Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blažić

  • Upload
    slacinp

  • View
    247

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    1/224

    HELENA BLAZIC

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    2/224

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    3/224

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    4/224

    UDBENICI SVEUILITA U RIJECI MANUALIAUNIVERSITATIS STUDIORUM FLUMINENSIS

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    5/224

    Copyright 2006. HELENA BLAI ISBN953-614-55-2

    Prof. dr. sc. H!"# B!#$%&

    USPOREDNI POREZNI SUSTAVI

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    6/224

    %ro&. 'r. (). H*+*, B+i/

    USPOREDNI POREZNI SUSTAVI

    ' OPOREZIVANJE DOHOT(A I DOBITI

    Izdava:

    Eo,o(i &+t*t S*i+it !i*)i

    Recenzenti:

    %ro&. 'r. (). Io S**r$ r*'oiti pro&*(orEo,o(og &+t*t S*i+it !i*)i %ro&.'r. (). Ni Nio+i/$ r*'oiti pro&*(orEo,o(og &+t*t Sp+it

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    7/224

    S*i+it !i*)i$ 2006. - ='8*,i)iS*i+it !i*)i G ?,+i=,i*r(itti( (t'ior +i,*,(i(F

    Bi8+iogr&i.

    ISBN 953-614-55-2

    I. %or*,i ((t -- ='8*,i

    1101>02>

    ISBN )*+',-/'**'0

    PRED1OVOR

    N(t,* '8*,i Usporedni porezni sustavi: Oporezivanje dohotka i dobiti otiir,o

    * pri* (*g *+o ' (* r*+ti,o *groito pri* 'io ,(+o*,i*g ,(t,og t*ri+

    o+*gi Usporedni porezni sustavi oi (* pr*'* , 4. go'i,i 'o(',*g (*i+i,og (t'i

    Eo,o(og &+t*t !i*)i (*roi Meunarodna razmjena i Financije i bankarstvo),

    o',o(,o 4. i 5. go'i,i t. 1. i 2. go'i,i 8'/*g 'ip+o(og (t'iF ,oog 8o+o,(i

    r*&orir,ogFF (*i+i,og (t'i Eo,o(og &+t*t S*i+it !i*)i (*roi

    konomija javno! sektora, Financije i bankarstvo t* o i8or,i o+*gi , ,i 'rgih (*roF.

    I(to to$ *', 'io oog '8*,i - o, o opor*i, 'o8iti - o/i /* ori(titi i (t'*,ti

    o+*gi Oporezivanje poduze"a ,i 'io (o*g ,(t,og t*ri+

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    8/224

    #ori(ti pri+i ' (* pr*,(t*,o h+i pro&. 'r. Ii S**r$ ,* (o o r*)*,*,t$

    */ i o (o* tr,o* *,tor , oi,(o 8rii i poo/i (+o*,o po'r ,ih &i,,)i

    i opor*i, t* o (+o*,i* po'r '*(og iot.*+i h+,o(t 'g* i pro&. 'r. Nii Nio+i/ o+*gi+, po'r ti*o ir'* i

    o,,og o8+io, oog '*+. Iti r*)*,*,t* 'oi) ,i* r,gir,ih (*i+i,ih'*+t,i$ oi ( *',o (tr,)i pro ,*'*,o po'r$ *+i * (t.

    @h+* i pro&. 'r. !t @*+*,ii , *to'o+oi (*ti (*i o8+io, ,ig* t*(oo '*o,(trtori)i I,i K*ri/ (ot, poo/ t*h,io o8r'i 'i*+ t*ri+.

    I(pri (* (oo o8it*+i , ig8+*,iF go'i,i o'ori i *iti i*,'i pr*'r,+o.

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    9/224

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    10/224

    (AZALO

    PRED1OVOR........................................................................................................................ >

    (AZALO....................................................................................................................................

    1. UVOD.............................................................................................................................. 13

    2. DOHODA( ILI POTRONJA ' OSNOVICA IZRAVNO1OPOREZIVANJA........................................................................................................ 15

    0.-. DOHODA( (AO OSNOVICA IZRAVNO1 OPOREZIVANJA 'DOHODOVNI (ONCEPT................................................................................... 15

    2.1.1. Tor%2# %34or# ' 5$% do6odo4"% 7o"c89 ............................................................. 162.1.2. Tor%2# 8r%r#s9# :o;#9s94#< Sc6#"3'H#%;'S%=o"so4 do6od#7 ' >%r% do6odo4"%

    7o"c89 .............................................................................................................. 1>2.1.3. (o"c89 ?do6o97# os94#r"o; "# 9r$%>95? ' ?"o4@#"o; do6o97#?.................. 19

    2.1.4. Por3 "# do:%9 7#o dod#9"% 8or3 "# do6od#7 od d%o"%@7o; 7#8%9#!# 22

    SAETA( 0.-.................................................................................................................... 31(ONTROLNA PITANJA 0.-.................................................................................. 32

    0.0. POTRONJA (AO OSNOVICA IZRAVNO1

    OPOREZIVANJA POTRONI (ONCEPT 33

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark0http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark0http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark0http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark1http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark1http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark1http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark4http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark4http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark8http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark8http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark12http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark12http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark24http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark24http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark24http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark25http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark25http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark25http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark25http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark1http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark3http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark4http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark8http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark12http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark24http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark25http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark26http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark0
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    11/224

    2.2.4.1. orez na dobit !manjen za zatitn! kamat!...................................... 6>2.2.4.1. 'pe%iinosti oporezivanja dohotka obrtnika kod alternativnog

    modela................................................................................................ >32.2.4.3.ritike alternativnog modela................................................................ >52.2.4.4.rimjena modela ! dr!gim dravama.................................................. >>

    SAETA( 0.0.....................................................................................>9(ONTROLNA PITANJA 0.0.................................................................................. 0

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark75http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark75http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark88http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark88http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark88http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark90http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark90http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark96http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark96http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark96http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark75http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark86http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark88http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark90http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark95http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark96
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    12/224

    0.+. USPOREDBA DOHODOVNO1 I POTRONIH MODELA 1

    2.3.1. As879% 7o"o=s7 f%7#s"os9% .......................................................................... 1

    2.3.2. As879% 6or%3o"9#!" 8r#4d"os9% ...................................................................... >2.3.3. As879% 4r9%7#!" 8r#4d"os9% ......................................................................... 902.3.4. Ad=%"%s9r#9%4"o'96"%@7% % f%s7#!"% #s879% ....................................................... 912.3.5. R35!9#9 s5@!2#4#"2# #r;5="#9# 5 7or%s9 do6o97# % 8o9ro>"2 5

    8r#7s%< 6%:r%d"% =od!%..................................................................................... 930.+.,. D5#!"% 8or3 "# do6od#7 's5s9#4#" 6%:r%d"% =od!......................................... 94

    SAETA( 0.+................................................................................................................... 9(ONTROLNA PITANJA 0.+.............................................................99

    +. USPOREDNA ANALIZA POREZA NA DOHODA(..................100

    +.-. POREZNO PRIVILE1IRANI DOHOCI OD (APITALA.................100

    3.1.1. Por3"o %3539% do6oc% od 7#8%9#!#< 6%:r%d"os9 5 s=2r5 #!9r"#9%4"o; =od!#8o9ro>"2 ..........................................................................................................100

    3.1.2. D5#!"% 8or3 "# do6od#7< (o!%7o s5 "ord%2s7 dr$#4 os9#! 42r"%34or"o= =od!5 % 7o2 %6 s4 dr$#4 s!%2d............................................ 105

    SAETA( +.-................................................................................................................. 113(ONTROLNA PITANJA +.-...........................................................113

    +.0. "3+T T+ U TRANZICIJS(IM DRAVAMA< TO JE OSIMJEDNE STOPE OSTALO OD HALL'RABUSH(INAMODELA............................................................................................................... 114

    SAETA( + 0 11>

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark104http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark104http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark108http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark108http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark109http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark109http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark110http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark110http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark110http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark113http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark113http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark113http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark118http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark118http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark118http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark131http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark131http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark131http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark97http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark104http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark108http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark109http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark110http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark110http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark113http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark118http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark119http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark120http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark131http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark131http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark142http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark143http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark148
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    13/224

    3.4.2. O!#7>%c s o:3%ro= "# 96"%75 "2%6o4# d#4#"2#............................................. 1353.4.3. S9#"d#rd" o!#7>%c.......................................................................................... 13>

    ,.4.,.1. ojam i vrste standardnih olaki%a..................................................... 13

    ,.4.,.2.5sporedna analiza standardnih olaki%a............................................ 141+... Ns9#"d#rd" o!#7>%c...................................................................................... 146

    3.4.4.1.ojam i vrste nestandardnih olaki%a................................................ 14>3.4.4.2. 5sporedna analiza nestandardnih olaki%a....................................... 152

    SAETA( +................................................................................................................... 15

    (ONTROLNA PITANJA +............................................................159

    . USPOREDNA ANALIZA POREZA NA DOBIT.................................... 160

    .-. INTE1RACIJA POREZA NA DOHODA( I POREZA NADOBIT........................................................................................................................ 160

    4.1.1. Pro:!=#9%7# 7o"o=s7o; d4os9r57o; o8or3%4#"2# d%4%d"d%.................... 1604.1.2. O!#7>%c 3# d%4%d"d "# r#3%"% d%o"%@#r#...................................................... 1654.1.3. S429s7% 9r"do4% % 9r"59"# s%95#c%2#............................................................... 16

    SAETA( .-.................................................................................... 1>2(ONTROLNA PITANJA .-...........................................................1>2

    .0. POREZ NA DOBIT I INVESTICIJE.............................................................. 1>3

    4.2.1. Por3"% 8o9%c#2% 3# %"4s9%c%2 7od 8or3# "# do:%9........................................ 1>44.2.2. Por3"% 8r#3"%7................................................................................................. 1>>4.2.3. I"4s9%c%2s7 o!#7>%c 5 5$= s=%s!5................................................................ 124.2.4. S9o8# 8or3# "# do:%9....................................................................................... 164 2 5 Us8ord"# #"#!%3# 8or3"%6 8o9%c#2# 3# %"4s9%c%2 5 o74%r5 8or3# "#

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark169http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark169http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark174http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark174http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark179http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark179http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark183http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark183http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark187http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark187http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark187http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark187http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark191http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark191http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark194http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark194http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark200http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark200http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark200http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark213http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark213http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark215http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark215http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark225http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark225http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark231http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark231http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark246http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark246http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark250http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark250http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark264http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark169http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark174http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark179http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark183http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark187http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark191http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark194http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark200http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark201http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark202http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark213http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark215http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark220http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark221http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark225http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark231http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark246http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark250http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark264
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    14/224

    -. UVOD

    I,t*,iir,* pro)*( g+o8+i)i*$ o i i,t*gr)i(ih pro)*($ (* i* r(t* ,o(t

    por*,ih i,it*+. 7,i ( 8it,i$ o 'o,o*,* i,*(ti)i(ih i +o)i(ih o'+$ to i o

    rit*rii i (t,'r'i '*ort(og 'rt. %o(to*/i (* ((ti (t+,o i(pit ( o8iro , ,iho

    *&i(,o(t$ horio,t+, i *rti+, pr*',o(t$ *',o(t,o(t i tr,(pr*,t,o(t t* &i(+, i',o(t. I

    (i ,*'*,i pri,)ipi (t+,o 'oi+ (o* r*i,t*rpr*t)i*. ?o* (* r*/i ' * por*, r*&or

    o,(t,t, pro)*($ i (tog (* oi ((ti o,(t,t,o i*,. I(to * to o,(t,t,o pr*i(piti,*

    poi)i* Hrt(* ,*'*,o *J,ro',o por*,o or*,.

    %o(*8,o ( (+o*,i pro ((ti opor*i, 'ohot i 'o8iti o o8+i 'ohot oi (*

    o8h/ po(*8,i por*o - por*o , 'o8itF. N*'*,i por*,i o8+i)i$ o(i (o* *o,o(* i(o)i+,* ,o(ti$ i i ir*,o &i(+,o ,*,*. Niho 'io 'r* 7ECD- p,i

    priho'i o' por* +/i 'opri,o(* (o)i+,o o(igr,*F i,o(i pro(* oo *trti,$

    o',o(,o '*(*ti, Hrt( ( i,o(i$ ,r,o$ ,i i i,o(* oo '*(*ti,*$ o',o(,o ''*(*ti,*

    por*,ih priho'F.

    = (*t(o ( ,,(t*,o ,o(ti pri+i,o ri*ti i (i +,)i$ o+i ,ig* i po'r

    oprti,og opor*i, *r (* r'i o t*i o * i*t,o t+,$ ,o pri+i,o (+o*, i

    'oi+ o,(t,t,* i*,*. = Hrt(o (* oo po'r* ri*to o8rJ*. %o(*8,o ( ri*ti

    '8*,i)i i oog po'r$ o (i*t$ to i Hrt(o.

    6ilj '8*,i Usporedni porezni sustavi # Oporezivanje dohotka i dobiti * o'gooriti ,

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    15/224

    #,ig ,(toi potri*piti 8r98os9#475 o "8os9o2#"25 @%s9%6 =od!# 5 8r#7s% % o

    6%:r%d"os9% 8or3"%6 s5s9#4# oi o(i 'oho'o,ih *+**,t i i (* i* *+**,t potro,ih

    o'*+ ir,og opor*i,$ po(*8i)* +t*r,ti,og o'*+. N*'*,o * ,roito ir*,o o'

    tr,i)i(ih *o,oi$ o ,oih +,i) E=-$ to i 'r r*gi*.

    7(i =7DA$ oi i,i pri 'io i o* ( i,*(*,i pr*'*t$ )i+*i i(tri,$ t**+,

    pr*tpo(t t* ( (trtr r'$ ,ig * po'i*+*, , tri t**+, 'i*+.

    = 'rgo* 'i*+ po' ,(+oo D7H7DA# ILI %7K!7N"A - 7SN7ICA I@!AN7

    7%7!E@IAN"A (*+ (* ' o(,o, o,)*pt ir,og opor*i, o ( t**+i

    o8+io, por* , 'oho' i por* , 'o8it: 'oho'o,i i potro,i o,)*pt. N*'*,o *

    rrJ*,o ro tri t*t(* *'i,i)*: 'oho' o o(,oi) ir,og opor*i, - 'oho'o,i

    o,)*pt$ potro, o o(,oi) ir,og opor*i, - potro,i o,)*pt i (por*'8 'oho'o,og ipotro,ih o'*+. Do (* pr* 'i* *'i,i)* o8, 'oho'o,i$ o',o(,o potro,i o,)*pt i

    ,ihoi o'*+i po(*8i)* (t,'r',i i +t*r,ti,i ,tr potro,og o,)*ptF$ tr*/ (*+

    rg*,t* ori(t o8 o,)*pt i ,*'*,ih o'*+F +/i o ,*'*,o pr(i

    r*+tir hi8ri',i o'*+i i pr**,tir/i '+,i por* , 'oho' o (o*r(,i o,i(t*,t,i

    'o(+*',iO hi8ri',i o'*+.

    = tr*/* (* 'i*+ po' ,(+oo =S%7!EDNA ANALI@A %7!E@A NA

    D7H7DA# 'o,o(i (por*', ,+i o,r*t,ih por*,ih ((t por* , 'oho' o o8h/

    ri*,* i tr,i)i(* *o,oi*$ t. pr*,(t*,o 'r* E=- i 'r* r*gi*$ ,o i ,** 'rg* 'r*

    7ECD = (+op pr * t*t(* *'i,i)* i(tr * (* pri i+*gir, po+o 'oho' o' pit+

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    16/224

    OPOREZIVANJA

    = oo (* 'i*+ '*&i,ir d4# 9=!2"# 9or9s7# 7o"c89# 8or3" os"o4%c %3r#4"o;o8or3%4#"2#< 7o"c89 do6o97# do6odo4"% 7o"c89 % 7o"c89 8o9ro>"2 8o9ro>"% 7o"c89 oi ,ihoi o'*+i$ i to o , ri,i &iiih o(o8$ to i po(+o,ih (8*t.

    Kr'i)io,+, o(,oi) * o, t**+*, , o,t*(t do6o97# o por*,* o(,oi)*.

    7(*t+,* t**+,ih rt*ri(ti i r(t;o,)*pt o* o(,oi)* , o(o8,o ri,i$ o i ,

    ri,i po'*/ por* , 'o8itF$ g+,i * *+**,t pr* t*t(* *'i,i)* oog 'i*+.

    Drg t*t( *'i,i) o',o(i (* , 8o9ro>"25 o por*, o(,oi)$ t. potro,i o,)*pt$

    ,*go ' t**+, o'*+ i ,*go* g+,* r+i* o',o( , 'oho'o,i o,)*pt. N*'*,o /*

    o8htiti o(o8, ri,$ o i po'*t,i ri,. %o(*8, (* p, pri'* hrt(o* o'*+$

    oi * pri i (' *'i,iF 'o(+*',i pri*r pri*,* t. +t*r,ti,og o'*+ o,)*pt potro,*M

    pr(i$ o i H++-!8(hi,o +t*r,ti,o o'*+ - t. $%at ta&u 8og ,*go* irit*

    t+,o(ti pr(i tr,i)i(ih 'r.

    N r /* (* tr*/o t*t(o *'i,i)i s5@!%9% #r;5="9% o:#25 7o"c8#9# oi pr(i

    'oo'* 'o hi8ri',og o'*+ por* , 'oho'$ t* priti o'*+ '+,og por* , 'oho' o

    r*+ti,o t*or*t(i ((t, hi8ri',i o'*+.

    0.-. DOHODA( (AO OSNOVICA IZRAVNO1 OPOREZIVANJA '

    DOHODOVNI (ONCEPT

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    17/224

    r+i * to* ho/* +i (* opor*iti s#=o o"% do6oc% 7o2% "#s9#25 %3 s9#!"%6 %34or# i+i (

    pri, 8* o8ir , t**+ ,iho ,(t,.

    N,,ii pr*'(t,i t*ori* ior 5 5$= s=%s!5 PQ*++*,th*ori*PF * ,*i

    t*or*tir i(ti,g oi 'oho' '*&i,ir o 'sveukupnost onih ekonomskih dobara koja svake !odine

    pritjeu pojedincu iz trajnih izvora' pr* A,'*+$ 1993.$ (tr. 290F. Bit, *$ '+*$ rdo4%9os9

    prit*), priho' i o'r*J*,ih ior. 7 * t*ori t*)+ , *,g+*(i por* , 'oho' to *

    i'+io po(*8,o por* , pit+, 'o8itF$ t* i , *,i pr(i por* , 'oho'. N*i,

    pri(t,o(t i'+i *$ *Jti$ i (i o(t+i ((ti por* , 'oho'$ pri* (*g to* to

    (* po(*8,i por*i opor* ,(+*'(t i 'roi$ o i (+,i 'o8i)i - ,pr. o,i o' igr , (r*/.

    = t*ori ior 5 >%r= s=%s!5 8r (* o ,** (ro',* t*ori* S)ho+*r$ Sith$ H*r,

    i Coh,$ !o()h*r$ H*)*+$ Rg,*r$ o)*$ Li*&,< pr* o'i/$ 1994.$ (tr. 363F$ o to (

    t*ori potro,og &o,'$ t*ori p*rio'i,o(ti$ t*ori proio',* i t*ori priho'.Tor%2# 8o9ro>"o; fo"d# 'ohoto (tr o, o+ii, 'o8r o po*'i,) i*(,o

    r**,(o r'o8+ o* potroiti po'ir*,* (oih potr*8$ ' ,* pogor (o* po*t,o

    ioi,(o (t,* S)ho++*r< pr* o'i/$ 1994.$ (tr. 36-3F. 7 i'* 'i*+i i Sith.

    @,i+io *$ *Jti$ (po*,ti$ ' ?*'o o'8or o '*&i,i)i1pro (tr (i,o,io

    P(*o8ht,i 'oho'P (+' ( t*orio prir(t 8ogt(t.

    Tor%2# 8r%od%@"os9% ii ( ,,,ii pr*'(t,i)i H*r, i Coh,$ ,'i pr*tpo(t '

    * *', o' 8it,ih *t 'ohot ,*goo r*'oito po,+,* o'r*J*,i r**,(i r)i.

    Tor%2# 8ro%34od"2 ii ( ,iritii pr*'(t,i)i Lot$ !o()h*r$ H*)*+ i Rg,*r$

    ' h t t i ' i ' ti i ' t i i i+i

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark4http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark4
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    18/224

    (i ,r,o$ oir 'oho'o,* o,)*p)i*F prih/*, P(*o8ht,i 'oho'P (i(+

    t*ori* prir(t 8ogt(t$ t. t*ori* r**,$ t*h,i ,*goog trJi, i prti, o'(tp, de

    $acto *+ii 'i*+o potrJ pri(t,o(t t*ori* ior. K pri(tp ,+io i o' hrt(og

    @o, o por* , 'oho' NN 1>>;2004.$ +. 5F.

    0.-.0. Tor%2# 8r%r#s9# :o;#9s94#< Sc6#"3'H#%;'S%=o"so4 do6od#7 ' >%r% do6odo4"%

    7o"c89

    K*or*t(* t**+* ir* 'oho'o,o o,)*pt$ g'* (* 'oho' '*&i,ir o r+i prir(tF

    ioi,i 8ogt(tF i*J r,*g i po*t,og (t, t. t*ori r**,MF po(tio * Sc6#"3.

    %r* ,* * 'oho' 'jednak akumu%aciji bo!atstva u odreenom vremenskom razdob%ju,

    uk%juuju"i i vrijednost us%u!a koje dobivamo od dru!ih' pr* ?(gr*$ 1990.$ (tr. 32F. D*&i,ir,

    o prirast o',o(,o po*/,* 8ogt(t i potro,F$ 'oho' po(t* ,*oi(, o *(t+o(ti$

    r*+i)ii i+i ior. N*goi (,ii *rii (+*'8*,i)i 8i+i ( H#%; oi 'oho' '*&i,ir o

    'pove"anje i%i prirast sna!e (sposobnosti) u zadovo%jenju potreba u danom periodu, koja se sastoji od

    ) novca, i%i *) bi%o e!a +to se moe novano vrednovati' pr* Kip*$ 191.$ (tr. 66F i S%=o"s

    pr* i* * i+*, 'oho' 'a%!ebarski zbroj ) tri+ne vrijednosti potro+nje i *) promjene u

    vrijednosti imovine izmeu poetka i kraja odreeno! razdob%ja' pr* Kip*$ 191.$ (tr. 66F.27',o(,o 8ro (ih 8'/ih og/ih potro,i (*'*,ih , (', ri*',o(t pr* o'i&i)ir,o &or+)ii oo'*190.$ (tr. 50F

    Sr**, * ,,o(t o ,i &i,,)i (i,t*tiir/i ,*'*,* t*or*tir* prihti+ t.

    S 6 H % S% 7 %2 S H S d 6 d 7 9 9 7% %d ! t +

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark5
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    19/224

    -./012 ()

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    20/224

    oo - o, 'oho'$ /potro,$ 12pro*, ,*to 8ogt(t.3D 8i (* 'oho' ogo

    o,r*t,o tr'iti$ tr*8 pri/i ( (t+it ,*goog &orir,. 7'* t*ori prir(t goori o

    i,i)i+,o prir(t 8ogt(t (i(+ 8r%r#s9# 8o9"c%2#!" 8o9ro>"2 o',o(,o =o;5&"os9%

    8o9ro>"2 7o"o=s7 s"#;8* o8ir , to , oi (* ,i, i i oih ior o, (t**. N'+*$

    8it, * og/,o(t orit*,$ ,* ,*i,o (tr,o orit*,*$ o to * to (+ ' * potro,

    pot*+ por*,* (po(o8,o(ti.=o+io (* ( 2i o,i 8ogt(to , po*t r'o8+ i, i * t (r)pr*'i'+i$ (i

    (i prii)i oi ,* pot* o' 8ogt(t$ o to ( ,',i)*$ tr,(&*ri i (+. i oi prit* , r

    r'o8+ i, o i t$ o* (* (tr'iti ' *

    20j . i 0 (0r)2i # d (*)

    to (* o* iriti i r,ot*,i o',o(o$ t. ' *

    d012i . i 0 r23 (4)37'* * o'h potr*8,o ,g+(iti ' t*ri,i Ppotro,P i P8ogt(toP ,i( '*&i,ir,i a priori, */ * to 't por*,*po+iti*.47'* (* (+i,o o i (+ '*&i,ir, orit*, 'ohot$ t. t*ri, Ppotro,*P i P8ogt(tP$ otr pit,*opr',o(ti po*'i,ih PtrooP$ o',o(,o o(tri, ,*to ,*+ o* * r*+ti,o *',o(t,i* o(triti o' ,*ih'oho'$ ,pr. o' 'ohot o' (o(t+,* '*+t,o(ti$ 'o * o' o(t+ih t**$ to ' o pro8+*ti po,o,o 'oti*pro8+*ti por*,ih o+i).

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark7http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark7http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark7http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark7
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    21/224

    tr*8+i 8iti ,*,i troo* ,iho (t*),$ o i **,t+,* 'rg* i't* oi (* ,* 8i

    og+i (trti potro,o.4

    Npo(+*t$ o(,oi) 8i tr*8+ o8htiti i ( ,(+*'(t i 'ro*$ (+,* 'o8it* ,pr. o,* o'

    igr , (r*/F i ,o,* protri*',o(ti (+g tr*/ih o(o8 i (ih o(t+ih og/ih ori(ti S)h,9d"2 5

    9r"5975 "23%"o; for=%r#"2# 92. od:%2#"2= >9d"2 od 8or3" os"o4%c 8or3# "# do6od#7)standardni model* %!% 8#7 7#s"%2%= "o8or3%4#"2= 8r%"os# od 9 >9d"2 ' do6od#7# od7#8%9#!# )alternativni model*. 78o* i i (o* 'o't,* (p*)i&i,* ip+i)i* , ri,i

    po'*t,iih (8*t. Stog (* ,(t o:# =od!# %3!#$5 "# oso:"o2 r#3%"% % "# r#3%"%8od539"%@7%6 s5:27#9#.

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark98http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark98http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark99http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark99http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark98http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark99
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    36/224

    potro, ( (p*t por*,* *',o(ti goro * i A' Sith 1>>6.< pr* ?(gr*$ 1990.

    199.F$ (tr. 339F. = (+' ( (*ti)io prit,(* *ti* ?Z R*8*r 1905.< pr* ?(gr*$

    1990. 199.F$ (tr. 339F 8i+o * i +g,* por* , potro,$ ( o8iro , to ' (* t*', (tr+

    r+i,o. "oh, Strt ?i++ (* (r*'i,o '**t,*(tog (to+*/ toJ*r i(,io proti 'o(trog

    opor*i, t*',* ?i++$ 165.$ (tr. 402< pr* 1990. 199.F$ (tr. 339F$ ( ti* ' ( ,*goi

    rg*,ti i+i i(t,tii *o,o(i ,g+( /i , pro8+* 'i(rii,)i*$ t. 'o(trog

    opor*i, t*',*$ t* (*i tog ,* (o *o,o(* *&i(,o(ti$ */ i horio,t+,* pr*',o(ti.

    N pro8+* 'o(trog opor*i, t*',* i+i ( i ?r(h++$ Ei,'i i %igo. Niho riti

    'i*+i i "o(*ph A. S)hp*t*r$ oi ,+* ,*(t, por* , 'oho' *',o ( *o,o(i

    ((to i *,t+it*to grJ,(og +i8*r+i$ o* t por* i 'g* (o *gi(t*,)i

    1923.;1930.< pr* !o(*$ 1990. 199.F$ (tr. 3F.

    @,, 'opri,o( oo o,)*pt 'o * Iri,g i(h*r i(h*r$ 193>.< pr* !o(*$ 1990.

    199.F$ (tr. 3F$ po/i ' (* os"o4%c# oog por* prti,o o* tr'iti i o r#3!%7# %3=G5

    do6o97# % >9d"2. Ki* * ot+o,*, ,*'o(tt op/*g por* , potro, (i(+ ,*go*

    ,*ir,o(ti i o8*t,o(ti$ o',o(,o$ po,o * i ' opor*i,* potro,* o* 8iti ir,o t* '

    o por* o* *ti o8ir o(o8,* oo+,o(ti por*,og o8*,i$ po *+i o* 8iti i progr*(i,.%ri * pr(i o o,)*pt '*t+,i* rr'io i prii*,io Ni)ho+( #+'or I,'ii 195.-

    1962.F i ' pt ri L,i 195.-1962.< 19>6.-19>.F. Io ,*(p*h oih po *(to (+i o

    *', o' g+,ih rg*,t proti,i)i oog por*$ tr*8 ,po*,ti ' (* ,i* r'i+o o

    i(+io ir,o o(o8,o por*$ */ o (por*',o 'op,i por* , 'oho' oo'*$ 190.$ (tr.

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    37/224

    7',o(,o$ *',o(t,i* r**,o$ ' (* o' +(i,og$ t. (i,t*tiog 'ohot po*'i,) o'* ,*go

    o(o8, t*',$ 8og *g (* o por* o o* i por* , 'oho' ,*, t*', oi/*, o'

    t*',*F !o(* i !o(*$ R*,g*r$ r+iiti r'oiF.

    %rito (* i8*g pro8+* pro)*,* priho' o' prir(t ri*',o(ti ioi,* pit+,i

    'o8i)iF *r o,i i(to'o8,o pr*'(t+ i t*', t* (* o,' ,* or +iti ,iti priho'* o'

    pit+ 8ogt(tF$ ,iti t*',. =o+io (* i i iptir,i 'oho)i$2> o (* por*,i o8+i$

    o ,* po*',o(t+*,$ s4od% "# 934. %ash lo/ 8or3. ?*Jti$ (,i,* po(to*/*g

    8ogt(t$ '+* ,*goo tro*,*$ toJ*r * opor*io$ o i tro*,* Pt*/*gP 'ohot.

    %ri(t,* ( r+iit* rr'* i ri)i* por* , o(o8,* r(ho'*$ +i * (i *',io

    (top,o opor*i,* go'i,* potro,* i* (* *+ii,ir pro8+* 'i(rii,)i*$ o',o(,o

    'o(trog opor*i, t*',* *r (* o, o o'8it, (t ,* opor** pro)*( ,*i,og

    ,(t,. = K8+i)i 1 pri, * op/ (h* r*+*,t, ir, go'i,* potro,*.

    T#:!%c# -< I3r#@5" oso:"o; %ash lo/ 8or3#

    %or*,o r*+*,t,i prii)i [F %or*,o r*+*,t,i i')i -F1F 'oho' o' r'

    2F 'oho' o' pit+3F tr,(&*r,i 'oho)i iroi,*$ potpor*F4F po+*,* ,o) ( P+i&i)ir,ihPr, (,*,* t*',*F

    1F tr,(&*r,i i')i (o)i+,o o(igr,*F

    2F p+t* , +i&i)ir,* r,*3F i')i (t*),* 'ohot4F por*,* o+i)*

    Do6od#7 - 0 + 9d"2# % os9#!% od:%c% - 0 + *ti r*'iti\ otp+t* g+,i)* r*'it i t*\'o8i*, ,(+*'(t i 'roi ', ,(+*'(t i 'roi

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark30http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark30
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    38/224

    consumption), 'o (* (+ ' (* ,* o'8i r'i o potro,i pr* iot,o (t,'r'

    (standard#o$#%ivin!#consumption) pr* Br'&or'$ 192.$ (tr. 24-250 i 194.$ (tr. 30-31F.

    %o(*8, * pro8+* tr*t, 'goro,ih potro,ih 'o8r po(*8,o ,*r*t,i,F. K*ori(i *

    pri+,i* tr*tirti p, o i,*(ti)i$ t. i' t*',* - '+*$ o o'8it, (t$ pri * 8i (*

    o,' r+iit ri*',o(t orit*, iptir, ri*',o(t 8or +(tito /i i (+.F$ o i prii)i

    o' pro'* tr*tir+i o pri8it,* (t*. N*'*, t*or*t( 'o(+*',o(t ri*'i por* , o(o8,*

    r(ho'*$ 'o 8i (trit,o poti,* cash $%o5 ,*+ o* (* 8iti +* Br'&or'F hti*+o

    +*,* (o ,o,ih priit '+*$ i(+*,* ri*',o(ti 8'/ih potroih (+g:

    iptir,* r*,t* i (+.F. Ko 8i r**,*$ *Jti$ po,o,o 8i+o ,*'o(+*',o. I/i , t*o/*

    pro)*,i, iptir,* r*,t* i o(t+ih o8+i 8'/ih potroih (+g$ i(+*,* ,*'*,ih

    tr,()i i ir,$ t. tr*tir,* p,* tr,ih potro,ih 'o8r o potro,* i,i (*

    priht+iii r**,*2 Br'&or'$ 194.$ (tr. 10-109F. ?*Jti$ o'* (* + pro8+*

    pr**+iog por*,og opt*r*/*, o' *,* por*,o pri,tog o8+i t*',* por*,o ,*pri,ti

    p, /*F. K 8i (* pro8+* og+o ri*iti$ pri*ri)*$ r+iiti t*h,i P*',,P

    (avera!in!), (+i,o o o' tr*t, 'goro,og pit+,og 'o8it. D+,i * pro8+*

    rgr,i,* i,*(ti)i 'goro, potro, 'o8r +(tit* potr*8* i o*r)i+,* potr*8*

    ,pr. i,+i,* i (+.F$ *r (* 'rgo (+ r'i o por*,o r*+*,t,i prii)i i i')i.2A+t*r,ti,o 8i (* toJ*r og+o gooriti o t*',i o (* pri*,* +t*r,ti,i prepa>ment o'*+. No. ( 'rg*(tr,*$ (r*'(t g'* ( og/i */i pit+,i 'o8i)i tr*8+ 8i 8iti r*gi(trir, St,o,i$ 199. (tr. 101F. 29%o(to,* op)i*i,i Br'&or'o ri,t por* , o(o8,* r(ho'* por* , 'oho' ,*,og t*',F hi8ri'o i*J oogpor* i +t*r,ti,og o'*+ por* , 'oho' o' r'$ por* , 'oho' ,*,og tF. #' 8i (* ( t*',o'i+ pr*o +i&i)ir,ih r,$ r'i+o 8i (* o PproP por* , o(o8,* r(ho'*$ +i * i'+io ' * o, prti,o

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark31http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark31
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    39/224

    #r*'iti og i+i ,* og 8iti por*,o r*+*,t,i. =o+io (* i pr*o +i&i)ir,ih

    r,$ opor*o,i ( +* o(,oi)F$ t* (* o,' i ,iho otp+t g+,i) i t*F (tr

    t*',o. = proti,o (+ r*'iti ,i( por*,o o8h/*,i.3030= *i ', r*'it$ o* (* +iti ' * o,o$ popt ,*go* otp+t*$ por*,o ir*+*,t,o o (* ri io+i&i)ir,ih r,. =o+io (* o8+ pr*o ,ih$ r'i (* (o o *',o o' og/ih tr,()i pr*o ,*'*,og r,.

    Bro,i ( i*'8*,i pri*'+oi r+iitih o'*+ ir,og o(o8,og opor*i, potro,* ,

    ri,i po*'i,) (t,'r',o o8+i o'8i,* t*',*F31$ o to ( i ="o;o:ro2"% orit*,i "#3%4%

    31

    = ,(t (* ,o'* (o ,** ,,,i*:Br'&or'o pri*'+og ir,og opor*i, potro,* ,(toi (i+,o i(ori(titi og/,o(t i,'ii'+i)i*

    oog por*,og o8+i +/i (* ir, progr*(i$ t* r+iit* o(o8,* i o(t+* por*,* o+i)*$ +io i o,* troo* (t*), 'ohot.

    %oi*(,o * oo pri*'+og pr*tho'io */ (po*,ti #+'oro pr* #i(*r$ 1992.$ (tr. >->9F$ g'* o(,oi)por* , o(o8,* r(ho'* (e&penditure ta&) +* p+/*$ t*$ 'ii'*,'* i o(t+i prii)i i po'*t,i* '*+t,o(ti$'o8i*, ,(+*'(t i 'roi$ pri,o(i o' i,*(ti)i$ 'o8i*,i r*'iti$ o i 'o8i*,* otp+t* r*'it. #o o'8it,* (t*+ (* t*J*,i 'i*+oi 'ohot$ i,*(ti)i(i i')i$ ', i otp+t* r*'it$ t* p+/, t. S* p,* 'goro,ihpotro,ih 'o8r o(i +(titog 'oF ,* og (* o'8iti o' por*,* o(,oi)* (tr (* potro,oF$ 'o (* (t,o,*tr*tir o i ( 'rg i,*(ti)i. D, ,(+*'(t i 'roi (*$ ,** ,* i*t* +i*,t)i* i 'r,F$ ,*og o'8iti o' por*,* o(,oi)* P8i+ity to pyP ,*+o$ t. ,*+o por*,* (po(o8,o(tiF.

    P=,i*r(+ EZp*,'itr* KZP pr*'+o*, o' (tr,* t. ?*'oog o'8orM ?*'*-Coitt** - IS$ 19>.$ (tr.1>5-204F$ (+i,o o i Br'&or'o pri*'+og o P+i&i)ir,i r,iP$ potr*8+ t*ri,* Pr*gi(trir,P i P,*r*gi(trir,tiP. ?*Jti$ r+i o' Br'&or'$ ', ,(+*'(t i 'roi ( opor*ii ('abi%it> to pa>' ,*+oF. %or*, (top *progr*(i,$ +i ( *+ii '*+o prog por*,og rr*'.

    #o,)*pt por* , o(o8,* r(ho'* (e&penditure ta&) S*,-7+o& Lo'i, Lo'i,$ 19>.$ pr* #i(*r$ 1992.$ (tr.

    2F i(ti* (* (p*)i&i,i tr*t,o 'goro,ih potro,ih 'o8r g'* (* o,$ 'o'*$ tr*tir o potro,$ +i (pr*'iJ*,* po(*8,* por*,* *r* oi (* to i,o i(oo por*,o opt*r*/*,* r(por*J* , '* r**,(or'o8+*. D, ,(+*'(t i 'roi ( opor*ii.

    #o,)*pt Aro, i +p*r Aro, i +p*r$ pr* i8.F ,, cash $%o5por*o , 'oho' (cash$%o5 incometa&) o'gor o,o* ?*'*. D, ,(+*'(t i 'roi ( opor*ii$ 'gotr, potro, 'o8r tr*tir (* o potro,$ t*(* pri*,* ir, i ,*ir, progr*(i.

    #y i #i,g ( (o pri*'+og o8+i por* , o(o8,* r(ho'* ,+i P+i&*ti* *Zp*,'itr* tZP. !+og +*i i,*,i)i to *$ (+i,o o i o' Br'&or' i ,*ih (,iih pri*'+og$ o(t+*, op)i tr*t, ,*ih o8+i t*',* po

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark32
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    40/224

    o4o; o:!%7# ,pr. por* , o(o8,* r(ho'*;i't* - p*r(o,+ *Zp*,'itr* tZM$ cash#$%o5 por*$

    (t,'r',i o'*+$ tr'i)io,+,i o'*+$ por* , o(o8,F potro,$ ,*ogr,i*,i o'8it t*', -

    =,+iit*' Si,g A++o,)*FF =SA tZMF$ por* , 'oho' oi/*, o' t*',* ; ,*,

    t*', - Spr8*r*i,igt* Ei,o*,(t**rM - Si,g(-'(t*' *Z)+(i*F p*r(o,+ i,)o* tZMF. =

    ,oi* (* ri** por* , o(o8,* r(ho'* , ,g+o((o,(o po'r (t+io i ,i Ppor* ,

    potro*,i 'oho'P CIK - P)o,(*' i,)o* tZPF$ pr* pri*'+og *riog ?i,i(tr(t

    &i,,)i =S Kr*(ry CIKMF ?)Lr* *t +.$ 1995.$ (tr. 4< A*r8)h$ 2006.$ (tr. 1>F$ io (* (*

    */* *',o(t,o ori(ti ir )o,(ptio, tZM ,pr. r*++*$ 1994.< A*r8)h$

    2006.F.

    I(to to$ og/i ($ o to * */ i(ti),o$ i r+iiti =%2>#"% o:!%c% oi o8i,ir

    +t*r,ti,i o'*+ (prepa>ment) ( (t,'r',i$ o i *', o'*+ , ri,i &iiih o(o8 -

    ,*po'*t,i$ ( 'rgi , ri,i po'*t,iih (8*t &iiih o(o8$ o',o(,o (ih

    po'*t,iih (8*tF.

    #o to * */ i(t,to$ 8og 'i,i(trti,* (+o*,o(ti po(*8i)* *i'*,tir, pro*t ,

    +i&i)ir,i r,iMF$ +i i r+og *rti+,* pr*',o(ti i &i(+,ih r+og$ "%9% 2d"# dr$#4#

    "%2 8r%=%2"%!# o4#2 =od!.

    No !="9% o4o; =od!# 5;r#G"% s5 5 ="o; s5s9#4 8or3# "# do6od#7. K (* pri*

    (*g i(+i , 9r9=#" =%ro4%"s7 >9d"2 +i i ,*ih o(t+ih o8+i t*',*. 78*, (* iroi,(

    t*', *',o ( o(t+i o8*,i 'opri,o(i (o)i+,o o(igr,*F pri+ o'8i o' por*,*

    32

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark33http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark33
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    41/224

    0.0.0. A!9r"#9%4"% =od! %3r#4"o; oso:"o; o8or3%4#"2# 8o9ro>"2

    @8og */* (+o*,o(ti t*ti* +t*r,ti,og o'*+ opor*i, , ri,i po*'i,)roo,* ,*goo */o prti,o pri*,io/$ o',o(,o pri*,io/ ,*goih

    *+**,t$ ,*'*, /* (* pro8+*ti r*+iirti ro (+i*'*/* t*t(* *'i,i)*: 9=!2"

    3"#@#27 #!9r"#9%4"o; =od!# oso:"o; o8or3%4#"2# 8o9ro>"2 8r%7#3 6r4#9s7o; 8or3# "#

    do6od#7 -)). ' 0-. oi * 8io *'i, 'o(+*', pri*, +t*r,ti,og o'*+ opor*i,

    potro,* pr(i$ 9 8r%7#3 H#!!'R#:5s67%"# =od!# lat ta#a8 oi * ,po,tii pri*r

    +t*r,ti,og o'*+.

    2.2.2.1. Temeljne znaajke alternativnog modela osobnog oporezivanja potronje

    %o' +t*r,ti,i o'*+o ir,og opor*i, potro,* i(+i (* , 8or3 "# do6od#7

    7o2% " 57!25@52 do6o97 od 7#8%9#!# 92. 7#=#95 5 >%r= s=%s!5 Tpor* , 'oho'

    ,*,;oi/*, t !o(*< !o(*$ R*,g*r$ r+iiti ioriFU$ t. 8or3 "# do6od#7 od r#d#.++

    I t*ori* * po,t2d"#7os9 %3r#4"o; 8or3# "# oso:"5 8o9ro>"25 o8,*,og 2.2.1.(t,'r',i o'*+F s 8or3o= "# s#=o 3#r#G"% do6od#7 do6od#7 od r#d#. =

    ,(t /* (* priti t**+,* ,* i ogr,i*, pr*tpo(t*F o* *',o(ti.

    %o+i (* o' po*',o(t+*,og o'*+ iot,og )i+($ oi (* ((toi o' ' r'o8+ ,pr.

    Stig+it$ 1999.$ (tr. 504< Br'&or'$ 190.$ (tr. 9>-99< #i(*r$ 1991.$ (tr. 23623F. = pro* po*'i,)

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark34http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark28http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark34http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark28
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    42/224

    g'* * 5 # 'oho' o' r'$ / #potro,$ @ # t*',$ pri * (8(ript o,$ ,r,o$ pro

    r'o8+* iotF. I ,*'*,og proi+i i r*+)i potro,

    / . 5 # @ ()

    = 'rgo r'o8+ po*'i,)$ o(i 'ohot o' r'$ i i pri,o( t**+* t* (r) o r*+tt

    pr*tho',* t*',*$ t* ( (o r(po+oi (r*'(t potroi$ to ' * t pro)*( og/* iriti

    r*+)io oo *

    /* . 5* 0 @ ( 0 r) (*)

    =rt,* po*t,* *',o(ti pr*tho', 'o8i (* i,t*rt*por+,o 8'*t(o ogr,i*,*

    /* . 5* 0 (5 # /) ( 0 r) (4)

    i *g proi+i ' *

    /* 0 / ( 0 r) . 5*0 5C ( 0 r) (7)

    o',o(,o

    /* 5*########## 0 / . ---------------- 0 2 (8)( 0 r ) ( 0 r )

    I ,*'*,* r*+)i* proi+i *',o(t (',* ri*',o(ti potro,* i 'ohot o' r' t*$ (+',oto*$ i ,i o por*,i o(,oi).

    = ,*to (+o*,io ri,ti$ t. o,o ( +*,i ,(+*'(ti (I), o',o(,o o(tti,o (D),

    o i i* r**,(ih r'o8+$ g'* i o, ,iho 8ro$ 'o8io:

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    43/224

    @8og tog to (* *i+*,)i potro,* i 'ohot o' r' ,*'*,* pr*tpo(t*F

    o(tr* t* , )*+oiot,o ri,i por* , 'oho' o' r' o* (* por*o , iot, potro,$

    r+i o' por* , o(o8,* r(ho'*$ oi (* o* i por*o , go'i, potro,. 7 (* por*$

    po' */ i(t,ti pr*tpo(t o'*+$ ,i i por*o , iot,i 'oho' 'oho' )i*+o

    iot,o )i+(F.

    ?*Jti$ ,*'*, *i+*,)i ri*'i (o po' pr*tpo(to propor)io,+,* i

    o,(t,t,* (top* por* , 'oho' o' r'$ *',o(ti 'i(o,t,* (top* i tri,* t,* (top*$

    o',o(,o (r*,og trit pit+ ',$ (igr, i *'i,(t*, t, (topF. 34 Stog t*or*t(i

    to,i ri,t oog o'*+ ip +* t* i,' P,or+,ihP t* opor*i,* ,(+*'(t i

    'ro.

    Do ( (tri* 'otri,* ir,og o(o8,og opor*i, potro,* i* i(ti)+* ior,i o'*+$

    ,oi* ri** (* (* r,opr,i* pri'r pri*'+oi +t*r,ti,og o'*+. !+og *

    ,*goo t**+,o por*,o-t*h,io pr*',o(ti -2d"os9#4"os9% o p(o+t,o pog+*'$ to i

    o',o( , */ (+i,o(t ( po(to*/i ((to opor*i, 'ohot i o+,i pri*+ , ,*'*,i

    o'*+.

    */ (* (po*,to Br'&or'oo o'*+ ir,og o(o8,og opor*i, potro,* +

    og/,o(tprepa>ment op)i*. 7, 'goro,o o(tr* i(t* i,* o i o'8i,* t*',* i ,*i,o

    (,i* opor*i,* (+ tro*,. K (* op)i +* o(tr* ro *',o(t,o por*,o

    ,*ri,* t*',* (i(+ o'8i,F$ o',o(,o (,iih priho' o' t*',* (i(+ +*,

    por*, o(,oi)F.

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark38http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark38
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    44/224

    !8(h*$ ,iho pri*'+og t*or*t(i por*, o(,oi) 'o(+*',i* +* pri+*, ,(+*'(t i

    'ro*. N'+*$ pr*'+* (* ir, progr*(i '+*$ o, ( i* ,oi,+,ih rgi,+,ih (topF.

    Atori (* o por* + po(*8i)* 8og ,*goih 'i,i(trti,ih pr*',o(ti o',o( , por*

    , o(o8,* r(ho'* - pri* (*g *',o(t,o(ti T?)Lr*$ "r.< @o'ro$ 199.1990.FU.

    7 * pr*',o(t po(*8,o , ,*ri*,* i tr,i)i(* 'r* ( ,*ri*,i ((to

    por*,* pr* i 8og tog i(oi trooi prip+, ior,og por* , potro,$ o

    por*,* o8*,i*$ to i por*, pr. =pro 8og tog ?)Lr*$ "r. i @o'ro T?)Lr*$ "r.

    1991.$ @o'ro$ ?)Lr*$ "r.$ 199.1990.FU$ o por* po(*8,o pr*'+ ,*ri*,* i tr,i)i(*

    'r*$ t* g$ i(ti/i o pr*',o(t$ o Ppo*',o(t+*,i +t*r,ti,i por*oP (@imp%i$ied

    1%ternative 9a& # @19)6 Io ,iho o'*+ 'oo+ +i,* r+iitih (t,'r',ih i

    ,*(t,'r',ih o+i) t* i* (top o i og/i pri*+ , o8it*+ o por*, *'i,i)F$ o* (*

    o'i&i)i* ,* pr*por ,*'*,* 'r* 'o (* 'oo+,o ,* ri* 'i,i(trti,

    i,&r(trtr.

    ?*J '+,i pr*'+gt*+i oog o'*+ i(ti (* o E776#rd ";r % M#"frd

    Ros !o(* i !o(*$ R*,g*r$ r+iiti r'oi< #i(*r$ 1992.F. Do R*,g*r gor ii,*

    pri+*,ih ,(+*'(t i 'ro i por*,* o(,oi)*36$ 'rgi * ,ihoo +*,*. K**+,

    pr*',o(t ,ihoog o'*+ * t to ($ oii t**+,i ,*'o(tt +t*r,ti,og o'*+ o',o( ,

    (t,'r',i - por*,o ,*o8h/,* i,'pro(*,ih 'oho' o' pit+$ origir+i ,*opor*i,

    'oho' o' pit+ (o i,o(* i(i,i (t,'r',* t*. @ pro(i)i P(t,'r',*P

    t* pr*'+o*, * t , 'r,* o8*,i)*.

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark39http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark39http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark126http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark135
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    45/224

    7#8%9#!# od"os"o "2%6o4o :!#$ o8or3%4#"2.N*'*,o * '*t+,i* r+o*,o 3.1.1. i 3.1.2.$

    o i 2.3.5.

    2.2.2.2. Hrvatski porez na dohodak 1994. - 2001. jedina dosljedna primjena alternativnogmodela oporezivanja potronje ! praksi

    T=!2"# 7#r#79r%s9%7# #!9r"#9%4"o; =od!#< "o8or3%4#"2 7#=#9 5 >%r= s=%s!5 92.

    s4%6 do6od#7# od 7#8%9#!# 5 Hr4#9s7o2 ;o9o4o 2 dos!o4"o 8ro4d"#. Por3"5 os"o4%c5 @%"%!% s5

    s#=o do6oc% od r#d# - ,*(o(t+,og +/i i iroi,*F i (o(t+,og$ t. (o(t+,*

    '*+t,o(tiM pr* hrt(o por*,o t*ri,o+ogii. D*t+,i* opor*i,* (o(t+,* '*+t,o(ti$ t.

    o8rt,i$ o8,*,o * *',o ( o,',i ((to por* , 'o8it 2.2.4.7'* /* (* (o

    ,g+(iti ' (* o' po'*t,i$ 8i+o ' ( (* opor*i+i por*o , 'oho' o8rt,i)iF$ 8i+o

    por*o , 'o8it trgo 'rtF$ opor*i+ (o ,tpro(*, 'o8it$ t. 'oho' pt*

    i,(titt t. tit,* t*M$ to ,i ' (* ,or+,i 'oho)i o' pit+ ,i( opor*i+i.

    7(,oi) por* , 'oho' ,8o+* i+(trir K8+i) 2.

    T#:!%c# 0< Os"o4%c# 8or3# "# do6od#7 5 Hr4#9s7o2 -)).'0-.

    Doho' o' ,*(o(t+,og r' - p+/

    [ 'oho' o' ,*(o(t+,og r' - iroi,

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark126http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark126http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark135http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark112http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark112http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark79http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark126http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark135http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark112http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark79http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark35
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    46/224

    #o to * */ i(ti),o 2.2.2.1.$ o' +t*r,ti,og (* o'*+ (oo *',o(t,o ri,ti

    po+* pro8+* ,*opor*i, ,tpro(*,ih 'oho' o' pit+$ to (* pri+ r* to '

    (* o,i or 'o't,o opor*iti (o to (* o(tr* *i+*,)i ( (t,'r',i o8+ioF. No$

    "#98ros2@"% %3"#d"or=#!"% do6oc% od 7#8%9#!# o8or3%4#!% s5 s 5 Hr4#9s7o2 s#=o "#

    8od539"%@7o2 r#3%"% por* , 'o8it$ opor*i,* 'oho' o' (o(t+,* '*+t,o(tiF. #o' &iiih

    o(o8 - grJ, ,*po'*t,iF i (i r*tori o'*+ !o(*$ R*,g*r$ 1993.F pri,+i ( ,,o(t

    ,iho opor*i,$ +i ( i r+og *',o(t,o(ti o' ,*g o'(t+i. N*opor*i,* ,tpro(*,ih

    'oho' o' pit+ 8r,i+i ( ,o *rot,o/$ o',o(,o *(t+o/ o(tr*, ,tpro(*,ih

    pri,o( o' pit+ , ri,i &iiih o(o8 ,*po'*t,i. N*'*,o o'(tp,* o' ,*tr+,o(ti

    po(*8,o * ,,o i(o* pit+,* 'o8it* ,pr. o' ri*',o(,ih ppirF$ oi ( rt*riir+i

    gotoo (* tr,i)i(* 'r*$ po(*8,o po*t,i go'i,. @ o,',* (t,* Hrt(o tr*8

    o ,g+(iti i i(o* t* o r*+tt ,*'o(tt pit+. %oto,i (+*i 8i+i ($ o to /* (*

    i'*ti 2.2.4.2.$r*+*,t,i ,* (o grJ,*$ */ i o8rt,i*$ ( o8iro ' ( (* o8ir i+*

    (o ,iho* r*+,* ,* i &i,,)i(* tr,()i*F.39 #o,(ori*,ti*rt* N*or',,g '*( St**r(y(t*(M !*&or por*,og ((t (*r*, potro,iF -t. H*i'*+8*r grpM40 %r*'+g+i ( i(ti tr*t, o i o8rt,i*

    #o to (* i'i i K8+i)* 2 (ita%ic tekst), 6r4#9s7% 2 8or3 "# do6od#7 %8#7 8o=#!o

    ods958#o od r!4#"9"o; 9or9s7o; =od!# 7od 9r9=#"# %=o4%" % 9o 7od "7r9"%"#+/ oi *$

    (prot,o pri*'+oi #NS grp*39 !o(*$ R*,g*r$ 1993.F40$ irito 'oho'o,og rt*r$

    ,*go* o8i*,* ,*'o(tt* ,,* i ,** ri*,* 'r*. Ni*$ opor** (* 'oho' o'

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark35http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark35http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark87http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark87http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark87http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark35http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark87http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark43
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    47/224

    *',o ( o(t+i o8*,i 'opri,o(i (o)i+,o o(igr,*F o'8i o' por*,* o(,oi)* ,*

    opor** (* por*o , 'oho'F. No, pr*(t, p+t 'opri,o($ t. ' o o8+i t*',*

    pr*(t* i ' poi,* t*/i i(p+t iroi,$ iroi,* +* por*, o(,oi) por* , 'oho'$ t.

    opor*i* (.

    #o,,o$ i K8+i)* 2 i'i (* i ' * 6r4#9s7% =od! 5 8o985"os9% s!%2d%o 8r8or57 ,*

    (o H++-!8(hi, i o(t+ih +t*r,ti,ih o'*+ o i$%at ta&pri*'+ogF$ */ % 8or3" rfor=

    os#=ds9%6 % d4ds9%6-i* ( i'** t+,* o i ',($ po(*8i)* tr,i)i(i 'rF$ o

    57%d#"25 s4%6 "s9#"d#rd"%6 o!#7>%c#. Ko ( Hrt(o i(ti, po(to+* (o o(o8,* i

    o8it*+(* o+i)* t* o,* o8*,* 'opri,o(* (o)i+,o o(igr,*. %oto,$ (+i,o o i ('$

    &or+,o i ,* rt*r por*,* o+i)* o'8itF$ */ (* (tr i'to pri trJi, 'ohot

    o' ,*(o(t+,og r'$ t. ,iti ,* +i ,*to 'oho'$ o',o(,o 'oho'M pr* hrt(o por*,o

    t*ri,o+ogii.

    Io o,',i hrt(i por* , 'oho'$ o ,i o(t+i ((ti por* , 'oho' (i*t$

    "%2 57!25@%4#o "#s!2ds94# % d#ro4 Hrt(o (* to o,o ri** ip og+o o*iti. +,i *

    r+og pro (p*)i&i,o(t o'*+ +t*r,ti,i o8+i i pr*tpo(t* o *i+*,)ii ( (t,'r',i

    o8,*,* 2.2.2.1.F. N'+*$ i,*,i) '$ o i o(t+i 'r$ Hrt(o toJ*r po(toi i

    po(too *F por* , ,(+*'(t i 'ro* o po(*8, por* oi i , (,g 8og tog to$

    r+i o' */i,* o(t+ih *+$ oo* por* ,*'o(t* 'o(tr progr*(i 42 t* ( ,8+ii

    (ro',i)i i*ti.

    N* tr*8 ,iti (poi,ti ' * %3os9#o i 8or3 "# %=o4%"5 oi ( pr*'+g+i i ,*i o'

    2 2 2 , "l t t H ll $ b hki d l j tiji i j lt ti d l i t li

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark44http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark36http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark36http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark44http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark44http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark44http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark36http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark44
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    48/224

    2.2.2.,. "lat ta# Hall-$ab!shkin model - najpoznatiji primjer alternativnog modela i ostaliobli%i

    @8og t+,o(ti t*ti* $%at ta&a i +( oog o8+i opor*i, 'ohot por*,*

    ((t* (' (o tr,i)i(ih 'r$ oo t*ti)i (* po(*/* po(*8, t*t( *'i,i). #o

    8i (* '*t+,i* i+(trir+ o pro8+*ti$ po,o+*, * i 'io gr'i i ,ih &i,,)i.

    N* '*t,og hrt(og pri*o' ir &+t tZM. N'o(+*',i* 8i g (* og+o pr**(ti

    o 8or3 s 2d"o= ,oi,+,o - gr,i,oF 8or3"o= s9o8o=. 78i,o (* o' ,( pr*o'i opropor)io,+,i por*M$ to o* (toriti 8, (tog to $%at ta& o*$ +i i ,* or 8iti

    propor)io,+,. = pr*tho',o (* (+ r'i o to* ' (* , por*, o(,oi) pri*,* (o

    *', por*, (top i prito ,* o(o8,og o'8it ,iti ,** 'rg* o(,o,* (t,'r',* o(o8,*

    o+i)*. Ko * pri propor)io,+,i por*.43No$ (i *$%at ta& o' por* , 'oho' i t*orii$

    pogotoo pr(iF %"d%r79"o 8ro;rs%4#" 8or3 o to /* (* ,(t o8(,iti.

    Io * ,*go "#28o3"#9%2# 4#r%2#"9# o,t*(t potro,* o por*,* o(,oi)* H#!!'

    R#:5s67%" =od! $%at ta& (* o* prii*,iti i , 'oho'. Ni* (i $%at ta& i(+io H++-

    !8(hi, o'*+$ por*, t*ori +i ,* i pr(F */ ',o po,* i(+io i,'ir*t,

    progr*(i.44

    F%at ta& (*$ o to ( ri* *$ o',o(i , por*, (top. i,,)i( ,,o(t ,pr.!o(*,$ 1999.$ (tr. 2>>F ,g+ r+i i*J gr,i,* rgi,+,*F i pro(*,* por*,* (top*.

    %r * (oo ,*',o(t,io ri,ti *', ,oi,+,i gr,i,i (top45,pr. Hrt(o

    (' io *tiri (top*: 15W$ 25W$ 35W i 45WF. ?,ogi pro por(t o* gr,i,* (top*$ t. i*

    rgi,+,ih (top o* r(t o r(t* 'oho'$ (tr progr*(io. K (+ * t. 'ir*t,

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    49/224

    No$ 8it, * r(t pro(*,*$ ,* gr,i,* (top*. %ro(*, (* (top 'o8i* to ' (* (ti

    o',o( p, por* ( p,i 'ohoto o',o(,o por*,o o(,oi)oF. !(t o* pro(*,*

    por*,* (top* (tr (* progr*(io.46Ko * og/* ' io (o *', por*, (top ($%at ta&),

    '+*$ &or+,o propor)io,+, (top$ ip o(tr*o progr*(i.

    !+og to * *gi(t*,)i+,i i,i oi (* ,* opor**$ t. o'8it o' por*,* o(,oi)*

    o(,o,i o(o8,i o'8it (+',o hrt(o por*,o t*ri,o+ogiiF.N*'*,o /* (* i+(trirti r+o *',o(t,i pri*ro K8+i)i 3.4> %r*tpo(t+ (*

    ,*opor*ii i,o( - o(o8,i o'8it o' 3.000 ,o,ih *'i,i) (tp) 2F. @8og tog (* por*, (top

    o' 20W pri*,* , ,*, o(,oi) (tp) 3F$ to 'o't,o ,* i,o( por* (tp) 5F.

    K8+i) 3: I,'ir*t, progr*(i

    ohodak :eoporezivi iznos; osobni odbitak

    oreznaosnovi%a

    orezna stopa)granina* 20 1-2 4 ? > ,@4 A > ?B13.000 3.000 0 0$2 0 05.000 3.000 2.000 0$2 400 0$0

    10.000 3.000 >.000 0$2 1.400 0$1430.000 3.000 2>.000 0$2 5.400 0$160.000 3.000 5>.000 0$2 11.400 0$19

    Ior: !o(*,$ 1999.$ (tr. 2>> i "*+i/$ 2001.$ (tr. 94 o8r'i+ tori)F

    i'+io * ' s94#r"# 8ros2@"# 8or3"# s9o8# o (* 'o8i* ' (* i,o( por* po'i*+i (

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark48http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark45http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark48
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    50/224

    r&io, 1 pri* tr*,t,i 2006. go'i,F hrt(i por*,i ((t ( *tiri gr,i,* por*,*

    (top* (por*'8i ( 'i* ri,t*$%at ta&a:pro ( por*,o (topo o' 20W i o(o8,i o'8ito

    o' 3.000 ,$ t* 'rgo ( por*,o (topo o' 15W i o(o8,i o'8ito4>!'i (* o t**+,o gr'i ,ih &i,,)i - o,+tirti ,pr. !o(*,$ 1999.$ (tr. 2>>< "*+i/$ 2001.$ (tr. 9495

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    51/224

    'oho'

    L;"d#< 6r4#9s7% 8or3 "# do6od#7 oso:"% od:%9#7 -., 7" s9o8 -*0* +* % *

    GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG$%at ta& oso:"% od:%9#7 -., 7" s9o8# 0GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG$%at ta& oso:"% od:%9#7 +. 7" s9o8# -*

    i'+io * ' o8* ri,t*$%at ta&a i(o* 'ohot* pr*+* propor)io,+,o(t$ 'o *

    8ro;rs%4"os9 3#64#!2525&% oso:"o= od:%975 4!%7# s#=o , po*t$ t. 3# "%$ do6o97.

    N*'*,i i, (* (pr* o' (',*g hrt(og por* , 'oho' 8og tog to (o

    r&io, 1: =(por*'8 (',*g hrt(og ((t por* , 'oho' ( '* ri,t$%at ta&a6

    i F 'i + ' h R ! 9% % :%9 %7 d 2% ! 2 i '

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    52/224

    pri*F 'i*+o (o*g 'ohot. R!#9%4"% ;5:%9"%7 oog ((t * srd"2% s!o2 oi o',o( ,

    pr*tho', (it)i ,* i (,*,* gr,i,* por*,* (top*$ ,iti ,*g ,*opor*i 'io i o,o

    ,*,* o ,,i* 'ohot*.4

    Nr,o ' (* goor,i)i$%at ta&a 8io o, ,tr o,)*pt potro,* i+i i 'ohotF pri*

    (*g poi , ,*go* o@7%4#" 8o3%9%4" 5@%"7 7o"o=s7 f%7#s"os9%< (,*,* i,

    (p(tit)i*$ t. poti), *+**,t ,i*$ t. o,(t,t,* gr,i,* por*,* (top*$ o , po*/,i r',i

    ,por to i , r+iit* o8+i* t*',* o+io 'oho)i o' pit+ ,i( i*ti - potro,i o'*+F$ ,o i

    (,*,* (i* *o,oi*. 78o* 8i pro 8og (tr,og r(t *o,o(* ti,o(ti$ 'rgo 8og

    (,*, por*,* *i* 'o*+o 'o 8o4"%6 8or3"%6 8r%6od#pr*,(t*,o t**+* por* ,

    'oho' i 'o8itF$ +i i 'rgih por*.49N*'*,i 8i r(t r+iitih o8+i *o,o(* ti,o(ti i

    por*,ih priho' 'i,ii *&*ti50F ro r*+tir/i por(t 8+go(t, (ih 'oho'o,ih (+o*

    'goro,o tr*8o ,*tr+iirti ,*gti,* 'i(tri8)i(* i,* *rti+, pr*',o(tF (,*,

    por*$ pri* (*g ,i* 'ohot*. No$ ' 8i (* to i o(tri+o$ t 'i,ii i, pri*+ o'

    i* gr,i,ih (top , *',51or 8iti r*+ti,o ,, 7ECD$ 2006.$ (tr. F.49 S $%at ta& o, pri* (*g por* , 'oho'. No *(to (* i(t (top$ p (i ti* i ir p*tMpri*,* i , por* , 'o8it i %D ,pr. (+ S+o*F. Spo*,to po*/,* priho' i o(t+ih por*o8h/ o (it)i ' (* po' poo &+t tZM r*&or* i(+i , i* por*,ih o8+i o,r*t,o triF

    o8h/*,ih i(to (topo$ to i (it)i ' (* r'i (o o por* , 'oho' i+i 'oho' i 'o8itF$ *r 8ogpo*/,* *o,o(* ti,o(ti r(t i ,r+iitii por*i po o(t+i o(,o.50 @pro (* r'i o po,ti i,)i *o,oi* po,'*$ o',o(,o L&&*ro* ri+*.51 = og/* 'o't,* pro*,* por*,* o(,oi)* o+io (* i*-,* pri*,i H++-!8(hi, o'*+F52 =pro * i((to !(i* po+o ' * por(t por*,ih priho' pri* (*g r*+tt r,ih o(t+ih t*h,iih*r (*r*,ih , 8o+ ,p+t por* i (,*,* por*,* *i*$ t. ' (* ,* o* ir,o pripi(ti (o$%at ta&u, t. ,*goi o*i,i i,)i *o,oi* po,'* pr*tho',o (poi,,i 'i,ii i,)iF.I,o$ #**,$ #+*$ 2005.F. i,i (* ' * 'i,i(trti, r*&or oito 8i+ ,i o' p* pro*,* (top*$

    ' + K i +i ti/i 7%d 2 d %@ 2

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    53/224

    'r* o* ( g *+*. Ko (* pri* (*g *+i po(ti/i 57%d#"2= od"os"o o;r#"%@#4#"2=

    8or3"%6 o!#7>%c# 8os:%c "s9#"d#rd"%6pri * (*$ o to * */ r**,o$ ,(toi ,/i pro(tor

    8o4"2 oso:"o; od:%97# 8r* o(,o,ogF. I (i goor,i)i o* r*&or* , ' 8i 8i+opr*op(,o r,ti (o , 'i,i* i,*. N'+*$ oJ*,* $%at ta&a ,i' ,i* io+ir,o$ */

    'o+i p*t ( o(t+i *r *o,o(* r*&or*$ ,tr oih (* po(*8,o i(ti r+iit* o(t+*

    t*h,i* *r* (pr*,;(,*, por*,* *i*.52

    #o to * */ i(t,to$ ,po,tii goor,i)i $%at ta&a &i,,)i(o +it*rtri p i (,ii

    ,i i(tpiF '*&i,iti,o ( 8i+iF H#!! % R#:5s67# H++$ !8(h$ 195.$ i ( 2d"5 s9o85

    7o=:%"%r#!% s "o8or3%4%= d%2!o= do6o97# oso:"%= od:%97o= por*,og o8*,i i ,*go*

    'r,* +,o* ,*ir, progr*(iF. Atori ( (* +g+i (top o' 19W$ oo (* ,*opor** (o 'oho' &iiih o(o8$ */ i 'oho' po'*/ t. 'o8itF. I(to to$ '+i ( op)i* i

    i$ o',o(,o ,i (top o' ,*'*,* 15W$ o',o(,o 32WF o 8i o,' tr*8o prtiti ,i$

    o',o(,o */i por*,i o'8it o' por* , 'oho' o 8i (* o(tri+ i(t ri, por*,ih priho'.

    H#!! % R#:5s67# s5 5 f%"#"c%2s7o2 !%9r#95r% s4o2%= =od!o= lat ta#a 8r4"s94"o

    8o3"#9% 7#o 9=!2"% 3#;o4or"%c% #!9r"#9%4"o;# =od!#. D+*$ io ( iro ,o(ti po,tii po

    gor, *', por*, (top o' por* , 'oho'$ oi ( tori pri* (*g 8os9#4%!% 2d#"

    od 9=!2"%6 o:!%7# #!9r"#9%4"o; =od!# 8or3# "# do6od#7 9o@"%2 r@"o 7o=:%"#c%25 @%s9o;

    #!9r"#9%4"o; =od!# 3# "8od539"%7 % %ash lo/ s9#"d#rd"o; =od!# 3# 8od539"%7 %

    ;oduzetnici su kao +to je ve" istaknuti oporezovani cash $%o5 porezom i'i 2 2 3 F '+*

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark49http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark55http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark55
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    54/224

    ;oduzetnici su, kao +to je ve" istaknuti oporezovani cash $%o5 porezom i'i 2.2.3.F$ '+*

    pr* (t,'r',o o'*+. Ko ,i ' ,* o8r, orti)i*$ t. ' (* (* i,*(ti)i* tr*,t,o

    otpi( *',ort,i otpi(F. %r*'+* (* i i',* (ih 'rgih poti) i,*(ti)i*. N'+*$ ,*og (* o'8iti trooi t ( o8iro ' (* t* o priho' ,* opor* , ri,i &iiih

    o(o8. N*opor*i,* 'ii'*,'i , ri,i po*'i,) i ,*pri,,* troo t pri+io

    ir, por*,* o(,oi)* r*+tir opor*i,* r(por*J*,* i ,*r(por*J*,* 'o8iti i(to

    por*,o (topo$ to ' ,* 'o+i 'o */ ,*'*,ihF por**/ i*J 'r,* 'o8iti i

    r(por*J*,* 'o8iti$ o',o(,o 'g i +(titog pit+. #o to * i(t,to 2.2.3.$cash $%o5por* ,

    'o8it ,*tr+, * pri 'o,o*, o'+* o ,i, &i,,)ir,.

    D+*$ por* (* p+/ , 'i* ri,*: , ri,i po'*/ p+/ (* por* , 'o8it o,

    ir,t po cash $%o5 pri,)ipF$ 'o r',i)i op*t p+/ por* , (o* r'* i tih po'*/$ 'o't,ih p+/, , 'ohot* o' pit+ &iiih o(o8 ,*. Ko (* o(igr ' (* por* p+/

    (o *',o$ t. ' ,* *o,o(og 'o(trog opor*i,.

    i'+io * ' * o(,o, pr*',o(t oog o'*+ ,*go *',o(t,o(t. =(to$ o, pr*,(t*,o

    r, , */ o8,*,* 'i,i* i,* *&i(,o(ti$ (tr (* i *rti+,o pr*',i 8og

    ,*opor*iog 'i*+$ t* i*t,o ,*tr+,i horio,t+,o pr*',iF 8og io(t, *o,o(og

    'o(trog opor*i, i tr*tir, (ih opor*iih 'oho' , i(ti ,i,.

    H++ i !8(h ( ,*'*,i por* pr*'+g+i SAD i t (* pri*'+og t+iiro

    pr*'(*',io p,i o * 1996. go'i,* o'io pr*'(*',ii ,'i't St** or8*(.Io H++-!8(hi,$%at ta& ,i* prih/*, SAD-$ (+i*'i+ * r!#9%4"o >%ro7# 8r%=2"#

    ,ihoog (tr,og 'ohot to ,i ' (* r'i o ,*gti,o por* , 'oho' ,i(* 'ohot*

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark55http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark56http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark55http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark56
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    55/224

    ,ihoog (tr,og 'ohot$ to ,i ' (* r'i o ,*gti,o por* , 'oho' ,i(* 'ohot*

    o,* ii * por* i(po' i,o( por*,og r*'itF. K (* o8+i o o* $%at ta& ( o(,o,i

    'ohoto 8(i) i,)o* &+t tZMF$ g'* po o(,o,og 'ohotM *,* (* ,o,* i,tr+,* tr,(&*r* (o)i+,og o(igr, (bene$its)6 N r(po+oii (* 'oho' rr**

    propor)io,+, por*, (top t* (* o' to 'o8i*,og i,o( por* o'8i por*,i r*'it. Nr,o$

    o(o8 8* 'ohot 'o8it /* ,*gti, por* i,o( )i*+og por*,og r*'it$ t. it /* gr,tir,i

    o(,o,i 'oho'. D+*$ i o * ((t progr*(i,< ,* 8og o(o8,og o'8it$ */ 8og por*,og

    r*'it.. @8og tog to * i(ti (*$ i r*+ti,o */* ,*,* ,i(* 'ohot* i ,o(i progr*(i

    ((t. I'* * i ' o(,o,i 'oho' (non#5astab%epor*,i r*'itF ,* i*,i (o (* tr,(&*r*$

    */ i (* por*,* o+i)* o* (* */i,o ' o8+i o'8it o' o(,oi)*F. Ki* 8i (* ri*io i

    pro8+* t. * 8i*'*M$ o',o(,o * ,*po(+*,o(tiM$ o o* /* i* ri*i 8iti 3.3.3.

    Nr,o$ o(t* otor*, og/,o(t &i,,)ir, gr,tir,og i,o( o(,o,og 'ohot (iho 8i og+ pot,ti por(t por*,* (top*$ o',o(,o (,*,* ri,* o(,o,og 'ohot.

    Si,t*tiir/i ,*'*,o$ o* (* +iti ' po(toi "7o!%7o 9%8o4#lat ta#a

    1. *', (top i 8* o(,o,og o(o8,og o'8it$ o(,oi)-'oho' propor)io,+, ((tF

    2. *', (top ( o(,o,i o(o8,i o'8ito< o(,oi) - 'oho' progr*(i, ((tF

    3. H++-!8(hi, o'*+ *', (top$ o(,o,i o(o8,i o'8it< o(,oi) - 'oho' o' r'$ t.

    +t*r,ti,i o'*+< proir* (* i , po'*t,ii 'oho' oi (* opor** cash $%o5

    por*oF

    4 Ati,(o,o o'*+ T*', (top ( non# 5astab%e por*,i r*'ito o(,o,i 'oho'F<

    0 0 + S9#"d#rd"% =od! %3r#4"o; o8or3%4#"2# 8o9ro>"2 "# r#3%"% 8od53< %ash lo/

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark159http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark159http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark159http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark159
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    56/224

    0.0.+. S9#"d#rd"% =od! %3r#4"o; o8or3%4#"2# 8o9ro>"2 "# r#3%"% 8od53< %ash lo/

    8or3%

    A,+og,o o'8i, t*',* , ri,i &iiih o(o8$ * o'8i,* i,*(ti)i , ri,i

    po'*t,iih (8*t. Io * po cash $%o5a op/*po,t$ o, pri+ ,i* prih/*, o'

    por*,ih ((t o o(,oi) por* , 'o8it.557 t*t( *'i,i) o8rJ* por*,* (p*)i&i,o(ti

    i r+iit* pri*'+og* *,* cash $%o5 opor*i,* i ,*go* o(,oi)*: R'os"o4%c5 RF'

    os"o4%c5 S'os"o4%c5 o8or3%4#"2 "9o 4!#s"%@7%6 %s8!#9# o8or3%4#"2 d%4%d"d% RA'

    os"o4%c5 % #795#!"os9 %ash lo/ 8or3#.

    2.2.,.1. $-osnovi%a

    "*', o' ,*',o(t,iih cash $%o5 o(,oi) (igr,o * t. !-o(,oi)M o o:564#

    s#=o ;o9o4%"s7 9%27o4 3#s"o4#" "# r#!"%= 9r#"s#7c%2#=#. Io * o 194. pr*'+oio

    Bro, pr* #i(*r$ 1992.$ (tr. 42F$ (r**, * &i,,)i( ,,o(t o8i,o ** +*g*,'r,i

    ?*'o i*t$ o',o(,o i*t ?*'oog o'8or IS$ 19>.$ (tr. 230-259F$ o* (* o

    o(,oi) pr*'+* o *', o' tri og/,o(ti cash $%o5 o(,oi) S* tri o(,oi)* or,o pri*

    7'r*J*,* o'i&i)ir,* *ri* cash $%o5por*,* o(,oi)* pri+ 8* *',ort,og otpi($ ,o /i ,*+o8+g,*$ t. io(t, r,oo'(t*,og ,*+ ,(t, po(+o,og 'ogJ i pri*+ , cash $%o5, t. ,*+o ,o,ogti*F *(to ( pri(t,* o' +ih po'*t,i.

    F0%ri,* otp+t* ',ih r*'it F0D,* r*'itF %o*/,* '*, po t*/* r, F S,*,*

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark52http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark52
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    57/224

    F+%o*/,* '*, po t*/* r, F+S,*,* ...FS,*,* gotoi,* 8+g,i\\ F%o*/,*...F*%o*/,* o(t+ih '*, F S,*,*...F,S,*,* o(t+ih po('8i F,%o*/,*...F%ri+*,* t* F%+/*,* t*F/S,*,* ,*g '*+ po'*/i F/%o*/,*...

    o ,i( 'o/i r*i'*,ti

    F FTr#"s#7c%2 s 5d2!%=# 5 953="%= 8od53&%=# S

    *- %o*/,* +(titog pit+ i',* S0S,*,* ...

    ,oih 'io,i)F*0 S,*,* 'r, '*+ 'rgi t*,i S0%o*/,* ...po'*/i

    *+ %rii)i i '*+ t*,i po'*/i S+I(p+t* +(,i)i '*+pri+*,* 'ii'*,'* i (+.F p+/*,* 'ii'*,'* i (+.F

    S SPor3" 9r#"s#7c%2 T

    T% %orti por* T% =p+t* por*

    \ = ior,o *rii (* *(to t*ri, Ppo'*/*P oi o'* o, go(po'r( '*+t,o(t (og o8+ipo'*t,itF ori(tio t*ri, Porpor)iP *r (* ior,i r*&or(i pri*'+og o',o(io (o , orpor)i(i(*tor.

    \\ Dr,* gotoi,* 8+g,i (tr (* ,+og,i &i,,)i(o i,*(ti)ii. Ior:

    IS$ 19>.$ (tr. 231$ K8+i) 12.1 o8r'i+ tori)F

    #o to * i'+io i pr* (pi,* tr,()i$ !-o(,oi) o8h/ r*+,* pri+** i o'+**.

    %or* (*$ '+*$ rr** , p,* priit* pri+**F po'*/ o' pro'* (ih

    prii)i pri+*iF o' pro'* t* ioi,* +iti por*, o(,oi) i* /* (* i(tor**,ot+ iti 8+ ' t i it + ih ' 8it ' '

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    58/224

    ot+o,iti pro8+* '*t,og opor*i, pit+,ih 'o8it o' pro'*.^ S* p,* i pro'* r+iitih proio' i (+g por*,o ( r*+*,t,* (o o ( 8!#&"

    od"os"o "#8!#&".

    ^ S o8iro ' &i,,)i(* tr,()i* o i tr,()i* ( +(,ii '*+i po'*/F ,* +* por*, o(,oi)$ to ,i ' ,i 8r%6od% od 8r%=!2"%6 7#=#9# " 5!#3 5 8or3"5 os"o4%c5,iti (* p+/*,* t* og o'8iti o' por*,* o(,oi)*.

    Bit,o * oiti ' */ o ,*',o(t,ii potro,o (*r*,i$ o',o(,o cash $%o5 por*

    o'r ,iho t**+, rt*ri(ti - o'((to t*) , 'o8it proi+ i ,oihF i,*(ti)i ,

    ,i, ' (* por*o ,* ,o(* por**/i o'+* o &i,,)ir,. Ko,i* r**,o$ i,*(ti)i r*+,ioi, ,pr. tor,i)$ (tro**$ opr*F i ,*,i pri,o(i por*,o ( r*+*,t,i$ +i , ,i, ' (*

    8or3o= " 592@ "# s9o85 do:%9%.

    Ko ,*',o(t,i* pri* (+*'*/i 8r%=2r.*, I,*(titor /* r*+, i,*(ti)i o' 200

    ,o,ih *'i,i) ,..F por*, (top !-o(,oi)* cash $%o5por* o' 50W tr*8ti +oiti (*g

    100 ,.. pit+. S o8iro ' * o'h pri+io i,*(tir, i,o( o' 200 ,. . o'8it, (t o'

    por*,* o(,oi)*$ pri (topi o' 50W por*, t*' i,o(i 100 ,.. Npr. o+io 8i por*, o(,oi)

    8* i,*,* i,*(ti)i* i,o(i+ 1.000 ,..$ i,o( por* 8io 8i 500 ,.. = i,*(ti)i o' 200 ,.$

    por*, o(,oi) i,o(i 00 ,. .$ i,o( por* 400 ,. .$ i *g proi+i (,*,* por*$ o',o(,o

    por*, t*' o' 100 ,. .F. = (+ ,*po(to, poiti,* por*,* o(,oi)* pri* i,*(ti)i*$ t. (+ ' * to pr i *'i, i,*(ti)i po'*/$ og+o 8i (* gooriti o ,*gti,o por*$ t. o

    tr,(&*r o' (tr,* 'r*.

    pr**to pr* IS-$ 19>.$ (tr. 232$ o'r*J*, ,'op,*, i po,*,

    po'*/* /* tr*8ti p+titi por* o' 110 ,.. 50W o' 220 ,. .F. Ko ,i ' o(t* 110 ,.. D+*$

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark59http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark59http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark59
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    59/224

    p p p F $

    , +o*,ih 100 ,. . o(tr* (* i(ti pri,o( o' 10 ,..$ 5 '+* ,or+, (top 'o8iti$ o ,i*

    ,*, por*o. %or* ,i* r*+tiro +(i,i Ppor*,i +i,oP o*g ,+io o' por* ,'o8it ,tr 'oho'o,og o,)*pt -+(i,og por* , 'oho' (i*t.59

    Ko i(tor**,o ,i ' (* 'r + o tihi prt,*r i,*(tir,. 7, ('*+* 'i*+

    i,*(ti)i*$ oi(,o o i(i,i por*,* (top* oo (+ po+oi)iF$ +i i(to to ('*+* i 8'/o

    'o8iti i(to* o*r.

    Io pr*tho',o pri*r por* ,i* proi*,io (top 'o8iti$ t* t*ri,i (',*

    ri*',o(ti 'r i ,i* 8r+ por* 'r * tr*,t i,*(tir, ig8i+ 100 ,.. por* ' 8i

    (,i* ,p+ti+ 110 ,. . por*$ o',o(,o 100 ,.. (*'*,o , (', ri*',o(t$ to r*+tir ( 0 ,..

    por*F$ ,* o* (* r*/i ' o por*,i o8+i 'ri ,* 'o,o(i priho'*. #' 8i (* o, *o$ o i*

    8i 8i+o ioi,* o 8i ,o(i+ pri,o($ 8* ,*,* i,*(ti)i* o por*,* t*'* o'8it,* (t* pro+o(tiF$ t. ioi,* o (* i,*(tir+o po 'o(',* (tro r*i por* , 'o8it. No$ o'*

    (* pri* (*g i(+i , grJ*, rt*ri(ti cash $%o5 por*$ pri * (* o, 8iti 5:%r "#

    %3"#d8ros2@" 8r%"os o' (+ !-o(,oi)* r*+,ihF i,*(ti)i.605 I(to /* ri*'iti (+ ' (* i,*(ti)i &i,,)ir +(titi pit+o$ 'r,o 'o8iti i+i po('8otJi pit+oF$ o to /* (* poti (,i*.59 i'i2.1.4.60 Ko ( o,i oi ( i,' ,or+,* t*$ o',o(,o (top* 'o8iti pri,,o pri*r 19WF$ o (*,*/* o'r*J* i/i o8ir t, (top , 'r,* o8*,i)*$ '+* o, po oo (* '* 'ri o i(tor**,o ,i (igr, pri,o( por*,* o8*,i*.

    =o+io 8i pr*tho',o pri*r i,*(ti)i o' 200 ,.. 'o,o(i+ pro&it o' 100 ,..$ '+* 0

    =pro (* o t*h,i p+,ir+ o' r*&or(ih pri*'+og oJ*, oog por*,og o8+i SAD-.

    i pr*tho',og pri*r */,o 0 ,.. i,'pro(*,* 'o8itiF. %or*, o(,oi)$ '+*$ i,o(i 300

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark13http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark13http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark60http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark13
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    60/224

    ,..$ to por*, (top o' 50W 'oo'i 'o por*,* o8** o' 150 ,.. S*'*,o , (',

    ri*',o(t t, (top o' 10WF$ to i,o(i 136$36 ,.. Ko * (o (+ i* o' 100 ,..,*gti,og por* por*,og g8itF pr*tho',o go'i,i. Ko ,i ' * i t*ri,i (',*

    ri*',o(ti p+/*, por*. 7, * 8r, 8og o(tr*, 'o8iti i(i,i i,'pro(*,* t*.

    I,o( o' 150 ,.. por* ,'+* ,i ' * po'*/* 'r+o po+oi) i,'pro(*,* 'o8iti

    t. 150 ,.. - 110 ,..F$ 'o * 'r 'r+ 'rg po+oi). Dr *$ '+*$ o prt,*r po'*/

    P+oi+P 100 ,.. ig8+*,i por*,i priho'F$ o(tri+ 150 ,..$ t. 40 ,.. po+oi)

    i,'pro(*,* 'o8itiF i* o' pr*tho',o pri*r o(tr*,ih 110 ,.. ,or+, 'o8itF. Ko

    'r pro o(tr* o'r*J*,i +(,ii 'io po'*/ 'i*+*/i i troo* i,*(tir, 8og

    o'o8r, tr*,t,og otpi(F$ +i i r*+tir/ 'o8it$ o i g8it$ i to (+' ( i(i,o t,*

    (top*. @ po'*/ o o(tr i,'pro(*,* pri,o(*$ 'r o(tr* i ,*to por*,i priho'.

    =pro 8og pr*',o(ti cash $%o5por* ( *',* i *',o(t,o(ti (* !-o(,oi)* ( 'rg*

    (tr,*$ to * i,i po(*8,o pogo',o +* po'*t,i*$ o * o(,oi) ,+ (o* *(to i

    ,ogi 'rgi r*&or(i pri*'+oi. K tr*8 pri* (*g (po*,ti$ ?)Lr*$ Br'&or'$ H++

    i !8(h. @+ (* *'i,(t*,i por*,i tr*t, (ih po'*t,iih o8+i$ r+i o' ?*'*$

    oi * (o* tri o(,oi)* cash $%o5 por* pr*'+go (o orpor)i(i (*tor. N*'*,i (*$

    *Jti$ t*or*tiri r+i po (oi pr*'+o*,i o8i,)i opor*i, po'*/ (

    i,'ii'+,i opor*i,* ,r,o$ toJ*r potro,o ori*,tir,iF. Do ,*i r,ii Br'&or'oi

    ?)Lr* i @o'ro (o IK%;! T?)Lr*$ @o'ro$ 199. 1990.FU$ o',o(,o pri*'+og SAK ?)Lr*$

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark46http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark46
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    61/224

    1991.F - i'i 2.2.2.1.- toJ*r gor i,'ii'+,i progr*(i,i por* , 'oho' o' r'

    o8i,)ii ( por*o ( !-o(,oi)o , po'*t,io ri,i. %rito * toJ*r pri(t, *',o(t,i* i,'ii'+,* ( po'*t,io (topo. H++ i !8(h H++ i !8(h$ 195. i 1995.F$ o

    to * pri,o 2.2.2.3.$gor o8i,)i por* !-o(,oi)* ( propor)io,+,i por*o ,

    'oho' o' r' , i,'ii'+,o ri,i. 7 po(+*',i pri*'+og po,oo * t+iir, '**'*(*tih

    go'i, SAD- Chri(ti,$ 1995.< Boy*r$ !((*++$ 1995.< Ko'*r$ 1995.< Ho+t-Ei,$ 1996.< *+'$

    1995.F po' */ po,ti ,io P+t KZP. No$ io (*$%at ta& prii*,io ,*i tr,i)i(i

    'r$ o, ,i* pr/*, !-o(,oi)o , po'*t,io ri,i.

    2.2.,.2. $&"-osnovi%a

    Drg og/ o(,oi)$ o * toJ*r pr*'+oio ?*'o o'8or62$ * ![ o(,oi). @

    r+i o' !-o(,oi)*$ o, por*, o(,oi) +* i &i,,)i(* tr,()i* o,*,* K8+i)i

    4 ( F. Io * t*or*t(i i(pr,i$ o, * 8og (o* (*o8ht,o(ti ,*to (+o*,i. %ri* (* o

    RF os"o4%c# R F ' R F (

  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    62/224

    otr o'r*J*,* pro8+**. Ko pro ,i ' 'r ,* ('*+* o prt,*r &i,,)ir,

    &i,,)i(ih i,*(ti)i$ t. ,* 'oo+ ,iho *',ort,i otpi(. Ko (* i,o(i +o*,i &i,,)i(*i,*(ti)i* ,* o(+o8J por*$ +i to r*+tir i (,ii ,*opor*i,* pri,o( t*F oih

    i,*(ti)i.63No$ r+i o' i,o( &i,,)i(*F i,*(ti)i*$ oi * po,t i o'r*J*,$ p pr* to*

    i i, io(t, por*,* t*'*$ to ,i* (+ ( 8'/i pri,o(i. Nihoo ,*opor*i,* ,i i

    io(t, opor*i, ,* (o ,or+,ih pro(*,ihF$ ,*go i (ih i,'pro(*,ih pri,o(.

    Ei+*,)i i, por*,og tr*t, r*+,ih i &i,,)i(ih i,*(ti)i *r*,o t*ri,i

    (',* ri*',o(tiF ,tr !-o(,oi)* o proi+i i pr**,tir,* *i+*,)i* (t,'r',og i

    +t*r,ti,og o'*+ i'i 2.3.1.Fri*'i (o (+ o(tr*, pro(*,ih ,or+,ihF pri,o($ t.

    t*. = (+ o(tr*, i,'pro(*,ih pri,o($ &i,,)i(* ( i,*(ti)i* por*,o prii+*gir,*

    *r ( potp,o(ti o(+o8oJ*,* por*$ r+i o' r*+,ih$ o* ( i* opor*o,*.64

    Stog *![-o(,oi) t*or*t(i 'o(+*',i i pr*',i ( (t+it horio,t+,* pr*',o(ti.

    #+(i,i ((t por* , 'o8it - por* , 'o8it 'oho'o,o o,)*pt ('ri */ ,**

    rt*ri(ti* ![-o(,oi)*$ r+i o' !-o(,oi)*. %ri+io trJi, o(,oi)* por* , 'o8it

    og (*$ ,i*$ o'8iti t* , ,gir, tJi pit+65$o to i priho'i o' t +* por*,

    o(,oi). Nr,o$ r+i* (* og+*' ,*po(to, por*,og pri,, *',ort,og otpi( i

    r*+*,t,og (,i*g +*, priit o' pro'* ioi,* por*, o(,oi)$ o i ,*+*,

    pri+*,ih r*'it por*, o(,oi).

    65 7'8i,* t* , +(titi pit+ tit, tF */ * +t*r,ti,i o8+i potro,og por* , ri,ipo'*/ i'i 2.2.4 .F.

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark100http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark100http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark63http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    63/224

    S-o(,oi) * tr*/ ri,t o * pr*'+oio ?*'o o'8or t* (* o' (tr,* oog o'8or

    s=#9r# "#2:o!2o= i pr*'+* o8i,)ii ( (t,'r',i o'*+o 'ir*t,og opor*i,

    potro,* ,*opor*i,* t*',*$ o',o(,o por* , o(o8,* i't*F , ri,ipo*'i,). 7 *

    o(,oi) (o "# dr5;% "#@%" 8r%7#3#"# RF'os"o4%c# to ' i ,*i,* pr*',o(ti$ +i * ( 'rg*

    (tr,*2d"os9#4"%2#. !, (* t**+* po'*+* tr,()i K8+i)i 4 , (+*'*/i ,i,:

    S'os"o4%c# S ' S (?)

    N*, ,+ogi ( ![-o(,oi)o ,+* * o8(,iti i'o K8+i) 4. = (+' ( pr**,tir,o

    t8+i)o$ po'*/* )*+i,i p,i pri+* tr*8 8iti *', p,o o'+*. Ko '+* ,i '

    ri*'i IS$ 19>.$ (tr. 233-235F:

    )$ & "* - )$ & "* > )' - '* & )T - T* (*B)

    "*',o(t,i* r**,o$ s4% "9o 8r%!24% 8r%=%c% %3 r#!"%6 % f%"#"c%2s7%6 9r#"s#7c%2# d%2!

    s %3=G5 d%o"%@#r# % 8or3" 58r#4. =o+io o,i$ ,pr.$ i,o(* 10 i+i, ,.. i 'i*+* (* to ' 5

    i+i, ,.. 'o8i 'io,iri$ t* (* p+/ 5 i+i, ,.. por*$ o* (* r*/i ' (* pri*,* ![-

    o(,oi) ![F - ![FF por*, (top o' 50W o (*8i +* i,o( por* t. 'ta&

    inc%usive' o(,oi)$ t. o, iz o* (* p+/ por*F i+i p ' (* , S-o(,oi) S-SF$ o (*8i ,*

    ('ri por* t. 'ta& e&c%usive' o(,oi) t. o, na o (* p+/ por*F p+/ por* por*, (top

    o' 100W.

    N*'*,o (* o* i t*tii i*(ti , (+*'*/i ,i, =o+io (* ( tR0F o,i por*,

    C$&"

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark77
  • 7/23/2019 Usporedni Porezni Sustavi - Oporezivanje Dohotka i Dobiti - Helena Blai

    64/224

    C$&"ts >-------------------------- )2,*

    #o to * i'+io$ i (por*'8* S i S tr,()i$ por*, o(,oi) S-SF po'*/ ,i( (o

    i(p+/*,* 'ii'*,'* ,*,* i',* ,oih 'io,i). 7, (* po*/ i (* ,*to i(p+t*

    o(t+i po'*/i1 t**+* 'io,iog pit+ ,pr. p,o 'io,i) 'rgih t*,ih 'io,iih

    'rtF. !+og to* * i8*g,* 'o(trog opor*i,$ o',o(,o 'o(trih por*,ih

    o'8it$ t. por*,* *i*. =o+io 8i (* por*, o(,oi) ogr,ii+(o , ,*to +(,i* i(p+t*

    'ii'*,'* ,*,* i',* ,oih 'io,i)F$ po'*/ 8i og+ *J(o8,o poti i i'ti

    'io,i)* o 8i (* i8*g+o p+/,* por* i'i 2.2.3.4.F.

    I(to o to * i(t,to o' opor*i, !-o(,oi)*6>$ % o8or3%4#"2 S'os"o4%c 3"#@% d#

    s 8or3o= " 592@ "# s9o85 do:%9% 8r%"os# %"4s9%c%2#.,/No$ o'* (* to po(ti* dr5;#@%2o=96"%7o=. S i,*(ti)i &i,,)ir, 'go * por*,o ir*+*,t, ( o8iro , i,*,i) ' (* ,*

    opor* p+/*,* t*$ i,* ,* pr*'(t+ por*, t*' o'8it o' por*,*

    o(,oi)*F. %ri,o( i,*(ti)i* &i,,)ir,* +(titi pit+o i i(ti por*,i tr*t,$ 8* o8ir r'i+o

    (* o i', ,oih 'io,i) i+i &i,,)ir, i 'r,* 'o8iti.

    %ri*r pr* IS-$ 19>.$ (tr. 234-235F ( i(to por*,o (topo o' 50W 0$5F

    prii*,*,o o' pri*r ( !-o(,oi)o$ o 8i ri*'i+ i (+ ![-o(,oi)*$ o'* (* i

    o8ir ' (* r'i o por*,o o(,oi)i o (*8i ,* +* por* ('ta& e&c%usive'), t. por* na S-

    o(,oi). = to (+ r'i (* o (topi o' 100W pr* */ ,*'*,o &or+i

    ri*'i 8og (por*'8* 'r,* i r(po'i*+*,* i(p+/*,*F 'o8iti. Ni*$ ' 8i (* 200 ,.. 'o8iti

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark69http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_1/HYPERLINK%23bookmark69http://var/www