อ.ดร.ชัชชม อรรฆภิญญ์ วิชา กฎหมายทรัพย์สินทางปัญญา

!"#$%&'!()&*!+,-./0.,+12

!. "#. $%$$& !##'()**+

3*%$#$%&456-./0.,+12

,)-.)/%0# (Patent) 1&23456 17%6,8!,92:%*-;<!!=>1?@A8<!:B?&:#!6=2#C#D")EF+1#8!=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+02&-;<=9217">71&L" 2 GID1&L" 3 G1M6A#D#2$/%**%0)7;N (A#D#2$/%**%0),)-.)/%0# A.O. 2522 &20#2 3)

728'9/456-./0.,+12

• ,)-.)/%0#=2#C#D")EF+• !7B,)-.)/%0#• ,)-.)/%0#=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+

-./0.,+12!%2728:.;<=

=2#C#D")EF+-;<P!#%/,)-.)/%0#Q"? 0?!6&;I%=EJD"%60M!QC7;N

• @CR7=2#C#D")EF+P5N7>1&M• @CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<&;P%N7=2#C#D")EF+,S6P5N7

• @CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<,2&2#4C#D3B=0+>7-26!B0,21=##&(&20#2 5 G0M!3SM(23>0?/%6:%/&20#2 9)

!%2728:.;<=4>?@A#$B

Q"?G=M=2#C#D")EF+-;<Q&M@CR7627-;<C#2=T!3SMGI?L (&20#2 6)

• =U1&23,)-.)/%0#@7?7:L2&>1&M (novelty) @78<!6V2=L%04BC#D,6:+P!6=U1&23,)-.)/%0#:8!=2#,M6@,#)&>1?&;=2#HI)0P!6>1&M V56Q&M:B?&:#!6627-;<C#2=T!3SMGI?L

• “627-;<C#2=T!3SMGI?L” :8!,)<6-;<&;!3SM>7@LI27%N71#8!@CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<&;!3SMGI?L>7PJD7%N7 :8!>7PJD-;<P!#%/,)-.)/%0# W"3Q&M:92756456LM2HS?C#D")EF+VD#S?1#8!Q&M#S?

3C%D.D%!;%E%F"(!%/() 872/2538@#8<!6&M27/%602C#D0S@1IX= O2IU;=2L)7)VY%3LM2=2#C#D")EF+"%6=IM2LQ&M>$M=2#C#D")EF+P5N7>1&M-;<VDP!#%/,)-.)/%0#Q"? @78<!6V2=&;>/&M27/%602C#D0S@1IX=7;N>70M26C#D@-O&2727GI?L =2#C#D")EF+P!6WV-=+V56Q&M>$M=2#C#D")EF+P5N7>1&M G0M@CR7627-;<C#2=T!3SMGI?L -%N67;NW"3Q&M:92756LM2WV-=+1#8!HS?C#D")EF+VD#S?1#8!Q&M#S?

6%@/()72%!G5&HBIFJ* A#J#$%&3*%$K>6!%2728:.;<=:+61B5L7@(?:J*& ($%12% 6 *223-56)(1) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;1#8!>$?GA#M1I23!3SMGI?L>7#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#(2) =2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?&;=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3">7@!=,2#1#8!,)<6A)&A+-;<Q"?@H3GA#M!3SMGI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# GIDQ&MLM2=2#@CZ"@H37%N7VD=#D-92W"3@!=,2# ,)<6A)&A+ =2#792!!=G,"6 1#8!=2#@CZ"@H30M!,2.2#J$7"?L3C#D=2#>"

(3) =2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#

(4) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;HS?P!#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?L7!=#2$!2J2V%=#@CR7@LI2@=)7,)/GC"@"8!7=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# G0M3%6&)Q"?&;=2#!!=,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#>1?

(5) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;HS?P!#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=# GIDQ"?C#D=2OW'EJ2GI?L=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#>7#2$!2J2V%=#

4J5D.M%2N% 02&&20#2 6 L##:,!6(1) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;1#8!>$?GA#M1I23!3SMGI?L>7#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#GA#M1I23 - Q&MQ"?!3SM-;<V927L7@,&!QC G0MC#D@"X7:8!=2#C#D")EF+7%N7Q"?@H3GA#MQC,SM,2.2#J$71#8!Q&M @$M7 @:#8<!6@CI;<37AI%6627G,6!2-)03+>1?@CR7@$8N!@AI)6 =%/W-#O%A-+&8!48! GA#M1I23-;<>" - 0?!6>7#2$!2J2V%=#@-M27%N7 GA#M1I23@&8<!>" - =M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#

“*+@452+,-./0.,+12” - &;P?!A)V2#J2 3 =#J;

• =#J;G#= :8!L%7-;<&;=2#38<7:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#GID@V?217?2-;<#%/:92P!7%N7

• =#J;-;<,!6 :8!=#J;02&&20#2 19 Q"?G=M=#J;-;<&;=2#792@!2=2#C#D")EF+7%N7!!=G,"6>7627G,"60M!,2.2#J$7[5<617ML3627P!6#%F@CR7HS?V%"1#8!!7B*20>1?&;P5N7>7#2$!2J2V%=# GID38<7:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#,921#%/=2#C#D")EF+7%N7(23>7,)/,!6@"8!77%/G0ML%7@CZ"627\ >1?48!LM2Q"?38<7:92P!7%N7>7L%7@CZ"627G,"67%N7

• =#J;-;<,2& :8!=#J;02&&20#2 19 -L) Q"?G=M=#J;/B::I02&&20#2 14 -;<Q"?38<7:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#,921#%/=2#C#D")EF+QL?7!=#2$!2J2V%=# 4?238<7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#,921#%/=2#C#D")EF+7%N7>7#2$!2J2V%=# (23>7,)/,!6@"8!77%/G0ML%7-;<Q"?38<7:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#7!=#2$!2J2V%=#@CR7:#%N6G#= /B::I7%N7VDP!>1?#D/BLM2L%7-;<Q"?38<7:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#7!=#2$!2J2V%=#@CR7:#%N6G#=@CR7L%7-;<Q"?38<7:92P!>7#2$!2J2V%=#=XQ"? 1&23@10B &20#2 14 =9217"@#8<!6:BJ,&/%0)P!6/B::I-;<VDP!#%/,)-.)/%0#Q"?

4J5-+6'!1 :L2&GA#M1I2302&&20#2 6 L##:,!6 (1) 7%N7Q&M&;P?!3=@L?7 G&?HS?C#D")EF+@!6@CR7HS?792=2#C#D")EF+!!=V9217M23GA#M1I23=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# 1#8!&;HS?!8<7792=2#C#D")EF+7%N7!!=V9217M23=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#V7GA#M1I23 =XVD&;HI>1?=2#C#D")EF+7%N7Q&M48!LM2@CR7=2#C#D")EF+>1&M!;=0M!QC

(2) =2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?&;=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3">7@!=,2#1#8!,)<6A)&A+-;<Q"?@H3GA#M!3SMGI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# GIDQ&MLM2=2#@CZ"@H37%N7VD=#D-92W"3@!=,2# ,)<6A)&A+ =2#792!!=G,"6 1#8!=2#@CZ"@H30M!,2.2#J$7"?L3C#D=2#>"

P?!,%6@=0 =2#@CZ"@H3 02&&20#2 6 L##:,!6 (2) 7;N 1&23456=2#@CZ"@H3-%<L ] QC G0M0?!6&;I%=EJD=2#@CZ"@H30M!,2.2#J$7Q&MLM2W"3L).;>" ] GIDQ&MLM2VD@CZ"@H3(23>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=X02& 12=&;=2#@CZ"@H3GI?L 48!LM2Q&M>$M=2#C#D")EF+>1&M

4J5&!'*J@/()L$BA#JKO5*B%'7P@!%2'7Q:'R& &;=2#=#D-92!3SM 3 I%=EJD-;<Q&M48!

LM2@CR7=2#@CZ"@H3 (&20#2 6 L##:-?23) "%67;N:8!

• =2#@CZ"@H3[5<6Q&M$!/"?L3=U1&23• =2#@CZ"@H3W"3HS?C#D")EF+@!6• =2#@CZ"@H3>7627G,"6,)7:?2#D1LM26

C#D@-O 1#8!>7627G,"60M!,2.2#J$7P!6-26#2$=2#W"3HS?C#D")EF+@CR7HS?@CZ"@H3@!6 GIDHS?C#D")EF+Q"?38<7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#(23>7 12 @"8!7 7%/G0ML%7-;<Q"?&;=2#@CZ"@H3

(3) =2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#4J5-+6'!1 G&?HS?-;<Q"?#%/,)-.)/%0#>7C#D@-O175<6GI?L =XQ&M,2&2#4P!#%/,)-.)/%0#>7C#D@-OQ-3Q"?!;= @78<!6V2=@CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?#%/,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?L

(4) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;HS?P!#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?L7!=#2$!2J2V%=#@CR7@LI2@=)7,)/GC"@"8!7=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# G0M3%6&)Q"?&;=2#!!=,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#>1?(5) =2#C#D")EF+-;<&;HS?P!#%/,)-.)/%0#1#8!!7B,)-.)/%0#QL?GI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=# GIDQ"?C#D=2OW'EJ2GI?L=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#>7#2$!2J2V%=#

=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3"-;<@=)"P5N71#8!@CR7HI&2V2==2#=#D-92!%7&)$!/"?L3=U1&23 1#8!=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3"W"3HS?C#D")EF+ #L&-%N6=2#G,"6HI627P!6HS?C#D")EF+>7627G,"6,)7:?2#D1LM26C#D@-O 1#8!>7627G,"60M!,2.2#J$7P!6-26#2$=2# GID=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3""%6=IM2LQ"?=#D-92(23>7,)/,!6@"8!7=M!7-;<VD&;=2#P!#%/,)-.)/%0# &)>1?48!LM2@CR7=2#@CZ"@H3,2#D,92:%*1#8!#23ID@!;3"02& (2)

!%2728:.;<=/()$(4+?@!%2728:.;<=-H64>?@(Inventive Step)

• Q"?G=M=2#C#D")EF+-;<Q&M@CR7-;<C#DV%=E+W"36M23G=M/B::I-;<&;:L2&$9272*>7#D"%/,2&%*,921#%/627C#D@(-7%N7 (&20#2 7)

• 1&23:L2&LM20?!6Q&M@CR7,)<6-;<,2&2#4:)":?7Q"?W"36M23@=)7QC,921#%/HS?-;<&;:L2&,2&2#4!3SM>7#D"%/C27=I26

:92A)A2=E2O2IU;=2-;< 3523/2537 WV-=+Q"?:)":?70D=#?!AI2,0)=GID@CR7@V?2P!6,)-.)/%0#0D=#?!

AI2,0)="%6=IM2L O2IU;=2L)7)VY%3LM2HI)0(%JK+0D=#?!7;N&;P%N7=2#C#D")EF+,S6P5N7

!;=0%L!3M26175<6:8!@#8<!6@:#8<!6V%=#HI)0=#D"2E O2I,S6,1#%F\ 0%",)7LM2&;P%N7C#D")EF+,S6P5N7 W"3>1?"S-;<HI Q&M0?!6"SLM2W:#6,#?260M26V2=@")&&2=7?!3@A;36>"

'7P@!%2728:.;<=/()-%$%2K728&S!1=A@/%65S1-%#!22$Q"?G=M=2#C#D")EF+-;<,2&2#4792QC>$?C#DW3$7+>7=2#HI)0-26!B0,21=##& #L&-%N61%04=##& @=E0#=##&GIDA2J)$3=##& (&20#2 8)

!%2728:.;<=/()452+,5@S-./0.,+12L:J – @CR7=2#C#D")EF+P5N7>1&M– @CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<,2&2#4C#D3B=0+>7-26!B0,21=##&

(&20#2 65 -L))4J5-+6'!1

,)-.)/%0#&;!23B 20 C (&20#2 35) ,ML7!7B,)-.)/%0#&;!23B 6 C GIDP!0M!!23BQ"? 2 :#%N6 ] ID 2 C

!%255!I,,RF.19+NT=/()452+,-./0.,+12L:J &;1I%=@=JK+02&&20#2 56 "%67;N• 0?!6@CR7=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+>1&M• 0?!6@CR7=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+@A8<!

!B0,21=##&1#8!1%04=##&@-M27%N7=2#-"I!6G//HI)0(%JK+GH6,23!2=2O@:#8<!6#%/W-#-%O7+GIDL)-3BLM2,2&2#4>$?#%/,%**2JW-#-%O7+GIDL)-3BQ"?1#8!Q&M V56@CR7=2#-"I!6@A8<!"SLM2=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+7%N7@CR7=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+@A8<!!B0,21=##&1#8!Q&M (:92A)A2=E2U;=2-;< 7769/2547)

F+!;N8!%255!I,,RF.19+NT=/()L$BKO5*B%A#$B

(1) @CR7,)<6-;<&;1#8!>$?GA#M1I23GI?L>7#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#(2) G//HI)0(%JK+-;<Q"?&;=2#@CZ"@H3(2A ,2#D,92:%* 1#8!#23ID@!;3">7@!=,2#1#8!,)<6A)&A+-;<Q"?@H3GA#M!3SMGI?LQ&MLM2>71#8!7!=#2$!2J2V%=#=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0# - &;1I%==2#@1&8!7=%/,)-.)/%0#=2#C#D")EF+>7&20#2 6 L##:,!6 (2)

(3) G//HI)0(%JK+-;<Q"?&;=2#C#D=2OW'EJ202&&20#2 65 C#D=!/"?L3&20#2 28 &2GI?L=M!7L%7P!#%/,)-.)/%0#(4) G//HI)0(%JK+-;<:I?23=%/G//HI)0(%JK+"%6=IM2L>7 (1) (2) 1#8! (3) V7@1X7Q"?LM2@CR7=2#@I;3/G// 4?2VD48!LM2>1&M 0?!6G0=0M26=%7&2= 0%L!3M26 "S :92A)A2=E2U;=2-;< 5341/2533

:92A)A2=E2U;=2-;< 5341/2533WV-=+!!=G//@138!=7N92W"3!!=G//AL3#)77N92@CR7#M!6,;<@1I;<3&WV-=+QCP!#%/,)-.)/%0# G0MQ&MQ"?#%/=2#V"-D@/;37 V56_!6:"; O2IU;=2@1X7LM2-;<C2=AL3#)77N92-92@CR7,;<@1I;<3&7)"@";3L 0M26=%/P!6HS?!8<7@A;36#23ID@!;3"@IX=7?!3 48!LM2@P?2=#J;02&&20#2 57 V5648!LM2Q&M>$M=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+>1&M

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

!%2452+,-./0.,+12

,S33F/()$(-./0.452+,U 1. HS?C#D")EF+1#8!HS?!!=G//HI)0(%JK+ (&20#210, 15, 65)2. 723V?261#8!HS?LM2V?26 (&20#211, 12, 13)3. HS?#%/W!7,)-.) (&20#210 L##:,!6GIDL##:,2&)

#F+!'!NT=!%2&O)@3C%452+,-./0.,+12• RHJ&O)@3C%45!B5@&B5$$(-./0.!B5@ ($%12% 16) - First-

to-file system• '7P@!%2728:.;<=#2O555!I,,4>?@A#$B ($%12% 6 IF8 57)

3C%452+,-./0.,+12!%2728:.;<= &; 5 #23=2# "%67;N

(1) $8<!-;<G,"6456=2#C#D")EF+(2) I%=EJDGID:L2&&BM61&23P!6=2#C#D")EF+(3) #23ID@!;3"=2#C#D")EF+ \(4) P?!48!,)-.)W"3$%"GV?6(5) #23=2#!8<702&-;<=9217">7=U=#D-#L6

\I\

(&20#2 17)

,ML7,92:%*-;<,B":8! #23ID@!;3"=2#C#D")EF+ GIDP?!48!,)-.)#23ID@!;3"=2#C#D")EF+ 0?!6@CZ"@H3 W"3&;1I%=@=JK+02&&20#2 17 L##:,!6 (3) "%67;N

– 0?!6&;P?!:L2&,&/S#J+#%"=B&– $%"GV?6A!-;<VD>1?HS?&;:L2&$9272*>7#D"%/,2&%*>7O)ICD1#8!L)-32=2#-;<@=;<3LP?!6,2&2#4-92GIDCT)/%0)=2#02&=2#C#D")EF+7%N7Q"?

– #D/BL).;=2#C#D")EF+-;<";-;<,B"-;<HS?C#D")EF+VDA56-#2/Q"?

P?!48!,)-.) (Claim) 1&23456,ML7-;<HS?P!#%/,)-.)/%0#G,"6456@V0721#8!:L2&C#D,6:+-;<VD=9217"456I%=EJDGIDP!/@P0P!6,)<6-;<0?!6=2#Q"?#%/,)-.)G0MHS?@";3L &;1I%=@=JK+>7=2#@P;37P?!48!,)-.)02&&20#2 17 L##:,!6 (4) "%67;N

• 0?!6$%"GV?6>7,)<6-;<0?!6=2#Q"?#%/:L2&:B?&:#!6

• 0?!6$%"GV?6456:L2&>1&M"S :92A)A2=E2U;=2-;< 872/2538

3C%452+,-./0.,+12!%255!I,,RF.19+NT=

&20#2 59 =9217"LM2&;1I%=@$M7@";3L=%/:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#=2#C#D")EF+ G0M:92P!#%/,)-.)/%0#=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+0?!6&;(2AG,"6G//HI)0(%JK+"?L3

-./0.456RHJ/26-./0.,+12

1. ,)-.)02&&20#2 36 [5<6!2VG3=I%=EJDG1M6,)-.)!!=@CR7 2 I%=EJD02&C#D@(-P!6=2#C#D")EF+ "%67;N

- C#D@(--;< 1 ,)-.)/%0#HI)0(%JK+ (Product Patent)

- C#D@(--;< 2 ,)-.)/%0#=##&L).; (Process Patent)

,)-.)/%0#HI)0(%JK+Q"?#%/:L2&:B?&:#!6&2==LM2,)-.)/%0#=##&L).; @78<!6V2=HI)0(%JK+175<6!2VQ"?&2W"3&;=##&L).;1I23!3M26 0%L!3M26@$M7

:92A)A2=E2U;=2-;< 3523/2537 @#8<!60D=#?!AI2,0)=

• ,)-.)P!6HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#HI)0(%JK+ – &20#2 36 L##:175<6 (1)• ,)-.)P!6HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#=##&L).; – &20#2 36 L##:175<6 (2)• ,)-.)P!6HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+ – &20#2 63

4J5-+6'!1

=2#HI)002&P?!48!,)-.)Q&MV92@CR70?!60#6=%7-B=I%=EJD 4?2&;:BJ,&/%0)@1&8!7=%7 C#DW3$7+@1&8!7=%7 -92>1?@=)"HI!3M26@";3L=%7 48!LM2@P?2PM23ID@&)"

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

(6) =2#>$?!BC=#J+[5<6@CR7=2#C#D")EF+-;<Q"?#%/,)-.)/%0#-;<@=;<3L=%/=2#,#?26 =2#-92627 1#8!!BC=#J+!8<7P!6!2=2O327 1#8!327A217DP!6C#D@-O-;<@CR7(2:;G1M6!7B,%**21#8!:L2&0=I6#D1LM26C#D@-O@=;<3L=%/=2#:B?&:#!6,)-.)/%0#[5<6C#D@-OQ-3@CR7(2:;!3SM"?L3 >7=#J;-;<!2=2O3271#8!327A217D"%6=IM2LQ"?@P?2&2>7#2$!2J2V%=#@CR7=2#$%<L:#2L1#8!W"3!B/%0)@10B(7) =2#>$? P23 &;QL?@A8<!P23 @,7!P23 1#8!792@P?2&2>7#2$!2J2V%=#[5<6HI)0(%JK+02&,)-.)/%0# 12=HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#Q"?!7B*201#8!3)73!&>1?HI)0 1#8!P23HI)0(%JK+"%6=IM2LGI?L

-./0.456RHJ/26-./0.,+12 (1B5)2. ,)-.)02&&20#2 37 >7=2#>$?4?!3:92LM2

“,)-.)/%0#Q-3” 1#8!!%=E# ,/- 1#8!!%=E#0M26C#D@-O-;<&;:L2&1&23@";3L=%7!75<6 =2#>$?:921#8!!%=E#02&L##:175<6 0?!6#D/B1&23@IP,)-.)/%0#QL?"?L3

3. ,)-.)02&&20#2 383.1 !7B*20>1?/B::I>">$?,)-.)02&,)-.)/%0#P!60702&&20#2 363.2 W!7,)-.)/%0#>1?G=M/B::I!8<7

1I%=@=JK+=2#!7B*20>1?/B::I!8<7>$?,)-.)02&,)-.)/%0#=2#!7B*20>1?>$?,)-.)02&&20#2 38 HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#VD=9217"@68<!7QP P?!V92=%",)-.) 1#8!=9217":M20!/G-7>7I%=EJD@CR7=2#V92=%"=2#GPM6P%7W"3Q&M$!/.##&Q&MQ"? "S =U=#D-#L6Y/%/-;< 25 A.O. 2542 [5<6G/M6@68<!7QP P?!V92=%",)-.) 1#8!:M20!/G-7\ !!=@CR7 2 C#D@(- "%67;N

=. @68<!7QP P?!V92=%",)-.) 1#8!:M20!/G-7-;<&;I%=EJD@CR7=2#V92=%"=2#GPM6P%7W"3Q&M$!/.##&>70%L@!6 (per se rule) –5 =#J;P. @68<!7QP P?!V92=%",)-.) 1#8!:M20!/G-7-;<Q&M&;I%=EJD@CR7=2#V92=%"=2#GPM6P%7>70%L@!6 [5<6@CR7@#8<!60?!6A)V2#J2@CR7=#J; ] QC (rule of reason)

#@J%/()456RHJ/26-./0.,+12

1. >$?=2#C#D")EF+1#8!=2#!!=G//HI)0(%JK+>1?@=)"C#DW3$7+>7C#D@-O (&20#2 46, 48, 55)2. 17?2-;<@,;3:M2.##&@7;3&#23C (&20#2 43)

=2#@A)=4!7,)-.)/%0#1. @78<!6V2=:L2&Q&M,&/S#J+P!6,)-.)/%0# (&20#2 54, 64)W"3=U1&23=9217">1?HS?&;,ML7Q"?@,;3 1#8!A7%=627!%3=2#_!6O2IP!>1?@A)=4!7,)-.)/%0#-;<Q&M,&/S#J+@78<!6V2=&;=2#!!=,)-.)/%0#W"3Q&M4S=0?!6Q"?"S T;=2-;< 2670/2532 C#D=!/

2. @78<!6V2=HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#Q&M>$?=2#C#D")EF+>1?@=)"C#DW3$7+>7C#D@-O W"3C#2=TLM2&;P?!@-XVV#)6"%60M!QC7;N

=. (231I%6-;<Q"?&;=2#!!=>/!7B*20>1?>$?,)-.)02&&20#2 50 GI?L HS?-#6,)-.)/%0# 1#8!HS?#%/!7B*20 1#8!HS?Q"?#%/!7B*20Q&M"92@7)7=2#HI)0 1#8!Q&MP23 1#8!P23>7#2:2,S6@=)7,&:L#@CR7@LI2@=)7,!6C7%/G0ML%7!!=>/!7B*20

P. HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#!7B*20>1?/B::I!8<7>$?,)-.)W"3ab2ac7&20#2 41(Q&M-9202& “G//”)

>7=#J;"%6=IM2L !.)/";=#&-#%A3+,)7-26Cd**2&;,)-.)P!>1?:JD=##&=2#,)-.)/%0#,%<6@A)=4!7\ (&20#2 55)

4?2HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#Q&M@1X7"?L3=%/:92,%<6@A)=4!7,)-.)/%0#P!6:JD=##&=2#,)-.)/%0# =X&;,)-.)!B-.#J+0M!O2IQ"?(23>7 60 L%7 7%/G0ML%7Q"?#%/GV?6:92,%<6 (&20#2 74)

A#D#2$/%**%0),)-.)/%0# A.O. 2522 &20#2 51 /%**%0)LM2 “@A8<!C#DW3$7+>7=2#C#D=!/=)V=2#!%7@CR7,2.2#JSCW(:1#8!=2#!%7V92@CR7>7=2#C`!6=%7C#D@-O 1#8!=2#,6L7#%=E2 1#8!=2#Q"?&2[5<6-#%A32=#.##&$20)1#8!,)<6GL"I?!& 1#8!C!6=%71#8!/##@-2=2#P2"G:I7!212# 32 1#8!,)<6!BCW(:/#)W(:!3M26!8<7!3M26#B7G#6 1#8!@A8<!C#DW3$7+,2.2#JD!3M26!8<7 =#D-#L6 -/L6 =#& !2V>$?,)-.)02&,)-.)/%0#!3M26>"!3M26175<602&&20#2 36

W"3=#D-92=2#"%6=IM2L@!61#8!>1?/B::I!8<7=#D-92G-7 >7=2#>$?,)-.)"%6=IM2L =#D-#L6 -/L6 =#& VD0?!6@,;3:M20!/G-7G=MHS?-#6,)-.)/%0#1#8!HS?Q"?#%/!7B*20>1?>$?,)-.)P!6HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#02&&20#2 48 L##:,!6 GIDVD0?!6GV?6>1?HS?-#6,)-.)/%0#-#2/@CR717%6,8!W"3Q&M$%=$?2 -%N67;N W"3Q&M!3SM(23/%6:%/@68<!7QP&20#2 46 &20#2 47 GID&20#2 47 -L)…\”

Documents

อ.ดร.ชัชชม อรรฆภิญญ์ วิชา กฎหมายทรัพย์สินทางปัญญา