iutrtfirru il{rtf,e'tfrunotrrdru rflufru

ifipd ilrcqruruuls, uaceJuc ( 2s16:2) 't6flnrrnrra*sufi.adt

lurlrs r ndlngrsu'irtil 24sL-25LG f frndrrfi',rnrrtradunru ilarltnot

Hoatey .ir,, n 1 : tradu r f,uif; n r rrJiufi e r a ouutdd acn,t tue'l 'ttttrirlqadl a s

nrzfflilin leanrtrndrr.f,radsdoT da iltsdrntiiuurffiudegntt'r'lafr?t o{

rfi f,ufiuffi ui an r dtun r rrir.t ru "a" r r*r*". nilr.ddr'I a n rdlun r td r t rufi a a

rrrCiluddil an rdtunr rrir t ru r ilou.nfrt

nzunll{ t ntrsittnceianrd ( 2519: 10 ) lfrrtzs tiutnrtnrrfisur,nd

uun{u'ltru1o t afl it1a{e rouuriu {',ruTauurdrrnru {wie nT Slu{ ru'i'r

dnrun r s il{ nr ! 0 { r nre zn rtu r rntn :.tn r rdtn d r r Cru'tuqidf;uf; otuH,tun ? 1r

r fiuoi drnrsaurfia Basn'lri?uiiadra r ua'ed-rfiuuas'ilul9

Page 47: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

29

rlilr dvsv (2520: 1001'tfrfrnrrriltautfiauEruonl{tA1p5fir

uasf,tnUra{ [ nECI?nr 'lUr re1e rtnrtdailtsn'luuua\tU?T AnAUUu dr tna

fi.nro i.rniarauuriu su'ir rdarrl{autfiatnrtrtrrf,urlrintuaoCntn.n4-orlu

n.1z r nrqr 1a?a5tn1ilut ntrq?n1{"1 wu'ir I nr6lnrndl{f fiturirdailtcnrutl!l

{a'tI! -

dil 1il n 0 { n n t n 1 { n 1 ? I fllrq T r 'l fl n ? 'l n 6iil r flrq ? n r n 4 il {f df d iud1ilnil z u n rurql

figfid Rtrtts (zSZ2z17) 'tfifinrT wanzsnun.r?ffffiT fnilzon.*d

noruad a n r ra at iuina rn r t I nrnruiru'tnd I a t t nrntn rlu1n t tn r rdailt!,n1u

firm1an uu,ir rratfrlnidoilernnrr [ flrotIE.r I nrorn?1u t nndarlr"nruil

rratdanBq.lnn.t? r nunrdrn'ir r npqrnruan t rqdailzsnru d'.rrratfigninrt

n1?[flrorEo.trnrornr.lurrqdarlrsn.,ur"dr Ls,g74.go u1n/il udla',t

rntrnrflruanrsqdailz"nruiizraffi4nir"dtriia.r 14,42O.67 u1n /il

finfi intsind uasnilc r)rrrror, lfifinrrdnrstctp'fiqiltnlnos

rnrnrnrfiiufi.rfalr$n1u drrnaitdrtad'rru i.rraiadr{nos sru'ir tno?nr

ru, orruirrnruiinrrudasnrrtfian r iru.uffufisarflnrrild g o.nile, uas

a.ncruuil.rfi o,rn r r1fian r {aud.rn.i rirailfinr.,itd 3 tc a r nrn rn t.lriffa tn r r

tfianranruriruT

4lltt

iunaruud (ZSZSzZT6l 'tdfinr,tHnnzcniltntsnrriln

il:onrufi'rou {.ruiodnnue: su'ir ilalardadnTutC:rgir-illnu d.,rdauil

, d, o..n r n,,n rnzrr.rilrrd t srsilnnr.nf;u rr rilr.d r sluilan t d"f;ttiaa"u 2t

tur tnie rldiur rnf,unfir coiioauiqda'ti rduffr, Ba!roauqnirtfiuilr ldau

uilalerl t nnfintun.riliuilrofiud fufi.ueir r iaut ntrntnx su'iriizraf frl ilu

rtude,iiuf;, Tnarc$rulurlaiellddutnilnzfl1 iizratfi ,duft ttnrfircrn

1,506.12 u.ln/rfiaufuit 2518 ,flr, 4,64s.27 u1n/rfiau'tuil 2522 ud

r1r r n a'i r r r atd4nid, ft, iudonr t n r r I nrn r'lu t lnfi:npiludluttt'nrult t r a

I6aea'.r rslzrofiununrr$find't

qqt6lnfl1noI

sradadnrs r crrXfiq1u t lqf n:lnrt n'rz'in,dof;t iea"" Lz.8

uT tnufitfiun.rnnu

Page 48: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

30

aasiadnrflfi,rnuur.ir r nrqrnrdruturtiinrrrfie,fit dfidtnrrfisuru d .. tna {nuunil?1nA?'tif ar rufieu t'rfiu?u, {,on r t'ttfiT ua!,i'luu'i1 t nsnrntiuue

sdTfrililcca o1 iunrrd.o r diun r rrlqnfi t.tuqeuils 1ufi run r z r rJdaufiudtr eilfioa

s q rs art { <r ---!

r

a.oqo a 8nil$ufl !'l?uu t 11 0 il a8tlll

t d rf1zun t2527 z2L7 | lfidnrrifafl afl rununl{ t gtr5fi r uns

f, rnr r a sn r rfigu.rdfi uu6rsur46i.rfi r tuu? r ?ilTn r \i n r zfisureiufi T udu{l Hnyt

rou.lsnrdisiruadr{rfi'{ drrnauriuit itraicrta.rtud uu'ir'tufr'ruf,.rnu

r nrn rn zlurn r Ina ritn r rlariinn'

adr'ro'

--e. . q I .q - ---{' o '2527 z32, 'tdrirn,trilzs t nuc|an.l?d.l t drrusurneu ts1uau1nail

og'ff16UU1l ?\tn?eilnTSUI| gil?'l

I

nrrfir,u',dfir. flrcni?{t t flror$nsduntrir < tr.rfis tu{

d ruu r s deulrtun rrfisurdliur a'.rnu r fiu

dltua

dr rna

ruasiodnru r d:r5fie uu'ir r nrnrnrtur nnlnrtn'rrfiBturdiufirratfr

rillfrun'irriausir tilu1nttnrz 'LudnrrCru 13 3 - 48r Cru

61asiadnr$f,tn1 wu'ir t nrnznrdru'trnrt{aaac 78. 58 aaufuata

q rn'l r6i r r iut tur a {19 t.ln 1 Tfi$ur

ori drnruaurfia uacnrrnruurnrlun..tddffu rnrnrntdru'tHriiaans 91- 42tt

iin r rrnrnnilqdrd r f,uar rin n a r'[nr sn.r, d, o..nrir'rfi r fi nn r rudun I unoii

ex1rd1 r tqruflint

ff,nfi inarfin 12528:361-368) 'tfifinrruan tnnudru r rurgfi rt

ua giltnu n a.rtn r.,rn r rfigu'rd6u, drn., t fl rn rn'lq r ufi o flnrr t ourontdlitnTe

r ila.,r:ra nu'iriiwadadR,rst crr5fiqua!,f,{nu 6tderrrfi

fladodnlr r drygir nu'ir t nrntnttur !n'[Rr{n1tfro{ r lai'r'tiliraI

lunrrntnud.t ilnartuqnei'l'8la'0zra1d'ludrunrrsn,tTa

druf rarif dfi r iuoal uas r fiu'irgruon,1{ t C:r5fielaonufif;u

'lue runr rsn,t T a orsu?1 [ nro?fl 1

rir'rfit fian'rr t rjdauurlattuffrunl.u t f,*

U

Page 49: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

31

aadadnrsH.rnl wu.ir Te a r adaufreni. , ,'rr,ufio t f,urlrinndlnr"t

f,snu ilrvnrru g ndl n?111n1eui.r'Luournolo.tuotdeu'tuddu.1rndtunt

r tauf dfrsusin rtfinnrnrnfi tfiu uei'lunrrln reuS'r'tutndlnrttflH'tra iluor

t fi H rn r r uu {tI i'tursdurlErUrUrni f fi6 ers, u ri uo tlun r tdqlul c r fi an a r ils$ae

, fiu.i ruq rd r ane zldiun r rfi nrrl rnn'i un ttlfr .r tufi run r z'tt r ra Ti r t wu'i r

druluricu.rt r ea r.i.r rufi tqen ra r fl rsdanlun r zur z r a'tfrfi r rr fi riruue t ?a'l

tun rtdr t ru uacnrtilifififirie zrlzsir{ulo tnut.

qTu irilazinw.rf uaon*" rdr,rfi.rff,nfi inarfin 2528?52, ils

.tdrlrc r fiuaratn r {nrrfisurdfit u.unrs :rdiltcdod tt n. rilrs t iulnttn r rtu

rl r !, r n C't n a wu'i r fi ar a ei s dn ru r Cmr5fi r u a s f, .r n 1 d'r d af rf fi

aasiadnrut dtrgfir nu'irtot.rnT rfinu'rddu fiwariT'tfit nrnrnrtu

Tnr.rnrrifnerri uacn'l'lr r Cataluufin r nrnruaru'trad uauaautu'trlrlhfifisru

cudrf fiiln. n, fi ,,"^"fi qd.rfua i T siifi adr6run'r.rAfi fi In t.rnr zilelndoe r rrunn

sir.rtuyra.tdsa.0,nrrrlrrrir.rilfiadrdrunr.rafifi ndrrfiatnuntntturnt'qnrt

ilfi rraffi , dur.nf;unraufi.rillnt.qnrtfit 3' 2e9. 48 lt'11/ t dauturutd, nt"nzuanlRrtnrzii:raffi rduf;uriiat L,278. 42 u1n/ rc'su rda0qrtil'ln1ls

nilAr. rlzrna,i.r tuit s.C. z1t4 tnrqrnx,fr.nfiitu"" 36.0 n1aufr{'tnrc

n r rdt r ilu.,r ru1iluff rfi .,r u. c. zE 19 dnrnn t:, fr.nfi oto r nrn tn tfi ia aa" 15 . o

latf rurut nrstnt'Lu1nztnrif;onu, tufrrunrrufi{uolcls{ [ n$nTflt ul'ir

r nrnrn:ioaa!, g L. tt iin r ruua?qturla'tfi I a snu'tuHrudnrsilru r ioudo;i

o T fl aiienr*dd*u oo." rff* ilgru'fifrun'ir r darriirnr {n 1?

saoiodnruf,tnu st'irHrudlnruaurfia tnrorn:iaaac 86.5,fi*,i riin r zuin r tnr talrsrt$dl I ila tua frrun r rRnrT su'ir t nrn tn ztu1n ztn r t

il teunfi dfi a.r n r r1fi un ,,ia 1u! a.,r nu'r fi iun r rilnr r d tfrr. .. n n. rilnr rn ,'n fi t fi u

fisiaanr BO. s9 rdarrtiaurfiaufiunrauantnrsnrr tnrnrnzfratnrztfiuor

narufinnrd{qrnnrnnrrilnrrfi'rfiu rfia'r?aaao rt2' 85 'tufrrufidunf,rst

r nrnrfl ? uu.i r r nrnrnrCru'tuqi r fiufi r afi'n I zri't t fiun I zra t1n zsn r t

Page 50: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

32

e.lrfi dfiusin 125292 43t tHrirn'r:i{a I {at nrzfinrrdnru

r Crrgfiq uacfrrsilra{ r n'qlflt 'tut nqtnr'onrtdailtcnrufira t du't d'r tnaJ

rfios isrlTeA?un{ riligurfiaurru'i1.itnro?ntfifdiuriT dailtcnru fiu

r nuq zn rfif rif fi iufi 'rdailts nru uu'i r fiHasi oCn'ln r Ctrgiruau f, "rnlfi "rd nIilfi

aaeiodn,rurCrugfir uudr firunrr"nrrfiril tflro?nrn{u{ffifufir- 4. trou,rnn,i,rnriu r nrnrntfif rirdtufirdarltsnru rodtururaludnrlzvnruilnl?nl I ILrld{.{

,l1xflsiln I uou.l r .,iuru ra sniln1{n1i r nrn I r f,udeu'luri" ' - {i--' andacn.*xo.r] uu.irnril r flrErnrdrdrfiiufirt'arlrcn'tuilnrtilraansiodnruf,snu

tu6T u

atd

dur rn..nTn r tn I rl,r nn.i'rnri,,duf nriu r nrn rntfi-tfr furirf arlrsnruiin r 1u

fi o snr ru asn reu{slfiuq rtfi iun r rfin'rdt n'n r r r tr r fluauriln a',rdn zn'l {fl 1 r

r flsnr uns r ilr{el.ficnrrutuiluilulrnn'i't ndlfidf rif fiiufiT f nlt!'n1u 1u

firunrr"nT r r turlra nir t iaula',r t nrnrntfi'tfiiuilrf ailtuntu iiotto t iu

I

rJrafiaand.l aix t iaunot r nrolflrfi{ldf rif fiiuilrqrndnrlrsnru

Indurnr rnriI r nrs rn rfi'tfi i'fi T lnrtrunruio'tur rn r tfiuddn'i t naiu r ntro 'n

r

frrrirfiTufirdarltcnru

olradr:equau?1\tnsfu natienrtdAuilnen.uuri'rtrrfi ('z527) Ifr

finrrdnru r d*gfi c uasf,1nurasrrrgztuurifi'rurlrtfi Tnztnrrrli'rlr-rrlT

af.rruurisd'rfirlriufitnr drtnaf,au're,tn ituTaasu{ uu'iun'ntd""gt

f,.ra r f,rurariturarifirudrulrani n'a {aaao 64. 28 fiatnrtu'tr.ilAtttitfiu $ofl

fir,,d.uu^rrgrfif,nrirtr{aaao 2L.42 o"odruiiadeuflaa 6a usit'l1ufiunu

ilr.dfi nntridclnonaruurirtrrfi fi'aure d.rrnarlrd'f,n iruTnrsdzurd naon

eurirf,n { r fi u r, f, a oruiludf; r a aa rf, r r idd r dainr rieurifi rurlr'tffs uTn :'t

nr:6.rnrirr

rdarfiu:ra'tfilslutiaunraunir uu'ir d ru'tuqii r r ar fr'tuz s fi u

6,OOO-15,999 U1n/il ?8{A.tU1rf,r, ze'0oo-35'999 Urn/il uas' 16'OOO

-zs,eee urndait dofiarfu:ratfi,odrtrirfiu 26,?13-?8 u.rnril fiuirai

lur nm{ilrufla'l\t

Page 51: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

33

S.*#',1di,YfiFf 1ufi .run r r.fi o r fi un, o r.ro, r d a r fi un r z ioddu'rugrluri ilrurl'rr fifiu

Crutrart r fiufirs c'fiilr ofi , fia o , finfir rdrri r fiufrr a dofin." , f,un.ndn'ddu

e?auera\ioririauuffrrfiun'ir rs fd drunrrfin".rdrrrliaurfiaudnrsnr'l

fi.rurd6giqunef,{nura{rlrinuriilrurlrril fiurndilT utnfirda',rfiu coul{ru

(zszil rfifinrreurinurifirurlrrficeudlr6q isuianrflluf fiuurifirurnfi

r fia{ uu,i,r ,lio r fir r furlr?nrndfirurlrtfi qoilnrr r ildauurja{n1{ r cffitfic

!a{n?ounia lufirug.rusrn?''tttrflua{ rra'lfi U'fun'r'rd6fru drudnrsnrs

' -l -s--- - --.teroan.e.lrl rls' | ' q '" ruilr1frfif,.rnlTeafie'trl rfiarfiunrzdnrrnatilOTr4a.1u ilrrnArraflrdnr4lur

n r rriltcdrddrorfiue nanru'tfifunr rilnrrruffuesn'ir nr tfr,run rru irlila

r d ariT fi qn mud. oa

or,.,l,OrrOru rinuriilrurlrf fi ruf fin r rildu'tc uatn r ru i ru

n'aurnn,ir rdufiu ud'tufrrunerl!t darfiunrzau.riia n1??'l$uEfuntaunit

n rrildulc dr rarrfi ru r fi o t rr'rri. la.t t da rfiunrriltlrnaua rilrn rtfier rrui

n.l 1 u r trl ru as n r rudul r 1urcfi u r d a r fiuf; ..t eu rinradfi rurh'tfr u asudfi rut n ff

rdar deunrrrfierfiudatnrtnrril4nrirt*rurlrfiu f;telrinradilrurlTrfi

uaoradfirurnfirda.rd-r.rfirfiufieafi";;:;.rrdurdarfiu drura irurr, fttdfinyrn r r ufi o r 6ur o rdr T ?nu{fi rurlrt frd an r trlg nrf r.r drudr'Lurt uuudfi T u

rh.rfi s, o, odn., ;;;;.; ;ro,t.rl *.r r fi utaruior'ttuurdarn ru6lun.u,$fir

rafirnrauntrelrinurifirurlrffr rlil Se urisiruru 1,636 11a tru'iTnfi

ri r r ur Crulrani r flus 1;a11ufi , oduduandf; r tdauilr Crur rrazdo...no."d*fi

fiaaair.r'ttfi*., rl:'rno'ir ilzcdrn tnr.tnrnn!, iuoafl r da s, ufi ,"uf; odr.g.t

n rsriqn r&r raailu t nnrland{r tdturhnrn r uilaciaufrr',rlrnvd

n.lr r !111 r uuaur?nurifirurlr'tfi Crufuqifra.rnrtddurirfiu

n r til.r rurir n a tdu rilntun zaue i't ua gn rr1fi iuciefi na td r tt

CeutungaIs{

Ua!, tUgr.r'lCffrU

36025 i rrr rcbe9

Page 52: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

34

rl1nfl 'lltjrs t firrn?1il6e rfiu r darfrun'rroir rilunrtrjandtr.odaurlr

learsuur4ililrurlrrfi 1 1fl n 1 f n 1rn r rliilnr a.rdrr?n r rliau, irurrn,i.r s4i. q

- d .u u a t

air t ur r drfruilariflrrfiu n'rr'tfiuin.rruasrdidfi n.r rtd r,r1 r du frrunr:u?n r tutu'.tu'rdr ur?i Yr{flr n1?inyrua'lula n1T?1\rnerun?aunir nrz.tfiu?nrzfrru

nrzfinrr nrtsuC{staolfrqnrtnlTtnrq? nrriuir.,rrirr.rufiudauilr oaaa

runrrilr tutro t dantrrir'td uas rturrrTafr r cr sudrasrindru'turtua'tr

u a "

fr a .,r n r r c v o i r iiuao., ilnuri fi rurl rt fr d a't rl

r1nfl 'l?nun2u??rsunrrt, ri'rdrrurulff6rnairetrsfru er rfiu.iriiv"ludrurlr r narilu a'lq ruffun'lrfinrr arilurafin s1tura.,i irurudrrin'tunir r iau rra'tfr zraira fl1rsn1?aar n1rsn.lz, fiuril n.riradu

oda ? 1rn 1or,ra.c r na rfrun rrfinurno €uq?

In1? r f,rderficnrlriludu nrr'afrfuI

u?nrrfrrudrsrtuil'tnn uaeR'rrsnrr r iurlea driaradanrzfi$uruasd{ r etu

nEiurJtudrntdesri a'rfi r fi aeradarfnru r erugfi e-fr.,rnr oa oeiun 1 riifirunfi da

Tnrtnr: friiaT{d'rl,r r iiunrulrdrfltunrri{atun*rfi

Page 53: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

,nC s

q{. - -o?fle1 tuiln1T?18

nrziiae?tfl r flunrrrir I s,rrs r ilauif;n.rriianr.rf,rnrcrdo{ur

lfltunrtilnrr uavriiunrzfinnrtorarrnnrnduru (survey Research, iio

drnr:,fiutola qrnnrzifunrpol.rnurudornrr fiiiarfrri, nrrilnrr fiunTrt'll

r anrf tz aaaeeuir:r uauila{1ui{ad, d"rfra'rufrr rfirafunrrrfic r fiuiruusrir unsrfinr.tnt.u t fuu. nr:ir r ilu.srulor'[nrtnrrc'lnfffuficil0uTn1.,l

n1r rdonrrqdauffala r ilotfrr uau r fiutaunfiu5rulunrri r nrroritarua

ilrgilrnr r ilrr,rura

ilrt drnrrflruura ufarrrozdrflufirufirnfrriau dtarf,aai'tut

t rnrn:.tnrr{eradfirurlr'tfi fiT unf;wiclur,$ tdruarlrri'r dr rnaaruf,n {tuiaofiasril druru tza aitriau uasrilrcdrnrdarf,aodtufiudrrsilrrdrn.,

I---y--l- --9 e _-_-. _.. |t s ioa ! I ?a u .-s . ataurnE ua{uu?flutru I Dn?nr,lrfilfr6laxilruranruts lnun [rut !1!,t.1{ sirualt

rcri'l drrnaaruf,n f.ruToqfiasrii irueu ?o nirriau uac firurrrrtarI

tdruart dr drrnanruf,n {.,ruTaafias'1il iruru roa nfrrinu r.u,flu !74I

nirrisu uaez?rrilurlrsdrnrnaiuriltmraf;of,u saa nirriiauI

lolaotn 1 ltut ?aE 1{uastru,tcta {narn r aar Iit

iruruilruilrnrril'naurafr{ure B4B nirriau fri{arfruri.rndrf,r

airtaan,fit z ndu rfruri niudariru'lnrrnr:rarifirurlrril uarndrda{uan

Tn ztn r tu{fi aurlrIfr frt{arfrrtn r zCufi r a i r.r uasn r rriruue !u1e !o.,rneiud artst,-8<aa1{a{u na

Page 54: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

35

tdflatnada:irurn r sn r:rariil'rurJr'tfi rfiif;n rz r fi ufrr ai r tr rnfirufirat

u<ln?? [ ?au

1. flar|nAA'auIe 1\in1?r4t|il1iltj1'ttl 'af 2fln'17 t ntt!!

iruru LT4 nTrrlau tfierfiuiaaac es.oB) rrnilrcdrn: r ilr

d.telfirnrz r nufreprirriruru zo

uo.ofi.,uuu iruru 183 nfr r iau do r flt ndufirari'r'r dr iiurrrilnratTnr,,rt

nr:udilrurjrlff firuntnieuurol druarcrir Eirrnanrufln i.rraTnofianrfit!!t

r d . E ^r.f-d I 9 | | o ! .z. nailnasuaflrnr{fl'l?'tflifrnrrdufiraart rrlilflnilo?0a1$ursItlq

g'rncdarfraarilur rqilr rdanrraufnf ufrtuurfiudurar r rninrrfit df,r{tlT9tle u .l q . .u o .u .ld ,uufrrarrufr*r d.riifruru 13 nriilru Teanrrinoa'lnrr1nurifrrufrilarifr{nileilrrIt

rs * rnfa z udfirudrdrrrznCltfrfiTur!'l[21\r oiruarsd'r drrnaarufln

d.rfirtrrtrn"f;ofrui.,ru5aofissrfi i{frilrsilrnrfi{Fu zo nfrr€au rirnrzrfrufieprirriruru zoI

nirtiou <frarfiuiaaao sz. tn un"firurnrriiar silunrsdr airrnaaruiln

{.rrnTsafiarrfi iirlirtrulrnrf;rfiu ro7 nir r *au drnrr r fiuf,rair.,r iruru104 o?.,;m, tfiarfiuiaaao s7 .zu r?rtrfiuniurjrsdrnzfiroirr iruru

I.t -!r!.l 4 . . . it { 4 o u etT 4 nirtf0u lilisnrttnueeodr{ qlnilrcdrnrrilrrarra frrilufrrufl'lnT?

rr d q ' o 'r' rlr'tfr *.rairur rqrl,r tdoI TEUDO{lj?vd',lfl? nO10[80AUOn r nnTnZ'OnrtUUUtu, rolon'l?ou?flD rantuurfiudu rat r nninrrfiuddn{rlrfirarruil.,r tufiosdfi.ril o.ll

fl'11{ uncfirur s1ri|ar si'luarsdr nir rnaaruf,n iqaToafissrfiI

, "d"oiiadtff.tunrrifa

nrzi{an*rflfritartruudoufl,rr ( euest ionaires r , f,rr r.{roii,lunrt t fiutrutrr taranrnduru te arirnrrlir.,r unsdr riunrz r fiutnuao8<A{U nA

1. ntrdirtuuil6foilo,ru (interview sched,ule) fri{afdeirsC q {a g q-[ul1nuu'rn?1une nqra r4an1tr'1fl1r rl:snaufiugatruiiari.oa d,da.f,ro

fi un r :i ia" ?ofid{dur fr r n afl nr. nr sdruf,il T u fr r u au't friliurl1.r'tfi r uu rsdufiu

dnrun r trin a { I ,.nardc" drn rrfinnrrun *.,rf, tea r o*.", i "..1C

srudeur a rta

Page 55: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

36

rila ilarailn unsuuuilruriuir (ratiTn r tn r :{eradilrurJrri u o tn zurlrrfi d..rfinrrus r a tir n.ufir., fiufi ouuuila r a

Cru r darfirfrfiruor.udfra{nrrff.rsiaril

'tffuri rsd.qn11U1[eil

!Iv.i1.1 raruaila1il

It

a'la rilotrfi crdurI

d-qqAduIn [ fla ?nufln1un1{ r flTr5nlBac5t{nil oa aoqun ? 1iloe r uu! a {t'lrot I na ?nu!f

a

scale) t.rilrsnaufrrairnrr 4

nai r rfi .rdn'lun luTe afi rt rt z a.riltfilun rrrircdunrr;lnrr iruruafrrinru"lrunir nfi

zsdur rardarfraad'tu

ng&u

fu a d - y durulu n?'lilneIuu-aufl1ra1anu

!l

t.z talnnr.rfrlurd?uafii nri'rrfr-rorfs rT a'tfr r,tsi,la!|

{dqaq..an'l?flan?a{nou antrflsn'l?Hafrunsfl'lT11t4u'lagranaan't{n1Tt nDfr? nrr'ttuttsrulunrtglho itrparlunrrrirnr:rnrnrnrrr iruruniuilt o..rn.t

q{q[ {u ( fiu5lu)

1.3 toruafr'ruf,.,rnl nairrfr.r n.rTnru'rnunrrfieia fiuf,rnnI

R,tsuon nrt'tfriurirrdrz nrrianrzilnrr n?'lrn1eili.r'tunrrilflD1!E{

Uex n1?il?n,trdrrrtsdn tstudtsrrruillnnrdr{61 n1? r trirllunrilfi rn:rt99a'9

' '{ d fiuai'Lusfiq fiuflrcfiuo1{1 UAstilT8Uln8U6tn1flR?'l||[

" e

L. 4 talafrrunerrn'erfiuuacfieunfi nrirrfr.,r nrruilnfinfialidc r o aq I t o J oEa{r'ltr0rilfda nrtauinffrcirlT nrzauinfnfsarnrrlrlil ntrilandrdldu

uasficunfitd snrr{ntn rln r ruriilrurlrlfrI

z.'tfrriruuutrruo.udiliiacirrf;u rilneaarttf,lnT nrifirufirnirI

risundfiru1rltdrlRu druarsdr drrnaaruf,n {.ruiaofiasri! iridnr"","ou

q 1{'l n{n1{e1uilisd1ni finrflsn'ltn,taR,tsra.,rurifiru' aarraudnn$snr,,t

d'ru t cmgfie-f,tnl ndranfi-rfirndlf,rai. o, il.unladrrilnurtfa Te ari'ln,lruiilun, rrir (Pre-test) iauru go r1a ufi{lrnl6nena.,rtiluflrt.niurneafou

{-{n ? 1u t riatTaaid q coef f ic ient ro{ntouil,tduasd'lntrrliurJrtufr'tlriol

fiurirurrjinrrroi'ruucri'r nrrrfia , fir, ft, r firfiuarr.tddrlinr-, r darfiluu-- -.- - -.rr- {- -_ |5tAUn1rilA?1rrnA\in1.r (Content Validity) uncnraunnrtileu'lla{n1r

i i a f; tr.rr n u fr r t.r ri T't rJ f, u n r rsll r s d r n r n d r fi a a i r .,r dilnn r uiludri, r u

anrtrlrfl 1 T r ['lr 1 n 1Aa a dturail ff rurlr'tfi

Page 56: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

37

ifrnrrilnrT

r d otfi u t t n Tn n rl rc d..r d r a o .r rui {ad r fr o .r n r r fr a r a n r t fr ruoi'r.,r1 6a

ilaryafir'trI toryanro6.rr,'orrgfi.uacf,{nr f,alnnT .rdrunrrrfiarfiuuarficu99r

n6 drrfiuffa.rrti#nrrfinrruaraif,ilrcnaufiufi.rfifio

dufl11 t flUT?U1?t|naIA

1. tararJSrni (prinary data) friiartif;n.lrrfiufrara tea

n r z f, un rrr$n u u urtda un r r u fr r fiufi n i r q o u a.o1uu uu do un r I re a a.,r ii a frun,rr,$

fi r aeu r a.suao {r tufin.,r ruf,ln.rr$ iruru g nu raaful.r?fiufin.r ruf,ln.rrdfiq ? 1r r t'rt q1 uco rltc d.i6 n a t ri r a rru d a o ta qa a o cuuusdr r nefintun r rfr un ruri

rdarfirdArrrudnnfrao qr.,rilrr r 6u uncufi{ern r firtaun r e{c'ruuliao{u fi

I

{eudfiruilr'1fr9

c c d r n r tn t t c daun r r I n n Ha.c r a.o ri r n rr'Luu urdatn.o 6n "

{onfi .rrc af frri1 n 1 T1s-{

t nutauao{u

1. 1 fraqn r darfiucnlun'r{ r drrgfie-f,.snr figunfidarn?{n.l?

nrrrlanrltdtdu n r z ar4in{nina rn rrl.rISu ncf,n{rh rffc rn

nrtfrtnmrifirrafirnTr t tau ulaaruT in'tunraunfa raruriilrurlrrfrfirunisiangtr$ ra{da druatcdr drrnaaruiln isl,rTaafiarri! t.i.r. LT4 nterfau

" o ", e . . {uas, r aonnailffrarirsilzcf rnz irsdrnrrfinrr r rtiaur fiau fe alilif;n,rrdu

adrr.,ira ( sinple Randon sanpling) rtnniuilrut'rnrdatflrrriurnr.jonrzradilrurlrlfr f.,roitur lnrh,drn.ruuind uf,ruurfiuduta-r r rninrrfiuds-!,t- rl--. r.- -: --!.-.---- t.' dd ,! rr :doirJT uranrui.r rcanr:iron1nl1nndilrufiu'a{firuraur rs r uta z u{ilru d.rdurtnCl'tdilrur !'r!r'l{ iirlrcdrnrf;of,r. ze nir r iau f,unrrd

iruru zo nirtiau ua"filurrrriiariirjrctrnrf;rfiu roz nirr?au drnrrflrnmrfiiruru roa nfa r ilsurrr r iiundrrt:sdlnrfrrai, .rdri.rnrrfinrr r rliau

rfiauiruru tz + ai:,rlau uAsrrrliundrrtrsilrnufiradrrdtflrunrrFnrrurru9

iia'lunirfi irurufi .,rlu 348 nirrfau

Page 57: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

38

L. z friiardrirnrzf,r r nqdnrneir.r"t nrud'trlfiunrrdmtri

u nori.d.rdl fr c rnn r rf, r r nq r rfi r r trurilts n aufiufr aradrffr rnuuudarn rr1. g ri'ruuudaunlodtffornnrrf,uarrnl lrriT n.r?ne6faun?1u

rda.ttaaii c coeff icienb ro.,lazouurd dn"{oriio

rtndosI

or = _J_ (l-ESre)

n-l s 2E

1. 4 ie rirualud?s?1{ 1: Eoooo urfcruur, nrdfro ra.trariI

rjrrfi firunfiudruu:ri urifiruuan r roTnz,onrzr firur r1r?'rt firur sr r fiart!!

siruassri'r Eir rnaaruf,n i.,rraTeafiarrilI

2. frarya1fia4i (secondary datallffrirnrrfrunirrartru.,dr.9l$-r

fiufinrrus uasdnrsfirlil nrofiuddffotnrrilnrri{a roa'tddr rfiunrrfi,rfi

2. r dnrudrtrc r ilo.tfiu dr tiunrrCr:rrdnrufirtrl'tufio.,rd

ut r zrulat{n1r ieurifirurlrtff fiT unisiauurd uacu?,.*fiud frnyr r rJiar

t fiau rffurifirur 1M1{ ua"firur rr r tar Te arirnrrCrzrrfinrruclnr.{dirs.tt alq 4 rIA{UrU',rU tr?On21l| r rjuoqIa{T1ra?IT finr$sniilr!, r nd dnrsrJ'r1il Bac

dnrruraHtrt"ur Tnafir'trl di., fudonrrilnrr rdarirl,r'!il'tunr:ar{ugru

dr r fiun r :i f atun T..rfld rrrt

2.2 titnrtnzrq unri , ntrrri r andrrtan.d, nafifitlnrriiatt

'riufrr f;otrludr{'tulrtr ondrz unuufingrr.dur dlrT natufia.rd rduilnrflsett.

nrtfrtdutru irurun?auni? Bacara{'runrrfiour rdatfinzrufirnrrl,iir.u.u

trofro r 0flal'l?n'lrrrdnrr uarrarirasrudrt .l d, nta.ta.r r du crarnarri.rHieofiarrfi drfinrrurh'tfrfrninafiasrd drfinyrurh'tirrnunrdrrzd

n:urh'lfi nrilfi$urdiu r flufru

Page 58: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

39

qJsn112 I nl1sU!e||a

I

tauadududrfr..n4 4 { ddd.r r ilur iatfr r fiarfiudn1u r rf rEEfil

ddr ra r nur?u1?fttro{lrn1'lnn'ln6fu1lt r eief;uufre

nr rflurrnlfiu ertfiidafiuT g t i.,tvtrzrur

fi.rnl uncnrrufierfiudatnr{n1T ro{r1rA?'lurrnTnz.rnrricradfiT urlrffr

firunfsiluurol uny?1no?uofl t nqTnztnrzr'tduri rrrgrilru, 0"1... ouo

r T rgrfi ru r ! 1 r fi a ? Crufr aua r ?.,rrj?l rrudtfi ..nn. rf,untr$fi eufi rn ir r iaurcra '4!{g"r,-u'1il'lu ? ?tuan rilann r {ur{\r un ?1 {n1n'r ra t :fidtala'lun :ca1rdrniua.,r zfir(code sheetl CIrrudfrsn1?a{?fid (code rnstruction) dei.ofru rdaqcqlet{"-t|udr-oi t n:1srfinrs t niosnar-r r o0i frrfialafiai'lurcdilnrt5euuuneiu ( Noninal

Scale I unntaradoitutofiunrtTeuuudr.r ( Interval Scale I ui'lrir s fiu

nrei satrylfrtaLuaTeattifnrrnr{dfifi < statistical analysis) laanrrducnur{nrrrd (frequency distribution) ir{aaar (pereentr ir

{t{rl0618 (nean) e1rila{[iluu1nT'151u (st,andard deviation) uacurfir

n I lruond 1 { fl o {n' 1 r odauda"f, rurlrfr r aiin r rn,,,refi fi uuu t -test r danedau

drulfi grurare r rrf,rfiuf, ra.rfi rurlr i r n rrrrirar :iluuun r rlf,ufiud rsudr {frr

urI:6dzuuaraf,r fiufiruil:nrur,td.rdr lea'tilnrri rnrr"rfi fl1ronn0a$uuuug

frunau (Hultiple Regression Analysis) leadruueffiifisC'tdcunr.rdifi

dzuf,u o. 0F rf,unf,ntunr:nadaudlrfilru

'tunrri r nrr"rif,ala rirtaralrrirnrri r nrrrrile attnT zilrsr1at

atafi ra * u*ro. rotr r na{ tealflrrjrunrrdr r fent spss/pc+ ( stat, ist icatPackage for the social sciencesl rirrlnrrirnrrrridrfitT oiulruatealtifinT :irnrr"rif,oualt.rurrm Tegr6anrffnfifilunrri,arrudfrara

t-ge{u

efi fi dr ilaiu1 adnr$sdrr rll a .ln dgf, e e i r rdflnr. fr aranr tdru1.

r c:rgfie-fr.rnrtt

uariloun r rligur ilaudnrun'l{fr1ur ezrgfie-f .rnl ro\in6irtl

rlzcdrnrda'rflaaitu r roTn?{nrttnndfi rurh'tfr ualrndililzrdrntdarf,aa{

Page 59: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

40

uafl r EqTar.rn.rt dorrirt r rqrlT r drn'rrruin# rafituurfrudura.,r r uninrrfiud

fin{rJT firanrut.,r Ifio; driaaar, o"tr"it ) n1?uenu.or..ud t r"rqu"o"J

distribution) i.,ad, (neanl unoir,dootilur16T'151u (standard

deviat ion )

z. afifidrffi, "rrrri"rrgf,rfiud

rdone daudrrfigru 'afruri ireu.o.r.d6aanc ( percent ) ttaun,ltnodoufiadrfirU !a{n'l,trunnsi't.,ttst4'ir.teir t oda

usincfiruilzTna'tfl t-test raia (t) uaonrrirnrrrr{ n,troenaanrouuff*

q0u (MuItipIe Regression Analysis) losttild{ Stepwise

Page 60: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

dn

q lufl'1T? t ATlvunAiln

!u

UN

qd3dafl1T',l1A

- q 4uufls I StuoatanlT? t nu 1uilraila

lI'dtairLnrrifra

*Ho#ur r duaaranrri r o"."11ffauarrn, f,r. z nau 6acl

{ q 4u { 'oaufi 1 fl'lr- r arrclafailn r narnufrnurucfir'lil flo{?1r4?lur nor

- rV | --uv o 4 t ry-tFtr{fl1Turuu'trrtlrlfiilruniuaAruutrt $asuriil'luuonTer{nrrr,rilfirurlr'lfr firuggtuf!

rfl1D?1{ firurnrrifar oirua:srit aitrnaaruf,n fr.rraToafisnrfiI

{ - A 4e .lorarrfr 2 n1?i r ertryfifiarun rfisafiudarurrfsugfiqna\irlrqtlur nsl

le z s n r zuil ilT urj r'lfi fi runff* druu rol u aoud fi ruuo fl Ta r { n r trari fi 'rurjrt ff fi ru9 1il !M

t fl10'l'l\t firur nr r fiar oiruatsdr nir tnanrufrn fi.ruToafiasril $nsilo6fauI

n arruunnoi r t t"u'ir sri'.r r *ds rratffrnBila \inraua 6rsiail nrrfi anzaof,Aufu9

ado nrtfianta{dduruilqcfiu unsnarrfiron.rd6r.rirfiu ToadrnrznoftailI.d{r.du

r rJf au t fr auzsu'i 1.!ndil r1r4:fi a rfra odtu t rnTo ztn r :{oudilrurlr'1fr frtneiru{qrt'ruqrfr a rfr e aduon r aCITn r rn r sfiaraililrurJr'tfr

9g

{00un 3 n r ri, u t I orir'', ? ilu uil r a { a I'l il fr ilfiud z ru'i r .r fr r u il za' d rsun I aff r fiuzralfr4nfr n a.sn ?r r toutd ail il a {?1rarlu r snTn:.rn rtadfirurl.rrfr9-11vultfrrunfuaailurti unruilfiruuan1nrtnrrrailfirurl'rrff firur f,1fl?'l{ firur nr$tu

tise siruntcril eirrnanruf,n i,rraToafianfiI

{ - a lu { vqaufr 4 nlTi r nsrsrufarun t ilarfirdnrunrtfi{nil!a{?'lr6z'lur nn

To z t n r uuil fi rurl rrfffi run fivrdcil il?01 u asurifi ruilonta ? {n r ruriff rurJT tfi fi ru1!!9!

r n1n?1{ fi'ru r f,1 [ !'a? siruarsil'l dt r noaruf,n i.rra{oafias,ril9

Page 61: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

42

ooud s n'rzi r nzrrdurziluurnotnrrrufiufiudtrra'ir.rffruilta'drs

un r afr r fiunrrrunrouTslunr:finrra a {un I na rrrrqrlu r rn1ntsn'r traqifiruft

I 'v ! u t 4 'v '"'urlrrfi firurnln?'l{ ilrulJ1-til U1ilnlusdilUT6U [tneuilil1U1,[0ltTn?{fl 'l114tJU1r

dr a1r ss? orruarcdl nir r naaruf,n {ruToafianrfi

I

,rrrd o nrci,.r.rd r rltsu r fisu dnru r epSis-fitcrru luadn fililq cfiu a 0 { I rr6z1u r sqln I {fl 'l rrarifi rurlr'lfr fi run?ndauutt$ uarurifi ruuan

Tnrrnr:railfirurl'r'tff firur r,tnyl\r il'rur n'r r if sr siruntsdr dr tnoaruf,n!!

4a

1{fi?OOn8fl'lUI

d - lv {naufi z nrri r o:rrfiilailn r frsrfrufietunfi ra{r1ra?tur rqTnz.r

n r rrarifi rurl r't fr fi run iudaruu rr$ unorarifi ruuo nTn r { n r nrdfl rurl'r1fr ilru r n'rld$t9u <'

I naarufin fisraToafissril sianr:ouinffl?1{ lJ1uIn1trg? gt"lila?sil'l fl1[naa1u6[n q$u'l( q e

frsr{rlr nrtouffnfrlr'tff nrzilanilrdrudu rracnrrioTnr.rnrzraililrurlT'1fr

1unrti r o:r"riilaruauavuilan?1il1rru1salanrri r orT rrifratn 'tunrttug

Au C C d ,!?qser\iu rua'lurfiorerrl r fi"rtsnc{frutunrruilnnr'1ilr4118 ffiiatffriruuo!I

firufi nrrirun r ri r n r'rrrifr arua6.rflI

unu

t[Ru'

$nu

un%

Inu

unu

,dqo1[ on8 [ aEnaun

rd6[?U r ilB { r lJUil 10 T5'lU

"iruruSignif icance

Non Significance

MS

ei T tq rrdruinqndrtlun 1 rfi q r rirr

tunrrurnuctir rUnU Mean Square

f,rufinrnldtfftun r ri r e r r rri ff arn

x

S. D.

N

s

ns

T

Page 62: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

43

xxxxx

x1

xe

x3

x4

x5

x6

x7

xe

$nu rufiilfidun&rddair.,ri.,r Hrrafr.{'tfrnsuuu

ernnlrTofiaunfi G-10 e"duu

Bnu zsfiufidunfirilo' ururafr{ rflnsuuur'rnfl'l?

Toficuefi 11-ls nsuuu

unu rsrfiufidunfiilrunar'r rarurafrs Ifrns[uuqrn

n'rrTofraunfi L6-zo nuuurl

unu rsdufidunfid railrsfi.,r lfinduuuqrnnrr5a

ficunq' zt.zs ac$uu

$nu rufiufidunfidrrn nrurafi.s'0ffnsuuur1nn1x

iofiaunfi 26-30 auuuu

unu rud

unu a1g

unu ofrdur

unu nrrfinrr

rnu n r rudrru rrntun rr nirurafi.,rila

unu afnrunru

$nu tiruruuntI

$nu drurun:auairdarf,aailudqqfiu!!o

xo Bnu druaudurindarHaai'tuilr{fru

x,o unu aieir rur r fin

x,, unu n'rrff'rudu

x, " u?ru rvav t ?n1[fl{flrtaqiarf;aI

x.. unu ,*q"udrffrl,rnqio'rf,at!I

X,o Bilil vui'nrrrda tnrz6T adu'tuaurnd

xr., unil nr:fionsaodAt,

x,. unu nrrzuffatn.rdAr.ri.fit,

x,., unu nrrufiotn.ro."dBurirfiu

Page 63: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

44

x,, unu arturafin

X. " unu arilutnlt

xro slnu frnrruonrrlffurr.rruluntofinir

x* unu eirlffiralun'lrl.,fion'l{n1T I nror.aq

x uo $ylu n'11?111u18ataruan

.;ztrr{-xu, unu a.|uuculqln [?1r4u1nT5

x"o unu fl1?aail r iud r nfiaqrnnlrtfr{ls

Xr. unlr fl'l? t tT drilfisntrillrrfi\inil

x.. unu fllrilTnrlflrUrard rie fru

x,, $nu fl1r r 6uilratuzauilduffr

X,, trntr dnrfiaurfrs

x,,, u?ru nltinr,t$s1il1a r lia r 6urlr!

x"o ulru Trs r iau

x", unrr dnruilnrrra{iln7

X." unu e?1ile'loui.r'tunrrfinr1ilopilnr

x". unu uudsfiT 4rlTnn l?Tnn ruflflfiux"o unu ilruu.fi.drflortrnn utTnn ltuilqrfiu

x", unrr nrrfiffrru'tt

X.. Bnu trfiana.rfirru

x." $Ytu n1?iiIdfl1'tff

x.. unu r o*attff uardsEi'ru?anxlhdco?n

X", u?ru n1? rfiunrraanuanudfrru

xoo unu enruddfinccrfiun'tslil

x,,. unu urrut odti'runrzrfiunrs

x ou unu finrrusnuudf fft fiunr.r

Page 64: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

45

xo" un% r ta rufi.rdtflrunrtrlsffn

xoo ttntr ur,tai.r, to rnfio

xo, Bntr rJirurru t fla r ufr'r

Xo, unu uuei.r rir rd'r tXn, unu rratfiAnBza{e?auairoiail

xo. unu dnruna{T?\irisurrliautfiauadq filiIa1fiu

Xo. unu dnrura{dn'l%;flr1$B1u'la

X=o unu dnrut#unT {ail%1n&l

X=1 ttnll dnrusa{Tq

xu. un% dnruro{uu6i.tfi'lfit,

x-. unu dnruro.rur,rri..rfirtff

xro unu dnrurarnr:'t$flT turadfrru

x=, unu rra.tfrsa{arailaffr r rliaur fiauadn filflsrfiu

x-. Inu t.rnatfion't{n1? [ fltr67

x-" untr nrrufro{fl1?tun'l:ficruT fia.rfiu

x,. unu ficunfinasnpo?danrrauindfioitJ'l

x* unu fieunfiso.,rrluAxsi0nlxou;ndrlrf ff

x.o untr ficuofisa.,rrrrgrdanrzrJanrlrdldu

x., unrr figunfira.r?1ra?dalnr{fl1rfou{ffrurl'r'tfr

Page 65: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

46

{{trl{outj-'caufr 1 n,rrirnrllrritalarfiazfruinrssrCruilnna ialafrttrl

.l { ls,t { |

B111{fr 1 nlri t er1cfifforua t ilaafrr finrrucfir'tiJ sa{ilfirrd1nrnritfr:lair.r.9 I --U L, s t I

radfrrurj, lfr firunTuifuurri uas rarifiruuanTn?{nrnadfirurl,rffr0glu9

ilru r nr r if ar firu r n1!r1{ rf ruanruf,n {.ruiaafiasrfiq

finrrusdrlrJ

r.rrifirurlrrff

t ffruniudrruuzrfil

uri fi ruua nTn r t nr zudfi rurj rr fr!rIud',

( u'lu [ !1 t Da?, u'lu [ !1!?1{ )

,pN TagncIN ?AEAg

u.O

1'lu?un{14ilo

r uef

il'td

lfau't

a'lg

2a-2s il

30-3e il

40-4s il

50-5e il

eo itfurrl

drdua

1|nfrI

t74 100. oo

L52

22

87 .40

12.60

45

56

30

29

L4

25.90

32.20

!7.20

16.70

8. 00

L74 100. 00

114 100. oo

L64

10

94.30

5. 70

7t

35

34

19

15

40. 80

20.10

19.60

10. 90

8. 60

t74 100. oo

* rwc ara rfiurasfirnfirnzaunfefrtfif,lnt$lrt

Page 66: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

47

n'lyl.od r tsial

frnrilsfir'1il

r,rdilrurlrrfr

t firuniwderurnlr

rarifi ruuanTn rr t n r tu{fi rurlrrff

t firu r nr t ilgr, firur 11tr?1\t )

IN ?AaAs Nut88As

nrsfinrT

rdrfrr iau

ilrvnrfinrr

frssilfrnrr

orfrflnrraorufrnrr

n'rzEirurafisfa

nirurilaan

druaan r iiaurdrfr

druaan r l'auIfi

dnrunrsafuti{

TdnI l'/e

un{{1uaga?anutaolun{{1iluaflnuoa

IaL,

ua1?1{

37

116

13

3

5

21.30

66. 70

7.50

L.70

2. 80

39

4

131

22.40

2. 30

75. 30

T4

154

6

8. 00

88. 60

3. 40

75

97

2

43. 10

55.70

L.20

79

L4

E1

46. 40

8-00

46. 60

2

125

4g

4

r.20

71.80

24.70

2. 30

*nr:finrr nrrudrurrn'tunrrdT urafirta r flurarfienfirntauniefr'tfif,unrrd

Page 67: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

48

dln1?1{n 1 (Oe)

finprusfir'til

rarifirurlrlil

t ilruniuitrrlzr$t

udfiT uuanTnz rn r trrdilrurlrrfrttI 4al a,

( ulut tr1 t tra?, ulut !19?1{ )

uN ?aans

tiruruuCIr

1nu

2au3au

4RU

5au

.-dq1u'luRtaunS?n

81assdlufi1u

-g-

1 elauni?

2 nrouni,l

iruaudtrilnlua4

,L?? t tou

1-3 nU

4-6 nu

7-9 nu

3. 40

6. 30

42.40

39. 70

8. 60

81. 00

19. 00

1,2. tO

52.80

35. 10

89.70

10.30

46.00

46. O0

8. 00

Page 68: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

49

q.,rf id r teial

finrrucfir'trl

rarifirurJr'til

r firunfniauurdr

uri fi ruuan1n z t n r trarifi rurl rr fr

t ilrur rr t iar, firut 11r?'l\t )

vN TAgAsIN TAAAg

q.S

RilA1[U1[Otlq^.s{

r iletuudfrrufrarf,a|!

oituilrcfiutl

r fiolusiruntrrdrv.d8'l8il1rt'lfln 1ilnau

nardr rnaarufrne{a'1ail1rt1fl01 [ n0au

sasi..rrrTeafiasrfitvs-{8',lar111nrt{fl?e au

nrrfrra'trlrridd"qr{

Inun?1 3 toau

'trir naffT a

u"-a'lg 1 n1\iDgE'lE 2 n?{sva1a 3 n?{ur!A1Ail1nnl1 3 O?.1

27 15.50

2l

28

12.

16.

10

10

16 9.20

82 47.LO

48

30

TO

24

2

27.60

L7.20

40. 30

13.80

1. 10

20

28

11. 50

16. 10

2. 90

L2t 69. 50

106

33

20

15

60. 90

19.00

11.50

8.60

Page 69: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

{.n'l?1{?t 1 (0a) 50

frnnruvfirlil

udfirurh'tS

< fiT uninirrurnlr

uri fi ruuo nrn r.rn r rudfi rurl rrfrtt9el',

( u.lut n1t na?, il1ut [1['11{ )

uN TAAAB

vN TAgAs

r raT darf,aori'Lu

nXil'ruflqefiu i

1-B il I

4-6il |

r-s il I

ff.r,rd 10 ilfurrr I

t ranarad r firrrariru I

IXfiTuilqrfiu -l

nrruoistru I

I

ilrgurernfiasrrldrEq dq .a - |uruu,lneun,lflur cr|

|

flruurffruilcfan'l.r I

r drugfirtr.dri, A, I

-dg{slru,lnuua{, Iuou {n I

drurraifirg I

n'rzfisurrnz.reir.r I{- - 'u ITU51U!fl{r{t|il',lU

r 6rrri6uo I

rrifidfiurhfiuunri I

'jrnr.rrrilnrrrY{a I

rrrddu'tfilurrluri Iilrurlrril |

109

a

I2

48

62.60

2.90

6. 90

27.60

3

I

36

7

1. ?0

5. 20

20.70

4. OO

19 11.OO

3 1.70

9T 55. 70

t32

2L

2t

75. 80

LZ,. tO

Lz.tO

13

18

40

35

7. 50

10. 30

23. 00

20. 10

66 38.00

2 1. 10

Page 70: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

51

{.01T'l{n 1 (na)

finrilcfir'1il

radfirurlr'tfr

t fiT uniui*rulrnll

uriil'ruuanla u rn r ruliilT urJrr ilI!t

9d'r'( u'lu[ [1[ [a't, u1u[ [1[2'l{)

IN TaaasUN loaau

uy{R?1iln0{n1?a1ant{

156

t2

L

89. 60

6.80

0.60

60

r.20

60

o.60

87

79

2

50. o0

45. 40

L.20

1. 70

L.70

'luaurno

- ,u u 41il04 {n1?D1gnu

rriurirquud{na{n1?81anu I uo{

rrlnnlTuei{{'luul,{dCIA{fl1tE1AflU t UA\t

dqddo'i'lnruUIUU1[ ?A\ineil

rirfiuu.td{CIa{n1?8'lSnutua{

{q It q ol1nIU5ln{1e 1uil11A

.qn1{ [ HTr5nrlr,u{{na{n1Ta1aflutua{

q{srl'1nfl10, tTou tflrrurrlaiddu

I.)tt{4na{n'lT8'lanulua\t

rrlnnl?fisu1TnT\i.s{.

6[?'l \igilt 1Utr A \iHll

firurrifisa uia Idd

I lf a{uo

Page 71: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

52

.l - { itrt { u s .tslnn'l?'l{fr 1 ude {GlanlT- [ nT.lcuiara r ilE?iludnrilsrfrr'lij ra{, d. a ^i2 . a r . { q I

ilrsrtr 1fl ?nnilnn1fl 1 Tfrnrr loalf;nauqr a a 1 { r1fl rJrcdln ziia'rf,aari'lulo ts9tl

nr:r,rdilrurl, f fr firunfuirililrnl sirunrcilr air rnaaruf,n i.ruicafiarril1|!l9

viruru L74 n?auni?11nilrudlnzfrsure 1Bg n?aunfi? tfiarfiuiaaa"

es. 08 ) uaEil:rrlrntda'rflaoiuonTnr.,rnrnadilT urjr'tfi iirrf r flundrtfirarir.,rttl

{9 .d .a . .a, rl at d6nn1[llTsulnau 11u?u 2 Hilil1u na il?stt'lnT11flu1uln'lr!8? sirilaturirt

atrirrnanruf,n i.rnToafiasrfi iruru toa n:otnir i1nil?lrt''lntft.,ruta torI

uqeuntaueie < n-s t iluf aaac gr .20) uayilrsiltnrrrnfilur tr1!'r1,,r rf ruanruilnuoo{.ui{raTeafrssrfi iruau zo nraunfr crnilzcdanrfirute T6 nraunil tfio

9

r fuiaant sz. lL, trlriluil:strn:ndrffrair.,rdrt'runrrilnrri{atun?.rfiriruru gaa nraletr

dclt n asc r til1$ anq lilfrnrilcfi r'tiln s siltcdrn rfi r ai r t uu'irCeuiurt

fi erafirn tailn;? r f,u r nddr a nrirrn'a lu r ratnr.rn, mrifi rurJrlil r flu r scdra

fruau tsz nu riaans Bz.40l ,fiu,udufrriruru zz nu(iaaac 12.60)

u a ondfi ruua nTn r.rn r trariil,rurl rtfr rfiutscira iruru 164 nu tiaaac

94.301 ,iiurndr,rfr.r iruru 10 nu riaaac s.?0)

turrnTnr{n1z"r dru'trlri frara ariludrs g0-g9 il tiruru se

nu fiarfiuioaao sz.zol rasarurfia dr.r zo-zs il riruru as nufiorfiu

faaasr zs.gol dr.,r 40-49 il riruau go nu ficriiuiaano tr.zol dr.r

Eo-Ee il <iruru zg nufie riiuisaa" 16.?0l uasdr{ 60 il lsuril<iruru14 nu fieriiuiaaae B.o0) nurirdu lcaiiara,*drrri.rfiu s9.84 it Cru

uaflrrn1nrrnrrr druturtiiara ai'tudrt zo.zs il rfruru zr nu finrfiuiaaar 4o.Bo) ro\ia{il1 6a dr.,r go-g9 il tfruru gs nu fiorf,uiaaao

z0.10l de.l 40-49 il riruru 84 nufieriluiaaau 19.601 dr.r Eo-sg iltiruru 19 nu ficrfiuiaaa" 1o.9ol ua"drr 60 il ffurrr riruru 1E nu

6arfiuioaar B.60l nrudrfiuTe aiiarar"drrrirfiu sr.L4 il 'lut lnTnr.l{stuilSunun1?a $nsuafl r lnTnr.snrtr iaanr 1oo. oo fiufiaeT au1flntr

Page 72: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

53

lur naln:{n1ra Cru'turt 'tfrilnT rfinrr 'tursduilrcnu;lnyl

<.iruru L16 au fiorfuiaaar 66.2o) ?a{a{r1 n'o rdrfriun,rzflnrr

<,iruru gr nufierfu?aaar 21.30I rfiilnrrfinrrrvdrfrsauilnrl (f1u?u

1s nu6orfiuiaaao z.so) rffiunrrflnrrrsf,uoaufinrr <fruru s nu fie

rfiuiaaao z.B0l uaurfrtrnrrfinrrrcdualirfinrr tiruru g nu fierf,u

iaaao L.Tol qurirfiu druuan r snTnr.snrrc Cruturtrfrfunrzfinrrrsfiu

ilrcnufinrr <druru gz nufierfiuiaan" ss.z0) ra{a\ru1 6a fdffriiln1rflnrr r'iruru zs nu derfiuiaaao 4g.10) uac'lfriunrrfinrrrlrdufrrau

finrr <.iruru z nu fiorfiuiaaar L.zol qruairfiu

?ut nqTnt{n1t"r dru'tHrti d'ruT rndruuaur ilaurafi.,rilatff <iruru

131 eu fierfiufiosno zE.so) ?a{a{il1 'tridurrnsiru ua"rfrguufi{;lotfr

triruau Be eu6o rfiuiasno zz. ro) d1il'r?nrirurafi'rilarffudrd*.rr1?srrfisu

rafi.rilofff tfruru c nu 6orfiu?ogao z.gol nrtrirfiu druuanrrnTn?{

n'r?"r drutraqi drrrrnairurasrfiauufistatfr riruru st nu fieriiuiaaat

46.60 ) ?a{a{ilr lridrrurtndruuar r a'aurlfi.rilaf fr t iruau ?g nu f,n r iiu

iaans 4s. 40) 6hil1?nrirurafi.,rtarfrudrri*rulrnrtauufi.rtatff riruru L4

nu 6a r fiuiaaa" B. oo I nrrrrirfiu

'lut rn1n:{n1?"t Cru'tufti u 0.! { 1uu as a ae e afrufitnr:a tuioerfit{ro{a\ru1 d'a dnruntn1da tirurut iru'ru Ls4 nufio r iiuiaaar 88.60 )

14 nu fiorfiuiaaao B.ool raiT tT.r riruau e nu fie riluiaan" s.4o)q'rrudrfiu CruuantnqTnttnrrr dru'tHriud{{'luunsaifirafiufirnrrarHiat.d-4tl.rrro6t'1il (l'lu?u 124 nunc[ilu?aaas 71.80) :n{a\ilt Ca usi.r.cruuduanfru

a{finnr:arraiarril riruru ag nu ficrfluieaao 24.?ol ui.rirs ti.ruru4 nu fio r iiuiaaa" z. so ) ua&dnruntsTdn (iruru 2 nu ficrfluiaano

t.zot qT urirffu

Page 73: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

54

42.oo) ?0{n'rrriiuqr 4 nu tiruru eg nufiorfluiaaar 39.?0)

5 eu tirueu ls nu fierfiuiaaau 8.Gol iunz 2 nu tfruru 11 nu 6o4rr{.q4uliluTa8au 6.30) uac&uo1 1 nu (l1u?u 6 nuaetiluTaaas 3.40) n,lsl

.u{adteirf,l unsr'uo?[ods g.44 nusianzalntr druuonTnr{n1?.i deu'luqi fiuasd1nu tiruru og nu fiorfiuHaano g6.20) xa\ia{r1 luor g nu tiruru

I

fiqrfiuiaaar zs.4ol iun: z au tiruru so nu 6erfluioaa"{.q4uuac iiuoz 4 nu tdruru 10 nu dariluiogac E.?o) .on1ila10u

dd,to.ouasilu0?[oas0oaTauer?tn1nu 2.05 0uI

tutnr.snrrr Cruluri fiilnt B eu tiruru zs nu 6otfiuieaat

d

{.TUNT

I

51 au

28.70)

tuTnttnrtr dru'Luqi finraunirfiorf,anrirrsfiu'tufiru iruru Lt

ntouair t f ruru L4L nufio r fiuiaaao 81. 0o ) ?a.Ea{il'r iinraunirdo.rf,a

arizrlfiu?ufiru ,iruau z nrarnir <iruru gg nu fiarfluioanc 19.00)

uarfinrauniedarfiaairrrufiutuilru, *d, 1. le n:arnir druuon1n?\rn,l?.1

deutrari finzaunirdriArr;rrlfiu'tufi.ruiruru r nrounix(i1u?u 186 Ru

ficriiuiaaau Be.zo) {-{qrs?a{a{r1 iinrounirfisrflaairelfiu'tufiru iruru z

nrounfr tfruru 18 nu 6erfiutaaa" 10.sol unuiinraunirdardasi:elt

e{.eilutoa-a rrirfru 1.10 nraunir

lu1n:tntn dru'turtfialrintunirr{auirutu 4-6 nu tirurugz nufierf,uiaanc sz.80) ?a{a{rr il*rrin'lunfrriau z-g nu riruruGl nu finrfiuiaaar ss.10) uflc 1-s nu r{ruru zr nu fie riluiaaa't2. rol qudrdl uaoifdlr?ntunirriaurodarrirfiu s. 44 nudruusnTnrs

n1?"r fialrintunirriou{T uru 1-g niluas 4-6 nu'luirururrirfru<ituru

.a

Bo eu fierfiuiaaao 46) drnfiafi*ur?ntuniariauiruru ?-e nu tirurut4 nu fie r fiufaaan 8 ) uasiltrr1in'lunir r laur

"dn rirfru 4. 06 nu

'lutnztnrrr Ceu'trart finirirrurrfiu 6a trarrrrnirHiadutiruru az nu fie rfiuiaaa" 4T.ro) Teaarcasillq,tn drrnsfiunr {..ltaie

f,aurn dr r Roatcarr i.suicunze rrzd

air rnaflaylc,ta itvrTaanui dr rna r nudheI

reddr r nailruuri nir r noTnnda1r..r

drtnauuasfirtsrut f.ruic

Page 74: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

55

crq{u.{ilanr to{a{il1 na a'tgsrl?1flo1ilaauca{a1[naa1uf,n tiruru za nu fieg

4ttt iluiaaav 1c. 1o I lfrurieiruaaruf,n tdruarlrta tn"ruarJrsdfiu dr r noaruf,n

Iy---? u { q d t ! q

- .1, { q !{ tt s e ( .c{u?oanafl1u 6t?un t ua0aa I no'aur4ilu'runol9ls0aCatrrunifladru?ru t iruruIt!!t

27 nufietfiu{aaas 1s.Eol rfie'Ludruarsdr tiruru zt nu fierfiu{aano

12. 1o I uarfrrarrcrnril rordu ro.r{ruioafiarrfi r f ruru 16 nu 6n r fiuI

Yosa" g.zo I rfruri drrnafirufiu airrnauua{o'l{ nirrnaraua{['lr4si1{

i.rraTeqfiarrfi qrld'rffu dsfifinrru"rduro'srfi'u uanTnrrnrrr fia drulrart

fiafidrrurrfildafrraurcrni.rraTqdu riruru lzL nu fiorflufoaa, 6e.so)lll

ra.ln'qlrfra firatrrrndrladusa{tirrnanrufrn tiruru za nufieriiuiaan"

16. 10 I r fialudrunrsdr r i.ruru zo nufie r iiufiaaao 11.801 uncffraur

11n01 r RAAUflA{?$r4?OAngfr1U ( q1U?U 5 nUeiO t tlUiaans 2. g0 I nruaitduI

tutnrrnrr"r dru'tHlti u'nrrff.ra'trrariddurfiun,j,r g rdau iruruz .*o t,iruru zo nu fiorfiuioaar 40. go) ?a.ra\rtrdsrdrnadrariloid

tduriun'ir s tcoau<iruru 48 nu6e rfiuiaaar zr.60l fira'trlariddutruru

Ur nF.,r tdrueu go nu fiorf,uiaaar LT.zo l Hra'trjaidr"" iruru g "?oI

<irueu e+ nufietiiu{sans ls.Botunufrlarlaidduu.nn'ir s .{oriruruz nufie rf,uf;aann 1.10r nrldrf,u Bns,*dafinrrfrrauadddurfiu g rfiau

rrirfiu z.aa "*o Cruuan'tnr{n1r"r deu'tuniccin.rfi.rirlaiddu ururfiut

n'j'r g rdauirueu r .{o tirueu 106 nufiarfiuiaaao 60.90) ?a{a{r1daffra'trla{dd" iruru e "fo tiruru gs nu fie riluiaanu le) fira'trlari

ddui'ruru t u*o tiruru zo nu 6e rfluiaaar 11.s0) uas irarrlaiddurrnn'ir s "*o rfruru 1E nu finrflu{ean" a.6ol nurirf,u uasrsdai

n'rrfrrarilr{ddurfiundr g rfisu rrirfiu 2.68 .*otuinztnrtr druluqi iiruao r ?n1ra{nrzaiorHa'tuudfi'ruilrcfiu

1-s il <iruru rog nun'e rilufaan" 62.60l za,ontlrfia ff.rud 10 ilfurrrtiruru +e nu fie riluioaa" zr.60) ?-e it rfruru Lz nu finrfiuiaaat

G.90) un!, 4-6 il <iruru s nufiarfiuiaaao z.eo l qrudrdrd.riifinru"

Page 75: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

56

t du r e'a rfiu uonTnrtnrzr 6a daurrariilz vdv r?a'lra{n'tzaiarf,atur,rdilru

ilqcfiu 1-3 iltiruru tsz nufie rfiufaan, ?s.80) ra\ia{rrfiafrtnaor?41

4-6 if uno T-s it tu,irurudrri, fiu <.iruru zL nu 6orfu{aaa" Lz.Lo,

turnt.snr:r Cruturi i,rraludr ffu'raqi'tuu{firuilrlfiu c'a rdiie9tl

do o q e.iloun1flu uasrr?1n1{nrrrcierzrddurfilurrjredilrurlr'|fr tiruru gz nufie

rfiu?aaar ss.?o)

6erfiuiasar zo.To,

!lt{<tqd-.{-[ilnHa?0{a{u'r n0 rilruil1neun1nulet| (11u?u 36 nu

9

rdrr{q-tv.sfU,lOsUA\i twAu ilnd?ur|'laae?a (1'lUzU 19 nU not

rfiuioaar 11.001 ilruurrrnfiarrrudrfi tiruru g nufierfiuioaas s,z0)

ilsurarfi'ruilqfsn'r.r r crutfiqtudarirdr t iruru z nufia r fiuiaaas 4,

fisurTnrrrir.rfiug'rura.oudfirurfiutriduo ( flu?u s nufia r fuiaans 1. ?o)

uacnrrud{\ilutiruru g nu fierfiutaaar 1.zol orldrdu druuonTers

fl1r"r dtu'tuqi fi r**r^dr firurai'tur,rriilruilqriluda ru.fi dfia.r rdru ilndruro-q4ru{qdq.sq

il1Eg (1',1%2u 66 eune[ilUToAnc 38) tfiqafara{n{il1nailqru1noun1nuler99

tfruru ao nu fiorfiufoaao 23) ilrurarfiruilqianrt r d:rgfie rudad r o'u

<iruru gs nufierfiuiaaau zo.10l ilruurqrnfiasrrrdrfitiruru 18 nufin

r fiuiaaau 10. Bo I nrrusi.r{1u( iruru 13 nufre r fluieaar ?. so ) $acn1?

fi$urTnz.,reirsffutru nauarifiaurfiltridna tiruzu z nu fierfiuiaaao

1. 1o I oT rrirdu

'luTarsnrrr Cruturu rdfra,,rnrzdcrfirafiu tiruru 1sG nu fia

rfiuiaaa, 89.G0) ra{a{ilrn'arriuritc tiruru Lz nuie rfiuiaaau 6.Bo)

fra.,rnrzfrT afiu rda.reT nfiflruur frruilqianr.0rrfrrgfic tiruru z eu ficrf,u

f,osa" L.zol nrruairfiu iisilfinrru"nfrranfr.rfiuuonrnr\tn1?.,r 6adau'turtrri

ffasnrzffrafiu tiruru ez nufierflutoaa" E0) zatnrrrifotriuri'trriruru7 s nufie r fiuiaann 4s . 4ol fra.,rnT rfi.r, dror.nfiflruu'rfrT uilqianr.s r dmlfi e

tiruru g nu fie rfiuiaaa" t.Tol fra.rnr ziltards.rqrnrurfi ,dut ilndru

rrrariddu tfruru 3 Ru ficrfluiaaao L.rol uarfrasnrrira,dro".nn.,

fl'll

,.s4uusi.lrru tiruru z nu ?ie rilufaaac L.zol nui'rfiu

Page 76: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

57

{naun 2 - Jtt { o -fl 1Ta l n11sil!eua I nt2nu{n1lnrl I f,Tl}tnl

I

d q lu d a q .n1?1{n 2 n11? r n?1sr{!ara r na?fiu rtnrunr.o r dur!ilr [a{il1cd1n1n6iil

t -- I

fi e a i r srari fi rurl'rr ilfi runtuidu u rni u a cud fi T uuo ntn ? { n 1 ruri il1uglltt

rlr'tfr il'rurr.triisx ilrur!1tr?'l.r tdruaaruf,n {sraToafiasrilq

dnrnnr.s r c:r3fir

radff'rurh1fr

< il'runfni*lu:nll

udilruuonrn zsn rtradfi T url, rilt||

!d9( u1u[ ['l I ra,t, u'|ur [1!x'l{ )

uN xeansIN loaau

u.01'lu?un{uile

-- u{qanrilufl1T'tonouil1

t74 10O; 0O

2

I15

149

L.20

4. 60

8.60

85.60

55

119

31.60

68.40

23

151

t9.20

86.80

174 100. 00

104

18

52

59.80

10. 30

29. 90

2L

153

L2. LO

87. 90

25

L49

14.40

85. 60

6uca.t

'tfriurtqncnnae

fttfriuier:r

nrrrfra rn.tdfiutt,

&r&rfiatsaufrr

ir'td rfiarua

Un?1ro0{n1?[14

!'lg

lrirT a

Page 77: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

58d.011'l{n 2 (oa)

dnrwnr',r r dzr5fiq

radilrurh'til

< firunfir6ruurnlrt

radfi ruuo nrn r.q n r rudfi rurlrrfiIt

at{rt(u'lu[ !'lI IE?,tl'm[ ['lI21f)

UN taaas,uN faaaB

ariuufin'tuilcefiu

r nro1n1?r. -q tt

ilfr5lCI?I

In1r1gav?il11{

-l,o91fl16t?Un?9

o rilwr a.,rtuilqcfiu

t nrn?n1?il

ilcfln{

tltcr.r

flir.rtdfiortnzas

finrorcnrrltuzr.rrr

140

13

6

L4

1

80. 50

7.50

3. 40

8.00

0.60

LL

49

8

106

6. 30

28.20

4.60

60. 90

101 58. 00

7

66

4.10

37. 90

148

I4

I4

85. 10

4.60

2. 30

8. 00

TT

42

101

20

6. 30

24.20

58. O0

11. 50

143 82.20

5

28

2. 90

14.90

ltut't't'tu'tuntauD

nirficula,t rr{11{HEUn,lCInAe

!|

'lffut.,rtru'tunrauorlrl4U

n??UA!,1'l\t0,1AUUT {t

Page 78: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

59dln1T1{n Z (OA)

dnrnnrr r czrgfie

radfirurjrrfr

r firuniuialrrr$r

uriilruua nTn r.$ n'r ?udfi rurlrr frIt

ud!( u'lu [ !'l t Ia ?, u1u I r1!,11\t )

N {aaa" UN ?aaas

drrf;iT alunrrwfiq

r tududur.r{ { un8il t uauil1uIu< qdsnailfu1oflua{!Iunl1n rnd.||u . e rvfl?|1nfunT$uuu'lu!ltu19n11n$anlnuna'l{I

.lqn'r?1'luulaHnHnn

dr'trjrra'tur ilar r a

<tr e o { o dl|saRlr'l?utan{n

ri, IrlCtrisffrtur ia

r irufirdur'lfinrr.{o

tlusu1 t na?niln11

fltnr?u*.1TT

{tl

16

3

3

90

a2

9. 20

1.70

1.70

51.80

35.60

56

L2

06

32.20

6.90

60. 90

5

169

2.90

97.10

50

5

29

90

28.70

2.90

16.70

51 70

46

L28

26 40

73

160

I4

92.00

8. OO

Page 79: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

60dro'l?1{n z (oa)

dnrunrs r drrgfiq

.at r --tl{ru1url1'trf

eula( u,lunrua6[ril?nr)

!|

radilruuanTn z tn I rudfiruilT rfrtt,tdu

( u'lu I t1 t Dg?, u1l{t !'l!?1{ )

N iaaas N iaaau

r tur fiutuilrefiu

'tdil

fiutdrtfara.,rri'tfl

lufiT u

n'rfiurir arluil'ru

utdtnsurnrt'ti

t22

2

70. 10

L.20

44

6

25.30

3- 40

158

10

90.90

5.70

6 3. 40

..nr.r.od z udc{aranrzi , "r.rrritala

r ilariludnrsnrt l clr!I

fir ro\i?1ro?'luTnrtnrturifirurh'til ilrunisieuut,i druarsdr dr rnsaruIt

f,n itraTnqfiasrit unsrrr6runnTntsnrzudilT url'rrfr irueu z uriilru iial--rr" d u ' ra,tudniruTnefialriiu'lut !1r Ig'l uacu1ilM!?1{ g1uatsu.l 81tnt

rqa-8

z,laac t oaae{u

tur rnTnr{fl1?.r Ceu'tnrt iif,nrruunrrrfrdfiurrqrnnrzlfrfuntr

indrr tiruru r+g nufie rf,uiaano 85.60) ra{n{g,riiofdddur'ti,rnn,rz

fr tiruru 1s nuficrf,ufaaao 8.60l rfiiuurcflnnnee tiruru g nu fia

tfluiaaan 4.Go luaslfirrTaanrriule{(iruru z nuhnrfuioaar 1.zo)qrrudrfiu Cruuant so1nr{nrr"r druirad rctiHnrorun,trrfrdfiulrreanrriurra{ tiruru 1o4 nu fierfluieaar E9.Bo) ra{n{rr 6a rfrrrrrnn.tfttiruru sz nu fiarfiuiaaa" 29.90t uas'tfriurrannnngn tfruru 18 nu

Page 80: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

61

fic r iiuioaa, 10. 30 l nudrdu Taa'ruadn :rrgr'tur rnTe:snrrr finrriisd.r {ntasfrdut sdanraunfrns g. zg ldrrraruon r EnTn?rnrrrilnrrfianzaod6r.

{roaanzaunfras T.04 rd uas'tuflccfiu rrra:.LuTnzrnrrr finrrfionra{dqd.ndu rod'an?aunirau 21.09'td Crurrrgzuafl r[nlnr{n1z.r in,rrfianro{dAur *dr.rru.frac 10.69 'td

tur rn1ar{n1?.r cru'tu.i ilnrrunrrr rfiudr'tuilrqfiufr.,rfidfiurritcatuo tiruru 11e nu finrfiuiasao 68.40r drufiafiafia.irdfiuluflrrfiu

rfia'rwaufrr tiruru ss nufierfluiaaao g1.60l d.rfifineilrntranfitfiuuon

t lntnt'snrt"t 6o dru'tHrtrsinrru rfiu'irdfiu'tuflrrfiufi.r'tri rfiarno r iruru153 nu 6e , fiuiaano 8z. eo) uas drufiofiafie d.rdfiu'tuilrqfiurfia..rra$fie

(iruru 21 nu fiarfiu{aanr tz.ro) Teatursntnttn.r.dil"r.urfiur'risid6urri t fi a tnaurin rtdT fi u fin r rufrs tn. rdAu r darfi r fi a.,rsaurin r rrirfiu,

"d,craunira!, 25.72 \i dauuanr sntnz{n.t"dt'...r rfiudri.,rfidfiurd ri!a.r

naudnr:drfiu n'nrrufratn.rdAu rdarfirifa.,ruaurin,rzrirfiu radan:aunie

ac 25.26 'td

fie rfluiagao, 86.80, drr.ra'adafraon.rd.oo.rddr.'rr.o"rf, r fruru zs nu

6e r iiuiasao 18. zo r dtfifinrm"ndraafi.rfiuuen r rnTnrtnrrr fie dru.tud

iio fra.rnrzdcrn.rdfiurun""fi riruru 2s au fiariluiaaao 14.40,

'lur rnTnz\rn.l?"r drutur,! iiartsradniiarnrnrnrrr riruru 14o

nufierfiuiaan" 80.50) ?0{a{r1 fiaartsiuirt <iruru t+ nuf,eriluiaans B.oor aT ilurtgf,n{ riruru 1s nu fiariluiaaao ?.so I arilsfr1!.ra

tiruru 6 nu fierf,uiaaa" s.4o) uacqrficdruf,e tiruru 1 nu finrfluiaaao o.60l nrlirfiu driifinr""ariluuf,nnfrrafiu uanrrnlnrrnrrr ifa

?uranTn:{n1r"r CruruJirdfrn.rnrrd""o.rddu <iruru 1b1 nu

'lilfr4tnrrd"on.tddulurnr"fi riruru r4s nufinriluiaaa" BE.60l d,ufin

deu'tffircfisrtuufin 6n rflrelnrzr tiruru 148 nufierf,uiaaar Bs.10)

Page 81: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

62

r0{a.rrl6aartwfutr.,r riruru 14 nu ficriiu{aano B.oo) artsrt*f,q{

tiruru s nu fioriluioaau 4.60)U.sT08ns 2. 30 ) n1ila'lail

ua"orflnfrMa tiruru 4 eu fiarilu

1utrnTnr{n'l?a Cruiurti n'arflsra.sdsarflniuir.-r <iruzu 106

nu fieriluioanr 60.eo) ro{a{uT iianrilsrtrfln{ <iruru ag nuicrfluiaa

alrze.zo) artsrnrnrfl?rl tiruru tt nil fiorfu{oano 6.30 ) uas

arilwrlrsu.i (i'lu?u I nu fie rf,uiaanr 4.601 qud'rdr doiifinrrrartuta.0narafru uan t rnrnrtnrzr iiaC'ru'tradqciiartuzo.,riiaartnilir{ ( f 1u?u

to1 nu fioriuiaaao sB) tasntrrdaorflsrlef,q{ tiruru +z nu fiariiu

faaa" z4.zol arturntrCIrnr?r < irueu u. nu fie liluiaaao 6. g0) unc

trifiarilwrar <iruru 20 nu fie,fiufaaa" 11.Eol nurirfru

1u l s qTn r { fl 'l r.t Cruf uoiifinrrugn I rt tu r.s.,r ru'ta an r rtffu I { { 1u

'tun:otnf.fionu, ti'ruru 101 nuficrf,uioaao sB) rasasrriia'tturrtru'lun:aunirua"irsffaoufir.r <iruru ee nu fie rfluiaaau a?.90t ua"ir.rfrtdurirnaae <iruru z nu fie rfiuiaano 4.10 ) qlrn,tau u\iilanrilEnrrltu r's',t tunh r afr u ua n I lnln r tn r rriiadrulurfrc lidnrflc n 1 r'Lilu r s t ruTa an r rltuz.rrru'lunrouni.finrn"tiruru 14g nufierfluffaanr Bz.zu lala{r'lfialtutt.rru'lunrauniruauir.rfiduilr.r t iruru ze nufin r iluioaao 14. 90 )I

uarir.rfrdurirnaaq tiruru s nu fiarfiuioaau z.golnuirdu!|

'Lu r rqTn z { fl 'l ?.r deu'tuoti 'i r'til{,r alun r rafi nr 11 1nn 1 ?ff tn d.

tiruru go nufierfluiaaau s1.Bo) 1a{a{rrfiaffc'ln*nnzdurifiru r{ruruo2 nuf,e riiuiaanr gs.60l riuatratr tiruru t6 nu f,erfiuiaaac e.zo)

ffiiurdaufiru <iruru a nuiarfluinaao 1.?ol uauiltrrurfi dfis.r tirurus nu fioriiuiaaar 1.?ol nrudrdr druuanrrnTnrtnrr.r dauturieoiiir

lffira'tunrtarinrrrrn nrzficrndafrrnunarr tiruru 90 nil Bariuiaaaot

s 1 . ?o ) ?o{a{uriia r tudsdu t iruru so nufic r iiuiaaao zB.Tol fiiururfi{-'?- -sua{ ( rllu?u 29 nuee r ilu?aaaB 16.70 } unsndu rrlauuru ( i1uxus nu

6erfiuioaar z.90l orudrf,u

Page 82: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

63

tut sotnr\ifl 'l?'r druluru ilanuucn,trcrudraaagfinTnanrtrirlrl

d.rdafrr'turfiar tirueu 106 nu 6nriluiaaau 60.90) rE\ia{u,rfienr:ri,r

wnwinlilnra r artur iis.,r riruru s6 nu 6e r flufaaar sz.zal uarfidafrr

uT fufafrrd (fruau 12 nu 6e rfiuiaaar 6.eol nurirfiu dofifin"*"n.,f rurirawnEa'nnfrrafiu uafl t rnTerrnrzc Cru'lurtr fiunrrriraaaie rrtC,,rriafir

tutila',r tiruru Lza nufiarfluiaaau zB.60l drufinfradrqaufinrilrraror

lu r fia.s t f ruru ae nu fia r fluiaaao 26 . 40 )

?u t rn1nt{n1r"r Cru'tr,rJt i r irufirdurlfinrruusdr r ndarfiunrr

ninrru r f ruru 16e nu fie r iiuiaanr e?. 10 r drufio riia.rcrufiaadrdfi

rtrHfirdrrlfiiruusrir tirueu s nuderfiuioano z.90l druuonrrnTn?,l

n'lr"t Ceulurfrerriiit irHfirdlT tfii'ruusrir r darilunrrnlnzrlr < fruru 160

nu fie rflutaaao ez.0or drufiarfiasdrufiaa dir irufi.drrtfin.rruusrir( {ruru L4 nu 6o r iiu{aaa" B. oo )

lut rn1nr{n1T.r druruoi qau'irilcrfiurdfirturfiu tfruru Lzz

rasntrrn'afi r tur fiurm r fiuri, r.rdfi.r. r irurueu 6eriiuiaaa" zo.10)

44 nu fiatiiu{aaar zs.sol irtualrnsurnrrrt <iruru 6 nu fie riluisans s. 40 I uagiiurd'tfffaro.rri'ttruilru t iruru z nufia, fluiaaao 1. zo )

nudrf,u iioidnrroonfrrafiu uan r rn'lRrrnrr.r iia Cru'tunirunau,ir'tdiirtu

,fiu ti'tu'tu 1EB nu 6erfluiaano eo.eo) ia{n{uriioiiudrilforntriril'tufirutfruru 10 nu6erfluinaa" s.?ol uariiriurfiutnarfiurlratlufi'rut iruru e nuie r iiuiaaar s.40 l nuirfiu Te azrrortu r lntnzrn r zuri

fiT urJrril fitratfrrniratntaunirdail dtndrrrrardarHaafuan1nzrnrt

radilT urlrrfr t,'r"ard r T da a i'tu r rnTn zrn r rudfi rurl.rrfriir r arddnir s tn r au

nfrdailrrirfiu 14,1se. s1 il1n

Ilrratdrose zaunirdail r ri.rfiu

uac zlrarda rdaaiusnTnrrn rmdfi rurlrrfr11,336.61 il1n)

Page 83: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

d0'111{n

64

3 udc{s,fan1?ncdoiln?1rttnnoi1{?cu'i'l{ir r odara.r rra'!fr*nira.rnzaunirdail ra.ru{ilru'luTnrrnrnldilrurl,rril firuni*jnrurrfuasrudilruuanTn r rn. rrriil.url.rfi fr .r., o. n.. oo.cilru r u r r ta r

{o.-dorusfllnjunTccu .01

l1n01f1{n 3 nud r r T a'(denir a rn r ounird ail r a tudfi ru'tutn r.rlt

nrrurifirurlrrfr unuudfiluuan1nrrnrmdilT urh'tfr ilnzruuqndrtiluarirril

fiadrf,runrtefifidrcdu . o1 Te anarddni r odara.rurifiru?u1nrrnrrnrifirut!|r

rl r r fr a.,r n'i r r r a't fr dni I s sud fi ru n iu e ntn r r n r trad fi r urJ r't frIrttr

Innu

I 1',lu'ru,{

n1 I Ons s. D. t P

udilTurlrrfrt

artr4IU,lUUAn-t

In:tnrs

L74

I74

14,159.31

11, 336.61

912. 51

87 4.20

29.48 <.01

Page 84: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

d011',1{n

65

4 uda{g|anllnndauR?1t|uond,l{ rru.irrir,odrnuofiudiir.ruo

ilo\i?'lr6rtuTn:tnrm{firurlrfil ilruni*ifrUrr$ uaurlr}OrIt

udilruuanTRrrnrrurifirurlrrfr firur tr1!?1{ un"firur nr r iae

{o.-doiluat1n3unlcau . 01

..nr.r.nd a su'irrurcilt dfiu""rorod, rstudfflututnr{n1rt

urifirurh'tfr unsudfiruuanTnz.rnrruriilrurhlfr iinrr$unndrrfiuadr.,riifiaItt.o-qqdo{do.ldrfirunrtddiiiirsdu . o 1'[eatutasilnnanra{ r oaa!s{uriilru'tutnrtnrrud

ilT urlrr fi u r n n'i r rum$t do"" tr o, "dr

n u -rudfi rua iusntn r r n r rr,lri fi rurlrtfrt

a

nnrI

31U?U.d

e'l I of,a s. D. t P

udilTurh'lfrt

aatuilil1uuan-

I

Tezrntr

t74

t74

21. 09

10.69

22-99

20.46

17. 83 (.01

Page 85: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

66

"lrrrd{dcn 1 I 1 \tn 5 u5[n {oan 1 Tiladoiln'l 1rtuonoi1.r rcui 1 {i 1 r od'a I a {durid'on ta.s'lu{

0eo ! a { I 1DA?'tu1n I sn r nltdilrurl'rI fr ilrun iu ifu urnl u a "urifi

ruItt

uanTnrrnrzrldffrurl'rtfr fi.ruM!r1.r uaufirur ur t taet

a

narI

11U?U, .ol

n1 t oaa S. D. t P

urifirurl'r1fr1l

a914rU'lUUOn-t

Tnr.snrr

LT4

174

9. 28

T.O4

32.47

T2.T I3. 40 (.ol

du.-doilu86['rnsunTcAil . 01

l1no1r1\id s suiruure$t diiu.rusroda retudfiru'luTnrrnrzt

ra{ilrurlrIfr unou{fi1uuan1n?{nlrnBdn ilnrruunnir.,rfiuai'r.riifiaCrf,runr.r

cfifidr"du . o1 Tearure$rrdiir"rr.,, odrn.ordilru'tu'tnr\rn1ruililT urlrrfit

' f dc d 'e 'l o n,rtudilrurJrrfiI1fln?1!U'|ASU||OAnTa{[OAAIO\tUlU.lUBAilAnlnt{l r

Page 86: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

67

---- { r^-.^^^--- t t -. d e {ro1?1{n 6 u6[a{afan1?nedoun?1runngi1{ ruu'i1{i,l Isaan2lr6atnrriduriTfru !a{?1ra?tuTnrrnrtu{firurlrtfr firunfsjruurri uacra

aY . uuriilruuantn:tnrruifirurlrrfr ilrur !1!?1{ uasfirur rr r iar!|r

,nau

I11U?U

. .ol

n1 t oag s. D. t P

udilrurlrrfrg

rttutfu,luuafl-

9

Tnr,rnrr

L74

L74

25.72

25.28

30.01

24.92

o.62 >. 05

'tdiifiaCrdrudrndu . oE

^-- C ^ | u dq o.e11flO1?1{n 6 ru?1n?,|r|6atnrriidudrfru !a{llrortulnrtnrturifi rurh'tfr ua, r rrotde rf,a a duan:tn rsn T rudilrurhrfi rdiin rruuanir tfruair.rif,adrdqnrttifi

Page 87: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

nDud 3

68

n1"i Inr1srin1riluuu!a{az'uiluil# rsndrrf,zuilricrsueraf,zt

fiutralfrdniralaraunirieil rarnrifirutuTcrrnrrnriil,rurlrrStIf-ueaail'runirillurri uartrdfiruuanTnrsnrrndilrurlrt$ fi.rur !1tr?'r{tttc { ' .--- -!^u1Ilt',rtta2 91ila1au'l 811naa1

r

n r ri r n rroriur riluuur o'rnr uf,lfiud rcud r {fi ruilridruua raffa

fiufieurJ:n rrufi.rf;r Toa'tffnrri r n:rrr{n'l?ncnaa$ruuufrrrruu u{u rt ipleI

Regress ion analys is I t fiun r ti r n trorign I s rfi rurlridts'i rc"n'crad an r rn 1 ? r ildauu rla .,r r s .,r z r a't fr dni r a.s n r o un i r d sil ! a { T,trar'luTe r rn I ruriil.ru

I

rlr'lfr fi',uniruderutni uasx'lrq?uanTnrsnrrradfirurlrrfr fia firur !1tr,1'r\i

firut sr r ilar rrnfiaa rfia.,rta uda.rfrrararaisinisasa{firuilr dnnrir r frr'tut

u uuira a tn r rrfrlfiudrt uda, f;un au unc$atc a rrr n a rnisfi ruilr iirfirulrdr trCu uuf rn a tu einc f;r.r ru c" r f,uf, eu I rdiifi adrerud r r. irfidni r o.,rn raun ir

rd a il r a \i r lra r'tuTn r.s n r :radfi 'rurhrfi u ns r rraruanTn r.rn T rudfi ,rurlrrfi

t.r.od z udatranrzitnrrrrinnnaafl?rnnr rdalfinouuuzralddnitotIt I

n r a un i r d a ih o .,r r tg r'lut n z t n r mi il.rurl,rt fr il run is dau u rrf,

uactl$a?uan1nrrnrr 6a fi,rur!1!?1\t firurrrrloar druaqauo{lcil1 A',llROA1U6In l{U?nAnAtlU

Iriluf,aurlrnu Teara'an

t fl fi rn a r n tul r o*. o dfifi adrfirunr.r*fi fi

otn2$a1n't$ R RO Ro., rtt I xll

d. rl.6f .

F Sig. F

E Beta

1'lu?uuo?I

.8456 .7150 o. 7150 -2822.70 -.8456 868. 17 . 0000

Page 88: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

69

{lo1?1{n 7 (n0)

uln?$81flTtU R RO Ro*. d.,

d. rJ. d.

F Sig. F

B Beta

l. d- I

l::u'un"" l 'e133

I nnsn?o{

|

Juztrru'tu | . szae

lnfrriou I

I nrrunre rlti.r. ggge

I nrzfrnrrucr

nrtsufin l

. rasz

ir'tflira'tuf . snre

n1tera0n1{ |

fl'I'Intrn? |

n,.ranrl f.ro*

rarfirufi'r I

aT'l t ?au I

nrrirradra |

. sasa,

!ilao3ran1{ | tn1?rntnl I I

",'"od I i

.8340

.8553

.87 L9

.8820

.8866

.8906

.8937

o.1190

0.0213

o.0166

0 . 0101

o.0046

o. oo40

0. 0031

880.77 4

| 228.26t

-72L.921

411.903

-296.916

134. 100

4t2|897

13124-80 |

I

.3715

.2Lt3

-.1645

. I745,

-. 1384

.L844

.0715

866. 90

677 .49

583.79

511 . 38

444.51

395.39

356.27 |

64.64

. oooo

.0000

.0000

. oooo

. oo00

. oooo

I

. ooo0

.oooo

f' = 358.?.A721 (P(-Ol)

Page 89: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

7A

11no1r1\id 7 uan,tritn?.tsdaenoE$uniluur'rfifirurtrtaiaflr{ad. -ndrr r rn adur an r rru il?il??ura {nuuuu r1 alfr{ni! 0 { ?1ro??u r rn.tn r{n 1,1

{ni iaaa, 8e.06 (Ro=.BeoGl firuilrd e rduri nrrfrHrirawfinolnnrr

rflrsr ilcrada :ratfreni isan" o.slI

d.t l r -dnr!1f,uux1'laa{o1n L 2 3 4 5I

zratfr*ni iaaar 89.3? (Ra=.893?)I

(Rtd.i.,=. oo31l,drrrnfiufirurltG unc ? cu,irfrruilrf;.rurleiiaada

d.rdn iaaao 10.6s (too-89.g?)

urifi rurl rr fr u a" r to xua n r rnTn rrn r r,{il.rurlrr fr rfr a d,r.rilfi acr6run1.$ daa

f;oru, 8 firuilr Teairraaurfiaefftf, firur:di'ada rrgtfirni u.nd*,{.ra{, ll9fia dluauunt ndrrfia riiuf;rurtzurndnnderfian rtr{uuuiraarilrsru,rrui,rIt

uarilaada zratdeni ioanu z1. so (R'=. z1sol f,ruilrdiiunda narfi{ffi ?s{n{',1 n'a iTurudfiudfir.r"o u'arada :ratfi*ni {oaa" 11.eo( R"*. d,,=. 1190 l , drr.ofirfirurjrurnd r frr{uuuiraat sud.rdeurlrf;rrariiwnsia rratfirni {aaar Bs.40 (R'=.8B4ol A.nrlrd s rfiuri ur.c.,rru.tu

sfrrfau faanr z.Ls (Ro*.*-.= .oztsl rdrr.ofildrulrdrtrCuuuilaa{titrr| rfird r uatfird z su'irfirurjrf;.,rrrliafadarrarfieni es.sg (R'=.BFEg)

firuurd a lfruri n?'rrnleui',r'tunrrf,nnuoziialadarrarfi*ni f,aanu 1.86(R'+.d., =-o1661 ,drrrrfiuf,rurlrdrfrrcuuuirao,,rf,rd 1z $as g sudrfirutrf;.rd liarardorrarfftni iaaao B?.1e (Re=.Br1el firurlrd s rfiuriartuuf,nifladazralfrrni ?aaa" 1.01 (Ro*.s.,=.o101l rdu".ofiufirurlrdrtr{uuuiraa.,rf,rd L z B uas r su,ir f,ruurf;.rfir iiradarrgtfienir ---- . t{aano 88. 20 ( Ro=. 8820 I firuurd e Ifruri irtti'ra'tunrraionl\rn1trn$q? fiaradsrrgffreni{aaas, o.46 (Ro*.d.,=.0046l,dur.lfiufirurlrdrt'rCuuuiraa.rdrd t z s 4 ras s ru'i.rf,rurtrf;wn iifladerlarffdniiaano 88.66 (Re=.88eGl firuilrd z rfrud nrrilnrrlerfieufitnirriiaufiarndatraffr*ni iaan" o.40 (Rod.d,,=.oo4ol rdur.lfiufiruilr drffr{uuuiTaa.rf,rd L 2 s 4 E uas 6 uuir frruurf;trte iiaadanarfi

Page 90: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

Ya

7T

iiuarrcrnarrundu uacnrr'lflf,rurl:f;uale urrltsuttrirnrtaariu finr'rl

na'le,ru"rr, ss1. 34?16 uuuiraot?uffuoauenfira dtd..nn.rirnzT rri

'turilnssuuiu 6a

L3124.797OO9 - O.8456X:, + O. 3715rrE + O. 2113xco

o.1645xse + O.1745Xr6 - O.1384xea + O.1844X4

o. o715Xss

n r znrrrdauuuuirao {rlzur rnti r r s r tralfrrnira \in raunird ail

I a { r 1rarlu r unTn : tn r mrifi rurl rIfr u as rlroiuan I rnTn z.rn r rurifi rurlrtilaadrnrtirntrori n2,trnalerattut (Residual Analysis) uasn,tr

i r nrrrr{n r ruf,ufiudzuud r cf, rulr re aduuuirn a r Hiiadunrrncnaadlfrc rn

o8e{il

n r ri r n r r orin r rn a n a asfi nnn o ila .r ilnnrel ffi r ilul rln r u ff as n a t ( As sunpt i on )

{r{{g41. n'l?u1flu1{ uTEn'ltn?E?N1t!e{n1n?'ll|nn'ln I RaDuuanrfls t ilu

uuuilnfi (Nornality)

z. n t ruurlrilrrur a tirnr runn.", "dur,

iiirn.rduiad, ian'ir r ilu

I onR,tn (Honoscedasticity)

s. nx1ilna.r, "drud

r finfru'tuuiauirf,s t nn r iluBrrsdafiu ( Non

Autoregreseion)

1 . n 1 ls 1? 16taun 1 ru qnu r.ruia n'l rn rc1'l a r a rirn z ,trna 1a, "duta

1.1 a1,tn Hi.strogran Standized Residual su'irilt

d.rrrrir'tfi'tfi uluiraa.tilzsl1rir uia dunrrncnaadcudrurrn

rtzcur$ir v'rfruriuriruacdr, Cafi an.nd*, lr.n.ziianirfiirtfrrirnrrn??q

darnudufiEro.ruuui,rao{ Teanari, "r.Jri".lrna1n,"dru

nrliadu d.rfi

dnruunrtnls?lariiuuuurtni (Nornality) d.rtud I

Page 91: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

72

Jltjil 1 Histrogran-Standardized Residual udntfinrmsnl?ntcttlat,{

[o{a1a?1l|nn,lcrnnau Ia{uuud,laa{ilrsilrflir ?18'tddnita.rI

n ? a ua i? d s fl n o .r : rro r'Lu r lo1 n ? { n 1 nariilrurlrr fr il,run is jau u rd.y I --t t U {unc?.luozusn r nqTe ?{n1Tultu1utl1'll|u,lut !,1[?1{ lrut !1[ !a?

T

ei'liln:sdr dr r nsaruf,n i.rraTeofiasrilI

Histogran - Standardized Residual

N Exp N (* = 3 Cases : = Nornal Curve) ,.1-,

4 .27 Out *o .53 3.000 l .36 2.670 3. 10 2.33o 6.35 2.002 t1.63 1.67 *2 19.09 I .33 'k8 28.07 I .OO *r*

25 36.96 .67 x*******46 43.60 . 33 rt************* .

14l 46 .06 .00 ,lr.ttt*rtrt**f **** . *rt****I****t(******t*******&*****55 43.60 -.33 ***f**********;***37 36.96 - .67 ******fc**** ;

11 28.O7 -1.0O **r*15 rg.0g _1.33 ****,r.2 Lt.63 -1 .67 '.o 6.35 -2.O00 3.10 -2.330 1.36 -2.670 .53 -3.00O .27 Out

J&ldrr: sPss/Pc* Printout irf,l Residusls

Page 92: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

73

1.2 Ql1n Nornal Probability (P-P) plot I!o{n1

standard ized Residual ru'j'rifinrm"iautrtrilurfiuozr dtrUd z

gild z uda{ Nornal Probability (P-P)plot natirStandardized

Residual !o{uuui'laarrjrcursir yralfienila{nraunirdail

rs{r1ro?'lur rnTnrrnT nadfrrurlrlff fi.rrni*ieuurr$ uac?1rgr

uofl r rn1nrrnrrurifiruilrri il.r., r'r!?1{ firur rr r tar irua

rsrrir nir rnaaruf,n i.rrniaafiarrfi

Nornal Probability (P-P) PlotStandardized Residual

1.0 +---------+---------+---------a----********** . f*** {II{f **f

**{

observed

+

Tf!f+

{Iit+

.75

.5

f+g

Tgg+

nITI

t.25 +

t*

{.*{f.*tiT.***ff.**** f+* *l ------+---------+---------+---------+ Expec ted

.25 .5 .75 1.0

do.= spss/Ps+ Printout ird.r Residuals

Page 93: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

74

2 . n'lroitldouirn r ruuilrilr rula{nt1!na.,, "dr*

fr r an r r t iaun rrrczsu'i r {fr ruilzn ril c rnn r rrjrur rni r fruirnr rl---- -{ ..u 4 . . r { {nn,le r na au ( ilTU r ilun 1|| 1f, ?5'lu ) 1f il?1n1i a{n?'ll|na10 [ na au-n1TnIsl1a

?Ett1 ir o uaulriiltrluuut0{e'l'ufllfiudduriuou udet'jrnrrtuilrilrrur0{irnrrrna',o rndaufiin"*r,fiu,, ano.$ fi,rrtjd B

rld 3 $dq'.t standardized scatterplot rcu'ir.rfiruilrnrurrnnltrlrcilrerir (pRED) fiu irnr1rnn1c,.d"* (REsrD) !a{uuu

irnatrl:uurruir yratfr4niro{RxEUafedail tra{?lrarturrnrn:rnrruriilrurlrrfi fi.r.n;*i*uur,$ uacrlrazuan r rntnrrnrrvrdilrurJrtfr ilrur r1r?1\r firur rr r iiar irua:cdr dr rnaarufrn

{{u{aafian1fi

Standardized ScatterplotAcross - ,IPRED Down - *RESIDOut ++-----+- -+- . -+-----*-----+-----++

3+ +{f

-3+ +out ++-----+-----+-----+-----+-----+-----++

-3-2-101 2 3Out

T2+

ff

1+T{

0+II{

-L+ftl

-2+

n+

T{+

{n+

n{+

I{+

iT

Synbols:

Max N

. 6.0: 12.0x 25.O

Tf

du'r. sPss/ps+ printout ird-l Scatterplot

Page 94: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

75

dfifi ourbin-t{atson test11nfl1r r ile orzr.slHdr a

g. n1lnr??daunr1il r fiu6arudafiuratirnllrnnle ,.dru Taatil,_ q d t . _ d I r uH4fl11? t At,lsl.t luu?1n1 d r|a1 [ n'lnu O. 60

{t I u

= o.ze (c =.081 iioirdCrurrulfr ilirlrnn.irir d- q1fln'l?1{unru'irfioan'iri'r 4-d- (4-d- = g.Tll udet,irirnrrru

nn10 r ndoufdfinr"rruilufiudfiu uio r iluirrrdafiu (Non Autocorrelat,ion)

n trrdsun rruf,lfiudrsr,l'ir.rfrtuilrdnnrir r frrluuuuirao {ilrurr rnr

ir Toaqrrn sinpletl

adlurrfiudtdc.rr rnfinrt

I

c o r re I at i on su'i r n r I ru f, tfiud r ru'i'r.,r fi r u il ra' dr c

fi alr'ei r f,ru rt rrRndrrf,rfiud#.r ud o . z -o . I i.rrri ri a

lfi r fi eflruurn r rsf,tfiuf trra'i r tfi ruilr ( l{u lt, ico l l inear ity l'tun r ri r n z T

"rifiarun fittauadudatlunrr.od a

{n'l?T {n 8

11AA{

u de .r d r fl u rt r u lndau f, rfiud r u ra'i r .,r fi r u il rfi *r "

dn n r i! a n r t r Cu r u

Correlations: x.o XroN,7 x..

iruruunr (x?).dql1U?UneU (x16)

ur{{1il'lunfr r igu ( xeo )

n'r'trnlcuittunrrn1?Anr1iln? (xce)

{oa1f$ilan (x1o)

iT 'til{ra'lun1?afnn (xe 1)

nrzilnrrro sfier,rfir

nieriau (x4)

nrzilniraafinaa lx,.e,

1. 0000

- . 3? 14**

-.5171**

.4702**

-. 430?**

.1440*

-.440g*t

-.37 14**

1. OOO0

.6632**

.1945**

-.51?1**

.6632**

1. OOOO

-.0862

.4702**

.1945**

-. 0862

1.0000

.765g**

.5005**

. ?310t*

.6534**

.6416*r

. g562t'

.19?4**

.2111**

. L725n

-. 1193 .5g66** .25g3** .1087

Page 95: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

7A

n'rr1{d I tdol

Correlations: xr. Xtt x4 Xu.

irururn: (x?).Jo11U?UneU (x1B)

ur\r{1ulunir r iau

nl1iln1euis'tunrz

n1lanr1un? (xse){ealisuan (xaa)

ir'lttra'lunlref6ot9n1?f,nlt1tra{u?t{u'l

.ln1?[TOU (x4)

.lqnM1fiU',lAflnn$a

-. 430?".. ?658**

.6534**

.19?4**

1.0000

.477g'"

. g062**

.1440*

.5005**

.6416r*

.2LLL**

-. 440g'*

. ?3 1o**

. g562**

. L726*

-.1193

.5g66**

.25g3**

.1a87

.427g**

.26g7t*

.3162**

(xuo)

(xzl)

.477g**

1. 0000

.65gg**

. g062rr

.659g*r

1, OOO0

(xec) .427gtt .269?*' .3162** 1. 0000

z-toiled signif: * iifiadrf,fldrlrdu .o1** i[firCrf,adrrrHu .oo1

Page 96: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

77

eoud 4 n,rrirnrr"r{fralardarfiucnrrnrtftnu

{ q lv {o 1 T1 {fr 9 n'l ri r e rlct{! arn r n arfiudnrunr rf,{nr[ 0 \rrlxctrn zn6iilfi rai r.,r

l9

r,rd fi rurlrr fi fi run fsirr u zr$ u aor,rri fi ruuo nTR r,,i n r zuriilrurJ rt frtttt

ilrur n r fiar ilrur !1fl?'l\r eituaaruf,n i.rraTaafigsrilI

dnrwnrtf,tau

r,rdilruilrrfr

< firun{uderlrntl

ud ilruuan1n :.r n r rudilrurlrrfrlt9{9

( ltlu[ !'l [ [8?, u1u t I1!?1{ )

IN ?aans,a)N TAENU

I.o11UXUn{nilO

IrQfl1? [ t'lT2rnlnT?r

L74 100. oo

3

5

163

3

1. 70

2. 90

93. 70

L.70

L74 100.00

r57

15

2

90. 20

8. 60

r.20

ndudr.rtr e -rdurin

'tuniz r iau

'td r naa

nnil [ fltrn1fl?Ir-loC

nailf,ufl?tu00iln?saI.Unarann'l fnaf.tt

tl.{{nnl|tna{In fltvilnI

nair r arrduuriualrr

Page 97: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

78

01?1od g trdal

dnrunrtf,snn

udilrurlrrfr

t ilT unindclu:ril

vrd fi ruuo nrn : t n t rrari ilrurJ rrfit!l

t, €a l,( u'lu[ [1[ tg't, u1u[ [1!?'l{ )

IN TAaAsatN 1084u

nrzlffiuirrJTnrr

, duilflruu.frT udr.rr

56

6

7

46

59

32.20

3. 40

4. 10

26. 40

33. 90

36

2

1

98

I

28

20.70

L.20

o.60

56. 20

5.20

16. 10

151

13

10

86. 80

7.50

5. ?O

4

20

3

52

15

Ig7

35

2.30

11. 50

1. 70

29. 90

8. 60

4.60

21. 30

20.10

U^ .U'i1na-a?ffllu1u|l

r{url'lnrylnguo{d-

c'1fl$Tsn2a

1'lnnTt4v

11fl [ IIOUU1U

r,u{rq1n r irufirfrnatig

rrndeurin'tunfr

r iaur iurha'turauqduUNUR?

*ueail1a1 r;a

1ilr fiaaaan

nauatuon

rfrHie

Trncari

fia.rdzrai't{ut{

ttnfirlrfi.,r

lrnrrndrro'lu1?

{( t ar an r r o n 1 r r 6lrl a ar dc 1 n n 1 I f, rn.",fiiio u.. n 1 e I n a{ aufi r fr s u a n r {ucnitt

Page 98: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

79

n1r1.{d e rdal

dnrwnt.,lf,.onn

radilrurl'rrfr

t ilruniui*uurnlrI

udfi ruua nTn r.sn r rudfi rurlrrfrtt

lt{u( tl'lU[ ['l [ [A?, U1U [ !1!11'l\i )

N ioant N iaaao

darfisurfra'turadfirr

t74 100.00

7t

18

51

34

40.80

10.30

29.40

19.50

t74 100. oo

L74 100. oo

13

76

53

gz

7. 50

43.60

30.50

18.40

L74 100. oo

ll

rdfi

n1lTnr1Sa1U1a

, daiin.t r iurlra

nruarduulsrt{tta,lr.|n,lut 8{

tt.u,luf,nao'lua

'e ddnrilaurfradrua

Iillr.,ruaruradr rR

{!I1{ I TSUU'Ert,lutlg

u1uelu

-- t{1l|11

Page 99: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

80

o1i1{d 9 ttdol

dnrsnrrf,tnn

tu r l,urrruil'rIuI

evl,a( u1un1uE5tililt$)

t

uriilruuo nTn r.qn r tnriilrurlrrfrtt9<alt

( ulut n1r !a2, u,lut tr1!2'l{ )

t,N ?084s N ioanu

nrztfiunr',r'trlrigu

169 97. 10

2. 90

39

56

65

L4

22.40

32.20

3?. 40

8. OO

116 66.70

L.20

56 32. 10

126

L7

24

7

72.40

9.80

13.80

4. O0

nfi.,rilaratdl'rintuo{

nT2 I TaU

Tt.,t t iaurlrsirudI

ttu'tu

1:t r ?auudfirutnfrtd

I na{

trt r iaurlrsirdr rna

rdrdr iauufi.rta

'da?1rn1nurrneclfi

Wgiauufi.rfla9

ruiluilrsnuilnrr

cufrufisauilnrr

cuorilr;lnn

rurrduiliruru'rni

Page 100: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

81d.01r1{n I (00)

afnrrnrrf,rnn

r,rdilT url'r'tfr

< firuniuitruuzollt

rri fi ruuo nTn r r n r rudfi rurl rrill

Itd',( lt1ul [1t !a?, u1u3 !1tr?1\t )

N isaat UN laaas

uud.,rfirdrtrunrr

ailTnn uiTnn9at

drduuagrirrlruilr{.e

11n 1!oU'lUVutU.lUtYUrirdu, ririlrrrilrrrn{T

I trAUltn|,U111n,"fn||ul a,|nao{

UUrircfuunsd,tu'te 1auatrirCuuaurill'tn

,tl.uuu,l nleaa{9t

rirdu, dru,tcrnuactr9. l. .u1l1nUIU1n'lnnB{

frnrxnrilruurfiT dttrdiiilrunr

. '! r^- a,uua{u18a1flau'tut

!

rrnriturrncI

cd I gunaulilt|uu,l{nt{d.ot|nsnauIutrut

rrtdra'triaiaa

ntius u fiufinrrirfia

150 86. 20

24 13. 80

64

6

56

3

6

2

37

36.80

3. 40

32.20

1.70

3. 40

1. 20

21. 30

56

77

92.20

44.20

4L 23.60

7g

27

L2

a2

42.OO

16.50

6.90

35.60

Page 101: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

82

{lq1?1\tn I (OO)

dntunr.of,.rnu

uriilrurlr'tit

t ilrunisicu:r$r

udilT uuanln rrnr:udilrurlrrfrttu{o

( ltlu r D'I1 !a?, u1u M!'l1lt )

N iaaa, N faanu

nr:iffuttdll

1dil

f,nrusnr:rtfirlffrrruau

firuaro

rlriaanuszzrtrfi

il'rdu

rffiu,dauilru

nrriitoflT'til raia

L74 100.O0

L74 100. o0

18 10.30

98

2

16

40

66.30

t.20

9.20

23. OO

111

63

63.80

36. 20

85

2A

13

26

25

48.90

14.90

7 .40

14.40

14.40

2 t.20

166

3

13

89.60

1.70

7.50

uui,,r'tfiu*ll'irr

'tur zarnarsiiu

rdiirddr ?trfiau

Irunu

1ilnc r fiarfirfiuunu

'tf;ncrfia.,rttrnra

'tffns r fia.rufia

ituun, ruiunr.

Page 102: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

83

{fo'lT1{n I (s8)

dnrunr.,rf,tnn

uriilrurh'1ilI

< ilrunicd*uurr$rI

uri il'ruuanTn r t n r rndfi rurlrriltt

UdU( ulut [1t Da?, u'luM!?1{ )

UN TSAA& N taaat

r e{ntttua"d.,r

druraerrrdsre tn

2naI

Tn{nrs1u-a2nguns?fl1n?8111

tq'lna. tnu unu

I

rn{nra1uq.u2nE, tnil, intE,lu

t-

uarTnrficrltT r-drq.o?nE, lnurlflta1u,toar|RlA1UtUn UAc

rnrfisrllatu?na, 1nu,lfltE1u,

t-IUUgaoa

rf flta,luguc, ultu1,

rn:figdlluarrnaud

93

59

11

L

53. 40

33.90

6. 30

o.60

4. OO

t.20

0.60

33

19

103

19

19. oo

10.90

59. 20

10.90

Page 103: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

84

d,0'111\tn I (0a)

dnrsn'rrf,lnu

udilrurlr'tfr

t firuniuiauuzr$rI

HdilruuanTn z r n r rudilrurlrrfrIt

U{U( u1u t t1 I ra2, u'lu M!?1{ )

N isan" N iaaat

n1f I nunl{88nu8n

to2

63

L

I

58.60

36.20

o. 60

4.60

37

t24

13

2r.go

7t.20

?. 50

24

4T

3

1

105

13. 80

23.60

t.70

0.60

60.30

86

5

83

49.40

2.90

17.70

38

t29

T

21. 90

74.LO

4. OO

20

L4t

11. 60

81. OO

7.6013

.Ul4flu1u

tUilrlnrriasni.r

rUf,rlcrrinu z-g nfr

tJ

flrlnrrlac B-? nit{"-

t nSuasn?{

-{d-qfnlllnn$nqc I nu

n1{1rl

uriilrutnir 6ar

f,rir rnaaru6lnouuuaan?1{u,|eanat'lu

r.ruuo$ttrfiunrra9

80nu8nil||U'lul-

.Urcutn,l

to?n1e1uoatolntS,lual|n

Jt oTntund?rn?a

?nruoleEs|1t

Page 104: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

85

d,q1z'r{n I (na)

dnrwnrtf,tnn

urifirurlr'ti

< ilruniri*ruzr$r

udfi 'ruuo nTR : s n r :uriilrurlrritt

U.'U( U'|UM t !E'l' U1U3 [1!?1\t )

JN lD8As N iaaau

dnrr t fiunr,,rnrz

tfiunr"t

nuualccrnafura-- rd

auuluti r osru0e ofu't

auu'tdfinnaeil

r ilu r rfirdlfl'tun'rr

65

109

?7 .40

62.60

32

47

93

2

18.40

27.OO

53.40

1.20

42

58

T4

24.tO

33.40

42.60

83

91

47.70

52.30

103

22

49

59. 20

12.60

28.20

2

138

34

t.20

79.30

19.60

@ilu

riru

flu uac dru

r nrufid

,{-[ua{ I trE lra{ttl,l1ll1t a.rcrndr

il, ,,"r r{'ru1ra{

crndr

Page 105: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

86

n1r1.rd 9 tdsl

dnrunr.tflsnu

udilrurh'tfr

t ilrunfsirruzollI

ndfi ruua nTR z t n r trrd fi rurh'tffIta{u

( u'lul [11lE',1, u1u[ !1!21{ )

N ioan" N iaaao

ilirrur ila rs6.,rru

96

59

19

56.20

33. 90

10.90

4

161

I

2. 30

92.50

5.20

46

73

2

51

3

25.80

42. OO

1. 20

29.30

1. ?O

30

to7

3T

L7.20

61.50

21. 30

4

170

2. 30

97.70

28

29

93

15

9

16.10

16.70

53.40

8.60

5.20

ihrfiu

u1fl t nu$a{

ITE{SB.Unau!1{!,leuRau

!1COnnilr'ln

su.irdrrdrzo{44uu{f,Exur

2naI

rnrfisd

nrrrfrnrnrzlfioru{n11r.|u1n8{nr|

nur

lrlilrnttldsarc

nrrCr r eiuartrrnteadrrilrsirnr

,?uua{u'l

Page 106: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

87

i1nn1t1{d 9 udc\tflan.tzirarroriilauardarfiuenrnnrrfltnut

!s\trlsot?u'tnrtnrtudfirurlr'tfr ilruni*i*unt,i d,tuazudr rirrnanruf,ntt

{suiegfrarrfi reuilro?uonTnrtnrzndfirurl,rri iruru z udfiru 6al-rt

',',dT,trazr,tnfturtrl!?'l{ uas[rur!'ll[a? nruarcdr dtrnantuin {rniao{ad{-{anafr"lu l|T'laasI8f,nc{u

I

1ur rnTnr.tnlr.r Cru?uqi finT rr frrdrufienrru?uniror,.n.r,duI

n,trtnDs? (snal. I tiruru 16g nu 6eriiuiaaao 9g.?o) ra\ra\rrrtan.lz

rtT dauftrnrrr 'tuniudunrnlaalnisd tiruru s nu finrfuieano z.eo)I..q4uenriurn$qrnr tiruru g nu 6e riluraans 1.?o I uasniuriar Tn nrsilet1

tiruru s nu fie riiuioaar L.Tol erudrdu Cruuan r lc1n rsnr rudiltrt

rhlfr Crutuqi rlr'tdrnarfr'rdufirnrutuniudr.rt riruru 1s? nu f,e rilu

iaaa" eo. zol iirfiarCrufiardr"rrtrduficnrrr'tund$rnroznr r{rururs nufialiluiaaao B.Gol uaunirrarrdundrdrr tiruru 2 nuficriuiaaos 1.20)

'lutlnlnr{n1zn Czu'tnrt rslfriuirrlinrr riaiiilqmrfirudr.rt

'r,rnrtrufirdrarit tiruru se nu fie riluiaaa, 3s.eo) ra{e{r.riierfriu

irrfinrrrrnfr'turtil'lu riruru se nuinrf,uiaaar gz.zo) i'rnn! tiruruae nuinriluiaaeu a6.4ol ".nr""ili" tiruzu z nuinrfiuiaaar 4.10)

raul1ng1idfia.r <{ruru e aufinrf,uiaaau g.4ol oruirdu Cruuanrrn

Tnrrnrrr Cruturt eurfiiui'rilinr1crnflridfie.r riruru r6t nu f,crilu

iaaao E6.Bo) ia{a{r, ds1Hiuitd?nrrrrn*rodi" tituru rg nuinrflu

ieano ?.so) raciln,dauilruriruru to nuficriluisanu s.?olnrsirdu

tur rqTnr{n1in Crutud iirrndrurintunir r liaur iurhatursu

ildufrrdarfruin tiruru eB cu fie riluiaaau E6.zo) rerarrrila lrirna

riurlra t{ruru ge nuieriluiaaa" 2o.Tol Tznirufir riuzu es nu6n

riluiagao 10.1ol fia.rdrtairrurr rituru 9 nu finrfluiaaag E.zo)

nrarria tiruzu e nuinrfiuiaaao L.zol uaslfrrifansan r{ruru 1 nu

ficriiuisaae o.60) nrudrdu CruuanrrnTnrtntr.r C'lu'luoiqsrilrrtratt

Page 107: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

88

nia ti'luru sz nuinrfluiaano 29.eo) re{n\trrila ltnfirufir tirurugs nu fiarflu{aa^n 21.30) Trn!'leclzo'ru11 riruau ss nu 6nrfuiaa

Ac zo.1ol urartia tiluru zo nu fictfiuisanu 11.so) 'trnrElitfruru ls nu 6arfluiaaar g.Gol fia.rde.rarirrurr <iruru g nufiarflu

iaan, 4. Go I 'tri r nailaa t iruru a nufin r iluiaaar z. go ) uasnEnoa$on

<iruau s nu fie rfluiaaa" 1..Tol suirfiu'lursslnr{n'lra f;orro" nau'ir ittriiien'rfieurfialuu{ilru dt

fidnrsr t dur fiarfiu usn r ra1nrrnrr.r ila f;onu"rrudrfi.rrriienrfiourfiatu

urifrru tf'ruru 1?4 Ru fie riluiaaau 1oo)

'lu t rs.tn r {n 1 in Cru'tuJtiin r rinrrsa 1u1a r is r turhalean r rf,a

a1r'ln'lura{ tiruru zt nu ficrfluiaaao 40.80) ra\ra{uT 6a lrldnrfi

aurfiairua tiruru s1 nu finrilutaanr zg.40) ril'tr{naruradrrna

tiruru s4 nu finriluiaaau 19.sol unsltlsuurndirua <{ruru lE nu

ie r f,uiaaau 10. so I n'udrfiu iioiif,ntrucn'rrintrraruranfrrafru uan r !n'lnrrnrr.ra'sCrutuni.ufrr.*.n'l$] a{ tilmu ze nudcrf,uieaa" 49. Go)

ra.sarurila'trJdnrfiouriladrua riruru Eg nuinriluiaan, go.60l rilrrruarurndrrna tiruru 3g nu icriluioaao 18.40) uocnluardrursr

tiruru 1s nu ficriluiaaau ?.so) aruirdu

lut cnlnr{fl1?n f;oru" oal'iriirr{ r iaurlrci'rudfiru t {'rurr1?4 nu 6nrf,uiaaao 1oo) iirunnirsilnuaRrrntnrrnrr.riiaf;oHucnaud'r

firtriihrrriaurjrlrirraifiru tiruru 1?4 nu ficriluinaas 1oo)

'lur rnTnr{n1r.r dtrtnriiinrrr6unrrlrlr iauufirtsrnrcsT ?n?uoa4nirriau do nrr'tilTrrriaurlrsirrerifiru (iruru tog nu ficriluiaant

9?.10r drraiatrlTrrriaurlrlririirrno tiruzu s ar fiarfluiaaau z.90)

Cruuanr nnTnrrnrrrCru'luqicu'hlTrtriauudfirutntrfias tiruzu 116 nu

fie riluiaaau G6.zo) ra{a{!rT fio frifdriaunfitila tiruru 6G nu ierfluiaaau gz.D uacril'trrriauilzs{rrirrna({1u?u z nuintiluiaaau 1. zo)

Page 108: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

89

tur rnTnr{n1r.r Crurnri ilnrrrnrnni{drctfiunf I iauufi,lilacu

artrfrnur t iruru es nufie r iluf aan" sr .40) re{a{r.riisru#ufuarilnrrriruru s6 nu 6ariuieanu gz.zol rufrurlrsnufinur riruru gg nufie

rf,uiaaa, zz.40 ) uaclurcfiurjtrururni riruru L4 nu fierf,uiaaa, 8)

nuirdu dtuuan r tnTnttnrt.r dru'trartcuinrrrn'rcui.rdrsifiunz r fauruturjrrnuflnrr riruru Lza nu fierfiuiaanu ?2.40, ,rouoo.i, ruarilrfinnr tdruru za nuicrfuiaaao 19.Bol eutufigarilnrr tiruru 1z nu

fiqrfluiaaar 9.so) uacluzudurtiruru,rni tiruru z nuf,crfiuiaae" 4)

'lurrnrnr{n1?n cru'turt iuui.rfi,rd'tt'tunrzailTnn uirna 6a

firclu uaufiriltcilr vrndrtrfisfirtuurifiru <iruru 160 n$ ficriuiean"86 . 20 I d r ufr aiia c rnir cuu a,rfi rrlro ilrc rn ri'r r, fi ufi .o

"ofi ...nnrifi rrfrnn a r

r iruru za nufintiluioaao 19.B0l Cruuanr rnlnrtnrr"rCru'lurfrrriiunrit

fi.d'tf,'tt nrrarlTnn uirnn 6a rrni'rafuu"rfi.".nndfiriraaar ritmu zz3- 4 u { Znu nelilulslns 44.20) 1a{a{rrd'arrndtCuuauriru.tc'ta tiruru s6 nu

ficriiuiagar gz.zu uacllnfiran n.rfi.u.r.o orofi...nurifi,rirnaa.rtiruzu 41 nx fiariiuiaaao zs.60l suirdu

tu r r nTa r r n r rrcrutudn ou d T fi r ilr ila {'tuile 1 ilu'rriiiilrurar t iruruG4 nil 6erfluiasa" 36.80) ra{n{rriie ilrunrn.rn..fi.luurrqc riruru56 nu fiatfluiaano sz.zol flrprrnrtucrfiufinrdrifarra tfruru gz nu

fiariluiaaao 21.Bo r ilrnrruuddra{rnnfi.ru riruru 6 nu ficriiuiaaats. 40 l ilnurfiT iinn neuriufru t iruru 6 eu f,n r iiriaans s. 40 l ilrnrrfiriindt ,ufiutuuT rnir tiruru s Ru ficriluiaanr 1.?ol uauilqrarrdtrnrd

aiaa t{ruru z nu Berf,uieaar, 1..zol errtd,rdu druuenrlqlcrceu'tnqicsuuilqnrruui.rfirairnailru riruru zg nufiariluiaaar azl't

awrils itruurnrdusrfiufin'tdrdawa r iruru ez nuiarfluiaaau sE. 60)

ilnnaurarirtuursqn tiruru zr au ficriluiaaar 1E.sol uarf,rprrfirii

druuen t lqlcttnrr.rta{

.',a4',.snunautrutru (l1u?u L2 e,I nnlilutaae& 6.go) nuariuI

Page 109: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

90

'lurrnTnr{n1?n f;oru, nau'iriif,rltt tiruru 124 nu fiatilu

iaaao 1oo ) druuan r rntnr.rnrzrdzu'tHrieonau'iriifrurit fruru 111

fierfiuiaaao Gs.Bol ua"ilurrdzuaaudrd..rrriilfielti tiruru 6s nu

nu

-ee

r iiuiaanr 36. zo )

lur nntnr\tR1r.r f;or u. naudr Hnrflsra,$firud'ttriiufiunrc

tiruru 124 nu 6arfuiaaar 1oo) CruuanrrnTnrsnrrr Cruturir"itfru

riufiauaar <iruru 8E eu ficriluiasau 48.90) za{a\tlrdariuffuerc

tfruru ze nu fie tiiuiaaao 14.eol ?tiriu tiruru zs nuie ,f,t iurut14.4ol 'tflfiurdaufiru tiruru zs nu fierfluiaaa" 14.401 unsildaaqlr

rrrudrfi tfruru 19 nu 6e riluiaan" T.4ol nudrf,u

tur rnTnr{n'lr.r Cruturt 'tflnc r figririutunrzCa,rddrtlur rar

nartifu t iruru 98 nu 6c r fluioaau 86. Bo ) ra{a\rrriia 'tiluu", ruinn*

riruru ao au f,nrilu{aaar zs.oor lilrilaurr <iruru 18 nu fierilu

iaaao 10. go I 'ttnc r iiarufta t f ruru 10 nu fic r fiuiaaau g. 20 ) unclil{U.qilU.s-vonsrfla{rl'lsT E tiruru z nuf,ariluiaaau r.2ol nruirfiu dsnfrranuuan

I

r rnTnrrnrr..r fia E.rrdiiruilrtt Cru?nnicc'tilnsrfiatfirfil'lunrrCar*drt

r rarnarrfiu t iruru 1sG nu fie r iluiaaa, 89.60 ) za{a\trriia'ttnc t n'at

ufil tiruru 13 nu finriluiaga" ?.so)'tilnlrriia.rttrsra tiruru 3 nr

ficrfluiaaau 1.?ol uac?f,riaurr tiruru z nu fiariluiaan" 1.zo)

'Lur rnTnz{n1xn Ceu'traoliirniat'til uariitirutanrucsnrn ifa

ina t iluru 93 nu 6c r iluiaaao 83. 40 ) ra{a{urilern{nz61u t iruruse e$ finrfluiaaar 39.9ol inauacrninraru tiruru tl cu f,criluisa

as e.so) inq rnil {nraru uestnzficrfurn-dr tiruru z nu fierihiaa

ti'ruzu 1nu finriluisan" o.eo)

rnzfitrlil ue""oaud ti'ruru L

au 4) inr rnil inraru {nraruaudI

taaa" t.zol ina rnil uaurninrrtut

unctnrfiedt tiruru z nu f,crilu

uasina rnrl {nzaru inrgruaud ilu*T

nu icrfluiaaao o.eol nudrfiu druuanr rn"[nrrnrrrrrifirurh'tfi Cru

'tudruiir n{a.r'ttunodrdruranrrlstucrniiainq uauzn{nraru t {ruru tos

Page 110: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

91

au f,erfuiaaao Ee.zo) ?a{a{rT iia iiina <iruru ss nu f,nriuiaaao

19.ool rninraru tfruzu 19 nu fierfluiaan" 10.90) unr ina tnrl

uauzn{nraru tiruzu 19 nu 6criluiaaau 10.901 nurirf,u

'lur rntnz{n'l?.r Cau'rraqi cs t fiunrtaanuanndilruflrte rri"""*oI

tfruru Loz nu fierilu{aaar bB.60) zarntur iia f,rlarriar z-s "*o

tiruru eg nufierf,ufaaau 3G.zol ,iiru"u"*o tiruru a nu ficrfiuiaa

ac 4.601 uacdilcrr{au 6-? "*o tiruru 1nu finrfiufaaas o.Bo) n'lr

d'rf,u druuanr rn1nrrnrrr Crutunircrfiunrtaanuanudilruf,rtcrria"n*s

t iruru ge nu fia r fluisaa" 49. 40 ) rB\ia{urila, iirr,"o"*o t iruru 8g

nu ficrfluioaa, 4T.Tol uasf,ilcrriau z-g .io tiruzu s nu ficrf,uioa

as 2.gol srtirfiutur aqtnz\tn'lr.r drutnri illo.rddfnrcrGun'r.,rhl 6a dadatna

aruln tiruru Lz4 ex 6crf,uiaaas Tr.zo) ra{a\trrfio udfirutndrda.r

tfruru B? au fieriluiaaao zt-sol uac{ruicafiasTfi tiruuu rs nuie

riiuiaaau ?.601 nrudadu Cniinrtrdunrrnfrrgfiu unnrrn1ar,rnrr.l 6a

Cru'tur[au r BunrrrrlfrrHrdr r nanrufln t iruru tzg eufin r iiuiaaar T 4. Lo,

zatarurileurifiT u'tnfrrn'at tiruru sB n$ 6nriiuiaaat zt.90l racdr

{ruinafiarril <iruru z nu f,nriluisaao 4, nruirdu

'lu r ro'tnz{n1zn Crutun! iirtrnaudleadrr, il*..tt ttunrr t iu.u.qA',

n1{eanuanudfrru t'iruru 1os nu iictiluiaaast60.30) tD\ta{I1

rEurfir t iruzu{nraru tiruru 41 nu fiarfluiaaar 23.60)

6eriluiaaau 1s.Bo) rn{nzaruaud tfruru g nu f,nriiuiaaau 1.?o)

o",rrnr*dCrufir riruru 1 nu fiatf,uiaaau o.oot nruirdu Cruuantla

TRrtntrr Ceutunirc'til{nraru ,flt r.nt o'lunrzrfiunrt tiruru 141 nu

ficriiuioanu B1) to\ta{rrdariurfiT <iruru zo nuhcrf,uiarnt 11.8o)

ano r$

24 nu

u"rrnaud'taadrr <iruru 13 nu 6ntfluiaang 7.5o) n'uirdu

Page 111: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

g2

'lurrnTnr{n1ra drururt ildnrsnrrrfiunrr 6a nuu'tridrsrlc6l?Bfu tfturu 109 nu fierfuisanr 6z.ool drrafiarfiudrnuualccrn6tsurg

t f ruru es nu6a r iiu{aaao gz . 4ol Cruuon r rnTnrrnrrrCru'ludr"fidnrs

nuurrifiCInoeil tfruru gt nu finriluiaaau sz. sol iiur,ldrurfiu'irdn,rn

nuu'tridrocrs'tu0ecu <iruzu Bg nu ieriluiaano 47.To,

1ut rn1nt{n1rn Crutrart ttrilarsir'tunrrurfrr fia iluuardru

<iruru gg nu Bcriluisano sB.40) ?a{a{rriia'ttdru tiruru 4? eufie

rfluiagno zrr'ttilu tiruru Bz nu 6nriiuiaaau 18.40r uac'lilra.rufi*

riruru z nu fie riiutaaau L.zal nrudrdu druusnrlornrlnrrrCzu'lnd

'ttilu , ilt , ilr r ui.r'tunrzurdu t iruru 1os nu fie r fluieaa" E9. zo ) rE{

agnlralnl|

Cruturt iiur,li.r r ila r 16.riia

atrrfia ifuuaodru tiruru ag eu ficrfluiaano zg.zol uas.iru t{ruruzz ex ficriiuiaaar lu.60)

tut lnlar{n1T.l f. o.rr.r1re{u1u1 r arrrndrrrnilr t{ruru ?4 nu 6erf,uiaaau 4z.su ra{a{lTiia

(iTuru E8 au inriiuiaaau sg.40, n."f,rn. tiruru 42 eu finrfluiaa

as zt.rol nruirdr CeuuanrrnTRrrnrz.r dru'tunlesilunirdlrouo,il"

rsfiriio Hrrarerndr riruru 1sB nu finriluiaaac ?9.s0)

tuo"un.nr r errrndr t iruru 94 nu 6a r ilutaanr 19. so )

( iruru 2 nu fic r fluiaaa" 1. zo I nuirdu

Cl

tiruru tg nuficrf,uiaano 10.9ol Cruuanrrntnrsnrr.rCru'ludc"rfiudr

Iirtiuasrr ila rsir'tuflcqfiufirnr rfiarra t iruru 10? nlfin r iiuiaaau 61. so)

zararur 6a rfiu'iT rilarsiriaufrrrrreueau tiruu s? cu ie riiuinaao

{ta{a{r1naIt]au t8lt1

'lut rolnr{n1r.r Cru'turirfiu'iriirliur", ilu r sir'tuilcSfiurifawa

tiruru ge nu ficriluiaaa" ss.zo) .aC.l-.ut a {a{r 1na I uu?1 1 tr9 t f,a {neu! 1{

l.tcunau < iruru s9 nu f,c r iluiaaao gg. 90 ) Bas tull?Mnunaul|,|n

z1. sol uaoiirtir,rrrr,rnrfiura <iruru go nufiariluioaao rr.20,

Page 112: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

93

'lurrotnz{n1rn Cruruqiliuuri.rd.rrdr:6a ina tiruru ret nu

6erfiuinaa" 9z.sol rararrrdo rrntnrfierl rfruru e nu finriuiaaa"E . zol uasr,rfi.rila0rd < iruru 4 nu fie r fiuiaaao z. s0 I cudrdu Cru

uan r rntnrtnrzr Cru'lurieriiuudrdrrdr:crnins < iruru LTo nu fin r fiu

{aanu sr.To) uasi'.nufislefiu{ <iruru a nufinriiuiaan" z.30)

'turrnTnz{n1r.r crutnrri fra.tnrrdcsrfidrr{flr <iruru zg nu

fiarfiuiasno 42, rs{a{u'l;io nrrc.rreiuarils tiruru sr nu ficrilu?saUac 29. 301 fiarnr?fluu t {ruru ls nu fic r iluiaaar zE. oo I fra.rnrr

rnte adrrilrsirnr{ t i'ruzu g nu fic r iluiaaar 1. ?o I ua"fra\in1rn1t

fisurnzudcatn tiruru z nu 6eriluiaaau 1.zol orrdrdu Cruuanrrn

Tnt.onrt'r Crutun!fra.rnrz'tfiiinrrCt r eiuoT ts t iruru gg euf,c r iluiaga"

53.40) rs{a\ilriia da.rnrzldflr tfruru 29 nr f,atiiuiaaau 16.2o)

frasnr:nuu tiruru zB nu finriluiaaa" 1G.1ol fra.rnrrrnTeadrrilzuir

n1\r tiruru 1E nu fie rfluiaaao B.eoluasfla{nrruradrfir tfruuu 9 nu

fieriiuiasau s. zol nT uirdu

Page 113: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

.ltDun 5

94

n.trt tnrtorinrriluuularnzT uilf,ud zuildrsdruilziCzsuetair

fiun r rrn ranirlunr z3nn s a run r ! a { rrrorila rHa a dluTc r{n 1in{ fi tnl rr ifi run irirlurd u eonrifi ruua nln r s n r nui fi rurlrrfiilrutttl

rtr'r!?1{ firurrrriar druarstir drrnaerufln fwinafiatritI

-1._.aulto.q-un 1 I ? [ n l1suu'l ltlultut E {n r rtalrtuur tsur 1 tdturlziialzcua r adr!|

lfedu^4{tJfrudruiltnruuil.rdr Taalilnrritnrrsran,t?nanDauluuuffunau (Hultipre

Regress ion enalys is I, ilunrti r nzrorlaare sfiruilrBdrrdre"iiondanrr

nr'rrn,teuTt'tunrrflnr,tUer ra{r1rar'luTnrtnrmdilrut-r

rlrrfr firunfui*uut,i uactlroruanTRrrnrrurifirurlr'lfi firur !M1{ firu

t rr rilar urnfiaa rila.r'le udntfr.,rea raiainirnratfiruilr dnnrirr frr'tuuuu

ira o tn r rufllfiudruuda" ffun ou uagEaTea r?il !a {niudrurlr drf,rurtrd r f,rt

{u uui r a a o u du o ffr." au.r & r iiufi r u rlr difir *.f,rusi a n r r rc r en {t'lun r rElnrr uq zt-t

! a { ?1uar'lu t rn1n z.,r n T nrifi T urlr'tfi u au T 'rr0 tuan r rnTn rrn r ruriilrurlrril

n11r ildauurla.r

Page 114: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

95

dn1?'l{ii 10 [t5te\tnanlrirnzrorioaooasUQor rdarfinouuuntlrnlauistuq{{.n1?cns,tun? ra{?1norfra'rf,aai'tur lo1n?{nrmriilrurhrfi9--rr

!4--.-.q a. ------{- r . .sil1unr$adtu1fl uacz,lrarnorilaaduon[ !q tRrtntruriurut - f ---'' rrlrrfi ilrurr,''?1{ ilrurrT rtar druarsdr rirrnaaruf,n

i''uie afiarrii r fluffrurrrnrs Taa r fiantflfirnarnrdr o*."dilfiaCrfrrunrrafifi

oan.tfl8'lrx?01 R R' Rt, r

'|lflll

5r. tJ. d.

F Sig. F

B Eeta

rtlu?uuo?I

rra'td.d-

l1U',tUnCU

{cnoanTo{

U1\i{1U'lUu<lnt? I tDlt

ir'lilira?ufl113.taCIn1{

n,|tt ntrat..1

n1a{n

.7496

.7790

.8103

.82fJ4

.8329

.5618

.6069

.6565

.6731

.6846

0.5618

o. o451

0. 0496

o. o166

0. o115

-. 244630

.722062

.L97245

.173090

-. 138187

1.861268

-. ?496

.2181

.3329

.5166

-.5864

220.54

131.99

108.31

86.99

76.10

5.99

.0000

. oooo

. oooo

. oooo

. oooo

.oooo

F = 78.10157 (P(.Ol)

Page 115: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

96

rl 1nn 1 I 1',0d 10 fl an 1 ti r n z rurlnao E arilnflsu.i u'fi ru rjrulailr ia{. q

lt

n6['lr1 zn aduranr ruuilTtJz?u[a \rnlruuu n?1rn'laui.r'tunrzilnylun? !a{1'lr3r'lur la1ntsnrru{ilrurlr'tfr uaszlrAruan I !r

" Ias?lraruon MTnr,,rnrzudilrurt.rl r;

srir.rifiadrdrunrtefififrorale s f;euilr Tcairran"rdaaf,ril f,esilrdilaaia

Q?1rn1OXit'lUnrzf,nr,ttlal !0't?1Da?'lur nnlnr{n.lt.t uasugntunTnrt----c-- {^ -.- ^t -- . <an11'r lrnndc Ca frutuunz nairrd'a r iludeuilrutnfinnf;c r fian r frrCuuu

iraa.rilrcu."A. o.rfi".irn?1rn1auit'runrr?lnrrunr ieaa" s6.18-t

( R'=. 56181 frruutdilaf adanrrrnrarnirlunrrfinrrunr zatarurila rra1fid,o-oognataianaunrcrair?unrrilnrruat iaaao 4.81 (Ro*.d.=.o4E1l,drr.nos{ttl .-uiludrurltutniit iT Cuuuitaat sudr firuilrfi.,rda'ritaadanrtlnrauit?unrr

frnrrlnr inaao 60.6e (R'=.6o6el frrurlrd g rfruri {,ruzudiudfir"rrot

ioaa" 4.eG(R"*.d,=.o49G,,drr.ofiuf,ruUrdrtrCuuu{raarf,rd 1 unc

fird z uu'i'r firurlzf;r*rriisadnnrrrnrauir'lunrrtn$1unr iaaau 68.6s( Ro=. 65651 drurl:d c lduri utrrru'lunir r iau iiaaientlrnlnui.r'tunr:f,nnrunt Taaar 1.66 (R"C.d.n =.o1GGl1,drr.lfiuf,rurlrdrfrrCuuuiraa.rfird L zuac s sudr f,rurlzfirdiigadaneuareu{rtunrrilnrrunr

inaao 6?.31 (Ra=.6?91l Hrurlzd s

t

ir'tf{ T a'tunlrgien,t{n1 r r nror{,-- .- - , .! ^---- - -9 --,,.- e -e aiianeianrrucleili{'tuntrGlnrtrlnr isanu 1. ls (Ro*.d.,=.01161 riiarrufiudruurdrilrCuuliraa-rfird t z s uas 4

nrcuirtunrrilnprrnriaaar 68.46 (Ra=.

rrc,tndr,r.du uasnlr?fdrurlrf;.ruln lrrl

.o.Jrl{rsu'l102uuln{u1 rtranSn?1r

nrcuirtunr rrnriaaas 68.46 (Ra=.68461 Csdniaaas sr.E4 iiEa

rrc,tndr rnnI

u asn 1r1fldruilrf; rrue rrilrcu rsri rn rraau iu lln z una re

1.861268 - O.T496X., + O. 2lgLL17 + O. 33ZEXa5

+ o.5156xso - O.5g64XGr

, "duu

o. s 1 uuuiraartuffunau*efi T adrHrrnnrri r nzruriturileuuuuiil;fatt

Ya

Page 116: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

97

n 1 Ta ? ? ? dauuuri 1 a a.r iJ?s r 1$i r a a rrn r rtn rcu it'lun r rilnrrun rr a { I .tr0t'tu t lntR z tn r zu{fi 'rurl'rIi u as ? ,trarua n r lqla r.o n r zudilrurlrf fi

2 . n?1ilurlrilr2uso.,tirnrrrna., , "dur.

iirn.,rdniod r iandr r f,u

lDnnlll (Honoscedasticity)

3. n,r'rrna.", "duud

r fiafruruusialrird{ r nn r iluierrdafiu ( Non

Autoregression )

iirecdr'tfi'lfr uuuiraalilrsrrflir ufa dlnrro"orrd.sdrulrnilrcursir Y'tdsdui,ruasdr r ilafiournila" tun.ri{an{.rili.rrf,rirnrzq??a

eaunordlilfilo.ruuufraat TcanT rirnzrofiarrrnalnredau cudrf,u f,.riI

1 . n 1 ?nr?qdaunr rucnur tuitan .trn rEvlaratirer ,trea1n, "dut

1.1 ett1n Histrogran Standized Restdual su'iTitfrnrs"I

n'lrnrsllarfluuuurlnB tNornality) fisrttil +

lnarirnrrirnrr"ri er.trna,tar"drr. (Residual Anarysis) oasn.tt

i r n tT odn r ufllfiudtgu'i r.,tfi rurlr taaduuui ra s t nf adrnrrncnoadrHq rn

nr:i t nrrtrinrlne nEauunnrqufra.,rinrudlfifi r fiuIrlnruilaana.,l (Assunption )

-{a{u

1 . R 1 ru rrnu r,s ut an 1 rn rc 1 1 s r a si rn r rrna 1c r na{ auiifinrnr r ilu

uruilnfi (Normality)

Page 117: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

98

zud +t Ilietrogran-Standardized Residual udntilnracn,tznrsqla

rarirnrrrnale,.dur. aoruuuiraatilrulnmir nruareuTt.lun r rilnrr uo ? r I { r'ltrot'lu r r nte z tn r zu{ilrud,rrfrilrunfsdcl g rd

I

uasrlraruon I unTnzsnrrradfirurhrfrilrur !1!?1{ firur ar r tae|.aanluarcul atlnaarudn {.rrainafrasrfr

I

Histograq - Standardized Residual

N Exp N (* = 3 Cases, . : = Normal Curve)6 .27 Out **0 .53 3.O03 1.36 2.67 *3 3. 10 2.33 :7 6.35 2.OO *:2 II.63 1.67 'r0 19.09 1.33o 28.O7 1.00

45 36.96 .67 ********s**.*r*14 43.60 .33 *****

178 46 .06 . O0 ************** ; *tt*tt***ttl&*******&**t***t*t*****&**t********50 43.60 -.33 *t****t****fs*.*&0 36.96 -.679 28.07 -1.00 x**6 19.09 -1.33 **8 11.63 -1.67 ***.4 6.35 -2.O0 *.0 3.lo -2.330 L.36 -2.67

ll .53 _3.00 *r**2 .27 Out *

dr", spss/pc+ printout ir*r Reelduale

Page 118: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

standardized, Residuar sudrifrnrs"iaut.rrrfurf,uqrt Hrrld st

udnt Noraal probability (p-p)plot rasirstandardizedResidual raruuui'ras{ilrsil,rrudr nrrunrauir.tunrrilnrrunr

rld st

99

1.2 Qi,tn Nornal probability (p-p) plot larir

ra{?1ror'lur rsTarrnT rradfirurlr'til ilrunfsdlllrd Bacr,trotlg

uon t roTnrrnrnaqifirurlrtfr ilrur !1!r1\i ilur rr r ilar druat

zlrfr drrneatuf,n {tuTeafiasrit

Nornal Probability (P-p) plotStanilardized Residual

1.0 +---------+---------+---------+---------*rit*****tt

r.t&.{

rxrfl* I

obsefved

*

**

{.**t t*tt*!t*t*t**tt** f+---------+---------+---------+---------+ Expected

.25 .5 .75 1.0

+

iftf+

nI!I+

IIf

fITI

.75 +

nft{

.5 +g

iff

.25 +!

dn., spss/ps+ printout irdr Res1duals

Page 119: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

100

z. n'l?q??idauirn rrlurlrilrrula {n?1rna.r, adru

dranrtt f,auntrilrcH'ir{firuilrnrrqrnnrrilrsursiT fiusirnzru---- -4 ..u 4 r i r { {na,lc I aa0u ( ulur ilun1rt1n?g1u) sri,li,lro\in?1una1a lnn'auiinrrnrs?1a

?ou't ir o uasldfitiluuuta.inrrlf,ufiuiduduou udatdrnrlruiliilr?r.ra\t

ude{ standardized. scatterplot rcu'j'l.tfrruilreurrfln'l?rlruurfli'l (pREDl f,u irnruna.r,"*r* (REsrD) la{uuuirna{rl:slrnrir n11rR'rcrristun'rrflntr'tuor !a{r1rar'tur rolnrrnrrudffrurh'tfr firunfrdcugrd uasrlrgruan r tstnrtnrz!|a

u{firurlr'tfr ilrur rl!,11{ firur rr r frar druatsdr dr rnaaruf,nIoao{a1{UXAAnAtIUt

Standardized ScatterplotAcross - *PRED Down - *RESID

irnrrraa.o r ndoufifinrorc, iiu, ann.s f,,rrld e

rld e

3+T{

2+{i

l+f{

O+g

fl-l+

t{

-2+ii

+

t{+

II+

If+

I!+

!f+

II

Symbols:

Max N

. tz.o: 24.O* 48.0

**

-3+ +out ++-----+-- . +-----+-----+-----+-----++

-3 -2 -l O | 2 30ut

**

dn.r spss/ps+ prlntout irdr scatterprot

Page 120: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

101

g. n1?or?ldsun?1u r iluiezudafiurarirn?1ilea1e, "dru

Tcgtflefifi ouruin-t{atson test afnnrzirnrrori srdrir a fiir rrirfiu 0.60l'Iflfl'l? t ilanrtrt'tfrir d* =o. 19 (c =. oE l iioirdfiruesld iiiu,rnn,iri't d- q'lflq1r1$unriiirfisan.jrir 4-d- (4-d,- = g.8tt udctdritnrrnna'le rndaurdinetrf,ufiuffiu Hia r ilu6erudafiu (Non Autocorrelation)

n r r r dsun lruf,ufiu# ruu i r rfr eu rJrdnnrir r trluuuuira a rilzsr,rsir roaqrrn sinple correlation su'irnrruflufiufzrudrtf,ruilrialrs

tfi r fi a ilrur.rr n r rs f,lfiuf z"u d r t fi r u ilr ( t{u lt i co 1 I inear ity I'lun r ri r n r t rfifrara f,.rfrarndudar'tuqrrr.rd 11tt

ari?uzcdudrri4.rrrnfin 6a n'irf,ilrtzclnf*uf,rfiuf#rutd o. z-0.8 ttrririslt

11AO{".r.od 11 udetiT f,lrtroflnf*udrfiufrrudrrf,rurlzi*rodnn I ian r f,rduuu

Correlations: N7 X.t X^o Xoo Xo"

iruruunz (xz)

z'ralfr (x4,').dqrt1u2uneil (x16)drnnnnta{

ur{{'lutxnir r iau

irttira'tun,rrsAn

n1{fl1f l nrgt

1.oooo .gg3g" .?lggtt .Tgz:-rr

. gggg*t 1.oooo . gggl*t .Ezgstr

.?19g** . gggl'* 1.oooo .sgz4*'

. ?968"

.523gt*

.626g**

(x.o).?gz1rt .szgs*r .sgz4t*(xer).?g6s** .Ez3g** .6266*'

1. OOOO

. g562'*. g562rr

1. 0000

Z-taited Signif: * iifiaCrf,drsf,u .o1It{g.-{.-- iifieCrdqilruiu .oo1

Page 121: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

IOz

.leern 6 n,tri r nr'rsf r rliau r ilaucnrra2,rr r iluedruedeuasilrefiu

- d a.___ .|rt .{ d 4 | | .lnrzrtfr Lz n1T- t nrrcl{iara r iliau r riau dRrunrrl r iluaizcu,ir.rfisrHaai

luadn fiuilqrilu ratiltsdrn:niuHaair.ruriilrurlr'(fi ilrunisittt

eturd uatudfiruuanrnttnrrudfirurlrtfr ilrur rr r ilar ilruIrt

r r1!z'l{ druaaruf,n iruicnfiarr{lI

dnrrusfir'1il

HdfirurlT lfrt ilrunfsd*uurrirt

radfi 'ruuantn r rn r rvrdfi rurl T rfrTIU{U

( u1u1 !'t t !E?, u,lul-!?'t{ )

N iaaao N iaaao

I.g

11U?Un{Ul|e

dnrnra.rTrs r iau

rdrdn'ir

ldunndrtfiu

ilcrfiu6ndrI

afnrrrerdnruinrr

L74 100.OO

L74 100.OO

106

68

60.90

39.10

L74 100. oo

L74 100. o0

27

L47

15.50

84.60

g-@q{,

I eilen?1

'tdunndrtfiuaodau?ltrucn21

I

Page 122: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

103

e'r?1{d tz rdar

finuusfirIil

rariilrurl'r'1fr

t fiT unir{asurslr

Hdfi T uus n'[n t.sn r nadil'rurl,rrfrttU.'J

( ulut D1[ !a?, il'lu[ [1!2'l{ )

N iaaat N iaaau

dnrnrat r fiunT .t

nilu'ln&qdr

I AInfl?',I

Iriunnci,r{fru{o4aultuu0n?1t

dnrsla.tic-{aataunn?1

Iriunndrrfiuqsitll11iluen21

i

at-t.-f,R1fl!E{BUA{U1nU

5

169

2. 90

9?.10-1d

L22

62

70.10

29. 90

t74 100.oo

L74 100.00

96

7g

54.60

46.40

162

22

87.40

12.60

146

28

83.90

16. 10

133

4t

76.40

93.60

.a{,tel|an?1

'lduenirrfiu

ilrrfiudn'ir

dntsaasuudrfirrt

l Are n?'l

lriunnirrffu

f,reiiudndrt

Page 123: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

104

o1r1{d tz rdar

dnrruufir'trt

Hriil.rurh'tS.at s a a( u,lunrrE6lltulaB)

u{fi ruuanln r.sn r rudilrurl,rrfrltu{J

( u'lu[ !1t !82,lt1uMt?1{ )

N iaaao N taaau

afnrulornrrldflr

tuudilruqdl

l9l|nn?'l

Iriunneirlfiuqu<lau11UUOn21

I

rratdaniirE{nrail

146

28

83.90

16.10

30

92

52

t7.20

52. gO

29. g0

67

81

36

92.70

46.60

20.70

L74 100. oo

L7

128

29

9.80

73.60

16.60

70

7l33

40.20

40.80

19. oo

nt?-drI C&nnx'l

--f a elt|UnnO,|{nUqudau11UUOn21

I

ag3f a3rann1{n1un'tt

-

r nrnz-a,!tet|cn?1

--aoolrunns,l{nilqg<lrurtluuon,l1

I

Page 124: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

105

i1no1t1{d rz udareanrzirnzT uritararrliaurtau dnrunrz

d r z t fl in ton d r td a'rf, a ai'tua do fr uitc effur s r rtru f, 'r n r n d u f, r a d r .llrd ilrurl rr il

ilruntudalutri rdruarlrir nirrnaaruiln iruTaafiasrfi uasilrci.rnzd

arf,aaduan1nrtntznriilrurlT'tfr iruru e Hriilru 6s ilrudrnmrnilrur lroai

riar siruatcdr drtnaaruf,n i.ruTeafiatrfi uacilrrrtlnrcrnfi'lurrrI

!r'l{ rdruaarudn isuTaafiaari! ilzraa" r dacfirdt

'lut rntcro. f;oou" nau'itdnrslarTt.r r iau'tuflcrfiudnd'renru

uat"ltsriautuadn tiruru 1?4 nu f,nrfiuiaanu 1oo) CruuanrrnTnrr

tut snTRz{n'rrn Cru'tuJti

ilrriiuunsluadn'tduondr.rfiu t irurut

3fl 'lr"r n{}rrcnail'irdnrsro.tttl r iautuodnunsilcrfiu lriunndrrfiu t iruruLT4 eu 6nriiuiaaa" 1oo)

ru'ir dnrrlardnruinnrrarurn'lu

roe nuf,n r iiuiaan, Bo. eo I d r niia

eeu'iraflnruinrruaruratuilrrilu dn'irtuadn tiruru GB nu finrf,uiaaa"I

99. 10I Cruuenr ln1arrntrr drulurinau'irdnrrlaqrlnruinrtaruralu

ilqcilu dn'ir'tuadn tiruru t47 Ru Bnriluiaaau 84.Eol dtuifanau'i'rI

ntnruinrr*r.r".f;oluadn uasilecfiu'tdunnirsfiu

iaaao 1s.Eo)

t{ruru az nu fiariiu

'lu r rnTar{n'r zn Clrturhu'i r dntr r fl$nr tnuutnu'tufl r 1fiudn d T

'tuadntiruru reg nuf,eriiuieaar 9?. lool drnianaudrcnrrfl'rtn{$14rt

'luadnuac'luilccfi$'tdsonirrfiu tiuru E nu finrihiaano z.9ol Cru

uan I lo1e r rn I z.r Cru'luqin a u'i ran,tr! a { t flunr rnlutnu'lunilnuau?uilr 1fiu

Irissncirtfiu tiruru es nu 6nriluisaau E4.eol iltniianaudrdntriu

n1{nrulnl'tuilccfiudn'irluadn t iruru ?9 au 6n I iluieano 46. 40 )

luIartnrrnrifirurlrlfr Czu'tuttf,udr dnrustintuflrlfiusaslut-f

esotdunnd, rfiu tiruru Lzz ev 6erf,uiaaag ?o.1o) druiacaudrdnrr

rs{ietuilccfiudndrtuafie <irs?u sz nuf,e tiluiseao ze.eor lliif,nrus

Page 125: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

106

nfrtafiuuan r rnTnz.,rnrzrda Crutu{nau'ir dnrsratia'luadn [astuilrrfiu'tduendr.rfiu <iruru rlz nu ficrfluiaaao Bz.4ol drrianau,irdnrnnas

icf;sruilrciiufindr'ruafin riruru ez au fierfluiaaao 12.60)

?ut tn1nz{n1?'r f;.rurcnau'ir alnrsraruradtfiT iuruilcqiludnd.l

'luadn riruru LT4 euinriiuiaaao 100) Cruuanrustnzrnrrr Cru'tuqi

aau"i I dnrcl s sun6itfi rfiu'tuaa'nunlr'luilcrfiu'triunnd r tfiu t iruru 146 nu

fiariluiaaar BB.eo) d r u ii a n a u d I dn rr r a .,r uuri .,r fi rfi u't ufl r e fiudn d r.f us 6n

t iruru zB nu fie r iluiaaa" 16. 10 )

'lut lotnr{n1t.r f;tnlnqau'ir cnrsraruurirfirrttuilrefiudndr

lusdn tiruru r74 ev ficrfiuiaanu 1oo) Cruusnrre1arrnrrr Crulrari

oou'irdnrslaturadrfirtt'tuadnuegtuilrefiuldunnirlfiu tfruru 1sB nu

6c r iluiaaau ?0. 40 ) d r ufi an eud r cnrrl a suni rfi rtt'tuilq qfiudn.i rtuodn

tiruru 41 nu f,nrf,uiaaar 28.60)

turreTnr{n1?n Crutnrt ru'ir dnrulasnrr'tdfl,rtuurifirulu

ilqefiuuas'tuafinrriuendr.rfiu tiruru tae nu6erfluiasnu 83.901 drufia

"uu,. dnrr'tdflr'ruilr1iludn'iT'tuac'n tiruru za nufinrflniaaar 16. 10)

Cruuan r rnTnrrn rrud.r f;ono.rru'irrlnrua rnrrldfl r'tuuriffT uluailnun"It

tuilerfiu triunnir.rfiu tiruru t74 e! icriluiaeao 1oo)

?ur lntar{n1?.r Crutnlhudr natfrcni!a{nraueie?uilrcfiu

uas'luan'ntdunnirtfiu tiruzu 92 nu f,nrihisaau Ee.90) ra{a\tr,tnou

'irzratfraniretnraunie'tuf,crfiudn'ir'tusde tiruru oz nuficriluieaa"It

29.eo) uaerlatfranitatnzeunir?uadn dn'irtuilrcfiu rfruru go n$

finriniaanu lT.zol nudrdu Coiifinrsrrduriarfiu uonrrnlarrnrzriis Crutilrisaudr rT a'adanila{niarnfetueiin unctuilccfiu ldunnirlfiutfruru 1zB nu icrfuiaaac ?g.60) ra{a{rlneudrrralfrdnirarnrau

nirtuitcrilufiniTtlafin tiruur 29 nu finrfluiaaar 16.601 unurralfr

dnirarnraunir'lusdn iin'irruilccilu tfruru rr au finriluiaaar e.Bo)lt

nudrdu

Page 126: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

to7

Cru'trartsu'iraraaiCInl{n1? r nrnr'luflcrfiu ua!,?u t rnTn r \i fl 1 T.r dru'trartsu.j r ar aai CI n 1 { n 1 ? [ rl

luadnlriunndr.rfiu tiruru gr nu n'erfu?aaao 46.60)q{{l

arns{tiqnr.,in'l? r nrqrtuaon dn,iriuflerfiu t f turu sz nuI

6a r fiuiaan"gz.Tq) [asarnrudnnrtnrrrnrqr'luilrqfiu a'n,irtuadn tiruru ge nu fiat fiuf osac zo.7ol nrreirdu dofi;n"ri"lnffr fia.rfiu uon r rnTnrtnrrr iia

drutraqie au'i ralaatfi qn1 {n 1 ? t nrn r'tuodnuaofle rfiulduqndr sfiu t iruru z r:-.4 tt . qnu doriluSaaac 40.80) ?a\in'rrlnau?'l runruaqn1{n'ttlnrnrluadn dndr

1uilr1fiu t iruru zo nu fio r iiu#aan" 40. zo ) uasunara'nnr.sn1? r nrflTI

luflr1fiufin'ir'tuadn riruru gg nu 6qriiufaano le) nud.rf,rI

ta10{fl{il1nau?1

,.".0d 13 udetwarufindo'rd raofirdlanlurrqrnz.snrzudfirurlrtff uasI

uon I rntnttnrnarifiT urJrtfrI

tilefirdilan 'lut rn1nt{fl1T.4.4o-dilanI1n r uuauoilnt

uofl r tnTnr.cnttr.4u-dunflr1n I iluauaunI

uaarlndotd

t fitaniu l

frT r'tso, #a.rfln{

taa

frudrrlsrltfi.,r

ilTrurf;l

ilT rrilT .r

.!dn? [ [82

flTa.:{fl? l r4AA{

.loo?a6t{

L

2

3

4

5

6

7

4

2

1

3

6

5

7

I

266. OO

5,937.50

2,744.63

203. gg

203. 50

97.67

188. 75

139. 80

141. 67

du. : 6udafrfrn1z r nrnr d'rfin.rru r crugfien1r r ntrot

Page 127: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

108

in{rlr nrrilanilrI

dn8un 7

I

dq'l11{n L4

ficnnil a s rrrgri an r rauinfnfra,rn rrhlirf udu uasi a1n rrnr ruriilrurlrlfr

u do { ss frilfi cuafi n a.r r rr4 rtu1n t,r n r tra{fi rurj,rf fr u as ? 1ra ruan r snTn r tn r rradfi rurlr't fi d an rrrr.;if A, irt.

rsdufiounfi 'lut rnTnt{n1?"1I

( TAgAs )

uon I nnTnttntzrU

( ?a8as )

fi*unfirda'air.rio

fisunfirrid

fi*unfirtrunn,t\i

fieuntsd

fieunfidrurn

to.92

LT.24

66. 67

5. 57

8.62

2L.26

28.7 4

27.OL

L4.37

,r.od 14 ude{rsfiufi*uefi lo\ir1ra?dorflaai.tur re1nr.,r

nrt{m.rqjffrurlr'tfr unsr'rrotdarf,aaiuan r rqTnrtnrnedilrurtr'tfr danrrt-rl

a4inf ilo {rl'r r doft cr zfl 1? 1nn1 11.,rudr suir rtatda'rf,a si'lu r rnTnr{n1 r{curiil.r.rlrrficru'trait <iruru 116 nu fie rfluiaanu 66.6?l fifieunfidfi;,

nrtauinff,nirlr ta.rnsrrilfi*uafirsduilrunart riruzu go nu 6crfluiaaau L7.z4t fifi*unfidrrid tiruru 1e nufierfuiaano 10.e2l uaoificunfi

dfiu.n t{ruru g nufinriluioaar 5.\zl nuirdu drurtordardaaduon

rreTnrtnrrieurifiTurlrrff dru'tuqi tiruru so nuie riluiaaa" zs.z+l iifiaunfitcffuilrunartrdan'rraufndf,n{rl', rarnsuriifirunfidd tiruru 47 e1rt

fre r f,uiaaao zr .oD iifieunfidrrid t {ruru gz nu Ba r fluiaaar zt.z6,fifieunfidfirrn <i'ruru es nu 6crfiuisr", 14.sn ua"iifirunfidrric'air.r

do tiruru 1E nu finrfluiaaau 8.62l nrudrdu

Page 128: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

{fi1?1{n

109

15 u de {fl an 1 Tnedaun ? 1il$nnd 1.,r zou'i r'ri r r adaficunfi r o o z.rardarf,aai?u1nz.rnrz{ararifi.rurJrrfr il.runf*drlurnl ouor."6rda rfl s o duanTn r tn r rierarifi rurlrtfi ilru r E 1 D'l r tunofi ru r r r r fr a a

tdonrraufnf f,n{tlr

a

nailt 11U'lU.d

R1 t OnA s. D. t P

radfirurl'rrilt

ay14t|il1UUAn-t

Tnrrnrr

L74

L74

2L.27

18.63

3.98

5.93

4.88 <.01

dg.r{uua6t,lnrunrtse il .01

o.nn.r.od rs uu.ir fieunfitdan'rrsuinff,n{rJ.aaorrrarderf,asd

luTn t rn r r{erldfi 'rurh'tfi ilrunind*r,urnl nir r."orda rfl a a riurnr", on. Iicu{fi rurlrtfr itn r ruunnd r rfiuo i r.,rltfi adrdrunr tdfifi drsdu . o 1 tear.rra?t

darHaoiruTnr'$nlrieudilrurlrtfr firuniud*uu:d fificunfidddanrrauinfItt9

frn{rJT 6a fin"uuuirrodao{tudr.r zL-zs Crurrrardorflasiuontnrrnrr

{erariilrurlrrfr iificunfi'turcduil'runarr denrrauinfflnirl'r 6o iln"uuuirtl

r odaaritudro 16-zo

Page 129: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

{n1z1{n 16

110

u da { rcdufrduofi n a.,r r 116 zluTn r t n r tudfi rurlrrff u au r1u0r

uon I nqTn r tn r rradfr .rurl'r't fi d an r z ouindrlrtfr

:cfiuficuafi 1ut nqTsr\in'lr"lv

( T0aas )

uan [ trn1nr.snrtru

( TnSAs )

ficuaArdn'ad'r.rfi.,r

ficunfiyrin'

ficunfirJruna,r{

ficunfia'

fisunfidurn

6. 90

L7.24

68. 96

6. 90

17.24

43.68

24.7 L

L4.37

o.nr.r.od 16 uatq.{rsffufieunfi na{?'lrardorflaari'tur rqrnr*r

nrt{orarifirurlrtfi uas?lrardarf,ao{uan r rnTnr.rnrm{firuilr'tfr sinnrr

,u;nfrt.rfi r dofi c'l rrx,r q'rnn 1 ? 1.ruff r'*u'i. "."6rdr.al, 6'ru r nn1n r.cn r r

ierariilrurl'r'tffdrulurt rdruru Lzo nu fie rilu?aaau 68.e6l fifi*unfidr';t

nrrauin$rhrfr ?s{a{!1 ilfieunfir"fiuilruna'rr <irueu go nu fie riluiaaac t7 . z4l fifieunfidrdo' t,iruru Lz nufie r iiuiaaau 6. eo I uaulifieunn'

do'u.n <.iruru Lz nu fiarfiuioaar 6,901 nuirdu crurt6zdorf,aad

iteunfidrrie' tdonrrouinfrjrrfr ?o{a{lr1 ilfiaunfircf,uilrunar.s tiruru

uant nnTnt'snrt{era{firurh1fr Cru'traqitiruru ze nufierfiuiaaar 4s. 68)

U?aaas

n1oil

4s nu fie ,flu{aaa" 24.Tr, ilfinuefidrridairsi..r riruru go nu fiarfuL7.z4l unrilficunfidd rfruru zs nu fierfiuiaaar t4.sr) o1r

Page 130: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

d0'lT1{n

111

r? u da {u n n 1 r no do un ? 1 r u o n 6i'l r z rra'i r rr ri,r r od a fi gunfi r o.r r -rrq zd

arfraod'tuTn:rnrrior,'riilrurjrrfr firunindeurrr$ ounr.,*6rd

a r Ha a riua nTs z r n r : fioud fi rudr't ilfi 'ru r r 1 f, ? 1 \iu n ofi ru r r r r fr a rsian ,r raufndrlrrfr

do.-duruaSllefuntsrou . 01

'luTnrrnrriouriilrurlT rfr il,runiudallrul

..nn.r.od rz nu'ir figunfidanrzauinfrJrrfr ro.srtqrdorf,aoi

uas ?'lrarda'rf,a aiuanTn rrn r riaradfirurjrtfi finruuqnsir{fiuair.rfifiadr6onT rdfifidrrdu . o1 rearrrard a rfl a a iruln r.c n r z{mad fi rurl'r'lfr ilrun iu iclrrt:nlttr

dg. qd<r o 4rnf,unnnenanll0u?nr

rlrrfr n'a iincuuuir r adaaqitude.r zt-zs CrurtardaT flaaiusnTnr{n.l:

{aradfirurlrrfr ilfiaunfirrid tdanrzaufnfrl.rril 6a fiaruuuir r sataadtu

dr.,r 11-1s

a

nnilI

11U?u,{

R',l I ona S. D. t P

radfirurlrrffc

a9tlttlt'luuan-T

Te r.onrz

L74

t74

21.66

14.5L

3.85

4.73

15.47 (.01

Page 131: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

.ln1t1{n

LL2

u da { rcfiufidunfi n a t z rrartuTe z s n r ruriff .rurlrr ff uac rlra?uan r roTe r r n r narifi 'rurjr't fr d a n'r :ilanrlrdru du

rsrfiufiAunfi lut nnTnt{n'l?"rv

( ?aaac )

uan t rnTntrntzrv

( TAAAg )

fiauafirddarir'rir

ficunfirdd

fiaunfiilruna'l{

fiaunfid

figunfidurn

5.75

18.96

32.76

40.23

2. 30

L2.64

47.70

23.56

13. 23

2.87

o.no.r.od 18 udetrsfiufiounfi f,a{x'lrardarHaorirursn1nr.,r

nrriorarifi'rurlT 'tfr uac?'ruordorfraaduan r un1nz.rnrzra{firurlr'tfr sian'lr

rtanrhriru r dafi r. r*'rq 1fl n 1 r'r sufi r "nu'i.

r.rardr.ar, {'ru, rnTn r.snrr

{ararifiTurl'r'lfr dau'turt tiruru zo eu fierflu?oaar 6G.Gz)do - cdqrnf,unoile

18

sianrzilanrlrdrdu ro{a{tt1 u'ficunfiz"duilrunar{ (i1il?u sz eu fe rfiu

?asar sz.?6r iificunfidrilo' r iruru gs nufic r f,uiaaao 18. e6l iifi*unfi

drde'arirri.r tiruru 10 nufierf,uiaaao E.?sr ua"fifigunfiddrrntiruruqAu4 nu de r iluf aaas, 2. 301 nrrrirdu rdqdrurrrazfroT daoiuan r seTn:{n1T

ficrfluieaa' 4r.7or ifiaunfidrddiaurifirurh'tfi deu'turii ( iruru 83 nu

rdanrzilnnrlrt'ldu ?E{n{r1 iifigunfirufiurlrunar.s tiruru +t nu ficrilu

f;aaao zs.s6r fifieunfidd <iruru zg nu6orfiuiaaa, ls.zsr fifigunfid

rridaiT .rC{ ( i1u?u zz nu6e r iiuTaan, Lz.B4t uaoiifieunfide'lT n t f ruruadrl5 nu ne [ililTE8a!' 2.87 ) 01iln'lnil

Page 132: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

dn'l?1{n

113

19 udo {fl an 1 rnodaun ?'rxuond 1 {Tsu'j 1 rd r r odafidunfi n a or."6rdarfraadluTer{nrr{oradfirurlr'1fr firunfisicuutnl u"rr."arda T f, a a riua nTo e t n r tioradilrurl'r't frfi ru r f, 1 n ? 1 tu arfi ru r n r r iia rcian rrilnnrlrdtdu

a

t{u?'lq1nn1?'l{n 19 tfu?.1 nCunsin

Tn rr n r riorarifi rurl'rl fr fi runfsdarur,$ ttas, r,trards rfl a ariuanTn ztn r rintt !I

ra{firurlT rfi fine'ruunndr.,rfiuoirsfifiadT f,run'r.refifidzudu . o1 Tnazrrozdt|

arflaariturn:tnrtiorarifirurlrtts il'runftriruurr$ fificunfituruffuijrunar.,r

11-15

sian'rrd.rrd?lnrrrlonrlT illdu 6o ltnouuui'rrodaaitudr.,r 16-zo Cru{a.rrrariia rda niuanTnrtnI r{eudilrurl,rf il

tl

rjandrdrudu fia frnruuuir r adaari'tudr.rtlr

fifieunfidrrid donrrC.r r d?rnrt

a

nnilq

iruru ,{n1 [ oaa S. D. t P

r,lrifirurlrrfr,

r9lltlU'lllld0fl-

I

Tnrtnrr

174

174

18.87

14. 93

5. 35

D. 25

6.95 < . o1

ds.-{ailusfl1niln?sou.o1

fi*unfidanT zilqndldu ra{rlrorda,rHaa{'ru

Page 133: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

dn'lT'l{n 20

lr4

u do s r c 6il fi dua q' r a t z r 16 rt uT n r t n r su d fi rurh y ff u a s, z.l u0 ru 0 n r n q T n r t n r rud fi r ulJ r't ff ti a r n r.r n r : {era d fi .rurJ.r.t fr

zsfiufiauefr tur rnTRt{n.l?"r

< #aanc )

uon r gqTnrtnt:ra,( ?oaas )

fidunArildorirsf,s

fi*ucfirdd

fiouerq'rjrufln1{

ficunfia'

fiaunfidlr.rn

6.90

6.90

75. 86

10.34

L4.94

43. 68

25.29

L4.37

L.72

n rrior,rdfirurlrtfrt

nT z{orarifirurlrlfrI

{-u3 t| AUi 1 ?011 1'lnn 1 ?'l \iIA 2

l1no1r1od zo uda{zsdufieuafi ro{r1ra?darf,aadrurrqtnrrda

u ns, ? 1ra?fr a rfl a o iuan r rn1n :.rn r rudilrurlr'tff d a1n rs

urir r."grdr.f,aoi'tur sn

lnrrnrr{ara{firurlrrildru'trart tiruru Lsz nu fiariiuiaanr ?s.86)

ncunfidfi daTnttnrr{ara{ilrurlr'1fr :asatrriifieunfiddrrn <iruru 18 nu

fiorflufnann 1o. s4) fifirunfidrria' ti,ruru Lz nu ficrilu{aanr 6.eo)unsn'fiefuofitursduil1ufla1{ tiruru Lz nu fie ,fiuiaan" 6.901 nudrffudrutt0rdarfraa;iusnranTnr.rnrr{crl{ffrurh'1fi drurrart riruru ?6 nu

forfiu{aaau 4s.68) fifirunfidrdd tdaTnztnrriaradilrurh'til ?0{a{r-r

fifigunfittfiuilruna'r{ (i'luxu 44 nu fie rfiuiaaar 25.zsl iifi*unfidrria'

arir.rCs tiruru 26 nu fie rf,uiaaar r4.e4l in*unfidd tfruru zs Ru

fiqriiuiaanr L4.srl ua"n'fieunfiddrrrn rfruru g nufieriluisaau z.ET,n'lila1sil

Page 134: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

d01T1{n

115

2 L tr do {l,ra n 1 rno da un ll r u q nd 1 { Tsu d'l .r i r r q da fi eun fi o, o r.rq rdarfiaai'tuTnr.rnrr{eradfirurlrrfi ilrunffudruur,$ ur"r.rarda r fr a o riu a nre r.r n r r{ouri fi rurl r't ff il1u r tr'l ! ?'l ru n r fi ru r n r r ila roi aTn z.r n T z{aradilrurl rrfi

,fl4il

I1'lu?%

rda1 t oa8 S. D. t P

r,rdfirurlr'tfig

luuIUlUilAn-t

In:rntt

t74

L74

22.63

14. 99

3.72

4.85

t6.47 <.01

ilfiadrdrudzsdu . o1

..no.r.od 2L ul'ir ficunfidarnrrn'lr{eudfirurlrtfr larrtgrda rda o ri'tu r rnTn:.sn r uradfi rurlrtfi fi runfsirruznl uas r1s0?da,rHa a ;iuan

t nnTn t'sn r tu{fi rurlrri lln r ruuenn'r.,rfiua i r.rfifiadrdrunr.rrfi fi dtsfiu . o 1

Ie a t rr6zd a T Ha a qi'tu r r nTn z rn r rrad fi rurh't fr fi run in jen urnl fi ncunfi ddsi oltr

Tn:rn r rinudfi rurh'tfr fisinouuuir r odaa;itudr.,r zl-zs drurrrazdarf,a

a duan r nnTn r.sn r rndilrurlrtfrIt.{,{ilnsuuuFt1 r oaaai'tudet 1 1-18

I

iifisunfid'tdd darez.,rnrr{enriil.rurlrrfr 6a

Page 135: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

onnt s

Crrlsan r ri f auar, fr a r cuouns,

11nuan1?flnrralrjlddr ndlfirsdr.,r qrnTnrrnT znrifirurlrtfr

cruiurifirufirnraunirrilur*J0." fir.rjdarrd.o go-gg it ourir.r,od,lll

rrirfiu 3e.54 il Ceun{rfirairtrrnu{ilruuanTnrrnrzu{ilT urlrrfr Cau'turt

rscrira fiarqa{tud..r'ro-r, il nuuir.r,"drrrirfiu ,i.ro il f;o*uon,iu9 I I -- - -- i--

dru'tHrtfiufiacrdurtnr uaslfriunT rflnrrturufiutlzcnu;lnrr r du r darfiu

,.rar'tJ, rq1n:tnrzu{ffrurh'lfi Cru'tr,tqiuds.,rru uasadfirafru

fiunrrarHiiaerii iunrdorid.r,"l, s.44 nu linzounirdarflasiriufiu.tr.rr-ilrursda 1.19 n:ounir uariidrT iiln'lunirriaur"d, s.44 nu cruzruor

usfl r rn"tn : rnr rudilrurlr'tfr CrutuRiud { { 1u uac a riHr af,ufiunrra ruia arit

fiuqrdadd.r,*d, z.os nuiinrarntrdarflaairrufiu'tufiruroda r. ro nirttr

r iau uncit*rrilntunir r isur oda 4. 06 nu

luttnTnt{n1tn drutrani iinidrrurrf,lifef;rarrrrni.ru{edutcaasarr,tl,tn drtnofiunr {ruieilaurn drrnaarearr {luicunrgzztdairtnafiruud ;.tnaTnnCrTz.l irrnaf,aulc'ln {luiaarui drtnatnrdfin

drtnauuotfirtctur {.rraintani finrrfrrauauarflaa{dfrraurfiu g tfiau

,od, z.u ,4o iruau ?41 ra{nrzadarf,atuurifi.ui".fiu 1-s il iirun

,ud, t'ru T e ituHdilruitqrfiu fi a rdildiu;rfiuuac i'i rn1 {n ,r rec {n*rrdiu'rfi'turrluiilrurlr'tfr r iluCru'turt uactdfrron.rd"ofiradu iiriidnnE" r dur dartT

fiu uantrnTnttnrrr Cru'lusriinidrrurrir fia frrarrc'rn{tuicdu iin.rr

firauaiddu r,.rrriun'ir 3 rder.,oada z.68 r*o iir"aulxal rornrra{I

drrluec aiilrrauan r ri{a

Page 136: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

tL7

orf,a'tuudfiruflrcfiu l-s il ilrn"""f,r frrlrai'tunriilruflcrfiu fia rurfidfia.r4arsau f,ndrurrnd uasCru.tunrirrifra.rnrrffradu

rrr, oiror{n'rr"r dru'rurfifrnuflsnlr'rffdfiu r.r1.rnfl1?rdiunrz

iodrr Taa?uadafrnrziianzaodfiua{ufrr,*da"rauairas 9. 28 .t.i :rrufirt

'tuilccfru n'nrzfianz.odfit, o.to"ruu"ira!, 21. 09 rd iitCzu.trartfinrru r fiu'i rdduruf, r cfiuff sr d r fi a.rwa u rin a rdrfi uu au fi n r r.fi , o n. rdfi ,.

ae zE.7z'td isrc rfiatuaurinrzri,rfiufr,lun,.?r ntrernrru

fra.,tn',zdqro.rdfiu'tun*"fi druuan r nnTn?{n1r.l Cru'tnrt ruilfinrsunrtrfrdfiul rte sn r z{uea r'tuae'niin rrfi an zatddua iudr r odan raun iras T . o 4

't d r uu fr rluilq rfiufi n r tn'an r a.r diu r oa{ae ra un irns 10 . 6e r i iirdru.trart{1rd.iinrrs tuu'i'r iliu'tufle1ffudrrd rita'rraurinrrrirfiu uauilnrufrernrzdiu, o"tr"urunirar, 25. 26 Id isrr tilaruaurinrzrirfiu tnaCru.tunitrifia,rnrrddq!nls!1anau-(u!0tsu

q,lnn'l?nasfaunrtlunntdrt rrn'irrir,"dr ouofiudiirnra{ !o{r ru6 r'tu'tn z tn r :rndfi rurlrril fi runiuiar uzri fiur rrgrnrifi ruuan'tn r,tn 1 rudilT udrt$ fiT urE'lr?1\i uaoilrurrrriar su,ir ot."fit dfiaere.t,odrouo

,."q"dr.f,asd'tu r rq1n rrn r :uriil.rurlrrfi uas r."6rdr.fla aiuanTnr{n1 rra{fi rurJrrfr itn r ruunnd r rfiua d,r,,riifi ac.rf,runr tcfi fi dru f,u . o 1 Tn a !u."$rdI{ddoRta t t odaI a s rrrgr'lu r rq1n rtnr rH{ilrurlrtiliir rnn r'r nu.rilt diian ?a {t

d{r oda I a r r rugrfr a rf,a a duan'tn r tn r narifi rurhlfr

rr1nn1?naeiu...nnnndrs zrud'r.ri.rod, nro$r.dtunra{ !E{r rrqrluTn r's n r zrariilrurlT'tfr ilrunisi*u gt,i fiu rt6 zuriilruuantR r {fl 1 rudilrurlrrfi ilrurnln..o uaofirurn.,;ri tuodq uudr nr.."$r.dfianrat

, "d,

n, o rrrazda rfla o{?u r rnlnrtnrna{fi rurlrrfi ualr r.rordu.flaa dusntla

TnzsnrrudilrurJ'rrfr ilnr rrunndr sfiuairtiifigCrftunrtcifi drsf,u . ot Tea{dc d- {.

suraCuildaR r a { I sda'luae-n r a { ? lror'tu r rn1s r rn r rurifi rurl'rlil itu rnn d r{ .l{turnriuidon ra { r gda'luado tr a { t'rratda rHa a iu, nt., ln. rurifi rurlrtfi

r adan:aunir

re aCrutu6ttd

Page 137: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

118

i 1 n n'l ?nn dorn r r run nd r.s zru r' r.,ri' odr...ufr ,.r n. rdfi uri,riur 0 { r'lno ?'tuln t t n r turifi rurh't S il'run iv,iruu",i fil r rrgzurifr 'ruua nTn z rnrzuriilrurlrrfr firur !1!2'l{ uarilrur rr r iar uyi.r 'triiinlruunntirsfiuo ri'r.r ifi a dr firun.r .r rfi fi

lurrnlnz\rn1ra dru'ruqi fiartnudn fia fl1?rnrn?fli?r uariia r tr t s.l 6 s f u{r',r drutuqin'dnrils, n r rl ffu r t t ru1e a n r rttu z.r.r rutun r o u

gynirfr'lr,|rre rota'quriia ttur.c'rru'lunrarnir uaotrtfiduilr.-r rilaiirdlando r r d-- J

,. Ifrfnrrudrfiru unciil?urrulrndqe r ia'srrnrrnlrha'rfisa rduri trrtua,f,rof,n{ ffaa ffucrrJuudo ff..u.it trrdr.r fir r iiar uarilra Cruuan r ae

Tn:tnrrr ila dru'turi cuioriluufrnnrrnrzrnrornr?r uaniarinrar 6a

iuirt r dur daefiufiulur roTnzrnrrr Ceu'lu.i fiilnrsunrflilurtrruTe In r rltu tt's rulun raun irf; ,,ruue xo {a {r't iia'ttu zs s rutuntaun iruac ir.l^q4^-^q- - .a {.d . d.r . sqdufrrt lilefrriirjanfiiineT uCT fiq uaufirlirrnurndte r iatcrnulnrilurfisa.t;un fiucrrjcndt taa ilrrurit fiu f,ar fl'ra dlrafia.r ua"ilrir.r

?ur rn1nr{n1?a deu'tuJtiiir'tiliT a'tunrzsisrrrrnnrrt snd.

ilfinrsrnrtitadraaaE6n Ie anrrdrrlC.rdefrr'tur iie.,rfrranur a.r r iluCru.rrart

Te aesrii I trufi rd r t'u r'Lfin 1 :uusrir r da eilun r rniln rru Cruuan r rnrersnrrdrutuni c sili r'tili t atun r ralfi nu rr r nn r rfir rnriafr rnuna r.,r uaufrndrarncin

'tild.r'tfid afr rlu r ila.!dr aqu r e c

rrlnn'rlncdaunrruunnir.,r rrHdrri'r r sdarra'afr4ni !a{z1ralI

'luTnrtnr:udfirurhlfr ilrunicirrurd fiurrrgrurifiruunntnrrnrrudilrurJT ril ilrurr1tr?'r{ unlrilrurrrriiar su'ir rratdenidsil rarnrordarf,aa ri'tu r rnTn z tn r :rarifi rurlrrfr ilur T raznds rda s iuanTn r t n r na{ilrurlrrfr inrrlunndr.,rfiu aiT .riifiaCrdrlnrseifidr"f,u .01'taarra'tfr*nircda !a{

i

rtar'lu r rn1n ztnr ru{ilrurlrril 6.,rn dr rratd4ni, "donu.rrrrgrda,rfla

aittr

uanrntsnrtudilT urJrtfr t rraldeni r odadeit ro{r'lrar?ur aoTarrnrruri

firurlrrfi rriT fiu 14,1ss. s1 u1n ua'?rarfr4nirodaiait tra{rlrordarf,aI

aiuon1nr.rnrtariilrurhlfr rrirfiu 11, 996.61 u1n)

Page 138: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

lur nernr{fl'lr"r crurraqiilnrz r trirufirnrrr?unrir rnc. uacd{qurrr-.-a'

r roiiilrur,rrdruoir.rl estfriui'rrjinrr ?1n r t.rufirdna.rig cruuan r roTnr{n'l?'l drulur[esldrna r frrdriliqnrrilte "l uas r u{afiitrurartut'rudr.rt rc.tfriuirrt?nrrc1nfl1fi dfiro

'lut noTnr{n'l?"r fitrt r iaurlrci, Hdfiru unruarud-ru1u n r iauufi',riladrrs t iauilzcirudil'ru'rfi dru?urtiinzrrnraraT{drc'tfiuorr {aur,lfirtacilturcfruortrflnrr doornd.o.ir1fl uan r nntnrtnr:r 6a dorriirro r iaurtzsirrldfiru Cru'tud qnruaru rs'lil'Ir'rriaulrriilru'tnfrrdas uas dru.rrari

c r iln r r r n r ara {.,r d r r t fi un z, i o u" ufruil : s n r fl n yltur rnTnz{n1r.r crutuqiiiutairfir dttrunrroiltna uiTnn 6a

fi rduuarrfi rrtrlrrtrq rn d r r r fiufi rruu{fi .ru cru'tnrtrdfi ilruu,r, {, oi. Cruuan

r lnlnttnrrr Cru'tu4iruliurai'rfirdrftunrrarltRn uitnn iia crnfirduua"

fi ... n n rifi r ei r n a a.o Ie a Cru'tnrric "uufl.uu,r

uud ofi .r a ir n nfi ru

?ut rnTnz{n1xn Cru'lnJtiiraia.,rlf, unodrdruranrrrdsnrn 6a

inq to{nwl fia tninzaru iirnfrrafiruanrroTnrrnrn drulnolcsii

rn{a.r'tflua"drd'rueanrrraluarn iia ina uauzn{nraru

tut ncTnz{fl11a dru'tr,lrrirctdunrr aanuanuriilruf,rlarri.o"*o

rcaenruddin.u tdunrr'trl fia f,rd'r rnnnruf,n Cruturt iirnaudrcadrrr ilu

wruuultrn,tr t iuaanuonuriffru alnlun'lr r iunrtnuues'tdd r srrugnefu druil8n I rn"[n :',rn r z"l Ceu'luoiec r fiun r r a anuennrifi T uf,rJe rrinon *t te aeo.r,d

dfrn.otfiunrtril dnf,rdrrnsa'luiln rdufiu dzutuoirutil{nraru,iiu".nuolunrrrdunrt uasdnrsnuutrideaaeil

119

uacu.rr'r r srrrnluilr Crutuqirfiudrrtilrnr

Cruuan r ln1nr.cnrzr Cru'lurtc".tilifur iiu

Cru'turtesliurai.rdlrtrI{r ila,*io iia nr r srqrndr uasCtu'lHitinrril rfiu'ir rlirrsr ila rsirtuilcqfiu i..rnriirfi'rilair.r

?urrqTnr{n1:'r crurfftrtrtarwir'tunrrnrfrr iia iluuauriru---,!. -, { { {tngiluila{ I tE tua{l'tnn,tl tor ilo rrit'tuilrrfiu isirila{se

urila ruir'tunrzrlrfrr D1yr1t

{tca.l[a

Page 139: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L20

lur snTer{n1r"r drururtfruuri.rd,rrd.rr 6a inq unsdau.turifra.,r

n r tdq o lfi fi r uil'rr ft ur.rd fi r u z a { a r r r n' o ff 0.-r n r r't fifi n r rC'r r tr?ldrua r ils r a,r

*o r dur 6arfrufru uafl r raTn:tnrrr drutuqi ruiuradrd.rrdrrrrnina uncI

dru'turtfra'rn r r'tfifrn r tC.r r atrff ruo rtura'r I a {a {rr 1 fi a fia.,rn r z.rfii.trffl rrfltuurifrru

q lu .d {n r ri r n r rcfi tor a r iliau r iiau dnrun r roir r.,rilin zru'ir.rdo rf, a o i

1uadnfiuih1fru na{?lro?'rur nnTnr{n,lz.r fiu:rroruan r anTnr{n1zn".-$TIAAs I AEOO{U

lut lntnr{fl1?a fituto nnu'irdnrsnatr:.,rr iautuilcqfiu dndrtuafre cruruni naudr dnruaatdnruinrruarrra.tuodo uarilrcfiu rduqnsir.tfiu dnrutffunt'snturnr'luflrcfiu dn'ir'tusntn dnrsra.sie.luadnua!,

ilcrfiu'ttiunndrtfiu aln,trls.rur,ld.rilrfiuunrurui.,rfirtil .tuflerfiudn,i'rtuodn

dnrurotnrrrdflriuudfiru'tuadouacilrcfiu lriunndrtfiu C.lururii nau,jrz'r a'tdenB n a {n r aun ied aihuadfrq uasilrqfiutdunnn'rl

trst

fr n0'l {nu uacef ngei'gn1 {n'l Ir nnnr'luadnuacilcefiurdunndrrfiu druuan r untnrtnrrr fiouo, qou,ir

dn rnl a tT t t t iautuae'nu asrilqefiu'tdunnd r.rfiu dnrur a r dn ruinrrsa 1 il1 n

'tuilr c ilu dn'j rtuodn afnrsr s r r fiunr tnuurnu'tuadnu asilerfiurriunnd r sfiu

dnrunotia'tuadnuacilcrfru'tdunndr.sfiu Ceurun! dnrrraruurirfirfiuuno

uHri..rfi rt fl 'tuaEiou asilq r fiur dunnd r.,rfiu dRtsr a rn'r t'tdf, r?uuriilrutuadn

uasflcrfrulriunnd r sfiu dru'tnni zratfr*nir a tnroun ir'tuodn uac.luilrefiu

1 riu nn d r.rfiu u nsoaainn 1 \rn 1 I r nrn rtuadqu asrilre fiutriuend r tfiucrnnrtflnrr t rliar t iiail:cdufieunfi !s{?lraldarf,aairut rs

rn z tn I tiar,r{fi 'rurl'rtfr fi ur tozda rHa a {uanTn r rn r r{nurifi 'rurlrtfi d an r r| '---- - touinff,n{rlr uudr tur rntnz{n1?"r Cru.trari iimcunfidddanrzarlinfAn{rh

re afitsduncuuur odaficuni r rirfiu zL.zr d,rairudr.rre{nrrif*u"adddunrrauinffrn{rlr Cruuanrrotcrtn.rn C.urri ifi*unfirrdurlrunarcgienrzaufndf,n{rlr Teafi:lrfiunsuuurodafi*unfi rri.rfru 18.6s iita{.rud.r.r

ro.rnT :itfiCuefilurcf;uilrunnrt sianrrau;ndf,n{rht

Page 140: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L2I

uu'jr t'rtardr'',fiaadturuqTnrtnrzfourifirurl.rrfi drutrart ilfiaunfidd sianlzauindrlrrfi ruufircffunyuuuradafiounfirrirfir 21.66 iioadtudrsnotnrtfifisrusfindd oianrsaufinfrJrrff drur116rdarf,aaiuon r En

Tn r r n r z iararifi rurJ r't ff drulraqi fi nauufi drdo' si a n r r *oirft.,r; ;;;;;;;evu%u,*otrfiwuufr rrirfiu 14. sr doadtudrooron.rujfieunfidrdd oion.rz

u 4 t --u0uTnril1'1rJ

su.i .r r. "q,

nt, .r fi s a ri1 u r r o r a r t n r z ia ud ilr urj.r.t fi

fiaunfidd sionrrilanrJT dudu trlfirrffrneuuur odafiaunfi r rirfiuadtudr{ro{fl1? fifieunfitu rsffuilrunars sianrrrlanrl.rdrdu

orfiaaduon r rnTnztnT :ieradilrurJrtfrcrutrarf{aanu 4T .To

sianrrilanrlT dldu regirsfiunsruuur odafigun& r rirfil 14.9sltl

Ceu'trast fi

18. Bz dor.dfl?uT'lro?n

fifisunfidrda'

d.:aitudrsu a rnrrilfiounfi drdd sion rrilnnd.rrrru

sl'ir t.tgrntr.daari'tut nnTnr.rnrriararifirurlrlfi druluqi fi

fiounfi do'd arn t t n r z teudfi rurJ.irr, oUrc fiuncuuu r odafiaunfi r ri.rfiu zz. 6s

do tdtude t n a tn r til;eunfi dd oi aTn rrn r r{era{fi rurlrrff Crustrarda rda o ir.lan r rnrnt.snrr{orariilrurhrfiCru'trariiaaao ir.., fifieunfrdrrir' du;"r*nrziouriilrurlr'tfr Toai:lr6'uneuuurodafieund rri.rfiu 14. 99 ii.ra{rudr.r

do - qd-n o t n r ziifiauad ilY dd si a1n r.r n r r iorarifi rurl r.t fr

q'rnnrsi rnzr"r1 urliluurra.,rnrrlf,rfiud r"u.jr,sf,rudridtcraarafrr frufirurlznrlrad.rfie tlarffnr:irnzr"ri n.trflanaa*nnuuffrrrr,(l{uttiple Regression analysisl,dru.f,'lurJritrt"dfiandanr:rrjdau

'ir frfirurtr rafa ilcfa

r fr a i r.,r fi fi a d r firun r .,r rfi s'

uilatIatrT atfi4nirstntaunfrdail ra{z1rar'luunsuan r rnTnztnrzr uu

dd.u. roriur an r rtuilrrl: ruu a {nlruuu z,r glfifnifrnrr, I fiaurt: Teafiruilrdfiwadar.ra.tficnirrn

d{o 6a druruunr ndrrfiarfiufirurJrurndqnficrfisnr ffrCuuuiraarilrcrrnrt9t|-'t,.lor-eir il.rilarndarrarfr4ni{asne z1.so rornsrriia i,rurudfiudfirorro rr{rruluefrrfau .rio..rr{.rtunrzfrnrlue? a.rilwufin dr.tff{ra.tunrrwfin

fl 1 {n'l r t flr'or n,ttBnrrso tfirufirni., trr. uasnrrdrurir as'tfi qHa qrtdrffu

Page 141: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

t22

1'lnnlTita?1sti fi1?iluiluno'rn'lrruflrfiud roH'ir{6rurlro-d:ctauaraffa fiuffeurjtnT ruufi.rfir re alffnrzi r nzrod n1?flonosuuuuununau

(t'tultiple Regression analysisl rdorarfirulziazsdfigtneianrrrldau

uila tn rrrunrouTttunrtfrntr1uqr fl a{?'tnartuunlruan r lnTaz.qnr:r su'i.t9

ifirurtt r,ria ilqia dd.u.roaiurgnrrruuilrilrrura\iesruu n?'lrtn'louT.rtu

nrrfinrrunr YffadrsfrfiadT firunr'rrfid fioru, I firurfz Taafiruil:diarada

fl?'luerouTtlunrtfinrrunt u.ndtr, 6a druruuer nri'rrdarfiuffeuilrornd

nn6o t fian t frrCuuu,irnorilrcurrudr d.rloarnsiarralff{niioanu s6. 18 ra\r

aslrfia rra'tfi ,iruruddudfirurro ur.rtrulu*i., {ru uacirlt{ralunrtarfinnl{n1? r flrnr nrtrf rfiu

ia r duauug.t1flsafl1ri{a

1. l1narnfl1riia wu'ir r."6rdr.f,aari lurrnTRztnrnadfiru

rlrrfi q"firT a'tfi{nirasnraunirsiail {.rn'ir r.rirdr.f,aaiuanrori"ronrzradfirurlrrfr f;ofir..r",drou...n rtarlur nn1nrtnrr"r d.q dqlm?lt'l$noudqr-alfrd'anror rrnn'i'r x,traiuonTnr.snrzr <rrnnrrfinrr uu"i'r rrror'lurnn

Tnrrnrzq fidfir,fiantror"d, nrauniras 21.09 rd drurrr6zuanrrn

Tnrrnrr.r iidfiun"orro,*d, nzauntrns, 10.69'tdl rlrcnailfiurrrar'lu

r nnTn:.snrrr'tfriunr:afiuauu'tufirutdr.r1 crnnrnigurn lduri idrnrrr nnTuTaiinrrwio e aae qu r n{o.rfiadr.,rt lunrtrltsnararilu ii.rCrurrani

rflua.fun1{n1?rntsnr rdu eirsrfiufi. nuu "rn"r trsrrrfiu*rtundri.tfi:torlur rq r rntnr{n1T"r fir'ra'tfilrnn'ir r'troruantnrtnrz"r udnrtd

qsriil.{urtzerrruatrilrdofiourtuffudror fir.u nr:iril.,rfrtHafisfidcs'tdfu

'irfrrfiunudrfra srilutard uarr rnfi s a r fi a.r'ta drnr rdrotir r fiu1n:'cn rtluluzrju uu r fi ld a't rluio't d

Page 142: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L23

z. q1nflan1ri{a uu'i, r'l"grdrrf,aad lursornr.rnrnadfiru

rJr'1ff q"iln r rrun rouTrlun r tfinr.rus r turcffud'rn'i ir'rrordr.f,r r riuri, o,

Tn t tn r tradfi 'rurlrrfr fi tfi o 1 q qs, d, ou.u.n :rrqtlu r nqTn r{n'l x"r ilrt?ru rru

dAudfir""ro rurnn'jr rrra?uon1artnrsr fizra'rffdrurnn'ir uncilrsnail

fi u :'rr4 ttu r noTst t't n r tr't fi f un r rdfi uduudidfr n r zf, .r n u1uff rusi r { 1 I'l fl R 1n

i5ura 't6uri Ts.r r igu ri.o, fiufil ouu rjrcil'rerndT r r firfi'r eiruucr.i'l

qrn r irrafirdna'rig ",,ar dsrirtfifienrun, rf,.rs,rfi#u t{orc r f,urr rnndri.rfi

rrrqr?uranrrnTn?{n1T"r ilnrrrunrouTstunrtilnrruqr ?1ra?rranTnr.r

{e{t fl8?nu[ ?8{n1?

r rliailr fiaufiurra'lfr

r dotff r iluffaratunrrie rrtuorunrz'lt{ililzsrrfl 1fir urrcdu

fi ufi*d d." a .,r't ilfieru r r d arfir ff I r s T a d{d{ do r r n n r zfiEurtufiudfi"rI

,,z. tunrrriri{anirsia'til nern'n rrdT i{a fr{flciadiidrurr'le

r du drrT zqilTo"digirrfi'turadfiru

r dart r fluf, aratun rzicrl:slrf,rfiudlfi?1rar'16?fnrnr.rnrziaHrifirurj, rfi r,'rniof;r.

I

B. tunrrririian*sda'trl neriinr:dri{a frsilciadtuecfrar

tufr ruoi T .,r1 d r nta r fi a.rfiun r riaTa z.sn r rurifi rurlr'tfi r du ilq{an1 {n1aR1u

r a.rfiurufirrdTu r on. rri r r ras rr dudqr d.€ r e?u o rilnte'tfidl rilntutn :.t n r t

,dfl1r.r umn'l?nceriil{iltJzsilrrua.o"ttJrdafierurtt fit drtr fin.u arrirfi.rfi.rara

fiufi dc"rfi iu'i afflfi unudtffa.rrdraia'tri uaru rnfi a a r fi a.-r1e dun r rdr"tir r ilut9

Tn r t n r rtu'Lurrlu uu r fi rud a'trjraio'td!I

uo.qu"-ar a r aluauuc d'luTun'rrfi r i{an irialil

L. tunrrririian{rda'trl nrrfinrzririia

rlzc r fiufrunu dtftun.tfisurTnrtnrr{eudfi'rurl'r'lff9

,<ddtoailn I ililIil

1unr r r frT drutn r.sn r r{oradfirurh'tfr

n'rrfinrr t nnTuTainrtatin .ra.l

Itfir.r ilciafrlunl?ufl?n rirarailr flq{g'tufr'lunrrauinffiuu"ofi. r fufru

Page 143: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L24

n,traiilr'lasan,triia

r. tunrrioTertnrrradfi'rurl'rrfr rri'irqo t f,u1u, oofiudrufir.l

arrfinr:finurfi.r frnanrunao#udfiur r flariau rdaqrrfrd'r'trl'tfl rfiufrorya tu

n r ufr q'l rrul rlrc n oun 1 ufi eRur s dcc6i r r ilun r tionT r raiafi.,r.fir.dfirra'nd..{ { { &{{ o {na r ila r rl r nofllfunnrcq,r ruunrzfoTnr.qnttudfirurlT rfrlfiufir , r.".rntu"a.s-g{{{aettfiflr1nlufliluotra{uunn I i'l r aafl n{n'l{n1ufl1gn1re flrnrr,r r nil untffruf,snn

o.ori xfinrunnfi'rusvri'rtfi r rrn:ru'i.ffudfiur t uurrdlrdqsltdracTt r du

ra rn qot flffrrdfiurirn. ? r ntra r fi cc dr1fi t t rntrl'i. fiudfiuil".'rldud.slfiln n

firriloro dr.,rr'rt.ddro"rtilan qa ra ra riuwaarin oddt*u flqiadrffd.r

rd?runrrarRCIfias'tzfir.r u^rfiffuddtffrirrjzsrtarrlrrirtcisct rfiasuaurinrtff.t

flu r da r rrlfrdrnrrfinr, urriauufirfiuuffr ficontru'irnrtdroi'l\t'lr fiilruur

lunrrr1iiifi ac'tzfir.i d.rcodrtfidrtrtn r 6anilbfifi'tfrair.rqnfra'-r

z. nrr{ern:rnrrudfirurlr'1fr nrzinrtll\tusfurdata.riuilrura'r

ffuarc t fioernnrznarafir fion.oi.rrt C:rgic uasfltnl lostjzsd'lnr Bnc

dildulurc avsl't r ar'ti6ea r du run*{$?fl d, ,.iofiudti.fit tfintaunirne,

14 Id z {'lu ludrttsavurnl ou.ooroftudtti'rf, arrrswodrfiu udrdo

r.",svr rarairurrl nzountrilinr:ngradr iirrur?n,iiuf;u,t {-nrrr6atnrzfrdudr

3.

drillqt.inrt"lnr:{e dtt'tfi

fiufi d a ri r fr urr'rnfru r f,u l'r ro udr fi .,rfiui.ro r zfi n rr{a t oiailuatu r da zat fut ir du nrrd.,r r eiufirunrzfinrr nr:ds r d?rariluta'-t nrrCs s diufi'runrt

1trnnTuradtfiurtztRnfinT ulunT tstho rflufru

nrtie1e ttn r:urifi T urJrrfr!l

4 a Y u. q ud.Cf4il1An \i n\iB,O'l [ ilUn 11ie

|l

, -d. {(nailT1raT) alne'lIuufl1Tle

ra$ud]tn'lTn'lu{o{e 1%ilnnanTn?s t tr1i

( unnn,tnrrotigl. rrd-- rr-

uasrunl0?udttnrrilnrrui nrrtdrr,t?n ttas

|l

o q . ^ { {d .--a---^-e.^ -(^--t- { ----!--gC- .,nzrun-tilrur4rsi'1.t1 tuuunnqce 1tilun1Tqe t ililo8'l\ie n'lr I aan{mqc I r1il'l

adtuTnrsnlT"r fiior"fra.r?frtfinr" nrtldrutru uasnl,tlafrlrrn tunrrr|lt

d ! { { -et rq { ^q . --^E-.-?- r^ et

ilrsrn a ua,lil$r a {ilnanuu r wancsr'f fids t d?l a rilnf fiuriUnnafiuf fr a ri 1 {nfl no \i9!l

^:"^^^"'ir iio r fit doddruttndrtfi',i'ran'ir uauurtatta'tdtra r {tBAECI?{flUn'l 1l|OUS U \t [ ilUn{nn''lll'l13lYl-l tq$-lall'. I

n.ir n,rrdrrdirrariutraddfriiinrrrr{ rrififinrc rafanrrunfio

Page 144: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L25

n 1r{o1n t{n ''r rridfirurJr'1fr rarirs t rur a r f5n r rirufiafrurir$

luun 1 euiir a s ru irdrfi , fiu...u frufi atraun a.rudr s r ru'loude, o.r.rfio, dr.t,49rdye1n ueealnrflotrariratruuil't1 fiu dallnrrrui nrrrudrurrg rawrctudrnr

lgd ,qsa t d u

frnurldfiE.r1uad r ilurlrsdr r rirfiu nrrirruloofiuuatal radra.rru qcdrtfir froeY-^u.{{q

a'l1uuTailn{-(uo1iln1a\iRu n'ln{ t ala\i1|o .tltil?eil'l0t na001ufl1fi{n?1ilneu 4 . -u

q q 4

o 21tl x $nca? 1rd1il'l ?n d.rqsrria'tfi r fion rrrufiilqniara s a {Ia r{n 1T'tffa rir s(D

d d. q at?o t T? uasililTuf,nfrfl1t{

E.'trinrrtffr irrafirdra,rig dtiiifi.rruailufiuddqvdrnrrfinrr

r fiufiiia rwrrsrsrirrfirdtorrdfirou.u rda.rqrnr.iarfiu..r r n?{lq ugoo

4.

tI

t ntrnfir frdaunru t.rorr'triqourirnruqr\iq1rn'r1r t flur?s

6. riauaanuuudaun'til nrrruilnrr'tfias r dae r f,ariaudrcstt*fifi

fi 11 e'lun r ri r n rrrd fi au a u fi ri..r i a a fl o nuililata un u1fi da o nfr a..r fi ldfi fi dr ur ff

lunrriia rdu afieuT .rfirfia.r1fffiu frrurlrdfizrfiunrr{orfiunrir (Noninal

scarel r t.fifrtrriruurrfarnrrlfirfiunT rleuililrfiunrir uia dinur'rfirfras

tfffiu firulrdilrsrfiilnrrTe ilrs rnndrs ( rnterval scalel , t.fifrrtdruuu

daun rllfi r fun r:Tauiluilzs, r nndet , fluffu

T .'trinr:aonuuudarntrrfifiirururrnuiafiaarfiu'trj,dro..n

frrirdounruiirurnrfiu'trl froailficoifinrilard.ira rir'tfirfrirnaudrdd udfrT

urndrn rrfifi a a r fiurrl fi q gdrrfirfr fr auadrda rlfrrudlurr$

Page 145: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

r26

urtE,|uflfll

n:rurlrIfr .2834. r nnffnrrfiudf,n{rJ'r. al'lad'r t d?ru t wauui na{

aufnffiCIi,J. *-rl.tfi"*n..

4 y t..tru u f{ . ,--31r flpru sun?un 1.2523. rJ'r'(frfiunltfierurduiln. ?ud'ldqr?{tl?c tt{tu

rs firarilflr ilnrtilnyr zszl-i.524. rr.r0udduuudrantr$

uti.ttltc t ngf'lna, flT{ t nu"t.

do'lTtu

I

qiru iunfrflril1 . zszs. afifiif,i r ntrvrluasrrr'{uetu.tlui{a. u?f,n

drfinfirurirnaiorursrfid irfie , nT.0 t nu"t.

*rod einied .zsze. f,sailinsrduun. tufiqanrtfiud,nr{rnu"l.

$.dd.qqauo{u1ru. 253t. fl1Tcfln1 I iltBil t ngililTUdnflfl'lu fl'lru?u'lr

rurruiltvilrradfiruddr r ilunrt 1egatdnrtuiurrC:ui-!u5e

-$

u n E n.us n I ril n 1 zn a { nufisur iltsil rudilru'tuntq sgitrg-q-n

d <l q a / -q -- - rt -q,r dat ruila. inaruuustliilr1rTn. rr4lina.taarue a' fl?{ [ nsJ"t.

.4n'nar vr.rfeTffi .zssl. nrtdnrrtrjiauriiaudnrutCrusfir-f,snn

r a {n Gir, nro rn rd r f, a.srnul u n s n airrt n n rn rdr rirfi t f, a.rrauili

ulur aqinr{n1?firru1 unsd's I d?ilnrz r a'a'sTnurt rdrunri'rsilr

nar{ nir tnoilrn rrnatn i{uie dtsui. inaT iluudrl?rururTn-qsa

ilu'l?ng1n8r?lqa, fl?{ [ nil'|.-fl

ficurnt wrfruei . 252s. nrnlls$uq4 ufuerylgElldrrt19-' 'd "nrtdriluilzs lnnidrnranz?{snfi(an 55?) ?srouil?t fl1f,UAU r-

Anz'ttzsz 4. i n a rilwudlirururrn. lrra ri na rfi alfi ca, n 1{ I nun .

Page 146: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L27

r noq alilrnr .Bszz. nr:firunzasrlru a'rdT fi. nusrucrdn{ ilu1t-

ina'rfis r nrntdrd"{. nto I nu"r.'q

tffilrrTatrrlddu uarn'rzu?Tnn'lfr ao.rt'rrazsionlzionrtilu

lqnaruur,i.rd'rfi t atr iru i{ilTonrrurult. ina'rfiuufl?rururrn -

rurinarfia t nrosc'tdn{. nu t i nil"t.-9

lntr$ afiana{. zsgo. In:.rdir{uasriluuura',rudffrurlr'ti drtn-uue 1a a1[Rano{gf 'l e u d q q d.qnu iruianrflquuf . inaruuuarlfrururTn.

uurinarfia r nrnzdrdn{. ntt I n$'r.-9

dfrn finrtuffe .2525.ils reina.ruacnrrfe nrrn?uarn:rlr'tfr. t on

dr:drilnT tilnartl r {atnrtirn.rdon.cHal 1s-14fiil?'lnr

zlzs. drfinrrun.ucn?rrnrzd.,rure frsrutistrrfi, nT{ t nu.r.

dliln eiosriu.zsre. nrrouindniuarntszttilrfi. tt.rftudlraT

ilTA' r*asurilr. zsLT. nruauinfnffuarnrntttdrfi. nrtdgtnat

n'lT1{il1{,n?{[nu'r.I

urudeB a?rn?T?fi'il. zsgs. arnnzvnunot dntu r dtu5fir f,tnl n.tz

qo?na'laaT.lrR.lull{, fl?{ [ n$'1.'9

Crfint'runilsflTTilnlztctrtir uasf,{nilud.rrr8. 2530. uaufiour-qq..q-drczngiq unsfr{nilud.idrd siiufr e ts. c. zsso-zsg+l . d'l

oo4aunu,lEnTSIUnt, fl1{ t nu'|.I

drfin..rrunilsflTrilfl1ttdzrgfir uagf,{nrurisd, fi . 2535. uwufisur

r e ru5fiq uasrf,.{nilud',itrrfi ofiud z t fl. d. zsgs-zsag I . C'l

aoaluflu1afl?5iluqT, fl1{ t nu.l.

Page 147: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

arrd

r28

ilnrrna . zszs. ilr rginsr. air:r r andrzitrrn'rzafiud +.Rln

fierurtdrrr uny r andrridrnrt r.niraflnr, fi r nerl nrilfl1r

0.tnuoa?,flT{[nu1.llt I

cTafi

{a Tau

t

4ul6[1T1ru 6rilrrruo.ta . zszz.nlTauzflunf,uarntnzrud'rfi . tt.rfiruriruur

9-qu?nB'14811|ln'l[l4{' fl1\t t nil.l.

I

qoduuarusrui{g I dan11ltno'snrrna\i t fltrnrnr'lut nn

{.ruia t ta{tra. artdtzntrufieru.do'u, n?{ t nwn.

suofi c i.r r € a'r . zszg. n rrflnrr tilu uuu asTn t.,rdir.,r s a tuilfi ruI

rlrtffdruaraua.rrlar'tua air tna r fi4..r {sraToe zcui{{J?. ?na1

iluudl?rururTn. ruurina1fia t nrntc'td*{, nto r nu"t.

drurg ufrrR.rri . zszg. nrrrfie, fiuntoaurinradffrurlrtffdanrrilant

d{r .r d ruil't'lur s uuud fi rurl rt fi r a t a',r 6 n r r a n r t,rn : : t d rI il.

drarlandirsdrurlr. sodnT tandtant:urh'lff. n?un??\itl

[ fltrnzuauduntr$, flt{ [ nu.r.

Eirura narild.zszr.gdfirurlrtfilos aart. ilnn?lluttarailRo

rltrurur1nd.o.doo.rfraru. nruotucrdq{ ilurinsrffa t nunrc't

dn{, nzt t nrf"r.

zszg. rudr dq {dl t'u. I 1 a { 1un 1 ziltsdu r t t rlfifin'n r tTn t',t

n r r{eudfi ruilr't fi . n a t fo n r rdfi utj. an.uuritr'rfi n :lrlrr fr ,

flT\t I nU.l.

yuil. zszs.

Page 148: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

t29

zsg4. dnrunrrnlrlrlfrnasisraiqafiasrfi. r andr:drilrraI

rrudnrun'rrdilrrff{.rra1oofias'rfi . CT fin.rrurlrtff{suToafrao.uu<a.Ifl1U, 1{tfi2OOn8ff1%.

2 5 3 5 . 1 n z t n r zrj?urj r.r rJ T d.r ruuri.r tr r fi rh fi u r da r -fi r an a n

n?1s (3) lurrjradfirurl'rffr. t0nd1??'la{rudrilnrrdrrfiu

fl''rr lnusnrriliurJrrrlrdrruur,i.rdrfi rlrfiutdnr-frrgnonq

a?14 ( g ) ?uriluilfiT urJ'r'tfr urid s ffrueir.-rfirao.r tdruatcilrgt!!

dr r naaruf,n i.rraToofiaflrfi il2"{1il{uilts&'ltu 2535. dr9

fin.r rurj'rI fr isra To afi asrfi , {.rrnio ofi arT fi .99

zssb . rrraradrrl{luiqqfiarrfi. t'l I \t1uu?ta rad1rl{su{oI.ar

a n afi 1u . a r fi n t r ui sra To a fi sn r fi , {',rra in a fi ar ril.999

2b35. dnrunrtr$rlruu'lfiugu. T1a\ilunltiltudettauu, dr.99

fiudnrunrtr$rlT uurfiudulut lodr t nnaruf,n itrnraanas1u.

drfin.r rui.ruTo afi ar ril, i.ruie ofi asrfi .

Haquet,L. lgSS.Replenishing the worldts forestry' the

future of world's tropical forestry. Connon

sealt,h Forestry Review, 62(3) : 195-200.

Kunstadt,er, P. and E. C. Chapman. 1978. Problens of shif

ting cultivation and econonic developnent in

northern Thailand Farner in the forest. The Uni

versity Press of Hawaii,Honolulu. 63 p.

Page 149: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

a'lnHu2n

Page 150: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

n1n3tu2fl n

n 1 lu,rilrslninru a.r, n i" oii"

Page 151: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

130

o d ^u- q . q 'n'lrtnnT .trrna{-leatffanrf,uiltc;lni c (q Coeff icin11r r da.rd:fftosif;fl r fiunrrTe a?1ildaonfratnT a'tu nrfluu.rd

( cronbach) cqrflrffdT uffuurfililrrRndur,itn?'lu r dro so{uuunodau drfi

asuuu??u r fufra rfruri fradauurrr iare rru url{oficunfi ulurltu tfiu

dr z r nn rul ufr rud r,,r t ndfi a .r rt r o r fi ulu a n r n d r n n u n c u uild a u n 1il dia il ts r iui r(RaLins scale) dqtfrrurlrtfln# cl 6o

-n(l

n-1

z.Es r,2

s -

n

gr

irurufrodau

errrurlzrl?'ru[a{esuuuudacfra (variance

of a single iten)

n r rt u rlzil? ?utr o {n!ruuur 4.,rfr iun r rne dalf; .r!|

{.e.t{-uta uf a nrntalatl0{6f?uI ua\i I uilr1nrg1uyeg

tr a {nsuuu[ 0 {u lun 1 Tnedoilfi \iullot

s

..UroN

2-z.Et

N

re afirlrjufiruuunodaunrtfitcdueruarnfrtutd o. 20 o - 8o

t iltsns,,t nrtfldn1r2529 : 55-61)

etan,rru,rirf,urltslnforio"..u r dgsuu'iriid'l . Sz iita{'fur nar{d

rir r dafia

EX

N

I-I.N

sr

Page 152: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

R1n$U'ln tr

uuudauo'llrT ui{a

Page 153: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

Lf, tlrida 1t6r -l &r

nlrfinr,r r rJiaufrru r drrgfi e-f,.rnr zouirrTnrrnrriorarifirurl'r'1fi

unrrailfiruuonTnrtnrt

fftfif,unrr,{----- nr.rruf,ufiuf fiufirrafirnrounTeg-

darifirur^nd---urid -firu siruarsrdr nirrnaaruf,n {.,rraTe afiarrfi!t --- (| -- 9

fff,lnrrr$ Tudfl'lrnrrr$t-

rJzcrnnnasradfiru ( ) radilrurlrtfrtaa ( ) radilrutnffrda.rtgt

rrt d r fralafirtrt

131

{I arn

l.firrafirnirriourud()dtaz. o'rs il

9---------

3. dratur ( ) unfl ( ) ntfd ( ) ianu4. nr:finrr ( ) rdrfrriauufi'rilo (, rfiriauufi.rfa

urnldrtaunfirtaqunrrilnrrrsrdu ( )ilrsnrfinrr t lfrraufinrr

t lartrdnrr t lrlirururnt t laf.rn'i"rrt?qru'rni t ldur

s. nrreiTurafirila ( ) dru'triaon ( ) eiruaanrl'aurdrfr

( ) niruaonrr'au'tfi

6. dnrunruafrrd( )Tde ( )uei.,r.rruuncaidrafiu( )nirirsI

( ) utd'r.rruuduanfiuo{toatdr,tirir.r ( ) dua-----I

), 14-11u?uun?nsrlte____-_nil r rludrg______nu r iluul1.r9 ----

nu.-d1'ru?unraunzrnarf,aai'tufiru ( )1 nraunir ( rz nrarnirt

( )B nraunir ( ) urnn'ir g nrauntr n'o- n:aunirT9. drurudu'r?nlunraunir fiturrciT uru nu

t,d..d( ) a'rasi'tnd'r 1il iruru nu ( ) alsrsr.r?'l\r t-L4 u nuI -- I --

( ) ufr'r

d( ) ou.l

7.

8.

( ) orazsu'i'r.r 1s-s9 il nu ( ) a'la 60 ilf;urlfruru nuI -- I --

Page 154: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L32

.. v {ilrg6funrzd?unrriradu

10. nirir rul r Ailro.rri.ru ( rrfiadudfi.tfl ()riarudrunf,( ) firafiurure'rnsirundunareir rnanrufln 6a oirun

yd.{auo{<r( ) s1snuil'ls'ln0'l Inaauf,a{i.{uie anafl.lu fia nit rns_ude-{{( ) g1gnuil'ls']nq{r4?aou ao rit tno i.tuTo

11. fiu#.rueirfio r drrrurrndr'tfrl rirur nafirarlaiddur r fiur raruruq.<l .Y

I nr{fl?'l 3 [ oau q1u?u nt\r ( ?sril?1aas r tacluq,l?,I{ )9

rz. druarf,aaiddurrtrnurru ( ) L- Bil ( ) 4- Gil( ) 7 e il ( ) ff.rud 10 il ffurrl

1s. , rrnr"d r truT ad'ruudfirufi (Itt

!

e?{

{n

il u. a.

CI1UA

Eir rna

1{t4?Aal

r oIn0uud81AOU

dr rranlu9

,r{fl1?A1anU

.,{fln1$fl'l1n 0n ?a {{q.{.u{nauil'lnunaua.lanu

. .- r{c( trru11u2u11nilI

uaclffrirfiur?.,r1luU

nilsfiul

atr{nnrilsfl'lTa'l8nu

Ia,lanu

dI e8?

eValan{

e?ou

n??

1

2

3

4

5

I fiilr1ure'rnfianrzlilrfirds4dc.qa( ) fl11t[n\i{1U ( ) ||lJtllfi,l[?a.ln0iln1flUlCtl

( ) ililruurfr'ruilq{anr.srczrgic'tuda{rfirdou( ) iiilruurdrun?1rilnflefiaernTqt$4uI

q{r, { { a - ra,( ) il1n$ua{utoruou fnd?uil1oae,l8

Page 155: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

133

{c1 { .! { rt, q -- r{( ) n-ilrUrar rua{q1nfl'lruflu1Tn?{df'lrfru5ru nosurifi'rurfiru'tdatl

( ) dari, frrurdn'ddurirfiuunri'irnr\ir1dn'l?lcfo*rrdfrutfr'rurrtg|lr

railfiTurlrrfrg

14. errufia.inrtffrsfiuluaursn ( ) 'tdfio'rn'r:trafiu ( ) 'tiluutq

( ) fiosn'rtfr.afiu rladddv e .i15. IUoruAnqa{fl1?a18flU

tl

I()n'l?uo{{1u ()

!t ------

( ) fiilruurrrnfiarzrudrfida{{+.qillIfut41t TA{nOUn'lnU

L7 . flrurard riofrurudrirfiu ilr1fiu

eaud 2 dn1rn1{ rczntn'e

18. flqrfiudruilnrtn'an ta.rdfiuo dr.r't t1B. 1 dAuti.fit na{qur at{ruru--urjatirueu--'td--{'lu--fl r?.

( ) fir ancrtRnf i.u.rr--urla'siruru--'td--.t1u--nu ?.

( ) 'tdiit anaT slndf ruru-utjatiruru--1d--',rru--e r? -

LB. z dAt tl.fit dnt'czrdnrziodtftfi .irueu---Id--'rru--s12.dq' a drdrfrdu iruru--uila.ciruru--'td--.rru--q??.18.3 neun,lnun'

"rilairrdT'tdac u1n/il rf,u,tuf;nf,t ---------il1n/it

LB.4 daud r firri'r r rjairlaa'trit flair r dr {ruru uila.,l

( ) dfit t rnrrqilrdtruurittrrfi iruru--Id--iruru 'td

.t'l$__nt?.

\t'lU__n??.

l fiilruurffruflqianr.r r drrgfiq{g e rdaoefiaqrntctfizra) iltJfuu.lo'lt,ln?1il r

I ruTfi, ,drr. f,nrrulfifirauodddu

I ilflrura r, d, o.. n n r zfisurTn :.,r eiT .rffuo 1u r o {titrifi ru r 6 tr de'

I *t a i r 6 rur il fi dfi uri T iuu a r i'i r n r s t r d n r t q s, io e t : nde'u'tfituz rJatt

rarifirurlrrfrtq { q C ^ d. q q I u ,{d16. ilrur4'lnlnoru-aunn'lflut oil flau81ail1a8nu

( ) dAt f ur rndrdtruuri.rlT fi

Page 156: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

t34

dq.qJ18. 5 titl-utitduauf iruau____ttila'r 'iruru _'t'j {1u nTt.18 . 6 riruru'ddurirfrutrrufi.rfru r reu#.rurn'fra 18 . 1- 18. s )

iruru___ _____uilnr iruru__.ti__{'lu__n??.

19. riT urfrdhurirfiuna.rri.ru t rlontrruluffa 18 . 1, 18 . 4 une 18. s )

rur'tffarirr'tr tsrau'tffilrnn-ir , tr, , I furas r l1fiiurutonlu( ) flsrino u1n ( ) dt*t (lsu)

za. ila,r,l.fiud".rirJtrilcqfiutr.ud*u;'.;; t;. ;;;;;;;;;;ffosnrnrfa'td ( ) rfiatua ( )'trirfis{ua,drn..n

zL. firld riia.rua riruda.rnr"d6t ri.Audn iruru__'l'i-_.rru___nyl.

zz. rirufiedrnrrid6t irueu---------ri i.rcorfia.,ruaurinrrrirfiuda'{{-.qr-Stzg. urnn-6rriloheunrnusa{n'lu'(uu.usru n,tuesI,tauiard

E

( ) il'18 rlt?1s,

( ) Yrinra r$?1c

24. artuufintuflrrfiu ( ) rn$n?n?r&r ( )lef,q{ ( )ilscrr( ) ffrrra ( ) iuir.,r ( ) trrrilnrr ( ) rrficCrufrr

I

zs. orturatluflcefiu ( ) rnunxn?rr ( )rref,n{ ( }ilzsl.r( ) frrrra ( ) ili,.r ( ) iurtdnrz ( ) srfiedruf,r

26. frnrilsnrrtfiuz.rsruf, a{n?oilRfz1uflrcfiu

( )tflur.,rtrutunzauni.f;oro, ( )ir.,rfrdurirqana

( ) 1ffu r r.,r'rulun :aun iruarir tffo{urir, f,r,. *0" r..

nrrrlrenauarifr uaszrald, od"

Page 157: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

135

zr . rra'tffqtnnrrilzcnouoriluluflqqfru

zr . L rrayffrrnarawinfir r nror

finrrucri'rtfid'r aVU[1'l [ 11

I df,''t? t uua? frud'rrjsrafis

uoaa ilra {.o

uf,a,n

il"d, ursilnn. u {.11U?UnT\inn1/:, <dqn1fl1t|nourrJo

01t ?f 'lnou I

I

rir ir.r't n I

r ds t Ia1rilanuufl I

I

oirfrrsrjan Irl.ud{]

n1rt1{ t nil [ ng? ]

.Ltin'11'r{u1s ]

+iT ir.rruH'tar{at

eirir.r rud{a,aar;

drfiaI

irarrltrrHndir

irarilrruitrfi:ir

nq

s

T2ra{nuI

-r{arnua0l?iln4ilal

?1e1nauu?8

rxil?'rslfrfiniT

rtiradail

Page 158: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

136

riruiilnprr?un,tzilrsnarartrrrrsilnnuiarri ( )'tdiilrurar ( ) fiflrgHrnoa

( ) o.ofi'l ( ) rrnfrqzfitr ( ) rreriunu ( ) ilrgurnrrnarn

( ) 6uu'nerruaoudrutolui. ( ) trerre.rnariqdrraiarric{d

zr .z na'rfisrnn1r r f,aof,n{

.-da10un rile frni, fru.t rra'lfr ( u'1il/il

1

2

3

4

5

r?ilr1alff? 1fl fl 1 ? r f,a.,rflr{

riruiiilrrnT?unrttzrnaue,rih,il"of,n{riald ( ) rriiiilrurar ( ) iiflrurlrfia

( )rrnf,q{( )r'reriunu ( ) zrnranatiqdrratarrin.rd

( ) ilrurarnrtqarn ( ) dur (lstt)

zr.B zT alfrcrnnrriliT t ttcuilie lo\t{1u)

.-dnlcun dilerasrrudiui.o :T a'tfi ( u1n/il

t

2

3

4

Page 159: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

r37

riruiiilrnrTrrnnrzrtrrnauarifririrrnfalri ( ) rriilflruur

( ) ilflrurar fia

zr .4 r'ra1fisrnn'lrfrrnra f ruru

riruiiilrur,r'rcrnn'rrtjrrnauartrfrrrrauiatd ( ;;;;;; --urnzir

( ) fiflrunr 6a

zr . E rra'tfrs rnuHai.rdul

t d:ourut fl zr . L-zr .s, i.u.uf;.,rf;u

27 . G rrltra'tffr rnnrrrlrtnouartnluilqqiiu

il1n/il

za. r1atra1ul""fuI

zg . t rrairafi runr zlt1nn'Lunir r t'ou

u'ln/iln 10'll4'l T_

i'r r f afir il'rn/il. s -{irarfnrr1tn -u,tn/il:.. .:--:---nltoilutilnaaarCa- -u1n/ilt,{.odirrniasilrcdu -u1n/U: driruauuu- -rt1n/rl

ir'tff{ra t fit, "f

t t u{flndon dri 'rnr-- --il1n/ilI

{{a-uf ( rsa) _il1n/ili ------

.-{a'lqun uuri.rdu'rra.rtr aIfr rra'td ( u1n/il

1

2

3

rru: ra'tfiurad.,rdu "l

I?r r futrairadrunrtuitnnlunir r rott u1n/il

Page 160: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

138

zB.z rra.iraffrusuil flrrrurfiarI\t'lU[[6{ {'lU

trudu

r?rr1ai1a?uadntdrsuluta za. r-zs.z, f;of,"

rj:s rufi unsTEunrru

u1n/il

il1n/il

'rruilturi u'ln/il.l

{ 1Un'luiln 1{cl9-

u1n/il4{1UAU1 ( tvu) U1n/il-9

,ru , firrr.sirafirusuu fi?rr r ilau il:c r ufi .rar u1n/il

zg. uafllrnrraira'tufia 46 ufrrfr.oilrrairadur dnilrsrrril--urnril

so. rerrrardtniruilqefiu f;.rfuu5su1fl--- ------u1n/it31. ilqcfiuirlffiratunrzariqdrutudurvrn ( ) rtudsrdu ( ) {iusz. frrfrdrurirufra'uurqrndto r ndaufiru ( ) ruTfidfiao ( ) riafirg9

( ) rurnrrurfrdd ( ) snd. ( ) cranrr{ ( ) dtr (nza)---g3. waara'qdrffluilqqfiu Crurrnfrnriraarirrrr

( ) rir'trjnra'lurila'rfrraouro{ ( ) lr'dafrrlriuf,tfrod

( ) riT 'trlC.,rriafrrtur ila.r ( ) au1 (7vtt)

34. il r {'rufirduT tfiiruusrir t daafiunrtnlnrtruf o'tri

( )'tdil ( )it uusdrtufrru

ss. r {rtafirddrrtfiiruuudrfrrudrst rrcrnnrirasru'taffrt

t r ta.sn rueirduduurir ude",

54. 1

54.2

54.3

flrqfiudrui r turr,rfia r fiuuiarri ( l fi ( ) 'tdil ( ) dtr

ih r iiu r rt o ri r un' r t u r ra n' o fr n r fi u? u t tlu uu'l e

( ) rrirfirudfosasti'tfl'tufiru ( ) rftutiras ( )drnru'rn,rr

( ) rfi{aaufi ( ) dr.r (lail)

u.rn/il

36.

37.

Page 161: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

naud 3

139

dnrrnrtfltnl

38. ilsrfiudrl?ntuazaunf rra.rriru r na r fir.irrrficnrzillunaiuaslz9t

fir'rraia'td ( ) raa ( ) 'trirea

dau1

39. qrnfra 38 u'ln r na druttntunraunfrna.rrirur ng r frrdrrtneiuq

q ^ U . .lU InqnTTil'aou'l{ ( ) flnilutlil1u[fltrnu ( ) nnt|[nrotfl?9t

( ) naillunrnlaarunind ( ) nairr#a.r1r,rru ( ) nairrnnfir rnd.9ttt

( )neiuaufndTeunrrru ( )naiilsurnrzar ( )nriunaffrt99t

u( ) neiu r fiarTnnr"ila ( ) nduuurcr t/ tatttu ( )9tl

40. flccfiu , doil, *ro r dae iau riru'trlrj?nrrlnzlrndda

. ; rirfiu ( ) firurtfiru ( ) rurfidfia.,r ( ) orrduo ( ) n?I

( ) ritafiTdro..rig ( ) dur (nsu)

4t. tutauitduffe duT ilnlunir r tauratrirur iuilrafrralrnas'ttilr.t

r l'tdr.o,flr, ( ) rurnrrda ( ) 'ttra'aeaan ( ) ltntfirilrs( ) 1fiu{o ( ) tznuari ( ) fiosirsadl\iu?{ ( )eauaaflan

()ilo ( ) trnfirufi..r ( ) flual ( ) Ttnn.t.,it6uura'lrA( ) Trnrroarrarz ( ) lznau"l(Tsil)

flcqfiu radfi rurirufian rfi au'rffaraia'ld{( )rl ( ) 'triu'42.

43.qu{Alr{uilcquu r ro I rurl'tanlurfl1?Tnr'tsa,tilrnoirtrt

a ; nrugrduuruz ( ) frr.u.n.uto{ ( )u1uilanra'tuu{firuJ 4 { u:( ) uunauruuTil?'ltuuilauT!, ( )uuna01ila ( )6tn1u0u1raCI1ila

( ) f rtuarurnair rna ( ) au1

44. flerfiu urifiT uriT uiir:.r r iauuTatri ( ) fi

4E . ilc r ffu uo ?ua 1u! o.r ri rurrl r iaurafi ',r iltdt.( ) lz.tttauilzcirurifiru ( )Tr.ttiauilrsirdrrna t ldur--

druiin r run rnnitdcslfiun tr a trirl t iaueun I tilnyr zcfiutn

( ) fisarufinyr ( ) artrHnur (

()csn'irrjtrururnt'()dur

( ) 'tdfi

r rttrururn*

Page 162: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

140

4G. ilqefiu rirurfriufirrunrrailrnn u?Tnalunir r f aurrnurarirfirlol9,ravUu(qau'l6il''rnn'i'r 1 frat ( ) li'raru ( ) tJruro.o ( ) ,dru

( ) firrlrsrlrnrar ( ) ,irfi.f,u ( ) ar.rsfi.rfiu ( ) eirorfiufi.Iv( ) ririlrcilrrrnniro, fiufi..,, , dr* ( ) fi.o.nurifir airnnasd( ) 8U"1 (7s1t)

4T . frnrrucra{ilru".fi.drffarJ1nn u?Tnn luilqqfiu( ) uraei,,rfirarirnufi.r, ( ) o.ufi.u.ruqg (

-da9( ) ilquflautruiuI

( ) rddrolriodas

( ) f dlr'ilruvrr

o{ a Y) ilnnutultuutsni.r

( ) fieill,"fin

48. ilcrfiu firurarriru9

( ) r fiau'tn

ilffarrffraiardu( ) dttuan

I()

()

()

{a()u

4.( )rl

( ) arrfiatrirura{( ) oill_____

vdflrauI

I rnrl

( ) rn{nraru ( ) fnzaruaud ( ) rnaud ( ) dur

s 1. fl17 r fiunrs oanuonrarifirudri.rua rfraai'ruilccfiu

( ) f,rtqrdn"n*.r r I f,rJqrltan z-s "fo( ) frrlarriau B-7 "{o

( ) ,6ruuo"*o

sz. anrudfinecriunr{ril ( ) radilru'rnffrfig{ ( )'ruf,rnirrna( ) lufirituTe ( ) drrr iroor--,

I ------

I

( ..{. I J) 6tile 1uAs4-5 nt.,l

{( ) oulrrail)I ---

( ) 'tdfinrrucrfiufinriis{$a ( ) dur (leil)9 ------

frriir fiufirurinrn

drrrii riT uri,r{nacarr"frraif,.tn

( ) itr.rdu ( ) 1fffiurdaufiru

4e. ileqfiu uilfiruriruirrlflrrtnr'a'tri9!l

frrfi rirur tair'trt'fih r daunr_ _u1n

fr r r ri fi rufl r ri ru1 fr u d.r d'i r .r q r n uraai.r't a't u r r a r n a r r fiu{".o( ) nstfla{u'lilu

( ) estfiasufid ( ) rn{a.,rdurrl

so. flerfiu ilrurirufi r n*a.,rtfuardrd'rueanr,tudcornacl:ff.I.,1

( ) rqrtoldflr t I rafrau.sfrrr'tdflr ( ) fioal ( )

( ) rnrfierlil ( ) ln:fisrfurrdr ( ) fiofi. ( ) ina (

U.Vf,ruare ( ) frrtintnrnrkiaanrlssrldrfi{aul (Tsa)

t ------

( ) 'trii

()rdfi

Page 163: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

t4L

s3. $r'u4usrdlilrfiunr.r'tiluanrarifi.ruluflrrfiu r I rfiurfi.r < l{n:aru( ) inrarugud ( ) rnauddruffr ( ) rnToadrr t

84. n1r r fiunr.raonuanrarifiruluilqqfiu ri.rufio'j.r r fiuodr.r'ttll rl

( ) dco?ndu1a ( I nuu'tddonaail ( ) nuutildrourvqeafu

bs. ilqqfiurilulilacltrf,urtorufirtunrrurffru ( )fiu ( )riru( ) iluuarsi'ru ( ) rnrufid ( ) rqrlrlfl'r ( ) dur________

sG. rfa rufi.,rdtdtuilcqfiurirudrrrrrntrau ( ) u1r1r otqrnilr( ) f,r ( ) fruuorlo1ra.{q'rnil1 ( l dur (!su)

sr . flsrfiu , ils rufiod'rtfirfiaruaraiatri ( ) rr1n rfiuua < l rif aruatr9

( ) naus'l\i8'lo[[nau ( ) rlauaauilln ( ) tdn''tfraa

sB. flqqfiuriTu'tfiiurirrdrrrrnuuaiste ( ) rafi.rtafilri ( ) ina( ) rn:fierl ( ) raan:cqradlr ( ) dur (ruil)

s9 . r rliau r ilaudnr$n'r rir r.rfliqz"ra'ir qda rf,a o iluse'qfiuilqefiu tu

r {assiarilf,

59. 1 6{R1$n'r'lr r fiuaira.,rntaunir 6a

Ee. 1. 1 dnrura.ctlo,;'.()rfirfin'iT ()fleqfiudn'i1 (t'triunndr.rfiu

59. 1. 2 dnrunosdnrutnrrsaMa()rfirc'n'ir ()ilrcfiudn'ir ()'triunndrsfiu

s9. 1. 3 dR1uf,o.i r ffunrtnrulnil torru

"ranao()rfirdn'iT ()flrcfiudn'ir ()rriunndr.rfiu

59.1.4 dnlurarTa

()rfiue'n'j'r ()ilqcffudn'ir ()'triunndr.-rfiu

59. 1.5 alnrsratuud.rfiT fiu

()rfirdn'ir ()ilrqfiue'n'ir ()triunndr.rfru

59. 1. 6 dR.tuflo.tuud.rfir'tfl

, dur--

( ) rfirufin'ir ( ) ilqcfiudn'ir ( )'tdunndrtfiuI

Page 164: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L42

. s9.L.T dnrwratnrrldfl.rturadfrru

( ) rdruo'n'ir ( ) i.ufirrr'nd1 ( l .lduend'r.rfru

sg . z r.rg'tffnosnraunffr

( ) rfirufin'ir ( ) ilqqfiuoon.ir ( ) 'triuonrdr.rfiu

89. 3 araarfinnrtffrunrr I nrqr e

( ) rfirudnir ( ) ihcfiufind1 ( I .triuflndrrfru

Go. rirufio.onrrtfinonrrfigurfir.,rfiurri'',oirfi.r r nau.tfirurnn,ir r tarTsslrnilrn'trlrarfiaal ( ) 61uu ( ) 'tdflr ( ) rlrcilr

rY( )urari.rrir ( )tnzf,ur{ ( )a?1ilafca1e

( ) nrrdrratuartu ( ) rnToadrzilrsrfrnr.{ ( ) ""ur

ilrunrdru'tuilq q fiu r ti a n u i tE ae z uti zEqt z nu t n ttt n tila d t(1)

(2'

(3)

ficunBrarnrozianr:auinfnirarnrd, rfr fln{rh n.rrilanrl,rilriu uac

d aTarrn r:{andilrurl'r'4frtt

1 . ficunfi g o {rrrarsi an'l raU;nr$Anjd:dueu--.d]t--rAu

rr4ue la tuue?a Ioa .l 'tl|]uue?g 'Suruuora

air.,rd.r triuritq air.rdo- u tq t t1.1 n1?auTntr5[B?il1 ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

, fiudoddfiilrcratrloiailzs t nddrfi

r.z nrzauinff,nirlr ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

, f,udodrriir r flu rurrufi{arir.,rrzfrn{rlrfie'rlrrnusdnarafiudrfrI

r o{o1rE'lrrrrfioiufrrIT

I d lt1.3 n1?R15[q?il'l ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

r fiua r tnudrdn r refi ilduu'tfid 1 r crr r sr1uil r fi .,rlidn'1 a ri dnu r n3t

Page 165: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L.4 nlrdrf,n{rJr

Aut t4uo?a

,{il81{ A {

()

dut uuo?a

()

la8 "1

filuutq

()

rd r fiuffra

()

r fiuii'rdftanauerl a uacfi qdafl ?rrl

1.5 n1r6i.rf,n{il.r () () () () ()

rirlfirr rfi rufi rrarff r fi ur rn#u

1.6 flo{ilrnrrarf,aod ( ) () () () ()

. ?urh r rirfiu rrinrrrirur r fras.tilufiru

fiauefina,rrlrordanrzauinff,r{rJr nsru%u??r esuuu

z. fidunfi na t rrnard on r zor$nr$rh$duAu

lvtuo?a Iuuela tfla "l,daE'l{a\i tdurif r

rrirfiudra rdrfiudra

z. L rj'rrfrr fiuariifidru ( ) () () ()

rrtno.silrs r ncdrfi r yrirerrdrsfiucuainrrf {1fin.roriqnae '1il

z.z fl'lrrfr'rlrjrirfiu'tu ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

L43

rrit fiuffrard

0a1 {8{

()

'dAA1{A\t

()

()

()

()

t nnilrautnf r flud.,rda' r urr"6ufin?1rAcilatr!ir$6f .,t

z.s nlrri'rr4uetfiiirrn ( ) ( , ; , ' .",

rhauinf r flunrruriodAt ti.fiuro,st'rrfiru9

2.4 n1T [ frr'trjinqa.rrir ( ) () () ()

fi urirn'u 1u r snilr auind, fiudod""nar4u 1 E

2.5 n'l{T'1iln1?n1x ta

) ( ) ( )

a uru r n'L fi r 1 ro ? r t r't rt ri'r n' u't u r r n rl r a q in f t fi

()

{q.-a ? 1l|8 1nlUSAsfl 1?!'leUnAunerln'lnura{ T'lroT

z.B rlrrfrdcruzr$rirtfi

r.ril.uili1u1? rdu

, dr , ilt n.rufrilrurar

() () () () ()I ' -r' iiil,rtflacuelurr$frratfio t4ufl't! uas 3 r

fidunfi r a.r z rrard an r raqtn{rlr'tff nsuuu? ?r----- ----- -ncuuu9

Page 166: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

L44

3 . ficundsa { r1r0r6ian r rilnnrJ.rgrrdu

rfiuffra ,6t ffra roa "l rdrfiufira .trirfiufira

ai'r.rir rilurite arir,ri.rg.1 nrzilanilrrflun.r ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

{.un rnfiririur a.rdr rfiru

s.z n'rrunrnffudil.rfr ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

4-I uiln1Tetonauil18

B.gnrrilnnil.rrir'tfiru' ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )

rffrirf,*aalunraufir

s.4 nrzilanrlr frdrfr () () () () ()!tt

iurjrrrTadtlr.nde" 6a ilssdrdu

B.s nrrilnnilT ,flrr?io () () () () ()

drdf 'r r fiu rnrr'firairsrzrfrfiffur a.,rrfi

g. c i.,r'trinarrjnnilr

r u:rcilrIfr 6.,rfr o ridnr r n

fi gunfi n o.,r r rr4 rei a n,r rrtan rl r {rt du n c uuur ? u _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ nu tluu

Page 167: n.trailnr,triliauriiat 6rurcrlnq-flrnr - s Ta z r rnrifi r ...mulinet11.li.mahidol.ac.th/e-thesis/scan/36075.pdfvillage Proiect and, without Forest village Proiect case Study : in

4. ?!-- q . ^ a .tndun0i ! a t r rrgzoi aTn z tn r rioudilrurlryfr

t45

rri r fiuffra,{

aa1{B{

()4.1 nuraddudrfrffu

r fia.ruauffe{u.4.2 r frauilrudrutrarj

4. 3 Tn?.inrrr,triilrut

4.6 rdafinrt{orariilru ( )

u a1 qffu zijuuun r ziouilfi ruuuufi9g

ros.l rdrfiufrra

rriuiltc

() ()

6- LO

11-15

16-20

2L-25

26-30

dyAyI uun?8 [ 14UO?g

,

481{8{

() ()

() () () () ()

() () () () {)

() () ( ()

(

(

(

(

(

) 'td rfiufreaari.oBo

) 'td rfrufiea

) roa r rriurilrdy) t ?tua?a

-A.),{, IHUe?aEA1{A{

anuultu?st{11{I

ocuuuu sli?1{a

ncuuuTsfi?1\ta

nuBuu?su?'l{,gsuuuTul4?1{

*n?1ili?iliiara.rffrfiflrnrrr$ (

*a?1&r, Cofrrrrotaradrfrtu (

I dr,n (

I 6rurn (

) ij,lunn,l{ (

) il1unA1{ (

I dTxa

I d'r*

d)e(d)e(

rh'|fr 'td r iiurjrutarrleiarJzs r ncdr8

a.a nrrieradfrrurjrtff ( ) () () ( ().t d-n on 1 ? r a'lnour o t dr zfi ru't rjrlnnrJr

4.s nrftfrdrrfiruari ( )I

() () ( ()

fruodr.,r r dr Toa'tri fra.r{oradfirurh'tfr

rh Y ff u fr r aR 1$n ? .r u r fl u a ri r a s d r r ff ruds a r n du r affu

fi eunfi r a.,r r lraxei 0 n.r r{crari fi rurJ r't fr nsuuuT2l| _ncuuu

360'75