Z•

s

Ti! PH

KT. GIAM DOC PHO GIAM DOC

beiG

UBND TINH DONG NAI ONG HOA XA HQI CHU NGHiA VIETNAM SO TU. PHAP Dc 16p - Ty' do - Hanh pink ;

SO:dia/STP-PBGDPL Dang Nai, ngay 1"4-thang 5 it 2018 V/v trien lchai thuc hien Thang tu so 03/2018/TT-BTP cUa BO truang BO Tuphap

Kinh - Cac sec ban, nganh cap tinh; - UBND cac huyen, thi xa Long Khanh,

thanh pho Bien Hoa.

Thkrc hien Thong hr s6 03/2018/TT-BTP ngay 10/3/2018 Gila B6 truemg BO Tu phap quy dinh BO tieu chi danh gia hieu qua cong tao ph6 bien, giao duc phap luat;

SO Tu phap d nghi cac so*, ban, nganh cap tinh; UBND cac huy'en, thi xa Long Khanh va thanh pith' Bien Hee ta chirc ft-FL khai, ph e Nen cac nOi dung dm Thong tu cho can bO, c6ng chirc caa ca quan, dcm vi.

NOi dung Thong tu so 03/2018/TT-BTP dugc dinh kern Cong van hay clang tai ten Trang thong tin then -Cr Sec Tu phap tai dia chi http://stp.dongnai.gov.vd, muc Van ban chi dao, dieu hanh./.

Noi nit/in: - Nhtr Iran; - Chü tich UBND tinh (bao cao); - D/c Nguygn Hon Hip: PCT. UBND tinh — Chit

HOi clOng PBGDPL tinh (bao cao); - Van phong UBND tinh; - Phong Tir phap cac huyen, thi IA Long Kith,

thanh pha Bien Hem; - GD, cac PGD Ser Tu phap; - Trang thong tin din tit. Set Tu phap (dang tai); - Lyn: VT, PBGDPL. Ng8 Van Tan

THONG TU. Quy dinh BO tieu chi danh gii hi?ti qua cong tic phi,' bien, giGQ i i4 luat 354-,

VAN NGAY:plicietAlDEN

Can c&Ludt pha gicio dye phop luOt ngay 20 thong 6 CHINE' N: 2

so 111PHAP DotqL,

BO TU' PHAP CQNG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VII' NAM Bac lap — Ty do — Hunh phtic

SO: 03/2018/TT-BTP Ha Nal, ngay 10 thong 3 77ain 2018

Can ca. Nghi clinh so' 28/2013/NB-CP ngay 04 dying 4 nom 2013 ciia Chinh phi, guy dinh chi tiet inOt so dieu va bin phap thi hanh Ludt pith b/en, giao dye pith]) luat;

4

Can etre Nght ctinh 96/2017/ND-CP ngay 16 thang 8 narn 2017 ciia Chinh phu guy cli:nh ye cht:rc nong, nhiem vy, guyen hgn vii ccx cou to char cna. BO Tic phap;

Theo nghi: cña Vy tru-ang Vy Pha bien, giao dyc phap kid";

BO try Ong BO Tie phop ban hanh Thong tie guy dinh BO tieu chi danh gia hie'u quO cong teic pho hien, giao dyc phap luat.

Chuang I

QUY DINH CHUNG

Dieu 1. Phum vi dieu chinh

Thong tu nay quy dinh BO tieu chi danh gia hieu qua ding tac ph a bien, gido duc phap luat bao gom nOi dung BO Tieu chi; danh gia, cham diem, xep loal hieu qua cOng tac pho bien, giao d9c phap luat va bin phap bao dam thgc hien.

Dieu 2. nM ttnyng áp dung

BO, ca quan ngang bO.

tit y ban nhan dan tinh, thanh ph O trgc thuOc Trung ucmg (sau day g9i chung là Uy ban nhan dan cap tinh).

Dieu 3. Nguyen tic lay dtIng va áp dung

Tuan 7th9 quy clinh cüa phap luat hien hanh; de cao trach nhiem tg danh gia, cham diem dm bO, ca quan ngang bO, Uy ban nhan dan cap tinh voi clanh gia, cham diem va xep loai dm BO Tu phap theo quy clinh tai Thong tu nay.

Phan anh trung thgc, chinh xac, lchach quan, toan dien tinh hinh t6 chüc thgc hien nhiem vu &Ong tac pho biên, giao dgc phap luat; bac) dam re' rang, day dñ va thong nhat thong tin thu nhan duce tir hoat dOng danh gia, cham diem.

Bao dam sir pith hop cilia cac phuang phap, cling cp danh gia d6i veri anic dich, doi tugng, pham vi vã nOi dung danh gia.

Chuang H

NO1 DUNG Bo TIEU CHI (100 diem)

Dieu 4. Thanh phan B Tien chi

Nhom tieu chi thyt hien chat nang quan nha nuot ve ph6bin, gido dye phap luat (toi da 30 diem).

Nhom tieu chi trien khai the hog &Ong ph a bin, gido dye phap luat (ti da 20 diem).

Nhom dela chi ve cac dieu kin bao darn thyc hien ding tac ph6 bi'en, gido dye phap1uat (toi da 20 diem).

Nhom tieu chi danh gia hieu qua tac dang cüa cOng tac ph6 bin, giao dye phap luat d6i veri xa. hai (toi da 20 diem).

Nh6m tieu chi khac (tai da 10 diem).

Dieu 5. Nh6m tieu chi thut hien chat nang quan 1 nha mite ye phi; bien, giao dye phap luat (t6i da 30 diem)

1. Ban hanh theo tham quyen,cac,chucmg trinh, k hoach, van ban chi dao, huong dan nghiep vy ding tac pho bi8n, giao dye phap luat trong lTnh vyt, dia ban dugc giao quan byr (thi da 04 diem).

Ban hart chuang trinh, k hoach phe bien, gido dye phap luat hang Mm: 01 diem; tnrong hcrp thong ban hanh: 0 diem;

Ban hanh chuong trinh, k hoach tuyen truyen, ph6 bin cac van ban phap luat mai theo htrang dan eüa ca Tian co tham quyen hoac phü hgp vol die thn cüa dia ban, lilt we quan 1y: 01 diem; true:mg hop khOng ban hanh: 0 diem;

Ban hanh chuong trinh, ká hoach pha bin, giao dye phap haat trung han va dai ban theo huerng dan cUa cci quan, to chuc c6 tham quyen: 01 diem; tnrong hop khOng ban hart: 0, diem; truang hgp trong danh giá khong phat sinh nhiem vy thi dirge 01 diem;

Ban hanh the van ban chi dao, huong dan nghiep vy cong taz pha bien, glen dye phap 1114 trong linh vyc, dia ban dirge giao quan 1Y: 01 diem; truemg h9p khOng ban hanh: 0 diem.

2. T6 chfrc thyc hien cac chuong trinh, k hoach, van ban chi dao, huang dan nghiep vy &Ong, tac pho bien, gido dye phop 14t trong linh vyc, dia ban dugc giao quan 1? (tai da 04 diem).

Hoan thanh tir 90% den 100% the nhiem vy va boat Ong de ra: 04 diem;

Hoan thanh tir 80% den 90% cac nhiem vy va boat Ong d ra: 03 diem;

Moan thanh tU 70% den 80% cac nhiem vy va boat deng d'e ra: 02 diem;

Hoan thanh tit 60% den 70% cac nhiem vy va hoat dang d ra: 01 diem; 2

d) Hoan thanh clued 60% cac nhiem v3/41 va hoat &Ong dé ra: 0 diem. 3. Ve thai diem ban hanh cac chuong trinh, k hoach, van ban chi dao,

huang dA'n nghiep vo a:mg tac pha bien, gido dye phap luat trong linh vuc, dia ban doge giao quanbi (toi da 02 diem).

Ban hanh tong thai han 15 ngay lam viec k -Ur ngay ca quan co thAm quyen hoac ccr quan, t8 chat cap tren ban,hanh chuong trinh, ke hoach, van ban chi dao, huong dan nghiep va ding tac ph8 bin, gido chic phap luat: 02 diem;

Ban hanh trong theri han tren 15 ngay lam viee,va clued 30 ngay lam viec ke tit ngay co van co tham quyen hoac co quan, to elide cap tren ban hanh chuong trinh, ke hoach, van ban chi dao, huong dAn nghiep vii cong tac pho bien, Oen dye pith') luat: 01 diem;

Ban hanh sau 30 ngdy lam viec ke tit ngay co quan CO tham quyen hoac co quan, tO chat cap tren ban hanh rchuang trinh, ke hoach, van ban chi dao, huong clAn nghiep vo cling tic pito bién, gido due phap luat: 0 diem.

4. Xac dinh nOi dung va hinh that ph a bin, gide' dye phdp luat phi hop voi tixng nit di Prong trong 111th we, dia ban dirge giao quan 132 (tai da 05 diem)

Xac dinh nOi dung pith bien, gido chic phap luat (ti da 02 diem): CO xac dinh pha hop voi tung nhom den tugng: 02 diem; co xac dinh nhung khong pha hop \Teri timg nh6m doi tugng. 01 diem; truong hop khong xac dinh: 0 diem;

Xac dinh hinh tic ph a bin, giao due phap luat (tai da 02 diem): Co xac dinh pita hop veri timg nh6m doi tugng: 02 diem; co )(de dinh nhung khOng pha hop voi timg nh6m doi tugng. 01 diem; truang hop kitting xac dinh: 0 diem;

CO chi dap, hthang clAn viec xac dinh nOi dung va hinh tin:re pith bin, giao dye phap luat dc tha pha hgp vOl timg nhom doi tugng trong Binh we, dia ban dirge giao quan15/: 01 diem; truerng hop khong c6 chi dao, huerng &An: 0 diem.

5. Ta chitc tap hudn, bai throng kin tin:re phap luat, ,nghiep virt pha gido chic pith') luat theo quy dinh caa phap luat (toi da 05 diem).

,Hang nam co ta. chac tap huAn, bi duang kien tic pita') luat, nghiep vii pito bien, gido doe phap luat cho dOi ngü Bao car) vier' phap luat, Tuyen truyen vien pith') luat thuOc pham vi quan lY (toi da 03 diem). Trong da, tit 80% trot len: 03 diem; tit 65% den 80%: 02 diem; tix 50% den 65%: 01 diem; duti 50%: 0 diem;

,Hang nam co th chat tap huAn, bai chlang kien iliac phap luat, nghiep vii pho bien, giao dye phap luat cho di ngü ngueri lam ding the quan lY nha nu&

ph8 bin, gido clac pita') luat (toi da 02 diem). Trong da, tit 80% ter len: 02 diem; tit 65% den 80%: 01 diem; dual 65%; 0 diem.

6. To chat cap nhat van ban guy pham phap luat len co sa dit lieu quac gia ve phap luat theo quy dinh tai Dieu 13, Nghi dinh sa 52/2015/ND-CP ngay 28 thang 5 nam 2015 caa Chinh pha (tai da 05 diem).

3

, a) To chirc cap nhat clay di): 03 diem; cap nhat khong day dü di)/ theo tinh chat, mire dO ma dugc tit. 01 diem den 02 diem; khong cap nhat: 0 diem;

b) T6 chuc cap nhth kip thed theo quy dinh tai Dieu 17 Nghl dinh s6 52/2015/ND-CP ngay 28 thang 5 dam 2015 cüa Chinh phi) (toi da 02 diem). Trong do, cap nhat dung the," han theo quy dinh: 02 diem; cap nhat trong thai han khOng qua 15 ngay lam viec so ved then han theo quy dinh: 01 diem;, cap nhat trong thin han tren 15 ngay lam viec so voi thed theo quy dinh: 0 diem.

7. Thong ke, bao cao, tong ket, thanh tra, kiem tra, giai quyet khieu nai, to cao, xd 1 vi pham phap Kith ve ph6 Hen, gido dvc phap luat theo quy dinh ell a phap Kith (tell da 05 diem).

Thvc hien die' dO thing ke, bao cao, tAng kat theo clung quy dinh cüa phap luat vã hugng dan dm co quan nha nuac c6 tham quyen: 02 diem; tnrang hgp c6 thvc hien nhung lchong dung quy dinh cUa phap luat va huong clan dm co. quan nha nuot ea tham quyen: 01 diem; khong thvc hien: 0 diem;

Thvc hien viec thanh tra, kiem tra ye phi; bian, gido,cluc phap luat theo dang quy dinh cUa phap kith va huong clan elm ca quan co ththn quyen: 01 diem; tnrong hop khong thgc hien hoc thoc hien kheng dOng quy dinh cUa phap luat va huong clan ciia CO quan co tharn quyen: a diem;

C) Thvc hien viec giai quyat khiau ta cao ye ph6 bian, gido dpc phap kith dung quy dinh cUa phap luat vá huong dan ciia ca quan ca tham quyen: 01 diem; trueng hop thong thvc hien hoac, thvc hien khong dung quy dinh dlla phap that va huong dan ciia CO quan CO tharn quyen: 0 diem;

d) Thgc hien viec )(Ix 1 vi pham phap luat ve pha bin, gido clue phap luat theo dung quy dinh ella phap luat ILA huong dan dUa ca quan CO tham quyen: 01 diem; tnang hop khong urge hien hoac, thvc hien khOng clUng quy dinh cua phap luat vá huong clan ciia ca quan CO tham quyen: 0 diem.

A Dieu 6. Nhom tieu chi trien khai cac hot Ong phi; bin, giao due phi') Jut (tOi da 20 (hem)

Thvc hien trach nhiem clang tai thong tin phap luat van trang th'Ong tin din tir theo quy dinh tai Dieu 13 Luat ph8 bien, gido duc phap luat (toi da 04 diem)

, a) Dang tai clay dil (tai da 03 dim). Trong d6, dang tai tit 90% tr& len: 03 diem; dang tai tir 80% den 90%: 02 diem; clang tai tir 70% den 80%: 01 diem; dang tai duai 70%: 0 diem;

b) Dang tai kip then (tai, da 01 diem). Trong d6, 'Tang tai cham nhat trong thai han 15 ngay lam viec ke fir ngay phat sinh thong tin pith") luat thuec dien phai clang tai: 01 diem; sau 15 ngay lam viec ke tir ngay phat sinh thong tin phap luat thuOc din phai dang tai: 0 diem.

TO chirc pith bin, giao due phap lua.'t Cho can bO, cong chic, vien chirc ngued lao Ong thuoc pham vi pan l (toi da 04 diem)

a) T6 chat day dU, kip then: 04 diem;

4

TO' chdc day dü nhtmg chua kip theri: 03 diem;

Co ta ch(rc nhtmg khong day dü, chua Icip Mei: 02 diem;

Twang hop khong to elide thdc hien: 0 diem.

3. Ta chdc truyen thong, phi bin cac van ban, chinh sach phap luat mai thuOc pham vi linh vdc, dia ban dugc giao quan 19 bang mOt trong cac hinh thdc quy dinh tai Dieu 11 Ludt phO bien, giao dye phap luat (toi da 04 diem)

TO chirc trien khai day da, kip that 04 diem;

Ta chat trien khai day dà nhung chin Icip that 03 diem;

Ta chat trien khai khong day &I, chua kip thai: 02 diem;

Throng hop khong trien khai tilde hien: 0 diem.

, 4. Chi dao cac nha truang, ca se( giao dpc nghe nghiep thuOc pham vi quan 19 to chtirc ,giao dpc ,phap luat trong co sey gido dpc, ca giao dye nghe nghiep; bap In, chuan h6a, b8i duang di ngfl giao vien day mon giao dye clang dan, giao vien, giang vier' day phap luat thn/Oc pham vi quan 19 (Vol da 04 diem).

Co van ban chi dao, huong dart nhd trifling, ca ser giao dye nghe nghiep thuOc pham vi quan 19 t8 chirc boat dOng giao dye phap luat trong ca sg• giao dpc, ca giao dpc ,nghe nghiep: 01 diem; throng hop khong c6 van ban chi dao, huong dam 0 diem;

Rd soat, chuan h6a, bOi duang di5i ngü giao vien day mon giao dpc c6ng dan, giao vien, giang vien day phap luat thuOc pham vi quan 19: 02 diem; truang hap ca ra ,soat, chuan h6a nhung Ichong to chic beli duang: 01 diem; killing thdc hie'n: 0 diem;

Co chi ciao, huong dan vie rà soat, chuan h6a nOi dung chuang trinh, giao trinh, tai lieu phn hop voi ,cac van ban moi ban hanh• 01 diem; truang hop khong chi dao viec rà soat, chuan h6a: 0 diem.

5. Chi dao, huong clan, don dac, kiem tra cac ca quan, ta chat, dan vi trdc thuOc trien khai cac hog dOng huong ding Ngay Phap luat nu& COng hea xã hOi chit nghia Viet Nam (toi da 04 diem).

Co ban bath van ban chi dao, huong dan, don dc, kiem tra: 01 diem; khong c6 van ban: 0 diem;

CO trien khai cac float dOng cp the huong ling: 02 diem; kh8ng trien khai cac hoat dOng cp the: 0 diem;

CO mo hinh huang umg Ngdy Phap kat hieu (pa, thiremg xuyen, lien tpc: 01 diem; khong c6 mo hinh hoc khong hieu qua, thieu thuang xuyen: 0 diem.

5

Dieu 7. Nhom tieu chi ve cac dieu ki'en ban dam thut hien cling tic ph6 bin, giao due pita') luat (t6i da 20 diem)

1. Xay dyng, quan 12, khai thac vã sir dting hieu qua di ngü Bao tho vien phap Tuyen truyen vien phap lug theo quy dthh aim phap lug (toi da 05 diem).

Hang nam c6 xay dpng, ciing co, lcien toan dap img you cu nhiem vy: 03 diem; tnrang hop có xay dtmg nhung khong ding co, kien toan: 1,5 diem; khong xay dyng, cling co, kin toan: 0 diem;

Di ngü Bao ea° vien phap rluat, Tuy8n truyen vien phap lug &tot sir dyng hieu qua trong ding tde pho bien, gido dye phap lug: 02 diem; truong hop c6 sfr dyng nhung hieu qua khong cao: 01 diem. Bao cao vien phap lug, Tuyen truyen vien phap lug khong tham gia pho bien, giao dye phap lug: 0 diem.

2. Bao dam to chin 1315 may, can bi) lam cong tac pith bin, giao dye phap luat theo quy clinh cüa phap that (-Lai da 05 diem).

Co pilau clang, giao nhiem vy cho ea quan, dan vi lam dau mai tham mtru, trien khai nhiem vy ding the pho bien, giao dyc phap luat phü hop voi linh voc, dia ban quan 1Y: 02 diem; truerng hop eel phan using, giao nhiem vu nlymg khong phi' hop, \raj linh we, dia ban quan lyr: 01 diem; khong phan cong, giao nhiem vy: 0 diem;

CO 136 tri dOi ngli can b, cong chin lam ding tac pha bin, giao dyc phap lug phü hop,veri nhu cau pith bien, gido dye phap lug trong tinh we, dia ban Tian 1: 03 diem. Trong do, bo tn dü sO luong ,chi tieu, bien eh& dirge giao: 03 diem; chin ba tri dit so lucmg chi tieu, bien ché dirge giao: 02 diem; khong be tri can NI, cong chirc lam cong the pho bien, giao due phap lug: 0 diem.

3. Bao darn kinh phi cho cong tac ph a bien, giao dye phap lug theo quy dinh ctia phap lug da 07 diem).

Hang nam deu b tri dü kinh phi thuong xuyen trien khai thyc hien nhiem vy cOng tdc pho bien, giao dye phap lug theo quy dinh cüa phap luat ve ngan sach nha nuot: 03 diem; truong hop co bo tri nhung khong dii de thue hien nhiem vy &roe giao: 02 diem; khang bo tri: 0 diem;

Hang nam deu ba tri du kinh phi trien khai thge hien cac Chuang trinh, DE an ye pho bien, gide dye phap lust thuOc pham vi dirge giao chii tri thtrc hien: 02 diem; ,truang hop bô tri khong dii dê thgc hien nhiem vy dirge giao: 01 diem; khong ho tri: 0 diem;

CO trien khai cdc hoat dOng van (tang, thu hut, huy dang dirge the nguan lye xa hi tham gia pho,bian, gide dye phap lug theo chit truang xã hal boa: 02 diem; truerng hop c6 trien khai cdc hog (tang van clang tai tro nhtmg khong thu hut, huy dOng dirge cdc nguon lye xã hi tham gia: 01 diem; khong trien khai cac hog Ong van clang, thu hut, huy Ong cac nguon the: 0 diem.

4. Bao dam ca so vat chat, phtrang tien cho cong tac ph a bin, gido dye

6

phap luat theo quy dinh cüa phap War (teli da 03 diem).

r a) Bao darn day dU ca ser vat chat, phuang tin can thiet cho ding tat phi5 bien, giao dvc phap luat theo quy dinh cüa Chinh ,phil: 02 diem; truang hop bao dam khi5ng day der: 01 diem; khong bao dam: 0 diem;

b) C6 trien khai cac hog clOng irng dung ding nghe thong ,tin trong ding tac ph0 bien, gido dvc phap luat theo quy dinh: 01 diem; khong trien Ichai: 0 diem.

Dieu 8. Nhom ti'eu chi danh gia hi'eu qua tic dOng cfia cling tfic phO bien, giao dye pilaf) Ill@ doi vfri xä hi (ti da 20 diem)

1. Mire c10 nguoi dan, can b0,,cong chirc, vien chirc, nguti lao Ong tir h9c tap, chn Ong tim hieu pith') luat (toi da 04 diem)

Dat tir 85% den 100%: 04 diem;

Dat lir 70% den cluoi 85%: 03 diem;

Dat tir 55% d'en duoi 70%: 02 diem;

Dat duoi 55%: 01 diem.

2. Mirc dO ngued dan, can bo, cOng chirc, vien chüc, nguoi lao Ong biet pith") luat (tei da 04 diem)

Dat tir 85% den 1001/4: 04 diem;

Dat tir 70% den clued 85%: 03 diem;

Dart* 55% den cluti 70%: 02 diem;

Dat duoi 55%: 01 diem.

3. Mire do ngugi dan, can b0, ding chirc, vien chat, ngugi lao Ong hieu phap lu'at (tad da 04 diem)

Dat tir 85% den 100%: 04 diem;

Dat dr 70% den duoi 85%: 03 diem;

pat tir 55% den clued 70%: 02 diem;

Dat dugi 55%: 01 diem.

4., Mire dO nguesi dan, can ,b0, ,cong chirc, vien chirc, ngudi lao ,Ong hai long ye chat lugng hoat dOng pho bien, gido dvc phap luat (tOi da 04 diem)

Dat tir 85% den 100%: 04 diem;

Dat dr 70% den duoi 85%: 03 diem;

Dat dr 55% den duo" 70%: 02 diem;

Dat thrOi 55%: 01 diem.

5. Tinh hinh vi pham phap luat trong linh vkrc, dia ban thuOc pham vi quan 7

19 do khong hieu bit phap luat giam (thi da 04 diem)

Dat tir 85% den 100%: 04 diem;

Dat tir 70% den duti 85%: 03 diem;

Dat tit 55% den duti 70%: 02 diem;

Dat duôi 55%: 01 diem.

6. T9 ie % quy dinh tai khoan 1, khoan 2, khoan 3, khoan 4 va khoan 5 Dieu nay duet tinh the° clang that: T91e %,dat dirge = (Tong se ngueri hp chon ni dung tra loi trong phieu khao sat/Tong so phieu duet khdo sat)* 100%.

Vi dy. I: Tien hanh Mint sat, phat tong 50 100 phieu cho nguti dan, can bo, ding chirc, vien chat, nwati lao dOng; cep 35 phieu tra 1&i là Net phap luat la do tv hoc tap, chi) dOng tim hieu phap luat. T9 le % mat c10 nguti clan, can 130, c8ng chirc, vien chirc, nguti lao.dOng tv hgc tap, chü d0ng tim hieu phap 141 = (35/100)*100% = 35%, thuec diem d, khoan 1, dirge 01 diem.

Vi dy 2: Tien hanh khao sat, phat tang se) 100 phieu cho nguei dan, can b0, c8ng chirc, vien chec, ngued lao dOng;,c6 55 phieu tra led la biet (hoc hieu rO) ve quy dinh cüa phap luat. T$7 le % ve mitt dO nosed dan, can 1)0, ding chec, vien chirc, nguti lao &Ong Net (hoc hieu) phap 1114 = (55/100)*100% = 55%, thupac diem c, khoan 2 va khoan 3, dirge 02 diem.

Vi dy 3: Tien hanh khao sat, OS tang sa 100 phieu cho nguti clan, can b0, ding chat, vien chat, nguai lao clang; c6 75 phieu tra led la hai long ve chat luvng host Ong ph() bien, gido cl9c phap 1141 l'e % mitt dO nguai dan, can b0, ding chirc, vien chirc, ngtrai lao Ong hai king ve chSt lugng hoat d'ang pho bin, gide due pith!) luat = (75/100)*100% = 75%, thuOc diem b, khoan 4, dirge 03 diem.

Vi dy 4: Ti'en hanh khan sat, pilot thng sa 100 phieu cho ngued clan, can b0, clang chirc, vien chec, nguti lao ging c6 hanh vi vi pham phap luat; c6 70 phik tra led nguyen nhan vi pham phap luat la do kh8ng hieu biet phap luSt. 13'I % ngubi vi pham pita') luat do khong hieu biet phap luat = (70/100)* 100% = 70%. So sanh vol ding k9 danh gia hoac nam trutc do de xet t9 l tang hay giam de xac dinh t9 le, infrc (10 giana de tinh diem so tuang i.rng vied mix do dat dirge.

Dieu 9. Nhom tieu chi khic da 10 diem)

1. Dai vai b0, ca quan ngang b0 (tai da 10 diem)

Thgc hien day dà trach nhi'em h9p bao, thong cao bao chi ve van ban guy, pham pile") luat do minh chü tri son thao theo quy dinh tai Dieu 12 Lust pith bien, gido dye phap luat: 05 diem. Truang hap thgc hien khong day dü thi diem so dat dugc Wang ung veri so diem tai da than vai t9 le % mat do hoan thanh nhi'em vw dirge giao; khong thvc hien tech nhiem duet giao: 0 diem;

Ta chec bien soan tai lieu va pha bien kin thee phap luat chuyen nganh bang hinh thirc thich hop: 05 diem. Twang hap thubc hien khong day dü thi diem

8

so dat dugc tuang áng veil so diem toi da than voi tjf le % mire dO hoan thanh nhiem vi dugc giao; khOng thyc hien trach nhiem dugc giao: 0 diem.

Truang hop khans phat sixth nhiem vi quy dinh tai diem a khoan 1 Dieu nay thi dugc diem se t6i da theo quy dinh (05 diem).

2. Dai voi Uy ban nhan clan cap tinh (tai da 10 diem) Gang co, kin toan, trien Ichai thyt hien day dU chdc nang, nhiem vp va

quyen han cim HOi Tong phoi hop pho bien, gido dyc phap luat cap tinh: 02 diem; twang hop IchOng thyc hien: 0 diem;

De ra giai phap nang cao hieu qua hoat clOng cUa HOi demg phi hyppha bien, gido dyc phap luat cap tinh: 02 diem; truong hop Ichong thyc hien: 0 diem;

Chi dao,, huomg dan vie'c,cong ca, kin toan va nang cao hieu qua hoat dOng cüa HOi doing phai hop pho bien, gido dyc phap luat cap huyen: 02 diem; truang hop khong thgc hien: 0 diem;

Chi dao, huang dan, trien khai thyc hien cons tac ph a bin, gido dyc phap luat cho cac dai arcing dc tha theo khoan 4, Dieu 18; khoan 3, Dieu ,19; Ichoan 4, Dieu 20; khoan 3, Dieu 22 Luat pho bien, glen dc phap luat: 04 diem; truemg hop khong thyc hi'en: 0 diem.

Chuang III DANII GIA, CRAM DIEM, XEP LO.AI HIEU QUA CONG TAC PHO

BIEN, GIAO DIX PRAP LUAT Dieu 10. IC3, die& gia, each thee dinh gia, chant diem

Vie danh gia, chain diem, 'cep loai hieu,qua cong tac pita bien, gide) dyc phap luat dugc thyc hien clinh kS7,02 nam mOt Ian. Thai diem an dinh cac thong tin, so lieu de danh gia, cham diem, xep loai IA ngay 31 thang 12 dm ram -did hai tinh tü Mari diem danh gia kS7truoc; aloe thai gian de tinh IcST dãu danh gia la ngay 31 thang 12 nam 2018.

Vic death gia, charn ,diem di vói timg tieu chi, chi tieu thanh phan quy dinh tai Dieu 5, Dieu 6, Dieu 7 va Dieu 9 Oa tren ket qua dat dugc, müc dO hoan thanh nhiem vp va diem so quy dinh tai Thong tu nay. Viec danh gia, cham diem doi vai nhom tieu chi quy dinh tai Dieu 8 dugc thgc hien bang phucmg pita') dieu tra xA hOi, hoc chra ten BO &Ong cp danh gia do bt), ca quan ngang bO, Uy ban nhan dan cap tinh chü tri thyc hien hoac ca quan, to chat dc lap tien hanh phn hgp vài quy dinh tai Dieu 3 va quy dinh tai Thong tu nay.

Hang nam, bO, co van ngang 1)0, uy ban nh'an dan cap tinh tO chirc viec tir danh gia, cham diem doi vOl tfmg tieu chi, chi tieu thanh phan quy dinh tai Dieu 5, Dieu 6, Dieu 7 va Dieu 9; km chon mOt so lith vyc, dia ban tong diem do to chirc khao sat, danh gia, cham diem doi vai nhom tieu chi, chi tiou quy dinh tai Dieu 8 ThOng tu nay va tong hop ket qua trong ban cao cong toe ttu phap, phap che hang nam gun BO Tu phap. Can ,cfr ket qua hi danh giá, cham diem va mire dO dat dugc, de de ra giai phap khac phyc, nang cao diem so doi vai chi tieu, tieu chi dat diem so thap.

9

Kt qua tr danh gia, chain diem hang nam cüa b(), ca quan ngang be, fly ban nhan dan cap tinh , la can dr de BOTir phap danh gia mac d hoan thanh nhiem vi acing tac ph bin, gido dpc phap lust hang nam; có bi'en phap don doc, chi ciao, huang dan, kiem tra, chan chinh viec thyc hien nhiem vv ding tac pito bien, gido dye phap luSt hoc icien nghi Chinh pha, Thu tuong Chinh pha cac giai phap de nang cao hieu qua cong tac pho bien, gido dye phap 141

Trong truang hop âê phyc vy yeu cau guar' lY nha nuot, BO truarT BO Tij phap quyet dinh viec to chirc danh gia det xuat, danh gia doi vai mOt so bO, co quan ngang be, fly ban nhan dan cap tinh. Viec danh gia dugc thyc hien dya tren BO ding cv danh gia bao 1Vidu phieu diet' tra, khao sat; nOi dung kiem tra, phOng van; bac) cao va cac tai lieu pha hop khac. Phuongphap danh gia, BO cong cu danh gia do BO -1-tr phap quyet dinh pha h9p vai doi Wong, nOi dung khao sat, danh gia va quy dinh tai Dieu 3 va quy dinh tai Thong tu nay.

Dieu 11. TO chat danh gia, cham diem khi ket thtic lit &tilt gia

Kt thac IcY danh gia, 130, co quan ngang b0, Uy ban nhan clan cap tinh to chirc tu danh gia, cham diem toan be cac nhom tieu chi, chi deli theo Thong tu nay va gfri bao cao ket Rua ty danh gia, chain diem ye BO Ttr phap de' danh gia, cham,diem, xep, loai. Diem so caa tang nhom tiou chi quy dinh tai Dieu 5, Dieu 6, Dieu 7 va Dieu 9 la diem so trung binh cong caa hai nam trong cang ky danh gia; diem so caa nhom tieu chi quy dinh tai Dieu 8 &Tye lya ch9n dya,tren rkat qua dieu tra xã hei h9c quy dinh tai khoan 2 Dieu 10 ThOng tu nay. Diem so ty danh gia dugc tinh h so 1. Thai gian gai bao cao ty rdanh gia, cham diem chant nhat IA ngay 28 thang 02 caa nam lien ké sau nam cuoi caa danh gia.

Can cir ket qua ay danh gia, cham diem caa b0, ca quan ngang ban nhan dan cap tinh va ket qua theo dOi, quan 132, ket qua kiem tra, Ufa° sat, toa darn va cac nguOn thong tin hop phap khac, BO Tir pita') te chfrc viec (Mirth

ch'am diem tang nhom lieu chi trong nOi dung BO Tieu chi theo Thong at nay. Diem so do BO Tu phap danh gin dirge tinh h s8 2.

Trong truong hop can thiet hoc eel nOi dung chin ro, BO Tu phap d nghi co quan dirge danh gia gui tai lieu kiem chi:mg nhu: bao cao, ke hoach, thong bao, guy& dinh, &Ong van... de xac minh de tin cay cüa ket qua ty danh gin, cham diem. Doi yeti cac tieu chi khong co tai lieu kiem chUng, de nghi ca quan duqc danh gia giai trinh ve cach danh gia, tinh diem; tai lieu kiem chung dirge gin den BO Tu phap kern theo bao cao at danh gia, cham diem quy dinh tai khoin 1 Dieu nay.

Tong s6 diem lam can dr de BO Tu phap xep loai hieu qua cong tac phO bien, giao dye ephap 11* dugc tinh theo cong thdc: Tang se diem dat &roc = (Diem se ty cham *1 + Diem so do BO Tu phap cham * 2)/3.

Vi dy 5: Ket thac kY dart gin, be, ca quan ngang be, ljy ban nhan dan cap tinh ty danh gia va cham dirge 85 diem; BO Tu phap to chirc viec danh gin va cham diem dugc 88 diem. Khi do, tong so diem dat duoc lam can dr de Bq Tu

10

phap xep loai hieu qua cling tac pha bin, gido due phap luat la: (85*1 + 88t2)/3= 87 diem.

Dieu 12. Thyt hien viec xep loai

Vic xep loai dugc thgc hien can dr vao t6rig so' diem ma bel, ca quan ngang b0, Uy ban nhan dan cap tinh dat dugc theo quy dinh tai khoan 2 Dieu nay.

Tong so diem dat dugc va mirc xep loai nhu sau:

Tang so' diem dat dugc tit 90 diem tret Xep loai xuat sac;

Tang sa diem dat dugc tit 80 diem den 90 diem: Xep loai t6t;

Tong so diem dat dugc tit 70 diem den 80 diem: Xep loai kha;

Tang sa diem dat dugc tit 50 diem den 70 diem: Xep loai thing binh;

d) Tang sa diem dat dugc dueti 50 diem: Xep loai y6'u.

Dieu 13. COng 136, thong tin ye ket qua xep lo3i

Kt qua xep loai be, ca quan ngang b0, fly ban nhan clan cap tinh theo Dieu 12 Thong tu nay &tot BO Tu phap ding ba tntac ngay 30 thang 4 cii a Mm lien ke sau Mm cuOi cüa kST danh gia va thong tin den ca quan duce xep loai HinTh thirc ding b0 do BO Tu phap quyet dinh.

fat. • Chuang IV

BIEN PHAP BAO DAM THI.Jt HIEN

Dieti11414. Tiach nhiem t chlit thvc hien

Can cuir vao chirc nang, nhi'em vu va quyen han dugc giao vã dieu hen thgc lien, BO throng, Thu truang co quan ngang b0, Uy ban nhan clan cap tinh t8 chitc trien khai thgc hien Thong tu nay; chi dao, huerng dan viec op dung ngi dung BO Tieu chi danh gia hieu qua c8ng tac ph8 bien, giao due phap luat dOi vai ca quan, dan vi thuec pham vi quan 13i phit hop \Teri quy dinh tai Thong tu nay.

Vg Ph 6 bin, gido due phap luat chit tri, phai hgp vói dan vi có lien quan thuec BO tham muu giup BO truong BO Tu phap thgc Men nhiem vg quy dinh tai khoan 4 va khoan 5 Dieu 10; khoan 2, Dieu 11, Dieu 12 va Dieu 13 Thong tu nay.

Ta chirc phap cite tham muu, ginp BO truang, Thu truerng co ,quan ngang b0 thgc Men viec tçr danh gia, cham diem hieu qua cong tac pho bien, giao due phap luat lien quan den flail vat quan 157 theo Thong tu nay.

Sef Tu phap , tham muu, ginp fly ban nhanedan clap tinh thgc hien viec tv danh gia, cham diem hieu qua cong tac ph8 bien, gido due phap luat tai dia phuong theo Thong tu nay.

Dieu 15. Kinh phi thut hien 1. Kinh phi thgc hien Thong tu nay dirge bá tri trong dg toan chi ngan sa.ch

11

Le Thanh Long

thuong xuyen hang nam eüa bO, co quan ngang b0, ny ban nhan dan cap tinh theo phan cap ngan sach nha nuot hien hanh.

2. Khuyen ichich to chile, doanh nghiep, ca. nhan 11-6 trçx Icinh phi thuc hien 1chao sat, danh gia hieu qua cong tac phi!, bien, gido due phap luat doi yeti nhom tieu chi quy dinh tai Dieu 8 và quy dinh tai Thong tu nay.

CHIYONG V

DIEU KHOAN THI HANH

Dieu 16. Hien lire thi hanh Thong tu nay Co hi'eu lye thi hanh k& tag ngay 01 thing 7 nam 2018.

Dieu 17. Trach nhient thi hanh BQ tnrong, Thu tn.remg co quan ngang b0, Chü tich fly ban nhan dan cap

tinh, Thu truong cac don vj thuoc BO Ttr .phap, to' chirc phap che, cac dun vi dugc giao phu tech Gong tac phap che, phe hien, gido due phap hi@ caa b0, ca quan ngang b0, Giam doe Sà Tu phap tinh, thanh pho nue thuOc Trung wing chinu trach nhiem thi hanh Thong tu

Nol - Thu Wong Chfith phi% - Ck PIM TIM tuang Chinh pith; - Van pi-1611g Quoc c hOi; - Van phong Cho tich mot; - Van phOng Chinh phi; , - Vin kiem sat nhan dan toi cao; - Tôa an nhan dan thi cao;

Ban Tuyen giao Trung trong; Ca quan Trung trong cUn cac to chirc chinh tri - xa hi; Ck b0, ca quan ngang be;

- US, ban nhan dan cac tinh, thenh phor hire thutje Trung yang; - BO Tu phap: BO twang, cac Thir tnrang, ck dan vi thuOc BO; - TO civic phap che cac b0, ca quan ngar$ b0, I:Jy ban Trung trong Mat tran To quOc Viet Nam va the to chit° chinh tri - xA hei, to chirc chinh tri-xa hei, nghe nghiep, to chic id hoi, to chat xä hei - nghe nghiep a Trung trying;

Ser Tu phap cac tinh, thanh phO true thuOc TW; - Cong bap; Website Chinh pha; Ccr ser da lieu quOc gia ye van ban quy pham phap luat; - COng thong tin din ta. BO Ttr phdp; - Ltru: VT, PBGDPL (30b).

12