-

:

- 2016

- 2016

, , , ,

,

, ,

,

,

,

: , , . , -, , - .

- , , . , - , -. - , , . - : , - - 2016 ., - : , , , , , --, , . , , , : , .

, , , , -, . , .

- - - . . , , . , , , - . : , , , , , , , , .

, , , . , , - . - , - .

, , , , - .

..

, - :

. . , . ; . . , . ; . . , . -; . . , . ; . . , . ; . . , - . ; . . , . ; . . , . --.

, , - :

. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . -, . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . -, . . , . . , . . , . . , . . .

, , , , -, , . - , , - , . , -:

. . , . , . . , . . , . . , . , . . -, . .

, - , , -, :

. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . .

2015 2016 . - . . , - , , , - . , , - . - . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . , . . .

- . . - - .

- - - . . , - .

- - , -, , .

, - , - .

, -

-, , . - . , - . . - . , - , , .

,

- . - , . , , .

, , . -. , , . , .

. . . -. , -. , , -.

. . - , , , .

. -, , - .

, -: ; , ; - , - .

- , , . , . .

,

- : - - . , , ,

, - . , , .

, , , - .

. , , . , . - .

,

, , - . . , , - , ; , ; - , , , , - . - , - ( , ). -, , , . , , , - .

- , . , - .

, , - , . - - : , - , . , , , - , - .

- , , , , , -, .

, . - , - .

BIM Building Information Modeling ( ) : , , , , - - - -

1

4

5 5 6

6 10

12 16 16 16 17 18 18 18

1. - 201.1 211.2 211.3 22

1.3.1 ? 221.3.2 271.3.3 281.3.4 301.3.5 -

431.4 44

1.4.1 441.4.2 441.4.3 461.4.4 461.4.5 46

1.5 - 501.5.1

511.5.2

511.5.3

541.6 56

2. - 582.1 592.2 592.3 61

2.3.1 , 622.3.2 62

2 -:

2.3.3 , 632.3.4 642.3.5 64

2.4 652.4.1 652.4.2 , 68

2.5 742.5.1 742.5.2 76

2.6 802.6.1 802.6.2 85

2.7 85

3. vs : 883.1 893.2 893.3

- 913.3.1 913.3.2 95

3.4 983.4.1 983.4.2

1033.4.3 110

3.5 121

4. 1244.1 1254.2 1264.3 : 1294.4 1324.5 1344.6 1344.7 135

4.7.1 , 1354.7.2 , 136

4.8 1374.9 1374.10 1434.11

1454.12 146

5. 1505.1 1515.2 1515.3 ? 1535.4 157

3

5.4.1 1575.4.2 1575.4.3 1595.4.4 161

5.5 1705.6 173

6. 176

180

184

186

1. 1. 23 2. 29 3. 31 4. 35 5. 41

2. 6. : 69 7. : 82

3. 8. ? 93 9. 95 10.

- 111 11. : 112 12. 120

4. 13. 127 14. NYC BigApps 128 15. - 131

5. 16. 165

4 -:

5

, - - - . - ( , - , , - ), .

- - - . - , , -, - , , - , - - -.

-, , - - -. - - . , - - , - , - .

-

, - . - - , , - , - . , - , - , - , , , - , , .

- . , - - , - - - . - . . - - - , - .

- , , - . ,

6 -:

- - (, ). , - - , - . - , - , , -, (), - - - . - - , - - .

-, , , - , , , - , -, - . , , - , -.

, -

, , - , - , , - .

- -, - , - . , - , , , , , - - - .

, - - , , - ,

- , , , , .

7

- . - , -, XIX , 1, - -. - , . - - , , . , - - , , - , , - .

- - -. . 2 1925 , , - - : . - - :

; ; ; ; .

, - .

- , -, , , - . , - , - .

- (. 3) - - . - , , , , , - - ( -) . , - , - , .

- - -. - , - . - - . - - -.

1 , .. . : , 1926.2 . : // . . 11. . 2000, 4. . 122136.

8 -:

(spatial governance), , , - (. 1).

-, - - (. 4) (. 5). - - , , , - -, , - , , , . - -, , ,

, - , - -.

, - , - - . , - : i) - , - , - , (, - , -); ii) , , ; iii) , - ,

.1.C

:

-

(+)

9

, , ; iv) - -, .. , - , , - , , - .

- - . , . -. - - . - - . - 1994 3 -

, - - , - . , - , (impact assessment method)4, - - . - - (. 2).

, - : -, , . - - . - - - .

.2.

:

3 Wegener M. (1994) Operational urban models: state of the art Journal of the American Planning Association, 60, 1729.4 The 2006 City of Ottawa Transportation Impact Assessment (TIA) Guidelines, 2006; The 2015 Social impact assessment policy of Liverpool City, 2015.

10 -:

- :

- - - - . - , - .

- (, - , - , - , - , ..) , - , - .

5 , , -. - , - - . - - , .

, , , - -. -

. - - - , - , - .

, - -, - , , - . - - , - - (, - - , - ). - - . - , .

, - , - - . , , , .. - , , - - , -

5 : [] 28 2014 . N 172- ( ", 30.06.2014, N 26 ( I, . 3378)

11

- . - - , , , - . - - .

- . , - - - -.

-, - - . - , - , , - . , , , , - ?

- . , , -, -. , - , - - , - - .

- - , - -, - -, .

- - - . - . , - -, , , -, - , - - . -, , - , - , - .

, - - , , , , - . , - - - , 6 (

12 -:

- -, - ). - - , ( -)7. - , - , . - , -, , - . , - . - - . -. , - , , - , - , . -, - , . - . - . - .

- , . . - .

- - -, . , - , .. - - . - - , - . - - . -, - -.

, - - - , - - - , - - . - - , - .

- -. , .

6 . 136..2 []: 31.07.1998 N 145- (" ", 03.08.1998, N 31, . 3823)

7 . 81 .3 31.07.1998 N 145-

13

- , - - - . - - - - . - - - , - , , , - - . , , -. , - , - . - , , - , - - ( , -) . - , - , , - - . - , - . - - (),

, , - .

- , - - -, -. , -, , ( ). -, . , - . - - - - - .

- - -, - , - . - - , 2008-, -. . , ,

14 -:

. - 15% , . - , . , - - , .. () . ( !) - - - . - , - - -, - - . , , - . , , - - - . :

- - ;

- - - .

, - - - .

- . - , - , - - . - - - - . - - - -, . - , - - , - - . - , - - .

- - , - (, - .). - - -, - ( ), ,

15

-. - - - , - - . - - - .

- - -, - -. . , - - , -, , -.

. - , - , - - . , , - - - , - ( -). , - -

(, ), (, - - - ).

. - - -. - - , . - , - , -, ..

. - -, , , - , . -, . - - .

- . -. - - -, -. ,

16 -:

-, .

- 8 : , , , , , --, - . : - , 2015 2016 . , - .

- , , . - , - . - , , -, , - . - : - 6 , 1% 20% . , , , - , - 8. - , , , - ( - ).

, , , - , - , - , - , ( 5% ) - , 9. - - .

- . - -. : ; , ; - -; ; ; . , -, , -, , , -, , , .

-, 20082015 ,

8 20 000 2 000 000 .9 UN Habitat (2013). Urban Planning for City Leaders. United Nations Human Settlements Program (UN-Habitat), Nairobi

17

. 2015 (, - -) - 2014 .

: -;

- (-, , ..);

- ;

() -, - ;

- - , , , ;

- ;

, - - - ;

, - : - .

, - , -, - .

- . - , - - .

, -, , - , - .. - .

, - - :

, ;

- . - ;

- , - ;

- - - , - - . , , - - . , - , - - ;

- . - - 8 . - - , ,

18 -:

, , , . - , - .

, , - - -. - .

, - , -, - , - -. - -, - . - - - -, , , - . , - , .

20152016 , -, , , - -. , - . , - , , , , -- -. --2015 (-, 2015) - (, 2015), - - : , -, (, , 2015). - 2015.

, . - . - - , . - - .

19

- . - , . - - - .

20 -:

1.

-

1. -21

1.1 - - , . - - - -. , - -. , , - -.

- - , -, - , . - - (, , ..), , , 25 - , - -. : , - , - . , - . - -, - - . - - - .

- -

, - : - - , -, - .

-, , :

- , , - , -, - ;

- -, - .

- - - - .

1.2 - - (-, - 100%), - , -, - . - - .

22 -:

: - , , , -.

- . -, , , - , . - 13-- 12- . - , - - - . - - - , . , , , - , - .

1.31.3.1? , - ,

. - , - , , - - -. , - - , , . , - - . - (governance without government), - 1996 , - ( 1). , - - - , , . - . , .. : - (. 3)?

- - -, - . - , , - , - - -, - . , -, - -: ,

1. -23

- urban government urban governance. -, , . - . -, .

: , , - . government , , , , - . , .

- - . , - , , , , , , , , . , , . , , . - governance . .

OOH urban governance: , , , , , . , , - . - , , , c, , , ( good governance). , (Urban Governance Index) OOH (. 1.1), , , - , ..1.

1 Lange, F.E. (2009). Urban Governance: An Essential Determinant of City Development? World Vision Institute for Research and Development. http://www.worldvision-institut.de/_downloads/allgemein/TheorieUndPraxis_6_UrbanGovernance.pdf

1

24 -:

- , - . - , , , , . . , , - . , - . - , , 2. win-win , , .

: - , , - -, , , , ,

2 Pierre, J.(1999).Models of Urban Governance: the Institutional Dimensions of Urban Politics. Urban Affairs Review 34; 372. http://www.euro.centre.org/rescalingDocuments/files/ESP/UrbanGovernance.pdf

.1.1.

: UN-HABITAT Urban Governance Index http://mirror.unhabitat.org/content.asp?typeid=19&catid=25&cid=2167

,

,

, ,

1. -25

, .. : (i) ; (ii) ; (iii) -; (iv) . - , . , , . - , - -, - . , , . , - - .

. - . - . , . - , - , , , . , , .

- - . . , , - , , . , . . . . . - - . - .

. , . , - . , - . . - : , () . -. - , . , - .

26 -:

.3.

: vk/com/rookosa

, - , -, .. (. 8. ?). - . , , - , -.

governance () . - , .. , - , .

, , , , . , - . - .

1. -27

10 Osborne D., Gaebler T. Reinventing Government. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. 1992, p.25

, - . - 1992 , - / , 10.

- - , - - - , - , .

1.3.2, -- , - -, - - . 1 - .

1, - , , (, , , ..). , , - - .

- -. , - , -

. - - , , . - - - , - , -, -. - - : . - - . - -, .

- - , - , -, . - - . - - , - , - - .

- - -. , , , . .

28 -:

11 : [] 28 2008 . N 607 ( , 05.05.2008, N 18, . 2003. ); 28 2008 . N 607 : [] 17 2012 . N 1317 ( - , 24.12.2012, N 52, . 7490).

1.3.3 - - , - , - - , .

- , , -- - - . , - - , - . 1960- -, , , -, , . ,

- -. - , , - - (-, - ), ..

, - , . 11:

, - -, (. );

, - , -

1.

/

/

/

//

:

1. -29

- (-, ) - - (. );

, - 10 . - , , - , (-);

, , - , - - ().

12 , , , -. .

12 J.R. Logan and H.L. Molotch (1987) Urban Fortunes: The Political Economy of place. Los Angeles: University Of California Press, 1987, p. 5098.

- XX . 1950 1000 10 161 . , 1990 293 . 1. - . - , , 19201930- , .

: , (inner city), - . , , , . 1950- 1980- .

- . , , - .

2

1 Ewing, R., Pendall, R. & Chen, D. Measuring Sprawl and Its Impact, Smart Growth America, 2002. Jackson, K. T., 1985, Crabgrass frontier the suburbanization of the United States: New York, Oxford University Press, 396 p.

30 -:

, (- , - ..), , - - , - .. -.

-, - - , , -, -, .. , - $1 , LSE Cities Victoria Transport Policy Institute13. , 80% - 60% -. - $626 , , $400 , 14. - , , , -, , , - $27 15.

1.3.4 - - , - (. 3), - ( 4) ( 5) ,

- .

- , - , , , - , -, - , , - . -, , - - , , -, , . , , , , (, - , - , , , , - , - ..), - . -, - . - - , -, . , -, , -, , -, . - 4.

13 New Climate Economy Report: Analysis of Public Policies That Unintentionally Encourage and Subsidize Urban Sprawl (2015) http://static.newclimateeconomy.report/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/public-policies-encourage-sprawl-nce-report.pdf.14 Op. cit.15 Thompson D., Suburban Sprawl: Exposing Hidden Costs, Identifying Innovations, Sustainable Prosperity Report, 2013.

1. -31

19601970- , - - . . - . , , , . , - , 1, 1972 - . - . , - ( , ) 2100 .

, (UNEP). , - . - , , , . 1982 , - 5 - , .

1987 (WCED) - , . . ,-,2. , . 1989 . sustainable development, - .

-- 1992 ( ) .

3

1 .., . ., ., .., : . . . : [. . . . ]. - . : - , 1991. 205.2 . ., : . . . ():/ . . . -, . . ; - . : , 1989. 371.

32 -:

: -- , XXI , , , - . , , , .

XXI . XXI - . : - , , , - , ( , , , ).

XXI , , , 3. - . , , , , - . . , . - . -, , , - . , , . - , , - , , .

- 1994 , ( ). , . 80 . - , , , , , ..

-- 1992 - . , - . 2012 20 --. , . , 2012 - .

HABITAT III, 2016 . 2030 , . -, (New Urban Agenda).

1 Agenda 21, https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/Agenda21.pdf

1. -33

(- , , , - ). - , ( , ), (, -), ( , ).

: , -, , . - , . , - . - , - . , , . . , - . , , , - . , , , .

, , , :

; ; ( , - , );

, , - ;

; ; ( , .); ; , ; ; , .

, .

4 Guidance for Member States on Integrated Sustainable Urban Development (Article 7 ERDF Regulation), European Commission http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/informat/2014/guidance_sustainable_urban_development_en.pdf

34 -:

, , . -, , (car free city). - (urban resilience), (urban livability).

, . : , -. , . , - .

- . , , - - - (. Not In My Backyard, NYMBY). - - - ( 2, 3). - (infill development) -, , - - , - , - , - .

, - , - . , - ,

, , - .

, , . -, - - - . , - . , - , - , - - . - , - - : - (), (), - . (, , ).

1. -35

- . . 4.1. . - 1930- . , 1935 . , , , , , , . , 19601970- , , , , .

, , . 1960- , -, . ,

4

.4.1.

: OECD (2012), Compact City Policies: A comparative assessment, OECD Green Crowth Studies, OECD Publishing

:

:

,

-

:

:

-

-

(1930- . .)

, (1960 . .)

(1990 . .)

(2000 . .)

36 -:

. - , .

1980- -, , . , 1. , - , 2. - . , , . , , , , - . , , , , .

, . -

1 Fulford, C. (1996), The compact city and the market, in Jenks, M., E., Burton and K. Williams (eds.) (1996), The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form&, E & FN Spon, Oxford.2 Commission of the European Communities (1990), Green paper on the urban environment, COM(90)218 final, Brussels, 27 June.

.4.2.

: Newman, P., Kenworthy, J., Sustainability and Cities: Overcoming Automobile Dependence. Island Press, Washington, DC, 1999

00

2 000

4 000

6 000

8 000

10 000

12 000

14 000

50 100 150

(/)

Seoul

Hong KongManilaBeijing

JakartaSurabaya

BangkokTokioSingapore

Frankfurt

New York

Perth

Los Angeles

Chicago

ZurichBrussels

Paris

London

200 2500 300

1. -37

, , , , , - . , , , - . , - . (. 4.2).

, - , , - , , . , - , , , , , .

. , - . , , . - , - . , .

( , , );

, ( , , - , );

( , - , - , );

, ( - , , , - );

( , - , , - ).

, , , . , -, , ( )

38 -:

, . - , , .

: :

, , -;

; - ;

; , , (, - , ) (. 4.3);

: , , , ;

, ; ; .

- 50% 20% 3. - 19 $ 4.

1995 $10 , - 5. 14% , 4%, 7%6. , , - 2030 - $1,4 7. 15% 2013 . $200 - ( ), 8.

- - . :

2,5 ; 5 ;

3 Arrington, G.B. and Cervero, R., 2008. Effects of TOD on Housing, Parking, and Travel. Transit Cooperative4 Cortright, J, 2010. New Yorks Green Dividend. CEOs for Cities.5 Laconte, P., 2005. Urban and Transport Management International Trends and Practices. Paper presented at the Joint International Symposium: Sustainable Urban Transport and City. Shanghai.6 Laconte, 2005. Urban and Transport Management.7 The World Bank and Development Research Center of the State Council, 2014. Urban China.8 Rode et al., 2014 (forthcoming). Accessibility in Cities: Transport and Urban Form.

1. -39

30% .

: , - ;

;

.

: 2 ;

, , ; ; - ;

.

.4.3./

: T. Matsumoto, Compact city policies: a comparative assessment, OECD, Presentation at the UNECE-OECD seminar September 26, 2012, Geneva, https://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/hlm/prgm/hmm/green_economy/Sep_26_2012/2_OECD_Tadashi_Matsumoto.pdf

200

500

1 000

1 500

2 000

2 500

3 000

3 500

30 40 50 (./)

60 70

40 -:

700 2 0,8 ( 1,5 CO2- 2030 ). -, 44% 9. , 2, , .

, , . , - . , , , 10 53% 2004 2011 500 10.

9 Asian Development Bank, Clean Air Asia and Chreod Ltd., 2013. Rapid Assessment of City Emissions from Transport and Building Electricity Use. Pasig City, Philippines.

10 Rode et al., 2014 (forthcoming). Accessibility in Cities: Transport and Urban Form.

.4.4.

: Accessibility in cities: transport and urban form. Rode, P., Floater, G., Thomopoulos, N., Docherty, J, Schwinger, P., Mahendra, A. and Fang, W. (2014) Accessibility in cities: transport and urban form. New Climate Economy Cities, Paper 03. LSE Cities, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK

601993

1997 2001 2005 2009

80

100

120

140

160

601993 1997 2001 2005 2009

80

100

120

140

160

601993 1997 2001 2005 2009

80

100

120

140

160

-

1. -41

. , - - - .

- , - , -, - ,

- . , -, - . , - - .

(Smart growth). - 1970- , . - , - , , - . 1991 , - The Ahwahnee Principles, (The Local Government Commission) . - , - - (. 5.1). .

- . , , . (Land Use Board of Appeals) , - - .

- , . - . - , .

, - , , - .

5

42 -:

: ; ; ; ; ; , ; ; ; , ; .

2002 Smart Growth America , - , , 1000 Friends of Oregon (1975 .), the Congress for the New Urbanism (1993 .) .

.5.1.,,

: Floater et al., 2013; Floater et al., 2014; Rode et al., 2013

1. -43

1.3.5- , , -. , - , - -, - , - . - , - - . - - - .

: [] - , .

- :

[] - , , .

-

- .

- -

, , - .

. [...] - .

- - . - - , - . -, - -.

-

, [...] - . - .

-- -

- - , , - :

--; ; [...].

- :

;

44 -:

- - ;

[...].

, - - . - , - , , .

1.4 , - - -, . , , - . , , , - , , - - - .

. , - , - , , , , ..

- - -

- (. 4).

1.4.1 - , - , , - , .. - - , . - - . - : - - - - , - , - - , - . - , - (. 5).

. 5 -, -. . - .

. 5, - -, -. , 34 .

1.4.2 .

1. -45

- - (, BIM , -), (- , ). - - , , - , , (, , ), - (, , --) .. - - -, - . , -

(. 6), , ..

- -, . , , , - . ( , - ) - , - , - -, 16.

.4.

:

16 Oregons Statewide Planning Goals and Guidelines (2010) http://www.oregon.gov/lcd/docs/goals/compilation_of_statewide_planning_goals.pdf

46 -:

- -. , , - - 20 17.

1.4.3 , - . , -, - , -. - , - -, : , - , .. , - , , - , . , - , - , - .

1.4.4 , - . - - ( 510 ), - , - - . - -

, - - , - . - - - .

1.4.5 , - - - - . 18, - - 19 . , - , - . - , - - (. 7).

. 7, - - , -, -, . , - , ,

17 Mandelker D. (1999) Managing Space to Manage Growth. William and Mary Environmental Law and Policy Review, 23(3), p. 801830.18 Public Expenditure Management Handbook (1998), Washington, DC: World Bank. www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/pe/handbook/pem98.pdf19 Simson R., Sharman N., and Aziz I., A Guide to Public Financial Management Literature: For Practitioners in Developing Countries. London: Overseas Development Institute. 2011.

1. -47

.5..,20112015.

: , .

. .

..

48 -:

.6..

: .

1. -49

, .

- , - - (. 8).

, . 8, - , - - - . -, , -, ,

- , 5, 25 . - , , - , - . -, - . - - .

.7.,

: Public Expenditure Management Handbook (1998), www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/pe/handbook/pem98.pdf

1.

, ,

4. ,

6.

,

5.

,

2.

, ,

3.

50 -:

, . (, ..) - .

1.5- - - - .

, - , , , , - , - - .

- - , - , -, .

-? - - - ?

.8.-

:

-

,

,

-

,

1. -51

1.5.1 - - . - - , - , - :

; ; ; -;

-;

.

-, , - , - , - .

. 9 , - 20112014 . - , , - , . (. . 1.3.5).

- ( , - ). , ,

- , - ( , ). - , - ( - 50 ).

1.5.2 - , -, - - , . - 1920- , - - -. - - 20, - , 21. ,

, , , , .

20 . 1909 , .21 . , 1112, 1926 . 200202. : .. . 19261932 . , 2008, . 45.

52 -:

.9..,20102014.

: , .

C , ,

1. -53

, ( , -, , ..) , - . - , - .

- ?

. 10 - (

) - ( ) , - . , ( - , , ..), - - . - : (, , )

.10.,20112025.

: 20092015 ( 11.12. 2008 674) 20112025 ( 02.12.2011 1701)

54 -:

- - .

- , . 10, - -, (. 11).

( - - 2007 2013 ) , - , , - (. 12).

, -, , , , , - , ,

- .

1.5.3 - - - - . - , - - , . .

- -, , - .

.11..,20112014.

:

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

2011 2012 2013 2014

. .

1. -55

. - , - - , - . , - - . - : - . .

, - , -

, . - , - , , . - - , , - .

8 , - 22. -

22 51 : [] 29.12.2004 N 190- ( , 03.01.2005, N 1 ( 1), . 16).

.12.,20072013.

:

0

2

4

6

2007 20092008 2011 20122010 2013

. .

56 -:

, . , - - 23.

1.6.

, -. - , -, - . - -, .

, . - - , , . - , . , , , -

- - .

, - - . - , - - - . , - , -, . - -. - , - . - - , , ,

, , , .

23 51 : [] 29.12.2004 N 190- ( , 03.01.2005, N 1 ( 1), . 16).

1. -57

. - , . - - - . - - - . - , - . , - - - .

58 -:

2.

-

2. -59

2.1 - , - . , - - - , . - . , , - - - , . - - - .

8 :

, - , 75% - ;

, , ;

, - (, ), - , , , , -;

-

- 24, - -;

- ( , - ..), -- - ;

, .

2.2 - , - , - - , - .

25 - - . , - -, , -, . :

;

( , , , );

- ( - ,

24 . , (, -, ); , ( ( 9); , ( ).

60 -:

25 .. (2015) XX XXI . 31(655). . 2336.

- - - -, - - ).

- - - - , - -, - , - - - .

- - . - : , , , , .

-, , . - - - . ( , -

), - . , -, , - . , - , .

- - (, ), - - . , - 25, - .

- - . , , ,

, , .

2. -61

, , . - 172- - - - -, - , - . - , - , - - , , - (!) - - .

2.3 -, - , ( ), ( , - , - ..).

- , , , . - ,

.13.

:

62 -:

, - .

, , . 13.

2.3.1, - . - , - - - . , - , - - - , .

. - , - 26 - - , , - . - , .

, -, , , , - , .

2.3.2 27

26 : [] 7 2012 . N 599 ( , 07.05.2012, N 19, . 2336).27 . 11 1.

.14..,20082014.

: : ,

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

20092008 2011 20122010 2013 2014

.

.

2. -63

, - . , , -, :

, - -, (. );

, - 10 . , - , - - ();

, , - , - - ().

(50 ),

( - ), , - , - -. , - , , - , , . - - ( ) , .

2.3.3, , - . - - , , , - (. 14 15).

, , ,

.15..,20072014.

: ,

0

5

10

15

20

25

200920082007 2011 20122010 2013 2014

.

.

64 -:

28 92.1 .29 . 27.30 136 .31 93.3 .

- . - , - , -, - , - , - .

2.3.4 - , , . , , -, - -, , , - , - .

2.3.5 - - , , . , - . - , , : . , -,

- . - - 10 - 28. , ( ).

- -: ( - - ) - ( ) (-)29. , - , - - (, - )30. , , - ( ), .

, -, . - - 31.

10 .

2. -65

, , - ( -) , - .

- - , , - .. - . - , - , , - , - , ,

-.

- - - - , .

2.42.4.1 20072014 - ( ,

.16.,20072014.

:

15% 20% 20% 24% 24% 25% 25%

33%

23%

28% 28% 34%

27% 27% 43% 28%

54% 43% 43%

33% 44% 43%

28% 35%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

--

66 -:

2.,%

2004 50 50

2006 60 40

2010 70 30

2014 85 15

2004 30 45 15

2014 100

:

3.20072014.,%

*

19% 9%

,-

5% 10%

6% 12%

15% 39%

, 29% 2%

25% 27%

: * 20072017 . 42% 44% .

:

2. -67

-) 67% 85%. . 16, - .

- . - 2, - ().

, - . - - . , - -, - . (, -, , -) , .

- -. 3, 20072014 - ( ) 45% 70% . - , - - .

- 32, - , . - . - (, , ) 20062014 - 4.

- - 2 . 10% ( ) 16% ( -) .

4.3320062014,..%

991,849.07 7% 1,008,501.72 6% 1,748,763.21 9%

2,146,329.75 16% 2,763,047.93 16% 2,059,147.17 10%

13,298,887.47 100% 17,532,079.86 100% 19,641,613.29 100%

:

32 . 137, 139, 140 .33 . , - .

68 -:

- - - - ad hoc , . . -, 2015 20162017 :

2 ; 4 ; 5 ; 5 ; 7 ; -- 8 ; 10 ; 12 .

, - , - - , - , - . - , - . - , - , - .

2.4.2, - . - , -

, . 15% , , - - , - (. 17).

. 17 , ( ) - . 27% , - .

- - ( , ..) - -. 5 - .

5, -. , - ( ) - . , - , - -. , 2015 11% - 1516% 34.

67% 85% .

34 24 26.03.2015 .

2. -69

: , - - . , - , , . , .

. - XX . , , 1. , , , 2, 3, 4 .. - 5.

, . , 46%6. , , . , , - , , .

, . : , , - , , , . - , , , , , - . , - .

. .

6

1 Zhuravskaya, Ekaterina (2010). Federalism in Russia, CEFIR / NES Working Paper No. 141.2 Turner, David and Philip Whitman (2005). Learning from the experience of recovery: The turnaround of poorly performing local authorities, Local Government Studies, 31(5), 627 6543 Rodden, Jonathan A. (2006). Hamiltons Paradox: The Promise and Peril of Fiscal Federalism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press4 Bordignon, Massimo (2013). Economic Crisis and Recentralization of Government: The Italian Experience, IEBs Report on Fiscal Federalism, 62-67.5 Viver Pi-Sunyer, Carles and Gerard Martn (2013). The Recentralization process of state autonomies, IEBs Report on Fiscal Federalism, 46-616

70 -:

28% 21% . , - . . , , - -. 2012 20 . , , ( 681 . .). 1975 -. , -, .

, , 7, . - ( 33%, 31%, 19%), , , , . ( 94%, 78%, 66%) (- 91%, 68%). , , . -45%, , , (77%) - .

, . - , , , , . , , , - . , . - , . , - - , . -, , (, 15%), , . . - - .

7 K. Davey, A Handbook on Finance at Local and Regional Level, https://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?p=&id=1378257&Site=DG1-CDLR&direct=true#Top

2. -71

, -, . - - , 35, - . -

, , - , , - - 36. , - . , , (15%), . , 23%37 15%, 20%38.

.17..,20072014.

:

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

--

21% 27% 22% 32% 25% 23%

43%

19%

35 Chernick H., Reschovsky A. Urban Fiscal Problems: Coordinating Actions Among Governments. In The Urban Crisis: Linking Research to Action, edited by Burton Weisbrod and James Worthy Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 1997.36 .. (2012) . - . -. . 151154. 37 2015 2016 2017 :[] 2 2014 . N 115 ( 01/01 (114) 15 2015 ).38 2015 2016 2017 :[] 28 - 2014 . N 152- ( - http://www.npa.bashkortostan.ru, 29.11.2014).

72 -:

5.

,

,

.

,

.

,

.

,

.

,

.

:

2. -73

6.

(2014) 39(2014)

. .

( )

.

N21 . -

N18 . -

( )

: .

39 . . - . .

74 -:

- (. 17) - , . - - . , ( 6).

6 , . - - - . , , - 15% , . : - , , - , - .

, - , , -. , - - ( ) - , - .. - , .

2.52.5.1 -, - . - -. - , -. , , - . - - , - , - ( 7). - - , - - .

7, - , - .

, - .

2. -75

7.

/

(, , ..)

,

,

()

,

, , () ,

()

:

76 -:

2.5.2 , - -, . ( ). - ( - , ). , - - , - , ..

-

- 15% 33%. - -, 49% 79% - - , - - (. 18, 19).

- 40 9% 19% (. 20).

.18.

:

40%

60%

75%

25%

9% 19% .

40 , ( , , - ).

2. -77

.20,20072014.

:

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

--

9% 10% 16% 12% 12% 18%

19% 17%

.19..,20072014.

:

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

--

22% 31%

21% 23% 36%

13% 25% 20%

27% 15%

51%

23% 8%

47%

47%

29%

11% 4%

6%

7% 5%

10%

5%

3%

78 -:

.21.:(),(),()

: ,

47% 42% 47% 48% 46% 64% 60%

74%

34% 51% 58% 45% 54% 45% 52% 50%

49% 46% 41% 47% 48% 62% 71%

0%

10%20%30%40%50%60%

80%

70%

90%100%

200920082007 2011 20122010 2013 2014

200920082007 2011 20122010 2013 2014

20092008 2011 20122010 2013 2014

0%

10%20%30%40%50%60%

80%70%

90%100%

0%

10%20%30%40%50%60%

80%70%

90%100%

2. -79

- - . 20. - - - (. 21 ,,).

- - - , - . , , , - . , , - , -, - .

, - -- , - .

8.2014.

16 32

8 21

10 30

5 18

13 22

8 31

-- 40 40

4 20

:

, , .

80 -:

2.62.6.1 , - - . - :

: , - , -;

: - - -, - ..

- -, 1, : - ( ) - , . , - - (- , ). .

( 2), - -. , - - , - . - - , ,

- - , 41 ( 8). - - - .

, , - , --, . , - . - -, - - - . , , , , - .

- , , - , - - . - . - - ( ) - ( ). - -.

- -

41 . 31 :[] 31.07.1998 N 146- ( , N 31, 03.08.1998, . 3824).

2. -81

. - - ( 9). , - , . , -, .

, -, - . -. -, 12%.

6 . - - , , - . - , - , - . , , - - - .

9.

,

(16 ) (31 )

, : , , , , ,

, , : , , , ,

50 (./. )

55 ,

8 , ; 6 ; ,

:

82 -:

: . , , 1. , - . , ( , 1% ). - - . , , - . , . , - , , :

? , , - , ?

, .

- 2, , , . - , , , 3, - .

- , - . -. , , . - , , , - . , , . , - .

7

1 H. De Soto (2000), The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else (New York: Basic Books)2 Davy, B. 2012. Land Policy. Planning and The Spatial Consequences of Property. Farnham, Surrey & Burlington, Vermont: Ashgate3 Klein, Daniel B. and John Robinson. "Property: A Bundle of Rights? Prologue to the Property Symposium," Econ Journal Watch 8(3): 193-204, Sept 2011

2. -83

, , (. 3).

, 70 . , , , , - . , - 3,9% . . , - 70% , - .

. , -, , . , 4, 44 , , - 45% -, . 5 , -. , . - 40%.

-. . , - , . , , 6, 1.5%4.5%. 7, - 60% .

, . - , . , , , .. .

4 C.J. Mayer, C.T. Somerville (2000) Land use regulations and new construction Regional Science and Urban Economics, 30 (6) (2000), pp. 6396625 E. Glaeser, B. Ward (2009) The causes and consequences of land use regulation: evidence from Greater Boston Journal of Urban Economics, 65 (3) (2009), pp. 2652786 A. Bertaud, J. Bruckner (2005) Analyzing building-height restrictions: predicted impacts and welfare costs Regional Science and Urban Economics, 35 (2005), pp. 109125 7 Ding, . (2013) Building height restrictions,land development and economic costs In Land Use Policy. January 2013 30(1):485-495

84 -:

. -, , . Urban land market and policy failures , , -, 8.

, . -, - . - , (Not In My Backyard, NYMBY). , , - .

. 9, , - , . - - . , 10.

. - , .

, , , . , . . , , , . - , , -, .

8 Cheshire, P.. (2009) Urban land markets and policy failures. Land Use Futures discussion papers, Foresight, Department for Business Innovation and Skills, London, UK., http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/30837/1/Urban_land_markets_and_policy_failures_(LSERO_version).pdf 9 Ramsey, F. (1927). A contribution to the theory of taxation. Economic Journat 37: 47-61 10 Glaeser E. (1996) The Incentive Effects of Property Taxes on Local Governments 9 Ramsey, F. (1927). A contribution to the theory of taxation. Economic Journat 37: 47-61 10 Glaeser E. (1996) The Incentive Effects of Property Taxes on Local Governments

2. -85

2.6.2 - - , , - . , , - -, , - . - - - . , , , , - .

1, , -. - - (. . 11) , , . , , - , - , .

- -, -, . , - -, , -, ,

. - , - . - , . , - - .

2.7 - :

- : - + -, . , - - , - . , : -, , .. - - .

.

, , .

86 -:

, - . , . - , - . - - - . - .

- - . - , , - , - , . , - . - , , , , .

- -. - - , - 25 - . -, , , () - . .

-

. - - -. - , , . -, , -. - - . , - -, , - .

- - -. - , - , - , . , , - , - . - - (- ), ( , - , , ..).

- , - -.

2. -87

- - . - , - . , . (, , -) . , - , - - , - . , , , .

- . - , -, (-) - , - .

- , - . - - - . - - - , -, - .

88 -:

3. vs :

3. vs:89

3.1 - , -, , - , - , , . , - - .

-, - , -. -. 25 - -: , - ( , ..).

- - -, , . - - , - , - .

, - , - , - , -, :

, ;

;

- - - ;

, -, .

, , , , - - (- - , - ..).

, - , - , - , .

3.2 , - - . - - , , - - . - , - - , , , - ( - ) - - (. 22).

90 -:

. 22, : 80% - - , -. , - , - . - .

, - , - 1998 . -, , 42. -

: - - - -. , , -, - 43.

, - - . - - ,

.22.,19801990.

: 1990 . . 1991

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

60%

70%

199019851980

-

42 23 : [] 29.12.2004 N 190- ( , 03.01.2005, N 1 ( 1), . 16).43 3 : [] 07.05.1998 N 73- ( , N 19, 11.05.1998, . 2069).

3. vs:91

- 1998 . - - , - .

, - - - -. - , - 2004 , - 44. , - - - , , - - .

3.3- -

- , , - - , - .

3.3.1 . , , -, .

- - -45. - :

, - , ;

, - , 10 . , , , - - ();

, - , -, ().

, - ,

44 30 : [] 29.12.2004 N 190- ( , 03.01.2005, N 1 ( 1), . 16.45 : [] 28 2008 . N 607 ( , 05.05.2008, N 18, . 2003); - 28 2008 . N 607 - : [] 17 2012 . N 1317 ( - , 24.12.2012, N 52, . 7490) .

92 -:

-, - , - - - , - -. - - , , - .

. - , - - - . - - . , , - . - - . -, -, - .

-. . - , 2014 , - - . , - .

- , . - -. , - .

. , - - . - , , - - , - , , .

- - . , -, - , . , - -. ,

50 14 (28%) , , - , 8 34 (24%), 7 36 (19%).

3. vs:93

? , , . , -, 1.

-, . - , , , . , - . , - , , , . . . , - , , . , , .

- . , . , , . -, . , . - , -. , , . - : - , - , . - , , .

. () : , . (). - , - . , . , . , .

. .

8

1 E. Slack, A. Cote, 2014, Future of cities: comparative urban governance. Foresight Government Office for Science, London, https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/360420/14-810-urban-governance.pdf

94 -:

- - - 46. - , , - . - . , -, - - , , - , - - -, - .

- -. - , (. 9).

. , , , . -, , - - , , - . , - 2018 ( - , , --). - . (-, , -), , , ( , , - --) - - , - - ,

, . , - , . : , . . , , .

, , - , . - , - . , , , , , - .

46 24,28,30 : [] 29.12.2004 N 190- ( , 03.01.2005, N 1 ( 1), . 16.

3. vs:95

. - , - , 47. - - .

3.3.2 - . - -, - -, , - - . - (. 23).

. 23, 15 70% . , - , .

. , - ,

. . - . . , charrette. - , , , , , , . . , -. , - , , . , . , , , , , .

9

( to boost , , , , ) - , , , .

47 http://top-rf.ru/places.html/153-stroitelstvo-zhilya-v-rossii-za-9-mesyatsev-2014-goda.html http://riarealty.ru/news_house/20160201/406891177.html

96 -:

. , - (. 24).

, - , - - : ( , ) ( 3 ). , - ( 20112015 0,07% - , -- 0,55% , - 0,55%), , , - , .

- , .

, . -, , - 5% (. 10).

10, - - , , -. - , - - .

.23.,19902014.

:

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

1996 19971990 1995 2000 2001 2005 2010 2011 2012 20131998 1999 2014

.

3. vs:97

-, , , -, , --, .

- , () - . - - ,

.24.(,),20052013.

: . - . . 2015

6%6%

5% 4%3%

7%

10%

6%

8%

9%

5%

8%

5%

7%

9%

14%

8,0%9,0%

6,5%7,1%

5,3%

6,9%

10,4%

6,9%

0

0,02

0,04

0,06

0,08

0,10

0,12

0,14

2005 2010 2013

10.20132015.

,

3% 2%

-- 3% 3%

4% 4%

4% 3%

: .

98 -:

, - .

, - - ( -), , - , , - , - .

, - - .

3.4 - - - . -, , - . - :

- - (- ) - ;

, - , - ;

- , -.

- , - - . - , - -, - .

3.4.1 - . 19902000- - - . - - -. (, ), - (. 25).

. 25 , - - , . -, . - ( , - ) . -

3. vs:99

, .

, , -, . (- ) , . - - , . , .

- . (. 26). - 80 , - , - -, ,

.

- - 52 - (. 27). , , - -, , ( - ).

- , - . : - , . , , - . , , .

.25.01.01.2015.

:

74%65%

90%

19%20%

8%2%

7%15%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

100 -:

, - - - -, . - - , .

- - . - , - , . - - (. 28)

, - .

. 28 , - - , -, . (- ), - .

- -, - - . , , ,

.26..

:

3. vs:101

. .

- - , - - -. : -

. 48 - . , , - - . - . . , -

48 VII : 25.10.2001 N 136- ( , 29.10.2001, 44, . 4147).

.27.

: Wikimapia

102 -:

.28.,20112014.

: , .

C , ,

3. vs:103

- -49.

- - . - - ( 01,5%) - ( - 3 ), - -. -, - , , - , . - , - . - - - . , -.

- -, - - . , - - . ,

-, 50.

- , - - 51. - . , : , . , - .

3.4.2 - -, - - . - - . - , - - .

11 - , - - . - , - .

49 46. .50 1. , - , , , : [] 05.08.2010 949 ( , N 142(4418), 10.08.2010) .51 778655-6 , http://asozd2.duma.gov.ru/main.nsf/(SpravkaNew)?OpenAgent&RN=778655-6&02)

104 -:

- 50 , 46, 66, 45 (- ). - - . - - - , , - (, -, ..). , - , - .

- , - - , - , - - . 11 - , . - - - , - . :

- - , - , , -

, - - 52;

- 53;

- - , 54. - , - ..

- . 2011 2013 1126 . - . 29.

. 2930, - - . - , - - .

, -

20112013 . 348 , 42% . , 441 .

52 33 .53 39 .54 40 .

3. vs:105

11

.

,

,

(

-1)

(

)

(

-1)

(

-2)

-

,

-

,

,

,

, ,

, ,

,

3

16

,

,

,

,

,

4-

1

,

:

,

,

,

,

, ,

-

,

40

0 .

,

50

0 .

:

,

,

,

, ,

,

-

,

-

, , -

, ,

,

,

, (

),

,

,

,

,

,

,

5

:

106 -:

, -. - :

-, - ;

- - , , -

- , -55.

, - . - - -- (. 31).

. 31,

55 51 .

.29.,,2011.

: ,

3. vs:107

, . - , .

- . , , - , , - ,

, - . ad hoc , - . -, (. 32).

. 32, - , ,

.30.,,2013.

: ,

108 -:

, . - -, , - - . - - - ,

..

- . , - , -. - -

.31.--,20102015.

: -

20 1019 9

3. vs:109

, , , . - : - , . - - , - . , ,

- .

- - . .

,

1 20092015 : [] 11.12.2008 674 ( , N 235(4028), 24.12.2008).2 20122025 : [] 29.03.2012 193 ( , N 60(4837), 07.04.2012).

.32.1()2(),

:

110 -:

- . - . , - , - -, - , -, .

- . (, ), ( 6). , - , - - - (form-based code), - (performance-based code), , - , - (flexible zoning).

- , - , , . . -. , - , , -56.

-

- . , , , , -. , (). - , , - (-), - - ().

, , - -. , , -, - , - ..

3.4.3 - , - . - . - -, - , - - , , ,

56 10.06.2015. http://www.hel.fi/static/kv/tontti/jatkuvatonttihaku/hakuehdot-ryhmarakennuttamistontit.pdf

3. vs:111

- - . - . -, . City Environmental Quality Review, National Environmental Policy Act. - 1991 .

- - - 1. , 17 :

- ; ; ; ( ); - ; ; (, .); ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; .

30 45 .

, - . , , , -, - , . - , . , - , , ,

10

1 City Environmental Quality Review. Technical Manual http://www.nyc.gov/html/oec/html/ceqr/technical_manual.shtml

112 -:

. , - , , ,

, - .

- , - , .

. - . , , , , .. . - . ( ), . -, , , , - . , . , .

: - . , - -, , . , .

. , , , , . , , 1. .

(taxe locale d'quipement). , , . - 10 . . . 1 . 14 , . 1 5% . 18 36 - .

11

1 French-property.com. Real Estate, Real Living, Real France http://www.french-property.com/guides/france/building/planning/planning-taxes/

3. vs:113

(taxe damnagement). 2012 , , --2. , - , , - --, , (plan local d'urbanisme). ( , , , .., ), . - -- , , , .

, , - , , . . , - , , 400 . . 1 . . 2014 807 , -- 712 . . 200 1 . , 2000 5000 1 .

, , 1 5%. , 150mX712X2.5% = 2670. , , , . 2 : 12 24 - .

(Versement pour sous-densit). . . , . - 25% . , 3. , .

, , : -, , . , , - . - .

2 Code de l'urbanisme Article L331-1 (https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCode.do;jsessionid=7BC0A196F80A09C37D0154FD6F5EF209.tpdila08v_2?cidTexte=LEGITEXT000006074075&dateTexte=20160420)3 Code de l'urbanisme Article L331-37 https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCode.do?idArticle=LEGIARTI000023372099&idSectionTA=LEGISCTA000023370620&cidTexte=LEGITEXT000006074075&dateTexte=20160420

114 -:

.33...20112015.

: ,

,

3. vs:115

2011 - - 57, - - . - 440 . . , 530 . . 20112015 36% (. 33).

. 33 , - , , - , -, . - . 33, - . . - -58.

12, ,

, . - , -.

- , , - -, , ( ) , - .

. 34, - , - - , .

57 14.07.2010 150-III : [] - 25.06.2014 1548-III. ( , N 53, 11.07.2014).58 45 .

12.

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

3 7 6 8 19

1 3 6 8 13

1 3 6 8 7

: ,

7 . , , 2,26 . (32%) .

116 -:

.34.(,,).,20072016.

: ,

3. vs:117

, - - , , - . - , - , - -.

-

(. 35).

. 35 , 20092015 -. 2007 . - .

22 .

.35.,.,20092015.

: , . 2007 .

118 -:

- 16 . - 13,2 . , - - .

- , - . - . 35 , . , 2009 , 2015-. -, . - , , - , -: , -, - 2015 . -, - , - - - .

- . , - - , - - . - - -.

, , - , - , - - .

, - , . - - . , - (-, , , , - -, - ..), - -. - ( --). - , - . -, -, , - .

- - , , . ,

3. vs:119

, , . - , - , -, , .

- - :

- ;

.

- . , - - - , - - - -. (. 11). , - - , , .

, . :

- -, , , ;

-

;

- , - - ( , , - 1);

( - - );

- - .

, , - - . , - - . - , - , .

. - (-, , - 2016 ).

- , - - , - , .

120 -:

. - , , . , .

. , -, , - . , , -. . , 1995 1, - 2005 50% .

, - . , , . - (, ) -, . , , . , , . - 2.

. 19972011 , - ( The Federal Brownfields Tax Incentive)3.

. , - , - , . - , . , (Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits Program4).

12

1 Department of Environment (1995) White Paper. Our Future Homes. Cm2901, HMSO, London.2 . Mello-Roos (The Community Facilities Act) 1982 .3 Brownfields Tax Incentive Fact Sheet (2011) https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-08/documents/ti_factsheet.pdf4 Historic Preservation Tax Incentives (2012) https://www.nps.gov/tps/tax-incentives/taxdocs/about-tax-incentives-2012.pdf

3. vs:121

, , .

, - . , , . , , Birmingham Alliance, .

- , . . , - , . , - , - .

, . - , - , .

3.5

25 . - , , . - , -, , - .

- , - , -. , - , - , .

:

- -. , - . - - / . - , - . - .

- . 25 - , -

122 -:

. - - . - , . , - - , .

- . - . , . - , - , - -, . , - - , , - .

. - , - . - . , - , , - , -. - , -, -

- .

- - . - - ( , - ), -. - . - , , , . - -, -, - . - - (, ). - , - ( , - ..) .

3. vs:123

124 -:

4.

4. 125-125

4.1 . - , , - -. .

- , - , . - -. , - , - , - , - , , , -, - - .. - , ? - , - , - - - .

- - - - ( ).

. - . . , - , (

, - ), . , -, , , -.

, - - , , - -, - , - - ..

, - - . - , , - . - , (, ) -.

- - :

/ ;

- ;

, - ;

-;

- ;

126 -:

- - .

, - , , , - , . -, , . , - , - -. , , - , , , -, - , - (. 13. ). - - , - (. 14. NYC BigApps).

4.2 - - . - ( ()), .

-. - . . , 1921 59. - 1920- - , , - , - , - - 60.

- . - , - . 2008 - 61. - - . - , , - . - - . - - . -. - - - -, . - -

59 .. . . 53. . 122.60 ..(2012) 1920- . . 4 (30). . 257 263.61 : [] 12.05.2008 . 724 (- , 19.05.2008, N 20, . 2290).

4. 127

data-driven city , , . , .., . - .

. 2008 , 55% 1. , . - , , , . , - . 8 .

data-driven city - , . 2013 Amsterdam Institute for Advanced Metropolitan Solutions (AMS Institute), - Delft University of Technology, Wageningen University MIT. , .

, ( ) - , (urban resilience). - , , , , . - , , .

13

1 Fitzgerald. M., Data-Driven City Management., MIT Sloan Management Review, May 2016.

128 -:

NYCBigAppsNYC BigApps , -. - (New York City Economic Development Corporation), , -1.

NYC Open Data. - , , , , . 2009 , - .

. , 2010 MyCityWay BMWi Ventures -, . MyCityWay , , - .

, BMWi Ventures, Embark NYC , - , . 12 .

. , - , . 2013 , - . 2013 , , , , -. 2015 , , , . , - .

, - , , - - , , .

14

1 NYC BigApps, http://bigapps.nyc/p/

4. 129

-62. - - - - -63,64.

- - - - . - , , , - . , - - .

- - - . data-driven city -. - - - - . , -

- - 65. , -, - , - , - - .

4.3: - . - 200 - 66 ,

62 : [] 29.11.2007 282- ( , 03.12.2007, N 49, . 6043).63 , - : [] - 11 2006 670 ( , 20.11.2006, N 47, . 4901).64 - : [] 18 2008 620 ( , 25.08.2008, N 34, . 3929).65 Hancke G., Silva B. (2012) The Role of Advanced Sensing in Smart Cities. Sensors . Volume 13 (1), P.393-425.66 http://www.gks.ru/form/Index.html

DATA-DRIVEN CITY , , .

130 -:

, . ,

- :

1-: - ;

1-: ;

1-: , - ;

1-: - ;

-1: - ;

3-: - - , - ;

1-: .

- , . , - . - - -. , - , , - , . - - , - .

, - -, ,

. - , ( , -; ..), - , - . , - - - - , - - . . - - 67.

- - - . , . , - - , - . - - : (, , ) -, - .

- - , - . -, ( 15).

67 http://www.cityindicators.org/Deliverables/Aggregation%20Final%20Report%20(Reduced)_1-7-2014-129784.pdf

4. 131

- . - , , , . -, 2001 , Bloomberg LP , .

2013 - Mayors Office of Data Analytics, - . , , , -, . , . 1:

. 50 , , -, , , , , , - , , - . - . . , , , - . , , - 60%. - , - .

DataBridge. , - . DataBridge. - DataBridge . , . , - . . - . , , , .

15

1 Mayors Office of Data Analytics, http://www1.nyc.gov/site/analytics/about/about-office-data-analytics.page

132 -:

, - , , . , - - - , , - , .

( ). , , . - -, , . - 1350 . , . , , , -. , - . , - .

, - , .

: , , -, , . , , , .

4.4 - - , -, - , (, ).

-.

(). - - - . . , 2014 - - 1,5 68.

68 .

4. 133

-, -- , , - - 2013 69:

2011 ( 1.19 );

- 2011 ( 1-);

2011 ( .1-);

( 1-);

- ( 1-);

, - 2011 ;

1 2011 ;

-;

- ;

- - (10 - );

- , - ( ) -.

151 966 . -. , -, - .

(, ) - .

- . - , - - (), - ( , - ) . - . -, . - , .

- , - . , , - , 70. , - -, . - - - - ( , ..), . , , - , - - .

, -,

69 http://zakupki.gov.ru/epz/contract/contractCard/common-info.html?reestrNumber=0151300039511000027&source=epz70 102. .

134 -:

( , - ), - . - , - - . , -, - . - , - - . - . - - .

4.5 - - . , , -. - - - , - .

- -, , ,

. -, - - , , - ( ), - . , - , , - -, - . -, --, , - - - (. 31). - . -, , - -, , . - - . - , , , - . , - (. 3), - .

4.6 - - - -,

4. 135

. - - (, - ). - , - . - , - ( -, , - ), -, . - , - , - - .

, , - , - . - , -, - - ( , ..). -, . - , - , - . - , - . - - .

- , . - ,

. - , , - - .

4.74.7.1, , . , -, . , - , - (. 36 - ). , , - , -. :

, - , - ;

, - - , ; - (. 23 -416 );

- (. 26 -115);

- , ,

136 -:

(. 49 -44); , - - (. 12 -261);

(. 28 -190);

- (. 29.3 -190);

- .

- -. , - . - - . , - , - . ,

- -. , - , - ( 13).

13 , - .

, - . - . , . , , - .

4.7.2, , - -: -

13.,

20082014

-- 20092014

20062014

20102014

20132014

20132014

20082014

20122014

:

4. 137

. , - .

- , - . , -, ( ), , , - , - . - -. , - - . - . , - .

- , , - , - - . - , - - . , - , , .. - , - , , - - .

. , -- - , -. - - .

4.8 - - , - . , , - . - - - . - - . - , , - .

4.9 , - , - , -, . - - , , , . -

138 -:

. - , - . , , ; ; - ..

- ( , , , ) . -, ,

-- (. 31), - . - - , (. 36), .

- , . - , -, , - - , -. - . ,

.36..,20112014.

: ,

18% 6% 14% 12%

21% 20%

29% 36%

14% 14%

12% 16% 3%

12%

16% 24% 17% 16%

2011 2012 2013 2014

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

4. 139

.37.,.(),()

:

2000 . .. 2001 4000 . .. 4001 6000 . .. 6001 8000 . .. 8001 10000 . .. 10001 12000 . .. 12001 15000 . ..

100 . .. 101 1000 . .. 1001 5000 . .. 5001 50 000 . .. 50 000 . ..

140 -:

, - . , , , - , - , .

. 37 - ,

. - : - , -. . - , - . (- ).

.38..

: ,

4. 141

- - . - - . - .

, - , , .. - .

.39..

: ,

142 -:

.40..,20102014.

: ,

C , ,

4. 143

4.10 - - , - . , - . 10 , - 71 - - - - - - . - -, - . , - - (-, ..), - - . -

- (. 38).

. 40 - - - . - - - : - , . ( , , -). - (. 39).

(. 3840) - . (. 40), -

, , , .

71 20092015 : [] 11.12.2008 674; - 20112025 : [] - 02.12.2011 1701.

144 -:

(. 39). , - (. 38).

- -: , - , - , -, - , , - , .. - , - .

, -.

, - -. , , , . - - . - - - .

- - - , ..

.41..,2011.

: ,

71%3%

25% 1%

,

4. 145

- - - - .

4.11 , , , - ,

, . , - , , - , - , , . - . . , , . , - .

- , - 2011 2013 (. 2930). , - -.

.42.,2011.()

: ,

62%15%

10%

8%

5%

146 -:

- - . , - . - , - , .. - - . , 2011 - 833 , 2% . . - -, , - . - . - -, , - - .

. 4142 , 71% - - , -. 62% - . , , . , - -. 2011 394 , (210 ./) - - 80 . . - , -,

- .

4.12 - , , , - . - .

, , , -. - - - - .

, , - , - . - - - . - - , - (, - ). - , - - . - - , .

4. 147

, - , - , , , , . - - . 25 - , - - , - . - . , (, - , - - ).

, - - :

- ( - );

- ;

, ;

-, - , - ;

- ;

-

, - ;

- - .

, - . -, - - . - -. - - , -. , - - , .

- -. , , - , - .. - , -, - , , - - .

, - :

-/ -. - - ,

148 -:

- , , , -, , .

- -. - . , - , - , - .

- , - . - , -, 20062007 . . -, -. , , .

- . - - , - -. , , , -. , - - -, - .

- .

, - - - . - data- ( - , - ..). - -, , .

- - - . - . -, , - . - - - -. , - , -.

- - - - - . , - ( ) - - ,

4. 149

- - .

150 -:

5.

5. 151

5.1 - 25 - , - -. -, , - . - , -. - , , - - - -.

- -. , -, , - - .

- - - ( 1), - . - -, ( ). , - - , .

- , (, , - - ), -, .

-, , - . , - . , , - , . - -, - , - .

5.2 , , - . - -, , - , . - , - , - -. - , -, , , -. - (, -

152 -:

), (, - ), - ..

, -, - , - . - - - , - . - -, - - . - , , - , - , - 2.

- - . , - , - , - - . - . , , - - .

- , , . , - - . , , , , , -. , , .

, - , - (-, , ), (, -). , , , - , - -, (- - - - 72). , , , -, - , , . - - . , - , 2010 73. 2014-74.

72 . 3 29.12.2004 191- .73 . 2, . 7 .74 01.09.2014 540 (. 30.09.2015 ) - .

5. 153

, ( ), - , - - .

5.3? - -. - -, - . - - - - , . - , , - . : - , -. : .

Village of Euclid, Ohio v. Ambler Realty Co. (1926 ), , -, - - . - , , , - . - - (land-use zoning).

- . - , - 75.

- , - - . , - , . , - 76 77. . , , ..

- - . -

75 Adams D., Watkins C., White (2005) Planning, public policy & property markets. Oxford: Blackwell.76 Downey G. (1976) Aristotle as an expert on urban problems. Ekistics. Vol. 42, No. 253, pp. 316-321; Rodriguez, Roberto B. (2013). The law of Indies as a foundation of urban design in the Americas, In: ARCC Conference Repository.77 Dcret imprial du 15/10/1810 relatif aux Manufactures et Ateliers qui rpandent une odeur insalubre ou incommode.

154 -:

- ( ) -. , - - , - , - - ( , ..). 1916 , - . - . , - -, .

-, -,

- - . - , ( -). -, , - , , .

- , - - . , , , - ( - 1). ,

.43.

:

5. 155

- , - - , -, , , - (. 43).

. 43 - - , - , - - . - (-, , - ..), -

( ) (. . 44).

, ( , - , ), - , - .

.44.

:

.

156 -:

- - , - - . - - , - -, ( - - ). - - , - - . - . . - , - , nuisance -, - , - - , , - , 78. - Spur Industries, Inc. v. Del E. Webb Development Co. 1972 , , - , , , , -.

-, - ( ) - (. 10).

- - . -, - ( , ..), . - - - , - . , - , - 79.

, - , - . -, - . - - - , -, .., .

78 Bermingham, V.; Carol B. (2008). Tort Law. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-922798-3.79 Mason R. (2005) ECONOMICS AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION: A GUIDE AND REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE. A Disc