!"#$%" &'#"()*"

!"#$%& & '(&)** !"+&#*+",-

+)%(*"2011

!"# 351/354$$# 65.7 $91

!"#$%&'()%*+ ,'$-+#$./% 012 3.4"// "$ 5.&#+)%$*'&6/& 7+%+-.$7// #'8 +,'+9:/.

!"#$%&'$, (.).

$91 %&'()* * +,*-.. /&0*'.0&12 / 3.4. $*,56&75. – 8. : 999 «:;5<=(> %,(11», 2011. – 271 1=,.

ISBN 978-5-4295-0012-6

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

!"# 351/354 $$# 65.7

1)& 5.$*$ "$;/;&6<. =/:$:$8 >$)%( ?%+@ :6/-/ 6& A+9&% ,<%( *+)5.+/"*&#&6$ * :$:+@ ,< %+ 6/ ,<'+ 7+.A& / :$:/-A/ ,< %+ 6/ ,<'+ ).&#)%*$A/ ,&" 5/)(A&66+-+ .$".&B&6/8 *'$#&'(C$ $*%+.):/D 5.$*.

© $*,56&75 3.4., 2011 © 999 «:;5<=(> %,(11», 2011ISBN 978-5-4295-0012-6

3

"./01/2342

%&,=,(= 1=,5;G 4%,(>.10&7.( 69= 57=&,5 8MK! ('51=& 7G165-G75()G( *=7(,A>(;.D) 12

,-"*" 1. «8G /,.B0., '=&HG /&)(;D=2 71( /,57.05 .?,G» 27,-"*" 2. I&A>(;.( ;&7&< 1=,5;G 44,-"*" 3. !,&6 /(,7G<: >(H@,&6,5=.-5C.D 57,-"*" 4. !,&6 7=&,&<: /,.75=.-5C.D 78,-"*" 5. !,&6 =,(=.<: 0.H(,50.-5C.D 161,-"*" 6. #56 17&H&>5 )(;D(= 1=,5;* 244

40L57.=;G< *65-5=(02 .)(; 261

!"#$"

%&'&()

*+,-

./0&()

12#3-3-

42,"-5-

(65,-"

/78$+9"2$-

/:"9;-:6

<-+=-

!"#$%" &%#"

!"#$%&

'())%*)+,& -./.#,$%&

!"#$#%#

069">-

<25,">-

!+$-

(,?>"$-

0#1.2%&03.#4,*/5,2

!567627 876039:"(%; !(;<+$=*>: ,?"+*@;: !+"A;B-: 69 700 #*,+$==",?- =;,$+$=*>: 4,4 ( 1 2010 ),($B=>> !("B"+C*?$+-=",?- C*)=*: 69 ( ), 77 ( ) ",="<=;> ($+*'*>: <<! =; B&D& =;,$+$=*> !" !;(*?$?;% !"E&!;?$+--="F ,!","G=",?*: 2009 �– 4332 2005 <;+H?;: (GEL)

6

!62I48/5142

!&0=&,5 ?&>5 ;5-5>, 6&?>5 D 7/(,7G( *-;50 & =&), '=& 35,.-15 $*,56&75 ?&=&7.= 6;.?* «%&'()* * +,*-.. /&0*'.0&12»,

7 &HE(1=7( /,(&H05>50& &E*E(;.( -51=&D, . D &H,5>&7501D J=&< 6;.?( 656 0(65,1=7* /,&=.7 /&,5-.7B(?& &HE(1=7& *;G-;.D. #;.?5 1&&HE5(= H05?*@ 7(1=2 – «HG1=,G( /(,()(;G 6 0*'-B()* 7&-)&A;G» –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«>&?&7&,;G( 6&;6*,1G».

N(?&>;D, 6&?>5 /&71()(1=;& '*71=7*(=1D &A.70(;.( &HE(-1=7(;;&< )G10. . >(<1=7.D, 6&?>5 7;&72 ;5'50512 -5HG=5D 1 6&;C5 1980-F H&,2H5 /,&?,5)), D '.=5@ 6;.?* 1 '*71=7&) &-5H&'(;;&1=.: 1)&A() 0. )G ,51/&,D>.=21D B5;1&) >0D /(,()(;, 6&?>5 &; ;56&;(C /&D7.=1D? K I&11.., 656 7 P;>.., &/.15;;&< 8&;=(6&) 4F0*750.(<, L&,).,*(=1D «1.02;G< 6&;-1(;1*1 7 /&02-* 105HGF ,(L&,)». Q=& ;( =56 /0&F&, 6&?>5 ;*A;G .)(;;& «105HG( ,(L&,)G». 9>;56& .;=*.C.D /&>165-G75(=, '=&, (10. 1,57;.75=2 ?,*-.;16.< 75,.5;= ,(L&,)G /&0.C..,

7

!"#$%&'()%#

?>( -5)(;.0. 90 /,&C(;=&7 0.';&?& 1&1=575 . );&?&6,5=;& /&7G1.0. -5,/05=G, 1 *)(,(;;G), 1&/,&7&A>5@E.)1D «&/=.-).-5C.(<» '.10(;;&1=. 1&=,*>;.6&7 ;5 15 /,&C(;=&7 . /&7G-B(;.() -5,/05= ;5 =( A( 15 /,&C(;=&7, *=&/.';G) . ;(1/&1&H-;G) /,.7(1=. 6 *1/(F* 7G?0D>.= .)(;;& /&10(>;.<.

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

%,.7;(1(;.( /&>&H;&< '(1=;&1=. 7 .>*E.( 1(<'51 ,&11.<-16.( >.16*11.. & 1=,5=(?.. ,5-7.=.D 1=,5;G /&-7&0.= ;5/&)-;.=2 ;5) & =&), '=& =56&( J=5 «1=,5=(?.D». 8G 10.B6&) /,.-7G60. 1)&=,(=2 ;5 1=,5=(?.@ 656 ;5 ;(6.< /05; >(<1=7.<, 1/.-1&6 71(?& =&?&, '=& 1=&.= 1>(05=2 . & '() A(05=(02;& ;( -5HG=2. 9>;56& 7 (( &1;&7( 71(?>5 0(A.= &=65- &= ;51=*/0(;.D /& 71() 5-.)*=5) 7 /&02-* 1&1,(>&=&'(;.D *1.0.< ;5 ;(16&026.F ;5-/,570(;.DF. +&=&7;&1=2 ?,*-.;16.F /&0.=.6&7 &?,5;.'.=2 >(-D=(02;&1=2 ?&1*>5,1=75 D70D(=1D /,.)(,&) F&,&B(?& '*71=75 1=,5=(?... %& 71(< 7.>.)&1=., .)(;;& J=.) '*71=7&) . )&A;& &HTD1;.=2, /&'()* * +,*-.. /&0*'.0&12.

*'+,-./ 01.-, ;5*';G< ,*6&7&>.=(02

O5C.&;502;&?& .110(>&75=(0216&?& *;.7(,1.=(=5«KG1B5D B6&05 J6&;&).6.»

8

"7 017560

" 6&;C( 57?*1=5 2007 ?&>5 7 ,5)65F ,*116&D-G';&?& /,&(6=5 5)(,.65;16&?& .110(>&75=(0216&?& .;1=.=*=5 #5=&;5 HG05

7/(,7G( &,?5;.-&75;5 0(=;DD B6&05 >0D 1=*>(;=&7, .;=(,(1*-@E.F1D .>(D). 17&H&>G. N,(>. *'51=;.6&7 B6&0G HG05 . D, 1,(>. /,(/&>575=(0(< – #5F5 $(;>*6.>-(.

P;=(,(1;G< ,51165-'.6 1 H&?5=(<B.) &/G=&) . 656.)-=& &'(;2 (1=(1=7(;;G), .;=*.=.7;G) '*71=7&) 17&H&>G, #5F5 47-=5;>.0&7.' /&1=&D;;& 1&H.,50 7&6,*? 1(HD 1=5<6. A5>;GF >& .;L&,)5C.. *'(;.6&7. U( ,5-?&7&,G, /,&>&0A57B.(1D ?0*H&-6& -5 /&0;&'2, >& 1.F /&, 71/&).;5@=1D 1 H&02B&< =(/0&=&<.

K /&10(>;.< >(;2 -5;D=.< )G – 1=*>(;=G, 1=57B.( *A( ;( =&026& (>.;&)GB0(;;.65)., ;& . >,*-2D)., – B*=D &/,(>(-0D0. 17&. >502;(<B.( 65,2(,;G( /(,1/(6=.7G. #=&-=& 7.>(0 1(HD ?057&< /,(-.>(;=16&< 5>).;.1=,5C.., 6=&-=& – )J,&) ?&-,&>5… V, 7/(,7G(, ;57(,;&(, -5>*)57B.12 =56 /,(>)(=;&, /&<-)505 1(HD ;5 )G10., '=& );( HG05 HG .;=(,(1;5 >&0A;&1=2, 6&-=&,*@ ;5 =&= )&)(;= -5;.)50 $(;>*6.>-(, – ?&1*>5,1=7(;;G< ).;.1=, /& 6&&,>.;5C.. ,(L&,).

N =(F /&, . ,(L&,)G, . +,*-.D 1=50. /,(>)(=&) )&(?& 1;5'505 0.B2 0@H&/G=1=75, 5 /&=&) *A( .110(>&75=(0216&?& .;=(,(15. P 7 &6=DH,( 2008 ?&>5, 6&?>5 D 7/(,7G( &65-50512 7 +,*-.., 7&-;.60. )G10. & ;5/.15;.. J=&< 6;.?., /(,(,&1B.(, 6 )&()* *>.70(;.@, 7 ,(502;G< /,&(6=.

W5 J=& 7,()D D HG7505 7 +,*-.. '*=2 0. ;( '5E(, '() 7 8&-167(. W;56&).0512 1 /,(>1=57.=(0D). &//&-.C.., 57=&,5). . .1/&0;.=(0D). );&A(1=75 ,(L&,), H(1(>&7505 1 =561.1=5). . A.=(0D). ,5-;GF ,(?.&;&7 +,*-.., /&71=,('505 );&?& ;&7GF >,*-(<. P, 6&;(';&, 7 6;.?( ;( /(,(>5=2 71(?& =&?&, '=& );( /&-

9

*+ ,)+(",

1'51=0.7.0&12 *-;5=2 . *7.>(=2. O& D /&1=5,5@12 F&=D HG &H&--;5'.=2 =( L56=G, ,51165-G . 7/('5=0(;.D, 6&=&,G( 1L&,).,&-750. )&( /,(>1=570(;.( & /,&.1F&>.7B.F 7 1=,5;( ,(L&,)5F.

%&J=&)* 7 6;.?( );&?& /,D)&< ,('.: '=&HG /,(>&1=57.=2 '.=5=(0@ 7&-)&A;&1=2 «*10GB5=2 ?&0&15» =(F, 6=& -5>*)G750 . /,&7&>.0 J=. ,(L&,)G, .1/G=5=2 =* ,5>&1=2 &HE(;.D 1 /,&-L(11.&;505)., 6&=&,5D ;(.-)(;;& 7&-;.6505 * )(;D /,. 65A->&) ,5-?&7&,(. 4 >0D *1.0(;.D «JLL(6=5 /,.1*=1=7.D» 7 =(61=( /,.7(>(;G H.&?,5L.. ?057;GF ,(L&,)5=&,&7.

#&;(';&, ;5 7GH&, 1&H(1(>;.6&7 /&70.D0& )&( 0.';&( 7&1-/,.D=.( =&?&, «'=& =56&( F&,&B& . '=& =56&( /0&F&». "0D )(;D H(;>*;&).65 (=56 &//&-.C.&;(,G ;5-G75@= ,5>.6502;G( 0.-H(,502;G( .;.C.5=.7G ;&7&?& ?,*-.;16&?& ,*6&7&>1=75) – J=& J6&;&).65, 6&=&,5D 1=505 /,.&,.=(=;G) ;5/,570(;.() ,5-7.-=.D 7 ;&7&< +,*-... P J=5 6;.?5 – 17&(?& ,&>5 *,&6. J=&< ;5-*6. – 7G,&105 .- );&?&'51&7GF ,5-?&7&,&7 1 #5F&< 47=5;>.0&-7.'(), 1 (?& /&10(>&75=(0D). . 1&,5=;.65)., '2. 7-?0D>G );( H0.-6. . /&;D=;G.

O56&;(C, 1'.=5@ ;(&HF&>.)G) &HTD1;.=2, /&'()* D J=.) -5;.)5@12. I(L&,)G, /,&7(>(;;G( . /,&7&>.)G( 7 +,*-.., .;-=(,(1;G, /&0(-;G, *70(65=(02;G ., 65A(=1D, *;.6502;G. 8;&-?&( .- =&?&, '=& 1>(05;& 7 J=&< 1=,5;(, I&11.D )&A(= . >&0A;5 /(,(;.)5=2. $&0(( =&?&, 7 ;(6&=&,GF -56&;&>5=(02;GF .;.C.-5=.75F 7 I&11.. &='(=0.7& /,&10(A.75@=1D ?,*-.;16.( 6&,;.. O& 7&= *7(,(;;&1=., '=& &;. /,.7(>*= 6 5;50&?.';G) ,(-*02-=5=5), 1(<'51 ;(=.

%&65 & ?,*-.;16.F ,(L&,)5F * ;51 .-7(1=;& ;( =56 );&?&. 9H1*A>(;.( .F =&026& ;5'.;5(=1D. X&=D 1605>G75(=1D 7/(-'5=0(;.(, '=& 6,&)( J)H5,?& ?,*-.;16.F 7.; . ).;(,502;&< 7&>G *1=5;&70(;5 (E( . 1/(C.502;5D H0&65>5 ;5 .;L&,)5C.@ .- +,*-.. . & +,*-... Q=5 H0&65>5 1=505 /,.'.;&< ;51)(B(6 15=.,.65 . /.15=(0D 8.F5.05 Y75;(C6&?&, /&/57B.F, 6 *>.7-0(;.@ );&?.F, 7 JL., ?&1*>5,1=7(;;&?& =(0(65;505: «! )(;D /,&1=& 10(-;5D /,&12H5: &=6,&<=( ;5) +,*-.@. Q=& D ?&7&,@ *A( “=*>5”. Q=& D ?&7&,@ /,&1=& 7&= 7 &'6& =(0(65)(,G. ",&-

10

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

A5E(( &'6& =(0(65)(,G... U,(/(E*E(( &'6&... 9=6,&<=( ;5) +,*-.@! K1( ?&7&,D=, '=& * ;.F 7;*=,(;;DD /&0.=.65 *);(( 7;(B;(<. K1( ?&7&,D=, '=& &;. *;.'=&A.0. 6&,,*/C.@. K1( ?&7&,D=, D ;( -;5@, /,&'(1=2 &H J=&) ;(?>(. K1( ?&7&,D=, '=& &;. =5) +4P 656-=& 0.67.>.,&750.. M=& * ;.F 7 ).;.1=(,1=7( )&0&>G( 0@>. ).;.1=,5). 10*A5=, .) /& >75>C5=2 1()2 0(=. P /& ;(16&026* '(0&7(6 – 1&1=57 ).;.1=(,1=7. M=& ;5) )(B5(= /&-5.)1=7&75=2, /&>1)&=,(=2 7 1675A.;*, '=& =5) /,&.1F&>.=? N&&HE.=( ;5), '=& =5) /,&.1F&>.=. 9==&?&, '=& &H J=&) ;( ?&-7&,D=, &E*E(;.(, '=& =5) ,5<»1.

P;L&,)5C.. & =&), '=& /,&.-&B0& 7 +,*-.. -5 /&10(>;.( 1()2 0(=, >(<1=7.=(02;& )50&. W5=& 10&A.0&12 );&?& ).L&7 &H J=.F ,(L&,)5F – .---5 ;(7(,;&< .;=(,/,(=5C.., .---5 *)GB-0(;;GF *)&0'5;.<, .---5 /(,(>(,?.75;.< . /&>)(;G /&;D=.<, '5E( 71(?& – .---5 HG1=,&=G /,&.1F&>DE.F .-)(;(;.<. U56 '=& 6;.?* 17&@ D ,(B.05 ;5'5=2 .)(;;& 1 ,5-H&,5 J=.F ).L&7, '=&-HG 7 >502;(<B() '.=5=(0D ;.'(?& ;( &=70(650& &= /&7(1=7&75-;.D & 15).F ,(L&,)5F.

***

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

1 "(A*,;G< /& 1=,5;( (www.jvanetsky.ru/data/text/vs/dejurnyi84).

11

*+ ,)+(",

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

12

#<& (!"#$% &'#(")'&"*+'* ,$&*-./*012)1

" 0@H&< 5*>.=&,.., 6&=&,&< D ,51165-G7505 & ?,*-.;16.F ,(-L&,)5F, 5,?*)(;=G )&.F &//&;(;=&7 17&>.0.12, 656 /,5-

7.0&, 6 &/,(>(0(;;&)* ;5H&,* *1=&<'.7GF *=7(,A>(;.<. "5-0(6& ;( 71( J=. *=7(,A>(;.D 1&&=7(=1=7*@= >(<1=7.=(02;&1=.. V F&'* /,&6&))(;=.,&75=2 ;(6&=&,G( .- ;.F2.

1 I51'(=G /,&7(>(;G 7 P;1=.=*=( J6&;&).'(16&?& 5;50.-5. N&/*=1=7*@E.( =()( )5=(,.50G )&A;& ;5<=. ;5 15<=( www.iea.ru/georgia.php. (E#&)( / #$'&&, :.+A& +)+,+ 4:$"$66<D )'4>$&*, 5./A&>. $*%+.$)2 K 6&))(;=5,.DF .1/&02-*(=1D 10(>*@E5D /(,.&>.-5C.D:1992–2003 ??. – /(,.&> >(D=(02;&1=. 5>).;.1=,5C.. /,(-.>(;=5 Q>*5,>5 S(75,>;5>-(;1 2004 ?. – /(,.&> >(D=(02;&1=. 5>).;.1=,5C.. /,(-.>(;=5 8.F5.05 N55-65B7.0.;1992–1994 ??. – /(,.&> /(,7&;5'502;&?& (=,5;1L&,)5C.&;;&?&) J6&;&).-'(16&?& 1/5>5;1995–2007 ??. – /(,7G< /(,.&> J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5, /,&>&0A57B.<1D >& ,&11.<16&-?,*-.;16&< 7&<;G . ).,&7&?& J6&;&).'(16&?& 6,.-.15;1995–2003 ??. – /(,.&> J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5 /,. /,(-.>(;=( S(75,>;5>-(;2000–2003 ??. – '(=G,( /&10(>;.F ?&>5 J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5 /,. /,(-.->(;=( S(75,>;5>-( >& I(7&0@C.. ,&- ('(=G,(F0(=;.< /(,.&>, /& >0.=(02-;&1=. 1&7/5>5@E.< 1 /(,.&>&) /,&7(>(;.D ;5.H&0(( J;(,?.';GF ,(L&,) /,. /,(-.>(;=( N5565B7.0.);2004–2007 ??. – /(,.&> ;5.H&0(( J;(,?.';GF ,(L&,) /,. /,(-.>(;=( N55-65B7.0.;2008–2009 ??. – /(,.&> -5)(>0(;.D J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5, 5 -5=() J6&-;&).'(16&?& 1/5>5 7 ,(-*02=5=( 7&->(<1=7.D /,(A>( 71(?& ,&11.<16&-?,*-.;16&< 7&<;G . ).,&7&?& J6&;&).'(16&?& 6,.-.15;1 2010 ?. – 7=&,&< /(,.&> J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5.

13

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

1. «!"#$%&'()* +#,)» ')'-)./)'0 %'(/1+%-*/0&) 2/34),3".

("#5&)63'7-32&)8 63-*"%3/0&)8 5),,*"9(* $353,&:; '-"3&,

< 5*"<#1 )+*"*,0 =>?.

"(<1=7.=(02;&, 7 +,*-.@ /&1=*/5(= 1*E(1=7(;;5D /&)&E2 .---5 ,*H(A5. 9>;56& 7;(B;@@ /&>>(,A6* /&0*'5@= H&0(( 180 1=,5; ).,5, . >50(6& ;( 71( &;. >()&;1=,.,*@= 1&/&-1=57.)G( 1 ?,*-.;16.). =()/G J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5. K1(?& -5 1992–2007 ?&>G 7 +,*-.@ /&1=*/.0& 7 65'(1=7( &L.C.502-;&< /&)&E. ,5-7.=.@1 (9%I) 4,3 ).00.5,>5 >&005,&7 NS4 (7 C(;5F 2005 ?&>5), /,.'() 3 ).00.5,>5 – -5 1992–2003 ?&>G, 5 1,3 ).00.5,>5 – -5 /(,7G( 4 ?&>5 ,(L&,) (2004–2007 ?&>G). %,. J=&) 7 =('(;.( 9 0(= – 1 1994 /& 2003 ?&> (/(,.&> J6&;&).-'(16&?& ,&1=5 >& ;5'505 ,5>.6502;GF ,(L&,)) – ,5-)(,G 9%I 1&1=570D0. 7 1,(>;() 7,7 /,&C(;=5 KK% 7 ?&>, 5 1,(>;(?&>&7G( =()/G J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5 – 5,9 /,&C(;=5. K /&10(>*@E.( 4 ?&>5 (2004–2007) ,5-)(,G 9%I 1;.-.0.12 >& 4,7 /,&C(;=5 KK%, &>;56& 1,(>;(?&>&7G( =()/G /,.,&1=5 KK% +,*-.. *7(-0.'.0.12 >& 9,3 /,&C(;=5.

K 2004–2007 ?&>5F +,*-.. HG05 /,(>&1=570(;5 9%I 7 ,5-)(-,( 298 >&005,&7 ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D (7 C(;5F 2005 ?&>5). W5 =&= A( 15)G< /(,.&> /&)&E2 7 H[ 02B.F ,5-)(,5F 7 /(,(1'(=(;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D /&0*'.0. 44 1=,5;G ).,5. 9>;56& =()/G /,.,&1=5 KK% ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D 7GB(, '() 7 +,*-.., &65-5-0.12 =&026& 7 &>;&< .- ;.F – 7 4,)(;...

NS4 -5 J=. '(=G,( ?&>5 /,(>&1=57.0. +,*-.. 349 ).00.&;&7 >&005,&7 (7 C(;5F 2005 ?&>5), =& (1=2 '*=2 H&0(( '(=7(,=. &= 71(< /&0*'(;;&< +,*-.(< /&)&E., .0. 79 >&005,&7 ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D. K =& A( 7,()D 14 1=,5; ).,5 /&0*'.0. &= NS4 H[ 02B*@ /&)&E2

1 9L.C.502;5D /&)&E2 ,5-7.=.@ (9%I) 1&1=&.= .- 6,(>.=&7, 7G>5;;GF ;5 02?&=;GF *10&7.DF, 5 =56A( ?,5;=&7 &L.C.502;GF *',(A>(;.< 1=,5; – '0(;&7 #&).=(=5 1&>(<1=7.D ,5-7.=.@ (#NI), );&?&1=&,&;;.F &,?5;.--5C.<, 5 =56A( 1=,5;, ;( D70D@E.F1D '0(;5). #NI, >0D 1=.)*0.,&75;.D J6&;&).'(16&?& ,5-7.=.D . H05?&1&1=&D;.D 7 1=,5;5F . =(,,.=&,.DF, /&-0*'5@E.F 9%I .- 1/.165 #NI. 9%I 760@'5(= 7 1(HD 6,(>.=G 1 J0()(;=5). ?,5;=&7 ;( )(;(( 25 /,&C(;=&7 (,511'.=G75(=1D /& *'(=;&< 1=576( 10 /,&-C(;=&7).

14

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D, 7 =&) '.10(, ;5/,.)(,, 4,)(;.D – 87 >&005,&7 ;5 '(0&7(65. N0(>*(= -5)(=.=2, '=& -5 '(=G,( ?&>5, /,(>B(1=7&-757B.( ,(L&,)5) (2000–2003), +,*-.D /&0*'.05 &= NS4 /&)&E. H&02B(, '() 7 /(,.&> ,(L&,) (2004–2007), – 413 ).00.&;&7 >&0-05,&7 . 349 ).00.&;&7 >&005,&7 1&&=7(=1=7(;;&. 9>;56& 6 5;5-0&?.';G) J6&;&).'(16.) *1/(F5) 70.75;.D 7 >&,(L&,)(;;G< /(,.&> ;( /,.7(0.: 1 2000 /& 2003 ?&> >*B(7&< KK% 7G,&1 ;5 28,7 /,&C(;=5, 5 7 2004–2007 ?&>5F – ;5 40,6 /,&C(;=5.

2. !"#$%&'(3. @()&)6%(3 $3<%'%- )- 5*"*<),)< @6%4"3&-)<.

"5, >0D ;(H&02B.F ;(H&?5=GF 1=,5; =56&< .1=&';.6 1,(>1=7 .?,5(= 75A;*@ ,&02 7 /&>>(,A5;.. *,&7;D /&=,(H0(;.D ?,5A->5;. 9>;56& ?5,5;=.,&75; 0. HG1=,G< J6&;&).'(16.< ,&1= ;5 >(;2?. «H&?5=GF ,&>1=7(;;.6&7»? K 2004–2007 ?&>5F 7 7.>( /(,(7&>&7 '51=;GF 0.C .---5 ,*H(A5 +,*-.D /&0*'.05 1,38 ).0-0.5,>5 >&005,&7 (7 C(;5F 2005 ?&>5), .0. 315 >&005,&7 ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D. W5 =( A( ?&>G 55 1=,5; ).,5 /&0*'.0. 7 ,51'(=( ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D H&02B( >(;(A;GF 1,(>1=7, '() +,*-.D. O& =&026& 7 >7*F .- ;.F – 35=7.. (/(,(7&>G .---5 ,*H(A5 7 ,5-)(-,( 804 >&005,5 ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D) . 4,)(;.. (694 >&005,5) – =()/G J6&;&).'(16&?& ,&1=5 &65-50.12 7GB(, '() 7 +,*-...

K /&0*'(;.. H(-7&-)(->;GF 1,(>1=7 .- >7*F .1=&';.6&7 >(;(? – ?,5;=&7 . >(;(A;GF /(,(7&>&7 .---5 ,*H(A5 – 7 2004–2007 ?&>5F 4,)(;.D &/(,(A505 +,*-.@ (1010 >&005,&7 ;5 >*B* ;51(0(;.D /,&=.7 613 >&005,&7). U56.) 1&&=;&B(;.() )&A;& /&/G=5=21D &HTD1;.=2 H&0(( 7G1&6.( 1,(>;(?&>&7G( =()/G /,.,&1=5 KK% 7 4,)(;.. (12,8 /,&C(;=5), '() 7 +,*-.. (9,3 /,&C(;=5). O& >(1D=6. 1=,5;, /&0*'.7B.F H[ 02B.( 70.75-;.D 9%I, =() ;( )(;(( ,&10. 1*E(1=7(;;& )(>0(;;((.

3. A3 <"*6. 5"3</*&%. =33(37<%/% '-"3&3 5)4"#$%/3'0 < ,)/-

4)<#1 .6#.

N.=*5C.D 1 7;(B;.) ?&1*>5,1=7(;;G) >&0?&) +,*-.. 7G?0D>.= 10(>*@E.) &H,5-&). O5 6&;(C 2003 ?&>5 &; 1&1=570D0 1,849 ).0-0.5,>5 >&005,&7, .0. 46,3 /,&C(;=5 KK%. # 6&;C* 2007 ?&>5 (?&

15

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

5H1&0@=;G< ,5-)(, /&'=. ;( .-)(;.01D – 1,838 ).00.5,>5. 9>;56& 7 1.0* HG1=,&?& ,&1=5 J6&;&).6. . /&7GB(;.D ,(502-;&?& 6*,15 05,. 7(0.'.;5 >&0?5 &=;&1.=(02;& KK% 1;.-.0512 >& 18,1 /,&C(;=5. W5=() – 7 7&(;;&) 2008 ?&>* . 7 6,.-.1;&) 2009 ?&>* – +,*-.. HG0& /,(>&1=570(;& H&02B&( 6&0.'(1=7& 6,(>.=&7 >0D 7&11=5;&70(;.D J6&;&).6.. K ,(-*02=5=( 7;(B;.< >&0? 1=,5;G 7&-,&1 . ;5 6&;(C 2010 ?&>5 1&1=57.0 4,199 ).00.-5,>5 >&005,&7, .0. 35,6 /,&C(;=5 KK%. P;G). 10&75)., &=;&1.-=(02;& ,5-)(,&7 ?,*-.;16&< J6&;&).6. 7;(B;.< >&0? 1(?&>;D 71(-=56. ;.A(, '() &; HG0 7& 7,()(;5 Q>*5,>5 S(75,>;5>-(.

#&?>5 7 I&11.. HG0 /,.)(,;& =56&< A( *,&7(;2 7;(B;(< -5>&0A(;;&1=. – 35,3 /,&C(;=5 KK% 7 2002 ?&>*, – J=& 7&1/,.-;.)50&12 7 ;5B(< 1=,5;( 656 1(,2(-;5D /,&H0()5. I&11.<165D 1.=*5C.D *1*?*H0D0512 (E( =(), '=& &H10*A.75;.( 71(?& ?&1*->5,1=7(;;&?& >&0?5 &HF&>.0&12 7 2,2 /,&C(;=5 KK%. N*E(1=7&-750. &/51(;.D, '=& /05=(A. /& 6,(>.=5) 716&,( 1=5;*= ;(/&-1.02;G) H,()(;(). #56 .-7(1=;&, >&0?&7&< 65=51=,&LG 7 /&-10(>*@E.( ?&>G 7 I&11.. ;( /,&.-&B0& – 7G,*'.05 1=,5=(?.D, 1/&1&H1=7&757B5D /&>>(,A5;.@ 7G1&6.F =()/&7 J6&;&).-'(16&?& ,&1=5 (;50&?&75D ,(L&,)5, 1;.A(;.( ;(/,&C(;=;GF ?&1*>5,1=7(;;GF ,51F&>&7, &H(1/('(;.( /,&L.C.=5 ?&1*>5,-1=7(;;&?& H@>A(=5, 1&->5;.( 1=5H.0.-5C.&;;&?& L&;>5).

N(?&>;D 7 +,*-.. ,51F&>G /& &H10*A.75;.@ >&0?5 ;( /,(-7GB5@= 1 /,&C(;=5 KK%, 5 1,(>;(7-7(B(;;5D 1=5765 /& 7;(B-;.) 6,(>.=5) 1&1=570D(= 71(?& 2,1 /,&C(;=5. #,&)( =&?&, (10. 7 6&;C( 2003 ?&>5 )(A>*;5,&>;G( 750@=;G( ,(-(,7G +,*-.. 1&1=570D0. 196 ).00.&;&7 >&005,&7, =& 6 6&;C* 2010 ?&>5 &;. 7G,&10. H&0(( '() 7 11 ,5- – >& 2,264 ).00.5,>5 >&005,&7.

K5A;G) /&65-5=(0() *1=&<'.7&1=. >&0?&7&< 1.=*5C.. =,5>.C.&;;& 1'.=5(=1D &=;&B(;.( /,&C(;=;GF /05=(A(< 6 J61/&,=*1. W5 /&10(>;.( 7 0(= 7 +,*-.. &;& =56A( 1*E(1=7(;;& *)(;2B.0&12: 7 2003 ?&>* (A(?&>;G( 7G/05=G /& 6,(>.=5) 1&-

1 N=5=.1=.65 7;(B;(?& >&0?5. I*6&7&>1=7& >0D 1&1=57.=(0(< . /&02-&75-=(0(<. 8(A>*;5,&>;G< 750@=;G< L&;>, 2003. N. 184–185 (www.imf.org/external/russian/pubs/ft/eds/guide/guider.pdf).

16

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

1=570D0. 17 /,&C(;=&7, 7 2007 ?&>* &;. 1;.-.0.12 >& 4,8 /,&-C(;=5, 5 7 2010 ?&>* HG0. ;5 *,&7;( 7,4 /,&C(;=5 &= J61/&,=5.

4. =33(37<%/% "3'5"),3/ "),%&#, <'* '(#5%/% %&)'-"3&B:.

Q=& /,57>5, '=& 1 /,.F&>&) 6 7051=. ;&7&< 6&)5;>G 7 2004 ?&>* ;5'50512 .;=(;1.7;5D /,.75=.-5C.D. K /&10(>;.( 5 0(= /,57-0(;.D S(75,>;5>-( (1 1999 /& 2003 ?&>) &= /,&>5A. ?&1*>5,-1=7(;;&?& .)*E(1=75 HG0& /&0*'(;& )(;(( 62 ).00.&;&7 >&0-05,&7, 5 7 /&10(>&757B.( 5 0(= (1 2004 /& 2008 ?&>) – 1,44 ).0-0.5,>5.

O516&026& -;5'.=(02;G) 1=50& *'51=.( -5,*H(A;GF 1&H-1=7(;;.6&7 7 ?,*-.;16&< J6&;&).6(? "&0D .;&1=,5;;GF 6&)-/5;.< 7 7G/*16( /,&>*6C.. 1 2006 /& 2009 ?&> 7G,&105 1 28,4 >& 35,2 /,&C(;=5. #5A(=1D, ;(;5);&?&. O& 7&= 7 '() .;&1=,5;CG >(<1=7.=(02;& 0.>.,*@=, =56 J=& 7 *,&7;( 70&A(;.< 7 &1;&7-;&< 65/.=50. W5 4 ?&>5 (2006–2009) &;. .;7(1=.,&750. 2 ).0-0.5,>5 >&005,&7 (7 C(;5F 2006 ?&>5), 7 =& 7,()D 656 '51=;G( ,(-.>(;=G – 1,5 ).00.5,>5, 5 ?&1*>5,1=7& – 1,6 ).00.5,>5.

5. !"#$%&'(3. @()&)6%(3 $3<%'%- )- C)''%%. D #'/)<%.; ")''%8-

'()4) @623"4) )&3 ,)/4) &* 5"),*"9%-'..

I&11.<16.( 7051=., /&F&A(, .1/&02-&750. 71( .;1=,*)(;=G, '=&HG ?,*-.;165D J6&;&).65 /(,(1=505 HG=2 -57.1.)&< &= I&1-1..: ,(-6&( /&7GB(;.( C(; ;5 ?5-, J)H5,?& ;5 ?,*-.;16&( 7.;& . ).;(,502;*@ 7&>*, =&,?&7*@, =,5;1/&,=;*@ . /&'=&7*@ H0&-65>*, &=)(;* 7G>5'. 7.- ?,5A>5;5) +,*-.., 7G1G06* ?,*-.;-16.F ?,5A>5; .- I&11.., 5;=.?,*-.;16*@ /,&/5?5;>.1=16*@ 65)/5;.@, 7&(;;&( . >./0&)5=.'(16&( >570(;.(, 7&<;* . &6-6*/5C.@ /D=&< '51=. 1=,5;G.

O(*>.7.=(02;&, '=& ,(-*02=5=&) J=.F )(, 1=50& ,(-6&( 1;.-A(;.( .;=(;1.7;&1=. =&,?&7GF 17D-(<. K 2005 ?&>* 7 I&11.@ ;5/,570D0&12 17,8 /,&C(;=5 ?,*-.;16&?& J61/&,=5, 7 2009 ?&>* J=&= /&65-5=(02 */50 >& 1,6 /,&C(;=5. !>(02;G< 7(1 I&11.. 7 ?,*-.;16&) .)/&,=( 1;.-.01D 1 15,4 7 2005 ?&>* >& 6,6 /,&-C(;=5 7 2009 ?&>*.

17

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

%&1=,5>505 0. +,*-.D &= 1&6,5E(;.D =&,?&7GF 17D-(< 1 I&1-1.(<? O( H(- J=&?&. O& ?,*-.;16.< KK% 1 2003 /& 2010 ?&> 7G,&1 ;5 49,3 /,&C(;=5, 5 ,&11.<16.< – ;(1)&=,D ;5 .160@'.=(02;& 7G1&6.( ).,&7G( C(;G ;5 =&75,G =,5>.C.&;;&?& ,&11.<16&?& J61/&,=5 – 0.B2 ;5 34,8.

6. D !"#$%% &*- ')2'-<*&&)4) 5")%$<),'-<3, &3 5"),39# <:<)-

$%-'. -)/0() 6*-3//)/)6.

"& ;5'505 ,(L&,) )(=500&0&) >(<1=7.=(02;& 0.>.,&750 7 1/.-16( J61/&,=;GF =&75,&7 – 7 2004 ?&>* ;5 (?& >&0@ 7 J61/&,=( /,.F&>.0&12 14,8 /,&C(;=5, 5 =,(=2( )(1=& -5;.)50. L(,,&-1/057G (6,6 /,&C(;=5). 9>;56& -5=() 1.=*5C.D .-)(;.0512. K 2010 ?&>* 16,7 /,&C(;=5 ?,*-.;16&?& J61/&,=5 1&1=57.0. L(,,&1/057G (0.>.,*@E5D 1=5=2D J61/&,=5), 5 0&) '(,;GF )(-

<&+(-:%8: ",&-#+ 2( $,::7. =+,+%&+%-#&8(> &'/9?7 0"/1%%, External Trade (www.geostat.ge/index.php?action=page&p_id=137&lang=eng)

./0-1234 *0% 5)%%$$ * %6#'(6'#0 *207204 6)#8)*-$ ,#'9$$ (%)

) @8&2("+# ) %.2("+#

32

30

28

26

24

22

20

18

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

01998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

18

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

=500&7 –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

7. E-) &* /%2*"3/0&:* "*F)"6:, *'/% "3'-#- 4)'#,3"'-<*&&:*

"3';),: % #<*/%+%<3*-'. ,*F%B%- 21,9*-3.

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–2007 ?&>5F HG0 H0.-&6 6 &/=.)502;G) -;5'(;.D) >0D 1=,5;G =56&?& *,&7;D J6&;&).'(16&?& ,5-7.=.D1. K&-)&A;&, 7 =&) '.10( . /&J=&)* ?,*-.;165D J6&;&).65 .)(;;& 7 J=&= /(,.&> ,&105 =()/5)., 1*E(1=7(;;& /,(7GB57B.). 1,(>;().,&7G( /&65-5=(0.. +&1*>5,1=7(;;G( ,51F&>G ,&10. 7)(1=( 1 >&F&>5). H@>A(=5, 6&=&,G( *7(0.'.0.12 H05?&>5,D ,&1=* 1&H.,5()&1=. ;50&?&7, 7G-75;;&)* 1*E(1=7(;;G) 1;.A(;.() ;50&?&7GF 1=57&6. %,.'() *7(0.'(;.( ?&1*>5,1=7(;;GF ,51F&>&7 HG0&

1 8(=&>.6* ,51'(=5 &/=.)502;&?& *,&7;D ?&1*>5,1=7(;;GF ,51F&>&7 1). 7: !''$./+6+* F., G/*+*$.+*$ =. I5-)(,G ?&1*>5,1=75 . J6&;&).'(16.< ,&1= // K&/,&1G J6&;&).6.. 2002. \ 9. N. 18–45.

19

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

7 C(0&) &=;&1.=(02;& 1H505;1.,&75;;G): 7 2005–2007 ?&>5F >(L.C.= 6&;1&0.>.,&75;;&?& H@>A(=5 1&1=570D0 71(?& 0,2–0,3 /,&C(;=5 KK%.

9>;56& =(/(,2, /&10( 6,.-.1;&?& /(,.&>5 2008–2009 ?&>&7, 6&?>5 /&65-5=(0. ?&1*>5,1=7(;;GF .-TD=.< .- J6&;&).6. >(<-1=7.=(02;& 1(,2(-;& &=60&;.0.12 &= &/=.)502;GF -;5'(;.<, ;(&HF&>.)& .F 7&-7,5E(;.( 6 *,&7;D) 2004–2007 ?&>&7, &H(1-/('.7B.) 1=,5;( =&?>5 ,(6&,>;G( =()/G ,&1=5.

«%&>&H;& >,*?.) 1=,5;5), ,(C(11.D -5=,&;*05 . +,*-.@, &>;56& /,57.=(021=7& ,(5?.,*(= ;5 J=& ;( /&7GB(;.(), 5 1;.A(;.() ;50&?&7 . /,&>&0A(;.() ,(L&,), – &=)('5(= HG7B.< /,()2(,-).;.1=, Q1=&;.. . HG7B.< 1/(C.502;G< 1&7(=;.6 /,(-.>(;=5 +,*-.. 85,= 355,. – %&F&A(, J6&;&).-'(165D 17&H&>5 D70D(=1D 0*'B(< /&0.=.6&<, . /&/G=6. /(,(-7(1=. 1=,5;G 7 ;5/,570(;.. 1.0&7&< /&0.=.6., 656 J=& /,&-.1F&>.= 7 ;(6&=&,GF /&1=1&7(=16.F 1=,5;5F, – J=& H&02B5D &B.H65»1.

8. ? <)- ?"6*&%. "3'-*- 2:'-"** !"#$%% 2*$ <'.(%; /%2*"3/0-

&:; "*F)"6.

U56&( /,(>1=570(;.( &H 4,)(;.. ;(7(,;&, 0.H(,502;G( ,(L&,-)G 7 ;(< HG0., =&026& 7 &1;&7;&) &;. HG0. /,&7(>(;G ,5;2-B( – 7 1(,(>.;( 1990-F ?&>&7. P .)(;;& 1 =(F /&, 5,)D;165D J6&;&).65 /&65-G75(= 7G1&6.( =()/G ,&1=5. +&1*>5,1=7(;-;5D ;5?,*-65 ;5 J6&;&).6* 7 4,)(;.. 7 =('(;.( >0.=(02;&?& 7,()(;. HG05 H0.-65 6 &/=.)502;&< – H@>A(=;G( ,51F&>G 7 2000–2008 ?&>5F >(,A50.12 7 /,(>(05F 20–25 /,&C(;=&7 KK%. $05?&>5,D ,(L&,)5) +,*-.D 1)&?05 /,.H0.-.=21D 6 *,&7;@ 65-'(1=75 J6&;&).'(16&< /&0.=.6.2, *A( >&1=.?;*=&)* 4,)(;.-(<, =&026& 6 2007 ?&>*.

1 H$$. 0. %&>&H;& >,*?.) 1=,5;5), ,(C(11.D -5=,&;*05 . +,*-.@ // Business +,*-.D. 2009. 12 )5,=5 (bizzone.info/2009/gov/1236902505.php).2 O5/,.)(,, /& .;>(61* J6&;&).'(16&< 17&H&>G (Heritage Foundation Index of Economic Freedom), /& .;>.65=&,5) 7(,F&7(;1=75 -56&;5 . JL-L(6=.7;&1=. */,570(;.D (Aggregate Governance Indicators, World Bank).

20

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

9. D !"#$%% &%(-) &* "32)-3*-. G*$"32)-%B3 ()/)''3/0&3, )&3

,);),%- ,) 70 5")B*&-)<.

!,&7(;2 H(-,5H&=.CG 7G1&6.<, J=& /,57>5. %& >5;;G) 1=5=.-1=.'(16&< 10*AHG +,*-.., &; 1&1=570D(= &6&0& 17 /,&C(;=&7. 9=6*>5 A( H(,(=1D L5;=51=.'(165D C.L,5 70 /,&C(;=&7? "(0& 7 =&), '=& ;(6&=&,G( ?,*-.;16.( J61/(,=G /,(>05?5@= 1'.=5=2 H(-,5H&=;G). 71(F, 6=& /& 1=5=.1=.6( 7F&>.= 7 ,5-,D> 15)&-5-;D=GF1, 5 -5;D=G). – =&026& ;5();GF 10*A5E.F2.

N5)&-5;D=&1=2 1=505 &1;&7;&< L&,)&< =,*>&7&< >(D-=(02;&1=. 7 +,*-.. 1 1(,(>.;G 1990-F ?&>&7. M=&HG 7GA.=2, 0@>D) /,.F&>.0&12 -5;.)5=21D ;5=*,502;G) F&-D<1=7&), . 6 2003 ?&>* 15)&-5;D=G). 1=50& 58,3 /,&C(;=5 J6&;&).'(-16. 56=.7;&?& ;51(0(;.D. %,&7(>(;.( ,(L&,) 1/&1&H1=7&75-0& 1;.A(;.@ J=&?& /&65-5=(0D, . 7 2009 ?&>* &; &/*1=.01D >& 53,2 /,&C(;=5. #1=5=., «H(-,5H&=;G).» ;(,(>6& 1(HD 1'.=5@= HG7B.( ?&110*A5E.(, 1=57B.(, ;5/,.)(,, =561.1=5). . -5-,5H5=G75@E.( H&02B(, '() HG05 .F &L.C.502;5D -5,5H&=;5D /05=5 ;5 /,(A;() )(1=(.

10. H%$&0 % $,)")<0* &3'*/*&%. 5), #4")$)8, 5)-)6# +-) <)

6&)4%; 'F*"3; )-6*&*& 4)'#,3"'-<*&&:8 ()&-")/0.

K ;(6&=&,GF 1L(,5F ?&1*>5,1=7(;;G< 6&;=,&02 >(<1=7.=(02-;& &=)(;(;: ;5/,.)(,, ;( 1*E(1=7*(= /&A5,;&< .;1/(6C.., 15;.=5,;&-J/.>().&0&?.'(16&< 10*AHG, &HD-5=(02;&?& =(F-;.'(16&?& &1)&=,5 =,5;1/&,=5, &HD-5=(02;&< 1(,=.L.65C.. . 1=5;>5,=.-5C.. /,&>*6C... O& &1*E(1=70D01D 0. ,(502;G< 6&;=,&02 ,5;((? N=50& 0. F*A( /&=,(H.=(0D) &= &=)(;G H@,&-6,5=.'(16.F /,&C(>*,? %,.7(05 0. &=)(;5 L&,)502;&?& 6&;-=,&0D 6 ,&1=* *?,&- >0D ->&,&72D . A.-;. ?,5A>5;?

1 N 5 ) & - 5 ; D = G ( – 0.C5, -5;D=G( &/,(>(0(;;&< >(D=(02;&1=2@ 1 C(02@ /&0*'(;.D /,.HG0. .0. 1()(<;&?& >&F&>5 (7 >(;(A;&< .0. ;5=*,502;&< L&,)(), .0. /,(>/,.;.)5=(0., &L.C.502;& ;( ,5H&=57B.( 7 =('(;.( &=-'(=;&?& /(,.&>5 /& 656.)-=& /,.'.;5).2 N0*AH* 1=5=.1=.6. &H7.;D@= 7 -5;.A(;.. >5;;GF /& H(-,5H&=.C( // Business +,*-.D. 2010. 7 )5D (bizzone.info/government/2010/1273263568.php).

21

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

O(1)&=,D ;5 */,5->;(;.( 57=&.;1/(6C.. . &HD-5=(02;&?& =(F&1)&=,5 '.10& /&?.HB.F 7 "U% 7 ,51'(=( ;5 1000 57=&)&H.-0(< 1;.-.0&12 1 1,79 7 2003 ?&>* >& 1,05 7 2010 ?&>*1.

%&A5,;5D .;1/(6C.D 0.67.>.,&75;5, 5 '.10& /&?.HB.F /,. 7&-?&,5;.DF *)(;2B.0&12 1 434 '(0&7(6 -5 1997–2003 ?&>G >& 371 '(0&7(65 7 2004–2010 ?&>5F.

%,. &=)(;( ;(,5H&=5@E.F )(F5;.-)&7 ;5>-&,5, HG7B.F )&E;G) .1=&';.6&) 6&,,*/C.., 15)5 J=5 6&,,*/C.D .>(= ;5 1/5>, 5 >&/&0;.=(02;GF *?,&- ->&,&72@ . A.-;. 0@>(< /,. J=&) ;( 7&-;.65(=.

11. D !"#$%% &*- 2:-)<)8 ()""#5B%%, $3-) -3( &3$:<3*63.

@/%-3"&3. ()""#5B%. &*')5)'-3<%6) 2)/07* -)8, +-) 2:/3 5"%

>*<3",&3,$*.

%,(A>( 71(?&, >5A( 6,.=.6. /,.-;5@=, '=& *,&7(;2 HG=&7&< 6&,,*/C.. 1;.-.01D. P J=& *A( 15)& /& 1(H( 75A;&. M=& A( 65-15(=1D =56 ;5-G75()&< J0.=5,;&< 6&,,*/C.., =& ;*A;G 6&;-6,(=;G( /,.)(,G. W5 ;(16&026& 0(=, 7 =('(;.( 6&=&,GF 7,()D &= 7,()(;. 7 5>,(1 7051=(< -7*'5= =56.( &H7.;(;.D, ;.6=& /&65 ;( 1)&? /,.7(1=. ;. 1/&1&H5 &C(;6. L(;&)(;5 «J0.=5,-;&< 6&,,*/C..», ;. (( /&>=7(,A>(;.D.

K& 7,()D (A(?&>;&?& &='(=5 7 /5,05)(;=( 7 L(7,50( 2011 ?&>5 &>.; .- >(/*=5=&7 &H7.;.0 7051=. 7 J0.=5,;&< 6&,-,*/C... K &=7(= ;5 J=& 8.F5.0 N5565B7.0. /,(>0&A.0 *65-5=2 6&;6,(=;G( 10*'5. =56&< 6&,,*/C.. . ;5-75=2 L5).0.. =(F, 6=& 7 ;(( 7&70('(;G. 9=7(=5 ;5 J=* /,&12H* ;( /&10(>&750& ;. 7& 7,()D -51(>5;.D /5,05)(;=5, ;. /&10( ;(?&.

%& >5;;G) +0&H502;&?& 6&,,*/C.&;;&?& H5,&)(=,5, 1,(>. 86 1=,5; +,*-.D -5;.)5(= 7=&,&( )(1=& /& >&0( ,(1/&;>(;=&7, 1'.=5@E.F, '=& *1.0.D /,57.=(021=75 7 H&,2H( 1 6&,,*/C.(< JLL(6=.7;G (77 /,&C(;=&7), . ;5 /(,7&) )(1=( /& >&0( ,(1/&;-

1 K +,*-.. ;5 1000 A.=(0(< 7 2010 ?&>* /,.F&>.0&12 147 57=&)&H.0(<. %,. 5;50&?.';&) *,&7;( )&=&,.-5C.. 7 I&11.. (7 1997–1998 ?&>5F) '.10& /&-?.HB.F 7 ,51'(=( ;5 1000 57=&)&H.0(< HG0& 1,29.

22

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

>(;=&7, 1'.=5@E.F, '=& -5 /&10(>;.( 3 ?&>5 )51B=5HG 6&,,*/-C.. 1;.-.0.12 (78 /,&C(;=&7).

12. !"#$%. – 5)/%B*8'()* 4)'#,3"'-<). D '-"3&* #'-3&)</*&3

-)-3/0&3. </3'-0 IDJ.

M=& &-;5'5(= =(,).; «/&0.C(<16&( ?&1*>5,1=7&»? Q=& =56&( ?&1*->5,1=7&, 7 6&=&,&) ?,5A>5;( H&D=1D /&0.C..? P0. J=& ?&1*>5,1=7&, 7 6&=&,&) ?,5A>5;( >&7(,D@= /&0.C..? K +,*-.. *,&7(;2 >&7(-,.D /&0.C.. ;(7(,&D=;& 7G1&6 – 7GB( 70 /,&C(;=&71. %& );&?.) &/,&15), /,&7&>.7B.)1D 7 2005–2010 ?&>5F, /&0.C.D 1=5H.02;& ;5F&>.=1D 1,(>. .;1=.=*=&7, /&02-*@E.F1D ;5.H&02B.) >&7(,.-() ?,5A>5;, 10(>*D 7 J=&) ,(<=.;?( 1,5-* /&10( C(,67. . 5,)..2. 9 =56&) /,.-;5;.. /,57&&F,5;.=(02;G) &,?5;5) 7 ;(6&=&,GF >,*-?.F 1=,5;5F, 760@'5D I&11.@, )&A;& =&026& )('=5=2.

KG1&6.< *,&7(;2 >&7(,.D /&0.C.. &H*10&70(; );&?.). L56-=&,5)., /,(A>( 71(?& '(1=;&1=2@ . /&,D>&';&1=2@ 0.';&?& 1&-1=575, .-)(;(;.() /&,D>65 ,(?.1=,5C.. /,(1=*/0(;.< (0@H5D .;L&,)5C.D & L56=( 1&7(,B(;.D /,(1=*/0(;.D D70D(=1D &1;&75-;.() >0D ;5'505 /,(>75,.=(02;&?& 10(>1=7.D) . ,(-6.) 1;.A(;.-() *,&7;D /,(1=*/;&1=.. O5/,.)(,, 7 /&10(>;.( 5 0(= /,&.-&B0& ;()G10.)&( ,5;(( – =,(F6,5=;&( (!) – 1&6,5E(;.( '.105 =DA6.F /,(1=*/0(;.< /,&=.7 0.';&1=. (*H.<1=7, *)GB0(;;&?& /,.'.-;(;.D =DA6&?& 7,(>5 ->&,&72@, .-;51.0&75;.<, ?,5H(A(<).

X&=D 7 J=&) -5D70(;.. . /,.1*=1=7*(= J0()(;= 1*HT(6=.7-;&< &C(;6., =() ;( )(;(( )&A;& /&;D=2 J)&C.. &>;&?& .- 57-=&,&7 «?,*-.;16&?& /&0.C(<16&?& '*>5» – ).;.1=,5 7;*=,(;-;.F >(0 K5;& 8(,5H.B7.0.: «R10. ;5-G75=2 J=& /&0.C(<16.) ?&1*>5,1=7&), =&?>5 D ?&,A*12 =(), '=& +,*-.D – /&0.C(<16&( ?&1*>5,1=7&!»3.

1 IRI, USAID, Baltic Surveys // The Gallup Organization, IPM Georgian National Study, September 27 – October 7, 2010 www.iri.org.2 Ibid.3 1/6+-.$#+* 2. +,*-.;16.< &/G= ,(L&,)G 8K": &HG75=(0. >&7&02;G, &//&-.C.D – ;5&H&,&= // IP4-O&7&1=.. 2010. 22 1(;=DH,D (www.rian.ru/ocherki/20100922/278068474.html).

23

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

13. =33(37<%/% < !"#$%% <'* &*&3<%,.-.

K >()&6,5=.'(16&) &HE(1=7( &=;&B(;.( ?,5A>5; 6 7051=. /,&7(,D(=1D .;1=,*)(;=&) /&> ;5-75;.() 7GH&,G1.

KG1&65D /&>>(,A65 8.F5.05 N5565B7.0. 1,5-* A( /&10( I(7&0@C.. ,&- &='51=. &HTD1;.)5 – &;5 )&?05 17.>(=(02-1=7&75=2 &H J<L&,.., &F75=.7B(< ?,5A>5; 7 17D-. 1 6,*-B(;.() ,(A.)5 S(75,>;5>-(. 9>;56& *,&7(;2 &>&H,(;.D N5565B7.0. ;5 7=&,GF /,(-.>(;=16.F 7GH&,5F 7 D;75,( 2008 ?&>5, /&10( '(=G,(F 0(= ,(L&,), – J=& *A( &C(;65 . 65-'(1=75, . )(=&>&7, . ,(-*02=5=&7 .-)(;(;.<, /,&7&>.7B.F1D .) . (?& 6&)5;>&<.

$&0(( =&?&, 7 2008 ?&>* /,57DE5D /5,=.D /&0*'.05 H&02B( ?&0&1&7 .-H.,5=(0(<, '() /,(-.>(;=, '=& 6,&)( 71(?& /,&'(?& *65-G75(= ;5 =&, '=& ?,5A>5;( >5A( 7 H&02B(< 1=(/(;. /&>>(,-

1 #1=5=., ,(-*02=5=G 7GH&,&7 /,(>1=570D@=1D &HE(1=7(;;&1=. ;( =&026& 7 7.>( 17&>;GF .=&?&7GF C.L,. O5 15<=( ZP# )&A;& *7.>(=2 &=165;.,&75;-;G( /,&=&6&0G 71(F *'51=6&7GF .-H.,5=(02;GF 6&).11.< (15<= Z(;=,502-;&< .-H.,5=(02;&< 6&).11.. +,*-.. www.results.cec.gov.ge).

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

01990 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

A, 1

00 +7

&. :,&#'#:%;

24,5

48,3

38,934,2 33,1

30,4 30,0 31,736,4

42,0

62,6

71,8 73,6

51,5

44,7

32,0

23,1

:$%-) 6;<($= >#0%6'>-02$4 >#)6$* -$?2)%6$ 2" 100 63%. 2"%0-02$;

<&+(-:%8: ",&-#+ 2( $,::7. =+,+%&+%-#&8(> &'/9?7 0"/1%% (www.geostat.ge/index.php?action= page&p_id=602&lang=eng)

24

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

A.75@= 7(6=&, ,5-7.=.D 1=,5;G 7 C(0&), ;(A(0. &=>(02;*@ 0.';&1=2. U&, '=& .-H.,5=(0. ;( =&026& ;( ,5-&'5,&750.12 7 7GH,5;;&) /*=., /&>=7(,>.0. ,(-*02=5=G 7GH&,&7 7 &,?5;G )(1=;&?& 15)&*/,570(;.D 7 )5( 2010 ?&>5, 6&?>5 R>.;&( ;5-C.&;502;&( >7.A(;.(1 7;&72 *7(0.'.0& 17&@ &HE(1=7(;;*@ /&>>(,A6*, /&0*'.7 65,8 /,&C(;=5 ?&0&1&7.

8&A;& 1,57;.=2 1 J=&< /&.1=.;( ;5,&>;&< /&>>(,A6&< /5>(;.( /&/*0D,;&1=. $&,.15 R02C.;5 . (?& ,(L&,)5=&,16&< 6&)5;>G 7 /(,7&< /&0&7.;( 1990-F – /& >5;;G) 7GH&,&7 . ,(L(,(;>*)&7. %,&C(;= ?&0&1&7, &=>5;;GF -5 R02C.;5 ;5 /(,-7GF /,(-.>(;=16.F 7GH&,5F 7 .@;( 1991 ?&>5, 17.>(=(021=7&-750 & (?& >&1=&<;&< /&H(>( 7 =,*>;&< 6&;6*,(;=;&< H&,2H(. O(1)&=,D ;5 =DA(0G( /&10(>1=7.D ,(L&,) '(,(- 15 )(1DC(7 /&10( .F ;5'505, 7 5/,(0( 1993 ?&>5, *,&7(;2 >&7(,.D /,(--.>(;=* 1&F,5;.01D. O& *A( '(,(- 7&1()2 )(1DC(7, 7 >(65H,( 1993 ?&>5, 7& );&?&) .---5 /,&>&0A(;.D =DA(0&?& J6&;&).-'(16&?& 6,.-.15, 5 =56A( B&65 .---5 1.0&7&?& ,5-?&;5 /5,05-

1 %,57DE5D /5,=.D, &1;&75;;5D 8.F5.0&) N5565B7.0. 7 2001 ?&>*.

509'-16"63 8)-)%)*"2$; 2" *3@)#"= >#09$/026" $ >"#-"A026" * ,#'9$$, 2004–2008 88. (%)

96,0

67,0

53,5

59,2

B. =,,8,C)%'%. !"#1%$#:+, ;:),"3 2004

A,D%(:,'3:(# $)%9#:%# – $#.(8",+7.!,"',.#:+, .,"+ 2004

B. =,,8,C)%'%. !"#1%$#:+, ;:),"3 2008

E$%:(# :,D%(:,'3:(# $)%9#:%#.!,"',.#:+, .,> 2008

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

<&+(-:%8: F#:+",'3:,; %1?%",+#'3:,; 8(.%&&%; 0"/1%%

25

456 (-,&+( )7&8,17),#.7# /+)#"9$#:%;)

)(;=5 >&7(,.( .-H.,5=(0(< 6 &1;&7;&< /&0.=.'(16&< &,?5-;.-5C.. ,(L&,)5=&,&7 – «KGH&, I&11..» – ,(-6& 1;.-.0&12. 4 (E( '(,(- >75 ?&>5 /&>>(,A65 57=&,&7 ,&11.<16.F ,(L&,) HG05 /&=(,D;5 &6&;'5=(02;&1.

***

W;5'.= 0. 71( 7GB(165-5;;&(, '=& 7 +,*-.. ,(B(;G 71( /,&H-0()G? #&;(';& ;(=. K 1=,5;( 1&F,5;D(=1D 7G1&6.< *,&7(;2 H(--,5H&=.CG, ;( 1;.A5(=1D .;L0DC.D2. K(0.65 >&0D ?&1*>5,1=75 7 J6&;&).6(. I5-)(,G ?&1,51F&>&7 7 KK% 7GB( &/=.)502;&-?& *,&7;D. $@>A(= ;(1H505;1.,&75;. K 2009–2010 ?&>5F ,(-6& 1;.-.0.12 )51B=5HG /,.75=.-5C... 8(>0(;;& .>*= .-)(;(;.D 7 1(0216&) F&-D<1=7(, L.-.'(16.< &HT() /,&.-7&>1=75 7 ;()

1 R10. /,.;D=2 7& 7;.)5;.( 71( /5,=.., ;( ;5F&>.7B.(1D 7 ;(/,.).-,.)&< &//&-.C.. 6 R02C.;*, =& ;5 7GH&,5F 7 +&1*>5,1=7(;;*@ >*)* 1993 ?&>5 .F /&>>(,A50. 51,8 /,&C(;=5, 5 7 1995 ?&>* – 38,1 /,&C(;=5 .-H.,5=(0(<. 2 N,(>;(?&>&7G( =()/G ,&1=5 /&=,(H.=(0216.F C(; 7 1997–2003 ?&>5F 1&1=57.0. 7 /,&C(;=&7, 5 7 2003–2010 ?&>5F – 7,3 /,&C(;=5. K L(7,50( 2011 ?&>5 ?&>&7G( =()/G .;L0DC.. >&1=.?0. 13,7 /,&C(;=5.

<&+(-:%8: F#:+",'3:,; %1?%",+#'3:,; 8(.%&&%; G(&&%%

509'-16"63 8)-)%)*"2$; 2" *3@)#"= >#09$/026" $ >"#-"A026" * 5)%%$$, 1991–1995 88. (%)

57,3

58,7

15,5

3,9

H. E'3D%:. !"#1%$#:+, %I:3 1991

J()#";#+# '% )7 2"#1%$#:+/ H. E'3D%:/? G#K#"#:$/., ,2"#'3 1993

«57?(" G(&&%%», 2,"',.#:+, $#8,?"3 1993

«J#.(8",+%-#&8%> )7?(" G(&&%%», 2,"',.#:+, $#8,?"3 1995

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

26

!(-#./ / 0"/1%% 2('/-%'(&3

1;.A5(=1D. O51=&,5A.75(=, '=& =()/ );&?.F ,(L&,) -5)(>0.0-1D, 7 ;(6&=&,GF ;5)(=.01D &=65=.

N*E(1=7*@E.( /,&H0()G ;5>& -5)('5=2, &H1*A>5=2 . ;5F&->.=2 /&>F&>G 6 .F ,(B(;.@. O& .)(@E.(1D /,&H0()G ;( >&0A-;G -510&;D=2 =&, '=& *A( HG0& >&1=.?;*=&, /,.'() -5 1=&02 6&-,&=6.< 1,&6.