1
VOL. CLXVI .... No. 57,723 © 2017 The New York Times Company SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 17, 2017 THE CITY THAT NEVER SLEEPS IS ABOUT TO WAKE UP THE WORLD. FOR FREEDOM. FOR JUSTICE. FOR ALL. PROUD PARTNER OF THE GLOBAL CITIZEN FESTIVAL. PROUD SPONSOR OF PROGRESS. WWW.GLOBALCITIZEN.ORG/CITI #GCFEST 9.18.17 - 9.23.17 NEW YORK, NY FORTALEZA, Brazil Children’s squeals rang through the muggy morning air as a woman pushed a gleaming white cart along pitted, trash-strewn streets. She was making deliveries to some of the poorest households in this seaside city, bringing pudding, cookies and other pack- aged foods to the customers on her sales route. Celene da Silva, 29, is one of thousands of door-to-door vendors for Nestlé, help- ing the world’s largest packaged food con- glomerate expand its reach into a quarter- million households in Brazil’s farthest- flung corners. As she dropped off variety packs of Chandelle pudding, Kit-Kats and Mucilon infant cereal, there was something strik- ing about her customers: Many were visi- bly overweight, even small children. She gestured to a home along her route and shook her head, recalling how its pa- triarch, a morbidly obese man, died the previous week. “He ate a piece of cake and died in his sleep,” she said. Mrs. da Silva, who herself weighs more than 200 pounds, recently discovered that she had high blood pressure, a condition she acknowledges is probably tied to her weakness for fried chicken and the Coca- Cola she drinks with every meal, break- fast included. Nestlé’s direct-sales army in Brazil is part of a broader transformation of the food system that is delivering Western- style processed food and sugary drinks to the most isolated pockets of Latin Amer- ica, Africa and Asia. As their growth slows in the wealthiest countries, multinational food companies like Nestlé, PepsiCo and General Mills have been aggressively ex- panding their presence in developing na- tions, unleashing a marketing juggernaut Continued on Page 12 Celene da Silva, left, and her daughter Sabrina delivering Nestlé products like Kit-Kats and pudding in Fortaleza, Brazil. WILLIAM DANIELS FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES PLANET FAT Nestlé Goes Door to Door By ANDREW JACOBS and MATT RICHTEL How Big Business Got Brazil Hooked on Junk Food KABUL, Afghanistan — Soon, American Embassy employees in Kabul will no longer need to take a Chinook helicopter ride to cross the street to a military base less than 100 yards outside the present Green Zone security district. Instead, the boundaries of the Green Zone will be redrawn to in- clude that base, known as the Ka- bul City Compound, formerly the headquarters for American Spe- cial Operations forces in the capi- tal. The zone is separated from the rest of the city by a network of po- lice, military and private security checkpoints. The expansion is part of a huge public works project that over the next two years will reshape the center of this city of five million to bring nearly all Western embas- sies, major government min- istries, and NATO and American military headquarters within the protected area. After 16 years of American pres- ence in Kabul, it is a stark ac- knowledgment that even the city’s central districts have become too difficult to defend from Taliban bombings. But the capital project is also clearly taking place to protect an- other long-term American invest- ment: Along with an increase in troops to a reported 15,000, from around 11,000 at the moment, the Trump administration’s new strategy for Afghanistan is likely to keep the military in place well into the 2020s, even by the most conservative estimates. No one wants to say when any final pullout will take place be- cause the emphasis now is on a conditions-based withdrawal — PROJECT EXTENDS U.S. TIMETABLE IN AFGHANISTAN A REMAKING OF KABUL Expanding Green Zone, and Digging In for the Next Decade By ROD NORDLAND Continued on Page 10 WASHINGTON — Every year, the president heads to New York to welcome world leaders to the United Nations General Assem- bly. He gives a speech and meets with an endless string of foreign potentates to discuss a dizzying array of complicated, often in- tractable issues. The days are “kind of like speed dating from hell,” as one analyst put it, and the evenings are “the world’s most tedious cocktail party.” In other words, not exactly President Trump’s favored format. But when Mr. Trump attends the first United Nations session of his presidency this coming week, all eyes will be on him as counterparts from around the globe crane their necks and slide through the crowd to snatch a handshake — and, in the process, try to figure out this most un- usual of American leaders. “The world is still trying to take the measure of this presi- dent,” said Jon B. Alterman, a senior vice president at the Cen- ter for Strategic and Interna- tional Studies in Washington and author of the speed-dating anal- ogy. “For a number of leaders, this is going to be their first chance to see him, to judge him, to try to get on his good side.” In some places, there has been an instinct to dismiss Mr. Trump, a bombastic, Twitter-obsessed political and diplomatic neo- phyte. “But the fact is you can’t write off the American presi- dent,” Mr. Alterman said. One of Mr. Trump’s primary tasks will be to define how his America First approach — which has led him to pull out of interna- tional agreements on free trade and climate change — fits into the world-first mission of the United Nations. His challenge is “to describe the Trump Doctrine on U.S. As U.N. Meets, Eyes on Trump Leaders Gather, Taking Measure of a President NEWS ANALYSIS By PETER BAKER Continued on Page 9 LAKEWOOD, Colo. — Jack Phillips bakes beautiful cakes, and it is not a stretch to call him an artist. Five years ago, in a decision that has led to a Supreme Court showdown, he refused to use his skills to make a wedding cake to celebrate a same-sex marriage, saying it would violate his Chris- tian faith and hijack his right to ex- press himself. “It’s more than just a cake,” he said at his bakery one recent morning. “It’s a piece of art in so many ways.” The couple he refused to serve, David Mullins and Charlie Craig, filed civil rights charges. They said they had been demeaned and humiliated as they sought to cele- brate their union. “We asked for a cake,” Mr. Craig said. “We didn’t ask for a piece of art or for him to make a statement for us. He simply turned us away because of who we are.” At first blush, the case looked like a conflict between a state law banning discrimination and the First Amendment’s protection of religious freedom. But when the Supreme Court hears the case this fall, the arguments will mostly center on a different part of the First Amendment: its protection of free speech. The government, Mr. Phillips contends, should not be allowed to compel him to endorse a message at odds with his beliefs. “I’m being forced to use my cre- ativity, my talents and my art for an event — a significant religious event — that violates my religious faith,” Mr. Phillips said. Gay rights groups regard the case as a potent threat to the equality promised by the Su- preme Court in 2015 when it said By ADAM LIPTAK Jack Phillips, a Colorado baker, was accused of discrimination. His Supreme Court appeal will focus on free speech rights. NICK COTE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page 16 Cake Is His ‘Art.’ But Can He Deny One to a Gay Couple? Every other day or so, Hatem El-Gamasy connects to a news au- dience nearly halfway around the world, delivering hot takes on American politics, live from New York, but on Egyptian television. When the broadcast ends, he slips out his earpieces, opens the door of his makeshift studio and returns to his day job. “You want ketchup on that?” he said to a customer on a recent morning. “Extra ketchup as usu- al?” Mr. El-Gamasy owns the Lotus Deli in Ridgewood, Queens, a place known for its sandwiches, extensive craft beer selection, and its gracious, friendly owner. But few of his customers — and likely, none of his viewers in Egypt — know that the man making egg sandwiches and small talk behind the counter is the same one who appears on popular Egyptian tele- vision news programs, holding forth on subjects from immigra- tion policy to North Korea. Nor do many know that his tele- vision studio is actually a wash- room in the back, past the potato chips display. After a reporter approached Mr. Making Political News in Egypt From a Washroom in Queens By SARAH MASLIN NIR Hatem El-Gamasy, owner of the Lotus Deli in Queens, where he holds forth on news topics for Egyptian television programs. MARK ABRAMSON FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page 17 HOUSTON — It was a hard choice, but in the end it was no choice at all. A small rescue boat had come up the driveway, offer- ing help. Carl Ellis was with his frail, 73-year-old mother, Wilma Jean. The boat had room for one. The water was already up to Mr. Ellis’s knees, so there was no time to wait for rescuers with more room. His mother would have to go alone. Using the back of a pickup truck as a gangplank, Mr. Ellis helped his mother into the boat, her be- longings trussed up in garbage bags. There were no life jackets, but it was a short trip and the res- cuers promised to come right back for him. He never saw them — or his mother — again. Any catastrophic weather event has its measurable aspects: inches of rain, speed of wind, cubic yards of debris. Others are incal- culable: waterlogged photos, frayed communities, the invisible moorings of permanence and safety swept away. But perhaps the worst things are the unknowable, forever lost in the confusion, mysteries like what happened to Ms. Ellis, who was rescued not once, but twice, and who nonetheless became a casualty of the storm. At the time her son believed she was being ferried to higher ground, she was found floating Twice Saved From Houston Floods but Still, Mysteriously, a Victim By SHAILA DEWAN Continued on Page 18 A surge of violence has shaken the once-peaceful tourist destination of Los Cabos, exposing stark inequality and government indifference. PAGE 6 INTERNATIONAL 4-14 Murder in a Mexican Hot Spot We expect computers to do all sorts of things. But as those demands test com- puter chips’ limits, engineers are taking design cues from the brain. PAGE 1 SUNDAY BUSINESS Chip Off the Old Block Hillary Clinton and the actress America Ferrera discuss the presidential elec- tion’s emotional toll, gratitude and a path forward. Table for Three. PAGE 1 SUNDAY STYLES Pain and Progress After 2016 Todd Marinovich, a starting quarter- back in the World Developmental League, is making a return that has little to do with football. PAGE 1 SPORTSSUNDAY At 48, Finally Playing Sober U(DF47D3)W+@!:!/!=!/ Maureen Dowd PAGE 1 SUNDAY REVIEW Printed in Chicago $6.00 Partly cloudy. Afternoon showers or thunderstorms. Humid. Highs in the middle 70s to the upper 80s. Show- ers or thunderstorms south tonight. Details in SportsSunday, Page 8. National Edition

Hooked on Junk Food How Big Business Got · WAKE UP THE WORLD. FOR FREEDOM. FOR JUSTICE. FOR ALL. PROUD PARTNER OF THE GLOBAL CITIZEN FESTIVAL. PROUD SPONSOR OF PROGRESS. !CITI #GCFEST

  • Upload
    vudang

  • View
    217

  • Download
    4

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Hooked on Junk Food How Big Business Got · WAKE UP THE WORLD. FOR FREEDOM. FOR JUSTICE. FOR ALL. PROUD PARTNER OF THE GLOBAL CITIZEN FESTIVAL. PROUD SPONSOR OF PROGRESS. !CITI #GCFEST

C M Y K Yxxx,2017-09-17,A,001,Bs-4C,E1

VOL. CLXVI . . . . No. 57,723 © 2017 The New York Times Company SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 17, 2017

THE CITY THAT NEVER

SLEEPS IS ABOUT TO

WAKE UP THE WORLD.

FOR FREEDOM. FOR JUSTICE. FOR ALL.

PROUD PARTNER OF THE GLOBAL CITIZEN FESTIVAL.

PROUD SPONSOR OF PROGRESS.

WWW.GLOBALCITIZEN.ORG/CITI

#GCFEST

9.18.17 - 9.23.17

NEW YORK, NY

FORTALEZA, Brazil — Children’ssqueals rang through the muggy morningair as a woman pushed a gleaming whitecart along pitted, trash-strewn streets.She was making deliveries to some of thepoorest households in this seaside city,bringing pudding, cookies and other pack-aged foods to the customers on her salesroute.

Celene da Silva, 29, is one of thousandsof door-to-door vendors for Nestlé, help-ing the world’s largest packaged food con-glomerate expand its reach into a quarter-million households in Brazil’s farthest-flung corners.

As she dropped off variety packs ofChandelle pudding, Kit-Kats and Muciloninfant cereal, there was something strik-ing about her customers: Many were visi-

bly overweight, even small children.She gestured to a home along her route

and shook her head, recalling how its pa-triarch, a morbidly obese man, died theprevious week. “He ate a piece of cake anddied in his sleep,” she said.

Mrs. da Silva, who herself weighs morethan 200 pounds, recently discovered that

she had high blood pressure, a conditionshe acknowledges is probably tied to herweakness for fried chicken and the Coca-Cola she drinks with every meal, break-fast included.

Nestlé’s direct-sales army in Brazil ispart of a broader transformation of thefood system that is delivering Western-style processed food and sugary drinks tothe most isolated pockets of Latin Amer-ica, Africa and Asia. As their growth slowsin the wealthiest countries, multinationalfood companies like Nestlé, PepsiCo andGeneral Mills have been aggressively ex-panding their presence in developing na-tions, unleashing a marketing juggernaut

Continued on Page 12

Celene da Silva, left, and her daughter Sabrina delivering Nestlé products like Kit-Kats and pudding in Fortaleza, Brazil.WILLIAM DANIELS FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

PLANET FAT

Nestlé Goes Door to Door

By ANDREW JACOBS and MATT RICHTEL

How Big Business Got BrazilHooked on Junk Food

KABUL, Afghanistan — Soon,American Embassy employees inKabul will no longer need to take aChinook helicopter ride to crossthe street to a military base lessthan 100 yards outside the presentGreen Zone security district.

Instead, the boundaries of theGreen Zone will be redrawn to in-clude that base, known as the Ka-bul City Compound, formerly theheadquarters for American Spe-cial Operations forces in the capi-tal. The zone is separated from therest of the city by a network of po-lice, military and private securitycheckpoints.

The expansion is part of a hugepublic works project that over thenext two years will reshape thecenter of this city of five million tobring nearly all Western embas-sies, major government min-istries, and NATO and Americanmilitary headquarters within theprotected area.

After 16 years of American pres-ence in Kabul, it is a stark ac-knowledgment that even the city’scentral districts have become toodifficult to defend from Talibanbombings.

But the capital project is alsoclearly taking place to protect an-other long-term American invest-ment: Along with an increase introops to a reported 15,000, fromaround 11,000 at the moment, theTrump administration’s newstrategy for Afghanistan is likelyto keep the military in place wellinto the 2020s, even by the mostconservative estimates.

No one wants to say when anyfinal pullout will take place be-cause the emphasis now is on aconditions-based withdrawal —

PROJECT EXTENDSU.S. TIMETABLEIN AFGHANISTAN

A REMAKING OF KABUL

Expanding Green Zone,and Digging In forthe Next Decade

By ROD NORDLAND

Continued on Page 10

WASHINGTON — Every year,the president heads to New Yorkto welcome world leaders to theUnited Nations General Assem-bly. He gives a speech and meetswith an endless string of foreignpotentates to discuss a dizzyingarray of complicated, often in-tractable issues.

The days are “kind of likespeed dating from hell,” as oneanalyst put it, and the eveningsare “the world’s most tediouscocktail party.” In other words,not exactly President Trump’sfavored format.

But when Mr. Trump attendsthe first United Nations sessionof his presidency this comingweek, all eyes will be on him ascounterparts from around theglobe crane their necks and slidethrough the crowd to snatch ahandshake — and, in the process,try to figure out this most un-usual of American leaders.

“The world is still trying totake the measure of this presi-dent,” said Jon B. Alterman, asenior vice president at the Cen-ter for Strategic and Interna-tional Studies in Washington andauthor of the speed-dating anal-ogy. “For a number of leaders,this is going to be their firstchance to see him, to judge him,to try to get on his good side.”

In some places, there has beenan instinct to dismiss Mr. Trump,a bombastic, Twitter-obsessedpolitical and diplomatic neo-phyte. “But the fact is you can’twrite off the American presi-dent,” Mr. Alterman said.

One of Mr. Trump’s primarytasks will be to define how hisAmerica First approach — whichhas led him to pull out of interna-tional agreements on free tradeand climate change — fits intothe world-first mission of theUnited Nations.

His challenge is “to describethe Trump Doctrine on U.S.

As U.N. Meets,Eyes on TrumpLeaders Gather, TakingMeasure of a President

NEWS ANALYSIS

By PETER BAKER

Continued on Page 9

LAKEWOOD, Colo. — JackPhillips bakes beautiful cakes,and it is not a stretch to call him anartist. Five years ago, in a decisionthat has led to a Supreme Courtshowdown, he refused to use hisskills to make a wedding cake tocelebrate a same-sex marriage,saying it would violate his Chris-tian faith and hijack his right to ex-press himself.

“It’s more than just a cake,” hesaid at his bakery one recentmorning. “It’s a piece of art in somany ways.”

The couple he refused to serve,David Mullins and Charlie Craig,filed civil rights charges. Theysaid they had been demeaned andhumiliated as they sought to cele-brate their union.

“We asked for a cake,” Mr. Craigsaid. “We didn’t ask for a piece ofart or for him to make a statementfor us. He simply turned us awaybecause of who we are.”

At first blush, the case lookedlike a conflict between a state lawbanning discrimination and theFirst Amendment’s protection ofreligious freedom. But when theSupreme Court hears the case thisfall, the arguments will mostlycenter on a different part of theFirst Amendment: its protection

of free speech.The government, Mr. Phillips

contends, should not be allowed tocompel him to endorse a messageat odds with his beliefs.

“I’m being forced to use my cre-ativity, my talents and my art foran event — a significant religiousevent — that violates my religiousfaith,” Mr. Phillips said.

Gay rights groups regard thecase as a potent threat to theequality promised by the Su-preme Court in 2015 when it said

By ADAM LIPTAK

Jack Phillips, a Colorado baker,was accused of discrimination.His Supreme Court appeal willfocus on free speech rights.

NICK COTE FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page 16

Cake Is His ‘Art.’ But Can He Deny One to a Gay Couple?

Every other day or so, HatemEl-Gamasy connects to a news au-dience nearly halfway around theworld, delivering hot takes onAmerican politics, live from NewYork, but on Egyptian television.

When the broadcast ends, heslips out his earpieces, opens thedoor of his makeshift studio andreturns to his day job.

“You want ketchup on that?” hesaid to a customer on a recentmorning. “Extra ketchup as usu-al?”

Mr. El-Gamasy owns the LotusDeli in Ridgewood, Queens, aplace known for its sandwiches,

extensive craft beer selection, andits gracious, friendly owner. Butfew of his customers — and likely,none of his viewers in Egypt —know that the man making eggsandwiches and small talk behindthe counter is the same one whoappears on popular Egyptian tele-vision news programs, holdingforth on subjects from immigra-tion policy to North Korea.

Nor do many know that his tele-vision studio is actually a wash-room in the back, past the potatochips display.

After a reporter approached Mr.

Making Political News in EgyptFrom a Washroom in Queens

By SARAH MASLIN NIR

Hatem El-Gamasy, owner of the Lotus Deli in Queens, where heholds forth on news topics for Egyptian television programs.

MARK ABRAMSON FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page 17

HOUSTON — It was a hardchoice, but in the end it was nochoice at all. A small rescue boathad come up the driveway, offer-ing help. Carl Ellis was with hisfrail, 73-year-old mother, WilmaJean. The boat had room for one.

The water was already up to Mr.

Ellis’s knees, so there was no timeto wait for rescuers with moreroom. His mother would have togo alone.

Using the back of a pickup truckas a gangplank, Mr. Ellis helpedhis mother into the boat, her be-longings trussed up in garbagebags. There were no life jackets,but it was a short trip and the res-cuers promised to come right

back for him.He never saw them — or his

mother — again.Any catastrophic weather

event has its measurable aspects:inches of rain, speed of wind, cubicyards of debris. Others are incal-culable: waterlogged photos,frayed communities, the invisiblemoorings of permanence andsafety swept away.

But perhaps the worst thingsare the unknowable, forever lostin the confusion, mysteries likewhat happened to Ms. Ellis, whowas rescued not once, but twice,and who nonetheless became acasualty of the storm.

At the time her son believed shewas being ferried to higherground, she was found floating

Twice Saved From Houston Floods but Still, Mysteriously, a Victim

By SHAILA DEWAN

Continued on Page 18

A surge of violence has shaken theonce-peaceful tourist destination of LosCabos, exposing stark inequality andgovernment indifference. PAGE 6

INTERNATIONAL 4-14

Murder in a Mexican Hot SpotWe expect computers to do all sorts ofthings. But as those demands test com-puter chips’ limits, engineers are takingdesign cues from the brain. PAGE 1

SUNDAY BUSINESS

Chip Off the Old BlockHillary Clinton and the actress AmericaFerrera discuss the presidential elec-tion’s emotional toll, gratitude and apath forward. Table for Three. PAGE 1

SUNDAY STYLES

Pain and Progress After 2016Todd Marinovich, a starting quarter-back in the World DevelopmentalLeague, is making a return that haslittle to do with football. PAGE 1

SPORTSSUNDAY

At 48, Finally Playing Sober

U(DF47D3)W+@!:!/!=!/

Maureen Dowd PAGE 1

SUNDAY REVIEW

Printed in Chicago $6.00

Partly cloudy. Afternoon showers orthunderstorms. Humid. Highs in themiddle 70s to the upper 80s. Show-ers or thunderstorms south tonight.Details in SportsSunday, Page 8.

National Edition