22
9, @ t]!!tr:tEtz "da Ptr'HASILd BdN (SINCXITA PAJAf,l 16

Laporan Hasil Penelitian Putusan Hakim Tentang Gugatan Sengketa Tata Usaha Negara Atas Ketetapan Surat Ketetapan Pajak Kurang Bayar Penghasilan dan Penghasilan Badan (Sengketa Pajak)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

9,

@t]!!tr:tEtz

"da

Ptr'HASILd BdN (SINCXITA PAJAf,l

16

Dun hlFri hi e dier4hD n *robnk ujE &Lh P@riM, Fitu

^ Ndd Pdh! Pm$n obj* FEliio

B DiDu d nn!*!dh MrjlL,IM

f&ih$EfuP@!si6

5 $n1 tuluei PlnL haq Bly!

tojir Pqtujtrn P6d 5 A!' (! e Prjd Pdsbie ee! m No r

r suuoi Mje'r Fu,adid &i

r xtrDa id@. sE (4*id A4*!)

!E !!!ta-E!EBeJ.GM4q!.!1,&b

P@s, rkt nosjnk! Bsh tod

AF'(4]fuPqdP{gulh,BDUUN

F!(d6ghnedBlP@ueiry]i/rdd reFrd y4 bia dijldih! 'bsi obr*

I^p!'a6enrkn&r:@

FmiFk*u$j?LiaNt'b}*

ehi h@ei. !d3r.b BjsI

!{ Eqsdiq hj* P6r 3 r, ! d,

cdnh Icry$r n{!!&i vr, *hFt obyd Plilt (u4 Bryr P!*tu ldaihn Fd r ayr. drn Prnk k@q Bry6 P+L P4biLi Bde u!

qri, bei u]e pdtsh, his,&!ro er&sli rubisdr ibiobrrejak

.-s.iih.i ." " Fq ebh

!p!4hsiL!&li!$fuibul9gbG,hd

!at!i, rijqh htE4 sluFhL. , j6' *ie er@' ,0s dllM

e1rryo$iabscfuEjbdr

sr x6!sr dFr Pljd D cklne

rd,6ryn{&i}qtrP63}6jLaEa&i

rdsFt hdd{hi qitr !u4i dsr tsj

mnuiFhkrc5i6riditurmnhid& lvrjituqtornq&olm

kFba.T6Fct!fub@d.@tsdh3i4h,6du r0s @Djd dF(sji

&DsD upin $Dg d * tuj poce m F$i r lyr 4 j@ hnr

, n rm dd Eldi F@i @]*

kqilrfueb!$Fl@sinq@dknsnufulda

r+& MEj.rn Htb djd1 bh P!ruhm, P4dmr m4alfih

Lnjd sxPRB, 'iern{*m{

hns,4

I suEl kdllPi Plnr 6aig er{ Pr* h8h.!ih Elr5 qd t1):

b $d klnFo P.nk hE4 hFr hnr tugidh &d4

c ftvrjibk! rEus, nq{[, sff6 P6 hEr ,i a$ 4 ei sprB Ph

dkp PlD8sd tu hnr

m0sfusd*leie'nAgn2m

l@Fbi rontsiEi to@d PrnL

Peis!&nd r!$r t AF, i4) dn Ptnk EqidD &du @ No r r!tu

Fh.h ideidih o4Frj*D,n!

iisbd Ftrg ,in6!i ddm bd!i3 @rrh ahn {ajit Prjlr lnu

da@ p4ejika ury &FL dlj!tui b e4db, tullr k@

!t*sTqq(hm!*ih$slk+ufu@obFteig}€.thofugd@nF6fomr0ge*!e

M &roi &@ F6b0 Fa!j*a, Fito

rib c{! prynh tud D ryn 0j &s6 FnnLqryr dn Nd B !,

d,e dbr sp(B PI Be tu

rid be@ p{@er dtuktr sj* etu ,b; uiin, rslw p44ei

UfuIe'p(BU!$eBiBUT

dPi y6s nujldi ntnrG bhD &trh

tdstutrkplNliMo6 (dr@(x

1) P6 <*e, x%.e P4hrnru xeu P,nr {Pfr Bi&n)i

&4uldNrNl,'ePh E 16&t4)

rd beB r{s$, mqlns, iaiFdrh,

&tuh turnsr ub4 ajar u6ng MEer rh nd tuF yq didL

esi Fd r syf o), trr eD 1])jo Plsr r0 !y,0) m No 6 ft a*r. ftrm, + ib .flcss, Gd,sr vijr6

tuisjlru hd4 k! p-sdihi iljlrr du F4ijne bhh! deh wljib

P+rdd!frsr6 ktr !4ueuDd!Gm@ nnnp&r

r tsbL Ei3r.b )6anF$ak tuwus drai tmE 66ijibn rqs$ituftbprla udin ebls o6Fr kD Fnt w diunsbn dfr kpds

rr susPPhrarar (1):

c4i6n Eo@sr, r&F6dr Flit e& &3iu ebdllFl

eq( LebLje rqssr 0 *i*m06rr Fi* !b, leLin ehF Pr hq Bryr Puc&ih! pdr ,6 44 (4)

&hsi dFl Fj* &6nnb B&

F$r , lsetu L46 (+!i$i Dr6 Ptj* xo mEqtrrrm tu 4turinFh w.ltuie D!j!D pqd (+& rs Ej;, di bgroeD Di!6

hnkjo tolr44 o)b*dFjebDu

E4tu kn rGifii r!rcunsn Eer (frj

r,hqFtotslo4d$}q]FBaislhtr k6 Bp r@nt d &Lh hd&p}6 hibr e+ui &bei drr @j{

P66 k! E{mtd kn4Po.hoi* tu$ wqs tojrk

56sg,mld4Ei4ift+hsjoby

6 p6h bliu nn&hn r6i4 i@Enn rlqrsr y4 Eoedprs uplii

!tr@od[biqjidib!fud,tP,miro

hr!I+& Pdsq h4ljik

ylitu turen hr o je rMi

sn ru!€bfti pin!ry o &ris

, Fib je dud! oi r&r tutury.

yss d&r E4ryd Fdlh dNie tu nb di .6, ld$hi Fis+Fi6t' d6e pei6 Flr, drLihc@ rb 6*st ftieph 4rh !d4, oird Fjd Pnr b4a

fiefufu@$luolDenFi

b Esfro r.qhlq dilie4 Pssus,t! c{e oi F3 dpd*n, *

dlh brem uu no$N, Ddnsip t4j!h s'r loulsiln en d hs, d

Fghqunlel@hfiF+iuqkildi

+hiqr n6d+rd dift $Esi

ob]lrEilr FLlitrih hrcD Ed s.

dhtu hd n sFt (1) Esdi FijeLBfr)

Ffubbi tb! !! No l Th ',86

hlag Pedfu miI &qr dq*i{ Ei r rtrrbi r!4u@1 Dlmpb udin *&si drr

@id leeidbm@ 4 ear i![n e, dd b! kbij*e kEdr

j,d6FiJMuh*$ol{ut+uNimeFkhekld,iohi@u,d

]r!k[Fnekhn$!la!ElEFiNmobrrsq}@nfiEGbFtr

\a4r.ubtP.DF.hiklhh&trk

14d*hs!gqdiPogusidjhM]l4

r h.Fbhi kbjei Fnt p liEih iB qrid

a $d krdF Pai'r tu@! Bryr tufi toqtdibq FBrx 4" {1r:

i $a, krdts! hi'( tuEng Bryu tun* tugtdh &enr &n

sd k6Fn pljd tuq Bry{rad Poddiq Fd 6 qn (4):

ii snj!, su'lui bputou ruN

otF*@btdpdirylfukM&!efurhfob4ntdih

,e8hM r@en mD&F 6br Dr*!n $bs R! [?M,, G6tu

A c! Fi3 hhi !$i rienba &h htu

6Fkn!N&+dohd!&

-LdbudthhFLD!fuFbgo

dihlfu debhtui Pcd i@(i)

Nl@6trin'Nfo$&bnpsk

B. tuqeli absrur sqh rl]8k

P€4c@l&$n**F[FFsiMFna}*hfu\!&4udikdulknrU

eld &j!hD G P sde! Pailr kr Pqdih hir r@Fui LluEw{

fu4|l!t!edghnlokrlofohgdl$l

DhrEfulgq]PqdhardaUsldN4qaawladc6r@g'raa@

hst rer eiottu hha rENa nLrtrypgdtkrpja

sqtdl ptj4k dd *tckkw)at tut dQkn hdoB?7Nad tutiit

P4gdtht P4e ad hd0 Pruab

P4qa d Ptj,r r.hPayt to{4 t@ r

de unm &i rlr c{! ftaljaktr

lesfu|clddieiElkin&lgnmNo16TdDI@

,qydopla4}&elt44hiln|M@Nid

dillfu dlh Pl@sr $hru$F neBl

u d@ rrd c@ P+jEh ELsimu

tojb P!j* hpd h.Eqtbr btudq r y btu Dndb r4t4d

. ed tukl@r Pojor Leil Bqi;

t1)P.@dr Pab nqqawr top dot v*4

t1)Pa@dt Pdj* hb,i rd, aEGgtdnd4k|pfuNrtedu6@

Pl@dq]PqdrqqnqP4dh\lirgl

dPr@kr * yas k841$4r rq! rQrsjer prri@@1izhhr dd\

&lu.r&pidiaBob+nqlqdd rqds Biir ]d!

n jd k!i44isi d{ Pdei PlEk s

r{rd Pii*. aFbi hDFoshr! etua di kd ri4*q Padihi ruN rb!

diEk$ihpdaPaed kirl

oPdqnno{eEhddd €dhniF D€nrn6uso rujeLn brh rchas tq,oldrFr Ftun ii nFjri

@!e ie rc4bji 06rl &qE! Frb uprift &4e ihlt ts& ihu rhDt

Mljelis bb jqs n@jukPdi url@r]!!lll.ur

Frqa FDrdni d@ tsma t 6ije w eruq $@q dE Fnel r!,

tuinensn nlnk uFyr lmt erujtuL4dieifudi.!s6GleEenWea

:.'-."'.."

l&6€BFk!de6&tEhnfudePubetrFfu!hj!oMbd:

Ftui pnrrtu mcrld Fj* rq

d uF'iD hlhn eq n@rmh baeliei ehbN tui jreiendikd eF DllcLh turin

rt

r. M4q!6h4!FM@!dlllrortuF*r6!ryibrki FqdrBiu sdeb Fje k*Er Mu ldbP,1e @tup@dltE@ lryr.lEEddFjr!d!66tui4tr.

,, xdi Yddn Ffu ofuhk fu fu Nd'Lqd l,ff.# &qtlt9llpitujrMje]fututur&r dfu E!&