6
 Human Rights Alert (NGO) (NGO) י כ ז ל  גי סידא ה Joseph Zernik, PhD נ צר ףסו ר" ד PO Box 334!, e# $%i%, &sr'e# ד"( 334! )"( * +333 -34.+x/012'i#5o 66 Israeli Supreme Court – Requests for appointment records of clerks and responses  ב ש ם י ר י !" # ש י $ י"% יב # ש& ב ' (   י#)% *+ ש"% י ב  $sher 7r8nis, Pre si9in2 J8s:i5e o ; :he &sr'e#i <8p ree =o8r: The law of the State of Israel does not prescribe the appointment of Chief Clerks in the courts. The Magistrate of the Court is authorized to perform the duties of the Chief Cler k. However, there is no doubt that the law does not  permit the appearance of an impostor as a Chief Clerk!, with no lawful appointment. "ith it, the Israeli courts ruled that a court with no lawful office of the clerk, is an incompetent court. The evidence shows that Ms Meloul has no lawful appointment as Chief Clerk!, and likewise, her predecessor Sarah #ifschitz was an impostor. "ith it, the conduct of simulated litigation and issuance of simulated court records has become a routine in the Israeli Supreme Court. Issuance of simulated court records is an age$old, common form of %udicial corruption. The Israeli penal code does not include a specific section,  pertaining to the issuance of simulated court records. &or discussion purpose, the term simulated court record! is used here in reference to its definitio n in the Te'as (enal Code) ex's Pen'# =o9e 6 <e5:ion 3-4> <i8#':in2 ?e2'# Pro5ess , -./01/ SI23456I78 49854 :R;C9SS @'A $ person 5oi:s 'n o;;ense i; :he person re5k#ess#/ 5'8ses :o e 9e#i%ere9 :o 'no:her 'n/ 9o58en: :h': si8#':es ' s8ons, 5op#'in:, C892en:, or o:her 5o8r: pro5ess i:h :he in:en: :oE  @A in985e p'/en: o; ' 5#'i ;ro 'no:her personF or @-A 5'8se 'no:her :oE @$A s8i: : o :he p8:':i%e '8:hori:/ o; :he 9o58en :F or @BA :'ke 'n/ '5:ion or re;r'in ;ro :'kin2 'n/ '5:ion in response :o :he 9o58en:, in 5op#i'n5e i:h :he 9o58en:, or on :he 'sis o; :he 9o58en:  @A Proo; :h': :he 9o58en: 's 'i#e9 :o 'n/ person i:h :he in:en: :h': i: e ;or'r9e9 :o :he in:en9e9 re5ipien: is ' s8;;i5ien: shoin2 :h': :he 9o58en: 's 9e#i%ere9 *+

0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and responses // בית המשפט העליון: בקשות לכתבי המינוי

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 1/6

Human Rights Alert (NGO) (NGO) י כ ז ג ל י י דס א ה Joseph Zernik, PhD נ ר ף צ ס ו ד"ר PO Box 334 !, e# $%i%, &sr'e# 334)"ד !)"( *+ 333

-34.+x/012 'i# 5o

6 6 Israeli Supreme Court – Requests for appointmentrecords of clerks and responses

ב ש ם י ר י !" # ש י י$ "% י ב # ש ב& ' ( י #)% *+ ש "% י ב

$sher 7r8nis, Presi9in2 J8s:i5e o; :he &sr'e#i <8pre e =o8r:

The law of the State of Israel does not prescribe the appointment of ChiefClerks in the courts. The Magistrate of the Court is authorized to perform theduties of the Chief Clerk. However, there is no doubt that the law does not

permit the appearance of an impostor as a Chief Clerk!, with no lawfulappointment.

"ith it, the Israeli courts ruled that a court with no lawful office of the clerk, isan incompetent court.The evidence shows that Ms Meloul has no lawful appointment as ChiefClerk!, and likewise, her predecessor Sarah #ifschitz was an impostor."ith it, the conduct of simulated litigation and issuance of simulated courtrecords has become a routine in the Israeli Supreme Court.Issuance of simulated court records is an age$old, common form of %udicialcorruption. The Israeli penal code does not include a specific section,

pertaining to the issuance of simulated court records.&or discussion purpose, the term simulated court record! is used here in

reference to its definition in the Te'as (enal Code)ex's Pen'# =o9e 6 <e5:ion 3- 4> <i 8#':in2 ?e2'# Pro5ess

, -./01/ SI23456I78 49854 :R;C9SS@'A $ person 5o i:s 'n o;;ense i; :he person re5k#ess#/ 5'8ses :o e 9e#i%ere9 :o'no:her 'n/ 9o58 en: :h': si 8#':es ' s8 ons, 5o p#'in:, C892 en:, or o:her 5o8r:pro5ess i:h :he in:en: :oE @ A in985e p'/ en: o; ' 5#'i ;ro 'no:her personF or

@-A 5'8se 'no:her :oE@$A s8 i: :o :he p8:':i%e '8:hori:/ o; :he 9o58 en:F or@BA :'ke 'n/ '5:ion or re;r'in ;ro :'kin2 'n/ '5:ion in response :o :he

9o58 en:, in 5o p#i'n5e i:h :he 9o58 en:, or on :he 'sis o; :he 9o58 en: @ A Proo; :h': :he 9o58 en: 's 'i#e9 :o 'n/ person i:h :he in:en: :h': i: e;or 'r9e9 :o :he in:en9e9 re5ipien: is ' s8;;i5ien: sho in2 :h': :he 9o58 en: 's9e#i%ere9

*+

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 2/6

@5A &: is no: ' 9e;ense :o prose58:ion 8n9er :his se5:ion :h': :he si 8#':in29o58 en:E @ A s:':es :h': i: is no: #e2'# pro5essF or

@-A p8rpor:s :o h'%e een iss8e9 or '8:hori0e9 / ' person or en:i:/ ho 9i9 no:h'%e #' ;8# '8:hori:/ :o iss8e or '8:hori0e :he 9o58 en: @9A &; i: is sho n on :he :ri'# o; 'n o;;ense 8n9er :his se5:ion :h': :he si 8#':in29o58 en: 's ;i#e9 i:h, presen:e9 :o, or 9e#i%ere9 :o ' 5#erk o; ' 5o8r: or 'ne p#o/ee o; ' 5#erk o; '5o8r: 5re':e9 or es:' #ishe9 8n9er :he 5ons:i:8:ion or #' s o; :his s:':e, :here is '

re 8::' #e pres8 p:ion :h': :he 9o58 en: 's 9e#i%ere9 i:h :he in:en: 9es5ri e9 /<8 se5:ion @'A @eA Gx5ep: 's pro%i9e9 / <8 se5:ion @;A, 'n o;;ense 8n9er :his se5:ion is ' =#'ss $

is9e e'nor @;A &; i: is sho n on :he :ri'# o; 'n o;;ense 8n9er :his se5:ion :h': :he 9e;en9'n: h'spre%io8s#/ een 5on%i5:e9 o; ' %io#':ion o; :his se5:ion, :he o;;ense is ' s:':e C'i#;e#on/

$99e9 / $5:s HH!, !.:h ?e2 , 5h >H, I 3, e;; '/ - , HH!

"ith it, the issuance of simulated court records should be deemed in violationof the Israeli law relative to &raud and -eceit, bstruction of /ustice, and0reach of #o1alt1.

Date ך י ר Record and linkא ר ש י ק סך 2012-04-16 Criminal fraud complaint (158921/2012) against Sarah ifschit! of th"

Supr"m" Court of th" Stat" of #sra"l$ fil"d %ith #sra"l &olic"$ %ithc"rtificat" of complaint ' th" raud *i+ision of th" ,"rusal"m &olic"

3158921/20123 7 : ;< = > ?> 3>< 3 3= 3 @ A B > 3 > <3 D @3 ? > 3 > : >=

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/8951G688/ httpsE//docsFgoogl"Fcom/fil"/d/0H8Ia2JKL'mM5N0dOamPm'Q, S!g/"ditRusp sharing

201T-04-18 U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court Wl"tt"r Po 1 to &r"siding ,ustic" of th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court XY= Z ? > 3 > [ \2689/1T] 7 ^ A 1D @3 ? > 3 = >

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1T6GT268G/ 201T-04-19 &_`SS _` `IS` ( `H) &r"siding ,ustic" of th" #sra"li Supr"m" court is

asM"d to "nsur" hon"st r"gistration of p"tition that docum"nts lacM ofint"grit in court r"cordsF

> D @ 3 @ > D< 3 Z > =; >[ 3 D @3 ? > 3 = >D @3 ? > 3 Z 73

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1T6908485/

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1T691T40G/ ( nglish onl )201T-05-02 U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court W

_"bu"st Po 2 to &r"siding ,ustic" - for hon"st r"gistration$ alt"rnati+"l -r"fund of filing f""s

XY= Z ?> 3 > [ \2689/1T] 7 ^ A 2 ^ D @3 ? > 3 = >? > 3 <= Y3 ^ D Y D< 3 Z > 3>[

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1T9556T02/ 201T-05-0T U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court W

_"spons" Po 1 ' &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis on l"tt"r all"ging fraudin th" effic" of th" Cl"rM of th" Supr"m" CourthttpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/141TG55T2/

2+

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 3/6

201T-05-06 U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court W_"spons" Po 2 ' &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis on l"tt"r all"ging fraudin th" effic" of th" Cl"rM of th" Supr"m" CourthttpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/141TG5G08/

201T-05-08 U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court Wl"tt"r Po T to &r"siding ,ustic" - r"garding fals" and d"li'"rat"lmisl"ading "l"ctronic r"cordshttpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/14TG61T24/

201T-05-14 U"rniM + Vinist"r of ,ustic" "t al (2689/1T) in th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court Wl"tt"r Po 4 to &r"siding ,ustic" - r"bu"st for appointm"nt r"cord of th"Chi"f Cl"rM

] 74B > X <3 > 3 7 3>[ D @3 ? > 3 = >: >= 3 7 :7

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/141TG6200/ 201T-05-14 &r"siding ,ustic" of th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court is asM"d to produc" th"

Chi"f Cl"rM s appointm"nt r"cordhttpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/141G16284/ ( full `nglish translation)httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/141G18419/

201T-06-18 "tt"r Po 5 to &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis of #sra"l Supr"m" Court -r"p"at r"bu"st for th" appointm"nt r"cord of Chi"f Cl"rM Sarah

ifschit! ] 753 7 Y 3>[ ^ ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = >

>= 3 7 :7 B > 3 > X <3 >:httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/14849G2T6/

201T-08-05 _"spons" ' &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis of th" #sra"li Supr"m" Courton r"bu"st for th" appointm"nt r"cord of Chi"f Cl"rMj Sarah ifschit! -

Vs Sarah ifschit!$ Chi"f Cl"rM of th" Supr"m" Court$ %as appoint"d$ pursuant to pr"+ailing rul"s in th" Stat" S"r+ic"$ r"lati+" to th" p"opl" ofsuch offic"Fj

> 3 7 <\3 3>[ @ ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > > > >= 3 7 B > 3 > <3: B > 3 > k >= 3 7@ < 3 ; 3 > Z < 3 3 Z 7 Z= 3 3 D @3 ? > 3

: 3 ; @ ; [httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/16110G108/

201T-08-28 _"spons" l"tt"r ' th" offic" of Ittorn" L"n"ral in r"E Criminal fraudcomplaint against Chi"f Cl"rMj Sarah ifschit! of th" Supr"m" Court ofth" Stat" of #sra"l

3 7 : ;< 3= 3 @ 3 D ; 3 > ? > 3 B@ 3 >>=D @3 ? > 3 B > 3 > :

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1G8924452/ httpsE//dri+"Fgoogl"Fcom/fil"/d/0H8Ia2JKL'mM5KnHsdlHee h+a V/ "ditRusp sharing

201T-11-06 "tt"r to &r"siding ,ustic" of th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court Ish"r Lrunis$ inr"E Chi"f Cl"rM of th" Supr"m" Court

? > 3 >= 7 D ; ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > 7D @3

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1819GG60G/ httpsE//dri+"Fgoogl"Fcom/fil"/d/0H8Ia2JKL'mM5_MM5c2J1' U OV/ "ditRusp sharing

3+

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 4/6

201T-11-06 #S_I` E Supr"m" Court &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis is asM"d todisclos" - %ho toda holds th" authoriti"s of Chi"f Cl"rMR (full `nglishtranslation)

[ Y < >[ 3 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > = >>= 3 7 3 7 ] R

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1820T0544/ 201T-11-22 "tt"r to #sra"li Supr"m" Court &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis$ r"E

Ipp"aranc" of Vs Iluma U"rniM as Cl"rM : 7 :7 [ \ 3 = X <3 @ 3 D ; D @3 ? > 3 = > 7

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/186296G86/ 201T-11-2T #S_I` _"spons" ' &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis of th" Supr"m" Court r"

Chi"f Cl"rM s authoriti"s$ follo%ing d"partur" of Chi"f Cl"rMj Sarahifschit!

>= 3 7 3 7 ] D ; ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > >>= 3 7 : > :3 > : [@B > 3 > :

httpsE//dri+"Fgoogl"Fcom/fil"/d/0H8Ia2JKL'mM5P ,t_ P "`,M `/ "ditRusp sharing

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/19090244T/ 201T-11-2G #S_I` E Supr"m" Court ith Po Chi"f Cl"rM - In #ncomp"t"nt Court

( full `nglish translation) >7 ? > >= 7 = @ D @3 ? > 3

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/18G6T9292/ 201T-11-28 #sra"li Supr"m" Court ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis r"spons" in r"E Ippointm"nt

r"cords of Cl"rM Iluma U"rniM W no n""d for appointm"nt of cl"rMsj of th" sitting courtFFF

> 3 7 3>[ @ ] < >= ? >3 D @3 ? > 3 = > > : 7 : q \ D = ^ [ \ 3 = : 7 :

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1920001G4/ 201T-12-04 #S_I E Po Chi"f Cl"rM in th" Supr"m" CourtR &r"siding ,ustic"

LrunisE " +" got man FFF( full `nglish translation)3 3 > ] < >= 7 = D @3 ? >

httpsE//dri+"Fgoogl"Fcom/fil"/d/0H8Ia2JKL'mM5P!g0VM05 !H "QI/"ditRusp sharing httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1894G4G08/

201T-12-11 _"bu"st from &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis of appointm"nt r"cord of "ad of&ro S" S"ction Ittorn" H"n o+im ( full `nglish translation):Z <\ ; : > 7 = < \3 >[ 3 D @3 ? > 3 = >

Z ? D ; ;: @ ^ httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1909112G9/

201T-12-11 &r"siding ,ustic" is asM"d for appointm"nt r"cord of &ro S" S"ctionj ( full`nglish translation)

; : > 7 = < \3 >[ 3 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = >:Z <\

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/190944TT2/ 201T-12-19 #S_I` E &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis - cl"rMs of th" sitting Supr"m" Court

r"buir" no la%ful appointm"ntFFF

D @3 ? > 3 ; : 7 : [ Y7 q \ D = ] < >httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1925154G1/

4+

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 5/6

201T-12-25 U"rniM + i+ni "t al (2689/1T) copi"s of *"cision and ,udgm"nt$ purport"dl r"spons" on r"bu"st for c"rtification

[ \2689/1T7 7 Z > = D ; [] 3? Y3 > [ @3 A httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/201G14152/

201T-12-T0 Simulat"d r"spons" ' #sra"li Supr"m" Court$ r"E Ippointm"nt r"cord of&ro S" S"ction sic *ann H"n o+im _IPS I `

; : > 7 3>[ @ D @3 ? > 3 D @ = 3 >Z ? D ; :Z <\

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/20180T651/ 2014-01-02 #S_I` E _"p"at r"bu"st from &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis for appointm"nt

r"cord of &ro S" S"ction Ittorn" *ann H"n o+im ( full `nglishtranslation)

:Z <\ ; : > 7 D @3 ? > 3 = > Y 3>[Z ? D ; ;: @

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/195102959/ 2014-01-02 #S_I` E Supr"m" Court &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis is again asM"d for th"

appointm"nt r"cord of "ad of &ro S" S"ction> 7 = < \3 > >[ 3 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = >:Z <\ ; :

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/1951T6099/ 2014-01-2T _"p"at r"bu"st from &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis of &ro S" S"ction "ad

*ann H"n o+im s appointm"nt r"cord ; : > 7 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > Y 3>[

Z ? D ; :Z <\httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/201818126/

2014-01-2T U"rniM + i+ni "t al (2689/1T) W _"p"at r"bu"st for c"rtification of Ipril 18$2012 *"cision and ,un" 25$ 201T ,udgm"nt$ ru" Cop of th" eriginal

XY= [ \2689/1T3 Z 3? Y3 > = Y 3>[ A 18=201T3 Z D ; [] 25201T: [ Z = [ @3

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/201GT480G/ 2014-01-2T #S_I` E &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis is asM"d to pro+id" c"rtifi"d

copi"s$ ru" Cop of th" eriginalj$ of Supr"m" Court d"cisions inU"rniM + Vinst"r of ,ustic" "t at (2689/1T) ( full `nglish translation)

[ \ ? Y3 > = = \ 3 >[ 3 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > XY= Z ? > 3 > )2689/1T( ! ": [ Z = [ @3

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/201G9T0T4/ 2014-02-06 &r"siding ,ustic" Ish"r Lrunis$ #sra"li Supr"m" Court r"spons" on r"p"at

r"bu"sts for appointm"nt r"cords$ c"rtification of r"cords W r"fusal tor"spondF ( full `nglish translation)

3 7 Y >[ @ ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > > > ; @ >$>3 ] ^ Z 7 > =

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/20G908166/ 2014-02-18 #S_I` E "' pag" of th" Supr"m" Court lists a n"% Chi"f Cl"rMj - #dit

V"loul ; @ ^ 3>;Y : >= 3 7 : 3= D @3 ? > 3 > 3 v;

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/20G902985/

5+

8/12/2019 0000-00-00 Israeli Supreme Court: Requests for appointment records of clerks, for certification of records, and res…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/0000-00-00-israeli-supreme-court-requests-for-appointment-records-of-clerks 6/6

2014-02-19 #sra"li Supr"m" CourtE P"% Chi"f Cl"rM R er a n"% impostorR3 Y ; @ = D @3 ? > 3 3>;Y >= 3 7

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/20G9182G0/ 2014-02-19 _"bu"st addr"ss"d to &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis of appoint r"cord of Vs

#dit V"loul as Chi"f Cl"rM of th" #sra"li Supr"m" Court] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > 3 3> 3>[$> 3 7 [ @3

7 ;@>= 3 7D @3 ? > 3 >httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/20G912952/

2014-0T-09 _"p"at r"bu"st for th" appointm"nt r"cord of Vs #dit V"loul as Chi"fCl"rM of th" Supr"m" Court$ addr"ss"d to &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis

7 [ @3 ] < >= D @3 ? > 3 = > 3 3> w Y 3>[D @3 ? > 3 > : >= 3 7 :7 ; @ X < > 3

httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/2114T95G6/ 2014-0T-09 #sra"li Supr"m" Court &r"siding ,ustic" Lrunis r"fus"s to "Jplain th"

appointm"nt of n"% Chi"f Cl"rMj #dit V"loulx Lrunis must r"signx3 7 3: > 3 = ]3 ] ] < D @3 ? > 3 = >

y ? 3 Y ] < y ; @ X < 3>;Y3 : >= 3httpE//%%%Fscri'dFcom/doc/211602514/

+