45 Main Street, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201
718 625 4843‑—www.hugeinc.com
By: Dan Hou, Senior Product Strategist and Aaron Shapiro, Partner | June 15, 2010
Display advertising: a user–centered approach
Summary.
A user-centered approach to display advertising—
one that is sensitive to how today’s users actually
engage with traditional and multimedia ads—
can lead to significantly higher recall. This is
particularly true for new formats such as video
pre-roll, video overlay, push-down banners and
other interruptive ads. Publishers and advertisers
are increasingly relying on these formats after
users learned to ignore static banner ads. But
traditional banner ads can still be memorable
if carefully tailored to trends in user behavior.
Regardless of format, a user-centered approach
to display advertising efforts is required if ROI is
to be maximized.
Research Methodology:
Our research team conducted one-on-one
surveys with 60 casual Internet users ages 18
to 45 to better understand how users approach
multimedia and banner ads.
Users were asked to complete various tasks that
demonstrated their daily Internet routines over a
45-minute period. Tasks included browsing news
headlines and video clips, finding the latest sports
results, booking a flight for vacation, selecting
a restaurant for dinner, choosing a movie and
showtime, researching consumer electronics,
and watching video content that a friend
recommended. We interviewed the participants
about ad recall following this period of use.
Key Findings:
• Positioning ads too far above the fold often
reduces the amount of time the ad is visible.
• Relevance is the strongest driver of ad recall.
• Heavy ad repetition results in unaided ad
recall.
• Interruptive advertising improves recall, but at
the expense of the user experience.
• Video pre-roll performs better than overlay.
• Users are developing behaviors to ignore
video ads.
Figure 1: Content position below the fold
Figure 2: YouTube “Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2” masthead
Fold
The Value of Above-the-Fold Ad Placement
is Overrated
Customarily, ads placed higher on the page
command greater cost per thousand impressions
(CPMs) due to the assumption of greater visibility.
However, a user’s target content is often located
below the fold, and that motivates users to scroll
away from the leaderboard.
For example on MovieFone.com, a site frequented
during our study, showtimes are located below
the fold. As a result, users scrolled down quickly,
sometimes even before the above-the-fold ad fully
loaded.
Obviously for a display ad to even have a chance
at making an impression on a user, the user has
to see it. Therefore, a smaller ad placed further
down the page adjacent to desired content could
perform better than a larger ad that’s above the
fold and closer to the global navigation.
Relevance Powers Ad Recall
The vast majority of directly and indirectly recalled
ads were ones that were relevant to the user’s
interests.
In one instance, a BMW ad consisting of synced
display and pre-roll ads left no impression on
nearly all users who saw it. However one user,
a self-professed car lover, was able to recall the
particular advertisement, the brand and the exact
car model featured.
This was observed again involving a banner ad
for video game “Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2”
on YouTube’s homepage. The only person who
recalled seeing the ad was a 19-year-old male
who frequently played video games. He was
not only able to recall the creative and layout of
the advertisement, but also the specific game
featured in the ad. Relevance helps users notice
an ad and drives home the brand and the brand’s
message.
Size, on the other hand, doesn’t power recall. The
“Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2” video game ad
occupied a full 1/3 of the space above the fold
(Figure 2), but was ignored by 11 out of 12 users
who came upon it.
Heavy Repetition Pays Dividends
Repetition strongly influences recall. Banner
ads that are perceived to be ubiquitous and
unchanged over a long period of time maintain
user mindshare. In exit interviews, people recalled
Netflix and Classmates.com ads, but neither
was displayed during the course of the study. It
is therefore evident that once a high threshold of
impressions is met, advertisers achieve unaided
display ad recall.
Interruptive Ads Have High Recall, but Can
Backfire
Interruptive ads such as pop-ups and full-screen
overlays make lasting impressions on users, but
the impression tends to be a bad one. Nearly
half of the respondents directly or indirectly
recalled interruptive ads, making the format the
most recalled type in our study (Figure 3). But
it was also vehemently disliked. The majority of
participants expressed annoyance and frustration
when discussing interruptive ads.
“They are annoying. Very annoying. Those full
ads…. I don’t mind banner and sidebars, but don’t
make me stop and click and close a window to
get to where I’m going. I don’t like that extra click.”
–Allyson, 34
“F**k!” -- Sean, 26, in response to JVC overlay on
CNET
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
2.2%
41%
19%
30%
StaticBanner
Interruptive Overlay Pre-Roll
recall rates by ad format
Figure 3
Video Overlay Recall is Good,
but Pre–Roll is Better
Video overlay and pre-roll ads stood out as
effective ad formats over the course of the study.
Both were dramatically more memorable to users
than typical banner ads. However, pre-roll was the
clear winner. It was significantly more effective in
terms of brand and message recall.
recall rates for video overlayrecall rates for pre-roll
recall rates for video overlayrecall rates for pre-roll
recall rates for pre-roll
recall rates for video overlay
Users are Learning to Ignore Video Ads
Banner blindness is already a well-documented
phenomenon. But users are developing video ad
blindness now too. Some users in the study were
observed avoiding video advertisements similar to
the way one would avoid television commercials.
When pre-roll ads ran, users would shift their
attention to other content on the page, completely
scroll away from the video or direct their attention
to another browser window. Audio cues let them
know when the ad was over.
Overlay ads, meanwhile, are getting the pop-up
treatment. A few users reflexively closed the
overlay within a second or two of it popping up,
never really observing the contents of the ad.
“I usually have other pages open at the same
time; I’ll tweet while I’m waiting for the ad to
finish.” – Lisa, 29
“As soon as [the ad] went over what I was reading,
I switched to the next tab. I’ll flip back when I
figure it’s over.” –Mary, 49
What to Do? When designing a marketing plan, advertisers
should:
• Ensure that ad placements are close to
meaningful content, rather than simply being
above the fold.
• Implement a behavioral targeting solution
across all of a publisher’s properties.
• When considering implementing an
interruptive marketing effort, carefully weigh the
value of brand awareness against the cost to
the brand’s goodwill.
• Produce pre-roll or overlay video ads. The
higher production costs can be balanced with
higher recall.
• Continue to experiment with new, innovative
ad placements to stay ahead of ever-evolving
user avoidance behaviors.
Appendix.
Display Ads: This category includes static and
animated banner ads in a variety of placements
and sizes. Text ads are not included in this
category and were not considered during this
study.
Interruptive Ads: This category includes pop-
ups that open in a new window, interstitials and
large pushdown ads.
Video Overlay Ads: This category includes ads
that overlay an online video. The size and specific
format varies, but most could be closed at the
user’s discretion.
Definition of Key Terms The following terms are used throughout this document with specific meanings:
Video Pre-Roll: This category includes video ads
that played before, during or after an online video.
The lengths ranged from 5-30 seconds.
Direct Recall: A user was able to remember
specific brand and/or messaging aspects of an
advertisement.
Indirect Recall: The user only had a vague
recollection of general ad characteristics. This
data is still relevant and important to capture
because indirect recall would still influence
purchase decisions in a shopping environment
where there are visual brand cues.
New York
45 Main Street, Suite 220
Brooklyn, NY 11201
Phone: +1 718 625 4843
Fax: +1 718 625 5157
Contact.London
60 Sloane Avenue
London SW3 3XB
Phone: +44 20 7193 8879
Fax: +44 20 7900 6729
Stockholm
Birger Jarlsgatan 57C
Stockholm 113 83
Phone: +46 75 240 6001
Fax: +46 75 240 6002
Los Angeles
11135 Weddington St., Suite 131
North Hollywood, CA 91601
Phone: +1 310 614 5838
Fax: +1 310 469 6306
45 Main Street, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201718 625 4843‑—www.hugeinc.com