50
HI$12 $IHqAq OPIIX$LOW $IHflM HJO$1 YI4A YAJq a5IAqJaw IOU cMOIID3u IHUAH HJAMH i'll noH no2msilliW 1iH I'I .oM 13qiq nbhoW HD$1AH3$1 DIMOMOD IO UA3$ITJEI JAMOITAM unvA flwcI3aJ3M OOf 8€1O AM bhdmD QQ1 nut XHA bru qidthH 3h1mI" Ltii 3d1 ibnu b3iaIuii3 w iqiq 2ktt lo ffOi21V euoiviq A £ ln,1q3i iqiq cIi lo noiiv ln3Tw3 3dT "St113 w1!W io i113 :2iibn3a b3ilflnd vnrf I .noiiv iha, th ivo thhi&n 3di lo thbotd bn noiEivx 1thinldu mit ,soiM moT nhlloM n3do$I isM xirifl ,iH abiT4 ,,aaD 3nnA diiw noi2auoib rrioil nid3iM i tnBqi3irwq iinim briE ifkou nnIO buu$I Iirn jI3woq $1H8M rb bris qorIahoW ti,voq no d31a5I iol 3iifliinI rIi oiU n2 rn3t2wcIfloM w tioqqu thh3naniI .rwiaia d31B5I lnllx bbivoiq iiniE uD .3jurnaflI imrnu IhiijbnI iol 3iiflii2nI s1i ,in3mqo13vU di1cH blidD iol luli3nJ 1nohiM ifi mon bvi5I is$1 no flimmoD rh briE dn,2 3irnonoz3 briE niaufl iol 3iuliinI 3r11 ,noitE!$I .Ih3fl DU lB "CtotffIod&I 23ramono33 rfi d bbivoiq aaw noqqu niluqrnoD b1qx3 anoiniqo nA .a3zmono3H 3lIduq iii ms1oiq d3iaI a'Sl3flM lo lmq ai qq thIT .ia51 3hrnono33 lo us5wfl IsnoilEM di lo aor1i ion briE iorlius di lo aorii bx 01 ion ixi 10 anoiia noria .bviai aic1h hA .arroH noamEilliW yjEl H sd QQ1 © nthiJ!3ni rib31 hizil i&b bbhvoiq noiaairrri3q li3iIqx iuorbiw b3oup 3d m adqBBiBq owl .331u02 3r11 01 n,vi ai ,iion ©

$IHflM - NBER

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: $IHflM - NBER

HI$12 $IHqAq OPIIX$LOW $IHflM

HJO$1 YI4A YAJq a5IAqJaw IOU cMOIID3u IHUAH HJAMH i'll

noH no2msilliW 1iH

I'I .oM 13qiq nbhoW

HD$1AH3$1 DIMOMOD IO UA3$ITJEI JAMOITAM unvA flwcI3aJ3M OOf

8€1O AM bhdmD QQ1 nut

XHA bru qidthH 3h1mI" Ltii 3d1 ibnu b3iaIuii3 w iqiq 2ktt lo ffOi21V euoiviq A £ ln,1q3i iqiq cIi lo noiiv ln3Tw3 3dT "St113 w1!W io i113 :2iibn3a

b3ilflnd vnrf I .noiiv iha, th ivo thhi&n 3di lo thbotd bn noiEivx 1thinldu mit ,soiM moT nhlloM n3do$I isM xirifl ,iH abiT4 ,,aaD 3nnA diiw noi2auoib rrioil

nid3iM i tnBqi3irwq iinim briE ifkou nnIO buu$I Iirn jI3woq $1H8M rb bris qorIahoW ti,voq no d31a5I iol 3iifliinI rIi oiU n2 rn3t2wcIfloM w tioqqu thh3naniI .rwiaia d31B5I lnllx bbivoiq iiniE uD .3jurnaflI imrnu

IhiijbnI iol 3iiflii2nI s1i ,in3mqo13vU di1cH blidD iol luli3nJ 1nohiM ifi mon bvi5I is$1 no flimmoD rh briE dn,2 3irnonoz3 briE niaufl iol 3iuliinI 3r11 ,noitE!$I .Ih3fl DU lB "CtotffIod&I 23ramono33 rfi d bbivoiq aaw noqqu niluqrnoD b1qx3 anoiniqo nA .a3zmono3H 3lIduq iii ms1oiq d3iaI a'Sl3flM lo lmq ai qq thIT

.ia51 3hrnono33 lo us5wfl IsnoilEM di lo aor1i ion briE iorlius di lo aorii

bx 01 ion ixi 10 anoiia noria .bviai aic1h hA .arroH noamEilliW yjEl H sd QQ1 © nthiJ!3ni rib31 hizil i&b bbhvoiq noiaairrri3q li3iIqx iuorbiw b3oup 3d m adqBBiBq owl

.331u02 3r11 01 n,vi ai ,iion ©

Page 2: $IHflM - NBER

nbhoW 5IHT4 .QQI nut

31O$I YMA yAJq 3$LAJE1W IOU 2MOI2IDHU 1TH2cJAJH 1JAM31 MI

TDA$ITIIA

b3iinU dr ni aiIirnz1 A3s1d bna 3iirIw 10 noi1ioqmo3 r1i ic tiirIi i2J1 rli nhziU

31w nib1idz ffiiw iIim1 lo rntq nr n&b a! OôI nI .1th3ii&ru1b bnith id iir nibliuI3 djiw i1irna1 10 rn3JI3q inwJ ncdi iom OQQI iii Iidw rfiom 1nia i cJ bbd

2.U 3d3 lo 31oi ñr no bu3o1 d d311 10 bod 1BI A .ab1orbuorf bbd Lr3m1 5I3 minoiq (DUIA) nib1idD 1nbnq3cI diiw iIim3 oi biA rD 11u3 nBq ni bn m3i 1!w

1Rno1i33a-ao13 u thui 3oM .3w13trd s1imit ni nBr13 3ziEmBlb di or niiudhino3 ni

rIi ni noirFisv 3ir21rni duoirb qirtb3r1 thm3l no u11w lo raTh th Thnbi bn £ib 3d1 no rsqmi ju3I a srt zi11 rar iol nillotino uufi bnfl ii inz5I .mao1q DUIA

1oi rii nrram3 io1 l3flam r311 31ai 'dw nimx qaq irIT .r1h rufflw bruni baa 1113 Isubivibni lo 3nafloqrrü rfi ninimax d noiib qiffbarI Iscn1 ni iauIw lo

nocIioqfno3 fj iarIi zi 13fl&n r11 iai dw iol noiisnaLqx3 Isiuran A .iinobn iIoq 3rb lo ii2on &1i or b31aIi i noili2oqrno3 3rD baa dflib ia1 3rD otn noiraluqoq 3rD lo

3rD 3varI bIuorf arz,11 Iaubivibni ioI nilloi3no3 n3rD rrii i isili II .rnioiq 3is113w '3ial b3nimax3 ai 3iIoq DHA lo sri3agobn3 3rD ,bnoo .a113 isi io1 ni1fo1ino3 a i1ui

work 2i1u1 3rIT .'rioi3ng 51a113w 1ai b laanirrrI3l3b 3rD niin3Iq31 21oflno nibuL3ni 'd 03 iudFiino 51a113w 3ad1 n3biv3 on ai 313r11 &1b 1aubivibni ioI nh11oiino3 i311a rarli

irjgj .bs1d io 3if1w i3r11i3 iol th1odzuod b3ba3d 31sm31 rmol 03 2in3qoiq ni2B3i3ni

3(11 if! aid biawqu n.s 01 baI 13sId noma noiiaiirn b33ubni-5w113w rsrli 33u iLui 3(11

.ibuia woiviq ni i1h 31B1I3w b3lamiie3

3noH nornai1!iW vialiH imono 1o tn3mtIsq3U

O88Ei lisH nav Qt aimoIiIcD 10 3ki3vinU O88€-VOVQ A i1i3a

5B81 baa

Page 3: $IHflM - NBER

pvc ppcL bLobcu? to pg booLpcsq OL ponpoq z.c wot.c bt.ouc o boicz.O tpu tpoc Mpo m5u.) uq qm CACU q tpcA pq wmq tpGA mA

1ouc ponjq pg cicpij rn 1uiethLcuu ji i;ut cnjj? umA pg rpt tpo ouiu i#po pccowc uJj

jpc2c ILGUq2 JrnAc eqwnjsreq s jsLc poqA 04, LG2GSLCJI cxbIoLlu qic boieuqs cxbJsust!o112 tOt.

pLqf suq pecowe pcsq o JI0ff2CJJ0f qJCW2G4AG2 (CI'SIJSpSU rogg)1

1I GW51G pcsqcq JJOfl2GPOj2 SLC WOLC J!1CCjA to qLob 0(14 01. P!P 2Cp0OJ pSAG 511 Ofl( 01. MGJOCJC

JJJGLG 2 cqeucc (JJS( qIc2G 4LGU2 SLG PG!1I us1I2w!ucq (PL0f1JJ G11GL5(JO1J2 S2 4GWSJG cpJqLcu Ls2eq

jIM0Oq 1o2Q) suq ql2bLoboLqous(GJA LcbLc2cIucq Swou (PC bCL221GUqA booi. (Dnucmf

boot. 1 s i,cu Aest. pm (PeA st.c 3120 WOLC jqccjA to psic j0UL 2bcJJ2 o b0ACLA (RUG suq

(JIG 4GLW (JIG 4,tGUI!U!S4!OU 01. boAcJ.A1, j4Ot ouiA twi JJGSq2 o ponepojq WOLG jqcejA 0 pe

qibt.oboi.tioustc LGbLG2GIJ(SPOU 04 1.CWSIG pcsqeq }JOf12CJJOJ2 S1JJOU (JiG booL bobnjsqou Ji32 jcq to

P11. O4 5JJ 1.SIJJII!C2 !U bOACL4A SLC UOM scconutcq tOL pA tGUISIG pcsqcq p0fl2cp0Jq2 IP!2

coWbsLGq (0 (JiG L9(G °1. 3WOU 4MO-b9LGU( 1.SW!I!C2 (n2 9fILGSfI 01. (JIG CGU2(12 JooiP) OAL

bsicu tsuJ!!1e2 Ju IôôO' (PC boAGLA L3(G 3UIO1J 1.CWSJC pcsqcq pon2cpolq2 M4JJ CpJqLeu M92 4

COIJCGW 12 CCSfl2G (JIG GCOUOJJJJC IAGJJ-pG!1J 01. 2!1JJG b9Le1u 43W1J!G2 !2 (Ab!CSJJA GJOM (JJS( 04 (MO-

OUG LCS2OU PApA (p12 !UCLCS2G ! (JIG bCLCCU4SG 04 1.8W!1!G2 pcsqeq pA 2!UtG MOWCU 12 04

HOA2G 01. J{GbLC2GUW(IAG2' J5)

SIJq MJJJ(G2 1 4JIJJA uAo-(pjLq2 01. SJJ P!(P 3UJ0U PISCJC2 MGLG (0 n1JuIsLLcq WO(JIGL2 (fj

PCCU !P1G 1UCLGS2G2 1" (PG UITWPCL 01.0(1401. MCJ0CJC P!L4P2 suq 1CGU5G bLGusuclc2 swou pjscjc2

pJSCJC t3UJ!J1G2 5J(JIOI1JI (JIG WCLGSG 91J101J PIC1C 1.3W!J!G2 JJS2 pecu WOLG qLswsqc JJJGLC AG 3J20

pOrl2CJJoJq2 (fl2 BflLGSfl 01. (PG CGU2fl2 JÔQJ ToJY jJJG2G (LCIJq2 SLG COUJWOU to poqi MpJ(G suq

W04JICL Millie ! Jt,) WOLC (p311 VAcUA bct.ccu 01. 1.3W!I!G2 M!W CIJ!JqLGU MGLG 1.GWS!C psqeq

qt.surnqcsA' pi JG22 tpsu tcu bct.cu 01. 1.SW!11G2 M!IJJ cpuIqLGu MGLG PC511CCI pA 2!U!G

DnL!U (JIG J2( (p11-A Ac81.2 (PC COWbO2IflOU 01. 1.SUJII!C2 !' (PG flhI(C 2WtC2 Ji32 cpsucq

F u1LoqIIc4oH

Page 4: $IHflM - NBER

2.U rb lo Ioi rti no bau3O1 asti rI31sa5I d3 to II3LJM .1u33zr13a (Iims1 ni 2(15113 gni)trna arft

(DQIA) riibIit1D rnbnq3U riliw aiIfms1 or biA rIT .anoiai3b 1zfl31nia 1ims1 no mia'a isIbw

suit ni srifidii1 bns n1bliuI3 rhiw arnisq 3tni2 or Iiismhq aifInd rfas abivoiq msioiq

Its nojiibbs nI .abv3I ras wol bits 3mo3ni wol diod (111w aitims1 320th 01 b13hi231 si msioiq

.arrIsgo1q bis3ib3m bns qmsra bool 3111 rfuoic1i arihn3d vii or 3tdigil3 is ainsqi3thsq DUA

2.U r1r rsih b3u1s 2111 ,a3iIimsI rn3lBq-owr or 3ldslisvs ron s1Is13ng is aifl3n3d 323111 32U533

3Iqrnsx3 iol) 3psinsm31 bits 3asinsm lo 's13b dr bits noiislsq32 iovib 23S1IJO3I13 m312'2 515113W

absb owl last r1l ivo qidabs3rl 31sm1 111 32s313n1 rIi iol anoitsnstqx3 irfiO .(18Q1 sriuM

rlguoith (asnslsdmi olisi a ü niiIu231) n3m 3Ids3sinsm lo dmijn 3111 Iii noii3ub3l 3111 3bIJI3ni

3a5313n1 di ,(ô8Q1 nsmiAV1 bns noIiW) rsi iiIsriom bris noiisl33ls3ni 4n3mo1qm3nu tIict

.n3mow bits nm nvi1d asw 3vilsbl ni ilsI 3111 bits in3mo1qrn3 31sm31 ni

3111 ol aludhino3 m,taa 315113w iuo 3n31x3 is11w or 3nim1b 01 lasi3lni 3i1Oq 10 211!

10 bbom s 21n3231q (18Q1 ,4VQ1 EXQ1) 13±,8 .abiothworl b3bsi1 315m31 lo drnun f1125513fli

bits 3biani litiiu 3(11 gnnsqmo d (qidabs3d 3fsrn1 io) gsrrisrn 3200113 nmow d313r1w 35i115ffl

3IdsIisvs tIs13n3g) aifl3n3d DCFIA 1311ir1 rsth 21 bbom airli lo noiis3itqfni ciA .3gshlsm 3bialuo

3(11 Is 132 315 aliI3rl3d DUA .qicI2bs3rI 3lsm3l lo 231s1 13rticf or bsI Itiw (3gsillsm 3bialuo i1no

lo Iims1 s io1 arfl3n3d mumixsm , !QQI ci! .231s12 220135 nobsilsv 2U01Ofl3 iidiIlx3 bits 13v3t 33532

ni O1Z bas srtsibnl ni 88Z or ru3iifmoD ni O8Z bits sinioliisD ni 'QôZ rnoil bnsi stth

(RU) 111q botqrn9nUXF:1A 3111 bnu itimI 3n3Isq-owl 3Idi8iI3 03 3IdsIisvs is 2311311311 ,233632 311102 nI

'tims1 ln3lsq-owl 3113 it ffi3Ii 3110 32631 IA .3vij3h3ai 3mm 319 aln3m31iup5l 1iIidii13 3113 ,l3v3woH .rns1o1q wod 00! 119113 310W *nthow d Ion ff63 bits ,13hsm todsi 3113 03 3n3fn1136336 3ns3flini2 i lo £ 3v611 Jaum

bsob63 3thIo ô Ino ,!QQI ni rnitotq CIU 3ih tbnu ath3a3d b3bivotq 3i3 ô hill 33i1 3113 33iq23C1 .dinom tq qu qu 332 233532 Iii isili 23tiiJp3t 88Q1 b 13A noqqu2 Iimit 3dT .mstotq 1U d3 i3bau 21113n3d 801 V13331 313w

,tthIw bits Iqqua mdii no ¶U-DU9A lo e 3111 a3nimu3 (*nimo3dflol) noH .OQQI d ainsto1q .31u33uila iiini1 no msz3oIq 9U 3111 gnibnsqx lo 33e 3113 al3biano3 (EQQI) 13131111W bus noilsqi3itIsq

113111w 3w16133i1 10 vismmua £ tol (OQQI) nstD bus boowita bus (ô8Q!) nIkflJ3M bus I3AaihsD

bu3n33 £ abivotq (8Q1) 3bs1kn3q .noihi2oqmo3 1iini1 no 233*16W mdii ni 2ns1b 10 31o1 3111 231o1qx3

.23361 tshhsin iii abni3 lo 2lnsnuIm3I3b 3111 lo W3IVI3VO

Page 5: $IHflM - NBER

JJC ILnC CcCI

COLLCS ML MCfl9LC pcucjr qicu qJc wsrcq MCJ4SLC CJC1 MJJ OACLC2I!wSm (nuqCLcwsiC)

CWSC2 LOW qJCC ?U7q1C2 MIll PC P!F li IpC ntnicscq C1? SIC bO2!ACJA (uicj?)

MCJSLC CLCI2 OLWSJIA' MCftSLC PCUC4JI2 SIC COLLCSLC M!fJJ (ILJWC2flL L'S1C iu1qc

pcsqq ponpojq p s cLo2-cc1ou9J rnq?t Thn cmJ uO !qUQ poqi is jpq GjCl2 suq

12 WOLC scccbpu o uou-rLsqtpouSJ jSuJ!!? 2UJICWLC2 WS? SAOL S pJpCL jicj o, 2nbbou oi. i,cwsj

wsA uoi psic wncp 2nbboL jpL viic bLoLSw suq PCUCC OUCL J0M PCIJCLI2 OL S 2151t MIJ!CIJ

EOL cx9wbjG j qic bobnjsqou pJ s icu siS pCpC/c ou u ipc v#o-bsiu SW!J? 1:IJC

1pd113 sbbspu o isuqsLq owuq ASLISpJC pise SL11WCIU2 qic MCJSLC PCUCIJt C44CCI MIJJ C P!S2W

BSUC (ioa)' iPC2G JStCJA flUO2CLJSJC !UUflCU2 SIC COLLCJS1C M!IIJ iPG 2WiC MCJ4SLC PCUC4JI

2ILflCUILC CCi2iOU2 SIJq SIC JSICJ? I1UOP2CLASPIC jO fiG LC2CSLCpGL V C11C(l pA EJjMoo suq

U0LW2 CITIWLSI CIJC suq LCJ!OII !UUnCIJCC2 SIC 1!ICCIA o bjsA u !Wb0I45IJ LOJC Hi SUJA

JJJCLC SIC flJLGC LCS2OIJ2 MpA fiG MCLC CtCC L0W fJG2C 2wqC2 uiA G P!CW h!L2r 20C!SJ

JÔÔO HOlIWSU C SJ jJ 2CIJnIS' JÔÔf M!1JflCL J3)

ou qic bLobcuA O OLW 1,GWSJC lJcSqGq Of12GOJ2 (DSUSiCL Ct SI J83 EIIMOOq Sixi BUC

OLC LCCCUL CAGUCG !UJbllC2 fiSt fiG MCJSLG 2A2iGW P2 b02!f AC siiq 211!UCSIU Act woqct cicct

qic csqA IIGLSU1LG ionuq iU2!IJ!4jCSUL CJCL2 O, fiG MGJSLC aAtCW ou suJ!iA 2S!C[liLC

OfJGL 2LStG CPSLSCGL!2fC2 JJJG LC2flJI2 tLOW tlJ!2 LG2GSLCJJ SIC WXG V2 2flhiJUJSI!C1 iJ QLOCLJCAGJ

S jCWSJC pGSq2b CdflSfOU 52 5 JJTUCfOU O uqAqn5J Cp5LSCtCLi2PC2 PCUG1Ji2 suq lu 20WC 2wqG2

4CWSJC pGSq2pb y2 LCAICMGq !11 OjjU (j W02t 2tflfG2 nc cLo22-SGcpousl qsw suq G2PWStC

JJJI2 !UtL2WiG ASLiStiOU LU pCUC12 OLUJ2 fIG 522 OL C2qUJSqU fIG C1JCCL O VLDC OU

!1 LCJStIACJA JOM PCUCIJt t2

VEDC PCUCW2 tGLCOLG ponjq pG WOLC IJIcCIA £0 CJJOO2C 4GWSJG pCsq2JJJb IJJCU MOWCIJ MJJO JJAC

AT22!22ibbI (n HOC 01 KGbLG2C1Jt5tIAG2 /JOWCU MJJO HAG H' 2SjC2 MIfJ LCJStIAGJA pip

-1-

Page 6: $IHflM - NBER

qic bojcA qtcunimqou dnqowipc qicct o(bol!cA on orncow in bz.cpcc tpcA tjuq t qcnt to nq ooq !utu1wcui2 LOL qcu1Qun8coucjtcq iiqJ rpc CLLOL u ipc pq2JIjb cdn ow jpcA bLoboc U !U2IUIIIICUWI AV1JJ2 bbLocp 10 ctumqiicornLojpu LOL opuspjc qctcuupmut L boI!c? umA not pc vtujccug uc nuopcupjc qctciwuug wA pcnqq woq u pc fltwLC (% xcq qcci moqcj qLc cc-!u-llLt11c; woqcj jpA bong ont qrt

4BC21CA SIXI C2C (Io4) CLAC iic P!2 qmc i.ctqi iom ouiqu qic boj!cA GtCUUUUt2 rnJqGL 2CACLj

v wq bLopJcui j ip !wboLNucc O4 owucq qcct jJJGL !Wb0UIU

C2tUI2 14 tPC VEDC GJCt4

CU!IJ A4PJC2 LC LC1G to i,curnjc pqpb tPCU OWUIJ WC L!PjC WA jo jcq to picq

ucoth0Lq lu tpc cuibiL!cI I!tLtnLc ou qic clct o MJiLC ou LuJ!IA tuictru. i qscc boiicA

(DI.!tA uq jAL blopilcic uq f!u1cL2 uq jou JoP) tpcA pvc uot pcu

to tpc IwboLtmic o bopcA ipijc tpc qtI.wumu2 o VEDC CIij12 pc pu XUJHJGq

qujJuut LC Ljtq tO tjJC ALJC 14 U1CLC21 1JJL 0W122!OU CIJ jq to CLLOUGOfl COUCJ(1210U2

pA bojiqcj mJq ccououiic couqwou2e suq AOIGL bLLcucc jpcA Inc tpst II, tp boj!cA

tp cxmiibj o MoLJccL1 cowbcut!ou pcucijt cxbjoLc Ipc bo!p!I!tA qrnt bojicA

v ccouq botuqsj bLopjcw j tp cuqocuctA oi boj!cA BICA uq c (ioo*Y

UJUL

U!UCIJt to Ut!1 miq IUtCLC2t!U1A JOL J9CjC MOWGU qJ 2[1 qict qiq UOt

NO1jjU ijuq tjrnt qq!u C1GCi2 CpIJC2 1}JC PCUGIJI OL MIJ!1 MOWGU LOW bo2!t!Ac 9Uq

H ! PJC to qutQ poqi pA booJ!u GACLJ CLO-Ct1OU () 1G C11LtUt b0bflJP0U 2nLAA

woqcj o, cwsjc pcqpb nu wic ccctz coup.oJ tOL vjtcAL!St0U !I3 pcucut qICA C2t!W!t pcuct JCI MpJC C0U1LoI!!U LOL cctv (jooi)

jcjpooq 14 LCCAU VEDC PCUCW !. !"J bcuqiooq C0W BA CLGU !ut-2t

wt' M1LC pcucjt (Iu2tcq o wbjA iici.c pcucut2) pA qnqu tp pcuijt 4OL tpc

spont tPC !WbCt o McRi.c ou urnjc pcqe1b EflMOO uq B1JG (J) ucnq u ojMO 2tnqic bLoAIq qjt IUOLIU jtG CJC12 cvii jq to IUCOLLGCI coucjniou

Page 7: $IHflM - NBER

--

qirfbd tsm1 bns gsinsm a d3u , ioibb noiii2oqmo3 1im IBubivibni b ansrIirrrI3ib

btlrIo3 d ym bflimo th i&ii Idiaaoq i II .iifnsei iIi d brido iOn 51S 113111W

ni ilui bluow ii1T ivo noiisigim bi1 rfguoub aiiIn3d DUA lo ii2o13n3 fi3 riliw

r1i oi iqi rfiiw noiisluqoq r1i lo noiiudili2ib r1i bn 13v1 iitnd iThw nviid noilBI5llO3

.iuiii1 ,11i ni bnifnsx3 ncJ ion sd irfT .bd ,Iami £ d 01 iianqo1q

r1i iii id £ 03 b1 m i3113 it gniiiiino 3&11 inioq gnin&r s A1 bIn2 ii1T

io iJiim ai1h fIw 1o1qx3 I .noiib qir1abi1 1smt no DUIA lo iI1 biEmit

IEubivibni b anErioqmi rti grünimsx d 2noibb qirkbsd 31m1 ni w1bw lo 31o1 di rxiismi

lEdi i inam i31h sx r1w iol noii&rs1qx fsiin&i A .iinobn, ai1oq bns a3311

1iao13n ,di at b3Eb1 i noiiioqrno3 r1i bns iThb 3s3 ,di oi noii1uqoq f1ilo noirroqmo3

10 gsivs mo i ir1i ru i311 iE3 r1i lo noiiaiiqiini r1T ms1o1q i1bw i1e 1i lo

th vsd b1uor1 ai1h Isubivibni iol nu11o,iruo3 nr1i u-rt i 3511311 .noiisluqoq au bo abifliJis rIi

bnirnsx ai 3iIoq D(FIA lo iinobn r1i ,bno3 .ai311 i&t lol nu1101inO3 as ituai msa

mo-il sisb air1j ob oT .iiaoin is1bw 3isialo a3nsnimbb 11i niina1q1 aIOllfIo3 nibu13ni d qir(absr1 1sm1 lo Ibom a ,iamiia 03 beau ai (UI) aimsn'U rno3nI b bui bnsI ii M31b is 1sia rti1o a3iiai1t3s1ar13 nsmow r1i1o a3riai1i3a1su13 aifln3d 5is11w iol gnilloiinoo

a lo n0ii53i1iif1bt rti iol awolla stab Ian0ii3a-aa013 b31oo .aibh 1ubivibni bns M3311 isia

emit -ivo anoa-iq no anoiisviado bisqi nivsr1 d ,sisb 1ns'1 .i11 rs3a £ bna i3lb is1bw

.auzb1 Isubivibni bns ista ,ig1bw 10 nons3ihjnbi r13 iol 2woIIZ

3rJsmslb a asd i1h Isubivibni biuas,mnu iol ni11o1ino3 1qmi aia1sns 3113 lo ai1uai 311T

i113 is1Iw b3tamiia 311.1 ni asid 3rIT .31u331r132 Iims1 iii 315113w lo 31o1 di lo 23ismr.1a3 no 333113

-iol ni1foiiruoz l3fiA .ai33Ib Isijbivibni io 3si b3flimo 13113i3 01 b3iudiWs 3d flS3 a3iirlw lob

,di no a3ldshsv 3ista ir1io io aul13 b3x11 31532 13113i3 lo l3sqmi on ai 313th a3331b3 lsijbivibni

woiviq riliw in3jaiano3 lud l3flcrn au33113 Isubivibni 23a1d nomA .133113 5ts113w b31smiia3

Page 8: $IHflM - NBER

(ieY o'.u'iij uq (!oQ)QcA!GMa o4, W! J!1LUL CU pc osmq U 1 (1ô83Y BPOb (JOY M!12ou uq j,cjccuu

(i mImJL) o tpc I!iLswt ou tp cc 0LMCC ou on mcvn.c o, mqA combor!oir

C1JGCt 04 MC4,SLC 011 4,CWjG pGqpb DUS!CL ci s (j ncq qsi 4,LOW fIG CflLLGUI bob1It!ou

I!LCLUILC nau A!Ct 04 CL0-2CCf0UJ qwci JJ0M2 hJ!4jCIU uq bO2!fAG pnt woqc

cAqGuCG IIJ4 VEDC P 1U!UCIU C4,4C1 011 4,CWJG pcqp!b qGc!2!ou2Q JJJC WOLC i.cccui

2A41 OL C!t)t 1'I U1?tC JJIG LG2rIIIZ 4,LOW 1jJ2 I!iGLWLC 8LC wixcq uq ijuq uo cowbcjjiu

JJJG CJI4A 1!ICLWLC Oh fiG C4,4,GCI2 04, VEDC 011 4,CWJG pCq2pIb pcq bL!w!J? 011 wic

(Mooq miq BIJG T8? bIOIU!CJe IO DTUCII miq HOUPJ ioO)

ci jy put!ou to curnc pcqpib (cupue uq ont 04, MGOCJC cpjqpciu

LCWUG (Ho4,4,wnJ suq DI1UCJ jgg) npwJA 4,0LW0U (JJMooq 9uq 9IJG JÔg H1TICPCU

LOJC 04, MCJ4,LC 011 fiG bLoppJi) 04, qAoLCG (Ho4,4,wu uq DnUCIJ JÔÔ1 DGCJJIGLe iooY

GX!2qU CMqCUCG 011 fiG C4,4,CCI 04, MCJ4,LG bL0LUJ 011 4,CUJJG JJcq2pb OIPGL tf1qIG2 cxbIoLc fiG

111 fiG 4,UJIA 2ILflCWLG !1J fiG fl jJJG CI1LLGUI Cfl20U JJ0MGAGL !!111!1(l 10 2flUJWI4!U fiG

JJIGLG JJ2 GG1J LGI qcj 04, LG2CLC GXbJ0L!U bopic cxbjmrnpou2 4,OL fIG LGCGIJI ILCUCI

LL6A10f1 ltJq6IJC6 0114116 K016 01. VLDC 011 E6W16 H6P!b

bLoAqcq pi 2GCU0U

4 fi2Cfl2G2 fiG qw ncq Iii fiG U9IA2!2 2GCfOU bLC2GIil2 fiG LC2flIW LGULJC2 LG

011 4,GUJJG pcq2pb cctou bLGui2 fiG CC0uOW!C WOqC miq cwb!L!c91 !wbIGwcuWfow 2CCfOU

JJJC LGI 04, fiG bbGL 0L1flC 4,0fl012 2GCfOU PL!G4J LCA!CM2 fIG GX1!U I!1L9U1LG

poncpojq 4,OL G!fICL MJJ!1G2 OL P1CJ2'

G4,4,CCI2 fiGLG !2 110 G14GUCC I1JI MG4,LC COIJIL!PnIG2 10 !UC2!1J bLobGuc2 10 4,OLW 4,CU1IG pcqcq

2flG IIC G4,4,CC12 qo u0t OACL1Ie 011CC fiG WOCJGJ ! COLLGCIIA 2bGc1jcq to uqAqr1J

Page 9: $IHflM - NBER

(18Q1 Qt ,'QI) 1i3 to rroimii, baB noUsifi'nio't iit d3 bivoiq baB (2D) vjv'zu2

bn thism rtiod ni 3Idsli6vE 3mo3a1 bn agnifn &fi bismi3 '1T .noii&rrio1 1sthm 'to Ibom

d Aiow di abnrx (QQ!) 31ud32 .Dc.FIA to jn3ftirxi bnuol bns qtrkbrf 1srn1

13n33ino bniI H .auisi 13iim bn nin-i s ffw a 3ifiti1 gnifbom d .is i .I3Sld iol a31uai bxirn iom rEdwmo iud ,th1w iol qic1bsr1 1sm1 no is11w1o 11 viiioq

no i1bw 'to 311 3nsiuingi brwol o21 vsd bbom a'13ifl 'to rrrio1 bub31 no basd ibu3 noiiznift s a b6l1 1Em31 S gni3d 10 3iIidsdoiq r13 1bom 11S3!qi eibu3 ar1T .qhkbsd 3ISm1

affi us8 .(QQ! ,bLniW ;sOQQI flitIoM) iiiisisb 3s1a bits ,a3iin3i3s1sr13 lsubivibni to

th i31b 5ts'tIw 11i 33smi13 03 a3it3n3d 5s'tIw 13 iii noi3shsv 3isja-ao,3 no aibuia

bits aiith Isubivibiti bits wsi 'to noiaiino ot ub sid 'to 3iuOa 351(13 3111 molt 1311u 03 b1i1

lil3n3cf rft (111w b3tsIsrio3 sis J't1 31darn&Ionu e3th II .noiisnimib '3i1oq 101 Io1iflo3

315113w b3tsmi3 311i ni sid s d 111w 513111 ,atn3mugzs 3ldshsv b3flimo bisbnsi riiw nd3 3tdshsv

V

Isfil aibu1a w3't 3rIT .zi1t 335ia rtinimo 'to 33nsrloqmi rf3 nini33no3 33n3biv3 ai 313rtT

bismija 3(13 no a113 lns3i1ingi worl zn3uflni tsl b3lIJas3mnu ,o1 t3sno3 03 b1qmns 3vsd

3113 ni asid lsiin3toq th 'to uaai di aisi ot iaifl di 313w (8X) 31158 bits boowll3 .333113 315113w

'to boor1i1Ai1 3111 d noiislip3 qiiiabsd 3113 itI a3113113d sts'tbw b3raulbs dT .3ismita 315113w

3113n311 3113 th noiithsv 33532-513n1 b335513 aii'JT .n3aoII3 asw qiulabs3rl Ii DCIIA ni nuisqi3iflsq

nsm b3l3bianoz rb IiEIW 8a3't't3 bcxft tzta 33smi3a 03 1113(13 b3wolls nd3 113111W 3ldsilsv

as d3ua amo33uo itho 1dahsv moiuo 3d3 as aoiabb qidabad 1am't ib no aau3o1 iqaq azli 1ii1W mitT .how3mfit msa aith ni b3s15aa ad vsi1 asniq sa3 adnid bo1bw 'to mo ,nobaisqa ,iovib

.ibua aod3 03 Lqqa oals 331't3 3fi3113d b3wiiia 5d3 si asid Iaila3loq ib luoda arn3almo3 gniwoliol 1aw31 Ha iøl noilsup3 noimaqbinsq D(FLA as b3iamuia3 '(edT .31ubo1q qa owl a b3w nafl baa boowll38

ani1idsdoiq nOuaqi3Inaq 33 b3lq 03 b35u 1W flOilsUp3 I&th mon 2l5UIbZ 3dT .lqffls2 d3 iii blothauod 'to aba3d tti!" ibiw bs!q31 113d3 al noimsup qiñabsd 315m31 di 111 1dhav 3iIa3d 3dT .(qmsa 3d3 ni n&now !i oI Iqma £ flO 231131 bodl3m aith zus8 .tliidsdoiq aoilsqi3iflsq b3iamila3 3d3 d 23113n3d 3niLqi3tum d alft3fl3d

goiab3b aouaqi3ItIEq 3113 1133 W13d 2110 135131103 flS 333't13 IIoilsql3lnsq 3111 3lami3a o3 b1odauod 'to abs3d 31ami 'to 3153111 1qmsx3 io1 .e3imi1idsdoIq noimsqi3insq b3tcmi3a ,dm 111 asic! a msi bluo3 noiabb qli1absd 318m31 baa

Page 10: $IHflM - NBER

-8-

vsd oi bituol sw tslI3w (nhsdblihf3 iootbw-1o-iuo qir!bsrI 1srnl novib) 1dsiisv rnoWo

is inwi ivo u (4QQ1) nifloM .finbnqbni gaivif lo iIidsdoiq rh no i11 gtsI di qirtbsi1 Isml s ismhs 03 vviu nobsIuqo 1ninuD 3th moil stsb !snoii-ot bfooq lo

oi baud! asw ailb ts3s kIsiuasmnu iol gnillotflioD .31b 3s3s mobnsi bits b,xft tfiiw fbom

irIT .bsfd iol 331I 5I5uIw bL3ismiis d3 aa13ni lud 1idw iol is1bw lo 1oi dt riainimib

.2333113 Isijbivibni lo xis3'Ioqmi 3d3 10 noiisnirrlsx3 ns n33d ion 25(1

3(13 nimsx (dOQQt) flilloM bits (8Q1) 21iniW bits L3imo1q (€8Qt)21M bits iiisU

13v31-31512 lo ainsninrI3i3b 3113 ibinoi (8Q1) ei3niW bits f3inioIq .23113n3d D(HA lo a3ctsninrib

3mo3ni siiqs3 13q l3rfgid (131w 23ri2 (131w bisiaos is aiit3rt3d iiiirt isrli bail bits aiit3rI3d D(FIA

3smm311f 10 Ivf l3wof rzi nq1331 315113w irtii1 noiisluqoq iooq 11i lo 'iiEn3b 13did

bbom wons31umi2 s l3biaao3 21M bits yiiisQ .a13v31 qrns3 bool l3wot bits 2in3iqi331 noms

bail 'riT .eu 3di iol slsb i-i 3mb Isurms niw noiisnimib iit3n3d bits qirI2bs3fI 315m31 lo

.isi gsiiism 33r13uflrn 3011 ob DU1A ,aift3nd lo 1i3n3gobn3 r1i iol rtiI1o1ino3 if1s isiti

i1ir1 rliiw b3Jsi3oas 31103 alfI3n3d qmai bool l3woI bits 3mo3ni 33B12 13r1id bnuol (dOQQI) flhtloM

01.afl3n3d DQIA

qhIthsH elam,1 bus D(NA lo I9boII1 Iitriiqw3 nA .E

EVQI) 11338 d b3qobv3b 25 noiiuloaaib bits aobsmiol lsthsmlo Isin3msbrnJl ,rIT

.I3bom 2111 lo noiiv moa rliiw nigd nolisirriol '1ims1 lo ibuta ls3iliqm3 32Gm bits (18Q! 1VQ1

aimoao33 3111 it3dw sinsm ood3 111w nsmow s iazIi nobi2oqolq 3113 110 b325d 21 I3bom 2'131z

111w bothem aith ndi anosi Ickiuzswnu tol DCI9A iii isqbin&q bliI iom s b1odwoi1 lo bsd .nmow bthssn tol abi1idNdo1q floiisqi3insq th 1smi323vo

D(NA d3 ml zin3muil2ni ns 3s3ibai ion bib sfi 33ui2 DUIA lo ailb di 'Thnbi tb wod 1513 Ion ai lI .oiist noiisluqoq bits 231st 3n3fno1qrn3nu 315 qiikbsd s1in1 tol arn3fnLmani 3dT .noiisup3 noiisnkln3i3b

l3bizno3 (QQ1) bus 1H .enoiis3iIqqs 13db ni baimsx3 nd 3vsd abi1oq ts to 1i3nobn 3dT i3biano3 (ô8Q1) niqioW bus gi3wsno$I mo3Iuo iAtw todsi no ailbn3d noha2n3qmo3 thow lo 333113 3db

03 bnoqt 1sI2 wod at9bieno3 (lQQ1) £th3Jo bus ,23m033uo thIs3d no asns1otq 9ninnslq '(limsi 10 333113 3db .zith3 15321110 abOfl3q

Page 11: $IHflM - NBER

ioth iH .sinsm bi2iuo alirI3d 3imono rb bx gshisrn bi2ni ('OiIilu io) aiitnd

isifT .2im1sq di nwid fbi si1sbq2 ai irfJ Ii wosirisvbs hsfu3il1sq i sinsm isdl i1qmi

.noii3ubolq mod ni iIsb3q2 iifio ifi liuiw *iow i*ism ni i1si3q intIsq 300 ,ai

iliw uoq fsLln3)oq 3r11 lo asw 10 2nifns3 3r13 ni a325313r1i rsifi 315 I3bOm aith lo r!oiis3i1qm!

rf3ua) siiism 3biajuo 3fdslisvs aiiI3n3d ns iii a3a5313r11 31111w sinam lo ii1idsdoiq 3111 3a551311i

worl2 bbom 1L33fl lo noianix3 .gsirism lo ii1idsc1o1q di 3sib Iliw (2iitn3d 3151bw 25

.gsi11sm lo ii1idsdoiq 3113 110 133113 2.1JoUi&flS 116 3V&1 1153 3SW a'iismow i1i (ii 325313ff! (15 15113

£ 3V5f1 1153 113111W 3mo3ni 1ims1 232531311! nsmow fü lo gninis lii asini its bnsrt 3(10 nO

moil n3brf3q3bni aarili3s1 oals aninis lii 325313ni airll fl.i8 .gsirtsm 1i no 311 nixi1ids3a

owl 323111 ol 13131 (VQ1) ItirIws bris aao$1 11.sirism lii as,ib £ ol b531 ns rk)i(1w ,bnscfaud 3(13

a133113 33n3bn3q3bni bits 3m0311i 3111 25 2333113

315m31 lo 3310ff 3 31321b 111 lo 1nBr1hmni3b 3(13 iebiano 13bom a'13A338 1o lniqz 3111 a!

,floii3IlIil 1ili1u 311T .35iTtSm 2U213V qid2bsIf

(I)

3SlT1S 10 (\=W) qirIabs3s1 315m31 gniaoorl3 iftiw b3isboaas 3i1iiu mumixsm r1i 23n3231q31

c1 ?w gsw ansmow 3(13 to noii3rnñ £ i si11sm riliw b3jsi3oaas i1i1u mumixsM .(O=Wt)

gfliaOOl13 it! .X ,23112i1313515113 ansmow 3113 bits ,1 1it3n3d 315113w "W sw awoqa 1siiit3oq

03 as anisg lud 1{ asw auoqa fsitn3oq di 03 233S ao1 nsmow ft ,qil12b5311 31sm31

ihsm iods! anmow 3ai293iUi to nobs3ifqmi nism d3 as 3fl 3fIbn(pbni di no 23211301 tb3811 111w thitlw bub is noiisth!siqa 03 anise 3d3 3s113 a3ilqmi nsmow 3d3 to aninis, lii 3asini nA .a3ilixwnoqqo

.shism lo 3ilidsdo1q ,di no bsqmi 3vi3gn 3v511

Page 12: $IHflM - NBER

-0!-

.iiliiu i2f1iIf f1i illiw 363 fIi 3OOf13 rrfi asmow fT .% ,ii1ncf 1B1fw

rfi nth owl rfj nv,id iiliiu Ismix&n rii ni n13Thb c1i s bnithb i II

:oi nsdl i W1 11 qirI2bsd tsmI aoorI3 ndi nmow

(X0"W,WO)U - (XL0,W,i)'3 =

() <*qj I iwiIio 0 J

01 bn w gEir1Km io qirfabcf 32OOd3 nmow £ lErfi 3ilididoiq th iaIv 01 ib-io a!

iath i 1tu3iflib rfi ,vwoH .Ew woqa Iiin3oq 10 woq irI bna gw 'namow fb womi

'Lno w bns (nbhow al uoq di baa) birwm ai n&now di Ii aw woq £ vdo 1no w namow sth 1o noii3rnft a sia sgaw lath muaas w 11 .ni*iow i srI 'ti zw riamow a sviado

iidi d Idsiwv aw rhod a1qi t1S3 w nsth (i) 1dahsv i4iam ,odal bns (X) 23112i1313a1a1b

irris uoq tthinroq iscl bits namow th lo aairns lo i1h th s'ioIisdT .inanimib

ion fl53 Ibom rrriol bijbsi ii1j moil 3Jiii r1i ,IidW .insnim,b ,irfi dijoirfi 1ii3i1qmi

thiw asiliuia1 oj biA sib isbau iftsasd tha sbuL3ai zsiliuzal ioI msia stitbw .2.IJ sift lo thsasd thauz sdT1 smo a! .rnaioiq biaibsM baa aqma boo'I sib duoub 2lftsnsd bniA-ni baa inaio1 nsibfiiD lnsbnsqsU

21111 sAi II 1w noilslnsmslqmi 1ahiqins sib sfi11W .si1imI lnsiaq-owl ol sldaliavs sia 3ftsfisd ssdi 2s3aa32mu31i3 1no stdahava sia alilsnsd 3a111 3i3l1qmi2 ioI 5fU1J?2 Iliw aOi2ZU32ib 113135105113 21113 lb isbaiatnsi 5(11 3flUO33a olni

.2lsdiom 513fli2 03

latham lo Isborn 3n1an(b A .bohsq ibas bs3wlsvs-s't i tithu sf13 sistlw sgainam lo Isbom 3iqom a 2i th1T .siuiaisiil sib iii bsqobvsb 5(1 o3 3s ead lud noi2fl53Xs batfl*n £ 21 Lsbom ibiasa a no bsad auiai

'41 baa '-'R diod ,aio3t tsham iodal 10 saa3ioqmi 5113 nininnsisb iii bsmsisini i sno Ii ,1svbsn1s31AM to sIqma2 sill no bsasd noilaups saw a s3&mitas 03 21 s'iuigisiil sf11 in bsw daao'zqqa silT .bsismiias sd 03 bssa

nsmow lo sfqmaa süin sib iol sgaw 'sauoqa 1311mg 0, aslaiufias saoift san 03 baa aswow bsinain Io asauoqa ot bsau asishavo3 sdT .(IQQ! 1a Is naaffloH ;OQQ! ,nauffloH baa na3auC[ ;'QQ1 ,31ud32 ;8Q1 ,ls Is isimaQ)

anknas a11amiia .asldthav tsiiam iodal Laaol baa sliw sf13 'to 23132fl51311Sd3 sbubni noiiaups saw sib samiias saoib ol sauoqa lo saw sf13 svisado hio sW .3i3&wsIdoiq sd aa ,vswod ,sisla flaal-tslnuo3 sill ni 51110301 o

sili ls11a oala (13111W qiilabasd slamsl 335111 tath 2103311 sldavisedoau sia s'isdj 11 baa bsinam sia oriw nsmow sLqmsxs iol .asiamitas sgaw sift lol aslamrlas bsasid b1si 111w boibsin antI usd1 ,szuoqa taiinsioq sub lo animas

slamsi iol asaw a'sauoq2 slam iasisvo 111w sw nsib asfthnmoqqo sainam iszl3isl svazl bsinam sta oxlw nsrnow Ii niiainiias 2sliIIpSl 2Jnsnoqmo3 sldavisadoau sib ni uoiiclsn03 21113 iol gniinuoa tkñ sIhfW .bloilsaiaodlo 2basll

.(OQQI namuloH baa n&3auU ;IQQ1 i1ud3) bsau nssd aazl bodlsun aoiiamilas sa1a owl a bbom auosaallunna a

Page 13: $IHflM - NBER

cqcsiq bLosw2iu (PC wb!uc LC211J(2 2 1nnLCq pA (PC couJpuCq PCIJCLJI2 tLOfl (P VEDC ooq wba uq

!O yOjju I4' M!UJCICL IY,Lpz LCqnCq owi vbbLocp p p;u nzq pcdn;uqA pc I!(CLWLC (EnMoocl IJcI BSUC NOWt(a

S22f1UJG jO pc GLLOL2 ACSL GGCI2 SLC ucnqcq O CSbUILG mJA COWUJOU 11C11q2 !U 20C!SJ UOLUJ2

/#4JGLG qic SLG Asi CJGC J SIC 2WIC IJXGq GjGCI2 & SLC uqAqnSJ GIGCL siiq (PC c' SIC

= + + & + g + ()

JJJC GLLOL ! 2bGCCq S2

msc obboLuTuiiiC23 SIC CSbnLCq pA

blo&Sw 12 UO Ou bSI Mp (PG 2!iJJG WOJGL2 bLoLSw SPOL UJSLJCC ASL!SP1C2 MJJ!CJJ COIULOJ tOL

pG qnccq HOMGAGLe (PC GJ!p(PtA LflJC2 SIC WOLC LC !CPAG OL fib W!J!C2 SIJ(J i]J(12 (PG

Monjq CXbGC (PSi pA OtGL!U fib PCUCW (PC GCOIJOWIC S!U O CIJ S tGWSIG pCSq 04 0fl?GOJ

SIC SAS!I9piC U) C1!!PiG jMO-bSLCIJ4 1SW!IC2 qiionp (C VEDC-flb bLoLmir vii CI2G Gdnj MG

PGIJGW2 SIC cxbcc(Cq 40 !UCLCS2C (PG bLopsp!1!A 04 GUISIC p;Sq2pb J sporu pSJ, (PC 245(G2a PC1JGQI2

MC4pGL 2451C 2 o4jcLGq VEDC CIJC4J12 U) 4li0-bSLCU 4WII!G2 !U bCL0q . (ç\1.jz). JQ HJPCL MGI4SLC

csbwtcq qaonp iito ASL!Spic2: si 1CAGI VEDC CUGIjL ('f) suq s qnwwA ASL!SPIG uqcqu

MPCLC (PC 2flp2CL!b12 •2 coLLC2bouq 10 uqiqns !U boq t IAIU 111 245[C V fiCi4LC PGUG4JI2 SIC

= O +gT +gçi +1y +ç + (1,)

qCLcuCG ! fl4!I!(A pGcOWG2

v2enw!u S I!UCSI 4PUJJ t0L (PG !uq!LG1 flqi!A 4fIUCI!OU suq !qqU SU CLLOL LGLUJ3 (PC

G4AGCISI?

SIC SbbLObL!S4G 40 CXbIOLC (PC LOJG 04, MCI4SLC PCIJG4JI2 !U (PC bLG2Gucc 04 LC!0USJ OL 245(C

pG fl2C 40 G4CLWUJC (PC !WbOL49U 04 CJJSUG U (PC CUJbJOAWGIJI mq GSUJ!U2 04 UJCU suq MOWCIf

—I J—

Page 14: $IHflM - NBER

- I -

insi1vni ,mii 1u1qs3 iTh IT .noiabb Ic3iim lo innimiib icbo 10 anoiisiqx bns

Isubivibni IT .isi th lo inbii Us d bnsrI is rI3iriw qirIbsrI ,Ism1 nuflni isril 1ot3s1

icis iiT .mii vo gnsi13 ion ob isth bv3I 1ubivibni rii is aioi3sI bvidonu di 1IJiqS3 a3311o

.aii1n3d DU1A isia 10 ainsnim,ib 1dioq ,rii in31q1 a1dthsv

nrfi , fdsiisv ifl3nd di rfiiw b31515no3 is 11 1ubivibni 10 a11h isi di idti 11

rIi isrIi nwoifa n,d ssrl ii i i1h 3xsIbw di lo ismiia basid s oi bsf 111w io rriflimo

bbu13ni is di ndw nsrf3 ai1uai v1insiadu di bns aiitnd rfiiw bis1TIO3 is aiTh isia dw nimsx oi ai bw airti ni au3ol dT .(QI iillIoM 8Q1 nsfl bns boowU3)

ii1i lo noiiiaoqmo3 rfi iii Thb aisia lsth i bio1qx d 111w isrIl 2iauIioqr1 nO .l3flsm

s lo noiisiiq-iini nO .Iv1 iitnd isia ir riliw b1sI11o3 nlui ni ai cI3rliw noiisluqoq

nr13 ,oa II .atn3bia-I isia r1i 10 3n1h1q tIi lo noiis1gs ns a3na1q1 ii isrli i t311

as (iuI is1Iw brsrniia th no) isqmi msa r11 vsfI bluorla ai311 Isubivibni 101 nh1Io1ino3

Ion 111w 311 isia rb ndi ivwoH rnhi 1VO vom ailims1 II .aio1h is3a di iol nh1Io1Jno3

acImun ifli3fl1IJa Ii 151oh1rfT .aiu1 Isubivibni rft as a3nuflhri rnsa di 51uiq53 1iisaan

nr1i (cIRq r1i iii briado ai noiis1im tsia13ni) sisb ciia i11 lo a,uo th 1VO vom ai1ima1 1o

s1a lo 1inbnqbni bflhiribi d ns ai11 Isubivibril

isth eoqqua ,lsIu3lrIsq nI .auongobn ai zi1oq is1Iw isia 1r lath ai aiadioqirf bno3a A

in bitnqs a1dsiisv ls3iiiIoq bns 3!r1qs1omb ,oimono d b3nuflni is aiihnd isia

.j11 1s113w bismila jj asid a ol bs1 oals sm a1dahsv a1i lo noiaaimO

1nia a no 3nsx13I dt 1o zusd ,lud (Ia.) iii dosoiqqs 3d1 awollol iWsiiiI di lo izoM

lnTIu3 ifi ni .() ni iuio&rUa 10113 3(11 lo ain3noqmo3 di 1iin3bi ion a3ob i3acisb Isnofi33a-aaol3

isi i aol 1iq3ni izbonA i&1 bflimo ih lo noi1s1iq3ni n8 bus boowila zsw lo ii1ic1stisvs rb s d3u d bw1qs ion insigo-iq iibw a'1s3 di lo aiith,isiszb idio 1ulqE3 si11 di inuoib is1 b3n3z1q 3d 01 1z3biv3 ,mo 3u113w 3d1 is anoilibno3 233iVI32 3ninizn bus nohs3ub3

.noiisi9!ql3ini IIS1 3113 lo zasnoqrni

Page 15: $IHflM - NBER

-El -

.331b tsubivibiii bits isi rliod 10 nobs3iti3nbi rLt iol wo!Is siab Insq 1o w th rIoiIsaitqqs

sf13 niau noiisup qii1abad 3Ism1 di ismi3a 03 bw i (MJ) bbom '3iIidsdoiq isniI A

1mq bisbrts3 niw J11 b3xiI s bAsmi iB aIftnoqmo3 1OTI rfT .() (U 11fl3Zrt32 1OTI

b lo w&M bw i Ibom MqJ dT .Ø8QI oisT !qmsx iol) iuboiq noi1smii

thu io1 i1h bxi1 tsiibivibni tliiw abbom iigol io ridoiq di niismi lo 3iIidis1ni

sfsbbsM a 11qmsx iol) nwonl-!bw ,is ,ivwod M'1J iL3 niw 03 atiRIji f1T 81.noiIs3ifqqs

is bbom rb lo noi3s3itiq mo noi1qmuaas MJ ril 03 1IV13!R32 rt3 I3II3 oT .(E8QI

nsm±H) 311 mobns-i Isubivibth bits aX11 bxfl tsi titiw bbom 3io1 bxim s niu b33smii

'.A xibnqqA ni biniq al bbom tiof bxim ,rb iol no133nu1 boorfiblif rfT .(48Ql ini bits

.t 3knsflU moanI lo but bns rf3 motI nwsib ts isf&is ith tot bu sisb aism riT

Lt ts (512!) ff31s251 151302 tol 1WiiriI ih 'd biI1oa 3s3sb tsrnbiflinoI s ai U12q dT .(ul2q)

grnfIislfIO3 b1orbwog1 OOO tuod lo 1qms€ s riiiw 8ôQ1 ni nsgd iI3ifIw nBui3iM lo ii2tvinU

-t nd vsd ai1ims1 vvIu fsniito th to (ansbneb bits) icfmm HA .Isubivibni OOO8I

alsubivibni 000,8E nsdt tom ,bnsq d3 lo is bno inw3 di 'd 3&i3 thus Ifunns bwiviini

bsd ts ir1 b3n31q 2ism ILA .vtua di ni gniisqi3lrlsq 13nTIU3 is to b3sqi3thsq vsd

owi to 2i2irro3 1qmsa 8ôQf 1sriiito dT .UI2l dJ 10 3Lqms (HXX VBW to) Q8Ql-8Ql rfi no

to 133n) dais$L vtu2) b1orbwort 000,E lo 1qmsdu2 vi3s3ntq31 11snoitsn s :Iqms2dua

wol lo 1qmss gnuiix3 as moil b3ba thlotbwoul OOQ, I lo 1qmsdu £ bits (1qmsdu D$12

bxi1 Isubivibni 3smi3 03 beau d ns3 bbom i*°' IMOiJibaO3 331 bxfi £ 3s113 woife (08Q1) nMhdmsn8 bIThnbi is a11 bxft di sib 2xIqm iboiqqs boodiblil fsuobib(1o3 dT .bbom foib itib sni a311

it1i a! .tsJsb dJ at (wJsi bsd tsnz1-noa bus bsd Lsmt awid noiiiaasii odw od1 ,

.) %1I)1N% di d .dsoiqqs 21ñ3 Uim1qmi 03 )n5i3Mu2 ma al d33iw2 10 sk Eqrns di .noi1a3iIqqs

nivhb ts Idsrisv !subivibai bniino isib id3oqid ib nimsx o3 bu d ma na bbom IigoI bxim dT i au1 fwbivibth ifj niditb noiiudnjeib t,tib d3 noiiini1b d ws3d afut 311 bxR s3 di .bbom d1 iii 3shsvo3 di lo 1nbnpbni d oi brnuaa

Page 16: $IHflM - NBER

OCUC!t) O L14!J!tA qccoimjçopcu yojjr v pcoqy tc 22incq p2cq ou uqtqWJ?t c ftonL bcou2) GCfl2C o, ipc boicuijLOW fl3C }ooq nq .4fItU•OU L#CCe DCLWICUt OL V4CnIWIC jjic cqicq qSfS Mfl CUcLOfl2II bioAiqcq pAVqt!0IJ DcbLwJcu HCIflJ HfIIJJ1 2cLA1Cc2 jpc ooq 2Inb qs cinc iom nubnppcqcqciq o pc ocxbcuquILc2 u VIDC qt cin; zow nubnppcq upjc pow rpc JmjA 2nbboumcomc pciu jucq1 ! ciqcn u tpc ooq ewb pcucur ou uq ojc (J) onuqqic cp inc otpc vci8c cqciq pcncw (oi VEDC ,.cc!b!;w) oL wjA o toni .Lpc LC2flJt iom VEDC2wwb wuinnw pcucijt bjn2 Qg o pc vcw8c pcqciq ;zbcucpuac jpc mcqciq pcutjt cjcnjrcq

1jpc towj csp MJRC opc qiicc bw&m2 nucq to Pc opc u,u,nm YEDC PCUCW bin2 ,pc ooqMC oulA UcjflqC tO2C MOWCIJ MpO qici bLCIU poncpojq nq tpcu Lcuiur2C onjq Pc qcutijcq 92 ! af1p9wflA pcq Low qist bo!uc ou jp conq cn2c wbjc cjccqou bLoplcw2 CCfl2Ccqjq "°t qczup nptun jq HOMCACL pci bicug12 Ofl2CJJOJ Uq qJCU LCWUJ2vipux!JA pcsq OL cX9Wb1C ! M0W11 !2 I!'4' MtP pci bicut t tpc tu OL ipc vwbjc uq pc p pci OMUtpc b2ID ii not nut!! MOWUU 2bpt2-o uq CLCtC2 pci 0MB pon2cpojq gpt 2PC " PC !qcUqCq 92OuJA rjioc UAIIJ8 M!rpont! 2b0n2c oi bigucr t4OtC qvt IJJCLC 20U3C 1uCOu2accucA ! 2npwjJJc2 111

3owcu po ic copptu i.c 9228ucq to ipc uou-Lcumjc pcq oi muicq cpo!cc cumjc pctq2 !Uqflq

qitumA AL1JC cdnj to ouc we wte pq u vhDc-nb bLoLw !u w bi.qcni. ?eu jpc

AJf1C O pCuj2 0L Ill!JA O OflL LOw VEDCa booq WIJJb2 uq eqcsq51 j)f,C J2O !ucIflqG

q!cq bLoLuJ jpe pcucjt AL!PIc !U qic IJJA2i2 ednj to jpc cowpueq cp

cp 2L2 ijpjc rIuqeL we bLoLuf pnt j2O !ucJqe u-!uq peucjt qaonp we ooq wb

GUC4jt2 IPI !U ccp 2C Ii GCJJ 1. uqj12 10L VhDC bqcbut2 LC uot jiu.mcq to qic

bobnjuou CJJLJCtCLJ2t!C2 mq bojqcj zuqc9toL2 JM0 AL!PJc2 LC f12Cq to qc2cLpc we

LPC b2ID qt 12 riujciiicq M!tP 2[iC eAC Oil MCJ1LC PGUCJt2 ccouowic couqqou

OP2LAOU2 OL 18O Mp!te MOWCU suq 3OI PICiC MOWCU OAeL Ipe RAUtA-tMO beLioq

2I2QC2 tpi2 2uJbJe cjccqou couqiqoli jpc c2qWqOU q9cct COlUU? torj o &oto12 CUJSjC pcq iiq eLo otJCLM!2C0 VIJ op2cLA9qou !2 CLG OL ccp ?cL qrni tpc MOWlJ

OL poncpojq peq2• jpe qebeuqeut iLipJc !U qie cwb!L!c1 ijjA cdri to ouc q qie MOurnu

jpc eqiirniiou qtet ucJnqe2 Moweu M!w cpJqLcu MO LC CIIpGL WUCq

bLoAqcq pA we 1)21D

to qic oAcL2miJbjiu o, JOM !ucowc Lonb2 9uq to tou ','-jj LC2flJI2 bic2euiq pete ne qie mc!pt2

LOL w!2 uoui.uqow cowbo2rqou W b2ID !UcIncIca MC!Pt2 qcucq to ci! wuntc 2G2 9WJPIIWP!c

wcowc suq wwoiA bobnioua (nueA o couowic ObboLtnuiO OL 2E0 2flp21JJbJC) jo qr12t

-It-

Page 17: $IHflM - NBER

jC2 ILC qW !ACLC 8CUCLOflJ) bLoAiqcq p yuucqc2c4buou o qic VEDC-flb bLogl.sIw

2flbboLL O 1Ô2 U JCjUI fPL ll CZiCUq VEDC-flb pCIJ2 pA IO 2 HOAU (j3) LOL IIUTJcLucLcncq qicu qcccncq u tpc cijA bucbqou ps2 ucccq 2UCC rpc cq io .LP "&iv ipc bLo&ur ID ier i ttq VIDC-flJ, Cii2 jpionp qic unq-j gc biqcbsiion

OACL PC t!'IJ Oq COACLj pA SpC b2ID qiCLC M OUJA UJIDOL A!LJPOU ID qiC UUIUf)CL o wtc b!uIcIbUu8

WLG PCCII UUU!U O CUGjJ2 2!UC J3 JJJ LCJ qccjuc !U ClJCIji2 JJ9 GCIJ WOqCLq

b2ID JJJC VbDC fLU1 p? P1J cICI!U!IJ !U LC9J LUJ OAcL [J CIULC bcLoq' JIporip

bcur ALG LC JCACJ2 9UJOIJ OJTL 2UJbJ Oj MOWCU Mp cJjijqLcu ow

L1C P!PCL MC2 Wt© !UCOWC miq LCfCL Lcbnppcu bLccuc !u ipc 2W OLUWIJF

pqe oi poncpoq cbcc!I1A pI 9LC WOLC J!IcJ? o ic LCH2 /iip nuwbjo?wuj

Ot P1CIC MOUJCI) LG pbI21 MJJ!Ic MJJJGMOWCIJ LC WOLC J!JP o pe bLoiu1 01. cpojc cwjc

ipe pcg ! bLoAIqq iu b2ID PIcJJ jqcc o pe coucjq MiJ pcq2p1b jpc UJ9I0LIA

CJJIJqLCU LG WOLG JJCCJ? jO 9AC I0ML qncqou 1CACI iiq JLGL SUJll!c? 191J MJJ!12 fGJ110U 0j

pa,c J0ML cqnC!ou JAJ2 JJAC UrnJJGL slJq JAC !U 911 ly BJ9CJC MOUJCU /#1tp

pcqpib o,ci qic bLoq j,pi j uq 20M qJ9 cwc pcq o poripojq WOLC ilicciA o

oit. qic 2911Jb1c bcLioq MPCLC poiji MP!W2 q PII 29M 9 U9L qonppu !U ipc iuciqucc 0 1W9JC

curnjc pcq2 cowbmcq o j bcLcu opJ9CJc2 jpc ID q19 0M2 !UCL!U p.iIq2 ru pc9qpIb

O2CLA9UOU OL pJ9cJc2 OACL qic swbjc bcLoq1 bLCGU 0j pc M0WU zu qic 2Swbjc MCL

pjgcc MOUJGU !U j9JC jJJLG 9LC 0 j0[9 O 02CLA00U2 0L Mp! ouq

/J1ciJucq 22IC 0L qic iiibjc q 2flUJUi9U OL MJJ!tc MOUJCU U LP1 I oug OL

boi.A 04 rpc OACL1J0L ouq we bsuA cowboqou o, ipe ie cuoic ouq ponc

bobnjoqou IP9 !2 OACL 9C Q ouq qic bCLCGIU Cp9 OLC cpqcw 1P bO!!1!C1 A9L!OPIc2 UCJflqc qic

wcowc ouq 2tCM1C mcJ9tc boLqcboqou L0jc2 DCUJOL5bP!C AoI.opIc iucjnqc qie bcLccui o4, qic

ccouowc ADL!opIce ucnqc w nucwbjoAwcu L0tc cLo M0 !u woufuocwL!u bez. cbit

qio: OjCL flb pcijcj euq to pe pipei pcuciji P!JicL C92JOOq jpc 9tC-AcJ

-U-

Page 18: $IHflM - NBER

-o 1-

bs13ni amsioiq -i11 r1i to ufsv rta& bnidmo3 r1i s bis3ibm bits qmsi boot ni diwoi d ol 3v511 'tlB13n atithn3d DCHA iii sini ,IiiIW .Z)nI bnib3b vsr1 bits 'Q! Iiirw isi1wmoa

101 'llsunns-im io IIsurins biw1bs 315 Eift3n3d qrnsi boo 1uis1aig3I 1sie d b3i1orüus d lo iio13n r1i ni bnii 1o 3lubiq ,viiqob s vig 3n015 DCRA niU .3hq bool 111 33ft8f13

3th it! .iiUons ni ,nib3b i3alIo 11n31x3 mo ot ,ns3 msioiq no iii iliwoig ausd '3lsIbw"

.ii13n3d 3islbw lo noitini1b r1i ot 3vdin3a ion 3 2t1u31 Ii awollol isdi *10W Is3liiqffl3

isdi aisqqa ii •

I iugit ni qirfbs3r1 3tsm31 RI bnii 3111 01 ait3n3d ni bn5li 3(11 gniisqinoD

3v511 arit3rl3d 1s31 n3th 33fii .OcQI bim 3111 lirnu 13oI3 tiup qidabs3rI 315rn31 b13s1i iit3n3d

.31u1513111 ii 3m1 3111 flu 3bsm nd sd inioq thIT .bs3-i3ni astl 31s1 qirkbs3rf 3di 3[irfw b3nibb

101 3101 s 3v531 tlti 5ffl 113111W OVQI bim 3111 3Z)fli b3gnsd3 vsi1 'sm aioi3sI irlio ,l3v3woH

.315113w

ifl8a3d ni noiishsv isia nithiw i(1 b3ithn3bi f i11 316113w 3111 f3bom i113 b3xit 315Th ru

3111 20i3E bn31i 3(11 flu 33n3-13Thb ins3iIirIgia 31B 313(11 isdi 3isliwlli .t bits F 231ug11 .mii 13V0

31s113w gisl rlliw 1s1 iil3n3d rlgi(1 03 3isl3bom iuol iot aifl3n3d DU1A 1si awod F 31ugi1 23t6Th

no won i bits (31sr bArusi ra3dgirf rfiiuol) 80Q1 ni tsi iibn3d rfgirf (13V s sw iorti1l1 .bso13es3

3613V5 116 sw siniolilsD .(IIsl3vo bi b1rtsi) riflio 3rfi 1o ,bi1uo 1siz iihn3d Th3wot 3113 1o

r1i lo bn3 r1i d isi iitn3d ir1gid 1o no 3mod or nii asif iud (bi b1rwi) SOQI ni 31sra

'I1n3Thi2fto3 sd iqqiiiM 31111W .arsj iit3n3d wol ith iol bn3ri itt awoii 4 31ugiL .boi13q

211t3n3d Th3bom moil ff31161 sd sx3T ,boil3q 3111n3 3rIr l3vo a.tsi2 iftn3d i3wo1 di 1o no nd smsdslA 3vods bi b3Ansl) flnuo3 3111 ni 3tsta 111311311 Th3Wo1 3(11 1o no or (80Q1 gil r11I bAnai)

.(iqqi2iiM bris

11s3usmo1us 373w ftnd DCIIA dw isi iojsin 1no 3111 asw siirrolils3 boh3q iib b zbum ihuU atft3n3d bits e311nthi1 iia 311i d 1Mnimon b2 318 ilb3a3d !IiqT .gthvil lo ioz> 3111111 23nsd3 oI b3iaujb8

1sv lo thoil3q iol nni lsnimon ni bxft nthmi

Page 19: $IHflM - NBER

uAC cocjcui ou w VEDC-flI, qnwmA jp i So onuq pA jiujqcL (jW(C2 LC2rIU2 JO( 2QMU !U(CLSC(!IJ VEDC-flb qnwwA M!fP 4P pCUC( rn1iSpc LGV(1(2 ! (J1 CXbc(qbo2!PIc (11Sf (PC CCCf O I)CIIC(2 Ou fUJ1A (LflCWLC '4tI qqcL U fS(C2 OL!U VEDC-flb PCUCIJ(2 ACL2fl2 UOU-flb

ru j, 2(S(C2 pcuc sc bogcuusjjA sjspc poqi uqc wq onriqc ot wsuzc con nrnjA s

2JJO1i gpn cwsj pcsq2pb 12 yJpGL LOL AOnUCL MOWCIf M1p JOMCL qncqou JCACJ2 MIfJJ OJqcL

(jqionp !u2!1J!4jcS1U) CI OU WJG JJq2Jb JJJC O4ICL COIL!Si uCJflqGq !U (PG woqc

(0 cxbGq1pou2 J1AtU !U S SiSm (S( OCL2 VIiDC-flb pGucjis s G2tWS o psi s

cwsj psqpb orrjq IUCLCS2G pA obcLccuis bo!ius su uci. sec otsporn jjic bcLccut CoupLA

pn woqc2 ccf ou icwsjc pqepb 0L MP!fG MOUJCW R VEDC pGUGt MCLC IIJCLCSCCq pA

suq 1IiJC cu.cc'e C0UCU( m!Ip LGCGUf cA!qcuCc MGjSLG pcucip psic S boeAc suq 2!u!jjcSIJf

MGJ45LG PGIJGW A5L!5PJC CpSISC4GLI2(iCe 0 LpG MOUJSIf ISPOL WSLJCG( L!sp1ce qA20U fJ(1WUJIC

Luoqcj sc bLoIuqcq u pjc oqc (j) bLoAqc2 i!IJJSG2 OL (PG p52!C woqc Mp!cp iucjnqce

b5LSUJGL G2PWSG2 0L (PG pcsqepib cdnsuou pL M(G wowcu psecq ou ipe J!ucsl. bLopsp!J!IA

kM3 th031

!!UL woqcj (ysqqss j)

woqci !? G2t!WS(G1 5CCOflUf!11 0L p cL0eccqse(Ci(A qnc (pG IICG 0 S 12CLC(C qthcuqcu( suspjc

OL SLPIfLSLA C0LLGJS(0U OACL (PuG 112!U ipc COLLGCI!OU 0 HI1PL (j) jpc jucsi bLopsplpA

cowboeoif SJJ LCLG22O1J2 SLC cequsicq (1e!U (pG enwbfc pe wuqsiq GLLOLC si.c sq1neq

ecbsLs cdn oue si.c iurnicq OL Mp!( suq pjscjc M0GW 1 cc0nIU OL uoLJ-LsIJqow eswbjc

(JJmooq suq CLJIJGa !O DSIJGL G( !23 HO1WSU C( Sj jj oijj !ooosojju iootY

cdnsj (0 GLO OWGLM!2G BGCSfl2G jicsqejib bsucuie qc dcijc enpeisiusjjA OL JSCJC2 suq iipic2

(pG SG2 01 JQ suq jpc qcbcuqcu( ASL!spIc !2 cdnsi (QOUC 14 (PC mowsu e s cwsc pcsqe suq

esiuibjc C0IJ2(2 O SJJ UJSLLcq MOWGIJ OL 4.W51G pcsqe O ponecpoq M!()J CpflqLdu MjJO SLG CLMGGU

flJIC ecciiou bLceGu(e G2WS(G2 0L qic cwsjc pGsqepb woqcjqcecLpcq ill eccpou :i

-I -

Page 20: $IHflM - NBER

-81-

iIi ol viis!i --noitsilitis woiibi d hsv o1s qidabsc1 Isrn,1 .asis nsthu ni gnivil ri,blid3

irfiii 3vsd noii1i b3isi on ibiw oi(i bits iwo1 vsd nmow rtiw --3i1odiE3 o quoi bnimo

sis ndu its iii niviI bits no1is3ub lo i311 3111 .b!orf3auolI lo bs3ri 315(1181 s 3d 01 2thin3qoq

nsdi iom 315 noiis)ub3 lootha i1ii1 nsdi aaI rijiw n,mow iidW .a33Th gis1 hs1u3thsq 3V5f1

3111 2325513(11 AM2 its ru uiviJ .aisubsi 1001132 rfirI nsth 2115311 315(1131 3d 03 SI3)1iI as 33!Wi

Ion 315 3513VS bits aisi 1n,mo1qm3nU .1n3313q d iilidsdoiq qic12bsr1 31sm31

101 IoDno3 cit b,bubni 315 ai1b 3miT .e3moaluo qidabs3rl 81sm31 to ainsrrirrnb lrIEiloqmi

1inio1 315 aif1, mh a3dT .bnsui biswqu 311312121103 £ worla bits amion 151302 (Ii 23.11S113

.13v31 3n3313q I 31(3 35 111531 ifli2

03 8uU .a3Tt Isubivibni bits ista lo 3101 3111 3nimsx3 E 1dsi ni aI3bom ninism31 3rfT

gnibuI3ni 3tqms hun d1 lo iadua s no b31smiia sus ailuasi a3di ,a31sla 3moa 111 2i 3lqmsa lisma

sis 31qm52-dua 31sia 3d3 1o &u1ai13is1sth rtT V•no1Isv,do lo Esioi £ iol a31s12 1 nolaivib luoritiw bits riiiw 2noiis3i1iqa 3n3231q (€) bits () abboM .1-8 3Idsi xibn3qqA ni b31n3a1q

uaom iol 333113 Isnigism 3113 lud 13dir1 isrlw3moa 21 3[qmsacfua airli ni I113 315113w 3dT .aimmub

llsiirtsiadua (t) iii b33n8231q as ,a31sia 3113 iol a3z113 b3xit 3111 nibbA .islimia 315 a3isilsvo3 13(130

31iup 315 2333113 isia b3liias3mnu 3(11 35(11 1qmi a31u231 82311T .333113 31s113w b31sm1323 3111 agn&fa

32013 gnl3d cit 3as3flhrria bits 3vlliaoq ni3d moil agnsd 133113 315113w b3Ismiia3 8113 25 Isiin3uflni

slolqx3 oT .13v31 1r13313q I 3(1115 ins3Itingia 1.tnioi 315 2333113 31532 ar(T .ins3itiniani bits o,3x 01

515113w 3513VS I2ffi5S 2333113 b3xlt 33512 b3iSmita3 3111 aiolq 3lugfl j5218v51 atIfI 282U53 isriw

11u231 5 al 133113 315113w b3lsmila3 3(11 itj 3th133b 3r1T .3Iqmsa 3(11 (11 a31sia 3111 10 11353 iol aJIt3n3d

iii vi1 01 i1iq rn abs3d 1smI .1us as abu1 adi 3nuIiq131ni iii ts 1si bhioda no Jin nI .eioi1 idio rn ,acloj airna lo iihid1ivs lo aus3d aA2M2

di tvo amow vfI-rnva tas1 is iol aaoiisrnado iw iifi Ii 1qmsa is1a 3111 iii b3bubni asw 31&iz b3rnsm auwiv ab&d 3150131 lo notiiaoqmo3 3d1 no b3asd ol b3iba ion iw aisiz 3adT

. bnsq 311i lo 321U03

ai1ims1 iii1w Its lo 1niq OV iuods io bsobzs 31ii3w (slot lo iniq X inods iol 11010335 zis3a adT .ntnow .n3lbhixf3 diiw

Page 21: $IHflM - NBER

II moup COu2qGLu WOLG oLwoIIh mph mc w!p1 Gxbccl iom ouq !uq!qi GUGCI2 10

10 OCCOIIUI OL bobnjoqou PC1GL0GUC1A 0CL022 01t2

oujh boojcq CL022-2GC1!OU0J !U0L1110lu0u 2 0A0flSJG U [p01 C0U[LOI!!U 0L 2[OIG CI.JGC[2 2 2JIUJCIGU[

qich qo uo IUJflGUCG [G cwoiq MCJLG cjjcr jp LCflJt ooq UGM2 0L obbIIcoriou2 MGU

fIG 2W[G CUGC[2 OLG 2qJJ !WbOLWIU (i qJCh OLG 21flJ 10iUJh 2IJ!UC0U1 01 [JIG j bCLCGIJ[ JGAGJ) fl[

ou uq!qJ GGC[2 ucJnqGq oqqIu roi ccc qo U01 CJI0UC [JIG boLowGL o[ !u[GLC

GCC[2 -- [JIG COGUC!GU[ OU VhDC PGUGIJ[ CCOWG2 2W011 (oculojih WLU2 1JG0[JAG) miq !u2!u!uCour

02 2JIOMU !u ( po AII.UloJIh jpc 2OWC iwbc ou [JJG G2[JW01G MGJ1,0LG GGC[ 02 oqqiu 2W[G jjxcq

J1JGLGUCG2 ii [JIG cowbo2!pou O [JIG bObflJO[IOIJ 0CL022 [JIG 2[0[G2 vqqJu uqq1 ljxGq GJGC[2

jJJG LGurniuqcL O [JIG [PIG bLoAIqG2 2110U GAJqGUcG [JI01 OL Mpi[G2e 210[G GGC[2 OLG C0b[1IL!U

ICW0JG pcoq o pon2GpoJq

CtGCl2 !UCLG02!U PGUCIJI2 ph ziøø J[J2 [0 0 2GAGU bCLCGIJ[ !UCLGO?C !U [JIG bLopopiplA 0j pGJU 0

qi2wLpsIJcG !u [JIG boucj (HGcldurnu ouq 2!UGL jg JJIG2G LC2flJ[2 !wbIh flI0 u [JJG OP2GUCG 0l2W[G

2bccicoqou !U WPJG V-i oqq qJ2CLG[G uqJAqIToJ LOuqow G1JGC12 [0 OCCOfl1JI 0L 0 COWUJOU

210[G 4GC[2 LGqITCG2 O[JI [JIG w0uJ[rTqc ouq 2W[12[!COJ 2!1I!UC0UCG 0, [JIG MGJ0LG G4JGCr jpG f2[

woqcj M92 0J20 G2[JW0[Gq JJJG2C G2[JUJ0[C2 bLcuq iii bbuqpc L0P1G V-i COUIJLW [p01 oqqiu

iu OLCL [0 C0UJLW [JIG L0I12[UG22 0 [JJG2C LC2flJ[2 [0 [JIG IJIUC[J01101 0LUJ 022flWb[J0U 0

2[0[G GUGC[2 0 MGflSLC !UCGU[JAG

GMGL G1JJ0JG pcoqcq 0fT2GJI0J2 ouq JG22 2IlbbOL[ 49L [JIG VI.tC bLoL9ur MOl WJC!U 11110 OCCOflU[

ouq MGj0LG CUG1j[2 LOL GXOUJbICe S 2[S[ lUSh JISAG S 2[L0LJ [MO-tSW!JA [LSqJ[Jou MJJ!CJJ LC2flJ[2 UI

LG2IIJ[2 SLG C011212[GU[ MJL}J [JIG iqcS [pSI flIJUJG02flLG 2[0[G G1JGC[2 !uUflGUCC MJJI[G pGoq2pib CCJ20U2

PGIJGUI2 ouq LGJSI!AGIA ISL 2[S[C GGC[V fIG COLLGISI!OU COqIJCJGUL 0L [pC2G 2GL!G2 12 OQ jJJG2G

pon2Gpotq oi cxouibj JI!J PGUGUI 2W1G2 2flC 9 C0I!tOLu!0 IJUUG2OW auq 4GM AOLIC JISAC pip

04 [JIG 2[S[C CIJGC[? PG!IJ OI%) C0LLGJ0[C m![p 2[S[G MGJ0LG PC1JGLI[2 0L 4CWSJC JIGSq2 04

-Jo-

Page 22: $IHflM - NBER

rft ivo bvom ilimth on isdi oqqu2 .iIb 3Itbw biEmil rfi rio I3sqmi IthiniThb s

bluow 11 bxit ii rfuoirIi nbii lo iz iot 1o1ino3 rir!T .1riq UII 3r11 lo 1UO3

i1bw ussd i airiT .ai1h Iubivibni rIi as b11 is1bw rfl rio zrzuflni msa rtt vsrf

vsr1 w lsrfl Its aisra aaoi3s vom ablotbauort on isdi 1nv iti ni 1bns 1s1a sd isv 1rto aiftnd

lqx bluow w as lsrti it! .a1nbiai all b ai311 tsubivibrn dl ai al11 3151a dr 1iin,bi 01

rIi ,ab,ow 131110 it! .aift3n3cJ 31s113w no 111313111303 msa 3111 vsrI ol () bits (1) anoi1s3f1iqa

nviid noiisbiioa 3d1 01 tsup3 3d bluow alt13 1512 bits aiil3n3d 3lsIbw nvi1d noiiaIrtoo

U12q 3rt1 flu alsTh nwld gnivom a3ilimtt 3v1ado 13v3wor1 ob 3W .alI13 Isubivibni bits a1i1n3d

lo lnnq ôI bits lo 1n3313q Q luods btod3auorl lo abs3rI 3Ism81 lo fqmsa 3di nomA .slsb

isdi a3ilqmi noil5iim airiT .UII 3d1 sd b313vo3 abs3b owl 3r11 l3vo 3m11 moa is vorn 231111w

31512 bits ai1h tsubivibni 1o1i3th bits b3xi1 ion ai 31512 s nurtiiw noiisluqoq 3d1 lo itoh oqmo 3rfi

.l113 3lslI3w b31smila 311i no at3sqmi 1ni311ib 3vsrl rts3 aifl3

lo alnsniml3l3b ni11imo or i1h 3lslI3w b3lsrnu1a 3r11 lo 1iviliana rf1 a3lotqx3 .t *1sT

or 23Idthsv Is3iiiIoq bits 31m0flo33 31532 abbs 3Idsi 3113 lo I3rwq qqu r1T .aift3rt3d DU1A 31512

323111 a31smi3a3-s, 3Ids1 3rIi lo bnsq l3woI 311T .ai113 31sia ,ol atolino3 on 1131w 31d51 iii () Ibom

'ffimsl bits fsubivibrti Its abuIarn oats . 31d53 Eli fl0135311133q2 rbs3 .a1u13 31512 rlliw al3bom

lo 23151 l3dgirI Isdi tqmi 2315mi123 3a3dT tivid iol b31limo is lud ,fdsl ni b32u afo,irro3

iom bits I13bI3 13w31 n3lbIirI3 13w31 (IIsnothoqoia) 1111w a1s1a lii bnuol is qirfabs3rf 315(1131

Is3iriIoq 3rIT .agsw gsivs bits 23151 rn3moIqm3rtu 13dif1 1131w a31sla bits Miqaa 13q 232S3 DCFIA

ob (zns3iIduq3$I d bI3fI 232u011 31512 lo noirioqoiq bits iornvog fls3iIduq3l iol mmub) a3Idsilsv

an13flsq qiiiabs3d 315rn31 ni itoiisiisv nisfqx3 ol ii1ids 113111 3liqa3U .lnstloqmi 3d 01 isqqs ion

noils3iIi33q2 .a1113it311 315113w lo vibn3obn3 3d3 iol 33n3b1v3 nona 3bivolq ion ob 211u231 323111

bbuI3ni nd vd iszU 210111103 rhsm iodsl di 2qoib I Idsi noi3s3itiqa laift th ,33n1311 lo itiioq s aA .11315m ion ob amit brnsq iti 2udT .E Idsi iii 2noiis3flb3qa tIs ff1

Page 23: $IHflM - NBER

bLCaCULCq in vbbcuqix wpJJJJC2C iSIC2 CCO1UU OL Ofli bCLCCIJI O JJ p5CJC WU!C MU CPflqLCW JJJC WU 04 tJI np2swbjc tc

2W4C anpmbIG OL CJC2 couwn ta ip s jc o omcu i owc bonn qrn.u qicjmn8c 2flpWULJIA

0VEDC ccoq bc& cbi ! boiu HA wqo8uon2 n qLobbcq jL0m qJ LCLC2!OU tP LflJ qo! ImJHCCIA qnc o qic cjc o( G14qcucc pq on opcuspjc uijnwcc

qo uoi rpc cqumrq MJ!LC GJC COILC1OU CMCCU IpC tWOPCLMPIC CJCWCW COP1 1!II JI (0oq PA 2JcA suq c (JY ! p owriou °L jcici qcsuIIpmu2 o VEDC pcuqp

IJrnL 1J LcanJ o. pc aii 2np2ulbJc qo uo qc 2np uj) cowbq jo C2PW2 OL qc

2npcuJbJc OL pjqc COU!U2 O92CLA3tOIJ2 iii J 2JJ joqj () JJOM

COAL!L 2WJL iO qrn pnuq 140L Mpii

LOI1b MIWIU L9CIJ LOflb (owu jØ Aoju M1UJCICL j) jjjc qic oi oqi

I ôôO HOU.WIJ j j,ojju j Mfl 2 LCL MCJLG q1cc2 UJO1I JOMCL qnciou

bLiri2 mq! 9A onuq LC[CL MCI1LG CuCIjI2 OL psc2 (jMooq uq 991JC jg

PICF2 UJ p LCI1J1 O pJcJc2 PA!U LCL cjipooq O £IJCiIJ rib pcucjj 9 cw pq

pcqpb bLoppiJ!(A pA OACL (MO bCLCC1JWC bO!Ut OL bcLccur jjiC JJLCL McJLc qLcc( 4)L

SUJOIJ pjCJC IIJ91J !1 OL Mp!2 EOL P1CP JOO !UCL2C lu MCILLC GU4jI2 !UCLc2C2 1p

qLIIL flp2UJA LOW qJC CPWiG LcboLmq OL !AJJ! IJJC pGuj ! U!UC1UP JLL

wbjc MqI qAOu qrlwwG2 woqc (j) 2JJOM 1JJ iJ qiL1JJIUSU12 O CWjC pq2JJib tOL picjce

KC2flII2 40L 1p j!ucL bLop9pJA woqj tc bLc;urq !u Li!c jji cnws OL tG

%tS2\ ic oxpvc uo !uIb9c ou ipc cwq MCJL

!u wp qqiu qcwoLbpc uq bojqcJ AL!pJC2 9 qqiqoirnj boj!CA qciunuou

urnLJc coulioj2 (nucwbJoAwcu( L9(C mq VCLC #) JI MLC pjcnqcq !U (G II!CL 2bcciijcIou2

cbnn) LflC2 (JJ 2! ot 1pc jmc ccv jpi bL!wnujA qric o c !ucIn!ou o pc JPOL

() !u I9PJC rpi qqnJ coujioj tOL couowc ALJ2 (iucjnqiu VEDC ccjoq bL

-31-

Page 24: $IHflM - NBER

sismuis sth 01 1s13no3 q15112 it! .ais1h Isubivibni bits s1si bbs 2bbom ninistnsi silT .sIqms

sis'tlsw no iasI'ts on tomls sd ) bbom iii nwok s 11s sisi iol nil1onoa stirlw io't

33512 ns iuothiw 8O.O ol bslsqmo3 O.O 21 ?JiIsnsd DCHA no insiailhoa silT .33smi12s iitsnsd

ssisvs bits alasl'ts bxfl 33sra bsismitas sill nsswtsd noiisbrtoa 'to iasl sill 2wOil2 a siui1 .fls sub i noiisbrioa sviissn issw ur1T .V0.O- 21 lnsiaflboz) noilsisrios silT .33512 d 2liisnsd is'tbw

.alas'tIs sisia saisi sbvitsEi svsil ilaiiIw (sbiioR sigiosO) si512 iitsn,d wol w't £ 03

lo 23112i1533515f13 istho gnhwqsa sis atasib sisra sill isili sldiaaoq ai ii isilizs bsiasgua aA

lqmi bluow iii3 1isvswoH .litsn,d sisllsw sill 'd bsiuiqsa gnisd ron msioiq sislbw sisra li nomA .bcwoI ion ai rlurlw nois,si s.tiilw bits iasld srli iii lasits sisla sth io't asulsv islimia

stsia sill nsswisd noiisLsTloa sill ,aslqmsadua slara slirIw bits A3sId sill or nommoa 251532 1 sill

.insaitiniani lud sviliaoq bfssw 21 alasits

bsisbnoa sis aiasfls Isubivibni bsvisadorw Isdi WOila sf1153 lii anoilsaitiasqa gninismsi silT

sistlsw sill 'to sbulinam sth asaubsi ( Isbom) alasils Isubivibni nibbA .Ivs1 3ibnd sisla sill illiw

s ninimo '8 .100.0 urxsaflingini 11saijaiisla £ 01 80.0 lnsoittn3t2 bits sviiiaoq a inoil lash,

sill ni siaIfsw lo sloi sill slsmilasisvo sw eaiithsiasisifa Isubivibni bsnsadonu ioI lolinO3

sis alaslIs Isubivibni sono ,slirlw or 1islimi2 .blorls2uoti ho bssii slsmsl s sd 03 'iiansqo1q

.iswoq sviiaibsiq on asbivoiq atashls 31532 gnibba bsbufani

Isubivibni gniilimo iaiiq .a1as1d ioh 231u231 sth molt wsib 03 alnioq lnstioqmi owl sis sisriT

qiiiabssrl sfsmsl ioI isnsm aiilsnsd DCHA lsth noiaubnoa sill 01 -- luonoiis --bssf nsa alaslts

03 riansqo1q iisth 03 lasqasi rlliw) asisla sill aaoias nsmow (3s1d to nothaoqmoa silT .aiioiatasb

d bsnislqxs sd nsa iilT .iftsnsd sishlsw sisla sill iliiw bsislsnoa at (qiilabssrf slsmsl saooila

ni bm32s1qs 'fiooq ts 2noi2ivib au&is Sf102 ,uoiisluqoq *Id sf11 lo ito bud hl2Ab Isupsnu sili to s2us33a .(t) bbotn iii siinmub nofivib bsismii2s silt ho aoiJs3slqlstni silt 2335115 zull' .slqtnsadua SISIa bsld sill

.slqms2 53532 silt o1 Isbom szsd sdi ai 2sIrnnwb noi2ivib tuodhiw () Isbom 13nib1o33A silT .2ls11s mobitsi d3iw Isbom i3ol s 3niau bstsmb2s 0215 sisw 1sbom ssdi 1A3sila noitsafii3sq2 S

.Ls2of3 stiup ailuasi Isbom iasail sill daisw ,-A sldsi xibasqqs ni bsinsasiq ,bbom 31301 bsxim sill to 23111251

Page 25: $IHflM - NBER

bisIsno3 ion 518 Lostd iol 311 ii bno2 .23i1nd 3181bw irIgid riliw aJJa 03 rioiiaigim

d b3nuflni si nmow A381d 113111w 111 no138u112 B rIiiw ini2i2no3 21 2U1T .iiInd sx11w tliiw

r13 luff (in83flini2 sis aru1 tt tD) bvI 3E32 f3 38 2fIllOfl 2lJOigi(5I 10 1811J31U3 1Si3O2 mo2

d m 2icfT .z1it3nd sIB11w ir1irf oi nibl 22.301q i3i1oq th iYts ion ob mion lif1umm03

.quo1 irfi ni iwoq 1&iiiloq lo 1zI lo aud noms noitsigim Isiin,i11ib d bnistqx d ns ai113 bxfl IBubivibni lo ri8i1oqmi r1T

owi-lnwi th niiub mi3 mo2 is vom 1qms2 f3 ni 2311iff1s1 L3sIdlO 3n3313q nin luodA .aA3sId

gB1vB nO .noiisigim 1si3n1Iib b nbiv3 3bivolq a3381 1E13v .1qmE2 UR1 ü ni ns 2iitnd iith bnio1 bvom odw 2of1T .23siz titnd ir1ir1 03 gnivom 518 3V01T1 18(13 2i1imB1 a(13

1f1id £ illiw 20th ,irIriuq .bl2 bsrf 13 li nd vs11 bluow b 118th iiigu1 ln3iq . I d 03

1831 lii 328313fl1 1318I S 33113113qx3 (IX) 101 3u18v 1311 gid B) blort32uoff lo bsf 318m&t 3d 03 ii2rI3qo1q

211u251 ET .bfod32uorI lo bsr1 318m31 s 3d 03 n2n3qo1q l3woI s 1131w 320113 03 3v116131 23113n3d

bnuol nd 28(1 lsrIi qirtabs3rI 31sm31 briB 21113n3d 318113w rxw1d q!rl2noiisbl 3vIiiaoq 3113 isth 1qmi

noii81im b33ubrri-518113w rlguouli b3v311138 133113 flOili2OqmO3 8 lo 11u31 8 21 ibu32 zuoiv3lq 111

318m31 bns aliIn3d sisbbw nm3d qirf2nofisIsI 182U83 £ lo 18(13 sn3biv3 on i sI3liT .3mii 13V0

qiIf2bs3d

ff1 231t3n3d 518113w lo 33nBrIoqml 3(13 38 nh333 lo sw i33libni V3V 318 23n325 iqsi 2irtT

2WOff 2 bn8 31J221 21(13 23flifflBX3 1131(1W 511J1813311 31dS3i2 £ 13V3W0(1 2i 5131IT .2no12i33b nodsigim

3(13331 a 3IqrnBx3 iol) 2noi2i33b noi3sifm no sislbw lo 333113 ir1s3flini2 11s3ii2iisi2 bns t23bom £

on 2bnil orlw (IQI) ifIsW 21 noriq33xs rusm 311T .(QQQI) iLIsW bns (QQI) ililloM ni 2w31v31

d3irfw (131w tsi2 iiI,n3d wol (11s3o1) d1 moil 23si2 1113n3d dgid 351113 or noiisiim lo 33fl3biV3

.213b10d 518112

(S3iliLoq bus 311(1011033 nibuE3fli 01 2noi2ul3no3 323(11 lo 3m2udo1 3113 23101qX3 ô 3ldST

33832 323(11 nibbs 213b12n03 31d83 3113 lo bnsq qoi 3111 nisA .thi3n3d D(FIA lo 2inSnhrrI3t3b

Page 26: $IHflM - NBER

-t-

rIi oi tdfthBv rii bbB bnsq monod b liifw i31h isj iuorliiw 1bom th oi 1dBi-1sv

lo iriobn lo n3biv As3w i ith aiifIw iol aflui 31rJ ol 1BIimi .a1h isi rfiiw Ibom

bmiia th aubi () noli flizqa ni tdfihsv 3ifflOnO3 th nibu13ni irfr ni iitnd 1B1Iw

i inmoIqrnnu idgicI cfiiw iJa ni bnuol q&tbi tBm1 lo isi irIgiH .i11 is11w

rft ni 2ftB3ilduq5I iom thiw ionivo nB3ilduq1 rfiiw a1 .mo3f1i i4grI bnB ,gsw irf&ñ

rit gnibbB ,1v3wod 311 3iB tfiiW .qifkbBf1 Ism1 lo ti iwoI 3v6f1 iEn Ei .i311 1I1Ern rf3um B vBd Idshv

noiwbuoD

IdBi1sv bnE ai11 IBubivibni 1J b1us3mnu i3sqmi i&tw nifflBx iqsq iifT

no th1nd 1E1Iw lo 113 rli lo 23JBmii no vf 2iihnd DA lo insnim,b rIi gnilu2s,m

ffl03ffL lo bLfl bass [i moiI b lo 'nwJ io nilJ .noi2izb qkfbaf Ism1

3i13B1B1!3 iol IO1fl1O3 bu13ni Ino on iBrIl qiribrt 1lrn31 lo Ibom B 1i3q w 3irnBnU

lo iol Iottr!o3 oIs iud ldBhBv 1B1Iw bnB 311 1B3 3fim3S1E(f3 is nsmow Ii lo

riliw b31BIno3 Ivithoq 1B ii1nd 1E11w lBth wor1 iIui rIT .i311 (Eubivibni bns 3nbi1

B flu J1u?3I 21U2B diod nibu13x hboM .nmow 1irIw iol 2i311 bnB IBubivibni rtiod

B oi bBI 131h ir1ji r11 nibuIoni bbom 3rf1 IiuIw ia1b 5Ls11w tn&iuingia bitE viiioq

l3Eqfni rü asri ia1h Isubivibni nibu13ni i tsrlT .i1b 1B11w rns3tinini bitE (oi io)

r1i ni1uiqB3 as 1o1h IEi di ot noiisi1qI3irü EE1WBn s vi 2ir!T .ai11 isi iol nuI1oiinoa as

1nEq ion i idi 3ir1w f1obs3!1qqs odi iol awn boos i iiiT .ainbiai iat di lo noiii2oqmo3

.ini11ib 3tiup 1s iIui 3r11 ivworf ,aL3Efd gnomA .is no-oi b&ooq tud IdB1isvE EtEb

i1h 1Ei ninimo bits iiInd is'tIw bits z1z11 i&ia nwid noiisI5no3 on IIButIiv i ir1T

iB1fl ob i113 fubivibni di niitimo ,1v3woH .i11, is1Iw bismb iIi no l3fiqmi on asri

bits llsm i iz113 5mlbw b1Emiia rfi M31b lfiubiVibfli iol Iolino3 w 3flO .asid tsiinai2du S

noiisiim b3ubni is11w iol aiii2nqo1q i,rfirt cJ bnis1qx d (153 21(11' .Ina3fhngf2rn s(fIB3ii2LBi2

Page 27: $IHflM - NBER

01 LG2flJ2 MJJ!CJJ LGJA OU UL-IC ALi9OU MJJCIJ qJC LLG2!0U W C0UU flhJuJnLgq

pcqpb J0LG IJLJIA L)JC UIqA S0 (IIJCLC0LG2 fpC !wb0L4UCC 01 cjo Gxujuøpou

JJJ nqA cILJA JJOM qJ9 JCL !? U0 VEDC pcuj bj? siiX L0J u iwj

jJJ2C LC211J12 JJAC !Wb0I1U !WbI!C!0U2 IOL 1P JIiLU1LC OU MGJILC uq 1CUJIC JJCq2p1b

pjcjc owcu onjq pc nqnj

2?GUJ jpI flG? tP WIqA GXJUJWIIJ luG GGUU3U 01 !U[GL-2G WLU0U bGLu2 01

p? MOWGU Mp LCGL jJCGflpO0q 01 PC0W!U 1GUIG pGsq 01 JJ0fl2GP0IcJ UqCbGUqGIJi 01 lPG MGI1LC

Page 28: $IHflM - NBER

JJJOW 1Ô8 jLcuq Il ywCL!c: E2!W2 IwbJ!c!ou 911q fluqGLJA1u

Ku0M14 o\vj.ouoc iXww •-EIIooq D!q uq oirnqiu cLIJc ioo' EuJ!I cvucvwou BJc VwGL!cu2: jpi qo M

VLLIIGUJCUL2N !U I�icpLq EJJLCUPCL cq 2tt flI X%O AOII1WC ,EIIM0XI DAq iJq ALA O BUG io iv Jwb9c1 04 VEDC OIl }UJ¼ 2PJICUTLG uq r'!A!il

pcqjocjc Up UJOU BICJC LU O!LJN o%W) t)DI1UCUe QL mq 2! HOUWU 1ôô0 Ni4 ucj12e ECOUOW!C bboI4nuqc uq o-o-

JJJC flUIACL2IA O CJJ!IFDIUC1J QLC J4 }1'S2 O\%OJAb }L2 O1 IJIJ LpoL: IJIUUt OL ocJj 1cp3

UJ!UJO

DCIUL V!WC 1ÔÔ5 UJJJ EUCCI O JOUJU2 ECOIJOWIC uqcbuqcuc© Oil flUOU D!2OIflt!OU

/AllLC DcbuqCucA ucsiDL!A HI!tIUJ SIJq WnCJ yL2 Jô8 UCPIJC !13 9JCJC UJJJA nJIculLC: IwbJ!c!ou 4L

EccflOIl!t•c2 VrIn1MC1IPL DLW!UIU2 O4 ECWfC b01LA IJ1 oncjJojq Hqpb11 oiu oDIJ!L pCqoIf QCOL JCnpOIY flJ 2CPML(S uq EflUC 2UJOU2JCA jOLJC uq

t-:ig•CPSU1PCLI!U CiA 1ô20 UV1A2!2 O COAL!1C MLp DW M o\ OIOIXIC

Eqd11C . O\%1tiflI !OIflC% JB!2IJOb O}JW 1ô20 1OP2 CP jLU21L uq 'j PH!A V IGA!GM uq Auqjc o, qi

EUqOCUofl2 bOI!C!C1, V't 4è2Q DCCWPL jfBCJCA J)UJOJA uq VUIJC J4 11flu1rnwL9j EXbCL!WCIJ12 EW!U qiC Iucqwcc O

• JJ 4 OI %ThiI L/Lq flIJ!AGL!A C2•

i ôt NV LIJOL Ot Lu: L'4 !I . \OflU1I o\ COUOI) : J

BCIL GILA JÔ V JJJGOL) O ALLc: LI4 i \ott11 j: 8I-Q2bJJ ou*i omi

JqL? O uq D! EJmooq jQ 2J!bb!u iuio uq yu ot bo4: .u Drnw!c2 O

flUJACL2JA WCMUPCL cq %OJA HI11t ThO DO2U bt cuJpuq: H9LAL

BU LA 1o flHonecpojq Cowbo21!ou mJq boIciA u pcjqou DSUL uq DU!CJ

BGLGLGUCG

Page 29: $IHflM - NBER

vt'u"o2 bb j-j•iô N1cuL E1C12 O 1p fl2 MCItSLC 2iw: V JçcAJG/&

• 1ôOP I.H2 2i D!L!PflhiOU b01!CA QLOMIJ OLC '1t%OS1%

nc bb ioi-rvOUjUa }çOpcL JO LP EUC O qic fl ficILc 2AW ou Affl4} ornc o\

Honwojq D o%citi) (YNCFUPU 2L !Ô9 hW!I 21L(1CWL uq CbCUqCuCA: ELIA jLUOIJ o }CW1JC

flU!AGL2!A }L02 iô cupiq

2flPUflJJ!J1C OflU1 St1IHflCIJCU2 KOPCLt QOL cnpou uq 2'I 2cpM9L1 1o8o 4VhDC Uq qiG }OLWOU 04

j:j-couqou Ot%2 'çc) os 'y'n cicHflPGL hi JÔQ U.LPC BCPA!OL O SX!WnUJ flJCqiOOq E2I!UJ12 flIJqCL 4ou-uqLq

flb hOI4pCOW!U cco%owcu.ccrHO?U H!I' M!I1!'°J J MGJL 1LIJtL2 Iii jMO-bLCU Lwll!: ..LPC C O1VhDC-

2LflCP1L miq MR.LC fl DC!2!0U O yOLcq OL cbicq owcu ottucs orn• 1ô82 4V CowbL!ou ocpOJCc-B2cq I1!uoIJ iiq r°i oqcj: jpc wijA

4LJ! D!LflW!0U UJJ1JJOHOUWIJ flj uq 0L DnUCIJ JÔÔ U1P EUC1 O IIJCOUJC 'J1 VEDC BUCJ2 OU

04 I.L1C TWOU B!C!C suq JC ftOIiJGU1 UJ!WOMOWCU DO fPOL ALJCC ILC uq jc!ppoLpooq jCOL VCCOflIU 4OL DcCIPI!U

HOWJJIJ 2"I 0L DflUCU mq jouiq IJC IàU LL 9uq MCJ4LC fl2C VIJJOU AOflU

vnwbqou2 Ill ECOUOWCL!C yjoj 4OL DflL!OU DI, :5J-3jHGCJCWJ ISIJJ 1cI B1I4OU 2!UL I8t. .v vWo 4OL AHJ!wJs!IJ ipc iwbci o DJ2pipnqouJ

QOJ¼CLIJWCUI bL!WiU Ot4JAOIflUJC I ' MIJ!ULOu DC: fi2

QLOCUGAGI r'Aic YUCIJI HUUU uq J4JUCA jflW tJJJC flLp1J IU21!Wi WG0LU1JJIe ILN1 suq L9 !ÔQ %%1 1I°W 1 C%' MPuou DC:

Cfl2G14 Ob1tO* D bUIU% tm

Page 30: $IHflM - NBER

xc% '%,o iw\. ",ai113 £5!A rfiiw qffkbsH fsmT no aiTt3 isllW" .1QQI ______ .ô€ô-1ô .qq ()Q %o51

is1bW no rnsioiq bisaibM rfi lo b113 ,rIT" .QQ! .1IoW sisths8 bns fldoR ,flhtIoM ti uoso \o w't9 ".1qqu2 iodsJ bits noiisqbfiis

aAoo8 iasa :*ioY wVI ,O%Q-O.Q. o% tho?. wiiniK ioi ,hsrD srwM .8Q1

bits anoi1uiiiri1 isbbu8 10 i113 dT :3i1D Isi! ot noq$I isj2" .€QQI .mst sthJoq .'jnoio o'to Swnot iii aimo3thIot ",3i3ilo1

"O8Q1 rIj moil 3nbiv3 :niisdbfic1D bo1bW-1o-iuO bits is11WM .OQQI .rido$( bimo1q tno ii&\o \oniio\.

fflO3flI lo iodT 3rrnono3a-o3ijiloq A" 28Q1 .iiniW bisibi$l bits rido$I ,l3tnjolq .V-8:QV \m\o9 niK "rioiiudhiib$1

btudhiiU IIsmiiqO 1o 23113 th 3niisulsv3" .ô8Q1 .niqf oW r!rnn,)( bits *isM ,iwxnao$! .84'-OV.:(t)ôV ono nomK "msioiq 3ikIIA

S.itnt \o oi t ojw1 \o ni .VQI .1Iir1ws bds2I bits ,risH ,o$L •1c1 winI nsdiU riT :DU noiniiksW .nnoW

1*isM iodsj bits is1bW :1si b1inU ifi ni ii[iri! bn aifls2 fsthsM" .1QQ! .LusI .T iIurL32 .Qô-V€ô .qq ,()Q %twot ",i311H

.aiq 1iaivinU bhdrnsD ,oü \k'o ñvjnK .ô821 .gnrLD ,oisT

o'1 ,O-q iôi .wrD rb lo usiua .2.U .oo1

,O-q tn \oo1% .sIQQ! .wn3D irfi lo usiua .2.U

• 84

•VI ,o4 foo-q tn\3 n 'iok .dIQQ! .wn3D rIi lo usiua .2.U

nukW no tü ni*t .QQ1 .viisiniq5I b woH 2.U nhinhq jnmni,voO .D.U noinidasW

. tno vW no tnno i\o noti\.

•,31'IIO

ninbiW s1T :1u33Ir13 Iim&i bits ji,voq" •8Q1 •nsmbT4 3nul3dis)I bits msilliW no1iW ,i3dni,W binsU bits ,isiisU nobbd iii ",auaI 3jf0q 3iIduq bits &nbiv3 nwid qsE) 1iivinU bisvisH :biidatsD •' noü W tnt .*oW iW1 .vwto% ntV

omim "88QI lo 13A rtoqqu 1imsI rb bits noiisiidsrloD ,DCHA" •FQQI •nnA iIAniW

Page 31: $IHflM - NBER

flUIACL2!fA 04; wr2aonLr 21- rOfl!2

Page 32: $IHflM - NBER

A xibnqqA

bboM igoJ bxiM ioI noii3n&T boodiIIiJ

zinioq A ri3iw noitudinaib i31aaib s mon fiwEib ai () iii ro1 [Bubivibni cfi isth muaaA

noiiudinaib 3ril ti iutriuq 1ifid&foiq rtiiw d n,vig tioqqua to affiioq dT .floqqua lo

nvi bIodwod lo bsd 1sm1 £ ai nmow £ iI1i iiIiddoiq rii nb e3iiaioI 21 eu3 10113 3d1 10

311T .((im+ =1 313r1w i+)' d fl3V1 21 I i11 mobnsi 3t31321b bns atshvo

d n3vi al n3rb Iubivibni 101 boofliI3AiI

(LA) [(i+S). 11 (+)'i rJ r =

.3aiwdio oi bnE b1od32uor1 lo bB3ff 3tEm31 s al is iii s IBubivibni Ii I oX lup al ô 313(w

Page 33: $IHflM - NBER

!2flG22o.c: fl Bm 0, qiG CU2n 'ovLc\o izt Q 3CtçU%UC? AT4OI12

Mp!ie •-•--• BICt

1699 485 .1690 .189900-

I I I I I I

U .rr

CD

Ia)CD

m .5.L2

= 15.V_

C) .555

a)..C •. sees_.5%..— 5S.- _, - 5.-' 5..-,'—

B 3CGLG1*J31c HGII HOnPOIq 3 bLcI °L VII E31tJ!I!G M!W pJqL6& iaQ-JóO

L!1ILG j

Page 34: $IHflM - NBER

2onLc: ° LpflJq0U2 01 TôQ8-Iâ8 b!U1 2Wq 01 IIJCOWC DAU3W!C2

VEDC -- vEDc+Eq!!q

A6.iee ie.s .ie.e .ie.e .iao .1a95 4e8 .iee 499

300— I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I

IIIIIEIIIIt)

e2o••lb ._ee.s_s—

.100•

20-

jLG1J !U I1 V}DC uq joa 1AGIL BGUGU 1Qg-Iô

Page 35: $IHflM - NBER

a)Ca

rrDC)wa,Ca)

C')

a,ciiD0CaF-C')

. C91!40LU!9 —v- III!uo!2 vcpauAG9L

EItTLC 3LU2 !u VLDC OL cjcccq H!I BCU!i

Page 36: $IHflM - NBER

-V V1!22!22!bb! • GeoLaig jexGL

.1099 480 J8.5 J8.I4 J$9 16.9 .1880 .1685 1694 .1699 .1888on- I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I— -,

jLuq U VEDCBCU!OL jcccq J'OM BUC!iLI1ILC

C)Ca

rrDC)

C)CC)

0)

a,Co

0Ca

C')

.100-

.120-

500-

520-

300-

320-

V-\ V

Page 37: $IHflM - NBER

bci.oqDJ!C fiCJ1LC PCUC1jf HLG LCI uq LC SACLdcq OACL tp wcuA-1Mo ?c

wo: B92G1 OU c2qw2 1,LOW woqc ('0 !u i.Pw 3 flW qw 1,LOW qic 1oQ2-Iogo !ucj ewq oj,

0J3 0J4 0J2 OJ OJ. O9 OJB 050 05J O O O' O 059I I I I I I I I

4 V

200 V

900 VV

- VV V

00-V

V V cvV V

900-

800-yMw8e euetj'

C0GI1!0Th B6UU 2i Epq nq JGL8G !1GflfL6 B6uGU

Page 38: $IHflM - NBER

bCLIOq

PJCOWC DJW! MCILC PCIJCW2 LC LCSJ 911q LC CLGq OACL IJIC 1WUfA-iMO'wow: cq ou C2qWi LOW woqcj (t) !u JpJc nu qsw LOW c JôQ8-Jô8 bUC1 2wqo

Q 2 EPq EUe—04 00 03 04 02 02

I I I I I

300-

h/?V

400- VEr

V200-

V900- V VVV

00- V

V

900

800yAeLuce

C0IIi!0U flGMG6U 2LG EP1 ELL6CIq yAGIG M6UJiLG BGUGU2LJflL6 Q

Page 39: $IHflM - NBER

comp!ucq czpAJfl opuqiz iow VEDC ooq rmb uq mcqcsq wjA ol, onr cc ic tOL qGwi2

MflWPCL O OP1.1!0U2

curc (e) oat oi oaxjçcb 2IL HOfl () OôO OJ OJQQ

jb Qo#;i.uoL oixi2bObB19CJC() OJ4 00Q8 OiO OOXI

OJÔ 00302tb0bOACLQ() oin ooo ooio

2W Iucow bc cbi (iooo) ii i

VACLMC jjgucwbjoAuiu JcVhDC-flb 0Q40 0Q1'tMGUPLC BC1JCQ1 QJ4Q JOJô22V 0200J4O KC!J!OU 01NOIIJCL JI!!0U 0082 0 TOG?

1GM!P O.OTô

bL0WIJ1 O9O018Q

cqJoiic oj> oooo.oo o.oJ

VG O )OflUC1 0 J88 OôOWflUJpL oIpIJqLcu I8J JOJQ JJO4

OtJS OOQ-JJ OJ OJQO

EqncloIJ OO OOtXnJQ

DA!OU DMt1OU2wuqLq miq1.q

°1 bID awb1e p L6WIG H6P!b iifl21PJG j

Page 40: $IHflM - NBER

T cowpiucq C2 AJflC opcucJt2 L011 VEDCa (ooq 2WWb !uq uiCqiciq LOL SIJJJ?O L°'' 2 (CXL OL qCIJ2

WIWPCL O OPIJ!OU 10't3 J3881

bCLCIU cu b o't oio oobCLCG1U HOfl KCb o'1 0 1Q 0x 0 J8tgbnpcu QOAUJOL O4QQ 04JbCLCGJUBJCJC O18 OJU 0JÔÔ 01J0

00S8 05t 00JOJJJ 0012 010.X 00JÔ

ucowc bc Cb!1 (1000) 1X T0Q03JtWQJO 81Ô8 14J8

flUCWbIO?UJGU B 00J 13J 3H101

VEDC-flb 0t 0'tMGII.LC BG1JCU1 Q18 TJÔ502L1V 0.80 0.XOJ

L40 gC1OU 0O8 008JOiPL JJ1JOU 0.0 0.010O2IJI 01ô1Bb 0Qvt.X 0Q10cqJoJc 0.0 0.0

> 0t 0N40.4

V O AOflIJC 0ô8WJIUJPCL op!JqLcu itJ

0181J 0. 0410ô-JJ ?CL2 03<a ACL2 0.O 0 104

808X 4Q

DGAqOU DA!!OUwuqq

J4G1J O I21D wbG p L6WJ6 H6WP!b tjirhLP16

Page 41: $IHflM - NBER

iuqq uO1.2 LC pi bi.utpc

O OP2W!0U

uqr jwcq EIACCi2 110 110 U0

2C DflUJUJC2 U0 U0 110 Ac2

DV42!OU DnWW!C2 uo 110

AC DflhiJ1111 Ac2

IucLccb oo (ooi) oo (ooQ) oi (oiog)-ooo (ooo) ooo (ooot) -ooo (ooio) ooi (ooo)

flUGUJbIO?tUJCIU oooi (ooos) ooi (ooo) oooi (ooot) oooi (ooo)o cjitou ooi (ooo) oo (ooi) oo (ooii) oolo (ooo)OWCL KI!!011 oo (ooi) oo (oo) -oot (ooso) -ooio (ooi)

oo (oojo) oo (ooi) oo (ooj) ooo (ooo)-oo (ooo) -oo (oo.x) -oo'x (ooi& -ootx (ooii)

RSb!2 0004 (ooo) oot (oot) oo (ooi) -ooo (cioi 1)oot (ooo) oo (ooi) OOJ (ooi) ooo (ooo8)

J4flIIJPCL O4 CpJq -oo (ooo3) -oon (oooe) -ooo (ooo4) -oo (ooo)V A01'J >2 OOQ (ooJ3) oo (ooi) oo (ooi) oogo (ooo8)vc Aonuc oo (ooii) ooo (ooi) oo (oo3o) ooo (ooo)qncpou -01J2 (ooi) inJ (ooo) -oii (oo) -oJt (oo)Eqncou 13 -0114 (oo13) -oi (ooi) oit (ooi) -oi (oo)qflC!ou a-u -0031 (oo13) -ooo (oo3Q) -oo (oo) -oo (oo)

-00o1 (oooi) -ooo (oooi) -oooi (oooi) -ooo (oooi)VhDC-flb ooo (oooa) -000Q (ooio) -ooo (cvol3) -oooa (ooi)

oooe (wood) ooi (ooo) ooJi (ooio) 0005 (oooQ)

(1) (3) (3) (4)2tc1t %-%1t

rmcøL ILOp5pflA joqqbLWGLE41WØG LOL L6W96 flq2pb ]/JO6J

Page 42: $IHflM - NBER

LLOL2 in bcu1pc2c

0j OP101J

uq E!X1 E4121L DffUJIJJ! 130 C2

D!A!!0U DPUJW!G2 130 130

AL DRWIJJ!G2

IULbV1GL 0001 (ooo) ooos (ooot)flUWb!0AW1J1 o000 (oooi) -0001 (oooi)40 1C!JZ0U

OPCL 1CI!!0UbL0G21U

LCM!P

2Ys12V oou (oooQ) ooss (000Q)I4I1UJPGL O flLC13 000ô (ooos) -ooog (ooos)V A011U > ooo (ooo) 004ô (ooo)v A0flU ooi (ooot) oo5 (ooo)EqC0U > 15

Eqfl10U 15EqflCiOIJ -J I

0005 (ooo) 0005 (ooo)VEDC-flb -OOJQ (oooQ) 0055 (ooo)MC1LC BCUCUI 0005 (o'oo) -0005 (ooo)

() (Q)

xucwc£bc

- oupuncq

flUG8L opJpfflL) 1OqGJJ9LmJJ6iGL UJG LOL LGW5IG HGP!b oqj

LpI j

Page 43: $IHflM - NBER

tnqLq CLIOL2 LC IJ buWc

% O1 OPL/I!0UAL DfWIW!Cgcb HOflG () 0•004 (0 !o5)jcb 2CUC () o04 (o103)KCb QOAGLUOL oooo (oon)KID2\bOb -31Qô (ixi) -noo (o8o)VCED\bOb (vJ) oo (J3Jo)VEDC CG\bOb 33 (r4i3) ii (io) (o)2ll1C\bOb (J000) ooo (ooio) -ooo (ooo) -ooo (ooi)VACLM 0008 (ooio) ooo (ooi) ooo (oo13)flhJCWbIOAUJGIU ic O00 (0003) OOO (ooo3) 000Q (woo8)VLDC-flb -ooie (oojo) -ooie (oo14) -ooi (oooo) -oo (oo!Q)Mc1L BCUCU oooi (oooQ) ooot (oooQ) ooot (ooo?) 0003 (ooo8)

(1) (3) (3) (4)

( ' x'% O OP2LAI!OU 3,33 533 533 335ACL DnUJW! ?c ?c ?c2 ?cgcb H0112C () 003 (oo)j,cb 2CU () -0001 (oJ32)jçcb QOAGLIJOL oooo (oo14)K1D\bOb -J33 (oO2) -Jo08 (o)VGEDbOb -oe (oo) -oio (o93)VLDC C2\bOb 33X1 (1 3) I QXO ( 13Q) I ô (1 3 14)2flMC\bOb (1000) 0001 (ooo) -o'oo (oooQ) -0008 (ooo)VACL HC 000. (ooo3) 0014 (ooo8) 0013 (ooi)flUCUJbjOXWCUI J� 000X (ooo5) ooo (000vt) ooo (oooe)VEDC-flb 0o11 (ooi) -0013 (ooo) -0013 (o018) -00J4 (oo3)

cuGui 001! (ooo) ooo (ooo) 000Q (oooQ) ooo (oooQ)

(1) (5) (3) (4)

joq t) ni

yqqu CODP.0IbL5W6tL Ei!UJ LOL LWBJ6 lJOq6I

Page 44: $IHflM - NBER

uqiq CUOI2 ic !U biuip

O OPLML!01J

iUq LPC1 EtGC 110 110 DO DO

2LC DnWW!C DO DO DO

D!A!210U DflWIJJ! DO DO

AL DnWIJJI2 )c2

I1ULCCb( -0041 (oogQ) O'OQ (ooi) oi (oo2?)VACLC M -003 (ooo) -0034 (oo31) 0 03Q (oo) 00 (ooo)flhJCUIbjOAWGZU B -00? (oot) -00ä4 (oon) ooj (olo?) -0JL (oo)MO I1!!OU 0001 (oo) -0011 (oo3Q) -OOJ? (oo52) -00 (ooQ)OLPCL JCJiiOU 004. (oo) oo (oo) 0049 (oo) ooi.x (oo9)

ooi (ooo) oo (cvooQ) oo (ooo8) oo (ooi)B9b ooi (ooo4) ooi (ooo4) ooi (ooot) ooi (ooo?)

0014 (o014) oo (ooi't) oo (ooi) -000? (ooI?)WIWPCL Ot cpqqLcu -0001 (oo04) -ooo (ooo) -ooo4 (oim) -000? (ooo)yc onu > oo (oo14) OO9 (oo14) oo (ooi) 00Q (ooJ?)VG onu ooi (ooJ4) 000Q (0o14) ooia (oo12) o0o (ooi)EqncOIJ > J -0i0 (oo) -01e3 (ooi) -oiQo (oo) -0J.2 (oo)Eqncou 1 -OIOQ (ooio) -o0o (ooi) -oo (oo) -0105 (ooio)qncuou o-i I ooos (oojo) ooJ (oo1a) oosi (o'oso) -0004 (ooi)

-000? (000i) -000? (ooo) 0004 (oooi) 0004 (ooo)VEDC-flb 0034 (ooJ) oox (oo18) oosx (ooio) oo (ooo)

i' ucii oosi (ooo) oo5 (oooQ) ooo (oooa) oos (ooJ I)

(1) (s) () (4)

T!UGBL bLOpBpu' flOGJbBL8WG6L EUJLG LOL LGIWJIG HIPb jgoqq

jppJG

Page 45: $IHflM - NBER

mIqVLq CLLOLV via W bviupavQr

0 OPi!°'J

uq h!I EUc2 AG2

1SG D1IWW!G2 110 AC2

DM121011 DIWJW!2 110 110

AG DnUJ1IJ!C2 ?G2

VAGLG1IG -ooo (ooot) 0oo (ooo't)fluGwbjoAwGul ics oooi (ooo5) oooi (0003)M0

IJGL IGt!!0UbL0iG211U

BSb1!2

2I2V -00R (ooo& ooot (oo!o)L411WPGL 0 pqi.cu -0'00 (o0o3) -ooo (o0o3)V A0U2 > ooi (ooo) ooi (ooo)v A0fl11 3- 0010 (ooot) ooo (ooot)EfICP0U > 13EflC0U 13qffCU0U -I I

0001 (ooo3) ooo (ooo)VEDC-flb -0013 (oooa) -0011 (ooio)

0003 (ooot) -000 (ooo't)

() ()%UM3

-

F!°' bLOPPII!t i°q'iIILW4cL UJJ LOL LGWØJG HFP!b qoq€u

LPIG

Page 46: $IHflM - NBER

UOL2 VLG UI ipG2

e 01. OPGL1L!0U2

AG9L DflUJUJ!G AG?

Jb* H° () oQo (oi)gb usi () -04I0 (014!)JçGb GOAGLUOL -ooi (oon)KID2\bOb -1010 (1J) -0QVOED\hOb -3213 (rto) -3188 (ri.)VEDC C2GbOb -08't (3'tJ) -I38 (32) -Q8 ( i't)2WOb (1000) oooi (oooi) oooo (ooo3) -0001 (oooi)

ooog (ooii) ooo (oo13) ooo (ooJJ)flIJcwbJoAwGIU Bi 0030 (oooQ) oojg (ooog) ooi.x (ooo)VEDC-flb oo (oo) ooi (oo) oos.x (oo4) oog2 (oo)

11. BGUGW oo (oo13) oo (ooii) ooo (oou) oo (ooio)

(1) () (i) (!t)

(1JO ) U

04 OP2A0112 31 3'I 31'tAG'L DUWWIG? AG? A2 AG? AG?

JGb H0flG () o322 (o1J&KGb () -OOOQ (o ii!)J.çGb GOAGLIJOL -003't (ooJ4)KID2\bOb 0331 (f3) (os.)VCED\bOb o't (o3oo) oi (oi)VEDC C?2G\bOb -002.i (ito) 0310 (F!2) -13 (i)2LIWC\bOb (1000) oon (ooo) oon (ooo) ooa (oooo)VAGLG o•oi (oooQ) o018 (oooQ) -ooot (ooo)fluGwbioAwciu B9c oo (ooo) ooi (ooo) 003Q (ooo)VEDC-flb oo (ooJ) oos (oo3o) OO (0030) OO (o031)1GI?LG GUGJ oott (oooQ) oo (ooo) oo (ooo) 0030 (ooo)

0) 3) ()

VO %t (3') U 1$I ')

vqqu couti.opL8WGGL ?4IWG tOL LGWUJG HGPP!b 1,loqGJ

ILPJG Q

Page 47: $IHflM - NBER

uqvLq CU.OL VLC ID bvupcG

* O OPUi!0U2ro rjiooq -iowuqow piq E4PCi2 Do uo

D1mM11!G UO 00

DIA1!0U DffWW! 00 A2 110 110

AL DIIJJGIULCGb -ro (oio) -i (oi)oot (ooi) oo (ooi) oioo (oot) ooi (oo)flUGwbI01WGu J� ooX (ooi) ooo (ooi) OOQO (oo12) oocg (ooo)o jcpiou (oo) (ooe) (oo) 0 io (oo*)JGL Jpiou oi (oox) oo (ooxt) oou (oo) -0Q (oir)

oi (ooti) oi (oo) owi (ooi) o!gg (oo)1GM!2P oo (oJo4) -oei. (oio) (oio) ooo (o'oo)B4! ooi (ooi) oi (oot) oii (oo) oo (oo)2LA2V oi (oot) oo (oot) 0!QI (oo) oi (ooo)nwpc o, ot (ooi) -o (oow) (oow) ot (ooio)V AO111G > oo (oo't& oo (ooto) ooo (ooo) oai (oo)V A0'U oa (ooi) oa (ooi) oo (oor) -0Q31 (oJoQ)qncou > j -i (oo) -io (oo) -iio (oo8) -ii (oo)qncou -in (ooi) -rio (oo) -rit (o'ot) -i (ooi)qt1CSOU j -oii (oot) -oo (ooQ) -o (oo) (oo)

-oo (ooo) -oo (ooo) -oot (o003) -oo (ooo)VhDC-flb -ooo (oot) OOQ (oo22) -oo (oo8o) -ooo (oat)fiGJ1. cuqr ooo (ooig) ooco (ooi) ooi (oo) 0010 (ooto)

(1) () (3) (4)

w'q F°!t 11°II8LWG1GL IIJ8 O1. LGWJJG HGFP!b ii°qu

18p1G V-I

Page 48: $IHflM - NBER

-A 9(dJZT

kboM qiikbasH 918m&I iol a3amit3 I939mr1kI I9bOW iigoJ b9xit

nno'fl *u

() (E) () (1)

(140.0) V80.0 (0.0) 81.0 (140.0) 810.0 (800.0) V1.0 fftn38 itIW (10.0) 1E1.O (8U.O) (1O.0) 880.0 (O.0) 8U.0 'ltJ-D(RA (100.0) V00.0- (00.O) 4O.0- (00.O) £0.0- (100.0) 1O.0- (80.O) 40.0 (440.0) ô10.O (no.0) Q0.0 (0.0) €0.0 I 1-Q flOliS3Ub3

(V80.O) M.0- (140.0) 184.0- (0.O) Q.0- (i0.O) nO4.0- 1 noii3ub3 (Q0.0) 048.0- (Vt0.0) 18.0- (440.0) 4.0- (E0.0) 81V.0- 1 < noi3sub3 (801.0) 811.0 (X0.0) ono.o (VO.O) 1O.O (0.0) 810.0 iagnuoY A (IVO.0) 41.0 (140.0) V8LO (0.O) 8U.0 (lnO.0) Q.0 < gnuoY A (810.0) 0.0- (Q00.0) 0.0- (800.0) 0.0- (ô00.0) E0.0- n3lbIirlD b idrnuM

(V0.0) Q80.0- (0F0.0) 0.0- (?.0.0) ô1.0 (lnO.0) 8ô1.0 AM2 (0.0) V80.0 (140.0) OVO.0 (p00.0) 80.0 (0.0) 841 .0 91851 in3nioIqm3nU

(OQO.0) 0ô0.0 (Và0.0) 0o0.0 (ô10.0) 4V0.0 (80.0) 011.0- sW 913vA (Q0.0) Q00.0 (0.0) V0.0 (110.0) V0.0 (10.0) 0.0- iiJqEa (101.0) Q81.0- (ô40.0) Q.0- (.10.0) E0.0- (110.0) 1.0- (Q1.0) 801.0- (80.0) 8ôô.0- (V0.0) Fô.0- (00.0) V0.0 noii[$1 l3ffiO

(QOl .0) Q81.0- (40.0) £1.0- (0.0) a8n.0- (Q00.0) QQO.0 noiib51 o'1 (.0) £8V.0- (8Q0.0) oro.n-

29immuU iY on on on immijU noiziviG

Off On 9imrnhJU 33E1

On 011 011 133T13 .ibril mobn$$l

1111- 1Q01- Qt1- ôô1- boofiibiiJgoJ anoii6v1dO o %

.3a3d1n5I&q iii ii ou bithn&J2

Page 49: $IHflM - NBER

1omprncq cp nc o CDCJ12 tww VEDC' ooq twb aq wcqciq oi wjA ot onr 2CC Icri tOL qcj

WWPCL 0j OP2CLA!OU2 3100

geb 2WL 2CU () 04O OR8 03&12iL HO"2 () O3Ô OJSÔQOALIJOL 0'tJ 033

2bObBICIC() oit o.o oi 0080J2

21L bob O Q () 0114 O0O 0113 0'O0vixc Cg bc cb!w OOJQ 0.0 00U 0053wm picowe bci cbi (1000) 11 10ô I Q84 TI 454 1 3Q

R1 8ÔQQ F534 8833 1550flucwbJo?wuI i�ic 05J 558J QQ5VhDC-flb 0ô0 0Q4MdllPLCBCUU1 Q3QOQ 14300ô Q838. J3I2Q2N2V 0Q58 0.QJL40 KCI!!OU 0158 OOÔQ

OP I{I!'°" 003 0 10$MI2JJ 0OI 0099bLO13IU 03Q 0343

01Q8 OJQ4cqoll 0.Sfl osos

> 0Q08 018003

V O A°f'1 0I0 0583WWPCL O1 cp'iq 184 Job 5155 IJQ9

>I3L2 05JQ0911 0250

-JJ 05ô4 0I200.18 0'044

VG 33815 81ô8 344.18 8Jô8

CU DCA!!OU DCAI!OUwuqq

o( js ubj€ p) .ws€ flGsqpb1PIG B-I

Page 50: $IHflM - NBER

C0uP!1 cvp iønc o, pucj tow VIc ooq uJb2 uq wcqcq LOL Lsw!IA o onv cc i OL

L4fIWPCL 0j OPLA!OU

CLCU CIJL JCb o1 oJo oi 050QbLCU HOfl2C gth Oô 01Q2 018Qcbnpticu QOACUJOL Ot OtJQLCLCUBJC!C O1ô OT OSO1 010ô

OJ OO 0531 00310110 0018 010Q 001ô

VLDC C2 bcL Cb1 00JQ 00N 00I 0013IUCOWG bL Cb!W (iooo) Ti IVAGLcM WQJ I8flhJCWbJO?WIUVEDC-flb 03MCIII. B'Wi 1QQ2Y12V O?L40 JfCJ!OU 008 008JJGL gC!iOU 0050 O.010bLOW 0i8 OsloBb 0Q? OQIJCP0I!C O0X 0.O

> O•t2 011O•530 0540

V O JO11U <1 0301 O13QJ,1tTUIPL O I 15

>J3AL 0iX 05J013 O8X 01OJ0-11 1L O.QJ

qncou O.o 0 i033t4Q fli g.5JQ

V1U DCA!!O11 tSjIJ2wuqLq

'wit'

GUIJ °L G mIJbI6 p)k LGWIG HIPibJ,pIG 11-3