Arbitrazh Court - Strat Ind Law Decision 1

8/9/2019 Arbitrazh Court - Strat Ind Law Decision 1

1/16

891168(1)[ .- . !

KoTC:{i$l,-" " M_ !I

E bI A P P A bI t A E L 0 bI t

27994 ocKBa f-4 npOe3 OJOeHHO TOO 2apec Be6-caTa: htp//9aasat

A E EN9A-2929-f

r OCKBa eO N A49SS/9 4-2 eKa6p 29 rOa

Pe3IOTMBH aCTb nOCTaHOBJeHM 6'bBIea 2 HO6p 29 rOaOHbI TeKCT nOCTaHOBeM M3roTOBeH eKa6p 29 rOa

eBTbI ap6MHbI aneJIIUMoHbI CY B COCTaBenpeceaebCTBYOero CYbM apMnoBacYe Y3HeuoBo EE apTbIHoBOnpM BeeHMM npOTOKOa cYe6HOrO 3aCeaHMnOOHMKO CYbM P OaTOBbI

paccoTpeB B OTbITO cYe6HO 3aCeaHM aneJIIUMOHHbIe )aI6bIA JIopec eIOBa e eKcOBa YKOBCKO epbIMKOJIaeBHbI a TaKe 000 P 000 HBecTMUMoHHo-acoBaKOnaH poHBecT 000 npaBOa KOnaHM BepecT cceTeHeeHT 00 0 HMCOH pacTHa peeHMe Ap6MHoro cya r OCKBbI OT 2829 _no eIY !A4-9SS/94-2 pHToe cYbe BOCTOBOno MCKY 000 PE HBecTK 000 a 6poKep 000 paBJIa KOnaHM BepecT cceTeeeHT I6MHO bre AHaTOJIbeBHe oeHKoBY eHa

pbeBMY A MTa6aHK ObIKHY MTpm OCOBMqyEpOJIeHKO pm EBreHbeBMY 000 P 000 HBecUMoHHoaHCOBa KOnaHM poHBecT MHY eY MKOaeBMY eepcKoEeHe aMpOBHe A A eTypreCK HBecTUMoHHbI aHKOCYapCTBeHHo KopnopaUM AreHTCTBO IO cTpaoBaHMO BKIaOBOXMHY KOa epreeBMY MXaJOBY AHpeO feHHabeBY

OXOBO aprapTe AJeKCaHpOBHe 000 0 C eHC AeO OJaeBMY OOBY OMCY PyOOBM onaTKHY AHpeOaCMIbeBY YKOBCKO epe KOJaeBHe 000 f YKOBCKOY AHpeO MKOIaeBMY fop6YHOBO EBreHMM eHHabeBHe 000 pe

epHMKoBY MT AHaTObeBMqy 000 HCO pacT OBKOBYIaMMpy OHCTaTHOBMY eJIOBY TaCJIaBY OpCOBq OnaH no ynpaBeHO HBeCTUM aap maY


2/16

2 A0-6955/09 0430

peHOB; eOBY Ae eKCOBWy pKOBY P\ OHCTaHTHBqy; A eHope; HKoBecT; A ai CCeT eHeKMeHT; A npaB5a5 KMnaHf5 AIeMap; aKTOHOB AeKCaHPY aepbeBq; A HBeCTHHoaHCOBa5 KOpnOpaAJIeMap peI AHaTOIO BaHoBqy; MaHCKOMY er JIaMpoBq; aTOKHY rop APHOJIbOBqy; A


3/16

14

IPHfaHOOB)aPOBHq;HTeT,

CR

A.,

1,

3 fN9Hl3BepeCT 3CCeT eHe)KeH T Y, 000 YHMCOH paCT ro.aJIM

aeJHHbe )6b, KOTObX pcT OTeHMTb peeHMe cy.a M OTKa3aTb y.OeTOpeM e6aCT(a

6CHOaHle Ce 3l OTeTq1Kl YKa3baOT qTO 2 HeJeTC caTelqeCK X3icTeb eCTO; .eiCT1e aKOHa .2 5 He pacpcaHeTC a cpHbe .rOOb, TK c.eJIKM 3aKOeHHbe a

OCHOaHMl 3HMKe y lCT(a . cyJIeH 528 e CY63aHHOCTM HapaJIeH1O 63aTeJbHOrO pe.JO)eH, CO epICbCTO eHOMQHO, a He COCTae yb JM( C yqacTMe MHcaHHMHeCTpa, e MHeCTl(l1 He JOTC MHcaHHbl, aKOH He MeeT6paTHi CMb, M .rpb KyMp.a)l e).y lCT(O l OTeTQMKal Hee)aT pe.apMTeJbHOY COaCOaHMO, TK ya JM( MCT(a Ja.eJa6ee Qe 5% OOcYMX aK(Mi 2; COOTeTCTMl c 5 CT 84 06 aK(lHepHbx 6eCTax Hec6O.eH1e aKHa 2 5 pMHaaeHM 63aTeJbHOrO peO)eH1 He .eJaeT .OpbHeeicTMTeJbHbM HWO)HbM; lCTe( 3Jye6eT COMM paaM

CbCe 2 CT P, OCKOJIbKY Cb Ce.eH1 COCTae cei yb 1 KOleCTe pMHa.e)alx a


4/16


5/16

- 04320

o cObI I

JI00PCa

icaA40_CJbKye,

OCb.ea

B0e0

H

,

5

OKa3BaH B paKax HaCT05eo eIa poe Too,OTBeTqMKOB HOCT rperOJIoTeJIbHbl xapaKTep.

l

A40-69 1N6nH !YKaHHble ,

PM M3JIO)eHHbIX 06CTOTeJIbCTBaX ae OTKOHeHO xoaTacTBo 000PO 06 Mce60BaHMM Y O U 3 TCJI HTepHeH,


6/16


7/16

-10432

e6 la

f

a(

aaea


8/16


9/16


10/16


11/16

9 00

aeO 0e

FBeT)aBeY C

eC 3aaO e

ee O

O

O

OB

11 Af COOTBeTCTB C n CT eepabHOO 3aKOHa OpKe

ocyeCTBe Hoc'aHHhx HBeCT B X03CTBeHhle 06ecTBa,eOme cTpaTeecKoe 3aeHe I 06eCneeHS 060pOHbI caHb 6e30acHocT ocyapcTBa ceJK, YKa3aHHble B CTaTbe 7 HaCT0IeO


12/16


13/16

14_

e . 2008 T, a:

e

Re oB0!aR

06Be KTrK_

OBeOe

B0

OaRRR

Ra

rK-0

H.

H3e

3 A0 mI1 r I YCaHaBJIMBacoo onpe.eIeHHbe MepMM .5 p13HaH15 Y IX-f;Jc.eJIK HM)Hb1 u;eHKa .06pCOBeCHOCM .eCB1 1Cua He Be HaHe.eCBMeJIbHOCb 1X c.eJK paBoBoe 3HaeH1e 1ee J1IIb CBeCB1eCBepIIeHHbX c.eK e60BaH aKHa

p1 ocynMBMe Ha Ce 1Ca B pe3YIbae CBepeHocafBaeX c.eJK aKMM B03BpaI(eH 1 Ha e Cea H1HbHbIX fX

e)aeJe C KPX Hf Cn1JM nBepaeC5 cpaBK AUN2 7 28

B. 3a5BMeJe 06 HC1ebH HapYIeH15 Cy. epBo1HCaH1M Hp poueccyaJIbHO rpaBa B CB531 C HeHa.e)a(1 13Be(eH1eBeMKB nCKbKY no 1X HeH1O, y cy.a He 6bIJ .OKa3aeIbCBJIYeH 1M YBe.Je1 0 eCe 1 BpeeHM cy.e6Hoo 3ace.aHM5,KJH5C5 cy.e6Ho KOJIJe1e

aK, B COBeCB11 CO C 2 A Ma, YacBY(1e B .eJe 1Me YacHMKM ap6MaHoo npou;ecca CMaC5 13Be(eHHb1

HJea(M 06Pa30 eCJIM K HaaJY cy.e6Hoo 3ace.aH, poBe.eH.eJIbH oeccybH .eCB ap6Ma)Hb cy. pacnJaaeCBe.eH1 0 IYeHf1 a.pecao HanpaBeHH eY KoMM cy.e6Hoo aa

1a, YacBYI(Me B .eJe, 1 1Hbe yaCHMKM ap6Ma)H rpoueccaaKe CMaC 13Be(eHHbI1 Ha.JeaI(M 06pa30 ap6Ma)Hb cy.,eCJIM Heco Ha nBoe M3Be(eHMe peca He BMIC5 3a nYeHMeKoMM cy.e6Hoo aa, HanpaBIeHH ap6Ma)HbI cy.O B YCaHBJeHHOp.Ke 0 e opaH CB53M pMHPMPBa ap6MHb cy. Orcy.e6Hoo aKa HapaBIeHHa5 ap6MaHbI cy. no nCJIe.HeY 13BeCHYcy.y ecy HaX.eH opaHM3a;MM eCY MebCBa paaHMHa, He

BpYeHa B CB531 C CYCBMe a.pecaa ro YKa3aHHY a.pecy, 0 qe opaHCB53M npMHOPMBa ap6MaHb cy.

JaCH C 24 A Mu;a, yaCBY(Me B .ee, 0653aHbC006(Mb ap6Ma)HOY cy.y 06 M3eHeHMM CBoeo a.peca BO Bpe5pM3Bo.CBa no .eJIy PM OCYCBMM aKoo C006I(eH KorMM Cy.e6HbIXaB HaaBIC5 o nCJe.HeY M3BeCHOY ap6MaHY cy.y a.pecy MCMaC5 .CaBIeHHM, XO5 6b a.peca no OY a.pecy 60ee HeHax.MC5 MJM He npMBae

aK CIee M3 aepMaOB .eJa, B .eJIe MeC .Ka3aeJbCBaHaeaeo B CBeCBMM C YKa3aHHbM HopaM M3Be(eH Bcex

YaCBYX Jf 0 BpeeHM M eCe cy.e6Hoo pa36MpaeIbCBa a aeCBe.eH opaHa B CB3M 0 HeBpYeHMM .ebHbI BeQ1Ka KonMcy.e6HbIX aKOB B CB53M C CYCBMe a.pecaOB no nCJe.HeY M3BeCHYcy.y ecy MX )MebCBa

y. epB 1HCaH1M OBeQ1K1 YBe.OJI5JMCb no MeO(1C5 B.eIe a.peca B MCe co.ep)a(MC B 3a5BeHM5X 0 po.ae aKM Me60BaH15X B a.pec 6ep6aHKa 06 Onae o 6aHKoBcK apaHMM

pM .OKa3aebCB Oo, BeQMKM YBe.OJ5IM cy. 06M3eHeHMM CBoeo eCHaXO.eHM5 B COBeCBMM co C 24 Ap61aHoo

poeccyaIbH Ko.eKca CCMCKO e.epaU;MM, B aepMaX .ea HeMeeC5

pM aKMX 06C0ebCBaX y cy.a aneJ5U;MOHH 1HCaHU;M1


14/16

4 0-69S /0910320

OTCYTCTBYT OCHOBaH CTaTb, TO OTBeTK He 6bIJI 3BeeHbI 0 BpeMeHFMeCTe cye6Horo a36aTebCTa He)M 06a0M

aK)e noJeaT OTKJOHeH OObI 06 0 He3eeH 0 TeeMeH npoOI)eH cyeHoro 3aceaHU nOCJe 06BJeH cyOM neB;HCTaHQ nepebIBa

CY n 5 CT. 163 AI P Qa, YlaCTByorqe eJIe LncYTcTBoBame B 3e cye6Horo 3aceaHR o 06'bSBeH nepebICTCR HJe)aM 06p30M 3eeHHbIM 0 BeMeH 1 MeCTe cye6Ho3aceaH, X HeRBKa B cye6Hoe 3aceaHl1e nOCJIe OKOHaHR nepepbIBa H{DeTCR neIRTCTBl1eM ero npoO)eHR.

TOM B COOTBeTCTB C HopMaQ0HHbIM nCbMOM A P O9926 NQ 3 npMeHeH CTaTb 63 A P> OCKObKY epepbIB Bcye6HoM 3aceaH 06bRBJeTCS Ha HepoOJKTebHbI CpOK B CJY qaCT 4CTTb 63 P OCe OKOHqaH ep ep bIBa cye6Hoe 3aceaHenpoOJ)aeTCR, cy He 06R3aH B opRKe, npeYCMOeHHOM q CT 2 A P


15/16

5/09-4_32

H O.aTeOM nepBO

ee InppBaeo(pB '

P< 01ppbIB Bc 4

cee .KP


16/16

-

Documents

Arbitrazh Court - Strat Ind Law Decision 1