312
!" $"%&'($)!($*" $"(* (+& !"#"$%&'"() %+ ,( "++"-).#" !"#"$%&' )"*+%'*&%,# -),."'' $,) !"#$%!&#'" )*+'#,%'-&%-'" .'/0"&%, !!"#$%&'( *!"#$%&'() "#$%$ &#'()( *+,-

0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!"#$"%&'($)!($*"#$"(*#(+&#

!"#"$%&'"()*%+*,(*"++"-).#"!

!!"#"$%&'()"*+%'*&%,#(-),."''($,)(

!"#$%!&#'"()*+'#,%'-&%-'"(.'/0"&%,!

!!

!

!

!

!

!!"#$%&'()*!"#$%&'()!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%$!&#'()(! ! ! ! ! ! ! *+,-

! ! !

!

Page 2: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!"#$"%&'($)!($*"#$"(*#(+&#

!"#"$%&'"()*%+*,(*"++"-).#"*!

!"#"$%&'()"*+%'*&!"#$%&"'())$*"&$

!"#$%!&#'"()*+'#,%'-&%-'"(.'/0"&%,!

!!

!

!

!

!

!!"#$%&'()*!"#$%&'()!

!

!

.'/01#!/23!4/5'!6275/(1589185'!:'('/59#!/23!622;</1);2!4'215'!=9#;;0!;7!1#'!>8)01!?2<)5;2@'21!4;00'A'!;7!=9)'29'!/23!&'9#2;0;AB!

C2)<'5()1B!;7!=/07;53D!E5'/1'5!F/29#'(1'5D!CG!

!

!

"#$%&''()!&*!+,-'&,.!/#.0&.%(*'!10!'2(!3(4#&-(%(*'5!10!'2(!!6(7-((!10!618'1-!10!+2&.15192:;!<9-&.!=>?@!

Page 3: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! &&&!

&/H0'!;7!9;21'21(!

,! 4.I"&?:!JK?!L!6K&:J%C4&6JK! ,!

,$,! >/9MA5;823! ,!?A?A?! B2(!&%91-',*8(!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82! =!?A?A=! C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(5! @!

,$*! :'('/59#!2''3! N!

,$-! :'('/59#!7;98(!/23!/)@! O!

,$P! :'('/59#!;HQ'91)<'(! O!

,$N! 4;215)H81);2(!1;!M2;R0'3A'! S!

,$T! J810)2'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB! U!

,$O! =1589185'!;7!1#'!1#'()(! ,,!

*! 4.I"&?:!&VJ!W!>?K?X6&=!:?IY6=I&6JK!IK%!FIKIE?F?K&!I!Y6&?:I&C:?!:?Z6?V!

IK%!4JK4?"&CIY!":J4?==!FJ%?Y! ,-!

*$,! 6215;3891);2! ,-!

*$*! "5;A5/@@'D![5;Q'91!!/23!;['5/1);2(!@/2/A'@'21! ,P!

*$-! 4#/2A'!@/2/A'@'21! ,S!

*$P! 4;@[0'\)1B!/23!@/2/A'@'21!H0)23!([;1(! *+!

*$N! 4;21)28;8(!)@[5;<'@'21! *,!

*$T! "'57;5@/29'!@/2/A'@'21! *-!

*$O! "'57;5@/29'!@'/(85'@'21! *P!

*$S! ?</08/1);2!/23!</08'!A'2'5/1);2! *T!=ADA?! "#%%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*! =D!=ADA=! /1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*! =F!=ADA@! +15'!G88#9,*8:!HE,.#,'&1*!I+GHJ! @>!

*$U! =1/M'#;03'5!@/2/A'@'21! --!=AFA?! "',K(21.)(-5L!-(4#&-(%(*'5!,*)!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! @M!

*$,+! 6215;3891);2!1;!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/[[5;/9#! P+!

*$,,! >'2'7)1(!1'5@)2;0;AB! P-!

*$,*! >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2! PN!=A?=A?! C(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!$:!E,.#(!':9(! NO!

Page 4: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! &E!

=A?=A=! C(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!$:!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!1-!$#5&*(55!&%9,8'! ND!=A?=A@! P*9.,**()!1-!(%(-7(*'!$(*(0&'5! O>!=A?=AN! <8'1-!1-&(*','()!8.,55&0&8,'&1*! O?!

*$,-! >'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!@/2/A'@'21!W!/[[5;/9#'(!/23!@;3'0(! N-!=A?@A?! <8'&E(!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! ON!=A?@A=! B2(!Q-,*0&(.)!%1)(.!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! OO!=A?@A@! B2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82! OR!=A?@AN! <8'&E(!$(*(0&'!-(,.&5,'&1*! OM!=A?@AO! B1S,-)5!$(5'!9-,8'&8(!'1!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! OD!=A?@AR! T,*,7&*7!5#88(550#.!9-17-,%%(5!7#&)(! OF!=A?@AM! C(*(0&'5!E&(S!&*!'2(!2,*)$11K!10!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'! R>!

*$,P! :'([;2()H)0)1B!7;5!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2! T,!=A?NA?! 31.(5! R?!=A?NA=! U1E(-*,*8(! R@!

*$,N! >'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!W!M'B!'0'@'21(D!1;;0(!/23!1'9#2)]8'(! TP!=A?OA?! C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! RR!=A?OA=! C(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*;!)(9(*)(*8:!,*)!%,99&*7! RR!=A?OA@! C(*(0&'5!%(,5#-(%(*';!-,*K&*7!,*)!9-&1-&'&5,'&1*! RM!=A?OAN! C(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7!,*)!-(E&(S! RF!

*$,T! Y)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!(8@@/5B!/23!3)(98(();2! O+!

*$,O! =B21#'()(!;7!1#'!0)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!/23!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!3'<'0;[@'21! O-!

*$,S! I2/0B()(!;7!1'9#2)]8'(!1#/1!'@H5/9'!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!@/2/A'@'21! OO!

*$,U! 4;2()3'5/1);2(!7;5!3'<'0;[)2A!1#'!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5;9'((! OS!

*$*+! >'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!^>':'/0_!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!;<'5<)'R! S+!=A=>A?! +2,5(!VW!C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! D?!=A=>A=! +2,5(!VVW!C(*(0&'5!82,-,8'(-&5,'&1*!,*)!$(*(0&'5!%,99&*7! D=!=A=>A@! +2,5(!VVVW!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! D@!=A=>AN! +2,5(!VXW!C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S! D@!=A=>AO! C(3(,.!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!5'-#8'#-(! DN!

*$*,! 62<'(1@'21!/[[5/)(/0!/[[5;/9#'(!)2!#'/01#9/5'!)275/(1589185'!3'<'0;[@'21$! ST!=A=?A?! <.&7*%(*'! 10! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 5',7(5;! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S! 7,'(5! ,*)! '2(! C(3(,.!

81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55! F@!

*$**! 4;2908();2! UN!

-! 4.I"&?:!&.:??!W!:?=?I:4.!F?&.J%JYJE`! UT!

Page 5: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! E!

-$,! 6215;3891);2! UT!

-$*! &#'!5'('/59#!@;3'0! UO!

-$-! :'('/59#![#)0;(;[#B! US!

-$P! &#'!5'('/59#!(15/1'AB! ,++!@ANA?! Q1*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82! ?>?!@ANA=! <8'&1*!-(5(,-82! ?>@!

-$N! &#'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;A)9/0!75/@'R;5M! ,+P!@AOA?! 3(5(,-82!9-18(55!5'(95!,*)!%('21)5! ?>O!

-$T! Z/0)3)1B! ,,,!

-$O! =8@@/5B! ,,*!

P! 4.I"&?:!XJC:!W!&.?!>?:?IY!":J4?==!6KZ?=&6EI&6JK!IK%!%?Z?YJ"F?K&! ,,P!

P$,! 6215;3891);2! ,,P!NA?A?! 61#7.,5!U-((*!Z!Q,5(!5'#):!?! ??R!NA?A=! "'!B21%,5!Q1%%#*&':![159&',.!Z!Q,5(!"'#):!=! ??M!NA?A@! @B5!3(7&1*,.!Q(*'-(!\!Q,5(!5'#):!@! ??F!

P$*! 4/('!(183B!@'1#;3;0;AB! ,*,!

P$-! 4/('!(183)'(!/91)<)1B! ,**!NA@A?! <8'&E&':!)(58-&9'&1*!,*)!1#'9#'5!10!Q"!?! ?=@!NA@A=! <8'&E&':!)(58-&9'&1*!,*)!1#'9#'5!10!Q"!=! ?@M!NA@A@! <8'&E&':!)(58-&9'&1*!,*)!1#'9#'5!10!Q"!@! ?N=!

P$P! &#'!/3<)(;5B!A5;8[!</0)3/1);2!@'1#;3! ,N+!

P$N! %)(98(();2D!)2<'(1)A/1);2!/23!</0)3/1);2!0)@)1/1);2(! ,NT!

N! 4.I"&?:!X6Z?!W!>?:?IY!":J4?==!I:4.6&?4&C:?! ,T+!

N$,! %'7)2)2A!1#'!@/)2!1'5@(! ,T+!

N$*! >':'/0![5;9'((![#/('(!'<;081);2! ,T-!

N$-! >':'/0![#/('(!)2!3'1/)0! ,TU!OA@A?! "'-,'(7:!<.&7*%(*'! ?RF!OA@A=! H.&8&','&1*! ?M@!OA@A@! G9'&1*((-&*7! ?MR!OA@AN! +,'2S,:! ?MF!OA@AO! <55(55%(*'! ?D=!

N$P! G'B!>':'/0!1;;0(!/23!1'9#2)]8'(! ,SN!

Page 6: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! E&!

OANA?! C(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?DO!OANA=! C(*(0&'5!$-(,K)1S*!,*)!2&(-,-82:! ?DR!OANA@! C(*(0&'5!"(7%(*','&1*! ?DD!OANAN! T#.'&!8-&'(-&,!-,*K&*7! ?F>!OANAO! C(*(0&'5!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!-(51#-8(!)(9(*)(*8&(5! ?F=!OANAR! Q1*'-1..&*7!,55#-,*8(! ?F=!

N$N! "5;9'((!)@[0'@'21/1);2!1'/@! ,UP!

N$T! %)(98(();2! ,UT!OARA?! +,-,)&7%!52&0'! ?FR!OARA=! +-18(55!&*'(7-,'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5! ?FM!OARA@! +-18(55!K(:!,59(8'5! ?FD!

N$O! >':'/0![5;9'((!</0)3/1);2! *+P!

N$S! 4;2908();2! *+T!

T! 4.I"&?:!=6a!W!4JK4YC=6JK=! *+O!

T$,! Y)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!7)23)2A(! *+S!

T$*! 62<'(1)A/1);2!7)23)2A(! *,+!

T$-! :'('/59#!9;215)H81);2(! *,*!

T$P! >':'/0!2;<'0!9;215)H81);2(!)2!5'0/1);2!1;!1#'!./46:64![5;Q'91! *,-!

T$N! :'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!/23!</0)3)1B! *,P!

T$T! :'9;@@'23/1);2(!7;5!7851#'5!5'('/59#! *,O!

O! :?X?:?K4?=! **+!

I""?K%64?=! *-S!

I""?K%6a!6!W!&?4.K6bC?=!&.I&!?F>:I4?!>?K?X6&=!:?IY6=I&6JK! *-U!

I""?K%6a!66!W!4I=?!=&C%6?=!%I&I! *N,!

I""?K%6a!666!W!>?:?IY!":J4?==!&?F"YI&?=! *ST!

I""?K%6a!6Z!W!>?:?IY!":J4?==!%?Y6Z?:I>Y?=!XYJV4.I:&! *U-!

I""?K%6a!Z!W!>?:?IY!":J4?==!6KXJ:FI&6JK!&?4.KJYJE`!"YI&XJ:F! *UP!

I""?K%6a!Z6W!"C>Y64I&6JK=!IK%!I4&6Z6&`!>`!&.?!IC&.J:!:?YI&?%!&J!&.6=!&.?=6=

! *UT!

Page 7: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! E&&!

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`,%9.(5!10!)&-(8'!,*)!&*)&-(8'!$(*(0&'5!IQQB<;!=>>>J! NM!/&7#-(!FW!U(*(-&8!01-%!10!$(*(0&'5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FF@J! ND!/&7#-(!?>W!C(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!$:!$#5&*(55!&%9,8'!#5&*7!'2(!Q-,*0&(.)!U-&)!a!C15'1*!T,'-&`!!

IC-,).(:;!=>>R!&*!GUQ;!=>>M,J! NF!/&7#-(!??W!<8'&E(!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!Ib(:'1*;!?FFOJ! ON!/&7#-(!?=W!Q-,*0&(.)!+-18(55!T1)(.!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!I_,-);!?FFRJ! OO!/&7#-(!?@W!Q1-*(-5'1*(5!10!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!<99-1,82!IB21-9;!?FFDJ! OR!/&7#-(!?NW!Q1*8(9'#,.!%1)(.!01-!C3!)(E(.19%(*'!I<52#-5';!=>>@J! OF!/&7#-(!?OW!C(*(0&'5!$-(,K)1S*!2&(-,-82:!I,),9'()!0-1%!]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>O;!3(&55!('!,.A;!

=>>RJ! R?!/&7#-(!?RW!<!':9&8,.!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!5'-#8'#-(;!521S&*7!21S!'2(!E,-&1#5!915&'&1*5!&*E1.E()!&*!

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

&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!9-18(55(5! FN!/&7#-(!=OWB2(!c](5'()L!-(5(,-82!%1)(.!Id,7&17.1#;!?FFFJ! FM!/&7#-(!=RW!B2(!2(-%(*(#'&8!.(,-*&*7!59&-,.!IG.)%,*;!?FDOJ!&*!Id,7&17.1#;!=>>>J! FF!/&7#-(!=MW!Q1*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!0.1S82,-'!I,),9'()!0-1%!X,&52*,E&!,*)!d#(82.(-;!

=>>NJ! ?>=!/&7#-(!=DW!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-K! ?>O!/&7#-(!=FW!C(*(0&'5!%,9!10!T,"B!bV/B!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'!c!V%9-1E()!9,'&(*'!5(-E&8(5LA! ?=F!/&7#-(!@>W!+-18(55!&*'(7-,'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5! ?R=!/&7#-(!@?W![&72!.(E(.!E&(S!10!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55! ?R@!/&7#-(!@=W!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!'&%(.&*(! ?RO!

Page 8: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! E&&&!

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

!

! !

Page 9: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! &`!

Y)(1!;7!1/H0'(!B,$.(!?W!Q2115&*7!'2(!-&72'!.(E(.!10!+GH!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJ! @?!B,$.(!=W!B2-((!%,&*!+GH!'11.K&'5!\!I3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!?FFD;!B#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!

X&88,-5;!=>>RJ! @=!B,$.(!@W!"',K(21.)(-!':9(5!I[,--&5;!=>>DJ! @N!B,$.(!NW!+,-,)&7%!52&0'!01-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!IB-#,`;!?FFMJ! N=!B,$.(!OW!C(*(0&'!E,.#(!':9(5!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJ! NR!B,$.(!RW!B,`1*1%:!10!2(,.'28,-(!,8'1-5!IT,*'e,*,!,*)!B2(%&5'18.(1#5;!=>>NJ! O=!B,$.(!MW!C(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!5#%%,-:! O=!B,$.(!DW!Q1%9,-,'&E(!%,'-&`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bV/B!8,5(!5'#):!\!(`,%9.(5!,*)!$(*(0&'!1-7,*&5,'&1*! ?=M!B,$.(!?DW!Q"!?!T,"B!bV/B!),',!81..(8'&1*!%('21)5! ?@>!B,$.(!?FW!f#(5'&1*5!,*)!$(*(0&'5!.&*K!&..#5'-,'&1*! ?@=!B,$.(!=>W!"#%%,-:!10!Q"?!4#(5'&1**,&-(!-(5#.'5!&*!'(-%5!10!5,'&50,8'1-:!.(E(.5! ?@R!B,$.(!=?W!H`,%9.(!10!8#%#.,'&E(!5,'&50,8'&1*!.(E(.5!\!81--(.,'&1*!10!4#(5'&1*5!S&'2!$(*(0&'5! ?@M!B,$.(!==W!Q"=!-(5(,-82!%('21)5!,*)!,&%! ?@D!B,$.(!=@W!"'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!81*51.&),'&1*!Q"!=! ?N=!B,$.(!=NW!Q"@!-(5(,-82!%('21)5!,*)!,&%! ?N@!B,$.(!=OW!Q"@!\!C"P[!@B5!!\!V)(*'&0&8,'&1*;!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,*)!S(&72'&*7!10!5'-,'(7&8!,*)!5#$!

$(*(0&'5! ?NF!B,$.(!=RW!!3(5(,-82!%('21)5W!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!%(('&*75aS1-K5219!5#%%,-:! ?O?!B,$.(!=MW!Q,5(!5'#)&(5!5#%%,-:!,*)!&*0.#(*8(!1*!C(3(,.!92,5(!(E1.#'&1*! ?RN!

!

! !

Page 10: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! `!

!!!!

!

!

!

!

8+!:/.30$.;!-).%'+(!.#0!-)&,.#+(!

!!!! !

Page 11: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! `&!

I9M2;R0'3A'@'21(!

V!S1#.)!.&K(!'1!,8K*1S.()7(!%:!7-,'&'#)(!'1!'2(!01..1S&*7!9(19.(!'2,'!2,E(!$((*!

&*E1.E()! S&'2! %(! )#-&*7! '2(! :(,-5! '2,'! '2&5! ^1#-*(:! 2,5! ',K(*! '1! -(,82! &'5!

cV'2,8,LA!

B1!%:!5#9(-E&51-!+-10(551-!T&82,&.!d,7&17.1#;! 01-!2&5!81*'&*#1#5!7#&),*8(!,*)!

5#991-'! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! -(5(,-82!,*)! 01-!$(.&(E&*7! &*!%(!,5!,!9(-51*A!_&'21#'!

2&5!E&5&1*;!S&5)1%!,*)!81*5',*'!(*81#-,7(%(*'!'2&5!'2(5&5!S1#.)!*1'!2,E(!2,)!

%,'(-&,.&5()A!

B1!%:!S&0(!Q.,#)&,;!'2(!9(-51*!'2,'!2,5!)(0&*()!%:!.&0(A!/1-!,.S,:5!$(&*7!$:!%:!

5&)(!01-!'2(!^1E&,.!$#'!,.51!'2(!82,..(*7&*7!%1%(*'5!)#-&*7!'2(!9,5'!=O!:(,-5A!T:!

51*5!"',E-15!,*)!"'(0,*15! 01-!%,K&*7!%(! 0((.!9-1#)!,*)! 01-!7&E&*7! '2,'!59(8&,.!

9#-915(!&*!%:!.&0(A!

B1!%:!9,-(*'5!"',E-15!,*)!61-1'2(,!01-!$(&*7!,!51#-8(!10!#*81*)&'&1*,.!.1E(!,*)!

81#-,7(;!V!S&..!,.S,:5!$(!7-,'(0#.A!

T:! 0-&(*)5! ,*)! 81..(,7#(5! ,'! '2(! P*&E(-5&':! 10! ",.01-)! ,*)! 59(8&,..:! d,'2-:*!

g,'(5!,*)!3&8,-)1!Q1)&*21'1!01-!'2(&-!#*-(5(-E()!5#991-'!,*)!01-!%,K&*7!S1-K!

,!$(''(-!9.,8(!'1!$(A!

"9(8&,.! '2,*K5! '1! h15i! C,--(&-1! b&%,! 01-! $(&*7! ,!%(*'1-;! ,! 0-&(*);! ,! 51#-8(! 10!

K*1S.()7(!,*)!01-!59(*)&*7!(*).(55!21#-5!S&'2!%(!)($,'&*7!,*)!,55(55&*7!'2(!

1#'81%(5!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!!

V!%#5'!(`9-(55!%:!'2,*K5!'1!,..!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!,*)!9(19.(!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!

,*)! '2(! c,)E&51-:! 7-1#9L! 01-! '2(&-! '&%(! ,*)! 81*'-&$#'&1*! &*!$#&.)&*7! 51%('2&*7!

%(,*&*70#.A!V*!9,-'&8#.,-!31$!"%&'2;!6#,*(!+,55%,*!,*)!+,'-&8&,!b(,2:A!

"9(8&,.! '2,*K5! '1! '2(! [(,.'2! ,*)! Q,-(! V*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 3(5(,-82! ,*)! V**1E,'&1*!

Q(*'-(!I[,QV3VQJ!01-!9-(5(*'&*7!'2(!1991-'#*&':!01-!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!!

/&*,..:!jklmnop!,! '-#(! 0-&(*);!2(!2,5!,.S,:5! cK(9'!%(!S,.K&*7L!,*)!521S()!%(!

'2,'!c.&0(!&5!5&%9.(L!,0'(-!,..A! !

Page 12: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! `&&!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!<=,!*+3!0+#>)>!?#+@!@6&'&!*+3>'&!A+$#A;!.#*!2.)6!$(!.(!A++0!.(!.#+)6&'!B!C3)!*+3!

@+#>)! '&./$(&! *+3>'&! /+();! *+3! @+#>)! ?#+@! @6.)! )$D&! *+3>//! A&)! )6&'&;! *+3! D$A6)!

3#?#+@$#A/*!C&!A+$#A! $#!E$'E/&(;!.#0!+)6&'(!@+#>)!3#0&'().#0!6+@!)6&*!E.#!6&/29!

F#0;! ($#E&! *+3! E+3/0! 2.((! '$A6)! C*! @$)6+3)! ?#+@$#A! $);! *+3! @+#>)! A&)! )6&!

(.)$(,.E)$+#!+,!6.%$#A!.''$%&0>!

G&@$(!:.''+//H!F/$E&!$#!)6&!I+#0&'/.#0;!JKLM!

!

! !

Page 13: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! `&&&!

IH(15/91!

B-,)&'&1*,..:;! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! )('(-%&*(! '2(&-! .(E(.! 10!

5#88(55!%,&*.:!,7,&*5'!815';!4#,.&':!,*)!'&%(!10!)(.&E(-:;!,*)!*1'!1*!'2(!)(7-((!'1!S2&82!$(*(0&'5!

1-! &%9,8'5! ,-(! )(.&E(-()A! B11! 10'(*! 9(19.(! 2,E(! ,55#%()! '2,'! ,! 9-17-,%%(! 1-! 9-1^(8'! S&..!

,82&(E(!8(-',&*!$(*(0&'5;!S&'21#'!8,--:&*7!1#'!,*,.:5&5!'1!0&*)!1#'!S2,'!#5(-5;!9,-'*(-5!,*)!1'2(-!

5',K(21.)(-5!-(,..:!E,.#(!1-!21S!'2(5(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!,82&(E()A!B2(:!81*8(*'-,'(!'2(&-!(001-'5!

1*!,82&(E&*7!1#'9#'5;!5#82!,5!,!*(S!$#&.)&*7;!,*!V*01-%,'&1*!B(82*1.17:!IVBJ!5:5'(%;!1-!,!82,*7(!

'1!,!5(-E&8(A!C:!'2(!'&%(!'2(5(!71,.5!,-(!)(.&E(-();!'2(-(!&5!.&%&'()!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2(!59(8&0&8!

,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5!,*)!.&%&'()!,$&.&':!'1!&*0.#(*8(;!1-!(E(*!'-,8K;!'2(&-!,82&(E(%(*'5A!!

B,-7('&*7! 8.,-&0&8,'&1*! 10! &%9,8'5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5! &5! (%(-7&*7! ,5! ,! %('21)! '1! ,55&5'! 2(,.'28,-(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1! %,*,7(! S21.(! .&0(! 8:8.(! 10! 9-17-,%%(5! 0-1%! )(E(.19%(*';! 81*5'-#8'&1*! '1!

19(-,'&1*5!,*)!0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(%(*'A!B2&5!S,5!9-(5(*'()!,5!,*!1991-'#*&':!'1! &*E(5'&7,'(! &*'1!

'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!IC(3(,.J!9-18(55A!!

<!81*5'-#8'&E(!,*)!8,5(!5'#):!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7:!S,5!)(9.1:()!01-!'2(!&*E(5'&7,'&1*;!)(E(.19%(*'!

,*)! E,.&),'&1*! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55A! <! *#%$(-! 10! -(5(,-82! %('21)5! 5#82! ,5! S1-K52195;!

1$5(-E,'&1*5!,*)!4#(5'&1**,&-(5!S(-(!#5()!'1!81..(8'!),',!01-!'2(!-(5(,-82A!<!-(.(E,*'!.&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S! S,5! 81*)#8'()! ,*)! &*8.#)()! -(E&(S5! &*'1! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*!

,99-1,82(5!,*)!&'5!5,'(..&'(!5#$^(8'5;!&*8.#)&*7!9-17-,%%(!,*)!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*';!5',K(21.)(-!

%,*,7(%(*';! (E,.#,'&1*! '(82*&4#(5! ('8A! B2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 0&*)&*75;! )&58#55&1*5! S&'2!

2(,.'28,-(! 9-,8'&'&1*(-5! ,*)! (`9(-'5! &*! '2(! 5#$^(8'! ,-(,! ,5! S(..! ,5! '2(! ,#'21-L5! 9(-51*,.!

(`9(-&(*8(5!S(-(!&*'(7-,'()!S&'2!,!*#%$(-!10!8,5(!5'#):!0&*)&*75!'1!&*01-%;!)(E(.19!,*)!E,.&),'(!

'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!B2(!9-18(55!81*5&5'5!10!0&E(!92,5(5;!S2&82!81*5&)(-!'2(!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)!#5(!

10!$(*(0&'5!,5!'2(!%,&*!)-&E(-!01-!'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-1^(8'5!S&'2!,!%1-(!

9-()&8',$.(!5#88(55!1#'81%(A!

B2(!%,&*!81*'-&$#'&1*!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!&5! &*!'(-%5!10!9-(5(*'&*7!,!%('21)1.17:!10! &*E(5'&7,'&*7!

,*)! )(E(.19&*7! ,! 9-18(55! '2,'! (%$-,8(5! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82A! B2(! 9-18(55! &5! $#&.'!

#91*! &*'(7-,'&*7! 9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(5! ,*)! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'!%('21)5A! V'!

9-1%1'(5!K*1S.()7(!0.1S!)1S*!,*)!52,-&*7!$:!%,*,7&*7!5',K(21.)(-5L!(`9(8','&1*5!'2-1#721#'!

'2(!82,*7(!.&0(8:8.(;!S2(*!9.,**&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(5A!

!

!!!!

Page 14: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?!

, 4#/[1'5!J2'!L!6215;3891);2!!

B2&5!82,9'(-! &5!,*! &*'-1)#8'&1*! '1! '2(!5#$^(8'!,-(,!10! '2(! -(5(,-82!#*)(-',K(*! 01-!

'2&5!'2(5&5A!V'!018#5(5!1*!'2(!-(5(,-82!9-1$.(%!,*)!'2(!*(()!01-!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!

,!9-18(55! '1!,))-(55! '2(!7,9!,5! &'!S,5! &)(*'&0&()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(A! V'! &..#5'-,'(5! '2(!

*(()! 0-1%! '2(! &*)#5'-:! ,*)! ,8,)(%&,! 01-! ,! *(S! 9-18(55! '2,'! S&..! (*,$.(!

9-,8'&'&1*(-5! '1! &%9.(%(*'! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! '2&*K&*7! ,*)! ,99-1,82;! S2(*!

9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-&*7! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A! <*! 1#'.&*(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)1.17:!&5!9-(5(*'()!,.1*7!S&'2!'2(!-1,)%,9!'1S,-)5!,82&(E&*7!'2(!-(5(,-82!

,&%5!,*)!1$^(8'&E(5A!B2(!5'-#8'#-(!10!'2(!'2(5&5!&5!&..#5'-,'()!2(-(;!92,5(!$:!92,5(!'1!

)(%1*5'-,'(! 9-1$.(%! ,S,-(*(55;! ,*)! '2(! ,8'&1*5! ',K(*! '1! )(E(.19;! ,*)! (E,.#,'(!

,*)!81*8.#)(!'2(!-(5(,-82(-L5!81*'-&$#'&1*!'1!K*1S.()7(A!

,$, >/9MA5;823!!

V*! 7(*(-,.! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! ,-(! )-&E(*! $:! ,! *(()! '1! 5,'&50:! ,! 5('! 10!

$(*(0&'5! 01-! )&00(-(*'! 7-1#95! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! I_&*'(-! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! "#82!

&*&'&,'&E(5!8,*!1*.:!$(!-(7,-)()!,5!5#88(550#.!&0!'2(!&*'(*)()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!-(,.&5()!

IT8Q,-'*(:;! =>>>JA! [1S(E(-;! &'! 2,5! $((*! ,-7#()! '2,';! 0-(4#(*'.:;! 9-1^(8'5! ,*)!

9-17-,%%(5!,-(!)(.&E(-()!&*!'&%(!,*)!S&'2&*!$#)7(';!$#'!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!

,-(!*1'!,.S,:5!9(-8(&E()!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!!

B21-9!I?FFDJ!5#77(5'5!'2,'!'2(!8#--(*'!%,*,7(-&,.!9-,8'&8(5!,-(!'2(!%,&*!-(,51*!

01-!0,&.#-(A!V*!0,8';!d15K(.,!,*)![1S(..!I=>>?J!,-7#(!'2,'!'2(!#*)(-.:&*7!'2(1-&(5!

10!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!2,E(!$((*!5#$^(8'()!'1!8-&'&8&5%!5&*8(!'2(!?FD>L5A!V'!2,5!

$((*! ,-7#()! '2,'! 5#82! '-,)&'&1*,.! ,99-1,82(5! ,-(! '11! *,--1S.:! 018#5()! 1*!

%,*,7&*7! 815';! '&%(! ,*)! 4#,.&':! IB21-9;! ?FFDJ;! ,*)! ,-(! $,5()! 1*! 5&%9.&5'&8!

%1)(.5!'2,'!,-(!&*5#00&8&(*'!'1!)(,.!S&'2!9-,8'&8,.!9-1$.(%5!Id15K(.,!,*)![1S(..;!

=>>?JA!!

V*! ,))&'&1*;! B2&-:! I=>>=J! 8-&'&8&5(5! '2(! 8#--(*'! 9,-,)&7%! 10! 9-17-,%%(!

%,*,7(%(*';!S2&82! &5! $,5()!1*!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! '2(1-:A!<881-)&*7! '1! '2&5!

,#'21-;! 9-17-,%%(5! ,-(! 5#$^(8'()! '1! ,%$&7#&':! ,*)! *(()! '1! $(! %,*,7()!

Page 15: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =!

)&00(-(*'.:! '2,*!9-1^(8'5A!B2(!5,%(!,#'21-!,-7#(5!'2,'!8#--(*'!9-,8'&8(5! .,8K! &*!

81*5&)(-&*7!%1-(!510'! &55#(5;!5#82!,5!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*';!81%%#*&8,'&1*!

,*)!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!*(()! '1!$(''(-! 81*5&)(-! 510'! &55#(5! &*!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! &5!

,.51! )&58#55()! &*! ,! 59(8&,.! &55#(! 10! '2(! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.! 10! +-1^(8'!

T,*,7(%(*'! 9#$.&52()! &*! =>>R;! (A7A! _&*'(-! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! ,*)! <'K&*51*! ('! ,.A!

I=>>RJ;!S2(-(!%,&*!0&*)&*75!0-1%!'2(!3('2&*K&*7!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*'!-(5(,-82!

*('S1-K!,-(!)&58#55()A!

,$,$, &#'!)@[;51/29'!;7!/!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/[[5;/9#!

"&*8(! '2(! ?FD>5! '2(-(! 2,5! $((*! 2#7(! &*E(5'%(*'! 9-17-,%%(! &*'1! '2(! PdL5!

()#8,'&1*;! 21#5&*7;! 81%%#*&':! -(7(*(-,'&1*! ,*)! &*! 9,-'&8#.,-! 2(,.'28,-(!

5:5'(%5A! B2(5(! 81%9.(`! 9#$.&8\9-&E,'(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(5! ,-(!

)-&E(*! $:! '2(! *(()! '1! -(,.&5(! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#721#'! '2(&-! .&0(8:8.(A! C(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! S,5! 1-&7&*,..:! )(E(.19()! '1! ^#5'&0:! 59(*)&*7! S&'2&*! '2(! VB!

IV*01-%,'&1*!B(82*1.17:J!5(8'1-!&*!'2(!.,'(!?FD>5!,*)!(,-.:!?FF>5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!

?FFFJ;! $#'! 2,5! $(81%(! &*8-(,5&*7.:! #5()! S&'2&*! 2(,.'28,-(! ,*)! 1'2(-! 5(8'1-5!

IGUQ;!=>>M,;!C-,).(:;!=>>RJA!

B2(! %,&*! &55#(! &5! '2,'! *1'! &)(*'&0:&*7! 1-! )(0&*&*7! $(*(0&'5! )#-&*7! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(5!10!,*!&*&'&,'&E(!%,K(5!%,*,7&*7!,*)!%1*&'1-&*7!'2(%!%1-(!

82,..(*7&*7;! S2&82! %,:! .(,)! '1! 911-! 9(-01-%,*8(! ,*)! #.'&%,'(.:! '1! '2(!

$-(,K)1S*!10!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*;!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!IC,-'.('';!=>>Rq!3(&55!('!,.A;!

=>>Rq! +,:*(;! =>>MJA! C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 2,5! (%(-7()! ,5! ,!%('21)! '2,'! 8,*! $(!

#5()! '1! 2(.9! 5'((-! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,S,:! 0-1%! '2&5! 91'(*'&,..:!

#*81*'-1..()a#*5#88(550#.! ,99-1,82A! V*! 51%(!10! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! &'! &5! ,-7#()! '2,'!

,8'&E(.:!%,*,7&*7;!%1*&'1-&*7!,*)!-(,.&5&*7! IU.:**(;!=>>MJ!$(*(0&'5!S&'2&*! '2(!

2(,.'28,-(! 5:5'(%;! %,:! -(5#.'! &*! ,! $(''(-! (4#&.&$-&#%! $('S((*! -(51#-8(!

#'&.&5,'&1*!,*)!5(-E&8(5A!

V*! '2&5! 81*'(`';! $(*(0&'!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*!2,5! -&5(*!,5! ,*!,.'(-*,'&E(!

,99-1,82! '1! 8#--(*'! 9-,8'&8(5;! S&'2! ,! S&)(-! 018#5! 1*! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! 10!

&*E(5'%(*'5A!B2&5!,99-1,82!5#77(5'5!,!81*'&*#1#5!9-18(55!10!(*E&5&1*&*7!-(5#.'5;!

Page 16: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @!

&%9.(%(*'&*7;!82(8K&*7!&*'(-%()&,'(!-(5#.'5!,*)!):*,%&8,..:!,)^#5'&*7!'2(!9,'2!

.(,)&*7!0-1%!&*E(5'%(*'!'1!-(5#.'5!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!!

"#82! ,*! ,99-1,82! 521#.)! ,&%! '1! ',8K.(! %,^1-! -(,51*5! 01-! 0,&.&*7! '1! ,82&(E(!

5#88(550#.!9-17-,%%(5;!5#82!,5W!

,A B2(! E,7#(*(55! S&'2! S2&82! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! )(0&*()! ,*)! 0#-'2(-!

)&00&8#.'&(5! '1!%,&*',&*! 018#5!S2(*!5#$5(4#(*'!9-1$.(%5!188#-!I3(&55!('!,.A;!

=>>RJ! ,5! S(..! ,5! ,! 81*5(4#(*'! #*8(-',&*':! &*! ,..18,'&*7! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-!

%,*,7&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!$(*(0&'5!Ib&*!,*)!+(-E,*;!=>>?Jq!

$A B2(! *1*\81*5&)(-,'&1*! 10! 51%(! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,*)! 21S! '2(:! 8,*! &*0.#(*8(!

9-1^(8'5L!-(5#.'5!I_,-)!r!6,*&(.;!=>>RJq!!

8A B2(!.1*7!9(-&1)5!10!,!9-1^(8'L5!.&0(!8:8.(;!.(,)&*7!'1!,!)&581**(8'&1*!$('S((*!

$(*(0&'5! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-:! )#(! '1! 82,*7(5! &*! 9(-51**(.! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;!

=>>RJq!!

)A B2(! *1*\81*5&)(-,'&1*! 10! *(8(55,-:! &*'(-81**(8'()! &55#(5! '2,'! %&72'!

&*0.#(*8(!'2(!9-1^(8'L5!5#88(55!IB21-9;!?FFDJq!,*)!

(A +11-!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!*(8(55,-:!%(,*5!'1!,82&(E(!$(*(0&'5!,*)!911-!,$&.&':!'1!

%,*,7(!82,*7(!IB-#,`;!?FFMJA!

]1S,),:5;!%,*,7&*7!$(*(0&'5!2,5!$(81%(!,!'19&8!10!)&58#55&1*!&*!)&00(-(*'!,-(,5;!

&*8.#)&*7!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!I][";!=>>OJ!,*)!)($,'()!&*!%,^1-!GUQL5!IG00&8(!

10! U1E(-*%(*'! Q1%%(-8(J! 9#$.&8,'&1*5! -(7,-)&*7! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(!

%,*,7(%(*'A!!

,$,$* >'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!#'/01#9/5'!)275/(1589185'![5;A5/@@'(!

[(,.'28,-(! 9-17-,%%(5! ,-(! 81%9.(`! 5:5'(%5! )(E(.19()! S&'2&*! %#.'&\

5',K(21.)(-!(*E&-1*%(*'5!IQ,--#'2(-5!('!,.9;!=>>Rq!"S((*(:!,*)!U-&00&'25;!=>>=JA!

"#82! 9-17-,%%(5! ':9&8,..:! 2,E(! ,! .1*7! .&0(59,*;! S&'2! %,*:! 92,5(5! &*8.#)&*7!

91.&8:!5(''&*7;!9.,**&*7;!)(E(.19%(*';!81*5'-#8'&1*;!81%%&55&1*&*7!10!2(,.'28,-(!

5(-E&8(! 19(-,'&1*5;! 0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'! I(A7A! %,&*'(*,*8(J;! -(0#-$&52%(*'5!

,*)!)(%1.&'&1*A!!

Page 17: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! N!

B2(! 81%9.(`&':! &*)#8()! $:! 5',K(21.)(-! )&E(-5&':! ,*)! '2(! .1*7! .&0(59,*! 10!

9-17-,%%(5!%,:!&*)#8(!0,&.#-(!&*!)(.&E(-&*7!,&%5!5('!1#'!&*!&'5!&*&'&,.!5',7(5!&A(A!

5',K(21.)(-5! ,-(! *1'! -(,.&5&*7! S2,'! 2,5! $((*! 9.,**()A! 6&59,-&':! 1-! .,8K! 10!

81--(591*)(*8(!$('S((*!'2(!&NO.#)&!,*)!&NO2+()!5',7(5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJ!8,*!

$(! -(.,'()! '1! 911-! I1-! .,8K! 10J! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'A! C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

5#991-'5! '2,'! 5#82! )&59,-&':! $('S((*! .&0(8:8.(! 5',7(5! &5! %,*,7()! '2-1#72! ,!

9-18(55! '2,'! &*E1.E(5! (.&8&'&*7;!%,*,7&*7;!%1*&'1-&*7a81*'-1..&*7;! -(,.&5&*7! ,*)!

%(,5#-&*7!$(*(0&'5A!

C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &5! '21#72'! 10! ,5! 9,-'&8#.,-.:! &%91-',*'! S&'2&*! 2(,.'28,-(!

(*E&-1*%(*'5!,5!&'!c2(.95!'1!(*5#-(!,!8.(,-!5&7*!915'&*7!10!S21!&5!-(591*5&$.(!01-!

'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!'215(!$(*(0&'5L!I][";!=>>MJA!/#-'2(-%1-(;!'2(!81*'&*#1#5!82,*7(5!

&*! '2(! 5'-#8'#-(! ,*)! 71E(-*,*8(! 10! '2(! ],'&1*,.! [(,.'2! "(-E&8(! I]["J!%,K(! &'!

)&00&8#.'! '1!(E,.#,'(!5(-E&8(5q!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!S1#.)!(*,$.(! '2(5(! &%91-',*'!

(E,.#,'&1*5!'1!188#-!#*)(-!,!#*&4#(!,*)!9-17-(55&E(.:!19'&%&5()!,99-1,82!I][";!

=>>MJA!

Q2,*7(5!'2,'!2,E(!188#--()!,*)!S&..!81*'&*#(!'1!188#-!&*!'2(!]["!&'5!5'-#8'#-(;!

71E(-*,*8(;!-1.(5!('8A!2,E(!2,)!,*)!S&..!81*'&*#(!'1!2,E(!,!2#7(!&%9,8'!1*!'2(!

,$&.&':! '1! (E,.#,'(! '2(! 5(-E&8(A! /,-$(:! ('! ,.A! I?FFFJ! (`9.,&*! '2,'! '2(! 52&0'! &*!

-(591*5&$&.&':! ,*)! 91S(-! $('S((*! S1-K(-5! )#(! '1! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 5'-#8'#-(!

82,*7(5;!2,5! .()! '1! 81*0#5&1*!1E(-!9-&1-&'&(5;!S&'2!7-1#95!*1S!81%9('&*7!S&'2!

1*(!,*1'2(-!01-!'2(!,#'21-&':!,*)!81*'-1.!1E(-!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*;!&'5!5'-,'(7:!,*)!

E,.#(!5:5'(%A!_&'2!'2&5!81%9('&'&1*!S&'2&*!'-#5'5!,*)!$('S((*!'2(%!(E,.#,'&1*!

2,5!$(81%(!%1-(!018#5()!1*!'2(!815'!(00(8'&E(*(55!,*)!(00&8&(*8:A!

B2(-(! ,-(! 5(E(-,.! &*&'&,'&E(5! S&'2&*! '2(! 6(9,-'%(*'! 10! [(,.'2! &*! '2(! Pd!

,''(%9'&*7!'1!,))-(55!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!C,8K!&*!=>>O!S,5!'2(!0&-5'!,''(%9'!'1!

$-&*7! ,..! 5#82! ,''(%9'5! #*)(-! 1*(! #%$-(..,A! B2(! V*'(7-,'()! "(-E&8(!

V%9-1E(%(*'!+-17-,%%(!IV"V+J!-1,)!%,9!01-!cB-,*501-%,'&1*!Q2,*7(L!S,5!'2(*!

&*'-1)#8()!'1!'2(!][";!&'5!0&E(!,&%5!S(-(W!

• 6(.&E(-&*7!,!9,'&(*'\.()!]["q!

• 6(.&E(-&*7!4#,.&':!,*)!E,.#(q!

Page 18: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! O!

• b18,.!,8'&1*q!*,'&1*,.!E1&8(q!

• "9-(,)&*7!$(5'!9-,8'&8(q!

• V*'(7-,'&1*A!

V*!T,-82!=>>R!,..!b18,.![(,.'2!Q1#*8&.5!Ib[QJ!2,)!'1!9-(9,-(!,*)!5#$%&'!'1!'2(!

6(9,-'%(*'! 10! [(,.'2! ,*)! '2(! "'-,'(7&8! [(,.'2! <#'21-&'&(5! I"[<J;! ,! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!IC3+J!01-!,..!10!'2(!c&*'(7-,'()!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(5!9-1915()!&*!

'2(&-!V"V!+.,*LA!B2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!*(()()!'1!$(!,.&7*()!S&'2!'2(!G00&8(!

10!U1E(-*%(*'!Q1%%(-8(! IGUQJ;!T,*,7&*7!"#88(550#.!+-17-,%%(5! IT"+J!,*)!

'2(!+3V]QH=!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!%('21)1.17:A!B2(!,&%!10! '2&5!S,5! '1!(*5#-(!

'2,'! '2(! b[Q! ,-(! S1-K&*7! '1S,-)5! '2(! K(:! ,&%5! 10! '2(! Pd! 71E(-*%(*'! &*!

9-1E&)&*7! ,! 2(,.'28,-(! 5:5'(%! '2,'! &5! 9,'&(*'! .()A! <))&'&1*,..:! &'! ,&%()! '1!

&*'(7-,'(! ,*)! ,.&7*! ,..! 91.&8:! )-&E(-5! ,5! '2(:! ,-(! )(.&E(-()! '2-1#72! )&00(-(*'!

9-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5!'1!9-1)#8(!'2(!)(5&-()!$(*(0&'5!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!/&7#-(!

?A!

!

X)A85'!,c!621'A5/1)2A!9#/2A'!)2!1#'!K.=!^K.=!6=6"D!*++O_!

,$* :'('/59#!2''3!

<5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! '2(! &*'(-&%! -(91-'! 10! '2(! cPQ-! P&N)! -).A&! R&%$&@>! 9-(9,-()! $:!

+-10(551-!b1-)!<-,!6,-e&!,*)!&55#()!&*!G8'1$(-!=>>M;!'2(!6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!

%,*),'()! '2(!GUQ!U,'(S,:Y!3(E&(S!9-18(55!S2(*!#*)(-',K&*7!%,^1-! 82,*7(!

!"#$%&$#%'()*+#*$),&-.#

/012.#

3&-,4)!"#$!*$),&-#

2$5%*-#),4#678#

2)9-#8-*594#0-9:%*-#

;%&%+)<#;%)&,5.+%*.#

=)+%5,)<#.-9:%*-.#>9)'-?59@.#

A.+)+-.#

B).+-9#.-9:%*-.#

C59-#->D%*%-,+#.-9:%*-.#

E-++-9#()+%-,+#-F(-9%*-,*-.#

G)((%-9#.+)>>#

/'(95:-4#.)>-+H#

E-++-9#*<%,%*)<#5I+*5'-.#

B%,),*%)<#7)<),*-#

J5*)<#;-<%:-9H#6<),.#

B1#C%&9)+%5,#

J5*)<#0-9:%*-#9-*5,D%&I9)+%5,#

3#6)+%-,+K<-4#=G0#

=G0##%'

(95:-'-,+#(<),#

!"#$%"$#&$&'()"*+$,$*-+&./0+&$-01"-0)$*-*1012&3$3456$037$ 8-$+6&$5"-+&'+$7$ 9"$(/"%45&$7$

Page 19: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! R!

9-17-,%%(5!1-!9-1^(8'5!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!I6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2;!=>>DJA!<!

5#%%,-:! 10! '2(! -(5#.'5! 10! ???! -(E&(S5! S,5! 9#$.&52()! '2-((! :(,-5! .,'(-!

2&72.&72'&*7! '2,'W! cs,+'!D.#*! *&.'(;! )6&'&! 6.(! C&&#! $#E'&.($#A! .@.'&#&((! +,! )6&!

#&&0! )+! ,+E3(! +#! $0&#)$,*$#A! .#0! 0&/$%&'$#A! C&#&,$)(9! S%$0&#E&! ,'+D! T.)&@.*;!

6+@&%&';!(6+@(!)6.)!)6&'&!$(!.!A.2!C&)@&&#!.(2$'.)$+#(!.#0!)6&!'&./$)*!$#!)6&!3(&!+,!

C&#&,$)(! D.#.A&D&#)! $#! )6&! 23C/$E! (&E)+'9! U.#*! 2'+A'.DD&! .#0! 2'+V&E)! )&.D(!

()'3AA/&! C&E.3(&! )6&'&! .'&! ,&@! C&#&,$)(! '&./$(.)$+#! D&)6+0+/+A$&(! .#0! )++/(!

.%.$/.C/&!.#0!C&#&,$)(!'&./$(.)$+#!$(!W0$,,$E3/)X!I6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!=>??;!99A!@JA!

<8'&E&'&(5! '1! &)(*'&0:! ,*)! -(,.&5(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! 10! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

9-1^(8'5!2,E(!10'(*;!$((*!8,--&()!1#'!&*!,!9(-0#*8'1-:!S,:A!B2(-(!2,5!$((*!.&''.(!

5:5'(%,'&8! 01..1S! '2-1#72! '1! )-&E(! 01-S,-)! )(.&E(-:! 10! '2(5(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! '1!

%(,5#-(!S2,'!&5!,8'#,..:!,82&(E()A!!V'!&5!,.51!-,-(!01-!,*:!#*,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5!

1-! )&5$(*(0&'5! '1! $(! 8,9'#-()! &*! ,! 5:5'(%,'&8! S,:A! Q#.'#-,.! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'!

&55#(5;! 10'(*! .(,)&*7! '1! &*,)(4#,'(! ,''(*'&1*! '1! '2(! 19(-,'&1*,.! 5',7(! 10!

9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5;! ,-(! 9,-'.:! -(591*5&$.(A! V*! 9,-'! '2(! 9-1$.(%! &5! ,.51!

$(8,#5(!10!5:5'(%5!,*)!9-18(55(5!S2&82!018#5!1*!'2(!9-18#-(%(*'!5',7(5;!.,8K!10!

K*1S.()7(! ,$1#'! 21S! '1! #*)(-',K(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;! ,*)! )&00&8#.':! &*!

(5',$.&52&*7! (00(8'&E(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55(5! &*! '2(!

,$5(*8(! 10! )(',&.()! 7#&),*8(! ,*)! '11.5A! "8-#'&*:! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! 2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-1^(8'5! &5! #5#,..:! 018#55()! 1*! 0,8'1-5! '2,'! ,-(! (,5&(-! '1!

#*)(-5',*)!,*)!%(,5#-(! 5#82!,5!)(.&E(-:! '1! '&%(;!4#,.&':! ,*)! 815'A!C#'! ,*!1*\

71&*7!018#5!1*!,82&(E&*7!)(5&-()!5(-E&8(5!,*)!1#'81%(5!&5!*(()()!&0!'2(!(`9(8'()!

E,.#(!01-!%1*(:!&5!'1!$(!,82&(E()!1E(-!'2(!.&0(!10!,!9-1^(8'!1-!9-17-,%%(!Ib(,2:;!

=>>FJA!

B-,)&'&1*,..:;! &*E(5'%(*'! 9-17-,%%(5! I,*)! 9-1^(8'5J! )('(-%&*(! '2(&-! .(E(.! 10!

5#88(55! %,&*.:! ,7,&*5'! 815';! 4#,.&':! ,*)! '&%(! 10! )(.&E(-:;! ,*)! *1'! 1*! ,! 0#..!

82,-,8'(-&5,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! 1-! &%9,8'5! )(.&E(-()A! B,-7('&*7! 8.,-&0&8,'&1*! 10!

&%9,8'5!,*)!$(*(0&'5;!K*1S*!,5!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*;!&5!(%(-7&*7!,5!,!%('21)!'1!

,55&5'!1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1!%,*,7(!S21.(! .&0(! 8:8.(!10!9-17-,%%(5! IU.:**(;!=>>MJ;!

0-1%! )(E(.19%(*';! 81*5'-#8'&1*! ,*)! 0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*';! '1! 19(-,'&1*5!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!$,8K\100&8(!5(-E&8(5!)(.&E(-:A!

Page 20: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! M!

Q1*8.#)&*7! 1*! '2(! ,-7#%(*'5! 9-(5(*'()! 9-(E&1#5.:! '2(! -(5(,-82! *(()! 8,*! $(!

5#%%,-&5()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!91&*'5W!

• B2(!*(()!0-1%!'2(!Pd!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!'1!)(%1*5'-,'(!E,.#(!01-!%1*(:!

0-1%!9#$.&8!,*)!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-!&*E(5'%(*'5q!

• Q2,*7(!9-17-,%%(5!,*)! &*&'&,'&E(5!#5#,..:!)1!*1'!)(.&E(-!,..! '2(:!81#.)!

,*)!521#.)q!

• 6(8&5&1*5! 1*! &*E(5'%(*'! ,*)! 19(-,'&1*,.! %,*,7(%(*'! ,-(! *1'! #5#,..:!

)-&E(*!$:!-&71-1#5!,*,.:5&5!10!$(*(0&'5q!

• B2(-(!&5! .&''.(!5:5'(%,'&8!01..1S!'2-1#72!'1!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5!,*)!%(,5#-(!

,82&(E(%(*'!&*!'2(!9#$.&8!,*)!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-!9-1^(8'5!,*)!9-17-,%%(5q!

• 6#-&*7! '2(! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-:! 92,5(5! 5',K(21.)(-5L! &*E1.E(%(*'! &5!

0-,7%(*'()!8,#5&*7!81%%#*&8,'&1*!,*)!K*1S.()7(!0.1S!$-(,K)1S*q!,*)!

• !6(.&E(-:! '(,%5! .,8K! '(82*&4#(5! ,*)! '11.5! '1! 5#991-'! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*!

,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5A!

,$- :'('/59#!7;98(!/23!/)@!

B2(! 018#5!10! '2(! -(5(,-82!9-(5(*'()!2(-(! &5! '1! &*E(5'&7,'(!$(5'!9-,8'&8(5! &*! '2(!

,-(,!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'q!21S!'2(5(!,-(!,99.&()!&*!'2(!Pd!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!

,*)!&*!9,-'&8#.,-!&'!,&%5!'1!)(E(.19!,!-1$#5'!9-18(55!01-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!!

_&'2!'2(!,$1E(!,&%!,5!)-&E(-;!'2&5!'2(5&5!5((K5!'1!,))-(55!'2(!01..1S&*7!-(5(,-82!

4#(5'&1*W!

• _2,'! &5! '2(!9-18(55! 01-!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! '2,'!S1#.)!2(.9!,))-(55! '2(!

9-1^(8'! 5#88(55! &55#(5! S&'2&*! '2(! PdL5! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

)(E(.19%(*'!5(8'1-!,*)!71(5!$(:1*)!8#--(*'!$(5'!9-,8'&8(t!

,$P :'('/59#!;HQ'91)<'(!

C,5()! 1*! '2(! -(5(,-82! ,&%! ,*)! '2(! -(5(,-82! 4#(5'&1*! -,&5()! '2(! 01..1S&*7!

1$^(8'&E(5!,-(!5('W!

Page 21: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! D!

• P*)(-',K(! ,! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! '1! &)(*'&0:! c$(5'! 9-,8'&8(L! ,*)! &55#(5! 1*!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! -(.,'()! )&58&9.&*(5A! V*! 9,-'&8#.,-!

,&%&*7!'1!&)(*'&0:W!

o _2,'!,-(!'2(!8#--(*'!9-,8'&8(5!,*)!,99-1,82(5!-(.,'()!'1!$(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*t!

o _2,'! ,-(! '2(! 8#--(*'! 9-18(55(5! 01-! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-&*7!

2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%5t!

• 6(E&5(! ,! %('21)1.17:! 01-! &*E(5'&7,'&*7! 5&7*&0&8,*'! &*5&72'5! &*'1! 21S!

c$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*L!&5!#*)(-5'11)!8#--(*'.:!,*)!.&*K!,..!-(.(E,*'!&55#(5!'1!

2(.9!)(E(.19!,*)!9-1%1'(!'2(!,)19'&1*!10!,!c$(*(0&'!)-&E(*L!,99-1,82q!

• 6(E(.19! ,*)! 9-1915(! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! 5#&',$.(! 01-!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!S&'2&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!5(8'1-!'2,'!&*8.#)(5W!

o T('21)5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!01-!)(0&*&*7!,*)!%1*&'1-&*7!$(*(0&'5q!

o V%9.(%(*','&1*!,*)!E,.&),'&1*!(E&)(*8(!0-1%!-(,.!8,5(5!,&%&*7!'1!

,55(55!&'5!#'&.&':!,*)!#5(0#.*(55q!

• 3(81%%(*)!0#-'2(-!S1-K!$,5()!1*!'2(!1#'81%(5!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!

,$N 4;215)H81);2(!1;!M2;R0'3A'!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!)(E(.19()!0-1%!'2&5!-(5(,-82!,59&-()!'1!$(!'2(!

,99-19-&,'(! %('21)! '1! ^#5'&0:;! )-&E(! ,*)! 81*'-1.! 82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(5! $,5()! 1*!

$(*(0&'5A!

B2(!%,&*!81*'-&$#'&1*!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!&5! &*!'(-%5!10!9-(5(*'&*7!,!%('21)1.17:!

01-! '2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! ,*)! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,! 9-18(55! '2,'! (%$-,8(5! ,! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! $:! &*'(7-,'&*7! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(5;!

81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! %('21)5;! K*1S.()7(! 0.1S! )1S*! ,*)! 52,-&*7A! B2(!

9-18(55!018#5(5!1*!%,*,7&*7!5',K(21.)(-5L!(`9(8','&1*5!'2-1#721#'!'2(!82,*7(!

.&0(8:8.(;!S2(*!9.,**&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(5A!

B2(!,#'21-!)(%1*5'-,'(5!21S!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!8,*!$(!,99.&()!&*!,!2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-1^(8'!)(E(.19%(*'!8:8.(!$:!)(E(.19&*7!,!9-18(55!'2,'!2,5!$((*!

Page 22: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! F!

&*01-%()!$:!,*)!&%9.(%(*'()!&*!9-,8'&8(!'2-1#72!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!81*5#.','&1*!

S&'2!&*)#5'-:!9-,8'&'&1*(-5A!!

B2(! -(5#.'! &5! ,! 81..,$1-,'&E(! 9-18(55! '2,'! 8,*! 2(.9! '215(! &*E1.E()! &*! )&00(-(*'!

-1.(5! '1! &)(*'&0:! ,*)!%,*,7(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! )&5$(*(0&'5! '2-1#721#'! '2(! .&0(! 10! ,!

9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8';!)(59&'(!'2(!.&K(.&211)!10!82,*7(5!1E(-!'&%(!&*!&'5!(`'(-*,.!

1-!&*'(-*,.!(*E&-1*%(*'5A!

,$T J810)2'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!

V*! '2(! 81#-5(! 10! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! 9-1915,.! '2(! 2''3! S,5!

&)(*'&0&()! ,5! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '2(! 9-(E&1#5! 5(8'&1*A! B2(! 1#'.&*(! %('21)1.17:! '2,'!

S1#.)! 5((K! ,*5S(-5! '1! '2(! -(5(,-82! 4#(5'&1*! ,*)! S1#.)! 2(.9! '1! %(('! '2(!

-(5(,-82!1$^(8'&E(5!S,5!'2(*!)(E(.19()!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!/&7#-(!=A!<!2&72!.(E(.!10!

,8'&E&'&(5! -(4#&-()! ,881-)&*7! '1! '2(! ,#'21-! '1! 5#88(550#..:! #*)(-',K(! '2&5!

-(5(,-82!521S&*7!21S!'2(!K*1S.()7(!,84#&-()!0-1%!5',7(!'1!5',7(!0.1S5!'2-1#72!

&*'1!-(,82&*7!,!-(5(,-82!81*8.#5&1*A!

!

X)A85'!*c!&#'!;810)2'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!

!B2(! -(.(E,*'! .&'(-,'#-(! S,5! &)(*'&0&()! ,*)! &*8.#)()! -(E&(S5! &*'1! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! &'5! 5,'(..&'(! 5#$^(8'5! 5#82! ,5! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)!

9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*';! 5',K(21.)(-! %,*,7(%(*';! (E,.#,'&1*! '(82*&4#(5! ('8A!

!"#$%&'(&)*%#$+)

•  !"#$%&#'%$()$*"$+(,%-.$//(•  0#$$%"12(3%-',(4"/.'//"-1/(•  5&67)76(8-%#9-:"-(

74$1#"9;()$/$&%.<(=$$4( >$*$:-,(?'#:"1$()$/$&%.<(@$#<-4-:-2;(

)$/$&%.<(@$#<-4-:-2".&:(A%&B$+-%C(

D$1$E"#/()$&:"/&#"-1(,%-.$//(4$*$:-,B$1#((( F$/#(G(7B,:$B$1#&#"-1((( A"14"12/(&14(H&:"4&#"-1(

6-1.:'/"-1/(

Page 23: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>!

H.(%(*',-:! )&58#55&1*5! S&'2! 2(,.'28,-(! 9-,8'&'&1*(-5! ,*)! -(5(,-82(-5! &*! '2(!

5#$^(8'!,-(,!,5!S(..!'2(!,#'21-L5!9(-51*,.!(`9(-&(*8(5!S(-(!,.51!&*'(7-,'()!,*)!

81*5&)(-()! &*! '2&5! 1#'.&*(A! V*0.#(*'&,.! '1! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)1.17:! S,5! '2(! 9.,8(%(*'! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2&*! '2(! [(,.'2! ,*)! Q,-(!

V*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 3(5(,-82! ,*)! V**1E,'&1*! I[,QV3VQJ! S2(-(! '2(! -(5(,-82! 9-1^(8'!

'2(%()!c-322+')$#A!7&E$($+#O!U.?$#A!$#!Q&./)6E.'&!<!S,5!$(&*7!&*E(5'&7,'()A!B2(!

S&)(-! [,QV3VQ! -(5(,-82! 9-1^(8'! &*E(5'&7,'()! '2(! 81%9.(`! *,'#-(! 10! )(8&5&1*!

%,K&*7!&*!2(,.'28,-(!,5!'2(!*#%$(-!10!E,-&,$.(5!,-(!2&72!,*)!'2(!9.,:(-5!&*!'2(!

)(8&5&1*! ,-(! *#%(-1#5A! B2(-(! S(-(! 5(E(-,.! 9-1^(8'5! '2,'! 81*'-&$#'()! '1! '2(!

$(''(-!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2,'!&55#(;!5#82!,5!I&J!,!5'#):!.11K&*7!,'!'2(!S,:!)&00(-(*'!

5',K(21.)(-5!81..,$1-,'(!S&'2&*!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!,*)!21S!'2(:!9(-8(&E(!cE,.#(L;!I&&J!

,*!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!&*'1!c(E&)(*8(!$,5()!)(5&7*L;!I&&&J!,!5'#):!&*!.(,*!5(-E&8(!)(.&E(-:!

,*)! I&EJ! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! 10! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55!

)(E(.19()!$:!'2(!,#'21-!,*)!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!)(',&.!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5A!

!B2(!,#'21-L5!&*E1.E(%(*'!S&'2!'2(!S&)(-![,QV3VQ!-(5(,-82!9-1^(8'!(*,$.()!'2(!

&*'(-,8'&1*!S&'2!'2(!9-1^(8'L5!5'((-&*7!7-1#9A!B2(!5'((-&*7!7-1#9!S,5!81*5'&'#'()!

$:! 9-,8'&'&1*(-5! 0-1%! '2(! 2(,.'28,-(! ,*)! 1'2(-! 5(8'1-5! ,5! S(..! ,5! .(,)&*7!

,8,)(%&85!S&'2&*! '2(! "8211.! 10! C#&.'! H*E&-1*%(*'! ,'! '2(!P*&E(-5&':! 10! ",.01-)A!

B2,'! 7-1#9!(E1.E()! '1! '2(!C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9-1^(8'! c<)E&51-:!7-1#9L;! ,5! &'! &5!

(`9.,&*()!.,'(-!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5!I&*!82,9'(-!NJA!

B2(!0)1'5/185'!5'<)'R![5;9'((!,*)!'2(!3)(98(();2(!S&'2!'2(![,QV3VQ!5'((-&*7!

7-1#9!%(%$(-5! &)(*'&0&()!'2(!2&5'1-&8,.!)(E(.19%(*'!10!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*;! &'5!

.&*K5!S&'2!1'2(-!%,*,7(%(*'!)&58&9.&*(5!,5!S(..!,5!&'5!-(.(E,*8(!,*)!&%91-',*8(!

S2(*! )(E(.19&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-&*7! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A! ! B2&5!S,5! '2(! 0&-5'!

5'(9! &*'1!)(E(.19&*7!,*)!9-1915&*7!,!2&72! .(E(.!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55A! V*!

,))&'&1*! '1! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,! *#%$(-! 10! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! S&'2&*! '2(! Pd!

2(,.'28,-(! 5(8'1-! S(-(! 81*)#8'()! ,&%&*7! '1! 0#-'2(-! &*01-%! '2(! 3'<'0;[@'21!

,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'.:! 1'(1! /23! </0)3/1'! &'5! ,99.&8,$&.&':A! B2(! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(!

.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S;! '2(!,-7#%(*'5!)&58#55()!S&'2!,8,)(%&8!,*)! &*)#5'-:!(`9(-'5!

,*)!'2(!0&*)&*75! 0-1%!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S1#.)!81*'-&$#'(!'1!'2(!,#'21-!-(,82&*7!

'2(!9;2908();2!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!,5!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5A!

Page 24: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??!

B2(! )(',&.()! -(5(,-82! %('21)1.17:! &*! 82,9'(-! @! 9-1E&)(5! ,! 8.(,-! ,*)!

81%9-(2(*5&E(!^#5'&0&8,'&1*!10!'2(!%('21)1.17&8,.!821&8(5!%,)(!$:!'2(!,#'21-!&*!

#*)(-',K&*7!,*)!81%9.('&*7!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!B2(!E,.&)&':!10!'2(!9-18(55!)(E(.19()!

,*)! '2(! %('21)1.17:! S1#.)! $(! (`,%&*()! '2-1#72! '2(! )&00(-(*'! -(5(,-82!

5'-,'(7&(5!,)19'()A!B2(!821&8(!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S,5!$,5()!1*!'2(&-!-(.(E,*8(!

'1! '2(! -(5(,-82! ,&%5! ,*)! 1$^(8'&E(5! ,*)! '2(&-! -(59(8'&E(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5!

915&'&1*&*7!S&'2&*!'2(!Pd!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!,5!(`9.,&*()!&*!82,9'(-!NA!!

B2(!%,K&*7!10!'2(!'2(5&5!,*)!&'5!&*'(-9-(','&1*!,&%5!'1!)(%1*5'-,'(!'2(!,#'21-L5!

#*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! ,-(,;! '2(! ,8,)(%&8! -&71#-! ,*)! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'!

5',7(5!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55A!!

,$O !=1589185'!;7!1#'!1#'()(!

B2&5!'2(5&5!&5!1-7,*&5()!&*!R!82,9'(-5!,*)!,99(*)&8(5!,5!5#%%,-&5()!$(.1SW!

B2(! 7)5(1! 9#/[1'5! 9-(5(*'5! ,! 7(*(-,.! &*'-1)#8'&1*;! 1#'.&*&*7! '2(! *(()! 01-! '2(!

-(5(,-82! 9-1^(8';! &'5! -(.(E,*8(! ,*)! 1-&7&*,.&':! 81*'-&$#'&1*A! V'! 0-,%(5! '2(!%,&*!

,&%!,*)!1$^(8'&E(5!,*)!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*5A!B2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!(%9.1:()!

&*!'2(!-(5(,-82!&5!,.51!1#'.&*()A!!

4#/[1'5!1R;!)(',&.5!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!0&*)&*75A!V'!5',-'5!S&'2!,*!1E(-E&(S!10!

)&58&9.&*(5! '2,'! ,-(! 8.15(.:! -(.,'()! S&'2! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*';!

,*)! 2,E(! '1! $(! 8,-(0#..:! 81*5&)(-()! )#-&*7! '2(! 9-18(55! )(E(.19%(*'A!

"#$5(4#(*'.:!&*'-1)#8(5!'2(!81*8(9'!10!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'A!V'!

71(5!0#-'2(-!&*'1!1#'.&*&*7!'2(!K(:!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82(5!#5()!'1!),'(A!

B2&5!82,9'(-!,.51!9-(5(*'5!,!5:*'2(5&5!10!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81%9,-(5!'2(!

(`&5'&*7!,99-1,82(5A!V'!9-1E&)(5!$,8K7-1#*)!&*01-%,'&1*!10!'2(!%,&*!&*E(5'%(*'!

,99-,&5,.! ,*)! 9-18#-(%(*'! 9-18(55(5! #5()! &*! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

)(E(.19%(*'A!B2(!0&-5'!81*8(9'#,.!9-1915()!9-18(55!,*)!&'5!$(*(0&'5!81*'-1..&*7!

5'-#8'#-(!,*)!92,5(5!,-(!0&*,..:!&*'-1)#8()A!!

4#/[1'5!1#5''!)(58-&$(5!&*!)(',&.!'2(!-(5(,-82!92&.15192:;!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7:!,*)!

-(5(,-82! %('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! (%9.1:()! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! -(5(,-82A! <*!

Page 25: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!G*(!\!V*'-1)#8'&1*!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=!

1E(-E&(S! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! %('21)5! #5()! '1! 81..(8'! ,*)! E,.&),'(! ),',! &5! ,.51!

&*8.#)()!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-A!

4#/[1'5! 7;85! 81*',&*5! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! -,'&1*,.(;! ,8'&E&':! ,*)! %,&*! 1#'9#'5A!

+-(5(*'5! '2(! -1.(! 10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! S1-K52195! ,*)! 81*8.#)(5! S&'2!

)&58#55&1*! $,5()! 1*! 0&*)&*75! ,84#&-()! '2-1#721#'! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*A!!

4#/[1'5!7)<'!)(58-&$(5!'2(!0&*,.!,-'(0,8'!,5!'2(!-(5#.'!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!)(',&.()!&*!

'2&5!'2(5&5q!'2(!,#'21-!)(58-&$(5!,*)!)&58#55(5!21S!'2(!(%(-7()!9-18(55!92,5(5!

,-(!81*5'-#8'();!,*)!'2(!K(:!9-18(55!5'(95!S&'2&*!(,82!92,5(A!B2(!K(:!'11.5!,*)!

'(82*&4#(5! '2,'! ,-(!)(9.1:()! &*! '2(!9-18(55! 92,5(5;! ,5! '2(:!2,E(!$((*! -(0&*()!

01..1S&*7! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '2(! 0&(.)! -(5(,-82! 1#'81%(5! ,-(! 9-(5(*'()A! B2(!

&*'(-9-(','&1*!10!'2(!*(S!K*1S.()7(!,84#&-()!$:!'2(!,#'21-!&5!,.51!9-(5(*'()!&*!

'(-%5!10! '2(!9,-,)&7%! 52&0'! *(()();! '2(!9-18(55! &*'(7-,'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5! ,*)! '2(!

K(:!,59(8'5!81*5&)(-()A!!

4#/[1'5! ()\! 9-(5(*'5! '2(! 0&*,.! 81*8.#5&1*5! 1*! '2(! -(5(,-82! 1*! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! &'! 5#%%,-&5(5! '2(!%,&*! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S!,*)! '2(!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195!#*)(-',K(*!

$:!'2(!,#'21-A!B2(!82,9'(-!)&58#55(5!'2(!0#.0&.%(*'!10!'2(!1$^(8'&E(5!,*)!-(5(,-82!

4#(5'&1*5! '2,'! 5('! ,'! '2(! $(7&**&*7! 10! '2&5! 4#(5'A! /&*,..:! &'! 2&72.&72'5! '2(!%,&*!

1#'81%(5!,*)!-(81%%(*),'&1*5!01-!0#'#-(!-(5(,-82!*(()()!&*!'2(!0&(.)A!!

B2(! /[['23)9'(!,'',82()!9-1E&)(!)(',&.()! &*01-%,'&1*!-(.,'()!'1! '2(!-(5(,-82A!

B2(:! ,-(! 5(8'&1*()! &*! 5&`! 9,-'5! '1! )(',&.! 0&*)&*75! ,*)! %('21)5! 10! '2(! C(3(,.!

-(5(,-82! 9-1^(8'! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '2&5! '2(5&5A! B2(! 5&`! ,99(*)&8(5! 5(8'&1*5! ,-(! I&J!

'(82*&4#(5! '2,'!(%$-,8(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*q! I&&J! 8,5(!5'#)&(5!),',q! I&&&J!C(3(,.!

9-18(55! '(%9.,'(5q! I&EJ! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! )(.&E(-,$.(5! 0.1S82,-'q! IEJ! C(3(,.!

&*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:! 9.,'01-%q! ,*)! IE&J! 9#$.&8,'&1*5! ,*)! ,8'&E&':! -(.,'()! '1!

'2&5!-(5(,-82A!B2&5!%,'(-&,.!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2(!,99(*)&8(5;!,5!&'5!&*8.#5&1*!'1!'2(!

%,&*!'(`'!10!'2(!'2(5&5!S1#.)!2,E(!)&5-#9'()!'2(!0.1S!10!&*01-%,'&1*A!

!

Page 26: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@!

* !4#/[1'5!&R;!W!>'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!@/2/A'@'21!

/!0)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!/23!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!@;3'0!!

V*! '2&5! 82,9'(-! '2(! ,#'21-! )(',&.5! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 0&*)&*75A! B2(! .&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S!5',-'5!S&'2!,*!1E(-E&(S!10!)&58&9.&*(5!'2,'!,-(!8.15(.:!-(.,'()!S&'2!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*';! ,*)! 2,E(! '1! $(! 8,-(0#..:! 81*5&)(-()! )#-&*7! '2(!

9-18(55! )(E(.19%(*'A! "#$5(4#(*'.:! &*'-1)#8(5! '2(! 81*8(9'! 10! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

,*)! %,*,7(%(*'A! V'! 71(5! 0#-'2(-! &*'1! 1#'.&*&*7! '2(! K(:! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

,99-1,82(5! #5()! '1! ),'(A! B2&5! 82,9'(-! ,.51! 9-(5(*'5! ,! 5:*'2(5&5! 10! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S!,*)!81%9,-(5!'2(!(`&5'&*7!,99-1,82(5A!V'!9-1E&)(5!$,8K7-1#*)!&*01-%,'&1*!

10!'2(!%,&*!&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!,*)!9-18#-(%(*'!9-18(55(5!#5()!&*!Pd!2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'A!B2(!,#'21-!&*'-1)#8(5!2(-(!'2(!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!,*)!

92,5(5! ,5! '2(5(! 2,E(! $((*! &*01-%()! $:! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 81*)#8'()! ,*)!

,)E&51-:!7-1#9!)&58#55&1*5A!

*$, 6215;3891);2!

"&*8(! ?FD>;! '2(-(! &5! ,! E,5'! .&'(-,'#-(! &*! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! $(&*7! ,99.&()! '1!

)&00(-(*'! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5A! /1-! '2&5! -(,51*;! '2(! ,&%! 10! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S!S,5!'1!&)(*'&0:!,*)!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!1*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*';!,5!,*!,''(%9'!'1! &*E(5'&7,'(!'2(!)&00(-(*'!9(-59(8'&E(5!'1!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! &)(*'&0:! '2(! %,&*! 81*5&)(-,'&1*5! S2(*! )(E(.19&*7! ,!

9-18(55!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*A!!

V*! ,))&'&1*! ,*)! 9-&1-! '1! 9-(5(*'&*7! S2,'! &5! )(58-&$()! ,$1E(! '2(! -(.,'&1*5! 10!

$(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! S&'2! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*';! 82,*7(!

%,*,7(%(*';!9(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!%(,5#-(%(*';! ,*)! 0&*,..:! '2(! -1.(!

,*)!&%91-',*8(!10!5',K(21.)(-!&*E1.E(%(*'!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!,-(!-(E&(S()A!!

Page 27: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?N!

*$* "5;A5/@@'D![5;Q'91!!/23!;['5/1);2(!@/2/A'@'21!

B2(! Pd! 71E(-*%(*'! )(0&*(5! 9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,5! '2(! 811-)&*,'()!

%,*,7(%(*'! 10! ,! 91-'01.&1! 10! 9-1^(8'5! '2,'! 82,*7(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1! ,82&(E(!

$(*(0&'5!'2,'!,-(!01-!5'-,'(7&8!&%91-',*8(!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!<*1'2(-!5&%9.(!)(0&*&'&1*!

10!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'!&5!'2(!1-82(5'-,'&1*!10!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!82,*7(!I3(&55!

('!,.A;!=>>RJ!,*)!2(!81*5&)(-5!,!9-17-,%%(!,5!,!$(*(0&8&,.!%&`!10!9-1^(8'5! '2,'!

)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5!I3(&55;!=>>>JA!!

+-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'!&5!,!S&)(.:!#5()!,99-1,82!01-!$-&*7&*7!,$1#'!9.,**()!

82,*7(! I+(..(7-&*(..&! ('! ,.A;! =>>MJA! B2(! ,99-1,82! &5! #5()! '1! &%9.(%(*'! 5'-,'(7:!

I+,-'&*7'1*;! =>>>;! +(..(7-&*(..&! ,*)! C1S%,*;! ?FFNJ! '1! )(E(.19! ,*)! %,&*',&*!

*(S! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! I+(..(7-&*(..&;! ?FFMJ;! '1!%,*,7(! 81%9.(`! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5!

&%9.(%(*','&1*5! I3&$$(-5;! =>>=J! ,*)! %,*:! 1'2(-! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(5A! V*! ?FF?;!

/(-*5!100(-()!,!)(0&*&'&1*!10!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'!8(*'-()!1*! '2(!*1'&1*!10!

'2(!9-17-,%%(!,5!,!811-)&*,'&*7!%(82,*&5%!01-!9-1^(8'5!'2,'!(*,$.()!1'2(-S&5(!

#*-(,.&5,$.(!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!(`'-,8'()!I/(-*5;!?FF?JA!

V*! '2&5! '2(5&5! '2(! '(-%5! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! ,-(! #5()! &*'(-82,*7(,$.:;!

,.'21#72!&'!&5!-(817*&5()!'2,'!9-1^(8'!-(9-(5(*'5!'2(!1E(-,..!5819(!10!S1-K!$(&*7!

9(-01-%()!'1!81%9.('(!,!59(8&0&8!^1$;!':9&8,..:!#*)(-!,!'(%91-,-:!(*)(,E1#-!,*)!

'1! 8-(,'(! ,! #*&4#(! 9-1)#8'! 1-! 5(-E&8(! I+2&..&95;! =>>@Jq! S2&.5'! 9-17-,%%(! &5!

#*)(-5'11)! ,5! ,! 91-'01.&1! 10! 9-1^(8'5! 5(.(8'();! 9.,**()! ,*)! %,*,7()! &*! ,!

811-)&*,'()!S,:!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!

<881-)&*7! '1! 3(&55! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! $(*(0&'! %,*,7(%(*'! &5! ,! 9-18(55! 01-! '2(!

19'&%&5,'&1*!1-!%,`&%&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5!0-1%!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(5A!B2(!9-18(55!

&*E1.E(5! )(0&*&*7;! ,7-((&*7;!%(,5#-&*7! ,*)! -(91-'&*7! 1*! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5A!

B2(! -(.,'&1*52&9! $('S((*! 9-1^(8'5! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! $(*(0&'! %,*,7(%(*'! &5!

0-(4#(*'.:!4#&'(!81%9.(`A!3(&55!('!,.A!I=>>RJ!)(58-&$(!'2,'W!

• +-1^(8'5!)1!*1'!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5;!$#'!8-(,'(!)(.&E(-,$.(5q!

Page 28: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?O!

• +-17-,%%(5! '2(%5(.E(5! -,-(.:! )(.&E(-! $(*(0&'5! )&-(8'.:;! $#'! $:! 81%$&*&*7!

9-1^(8'5!,*)!'2(&-!)(.&E(-,$.(5!'2(:!8-(,'(!'2(!8,9,$&.&'&(5!'2,'!S&..!(*,$.(!'2(!

)(5&-()!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!,82&(E()q!

• B2(! $(*(0&'! %,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55(5! (*5#-(! '2,'! '2(! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! 8-(,'()! $:!

9-17-,%%(5!,-(!#5()!'1!)(.&E(-!'2(!,*'&8&9,'()!$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5!

+-17-,%%(;!9-1^(8'!,*)!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!,-(!(55(*'&,.!'(82*&4#(5!'1!5#991-'!

,*)! )(.&E(-! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! 82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(5! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJ! ,5! /&7#-(! @!

&..#5'-,'(5A!

B2(! #.'&%,'(! 5#88(55! 01-! (,82! 9-17-,%%(! 521#.)! $(! %(,5#-()! &*! '(-%5! 10!

S2('2(-!1-!*1'!&'!)(.&E(-5!'2(!9.,**()!$(*(0&'5A!

!

X)A85'!-c!>'2'7)1D!9#/2A'D!/23![5;A5/@@'!/23![5;Q'91!@/2/A'@'21!^:')((!'1!/0!D!*++T_!

3(&55!('!,.!I=>>RJ!(`9.,&*!'2,'!,!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!8:8.(!&5!&*&'&,'()!'2-1#72!

'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,!9-17-,%%(A!B2(!S,:!'2,'!c9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'!'(,%5L!

8,*!&)(*'&0:!,*)!&*&'&,'(!9-1^(8'5!S&..!)(.&E(-!'2(!-(4#&-()!1#'81%(5A!B2(!9-1^(8'5!

'2(*! 8-(,'(! )(.&E(-,$.(5A! "#$5(4#(*'.:! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! 8-(,'(5! ,! 8,9,$&.&':!

S&'2&*!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!'2,'!81%$&*(5!'2(5(!)(.&E(-,$.(5A!B2(*!'2(!$#5&*(55!#5(5!

'2(! *(S! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! ,*)! '2(-(01-(! )(.&E(-5! '2(! ,5518&,'()! $(*(0&'5! I/&7#-(! NJA!

B2(!.17&8!01..1S()!&*!'2,'!0&7#-(!&5W!!

!"#"$%&'()*#*+","#&(

!"#$"%&&'()%*%$'&'*+((

,-%*$'()%*%$'&'*+((

!"#.'/+()%*%$'&'*+(

Page 29: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?R!

• C(*(0&'5!,-(!%(,5#-()!,*)!S2(-(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!*1! .1*7(-!(`9(8'()!

1-! -()#8();! 01-! ,*:! -(,51*;! '2(! 9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'! '(,%! -(91-'5! '2(!

&55#(q!

• <5!$(*(0&'5!,-(!,8'#,..:!,82&(E()! '2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!82,*7(5A!T(,5#-(%(*'!10!

'2(5(! &%9-1E(%(*'5! .(,)5! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! '1! ,! -(E&5()! 5'-,'(7:! ,*)! '2(!

81*'&*#,'&1*!10!'2(!8:8.(q!

• B2(! &**(-! 8:8.(! 521S5! 21S! '2(! 9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'! '(,%! 5',-'5! S&'2!

$(*(0&'! )(0&*&'&1*;! %1E(5! 1*'1! '-,8K&*7! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,5! '2(! '(,%! %1E(!

'1S,-)5!$(*(0&'!)(.&E(-:!,*)!(*)5!(,82!8:8.(!,55(55&*7!'2(!$(*(0&'5!,8'#,..:!

)(.&E(-()A!

!

X)A85'!Pc!.)A#L0'<'0!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21![5;9'((!@;3'0!^:')((!'1!/0$D!*++T_!

B2(-(! &5! ,.51! 8.15(! .&*K! $('S((*! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! ,! 9-17-,%%(L5! 9-1^(8'! 91-'01.&1!

I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! B2(! $(*(0&'5! 10! (,82! 9-1^(8'! *(()! '1! $(! ,.&7*()! S&'2! '2(!

5'-,'(7&8! 8-&'(-&,! 01-! (E,.#,'&*7! '2(! S21.(! 91-'01.&1A! C(*(0&'5! 521#.)! $(! ,! K(:!

)(8&5&1*! (*,$.(-! #5()! '1! )(8&)(! S2('2(-! 1-! *1'! '1! &*E(5'! &*! ,! 9-1^(8'! 1-!

9-17-,%%(!,5!9,-'! 10! '2(!91-'01.&1! IU.:**(;! =>>MJA! +,--! ,*)!_&..&,%5! &*!=>>M!

915&'&1*!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,5!'2(!%('21)!'2,'!us6&/2(!)+!&#(3'&!)6.)!)6&!C&()!

2+'),+/$+!+,!2'+V&E)(!)+!D&&)!)6&!()'.)&A$E!+CV&E)$%&(!+,!)6&!C3($#&((!E.#!C&!(&/&E)&0!

!"#$%#&&'%"$%#()*&+,$-'&

.#-#/%'&%"$*0)-(&

.#-#/%'&1#$,)'$23-&

1#4)#5&'%"$%#(6&

!$+%7"#&,#$"-)-(&

8#$'7"#&/-$-*)$,&$-9&-3-:/-$-*)$,&;#-#/%'&

<=+,#=#-%&-#5&*$+$;),)2#'&>?"3=&+"3("$==#&37%*3=#'@&

!"#$%#&+"3A#*%&9#,)4#"$;,#'&

.#-#/%'&9#/-)23-&

.#-#/%'&$''#''=#-%&

B7$-2?6&'%"$%#(6&

B7$-2?6&CD<'&

E#,#*%&+"3("$==#'&

E#,#*%&+"3A#*%'&

Page 30: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?M!

.#0!D.$#).$#&09! -)'3E)3'&0!C&#&,$)(!D.#.A&D&#)! $(! )63(!.!%$)./!#.%$A.)$+#./!.$0!

+#!)6&!V+3'#&*!)+!.E6$&%$#A!()'.)&A$E!+CV&E)$%&(X9!

Q11K(\6,E&(5;! =>>=! &*!]17(5'(;! =>>R! .&*K! 9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! 19(-,'&1*5!

%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! 2&72.&72'! '2(! *(()! '2,'! '2(5(! 'S1! )&58&9.&*(5! *(()! c)+! @+'?!

)+A&)6&'! )+! &#(3'&! )6.)! )6&! +'A.#$(.)$+#! '&E&$%&(! )6&! C&#&,$)(! )6.)! .'&! &N2&E)&0!

,'+D!.#*!2'+V&E)LA!

<88(9'&*7! '2,'! 19(-,'&1*5! %,*,7(%(*'! &5! -(591*5&$.(! 01-! )(.&E(-&*7! $(*(0&'5!

0-1%! 9-1^(8'! )(.&E(-,$.(5;! &'! &5! &%91-',*'! 01-! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(-5! '1! (*5#-(! '2,'!

19(-,'&1*5! %,*,7(%(*'! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,-(! (*7,7()! ,*)! 52,-(! '2(! 81%%1*!

#*)(-5',*)&*7! I]17(5'(! ,*)!_,.K(-;! =>>OJA! B2(:! ,-(! -(591*5&$.(! 01-! 9.,**&*7!

,*)!%,*,7&*7!'2(!S1-K!-(4#&-()!)(-&E&*7!'2(!,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5! 0-1%!9-1^(8'!

)(.&E(-,$.(5!I]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>OJA!+-1^(8'!%,*,7(-5!521#.)!&)(*'&0:!'2,'!

9-1^(8'!S1-K!&*E1.E(5!,!.,-7(-!81%%#*&':!10!5',K(21.)(-5!1E(-!,!.1*7(-!9(-&1)!10!

'&%(q!S(..!,0'(-!'2(!9-1^(8'!2,5!$((*!81%9.('()!IQ11K(\6,E&(5;!=>>=JA!GUQ!,.51!

5#991-'5!'2,'!9-17-,%%(!,*)!9-1^(8'!'(,%5!$(&*7!&*E1.E()!&*!9-1^(8'5!'1!)(.&E(-!

$#5&*(55! 82,*7(;! ,*)! $#5&*(55! #5(-5! ,*)! %,*,7(-5! $(&*7! -(591*5&$.(! 01-!

%,*,7&*7!,*)!-(,.&5&*7!$(*(0&'5!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!Q11K(\6,E&(5!I=>>=J!$(.&(E(5!'2,'!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!*(()5! '1!$(! &*'(7-,'()! &*'1! (`&5'&*7!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!

9-,8'&8(5!-,'2(-!'2,*!5&%9.:!u$1.'()!1*vA!_,-)!('!,.!I=>>RJ!)(58-&$(!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!&5!,!%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55!,99.&8,$.(!'1!,!S&)(!-,*7(!10!&*E(5'%(*'5!

'2,'!&5!,$.(!'1!$(!&*'(7-,'()!&*'1!%,*,7(%(*'!9-,8'&8(5!c'2-1#721#'!'2(!$#5&*(55!

82,*7(! .&0(8:8.(\! 0-1%!5'-,'(7&8!$#5&*(55!9.,**&*7! '2-1#72! '1!(E(*'#,.!)&5915,.!

10!,!'2(!5(-E&8(!1-!,55('L!IGUQ;!=>>@!&*!]17(5'(;!=>>RJA!_2&82!S2(*!811-)&*,'()!

S&'2! 1'2(-! $#5&*(55!%,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55(5! 9-1E&)(5! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*!S&'2! '2(!

1991-'#*&':! '1! '-,*501-%! &'5(.0! &*'1! ,! 2&72! 9(-01-%,*8(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! I"&%1*;!

=>>@!&*!]17(5'(!=>>RJA!

3(&55! I=>>>J! 5','(5! '2,'! $(*(0&'5! 2,E(! *1-%,..:! ,*! &*)&-(8'! -(.,'&1*52&9! S&'2!

(,82!9-1^(8'A! B2(!$(*(0&'5! 10! (,82!9-1^(8'! 8,*!1*.:! $(!)(-&E()!S2(*! 81%$&*()!

S&'2!'2(!1#'81%(!10!1'2(-!9-1^(8'5!I3(&55;!=>>>JA!<881-)&*7!'1!'2(!5,%(!,#'21-!

9-1^(8'5!8,*!$(!8.,55&0&()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(&-!,$&.&':!'1!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5!,5!01..1S5W!

Page 31: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?D!

• 6&-(8'W!9-1^(8'5!S&'2!)&-(8'!$(*(0&'5q!

• H*,$.&*7W! 9-1^(8'5! '2,'! )(.&E(-! *1! )&-(8'! $(*(0&'! $#'! S2&82! ,-(! E&',.! '1! '2(!

)(.&E(-:!10!,!S21.(!-,*7(!10!$(*(0&'5!0-1%!1'2(-!9-1^(8'5q!

• +,55(*7(-W!+-1^(8'5!'2,'!8,*!1*.:!,))!$(*(0&'5!(`9(8'()!0-1%!1'2(-!9-1^(8'5q!

• ":*(-7&5'&8W! ,! 7-1#9! 10! 9-1^(8'5! (,82! 10! S2&82! %,K(5! *1! I1-! 1*.:! ,! 5%,..J!

81*'-&$#'&1*!#*.(55!81%$&*()!&*'1!,!9-17-,%%(A!

B2(! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! 9-1^(8'! 5#88(55! 8-&'(-&,! -(.,'()! '1! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5! &5!

)(9(*)(*'! 1*! '2(! 8.(,-! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! $1'2! ',*7&$.(! ,*)!

&*',*7&$.(! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5;! S&'2! ,*! &*8-(,5&*7! *(()! '1! 018#5! #91*! &*',*7&$.(!

1#'81%(5;! I]17(5'(! ,*)! _,.K(-;! =>>OJA! U,-8&,\<:#51;! =>>@! &*! ]17(5'(! ,*)!

_,.K(-;!=>>O!,.51!,-7#(5!'2,'W!

• V*',*7&$.(5!,-(!0#*),%(*',.!51#-8(5!10!81%9('&'&E(!,)E,*',7(5!'2,'!%#5'!$(!

&)(*'&0&();! %(,5#-()! ,*)! 81*'-1..()! &*! 1-)(-! '1! (*5#-(! '2(! (00&8&(*'!

%,*,7(%(*'!10!81-91-,'&1*5q!

• B2(-(! &5!,!81*5&5'(*'!-(.,'&1*52&9!$('S((*!%15'! &*',*7&$.(! &*E(5'%(*'5!,*)!

5#$5(4#(*'!(,-*&*75!,*)!E,.#(!8-(,'&1*!&*!$#5&*(55!81-91-,'&1*5q!

• B2(-(! &5! ,! .,8K! 10! -(.(E,*'! ,*)! -(.&,$.(! &*01-%,'&1*! 1*! '2(! &*',*7&$.(!

)('(-%&*,*'5! 10! '2(! E,.#(! 10! 81%9,*&(5! '2,'! ,8'#,..:! -(5#.'5! &*! 5&7*&0&8,*'!

),%,7(5!01-!$#5&*(55!0&-%5!,*)!'2(&-!5',K(21.)(-5q!

• V*',*7&$.(5!,-(!*1S,),:5!'2(!%,&*!)-&E(-5!10!7-1S'2!,*)!81%9('&'&E(*(55!&*!

1#-! 518&('&(5! ,*)! '2(&-! %(,5#-(%(*'! &5! (55(*'&,.! 01-! '2(! )(5&7*! ,*)!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!9#$.&8!91.&8&(5A!

*$- 4#/2A'!@/2/A'@'21!

B21-9! I?FFDJ! 5#%%,-&5(5! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,5! '2(! 21.&5'&8! ,*)! 9-1,8'&E(!

,99-1,82! '1! %,*,7&*7! '2(! '-,*5&'&1*! 0-1%! 8#--(*'! '1! )(5&-()! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

5','(;! 018#5&*7!59(8&0&8,..:!1*! '2(!8-&'&8,.!2#%,*!1-! c510'L! (.(%(*'5!10! 82,*7(A! V'!

&*8.#)(5! ,8'&E&'&(5! 5#82! ,5! 8#.'#-(! 82,*7(! IE,.#(5;! $(.&(05! ,*)! ,''&'#)(5J;!

)(E(.19&*7! -(S,-)! 5:5'(%5! I%(,5#-(5! ,*)! ,99-19-&,'(! &*8(*'&E(5J;!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! )(5&7*;! 5',K(21.)(-! %,*,7(%(*';! 2#%,*! -(51#-8(! 91.&8&(5! ,*)!

Page 32: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?F!

9-18()#-(5;! (`(8#'&E(! 81,82&*7;! 82,*7(! .(,)(-52&9! '-,&*&*7;! '(,%! $#&.)&*7! ,*)!

81%%#*&8,'&1*! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! (`(8#'&1*A! 3(&55! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! )(0&*(! 82,*7(!

%,*,7(%(*'! 5&%9.:! ,5! '2(!%,*,7(%(*'! 10! 82,*7(! $#'! &'! )&5'&*7#&52(5! &*! 'S1!

.(E(.5W!

• T&8-1!.(E(.;!S2(-(!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!&*E1.E(5!,!5('!10!'(82*&4#(5!#5()!'1!

&%9.,*'!*(S!'(82*1.17:!,*)!9-18(55(5q!

• T,8-1! .(E(.;! S2(-(! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*'! 81*',&*5! &)(,5! ,$1#'! S2,'!

&*'(-E(*'&1*5! '1! %,K(;! %,K&*7! '2(%! ,*)! '2(*! -(E&(S&*7! 21S! '2(5(! ,-(!

S1-K&*7A!

B21-9!I?FFDJ!5','(5!'2,'!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!S&..!1*.:!-(,.&5(!$(*(0&'5!'2-1#72!82,*7(;!

,*)!(4#,..:;!82,*7(!S&..!1*.:!$(!5#5',&*()!&0!$(*(0&'5!,-(!-(,.&5()!1-!c5((*!'1!$(!

-(,.&5()LA!B2(!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!<99-1,82!IC3<J!&*'-1)#8()!$:!B21-9;!I?FFDJ!

-(4#&-(5!9(19.(!'1!82,*7(!21S!'2(:!'2&*K;!%,*,7(!,*)!,8'A!B2&5!S&..!$(!)&00&8#.'!

,*)!10'(*\9,&*0#.!82,*7(5!S&..!*1'!2,99(*!$:!'2(%5(.E(5!,*)!(`9.,&*5!'2,'!,0'(-!

9(19.(! 71'! '2(! ,S,-(*(55!10! '2(!*(()!10! 82,*7(! '2(:!%#5'!#*)(-5',*)! '2(! 0#..!

(`'(*'!10!'2(!9.,**()!82,*7(A!IB21-9;!?FFDJ!%(,*5!'2,'!1*.:!$:!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!

,*)! 81%%&'%(*'! '1! '2(!9.,**()! 82,*7(!9(19.(! '2(*!2,E(!71'! '2(! 8,9,$&.&':! '1!

',K(! '2(!-&72'!,8'&1*5A!_2(*!9(19.(!2,E(! '2(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!*(8(55,-:! '1!$#&.)!

81%%&'%(*';!'1!0#..:!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!5819(!10!S2,'!'2(:!,-(!81%%&''&*7!'1;!'2(*;!

,*)! 1*.:! '2(*;! '2(:! 8,*! ,8'! S&'2! ,*:! -(,51*,$.(! 82,*8(! 10! 5#88(55A! T,*:!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!,-(!.11K&*7!01-!5&%9.(!%1)(.5!01-!82,*7(;!$#'!'2(-(!,-(!*1!5&%9.(!

51.#'&1*5! ,*)!S&'2! '2(! 5&.E(-! $#..('! '2&*K&*7! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5!S&..! 81*'&*#(! '1! 0,&.!

IB21-9;!?FFDJA!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!521S5!'2,'!(E(-:!:(,-!&*!'2(!P*&'()!d&*7)1%!,.1*(!,99-1`&%,'(.:!

w?>>! $&..&1*! &5! 59(*'! 1*! 82,*7(! 9-17-,%%(5A! V'! 8,*! $(! ,55#%()! '2,'!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,-(! 219&*7! '2,'! '2&5! &*E(5'%(*'! &*! 82,*7(! S&..! &%9-1E(! '2(&-!

9(-01-%,*8(;! '2#5! -(5#.'&*7! .1*7\'(-%! &*! %1-(! 9-10&'5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5A! [1S(E(-!

'2(-(!&5!,!$&7!9-1$.(%;!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!%,K&*7!'2(5(!&*E(5'%(*'5!,-(!#*5#-(!10!

'2(!&%9,8'!'2(!82,*7(!&5!2,E&*7!1*!'2(&-!9(-01-%,*8(!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!B2&5!8,*!

$(!9,-'.:!$.,%()!1*!'2(!0,8'!'2,'!9(-01-%,*8(!71,.5!,-(!*1'!10'(*!%,)(!(`9.&8&'!

Page 33: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>!

1-!,'!,..;!%,K&*7!&'!2,-)!'1!%(,5#-(!1*(5!9(-01-%,*8(!,7,&*5'!,*:'2&*7!IC-,).(:;!

=>>RJA! B2(! 5,%(! ,#'21-! 91&*'5! 1#'! '2,'! ,.'21#72! '2(5(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,-(!

&*E(5'&*7! &*! 82,*7(!,*)!,-(!S&..&*7! '1! 82,*7(! &*'(-*,..:;! 82,*7(!(`'(-*,..:! &5! ,!

81*'&*##%!,*)!S&..!01-(E(-!2,E(!,*!(00(8'!1*!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*A!V'!8,*!'2(-(01-(!$(!

,-7#()! '2,'! 01-! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! '1! (*5#-(! '2,'! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! &5!

,82&(E()! &'! 521#.)!$(! ,$.(! '1! ,),9'! '1! &*'(-*,.! ,*)!(`'(-*,.! 82,*7(!(00(8'&E(.:A!

cs86&! E6.//&#A&! $(! )+! 0&%&/+2! .#! &,,&E)$%&! .#0! )$D&/*!D&)6+0! +,! 0&)&'D$#$#A! )6&!

#&N)! (&)! +,! E6.#A&(;! .#0! )+!D.#.A&! )6&D;! (+! )6.)!0&,$#&0!2&',+'D.#E&!A+./(! .'&!

.E6$&%&0L! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJA! V'! &5! *1'! '2(! 5:5'(%! '2,'! &5! &%9.(%(*'()! &*'1! ,*!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! '2,'! -(5#.'5! &*! ,! $(*(0&';! $#'! -,'2(-! '2(! 82,*7(! 8#.'#-(! '2,'! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!2,5!'1!,)19'!)#(!'1!'2(!5:5'(%!I_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!

<5! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! ,8'#,..:! ,82&(E()! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! 82,*7(5A! T(,5#-(%(*'! 10!

'2(5(!&%9-1E(%(*'5!.(,)5!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!'1!,!-(E&5()!5'-,'(7:!IC-,).(:;!=>>R;!

_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!

<*! &*'(-(5'&*7! 81**(8'&1*! $('S((*! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 82,*7(! &5! &*'-1)#8()! $:!3(&55!

I=>>>J! ,*)! &5! '2(! '(-%! cC(*(0&'5! Q-((9L! &5! (`9.,&*()! ,5! '2(! 92(*1%(*1*! '2,'!

)(7-,)(5!$(*(0&'5A!6#-&*7!'2(!.&0(!10!,!9-17-,%%(;!82,*7(5!%1)&0:!(,82!9-1^(8'L5!

,$&.&':!'1!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5A!B2(5(!82,*7(5!8,*!81%(!0-1%!S&'2&*!I82,*7(5!'1!'2(!

9-17-,%%(5!'2(%5(.E(5J!1-!0-1%!'2(!(*E&-1*%(*'!82,*7(5!&*!'2(!1#'5&)(!S1-.)!

'2,'!,00(8'!'2(!E,.#(!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!I3(&55;!=>>>JA!

*$P 4;@[0'\)1B!/23!@/2/A'@'21!H0)23!([;1(!

V*! '2(! &*'-1)#8'&1*! '2(! &55#(! 10! 81%9.(`&':! S,5! 9-(5(*'()! S2(*! 81*5&)(-&*7!

'17('2(-! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 82,*7(! ,*)! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

9-17-,%%(5A![(,.'28,-(!9-17-,%%(5!':9&8,..:!2,E(!,! .1*7! .&0(59,*;!S&'2!%,*:!

92,5(5! &*8.#)&*7! 91.&8:! 5(''&*7;! 9.,**&*7;! )(E(.19%(*';! 81*5'-#8'&1*;!

81%%&55&1*&*7! 10! 2(,.'28,-(! 5(-E&8(! 19(-,'&1*5;! 0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'! I(A7A!

%,&*'(*,*8(J;!-(0#-$&52%(*'5!,*)!)(%1.&'&1*!IQ,--#'2(-5!('!,.A;!=>>Rq!"S((*(:!

,*)! U-&00&'25;! =>>=JA! B21-9! I?FFDJ! 5#991-'5! '2,'! )&59,-&':! $('S((*! .&0(8:8.(!

5',7(5!,*)!81%9.(`&':!,))()!$:!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!)&00(-(*'!9(-8(9'&1*5!81#.)!$(!

%,*,7()! '2-1#72! ,! 9-18(55! '2,'! &*E1.E(5! &)(*'&0:&*7;! %,*,7&*7;!

Page 34: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?!

%1*&'1-&*7a81*'-1..&*7;!-(,.&5&*7!,*)!%(,5#-&*7!$(*(0&'5A![1S(E(-!&*!)1&*7!'2,'!

&'!&5!&%91-',*'!'1!9,:!,''(*'&1*!'1!%,*,7(%(*'!$.&*)!591'5!'2,'!&*!'#-*!'2(:!01-%!

'2(!01#-!8-&'&8,.!)&%(*5&1*5!10!81%9.(`&':!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!B2(5(!$.&*)!591'5!,-(W!

.&*K,7(q!-(,82q!9(19.(q!,*)!'&%(A!

• G$#?.A&! &5! '2(! *(8(55,-:! .&*K5! '2,'! *(()! '1! $(!%,)(! $('S((*! '2(! (`9(8'()!

-(5#.'5! 0-1%! ,! 9-1^(8'! 1-! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! '2(! 1E(-,..! 5'-,'(7:! 10! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*q!

• R&.E6! -(0(-5! '1! '2(! $-(,)'2! ,*)! )(9'2! 10! 82,*7(! -(4#&-()! S&'2&*! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!01-!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!-(,.&5()!,5!S(..!,5!#*)(-5',*)&*7!'2(!,-(,5!

10!&%9,8'!,*)!'1!S2,'!(`'(*)!5',K(21.)(-5!S&..!$(!,00(8'()q!

• 5&+2/&;!,!.,-7(!*#%$(-!10!9(19.(!%#5'!$(!%1'&E,'()!,*)!9-(9,-()!'1!82,*7(A!

<! 8.(,-! #*)(-5',*)&*7! &5! *(()()! ,5! '1! S2&82! 9(19.(! ,-(! &*E1.E()! ,'! S2,'!

5',7(;! S2,'! &*'(-E(*'&1*5! S&..! $(! -(4#&-()! '1! (00(8'! '2(! 82,*7(! 21S! '2(5(!

&*'(-E(*'&1*5! S&..! $(! %,*,7()! 01-! 9(19.(! S&'2! )&00(-(*'! 5',-'&*7! 91&*'5;!

,''&'#)(5!,*)!%1'&E,'&1*5q!

• 8$D&;!&*!,*:!'-,*501-%,'&1*!9-18(55!'&%(!&5!,.S,:5!10!'2(!(55(*8(A!G*(!*(()5!

'1!,5K!Z,*)!,5K!,7,&*!,*)!,7,&*\!S2,'!'2(!-(,.&5'&8!.(*7'2!10!'&%(!&5!01-!,..!'2(!

*(8(55,-:! 82,*7(5! '1! 188#-! ,*)! 01-! '2(! 0#..! $(*(0&'5! '1! $(! -(,.&5()A!

H5'&%,'&1*5! 10! '&%(! %#5'! $(! $,5()! 1*! #*)(-5',*)&*7! '2(! '2-((! 9-(E&1#5!

)&%(*5&1*5A!B2(-(!%#5'!,.51!$(!-(817*&'&1*!'2,'!'2(!1'2(-!'2-((!)&%(*5&1*5!

S&..!82,*7(!'2(%5(.E(5!1E(-!'&%(A!

*$N 4;21)28;8(!)@[5;<'@'21!!

G*(! 10! '2(! )-&E(-5! $(2&*)! ,! $(*(0&'! )-&E(*! ,99-1,82! &5! '2(! S&..&*7*(55! '1!

81*5',*'.:!&%9-1E(!,*)!)1!'2&*75!$(''(-!,5!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,$51-$5!'2(!.(551*5!

.(,-*'!0-1%!9-1^(8'!'1!9-1^(8'!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!

B2&5!S&..&*7*(55! &5!(%$-,8()!,*)!9-1%1'()!$:!,!Q1*'&*#1#5!V%9-1E(%(*'!IQVJ!

,99-1,82A!QV!&5!,!92&.15192:!10!1*\71&*7!&%9-1E(%(*'!S2&82!1-&7&*,'()!&*!h,9,*!

S2(-(!&'!&5!K*1S*!,5!K,&e(*;!&*E1.E&*7!(E(-:1*(!&*!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!1*!,!),:\'1!Z

),:! $,5&5! &*! ,! 81*5',*'! 4#(5'! 01-! 81*'&*#1#5;! &*8-(%(*',.! &%9-1E(%(*'! &*! ,..!

0-1*'5!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!!

Page 35: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==!

T15';!&0!*1'!,..;!)(0&*&'&1*5!10!QV!&*8.#)(!5','(%(*'5!,$1#'!S2,'!QV!,8'&E&'&(5!5((K!

'1! ,881%9.&52A! B2(! %15'! 0-(4#(*'.:! 5','()! &*'(*'&1*5! &*8.#)(! u1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

(00(8'&E(*(55! ,*)! 81%9('&'&E(*(55v! I"82-1()(-! ,*)! 31$&*51*;! ?FF?J! ,*)!

c(*2,*8()! 8#5'1%(-! 5,'&50,8'&1*L! Ih2,! ('! ,.A;! ?FFRJA! G#'81%(! 8-&'(-&,! 10! 7-(,'(-!

59(8&0&8&':;! 5#82!,5! 815'! -()#8'&1*;! 0.(`&$&.&':;! ,*)! -()#8()!8:8.(! '&%(! IQ,#)-1*;!

?FF@J!,-(!,.51!81*5&)(-()A!QV!,5!,!81..(8'&1*!10!,8'&E&'&(5!'2,'!81*5'&'#'(!,!9-18(55!

&*'(*)()! '1! ,82&(E(! &%9-1E(%(*'A! V*!%,*#0,8'#-&*7;! '2(5(! ,8'&E&'&(5! 9-&%,-&.:!

&*E1.E(!5&%9.&0&8,'&1*!10!9-1)#8'&1*!9-18(55(5;!82&(0.:!'2-1#72!'2(!(.&%&*,'&1*!10!

S,5'(!Ih2,!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!V*!5(-E&8(!&*)#5'-&(5!,*)!'2(!9#$.&8!5(8'1-;!'2(!018#5!&5!1*!

5&%9.&0&8,'&1*!,*)!&%9-1E()!8#5'1%(-!5(-E&8(!'2-1#72!7-(,'(-!(%91S(-%(*'!10!

&*)&E&)#,.! (%9.1:((5! ,*)! 81--(591*)&*7.:! .(55! $#-(,#8-,8:! IT8b,#72.&*! ,*)!

d,.#e*:;! ?FF>JA! <84#&5&'&1*! ,*)! #5(! 10! 5K&..5! 01-! 9-18(55! ,*,.:5&5! ,*)! 9-1$.(%!

51.E&*7!,-(!5((*!,5!0#*),%(*',.!'1!QV!&*!'2(!9-&E,'(!,*)!9#$.&8!5(8'1-5!IT#.E,*:;!

?FFFJA!

<!5:*195&5!10!'2(!%,^1-!(.(%(*'5!10!QV!01..1S5!Ih2,!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!!

<A P*)(-5',*)!,*)!)18#%(*'!'2(!9-18(55W!

• V)(*'&0:! E,.#(\,))()! E(-5#5! *1*\E,.#(\,))()! ,8'&E&'&(5! I)1&*7! '2(! -&72'!

'2&*75Jq!

• <*,.:5(!815';!4#,.&':;!,*)!1'2(-!-(.(E,*'!%(,5#-(5!01-!(4#&9%(*'!I)1&*7!

'2&*75!-&72'Jq!

• b,$1#-;!,*)!%,'(-&,.!&*9#'5A!

CA "&%9.&0:!,*)!&%9-1E(W!

• 3()#8(;!81%$&*(!1-!(.&%&*,'(!,8'&E&'&(5q!

• V%9-1E(!'2(!9(-01-%,*8(!10!(4#&9%(*';! .,$1#-!,*)!%,'(-&,.!&*9#'5!S&'2!

-(59(8'!'1!815';!4#,.&':!,*)!1'2(-!-(.(E,*'!8-&'(-&,q!

• V%9.(%(*'!.1S!7-,)(!I&*8-(%(*',.J!,#'1%,'&1*q!

• 3(E&5(!$#5&*(55!-#.(5!,5!*(()()A!

QA "',*),-)&5(!,*)!&*'(7-,'(W!

• 3(&*'(7-,'(!-(%,&*&*7!,8'&E&'&(5q!

• "',$&.&5(!'2(!9-18(55!,'!&'5!*(S!.(E(.A!

6A T1*&'1-!9(-01-%,*8(W!

Page 36: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@!

• T(,5#-(!,*)!%1*&'1-q!

• "('!*(S!',-7('5A!

B2(-(!&5!,!8.(,-!-(5(%$.,*8(!$('S((*!'2(!QV!5:*195&5!%(*'&1*()!,$1E(!,*)!'2(!!

u9.,*\)1\82(8K\,8'v!8:8.(!I+\6\Q\<J!1-!"2(S2,-'!8:8.(!I6(%&*7;!?FDRJA!!

QV! 5((K5! '1! &%9-1E(! 9(-01-%,*8(! &*! ,! E,-&(':! 10! )&%(*5&1*5! 01-! '2(! 8#5'1%(-;!

5#82! ,5! 815';! 4#,.&':;! 9-1%9'*(55! ,*)! '&%(.&*(55;! $:! &%9-1E&*7! 0#*8'&1*,.! ,*)!

8-155\0#*8'&1*,.! 9-18(55(5A! B1! )1! '2&5;! QV! $#&.)5! ,! K*1S.()7(! $,5(! S&'2&*! '2(!

1-7,*&e,'&1*!$:!)18#%(*'&*7!9-18(55(5;!51!'2,'! 0#'#-(! &%9-1E(%(*'5!8,*!$#&.)!

1*! 9,5'! ,881%9.&52%(*'5A! QV! 81*5&5'5! 10! 9.,**()! 82,*7(;! 01..1S()! $:!

5',$&.&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! 5:5'(%! ,'! &'5! *(S! .(E(.;! 01..1S()! $:!%1-(! 9.,**()! 82,*7(A!

B2#5;!81*'-1.!,*)!5',$&.&':!,-(!E(-:!%#82!9,-'!10!'2(!QV!9-18(55!Ih2,!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!

B2(!,#'21-!$(.&(E(5!,'!'2&5!5',7(!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!)-&E(*!9-18(55;!521#.)!01..1S!'2(!

5,%(!.17&8!,5!'2(!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!8:8.(A!B1!)1!51!,*)!'1!&)(*'&0:!&0!5#82!

,!9-18(55!S&..!81*'-&$#'(!'1S,-)5!,!$(''(-!9(-01-%,*8(!'2(-(!&5!,!*(()!'1!-(E&(S!

-(.,'()!.&'(-,'#-(!&*!9(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!%(,5#-(%(*'A!

*$T "'57;5@/29'!@/2/A'@'21!

+(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'! $(7,*! '1! $(! 10! &*'(-(5'! 01-! 5'#):! &*! '2(! .,'(! ?FD>L5!

IC#5&! ,*)! C&'&'8&;! =>>RJ! '2&5! S,5! (%#.,'()! &*! 9-,8'&8(! &*! '2(! 0&(.)A! V'! &5! *1S! ,!

9-(0(--()! #5(! 10! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! '2(! 9(-01-%,*8(! 10! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! &5!

&%9-1E()! '2-1#72! '2(! #5(! 10! &'! I",*)'! ('! ,.A;! =>>?;! _,,.;! =>>RJA! [1S(E(-!

,.'21#72!'2(-(!&5!(E&)(*8(!10!&*8-(,5()!9(-01-%,*8(!S&'2!'2(!#5(!10!9(-01-%,*8(!

%,*,7(%(*'! I_,,.! ,*)! Q1#*(';! =>>RJ! 5','(! '2,'! ORx! 10! '2(! &%9.(%(*','&1*5!

,-(! #*5#88(550#.;! '2(:! ,-7#(! '2,'! '2&5! 81#.)! $(! )#(! '1! '2(! 9(-01-%,*8(!

%,*,7(%(*'!5:5'(%5!'2,'!2,E(!$((*!9#'!&*!9.,8(!$(&*7!#5()!,99-19-&,'(.:;!$:!,..!

1-! ,'! ,..! '&%(5A! <! *#%$(-! 10! S-&'(-5! I/-,*81! ,*)! C1#-*(;! =>>@;! _,,.;! =>>RJ!

$(.&(E(! '2,'! '2(! 5:5'(%5! 0,&.! )#(! '1! $(2,E&1#-,.! ,59(8'5! 10! 9(-01-%,*8(!

%,*,7(%(*'!$(&*7!1E(-.11K()A!B2(:!,..!,7-((!'2,'!01-!9(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'!

'1!$(!5#88(550#.!S&'2&*!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*;!$(2,E&1#-,.!0,8'1-5!%#5'!$(!',K(*!&*!'1!

Page 37: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =N!

81*5&)(-,'&1*! ,5! S(..! ,5! '2(!%1-(! &*5'-#%(*',.! ,59(8'5A! B2(! $(2,E&1#-! 10! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! &'5!%(%$(-5! 2,5! '1! $(81%(! 9(-01-%,*8(! )-&E(*;! -(5#.'&*7! &*!

)-&E(!01-!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!,*)!$(''(-!-(5#.'5A!_,,.;!=>>R!2,5!)(E(.19()!

,!%1)(.!S2&82!2(.95!'1!)(%1*5'-,'(!'2&5!9-18(55;!5((!/&7#-(!OA!

!

X)A85'!Nc!&#'!(15/1'A)9!['57;5@/29'!@/2/A'@'21!3'<'0;[@'21!9B90'!^V//0D!*++T_!

+(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!,-(!E(-:!8.15(.:!-(.,'()!

'1! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*A! +(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! &%9.&(5! '2,'! 9(-01-%,*8(!

%(,5#-(%(*'!%('21)5! 8,*! $(! #5()! '1! c2(.9! '1! &)(*'&0:;! 9.,*! ,*)! &%9.(%(*'! ,!

$(*(0&'!-(,.&5,'&1*!5'-,'(7:!S&'2&*!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*L!I"()(-,!('!,.A;!=>>?JA!

*$O "'57;5@/29'!@'/(85'@'21!

+(-01-%,*8(! %(,5#-(%(*'! 8,*! ,.51! $(! .&*K()! '1! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!+(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'!&5!5((*!,5!,*!(55(*'&,.!(.(%(*'!&*!

'2(! .&0(! 8:8.(! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'! S2('2(-! &'! &5! 01-! ,*! ()#8,'&1*;! 21#5&*7;! 81%%#*&':!

-(7(*(-,'&1*!1-!2(,.'28,-(!9-1^(8'A!B2(! '11.5!,*)!%(,5#-(%(*'5!,-(! 5((*!,5! c,!

-1#'(! 01-! $(''(-! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! ,881#*',$&.&':L! ,*)! 9-1E&)(! &*01-%,'&1*!

-(4#&-()!01-!9-18(55!81*'-1.;!(*,$.&*7!'2(!(5',$.&52%(*'!10!-(,.!$#'!82,..(*7&*7!

',-7('5!'2,'!81#.)!$(!'-,*5.,'()!&*'1!$(*(0&'5!IB1S*.(:;!=>>=JA!

+(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*';!,5!S&'2!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;!$(7,*! '1!-(8(&E(!,!-&5(!

&*'(-(5'!$1'2!&*!'2(1-:!,*)!9-,8'&8(!,-1#*)!'2(!.,'(!?FD>5A!<.'21#72!,5!I]((.:!('!

!"#$%#&'(&)*+,#$-&./#+$0&1*+.2*3.(+$

!"#$%&'()#*#43&*3#1.,$

5*+*1#)#+3$+,-%.##

/"#$%&'()#*#012*1%('3#

6#7(&3.+1#+,-%.#

4"#$%&'()#*#%#&'(&)*+,##

-2'5%)#6%7*5',82*.#9,-%.#

Page 38: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =O!

,.A;!=>>=J!91&*'!1#'!&'!2,5!$((*!5'#)&()!01-!51%(!'&%(A!G-7,*&5,'&1*5!&*!'2(!?FD>5!

018#5()! '2(&-! 9(-01-%,*8(! %(,5#-(%(*'! 9-()1%&*,*'.:! 1*! &*81%(! ,*)!

9-1)#8'&E&':A! C-,).(:! I=>>RJ! ,*)! IU2,.,:*&! ('! ,.A;! ?FFMJ! $(.&(E(! '2(! -(,51*! 01-!

'2&5!S,5!$(8,#5(!,'!'2(!'&%(!2#7(!&*E(5'%(*'5!S(-(!71&*7!&*'1!01-(E(-!,)E,*8&*7!

'(82*1.17:A! ! "()(-,!('!,.! I=>>?J!,-7#(! '2,'!,.'21#72! &'! &5! '2(!*1-%!'1!%(,5#-(!

9(-01-%,*8(!1*!3GV! I3('#-*!1*! V*E(5'%(*'J! ,*)!3GQ! I3('#-*!1*!Q,9&',.J! '2,'!

'2(!0&7#-(5!8,*!E(-:!10'(*!$(!81*0#5&*7!,*)!)(8(9'&E(!,5!'2(!&*',*7&$.(!,55('5!10!,!

$#5&*(55! 8,*! 10'(*! $(! S1-'2! %1-(! '2,*! '215(! S2&82! ,-(! ',*7&$.(;! #9! '1! D>x!

,881-)&*7!'1!C,-'21.1%(S!I?FFFJ!&*!I"()(-,!('!,.A;!=>>?J!&*',*7&$.(!,55('5!-(5#.'!

&*!.,5'&*7!$(*(0&'5!S2&.5'!'2(!',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!%1-(!521-'!'(-%;!,.51!',*7&$.(!

,55('5! %(,5#-(! '2(! 9,5'! 9(-01-%,*8(! 10! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*A! B2(-(01-(! S2(*!

%(,5#-&*7!9(-01-%,*8(!&'!S1#.)!$(!,)E&5,$.(!01-!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!'1!.11K!,'!$1'2!

',*7&$.(!,*)!&*',*7&$.(!,55('5A!![1S(E(-!&*',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!2,-)!'1!%(,5#-(!

*1'! 1*.:! $(8,#5(! '2(:! 8,*! ',K(! ,! .1*7! '&%(! '1! $(! -(,.&5()! $#'! ,.51! $(8,#5(! &'!

&*E1.E(5! %(,5#-(%(*'! 10! $(2,E&1#-! 5#82! ,5! 1*(L5! 0((.&*7! 10! -(817*&'&1*;!

5&7*&0&8,*8(;!5','#5!,*)!-(9#','&1*!IG'.(:;!?FFFJA!!

/-1%!'2(!-(817*&'&1*!'2,'!$1'2!',*7&$.(!,*)!&*',*7&$.(!,55('5!S(-(!&%91-',*'!01-!

9(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'! 8,%(! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,! *#%$(-! 10!%1)(.5! '2,'!

81*5&)(-()!,!$,.,*8()!5('!10!%(,5#-(5!'1!(E,.#,'(!'2(!1E(-,..!9(-01-%,*8(!10!,*!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! Id,9.,*! ,*)! ]1-'1*;! ?FFR;! ]((.:! ('! ,.A;! =>>=JA! ! "1%(! 10! '2(5(!

%1)(.5!,-(!.&5'()!$(.1S!I"()(-,!('!,.A;!=>>?JW!

• +-18(55!9(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'!%1)(.q!

• _1-K0.1S!$,5()!%(,5#-(%(*'!%1)(.q!

• "','&5'&8,.!81*'-1.!%('21)q!

• B2(!9(-01-%,*8(!9:-,%&)q!

• "(.0\,55(55%(*'!%('21)q!

• +(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'!%,'-&`q!,*)!

• C,.,*8()!"81-(8,-)!%('21)A!

<..! '2(5(! %1)(.5! &*E1.E(! (E,.#,'&1*;! 9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

%(,5#-(%(*'A!B2(:!,-(!'2(!S,:5!'1!(`,%&*(!21S!E,.#(!&5!7(*(-,'()!,5!,!-(5#.'!

Page 39: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =R!

10! &%9.(%(*'&*7! 82,*7(A! B2&5! &5! ,'! '2(! 8(*'-(! 10! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)!

%,*,7(%(*'!,5!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!&*)&8,'(5A!!

*$S ?</08/1);2!/23!</08'!A'2'5/1);2!

C(*(0&'!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!E,.#(!7(*(-,'&1*!2,5!$((*!1*(!10! '2(! .,'(5'!,))&'&1*5! '1!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!!IC-,).(:;!=>>R;!_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!X,.#(!2,5!5(E(-,.!

%(,*&*75!,*)!&*'(-9-(','&1*5;!_&K&9()&,!5#%%,-&5(!E,.#(!)(0&*&'&1*5!,5W!

• B2(! 4#,.&':! I915&'&E(! 1-! *(7,'&E(J! '2,'! -(*)(-5! 51%('2&*7! )(5&-,$.(! 1-!

E,.#,$.(q!

• B2(!)(7-((!10!&%91-',*8(!:1#!7&E(!'1!51%('2&*7q!

• B2(!,%1#*'! I10!%1*(:!1-!711)5!1-! 5(-E&8(5J! '2,'! &5! 81*5&)(-()! '1!$(!,! 0,&-!

(4#&E,.(*'!01-!51%('2&*7!(.5(q!

• ]#%(-&8,.!4#,*'&':!%(,5#-()!1-!,55&7*()!1-!81%9#'()A!

V*!G`01-)!)&8'&1*,-:W!X,.#(!&5!'2(!*#%(-&8,.!%(,5#-(!10!,!4#,*'&':!1-!,!*#%$(-!

)(*1'&*7! %,7*&'#)(! 1*! 51%(! 81*E(*'&1*,.! 58,.(A! <)19'&*7! '2&5! )(0&*&'&1*!

C-,).(:! I=>>RJ! )(0&*(5! E,.#(! 10! $(*(0&'! ,5! '2(! %,7*&'#)(! &%9-1E(%(*'!

,5518&,'()! S&'2! '2(! $(*(0&';! ,*)! ,-7#(5! '2,'! &*! %15'! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '2(-(! &5! ,!

91S(-0#.! )-&E(! '1! E,.#(! $(*(0&'5! 0&*,*8&,..:! &--(59(8'&E(! 10! S2('2(-! '2(&-!

,82&(E(%(*'!S&..!,8'#,..:!7(*(-,'(!8,52;!,*)!'2,'!&5!$(8,#5(!'2&5!&5!'2(!5&%9.(5'!

%15'! 81%%1*! 8#--(*8:! 01-! 81%9,-&*7! ,*)! -,*K&*7! $(*(0&'5A! /&*,*8&,.! $(*(0&'5!

,-(!,.51!'2(!%15'!#5(0#.!01-!9-1E&)&*7!,!^#5'&0&8,'&1*A!

<881-)&*7! '1! B21-9! I?FFDJ! E,.#(! &5! '2(! -(.,'&E(! S1-'2! 1-! &%91-',*8(! 10! ,*!

&*E(5'%(*'! 01-!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!1-! &'5!K(:!5',K(21.)(-5A! V'5!(`9-(55&1*!%,:!',K(!

E,-&1#5! 01-%5;! &*8.#)&*7! %1*(',-:! 1-! %,'(-&,.;! 5#$5'&'#'&1*! (4#&E,.(*8(;!

5#$^(8'&E(!^#)7(%(*';!('8A!!

311K(!('!,.A!I=>?>J!5#%%,-&5()!'2,'!E,.#(!&*!9-1^(8'!'(-%5!8,*!$(!8,'(71-&5()!,5!

(`'(-*,.!1-! &*'(-*,.A!_2(-(!(`'(-*,.!8#5'1%(-!E,.#(!&5!'2(!#.'&%,'(!1$^(8'&E(!10!

'2(!9-1^(8';!&'!8,*!$(!8,'(71-&5()!,5!(&'2(-W!

Page 40: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =M!

• +-18(55! E,.#(;! )(-&E()! 0-1%! '2(! 8#5'1%(-y5! (`9(-&(*8(! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'L5!

)(5&7*!,*)!)(.&E(-:!9-18(55q!1-!

• +-1)#8'! E,.#(;! )(-&E&*7! 0-1%! '2(! 82,-,8'(-&5'&85! 10! '2(! 0&*&52()!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&'5(.0A!

V*'(-*,.!E,.#(!&5!'2(!E,.#(!8-(,'()!01-!9,-'&8&9,*'5! &*!'2(!9-1^(8'!)(.&E(-:!'(,%A!

H%%&''! ('! ,.A! I=>>OJ! 2,E(! &*! 311K(! ('! ,.A! I=>?>J! ,.51! 5#77(5'()! '2,'! E,.#(! &5!

5#$^(8'&E(!,*)!&'!82,*7(5!1E(-!'&%(A!B2(:!71!1*!'1!,.51!1$5(-E(!'2,'!'2(!8#5'1%(-!

&*! ,*:! 9,-'&8#.,-! 8,5(! %,:! -(9-(5(*'! ,! 81%9.(`! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,*)! '2,'!

&*'(-(5'5! 0-1%!'2(!S&)(-!*(&72$1#-211)!%,:!,.51! &%9,8'!1*!1#-!81*8(9'&1*!10!

E,.#(A!B2:55(*;!('!,.A!I=>?>J!,))W!

• B2,'!cE,.#(L!8,*!$(!)&5'&*7#&52()!0-1%!yE,.#(5y;!S2&82!-(0(-5!'1!9-&*8&9.(5!

,*)!&)(,.5q!!

• ]1'S&'25',*)&*7!&'5!5#$^(8'&E(!*,'#-(;!E,.#(!8,*!51%('&%(5!$(!5#$^(8'!'1!

1$^(8'&E(! %(,5#-(%(*';! '21#72! '2&5! %(,5#-(%(*'! 10'(*! )(9(*)5! 1*!

81*'(`'q!

• B2(! )#-,$&.&':! 10! ,! E,.#,'&1*! )(9(*)5! #91*! '2(! *#%$(-! 10! 9(19.(!S21!

,7-((!1*!&'!,*)!'2(!81--(8'*(55!10!'2(&-!,55#%9'&1*5A!

/&*,..:;!'2(:!*1'(!'2,'!%,'2(%,'&8,.!)(0&*&'&1*5!10!E,.#(;!5#82!,5!'215(!5#77(5'()!

$:!B21%51*!('!,.A!I=>>@J;!,-(!5&%9.&5'&8!,*)!*1*5(*5&8,.A!

6(.&E(-&*7!E,.#(!$(7&*5!S&'2!)(0&*&*7!'2(!(`9(8'()!2&72\.(E(.!1#'81%(5!$(01-(!,!

9-17-,%%(! &5! ,99-1E()! ,*)! 81*'&*#(5! '2-1#72! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*;! 9-10&.&*7;!

'-,8K&*7!,*)!(%$())&*7!10!$(*(0&'5A!B2&5!,.51!&*E1.E(5!,55(55&*7!-&5K!,7,&*5'!'2(!

9-1915()!1#'81%(!'1!81*0&-%!21S!E,.#(!8,*!$(5'!$(!,82&(E()!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!

B21-9!I?FFDJ!&*'-1)#8(5!&*!2&5!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!<99-1,82!IC3<J!I)(58-&$()!

&*!=A?@ANJ!&*!/&7#-(!R!,!E,.#(!,55(55%(*'!'(82*&4#(!'2,'!8,*!,55&5'!&*!7,#7&*7!'2(!

1))5!10!5#88(55!01-!59(8&0&8!&*E(5'%(*'5!9-17-,%5A!B2(!'(82*&4#(!&5!$,5()!&*!'2(!

c01#-!<-(5L!,5!&*W!

Page 41: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =D!

?A <-(!S(!)1&*7!'2(!-&72'!'2&*75t!Z!<))-(55&*7!'2(!)(0&*&'&1*!10!$#5&*(55!,*)!

$#5&*(55!)&-(8'&1*q!

=A <-(! S(! )1&*7! '2(%! '2(! -&72'! S,:t! Z! <))-(55&*7! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

5'-#8'#-(!,*)!'2(!9-18(55q!

@A <-(! S(! 7(''&*7! '2(%! )1*(! S(..t! Z! <))-(55&*7! 8,9,$&.&':! -(51#-8(! ,*)!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(q!

NA <-(!S(!7(''&*7! '2(!$(*(0&'5t! Z!<))-(55&*7!9-1,8'&E(!%,*,7(%(*'!10! '2(!

C3!9-18(55!,5!,!S21.(A!

!

X)A85'!Tc!&#'!7;85!I:?(!)2!</08'!/(('((@'21!^&#;5[D!,UUS_!

_2(*! ,55(55&*7! E,.#(! '2(-(! ,-(! 'S1!%,&*! ':9(5! 10! (E,.#,'&1*! &)(*'&0&()! &*! '2(!

.&'(-,'#-(A!B2(5(!,-(!I?J!5#%%,'&E(!,*)!I=J!01-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*A!

*$S$, =8@@/1)<'!'</08/1);2!!

C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! ,-(! 9-18(55(5! '2,'! ,55&5'! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1!

59(*)!%1*(:!S&5(.:! ,*)! '2(*! '1! ,881#*'! 01-! '2(!,%1#*'5! 59(*'A! V*! '2&5! ,59(8'!

'2(:! ,-(! (55(*'&,..:! 5#%%,'&E(! ,8'&E&'&(5;! (`,%&*&*7! ,*)! 8,..&*7! 9(19.(! '1!

,881#*'A! /,-$(:! ,'! ,.A! I?FFFJ! 2,E(! ,-7#()! '2,'! 01-! c$(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'!

9.,**&*7! 01-!$(*(0&'5!(`!,*'(;!,*)!(E,.#,'&*7! '2(%!(`!915'!,-(! 'S1!5&)(5!10! '2(!

5,%(! 81&*L;! &*! 51! 0,-! ,5! ,! 812(-(*'! $(*(0&'5! (E,.#,'&1*! 9.,*! $(01-(! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'!10! '2(! 5:5'(%!(*,$.(5! '2(! &)(*'&0&()!$(*(0&'5! '1!$(!%,*,7()!,0'(-!

!"#!$%&'()*(+!

!,#!-*(*.&+/!

0#!1(+*'23+&4(! 5#!63738&%&+9:;<.&=&*(=9!

!"#$%#$&#''()&$'*#$+#)#,('-.$

!"#$%#$&#''()&$'*#/$01)#$%#22.$

!"#$%#$01()&$'*#$"(&*'$'*()&-.$

!"#$%#$01()&$'*#/$'*#$"(&*'$%34$

Page 42: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =F!

I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FF@JA!"#%%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*!1-!(E,.#,'&1*!01-!,881#*',$&.&':;!&5!,!

E&(S! 10! (E,.#,'&1*! '2,'! 9-(5#%(5! ,! 5',$.(! (*E&-1*%(*'A! V*! ,*! (*E&-1*%(*'!

S2(-(! 5'-#8'#-(5! ,*)! E,.#(5! ,-(! 82,*7&*7! S2,'! &5! -(4#&-()! &5! ,! 9-18(55! '2,'!

&*8.#)(5! ,! 9-1,8'&E(! 5(,-82! 01-! #*(`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;! ?FFFJA! B2(!

9-1$.(%! &5! '2,'! 5#%%,'&E(! %('21)5! 0,&.! S2(*! 8&-8#%5',*8(5! ,-(! -,)&8,..:!

82,*7()!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!B2(-(! &5! .&''.(!91&*'! &*!21.)&*7!9(19.(! '1!,881#*'!

01-!,!5&'#,'&1*!$(:1*)!'2(&-!81*'-1.!,*)!S2&82!%,:!*1!.1*7(-!$(!-(.(E,*'A!

*$S$* X;5@/1)<'!'</08/1);2!

/1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*!1-!(E,.#,'&1*!01-!&*01-%&*7!'2(!9-(5(*'!,*)!.(,-*&*7!0-1%!

'2(! 9,5';! &5! '2(! 1'2(-! (E,.#,'&1*! ,99-1,82! 9-(5(*'()! 2(-(A! HE,.#,'&1*! .(,)5! '1!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! .(,-*&*7! $(8,#5(! &'! 2(.95! 9(19.(! '1! ,! %#'#,.! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10!

S2,'!%,K(5!,!$(*(0&'!I,*)!815'5!,*)!-&5K5J!Id,9.,*!,*)!]1-'1*;!?FFR;!":%1*5;!

?FF>J! '2(! -(5#.'5! 10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 2(.9! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1! .(,-*! *1'! '1!

%,K(!'2(!5,%(!%&5',K(5!1E(-!,*)!1E(-!,7,&*A!/1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*!&5!'2(-(01-(!,!

$(*(0&8&,.! ,8'&E&':! &*! &'5! 1S*! -&72';! -(7,-).(55! 10! '2(! (00(8'! 1*! 81*'-1.! 1-!

,881#*',$&.&':!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!/1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*!,.51!2(.95!'1!7('!$#:\&*!

,*)!,''-,8'!%#82!*(()()!%,*,7(%(*'!,''(*'&1*!,*)!5#991-'A!B2&5!E&(S!8.(,-.:!

9-(5#%(5! ,! 7-(,'! )(,.! ,$1#'! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,*)! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! $(2,E&1#-;! 01-!

(`,%9.(!&'!,55#%(5!'2,'!'2(!8#.'#-(!,*)!-(S,-)!5:5'(%5!,-(!5#82!'2,'!9(19.(!,-(!

*1'!,0-,&)!'1!u.(,-*yy;! '2,'!$.,%(!S&..!*1'!$(!,55&7*()!'1!,*:1*(!S21!91&*'5!1#'!

)&00&8#.'&(5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!

/1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*! &5! 0#*),%(*',..:!)&00(-(*'! 0-1%!,8'5!10! (E,.#,'&1*! &*! '2,'!

(,82!,8'&E&':!&*!'2(!9-18(55!8,**1'!$(!E&(S()!&*!&51.,'&1*;!&A(A!,5!,!5&*7.(!5*,9521'!

'1!$(!5((*!,5!,*!(*)!&*!&'5(.0;!$#'!(,82!,8'&E&':!&5!-,'2(-!E&(S()!,5!1*(!&*!,!5(-&(5!

10! ,8'&E&'&(5! S2&82! &*! '1',.&':! %,K(! ,! 21.&5'&8! .(,-*&*7! 9&8'#-(! I3(%(*:&! ,*)!

"2(-S11)\"%&'2;! ?FFDJA! /#-'2(-%1-(;! 01-%,'&E(! (E,.#,'&1*! ,.51! &*E1.E(5!

81*8(9'5! 5#82! ,5! %#.'&9.(! 5',K(21.)(-! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! '2#5! ,..1S&*7! 01-! '2(! 81\

(E1.#'&1*!10!'2&*K&*7!,%1*75'!'2(5(!5',K(21.)(-5A!B2&5!81\(E1.#'&1*!9-1%1'(5!,*!

(*E&-1*%(*'! 10! .(,-*&*7! ,*)! )(E(.19%(*'! I3(%(*:&! ,*)! "2(-S11)\"%&'2;!

?FFDJA!

Page 43: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @>!

/1-%,'&E(! (E,.#,'&1*! 0,8&.&','(5! -(817*&'&1*! 10! #*(`9(8'()a(%(-7(*'! $(*(0&'5!

I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!V*!9-,8'&8(!%,*:!10!'2(!%15'!59(8',8#.,-!$(*(0&'5!1$',&*()!

0-1%!'2(!&*'-1)#8'&1*!10!*(S!&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5!S(-(!#*9.,**()!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!

?FFFJA!

d#%,-!I?FF>J!,-7#(5!'2,'!&*!1-)(-!'1!(*5#-(!'2(!&*)(9(*)(*8(!10!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!

,!%1-(!7.1$,.!5('!10!8-&'(-&,!'2,*!'215(!81*8(&E()!$:!'2(!)(E(.19(-5;!(E,.#,'&1*!

521#.)! $(! %,*,7()! ,*)! 9(-01-%()! $:! 9(19.(! 1'2(-! '2,*! '2(! %(%$(-5! 10! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'! '(,%A! B2(! %(82,*&5%! 01-! 9(-01-%&*7! 915'\&%9.(%(*','&1*!

(E,.#,'&1*!%,:! (&'2(-! $(! ,*! &*)(9(*)(*'! 4#,.&':! ,55#-,*8(! 7-1#9! 1-! ,! %#.'&\

5',K(21.)(-!(E,.#,'&1*!'(,%!.()!$:!'2(!#5(-5!Id#%,-;!?FF>JA!

3(%(*:&! ,*)! "2(-S11)\"%&'2! I?FFFJ! ,.51! 5#77(5'! '2,'! ,! 7-1#9! 10! &*)&E&)#,.5!

521#.)!$(!(5',$.&52()!S21!S&..!$(!-(591*5&$.(!01-!81*)#8'&*7!'2(!S1-K!'1!(*5#-(!

'2(!5#88(55!10!,!01-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*A!<!'(,%!81%9-&5&*7!-(9-(5(*','&E(5!10!'2(!

#.'&%,'(! #5(-5;! '2(!%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! '2(! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5! )(E(.19(-5! $(5'!

81*)#8'5! '2&5! S1-KA! <881-)&*7! '1! 3(%(*:&! ,*)! "2(-S11)\"%&'2! I?FFFJ! &'! &5!

$(''(-! &0! ,! #5(-!S21!S&..! ,88(9'! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 82,&-5! '2&5!

7-1#9A! V'! &5! &%91-',*'! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2,'! '2(! (E,.#,'1-5! ,-(! 9-&%,-&.:!

81%%#*&8,'&1*5!,7(*'5!0,8&.&','&*7!,!81*5'-#8'&E(!)&,.17#(!$('S((*!'2(!E,-&1#5!

5',K(21.)(-5!,*)!'2(-(01-(!81*5&)(-,$.(!8,-(!*(()5!'1!$(!7&E(*!'1!(*5#-&*7!'2,'!

(E(-:1*(!#*)(-5',*)5!(,82!1'2(-A!

B2&5!%(,*5!'2,'!&55#(5!*(()!'1!$(!0#..:!,&-()!,*)!'2,'!0&-%!915&'&1*5!521#.)!*1'!

$(! ',K(*!#*'&.! ,..! ,59(8'5!10! '2(! &*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5!2,E(!$((*!)($,'()! &*! 0#..!

I3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!?FFDJA!

*$S$- ";(1!J998[/29B!?</08/1);2!^"J?_!

+GH! 2,5! $((*! )(0&*()! Iz&%-&*7! ,*)! 3(&e(*5'(&*;! ?FD>J! &*! IB#-9&*\C-11K5! ,*)!

X&88,-5;!=>>RJ!,5!c(`,%&*,'&1*5!10!'2(!(00(8'&E(*(55!01-!2#%,*!#5(-5!10!188#9&()!

)(5&7*!(*E&-1*%(*'5LA!+GH!,55(55(5!21S!S(..!$#&.)&*75!%,'82!#5(-5L!*(()5!,*)!&'!

,.51! &)(*'&0&(5! S,:5! '1! &%9-1E(! $#&.)&*7! )(5&7*;! 9(-01-%,*8(! ,*)! 0&'*(55! 01-!

9#-915(!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!V'!&*E1.E(5!'2(!5:5'(%,'&8!(E,.#,'&1*!

Page 44: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @?!

10! 19&*&1*! ,$1#'! $#&.)&*75! &*! #5(;! 0-1%! '2(! 9(-59(8'&E(! 10! '2(! 9(19.(!S21! #5(!

'2(%!Iz&%%(-%,*!,*)!T,-'&*;!=>>?JA!

+GH!&5!*1'!,!*(S!81*8(9'q!&'5!)(E(.19%(*'!&*!'2(!Pd!S,5!(*81#-,7()!&*!'2(!(,-.:!

?FR>5! '2-1#72! ,-82&'(8'#-,.! 9-,8'&8(! -(5(,-82!S2&82! .(,)! '1! '2(! 9#$.&8,'&1*! 10!

+,-'!TW!0(()$,8K;!10!'2(!3VC<!I31:,.!V*5'&'#'(!10!C-&'&52!<-82&'(8'5J!9.,*!10!S1-K5!

IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!!

G*(!10!'2(!-(,51*5!+GH!2,5!-(\(%(-7()!&*!'2(!Pd!&5!)#(!'1!'2(!-(91-'!c3('2&*K&*7!

Q1*5'-#8'&1*L! 9-1915&*7! '2,'! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&1*! &*)#5'-:! 521#.)! u018#5! 1*! '2(!

8#5'1%(-v! IH7,*;! ?FFDJA! +GH! 8,*! 9-1E&)(! ,*! 1$^(8'&E(! %(,5#-(! 10! 8.&(*'!

5,'&50,8'&1*! 01-! )(E(.19%(*'A! +GH! 2,5! -(817*&5()! E,.#(! S&'2&*! '2(! 0,8&.&'&(5!

5(8'1-! ,5! ,! '(82*&4#(! (%9.1:()! '1! ,&)! $(*82%,-K&*7! 10! '2(!4#,.&':! 10! 5(-E&8(5!

-,*7&*7! 0-1%! %,&*'(*,*8(! ,*)! 8.(,*&*7! '1! '2(! 9-1E&5&1*! 10! 100&8(! 0#-*&52&*75!

I_,#'(-5;!=>>OJA!_,#'(-5!81*0&-%5!'2(!E,.#(!10!u#5(-!5,'&50,8'&1*!5#-E(:5v!,5!,!

9-(8#-51-! '1! 5(-E&8(! .(E(.!$(*82%,-K&*7!,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'! -(81%%(*),'&1*5! 01-!

&%9-1E&*7!0,8&.&'&(5!5(-E&8(5!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!

+-(&5(-! I=>>?J! &)(*'&0:! '2-((! .(E(.5! 10! (001-'5! &*! +GHA! B2(! .(E(.! #*)(-',K(*!

)(9(*)5! 1*! '2(! ,E,&.,$&.&':! 10! 0&*,*8(;! '&%(;! %,*91S(-! ,*)! '2(! -(4#&-()!

1#'81%(!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!B2(!7(*(-,.!,99-1,82!'1!(,82!.(E(.!

S&..!&*E1.E(!9.,**&*7!'2(!9-18(55;!81*)#8'&*7!'2(!5'#):!,*)!,*!&*'(-9-(','&1*!10!

'2(!-(5#.'5A!B2(!'2-((!.(E(.5!,-(!,5!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!5#%%,-&5()!I+-(&5(-;!=>>?J!&*!

B,$.(!?A!

&/H0'!,c!4#;;()2A!1#'!5)A#1!0'<'0!;7!"J?!^&85[)2L>5;;M(!/23!Z)99/5(D!*++T_!

Y'<'0!;7!"J?! I)@(! F'1#;3(! &)@'(9/0'!

V*)&8,'&E(! <55(%$.:!$:!(`9(-&(*8()!9(-51**(.!'1!2&72.&72'!+GH!&55#(5!

_,.K!'2-1#72!(E,.#,'&1*;!"'-#8'#-()!V*'(-E&(S5t!!!!!!!!!U-1#9!%(('&*75!S&'2!(*)!#5(-5t!U(*(-,.!&*59(8'&1*!10!$#&.)&*7!9(-01-%,*8(t!!<-82&E,.!)18#%(*'!(E,.#,'&1*5t!

"21-'!&*59(8'&1*!9(-&1)!

V*E(5'&7,'&E(! V*\)(9'2!5'#):!10!'2(!$#&.)&*75!9(-01-%,*8(!,*)!51.#'&1*5!'1!9-1$.(%5!

"#-E(:!4#(5'&1**,&-(!,*)!&*'(-E&(S5A!3(5#.'5!,-(!81%9,-()!S&'2!5&%&.,-!0,8&.&'&(5A!3(91-'!,99-19-&,'(!51.#'&1*5!'1!9-1$.(%5!

/-1%!1*(!S((K!'1!5(E(-,.!%1*'25!

Page 45: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @=!

Y'<'0!;7!"J?! I)@(! F'1#;3(! &)@'(9/0'!

6&,7*15'&8! "21S!#9!,*:!)(0&8&(*8&(5!I'1!-(8'&0:J!,*)!81..(8'!),',!01-!0#'#-(!)(5&7*!1-!5&%&.,-!0,8&.&'&(5!

"192&5'&8,'()!),',!7,'2(-&*7!,*)!,*,.:5&5!'(82*&4#(5A!f#(5'&1**,&-(5;!5#-E(:5;!&*'(-E&(S5!,*)!92:5&8,.!%(,5#-(%(*'5!!

/-1%!5(E(-,.!%1*'25!'1!5(E(-,.!:(,-5!

B2-((!)&00(-(*'!4#(5'&1**,&-(5!,-(!8#--(*'.:!S&)(.:!,E,&.,$.(! 01-!+GHq! '2(:!,-(!

'2(! ]["! '11.K&';! '2(! )(5&7*! 4#,.&':! &*)&8,'1-5! I6fVJ;! ,*)! $#&.)&*7! #5(! 5'#)&(5!

ICP"J! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! I,E,&.,$.(! 1*! .&8(*8(JA! IB#-9&*\C-11K5! ,*)! X&88,-5;! =>>RJ!

9-(5(*'!'2(!%,&*!2(,)&*75!10!'2(!'2-((!+GH!4#(5'&1**,&-(5!&*!B,$.(!=A!

&/H0'!*c!&#5''!@/)2!"J?!1;;0M)1(!L!^:'@'2B)!/23!=#'5R;;3L=@)1#D!,UUSD!&85[)2L>5;;M(!/23!Z)99/5(D!

*++T_!

K.=!&;;0M)1!^K?I&_! %'()A2!b8/0)1B!623'\! >C=!

?A P5(!=A <88(55!@A P5(!NA <88(55!OA "9,8(!RA Q2,-,8'(-!,*)!

&**1E,'&1*!MA Q&'&e(*!5,'&50,8'&1*!DA V*'(-*,.!(*E&-1*%(*'!FA P-$,*!,*)!518&,.!

&*'(7-,'&1*!?>A +(-01-%,*8(!??A H*7&*((-&*7!?=A Q1*5'-#8'&1*!

?A P5(!=A <88(55!@A "9,8(!NA +(-01-%,*8(!OA H*7&*((-&*7!RA Q1*5'-#8'&1*!MA Q2,-,8'(-!,*)!

&**1E,'&1*!DA /1-%!,*)!%,'(-&,.5!FA V*'(-*,.!(*E&-1*%(*'!?>A P-$,*!,*)!518&,.!

&*'(7-,'&1*!

?A C,8K7-1#*)!=A B2(!$#&.)&*7!1E(-,..!@A +(-51*,.!81*'-1.!NA f#&8K*(55!10!-(591*5(!OA 3(591*5(!'1!9-1$.(%5!RA Q1%01-'!MA ]1&5(!DA b&72'&*7!FA GE(-,..!81%01-'!?>A +-1)#8'&E&':!,'!S1-K!??A [(,.'2!?=A g1#-!)(5K!1-!S1-K!,-(,!?@A B-,E(.!'1!S1-K!I19'&1*,.J!

B2(!]["!B11.K&'!S2(*!#5()!&*!2159&',.!(*E&-1*%(*'5!&5!9-1E()!'1!$(!E(-:!#5(0#.;!

&*!59&'(!10!&'5!.(*7'2:!,99-1,82!I321)(5;!=>>NJA!B2(!6fV!01-%!10!+GH!S,5!01#*)!

'1! $(! -(.(E,*'! 01-! '2(! ()#8,'&1*,.! 5(8'1-;! ,..1S&*7! 81*5&5'(*8:! &*! (E,.#,'&1*!

IQ1..:(-;! =>>OJA! 6fV! 8,*! ,.51! $(! #5()! 01-! 5',K(21.)(-! ,*,.:5&5! )#(! '1! &'5! *1*\

'(82*&8,.! 01-%,'!S&'2!)&-(8'!,99.&8,'&1*!'1!'2(!()#8,'&1*!5(8'1-!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!

,*)! X&88,-5;! =>>RJA! B2(! CP"! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! 5((K5! '1! 9-1E&)(! ,! 81%9-1%&5(!

$('S((*!'2(!*(()5!10!'2(!-(591*)(*';!),',!%,*,7(%(*';!),',!,*,.:5&5;!5','&5'&8,.!

E,.&)&':! ,*)! 4#(5'&1*! ,*5S(-&*7! E,.&)&':A! V'! #5(5! ,! -(.,'&E(.:! 5%,..! 5('! 10! K(:!

9(-01-%,*8(! &*)&8,'1-5! '2,'! 8,*! $(! (,5&.:! 81%9,-()!S&'2! 1'2(-! $#&.)&*75! '2,'!

2,E(! $((*! 5'#)&()A! V'! &5! $,5()! 1*!S2,'! (`9(-&(*8(! ,*)! 5','&5'&8,.! ,*,.:5&5! 2,5!

521S*! '1! $(! '2(! %15'! 5&7*&0&8,*'! 4#(5'&1*5A! V'! S,5! )(E(.19()! ,.1*7! S&'2! '2(!

C#&.)&*7!3(5(,-82!H5',$.&52%(*'!IC3HJ!IQ12(*!('!,.A;!=>>>JA!

Page 46: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @@!

+GH!'11.5!,-(!E,-&()!&*!*,'#-(;!5&e(;!.(E(.!10!&*'(-,8'&E&':!,*)!2(*8(!5#&',$&.&':!01-!

)&00(-(*'!$#&.)&*7!81*)&'&1*5!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*5q!&'!&5!8.(,-!'2,'!u1*(!5&e(!)1(5!*1'!

0&'!,..v;!9,-'&8#.,-.:!&*!-(59(8'!10!'2(!u95:821518&,.v!,59(8'5!10!188#9,'&1*!IQ2&71';!

=>>OJ! 1-! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.a&*)&E&)#,.! 8#.'#-,.! &*0.#(*8(5! 1*! S1-K9.,8(!

5(''&*75a5,'&50,8'&1*!IQ<CH;!=>>OJ!&*!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!

V*! )(5&7*! '(-%5! 1*(! 10! '2(! 9-1$.(%5! 10! +GH! &5! 1S*(-52&9! IB#-9&*\C-11K5! ,*)!

X&88,-5;! =>>RJA! B2(-(! ,-(! $(*(0&'5! 01-! $1'2! '2(! 8.&(*'! ,*)! )(5&7*(-! $#'! cS21!

521#.)! 9,:! 01-! &'Lt! C(8,#5(! +GH! &5! *1'! 9,-'! 10! '2(! 5',*),-)! 9-18#-(%(*'!

9-18()#-(!'2(-(!&5!.&''.(!&*8(*'&E(!01-!'2(!)(5&7*(-!I1-!'2(!9.,**(-J!'1!,))!'1!'2(!

5',*),-)! ,99-1,82! IB#-9&*\C-11K5! ,*)! X&88,-5;! =>>RJA! B2(-(! &5! ,! 4#(5'&1*! 10!

.&,$&.&':!,5!,!-(5#.'!10!,*!(E,.#,'&1*!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!B2(!+GH!

%,:! #*81E(-! 9-1$.(%5! '2,'!%,:! .,$(.! '2(! $#&.)&*7! ,5! u#*)(-! 9(-01-%&*7v! ,*)!

-()#8(!'2(!E,.#(!10!'2(!$#&.)&*7!01-!'2(!8.&(*'!IB#-9&*\C-11K5!,*)!X&88,-5;!=>>RJA!

Ih,#*e(*5! ('! ,.A;! =>>@J! (`,%&*(! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 10! +GH! ,'! )&00(-(*'! 5',7(5! 10!

188#9,*8:;! 0-1%!&*&'&,.!188#9,'&1*;!'1!,*!,**#,.!-(E&(S;!1-!9-&1-!'1!,!%1E(q! 01-!

5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! 5#82! ,5W! 8.&(*'5;! (*)\#5(-5;! 0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(-5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'!

'(,%A!P*.(55!+GH!$(81%(5!9,-'!10!'2(!5',*),-)!9-18(55!10!9-18#-(%(*'!'2(*!'2(!

$,--&(-5! %,:! *1'! $(! 1E(-81%(! '1! (*,$.(! ,! 0#..! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! 91'(*'&,.!

$(*(0&'5A! V'! &5! .&K(.:! '2,'!%,*:!8.&(*'5;!%(%$(-5!10!,!)(5&7*!1-!,!9.,**&*7! '(,%!

,*)!(*)\#5(-5!2,E(!*1'!2(,-)!10!+GH!Iz&%%(-%,*!,*)!T,-'&*;!=>>?JA!

*$U =1/M'#;03'5!@/2/A'@'21!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!&5!,..!,$1#'!'2(!%,*,7(%(*'!10!)&00(-(*'!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!%,:!

$(! ,55&7*()! '1! )&00(-(*'! 5',K(21.)(-5! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJA! B2(-(01-(! &'! &5! ,.51!

(55(*'&,.! '1! #*)(-5',*)! ,$1#'! 5',K(21.)(-! -(4#&-(%(*'5! 8,9'#-(! ,*)!

%,*,7(%(*'A!V'!&5!E&',.!&*!(*5#-&*7!,!9-1^(8'!1-!9-17-,%%(!)(.&E(-5!$(*(0&'5!01-!

,..!'2-1#721#'!&'5!.&0(8:8.(A!"',K(21.)&*7!2,5!$((*!-(817*&5()!S&'2&*!81*5'-#8'&1*!

9-1^(8'5!,5!0,-!$,8K!,5!?FR@;!,5!&)(*'&0&()!$:!-(5(,-82!#*)(-',K(*!$:!Q:(-'!,*)!

T,-82!I?FR@JA!B2(:!01#*)!'2,'!1*(!5#82!9-1^(8'!81#.)!&*E1.E(!%#.'&9.(!8.&(*'5!1-!

,8'1-5;! ,..! 10!S21%! 81#.)! 2,E(! )&00(-(*'! .(E(.5! 10! 91S(-;! &*! '(-%5! 10! &*0.#(*8(!

S2('2(-! &'! &5! 0&*,*8&,.! 1-! 91.&'&8,.A! B2&5! &)(,! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! (`&5'&*7! S&'2&*! ,!

Page 47: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @N!

81*5'-#8'&1*!9-1^(8'!2,5!5&*8(!$((*! 0#-'2(-!5#991-'()!$:!*#%(-1#5!,#'21-5!,5!

91&*'()!1#'!$:!I](S81%$(;!=>>@JA!B2(-(!,-(!,!*#%$(-!10!E,-&()!)(0&*&'&1*5!01-!

'2(!'(-%!5',K(21.)(-!0-1%!IQ,--1..!,*)!C#8221.'e;!=>>R;!d,K,$,)5(!('!,.A;!=>>N;!

d,7&17.1#!('!,.A;!?FFD;!+15'!('!,.A;!?FFO;!_2((.(-!,*)!"&..,*9{{;!?FFMJ!,*)!%,*:!

%1-(A!<!$.(*)!10!51%(!10! '2(5(!)(0&*&'&1*5! &5!#5()!,*)!,!5',K(21.)(-! &5!)(0&*()!

2(-(! ,5W! cF#! $#0$%$03./! +'! A'+32! )6.)! 6.(! .#! .,,&E)! +#! +'! $(! .,,&E)&0! C*! .#!

+'A.#$(.)$+#!.#0!$)(!.E)$+#(!.)!.#*!)$D&!.#0!$#!.#*!@.*LA!B2(! .&'(-,'#-(! &*)&8,'(5!

'2,'!5',K(21.)(-5!8,*!$(!7-1#9()!&*'1!)&00(-(*'!':9(5;!,!*#%$(-!10!S-&'(-5!2,E(!

)(0&*()!'2(5(!)&00(-(*'!7-1#95!IQ,.E(-';!?FFO;!Q,--1..!,*)!C#8221.'e;!=>>R;!+15'!

('!,.A;!?FFO;!_2((.(-!,*)!"&..,*9{{;!?FFMJ!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!B,$.(!@A!

&/H0'!-c!=1/M'#;03'5!1B['(!^./55)(D!*++S_!

I81#;5!=1/M'#;03'5!

A5;8[!I115)H81'(!

=1/M'#;03'5!

A5;8[!I115)H81'(!

Q,--1..!,*)!C#8221.'e;!I=>>RJ!

V*'(-*,.! +-1^(8'! 9,-'*(-5! S21!2,E(! ,! )&-(8'!-(.,'&1*52&9! $,5()! 1*! ,!81%%&'%(*'! ,*)!81*'-,8'! ,*)a1-! S21!9-1E&)(! 0&*,*8&,.!,55&5',*8(A! B2(:! ,-(!,00(8'()! ,*)! 8,*! ,00(8'!'2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! &'5!9-1^(8'5!

H`'(-*,.! G*! '2(! %,-7&*5! 10! '2(!9-1^(8'! a1-7,*&5,'&1*;!*1'! 81**(8'()! )&-(8'.:!$#'! S&..! 5'&..! $(! ,00(8'()!$:! ,8'&1*5! ,*)! 2,5!&*0.#(*8(! (59(8&,..:!S2(-(!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!-(9#','&1*!&5!81*8(-*()!

_2((.(-;!,*)!"&..,*9{{;!I?FFMJ!

+-&%,-:! "(81*),-:!

+15'!('!,.A;!

I?FFOJ!

X1.#*',-:! V*E1.#*',-:!

Q,--1..!,*)!C#8221.'e;!I=>>RJ!

"'-,'(7&8! X&',.!'1!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,*)!'2(!-&5K5!,*)!1991-'#*&'&(5!,'!,!59(8&0&8!

H*E&-1*%(*',.! <..!1'2(-!5',K(21.)(-5!'2,'!,-(!*(&'2(-!5'-,'(7&8!1-!81-(!

!!

Q1-(! <!5#$5('!10! '2(!5'-,'(7&8!5',K(21.)(-5!

_2((.(-;!,*)!"&..,*9{{;!I?FFMJ!

"18&,.! V*)&E&)#,.5!a7-1#95!,00(8'()!$:!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,*)!&'5!9-1^(8'!

]1*\518&,.! B2(5(!,-(!*1*\2#%,*!1-!:('!81*8(&E()!5',K(21.)(-5!,00(8'()!$:!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,*)!&'5!,8'&1*5!

V'! %#5'! $(! -(%(%$(-()! '2,'! &'! &5! (,5:! 01-! 5',K(21.)(-5! '1! ^#%9! 0-1%! 1*(!

5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#9! '1! ,*1'2(-A! ! /1-! (`,%9.(! ,*! &*)&E&)#,.! 1-! 7-1#9! 81#.)! $(!

2(,E&.:! &*E1.E()! )#-&*7! ,! 9,-'&8#.,-! 91&*'! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,'! S2&82! '&%(! '2(&-!

5',K(21.)(-! 5','#5! 81#.)! $(! 5((*! '1! $(! E&',.! ,*)! '2(-(01-(!

Page 48: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @O!

&*'(-*,.a9-&%,-:aE1.#*',-:a5'-,'(7&8!1-!81-(q!21S(E(-!1*8(!'2(&-!9,-'&8&9,'&1*!

,*)! )&-(8'! &*E1.E(%(*'! 2,)! 0&*&52()! '2(:! 81#.)! 4#&'(! (,5&.:! %1E(! &*'1! '2(!

(`'(-*,.a5(81*),-:a&*E1.#*',-:!1-!(*E&-1*%(*',.!7-1#9A!B2&5!&5!S2(-(!$(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!81%(5!&*'1!(00(8'!K((9&*7!'2(!5',K(21.)(-!(*7,7()!'2-1#721#'!'2(!

.&0(8:8.(!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!

"',K(21.)(-5! 100(-! '1! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*! ,--,:! 10! -(51#-8(5! ,*)! ,55('5! '2(:!

&*8.#)(!I+15'!('!,.A;!?FFOJW!

• Q,9&',.q!

• d*1S.()7(q!

• "18&,.!,88(9',*8(q!

• b&8(*5(!'1!19(-,'(q!,*)!

• 3(E(*#(A!

H,82!5',K(21.)(-!2,5!'2(&-!1S*!&%91-',*'!-1.(;!&)(*'&0:&*7!'2(5(!,5!S(..!,5!'2(&-!

-(591*5&$&.&'&(5!,*)!$(*(0&'5!,-(!(`'-(%(.:! &%91-',*'A! V'! &5!(59(8&,..:! &%91-',*'!

S2(*!82,*7(5!S&'2&*!'2(!7-1#9!188#-A!

B2(!#5(!10!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!2,5!$(81%(!9,-'!10!'2(!),&.:!-(591*5&$&.&':!

10! ,! 81%9,*:A! B2(! &*8-(,5()!#5(! 10! 5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! &'5! '11.5! 2,5!

$((*! ,!)&-(8'! -(5#.'! 10! 7-1S&*7! 81%9('&'&1*! 8,#5()!$:! 7.1$,.&5,'&1*! I"82,-&1'2!

,*)![#$(-;!=>>RJA!

/1-! 5',K(21.)(-! %,*,7(%(*'! '1! 188#-! (00(8'&E(.:! &'! &5! *(8(55,-:! 01-! ,..!

5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! ,*)! &*)&E&)#,.5! '1! $(! 81*5&)(-()A! B2(-(! ,-(! ,! *#%$(-! 10!

'2&*75!'2,'!521#.)!$(!81*5&)(-()!)#-&*7!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!,5!91&*'()!1#'!

$:!+15'!('!,.A!I?FFOJ!&*![,--&5!I=>>DJW!

• C(*(0&'! 0.1S5! Z! '2&5! 71(5! '1! ,*)! 0-1%! $('S((*! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! ,*)!

1-7,*&5,'&1*q!

• T#.'&9.(!.&*K,7(5!Z!,..!5',K(21.)(-5!8,*!$(!&*E1.E()!S&'2!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,'!

'2(! 5,%(! '&%(;! S2&82! %,:! -(5#.'! &*! .&*K5! $('S((*! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5!

'2(%5(.E(5q!

Page 49: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @R!

• "&%#.',*(1#5! -1.(5! Z! 5',K(21.)(-5! 8,*!9.,:!%1-(! '2,'!1*(! -1.(! ,'! '2(! 5,%(!

'&%(!(A7A!,*!(%9.1:((!8,*!,.51!$(!,!52,-(21.)(-!1-!81*5#%(-q!

• V55#(!E,-&,*8(!Z! 0,8'1-5! 82,*7(!)#-&*7!,!9-1^(8'! (A7A! '-#5'! &5!1*.:!$#&.'!1E(-!

'&%(;!1-!,*!&55#(!%,:!%(,*!%1-(!'1!1*(!5',K(21.)(-!'2,*!'1!,*1'2(-A!

V'!S1#.)!$(! ,)E&5,$.(! 01-! ,! 81%%#*&8,'&1*! 5'-,'(7:! '1! $(! 5('! #9! 01-! '2&5! '1! $(!

,82&(E()!I[:*)5!,*)!T,-'&*;!?FFOJA!<5!S(..!,5!(00(8'&E(!81%%#*&8,'&1*;!,!2&72!

.(E(.! 10! '-#5'! $('S((*! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! 5',K(21.)(-! &5! *(8(55,-:! ,*)! '2&5!

*(()5! '1! -(%,&*! '2-1#72! 1#'! '2(! 9-1^(8'A! B21%,5! ,*)! B21%,5! I=>>OJ! S1#.)!

5#991-'!'2&5q! '2(:!$(.&(E(!'2,'!2,E&*7!,..!5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()!0-1%!'2(!1#'5('!

2(.95!'2(!'(,%!'1!$(81%(!&*'(7-,'()!S&'2!,!81%%1*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!,*)!52,-()!

K*1S.()7(A!B2(!5,%(!,#'21-5!,.51!5#77(5'!'2(!01..1S&*7!,-(!E&',.!&*!(5',$.&52&*7!

(00(8'&E(!5',K(21.)(-!81%%#*&8,'&1*W!!

• "#%%,-:!,*)!8.(,-!-1.(5!10!,*! &*'(7-,'()! '(,%!S1-K&*7!,5! &'!,99.&(5! '1! '2(!

9-1^(8'q!

• B2(!&55#(!-(51.#'&1*!9-18(55q!

• B2(!8.&(*'5!E,.#(!8-&'(-&,q!

• d+V5!,*)!&%9-1E(%(*'!',-7('5q!

• H`9.,*,'&1*5!10!9-1^(8'!,8-1*:%5!,*)!^,-71*q!

• H`(8#'&E(! 5#%%,-&(5! 10! E,.#(! ,*)! -&5K! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! 9,-'*(-&*7!

S1-K52195q!

• P9\'1\),'(!9,-'*(-&*7!,*)a1-!9-1^(8'!'&%(',$.(5q!

• "82()#.(! 10! ,..! 81-(! 7-1#9! ,*)! 9,-'*(-&*7! '(,%! %(('&*75;! S1-K52195! ,*)!

518&,.!(E(*'5q!

• V*01-%,'&1*!1*!S2(-(!1-!0-1%!S21!0#-'2(-!&*01-%,'&1*!8,*!$(!1$',&*()A!

[,E&*7! '2&5! K*1S.()7(! %(,*5! '2,'! (E(-:$1):! &5! ,S,-(! 10! ,..! 5',K(21.)(-5!

&*E1.E();! '2(&-! -1.(! S&'2&*! '2(! 81%9,*:! ,*)! -(4#&-(%(*'5;! '2&5! %(,*5! '2,'!

81%%#*&8,'&1*! $('S((*! '2(%! 521#.)! $(! (,5&(-;! S2&82! S&..! .(,)! '1! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-!7-1#95!%1-(!-(,)&.:!'1!'-#5'!(,82!1'2(-A!B2(5(!%('21)5!S1#.)!2,E(!

'1! $(! #*)(-9&**()! $:! ,*! (00(8'&E(! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*'! 5'-,'(7:;! S2(*!

81*5&)(-&*7!'2(!&*'-1)#8'&1*!10!,!*(S!9-18(55!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!!

Page 50: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @M!

B2(! '(82*&4#(5! &..#5'-,'(! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! 52,-()! K*1S.()7(;! 711)!

81%%#*&8,'&1*!,*)! '-#5'!$('S((*!5',K(21.)(-5!S&'2&*!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*;!,5!S(..!

,5!'2(!&%91-',*8(!10!,*!(00(8'&E(!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:!,..!10!S2&82!2,E(!

$((*!)&58#55()!,5!&%91-',*'!9,-'5!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'A!V0!,..!8,*!$(!,),9'()!

B21%,5!,*)!B21%,5!I=>>OJ!$(.&(E(!'2,'!,!5%11'2!8-155!1E(-!$('S((*!9(-51**(.!

8,*! 188#-! ,*)! #.'&%,'(.:! ,! -()#8'&1*! &*! '2(! E1.#%(! 10! 915'\81%9.('&1*! #5(-!

9-1$.(%5!,*)!81%9.,&*'5;!-(S1-K!,*)!&*8-(,5()!#5(-!5,'&50,8'&1*A!

*$U$, =1/M'#;03'5(d!5']8)5'@'21(!/23!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!

G*(!10! '2(!%,&*!)&00&8#.'&(5!10!2,E&*7!,!*#%$(-!10! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()! &5! '2(!

)&00(-(*'!1$^(8'&E(5!,*)!)(%,*)5!(,82!10! '2(!7-1#95a&*)&E&)#,.5!21.)5! '2,'!,-(!

,'! '&%(5! 81*0.&8'&*7! I<:#51! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJ;! '2&5! 0-(4#(*'.:! 188#-5! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 10!

81*5'-#8'&1*! 9-1^(8'5! ,*)! 2(,.'28,-(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! IQ,--#'2(-5! ('! ,.A;! =>>R;!

G.,*)(-!,*)!b,*)&*;!=>>OJ!<*!(`,%9.(!10!'2&5!S&'2&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!

S1#.)!$(!'2(!9-18#-(%(*'!10!,!9-&%,-:!2(,.'2!8,-(!$#&.)&*7;!'2(!$#&.)(-5!S&..!$(!

S1-K&*7!'1!,!9,-'&8#.,-!)(5&7*;!.18,'&1*;!815'!,*)!'&%(;!21S(E(-!'2(!81%%#*&':!

%,:!$(!#*2,99:!S&'2!'2(!.18,'&1*!10!'2&5!$#&.)&*7A!B2&5!K&*)!10!81*0.&8'!$('S((*!

'2(! 'S1! 5',K(21.)(-5! 8,*! 8,#5(! )&5-#9'&1*! '1! '2(! S21.(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! 81#.)!

91'(*'&,..:! .(,)!'1!'2(!(*)!10! &'A!Q1%9.(`&'&(5!,'!,!5',K(21.)(-!.(E(.!,.51!.(,)!'1!

81%9.(`&'&(5!&*!-(4#&-(%(*'5!8,9'#-(a%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55(5!IBe1-'e191#.15!('!

,.A;!=>>RJA![1S(E(-!'2&5!K&*)!10!5&'#,'&1*!8,*!$(!-(51.E()!S&'2!'2(!2(.9!10!1'2(-!

5',K(21.)(-5!$(81%&*7!%1-(!&*E1.E()!'1!'-:!,*)!,99(,5(!'2(!5&'#,'&1*!'&72'(*&*7!

'2(&-! -(.,'&1*52&95;! ,*)! '2(! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(-! 81%%#*&8,'&*7! 0.#(*'.:! ,*)!

(00(8'&E(.:! '1! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5! -(817*&5&*7! '2(&-! 81*8(-*5! S&'2! ,*! ,''(%9'! '1!

-(81*8&.(! '2(%! IG.,*)(-! ,*)! b,*)&*;! =>>OJA! ! C(&*7! ,S,-(! 10! '2(! )&00(-(*'!

-(4#&-(%(*'5!2(.)!$:!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!&5!E&',.!'1!(*5#-&*7!'2(!5%11'2!9-18(55!10!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'A!

G'2(-! '(*5&1*5! '2,'! 8,*! (`&5'! $('S((*! 5',K(21.)(-5;! (59(8&,..:! '215(! S&'2&*!

81*5'-#8'&1*!9-1^(8'5!,-(!)#(!'1!I](S81%$(;!=>>@JW!

• b1*7!'(-%!E(-5#5!521-'\'(-%!1$^(8'&E(5q!

Page 51: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @D!

• f#,*'&':!E(-5#5!4#,.&':q!

• Q15'!(00&8&(*8:!E(-5#5!^1$5q!

• Q1*'-1.!E(-5#5!&*)(9(*)(*8(A!

B2(5(! '(*5&1*5! ,*)! 9-()&8,%(*'5! 521S! '2,'! '2(! -(.,'&1*52&9! $('S((*! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-5!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*!&5!'S1!S,:;!$1'2!8,*!2,E(!,*!&%9,8'!1*!'2(!1'2(-q!

'2(:! 8,*! $(! ,00(8'()! $:! '2(! $(2,E&1#-;! )(8&5&1*5;! 91.&8&(5;! 1$^(8'&E(5! ,*)!

9-,8'&8(5!10!'2(!1'2(-A!6#(!'1!'2&5!,*)!'2(!-(817*&'&1*!10!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5L!-1.(!&*!

5#88(550#.! $#5&*(55(5;! )&00(-(*'! %('21)5! ,-(! $(&*7! #5()! '1! %,*,7(! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-! -(.,'&1*52&9;! ,*:! 82,*7(! '2,'! %,:! 188#-! ,*)! '2(! 9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(!

IC-,).(:;!=>>RJ!'2(5(!&*8.#)(W!

• 6(E(.19&*7! ,'! '2(! (,-.:! 92,5(! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'! ,*! (00(8'&E(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*5!

5'-,'(7:q!

• 6(E(.19%(*'!10!,!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! 01-! '2(!S21.(! .&0(!8:8.(!

10!'2(!9-1^(8'q!

• B2(!(,-.:!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! 0-,%(S1-K!S1#.)!2(.9! &*!

'2&5!5&'#,'&1*A!

<:#51!('!,.A! I=>>RJ!$(.&(E(! '2,'! '2(! -(4#&-(%(*'5;!*(()5!,*)!,&%5!10! 8#5'1%(-!

,*)! (%9.1:((! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! 8,*! $(! &)(*'&0&()! ,*)! ,82&(E()! '2-1#72! '2(!

5&%#.',*(1#5!#5(!10!'2(!01..1S&*7!8,9,$&.&'&(5W!

• "',K(21.)(-!)&,.17#(!Z!,..1S5!81*'&*#1#5!'S1!S,:!81%%#*&8,'&1*!$('S((*!

5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! ,*)! 81%9,*:;! 81*8(*'-,'&*7! 1*! .&5'(*&*7! S&'2!

#*)(-5',*)&*7!,..1S&*7!2&))(*!$(.&(05!,*)! &)(,5! '1!$(!(`9-(55()! .(,)&*7! '1!

'-,*59,-(*8:!,*)!$#&.)&*7!'-#5'A!!B2&5!#.'&%,'(.:!,..1S5!'2(!7-1#9!'1!&)(*'&0:!

,*)!018#5!1*!81%%1*!&*'(-(5'5q!

• "',K(21.)(-! K*1S.()7(! &*'(7-,'&1*! Z! 0-1%! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! )&,.17#(!

5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!,$.(!'1!7,&*!$1'2!9-,8'&8,.!,*)!8-(,'&E(!K*1S.()7(!0-1%!1*(!

,*1'2(-A! ! /-1%! '2&5! K*1S.()7(! &)(,5a9-1)#8'5a5(-E&8(5a&**1E,'&1*5! ,&%()!

,'! %(('&*7! '2(! -(4#&-(%(*'5! ,*)! (`9(8','&1*5! 10! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,-(!

-(,.&5()A!

Page 52: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! @F!

B2(5(! 8,9,$&.&'&(5!S1#.)! $(! &%91-',*'! &*! &)(*'&0:&*7! ,*)! -(,.&5&*7! '2(! $(*(0&'5!

01-!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!'2-1#721#'!,!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55A!

"',K(21.)(-!)&,.17#(!8,*!188#-!9,55&E(.:! '2-1#72!8,..!8(*'-(5;! .(''(-5!1-!(%,&.5!

1-!,8'&E(!'2-1#72!%('21)5!5#82!,5!%(('&*75!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!5'-#8'#-(!I<:#51!

('!,.A;!=>>RJA!/1-!,*:!10!'2(!'11.5!10!5',K(21.)(-!)&,.17#(!'1!$(!(00(8'&E(!,..!9(19.(!

&*E1.E()! 2,E(! '1! (*5#-(! '2(:! ,-(! 21*(5'! ,*)! 9-(5(*'! $1'2! '-,*59,-(*'! ,*)!

9-(8&5(! &*01-%,'&1*A! <.'21#72! 5:5'(%5! ,*)! 9-18()#-(5! 8,*! $(! 9#'! &*! 9.,8(! '1!

,''(%9'! '1! (*5#-(! '2(5(! 9-18(55(5! 188#-;! '2(5(! ,-(! $,5()! 1*! &*',*7&$.(! ,55('5!

S2&82! ,-(! 9155(55()! $:! '2(! &*)&E&)#,.5! S&'2&*! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! ,*)! 81%9,*:!

7-1#95;! '2(-(01-(! &'! 81#.)! $(! 2,-)! 01-! ,! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(-! '1! (*5#-(! '2,'! ,..!

9-18(55(5! S(-(! $(&*7! #*)(-',K(*! &*! '2(! 81--(8'! %,**(-A! <:#51! ('! ,.A;! I=>>RJ!

$(.&(E(!'2,'!'2&5!9-1$.(%!8,*!,'! '&%(5!$(!-(51.E()!S&'2!5'-#8'#-(5!,*)!5:5'(%5!

'2,'! ,-(! $,5()! 1*! S2,'! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! E,.#(! ,*)! '2(-(01-(! -(4#&-(%(*';! &0! ,!

5:5'(%! &5! $,5()! 1*! 51%('2&*7! '2,'! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! $(.&(E(5! S&..! $(*(0&'! '2(%!

'2(:!,-(!%1-(!S&..&*7!'1!,)2(-(!'1!'2(%A!

<82&(E&*7!5#88(550#.!82,*7(!&5!%#82!(,5&(-!&0!,..!5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!81%%&''();!'2(!

(,-.&(-! '2&5! 81%%&'%(*'! &5! ,881%9.&52();! '2(! 5%1'2(-! '2(! 9,'2! '1! ,! 5#88(550#.!

1#'81%(!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!V*!1-)(-!'1!(*7,7(!,*)!&*E1.E(!5',K(21.)(-5!'2(:!0&-5'!

*(()! '1! $(! &)(*'&0&()A! <'! '2(! (,-.:! 5',7(5! 10! ,! 9-17-,%%(;! 9-1^(8'! 1-! ,! 82,*7(!

9-18(55!'2(!5',K(21.)(-!919#.,'&1*!%,:$(!,!.&''.(!0.#&)A!B2(!9-18(55!'2(-(01-(!10!

&)(*'&0:&*7! '2(%!*(()5! '1! $(! &'(-,'&E(A! B1! (*5#-(! '2,'! ,..! 5',K(21.)(-5! $(81%(!

81%%&''()! &'! &5! &%91-',*'! '1! (*7,7(! '2(%!(00(8'&E(.:;! '2-1#721#'! '2(! 81%9.('(!

82,*7(!.&0(8:8.(A!

B2(!81*8(9'!10!%,*,7&*7!$(*(0&'5!&*!1-)(-!'1!(*5#-(!'2(&-!)(.&E(-:!&5!#5#,..:!*(S!

S&'2&*!,!5(8'1-!1-!1-7,*&5,'&1*A!B2(!E,-&1#5!5',K(21.)(-5!S&..!*(()!()#8,'&*7!&*!

21S!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!&)(*'&0&();!%1)(..()!,*)!5#$5(4#(*'.:!)(.&E(-()!I3(&55!('!

,.A;!=>>RJA!V'!S1#.)!$(!-&5K:!'1!,55#%(!'2,'!,..!5',K(21.)(-5!S&..!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!

&%9.&8,'&1*5! 10! $(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)! 9.,**&*7A! d,7&17.1#! ('! ,.A;! I=>>>J!

2&72.&72'! '2,'! 9-1^(8'! 5#88(55! -(.&(5! 1*! '2(! -&72'! 9(19.(! 2,E&*7! '2(! -&72'!

&*01-%,'&1*! ,'! '2(! -&72'! '&%(! 5','&*7! '2,'! '2(! ,8'&E(! &*E1.E(%(*'! 10! ,..!

Page 53: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! N>!

9,-'&8&9,*'5;!(59(8&,..:!&*!'2(!(,-.:!92,5(!10!,!9-1^(8';!%,:!5#$5(4#(*'.:!2(.9!'1!

015'(-! ,! '(,%! (*E&-1*%(*'! ,*)! (*81#-,7(! ,99-19-&,'(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*! ,*)!

)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7A!

*$,+ 6215;3891);2!1;!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/[[5;/9#!!

B2(! T8Q,-'*(:! -(91-';! T1)(-*&5&*7! U1E(-*%(*'! &*! <8'&1*! I=>>>J! 5','(5! '2,'W!

c+-1^(8'5! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(5! 8,*! 1*.:! $(! -(7,-)()! ,5! 5#88(550#.! &0! '2(! &*'(*)()!

$(*(0&'5! ,-(! -(,.&5()L! S2&82! &*0.#(*8()! '2(! &*&'&,'&1*! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82! ,5!

&*'-1)#8()! &*! 82,9'(-! ?A! <! 81%%1*! 82,-,8'(-&5'&8! 10! %,*:! #*5#88(550#.!

9-17-,%%(5! &5! '2(! E,7#(*(55! S&'2! S2&82! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! )(0&*()!

I3(&55;!=>>RJA!_&'21#'!8.(,-.:!)(0&*()!1$^(8'&E(5! &'! &5!)&00&8#.'! '1!%,&*',&*!018#5!

S2(*!5#$5(4#(*'!9-1$.(%5!188#-A!!

+-1^(8'5! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(5! ,-(! 7(*(-,..:! )-&E(*! $:! ,! *(()! '1! -(,.&5(! 59(8&0&8!

$(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! 5'-#8'#-()! 82,*7(A! T1-(! -(8(*'.:;! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! I,*)!

%,*,7(%(*'J!2,5!$((*!-,&5()!,5!'2(!u*(Sv!9-,8'&8(!01-!9-&E,'(!,*)!9#$.&8!5(8'1-!

9-17-,%%(5! &*! ,! )&E(-5&':! 10! 5(8'1-5;! &*8.#)&*7! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(;!

21#5&*7!)(E(.19%(*'5!,*)!()#8,'&1*A!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&5!'2(!(E1.#'&1*!0-1%!,!

7(*(-,.! &*E(5'%(*'! 9-17-,%%(! ,99-,&5,.! ,99-1,82! I#5#,..:! $,5()! 1*! 815';!

4#,.&':!,*)!'&%(J;!'1!,*!,8'&E(!9.,**&*7!,99-1,82!5#991-'()!$:!$(*(0&'5!9.,**();!

)(.&E(-()!,*)!-(,.&5()!I1-!*1'J!$:!5',K(21.)(-5!IU.:**(;!=>>MJA!

B-#,`! I?FFMJ! &*! b&*! r! +(-E,*! I=>>@J! 5#77(5'! ,! *#%$(-! 10! -(,51*5! 01-!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!*1'!7(''&*7!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2(:!(`9(8'()W!

• V%%()&,'(!-(5#.'5!10!,*!&*E(5'%(*'!,-(!-,-(.:!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5q!

• ](8(55,-:!%(,*5!01-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,-(!*1'!&)(*'&0&()q!

• C(*(0&'5!)1!*1'!188#-!S2(-(!,*)!S2(*!'2(:!,-(!9.,**()q!

• B2(!cc-&72'LL!$(*(0&'5!,-(!)&00&8#.'!'1!&)(*'&0:!#9!0-1*'q!

• +-1^(8'5!,-(!'11!*,--1S.:!)(0&*()!01-!(00(8'&E(!)(.&E(-:!10!$(*(0&'5q!

• G-7,*&5,'&1*5!10'(*!2,E(!,!.&%&'()!,$&.&':!'1!%,*,7(!82,*7(A!

Page 54: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! N?!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! &5!)(0&*()!,5! '2(!9-18(55! 01-! '2(!19'&%&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5!

0-1%! ,! 9-17-,%%(L5! 82,*7(! 9(-59(8'&E(! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! ](E(-'2(.(55;! '2(!

81*8(9'!10!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &5!*1'!*(S! I"&%1*;!=>>@;! &*!]17(5'(;!=>>RJ!,*)!

*(&'2(-!&5!'2(!,S,-(*(55!10!'2(!.&*K5!$('S((*!9-1^(8'!,*)!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

,5!(E&)(*8()!$:!,!5#-E(:!),'&*7!0-1%!?FF>!'2,'!01#*)!'2(!c*#%$(-!1*(L!8,#5(!10!

&*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%a&*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:! IV"aVBJ! 9-1^(8'! 0,&.#-(! '1! $(! u'2(!

E,7#(!5','(%(*'!10!$(*(0&'5;! .(,)&*7!'1!,*!#*8(-',&*!,..18,'&1*!10!-(591*5&$&.&':!

01-!%,*,7&*7!'2(&-!)(.&E(-:!Ib&*!,*)!+(-E,*;!=>>?JA!

B2(!(`&5'(*'!.&'(-,'#-(!1*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!81*5&5'5!%,&*.:!10!9-,8'&8,.!7#&)(5!

,*)! 0-,%(S1-K5! ,-1#*)! &*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:! a! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5! IVBaV"J!

9-1^(8'!&*E(5'%(*'!^#5'&0&8,'&1*!S&'2&*!'2(!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-A!!

C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! -(,.&5&*7! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 0-1%! &*E(5'%(*'5! %,)(!

(59(8&,..:!$:!'215(!&*!VB!5:5'(%5!$(8,%(!,*!&%91-',*'!,-(,!&*!'2(!.,'(!?FD>5!,*)!

(,-.:!?FF>5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!

B2(!&*8-(,5(!10!&*'(-(5'!&*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!2,5!81&*8&)()!S&'2!'2(!&*8-(,5&*7!

#5(! ,*)! 81%9.(`&':! 10! VB! I<52#-5'! ,*)! 612(-':;! =>>@;! _,-)! ,*)! H.E&*;! ?FFF;!

C-,).(:;!=>>RJA!V'!2,5!$((*!-(817*&5()!'2,';!&0!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!&5!&*E(5'&*7!,!.1'!10!

%1*(:!&*'1!,!*(S!5:5'(%!'2(:!S,*'!'1!(*5#-(!,*)!5((!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!'2(:!7('!

0-1%! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'A! B2&5! '2(:! )(0&*(! ,5! c'2(! 9-18(55! 10! 1-7,*&5&*7! ,*)!

%,*,7&*7;!5#82!'2,'!'2(!91'(*'&,.!$(*(0&'5!,-&5&*7!0-1%!'2(!#5(!10!VB!,-(!,8'#,..:!

-(,.&5()LA!

<5!81%9('&'&1*!)#(!'1!7.1$,.&5,'&1*! &*8-(,5(5! &'! &5!(E(-!%1-(! &%91-',*'! '2,'!,*!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!9(-01-%5!'1!&'5!$(5'!8,9,$&.&'&(5!I<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':;!=>>@JA!+-10&'!

%,K&*7! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! %,K&*7! &*E(5'%(*'5! *(()! '1! K*1S! '2,'! '2(5(! ,-(!

S1-'2S2&.(;! '2,'! '2(:! ,-(! &%9-1E&*7! '2(! 9(-01-%,*8(! 10! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)!

#.'&%,'(.:! .(,)&*7! '1! &*8-(,5()!9-10&'5A!B2(! .,''(-!)1(5!*1'!*(8(55,-&.:!,99.:! &*!

'2(!9#$.&8!5(8'1-!S2(-(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!%(,5#-()!&*!'(-%5!10!E,.#(!01-!%1*(:!,*)!

5(-E&8(! 4#,.&':A! B2&5! &5! S2(-(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! $(81%(5!%1-(! &%91-',*'! ,5!

'2&5!%('21)!8,*!$(!#5()!'1!-(,.&5(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!0-1%!'2(!82,*7(5!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!

&5!%,K&*7A!

Page 55: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! N=!

B21-9! I?FFDJ! &*'-1)#8()! '2(! '(-%! c"&.E(-! $#..('! '2&*K&*7L! (`9.,&*&*7! &'! ,5! '2(!

*,&E(!$(.&(0!'2,'!c$#5&*(55!51.#'&1*5L!81%(!*(,'.:!9,8K,7()!,*)!5',%9()!c$(*(0&'5!

&*5&)(L;! -(&*01-8&*7! '2(! &)(,! '2,'!,..!:1#!2,E(! '1!)1! &5!9.#7! &*! '2(! '(82*1.17:!1-!

2,*)1E(-!'2(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!,*)!%,7&8,..:!$(*(0&'5!S&..!0.1SA!

<881-)&*7! '1! B-#,`! I?FFMJ;! 5((! b&*! ,*)! +(-E,*! I=>>?J;! '2(-(! 2,5! $((*! ,!

9,-,)&7%!52&0'! &*! '2(!E&(S!10!$(*(0&'5! ,*)! &'! &5! '2(-(01-(!*(()()! '1! 82,*7(! '2(!

%,*,7(%(*'!0-1%!9,55&E(.:!%,*,7&*7!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'1!,!9-1,8'&E(!%,*,7(%(*'!10!

$(*(0&'5!IB,$.(!NJA!

&/H0'!Pc!"/5/3)A@!(#)71!7;5!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!^&58/\D!,UUO_!

&5/3)1);2/0!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5)29)[0'(! K'R!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5)29)[0'(!

C(*(0&'5!,-(!5',$.(!1E(-!'&%(! B2(! 91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! 0-1%! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! 82,*7(!

1E(-!'&%(!

B2(! &*E(5'%(*'!)('(-%&*(5! '2(!*,'#-(! ,*)! 5819(!10!

$(*(0&'5!

B2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! &'5! $#5&*(55! 81*'(`'!

)('(-%&*(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

/&*,*8&,.! -('#-*5! -(9-(5(*'! '2(! %15'! E,.&)!

^#5'&0&8,'&1*!01-!,*!&*E(5'%(*'!

<..! '2(! 1#'81%(5! 10! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! -(9-(5(*'!

91'(*'&,.!51#-8(5!10!E,.#(!

V'! &5!5#00&8&(*'!'1!%,*,7(!'2(!&*E(5'%(*'!'1!7(*(-,'(!

'2(!$(*(0&'5!

B2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! %#5'! $(! 9-1,8'&E(! &*! -(,.&5&*7!

$(*(0&'5!

V*!%,*:!.,-7(!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!,*)!81%9.(`!9#$.&8!&*'(-(5'!5(8'1-!9-17-,%%(5!,*)!

9-1^(8'5! 0,&.#-(! '1! &)(*'&0:! ,*)! ,82&(E(! 9.,**()! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! 82,*7(!

&*&'&,'&E(5!,99(,-5!'1!$(!81%%1*!IC,-'.('';!=>>RJA!V*!7(*(-,.!'2(!4#(5'&1*!&5!1*(!

10!'2(!)&00&8#.':!10!%,*,7&*7!2&72.:!81%9.(`!9-17-,%%(5;!91-'01.&15!1-!9-1^(8'5!

-,'2(-!'2,*!.,8K!10!9(-01-%,*8(!10!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A!b,8K!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

&5!10'(*!,!-11'!8,#5(!10!9-17-,%%(!0,&.#-(;!$#'!(4#,..:!),%,7&*7!&5!911-!$(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*';! '2,'! ,''(%9'5! '1! %,*,7(! $(*(0&'5;! S&'21#'! -(817*&'&1*! 10! '2(!

81*'-&$#'1-5! '1! 5#88(55A! B2(! ',5K! &5;! '2(-(01-(;! 81%9.(`;! ,*)! )(%,*)5! ,! S&)(!

59,*!10!81*'-1.!IC,-'.('';!=>>RJA!

Q15'5!,*)!$(*(0&'5! 8,**1'!$(!E&(S()! &*! &51.,'&1*!,*)! '2(!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

9-18(55! ,*)! '2(! 1E(-,..! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 521#.)! $(! 9.,*()! '17('2(-A! B2(!

Page 56: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! N@!

1*71&*7! 815'5! ,*)! -&5K5!S&..! #5#,..:!$(!%1*&'1-();! $#'! '2(! ,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5!

,-(! *1'! 51! (,5:! '1! )(0&*(! ,*)! 4#,*'&0:! IGUQ;! =>>@JA! C(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'!

(*5#-(5! '2,'! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(! ,82&(E(5! '2(! (`9(8'()! -(5#.'5! $:! '-,*5.,'&*7!

$#5&*(55! 1$^(8'&E(5! &*'1! &)(*'&0&,$.(! %(,5#-,$.(! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! 8,*! $(!

5:5'(%,'&8,..:! '-,8K()! IGUQ;! =>>@;! +,:*(;! =>>M;! 3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! C(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'! 81%9-&5(5! 10! ,! -,*7(! 10! %,*,7(%(*'! ,8'&E&'&(5! )(5&7*! '1! (*5#-(!

'2,'! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! -(,.&5(5! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 0-1%! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;!

?FFFJ! 5#82! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,-(! $#&.'! 1*! '2(! #*)(-.:&*7! -,'&1*,.(! '2,'! '2(! 815'! 10! ,*!

&*E(5'%(*'!*(()5!'1!$(!-(.,'()!'1!'2(!$(*(0&'5A!G*(!10!'2(!9-1$.(%5!S&'2!'2&5!&5!

'2,'! '2(! 815'5! '(*)! '1! $(! &*8#--()! &%%()&,'(.:;! S2(-(,5! $(*(0&'5! 188#-! &*! '2(!

0#'#-(!Ib1E(!('!,.A;!=>>NJA!

*$,, >'2'7)1(!1'5@)2;0;AB!

<.'21#72! '2(! S1-)! L$(*(0&'L! &5! #5()! S&)(.:! &*! (E(-:),:! .&0(! &'! &5! E(-:! 911-.:!

)(0&*()A!V'!8,*!5&%9.:!$(!&*'-1)#8()!,5!c,!%(,5#-,$.(!&%9-1E(%(*'LA!<!$(*(0&'!c&5!

,*! 1#'81%(! S215(! *,'#-(! ,*)! E,.#(! ,-(! 81*5&)(-()! ,)E,*',7(1#5! $:! ,*!

1-7,*&5,'&1*ALIGUQ;!=>>M$;!B21-9;!?FFD;!_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFOJA!

C-,).(:!I=>>RJ!)(0&*(5!&'!,5!,*!1#'81%(!10!82,*7(!S2&82!&5!9(-8(&E()!,5!915&'&E(!

$:!,!5',K(21.)(-!,*)!01..1S&*7!'2(!5,%(!'21#72'!_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.!I=>>RJ!)(0&*(!

&'! ,5! c,*! ,)E,*',7(! 1*! ,! $(2,.0! 10! ,! 9,-'&8#.,-! 5',K(21.)(-! 1-! 7-1#9! 10!

5',K(21.)(-5L!B2(!&%91-',*'!91&*'!&*!'2(!'S1!.,'(-!)(0&*&'&1*5!&5!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!,-(!

1S*()!$:! &*)&E&)#,.5!1-! 7-1#95!S21!S,*'! '1!1$',&*!E,.#(! 0-1%!,*! &*E(5'%(*'!

IU.:**(;!=>>MJA!

+,:*(!I=>>MJ!,-7#(5!'2,'!%15'!9(19.(L5!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

&5! 8.15(-! '1!S2,'! &5!)(58-&$()!,5!9-1^(8'! 0&*,*8&,.!E,.#(!,99-,&5,.A!B2(-(01-(!2(!

&*'-1)#8(5!)(0&*&'&1*5!,*)!)&00(-(*'&,'(5!$('S((*!'(-%5! c1#'81%(L;! c$(*(0&'L!,*)!

0&*,*8&,.!&%9,8'A!!

• G#'81%(!2,5!'S1!%(,*&*75!)(9(*)&*7!1*!&'5!81*'(`'A!<'!%,8-1!.(E(.;!)(5&-()!

1#'81%(5!,-(!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!82,*7(5!'2,'!,!9-17-,%%(!&5!)(5&7*()!'1!0#.0&.A!<'!

Page 57: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! NN!

%&8-1!.(E(.;!1#'81%(5!,-(!'2(!82,*7(5!'1!),:\'1!Z),:!19(-,'&1*5!'2,'!9-1^(8'!

1#'9#'5!8,#5(q!

• C(*(0&'5!,-(!%(,5#-,$.(!&%9-1E(%(*'5!-(5#.'&*7!0-1%!1#'81%(5q!

• /&*,*8&,.! &%9,8'! &5! '2(! &%9-1E(%(*'! &*!$#5&*(55! 0&*,*8&,.!9(-01-%,*8(! '2,'!

-(5#.'5!)&-(8'.:!1-!&*)&-(8'.:;!0-1%!,82&(E(%(*'!10!1*(!1-!%1-(!$(*(0&'5A!

/&7#-(!M!$(.1S!&..#5'-,'(5!,!-(.,'&1*52&9!$('S((*!$(*(0&'5!,*)!1#'81%(5!,*)!'2(!

82,&*!10!21S!1*(!S&..! &*0.#(*8(!1-!)(-&E(!'1!'2(!1'2(-! &*!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!

5(''&*7A!

!

X)A85'!Oc!4#/)2!;7!H'2'7)1(!75;@!;81[81!1;!;HQ'91)<'!^JE4D!*++O_!

G#'81%(5! ,-(! *1'! ,.S,:5! (`9(8'()! ,*)! 915&'&E(;! '2(!%,:! ,.51! $(! *(7,'&E(! ,*)!

#*(`9(8'()! I_,-)! r!T#--,:;! ?FFMJ;! S&'2! '2(! 81%$&*,'&1*! 10! '2&5! 'S1! 0,8'1-5!

91'(*'&,..:!.(,)&*7!'1!)&5$(*(0&'5!I]17(5'(;!=>>RJA!!

B2(!'(-%!c)&5$(*(0&'L!&5!,!K(:!(.(%(*'!10!%,*:!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*a!%,*,7(%(*'!

,99-1,82(5! ,*)! &'! S,5! 0&-5'! &*'-1)#8()! &*! '2(! 81*'(`'! 10! ,*! VBaV"!!!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!,5!'2(!,)E(-5(!(00(8'!'2,'!,!*(S!VB!9-17-,%%(!81#.)!2,E(!&*!'2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!&*01-%,'&1*!0.1S!5',$&.&':A!B2(!S1-);!c)&5$(*(0&'L;!2,5!,!*#%$(-!10!

)(0&*&'&1*5A!B2(5(!&*8.#)(W!!

• <!)&5,)E,*',7(!I"1,*(5!,*)![,SK(-;!=>>OJq!!

• "1%('2&*7! )&5,)E,*',7(1#5! 1-! 1$^(8'&1*,$.(! IT(--&,%\_($5'(-;! =>>OJq!

51%('2&*7! '2,'! %,K(5! ,! 5&'#,'&1*! )&5,)E,*',7(1#5! 1-! #*0,E1#-,$.(!

IH*8,-',|;!=>>OJq!

• P*)(5&-,$.(!(00(8'5!10!,*!&*E(5'%(*'!IC,**&5'(-!('!,.A;!=>>?Jq!

!"#$%&##'()*%+&'',&-+-'./&.*/*0$1%#'*%2'0/*$%$%+3'

4/15&60'7"0."0',&-+-'&86199&/6&'#:#0&93'

;%0&/9&2$*0&'<&%&=$0',&-+-'$%6/&*#&2'&81/2&/#3'

>%2'<&%&=$0',&-+-'$%6/&*#&2'#*?&#'/&@&%"&3'

A0/*0&+$6'7<5&60$@&',&-+-'$%6/&*#&2'./1=$0*<$?$0:3'&%*<?&#'

./&.*/&'01'/&*?$#&'

$%'0"/%'/&*?$#&#'

61%0/$<"0&#'01''

Page 58: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! NO!

B2(! S1-);! )&5$(*(0&';! 2,5! $((*! #5()! &*! 81**(8'&1*! S&'2! '(82*1.17:! 01-! 51%(!

:(,-5!IT#.E,*:;!?FFFJA!

_,-)!('! ,.A! I?FFRJ!2&72.&72'! '2,'!91'(*'&,.! )&5$(*(0&'5! 10! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! 521#.)!

,.S,:5!$(! 81*5&)(-();! )(0&*&*7! '215(! ,5! ,)E(-5(! &%9,8'5! 1*! ,! $#5&*(55! ,*)a1-!

1-7,*&5,'&1*A!<*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!1-!&*E(5'1-5!*(()!'1!,7-((!'2,'!*(7,'&E(!1#'81%(5!

1-!)&5$(*(0&'5! ,-(! '2(!91'(*'&,.! c9-&8(!S1-'2!9,:&*7! '1!1$',&*!915&'&E(!$(*(0&'5L!

I_,-)!('!,.A;!=>>NJA!"1%(!1#'81%(5!%,:$(!0,E1#-,$.(!01-!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,5!,!

S21.(!$#'!#*0,E1#-,$.(!01-!9,-'5!10!&';!51!,*:!5#82!)&5$(*(0&'5!%#5'!$(!&)(*'&0&()!

,*)!'-,8K()!51!'2(&-!&%9,8'!8,*!$(!%&*&%&5()!IQQB<;!?FFFJA!

B2(! 188#--(*8(! 10! )&5$(*(0&'5! &*! %,*:! 5(8'1-5! &*)&8,'(5! '2(&-! 9-(E,.(*8(A! B2(!

&*81-91-,'&1*! 10! )&5$(*(0&'5! S1#.)! &*'-1)#8(! 7-(,'(-! $,.,*8(! &*'1! &*E(5'%(*'!

(E,.#,'&1*!'(82*&4#(5!'2,'!8#--(*'.:!018#5!#91*!$(*(0&'5!,*)!&7*1-(!)&5$(*(0&'5!

I/1`;!=>>DJA!

*$,* >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!

T,*:!,#'21-5!,881-)&*7!'1!,!E,-&(':!10!)&00(-(*'!8-&'(-&,!,''(%9'!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!10!

$(*(0&'5q! '2&5!S&..! &*8-(,5(!'2(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10! '2(!*,'#-(!10!$(*(0&'5;!,*)!S&..!

,55&5'!,*,.:5&5!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!

*$,*$, >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!HB!</08'!1B['!

B2(!%15'! 81%%1*! ,*)! &*&'&,.! )&5'&*8'&1*! 01-! $(*(0&'5! &5! $('S((*! ',*7&$.(! ,*)!

&*',*7&$.(A!]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>O!81*5&)(-!,!',*7&$.(!1#'81%(!'1!$(!1*(!'2,'!

2,5!$((*!19(-,'&1*,.&5()!,*)!8,*!$(!%(,5#-();!%1*&'1-()!,*)!81*'-1..()q! ,*)!

&*',*7&$.(!1#'81%(5;! 5#82! ,5! cc5,'&50,8'&1*LL! ,5!$(&*7!19(-,'&1*,.&5()!1*!2&72! '1!

.1S!9(-8(9'&1*!58,.(5A!B2(!K(:!,''-&$#'(!10!,*!&*',*7&$.(!1#'81%(!,5!)(58-&$()!$:!

'2(! 5,%(! ,#'21-5! &5! '2,'! -,'2(-! '2,*! $(&*7! ,55#%()! ,*)! #*)(8.,-();! &'! &5!

19(-,'&1*,.&5()!I10'(*!'2-1#72!,!0,8&.&','&1*!9-18(55J!S&'2!,*!,7-(()!%(,5#-(!10!

5#88(55! 1-! 0,&.#-(A! B:9&8,..:;! '2(5(! &*',*7&$.(5! &*8.#)(;! $#'! ,-(! *1'! .&%&'()! '1;!

-(.,'&1*52&95;! K*1S.()7(;! 9-18(55(5! ,*)! 5:5'(%5;! .(,)(-52&9! ,*)!

81%%#*&8,'&1*;!8#.'#-(!,*)!E,.#(5;!-(9#','&1*!,*)!'-#5';!5K&..5!,*)!81%9('(*8&(5!

Page 59: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! NR!

I/#'#-(! ,*)! V**1E,'&1*! P*&';! =>>?JA! _,-)! r! 6,*&(.! I=>>RJ! ,.51! )&00(-(*'&,'(!

$(*(0&'5;!,5!',*7&$.(!,*)!&*',*7&$.(;!S2(-(!',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'215(!'2,'!8,*!$(!

%(,5#-()! $:! ,*! 1$^(8'&E(;! 4#,*'&','&E(! ,*)! 10'(*! 0&*,*8&,.! %(,5#-(A! V*! 51%(!

8,5(5! &'!%,:! $(! '2,'! ,! $(*(0&'! 2,5! ,! 4#,*'&','&E(!%(,5#-(! $#'! &5! *1'! 0&*,*8&,.A!

V*',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! '215(! '2,'! 8,*! 1*.:! $(! ^#)7()! 5#$^(8'&E(.:! ,*)! '(*)! '1!

(%9.1:! 4#,.&','&E(!%(,5#-(5;!%,*:! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! -(817*&5(! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10!

&*',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! (E(*! '21#72! '2(:! 8,**1'!9#'! ,! 0&*,*8&,.! E,.#(! 1*! '2(%!,*)!

'2(:! ,-(! -(81-)()! &*! '2(! $#5&*(55! 8,5(! 01-! *(S! &*E(5'%(*'5! S(-(! '2(:! ,-(!

E&(S()! ,5! &%91-',*'! ,5! ',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! I_,-)! ,*)! 6,*&(.;! =>>RJA! B2&5!

8.,55&0&8,'&1*! &5!#5()!$:!%,*:!,#'21-5!IC-,).(:;!=>>R;!C,-'.('';!=>>R;!/,-$(:!('!

,.A;!?FFF;!b&*!,*)!+(-E,*;!=>>?;!]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>O;!3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJ!,*)!

9-,8'&'&1*(-5;!,*)!&5!%,&*.:!$(8,#5(!&5!-(.,'()!'1!'2(!E,.#(!':9(!10!'2(!$(*(0&'!,5!

5#%%,-&5()!&*!B,$.(!OA!

&/H0'!Nc!>'2'7)1!</08'!1B['(!^>5/30'BD!*++T_!

Z/08'!&B['! %'7)2)1);2!?\/@[0'!

Q,52,$.(!! ]1*\8,52,$.(!

&/2A)H0'!

6(0&*&'(!X,.#(!%,:!$(!9-()&8'()!S&'2!

8(-',&*':!

3()#8()!

Q15'5!

/(S(-!"'(95!&*!,!

9-18(55!

H`9(8'()!

X,.#(!%,:!$(!9-()&8'()!1*!'2(!$,5&5!

10!2&5'1-&8!'-(*)5!,*)!2&72!.(E(.5!10!

81*0&)(*8(!

V*8-(,5()!

",.(5!

f#&8K(-!

9(-01-%,*8(!10!

',5K5!

<*'&8&9,'()!B2(!$(*(0&'!&5!,*'&8&9,'()!$#'!&5!E,.#(!

&5!*1'!-(.&,$.:!9-()&8',$.(!

b1S(-!

&*5#-,*8(!

9-(%&#%5!

U-(,'(-!

Q#5'1%(-!

",'&50,8'&1*!

621/2A)H0'!

T,:$(!,*'&8&9,'()!$#'!)&00&8#.'!'1!

5#$5',*'&,'(A!+-1`:!%(,5#-(%(*'!10!

1'2(-!8,5#,..:\-(.,'()!$(*(0&'5!%,:!

7&E(!(E&)(*8(!10!-(,.&5,'&1*!

V%9-1E()!&%,7(!I9-1`:W!

&*8-(,5()!*#%$(-!10!915&'&E(!

'(5'&%1*&,.5J!

V*!-(8(*'!:(,-5!I/1`;!=>>DJ;!'2(!,55(55%(*'!10!&*',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5!2,5!$(81%(!,*!

(`9.&8&'!-(4#&-(%(*'!10!&*E(5'%(*'!(E,.#,'&1*!'(82*&4#(5!IU(-S&*;!?FDD;!b&..-,*K!

Page 60: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! NM!

('! ,.A;! =>>?;! T#-92:! ,*)! "&%1*;! =>>=;! ".,7%#.)(-! ('! ,.A;! ?FFO;!_2&'&*7! ('! ,.A;!

?FFRJA! V*',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! %,:! 51%('&%(5! 2,E(! $((*! &)(*'&0&()! ,5! $(&*7!

&%91-',*'! 9-&1-! '1! &*E(5'%(*'! (E,.#,'&1*! S2(*! (`9.1-,'1-:! %('21)5! 5#82! ,5!

58(*,-&1!,*,.:5&5!Ib&**(%,*!,*)!d(**(..;!?FMMJ!S(-(!#5()A!

B2(!5,%(!)&00(-(*'&,'&1*!$('S((*!c',*7&$.(L!,*)!c&*',*7&$.(L!&5!$:!#5&*7!'2(!'(-%5!

c2,-)L!,*)!c510'LA!_2(*!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!8,**1'!$(!(`9-(55()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!

.&K(.:! &%9,8'!1*!'2(!$,.,*8(!52(('!1-!'2(!9-10&'!,*)!.155!,881#*'!,-(!)(0&*()!,5!

c510'!$(*(0&'5L!I1-!&*',*7&$.(J!I+2&..&95;!=>>@JA!B215(!'2,'!8,*!$(!51!(`9-(55();!1-!

'215(!'2,'!2,E(!,!',*7&$.(!0&*,*8&,.!1#'81%(!,-(!#5#,..:!-(0(--()!'1!,5!2,-)!I1-!

',*7&$.(J!I+2&..&95;!=>>@JA!!

"10'!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'215(!'2,'!,-(!.(55!(,5:!'1!(`9-(55!,*)!'1!%(,5#-(!&*!'(-%5!10!

8,52!1-!1$^(8'&E(!*#%$(-5A!+2&..&95!I=>>@J!)(0&*(5!2,-)!$(*(0&'5!,5!-(9-(5(*'&*7!

'2(! 1#'9#';! 4#,.&':;! 815'! ,*)! '&%(! 10! S1-K! -(.,'()! 9-18(55(5A! B2(:! ,-(!

82,-,8'(-&5()!$:!$(&*7!1$^(8'&E(;!-(.,'&E(.:!(,5:!'1!%(,5#-(!,*)!(,5:!'1!81*E(-'!

'1!%1*(:!E,.#(5A!C:!81*'-,5';!2(!82,-,8'(-&5(5!510'!$(*(0&'5!,5!5#$^(8'&E(;!10'(*!

)&00&8#.'! '1!%(,5#-(;! ,.%15'! ,.S,:5!)&00&8#.'! '1! 81*E(-'! '1!%1*(',-:! E,.#(5! ,*)!

0-(4#(*'.:!$(2,E&1#-,..:!1-&(*'()!I+2&..&95;!=>>@JA!!

!

!X)A85'!Sc!?\/@[0'(!;7!3)5'91!/23!)23)5'91!H'2'7)1(!^44&ID!*+++_!

IndirectExamples• Better Image• Staff morale• Customer Service(improved perception)

DirectExamples• Greater accuracy• Lower staff turnover• customer service(increased speed of response)

DirectExamples• Staff reductions• Skills Mix• accommodation

Tangible

Intangible

Relate to non-financial objectives

Relate to financial objectives

IndirectExamples• Better Image• Staff morale• Customer Service(improved perception)

DirectExamples• Greater accuracy• Lower staff turnover• customer service(increased speed of response)

DirectExamples• Staff reductions• Skills Mix• accommodation

Tangible

Intangible

Relate to non-financial objectives

Relate to financial objectives

Page 61: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ND!

B2(!5,%(!$(*(0&'5!8,*!,.51!$(!8.,55&0&()!,5! c)&-(8'!1-! c&*)&-(8'L! &*! '(-%5!10! '2(&-!

0&*,*8&,.! &%9,8'A!/&7#-(!D!9-(5(*'()!&*! c'2(!<*'&)1'(L! &*!=>>>!7&E(5!(`,%9.(5!10!

5#82! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! %,K(5! '2(! 9,-,..(.&5%5! $('S((*! '2(5(! )&00(-(*'! '(-%5!

Id&99(*$(-7(-;!=>>>JA!

*$,*$* >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!HB!;5A/2)(/1);2/0!;5!H8()2'((!)@[/91!

<*1'2(-! S,:! 10! 8.,55&0:&*7! 7(*(-&8! $(*(0&'5! &5! '1! ,.&7*! '2(%! S&'2! '2(! %,&*!

(.(%(*'5! 10! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*q! '2&5! &5! #5#,..:! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 10! 2,-)! 1-! ',*7&$.(!

$(*(0&'5! ,*)! &5! 0,8&.&','&*7! '2(!S,:! '2,'! $(*(0&'5! 8,*! $(! 8,'(71-&5()! ,*)! $(''(-!

#*)(-5'11)! $:! $#5&*(55! 5'-(,%5! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;! ?FF@JA! B2(5(! $#5&*(55! 5'-(,%5!

,-(W!"'-,'(7&8q!%,*,7(%(*'q!19(-,'&1*,.q!0#*8'&1*,.q!,*)!5#991-'A!!

H`,%9.(5!10!5#82!8,'(71-&5,'&1*!,-(!7&E(*!&*!/&7#-(!FW!U(*(-&8!01-%!10!$(*(0&'5!

I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FF@JA!

!

!X)A85'!Uc!E'2'5)9!7;5@!;7!H'2'7)1(!^X/5H'B!'1!/0$D!,UU-_!

Q.,55&0:&*7! $(*(0&'5! $:! $#5&*(55! 1-! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! &%9,8'! &5! 2(.90#.! S2(*!

82(8K&*7! 5'-,'(7:! ,.&7*%(*'! ,*)! $,.,*8(! ,*)! S2(*! 81%9,-&*7! '2(! -(.,'&E(!

5&7*&0&8,*8(!10!$(*(0&'5!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!/#-'2(-!%1-(!2(!(`9.,&*5!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!&*!

'2&5! ':9(! 10! 8.,55&0&8,'&1*! 521#.)! $(! &*! ,881-),*8(! '1! '2(!%,&*! '2-((! 5'-,'(7&8!

!"#$"%&'()•  !"##$%&'($%'&)*'$%+,-./,&.$-'/&%,&*+0'$%'1./.$-'

•  2$-+'$%'/)$%&'&*%3'1.,4.5.&0'$('&)*'$%+,-./,&.$-'

•  6%$1.7*'8"/&$3*%/'9.&)'"-.:"*'1,5"*'#%$#$/.&.$-'

•  ;*/.%*'&$'4*'/**-'&$'4*'.--$1,&.1*'•  6*%3.&'-*9'4"/.-*//'3$7*5/'•  <".57'4,%%.*%/'&$'*-&%0'•  =2$8>'.-?'8"/&$3*%/'•  @*$+%,#).8'$%'3,%>*&'*A#,-/.$-'

*+%#$"',-$.)•  B$%*'*((*8&.1*'"/*'$('*A./&.-+'CD',-7''/0/&*3/'

•  C3#%$1*7':",5.&0',&'%*7"8*7'8$/&'•  C3#%$1*7'&"%-,%$"-7'&.3*'•  E*7"8*7')*,78$"-&'•  E*7"8&.$-'.-'#%$#*%&0'8$/&/'•  C-8%*,/*7'.-8$3*'(%$3'4*&&*%':",5.&0'#%$7"8&/'

•  D.3*5.-*//',-7',88*//.4.5.&0'$('7,&,'

'

/$-$&%0%-")•  C-8%*,/*7',+.5.&0'•  <*&&*%'8$-&%$5'&)%$"+)'.3#%$1*7'.-($%3,&.$-'

•  @%$9.-+'&)*'/>.55/'$('&)*'9$%>($%8*'•  B**&.-+'&)*').+)*/&'#%$(*//.$-,5'/&,-7,%7/'

•  C3#%$1*'&)*':",5.&0'$('9$%>.-+'5.(*'•  FA./&.-+'/0/&*3/'),1*'4*8$3*'.-,7*:",&*''

•  2*//'8%./*/'•  G5,&&*%'$%+,-./,&.$-,5'/&%"8&"%*'

12-("',-$.)))))))))))

''

!2++,#")))))))))))

''

•  F3#5$0**'/*5('/*%1.8*'•  C3#%$1*7'%*8%".&3*-&',-7'%*&*-&.$-'#%$8*//*/'•  6%$1./.$-'$('.-(%,/&%"8&"%*'/0/&*3/'•  C3#%$1*7'8$33"-.8,&.$-',-7'8$55,4$%,&.$-'$##$%&"-.&.*/'•  H7$#&.$-'$(',7)*%*-8*'&$'/&,-7,%7/'•  I$3#,&.4.5.&0'9.&)'8"/&$3*%/?',-7'/"##5.*%/?'/0/&*3/'•  F-($%8*3*-&'$('%*+"5,&$%0'$%'5*+,5'%*:".%*3*-&/'•  C7*-&.J.8,&.$-'$('4*/&'#%,8&.8*'•  6%$7"8&.$-'$('/&,-7,%7'%*#$%&/'•  <"/.-*//'8$-&.-".&0'K'7./,/&*%'%*8$1*%0'

Page 62: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! NF!

&%9-1E(%(*'! ,-(,5! 10! 9-1)#8'&E&':q! -&5K! %&*&%&5,'&1*! ,*)! 7-1S'2A! <! %('21)!

#5()!01-!'2&5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!&5!$:!E,-:&*7!'2(!cC15'1*!T,'-&`L!1-!'2(!cQ-,*0&(.)!U-&)L!

*1-%,..:!#5()! &*! ,*,.:5&*7! '2(! &%9,8'! ,!91-'01.&1! 10! &*E(5'%(*'5!2,5A!B2&5!2,5!

$((*!,),9'()!$:!C-,).(:!I=>>RJ!&*!'2(!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!T,*,7(%(*'!IC3TJ!

,99-1,82!,*)!8.,55&0&(5!$(*(0&'5!$:!$#5&*(55!&%9,8'!I5((!/&7#-(!?>JA!

!

X)A85'!,+c!>'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!HB!H8()2'((!)@[/91!8()2A!1#'!45/27)'03!E5)3!e!>;(1;2!F/15)\!!

^>5/30'BD!*++T!)2!JE4D!*++O/_!

C-,).(:!I=>>RJ!,*)!_,-)!I?FFRJ!8.,55&0:!$(*(0&'5!&*!01#-!%1-(!8,'(71-&(5!$:W!!

• "',K(21.)(-! 8.,55&0&8,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! )&5$(*(0&'5! ,881-)&*7! '1! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-!S21!S&..!0((.!1-!(`9(-&(*8(!'2(&-!&%9,8'q!

• U(*(-,.!$(*(0&'!8,'(71-:!01-!(`,%9.(! &*!815'!-()#8'&1*q!-(E(*#(!7(*(-,'&1*q!

-&5K! -()#8'&1*q! 9-1)#8'&E&':q! S1-K01-8(! 5,'&50,8'&1*q! 8#5'1%(-! 5(-E&8(q!

81%9,*:!&%,7(q!

!"#$$

!"#$"%&'()

%&'&()*+$#,)-,$.&/0*&$*"$*+"+#%$,+-'.%--)/00/#"+.'"'%-1$

23+)'&++$4&5&/"67&'*1$8."#*,$

%&'&()*+$0.)+)'8$9."7$(#'"'($1)"/)"/2$34-)/0%#$"'/.-$:$&;8;$)'-.&0+&4$&9()-)&'-<$0'4$

&99&-*)5&'&++$

$$5'(%)"/)6$7%)2&'&()*+$)'$*,&$+&'+&$*,0*$*,&$".80')+0*)"'=+$8."#*,$".$+3.5)50/$#)//$'"*$4&6&'4$"'$*,&7$:$3+30//<$

4&.)5&4$9."7$)76."5&7&'*+$*"$'"'>-.)*)-0/$0-*)5)*)&+$

$%&'&()*+$#)*,$6'&6)$(6'%7%8%.")#'-91$23*$"9*&'$,)8,$.&#0.4$:$&;8;$0.)+)'8$9."7$&?6&.)7&'*)'8$#)*,$*,&$#0<$#&$

4"$*,)'8+$$

!+00/#")

!0%(+1$"'7%)

:%3);0%#$"'/.$1)

@)8,$$

!"#$$

!"#$%&'()*+,(-.(/0%)*++

12%0&++

Page 63: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! O>!

• +,-'&8#.,-! ':9(!10! ,8'&E&':! 01-! (`,%9.(! '(,%!S1-K&*7;! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7;! 5K&..!

,84#&5&'&1*q!

• Q2,*7(!':9(5!$:!&)(*'&0:&*7!&0!'2(!$(*(0&'!S&..!$(!,82&(E()!$:!)1!*(S!'2&*75q!

)1!'2&*75!$(''(-!1-!5'19!)1&*7!'2&*75A!

/#-'2(-!%1-(!_,-)! ,*)! 6,*&(.! I=>>RJ!S2(*! 8.,55&0:&*7! $:! 82,*7(! ':9(;! 5','(!

'2,'! (,82! $(*(0&'! 521#.)! $(! 0#-'2(-! &)(*'&0&()! $:! '2(! (`9.&8&'*(55! 10! '2(!

81*'-&$#'&1*!'1!&'A!B2(5(!,-(W!

• G$5(-E,$.(!$:!#5(!10!,7-(()!8-&'(-&,;!59(8&0&8!&*)&E&)#,.5a7-1#95!S&..!)(8&)(;!

$,5()!1*!'2(&-!(`9(-&(*8(!10!^#)7(%(*';!'1!S2,'!(`'(*'!'2(!$(*(0&'!2,5!$((*!

-(,.&5()q!

• T(,5#-,$.(! '2&5! ,59(8'! 10! 9(-01-%,*8(! &5! 8#--(*'.:! $(&*7! %(,5#-()! 1-! ,*!

,99-19-&,'(! %(,5#-(! 81#.)! $(! &%9.(%(*'()A! C#'! '2&5! &5! *1'! 9155&$.(! '1!

(5'&%,'(! $:! 21S! %#82! 9(-01-%,*8(! S&..! &%9-1E(! S2(*! '2(! 82,*7(5! ,-(!

81%9.('(q!

• f#,*'&0&,$.(! 5#00&8&(*'! (E&)(*8(! (`&5'5! '1! 01-(8,5'! 21S! %#82! &%9-1E(%(*'!

521#.)!-(5#.'!01-%!'2(!82,*7(5q!

• /&*,*8&,.! $:! ,99.:&*7! ,! 815'a9-&8(! 1-! 1'2(-! E,.&)! 0&*,*8&,.! 01-%#.,! '1! ,!

4#,*'&0&,$.(!$(*(0&'!,!0&*,*8&,.!E,.#(!8,*!$(!8,.8#.,'()A!

*$,*$- C2[0/22'3!;5!'@'5A'21!H'2'7)1(!

V'! %#5'! ,.51! $(! #*)(-5'11)! '2,'! ,5! S(..! ,5! 9.,**()! $(*(0&'5! 10'(*! '2(-(! ,-(!

#*9.,**()!$(*(0&'5A!B2(5(!,-(!10'(*!,!81*5(4#(*8(!10!,!82,*7(!&%9.(%(*'()!1-!

,*1'2(-!$(*(0&'!7,&*();!,*)!%#5'!$(! &*8.#)()!)#-&*7!,*:!K&*)!10!,55(55%(*'!10!

9(-01-%,*8(! 1*! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*A! cV*8&)(*',.! &%9,8'5! 521#.)! ,.51! $(! &)(*'&0&()!

,*)!9-1,8'&E(.:!%,*,7()L!I<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':;!=>>@JA!

/,-$(:!('!,.A!I?FF@J!&)(*'&0&()!'2,'!%,*:!10!'2(!9-1^(8'5!'2(:!5'#)&()!&*!,))&'&1*!

'1!'2(!,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5;!7,E(!-&5(!'1!#*9.,**()!1-!(%(-7(*'!$(*(0&'5A!T,*:!10!

'2(5(!#*9.,**()!$(*(0&'5!,99(,-!'1!$(!c5(81*)!1-)(-L!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!,-(!'2(:!,-15(!

0-1%!,82&(E&*7! ,*! &*&'&,.! 1-!9.,**()!$(*(0&'! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;! ?FFFJA! V*'(-(5'&*7.:!

'2(:! 01#*)! '2,'! #*9.,**()! $(*(0&'5! '(*)()! '1! $(! %1-(! &*',*7&$.(! '2,*! '2(!

Page 64: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! O?!

9.,**()!$(*(0&'5A!B2&5!&5!.,-7(.:!'1!'2(!0,8'!'2,'!9.,**()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!7&E(*!c2,-)L!

0&*,*8&,.!%(,5#-(5! ,*)! '2(:! ,-(!)18#%(*'()! &*!$#5&*(55! 8,5(5! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! ,!

82,*7(! 1-! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'A![1S(E(-;! 4#,.&','&E(! 1-! &*',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! 10'(*!

,5518&,'()!S&'2!21S!&*)&E&)#,.5!9(-8(&E(!'2(!&*E(5'%(*'!1-!'2(!82,*7(!-(5#.'&*7!

0-1%!&'!I_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!

*$,*$P I91;5!;5)'21/1'3!90/(()7)9/1);2!

<*!,8'1-\1-&(*'()!,99-1,82!&5!(%9.1:()!01-!'2(!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!

,-(!)(-&E()!0-1%!'2(!,)19'&1*!10!,*!&**1E,'&E(!'(82*1.17:!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!,-(,A!

V'!S,5!0&-5'!#5()!&*!?FF@;!&*!,!],'&1*,.![(,.'2!"(-E&8(!I]["J!9#$.&52()!,!-(91-';!

&*!S2&82!'2&5!,99-1,82!S,5!#5()!'1!8.,55&0:!$(*(0&'5!10!'2(!H.(8'-1*&8![(,.'2!Q,-(!

3(81-)5!IH[Q3J!IT,*'e,*,!,*)!B2(%&5'18.(1#5;!=>>NJA!B2(!'(-%!,8'1-!-(0(-5!'1!

,..! 2#%,*! ,*)! *1*\2#%,*! #5(-5! '2,'! &*'(-,8'! S&'2! ,! 5:5'(%! IT,*'e,*,! ,*)!

B2(%&5'18.(1#5;! =>>NJA! P5&*7! '2&5! ,99-1,82! ,*! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! '2(! cS1-.)5L!

,00(8'()! $:! '2(! 5:5'(%! &5! *(8(55,-:A! V*! '2(! 0&-5'! &*'-1)#8'&1*! 10! '2&5! ,99-1,82!

S&'2&*!'2(!]["!'2(:!S(-(!'2-((!S1-.)5!&)(*'&0&()!I][";!?FF@JW!

• +,'&(*'5L!S1-.)q!9,'&(*'5;!*(`'!10!K&*;!8,-(-5q!!

• B2(!8.&*&8&,*5L!S1-.)!8.&*&8&,*5;!*1*!8.&*&8&,*5;!-(591*5&$.(!8.&*&8&,*;!,!2(,.'2!

8,-(!0,8&.&':!,*)!8.&*&8,.!5'#)(*'5q!,*)!!

• B2(! '2&-)! 9,-'&(5! S1-.)q! 81*'-1..(-;! '(82*1.17&5';! ,)%&*&5'-,'1-;! .(7,.!

9-10(55&1*,.;!1'2(-!'2&-)!9,-'&(5A!

<)19'&*7!'2(!]["!,8'1-\,99-1,82! &5!9-1915()!'2,'! &*!,*! &*E(5'%(*';!9-1^(8'!1-!

9-17-,%%(! '2(!,8'1-5! 8,*!$(!8.,55&0&()! &*! 01#-!%,&*!8,'(71-&(5! IT,*'e,*,!,*)!

B2(%&5'18.(1#5;! =>>NJ;! '2(5(! ,-(W! I?J!9-1E&)(-5q! I=J! ,88(9'1-5q! I@J! 5#991-'(-5q!

,*)!INJ!81*'-1..(-5A!<))&'&1*,.!'1!'2(!01#-!9-1915()!8,'(71-&(5!'2(!5,%(!,#'21-5!

8.,55&0:! '2(! ,8'1-5! &*! 'S1! )&00(-(*'! )&%(*5&1*5W! I?J! 2#%,*q! ,*)! I=J!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.A!!

<*!&..#5'-,'&1*!10!9-1915()!',`1*1%:!01-!'2(!,8'1-5!9-(5(*'()!,$1E(!&5!521S*!&*!

B,$.(!RA!

!

Page 65: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! O=!

!&/H0'!TW!&/\;2;@B!;7!#'/01#9/5'!/91;5(!^F/21f/2/!/23!&#'@)(1;90';8(D!*++P_!

! ! I4&J:=!!! ! I99'[1;5(! "5;<)3'5! =8[[;51'5! 4;215;00'5!

%6?FK=6JK! [#%,*!! +,'&(*'5!

](`'!10!K&*!Q.&*&8&,*5!]1*\!Q.&*&8&,*5!Q.&*&8,.!5'#)(*'5!

<)%&*&5'-,'1-5!+-10(55&1*,.5!3(5(,-82(-5!

T,*,7(-5!

G-7,*&5,'&1*,.! ! [159&',.5!T()&8,.!6(9'5!Q.&*&85!

"#99.&(-5!B(82*1.17&(5!V*5#-(-5!

U1E(-*%(*'!61[![(,.'2!,#'21-&'&(5!!

B2(!&%9.&8,'&1*5!10!'2&5!8,'(71-&5,'&1*!,-(!'2,'W!I,J!&'!&%9-1E(5!'2(!.(E(.!,*)!'2(!

)(9'2!10!,*,.:5&5!I%1-(!)(',&.()Jq!I$J!&'!8,*!0#-'2(-!0,8&.&','(!'2(!)(8&5&1*!%,K&*7!

9-18(55q!,*)!I8J! &'!5(9,-,'(5!2#%,*!,8'1-5! 0-1%!'2(!1-7,*&e,'&1*,.!1*(5!,*)! &';!

'2(-(01-(;!,..1S5!)&00(-(*'!5'-,'(7&(5! '1!$(!,99.&()!S2(*! 018#5&*7!1*!1*(!1-!1*!

'2(!1'2(-!)&%(*5&1*!IIV-,*&;!?FFDJ!&*!IT,*'e,*,!,*)!B2(%&5'18.(1#5;!=>>NJJA!

*$,*$P$, =8@@/5B!;7!H'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!

V*!5#%%,-:;!%,*:!,#'21-5!,99-1,82!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!,*)!8,'(71-&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5;!

81*5&)(-&*7! )&00(-(*'! ,59(8'5! 1-! 8-&'(-&,q! 8.,55&0&8,'&1*! 2(.95! '1! &*8-(,5(! '2(!

#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2(!*,'#-(!10!$(*(0&'5;!,*)!,55&5'5!,*,.:5&5!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*!

IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!!B,$.(!M!5#%%,-&5(5!(`,%9.(5!10!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!1-!8,'(71-&5,'&1*!

':9(5;! S&'2! '2(! %15'! 81%%1*! )&5'&*8'&1*! $(&*7! %,)(! $('S((*! ',*7&$.(! ,*)!

&*',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5A!

&/H0'!Oc!>'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!(8@@/5B!

I(['91(! 4;@@'21(!

&/2A)H0'D!)21/2A)H0'! B,*7&$.(! ,-(! '215(! ^#)7()! D+'&! 1$^(8'&E(.:;! 81*5&)(-&*7! 4#,*'&','&E(!%(,5#-(5! '2,'! ,-(! 10'(*! $#'! *1'! ,.S,:5! 0&*,*8&,.! I&A(A;! &*! %1*(',-:!E,.#(5JA! V*',*7&$.(! ,-(! '215(! ^#)7()! D+'&! 5#$^(8'&E(.:;! %15'! 10'(*!%(,5#-()!(%9.1:&*7!4#,.&','&E(!%(,5#-(5!I*1'(W! $#).#A$C/&!$(*(0&'5!,-(!7(*(-,..:!)&00&8#.'!'1!81*E(-'!'1!%1*(',-:!E,.#(5JA!

I_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>Rq!C-,).(:;!=>>RJ!

J5A/2)(/1);2/0!)@[/91D!H8()2'((!)@[/91!!

B2(5(! $(*(0&'5! 8,*! 81%(! &*! O! )&00(-(*'! $#5&*(55! 5'-(,%5W! I?J! 5'-,'(7&8q!I=J!%,*,7(%(*'q!I@J!19(-,'&1*,.q!INJ!0#*8'&1*,.q!,*)!IOJ!5#991-'A!

I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJ!

>8)01!'2<)5;2@'21!0)7'9B90'!<)'R!

B2(!$#&.'!(*E&-1*%(*'!.&0(8:8.(!5','(5!'2,'!E&(S5!%&72'!$(!5(7%(*'()!,5!01..1S5W! I?J! )(E(.19%(*'q! I=J! 81*5'-#8'&1*q! ,*)! I@J! 0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(%(*'A!

Ig,'(5!('!,.A;!=>>FJ!

Page 66: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! O@!

I(['91(! 4;@@'21(!

=1/M'#;03'5;!/91;5!;5)'21/1'3!

Q.,55&0&8,'&1*! ,881-)&*7! '1! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! I7-1#95J! S21! S&..! 0((.! 1-!(`9(-&(*8(! &%9,8'5A! V*! ,*! &*E(5'%(*';! 9-1^(8'! 1-! 9-17-,%%(! '2(!,8'1-5a5',K(21.)(-5! %&72'! $(! 8.,55&0&()! &*! 01#-! %,&*! 8,'(71-&(5;! '2(5(!,-(W! I?J! 9-1E&)(-5q! I=J! ,88(9'1-5q! I@J! 5#991-'(-5q! INJ! 81*'-1..(-5A! <..!'2(5(! 01#-! %,&*! 8,'(71-&(5! %&72'! ,.51! $(! 8.,55&0&()! &*! 'S1! )&00(-(*'!)&%(*5&1*5W!I?J!2#%,*q!,*)!I=J!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.A!

IT,*'e,*,!,*)!B2(%&5'18.(1#5;!=>>NJ!

"0/22'3D!82[0/22'3e!'@'5A'21!

P*9.,**()! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! 10'(*! ,! 81%9.(%(*',-:! 81*5(4#(*8(! 10! I1'2(-J!9.,**()! $(*(0&'I5J! ,*)a1-! 10! ,*! &%9.(%(*'()! 82,*7(I5Jq! )#(! '1! '2(!(%(-7(*'! *,'#-(! 10! $(*(0&'5;! '2(5(! ,-(! *1'! #5#,..:! )18#%(*'()! &*! '2(!$#5&*(55! 8,5(;! *1'! $(&*7! &*&'&,..:! -(.,'()! S&'2! 9.,**()! 82,*7(5! ,*)a1-!&*E(5'%(*'5!)(',&.()A!I<52#-5'!,*)!

612(-':;!=>>@J!

J5A/2)(/1);2/0!<)'R! G-7,*&5,'&1*,.! E&(S5! ,-(W! I?J! 19(-,'&1*5! %,*,7(%(*'q! ,*)! I=J! $,8K\100&8(q!S2&82!(*8.15(5!,5!%,&*!0#*8'&1*5!I=A?J!&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5q!I=A=J!2#%,*! -(51#-8(5q! I=A@J! .(7,.q! I=ANJ! 9#-82,5&*7! ,*)! 9-18#-(%(*'q! I=AOJ!0&*,*8(!,*)!,881#*'&*7q!,*)!I=ARJ!1'2(-!100&8(!5(-E&8(5A!Ig,'(5!('!,.9;!=>>FJ!

*$,- >'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!@/2/A'@'21!W!/[[5;/9#'(!/23!@;3'0(!

C(01-(!.11K&*7!&*'1!'2(!'(-%!c$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*L;! &'! &5!*(8(55,-:!'1!#*)(-5',*)!

'2(! 'S1!S1-)5! '2,'!%,K(! '2(! '(-%;! $(*(0&'! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*A! ! 3(,.&5,'&1*! &*! '2(!

Q1*8&5(! G`01-)! )&8'&1*,-:! &5! )(58-&$()! ,5! $(&*7! ,S,-(! 10! 51%('2&*7! '2,'! &5!

,82&(E()A!

B2(-(01-(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!81#.)!$(!)(0&*()!,5!u1*(!$(81%&*7!0#..:!,S,-(!10!

'2(! 915&'&E(! &%9,8'! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! ,! 82,*7(vA! C:! &*'-1)#8&*7! '2(! 0,8'1-!

c%,*,7(%(*'L!&*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!/,-$(:!('!,.A!I?FFFJ!)(0&*(!&'!,5!u'2(!9-18(55!

'2,'!-(,.&5(5! '2(!$(*(0&'5! '2,'!,-(!,82&(E()!,*)!%,*,7(5! '2(!#*(`9(8'()!1*(5v;!

,*)!C-,).(:!I=>>RJ!)(0&*(5!&'!,5!u'2(!9-18(55!10!1-7,*&5&*7!,*)!%,*,7&*7;!51!'2,'!

91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! ,-&5&*7! 0-1%! &*E(5'%(*'! &*! 82,*7(;! ,-(! ,8'#,..:! ,82&(E()vA!

3(&55! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! )(0&*(! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,5! u'2(! 9-18(55! 01-! '2(!

19'&%&5,'&1*! 1-! %,`&%&5,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! 0-1%! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! 82,*7(!

9-17-,%%(5vA!

C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*'! &*! ,*! VB! 5(''&*7! S2(-(! '2(! '(-%! S,5! 0&-5'! &*'-1)#8()! &5!

10'(*!)(0&*()!,5!'2(!c9-18(55!10!1-7,*&5&*7!,*)!%,*,7&*7!5#82!'2,'!'2(!91'(*'&,.!

$(*(0&'5!,-&5&*7!0-1%!'2(!#5(!10!V"aVB!,-(!,8'#,..:!-(,.&5()L!I_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!

Page 67: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ON!

<881-)&*7! '1! b&*! ,*)! +(-E,*! I=>>?J;! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! &5! '2(! 9-18()#-,.!

,99-1,82! 10! 21S! '1! %,*,7(! '2(! $(*(0&'5! (E,.#,'&1*! '1! -(,.&5(! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 10!

8,9&',.! &*E(5'%(*'5A! _&'2&*! ,! 9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'! 5(''&*7! IGUQ;! =>>M$J!

$(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 81%9.(%(*'5! ,*)! 1E(-.,95! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! &*! '2(!

$#5&*(55! 8,5(A! _2&.(! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 9-1E&)(5! '2(! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*! 01-! '2(!

&*E(5'%(*';!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,..1S5!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!'1!9.,*!01-!,*)!,82&(E(!

'2(!$(*(0&'5A!

B2(-(! ,-(! 5(E(-,.! c$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'a-(,.&5,'&1*L! ,99-1,82(5! '2,'! (`&5'! ,*)!

'2(:! ,-(! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '2(! *(`'! 5(8'&1*! &*! ,! 82-1*1.17&8,.! 1-)(-! ,*)! $:! $-&(0.:!

2&72.&72'&*7! '2(&-! %,&*! 018#5A! _2,'! &5! (E&)(*'! 0-1%! ,.%15'! ,..! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82(5!&5!'2,'!'2(:!81%9-&5(!,!8:8.(!10!+.,*\61\

Q2(8K\!<8'!I+6Q<J!81*'&*#1#5!V%9-1E(%(*'!8:8.(!)(58-&$()!&*!=AO!I]17(5'(!,*)!

_,.K(-;!=>>OJA!

*$,-$, I91)<'!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!!

b(:'1*L5! I?FFOJ! ,8'&E(! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55! 5('5! '2(! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'! ,8'&E&':! &*! '2(! 81*'(`'! 10! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(A! B2(! 0-,%(S1-K!

9-(5(*'()! &*! /&7#-(! ??! %,)(! (`9.&8&'! '2(! -(.,'&1*52&9! $('S((*! 82,*7(! ,*)!

$(*(0&'5;!521S&*7!'2,'!'2(-(!&5!,!81*'&*#1#5!0.1S!$('S((*!82,*7(!,*)!$(*(0&'5A!

!

!X)A85'!,,c!I91)<'!>'2'7)1(!F/2/A'@'21!^Y'B1;2D!,UUN_!

!"#$%&'(")(*+,-#%,,($./#0%,(#%%1%1('"(/112%,,(,'2/'%03(

45&6%5%#'/'-"#(")("20/#-,/'-"#(/#1(*+,-#%,,(

$./#0%,(

7%/6-,/'-"#(")(*+,-#%,,($./#0%,(

45&6%5%#'/'-"#(")(48(,3,'%5,(

9:%2/66(*%#%;-',(5/#/0%5%#'(&2"$%,,(

!"#$%&'(")(48(,3,'%5,('"(,+&&"2'(*+,-#%,,($./#0%(

<+,-#%,,($./#0%(1%;-#-'-"#(

45&6%5%#'/'-"#(")(,'2/'%03(2%/6-,/'-"#(")(*%#%;-',(<+,-#%,,(/#1(48(,'2/'%03(

Page 68: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! OO!

*$,-$* &#'!45/27)'03!@;3'0!;7!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!!

B2(! Q-,*0&(.)! %1)(.! 10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 018#5(5! 59(8&0&8,..:! 1*! $(*(0&'5!

0-1%! VBa! V"! &*E(5'%(*'5A! V*! '2&5! 9-18(55! '2(!91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&();! ,!

9.,*!&5!)(E&5()!01-!'2(&-!-(,.&5,'&1*;!'2(!9.,*!&5!(`(8#'()!,*)!'2(!-(5#.'5!-(E&(S()!

,*)!(E,.#,'()!I_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!!

B2(! Q-,*0&(.)! %1)(.! 10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 2,5! $((*! #5()! ,5! '2(! $,5&5! 01-!

7#&)(.&*(5!1*!$(5'!9-,8'&8(!&*!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'A!_,-)!('!,.!I?FFRJ!,-7#(!'2,'!

$:! #5&*7! '2&5! 9-18(55!%1)(.;! &'! &5! 9155&$.(! '1! )&,7*15(!S2:! 51%(! 9-1^(8'5! ,-(!

5#88(550#.! &*! )(.&E(-&*7! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 1'2(-5! ,-(! *1'A! I_,-)! ,*)!T#--,:;! ?FFMJ!

/&7#-(!?=!521S5!'2(!K(:!(.(%(*'5!,*)!-(.,'&1*52&95!&*!'2&5!9-18(55!%1)(.A!

!

X)A85'!,*c!45/27)'03!"5;9'((!F;3'0!;7!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!^V/53D!,UUT_!

<*! &%91-',*'! 0(,'#-(! 10! '2&5! %1)(.! &5! '2(! 1#'(-! .119;! '2(! 1*(! '2,'! -(817*&5(5!

.(,-*&*7!,*)!0(()5!$,8K!&*'1!'2(!9-18(55A!B2(!*(()!01-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&*!VB!

S2(*!'2&5!9-18(55!S,5!&*'-1)#8()!S,5!!u*1'!'1!%,K(!711)!01-(8,5'5!$#'!'1!%,K(!

'2(%!81%(!'-#(! AAA!,*)!V"aVB!1*!&'5!1S*!)1(5!*1'!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5Av!I_,-)!('!,.A;!

?FFRJA!<*1'2(-!K(:!0(,'#-(!10!'2&5!Q-,*0&(.)!%1)(.!&5!$(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7A!

!"#$%&'()*)+%,-.%-,#)/#$#0&%1)

234$)/#$#0&%1)

5#43&14%&6$)

78#.-%#)/#$#0&%1)234$)

5#9&#:)*)7943-4%#)5#1-3%1)

26%#$%&43)'6,);-,%<#,)/#$#0&%1)

Page 69: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! OR!

C(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7!81%9,-(5!9-1^(8'! -(5#.'5!S&'2! '2(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!

)#-&*7!'2(!9-1^(8'!,*)!,55(55(5!&0!,*:!&*'(-*,.!1-!(`'(-*,.!82,*7(5!2,E(!188#--()!

'2,'!S&..! ,00(8'! '2(! )(.&E(-:! 10! 9.,**()! $(*(0&'5A! V'! &5! *(8(55,-:! '1!%1*&'1-! '2(!

$(*(0&'5!10!VB!9-1^(8'5!$(8,#5(!&55#(5!,-&5(!'2,'!%,:!9-(E(*'!'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!'2(!

$(*(0&'5A! V'! &5! ,.51! 9155&$.(! '2,';! ,'! '2&5! 5',7(;! 0#-'2(-! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()!

I_,-)!r!T#--,:;!?FFMJA!

*$,-$- &#'!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/[[5;/9#!!

B2(!u$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82v!IC3<J!S,5! &*'-1)#8()!$:!B21-9! &*!?FFDq! &'!

9-1E&)()! ,! $,5&5! 01-! #5&*7! &*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:! '1! )(.&E(-! $#5&*(55! -(5#.'5!

%1-(!81*5&5'(*'.:!,*)!9-()&8',$.:A!B21-9!I?FFDJ!,-7#(5!'2,'!'2(!,99-1,82!81#.)!

$(!,99.&()!'1!,*:!%,^1-!&*E(5'%(*'!&*!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!82,*7(A!

!

X)A85'!,-c!4;52'5(1;2'(!;7!>'2'7)1(!:'/0)(/1);2!I[[5;/9#!^&#;5[D!,UUS_!

B2(!c$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82L!&5!$,5()!1*!'S1!81-*(-5'1*(5!I/&7#-(!?@JW!

!"#

!"#$%"&'"()*+*,-)-+$.(!"#$%&'&(")*$+&,-&.*/"01$!""#$,+"2'3&')1$!"""#$4,+5&$60)"3"*,)"6'$7$."*89.&:,.-1$

!"4#$0.62.,3$*&+&;)"6'$,'-$!4#$06.)<6+"6$,-=5*)3&')>$

!#"/-0$()*+*,-)-+$.(!"#$-&+"4&.?$6<$;,0,%"+")"&*1$!""#$"'05)*1$!"""#$%5-2&)$,'-$!"4#$*;/&-5+&>$

!#",#*)()*+*,-)-+$.(!"#$%&'&(")*$*06'*6.*/"01$!""#$6:'&.*/"0$6<$%&'&(")*1$!"""#$%&'&(")*$*).&,3*1$

!"4#$,++$&+&3&')*$6<$%5*"'&**$*?*)&3$,'-$!4#$35+)"0+&$0.6=&;)*>$

10$'2'$3(100"4+$*5'&'$3$

6-&-2*+$(7-*84#-)-+$$

94&&(:30&-(;"2-#+*+0-$

!#"*0$'2-(7*+*,-)

-+$("%(:<*+,-$

Page 70: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! OM!

<A B2(!52&0'!0-1%!5',*)!,.1*(!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!'1W!

• C#5&*(55!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'q!

• 6&58&9.&*()!91-'01.&1!%,*,7(%(*'q!

• /#..!8:8.(!71E(-*,*8(A!

CA B2(! '2-((! *(8(55,-:! 81*)&'&1*5! 01-! '2(! 5#88(550#.! &%9.(%(*','&1*! 10! '2(!

c$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82LW!

• <881#*',$&.&':!10!,8'&E&5'5q!

• 3(.(E,*'!%(,5#-(!,5!&*!%(,5#-&*7!'2(!'2&*75!'2,'!-(,..:!81#*'q!

• +-1,8'&E(! %,*,7(%(*'! 10! 82,*7(! '1! 7&E(! 9(19.(! 1S*(-52&9! 5',K(5! &*!

9-17-,%5A!

C3<!&5!$#5&*(55!1-&(*'()!0-,%(S1-K;!5#991-'()!$:!,!5('!10!9-18(55(5;!'(82*&4#(5!

,*)! &*5'-#%(*'5!S2&82! (*,$.(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1! 5(.(8'! ,*)!%,*,7(! 91-'01.&1! 10!

9-17-,%5! 5#82! ,5! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! 8.(,-.:! )(0&*();! 19'&%&5()! ,*)! ,.&7*()!S&'2!

$#5&*(55!5'-,'(7:!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!

*$,-$P I91)<'!H'2'7)1!5'/0)(/1);2!

B2(!,8'&E(!$(*(0&'!-(,.&5,'&1*!I<C3J;!)(E(.19()!$:!3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2!

I?FFDJ;! &5!,!9-18(55! 01-!%,*,7&*7! &*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5L!)(E(.19%(*'!'2-1#72!,!

81*'&*#1#5! (E,.#,'&1*! ,99-1,82A! B2&5! 9-18(55! -(4#&-(5! ,8'&E(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*!

)#-&*7! 9-1^(8'! )(E(.19%(*'! 0-1%! '2(! 9-&%,-:! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*8.#)&*7! .&*(!

%,*,7(-5!,*)!#5(-5;! 0&*,*8&,.!5',00!,*)!&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5!)(E(.19(-5! !I",K,-!

,*)!_&)(5',)2;!=>>OJA!B2(!<C3!9-18(55!-(4#&-(5!,!)&-(8'!,*)!81*'&*#1#5!018#5!

1*!$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!&5!$,5()!1*!,!81*'&*7(*8:!92&.15192:;!S2&82!

%(,*5!'2,'!'2(!,8'#,.!&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%!1#'81%(5!,5!S(..!,5!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!

,8'&E&'&(5;! ',5K5! ,*)! 9,-'&8&9,'&*7! -1.(5! 10! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,-(! ):*,%&8!

'2-1#721#'! '2(! )#-,'&1*! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! I",K,-! ,*)! _&)(5',)2;! =>>OJA! V*! '2&5!

,99-1,82! &'! &5! 0#*),%(*',.! '2,'! '2(! 9-&*8&9.(! 5',K(21.)(-5! 10! '2(! &*01-%,'&1*!

5:5'(%! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()! ,'! '2(! 1*5('! ,*)! '2,'! '2(:! ,88(9'! ,*)! ,7-((! '2(&-!

81*'&*#1#5!&*E1.E(%(*'A!I3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!?FFDJA!

Page 71: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! OD!

B2(!<C3!,99-1,82! 8,*!$(!)&E&)()! &*! '2-((!)&5'&*8'&E(!92,5(5! Ib&*! ,*)!+(-E,*;!

=>>@JW!

• "(''&*7! '2(! 81#-5(W! B2&5! &*E1.E(5! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! 5('5! 10! 9-(8&5(!

-(4#&-(%(*'5! #*)(-! '2(! 2(,)&*75! 10! ,! $#5&*(55! 9&8'#-(;! ,! 0&*,*8&,.! 9&8'#-(;!

,*)!,!9-1^(8'!9&8'#-(!I3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!?FFDJA!G*8(!'2(5(!'2-((!

9&8'#-(5!2,E(!$((*!9-1)#8();!,!)(8&5&1*!&5!%,)(!,*)!,*!,7-((%(*'!-(,82()!

,5!'1!S2('2(-!1-!*1'!'1!.,#*82!'2(!9-1^(8'q!

• /1-%,'&E(!(E,.#,'&1*W!B2&5!&*E1.E(5!,55(55&*7!'2(!9-17-(55!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!<..!

5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!,$.(! '1!)(E(.19!E&(S5!,5! '1!21S!'2(!9-1^(8'! &5!9-17-(55&*7!

,*)!'1!(`82,*7(!'2(5(!E&(S5!&*!19(*!,*)!81*5'-#8'&E(!)&58#55&1*A!B2(-(!,-(!

'2-((!9155&$.(!1#'81%(5W!I,J!#9),'&*7!'2(!'2-((!&*&'&,.!9&8'#-(5q!I$J!-(01-%&*7!

'2(!9-1^(8'! &0! '2(-(!,-(!*1'! 5#00&8&(*'! 0#*)5;! '&%(!1-! 5K&..5! ,E,&.,$.(q! ,*)! I8J!

'(-%&*,'&*7! '2(! 9-1^(8'! &0! '2(! 9-1^(8'! 2,5;! 01-! 1*(! 1-!%1-(! -(,51*5! $(8,%(!

&--(.(E,*'!'1!'2(!1-7,*&e,'&1*L5!$#5&*(55!-(4#&-(%(*'5q!

• T1E&*7!01-S,-)W!B2&5!9-1E&)(5!,!0(()$,8K!.119!'2,'!521#.)!$(!,E,&.,$.(;!*1'!

1*.:!)#-&*7!)(E(.19%(*';!$#'!,.51!'2-1#721#'!'2(!(*'&-(!.&0(!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!

<C3! &5! ,! -(&'(-,'&E(! 9-18(55! $,5()! 1*! '2(! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! 9-17-(55;! ,! -(E&(S! '1!

(*5#-(! '2,'! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! &5! 1*! 81#-5(! '1! -(,.&5(! $#5&*(55! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! ,*!

,7-((%(*'!'1!9-18(()!I3(%(*:&!,*)!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!?FFDJA!

*$,-$N &;R/53(!H'(1![5/91)9'!1;!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!!

<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':!I=>>@J!#*)(-'11K!(`'(*5&E(!-(5(,-82!&*'1!$(5'!9-,8'&8(!01-!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! 0-1%! '2&5! 8-(,'()! ,! 0-,%(S1-K! ,5! &..#5'-,'()! &*! /&7#-(!

?NA!

Page 72: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! OF!

!

X)A85'!,Pc!4;29'[18/0!@;3'0!7;5!>:!3'<'0;[@'21!^I(#85(1D!*++-_!

V'!8,*!$(!5((*!0-1%!'2(!0&7#-(!,$1E(!'2,'!01-!<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':!I=>>@J!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! &5! ,! 81*'&*#1#5!9-18(55! '2-1#72! ,*! (E1.E&*7!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 81*'(`'A!!

<.'21#72!'2&5!0-,%(S1-K!&5!018#5&*7!,7,&*!1*!VB!9-1^(8'5!&'!81#.)!$(!#5()!01-!,*:!

K&*)!10!9-1^(8'!I<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':;!=>>@JA![1S(E(-! &'!)1(5!*1'! &..#5'-,'(!'2(!

&*0.#(*8(5!'2,'!(`'(-*,.!0,8'1-5!%,:!2,E(!1*'1!'2(!9-1^(8'A!

<52#-5'!,*)!612(-':!I=>>@J!)(0&*(!'2(!'(-%!$(*(0&'5!-(E&(S!,5!'2(!u9-18(55!$:!

S2&82W! '2(! 5#88(55! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! &*! '(-%5! 10! $(*(0&'! )(.&E(-:! &5! ,55(55()q!

1991-'#*&'&(5! 01-! '2(! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! 0#-'2(-! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()q! ,*)! .(551*5!

.(,-*()!,*)!1991-'#*&'&(5!01-!&%9-1E(%(*'!&*!0#'#-(!9-1^(8'5!,-(!&)(*'&0&()vA!

*$,-$T F/2/A)2A!(899'((780![5;A5/@@'(!A8)3'!

B2(!G00&8(!10!U1E(-*%(*'!Q1%%(-8(! IGUQJ! &5! ,*! &*)(9(*)(*'!G00&8(!10! '2(!Pd!

B-(,5#-:A! V'!S1-K5!S&'2!9#$.&8!5(8'1-!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!'1!2(.9!'2(%!&%9-1E(!'2(&-!

(00&8&(*8:;! 7,&*! $(''(-! E,.#(! 01-! %1*(:! 0-1%! '2(&-! 81%%(-8&,.! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)!

)(.&E(-! &%9-1E()! 5#88(55! 0-1%! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! I+(..(7-&*(..&! ('! ,.A;!

=>>MJA! B2(! GUQL5! 9#$.&8,'&1*! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.! +-17-,%%(5! IGUQ;! =>>@J!

-(9-(5(*'5!'2(!Pd!U1E(-*%(*'L5!E&(S!1*!'2(!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'!9-&*8&9.(5!

,*)!'(82*&4#(5!'2,'!2,E(!$((*!)(E(.19()!,*)!,99.&()!01-!%,*:!:(,-5A!V*!)-,0'&*7!

!"#$%&'(%)%*+,&%-$'./+0%1$'2'''

!"#$%&'(%)%*+,&%-$'./+0%1$'3'''

!"#$%&'(%)%*+,&%-$'./+0%1$'4'''

5)+*)6-7'8/79-6#9$6+-9*':+-$%;$'

!"#"$%&'()*##+#,'

!"#"$%&'-")+."/0'

!"#"$%&'1".+"2'

!"#"$%&'()*##+#,'

!"#"$%&'-")+."/0'

!"#"$%&'1".+"2'

!"#"$%&'()*##+#,'

!"#"$%&'-")+."/0'

!"#"$%&'1".+"2'

<='>='?%9/-6-7'

<='>=':9,9@6*6$6%#'

Page 73: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! R>!

T,*,7&*7!"#88(550#.!+-17-,%%(5! IGUQ;!=>>@;!GUQ;!=>>M,J;! '2(!GUQ!81*5#.'()!

S&)(.:! 01-! E&(S5;! 81*8(-*5! ,*)! 81*'-&$#'&1*5! 0-1%! .(,)&*7! 9-,8'&'&1*(-5! 0-1%!

S&'2&*!'2(!9#$.&8!,*)!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-5;! &*8.#)&*7!9-10(55&1*,.!$1)&(5!,*)!.(,)&*7!

81*5#.',*8&(5A! T"+! &5! *1S! '2(! ,99-1E()! ,99-1,82! 01-! %,*,7&*7! 9-17-,%%(5!

'2-1#721#'!'2(!Pd!9#$.&8!5(8'1-!I+(..(7-&*(..&!('!,.A;!=>>MJA!

T"+!&)(*'&0&(5!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,5!cc,!81-(!,8'&E&':!,*)!,!81*'&*#1#5!c'2-(,)L!

'2-1#721#'!'2(!9-17-,%%(LL!IGUQ;!=>>M,J;!,*)!0#*),%(*',.!'1!'2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!

$(*(0&'5! 0-1%! *(S! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! )(.&E(-()! $:! 9-1^(8'5! S&'2&*! '2(! 9-17-,%%(A!

H%92,5&5! &5! 9.,8()! 1*! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*;! 4#,*'&0&8,'&1*;! ,55&7*%(*'! 10! 1S*(-5! ,*)!

'-,8K&*7A!

C(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! (*5#-(5! '2,'! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(! ,82&(E(5! '2(! (`9(8'()!

-(5#.'5! $:! '-,*5.,'&*7! $#5&*(55! 1$^(8'&E(5! &*'1! &)(*'&0&,$.(!%(,5#-,$.(! $(*(0&'5!

'2,'!8,*!$(!5:5'(%,'&8,..:!'-,8K()!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!GUQ!'2-1#72!'2&5!9-18(55!,&%5!'1!

%,K(! 5#-(! '2,'! )(5&-()! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(! 1-! 91.&8:! 1#'81%(5! 2,E(! $((*! 8.(,-.:!

)(0&*();! ,-(! %(,5#-,$.(;! ,*)! 9-1E&)(! ,! 81%9(..&*7! 8,5(! 01-! &*E(5'%(*'! \! ,*)!

#.'&%,'(.:! '1! (*5#-(! '2,'! '2(! 82,*7(! 1-! 91.&8:! 1#'81%(5! ,-(! ,8'#,..:! ,82&(E()!

IGUQ;!=>>@JA!!

*$,-$O >'2'7)1(!<)'R!)2!1#'!#/23H;;M!;7![5;A5/@@'!@/2/A'@'21!

3(&55! I=>>@J! .&K(! _,-)! ('! ,.A! I?FFFJ! ,*)! IQ11K(\6,E&(5;! =>>=J! 018#5(5! '2(!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!%1)(.!&*!'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!$(*(0&'5!$:!9-1^(8'5!I]17(5'(!,*)!

_,.K(-;! =>>OJA! 3(&55! I=>>>J! )(0&*(! '2(! 5819(! 10! $(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! ,5! u'2(!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!%1*&'1-&*7!10!$(*(0&'5!)#-&*7!,*)!,0'(-!(`(8#'&1*!92,5(L! ,*)!

)(9&8'5! '2(! uE,.#(! 9,'2v! -(.,'&1*52&9! $('S((*! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! ,5! ,!

[&(-,-82&8,.!C(*(0&'5!5'-#8'#-(!I]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>OJ!5((!/&7#-(!?OA!

Page 74: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! R?!

!

X)A85'!,Nc!>'2'7)1(!H5'/M3;R2!#)'5/59#B!^/3/[1'3!75;@!K;A'(1'!/23!V/0M'5D!*++ND!:')((!'1!/0$D!

*++T_!

B2(! 2&(-,-82:! 9-1915()! $:! 3(&55! &5! *1'! '-,)&'&1*,.! 2&(-,-82:! S&'2! (,82!

5#88(55&E(! u.(,0v! 81--(591*)&*7! '1! 1*.:! ,! 5&*7.(! $-,*82! I]17(5'(! ,*)!_,.K(-;!

=>>OJA!<!9-1^(8'!%,:!8-(,'(!%1-(!'2,*!,!5&*7.(!)(.&E(-,$.(!,*)!,.51!81*'-&$#'(!'1!

,! 5&*7.(! )(.&E(-,$.(! ,.1*7! S&'2! ,*1'2(-! 9-1^(8'! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJq! '2(-(! &5! ,!

c%,*:! '1! %,*:! -(.,'&1*52&95! $('S((*! )(.&E(-,$.(5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5! I3(&55;! =>>>JA!

B2(! 5,%(!,#'21-! &*! I]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>OJ!)(58-&$(5!9-1^(8'5!,5! 8-(,'&*7!

)(.&E(-,$.(5! '2,'! ,-(! 81%$&*()! $:! 9-17-,%%(5! '1! 8-(,'(! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! '1! 7,&*!

$(*(0&'5A!"&%9.:! c$(*(0&'5!,-(!'2(!-(,51*5!$(2&*)!'2(!&*&'&,'&1*!,*)!(`(8#'&1*!10!

9-1^(8'5!I3(&55;!=>>>JA!

*$,P :'([;2()H)0)1B!7;5!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!

*$,P$, :;0'(!

_2&.(! 9-17-,%! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! '(,%5! S&..! $(! &*E1.E()! &*! 9-1^(8'5! '2,'! )(.&E(-!

$#5&*(55! 82,*7(;! '2(! 1*(5! '2,'! ,-(! -(591*5&$.(! 01-! %,*,7&*7! ,*)! -(,.&5&*7!

$(*(0&'5;!,-(! '2(!$#5&*(55!#5(-5!,*)! '2(!%,*,7(-5!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!B2(!T"+!7#&)(!

5','(5!'2,'!'2(!9-1^(8'!1S*(-!&5!-(591*5&$.(!01-!(*5#-&*7!'2(!%,*,7(%(*'!10!'2(!

9-18(55! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5A! V*)&E&)#,.! %,*,7(-5! 10! $#5&*(55! ,-(,5!

521#.)!$(!-(591*5&$.(!01-!,8'#,.!$(*(0&'5!)(.&E(-:!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!

!"#"$%&'(!"#"$%&'( !"#"$%&'(

)"*%+",-.*"()"*%+",-.*"( )"*%+",-.*"(

/-0-.%*%&1( /-0-.%*%&1(

2,34,-55"( 2,34,-55"(

2,36"7&( 2,36"7&( 2,36"7&(2,36"7&(

Page 75: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! R=!

3(&55! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! 21S(E(-! ,-7#(! '2,'! '2(! 1E(-,..! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-! '2(!

5#88(550#.! )(.&E(-:! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 10! &'5! ,*'&8&9,'()!

$(*(0&'5!&5!S&'2!'2(!9-17-,%%(!)&-(8'1-A!B2#5!&5!'2(&-!-(591*5&$&.&':!'1!)(0&*(!'2(!

1E(-,..!5'-,'(7:! 01-!%,`&%&5&*7!$(*(0&'5!,*)! 01-!(*5#-&*7!'2,'!,99-19-&,'(!5',00!

,*)!-(51#-8(5!,-(!,..18,'()!'1!'2(&-!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*A![1S(E(-!1'2(-!

%,*,7(%(*'! -1.(5! 2,E(! %1-(! )&-(8'! -(591*5&$&.&':! ,*)! '2(&-! &*'(-\-(.,'&1*!

521S*! &*! /&7#-(! ?RA! B2(! 81-(! 10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! &5! ,$1#'! (`9.,*,'&1*!

9-(5(*','&1*! ,*)! *(71'&,'&1*! 10! ,7-((%(*'A! B2(! E,-&1#5! -(91-'5;! )18#%(*'5;!

'11.5;! ,*)! '(82*&4#(5!8,*!2(.9!$#';! &*! '2(!(*);! 5#88(550#.!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

-(.&(5!1*!2,E&*7!(`9(-&(*8(;!$#5&*(55!018#5()!5',00;!S&'2!(`8(..(*'!9-(5(*','&1*,.!

,*)!&*'(-\9(-51*,.!5K&..5!,*)!*(,-!(*).(55!9,'&(*8(;!'1!%,K(!&'!,..!2,99(*!I3(&55!

('!,.A;!=>>RJA!

!

X)A85'!,Tc!I!1B[)9/0!;5A/2)(/1);2/0!(1589185'D!(#;R)2A!#;R!1#'!</5);8(![;()1);2(!)2<;0<'3!)2!H'2'7)1(!

@/2/A'@'21!)21'5L5'0/1'!^:')((D!*++T_!

3(&55!I=>>RJ!,.51!,-7#(5!'2,'! '2(!9(19.(!-(591*5&$.(! 01-!,8'#,..:!)(.&E(-&*7!'2(!

$(*(0&'5! ,-(! 10'(*!)&00(-(*'! 0-1%! '215(! -(591*5&$.(! 01-! )&-(8'&*7! ,*)!%,*,7&*7!

'2(! 9-17-,%%(! &'5(.0;! %(,*&*7! '2,'! '2(! 9(19.(! -(591*5&$.(! 01-! -(,.&5&*7! '2(!

!"#$%&'(

!"#)"*++%(,#*"-(

!"#$%&'(./0%(+*0*)%+%0'(

!"#)"*++%(-/"%&'#"(

1*/0(,#*"-(

2%0%3/'(+*0*)%"(

!"#$%&'(+*0*)%"456(

78*0)%(+*0*)%"456(

7#"9#"*'%(:'"*'%);(

2<5/0%55(7*5%(

2%0%3/'(:'"*'%);(9=*0(>(%'&?((

Page 76: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! R@!

$(*(0&'5! ,-(! *1-%,..:! '2(! #5(-5! ,*)! '2(&-! .&*(! %,*,7(-5;! *1'! '2(! 9-17-,%%(!

'(,%! '2,'! 8-(,'()! '2(! 8,9,$&.&':A! [(! ,.51! ,-7#(5! '2,'! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'!

521#.)!$(!5(9,-,'()! 0-1%!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'A!+-1^(8'!%,*,7(-5! '(*)!'1! c2(,)!

)1S*L!,*)!2(,)&*7!01-!'2(!0&*&52!.&*(;!'2(:!)1!*1'!2,E(!'2(!%&*)!5('!'1!81*5&)(-!

'2(!E,.&)&':!10!'2(&-!9-1^(8'5!I3(&55;!=>>>JA!

<881-)&*7!'1!_,-)!('!,.A!I?FFRJ;!59(8&0&8!-(591*5&$&.&':!01-!-(,.&5&*7!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

&5!,..18,'()!S&'2&*!'2(!$#5&*(55!01-!(,82!$(*(0&'A!_2(*!&)(*'&0:&*7!-1.(5!'2(!',5K!

521#.)! &*8.#)(! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,00(8'&*7! '2(! )(.&E(-:! 10! (,82! $(*(0&';! ,*)! '2(!

82,*7(5!,*)!',5K5!*(()()!'1!(*5#-(!)(.&E(-:!I",K,-!,*)!_&)(5',)2;!=>>OJA!!!

3(591*5&$&.&':!01-!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!0,..5!&*'1!01#-!,-(,5!IQQB<;!?FFFJW!

• V)(*'&0:&*7!,*)!)(0&*&*7!\!C#5&*(55!82,*7(!%,*,7(-q!

• +.,**&*7! ,*)! %1*&'1-&*7! Z! +-17-,%%(! 5#991-'! 100&8(-! a! +-17-,%%(!

%,*,7(-q!

• 3(,.&5,'&1*!Z!b&*(!%,*,7(-5q!

• <55(55%(*'! \! V*)&E&)#,.! S&'2! 711)! K*1S.()7(! 10! '2(! ',-7('! $#5&*(55! ,-(,5!

$#'!*1'!)&-(8'.:!&*E1.E()!&*!'2(!9-17-,%%(A!

*$,P$* E;<'52/29'!

V'! &5! 81%%1*! 01-! 51%(! $(*(0&'5! *1'! '1! $(! -(,.&5()! #*'&.! %,*:! :(,-5! $(:1*)!

&%9.(%(*','&1*A! G0'(*! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! *(E(-! -(,.&5()! 1-! %&5%,*,7()! $(8,#5(!

$(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! (*)5! S&'2! 8.15#-(! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'! 1-! 9-17-,%%(! IU.:**(;!

=>>MJA!+,--!,*)!_&..&,%5!I=>>MJ!,8K*1S.()7(!'2,'!,%$&7#&':!8,*!(`&5'!$('S((*!

9-1^(8'!a9-17-,%%(!,*)!$#5&*(55!19(-,'&1*5!-(591*5&$&.&':W!c'2(!*(()!01-!8.(,-.:!

)(0&*()! -(591*5&$&.&'&(5! ,*)! ,55&7*%(*'! 10! '2(5(! '1! -1.(5! ,*)! &*)&E&)#,.5! &5!

2(&72'(*()! S&'2&*! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! $(8,#5(! 10! '2(! 91'(*'&,.! ,%$&7#&':!

$('S((*!',5K5!01-!'2(!)(.&E(-:!'(,%;!,*)!',5K5!01-!'2(!19(-,'&1*,.!$#5&*(55LA!V'!&5!

81%%1*! %&5',K(! 01-! 9-1^(8'5! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(5! '1! 1S*! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! *1'!

&*E1.E(! '215(! )&-(8'.:! ',5K()! S&'2! %,*,7&*7! 82,*7(! S&'2&*! '2(! $#5&*(55!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!IU.:**(;!=>>MJA!/1-!,!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!'1!$(!5#88(550#.;!'2(-(!

%#5'!$(!,*!,7-(()!71E(-*,*8(!%1)(.!'2,'!(*5#-(5!1S*(-52&9!,*)!,881#*',$&.&':!

Page 77: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RN!

#*'&.! ,..! $(*(0&'5! 2,E(! $((*! 01-%,..:! -(E&(S()! ,*)! %(,5#-()! IC-,).(:;! =>>R;!

U.:**(;!=>>M;!_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!!

Q11K(\6,E&(5!I=>>=J!,.51!2&72.&72'5!'2(!&%91-',*8(!10!71E(-*,*8(!,*)!9-1915(5!

'2,'!'2(!01..1S&*7!'2-((!9-&*8&9.(5!c#*)(-9&*!,*:!(00(8'&E(!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!

5:5'(%!I]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>OJW!

• Q-(,'(! 9-1^(8'! 71E(-*,*8(! 5'-#8'#-(5! '2,'! &*E1.E(! $1'2! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! '2(!

0#*8'&1*,.!.&*(!1-7,*&5,'&1*q!

• 6-&E(!,..!71E(-*,*8(!)(8&5&1*5!,$1#'!'2(!9-1^(8'!'2-1#72!'2(!$#5&*(55!8,5(q!

• 3()(0&*(! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! %('21)5! ,*)! 0-,%(S1-K5! 51! ,5! '1! %,K(!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*!&*'(7-,.!9,-'A!

*$,N >'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!W!M'B!'0'@'21(D!1;;0(!/23!1'9#2)]8'(!

B2(! 01..1S&*7! 5(8'&1*! &*'-1)#8(5! '2(!%,&*! (.(%(*'5;! '11.5! ,*)! '(82*&4#(5! '2,'!

,-(!#5()!&*!'2(!,99-1,82(5!%(*'&1*()!$(01-(!,5!'2(:!2,E(!$((*!&)(*'&0&()!&*!'2(!

.&'(-,'#-(A!B2(!.&5'!10!'2(!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!2,5!$((*!81%9&.()!$:!&)(*'&0:&*7!

'2(! 81%%1*! ,-(,5! $('S((*! ,..! ,99-1,82(5! ,*)! '2(&-! &%91-',*8(! &*! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'A!/&7#-(!?M!&..#5'-,'(5!'215(!%,&*!&*7-()&(*'5!&*!,!7(*(-&8!,99-1,82!

'1!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!$:!GUQ!I=>>@J;!'2(5(!,-(W!!

• C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*q!

• C(*(0&'5!V)(*'&0&8,'&1*;!)(9(*)(*8:;!%,99&*7q!

• C(*(0&'5!%(,5#-(%(*'q!

• C(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7A!

Page 78: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RO!

!

X)A85'!,Oc!E'2'5)9!/[[5;/9#!1;!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!^JE4D!*++-_!

B2(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!)1!*1'!^#5'!2,99(*()!^#5'!$:!)(.&E(-&*7!9-1^(8'5!

%#5'!$(!5#991-'()!S&'2!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!'1!%(,5#-(!'2(!$(*(0&'5q!,*)!S&'2!

9-18()#-(5! 01-! %1*&'1-&*7;! -(91-'&*7! ,*)! -(591*)&*7! '1! '2(&-! ,82&(E(%(*'! 1-!

*1*\,82&(E(%(*'! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! +,:*(! I=>>MJ! 5#991-'5! '2,'! E&(S! ,*)!

2&72.&72'5! 'S1! %1-(! 8-&'&8,.! (.(%(*'5! &*! ,! $,.,*8()! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'!

(*E&-1*%(*';!I&J!b(,)(-52&9!,*)!I&&J!+(19.(a1-7,*&5,'&1*!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!/&7#-(!

?DA!

!

X)A85'!,Sc!45)1)9/0!'0'@'21(!;7!/!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!'2<)5;2@'21!^"/B2'D!*++O_!

!"#"$%&'()"*+%'*&%,#(-+*#(

.,'&(/(0"#"$%&(1#*+2'%'(

3"4"+,56"#&(*#7(865+"6"#&*&%,#((

!"#"$%&'(87"#&%$%9*&%,#((

!"#"$%&'(:*#*;"6"#&(<&=*&";2(

)"*+%'%#;(*#7(&=*9>%#;(0"#"$%&'(

?5&%6%'%#;(&@"(6%A(,B(0"#"$%&'(

)"4%"C%#;(*#7(6*A%6%'%#;(0"#"$%&'(

!"#$"%&'()* +",)-"*.*/%0#1(&#2(,1*

3,,-&*#1$*3"4'1(56"&*

7"1"8(2&*9#1#0"9"12**

Page 79: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RR!

<!$-&(0!)(58-&9'&1*!10!'2(5(!%,&*!(.(%(*'5!&5!7&E(*!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!5(8'&1*5!,*)!

,!%1-(!)(',&.()!1*(!&5!&*8.#)()!&*!Q2,9'(-5!N!,*)!O!S(-(!'2(!,-82&'(8'#-(!10!'2(!

C(3(,.!9-18(55!&5!0#..:!59(8&0&()A!

*$,N$, >'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!(15/1'AB!/23!5'/0)(/1);2![0/2!

V*! '2(! <8'&E(! C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! $:! 3(%(*:&! ,*)! "2(-S11)\! "%&'2!

I?FFDJ! #*)(-.&*(! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! ,.&7*&*7! '2(! $#5&*(55! 1991-'#*&':! '1! '2(!

5'-,'(7:!10!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,5!(`9-(55()!$:!&'!8-&'&8,.!5#88(55!0,8'1-5A!

GUQ! I=>>MJ! #*)(-.&*(5! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! )1&*7! ,! %,*,7(%(*'! 9.,*! '2,'!

)(58-&$(5!21S!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!S&52(5!'1!%,*,7(!,*)!,82&(E(!$(*(0&'5!0-1%!,*:!

&*E(5'%(*'! &*! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(A! B2(! C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*! +.,*! \! &*8.#)&*7! K(:!

,55#%9'&1*5! ,*)! 5(*5&'&E&':! ,*)! -&5K! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '215(! $(*(0&'5! (`9(8'()! '1!

81*'-&$#'(! %15'! '1! 1#'81%(5! \! 521#.)! $(! 5((*! ,5! ,! %,^1-! 81%91*(*'! 10! '2&5!

)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!9-18(55!IGUQ;!=>>M$JA!_,-)!('!,.! I?FFRJ!,-7#(!'2,'!S&'21#'!,!

9.,*! &'! &5! )&00&8#.'! '1! 9-()&8'! 21S! ,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! %&72'! (00(8'&E(.:! -(,.&5(!

$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5A!

*$,N$* >'2'7)1(!)3'21)7)9/1);2D!3'['23'29B!/23!@/[[)2A!

B2&5! &5! '2(! &*&'&,'&1*!5',7(!10!,*:!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!8:8.(!S2(-(!,..!)(5&-()!

$(*(0&'5! 521#.)! $(! &)(*'&0&()! ,*)! )18#%(*'()A! C(5'! 9-,8'&8(! &5! '1! &*E1.E(! K(:!

5',K(21.)(-5! '1! &)(*'&0:! ,*)! ,7-((! )(5&-()! $(*(0&'5A! B2&5! %,`&%&5(5! '2(!

.&K(.&211)!10!81%%&'%(*'! '1!-(,.&5&*7! '215(!$(*(0&'5!,8-155!,!-,*7(!10! .(E(.5! &*!

'2(!$#5&*(55!1-!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!IU.:**(;!=>>MJA!C(*(0&'5!,'!'2&5!5',7(!521#.)!$(!

5'-#8'#-()! &*! 1-)(-! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! .&*K,7(5! $('S((*! '(82*1.17:! (00(8'5;!

$#5&*(55!82,*7(5!,*)!1E(-,..!$#5&*(55!(00(8'5!I",K,-!,*)!_&)(5',)2;!=>>OJA!

6(E(.19&*7! $(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:! *('S1-K! &5! ,*! &'(-,'&E(! 9-18(55;! ,5! -(4#&-()!

82,*7(5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()! ,*)! ,! *('S1-K! 10! &*'(--(.,'&*7! 82,*7(5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5!

(E1.E(5!,*)!'2(!0(,5&$&.&':!10!,82&(E&*7!51%(!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!1-&7&*,..:!&)(*'&0&()!

S&..!$(!4#(5'&1*()!IC-,).(:;!=>>R;!+,:*(;!=>>M;!_,-)!,*)!H.E&*;!?FFFJA!"1.#'&1*5!

S2&82!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5!S&..!2,E(!$((*!)(5&7*()!0-1%!5',K(21.)(-5!E&(S!1-!E&5&1*!

Page 80: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RM!

S2,'!81*5'&'#'(5!,!$(*(0&'! I]17(5'(!,*)!_,.K(-;!=>>OJA! V'! 8,*!$(!,-7#()! '2,'!,!

5',K(21.)(-! S1-K5219! 9-1E&)(5! ,!%(,*5! 10! )(E(.19&*7! ,! $(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:!

*('S1-K!I_,-)!,*)!H.E&*;!?FFFJA!C(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,8,--&*&!I=>>NJ!,.51!5#991-'!

'2(!E&(S!'2,'!&*'(-E&(S5!,*)!S1-K52195!S&'2!5',K(21.)(-5!&5!,!5'-1*7!'(82*&4#(!

10! &)(*'&0:&*7!9-1^(8'!$(*(0&'5! I]17(5'(;!=>>RJA!<!$(*(0&'5!)(9(*)(*8:!*('S1-K!

,99-1,82! )(9&8'5! '2,'! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(5! (*,$.(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 82,*7(! I3(&55;!

=>>>JA! <! $(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:!%,9! 81#.)! -(5#.'! &*'1! ,! 5'-(,%! 0.1S! 10! $(*(0&'5!

1E(-! '&%(! -(5#.'&*7! 0-1%! ,! 5#88(550#.! &%9.(%(*','&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'! 10! ,!

$#5&*(55!9-17-,%!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!

*$,N$- >'2'7)1(!@'/(85'@'21D!5/2M)2A!/23![5);5)1)(/1);2!

T(,5#-(%(*'! &5! '2(! K(:! '1! (00(8'&E(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,881-)&*7! '1! B21-9!!

I?FFDJ;!&A(A!c&0!:1#!8,*y'!%(,5#-(!&';!:1#!8,*y'!%,*,7(!&'L;!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!B2(!5,%(!

,#'21-! &*! 2&5! C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*! <99-1,82! ,-7#(5! '2,'! %(,5#-(%(*'! &5!

&%91-',*'!S&'2!-(.(E,*';!,88#-,'(!,*)!81*5&5'(*'!%(,5#-(5!10!'2(!9(-01-%,*8(!10!

(,82!9-17-,%;!,*)!10! '2(!9-1^(8'5!S&'2&*! '2(%A! V'!%#5'!$(!)('(-%&*()!S2,'! '1!

%(,5#-(!,*)!S2(*!'1!%(,5#-(!&'!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FF@JA!B2(!8-&'(-&,!01-!)(5&7*&*7!

(00(8'&E(!%(,5#-(%(*'!5:5'(%5!,-(!,881-)&*7!'1!IB21-9;!?FFDJW!

• T,K(!5#-(!%(,5#-(5!(`&5'q!

• T(,5#-(!'2(!-&72'!'2&*75q!

• T(,5#-(!'2&*75!'2(!-&72'!S,:q!,*)!

• T,K(!5#-(!%(,5#-(%(*'!5:5'(%5!7#&)(!)(8&5&1*5!,*)!,8'&1*A!

V'! &5! 10'(*! E(-:! )&00&8#.'! '1! 81*E(-'! ,! 91.&8:! E&5&1*! 1-! ,! $#5&*(55! 5'-,'(7:! &*'1!

)(',&.()! ,*)! %(,5#-,$.(! 5','(%(*'5! 10! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5A! V'! 8,*! $(! 2,-)! '1!

-(,.&5(!,*)!%(,5#-(!,..!$(*(0&'5!0-1%!,*!&*E(5'%(*'!1-!82,*7(!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!!

C(8,#5(!51%(!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!%,:!$(!5(81*),-:;!1*(5!'2,'!S(-(!*1'!(`9(8'()!,*)!

2,E(! -(5#.'()! &*)&-(8'.:! 0-1%! '2(! 82,*7(5! '2,'! 2,E(!$((*!%,)(;! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;!

?FFFJA!

Page 81: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RD!

<881-)&*7!'1!IB21-9;!?FFDJ!'2(!0#*),%(*',.!81*8(9'5!10!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!2(.9!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!)(,.!(00(8'&E(.:!S&'2!'2(!&55#(!10!%(,5#-&*7!E,.#(!&*!01#-!&%91-',*'!

S,:5W!

• V)(*'&0:!'2(!1#'81%(5!'1!%(,5#-(;!,*)!21S!'1!%(,5#-(!'2(%q!

• "21S! '2(! -(,51*&*7! ,$1#'! '2(! .&*K,7(5! -(.,'&*7! 9-17-,%5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! '1!

1#'81%(5;!%,K&*7!&'!(,5&(-!'1!#*)(-5',*)!S2,'y5!71&*7!1*q!

• T,K(!%(,5#-(%(*'! 81%(! ,.&E(! $:! 8.(,-.:! ':&*7! ,881#*',$&.&':! '1!%(,5#-()!

-(5#.'5q!,*)!

• B,K(!,8'&1*!$,5()!#91*!%(,5#-(%(*'5!'2-1#72!0#..!8:8.(!71E(-*,*8(A!

3(&55! ('! ,.A! I=>>RJ! )(58-&$(! '2,'! %,*:! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! ,-(! 10'(*! '(%9'()! '1!

%(,5#-(!,*)!(E,.#,'(!'2(!5#88(55!10!,!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!$,5()!1*.:!1*!2,-)!

$(*(0&'5A!!B2(!)-,S$,8K5!S&'2!'2&5!,-(W!

• B2(!%15'!E,.#,$.(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!10'(*!.,-7(.:!&*',*7&$.(q!

• B2(!(,5:\'1\%(,5#-(!,*)!0&*,*8&,..:!1-&(*'()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!10'(*!'2(!.1*7!'(-%!

-(5#.'5!10!7,&*&*7!%1-(!&%%()&,'(!510'!$(*(0&'5!,*)!!

• _2&.(!-&5K5!8,*!$(!%,*,7()!(00(8'&E(.:!S&'2&*!,!9-17-,%%(;!&'!&5!%#82!%1-(!

)&00&8#.'!'1!0,8'1-!'2(!&%9,8'!10!-&5K!,*)!#*8(-',&*':!&*'1! .1*7\'(-%!0&*,*8&,.!

9-1^(8'&1*A!!

<.51! ,881-)&*7! '1! C,-'21.1%(S! I?FFFJ! &*! "()(-,! ('! ,.A! I=>>?J! 2,-)!%(,5#-(5!

5#82! ,5! 0&*,*8&,.! 0&7#-(5! 8,*! E(-:! 10'(*! $(! 81*0#5&*7! ,*)! )(8(9'&E(! ,5! '2(!

&*',*7&$.(! ,55('5! 10! ,! $#5&*(55! 8,*! 10'(*! $(!S1-'2!%1-(! '2,*! '215(!S2&82! ,-(!

',*7&$.(;!#9!'1!D>x!IC,-'21.1%(S;!?FFF;!"()(-,!('!,.A;!=>>?JA!

U.:**(!I=>>RJ!,-7#(5!'2,'!&0!,!$(*(0&'!8,**1'!$(!%(,5#-()!*#%(-&8,..:!,*)!$,5(!

.&*()!&'!521#.)!*1'!$(!&*8.#)()!&*!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*;!510'!$(*(0&'5!8,*!$(!

)&00&8#.'!'1!%(,5#-(!,*)!'2(:!%,:!*(()!'1!$(!.(0'!1#'!10!5#82!9.,*A!

3(&55!('!,.A! I=>>RJ!5','(! '2,'!S2('2(-!-(.:&*7!1*!2,-)!1-!510'!$(*(0&'5! '1! ^#5'&0:!

'2(!5#88(55!10!,!9-17-,%%(!'2(!,*,.:5&5!%#5'!$(!-&71-1#5;! 81%9-(2(*5&E(!,*)!

,7-(()!$:!,..!K(:!5',K(21.)(-5A!/#-'2(-%1-(!&'!521#.)!$(!9155&$.(!'1!(`9-(55!,..!

Page 82: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! RF!

$(*(0&'5! &*! 5#82! S,:! '2,'! '2(&-! #.'&%,'(! ,82&(E(%(*'! 8,*! $(! (5',$.&52()A! V*!

9-,8'&8(!5#88(550#.!9-17-,%%(5!81%$&*(!,!-,*7(!10!2,-)!,*)!510'!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!

)&00(-(*8(! $('S((*! '2(! 'S1! ':9(5! 10! $(*(0&'! $(81%(5! .(55! &%91-',*'! ,5! 2,-)!

$(*(0&'5!,-(! '(%9(-()!S&'2!9-1E&5&1*5!,$1#'!-&5K!,*)!*1'&1*5!10!2#%,*!*,'#-(!

,*)! 510'! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! )(0&*()! &*! '(-%5! 10! %(,*&*70#.! ',-7('5;! %&.(5'1*(5! ,*)!

%(,5#-(5!I3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!

T(,5#-&*7! $#5&*(55! ,*)! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 9(-01-%,*8(! ,*)! 5(''&*7! ',-7('5! 01-!

&%9-1E(%(*'5! &5! ,*! &*8-(,5&*7.:! &%91-',*'! ,59(8'! 10! %,*,7(%(*'! I_,-)! ,*)!

6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!!

C(**&*7'1*! ,*)! C,88,-&*&! I=>>NJ! ,*)! _,-)! ('! ,.A! I?FFRJ! 5#77(5'! '2,'! d(:!

+(-01-%,*8(!V*)&8,'1-5!Id+VJ!,-(!$(&*7!,..18,'()!'1!9-1^(8'!$(*(0&'5;!,5!$(*(0&'5!

S&'21#'! d+V5! ,-(! 10! .&''.(! E,.#(! ,*)! '2(-(! 521#.)! $(! *1! E,.&)! -(,51*! S2:!

%(,5#-(%(*'!10!$(*(0&'5!521#.)!$(!,!9-1$.(%A!!

*$,N$P >'2'7)1(!@;2)1;5)2A!/23!5'<)'R!

C(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7!81%9,-(5!9-1^(8'! -(5#.'5!S&'2! '2(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!

)#-&*7!'2(!9-1^(8'!,*)!,55(55(5!&0!,*:!&*'(-*,.!1-!(`'(-*,.!82,*7(5!2,E(!188#--()!

'2,'!S&..!,00(8'!'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!9.,**()!$(*(0&'5!I_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!

C(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7! &5! ,! .1*7! 8:8.(A! <881-)&*7! '1! C,-'.(''! I=>>RJ! &'! 5',-'5!S&'2!

$(*(0&'5! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! (*)5! S&'2! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*A! B2(! $(*(0&'5! 5','()! &*!

9-17-,%%(L5! $#5&*(55! 8,5(! ,-(! '2(! -(5#.'! 10! ,*! 10'(*\9-1'-,8'()! 9(-&1)! 10!

$(*(0&'5!9.,**&*7A!C:!'2(!'&%(!'2(!$#5&*(55!8,5(!2,5!$((*!5&7*()!10;!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

,5!1-&7&*,..:!81*8(&E()!%,:!2,E(!$((*!5&7*&0&8,*'.:!)&.#'()!IC,-'.('';!=>>RJA!

C(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,88,-&*&!I=>>NJ!21S(E(-!,-7#(!'2,'!%15'!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!)1!*1'!!!!

%1*&'1-!'2(!$(*(0&'5!01-!'2(!01..1S&*7!-(,51*5W!

• b,8K!10!(`9(-&(*8(!,*)a1-!$#5&*(55!,S,-(*(55q!

• /18#5!1*!%,*,7&*7!'2(!)(.&E(-,$.(5!-,'2(-!'2,*!'2(!$(*(0&'5q!

• V*5#.,'&1*! 0-1%! '2(!$(*(0&'5! '2,'! 81%(! 0-1%!S2(*!$#5&*(55!%,*,7(%(*'! &5!

-(591*5&$.(!01-!#5(-5q!

Page 83: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! M>!

• b,8K!10!018#5!1*!'2(!9(19.(!S21!S&..!(*^1:!'2(!$(*(0&'5q!

• H%1'&1*,.! 81%%&'%(*'! '1! '2(! 81*'&*#&':! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! 51! *1'! 19(*! '1!

82,*7(5!'1!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!'2-(,'(*!9-1^(8'!E&,$&.&':q!

• b,8K!10!'11.5!'1!2(.9!(*5#-(!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!S&..!$(!)(.&E(-()A!

<881-)&*7! '1! _,-)! ,*)! U-&00&'25! I?FFRJ! '1! $(! ,$.(! '1! %1*&'1-! $(*(0&'5!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!2,E(!'1!,8'&E(.:!1E(-81%(!,*)!2,*).(!'2(!82,..(*7(5!S&'2!$(*(0&'5!

%1*&'1-&*7A! <52#-5'! ,*)!612(-':! I=>>@J! 8,..! '2(! $(*(0&'5!%1*&'1-&*7! 5',7(! 01-!

$(*(0&'5!)(.&E(-:!,*)!)(0&*(!&'!,5!u'2(!(`(8#'&1*!10!'2(!5('!10!,8'&1*5!*(8(55,-:!'1!

-(,.&e(!,..!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!59(8&0&()!&*!'2(!$(*(0&'!9.,*vA!Q1*5(4#(*'.:!'2(!9-18(55!

10! $(*(0&'5! )(.&E(-:! ':9&8,..:! -#*5! 0-1%!9-1^(8'! &*&'&,'&1*;! ,0'(-! ,99-1E,.! 10! '2(!

$#5&*(55!8,5(!1-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*;! '2-1#72!'1!81%9.('&1*!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!

C(*(0&'5!)(.&E(-:! 018#5(5!#91*!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!82,*7(!*(8(55,-:!'1! 0,8&.&','(!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;! -,'2(-! '2,*! '2(! )(.&E(-:! 10! '2(! 51.#'&1*! I",K,-! ,*)!

_&)(5',)2;!=>>OJA!

*$,T !Y)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!(8@@/5B!/23!3)(98(();2!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82!(%(-7()!&*!'2(!5(8'1-!10!&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5!

,*)! '(82*1.17:! )#-&*7! '2(! ?FF>L5A! V'! S,5! %1'&E,'()! $:! '2(! .1S! 5#88(55! 10!

'(82*1.17:! &%9.(%(*','&1*! 1*! 7(*(-,'&*7! '2(! (`9(8'()! $#5&*(55! $(*(0&'5! '1!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5! IB21-9;!?FFDJA!3(&55!('! ,.A! I=>>RJ!(%92,5&5(! '2,'! '2(-(! &5! ,!9,'2!

0-1%!9-1^(8'5!'1!$(*(0&'5W!9-1^(8'5!2,E(!1#'9#'5!,*)!'2(!81%$&*,'&1*!10!)&00(-(*'!

1#'9#'5! 7(*(-,'(5! '2(! 8,9,$&.&'&(5! '2,'! (*,$.(! '2(! )(5&-()! $(*(0&'5! '1! $(!

,82&(E()A! <881-)&*7! '1! '2(! 5,%(! ,#'21-;! S&'21#'! '2(! (00(8'&E(! '-,*5&'&1*! 0-1%!

1#'9#'5!'1!1#'81%(5;!9-1)#8'5!,*)!5(-E&8(5!-(%,&*!1*.:!8,9,$&.&'&(5;!1-!91'(*'&,.!

51#-8(5!10!$(*(0&'5A!

<881-)&*7! '1!B21-9! I?FFDJ! '2(!*(()! 01-!%,*,7&*7!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &5!$,5()!

1*! '2-((! 9-(%&5(5W! I,J! $(*(0&'5! )1! *1'! ,#'1%,'&8,..:! ,99(,-!S2(*! ,! 9-1^(8'! &5!

)(.&E(-()q!I$J!$(*(0&'5!-,-(.:!2,99(*!,881-)&*7!'1!9.,*q!,*)!I8J!-(,.&5&*7!$(*(0&'5!

&5! ,! 81*'&*#1#5! 9-18(55! 10! (*E&5&1*&*7! -(5#.'5;! &%9.(%(*'&*7;! 82(8K&*7!

Page 84: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! M?!

&*'(-%()&,'(! -(5#.'5! ,*)! ):*,%&8,..:! ,)^#5'&*7! '2(! 9,'2! .(,)&*7! 0-1%!

&*E(5'%(*'5!'1!$#5&*(55!-(5#.'5A!

G*(! 0#*),%(*',.! ,59(8'! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! &5! '1! &*8-(,5(! '2(!

9-()&8',$&.&':!10!$(*(0&'5!$(&*7!-(,.&5()!'2-1#72!E&5#,.&5&*7!'2(!)&00(-(*'!9155&$.(!

9,'25!0-1%!,8'&1*5!'1!-(5#.'5!,*)!'1!'2(!7(*(-,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5;!S2&.(!81*5',*'.:!

(E,.#,'&*7! I3(%(*:&! ,*)! "2(-S11)\"%&'2;! ?FFDJA! zS&K,(.! ,*)! "%:-K! I=>??J!

(%92,5&5(! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! (5',$.&52&*7! ,! 71E(-*,*8(! 5'-#8'#-(! ,*)! 8,--:&*7!

1#'!(E,.#,'&1*!8:8.(5!'1!%,&*',&*!'2(!018#5!10!9-1^(8'5!1*!,82&(E&*7!'2(!(`9(8'()!

1#'81%(5A!

V*! ,))&'&1*;! 5',K(21.)(-! 81%%&'%(*'! &*! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! &5!

(55(*'&,.!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!<881-)&*7!'1!'2(!5,%(!,#'21-;!&0!82,*7(!&5!&%915()!1*!

9(19.(!S&'2!*1!(`9.,*,'&1*!10!'2(!-(,51*!S2:;!'2(*!7-(,'!-(5&5',*8(!&5!7(*(-,'()A!

"#88(55! &5!%#82!%1-(! .&K(.:!S2(*!5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!(*7,7()! &*! 01-%#.,'&*7!'2(!

E&5&1*! 1-! ,'! .(,5'! &*0.#(*8&*7! '2(! 52,9(! 10! '2(! 82,*7(;! ,*)!S2(-(! '2(:! 8,*! 5((!

8.(,-!E,.#(;!(&'2(-!01-!'2(%5(.E(5;!1-!01-!'2(!S21.(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!

B2(!&%91-',*8(!10!(*7,7&*7!)&00(-(*'!5',K(21.)(-5!'1!)&58#55!9-1^(8'!E,.#(5!2,5!

,.51! $((*! (`9.1-()! &*! 81*5'-#8'&1*! '2-1#72! '2(! ,)19'&1*! 10! ,! E,.#(\$,5()!

,99-1,82!'1!)(5&7*!%,*,7(%(*'!IQ2-&5'100(-5(*!,*)!H%%&';!=>>FJA!!

T1-(1E(-;! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! .&'(-,'#-(! (%92,5&5(5! '2(! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10!

9-1^(8'5! ,5! 5:5'(%5! &*! S2&82! 81..(8'&E(.:! &)(*'&0:&*7! '2(! %,*:\'1\%,*:!

-(.,'&1*52&95! $('S((*! 9-1^(8'5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! (55(*'&,.! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA!

C(*(0&'! %,99&*7! 8.,-&0&(5! '2(! -1#'(! '1! $(*(0&'5;! '2(! )(9(*)(*8&(5! $('S((*!

9-1^(8'5;! )(.&E(-,$.(5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5;! ,5! S(..! ,5! '2(! )&5'-&$#'&1*! 10! $#)7('! ,*)!

-(591*5&$&.&'&(5A! <5! ,! 81*5(4#(*8(;! &'! 9-1E&)(5! $,5&5! 01-! -&5K! %,*,7(%(*';!

%1*&'1-&*7!,*)!$#)7(',-:!81*'-1.!I3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!Q1*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!

&5!,.51!(%92,5&5();!$,5()!1*!8:8.&8!(E,.#,'&1*5!'1!(*,$.(!.(,-*&*7!,*)!,),9','&1*!

I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJA!B2(!&%91-',*8(!10!81*5&)(-&*7!81*'&*#1#5!-(\(E,.#,'&1*!10!

9-1^(8'! %(,*5;! (*)5! ,*)! 81*5'-,&*'5! &5! ,.51! )&58#55()! $:! C,..,-)! I=>>DJ! ,*)!

[1S(..!('!,.A!I?FF@JA!

Page 85: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! M=!

"1%(!82,..(*7(5!'1!1E(-8,%(!'2,'!2,E(!$((*!&)(*'&0&()!&*!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!

.&'(-,'#-(! ,-(W! I,J! '2(! ,$&.&':! 10! 5(''&*7! '2(! ,)(4#,'(! %(,5#-(%(*'5! '1! '-,8K!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;! 5&*8(! &'! &5! )&00&8#.'! '1! 81*E(-'! ,! 91.&8:! E&5&1*! 1-! ,! $#5&*(55!

5'-,'(7:! &*'1! )(',&.()! ,*)!%(,5#-,$.(! 5','(%(*'5! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJq! I$J! '2(! 0,8'!

'2,'! 51%(! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! %,:! $(! 5(81*),-:;! *1*\(`9(8'()! ,*)! ,! -(5#.'! 10!

82,*7(5! '2,'!S(-(!%,)(! )#-&*7! &%9.(%(*','&1*! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;! ?FFFJq! ,*)! I8J!

,0'(-! '2(! 9-1^(8'! 2,5! $((*! )(.&E(-();! 7(*(-,..:! '2(! '(,%! &5! )&59(-5();!

-(9-(5(*'&*7! ,! )&00&8#.':! '1! 5('! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-! '2(! ,881#*',$&.&':! 10! $(*(0&'5!

IzS&K,(.!,*)!"%:-K;!=>>FJA!!

/1..1S&*7!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!5#%%,-&5&*7!'2(!,#'21-!9-(5(*'5!2&5!&*&'&,.!

#*)(-5',*)&*7!&*!311K(!('!,.A!I=>?>J!'2,'!'2(-(!&5!,!*(()!01-!,!*(S!%1-(!(00(8'&E(!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55!'2,'!(%$1)&(5!,*)!19(-,'&1*,.&5(5!

'2(!81*8(9'5!,*)!&55#(5!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-A!B2(! .(,-*&*7!,5!7(*(-,'()!,'!

'2&5!5',7(!8,*!$(!5#%%,-&5()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!91&*'5W!!

• H`9(8','&1*5!%#5'!$(!%,*,7()A! !"&*8(!'2(!9-18(55!10!,82&(E&*7!1$^(8'&E(!

E,.#(! ^#)7%(*'5! &5! &*'(-\5#$^(8'&E(;! '2(!5#99.&(-!,5!S(..!,5!'2(!8#5'1%(-!

&*0.#(*8(5!&'A!!+-1^(8'!%,*,7(-5!%#5'!$(!8,-(0#.!*1'!'1!7(*(-,'(!#*-(,.&5'&8!

(`9(8','&1*5!'2,'!S&..! .(,)!'1!'2(!8#5'1%(-!$(&*7!)&5,991&*'()A!IC,-'.('';!

=>>Rq!3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJq!

• +-1^(8'!,*)!9-1)#8'! .1*7(E&':!,-(!,.51!,!'2-(,'!'1!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*;!,5!

9(-8(9'&1*5!%,:! 82,*7(! 1E(-! '&%(;! '2&5! *(()5! '1! $(! ,))-(55()! '2-1#72!

(`9(8','&1*5!%,*,7(%(*'!IC,-'.('';!=>>RJq!

• B2(! .&*K! $('S((*! 5'-,'(7&8! ,&%5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5! &5! E#.*(-,$.(! '1!

$-(,K)1S*!,*)!%#5'!$(!%1*&'1-()!IB21-9;!?FFDJq!

• <! 0#..! ,*,.:5&5! 10! 91'(*'&,.! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,*)! '2(! &%9,8'! 1*! '2(%! &5!

*(8(55,-:! &*! 1-)(-! '1! -(5&5'! '2(! 9155&$&.&':! 10! #*&*'(*)()! 1#'81%(5!

IB21-9;!?FFDq!](S81%$(;!=>>@Jq!

• "',K(21.)(-! &*'(-(5'5! S&..! 51%('&%(5! 81*0.&8';! 9-(5(*'&*7! )&00&8#.'&(5! 01-!

'2(! )('(-%&*,'&1*! 10! ,! E,.#(! ,*)! -(4#&-&*7! 5(*5&'&E&':! '1! ,*)! 9-1,8'&E(!

%,*,7(%(*'! 10! 91S(-! -(.,'&1*5! I](S81%$(;! =>>@q! d(*-&8K;! =>>Nq!

",91#*'e&5!('!,.A;!=>>D$Jq!

Page 86: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! M@!

• <!0#..!,*,.:5&5!10! '2(!9(-51**(.! &*E1.E()!&*!$(*(0&'!)(.&E(-:! &5!*(8(55,-:;!

&*8.#)&*7! '&%(! 10! &*E1.E(%(*';! ,8'&E&':! ,*)! %1'&E,'&1*5! IB21-9;! ?FFDq!

311K(!('!,.A;!=>>@Jq!

• B&%(.&*(5! S&..! $(! E#.*(-,$.(! '1! ,..! '2(! &*0.#(*8(5! .&5'()! ,$1E(! IB21-9;!

?FFDJq!

• "#88(550#.! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! -(4#&-(5! '2,'! 5#99.&(-5! ,8'&E(.:! $#&.)!

)&,.17#(! ,*)! 9,-'*(-52&9!S&'2! '2(&-! 8#5'1%(-5! I[,--&51*!r! h12*;! ?FFRq!

<:#51!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!

*$,O =B21#'()(! ;7! 1#'! 0)1'5/185'! 5'<)'R! /23! 9;29'[18/0! [5;9'((!

3'<'0;[@'21!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-!521S5!'2,'!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!

,99-1,82! 5#77(5'5! ,! 81*'&*#1#5! 9-18(55! 10! (*E&5&1*&*7! -(5#.'5;! &%9.(%(*'&*7;!

82(8K&*7! &*'(-%()&,'(! -(5#.'5! ,*)!):*,%&8,..:! ,)^#5'&*7! '2(!9,'2! .(,)&*7! 0-1%!

&*E(5'%(*'! '1! -(5#.'5! IB21-9;! ?FFDJA! ! B2(! *(S! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! ,5!

)(E(.19()! ,*)! &*E(5'&7,'()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! 521#.)! ,&%! '1! ,))-(55! '2(! %,^1-!

-(,51*5!'2,'!9-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5!,-(!0,&.&*7!'1!,82&(E(!5#88(55!,5!&)(*'&0&()!

&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!5#%%,-&5()!$(.1SA!

I,J! B2(!E,7#(*(55!S&'2!S2&82!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!)(0&*()!,*)!0#-'2(-!

)&00&8#.'&(5! '1! %,&*',&*! 018#5! S2(*! 5#$5(4#(*'! 9-1$.(%5! 188#-! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;!

=>>RJ! ,5! S(..! ,5! ,! 81*5(4#(*'! #*8(-',&*':! &*! ,..18,'&*7! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-!

%,*,7&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!$(*(0&'5!Ib&*!,*)!+(-E,*;!=>>?Jq!

I$J! B2(!*1*\81*5&)(-,'&1*!10!51%(!5',K(21.)(-5!,*)!21S!'2(:!8,*!&*0.#(*8(!

9-1^(8'5L!-(5#.'5!I_,-)!r!6,*&(.;!=>>RJq!!

I8J! B2(! .1*7! 9(-&1)5! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'L5! .&0(! 8:8.(;! .(,)&*7! '1! ,! )&581**(8'&1*!

$('S((*!$(*(0&'5!9.,**&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-:!)#(!'1!82,*7(5!&*!9(-51**(.!I3(&55!('!,.A;!

=>>RJq!!

I)J! B2(! *1*\81*5&)(-,'&1*! 10! *(8(55,-:! &*'(-81**(8'()! &55#(5! '2,'! %&72'!

&*0.#(*8(!'2(!9-1^(8'L5!5#88(55!IB21-9;!?FFDJq!,*)!

Page 87: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MN!

I(J! +11-! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! *(8(55,-:! %(,*5! '1! ,82&(E(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 911-!

,$&.&':!'1!%,*,7(!82,*7(!IB-#,`;!?FFMJA!

B2(! %,'(-&,.! -(E&(S()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &5! 7-1#9()! &*! '2&5! 5(8'&1*! $:!

5&%&.,-&':;! -(5#.'&*7! &*! ,! %,'-&`! IB,$.(! DJ! '2,'! 9-(5(*'5! )&00(-(*'! ,59(8'5!

%(*'&1*()!$:!(,82!,#'21-A!B2&5!9-18(55!,..1S5!'2(!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!'2-((!%,^1-!

)&%(*5&1*5! &*!S2&82!'2(! &55#(5! 01-!81*5&)(-&*7!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55! &5!

$,5()A!!

B2(5(!,-(W!

• +-1,8'&E(!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!.(,-*&*7q!

• "',K(21.)(-!(*7,7(%(*'q!

• "'-,'(7:!)(9.1:%(*'A!

P5&*7! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(! &)(*'&0&()! $1'2! &*! .&'(-,'#-(! ,*)! &*! &*)#5'-:! '2-1#72! '2(!

,)E&51-:! $1,-)! )&58#55&1*5! I9-(5(*'()! &*! NADJ! '2(! ,#'21-! #5(5! '2(5(! '2-((!

)&%(*5&1*5!'1!01-%!'2(!01#*),'&1*!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55A!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!1*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&5!S&)(;!,*)!81E(-5!)&00(-(*'!9(-59(8'&E(5;!

(A7A! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*'! ! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJ;! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(! IC,-'.('';! =>>RJ;!

9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! B2(-(! ,-(! ,'! .(,5'! (&72'! )&00(-(*'!

9-18(55(5! )(58-&$()! &*! 5(8'&1*! =A?@! '2,'! ,&%! '1! ,))-(55! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'!

,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*A! B2(! ,59(8'5! '2,'! 521#.)! $(! 81*5&)(-()! &*! (,82! 5'(9! ,.51! E,-:!

,%1*7!,#'21-5A!

B2(! (&72'! )1%&*,*'! %1)(.5! 01-! 01..1S&*7! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! S(-(!

&*E(5'&7,'()!,*)!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!82,9'(-!'2(:!,-(W!

• <8'&E(!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!$:!b(:'1*!I?FFOJq!

• B2(!Q-,*0&(.)!9-18(55!%1)(.!10!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!$:!_,-)!('!,.A!I?FFRJq!

• B2(!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!<99-1,82!$:!B21-9!I?FFDJq!

• B2(!<C3!,99-1,82!$:!b&*!,*)!+(-E,*!I=>>@Jq!

• B1S,-)5! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(! &*! C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*'! $:! <52#-5'! ,*)! 612(-':!

I=>>@Jq!

Page 88: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MO!

• C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*! &*! V*'(7-,'()! "(-E&8(! V%9-1E(%(*'! Z! V"V+! $:! ]["!

I=>>OJq!

• C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*! T,*,7(%(*'! &*! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.! +-17-,%%(5! $:!

GUQ!I=>>MJ!,*)!C-,).(:!I=>>RJq!

• C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!&*!'2(![,*)$11K!10!+-17-,%%(!T,*,7(%(*'!$:!3(&55!

('!,.A!I=>>RJA!

B2(! %,'-&`! &*! '2(! *(`'! 9,7(! &5! ,! 5:*'2(5&5! 10! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 81*5&)(-,'&1*5!

&)(*'&0&()!&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!&*8.#)&*7!'2(!(&72'!)1%&*,*'!%1)(.5A!B2(!%,'-&`!.&5'5!

'2(!K(:!(.(%(*'5!a81*5&)(-,'&1*5!'2,'!,))-(55!'2(!'2-((!%,^1-!)&%(*5&1*!(,-.&(-!

&)(*'&0&()!,*)!%,95!'2(%!,8-155!,5!'2(:!,-(!$(&*7!',8K.()!$:!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(A!B2(!

%,'-&`!&5!81%9&.()!&*!5#82!,!S,:!'1!7&E(!'2(!,#'21-!,*)!'2(!-(,)(-!,!8.(,-!E&5#,.!

#*)(-5',*)&*7!1*!S2(-(! '1! 018#5! '2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)! '2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10! '2(!

9-18(55A!

! !

Page 89: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MR!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

&/H0'!Sc!4;@[/5/1)<'!@/15)\!;7!H'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21![5/91)9'(!

!"#$%&'()*%"#$+,"

(+-'

#',%*$+.)#

)/'.

'#*+)#

&+(')0%$)*%"#

1(2)3+4556

7'8*"#+4559

:)(&+'*+)0;+455<

!!1=+4555

=$>2($*+)#&+?">'(*8+@AAB

:)(&+'*+)0;+@AAC

D)#*E)#)+)#&+1>'.%$*"F0'"2$+@AAC

7%#+)#&+G'(H)#+@AAB

I)(-'8+'*+)0;+4555

J()&0'8+@AA<

J)(*0'**+@AA<

:)(&+)#&+?)#%'0+@AA<

K08##'+@AA6

LK!+@AAC+M+@AA6

I"3+@AAN

:)(&+)#&+K(%,,%*>$+455<+

1>"(O+455N

P)Q)(+)#&+:%&'$*)&>+@AA9

R'.'#8%+)#&+P>'(S""&TP.%*>+455N

G)8#'+@AA6

R'%$$+'*+)0;+@AA<

J'##%#/*"#+)#&+J)FF)(%#%+@AAC

UVP+WPWG+@AA9

G(")

F*%H'+.)#

)/'.

'#*+)#

&+0')(#%#/

!"#$%&'#()*&+

,-.&

%#'/0--'#&

)%1+'2,

%',33

,%($"0(0&

#'(,'4)504

0#&'6&"

&20(#

XX

X7%)1*'.0#6&"

&20(#'0"',%.&%'(,

'%&.$

1&'(+

&0%'043)1(

XX

X7%)1*')".'3%,)1(08&-9'4)"):&'(+&'&4

&%:&"1&',2'$"3

-)""

&.'6&"

&20(#

XX

XX

;%,)1(08&-9'4)"):&'1+)":&

XX

XX

X<,

"(0"$,

$#'&8)-$)(0,"'02'3%,1&##'0#')

.&=$

)(&'(,'.&-08&%'6&"

&20(#

XX

>.&"

(029',3

3,%($"

0(0&#'(,

'%&)-0#&

'2$%(+&

%'6&"

&20(#

XX

XX

X?&

80&/

')".

'&8)-$)(&'%&#$-(#')".

'2&&.

@6)1*'0"(,'(+

&'3%,1&##

XX

XX

X?&

80&/

')".

'&8)-$)(&'%&#$-(#')".

'2&&.

@2,%/

)%.'0"(,'"&5('3

%,A&1(#

XX

>.&"

(029'+,

/'0"(&%")-')".

'&5(&%")-'1+)":&#'4

)9')22&

1('(+

&'3%,1&##

XX

X<,

"(0"$,

$#-9'%&

80&/

'(+&'-0#(',

2'&53&1(&.'6&

"&20(#'(,'1+&1*'#(%)(&:01'20(

XX

P*)Q'>

"0&'

(+'#

/)/'.'#

*<-&)%-9

'.&20"&'6&

"&20(#')

('(+&

',$(#&(

XX

XX

XX

!"#$%&'#()*&+

,-.&

%#')%&'1,4

40(&

.'0"'%&

)-0#0":'6&"

&20(#

XX

XX

XB-0:"'3%,:%)44&'6&

"&20(#'/

0(+'#()*&+

,-.&

%'#(%)(&:01',6A&1(08

&#X

XX

XX

!"#$%&'(+

)('#()*+,

-.&%#')

%&')/)%&',2')".

'):%&&'(,

'2)1&'.0#6

&"&20(#

XX

XX

X!"

:):&'#()*&+

,-.&

%#'(+

%,$:+,

$('(+

&'&"

(0%&'3%,1&##

XX

XX

P*()*'/8+&'O

0"8.

'#*

!"#$%&',$(1,4&#')%&'%&

-)(&.'(,'#(%)(&:01',6

A&1(08&#

XX

XX

C%08&'(+&'3%,1&##'6

)#&.

',"'4&)#$%&4&"

(#X

XX

XX

7%)1*')".'%&3,

%('%&

)-0#)

(0,"',2'6&"

&20(#')".

',(+&%')1+0&8&4&"

(#X

XD#&'&53&1(&.'6&

"&20(#')

#')'%,

).4)3'2,

%'1+)":&

XX

X>.&"

(029'(+&'")($%&',2'6

&"&20(#'(+

%,$:+'1-)##0201)(0,"

XX

>"1-$.

&')##&##4&"

(',2'0"()":06-&'6&

"&20(#',

"'0"8&#(4&"

('&8)-$)(0,"

X7%)"#-)

(&',6A&1(08

&#'0"(,'4

&)#$%)6-&'6&

"&20(#'(+)('1)"'6&'(%)1*&.

XX

XX

XE&)#$%&'(+

0":#'(+

)('%&

)--9'1,$

"(X

X!"

#$%&'&53&1(&.'6&

"&20(#',

2'0"8&#(4

&"(')

%&')1+0&8&.

XX

XX

X7+&'3)(+'2%,4

'0"8&#(4&"

('(,'6&

"&20('.&-08&%9'4$#('6

&'&22&1(08&-9'3-)""&

.X

XX

XX

X

Page 90: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MM!

*$,S I2/0B()(! ;7! 1'9#2)]8'(! 1#/1! '@H5/9'! H'2'7)1(! 5'/0)(/1);2! /23!

@/2/A'@'21!

/#-'2(-!'1!'2(!(&72'!%,&*!)1%&*,*'!%1)(.5!'2(-(!,-(!1'2(-!,99-1,82(5!'2,'!S(-(!

8215(*!,*)!,*,.:5()!$:!'2(!,#'21-! 01..1S&*7!)&58#55&1*5!S&'2! &*)#5'-:!(`9(-'5!

,*)!,8,)(%&85!S&'2&*!'2(![,QV3VQ!(*E&-1*%(*'A!B2(5(!,99-1,82(5!,-(!-(7,-)()!

$:!'2(!&*)#5'-:!,5!919#.,-!(`&5'&*7!9-,8'&8(5!'2,'!,-(!$,5()!&*!5&%&.,-!9-&*8&9.(5!

'1!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!!

B2(5(!,99-1,82(5!,-(W!

I,J![152&*7!d,*-&!Z![d!$:!V5S&K,S,!&*!?FO>5q!

I$J!b17&8,.!/-,%(S1-K!<99-1,82!Z!b/<!$:!315(*$(-7!&*!?FRFq!

I8J!6(5&7*!f#,.&':!V*)&8,'1-!Z!6fV;!IU,**!('!,.A;!=>>@Jq!

I)J!f#,.&':!/#*8'&1*!6(9.1:%(*'!Z!f/6!$:!<K,1!&*!?FRRq!

I(J!+-1^(8'5!V*!Q1*'-1..()!H*E&-1*%(*'5!Z!+3V]QH=;!IQQB<;!?FDFJA!

B2(! &*'(*'!10! &*01-%&*7!'2(!9-18(55!#*)(-!)(E(.19%(*'!0-1%!1'2(-!,99-1,82(5!

S,5!'1!-(,82!,!$(''(-!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!21S!'2(!9-18(55!S&..!)&00(-!0-1%!'2(!1'2(-!

,99-1,82(5!,*)!21S!&'!81#.)!$(!&%9-1E()!$,5()!1*!(`&5'&*7!711)!9-,8'&8(5A!

V'!&5!&%91-',*'!'1!(%92,5&5(;!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&5!018#5()!9-&%,-&.:!1*!'2(!

$(*(0&'5;! 1-! 1#'81%(5! 9(-8(&E()! ,5! 915&'&E(! ,*)! ,)E,*',7(1#5! $:! )&00(-(*'!

7-1#95! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5A! B2(! (%92,5&5! &5! 1*! '2(! ,)E,*',7(5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5! 10! ,!

9-1^(8'! -,'2(-! '2,*! 5&%9.:!)(.&E(-&*7! ,! 9-1)#8'!S&'2&*! 59(8&0&8,'&1*5;! '&%(! ,*)!

S&'2&*! $#)7('A! B2&5! $-1,)(-! 018#5! &5! '2(! %,^1-! )&00(-(*8(! 0-1%! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! '1! 1'2(-! ,99-1,82(5A! B2(5(! ,99-1,82(5! ,-(! 0#-'2(-! )(58-&$()! &*!

,99(*)&`!Vq!S2&.(!,!5#%%,-:!10!'2(!81%9,-&51*!&5!521S*!&*!B,$.(!FA!

!

!

Page 91: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MD!

&/H0'!Uc!I[[5;/9#'(!()@)0/5!1;!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!/23!1#')5!@/)2![5)29)[0'(!

! =)@)0/5!/[[5;/9#'(!1;!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!

"5)29)[0'(!1;!H'!9;2()3'5'3! .G!

YXI!

%b6!

bX%!

":6K4?!*!

H*7,7(!5',K(21.)(-5! ! a! a! ! !

Q-(,'(!,!52,-()!E&5&1*!10!-(5#.'5! a! a! a! a! !

<7-((!1*!$1'2!915&'&E(!,*)!*(7,'&E(!&%9,8'5! a! ! ! ! !

6(9.1:!5'-,'(7&8!1$^(8'&E(5!&*'1!19(-,'&1*5! a! a! ! a! a!

T1*&'1-!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!5'-,'(7&8!1$^(8'&E(5! a! a! a! a! a!

T1*&'1-!'2(!(%(-7(*8(!10!#*(`9(8'()!&%9,8'5! a! ! ! ! a!

V%9-1E(!'2(!9-18(55!81*'&*#1#5.:!$,5()!1*!,55(55%(*'!! a! a! ! ! a!

6:*,%&8,..:!,),9'!'2(!9-18(55!$,5()!1*!,55(55%(*'! a! ! a! ! a!

*$,U 4;2()3'5/1);2(!7;5!3'<'0;[)2A!1#'!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5;9'((!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! 0&-5'! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! S1-K5219! I0#..:! )(58-&$()! &*! 5(8'&1*! NANJ!

S2(-(! '2(! 0&*)&*75! 10! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! S(-(! 9-(5(*'()! ,*)! )&58#55()! ,!

*#%$(-!10! &55#(5!S(-(!-,&5()A!B2(!,#'21-!)(58-&$(5!2(-(! '2(! &55#(5! -,&5()!,*)!

21S!'2(:!&*0.#(*8()!'2(!&*&'&,.!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!9-18(55A!!

B2(! 0&-5'! &55#(! 81*5&)(-()! S,5! '2(! &%91-',*8(! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2,'! 1E(-! '2(!

81#-5(!10!,!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!.&0(8:8.(;!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!,*)!71E(-*%(*'!91.&8:!

)-&E(-5!(59(8&,..:!S&'2&*!,!2(,.'28,-(!5(''&*7!,-(!2&72.:!.&K(.:!'1!82,*7(!,*)!'2&5!

S&..!&%9,8'!#91*!,7-(()!$(*(0&'5A!!B2(!,.&7*%(*'!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!

S&'2!,!-1$#5'!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!,99-1,82!,$.(!'1!,881%%1),'(!,*)!-(,8'! '1!

'2(5(!82,*7(5!S,5!'2(-(01-(!81*5&)(-()!(55(*'&,.A!B2(!&%9,8'!10!82,*7(!521#.)!

$(! %1*&'1-()! '2-1#721#'! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! )(E(.19%(*';! ,*)!

%(82,*&5%5! 521#.)! $(! &*! 9.,8(! -(,):! '1! ,)E(-5(! ,*:! *(7,'&E(! &%9,8'!

&%9.&8,'&1*5A!

Page 92: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! MF!

V'!S,5!,.51!2&72.&72'()! '2,'! '2(!K(:! 01-!5#88(550#.! &%9.(%(*','&1*!10!,!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!&5!&'5!&*'(7-,'&1*!S&'2&*!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!5'-,'(7:;!$#5&*(55!

9.,**&*7!,*)!8#.'#-(;!',K&*7!,.51!&*'1!,881#*'!(`'(-*,.!0,8'1-5A!!

B2(!0&*)&*75!0-1%!'2(5(!&*&'&,.!5'#)&(5!5#77(5'!'2,'!,!7(*(-&8!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!

9-18(55!521#.)!,&%!'1!$(W!

• <99-19-&,'(! 01-! '215(! S21! 19(-,'(! &'! ,*)! '215(! '2,'! #5(! '2(! &*01-%,'&1*!

9-1)#8()q!!

• C,.,*8()! &*! &'5! ,55(55%(*'! 10! ,..! -(.(E,*'! ,59(8'5;! &*8.#)&*7! '215(! '2,'! ,-(!

2,-)!'1!4#,*'&0:q!

• Q15'!(00(8'&E(!$:!9-1)#8&*7!9(-01-%,*8(!&*01-%,'&1*!'2,'!-(,.&5(5!$(*(0&'5!&*!

9-191-'&1*!'1!'2(!&*E(5'%(*'!-(4#&-()!'1!81..(8'!&'q!

• "&%9.(!'1!&%9.(%(*'A!

B2(-(! &5! ,! 81%%1*! #*)(-5',*)&*7! '2,'! S2(*! 9(19.(! 9.,*! '1! )1! '2&*75! '2(:!

,.-(,):!K*1S!S2(-(! '2(:!S,*'! '1!7('!$(01-(! '2(:!5',-'! '2,'! ^1#-*(:A!B2&5!)1(5!

*1'! ,.S,:5! 5((%! '1! $(! '2(! 8,5(!S&'2&*! 9-1^(8'5! 1-! 9-17-,%%(5A! G-7,*&5,'&1*5!

#5#,..:! '-:! '1! ^#5'&0:! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'! 10! ,! 9-1915()! 9-1^(8'! S&'21#'! '2&*K&*7!

'2-1#72!S2,'!&5!-(,..:!-(4#&-()!'1!)(.&E(-!'2(!)(5&-()!$(*(0&'5A!/1-!(`,%9.(!'2(!

)(.&E(-:!10!,!*(S!2(,.'28,-(!0,8&.&':!81#.)!$(!'2(!)-&E(-!'1!$-&*7!82,*7(!S&'2&*!,!

81%%#*&':;!21S(E(-!9-&1-!'1!)(8&)&*7!&0!,!*(S!2(,.'28,-(!0,8&.&':!&5!-(4#&-();!'2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! *(()! '1! 81*5&)(-! S2,'! $(*(0&'5! S1#.)! .&K(! '1! )(.&E(-! '1! '2(!

81%%#*&':!,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'.:!)(8&)(! &0! ,*)!S2,'!K&*)!10! ,! 0,8&.&':! &5!*(()()! '1!

)(.&E(-!'2(5(!$(*(0&'5A!/&7#-(!?F!&..#5'-,'(5!'2(!9-&%,-:!'21#72'5!10!'2(!,#'21-!1*!

21S! $(*(0&'5! 521#.)! $(! #5()! '1! (*,$.(! 0.1S! )1S*! 10! &*01-%,'&1*! 0-1%! 91.&8:!

.(E(.! '2-1#72! '1! 8-(,'&*7! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! 91-'01.&1! ,*)! (E(*'#,..:! )(.&E(-&*7!

9-1^(8'5!,*)!582(%(5!'2,'!S&..!(*2,*8(!'2(!9-1$,$&.&':!10!'2(%!$(&*7!5#88(550#.!

,*)!,)2(-(! '1! '2(!91.&8:!,5! &'!S,5!5('!1#'! '1!$(A! !B2(!9-1915()!9-18(55!521#.)!

,.51!8,9'#-(!'2(!K*1S.()7(!7(*(-,'()!S2&.(!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!0.1S!)1S*!&5!

9-17-(55&*7! ,*)! 0(()$,8K! '2(! .(551*5! .(,-*'! &*! '(-%5! 10! 9.,**()! ,*)!

#*,*'&8&9,'()! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! )&5$(*(0&'5! ,5! '2(:! (%(-7(! 0-1%! '2(! 9-1^(8'5A!

<.'21#72! '2(! 0.1S!)1S*!,*)! 0(()$,8K!S&..! .119! 0-1%!91.&8:! '1!9-1^(8'!)(.&E(-:!

Page 93: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! D>!

'2(!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!&'5(.0!S&..!81*8(*'-,'(!1*!'2(!9-1^(8'L5!

81*8(9'&1*;!9.,**&*7;!)(.&E(-:!,*)!19(-,'&1*A!

!

X)A85'!,Uc!>'2'7)1(!35)<'2!)27;5@/1);2!70;R!3;R2!/23!0'((;2(!0'/521!0;;[!

*$*+ >'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2!^>':'/0_!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!;<'5<)'R!

/1..1S&*7! '2(5(! 81*5&)(-,'&1*5! ,*)! &*0.#(*8()! $:! B21-9! I?FFDJ! c/1#-! <-(5L!

,99-1,82! &*! C3<! 9-(5(*'()! &*! 5(8'&1*! =A?@A@;! '2(! ,#'21-! $,5()! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.!

,&%&*7! '1! ,*5S(-! 01#-! 5&%9.(! 4#(5'&1*5! '2,'! ,*:$1):! 1-! ,*:! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! &5!

9.,**&*7! '1! &*E(5'!521#.)!,5KA!B2(5(!S(-(! 0#..:!)&58#55()!,*)!(*)1-5()!)#-&*7!

0&-5'!S1-K5219!10!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9A!B2(!4#(5'&1*5!,-(W!

• 61!S(!K*1S!S2,'!S(!*(()t!

• <-(!S(!5#-(!S(!,-(!71&*7!'1!7('!S2,'!S(LE(!,5K()!01-t!

• 6&)!S(!7('!S2,'!S(!2,E(!,5K()!01-t!

• _,5!&'!,..!S1-'2!&'t!

!"#$%&'

()*+,-.+)-'

()/01,-02%-20+'3"0-/"#$"'

4+%-"0,'5'6+1#-78'6"2,$)98':;2%1-$")'

!"#$%&'()*+,)-&.%/%()

<+10)$)9'/++;=1%>'?+)+@$-,'@#"A';"A)'

B%-21#'3#1))+;'1);'2)1)-$%$31-+;'$.31%-,'

!#1))+;'?+)+@$-,'

Page 94: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! D?!

C,5()!1*!'2(5(!01#-!4#(5'&1*5!,*)!&*!,!5&%9.(!,''(%9'!'1!0&*)!,*5S(-5!'1!'2(5(;!

'2(!C(3(,.!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!9-(5(*'5!01#-!*1*\5(4#(*'&,.!92,5(5;!&..#5'-,'()!&*!

/&7#-(!=>A!B2(!01#-!%,&*!92,5(5!10!'2(!C(3(,.!S(-(!81*8(9'#,.&5()!'2-1#72!,*!

(`'(*5&E(! .&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,5!9-(5(*'()! &*! '2&5! '2(5&5;! &*01-%()!$:!)&58#55&1*5!

,*)!%(('&*75! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! S&'2! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10!

)&E(-5(! (`9(-&(*8(! &*)&E&)#,.5! 0-1%! '2(! &*)#5'-:! ,*)! ,8,)(%&,! I'2(! ,)E&51-:!

7-1#9!&5!0#..:!)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!NANJA!

!

X)A85'!*+c!>':'/0!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!

*$*+$, "#/('!6c!>'2'7)1(!@/2/A'@'21!(15/1'AB!

B2&5! 92,5(! &5! 81*8(-*()! S&'2! &)(*'&0:&*7! ,*)! )18#%(*'&*7! )(5&-()! 5'-,'(7&8!

$(*(0&'5! ,*)! 5#$! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! )(E(.19&*7! ,! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 5'-,'(7:! '1!

52,-(!,*)!81%%#*&8,'(!'2(5(!'1!-(.(E,*'!5',K(21.)(-5A!

C(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,88,-&*&!I=>>NJ!5#77(5'!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!521#.)!(%(-7(!

0-1%! ,! 81%$&*()! ,99-1,82! 10! &*'(-E&(S5! ,*)! S1-K52195! &*E1.E&*7! K(:!

5',K(21.)(-5A!3(%(*:&!,*)!"%&'2!I?FFDJ!,-7#(!'2,'!,!K(:!,59(8'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*a(.&8&','&1*! 9-18(55! &5! '2,'! 5',K(21.)(-5! $(''(-! #*)(-5',*)! '2(!

&*E(5'%(*';! S2,'! &5! ,001-),$.(! ,*)! 9155&$.(A! B2(! &*E1.E(%(*'! 10! K(:!

5',K(21.)(-5! &)(*'&0:&*7! ,*)! ,7-((&*7! 1*! )(5&-()! $(*(0&'5! &5! (55(*'&,.! ,5! &'!

(*2,*8(5!,S,-(*(55!,*)!%,`&%&5(5!'2(!.&K(.&211)!10!81%%&'%(*'!'1!)(.&E(-!,*)!

-(,.&5(! '215(! $(*(0&'5! ,8-155! ,! -,*7(! 10! .(E(.5! &*! '2(! $#5&*(55! ,*)! &*! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! Id,7&17.1#! ('! ,.A;! =>>>q! U.:**(;! =>>MJA! "',K(21.)(-5! S&..! *(()! '1!

#*)(-5',*)! 21S! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! '1! $(! &)(*'&0&();! %1)(..()! ,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'.:!

)(.&E(-()!I3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!](E(-'2(.(55;! &'!S1#.)!$(!-&5K:!'1!,55#%(!'2,'!,..!

5',K(21.)(-5! S&..! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! &%9.&8,'&1*5! 10! $(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)!

9.,**&*7;!&*E1.E&*7!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!,.1*7!'2(!9-18(55!%,:!2(.9!'1!015'(-!,!'(,%!

!"#"$%&'()*+,+)&",%'+&%-#((

!"#"$%&'(.+//%#0((

!"#"$%&'(,"+1%'+&%-#(/1+#((

!"#"$%&'(.+#+0"."#&('&,+&"02(( 34+15+&%-#(6(

7"4%"8(

Page 95: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! D=!

(*E&-1*%(*'! ,*)! (*81#-,7(! ,99-19-&,'(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*! ,*)! (*,$.(! $(''(-!

)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7A!

*$*+$* "#/('!66c!>'2'7)1(!9#/5/91'5)(/1);2!/23!H'2'7)1(!@/[[)2A!

+-10&.(! ,*)!%,99&*7! ,-(! 'S1!%,^1-! (*,$.&*7! '11.5A! B2(5(! ,-(!91S(-0#.! ,5! '2(:!

21.)!81-(! &*01-%,'&1*!10!(,82! &*)&E&)#,.!$(*(0&';!,*)!%&72'!5#991-'! &..#5'-,'&1*!

10! )(9(*)(*8&(5a&*'(--(.,'&1*52&95! ,*)! 1E(-.,95! $('S((*! I)&5\J! $(*(0&'5A!

V*E(5'&*7! '&%(! ,'! &*&'&,.! 5',7(5! '1! (5',$.&52! -1$#5'! ,*)! -(.&,$.(! $(*(0&'! 9-10&.(5!

,*)!%,95!(*,$.(5!%,*,7(%(*'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!.&0(8:8.(A!

Y&#&,$)!2'+,$/&! \!T,*:!,#'21-5!IC-,).(:;!=>>Rq!3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>Rq!C,-'.('';!=>>Rq!

C(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,88,-&*&;!=>>Nq!QQB<;!?FFF;!/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFq!B21-9;!?FFDq!

_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;! =>>RJ! -(81%%(*)!)-,S&*7!#9! 01-%,.&5()!$(*(0&'! 9-10&.(5! 51!

'2,'!'2(:!8,*!$(!%,*,7()!S&'2!,!5&%&.,-!-&71#-!,5!815'5!10!9-1^(8'5A!](E(-'2(.(55;!

,.1*7!S&'2!1'2(-!,59(8'5!9-10&.(;!)(9(*)(*8&(5!,-(!*1'!#*)(-5'11)!,5!5','&8q! 01-!

(`,%9.(;! ,5! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! 9-17-(55(5;! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! '2(! $(*(0&'! 9-10&.(!

&*01-%,'&1*!S&..!5#00(-!-(E&5&1*5!IQQB<;!=>>>JA!

U.22$#A! \! B2(! $(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:! *('S1-K! I1-! $(*(0&'5! %,99&*7J! S,5! 0&-5'!

&*'-1)#8()!$:!_,-)!,*)!H.E&*! I?FFFJ!,*)!,&%5! '1! &..#5'-,'(!91'(*'&,.! c%,*:! '1!

%,*:L! -(.,'&1*52&95;! ,5! (A7A! $('S((*! (*,$.&*7! 82,*7(5;! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(5;!

$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5! ,*)! &*E(5'%(*'5L! 1$^(8'&E(5A!<!$(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:!*('S1-K;!

',-7('5!'1!%,9!,..!'2(!8,#5(!,*)!(00(8'!-(.,'&1*52&95;!,*)!'1!&*8.#)(!5',K(21.)(-5;!

82,*7(5!,*)!8-&'(-&,!01-!5#88(55!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!

H.&8&','&1*! 10! ()'.)&A$E;! (3C! C&#&,$)(! ,*)! &#0! C&#&,$)(;! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! $(*(0&'5!

9-10&.(5! ,*)! )(5&7*! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! %,9! 01-%! '2(! $,5&5! 10! *(8(55,-:! 1*\71&*7!

#9),'(5!'1!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*A!

Page 96: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! D@!

*$*+$- "#/('!666c!>'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![0/2!

/18#5!&5!1*!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!(`(8#'&1*!10!,!$(*(0&'!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!&*01-%()!

$:! '2(!9-(E&1#5!92,5(5! 81*'(*'a),',;! 81*5&5'&*7!10!%(,5#-&*7!,*)! '-,8K&*7! '2(!

$(*(0&'5!9-(E&1#5.:!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!&*81-91-,'&*7!(%(-7&*7!$(*(0&'5A!

GUQ! I=>>M,J! #*)(-.&*(5! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! )1&*7! ,! %,*,7(%(*'! 9.,*! '2,'!

)(58-&$(5!21S!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!S&52(5!'1!%,*,7(!,*)!,82&(E(!$(*(0&'5;!0-1%!,*:!

&*E(5'%(*'! &*! $#5&*(55! 82,*7(A! B2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*! )(E(.19()! )#-&*7!

92,5(!@!I'2,'!&*8.#)(5!K(:!,55#%9'&1*5;!-&5K!,55(55%(*'!,*)!5(*5&'&E&':!,*,.:5&5!

-(.,'()!'1!'215(!1#'81%(5!'2,'!81*'-&$#'(!%15'!'1!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5J!521#.)!$(!

5((*!,5!,!%,^1-!'11.!81*'-&$#'&*7!'1!'2(!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!9-18(55!IGUQ;!=>>M$JA!

_&'21#'! '2&5!9.,*! &'! &5!)&00&8#.'! '1!9-()&8'!21S!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!%&72'!(00(8'&E(.:!

-(,.&5(!$(*(0&'5!I_,-)!('!,.A;!?FFRJA!

*$*+$P "#/('!6Zc!>'2'7)1(!'</08/1);2!/23!5'<)'R!!

B2&5!92,5(!&*8.#)(5!'2(!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!81*'-1..&*7!10!$(*(0&'5A!C(*(0&'5!-(E&(S!&5!

'2(!9-18(55!$:!S2&82! '2(! 5#88(55!10! '2(!9-1^(8'! &5! ,))-(55();!1991-'#*&'&(5! 01-!

'2(! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! 0#-'2(-! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&();! .(551*5! ,-(! .(,-*()! ,*)!

1991-'#*&'&(5! 01-! &%9-1E(%(*'! &*! 0#'#-(! 9-1^(8'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()! I<52#-5'! ,*)!

612(-':;!=>>@JA!!

T1*&'1-&*7!,*)!81*'-1..&*7!521#.)!$(!)(E(.19()!81*'&*#1#5.:;!*1'!1*.:!,.1*7!'2(!

1E(-,..! 9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(;! $#'! ,.51! 81E(-&*7! 19(-,'&1*5! %,*,7(%(*'! 5(-E&8(5A!

V*)(();! '2(!$(*(0&'5!5','()! &*!,!9-17-,%%(L5!$#5&*(55!8,5(!,-(! '2(!-(5#.'!10!,*!

10'(*\9-1'-,8'()! 9(-&1)! 10! $(*(0&'5! 9.,**&*7A! /#-'2(-%1-(;! $:! '2(! '&%(! '2(!

$#5&*(55!8,5(!2,5!$((*!5&7*()!100;!'2(!$(*(0&'5!,5!1-&7&*,..:!81*8(&E()!%,:!2,E(!

$((*!5&7*&0&8,*'.:!)&.#'()!IC,-'.('';!=>>RJA!

<!5#88(550#.!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!.&0(8:8.(!*(()5!'1!&*8.#)(!9(-&1)&8!-(E&(S5!'1!

-(81*0&-%! '2(! ,.&7*%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! S&'2! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! 5'-,'(7&8!

9-&1-&'&(5A!!B2(5(!-(E&(S5!521#.)!,.51!,55(55!S2('2(-!1-!*1'!'2(!,*'&8&9,'()!5#&'(!

10! $(*(0&'5! &5! 5#00&8&(*'! '1! ,881%9.&52! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5L! 5'-,'(7&8! 71,.5! $:! ,.51!

Page 97: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DN!

81*',8'&*7!$(*(0&'5!-(E&(S5!,'!9-1^(8'!5',7(!7,'(5!!IQ11K(\6,E&(5;!=>>=q!]17(5'(;!

=>>RJA!

B2&5!92,5(!81#.)!$(!&*&'&,'()!&*!9,-,..(.!S&'2!'2(!1'2(-!92,5(5q!5&*8(!)&5\$(*(0&'5!

I,*)!$(*(0&'5J!%&72'!(%(-7(!)#-&*7!'2(!&%9.(%(*','&1*!5',7(!I(A7A!81*5'-#8'&1*JA!

<! ':9&8,.! )&5$(*(0&'! )#-&*7! -(0#-$&52%(*'! S1-K! 1-! (`9,*5&1*! 10! (`&5'&*7!

2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5!&5!'2(!'(%91-,-:!82,*7(5!1-!)&5-#9'&1*!'1!2(,.'28,-(!

5(-E&8(5!)#(!'1!81*5'-#8'&1*!1*5&'(!S1-K5A!

*$*+$N >':'/0![5;[;('3!H'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!(1589185'!

V*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!9-(5(*'()!(,-.&(-!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-!'2(-(!S,5!,!)(58-&9'&1*!

1*!21S!$(*(0&'5!8,*!$(!8.,55&0&()!,*)!8,'(71-&5()A!B2(!,#'21-!01..1S&*7!'2(!*(()!

01-!,!5&%9.&0&()!,99-1,82!'1!$(*(0&'5!8.,55&0&8,'&1*!&*'-1)#8(5!2(-(!'2(!'2-((\'&(-!

8.,55&0&8,'&1*! 5'-#8'#-(! '2,'! S,5! 0#-'2(-! '(5'()! ,*)! ,8K*1S.()7()! )#-&*7! '2(!

#*)(-',K&*7!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5A!B2(!'2&*K&*7!10!'2&5!,99-1,82!&5!'1!$-(,K!)1S*!

$,--&(-5! '2,'! %,:! $(! ,-&5&*7! S2(*! 9(19.(! ,'',82! .,$(.5! 5#82! ,5;! 0&*,*8&,.;!

19(-,'&1*,.;! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.;! '1! )&00(-(*'! $(*(0&'5A! B2(! ,&%! &5! '1! ,E1&)! 5&.15! ,*)!

018#5! 9(19.(L5! %&*)5! ,*)! ,''&'#)(5! '1S,-)5! )(.&E(-&*7! '2(5(! $(*(0&'5!

&*)(9(*)(*'!'1!S2(-(!'2(:!$(.1*7!&*!'2(!5',K(21.)(-!59(8'-#%A!

B2(! C(3(,.! 81*8(9'#,.&5(5! ,*)! 1-7,*&5(5! $(*(0&'5! &*! '2-((! %,&*! 8,'(71-&(5;!

-(9-(5(*'()!1*!/&7#-(!=?A!

!

X)A85'!*,c!>':'/0!9;29'[18/0!H'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!

!"#$%&"&'()*$

+,-$%&"&'()*$

+)./)&0(1$%&"&'()*$

!"#$#%&'$()#&(*+,-$*.$'))(/'01,2$*3,4$*4*)'5,4"#)',6,&*,4"#)',67,

!0#))(8(%#&(*+,

Page 98: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DO!

-)'.)&A$E!C&#&,$)(!,-(!-(.,'()!S&'2!'2(!9#-915(!10!82,-,8'(-&5&*7!'2(!9-17-,%%(;!

9-1E&)&*7!,*!1E(-,..!)&-(8'&1*!10!5#88(55!'2-1#721#'!'2(!.&0(!8:8.(q!!

-3C!C&#&,$)(! 82,-,8'(-&5(!59(8&0&8! ',-7('5! .&*K()!'1!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!,*)!521#.)!

)-&E(! )(5&7*! ,*)! 9-(.&%&*,-:! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! ,.'(-*,'&E(5! 10! &*E(5'%(*'! I(A7A!

5(.(8'&1*!10!$#&.)&*7!19'&1*5Jq!!

S#0! C&#&,$)(! ,-(! %(,5#-(5! '2,'! 82,-,8'(-&5(! &*! )(',&.! I(A7A! 2,-);! 510';! ',*7&$.(;!

&*',*7&$.(;!4#,*'&','&E(;!4#,.&','&E(J!'2(!',-7('5!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5A!

/&7#-(!==!&..#5'-,'(5!21S!'2(!&*'(--(.,'&1*!10!'2(!c)6'&&O)$&'!.22'+.E6>!S&..!)-&E(!

'2(! 9-1^(8'! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! &*'-1)#8(5! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 81*'-1..&*7! 5'-#8'#-(! &*!

'(-%5!10!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&()A!

!

X)A85'!**c!>':'/0![5;9'((!L!H'2'7)1(!9;215;00)2A!(1589185'!

B2(! C(3(,.! 81*'-1..&*7! 5'-#8'#-(! &5! )(5&7*()! '1! 81E(-! '2(! S21.(! &*E(5'%(*'!

.&0(8:8.(!&*8.#)&*7!'2(!9-1^(8'!(*E&-1*%(*'!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!1*(;!5#991-'&*7W!

I?J 6&00(-(*'! %(,5#-(%(*'! .(E(.5! )(9(*)&*7! 1*! '2(! 82,-,8'(-&5,'&1*! 10!

$(*(0&'5q!

I=J +-1E&)&*7!81*5&5'(*'!)(E&,'&1*!81*'-1.!$('S((*! c,8'#,.! I,5\&5JL;! ! c9.,**()!

I'1\$(JL! ,*)! c,8'#,.! I(%(-7(*'J′9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(! ,*)! )(8&5&1*! %,K&*7!

91&*'5A!

!"#$!%&'()*+#+,'-(!!"#$%&'#%!()$(!*)$'$*(#'+%#!+,!-#($+.!/)$'-0!%12(0!($,3+4.#0!+,($,3+4.#0!5&$,(+($(+6#0!5&$.+($(+6#7!()#!($'3#(+,3!$,-!$*)+#6+,3!12!%&4!4#,#8+(%!21'!()#!%#.#*(#-!19(+1,:!

!./0#1+(2!;)$'$*(#'+%#!()#!#<#'3+,3!%1.&(+1,%!()$(!,##-!(1!4#!-#6#.19#-!/+,*.&-+,3!$..!,#=!$*(+1,%0!+,+(+$(+6#%0!9'13'$<<#%0!9'1>#*(%0!=1'?!9$*?$3#%0!$*(+6+(+#%0!($%?%0!@7!'#5&+'#-!(1!-#.+6#'!()#!%#.#*(#-!19(+1,:!

!3-40-+1'5!*+#+,'-!";)$'$*(#'+%#!()#!9&'91%#!12!()#!9'13'$<<#!1'!9'1>#*(!$,-!9'16+-#!$,!16#'$..!-+'#*(+1,!12!%&**#%%!()'1&3)1&(!()#!.+2#!*A*.#:!

!"#067+4(2!;)$'$*(#'+%#!#B+%(+,3!/1'!$,(+*+9$(#-7!*$9$4+.+(+#%C'#%1&'*#%!&%#-C#B9.1+(#-!(1!%&991'(!-#.+6#'A!12!()#!%#.#*(#-!19(+1,!/14>#*(+6#%!1'!($'3#(%7:!

!386!*+#+,'-("#$%"9'1/!:+;+7!*+#+,'-(&!!;)$'$*(#'+%#!%9#*+8+*!($'3#(%!.+,?#-!(1!D('$(#3+*!E#,#8+(%0!()$(!-'+6#!-#%+3,!$,-!9'#.+<+,$'A!#6$.&$(#!19(+1,%:!

'()**+,"#-$./+&"

)0-1)("#)2.32&"

)0-1)("#+4+%5+,&"

'#,78+#5+!

'#,78+#5+!

!<8-5=>+(!%=6?+5-';+(@-041+-()2!F&(*1<#%!$'#!$*(&$.!/'#$.7!6$.&#%!'#.$(#-!=+()!4#,#8+(%!-#8+,#-!21'!()#!%#.#*(#-!19(+1,0!41()!$(!$!)+3)#'!/D&4!E#,#8+(%7!.#6#.!1'!-#($+.#-!/G,-!/H+%7E#,#8+(%7!.#6#.:!F&(*1<#%!*)$'$*(#'+%#!()#!I-#%+'#-J%($(#K!=)+*)!+%!+,!9.$*#!/)$'-0!%12(0!($,3+4.#0!+,($,3+4.#0!5&$,(+($(+6#0!5&$.+($(+6#7:!

Page 99: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DR!

B2(! c,8'#,.! I,5\&5JL! ),',! &5! -(.,'()!S&'2!S2,'! &5!%(,5#-()! ,*)! &5! $(&*7! ,8'#,..:!

-(,.&5()!I1-!*1'J!1*!'2(!8#--(*'!5','(;!9-&1-!'1!'2(!&*E(5'%(*'A!!

B2(! c9.,*()!I'1\$(JL!(%(-7(*'!),',! &5!-(.,'()!S&'2!IS2,'! &5!$(&*7!9.,**()!,*)J!

S2,'!&5!$(&*7!(5'&%,'()!,*)!521#.)!$(!-(,.&5()!&*!'2(!0#'#-(A!!

c<8'#,.! I(%(-7(*'JL! ),',! -(.,'(5! S&'2! S2,'! &5! ,8'#,..:! $(&*7! %(,5#-()! ,*)! &5!

$(&*7!,8'#,..:!)(.&E(-()!1-!-(,.&5()!'1a$:!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5A!!

V*! 1-)(-! '1! ,55#-(! ,! 81*'-1..&*7! ,99-1,82! ,.1*7! '2(! 9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(! 5',7(5;!

81*5&5'(*8:!$('S((*!5',7(5!,*)!'2(!)&00(-(*'!$(*(0&'5!1-7,*&e,'&1*!.(E(.5!Ic,5\&5L;!

c'1\$(L!,*)! c(%(-7(*'LJ! &5!#*)(-5'11)!,5!8-&'&8,.A!B,$.(!?>!9-(5(*'5!,*!1E(-E&(S!

10!'2(!C(3(,.!81*'-1..&*7!5'-#8'#-(A!

&/H0'!,+c!4;29'[18/0!>':'/0![#/('(!/23!H'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!

>':'/0![#/('(! ! >'2'7)1(!;5A/2)(/1);2!!

!!6(58-&9'&1*5! +2,5(5! ! "'-,'(7&8! "#$! H*)!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! V! ! !! ! !

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.(! VV! ! !! !! !

[&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!%,9! VV! ! !! !! !

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! VVV! ! !! !! !!

C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S5!I82,*7(!,*)!

$(*(0&'5J!VX!

!!! !! !!

b(7(*)W!! W!T,&*!018#5A!!

*$*, 62<'(1@'21! /[[5/)(/0! /[[5;/9#'(! )2! #'/01#9/5'! )275/(1589185'!

3'<'0;[@'21$!

+-&1-! '1! 5(.(8'&*7! '2(!8,5(! 5'#)&(5!,! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &*'1! '2(!%,&*! 5',7(5!10!,!

2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!9-18(55!S,5!81*)#8'()!,5!S(..!,5!

&)(*'&0:&*7! '2(&-! 91'(*'&,.! ,.&7*%(*'! S&'2! ,! ':9&8,.! 9-1^(8'! 9-10&.(! %1)(.A! <5!

9-(E&1#5.:!)(58-&$()!7(*(-,..:!&*E(5'%(*'!9-17-,%%(5!)('(-%&*(!'2(&-!.(E(.!10!

Page 100: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DM!

5#88(55!%,&*.:!,7,&*5'!815';!4#,.&':!,*)!'&%(!10!)(.&E(-:;!,*)!*1'!$,5()!1*!,!0#..!

82,-,8'(-&5,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! 1-! &%9,8'5! )(.&E(-()A! G*(! 10! '2(! .(,)&*7! 7(*(-,.!

)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7! ,99-1,82(5! 01-! ,99-,&5&*7! %,^1-! 8,9&',.! &*E(5'%(*'!

9-17-,%%(5! #5()! ,8-155! )&00(-(*'! 5(8'1-5! ,*)! -(81%%(*)! $:! '2(! Pd!

71E(-*%(*'! &5! '2(! U,'(S,:Y! 3(E&(S! $:! '2(! G00&8(! 10! U1E(-*%(*'! Q1%%(-8(!

IGUQJA!B2(!U,'(S,:Y!3(E&(S!2&72.&72'5!'2(!*(()!01-!,!-1$#5'!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!

%('21)1.17:!S2(*!%,*,7&*7!9-17-,%%(5A!!

B2(!,#'21-!,.51!.11K()!&*'1!'S1!%,&*!&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!,99-1,82(5!#5()!&*!

'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!5#82!,5!'2(W!

• b18,.! V%9-1E(%(*'! /&*,*8(! B-#5'! IbV/BJ! Z! ,99.&()! &*! 5%,..(-! 58,.(!

)(E(.19%(*'5!&*!'2(!9-&%,-:?!8,-(!5(8'1-q!

• Q,9&',.!V*E(5'%(*'!T,*#,.!IQVTJ!I01-!+#$.&8;!+-&E,'(!/&*,*8(!V*E(5'%(*'!

I+/VJ!,*)!+#$.&8!+-&E,'(!+,-'*(-52&9!I+++J!&*E(5'%(*'5J!Z!,99.&()!%,&*.:!

&*! .,-7(\58,.(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'! &*! '2(! 5(81*),-:=!1-! ,8#'(!

2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-A!

B2(!QVT;!bV/B!,*)!'2(!U,'(S,:Y!3(E&(S!%1)(.5!,-(!)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!

5(8'&1*5!2&72.&72'&*7!S2:!,!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!*(()5! '1!$(! (%$())()!

S&'2&*!'2(%A!

V*! ?FFN! '2(! ]["! (`(8#'&E(! .,#*82()! '2(! Q,9&',.! V*E(5'%(*'! T,*#,.! I]["!

(`(8#'&E(;!?FFNJA!B2(!9#-915(!10!'2&5!S,5!'1!,))-(55!'2(!8-&'&8,.!],'&1*,.!<#)&'!

G00&8(! -(91-'5! &*'1! '2(! ]["! %,^1-! 9-1^(8'5;! S2(-(! &%91-',*'! )&00(-(*'&,'&*7!

0,8'1-5!$('S((*!9-&1-&':! &*E(5'%(*'!,-(,5! &*! '2(!]["!*(()()! '1!$(!81*5&)(-()!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!?!5'$D.'*!:.'&\! )(58-&$(5! 81%%#*&':! $,5()! 2(,.'2! 5(-E&8(5! '2,'! ,-(! #5#,..:! '2(! 0&-5';! ,*)! 10'(*! '2(! 1*.:;!

91&*'! 10! 81*',8'! '2,'! 9,'&(*'5! %,K(! S&'2! '2(! 2(,.'2! 5(-E&8(A! V'! 81E(-5! 5(-E&8(5! 9-1E&)()! $:! 7(*(-,.!IU+5J;! 81%%#*&':! *#-5(5;! 81%%#*&':! '2(-,9&5';! 81%%#*&':! 92,-%,8&5';! 19'1%('-&5'5;! )(*'&5'5! ,*)!%&)S&E(5!IC&*.(:L5!]["!U#&)(;!=>>DJ!!

=!"&E+#0.'*!1-!FE3)&!:.'&\!&5!9-1E&)()!'2-1#72!]["!2159&',.5!'-(,'&*7!81*)&'&1*5!'2,'!8,**1'!$(!)(,.'!S&'2!$:!9-&%,-:!8,-(!59(8&,.&5'5!1-!S2&82!,-(!$-1#72'! &*!,5!,*!(%(-7(*8:A!B:9(5!10!2159&',.5!,.51! &*8.#)(!6&5'-&8'!U(*(-,.!2159&',.5;!B(-'&,-:!,*)!B-,#%,!8(*'-(5;!,*)!81%%#*&':!2159&',.5!IC&*.(:L5!]["!U#&)(;!=>>DJ!

Page 101: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DD!

9-&1-!'1!'2(&-!$#)7('!,99-1E,.A!+,55%,*!&*!=>>F!)&58#55(5!'2,'!'2(!QVT!S,5!5((*!

,8-155!71E(-*%(*'!,5!%15'.:!,.&7*()!S&'2!'2(!,E,&.,$.(!$(5'!9-,8'&8(!,'!'2(!'&%(;!

,*)!%,*:!10!&'5!9-&*8&9.(5!21.)!'-#(!'1),:A!V'!01..1S5!'2(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(5!,99-1E,.!

-1#'(!'2,'!&5!%,*),'1-:!9,-'!10!'2(!9.,**&*7;!,99-1E,.;!9-18#-(%(*'!,*)!)(.&E(-:!

10!&*E(5'%(*'5!S&'2&*!'2(!9#$.&8!5(8'1-A!B2&5!%1)(.!&5!'2(!6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!

-(81%%(*)()!,99-1,82!01-! '2(!9-(9,-,'&1*!10!5(-E&8(!-(.,'()!9-18#-(%(*'5! &*!

'2(! ]["! H*7.,*);! ,*)! &5! ,.51! #5()! (`'(*5&E(.:! S&'2&*! 8(*'-,.! 71E(-*%(*'!

)(9,-'%(*'5! ,*)! '2(&-! ,7(*8&(5A! B2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! $#5&*(55! 8,5(! ',K(5!

9.,8(!1E(-'&%(!,*)!8,*!$(!$-1K(*!)1S*!&*'1!0&E(!)&00(-(*'!,59(8'5A!6&5'&*8'&E(.:!

(,82!&*E(5'%(*'!9-1915,.!521#.)!I/.,*,7,*!,*)!]&821..5;!=>>MJW!!

• C(!5#991-'()!$:!,!-1$#5'!8,5(!01-!82,*7(q!!

• G9'&%&5(!E,.#(!01-!%1*(:q!

• V5!81%%(-8&,..:!E&,$.(q!

• V5!0&*,*8&,..:!,001-),$.(q!

• Q,*!$(!)(.&E(-()!5#88(550#..:A!

B2(!$#5&*(55!8,5(!)(E(.195!1E(-'&%(;!#5#,..:!&*!'2-((!)&5'&*8'!5',7(5W!!

• "'-,'(7&8!G#'.&*(!Q,5(!I"GQJq!

• G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!IGCQJq!

• /#..!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!I/CQJA!

B2(![T!B-(,5#-:;!&*!'2(!U-((*!C11K!7#&)(!I=>>@J!)(58-&$(5!'2(5(!,5W!

"GQ!\! &5! '2(!5819&*7!5',7(!,*)!&'5!9#-915(! &5! '1!81*0&-%!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!81*'(`'!10!

'2(! 9-1915,.A! V'! ,&%5! 1*! %,K&*7! ,! -1$#5'! 8,5(! 01-! 82,*7(! ,*)! '1! 9-1E&)(!

5',K(21.)(-5!S&'2!,*!(,-.:!&*)&8,'&1*!10!'2(!9-1915()!S,:!01-S,-)!I$#'!*1'!:('!

'2(! 9-(0(--()! 19'&1*J;! 2,E&*7! &)(*'&0&()! ,*)! #*)(-',K(*! "_GB@!,*,.:5&5! 1*! ,!

S&)(!-,*7(!10!,E,&.,$.(!19'&1*5!'17('2(-!S&'2!&*)&8,'&E(!815'5q!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!@!"'-(*7'25!_(,K*(55(5!G991-'#*&'&(5!B2-(,'5!

Page 102: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! DF!

GCQ!Z!&5!'2(!)(',&.()!9.,**&*7!92,5(A!B2(!9#-915(!10!'2(!GCQ!&5!'1!-(E&5&'!'2(!"GQ!

&*!%1-(!)(',&.!,*)!'1!&)(*'&0:!,!9-(0(--()!19'&1*;!S2&82!)(%1*5'-,'(5!X,.#(!01-!

T1*(:A!V'!521#.)!)(%1*5'-,'(!,001-),$&.&':;!)(',&.5!10!'2(!9-18#-(%(*'!5'-,'(7:;!

'17('2(-! S&'2! %,*,7(%(*'! ,--,*7(%(*'5! 01-! '2(! 5#88(550#.! -1..1#'! 10! '2(!

9-1^(8'q!

/CQ!Z!&5!'2(!)(',&.()!0&*,.!92,5(A!V'!',K(5!9.,8(!S&'2&*!'2(!9-18#-(%(*'!92,5(!10!

'2(! 9-1^(8';! 01..1S&*7! )(',&.()! *(71'&,'&1*5! S&'2! 5(-E&8(! 9-1E&)(-5! 9-&1-! '1!

01-%,.! 5&7*&*7! 10! 81*'-,8'5A! B2&5! &5! #5#,..:! '2(! 5',7(! ,'! S2&82! 0&*,.! B-(,5#-:!

,99-1E,.!&5!-(4#&-()A!B2(!9#-915(!10!'2(!/CQ!&5!'1!-(E&5&'!'2(!GCQ!,*)!-(81-)!'2(!

0&*)&*75! 10! '2(! 5#$5(4#(*'! 9-18#-(%(*'! ,8'&E&'&(5;! '17('2(-! S&'2! '2(!

-(81%%(*),'&1*! 10! ,*! ,001-),$.(! 19'&1*! '2,'! 19'&%&5(5! E,.#(! 01-! %1*(:A! V'!

521#.)! &*8.#)(!)(',&.()!,--,*7(%(*'5! 01-! '2(! 5#88(550#.!)(.&E(-:!10! '2(!9-1^(8'!

,*)!&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!5(-E&8(5!0-1%!'2(!8215(*!5#99.&(-5A!

V'!&5!S1-'2!2&72.&72'&*7!2(-(!'2,'!'2(!U-((*!$11K!I=>>@J!(*)1-5(5!'2(!*(()!01-!,!

-1$#5'!9-18(55!'2,'!2,5!,!5'-1*7(-!(%92,5&5!1*!'2(!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!

10! $(*(0&'5;! 018#5&*7! 1*! '2(! (*)! 5&72'! -&72'! 0-1%! '2(! $(7&**&*7A! ! <881-)&*7! '1!

/.,*,7,*!,*)!]&821..5!I=>>MJ;!'11!%,*:!5'-,'(7&(5;!9-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5!&*!

'2(! 9#$.&8! 5(8'1-! 0,&.! '1! ,82&(E(! '2(&-! 1$^(8'&E(5! $(8,#5(! '2(! K(:! 92,5(5! 10! '2(!

&*E(5'%(*'! 2,E(! $((*! &*,)(4#,'(.:! 5819()! ,*)! 9.,**();! '2(! ,5518&,'()! -&5K5!

2,E(!*1'!$((*!',K(*!&*'1!,881#*'!,*)!,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5!,-(!*1'!)(.&E(-()!)#(!

'1!'2(&-!911-!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'A!!

V*! =>>>! '2(! Pd! 71E(-*%(*'! .,#*82()! '2(! ]["! +.,*! I61[;! =>>>J! S2(-(! &'!

%,*&0(5'()! '2,'! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! *(S! ,8#'(! 2159&',.! 0,8&.&'&(5! S1#.)! $(!

)(.&E(-()! '2-1#72! ,! 81%$&*,'&1*! 10! '-,)&'&1*,.! 9#$.&8! 8,9&',.! 0#*)&*7! ,*)!

'2-1#72!'2(!+-&E,'(!/&*,*8(!V*&'&,'&E(A!

B2(!+/V!%(,*'! '2,'! '2(!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-!S1#.)!)(5&7*;!$#&.);! 0&*,*8(!,*)!19(-,'(!

*(S! 2159&',.! 0,8&.&'&(5A! B2(! 1S*(-52&9! 10! '2(! 0,8&.&'&(5! S1#.)! -(%,&*! S&'2! '2(!

9-&E,'(!5(8'1-!,*)!.(,5()!$,8K!'1!'2(!]["!1*!,!.1*7\'(-%!$,5&5!.(,5(A!!B2(!%,&*!

,)E,*',7(5!10!'2(!+/V!S(-(!81*5&)(-()!'1!$(W!

Page 103: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! F>!

• B2(!,88(55&$&.&':!'1!,*1'2(-!51#-8(!10!0&*,*8(q!

• B2(! %&'&7,'&1*! '1! '2(! 9-&E,'(! 5(8'1-! 10! '2(! -&5K! 10! 1S*(-52&9! ,*)!

)(.&E(-&*7!'2(!,55('!'1!'&%(!,*)!,7-(()!815'q!,*)!

• B2(! -(591*5&$&.&':! 01-! 0,8&.&'&(5! 1*! 71&*7!%,&*'(*,*8(! ,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!

01-!'2(!)#-,'&1*!10!'2(!.(,5(!S1#.)!0,..!&*!'1!'2(!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-A!!

B2(!]["! +.,*! ,.51!%,*&0(5'()! '2,'! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'! &*! 9-&%,-:! ,*)! 81%%#*&':!

8,-(!S1#.)! 81%(! '2-1#72! ,!*(S!9#$.&8\9-&E,'(!9,-'*(-52&9!K*1S*!,5! '2(!]["!

b18,.!V%9-1E(%(*'!/&*,*8(!B-#5'!IbV/BJA!

B2(! bV/B! %1)(.! &5! ,! 2:$-&)! &*&'&,'&E(! '2,'! 2,5! )-,S*! 711)! 9-,8'&8(! 0-1%!

'-,)&'&1*,.!+/V5!,*)!+++5A!B2(!-(5#.'!S,5!,!01-%!10!+++!'2,'!9-1E&)(5!.1*7\'(-%!

81*'-,8'5!01-!'2(!-(0#-$&52%(*';!81*5'-#8'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!10!.,-7(!$#*).(5!

10!U+!,*)!+-&%,-:!Q,-(!0,8&.&'&(5A!B2(!bV/B!&*&'&,'&E(!S,5!(5',$.&52()!9#-5#,*'!'1!

'2(![(,.'2!,*)!"18&,.!Q,-(!<8'!=>>?!,5!,!%(,*5!'1!&*'-1)#8(!*(S!51.#'&1*5!'1!'2(!

&*E(5'%(*'! *(()5! 10! 81%%#*&':! $,5()! 8,-(! 5(-E&8(5A! V'! &5! ,! 5'-,'(7&8! +++!

,--,*7(%(*'!#*)(-!S2&82!9,-'*(-5!',K(!52,-(5!&*!,!^1&*'!E(*'#-(!K*1S*!,5!'2(!

bV/B!Q1A;!S2&82!&5!5('!#9!'1!)(.&E(-!9-&%,-:!2(,.'2!8,-(!9-19(-':!0,8&.&'&(5A!<'!'2(!

'&%(! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82! '2(-(! S(-(! N@! bV/B! Q1AL5! 19(-,'&*7! *,'&1*,..:A! H,82!

9,-'*(-52&9!&5!%,)(!#9!10!'2(!01..1S&*7!K(:!9,-'*(-5W!

• Q1%%#*&':![(,.'2!+,-'*(-52&95!,*!&*)(9(*)(*'!81%9,*:!S21..:!1S*()!

$:!'2(!6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2q!

• b18,.!2(,.'2!8,-(!9-1E&)(-5!5#82!,5!+-&%,-:!Q,-(!B-#5'5q!

• <%$#.,*8(!5(-E&8(q!

• "18&,.!8,-(!9-1E&)(-5!5#82!,5!.18,.!,#'21-&'&(5q!,*)!

• <!9-&E,'(!5(8'1-!9,-'*(-A!

bV/B!2,5!$((*!)(5&7*()!'1!5#991-'! '2(!E&5&1*!10! '2(!]["!+.,*!01-!,*!,88(55&$.(!

2(,.'2! 5(-E&8(! )(5&7*()! ,-1#*)! 9,'&(*'5L! *(()5;! S&'2! (*2,*8()! &*'(7-,'()!

9-&%,-:;!81%%#*&':!,*)!518&,.!8,-(!5(-E&8(5A!bV/B!582(%(5!,&%!'1!81*'-&$#'(!'1!

.18,.!-(7(*(-,'&1*!,*)!*(&72$1#-211)!-(*(S,.!$:!(*5#-&*7!'2(!4#,.&':!10!.&0(!10!

.18,.!-(5&)(*'5! &5! &%9-1E()!'2-1#72!(*2,*8()!9#$.&8!5(-E&8(5;!,*)!'2,'!$-1,)(-!

Page 104: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! F?!

9-&E,'(! &*E(5'%(*'! &5! ',-7('()! '1S,-)5! ,-(,5! 10! 2&72(5'! )(9-&E,'&1*! I[1#5(! 10!

Q1%%1*5;!=>>RJA!!

cV*! ,))&'&1*! ,! bV/B! 1-7,*&5,'&1*!S&..! $(! (*81#-,7()! '1! &)(*'&0:! 1'2(-! 91'(*'&,.!

188#9,*'5!1-!#5(-5!10!0,8&.&'&(5!1-!1'2(-!81%%(-8&,.!1991-'#*&'&(5!'2,'!%,:!2(.9!

%,K(!,!)(E(.19%(*'!0&*,*8&,..:!E&,$.(!1-!(*2,*8(!9-10&',$&.&':!,5!S(..!,5!100(-&*7!

0.(`&$&.&':!'1!-(591*)!'1!82,*7&*7!-(4#&-(%(*'5L!IQ,-'.&)7(;!=>>RJA!Q1\.18,'&1*!10!

%,*:!5(-E&8(5!%(,*5!'2(!&*'(7-,'&1*!10!2(,.'2!,*)!518&,.!8,-(!0,8&.&'&(5;!-(5#.'&*7!

&*!,!%#82!%1-(!,88(55&$.(!2(,.'28,-(!5:5'(%A!B2-1#72!81\.18,'&1*!10!,!-,*7(!10!

2(,.'28,-(! 5(-E&8(5! 5(81*),-:! 8,-(! 8,*! 188#-! S&'2&*! 9-&%,-:! 8,-(! 0,8&.&'&(5;!

u,..1S&*7! 0,5'(-! ,*)!%1-(! 81*E(*&(*'! -(0(--,.5;! S2(-(! '2(! -(.(E,*'! 59(8&,.&5'5!

21.)!8.&*&85!&*!bV/B!9-(%&5(5v!I[1#5(!10!Q1%%1*5;!=>>RJA!!

B2(!5(-E&8(5!'2,'!S&..!$(!9-1E&)()!S&..!$(!#5&*7!,!81%%1*!,99-1,82!)(E(.19()!

$:!+,-'*(-52&95! 01-![(,.'2A! ! B2&5!S&..! -(5#.'! &*! ,!%1-(! (4#,.!)(.&E(-:!10! 2(,.'2!

,8-155!'2(!H*7.,*)!,*)!_,.(5A!B2(!bV/B!81%9,*&(5!S&..!)(.&E(-!$#&.)&*75!'2,'!,-(!

0#..:! 0#*8'&1*,.! ,*)! ,$.(! '1!)(.E(-! '1! '2(! .18,.! 81%%#*&':! '2(! 8,-(! &*! '(-%5!10!

2(,.'2!,*)!518&,.! '2,'! &5!*(()()!1E(-!,!9(-&1)!10!=>!:(,-5!I[1#5(!10!Q1%%1*5;!

=>>RJA!

/1..1S&*7! '(*! :(,-5! 10! )(E(.19%(*'! &*! '2(! ]["! IS2&.(! '2&5! -(5(,-82! S,5!

81*)#8'()J! #5&*7! '2(! ,99-1,82(5! )(58-&$()! ,$1E(! '2(-(! S,5! ,! 8.(,-! )-&E(! 01-!

)(.&E(-&*7!,))&'&1*,.!8,9,8&':!01-!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-A!b1-)!6,-e&!&*!=>>D!&*!'2(!

c[&72!f#,.&':!Q,-(!01-!,..L!-(91-'!2&72.&72'()!'2(!*(()!'1!,.51!81%%&'!'1!)(.&E(-!

4#,.&':! &*! '(-%5!10!$(*(0&'5!9-&%,-&.:! 01-! '2(!9,'&(*'5!,5!S(..!,5! '1! '2(!%()&8,.!

,*)!1'2(-!)(9(*),*'!81%%#*&'&(5A!

<5!&'!&5!2&72.&72'()!&*!'2(!-(5(,-82!*(()!5(8'&1*!I?A=J;!)#-&*7!'2&5!9,5'!)(8,)(!10!

2(,E:!]["! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*';! '2(-(! 2,5! $((*! .&''.(! 5:5'(%,'&8! 01..1S!

'2-1#72!'1!)-&E(!01-S,-)!)(.&E(-:!10!'2(!&*)&E&)#,.!&*E(5'%(*'L5!$(*(0&'5!,*)!'1!

%(,5#-(!S2,'!&5!,8'#,..:!,82&(E()A!V'! &5!,.51!-,-(!01-!,*:!#*,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5!

1-!)&5$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!8,9'#-()!&*!,!5:5'(%,'&8!S,:A!

Page 105: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! F=!

B2(!Pd!71E(-*%(*'! &*!=>>@! '2-1#72! '2(!G00&8(!10!U1E(-*%(*'! ,*)!Q1%%(-8(!

IGUQJ! &*'-1)#8()! '2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!9-18(55! '1!(`,%&*(!,!9-1^(8'!,'! 8-&'&8,.!

5',7(5!&*!&'5!.&0(8:8.(!,*)!'1!9-1E&)(!,55#-,*8(!'2,'!&'!8,*!9-17-(55!5#88(550#..:!'1!

'2(!*(`'! 5',7(!10! &'5!)(E(.19%(*'A!B2(!U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S!9-18(55!S,5!)(5&7*()!

01-! ,*)! ,99.&()! '1! )(.&E(-:! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-18#-(%(*'! 9-1^(8'5! ,8-155! ,..!

5(8'1-5! &*8.#)&*7! 2(,.'28,-(A! V*! 5&%9.(! '(-%5! &'! &5! ,! -(E&(S! 10! ,! 82,*7(!

9-17-,%%(! 1-! 9-1^(8'! 8,--&()! 1#'! ,'! K(:! )(8&5&1*! 91&*'5! $:! ,! '(,%! 10!

(`9(-&(*8()!9(19.(!*1'!,5518&,'()!S&'2!'2(!9-1^(8'!#*)(-!-(E&(SA!!

B2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!S,5!'2(!0&-5'!5:5'(%,'&8!71E(-*%(*'!&*&'&,'&E(!'1!2&72.&72'!

'2(!*(()!01-!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&*!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(5!1-!9-1^(8'5A!!V'!9-1%1'(5!

'2,'!,*:!9-17-,%%(!10!82,*7(!-(4#&-(5!,!81*5',*'!018#5!1*!'2(!&*'(*)()!$(*(0&'5!

I%(,5#-,$.(! &%9-1E(%(*'5J! &0! &'! &5! '1! )(.&E(-! E,.#(! ,*)! -(%,&*! ,.&7*()! S&'2!

$#5&*(55! 71,.5! ,*)! '2(!GUQ!U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S!9-18(55! I/&7#-(! =@J! -(0.(8'5! '2&5!

018#5!,'!(,82!5',7(A!

B2(! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S! 0-,%(S1-K! &*)&8,'(5;! ,'! ,! 2&72! .(E(.;! )(9(*)(*8&(5!

$('S((*! ,! ':9&8,.! $(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55! ,*)! '2(! 5'(95! 01-!%,*,7&*7! ,!

%,^1-! )(.&E(-:! 9-17-,%%(A! V'! ,.51!%,95! '2(!%,&*! $(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! 5'(95!

1*'1! '2(! 5',*),-)! )(.&E(-:! 5',7(5! )(58-&$()! &*! $1'2! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.!

+-17-,%%(5! IT"+J! ,*)!GUQ!U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S5;! $#'! '2(! ,99-1,82! 8,*!$(!#5()!

01-! ,*:! ':9(! 10! %1-(! 59(8&,.&5()! 82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(;! &*8.#)&*7! &*'-1)#8&*7! *(S!

91.&8:;!9-18#-(%(*'!9-1^(8'5!1-!%(('&*7!(\)(.&E(-:!',-7('5!IGUQ;!=>>@JA!

B2&5! 9-18(55! 81*',&*5! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! 91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! '2(&-! 9.,**&*7;!

%1)(..&*7! ,*)! '-,8K&*7;! '2(! ,55&7*%(*'! 10! -(591*5&$&.&'&(5! ,*)! ,#'21-&'&(5! ,*)!

'2(&-! ,8'#,.! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! &'! 2,5! 2(,E&.:! $((*! &*0.#(*8()! $:! '2(! Q-,*0&(.)!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!%1)(.!'2,'!S,5!&*'-1)#8()!&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!5(8'&1*!

10!'2&5!'2(5&5A!IC-,).(:;!=>>R;!GUQ;!=>>M,;!_,-)!,*)!6,*&(.;!=>>RJA!

Page 106: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! F@!

!

X)A85'!*-c!E/1'R/Bg!5'<)'R![5;9'((!^JE4D!*++P_!

*$*,$, I0)A2@'21! ;7! )2<'(1@'21! /[[5/)(/0! (1/A'(D! E/1'R/Bg! 5'<)'R! A/1'(!

/23!1#'!>':'/0!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((!

B2(! 9-1915()! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! &5! '1! $(! &*E(5'&7,'()! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,5! &'! &5!

)(58-&$()! &*! '2(! *(`'! 'S1! 82,9'(-5A! C(3(,.! )1(5! *1'! &*'(*)! '1! -(9.,8(! ,!

2(,.'28,-(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!&*E(5'%(*'!1-!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55!$#'!'1!-#*!

!"#$%&#'%&()*+,),'-&./'-$#.-&

!""#$%&#'()%*+&%(#,-.#&)%

012(',22&3-$#-,45&/#)%01"-2#""%+03#4$-.#"%'2(%

+1$4+5#"%%

62-#7+(28&712(',22&',,%&61"-2#""%2##(%-(#2$-7-#(%

(#.#,+8%8&+9&'55#%+&%8&+3#4$%0&-#*%

9,:,+/*&712(',22&.#2,&:8$-+2"%-(#2$-7-#(;%

'**+&('0-,-$)%'4<-#.'0-,-$)%'2(%.',1#%*+&%5+2#)%%

9,:,+/*&*$/.1$,),'-&2-$#-,45&

=8#4-*)%&#>1-&#5#2$";%18('$#%01"-2#""%4'"#%

:29+-29%*##(0'4?%'2(%,#""+2"%,#'&2#(%*&+5%&#.-#@

"%

A'$#@')%-2$#&.#2$-+2% =$'9#%-2%8&+41&#5#2$%,-*#4)4,#%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&=&=$&'$#9-4%'""#""5#2$%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&>&61"-2#""%31"$-7-4'$-+2%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&?&B&+41&#5#2$%"$&'$#9)%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&@&C2.#"$5#2$%(#4-"-+2%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&A&D#'(-2#""%*+&%"#&.-4#%

%;#-,"#5&<,:(,"&B&6#2#7-$"%E.',1'$-+2%

C#'#4,&./'-$#.-&=#&.-4#%(#,-.#&#(F%0#2#7-$"%'4<-#.#(F%8#&*+&5'24#%

-58&+.#(%

D/)*,-(-(:,&*$/.1$,),'-&E.',1'$#%0-(";%"#,#4$%"188,-#&;%

18('$#%01"-2#""%4'"#%

D+/21$,&E2(%+*%4+2$&'4$;%@+&?8'4?'9#%

#$4G%

%%H#4-"-+2%8+-2$%

Page 107: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FN!

,.1*75&)(!,*)!2(.9!'215(!&*E1.E()!'1!#*)(-5',*)!21S!'2(!018#5!1*!$(*(0&'5!8,*!

0#-'2(-!,55&5'!'2(!%,*,7(%(*'!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!B2#5!9-&1-!'1!0#-'2(-!)(E(.19%(*'!

,*)!'1!2(.9!S&'2!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!5(.(8'&1*!&'!S,5!*(8(55,-:!'1!,.&7*!'2(!9-1915()!

9-18(55!S&'2!'2(!%('21)5!)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!5(8'&1*!,*)!8#--(*'.:!#5()!

&*!'2(!Pd!$:!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!,.1*75&)(!GUQ5!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!9-18(55A!B2(!

9-1915()! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! &5! ,.51! 9-1E&5&1*,..:! %,99()! ,*)! ,.&7*()! ,7,&*5'! ,!

':9&8,.!9-18#-(%(*'!.&0(8:8.(!IGUQ;!=>>NJ!10!,!9-1^(8'!I/&7#-(!=NJA!

!

X)A85'!*Pc!&#'!7)5(1!9;29'[18/0![5;9'((D!/23!)1(![5;[;('3!/0)A2@'21!R)1#!1#'!@/)2!#'/01#9/5'!

)2<'(1@'21!/[[5/)(/0![5;9'(('(!

V'!&5!&%91-',*'!'1!2&72.&72'!'2,'!,..!,99-1,82(5!&*'-1)#8(!,*)!,''(%9'!'1!018#5!1*!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,'!'2(!0&*,.!5',7(5!10!'2(&-!9-17-(55&1*A!B2(!,#'21-L5!E&(S!'2,'!

&5! ,! 01#*),'&1*! &*! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-1915()! 9-18(55! &5! '2,'! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! 521#.)! 5',-'! ,'! '2(! 81*8(9'&1*! 5',7(5! ,*)! )-&E(! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'!

'2-1#721#'!&'5!.&0(8:8.(A!B2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!&*'-1)#8()!&*!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

&*!82,9'(-!@!,*)! 0#..:!)(58-&$()! &*!82,9'(-!N!2,E(!$((*!5(.(8'()!,&%&*7! '1! '(5'!

,*)!E,.&),'(!'2(!9-1915()!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,*)!'1!,.51!2&72.&72'!'2(!-(.(E,*8(!10!

'2(!C(3(,.!92,5(5!S&'2!'2(!81--(591*)&*7!'-,)&'&1*,.!&*E(5'%(*'!9-18(55!5',7(5A!

B2&5! )#,.! ,99-1,82;! '2,'! %&`(5! ,*! (`&5'&*7! I,*)! 5',K(21.)(-5L! 0,%&.&,-J! %1)(.!

S&'2!,!*(S!,*)!(%(-7&*7!9-18(55;!8,*!0#-'2(-!(*,$.(!C(3(,.L5!#5(!,5!,!'11.!'2,'!

$-&*75! &*)&E&)#,.5! ,*)! '(,%5! '17('2(-! S2&.5'! $-(,K&*7! )1S*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

$,--&(-5!$:!52&0'&*7!9(19.(L5!'2&*K&*7!'1S,-)5!$(*(0&'5!,*)!1#'81%(5A!

!"#$%"&'()#$*+$)#(,)'

-*,./*$0$)#'1(2$.&.1$'

''3$.(4(,)'5,()#'

!!"#$%"&'6'"#$%&#'(')*!+*#,*'-.!!

!!"#$%"&'7'/)0'+*(')*!1'%2+2$)!

!!"#$%"&'8'3',12)'++!4$#!

+'#02%'!

!!"#$%"&'9'5')'62*+!'0,7&,*2$)!

!!"#$%"&':'5&+2)'++!8&+*262%,*2$)!

!!"#$%"&';'9*#,*'-2%!,++'++(')*!

!:'62)'!;&+2)'++!!)''1!

!"#'<,#'!;&+2)'++!!%,+'!

:'62)'!<#$%&#'(')*!!+*#,*'-.!

/)02*'=!'0,7&,*'!,)1!#'62)'!*')1'#+!

>,),-'!2(<7'(')*,*2$)!$4!%$)*#,%*!

>,)-'!,)1!$<'#,*'!%$)*#,%*!

9*#,*'-2%!%$)*'?*!9@A!

@&*72)'!;&+2)'++!%,+'!@5A!

B&77!;&+2)'++!%,+'!B5A!

:'+2-)=!C')1'#!%$)*#,%*!

A$)+*#&%*2$)=!!C'%D)2%,7!E,)1$0'#!!

"$+*!<#$8'%*!'0,7&,*2$)!

<=>'?-@='=)+$4#0$)#'"55*"(4"1'

A=@B'4#"C$4'F!

9C3GCHIJ!K!

9A@"H!L!!

BHG9/5/M/CJ!N!

:H9/IO!P!!

Q!AM@9H!R!!

5S/M:!T!!

A@>>/99/@O!U!

@"H3GC/@O!V!!

5HOHB/C9!

5')'62*+!%D,#,%*'#2+,*2$)!!

5')'62*+!(,<<2)-!!

5')'62*+!#',72+,*2$)!<7,)!!

5')'62*+!(,),-'(')*!+*#,*'-.!!

H0,7&,*2$)!W!3'02'X!

D$E$"1'

Page 108: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!BS1!Z!C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!%1)(.!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FO!

*$** 4;2908();2!

B2&5!82,9'(-!9-(5(*'()!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!81*)#8'()!$:!'2(!,#'21-!&*!'2(!0&(.)!

10! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*A! B2(! ,#'21-! (`9.1-()! 2(-(! '2(! -(.,'&1*52&9! 10! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! S&'2! 1'2(-! -(.,'()! )&58&9.&*(5! '2,'! *(()! '1! $(! 81*5&)(-()! S2(*!

&*E(5'&7,'&*7! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! 5#82! ,! 9-18(55A! B2(! -(.,'()! )&58&9.&*(5! S(-(!

&)(*'&0&()! ,5! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*';! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*';!

81%9.(`&':;! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*';! 9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

%(,5#-(%(*';!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!0&*,..:!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'A!!

<!5:*'2(5&5!10!'2(! .&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!01..1S()!,*)!S,5!9-(5(*'()!81%9,-&*7!'2(!

)1%&*,*'! $(*(0&'!%,*,7(%(*'! ,99-1,82(5! ,*)! 1'2(-! '(82*&4#(5! '2,'! (%$-,8(!

'2(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! '2&*K&*7A! !B2(!,$1E(!7#&)()! '2(!,#'21-! &*'1! &)(*'&0:&*7!

'2(! *(()! 01-! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! ,99.&8,$.(! S2(*! )(E(.19&*7!

2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(5! ,*)! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! S,5! &*'-1)#8()A!

B2(! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! &5! 92,5()! ,5W! IVJ! C(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! 5'-,'(7:q! IVVJ!

C(*(0&'5! 82,-,8'(-&5,'&1*! ,*)!%,99&*7q! IVVVJ! C(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*q! ,*)! IVXJ!

HE,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(SA!

B2(! ,99.&8,$&.&':! 10! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! &5! S&'2&*! '2(! 2(,.'28,-(! 5(8'1-! ,5!

5#82! ,! )(58-&9'&1*! 10! '2(! %,&*! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-18#-(%(*'! ,*)!

&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!%('21)5!&*!'2(!Pd!S,5!%,)(A!B2(5(!S(-(!&)(*'&0&()!,5!'2(!

Q,9&',.!V*E(5'%(*'!T,*#,.!IQVTJ!01-!5(81*),-:!8,-(!,*)!'2(!b18,.!&%9-1E(%(*'!

/&*,*8(!B-#5'!IbV/BJ!01-!9-&%,-:!8,-(A!/#-'2(-!1*!'2(!&%91-',*8(!,*)!-(.(E,*8(!

10! '2(! $#5&*(55! 8,5(! )(E(.19%(*'! 9-18(55! ,*)! '2(! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S! 9-18(55!

S(-(!)&58#55()A!B2(!,#'21-! &..#5'-,'()!21S!'2(5(!%('21)5!8,*!$(!,.&7*()!S&'2!

'2(!81*8(9'#,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,*)!&'5!%,&*!92,5(5;!'1!(*5#-(!&'5!-(.(E,*8(A!

B2(!0&*)&*75!10!'2&5!82,9'(-!01-%!'2(!01#*),'&1*!01-!'2(!0#-'2(-!)(E(.19%(*'!10!

'2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! ,5! 9-(5(*'()! &*! 82,9'(-5! N! ,*)! O;! #5&*7! '2(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! )(58-&$()! &*! '2(! *(`'! 82,9'(-! ,5! '2(! 9.,'01-%! '1!

5#88(550#..:!81*)#8'!,*)!81*8.#)(!'2(!-(5(,-82A!!

!

Page 109: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FR!

- 4#/[1'5!1#5''!W!:'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!

B2&5! 82,9'(-! )(58-&$(5! '2(! -(5(,-82! %('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! '2,'! 7#&)(5! '2&5!

-(5(,-82A!<!*(5'()!-(5(,-82!%1)(.!&5!,)19'()!81*5&5'&*7!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!92&.15192:;!

5'-,'(7:;! ,*)!%('21)5! #5()A! V'! )(58-&$(5! &*! )(',&.! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! 8:8.(!

5'(95!',K(*!,*)!'2(!-(,51*&*7!$(2&*)!'2(!821&8(5!%,)(A!!

-$, 6215;3891);2!

B2(! $,5&8! 9#-915(! 10! -(5(,-82! &5! '2(1-:;! &A(A! '1! #*)(-5',*)! ,*)! (`9.,&*!

92(*1%(*,;! 7,&*&*7! 51.#'&1*5! '1! 9-1$.(%5! 1-! ,*5S(-5! '1! #*51.E()! 4#(5'&1*5!

IBe1-'e191#.15;! =>>NJA! <! '2(1-:! 9-(5(*'5! ,! 5:5'(%&8! E&(S! 10! 92(*1%(*,! $:!

59(8&0:&*7! -(.,'&1*5! ,%1*7! E,-&,$.(5;! S&'2! '2(! 9#-915(! 10! (`9.,&*&*7! 1-!

9-()&8'&*7! Id(-.&*7(-;! ?FMFJA! 3(5(,-82! %('21)1.17:! -(9-(5(*'5! '2(! .17&8! 10!

)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!9-18(55!#5()!'1!7(*(-,'(!'2(1-:!Id(-.&*7(-;!?FMFJA!

B2(-(01-(;! &'! -(0(-5! '1! '2(! 9-18()#-,.! 0-,%(S1-K!S&'2&*!S2&82! '2(! -(5(,-82! &5!

81*)#8'()! I3(%(*:&! ('! ,.A;! ?FFDJA! U11)! 4#,.&':! -(5(,-82! 521#.)! $(! -&71-1#5;!

5:5'(%,'&8;!&*'(7-,'()!,*)!018#5()!I+('(-5!,*)![1S,-);!=>>?JA![1S(E(-!'2(-(!&5!

*1! 1*(! #*&E(-5,..:! ,88(9'()! 58&(*'&0&8! %('21)1.17:! Ib((;! ?FDFJ! $#'! -,'2(-! ,!

81%$&*,'&1*! 10! 9,-,)&7%5! ,-(! #5()! '1! 01-%! '2(!%('21)1.17:! 01-! '2(! -(5(,-82!

#*)(-',K(*A!V*!5#82!S,:;!(E(-:!%('21)1.17:!&5!#*&4#(!,*)!,99.&8,$.(!1*.:!01-!&'!

&*'(*)()!9#-915(!Id,7&17.1#;!?FFFJA!

+-18(55! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! &'5! &%9.(%(*','&1*! &5! ,! 81%9.(`! 92(*1%(*1*! E(-:!

%#82!52,9()!$:!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!81*'(`'!&*!S2&82!&'!',K(5!9.,8(;!,5!S(..!,5!$:!

'2(! 9(-59(8'&E(5;! $(.&(05! ,*)! %1'&E,'&1*5! 10! '2(! &*)&E&)#,.5! &*E1.E()A!

IBe1-'e191#.15;!=>>NJ!B2#5;!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)!,99.&()!521#.)!$(!,99-19-&,'(!

'1!2(.9!#*)(-5',*)&*7! '2(! 81%9.(`&'&(5! 10! '2(! &%9.(%(*','&1*!9-18(55! ,*)! '2(!

%,*:!0,8'1-5!'2,'!,00(8'!&'A!!

Page 110: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FM!

6&00(-(*'! %('21)1.17&(5! 8,*! $(! #5()! '1! )(5&7*! ,*)! (`(8#'(! -(5(,-82A!

]1*('2(.(55;! '2(! %('21)! #5()! 521#.)! $(! 5#&',$.(! '1! )(E(.19! ,*)! '(5'! '2(1-:!

S&'2&*!'2(!,-(,!$(&*7!5'#)&()!Id(-.&*7(-;!?FMFq!3(%(*:&!('!,.A;!?FFDJA!

-$* &#'!5'('/59#!@;3'0!

<! c*(5'()L! -(5(,-82! %('21)1.17:! &5! ,)19'()! ,5! )(58-&$()! $:! d,7&17.1#! ('! ,.A!

I?FFDJ! /&7#-(! =OA! "#82! ,!%('21)1.17:! 9-1E&)(5! ,! 21.&5'&8;! &*'(7-,'()! -(5(,-82!

%('21);! 7(*(-,'&*7! ,! 0-,%(S1-K! '2,'! 9-1E&)(5! '2(! -(5(,-82(-!S&'2! ,! -(5(,-82!

,99-1,82! ,*)! '(82*&4#(5! '2,'! $(*(0&'! 0-1%! (9&5'(%1.17&8,.! .(E(.! )&-(8'&1*! ,*)!

812(5&1*A!P*)(-5',*)&*7! '2(!(.(%(*'5! '2,'!81*5'&'#'(!,!%('21)1.17:!8,*!,55&5'!

&*! -(,82&*7! ,99-19-&,'(! ,.&7*%(*'! $('S((*! '2(! %('21)! ,*)! '2(! 5'#):! ,-(,!

IBe1-'e191#.15;! =>>NJA! B2(! (.(%(*'5! 10! '2(! *(5'()! ,99-1,82! ,-(! 5#%%,-&5()!

$(.1S!,*)!0#-'2(-!)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!5(8'&1*5A!

!

X)A85'!*Nc&#'!hK'(1'3d!5'('/59#!@;3'0!^G/A);A0;8D!,UUU_!

• 3(5(,-82!92&.15192:!7#&)(5!,*)!#*&0&(5!'2(!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7:!,*)!'(82*&4#(5q!

• 3(5(,-82! ,99-1,82! 81*5&5'5! 10! '2(! )1%&*,*'! '2(1-:! 7(*(-,'&1*! ,*)! '(5'&*7!

%('21)5q!

• 3(5(,-82!'(82*&4#(5!81%9-&5(!%,&*.:!),',!81..(8'&1*!,*)!,*,.:5&5!'11.5A!

:'('/59#![#)0;(;[#B!

[(-%(*(#'&8!.(,-*&*7!59&-,.!

+-(!Z!#*)(-5',*)&*7!,*)!#*)(-5',*)&*7!

:'('/59#!(15/1'A)'(!

Q1*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!r!8,5(!5'#):!

:'('/59#!@'1#;3(!

b&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S5;!S1-K52195;!

&*'(-E&(S5;!1$5(-E,'&1*5!

Page 111: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FD!

-$- :'('/59#![#)0;(;[#B!

h1&*&*7!'2(!(9&5'(%1.17&8,.!)($,'(!1*! c!21S!'1!$(5'!81*)#8'!-(5(,-82L!'2(-(!,-(!

'S1!58211.5!10!'21#72';!915&'&E&5%!,*)!92(*1%(*1.17:A!!

+15&'&E&5%!-(0(-5!'1!u,..!,99-1,82(5!'1!58&(*8(!'2,'!81*5&)(-!58&(*'&0&8!K*1S.()7(!

'1!$(!1$',&*()!1*.:!0-1%!5(*5(!),',!'2,'!8,*!$(!)&-(8'.:!(`9(-&(*8()!,*)!E(-&0&()!

$('S((*! )&00(-(*'! 1$5(-E(-5v! I"#5%,*! ,*)! HE(-();! ?FMDJ;! &*8.#)&*7! -&71-1#5!

1$5(-E,'&1*5! '1! 7(*(-,'(! 58&(*'&0&8! K*1S.()7(A! V*! '2&5! S,:;! &'! %,&*.:! #5(5!

4#,*'&','&E(! ,*)! (`9(-&%(*',.! %('21)5! '1! '(5'! 2:91'2('&8,.\)()#8'&E(!

7(*(-,.&5,'&1*5!IC.,&K&(;!?FF@JA!

+2(*1%(*1.17:!81*8(-*5!92(*1%(*,;! &A(A!1#-!(`9(-&(*8(!10!'2&*75A! V*!'2&5!S,:;!

92(*1%(*1.17&8,.! %('21)1.17:! 5((K5! '1! #*)(-5',*)! ,*1'2(-L5! (`9(-&(*8(!

IQ12(*! ('! ,.A;! =>>>JA! +2(*1%(*1.17:! #5(5! %,&*.:! 4#,.&','&E(! ,99-1,82(5! '1!

#*)(-5',*)! ,*)! (`9.,&*! ,! 92(*1%(*1*! IH,5'(-$:\"%&'2! ('! ,.A;! =>>=JA! V'! ,.51!

-(817*&5(5!'2(!&*)&E&)#,.!E&(S91&*'5!10!9-,8'&'&1*(-5!,*)!-(5(,-82(-5!&*E1.E()!&*!

'2(!9-18(55!I"(:%1#-;!?FFMJA!

V*! 5(8'&1*! ?A@! &'! S,5! 5','()! '2,'! '2(! ,&%! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82! '1! )(E(.19! ,! -1$#5'!

9-18(55! 01-! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! '1! &*E(5'&7,'(! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(5! &*! '2(! ,-(,! 10!

$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-A!B2#5!'2(!,#'21-!2,5!,)19'()!'2(!

&*'(-9-(','&E(!58211.!10!'21#72'!,5!'2(!(9&5'(%1.17&8,.!19'&1*!01-!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!!

_&'2&*! '2,'! 58211.! 10! (9&5'(%1.17:! '2,'! &5! ,.51! K*1S*! ,5! '2(! &*'(-9-(','&E(!

92&.15192:!I"&.E(-%,*;!?FFDJ!'2&5!-(5(,-82!&5!-11'()!1*!'2(!+-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!}!

P*)(-5',*)&*7!59&-,.!IG.)%,*;!?FDOJA!!

B2(!&)(,!$(2&*)!'2(!2(-%(*(#'&85!59&-,.!&5!'2,'!*1!K*1S.()7(!&5!9155&$.(!S&'21#'!

9-(5#9915&'&1*5Z! &A(A! '2(! 0-,%&*7! 10! ,*:! 58&(*'&0&8! 4#(5'&1*! ,55#%(5! 51%(!

01-(K*1S.()7(! 10! S2,'! S(! S,*'! '1! K*1S! I"#5%,*! ,*)! HE(-();! ?FMDJ! ,*)!

'2(-(01-(! -(5(,-82! $(81%(5! ,*! &'(-,'&E(! 9-18(55!S2(-($:! ,! 9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!

)(E(.195! '1! ,*! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! E,-&1#5! &55#(5! &*E1.E()A! <*! &..#5'-,'&1*! 10!

'2&5!,99-1,82!&5!521S*!&*!/&7#-(!=RA!

Page 112: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! FF!

!

!

X)A85'!*Tc!&#'!#'5@'2'81)9!0'/52)2A!([)5/0!^J03@/2D!,USN_!)2!^G/A);A0;8D!*+++_!

B2(!9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7! 5',7(5! -(.,'(! '1! '2(!9-&1-! K*1S.()7(!10! '2(! ,#'21-! '2,'!

01-%5! '2(! $,5&5! 01-! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! #*)(-5',*)&*7! '2,'! &5! *(()()! '1!

)(E(.19! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! %('21)1.17:A! B2&5! #*)(-5',*)&*7;! &*!

'#-*;!&5!'2(!$,5&5!01-!'2(!9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!01-!'2(!*(`'!5',7(!10!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!

,*)!51!1*A! V'!9-1E&)(5!,!9-17-(55&E(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2(!9-18(55!)(E(.19%(*'!

'2-1#72!)&00(-(*'!E&(S91&*'5!,*)!$:!,*!&'(-,'&E(!9-18(55!10!.11K&*7!'1!'2(!S21.(!

,*)! &'5! 9,-'5! IC,#%,*;! ?FMDJA! V'! &5! '2(-(01-(! 81*5&)(-()! ,99-19-&,'(! 01-! '2&5!

-(5(,-82A!

B2&5! -(5(,-82!S,5!9.,8()!S&'2&*! ,! .,-7(-! -(5(,-82!9-1^(8';! .11K&*7! ,'! c6(8&5&1*!

T,K&*7! "#991-'L! S&'2&*! '2(! [(,.'2! ,*)! Q,-(! V*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 3(5(,-82! ,*)!

V**1E,'&1*! Q(*'-(! I[,QV3VQJ! S2(-(! ,*! ,8'&1*! -(5(,-82!%1)(! S,5! ,)19'()A! V*!

'2,'!81*'(`'!'2(!%,&*!%(82,*&5%!01-!%1E&*7!0-1%!,!9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!5','(!&*'1!

,*! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 1*(! S,5! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! &*! %(('&*75;!

S1-K52195!,*)!7(*(-,.!)&58#55&1*!S&'2!'2(!9,-'&8&9,*'5!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5A!B2(!

,#'21-L5!.(,-*&*7!,*)!#*)(-5',*)&*7!S,5!#5()!'1!&*01-%!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!

C(3(,.! 9-18(55! ,5! &'! &5! )(58-&$()! &*! 82,9'(-! 01#-! ,*)! 0&E(;! '2(-(! S,5! ,.51!

81..(8'&E(!.(,-*&*7!01-!,..!9,-'&8&9,*'5!0,8&.&','()!$:!'2(!,#'21-L5!&*'(-E(*'&1*5!&*!

'2(!,8'&1*!-(5(,-82!8,5(!5'#)&(5A!

!"#$%&'("#)"*+,+

-%$+.+!"#$%&'("#)"*+,+

!"#$%&'("#)"*+/+

-%$+0+!"#$%&'("#)"*+/+

-%$+.!"#$%&'("#)"*+"1$'23+

Page 113: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>>!

-$P &#'!5'('/59#!(15/1'AB!

B2(! -(5(,-82! 5'-,'(7:! &5! '2(!%('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! '2,'! &5! )(E(.19()! ,*)!

#5()!$:!'2(!-(5(,-82(-!&*!(%$1):&*7!,!9,-'&8#.,-!5':.(!,*)!(%9.1:&*7!)&00(-(*'!

-(5(,-82!%('21)5A!B2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7:!&5!)(9(*)(*'!#91*!

Ig&*;!=>>@JW!

• B2(!':9(!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*!915()!,*)!'2(!*,'#-(!10!'2(!(*4#&-:q!

• B2(!(`'(*'!10!81*'-1.!'2(!-(5(,-82(-!&'!2,5!1E(-!,8'#,.!$(2,E&1#-,.!(E(*'5q!

• B2(!)(7-((!10!018#5!1*!81*'(%91-,-:!(E(*'5A!

6&00(-(*'! &55#(5! 2,E(! $((*! 81*5&)(-()! &*! )('(-%&*&*7! '2(! %15'! ,99-19-&,'(!

5'-,'(7:!'1!5,'&50:!'2(!-(5(,-82!,&%5!,*)!1$^(8'&E(5;!,5!01..1S5W!

• B2(!':9(5!10!(E&)(*8(!,*)!),',!I,*)!'2(&-!51#-8(5J!'2,'!*(()5!$(!81..(8'()!'1!

)(E(.19!'2(!9-18(55q!

• B2(!*,'#-(!10!'2(!),',!-(4#&-()!%1E&*7!0-1%!,!'2(1-('&8,.!,55#%9'&1*!&*'1!,!

9-,8'&8,$.(!%('21)1.17:q!

• B2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-18(55! I,-'(0,8'J! '2,'! S&..! 2,E(! '2(1-('&8,.!

81*'-&$#'&1*!,5!S(..!,5!7&E&*7!,*5S(-5!'1!,!9-,8'&8,.!-(.(E,*'!9-1$.(%q!

• B2(!,8'&1*!-(5(,-82! 0-,%(S1-K! '2,'! '2(! .,-7(-![,QV3VQ!9-1^(8'!2,)!,.-(,):!

,)19'()q!

• B2(!'&%(!'2,'!S,5!*(()()!'1!)(E(.19!'2(!9-18(55!,*)!E,.&),'(!&'5!&%9,8';!&A(A!,!

51-'(-! 9(-&1)! 10! '&%(! S,5! ,E,&.,$.(! 01-! '2(! -(5(,-82! I@! :(,-5J! '2,*! '2(!

.&0(8:8.(!10!,!':9&8,.!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(!I?O\=>!:(,-5Jq!

• B2(!,#'21-L5!9(-51*,.!(`9(-&(*8(!,*)!K*1S.()7(A!

B1! ,))-(55! '2(! ,$1E(! &55#(5! 'S1! )&00(-(*'! 5'-,'(7&(5! S(-(! 81%$&*()! ,*)!

)(9.1:()! '1! 01-%! '2(! %('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! 01-! '2&5! -(5(,-82! B2(!

%('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! 5'-,'(7:! 81%$&*(5! ,! I?J! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82!

,99-1,82! $:! b#KK,! I=>>@J! ,*)! d,5,*(*! ('! ,.A! I?FF@Jq! ,*)! I=J! 8,5(! 5'#):!

,99-1,82! Ig&*;! =>>@JA! B2(5(! 'S1! ,99-1,82(5! ,-(! )(58-&$()! &*! '2(! 5#$5(4#(*'!

5(8'&1*5;! 01..1S()!$:! '2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! &*!/&7#-(!=D! '2,'!

'2(!-(5(,-82!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5!2,5!$((*!$,5()!1*A!

Page 114: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>?!

-$P$, 4;2(15891)<'!5'('/59#!

B2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! ,99-1,82! 018#5(5! 1*! 9-1)#8&*7! '2(1-:\$,5()!

&**1E,'&E(! 51.#'&1*5! '1! -(.(E,*'! 9-,8'&8,.! 9-1$.(%5;! 5#%%()! '1! 7(*(-,'&1*! 10!

*(S! .(,-*&*7! ,*)! K*1S.()7(;! &*! '2(! 9-18(55! 10! 81*5'-#8'&*7! '2(! 51.#'&1*!

Id,5,*(*!('!,.A;!?FF@JA! !B2(!5,%(!,#'21-5!(`9.,&*! '2,'! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! &5!

#5()!S2(*!'2(!-(5(,-82(-!&5!5((K&*7!51.#'&1*5!'1!8.(,-.:!)(0&*()!9-1$.(%5A!"#82!

,*! ,99-1,82! &5! -(81%%(*)()! S2(*! .11K&*7! &*'1! 9-1$.(%! 51.E&*7;! &**1E,'&1*;!

)(E(.19&*7! %1)(.5! ,*)! %('21)5! 1-! 9-18(55! ,*)! 9-1)#8'! &%9-1E(%(*'5A! B2(!

(`9(8'()! 1#'81%(5! 01-! ,! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! ,-(W! ,-'(0,8'5! I(A7A! 81*5'-#8'5;!

%1)(.5!,*)!%('21)5J;!$(''(-!'2(1-&(5;!&%9-1E(%(*'5!,*)!'(82*1.17&8,.!-#.(5A!!

Q1*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!,55&5'5!&*!51.E&*7!'2(!,99.&8,'&1*!,*)!-(.(E,*8(!9-1$.(%5!

'2,'!2,99(*!&*!)&58&9.&*(5!81*8(-*()!S&'2!9-1$.(%!51.E&*7!5#82!,5!%,*,7(%(*';!

%()&8&*(;!,*)! &*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:!I[(*-&82;!=>>F;!3182,;!=>??JA!<5!,-7#()!

$:! X,*! <K(*! I=>>NJ! &*! '2(5(! )&58&9.&*(5! &'! &5! *1'! 5#00&8&(*'! '1! )(58-&$(! ,*)!

#*)(-5',*)! '2(! 9-1$.(%;! &'! &5! ,.51! *(8(55,-:! '1! ,8'#,..:! )(E(.19! ,*)! '(5'!

51.#'&1*5A!!

B2(!*(()!01-!'2&5!-(5(,-82!,5!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!1*(!S,5!$1-*!1#'!9-1E&)&*7!

,*5S(-5! '1! $1'2! '2(! ,8,)(%&8! ,*)! 9-,8'&8,.! S1-.)A! b#KK,! I=>>@J! ,-7#(5! '2,'!

9(19.(!#5#,..:!,5KW!S2,'!)1!S(!-(,..:!7('!01-%!,..!'2(5(!,8,)(%&8!,*,.:5(5t!B2(!

81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! ,99-1,82! &5! '2(! 1*(! '2,'! 7&E(5! (%92,5&5! '1! ,! 'S1\S,:!

81%%#*&8,'&1*!,*)!81%$&*(5! &*!5'-#8'#-()!S,:!$1'2!'2(1-('&8,.!,*)!(%9&-&8,.!

(E&)(*8(! ,*)! ,5! 5#82! &5! &*2(-(*'.:! *,--1S&*7! '2(! 7,9! $('S((*! 9-,8'&8(! ,*)!

-(5(,-82!Ib#KK,;!=>>@JA!!

B2(!81%%1*!5'(95! &*!)&00(-(*'!5(4#(*8(5!10!81*5'-#8'&1*!-(5(,-82!Id,5,*(*!('!

,.A;!?FF@;!b#KK,;!=>>@;!X,&52*,E&!,*)!d#(82.(-;!=>>MJ!,5! &*E(5'&7,'()!$:!3182,!

I=>??J!8,*!$(!7-1#9()! &*W! I,J!51.#'&1*!)(E(.19%(*'q! I$J! &'5!(E,.#,'&1*q!,*)!I8J!

'2(! 0,8'! '2,'! '2(! -(5(,-82!9-18(55! &5! *1'! .&*(,-! $#'! &'! &*E1.E(5! .1195A! X,&52*,E&!

,*)! d#(82.(-! I=>>MJ! )(0&*(! '215(! .1195! ,5! .&%&','&1*5;! '2,'! 8,*! 2,99(*! ,'! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! 5'(95! ,*)! .(,)! '1! -(E&5&1*! 10! '2(! 9-1$.(%!

,S,-(*(55;!8-(,'&*7!,!*(S!8:8.(!10!0#-'2(-!81*5'-#8'&*7!1-!)(E(.19&*7!,!51.#'&1*;!

Page 115: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>=!

#*)(-! ,! *(S!#*)(-5',*)&*7! 01..1S&*7! '2(!2(-%(*(#'&8! 59&-,.! 9-(5(*'()! &*! @A@A!

B2(:!71!1*!'1!)(0&*(!'2(!5(4#(*8(!10!'2(!9-18(55!5'(95!'2,'!*(()!'1!$(!',K(*!,5W!

+-1$.(%!,S,-(*(55!"!"#77(5'&1*!10!,!51.#'&1*!"!6(E(.19%(*'!"!HE,.#,'&1*"!

Q1*8.#5&1*A!

B2(! ,#'21-! &*! '2&5! -(5(,-82! 9#-5#(5! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,! -1$#5'! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55;!S2(-(!,5!)(0&*()!&*!81*5'-#8'&1*!-(5(,-82!'(-%5!'2,'!9-18(55!

S&..!$(!'2(!%,&*!,-'(0,8'!81*5'-#8'()A!d,5,*(*!('!,.A!I?FF@J!5#77(5'!'2,'!,!711)!

4#,.&':!,-'(0,8'!2,5!'1!2,E(!'2(!01..1S&*7!82,-,8'(-&5'&85W!I,J!9-,8'&8,.!-(.(E,*8(q!

I$J!#5(0#.*(55q!I8J!&*01-%()!$:!'2(1-:q!I)J!'2(1-('&8,.!*1E(.':q!I(J!,99.&8,$.(!&*!

1'2(-! (*E&-1*%(*'5A! V*! %1-(! -(8(*'! 5'#)&(5! X,&52*,E&! ,*)! d#(82.(-! I=>>NJ!

$,5()! 1*! d,5,*(*! I?FF@J! ,*)! b#KK,! I=>>@J! -(81%%(*)! '2(! 01..1S&*7!

%('21)1.17:!10!81*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!S2(*!018#5&*7!&*!)(E(.19&*7!,*!,-'(0,8'!,5!

9-(5(*'()!&*!/&7#-(!=MA!

!

X)A85'!*Oc!4;2(15891)<'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!70;R9#/51!^/3/[1'3!75;@!Z/)(#2/<)!/23!G8'9#0'5D!

*++P_!

!"#$%&'("#)

)*+",%-.)/01+-#-'')

*+"2"'-3)4"%&5("#)

6-7-%"2.-#5)

871%&15("#)92-+15("#1%)1#3):

"1%);#"0%-3<-)

!(+$&.'$+(25("#

)

!"#$%&'(&)*%#$+) ,-#.&++)/0&1+) 230130+)

*+"2"'1%))))))

4"%&5("#)5"),-)5-'5-3)

/+5-=1$5)

*-+="+.1#$-)>-1'&+-')

?-'&%5')

Page 116: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>@!

[(*-&82!I=>>FJ!,*)!3182,!I=>??J!)(58-&$(!'2(!9-18(55!5'(95!,5W!

• +-1$.(%! ,S,-(*(55W! V5! ,$1#'! 0&*)&*7! ,! 9-,8'&8,..:! -(.(E,*'! 9-1$.(%;!

S2&82!,.51!2,5!91'(*'&,.!01-!'2(1-('&8,.!81*'-&$#'&1*A!V*!'2&5!5'(9!'2(-(!&5!

'2(! *(()! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! 9-1$.(%! ,*)! (5',$.&52! 81**(8'&1*! '1! 9-&1-!

'2(1-:q!

• +-1915()!"1.#'&1*W!V)(*'&0:!,*)!9-1915(!9155&$.(!51.#'&1*5!1-!%('21)5!'1!

'2,'! S&..! ,))-(55! '2(! 9-1$.(%! &)(*'&0&()A! <'! '2&5! 5',7(! ,! )-,0'! 10! '2(!

,-'(0,8'!&5!9-(5(*'()!,*)!,!)(0&*&'&1*!10!'2(!%('21)5!'2,'!S&..!$(!#5()!01-!

&'5!)(E(.19%(*'q!

• 6(E(.19%(*'W!6(E(.19!,*)! &%9.(%(*'! '2(! 51.#'&1*! '1! '2(!9-1$.(%A!B2&5!

S2(-(!'2(!51.#'&1*!&5!81*5'-#8'()q!

• HE,.#,'&1*W! B(5'! '2(! 9-1915()! 51.#'&1*! ,*)! 81..(8'! ),',! '1! (E,.#,'(! &'5!

9-,8'&8,.!0#*8'&1*&*7A!B2(!,-'(0,8'L5!9(-01-%,*8(!&5!%(,5#-()q!

• Q1*8.#5&1*W!<55(55!'2(!,-'(0,8'5!9-,8'&8,.!,*)!'2(1-('&8,.!81*'-&$#'&1*!,*)!

9-(5(*'! 0&*,.! -(5#.'5A! <'! '2&5! 5',7(! '2(! '2(1-('&8,.! 81**(8'&1*5! ,*)! '2(!

81*'-&$#'&1*! 1-! '2(! K*1S.()7(! &*! '2(! 51.#'&1*! 10! '2(! 9-1$.(%! &5!

81*8.#)()A!!

-$P$* I91);2!5'('/59#!

[,QV3VQ! ,)19'()! ,*! ,8'&1*! -(5(,-82! %1)(! &*! '2(! S&)(-! -(5(,-82! 9-1^(8'! '2,'!

,&%()! '1! )(E(.19! '11.5! ,*)! %('21)5! '1! 0,8&.&','(! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7! &*! '2(!

2(,.'28,-(! 5(8'1-A! B2(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! &*! '2(! [,QV3VQ! ,8'&E&'&(5!

(*,$.()! '2(!,#'21-! '1!1$5(-E(;! -(81-)!,*)!',K(!9,-'! &*! &)(*'&0:&*7! '2(!9-1$.(%!

,*)!,.51!(*,$.(!'2(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2(!&55#(5!&*E1.E()A!!

B2(!,8'&1*!-(5(,-82!S,5!IQ12(*!,*)!T,*&1*;!?FFNJW!

• Q1..,$1-,'&E(W! &'! &*E1.E()! '2(! $-&*7&*7! '17('2(-! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! ,*)! 1'2(-!

-(5(,-82(-5! ,*)! 9-,8'&'&1*(-5! 9,-'&8&9,'&*7! &*! $1'2! '2(! [,QV3VQ! ,*)! '2(!

C(3(,.!9-1^(8'q!

• +,-'&8&9,'1-:W!B2(!,#'21-!S,5!',K&*7!9,-'!&*!,..!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!S,5!)&-(8'.:!1-!

&*)&-(8'.:!)(0&*&*7!,*)!&%9.(%(*'&*7!'2(!-(5(,-82q!

Page 117: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>N!

• HE,.#,'&E(W! <55#%9'&1*5;! 0&*)&*75! ,*)! %1)&0&8,'&1*5! S(-(! 81*'&*#1#5.:!

(E,.#,'()! S&'2&*! '2(! (*E&-1*%(*'! 10! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5;! S&'2! '2(! #.'&%,'(!

1$^(8'&E(!$(&*7!'1!&%9-1E(!9-,8'&8(!1*(!S,:!1-!,*1'2(-A!

<8'&1*! -(5(,-82! ,..1S5! -(5(,-82(-5! '1! S1-K! ,8'&E(.:! S&'2! &*)#5'-:! 51! '2,'! '2(!

*(()5!10!$1'2!7-1#95!,-(!,))-(55()!'2-1#72!'2(!-(5(,-82q!,*)!&0!*(()()!8,#5(!,!

82,*7(!S&'2&*! ,! 518&,.! 5:5'(%! Ib(S&*;! ?FNRJA! V*! '2&5! -(5(,-82;! ,8'&1*! -(5(,-82!

01..1S5!'2(! c-(7#.,'&E(!8:8.(L!10W!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*;!)&,7*15&5;!9.,*;! &*'(-E(*'&1*!

,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! I"'-&(*;! ?FMOJ! '2-1#72! &*'(-,8'&1*! $('S((*! '2(! -(5(,-82(-! ,*)!

&*)#5'-:A! B2-1#72! '2&5! &*'(-,8'&1*! ,*)! 81*'&*#()! )&581#-5(! $('S((*! '2(! 'S1!

(*'&'&(5;! ,! #5(-! 81%%#*&':! I,)E&51-:! 7-1#9J! 10! C(3(,.! S,5! )(E(.19();! '2&5!

81%%#*&':! 9-1E&)()! )&-(8'&1*! ,*)! ,)E&8(! '1! '2(! -(5(,-82(-;! S2&.5'! '2(!

-(5(,-82(-! 9-1E&)()! &*'(-E(*'&1*5! I-(5(,-82! 1#'81%(5J;! 01-! '2(! 9-1$.(%!

)&,7*15()!$:! '2(!7-1#9!,*)! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(A!B2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!,.51!,8'()!,5!

1*(! 10! '2(! %,&*! E,.&),'&1*! %(82,*&5%5! 01-! '2(! 9-18(55! 81*5'-#8'()! ,*)!

9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5A!

-$N &#'!5'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;A)9/0!75/@'R;5M!

B2(! &*'(7-,'&1*! 10! '2(! 'S1! -(5(,-82! ,99-1,82(5! I81*5'-#8'&E(! ,*)! 8,5(! 5'#):J!

S&'2! '2(! -(5(,-82! 92&.15192:! )(58-&$()! &*! '2(! 9-(E&1#5! 5(8'&1*5! 9-1E&)(5! '2(!

-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-K!9-(5(*'()!2(-(!I/&7#-(!=DJA!B2(!0-,%(S1-K!

81*5&5'5!10!,8'&E&'&(5!#*)(-',K(*!'2-1#721#'!'2(!-(5(,-82!9-1^(8'!9-17-(55&1*A!

Page 118: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>O!

!

X)A85'!*Sc!:'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;A)9/0!75/@'R;5M!

V*! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! ,*! ,--,:! 10! 4#,.&','&E(! ,*)! 4#,*'&','&E(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)5!8,*!$(!#5()!'1!&*01-%!'2(!K(:!(.(%(*'5!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!

0-,%(S1-KA! B2(! -(5(,-82! %('21)5! 5(.(8'()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! ,-(! (`9.,&*()! ,*)!

-(,51*()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!5#&',$&.&':!01-!'2&5!'2(5&5!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!5(8'&1*A!

-$N$, :'('/59#![5;9'((!(1'[(!/23!@'1#;3(!

<! -(5(,-82!%('21)! &5! ,!S,:! 10! 81..(8'&*7! (E&)(*8(! '2,'! &*)&8,'(5! '2(! '11.5! ,*)!

'(82*&4#(5! #5()! )#-&*7! ),',! 81..(8'&1*! IU,..&(-5;! ?FF=JA! <! E,-&(':! 10! %('21)5!

S(-(! ,)19'()! '1! 81..(8'! ),',! '2,'! &*8.#)();! b&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S5! ,*)! 5:*'2(5&5;!

4#(5'&1**,&-(5;!)18#%(*',-:!,*,.:5&5;!1$5(-E,'&1*5!,*)! &*'(-,8'&E(!S1-K52195A!

B2(5(! ,-(! #5()! '1! )(E(.19;! &%9.(%(*'! ,*)! (E,.#,'(! '2(! C(*(0&'5! 3(,.&5,'&1*!

IC(3(,.J! 9-18(55! 0-1%! %#.'&9.(! 9(-59(8'&E(5A! B2(5(! %('21)5! ,-(! 0#-'2(-!

(`9.,&*()! &*! '2(! 01..1S&*7! 5(8'&1*5! ,5! '2(:! ,-(! 915&'&1*()!S&'2&*! '2(! -(5(,-82!

!"#$%&'("#)

*+",%-.)/01+-#-'')2)

3#4-+'51#4(#6)))

*+"7"'-4)8"%&5("#)

9-:-%"7.-#5)

;:1%&15("#)

<7-+15("#1%)1#4)="1%)>#"0%-46-)

!(+$&.

'$+(75("#)

!"#$%&'(&)*%#$+) ,-#.&++)/0&1+) 2"3#-45"()6.057508)

•  ?(5-+15&+-)@-:(-0)•  /4:('"+A))=+"&7)B"+>'C"7)•  D1!E@E!)*"+5F"%(")

•  ?(5-+15&+-)@-:(-0)8A#5C-'(')•  /4:('"+A)=+"&7)B"+>'C"7)•  @-'-1+$C)G-5C"4"%"6A)

H'5)*+"7"'-4)7+"$-'')

E.7%-.-#515("#)1#4)I1%(415("#)•  !1'-)85&4(-')J!8HK)!8LK)!8MN)•  /4:('"+A)=+"&7)0"+>'C"7')•  9151)!"%%-$5("#)1#4)1#1%A'(')•  O+(1#6&%15("#))

9-51(%-4)*+"$-'')*+"5"5A7-)

•  /4:('"+A)=+"&7)B"+>'C"7)P)•  9(''-.(#15("#)•  /''-'')Q(#1%)$"#5+(,&5("#')

Q,5(!"'#):!?!+2,5(5!?;=!r!N!

[(-%(*(#'&8!"9&-,.!!

b&'(-,'#-(!3(E&(S!+-18(55!

Page 119: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>R!

%('21)1.17&8,.! 0-,%(S1-K! '1! (*,$.(! '2(! ,#'21-! '1! &*E(5'&7,'(! &*'1! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,*! (00(8'&E(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! 01-! Pd! 2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A! B2(! -(5(,-82! 0-,%(S1-K! 9-18(55! 5'(95! ,*)! '2(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)5! ,-(! &*'(-81**(8'()! S&'2! '2(! c5'&O3#0&'().#0$#A! [! "#0&'().#0$#A>!

2(-%(*(#'&8!59&-,.!'2,'!0,8&.&','(5!'2(!7(*(-,'&1*!,*)!0.1S!10!K*1S.()7(!7#&)&*7!

'2(!,#'21-!'1!,!9-1)#8'&E(!8:8.(!&*!-(,82&*7!2&5!,*)!'2&5!'2(5&5!81*8.#5&1*5A!

-$N$,$, :'('/59#![5;9'((!(1'[!,!L!"5;H0'@!/R/5'2'((!!

<'!'2&5!&*&'&,.!5',7(!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!'2(!,#'21-!5((K5!'1!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!(.(%(*'5!

10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! -(,.&5,'&1*;! '2(&-! &*'(-,8'&1*! S&'2! 1'2(-!

%,*,7(%(*'! )&58&9.&*(5! ,*)! 81*'(`'#,.&5(! '2&5! K*1S.()7(! &*! ,! 2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'! 5(''&*7A! /1-! ,82&(E&*7! '2,'! '2(! ,#'21-! )(9.1:5! '2(!

81..(8'&1*!10!5(81*),-:!),',!&*&'&,..:!'2-1#72!,!0)1'5/185'!5'<)'RA!

B2(!,&%!10!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S5!S,5!'1W!

• +-1E&)(! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2! ,! 7-(,'(-! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! ,-(,!

#*)(-!&*E(5'&7,'&1*q!

• H*,$.(!'2(!,#'21-!'1!$#&.)!1*!,*)!#5(!'2(!S1-K!,*)!(`9(-&(*8(5!10!$1'2!

,8,)(%&8!,*)!9-,8'&'&1*(-5q!

• 6(%1*5'-,'(!'2(!*(()!01-!'2(!-(5(,-82!$:!&)(*'&0:&*7!7,95!&*!K*1S.()7(!

,E,&.,$.(!&*!'2(!9#$.&8!)1%,&*q!

• 6(%1*5'-,'(!'2,'!'2(!,#'21-L5!9-1915()!9-18(55!,*)!%('21)5!S(-(!$,5()!

1*!&*81-91-,'&*7!,*)!71!$(:1*)!c$(5'!9-,8'&8(L!&*!'2(!-(5(,-82!,-(,A!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!018#5()!1*!'2(!01..1S&*7!%,&*!,-(,5W!

I,J! C(*(0&'5!'(-%&*1.17:!,*)!21S!$(*(0&'5!,-(!8.,55&0&()q!

I$J! C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2(1-('&8,.!$,8K7-1#*)q!

I8J! <!2&5'1-&8,.!.&*(!10!5(E(-,.!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,99-1,82(5q!

I)J! B2(! %,&*! (.(%(*'5! *(()! '1! $(! 81*5&)(-()! S2(*! #*)(-',K&*7! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!,5!,*!1#'9#'!10!'2(!-(E&(S()!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,99-1,82(5q!

Page 120: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>M!

I(J! B:9(5!10!(E,.#,'&1*!01-!,!9-17-,%%(!,*)a1-!9-1^(8'q!

I0J! 3(.,'&1*5! 10! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! S&'2! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'!

T,*,7(%(*';! 82,*7(! %,*,7(%(*';! 9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

%(,5#-(%(*';! ,*)! 0&*,..:! '2(! -1.(! ,*)! &%91-',*8(! 10! 5',K(21.)(-! &*E1.E(%(*'!

,*)!%,*,7(%(*'A!

<!0#-'2(-!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!,*)!)&58#55&1*5!S&'2!&*)#5'-:!,*)!,8,)(%&8!(`9(-'5!

S,5! 81*)#8'()! ,&%&*7! '1! 7,&*! ,!$(''(-! ,S,-(*(55!10! '2(! -(5(,-82!*(()!,*)! &'5!

9-,8'&8,.&'&(5;!,5!'2(!,#'21-!S,5!5((K&*7!,*5S(-5!'1!'2(!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*!915()!

,'!'2(!$(7&**&*7!10!'2&5!'2(5&5!&*!5(8'&1*!?ANA!

B2(!,))&'&1*,.!'19&85!(`9.1-()!S(-(W!

I7J!B(82*&4#(5!'2,'!(%$-,8(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2&*K&*7q!

I2J!cC(5'!9-,8'&8(L!&*7-()&(*'5!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55q!

I&J! V*E(5'%(*'!%1)(.5!,*)!9-1^(8'!9-17-(55&1*!,99-,&5,.!,99-1,82(5!59(8&0&8! '1!

Pd![(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'q!

I^J!b(E(.5!10!2(,.'28,-(!)(.&E(-:!5(-E&8(5!&*!'2(!PdA!

B2(! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! I,J! '1! I^J! ,-(!)(',&.()! &*! 82,9'(-! 'S1! ,*)!<99(*)&`! VA! B2(5(!

0&*)&*75! S(-(! (*.&72'(*&*7! &*! 01-%&*7! '2(;! 5#77(5'&1*! 10! '2(! 51.#'&1*;!

)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!(E,.#,'&1*!5',7(5!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-KA!!

-$N$,$* :'('/59#![5;9'((!(1'[!*!L!=8AA'(1);2!;7!/!(;081);2!

"+-&1-! '1! '2(! 0&-5'! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! 81*5'-#8'&1*;! ),',! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S!S,5!7-1#9()!$:!5&%&.,-&':;!-(5#.'&*7!&*!,!%,'-&`!'2,'!9-(5(*'()!)&00(-(*'!

,59(8'5!%(*'&1*()!$:!(,82!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,99-1,82A!B2&5!9-18(55!,..1S()!

'2(!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!'2(!%,^1-!01#*),'&1*5;!&*!S2&82!'2(!&55#(5!01-!81*5'-#8'&*7!,!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! S(-(! $,5()A! B2(! #5(! 10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9!

R;5M(#;[(;! '2(! 9.,8(%(*'! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2&*! [,QV3VQ! ,*)! '2(! ,#'21-L5!

9(-51*,.! K*1S.()7(! ,*)! (`9(-&(*8(! 9-1E&)()! '2(! 51#-8(5! 10! '2(! 9-&%,-:! ),',!

'2,'! S,5! 5:*'2(5&5()! S&'2! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,5! )(58-&$()!

Page 121: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>D!

,$1E(A! <5! ,! -(5#.'! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! IC(3(,.J! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! &5!

&*'-1)#8()!&*!82,9'(-!NA!"

-$N$,$- :'('/59#![5;9'((!(1'[!-!/23!P!L!%'<'0;[@'21!/23!'</08/1);2!

<5! (`9.,&*()! (,-.&(-! '2(! 5(81*)! 5'-,'(7:! '1! $(! &*'(7-,'()! &*! '2(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)1.17:! 0-,%(S1-K! &5! 9/('! (183B! -(5(,-82A! B2(! ,&%! 10! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! &5! '1!

-(,82! ,! 0#*),%(*',.! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! 5'-#8'#-(;! 9-18(55! ,*)! 9(19.(!

IU#%%(51*;! =>>>JA! B2(! 8,5(! 5'#):! ,99-1,82! S1#.)! &*01-%! '2(! )(E(.19%(*';!

(E,.#,'&1*! ,*)! 81*8.#5&1*! 92,5(5! 10! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! 5(4#(*8(A! ! B2(!

,#'21-!2,5!,)19'()!,!%#.'&!8,5(!5'#):!,99-1,82!'1!0#-'2(-!81*5'-#8'!,*)!'(5'!'2(!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!#*)(-!)(E(.19%(*'A!

T#.'&9.(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,..1S! '2(! ,*,.:5&5! 10! ),',! ,8-155! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5;!S2&82! &*!

'#-*! (*,$.(! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! 81*'(`'! 59(8&0&8! 81*5'-,&*'5! &*! '2(!

&%9.(%(*','&1*! 9-18(55! ,*)! 1#'81%(5! I[(--&1'! ,*)! /&-(5'1*(;! ?FD@JA!T#.'&9.(!

8,5(5;!,)(4#,'(.:!5,%9.();!9-1E&)(!#*)(-5',*)&*7!,*)!(`9.,*,'&1*;!,5!'2(:!2(.9!

91&*'!1#'!59(8&0&8! 81*)&'&1*5!#*)(-!S2&82!,! 0&*)&*7!S&..!188#-;!,*)!,.51!2(.9! '1!

01-%!%1-(! 7(*(-,.! 8,'(71-&(5! 10! 21S! '2(5(! 81*)&'&1*5!%,:! $(! -(.,'()A! V*! '2&5!

S,:;! ,! %#.'&9.(! 8,5(! )(5&7*! ,..1S5! 01-! ,! -(9.&8,'&1*! .17&8;! &*! S2&82! (,82! 8,5(!

5'#):!5(-E(5!'1!81*0&-%!1-!)&581*0&-%!&*0(-(*8(5!)-,S*!0-1%!9-(E&1#5!1*(5!Ig&*;!

=>>@JA!

B2(!*#%$(-!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!'2,'!,-(!*(()()!01-!,!%#.'&!8,5(!5'#):!,99-1,82!

,-(!*1'!)(0&*()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(A!H&5(*2,-)'! I?FDFJ! -(81%%(*)5! '2,'!,*:'2&*7!

$('S((*!N!,*)!?>!8,5(!5'#)&(5!*(()!'1!$(!5'#)&()!01-!'2(!-(5#.'5!'1!2,E(!E,.&)&':A!

[1S(E(-! 6:(-! ('! ,.A! I?FF?J! 5#77(5'5! '2,'! '2(! )(8&5&1*! 1*! '2(! *#%$(-! 10! 8,5(!

5'#)&(5! 521#.)! $(! %,)(! $:! '2(! -(5(,-82(-! ,*)! &5! )(9(*)(*'! 1*! S2,'! *(S!

&*01-%,'&1*!8,*!-(5#.'! 0-1%!5'#):&*7!%1-(!8,5(5A!B2(!-(,51*5! 01-!5(.(8'&*7! '2(!

8,5(!5'#)&(5!,-(!)(58-&$()!&*!)(',&.!1*!Q2,9'(-!NA!!

_&'2&*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! '2(! 01..1S&*7! -(5(,-82! %('21)5! ,-(! )(9.1:()W! I?J!

S1-K52195q!I=J!)18#%(*',-:!,*,.:5&5q! I@J! &*01-%,.! &*'(-E&(S5!,*)!)&58#55&1*5q!

,*)!INJ!4#(5'&1**,&-(5A!

Page 122: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?>F!

-$N$,$P :'('/59#!@'1#;3!^,_!L!V;5M(#;[(!

T15'! 10! '2(! ),',! 81..(8'()! &*! '2(! -(5(,-82! S,5! '2-1#72! S1-K52195! S&'2!

5',K(21.)(-5A!

B2(!S1-K52195!8,--&()!1#'!&*!-(5(,-82!S(-(!10!'S1!':9(5W!

?A 6,',!7,'2(-&*7!,*)!9-18(55!)(E(.19%(*'!,5!9,-'!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!

B2(5(!&*8.#)()!S1-K52195!,8-155!,..!8,5(!5'#)&(5!'2,'!S(-(!#5()!01-!C(*(0&'5!

H.&8&','&1*;!C(*(0&'5!Q.,55&0&8,'&1*;!+-10&.&*7!,*)!"(7%(*','&1*A!V*!8,5(!5'#):!@!

S1-K52195! S(-(! ,.51! 8,--&()! 1#'! 01-! '2(! G9'&1*((-&*7! 92,5(A! B2(5(!

S1-K52195!,-(!0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!&*!82,9'(-!01#-!S(-(!'2(!0#..!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,-(!

9-(5(*'()!,*)!,*,.:5()A!!

!

=A <)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195W!

B2(5(! S1-K52195! S(-(! &*&'&,..:! 9,-'! 10! '2(! ,8'&1*! -(5(,-82! %1)(! &*! '2(!

[,QV3VQ!-(5(,-82!9-1^(8'A!B2(!S1-K52195!(E1.E()!&*'1!018#5&*7!51.(.:!1*!'2(!

C(3(,.! 81*5'-#8'&1*! ,*)! S2(-(! 8(*'-,.! '1! 0-#&'0#.! 9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7! ,*)!

#*)(-5',*)&*7! 9-17-(55&1*A! B2(! ,#'21-! #5()! '2(5(! S1-K52195! 01-!

9-(5(*','&1*! 10! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):! 0&*)&*75;! 9-18(55! ,55(55%(*';! E,.&),'&1*! ,*)!

01-%#.,'&1*! 10! ,! )(',&.()! 9.,*! 10! *(`'! 5'(95! ,5! '2(:! S(-(! &)(*'&0&()! &*! '2(!

-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-KA!

-$N$,$N :'('/59#!@'1#;3!^*_!L!%;98@'21/5B!/2/0B()(!

g&*! I=>>@J! 5#77(5'5! '2,'! )18#%(*',-:! &*01-%,'&1*! &5! .&K(.:! '1! $(! &%91-',*'! &*!

,*:! 8,5(! 5'#):A! 618#%(*'5! ,-(! 9-&%,-&.:! #5()! '1! &)(*'&0:! *(S! (E&)(*8(! ,*)!

,#7%(*'! (E&)(*8(! 0-1%! 1'2(-! 51#-8(5;! '2#5! 9-1E&)&*7! *(S! &*5&72'5A! B2(!%,&*!

,)E,*',7(5!10!#5&*7!)18#%(*','&1*!,5!,!51#-8(!10!(E&)(*8(!-(.&(5!1*!'2(!0,8'!'2,'!

&'! &5! 5',$.(;! &A(A! &'! 8,*! $(! -(E&(S()! -(9(,'().:;! &'! &5! #*1$'-#5&E(! ,*)! *1-%,..:!

9-1E&)(5! ,! $-1,)! 81E(-,7(;! &A(A! ,! .1*7! 59,*! 10! '&%(;! (E(*'5! ,*)! 5(''&*75! Ig&*;!

=>>@JA!

V*!'2&5!-(5(,-82;!)18#%(*'5!S(-(!#5()!%,&*.:!'1!9-1E&)(!59(8&0&8!)(',&.5!1*!'2(!

&*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 9-18(55! #5()! $:! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! &*E1.E()! &*! '2(! 8,5(!

Page 123: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??>!

5'#)&(5A! 618#%(*'5! ,.51! 9-1E&)()! 81%9.(%(*',-:! &*01-%,'&1*! 1*! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 5'-#8'#-(! ,*)! 81%%1*! 9-,8'&8(5! 1*! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'!

,*)!%,*,7(%(*'A!618#%(*'5!10!)&E(-5(!':9(5!2,E(!$((*!81..(8'()!,*)!,*,.:5();!

&*8.#)&*7!S-&''(*!-(91-'5;!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!,99-,&5,.!7#&)(5;!$#5&*(55!8,5(5!,'!'2(&-!

E,-&1#5! .(E(.5!10!9-17-(55&1*;! &A(A!"'-,'(7&8!G#'.&*(!Q,5(!I"GQJ;!G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!

Q,5(!IGCQJ!,*)!/#..!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!I/CQJ;!,5!S(..!,5!9#$.&52()!&*01-%,'&1*!,$1#'!

'2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! 1*! '2(! V*'(-*('A! B2(! 59(8&0&8! )18#%(*','&1*! ,*,.:5()!S&'2&*!

(,82!8,5(!&5!)(58-&$()!&*!Q2,9'(-!NA!

-$N$,$T :'('/59#!@'1#;3!^-_!L!621'5<)'R(!

=#)&'%$&@$#A!&5!'2(!%15'!5&7*&0&8,*'!4#,.&','&E(!'(82*&4#(!'2,'!8,*!$(!#5()!S&'2&*!

,! 8,5(! 5'#):! '1! 1$',&*! &*01-%,'&1*! 0-1%!,! 5%,..! 5,%9.(! IH,5'(-$:\"%&'2! ('! ,.A;!

=>>=;!g&*;!=>>@JA!/1-! '2(! '2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!9-(5(*'()! &*! '2&5! '2(5&5! '2(!,#'21-!

#5()! &*01-%,.! &*'(-E&(S5! '1! 81..(8'! 4#,.&','&E(! ),',! I5((! <99(*)&`! VVA?NJA!

V*01-%,.!&*'(-E&(S5!2,E(!51%(!9-()('(-%&*()!4#(5'&1*5;!$#'!'2(5(!,-(!#5()!1*.:!

,5! ,! 7#&)(;! '2(! -(5(,-82(-! &5! ,$.(! '1! 82,*7(! '2(5(! ,*)! (`9.1-(! 0#-'2(-! &*'1! ,*!

,*5S(-;! )(9(*),*'! 1*! '2(! -(591*5(! ,*)! 21S! '2(! -(5(,-82(-! &*'(-9-('5! '2(!

81*E(-5,'&1*!I31$51*;!=>>@q!T,:;!?FF@JA!

-$N$,$O :'('/59#!@'1#;3!^P_!L!b8'(1);22/)5'(!

<! *#%$(-! 10! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5! S(-(! #5()! '1! 7,'2(-! ),',! &*! -(7,-)5! '1! ,! +15'!

G88#9,*8:!HE,.#,'&1*!I+GHJ!&*!8,5(!5'#):!?A!B2(!,#'21-!#5()!'2(!),',!81..(8'()!

0-1%! '2&5! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! '1! &)(*'&0:! .&*K5! $('S((*! '2(! +GH! 1#'81%(5! ,*)! '2(!

)(7-((!'1!S2&82!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&()!2,E(!$((*!-(,.&5()A!!

f#(5'&1**,&-(5!,-(!'11.5!#5()!'1!81..(8'!4#,*'&','&E(!),',;!'2(:!7,'2(-!*#%(-&8,.!

),',! '2-1#72! S2&82! 9,''(-*5! ,*)! 8,#5,.! -(.,'&1*52&95! ,-(! )&581E(-();! '2(!

0&*)&*75!,-(!5((*!'1!2,E(!2&72!-(.&,$&.&':A!f#(5'&1**,&-(5!,-(!,!711)!S,:!'1!7,&*!

,*! &*5&72'! &*'1! c82,-,8'(-&5'&85;! ,''&'#)(5;! ,*)!$(.&(05L!10!%,*:!9(19.(! IT,-52,..!

,*)! 3155%,*;! ?FFFJA! V*! '2&5! 8,5(! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5! S(-(! #5()! '1! 7,'2(-! ,*!

&*5&72'! ,*)! ,55(55! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 7-1#95L! E&(S5! ,*)! 9(-8(9'&1*5! 10! '2(! 5(-E&8(5;!

0,8&.&'&(5!,*)!1E(-,..!(00(8'5!10!'2(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&*E(5'&7,'()!&*!8,5(!5'#):!?!I5((!

Page 124: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ???!

<99(*)&`!VVA?JA!B2(!4#(5'&1*5!,))-(55()!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&()!'2-1#72!S1-K5219!,5!

(`9.,&*()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!5(8'&1*A!B2(!<P6H!I<5518&,'&1*!10!P*&E(-5&':!6&-(8'1-5!

10!H5','(5J!,*)!Q<CH!IQ1%%&55&1*!01-!<-82&'(8'#-(!,*)!'2(!C#&.'!H*E&-1*%(*'J!

$(5'!9-,8'&8(!7#&),*8(!2,5!$((*!#5()! 01-!)(E(.19&*7!,*!(00(8'&E(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!

&*E1.E()! &*! +15'! G88#9,*8:! HE,.#,'&1*A!_&'2&*! '2(! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(! 7#&),*8(! ,-(!

-(81%%(*),'&1*5!10!'2(!K&*)!10!4#(5'&1*5!'2,'!521#.)!$(!#5()!S2(*!,))-(55&*7!

8.&(*'! 5,'&50,8'&1*A! !B2&5!S,5! -(.(E,*'! '1! '2(!S1-K!$(&*7!#*)(-',K(*!S&'2&*! '2(!

8,5(!5'#)&(5!,5!,! .,-7(!018#5!10! '2(!5'#)&(5! &5!1*!'2(!(`9(-&(*8(!10! '2(!5',00!,*)!

9,'&(*'5A!B2-1#72!,*,.:5&5!10!'2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!0&*)&*75!,*)!'2(&-!.&*K!'1!$(*(0&'5!

&)(*'&0&()!&'!S,5!9155&$.(!'1!5((!&0!'2(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'!&*!8,5(!5'#):!?!

2,5! )(.&E(-()! '2(5(! $(*(0&'5! &*! '2(! E&(S! 10! '2(! 5',00;! 9,'&(*'5! ,*)! 81%%#*&':A!

/#-'2(-!)(',&.5!1*!'2(!#5(!10!'2&5!%('21)!,-(!9-(5(*'()!&*!5(8'&1*!NA@A?A!

-$N$,$S :'('/59#![5;9'((!(1'[!N!L!4;2908();2!

B2(!81*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!5(4#(*8(!8:8.(!81*8.#)(5!,*)!-(&*&'&,'(5!$:!,*,.:5&*7!

,..!&*9#'5!,*)!1#'9#'5!10!'2(!9-(E&1#5!5',7(5!&*!1-)(-!'1!)('(-%&*(!&0!'2(!-(5(,-82!

,&%5!,*)!1$^(8'&E(5!2,E(!$((*!%('A!V*!)1&*7!51!'2(!,#'21-!&*!'2(!.,5'!82,9'(-5!10!

'2&5!'2(5&5!)&58#55(5!'2(!,-'(0,8'L5!IC(3(,.!9-18(55J!81*'-&$#'&1*5!'1!K*1S.()7(!

,*)!9-,8'&8(;!,-7#(5!1*! &'5!,99.&8,$&.&':;!#5(0#.*(55A!B2(!-(5(,-82!,*)!'2(-(01-(!

'2&5! '2(5&5! &5! 81*8.#)()! S&'2! -(81%%(*),'&1*5! 01-! 0#'#-(! -(5(,-82! *(()();!

81*'-&$#'&1*5! '1! '2(! %('21)1.17:! 01..1S();! ,*)! )&58#55(5! &'5! E,.&)&':! ,*)!

,99.&8,$&.&':A!

-$T Z/0)3)1B!

B2(! -(5(,-82! )(5&7*! 521#.)! $(! 5#00&8&(*'.:! -&71-1#5! '1! 9-1E&)(! 5#991-'! 01-! '2(!

5'#):! '1! $(! $(.&(E,$.(! ,*)! '-#5'S1-'2:! I31$51*;! =>>@JA! B2(-(01-(;! E,.&)&':!

521#.)! $(! 81*5&)(-()! S&'2&*! 92(*1%(*1.17&8,.! -(5(,-82;! (E(*! '21#72! '2(!

8-&'(-&,!01-!(E,.#,'&*7!5#82!&55#(5!S,5!)(E(.19()!01-!915&'&E&5'!-(5(,-82!)(5&7*5!

I3(%(*:&! ('! ,.A;! ?FFDJA! <5! &*'(-9-(','&E(! -(5(,-82! &5! )&00(-(*'! &*! *,'#-(! 0-1%!

915&'&E&5'! ,99-1,82(5;! '2(! 5',*),-)5! #5()! 521#.)! ,.51! $(! )&00(-(*';! ,*)! '2(:!

Page 125: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??=!

#5#,..:!-(0(-!'1!S2('2(-!'2(-(!2,5!$((*!81*5&5'(*8:!,*)!&*'(7-&':!&*!'2(!)(5&7*!10!

'2(!5'#):!I3(%(*:&!('!,.A;!?FFDJA!

/#-'2(-%1-(;!&'! &5!,8K*1S.()7()!'2,'!8,5(!5'#)&(5!8,*!$(!8-&'&8&5()!1*!'2(!$,5&5!

10! .,8K! 10! -&71#-;! &*8.#)&*7! $&,5! Ig&*;! =>>@q! 31$51*;! =>>@J;! $(8,#5(! '2(! ),',!

7,'2(-()!&5!%15'.:!$,5()!1*!'2(!9(-8(9'&1*5!,*)!5#$^(8'&E(!&*'(-9-(','&1*5!10!'2(!

-(5(,-82(-A! B2&5! $&,5! 8,*! $(! -()#8()! $:! ,! 9-18(55! 10! ),',! '-&,*7#.,'&1*! S(-(!

%#.'&9.(!9(-59(8'&E(5!10!'2(!5,%(!92(*1%(*1*!,-(!9-1E&)()!Id,7&17.1#;!?FFFJA!

B-&,*7#.,'&1*!&5!,!%('21)!10!8-155!82(8K&*7!'2(!(`&5'(*8(!10!8(-',&*!92(*1%(*,!

,*)! '2(! E(-,8&':! 10! &*)&E&)#,.! ,881#*'5;! $:! 7,'2(-&*7! ),',! 0-1%! ,! *#%$(-! 10!

&*01-%,*'5!,*)!'2-1#72!,!E,-&(':!10!82,**(.5!Ig&*;!=>>@JA!

B2(! #5(! 10! E,-&(':! 10! -(5(,-82! %('21)5! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! ,&%()! '1! ,82&(E(! '2(!

'-&,*7#.,'&1*!10!),',!,*)!'2(-(01-(!-()#8(!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!$&,5;!,5!5#991-'()!$:!

g&*!I=>>@J!S(-(!'2(!#5(!10!%#.'&9.(!51#-8(5!&*!8,5(!5'#)&(5!&5!-,'()!%1-(!2&72.:!

'2,*!'215(!'2,'!-(.:!1*!5&*7.(!51#-8(!10!),',A!

-$O =8@@/5B!

B2&5! 82,9'(-! 9-(5(*'()! '2(! -(5(,-82! %('21)1.17:! #5()! 01-! '2&5! -(5(,-82A! B2(!

%,&*!1$^(8'&E(!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!&5!'1!)(E(.19!,!-1$#5'!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!

01-! '2(! Pd! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 5(8'1-! ,*)! ,5! 5#82! ,*! &*'(-9-(','&E(!

,99-1,82!&5!',K(*!,5!'2(!(9&5'(%1.17&8,.!19'&1*A!

!B2(! 1E(-,..! -(5(,-82! )&-(8'&1*! S,5! )-&E(*! $:! '2(! c9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7! Z!

#*)(-5',*)&*7L! 2(-%(*(#'&8! 59&-,.! ,5! -(5(,-82! 92&.15192:;! $#&.)&*7! 1*! '2(!

,#'21-L!9(-51*,.!(`9(-&(*8(!,*)!&*'(-,8'&1*!S&'2&*!'2&5!-(5(,-82L5!(*E&-1*%(*'A!!

<!81%$&*,'&1*!10!81*5'-#8'&E(!,*)!8,5(!5'#):!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7&(5!S,5!,)19'()!'1!

&*E(5'&7,'(;! )(E(.19;! 81*5'-#8'! ,*)! '(5'! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55;! S2&82! &*! -(5(,-82!

1#'9#'!'(-%5!&5!'2(!%,&*!,-'(0,8'!)(E(.19()!2(-(A!!

B2(! ,#'21-! )(5&-()! '2,'! '2&5! -(5(,-82! S1#.)! $(! &*01-%()! $:! c-(,.! S1-.)L!

&*'(-,8'&1*5! ,*)! &*'(-E(*'&1*5! ,5! &'! &5! ,.51! -(81%%(*)()! &*! .&'(-,'#-(! S2(*!

,)19'&*7!,!81*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-KA!!

Page 126: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!'2-((!Z!3(5(,-82!%('21)1.17:!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??@!

B2(!#5(!10!5(E(-,.!-(5(,-82!%('21)5!01-!),',!81..(8'&1*!S,5!)(9.1:()!'1!E,.&),'(!

'2(! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5A! V*! )1&*7! 51! '2(! &*'(*'&1*! S,5! 01-! '2(! $&,5!

&*2(-(*'!&*!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-K!'1!$(!-()#8()A!

!

Page 127: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??N!

P 4#/[1'5!7;85!W!&#'!>':'/0![5;9'((!)2<'(1)A/1);2!/23!

3'<'0;[@'21!

B2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 9-(5(*'()! &*! 82,9'(-! =! &..#5'-,'()! '2(! *(()! 01-! ,! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! '2,'! 8,*! $(! ,99.&()!S2(*! 9.,**&*7;! )(E(.19&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-&*7! ,!

2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(A! B2(! ,#'21-! #*)(-'11K! ,! *#%$(-! 10! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,5!

&*E(5'&7,'1-:! ,*)! E,.&),'&1*! %(82,*&5%5! 01-! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55A! 6(',&.5! 10! 21S! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! S,5! 0#-'2(-! &*01-%()!

)(E(.19()!,*)!E,.&),'()!'2-1#72!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195!,*)!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!

,-(!9-(5(*'()!2(-(A!B2(!K(:!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!#5()!&*!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,*)!21S!

'2(5(!S(-(!&%9.(%(*'()!'(5'()!,*)!0#-'2(-!)(E(.19()!&5!,.51!)&58#55()A!

P$, 6215;3891);2!

B2(!,#'21-!#*)(-'11K!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!&*)#5'-:!S2(-(!2(!2,)!

'2(!1991-'#*&':!'1!$(!(`915()!'1!,!*#%$(-!10!&55#(5!.&*K()!'1!9-1^(8'!9-17-(55&1*!

)(8&5&1*5! -(.,'()! '1! 1#'9#'5! ,*)! $(*(0&'5A! B2&5! 82,9'(-! 9-(5(*'5! '2(! -,'&1*,.(! 10!

21S! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! S(-(! 5(.(8'();! ,*! 1E(-E&(S! ,5! S(..! ,5! '2(! %,&*! 0&*)&*75!

01..1S()!$:!.(551*5!.(,-*'A!!

B2(!5(.(8'&1*!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S,5!8-&'&8,.!&*!'2(!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!!

10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!,&%&*7!'1!'(5'!'2(!E,.&)&':!10!'2(!9-18(55!92,5(5A!

V'!S1#.)!2,E(!$((*!)&00&8#.'! '1!#*)(-',K(!1*(!8,5(! 5'#):! '1! '(5'!,*)!E,.&),'(! '2(!

S21.(!9-18(55!7&E(*!'&%(!81*5'-,&*'5;!,5!'2(!S21.(!.&0(8:8.(!10!5#82!9-1^(8'5!59,*5!

0-1%! =>! '1! @>! :(,-5A! B2(-(01-(! '2(! 9-18(55! *(()5! '1! $(! '(5'()! &*! 2(,.'28,-(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '2,'! %,^1-! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-1^(8'5! ,-(! ,8'&E(! ,*)! ,-(! ,'! )&00(-(*'!

5',7(5!10! '2(&-!)(E(.19%(*'A!B2&5! 5(.(8'&1*!8-&'(-&1*!9-1E&)()! '2(!1991-'#*&':! '1!

&*E(5'&7,'(!'2(!,99.&8,$&.&':!10!'2(!9-18(55!&*!&'5!E,-&1#5!92,5(5A!!!V*!5,'&50:&*7!'2&5!

,*)! 01..1S&*7! '2(! ,.&7*%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-1915()! 9-18(55! S&'2! '2(! )1%&*,*'!

&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!,99-1,82(5! '2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S2(-(!5(.(8'()!,5! &..#5'-,'()!

&*!B,$.(!??A!

Page 128: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??O!

!

&/H0'!,,c!4/('!(183)'(!/23!H'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5;9'((![#/('(!

!"5;[;('3!>':'/0![#/('(! 4/('!(183B!,! 4/('!(183B!*! 4/('!(183B!-!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! V! !! ! !

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.(! VV! !! !! !!

[&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!%,9! VV! !! !! !!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! VVV! ! !! !!

C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S5! VX! !! ! !

!! W!T,&*!018#5A!!

B2(!,#'21-!'(5'()!,*)!E,.&),'()!'2(!9-18(55!$,5()!1*!'2(!01..1S&*7!4#(5'&1*5W!

• [1S!)1(5!&'!0&'!&*!S&'2!'2(!)&00(-(*'!&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!,99-1,82(5t!

• _2,'! 5'(95!*(()! '1! $(! &*8.#)()! &*! '2(!9-18(55! '1!%,K(! '2(5(! ,99-1,82(5!

018#5!1*!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!)(.&E(-()t!

• V5!'2(!9-18(55!,99.&8,$.(!'1!)&00(-(*'!58,.(5!10!&*E(5'%(*'t!

• V5!&'!,99.&8,$.(!'1!)&00(-(*'!2(,.'28,-(!5(''&*75t!!

• Q,*!&'!-#*!,.1*7!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!,'!E,-&1#5!5',7(5t!

!<*5S(-5!'1!'2(5(!4#(5'&1*5!01-%!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!8-&'(-&,!,5W!

• V*E(5'%(*'!a!9-18#-(%(*'!9-18(55!-1#'(q!

• V*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(q!

• "&e(!10!'2(!8,9&',.!&*E(5'%(*'q!

• b(E(.!10!2(,.'28,-(!5(-E&8(5!9-1E&)()q!

• b18,'&1*!10!'2(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-1^(8'A!!

B2(!)&00(-(*'&,'1-5!10! '2(!,$1E(!8-&'(-&,!,*)!'2(!%,&*!82,-,8'(-&5'&85!10! '2(!'2-((!

8,5(!5'#)&(5!,-(!5#%%,-&5()!&*!B,$.(!?=A!

!

!

Page 129: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??R!

&/H0'!,*c!4/('!(183)'(!L!9#/5/91'5)(/1);2!(8@@/5B!

4#/5/91'5)(1)9(!='0'91'3!9/('!(183)'(!

%;8A0/(!E5''2! =1!&#;@/(!! !-&(!

V6!! Q"!?! Q"!=! Q"!@!

V*E(5'%(*'!a+-18#-(%(*'!31#'(! bV/B! +++! QVT!a!Pd!B-(,5#-:!

Q,9&',.!&*E(5'%(*'!Iw%J! ?O! N>! N=>!

b(E(.!10!2(,.'28,-(!9-1E&)()!! +-&%,-:! Q1%%#*&':!,*)!"(81*),-:!!

<8#'(!,*)!B(-'&,-:!

b18,'&1*! ",.01-)! "'18K91-'! C-&72'1*!

V*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(! +15'!G88#9,*8:! G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!IGCQJ!

G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!IGCQJ!

P$,$, %;8A0/(!E5''2!W!4/('!(183B!,!

B2(!61#7.,5! U-((*! 2(,.'28,-(! 0,8&.&':!S,5! &)(*'&0&()! ,5! 8,5(! 5'#):! ?! IQ"?JA! B2&5!

9-1^(8'!&5!9,-'!10!'2(!T,*82(5'(-!",.01-)!,*)!B-,001-)!!IT,"BJ!bV/B!9-17-,%%(A!<5!

9-(E&1#5.:!)(58-&$()!bV/B5!&*'(*'!&5!'1!81*'-&$#'(!'1!'2(!-()(E(.19%(*'!10!9-&%,-:!

8,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(;! '2-1#72! $#&.)&*7! 0,8&.&'&(5! '2,'! 8,*! )(.&E(-! )&E(-5(! 5(-E&8(5!

&*8.#)&*7! '215(! 01-! '2(! ,8#'(! 5(8'1-! IC&*.(:L5;! =>>DJA! V*! =>>D;! '2(-(! S(-(! N=!

*,'&1*S&)(! bV/B! 582(%(5! ,*)! '2&5!S,5! 5('! '1! 81*'&*#(! &*! '2(! 0#'#-(!S&'2! 5(E(*!

,.-(,):! #*)(-! )(E(.19%(*';! 01-! S2&82! 9-18#-(%(*'! ,8'&E&'&(5! S(-(! ,.-(,):! &*!

9-17-(55A!

V*!=>>?!T,"B!bV/B!S,5!&*'-1)#8()!,5!&*81-91-,'&*7!,!*(S!9-18#-(%(*'!-1#'(!01-!

9-&%,-:!8,-(!5(-E&8(5!'2-1#72!Q1%%#*&':![(,.'2!+,-'*(-52&95!IQ[+J!,*)!&'!&5!'2(!

.,-7(5'! 10! '2(! bV/B! 9,-'*(-52&95A! B2(! ,#'21-! &*! 81..,$1-,'&1*! S&'2! '2(! T,"B!

9,-'*(-52&9! 9-17-,%%(! )&-(8'1-! I%(%$(-! 10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9J! 5(.(8'()! '2(!

61#7.,5!U-((*!bV/B!9-1^(8'! 0-1%!?=!19(-,'&1*,.! 582(%(5! 01-! '2(!9#-915(!10! '2&5!

-(5(,-82A! B2(! 9-1^(8'! S,5! ,'! '2(! 915'! 188#9,*8:! 5',7(! 01..1S&*7! ,*! &*&'&,.!

&*E(5'%(*'!10!w?O!%&..&1*!,*)!2,)!,.-(,):!$((*! &*!19(-,'&1*! 01-!?=!%1*'25A!B2(!

Pd!71E(-*%(*'!2,5!%,)(!,!.,-7(!&*E(5'%(*'!&*'1!bV/B!(`9(8'&*7!%,*:!$(*(0&'5!'1!

$(!-(,.&5();!51!'2(-(!S,5!,.51!,!*(()!'1!(E,.#,'(!21S!5#88(550#.!bV/B!582(%(5!&*!

19(-,'&1*!2,E(!,8'#,..:!$((*A!![1S(E(-!,5!5','()!&*!'2(![1#5(!10!Q1%%1*5!-(91-'!

I=>>RJ!uV'!S&..!$(!%,*:!:(,-5!$(01-(!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!10!)(.&E(-&*7!5(-E&8(5!'1!

Page 130: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??M!

.18,.! 81%%#*&'&(5! '2-1#72!bV/B! 8,*!$(! -(,.&5()Av! ,*)! '2,'! '2(-(! u&5!*1'! ,! 01-%,.!

%('21)1.17:! '1! %,*,7(! ,*)! -(,.&5(! &*'(*)()! $(*(0&'5vA! Q1%$&*&*7! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*L5! *(()! ,*)! '2(!9#-915(!10! '2&5! -(5(,-82!61#7.,5!U-((*! .18,'()! &*! ,!

)(9-&E()! *(&72$1#-211)! &*! ",.01-)! 0&''()! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):! )&00(-(*'&,'1-! 5(.(8'&1*!

8-&'(-&,A!

B2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! &*'1! 21S! T,"B! bV/B! S1#.)! 01..1S! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

,99-1,82!9-(5(*'()! '2(!,#'21-!S&'2! '2(!1991-'#*&':! '1!)(E(.19!,*)!E,.&),'(! '2(!

%('21)5! 01-! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*;! $(*(0&'5! (E,.#,'&1*! ,*)! 5(.(8'&1*! 10! 5',K(21.)(-!

7-1#95! -(.,'()! '1! C(3(,.! 92,5(5! ,5! '215(! S(-(! 9-(E&1#5.:! &*'-1)#8()! ,*)!

&..#5'-,'()!&*!B,$.(!?@A!!

&/H0'!,-c!>':'/0![#/('(!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2!4=,!

>':'/0![#/('(!1;!H'!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2! 4/('!(183B!,!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! V! !

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.(! VV! !!

[&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!%,9! VV! !!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! VVV! !

C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S5! VX! !!

P$,$* =1!&#;@/(!4;@@82)1B!.;([)1/0P!W!4/('!=183B!*!

B2(!"'!B21%,5!Q1%%#*&':![159&',.!9-1^(8'!S,5! &)(*'&0&()!,5!8,5(!5'#):!=!IQ"=JA!

B2&5! 9-1^(8'! &5! 9,-'! 10! ]["! "'18K91-'! 9-&%,-:! ,*)! 5(81*),-:! 8,-(! 5(-E&8(!

-(81*0&7#-,'&1*!9-17-,%%(!S2(-(!$:!&*!=>>N!2,5!(%$,-K()!1*!?>\:(,-!^1#-*(:!'1!

)(.&E(-!0&'!01-!9#-915(!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A!B2(!,#'21-!&*!81..,$1-,'&1*!S&'2!

'2(! "'18K91-'!]["! /&*,*8(! )&-(8'1-! I%(%$(-! 10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9J! 5(.(8'()! "'!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!N!:+DD3#$)*!Q+(2$)./! Z! &5!,!2(,.'28,-(! 0,8&.&':! '2,'!$-&)7(5!,8#'(!,*)!9-&%,-:!8,-(A!<!81%%#*&':!2159&',.! &5!

1*(! S&'21#'! 81*'-,8'#,..:! -(5&)(*'! %()&8,.! 5',00A! B2(:! 9-1E&)(! %&*1-! 5#-7(-:;! -(2,$&.&','&1*! 5(-E&8(5;!%,'(-*&':!5(-E&8(5!,*)!81#.)!,.51!9-1E&)(!8,-(!01-!1.)(-!9(19.(!'2,'!*1!.1*7(-!-(4#&-(!2159&',.&5,'&1*;!$#'!8,**1'!:('!-('#-*!21%(A!IC&*.(:L5!]["!U#&)(;!=>>DJA!

Page 131: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??D!

B21%,5!9-1^(8'!S215(!%,&*!,&%!S,5!'1!u9-1E&)(!8,-(!8.15(!'1!21%(!,*)!'1!100(-!

-(591*5&E(;! 9(-51*,.&5()! ,*)! 81*E(*&(*'! 5(-E&8(5! S&'2! ,! 5'-1*7! (%92,5&5! 1*!

4#,.&':!,*)!5,0(':Av!I]["!"'18K91-';!=>>DJA!!B2&5!)(E(.19%(*'!S,5!,.51!81*5&)(-()!

'1!$(!,!0.,752&9!9-1^(8'!&*!'2(!Pd!71E(-*%(*'L5!81%%#*&':!2159&',.!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

9-17-,%%(A! B2(! 9-1^(8'! S,5! ,'! '2(! G#'.&*(! C#5&*(55! Q,5(! )(E(.19%(*'! 5',7(!

9.,**&*7!'1!&*E(5'!wN>!%&..&1*!'2-1#72!,!+++!&*E(5'%(*'!-1#'(A!!]["!"'18K91-'!2,)!

,!5'-,'(7&8!E&5&1*!5#%%,-&5()!&*!'2(!5&`!01..1S&*7!,&%5W!

• B1! 5((K! '1! &%9-1E(! '2(! 1E(-,..! 2(,.'2! ,*)!S(.. $(&*7! ,*)! '1! -()#8(! '2(!

E,-&,'&1*!&*!2(,.'2!(`9(-&(*8(!10!'2(!9(19.(!'2(:!5(-E(q!

• B1! 81%%&55&1*! ,*)! 9-1E&)(! 8,-(;! S2(*(E(-! 9155&$.(! ,*)! ,99-19-&,'(;! &*!

9-&%,-:!,*)!81%%#*&':!5(''&*75q!

• B1!5#991-'!,*)!&*E(5'!&*!5',00!'2-1#72!)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!5',00!&*E1.E(%(*'5!

9-18(55(5!,*)!51!%,K(!&'!0#.0&..&*7!'1!81%(!'1!S1-Kq!

• B1! &*8-(,5(! '2(! .(E(.! 10! 9#$.&8! ,*)! 9,'&(*'! &*E1.E(%(*'5! &*! '2(! )(8&5&1*\

%,K&*7!9-18(55(5!,$1#'!'2(&-!81..(8'&E(!,*)!&*)&E&)#,.!8,-(!*(()5q!

• B1! S1-K! &*! 9,-'*(-52&9! S&'2! '2(! b18,.! <#'21-&':! ,*)! 1'2(-! ,7(*8&(5! '1!

%,`&%&5(!'2(!1991-'#*&':!01-!81..,$1-,'&1*!,*)!^1&*'!$(*(0&'q!

• B1!%,`&%&5(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!10!'2(!-(51#-8(5!'2(:!%,*,7(!,*)!'1!-(%,&*A!

B2(-(!S,5! '2(! *(()! '1! '-,*5.,'(! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8! E&5&1*! &*'1! ,!%(,*&*70#.! )&-(8'&1*!

'2,'! "'! B21%,5!Q1%%#*&':!9-1^(8'!S&..! (%$-,8(! ,*)! ,&%! '1!)(.&E(-! '2-1#72! '2(!

*(S! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-1^(8'A! B2(-(! S,5! '2(! "[<L5O!-(4#&-(%(*'! '2,'! '2(! 9-1^(8'!

S1#.)! 01..1S! '2(! U,'(S,:! -(E&(S! 9-18(55! I9-(5(*'()! (,-.&(-J! S2(-(! ,! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! %('21)1.17:! %#5'! $(! &*8.#)()! &*! '2(! G#'.&*(! C#5&*(55! Q,5(A! B2(!

&*8.#5&1*!,*)! 81*'(*'!10! ,!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!%('21)1.17:!S1#.)!$(!,! 8-&'(-&1*!

01-!'2(!,99-1E,.!10!'2(!9-1^(8'L5!$#)7('!,*)!&*E(5'%(*'!1-!*1'!)(8&5&1*!'1!$(!%,)(A!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!O!-)'.)&A$E! Q&./)6! F3)6+'$)$&(! 1!S(-(! 8-(,'()! $:! '2(! Pd! 71E(-*%(*'! &*! =>>=! '1! %,*,7(! '2(! .18,.! ],'&1*,.!

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

Page 132: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ??F!

Q1%$&*&*7! '2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!*(()!,*)! '2(!9#-915(!10! '2&5! -(5(,-82!"'!B21%,5L5!

Q1%%#*&':!2159&',.!9-1^(8'!0&''()!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!)&00(-(*'&,'1-!5(.(8'&1*!8-&'(-&,A!

B2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! &*'1! 21S! "'! B21%,5! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S! 9-18(55! S1#.)! ,)19'! ,!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! 9-(5(*'()! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2! '2(! 1991-'#*&':! '1!

)(E(.19! ,*)! E,.&),'(! %('21)5! 01-! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*;! )(9(*)(*8:! %,95! ,*)!

01-%#.,'(! ,! *! ,99-1,82! 01-! )(E(.19&*7! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*! -(.,'()! '1! '2(!

81*8(9'#,.! C(3(,.! 92,5(5! VV! ,*)! VVV! ,5! '215(! S(-(! 9-(E&1#5.:! &*'-1)#8()! ,*)!

&..#5'-,'()!&*!B,$.(!?NA!

&/H0'!,Pc!>':'/0![#/('(!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2!4=*!

>':'/0![#/('(!1;!H'!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2! 4/('!(183B!*!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! V! !

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.(! VV! !!

[&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!%,9! VV! !!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! VVV! !

C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S5! VX! !

P$,$- -&(!:'A);2/0!4'215'T!L!4/('!(183B!-!

B2(!@B5!3(7&1*,.!8(*'-(!)(E(.19%(*'!9-1^(8'!S,5!&)(*'&0&()!,5!8,5(!5'#):!@!IQ"@JA!

B2(! C-&72'1*! ,*)! "#55(`! P*&E(-5&':! [159&',.5! IC"P[J! ]["! B-#5'! &5! &*E(5'&*7!

wN=>A?%! '2-1#72! 9#$.&8! 0#*)&*7! &*! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! 3(7&1*,.! Q(*'-(! 01-!

B(,82&*7;!B-,#%,!,*)!B(-'&,-:!Q,-(A!+-17-,%!81%9.('&1*!&5!(`9(8'()!01-!=>?FA!

B2(!,#'21-!&*!81..,$1-,'&1*!S&'2!'2(!C"P[!H5','(5!,*)!0,8&.&'&(5!)&-(8'1-!I%(%$(-!

10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9J! 5(.(8'()! '2(! B(-'&,-:;! B-,#%,! ,*)!B(,82&*7! I@B5J!S215(!

E&5&1*! &'! &5! '1! 9-1E&)(! 8.&*&8,.! 5(-E&8(5;! $#&.)&*75! ,*)! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! '2,'! S&..! $(!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!R!B(,82&*7;!B-,#%,!,*)!B(-'&,-:!Q,-(!Z!B(-'&,-:! 8,-(! 8(*'-(5!9-1E&)(! '-(,'%(*'! 01-! 81%9.(`! 81*)&'&1*5!(A7A!

8,*8(-!'2(-,9:!

Page 133: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=>!

#5()!$:!'2(!.18,.!919#.,'&1*5!10!T&)!"#55(`;!C-&72'1*!,*)![1E(!01-!'2(!*(`'!@>!'1!

N>!:(,-5! IC-&72'1*!,*)!"#55(`!P*&E(-5&':![159&',.5;!=>>FJA!C"P[!@B!S,5! &*!T,:!

=>>F!,'!'2(!$#5&*(55!8,5(!,99-1E,.!5',7(;!,*)!2,)!$((*!'2-1#72!,!*#%$(-!10!1'2(-!

5',7(5!5&*8(!=>>MA!

B2(! 9-17-,%! )(0&*&'&1*! $(7,*! S&'2! )(E(.19&*7! '2(! 5'-,'(7:! 01-! 2(,.'2! )(.&E(-:A!

B2&5! )(0&*&'&1*! 9-18(55! 5',-'()! &*! =>>M! ,*)! S,5! -11'()! 1*! ,!%:-&,)! 10! 91.&8&(5!

I.18,.;!-(7&1*,.;!*,'&1*,.J!01-!2(,.'2!)(.&E(-:!&*!'2(!PdA!"#82!)(0&*&'&1*5!,-(!8,--&()!

1#'! 9-&1-! '1! '2(! )(5&7*! 92,5(;! $#'! '2,'! )1(5*L'! %(,*! '2,'! 0#-'2(-! )(0&*&'&1*5! '1!

5(-E&8(5!81#.)!*1'!$(!)1*(!)#-&*7!'2(!)(5&7*!92,5(A!B2&5!5'-,'(7&8!9.,**&*7!92,5(!

&5!)18#%(*'()!1*!'2(!"'-,'(7&8!G#'.&*(!Q,5(!I"GQJA!<5!9,-'!10!)(E(.19&*7!'2(!"GQ;!

'2(!G00&8(!10!U1E(-*%(*'!Q1%%(-8(!IGUQJ!-(81%%(*)5!'2,'!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!

0-1%!'2(! &*E(5'%(*'5!521#.)!$(!5','()A!B2-1#721#'! '2(!9-17-,%!&%9.(%(*','&1*!

'2(!GUQ!,55(55(5! &'5!9-17-(55!,*)!,0'(-!81%9.('&1*;!(E&)(*8(!521#.)!$(!9-1E&)()!

'2,'!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!S(-(!,82&(E()A!

V*! '2(! @B! 9-17-,%%(;! '2(! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*! 01-! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'! &5! $,5()! 1*! 'S1!%,&*!

&55#(5W!,!*(()!'1!&%9-1E(!5(-E&8(!)(.&E(-:;!,82&(E&*7!2&72!5',*),-)5!'2,'!,-(!,.51!

$(''(-!,.&7*()!S&'2!]["L5!91.&8&(5!01-!2(,.'28,-(!)(.&E(-:q!,*)!'2(!*(()!'1!9-1E&)(!

,)(4#,'(!,*)!%1)(-*!$#&.'!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!'1!,881%%1),'(!5#82!5(-E&8(5A!B2(!"GQ!

)18#%(*'!,.51!%(*'&1*5!,!)(5&-(!'1!,82&(E(!'2,'!S&'2!(00&8&(*8:;!'2-1#72!'2(!$(5'!

#5(!10!-(51#-8(5A!

B2(!9-&*8&9,.!,&%!10!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!S,5!'1!(.&8&';!8.,55&0:!,*)!82,-,8'(-&5(!$(*(0&'5!

01-! '2(!@B5!2159&',.!)(E(.19%(*'!,5! '2(5(!S(-(! &*E(5'&7,'()! &*! '2(! 'S1!9-(E&1#5!

8,5(!5'#)&(5!,5!S(..!,5!E,.&),'&*7!'2(!C(3(,.!%('21)5!10!)1&*7!51A!/#-'2(-%1-(;!'2(!

8,5(! 5'#):! ,&%()! '1! )(E(.19! ,*)! '(5'!%('21)5! 01-! $(*(0&'5!S(&72'&*7! '2,'!S(-(!

5#$5(4#(*'.:! #5()! 01-! 5(.(8'&*7! $('S((*! )(5&7*! 19'&1*5! 01-! '2(! 2159&',.!

)(E(.19%(*'A! B2(! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,-(! &*! ,.&7*%(*'!S&'2!C(3(,.! 81*8(9'#,.! 92,5(5! V;! VV!

,*)!VVV!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!B,$.(!?OA!!

!

!

Page 134: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=?!

&/H0'!,Nc!>':'/0![#/('(!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2!4=-!

>':'/0![#/('(!1;!H'!)2<'(1)A/1'3!)2! 4/('!(183B!-!

C(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7:! V! !!

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.(! VV! !!

[&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!%,9! VV! !!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*! VVV! !!

C(*(0&'5!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(E&(S5! VX! !

P$* !4/('!(183B!@'1#;3;0;AB!!

B2(!%('21)1.17:!01-!#*)(-',K&*7!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S,5!'2,'!10!,8'&1*!-(5(,-82!,*)!

&5! )(58-&$()! &*! 82,9'(-! @A! B2(! ,#'21-! S,5! *1'! 1*.:! 1$5(-E&*7! ,*)! -(E&(S&*7!

)18#%(*','&1*!S&'2!-(7,-)5!'1!'2(!-(.(E,*'!9-1^(8'5!$#'!2(!,.51!'11K!,*!,8'&E(!-1.(!

&*!9,-'&8&9,'&*7!&*!9-1^(8'!-(E&(S5;!0,8&.&','&*7!S1-K52195!,*)!.(,)&*7!,8'&E&'&(5![(!

$(8,%(!,*!,%$,55,)1-!10!9-1%1'&*7!'2(!c$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2&*K&*7L!S&'2&*!'2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5!#*)(-! '2(!5819(!10! '2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!1*!188,5&1*5!,!8,',.:5'! 01-!

&*'-1)#8&*7!82,*7(5A!B2(!&*01-%,'&1*!7,'2(-&*7;!),',!81..(8'&1*!,*)!S,5!,82&(E()!

$:! ,8'&E(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! &*! %(('&*75! ,5! S(..! ,5! #5&*7! '2(! 01..1S&*7! -(5(,-82!

%('21)5W!!

• 621'5<)'R(!S&'2!K(:!9(-51**(.!&A(A!9-1^(8'!)&-(8'1-;!0&*,*8(!)&-(8'1-;!9-1^(8'!

,*)!9.,**&*7!%,*,7(-5q!B2(5(!S(-(!&*01-%,.!&*'(-E&(S5!,&%&*7!'1!8,9'#-(!

,*)!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!8#--(*'!9(-8(9'&1*5!10!'215(!&*E1.E()!&*!-(7,-)5!'1!'2(!

8#--(*'! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! )(.&E(-:! 9-18(55;! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! (*7,7(%(*'!

,*)!)(8&5&1*!%,K&*7!%(82,*&5%5A!B2(!&*'(-E&(S5!,.51!,&%()!'1!)(E(.19!,*!

#*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! 21S! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! &5! 9(-8(&E()!S&'2&*!

'2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! 21S! &'! %,:! 1-! *1'! ,55&5'! '1S,-)5! )(.&E(-&*7! ,!

5#88(550#.!9-1^(8'A!<!5,%9.(!10!'2(!4#(5'&1*5!,5K()!)#-&*7!'2(5(!&*'(-E&(S5!

&5!&*8.#)()!&*!<99(*)&`!VVA?NA!

• Q#--(*'! ,*)! 9,5'! 3;98@'21/1);2! 5'<)'R! S&'2! -(7,-)! '1! '2(! 9-1^(8'!

^#5'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)!)(.&E(-:!%,*,7(%(*';! &*8.#)&*7! $#5&*(55! 8,5(5;! "'-,'(7&8!

Page 135: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?==!

"(-E&8(! 6(E(.19%(*'! +.,*5;! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 9-18(55;!

U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S5;!%&*#'(5!10!%(('&*75!('8Aq!

• 627;5@/0! 3)(98(();2(!S&'2! 1-7,*&5,'&1*L5! 5',00! )&-(8'.:! &*E1.E()!S&'2! '2(!

9-1^(8'L5!9-17-(55q!

• /1-%#.,'&1*!10! ,![5;Q'91! R;5M)2Ae(1''5)2A! A5;8[! .(,)!$:! '2(! ,#'21-! '1!

9.,*!,*)!-(E&(S!8,5(!5'#):!,8'&E&'&(5q!

• <8'&E(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! &*! R;5M(#;[(! 018#5&*7! 1*! '2(! )(E(.19%(*';!

,99.&8,$&.&':!,*)!E,.&),'&1*!10! '2(!C(3(,.!92,5(5!#*)(-! 81*5&)(-,'&1*!,*)!

'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!'1!&*01-%!'2(!9-18(55q!

• 6(.&E(-:! 10! H'2'7)1(! 5'/0)(/1);2! @/(1'5! 90/(('(! 01-! %(%$(-5! 10! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! '2,'! S1#.)! $(! &*E1.E()! S&'2! '2(! 9.,**&*7! )(.&E(-&*7! ,*)!

%,*,7&*7!'2(!9-1^(8'!&*!19(-,'&1*A!<&%&*7!'1!-,&5(!,S,-(*(55!,*)!()#8,'(!

1*!$(*(0&'5!)-&E(*!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!$(5'!9-,8'&8(q!

• b8'(1);22/)5'(!S(-(!,99-19-&,'(!S&'2!'2(!0,8&.&'&(5!#5(-5!,*)!5',00!'1!7,&*!

)&-(8'! 0(()$,8K! 1*! 9-1^(8'L5! 1#'9#'5! &%9,8'! '1! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! '2(!

81%%#*&':q!

• I3<)(;5B!A5;8[!R;5M(#;[(!'1!8-155!E,.&),'(!0&*)&*75!0-1%!,..!8,5(!5'#)&(5;!

9-(5(*'! C(3(,.! )(E(.19%(*'! &*! .&*(! S&'2! '2(! *(S! 0&*)&*75! ,*)! .(551*5!

.(,-*'q!!

• X;98(! ('(();2(! S&'2&*! '2(! c,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! S1-K5219L! '1! )&58#55! 0#'#-(!

)&-(8'&1*! ,*)! ,99-1E(! 9-18(55! 5'(95! '1! $(! &*81-91-,'()! &*'1! '2(! 0&*,.!

C(3(,.!9-18(55A!

P$- 4/('!(183)'(!/91)<)1B!!

B2(! 5(8'&1*! '2,'! 01..1S5! )(',&.5! 21S! '2(5(! -(5(,-82!%('21)5!S(-(! 9.,**()! ,*)!

(`(8#'()!S&'2&*!'2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!9-(5(*'5!'2(!1#'9#'5!'2,'!81*'-&$#'()!

'1S,-)!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!5'(95!,-82&'(8'#-(!,*)!'2(!01-%#.,'&1*!10!'2(!K(:!'11.5!

,*)!'(82*&4#(5!'2,'!,-(!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!OA!

B2(!,8'&1*!-(5(,-82!,99-1,82!10!018#5&*7!1*!)&00(-(*'!,*)!59(8&0&8!,59(8'5!&*!(,82!

10! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5!9-1E&)()!,*!(`8(..(*'!9.,'01-%!,*)!,*!1991-'#*&':! '1! 0#-'2(-!

Page 136: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=@!

)(E(.19! ,*)! 8-155\-(0(-(*8(! ,*)! E,.&),'(! )&E(-5(! 81%91*(*'5! 10! '2(! C(3(,.!

9-18(55A!

P$-$, I91)<)1B!3'(95)[1);2!/23!;81[81(!;7!4=!,!

B2(!018#5!10!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!S,5!'1W!

,A H5',$.&52! ,*! &*'(-,8'&E(! 5:5'(%,'&8! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! &)(*'&0&()a(.&8&'()!

$(*(0&'5;! #*)(-! ,! '2-((\.(E(.! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! I,5! (%(-7()! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(!

-(E&(S!,*)!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!%(('&*7!?Jq!

$A V)(*'&0:!,!$(*(0&'5!%,99&*7!,99-1,82!,*)!&'5!#5(0#.*(55q!,*)!

8A V)(*'&0:!%('21)5! '1! (E,.#,'(!21S!5#88(550#.! '2(!2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

&5a2,5!$((*!&*!-(.,'&1*!'1!'2(!5',00!,*)!'2(!81%%#*&':! !I$,5()!1*!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5()JA!

B1! &*E(5'&7,'(! Q"?! '2(! 01..1S&*7! %('21)5! I5#%%,-&5()! &*! B,$.(! ?RJ! S(-(!

)(9.1:()A! B2(! )(',&.()! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)! 1#'9#'5! ,-(! )(58-&$()! &*! '2(! 5(8'&1*! '2,'!

01..1S5!B,$.(!?RA!

&/H0'!,Tc!4=,!5'('/59#!@'1#;3(!/23!/)@!

!4=,!:'('/59#!F'1#;3(! >':'/0!"#/('! I)@! 4=,!7;98(!

+-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9! <..! U1E(-*,*8(! !

V*01-%,.!&*'(-E&(S5a)&58#55&1*! V! Q#--(*'!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! !

618#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S! V! "'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*! I,J!

T,5'(-!8.,55!! <..! C3!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! !

_1-K5219!?!! VV! "#$!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*! I,J!

_1-K5219!=!! VV! C(*(0&'5!)(9(*)(*8:!%,9! I$J!

f#(5'&1**,&-(5! VX! HE,.#,'&1*! I8J!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!S1-K5219! <..!! G#'9#'5!E,.&),'&1*! <..!

!

Page 137: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=N!

:-J!5'+V&E)!@+'?$#A!A'+32!!

B2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#9! S,5! 8-(,'()! '1! (*5#-(! -(9-(5(*','&1*! 10! K(:!

5',K(21.)(-5;!&*8.#)&*7;!'2(!T,"B!bV/B!9,-'*(-52&9!9-17-,%%(!)&-(8'1-;!,!9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(-;!'2(!61#7.,5!U-((*!2(,.'2!8(*'-(!%,*,7(-;!,!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S(-!0-1%!'2(!

6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2;!,!0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(-;!,*)!,)%&*&5'-,'&1*!5#991-'A!!B2(!7-1#9!

582()#.()!%1*'2.:!%(('&*75! '1! -(E&(S!,*)!%1*&'1-!9-17-(55!,*)!7&E(!,)E&8(!1*!

0#'#-(!5'(95A!

:-!J!=#,+'D./!$#)&'%$&@(!.#0!0$(E3(($+#!

B2&5!'11K!'2(!01-%!10!1*(!&*01-%,.! &*'(-E&(S!I5((!<99(*)&`!VVA?NJ!S&'2!'2(!T,"B!

bV/B!9-17-,%%(!)&-(8'1-!,*)!5(E(-,.!&*01-%,.!81*E(-5,'&1*5!S&'2!'2(!9(19.(!'2,'!

S(-(! &*E1.E()!S&'2! '2(! 9.,**&*7! )(.&E(-:! ,*)! 19(-,'&1*,.&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! 61#7.,5!

U-((*! bV/B! 582(%(! I,*)! 81*5&5'()! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#9! ,5! %(*'&1*()!

,$1E(JA! B2(! ,&%!S,5! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! 8#--(*'! &*E(5'%(*'! 9-18(55! 10! '2(! bV/B!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!,*)! '1!S2,'! (`'(*'! ,!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!S&..!$(! 0(,5&$.(! '1!

&*E(5'&7,'(A!!G*(!10!'2(!%,&*!,&%5!10!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!S,5!'1!(E,.#,'(!'1!S2,'!(`'(*'!

'2(! bV/B! 582(%(! &*! 19(-,'&1*! 2,)! )(.&E(-()! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! &5! &*'(*)()! '1!

,82&(E(A!B2&5!%('21)!2,5!81*'-&$#'()!'1!'2(!81*8.#5&1*!'2,'!'2(-(!S,5!*1'!(*1#72!

(E&)(*8(!10!)18#%(*'()!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!81#.)!$(!#5()!,5!,!$,5(.&*(!01-!(E,.#,'&1*!10!

'2(!61#7.,5!U-((*!582(%(A!B2(!)18#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S!'2,'! 01..1S()!S1#.)!018#5!

1*!21S!c2&72! .(E(.L!$(*(0&'5!S&..!$(!-('-159(8'&E(.:! &)(*'&0&()!51!'2(!8,*!&*&'&,'(!,!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!&*!.&*(!S&'2!'2(!,#'21-5!5#77(5'&1*5A!B2(!%('21)!,.51!

-(5#.'()!&*'1!0#-'2(-!&)(*'&0:&*7!'2(!bV/B!5',7(!)(E(.19%(*'!9-18(55!,*)!21S!8,*!

$(!,.&7*()!S&'2!,!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,99-1,82A!

:-!J!7+E3D&#).)$+#!'&%$&@!1!Y&#&,$)(!$0&#)$,$E.)$+#!D&)6+0!

B2&5! %('21)! 81*'-&$#'()! '1! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! -(.,'()! '1! ?5'! S,E(!

582(%(5!10!T,"B!bV/BA!61#7.,5!U-((*!&5!9,-'!10!'2&5!S,E(A!B2&5!S,5!,!-('-159(8'&E(!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! ,5! '2(!61#7.,5!U-((*! 0,8&.&':!S,5! ,.-(,):! 188#9&()! ,*)!

19(-,'&1*,.A!V*!1-)(-!'1!81%9&.(!,!8,',.17#(!10!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!(E,.#,'();!'2(!5'#):!!!

.11K()!&*'1W!

Page 138: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=O!

• B2(!"'-,'(7&8!"(-E&8(!6(E(.19%(*'!+.,*!I""6+J;!<9-&.!=>>=q!

• B2(!,99-1E()!$#5&*(55!8,5(!)18#%(*','&1*;!h#.:!=>>NA!

B2(! -(5#.'! 10! '2(! 5'#):! )(.&E(-()! ,! 0&-5'! 5('! 10! 2&72! .(E(.! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! '2(! .18,.!

2(,.'28,-(! ,#'21-&'&(5! ,&%()! '1!)(.&E(-! '2-1#72!bV/B! &*! '2(! ,-(,! 10!T,*82(5'(-;!

",.01-)!,*)!B-,001-)!IT,"BJA!B2&5!S,5!'2(*!0#-'2(-!(`9.1-()!,5!9,-'!10!,!$(*(0&'5!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!S1-K5219! &*E1.E&*7!'2(!"'-,'(7&8!+,-'*(-&*7!C1,-)!I"+CJM!10!T,"B!

bV/B!,*)!'2(!9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7!7-1#9A!!

:-!J!U.()&'!E/.((!@+'?(6+2!

+-&1-! '1! 81%%(*8&*7! '2(! (*7,7(%(*'! S&'2! '2(! -(5'! 10! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! ,*)! &*!

1-)(-!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!'1!S2,'!(`'(*'!,!$(*(0&'!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!8,*!$(!#*)(-',K(*!

,*)!E,.&),'()!S&'2!T,"B!bV/Bq!&'!5((%()!,99-19-&,'(!'2,'!,!$(*(0&'5!%,5'(-!8.,55!

521#.)!$(!)(.&E(-()A!B2(!%,5'(-!8.,55!'11K!'2(!01-%!10!,!2,.0\),:!S1-K5219!S2(-(!

,*)! &'! &*E1.E()! ,..! '2(!%(%$(-5! 10! '2(!T,"B!bV/B! "+C!$1,-)! ,''(*)()A! B2(! ,&%!

S,5W!

• B1!-,&5(!'2(!,S,-(*(55!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2&*K&*7!,*)!,99-1,82q!

• +-(5(*'!21S!'2(!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!S&..!$(!&*E(5'&7,'()!

S&'2&*! T,"B! bV/B! ,*)! 21S! &'5! 91'(*'&,.! 81*'-&$#'&1*! '1! '2(! 8#--(*'!

&*E(5'%(*'!9-18(55A!!

:-!J!I+'?(6+2!JH!!-3C!O!C&#&,$)(!&/$E$).)$+#!@+'?(6+2!!

B2&5!S1-K5219!S,5!'1!(`9.1-(!:-J!.$D!\.]!$9&9!)+!&().C/$(6!.#!$#)&'.E)$%&!(*()&D.)$E!

+'A.#$(.)$+#!+,! )6&! $0&#)$,$&0^&/$E$)&0!C&#&,$)(;!3#0&'!.! )6'&&O/&%&/!+'A.#$(.)$+#! \.(!

&D&'A&0!,'+D!)6&!/$)!'&%$&@!.#0!.0%$(+'*!A'+32!D&&)$#A!J]A!

B2(!9#-915(!10!'2&5!S1-K5219!S,5!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!9-1915()!

5'(9!10! '2(!9-18(55!$:!1$5(-E&*7!21S!9,-'&8&9,*'5!S&..! -(,8'!,*)!81*'-&$#'(! '1! &';!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!M!T,"B!bV/B!"'-,'(7&8!+,-'*(-&*7!C1,-)!!

Page 139: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=R!

,*)!&)(*'&0:!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!10!21S!'1!,82&(E(!'2(!$(5'!9155&$.(!1#'81%(!$:!

81..(8'&*7!(E&)(*8(!'2-1#72!)&58#55&1*!,*)!'(%9.,'(5!,*!$:!'(5'&*7!'2(&-!#5,$&.&':A!!

C(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*! 1-! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! &5! ,! K(:! ,8'&E&':! ,5! 10! '2(! 9-1915()! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!,5!&'!S,5!)(58-&$()!(,-.&(-!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-!I5(8'&1*!=A?OA=JA!!

V'!S,5! &)(*'&0&()!$:! '2(!9-(E&1#5!%('21)5! '2,'! ,! 5('! 10! O! 0&E(!2&72! .(E(.! $(*(0&'5!

S1#.)!$(!#5()!,5!'2(!)-&E(-5!01-!'2(!S1-K5219!&*!1-)(-!'1!0#-'2(-!9-10&.(!$(*(0&'5!

,*)!(.&8&'!'2(!*(`'!.(E(.!10!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!S&..!82,-,8'(-&5(!59(8&0&8!',-7('5!,*)!.&*K!'1!

'2(!9-1^(8'L5!,82&(E()!1#'81%(5A!

+,-'&8&9,*'5! 10! '2(! S1-K5219! &*8.#)()! '2(! 01..1S&*7! 8,'(71-&(5! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5!

&*E1.E()!S&'2!'2(!T,"B!bV/BW!!

• T,"B!bV/B!Q1!82&(0!(`(8#'&E(q!

• T,*82(5'(-!+QB!0&*,*8(!)&-(8'1-!

• [(,.'2!8(*'-(!%,*,7(-5!`!@q!

• 6(9,-'%(*'!10!2(,.'2!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S(-q!

• T,*82(5'(-!Q&':!Q1#*8&.![(,.'2!h1&*'!P*&'!9-17-,%!%,*,7(-q!

• +-&%,-:!+.#5!0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(-q!

• Q1%%#*&':![(,.'2!+,-'*(-52&9!K*1S.()7(!%,*,7(-q!

• T,"B!bV/B!"+CA!!

B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! S(-(! 9-(5(*'()! S&'2! ,! 5('! 10! '2(! O! 2&72\.(E(.! $(*(0&'! 9-10&.(!

'(%9.,'(5!I(`,%9.(!&*!,99(*)&`!VVVA?J!,*)!S(-(!&*E&'()!'1!)&58#55!'2(&-!)(0&*&'&1*!

,*)!81%%1*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!'2(5(A!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! E,.&),'&1*! 10! '2(5(! 2&72! .(E(.! $(*(0&'5;! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! S(-(! '2(*!

,5K()!'1!0#-'2(-!$-(,K)1S*!'2(5(!'1!5#$\!$(*(0&'5!&*!.&*(!S&'2!59(8&0&8!',-7('5!'2,'!

'2(!61#7.,5!U-((*!582(%(!S,5!,&%&*7!'1!,82&(E(A!

B2(! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*!S1-K5219! )(.&E(-()! ,! 0#..! 5('! 10! $(*(0&'5;! 1-7,*&5()! &*'1!

"'-,'(7&8!I,5!'2(!2&72!.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!,-(!*1S!-(*,%()J!,*)!"#$!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!5('!10!

$(*(0&'5!81*5&5'!10!1E(-!O!"'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!,*)!@R!"#$!$(*(0&'5!I5((!B,$.(!?MJA!! !

Page 140: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=M!

&/H0'!,Oc!F/=&!Y6X&!9/('!(183B!L!'\/@[0'(!/23!H'2'7)1!;5A/2)(/1);2!!

! ! b(7(*)W!!!\!T,&*!018#5A!!

>'2'7)1(!! >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!

=15/1'A)9!H'2'7)1(! =8H!H'2'7)1(!

?A! V%9-1E()!9,'&(*'!5(-E&8(5! ! !! !

?A>?! V%9-1E()!9,'&(*'!(`9(-&(*8(! ! ! !!

?A>=! C(''(-!,88(55!'1!0,8&.&'&(5!I9-1)#8'J! ! ! !!

?A>@! U-(,'(-!9-&E,8:! ! ! !!

?A>N! T1-(!5(-E&8(5!&*!?!9.,8(!I81\.18,'&1*J! ! ! !!

?A>O! V%9-1E()!2(,.'2!1#'81%(5! ! ! !!

?A>R! U-(,'(-!,88(55!I5(-E&8(J! ! ! !!

?A>M! b(55!S,&'&*7! ! ! !

?A>D! ](S!5(-E&8(5! ! ! !!

?A>F! Q,-(!8.15(-!'1!21%(! ! ! !!

?A?>! V*8-(,5()!9,'&(*'!821&8(! ! ! !!

=A! B&%(!Q15'!f#,.&':! ! !! !

=A>?! /,5'(-!9-18#-(%(*'! ! ! !!

=A>=! /,5'(-!)(.&E(-:!0-1%!81*8(9'!'1!19(-,'&1*! ! ! !!

=A>@! 3(%1E,.!10!$,8K.17!%,&*'(*,*8(! ! ! !!

=A>N! ]1*\&*'(--#9'&1*!10!5(-E&8(!9-1)#8'! ! ! !!

=A>O! +-()&8',$&.&':!10!'&%(!815'!)(.&E(-:! ! ! !!

=A>R! <8'#,.!'&%(!815'!)(.&E(-:! ! ! !!

=A>M! /.(`&$&.&':!,*)!0#'#-(!9-110&*7! ! ! !!

=A>D! Q15'!5,E&*75!)#(!'1!81\.18,'&1*! ! ! !!

=A>F! b1S(-!'1',.!-#**&*7!815'5! ! ! !!

@A! Q1*'-&$#'&1*!'1!-(7(*(-,'&1*! ! !! !

@A>?! V*E(5'%(*'!&*'1!)(9-&E()!,-(,5! ! ! !!

@A>=! [&72(-!.18,.!(%9.1:%(*'! ! ! !!

Page 141: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=D!

I+'?(6+2!_H!`./$0.)&!.!C&#&,$)(!D.22$#A!.22'+.E6!

B2&5! S1-K5219! S,5! '1! (`9.1-(! Q"?! ,&%! I$J! $9&9! )+! $0&#)$,*! .! C&#&,$)! D.22$#A!

.22'+.E6! .#0! $)(! 3(&,3/#&((! .#0! 6+@! $(! '&/.)&0! )+! )6&! Y&R&./! 26.(&! ==H! C&#&,$)(!

E6.'.E)&'$(.)$+#A! C(*(0&'5! %,99&*7! 1-! )(9(*)(*8:! &5! ,*1'2(-! K(:! ,8'&E&':! 10! '2(!

9-1915()!9-18(55!,5!&'!S,5!(,-.&(-!)(58-&$()!!I5(8'&1*!=A?OA=JA!B2(!9#-915(!10!'2&5!

S1-K5219!S,5!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!21S!5#82!,!'(82*&4#(!8,*!$(!(`(8#'()!,*)!21S!#5(0#.!

S1#.)!$(!'1S,-)5!'2(!0&*,.!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!

B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! S(-(! ,5K()! '1! &*&'&,'(! ,*)! ,! $(*(0&'5! %,99&*7! ,99-1,82! ,*)!

7(*(-,'(!%,95!'1!&*8.#)(!5'-,'(7&8;!5#$!,*)!(*)!$(*(0&'5;!(*,$.(-5!,*)!82,*7(5!,5!

'2(5(!S(-(!&)(*'&0&()!&*! <:-J!I+'?(6+2!J>A!<!5(-&(5!10!?!S1-K5219!,*)!=!%(('&*75!

@A>@! V%9-1E()!81%%#*&':!0,8&.&'&(5! ! ! !!

@A>N! V%9-1E()!(81*1%&8!,8'&E&':! ! ! !!

@A>O! "#5',&*,$.(!(*E&-1*%(*'!I(81*1%&8J! ! ! !!

@A>R! "#5',&*,$.(!(*E&-1*%(*'!I518&,.J! ! ! !!

@A>M! C(''(-!.&*K5!S&'2!1'2(-!5(-E&8(5!Z!u8,#5(!,*)!(00(8'v! ! ! !!

NA! V%9-1E()!5',00!5,'&50,8'&1*! ! !! !

NA>?! C(''(-!S1-K&*7!(*E&-1*%(*'! ! ! !!

NA>=! V*8(*'&E(5! ! ! !!

NA>@! 3()#8()!,$5(*8(5! ! ! !!

NA>N! V*8-(,5()!8,-((-!9-159(8'5! ! ! !

NA>O! V*8-(,5()!'-,&*&*7!1991-'#*&'&(5! ! ! !

NA>R! [&72(-!.(E(.!10!5',00!-('(*'&1*!,*)!&*8-(,5()!81-91-,'(!.(,-*&*7!,*)!%(%1-:!

! ! !

OA! C(''(-!9,-'*(-52&9aQ1*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'! ! !! !

OA>?! +(19.(!S1-K&*7!'17('2(-!1*!%,*:!582(%(5!I7-(,'(-!#*)(-5',*)&*7;!-()#8()!815'!,*)!'&%(q!$(''(-!-(.,'&1*52&95;!.(55!81*0.&8'!%,*,7(%(*'J!

! !!!

OA>=! V*8-(,5()!4#,.&':!$('S((*!582(%(5! ! ! !!

OA>@! X,.#(!01-!%1*(:!&%9-1E(%(*'!0-1%!582(%(!'1!582(%(! ! ! !!

OA>N! <88(55!'1!0&*,*8(! ! ! !!

Page 142: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?=F!

S(-(! 1-7,*&5()! ,&%()! '1! '(5'! %,99&*7! '(82*&4#(5! ,*)! 9-1)#8(! ,! $(*(0&'!

)(9(*)(*8:! %,9! $,5()! 1*! '2(5(! $(*(0&'! 5('A! B2(! &*&'&,.! $(*(0&'5! %,99&*7!

S1-K5219;! &*E1.E()! %(%$(-5! 10! T,"B! bV/BL5! "+C! ,*)! S,5! 0,8&.&','()! $:! '2(!

[,QV3VQ!-(5(,-82!'(,%A!6#-&*7!'2(!S1-K5219;!9,-'&8&9,*'5!&)(*'&0&()!-(.,'&1*52&95!

$('S((*!-)'.)&A$E!,*)!-3C!$(*(0&'5!#5&*7! c8,#5(!,*)!(00(8'L!)&,7-,%5A!B2(-(!S(-(!

'S1!5#$5(4#(*'!%(('&*75!S&'2! '2(!2'+V&E)O@+'?$#A!A'+32! '1! 0#-'2(-!(*2,*8(!,*)!

E,.&),'(!'2(!%,9A!B2(!.17&8!10!'2(!%,9!S,5!'1!S1-K!0-1%!-&72'!'1!.(0'!S2(*!.&*K&*7!

-)'.)&A$E!'1!-3C!$(*(0&'5!,*)!0-1%!.(0'!'1!-&72'!S2(*!.&*K&*7!&#.C/&'(!1-!E6.#A&(!'1!

$(*(0&'5A!<*!&..#5'-,'&E(!(`,%9.(!&5!521S*!&*!/&7#-(!=FA!

!

!X)A85'!*Uc!>'2'7)1(!@/[!;7!F/=&!Y6X&!(15/1'A)9!H'2'7)1!h!6@[5;<'3![/1)'21!('5<)9'(d$!

a3&()$+##.$'&(H!S%./3.)$+#!!

V*! .&*(!S&'2! '2(!%,&*! 018#5!10!:-J!\E]!=0&#)$,*!D&)6+0(!)+!&%./3.)&!6+@!(3EE&((,3/!

)6&!6&./)6E.'&!$#,'.()'3E)3'&!$(!^!6.(!C&&#!$#!'&/.)$+#!)+!)6&!().,,!.#0!)6&!E+DD3#$)*!

.#0! '&/.)&0! )+! )6&!Y&R&./!26.(&! =`W! HE,.#,'&1*! ,*)! 3(E&(S! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)!

&%9.(%(*','&1*! 10! ,*! ,99-19-&,'(!5bS! \5+()!bEE32.#E*!S%./3.)$+#J!%('21)!S,5!

&*E(5'&7,'()A!V*!5(8'&1*!=A=>AO!'2(!5&7*&0&8,*8(!10!$(*(0&'5!-,*K&*7!,*)!-(E&(S!S,5!

)(58-&$()A! B2(! %,&*! ,&%! -(7,-)&*7! '1! S%./3.)$+#! 56.(&! S&'2&*! Q"?! S,5! '1!

&*E(5'&7,'(!21S!5#82!,*!(E,.#,'&1*!8,*!$(!.&*K()!)&-(8'!S&'2!'2(!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55A! ![,E&*7! ,! 5('! 10! $(*(0&'5! '1! $(! (E,.#,'();! '2(! ,#'21-!%1E()!

1*'1! &)(*'&0:&*7! 5#&',$.(! %('21)5! 01-! 81..(8'&*7! ),',! .&*K()! '1! '2(5(! $(*(0&'5! &*!

Page 143: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@>!

1-)(-!'1!$(!,$.(!'1!(E,.#,'(!'1!S2,'!(`'(*'!'2(5(!2,E(!$((*!-(,.&5()A!/1..1S&*7!,!

.&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 1*! +GH! ,*)! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(! (E,.#,'&1*! 7#&)(5! 01-! 2(,.'28,-(!

0,8&.&'&(5;! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#9;! ,55&7*()! ,! ),',! 81..(8'&1*! %('21)! '1! (,82!

&)(*'&0&()!$(*(0&'A!<!81%$&*,'&1*!10!%('21)5!S,5!&)(*'&0&()A!

B,$.(! ?D! 9-(5(*'5! ,*! (`'-,8'! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5a%('21)5! %,'-&`A! B2(! 018#5! 10! '2(!

(E,.#,'&1*!S,5!%,&*.:!1*!8,9'#-&*7!'2(!9(-59(8'&E(!10!5(-E&8(!9-1E&)(-5;!0,8&.&'&(5!

#5(-5!,*)!10!'2(!81%%#*&':A!

&/H0'!,Sc!4=!,!F/=&!Y6X&!3/1/!9;00'91);2!@'1#;3(!!

>'2'7)1(! F'1#;3(!;7!3/1/!9;00'91);2!

! f#(5'&1**,&-(5! 618#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S!

+,'&(*'! Q1%%#*&':! "',00!

?A! V%9-1E()!9,'&(*'!5(-E&8(5! ! ! ! !

?A>?! V%9-1E()!9,'&(*'!(`9(-&(*8(! !! ! ! !

?A>=! C(''(-!,88(55!'1!0,8&.&'&(5!I9-1)#8'J! !! !! !! !

?A>@! U-(,'(-!9-&E,8:! !! ! !! !

?A>N! T1-(!5(-E&8(5!&*!?!9.,8(!I81\.18,'&1*J!

!! !! ! !!

?A>O! V%9-1E()!2(,.'2!1#'81%(5! ! ! ! !!

?A>R! U-(,'(-!,88(55!I5(-E&8(J! !! !! ! !!

?A>M! b(55!S,&'&*7! !! ! ! !!

?A>D! ](S!5(-E&8(5! !! !! ! !!

?A>F! Q,-(!8.15(-!'1!21%(! ! ! ! !!

?A?>! V*8-(,5()!9,'&(*'!821&8(! !! !! ! !!

!!!\!T,&*!018#5;!,),9'()!0-1%!",91#*'e&5!('!./!I=>>FJ!,*)!g,'(5!&)!./9!I=>>DJ!

B2(!(E,.#,'&1*!S,5!$,5()!1*!'2(!9(-8(&E()!&%9,8'!,881-)&*7!'1!9,'&(*'5;!5',00!,*)!

8(*'-(! #5(-5! 10! '2(! 61#7.,5! U-((*! 2(,.'28,-(! 0,8&.&':! &*! -(.,'&1*! '1! '2(! O! cQ"?L!

5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5A! B2(! -(5(,-82! '(,%! #5()! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5! 01-! 5',00;! 9,'&(*'5! ,*)!

8(*'-(!#5(-5;!'1!9-1)#8(!9-&%,-:!4#,*'&','&E(!,*)!4#,.&','&E(!),',A!!

Page 144: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@?!

B2(!%,&*!$#.K!10!'2(!),',!81..(8'&1*!S,5!)1*(!'2-1#72!'S1!4#(5'&1**,&-(5!1*(!01-!

'2(!5',00!10!'2(!582(%(5!,*)!1*(!01-!'2(!9,'&(*'5!,*)!(*)\#5(-5!10!'2(!0,8&.&':!I"((!

,99(*)&`!VVA?JA!f#(5'&1**,&-(5!8,*!$(!#5()!'1!7,&*!,*!&*5&72'!&*'1! c82,-,8'(-&5'&85;!

,''&'#)(5;! ,*)! $(.&(05L! IT,-52,..! ,*)! 3155%,*;! ?FFFJA! V*! '2&5! 8,5(! '2(!

4#(5'&1**,&-(5! 7,'2(-()! ,*! &*5&72'! ,*)! ,55(55! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 7-1#95L! E&(S5! ,*)!

9(-8(9'&1*5! 10! '2(! 5(-E&8(5;! 0,8&.&'&(5! ,*)! 1E(-,..! (00(8'5! 10! '2(! bV/B! 582(%(A! ! <5!

(`9.,&*()! (,-.&(-! '2(! 4#(5'&1*5! ,))-(55()! $(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&()! '2-1#72! (,-.&(-!

%(('&*75!'2,'!S(-(!59(8&0&8!'1!'2(!7-1#9A!B2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!'11K!*1!%1-(!'2,*!'(*!

%&*#'(5! ,*)! &*E1.E()! ,99-1`&%,'(.:! R! K(:! 4#(5'&1*5! S&'2! ?>! 5#$! 4#(5'&1*5A!!

B2-1#72! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! 0&*)&*75! &'! S,5! 9155&$.(! '1! 5((! &0! '2(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&*!Q"?!2,)!)(.&E(-()!'2(5(!$(*(0&'5!&*!'2(!E&(S!10!'2(!5',00;!9,'&(*'5!

,*)!81%%#*&':A!!

+-&1-! '1! )(E(.19&*7! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(;! '2(! <P6H! I<5518&,'&1*! 10! P*&E(-5&':!

6&-(8'1-5!10!H5','(5J!I=>>RJ!,*)!Q<CH!IQ1%%&55&1*!10!<-82&'(8'#-(!,*)!'2(!C#&.'!

H*E&-1*%(*'J! I=>>DJ! 7#&)(5! S(-(! 5'#)&()A! _&'2&*! '2&5! 7#&),*8(! S(-(!

-(81%%(*),'&1*5!10! '2(!K&*)!10!4#(5'&1*5! '2,'! 521#.)!$(!#5()!S2(*!,))-(55&*7!

9,-'&8#.,-! &55#(5A! HA7A! I,J! 8.&(*'! 5,'&50,8'&1*! Z! 9-1)#8'q! I$J! 8.&(*'! 5,'&50,8'&1*! Z!

5(-E&8(q!I8J!)(0(8'5q!I)J!9-()&8',$&.&':!Z!815'q!I(J!9-()&8',$&.&':\!'&%(q!I0J!5,0(':q!I7J!

81%%(*'5A! B2(5(! &55#(5!S(-(! -(.(E,*'! '1! '2(!S1-K! '2,'! S,5! #*)(-',K(*!S&'2&*!

Q"?!,5!,!.,-7(!018#5!10!'2(!5'#):!S,5!1*!'2(!(`9(-&(*8(!9(-8(9'&1*!10!'2(!5',00!,*)!

9,'&(*'5A!B2(!7(*(-&8!K*1S.()7(!,84#&-()!0-1%!'2(!7#&)(5!%(*'&1*()!$(01-(!S,5!

81%$&*()!S&'2! '2(! -(E&(S!10! '2(! .18,.&5()!]["!",.01-)! I=>>DJ! =#%+/%&D&#)!)&.D!

4#(5'&1**,&-(! '11.K&'! 7#&)(A! B2(! ,#'21-! &*&'&,..:! )&5'-&$#'()! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5!

S&'2&*! '2(![,QV3VQ! -(5(,-82! 7-1#9! IR! 9(19.(J! ,*)! '2(! 9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7! 7-1#9! 10!

Q"?! ID!9(19.(J! ,*)! 0(()$,8K!S,5! -(8(&E()! &*! '(-%5!10! &'5! -(.(E,*8(! ,*)! 81*'(*'!

$(01-(!&'!S,5!-()(5&7*()!,*)!)&5'-&$#'()!'1!'2(!',-7('()!919#.,'&1*A!

B2(! ,&%! 10! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! S,5! '1! .&*K! (,82! $(*(0&'! '2,'! S,5! 71&*7! '1! $(!

(E,.#,'()! '1! ,! 59(8&0&8! 4#(5'&1*! I,99(*)&`! VVANJA! B2(-(01-(;! '2(! ,#'21-!S1#.)! $(!

,$.(! '1! ,*,.:5(! '1!S2,'! (`'(*'! 9,'&(*'5;! 5',00! ,*)! 8(*'-(! #5(-5! 9(-8(&E(! '2,'! '2(!

$(*(0&'!2,5!$((*!-(,.&5()!I'1',..:;!9,-'&,..:JA!B,$.(!?F!7&E(5!,*!&..#5'-,'&1*!10!51%(!

4#(5'&1*5! &*8.#)()! &*! '2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!,*)! '2(&-! .&*K!S&'2!,*!(.&8&'()!$(*(0&'! 10!

Page 145: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@=!

'2(! 9,'&(*'a8(*'-(! #5(-! 4#(5'&1**,&-(A! <! 0#..! ',$.(! S&'2! '2(! .&*K! (5',$.&52()!

$('S((*!,..!$(*(0&'5!,*)!4#(5'&1*5!&5!&*8.#)()!&*!<99(*)&`!VVANA!

&/H0'!,Uc!b8'(1);2(!/23!H'2'7)1(!0)2M!)008(15/1);2!

Sub - Benefits

Str

ateg

ic B

enef

it

Impr

oved

pat

ient

ser

vice

s

Impr

oved

pat

ient

exp

erie

nce

Bet

ter a

cces

s to

faci

litie

s

Gre

ater

priv

acy

Incr

ease

d pa

tient

cho

ice

How satisfied are you with

A A1 A2 A3 A10 ID Question Benefit

?AN! <$&.&':!'1!7('!'1!'2(!8(*'-(!$:!8,-! ! ! !! ! !

?AO! <$&.&':!'1!7('!'1!'2(!8(*'-(!$:!9#$.&8!'-,*591-'! ! ! !! ! !

?AR! +(,8(!,*)!4#&('!10!'2(!8(*'-(! ! !! ! ! !

?AM! /-(52!,&-!,*)!E(*'&.,'&1*!S&'2&*!'2(!8(*'-(! ! !! ! ! !

@A?D! <S,-(*(55!10!)&00(-(*'!5(-E&8(5!,E,&.,$.(!! ! ! ! ! !!

NA?! b(E(.!10!9-&E,8:!&*!'2(!0,8&.&':! ! ! ! !! !

NA=! Q1*E(-5,'&1*5!&*!'2(!'-(,'%(*'!-11%!I1E(-2(,)J! ! ! ! !! !

NA?>! <S,-(*(55! 10! )&00(-(*'! 19'&1*5! ,E,&.,$.(! &*!

-(7,-)5!'1!2(,.'2!'-(,'%(*'5!

! ! ! ! !!

+,'&(*'! ,*)! 5',00! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! S(-(! 81*',8'()! E&,! ,! 915',.! 4#(5'&1**,&-(A! Q(*'-(!

#5(-5! S(-(! 81*',8'()! E&,! )&5'-&$#'&1*! 10! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! $:! '2(! ,8'&E&':! .(,)!

I)(',&.()! 0#-'2(-! &*! '2(!*(`'! 5(8'&1*JA! /1-!9,'&(*'5! '2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!S,5! 5(*'! '1!

'2(&-!21%(!,))-(55!2(.)!1*!'2(!+QB!),',$,5(!I)&5'-&$#'()!$:!'2(!+QB!5',00!51!*1!

),',! S,5! 2(.)! $:! '2(! -(5(,-82(-JA! B2(-(! S,5! ,*! &*8(*'&E(! S&..! $(! 9-1E&)()! $:!

Page 146: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@@!

+-&%,-:! +.#5! ,! %,^1-! 5',K(21.)(-! 10! T,"B! bV/BA! B2(! &*8(*'&E(! S,5! '2,'! (E(-:!

-('#-*()! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! S1#.)! (*'(-! &*'1! ,! -,00.(! S&'2! '2(! 1991-'#*&':! '1! S&*! ,!

2,%9(-A!/1-!5',00!'2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!S,5!)&5'-&$#'()!#5&*7!'2(!&*'(-*,.!%,&.!5:5'(%A!

B2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! 2,)! ,*! ,881%9,*:&*7! &*01-%,'&1*! 52(('! S&'2! ,*! (`9.,*,'&1*!

,*)! 9#-915(! 10! &';! S&'2! ,55#-,*8(! '2,'! ,..! &*01-%,'&1*! S1#.)! $(! '-(,'()! S&'2!

81*0&)(*'&,.&':A! B1! %,`&%&5(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! '215(! 9,'&(*'5! S21! )&)! *1'! -('#-*! ,!

4#(5'&1**,&-(! S&'2&*! 'S1! S((K5! '2(:! S(-(! 5(*'! ,! -(%&*)(-! ,*)! ,! 01..1S! #9!

4#(5'&1**,&-(A!!Q1*5(*'!S,5!9-(5#%()!1*!-('#-*!10!,!81%9.('()!4#(5'&1**,&-(!&*!,!

5',%9()!,))-(55()!(*E(.19(!'2,'!S,5!9-1E&)()A!!

B2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! ',-7('()! '2(! '2-((! )&00(-(*'! 7-1#95! &*'(-,8'&*7! S&'2! '2(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&*!Q"?A!B2(5(!S(-(!I?J!5(-E&8(!9-1E&)(-5!I5',00Jq!I=J!#5(-5!I9,'&(*'5Jq!

,*)!I@J!8(*'-(!#5(-5!I9(19.(!S21!S1#.)!81%(!'1!'2(!582(%(!'1!#5(!,*:!10!&'5!1'2(-!

5(-E&8(5!01-!(`,%9.(!'2(!92,-%,8:!1-!81%%#*&':!8(*'-(!9,'&(*'5JA!

V*!5(.(8'&*7!'2(!5,%9.(!'2(!01..1S&*7!S(-(!81*5&)(-()W!

I?J!+,'&(*'5!\!<!@Ox!5,%9.(!5&e(!IT,:!?FF@J!10!'2(!9,'&(*'5L!'1',.!*#%$(-!10!?D=>!

S,5!',-7('()A!IB2(!9(-8(*',7(!&*8.#)()!,*!(5'&%,'()!N>x!*1*\-(591*5(!-,'(J!B1!

,82&(E(! ,! 7(*(-,.! -(9-(5(*','&1*! 10! '2(! 919#.,'&1*! ,*)! '1! ,E1&)! 1E(-!

-(9-(5(*','&1*! 10! 1*(! 8,'(71-:! '2(! 9,'&(*'! 5,%9.(! S,5! 5(.(8'()! #5&*7! 5'-,'&0&()!

-,*)1%!5,%9.&*7A!B2(!9,'&(*'!919#.,'&1*!S,5! 0&-5'! )&E&)()! &*'1! 8,'(71-&(5!#5&*7!

u,7(v! ,5! '2(! %,&*! 82,-,8'(-&5'&8! '1! )&00(-(*'&,'(! $('S((*! '2(%A! /1..1S&*7!

81*5#.','&1*!S&'2!'2(!]["!",.01-)!+QB!),',!21.)(-5!'2(!,7(!7-1#95!',-7('()!S(-(W!!

# <7(!?R~?F;!919#.,'&1*!10!?=Nq!

# <7(!=>~@N;!919#.,'&1*!10!ON?q!

# <7(!@O~ON;!919#.,'&1*!10!OF>q!

# <7(!OO~RN;!919#.,'&1*!10!=@Nq!

# <7(!RO�;!919#.,'&1*!10!@@?A!

<!5:5'(%,'&8!5,%9.&*7!,99-1,82!S,5!'2(*!#5()!01-!(,82!10!'2(!,$1E(!7-1#95;!,5!'2(!

-(5(,-82(-! K*(S! '2(! (`,8'! *#%$(-! 10! 9,'&(*'5! &*! (,82! ,7(! 7-1#9A! B2(! (*'&-(!

*#%$(-!&*!(,82!7-1#9!S,5!)&E&)()!$:!'2(!)(0&*()!5,%9.(!5&e(!I&*!'2&5!5'#):!@Ox!

Page 147: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@N!

0-1%!(,82!7-1#9J! '1!)('(-%&*(! '2(!5,%9.&*7! &*'(-E,.! IT,:;!?FF@J;!S2&82! &*! '#-*!

S,5! #5()! '1! 5(.(8'! '2(! 9,'&(*'! '2,'! '2(! 5#-E(:! S,5! 915'()! '1A! /1-! (`,%9.(! '2(!

(*'&-(! 9,'&(*'! 919#.,'&1*! 1E(-! ?R! :(,-5! 10! ,7(! S,5! ?D=>A! /1..1S&*7! ,7(!

5'-,'&0&8,'&1*!ON?!10!'2(!919#.,'&1*!01-%5!'2(!=>~@N!,7(!7-1#9A!_&'2&*!'2,'!7-1#9!

'2(!5,%9.(!5&e(!S,5!?DF!I@OxJ!'2(-(01-(!'2(!5,%9.&*7!&*'(-E,.!01-!'2&5!7-1#9!S&..!

$(!@q!%(,*&*7!'2,'!]["!",.01-)!S1#.)!5(.(8'!,!-,*)1%!*,%(!10!'2(!0&-5'!'2-((!,*)!

51!1*!10!'2&5!7-1#9!.&5'!'1!915'!'2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!#*'&.! '2(!5,%9.(!*#%$(-!10!?DF!

S,5!-(,82()q!

I=J!Q(*'-(!P5(-5q! '2(5(!S(-(!#5(-5!10! '2(!Q"?! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!1'2(-! '2,*!9,'&(*'5;!

&A(A!9(19.(!S21!S1#.)!81%(!'1!'2(!582(%(!'1!#5(!,*:!10!&'5!1'2(-!5(-E&8(5!1-!8(*'-(!

,8'&E&'&(5! 01-! (`,%9.(! '2(! 92,-%,8:! 1-! 81%%#*&':! 8(*'-(A! ! <! .&5'! 10! ,..! ,8'&E&'&(5!

'2,'! '11K! 9.,8(! S&'2&*! '2(! bV/B! 8(*'-(! S,5! 81%9&.()A! B2(5(! ,8'&E&'&(5! S(-(W!

5%1K&*7! 8(55,'&1*q! 2:9*1'2(-,9:;! ,8#9#*8'#-(;! %,55,7(! 5(-E&8(;! 81#*5(..&*7!

5(-E&8(;!4#,.&':!10!.&0(!,55(55%(*'q!8100((!%1-*&*75q!c,7(!81*8(-*L!5#991-'!5(-E&8(q!

VB! 5#991-'q! ,*)! &*'-1! '1! 81%9#'(-5A! 6#(! '1! '2(! .1S! *#%$(-5! 10! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! &*!

'2(5(! ,8'&E&'&(5! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5! S(-(! )&5'-&$#'()! '1! ,..! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! '2,'!

,''(*)()!'2(!8(*'-(!1E(-!,!9(-&1)!10!D!S((K5A!B2&5!9(-&1)!81E(-()!,..!'2(!59(8'-#%!

,*)!0-(4#(*8:!-,'(!10!'2(!,8'&E&'&(5q!

I@J! "',00;! '2&5! S,5! '2(! 7-1#9! 81*5&5'&*7! 10! '2(! S1-K&*7! 919#.,'&1*! 10! '2(! Q"?!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(A! B2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! ,&%()! '1! 8,9'#-(! '2(! E&(S5! 10! ,..! S1-K&*7!

)&58&9.&*(5!S&'2&*!'2&5!8(*'-(A!B2(!S1-K&*7!919#.,'&1*!S,5!)&E&)()!&*!7-1#95!#5&*7!

'2(!01..1S&*7!82,-,8'(-&5'&85W!

# T()&8,.!"(-E&8(5!Z!919#.,'&1*!10!M!I?!U+;!R!6&5'-&8'!]#-5(5Jq!

# <)%&*&5'-,'&1*! "(-E&8(5! Z! 919#.,'&1*! 10! N! I@! -(8(9'&1*&5';! ?! U+! 9-,8'&8(!

%,*,7(-Jq!

# /,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(%(*'!5(-E&8(5!Z!919#.,'&1*!10!=!I?!8(*'-(!%,*,7(-;!?!,#)&'!

%,*,7(-Jq!

# G'2(-!"(-E&8(5;! &A(A!Q(*'-(!,8'&E&':!I,5!)(58-&$()!,$1E(J!.(,)5! !\!919#.,'&1*!

10!Fq!

Page 148: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@O!

B2(! *#%$(-5! 10! 5',00! S&'2&*! '2(5(! 7-1#95! S,5! .1Sq! '2(-(01-(! '2(! )(8&5&1*! S,5!

',K(*! '1! ',-7('! '2(! S21.(! S1-K&*7! 919#.,'&1*! S&'2&*! (,82! 8(*'-(! 51! ,! 7(*(-,.!

-(9-(5(*','&1*!0-1%!(,82!7-1#9!S,5!,82&(E()!IT,:;!?FF@JA!

<..!),',!S,5!,*1*:%1#5!,*)!*1!)&-(8'!81*',8'!'1!(`82,*7(!9(-51*,.!),',!$('S((*!

'2(!-(5(,-82(-!,*)!'2(!9,'&(*'5;!5',00!1-!8(*'-(!#5(-5!S,5!%,)(!,'!,*:!91&*'!10!'2(!

5'#):A!+-&1-!'1!'2(!81%%(*8(%(*'!10!'2&5!,8'&E&':!'2(!,#'21-!5#$%&''()!,*!S)6$E./!

F22'+%./!,99.&8,'&1*!'1!'2(!]["!3(5(,-82!H'2&85!Q1%%&''((!I3HQJA!B2(!",.01-)!,*)!

B-,001-)! b18,.! 3(5(,-82! H'2&85! Q1%%&''((! -(E&(S()! '2(! ,99.&8,'&1*! 01-%! &*! h#.:!

=>>DA! B2(! 81%%&''((! ,)E&5()! '2,'! '2(! 9-1^(8'! &5! 81*5&)(-()! '1! $(! 5(-E&8(!

(E,.#,'&1*;! ,*)! '2(-(01-(! &'! )&)! *1'! -(4#&-(! ('2&8,.! -(E&(S! $:! ,! ]["! 3(5(,-82!

H'2&85! Q1%%&''((! 1-! ,99-1E,.! 0-1%! '2(! ]["! 3r6! 100&8(! IS)6$E./! .22'+%./! RS:!

R&,&'&#E&H!cK^QJccd^e_JA!

B2(!4#(5'&1**,&-(!,82&(E()!,!?Ox!-('#-*!1*!9,'&(*'!8(*'-(a#5(-!,*)!,!M>x!-('#-*!

1*!5',00!4#(5'&1**,&-(!)&5'-&$#'()A!B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!)1(5!*1'!8.(,-.:!)(0&*(!S2,'!&5!,!

5,'&50,8'1-:! .(E(.! 10! -('#-*()! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! 5#-E(:5A! [1.$-11K! ('! ,.A! I=>>OJ!

,55(55()! S2('2(-! .1S(-! -(591*5(! -,'(5! ,-(! ,5518&,'()! S&'2! .(55! #*S(&72'()!

)(%17-,92&8! -(9-(5(*','&E(*(55! 10! ,! 5,%9.(;! $:! (`,%&*&*7! '2(! -(5#.'5! 10! D?!

*,'&1*,.! 5#-E(:5! &*! '2(! P"<! S&'2! -(591*5(! -,'(5! E,-:&*7! 0-1%! O! 9(-8(*'! '1! ON!

9(-8(*'A! B2(:! 01#*)! '2,'! 5#-E(:5! S&'2! %#82! .1S(-! -(591*5(! -,'(5! S(-(! 1*.:!

%&*&%,..:! .(55! ,88#-,'(A!<.'21#72! '2(! ,#'21-!#*)(-5',*)5! '2,'! '2(! .1S! -(591*5(!

-,'(!8,*!7&E(!-&5(!'1!5,%9.&*7!$&,5!&*!-(7,-)5!'1!'2(!1#'81%(5A!<*,.:'&8,.!510'S,-(!

I"+""DJ! S,5! #5()! '1! ,*,.:5(! '2(! 4#,*'&','&E(! ),',! ,5! &'! S,5! (%(-7()! 0-1%! '2(!

4#(5'&1**,&-(5A!B2(! -(5#.'5!S(-(! 5(7%(*'()! &*! '1! 01#-! 5,'&50,8'&1*!8,'(71-&(5! 01-!

(,82! 7-1#9! &*! .&*(! S&'2! '2(! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! 5(8'&1*5A! B2(-(01-(! '2(! -(5#.'5! ,-(!

9-(5(*'()!&*!'2(!5(*5(!10!c!21S!5,'&50&()!,-(!:1#!S&'2W!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!D!! "','&5'&8,.! +-1)#8'! ,*)! "(-E&8(! "1.#'&1*5! I"+""J! Z! B2&5! &5! ,! 5#&'(! 10! 9-17-,%5;!S2&82! 01-%! ,! 81%9#'(-!

9,8K,7(! #5()! $:! $#5&*(55! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5;! ()#8,'&1*! ,*)! 2(,.'2! -(5(,-82(-5;! 5#-E(:! 81%9,*&(5;! '2(!71E(-*%(*'! ,*)! 1'2(-5A! B2-1#72! 5','&5'&8,.! ,*,.:5&5! 10! ),',! &'! 8,*! 8,--:! 1#'! &*\)(9'2! ),',! ,88(55! ,*)!9-(9,-,'&1*;!,*,.:'&8,.!-(91-'&*7!,*)!7-,92&85;!,5!S(..!,5!%,^1-!5','&5'&8,.!,59(8'5A!

Page 149: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@R!

?A C#&.)&*7!,*)!,88(55&$&.&':q!

=A _,&'&*7!'&%(5!,*)!,991&*'%(*'5q!

@A "(-E&8(5!,*)!5',00q!

NA +-&E,8:!,*)!9,'&(*'!821&8(A!

V*!5#%%,-:!'2(!-('#-*()!4#(5'&1**,&-(5!521S()!'2(!01..1S&*7!.(E(.!10!5,'&50,8'&1*;!

'2(!58,.(!10!5,'&50,8'&1*!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!X6"!IE(-:!)&55,'&50&()J;!6"!I)&55,'&50&()J!/!

I*(#'-,.J;!"!I5,'&50&()J;!X"!IE(-:!5,'&50&()JA!

&/H0'!*+c!=8@@/5B!;7!4=,!]8'(1);22/)5'!5'(801(!)2!1'5@(!;7!(/1)(7/91;5B!0'<'0(!

!

!

!

!

B2(! 5,'&50,8'&1*! 5#-E(:! -(5#.'5! I&..#5'-,'()! &*! B,$.(! =>J! S(-(! 5#$5(4#(*'.:!

9-(5(*'()!&*!'(-%5!S&'2!'2(&-!.&*K!'1!'2(!59(8&0&8!$(*(0&'5!I&..#5'-,'()!&*!B,$.(!?FJA!

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 5236 47289 5723: 16256;<#/#&'(=#>,-()(*??@#&/>,&/- :2:5 92A3 4:255 512:9 582A3B,CD#+,-()(B/<EE 4297 42:5 49299 7A251 :42:3FC#D<+0()(F</#,&/(GH@#+, 5296 9245 49286 76266 11286ID,C<$$ 5284 1214 4:256 54274 1:291

&'()*+(,-+./

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 1256 57248 43236 19237:;#/#&'(<#=,-()(*>>?#&/=,&/- 12@8 7259 4@2@7 @5288 @125@A,BC#+,-()(A/;DD @217 4247 582@3 47258 1326@EB#C;+0()(E;/#,&/(FG?#+, 421@ 72H3 442H4 49294 1@281IC,B;$$ @263 1277 4H247 43251 1@257

&'()*+(,-.,*/-0+12

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 5267 86239 8521: 382;;<=#/#&'(>#?,-()(*@@A#&/?,&/- 8249 ;25; ;:265 8:297 842;3B,CD#+,-()(B/=EE 12;9 ;26: 8;288 88285 35293FC#D=+0()(F=/#,&/(GHA#+, 82:7 52;8 ;9284 9:246 38217ID,C=$$ 3218 3285 8:244 8;285 ;427:

&'()*+,-.

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 4251 65278 78246 39245:,+";#/0<(=,>$/?(>&%(:>@,/0 6247 8288 9256 A9238 39235BCD$E0C,&/(:,;F#+,-()(G;>#&#&' 6291 1264 36255 77291 35268HE;I#&'(B&F#;E&C,&/()(J&+,&/#F,- 1233 1268 67214 7K239 1128ALF,;>$$ 32A7 12A3 6K263 74245 1828A

#&'((

Page 150: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@M!

B2(! 8-155\-(0(-(*8(! ,*,.:5&5! 9-1)#8()! '2(! -(5#.'5! '2,'! 81#.)! *1S! $(! .&*K()! '1!

$(*(0&'5!,*)!81*'-&$#'(!'1S,-)5!(5',$.&52&*7!'2(&-!.(E(.!10!-(,.&5,'&1*!&*!-(.,'&1*!'1!

9,'&(*';!8(*'-(!#5(-!,*)!5',00!9(-8(9'&1*A!!

B,$.(!=?!521S5!,*!(`,%9.(!10!21S!'2(!4#(5'&1*5!,*)!'2(!5#-E(:!-(591*5(5!S(-(!

.&*K()!'1!59(8&0&8!$(*(0&'5;!#5&*7!8#%#.,'&E(!5,'&50,8'&1*!.(E(.!10!'2(!),',!,*,.:5()A!

&/H0'!*,c!?\/@[0'!;7!98@80/1)<'!(/1)(7/91);2!0'<'0(!L!9;55'0/1);2!;7!]8'(1);2(!R)1#!H'2'7)1(!

!>'2'7)1(! ! :'(801(! b8'(1);22/)5'!/2(R'5(!^i_!

<?! 6@[5;<'3![/1)'21!'\['5)'29'! ! ! ?;R! ?;M! ?;F! ?;??! ?;?=! ?;?@! s!

! X(-:!)&5,'&50&()! ! @;=!x! =;N! =;N! =;R! =;N! @;@! R;F! s!

! 6&55,'&50&()! ! ?;F!x! >;>! N;F! >;>! >;>! >;>! @;N! s!

! /,&-.:!5,'&50&()! ! ?@;F!x! =;N! N;F! O;?! M;@! R;M! ?M;=! s!

! ",'&50&()! ! @=;D!x! =R;D! @?;M! =D;=! @N;?! NR;M! N?;N! s!

! X(-:!5,'&50&()! ! ND;=!x! RD;@! OR;?! RN;?! OR;?! N@;@! @?;>! s!

<99(*)&`!VV!&*8.#)(5!,!0#..!5('!10!'2(!),',!0-1%!Q"?;!&A(A!f#(5'&1**,&-(5!I<99(*)&`!

VVA?J;! 5,%9.(! )(%17-,92&85! I<99(*)&`! VVA=J;! ',$.(! .&*K&*7! '2(! 4#(5'&1*5! ,*)!

$(*(0&'5! (.&8&'()! I<99(*)&`! VVANJ;! 4#(5'&1**,&-(! -(5#.'5! &*! '(-%5! 10! I?J! .(E(.! 10!

5,'&50,8'&1*!01-!(,82!10!'2(!01#-!4#(5'&1**,&-(!5(8'&1*5!I<99(*)&`!VVA@J;!I=J!&*!'(-%5!

10!'2(!.(E(.!10!5,'&50,8'&1*!01-!(,82!$(*(0&'!.&*K()!I<99(*)&`!VVAOJA!

P$-$* I91)<)1B!3'(95)[1);2!/23!;81[81(!;7!4=!*!

C#&.)&*7!#9!0-1%!'2(!0&*)&*75!10!Q"!?!S(-(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!S(-(!-('-159(8'&E(.:!

&)(*'&0&();! '2&5! 8,5(! 5'#):!(`9.1-()! 0#-'2(-! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.!C(3(,.!92,5(! VV! I,5! &*!

5(8'&1*!NAOJA!B2(!018#5!10!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!S,5!'1W!

,A 6(E(.19! 0#-'2(-! '2(! '2-((! '&(-! $(*(0&'5! 8.,55&0&8,'&1*! ,99-1,82! ,*)! &'5!

#5(0#.*(55q!

$A V*E(5'&7,'(!'2(!C(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!%('21)!S&'2!,!)&E(-5&':!10!5',K(21.)(-5!

,5!,!8-&'&8,.!,59(8'q!!

8A V*E(5'&7,'(! 21S! C(3(,.! 8,*! &*01-%! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S5! ,*)! C#5&*(55! Q,5(!

)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(5A!

Page 151: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@D!

&/H0'!**c!4=*!5'('/59#!@'1#;3(!/23!/)@!

!4=*!:'('/59#!@'1#;3(! >':'/0![#/('! I)@! 4=*!7;98(!

+-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9! ! U1E(-*,*8(! !

V*01-%,.!&*'(-E&(S5a)&58#55&1*! ! Q#--(*'!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! I8J!!

618#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S! V\VVV! C#5&*(55!Q,5(!9-18(55! I8J!

T,5'(-!8.,55!! ! C3!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! !

_1-K5219!?!! VV! "#$!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*! I,J!I$J!

_1-K5219!=!! VV! H*)!$(*(0&'5!a,8'1-5!a(*,$.(-5! I,J!I$J!

<)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K5219! <..!! /(()$,8K!a!1#'9#'5!E,.&),'&1*! <..!

!

:-!_!5'+V&E)!@+'?$#A!A'+32!

B2(!*,'#-(!10!,!9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7!7-1#9!S,5!'1!%,K(!8(-',&*!'2,'!"'18K91-'!+QB!S,5!

0#..:!(*7,7()!S&'2! '2(!8,5(!5'#):!,&%5!,*)!1$^(8'&E(5!,*)!(*5#-(!)(.&E(-,$.(5! &*!

'2(!,7-(()!'&%(0-,%(A!B2(!7-1#9!&*E1.E()!'2(!,#'21-;!,*1'2(-![,QV3VQ!-(5(,-82(-!

,*)! K(:! "'18K91-'! +QB! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()! S&'2! '2(! "'! B21%,5! 9-1^(8';!

&*8.#)&*7;! "'18K91-'! +QB5! 0&*,*8(! )&-(8'1-;! ,! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(-;! ,! U+;! ,*)!

,)%&*&5'-,'&1*! 5#991-'A! B2(-(! S,5! ,! 582()#.()!%1*'2.:!%(('&*7! '1! -(E&(S! ,*)!

%1*&'1-!9-17-(55!,*)!7&E(!,)E&8(!1*!0#'#-(!5'(95A!

:-!_!=#,+'D./!$#)&'%$&@(!.#0!0$(E3(($+#!

B2&5! '11K! '2(! 01-%! 10! 1*(! &*01-%,.! &*'(-E&(S! S&'2! '2(! "'18K91-'! +QB! 0&*,*8(!

)&-(8'1-! ,*)! 5(E(-,.! &*01-%,.! 81*E(-5,'&1*5!S&'2! '2(! 9(19.(! '2,'!S(-(! &*E1.E()!

S&'2! '2(! 81%915&'&1*! 10! '2(! G#'.&*(! C#5&*(55! Q,5(! 10! "'A! B21%,5! Q1%%#*&':!

2159&',.A! B2(! ,&%! S,5! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! 8#--(*'! $#5&*(55! 8,5(! 9-18(55! '2,'!

"'18K91-'! +QB! S,5! 01..1S&*7! ,*)! '1! S2,'! (`'(*'! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55!

S1#.)!$(! 0(,5&$.(! '1! &*'(7-,'(! ,'! '2(5(!(,-.:! 5',7(5A!B2(!)&58#55&1*! -(5#.'()! &*'1!

&)(*'&0:&*7!'2(!*(()!01-!,!-1$#5'!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!S2(*!)(E(.19&*7!,*!

G#'.&*(! C#5&*(55! Q,5(! IGCQJ! 1-! ,*! &*E(5'%(*'! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*A! B2&5! %('21)! 2,5!

Page 152: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?@F!

81*'-&$#'()!'1!,.51!$(&*7!,$.(!'1!.&*K!'2(!9-1915()!C(3(,.!9-18(55!S&'2!U,'(S,:Y!

-(E&(S5A!!

:-!_!7+E3D&#).)$+#!'&%$&@!1!-)'.)&A$E!C&#&,$)(!$0&#)$,$E.)$+#!D&)6+0!

B2&5!%('21)!81*'-&$#'()!'1!'2(!'-,*5.,'&1*!10!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!E&5&1*!10!"'18K91-'!+QB!

&*!-(.,'&1*! '1!"'A!B21%,5!Q1%%#*&':!2159&',.A! V*!1-)(-! '1!81%9&.(!,!8,',.17#(!10!

$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!(E,.#,'();!,*!&*&'&,.!5'#):!$:!'2(!9-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9!.11K()!&*'1W!

• "'! B21%,5L5! 81%%#*&':! E(*'#-(! [(,.'2! V%9,8'! <55(55%(*'! Z! 3(91-';!

]1E(%$(-!=>>Mq!

• B2(!"'!B21%,5L5!81%%#*&':!E(*'#-(;!]["!"'18K91-'!3(91-';!h#*(!=>>Mq!

• ]["!"'18K91-'!"'-,'(7&8!+.,*!=>>F!'1!=>?N!Z!T,-82!=>>FA!

B2(!-(5#.'!10!'2(!5'#):!)(.&E(-()!,!0&-5'!5('!10!2&72\.(E(.!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!S&..!9-1E&)(!

'2(! )&-(8'&1*! 01-! '2(! "'! B21%,5! 9-1^(8'A! B2(5(! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! 0#-'2(-! (`9.1-()! ,5!

9,-'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!S1-K52195!'2,'!01..1S()A!

:-!_!U.()&'!E/.((!@+'?(6+2!

[1.)&*7!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!%,5'(-!8.,55!,5!9,-'!,*!&*'-1)#8'&1*!'1!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

(.&8&','&1*! S1-K5219;! S,5! *1S! ,! -(5#.'! 10! '2(! 5#88(550#.! )(.&E(-:! 10! '2(! %,5'(-!

8.,55! &*! Q"?!S2(-(! '2(! 0-1%! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! 915&'&E(.:! ,99-,&5()! &'5! #5(0#.*(55A!!!

B2(!%,5'(-!8.,55!'11K!'2(!01-%!10!,!'S1\21#-!&*'(-,8'&E(!5(55&1*!9-&1-!'1!'2(!'S1!

(.&8&','&1*! S1-K52195! ,*)! &*E1.E()! ,..! K(:! 5',K(21.)(-5! '2,'! 9,-'&8&9,'()! ,5!

)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!*(`'!5(8'&1*A!B2(!,&%!S,5W!

• B1!-,&5(!'2(!,S,-(*(55!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2&*K&*7!,*)!,99-1,82q!

• +-(5(*'!21S!'2(!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!S&..!$(!&*E(5'&7,'()!

S&'2&*! ]["! "'18K91-'! ,*)! 21S! &'5! 91'(*'&,.! 81*'-&$#'&1*! '1! '2(! 8#--(*'!

$#5&*(55!8,5(!)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!9-18(55A!

:-!_!Y&#&,$)(!S/$E$).)$+#!@+'?(6+2(!

B2(! 'S1! S1-K52195! S(-(! 018#5()! 1*! (*7,7&*7! K(:! 5',K(21.)(-5! 10! "'! B21%,5!

81%%#*&':!2159&',.!)(E(.19%(*'!&*'1!&)(*'&0:&*7!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!'2&5!9-1^(8'!S&..!

Page 153: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?N>!

$-&*7A! B2(! $(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&()! S&..! $(! #5()! '1! 01-%#.,'(! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

58(*,-&1!'2,'!S&..!$(!9,-'!10!'2(!/#..!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!01-!'2&5!9-1^(8'A!

B2(!%,&*!,&%!S,5!'1!E,.&),'(!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5;!&)(*'&0:!0#-'2(-!91'(*'&,.!5#$!

$(*(0&'5;!,*)!.&5'!5(.(8'();!(*,$.(-5;!,8'1-5;!$(*(0&8&,-&(5;!(*)!$(*(0&'5!I%(,5#-(5J;!

%('21)5!,*)!)&5\$(*(0&'5! 01-!"'!B21%,5!Q1%%#*&':![159&',.A! V*!,))&'&1*! '1! '2,'!

'2(! ,#'21-!S,5! &*E(5'&7,'&*7! 1*! '2(! $(5'! '(82*&4#(! 10! )1&*7! '2&5! ,5!S(..! ,5! 21S!

S1#.)!'2&5!81*'-&$#'(!'1!'2(!1E(-,..!#5,$&.&':!10!'2(!9-18(55A!

+-&1-!'1!'2(!'S1!S1-K52195!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.(5!S(-(!8-(,'()!#5&*7!'2(!

0&*)&*75! 10! '2(! <:-!_!7+E3D&#).)$+#!'&%$&@>A! B2(5(!9-10&.(5! I(`,%9.(! &*! ,99(*)&`!

VVVANJ! S(-(! E,.&),'()! &*! ,7-((%(*'! S&'2! ]["! "'18K91-'! $1,-)! '2-1#72! ,!

9-(5(*','&1*! 0-1%! '2(! 0&*,*8(! )&-(8'1-A! B2(-(! S(-(! R! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'! 8-&'(-&,!

&)(*'&0&()W! <88(55&$&.&':;! Q,9,8&':;! /#*8'&1*,.&':;! H00&8&(*8:;! _21.(! ":5'(%!

G9'&%&5,'&1*!,*)!H,5(!10!&%9.(%(*','&1*A!!

B2(5(! R! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'! 8-&'(-&,! 01-%()! '2(! $,5&5! 01-! )&58#55&1*! ,%1*75'! =D!

5',K(21.)(-5! '2,'! 9,-'&8&9,'()! &*! '2(! 'S1! $(*(0&'! (.&8&','&1*! S1-K52195A! B2(!

5',K(21.)(-5! 9-(5(*'! &*8.#)()! O! U+5;! N! U+! 9-,8'&8(! %,*,7(-5;! ??! "'18K91-'!

+QBa]["! )&-(8'1-5a.(,)5;! ,! 9-1^(8'! 5#991-'! 100&8(-;! @!%(%$(-5! 10! '2(! "'18K91-'!

%,*,7()!8,-(!7-1#9;!=!%(%$(-5!10!+<b"!I+,'&(*'!<)E&8(!,*)!b&,&51*!"(-E&8(J;!,*!

,-82&'(8';!,*)!,!B-&$,.!81*5#.'&*7!-(9-(5(*','&E(A!

B2(!S1-K52195!&*8.#)()!,!%,5'(-!8.,55!1*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!C(3(,.;!S2&82!

9-1E&)()! '2(! 7-1#9! S&'2! ,! $,8K7-1#*)! ,*)! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! 9-18(55A!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! %,5'(-\8.,55;! =! &*'(-,8'&E(! 5(55&1*5! '11K! 9.,8(A! B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5!

S(-(! 7&E(*! $(*(0&'! '(%9.,'(5! '1! 919#.,'(A! B2(:! S(-(! ,5K()! 01-! (,82! 10! '2(! R!

5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'!8-&'(-&,!'1W!

• 6(0&*(!(,82!8-&'(-&1*q!

• V)(*'&0:!"#$!C(*(0&'5!'1!5,'&50:!'2(!8-&'(-&,A!

<*)!01-!(,82!5#$!$(*(0&'!'1!&)(*'&0:W!

• H*,$.(-5W!&A(A!82,*7(5!*(()()!'1!)(.&E(-!'2(!$(*(0&'q!

Page 154: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?N?!

• C(*(0&8&,-&(5!I%,&*!$(*(0&'!-(8&9&(*'5Jq!

• <8'1-5! I%,&*! 9(19.(! 1-! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! *(()! '1! ,8'! '1! )(.&E(-! 1-! 1S*! '2(!

%,*,7(%(*'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'Jq!

• +1'(*'&,.!)&5$(*(0&'5!'2,'!"'!B21%,5!81%%#*&':!2159&',.!%,:!$-&*7A!!

<'!'2(!(*)!10!(,82!5(55&1*!7-1#9!-(9-(5(*','&E(5!9-(5(*'()!'2(&-!0&*)&*75!,*)!&*'(-!

7-1#9! )&58#55&1*5! '11K! 9.,8(! '1! 0#-'2(-! 919#.,'(! ,*)! ,7-((! 1*! '2(! $(*(0&'!

'(%9.,'(5A!

B2(! S1-K52195! -(5#.'()! &*! '2(! 81%915&'&1*! 10! R! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! =@! "#$\

$(*(0&'5A!+,-'&8&9,*'5!2,E(!,.51! &)(*'&0&()!,! .&5'!10!@R!$(*(0&8&,-&(5;!RD!,8'1-5!,*)!

M@!(*,$.(-5!'2,'!S&..! 01-%!'2(!&*9#'!'1!0#-'2(-!,8'&E&'&(5!S2(*!&*'(-)(9(*)(*8&(5!

$('S((*!'215(!(.(%(*'5!S1#.)!$(!(5',$.&52()!&*!1-)(-!'1!01-%#.,'(!,!$(*(0&'5!%,9!

,*)! ,! 9-1915()! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*A! <! .&5'! 10! ?D! )&5\$(*(0&'5! 2,)! ,.51! $((*!

&)(*'&0&()! '2,'! S1#.)! $(! #5()! '1! 0#-'2(-! &*01-%! '2(! 9-1^(8'L5! GCQ! -&5K! -(7&5'(-A!!

B2(5(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!$-&(0.:!&*'-1)#8()!2(-(q!,!0#..!.&5'!10!'2(!S1-K5219!1#'81%(5!&5!

&*8.#)()! &*! ,99(*)&`! VV! IVV! AR! $(*(0&'5;! VVAM! (*,$.(-5;! VVAD! ,8'1-5;! VVAF! $(*(0&8&,-&(5;!

VVA?>!)&5$(*(0&'5JA!!

/1..1S&*7! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '2(! S1-K5219! 0&*)&*75! '2(! &*&'&,.! 7-1#9! 10! 5&`! 5'-,'(7&8!

$(*(0&'5! 2,)! $((*! %1)&0&()! %,&*.:! &*81-91-,'&*7! 'S1! *(S! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5!

)(5&7*()!,5W!!

• "'-,'(7&8!0&'!I,*)!81*'(`'#,.Jq!

• G9(-,'&1*5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!8.&*&8,.!1#'81%(5A!

/1#-! 1'2(-! &*&'&,.! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! S(-(! ,.51! 81*51.&),'()! &*! 'S1! (%(-7&*7!

5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! B,K&*7! &*'1! 81*5&)(-,'&1*! '2(! &*01-%,'&1*! 1$',&*()! 0-1%! '2(!

%(('&*75;! 01-! %15'! 10! '2(! 5#$! $(*(0&'5;! (*,$.(-5;! $(*(0&8&,-&(5;! ,8'1-5;! %(,5#-(5!

,*)!%('21)5!S(-(!&)(*'&0&()A!

!

!

!

Page 155: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?N=!

&/H0'!*-c!=15/1'A)9!H'2'7)1(!9;2(;0)3/1);2!4=!*!!

"'-,'(7&8!C(*(0&'5!

V*&'&,.! ! H%(-7&*7!

\! ! ?A!"'-,'(7&8!0&'!I,*)!81*'(`'#,.J!

\! !=A! G9(-,'&1*5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! 8.&*&8,.!

1#'81%(5!

?A!Q,9,8&':!jj! @A!<99-19-&,'(!$#&.'!(*E&-1*%(*'!

=A!/#*8'&1*,.&':!

@A!<88(55&$&.&':!! jj! NA!<88(55&$&.&':!

NA!_21.(!5:5'(%!19'&%&5,'&1*!jj! OA!_21.(!5:5'(%!19'&%&5,'&1*!,*)!(00&8&(*8:!

OA!H00&8&(*8:!

RA!H,5(!10!&%9.(%(*','&1*! jj! RA!H,5(!10!&%9.(%(*','&1*!

P$-$- I91)<)1B!3'(95)[1);2!/23!;81[81(!;7!4=!-!!

B2(!018#5!10!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!S,5!'1W!

,A /#-'2(-! (5',$.&52! ,*! &*'(-,8'&E(! 5:5'(%,'&8! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! (.&8&'()!

$(*(0&'5;!#*)(-!,!'2-((\.(E(.!1-7,*&5,'&1*!I,)E,*8(%(*'!0-1%!Q"?!,*)!Q"=Jq!

$A 6(E(.19! ,*)! E,.&),'(! ,! 8.(,-! $(*(0&'5! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! %('21);! #*)(-! ,!

8.,55&0&8,'&1*!,99-1,82!I5(7%(*','&1*!81*8(9';!,)E,*8(%(*'!0-1%!Q"=Jq!

8A "'-#8'#-(!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!%(('&*75!S&'2!,!)&E(-5&':!10!5',K(21.)(-5!,5!,!

8-&'&8,.!,59(8'!I,)E,*8(%(*'!0-1%!Q"=!,*)!S&)(-!7-1#9Jq!

)A V)(*'&0:!,*)!'(5'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!S(&72'&*7a-,*K&*7!,99-1,82q!

(A V)(*'&0:!,*)!'(5'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!19'&1*((-&*7!,99-1,82q!,*)!

0A V*'-1)#8(;!&*01-%!,*)!E,.&),'(!,!%1*&'1-&*7a81*'-1..&*7!5'-#8'#-(!81E(-&*7!

'2(!1E(-,..!9-17-,%!.&0(8:8.(!I9,'2S,:!81*8(9'JA!

!

Page 156: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?N@!

!

&/H0'!*Pc!4=-!5'('/59#!@'1#;3(!/23!/)@!

!4=-!:'('/59#!@'1#;3(! >':'/0![#/('! I)@! 4=-!7;98(!

+-1^(8'!_1-K&*7!U-1#9! ! U1E(-*,*8(! !

V*01-%,.!&*'(-E&(S5a)&58#55&1*! ! Q#--(*'!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! !

618#%(*','&1*!3(E&(S! V! "'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*! !I,J!

T,5'(-!8.,55!! <..! C3!9-18(55!,S,-(*(55! !

_1-K5219!5(-&(5!INJ! VV! "#$!!,*)!H*)!C(*(0&'5!H.&8&','&1*! I,J!

_1-K5219!O! VV! C(*(0&'5!)(0&*&'&1*! I,J!

_1-K5219!R! VV! G9'&1*((-&*7!! I)J!I(J!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!_1-K5219! <..!! /(()$,8K!a!G#'9#'5!E,.&),'&1*! <..!

:-f!5'+V&E)!@+'?$#A!A'+32!

B2(! @B5! 9-1^(8'! 2,)! ,.-(,):! 9-&1-! 10! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):;! (5',$.&52()! ,! 9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(%(*'!1-7,*&5,'&1*! '1!)-&E(! '2(!9-1^(8'! 01-S,-)A!B2(!,#'21-!S&'2!,*1'2(-!

'S1! [,QV3VQ! -(5(,-82(-5! ^1&*()! '2&5! 7-1#9! ,*)! S1-K()! ,.1*7! '2(! 9-17-,%%(!

)&-(8'1-;! '2(!,55&5',*'!)&-(8'1-!10!8,9&',.!)(E(.19%(*'! 01-!C"P[;!,!5(-E&8(! .(,);!,!

2(,.'28,-(! 9.,*(-! ,*)! ,)%&*&5'-,'&1*! 5#991-'A! B2(! 7-1#9! 2,)! S((K.:!

'(.(81*0(-(*8(! ,*)!%1*'2.:! 0,8(\'1\0,8(!%(('&*75! '1!%1*&'1-! 9-17-(55! ,*)! 9.,*!

'2(!,8'&E&'&(5!)(58-&$()!&*!'2&5!5(8'&1*A!

:-f!=#,+'D./!$#)&'%$&@(!.#0!0$(E3(($+#!.#0!0+E3D&#).)$+#!'&%$&@!

B2(!,8'&E&'&(5! '1!,)19'!,!$(*(0&'! -(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82! &*! '2(!9-1^(8'!$(7,*!$(01-(!

#*)(-',K&*7! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):;! ,5! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! )&-(8'1-! 10! '2(! @B5! )(E(.19%(*'!

S,5!,!%(%$(-!10!'2(!C(3(,.!,)E&51-:!7-1#9A!V*!'2,'!9(-&1);!'2(-(!S(-(!'2-((!%,^1-!

9-(! 8,5(! 5'#):! &*01-%&*7! ,8'&E&'&(5! .()! $:! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! )&-(8'1-! ,&%&*7! '1!

)&58#55! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! ,! %,^1-! 2159&',.! )(E(.19%(*'! S&..! $-&*7! '1! ,..!

5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()A! B2(5(! '2-((! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,5! )(58-&$()! $(.1S! '2(-(! S(-(!

Page 157: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?NN!

8,--&()!1#'!9-&1-!'1!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*;!)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!E,.&),'&1*!

,8'&E&'&(5A!

B2(! 0&-5'! 9-(\8,5(! 5'#):! &*01-%&*7! ,8'&E&':! S,5! '2(! -)'.)&A$E! C&#&,$)(! &/$E$).)$+#!

2(.)! &*! /($-#,-:! =>>D! S2(-(! &*! &*! ,! S1-K5219! 9-&1-! '1! '2(! ,99-1E,.! 10! '2(!

-)'.)&A$E!b3)/$#&!:.(&!I"GQJ! 5&`! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! 2,)!$((*! (.&8&'()W! I?J! 5'-,'(7&8!

0&'q!I=J!8.&*&8,.!1#'81%(5q!I@J!%1)(-*!2(,.'28,-(!0,8&.&'&(5q!INJ!&%9-1E()!,88(55q!IOJ!

'(,82&*7;!'-,&*&*7!,*)!-(5(,-82q!,*)!IRJ!(00(8'&E(!#5(!10!-(51#-8(5A!

B2(!5(81*)!9-(!8,5(!5'#):!&*01-%&*7!,8'&E&':!S,5!,!5.)$&#)!.#0!-).,,!7&($A#!g+'3D!

2(.)! &*! "(9'(%$(-! =>>DA! V'! S,5! ,! S1-K5219! ,*)! 9,-'! 10! '2(! +,'&(*'! ,*)! +#$.&8!

V*E1.E(%(*'!I++VJ!(001-'5!'2,'!,-(!-(4#&-()!01-!'2&5!':9(!10!71E(-*%(*',.!9-1^(8'5A!

B2&5!S1-K5219!7(*(-,'()!,!.&5'!10!)(5&7*!-(4#(5'5!IE(-:!59(8&0&8!&55#(5J!'2,'!S1#.)!

.,'(-!$(!,*,.:5()!,*)!,))-(55()!)#-&*7!'2(!)(5&7*!92,5(A!B2&5!.&5'!S1#.)!.,'(-!$(!

&*8.#)()!&*!'2(!9-18(55!10!'-,8K&*7!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!

B2(!'2&-)!,8'&E&':!S,5!,!S1-K5219!S&'2!%,^1-!9,'&(*'!5',K(21.)(-!7-1#9!%(%$(-5!

,&%&*7!'1!7('!'2(&-!E&(S!1*!91'(*'&,.!$(*(0&'5!10!'2(!582(%(!9-1915()A!B2(!C"P[!

@B5!9-1^(8'!)&-(8'1-!,*)!'S1!5(-E&8(!&%9-1E(%(*'!0,8&.&','1-5!&*!"(9'(%$(-!=>>D!

0,8&.&','()! '2(!9,'&(*'! 01-#%q!?D!9,'&(*'! -(9-(5(*','&E(5!S(-(! &*E&'()A!B2(! 01-#%!

7,E(! 9,'&(*'5! -(9-(5(*','&E(5! ,*! 1991-'#*&':! '1! )&58#55! ,! *#%$(-! 10! &55#(5!

&*8.#)&*7! '2(! )(5&7*! 10! '2(! $#&.)&*7;! 1#'\9,'&(*'! 81%%#*&8,'&1*5;! '-,*591-';!

E&5&'&*7;! &*9,'&(*'!5',:!,*)! .(,E&*7! '2(!2159&',.A!/-1%!'2(5(!)&58#55&1*5!,! '1',.!10!

=D>!$(*(0&'5!S(-(!&)(*'&0&()A!!

/1..1S&*7!)&58#55&1*!,*)!-(E&(S!10!'2(!%&*#'(5!,*)!)18#%(*','&1*!9-1)#8()!,5!,!

-(5#.';! '2(! ,#'21-! &*81-91-,'()! '2(! 0&*)&*75! '1! K&8K! 100! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!8,5(!5'#):A!

:-f!U.()&'!E/.((!@+'?(6+2!

C#&.)&*7!1*!0-1%!'2(!K*1S.()7(!,*)!(`9(-&(*8()!7,&*()!1*!Q"?!,*)!Q"=!,!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!%,5'(-!8.,55!9-(8()()!(,82!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!S1-K5219A!B2(!%,5'(-!

8.,55!'11K!'2(!01-%!10!,!1*(\21#-!&*'(-,8'&E(!5(55&1*!,*)!&*E1.E()!,..!5',K(21.)(-5!

'2,'!9,-'&8&9,'()!&*!(,82!5(55&1*!,5!)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!*(`'!5(8'&1*A!B2(!,&%!S,5W!

Page 158: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?NO!

• B1!-,&5(!'2(!,S,-(*(55!10!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2&*K&*7!,*)!,99-1,82q!

• +-(5(*'!21S!'2(!9-1915()!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!S&..!$(!&*E(5'&7,'()!

S&'2&*!'2(!@B5!9-1^(8'A!!

:-f!I+'?(6+2!(&'$&(!!\JOd]H!!-3C!.#0!&#0!C&#&,$)(!&/$E$).)$+#!!

B2(! ,#'21-! S&'2! 'S1! 1'2(-! -(5(,-82(-5! 0-1%! [,QV3VQ! 0,8&.&','()! '2(! (.&8&','&1*!

S1-K52195! S&'2! )&00(-(*'! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! '1! 81%%#*&8,'(! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8!

$(*(0&'5! 9-(E&1#5.:! )&58#55()! ,*)! -,&5(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'!

9-18(55!,S,-(*(55!,*)!*(()A!"#$5(4#(*'.:!9,-'&8&9,*'5!S(-(!,5K()!'1!&)(*'&0:!,*)!

)(0&*(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!'2(!@B5!9-17-,%%(!-()(E(.19%(*'!S1#.)!.&K(!'1!)(.&E(-A!B2(!

018#5!S,5!1*!1#'81%(5!0-1%!,*!(*)\#5(-!9(-59(8'&E(!,*)!'2(!)&00(-(*'!5',K(21.)(-!

7-1#95A!

!B2(!1#'81%(!10!'2(5(!S1-K52195!S,5!,!.&5'!10!-()(0&*()!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!,*)!5#$\

$(*(0&'5A! B2(! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! -()(0&*()! S(-(W! I,J! 7(*(-,'&1*! 10! 1#'81%(5! &*!

81%9.&,*8(!'1!]["L5!5'-,'(7&8!&*'(*'!I2(,.'2!91.&8&(5Jq!I$J!&*8-(,5()!.18,.!,88(55!'1!

2(,.'28,-(! 5(-E&8(5q! I8J! ,)(4#,'(! 0,8&.&'&(5! ,*)! 0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'q! I)J!

&%9-1E()! 8.&*&8,.! 1#'81%(5q! I(J! (00&8&(*'! ,*)! *1*\)&5-#9'&E(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)!

&%9.(%(*','&1*! 9-18(55q! I0J! &%9-1E()! '-,&*&*7;! '(,82&*7! ,*)! -(5(,-82! 5K&..5q! I7J!

&%9-1E()!%,*,7(%(*'! 10! 5(-E&8(! 19(-,'&1*5q! ,*)! I2J! $(''(-! #5(! 10! -(51#-8(5! '1!

)(.&E(-!2&72!4#,.&':!8,-(A!B2(!81*51.&),'()!5('!10!5'-,'(7&8!,*)!5#$!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&'()!

&*!'2(!01#-!$(*(0&'5!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!S1-K52195!&5!521S*!&*!B,$.(!=OA!

B2(! 7-1#9! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! '2,'! S(-(! 5(.(8'()! $:! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#9! '1!

9,-'&8&9,'(!S(-(!'2(!1*(5!'2,'!S1#.)!2,E(!,!)&-(8'! &%9,8'!1-!$(! &%9,8'()!$:!'2(!

@B5!-()(E(.19%(*'A!H,82!7-1#9!S1#.)!01-%!'2(!,''(*)((5!01-!1*(!S1-K5219A!B2(!N!

7-1#95!S(-(W!

I?J!+,'&(*'!-(9-(5(*','&E(5;!,*)!+,'&(*'!H`9(-&(*8(!+,*(.!\!?=!9,-'&8&9,*'5q!

I=J!B2(!@B5!C"P[!9-17-,%%(!$1,-)!\!?=!9,-'&8&9,*'5q!

T()&8,.!9-10(55&1*,.5!,*)!-(9-(5(*','&E(5!0-1%W!

Page 159: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?NR!

I@J! T()&8&*(aH.)(-.:! 8,-(;! '-,#%,a8-&'&8,.! 8,-(;! *(#-158&(*8(5! Z! ?N!

9,-'&8&9,*'5q!

INJ!V%,7&*7a8,*8(-a8.&*&8,.!&*0(8'&1*!5(-E&8(a1#'9,'&(*'5!Z!?R!9,-'&8&9,*'5A!

B2(5(!S1-K52195!S(-(!#5()!'1!7,&*!'2(!E&(S5!10!'2(!)&00(-(*'!7-1#95!1*!C"P[!@B5!

,*)! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2(:! $(.&(E(! '2(! C"P[! @B! 9-17-,%%(! 521#.)! $-&*7A! B2(!

S1-K52195!S(-(!59.&'! &*'1!'S1!5(55&1*5!I,J!,!9.,**(-:!5(55&1*!S2(-(!'2(!,&%5!10!

'2(!S1-K5219!S(-(!)&58#55()!,*)!'2(!%('21)1.17:!10!(.&8&','&1*!S,5!,7-(()!,*)!

I$J! ,! 018#5! 7-1#9! 5(55&1*! S2(-(! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! S1-K()! '17('2(-! &*! (.&8&'&*7!

$(*(0&'5A! B2&5! ,99-1,82! 7,E(! 5',K(21.)(-5! '2(! 82,*8(! '1! )&58#55;! ,7-((;! )&5,7-((!

,*)a1-!)(E(.19!,!52,-()!9(-59(8'&E(!I[,K&%;!=>>>JA!

6#-&*7!'2(!S1-K52195!,*!1E(-,..!10!RD=!$(*(0&'5!S(-(!(.&8&'()!'2(5(!&*8.#)()!,!.1'!

10!-(9('&'&1*!1-!)&00(-(*'!&*'(-9-(','&1*5!10!'2(!5,%(!'(-%A!B2(!$(*(0&'5!S(-(!'2(*!

5#%%,-&5()!$:!'2(!9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7!7-1#9!,*)!81%9&.()!&*'1!'S1!%,&*!8,'(71-&(5!

81*5&5'&*7!10!D!()'.)&A$E!C&#&,$)(!,*)!@M!(3C!C&#&,$)(!I9-(5(*'()!&*!B,$.(!=OJA!

:-f!I+'?(6+2!M!O!Y&#&,$)(!0&,$#$)$+#!!

B2&5!S1-K5219!S,5!0,8&.&','()!$:!'2(!@B5!9-1^(8'!)&-(8'1-!,*)!S,5!,''(*)()!$:!'2(!

-(.(E,*'! C"P[! @B! 5',K(21.)(-5F;! ,*)! 188#--()! $('S((*! '2(! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*!

S1-K5219!5(-&(5!,*)!'2(!?5'!19'&1*((-&*7!S1-K5219A!B2(!,&%!S,5!'1!)(E(.19!'2(!,!

)(58-&9'&1*! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 51! '2(:! 8,*! $(! #5()! &*! ,!%(,*&*70#.!S,:! ,'! '2(! *(`'!

9.,**()! S1-K5219! '2,'! S1#.)! )(,.! S&'2! 5(.(8'&*7! '2(! 9-(0(--()! )(5&7*! 19'&1*!

$,5()! 1*! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! 2,)! $:! *1S! (.&8&'();! 81*51.&),'()! ,*)! )(0&*()! &*! ,*!

,7-(()! ,99-1,82! $:! ,.! K(:! 5',K(21.)(-5A! B2(! ',$.(! 10! '2(5(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! '2(&-!

)(0&*&'&1*5!&5!&*8.#)()!&*!<99(*)&`!VVA??!

:-f!I+'?(6+2!LH!b2)$+#&&'$#A!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!F!! "',K(21.)(-5W!6&-(8'1-!10!&*'(*5&E(!8,-(q!81*5#.',*'!2&5'19,'21.17&5'q!81*5#.',*'!5#-7(1*q!8.&*&8,.!)&-(8'1-;!

(%(-7(*8:! 8,-(;! +bQ! H]BaT/Pa#-1.17:a$-(,5';! @B5! )(9#':! 8.&*&8,.! .(,);! 81*5#.',*'! ,*,(5'2('&5';! 82&(0!*#-5(;!5(`#,.!2(,.'2!r![VX!81*5#.',*';!%,'-1*q!,!%()&8,.!)&-(8'1-q!,*)!,!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(-A!

Page 160: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?NM!

B2(! @B5! (5','(5! )&-(8'1-! S21!S,5! ,.51! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! )&-(8'1-! 01-! '2&5! 9-1^(8'!

0,8&.&','()! '2&5! )1#$.(! 9#-915(!S1-K5219A! B2(! ,#'21-! 9,-'&8&9,'()! ,*)! 1$5(-E()!

'2&5! ,8'&E&':!2,E&*7!9-&1-! '1! &'!)&58#55()! '2(!9-1915()!19'&1*((-&*7!9-18(55!S&'2!

'2(!0,8&.&','1-!,*)!,7-(()!'2(!%('21)!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!521#.)!$(!#5()!'1!)('(-%&*(!'2(!

9-(0(--()!)(5&7*!19'&1*!$:!'2(!K(:!5',K(21.)(-5A!B2&5!9-18(55!.,5'()!O!21#-5!,*)!

&'5!)&-(8'!1#'9#'5!,-(!5#%%,-&5()!$(.1SA!!

B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! 10! '2&5! S1-K5219! S(-(! K(:! 5',K(21.)(-5! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)!

&*8.#)()!-(9-(5(*','&E(5!0-1%!,..!'2(!7-1#95!'2,'!2,E(!9,-'&8&9,'()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!

S1-K52195!I?\NJ!'1!(*5#-(!81*'&*#&':!,*)!(*5#-(!'2,'!5',K(21.)(-5!S(-(!(*7,7()!

&*! '2(! )(8&5&1*! 9-18(55A! B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! &*8.#)()! '2(! C"P[! QHG;! ?>! 5(*&1-!

%,*7(-5;! O! 9,'&(*'! 7-1#9! -(9-(5(*','&E(5;! O! 2(,.'28,-(! 81%%&55&1*(-5;! @! .18,.!

,#'21-&':! -(9-(5(*','&E(5! ,*)! ?=! %()&8,.! 9-10(55&1*,.! -(9-(5(*','&E(5! '2,'! ,.51!

9,-'&8&9,'()! &*! S1-K5219! OA! IB2(! 0,8&.&','1-;! '2(! QHG! ,*)! '2(! ,#'21-! )&)! *1'!

9,-'&8&9,'(!&*!'2(!581-&*7!,*)!S(&72'&*7!10!'2(!19'&1*5JA!

B2(!0,8&.&','1-!K&8K()!100!'2(!S1-K5219!$:!9-(5(*'&*7!'2(!)(5&7*!19'&1*5!,E,&.,$.(!

S2&82!&*8.#)()!'S1!19'&1*5!10! c)1!%&*L![(!,.51!(`9.,&*()!'2,'!'2(!=!)1!%&*&%#%!

19'&1*5!,-(!^#5'!'1!0#.0&.!5'(95!-(4#&-()!$:!'2(!'-(,5#-:A!B215(!19'&1*5!S&..!*1'!$(!

)(E(.19();!,5!'2(:!)1!*1'!,.&7*!S&'2!'2(!E&5&1*!01-!'2(!@B5!S2(-(!,!#*&4#(!2159&',.!

&5!*(()()A!

B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5!S(-(! &*E&'()! '1! 5(.(8'! I&*'#&'&E(.:J! '2(&-! 9-(0(--()! 19'&1*A! H,82!

,''(*)((!S1#.)!9,-'&8&9,'(!&*!,8'&E&':!$:!581-&*7!(,82!19'&1*!'1!'2(!)(7-((!'2(:!0(.'!

&'! S1#.)! 5,'&50:! '2(! D! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 5#$\$(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&()! &*! 9-(E&1#5!

%(('&*75! I_1-K52195?\NJ! ,*)! ,5! )(0&*()! &*! S1-K5219! OA! <! ',$.(! S&'2! '2(5(!

$(*(0&'5! ,*)! 5#$\$(*(0&'5! &*8.#)&*7! S,5! 7&E(*! '1! (,82! 9,-'&8&9,*'! 9-&1-! '1! '2(!

9-(5(*','&1*!I&*8.#)()!&*!<99(*)&`!VVA??JA!

V*!'2(!-11%;!$1,-)5!81*',&*&*7!,!)(58-&9'&1*!10!(,82!19'&1*!I582(%,'&8!9.,*5!,*)!

'2-((\)&%(*5&1*,.!E&(S5!Z! 0-1%!'2(!-1,)!91&*'!10!E&(S!,*)!0-1%!'2(!5((!91&*'!10!

E&(S!Z!5K:.&*(JA!B2(5(!$1,-)5!,.51!2,)!)&,7-,%5!)(58-&$&*7!2&72! .(E(.5!92,5(5!10!

'2(!81*5'-#8'&1*!9-18(55A!

Page 161: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?ND!

G*.:! *1*\0&*,*8&,.! $(*(0&'5! S(-(! #5()! &*! '2&5! S1-K5219! ,*)! '2(! 0,8&.&','1-!

2&72.&72'()!'2,'!'2(!-(5#.'5!10!'2&5!5(8'&1*!S,5!71&*7!'1!$(!#5()!&*!'2(!5#$5(4#(*'!

S1-K52195!S&'2!'2(!-(5#.'5!10!,!8,9&',.!815'!,*,.:5&5!,*)!-#**&*7!815'!,*,.:5&5!I,5!

9(-!'2(!19'&1*((-&*7!5'(95!)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!OA@A@JA!

B2(! ,-82&'(8'! )(58-&$()! '2(! )(5&7*! 19'&1*5! ,E,&.,$.(! ,*)! (`9.,&*()! &55#(5! .&K(!

81*'(`';!*(&72$1#-5;!,88(55;!E&(S5;!S2,'!'1!-(',&*;!('8A!S(-(!',K(*!&*'1!,881#*'!,5!,!

-(5#.'! 10! '2(! 9-(\8,5(! 5'#):! 81*5#.','&1*! %(('&*75! )(58-&$()! (,-.&(-A! B2(! %,&*!

81*8(9'!#5()!S,5!'2(!u8,%9#5!.&K(v!':9(!10!$#&.)&*7!S2&82!&*'(7-,'(5!'2(!(`&5'&*7!

0,8&.&'&(5!'1!'2(!*(S!1*(5!,.51!&%9-1E&*7!'2(!1-&(*','&1*!,*)!0.1S!10!9(19.(!,8-155!

'2(! *(S! )(E(.19%(*';! '2(-(01-(! &%9-1E&*7! 9,'&(*'! (`9(-&(*8(! S&'21#'! 5(-E&8(!

)&5-#9'&1*A!

<0'(-!'2(!9-(5(*','&1*!'2(!0,8&.&','1-!(`9.,&*()!'2(!581-&*7!(`(-8&5(!'2,'!S,5!$,5()!

1*!0&-5'!5(.(8'&*7!&*'#&'&E(.:!'2(!$(5'!19'&1*!,*)!5(81*)!$:!0&..&*7!'2(!581-&*7!',$.(A!

V*!-(7,-)5!'2(!.,''(-!&5!&%91-',*'!'1!%(*'&1*!5,&)!'2,'!'2(!581-(5!S1#.)!$(!0-1%!?!

IS1-5'!19'&1*J!'1!?>!'2(!$(5'!19'&1*A!B2(!5#77(5'&1*!S,5!%,)(!'1!'2(!,''(*)((5!'1!

.(,E(!-1S5!&*!$.,*K!01-!'215(!S21!0(.'!*1*\4#,.&0&()!'1!,55(55!,!$(*(0&'A!N>!%&*#'(5!

S,5!7&E(*!'1!'2(!,''(*)((5!'1!0&..!&*!'2(!',$.(A!

@@!1#'!10!@O!,''(*)((5!IFOxJ!5(.(8'()!19'&1*!?!,5!'2(&-!&*'#&'&E(!0&-5'!19'&1*A!B2(!

1'2(-!=!E1'(5!S(*'!'1!19'&1*!@A!B2(!-(5#.'5!10!'2(!581-&*7!(`(-8&5(!S(-(!*1'!%,)(!

,E,&.,$.(!)#-&*7!'2(!%(('&*7A!

G*8(! '2(! 581-&*7! (`(-8&5(! S,5! 0&*&52()! '2(! 0,8&.&','1-! 5',-'()! (`9.,&*&*7! '2(!

S(&72'&*7! (`(-8&5(A! B2&5! (`(-8&5(! 5',-'()!S&'2! -,*K&*7! '2(! D! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! &*!

1-)(-!10!&%91-',*8(!,*)!'2(*!,''-&$#'&*7!,!9(-8(*',7(!'1!'2&5!$(*(0&'5!-(.,'()!'1!&'5!

-(.(E,*8(A! B2(! D! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! 521#.)! ,))! '17('2(-! ,! '1',.! 10! ?>>xA! B2(!

-,*K&*7!,*)!'2(!-(.(E,*8(!S(-(!7,'2(-()!'2-1#72!81*5(*5#5!10!'2(!7-1#9A!!

B2(!0&*,.!-(5#.'5!10!'2&5!(`(-8&5(!S2(-(W!

• Q.&*&8,.!1#'81%(5!I=J!,*)!,99-19-&,'(!0,8&.&'&(5!I@J!,5!'2(!%15'!-(.(E,*'!10!

'2(!$(*(0&'5!&*!(4#,.!.(E(.!10!&%91-',*8(q!

Page 162: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?NF!

• "'-,'(7&8! 0&'! I?J! ,*)! 19(-,'&1*,.! %,*,7(%(*'! IMJ! ,5! '2(! 5(81*)! %15'!

-(.(E,*'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!,*)!&*!(4#,.!.(E(.!10!&%91-',*8(q!

• <88(55! '1!5(-E&8(5! INJ!,*)! '(,82&*7;! '-,&*&*7!,*)!-(5(,-82! IOJ!,5! '2(! '2&-)!

%15'!-(.(E,*'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!,*)!&*!(4#,.!.(E(.!10!&%91-',*8(q!

• P5(!10!-(51#-8(5!IRJ!,5!'2(!01#-'2!%15'!-(.(E,*'!,*)!&%91-',*'q!

• 6(E(.19%(*'!,*)!&%9.(%(*','&1*!,5!'2(!.(,5'!-(.(E,*'!,*)!&%91-',*'A!

B2(!,''(*)((5!S(-(!81*5#.'()!S2('2(-!51%(1*(!2,-).:!)&5,7-(()!S&'2!'2(!-,*K&*7!

,$1E(A!]1!(`9-(55&1*!10!)&5,7-((%(*'!S,5!-,&5()A!!

B2(! 9,-'&8&9,*'5!S(-(! '2(*! ,5K()! '1! ,''-&$#'(! ,! 9(-8(*',7(! 01-! (,82! 10! '2(! 5#$\

$(*(0&'5;!,881-)&*7!'1!'2(!,%1#*'!7&E(*!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!-,*K&*7!(`(-8&5(A![1S(E(-;!

&'! S,5! 2&72.&72'()! '2,'! '215(! E,.#(5! 81#.)! $(! 82,*7()! &0! ,)^#5'%(*'5! S(-(!

*(8(55,-:A!B2(!-(5#.'5!,-(!9-(5(*'()!&*!B,$.(!=OA!!

&/H0'!*Nc!4=-!L!>=C.!-&(!!L!63'21)7)9/1);2D!;5A/2)(/1);2!/23!R')A#1)2A!;7!(15/1'A)9!/23!(8H!H'2'7)1(!

>'2'7)1(!6%!! >'2'7)1(!90/(()7)9/1);2!!! V')A#1)2A!!=15/1'A)9!! =8H!! i!

?A! "'-,'(7&8!0&'!I,*)!81*'(`'#,.J! !! ! ,-$P!?A>?! "',K(21.)(-5!,.&7*%(*'! ! !! =AR!?A>=! ":*(-7:!10!5(-E&8(5! ! !! =AR!?A>@! Q1*'(`'!)(E(.19%(*'! ! !! =AR!?A>N! Q1\.18,'&1*!a!)&5'-&$#'&1*! ! !! @AM!?A>O! V%,7(;!-(9#','&1*;!1$^(8'&E(5! ! !! ?AF!=A! Q.&*&8,.!1#'81%(5! !! ! ,O$U!=A>?! Q1\.18,'&1*! ! !! @A>!=A>=! 3()#8(!-(0(--,.5! ! !! =A@!=A>@! V%9-1E()!4#,.&':!10!8,-(! ! !! RA@!=A>N! V%9-1E(!8,-(!1#'81%(5! ! !! RA@!

@A! <99-19-&,'(!0,8&.&'&(5!I,*)!0,8&.&'&(5!%,*,7(%(*'J!

!! ! =OA>!

@A>?! /&'\01-!9#-915(!$#&.)&*7!,*)!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(! ! !! @A>!@A>=! /,8&.&'&(5!0.(`&$&.&':!,*)!0#'#-(!9-110&*7! ! !! @A>!

@A>@! +2:5&8,.! )&5'-&$#'&1*! 10! 5(-E&8(! .18,'&1*5!I.,:1#'J! ! !! NA>!

@A>N! V%9-1E()!5#991-'!5(-E&8(5! ! !! =A>!@A>O! V*8-(,5()!9,'&(*'a#5(-!5,0(':! ! !! OA>!@A>R! U-(,'(-!9-&E,8:!I$:!$(''(-!)(5&7*J! ! !! @A>!@A>M! 3(%1E,.!10!$,8K.17!%,&*'(*,*8(! ! !! ?A>!@A>D! C(''(-!S1-K&*7!(*E&-1*%(*'! ! !! NA>!NA! <88(55!'1!5(-E&8(5! !! ! ,+$O!NA>?! "(-E&8(!)&E(-5&':a8,9,8&':!0&'! ! !! OAN!NA>=! V*8-(,5()!92:5&8,.!,88(55! ! !! @AO!NA>@! V*8-(,5()!,E,&.,$&.&':!10!5(-E&8(5! ! !! ?AD!OA! B-,&*&*7;!'(,82&*7!,*)!-(5(,-82! !! ! S$U!OA>?! V%9-1E()!-(5(,-82!8,9,$&.&':! ! !! @AR!OA>=! V%9-1E()!'(,82&*7! ! !! @AR!

Page 163: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?O>!

b(7(*)W!!!\!T,&*!018#5A!

<),9'()!0-1%W!",91#*'e&5!&)!./9!I=>>FJ!,*)!g,'(5!&)!./9!I=>>FJA!Q1)&*21'1!r!+,55%,*!I=>>FJA!

[,E&*7!81%9.('()!'2(!$(*(0&'5!S(&72'&*7!,*)!-,*K&*7!I,99(*)&`!VVA?=J!&'!S,5!'2(*!

9155&$.(!'1!581-(!'2(!9-1915()!19'&1*5!I$('S((*!?!,*)!OJ!&*!-(.,'&1*!'1!'2(!-,*K&*7!

10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! &)(*'&0:! '2(! 0&*,.! )(5&7*! 9-1915,.! '1! $(! 8,--&()! 01-S,-)A! B2(!

9,-'&8&9,*'5! &*5(-'()! '2(&-! 581-(! &*! '2(! 59-(,)52(('! 9-1E&)()! I5((! (`,%9.(! &*!

<99(*)&`!VVA?@J!,*)!'2(!0&*,.!8,.8#.,'&1*5!-(5#.'()!&*'1!cG9'&1*!?L!$(&*7!5(.(8'()!,5!

'2(!9-(0(--()!)(5&7*!19'&1*!$,5()!1*! '2(!5',K(21.)(-5L!9(-8(9'&1*;!,5! '2(!19'&1*!

'2,'!S&..!%15'!9-1$,$.(!$(!$(''(-!)(5&7*()!'1!)(.&E(-!'2(!%15'!,*)!%1-(!&%91-',*'!

$(*(0&'5A!

P$P &#'!/3<)(;5B!A5;8[!</0)3/1);2!@'1#;3!

/-1%! '2(! $(7&**&*7! ,*)! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! -(5(,-82! '2(! ,#'21-! S&'2! '2(! [,QV3VQ!

P*&E(-5&':!10!",.01-)!,8,)(%&8!)&-(8'1-!(5',$.&52()!,*!,)E&51-:!7-1#9! '1!9-(5(*'!

2&5! 0&*)&*75;! &*&'&,..:! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'.:! 01-%! '2(! 8,5(!

5'#)&(5;!'1!0#-'2(-!&*01-%!,*)!E,.&),'(!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!!

B2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! 81*5&5'()! 10! ,8,)(%&85! ,*)! &*)#5'-&,.&5'5! '2,'! &*8.#)();! '2(!

],'&1*,.! <#)&'! G00&8(! I]<GJ! )&-(8'1-! 01-! +#$.&8! +-&E,'(! +,-'*(-52&95;! '2(!

6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!I61[J!)&-(8'1-!10!(5','(5!,*)!0,8&.&'&(5!,*)!2(,)!10!U,'(S,:Y!

-(E&(S5;!,!.(,)!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S(-!0-1%!61[;!'2(!Q1%%#*&':![(,.'2!+,-'*(-52&95!

OA>@! d*1S.()7(!'-,*50(-! ! !! ?AM!RA! P5(!10!-(51#-8(5! !! ! ?>AM!RA>?! C(''(-!(4#&9%(*'a-(81#-5(5!I'(82*1.17:J! ! !! @AO!RA>=! C(''(-!9(-51**(.! ! !! ?AD!RA>@! V%9-1E()!(00&8&(*8:! ! !! OAN!MA! G9(-,'&1*5!%,*,7(%(*'! ! ! ?=AO!MA>?! V%9-1E()!5(-E&8(!811-)&*,'&1*! ! ! @AO!MA>=! +-(E(*'&E(!2(,.'2!5(-E&8(5! ! ! NAM!MA>@! V%9-1E()!#5(-!(`9(-&(*8(! ! ! NA@!DA! 6(E(.19%(*'!,*)!&%9.(%(*','&1*! !! ! >AF!DA>?! V*E(5'%(*'!a!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!(001-'! ! !! >AF!DA>=! Q1*5'-#8'&1*!*(7,'&E(!&%9,8'! ! !! *aS!DA>@! +.,**&*7!,$&.&':! ! !! *aS!DA>N! "#5',&*,$&.&':! ! !! *aS!DA>O! 6(E(.19%(*'!0(,5&$&.&':! ! !! *aS!DA>R! 3()#8(!5(-E&8(!&*'(--#9'&1*! ! !! *aS!DA>M! /,5'(-!)(.&E(-:!I#9!'1!19(-,'&1*J! ! !! *aS!

Page 164: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?O?!

Q[+!Pd!82,&-%,*;!,!K*1S.()7(!52,-(!%,*,7(-!0-1%!Q[+;!'2(!9-17-,%!)&-(8'1-!10!

]["!T,"B!bV/B!9,-'*(-52&9;! '2(!T,"B!bV/B! 81! 82,&-;! '2(!)&-(8'1-!10! (5','(5! ,*)!

0,8&.&'&(5!10!C-&72'1*!"#55(`!P*&E(-5&':![159&',.5!]["!B-#5';!'2(!0&*,*8(!)&-(8'1-!10!

]["!"'18K91-';! ,! -(9-(5(*','&E(!10! ",.01-)!31:,.![159&',.!B-#5';! ,! 5(*&1-!9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(-! 01-! '2(! h1&*! [(,.'2! P*&'! 10! '2(! T,*82(5'(-! Q&':! Q1#*8&.;! ,! 0,8&.&'&(5!

%,*,7(-!0-1%!+-&%,-:!+.#5!b');! '2(![,QV3VQ!-(5(,-82!'(,%!;!,*)!@!9-10(551-5! &*!

'2(! 0&(.)5! 10! 9-18(55! %,*,7(%(*';! .(,*! 9-1)#8'&1*! '2(1-:! ,*)! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

(`8(..(*8(A!B2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!%('!5(E(*!'&%(5!)#-&*7!'2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! &*'1! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55A!!

<!5#%%,-:!10! '2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!%(('&*75aS1-K52195! &5!9-(5(*'()! &*!'2(!B,$.(!

=R!,*)!01..1S()!$:!,!)(',&.()!)(58-&9'&1*!10!(,82!1*(!(`'-,8'()!0-1%!'2(!S1-K5219!

%&*#'(5!,*)!-(91-'5!9-1)#8()!)#-&*7!'2(!-(5(,-82A!

&/H0'!*Tc!!:'('/59#!@'1#;3(c!/3<)(;5B!A5;8[!@''1)2A(eR;5M(#;[!(8@@/5B!

I3<)(;5B!A5;8[!! %/1'! K;!;7![/51)9)[/21(! IE!7;98(!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9?!Z!<U?! =Oa>?a=>>M! =R!b&'(-,'#-(!3(E&(S;!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55;!

8,5(!5'#):!5'-,'(7:!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!=!Z!<U=! >=a>Oa=>>M! =?! C(3(,.!,*)!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!@!Z!<U@! =Ra>Fa=>>M! ?R! B2(!-1.(!10!5',K(21.)(-5!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!N!Z!<UN! ?Na>=a=>>D! ?>!Q"?!0&*)&*75!E,.&),'&1*!\!"'-,'(7:!,*)!

<55(55%(*'!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!O!Z!<UO! =@a>Fa=>>D! ?@! Q"=!0&*)&*75!E,.&),'&1*!\!H.&8&','&1*!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!R!Z!<UR! >Oa>@a=>>F! =N!Q"@!0&*)&*75!E,.&),'&1*!Z!G9'&1*((-&*7!

,*)!+,'2S,:!

<)E&51-:!U-1#9!M!Z!<UM! >=a>=a=>?>! =?! /&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!!!\!<..!92,5(5!

V*!'2(!,$'()!D&&)$#A!\FTJ]!2(.)!&*!h,*#,-:!=>>M;!'2(!,#'21-!9-(5(*'()!'1!'2(!7-1#9!

'2(! &*&'&,.! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S;! 81%$&*()! S&'2! 2&5! 9(-51*,.!

(`9(-&(*8(!,*)!&*'(-9-(','&1*!10!21S!'2(!-(5(,-82!521#.)!9-17-(55A!B2(!&*'(*'&1*!

10!'2(!,#'21-!S,5!'1!)&58#55!,*)!E,.&),'(!'2(!01..1S&*7W!

Page 165: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?O=!

• B2(!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*5!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2(!&*'-1)#8'&1*!10!'2&5!'2(5&5q!

• U,&*!,!0#-'2(-!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10!21S!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!,'!'2(!'&%(!S,5!

9(-8(&E()!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!&*)#5'-:q!

• H`9.1-(! 21S! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! S1#.)! 81*'-&$#'(! '1! '2(!

5#88(550#.!)(.&E(-:!10!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5q!

• +-(5(*'! '2(! <!,+3'!2'+2+(&0!26.(&(!+,!)6&!Y&R&./!2'+E&((>! ,*)! c)6&!)6'&&O)$&'!

C&#&,$)(!E/.(($,$E.)$+#L!,99-1,82q!

• +-(5(*'!'2(!-(5(,-82!5'-,'(7:!,*)!7,&*!0(()$,8K!1*!8,5(!5'#):!5#77(5'&1*5!

,*)!%('21)1.17:A!

B2(!S1-K5219!.,5'()!01-!01#-!21#-5!,*)!'2(!1#'81%(!S,5!E(-:!81*5'-#8'&E(!01-!'2(!

-(5(,-82! 9-17-(55&1*A! B2(! -(5(,-82! 4#(5'&1*5! 5((%()! E(-:! ,99-19-&,'(! $1'2! 1*!

,8,)(%&8! ,*)! &*)#5'-:! (`9.1-,'&1*! '(-%5A! ! B2(-(!S,5! '2(! -(\(*01-8(%(*'! 10! '2(!

E&(S! 0-1%! '2(! &*)#5'-&,.&5'5! '2,'! '2(-(! S,5! ,! *(()! '2(*! %1-(! '2,*! (E(-! 01-! ,*!

(00(8'&E(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! &*! ,..! 81*5'-#8'&1*! 5(8'1-5! ,*)! 9-&%,-&.:! &*!

2(,.'28,-(A!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!9-(5(*'()!0(.'!,99-19-&,'(!'1!71!01-S,-)!S&'2!,*)!

'1!0#-'2(-!&*E(5'&7,'(!&'5!)(E(.19%(*'!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!5#77(5'()!,5!9-(E&1#5.:!

)(58-&$()A!B2(!S1-K5219!0&*)&*75!91&*'()!'2(!,#'21-!&*'1!'2(!)&-(8'&1*!'1!0#-'2(-!

(`9.1-(!,*)!&*'(7-,'(!'1!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!'2(!01..1S&*7!&55#(5W!

• U1E(-*,*8(!,*)!1S*(-52&9!10!'2(!C(3(,.!+-18(55!S2(*!,99.&()!&*!,!9-1^(8'!

(*E&-1*%(*'q!

• /(()$,8K!.119!S&'2&*!'2(!9-18(55!'1!9-1%1'(!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!,*)!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!.(,-*&*7q!

• [1S!8,*!'2(!9-18(55!$(!0.(`&$.(!51!&'!8,*!$(!,99.&()!,'!)&00(-(*'!5',7(5!10!,*!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'q!

• V*'(7-,'&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55!S&'2!c(E(-:),:L!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!9-,8'&8(q!

• B2(!-1.(!10!'(%9.,'(5!&*!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!(A7A!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.(A!

B2(! 0(()$,8K! -(8(&E()! S,5! &*81-91-,'()! &*'1! '2(! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! ,#'21-L5!

K*1S.()7(!,88#%#.,'()!51!0,-!,*)!01-%()!'2(!9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!'1!$(!(`9.1-()!&*!

Q"?!,5!'2&5!S,5!)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!NA@A?A!!

Page 166: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?O@!

B2(! (&E+#0! .0%$(+'*! A'+32!D&&)$#A! \FT_]! S,5! &*! T,:! =>>M! ,*)! 018#5()! 1*! '2(!

0&*)&*75!10!Q"?!S&'2!T,"B!bV/B;!'2(!,#'21-!9-(5(*'()!'2(!9-17-(55!%,)(!51!0,-!&*!

'(-%5!10!'2(!01..1S&*7!,59(8'5W!!

• <.&7*%(*'!10!C(3(,.!S&'2!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'q!

• C(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5q!

• C(*(0&'5!%,99&*7q!

• B2(!-1.(!10!)&5$(*(0&'5!,*)!#*,*'&8&9,'()!$(*(0&'5A!

B2(!S1-K5219!.,5'()!01-!'S1!21#-5!,*)!%,&*!1#'81%(5!&*8.#)()W!

• B2(!E,.&),'&1*!10!'2(!'(82*&4#(5!#5()!'1!(.&8&'!$(*(0&'5!-('-159(8'&E(.:!,*)!

'2(&-! &*81-91-,'&1*! '1S,-)5! '2(! 0&*,.! 5('! '1! $(! #5()! S&'2! '2(! C(3(,.!

9-18(55q!

• B2(! *(()! '1! 2,E(! ,! $(*(0&'5! 5'-,'(7:! 92,5(! ,'! '2(! 81*8(9'&1*! 5',7(! 10! ,!

9-1^(8'!S&'2!8.(,-!)&-(8'&1*!10!S2,'!$(*(0&'5!*(()!'1!$(!-(,.&5()q!

• B2(! 9155&$.(!%(-7(! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! )(9(*)(*8:!%,9!S&'2&*! '2(! $(*(0&'5!

9-10&.(q!

• V*8.#5&1*!10!'2(!)&5$(*(0&'5!S&'2&*!'2(!-&5K!-(7&5'(-!10!'2(!9-1^(8'q!

• B2(!-1.(!10!'2(!(*)\#5(-!I9,'&(*'!,*)!5',00J!10!2(,.'28,-(!0,8&.&'&(5!,*)!'2(&-!

19&*&1*!521#.)!$(!&*5'-#%(*',.!&*!)(0&*&*7!'1!S2,'!(`'(*)!'2(!9-1^(8'!2,5!

)(.&E(-()!$(*(0&'5q!

• B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 81#.)! 91'(*'&,..:! $(! ,! '11.! '1! 5'-(*7'2(*! ,-7#%(*'5!

S2:!9,-'&8#.,-!2(,.'28,-(!5(-E&8(5!,-(!*(()()!,*)!9-1E&)(!'2(!8,5(!10!S2:!

-(.,'()!82,*7(5!*(()!'1!$(!%,)(!$1'2!&*!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!,*)!5(-E&8(5q!

• B2(! ,)19'&1*! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 0-1%! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! $(:1*)! '2(!

-(%&'!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!S&..!$(!,!E(-&0&8,'&1*!10!&'5!9-,8'&8,.!81*'-&$#'&1*A!

B2(! )6$'0! .0%$(+'*! A'+32! \FTf]! '11K! 9.,8(! &*! "(9'(%$(-! =>>M;! '2(! ,#'21-!

9-(5(*'()!'1!'2(!7-1#9!'2(!9-17-(55!%,)(!&*!'(-%5!10!Q"?!,*)!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!

'2(!9-18(55!,*)!018#5()!1*W!

• B2(!-1.(!10!5',K(21.)(-5!,'!)&00(-(*'!5',7(5!10!'2(!9-18(55q!,*)!

Page 167: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?ON!

• B2(!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!10!21S!5',K(21.)(-5!8,*!9,-'&8&9,'(!&*'1!'2(!(E,.#,'&1*!10!

,!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!&*!'(-%5!10!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5()A!

B2&5!S,5!,!'S1\21#-!S1-K5219!,*)!%,&*!1#'81%(5!S(-(W!!

• B2(! &%91-',*8(! '1! &*8.#)(! &*! '2(! -(5#.'&*7! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! %('21)5! 01-!

5(.(8'&*7!5',K(21.)(-5!'1!9,-'&8&9,'(!&*!'2(!)&00(-(*'!5',7(!10!'2(!9-18(55;!'1!

19'&%&5(! '2(! 1#'81%(! 10! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*;! %,*,7(! (`9(8','&1*! ,*)! (*2,*8(!

81%%#*&8,'&1*q!

• <! 5#&',$.(! %('21)! 10! $(*(0&'! -(,.&5,'&1*! %(,5#-(%(*'! S,5! '2(! #5(! 10!

4#(5'&1**,&-(5! '2,'! S1#.)! ',-7('! '2(! 9,'&(*';! #5(-5! ,*)! 5',00! 10! '2(!

2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 0,8&.&':! ,*)! 4#(5'&1*5! &*8.#)()!S&..! $(! .&*K()! '1!

'2(!&)(*'&0&()!$(*(0&'5A!b&*K!10!1#'81%(5!,*)!8#5'1%(-!5,'&50,8'&1*A!

B2(! ,+3')6! .0%$(+'*! A'+32! \FTd]!S,5! &*! /($-#,-:! =>>D! S2(-(! '2(! 0&*)&*75! ,*)!

,*,.:5&5!10!'2(!),',!81..(8'()!S,5!9-(5(*'()!$:!'2(!,#'21-A!B2(!0&-5'!,*)!'2(!0&0'2!

92,5(! 10! '2(! 9-18(55! S(-(! 81%%#*&8,'()! &*! %1-(! )(',&.! &*81-91-,'&*7!

,)E,*8(%(*'! ,*)! .(551*5! .(,-*'! 01-%! Q"?A! B2(5(! ,-(! 0#-'2(-! )(',&.()! &*! 5(8'&1*!

OA@A?!,*)!OA@AO!,*)!,-(W!!

• "'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'q!

• <55(55%(*'A!

B2(!01#-'2!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!I<UNJ!S,5!,!'2-((\21#-!5(55&1*!,*)!'2(!,.51!,))-(55()!

'2(!01..1S&*7!&55#(5!'2,'!2(.9()!'2(!,#'21-L5!#*)(-5',*)&*7!&*!$(''(-!)(5&7*&*7!'2(!

,&%5! ,*)! 018#5! 10! Q"=! ,*)! 81*'-&$#'()! '1S,-)5! '2(! 81%915&'&1*! 10! '2(! )(',&.()!

5'(95!S&'2&*!'2(!92,5(5!10!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!9-(5(*'()!&*!Q2,9'(-!OA!

• _2,'!*(()5!'1!$(!81*5&)(-()!S2(*!01-%#.,'&*7!,!$(*(0&'5!5'-,'(7:q!

• B2(!(%$()%(*'!10!C(3(,.!&*'1!$#5&*(55!8,5(!)(E(.19%(*'q!

• <! 8.(,-! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! ,5! '2(:! ,-(! #*)(-5'11)! $:! '215(! &*E1.E()! &5!

*(()();!'1!(*2,*8(!81%%#*&8,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(!(`9(8','&1*5q!

• P5(!10!C(3(,.!,5!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!%(82,*&5%q!

• V)(*'&0:!$(5'!,99-1,82(5!1*!)(E(.19&*7!,!c$(*(0&'5!8#--(*8:LA!

Page 168: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?OO!

B2(! 0&0'2! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! %(('&*7! I<UOJ! S,5! &*! "(9'(%$(-! =>>D! S2(-(! '2(!

,#'21-!9-(5(*'()!'2(!0&*)&*75!,*)!.(551*5!.(,-*'!0-1%!Q"=A!B2(!5(81*)!92,5(!10!

'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!S,5!0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!5'(95!-(4#&-()!S&'2&*!

'2&5!92,5(!,5!)(',&.()!&*!5(8'&1*!OA@A=A!

• H.&8&','&1*!

o "'-#8'#-(!10!01-!$(*(0&'!9-10&.(!,*)!5(7%(*','&1*q!

o "'-#8'#-(!10!5',K(21.)(-!7-1#95!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*A!

B2(!<UO!S1-K5219!,.51!018#5()!1*!'2(!0&*)&*75!10!21SW!

• B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!8,*!&*01-%!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!&*!'2(!

)&00(-(*'!5',7(5!10!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!I"GQ;!GCQ;!/CQJq!

• B2(!#5(!10!'2(!K*1S.()7(!,*)!),',!7(*(-,'()!'2-1#72!'2(!&%9.(%(*','&1*!

10!C(3(,.!81*'-&$#'(5!'1S,-)5!U,'(S,:!-(E&(S5q!

• C(*(0&'5!8,*!$(!#5()!'1!)-&E(!9-1^(8'!9.,*5q!

• B2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! (5',$.&52&*7! c8,#5(! ,*)! (00(8'L! -(.,'&1*52&9! $('S((*!

$(*(0&'5!,*)!-(51#-8(5A!

B2(! ,#'21-! ,.51! 9-(5(*'()! 2&5! 5'-,'(7:! 01-! Q"@! S2(-(! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 9-10&.(! ,*)!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9.,*!92,5(5!S1#.)!$(!&*E(5'&7,'()A!

B2(!5&`'2!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!I<URJ!'11K!9.,8(!&*!T,-82!=>>F;!'2(!,#'21-!9-(5(*'()!2&5!

0&*)&*75!,*)!.(551*5!.(,-*'!01-!Q"@!S(-(!'2(!-(1-7,*&5,'&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55!&*!'(-%5!

10!'2(!*(()!'1!2,E(!,*!G9'&1*((-&*7!,*)!,!+,'2S,:!92,5(!S,5!81*8.#)()A!6#-&*7!

<UR!$(*(0&'5!-,*K&*7!S(&72'&*7!,*)!19'&1*((-&*7! '(82*&4#(5!S(-(!)&58#55()!,*)!

21S!'2(5(!%,:!$(!,99.&()! '1! '2(! 0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!B2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,*! VB!

9.,'01-%! '1! (*,$.(! '2(! (,5&(-! &%9.(%(*','&1*! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! S,5! ,.51!

)&58#55()A!

B2(!5(E(*'2!,*)!0&*,.!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!I<UMJ!'11K!9.,8(!&*!/($-#,-:!=>?>!,*)!'2(!

,#'21-! 9-(5(*'()! ,! 5#%%,-:! 10! '2(! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5;! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#95!

0&*)&*75! ,*)! .(551*5! .(,-*'! ,*)! '2(! 0&*,.! C(3(,.! 9-18(55A! B2(! 7-1#9! 0#-'2(-!

)&58#55()!'2(!81%915&'&1*!10! '2(!5'(95!S&'2&*!(,82!10! '2(! 0&E(!92,5(5A! !Q2,9'(-!O!

Page 169: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?OR!

0#..:!)(58-&$(5!,*)!)&58#55(5!'2(5(!5'(95!,*)!9-(5(*'5!'2(!0&*,.!,-82&'(8'#-(!10!'2(!

C(3(,.!9-18(55A!

P$N %)(98(();2D!)2<'(1)A/1);2!/23!</0)3/1);2!0)@)1/1);2(!

B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55! &5! &*01-%()!,*)!'(5'()!'2-1#72!8,5(!5'#)&(5! &*! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

)(E(.19%(*'5!,'!)&00(-(*'!5',7(5!10!'2(&-!.&0(8:8.(A!

B2(! 0,8'! '2,'! Q"?! IT,"B! bV/BJ! 018#5()! 1*! '2(! ,55(55%(*'! 92,5(! '2-1#72! +15'!

G88#9,*8:!HE,.#,'&1*!I+GHJ;!Q"=!I]["!"'18K91-'J!&*!5',K(21.)(-!81*5#.','&1*!01-!

)(E(.19&*7!,!5',K(21.)(-!&*01-%()!GCQ!,*)!Q"@!IC-&72'1*!,*)!"#55(`!@B5J!1*!'2(!

$#5&*(55! 8,5(! ,99-1E,.! 92,5(;! S,5! &*&'&,..:! -(7,-)()! ,*)! S,5! ,0'(-S,-)5!

81*0&-%()! ,5! ,*! 1991-'#*&':! '1! )(E(.19! ,*)! 5(4#(*'&,..:! E,.&),'(! '2(! C(3(,.!

9-18(55!$1'2!1*! '2(! &*&'&,.! 92,5(5!%1-(! -(.,'()!S&'2! '2(!$(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*! I&A(A;!

+2,5(!=W!Y&#&,$)(!2'+,$/&!.#0!6$A6O/&%&/!C&#&,$)(!D.2J! ,*)!S&'2! '2(!)(0&*&'&1*! 10! ,!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*! I&A(A! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 92,5(! @J;! #*'&.! '2(! 19(-,'&1*5! ,*)!

0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'! 92,5(! S2&82! &5! %1-(! -(.,'()! S&'2! )(.&E(-&*7!

%1*&'1-&*7a81*'-1..&*7! 10! $(*(0&'5! I&A(A;! 92,5(! NW! C&#&,$)(! &%./3.)$+#! .#0! '&%$&@]9!

B2(! 92,5(! '(-%&*1.17:! ,*)! )(',&.! 2,5! (E1.E()! &*! .&*(! S&'2! '2(! 8,5(5! 5'#):! ,*)!

,)E&51-:!7-1#9!0&*)&*75!,5!,-(!)(',&.()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!82,9'(-A!

B2(!81*'-&$#'&1*!10!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!),',!,*,.:5&5!1*!21S!

'2(! 9-18(55! S,5! &*01-%()! &5! 9-(5(*'()! &*! 82,9'(-! 0&E(;! ,! 5#%%,-:! 10! '2(! %,&*!

0&*)&*75! ,*)! 82,..(*7(5! 10! C(3(,.L5! &%9.(%(*','&1*! ,*)! E,.&),'&1*! ,*)! -(5(,-82!

.&%&','&1*5!,-(!)&58#55()!&*!81*8.#)&*7!'2&5!82,9'(-A!!

B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! S,5! ,)19'()! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! S&'2! ,! %,^1-! 018#5! 1*!

(5',$.&52&*7! ,! 01-%,.!%('21)! '1! 9.,*! 01-! IQ"=! ,*)! Q"@J! ,*)! (E,.#,'(! IQ"?J! '2(!

(`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! 10! &*E(5'%(*'5;! 81%9.:&*7! S&'2! GUQ! -(4#&-(%(*'5! IQ"=! ,*)!

Q"@JA!B2(!,#'21-!,59&-()!C(3(,.! '1!$(!,!9-18(55! 01-!8-(,'&*7!,*!(*E&-1*%(*'! 01-!

.(,-*&*7!,*)!&%9-1E&*7!)-&E(*!$:!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!,5!5#77(5'()!$:!/,-$(:!('!,.A!

I?FFFJA! B2&5! S,5! 81*5&)(-()! '1! $(! ,! 5#88(55! $:! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#95!

&*E1.E()!&*!,..!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!,8K*1S.()7()!$:!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!,5!'2(!%,&*!

018#5! 10! '2(! &%9.(%(*','&1*! ,*)! E,.&),'&1*! -(5(,-82! 5',7(59! "#82! (*E&-1*%(*'!

Page 170: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?OM!

5((%5! '1! &*8(*'&E&5(! ,! '(,%! '1! 018#5! 1*! 01..1S&*7! 9-18()#-(5! ,*)! ,E1&)&*7!

)(E&,'&1*5! 0-1%! 9.,*! I018#5! 1*! 9.,**&*7! ,*)! 81*'-1.J;! S2(-(,5! ,! %1-(! 0.(`&$.(!

(*E&-1*%(*'!81#.)!$(''(-!0,8&.&','(!.(,-*&*7!,*)!81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'A!

5'+%$0$#A!D&.#(! ,+'! .! %&'*! $#E/3($%&! 2/.##$#A! 2'+E&((! \! G*(! 10! '2(! %15'! 915&'&E(!

,59(8'5! 10! ,)19'&*7! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! &5! '2,'! '215(! &*E1.E()! 81*5&)(-()! &'! ,5! ,!

E(-:! &*8.#5&E(! 9-18(55A! H*7,7&*7! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 5',K(21.)(-5! I%,&*.:! 9,'&(*'5! ,*)!

#5(-!7-1#95!&*!Q"?!,*)!Q"@J!&*!'2(!9.,**&*7!9-18(55!S,5!,!E(-:!915&'&E(!,59(8';!,5!

&*!71E(-*%(*',.!9-1^(8'5;!9#$.&8!&*E1.E(%(*'!,*)!,88(9',*8(!&5!51%('2&*7!2&72.:!

)(5&-()!,*)!7(*(-,..:!-(4#&-()!$:!71E(-*%(*',.!,#'21-&'&(5A![1S(E(-;!&'!521#.)!$(!

*1'()!'2,'!,!9,-'&8&9,'1-:!9-18(55(5!81#.)!7(*(-,'(!,!.,-7(!,%1#*'!10!&*01-%,'&1*;!

S2&82! &5! )&00&8#.'! '1!%,*,7(A! <881-)&*7! '1! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()! &*! '2(! 8,5(!

5'#)&(5;! ,! .,-7(! ,%1#*'! 10! &*01-%,'&1*! ,$1#'! 9-(0(-(*8(5! ,*)! (`9(8','&1*5! S,5!

7(*(-,'()! ,*)! 51%(! '(,%! %(%$(-5! 0(.'! '2,'! &'! S1#.)! $(! #5(0#.! &0! '2(:! 2,)! ,!

0-,%(S1-K! '2,'! S1#.)! 5'-#8'#-(! 5#82! &*01-%,'&1*! ,*)! 8.(,-.:! )&59.,:! '2(!

(E,.#,'&1*! 8-&'(-&,! '2,'L5! &5! $(&*7! #5()A! <*1'2(-! 82,..(*7(! &5! '1! K*1S! S21! '1!

(*7,7(!,*)!S2(*A!H*7,7&*7!9,-'&8&9,*'5!1*!2&72\.(E(.!)&58#55&1*5!,$1#'!5'-,'(7&8!

&55#(5! ,*)! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! 8,*! $(! E(-:! )&00&8#.'! ,5! '2(:! '(*)! '1! (`9-(55!

'2(%5(.E(5! &*! '2(! .(E(.! 10! 59,'&,.! -(4#&-(%(*'5A! B2&5! &55#(! &5! ,))-(55()! S&'2&*!

92,5(!=!,*)!@!10!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55W!&/$E$).)$+#!.#0!+2)$+#&&'$#A9!

=#E'&.($#A! .@.'&#&((! +,! &N2&E)&0! +3)E+D&(! \! '2(! (5',$.&52%(*'! 10! ,! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!S1-K! 5'-(,%!S&'2&*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5!9#-5#()! &*8-(,5()!,S,-(*(55!10!

'2(! *(()! '1! #*)(-5',*)! ,*)! '-,8K! 21S! 9-1^(8'L5! 1#'9#'5! S&..! .(,)! '1! 9-1^(8'!

1#'81%(5A! V*! ,..! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! &'! S,5! 1$5(-E()! '2,'! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!S1-K!

5'-(,%!S,5!5(7-(7,'()!0-1%!1'2(-!9-1^(8'!,8'&E&'&(5A!G'2(-!9-1^(8'!'(,%!%(%$(-5!

S(-(!*1'!&*E1.E()!1*!'2(5(!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)&)*L'!2,E(!%#82!,S,-(*(55!,$1#'!S2,'!

S(-(!'2(!(`9(8'()!9-1^(8'!$(*(0&'5A!3(81%%(*),'&1*!'1!-(51.E(!'2&5! &5!9-(5(*'()!

&*! 5(8'&1*! OANAO! C&#&,$)(! .E)$%$)$&(! .#0! '&(+3'E&! 0&2&#0&#E$&(! .#0! OAO! 5'+E&((!

$D2/&D&#).)$+#!)&.D9!

7'$%$#A! 0&E$($+#OD.?$#A! C.(&0! +#! &N2&E)&0! C&#&,$)(! Z! V*! Q"@! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55!

9-1E&)()! ,! -,'&1*,.! )(8&5&1*! %,K&*7! 9-18(55! '1! (E,.#,'(! '2(! )&00(-(*'! )(5&7*!

19'&1*5!$,5()!1*!'2(&-!,$&.&':!'1!0#.0&.!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5A!"#82!9-18(55!%('!GUQ!

Page 171: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?OD!

-(4#&-(%(*'5! 01-!$#5&*(55!8,5(!)(E(.19%(*'!I,.51!(`,%&*()!&*!Q"=JA![1S(E(-;! &'!

S,5! 4#(5'&1*()! &0! 5#82! ,99-1,82;! S2&82! &5! $,5()! 1*! S(&72&*7! 0,8'1-5! ,*)! '2(*!

5(.(8'&*7! '2(!19'&1*!S&'2! '2(!2&72(-! 581-(! -(,..:! .(,)5! '1! 82115&*7! '2(!%15'! 815'!

(00(8'&E(!19'&1*A!<5!9,-'&8&9,*'5!S(-(!,5K()!'1!&*'#&'&E(.:!82115(!,*!19'&1*!$(01-(!

2,*);!'2(!4#(5'&1*!2(-(!&5! &0!)(8&5&1*5!S(-(!71&*7!'1!$(!)&00(-(*'! &0! '2(!S(&72'&*7!

S,5!,.51!$,5()!1*!815'!,*)!581-(5!10!1'2(-!&*)&E&)#,.!,''-&$#'(5A!B2(!%#.'&!8-&'(-&,!

-,*K&*7! '2,'! 01..1S5! '2(! $(*(0&'5! S(&72'&*7! 10! 19'&1*5! -(81%%(*)()! &*! 5(8'&1*!

OANAN!,&%5!'1!,))-(55!'2&5!&55#(A!Q,5(!5'#):!9,-'&8&9,*'5!&*!Q"?!,*)!Q"=!5','()!'2,'!

C(3(,.! (*,$.()! ,! 0-,%(S1-K! 01-! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! &*! '2(! 9-1^(8'! )(E(.19%(*';! ,!

-,'&1*,.&5()! ,*)! ^#5'&0&,$.(! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7! 9-18(55! ,*)! ,! %('21)! 01-!

,881#*',$&.&':!1E(-!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5()A!

5'+%$0$#A! D&.#(! .#0! D&)6+0(! ,+'! .EE+3#).C$/$)*! \! V*! %,*:! 9-1^(8'5! '2(-(! &5! ,*!

,''(%9'!'1!81%9.:!S&'2!GUQ!-#.(5!,*)!2,E(!,!9.,*!&*!S2&82!$(*(0&'5!,-(!5','()!,5!

S(..!,5!%(,*5!01-!,881#*',$&.&':A![1S(E(-;!9-1^(8'!5',K(21.)(-5!&*E1.E()!S&'2!Q"?!

,*)!Q"@! 5,&)! &*! '2(&-! (`9(-&(*8(! '2,'! &*!%15'! 9-1^(8'5! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! ,-(!

-,-(.:!(E,.#,'()A!B2(!'(,%!7('5!)&59(-5()!,0'(-!'2(!9-1^(8'!&5!)(.&E(-()!,*)!*1!1*(!

82(8K5! &0! '2(! &*'(*'!10! &*E(5'%(*'!S,5!,82&(E()A! /#-'2(-%1-(;! 5&%&.,-! 82,..(*7(5!

-(91-'()!1*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!S(-(!1$5(-E()!&*!Q"@!&A(AW!'2(!)&00&8#.':!'1!5('!%('-&85!'1!

&*',*7&$.(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJ;! )&00&8#.':! '1! 5:5'(%,'&8,..:! &*8.#)(!

#*(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!-(5#.'!0-1%!(%(-7&*7!1991-'#*&'&(5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJ;!

,*)!'2(!82,..(*7(!'1!,55(55!,82&(E()!$(*(0&'5!7&E(*!'2(&-!.1*7!9(-&1)!10!-(,.&5,'&1*!

I_&*'(-!('!,.A;!=>>RJ;!,*)! '2,'!S,5!9-1$.(%!'2,'! '2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!S1-K&*7!

7-1#9!&*!Q"@!,''(%9'()!'1!%&'&7,'(A!

B2(!9-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9! &*!Q"@!,8K*1S.()7()! '2,'!,5!,! -(5#.'!10! ,)19'&*7! '2(!

C(3(,.!9-18(55!'2(:!8,*!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!&%91-',*8(!10!9.,**&*7!,'!,!$#5&*(55!8,5(!

)(E(.19%(*'! 5',7(! '2(! S,:! '2,'! '2(:! S&..! %(,5#-(! &'! $(*(0&'5! $:! ,55&7*&*7!

-(591*5&$&.&'&(5! '2-1#72! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! S1-K! 5'-(,%A! [1S(E(-;! ,!

82,..(*7(!&5!'1!$,.,*8(!-&71-!,*)!-(.(E,*8(!&*!'2(!%(,5#-&*7!5:5'(%A!6&00&8#.':!S,5!

01#*)! '1! 0&*)! '2(! ,)(4#,'(! %('-&85! '1! %(,5#-(! 51%(! 10! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5;!

9,-'&8#.,-.:!01-!'2(!&*',*7&$.(!1*(5A!"&%&.,-.:;!)&00&8#.':!S,5!01#*)!'1!5('!%('-&85!'1!

,55(55! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&1*! 9-18(55! ,*)! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! -(.,'()! '1! &'A! ! "(8'&1*!

Page 172: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!01#-Z!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,*)!)(E(.19%(*'!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?OF!

OA@AN!S2(-(!'2(!9,'2S,:!92,5(! &5!)(58-&$();!,''(%9'5!'1!7&E(!,*!,*5S(-!'1!'2(5(!

81*8(-*5A!

8$D$#A!+,! $D2/&D&#).)$+#!.#0!&N)&'#./! $#,/3&#E&(Z!6&00&8#.'&(5!S(-(! ,.51! 01#*)! &*!

81E(-&*7! ,..! 5'-,'(7&8! ,59(8'5! &*! '2(! 9-18(55A! V*! ,..! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! '2&5! S,5!

,5518&,'()! S&'2! 'S1! 9-1$.(%5W! &%9.(%(*'&*7! '2(! %1)(.! &*! ,! .,'(-! 5',7(! 10!

)(E(.19%(*';! ,0'(-! '2(! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! 2,E(! $((*! )(0&*()q! ,*)! '2(! *(()! '1!

9#-5#(!(%(-7&*7!1991-'#*&'&(5;! &A(A!71E(-*%(*',.! 0#*)&*7! 01-!$#&.)&*7!51%('2&*7!

*1'! &*&'&,..:! &*!'2(!5819(!10!'2(!9-17-,%%(!I,5!&*!Q"@JA!B2(!&*&'&,'&E(!10!9#-5#&*7!

5#82!1991-'#*&'&(5!*(()5! '1!$(! 81*5&)(-()! &*! '2(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!S1-K52195!

,*)!(001-'5!,5!9,-'!10!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(!IOA@A=JA!

!

Page 173: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?R>!

N 4#/[1'5!7)<'!W!>':'/0![5;9'((!/59#)1'9185'!

B2&5!82,9'(-!)(58-&$(5! '2(! 0&*,.!,-'(0,8'!,5! '2(!-(5#.'!10! '2(!-(5(,-82!)(',&.()! &*! '2&5!

'2(5&5q!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!B2(!,#'21-!)(58-&$(5!,*)!)&58#55(5!2(-(!21S!'2(!(%(-7()!

9-18(55! 92,5(5! ,-(! 81*5'-#8'();! ,*)! '2(! K(:! 9-18(55! 5'(95! S&'2&*! (,82! 92,5(A! B2(!

C(3(,.! 92,5(! 2,E(! $((*! &*01-%();! &*E(5'&7,'()! ,*)! )(E(.19()! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! '2(!

.&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! 9-(5(*'()! &*! 82,9'(-! 'S1! ,*)! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*)! '2(! ,)E&51-:!

7-1#9!S1-K52195!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!01#-A! !B2(!,#'21-!,.51!)&58#55(5!'2(!K(:!'11.5!

,*)!'(82*&4#(5!'2,'!,-(!)(9.1:()!&*!'2(!0&E(!C(3(,.!92,5(5;!,5!'2(:!2,E(!$((*!-(0&*()!

01..1S&*7! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '2(! 0&(.)! -(5(,-82! 1#'81%(5A! B2(! &*'(-9-(','&1*! 10! '2(! *(S!

K*1S.()7(! ,84#&-()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! &5! ,.51! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '(-%5! 10! '2(! 9,-,)&7%! 52&0'!

*(()();!'2(!9-18(55!&*'(7-,'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5!,*)!'2(!K(:!,59(8'5!

N$, %'7)2)2A!1#'!@/)2!1'5@(!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):! 1#'81%(5! ,*)! 9-&1-! '1!

9-(5(*'&*7!'2(!0&*,.!E(-5&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55;!&'!&5!S&5(!'1!8.,-&0:!21S!'2(!%,&*!'(-%5!

#5()!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-!,-(!#*)(-5'11)!S&'2&*!'2(!C(3(,.!81*'(`'A!B2(!*(()!'1!2,E(!,!

8.(,-!)(0&*&'&1*!10!'(-%5!S,5!2&72.&72'()!,'!'2(!&*&'&,'&1*!5',7(!10!(,82!8,5(!5'#):!

,5!)&58#55()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!82,9'(-A!!

B2(!81*5'-#8'()!9-18(55!9-(5(*'()!2(-(!8,*!$(!#5()!'2-1#72!'2(!9-1^(8'!.&0(8:8.(A!

B2(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!IC(3(,.J!9-18(55!8,*!$(!#5()!S2(*!9.,**&*7! 01-!82,*7(;!

,..18,'&*7!-(51#-8(5!'1!&%9-1E(!9(-01-%,*8(;!,*)!)(.&E(-:!10!$(*(0&'5!'2-1#72!'2(!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!82,*7(A!

B2(5(! '(-%5!,-(!K(:! &*! 01..1S&*7! '2(!5'(95!10! '2(!9-18(55!,*)!,-(!#5()!-(7#.,-.:!

,*)!10'(*!2,E(!)&00(-(*'!%(,*&*75A!/1-!'2(!9#-915(!10!'2&5!82,9'(-!'2(:!2,E(!$((*!

)(0&*();! ,5! '2(:! ,-(! *1S! #*)(-5'11)! 01..1S&*7! '2(! ,*,.:5&5! 10! '2(! K*1S.()7(!

7,&*()! ,*)! &*'(-9-('()! '2-1#72! '2(! 2(-%(*(#'&8! .(*5! 10! '2(! ,#'21-! B2(5(!%,&*!

'(-%5!#5()!&*!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-(W!!

• C(*(0&'5!,*)!82,*7(q!

• +-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'q!

Page 174: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?R?!

• C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'q!

• "',K(21.)(-5A!

Y&#&,$)(! .#0! :6.#A&! O! C(*(0&'5! ,-(! )(0&*()! ,5! '2(! 1#'81%(5! 10! 82,*7(! I0-1%!

9-17-,%%(5! 1-! 9-1^(8'5J;! S2&82! ,-(! E,.#()! 915&'&E(.:! $:! 5',K(21.)(-5A! C(*(0&'5!

8,*! $(! (.&8&'()! ,*)! 9.,**();! %,*,7();! )(.&E(-()! ,*)! -(,.&5()A! ! C(*(0&'5! ,-(;!

'2(-(01-(;! -(.,'()!S&'2! 5',K(21.)(-5L! 9(-8(9'&1*5! ,$1#'! ,*! 1#'81%(! 1-! 1#'9#'! Z!

$(*(0&'5!,-(!-(.,'()!S&'2!'2(!E,.#(!9.,8()!$:!,!5',K(21.)(-!1*!,!82,*7(!&*&'&,'&E(A!

C(*(0&'5!,-(!)(5&-()!1-!,8'#,.!1#'81%(5! 0-1%!82,*7(;! '2,'!,-(!9(-8(&E()!915&'&E(!

$:!5',K(21.)(-5A!

Q2,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(5! ,*)! -(.,'()! 1#'81%(5! -(4#&-(! ,! $#*).(! 10! %,*,7(%(*'!

'(82*&4#(5! ,*)! -(51#-8(5A! B:9&8,..:! 82,*7(! &5! )(E(.19()! ,*)! )(.&E(-()!S&'2&*! ,!

9-17-,%%(! 1-! ,! 9-1^(8'! (*E&-1*%(*'A! Q2,*7(! &5! 1*.:! ^#5'&0&,$.(! &0! )&-(8'.:! I1-!

&*)&-(8'.:J!81*'-&$#'(5!'1!'2(!)(.&E(-:!10!$(*(0&'5A!

5'+A'.DD&!+'!2'+V&E)!!O!+-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5!,-(!*1'!#5#,..:!5('!#9!'1!)&-(8'.:!

)(.&E(-! $(*(0&'5A! B2(:! #5#,..:! 9-1%1'(! ,*! (*E&-1*%(*'! '1! &%9.(%(*'! 82,*7(;!

S2&82! &5! 8,9,$.(! 10! )(.&E(-&*7! $(*(0&'5A! +-1^(8'! I,*)! 9-17-,%%(J! %,*,7(%(*'!

':9&8,..:! )(.&E(-! 1#'9#'5;! $#'! S&..! *1'! *(8(55,-&.:! ,.S,:5! %,*,7(! ,*)! )(.&E(-!

$(*(0&'5A!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!018#5!1*!'2(!&*'(7-,'()!%,*,7(%(*'!10W!

• C(*(0&'5!Z!S2,'!&5!'1!$(!,82&(E()q!

• Q2,*7(!Z!21S!'2(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!)(.&E(-()q!

• T,*,7(%(*'! Z! '2(! 9-18(55! 10! &*'(7-,'&*7! '2(! uS2,'v! ,*)! '2(! u21Sv!

&*8.#)&*7!'2(!,..18,'&1*!10!-(51#-8(5A!

Page 175: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?R=!

!

X)A85'!-+c!"5;9'((!)21'A5/1);2![5)29)[0'(!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,&%5!'1!(*5#-(!'2,'!,*!1#'9#'!1-!1#'81%(!10!,!82,*7(!&*&'&,'&E(!

9-1)#8(5! '2(!9-1^(8'()!$(*(0&'5! &*8.#)()! &*! ,! $#5&*(55! 8,5(A! B2(!C(3(,.! 9-18(55!

2(.95! &)(*'&0:! ,..! '2(! &%9,8'5! '2,'! -(5#.'! 0-1%! ,! 82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(! ,*)! '2(!

%,*,7(%(*'!10!'2(!#*(`9(8'()!1*(5A!

-).?&6+/0&'(! ,-(! '215(! 9(-51*5! 1-! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! S215(! E&(S5;! &*'(-(5'! ,*)a1-!

-(4#&-(%(*'5! 8,*! 2,E(! ,*! &%9,8'! 1-! ,-(! &%9,8'()! $:! 9-1^(8'! 1-! 9-17-,%%(!

$(*(0&'5!,*)a1-!82,*7(5A!

B2(!9-18(55!1E(-E&(S!'2,'!01..1S5!5(7%(*'5!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,99-1,82!&*'1!

0&E(! 92,5(5;!S2&82! ,-(! 5'-#8'#-()! ,5! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5A! B2(5(! ,*)!1'2(-!

-(.(E,*'! '(-%5!,-(!9-(5(*'()!2(-(! ,5!#*)(-5'11)!$:! '2(!,#'21-! ,*)!#5()!S&'2&*!

'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!!

• 56.(&!&5!,!81%$&*,'&1*!10!5',*),-)!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5q!

• FE)$%$)*! &5! ,! 5'-#8'#-()! 5('! 10! ',5K5! '2,'! 7#&)(! ,*)! 5#991-'! '1! )(.&E(-!

81%%1*!1$^(8'&E(!S&'2&*!'2(!9-18(55A!(A7A!'1!8-(,'(!,!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.(q!

• 7&/$%&'.C/&(! -(9-(5(*'! )18#%(*'()! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! 9-18(55! &*01-%,'&1*A!

6(.&E(-,$.(5!,-(!'2(!-(5#.'!10!9(-01-%()!,8'&E&'&(5q!

• S,,&E)$%&#&((! -(.,'(5! '1! '2(! )(7-((! '1! S2&82! ,! 82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(!%(('5! '2(!

9.,**()! 82,*7(! 1-! '2(! )(7-((! '1!S2&82! ,! $(*(0&'! &5! )(.&E(-()! ,5! 9.,**()A!

H00(8'&E(*(55!-(0(-5!'1!'2(!-(.,'&1*!$('S((*!9.,**()!1$^(8'&E(5a',-7('5!,*)!

-(5#.'5!,82&(E()q!

• S,,$E$&#E*! -(.,'(5! '1! '2(! #5(! 10! -(51#-8(5! 81%%&''()! '1! &%9.(%(*'! '2(!

82,*7(! &*&'&,'&E(A! H00&8&(*8:! %(,5#-(5! 21S!S(..! $(*(0&'5! I1-! 1#'9#'5J! ,-(!

!"#"$%&'( )*+#,"(

-+#+,"."#&(

/*+&(01(2"(2+#&(&1(0"3%4"5( 612(01(2"(0"3%4"5(

!"#"$%&'78*+#,"(%#&",5+&%1#(

Page 176: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?R@!

)(.&E(-()! S&'2! '2(! %&*&%#%! -(51#-8(5A! H00&8&(*8:! -(0(-5! '1! '2(! -(.,'&1*!

$('S((*!-(5#.'5!,*)!#'&.&5()!-(51#-8(5A!

N$* >':'/0![5;9'((![#/('(!'<;081);2!

B2(!01..1S&*7!5(8'&1*5!S&..!)(58-&$(!'2(!0&E(!92,5(5!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!'2(:!

2,E(! $((*! &*01-%();! E,.&),'()! ,*)! )(E(.19()! $:! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! '2(!

8,5(5! 5'#)&(5A!B2(! 0&-5'! 81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55! I&*'-1)#8()!,'! 5(8'&1*!=A=>J!2,5!71*(!

'2-1#72!,!*#%$(-!10!&'(-,'&1*5!,5!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!S(-(!9-17-(55&*7!,*)!),',!S,5!

7(*(-,'()! ,*)! ,*,.:5()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-A! B2(! *(S! 92,5(! 5'-#8'#-(! )1(5*L'! 82,*7(!

)-,%,'&8,..:A!B2(! 0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,*)! '2(!5(4#(*8(!10!,8'&E&'&(5!(*8,95#.,'(!

'2(! '(-%&*1.17:! ,*)! ,99-1,82! ,5! ,*! 1#'81%(! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! 5'-,'(7:! ,*)!

%('21)1.17:!)(9.1:()A!<!2&72!.(E(.!5#%%,-:!&5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!/&7#-(!@?;!S2(-(!'2(!

(E1.#'&1*!0-1%!'2(!9-(\8,5(!5'#)&(5!9-1915()!9-18(55!'1!'2(!0&*,.!I01-!'2(!9#-915(5!

10!'2&5!'2(5&5J!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&5!521S*A!

!

X)A85'!-,c!.)A#!0'<'0!<)'R!;7!1#'!7)2/0!>':'/0![5;9'((!

V'! S&..! $(! 2(.90#.! ,'! '2&5! 91&*'! '1! E&5#,..:! 5#%%,-&5(! IB,$.(! =MJ! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):!

,8'&E&'&(5;! %('21)5! ,*)! '11.5! #5()! ,5! &*'-1)#8()! &*! 82,9'(-! N! ,*)! ,.51! E&5#,..:!

!"#

!"#"$%&'()*+,+)&",%'+&%-#((

!"#"$%&'(.+//%#0((

!"#"$%&'(,"+1%'+&%-#(/1+#((

!"#"$%&'(.+#+0"."#&('&,+&"02(( 34+15+&%-#(6(

7"4%"8(

((!"#$%&'()*%+%

((((

!"#$%&'()*%,%((

((!"#$%&'()*%-%

((

((!"#$%&'()*%-%

((

.$/$01'#%&'2"'$3*%

.$/$01'#%4$25627"/8$%

&'2"'$3*%9:13/7$/'% ;:181'"'16/% <='16/$$21/3% 4"'>?"*%% 9##$##7$/'%

9"":(;*+,+)&",%'+&%-#(

31%)%&+&%-#(<"0."#&+&%-#(

=/&%-#'(;*+,+)&",%'+&%-#(

!"#"$%&'(+#:(;*+#0"(>+&*8+2(

?./1"."#&+&%-#(6(;-#&,-11%#0(

!"#"$%&'(+#:(;*+#0"(34+15+&%-#(7"4%"8(

?./1"."#&+&%-#(>1+#(

=/&%-#(<"1")&%-#(

@%,")&%-#(-A(;*+#0"(

9"":(B5'&%$%)+&%-#(

Page 177: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RN!

-(.,'(!21S!'2(5(!2,E(!&*0.#(*8()!'2(!(%(-7&*7!0&E(!92,5(5!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!

19915()!'1!'2(!01#-!81*8(9'#,.!1*(5!)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!=A=>A!!

&/H0'!*Oc!4/('!(183)'(!(8@@/5B!/23!)2708'29'!;2!>':'/0![#/('!'<;081);2!

!!=CFFI:`!4/('!(183)'(!

%;8A0/(!E5''2! =1!&#;@/(!! !-&(!

Q2,-,8'(-&5'&85! ! ! !

V6!! Q"!?! Q"!=! Q"!@!

V*E(5'%(*'!a+-18#-(%(*'!31#'(! bV/B! +++! QVT!aB-(,5#-:!

Q,9&',.!&*E(5'%(*'!Iw%J! ?O! N>! N=>!

b(E(.!10!2(,.'28,-(!9-1E&)()!! +-&%,-:! Q1%%#*&':!,*)!"(81*),-:!!

<8#'(!,*)!B(-'&,-:!

b18,'&1*! ",.01-)! "'18K91-'! C-&72'1*!

V*0-,5'-#8'#-(!)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(! +15'!G88#9,*8:! G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!IGCQJ!

G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!IGCQJ!

6#-,'&1*!10!8,5(!5'#):! ?=!%1*'25! N!%1*'25! R!%1*'25!

T('21)5! ! ! !

618#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S!! !!! !! !!

+-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9! !!! !! !!

C(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!%,5'(-!8.,55! !!! !! !!

]1!10!S1-K52195! !=! =! !R!

<)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195! @! ?! @!

C(3(,.!92,5(!(E1.#'&1*! ! ! !

"'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!0-1%!92,5(!V! !!! !! !!

H.&8&','&1*!0-1%!92,5(!VV!! !!! !! !!

G9'&1*((-&*7!I*(S!92,5(J! ! ! !!

+,'2S,:!0-1%!92,5(!VVV! ! ! !!

<55(55%(*'!0-1%!92,5(!VX! !! ! !

<.'21#72! (,82! 92,5(! &5! -(9-(5(*'()! ,5! ,*! &*)&E&)#,.! 5('! 10! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)!

)(.&E(-,$.(5;!'2(!81*8(9'!&5!'2,'!&*'(-,8'&1*!$('S((*!(,82!92,5(!%,:!188#-!,'!,*:!

'&%(! '2-1#72! ,! 0.(`&$.(! u510'! 7,'(v! ,99-1,82;! 51! '2,'! 0(()$,8K! &5! 1$',&*()! ,'! ,!

Page 178: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RO!

5#&',$.(!'&%(!S&'21#'!21.)&*7!#9!,8'&E&':A!H,82!92,5(!&*!'#-*!&5!)(5&7*()!'1!&*01-%!

'2(!c2,-)!7,'(5L!10!'2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!&*'-1)#8()!&*!82,9'(-!=A!B2&5!521#.)!%,K(!

&'! (,5&(-! '1! ,.&7*! C(3(,.! S&'2! ,*! &*)&E&)#,.! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5L! 1S*! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!

9-18(55(5!,*)!#5(!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!1#'81%(5!,5!81*'-&$#'1-5!'1!)1!51A!B2(!8,5(!

5'#)&(5!2,E(!)(%1*5'-,'()!'2,'!'2(!9-18(55!8,*!5',-'!,'!,*:!5',7(!$#'!S&..!$(!%1-(!

(00&8&(*'!,*)!$(*(0&8&,.!'1!'215(!&*E1.E()!&0!&'!&*&'&,'(5!S&'2!'2(!-)'.)&A*!F/$A#D&#)!

92,5(A!!

B2(! 82,-'! $(.1S! I/&7#-(!@=J! 521S5!21S! '2(! 0&E(!92,5(5! ,-(! &*'(-)(9(*)(*'! ,*)!

8,--&()!1#'!&*!,!5(%&\5(4#(*'&,.!S,:!,*)!,.51!&..#5'-,'()!21S!(,82!92,5(!&*01-%5!

'2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!9-18(55A!

!

X)A85'!-*c!>'2'7)1(!5'/0)(/1);2![5;9'((!1)@'0)2'!!

B2(! Y&#&,$)(! U.#.A&D&#)! -)'.)&A*;! I81*8(9'#,.! 92,5(! VJ! &5! *1S! '2(! -)'.)&A*!

F/$A#D&#)!92,5(A!_2(*!9.,**&*7!01-!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!'2(!8,5(!

5'#)&(5!2,E(!51S*!'2,'!&'!&5!*1'!5#00&8&(*'!'1!^#5'!&)(*'&0:!,!$(*(0&'5!5'-,'(7:!$#'!'1!

.&*K! '2&5! S&'2! '2(! 1E(-,..! 5'-,'(7:! 10! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! '2,'! S&..! )(.&E(-! '2(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(A! B2&5! 92,5(! $-&*75! '17('2(-! K(:! 5',K(21.)(-5! '1! $#&.)! ,! 81..(8'&E(!

E&5&1*! 10! 91'(*'&,.! 1#'9#'5! ,*)! '2(&-! &%9,8'! 1*! '2(! -(59(8'&E(! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)!

1'2(-!$#5&*(55! ,8'&E&'&(5A!<! 81%%1*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!10! '2(! &*)&E&)#,.! 5',K(21.)(-!

91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! )&5$(*(0&'5! &5! 9#-5#()! &*! '2&5! 92,5(! '2-1#72! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8!

$(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*! S1-K5219! ,*)! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*!9.,*A!<5!,!-(5#.';!5',K(21.)(-5!7(*(-,'(!,!.&5'!10!

!"#$%&'()*+%,*-%(

.%-%/*'0(1'"2'%34(

.%-%/*'0(!%"5#"+2-&%(

1'"2'%34(6,*3-+%-'(

7,*&*'2'*#-(

89'*#-%%"*-3(

!2':;24((

600%00+%-'(

!<2'%;24(=("#$%&#'(')*!+*#,*'-.!!

!<2'%;24(>(/)0'+*(')*!1'%2+2$)!

!<2'%;24(?(3',12)'++!4$#!

+'#02%'!

!<2'%;24(@(5&+2)'++!6&+*272%,*2$)!

!<2'%;24(A(8*#,*'-2%!,++'++(')*!

!<2'%;24(B(5')'72*+!'0,9&,*2$)!

Page 179: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RR!

-)'.)&A$E!Y&#&,$)(;!S2&82! 82,-,8'(-&5(! '2(! 9#-915(! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! 9-1E&)(! ,*!

1E(-,..! 7#&)(! 01-! &'5! 5#88(55A! Q-&'(-&,! 01-! '2(! 9-1^(8'! )(E(.19%(*'! $-&(0! ,-(! 5('!

$,5()!1*!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!,*)!9-1E&)(!'2(!018#5!10!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'A!!

B2(! Y&#&,$)(! :6.'.E)&'$(.)$+#! .#0! Y&#&,$)(! D.22$#A! I81*8(9'#,.! 92,5(! VVJ! 2,E(!

$((*! &*'(7-,'()! &*'1! '2(! S/$E$).)$+#! 56.(&A! B2(! (%92,5&5! 2(-(! &5! #91*! $(*(0&'5!

(.&8&','&1*A!B2(! ,&%!10! '2&5!92,5(! &5! '1!$-(,K)1S*! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5! &*'1! 5#$!

,*)! (*)! $(*(0&'5! I'2(! )6'&&! )$&'! ()'3E)3'&! .22'+.E6! &*'-1)#8()! &*! NA@ADJA! B2&5!

,99-1,82!)('(-%&*(5!&*!%1-(!)(',&.!21S!'2(!"'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!,82&(E()!

,5! ,! -(5#.'! $(*(0&'5! 10! '2(! '2-((! )&00(-(*'! .(E(.5! ,-(! 8.,55&0&()! ,*)! 82,-,8'(-&5()A!

V*'(-)(9(*)(*8&(5! ,%1*75'! '2(%! ,-(! (5',$.&52()A! B2&5! 8.,55&0&8,'&1*! 8-(,'(5! '2(!

8-&'(-&,! S2(-(! '2(! 19'&1*((-&*7! 92,5(! '2,'! 01..1S5! S&..! $(! $,5()! #91*A! B2(!

(5',$.&52()! )(9(*)(*8&(5! $('S((*! '2(! '2-((! .(E(.5! 10! "'-,'(7&8;! "#$! ,*)! H*)!

$(*(0&'5!,*)!,..!&*01-%,'&1*!7,'2(-()!7(*(-,'(!'2(!81-(!$(*(0&'!9-10&.(A!!

B2(! b2)$+#&&'$#A! 26.(&! &5! ,! *(S! (%(-7&*7! 92,5(! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! %,&*.:! 10! '2(!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*! 10! '2(! 81*8(9'#,.! 9-18(55! &*! Q"@! ,5! )(',&.()! &*! NA@A@A! B2(! ,#'21-!

$(.&(E(5!'2,'!'2&5!&5!,!*&82(!,99-1,82!1*!5(.(8'&*7!9-1^(8'!19'&1*5A!B2&5!92,5(!,&%5!

'1!82,..(*7(!,*)!19'&%&5(!'2(!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.(!$:!,*,.:5&*7!19'&1*5!,7,&*5'!$(*(0&'5!

,*)! '2(! 0#*)&*7!,E,&.,$.(;!,*)! '1!,7-((!,! -(81%%(*)()!19'&1*A!"',K(21.)(-5!,-(!

$-1#72'! '17('2(-! '1! S1-K! 1*! 19'&%&5&*7! '2(&-! -(4#&-(%(*'5;! $:! S(&72'&*7! ,*)!

-,*K&*7!'2(%A!B2(!-(5#.'!&5!,!5(.(8'()!19'&1*!'1!$(!9-17-(55()!,*)!0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!

&*!'2(!+,'2S,:!92,5(A!B2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!E,.&),'&1*!10!'2(!Q"@!1#'81%(5!,*)!'2(!

,#'21-L5! 1$5(-E,'&1*5! ,*,.:5&5! -(81%%(*)! '2,'! '2(! G9'&1*((-&*7! 92,5(! $(! $(5'!

8,--&()!1#'!,.1*75&)(!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(A!

B2(!Y&#&,$)(!R&./$(.)$+#!2/.#!I81*8(9'#,.! 92,5(! VVVJ! &5! *1S! &*'(7-,'()!S&'2&*! '2(!

5.)6@.*! 26.(&9! B2(! K*1S.()7(! 7,&*()! )#-&*7! '2(! -(5(,-82! &*)&8,'(5! '2,'! '2&5!

92,5(! 2,5! '1! 81E(-! ,! S&)(-! 59(8'-#%! '2,*! 1-&7&*,..:! '21#72'! S2(*! 9.,**&*7! '1!

&%9.(%(*'!82,*7(A!<'! '2&5!92,5(!59(8&0&8!(.&8&'()!$(*(0&'5!,-(! .&*K()!'1!-(51#-8(5!

,*)!,-(!,5518&,'()!S&'2!9-1^(8'!9.,*!,8'&E&'&(5A!"',K(21.)(-5!,-(!(*7,7()!'1!,7-((!

1*! '2(! 9,'2S,:! 9.,*! ,*)! 5('! 1S*(-52&9! 01-! %(,5#-&*7! ,*)! %1*&'1-&*7! '2(!

-(,.&5,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5A! B2(! &%9.(%(*','&1*! 9.,*! 7(*(-,'();! ,5! ,! K(:! 1#'81%(! 10!

'2&5! 92,5(! &5! '2(! )18#%(*'! '2,'!S&..! 7#&)(! '2(! 9,'2S,:;! ,5! &'! (E1.E(5! )#-&*7! '2(!

Page 180: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RM!

9-1^(8'!)(.&E(-:!5',7(!,*)! &'!8,*!$(!#5()! 01-!,!9-1^(8'!,55#-,*8(!-(E&(S!,*)!,.51!

01-!7#&)&*7!'2(!19(-,'&1*,.!5',7(!10!'2(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(A!!

B2(!Y&#&,$)(!S%./3.)$+#!.#0!R&%$&@!I81*8(9'#,.!92,5(!VXJ!&5!9-(5(*'()!2(-(!,5!'2(!

F((&((D&#)! 26.(&A! <&%&*7! '1! &*'(7-,'(! '2(! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! S&'2! '2(! S&)(-!

,55(55%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! 1-! 018#5! '2(! 5#88(55! 1-! *1'! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! 1*!S2('2(-!

$(*(0&'5!2,E(!5',-'()! '1!$(!-(,.&5()!1-!*1'A!<'! '2(!,55(55%(*'!92,5(;!$(*(0&'5!,-(!

'-,8K()! ,*)! -(%()&,.! ,8'&1*! &5! ',K(*! ,5! -(4#&-()! '1! (*5#-(! ,)2(-(*8(! '1! '2(!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!9.,*! 7(*(-,'()!)#-&*7! '2(!+,'2S,:!92,5(A! V'! 521#.)! &*8.#)(! ,*:!

,)^#5'%(*'5! '2,'! ',K(! &*'1! ,881#*'! (%(-7&*7! )&00(-(*8(5! '1! '2(! &*'(-*,.! ,*)!

(`'(-*,.! (*E&-1*%(*'5! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S2(*! 81%9,-()! '1! '2(! 01-(8,5'A! B2(!

,55(55%(*'!&5!8,--&()!1#'!$:!&*'(-E&(S5;!4#(5'&1**,&-(5;!915'!188#9,*8:!(E,.#,'&1*!

I,5!&*01-%()!$:!Q"?J!,*)!1'2(-!'(82*&4#(5!'2,'!(*5#-(!)(9(*)(*8:!10!1#'9#'5!'1!

'2(! &)(*'&0&()! 1#'81%(5! IC(*(0&'5! 1-! )&5$(*(0&'5JA! B2(! 9-1^(8'! )18#%(*','&1*! &5!

'2(*!#9),'()!S&'2! '2(!(%(-7&*7!%(,5#-&*7!,*)!%1*&'1-&*7!1#'81%(5A!B2&5! &5!,*!

1*\71&*7! ,8'&E&':! I0-(4#(*8:! 10! '2(! ,55(55%(*'! S&..! )(9(*)! *! '2(! 58,.(! 10! '2(!

9-1^(8'J!S2(-(!5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!(*7,7()!'1!,55(55!'2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5A!!

B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 92,5(5! 81*5&5'! 10! ,! 81%$&*,'&1*! 10! 5',*),-)! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)!

)(.&E(-,$.(5!,5!)(58-&$()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!5(8'&1*5A!B2(!-(81%%(*)()!5(4#(*8(!10!

'2(5(!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!'2(&-!)(.&E(-,$.(5! &5! &..#5'-,'()! &*! '2(! 0.1S82,-'5! &*8.#)()!01-!

(,82!92,5(A!B1!0#-'2(-!,55&5'!'2(!-(,)(-!&*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!'2(!'2&*K&*7!$(2&*)!'2(!

5'-#8'#-(! 10! '2(! 0.1S82,-'5! 10! (,82! 10! '2(! 92,5(5! ,! 7(*(-&8! ,-82&'(8'#-(! 10! (,82!

92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!2(-(!I/&7#-(!@@JA!

Page 181: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RD!

!

X)A85'!--c!>':'/0!70;R9#/51!)008(15/1);2!

H,82!0.1S82,-'! &5!9-(5(*'()!&*!01#-! .,:(-5!,&%&*7!'1!0,8&.&','(!(,5(!10!'2(!9-18(55!

,)19'&1*A!B2(!01#-!.,:(-5!,-(W!!

• G-7,*&5,'&1*,.! &*9#'W!S2(-(!8.&(*'!,*)!#5(-! 59(8&0&8! &*9#'5! 0-1%!'2(!#5#,.!

$#5&*(55!9-18(55(5!1-!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!,8'&E&'&(5!10!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!&5!

-(4#&-()q!

• C(3(,.!59(8&0&8!,8'&E&'&(5W!'2(5(!,-(!,))&'&1*,.!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,8'&E&'&(5!

'2,'!2,E(!$((*!&)(*'&0&()!,5!,*!1#'81%(!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!,*)!,-(!8,--&()!1#'!

$:! '2(!9-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9!1-!C(3(,.! '(,%!,*)! '2(:!,-(! -(81%%(*)()!

01-!'2(!5#88(550#.!&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55q!

• "',K(21.)(-! 0#*8'&1*! 1-! 5#99.&(-! ,8'&E&'&(5W! '2(5(! ,-(! '2(! 5('! 10! ,8'&E&'&(5!

'2,'! -(4#&-(! 0#-'2(-!5',K(21.)(-! &*E1.E(%(*'!,*)!81*5#.','&1*! &*!1-)(-! '1!

(*5#-(! E,.&),'&1*! ,*)! ,55#-,*8(! 10! '2(! 1*! 71&*7! 9-1^(8'! 9-17-(55! ,*)!

0,8&.&','(! '2(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*! 9.,*! ,5! &)(*'&0&()! &*! '2(! 5'-,'(7:! ,.&7*%(*'!

92,5(A!

• 6(.&E(-,$.(5W!,-(!)18#%(*'5!'2,'!,-(!7(*(-,'()!,5!,*!1#'9#'!10!,*!,8'&E&':!

,*)!,-(!0#-'2(-!8,'(71-&5()!,5W!

o FE)$%$)*!0&/$%&'.C/&!Z!,!0&-5'!1#'9#'!10!,*!,8'&E&':q!

!"#$$%&'()*#(+,-+)*./01-

!"#$%&

#'('

!"#$%&

#')'

!"#$%&

#'*'

+,-./,012

-,3'

!"#$%&'()(

4#5,06,7,#6,#5'1$%/.%,3'!"#$%&'(

*(

+,-".//(0(

1.2%$.,342.(0!

!"#$%&'(*(

8' "#$%!!&'(%)*+''%*(+)!

!"#$%&'(0(49'

Page 182: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?RF!

o 8'.#(,+'D&0!0&/$%&'.C/&!\!S2(-(!'2(!1-&7&*,.!,8'&E&':!)(.&E(-,$.(!2,5!

#*)(-71*(! ,! -(E&(S! 1-! 2,5! $((*! #9),'()! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! 0#-'2(-!

81*5#.','&1*!1-!92,5(!9-17-(55&1*q!

o B2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!)('(-%&*()!'2,'!C(3(,.L5!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!

81#.)! $(! 8#5'1%&5()! )(9(*)&*7! 1*! 9-1^(8'! 82,-,8'(-&5'&85! 5#82! ,5!

58,.(! ,*)!%,*,7(%(*'! &*'(*';! 21S(E(-! '2(! 0.1S82,-'! &*)&8,'(! '2,'!

'2(! ?&*! .E)$%$)*! 0&/$%&'.C/&! ,*)! '2(! ?&*! 26.(&! 0&/$%&'.C/&! ,-(!

*(8(55,-:!&0!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!&5!'1!2,E(!,'!%&*&%#%!,!

%(,*&*70#.!,*)!$(*(0&8&,.!81*'-&$#'&1*!'1!'2(!5#88(55!10!'2(!9-1^(8'A!

B2(!K(:!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!10!(,82!92,5(!,-(!0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!&*!'2(!

5(8'&1*5!'2,'!01..1SA!

N$- >':'/0![#/('(!)2!3'1/)0!

N$-$, =15/1'AB!I0)A2@'21!

B2(!5'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!92,5(!.&*K5!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!5'-,'(7:!S&'2!'2(!9-1915()!

&*E(5'%(*'!,*)!'2(!-,*7(!10!91'(*'&,.!,82&(E,$.(!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!5'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!

,8'&E&'&(5!I/&7#-(!@NJ!2,E(!$((*!%,&*.:!&*01-%()!$:!'2(!)18#%(*','&1*!-(E&(S!&*!

,..! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! S2(-(! '2(! *(()! 10! ,*! (,-.:! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! S,5!

)((%()! &*5'-#%(*',.A! B2(:! ,-(! )(5&7*()! '1! .&*K! '2(! $#5&*(55! &*E(5'%(*'!%1)(.!

S&'2!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55;!'-,*5.,'&*7!2&72!.(E(.!91.&8:!&*'1!-(,.&5'&8!,*)!

,99-19-&,'(!,&%5A!!B2(!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!)(0&*()!S&..!9-1%1'(!,!9-17-(55&E(!

-(0&*(%(*'!10!5'-,'(7:!S2&82!9(-%&'5!'2(!&*'(-(5'5!,*)!K*1S.()7(!10!5',K(21.)(-5!

,'! ,..! .(E(.5! 10! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! '1! 52,9(! '2(! 01-%! 10! 5'-,'(7&8! 82,*7(! S2&.(!

-(',&*&*7!'2(!1E(-,..!5'-,'(7&8!)&-(8'&1*!)('(-%&*()!$:!9-&*8&9.(!5'-,'(7:!%,K(-5A!

!V*!1-)(-!'1!8,--:!1#'!'2(5(!,8'&E&'&(5;!,*)!,5!&*E(5'&7,'()!&*!'2(!&*&'&,'&1*!10!(,82!

8,5(!5'#):q!&'!&5!-(81%%(*)()!'2,'!K(:!5',K(21.)(-5!521#.)!$(!$-1#72'!'17('2(-!&*!

,!9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7!7-1#9A!B2&5!7-1#9!S&..!8-(,'(!,!81..(8'&E(!E&5&1*!01-!'2(!9-17-,%!

10! 91'(*'&,.! 1#'9#'5! ,*)! '2(&-! &%9,8'! 1*! '2(! -(59(8'&E(! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 1'2(-!

$#5&*(55!,8'&E&'&(5!Z!.(,)&*7!'1!,7-((%(*'!1*!'2(!2&72!.(E(.!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5A!

Page 183: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?M>!

V*!,..!92,5(5!(00(8'&E(!81%%#*&8,'&1*!S&'2!,..!5',K(21.)(-5!&5!K(:!'1!'2(!5#88(55!10!

'2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55A! B2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 2,E(! 521S*! '2,'! &*'(-*,.!

5',K(21.)(-5;!'215(!8.15(-!'1!'2(!9-1^(8';!10'(*!#5(!81%9.&8,'()!'(-%&*1.17&(5!,*)!

'(82*&8,.!),',!)#-&*7! '2(&-!)&581#-5(!S&'2! '2(!S&)(-!5',K(21.)(-!7-1#9A!B2&5!8,*!

.(,)! '1! 911-! 81%%#*&8,'&1*! $('S((*! '2(! 7-1#9! ,*)! ,! .,8K! 10! #*)(-5',*)&*7!

I[:*)5!,*)!T,-'&*;!?FFOJA!"',K(21.)(-5!*(()!'1!$(!,S,-(!10!'2&5!,*)!(*5#-(!'2,'!

'2(:! 81%%#*&8,'(! 0.#(*'.:! ,'! ,..! '&%(5! 51! '2,'! '2-1#721#'! '2(! 9-1^(8'L5! .&0(8:8.(!

(E(-:! 9(-51*! &*E1.E()! &5! ,S,-(! 10! '2(! c8#--(*'L! 5','#5! 10! '2(&-! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! '2(&-!

-1.(A!B2(-(01-(!,*!(,-.:!5',K(21.)(-!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*!9.,*!*(()5!'1!$(!&*&'&,'()!

S&'2&*!'2(!5'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!92,5(A!!

6#-&*7! '2&5! 92,5(! ,*! ,.&7*%(*'! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! S&'2! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!

&*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.!%('21)! &5! K(:! ,5! &'! S,5! '(5'()!%,&*.:! &*! Q"=! ,*)! Q"@! I,5!

9-(5(*'()!&*!5(8'&1*5!NA@A=!,*)!NA@A@J!S2(*!'2(!,.&7*%(*'!10!'2(!9-18(55!S&'2!'2(!

QVT!,*)!U,'(S,:Y!9-18(55(5!S,5!E,.&),'()A!B2&5!,99-1,82;!'2,'!%&`(5!,*!(`&5'&*7!

I,*)!5',K(21.)(-5L!K*1S*J!9-18(55!S&'2!,!*(S!,*)!(%(-7&*7!9-18(55;!8,*!0#-'2(-!

(*,$.(! C(3(,.L5! #5(! ,5! ,! '11.! '2,'! $-&*75! &*)&E&)#,.5! ,*)! '(,%5! '17('2(-! S2&.5'!

$-(,K&*7! )1S*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! $,--&(-5! $:! 52&0'&*7! 9(19.(L5! '2&*K&*7! '1S,-)5!

$(*(0&'5! ,*)! 1#'81%(5A! V*! 5#%%,-:! '2&5! 92,5(! 10! C(3(,.! 018#5(5! 1*! '2(! *(()!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 0-1%! ,! $(*(0&'5! 9(-59(8'&E(;! ,*)! 1*! '2(! &*&'&,.! )(E(.19%(*'!

^#5'&0&8,'&1*! 10! 82,*7(! &*E(5'%(*'5;! ,55#-&*7! 9-19(-! ,.&7*%(*'! S&'2! '2(!

1-7,*&5,'&1*!5'-,'(7:A!

d(:!,8'&E&'&(5!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!-(81%%(*)()!01-!'2(!5'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!92,5(!,-(W!

# "'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*q!

! B2(! ,&%! &5! '1! '-,*5.,'(! '2(! 9-(.&%&*,-:! *(()! 81*8(9'! &*'1! %(,*&*70#.!

9-1^(8'!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5q!

! B2(! (%92,5&5! &5! 1*! 81*'(`'#,.&5&*7! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*y5! 71,.5! ,*)!

8.,-&0:&*7!)&-(8'&1*q!

! C(*(0&'5! (.&8&'()! 0-1%! %(('&*75;! S1-K52195! ,*)a1-! 5#-E(:5! ,-(!

5#$5(4#(*'.:! 5(7%(*'()! &*! I5#$J! 8,'(71-&(5;! $:! 5&%&.,-&':! ,*)!

)&55&%&.,-&':!8-&'(-&,q!,*)!

Page 184: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?M?!

! <8'&E&':!)(.&E(-,$.(W!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'5!5('A!

# ](()!^#5'&0&8,'&1*!-(E&(Sq!

! P5(! %(('&*75! ,*)! S1-K52195! '1! (*7,7(! &*! )&58#55&1*! $('S((*!

5',K(21.)(-5q!

! /#-'2(-! 82,-,8'(-&5(! '2(! 9-(.&%&*,-:! *(()! '2,'! .()! '1! '2(!

9-17-,%a9-1^(8'!&*&'&,'&1*q!,*)!

! <8'&E&':!)(.&E(-,$.(W!618#%(*'()!5',K(21.)(-5y!9(-8(9'&1*5!10!'2(!*(()!

^#5'&0&8,'&1*A!

<!0.1S!82,-'!10!,..!'2(!-(81%%(*)()!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!10!'2(!-)'.)&A*!

F/$A#D&#'!92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!/&7#-(!@NA!!

Page 185: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?M=!

X)A85'!-Pc!=15/1'AB!/0)A2@'21![#/('!70;R9#/51!

Page 186: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?M@!

N$-$* ?0)9)1/1);2!

V*! '2(! (.&8&','&1*! 92,5(! '2(! c5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5L! ,-(! 0#-'2(-! E,.&),'()! ,*)! 'S1!

,))&'&1*,.! .(E(.5! 10! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&();! "#$! ,*)! H*)! $(*(0&'5A! B2&5! ,99-1,82!

S,5! &*'-1)#8()! &*! =A?OA=! ,*)! (`,%&*()! '2-1#72! ,..! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5A! ! "#$!

C(*(0&'5! ,-(! 59(8&0&8! ',-7('5! .&*K()! '1! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! '2,'! 5#991-'! '2(!

(E,.#,'&1*! 10! )(5&7*! 19'&1*5;! S2&.(! H*)! C(*(0&'5! ,-(! 59(8&0&8! ',-7('5! '2,'! (*,$.(!

9(-01-%,*8(! '1! $(!%(,5#-()A!6#-&*7! '2&5! 92,5(! )(9(*)(*8&(5! $('S((*! ,..! '2-((!

.(E(.5!,-(!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!'2(!81-(!$(*(0&'!9-10&.(!&5!8-(,'()!I)(58-&$()!&*!OANA?JA!

<8'&E&'&(5!S2&82!5#82!,5!c$(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7L!,*)!c5(7%(*','&1*L!,-(!#5()!'1!,--&E(!,'!

,!5('!10! 5'-#8'#-();!9-10&.()!$(*(0&'5! '2,'!8,*!$(!1-7,*&5()!$:! ':9(!5#82!,5;! '&%(;!

1S*(-52&9;!1-7,*&5,'&1*!&%9,8';!('8A!

/1-!(`,%9.(!,!5'-,'(7&8!$(*(0&'!u&%9-1E(%(*'!&*!9,'&(*'!(`9(-&(*8(v;!%,:!2,E(!'2(!

01..1S&*7! 5#$! $(*(0&'5! u&*8-(,5()! 9,'&(*'! 821&8(v;! u-()#8()! S,&'&*7! '&%(v;!

u&%9-1E()!81%%#*&':!0,8&.&'&(5v!,*)!u7-(,'(-!9-&E,8:vA!!

B2(! 5#$! $(*(0&'! u&*8-(,5()! 9,'&(*'! 821&8(v! %,:! $(! .&*K()! '1! ,*! (*)! $(*(0&'!

uV*8-(,5()!2(,.'2!5(-E&8(5!,E,&.,$.(vW!

# uV%9-1E(%(*'!&*!9,'&(*'!(`9(-&(*8(v!9-1E&)(5!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!)&-(8'&1*!10!'2(!

9-1^(8'q!

# uV*8-(,5()!9,'&(*'! 821&8(v;! u-()#8()!S,&'&*7! '&%(v;! u&%9-1E()! 81%%#*&':!

0,8&.&'&(5!,*)!7-(,'(-!9-&E,8:v!S&..!9-1E&)(!'2(!8-&'(-&,!1*!S2&82!19'&1*5!8,*!

$(!521-'.&5'()q!,*)!

# uV*8-(,5()! 2(,.'2! 5(-E&8(5! ,E,&.,$.(v! &5! '2(! ',*7&$.(! ',-7('! '2,'! 8,*! $(!

%(,5#-()A!!

B2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!(,82!$(*(0&'! &5!)('(-%&*()! '2-1#72! '2(!)(9(*)(*8:!8-&'(-&,!,5!

(5',$.&52()!)#-&*7!'2&5!92,5(A!!

d(:!,8'&E&'&(5!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!-(81%%(*)()!)#-&*7!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(!,-(W!

Page 187: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MN!

# /&*,.&5(!$(*(0&'5! 5(7%(*','&1*!Z!<!5(.(8'()!9-1^(8'\S1-K&*7!7-1#9! 0#-'2(-!

5(7%(*'5! $(*(0&'5! #5&*7! 5&%&.,-&':! ,*)! )&55&%&.,-&':! 8-&'(-&,A! 6#-&*7! '2&5!

,8'&E&':!'2(!7-1#9!521#.)!81*5&)(-!'2(!S&)(-!&%9,8'!10!'2(!$(*(0&'!1*!$1'2!

'2(! &*'(-*,.! ,*)! (`'(-*,.! (*E&-1*%(*'! I(A7A;! 0&*,*8&,.! &%9,8';! 5',K(21.)(-!

&%9,8';!('8AJ;!I5((!(`,%9.(!&*!<99(*)&`!VVVA@JA!

# ](()! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*! -(E&(S!Z!B2(!*(()! 01-! '2(! 51.#'&1*! '2,'! '2(!9-1^(8'!S&..!

)(.&E(-! &5! -(E&(S()! &*! .&72'! 10! '2(! %1-(! )(',&.()! $(*(0&'! 5'-#8'#-(A! B2(!

"'-,'(7&8!$#5&*(55!8,5(!&*&'&,'()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!92,5(!&5!#9),'()!'1!9-1E&)(!

,!%1-(!-1$#5'!^#5'&0&8,'&1*!01-!'2(!*(()!,*)!'1!9-1E&)(!(E&)(*8(!01-!$(''(-!

)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7A!

<!0.1S!82,-'!10!,..!'2(!-(81%%(*)()!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!10!'2(!

S/$E$).)$+#!92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!/&7#-(!@OA!

Page 188: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MO!

X)A85'!-Nc!?0)9)1/1);2![#/('!70;R9#/51!

Page 189: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MR!

N$-$- J[1);2''5)2A!

V*! '2(! 19'&1*((-&*7! 92,5(;! 19'&1*5! ,-(! ^#)7()! ,7,&*5'! (`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! ,*)!

,E,&.,$&.&':! 10! 0#*)&*7A! "',K(21.)(-5! S1-K! 1*! 19'&%&5&*7! '2(&-! -(4#&-(%(*'5;! $:!

S(&72'&*7!,*)!-,*K&*7!'2(%A!B2(*;!'2(!-(5#.'!&5!#5()!'1!5(.(8'!,!9-(0(--()!19'&1*A!!

B2(! 19'&1*((-&*7! ,*)! '2(! (.&8&','&1*! 92,5(5! ,-(! ,&%&*7! '1! )(,.! S&'2! '2(! *1*\

81*5&)(-,'&1*!10! 51%(! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,*)!21S! '2(:! 8,*! &*0.#(*8(!9-1^(8'5L! -(5#.'5!

I_,-)! r! 6,*&(.;! =>>RJ! '2,'! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &)(*'&0&()! ,5! 1*(! 10! '2(! %,&*!

-(,51*!01-!9-1^(8'!0,&.#-(A!!

G9'&1*((-&*7! &*E1.E(5! &)(*'&0:&*7!,*)!,55(55&*7!,.'(-*,'&E(!82,*7(!19'&1*5!$,5()!

1*!,!%&`!10!)&%(*5&1*5A!<!'2-((\5'(9!,99-1,82!'2,'!&*8.#)(5!,!$(*(0&';!,*!(81*1%&8!

,*)! ,! %#.'&\8-&'(-&,! ,99-1,82! &5! )(-&E()! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! $:!

&*E(5'&7,'&*7!'2&5!9,-'!10!'2(!9-18(55!)#-&*7!Q"@!,5!)(58-&$()!&*!NA@A@A!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!,99-1,82!&*E1.E(5!$(*(0&'5!-,*K&*7!10!19'&1*5!S2(-(!'2(!0&-5'!5'(9!&5!

'1! 521-'\.&5'! '2(! &)(*'&0&()!19'&1*5;! $,5()!1*! '2(! '2-((\'&(-!$(*(0&'! 5'-#8'#-(;! ,*)!

#5&*7!,*!,99-19-&,'(!58,.(A!

B2(! (81*1%&8! ,99-1,82! ,*,.:5(5! '2(! 521-'\.&5'()! 19'&1*5! $,5()! 1*! 8,52! 0.1S5!

4#,*'&','&E(!,*,.:5&5;!&*!S2&82!$(*(0&'5!IE,.#(J!,-(!*1S!81%9,-()!'1!82,*7(!I815'J!

10!(E(-:!,.'(-*,'&E(!19'&1*!I(A7A;!)1!*1'2&*7;!)1!%&*&%#%;!19'&1*!<JA!

B2(! %#.'&\8-&'(-&,! ,99-1,82! ,*,.:5(5! '2(! 19'&1*5! $,5()! 1*! '2(! (81*1%&8!

)&%(*5&1*! IE,.#(! \! 815'J;! S2&82! &5! *1S! $-1,)(*()! '1! &*8.#)(! ,))&'&1*,.! 9-1^(8'!

8#5'1%&5()!)&%(*5&1*5;!5#82!,5!'&%(!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*!-(,)&*(55A!

/1..1S&*7! '2(!%#.'&\8-&'(-&,! -,*K&*7! ,8'&E&':;! S2&82! -,*K5! 19'&1*5;! '2(! 9-(0(--()!

19'&1*!&5!&)(*'&0&()A!

B2(!K(:!,8'&E&'&(5!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!-(81%%(*)()!,'!'2(!19'&1*((-&*7!92,5(5!,-(W!

# 3(.,'&E(! S(&72'&*7! 10! $(*(0&'5! Z! B2-1#72! ,! 5%,..! $#'! -(9-(5(*','&E(!

5',K(21.)(-!S1-K5219!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!,*)!5#$!$(*(0&'5!,-(!S(&72'()q!

Page 190: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MM!

# T#.'&\8-&'(-&,!-,*K&*7!10!19'&1*5!Z!T#.'&\8-&'(-&,!-,*K&*7!&5!,!81-(!,8'&E&':!&*!

'2(!G9'&1*((-&*7!92,5(;!&*E1.E&*7!'2(!,8'&E(!9,-'&8&9,'&1*!10!5',K(21.)(-5!'1!

581-(! 82,*7(! 19'&1*5! ,881-)&*7! '1! ,! 7-1#9! 10! S(&72'()! )&%(*5&1*5A! B2(!

1#'81%(!&5!,*!1-7,*&5()!,*)!-,*K()!.&5'!10!,55(55()!82,*7(!19'&1*5q!,*)!

# "(.(8'&1*! 10! '2(! 9-(0(--()! 19'&1*! Z! C,5()! 1*! '2(! T#.'&\8-&'(-&,! 19'&1*5!

-(91-';! ,! 5(.(8'()! 7-1#9! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! I(A7A;! &*E(5'%(*'! $1,-)J! ,*,.:5(5!

,*)!)&58#55(5!-(5#.'5;! &)(*'&0&(5!*(`'!5'(95! 01-! 0#'#-(!-(0(-(*8(!,*)!,7-((5!

,8'&1*A! C,5()! 1*! '2(! 19'&1*5! ,55(55%(*'! &*01-%,'&1*! ,! 9-18(55! .119! 1-! ,!

0&*,.!&*E(5'%(*'!)(8&5&1*!521#.)!188#-A!!

<!0.1S!82,-'!10!,..!'2(!-(81%%(*)()!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!10!'2(!+2)$+#&&'$#A!

92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2(!/&7#-(!@RA!

!

Page 191: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MD!

X)A85'!-Tc!J[1);2''5)2A![#/('!70;R9#/51!

Page 192: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?MF!

N$-$P "/1#R/B!

B2(!+,'2S,:!92,5(!018#5(5!1*!'2(!)(',&.()!9.,*!'1!%,*,7(!,*)!-(,.&5(!'2(!)(0&*()!

$(*(0&'5! ,*)! &*81-91-,'(! #*9.,**()! 1*(5! S&'2&*! '2(! 81*'(`'! 10! '2(! 9-(0(--()!

19'&1*!10!'2(!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'A!!

V*!-(,.&':!'2(!9,'2S,:!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!5',-'5!,5!511*!,5!'2(:!,-(!81*8(&E()!)#-&*7!

'2(!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(A!

C:!'2(!'&%(!'2&5!92,5(!&5!-(,82()!'2(!$(*(0&'5!(.&8&'()!(,-.&(-!&*!'2(!9-18(55!S1#.)!

2,E(!$((*!5#$^(8'!'1!-1$#5'!81*5#.','&1*A!Q1%%1*.:!,7-(()!,''-&$#'(5!S1#.)!2,E(!

$((*! ,55&7*()! ,*)! S2,'! -(%,&*5! '1! $(! )1*(! &5! '1! .&*K! '2(5(! )&-(8'.:! '1! '2(!

9-1915()!9-1^(8'a82,*7(!9.,*A!!

/#-'2(-!,*,.:5&5!,*)!9.,**&*7!&5!9(-01-%()!'1!)(E(.19!,!-1$#5'!,8'&1*!9.,*!S2(-(!

$(*(0&'5!,*)!,8'&E&'&(5!,-(!8.15(.:!&*'(-)(9(*)(*';!(*,$.&*7!&%%()&,'(!-(817*&'&1*!

10!'2(!&%9,8'!10!,*:!9.,*!E,-&,'&1*!'1!'2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5A!!

B2&5!92,5(!,))-(55(5! 'S1!10! '2(!%,&*! -(,51*5! &)(*'&0&()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S!

,*)!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!N!,5!'1!S2:!,!9-1^(8'!0,&.!'1!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5!&A(A!B2(!.1*7!

9(-&1)5! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'L5! .&0(! 8:8.(;! .(,)&*7! '1! ,! )&581**(8'&1*! $('S((*! $(*(0&'5!

9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-:! )#(! '1! 82,*7(5! &*! 9(-51**(.! I3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJq! ,*)! '2(!

*1*\81*5&)(-,'&1*! 10! *(8(55,-:! &*'(-81**(8'()! &55#(5! '2,'! %&72'! &*0.#(*8(! '2(!

9-1^(8'L5!5#88(55!IB21-9;!?FFDJA!

6#-&*7!'2&5!92,5(!,!8.15(!.&*K!10!$(*(0&'5;!,8'&E&'&(5;!-(51#-8(5!,*)!K(:!9(-01-%,*8(!

&*)&8,'1-5! &5! (5',$.&52()A! T(,5#-(%(*'! %('21)5;! ),',! 51#-8(5! ,*)! 59(8&0&8!

%(,5#-(5! ,-(! ,55&7*()! '1! (,82! $(*(0&'A! C,5(.&*(! I,5\&5J! ,*)! ',-7('! I'1\$(J! 5','(!

58(*,-&15! ,-(! )18#%(*'()! ,*)! 9-1E&)(! '2(! 9.,'01-%! 01-! (00(8'&E(*(55! ,*)!

(00&8&(*8:!7,&*5!'1!$(!81%9,-()A!

B2(!K(:!,8'&E&':!10!'2(!+,'2S,:!92,5(!&5W!

# V%9.(%(*','&1*! 9.,*! )(E(.19%(*'! Z! BS1! K(:! (.(%(*'5;! $(*(0&'5! ,*)!

-(51#-8(5!,-(!,*,.:5()!'1!(*,$.(!,!)(9(*)(*8:!*('S1-K!'1!$(!8-(,'()A!B2&5!

,8'&E&':! (*5#-(5! '2,'! '2(-(! &5! ,! 8.(,-! .&*K! $('S((*! 82,*7(! 9-1^(8'5! I(A7A;!

Page 193: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?D>!

7-1#9! 10! ,8'&E&'&(5;! 59(8&0&8! ',5K5;! '&%(! 0-,%(a)#-,'&1*;! ,*)! -&5K5J! ,*)!

$(*(0&'5A!

<!)(',&.()!&%9.(%(*','&1*!9.,*!521#.)!(*8,95#.,'(!,!%,*,7(%(*'!0-,%(S1-K!'2,'!

(*,$.(5!-(E&(S!10W! '2(!$,5(.&*(!I,5\&5J!E5A! ',-7('()!I'1\$(J!E(-5#5!,8'#,.! I,5\&5J! &5!

,7-(()! ,*)! )18#%(*'()A! +(-01-%,*8(! %(,5#-(%(*'! %('21)5! &*! '(-%5! 10! S2,';!

21S;!S21!,*)!S2(*!&5!0#..:!&)(*'&0&()!,*)!)18#%(*'()A!

<!0.1S!82,-'!10!,..!'2(!-(81%%(*)()!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(5!10!'2(!5.)6@.*!

92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!/&7#-(!@MA!!

!

Page 194: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?D?!

X)A85'!-Oc!"/1#R/B![#/('!70;R9#/51!

Page 195: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?D=!

N$-$N I(('((@'21!

B2(!<55(55%(*'!92,5(!2,99(*5!)#-&*7!'2(!82,*7(!&%9.(%(*','&1*!,*)!'2(-(,0'(-;!

(*,$.&*7! '-,8K&*7!10! '2(! -(,.&5,'&1*!10! '2(!$(*(0&'5! ,*)! 82,*7(!9.,*!(*5#-&*7! '2(!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)!&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!-(%()&,.!,8'&1*5A!

B2&5!92,5(!018#5(5!1*!21S!'1!(E,.#,'(!82,*7(!,*)!'2(!.(E(.!10!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*;!

&)(*'&0:&*7! *(8(55,-:! ,)^#5'%(*'5! ,5! ,! -(5#.'! 10! '2(! &*'(-*,.! ,*)a1-! (`'(-*,.!

81*'(`'!'1!%,`&%&e(!-(,.&5()!$(*(0&'5!,*)!%&*&%&5(!)&5\$(*(0&'5A!

B2(! ,55(55%(*'! 92,5(! '-,8K5! 1#'81%(! ,5! '2(:! (%(-7(! I,5\&5a,8'#,.J;! 81%9,-(!

'2(%! '1! '2(! &*&'&,.! 915&'&1*! I,5\&5a$,5(.&*(J! ,*)! '1! 9.,*! I'1\$(! ',-7('J! ,*)!

0,8&.&','(5!81--(8'&E(!,8'&1*5!&*!'2(!.&72'!10!82,*7(5A!

B2(! ,55(55%(*'! &5! 8,--&()! 1#'! $:! &*'(-E&(S5;! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5;! 915'! 188#9,*8:!

(E,.#,'&1*! ,*)! 1'2(-! '(82*&4#(5! ,5! &*E(5'&7,'()! &*! Q"?! 9-(5(*'()! &*! NA@A?! V'! &5!

&%91-',*'! '1! 2&72.&72'! 2(-(! '2,'! &0! '2(! E,.#,'&1*! &5! '1! $(! ^#)7()! &*! '(-%5! 10!

5',K(21.)(-! 5,'&50,8'&1*;! '2&5! &5! ,! E(-:! )&00&8#.'! '2&*7! '1! %(,5#-(A! f#,.&','&E(!

)(58-&9'&1*! &5! *(8(55,-:! &*! ,))&'&1*! '1! ,*:! 4#,*'&','&E(! %(,5#-(5! #5();! &0! '2(!

$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!9-19(-.:!(E,.#,'()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(&-!.(E(.!10!-(,.&5,'&1*A!311K(!('!

,.A! I=>?>J!5,:!'2,'!,!)&5'&*8'&1*!521#.)!$(!)-,S*!$('S((*!1#'9#'5!,*)!1#'81%(5!

S2(*! (E,.#,'&*7! 9-1^(8'5A! B2(:! 71! 1*! '1! (`9.,&*! '2,'! 9-1^(8'! 1#'9#'5! ,-(!

'2(1-('&8,..:! #*)(-! '2(! )&-(8'! 81*'-1.! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*';! 21S(E(-!

5',K(21.)(-! E,.#(! %,:! $(! $(5'! 81*8(&E()! &*! '(-%5! 10! 1#'81%(5W! '2(! (00(8'! '2,'!

'2(5(!1#'9#'5!2,E(!1*!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!.&0(!1-!$#5&*(55A!V'!&5!,.51!&%91-',*'!'1!.11K!

0,-! &*'1! '2(! .&0(8:8.(! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! &'5! 1#'9#'5! &*! 1-)(-! '1! ,99-(8&,'(! &'5! '-#(!

915&'&E(! 1-! *(7,'&E(! 1#'81%(5;! ,5! '2(5(! 9-17-(55&E(.:! 9(-8(&E()! $:! 5',K(21.)(-5!

'2,'!&*'(-,8'!S&'2!&'A! V*!5&%9.(!'(-%5!)('(-%&*(!&0!'2(!$(*(0&'5!2,E(!$((*!-(,.&5()!

1-!*1'A!

B2&5!92,5(!521#.)!$(!5((*!,5!,*!1*\71&*7!,8'&E&':!S2(-(!5',K(21.)(-5!,-(!(*7,7()!

'1! ,55(55! '2(! -(,.&5,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 5&%#.',*(1#5.:! ,84#&-(! K*1S.()7(! ,*)!

.(,-*!0-1%!'2(!9-18(55A!HE,.#,'&1*!&5!1*.:!#5(0#.!&*,5%#82!,5!&'!,8'5!,5!'2(!$,5&5!01-!

.(,-*&*7! ,*)! &%9-1E(%(*'! I311K(! ('! ,.A;! =>?>J;! ,*)! .(,)5! '1! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!

Page 196: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?D@!

.(,-*&*7! 2(.9&*7! 9(19.(! '1! $#&.)! ,! %#'#,.! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! $(*(0&'5;! 815'5! ,*)!

-&5K5! Id,9.,*! ,*)!]1-'1*;! ?FFRJA! B2&5! &*! '#-*! 5#991-'5! 9-18(55! &%9-1E(%(*'! ,5!

9(19.(!.(,-*!$:!'2(&-!%&5',K(5!I/,-$(:!('!,.A;!?FFFJ!,*)!5#991-'5!'2(!,)19'&1*!10!,!

81*'&*#1#5!&%9-1E(%(*'!8:8.(!,5!)&58#55()!&*!5(8'&1*!=AOA!

B2(!K(:!,8'&E&':!&)(*'&0&()!&*!'2(!,55(55%(*'!92,5(!&5W!

# +.,*! -(%()&,.! ,8'&1*5! Z! '2&5! ,8'&E&':! -(.,'(5! '1! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!-(%()&,.!,8'&1*5!'1W!

! H*2,*8(! (00(8'&E(*(55! $:! $(''(-! ,.&7*&*7! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! 82,*7(! I,5\

&5a,8'#,.J! S&'2! '2(! &*&'&,.! 915&'&1*! I$,5(.&*(J! ,*)! '2(! 9.,**()!

58(*,-&1!I',-7('Jq!,*)!

! G9'&%&5(! (00&8&(*8:! $('S((*! 82,*7(! ,*)! $(*(0&'5;! %,`&%&e&*7!

-(,.&5()!$(*(0&'5!,*)!%&*&%&5&*7!-(4#&-()!82,*7(!,*)!)&5\$(*(0&'5A!

B2&5! 92,5(! 9#'! (%92,5&5! 1*! '2(! S&)(.:! ,7-(()! ,-7#%(*'! '2,'! %(,5#-(%(*'! &5!

8(*'-,.! '1!%,*,7&*7!$(*(0&'5! IB21-9;! ?FFDJA! B2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 2,E(! 521S*! &*! '2(!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'! (.&8&','&1*! 92,5(! '2,'! 51%(! $(*(0&'5! %,:! (%(-7(!

#*,*'&8&9,'()! 0-1%! '2(! 82,*7(! 9-18(55! I/,-$(:! ('! ,.A;! ?FFFJ! S2&.(! 1'2(-5! ,-(!

*,'#-,..:!)&00&8#.'! '1!%(,5#-(!I3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!B2&5! &55#(! &5!81*'-1E(-5&,.!S&'2!

51%(!,-7#&*7!'2,'!510'!$(*(0&'5!%,:!2,E(!'1!$(!1%&''()!0-1%!,!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!

9.,*!IU.:**(;!=>>MJ;!S2&.(!1'2(-5!5#77(5'!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!*1'!'&()!'1!d+V5!,-(!10!.&''.(!

E,.#(!IC(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,88,-&*&;!=>>NJA![1S(E(-!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!521S!'2,'!'2(5(!

510'!$(*(0&'5!,-(!10'(*!'2(!%15'!&%91-',*'A![,-)!%(,5#-(5!5#82!,5!0&*,*8&,.!0&7#-(5!

8,*!10'(*!$(!)(8(9'&E(;!,5!'2(!&*',*7&$.(!,55('5!10!,!$#5&*(55!1-!,*!1-7,*&5,'&1*!,-(!

10'(*!#.'&%,'(.:!10!0,-!7-(,'(-!E,.#(!,*)!5192&5'&8,'()!%(,5#-(5!(`&5'!01-!8,9'#-&*7!

'2(%!IC,-'21.1%(S;!?FFFJA!T(,5#-(5!521#.)!$(!81%9-(2(*5&E(!,*)!,7-(()!$:!,..!

5',K(21.)(-5;! 81E(-&*7! ,..! '2(! &%91-',*'! 1#'81%(5! '2-1#72! '2(! .&0(8:8.(! 10! '2(!

82,*7(!&*&'&,'&E(A!B2(:!%#5'!,.51!$(!-&71-1#5!S&'2!$(*(0&'5!(`9-(55()!&*!5#82!,!S,:!

'2,'!'2(&-!-(,.&5,'&1*!81#.)!$(!)(%1*5'-,$.(!I3(&55!('!,.A;!=>>RJA!B2(:!%#5'!,.51!$(!

8.(,-.:! 1S*()! $:! .&,$.(! 591*51-5! IB21-9;! ?FF>JA! <! 0.1S! 82,-'! 10! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)!

)(.&E(-,$.(5!S&'2&*!'2(!F((&((D&#)!92,5(!&5!9-(5(*'()!&*!/&7#-(!@DA!

Page 197: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DN!

X)A85'!-Sc!I(('((@'21![#/('!70;R9#/51!

Page 198: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DO!

N$P G'B!>':'/0!1;;0(!/23!1'9#2)]8'(!

V*! '2(!9-(E&1#5! 5(8'&1*! '2(!9-18(55!92,5(5!S(-(! &*'-1)#8()!,*)!)(58-&$();!S2,'!

01..1S5!&5!,!.&5'!10!'2(!K(:!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!,5!'2(:!2,E(!$((*!)(E(.19()!)#-&*7!

'2&5!-(5(,-82!,*)!#5()!'2-1#721#'!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!B2(!,#'21-!2&72.&72'5!'2(5(!

,5!(55(*'&,.!&*!1-)(-!'1!,82&(E(!'2(!9-18(55!)(.&E(-,$.(5!,*)!81*'-&$#'(!'1S,-)5!&'!

5#88(550#.!&%9.(%(*','&1*A!B2(5(!,-(W!!

# C(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7q!

# C(*(0&'5!$-(,K)1S*!,*)!2&(-,-82:q!

# C(*(0&'5!5(7%(*','&1*q!

# T#.'&\8-&'(-&,!-,*K&*7!Z!G9'&1*((-&*7q!

# C(*(0&'5;!,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!-(51#-8(5!)(9(*)(*8&(5q!,*)!

# Q1*'-1..&*7!,55#-,*8(q!

B2(5(!,-(!0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!&*!'2(!01..1S&*7!9,7(5A!

N$P$, >'2'7)1(![5;7)0)2A!

C(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! &5!,! 0#*),%(*',.!,8'&E&':! &*! '2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55! &'! &*&'&,..:!)(,.5!

S&'2! S2,'! 2,5! $((*! 2&72.&72'()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &*! -(0(-(*8(! '1! '2(!

E,7#(*(55!S&'2!S2&82!'2(!(`9(8'()!$(*(0&'5!10!,!9-1^(8'!,-(!)(0&*()A!I3(&55!('!,.A;!

=>>RJ!,5!S(..!,5! '2(!#*8(-',&*':!S&'2&*!9-1^(8'! '(,%5! &*!,..18,'&*7!-(591*5&$&.&':!

01-!%,*,7&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!$(*(0&'5!Ib&*!,*)!+(-E,*;!=>>?JA!

B2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 2,E(! 521S*! '2,'! '2(-(! ,-(! 10'(*! )&00&8#.'&(5! '1! #*)(-5',*)!

'(-%&*1.17:!S&'2&*!S1-K52195!(A7A!S2,'!&5!,!$(*(0&'t!,!5#$\$(*(0&'t!%(,5#-(5!,*)!

%('21)5t!B2(!9-18(55! &%9.(%(*','&1*!'(,%!*(()5!'1!$(!8.(,-!10! '(-%5!&'5(.0!,*)!

81*E(:!'2&5!'1!'2(!7-1#9!10!5',K(21.)(-5!&*E1.E()!,'!,*:!5',7(!10!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'A!!

C(*(0&'5! 8,9'#-(! &5! '2(! 9-18(55! 10! &)(*'&0:&*7! ,*)! )(58-&$&*7! $(*(0&'5;! ,5! '2(:!

#*)(-5'11)!S&'2&*! '2(! 81*'(`'! 10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! ,*)! &'5! 5',K(21.)(-5A! G*8(! '2(! K(:!

Page 199: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DR!

5',K(21.)(-5!2,E(!$((*!&)(*'&0&();!'2(!$(*(0&'5!'2(:!)(5&-(!0-1%!'2(!9-1^(8'!8,*!$(!

(.&8&'()!'2-1#72!,!81*5#.','&1*!9-18(55!,5!)(58-&$()! &*! '2(!&/$E$).)$+#!26.(&!#5&*7!

'(82*&4#(5!5#82!,5!S1-K52195!,*)! &*'(-E&(S5!IC(**&*7'1*!,*)!C,88,-&*&;!=>>NJA!

B2(5(!521#.)!$(!5'-#8'#-()!51!,5!'1!#*)(-5',*)!'2(!-(.,'&1*5!$('S((*!82,*7(5!&*!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(;!1-!'(82*1.17:;!$#5&*(55!9-18(55(5!,*)!$#5&*(55!9(-01-%,*8(!I",K,-!

,*)!_&)(5',)2;!=>>OJA!B2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!2,E(!81*0&-%()!S2,'!S,5!&)(*'&0&()!&*!'2(!

.&'(-,'#-(! '2,'! &*! ,))&'&1*! '1! 8,9'#-&*7! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2&5! 9-18(55! %,`&%&5(5!

81%%&'%(*'! IU.:**(;! =>>MJ! ,*)! 81%%#*&8,'(5! '2(! 5'-,'(7&8! ,*)! (81*1%&8!

81*5'-,&*'5!1*!'2(!82,*7(!&*&'&,'&E(!I3(%(*:&!,*)!"%&'2;!?FFDJA!

Q"?! &*&'&,..:! '(5'()! '2(! 81*5'&'#'&1*!10! ,! $(*(0&'! 9-10&.(! '(%9.,'(! IC-,).(:;! =>>RJ!

,*)! &'5!#5(!S,5! &*8-(%(*',..:! '(5'()!,*)!E,.&),'()! &*!Q"=!,*)!Q"@;!B2(!-(5(,-82!

E,.&),'()!'2,'!,!':9&8,.!$(*(0&'!9-10&.(!521#.)!&*8.#)(!,5!,!%&*&%#%W!

o 6(58-&9'&1*!01-!(,82!$(*(0&'!1-!)&5\$(*(0&'q!

o [1S!&'!S&..!$(!%(,5#-()!I(A7A!01-%#.,;!51#-8(!10!),',Jq!!

o V5!&'!,!4#,.&','&E(!1-!4#,*'&','&E(!$(*(0&'q!

o <!0&*,*8&,.!E,.#,'&1*!&0!9155&$.(q!

o V'5!&%9,8'!1*!8#--(*'!$#5&*(55!9-18(55(5q!

o [1S!&'!&*'(-,8'5!S&'2!1'2(-!$(*(0&'5q!,*)!!

o B2(!5',7(!,'!S2&82!&5!.&K(.:!'1!81%(!1*!5'-(,%A!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7!521#.)!$(!&*&'&,'()!,'!5'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!1-!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(!

,*)!K(9'!#*)(-!81*5',*'!-(E&(S!'2(!82,*7(!9-18(55!,*)!)(9(*)&*7!1*!'2(!58,.(!10!

'2(!9-1^(8'!%,:$(!5#$^(8'! '1!,.'(-,'&1*!IQQB<;!?FFFJ!,5! &'!S,5!(5',$.&52()! &*! '2(!

8,5(!5'#)&(5A!

<! '(%9.,'(! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 9-10&.(! ,5! &'! S,5! #5()! ,*)! E,.&),'()! &*! ,..! '2-((! 8,5(!

5'#)&(5!&*!521S*!&*!<99(*)&`!VVVANA!

N$P$* >'2'7)1(!H5'/M3;R2!/23!#)'5/59#B!

B2(! $(*(0&'5! $-(,K)1S*! ,*)! 2&(-,-82:! '(82*&4#(! &5! ,! 0#*),%(*',.! ,8'&E&':! '2,'!

*(()5! '1!$(!915&'&1*()!,'! '2(! &*&'&,'&1*!10! '2(!9-18(55A! V'! (E1.E(5! '2-1#721#'! '2(!

9-18(55!92,5(5!,5!,))&'&1*,.!5',K(21.)(-!&*E1.E(%(*'!,*)!81*5#.','&1*!188#-5A!<..!

Page 200: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DM!

'2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 81*'-&$#'()! '1! '2(! 0,8'! '2,'! ,! 8.(,-! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! ,..! 5'-,'(7&8!

$(*(0&'5;! 5#$! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! (*)! $(*(0&'5! *(()! '1! $(! ,-'&8#.,'()! ,5! $(*(0&'5!

'(-%&*1.17:! &5!#5#,..:!%&5&*'(-9-('()!$:!)&00(-(*'!5',K(21.)(-5!'2,'!,-(! &*E1.E()!

&*!,!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(A!!

B2(!-(5(,-82!2,5!81*8.#)()!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!%&72'!$(!-(,.&5()!,'!)&00(-(*'!5',7(5!10!,!

9-1^(8'5L! .&0(8:8.(;! ,.'21#72!%,^1-! &%9,8'5!S&..! 9-1$,$.:! 188#-! 1*! .,'(-! 5',7(5! 10!

'2(! 9-1^(8'L5! 19(-,'&1*,.! 5','(q! *(E(-'2(.(55! &'! &5! *(8(55,-:! '1! 8.,55&0:! ,*)!

82,-,8'(-&5(!$(*(0&'5!,5!(,-.:!,5!9155&$.(! &0! '2(:!,-(! '1!9-19(-.:!%,*,7()!,*)!$:!

'2,'!&*8-(,5(!'2(!9-1$,$&.&':!10!'2(&-!-(,.&5,'&1*A!!

<8'&E(! ,*)! 5:5'(%,'&8! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! 10! '2(! &)(*'&0&()a(.&8&'()! $(*(0&'5;! #*)(-! ,!

'2-((\.(E(.!1-7,*&5,'&1*!5'-#8'#-(;!&5!-(7,-)()!,5!,!*(8(55,-:!,*)!E,.#,$.(!,8'&E&':A!

B2&5! ,8'&E&':! 81*5&5'5! 10! 2&72.&72'&*7! I)&5J! 5&%&.,-&'&(5;! 81*51.&),'&*7! I(A7A! 'S1!

5&%&.,-! (.&8&'()! $(*(0&'5! &*! 1*(J! ,*)! 5(7%(*'&*7! (.&8&'()! ),',a$(*(0&'5! #*)(-! '2(!

5:5'(%,'&5()! ,99-1,82! '2,'! &5! ,$.(! '1! ,55#-(! 5#991-'! '2-1#721#'! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'!

9-17-,%%(!I(A7A!5(.(8'&1*!10!)(5&7*!19'&1*5;!81*'-1..&*7a%1*&'1-&*7JA!

<5!9-(E&1#5.:!)(58-&$()!C(3(,.!1-7,*&5(5!$(*(0&'5!&*'1!'2-((!'&(-5W!

# "'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! Z! '2(:! -(.,'(! '1! '2(! 2&72! .(E(.! 9#-915(! 10! '2(!

9-17-,%%(a9-1^(8'!,*)!9-1E&)(!,*!1E(-,..!)&-(8'&1*!10!5#88(55!'2-1#721#'!

'2(!.&0(!8:8.(q!

# "#$! $(*(0&'5! Z! '2(:! ,-(! %1-(! )(',&.()! $(*(0&'5;! '2,'! )-&E(! )(5&7*! ,*)!

5#991-'!19'&1*5y!,55(55%(*'q!

# H*)!$(*(0&'5!Z!,-(!$(*(0&'5!'2,'!,-(!0#-'2(-!9-10&.()!&*'1!59(8&0&8!',-7('5!'2,'!

(*,$.(!9(-01-%,*8(!'1!$(!%(,5#-()A!

<!)(9(*)(*8:!%,9!I/&7#-(!@FJ!.&*K&*7!'2(!'2-((!'&(-5!&5!81*5'&'#'()!01..1S&*7!'2(!

$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!&..#5'-,'&*7!)(9(*)(*8&(5!I'2&5!&5!,.51!5#991-'()!$:!'2(!C(3(,.!

VB!9.,'01-%!,5!)(58-&$()!&*!,99(*)&`!XJA!!

Page 201: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DD!

!

X)A85'!-Uc!!>'2'7)1(!H5'/M3;R2!/23!#)'5/59#B!

B1!)(E(.19!,! -(9-(5(*','&E(!,*)!-1$#5'! .&5'!10!$(*(0&'5;! &'! &5!*(8(55,-:! '1! &*E1.E(!

)&E(-5(! 5',K(21.)(-5A! B2&5! 81*'-&$#'(5! 2&72.:! '1! '2(! 4#,.&':! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 5('5!

(.&8&'()!I&*8.#)&*7!)&5\$(*(0&'5!,*)!815'J;!2(.9&*7!'1!,))-(55!'2(!-(,.!&%9,8'!10!'2(!

&*E(5'%(*'! ,*)! &'5! 1#'81%(5A! ! B2(! 9-18(55! &5! $(*(0&8&,.! &*! $-&*7&*7! K(:!

5',K(21.)(-5!10!,!)(E(.19%(*'!9-17-,%%(!'17('2(-!,*)! &*!,..! '2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!

2,5!9-1E&)()!'2(!9.,'01-%!01-!81..,$1-,'&1*;!(*2,*8()!81%%#*&8,'&1*!,*)!$(''(-!

&*E1.E(%(*'A![1S(E(-!,!S&)(-!5',K(21.)(-!(*7,7(%(*'!S1#.)!$(!%1-(!$(*(0&8&,.!

,5!&'!S,5!81*8.#)()!01..1S&*7!'2(!c$(*(0&'5!(.&8&','&1*!c!S1-K52195!&*!Q"@A!!

"&*8(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!(.&8&'()!,!'-,8(,$&.&':!%,*,7(%(*'!10!$(*(0&'5!&5!-(81%%(*)();!

2&72.&72'&*7! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E();! &)(*'&0&()! 1E(-.,99&*7! ,*)! )(9(*)(*8&(5!

$('S((*! '2(! $(*(0&'5;! ('8A! T,^1-! ),',! 81..(8'&1*! '(82*&4#(5! '(5'()! ,*)!

-(81%%(*)()! '1! (.&8&'()! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! S1-K52195! S&'2! 5',K(21.)(-5;! 5#-E(:&*7!

4#(5'&1**,&-(5! ,*)! 2&5'1-&8,.! ),',! 7,'2(-&*7! '2-1#72! 81*5#.','&1*! 10! (`&5'&*7!

)18#%(*','&1*A!<..!'2(!),',!&5!-(81-)()!&*!-(81%%(*)()!'(%9.,'(5!,5!&*!<99(*)&`!

IVVVA?J;! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*! &*9#'!%,'-&`! ,*)! <99(*)&`! IVVVA=J! (.&8&'()! $(*(0&'5! .&5'!

1#'9#'!%,'-&`A!

N$P$- >'2'7)1(!='A@'21/1);2!

C(*(0&'5!5(7%(*','&1*!&5!1*(!10!'2(!K(:!'(82*&4#(5!%,&*.:!#5()!&*!&*!'2(!5'-,'(7:!

,.&7*%(*'! ,*)! (.&8&','&1*! 92,5(5! ,*)! 2,5! $((*! &*E(5'&7,'()! %,&*.:! &*! Q"=!

IS1-K52195! ?! ,*)! =J! ,*)! Q"@! IS1-K52195! ?\NJA! V'! S,5! 1$5(-E()! 01..1S&*7! '2(!

,*,.:5&5!10!),',!7,'2(-()!)#-&*7!'2(5(!(.&8&','&1*!S1-K52195!'2,'!5#82!,8'&E&'&(5!'1!

#*)(-5',*)! 5',K(21.)(-! 9-&1-&'&(5! I(A7A!S1-K52195;! 5(%&*,-5J! 8,*! .(,)! '1! ,! .,-7(!

!"#"$%&'(!)"*+,-.#(*#,(/%")*)012(

!"#"$%&'()*#*+","#&(

3#,(!"#"$%&'(

4567(!"#"$%&'(

4&)*&"8%0(!"#"$%&'(

-.*/*0&"/%'*&%1#(

-2*''%$%0*&%1#(

456(((49:;;<(4&)*&"8%0(((4!:;;<( 3#,(((3!:;;<(

456(((49:;;=( 3#,(((3!:;;=(

456(((49:;;>( 3#,(((3!:;;>(

456(((49:;;?(4&)*&"8%0(((4!:;;=( 3#,(((3!:;;?(

456(((49:@@@( 3#,(((3!:@@@(

Page 202: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?DF!

,%1#*'!10!-(.(E,*'!$#'!E(-:!0-,7%(*'()!),',A!C(*(0&'5!5(7%(*','&1*!9-18(55!2(.95!

'#-*! 5#82! 0-,7%(*'()! ),',! &*'1! #5(0#.! &*01-%,'&1*! #5&*7! 5&%&.,-&':! ,*)!

)&55&%&.,-&':!8-&'(-&,A!

V*!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!5(7%(*','&1*!&5!#*)(-',K(*!'1!81*51.&),'(!(.&8&'()!$(*(0&'5!

&*'1!,!%,*,7(,$.(!*#%$(-!'2,'!0&'!'2(!-(81%%(*)()!'2-((\'&(-!,99-1,82A!

C(*(0&'5!,-(!5(7%(*'()!,881-)&*7!'1!,!)&E(-5&':!10!8-&'(-&,a,''-&$#'(5;!,5!2,-);!510';!

',*7&$.(;!&*',*7&$.(;!4#,*'&','&E(!1-!4#,.&','&E(;!)&5\$(*(0&'5!1-!#*(`9(8'()A!

B2(!$(*(0&'!5(7%(*','&1*!'(82*&4#(!&*81-91-,'(5!1#'81%(5!10!'2(!$(*(0&'!9-10&.&*7!

,8'&E&':! S2(-(! ,''-&$#'(5! -(.,'()! '1! (,82! $(*(0&'! ,-(! ,55&7*()! I(A7A;! 1S*(-52&9;!

-(591*5&$&.&':;!'&%(JA!T,*,7(%(*'!10!$(*(0&'5!$(7&*5!,0'(-!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!92,5(!,*)!

'2-1#721#'! '2(! S21.(! .&0(8:8.(A! C(*(0&'5! 5(7%(*','&1*! I,*)! 9-10&.&*7J! (*2,*8(5!

,S,-(*(55!,$1#'!S21%;!21S!,*)!S2(*!'2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!82,*7(!',K(5!9.,8(A!

B2(!5(7%(*'()!$(*(0&'5!8,*!,.51!$(!&..#5'-,'()!#5&*7!,!59&)(-!)&,7-,%!I/&7#-(!N>J;!

2(.9&*7!(,5:!&*'(-9-(','&1*!,*)!E&5#,.&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5!-(.,'()!),',A!

!

X)A85'!P+c!>'2'7)1(!('A@'21/1);2!)008(15/1);2!

B2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5!&*!'(-%5!,!5(.(8'()!7-1#9!10!,59(8'5!I(A7A;!9.,**()!,*)!

#*9.,**();! &*'(-*,.! ,*)! (`'(-*,.;! $#&.'! (*E&-1*%(*'! .&0(8:8.(! 5','(5;! 5',K(21.)(-!

!"#$"#%!"#%$"#&!"#&$"#'!"#'$"#(!"#

!"##"$%&'()*#+%,$"(#-".#/%(.0%122"//%#3%4"$5*2"/%

6-7$35"0%4#(8"93)0"$/%:3#*5(#*3.%(.0%;<7"$*".2"%

=(/#"$%>$32'$"-".#%(.0%;(/"%3?%6-7)"-".#(#*3.%

6-7$35"0%=(2*)*#*"/%(.0%122"//*@*)*#+%

;.9(.2"%A32()%;23.3-+%

6.2$"(/"%;?B*2*".2+%(.0%C7#*-*/"0%;??"2#*5"."//%

Page 203: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?F>!

8,'(71-:J! #5&*7! 5(7%(*','&1*! '(82*&4#(5! I5((! ,99(*)&`! VVVA@J;! &5! -(7,-)()! ,5!

,)E,*',7(1#5;! (59(8&,..:! '1!#*)(-5',*)!,*)!8.,-&0:!S2&82!,59(8'5!%&72'!$(!%1-(!

I1-!.(55J!-(9-(5(*'()!$:!'2(!(.&8&'()!7-1#9!10!$(*(0&'5A!!V'!,.51!2(.95!'1!#*)(-5',*)!

$(*(0&'!1S*(-52&9!&55#(5!,*)!S2(*!,!$(*(0&'!521#.)!$(!%(,5#-()!,*)!-(,.&5()!,..!

10!S2&82!81*'-&$#'(!'1!'2(!%1*&'1-&*7!,*)!%,*,7&*7!,59(8'5!10!'2(!9-18(55A!

"'-#8'#-()!9-1^(8'!$(*(0&'5!,5!)(-&E()!0-1%!5',K(21.)(-!S1-K52195!,-(!'2(!81-(!10!

'2(!1E(-,..!%,*,7(%(*'!9-18(55!,5!(`,%&*()!&*!Q"=!,*)!Q"@A!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!

&*! '2,'! -(59(8'! ,.&7*5! '2(! 1E(-,..! 9-1^(8'! 91'(*'&,.! 1#'9#'5! S&'2! '2(! 82,*7(!

&*&'&,'&E(5! ,*)! 5#$5(4#(*'.:! '#-*5! '2(%! &*'1! )(5&-()! 9.,**()! 1#'9#'5A! B2#5! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-! %,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55! '2,'! 10'(*! &5! )(9&8'()! ,5! (*'&-(.:! 91.&'&8,.!

IG.,*)(-! r! b,*)&*;! =>>O;! ](S81%$(;! =>>@J! &5! 5#991-'()! 2(-(! $:! ,! 5'-#8'#-()!

9-18(55!01-!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!10!$(*(0&'!1#'81%(5A!!

N$P$P F801)!95)1'5)/!5/2M)2A!!

T#.'&! 8-&'(-&,! -,*K&*7! &5! ,! -(81%%(*)()!K(:! '(82*&4#(!#5()! &*! '2(!19'&1*((-&*7!

92,5(!,*)!2,5!$((*!)(E(.19()!,5!,*!1#'81%(!10! '2(!-(.(E,*'!S1-K5219!R! &*!Q"@!

)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!NA@A@!IQ2,9'(-!NJA!

G9'&1*((-&*7! &5! ,..! ,$1#'! &*01-%()! 81..(8'&E(! )(8&5&1*! %,K&*7;! ,! 5(.(8'&1*! 10!

19'&1*5!$,5()!1*!S(&72'&*7!5'-,'(7&8!,*)!5#$!$(*(0&'5A!V'!521#.)!(*,$.(!'2(!)($,'(!

10!'2(!)&00(-(*'!19'&1*5!81*5&)(-&*7!,!5'-(,%.&*()!*#%$(-!10!$(*(0&'5!,*)!)1(5!*1'!

&*8.#)(! '2(! '2&-)! '&(-! &*! $(*(0&'L5! )(',&.5! I(*)! $(*(0&'5J! &*'1! '2(! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!

9-18(55A! B2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! 10! '2(! $(5'! 19'&1*! I-,*K&*7J! &5! $,5()! 1*! ,! -,*K&*7!

)(E(.19()!1*.:!,%1*7!'2(!521-'\.&5'()!19'&1*5;!,*)!,.51!018#5&*7!1*!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!

,*)! 5#$! $(*(0&'5! .(E(.5! I5((! <99(*)&`! VVVAO! 01-! $(*(0&'5! S(&72'&*7! ,*)! -,*K&*7!

%,'-&`! '(%9.,'(!,5!)(E(.19()! &*!Q"@JA!G*.:!,0'(-! -,*K&*7! '2(!521-'.&5'()!19'&1*5;!

0#-'2(-!)(',&.()!&#0!C&#&,$)(!,-(!&*81-91-,'()!&*'1!'2(!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!9-18(55!,5!

,!$,5&5! 01-!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,! 0#..!$#5&*(55!8,5(!,99-1,82!\(&&!Y&R&./!2.)6@.*!

26.(&!,/+@E6.')!/&7#-(!@M]9!

Page 204: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?F?!

T#.'&\8-&'(-&,! -,*K&*7! &5! ,! 81-(! ,8'&E&':! 10! 19'&1*((-&*7A! V'! &*E1.E(5! 581-&*7! 10!

82,*7(!19'&1*5!,881-)&*7! '1!,!7-1#9!10!S(&72'()!)&%(*5&1*5A!B2(!1#'81%(! &5!,*!

1-7,*&5()!,*)!-,*K()!.&5'!10!,55(55()!82,*7(!19'&1*5A!

B2&5!,99-1,82!&5!,!S,:!10!5'-#8'#-&*7!81%9.(`!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7;!#5&*7!,!5(,%.(55!

,*)! (,5:! 5'(9\$:\5'(9! %('21);! '2,'! (*)5! S&'2! ,! 5:*'2(5&5()! -,*K&*7A! <*!

&..#5'-,'&1*! 10! '2(!%#.'&\8-&'(-&,! )(8&5&1*\%,K&*7! ',$.(! &5! 521S*! 1*! '2(! 19915&'(!

9,7(A!

B2(! %#.'&\8-&'(-&,! -,*K&*7! 10! 19'&1*5! 81*51.&),'(5! 4#,*'&0&,$.(! ,*)! *1*\

4#,*'&0&,$.(!9-1^(8'!8#5'1%&5()!)&%(*5&1*5!&*'1!'2(!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7A!

V)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10! )&%(*5&1*5! 521#.)! &*8.#)(!%#.'&9.(! ,''-&$#'(5! '2,'! 5',K(21.)(-5!

81*58&1#5.:!5#77(5'!,*)!#*81*58&1#5.:!-(7,-)!,5!E,.#,$.(!I(A7A!$(*(0&'5;!-&5K;!815';!

(81*1%&8;!('8A!,5!9(-!/&7#-(!N?JA!!

!

X)A85'!P,c!:/2M)2A!/23!R')A#1)2A!)008(15/1);2!

<8'&E(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! &5! 2&72.:! -(81%%(*)();! 59(8&0&8,..:! &*! '2(!

%#.'&\8-&'(-&,! -,*K&*7! 10! 19'&1*5! ,8'&E&':! 10! '2(! 19'&1*((-&*7! 92,5(! I(A7A;!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!)&%(*5&1*5!521#.)!(%(-7(!0-1%!S1-K52195JA!

B2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!018#5()!1*!'2(!$(*(0&'5!)&%(*5&1*!,5!&'!S,5!9-(5(*'()!&*!

Q"@;!,!'(%9.,'(!,5!)(E(.19()!1*!'2&5!8,5(!5'#):!&5!)(',&.()!&*!,99(*)&`!VVVARA!

!"#$%&' ()&#*+,'

!"#$

%&'(')*&$ +$

,,,$ !$

-$ #$

.//0//)0(1$

23(4*(5$

6*)0(/*'($7$.$ 8$ -$

9$!$ :$ ,,,$

#$!$ 9$ -$

,,,$-$ ,,,$ ,,,$

+;$:!$ 9<$ -$

!$9$ +$ ,,,$

=(>0/1)0(1$.(3?@/*/$

6*)0(/*'(/A$BC?1*"&D*10D*3$

Page 205: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?F=!

N$P$N >'2'7)1(!/91)<)1)'(!/23!5'(;859'!3'['23'29)'(!

B2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)! .&*K!10! &)(*'&0&()!,*)!5'-#8'#-()!$(*(0&'5! '1! -(51#-8(5!,*)!

9-1^(8'!9.,*!,8'&E&'&(5!&5!K(:!'1!'2(!9,'2S,:!,*)!,55(55%(*'!92,5(5!10!'2(!C(3(,.!

9-18(55A!+11-!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!*(8(55,-:!%(,*5!'1!,82&(E(!$(*(0&'5!2,5!$((*!1*(!10!

'2(!%,&*!0,&.#-(5!&*!'-,)&'&1*,.!9-1^(8'!,*)!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'!IB-#,`;!?FFMJA!

<!)(9(*)(*8:!*('S1-K!&5!(5',$.&52()!,%1*75'!$(*(0&'5;!,8'&E&':!,*)!-(51#-8(5A!B2(!

(5',$.&52()!)(9(*)(*8&(5!-(.,'(!,*:!91'(*'&,.!E,-&,'&1*!&*!-(51#-8(5!,*)!,8'&E&'&(5!

I(A7A;!'&%(;!-&5K5;!815'J!'1!'2(!&%9,8'!10!'2(!-(,.&5,'&1*!10!'2(!.&*K()!$(*(0&'A!C,5()!

1*!'2&5!,99-1,82;!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7!,*)!'-,8(,$&.&':!&5!(E&)(*8()!,*)!0#..:!^#5'&0&()A!

6(9(*)&*7!1*!'2(!82,*7(!9-1^(8';!'2(!)(9(*)(*8:!*('S1-K!%&72'!$(!)(E(.19()!,'!

,*!(.(%(*',-:!.(E(.!I(A7A;!',5KJ!1-!,'!,!%1-(!81*51.&),'()!.(E(.!I(A7A;!,8'&E&'&(5!,5!,!

7-1#9!10!',5K5JA!

T1*&'1-&*7! ,*)! %,*,7&*7! '2&5! )(9(*)(*8:! *('S1-K! S&..! 0#-'2(-! (*,$.(! ,! %1-(!

(00&8&(*'! ,..18,'&1*! 10! -(51#-8(5;! 018#5&*7! 1*! (00(8'&E(! ,82&(E&*7! '2(! )(5&-()!

1#'81%(A!

!

X)A85'!P*c!>'2'7)1(D!/91)<)1)'(!/23!5'(;859'!3'['23'29)'(!

N$P$T !4;215;00)2A!/((85/29'!

B2(! 0&*,.! ,8'&E&':! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '2&5! '2(5&5! &5! K(:! &*! '2(! +,'2S,:! ,*)!<55(55%(*'!

92,5(5!$#'!,.51!'1!'2(!1E(-,..!-1$#5'*(55!10!'2(!9-18(55A!

Q1*8(9'#,.!)(5&7*!10! ,!%1*&'1-&*7!,*)!81*'-1..&*7! 5'-#8'#-(!81E(-&*7! '2(!1E(-,..!

9-1^(8'! ,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*! (*E&-1*%(*'! 521#.)! 7#,-,*'((! '-,8(,$&.&':! 10! &)(*'&0&()!

!"#$%$#&'()*+,-./0'+0-'1$*)+)"2&'

(*0*3$#4'()*+,-./0'+0-'1$*)+)"2&'

5*4.6)"*'()*+,-./0'+0-'1$*)+)"2&'

(*0*3$#4'7+0+8*9*0#'

:2+08*'7+0+8*9*0#'

!"#$%$#&'!())*'+,-,.$#''+())*' /,0123",'/())*'

!"#$%$#&'!())4'+,-,.$#''+())4' /,0123",'/())4'

!"#$%$#&'!())5'+,-,.$#''+())5' /,0123",'/())5'

!"#$%$#&'!())6'+,-,.$#''+())7' /,0123",'/())7'

:.4#';$*/'

<$9*';$*/'

=6+>$#&';$*/'

!"#$%$#&'!(888'+,-,.$#''+(888' /,0123",'/(888'

Page 206: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?F@!

,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)! 82,*7(5! ,.1*7! '2(! 9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(;! 2&72.&72'&*7! )(9(*)(*8:! ,*)!

1E(-.,99&*7!10!$(*(0&'5A!C,5()!1*!81*E(-5,'&1*5!2(.)!S&'2!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(%(*'!'(,%5;!'2(!8-155!,*,.:5&5!)(E&,'&1*!$('S((*!S2,'!$(*(0&'5!2,E(!$((*!

2/.##&0!I'1\$(J;!S2,'!&5!*1S!&*!9.,8(!\.(O$(!+'!.E)3./]!,*)!S2,'!&5!&*!0,8'!0&/$%&'&0!

\&D&'A&0]! 8-(,'(5! ,*! (00(8'&E(! .&0(8:8.(! %1*&'1-&*7a81*'-1..&*7! ,99-1,82! 10!

)(E&,'&1*5!'2,'!5((%5!'1!$(!(`'-(%(.:!-(.(E,*'!'1!9-19(-.:!%(,5#-(!'2(!5#88(55!10!

'2(! 9-17-,%%(;! ,*)! '2,'! 521#.)! 81E(-! $1'2! &,,$E$&#E*! I-(51#-8(5! E(-5#5! -(5#.'5J!

,*)!&,,&E)$%&#&((!I,82&(E(%(*'!10!S2,'!&5!9.,**()J!9(-59(8'&E(5A!

!

X)A85'!P-c!>':'/0!9;215;00)2A!/((85/29'!

<!5'-#8'#-(!10!81*'-1.!,*)!,55#-,*8(!'2,'!(*,$.(5!'2(!)(0&*&'&1*!10!'2(!$,5(.&*(!I,5\

&5J;! '2(! ',-7('()! 1#'81%(5! I'1\$(J! ,*)! '2(! ,8'#,.! -(5#.'5! I,5\&5J! &5! '2(-(01-(!

)(9.1:()A!

B2(! $,5(.&*(! I,5\&5J! %&--1-5! '2(! &*&'&,.! 5&'#,'&1*;! ,5! ,! $,5&5! 01-! (5',$.&52&*7!

,99-19-&,'()! d+V5A! V'! 81*'-&$#'(5! '1! *(()! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)! -(.,'()! 82,*7(!

)(E(.19%(*'A!

B,-7('()! I'1\$(J! 7-1#9! 10! d+V5! (*,$.(! '2(! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! 71,.5;! $1'2! &*! '(-%5! 10!

$(*(0&'5!IE,.#(J!,*)!82,*7(!I815'J!%(,5#-(5A!

<8'#,.! I,5\&5J!7-1#9!10!d+V5!(*,$.(!%(,5#-(%(*'!10! '2(! .(E(.!10!,82&(E(%(*'5;! &*!

'(-%5!10!$(*(0&'5!IE,.#(J!,*)!82,*7(!I815'JA!

!"#"$%&'()*#*+","#&(

-.*#+"()*#*+","#&(

/0*##"1(23&4*0( 23.%"5"1(

6789!":(;&*<+"&=(>"'84<3"'(?(!"#"$%&'(

@&*&4'9A48(-.*<*3&"<%B*&%8#(

!"#"$%&'9-.*#+"(CD&%,%'*&%8#(

!"#"$%&'9-.*#+"(E4'&%$%3*&%8#(

-8#&<800%#+(2#*0F'%'(

62'9G':(;H*'"0%#"=(>"'84<3"'(?(!"#"$%&'(

623&4*0:(;*3&4*0=(>"'84<3"'(?(!"#"$%&'(

G#5"'&,"#&(2#*0F'%'(

-8#&<800%#+(2#*0F'%'(

Page 207: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FN!

V*!1-)(-!'1!7#,-,*'((!81%9,-,$&.&':!$('S((*W!$,5(.&*(!I,5\&5J;!',-7('()!I'1\$(J!,*)!

,8'#,.! I,5\&5J;! '2(! 7-1#9!10!d+V5! 521#.)!$(! 8,-(0#..:! ,.&7*()! '2-1#72! ,99-19-&,'(!

),',!51#-8(5!,*)!%('21)5A!

N$N "5;9'((!)@[0'@'21/1);2!1'/@!

<*! +'A.#$(.)$+#! E6.')! '1! %,*,7(! '2(! 9-18(55! &%9.(%(*','&1*! ,*)! -(.,'()!

5',K(21.)(-5!&5!2&72.:!E,.#,$.(A!V'!81%(5!0-1%!'2(!0&*)&*75!10!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!

'2,'! 911-! ,$&.&':! '1!%,*,7(! 82,*7(! 2,5! $((*! 1*(! 10! '2(!%,&*! -(,51*5! 10! 9-1^(8'!

5#88(55! 1-! 0,&.#-(! IB-#,`;! ?FFMJA! B2&5! S,5! ,.51! &)(*'&0&()! )#-&*7! '2(! &*01-%,.!

)&58#55&1*!,*)!&*'(-E&(S5!%,&*.:!1*!Q"?!,*)!9-17-(55&E(.:!&'5!*(()!S,5!-(&*01-8()!

1*!Q"=!,*)!Q"@A!!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!,.51!91&*'5!'1!,!9-18(55!&%9.(%(*','&1*!'(,%!'2,'!018#5(5!1*!9-1^(8'!

,881#*',$&.&':!$#'!5#82!(001-'!521#.)!$(!&%9-1E()!&0!'2(!-(5'!10!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*!&5!

$(''(-!(*7,7()!1*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!S2,'! '2(&-! 81*'-&$#'&1*5! '1!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!

S(-(!IC-,).(:;!=>>RJA!

B2(!)&E(-5&':!10!5',K(21.)(-5!&*E1.E();!-,*7&*7!0-1%!8.&(*'5!,*)!#5(-5!'1!5#99.&(-5;!

*(()5!'1!$(!,99-19-&,'(.:!%,*,7()A!

B21%,5! ,*)! B21%,5! I=>>OJ! 5#991-'! '2&5! ,5! '2(:! $(.&(E(! '2,'! &*E1.E&*7! ,..!

5',K(21.)(-5! 0-1%! '2(! 1#'5('! 2(.95! '2(! '(,%! '1! $(81%(! &*'(7-,'()! ,*)! 2,E(! ,!

81%%1*! #*)(-5',*)&*7! ,*)! 52,-()! K*1S.()7(A! B2(! K(:! '2(:! S1#.)! 5,:! '1! ,*!

(00(8'&E(! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#9! S1#.)! $(! '2-1#72! &*'(7-,'()! '(,%S1-KA! B2(:! )1!

21S(E(-!91&*'!1#'!'2,'!S&'2!82,*7(5!'2,'!188#-!&*!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!(59(8&,..:!'215(!10!

9(-51**(.! *,'#-(! 01-! (`,%9.(! 5',00! .(,E&*7! ,*)! *(S! 1*(5! ^1&*&*7A! ! B1! )(,.! S&'2!

'2(5(! 82,*7(5! '2(-(! *(()5! '1! $(! 51%(! (00(8'&E(! %,*,7(%(*'! 0-1%! (&'2(-! '2(!

9-1^(8'!%,*,7(-!1-!,!81-(!5',K(21.)(-!7-1#9A!

B,K&*7!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!7#&),*8(!IGUQ;!=>>@q!3(&55;!=>>Rq!U.:**(=>>MJ!&*'1!,881#*'!

,*)! 0-1%! '2(! (`9(-&(*8(! 7,&*()! 01-%! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! '2(! -(81%%(*)()!

1-7,*&5,'&1*! 82,-'! 01-! %,*,7&*7! ,! $(*(0&'5! )-&E(*! ,99-1,82! 521#.)! 81*5&5'! 10! ,!

C(3(,.!811-)&*,'&1*!5'-#8'#-(!,*)!,!5'((-&*7!81%%&''((!,5!&..#5'-,'()!&*!/&7#-(!NNA!!

Page 208: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FO!

!

X)A85'!PPc!>':'/0![5;9'((!)@[0'@'21/1);2!1'/@D!)008(15/1);2!

N$N$,$, >':'/0!&'/@!(['9)7)9!5'([;2()H)0)1)'(!

_2(*! ,! 9-17-,%%(a9-1^(8'! #5(5! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! &'! &5! -(81%%(*)()! '2,'! ,!

C(3(,.!'(,%!&5!(5',$.&52()!,5!&'!S,5!'(5'()!,'!'2(!&*&'&,'&1*!10!(,82!8,5(!5'#):!,*)!

S,5! )&58#55()! &*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &*! 5(8'&1*! =A?NA! B2(! C(3(,.! B(,%Ä5!%,&*!

9#-915(!&5!'1!1E(-5((!'2(!19(-,'&1*,.!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!9-1^(8'!'2-1#72!,8'&E&'&(5!

5#82!,5!'215(!5('!1#'!$(.1SA!

• 6(.&E(-:!10!S1-K!,.&7*()!S&'2!'2(!9.,*!I,*)!9-1^(8'!)&-(8'&1*J!$:!%,*,7&*7!

),:\'1\),:!,8'&E&'&(5q!

• 6(',&.;!-(E&(S!,*)!)&-(8'!'2(!S1-K!10!5',K(21.)(-!5#$\7-1#95A!B2&5!&*8.#)(5!

9,-'&8&9,'&1*!,*)!9-1%1'&1*!10! ^1&*'! &*&'&,'&E(5;!),',!7,'2(-&*7;!)&58#55&1*;!

,*,.:5&5!,*)!)&00#5&1*!10!1#'9#'5q!

• Q1*'-&$#'&1*5! '1! '2(! &*E1.E(%(*'! 10! -(.(E,*'! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! ,*)!

9-1%1'(!(00(8'&E(!'S1ZS,:!81%%#*&8,'&1*q!

• !+-1E&5&1*!10!,!01-#%!01-!)&55(%&*,'&1*!10!&*&'&,'&E(5;!)(8&5&1*5!,*)!9-17-(55!

#9),'(5q!

• Q1\E,.&),'&1*! 10! 9-1^(8'! )(.&E(-,$.(5;! ,5! $(*(0&'5! 9-10&.(5;! 19'&1*5! -,*K&*7;!

-&5K5;!$#5&*(55!8,5(;!82,*7(!9-1915,.5q!

• H.&8&','&1*!10!5',K(21.)(-5y!9(-8(9'&1*5!&*'1!$(*(0&'5!82,-,8'(-&5'&85q!,*)!

!"#"$%&'(()*+,$-+(,&

!"#$%&'()*+*,%"(-./%"*001(

2'*3%4#05%"6("%7"%6%+'*'8/%69(!  :#*"5(;%;<%"6(!  =+/8'%5("%0%/*+'>"%0*'%5(67%&8*086'6(!  :%?%*0(6%0%&'%5(<#*"5(;%;<%"6(!  @(

./0+1"&2344()-&

!"#$%&'()*+*,%"(-(:%?%*0(1(

5$,$6"7",-& '8$,6"&!","0+-9&

.AB8&%(C6686'*+'(-:%?%*01(=D(D%*;(-:%?%*01(

2344%+")9&2-$:"8(%*")9& !"#"$%&;"$7&

!"#&E"%;%+'(FE+&'8#+((

!"#$%&'()*+*,%;%+'(((

F)(FE+&'8#+(((GGG(

2%+8#"()*+*,%"(-:%?%*01(()*+*,%"(-:%?%*01((@(

2'*3%4#05%"6("%7"%6%+'*'8/%6(-=+'%"+*0('#(<%(6%0%&'%51(

2'*3%4#05%"6("%7"%6%+'*'8/%6(-HI'%"+*0('#(<%(6%0%&'%51(

C"&48'%&'6(-2E7708%"1(

(H+,8+%%"8+,(-2E7708%"1(

:E80'(%+/8"#+;%+'(-"%0*'%5(6E7708%"61((=+A#";*'8#+('%&4+#0#,J(-"%0*'%5(6E7708%"61((!%"6#++%0(-"%0*'%5(6E7708%"61((!"#&%66%6(-"%0*'%5(6E7708%"61((@(

2-"")+,6&'(77+-""&

Page 209: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FR!

• <55#-(!0#'#-(!5#991-'!10!9(-01-%,*8(!,*)!81*'-1..&*7!&*&'&,'&E(5A!

N$N$,$* >':'/0!&'/@!5'[;51)2A!@'9#/2)(@!

• B(,%! S&..! -(91-'! '1! '2(! 81\1-)&*,'1-! '2,'! .(,)5! 9-1^(8'! 5'-,'(7:!

)(E(.19%(*'!,*)!1E(-5((5!9-1^(8'!),:\'1\),:!19(-,'&1*5q!

• B(,%! %(('&*75! ,*)! 1'2(-! &*&'&,'&E(5! S&..! $(! 9-1915();! ,7-(()! S&'2! ,*)!

9-(5(*'()!'1!'2(!811-)&*,'1-q!

• G#'9#'5! )(E(.19()! $:! '2(! '(,%! S&..! $(! 5#$%&''()! 01-! ,99-1E,.! '1! '2(!

,99-19-&,'(!.(E(.A!

N$T %)(98(();2!

N$T$, "/5/3)A@!(#)71!

B2(! K*1S.()7(! 7,&*()! 0-1%! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*)! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &5! '2,'!

$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*;! &0! ,*)! S2(*! 8,--&()! 1#'! ,'! ,..;! &5! *1'! &*'(7-,'()! &*'1!

1-7,*&5,'&1*5L!8#.'#-(;!$#5&*(55!,*)!9-1^(8'!,8'&E&'&(5A!<!82,*7(!&*!%(*',.&':!0-1%!,!

'-,)&'&1*,.! $,5()! ,99-1,82! 7#&)()! $:! %,8-1\1$^(8'&E(5! ,*)! -(4#&-(%(*'5! '1! ,!

$(*(0&'! )-&E(*! 5'-,'(7:! &5! '2(! 82,..(*7(A! <! '-,)&'&1*,.! ,99-1,82! 10'(*! 81*5&5'5! 10!

5','&8!)18#%(*'5!'2,'!,-(!.&%&'()!,*)!*1'!K(9'!#9!'1!),'(A!/1-!9,-'&(5!'1!2,E(!,*:!

81*0&)(*8(! '2,'! $(*(0&'5! S&..! $(! ,82&(E();! '2(-(! *(()5! '1! $(! ,! 9,-,)&7%! 52&0';! ,!

82,*7(! &*! '2(!S,:! 10! '2&*K&*7! 51! '2,'! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! &)(*'&0&()! '2-1#72! ,! -&71-1#5!

9-18(55;! ,-(! S(..! )(0&*();! 7&E(*! 1*\71&*7! ,''(*'&1*! ,*)! ,-(! %1*&'1-()a,)^#5'()!

(00(8'&E(.:!'2-1#72!1#'!'2(!.&0(8:8.(!10!'2(!9-1^(8'a!9-17-,%%(A!V'!&5!,.51!&%91-',*'!

'1!2&72.&72'! '2,'! ,! )&00(-(*'! I,*)!%1-(! (00(8'&E(J!S,:!10! '2&*K&*7! ,*)!S1-K&*7! &'!

8.(,-.:! -(4#&-(5! ,! 915&'&E(! 81%%&'%(*'! 0-1%! '19! %,*,7(%(*'! '1! &*'(7-,'(! '2(!

,99-1,82! &*'1! '2(!$#5&*(55! ,5! ,!S21.(;! &0! &'! &5! '1! ,82&(E(! &'5! 0#..! 91'(*'&,.A! V'!S,5!

(,-.&(-!)&58#55()!'2,'!,82&(E&*7!'2(!*(8(55,-:!52&0'!0-1%!,!'-,)&'&1*,.!,99-1,82!'1!

$(*(0&'5!)-&E(*!5'-,'(7:!&5!'2(!82,..(*7(A!B1!&%9.(%(*'!82,*7(!'2-1#72!,!$(*(0&'5!

)-&E(*!5'-,'(7:;!,!S,'(-0,..!10! .&*K5!*(()!'1!$(!81*5&)(-()!I(A7A! '2(! .&*K5!$('S((*!

,8'&E&'&(5!,*)!-(51#-8(5!I/&7#-(!NOJA!

Page 210: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FM!

!

X)A85'!PNc!"/5/3)A@!(#)71!75;@!15/3)1);2/0!/[[5;/9#!1;!/!H'2'7)1!35)<'2!/[[5;/9#!

/1..1S&*7! '2&5! 9,-,)&7%! 52&0';! c@6.)L! $(*(0&'5! '1! $(! )(.&E(-()! I'2(! $(*(0&'5!

5'-,'(7:J! *(()! '1! $(! .&*K()! '-,*59,-(*'.:! S&'2! c6+@>! '2(! $(*(0&'5! ,-(! '1! $(!

)(.&E(-();! ',K&*7! &*'1! ,881#*'! 10! '2(! -(51#-8(5! ,*)! ,8'&E&'&(5! -(4#&-();! ,*)! '2(!

81*'(*'!10!'2(!1E(-,..!82,*7(!5'-,'(7:A!

C(3(,.! 018#5(5! 1*! 21S! $(*(0&'5! 521#.)! $(! (.&8&'()! ,'! '2(! &*&'&,.;! 5'-,'(7:!

)(9.1:%(*'!5',7(5!10!,!9-17-,%%(;!21S!$(*(0&'5!521#.)!$(!%,*,7()!,*)! '-,8()!

,.1*7! '2(! .&0(! 8:8.(! ,*)! )(9.1:()! S&'2&*! '2(! 9-17-,%%(L5! $#5&*(55! 8,5(A!

"#$5(4#(*'.:;!'2(!,#'21-!,59&-(5!C(3(,.!'1!$(!,*!,99-19-&,'(!%('21)!'1!)-&E(!,*)!

81*'-1.!'2(!9-17-,%%(!9.,*5q!9-1E&)&*7!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!01-!)(0&*&*7!59(8&0&8!

$(*(0&'5A! V'! ,.51! ,..1S5! '2(! %(,5#-(%(*'! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! '2(! (`'(*'! '1! S2&82!

'215(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!)(.&E(-()!I1-!*1'JA!!

N$T$* "5;9'((!)21'A5/1);2![5)29)[0'(!

C(3(,.! ,8'&E(.:!9.,*5!21S!-(51#-8(5! 8,*!$(!#5()! '1! -(,.&5(!$(*(0&'5! ,'! '2-((!K(:!

.(E(.5;! 5'-,'(7&8;! 91-'01.&1! ,*)! 9-17-,%%(a9-1^(8'! .(E(.;! &*! ,! S,:! '2,'!

!"##$%!&''()*+,!

!"##$%!&''()*+,!

-,*./#!01(*1#/2!

34/,56#7#6!)89#+:7#%! !"#$"%&&'()

*'+,-"'&'./()01)2#.(/"%-.(3) !"#4'5/()

67'5-85%9#.() &+:74:#%!

*'(#,"5'()

-,*./#!01(*1#/2!

;#.#<1%!34/,56#7#6!)89#+:7#%! !"#$"%&&'()

*'+,-"'&'./()01)2#.(/"%-.(3) !"#4'5/()

67'5-85%9#.() &+:74:#%!

*'(#,"5'()

=(*$4:).*6!&''()*+,!

;#.#<1%!&''()*+,!

Page 211: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FD!

81%9.(%(*'5! 1'2(-! $#5&*(55! %,*,7(%(*'! '11.5A! /(()$,8K! .1195! &*! '2(! 9-18(55!

2(.9! K((9! ,! 018#5! 1*! '2(! &)(*'&0&()! $(*(0&'5! )(59&'(! 82,*7(5! &*! '2(! &*'(-*,.! ,*)!

(`'(-*,.! (*E&-1*%(*'A! <5! %,*:! $(*(0&'5! %,'(-&,.&5(! .1*7! ,0'(-! '2(! &*)&E&)#,.5!

&*E1.E()!2,E(!%1E()!1*;!C(3(,.!71E(-*,*8(!5'-#8'#-(5!81E(-!'2(!.&0(!8:8.(!10!'2(!

9-17-,%%(a9-1^(8'A!

<..18,'&*7! -(51#-8(5! (00(8'&E(.:;! (00(8'&E(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*5! ,*)! '-,*59,-(*8:! ,-(!

'2(! K(:! '1! &%9.(%(*'&*7! '2(!C(3(,.! ,99-1,82! 5#88(550#..:A! <5!C(3(,.! &*E1.E(5! ,!

)&00(-(*'! I,*)!%1-(! (00(8'&E(J!S,:! 10! '2&*K&*7! ,*)!S1-K&*7! &'! 8.(,-.:! -(4#&-(5! ,!

915&'&E(! 81%%&'%(*'! 0-1%! '19! %,*,7(%(*'! '1! &*'(7-,'(! '2(! ,99-1,82! &*'1! '2(!

$#5&*(55!,5!,!S21.(;!&0!&'!&5!'1!,82&(E(!&'5!0#..!91'(*'&,.A!H00(8'&E(!81%%#*&8,'&1*5!&5!

,!E&',.!,59(8'!10!,*:!82,*7(!9-17-,%;!81*'-&$#'&*7!'1!&*8-(,5&*7!'-,*59,-(*8:!,*)!

0,8&.&','&*7!'2(!%,*,7(%(*'!10!(`9(8','&1*5!,8-155!'2(!)&E(-5&':!10!5',K(21.)(-5A!!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!9,'2S,:!&5!52,9()!$:!'2-((!&*'(-.18K&*7!E&(S5!I&A(A;!u,5\&5v!,8'#,.;!'2(!

u'1\$(v! 9.,**();! 0#'#-(! ,*)! '2(! u(%(-7()v! ,8'#,.J;! 5#991-'()! $:! 5',K(21.)(-!

(*7,7(%(*'! ,*)! 8#.'#-,.! ,.&7*%(*';! '1! 9-1%1'(! $(*(0&'5! 1S*(-52&9! ,*)!

'-,*59,-(*'!)(.&E(-:A!!

P*.&K(! *1-%,.! 9-,8'&8(;! '2(! ',-7('()! $(*(0&'5! IS2,'! &5! '1! $(! )(.&E(-()J! ,-(!

%,*,7()!I9-18(55J!'1!(*5#-(!'2(:!,.&7*!0#..:!S&'2!82,*7(!,8'&E&'&(5!I21S!$(*(0&'5!

,-(! '1!$(!)(.&E(-()J!,5!(`9.,&*()!)(0&*()! &*!5(8'&1*!OA?!S2(-(! '2(!%,&*! '(-%5!10!

C(3(,.! ,-(! )(0&*()A! B2&5! &5! ,82&(E()! '2-1#72! '2(! &*'(7-,'&1*! 10!

9-17-,%%(5a9-1^(8'5;! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)! -(51#-8(5A! B2(! ,..18,'&1*! 10! -(51#-8(5;! &*!

9,-'&8#.,-;! &5! ,8'&E(.:!%,*,7()! '1! ',K(! ,881#*'! 10! '2(! u,5\&5v! ,8'#,.! 915&'&1*;! '2(!

u'1\$(v!9.,**();!0#'#-(!915&'&1*!,*)!'2(!u(%(-7()v!,8'#,.!,82&(E()!915&'&1*A!

N$T$- "5;9'((!M'B!/(['91(!

B2(! K(:! ,59(8'5! &*! '(-%5! 10! C(3(,.L5! 81*'-&$#'&1*5! '1! K(:! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'!

,-(,5!,5!'2(:!2,E(!$((*!&)(*'&0&()!,'!'2(!$(7&**&*7!10!'2(5(!-(5(,-82!,*)!E,.&),'()!

$:! 01..1S&*7! '2(! -(5(,-82! 5'-,'(7:! ,*)! %('21)1.17:! 8,*! $(! 7-1#9()! #*)(-! '2(!

01..1S&*7!2(,)&*75!,*)!)&58#55()!&*!'2&5!5(8'&1*W!!

• 6(8&5&1*!%,K&*7!5#991-'!$,5()!1*!,!$(*(0&'5!)-&E(*!,99-1,82q!

Page 212: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ?FF!

• +(-01-%,*8(!19'&%&5,'&1*q!

• Q1*'-1.!,*)!,881#*',$&.&':q!

• <55#-,*8(q!

• "',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!81%%#*&8,'&1*q!,*)!

• d*1S.()7(!%,*,7(%(*'!(*,$.(-A!

7&E$($+#! D.?$#A! (322+')! C.(&0! +#! C&#&,$)(! 0'$%&#! .22'+.E6! O! G*(! 10! '2(!

0#*),%(*',.!,&%5!10!'2(!,#'21-!S,5!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!,*)!)(E(.19!,!9-18(55!'2,'!9#'5!

$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,'!'2(!2(,-'!10!5'-,'(7&8!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7;!$:!#5&*7!$(*(0&'5!,5!,!

-1,)%,9! 01-! 82,*7(A! B2,'! 2,5! $((*! -(&'(-,'()! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! -(5(,-82A! B2(!

-(5#.'&*7!9-18(55!&*!(E(-:!5'(9!,*)!)(.&E(-,$.(!&5!,&%()!'1!81*'-&$#'(!'1!)(8&5&1*5!

'2,'! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! 2,E(! '1! %,K(! S2(*! )(.&E(-&*7! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'!

9-1^(8'A! B2(! ,.&7*%(*'! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55!S&'2! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! &*E(5'%(*'!

,99-,&5,.! ,*)!9-1^(8'! 9-17-(55&1*! 5(4#(*8(5!S,5! '(5'()! &*! ,..! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5!

,*)! &'!S,5! ,8K*1S.()7()! '2,'! '2(!1#'81%(5! 81*'-&$#'()! '1S,-)5!)(8&5&1*5!$((*!

%,)(!$,5()!1*!'2(!(E&)(*8(!'2,'!'2(!9-18(55!)(.&E(-()A!"#82!)(8&5&1*5!01-!(`,%9.(!

&*8.#)()! '2(! 01-%#.,'&1*! 10! ,! U,'(S,:Y! -(E&(S! -(91-'! &*! Q"=! $,5()! 1*! '2(!

(.&8&','&1*!S1-K5219! 1#'81%(5;! '2(! 5(.(8'&1*! 10! ,! )(5&7*! 19'&1*! 01-! '2(! 2159&',.!

-()(E(.19%(*'! &*!Q"@!,5!,! -(5#.'!10! '2(!19'&1*((-&*7!S1-K52195!,5!9-(5(*'()! &*!

"(8'&1*!NA@A@!IQ2,9'(-!NJA!!

5&',+'D.#E&! +2)$D$(.)$+#! O! B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! %,&*.:! 1*! '2(! +,'2S,:! ,*)!

<55(55%(*'!92,5(! &5!$,5()!1*! '2(!9-&*8&9.(! '2,'! 01-!$(*(0&'5! '1!$(!,82&(E()! '2(:!

2,E(! '1! .&*K()!)&-(8'.:!S&'2! '2(!,8'&E&'&(5! ,*)! -(51#-8(5!1*! '2(!9-1^(8'!9.,*! '2,'!

)-&E(5! '2(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'A! B2(! -(5(,-82! 2,5! 5'-1*7.:! &*)&8,'()! '2,'!

,82&(E(%(*'! 10! 5#5',&*,$.(! 711)! 9(-01-%,*8(! 521#.)! (%(-7(! 0-1%! 9-19(-!

&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!,*)!,..18,'&1*!10!-(51#-8(5! '1!(.&8&'()!$(*(0&'5A!"(*&1-!%,*,7(%(*'!

'2,'!S,5!&*E1.E()!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,8K*1S.()7()!'2,'!$(*(0&'5!)-&E(*!,99-1,82!

I5#82! ,5! C(3(,.J! 1*! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! 2,5! 915&'&E(! &*0.#(*8(! &*! -()#8&*7!

0-&8'&1*;! $-,K&*7! )1S*! 5&.15! ,*)! 018#5! '2(! '(,%!1*! 19'&%&5&*7! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5;!

,*)!,5!,!81*5(4#(*8(!2,E(!,!915&'&E(!(00(8'!1*!'2(!1-7,*&5,'&1*L5!9(-01-%,*8(A!

Page 213: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>>!

:+#)'+/! .#0! .EE+3#).C$/$)*! O! V'! &5! &%91-',*'! '1! -(%(%$(-! '2,'! %,*:!

9-17-,%%(a9-1^(8'! $(*(0&'5! %,'(-&,.&5(! .1*7! ,0'(-! &*)&E&)#,.! 9-1^(8'! '(,%5! ,-(!

-()(9.1:()!,*)! '2(-(01-(;! 81..(8'&E(! 71E(-*,*8(!*(()5! '1!$(! -(',&*()! '1!%,*,7(!

$(*(0&'5!.1*7(E&':A!!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&5!81*5&)(-()!'1!$(!$:!'215(!'2,'!&*'(-0,8()!

S&'2! &'! )#-&*7! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*)! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! ,! ):*,%&8! 9-18(55! '2,'!

,..1S5!$,5(.&*(5!'1!$(!5('!,*)!$(*(0&'5!'1!$(!'-,8K()!'2-1#721#'!'2(!.&0(8:8.(!10!,!

9-1^(8'A!!

F((3'.#E&! O! C(3(,.! ,.&7*5! S&'2! ,55#-,*8(! 0-,%(S1-K5! 5#82! ,5! ,#)&';! 5:5'(%5!

5'-#8'#-(5!,*)!1E(-5&72'!81%%&''((5;!'2-1#72W!

# <99.&8,'&1*! 10! 510'! 5K&..5! '1! )(.&E(-! 9(-51*,.! &*'(7-&':;! 8#.'#-,.! 82,*7(! ,*)!

5',K(21.)(-!81..,$1-,'&1*q!

# B-,*59,-(*'!82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'q!

# H`9.&8&'!-&5K!,..18,'&1*!a!,S,-(*(55q!

# B-,*59,-(*'! )(8&5&1*! %,K&*7! ,-1#*)! 19'&1*! ,*,.:5&5! ,*)! &*'(-9-(','&1*! 10!

0(()$,8Kq!

# +-1E&5&1*! 10! ,88#-,'(! ,*)! 8#--(*'! &*01-%,'&1*! 0.1S5! '1! 5',K(21.)(-5!

)(%1*5'-,'&*7! '2(! (00&8&(*8:! ,*)! (00(8'&E(*(55! 10! '2(! ,55#-,*8(! 91.&8&(5! ,*)!

C(3(,.! 19(-,'&1*5! IS2&82! 521#.)! ,.51! &*8.#)(! 81%9.&,*8(! S&'2! 5','#'1-:!

1$.&7,'&1*5JA!

-).?&6+/0&'!D.#.A&D&#)!,.E$/$).)$+#!O!B2(!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!&*'1!'2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!

1*! '2(! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 9-17-,%%(5! ,'! '2(&-! )&00(-(*'! 5',7(5! 10! '2(&-!

)(E(.19%(*'! 2,E(! 9-1E()! '2(! ,#'21-5! $(.&(0! '2,'! 5#82! 9-17-,%%(5! ,-(!

*1'1-&1#5.:! .,-7(! ,*)! 81%9.(`!S&'2!%#.'&9.(! 5',K(21.)(-5A! B2(! 82,-,8'(-&5'&8,..:!

2,E(! .1*7! S21.(! .&0(8:8.(;! S&'2! %,*:! 5',7(5! &*8.#)&*7! 91.&8:! 5(''&*7;! 9.,**&*7;!

)(E(.19%(*';! 81*5'-#8'&1*;! 81%%&55&1*&*7! 10! 2(,.'28,-(! 5(-E&8(! 19(-,'&1*5;!

0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'! I(A7A! %,&*'(*,*8(J;! -(0#-$&52%(*'5! ,*)! )(%1.&'&1*A! ! B2(:!

,-(!,.51!10'(*!5#$^(8'!'1!(*01-8()!5'-#8'#-(!,*)!71E(-*,*8(!82,*7(!)#(!'1!91.&8:A!!

6#(!'1!'2&5!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(5!,-(!2,-)!'1!%,*,7(q!'2(:!10'(*!

-#*! 1E(-! '&%(! ,*)! $#)7(';! ,*)! ,-(! 10'(*! #*,$.(! '1! -(,82! '2(! ',-7('5! '2,'! S(-(!

9.,**()! ,'! '2(! 1#'5('! 10! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! $:! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()A!

C(3(,.!8,*!$(!#5()!'1!1E(-81%(!'2(5(!)&00&8#.'&(5!'2-1#72!'2(!)&00(-(*'!'11.5!,*)!

Page 214: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>?!

'(82*&4#(5;! )(58-&$()! (,-.&(-! &*! '2&5! 82,9'(-A! ! V'! &5! 9,-'&8#.,-.:! (00(8'&E(! &*! '2(5(!

81%9.(`! (*E&-1*%(*'5! $(8,#5(! 10! '2(! 5',K(21.)(-! %,*,7(%(*'! 9-18(55(5!

&%$())()! S&'2&*! &'! ,5! &'! S,5! S&)(.:! ,8K*1S.()7()! 01..1S&*7! '2(! E,.&),'&1*!

S1-K52195!S&'2!'2(!-(5(,-82L5!,)E&51-:!7-1#9A!!

C(3(,.! &5! )&E&)()! &*'1! 0&E(! %,&*! 92,5(5W! "'-,'(7:! ,.&7*%(*'q! H.&8&','&1*q!

G9'&1*((-&*7q! +,'2S,:q! ,*)! <55(55%(*';! '2-1#721#'! (,82! 10! '2(5(! 92,5(5! &'! &5!

9,-,%1#*'!'2,'!5',K(21.)(-!(*7,7(%(*'!&5!,!9-&1-&':A!V*!.&*(!S&'2!8#--(*'!'2&*K&*7!

C(3(,.!',K(5!&*'1!,881#*'!'2(!@!%,&*!(.(%(*'5!&*'-1)#8()!&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!

,8-155!'2(!O!92,5(5!01-!'2(!5#88(550#.!&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!

T,*,7(%(*'! '2(5(! ,-(;! .(,)(-52&9;! 9(19.(a1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! &55#(5! ,*)! '11.5! ,*)!

'(82*&4#(5! I+,:*(;! =>>MJA! H,82! 10! '2(! '2-((! (.(%(*'5! &5! &*'(-.&*K()! ,*)! '2(!

(`9(-&(*8(!0-1%!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!2,5!&*)&8,'()!'2,'!S&'21#'!1*(!'2(!9-18(55!81#.)!

0,&.A! /1-! C(3(,.! '2(! 510'! &55#(5! &*8.#)()!S&'2&*! '2(! 9(19.(! a1-7,*&5,'&1*! 5(8'&1*!

&*8.#)(!'2(!'(,%!S1-K&*7!'2-1#72!'2(!(5',$.&52%(*'!10!'2(!9-1^(8'!S1-K&*7!7-1#9!

&*! '2(!"'-,'(7:!,.&7*%(*'!92,5(;!81%%#*&8,'&1*!I)&58#55()! 0#-'2(-! .,'(-!1*J!,*)!

5',K(21.)(-!(*7,7(%(*'A!_2&.5'!'2(!2,-)!&55#(5!.&(!S&'2&*!'2(!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!

5(8'&1*!5#82!$(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7;!$(*(0&'5!5(7%(*','&1*;!%#.'&! 8-&'(-&,!-,*K&*7;! '2,'!

,&)!'2(!&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55A!

!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&5!,!S,:!10!81\1-)&*,'&*7!)&00(-(*'!5',K(21.)(-5L!&*E1.E(%(*';!

9-1%1'&*7!S&)(! 81*5#.','&1*! ,*)! $#:\&*A! H`9(8','&1*5!%#5'! $(!%,*,7();! ,5! '2(!

9-18(55!10!,82&(E&*7!1$^(8'&E(!E,.#(!^#)7(%(*'5!&5!&*'(-\5#$^(8'&E(;!&'!&5!&*0.#(*8()!

$:! '2(! 5#99.&(-! ,5!S(..! ,5! '2(! 8#5'1%(-! I311K(! ('! ,.A;! =>?>JA! +(19.(! &*E1.E()! &*!

9.,**&*7! ,*)! )(.&E(-&*7! ,! 9-1^(8'! %#5'! $(! 8,-(0#.! *1'! '1! 7(*(-,'(! #*-(,.&5'&8!

(`9(8','&1*5!'2,'!S&..! .(,)!'1!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!$(&*7!)&5,991&*'()!IC,-'.(''!=>>R;!

3(&55! ('! ,.A;! =>>RJA! C(3(,.! (*81#-,7(5! '215(! &*E1.E()! '1! $(! -&71-1#5! ,$1#'! '2(!

$(*(0&'5!)(5&-()A!!

H,-.:!&*E1.E(%(*'!10!5',K(21.)(-5!&5!-(0.(8'()!&*!'2(!0&-5'!92,5(!10!C(3(,.W!-)'.)&A*!

./$A#D&#)A! ! B2&5! 0&-5'! 92,5(! &5! 81*8(-*()! S&'2! )(E(.19&*7! '2(! 9-1^(8'! '(,%! ,*)!

,55&7*&*7!-1.(5!,*)!-(591*5&$&.&'&(5!'1!(,82!10!'2(5(!&*)&E&)#,.5;!&)(*'&0:&*7!)(5&-()!

5'-,'(7&8! $(*(0&'5! S&'2! ,! 9-1^(8'! '(,%! ,*)! )(E(.19&*7! ,! 8.(,-! 81%%#*&8,'&1*!

5'-,'(7:! '1! (*5#-(! '2(! 9-1^(8'! %1E(5! '2-1#72! '2(! (00(8'&E(.:! '2-1#72! '2(!

Page 215: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>=!

5#$5(4#(*'! 92,5(5A! B2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! 7-1#9! 521#.)! 81*5&5'! 10! K(:!

-(9-(5(*','&E(5! 10! '2(! )&00(-(*'! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95! &*E1.E()! &*! '2(! 9-1^(8';! '1!

(*5#-(! ,! 0,&-! ,*)! '-#(! -(9-(5(*','&1*! 10! ,..! '215(! &*E1.E()! ,*)! ,00(8'()! $:! '2(!

9-1^(8'A!/1-!(`,%9.(!&*!'2(!-()(E(.19%(*'!10!@B5!&*!Q"@!'2(!C(3(,.!9-1^(8'!'(,%!

81*5&5'()!10!-(9-(5(*','&E(5! 0-1%!'2(!%()&8,.!5',00;!9,'&(*'5;!,)%&*&5'-,'&E(!5',00;!

'2(! 81#*8&.;! '2(! +QB! I&0! 5'&..! &*! (`&5'(*8(J;! '2(! ,-82&'(8'5;! 9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(-A!

B2(-(! &5! ,! 81*'&*#()!*(()! 01-! 5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! ,*,.:5&5! '2-1#721#'!

'2(! )&00(-(*'! 92,5(5! 10! C(3(,.;! S&'2! '2(! &*E1.E(%(*'! 10! ,! S&)(-! 7-1#9! 10!

5',K(21.)(-5! &*! '2(! 5(81*)! 92,5(! I&/$E$).)$+#J! ,5! S1-K()! &*! Q"=! ,*)! Q"@;! S&'2!

,8'&E&'&(5!5#82!,5!'2(!&)(*'&0&8,'&1*!10!(*)!$(*(0&'5;!$(*(0&'5!%,99&*7!,*)!9-10&.&*7!

'1! 01-%! '2(! $,5&5! 10! ,*! 1*! 71&*7! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9.,*A! ! Q1*5#.','&1*! S&'2!

5',K(21.)(-5! $1'2! &*'(-*,.! ,*)! (`'(-*,.! 81*'&*#(5! '2-1#72! '1! '2(! '2&-)!

b2)$+#&&'$#A!92,5(!S2&82!&*E1.E(5!'2(!S(&72'&*7!,*)!581-&*7!10!$(*(0&'5!'1!8215(!

'2(!)(5&-()!S,:!01-S,-);!S2&82!%,:!$(!,!)(5&7*!1-a,*)!,!5(-E&8(!19'&1*A!

V*! 5(8'&1*! =AF! 10! '2&5! '2(5&5! '2(! ,#'21-! 9-(5(*'()! '2,'! )#-&*7! 5',K(21.)(-!

%,*,7(%(*'! 10! ,*:! 9-17-,%%(! '2(-(! ,-(! ,! *#%$(-! 10! &55#(5! '2,'! 521#.)! $(!

81*5&)(-();! 1*(! 10! '2(%! S,5! '2(! c&55#(! E,-&,*8(L;! S2(-(! 9-1^(8'! 0,8'1-5! 82,*7(!

)#-&*7! ,! 9-1^(8'! (A7A! 1*(! &55#(!%,:!%(,*!%1-(! '1! 1*(! 5',K(21.)(-! '2,*! ,*1'2(-!

B2&5!&5!4#&'(!5&7*&0&8,*'!S2(*!,)19'&*7!C(3(,.!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!E,.#(!10!,!$(*(0&';!,5!

&'!S,5!(%92,5&5();!&*!9,-'&8#.,-!)#-&*7!'2(!(.&8&','&1*!,*)!19'&1*((-&*7!S1-K52195!

&*!Q"@A!<!$(*(0&'!%,:!21.)!%1-(!E,.#(!'1!1*(!5',K(21.)(-!'2,*!&'!)1(5!'1!,*1'2(-A!!

V'!%,:!(E(*!$(!'2(!8,5(!'2,'!,!$(*(0&'!'1!1*(!5',K(21.)(-!&5!,!)&5\$(*(0&'!'1!,*1'2(-A!

b(,-*&*7! 0-1%! '2(5(! S1-K52195! 1#'81%(5! S,5! '2,'! $:! &*E1.E&*7! ,..! -(.(E,*'!

&*'(-*,.! ,*)! (`'(-*,.! 5',K(21.)(-5! I1-! -(9-(5(*','&E(5J! &*! '2(! 9-18(55! 10! $(*(0&'!

(.&8&','&1*!&*!'2(!5(81*)!92,5(!10!C(3(,.;!(*5#-()!'2,'!'2(!E&(S5!10!,..!&*E1.E()!S,5!

8,9'#-()A! B2&5! ,99-1,82! &5! ,! *(8(55,-:! 5&7*&0&8,*'! 5#-E(:&*7! ,8'&E&':;! ,5! '2(!

9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! ,! E,-&(':! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5! (*,$.(5! '2(! &*81-91-,'&1*! 10! )&00(-(*'!

E&(S5! ,*)! 9(-59(8'&E(5A! B2(! 9-18(55! 10! (.&8&','&1*! 7,E(! ,..! '215(! 5',K(21.)(-5!

&*E1.E()! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*! 1991-'#*&':! '1! 2,E(! '2(&-! 19&*&1*5! 10!S2,'! '2(:!

$(.&(E(!'1!$(!,!$(*(0&'a)&5\$(*(0&'!10!'2(!9-17-,%%(!)18#%(*'()!,*)!,))()!'1!'2(!

1E(-,..!$(*(0&'!.&5'A!!B2(!(.&8&','&1*!'(82*&4#(!7&E(5!'2(!5',K(21.)(-5!,*!1991-'#*&':!

'1! )&58#55;! )&5,7-((! ,*)a1-! )(E(.19! ,! 52,-()! 9(-59(8'&E(! I[,K&%;! =>>>J;!%,:$(!

Page 216: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>@!

(E(*! ,7-((&*7! '2,'! '2(! )&5\$(*(0&'! &5! c,! 9-&8(! S1-'2! 9,:&*7! '1! 1$',&*! 915&'&E(!

$(*(0&'5L! I_,-)! ('! ,.A;! ?FFRJA! [1S(E(-! ,! 52,-()! 9(-59(8'&E(! 8,**1'! ,.S,:5! $(!

,82&(E();! ,5! &'! S,5! '2(! (`9(-&(*8()! S2(*! '2(! E'$)&'$.! '.#?$#A! ,*)!@&$A6)$#A! 10!

19'&1*5! ,7,&*5'! $(*(0&'5! S,5! &*E(5'&7,'()! &*! Q"@A! B2&5! S,5! 1E(-81%(! $:! 2,E&*7!

8.(,-! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! '2(&-! 9-10&.(! (5',$.&52()! &*! '2(! (,-.&(-!

S1-K52195! $:! '2(! 5,%(! 7-1#9! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5;! ,*)! $:! 81%%#*&8,'&*7! ,*)!

9-(5(*'&*7! '2(&-! )(9(*)(*8(! S&'2! '2(! E,-&1#5! 5',K(21.)(-! 7-1#95A! B2&5! S,5!

01..1S()! $:! '2(! $(*(0&'5! -,*K&*7! 9-18(55! '2,'! S,5! #*)(-',K(*! '2-1#72! 19(*!

)&58#55&1*5!,*)!7,E(!,..!5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E()!'2(!0((.&*7!,*)!'2(!-(,55#-,*8(!10!

&*8.#5&E&':!'2-1#72!^1&*'!)(8&5&1*\%,K&*7A!!

B2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S!10'(*!%(*'&1*5! '2,'! (00(8'&E(! 81%%#*&8,'&1*5! &5! ,!)(8&5&E(!

,59(8'! 10! ,*:! 82,*7(! 9-17-,%! Id,7&17.1#;! =>>>;! C-,).(:;! =>>RJ;! 81*'-&$#'&*7! '1!

&*8-(,5&*7! '-,*59,-(*8:! ,*)! 0,8&.&','&*7! '2(! %,*,7(%(*'! 10! (`9(8','&1*5! ,8-155!

'2(! )&E(-5&':! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5A! C(3(,.! 9-1%1'(5! (00(8'&E(! E+DD3#$E.)$+#! ,*)!

,55#-(5! (`9(8','&1*5! %,*,7(%(*';! ,&)&*7! (00(8'&E(! K*1S.()7(! 52,-(! #*)(-! ,!

5#5',&*,$.(! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! ,99-1,82A! C(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*!%(('&*75! 01-!

(`,%9.(!S&'2!,!)&E(-5&':!10! 5',K(21.)(-5!,-(! -(81%%(*)()!,*)!#*)(-5'11)!,5!,!

8-&'&8,.! 5#-E(:&*7! ,8'&E&':;! 5&*8(! '2(! 9,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! ,! E,-&(':! 10! 5',K(21.)(-5!

(*,$.(5! '2(! &*81-91-,'&1*! 10! )&00(-(*'! E&(S5! ,*)! 9(-59(8'&E(5A! +,-'&8&9,'&1*! 10! ,!

)&E(-5&':!10! 5',K(21.)(-5! I&*8.#)&*7! '2(!1E(-,..! 9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! '(,%J!,.1*7!

'2(! 9-1^(8'! .&0(8:8.(! ,*)! '2-1#721#'! '2(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! I(A7A! $#5&*(55! 0#*8'&1*5J! &5!

,.51! -(7,-)()! ,5! $(*(0&8&,.! #*)(-! ,!%,*,7(%(*'! 10! (`9(8','&1*! 9(-59(8'&E(! ,*)!

81*'-&$#'(5!'1!,!$(''(-!81%9-(2(*5&E(!5('!10!$(*(0&'5A!

h#+@/&0A&!D.#.A&D&#)!&#.C/&'!

B2(!9-18(55!100(-5!,!%(,*5!10!'#-*&*7!0-,7%(*'()!),',!&*'1!#5(0#.!&*01-%,'&1*;!,5!

&*'-1)#8()! S2(*! )(58-&$()! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 5(7%(*','&1*! ,*)! 9-10&.&*7! '(82*&4#(5A!!

C(3(,.! &*! 9-1^(8'! K*1S.()7(! %,*,7(%(*'! '(-%5! &5! ,$1#'! 7(''&*7! '2(! -&72'!

&*01-%,'&1*!-(.,'()! '1!$(*(0&'5;! &*! '2(! -&72'! 01-%;! '1! '2(! -&72'!9(19.(!,'! '2(! -&72'!

'&%(;! S2&82! ,881-)&*7! '1! 311K(! ('! ,.A! =>?>! &5! '2(! )(0&*&'&1*! 10! .(,*! K*1S.()7(!

%,*,7(%(*'A! d15K(.,! &*! =>>>! 5','(5! '2,'! $:! ,82&(E&*7! '2&5! 9.,8(%(*'! 10!

Page 217: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>N!

K*1S.()7(!81#.)!&*8-(,5(!E,.#(;!,*)!2(!71(5!0#-'2(-!'1!&)(*'&0:!'2(!0&E(!9-&*8&9.(5!

10!E,.#(!7(*(-,'&1*!S2&82!21.)!'-#(!01-!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!'11W!

• cS#(3'&! .//! E3()+D&'! '&i3$'&D&#)(;! C+)6! &N2/$E$)! .#0! /.)&#)! 6.%&! C&&#!

E.2)3'&0>q! &*! C(3(,.! '(-%5! '2,'! 8,*! $(! 5((*! ,5! '2(! &)(*'&0&8,'&1*! ,*)!

(.&8&','&1*!10!,..!)(5&-()!$(*(0&'5q!

• cS#(3'&! )6.)! E3()+D&'! '&i3$'&D&#)(! 6.%&! C&.'$#A! +#! .//! 0&/$%&'.C/&(! ,+'! .//!

E3()+D&'(>q! &*! C(3(,.! '(-%5! '2&5! &5! '2(! .&*K! 10! $(*(0&'5! &)(*'&0&();! $:! '2(!

5',K(21.)(-5! &*E1.E();! S&'2! 9.,**()! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5! )#-&*7! '2(!

19'&1*((-&*7!,*)!9,'2S,:!92,5(!,5!)(58-&$()!(,-.&(-!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-q!

• S#(3'&!)6&!E.2.C$/$)*!+,!)6&!2'+03E)$+#!(*()&D!)+!2'+03E&!2'+03E)(!'&i3$'&0>q!

C(3(,.! ,)19'5! '2&5! &*! '2(! 9,'2S,:! 92,5(! S(-(! '2(! )(9(*)(*8:! $('S((*!

$(*(0&'5;!-(51#-8(5!,*)!9-1^(8'!9.,*!,8'&E&'&(5!&5!,82&(E()q!

• S#(3'&! )6.)! '&/&%.#)! E3()+D&'! '&i3$'&D&#)(! .'&! .%.$/.C/&! $#! .//! 26.(&(! +,!

0&($A#!(+/3)$+#(;!2'+03E)$+#!2/.#(!.#0!2'+03E)(>q!C(3(,.!9-17-(55(5! '2(!#5(!

10! 5',K(21.)(-! (.&8&'()! ,*)! 5'-#8'#-()! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! ,..! 92,5(5! 10! '2(!

9-18(55! ,*)! &*! 9,-'&8#.,-!S2(*! 5(.(8'&*7! 19'&1*5! ,*)! 7(*(-,'&*7! '2(! 0&*,.!

9-1^(8'! 9.,*5A! C(3(,.L5! ),',5('! ,..1S5! '215(! &*E1.E()! #*)(-5',*)&*7! '2(!

,%$&'&1*5! ,*)! '2(! ,82&(E(%(*'5! 10! ,! 9-1^(8'! '1! ),'(A! ! V'! (*5#-(5! '2,'!

-(.(E,*'! 5',K(21.)(-! -(4#&-(%(*'5! I'-,*5.,'()! &*'1! $(*(0&'5J! ,-(! ,E,&.,$.(!

&*! ,..! 92,5(5! 10! 9-1)#8'&1*! I'2(! C(3(,.! 92,5(5JA! B2(! K(:! '11.5! ,*)!

'(82*&4#(5!)(58-&$()!&*!5(8'&1*!OAN!,..1S!)18#%(*'5!'1!$(!52,-()!,%1*75'!

)&00(-(*'!5',K(21.)(-5!,'!)&00(-(*'!.(E(.5!10!9(-%&55&1*q!

• <S#(3'&! C*!D&.(3'&D&#)! )6.)! %./3&! $(! A&#&'.)&0! ,+'! )6&! E3()+D&'>q! C(3(,.!

81*'-1..&*7!5'-#8'#-(!10!$(*(0&'5!,*)!'2(&-!%(,5#-(%(*'!1*!'2(!F((&((D&#)!

92,5(!,&%5!'1!)('(-%&*(!'2(&-!.(E(.!10!-(,.&5,'&1*!&*!'(-%5!10!8,9'#-&*7!'2(!

5',K(21.)(-5!9(-8(9'&1*!10!&'A!!

N$O >':'/0![5;9'((!</0)3/1);2!

B2(-(!S(-(!'S1!%,&*!-1#'(5!01-!'2(!E,.&),'&1*!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55W!

Page 218: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>O!

I?J!B2(!,)19'&1*!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*!'2(!]["!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!'2,'!9,-'&8&9,'()!

&*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#):! =! ,*)! 8,5(! 5'#):! @! 01..1S&*7! '2(&-! 81%9.('&1*q! I=J! '2(! S&)(!

)&55(%&*,'&1*!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!0&*)&*75!,*)!&*!9,-'&8#.,-!'2(!9-18(55!&'5(.0!,*)!21S!

'2(5(!S(-(!-(8(&E()!$1'2!$:!'2(!,8,)(%&,!,*)!'2(!&*)#5'-:A!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! 81*8.#5&1*! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 8,5(! 5'#):! @! I&A(A! '2(! @B5! 9-1^(8'!

&*E(5'&7,'()J! '2(! 9-17-,%%(! )&-(8'1-! ,*)! '2(! 9-1^(8'! '(,%! ,)19'()! '2(! C(3(,.!

9-18(55!,5!9-(5(*'()! &*! 82,9'(-!O! '1!%1*&'1-! '2(! -(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!,82&(E(%(*'!10!

(`9(8'()! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#721#'! 9-1^(8'! &%9.(%(*','&1*A! <! $(*(0&'5! .(,)(-! S,5!

,55&7*()! ,*)! ,! 5#$\81%%&''((! (5',$.&52()! ,5! &'! &5! 9-(58-&$()! &*! '2(! 0&*,.! C(3(,.!

9-18(55A!B2(!7-1#9!9-(5(*'5!9-17-(55!4#,-'(-.:! &*! ,! 59(8&0&8!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*!

$1,-)! %(('&*7! .(,)! $:! '2(! C"P[! QHGA! B2(! ),',! 81..(8'()! ,*)! %,&*! 1#'81%(5!

)(58-&$()! &*! Q"@! I5((! 5(8'&1*NA@A@J!S(-(! #5()! '1! &*01-%! '2(! 81%9&.,'&1*! 10! '2(!

582(%(L5!/CQ!,*)!^#5'&0:!&'5!91'(*'&,.!&*E(5'%(*'!$:!'2(!6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2A!!

/1..1S&*7! '2(! 81*8.#5&1*! 10! 8,5(! 5'#):! =;! ]["! "'18K91-'! ,)19'()! C(3(,.! ,5! ,!

%('21)1.17:!71&*7!01-S,-)!&*!)(E(.19&*7!,*)!&*01-%&*7!'2(!G#'.&*(!C#5&*(55!Q,5(!

01-!'2(!"'!B21%,5!9-1^(8'A!B2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S!'(,%!'2,'!,99-,&5()!'2(!9-17-(55!

10! '2(! 9-1^(8'! &*E&'()! '2(! ,#'21-! &*! '2(! 7,'(! @! -(E&(S5! 10! '2(! "'! B21%,5! 9-1^(8'!

S2(-(! '2(! C(3(,.! %('21)1.17:! ,*)! '2(! 1#'9#'5! 10! '2(! $(*(0&'5! (.&8&','&1*!

S1-K5219! S(-(! 9-(5(*'()A! B2(! 1#'81%(! 10! '2(! -(E&(S! 81*5&)(-()! '2,'! '2(!

%('21)1.17:!01..1S()!S,5!-1$#5'!,*)!-(81%%(*)()!'2,'!'2(!1#'9#'5!,*)!0&*)&*75!

S1#.)! 5'-(*7'2(*! '2(! "'! B21%,5! $#5&*(55! 8,5(A! <5! ,! 81*5(4#(*8(! '2(!U,'(S,:Y!

-(E&(S!'(,%!&*E1.E()!S1#.)!-(81%%(*)!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!1*(!'1!,)19'!S2(*!

9.,**&*7! 01-! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(5! 1-! )(E(.19&*7! ,!

$#5&*(55!8,5(!01-!,!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(!,5!5#82A!!

<))&'&1*,.!E,.&),'&1*!10!'2(!#5(0#.*(55!,*)!81*'-&$#'&1*5!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!8,*!

$(! )(%1*5'-,'()! '2-1#72! '2(!S&)(! )&55(%&*,'&1*! 10! '2(! 1#'9#'5! 7(*(-,'()! ,5! ,!

-(5#.'A!<!.&5'!10!,8,)(%&8!9#$.&8,'&1*5;!&*)#5'-:!-(91-'5;!K(:*1'(!9-(5(*','&1*5;!,*)!

&*E&'()!.(8'#-(5!&*!'2(!,-(,!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!,*)!%,*,7(%(*'!.()!$:!'2(!

,#'21-!&5!)(',&.()!&*!<99(*)&`!XVA!

Page 219: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!0&E(!Z!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,-82&'(8'#-(!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>R!

B2(!,#'21-!S,5!,.51!&*E&'()!$:!B2(!"','&1*,-:!G00&8(!IB"GJ!'1!$(!,!-(E&(S(-!10!'2(!

=>??! ()&'&1*! 10! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.! +-17-,%%(5! IT"+J! ,*)! 5#88(550#..:!

-(E&(S()!,*)!9,-'&8&9,'()!&*!'2(!81*5'-#8'&1*!10!'2(!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!82,9'(-!

S&'2&*!'2&5!7#&)(!(*)1-5()!$:![T!U1E(-*%(*'!IT"+!=>??JA!!

N$S 4;2908();2!

B2&5!82,9'(-!)(58-&$(5!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&A(A!'2(!,-'(0,8'!81*5'-#8'()!,5!'2(!-(5#.'!

10!'2(!-(5(,-82!9-(5(*'()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5q!B2(!,#'21-!)(58-&$()!,*)!)&58#55()!2(-(!

21S!'2(!(%(-7()!9-18(55!92,5(5!S(-(!81*5'-#8'()A!B2(!C(3(,.!92,5(5!9-(5(*'()!

&*!'2&5!82,9'(-!2,E(!$((*!&*01-%();! &*E(5'&7,'()!,*)!)(E(.19()!,5!,!-(5#.'!10!'2(!

.&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &*! 82,9'(-5! 'S1;! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*)! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9!

S1-K52195!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!01#-A!B2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!81*5&5'!*1S!10!0&E(!

92,5(5!,5!'2(5(!2,E(!(E1.E()!0-1%!'2(!81*8(9'#,.!9-18(55!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!?;!

01..1S&*7!'2(!-(5(,-82!%('21)1.17&8,.!0-,%(S1-KA!B2(!0&E(!92,5(5!,-(!I?J!"'-,'(7:!

,.&7*%(*'q!I=J!H.&8&','&1*q!I@J!G9'&1*((-&*7q!INJ!+,'2S,:q!,*)!IOJ!<55(55%(*'A!B2(!

,#'21-! ,.51! )&58#55(5! '2(! K(:! '11.5! ,*)! '(82*&4#(5! '2,'! ,-(! )(9.1:()! &*! '2(! 0&E(!

C(3(,.!92,5(5;! ,5! '2(:!2,E(!$((*!-(0&*()! 01..1S&*7!,*,.:5&5!10! '2(! 0&(.)! -(5(,-82!

1#'81%(5A!!B2(!&*'(-9-(','&1*!10!'2(!*(S!K*1S.()7(!,84#&-()!$:!'2(!,#'21-!&5!,.51!

9-(5(*'()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!9,-,)&7%!52&0'!*(()();!'2(!9-18(55!&*'(7-,'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5!

,*)!'2(!K(:!,59(8'A!!

B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!E,.&)&':!&5!,.51!9-(5(*'()!&*!'(-%5!10!'2(!1*!71&*7!,)19'&1*!10!

'2(!9-18(55!$:!'2(!]["!1-7,*&5,'&1*5!'2,'!81..,$1-,'()!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!

,99-,&5,.!$:!'2(!U,'(S,:Y!-(E&(S(-5!&*E1.E()!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!-(817*&5&*7!'2,'!

'2(!#5(!10!C(3(,.!S&..!,))!E,.#(!'1!,..!9-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5!&*!'2(!S&)(-!9#$.&8!

5(8'1-A!

!

Page 220: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>M!

T 4#/[1'5!=)\!W!4;2908();2(!

B2&5!82,9'(-!9-(5(*'5!'2(!0&*,.!81*8.#5&1*5!1*!'2(!-(5(,-82!1*!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!&'!

5#%%,-&5(5! '2(!%,&*! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! '2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! 10!

'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!,)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195!#*)(-',K(*!$:!'2(!,#'21-A!B2(!

82,9'(-!)&58#55(5!'2(!0#.0&.%(*'!10!'2(!1$^(8'&E(5!,*)!-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*5!'2,'!5('!,'!

'2(! $(7&**&*7! 10! '2&5! 4#(5'A! /&*,..:! &'! 2&72.&72'5! '2(! %,&*! 1#'81%(5! ,*)!

-(81%%(*),'&1*5!01-!0#'#-(!-(5(,-82!*(()()!&*!'2(!0&(.)A!

B2(!018#5!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!9-(5(*'()!S,5!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!$(5'!9-,8'&8(5!&*!'2(!,-(,!

10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!21S!'2(5(!,-(!,99.&()!&*!'2(!Pd!2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-;!

&*! 9,-'&8#.,-! '2(! ,#'21-! ,&%()! '1! )(E(.19! ,! -1$#5'! 9-18(55! 01-! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*A! B2(! ,#'21-! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! -(5(,-82! ,))-(55()! '2(! 01..1S&*7!

-(5(,-82!4#(5'&1*W!!

• <I6.)! $(! )6&! 2'+E&((! ,+'! C&#&,$)(! '&./$(.)$+#! )6.)! @+3/0! 6&/2! .00'&((! )6&!

2'+V&E)! (3EE&((! $((3&(! @$)6$#! )6&! "h>(! 6&./)6E.'&! $#,'.()'3E)3'&!

0&%&/+2D&#)!(&E)+'!.#0!A+&(!C&*+#0!E3''&#)!C&()!2'.E)$E&jL!!

B2&5! 4#(5'&1*! S,5! 0#..:! ,))-(55()! '2-1#721#'! '2&5! '2(5&5! ,*)! &*! 9,-'&8#.,-! &*!

Q2,9'(-! 0&E(!S2(-(! '2(! ,#'21-! 9-(5(*'()! '2(! 0&*,.! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 81*5'-#8'()!

)(',&.&*7!&'5!92,5(5!,*)!K(:!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5A!!

C,5()! 1*! '2(! -(5(,-82! ,&%! ,*)! -(5(,-82! 4#(5'&1*! -,&5()! &*! 82,9'(-! 1*(! '2(!

01..1S&*7!1$^(8'&E(5!S(-(!5('W!

• !c"#0&').?&! .! /$)&'.)3'&! '&%$&@! )+! $0&#)$,*! <C&()! 2'.E)$E&>! .#0! $((3&(! +#!

C&#&,$)(! '&./$(.)$+#;! D.#.A&D&#)! .#0! '&/.)&0! 0$(E$2/$#&(9! =#! 2.')$E3/.'!

.$D$#A!)+!$0&#)$,*H!

o I6.)! .'&! )6&! E3''&#)! 2'.E)$E&(! .#0! .22'+.E6&(! '&/.)&0! )+! C&#&,$)(!

D.#.A&D&#)!.#0!'&./$(.)$+#j!

o I6.)! .'&! )6&! E3''&#)! 2'+E&((&(! ,+'! 2/.##$#A! .#0! 0&/$%&'$#A!

6&./)6E.'&!$#,'.()'3E)3'&!2'+A'.D(t!

Page 221: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>D!

• 7&%$(&! .! D&)6+0+/+A*! ,+'! $#%&()$A.)$#A! ($A#$,$E.#)! $#($A6)(! $#)+! 6+@!

<C&#&,$)(! '&./$(.)$+#>! $(!3#0&'()++0!E3''&#)/*!.#0! /$#?!.//! '&/&%.#)! $((3&(! )+!

6&/2!0&%&/+2!.#0!2'+D+)&!)6&!.0+2)$+#!+,!.!<C&#&,$)!0'$%&#>!.22'+.E6Z!

• 7&%&/+2! .#0! 2'+2+(&! .! C&#&,$)(! '&./$(.)$+#! 2'+E&((! (3$).C/&! ,+'!

$D2/&D&#).)$+#!@$)6$#!)6&!6&./)6E.'&!$#,'.()'3E)3'&!(&E)+'!)6.)!$#E/30&(H!

o U&)6+0(!.#0!)&E6#$i3&(!,+'!0&,$#$#A!.#0!D+#$)+'$#A!C&#&,$)(Z!

o =D2/&D&#).)$+#! .#0! %./$0.)$+#! &%$0&#E&! ,'+D! '&./! E.(&(! .$D$#A! )+!

.((&((!$)(!3)$/$)*!.#0!3(&,3/#&((9!

B2(!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!)(E(.19()!0-1%!'2&5!-(5(,-82!,59&-(5!'1!$(!'2(!

,99-19-&,'(!%('21)!'1!^#5'&0:;!)-&E(!,*)!81*'-1.!82,*7(!&*&'&,'&E(5A!

B2(!.&'(-,'#-(!-(E&(S!&*!82,9'(-!'S1!,*)!'2(!,#'21-L5!)&58#55&1*5!S&'2!&*)#5'-:!

(`9(-'5! '2-1#72! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! S1-K52195! )(%1*5'-,'()! ,*)! 81*8.#)()!

'2,'! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &5! (%(-7&*7! ,5! ,! E&',.! (.(%(*'! 01-! c$(5'! 9-,8'&8(L!

9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'! &*! '2(!81*'(`'!10!2(,.'28,-(!8,9&',.! &*E(5'%(*'! &*! '2(!

PdA! B2&5! '2(5&5! 9-(5(*'()! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! ,! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! &*! 5#991-'! '1! '2,'!

5','(%(*';! &*'-1)#8()! ,*! (%(-7(*'! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! 9-18(55! IC(3(,.J! ,*)!

2&72.&72'()! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2-((! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5;! ',-7('&*7! '2(! &*'(7-,'()! 9.,**&*7!

,*)!(E,.#,'&1*!10!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5!,*)!5(-E&8(5!&*!'2(!PdA!B2(!-(5(,-82!

9-(5(*'()! 9-1E&)()! (E&)(*8(! 10! '2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,.1*7!

)&00(-(*'! 92,5(5! 10! 8,9&',.! &*E(5'%(*'! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! '2(! 0&*)&*75! 0-1%! '2(!

8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 2,E(! 81*'-&$#'()! '1! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! E,.&),'&1*! 10! '2(!%,^1-!

)&00(-(*'!)&%(*5&1*5!S&'2&*!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55;!,5!)&58#55()!,.1*7!'2(!01..1S&*7!

9,-,7-,925A!

T$, Y)1'5/185'!5'<)'R!7)23)2A(!

V*! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! S&'2&*! 82,9'(-! 'S1! &*01-%,'&1*! S,5! 9-1E&)()! 1*! '2(!

2&5'1-:!,*)!(E1.#'&1*!10!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*A!B2(!,&%!

S,5!'1!9-(5(*'!'2(!(`&5'&*7!,99-1,82(5!%('21)5!,*)!'11.5!,*)!21S!'2(5(!%,:!$(!

,99.&()! &*! '2(! 5#88(550#.! %,*,7(%(*'! 10! %,^1-! 9-17-,%%(5! ,*)a1-! 9-1^(8'5A!

Page 222: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =>F!

B2(! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! &*&'&,.! )&58#55&1*5! S&'2! &*)#5'-:! (`9(-'5! 81*8.#)()!

,*)!9-(5(*'()!'2(!01..1S&*7W!

• <.'21#72! '2(! *(()! 10! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!2,5! 81&*8&)()!S&'2! '2(! &*8-(,5&*7!

#5(!,*)!81%9.(`&':!10!VB!5:5'(%5!&'!&5!,*!(%(-7(*'!,*)!E&',.!(.(%(*'!01-!c$(5'!

9-,8'&8(L!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!&*!,*:!%,^1-!8,9&',.!&*E(5'%(*'!

&*!PdL5!2(,.'28,-(!&*)#5'-:q!

• B2(!*(8(55,-:!8.(,-!)&5'&*8'&1*!$('S((*;!$(*(0&'5;!1#'81%(5!,*)!1#'9#'5!,*)!

9-(5(*'5!21S! '215(!%,:! &*'(--(.,'(!)#-&*7! '2(! .&0(8:8.(!10! ,!9-17-,%%(!1-!

9-1^(8'!(59(8&,..:!'2(!91'(*'&,.!10!'2(!1#'81%(5!'1!)(.&E(-!$(*(0&'5q!

• Q.,55&0&8,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5! &*! '(-%5! 10! E,.#(;! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! &%9,8'! I&*'(-*,.!

,*)!(`'(-*,.J;!9.,**()!,*)!#*9.,**()!,*)!5',K(21.)(-!&*'(-,8'&1*q!

• B2(! &%91-',*8(! '1! #*)(-5',*)! '2(! )&00(-(*'&,'&1*! $('S((*! ',*7&$.(! ,*)!

&*',*7&$.(!$(*(0&'5!,*)!21S!'215(!%,:!$(!%,*,7()!,*)!-(,.&5()q!

• B2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! 8.(,-! -1.(5! ,*)! -(591*5&$&.&'&(5! 01-! 5#88(550#.! $(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!'2(!*(8(55&':!10!-1$#5'!%('21)5!10!71E(-*,*8(q!

• B2(! $-1,).:! ,88(9'()! &*! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&1*;! VB;! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(%(*'! &*)#5'-:! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! a! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82(5! ,*)!

2&72.&72'5!'2(&-!%,&*!(.(%(*'5q!

• B2(!-1.(!10!'2(!$#5&*(55!8,5(!,5!,!c.&E(L!)18#%(*'!S2(*!)-&E&*7!01-!5#88(550#.!

9-17-,%%(5!,*)!9-1^(8'5q!

• b&*K,7(5! $('S((*! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! ,*)! $(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

21S!(55(*'&,.! &5! '2(!%(,5#-(%(*';!%1*&'1-&*7! ,*)! -(E&(S&*7!10!$(*(0&'5! '1!

%,&*',&*! ,! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! %1%(*'#%! (&'2(-! S&'2&*! ,*! (`&5'&*7!

9-17-,%%(a!9-1^(8'!1-!S2(*!9.,**&*7!01-!*(S!1*(5q!

• B2(! -(.,'&1*52&9!$('S((*!E,.#(! ,*)!$(*(0&'5! ,*)! (`&5'&*7! (E,.#,'&1*! 5',7(5!

,*)!'(82*&4#(5q!!

• B2(! 9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,5! -1#'(! 01-! $(''(-! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

,881#*',$&.&':L! '2,'! 9-1E&)(5! &*01-%,'&1*! -(4#&-()! 01-! 9-18(55! 81*'-1.;!

(*,$.&*7! '2(! (5',$.&52%(*'! 10! -(,.! $#'! 82,..(*7&*7! ',-7('5;! '2,'! 81#.)! $(!

'-,*5.,'()!&*'1!$(*(0&'5q!,*)!

Page 223: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?>!

• B2(! #*)(-5',*)&*7! ,$1#'! '2(! 5&7*&0&8,*8(! 10! 5',K(21.)(-! -(4#&-(%(*'5!

8,9'#-(! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'! ,5! E&',.! &*! (*5#-&*7! ,! 9-1^(8'L5! 1-! 9-17-,%%(L5!

$(*(0&'5!)(.&E(-:!,*)!-(,.&5,'&1*!01-!,..!'2-1#721#'!&'5!.&0(8:8.(A!

V'! S,5! (E&)(*'! 0-1%! '2(! .&'(-,'#-(! ,E,&.,$.(! '2,'! 5'&..!%,^1-! 8,9&',.! &*E(5'%(*'!

9-17-,%%(5! ,*)! 9-1^(8'5! ,-(! %(,5#-()! 1*! '2(&-! 5#88(55! &*! -(.,'&1*! '1! 815';!

4#,.&':! ,*)! '&%(! 10! )(.&E(-:;! ,*)! *1'! &*! -(.,'&1*! '1! '2(! $(*(0&'5! 1-! &%9,8'! '2,'!

'2(:! 2,E(! )(.&E(-()A! <.'21#72! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &5! (%(-7&*7! ,5! 1*(! 10! '2(!

%('21)5! '1! ,55&5'! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! '1!%,*,7(! '2(!S21.(! .&0(! 8:8.(!10!9-17-,%%(5!

,*)! 9-1^(8'5! '2(-(! S,5! *1! (E&)(*8(! 10! '2(! 5#88(550#.! &%9.(%(*','&1*! &*! '2(!

2(,.'28,-(!5(8'1-!10!,*:!10!'2(!%('21)5!,E,&.,$.(A!!

B2(5(!0&*)&*75!52,9()!'2(!&*&'&,.!K*1S.()7(!10!'2(!,#'21-!#91*!S2&82!'2(!C(3(,.!

9-18(55!S,5!)(E(.19()!,*)!9-1$()!'2(!-(5(,-82L5!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!,-(,5A!

T$* 62<'(1)A/1);2!7)23)2A(!!

B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! &5! &**1E,'&E(;! 81%$&*&*7! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(! 0-1%! ,! )&E(-5&':! 10!

K*1S.()7(!,-(,5!,*)!&*)#5'-:!5(8'1-5A!V'!',-7('5!5#88(550#.!,*)!(00(8'&E(!)(.&E(-:!

10! $(*(0&'5! '2-1#72! (00&8&(*'! %,*,7(%(*'! 10! 82,*7(A! T1-(1E(-! &'! 2,5! $((*!

)(5&7*()! '1! ,.&7*! S&'2! 9-17-,%%(! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! '(82*&4#(5! ,*)!

&*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! 9-18(55(5! 5#82! ,5! '2(!U,'(S,:Y!3(E&(S;! +-&*8(=;! Q,9&',.!

V*E(5'%(*'!T,*#,.!,*)!'2(!/&E(!Q,5(!%1)(.!,5!&'!S,5!&*E(5'&7,'()!,*)!9-(5(*'()!

&*!82,9'(-!1*(!,*)!01#-!10!'2&5!'2(5&5A!

V*&'&,..:! '2(! %,&*! 1$^(8'&E(! S,5! '1! &)(*'&0:! 8#--(*'! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(5! ,*)!

)(%1*5'-,'(! 21S! '1! &%9-1E(! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &*! 2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

9-1E&5&1*A! V*! ,8'&E(! 81..,$1-,'&1*! S&'2! .(,)&*7! &*)#5'-:! 9,-'*(-5! I,)E&51-:!

7-1#9J! '2(! ,#'21-! #*)(-'11K! ,! E,-&(':! 10! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5;! *1'! 1*.:! '1! )(0&*(! ,!

$#5&*(55! 8-&'&8,.! 9-18(55! $#'! ,.51! '1! 5('! 1#'! ,*! ,99-1,82! '2,'! 9#'! $(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!,'!'2(!2(,-'!10!5(8#-&*7!S21..:!&*'(7-,'()!I81..(8'&E(J!82,*7(A!

6(.&E(-:! 10! 81*5&5'(*'! 2&72! 4#,.&':! 5(-E&8(5! ,*)! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! '2-1#72! )&E(-5(!

&*E(5'%(*'! %1)(.5! -(4#&-(5! ,! c$(*(0&'5! )-&E(*L! ,99-1,82A! B2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*!

Page 224: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =??!

'2-1#72! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! 5#-0,8()! '2(! '2,'! 82,..(*7(! 10! ,*5S(-&*7! 81%%#*&':!

*(()5! '2-1#72! &*'(..&7(*'! &*E(5'%(*'! &5! 81%9.(`! ,*)! )(%,*)5! ,! )((9(-! ,*)!

&*8.#5&E(! ,S,-(*(55! ,*)! ,99-(8&,'&1*! 10! 21S! '1! )(.&E(-! $(*(0&'5! ,*)! ,..18,'(!

-(51#-8(5!(00(8'&E(.:A!!

V*! '2(! .&72'! 10! '2(! -(5(,-82! 1#'81%(5;! S&'2! 1-7,*&5,'&1*,.! 5#991-'! 01-! '2(!

-(4#&-()! &*E(5'%(*';! C(3(,.L5! '11.5! ,*)! '(82*&4#(5! 01-! )(0&*&*7;! )(.&E(-&*7;!

%(,5#-&*7! ,*)! (E,.#,'&*7! 59(8&0&8! $(*(0&'5! 8,*! '-,*501-%! '2(! 82,*8(5! 10!

5#88(550#.!)(.&E(-:!10!82,*7(!9-17-,%%(5A!

B2(!-(5(,-82!',-7('()!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!,!-1$#5'!,*)!81%9-(2(*5&E(!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*!9-18(55!0-1%!'2(!5'-,'(7&8!9.,**&*7!5',7(5!'1!)(.&E(-:A!B2(!-(5#.'&*7!

9-18(55! ,*)! &'5! 0&E(! 92,5(5! 018#5(5! 1*! 21S! '1! (.&8&'! ,*)! 9-&1-&'&5(! 91'(*'&,.!

$(*(0&'5! S&'2! 5',K(21.)(-5! ,'! '2(! &*&'&,.! 5',7(5;! ,*)! 21S! '1! '-,8K! ,*)!%,*,7(!

$(*(0&'5! )#-&*7! '2(! .&0(8:8.(! 10! ,! 9-17-,%%(! 1-! 9-1^(8'! '1! ,82&(E(! 5#88(550#.!

1#'81%(5A!

B11!10'(*!9(19.(!2,E(!,55#%()!'2,'!,!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'!S&..!,82&(E(!8(-',&*!

$(*(0&'5;!S&'21#'!8,--:&*7!1#'!,*,.:5&5!'1!0&*)!1#'!S2,'!#5(-5;!9,-'*(-5!,*)!1'2(-!

5',K(21.)(-5!-(,..:!E,.#(!1-!21S!'2(5(!$(*(0&'5!,-(!'1!$(!,82&(E()A!!

V*!,..! '2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5! &'!S,5!1$5(-E()!'2,'!9(19.(! &*E1.E()!S&'2!)(.&E(-&*7!,!

82,*7(! 9-1^(8'! 81*8(*'-,'(! '2(&-! (001-'5! 1*! ,82&(E&*7! 1#'9#'5;! 5#82! ,5! ,! *(S!

$#&.)&*7;!,*!VB!5:5'(%;!1-!,!82,*7(!'1!,!5(-E&8(A!C:!'2(!'&%(!'2&5!71,.!&5!)(.&E(-();!

,5! &'! S,5! (E&)(*8()! &*! Q"?! '2(-(! &5! *1! #*)(-5',*)&*7! 10! '2(! 59(8&0&8! $(*(0&'5!

,*'&8&9,'()!,*)!*1!,$&.&':!'1!&*0.#(*8(;!1-!(E(*!'-,8K;!'2(&-!,82&(E(%(*'A!!

](().(55! '1! 5,:! #5(-5! ,*)! 9,-'*(-5! 10'(*! $(81%(! 0-#5'-,'()! 1E(-! '&%(! ,'! '2(!

0,&.#-(!'1!-(,.&5(!1-!$#&.)!1*!'2(!$(*(0&'5!(`9(8'()!,'!&*8(9'&1*A!

B1! 82,*7(! '2&5! ,..! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5!)(%1*5'-,'()! '2,'! '2(!9,-'&(5! &*E1.E()! &*!,!

82,*7(! 9-17-,%%(! *(()! ,! 81*'&*#&*7! 018#5! 1*! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '2(! -&72'!

,8'&E&'&(5! 5#991-'()! $:! '2(! -&72'! -(51#-8(5;! '1! )(.&E(-! '2(! -&72'! $(*(0&'5! ,'! '2(!

-&72'! '&%(A!B2(:!,.51!*(()!5#&',$.(!%1)(.5!,*)!9,'2S,:5! '1!7#&)(!,*)!5#991-'!

Page 225: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?=!

'2(5(! (001-'5! '1! ,82&(E(! 9.,**()! $(*(0&'5A! C(3(,.! S,5! ,8K*1S.()7()! $:! ,..!

&*E1.E()!,5!5#82!,!9-18(55A!!

B2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55! 2(.95! &)(*'&0:! ,*)! )(.&E(-! $(*(0&'5! 0-1%! 9-1^(8'5! '2,'! S&..!

)(.&E(-!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(5!0,8&.&'&(5!,*)!5(-E&8(5A!V'!,.51!2(.95!&)(*'&0:!5',K(21.)(-5L!

9-&1-&'&(5!S2(*!815'5!2,E(!'1!$(!-()#8()!,*)!,!*#%$(-!10!19'&1*5!,-(!,E,&.,$.(A!!

V*!,))&'&1*;!'2(!1#'9#'!0-1%!'2(!$(*(0&'5!5'-#8'#-(5!)&58#55()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5!&*!'2(!

01-%!10!(.&8&','&1*;!19'&1*((-&*7;!,*)!'-,8K&*7!8,*!2(.9!81%%#*&8,'&1*5!$('S((*!

9,-'&(5! ,*)! %,K(! (`9.&8&'! S2,'! &5! (`9(8'()! 0-1%! (,82! 10! '2(%;! &%9-1E&*7!

)(.&E(-:!,*)!,881#*',$&.&':A!!

B2(!'(5'&*7!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!2,)!51%(!.&%&','&1*5;!5&*8(!,!*#%$(-!10!'11.5!

,*)! '(82*&4#(5!,*)!1'2(-!(.(%(*'5!2,E(!*1'!$((*!E,.&),'()A!B2(!,#'21-!S1#.)!

.&K(!'1!2&72.&72'!2(-(!'2,'!(`9.1-&*7!'2(!+,'2S,:!+2,5(!0-1%!'2(!,8'&E&'&(5!.&*K()!

S&'2! $(*(0&'5! '1! '2(! ,82&(E(%(*'! 10! 1#'81%(5! ,*)! )(.&E(-,$.(5! S,5! 1*.:!

&*E(5'&7,'()! ,5! ,! 81*8(9'#,.! 92,5(! ,*)! S,5! *1'! 0#..:! &*E(5'&7,'()! )#(! '1! '2(!

.&%&','&1*! 10! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5A! [1S(E(-! '2(! 9-1^(8'! S1-K&*7! '(,%! &*! Q"@! 2,E(!

0#..:!,)19'()! '2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!S,5! &*&'&,'()!S&'2! '2(!,#'21-!,*)!,-(!*1S!

9#-5#&*7! '2(!)(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,*! &%9.(%(*','&1*!9.,*! ,5!9-(58-&$()!S&'2&*! '2(!

+,'2S,:!92,5(!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!!

"1%(! 10! '2(! (.(%(*'5! 10! '2(! 9-18(55! ,-(! 5'&..! ,'! ,! 9-1'1':9&8,.! 5','(! ,*)!%1-(!

-(5(,-82!&5!*(()()!'1!0#-'2(-!)(E(.19!&'!,5!-(81%%(*)()!.,'(-!&*!'2&5!82,9'(-A!

T$- :'('/59#!9;215)H81);2(!

B2(!%,&*! '2(1-('&8,.! ,*)! 9-,8'&8,.! 81*'-&$#'&1*! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82! &5! &*! '(-%5! 10!

9-(5(*'&*7! ,! *(S! 9-18(55! '2,'! (%$-,8(5! ,! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,99-1,82! B2(!

9-18(55! &5! $#&.'! #91*! &*'(7-,'&*7! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! $(5'! 9-,8'&8(5! ,*)!

81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! %('21)5A! V'! 9-1%1'(5! K*1S.()7(! 0.1S! )1S*! ,*)!

52,-&*7!$:!%,*,7&*7!5',K(21.)(-5!(`9(8','&1*5!'2-1#721#'!'2(!82,*7(!.&0(8:8.(;!

S2(*!9.,**&*7!,*)!)(.&E(-&*7!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-17-,%%(5!1-!9-1^(8'5A!

Page 226: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?@!

B2(!-(5#.'! &5!,!81..,$1-,'&E(!9-18(55! '2,'! &5! &*01-%()!$:!9-,8'&8(!,*)! .&'(-,'#-(!

,*)! 8,*! 2(.9! '215(! &*E1.E()! &*! )&00(-(*'! -1.(5! '1! &)(*'&0:! ,*)!%,*,7(! $(*(0&'5!

,*)!)&5$(*(0&'5!'2-1#721#'!'2(!.&0(!10!,!9-17-,%%(!1-!9-1^(8'A!

Q-#8&,..:! C(3(,.! S,5! -(817*&5()! $:! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! &*! '2(! 8,5(! 5'#)&(5! ,*)! '2(!

,8,)(%&85! ,*)! &*)#5'-&,.! 9,-'&8&9,*'5! 10! '2(! ,)E&51-:! 7-1#9! ,5! ,! ):*,%&8!

9-18(55;! 0,8&.&','&*7! ,)^#5'%(*'5! '1! 9.,*5! &*! '2(! .&72'! 10! (`9(-&(*8(! 7,&*()! ,*)!

82,*7(5! &*! '2(!(`'(-*,.!1-! &*'(-*,.!(*E&-1*%(*'!51! '2,'! '2(!$(*(0&'5!,&%()! 01-;!

2,E(!,!$(''(-!82,*8(!10!$(&*7!,82&(E()!,*)!,*!&*8-(,5()!9-()&8',$&.&':!10!$(&*7!

-(,.&5()A!

T$P >':'/0!2;<'0!9;215)H81);2(!)2!5'0/1);2!1;!1#'!./46:64![5;Q'91!

B2(!9.,8(%(*'!10!'2(!,#'21-!S&'2&*!'2(![(,.'2!Q,-(!V*0-,5'-#8'#-(!3(5(,-82!,*)!

V**1E,'&1*! Q(*'-(! 2,5! 915&'&1*()! '2&5! -(5(,-82! ,'! '2(! 01-(0-1*'! 10! '2(! 8(*'-(L5!

,8,)(%&8! -(5(,-82! 91-'01.&1! ,5! '2(! [,QV3VQ! (`(8#'&E(! $1,-)! 81*5&)(-()! &'! ,!

9-&%(! 81*'-&$#'&1*! '1! '2(! c-322+')$#A! 0&E$($+#!D.?$#A! $#! Q&./)6E.'&>! -(5(,-82!

'2(%(A!B2&5!0#-'2(-!-(&*01-8(5!'2(!E,.&)&':!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82A!B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!

&'! S,5! )(E(.19()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! ,*)! 9-(5(*'()! &*! '2(5&5! 2,5! 81*'-&$#'()! '1!

[,QV3VQL5! (*7,7(%(*'! S&'2! 1'2(-! -(5(,-82! 8(*'-(5;! ,8,)(%&8! &*5'&'#'&1*5! ,*)!

&*)#5'-:! 9,-'*(-5A! B2(:! ,..! 2,E(! -(817*&5()! &'5! 81*'-&$#'&1*5! ,*)! 8-(,'()!

,E(*#(5!01-!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55;!'11.5!,*)!'(82*&4#(5!(`9.1&'()!,*)!%('21)1.17:!

#5()!01-!&'5!)(E(.19%(*'!'1!$(!)(9.1:()!,5!01..1S5W!!

• B2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10! ,*! VB!9.,'01-%! '1! 0,8&.&','(! '2(! &%9.(%(*','&1*!,*)!

,)19'&1*!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*!81..,$1-,'&1*!S&'2!VB!,8,)(%&8!(`9(-'5!

,*)!-(5(,-82!5'#)(*'5!,'!'2(!P*&E(-5&':!10!",.01-)!I5((!<99(*)&`!XJA!B2(!

VB!9.,'01-%!.&*K5!'2(!9-18(55!5'(95!,*)!1#'81%(5!&*!,*!19(*!9#$.&8!,88(55!

S($5&'(! ,*)! ,! K*1S.()7(! ),',$,5(! '2,'! (*8,95#.,'(5! $1'2! 7(*(-,.! ,*)!

9-1^(8'!59(8&0&8!&*01-%,'&1*q!

• B2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,! C(*(0&'5! f#,*'&0&8,'&1*! T('21)! '1! &*01-%! '2(!

92,5(5!10! '2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!9-1%9'();! &*!81..,$1-,'&1*!S&'2![(--&1'!

_,''!P*&E(-5&':q!

Page 227: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?N!

• B2(!#5(!10!C(3(,.!&*!7(*(-,'&*7!(E&)(*8(!S2(*!)(5&7*&*7!U+!9-,8'&8(5!'1!

19'&%&5(!0.(`&$&.&':!,*)!82,*7(,$&.&':!&*!81%%&55&1*&*7!5(-E&8(5A!<!9-1^(8'!

&*! 81..,$1-,'&1*! S&'2! '2(! V%,7&*,'&1*! 3(5(,-82! Q(*'-(! ,'! b,*8,5'(-!

P*&E(-5&':q!

• B2(!9&.1'&*7!10!'2(!0&*,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!S&'2&*!'2(!6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!

&*!VB;!5(-E&8(!-(81*0&7#-,'&1*!,*)!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!-()(E(.19%(*'!9-1^(8'5q!

• B2(! 81*5&)(-,'&1*!10! '2(!C(3(,.! 9-18(55! '1!$(!#5()! &*! 81*^#*8'&1*!S&'2!

cC#&.)&*7!C(''(-!Q,5(5L!'-,&*&*7!9-17-,%!01-!9#$.&8!5(8'1-!%,*,7(-5!$:!'2(!

Q,9&',.!&*E(5'%(*'!#*&'!10!'2(!_(.52!<55(%$.:!U1E(-*%(*'q!,*)!

• B2(!)&55(%&*,'&1*!10!'2(!K*1S.()7(!7(*(-,'()!)#-&*7!'2(!C(3(,.!9-1^(8'!

'2-1#72;! I&J! '2(! 81*'-&$#'&1*! '1! '2(! -(E&5&1*! 10! '2(!T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.!

+-17-,%%(5;!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!7#&),*8(!,*)!I&&J!'2(!&*8.#5&1*!10!'2(!

C(3(,.!9-18(55!'1!'-,&*&*7!%,'(-&,.!S&'2&*!'2(!U,'(S,:!-(E&(S(-5!01-#%A!

T$N :'('/59#!@'1#;3;0;AB!/23!</0)3)1B!

<5! )(58-&$()! &*! 82,9'(-! '2-((! '2(! ,#'21-! ,)19'()! ,! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82!

%('21)1.17:!Id,5,*(*!('!,.A;!?FF@;!b#KK,;!=>>@;!X,&52*,E&!,*)!d#(82.(-;!=>>NJ!

01-! '2&5! &*E(5'&7,'&1*A!B2(!#*)(-.&*&*7! -(5(,-82!92&.15192:!S,5! '2,'! 10! '2(!9-(!

#*)(-5',*)&*7! Z! #*)(-5',*)&*7! IG)%,*;! ?FFO! &*! d,7&17.1#;! =>>>JA! B2(! %,&*!

%(82,*&5%! 01-!%1E&*7! '2(!,#'21-L5!K*1S.()7(! 0-1%!,!9-(\#*)(-5',*)&*7!5','(!

&*'1!,*!#*)(-5',*)&*7!1*(!S,5!'2(!9,-'&8&9,'&1*!10!'2(!,#'21-! &*!%(('&*75;!,*)!

7(*(-,.!)&58#55&1*!S&'2!'2(!9,-'&8&9,*'5!&*!'2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!5(E(*!

,)E&51-:!7-1#9!S1-K52195!,5!S(..!,5!'2(!,*,.:5&5!10!'2(!),',!7,'2(-()!&*!'2(!0&(.)!

-(5(,-82A!

!<5!'2(!%,&*!,&%!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!S,5!'1!&*E(5'&7,'(!$(5'!9-,8'&8(5!,*)!)(E(.19!,!

-1$#5'! 9-18(55! 01-! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! I'2(! ,-'(0,8'J! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82!

5(4#(*8(!10W!+-1$.(%!,S,-(*(55!"!"#77(5'&1*!10!,!51.#'&1*!"!6(E(.19%(*'!"!

HE,.#,'&1*"! Q1*8.#5&1*;! 2(.9()! '1! ,881%9.&52! '2&5! ,&%A! B2(! ,#'21-L5! .(,-*&*7!

,*)!#*)(-5',*)&*7!S,5!#5()!'1!&*01-%!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&*!

&'5!E,-&1#5!5',7(5A!!

Page 228: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?O!

B2(! -(5(,-82! %('21)1.17:! )(9.1:()! 2,5! 9-1E()! '1! $(! 5#88(550#.! &*! '(-%5! 10!

,82&(E&*7!'2(!)(E(.19%(*'!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55A!B2(!%('21)5!81*'-&$#'()!&*'1!

&)(*'&0:&*7!S&'2&*!'2(!.&'(-,'#-(!'2(!$(5'!,99-1,82(5!,*)!'2&*K&*7!&*!'2(!$(*(0&'5!

-(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'! ,-(,! ,*)! &)(*'&0:! K*1S.()7(! 7,95A! B2(! ,#'21-!

&)(*'&0&()!'2(!-(.,'&1*52&9!$('S((*!'2(5(!'S1!018#5!,-(,5!,*)!1'2(-!%,*,7(%(*'!

)&58&9.&*(5! 5#82! ,5!9-1^(8'! ,*)!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*'q! 82,*7(!%,*,7(%(*'q!

9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! %(,5#-(%(*'q! (E,.#,'&1*! ,*)! 5',K(21.)(-!

%,*,7(%(*'A! T1E&*7! 01-%! '2(! c9-1$.(%! ,S,-(*(55L! '1! '2(! c5#77(5'&1*! 10! ,!

51.#'&1*L! 0#-'2(-! .&'(-,'#-(! -(E&(S! ,*)! &*'(-,8'&1*! S&'2! &*)#5'-:! (`9(-'5! '11K!

9.,8(!'1! &)(*'&0:! '2(!%,&*!(.(%(*'5!I$:!5:*'2(5&5&*7!1'2(-!%1)(.!(.(%(*'5!,*)!

&)(*'&0:&*7!7,95!&*!9-,8'&8(J!10!'2(!81*8(9'#,.!,-'(0,8'!51!'1!#*)(-5',*)!,*)!,.&7*!

'2(! 9-18(55! S&'2! '2(! %,&*! Pd! 2(,.'28,-(! 5(8'1-! &*E(5'%(*'! ,99-,&5,.! ,*)!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,99-1,82(5A! B2(5(! 5'(95! 2,E(! .()! '1! '2(!

)(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! '2(! 0&-5'! &*'(-9-(','&1*! 10! ,! c5#77(5'()! 51.#'&1*Lq! '2(! 0&-5'!

81*8(9'#,.!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,5!9-(5(*'()!&*!5(8'&1*!=A=>A!!

B2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,5!'2(:!S(-(!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!01#-!,*)!)&58#55()!&*!

82,9'(-! 0&E(! (*8,95#.,'()! '2(! )(E(.19%(*'! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! 5'(95! 10! '2(!

81*5'-#8'&E(!-(5(,-82!8:8.(A!<.'21#72!'2(!5&7*&0&8,*'!),',!'2,'!S,5!81..(8'()!,*)!

,*,.:5()!0-1%!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!81*'-&$#'()!'1S,-)5!)(E(.19&*7!'2(!0&*,.!,-'(0,8';!

'2(! '&%(! 81*5'-,&*'! 10! '2(!9(-&1)! '2,'! 2(,.'28,-(!9-1^(8'5! ',K(! '1! 81%9.('(! I,5!

(`9.,&*()! &*! 5(8'&1*! =A=?J! .&%&'()! '2(! '(5'&*7! ,*)! E,.&),'&1*! 10! '2(! 0#..! C(3(,.!

9-18(55!,*)! &'5!-(81%%(*)()!'11.5!,*)! '(82*&4#(5A!B2(!S&)(-! &%9.(%(*','&1*!

10! '2(! 9-18(55! ,*)! &*! 9,-'&8#.,-! '2(! +,'2S,:! 92,5(! 01-%5! 9,-'! 10! '2(!

-(81%%(*),'&1*!01-!0#-'2(-!S1-KA!!

B2(!#5(!10!,!E,-&(':!10!4#,.&','&E(!%('21)5!S&'2&*!'2&5!-(5(,-82!'2,'! &*E1.E(5!,!

81*5&)(-,$.(!,%1#*'!10!E,-&,$.(5!,*)!&*'(-9-(','&1*5!10!92(*1%(*,!9-1%9'5!'2(!

4#(5'&1*!10!E,.&)&':;!,5!&'!&5!#5#,..:!'2(!8,5(!S&'2!5#82!,!-(5(,-82!,99-1,82A!A!B2(!

E,.&)&':!10!,!-(5(,-82!8,*!$(!)&E&)()!&*!'2-((!9155&$.(!81*8(-*5!,881-)&*7!'1!g&*!

I=>>@J! &*! [(*-&82! I=>>FJq! V*'(-*,.! E,.&)&':;! (`'(-*,.! E,.&)&':! ,*)! 81*5'-#8'!

E,.&)&':A!

Page 229: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?R!

V*'(-*,.! E,.&)&':! &5! -(.(E,*'! '1! (`9.1-,'1-:! ,*)! (`9(-&%(*',.! 5'#)&(5! S(-(! '2(!

9-110!10!,!81*8(9';!81*8.#5&1*!1-!2:91'2(5(5! &5!-(4#&-()A!B2&5!S,5!*1'! '2(!8,5(!

01-!'2&5!-(5(,-82!51!5#82!E,.&)&':!&5!*1'!*(()()A!!

H`'(-*,.! E,.&)&':! &5! -(.,'()! &*! 7(*(-,.&5&*7! -(5(,-82! 0&*)&*75! ,*)! '2(! ),',!

,84#&-()!'2-1#72!8,5(5!5'#)&(5!5#$5',*'&,'()!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&%9.(%(*','&1*!

,*)!#5(0#.*(55A!B2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!9-(5(*'()!&*!82,9'(-!01#-!S(-(!81*)#8'()!

&*! '2(! Pd! 2(,.'28,-(! 5(8'1-! S&'2&*! S(..\(5',$.&52()! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5! S2(-(! '2(!

9-1^(8'5!#*)(-!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!S(-(!#*)(-!)&00(-(*'!)(E(.19%(*'!5',7(5A!B2(!'2-((!

8,5(!5'#)&(5!,.51!2,)!1'2(-!)&00(-(*'&,'&1*!82,-,8'(-&5'&85! !I)&58#55()!&*!5(8'&1*!

NA@J;!5#82!,5!&*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!%('21);!.(E(.!10!2(,.'28,-(!5(-E&8(!9-1E&)();!

5&e(! 10! '2(! &*E(5'%(*'! ('8A;! 7&E&*7! ,! S(..\)(0&*()! 91-'-,:,.! 10! '2(! 2(,.'28,-(!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!5(8'1-A!<5!5#82!'2(!1#'81%(5!10!'2(!-(5(,-82!8,*!$(!81*5&)(-()!,5!

-(9-(5(*','&E(!(`,%9.(5!10!2(,.'28,-(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(!9-1^(8'5A! !<.51!'2-1#721#'!

'2(! -(5(,-82! ,! *#%$(-! 10! -(5(,-82!%('21)5! I&*'-1)#8()! &*! 82,9'(-! '2-((! ,*)!

)(%1*5'-,'()! &*! '2(! 5(8'&1*! NA@J! 5#82! ,5;!S1-K52195! ,*)! 4#(5'&1**,&-(5!S(-(!

#5()!'1!7,'2(-!),',A!B2(!,*,.:5&5!10!0&*)&*75!0-1%!,!*#%$(-!10!-(5(,-82!%('21)5!

(*,$.()!'2(!'-&,*7#.,'&1*!9-18(55;!S2&82!-()#8()!'2(!$&,5!10!'2(!4#,.&','&E(!),',!

81..(8'()! Ig&*;!=>>@JA! !B2(!,))&'&1*,.! 0,8'1-!10! '2(!#5(!10! '2(! c!<)E&51-:!7-1#9L!

S1-K52195! ,*)! )&58#55&1*5! I5((! 5(8'&1*! NANJ! ,5! ,! E,.&),'&1*!%(82,*&5%! 10! '2(!

8,5(! 5'#):! 1#'9#'5! ,5! '2(:! S(-(! #*)(-5'11)! ,*)! &*'(-9-('()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-;!

)(%1*5'-,'(5! '2,'! '2(! 81*8.#5&1*5! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82! &5! *1'! ,! 59(8#.,'&E(!

,55#%9'&1*!$#'!'2(!1#'81%(!10!,!%('21)1.17&8,..:!9.,*()!,*)!)&-(8'!&*'(-,8'&1*!

S&'2!&*)#5'-:!(`9(-'5!,*)!,8,)(%&85!'2,'!'2(!c,)E&51-:!7-1#9L!81*5&5'()!10A!!

B2(!),',!81..(8'&1*!%('21)5!#5()!&*!'2(!8,5(!5'#)&(5!,*)!'2(!8,5(!5'#):!)(5&7*!

)(9.1:()! $:! '2(! ,#'21-! &5! ,.51! -(7,-)()! ,5! ,! 5:5'(%,'&8! ,99-1,82! '2,'! 8,*! $(!

-(9.&8,'()! ,*)! ,99.&()! &*! 1'2(-! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! )(E(.19%(*'! 5(8'1-5! 5#82! ,5!

()#8,'&1*;!21#5&*7!1-!(E(*!5(-E&8(5!-()(5&7*!,*)!9-1E&5&1*A!!

g&*!I=>>@J!5'-(55(5!'2,'!'2(-(!,-(!'2-((!),',!81..(8'&1*!9-&*8&9.(5!'2,'!0,8&.&','(!

'2(!(5',$.&52%(*'!10!81*5'-#8'!E,.&)&':!I'2(!'2&-)!':9(!10!E,.&)&':!)&58#55()!2(-(J!

10!,!8,5(!5'#):!S(-(!,55#-,*8(!10!(E(-:'2&*7!'2,'!521#.)!$(!4#,*'&0&()!&5!-(,..:!

%(,5#-()A! ! B2(5(! '2-((! 9-&*8&9.(5! ,-(W! P5(! 10! %#.'&9.(! 51#-8(5! 10! (E&)(*8(q!

Page 230: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?M!

8-(,'&1*! 10! ,! 8,5(! 5'#):! ),',$,5(q! ,*)! 0&*,..:! '2(! %,&*'(*,*8(! 10! ,! 82,&*! 10!

(E&)(*8(A!!B2(!'2-((!8,5(!5'#)&(5!9-(5(*'()!,*)!)&58#55()!&*!'2&5!'2(5&5!(E&)(*8(!

'2(! -(5#.'5! 10! '2&5! -(5(,-82q! ,..! ),',! 81..(8'&1*! S,5! 8,9'#-()! &*! &*)&E&)#,.!

5',*),-)&5()! 59-(,)! 52(('5;! ,*)! '2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! 8:8.(! 0,8&.&','()! '2(!

82,&*!10!(E&)(*8(!,*)!81*'-&$#'()!'2(!-(5(,-82!-(,82&*7!&'5!81*8.#5&1*5A!

B2(!E,.&)&':!10!'2(!%,&*!,-'(0,8'q!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!&'5(.0!S,5!)&58#55()!,'!'2(!

(*)!10!82,9'(-!OA!

T$T :'9;@@'23/1);2(!7;5!7851#'5!5'('/59#!

B2(!0&*,.!1$^(8'&E(!10!'2&5!-(5(,-82!S,5!'1W!

• <R&E+DD&#0!,3')6&'!@+'?!C.(&0!+#!)6&!+3)E+D&(!+,!)6$(!'&(&.'E6>!

3(81%%(*),'&1*!01-!0#-'2(-!S1-K!8,*!$(!)&E&)()!&*!'S1!':9(5W!!0&-5'.:!-(5(,-82!

'2,'!*(()5!'1!$(!)1*(!'1!0#-'2(-!&*01-%!,*)!E,.&),'(!'2(!9-18(55!5'(95;!'11.5!,*)!

'(82*&4#(5;!,*)!5(81*).:!S1-K!'2,'!S&..!&*E1.E(!'2(!S&)(-!#5(!10!'2(!9-18(55A!

V*!,))-(55&*7!'2(!0&-5'!8,'(71-:!,*)!,5!)&58#55()!&*!'2(!9-(E&1#5!5(8'&1*5!10!'2&5!

'2(5&5!'2(!,#'21-!-(817*&5(5!'2,'!'2(-(!,-(!5'(95!S&'2&*!'2(!9-18(55!'2,'!,-(!*1'!

0#..:! E,.&),'()! $:! '2(! -(5(,-82! 9-(5(*'()! 2(-(A! "#82! (.(%(*'5! '2,'! '2(! ,#'21-!

81*5&)(-5!8-&'&8,.!01-!'2(!19'&%&5,'&1*!10!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!,*)!0#-'2(-!S1-K!&5!

-(81%%(*)()!,-(W!!

• B2(! &*E(5'&7,'&1*! 10! 21S! '2(! 5.)6@.*!26.(&! S&..! $(! &*! 19(-,'&1*!S2(*!

&%9.(%(*'()! S&'2&*! '2(! 5,%(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! '2,'! 2,5! 01..1S()! '2(!

9-(58-&$()! 9-(E&1#5! 92,5(5! 10! C(3(,.A! B2(! ,5518&,'&1*! 10! $(*(0&'5;!

-(51#-8(5! ,*)! ,8'&E&'&(5! ,5! ,! )-&E(-! 01-! '2&5! 92,5(! &5! 51%('2&*7! '2,'! &5!

81*5&)(-()! c*&82(L! S2(*! 9-1^(8'! 9.,*5! ,-(! &%9.(%(*'()! ,*)! &'5! 0#-'2(-!

&*E(5'&7,'&1*! S2(*! 19(-,'&1*,.&5()! S&..! 9-1E&)(! #5(0#.! 81*'-&$#'&1*5!

'1S,-)5! ,! $(''(-! ,.&7*%(*'! 10! '2(! 9-18(55! 5'(95! -(81%%(*)()! &*! '2&5!

'2(5&5q!

• "&%&.,-.:!'2(!0#..!&*E(5'&7,'&1*!&*'1!'2(!<55(55%(*'!92,5(!,5!,!5(4#(*8(!10!

'2(!,$1E(!&5!,.51!-(81%%(*)()q!

Page 231: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?D!

• P5(! 10! '2(! Y&R&./! =D2/&D&#).)$+#! 5/.#! ,5! '2(! 19(-,'&1*,.! $-&(0! ,*)!

%,*#,.! )#-&*7! 19(-,'&1*5A! B2(! ,#'21-! -(81%%(*)5! '2,'! '2(!

)18#%(*','&1*! ,*)! &*! 9,-'&8#.,-! '2(! C(3(,.! +.,*! 521#.)! ,8'! ,5! '2(!

19(-,'&1*5! %,*#,.! S2(*! '2(! &*0-,5'-#8'#-(! 1-! '2(! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(! &5!

188#9&()!1-!$(81%(!0#..:!0#*8'&1*,.A!B2&5!S&..!(*5#-(!'2(!81*'&*#,'&1*!10!

K*1S.()7(! ,84#&-()! 0-1%! '2(! )(.&E(-:! ,*)! )(E(.19%(*'! '(,%! 1*'1! '2(!

19(-,'&1*5!'(,%A!V'!S&..!$(!&*'(-(5'&*7!'1!(`9.1-(!21S!5#82!K*1S.()7(!S&..!

$(!52,-()!,*)!0.1S!,*)!'1!S2,'!(`'(*'!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!81*'-&$#'(5!'1!

'2,'q!

• <!$(*(0&'5!c8#--(*8:L!-(%,&*5!,!'19&8!'2,'!5'&..!-(4#&-(5!0#-'2(-!-(5(,-82A!V'!

S,5!*1'! ,! '19&8! '2,'!S,5!)&-(8'.:! ,))-(55()! '2-1#72! '2&5! '2(5&5;! $#'! '2(!

,#'21-! 2,E&*7! (*2,*8()! 2&5! K*1S.()7(! ,*)! (`9(-&(*8(! &*! '2&5! ,-(,!

$(.&(E(5! '2,'! &0! ,! 81%%1*! c$(*(0&'! 8#--(*8:L! '2,'! -(0.(8'5! ,*)! 81%$&*(5!

5',K(21.)(-5!9(-8(9'&1*5!10!'2(!S1-'2!10!,!$(*(0&'!&5!#5();!&'!S&..!0,8&.&','(!

'2(! 5%11'2(-! 0.1S! )1S*! 10! )(8&5&1*5! %,)(! ,*)! '2(! ^#5'&0&8,'&1*! 10! ,*!

&*E(5'%(*'q!

• B2(!0#..!,)19'&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55!,5!9,-'!10!(E(-:),:!$#5&*(55!,*)!*1'!,5!

,*!,))&'&1*,.!19(-,'&1*A!B2&5!'2(5&5!9-(5(*'()!,*)!)&58#55()!'2(!0&*)&*75!

10! '2(!-(5(,-82!,5! &'!S,5!9.,**()! &*!5*,9521'5!S2(*!,99.&()! &*! '2(!8,5(!

5'#)&(5!#*)(-!,!81*'-1..()!(*E&-1*%(*'A!B2(!,#'21-!$(.&(E(5!'2,'!'2(!0#..!

&%9.(%(*','&1*! 10! '2(! 9-18(55! $:! ,! 5&*7.(! 1-7,*&5,'&1*! &*! ,! 91-'01.&1! 10!

9-1^(8'5!S&..!)(%1*5'-,'(!'2(!)(7-((!'1!S2&82!'2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!8,*!$(!

,.&7*()! S&'2! ),:! '1! ),:! 19(-,'&1*5! ,*)! 81*'-&$#'(! '1S,-)5! 9-1^(8'!

5#88(55q!,*)!

• /&*,..:! '2(! 0#..! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! '(%9.,'(5! a)18#%(*'5! ,*)! &*'(7-,'&1*!

S&'2!,*!VB!9.,'01-%!'1!(*,$.(!'2(!81%%#*&8,'&1*!10!'2(!9-18(55!5'(95!01-!

$1'2!'-,&*&*7!,*)!,99.&8,'&1*!9#-915(5!&5!-(81%%(*)()A!!

B2(!C(3(,.!9-18(55!2,5!$((*!'(5'()!(`8.#5&E(.:!&*!'2(!2(,.'28,-(!&*0-,5'-#8'#-(!

)(E(.19%(*'! 5(8'1-;! '2(-(01-(! &'5! S&)(-! ,99.&8,$&.&':! 8,**1'! $(! 8.,&%();! '2(!

$(.&(0!10!'2(!,#'21-!,*)!'215(!9,-'&8&9,'()!&*!'2&5!-(5(,-82!&5!'2,'!C(3(,.!&5!0#..:!

-(.(E,*'!,*)!58,.,$.(!&*!,..!5(8'1-5!'2,'!(*7,7(!&*!9-1^(8'5!'2,'!,&%!'1!&*'-1)#8(!

82,*7(! I,5! (`,%9.(5! '2&5! 8,*! $(! 5(8'1-5! 5#82! ,5! ()#8,'&1*;! 21#5&*7! ,*)!

Page 232: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

Q2,9'(-!"&`Z!Q1*8.#5&1*5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =?F!

-(7(*(-,'&1*JA! "#82! ,*! &%9.(%(*','&1*! ,*)! ,),9'&1*! 10! '2(! C(3(,.! 9-18(55!

*(()5!'1!$(!0#-'2(-!(`9.1-()A!!

Page 233: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==>!

O :'7'5'29'(!

<K,1;! gA! I?FFMJA! Åf/6W! 9,5';! 9-(5(*';! ,*)! 0#'#-(Å! V*! +-18(()&*75! 10! '2(! @-)!

<**#,.! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! ":%915&#%! 1*! f/6! If/6LFMJ! ÇG*.&*(ÉA! 3('-&(E()!

>Fa>Ma>F!0-1%!2''9WaaSSSA40)&A1-7af/6}[&5'1-:A9)0A!

<52#-5';!QA!r!612(-':;!]A!/A!I=>>@JA!B1S,-)5!'2(!01-%#.,'&1*!10!c,!$(5'!9-,8'&8(L!

0-,%(S1-K! 01-! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! &*! VB! 9-1^(8'5A! H.(8'-1*&8! h1#-*,.! 10!

V*01-%,'&1*!":5'(%5!HE,.#,'&1*;!R;!?\?>A!

<'K&*51*! 3Aq! Q-,S01-)! bA! <*)! _,-);! "A! I=>>RJA! /#*),%(*',.! #*8(-',&*'&(5! &*!

9-1^(8'5! ,*)! '2(! 5819(! 10! 9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*';! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.! 10!

+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!EA!=N;!RDMZRFDA!

<P6H!I=>>RJA!U#&)(!'1!+15'!G88#9,*8:!HE,.#,'&1*!3(91-'!,*)!'11.K&';!9#$.&52()!

$:!'2(!<5518&,'&1*!10!P*&E(-5&':!6&-(8'1-5!,*)!H5','(5!!,*)!'2(!P*&E(-5&':!

10!_(5'%&*5'(-!S&'2!5#991-'!0-1%!'2(![&72(-!H)#8,'&1*!/#*)&*7!Q1#*8&.!

01-!H*7.,*)!!I[H/QHJA!

<:#51;!"A;!31)-&7#(e;!TA;!<A!r!3&8,-';!hA;!HA!I=>>RJA!P5&*7!5',K(21.)(-!)&,.17#(!,5!,!

51#-8(! 01-! *(S! &)(,5W! ,! ):*,%&8! 8,9,$&.&':! #*)(-.:&*7! 5#5',&*,$.(!

&**1E,'&1*A!Q1-91-,'(!U1E(-*,*8(;!R;!NMO\NF>A!

C,..,-);! UA! I=>>DJA! B2(! .(,*! 9-1^(8'! )(.&E(-:! 5:5'(%W! <*! #9),'(A! b(,*!

Q1*5'-#8'&1*!h1#-*,.;!=>>D;!?\?FA!

C,**&5'(-;!/A;!T88,$(;!+A!r!3(%(*:&;!6A!I=>>?JA![1S!%#82!)&)!S(!-(,..:!9,:!01-!

'2,'t! B2(! ,SKS,-)! 9-1$.(%! 10! &*01-%,'&1*! '(82*1.17:! 815'5A! B2(!

H.(8'-1*&8!h1#-*,.!10!V*01-%,'&1*!":5'(%5!HE,.#,'&1*;!O;!?\??A!

C,-'21.1%(S;!6A!I?FFFJA!+-18(55!&5!$,8K;!Q.(,E.,*);!V*)#5'-:!_((KA!

C,-'.('';!hA!I=>>RJA!T,*,7&*7!9-17-,%%(5!10!$#5&*(55!82,*7(;![,%952&-(;!PdA!

C,#%,*;! zA;! I?FMDJA! u[(-%(*(#'&85! ,*)! 518&,.! 58&(*8(W! ,99-1,82(5! '1!

#*)(-5',*)&*7v;![#'82&*51*!10!b1*)1*A!

Page 234: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==?!

C(**&*7'1*;!+A!r!C,88,-&*&;!6A!I=>>NJA!+-1^(8'!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'!&*!VB!9-1^(8'5!

Z!<*!<#5'-,.&,*!9(-59(8'&E(A!+-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'!^1#-*,.A!

C&*.(:L5! I=>>DJA! PQ-! T3$0&;! "#%%(-\<#'#%*! H)&'&1*;! C((82S11)! [1#5(!

9#$.&52&*7;!V""]!?MN=\MF?RA!

C.,&K&(;!]A;!I?FF@JA!u<99-1,82(5!'1!518&,.!(*4#&-:vA!+1.&8:!+-(55A!

C-,).(:;! UA! I=>>RJA! C(*(0&'! 3(,.&5,'&1*! T,*,7(%(*'! Z! <! +-,8'&8,.! 7#&)(! '1!

,82&(E&*7!$(*(0&'5!'2-1#72!82,*7(;![,%952&-(;!Pd;!U1S(-A!

C#5&;!TA!r!C&'&'8&;!PA;!"A!I=>>RJA!Q1..,$1-,'&E(!9(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'W!9-(5(*'!

7,95! r! 0#'#-(! -(5(,-82A! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.! 10! +-1)#8'&E&':! r!

+(-01-%,*8(!T,*,7(%(*';!M\=OA!

Q<CH! I=>>OJA! B2(! &%9,8'5! 10! 100&8(! )(5&7*! 1*! $#5&*(55! 9(-01-%,*8(A! B2(!

Q1%%&55&1*! 01-! <-82&'(8'#-(! ,*)! '2(! C#&.'! H*E&-1*%(*';! ,E,&.,$.(! ,'W!

SSSA8,$(A1-7A#KA!

Q<CH! I=>>DJA! <55(55&*7! )(5&7*! 4#,.&':! &*! bV/B! 9-&%,-:! 8,-(! $#&.)&*75A! B2(!

Q1%%&55&1*! 01-! <-82&'(8'#-(! ,*)! '2(! C#&.'! H*E&-1*%(*';! ,E,&.,$.(! ,'W!

SSSA8,$(A1-7A#KA!

Q,.E(-';! "A! I?FFOJA! T,*,7&*7! 5',K(21.)(-5W! B2(! 81%%(-8&,.! 9-1^(8'! %,*,7(-;!

T8U-,S![&..A!

Q,--1..;! <A;! CA! r! C#8221.'e;! <A;! dA! I=>>RJA! C#5&*(55! ,*)! 518&(':W! H'2&85! ,*)!

5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*';!"1#'2!_(5'(-;!B21%51*A!

Q,--#'2(-5;! hA;! <52&..;! ]A;! hA! ! r! 31);! TA! I=>>RJA! T,99&*7! ,*)! ,55(55&*7! '2(! K(:!

%,*,7(%(*'!&55#(5!&*0.#(*8&*7!Pd!9#$.&8!2(,.'28,-(!9#-82,5(-\9-1E&)(-!

8119(-,'&1*A!f#,.&','&E(!T,-K('!3(5(,-82W!<*!&*'(-*,'&1*,.!^1#-*,.A!

Q,-'.&)7(;!6A!I=>>RJA!+#$.&8!9-&E,'(!9,-'*(-52&95!&*!81*5'-#8'&1*A!31#'.()7(A!

Q,#)-1*;! "A! I?FF@JA! h#5'! (`,8'.:! S2,'! &5! '1',.! 4#,.&':! %,*,7(%(*'t! +(-51**(.!

h1#-*,.;!M=;!@=A!

QQB<!I?FFFJA!T,*,7&*7!"#88(50#..!+-17-,%%(5;!B2(!"','&1*(-:!G00&8(A!

QQB<!I=>>>J!Q(*'-,.!Q1%9#'(-!,*)!B(..(81%%#*&8,'&1*5!<7(*8:!\!T,*,7&*7!'2(!

$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!<*'&)1'(!=M;!=D\=FA!

Page 235: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ===!

Q2&71';!+A!I=>>OJA!H00(8'5!10!51#*)!&*!100&8(5W!5#$^(8'&E(!(`9(-&(*8(!E5A!1$^(8'&E(!

,55(55%(*'A!/,8&.&'&(5;!=@;!?O=!\!?R@A!

Q2-&5'100(-5(*;! <A! dA;! r! H%%&'';! "A! I=>>FJA! Q,5(! "'#):! <! H`9.1-&*7! '2(! X,.#(!

P*&E(-5(W! <! X,.#(5 C,5()! <99-1,82! '1! 6(5&7*! T,*,7(%(*'A!

<-82&'(8'#-,.!T,*,7(%(*'W!V*'(-*,'&1*,.!3(5(,-82!,*)!+-,8'&8(;!@N\O=A!

Q1)&*21'1;!3A!<*)!+,55%,*;!6A! I=>>FJA!f8(!-3((&N!Q+(2$)./!1!b2)$+#$#A!U&&)$#A;!

&*'(-*,.!9-18(55!-(91-';!F'2!/($-#,-:!=>>F!

Q12(*;! TA;! zA;! d,2*;! 6A;! bA! r! "'((E(5;! 3A;! [A! I=>>>JA! u[(-%(*(#'&8!

+2(*1%(*1.17&8,.!-(5(,-82W!,!9-,8'&8,.!7#&)(!01-!*#-5(!-(5(,-82(-5vA!",7(!

9#$.&8,'&1*5A!

Q12(*;! 3A;! "',*)(E(*;! TA;! C1-),55;! CA! r! b(,%,*;! <A! I=>>>JA! <55(55&*7! $#&.)&*7!

9(-01-%,*8(! &*! #5(! ?W! '2(! +3GCH! 9-18(55A! C#&.)&*7! 3(5(,-82! r!

V*01-%,'&1*!,*)!T,*,7(%(*';!=F;!DO\?>=A!

Q12(*;! bA;! <*)! T,**&1*;! bA;! I?FFNJ;! c3(5(,-82! T('21)5! &*! H)#8,'&1*LA! /1#-'2!

()&'&1*;!31#'.()7(;!PdA!

Q63<! Q1%%#*&':! 6(E(.19%(*'! 3(51#-8(! <5518&,'&1*;! I=>??JA! T(,5#-&*7!

6(E(.19%(*'W![1.)&*7! V*0&*&':A! <**#,.! -(91-';! =>>>a=>>?A! 3('-&(E()! 1*!

?=a??a>D!0-1%W!2''9WaaSSSA8)-,A1-7Ae,aA!

Q1..:(-;!TA!I=>>OJA!<55(55&*7!(00&8,8:!10!9-(58-&$()!)(5&7*!8-&'(-&,!'2-1#72!915'!

188#9,*8:! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! (*)! #5(-! 5,'&50,8'&1*W! 8,5(! 5'#):! 10! 5#-(! 5',-'!

.18,.!9-17-,%%(!8(*'-(5A!+.:*1#'2;!P*&E(-5&':!10!+.:%1#'2A!!

Q11K(\6,E&(5;! BA! I=>>=JA! B2(! y-(,.! 5#88(55! 0,8'1-5! 1*! 9-1^(8'5A! V*'(-*,'&1*,.!

h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!=>;!?DO\?F>A!

Q#)*(:;!HA!<A!I=>>FJA!P5&*7![152&*!d,*-&!'1!V%9-1E(!'2(!X,.#(!"'-(,%;!B,:.1-!r!

/-,*8&5;!?R>99A!

Q:(-';!3A!TA;!r!T,-82;! hA! UA! I?FR@JA!<!$(2,E&1-,.! '2(1-:!10! '2(! 0&-%A!H*7.(S11)!

Q.&005;!]h;!=A!

6(9,-'%(*'! 10! [(,.'2! I=>>DJ;! cQ2,*7&*7! /1-! '2(! C(''(-W! U#&),*8(! _2(*!

P*)(-',K&*7!T,^1-! Q2,*7(5! B1! ]["! "(-E&8(5L;! ],'&1*,.! 3(81*0&7#-,'&1*!

Page 236: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==@!

B(,%aQ1%%&55&1*&*7!r!":5'(%!T,*,7(%(*'!6&-(8'1-,'(;!6(9,-'%(*'!10!

[(,.'2;!Pd;!F'2!10!T,:!=>>DA!

6(9,-'%(*'!10![(,.'2!I=>??JA!3(E&(S!10!U,'(S,:!3(5#.'5!&*!'2(![(,.'2!"(8'1-!01-!

'2(!g(,-!?!<9-&.!=>>F! '1!@?!T,-82!=>?>A!+#$.&52()!O'2!10! h,*#,-:!=>??A!

<E,&.,$.(W!

2''9WaaS($,-82&E(A*,'&1*,.,-82&E(5A71EA#Ka�aSSSA)2A71EA#Ka(*aT,*,7

&*7:1#-1-7,*&5,'&1*aU,'(S,:-(E&(S5a&*)(`A2'%!!

6(%&*7;!_A;!HA!I?FDRJA!G#'!10!'2(!Q-&5&5;!Q,%$-&)7(;!T<;!TVB!Q(*'(-!01-!<)E,*8()!

H*7&*((-&*7!"'#)&(5A!

6fV! 6(5&7*! f#,.&':! V*)&8,'1-! I=>>FJA! 3('-&(E()! 1*! >Oa>Da>F! 0-1%W!

2''9WaaSSSA)4&A1-7A#KaS($5&'(a)(0,#.'A,59,A!

6:(-;!_A!UA;!_&.K&*5;!<A!bA!r!H&5(*2,-)';!dA!TA!I?FF?JA!uC(''(-!5'1-&(5;!*1'!C(''(-!

Q1*5'-#8'5;!'1!U(*(-,'(!C(''(-!B2(1-:W!<!3(^1&*)(-!'1!H&5(*2,-)'q!C(''(-!

"'1-&(5!,*)!C(''(-!Q1*5'-#8'5W!B2(!Q,5(!01-!3&71-!,*)!Q1%9,-,'&E(!b17&8ÅA!

B2(!<8,)(%:!10!T,*,7(%(*'!3(E&(S;!E1.A!?RI@J;!99A!R?@\R=FA!

61[! I=>>>JA! 86&! PQ-! 5/.#;! F! 5/.#! ,+'! $#%&()D&#);! F! 5/.#! ,+'! R&,+'D;! G+#0+#;!

[T"GA!

H,5'(-$:\"%&'2;!TA! ;! B21-9(;! 3A! r! b1S(;! <A;! I=>>=JA! uT,*,7(%(*'! -(5(,-82W! ,*!

&*'-1)#8'&1*vA!",7(!+#$.&8,'&1*5!b')A!

H7,*;!hA!I?FFDJA!3('2&*K&*7!81*5'-#8'&1*;!b1*)1*;![T"GA!

H.)&*;! ]A! <*)! [&K.(;! XA! I=>>@JA! +&.1'! 5'#):! 10! 4#,.&':! 0#*8'&1*! )(9.1:%(*'! &*!

81*5'-#8'&1*! 9-1^(8'5A! h1#-*,.! 10! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! H*7&*((-&*7! ,*)!

T,*,7(%(*';!?=FI@J;!@?NZ=FA!

H&5(*2,-)';! d! TA! I?FDFJA! uC#&.)&*7! B2(1-&(5! 0-1%! Q,5(! "'#):! 3(5(,-82vA! B2(!

<8,)(%:!10!T,*,7(%(*'!3(E&(SA!X1.A?NINJ;!99AO@=\OO>A!

H%%&'';!"A;!",*)(-;!6A!r!Q2-&5'100(-5(*;!<A!dA!I=>>OJA!yB2(!E,.#(!#*&E(-5(W!)(0&*&*7!

,!E,.#(!$,5()!,99-1,82! '1! .(,*!81*5'-#8'&1*y;!+-18(()&*75! VUbQ\?@;! h#.:;!

":)*(:;!<#5'-,.&,A!

Page 237: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==N!

H]Q<3B<|!I=>>OJA!2''9Waa(*8,-',A%5*A81%a)&8'&1*,-:a)&5$(*(0&'A2'%.A!C#00,.1;!

]g;!H*8,-',|!6&8'&1*,-:A!T&8-1510'!H*8,-',|A!

H#-19(,*!Q1%%&55&1*! I=>>=J;!+-1^(8'!Q:8.(!T,*,7(%(*'![,*)$11KA!3('-&(E()!

1*! >=a>Da>F! 0-1%W!

2''9WaaSSSA5'7%A1-7A'-a)185a??=@NO>?N@+QT}B-,&*}[,*)$11K}H]\

T,-82=>>=A9)0!!

/,-$(:;! CA;! b,*);! /A! r! B,-7('';! 6A! I?FFFJA! B2(! %1E&*7! 5',&-8,5(! Z! 9-1$.(%5! 10!

,99-,&5,.! ,*)! (E,.#,'&1*! &*! ,! '#-$#.(*'! (*E&-1*%(*';! V*01-%,'&1*!

B(82*1.17:!,*)!+(19.(!h1#-*,.;!?=;!=@D\=O=A!

/,-$(:;!CA;!b,*);!/A!/A!r!B,-7('';!6A!I?FF@JA![1S!'1!HE,.#,'(!g1#-!VaB!V*E(5'%(*'W!

<!"'#):!10!T('21)5!,*)!+-,8'&8(;!G`01-);!C#''(-S1-'2![(&*(%,**A!

/(-*5;! 6A;! QA! I?FF?JA! 6(E(.19%(*'5! &*! 9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'A! V*'(-*,'&1*,.!

h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!F!?ND\?ORA!

/1`;!"A!I=>>DJA!HE,.#,'&*7!91'(*'&,.! &*E(5'%(*'5! &*!*(S!'(82*1.17&(5W!C,.,*8&*7!

,55(55%(*'5! 10! 91'(*'&,.! $(*(0&'5! S&'2! ,55(55%(*'5! 10! 91'(*'&,.!

)&5$(*(0&'5;!-(.&,$&.&':!,*)!#'&.&e,'&1*A!Q-&'&8,.!+(-59(8'&E(!1*!<881#*'&*7A!

/.,*,7,*!;hA;!]&821..5;!+A;!I=>>MJA!+#$.&8!"(8'1-!C#5&*(55!Q,5(5!P5&*7!'2(!/&E(!Q,5(!

T1)(.W!,!B11.K&';!![(,.'28,-(!/&*,*8&,.!T,*,7(%(*'!<5518&,'&1*!I[/T<J;!

V"C]W!FMD\?F>NR=NN=N;!Q-1S*(;!C-&5'1.!;PdA!!

/-,*81;!TA!r!C1#-*(;!TA! I=>>@J! /,8'1-5! '2,'! 9.,:! ,! -1.(! &*! u%,*,7&*7! '2-1#72!

%(,5#-(5vA!T,*,7(%(*'!6(8&5&1*;!RFD\M?>A!

/#'#-(!<*)!V**1E,'&1*!P*&'!I=>>?JA!Q-(,'&*7!X,.#(!0-1%!g1#-!V*',*7&$.(!<55('5A!

b1*)1*;!6(9,-'%(*'!10!B-,)(!,*)!V*)#5'-:!IPdJA!

U,..&(-5;! 3A;! 6A;! I?FF=JA! cQ2115&*7! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5! -(5(,-82! ,99-1,82(5L;!

V*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%! -(5(,-82;\! V55#(5;! T('21)5;! +-,8'&8(5! U#&)(.&*(5;!

H)&'()!$:!U,..&(-5;!3A;!C.,8KS(..!"8&(*'&0&8!+#$.&8,'&1*5;!Pd!99A!?NN\?R=A!!

U,**;!6ATA;!",.'(-;!<AhA!<*)!_2:'(;!hAdA!I=>>@JA!B2(!6(5&7*!f#,.&':!V*)&8,'1-!,5!,!

'11.! 01-! '2&*K&*7;! C#&.)&*7!3(5(,-82! ,*)! V*01-%,'&1*;! X1.A! @?;! ]1A! O;! 99A!

@?D\@@@AU-,*';!=>>MJA!

Page 238: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==O!

U,-8&,\<:#51;!TA! I=>>@JA! V*',*7&$.(5! .(551*5! 0-1%! '2(! 9,5'! ,*)! ,! .11K! &*'1! '2(!

0#'#-(A!h1#-*,.!10!V*'(..(8'#,.!Q,9&',.;!N;!OFM\R>NA!

U(-S&*;! 6A! I?FDDJA! <! '2(1-:! 10! &**1E,'&1*! 9-18(55(5! 01-! 81%9#'(-\,&)()!

%,*#0,8'#-&*7! '(82*1.17:A! VHHH! B-,*5,8'&1*5! 1*! H*7&*((-&*7!

T,*,7(%(*'!h1#-*,.;!F>Z?>>A!

U2,.,:*&;! <A;! TA;! ]1$.(;! hA;! "A! r! Q-1S(;! BA;! hA! I?FFMJA! <*! &*'(7-,'()! ):*,%&8!

9(-01-%,*8(! %(,5#-(%(*'! 5:5'(%! 01-! &%9-1E&*7! %,*#0,8'#-&*7!

81%9('&'&E(*(55A!V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!+-1)#8'&1*!H81*1%&85;!=>M\==OA!

U.:**(;! +A! I=>>MJA! C(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'\82,*7&*7! '2(! 018#5! 10! )(.&E(-:A!

<5518&,'&1*!01-!+-17-(55!T,*,7(%(*'!g(,-$11K!=>>Ra>M;!NO\NFA!

U-((*!C11K!!I=>>@JA!c!<!7#&)(!'1!,99-,&5,.!&*!Q(*'-,.!U1E(-*%(*'L![T!B-(,5#-:!

U#&),*8(;!B"G;!b1*)1*!;PdA!

U#%%(551*;! HA;I=>>>JA! uf#,.&','&E(! %('21)5! &*! %,*,7(%(*'! -(5(,-82v;! ",7(!

9#$.&8,'&1*5;!=R=9A!

[,K&%;! QA! I=>>>JA! 3(5(,-82! )(5&7*q! 5#88(550#.! )(5&7*5! 01-! 518&,.! ,*)! (81*1%&8!

-(5(,-82W!=*)!()&'&1*;!31#'.()7(;!b1*)1*A!

[,--&5;!dA! I=>>DJA!<*!,*,.:5&5!10!S2,'!%,K(5! 5#88(50#.! '(,%W!<! 8,5(! 5'#):!10! ,!

-(5(,-82!'(,%A!"8211.!10!'2(!C#&.'!H*E&-1*%(*';!",.01-);!B2(!P*&E(-5&':!10!

",.01-)A!

[,--&51*;! hA! "A;! r! h12*;! QA! [A! "A! I?FFRJA!T,*,7&*7! ,*)! 9,-'*(-&*7!S&'2! (`'(-*,.!

5',K(21.)(-5A!B2(!<8,)(%:!10!T,*,7(%(*'!H`(8#'&E(;!?>I=J;!NR\R>A!

[,#5(-;! hA!3A!<*)!Q.,#5&*7;!6A!I?FDDJA!ÅB2(![1#5(!10!f#,.&':;Å![,-E,-)!C#5&*(55!

3(E&(S;!X1.A!]1A!@;!IT,:\h#*(J;!R@\M@A!

[(*-&82;! UA;! I=>>FJA! c6(E(.19%(*'! G0! <! B11.! /1-! 6&,7*15&*7! +-1)#8'&1*!

T,*,7(%(*'! H00&8&(*8:! G*! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! "&'(5L;! +26A! B2(5&5;! C#[#!

3(5(,-82!V*5'&'#'(;!P*&E(-5&':!10!",.01-);!PdA!!

[(--&1'';!3A;!HA!<*)!/&-(5'1*(;!_A!<A!I?FD@JA!T#.'&5&'(!4#,.&','&E(!91.&8:!-(5(,-82W!

G9'&%&e&*7!)(58-&9'&1*!,*)!7(*(-,.&e,$&.&':;!H)#8,'&1*,.!3(5(,-82(-;!X1.A!

?=;!?N\?FA!

Page 239: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==R!

[1.$-11K;!<A;!d-15*&8K;!hA;!,*)!+0(*';!<A;!I=>>MJA!uB2(!Q,#5(5!,*)!Q1*5(4#(*8(5!10!

3(591*5(! 3,'(5! &*! "#-E(:5! $:! '2(! ](S5! T()&,! ,*)! U1E(-*%(*'!

Q1*'-,8'1-! "#-E(:! 3(5(,-82! /&-%5Av! V*! <)E,*8(5! &*! '(.(921*(! 5#-E(:!

%('21)1.17:;!()A!b(9K1S5K&;!hA;!TA;!B#8K(-;!]A;!QA;!C-&8K;!hA;!TA;!6(!b((#S;!HA;!

6A;! h,9(8;! bA;! b,E-,K,5;!+A;! hA;! b&*K;TA;!_A;! ! ,*)! ! ",*75'(-!3A;! bA;!](S!g1-KW!

_&.(:A!

[1#5(!10!Q1%%1*5!I=>>RJA!c]["!b18,.!V%9-1E(%(*'!0&*,*8(!B-#5'L;!/1-':!5(E(*!;!

-(91-'!5(55&1*;!=>>O\=>>R;!Q1%%&''((!10!9#$.&8!,881#*'5;!B2(!"','&1*(-:!

G00&8(!.&%&'();![QOR=;!N'2!10!h#.:!=>>RA!

[1S(..;! UA;! b,#0(-;! <A;! r! C,..,-);! UA! I?FF@JA! P*8(-',&*':! ,*)! 9-1^(8'! 1$^(8'&E(5A!

+-1^(8'!<99-,&5,.;!DI?J;!@M\N@A!

[#'82&*5;! 6A! I=>>DJA! [152&*! d,*-&W! B2(! "'-,'(7&8! <99-1,82! '1! Q1*'&*#1#5!

V%9-1E(%(*';!U1S(-!9#$.&52&*7;!@>D99A!

[:*)5;! +A! r! T,-'&*;! _A! I?FFOJA! <! Q,5(! 5'#):! 10! 0,&.#-(! &*! 9-10(55&1*,.!

81%%#*&8,'&1*A! VHHH! '-,*5,8'&1*5! 1*! 9-10(55&1*,.! 81%%#*&8,'&1*;! @D;!

?@F\?NOA!

V-,*&;!zA!I?FFDJA!V*E(5'%(*'!h#5'&0&8,'&1*!10!V*01-%,'&1*!":5'(%5W!<!/18#5!1*!'2(!

HE,.#,'&1*! 10! T3+VVA! 6(9,-'%(*'! 10! T,*#0,8'#-&*7! ,*)! H*7&*((-&*7A!

b1*)1*;!Pd;!C-#*(.!P*&E(-5&':A!

h,#*e(*5;! 6A;! U-&77;! +A;! Q12(*;! 3A;! _,'51*;! TA! r! +&8'1*;! HA! I=>>@JA! C#&.)&*7!

9(-01-%,*8(!0(()$,8KW!7(''&*7!5',-'()A!C3H!6&7(5'A!_,'01-)A!

h2,;! "A;! ]11-&;! [A! r! T&82(.,;! hA;! bA! I?FFRJA! B2(! ):*,%&85! 10! 81*'&*#1#5!

&%9-1E(%(*'!\!<.&7*&*7!1-7,*&e,'&1*,.!,''-&$#'(5!,*)!,8'&E&'&(5!01-!4#,.&':!

,*)!9-1)#8'&E&':A!V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!f#,.&':!"8&(*8(;!?;!?F\NMA!

d,7&17.1#;!TA! I?FFFJA! u<),9'&*7!,*)!,)19'&*7!%,*#0,8'#-&*7!9-1^(8'!9-18(55(5!

&*'1!81*5'-#8'&1*W!,!%('21)1.17:vA!+26A!B2(5&5;!BVTH!3(5(,-82!V*5'&'#'(;!

P*&E(-5&':!10!",.01-);!PdA!

d,7&17.1#;!TA;!Q119(-;!3A;!<1#,);!UA;![&*K5;!hA;!"(`'1*;!TA!r!"2(,'2;!6A;!TA!!I?FFDJA!

<! U(*(-&8! U#&)(! '1! '2(! 6(5&7*! ,*)! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! +-18(55! +-1'181.A!

P*&E(-5&':!10!",.01-)A!

Page 240: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==M!

d,7&17.1#;! TA;! Q119(-;! 3A;! <1#,);! UA! <*)! "(`'1*;! TA! I=>>>JA! u3('2&*K&*7!

Q1*5'-#8'&1*W! '2(! U(*(-&8! 6(5&7*! ,*)! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! +-18(55! +-1'181.v;!

H*7&*((-&*7;! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! ,*)! <-82&'(8'#-,.! T,*,7(%(*'! h1#-*,.;! X1.AM!

]1!=;!99!?N?\?O@A!

d,K,$,)5(;! <A;! C,*K;! hA! r! X&**&81%$(;! "A! I=>>NJA! _1-K&*7! &*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5;!

U1S(-A!

d,9.,*;!3A;!"A!!r!]1-'1*A!6A;!+A!I?FFRJA!B2(!C,.,*8()!"81-(8,-);![,-E,-)!C#5&*(55!

"8211.!+-(55A!

d,5,*(*;! HA;! r! b#KK,;! dA! I?FF@JA! B2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! ,99-1,82! &*! %,*,7(%(*'!

,881#*'&*7! -(5(,-82A! h1#-*,.! 10! %,*,7(%(*'! ,881#*'&*7! -(5(,-82;! IOJ;!

=N@\=RNA!

d(-.&*7(-;! /A;! ]A! I?FMFJA! uC(2,E&1#-,.! -(5(,-82W! ,! 81*8(9'#,.! ,99-1,82vA! [1.';!

3&*(2,-'!,*)!_&*5'1*A!

d&*7;! CA! I?FDFJA! [152&*! +.,**&*7W! B2(! 6(E(.19%(*'! <99-1,82;! UG<baf+Q;!

T('2#(*!T<A!

d&99(*$(-7(-;!BA!I=>>>JA!T,*,7&*7!'2(!$#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5A!B2(!<*'&)1'(;!OA!

d15K(.,;!b! h!r![1#E&.,;!+!I=>>>JA! yG*!/1#*),'&1*5!10!Q1*8#--(*'!H*7&*((-&*7y;! \

V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!Q1%9#'(-!V*'(7-,'()!6(5&7*!,*)!Q1*5'-#8'&1*A!

d15K(.,;!bA!hA!<*)![1S(..;!UA!I=>>?JA!y3(01-%&*7!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*'W!B2(!31.(!10!

+.,**&*7;! H`(8#'&1*! ,*)! Q1*'-1..&*7y;! +-18(()&*75! 10! F'2! V*'(-*,'&1*,.!

U-1#9!01-!b(,*!Q1*5'-#8'&1*!Q1*0(-(*8(;!99A?DO\?FDA!

d#%,-;! dA! I?FF>JA! +15'\&%9.(%(*','&1*! (E,.#,'&1*! 10! 81%9#'(-\$,5()!

&*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5W!8#--(*'!9-,8'&8(5;!Q1%%#*&8,'&1*5!10! '2(!<QT;!@@;!

=>@\=?=A!

b((;!<A;!"A;!I?FDFJA!c<!58&(*'&0&8!%('21)1.17:!01-!TV"!8,5(!5'#)&(5L;!TV"!f#,-'(-.:;!

X1.A?@;!]1A;!99@=\O>A!

b(,2:;! +A;! I=>>FJA! +-(0,8(! &*! [,QV3VQ! cC(''(-! [(,.'2! '2-1#72! $(''(-!

&*0-,5'-#8'#-(L;! =>>F! +-17-(55! 3(91-';! $:! [,QV3VQ! V%9(-&,.! Q1..(7(!

b1*)1*;!PdA!!

Page 241: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==D!

b(:'1*;!3A!I?FFOJA!V*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.W!'2(!K(:!01-!VBt!V*!/,-$(:;!CA;!b,*);!/A;!/A!!

r!B,-7(';!6A!IH)5AJ![,-)!T1*(:;!"10'!G#'81%(5A![(*.(:!1*!B2,%(5;!<.0-()!

_,..(-!b');!&*!,5518&,'&1*!S&'2!P*&81%A!

b(S&*;!dA!I?FNRJ;!!<8'&1*!-(5(,-82!,*)!%&*1-&':!9-1$.(%5;!h!"18A!V55#(5!=INJW!@N\

NRA!

b&..-,*K;!+A;![1.19,&*(*;!"A!r!+,,E1.,;!BA!I=>>?JA!Q,'82&*7! &*',*7&$.(!VB!$(*(0&'5A!

B2(!H.(8'-1*&8!h1#-*,.!10!V*01-%,'&1*!":5'(%5!HE,.#,'&1*;!N;!?\??A!

b&*;!QA!r!+(-E,*;!UA!I=>>?JA!<!-(E&(S!10!V"aVB!&*E(5'%(*'!(E,.#,'&1*!,*)!$(*(0&'5!

%,*,7(%(*'! &55#(5;! 9-1$.(%5! ,*)! 9-18(55(5A! U-(%$(-7(*;! V*01-%,'&1*!

'(82*1.17:! (E,.#,'&1*! %('21)5! r! %,*,7(%(*'A! V)(,! U-1#9! +#$.&52&*7;!

==\=NA!

b&*;!QA!r!+(-E,*;!UA! I=>>@JA!B2(!9-,8'&8(!10! V"aVB!$(*(0&'5!%,*,7(%(*'! &*! .,-7(!

<#5'-,.&,*! 1-7,*&5,'&1*5;! V*01-%,'&1*! ,*)!T,*,7(%(*'! h1#-*,.;! N?;! ?@\

=NA!

b&**(%,*;! 3A;! HA! r! d(**(..;! hA;! 6A! I?FMMJA! "2&-'5.((E(! ,99-1,82! '1! .1*7\-,*7(!

9.,*5A!?N?\?O>A!

b1E(;!+A!HA!6A;! V-,*&;!zA;! "',*)&*7;!QA;!b&*;!QA!r!C#-*A;! hA!TA! I=>>NJA!B2(!(*&7%,!10!

(E,.#,'&1*W!$(*(0&'5;!815'!,*)!-&5K5!10!VB!&*!<#5'-,.&,*!5%,..\%()&#%\5&e()!

(*'(-9-&5(5;!V*01-%,'&1*!,*)!T,*,7(%(*';!N=;!FNM\FRNA!

b#KK,;! dA! I=>>@JA! B2(! 81*5'-#8'&E(! -(5(,-82! ,99-1,82A! Q,5(! 5'#):! -(5(,-82! &*!

.17&5'&85A! +#$.&8,'&1*5! 10! '2(! B#-K#! "8211.! 10! H81*1%&85! ,*)! C#5&*(55!

<)%&*&5'-,'&1*;!"(-&(5!C;!?I=>>@J;!D@\?>A!

T"+! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.! +-17-,%%(5;! I=>??JA! B2(! "','&1*(-:! G00&8(;! [T!

U1E(-*%(*';!Q-1S*;!V"C]!FMD>??@@?@=M@A!

T,*'e,*,;!XA!r!B2(%&5'18.(1#5;!TA!I=>>NJA!V)(*'&0:&*7!,*)!Q.,55&0:&*7!C(*(0&'5!10!

V*'(7-,'()![(,.'28,-(!":5'(%5!P5&*7!,*!<8'1-\G-&(*'()!<99-1,82;!h1#-*,.!

10!Q1%9#'&*7!,*)!V*01-%,'&1*!B(82*1.17:!\!QVB;!?=;!=RO\=MDA!

T,-52,..;! QA! <*)! 3155%,*;! UA! CA! I?FFFJA! 6(5&7*&*7! f#,.&','&E(! 3(5(,-82! @-)!

H)&'&1*;!B21#5,*)!G,K5;!Q<W!",7(A!

Page 242: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! ==F!

T,:;! BA! I?FF@JA! "18&,.!3(5(,-82W! V55#(5;!%('21)5! ,*)!9-18(55;!G9(*!P*&E(-5&':!

+-(55A!

T8Q,-'*(:;! [A! VA! I=>>>JA! "#88(550#.! VBW! T1)(-*&5&*7! U1E(-*%(*'! &*! <8'&1*;!

3('-&(E()!1*!?=a>Da>F;!0-1%W!!

2''9WaaSSSA178A71EA#Ka)18#%(*'5a"#88(550#.}VB}}T1)(-*&5&*7}U1E(-*

%(*'}&*}<8'&1*A9)0!

T8.,#72.&*;!QA;!+A!r!d,.#e*:;!<A;!6A! I?FF>JA!B1',.!4#,.&':!%,*,7(%(*'! &*!2(,.'2W!

%,K&*7!&'!S1-KA![(,.'2!Q,-(!T,*,7(%(*'!3(E&(S;!?O;!M\?NA!

T(--&,%\_($5'(-! I=>>OJA!T(--&,%\_($5'(-!G*.&*(!6&8'&1*,-:A!"9-&*70&(.);!T<;!

T(--&,%\_($5'(-A!

T#.E,*:;! +A! I?FFFJA! <55(55&*7! $&1'(82*1.17:! &%9,8'5;! Q.15&*7! 59((82;!

&*'(-%()&,'(! '(82*1.17:! )(E(.19%(*'! 7-1#9! ,5518&,'(5! c),:;!

V*'(-%()&,'(!B(82*1.17:!6(E(.19%(*'!U-1#9A!3#7$:;!_,-K5A!

T#-92:;! dA! r! "&%1*;! "A! I=>>=JA! V*',*7&$.(! $(*(0&'5! E,.#,'&1*! &*! H3+! 9-1^(8'5A!

V*01-%,'&1*!":5'(%5!h1#-*,.!@>?\@=>A!

]((.:;! <A;! <),%;! QA! r! d(**(-.(:;! TA! I=>>=JA! B2(! +(-01-%,*8(! +-&5%W! B2(!

"81-(8,-)!01-!T(,5#-&*7!r!T,*,7&*7!"',K(21.)(-5!3(.,'&1*52&9;!b1*)1*;!

/&*,*8&,.!B&%(a+-(*'&8(![,..A!

](S81%$(;! 3A! I=>>@JA! /-1%! 8.&(*'! '1! 9-1^(8'! 5',K(21.)(-5W! ,! 5',K(21.)(-!

%,99&*7!,99-1,82A!Q1*5'-#8'&1*!T,*,7(%(*'!,*)!H81*1%&85;!DN?\DNDA!

]["!I?FF@JA!B2(!U11)!H#-19(,*![(,.'2!3(81-)W!H'2&8,.!,*)!b(7,.!3(4#&-(%(*'5A!

b1*)1*A!

]["! H`(8#'&E(! I?FFNJA! :.2$)./! =#%&()D&#)!U.#3./;! b1*)1*;! [T"G;! V"C]W! >! ??!

@=?MMR!OA!B2(!Q,9&',.!V*E(5'%(*'!T,*#,.!81%9-&5(5!10!(&72'!$11K.('5W!!

b%&'%$&@;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M?D!D!

5'+V&E)!b'A.#$(.)$+#;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M?F!R!

Y3($#&((!:.(&!T3$0&;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M=>!Ñ!

U.#.A&D&#)!+,!:+#()'3E)$+#!5'+V&E)(;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M=@!N!

Page 243: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@>!

5'$%.)&!g$#.#E&!T3$0&;!V"C]W!>!??!@@?M==!R!

=Uk8!T3$0.#E&;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M==!R!

:+DD$(($+#$#A!.!Q&./)6E.'&!,.E$/$)*;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?M=N!=!

5+()!15'+V&E)!S%./3.)$+#;!V"C]W!>!??!@=?MMO!MA!!

]["! I=>>OJA! 6(.&E(-&*7! f#,.&':! ,*)! X,.#(W! B2(! V"V+! U#&)(! '1! "'-,'(7:! ,*)!

C(*(0&'5A!3('-&(E()!1*!?>a>Da>F!0-1%W!!

! 2''9WaaSSSA&5&9A*25A#Ka.&$-,-:a,-82&E(a5'-,'(7:,*)$(*(0&'5aV"V+}5'-,'(

7:},*)}$(*(0&'5}1E(-E&(SA9)0!

]["!I=>>MJA!]["! V*'(7-,'()!"(-E&8(! V%9-1E(%(*'!+.,*;!]1!6(.,:5!S($5&'(;!]1!

)(.,:5;!,-82&E(5A!

!SSSA*25A:Ka5(-E&8(&%9-1E(%(*'a'11.5aVBGVV\C(*(0&'5-(,.&5,'&1*A!

]["! ",.01-)! I=>>DJA! f#(5'&1**,&-(! '11.K&';! V*E1.E(%(*'! B(,%;! ",.01-)! +-&%,-:!

Q,-(!'-#5';!,E,&.,$.(!,'!SSSA5,.01-)\98'A*25A#K!!

]17(5'(;! dA! I=>>RJA! 6(E(.19%(*'! 10! ,! %('21)! '1! &%9-1E(! '2(! )(0&*&'&1*! ,*)!

,.&7*%(*'! 10! &*',*7&$.(! 9-1^(8'! 1#'81%(5!S&'2! ',*7&$.(! 9-1^(8'! 1#'9#'5;!

"8211.!10!C#5&*(55;!3TVBA!

]17(5'(;!dA!r!_,.K(-;!6A![A!BA!I=>>OJA!+-1^(8'!1#'81%(5!,*)!1#'9#'5W!%,K&*7!'2(!

&*',*7&$.(!',*7&$.(A!T(,5#-&*7!C#5&*(55!H`8(..(*8(;!F;!OO!\!RDA!

]G3<6! ]1-S(7&,*! <7(*8:! /1-! 6(E(.19%(*'! Q119(-,'&1*! I?FFFJA! B2(! b17&8,.!

/-,%(S1-K! <99-1,82! Ib/<JA! 3('-&E()! 1*! >Oa>Da>F! 0-1%W!

2''9WaaSSSA8819A1-A'2a++Ta)18#%(*'a21%(ab/<x=>$:x=>]G3<6x

=>[,*)$11KA9)0!!

G)%,*;!+A;!I?FDOJA!c[(-%(*(#'&85L!&*![#5(*;!BA;!r!+15'.('2S,&'(;!]A;!BA;!IH)5AJ!cB2(!

&*'(-*,'&1*,.! H*8:8.19,()&,! 10! H)#8,'&1*LA! +(7,%1*;! G`01-);! 99A=?R=! \

=?RFA!

GUQ!I=>>@JA!T,*,7&*7!"#88(550#.!+-17-,%%(5;!b1*)1*;!B2(!"','&1*(-:!G00&8(A!

GUQ! I=>>M,JA! T,*,7&*7! "#88(550#.! +-17-,%%(5! T"+;! b1*)1*;! B2(! "','&1*(-:!

G00&8(A!

Page 244: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@?!

GUQ! I=>>M$JA! "B6d! [1%(;! 6(.&E(-:! b&0(8:8.(W! C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*';!

2''9WaaSSSA178A71EA#Ka5)'11.K&'a-(0(-(*8(a)(.&E(-:.&0(8:8.(a$(*(0&'5}%

7%'A2'%.Ö$(*%,*,7(%(*'?!!

G.,*)(-;! "A! r! b,*)&*;! <A! I=>>OJA! HE,.#,'&1*! 10! 5',K(21.)(-! &*0.#(*8(! &*! '2(!

&%9.(%(*','&1*!10!81*5'-#8'&1*!9-1^(8'5A! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!

T,*,7(%(*';!@=?\@=DA!

G'.(:;! 6A;! BA! I?FFFJA! +(-01-%,*8(!%,*,7(%(*'W! <! 0-,%(S1-K! 01-! %,*,7(%(*'!

81*'-1.!5:5'(%5!-(5(,-82A!T,*,7(%(*'!<881#*'&*7!3(5(,-82;!@R@\@D=A!

+,--;! BA! r! _&..&,%5;! 6A! I=>>MJA! H*'(-9-&5(! +-17-,%%(! T,*,7(%(*';! +,.7-,E(!

T,8T&..,*A!

+,-'&*7'1*;!6A! I=>>>JA! V%9.(%(*'&*7! 5'-,'(7:! '2-1#72!9-17-,%%(5! 10! 9-1^(8'5A!

V*! B#-*(-;! hA;! 3A! ! r! "&%&5'(-;! "A;! hA! IH)5AJ! U1S(-! 2,*)$11K! 10! 9-1^(8'!

%,*,7(%(*'A!<.)(-521';!U1S(-A!

+,:*(;! TA! I=>>MJA! C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*'! Z! 3(.(,5&*7! 9-1^(8'! E,.#(! &*'1! '2(!

$#5&*(55;![,%952&-(;!Pd;!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(-!B1),:A!

+,55%,*;! 6A;! I=>>FJA! +.,**&*7! [(,.'28,-(! H*E&-1*%(*'5;! &*! d,7&17.1#;! TA! ,*)!

Be1-'e191#.15;!+A;!()5A;! V%9-1E&*7![(,.'28,-(!'2-1#72!$#&.'!(*E&-1*%(*'!

V*0-,5'-#8'#-(;!!_&.(:\C.,8KS(..;!G`01-);!Pd;!99!F!\@DA!

+,5'(#-;! dA! I=>>?JA! B2&*K&*7! ,$1#'! b17&8,.! /-,%(S1-K5! ,*)! "#5',&*,$.(!

b&E(.&211)5W!<!521-'! 8-&'&4#(!,*)!9155&$.(!S,:! 01-S,-);!=>>?A!3('-&(E()!

1*!?=a>?a>F;!0-1%W!2''9WaaSSSA.&E(.&211)5A1-7a915'a6185a.170-,%(A-'0A!!

+(..(7-&*(..&;! "A! I?FFMJA! +-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'W! 1-7,*&5&*7! 9-1^(8'! $,5()!

82,*7(A!V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!?O;!?N?\?NFA!

+(..(7-&*(..&;! "A! r! C1S%,*;! QA! I?FFNJA! V%9.(%(*'&*7! 5'-,'(7:! '2-1#72! 9-1^(8'5A!

b1*7!3,*7(!+.,**;!=M;!?=O\?@=A!

+(..(7-&*(..&;! "A;! +,-'&*7'1*;!6A;![(%&*7S,:;! QA;!T12)e,&*;! zA!r! "2,2;!TA! I=>>MJA!

B2(! &%91-',*8(! 10! 81*'(`'! &*! 9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'W! <*! (%9&-&8,.!

-(E&(S! 10! 9-17-,%%(! 9-,8'&8(5! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.! 10! +-1^(8'!

T,*,7(%(*';!N?\OOA!

Page 245: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@=!

+('(-5;!hA;!r![1S,-)5;!dA;!I=>>?JA!ub11K&*7!01-!711)!-(5(,-82!&*!%,*,7(%(*'!Z!,!

9#$.&52(-y5!8,5(!5'#):vA!T,*,7(%(*'!6(8&5&1*;!E1.A!@FIMJ;!99A!OFN\OFDA!

+2&..&95;! hA;! hA! I=>>@JA! 3('#-*! 1*! V*E(5'%(*'! &*! B-,&*&*7! ,*)! +(-01-%,*8(!

V%9-1E(%(*'!9-17-,%%(5;!C#-.&*7'1*;!T<A!

+15';! hA;! HA;! +-(5'1*;! bA;! HA! r! ",825;! "A! I?FFOJA! 3()(0&*&*7! '2(! 81-91-,'&1*W!

5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!,*)!1-7,*&e,'&1*,.!S(,.'2;!"',*01-)A!

+-(&5(-;! _A! I=>>?JA! /(()$,8K;! 0(()01-S,-)! ,*)! 81*'-1.W! 915'! 188#9,*8:!

(E,.#,'&1*!'1!'2(!-(58#(A!C#&.)&*7!3(5(,-82!,*)!V*01-%,'&1*;!=F;!NOR\NOFA!

3(&55;!UA;!<A!I=>>>JA!<!9,9(-!01-!81*7-(55A!

SSSA(\9-17-,%%(A81%a#9.1,)5a,-'&8.(5a!A!

3(&55;!UA;!<*'21*:;!TA;!Q2,9%,*;!hA;!b(&72;!UA;!+:*(;!<A!r!3,:*(-;!+A!I=>>RJ!U1S(-!

[,*)$11K!10!9-17-,%%(!%,*,7(%(*';!U1S(-!+#$.&52&*7A!!

3(%(*:&;!6A!r!"2(-S11)\"%&'2;!TA! I?FFDJA!C#5&*(55!$(*(0&'5! 0-1%! &*01-%,'&1*!

5:5'(%5! '2-1#72! ,*! ,8'&E(!$(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*!9-17-,%%(! V*'(-*,'&1*,.!

h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!?R;!D?\FDA!

3(%(*:&;!6A;!"A;!hA;!"S,-'e;!HA;!T1*(:;!<A;!r!_&..&,%5;!CA;!I?FFDJA!u61&*7!3(5(,-82!&*!

C#5&*(55!,*)!T,*,7(%(*'W!<*!V*'-1)#8'&1*!'1!+-18(55!,*)!T('21)vA!",7(!

+#$.&8,'&1*5;!b1*)1*A!@>F9A!

321)(5;!UA!I=>>NJA!Q1%%#*&8,'&1*!S&'2!(*)!#5(-5!S&..!&%9-1E(!$#&.)&*7!)(5&7*W!

%(,5#-()! '2-1#72! 915'! 188#9,*8:! (E,.#,'&1*A! +.:%1#'2;! P*&E(-5&':! 10!

+.:%1#'2A!

3&$$(-5;! +A! I=>>=JA! +-17-,%! %,*,7(%(*'! ,*)! 81%9.(`&':! 10! H3+!

&%9.(%(*','&1*5A!H*7&*((-&*7!T,*,7(%(*'!h1#-*,.;!?N;!=NO\=O=A!

31$51*;!QA!I=>>@JA!R&./!I+'/0!R&(&.'E6H!-&E+#0!S0$)$+#;!C.,8KS(..!+#$.&52&*7A!

3182,;! QA;! UA;! I=>??JA! <! 81*8(9'#,.! 0-,%(S1-K! 01-! )(0&*&*7! 8#5'1%&5,'&1*!

5'-,'(7&(5! &*! '2(!21#5(\$#&.)&*7!5(8'1-A!618'1-! &*!H*7&*((-&*7A!H581.,!)(!

H*7(*2,-&,;! +-17-,%%,!)(!+15\!U-,)#8,1;! (%!H*7(*2,-&,! Q&E&.;! P/3U";!

+1-'1!<.(7-(A!

Page 246: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@@!

311K(;! hA!<A;! ",91#*'e&5;!"A;!d15K(.,;!bA! hA;!Q1)&*21'1;!3A;!r!d,7&17.1#;!TA! I=>?>JA!

b(,*! K*1S.()7(!%,*,7(%(*'W! B2(! 9-1$.(%! 10! E,.#(A! V*! +-18(()&*75! 10!

'2(! ?D'2! <**#,.! Q1*0(-(*8(! 10! '2(! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! U-1#9! 01-! b(,*!

Q1*5'-#8'&1*!I99A!?=\=?JA!B(82*&1*\V5-,(.!V*5'&'#'(!10!B(82*1.17:!+-&*'&*7!

"(-E&8(5A!

311K(;!hA!<;!"(:%1#-;!6!,*)!/(..1S5;!3!I=>>@JA!yB2(!Q.,&%5!Q#.'#-(W!<!B,`1*1%:!

10!V*)#5'-:!<''&'#)(5!y!;!Q1*5'-#8'&1*!T,*,7(%(*'!,*)!H81*1%&85;!=?!I=J!;!

99A!?RM\?MNA!

",K,-;! +A! r! _&)(5',)2;! QA! I=>>OJA! C(*(0&'5! %,*,7(%(*'! \! [1S! '1! -(,.&e(! '2(!

$(*(0&'5! 10! V"aVB! &*E(5'%(*'5A! 6(9,-'%(*'! 10! V*01-%,'&85A! U1'($1-7;!

P*&E(-5&':!10!U1'($1-7A!

",*)';! hA;! "82,(00(-;!PA!r!_($(-;! hA! I=>>?JA!C,.,*8()!9(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'!

5:5'(%5!r!%,*,7(-!5,'&50,8'&1*\(%9&-&8,.!(E&)(*8(!0-1%!,!U(-%,*!5'#):!

_[PA!G''1!C(&52(&%!U-,)#,'(!"8211.!10!T,*,7(%(*'A!

",91#*'e&5;!"A;!g,'(5;!dA;!d,7&17.1#;!TA!<*)!<1#,);!UA;! I=>>FJA!3(,.&5&*7!C(*(0&'5!

01-!+-&%,-:![(,.'28,-(!V*0-,5'-#8'#-(5A!g.E$/$)$&(!l+3'#./;!=MI@aNJW!MN\MDA!

"82,-&1'2;! hA! r! [#$(-;! TA! I=>>RJA! +-(0,8(A! V*! [#$(-;! TA! r! +,..,5;! TA! IH)5AJ!

Q#5'1%&5&*7!5',K(21.)(-!%,*,7(%(*'!5'-,'(7&(5W!81*8(9'5! 01-! .1*7\'(-%!

$#5&*(55!5#88(55A!"9-&*7(-A!

"82-1()(-;!6A;!TA!r!31$&*51*;!<A;!UA!I?FF?JA!<%(-&8,L5!%15'!5#88(550#.!(`91-'!'1!

h,9,*W! 81*'&*#1#5! &%9-1E(%(*'! 9-17-,%5A! ".1,*! T,*,7(%(*'! 3(E&(S;!

@=;!RM\D?A!

"()(-,;!6A;!315(%,**;!TA!r!U,$.(;!TA! I=>>?JA!P5&*7!9(-01-%,*8(!%(,5#-(%(*'!

%1)(.5! 01-! $(*(0&'! -(.&5,'&1*! S&'2! (*'(-9-&5(! 5:5'(%5! \! '2(! f#((*5.,*)!

71E(-*%(*'!,99-1,82!!I8,5(!5'#):JA!

"(:%1#-;! 6A;! Q-11K;! 6A! r! 311K(;! hA! I?FFMJA! uB2(! -1.(! 10! '2(1-:! &*! 81*5'-#8'&1*!

%,*,7(%(*'W! ,! 8,..! 01-! ,! )($,'(vA! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! T,*,7(%(*'! ,*)!

H81*1%&85;!E1.A!?OI?J;!99A??M\??FA!

"&.E(-%,*;!6A!I?FFDJA!uf#,.&','&E(!-(5(,-82W!%(,*&*75!1-!9-,8'&8(5tvA!V*01-%,'&1*!

":5'(%5!h1#-*,.;!E1.A!DI@J;!99A!@\=>A!

Page 247: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@N!

"&%1*;!BA!I=>>@JA!_2,'!&5!C(*(0&'5!3(,.&5,'&1*t!B2(!+#$.&8!T,*,7(-;!OF\R>A!

".,7%#.)(-;!3A;!C-#77(%,*;!_A!r!_,55(*21E(;!bA! I?FFOJA!<*!(%9&-&8,.!5'#):!10!

8,9&',.!$#)7(''&*7!9-,8'&8(5!01-!5'-,'(7&8!&*E(5'%(*'5!&*!QVT!'(82*1.17&(5A!

V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!+-1)#8'&1*!H81*1%&85;!?=?\?O=A!

"'-&(*;!+A!hA!E,*!I?FMOJA!V*!/(..1S5;!3A!,*)!b&#;!<A!IH)5J!I=>>@JA!3(5(,-82!T('21)5!

01-!Q1*5'-#8'&1*A!

"1,*(5;! QA! r! [,SK(-;! "A! I=>>OJA! Q1%9,8'! 1`01-)! H*7.&52! )&8'&1*,-:! 10! 8#--(*'!

H*7.&52;!G`01-);!G`1*;!G`01-)!P*&E(-5&':!+-(55A!

"#5%,*;!UA;!VA;!r!HE(-();!3A;!6A;!I?FMDJA!u<*!,55(55%(*'!10!'2(!58&(*'&0&8!%(-&'5!10!

,8'&1*!-(5(,-82vA!<)%&*&5'-,'&E(!"8&(*8(!f#,-'(-.:;!E1.A!=@;!99A!OD=\R>@A!

":%1*5;! XA! I?FF>JA! HE,.#,'&1*! 10! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5W! V"! )(E(.19%(*'! &*! '2(!

9-18(55&*7!81%9,*:A!h1#-*,.!10!V*01-%,'&1*!B(82*1.17:;!OA!

"S((*(:;!dA;!r!U-&00&'25;!/A! I=>>=JA!Q1%9.(`&':!,*)!2(,.'28,-(W! ,*! &*'-1)#8'&1*A!

3,)8.&00(!+#$.&52&*7A!

B(**,*';! QA! <*)!31$(-'5;! +A! I=>>?JA! u[152&*! K,*-&W! &%9.(%(*'&*7! '2(! 8,'82$,..!

9-18(55v;!b1*7!3,*7(!+.,**&*7;!X1.A!@N!]1A!@;!99A!=DM\@>DA!

B2&-:;!TA! I=>>=JA! Å! Q1%$&*&*7! E,.#(! ,*)!9-1^(8'!%,*,7(%(*'! &*'1! ,*! (00(8'&E(!

9-17-,%%(! %,*,7(%(*'! %1)(.AÅ! V*'(-*,'&1*,.! h1#-*,.! 10! +-1^(8'!

T,*,7(%(*'! ! ! ;! H.5(E(&-! "8&(*8(;! G`01-)! I<9-A! =>>=J! =>! I@Jq! ==?\==DA! I!

/&-5'!9-(5(*'()!,'!'2(!N'2!<**#,.!+TV\H#-19(!Q1*0(-(*8(;!b1*)1*;! h#*(;!

=>>?JA!

B21%,5;! UA! r! B21%,5;! TA! I=>>OJA! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! +,-'*(-&*7! ,*)! V*'(7-,'()!

B(,%S1-K&*7;!C.,8KS(..!+#$.&52&*7!b')A!

B21%51*;!6A!"A;!<#5'&*;!"A!<A;!6(E&*(\_-&72';![A!r!T&..5;!UA!3A! I=>>@JA! yT,*,7&*7!

X,.#(! ,*)! f#,.&':! &*! 6(5&7*y;! h1#-*,.! 10! C#&.)&*7! 3(5(,-82! ,*)!

V*01-%,'&1*!@?IOJW!@@N\@NOA!

B2:55(*;!TA![A;!H%%&'';!"A;!C1*K(;!"A!r!d&-K\Q2-&5'100(-5(*;!<A!I=>?>JA!y/,8&.&','&*7!

Q.&(*'! X,.#(! Q-(,'&1*! &*! '2(! Q1*8(9'#,.! 6(5&7*! +2,5(! 10! Q1*5'-#8'&1*!

Page 248: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@O!

+-1^(8'5W! <!_1-K5219! <99-1,82y;! <-82&'(8'#-,.! H*7&*((-&*7! ,*)! 6(5&7*!

T,*,7(%(*'!RW?D\@>A!

B21-9;! hA! I?FFDJA! B2(! V*01-%,'&1*! +,-,)1`! \! -(,.&5&*7! '2(! $#5&*(55! $(*(0&'5! 10!

&*01-%,'&1*!'(82*1.17:;!B1-1*'1;!Q,*,),;!T8U-,S\[&..A!!

B1S*.(:;!CA! I=>>=JA! B2(! -1.(! 10! 81%9('&*7! -,'&1*,.&'&(5! &*! &*5'&'#'&1*,.! 82,*7(A!

<8,)(%:!10!T,*,7(%(*'!h1#-*,.;!NO;!?R@\?MFA!

B-#,`;!hA!I?FFMJA!V*E(5'&*7!S&'2!C(*(0&'5!&*!T&*)W!Q#-&*7!V*E(5'%(*'!T:19&,A!B2(!

6T3!_2&'(!+,9(-;!?\RA!

B#-9&*\C-11K5;! "A!r!X&88,-5;! UA! I=>>RJA! B2(! )(E(.19%(*'! 10! -1$#5'!%('21)5! 10!

915'!188#9,*8:!(E,.#,'&1*A!/,8&.&'&(5;!=N;!?MM\?FRA!

Be1-'e191#.15;! +A;! I=>>NJA! B2(! 6(5&7*! <*)! V%9.(%(*','&1*! G0! +-1)#8'!

6(E(.19%(*'! +-18(55! T1)(.5! V*! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! Q1%9,*&(5;! +26A! B2(5&5;!

3(5(,-82! V*5'&'#'(! 01-! '2(! C#&.'! ,*)! [#%,*! H*E&-1*%(*';! P*&E(-5&':! 10!

",.01-);!PdA!

Be1-'e191#.15;!+A;!Q119(-;!3A;!Q2,*;!+A!r!d,7&17.1#;!TA!I=>>RJA!Q.&(*'5y!,8'&E&'&(5!

,'!'2(!)(5&7*!0-1*'!\(*)A!6(5&7*!5'#)&(5;!ROM\RD@A!

X,&52*,E&;!XA;!dA;!d#(82.(-;!_A! h-;! I=>>MJA!6(5&7*!"8&(*8(!3(5(,-82!T('21)5!,*)!

+,''(-*5!V**1E,'&*7!V*01-%,'&1*!,*)!Q1%%#*&8,'&1*!B(82*1.17:A!B,:.1-!

r!/-,*8&5!U-1#9;!=NN9A;!Q2,9'(-!=A!

X,*! <K(*;! hA;HA;I=>>NJA! T,*,7(%(*'! -(5(,-82! $,5()! 1*! '2(! 9,-,)&7%! 10! '2(!

)(5&7*! 58&(*8(5W! B2(! 4#(5'! 01-! 0&(.)\'(5'()! ,*)! 7-1#*)()! '(82*1.17&8,.!

-#.(5A!h1#-*,.!10!T,*,7(%(*'!"'#)&(5;!EAN?;!*A=;!9A=?F\=NR;!=>>NA!

_,,.;! <A! I=>>RJA! B2(! 5'-,'(7&8! 9(-01-%,*8(! %,*,7(%(*'! 8:8.(A! +(-01-%,*8(!

T(,5#-(%(*'!<5518&,'&1*A!

_,,.;!<A!r!Q1#*(';![A!I=>>RJA!b(551*5!.(,-*()!0-1%!$,.,*8()!581-(8,-)A!V*!]((.:;!

<A;! d(**(-.(:;! TA! r! _,.'(-5;! <A! IH)5AJ! +(-01-%,*8(! %(,5#-(%(*'! r!

%,*,7(%(*'W!9#$.&8!r!9-&E,'(A!

_,-);!hA!r!6,*&(.;!HA!I=>>RJA!C(*(0&'5!T,*,7(%(*'!Z!6(.&E(-&*7!X,.#(!0-1%!V"!r!

VB!V*E(5'%(*'5;!_(5'!"#55(`!Pd;!_&.(:A!

Page 249: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@R!

_,-);!hA!r!H.E&*;!3A!I?FFFJA!<!*(S!0-,%(S1-K!01-!%,*,7&*7!VB\(*,$.()!$#5&*(55!

82,*7(A!V*01-%,'&1*!5:5'(%5!^1#-*,.;!F;!?FM\===A!

_,-);! hA! r! T#--,:;! +A! I?FFMJA! C(*(0&'5! T,*,7(%(*'W! C(5'! +-,8'&8(! U#&)(.&*(5A!

V"3Q\CT\FM>?R;! Q-,*0&(.)! "8211.! 10! T,*,7(%(*';! V*01-%,'&1*! ":5'(%5!

3(5(,-82!Q(*'-(A!Q-,*0&(.);!PdA!

_,-);! hA;! B,:.1-;! +A! r! C1*);! +A! I?FFOJA! V)(*'&0&8,'&1*;! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)!

%(,5#-(%(*'! 10! V"aVB! $(*(0&'5W! ,*! (%9&-&8,.! 5'#):! 10! 8#--(*'! 9-,8'&8(A!

C-1S*;! <A! ,*)! 3(%(*:&;! 6! I()5J! "(81*)! H#-19(,*! Q1*0(-(*8(! 1*!

V*01-%,'&1*! B(82*1.17:! V*E(5'%(*'! HE,.#,'&1*A! [(*.(:! T,*,7(%(*'!

Q1..(7(;![(*.(:!1*!B2,%(5A!

_,-);!hA;!B,:.1-;!+A!r!C1*);!+A!I?FFRJA!HE,.#,'&1*!,*)!-(,.&e,'&1*!10!V"aVB!$(*(0&'5W!

,*! (%9&-&8,.! 5'#):!10! 8#--(*'! 9-,8'&8(A! H#-19(,*! h1#-*,.! 10! V*01-%,'&1*!

":5'(%5;!N;!=?NZ==OA!

_,#'(-5;! CA! I=>>OJA! B2(! ,))()! E,.#(! 10! 0,8&.&'&(5! %,*,7(%(*'W! $(*82%,-K&*7!

S1-K!9-18(55(5A!/,8&.&'&(5;!=@;!?N=\?O?A!

_2((.(-;!6A;!r!"&..,*9{{;!TA!I?FFMJA!B2(!5',K(21.)(-!81-91-,'&1*;!+&'%,*A!

_2&'&*7;!3A;!6,E&(5;!hA;!r!d*#.;!TA!I?FFRJA!V*E(5'%(*'!,99-,&5,.!01-!VB!5:5'(%5A!V*!

_&..818K5;! bA! IH)AJ! V*E(5'&*7! &*! &*01-%,'&1*! 5:5'(%5W! (E,.#,'&1*! ,*)!

%,*,7(%(*'A!](S!g1-K;!]g;!Q2,9%,*!,*)![,..A!

_&*'(-;!TAq!"%&'2;!QAq!T1--&5;!+Aq!Q&8%&.;!"A!I=>>RJA!6&-(8'&1*5!01-!/#'#-(!3(5(,-82!

&*! +-1^(8'! T,*,7(%(*'W! B2(! T,&*! /&*)&*75! 10! Pd! 71E(-*%(*'\0#*)()!

-(5(,-82!*('S1-KA!V*'(-*,'&1*,.!h1#-*,.!10!+-1^(8'!T,*,7(%(*';!EA!=N;!*AD;!

99A!R@D\RNFA!

g,'(5;! dA;! C,--(&-1! b&%,;! hA;! ",91#*'e&5;! "A;! Be1-'e191#.15;! +A! <*)! d,7&17.1#;!TA!

I=>>FJA!C(3(,.!$(*(0&'5!-(,.&5,'&1*!%1)(.!&*'(7-,'()!,99-1,82W!B2(!$#&.'!

(*E&-1*%(*'!.&0(8:8.(!,*)!1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!E&(S5;!_#0!Q.:=R=:!=#)&'#.)$+#./!

-*D2+($3D;!<9-&.!=>>F;!C-&72'1*;!PdA!

g,'(5;! dA;! ",91#*'e&5;! "A;! b1#;! HA! ,*)! d,7&17.1#;! TA! I=>>DJA! uC(3(,.W! B11.5! ,*)!

%('21)5! 01-! &%9.(%(*'&*7! $(*(0&'5! -(,.&5,'&1*! ,*)! %,*,7(%(*'v;! O'2!

Page 250: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

3(0(-(*8(5!!

"#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! =@M!

]1-)&8! Q1*0(-(*8(! 1*! Q1*5'-#8'&1*! H81*1%&85! ,*)! G-7,*&5,'&1*;! ?>\?=!

h#*(!=>>F;!V8(.,*)A!

g&*;!3A!I=>>@JA!Q,5(!"'#):!-(5(,-82W!)(5&7*!,*)!%('21)5W!B2&-)!()&'&1*!P"<W!",7(!

9#$.&8,'&1*5A!

z&%%(-%,*;! <A! r! T,-'&*;! TA! I=>>?JA! +15'! 188#9,*8:! (E,.#,'&1*W! $(*(0&'5! ,*)!

$,--&(-5A!C#&.)&*7!3(5(,-82!,*)!V*01-%,'&1*;!=F;!?RD\?MNA!

z&%-&*7;!QA!r!3(&e(*5'(&*;!hA!HA!I?FD>JA!+15'!G88#9,*8:!HE,.#,'&1*W!<*!GE(-E&(S;!

H*E&-1*%(*'!,*)!C(2,E&1#-!8&'()!&*!z&%%(-%,*;!<A!,*)!T,-'&*;!TA;!=>>?A!

u+15'!188#9,*8:!(E,.#,'&1*W!$(*(0&'5!,*)!$,--&(-5vA!C#&.)&*7!3(5(,-82!,*)!

V*01-%,'&1*;!=F;!?RD\?MNA!

zS&K,(.;! GA;! "%:-K;! hA! 3A! I=>??JA! +-1^(8'! %,*,7(%(*'! 01-! '2(! 8-(,'&1*! 10!

1-7,*&5,'&1*,.!E,.#(A!b1*)1*W!"9-&*7(-A!

!

!

Page 251: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "#$!

!""#$%&'#()

!

Page 252: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "#=!

!""#$%&*)+),)-#'.$&/0#()1.21)#3452'#)4#$#6&1()

5#27&(21&8$)

98(.&$:);2$5&)<)9;)

>;30*(<! ?5(8*! *3! 5! 4'/0(*12'! 9;8! 34854'<*/! &;:*/@! )'&:;@6'(4! 4054! 053! 7''(!

A*)':@!23')!7@!B5&5('3'!/;6&5(*'3!C?*(<D!,=$=EF!G4!A53!)'H':;&')!*(!,=IJ!5()!

*3! 5! 92()56'(45:! ':'6'(4! ;9! .;45:! K25:*4@! L;(48;:! C.KLEF! .0'! 7'('9*43! ;9! 40*3!

4'/0(*12'! *3! 9;2()! 4;! *(/:2)'M! *(4'<854*;(! ;9! 34854'<*/! ;7N'/4*H'3! A*40! 45/4*/5:!

)5*:@!65(5<'6'(4D! 40'! 5&&:*/54*;(! ;9! 40'! &:5(-);-/0'/O-5/4! /*8/:'! 4;! 723*('33!

&8;/'33! 65(5<'6'(4D! &585::':! &:5((*(<! 5()! '+'/24*;(! 6'40;);:;<@D!

/;6&5(@A*)'! 5&&8;5/0! 5()! *6&8;H'6'(43! *(! /;662(*/54*;(! C.'((5(4! P!

Q;7'843D!"JJ,EF!!

%6;(<! 40'! *332'3! 4054! 6;4*H54')! 40'! )'H':;&6'(4! ;9! 32/0! 4'/0(*12'! *3! 40'!

)*99*/2:4@! ;9! /:'58:@! )'9*(*(<! 723*('33! <;5:3! 5()! 6'532857:'! 458<'43D! 40'!

/;(9:*/4*(<! 8'12*8'6'(43! ;9! )*99'8'(4! )'&5846'(43! A*40*(! 40'! ;8<5(*354*;(! 5()!

40'!:5/O!;9!&8;/'33!;A('830*&!:'5)*(<!4;!:*44:'!/;662(*/54*;(D!(;!2()'8345()*(<!

;9! '5/0! ;40'8R3! ('')3! 5()! 5! 7:56*(<! /2:428'! A0'(! 3;6'40*(<! <;'3! A8;(<!

C>24/0*(3D!"JJ$EF!

.0'! 4'/0(*12'! *3! /;6&;3')! 7@! 40'! 9;::;A*(<! ':'6'(43! C.'((5(4! P! Q;7'843D!

"JJ,EM!!

5F S*H'T@'58! H*3*;(D! ;8! 5(! *6&8;H'6'(4! &:5(! 753')! ;(! *(4'8(5:! 5()! '+4'8(5:!

;7345/:'3D!5()!8'H*3*;(!753')!;(!*(&24!98;6!5::!65(5<'83!;(!40'!)8594!&:5(U!!

7F V('T@'58!&:5(D!;8!40'!3':'/4*;(!;9!5/4*H*4*'3!753')!;(!9'53*7*:*4@!5()!:*O':*0;;)!

;9! 5/0*'H*(<! )'3*8')! 8'32:43! C5(5:@3*3! ;9! '(H*8;(6'(4! 5()! :534! @'58R3!

&'89;865(/'EU!

/F W'&:;@6'(4! 4;! )'&5846'(43D! 3':'/4*(<! ;&4*626! 458<'43! 5()! 6'5(3! CO'@!

*6&:'6'(454*;(! *4'63! 5()! 5! /;(3*)'854*;(! ;9! 0;A! 40'@! /5(! 3@34'654*/5::@!

5//;6&:*30!40'!&:5(EU!

Page 253: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "XJ!

)F W'45*:')!*6&:'6'(454*;(D!A0*/0!65N;8!9;/23!*3!;(!/;(4*(<'(/@!&:5((*(<D!40'!

5*6! *3! 4;! 5/0*'H'! 5! :'H':! ;9! 3':9T)*5<(;3*3D! 3':9T/;88'/4*;(! 5()! H*325:!

&8'3'(454*;(!;9!5/4*;(U!

'F Y;(40:@!)*5<(;3*3D!30;A*(<!40'!*332'3!4054!0':&')!;8!0*()'8')!&8;<8'33!5()!

40'!5/4*H*4*'3!4;!7'('9*4!98;6!40*3!:'58(*(<U!5()!

9F Z8'3*)'(4R3!5((25:!)*5<(;3*3D!A0*/0! *3! 9;/23')!;(!(26'8*/5:! 458<'43D!724!40'!

65N;8! 9;/23! *3! ;(! 40'! &8;/'33! 4054! 2()'8:*'3! 40'! 8'32:43! 4;!65O'! 328'! 4054!

65(5<'6'(4!*(!'5/0!3'/4;8!;9!40'!;8<5(*[54*;(!053!5(!5)'1254'!/5&57*:*4@F!

.0'!>;3*0(!?5(8*!5&&8;5/0!23'3!408''!65*(!4;;:3!4;!32&&;84!&;:*/@!)'&:;@6'(4!

CL2)('@D!"JJ=EM!!!

ZWL%!/@/:'M!5(!*4'854*H'!9;28T34'&!&8;7:'6T3;:H*(<!&8;/'33U!

5F L8;33T92(/4*;(5:! 65(5<'6'(4! CLSYEM! '(57:'3! 5! /;(4*(2;23! /0'/O*(<! ;9!

458<'43!5()!6'5(3!408;2<0;24!40'!&8;N'/4D!*(H;:H*(<!5!/8;33T92(/4*;(5:!<8;2&!

C*(4'8(5:! /;3426'83D! '+4'8(5:! /;3426'83D! 345O'0;:)'83D! '4/FE! 4;! 75:5(/'! 40'!

8'&8'3'(454*;(!;9!40'!;8<5(*[54*;(!;(!40'!>;30*(!&:5(U!

7F L54/075::M! 40*3! 4;;:! /8'54'3! 5! 9'')75/O! 3@34'6! 4054! 5::;A3! 5! /;(4*(2;23! 5()!

62:4*)*8'/4*;(5:! /;662(*/54*;(D! 7'*(<! '33'(4*5:! 9;8! 40'! )'H':;&6'(4! ;9!

458<'43!5()!5/4*;(!&:5(3F!

! !

Page 254: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X,!

=8:&'27)>523#?85@)!""582'.)<)=>!)

.0'! \(*4')! ]454'3! %<'(/@! 9;8! G(4'8(54*;(5:! W'H':;&6'(4! C\]%GWED! Z85/4*/5:!

L;(/'&43!G(/;8&;854')!CZLGED!5()!.'56!.'/0(;:;<*'3!G(/;8&;854')!A'8'!56;(<!

40'!'58:@!)'3*<('83!5()!23'83!;9!40'!^;<9856'D!3*(/'!40'!'58:@!,=_JR3!F.0'!9;/23!

;9! 40*3! 5&&8;5/0! *3! 4;! /8'54'! 5! /;66;(! 2()'8345()*(<! 57;24! 40'! 34854'<*/!

;7N'/4*H'3! 5()! 40'!6'5(3! 4;! 5/0*'H'! 32//'33! C`VQ%WD!,===EF!%//;8)*(<! 4;! 40*3!

5240;8D!40'!5&&8;5/0!*(4'(43!4;M!

%::;A!5!/:'58!H*'A!;9!40'!&8;<8566'3R!'+&'/4')!*6&5/43U!

5F W'9*('! 345O'0;:)'83! 8'3&;(3*7*:*4*'3! 8'<58)*(<! 40'! 5/0*'H'6'(4! ;9! '+&'/4')!

8'32:43U!!

7F G::234854'!40'!':'6'(43!4054!/;(34*424'3!40'!&8;<8566'!5()!40'*8!*(4'85/4*;(3D!

5::;A*(<!5!7'44'8!2()'8345()*(<!;9!40'!&8;N'/4U!

/F L;(3*)'8!)*99'8'(4!&;*(43!;9!H*'A!3*62:45(';23:@!*(!40'!&8;N'/4R3!/;(/'&4*;(U!

5()!

)F %H;*)! 5! 7:56*(<! /2:428'D! 'H5:254*(<! 40'! &8;N'/4! 753')! ;(! 40'!6;34! 8'5:*34*/!

&:5(!4;!5/0*'H'!32//'33F!

.0'! ^;<9856'! *3! 5! /;8'! 4;;:! 23')!A*40*(! Z8;N'/4! L@/:'!Y5(5<'6'(4! Ca28;&'5(!

L;66*33*;(D! "JJ"EF! G4! *3! 5! 4'/0(*12'! 4;! *)'(4*9@! 5()! 5(5:@3'! 5! <*H'(! 3*4254*;(D!

5()!4;!)'9*('!;7N'/4*H'3!5()!5/4*H*4*'3!4054!30;2:)!7'!2()'845O'(!4;!*6&8;H'!40'!

3*4254*;(F! .0'! ^;<9856'! 5:3;! &8;H*)'3! 40'! 753*3! 9;8! &:5((*(<! 5/4*H*4*'3D!

)'H':;&*(<!5!6;(*4;8*(<!3@34'6D!5()!5!9856'A;8O!9;8!'H5:254*;(F!

.0'!65*(!':'6'(4!;9!40*3!5&&8;5/0!*3!40'!^;<*/5:!S856'A;8O!Y548*+!*4!30;A3!40'!

6;34! *6&;845(4!53&'/43!;9!5!&8;N'/4! 9;8!5!12*/O!5()!'53@!H*325:*354*;(!C`VQ%WD!

,===EF!!

) )

Page 255: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X"!

-.#)A#(&:$)B027&1C)+$%&'2185)<)AB+)

.0'! )'H':;&6'(4! ;9! 40'! WKG! A53! 6;4*H54')! 7@! 5! :5/O! ;9! '6&053*3! ;(! )'3*<(!

125:*4@! *(! 40'! '58:@! 345<'3! ;9! &'89;865(/'! 6'5328'6'(4! 9;::;A*(<! Q'40*(O*(<!

L;(3482/4*;(!Cb5((!'4!5:FD!"JJ#EF!.0'8'!A53!5!/;(/'8(!4054!40'!H5:2'!;9!72*:)*(<!

)'3*<(! A53! 7'*(<! 8':'<54')! 4;! 5! 3'/;()58@! *332'! 7'/523'! 40'! &'89;865(/'T

*6&8;H*(<! 5<'()5! 9;/23')! 0'5H*:@! ;(! 40'! 6'5328'6'(4! ;9! &0@3*/5:! &8;/'33'3D!

'F<F!8')2/*(<!4*6'D!/;34!5()!A534'U!5()!(;4!62/0!544'(4*;(!A53!7'*(<!<*H'(!4;!40'!

125:*4@!;9!)'3*<(')!3&5/'3F!

.0'!W'3*<(!K25:*4@!G()*/54;8!CWKGE!A53!)'H':;&')!'+&:*/*4:@!4;!6'5328'!125:*4@!

;9! )'3*<(! '67;)*')! *(! 40'! &8;)2/4! -! 72*:)*(<3! 40'63':H'3F! .0'! 408''! 65*(!

':'6'(43! ;9! 40'! WKG! 4;;:O*4! C/;(/'&425:! 9856'A;8OD! )545! <540'8*(<! 4;;:D!

A'*<04*(<!6'/05(*36E!65&&')!40'!H5:2'!;9!72*:)*(<3!*(!8':54*;(!4;!40'*8!)'3*<(!

9;8!)*99'8'(4!23'3!5()!40'*8!57*:*4@!4;!6''4!5!H58*'4@!;9!&0@3*/5:D!53&*854*;(5:!5()!

'6;4*;(5:!('')3!;9!;//2&5(43!5()!23'83!Cb5((!'4!5:FD!"JJ#EF!!

WKG!5&&:*'3!5!3482/428')!5&&8;5/0!4;!533'33!)'3*<(!125:*4@!753')!;(!40'!6;)':!

7@!40'!'(<*(''8!c*482H*23D!A0;!)'3/8*7')!)'3*<(!*(!4'863!;9!24*:*453D!9*86*453!5()!

H'(23453D! ;94'(! 485(3:54')! 53! /;66;)*4@D! 9*86('33! 5()! )':*<04! Cb5((! '4! 5:FD!

"JJ#EF!WKG!23'3!5(!*(4'8&8'454*;(!;9!40'3'!4'863!53M!

C5E! S2(/4*;(5:*4@!C24*:*453E!T!40'!5885(<'6'(4D!125:*4@!5()!*(4'88':54*;(30*&!;9!

3&5/'3!5()!0;A!40'!72*:)*(<!*3!)'3*<(')!4;!7'!23'92:!4;!5::U!

C7E! d2*:)! K25:*4@! C9*86*453E! T! 40'! '(<*(''8*(<! &'89;865(/'! ;9! 40'! 72*:)*(<D!

A0*/0!*(/:2)'3!3482/4285:!3457*:*4@!5()!40'!*(4'<854*;(D!359'4@!5()!8;7234('33!;9!

40'!3@34'63D!9*(*30'3!5()!9*44*(<3U!5()!

C/E! G6&5/4! CH'(23453E! T! 40'! 72*:)*(<R3! 57*:*4@! 4;! /8'54'! 5! 3'(3'! ;9! &:5/'D!

*)'(4*4@! 5()! /0585/4'8D! 5()! 05H'! 5! &;3*4*H'! '99'/4! ;(! 40'! :;/5:! /;662(*4@! 5()!

'(H*8;(6'(4F!

.0'!)545!<540'8*(<! 4;;:! *3!)*H*)')! *(! 9;28!3'/4*;(3D!5//;8)*(<! 4;! 40'!/;(/'&425:!

9856'A;8OM! 5! 9*834! 3'/4*;(! /;::'/43! *(9;8654*;(! 57;24! 40'! 8'3&;()'(4! 5()! 40'*8!

Page 256: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X#!

5*63!9;8!40'!72*:)*(<D!53!A'::!53!40'!345<'!;9!)'H':;&6'(4!;9!40'!72*:)*(<U!3'/4*;(!

4A;!9;/23'3!;(!92(/4*;(!5()!053!408''!3273'/4*;(3M!23'D!5//'33!5()!3&5/'U!3'/4*;(!

408''! 9;/23'3! ;(! *6&5/4! 5()! /;(45*(3! 9;28! 3273'/4*;(3M! 9;86! 5()! 654'8*5:3D!

*(4'8(5:! '(H*8;(6'(4D! 2875(! 5()! 3;/*5:! *(4'<854*;(D! 5()! /0585/4'8! 5()!

*((;H54*;(U! 5()! 3'/4*;(! 9;28! '+&:;8'3! 72*:)! 125:*4@! 5()! /;(45*(3! 408''!

3273'/4*;(3M!&'89;865(/'D!'(<*(''8*(<!3@34'63!5()!/;(3482/4*;(F!

.0'! WKG! 92(/4*;(3! 408;2<0! 5! /;67*(54*;(! ;9! 4A;! 65N;8! ':'6'(43M! 3482/428')!

A;8O30;&3!5()!;(:*('!4;;:3!CWKGD!"JJ=EF!Z8'3'(454*;(3!54!40'!A;8O30;&3!78*'9!5(!

533'336'(4!<8;2&D!9;86')!98;6!6'67'83!;9!40'!72*:)*(<!/;662(*4@D!408;2<0;24!

40'! )'3*<(! 5()! 72*:)! &8;/'33F! Y'67'83! ;9! 40'! 533'336'(4! <8;2&! 58'! O(;A(!

*()*H*)25::@! 53! e8'3&;()'(43RF! .0'! ;(:*('! 4;;:3! <*H'! 40*3! 533'336'(4! <8;2&! 5!

3482/428'!408;2<0!A0*/0!4;!/;(3*)'8!5!3'8*'3!;9!*6&;845(4!*332'3!8':54*(<!4;!40'*8!

72*:)*(<F! .0*3!A5@D! 40'! 4;;:! 533*343! &584*/*&5(43! *(! 8'5/0*(<! 5! /;(3'(323! 57;24!

&8*;8*4*'3! 5()! 8':54*;(30*&3F! G(! )'3*<(*(<! 9;8! :58<'! 62:4*T23'8! 72*:)*(<3D! *4! *3!

*6&;845(4!4;!2()'8345()!40'!)*99'8'(4!H*'A3!;9!23'8!<8;2&3!5()!*()*H*)25:!23'83!

5()!40'(!4;!8'5/0!/;(3'(323!57;24!3058')!&8*;8*4*'3!5()!8':54*;(30*&3F!

.0'!A;8O30;&3!58'!6')*54')!7@!5!95/*:*454;8!A0;!*3!57:'!4;!533'33!40'!8'32:43!;9!

40'!;(:*('!4;;:3!5()!8'/;8)!40'!;&*(*;(3!;9!40;3'!&8'3'(4!CWKGD!"JJ=EF!.0'!;(:*('!

4;;:3! 45O'! 40'! 9;86!;9!12'34*;((5*8'3!5()!&8;H*)'! *(345(4! 8'32:43! 4054!<'('854'!

)*3/233*;(! )28*(<! '5/0! A;8O30;&D! *(9;86*(<! 40'! &8;/'33! ;9! )'3*<(*(<! 40'!

72*:)*(<F!

.0'!A;8O30;&3!30;2:)!45O'!&:5/'!54!5::!345<'3!;9!5!72*:)*(<!&8;N'/4F! G)'5::@!WKG!

30;2:)!7'!&24! *(4;!&85/4*/'!54! 40'! 9*834!A;8O30;&!0':)!)28*(<!40'!78*'9*(<!345<'!

5()!40'(!/;(4*(2')!408;2<0;24!40'!&8;N'/4F!>;A'H'8D!40'!WKG!/5(!7'!23')!54!5(@!

&053'!;9!40'!)'H':;&6'(4!&8;/'33!CWKGD!"JJ=EM!!

5F Z053'!,M!40'!WKG!&8;/'33!7'<*(3!A*40!5!78*'9*(<!345<'!A;8O30;&D!*(!A0*/0!40'!

533'336'(4!<8;2&!30;2:)!)'9*('!5()!*)'(4*9@!40'*8!&8*;8*4*'3!9;8!40'!72*:)*(<D!

)'H':;&!5!/;66;(!:5(<25<'!4;!/;662(*/54'!A*40!32&&:*'83D!9;86!5!/;66;(!

2()'8345()*(<!;9!A054!/;(34*424'3!32//'33!5()!95*:28'!4;!533'33!'5/0!345<'!;9!

Page 257: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "XX!

&8;N'/4!5()!&8;H*)'!&8;N'/4R3!)'3*<('83!5!*(T)'&40!2()'8345()*(<!;9!40'!78*'9!

5()!23'83!('')3U!

7F Z053'!"M!54!40'!)'3*<(!345<'D!WKG!&8;/'33!/5(!0':&!4;!'(328'!)'3*<(!'+/'::'(/'!

408;2<0!65*(45*(*(<!40'!)*5:;<!7'4A''(!40'!533'336'(4!<8;2&!5()!32&&:*'83D!

'(57:*(<! 40'!533'336'(4!;9!)'3*<(!753')!;(! 40'! 85(<'!;9!23'3!5()!('')3!;9!

40'!72*:)*(<!5()!*(9;86*(<!)'3*<('83!A*40!9'')75/OU!

/F Z053'! #M! 54! 40'! &8'T/;(3482/4*;(! 345<'D! 40'! 533'336'(4! <8;2&! /5(! 8'T533'33!

)'3*<(! 4;! '(328'! 5::! *332'3! 05H'! 7''(! 8'3;:H')D! /'84*9@*(<! 4054! 40'! 72*:)*(<!

A*::!354*39@!'+&'/454*;(3U!

)F Z053'!XM!54!40'!/;(3482/4*;(!&053'D!WKG!/5(!;(:@!7'!5&&:*')!A0'(!40'!72*:)*(<!

*3!/;6&:'4'D!4;!533'33!*9!40'!)':*H'8')!72*:)*(<!92:9*:3!40'!533'336'(4!<8;2&R3!

'+&'/454*;(3U!

'F Z053'!IM! 54! 40'!23'!&053'D!WKG! /5(!7'!23')!53!5!&;34T;//2&5(/@!'H5:254*;(D!

)'4'86*(*(<! 40'! *6&5/4! ;9! 40'! 72*:)*(<! ;(! *43! 23'83D! 5()! *(9;86*(<! 32//'33!

53&'/43D!:*6*454*;(3!5()!95*:28'3!4;!345O'0;:)'83F!

) )

Page 258: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "XI!

B027&1C)>0$'1&8$)A#"78C3#$1)<)B>A)

K25:*4@! S2(/4*;(!W'&:;@6'(4! CKSWE!A53! /;(/'*H')! *(! B5&5(! *(! 40'! :54'! ,=fJ3D!

)28*(<! 5(! '85! A0'(! B5&5('3'! *()2348*'3! 78;O'! 98;6! 40'*8! &;34Tg;8:)! g58! GG!

6;)'! ;9! &8;)2/4! )'H':;&6'(4! 408;2<0! *6*454*;(! 5()! /;&@*(<! 5()! 6;H')! 4;!

&8;)2/4! )'H':;&6'(4! 753')! ;(! ;8*<*(5:*4@! C%O5;D! ,==_EF! KSW!A53! 7;8(! *(! 40*3!

'(H*8;(6'(4! 53! 5!6'40;)! ;8! /;(/'&4! 9;8! ('A! &8;)2/4! )'H':;&6'(4! 2()'8! 40'!

2678'::5!;9!.;45:!K25:*4@!L;(48;:F!!

.0'!KSW!*3!5!&8;/'33!4054!053!7''(!23')!9;8!65(5<*(<!40'!)'H':;&6'(4!;9!('A!

65(295/428')!&8;)2/43!Ca:)*(!P!>*O:'D!"JJ#EF!%//;8)*(<!4;!40'!356'!5240;83D!*(!

40*3!&8;/'33D!7;40!3&;O'(!5()!2(3&;O'(!('')3!;9!40'!/234;6'83!58'!)'4'86*(')D!

&8*;8*4*[')D! 5()! 485(3:54')! *(4;!)'3*<(!&5856'4'83F! ]2/0!)'3*<(!&5856'4'83!58'!

533*<(')! 3&'/*9*/! 458<'4! H5:2'3! 5()! 58'! 98'12'(4:@! /0'/O')! 5<5*(34! /234;6'83R!

('')3!408;2<0;24!40'!)'H':;&6'(4!/@/:'!4;!'(328'!/234;6'83R!354*395/4*;(!A*40!

40'!'()!&8;)2/4F!

.08;2<0! 5! 3'4! ;9! &:5((*(<! 5()! /;662(*/54*;(! 8;24*('3D! 40'! KSW! 9;/23'3! 5()!

/;;8)*(54'3! 3O*::3! A*40*(! 5(! ;8<5(*[54*;(D! 9*834! 4;! )'3*<(D! 40'(! 4;! 65(295/428'!

5()!658O'4!<;;)3!4054!/;3426'83!A5(4!4;!&28/053'!C>523'8!P!L:523*(<D!,=$$EF!

.0'! 356'! 5240;83! &;*(4! ;24! 4054! 40'! 9;2()54*;(! ;9! 40'! 0;23'! ;9! 125:*4@! *3! 40'!

7':*'9! 4054! &8;)2/43! 30;2:)! 7'! )'3*<(')! 4;! 8'9:'/4! /234;6'83R! )'3*8'3D! 3;!

658O'4*(<! &';&:'D! )'3*<('83D! '(<*(''83! 6234! A;8O! 4;<'40'8! 98;6! 40'! 4*6'! 5!

&8;)2/4!*3!9*834!/;(/'*H')F!S2840'86;8'D! *4!/;(34*424'3!5!O*()!;9!/;(/'&425:!65&!

4054! &8;H*)'3! 40'! 6'5(3! 9;8! *(4'8T92(/4*;(5:! &:5((*(<! 5()! /;662(*/54*;(3D!

A0'8'!&';&:'!A*40!)*99'8'(4!&8;7:'63!5()!8'3&;(3*7*:*4*'3!/5(!408530!;24!)'3*<(!

&8*;8*4*'3!A0*:'!8'9'88*(<!4;!&544'8(3!;9!'H*)'(/'!;(!40'!0;23'R3!<8*)F!

) )

Page 259: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "Xf!

D58E#'1()&$)F8$15877#%)G$H&58$3#$1()IDJ+KFG)LM)

ZQG`La"! *3! 5! 3482/428')! 6'40;)! 9;8! '99'/4*H'! &8;N'/4! 65(5<'6'(4D! 9*834!

'3457:*30')! *(! ,=$=! 7@! 40'! L'(485:! L;6&24'8! 5()!.':'/;662(*/54*;(3!%<'(/@!

CLL.%ED!A0*/0!*3!(;A!40'!V99*/'!;9!b;H'8(6'(4!L;66'8/'F!!.0'!6'40;)!*3!23')!

'+4'(3*H':@! 7@! 40'! \?! <;H'8(6'(4! 5()! *3! A*)':@! 8'/;<(*3')! 5()! 23')! *(! 40'!

&8*H54'!3'/4;8D!7;40!*(!40'!\?!5()!*(4'8(54*;(5::@F!

ZQG`La"! *3! 5! &8;/'33T753')! 5&&8;5/0D! /;6&;3')! 7@! '*<04! )*99'8'(4! &8;/'33'3!

65(5<'6'(4D!A0*/0!*3!533*<(')!4;!5!&8;N'/4!7;58)M!

5F ]4584*(<!2&!5!&8;N'/4M!5!&8'T&8;N'/4!&8;/'33!4;!'(328'!4054!&8'T8'12*3*4'3!58'!

*(!&:5/'D!'F<F!&8;N'/4!65(5<'6'(4!4'56D!78*'9D!5&&8;5/0D!125:*4@!'+&'/454*;(3D!

8*3O!:;<!5()!*(*4*54*;(!&:5(U!

7F W*8'/4*(<! 5! &8;N'/4M! 5! &8;N'/4! 7;58)! *3! )'9*(')! 4;! 65(5<'! 7@! '+/'&4*;(D!

6;(*4;8! H*5! 8'&;843! 5()! /;(48;:! 408;2<0! 5! (267'8! ;9! )'/*3*;(! &;*(43D! 'F<F!

5240;8*[*(<! *(*4*54*;(D! /;66*44*(<!6;8'! 8'3;28/'3!54! 345<'!7;2()58*'3! 594'8!

/0'/O*(<! 8'32:43! 3;! 958D!6;(*4;8*(<D! &8;H*)*(<! <2*)5(/'D! 8'5/4*(<! 4;! 408'543D!

5()!/;(9*86*(<!;24/;6'3!4;!/:;3'!40'!&8;N'/4U!

/F G(*4*54*(<!5!&8;N'/4M!&:5(!9;8!125:*4@D!/;34!5()!4*6'D!65O'!328'!723*('33!/53'!*3!

5//'&457:'! 5()! *(H'346'(43! N234*9*')! C/;(3*)'8*(<! 40'! 8*3O3ED! 53! A'::! 53!

&8;H*)*(<! 40'!753':*('! 9;8!)'/*3*;(!65O*(<!&8;/'33'3F!.0'!O'@!);/26'(4!;9!

40*3!&8;/'33!)'9*('3!40'!A054D!A0@D!A0;D!A0'(!5()!0;AU!

)F Y5(5<*(<! 345<'! 7;2()58*'3M! 53328'! &8;)2/43! &:5((')! 05H'! 7''(! /;6&:'4')!

53! )'9*(')D! 5240;8*3'! 40'! 34584! ;9! ('+4! 345<'D! 8'/;8)! 6'5328'6'(43! 5()!

:'33;(3!:'58(')U!

'F L;(48;::*(<!5!345<'M!5::;/54'!A;8OD!'(328'!5!345<'!345@3!;(!/;283'!5()!8'5/4!4;!

2('+&'/4')! 'H'(43F! Y5*(! &8;)2/43! 58'! A;8O! &5/O5<'3D! &8;<8'33! 8'&;843D!

&8;N'/4!*332'3!:;<D!8*3O!:;<!5()!345<'!&:5(U!

9F Y5(5<*(<! &8;)2/4! )':*H'8@M! '(328'! &:5((')! &8;)2/43! 58'! /8'54')! 5()!

)':*H'8')D! *(/:2)*(<!'(328*(<!A;8O! *3!);('!5()! 4054! 40'! /;6&:'4')!&8;)2/4!

6''43!125:*4@!/8*4'8*5U!

<F L:;3*(<! 5! &8;N'/4M! 56;(<! ;40'8! 5/4*H*4*'3! *(/:2)'3! /0'/O*(<! 40'! '+4'(4! 4;!

A0*/0! '+&'/4')! ;7N'/4*H'3! 05H'! 7''(! 6'4D! 533'33*(<! &8;)2/43! 05H'! 7''(!

Page 260: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X_!

05()')! ;H'8! 5()! 5//'&4')! 7@! /;3426'8! 5()! <'('854*(<! 5! :'33;(3! :'58(')!

8'&;84U!

0F Z:5((*(<M!5!8'&'5457:'!&8;/'33!A0*/0!*3!*6&;845(4!*(!;40'8!&8;/'33'3!32/0!53!

&:5((*(<! *(*4*54*;(! 345<'D! &8;N'/4D! 5//'&4*(<!A;8O! &5/O5<'! 5()! &8;)2/*(<! 5!

'+/'&4*;(!&:5(F!

! !

Page 261: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X$!

=&(1)86)1887(N3#1.8%()5#721#%)18)'83"25#%)2""582'.#()

• .;;:3h6'40;)3!4;!'(<5<'!345O'0;:)'83!

o ^;<*/5:!S856'A;8O!6548*+!C^;<9856'E!

o L54/075::!C>;30*(!?5(8*E!

o d'('9*43!)'&'()'(/@!65&3!

o %99*(*4@!)*5<856!C>;30*(!?5(8*E!

• .;;:3h6'40;)3!4;!)'&:;@!34854'<@!*(4;!;&'854*;(3!

o ^;<*/5:!S856'A;8O!Y548*+!C^;<9856'E!

o Q'5:*34*/!aH5:254*;(!

o .0';8*'3!;9!L05(<'!

o aH*)'(/'T753')!Z;:*/@!

o `'4A;8O!.0';8@!

o W*6'(3*;(5:!%(5:@3*3!

o d23*('33! /53'M! *(/:2)*(<D! 8'53;(3D! ;&4*;(3D! '+&'/4')! 7'('9*43D! /;34D!

4*6'3/5:'D!*(H'346'(4!5&&85*35:!CZQG`La"E!

o L;(4*<'(/@!&:5(!C>;30*(!?5(8*E!

• .;;:3h6'40;)3!4;!6;(*4;8!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!

o K2'34*;((5*8'3!9;8!'H5:254*;(!7@!345O'0;:)'83!408;2<0!&8;/'33!CWKGE!

o ?ZG3!

o b54'3! 9;8! *(9;86*(<! 40'!5/0*'H'6'(4!;9!7'('9*43D!2('+&'/4')! *6&5/43!

5()!2&)54*(<!8*3O!:;<!CZQG`La"E!

o L0'/O&;*(4!8'&;84!CZQG`La"E!

o %]ZaL.!

o %aWa.!

• .;;:3h6'40;)3!4;!485/O!408'543!5()!;&&;842(*4*'3!

o ]/'(58*;!5(5:@3*3!

o Q*3O!5(5:@3*3!-!<'('854*(<!5!8*3O!:;<!CZQG`La"E!

o a(H*8;(6'(45:!]/5((*(<!

o ]4854'<*/!5()!5(4*/*&54*H'!*(4'::*<'(/'!;8!/;6&'4*4*H'!*(4'::*<'(/'!

• .;;:3h6'40;)3!4;!)@(56*/5::@!5)5&4!40'!&8;/'33!753')!;(!533'336'(43!

o a+/'&4*;(! &:5(! -! 30;A3! 40'! 5/4*;(3! 8'12*8')! 4;! 8'/;H'8! 98;6! 5!

)'H*54*;(!CZQG`La"E!

Page 262: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "X=!

o G332'! :;<! -! 'F<F! 8'12'34! 9;8! /05(<'D! ;99T3&'/*9*/54*;(! ;8! 3454'6'(4! ;9!

/;(/'8(!CZQG`La"E!

o b54'3!9;8!2&)54*(<!723*('33!/53'!CZQG`La"E!

• .;;:3h6'40;)3! 4;! /;(4*(2;23:@! *6&8;H'! &8;/'33! 753')! ;(! 533'336'(43!

C92428'!&8;N'/43E!

o b54'3!9;8!<'('854*(<!:'33;(3!:'58(')!:;<!CZQG`La"E!

G257C)'83"25&(8$)?&1.)O#J#27!

>;30*(!Z:5((*(<!*3!3*6*:58!4;!d'Q'5:! *(!40'!3'(3'!4054! *4! *3! 9;/23')!;(!'(<5<*(<!

40'! )*99'8'(4! )'&5846'(43! 5()! /8'54*(<! 5! 9;/23! 4054! A*::! )8*H'! 40'! '(4*8'!

;8<5(*354*;(! 4;! 5/0*'H'! 40'! 34854'<*/! ;7N'/4*H'3F! .0'! 4'/0(*12'! *(H;:H'3!

'(H*3*;(*(<!8'32:43D!&:5((*(<!9;8!8'5:*354*;(!5()!3'44*(<!2&!3*<(*9*/5(4!458<'43!4;!

6;(*4;8!40'!5/0*'H'6'(43F!>;A'H'8D!>;30*(!Z:5((*(<!*3!4054! *4! *3!7'*(<!5&&:*')!

*(! 40'! /;(4'+4! ;9! /;6&5(*'3! 4;! '(<5<'! 40'! )*99'8'(4! )'&5846'(43! *(! 40'!

5/0*'H'6'(4!;9!40'!/;6&5(@R3!723*('33!;7N'/4*H'3D!A0*:'!d'Q'5:!*3!7'*(<!5);&4')!

*(! 40'! /;(4'+4! ;9! &8;<8566'3! 5()! &8;N'/43! /;6&;3')! 7@! )*99'8'(4! <8;2&3! ;9!

345O'0;:)'83! 4;! 5/0*'H'! 40'! )'9*(')! '+&'/4')! 7'('9*43! ;9! 4054! 4'6&;858@!

;8<5(*354*;(F!!

.0'!^;<*/5:!S856'A;8O!%&&8;5/0!*3!5:3;!3*6*:58!4;!d'Q'5:D!53!*43!65*(!9;/23!*3!;(!

'(<5<*(<! 345O'0;:)'83! 4;! )'9*('! 34854'<*/! <;5:3! 5()! 40'(! &:5((*(<! 40'!

&8;<8566'!;8!&8;N'/4!753')!;(!4054!/;66;(!H*3*;(F!>;A'H'8D!40'!^;<9856'!053!

7''(! /8*4*/*3')! 9;8! *43! :5/O! ;9! 9:'+*7*:*4@D! 3*(/'! *4! 53326'3! 4054! (;! 92840'8!

N2)<'6'(4! 8'<58)*(<! 40'!&8;<8566'R3! ;7N'/4*H'3! *3! 8'12*8')D! 53!A'::! 53! 9;8! *43!

:58<'!'6&053*3!;(!125(4*454*H'!6'5328'3D!<'('854*(<!&;;8!32&&;84!9;8!)'/*3*;(T

65O*(<!CLWQ%D!"JJ,U!Z534'28!'4!5:FD!"JJ,EF!

.0'! 3*6*:58*4@!;9! 40'!W'3*<(!K25:*4@! G()*/54;8! 4;!d'Q'5:! :5@3!;(! 40'! 95/4! 4054! *4!

5:3;!9;/23'3!;(!'(<5<*(<!345O'0;:)'83!4;!)'9*('!5()!)*3/233!40'*8!&8*;8*4*'3!5:;(<!

40'!&8;/'33F!.0'8'!*3!5:3;!5!/;(4*(2;23!'H5:254*;(!4;!6;(*4;8!*9!'+&'/4')!8'32:4!*3!

7'*(<! 5/0*'H')F! >;A'H'8D! )*99'8'(4:@! 405(! d'Q'5:D! A0*/0! /;(3*)'83! H58*57:'3!

8':54')! 4;! 7'('9*43! 4;! 533'33! 8'32:43U! *(! 40'! WKG! 4;;:! 40'! 72*:)*(<! 125:*4@! *3!

533'33')! 5<5*(34! 40'! H58*57:'3! 4054! 58'! &8'T)'9*(')! 753')! ;(! 5! /;(/'&425:!

Page 263: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!,!-!.'/0(*12'3!4054!'6785/'!7'('9*43!8'5:*354*;(!5()!65(5<'6'(4!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "IJ!

9856'A;8OF!Y;8';H'8D!40'!65N;8!9;/23!;9!40'!'H5:254*;(3!*3!;(!40'!125:*4@!;9!72*:4!

3&5/'3D!A0*:'! *(!d'Q'5:! 40'!533'336'(4! *3! 9;/23')!;(!40'! *)'(4*9*')!7'('9*43! 9;8!

'5/0!3&'/*9*/!&8;N'/4F!

.0'!65*(!3*6*:58*4@!7'4A''(!KSW!5()!d'Q'5:!*3!;(!40'!&584*/*&54;8@!9;/23!;9!40'!

4'/0(*12'D! A0*/0! &8;H*)'3! 5! 6'5(3! 9;8! /;662(*/54*;(! 5()! *(4'8T92(/4*;(5:!

&:5((*(<F!%:3;D!3*6*:58:@!4;!d'Q'5:D!KSW!32&&;843!40'!&8;/'33!;9!&8*;8*4*3*(<D!5()!

485(3:54*(<!8'12*8'6'(43!*(4;!3&'/*9*/54*;(3D!5()!6'5328'3!4;!485/O!8'32:43F!!

>;A'H'8D!KSW!*3!5!4'/0(*12'!&8*658*:@!9;/23')!*(!485(3:54*(<!8'12*8'6'(43!*(4;!

&8;)2/4! 3&'/*9*/54*;(3F! W*99'8'(4:@D! 7'('9*43! 8'5:*354*;(! *(H;:H'3! '(H*3*;(*(<!

8'32:43! 5()! 72*:)*(<! /;66;(! 34854'<*/! ;7N'/4*H'3D! 9;8! 40'(! )'&:;@*(<! 40'3'!

34854'<*/! ;7N'/4*H'3! *(4;! ;&'854*;(3F! .0'! 9;/23! *3! (;4D! 40'8'9;8'D! *(! 5! &0@3*/5:!

;7N'/4!724!*3!)8*H'(!7@!40'!'+&'/4')!7'('9*43!;9!5!3&'/*9*/!&8;N'/4F!

ZQG`La"!*3!5!6'40;)!9;8!65(5<*(<!&8;N'/43F!.0'!3*6*:58*4@!*4!053!A*40!d'Q'5:!*3!

4054!*4!&8;H*)'3!5!/;(48;::')!'(H*8;(6'(4!4;!5/0*'H'!40'!'+&'/4')!8'32:43F!G4!5:3;!

&8;H*)'3! 8'H*'A*(<!345<'3! 4;!6;(*4;8! 40'!5/0*'H'6'(43!5()!32&&;843!)'/*3*;(T

65O*(<!753')!;(!40*3!533'336'(4F!>;A'H'8D!d'Q'5:!053!5!348;(<'8!'6&053*3!;(!

'(<5<*(<! 345O'0;:)'83! 4;! )'9*('! 40'! '+&'/4')! 7'('9*43! ;9! 5! &8;N'/4D! 5<8''! ;(!

&;33*7:'! )*37'('9*43! 5()! 6;(*4;8! 40'! 8'5:*354*;(! ;9! 7'('9*43! 7'*(<! 5A58'! ;9!

'6'8<*(<!2('+&'/4')!7'('9*43!5()!)*37'('9*43F!

Page 264: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I,!

!""#$%&*)++),)F2(#)(10%&#()%212))

+$%#*)

++PQ!L],!T!Z54*'(4!5()!/'(48'!23'8!12'34*;((5*8'!h!34599!12'34*;((5*8'!

++PL!L],!-!Q'428(')!12'34*;((5*8'!&8;9*:'3!

++PR!L],!!T!K2'34*;((5*8'!354*395/4*;(!:'H':!8'32:43!

++PS!L],!-!d'('9*43!^*(O')!4;!12'34*;(!6548*/'3!

++PT!L],!-!d'('9*43!354*395/4*;(!:'H':3!8'32:43!

++PU!L]"!-!d'('9*43!':*/*4')!*(!A;8O30;&3!,!

++PV!L]"!T!a(57:'83!*)'(4*9*')!*(!A;8O30;&!"!!!

++PW!L]"!T!%/4;83!*)'(4*9*')!*(!A;8O30;&!"!

++PX!L]"!T!d'('9*/*58*'3!*)'(4*9*')!*(!A;8O30;&!"!

++PQY!L]"!-!W*37'('9*43!*)'(4*9*')!*(!A;8O30;&!"!

++PQQ!L]#!-!d'('9*43!':*/*4')!*(!A;8O30;&3!,TX!5()!d'('9*4!)'9*(*4*;(3!

9;8!;&4*;(''8*(<!*(!A;8O30;&!I!

++PQL!L]#!-!d'('9*43!A'*<04*(<!5()!85(O*(<!*(!A;8O30;&!f!

++PQR!L]#!-!V&4*;(!3/;8*(<!3&8'5)!30''4!'+56&:'!*(!A;8O30;&!f!

++PQS!%::!L]!T!]56&:'!;9!&8;N'/4!3/;&'!5()!9'53*7*:*4@!12'34*;((5*8'!

Page 265: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I"!

!!

!The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

!"#$%&#'(')*%+',)%*#$-&&"$+%!!

!

"#$%&$'!%(&)$*!+,$!-.$&+/0(&!1$##0)!12!3.++/(4!./'0'1/'2/3'425!50*!$%6,!-.$&+/0(7!8,%(9!20.!50*!+%9/(4!+,$!+/:$!+0!%(&)$*!+,$&$!-.$&+/0(&7!

!!!

! !.613/6'(')7387'!8291:3'

;(!+,/&!5/*&+!&$6+/0('!)$!)0.#<!#/9$!+0!9(0)!%!#/++#$!1/+!%10.+!20.*&$#57!

=,%+!/&!20.*!4$(<$*>! ?%#$! @$:%#$!! !! !!

!=,%+!/&!20.*!%4$!4*0.3>! ABCAD! EFCGH! GICIH! IICBH! BICJH! JIK!! !! !! !! !! !! !!

!

!80!),/6,!05!+,$&$!$+,(/6!4*0.3&!)0.#<!20.!&%2!20.!1$#0(4>! ! ! ! ! !;<163! ' ' L*/+/&,' ;*/&,' M+,$*'! ! ! !! !! !!=153>! ' =,/+$!N!L#%69!

O%*/11$%('=,/+$!N!L#%69!

P5*/6%('=,/+$!N!P&/%('

M+,$*'

! ! !! !! !! !!"71./'28'"71./'?81617<! ' ;(</%(' "%9/&+%(/! L%(4#%<$&,/' M+,$*'! ! !! !! !! !!?:.@A'28'?:.@A'?81617<! ' ' "#$%&&'#(! P5*/6%(' M+,$*'! ! ! !! !! !!B<1/373'28'26<38'36</1@'C82DE' ' ' ! O,/($&$' M+,$*'! ! ! ! !! !!

!

Q0!20.!,%R$!%(2!</&%1/#/+2>! S$&! T0!! !! !!

!

"#$%&$'!&3$6/52!&$*R/6$&!+,%+!20.!.&$<!UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!

V0)!5%*!<0!20.!#/R$!5*0:!+,$!6$(+*$! ! ! W$&&!+,%(!A!:/#$!

L$+)$$(!A!+0!G!:/#$&!

L$+)$$(!G!+0!I!:/#$&!

?0*$!+,%(!I!:/#$&!

! ! ! !! !! !! !!

=,%+!6$(+*$X&!&$*R/6$&!<0!20.!.&$>! ?$</6%#! T0(C:$</6%#! L0+,!! !! !! !!

Page 266: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I#!

!!

! The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

!! !"#$%&'%"(()**+,+-+./!

"#$%&'()!*+!*,-'.!'#/+!&,!/0,*!(,-$!,1#0#,0!,0!2,*!(,-!3#0.!4+&&#04!&,!50.!5$,-0.!&2+!6+0&$+7!

! 8&$,04'(!

94$++!94$++!

:5;+!0,!

,1#0#,0!<#%54$++!

8&$,04'(!

<#%54$++!

=7!>&!#%!+5%(!&,!3#0.!&2+!2+5'&265$+!6+0&$+!! !! !! !! !! !!?7!>&!#%!+5%(!&,!$+562!&2+!6+0&$+!@(!1-@'#6!

&$50%1,$&! !! !! !! !! !!

A7!B2+$+!5$+!+0,-42!%#40%!.#$+6&#04!-%+$%!&,!&2+!

6+0&$+!! !! !! !! !! !!

C7!B2+!6+0&$+!#%!6,0;+0#+0&'(!',65&+.!*#&2#0!&2+!

6,DD-0#&(!!! !! !! !! !!

E7!B2+!+0&$506+!,3!&2+!@-#'.#04!#%!+5%(!&,!',65&+! !! !! !! !! !!F7!>&!#%!+5%(!&,!3#0.!5!15$/#04!%156+!! !! !! !! !! !!G7!<#%5@'+.!65$H15$/#04!%156+%!5$+!*+''!',65&+.! !! !! !! !! !!I7!>&!#%!+5%(!&,!3#0.!D(!*5(!5$,-0.!&2+!@-#'.#04! !! !! !! !! !!J7!B2+$+!#%!+0,-42!#03,$D5&#,0!'+5.#04!-%+$%!&,!

.#33+$+0&!1'56+%!*#&2#0!&2+!@-#'.#04!!! !! !! !! !!

=K7!B2+!@-#'.#04!#%!%-#&5@'+!3,$!.#%5@'+.!1+,1'+! !! !! !! !! !!==7!8&5#$%!50.!'#3&%!5$+!6,0;+0#+0&'(!',65&+.!

*#&2#0!@-#'.#04!!! !! !! !! !!

=?7!B,#'+&%!5$+!6,0;+0#+0&'(!',65&+.!*#&2#0!

@-#'.#04!!! !! !! !! !!

=A7!B2+!',65&#,0!,3!0+*!6+0&$+!1$,;#.+%!@+&&+$!

566+%%#@#'#&(!&,!%+$;#6+%!&250!@+3,$+!!! !! !! !! !!

=C7!B2+!6+0&$+!,33+$%!#0&+$+%&#04!50.!5&&$56&#;+!

%+$;#6+%!3,$!&2+!6,DD-0#&(!!! !! !! !! !!

!

! !"#$%0%'%123-+./%45%673()*%

>0!&2#%!15$&)!*+!*,-'.!'#/+!&,!/0,*!(,-$!,1#0#,0!,0!2,*!(,-!3++'!#0%#.+!&2+!6+0&$+7!!

! 8&$,04'(!

94$++!94$++!

:5;+!0,!

,1#0#,0!<#%54$++!

8&$,04'(!

<#%54$++!

=7!B2+!6+0&$+!5&D,%12+$+!#%!1+56+3-'!50.!

L-#+&!!! !! !! !! !!

?7!B2+$+!#%!1'+0&(!,3!3$+%2!5#$!50.!05&-$5'!'#42&!

*#&2#0!&2+!@-#'.#04!!! !! !! !! !!

A7!B2+!#0&+$#,$!',,/%!6'+50)!&#.(!50.!65$+.!3,$! !! !! !! !! !!C7!B2+!#0&+$#,$!25%!5!;5$#+&(!,3!6,',-$%)!

&+M&-$+%!50.!;#+*%!!! !! !! !! !!

E7!N0*50&+.!0,#%+!#%!D#0#D-D!#0!15&#+0&!

5$+5%!!!! !! !! !! !!

F7!8156+%!25;+!5!0#6+!;#+*!,3!&2+!,-&%#.+!! !! !! !! !! !!G7!O5&#+0&%!50.!-%+$%!25;+!566+%%!&,!,-&%#.+!

5$+5%!!! !! !! !! !!

I7!P5#&#04!5$+5%!5$+!1'+5%50&!! !! !! !! !! !!J7!B2+$+!5$+!%-#&5@'+!62#'.$+0!1'5(!5$+5%!#0!&2+!

6+0&$+!!! !! !! !! !!

Page 267: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "IX!

!!

!The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

"#$!%&'('!)('!*+,-)./'!.).0!1&)23,23!4)1,/,-,'*!! !! !! !! !! !!""$!5'2-('!*6)1'*!172*,8'(!1+/-+()/!8,9'(*,-0! !! !! !! !! !!":$!%&'!1'2-('!6(79,8'*!&,3&!;+)/,-0!*6)1'*!47(!+*'(*!)28!6)-,'2-*! !! !! !! !! !!

!! !"#$%&%'%()*+*,-%$*./0%),1%"223*,+./,+0%

<7=>!='!=7+/8!/,?'!-7!?27=!&7=!='//!*'(9,1'*!)('!4+/4,//,23!07+(!*6'1,4,1!2''8*!)28!,2!-,@'$!

! A-(723/0!B3(''! B3(''! C)9'!27!

76,2,72! D,*)3(''! A-(723/0!D,*)3(''!

"$!E&'2!1)//,23!-&'!1'2-('>!,-!,*!')*0!-7!3'-!-&(7+3&!-7!*7@'72'!72!-&'!6&72'! !! !! !! !! !!

:$!F4!2''8'8>!,-!,*!')*0!-7!3'-!)2!)667,2-@'2-!=,-&,2!-&'!*)@'!8)0! !! !! !! !! !!

G$!F4!2''8'8>!,-!,*!')*0!-7!3'-!)2!)667,2-@'2-!=,-&!)2!*6'1,)/,*-! !! !! !! !! !!

H$!F-!87'*2I-!-)?'!/723!-7!.'!*''2!.0!)!871-7(!)4-'(!@)?,23!)2!)667,2-@'2-! !! !! !! !! !!

J$!F!)@!*''2!72!-,@'! !! !! !! !! !!K$!%&'!1'2-('I*!76'2,23!&7+(*!)('!1729'2,'2-!! !! !! !! !! !!L$!M9'()//!=),-,23!-,@'*!)('!1729'2,'2-!! !! !! !! !! !!!!! !"#$%4%'%5/67*8/0%),1%5+)99%

F2!-&,*!6)(->!='!=7+/8!/,?'!-7!?27=!&7=!='//!*'(9,1'*!)28!*-)44!)('!@''-,23!07+(!'N6'1-)-,72*!!!

! A-(723/0!B3(''! B3(''! C)9'!27!

76,2,72! D,*)3(''! A-(723/0!D,*)3(''!

"$!%&'!1'2-('I*!*-)44!,*!&'/64+/! !! !! !! !! !!:$!%&'!1'2-('I*!*-)44!,*!4(,'28/0!)28!('*6'1-4+/! !! !! !! !! !!G$!F-!,*!')*0!-7!(')1&!*-)44!=&'2!2''8'8! !! !! !! !! !!H$!%&'!1'2-('!744'(*!)!1729'2,'2-!()23'!74!17@@+2,-0!*'(9,1'*! !! !! !! !! !!

J$!%&'('!,*!)!=,8'!()23'!74!@'8,1)/!*'(9,1'*!-&)-!1)2!.'!+*'8!8+(,23!)!*,23/'!9,*,-! !! !! !! !! !!

K$!%&'!1'2-('I*!*'(9,1'*!&)9'!)!3778!('6+-)-,72! !! !! !! !! !!

L$!E,-&,2!-&'!1'2-('!72'!1)2!4,28!)//!-&'!@'8,1)/!*'(9,1'*!2'1'**)(0!-7!4+/4,/!,-*!2''8*! !! !! !! !! !!

O$!%&'('!,*!)//!2'1'**)(0!@'8,1)/!';+,6@'2-!,2!-&'!1'2-('! !! !! !! !! !!

P$!Q('*1(,.'8!@'8,1,2'!,*!+*+)//0!)9),/)./'!)-!-&'!6&)(@)10! !! !! !! !! !!

!

Page 268: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "II!

!!

! The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

!! !"#$%&%'%!()*+,-.%/01),2%+34%5362(+,6)13%

"#!$%&'!()*$+!,-!,./01!0&2-!$.!2#.,!)3./$!$%-!4%.&4-'!5./!%)6-!)#1!%.,!$%-!3/&01&#7!'/((.*$'!(*&6)45!,%-#!#--1-18!!

! 9$*.#705!:7*--! :7*--! ;)6-!#.!

.(&#&.#! <&')7*--! 9$*.#705!<&')7*--!

=8!>)$&-#$'!4)#!%)6-!)!(*&6)$-!4.#6-*')$&.#! !! !! !! !! !!?8!>)$&-#$'!4)#!4%..'-!$.!3-!)0.#-!&@!$%-5!,&'%! !! !! !! !! !!

A8!>)$&-#$'!4)#!-)'&05!7-$!-B(0)#)$&.#'!)3./$!$%-&*!C-1&4)$&.#! !! !! !! !! !!

D8!>)$&-#$'!4)#!3-!&#6.06-1!&#!$%-!1-4&'&.#'!)3./$!$%-&*!%-)0$%4)*-!)#1!$*-)$C-#$! !! !! !! !! !!

E8!>)$&-#$'!)*-!'/((.*$-1!,&$%!)1-F/)$-!&#@.*C)$&.#!$.!C)2-!4%.&4-'!)3./$!$%-&*!%-)0$%!!

!! !! !! !! !!

G8!>)$&-#$'!)*-!),)*-!.@!1&@@-*-#$!.($&.#'!)6)&0)30-!*-7)*1&#7!$%-&*!%-)0$%! !! !! !! !! !!

H8!>)$&-#$'!%)6-!7*-)$!4%.&4-!.@!'-*6&4-'!&#!$%-!4-#$*-! !! !! !! !! !!

!! !"#$%7%'%5891(6+3,2%

;)6&#7!4.C(0-$-1!>)*$!=!$.!E+!(0-)'-!&#1&4)$-!$%-!0-6-0!.@!&C(.*$)#4-!5./!)$$)4%!$.!-)4%!.@!$%-'-!E!)'(-4$'! 35! *)#2&#7! $%-! &$-C'! @*.C! =! $.! E+! =! 3-&#7! $%-! 0-)'$! &C(.*$)#$! )#1! E! 3-&#7! $%-! C.'$!&C(.*$)#$8!!:2+;2.%3162%60+6%<1(%2+,0%)628%-1=%;01=:4%>)*2%13:-%132%:2*2:%1<%)891(6+3,2?!

@2+;6%)891(6+36%A%B%%CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC%D1;6%)891(6+36%A%&%

! I)#2!.@!&C(.*$)#4-!

>)*$!=!J:44-''&3&0&$5KL! MMMMMMMMMMM!

>)*$!?!JN/)0&$5!.@!9()4-KL! MMMMMMMMMMM!

>)*$!A!JO)&$&#7!P&C-'!)#1!:((.&#$C-#$'KL! MMMMMMMMMMM!

>)*$!D!J9-*6&4-'!)#1!9$)@@KL! MMMMMMMMMMM!

>)*$!E!J>*&6)45+!4%.&4-!)#1!"#$-*)4$&.#KL! MMMMMMMMMMM!

! !"#$%E%'%FG6(+%H232<)6;%

P%-!)&C!.@!$%&'!'-4$&.#!&'!$.!&1-#$&@5!)#5!3-#-@&$'!.*!#-7)$&6-!&C()4$'!$%)$!,-!C&7%$!#.$!%)6-!4.6-*-1!&#!$%&'!F/-'$&.##)&*-8!!O%)$!1.!5./!'--!)'!C)Q.*!3-#-@&$'!$%)$!-C-*7-1!@*.C!$%-!4.#'$*/4$&.#!.@!$%&'!4-#$*-!)#1!,%)$!1.!5./!$%&#2!,-*-!$%-!C)Q.*!#-7)$&6-!&C()4$'R!

D+I1(%J232<)6;%1<%602%32K%,236(2%)3%8-%19)3)13%B%L%M%D+I1(%32>+6)*2%)89+,6;%1<%602%32K%,236(2%)3%8-%19)3)13%B%L%M%

Page 269: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "If!

!!

!The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

!

!"#$$%&'(!")*++#),(!!

!

"#$%&$'!%(&)$*!+,$!-.$&+/0(&!1$##0)!12!3.++/(4!-.%/%0.%1.2%314!50*!$%6,!-.$&+/0(7!8,%(9!20.!50*!+%9/(4!+,$!+/:$!+0!%(&)$*!+,$&$!-.$&+/0(&7!

!!!

! !5-66%7816092%

!

;,%+!/&!20.*!4$(<$*=! >%#$! ?$:%#$!! !! !!

!

;,%+!/&!20.*!%4$!4*0.3=! @AB@C! DEBFG! FHBHG! HHBAG! AHBIG! IHJ!! !! !! !! !! !! !!

!

K0)!5%*!<0!20.!#/L$!5*0:!+,$!6$(+*$!

! ! M$&&!+,%(!@!:/#$!

N$+)$$(!@!+0!F!:/#$&!

N$+)$$(!F!+0!H!:/#$&!

>0*$!+,%(!H!:/#$&!

! ! ! !! !! !! !!!!80!),/6,!05!+,$&$!$+,(/6!4*0.3&!)0.#<!20.!&%2!20.!1$#0(4=! ! ! ! ! !:;052! % % N*/+/&

,%O*/&,% P+,$*%

! ! ! !! !! !!<042=! % ;,/+$!Q!N#%69!

R%*/11$%(%;,/+$!Q!N#%69!

S5*/6%(%;,/+$!Q!S&/%(%

P+,$*%

! ! !! !! !! !!#>0-.%18%#>0-.%?8050>;! % O(</%(% "%9/&+%(/! N%(4#%<$&,/% P+,$*%! ! !! !! !! !!?9-@A%18%?9-@A%?8050>;! % % "#$%&&'#(! S5*/6%(% P+,$*%! ! ! !! !! !!B;0.2>2%18%15;28%25;.0@%C81DE% % % ! R,/($&$% P+,$*%! ! ! ! !! !!

!

T0!20.!,%L$!%(2!</&%1/#/+2=! U$&! V0!! !! !!

!

S*$!20.!%#&0!%!.&$*!05!&$*L/6$&!)/+,/(!+,$!6$(+*$=! U$&! V0!! !! !!

"#$%&$'!&3$6/52!&$*L/6$&!+,%+!20.!.&$!WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!

;,%+!/&!20.*!066.3%+/0(X!3*05$&&/0(=!

Y"! "*%6+/6$!V.*&$!

S<:/(/&+*%+0*! "*%6+/6$!>%(%4$*!

! !! !! !! !!! K$%#+,6%*$!

>%(%4$*!",%*:%62! R0::.(/+2!

V.*&$!P+,$*!

! !! !! !! !!

Page 270: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I_!

!!

! The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

"#!$%&'()!*+',-')!-*'./#011111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111!

!

!"#$%&'%"(()**+,+-+./! 2%($34+0!54(''! 54(''! 6,7'!3$!

$*/3/$3! 8/-,4(''! 2%($34+0!8/-,4(''!

9:!"%!/-!',-0!%$!4'%!%$!%&'!.'3%('!;0!.,(! !! !! !! !! !!<:!"%!/-!',-0!%$!(',.&!%&'!.'3%('!;0!*=;+/.!%(,3-*$(%! !! !! !! !! !!

>:!?&'!.'3%('!/-!.$37'3/'3%+0!+$.,%'@!A/%&/3!%&'!.$BB=3/%0! !! !! !! !! !!

C:!"%!/-!',-0!%$!#/3@!,!*,(D/34!-*,.'!! !! !! !! !! !!E:!8/-,;+'@!.,(F*,(D/34!-*,.'-!,('!A'++!+$.,%'@! !! !! !! !! !!

G:!"%!/-!',-0!%$!#/3@!B0!A,0!,($=3@!%&'!;=/+@/34! !! !! !! !! !!

H:!?&'!;=/+@/34!/-!-=/%,;+'!#$(!@/-,;+'@!*'$*+'! !! !! !! !! !!I:!2%,/(-!,3@!+/#%-!,('!.$37'3/'3%+0!+$.,%'@!A/%&/3!;=/+@/34! !! !! !! !! !!

J:!?$/+'%-!,('!.$37'3/'3%+0!+$.,%'@!A/%&/3!;=/+@/34! !! !! !! !! !!

!

!"#$%0%'%123-+./%45%673()*! 2%($34+0!54(''! 54(''! 6,7'!3$!

$*/3/$3! 8/-,4(''! 2%($34+0!8/-,4(''!

9:!?&'!.'3%('!,%B$-*&'('!/-!*',.'#=+!,3@!K=/'%! !! !! !! !! !!

<:!?&'('!/-!*+'3%0!$#!#('-&!,/(!,3@!3,%=(,+!+/4&%!A/%&/3!%&'!;=/+@/34! !! !! !! !! !!

>:!?&'!/3%'(/$(!+$$D-!.+',3)!%/@0!,3@!.,('@!#$(! !! !! !! !! !!C:!?&'!/3%'(/$(!&,-!,!7,(/'%0!$#!.$+$=(-)!%'L%=('-!,3@!7/'A-! !! !! !! !! !!

E:!M3A,3%'@!3$/-'!/-!B/3/B=B!/3!A$(D/34!,(',-!! !! !! !! !! !!

G:!2*,.'-!&,7'!,!3/.'!7/'A!$#!%&'!$=%-/@'!! !! !! !! !! !!H:!2%,##!&,7'!,..'--!%$!$=%-/@'!,(',-! !! !! !! !! !!I:!?&'('!/-!,@'K=,%'!-*,.'!,($=3@!%&'!'L,B/3,%/$3!.$=.&!! !! !! !! !! !!

J:!N'3%('!-*,.'-!.$3-/@'(!.=+%=(,+!@/7'(-/%0! !! !! !! !! !!9O:!?&'('!,('!,@'K=,%'!.&,34/34!,(',-)!-&$A'(-!,3@!+$.D'(-!,7,/+,;+'!#$(!-%,##! !! !! !! !! !!

99:!?&'!.'3%('!'3,;+'-!,@'K=,%'!B,%'(/,+-!#+$A)!&,3@+/34!,3@!-%$(,4':! !! !! !! !! !!

9<:!P(',D!$=%!($$B-!,('!*($7/@'@!,%!,3!,**($*(/,%'!-%,3@,(@! !! !! !! !! !!

9>:!5**($*(/,%'!A$(D/34!B,%'(/,+-)!#=(3/%=('!,3@!'K=/*B'3%!,('!,7,/+,;+'!,%!%&'!.'3%('! !! !! !! !! !!

9C:!Q$(D/34!,(',-!&,7'!,3!,@'K=,%'!+,0$=%! !! !! !! !! !!

!

Page 271: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I$!

!!

!The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

!

!"#$%&%'%()*+,-./%0%1)23.4%256%(27)./! "#$%&'()!*'$++! *'$++! ,-.+!&%!

%/0&0%&! 102-'$++! "#$%&'()!102-'$++!

34!50$+!+60#2!-&7!+28-/+!$%9#+2!-$+!8(+-$()!.020:(+! !! !! !! !! !!

;4!<=90/>+&#!-&7!29//(0+2!-$+!-7+=9-#+()!2+89$+7! !! !! !! !! !!

?4!"+89$0#)!-(-$>2!-&7!7+.08+2!-$+!@$+=9+&#()!#+2#+7! !! !! !! !! !!

A4!BC+$+!02!-7+=9-#+!#$-0&0&'!%&!@0$+!2-@+#)!-&7!%#C+$!D%:!2-@+#)!0229+2! !! !! !! !! !!

E4!BC+$+!-$+!2+89$+!/(-8+!-.-0(-:(+!@%$!+>/(%)++2!#%!2#%$+!#C+0$!:+(%&'0&'2! !! !! !! !! !!

F4!BC+$+!-$+!-7+=9-#+!/%(080+2!-77$+220&'!C+-(#C!-&7!2-@+#)! !! !! !! !! !!

G4!H-2#+!02!702/%2+7!-//$%/$0-#+()! !! !! !! !! !!

!

!"#$%8%'%9:;3</:)5.%=),>-*)=%256%.,2-5-5?! "#$%&'()!*'$++! *'$++! ,-.+!&%!

%/0&0%&! 102-'$++! "#$%&'()!102-'$++!

34!I#C+$!>+>:+$2!%@!2#-@@!-$+!C+(/@9(! !! !! !! !! !!;4!I#C+$!>+>:+$2!%@!2#-@@!-$+!@$0+&7()!-&7!$+2/+8#@9(! !! !! !! !! !!

?4!BC+$+!-$+!-7+=9-#+!8%>>9&08-#0%&!8C-&&+(2!->%&'!2#-@@! !! !! !! !! !!

A4!BC+$+!-$+!-//$%/$0-#+!8%>/9#+$J!/$0&#+$!-&7!0&#+$&+#!-88+22!0&!#C+!8+&#$+! !! !! !! !! !!

E4!BC+$+!02!C+-(#C)!$+@$+2C>+&#!8C%08+2!-.-0(-:(+!0&!#C+!8+&#$+! !! !! !! !! !!

F4!BC+$+!02!-7+=9-#+!C9>-&!$+2%9$8+2!-.-0(-:(+!#%!'+#!$+=90$+7!D%:2!8%>/(+#+7!! !! !! !! !! !!

G4!B$-0&0&'!%$0+&#-#0%&!02!-7+=9-#+()!-.-0(-:(+!@%$!&+K!2#-@@! !! !! !! !! !!

L4!BC+$+!02!%//%$#9&0#)!@%$!2#-@@!#%!-##+&7!70@@+$+&#!8%9$2+2! !! !! !! !! !!

M4!"#-@@!C-2!#0>+!-.-0(-:(+!#%!-##+&7!8%9$2+2! !! !! !! !! !!

!

!"#$%@%'%A<,B-5?%)5>-,<5:)5.%256%C5*)5.->)=!

"#$%&'()!*'$++!

*'$++!

,-.+!&%!%/0&0%&! 102-'$++! "#$%&'()!

102-'$++!

34!"#-@@!8-&!-7D92#!#C+!(+.+(!%@!(0'C#0&'!@%$!2/+80@08!#-2N2J!0@!&++7+7! !! !! !! !! !!

;4!"#-@@!8-&!8%&#$%(!&%02+!(+.+(2!0&!#C+!+&.0$%&>+&#J!0@!&++7+7!! !! !! !! !! !!

?4!"#-@@!8-&!-7D92#!#C+!.+&#0(-#0%&J!C+-#!-&7!C9>070#)!%@!K%$N0&'!-$+-2J!0@!&++7+7! !! !! !! !! !!

A4!BC+$+!02!-7+=9-#+!%.+$-((!2#-@@0&'!(+.+(2! !! !! !! !! !!E4!"#-@@!C-2!-//$%/$0-#+!8%&#-8#!K0#C!K%$N0&'!8%((+-'9+2! !! !! !! !! !!

F4!O%((+-'9+2!.-(9+!+-8C!%#C+$2!K%$N!! !! !! !! !! !!

Page 272: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PQ!T!L],!W545!-!Z54*'(4!5()!\3'8!h!]4599!12'34*;((5*8'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "I=!

!!

! The image part with relationship ID rId1 was not found in the file.

"#!$%&''!()*)+,)!)-./01!2/33.(%!&-4!

0/+4&-*)!!!! !! !! !! !!

5#!61)()!&()!.33.(%/-+%+)2!%.!4+2*/22!+22/)2!

&-4!*.-*)(-2!!! !! !! !! !!

7#!$%&''!()*)+,)!&4)8/&%)!2/3)(,+2+.-!&%!

9.(:!!! !! !! !! !!

;<#!61)()!+2!*.==+%=)-%!%.!+-%)(-&>!&-4!

)?%)(-&>!'&+(-)22!&-4!)8/&>+%@!!! !! !! !! !!

;;#!A.(:+-0!1./(2!&()!*.-,)-+)-%>@!'>)?+B>)!! !! !! !! !! !!;C#!$%&''!&()!&9&()!&B./%!3.>+*+)2D!4)*+2+.-2!

&-4!*1&-0)2!%1&%!&'')*%!%1)+(!E.B2!!! !! !! !! !!

;F#!!$%&''!&()!3(.,+4)4!9+%1!4+'')()-%!'.(=2!

.'!+-*)-%+,)2!!!! !! !! !! !!

!! !"#$%&%'%()*+,-./01%

G&,+-0!*.=3>)%)4!H&(%!;!%.!ID!3>)&2)!+-4+*&%)!%1)!>),)>!.'!+=3.(%&-*)!@./!&%%&*1!%.!)&*1!.'!%1)2)!I!

&23)*%2! B@! (&-:+-0! %1)! +%)=2! '(.=! ;! %.! ID! ;! B)+-0! %1)! >)&2%! +=3.(%&-%! &-4! I! B)+-0! %1)! =.2%!

+=3.(%&-%#!!21.314%/+-1%-5.-%6+,%1.05%7-1)%8+9%35+92:%;7<1%+/28%+/1%21<12%+6%7)*+,-./01=!

>1.3-%7)*+,-./-%?%@%%AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA%B+3-%7)*+,-./-%?%C%

! J&-:!.'!+=3.(%&-*)!

H&(%!;!KL**)22+B+>+%@MN! OOOOOOOOOOO!

H&(%!C!KP/&>+%@!.'!$3&*)MN! OOOOOOOOOOO!

H&(%!F!K$)*/(+%@!Q!G)&>%1!&-4!$&')%@MN! OOOOOOOOOOO!

H&(%!R!KS=3>.@=)-%!2)(,+*)2!&-4!%(&+-+-0MN! OOOOOOOOOOO!

H&(%!I!KA.(:+-0!)-,+(.-=)-%!&-4!

T-*)-%+,)2MN!

OOOOOOOOOOO!

!

! !"#$%D%'%EF-,.%G1/167-3%

61)! &+=! .'! %1+2! 2)*%+.-! +2! %.! +4)-%+'@! &-@! B)-)'+%2! .(! -)0&%+,)! +=3&*%2! %1&%! 9)! =+01%! -.%! 1&,)!

*.,)()4! +-! %1+2! 8/)2%+.--&+()#! ! A1&%! 4.! @./! 2))! &2! =&E.(! B)-)'+%2! %1&%! )=)(0)4! '(.=! %1)!

*.-2%(/*%+.-!.'!%1+2!*)-%()!&-4!91&%!4.!@./!%1+-:!9)()!%1)!=&E.(!-)0&%+,)!+=3&*%2U!

B.H+,%I1/167-3%+6%-51%/1J%01/-,1%7/%)8%+*7/7+/%

@%K%L%%B.H+,%/1;.-7<1%7)*.0-3%+6%-51%/1J%01/-,1%7/%)8%+*7/7+/%@%K%L%

!

Page 273: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PL)T!L],!W545!-!]4599!K2'34*;((5*8'!8'428(3!&8;9*:'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "fJ!

!"#$$ !"#$%#&'( )#"'#&*+,-.%&'(&)/01# 2 3456!#701# 48 9652/:;;:&< 4 956=>*01 49 488#*&+*),-.49?4@ 4 95668?3A B A35C32?2A 2 345622?9A 3 4C5C92?CAC2D/:;;:&<=>*01 49 488/01&+0+(230425267E#; 3 4C5CF> 43 C456/:;;:&<=>*01 49 488869'2:267GH:*#+I":*:;H 46 B2GH:*#+J":;H 4 956I10'K+>"+I10'K+I":*:;H+L0":MM#0& 4 956I10'K+>"+I10'K+I":*:;H+NO":'0& 4 956I10'K+>"+I10'K+I":*:;H+P*H#" 4 956/:Q#R+GH:*#+S+N;:0&/:Q#R+P*H#"/:;;:&<=>*01 49 488;,-)+,::-.062,'+T))"0'*:'#+/0&0<#")"0'*:'#+F%";#U#01*H+'0"#+/0&<#"L>77%&:*(+F%";#)H0"70'( 6 4652NR7:&:;*"0*>" A 62P*H#" 48 9652/:;;:&<=>*01 49 488<&'6)&+!&)12:&3+=3&(E#; 2 3456F> 44 9C5C=>*01 49 488

Page 274: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PL!!T!L],!W545!-L'(48'!\3'8!K2'34*;((5*8'!8'428(3!&8;9*:'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "f,!

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

!"#$%"&;"%239"(&'("*E#; @@ 8@5C<- 3C 9=59>?*01 84 @AA

Page 275: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PL!!T!L],!W545!-Z54*'(4!K2'34*;((5*8'!8'428(3!&8;9*:'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "f"!

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

6%&#)%,4%)+$3%-,7-%(G#; A 246DH> DA E763=>*01 49 255

Page 276: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PL!!T!L],!W545!-Z54*'(4!L'(48'!\3'8!K2'34*;((5*8'!8'428(3!&8;9*:'!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "f#!

!"#$%&#'(%&#%)'*+%)' !"#$%#&'( )#"'#&*+,-.,%&-%)/01# 23 4562!#701# 58 9368/:;;:&< 5 362=>*01 ?? @AAB<#+<">%C@9D@E @ @652AD45 @2 @96?43D35 23 456?33D95 @? 246993D85 @9 226283F @ @65/:;;:&< 3 963=>*01 ?? @AA."/%'"'-$+"0$1$#2G#; 2E 4E62H> 53 9A68/:;;:&< 4 46E=>*01 ?? @AA3#4&$5$#2IJ:*#+K":*:;J ?A E26@IJ:*#+L":;J @ @64K10'M+>"+K10'M+K":*:;J+N0":OO#0& @ @64K10'M+>"+K10'M+K":*:;J+BP":'0& @ @64K10'M+>"+K10'M+K":*:;J+Q*J#" @ @64/:R#S+IJ:*#+T+B;:0& @ @64/:R#S+Q*J#" @ @64/:;;:&< @ @64=>*01 ?? @AA!"#$%&#'6%)/$5%+'7+%-U) @3 226@H%";# @ @63)J0"70'( @ @63)>S:0*"( @ @63Q*J#" @2 @?69/>"#+*J0&+>&#+;#"V:'#; 48 336E/:;;:&< E @@6?=>*01 ?? @AA

(%&#)%'6%)/$5%+'*+%-G#; @? 226@H> 9A ??6E=>*01 ?? @AA

Page 277: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++)PR!T!L],!W545!-]4599!]54*395/4*;(!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "fX!

!

!

!

!

3% 3% 16%

48%

30%

Overall Staff Satisfaction

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

100

Building & Accessibility

Security, Health and

Safety

Employment Services &

Training

Working Environment &

Incentives

Ave

rage

%

Staff Satisfaction Levels per Section

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 4251 65278 78246 39245:,+";#/0<(=,>$/?(>&%(:>@,/0 6247 8288 9256 A9238 39235BCD$E0C,&/(:,;F#+,-()(G;>#&#&' 6291 1264 36255 77291 35268HE;I#&'(B&F#;E&C,&/()(J&+,&/#F,- 1233 1268 67214 7K239 1128ALF,;>$$ 32A7 12A3 6K263 74245 1828A

#&'((

Page 278: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PR!!T!L],!W545!-L'(48'!\3'8!]54*395/4*;(!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "fI!

!

!

!

!

5% 4%

28%

23%

40%

User Only Overal Satisfaction

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Building & Accessibility

Waiting Times & Appointments

Services & Staff Privacy & Patient Choice

Ave

rage

%

User Only Satisfaction Level per Section

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 5267 86239 8521: 382;;<=#/#&'(>#?,-()(*@@A#&/?,&/- 8249 ;25; ;:265 8:297 842;3B,CD#+,-()(B/=EE 12;9 ;26: 8;288 88285 35293FC#D=+0()(F=/#,&/(GHA#+, 82:7 52;8 ;9284 9:246 38217ID,C=$$ 3218 3285 8:244 8;285 ;427:

&'()*+,-.

Page 279: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PR!!T!L],!W545!-Z54*'(4!]54*395/4*;(!!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "ff!

!

!

!

!

4% 4% 15%

31%

46%

Overall Patients Only Satisfaction

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Building & Accessibility

Waiting Times &

Appointments

Services & Staff

Privacy & Patient Choice

Ave

rage

%

Patients Only Satisfaction Levels per Section

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 5236 47289 5723: 16256;<#/#&'(=#>,-()(*??@#&/>,&/- :2:5 92A3 4:255 512:9 582A3B,CD#+,-()(B/<EE 4297 42:5 49299 7A251 :42:3FC#D<+0()(F</#,&/(GH@#+, 5296 9245 49286 76266 11286ID,C<$$ 5284 1214 4:256 54274 1:291

&'()*+(,-+./

Page 280: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

%&&'()*+!++PR!!T!L],!W545!Z54*'(4!L'(48'!\3'8!]54*395/4*;(!

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'* "f_!

!

!

!

!

4% 5% 20%

28%

43%

Patients User Overall Satisfaction

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Building & Accessibility

Waiting Times & Appointments

Services & Staff Privacy & Patient Choice

Ave

rage

%

Patients User Satisfaction Level per Section

VDS% DS% F% S% VS%

!"#$ "#$ %$ #$ !#$!"#$%#&'()(*++,--#.#$#/0 1234 1256 57248 43236 19237:;#/#&'(<#=,-()(*>>?#&/=,&/- 12@8 7259 4@2@7 @5288 @125@A,BC#+,-()(A/;DD @217 4247 582@3 47258 1326@EB#C;+0()(E;/#,&/(FG?#+, 421@ 72H3 442H4 49294 1@281IC,B;$$ @263 1277 4H247 43251 1@257

&'()*+(,-.,*/-0+12

Page 281: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(0#$#1&/2(3&$4#%(/5(*#$/6#(72#62(89#2/&5$$.&6#(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** :;<(

Ref BenefitA1 Improved Patient Experience 1.6 1.7 1.9 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.29 1.30 1.31 2.8 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.12 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.6 3.8 3.13 3.14 3.15 3.19

Very Disatisfied 5.49 8.6 11.4 8.8 8.6 0 4.8 5.6 11.5 13.3 13 8.8 6.1 2.9 0 3.2 2.9 3 3.1 6.9 0 0 0 0 0 5.7 5.7 11.4 6.5 6.2 3.3 8.3 7.1 6.7 3.2Dissatisfied 3.94 2.9 0 2.9 2.9 6.5 14.3 0 3.8 0 4.3 0 3 2.9 5.9 3.2 2.9 3 6.2 0 4.8 6.2 7.1 0 5 8.6 5.7 2,9 6.5 3.1 0 8.3 0 6.7 3.2Fairly Satisfied 23.19 2.9 8.6 0 5.7 19.4 47.6 72.2 34.6 86.7 13 0 0 8.8 20.6 19.4 8.8 6.1 18.8 34.5 28.6 25 50 33.3 30 5.7 8.6 5.7 12.9 6.2 16.7 58.3 50 40 9.7Satisfied 23.19 22.9 28.6 32.4 28.6 25.8 23.8 11.1 15.4 0 30.4 14.7 30 26.5 29.4 41.9 44.1 33.3 37.5 31 19 18.8 7.1 11.1 25 14.3 11.4 14.3 19.4 34.4 26.7 8.3 28.6 20 22.6Very Satisfied 44.21 62.9 51.4 55.9 54.3 48.4 9.5 11.1 34.6 0 39.1 76.5 60.6 58.8 44.1 32.3 41.2 54.5 34.4 27.6 47.6 50 35.7 55.6 40 65.7 68.6 65.7 54.8 50 53.3 16.7 14.3 26.7 61.3

A2 Better Access to facilities (physical) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.30Very Disatisfied 6.28 8.6 5.7 5.7 9.1 6.7 6.9 5.3 4 2.9 11.1 3.1Dissatisfied 7.05 0 2.9 17.1 0 6.7 6.9 15.8 16 5.9 0 6.2Fairly Satisfied 19.76 2.9 8.6 11.4 6.1 26.7 24.1 47.4 36 20.6 14.8 18.8Satisfied 24.95 20 40 28.6 36.4 26.7 24.1 5.3 8 29.4 18.5 37.5Very Satisfied 41.98 68.6 42.9 37.1 48.5 33.3 37.9 26.3 36 41.2 55.6 34.4

A3 Greater Privacy 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6Very Disatisfied 4.58 3.2 3.8 5.3 5.3 4.3 5.6Dissatisfied 6.70 9.7 3.8 5.3 15.8 0 5.6Fairly Satisfied 29.37 12.9 19.2 36.8 36.8 26.1 44.4Satisfied 16.28 19.4 11.5 15.8 15.8 13 22.2Very Satisfied 43.02 54.8 61.5 36.8 26.3 56.5 22.2

A4 More Services in 1 place (co-location) 3.5Very Disatisfied 9.50 9.5Dissatisfied 0.00 0Fairly Satisfied 9.50 9.5Satisfied 23.80 23.8Very Satisfied 57.10 57.1

A6 Greater Access (service) 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 3.5 3.17Very Disatisfied 4.23 7.1 5 5.6 5.6 0 0 0 9.5 5.3Dissatisfied 3.19 3.6 5 0 0 3.6 5 6.2 0 5.3Fairly Satisfied 32.57 21.4 45 38.9 61.1 21.4 30 50 9.5 15.8Satisfied 28.78 35.7 30 27.8 11.1 50 25 18.8 23.8 36.8Very Satisfied 31.22 32.1 15 27.8 22.2 25 40 25 57.1 36.8

A7 Less time waiting 3.10 3.12Very Disatisfied 6.30 5.9 6.7Dissatisfied 0.00 0 0Fairly Satisfied 37.65 35.3 40Satisfied 19.25 11.8 26.7Very Satisfied 36.90 47.1 26.7

A8 New Services 3.18 3.18Very Disatisfied 3.40 3.4Dissatisfied 3.40 3.4Fairly Satisfied 20.70 20.7Satisfied 34.70 34.7Very Satisfied 37.90 37.9

A10 Increased Patient Choice 4.3 4.4 4.10 4.11 4.12 3.50 3.11 3.7 3.13 3.18Very Disatisfied 6.42 9.5 5.9 5 8.3 3.4Dissatisfied 2.34 0 0 0 8.3 3.4Fairly Satisfied 32.28 9.5 52.9 20 58.3 20.7Satisfied 21.72 23.8 11.8 30 8.3 34.7Very Satisfied 37.22 57.1 29.4 45 16.7 37.9

C3 Improved Community facilities 3.9 3.16Very Disatisfied 7.05 5 9.1Dissatisfied 2.25 0 4.5Fairly Satisfied 16.60 15 18.2Satisfied 23.60 25 22.2Very Satisfied 50.25 55 45.5

Page 282: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(=0#$#1&/2(3&$4#%(/5(>./&#$/2(.$%(*#$/6#(72#62(89#2/&5$$.&6#((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** :;?(

Ref BenefitA1 Improved Patient Experience 1.6 1.7 1.9 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.29 1.30 1.31 2.8 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.12 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.6 3.8 3.13 3.14 3.15 3.19

Very Disatisfied 3.96 5.3 6.6 5.5 5.3 1.6 5.9 5.3 7.3 13.3 8 5.3 4 2.70 0 3.2 1.3 1.3 1.4 3.2 1.6 1.8 2 3.5 3.3 3.9 3.9 6.5 4.1 4.1 1.4 3.4 2.2 2.3 4.1Dissatisfied 3.01 1.3 2.6 1.4 1.3 3.3 7.8 2.6 3.6 6.7 4 0 1.3 1.30 4 4.8 1.3 5.3 6.9 1.6 4.8 5.3 4.1 1.8 5 3.9 2.6 2.6 2.7 1.4 0 3.4 0 2.3 1.4Fairly Satisfied 18.45 2.6 6.6 2.7 6.6 14.8 31.4 50 25.5 56.7 18 0 4 10.70 21.3 17.5 7.9 2.7 11.1 27.4 19 14 34.7 19.3 25 6.5 7.8 7.8 17.8 10.8 18.8 55.2 35.6 27.9 9.6Satisfied 28.33 23.7 30.3 30.1 31.6 34.4 33.3 18.4 20 10 36 22.7 32 29.30 32 42.9 47.4 37.3 38.9 37.1 28.6 24.6 18.4 28.1 30 20.8 19.5 18.2 23.3 31.1 27.5 17.2 26.7 37.2 24.7Very Satisfied 46.25 67.1 53.9 60.3 55.3 45.9 21.6 23.7 43.6 13.3 34 72 58.7 56.00 42.7 31.7 42.1 53.3 41.7 30.6 46 54.4 40.8 47.4 36.7 64.9 66.2 64.9 52.1 52.7 52.2 20.7 35.6 30.2 60.3

A2 Better Access to facilities (physical) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.30Very Disatisfied 5.06 5.3 5.3 5.3 5.7 5.7 4.9 7.5 5.3 2.8 6.5 1.4Dissatisfied 5.56 1.3 2.6 9.3 0 0 9.8 15 10.5 4.2 1.6 6.9Fairly Satisfied 15.88 2.6 5.3 12 5.7 5.7 26.2 45 33.3 18.1 9.7 11.1Satisfied 25.58 17.1 30.3 26.7 32.9 32.9 19.7 7.5 19.3 31.9 24.2 38.9Very Satisfied 47.93 73.7 56.6 46.7 55.7 55.7 39.3 25 31.6 43.1 58.1 41.7

A3 Greater Privacy 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6Very Disatisfied 1.93 1.4 2.9 2.1 1.8 1.5 1.9Dissatisfied 8.62 6.8 5.9 10.4 15.8 1.5 11.3Fairly Satisfied 19.43 6.8 13.2 27.1 24.6 18.5 26.4Satisfied 24.50 30.1 17.6 27.1 19.3 24.6 28.3Very Satisfied 45.48 54.8 60.3 33.3 38.6 53.8 32.1

A4 More Services in 1 place (co-location) 3.5Very Disatisfied 6.60 6.6Dissatisfied 0.00 0Fairly Satisfied 6.60 6.6Satisfied 37.70 37.7Very Satisfied 49.20 49.2

A6 Greater Access (service) 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 3.5 3.17Very Disatisfied 4.91 4.5 13.3 5 5 1.4 0 4.3 6.6 4.1Dissatisfied 5.39 3 13.3 3.3 6.7 4.3 3.2 10.6 0 4.1Fairly Satisfied 21.43 14.9 31.7 20 31.7 12.9 29 27.7 6.6 18.4Satisfied 33.30 34.3 21.7 33.3 30 44.3 33.9 29.8 37.7 34.7Very Satisfied 35.00 43.3 20 38.3 26.7 37.1 33.9 27.7 49.2 38.8

A7 Less time waiting 3.10 3.12Very Disatisfied 1.85 1.8 1.9Dissatisfied 1.75 3.5 0Fairly Satisfied 18.35 17.5 19.2Satisfied 21.20 19.3 23.1Very Satisfied 56.85 57.9 55.8

A8 New Services 3.18 3.18Very Disatisfied 2.90 2.9Dissatisfied 5.70 5.7Fairly Satisfied 24.30 24.3Satisfied 30.00 30Very Satisfied 37.10 37.1

A10 Increased Patient Choice 4.3 4.4 4.10 4.11 4.12 3.50 3.11 3.7 3.13 3.18Very Disatisfied 3.22 2.1 1.8 5.3 1.7 3.3 6.6 3.2 1.9 3.4 2.9Dissatisfied 4.89 10.4 15.8 1.8 3.3 5 0 1.6 1.9 3.4 5.7Fairly Satisfied 26.13 27.1 24.6 26.3 28.3 25 6.6 16.1 27.8 55.2 24.3Satisfied 26.90 27.1 19.3 29.8 28.3 30 37.7 27.4 22.2 17.2 30Very Satisfied 38.86 33.3 38.6 36.8 38.3 36.7 49.2 51.6 46.3 20.7 37.1

C3 Improved Community facilities 3.9 3.16Very Disatisfied 3.75 1.7 5.8Dissatisfied 2.90 0 5.8Fairly Satisfied 20.25 13.6 26.9Satisfied 28.50 33.9 23.1Very Satisfied 44.65 50.8 38.5

Page 283: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(=0#$#1&/2(3&$4#%(/5(+/.11(89#2/&5$$.&6#((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** :@A(

Ref BenefitA2 Better Access to facilities (physical) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9

Very Disatisfied 3.38 0 0 0 0 13.3 10 7.1 0 0Dissatisfied 11.72 0 18.8 6.7 23.1 6.7 10 21.4 0 18.8Fairly Satisfied 22.77 6.2 31.2 13.3 23.1 20 50 28.6 20 12.5Satisfied 27.00 43.8 12.5 33.3 23.1 26.7 10 28.6 40 25Very Satisfied 35.16 50 37.5 46.7 30.8 33.3 20 14.3 40 43.8

D1 Better Working Environment 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.29 1.30 1.31 1.32 1.33 1.34 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 3.1 3.2Very Disatisfied 2.79 0 18.8 0 0 7.7 0 0 0 0 33.3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6.7 0 0 0 14.3 6.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 7.7 0 0Dissatisfied 4.73 0 31.2 0 0 0 7.1 6.7 0 20 22.2 10 16.7 0 0 6.7 6.7 0 6.2 0 6.2 0 6.7 0 0 14.3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Fairly Satisfied 15.52 13.3 0 0 0 7.7 0 20 0 0 22.2 20 33 14.3 6.2 13.3 20 50 18.8 33.3 31.2 26.7 20 20 36.4 14.3 0 21.4 0 7.7 6.7 27.3 7.7 7.7 28.6 20Satisfied 48.76 53.3 25 50 33.3 38.5 35.7 46.7 60 70 22.2 50 33 64.3 50 33.3 33.3 35.7 56.2 50 43.8 53.3 46.7 66.7 54.5 35.7 50 50 61.5 69.2 66.7 45.5 69.2 61.5 42.9 40Very Satisfied 28.20 33.3 25 50 66.7 46.2 57.1 26.7 40 10 0 20 16.7 21.4 43.8 46.7 40 14.3 18.8 16.7 18.8 13.3 26.7 13.3 9.1 21.4 43.8 28.6 38.5 23.1 26.7 27.3 23.1 23.1 28.6 40

D2 Incentives 3.5 3.8 3.10 3.12 3.14 3.15 3.16 3.18 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.9 4.10 4.11 4.12 4.13 4.14 4.15 4.16 4.17Very Disatisfied 1.82 0 0 0 0 0 28.6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7.7 0Dissatisfied 1.54 7.7 0 0 0 0 7.1 8.3 0 0 0 7.7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Fairly Satisfied 15.34 38.5 25 13.3 15.4 30.8 21.4 41.7 8.3 6.7 6.7 7.7 6.7 7.7 6.7 8.3 7.1 14.3 25 7.7 7.7Satisfied 46.35 30.8 50 53.3 53.8 30.8 21.4 33.3 58.3 66.7 53.3 69.2 53.3 46.2 46.7 66.7 50 57.1 16.7 30.8 38.5Very Satisfied 34.98 23.1 25 33.3 30.8 38.5 21.4 16.7 33.3 26.7 40 15.4 40 46.2 46.7 25 42.9 28.6 58.3 53.8 53.8

D4 Increased career prospects 3.17 3.19 3.20Very Disatisfied 3.33 0 0 10Dissatisfied 3.03 9.1 0 0Fairly Satisfied 15.50 18.2 8.3 20Satisfied 41.83 45.5 50 30Very Satisfied 36.33 27.3 41.7 40

Question and satisfaction

Page 284: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(=0#$#1&/2(3&$4#%(/5(>./&#$/(89#2/&5$$.&6#((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** :@,(

Ref BenefitA1 Improved Patient Experience 1.6 1.7 1.9 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.22 1.23 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.27 1.28 1.29 1.30 1.31 2.8 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.12 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.6 3.8 3.13 3.14 3.15 3.19

Very Disatisfied 3.17 2.4 2.4 2.6 2.4 3.3 6.9 5 3.3 13.3 3.7 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 3 0 7.3 7.5 0 2.4 2.5 2.9 5.3 5.1 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4 0 0 0 0 4.8Dissatisfied 1.90 0 4.9 0 0 0 3.4 5 3.3 13.3 3.7 0 0 0 0 6.1 0 0 0 0 4.9 5 2.9 2.6 5.1 0 0 2.4 0,00 0 0 0 0 0 0Fairly Satisfied 13.88 2.4 4.9 5.1 7.3 6.7 17.2 30 16.7 26.7 18.5 0 7.1 12.2 19.5 15.2 4.8 0 5 21.9 12.2 7.5 26.5 10.5 20.5 4.8 4.8 9.5 19 12.2 17.9 52.9 26.7 18.5 7.1Satisfied 32.84 26.8 31.7 28.2 34.1 46.7 41.4 25 26.7 20 44.4 26.8 31 29.3 36.6 45.5 52.4 39 40 43.8 34.1 27.5 23.5 36.8 33.3 28.6 28.6 21.4 28.6 29.3 30.8 23.5 26.7 48.1 26.2Very Satisfied 48.24 68.3 56.1 64.1 56.1 43.3 31 35 50 26.7 29.6 70 59.5 56.1 41.5 30.3 42.9 53.7 47.5 34.4 46.3 57.5 44.1 44.7 35.9 64.3 64.3 64.3 50 56.1 51.3 23.5 46.7 33.3 61.9

A2 Better Access to facilities (physical) 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.17 1.18 1.19 1.20 1.21 1.30Very Disatisfied 4.86 2.4 4.9 5 2.7 6.2 3.1 10 6.2 2.6 2.9 7.5Dissatisfied 4.51 2.4 2.4 2.5 0 3.1 12.5 15 6.2 2.6 2.9 0Fairly Satisfied 14.67 2,4 2.4 12.5 5.4 9.4 25 40 28.1 13.2 5.7 5Satisfied 26.05 14.6 24.4 27.5 29.7 25 18.8 10 31.2 36.8 28.6 40Very Satisfied 50.97 78 65.9 52.5 62.2 56.2 40.6 25 28.1 44.7 60 47.5

A3 Greater Privacy 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6Very Disatisfied 3.42 0 2.4 0 0,00 0 14.7Dissatisfied 8.82 4.8 7.3 13.8 13.5 13.5 0Fairly Satisfied 14.72 2.4 9.8 20.7 18.9 18.9 17.6Satisfied 27.45 38.1 19.5 34.5 21.6 21.6 29.4Very Satisfied 46.13 54.8 61 31 45.9 45.9 38.2

A4 More Services in 1 place (co-location) 3.5Very Disatisfied 2.60 2.6Dissatisfied 0.00 0Fairly Satisfied 5.10 5.1Satisfied 46.20 46.2Very Satisfied 46.20 46.2

A6 Greater Access (service) 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 3.5 3.17Very Disatisfied 5.30 2.6 17.9 4.9 4.9 2.4 2.4 6.7 2.6 3.3Dissatisfied 5.84 0 15.4 4,9 9.8 4.9 0 13.3 0 3.3Fairly Satisfied 15.06 10.5 25.6 12.2 17.1 4.9 26.8 13.3 5.1 20Satisfied 35.77 34.2 17.9 34.1 39 41.5 39 36.7 46.2 33.3Very Satisfied 37.89 52.6 23.1 43.9 29.3 46.3 31.7 30 46.2 40,0

A7 Less time waiting 3.11 3.1 3.12Very Disatisfied 1.20 2.4 0Dissatisfied 0.00 0 0Fairly Satisfied 6.55 4.8 8.3Satisfied 25.40 28.6 22.2Very Satisfied 66.85 64.3 69.4

A8 New Services 3.18 3.18Very Disatisfied 2.40 2.4Dissatisfied 4.90 4.9Fairly Satisfied 26.80 26.8Satisfied 29.30 29.3Very Satisfied 36.60 36.6

A10 Increased Patient Choice 4.3 4.4 4.10 4.11 4.12 3.50 3.11 3.70 3.13 3.18Very Disatisfied 2.23 0 0,00 5.1 2.5 5.1 2.6 2.4 0 0 2.4Dissatisfied 4.76 13.8 13.5 2.6 2.5 5.1 0 2.4 2.8 0 4.9Fairly Satisfied 21.91 20.7 18.9 23.1 25 20.5 5.1 12.2 13.9 52.9 26.8Satisfied 30.38 34.5 21.6 33.3 27.5 33.3 46.2 26.8 27.8 23.5 29.3Very Satisfied 40.92 31 45.9 35.9 42.5 35.9 46.2 56.1 55.6 23.5 36.6

C3 Improved Community facilities 3.9 3.16Very Disatisfied 1.65 0 3.3Dissatisfied 3.35 0 6.7Fairly Satisfied 23.25 13.2 33.3Satisfied 30.05 36.8 23.3Very Satisfied 41.65 50 33.3

Page 285: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&/3(4#5#4(62(3./&32.7/&6$(8#4./#%(/6("./&#$/3(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 9:9(

$%&'()*)'+',-.-/0*1'2-3-2'4/'1)*01/)5*04.'6-2)*-7'*4'8)*0-.*1''

!" !"#$%&'()*+,-'.,)/0#'$-'.1'#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /0"1()**+,)*-)$. "0234+)%5&'6+,)*-)$. "/0776+,)*-)$. /8079#$%&'6+,)*-)$. 97089

!" !"##"$%&''"((%#)%*+',-,#,"(%./01(,'+-2%#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. /0345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 4/0287+,)*-)$. "2093#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 390:8

!" !"#$%#"&'"()$*+&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. "/01()**+,)*-)$. 2/213+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. 60/715+,)*-)$. 17/08#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 09/6"

!" !"#$%&$#'()$*%(+%,%-./)$0)"1.")/2("+#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 20223+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. 60725+,)*-)$. "10/2#$%&'5+,)*-)$. "10/2

!" !"#$%#"&'((#))&*)#"+,(#-&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. /0345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 8/02"7+,)*-)$. 1/099#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 1903:

!" !"##$%&'"$()&%&*+$ #$%%&'()*+,-./,-0,'1 %$23+,--./,-0,'1 3$334.,(5)*6./,-0,'1 7$886./,-0,'1 28$93&'()*6./,-0,'1 77$:8

!" !"#$%"&'()"*$ #$%"&'()*+,-./,-0,'1 2$34+,--./,-0,'1 3$546.,(7)*8./,-0,'1 29$"48./,-0,'1 25$#4&'()*8./,-0,'1 #9$94

!"# !"#$%&'%()*&+,%"+)-./,#%)$%&'()*+,-*+.*%/ 0102)*++,-*+.*%/ 31456,*&7'(8,-*+.*%/ 0"19"8,-*+.*%/ 2#12:$%&'(8,-*+.*%/ 3#190

!" !"#$%&'()*%""+,-./)012-3-.-'4)#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. "0"23+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. 6"0625+,)*-)$. "7072#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 8/012

Page 286: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&/3(4#5#4(62(3./&32.7/&6$(8#4./#%(/6(3/.22(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 9:;(

$%&'()*)'+',-.-/0*1'2-3-2'4/'1)*01/)5*04.'6-2)*-7'*4'1*)//''

!" !"##"$%&''"((%#)%*+',-,#,"(%./01(,'+-2%#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /0/1()**+,)*-)$. 2203"4+)%5&'6+,)*-)$. ""0336+,)*-)$. "3077#$%&'6+,)*-)$. /8029

!" !"##"$%&'$()*+%,*-)$'*."*##$%&'!()*+(),($- ./01!())*+(),($- 2/034*(%5&'6*+(),($- "7/7.6*+(),($- 28/09#$%&'6*+(),($- .8/.:

!" !"#$"%&'$(#$%&'!()*+(),($- ./0"!())*+(),($- ./123*(%4&'5*+(),($- .1/625*+(),($- 27/61#$%&'5*+(),($- 62/80

!" !"#$%&'%()#&$%%$)*$+'*%#,'#$%&'!()*+(),($- ./..!())*+(),($- ./0.1*(%2&'3*+(),($- 45/503*+(),($- "4/6.#$%&'3*+(),($- .7/..

Page 287: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#(()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&/3(4#5#4(62(3./&32.7/&6$(8#4./#%(/6(7#$/8#(<3#83(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 9:=(

$%&'()*)'+',-.-/0*1'2-3-2'4/'1)*01/)5*04.'6-2)*-7'*4'5-.*6-'91-61'

!" !"#$%&'()*+,-'.,)/0#'$-'.1'#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 30214+)%5&'6+,)*-)$. 730"26+,)*-)$. 730"2#$%&'6+,)*-)$. 1107"

!" !"##"$%&''"((%#)%*+',-,#,"(%./01(,'+-2%#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /0"1()**+,)*-)$. 20345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 8902/7+,)*-)$. ":094#$%&'7+,)*-)$. :8091

!" !"#$%#"&'"()$*+&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 30456+)%7&'8+,)*-)$. 9:0"48+,)*-)$. ;3092#$%&'8+,)*-)$. /"059

!" !"#$%&$#'()$*%(+%,%-./)$0)"1.")/2("+#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 20223+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. /0125+,)*-)$. 67082#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 190:2

!" !"#$%#"&'((#))&*)#"+,(#-&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 20345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 210897+,)*-)$. 1:09:#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 23011

!" !"##$%&'"$()&%&*+$#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 20223+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. 1"0/65+,)*-)$. 78096#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 1/082

!" !"#$%"&'()"*$ #$%"&'()*+,-./,-0,'1 #$23+,--./,-0,'1 #$234.,(5)*6./,-0,'1 73$836./,-0,'1 #2$83&'()*6./,-0,'1 #8$93

!"# !"#$%&'%()*&+,%"+)-./,#%)$%&'()*+,-*+.*%/ 0123)*++,-*+.*%/ 31425,*&6'(7,-*+.*%/ 431387,-*+.*%/ 3"193$%&'(7,-*+.*%/ 49133

!" !"#$%&'()*%""+,-./)012-3-.-'4)#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 30324+)%5&'6+,)*-)$. 780816+,)*-)$. 3"081#$%&'6+,)*-)$. 21032

Page 288: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&/3(4#5#4(62(3./&32.7/&6$(8#4./#%(/6("./&#$/(>(7#$/8#(<3#83(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 9:?(

$%&'()*)'+',-.-/0*1'2-3-2'4/'1)*01/)5*04.'6-2)*-7'*4'8)*0-.*').7'5-.*6-'91-61'

!" !"#$%&'()*+,-'.,)/0#'$-'.1'#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. /03"4+)%5&'6+,)*-)$. "70896+,)*-)$. :70//#$%&'6+,)*-)$. 820:9

!" !"##"$%&''"((%#)%*+',-,#,"(%./01(,'+-2%#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. /0/23+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. 6/0775+,)*-)$. "/0/7#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 890:;

!" !"#$%#"&'"()$*+&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /01"()**+,)*-)$. 20345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. /108"7+,)*-)$. 4809:#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 89082

!" !"#$%&$#'()$*%(+%,%-./)$0)"1.")/2("+#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /0/1()**+,)*-)$. 10112+)%3&'4+,)*-)$. /0/14+,)*-)$. 56061#$%&'4+,)*-)$. "7081

!" !"#$%#"&'((#))&*)#"+,(#-&#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. 30415+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 820/47+,)*-)$. 44049#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 43099

!" !"##$%&'"$()&%&*+$#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. /012()**+,)*-)$. /0"23+)%4&'5+,)*-)$. /10625+,)*-)$. 7/078#$%&'5+,)*-)$. 29012

!" !"#$%"&'()"*$ #$%"&'()*+,-./,-0,'1 2$34+,--./,-0,'1 5$647.,(8)*9./,-0,'1 2:$#49./,-0,'1 #4$44&'()*9./,-0,'1 #6$%4

!"# !"#$%&'%()*&+,%"+)-./,#%)$%&'()*+,-*+.*%/ 0122)*++,-*+.*%/ 31456,*&7'(8,-*+.*%/ 291"08,-*+.*%/ 2915#$%&'(8,-*+.*%/ 04149

!" !"#$%&'()*%""+,-./)012-3-.-'4)#$%&'()*+,)*-)$. "/01()**+,)*-)$. 2/345+)%6&'7+,)*-)$. 24/217+,)*-)$. 28/14#$%&'7+,)*-)$. 99/:1

Page 289: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&/3(45&6&/#%(&$(789:3;8"3(<(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,=>(

Str

ateg

ic B

enef

its

Sub

Ben

efits

Incr

ease

d av

alia

bilit

y of

se

rvic

es

Ser

vice

div

ersi

ty /

ra

nge

Incr

ease

d ph

ysic

al

acce

ss (

with

in

site

)

App

ropr

iate

lo

catio

n (a

nd

acce

ss t

o th

e si

te)

Incr

ease

d pa

tient

/use

r se

curity

and

saf

ety

Co-

loca

tion

/ di

stribu

tion

Use

/ c

apac

ity fit

(for

pur

pose

bu

ildin

g &

in

fras

truc

ture

)

Faci

litie

s fle

xibi

lity

and

futu

re

proo

fing

Bet

ter

wor

king

en

viro

nmen

t

Gre

ater

priva

cy &

co

mfo

rt

Syst

em o

vera

ll in

tegr

atio

n

Reso

urce

sy

nerg

ies

(im

prov

ed

effic

ienc

y)

Ser

vice

syn

ergi

es

Impr

oved

qua

lity

of c

are

Dec

reas

e in

tern

als

(adm

issi

ons)

Con

text

de

velo

pmen

t &

re

gena

ratio

n

Sta

keho

lder

al

ignm

ent

Bet

ter

equi

pmen

t /

reso

urse

s

Inve

st.

/ ch

ange

m

anag

emen

t ef

fort

Proj

ect

nega

tive

impa

ct

Sta

keho

lder

s in

volv

emen

t

Syne

rgy

of

serv

ices

(e.

g.

seco

ndar

y ca

re)

Impr

oved

ser

vice

co

ordi

natio

n

A Accesibility x XA1 Equity of sites and community coverage XA2 Enables improved service range to be delivered X XA3 Physical access to sites and premises optimal X XA4 Safe and secure setting X XA5 Clear Flows and way finding X XA6 Extended Opening hours X XB Capacity xB1 Enables PCT deliver capacity required for Tier 2 x XB2 Enables PCT deliver capacity required for GP expansion x XB3 Offers new capacity for extended PCHT x XB4 Enables PCT to deliver new and extended capacity required for psychological therapies x XB5 Enables extended and flexible capacity for health lifestyle services x XB6 Creating workforce and staffing opportunities employment and volunteering x XB7 Capacity increase in dental care x XC Functionality x

C1 Buildings are functionally fit for purpose x XC2 Future proof in terms of flexible clinical space x XC3 ‘User Friendly’ x XC4 Health and Safety Aspects x XC5 Integrated systems – infrastructure… x XC6 Integrated systems – hospitality, … x XD Efficiency x

D1 best use of space - optimal size areas for services x X XD2 flexibility of space - multiple use, DDA compliant x X XD3 flexibility of space - signage, wayfinding, respond to future changes in services x XD4 flexibility of space - Respond to future changes in services x XD5 optimum user of human resources - economy of scale (i.e. management and administration), working patternsx XD6 synergies of joint working x X XD7 shorter waiting times x XD8 meeting and greeting x XD9 multi-services in one location x X X

D10 appropriate booking facilities x XD11 new employment x XD12 better access to information x XD13 newer, improved and efficient uttilities - green x XD14 appropriate, up to date equipment x XD15 location of development - staff and patients x X XD16 use of available capacity x XD17 reducing hospital admissions x X XD18 more efficient, simpler patient pathway x XD19 reducing inappropriate patient contacts - streamline x X

E Ease of Implementation xE1 enables prasing plus balance of implementation x XE2 minimizes management time x XF Whole System Optimisation x

F1 pathway referral agreement x XF2 decreased DNAs xF3 decrease community service visits xF4 service provision - providers x

Emerging Benefits following consolidation and segmentation

Elicited Benefits from Workshops 1 and 2

Description (proposed)Elicited Benefits

Page 290: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"$(()(*+,(-./.()(4$.?5#93(&%#$/&2&#%(&$(789:3;8"(,(((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,==(

Accessibility Capacity Functionality Efficiency Ease of implementationWhole system optimisation

Equi

ty o

f site

s an

d co

mm

unity

En

able

s im

prov

ed

serv

ice to

be

Phys

ical a

cces

s to

sit

es a

nd p

rem

ises

Safe

and

sec

ure

setti

ngCl

ear F

low

s an

d w

ay fi

ndin

gEx

tend

ed O

peni

ng

hour

s

PCT

capa

city

- Ti

er

2 PCT

cap

acity

-GP

ex

pans

ion

New

cap

acity

for

exte

nded

PCH

TPC

T ca

pacit

y p

sy.

ther

apie

sEn

able

s ex

tend

ed

and

flexi

ble

Crea

ting

wor

kfor

ce

oppo

rtun

ities

Build

ings

are

fu

nctio

nally

fit f

or

Futu

re p

roof

in

term

s of

flex

ible

‘Use

r Frie

ndly

Heal

th a

nd S

afet

y As

pect

sIn

tegr

ated

sy

stem

s –

Best

use

of s

pace

- fle

xibi

lity

Resp

ond

to fu

ture

ch

ange

s in

Op

timum

use

r of

hum

an re

sour

ces

- Sy

nerg

ies

of jo

int

wor

king

Shor

ter w

aitin

g tim

esM

eetin

g an

d gr

eetin

gM

ulti-

serv

ices

in

one

loca

tion

New

em

ploy

men

t

Bette

r acc

ess

to

info

rmat

ion

New

er, i

mpr

oved

an

d ef

ficie

nt

Appr

opria

te, u

p to

da

te e

quip

men

tRe

ducin

g ho

spita

l ad

miss

ions

Mor

e ef

ficie

nt,

simpl

er p

atie

nt

Enab

les

pras

ing

plus

bal

ance

of

Min

imize

s m

anag

emen

t tim

e

Path

way

refe

rral

ag

reem

ent

Decr

ease

d DN

As

Decr

ease

co

mm

unity

ser

vice

Se

rvice

pro

visio

n -

prov

ider

s

A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D9 D10 D11 D12 D15 D16 F1 F2 E1 E2 E3 E41 Reduce Excuse factor 1 X2 One stop visit – diagnostics enhance “perceived” accessibility 1 X3 Liaise with GMPTE 1 X4 Security for staff – evenings etc. 2 X X5 Security inside building 2 X X6 Flexible working hours 1 X7 Government Policy 1 X8 Security 1 X9 PCT Contract 1 X

10 Transport 2 X X11 Service funding providers 1 X12 Staff 4 X X X X13 Money 3 X X X14 Practice Based Commissioning (PBC) 1 X15 Change management 1 X16 Education Programmes 2 X X17 Communication and information 3 X X X18 Equipment 2 X X19 Culture change 1 X20 IT 5 X X X X X21 Access 4 X X X X22 Trained staff 1 X23 Choice (How and interventions) 1 X24 Volunteers 1 X25 Info sharing protocol 1 X26 Info availability 1 X27 Partnerships 1 X28 Broader staff involvement 1 X29 Clinical governance 1 X30 Coldicott 1 X31 Patient/service user group 1 X32 Involvement 1 X33 Legislation 1 X34 Systems engineer 1 X35 Business Management 1 X36 Service providers 1 X37 Facilities Management 1 X38 Robust structured approach 1 X39 One stop shop model 2 X X40 GPs maximizing rent 1 X41 Estates strategy - SMBC 1 X42 Whole system engagement 1 X43 No decant necessary, phased 1 X44 On site diagnostics 1 X45 High profile location 1 X46 Multi-agency links 1 X47 Signage, way-finding 1 X48 Working patterns 2 X X49 Engagement 1 X50 Partnership with local organizations 1 X51 Reducing inappropriate patient contacts - streamline 1 X52 Booking plus utilization system 1 X53 Information pods/leaflets 1 X54 Complimentary facilities – crèche, secure buggy lock 1 X55 Location of services in building. 1 X56 Adequate parking provision 3 X X X57 Lighting and Environment quality 1 X58 Enough lifts etc 1 X59 Clarity of routes 1 X60 No bottle necks 1 X61 Separate Routes 1 X62 Infrastructure 1 X63 Room, space 4 X X X X64 Flexible space 3 X X X65 Project/ Building concept 2 X X66 Building environment 1 X67 Patient and staff facilities 1 X68 Training facility 1 X69 Optimal size areas for services 1 X70 Location/position site 1 X71 Multi-use rooms 1 x72 Design - standard sized rooms 2 X X73 Appropriate booking facilities 2 X X

PROC

ESS

PHYS

ICAL

Enablers

Cont

rol (

N.º

of c

ases

)

Initial Strategic Benefits

Page 291: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"%(()(*+,(-./.(0(!6/893(@%#$/&2&#%(&$(789:3;8"(,(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,=A(

Accessibility Capacity Functionality Efficiency Ease of implementationWhole system optimisation

Equi

ty o

f si

tes

and

com

mun

ity

Enab

les

impr

oved

se

rvic

e to

be

Phys

ical

acc

ess

to

site

s an

d pr

emis

es

Saf

e an

d se

cure

se

ttin

gCle

ar F

low

s an

d w

ay fin

ding

Exte

nded

Ope

ning

ho

urs

PCT

capa

city

- T

ier

2 PCT

cap

acity

-G

P ex

pans

ion

New

cap

acity

for

ex

tend

ed P

CH

TPC

T ca

paci

ty ps

y.

ther

apie

sEn

able

s ex

tend

ed

and

flexi

ble

Cre

atin

g w

orkf

orce

op

port

uniti

es

Bui

ldin

gs a

re

func

tiona

lly fit

for

Futu

re p

roof

in

term

s of

fle

xibl

e

‘Use

r Fr

iend

ly’

Hea

lth a

nd S

afet

y Asp

ects

Inte

grat

ed

syst

ems

Bes

t us

e of

spa

ce-

flexi

bilit

yRe

spon

d to

fut

ure

chan

ges

in

Opt

imum

use

r of

hu

man

res

ourc

es -

Sy

nerg

ies

of joi

nt

wor

king

Sho

rter

wai

ting

times

Mee

ting

and

gree

ting

Mul

ti-se

rvic

es in

on

e lo

catio

n

New

em

ploy

men

t

Bet

ter

acce

ss t

o in

form

atio

nN

ewer

, im

prov

ed

and

effic

ient

App

ropr

iate

, up

to

date

equ

ipm

ent

Redu

cing

hos

pita

l ad

mis

sion

sM

ore

effic

ient

, si

mpl

er p

atie

nt

Enab

les

pras

ing

plus

bal

ance

of

Min

imiz

es

man

agem

ent

time

Path

way

ref

erra

l ag

reem

ent

Dec

reas

ed D

NAs

Dec

reas

e co

mm

unity

ser

vice

Ser

vice

pro

visi

on -

pr

ovid

ers

A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D9 D10 D11 D12 D15 D16 F1 F2 E1 E2 E3 E41 SHA 2 X X2 SHE 3 X X X3 GPs 10 X X X X X X X X X X4 Finance 1 X5 PCT 6 X X X X X X6 Project Directorates 4 X X X X7 Stockport managed care (SMC) 4 X X X X8 Public consultation 2 X X9 PCT Commissioners 5 X X X X X

10 Service Providers 4 X X X X11 Patient consultation 5 X X X X X12 Consultants 3 X X X13 Contractors 8 X X X X X X X X14 LA 2 X X15 GMPTS 2 X X16 Staff consultation 1 X17 Security 2 X X18 Health and safety 2 X X19 Police 1 X20 Service managers/leaders 11 X X X X X X X X X X X21 IT support/supplier 6 X X X X X X22 Administration team 1 X23 LA highways 1 X24 Foundation Trust 5 X X X X X25 GPwSl 1 X26 NWAS (ambulance) 1 X27 Patient support group 2 X X28 HR 1 X29 Centre 1 X30 Architects and design team 7 X X X X X X X31 Healthcare planner 1 X32 MPs Councillors 1 X33 PCT providers 5 X X X X X34 GP support staff 1 X35 LMC 1 X36 PALs 1 X37 MPs/councillors 1 X38 DNs/ACM 1 X39 Pediatrists 1 X40 School nurses 1 X41 Social Care staff 1 X42 Therapists 1 X43 Pennine care F-T 1 X44 Voluntary organisations 5 X X X X X45 3rd/independent sector providers 3 X X X46 Substance and misuse service 1 X47 Public health 1 X48 Community group 2 X X49 College 4 X X X X50 Enterprise 1 X51 Commerce providers 1 X52 Marketing 1 X53 Partnerships 1 X54 DOH 2 X X55 Clinical governance 3 X X X56 Staff 4 X X X X57 Emergency services 1 X58 Facility management 1 X59 Local Government 1 X60 Policy makers 1 X61 Support service leads 1 X62 Health planners 4 X X X X63 Employers - external and eptc 3 X X X64 Human resource 2 X X65 SMBC 4 X X X X66 Procurement Staff 1 X67 FT 1 X68 Service implementation proj. lead 1 X

Actors

Con

trol

(N

.º o

f ca

ses)

Initial Strategic Benefits

Page 292: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"&(()(*+,(-./.(0(1#$#2&6&.9&#3(&%#$/&2&#%(&$(789:3;8"(,((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,=B(

Accessibility Capacity Functionality 0% Efficiency Ease of implementationWhole system optimisation

Equi

ty o

f si

tes

and

com

mun

ity

Enab

les

impr

oved

se

rvic

e to

be

Phys

ical

acc

ess

to

site

s an

d pr

emis

es

Saf

e an

d se

cure

se

ttin

gCle

ar F

low

s an

d w

ay fin

ding

Exte

nded

Ope

ning

ho

urs

PCT

capa

city

- T

ier

2 PCT

cap

acity

-G

P ex

pans

ion

New

cap

acity

for

ex

tend

ed P

CH

TPC

T ca

paci

ty ps

y.

ther

apie

sEn

able

s ex

tend

ed

and

flexi

ble

Cre

atin

g w

orkf

orce

op

port

uniti

es

Bui

ldin

gs a

re

func

tiona

lly fit

for

Futu

re p

roof

in

term

s of

fle

xibl

e

‘Use

r Fr

iend

ly’

Hea

lth a

nd S

afet

y Asp

ects

Inte

grat

ed

syst

ems

Bes

t us

e of

spa

ce-

flexi

bilit

yRe

spon

d to

fut

ure

chan

ges

in

Opt

imum

use

r of

hu

man

res

ourc

es -

Sy

nerg

ies

of joi

nt

wor

king

Sho

rter

wai

ting

times

Mee

ting

and

gree

ting

Mul

ti-se

rvic

es in

on

e lo

catio

n

New

em

ploy

men

t

Bet

ter

acce

ss t

o in

form

atio

nN

ewer

, im

prov

ed

and

effic

ient

App

ropr

iate

, up

to

date

equ

ipm

ent

Redu

cing

hos

pita

l ad

mis

sion

sM

ore

effic

ient

, si

mpl

er p

atie

nt

Enab

les

pras

ing

plus

bal

ance

of

Min

imiz

es

man

agem

ent

time

Path

way

ref

erra

l ag

reem

ent

Dec

reas

ed D

NAs

Dec

reas

e co

mm

unity

ser

vice

Ser

vice

pro

visi

on -

pr

ovid

ers

A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 A6 B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 D1 D2 D3 D4 D5 D6 D7 D9 D10 D11 D12 D15 D16 F1 F2 E1 E2 E3 E41 Service users 10 X X X X X X X X X X2 AHP 1 X3 GPs 10 X X X X X X X X X X4 Carers 9 X X X X X X X X X5 Community 18 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X6 Transport service 1 X7 Service user of social care 1 X8 Voluntary organisations 3 X X X9 PCT 5 X X X X X

10 PCHT 1 X11 Stockport managed care (SMC) 1 X12 Vulnerable groups 1 X13 Volunteers 2 X X14 Service Providers 4 X X X X15 Patients 18 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X16 Students 1 X17 Employees 1 X18 Local businesses 5 X X X X X19 Commissioners 3 X X X20 Social enterprise 1 X21 Transport 1 X22 IT support/supplier 1 X23 GP support staff 1 X24 PALs 1 X25 Social Care 1 X26 3rd/independent sector providers 1 X27 College 6 X X X X X X28 DOH 4 X X X X29 Staff 14 X X X X X X X X X X X X X X30 Local Employers 3 X X X31 Alied health professionals 1 X32 SMBC 3 X X X33 PP groups 1 X34 FT 1 X35 IS (loadstore) 1 X36 Service implementation proj. lead 1 X

Beneficiaries

Con

trol

(N

.º o

f ca

ses)

Initial Strategic Benefits

Page 293: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#$()(*+,(-(.&/(0#$#1&2/(&%#$2&1&#%(&$(3456/74"(,(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,89(

(

(

(

Acc

essi

bilit

y

Cap

acity

Func

tiona

lity

Effic

ienc

y

Ease

of

impl

emen

tatio

n

Who

le s

yste

m

optim

isat

ion

1 Reduction in activity in secondary care 1 X2 Further to travel & ease of access to new location 3 X X X3 No nearby parking facilities 3 X X X4 No Public transport available 1 X5 Loss of belonging 1 X6 Impersonal & Intimidating Building 2 X X7 Busy environment will create confusion 2 X X8 Security of the Estate 2 X X9 Staff Communication 3 X X X

10 Building not fully uitilised 1 X11 Not acceptable to some clients 1 X12 Transition period creating inneficiency 1 X13 New working patterns for staff (service) 3 X X X14 Great dependency on IT services 2 X X15 Room sharing 1 X16 Change impacts on staff 2 X X17 Not in a key shopping centreor location 1 X18 Reduced foot fall 1 X

100% 16% 6% 6% 29% 26% 16%31 5 2 2 9 8 5

Dis-benifits Summary

Con

trol

(N

.º o

f ca

ses)

Initial Strategic Benefits

!"#

$"#

%!"#

%$"#

&!"#

&$"#

'!"#())*++,-,.,/0#

1232),/0#

456)7862.,/0#

9:),*6)0#

92+*#8;#,<3.*<*6/2786#

=>8.*#+0+/*<#837<,+2786#

Page 294: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"##(()(*+:(.;2;(-(<#$#1&2/(#=&>&2#%(&$(3456/74"/(?)@(;$%(<#$#1&2(%#1&$&2&4$/(145(4"2&4$##5&$A(&$(3456/74"(B(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8?(

DoMin.

1. Strategic Fit1.1 Stakeholder alignment How consistent is the option with the priorities and targets of our

PCTs, SHA and Department of Health?1.2 Context How consistent is the option with the Trust’s strategic priorities?1.3 Research alignment How well does the option further the joint research priorities of

BSUH/Brighton & Sussex Medical School?1.4 Synergy How consistent is the option with the strategies of our clinical

networks and neighbouring NHS Trusts?1.5 Image & reputation To what extent is the option likely to improve the Trust’s

reputation/image with our patients and local residents?2. Clinical Outcomes2.1 Co-location How well does the option co-locate services on the RSCH campus

to improve patient care?2.2 Reduce unnecessary patient attendances Outdated accommodation leads to inefficient processes and

repeat patient visits. To what extent will the option improve this and reduce unnecessary attendances?

2.3 Improved quality of care How well will the option improve the patient’s experience of the 2.4 Improved care outcomes To what extent will the option improve clinical outcomes, eg.

Healthcare Acquired Infection, mortality.3. Appropriate Facilities (and Facilities Management)3.1 Fit-for-purpose building & infrastructure To what extent will accommodation be ‘fit for purpose’ in the

option?3.2 Flexibility and future development of facilities To what extent does the option lend itself to flexible use of

facilities and possible expansion in the future?3.3 Physical distribution of service locations (layout) How sensibly are buildings/services arranged in the option, eg. to

reduce time staff, patients and visitors spend moving across the site?

3.4 Improved support services To what extent does the option improve Facilities Management, eg. supplies, laundry, waste disposal?

3.5 Increased patient safety To what extent is the option likely to improve patient safety?3.6 Greater privacy (by better design) To what extent is the option likely to improve patient dignity and

privacy?3.7 Backlog maintenance To what extent will the option reduce backlog maintenance on 3.8 Better working environment To what extent will the option provide a better working 4. Access to Services4.1 Demand/capacity fit To what extent will the option increase capacity (eg. inpatient

beds) in line with demand?4.2 Improved physical access To what extent will the option improve patients’ and visitors’

physical access to the campus, eg. parking, public transport, finding their way once on site.

4.3 Availability of services To what extent will the phasing of the development allow the Trust’s highest priority services to start/be improved first?

5. Teaching, Training & Research5.1 Improved research capability To what extent will the option enhance the research capability of

the Trust/Universities/Brighton & Sussex Medical School?5.2 Improved teaching To what extent will the option enhance the teaching of

students/trainees of all disciplines?5.3 Knowledge transfer To what extent does the option create a good learning 6. Use of Resources6.1 Use of technology To what extent does the option take advantage of the latest

technology to provide more efficient and more effective services?6.2 Recruitment & Retention To what extent is the option likely to strengthen the recruitment

and retention of staff?

7. Operational Management7.1 Improved service coordination To what extent is the option likely to lead to more effective

operational management of services?7.2 Communication & teamwork To what extent is the option likely to strengthen staff

communication and teamwork?7.3 Impact of construction How likely is it that services will be able to treat the same

number of patients during the building/decant phase under this option?

8. Development & Implementation8.1 Investment / change management effort To what extent does the option require more investment in

change management than is likely to be feasible?

3 52A 2B

6.3 Improved efficiency To what extent is the option likely to improve the efficiency of services?

Criteria Description 1

Page 295: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#%(()(*+:(.;2;(-(<#$#1&2/(3#&A72&$A(;$%(4"2&4$(/>45&$A(5#/C=2/(&$(3456/74"(D(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8,(

Regional Centre for Teaching, Trauma & Tertiary Care: ‘3T Programme’ Scores from 9th February Non-Financial Appraisal Workshop

Criteria Criteria Scaled Weight

Option 1

Option 3

Option 5

Option Do

Min. A

Option Do

Min. B

1 Strategic Fit 13.4

1.1 Stakeholder Engagement 2.7 88% 67% 62% 7% 19%

1.2 Context 2.7 87% 70% 59% 33% 16%

1.3 Research Alignment 2.7 79% 68% 56% 7% 13%

1.4 Synergy 3.6 84% 67% 62% 13% 20%

1.5 Image & Reputation 1.8 88% 67% 59% 10% 17%

2 Clinical Outcomes 17.9

2.1 Co-location 5.4 85% 63% 61% 7% 15%

2.2 Reduce unnecessary patient attendances 1.8 84% 69% 54% 11% 20%

2.3 Improved quality of care 5.4 84% 72% 66% 10% 18%

2.4 Improved care outcomes 5.4 80% 71% 65% 11% 18%

3 Appropriate Facilities (& Facilities Management) 25.0

3.1 Fit-for-purpose building and infrastructure 3.6 83% 66% 60% 9% 16%

3.2 Flexibility and future development of facilities 2.7 81% 62% 55% 21% 25%

3.3 Physical distribution of service locations (layout) 3.6 81% 65% 64% 9% 16%

3.4 Improved support services 1.8 80% 71% 67% 12% 21%

3.5 Increased patient safety 5.4 82% 72% 66% 12% 21%

3.6 Greater privacy (by better design) 3.6 87% 78% 72% 13% 19%

3.7 Backlog maintenance 0.9 85% 76% 48% 9% 18%

3.8 Better working environment 3.6 88% 77% 67% 12% 20%

4 Access to Services 10.7

4.1 Demand/capacity fit 5.4 79% 71% 65% 7% 16%

4.2 Improved physical access 3.6 78% 68% 62% 11% 14%

4.3 Availability of services 1.8 87% 58% 55% 6% 22%

5 Teaching, Training & Research 8.9

5.1 Improved research capability 3.6 80% 73% 64% 5% 12%

5.2 Improved teaching 3.6 80% 72% 60% 5% 13%

5.3 Knowledge transfer 1.8 84% 74% 58% 6% 13%

6 Use of Resources 10.7

6.1 Use of Technology 3.6 83% 65% 57% 9% 18%

6.2 Recruitment and Retention 1.8 85% 71% 64% 7% 16%

6.3 Improved efficiency 5.4 86% 71% 66% 8% 18%

7 Operational Management 12.5

7.1 Improved service coordination 4.5 85% 65% 63% 8% 18%

7.2 Communication and teamwork 2.7 84% 62% 60% 10% 18%

7.3 Impact of construction 5.4 79% 58% 59% 25% 30%

8 Development & Implementation 0.9

8.1 Investment / change management effort 0.9 59% 57% 54% 32% 39%

Total 100 83% 68% 62% 11% 18%

Option 1 is the preferred design and will be taken forward to the financial appraisal process.

Page 296: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#&(()(*+:(.;2;()(E"2&4$(/>45&$A(/"5#;%(/7##2(#';F"=#(&$(3456/74"(D(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8:(

Crit

eria

W1

2A2B

35

Min

12A

2B3

5M

in1

2A2B

35

Min

1St

rate

gic

Fit

13.4

%0.

50.

40.

40.

50.

50.

10.

50.

40.

40.

50.

50.

20.

50.

50.

40.

60.

50.

23.

72.

72.

74.

04.

01.

03.

62.

83.

03.

83.

61.

63.

83.

43.

24.

64.

01.

61.

1S

take

hold

er a

lignm

ent

32

24

41

43

33

31

43

35

41

1.2

Con

text

53

35

51

43

34

42

44

44

41

1.3

Res

earc

h al

ignm

ent

32

34

31

43

34

43

1.4

Syn

ergy

33

33

32

43

35

42

1.5

Imag

e &

repu

tatio

n3

33

33

14

33

55

23

43

54

12

Clin

ical

Out

com

es17

.9%

0.7

0.5

0.4

0.7

0.5

0.2

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.7

0.7

0.3

0.8

0.5

0.5

0.9

0.8

0.3

4.0

2.7

2.0

4.0

2.7

1.0

3.3

2.5

2.5

3.8

4.0

1.5

4.3

3.0

2.8

4.8

4.5

1.8

2.1

Co-

loca

tion

42

24

31

32

24

52

43

34

42

2.2

Red

uce

unne

cess

ary

patie

nt a

ttend

ance

s3

33

33

14

33

54

12.

3Im

prov

ed q

ualit

y of

car

e4

22

43

13

22

44

14

32

55

22.

4Im

prov

ed c

are

outc

omes

44

24

21

43

34

42

53

35

52

3A

ppro

pria

te F

acili

ties

(and

Fac

ilitie

s M

anag

emen

t)25

%0.

80.

60.

51.

00.

70.

30.

80.

60.

61.

11.

00.

51.

00.

80.

71.

20.

70.

33.

22.

52.

24.

02.

81.

03.

32.

62.

34.

44.

11.

94.

03.

42.

64.

92.

81.

33.

1Fi

t-for

-pur

pose

bui

ldin

g &

infra

stru

ctur

e4

33

43

14

23

54

15

41

51

13.

2Fl

exib

ility

and

futu

re d

evel

opm

ent o

f fac

ilitie

s5

22

52

14

21

55

33

11

53

13.

3P

hysi

cal d

istri

butio

n of

ser

vice

loca

tions

(lay

out)

33

14

11

32

25

52

43

35

41

3.4

Impr

oved

sup

port

serv

ices

44

45

31

3.5

Incr

ease

d pa

tient

saf

ety

43

24

42

44

45

32

3.6

Gre

ater

priv

acy

(by

bette

r des

ign)

33

34

41

33

33

33

44

34

31

3.7

Bac

klog

mai

nten

ance

22

24

42

21

43

14

43

52

23.

8B

ette

r wor

king

env

ironm

ent

22

23

31

34

45

51

43

25

31

4A

cces

s to

Ser

vice

s10

.7%

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.5

0.5

0.4

0.5

0.5

0.1

3.0

3.0

3.0

2.5

2.5

1.0

3.3

3.3

3.7

3.7

4.0

1.3

4.3

4.3

3.7

5.0

4.3

1.3

4.1

Dem

and/

capa

city

fit

34

55

51

55

55

52

4.2

Impr

oved

phy

sica

l acc

ess

33

33

31

32

23

42

44

35

41

4.3

Avai

labi

lity

of s

ervi

ces

33

32

21

44

43

31

44

35

41

5Te

achi

ng, T

rain

ing

& R

esea

rch

8.9%

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

3.3

3.0

3.0

3.7

3.7

1.7

3.0

2.3

2.3

4.0

4.0

1.3

5.1

Impr

oved

rese

arch

cap

abili

ty0

00

00

03

33

44

12

22

55

25.

2Im

prov

ed te

achi

ng3

33

33

23

33

33

15.

3K

now

ledg

e tra

nsfe

r4

33

44

24

22

44

16

Use

of R

esou

rces

10.7

%0.

30.

30.

30.

40.

40.

10.

30.

20.

20.

40.

30.

10.

40.

40.

20.

50.

30.

13.

03.

03.

03.

53.

51.

03.

02.

32.

33.

73.

01.

03.

33.

72.

35.

02.

71.

36.

1U

se o

f tec

hnol

ogy

32

24

21

44

15

11

6.2

Rec

ruitm

ent &

Ret

entio

n3

33

44

13

22

33

13

32

53

16.

3Im

prov

ed e

ffici

ency

33

33

31

33

34

41

34

45

42

7O

pera

tiona

l Man

agem

ent

12.5

%0.

40.

40.

40.

40.

40.

10.

40.

30.

40.

50.

60.

20.

40.

40.

30.

50.

50.

23.

03.

03.

03.

03.

01.

03.

02.

73.

04.

34.

71.

73.

03.

02.

34.

34.

01.

77.

1Im

prov

ed s

ervi

ce c

oord

inat

ion

33

33

31

33

35

51

22

15

41

7.2

Com

mun

icat

ion

& te

amw

ork

32

35

51

33

24

42

7.3

Impa

ct o

f con

stru

ctio

n3

33

34

34

44

44

28

Dev

elop

men

t & Im

plem

enta

tion

0.9%

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

1.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

4.0

4.0

3.0

2.0

2.0

2.0

4.0

4.0

1.0

8.1

Inve

stm

ent /

cha

nge

man

agem

ent e

ffort

33

33

31

33

34

43

22

24

41

Cum

ulat

ive

Sco

re-

6049

4566

5517

9579

8011

511

347

111

9882

140

109

43W

eigh

ted

100%

3.0

2.5

2.3

3.3

2.8

0.9

3.3

2.7

2.7

4.0

3.9

1.6

3.8

3.3

2.7

4.7

3.7

1.5

Page 297: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#'(-(!==(*+(()(G54H#>2(/>4"&$A(;$%(1#;/&0&=&2I(JC#/2&4$$;&5#(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8@(

()*)+,-./0)12,.1-,3*/.435,*6/1*7/+)1.,8,2,-9/:/!*-)0;,)</503-3432/

KL!MGNK(OPK+QRES+(

!*-)0;,)<))/6)*)012/,*+30=1-,3*/

?T 37;2(&/(I4C5(54=#(&$(27#(45A;$&/;2&4$U(,T V4W(=4$A(7;X#(I4C(0#$(&$X4=X#%(W&27(27#("54H#>2(;$%(24(W7;2(>;";>&2IU(

>)*)012/43*-)?-@12,.1-,3*/

:T V4W(&/(27#("54H#>2(45A;$&/#%U(@T 37;2(&/(27#(>C55#$2(/2;2#(41(27#(%#X#=4"F#$2U(BT V4W(%4(I4C(%#/>5&0#(;(/C>>#//1C=(7#;=27>;5#(&$15;/25C>2C5#("54H#>2U(DT 37;2(%4(I4C(27&$6(;5#(27#(F;&$(/25#$A27/(41(27&/("54H#>2U(

A)04)5-,3*/3+/.-1B)C327)0/)*616)=)*-//

YT V4W(;5#( 27#(5#JC&5#F#$2/(41( 27#(/2;6#74=%#5/( &$X4=X#%(>;"2C5#%(;$%( 2;6#$(2754CA7(27#("54>#//U(

8T V4W(%4(/2;6#74=%#5/(";52&>&";2#(&$(%#>&/&4$)F;6&$AU(ZT !5#(27#5#(;$I(;%X;$2;A#/(45(%&/;%X;$2;A#/(;2(27#(#;5=I(45(=;2#(&$X4=X#F#$2(41(

/2;6#74=%#5/U(?9T V4W( &/( &$145F;2&4$( ;X;&=;0=#( 145( %#>&/&4$( F;6&$A( "54>#//( >;"2C5#%( ;$%(

>4FFC$&>;2#%U((

A)04)5-,3*/0)6107,*6/8)*)+,-./0)12,.1-,3*/

??T 37;2(&/(I4C5(C$%#5/2;$%&$A(41(;(0#$#1&2/(5#;=&/;2&4$("54>#//U(?,T 37;2(&/(I4C5(#'"#>2;2&4$/(5#A;5%&$A(&2/(4C2>4F#/U(?:T 37;2(%4(I4C(27&$6(;5#(27#(F;&$(>7;==#$A#/(145(;%4"2&$A(;(0#$#1&2/(5#;=&/;2&4$(

;""54;>7U(?@T 374(%4(I4C(27&$6($##%/(24(0#(&$X4=X#%(&$(/C>7(;$(;""54;>7U(?BT V4W(%4(I4C(27&$6(;(<[(;""54;>7(W&==(7#="(&F"54X#(27#(>C55#$2("54>#//U(

/

Page 298: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!"#'(-(!==(*+(()(G54H#>2(/>4"&$A(;$%(1#;/&0&=&2I(JC#/2&4$$;&5#(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8B(

A03D)4-/=,2).-3*).//

?DT +25;2#AI( ;$%( 0&%%&$A( "54>#//( \#TAT( 0C/&$#//( >;/#]( ^;2#W;I( 5#X&#W/]( .4V(;""54X;=/](1&$;$>&;=(>=4/#](#2>T_(

?YT +#5X&>#( %#/&A$( "54>#//( \#TAT( %#X#=4"F#$2( 41( >;5#(F4%#=/]( %#/&A$( #X;=C;2&4$(4"2&4$/](#2>T_(

?8T <C&=%&$A( %#/&A$( "54>#//( \#TAT( 5#JC&5#F#$2/( >;"2C5#]( %#/&A$( "54>#//]( %#/&A$(;""54X;=/](#2>T_(

?ZT *4$/25C>2&4$( "54>#//( \#TAT( 0#A&$$&$A( 41( >4$/25C>2&4$]( >4F"=#2&4$]( A;2#W;I(5#X&#W/](#2>T_(

,9T G4/2)4>>C";$>I(#X;=C;2&4$((

A03D)4-E./4@00)*-/7);)235=)*-/1*7/7)2,;)0,*6/5034)../5)04)5-,3*/

,?T G54>#//(3#;6$#//#/(\$#A;2&X#(;/"#>2/](%&11&>C=2&#/_(,,T G54>#//(+25#$A27/(\"4/&2&X#(;/"#>2/_((,:T 37;2($##%/(24(>7;$A#(&$(27#("54>#//U(

Page 299: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(RRR(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8D(

F55)*7,?/!!!/:/()G)12/5034)../-)=521-)./

/

!*7)?/

!!!"#( <#$#1&2( #=&>&2;2&4$( \3456/74"( R$"C2_( -( C/#%( &$( /25;2#AI(;=&A$F#$2(;$%(#=&>&2;2&4$(

!!!"%(K=&>&2#%(0#$#1&2/( =&/2( ( \EC2"C2(M;25&'_(-(A#$#5;2#%( &$(#=&>&2;2&4$(;$%(C/#%(&$(;==("7;/#/(

!!!"&(<#$#1&2/(/#AF#$2;2&4$(F;25&'(-(A#$#5;2#%(&$(#=&>&2;2&4$(;$%(C/#%(&$(;==("7;/#/((

!!!"'(<#$#1&2/("541&=#(\&$%&X&%C;=_(-(A#$#5;2#%(&$(#=&>&2;2&4$("7;/#(;$%(C/#%(&$(;==("7;/#/(

!!!"H(<#$#1&2/(W#&A72&$A(;$%(5;$6&$A(F;25&'(()(145(4"2&4$##5&$A((

!!!"I( E"2&4$( /#=#>2&4$( 0;/#%( 4$( 0#$#1&2/( #=&>&2#%( ( )( 145( 4"2&4$##5&$A

Page 300: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"#/J/<#$#1&2(K=&>&2;2&4$(\3456/74"(R$"C2_(-(P/#%(&$(+25;2#AI(!=&A$F#$2(`(K=&>&2;2&4$(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,8Y(

(

Wor

ksho

p da

te:

Inpu

t by:

Ben

efits

D

escr

iptio

n S

take

hold

er

Mea

sure

E

nabl

er

Act

or

Ben

efic

iary

N

ame

the

bene

fit

Des

crib

e th

e be

nefit

W

ho n

eeds

to

act t

o de

liver

the

bene

fit

Who

will

be

the

mai

n re

cipi

ent

Iden

tify

pote

ntia

l m

easu

re

Pro

pose

d ch

ange

nee

ded

Page 301: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"%/J/K=&>&2#%(<#$#1&2/(N&/2((\EC2"C2(M;25&'_(-(^#$#5;2#%(&$(K=&>&2;2&4$(;$%(C/#%(&$(;==("7;/#/(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** ,88(

Ber

ela

Pha

se:

Pro

ject

STA

GE

:

A.0

0St

rate

gic

Ben

efit

Gro

up N

ame:

A

.01

Stra

tegi

c B

enef

itE

xpec

ted

outc

ome,

sub

ben

efit

or e

nd b

enef

itFu

rther

det

ail o

n be

nefit

, i.e

des

crip

tion,

def

initi

on a

gree

d by

sta

keho

lder

sA

.02

A.0

3A

.04

A.0

5A

.06

B.0

0B

.01

Stra

tegi

c B

enef

itE

xpec

ted

outc

ome,

sub

ben

efit

or e

nd b

enef

itFu

rther

det

ail o

n be

nefit

, i.e

des

crip

tion,

def

initi

on a

gree

d by

sta

keho

lder

sB

.02

B.0

3B

.04

B.0

5B

.06

B.0

7C

.00

C.0

1S

trate

gic

Ben

efit

Exp

ecte

d ou

tcom

e, s

ub b

enef

it or

end

ben

efit

Furth

er d

etai

l on

bene

fit ,

i.e d

escr

iptio

n, d

efin

ition

agr

eed

by s

take

hold

ers

C.0

2C

.03

C.0

4C

.06

C.0

7

Lege

nd:

R

ecei

ved

Con

firm

ed

P

ropo

sed

Benefit Ref.

Ben

efits

Cla

ssifi

catio

nO

utco

me

or fu

rthe

r ben

efit

(Inte

rmed

iate

ben

efits

rela

ted

to o

ne a

noth

er)

Elic

ited

Ben

efits

Lis

t

Status

Des

crip

tions

Stra

tegi

c B

enef

it G

roup

Nam

e:

Proj

ect O

wne

r:

Inpu

t By:

Proj

ect:

Rel

ease

Dat

e:

Stra

tegi

c B

enef

it G

roup

Nam

e:

Page 302: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"#$%$)#$#*&+,(-#./#$+0+&1$(20+3&'(4(5#$#30+#%(&$(67&8&+0+&1$(0$%(9,#%(&$(077(":0,#,(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'****;<=(

Project STAGE: Preparing the Strategic Outline Case

Pro

duct

Ser

vice

NA

Sho

rt Te

rm

Med

ium

Ter

m

Long

Ter

m

Tim

e

Cos

t

Qua

lity

Pro

duct

ivity

Ext

erna

l

Stru

ctur

al

Inte

rnal

NA

Pat

ient

s

Visi

tors

/fam

ilies

Sta

ff/pe

rson

nel

Sup

plie

rs/p

rovi

ders

Inve

stor

s, b

usin

ess

and

man

agin

g pa

rtner

s

All

othe

r

NA

Pat

ient

s

Visi

tors

/fam

ilies

Sta

ff/pe

rson

nel

Sup

plie

rs/p

rovi

ders

Inve

stor

s, b

usin

ess

and

man

agin

g pa

rtner

s

All

othe

r/Com

unity

NA

Pat

ient

Que

st.

Com

mun

ity Q

uest

.

Sta

ff Q

uest

.

Inte

rvie

w

Dat

a C

olle

ct. &

Ana

lysi

s

Obs

erva

tion

NA

A.00 Improved Users Experience A.01 Product Improved patient service X X X X X X X X X X X X XA.02 Improved user (excluding patient) service X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XA.03 Better Access to facilities X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XA.04 Greater privacy X X X X X X X X X X X X XA.05 Racionalization and development X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XA.07 Service Improved health outcomes X X X X X X X X XA.09 Less time waiting X X X X X X X X X XA.10 Care closer to home X X X X X X X X X X XA.11 Increased patient choice X X X X X X X X X X X X XB.00 Time (Faster Delivery), Cost (Lower), Quality (Improved Development) B.01 Product & Service Faster Procurement (from concept to construction) X X X X X X X X XB.02 Faster delivery (from construction to operation) X X X X X X X X XB.03 Removal of backlog maintenance X X X X X X X X X X X X XB.04 Reduce service interruption X X X X X X X X XB.05 Predictability of time cost delivery X X X X X X X X X X XB.06 Optimise actual time cost delivery X X X X X X X X X X XB.07 Flexibility and future proofing X X X X X X X X X XB.08 Cost savings due to co-location X X X X X X X X X XB.09 Lower total running costs X X X X X X X X XC.00 Contribution to Regeneration C.01 Product Investment into deprived areas X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XC.02 Product & service Higher local employment X X X X X X X X X X XC.03 Improved community facilities X X X X X X X X X X X X XC.04 Improved economic activity X X X X X X X X X X X X X X XC.05 Sustainable environment (economic) X X X X X X XC.06 Sustainable environment (social) X X X X X X XC.07 Service Better links with other services – “cause and effect” X X X X X X X X X X X X XD.00 Improved Staff Satisfaction D.01 Product Better working environment X X X X X XD.02 Incentives X X X X XD.03 Services Reduced absences X X X X XD.04 Increased career prospects X X X X XD.05 Increased training opportunities X X X X XD.06 Higher level of Staff Retention & Increased Corporate Learning and Memeory X X X X X XE.00 Better Partnership/ Continuous Improvement E.01 People working together on many schemes (Greater understaning, reduced cost and time) (Better Relationships, Less conflict management) X X X X XE.02 Increased quality between schemes X X X XE.03 Value for Money Improvement from Scheme to Scheme X X X XE.04 Access to finance X X X X

RealisationTime Periods Surveying MethodPlanning/Construction phase Operations/FM phase

StakeholdersDimension

Ben

efit

Ref

.

Strategic Benefits Sub benefit(Intermediate benefits related to one another) Approach

Segmentation Criteria

Interface Context

Page 303: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"#$%$)#$#*&+,(-./*&0#(12$%&3&%4506(7(8#$#.5+#%(&$(90&:&+5+&/$(";5,#(5$%(4,#%(&$(500(";5,#,((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** <=>(

Strategic Objective Benefit Id A1

Programme Owner Details

Tangible Intangible

Definite Expected Anticipated Intermediate Final

Benefit Id Contribute to Result of OwnerB3 vD3 v

Process

Culture

People

Policy

Measurement Description

Start Date

Threshold / Target (Period) Achieved (Period) Achieved (Period) Achieved

Cost Risks/Issues to realisation

Projects Related

KPIs Affected

Date !"#$%&''

Business Change Required

Dependencies

Benefit Value Type

PCT Data

Stakeholder(s)

Supporting comments or description of benefit assessment

Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire

MethodImproved Rate of DNA

Less Waiting Times

Reduced number of Complaints/ Increased Compliments Data Analysis

Data Analysis

Benefit Measurement

SourcePCT Data

Benefit Action LogBook

Improved Patient Experience

More appropriate access to service, Improved customer service topatients, better physical environment, seamless transfer between different services and organisations

Removal of Backlog Maintenance

Reduced Abscences

MAST LIFT - Wave 1A

Detailed Description of Benefit

()#"%*'

!"#$%&

Benefit Title

Criteria

InvestorsClnical Teams

Service Planners

Improved Patient Services

Tracking Method

End Date

BeneficiariesPatients

Service Users

D Improved Staff SatisfactionImpact on Other Strategic Objective

Page 304: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"#$%$)#$#*&+,(-#&./+&$.(0$%(10$2&$.(30+4&'((5(*64(7"+&6$##4&$.(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'****89:(

Benefits Weighting Project Options: A B C D !/!100% Global score: 0 0 0 0 0

A. Improved Users Experience 11 20% Score/calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0Score: Calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0

A.01 Improved patient service 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.02 Improved user (excluding patient) service 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >> Please seeA.03 Better Access to facilities 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >> additional segmentationA.04 Greater privacy 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >> details on TBR.2.02A.05 More services in 1 place (Co-location) 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.06 Greater Access 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.07 Improved health outcomes 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.08 New Services 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.09 Less time waiting 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.10 Care closer to home 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>A.11 Increased patient choice 1.8% add 1-5 valuation >>

B. Time (Faster Delivery), Cost (Lower), Quality (Improved Development) 9 20% Score/calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0Score: Calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0

B.01 Faster Procurement (from concept to construction) 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>B.02 Faster delivery (from construction to operation) 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >> Please seeB.03 Removal of backlog maintenance 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >> additional segmentationB.04 Reduce service interruption 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >> details on TBR.2.02B.05 Predictability of time cost delivery 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>B.06 Optimise actual time cost delivery 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>B.07 Flexibility and future proofing 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>B.08 Cost savings due to co-location 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>B.09 Lower total running costs 2.2% add 1-5 valuation >>

C. Contribution to Regeneration 7 20% Score/calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0Score: Calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0

C.01 Investment into deprived areas 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >>C.02 Higher local employment 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >> Please seeC.03 Improved community facilities 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >> additional segmentationC.04 Improved economic activity 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >> details on TBR.2.02C.05 Sustainable environment (economic) 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >>C.06 Sustainable environment (social) 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >>C.07 Better links with other services – “cause and effect” 2.9% add 1-5 valuation >>

D. Improved Staff Satisfaction 6 20% Score/calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0Better Partnership/ Continuous Improvement Score: Calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0

D.01 Better working environment 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >>D.02 Incentives 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >> Please seeD.03 Reduced absences 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >> additional segmentationD.04 Increased career prospects 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >> details on TBR.2.02D.05 Increased training opportunities 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >>D.06 Higher level of Staff Retention & Increased Corporate Learning and Memeory 3.3% add 1-5 valuation >>

E. Better Partnership/ Continuous Improvement 4 20% Score/calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0Score: Calculus >> 0 0 0 0 0 Improved Users Experience 20%

E.01 People working together on many schemes (Greater understaning, reduced cost and time) (Better Relationships, Less conflict management)5.0% add 1-5 valuation >> Please see Time (Faster Delivery), Cost (Lower), Quality (Improved Development) 20%E.02 Increased quality between schemes 5.0% add 1-5 valuation >> additional segmentation Contribution to Regeneration 20%E.03 Value for Money Improvement from Scheme to Scheme 5.0% add 1-5 valuation >> details on TBR.2.02 Improved Staff Satisfaction 20%E.04 Access to finance 5.0% add 1-5 valuation >> Better Partnership/ Continuous Improvement 20%

Strategic benefits (number): 5 Legend: Strategic benefits (see column "C")Sub-benefits (Number): 37 Sub-benefits (see column "D")

Strategic benefits and Sub-benefits (number): 42

Graphic Representation

Summary of Data

Strategic Benefits Relative Importance

Strategic Benefits & Sub-Benefits Comments

!"#$!"#%!"#&!"#'!"#(!"#

)*+,-./0#12/,2#34+/,5/67/#

85*/#9:;2</,#=/>5./,?@A#B-2<#9C-D/,@A#EF;>5<?#

B-6<,5GFH-6#<-#I/J/6/,;H-6#

)*+,-./0#K<;L#K;H2M;7H-6#

N/O/,#P;,<6/,2Q5+R#B-6H6F-F2#)*+,-./*/6<#

Page 305: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(!!!"#(()(*"+&,$(-#.#/+&,$(01+2&'(31-#%(,$(3#$#4&+-(#.&/&+#%(()(4,2(*"+&,$##2&$5(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 676(

Opt

ion

>>>

12

34

5M

in1

23

45

Min

12

34

5M

in1

23

45

Min

A.

Stra

tegi

c Fi

t13

%0.

50.

30.

30.

50.

50.

10.

50.

40.

40.

50.

50.

20.

50.

40.

40.

60.

50.

20.

60.

30.

10.

40.

30.

13.

72.

72.

74.

04.

01.

03.

62.

83.

03.

83.

61.

63.

83.

43.

24.

64.

01.

65.

02.

01.

03.

02.

01.

0A

.01

Sta

keho

lder

alig

nmen

t3

22

44

14

33

33

14

33

54

15

21

32

1A

.02

Con

text

53

35

51

43

34

42

44

44

41

52

13

21

A.0

3R

esea

rch

alig

nmen

t3

23

43

14

33

44

35

21

32

1A

.04

Syn

ergy

33

33

32

43

35

42

52

13

21

A.0

5Im

age

& re

puta

tion

33

33

31

43

35

52

34

35

41

52

13

21

B.

Clin

ical

Out

com

es13

%0.

50.

30.

30.

50.

30.

10.

40.

30.

30.

50.

50.

20.

50.

40.

30.

60.

60.

20.

60.

30.

10.

40.

30.

14.

02.

72.

04.

02.

71.

03.

32.

52.

53.

84.

01.

54.

33.

02.

84.

84.

51.

85.

02.

01.

03.

02.

01.

0B

.01

Co-

loca

tion

42

24

31

32

24

52

43

34

42

52

13

21

B.0

2R

educ

e un

nece

ssar

y pa

tient

atte

ndan

ces

33

33

31

43

35

41

52

13

21

B.0

3Im

prov

ed q

ualit

y of

car

e4

22

43

13

22

44

14

32

55

25

21

32

1B

.04

Impr

oved

car

e ou

tcom

es4

42

42

14

33

44

25

33

55

25

21

32

1

C.

App

ropr

iate

Fac

ilitie

s (a

nd F

acili

ties

Man

agem

ent)

13%

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.5

0.4

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.6

0.5

0.2

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.6

0.3

0.2

0.6

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.1

3.2

2.5

2.2

4.0

2.8

1.0

3.3

2.6

2.3

4.4

4.1

1.9

4.0

3.4

2.6

4.9

2.8

1.3

5.0

2.0

1.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

C.0

1Fi

t-for

-pur

pose

bui

ldin

g &

infra

stru

ctur

e4

33

43

14

23

54

15

41

51

15

21

32

1C

.02

Flex

ibili

ty a

nd fu

ture

dev

elop

men

t of f

acili

ties

52

25

21

42

15

53

31

15

31

52

13

21

C.0

3P

hysi

cal d

istri

butio

n of

ser

vice

loca

tions

(lay

out)

33

14

11

32

25

52

43

35

41

52

13

21

C.0

4Im

prov

ed s

uppo

rt se

rvic

es4

44

53

15

21

32

1C

.05

Incr

ease

d pa

tient

saf

ety

43

24

42

44

45

32

52

13

21

C.0

6G

reat

er p

rivac

y (b

y be

tter d

esig

n)3

33

44

13

33

33

34

43

43

15

21

32

1C

.07

Bac

klog

mai

nten

ance

22

24

42

21

43

14

43

52

25

21

32

1C

.08

Bet

ter w

orki

ng e

nviro

nmen

t2

22

33

13

44

55

14

32

53

15

21

32

1

D.

Acc

ess

to S

ervi

ces

13%

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.4

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.6

0.5

0.2

0.6

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.1

3.0

3.0

3.0

2.5

2.5

1.0

3.3

3.3

3.7

3.7

4.0

1.3

4.3

4.3

3.7

5.0

4.3

1.3

5.0

2.0

1.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

D.0

1D

eman

d/ca

paci

ty fi

t3

45

55

15

55

55

25

21

32

1D

.02

Impr

oved

phy

sica

l acc

ess

33

33

31

32

23

42

44

35

41

52

13

21

D.0

3A

vaila

bilit

y of

ser

vice

s3

33

22

14

44

33

14

43

54

15

21

32

1

E.Te

achi

ng, T

rain

ing

& R

esea

rch

13%

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.6

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.1

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

3.3

3.0

3.0

3.7

3.7

1.7

3.0

2.3

2.3

4.0

4.0

1.3

5.0

2.0

1.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

5.1

Impr

oved

rese

arch

cap

abili

ty0

00

00

03

33

44

12

22

55

25

21

32

15.

2Im

prov

ed te

achi

ng3

33

33

23

33

33

15

21

32

15.

3K

now

ledg

e tra

nsfe

r4

33

44

24

22

44

15

21

32

1

6U

se o

f Res

ourc

es13

%0.

40.

40.

40.

40.

40.

10.

40.

30.

30.

50.

40.

10.

40.

50.

30.

60.

30.

20.

60.

30.

10.

40.

30.

13.

03.

03.

03.

53.

51.

03.

02.

32.

33.

73.

01.

03.

33.

72.

35.

02.

71.

35.

02.

01.

03.

02.

01.

06.

1U

se o

f tec

hnol

ogy

32

24

21

44

15

11

52

13

21

6.2

Rec

ruitm

ent &

Ret

entio

n3

33

44

13

22

33

13

32

53

15

21

32

16.

3Im

prov

ed e

ffici

ency

33

33

31

33

34

41

34

45

42

52

13

21

7O

pera

tiona

l Man

agem

ent

13%

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.2

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.6

0.3

0.1

0.4

0.3

0.1

3.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

3.0

1.0

3.0

2.7

3.0

4.3

4.7

1.7

3.0

3.0

2.3

4.3

4.0

1.7

5.0

2.0

1.0

3.0

2.0

1.0

7.1

Impr

oved

ser

vice

coo

rdin

atio

n3

33

33

13

33

55

12

21

54

15

21

32

17.

2C

omm

unic

atio

n &

team

wor

k3

23

55

13

32

44

25

21

32

17.

3Im

pact

of c

onst

ruct

ion

33

33

43

44

44

42

52

13

21

8D

evel

opm

ent &

Impl

emen

tatio

n13

%0.

40.

40.

40.

40.

40.

10.

40.

40.

40.

50.

50.

40.

30.

30.

30.

50.

50.

10.

40.

40.

40.

40.

40.

43.

03.

03.

03.

03.

01.

03.

03.

03.

04.

04.

03.

02.

02.

02.

04.

04.

01.

03.

03.

03.

03.

03.

03.

08.

1In

vest

men

t / c

hang

e m

anag

emen

t effo

rt3

33

33

13

33

44

32

22

44

13

33

33

3

No

Wei

ghtin

g-

6049

4566

5517

9579

8011

511

347

111

9882

140

109

4314

861

3290

6132

Wei

ghtin

g10

0%2.

92.

52.

43.

02.

70.

93.

22.

82.

83.

93.

91.

73.

53.

12.

74.

63.

81.

44.

82.

11.

33.

02.

11.

3

Ben

efits

\ St

akeh

olde

rs

Ave

rage

>>>

Ave

rage

>>>

Stak

ehol

der N

ame

Ave

rage

>>>

Ave

rage

>>>

Stak

ehol

der N

ame

Stak

ehol

der N

ame

Stak

ehol

der N

ame

Ave

rage

>>>

Ave

rage

>>>

Ave

rage

>>>

Ave

rage

>>>

Page 306: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(89)(:#;#1.(<2,/#--(=#.&>#213.#-(?.,@/A12+((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67B(

$%%&'()*+!,+-+.&/&01+%234&55+(&1)6&2071&5+81394:02;

Page 307: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(9C(:#;#1.(<2,/#--(8$4,201+&,$(D#/A$,.,5E(<.1+4,20(((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67F(

$%%&'()*+,+-+.&/&01+%234&55+!'832<0;)3'+=&4:'313>?+

%10;832<+

DA#(:#;#1.(&$4,201+&,$(+#/A$,.,5E(".1+4,20(%#".,E-(+A2##(01&$-(+,,.-G(

• !(H#3-&+#(

• !(I$,@.#%5#(-A12&$5(%1+131-#(

• 80".#0#$+1+&,$(+,,.J&+(

86%*9%:'#(%*

(!$( ,"#$( "K3.&/( 1//#--( -,K2/#( +A2,K5A( 1( @#3-&+#( +,,.( "2,>&%&$5( &$4,201+&,$(

13,K+(+A#(:#;#1.("2,/#--(1$%(2#.1+#%(+,"&/-(

;"+9/%0<%*-6.&%*7.(.:.'%*

DA&-(J$,@.#%5#(%1+131-#(+,,.( &-(%#-&5$#%(+,("2,>&%#(-+1J#A,.%#2-(@&+A(5#$#21.(

&$4,201+&,$( 13,K+( 3#$#4&+-( 01$15#0#$+( 2#.1+#%( +,"&/-( 1$%( "2,L#/+( %#%&/1+#%(

%&2#/+,2&#-(4,2(1K+A,2&-#%(-+1J#A,.%#2-(

=>2/%>%"(.(#+"*(++/?#(*

DA#( @#3( 31-#%( 80".#0#$+1+&,$( +,,.J&+( #$13.#-( :#;#1.( ,"#21+&,$1.&-1+&,$M(

/,$+2&3K+&$5( +,( >&2+K1.( 1$%( /,..13,21+&>#( @,2J&$5( #$>&2,$0#$+( 10,$5-+(

1K+A,2&-#%(-+1J#A,.%#2-N(I#E(4K$/+&,$1.&+&#-(&$/.K%#G(

! OA121/+#2&-#( 3#$#4&+-( +A2,K5A( 3#$#4&+( "2,4&.#-M( /,03&$&$5( 1( %#4&$&+&,$M( /,-+M(>1.K#M(,@$#2-A&"M(#+/N(

! P".,1%(1$%(01$15#("2,L#/+(".1$-(Q1/+&>&+&#-(1$%(2#-,K2/#-R(1$%(13&.&+E(+,(.&$J(+A#-#(@&+A(3#$#4&+-N(

! !//,K$+M(0,$&+,2(1$%(2#",2+(,$(3#$#4&+(2#1.&-1+&,$("#24,201$/#N(

! <2,>&%#(1(>&-K1.S521"A&/1.(2#"2#-#$+1+&,$(,4(3#$#4&+(-+1+K-(&$(2#.1+&,$(+,(+A#("2,L#/+(".1$(1%A#2#$/#N(

Page 308: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(9C(:#;#1.(<2,/#--(8$4,201+&,$(D#/A$,.,5E(<.1+4,20(((

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67T(

! =#>#.,"#%( +21&$&$5( 01+#2&1.-( 1$%( /K-+,0&-#%( +#0".1+#-( #$13.&$5( :#;#1.("2,/#--(-#10.#--(&0".#0#$+1+&,$N(

! !(5#$#2&/(3#$#4&+-(.&3212E(+,(3#(K-#%(&$(%&44#2#$+("2,L#/+-N(

! P-#2-(1/+&>&+E(+21/J&$5(1$%(1""2,>1.(2,K+#-N(

(

(

((

@)>A2&+B#C+!=+=331D);+E23>20<<&+0'(+E23F&4;+<0'0>&<&';+6)&9+0'(+7&'&8);5+(05:7302(

Page 309: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(98(C(<K3.&/1+&,$-(1$%(!/+&>&+E(2#.1+#%(+,(+A#(DA#-&-(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67U(

$%%&'()*+,!-+EA71)40;)3'5+0'(+04;)6);?+7?+;:&+0A;:32+

2&10;&(+;3+;:)5+;:&5)5+

EA71)40;)3'5++

V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( X&01M( YNM( Z1+#-M( INM( 1$%( I15&,5.,KM([N( Q6\]]R( ^:#;#1.G( !( 3#$#4&+-(

2#1.&-1+&,$( "2,/#--M( ?2,0( ".1$$&$5( +,( %#.&>#2EG( #44#/+&>#( 3#$#4&+-( 2#1.&-1+&,$_( 1(

O,$-K.+1+&>#( 5K&%#M( DA#( P$&>#2-&+E( ,4( V1.4,2%M( 8V:`( 7ab)])7\abF6)]U)\M(

[1$/A#-+#2M(PI(

V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(Z1+#-M(INM(X&01M( YNM(1$%(I15&,5.,KM([N(Q6\]\R(c:#$#4&+-(2#1.&-1+&,$G(

<.1$$&$5(1$%(#>1.K1+&$5(A#1.+A/12#(&$421-+2K/+K2#-(1$%(-#2>&/#-d(&$(I15&,5.,KM([N(

1$%( DW,2+W,",K.,-M( <N( #%-M( 80"2,>&$5( A#1.+A/12#( +A2,K5A( :K&.+( e$>&2,$0#$+(

8$421-+2K/+K2#N(H&.#E):.1/J@#..M(*'4,2%M(PIM(""(]UU)]7T(

D&..01$$M(<M(DW,2+W,",K.,-M(<M( V1",K$+W&-M( V(1$%(?,20,-,M(O( Q6\]\RM( fg#-+1,(%#(

3#$#4&/&,-( $1( #+1"1( %#( "2,L#/+,( #0( #0"2##$%&0#$+,-( A,-"&+1.12#-( %,( 2#&$,(

K$&%,(h[1$15&$5(3#$#4&+-(&$(+A#(%#-&5$(,4(A#1.+A/12#(41/&.&+&#-(&$(+A#(PIif(M(g#-+j,(

k(D#/$,.,5&1(%#(<2,L#+,-M(T(Q]R(M(""N(]\7)]B6(

V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(Z1+#-M(IN(1$%(I15&,5.,KM([NM(!,K1%M(gNM(Q6\\7R(c;#1.&-&$5(:#$#4&+-(

4,2( <2&012E( l#1.+A/12#( 8$421-+2K/+K2#-dM( ?1/&.&+&#-M( 9,.N6a( `,NBSFM( ""NaF)abM(

[12/AM(

A++"GSS@@@N#0#21.%&$-&5A+N/,0SL,K2$1.-NA+0m12+&/.#&%n]aaFb6b1$%-A,@nA+0

.(

D&..01$M(<NM(V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(DW,2+W,",K.,-M(<NM(?,20,-,M(ONDN((Q6\]6R(c!(O1-#(V+K%E(

*$( :#$#4&+-( ;#1.&W1+&,$( !$%( 8+-( O,$+2&3K+&,$-( ?,2( X&$J&$5( <2,L#/+( *K+"K+-( D,(

*K+/,0#-d( <2,/##%&$5-( ,4( ]7+A( !$$K1.( /,$4#2#$/#( ,4( 8$+#2$1+&,$1.( g2,K"( ,4(

X#1$(O,$-+2K/+&,$M(YK.E(]a()(66M(6\]6M(V1$(=&#5,M(O1.&4,2$&1M(PV!(

Page 310: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(98(C(<K3.&/1+&,$-(1$%(!/+&>&+E(2#.1+#%(+,(+A#(DA#-&-(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67a(

;,,J#M( YN( !M( l103.#++M( IN( DM( V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( X&01( YN( :NM( Z1+#-M( INM( I15&,5.,KM( [N(

Q6\]\RM( c=#>#.,"&$5( 1$%( &0".#0#$+&$5( -+21+#5E( 4,2( 3#$#4&+-( 2#1.&-1+&,$d( C(

l1O8;8O(]\(V#"+#03#2((

;,,J#M(YN(!M(V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(I,-J#.1M(XNM(O,%&$A,+,M(;NM(I15&,5.,KM([N(Q6\]\R(cX#1$(

I$,@.#%5#( [1$15#0#$+G( +A#( "2,3.#0( ,4( >1.K#dM( <2,/##%&$5-( ,4( ]b+A( !$$K1.(

/,$4#2#$/#( ,4( 8$+#2$1+&,$1.( g2,K"( ,4( X#1$( O,$-+2K/+&,$M( D#/A$&,$M( 8-21#.(

&$-+&+K+#( ,4( D#/A$,.,5EM(l1&41M( 8-21#.M( YK.E( ]F)]UM( ""( ]6)6]M( 8V:`(7ab)7UT)TTT)

F7T)B(

D&..01$$M( <N!NM( V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( DW,2+W,",K.,-M( <NM( ?,20,-,M( ONDN( Q6\\7R( c*(

"2,/#--,(%#("2,L#+,(#0(#0"2##$%&0#$+,-(5#2#$/&1%,-(",2(3#$#4o/&,-pM(V&0"q-&,(

:21-&.#&2,( %#( rK1.&%1%#( %,( <2,L#+,( $,( !03&#$+#( O,$-+2Ko%,( QV:r<( 6\\7RM(

`,>#03#2(]b)6\M(6\\7(

Z1+#-M(INM(V1",K$+W&-M(VN(X,KM(eNONHN(1$%(I15&,5.,KM([N(Q6\\7R(c:#;#1.G(D,,.-(1$%(

[#+A,%-( 4,2( 80".#0#$+&$5( :#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( 1$%( [1$15#0#$+dM( <2,/N( T+A(

`,2%&/( O,$4#2#$/#( ,$( O,$-+2K/+&,$( e/,$,0&/-( 1$%( *251$&-1+&,$M( ;#EJL1>oJM(

8/#.1$%M(]\)]6(YK$#(6\\7M(]M(66B(C((

Z1+#-M(INM(:122#&2,(C(X&01M( YNM(V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(DW,2+W,",K.,-M(<N(1$%(I15&,5.,KM([N(

Q6\\7R( c:#;#1.( :#$#4&+-( 2#1.&-1+&,$( 0,%#.( &$+#521+#%( 1""2,1/AG( DA#( :K&.+(

#$>&2,$0#$+( .&4#/E/.#( 1$%( ,251$&-1+&,$1.( >&#@-dM( 6$%( l1O8;8O( VE0",-&K0M(

:2&5A+,$N(

V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( l122&-M( IN( 1$%( I15&,5.,KM( [N( Q6\\bRM( cDA#( $##%( 4,2( :#$#4&+-(

;#1.&-1+&,$( C( O2#1+&$5( 1( 3#$#4&+-( %2&>#$( /K.+K2#( &$(PI_-(l#1.+A/12#( V#/+,2dM( ]-+(

l1O8;8O(VE0",-&K0(

c;#%#4&$&$5(A#1.+A/12#(&$421-+2K/+K2#N(8$+#521+&$5(-#2>&/#-M(+#/A$,.,5&#-(1$%(+A#(

3K&.+(#$>&2,$0#$+M(B)F(!"2&.(6\\bM(X,$%,$M(PI((

V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( l122&-M( IN( 1$%( I15&,5.,KM( [N( Q6\\bR( cDA#( %#>#.,"0#$+( ,4( 1(

:#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$([1$15#0#$+( <2,/#--( +,( %2&>#( -K//#--4K.( "2,52100#-( 1$%(

"2,L#/+-dM( &$( <1$+,K>1J&-M( YN<N( Q#%&+,2R( Q6\\bR( s<2,/##%&$5-( ,4( +A#( Y,&$+( ?,K2+A(

Page 311: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(98(C(<K3.&/1+&,$-(1$%(!/+&>&+E(2#.1+#%(+,(+A#(DA#-&-(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 67b(

V/&#$+&4&/(O,$4#2#$/#(,$(<2,L#/+([1$15#0#$+(Q<[)\FR(k(+A#(?&2-+(8<[!(S[#%`#+(

O,$4#2#$/#( )( <2,L#/+( [1$15#0#$+( !%>1$/#-M( D21&$&$5( k( O#2+&4&/1+&,$( &$( +A#(

[#%&+#221$#1$tM([1EM(67)B]M(OA&,-M(g2##/#M(8V:`(7ab(7U\)6TF)Uaa)6((

l122&-M( IN( !M( V1",K$+W&-M( VNM( 1$%( I15&,5.,KM( [N( Q6\\bR( cDA#( 0#+A,%,.,5&/1.(

%#>#.,"0#$+(,4(1(:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$([1$15#0#$+(<2,/#--(Q:;[<R(&$(+A#(/1-#(

,4([1$/A#-+#2M( V1.4,2%( 1$%( D2144,2%( Q[1VDR( X,/1.( 80"2,>#0#$+( ?&$1$/#( D2K-+(

QX8?DRdM(b+A(:KlK(8$+#2$1+&,$1.(<,-+521%K1+#(;#-#12/A(O,$4#2#$/#M(YK$#(6U()6a(

<215K#M(OW#/A(;#"K3.&/((

V1",K$+W&-M(VNM(l122&-M(IN(1$%(I15&,5.,KM([N(Q6\\aR(c:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$(<2,/#--(

4,2(l#1.+A/12#dM(8$+#2$1+&,$1.(VO;8(VE0",-&K0M([12/A(6\\aM(V1.4,2%M(PIN(

E2&5&';0;)3'5+G&?'3;&+0((2&55&5H)'6);&(+1&4;A2&5++

8$>&+#%(.#/+K2#-(,$(3#$#4&+-(2#1.&-1+&,$(1$%(:#;#1.(4,2(+A#(1/1%#0&/("2,52100#((

^O,$-+2K/+&,$(01$15#0#$+_(1+(+A#(V/A,,.(,4(+A#(3K&.+(#$>&2,$0#$+M(+A#(K$&>#2-&+E(

,4(V1.4,2%M(4,2(+A#(1/1%#0&/(E#12-(6\]\(+,(6\]BN(

^:#;#1.( 42,0( ".1$$&$5( +,( %#.&>#2E( 1$( #44#/+&>#( 3#$#4&+-( 2#1.&-1+&,$( "2,/#--( 4,2(

<2,/K2#( 6]u_( <2#-#$+1+&,$( +,( +A#( <6]u( 1%>&-,2-M( rK122E( l,K-#M( X##%-(

=#"12+0#$+(,4(l#1.+AM(]F([12/A(6\]](

c:#;#1.(1$%(+A#(g1+#@1E(;#>&#@("2,/#--d(I#E$,+#("2#-#$+1+&,$(1+(+A#(g1+#@1E(

;#>&#@#2-( 4,2K0M( 66(`,>#03#2( 6\]\M( X,$%,$( 1$%( 67(`,>#03#2( 6\]\M( X##%-M(

&$>&+#%(3E(+A#(=#"12+0#$+(,4(l#1.+AM(l#1%(,4(g1+#@1E(;#>&#@-(

cDA#( %#>#.,"0#$+( ,4( 1( :#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( [1$15#0#$+( <2,/#--( +,( %2&>#(

-K//#--4K.("2,52100#-(1$%("2,L#/+-dM(O,$4#2#$/#(<1"#2(<2#-#$+1+&,$(&$(+A#(Y,&$+(

?,K2+A(V/&#$+&4&/(O,$4#2#$/#(,$(<2,L#/+([1$15#0#$+( Q<[)\FR(k( +A#(?&2-+( 8<[!(

S[#%`#+(O,$4#2#$/#()(<2,L#/+([1$15#0#$+(!%>1$/#-M(D21&$&$5(k(O#2+&4&/1+&,$(&$(

+A#([#%&+#221$#1$tM(OA&,-M(g2##/#(B\+A([1E(6\\b(

c<#24,201$/#( [#1-K2#0#$+( 1$%( [1$15#0#$+( @&+A&$( l#1.+A/12#( <2,L#/+-dM(

O,$4#2#$/#(<1"#2(<2#-#$+1+&,$( &$( Y,&$+( ?,K2+A( V/&#$+&4&/( O,$4#2#$/#(,$(<2,L#/+(

[1$15#0#$+( Q<[)\FR( k( +A#( ?&2-+( 8<[!( S[#%`#+( O,$4#2#$/#( )( <2,L#/+(

Page 312: 0&%,usir.salford.ac.uk/29293/1/2013_Ph.D._Thesis_S... · 2013. 6. 7. · "#$%&'($)*!+,!-./,+'0!1!-)*/$.#+(!-.2+3#)4$(!1!567!86&($(! e&! oana?!c(*(0&'5!9-10&.&*7! ?do! oana=!c(*(0&'5!$-(,k)1s*!,*)!2&(-,-82:!

!""#$%&'(98(C(<K3.&/1+&,$-(1$%(!/+&>&+E(2#.1+#%(+,(+A#(DA#-&-(

!"#$%&'#()*+,*-./,+&0*1*-()/#."+'*-.2+3"(4#'*1*567*86%'#'**** 677(

[1$15#0#$+( !%>1$/#-M( D21&$&$5( k( O#2+&4&/1+&,$( &$( +A#( [#%&+#221$#1$tM( OA&,-M(

g2##/#(67+A(,4([1E(6\\b(

:#;#1.(1$%(X8<(v(X8?D(k(O,00K$&+E(l,-"&+1.-(I$,@.#%5#(D21$-4#2(<2,52100#(

X1K$/AM(l&.+,$(l,+#.M(<12J(X1$#M(X,$%,$(6]-+([1E(6\\b(

:#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( [1$15#0#$+( <2,/#--( C( !$( 8$+2,%K/+&,$M( `,2+A( H#-+(

!03K.1$/#( V#2>&/#M( <2,52100#( 3,12%M( `lV( D2K-+( l#1%wK12+#2-M( X1%E32&%5#(

X1$#M(:,.+,$(6B2%(,4(!"2&.(6\\b(

:#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( 1$%(l#1.+A( 80"1/+(!--#--0#$+(01-+#2( /.1--N( *251$&-#%( 3E(

O,00K$&+E(l#1.+A(<12+$#2-A&"-M(DA#(X,@2E(O,$4#2#$/#(2,,0M(P$&>#2-&+E(l,K-#M(

F+A(,4([12/A(6\\b(

:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$G(g,,%(8%#1M(3K+(A,@m(DA#(`H#gg(M(<2,L#/+(1$%(<2,52100#(

[1$15#2-( ?,2K0N(DA#(H,,%.1$%-(O#$+2#M( V,K+A",2+(;,1%M( OA,2.#EM( B\+A([12/A(

6\\b(

I#E$,+#( <2#-#$+1+&,$( ,$( :#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( 4,2( l#1.+A/12#( 1+( V&501( :;(

<21/+&+&,$#2-( ?,2K0M( +A#( 8$-+&+K+#( ,4( =&2#/+,2-M( ]]U( <1..( [1..M( X,$%,$( C( 6b+A(

`,>#03#2(6\\a(

:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$(<2,/#--(1$%(<[V(1+([1$/A#-+#2(O&+E(O,K$/&.M(l#2,$(l,K-#M(

[1$/A#-+#2M(]]+A(,4(!"2&.(6\\a(

:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$(C(D2&31.(O,$-K.+&$5(l#1.+A(<.1$$#2-([##+&$5M(X,$%,$M(]T+A(,4(

YK$#(6\\a(

:#$#4&+-( ;#1.&-1+&,$( &$( <2&012E( l#1.+A/12#( &$421-+2K/+K2#)( <12+$#2-A&"-( 4,2(

l#1.+A(:,12%(,4(=&2#/+,2-M(X,$%,$)(]7+A(,4(!"2&.(6\\a(

8$+#2$1+&,$1.( ;#-#12/A( H##JM( +A#( X,@2EM( V1.4,2%( rK1E-N( <2#-#$+#%( "1"#2(

:#$#4&+-(;#1.&-1+&,$(<2,/#--( 4,2(l#1.+A/12#( 1+( +A#( VO;8( -E0",-&K0(%1E(6a+A( ,4(

[12/A(6\\a(