23
ﺑﺮﺭﺳﻰ ﻋﻮﺍﻣﻞ ﻣﺆﺛﺮ ﺑﺮ ﻓﺮﻫﻨﮓ ﺳﻴﺎﺳﻰ ﺩﺍﻧﺸﺠﻮﻳﺎﻥ ﺩﺍﻧﺸﮕﺎﻩ ﺁﺯﺍﺩ ﺍﺳﻼﻣﻰ ﻣﻄﺎﻟﻌﺔ ﻣﻮﺭﺩﻯ: ﺩﺍﻧﺸﺠﻮﻳﺎﻥ ﻭﺍﺣﺪ ﭘﺎﺭﺱﺁﺑﺎﺩ ﭼﻜﻴﺪﻩ SPSS

ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

�������������� ������� �������������� !" #$#%&'� �()!

بررسى عوامل مؤثر بر فرهنگ سياسى دانشجويان دانشگاه آزاد اسالمى مطالعة موردى: دانشجويان واحد پارس آباد

����������� ������������

���������� ��������������

����*��*�+,-! .��/.� &����*��*��,0 .1�/.� &

چكيده .1� 2� 32456782����9�� ��':9; ��<49=>2��?�5 ��>.>��493. @ A );��9B $BC�� !� ��':'D� <'DB7&�>��9(E45 ��7%��� F�4�493.G$�H��I��4�'D� <5 J;49B $B�4� F :5��47�'(�<�49�7K .9(�5�4� !��-$��4L �A4� ��;49B $B5 :4 :':� #�;4'F5�7M':N���9�9B� :O��P�G.4�4Q>�I��4�R S&�4'D� <TDB7&57�U4 :'�$�2���9B $BC�� ! :'F-B49B B4OB �I>� :9�� :VL� �>A4�9�WB4�4�V� �X24�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! :�41= $YZ&[�47;9�WB4�4�V� �X24�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! : Y\�[�47;]-B4�V/B �^ S2�':O��P�G.4'F_`$�249.4 =a�1�9.4 =b7K5 � $c��'F-B4�V�49F AO��P�" @� 8�I-B4d� :VL� �>A4� @ AO��P���I>2�4�9B $BC�� ! :�4�9�D�54'e:4�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��-$)f�9B $B" ;WM45��V� =�4̀ :4�47�;':g'� 2OB �h9S�FTSA )��4�g � $c��G$:9���S��i72�4h9X. �$�0���4[$(%&�'.̀ �&54 :SPSS�4̀ !4b 2�5� �V0���4G$�H��N-B4�>��� 8�B4 �OB �':9.7=/B �54 :C�� !�9B $B_`$�24G$:'e:4��7<�̀ <':'F-B4�V�49F AO��P�j. �2I-B4�>�'�! =� ?: ���4�92 ��-$DK7�'F-B4a(e�G.4_>���� X2'(k��G.4I>X2>$.Z&l$#%&" $@ !�4b4>Fm$�� .7=/B �9B $B9. �'. n292 ���92 3�-$DK7��4"� 8��� .7�X24�oS&':�� :VL� �T#e��9B ��b7: :�F A92 3��

I-B4�>�'p4�4'�$��G.4��'F-B45� )�K49; ��<4 � �. � 9B $B C�� ! � :VL� � >A4� �4�V � �X24� � .7�X24� ,���� ���!"#�

I�4 !4-$)f�i729B $B_`$�249.4 =a�1�9.4 =b7K

�������������g^7k���>��.72h�72b $�� �X24�9B $Bb7(;� .� �B4�9�(;-k$�7J;I�I� :VL� �>A4�9�WB4�4�V� �X24�9B ��'D� <�� =9�(;-k$�7J;I�

I�72b $�� �X24�9B $Bb7(;>��49B ��� F57�X24�I�I�72b $�� �X24�9�(;-k$�7J;I�

Page 2: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

�23

مقدمه ':'F��4�9; ��<45>D:O.7q5� !>Dr: :��W;9�D.N-B49; ��<45�7<7�� �24� �!�O.7q9; ��<49=>2� $����� �24I>��9� $���4" $A':�9�D��4-$2 �24':-B�O.7qTD� <�4 !4 :7B�� 2�7B���� $=9�� .4��4 �.� :[� D&�O�F5 �O�F �� ?2�V������� �24'F-B49. �� ?2�4[3X��92 �24TD� <I>2�9�O�F9B $BC�� !� >� :9�9B $B5 �� ?2 �� ?2G. &�?��493.I�� B9�9(�;4��7q_�4>24 &�-B49; ��<45 �b n2j.4�5 �7�U4�49Xf:9B $B5 �� ?2�493.�47�;':

Ig��+s :��h��4��4 K�V5� =��9B $B5 �b n2-$;� X�5� .�56782�-B49; ��<49=>2� .1� 2̀ . =_>.>���>��4�����'F9B $BC�� !�>��_>�;5 �tq ��� F�4�493.��4�'D� <5 J;49B $B� �!� : .1� 2� 3249B $B5 :4 : :9B $Ba&4 �'(�(B':�� :'�$��G.4��I���9�� ��':'D� <TDB7&9(�5�4� !�':O.4 =9��4 2 .-$��4L �A49�$:07q�9�$:>:5� ��;49:�� ��;45 �7�U4 :�VoS&':�9B $BC�� ! :'F-B45��47�'(�<�4� $u�9�7K5�4� !� .-(�-U��-�73A"�>K':R7: �5 �� 3.��I��4�9�$#���Te:4�'D� <TDB7&v7#A5 :4 :9; ��<4-U4>;9B $B-F� X�9B4 F7��5�4�V-$;� X�-$�F A5 E �; �.��4`$2-B $B5� �(K':R7: �5 ��>.>� �.��9B $B-.7�9B B49B $BC�� ! :'�$�2�����4�'D� <w.>. #;� �0��4 ��� :��'X.�'F-B4O�7�9B $B9; ��<4 $c��G.4'F54�� ��=T��4� :G.4 : �:I-B4R S&�4��'D� <�V�V :'F9(�47;�9B $BC�� !TDU e�'D� < �X$:-q ��54 :'F-B4G���>��9�

Ig��+s :���>27�UVh>B�9� n2':5�� @��41=9� $YZ&� q5 �5 $=o@7�� � 3!� M ��� : �0��4�454';7���':9B $BC�� !� �V x(�f� 5 �-��K � 9B $B b n2 ': 9. �O.4 = [� � 'F >�F9� �� �4 9B $BG.4��Ig���,��y��4 �.�� �U �h>� :9�9B $Bb n2��O.7qO#2':9. �O.4 =9B $B[�47;':924��5 �O.4 =5 �D�':9B $BC�� !'F-B4>#�D��>27�UV'�$���7q�������� $=9� :��4�9B $Bb n2 �'F-B �O.4 =�49�$D�57�U4�-B49B $B[�47;': -S�2'F9. �O.4 =�4 9B $BC�� ! &l$K��7M': I>��9�5 <1. Almond

Page 3: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

�2.��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

C�� !`$2�92�G$�BV_>$#;':Ig��,���s57(;h>.7=9�GfB>24�>�5 $=-?<9�$n;Of:� $�'F-B4-B $B_� :�� 38&5 ��7$��454';7���-(�w.9B $B��9B $Bz� D&'F���V9���4 !4�924��9e$%��>� :9�{ �X�'D� <�4 !4�49�q ��5 $=-?<-�f2,-B4�>�[$3X&Of:���4��7�9�b �24�V|7}� ?}9�D�': 98M ;5 �5 $=-?<5 �.��9B $B" ;7@7��4 9� =V�iWM49�D�':

Ig�����,���+92�h" ;7@7�G.4':R7: �" 2 �$��" B �A4�>. #; �0��4�49�$D�57�U4�4-B4"� S;9B $BC�� !~ :x.� D&':b ���4 :9B $Bb n2��4� ?2V5 �5 $=-?<�9: .��4��>.� =92���'D� <�4 !4�`2'F9. �9� =V5 ��� :9B $B5 �0��44�9B $BC�� !x(�f�5 �'S�<�47&9�G.4 : �:N>�F9�G$$D&-B4927= 27=[�47;�4 YZ��9; ��<4_>.>� �G.4 :��W;I� F� $:9B $BO24��9B $B9� �&�4 YZ���'D� <�V9(FC�� !�4 YZ��'D� < �9B $BC�� !I>��9�[3�4��V'F9S$F &9�� B9B $BC�� !I� $=9�[3�� qTD� <w.��'F-B49; ��<45 ��>.>�

Ig���y�(#U4o. Bh>� :9� �0 �2�>. #; ��� : �0��4�454�`$�V'F��4�'D� <�WF )�; :-X�24� X& . n2��9B $BC�� !�� F� e� :� :���>27�UV :���>27�UVh-B4'D� < �.� E �; �X$: _>��F-.4>�'F>2�41=9�C�� !9�D.':�7q5� �!�-$U D!Ge:��9B $Bb n2 �]'F-B4�V :>27�UV[. : =Ig��+s� $=9�'�X} B ?2V�4b n29B $B5 �b4>K4'F-B493��54�P.�O.4 = :5 �7�U4� #�;45�Ig��,���+�4� ?�hd>� 29�9B $BC�� !4�O.4 =5 �7�U4'27=G.45�9B $BC�� !�� q�C�� !5 �7�U4':4� �O�$: ?�&'2]9B $B�>�9; ��<4'F��4�'3(:>. �29�'$SD&4�9. �'�32'D� <�>�9; ��<45 �>�.V !'3(:>Xf:9�l$�D&'D� <>��9��4 K'D� <��4�9& 32���41=9�O. �2':4�C�� !�49E q E �;� �-$8$F>$U7&� : ': 9B $B�>�9; ��<4 �.� � $: ': I>��F9�^ ��F . [.>D& 4� 4`<4 G.4 'F����,��+� .6G=hd>�F9�4>$�R S&�4� q9B $Bb n2� F� F54 :b�~5 �0��4>�247&9�>2�4��7<��>�9; ��<4��'F9. � $c��b �&'F-8=�47&9�G.4 : �:Ig��+9B $B_`$�24"W$)%&-$�7K5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �I>�� :�41= Y49B $BC�� ! :>�F9�9=>2��V��� !'F9; ��<4-$DK7��>�F9�4>$�[3�'D� <��'F9�$)f�i72

I>���[3�4��4 !49B $BC�� !5 Y\�[3�':>�247&9�'F>����9(�47;'(�<�41. Austin Ranney2. Almond and Verba

Page 4: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��2

9B $B-F� X�_� :��9B� :��%:��9B $B9B ��'D� <�4� �'. n2�04�[3. ��>�9; ��<49M� !'F��4�9�� $:�>�F9�� e�4�9B $BC�� !��>�9; ��<4�%:,>�F9�� $:04�I>�F9�4>$�-q �� ?2V_� :���� $=9�� .4�9. �0 �2� �0��4� �. ��7eBb �&��9B $B-F� X�'F��4��7<�54�� ��=��4�4 !>�47��{�4>�]��'F54'�$�� :9B $B�$%��-$)f�-$�7Ka�1�GB-$��<5� )�K49; ��<45 n2^>���04�[3. �Ig���,����04�hd>�F9�v !� $=9�"�7E-F� X��V� e�9B $BT�$�� .�$%��47�;':4�9B $BC�� !9B $B� �!�':���-B�_� :���7q9�q B�47�;':9B $BC�� !G.4 : �:N>� :�41= $YZ&9B $B� �!� :>247&9�'F>�F9�'(�<�4I��4��7<��>�� e�9; ��<4�$%���'F>� :�>D��[�47;�4 YZ��>247&9��WF�$%�-$)f�-$�7Ka�1�GB-$��<5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �':�47&9�[�47;G.4

I� F�� �4>����9; ��<49B $B�$%�':�>���-q B'F9(�47; . B�9; ��<49&� 8��5 � XK�4[3X��'D� <'F-B4G.4��4�9B B4-$��4 ��.4��'H2V �4'(�<�4I>�F9� 8.49B $B9; ��<4-F A� . <��"� 8��9X#25 XK �'F-B4�� ?<�� $q45 �'�����7)q':9B B4O#2��47��'F9; ��<4�?�5 � XK9B $B5 �OS�<� �.4�; :'F>24��7:� .7�X24�-B4'��4��4 .4� ��7XF��G$�H���?�[�47;�493.�47�;':9B $BC�� !I>24�>�9B B49B $B9; ��<45 �-F A�9B $B5 �b n2 :9Xf:-$;� X��� .1� 2� 324 9X#29B $B5 �� ?2 ���41= $YZ&9B� :54 :>247&9��7XF���7<7�5 �� �X24��493.�47�;':� :VL� �� �X24�I��4�

I� $=�4 K'DU e��O��P���7�'. n2G.45��7�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! : Y\�[�47;O��B�9B� :Q>� : @ AO��P�^ S2�':O��P�G.4'F9(E4OB �I-B4�>�G.�>&� :VL� �>A4�9�WB4�4�V� �X24���I>� :9�� :VL� �� �X24�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! :�41= $YZ&[�47;N-B4�V/B �

I-!��$�47qO��P�5 �'�! .��4 B':5 n2|7}� ?}�Q4>�4� $: :'�4�4

اهداف تحقيقN� :VL� �>A4��4�V� �X24�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! :�41= $YZ&[�47;G$$D&�

1. Michael Rush

Page 5: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

�����45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

N� :VL� �>A4��4�V� �X24�� .7�X24� :9B $BC�� !T. n2�7��V�� �X24�� .7�X24�G$:��9B $B5� =� B�9B $B� �!� :�41= $YZ&[�47;G$$D&�

I� :VL� �>A4��4�V

چهارچوب نظرى5 �'S�<�4b4>F �'F-B498(�f�5 �'. n2�4[3X��l$#%&G.45 n2|7}� ?}��7��$� 8�� � $c��b4>F ��>24'�q4� �9B $BC�� !_>.>�':5�>D���x(�f�04�[3. �I>24�� F9B� :�� e�9B $BC�� ! $c�� :5�41= Y4��4��7q n2�%: 9B $B -F� X� _� :�� 9B� : � �%: �� 9B $B 9B ��'D� < �4� �'. n2�>�9; ��<49M� !'F��4�9�� $:�>�F9�� e�4�9B $BC�� !��>�9; ��<4,>�F9�� $:04�I>�F9�4>$�-q ���V_� :���� $=9�� .4�9. �0 �2� �0��4lSM�7eBb �&��9B $B-F� X�'F��4��7<�54�� ��=��4�4 !>�47��{�4>�]54'�$�� :9B $B�$%��-$)f�-$�7Ka�1�GB-$��<5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �>�F9�� X2 M q5�Ig���,����04�hd>�F9�v !� $=9�"�7E-F� X��V��'FL B4 :9B $B-F� X�G$�H��I��`!4`$24�>?D&�o: �� �"� ?�>. :[�47;G.4':'F5 �-$)f�54�4��4 !4�4>#� �^ ���7M':N-B4"� 8��`$2� !9)f�5 �9=P.�'��4�5 �X$:-$U D!9B $B n2�4'F��4�^ ��A4>�� : &4 =�� :� &�(�� &9; ��<4N��41=9� $YZ&-F� X���54'nAW��7q���7M':`$25� )�K49; ��<4� �. �I>�� :-B4G3��9B $BC�� !'F n2G.4�4N��4�-$��4`$29B $BT�$�� .�$%�G$�H��v7X��3; : .>�Fl.7X&�7�9�9#(&aB ��'F4�-F� X�5 �"�7E .-F� X�

Ig��s���+� ��h>� S2-F� X��47�;':4�9B $BC�� !9B $B� �!�':���-B�_� :���7q5 n2^>���04�[3. �G.4 : �:N>� :�41= $YZ&9B $B� �!� :>247&9�'F>�F9�� e�9B $BT�$�� .�$%�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �hx(�f�[�47;�4 YZ���WF9�q B�47�;':9B $B5 �C�� !

I>����9; ��<4�$%���g-$)f��-$�7Ka�1�GB-$��<j.�>&': �� Fx. D& d-B $B': 0 �2] 5 �D�': 4� 9B $BC�� !4>�:4 >27�UV'F>27�UV�7?X� Y4I�4���:�7q5>D:� YV��4��V5 �tq ��x. D&G.4� D:4

Page 6: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

���

5 �-(�9q :9B $BC�� !54'�. #�O��P�':-B4�>�'��72 :����4� 3�� :9B $BC�� !b7?8�5 n2��:��^ AG$;���-�4�� )�q4G$&~5 3. �V�9. ���4x. D&>27�UV Y4G.4��I�7: Y\�� $�:9; ��<45 $=� .-! $��':|7}� ?}Tp4�4�,��+s :���>27�UVh�4� $$c&-B $B':d'2 B ���4��5 $=-�B]�44��7q9.4>�:4b n2� �� .d9B $B" ;7@7�_>�92���� D:4] :���>27�UV� =>.���5 $=-�BIg�sd_>�92���5 �9: .��4]�d �-q ��]d" B �A4]��'F�7:�V54`<4�� 3(�;9B $B9�q ��i4724':4�'2 B ���4��5 $=-�B :���>27�UV Y4G.4��I-! .9��7�2�4 !4i4724G$�H���9B $B5 �� �!��$�#&{W�4�G$���>2� F�$�#&'2 : .��4�9B �A4-$�F :��'F-B454'U7#�-q ��],>���4�� $: :���>27�UVI>2�4��4 K9B $BC�� !L �A4�d��4�-U~�� !57B�4" ;WM45��V !9. 247&�-%E-K�-$8$F :���� 8�&g5�7�Xqh-. @�-$2 S);�7}x(�f�9A��" $8$F�" 2 �$�[� �4�

I>���24�[$SKG.4�49&~ A9;4724':4�9B $BC�� !-B $B':5 $=-�B�0 �2i72L B4 : :���>27�UV'B���4 !4 ?2V n2�4I>2�7:�4 !4>� F6'F�7M� �� ?2V[$(%&>A4�I>2� F�$�#&9B $BC�� !'Fdo: & .� $�]>2�4�9�F� X�9B $BC�� !'Fd7<-F� X�]9(FTU7#�4�'2 X.>24w}7F9B $BC�� !'FdO.>24w}7F]�>2��V9��7<�':4�9�$;� .9DS&-%&�4 !45>�:�$�#&'�SU4Ig�s��+,��+s :���>27�UVh>2>�9��$�#&>2��V9�>.>��� �.�"� S;':N�7:92 ��Vi4724� $:oK4���'2 X.>24w}7F�9�$;�9�F� X�G.� �;'2�>�.7<-F� X�9(F�7M':�4 !4'2N-�$2 .1�� 3�49#. #AG$�}G�! .oK4��U ;5 �C�� !�4 ?2V[$U�G$��':I>����9�F� X� $u .9�F� X�9���9B $B5 �C�� !^ ��54 :N>����x(�f� E �;�49S$F &'F>24����V� $�':-S%E9S$F &9B $B54 :C�� !G.4�7<� JK�4�-B49�$;��9�F� X� E �;�49S$F &'Fd92>�C�� !] .-B4 Y\�-B4b�~� ��7&-$DS&�-F� X��454'<���V��'F9B4 F7��5�4>. �54'($SKo�47<>�2 �9��Bo�47<a(u4��'F9�F� X��O.>24w}7F9B $B5 �C�� !

I>2�4�4`��9�$� ��7�9��>� X�9��B5 �9� �� �� �5�7M4 ��4 .b n254`<4_� :���4 !4C�� !G.4��'F-B4G.49�F� X�9B $BC�� !9=P.�N>2�4�9����9#(&�� �B���4�>�.4 !9&� S;': .�5�41=-B $B�>�.4 !b n2�9B $B

Page 7: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

�����45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

5 ��.��I>2�4��7�4���7q�4^ D!O#2��4��� :':O.4 =�>�� =V�7�4� . <�4I>���� �C�� !�4i72G.4l.� )��4w$&4 F7��

�>�.4 !�b n2�9B $Bb n254`<4�49q :_� :���4 !49�$;�9B $BC�� !��� �. <9B $B�7�4�b n2���7q-F� X�54 :�>2�4�9�����tfX�5 $=-?<b n2�4� !9� =V�'e:4�C�� !�4i72G.4��I>24"� 8&9:�V_� :�� .>���$2[. K9����

I-B49U D824Te:4��7�4G$. �':��� . <�9B $B���4>29����9#(&9B $Bb n254`<4�4� !'2 X.>24w}7F9B $BC�� !�� �4 n2��I��4>2 n2��9X#2�7q54 :�>��F-F� X��47�;':�-�$2 �O#2w$38&':[p K�~7�D�54'($SK" ; ��<49B $BC�� !I-B4'e:4�>K !5� ;9=>2��-B $B� ?<�4-2 ?F�-B .�N��4>2�7<�9B $B5 �O#2i7�&o�47<G.4��I>� :9�/�BG.4�457:�C2� ?2V"4� n�24 .>2�4>2-�73A�45� n�24m$��4 !4N>����54'�f$�V5 �O#2���$B54`<4�49� =V�4`$��$�47f: =4^ AIg�s��+,��+s :���>27�UVh��4>29B $B �2 X2g���h^�><�$��� X2G.� �2"�7E':g�h_ �2 :4��V�4>#!�g�h_ �2 :4�

I�7:>�47q9B $B�7�4�4�4 !49#(&�o@7�

�8��8�7 #�1#�-#��#��<�����=7 �:�'��>���

9B $BC�� !'2 �$:'&7F*O.>24w}7F9DS&9�F� X�

" ;7@7�9B $Bb n

2

>�.4 !

5�41=

-B $

B

� !b n2

>�.4 !

5�41=

-B $

B

� !b n2

>�.4 !

5�41=

-B $

B

� !

� $c��

�49� =V�4̀ $�9B $B" ;7@7�

� !O#2�������������

� !0 �2-B $B_� :��

-B $B��-U q�b>;9B $B�7�4_� :��"� 8&9:

��-U q�':[. �&�7S2[$U�':-B $B9247& 2L �A4

�7�4 :5�41= $YZ&��

�-B $B��-F� X�':[. ��� $$c&� �.4L �A4

-F� X�l. M�4�7�4��

9�D�':g�hw.�m$� .��F� $�:9� =V9�D�':^�><G.4��g�h 8E'3�.4�$@7&I-B4� .�9� =V

Page 8: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

���

9���:4��9B $B�>�9; ��<49B $BC�� ! �O#2 �b n2�7%�^7A>27�UVIg��+,��+� .6G=h>�F9�G$$S&4�'DB7&�9B $B-F� X� �.>3.': �b n292���O.4 =5 �7�U4':�7q5� �!�-$U D!Ge:��9B $Bb n2 �],-B4>#�D�>27�UV[. : =5 �7�U4'27=G.45�I� $=9�'�X} B ?2V�4b n29B $B5 �b4>K4'F-B493��54�P.�

Ig��,���+�4� ?�hd>� 29�9B $BC�� !4�O.4 =9B $B� �!�'F>2>#�D�>�24�9�9B4 F7��a(K4�9B $B-F� X�'F :���>27�UV>#�D�>27�UVI-B49B $B�>�9; ��<4T�$�29?<7&�7q���4`$�':��4�5��� �!��P.�':C�� !�� q�C�� !5 �7�U4_� :��4� �O�$:�#!'2]9B $B�>�9; ��<4'F-B4>�F9�'$SD&4�9. �'�32'D� <�>�9; ��<45 �>�.V !'3(:>Xf:9�l�;'D� <9B $B�4 K'D� <��4�9& 32���41=9�O. �2':4�C�� !�49E q E �;� �-$8$F'F': 9B $B�>�9; ��<4 '3�.4 'EWqI>��F9�^ ��F . [.>D& 4� 4`<4 G.4 'F>��9�,��+� .6G=hd>�F9�4>$�R S&�4� q9B $Bb n2� F� F54 :b�~5 �0��4>$U7&� :

Ig��+����b n29B $B" SY� �� 3(�; �� ?2 �-q B :9B $BC�� !-B4>#�D�>27�UV� =4 !l. M�454'D� < ���9B $BC�� !I>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&4��V���41=9� Y4[�2': ���5 ��� =�9�� =5 �'2 B�'B�>���472 q^ 2 F�4�9B $B5 .1�'D� <9B $BC�� !�� F� e� : :���>27�UVoK4�':Ig+�,����04�h�7�9�[#���>.>< �.� E �; �X$:_>��F-.4>�'F>2�41=9�C�� !9�D.'D� <�WF )�; :-X�24�>�9; ��<4��'F9. � $c��b �&'F-8=�47&9�'EWq�7M':G.4 : �:N-B4'D� <5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �'(�<�4N>�� :�41= Y49B $BC�� ! :>�247&9�>2�4��7<�-$DK7��>�F9�4>$�[3�'D� <��'F9�$)f�i729B $B_`$�24"W$)%&-$�7KC�� !5 Y\�[3�':>�247&9�'F>����9(�47;>�F9�9=>2��V��� !'F9; ��<4

I>�FG$$D&4��4 !49B $B .1� $$c&� .1�Q eD249B $BC�� !��4�� #�;4'F-B4924 n2aA E�4�m$F��5���49(E4`F �&I-B4'��:4�>2�4��4 K�V���4 !4'F9e.4 ��-$DK7�':�-B4G.4��5>���7B�>$8�`. �&5�I��4��4 K>���9�[3�4��V'F9e.4 ���$%�4�4>�1. Rokeach

Page 9: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��?��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

[��h>� :L7�%� 2�9;4`�24-B4G3��'Fi7@7�':0 �2G$:m$F��I>�F9�'p4�4�� :'Y� A[��h-$DK7�':0 �2�g'(k���i7@7�w. .� ?2w.�� =w.tf�w.G.45��`F �&[� F�7M':�4 !40 �2�?!54 :�4I�7�9�[p K`. �&g� q-$U D! .�P:4w.':-S�29�$DK7���tf�'F5� �!�_7%2�4 n2�4I>�F9�� ?�X$�4�'8U\����P:4':0 �2T($B�':'F�7:>�47q'��:4��45 �0 �2� ��� :>. #;':-�4�>�47qIg��ys5 $�4h>�.V9�>.>�-$DK7�':0 �2l. M�4'F9. ��� :�>. #;':`$2�>.V>.>��>�V-B�':9. ���4�7XF���4O$:��'F54'�. #�9X. �$�" ;WM4 :�"� ?(�249M S&�4 ?�&'29:W#24 $$c&982��4 !4G$:� ��;49=>2��4-. @�'F>��9�� X2-B49B $BC�� !G$�H���-B4�S& �`$29B4 F7�� :'3(:��4�5� )�K4TDB7& :57K Diamondhg���,����>27� .�h -B4 9B4 F7�� � 5� )�K4 TDB7& G$: 57K 54'e:4�I�N9: $�FT$@ !I4,>�F9�� e�'$@ !�� �0��4927= =� :R S&�4��5�Ig1994:1-2

I5 .1�'D� <� �� .��>�9; ��<4T$@ !"� ?(��.4I-B45� )�K4T. n2��9. ?2-$:7(e�9U�`2^7E4':'$S�9: $�FT$@ !>2�41=9� B-X�4�5� )�K4-$��4�924�4 !�4��� ?2V'F-B4>#�D�9: uo�47<_� :���4 �.� :w.�`2Te:4�b4 �A4':� $2�V��'F-B4�>.� =9�.�>&^7%&': ��� �4G.4�54 :9. ?�&':4�9: $�FT$@ !5�I>24�>�-$��454�4�9�q ��9. S.��9��6-. @��>�9; ��<4T$@ !9�D.b��'$@ !��G.4�4N>24�9�29! F9���45 �927= =�9�$:O$�'F�. .1�9�b��T$@ !0 .1� :I>�F9�[.>D&4�^�4T$@ !'$@ !G.4I>�F9�� e�4�

Ig�s���,����"� ?(��.4h>���9�5��9p � 2�7M': �X$:�j.�>&': �0��49B $BC�� ! :5�4�9�D�"4 $YZ&92>�-$: &'F>2�4�� #�;4� !�>UV��7&4 :G$�H�� ?2VI-B4G$D��.4 �':'��:4�92>�-$: &5 �'� 2 :5>�V� F� $YZ& �4N��4�w$&4 F7��� �5 $=-?<5��92>�-$: &5 �'� 2 :"4 Y49: .��4_� :�� $S�4���'F9X. �$���"4 $$c&� �.4��0�7�V9�B�5 �0��I�,'F>��! .��>2�4�b �24w$&4 F7��5 �� �!�9���4�5� �!�"4 $$c&��9�B� $u5 �0��I�N>���� & Y\�� &>�V� F9�q ���O24��7eB :^�4T(����92>�-$: &5 �'� 2 :I�N>���� &>���7B� &>; �� $YZ&9B $B� �!�5�� ?2V'3�.4�4[SK>���� $YZ&54�4�9���45 �5 $=-?<�9� =V1. Inglehart 2. Bratton and Alderfer

Page 10: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��@

O.4 = :9���� $YZ&-! D��9� =VO24�92>�-$: &>B�9� n2':I>�� :'��4�� �X$:"W$)%&'F9. ?2V':�� :G.4��5� �!�"4 $$c&I��4�" : f�24��-F �':57B': �5 $=-?< : 92>�-$: & "4 $YZ& I�N�7�9���>%�>2�4� �X$: " ;WM4'��4�92 ?����>X29�$:O$�"4 $YZ&>247&9�92>�-$: &IsN-B4{>249; !9B4 F7����'F>����92 �F ?2VN>�F9�-(8ub� %�� $#!5 ��� =�492>�-$: &I+N>� :>�F9�[�; �?:92 ��92>�-$: &5 �'� 2 :I>2�4�5 ��F" ;WM4��� ��F"W$)%& �b $�>�247�: &>�� :�� F-! .��4�"W$)%&�0�7�V &~ :�7eB� =>��F-F� X�'F

Ig���� !�>UV��7&4 :h>��F{��4�5 �'. n2 9�q ��-! D� -! $�� �7H�� 9. �'. n2 �4 O��P� G.4 �� G$�H��92>� TD� < � 5 .1�'D� < '2 B ��b� � 5 �'. n2 9�q �� 9; ��<4 O�� 5 $=� .�47�;':l$#%&5 �'$@ !��'FO��P�G.4���>��� 8�B45 � $$c��I-B4�>�5�4� :� ?:�$%�9.4 =a�1�9.4 =b7K5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �[� �>�� :9��41= Y4[#��� $c��^>��>�� e�5 �'. n2':'<7& :G.4 : �:N-B49B $B_`$�24-$)f�9; ��<4

I>27�9B� :�[$(%& &>27�9�� e�l$#%&" $@ !�-B4�>�'p4�4l$#%&

مدل تحقيق

�AB#�!�C$D �A8��8�,E�FG#

H�*I�

� �. ��4�; ��<4J-�*/K

L7K�AB#�!

�B $BC�� !

M�<���� 7NO �>� �P�Q�>�

Page 11: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��R��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

فرضيه هاى تحقيق:N��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9; ��<4� �. �G$:I�

N��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9.4 =a�1��4`$�G$:I�N��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9B $B_`$�24G$:I�

N��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9.4 =b7K�4`$�G$:I�I��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�-$)f�i72G$:Is

روش شناسى (روش، اجرا و ابزارهاى پژوهش)I-B4�>��� 8�B49���S��i72�4gsurveyhO. �$�0���4-(;>�}':l$#%&G.4��5��Vo�<'F[$U�G.4':N>�F9�| �.44�0��G.4l$#%&TD� <�i7@7�-�f29E q�� =� XK':��>%��� .1�9�b �24 �2 �?�"�7E':��� ��=9%eB�� ���4�O��P�T�$�2b��I-B4l$#%&��7� n2��7�TD� <���4 !4�49&� 8��i4724�-�$2b7BI-B4 .1�� 3�49X. �$�TDU e�T. B�� �4G.4l#%&G.4 : �:N�7���4��$�D&>. :_� :�� �0�� . B�4 �X$:9�DB���4�l$K�" ;WM45� .��4>#�>247&9�O. �$�0��

I-�$2 .1�� 3�4 �0�� . Bl. M�4 �4G.4'F���V��4 !��`:54'D� <��� .7�X24�9B $BC�� ! : Y\�[�47;9B� :l$#%&G.4i7@7�'3�.4[$U�':���h5� <9($)%&^ B��'F-B45�4 !4b �&[� �G.4 : �:>� :9�� :VL� �� �X24�_7$�5 $='27�2_7$�l$#%&G.4��I>�� :9�[$)%&':^7cX�� :VL� �� �X24���gy�"�7E': ?2VG$:�4��>�'$?&� .7�X24�-�$U'F'27=�4>:N>� :9�9!� )& .9U ��A4

I-B4�>�| f�24 n2��7�T27�29!� )&a. @-B4^ � 254'27�2o.�7&'3�.4z ! :'27�2��AG$$D&l$#%&G.4��j.4�9; ��<4b7(;��� �$�M4a. @G.44 .�N�7�9�| f�24>E���s^7SK[: K� �$�M4^�><L B4 :a. @G.4':9: $�B�54 :gthb�~��4>2 �B4� S��4�4>D&a$& &G.>:I-B4���V :54 :9U7� !�� F4>$�>D:T(A �I�7:>�47q�*�+��4>2 �B4^ � 29�%�� .��eB"�7E':-B4�� B9!� )&5 $='27�2^7� !'F .�^7� !L B4 :'F-B4'27�2n

I�7�9�'SB %�9S. #&

n� 222

22

stNdsNt

Page 12: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��3

I 82��s�^� D�N9�D.5� �VTD� <I�I-B4�>�z !>E���s^� D�� �$�M4a. @I�

�47&':g�*sh : :4 :'F�7�9�z ! �F4>A5� �VT27�2���2 .�4����V :O$�I�I-B4�

'�$�2��'F�7�9�'�! = n2���*�5� �VTD� <':j. �2�$�D&� �$�M4T(E !I�I�7�9�d=�*�s

� .7�X24�G$:�49!� )&_7$�':'F>� :9� 82��s'27�2��A^7� !':'<7& :'��:4��[#���5 � $c��T$(F"4 Y4O��B54 :l$#%&G.4��G$�H��N>24�>�| f�24'F4�9(#���5 � $c���47�: &-B4�>��� 8�B4gb =':b =h5 $c��>�}�7$B4 =�0���454 :G$�H��N-q ��� : � $c�� . B�4>2�4�'��:4� $c���2 .�4�G$$D&��5 & Y\�O#2

I-B4�>��� 8�B4spss�4`!4b 2�4 ���4�[$(%&�'.`�&

يافته هاى تحقيقI��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9; ��<4� �. �G$:�,>�#�S���I>��9�� X24�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��9B $BC�� !G$:Te:4�g�h^�><

-�f29B $BC�� !�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:Te:4�G$$S&54 :l$#%&G.4��9B $B9� =V9�D.9B $BC�� !5 �';7��� .� :5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �5�41= $YZ&5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:Te:4���B�9B� :�F A9B $B5 ��� :�9B $B5 �0��4

I�� =9�G$$S&9B $BC�� !�

�-�*/K#�����/�#�,�FB�&����8��8�;)$�����9�ST9#�:��>���5� )�K4�9; ��<4� �. �9B $BC�� !

9B $B9� =V9B $B5 �0��49B $B5 ��� :Kendall’staub=��*���

Gamma=��*��sSig=�*���

Kendall’staub=�*�y�Gamma=�*�s�

Sig=�*��+

Kendall’staub=��*���Gamma=��*���

Sig=�*y��

Kendall’staub=��*��yGamma=��*��+

Sig=�*���

Page 13: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��.��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

9B $BC�� !G$:gsig=�*���h5�4�9�D��eB>��9�� X2g�h^�><'F�7M� �����*���h^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H��N��4��7<�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �� $c����G.4G$:98$D@� $�:Te:4�'F>��9�� X2� (Gamma=-*���Kendall’s tau-b

9B $BC�� !�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F9�D�G.>:N>� :9��4 K :�47&9�9B $BC�� !5 �';7��� .�5�4�9�D��7eB��-K� : 9U�I��4>2�7<��7<�5�4�9�D�Te:4��F A9B $B5 ��� :�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:'F� FR S��B45 ��� :�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:gsig=�*���h5�4�9�D��eB"�7EG.>:N��4� �*��+Kendall’s tau-b���*��yh^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H����F A9B $BI>� :9��4 K :98��-?<��'e:4��5�41= $YZ&'F-B4G.4_>���� X2(Gamma=-

9B $B5 ��� :�4`$� :���9�~ :�4 !45� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��4`$��>#} �a$& &G.>:I� $=9��4 K� =� B 2�eB���4 !4�F A

-F A~ :�eB':�4 !45� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��>#} �'F>��9�� X2g�h^�><I>2�4��F A9B $B5 ��� : :5 �X$:5� =� B 2�4 !4>�F9�

�-�*/K#�����/�#�,�FB�&���� ����8��8���$��9���9�ST9#�:�>���5� )�K49; ��<4 � �. �

o�< 9; ��<4 � �. �G$. � 5� )�K4

9; ��<4 � �. ��B7�� 5� )�K4

9; ��<4 � �. �~ : 5� )�K4

� =� B 2 9B $B 5 ��� :�������9��q 9B $B 5 ��� :��������++� =� B 9B $B 5 ��� :���������

���s�+���s

I��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9.4 =a�1��4`$�G$:UL�-�S���I-B49B $BC�� !�9.4 =a�1�G$:Te:4�_>���� X2g�h^�><

Page 14: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��2

�8��8�;)$������B#�!�C$D ���9�ST9#�:��>���9.4 =a�1�9B $BC�� !

9B $B9� =V9B $B5 �0��49B $B5 ��� :Kendall’s

tau-b=-�*��sGamma=-�*��+

Sig=�*+��

Kendall’s tau-b=�*��s

Gamma=�*��ySig=�*�++

Kendall’s tau-b=�*���

Gamma=�*��ySig=�*��s

Kendall’s tau-b=-�*�s�

Gamma=��*���Sig=�*��s

9� =V�9.4 =a�1�G$:gsig=�*+��h5�4�9�D��eB'F>��9�� X2g�h^�>< �*��+Kendall’s tau-b��-*��sh 4̂>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H��N��4��7<�9B $BTe:4�9B $BC�� !�9.4 =a�1�G$:'F-B4a(e�G.4 �2 X2g�h^�><��(Gamma=-

tq �9.4 =a�1��4̀ $�� F� $:�47&9�^�><��-K� :9U�N��4>2�7<�5�4�9�D�5�4�9�D��eBI>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&5�4�9�D�"�7E':4�9B $B5 �0��4 $c�� . 4̂>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H��9B $B5 �0��4�9.4 =a�1�G$:gsig=�*��sh�� � $c��G.49���S��'F-B4�V�49F A� (Gamma=*��yKendall’s tau-b��*���h'} �a$& &G.>:N>� :9�-S��-?<��5�41= $YZ&G.4���4��4 K54'nAW��7q���eBI�7�9� &� =� B�F A9B $B5 �0��4 :>�F9�4>$�O.4̀ !4� .7=/B �9.4 =a�1��4̀ $�>�F9�4>$�O.4`!4� .7=/B �9.4 =a�1�'} �'F-B4a(e�G.4 �2 $:P�Q^�><9.4 =a�1��4`$�-�4�� ?�4�47&9�G.4 : �:N�7�9� �X$: ?2V9B $B5 �0��4�4`$�9�D�G.>:G.4>. �I>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&5�4�9�D�"�7E':4�9B $B5 �0��4 $c��5 �0��441UN>��9�[$3X&9�.�5 �0��44�9�.�5 ��7A �X$:'3�.4[$U�':'F>� :

I>�F9�-.7#&4�9�.�9B $Bb n2 :l!47�9B $B5 �0��49�.��B#�!�C$D ����8��8���$�V1#���9�ST9#�:�>���

9B $B 5 �0��49.4 =a�1�

o�<G$. � 9.4 =a�1��B7�� 9.4 =a�1�~ : 9.4 =a�1�

� =� B 2 9B $B 5 �0��4�+���9��q 9B $B 5 �0��4s�������� =� B 9B $B 5 �0��4���������

o�<����y�����s

Page 15: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

�����45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

I��4��7<�'e:4�9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9B $B_`$�24G$:UL78�(���9B $BC�� !�9B $B_`$�24�4`$�G$:�7�9�'nAW�gsh^�><��'F�7M� ��G$�H��9B $BC�� !�GBg�sig=*���h5�4�9�D��eBI��4��7<�5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F>��9�� X2� (Gamma=*�+�Kendall’s tau-b��*�+�h^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @Te:4�9B $BC�� !�9B $B_`$�24G$:'F� F"� JK�47&9�� �$�M4>E���*�� :

I>� :9��4 K :-S��-?<�� $c����G.49���S�����4��7<�5�4�9�D�

�8��8�WE�FG#����8��8�;)$�����9�ST9#�:?�>���9B $B_`$�249B $BC�� !

9B $B9� =V9B $B5 �0��49B $B5 ��� :Kendall’s

tau-b=�*�+�Gamma=�*�+�

Sig=�*���

Kendall’s tau-b=-�*���

Gamma=-�*���Sig=�*���

Kendall’s tau-b=�*���

Gamma=�*���Sig=�*�+�

Kendall’s tau-b=�*��y

Gamma=�*�+�Sig=�*�+�

G.4':'<7& :�I>��9�� X24�9B $B_`$�24�9B $BC�� !Te:4�g+h�^�><G$�H��� .7=/B �9B $BC�� !���9� &~ :9B $B_`$�24�4`$�'} �-8=�47&9�^�><

I�7�9� &� =� B

�8��8�WE�FG#����8��8�;)$���ST9#�X�Y7��:@�>���

9B $B C�� !9B $B _`$�24

o�<G$. � _`$�24�B7�� _`$�24~ : _`$�24

� =� B 2 9B $B C�� !�y����+9��q 9B $B C�� !+�y��+�y�� =� B 9B $B C�� !��+������

o�<����+�+����

I��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�9.4 =b7K�4`$�G$:UL�N��S���

Page 16: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

���

9�A � 9B $B C�� ! 9.4 =b7K $c�� 'F -B4 a(e� G.4 _>���� X2 g�h ^�>< ?2VG$:5�4�9�D�Te:4��>��9�2�4 K $YZ&-%&`$24�9B $BC�� !5 �tq � .��7)q':4�9:7q� �S�29���S�� �tq ��49JD:�� � =a.4 @'} =N-�$2�4 K :�9.4 =b7KG$:gsig=�*�+�h5�4�9�D��eBI>��9�� X29B $B9� =Vtq ��� �*���Kendall’s tau-b��*���h^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H��9B $B9� =V $YZ&-%&-S��-?<��4�9B $B9� =V9.4 =b7K�4`$�'F>��9�� X2(Gamma=� .7=/B �9.4 =b7K�4`$�'} �9�D.N>� :9�'nAW��7q��� �S�2 $YZ&G.4I>��9��4 K5�4�9�D��eB��'e:4�G.49U�N���9� &~ : ?2V9B $B9� =V�4`$��7�9� �X$:G$�H��9B $BC�� !�9.4 =b7KG$:gsig=�*ys+h5�4�9�D��eBG$�H��I>� :9�2G.4_>���� X2� (Gamma=*���Kendall’s tau-b��*���h^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @ $c��G$:Te:4��7<�T$@ !G.4 : �:N��4>2�7<� $c����G.4G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F-B4

I�7�9�2>$.Z&9B $BC�� !�9.4 =b7K

�8��8�;)$������B#�!�L7K���9�ST9#�:R�>���9.4 =b7K9B $BC�� !

9B $B9� =V9B $B5 �0��49B $B5 ��� :Kendall’s

tau-b=009/0 ����������

���������

Kendall’s tau-b=�*���

Gamma=�*���Sig=�*�+�

Kendall’s tau-b=�*��s

Gamma=�*�+�Sig=�*s�s

Kendall’s tau-b=�*���

Gamma=�*+�

:��4��7<�'e:4� ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7�X24�-$)f�i72G$:U�+)&�S���^�><':'<7& : ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7=/B �-$)f�i72G$:Te:4�G$$S&��9B $B9� =V-$)f�i729B $BC�� !5 �tq �G$:��'F� F� $:�47&9�gyhG$�H����sig=*��� p73B45 F�7��VI>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&5�4�9�D�"�7E':4�C�� !�-$)f�i72G$:Te:4�'F>��9�� X2� Phi cramers v= *�+�9���S��a. @�4 K �tq � . B':-S�29.~ :�eB�� ?2VG$:9���S���>� :9��4�9�D�9B $B9� =V�4`$�>�� : &4 =�� :�4 !4'} ��7�9���4�� X2gyh^�><��'F�7M� ��I��4�

I���9� &~ : ?2V9B $B

Page 17: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

�����45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

�8��8��$�!Z���H�*I��[7G���9�ST9#�:3�>���

9B $B 9� =V-$)f� i72

o�<4 =����4 =�� :

G$. � 9B $B 9� =V�����y�B7�� 9B $B 9� =V������+�~ : 9B $B 9� =V�����+

o�<����s��s

C�� !�-$)f�i72G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F-B4a(e�G.4_>��F>$.Z&g�h^�>< � Phi*�+�9���S��a. @G$�H����sig=*�y� p73B45 F�7��VI��4>2�7<�9B $BG.49U���4��7<� $c����G.4G$:9�S��9���S��'} ='F>��9�� X2cramers v=

�7<�T$@ !-! ='�$�2�47&9�G.4 : �:N-�$25�4�9�D��eB��'e:4��9���S��I�7�9�2>$.Z&9B $BC�� !�-$)f�i72 $c��G$:'e:4�

�8��8��$�!Z���H�*I��[7G���9�ST9#�:.�>���9B $BC�� !

9B $B9� =V9B $B5 �0��49B $B5 ��� :�*Phi cramers v= �y� Chi-Square Tests

�*sig=�+�Phicramersv= �+��Chi-SquareTests

sig=�*���Phicramers v= �*��y

Chi-SquareTests sig=�*���

Phicramersv=�*���Chi-Square Tests

sig=�*���

9B $BC�� ! :[#���5 � $$c��"4 $YZ&�4`$�[$(%&�'.`�&':v7![A4 ��4>D:G.4g��h^�><'F-B4�>�'�q4� �b =':b =5 $$c��>�}�7$B =�':'<7& :�4 !4

I>��9�� X24� �[$(%&

Page 18: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

���

�8��8�;)$����9�M�<���6</0 ���$��\/ ���4]���#E� �:�2�>���

[#���5 � $c��9���S��a. @R� $c��>�}

G$$D&a. @R squares

a.4 @B�7$B =�� �:Tsig

9B $B_`$�24�*����*����*�s��*��y�*�+��*���9.4 =a�1��*����*�����*��y��*��+�*�y��*���

5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��*����*�����*�s���*�y���*y���*���9.4 =b7K�*����*�����*�����*�����*����*y��

-$)f�i72�*�y��*��y�*����*�+s�*����*���[F�*�s��*����*��s

F= 0.328 sig=0.002 R squares=0.041

�7$B =�[$(%&j. �2'F-8=�47&9�i7�����>��9�� X2g��h^�><'F�7M� ��9�D.l$#%&���>�� e�[#���5 � $c��5�41= $YZ&i7���'F-B4a(e�G.4_>��F� $:-$)f�i72�9.4 =b7K9B $B_`$�249.4 =a�1�9; ��<45� )�K4� �. �5 � $c��l$#%&G.4���>�� e�[#���5 � $c��G.4 : �:I>� :9��*��� : :4 :9(F5 �D����4 YZ���>2 � <':"4 $$c&41UN>2�4>24�9B $BC�� ! $c��5~ :9($qG$$S&9. 247&I>� :9�'�$��G.4�� �X$:" #$#%&b`(����>����'�q �� 2'F>� :9�5 �.�5 � $c��

تحليل داده ها�eB��� .7=/B ��4>E����*�9�D.� .7=/B �-. �F4'F-B4�V�4�49F A� �V :G$. �5� )�K49; ��<4� �. � �.��7eB�>�� :9�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��B7��G$�H��I>2�4��4 K5>D:5 �'S&���>E���y*� :~ :5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��>E��+*��eB���4 !4>E���*��#!'F5�7M':N>� :9�~ :� .7=/B �G$:��9.4 =a�1��4`$��eB��>E����*���B7���eB��>E��s�*�'F9U A��>2�4��4 K9.4 =a�1�G$. �

I>2�4��4 K~ :9.4 =a�1��B7��� .7=/B �G$:��9B $B_`$�24�4`$�'F-B4�V_>���� X298$E7&^�4><N�B7��9B $B_`$�2454�4�� .7=/B ��4>E���y*�'F9�D�G.>:N>� :9�G$. �':��N>�� :9�~ :9B $B�`$�2454�4� ?2V�4>E����*��G$. �9B $B_`$�2454�4�>E����*+���4>2�4 K9.~ :�eB��� .7=/B �G$:��9B $B_`$�24'F�7�9��>� X�G.4 : �:

Page 19: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��?��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

I>2 $=9��4 K~ :_`$�24�eB��� .7=/B ��45 ��F>E��>E���y*�'F5�7M':N>� :9�~ :':���B7��� .7=/B �G$:��9B $B9� =V�4`$�� ~ : 9B $B 9� =V 54�4� >E���y*� �B7�� 9B $B 9� =V 54�4� � .7=/B � �4G$: �� -�4� � ?�4 �47&9� G.4 : �: N>�� :9� G$. � 9B $B 9� =V 54�4� >E����*�

I-B4'�! =�4 K�B7���eB�� �X$:9B $B9� =V'DU e���7�� .7�X24� :� =� B5 �0��454�4�� .7=/B �-. �F4'F-B4�V�49F Al$#%&5 �'�! .N� =� B9B $B0��454�4�� .7=/B ��4>E��+�*y'F5�7M':N>�� :9�9B $Bb n2� =� B 2 9B $B 5 �0��4 54�4� >E���*� �#! � 9��q 9B $B 0��4 >E���s*�5� =� B':��9��q�eB��� .7=/B � :�F A9B $B5 ��� :^ AG$;��I>�� :9�>E���y*�N9��q9B $B5 ��� :54�4�� .7=/B ��4>E����*+'F9�D�G.>:N>� :9�I>�� :9�� =� B 29B $B5 ��� :54�4�>E����*��#!�� =� B9B $B5 ��� :54�4�N9��q9B $B C�� ! 54�4� � .7=/B � �4 >E��ss*�'F >����G.4 �2 $: ���4�� =� B 29B $BC�� !54�4�>E����*+�� =� B9B $BC�� !54�4�>E����*�-. �F49U���4�[. �&� =� BQ M':9��q�49B $BC�� !�4`$�G.4 : �:N>�� :9�� .7=/B ��4>E����*+�#!�>2�4��4 K9B $BC�� !5 ��q�eB��� .7=/B �

I>�� :9�� =� B 29B $BC�� !54�4�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��9B $BC�� !G$:5�4�9�D��eBl$#%&" $@ ![$(%&�� $c����G.4G$:98$D@� $�:Te:4�'F>��9�� X2 ̂ 4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G$�H���9B $BC�� !�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F9�D�G.>:N>� :9��4 K :I>X2>$.Z&9B $B5 ��� :�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:Te:4�T$@ !'�$�2��I��4>2�7<�'F� FR S��B4�47&9�9B $BC�� !5 �';7��� .�5�4�9�D��7eB��-K� :'F9�D�G.>:N��4��7<�5�4�9�D�Te:4�9B $B5 ��� :�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:� � =a.4 @G$�H���9B $B5 ��� :�5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �G$:5�4�9�D��eB9�D.N>� :9��4 K :98��-?<��'e:4��5�41= $YZ&G.4'F>��9�� X2^4>�F9:�4 &�eB���4 !49B $B5 ��� :�4`$����9�~ :�4 !45� )�K49; ��<4� �. ��4`$��>K �l$#%&G.4��'�! =b �245 �9B� :~ :j. �2x$E7&':'<7& :I� $=9��4 K� =� B 2� �. �'} �N>� :9�98��9B $B5 ��� : :5� )�K49; ��<4� �. �Te:4�'F��4�9�� $:

Page 20: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��@

I>��F9�4>$�9B $Bb n2 :� =� B 25 ��� :�4 !4���9� &~ :� .7=/B �5� )�K49; ��<4G$:'F-�4�4�-�4� :G.4�47&9�9B $BC�� !�9.4 =a�1�G$:Te:4��4G$�H���47&9�g�h^�><��-K� :9U�N��4>2�7<�5�4�9�D�Te:4�9B $BC�� !�9.4 =a�1�-%&5�4�9�D�"�7E':4�9B $B5 �0��4 $c�� .�tq �9.4 =a�1��4̀ $�� F� $:a.4 @G$�H��9B $B5 �0��4�9.4 =a�1�G$:5�4�9�D��eBI>��9��4 K $YZ&5�41= $YZ&G.4���4��4 K54'nAW��7q���eB�� � $c��G.49���S��'F>��9�� X2>�F9�4>$�O.4̀ !4� .7=/B �9.4 =a�1��4̀ $�'} �'F5�7M':N>� :9�-S��-?<��4�9�.�5 ���7A �X$:'F-B49�D��4>:G.4>. �I�7�9� &� =� B9B $B5 �0��49B $Bb n2 :l!47�9B $B5 �0��49�.�5 �0��441UN>��9�[$3X&9�.�5 �0��4N>��9��4 K $Y &-%&4�� .7�X24�9B $B5 �0��49.4 =a�1��4̀ $�I>�F9�-.7#&4�b n25 �0��4 :� 2V9B $B5 �0��4>�F9�4>$�O.4̀ !4� .7�X24�9.4 =a�1�'} ��� �49. �0��4 : �X$:a�1�_�7A'F� F9B� :�47&9�I�7�9�� =� B�F A9B $B� .7�X24�'F>� :9�9(�Z&[: KT�$�2G.4�>� :9�`$29B $Bb n29B $B5 �0��4'F��4�5�4�9�D�Te:4�9(F-U A��'} =N>2�4�`$2 &� =� B9B $B5 �0��4~ :9.4 =a�1� :

I>X2�>� X�� .7�X24�9B $BC�� !�9.4 =a�1�G$:�9B $B_`$�24�4`$�G$:'F-B4-$DK4�G.4_>���� X2l$#%&�4�>�V-B�':j. �2G$�H��9B $BC�� !�GB5�4�9�D��eBI��4��7<�5�4�9�D�Te:4�9B $BC�� !Te:4�9B $BC�� !�9B $B_`$�24G$:'F>��9�� X2^4>�F9:�4 &� � =a.4 @G.4 : �:N>� :9��4 K :-S��-?<�� $c����G.49���S�����4��7<�5�4�9�D�

I�7�9� &� =� B� .7=/B �9B $BC�� !���9� &~ :9B $B_`$�24�4`$�'} �I>� :9�~ :':���B7��� .7=/B �� $���9.4 =b7K�4`$��>�[E Aj. �2lSM�>E���y*� :9.4 =b7K�B7���eB4�9.4 =b7KG. �X$:�7�9�'nAW�'F�7M� ��TS&���4��4`$�G. ��F>E��s*� :G$. �9.4 =b7K�>E���+ :~ :9.4 =b7K�V�4>D:9.~ :�eB��� .7=/B �G$:��9.4 =b7K�4`$�'�$�2��N>� :9�4�4�9.4 =b7K�4`$�`$24�9B $BC�� !5 �tq � .�9�A�9B $BC�� !9.4 =b7K $c�����4��4 K�� � =a.4 @'} =4I-�$2�4 K : ?2VG$:5�4�9�D�Te:4��>��9�2�4 K $YZ&-%&� X29B $B9� =Vtq ����7)q':4�9:7q� �S�29���S�� �tq ��49JD:

Page 21: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��R��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

$YZ&G.4I>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&-S��-?<��4�9B $B9� =V9.4 =b7K�4`$�>��9��4`$��7�9� �X$:� .7=/B �9.4 =b7K�4`$�'} �9�D.N>� :9�'nAW��7q��� �S�2

I>� :9�25�4�9�D��eB��'e:4�G.49U�N���9� &~ : ?2V9B $B9� =VT$@ !G.4 : �:N>� :9� $c����G.4G$:�4�9�D�Te:4�b>;_>���� X2'$@ !�7��V'F9(� &[: K� $�:'�$�2I�7�9�2>$.Z&9B $BC�� !�9.4 =b7K $c��G$:'e:4��7<�9�D�G.>:N>� :9�9B $B9� =V :9.4 =b7KG$:Te:4�� $=�4 K�%:��7�>247&9�O.4`!4`$2� 2V9B $B9� =V�4`$����9� &~ :� .7�X24�9.4 =b7K�4`$�'} �'F9� =V�9.4 =b7K�4`$�G$:Te:4� :9(�47;'}oK4�':'F� F9B� :�47&9�I>: .9�9B $BC�� !�9.4 =b7K�4`$�G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�^ AG.4 :I>�� :9��41= Y49B $B� 2V9B $BC�� ! :9(F-U A��� .7�X24�9.4 =b7K9�D.N��4>2�7<�� .7�X24�

I>��9�O.4`!44�� 2V9B $B9� =V'} =��4>25�4�9�D� $YZ&�47&9�j. �2':'<7& : ?2V9B $BC�� !�� .7=/B �-$)f�i72G$:Te:4�G$$S&��"�7E':4�9B $B9� =V-$)f�i729B $BC�� !5 �tq �G$:��'F� F� $:� X2 �4 F9���S��a. @G$�H��� p73B45 F�7��VI>��9��4 K $YZ&-%&5�4�9�D�G$:9���S���>� :9�5�4�9�D�Te:4�9B $BC�� !�-$)f�i72G$:Te:4�'F>��9��4 !4'} �'F9�D�G.>:N��4��4 K �tq � . B':-S�254'nAW��7q���eB�� ?2V>���9�� X2�>�V-B�':5 �� �V9U�I���9� &~ : ?2V9B $B9� =V�4̀ $�>�� : &4 =�� :� p73B45 F�7��VI��4>2�7<�9B $BC�� !�-$)f�i72G$:5�4�9�D�Te:4�'F�7<� $c����G.4G$:9�S��9���S��'} ='F��4�9�� $: �4 F9���S��a. @G$�H��'F-�4�� ?�4�47&9�G.4 : �:N-�$25�4�9�D��eB��'e:4��9���S��G.49U���4�

I�7�9�2>$.Z&9B $BC�� !�-$)f�i72 $c��G$:'e:4��7<�T$@ !54�4�>���9�[$3X&l$#%&G.4��4�� .7=/B �-. �F4'F4 =�� :5 �-$)f�[p �� :>�247&9� �X$:>����4 =�� :'F9. �-$)f�I>�� :9�5 &~ :9B $B9� =V9B $B9� =V�4`$� :>247&9�'(k��G.4G.4 : �:N>�� :^7cX�'D� <��9B $B�9; ��<4'D� <�7�4��-F� X�54 :�4 !40W&b`(���'F9B $B_`$�24G$�H��I>� :�41= Y4 ?2V54'$@ ! ?�&I-B4��4��4 K $Y &-%&5�4�9�D�"�7E':4��4 !49B $BC�� !>� :9�9B $BC�� !�9B $B_`$�24G$:'e:4��7<�T$@ !-B4�>�>$.Z&l$#%&G.4��'F54 :57K_`$�24'F5�4 !4'F>� :a(e�G.4_>��FG$$S&>247&9�'e:4�G.4>$.Z&I>� :9�

Page 22: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'������( �)�*�

�+)&�,�-��,�����.����/0 1

��3

I>��F9�4>$�4��F A9B $Bb n2 :� =� B9B $BC�� !>2�4�4�9B $B�7�4��-F� X�5�41= $YZ&i7���'F-! =4�'�$�2G.4�47&9��7$B =�[$(%&�4�>�[E Aj. �2�49.4 =a�1�9; ��<45� )�K4� �. �5 � $c��9�D.l$#%&���>�� e�[#���5 � $c��G.4'F>� :9��*��� : :4 :9(F5 �D���9B $B_`$�24�-$)f�i729.4 =b7K9. 247&l$#%&G.4���>�� e�[#���5 � $c��'F-B4a(e�G.4_>���� X2a. @5 � $c���4 YZ���>2 � <':"4 $$c&G.4 : �:I>2�4>24�9B $BC�� ! $c��5~ :9($qG$$S&

I>� :9�'�$��G.4�� �X$:" #$#%&b`(����>����'�q �� 2'F>� :9�5 �.�

نتيجه گيرى و پيشنهادC�� !9�D.9B $Bb7(;�9B $B9B ��'D� <9B B4�$� 8��493.9B� :':l$#%&G.4�9B� :�%:�V_� :��9! F_�4>24':�4 .4� ��7XF��[E4��'F��4� �9�9B $B��5>.><�9! X�F4j. �2>247&9�9;72':l$#%&G.4j. �2G.4 : �:N-B4�>X2l$#%&9.4 =b7K�4`$�'F-B4a(e�G.4_>���� X2l$#%&�4�>�V-B�':j. �2I>� :'�$��G.4~ :':���B7��9B $B9� =V�B7��9B $B_`$�244 =�� :-$)f�9.4 =a�1�~ :

I>� :9�9��q9B $BC�� !-. ?2���b n2 :� =� B9B $B5 �0��45 �';7��� .� :[#���5 � $c��G$:'e:4��7<��454'nAW��7q��j. �241U�>� X�9B $B5 ��� :�9B $B5 �0��49B $B9� =V9�D.9B $BC�� ! $c��a(e�G.4_>���� X2l$#%&j. �2 �4N>� :9�'�A S��9B� :[: K ?2V�4b4>F ��>�[#���5 � $c���4b4>Fm$�>�>$.Z&'e:4��7<�'F9B $B_`$�24_� :��`<':'F>� :9�-. �F4G.4 : �:I>���9�2�4 K $Y &-%&4�9B $BC�� !9�D.l$#%&T��:4� $c��l$#%&4� � $c��G$:Te:4�5 ;�4l$#%&" $@ !��'F5 n292 S����>�� e�5 �'. n2'(k��G.4I>27�9�2>$.Z&l$#%&��7�5� �VTD� <':'<7& :�l$#%&G.4��>���4�'#e��9B ��b7: :�F A92 ���92 3�-$DK7�'F>� :a(e�G.4_>���� X2>247&9��92 3�-$DK7��4"� 8��� :VL� �>A4��4�V� �X24�� .7�X24��VaK D���� :VL� �G.4'F-! ='�$�2�47&9�G.4 : �:N-B4�>�'p4�4'�$��G.4��'F-B49. �'. n292 ��C�� ! :�41= $YZ&'F5 �.�5 � $c�� &>�F9�� :5>D:" #$#%&54 :4� J!l$#%&

I>27�9. B ���9B� :>����9B $B

Page 23: ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ … · ˘ˇˆ ˙˝ ˛˚ˇ˜ ! "#$#%& ’ ˇ()! ﻰﻣﻼﺳﺍ ﺩﺍﺯﺁ ﻩﺎﮕﺸﻧﺍﺩ ﻥﺎﻳﻮﺠﺸﻧﺍﺩ

��$�%&'�����( �)�*�

��.��45 �6 #7���8�9�:::�8��8�;)$����9

كتابنامهI .7F,�4 ?&b��� } &��. �,'�< &9�D�ET�! X$�TD� <��9��� !^7%&g����h>U 2��"� ?(��.4

I-�B,�4 ?&^�4� }5�7SE ?}7��,'�< &-B $B�'D� <g����h[3. �04�b7(; � 9B ��'D� < T. X2 d9���4 5 �b n2 � 92 �24 5 �0��4 -$� �] g��ysh �� $! 5 $�4

I�����tE���� ��9; ��<4b7(;0�7�V>��N9; ��<4 X2 ,�4 ?& ^�4 � }� =� B W$U ,'�< & -B $B �(; : 9. ��V N-�73Ag����h G$�BV 92�

I9� �X24�5� )�K4 � 9B $B " ;WM4 T(�� d9B $B C�� ! 54� $X; 92 S�] g���yh �7�%� �(#U4o. B

I��s���+5 ��� ��IG.72b7(; X2,�4 ?&^�4� }9B $B" M S&�4g���sh`.� �57(;

�(;��9B $BC�� !-! $��':9� �2N-B $B9��� !G$$S& :5>�V��]g��y+h>�A45>�%�[=I�����s�tE+�� ��9B $Bb7(;9X��P�9�(;T� 2O��P�d-B $B

I $8B,�4 ?&^�4� }G.>&>�A4,'�< &b7B� ?<��9B $B927= =�g��+�h�4� 3��� .6G=9; �� ?}7��,'�< &-B $B�(;':>.><9� �2g����h[. =`U� }�5�~� ��4 �U �9�27�

I9((�U4G$:�9B $B" DU e� �!�,�4 ?&^�4� }IC2� �,�4 ?&9B $B5 .1�'D� <g���+h`� ��4� ?�

������ ����!"#������$�%��&��the Civic Culture; Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations Boston��'����

������� �$�%��&��)*�'"���+�,���������5�!�6��Journal of Politics, No 18 Agust, pp. 391-409.

;"������<�������!">!"�,��$�%%%&��?����#?5!"� ������@!�#���E��$�%%%&��)@�!�!>>!��5�>�civic education on political culture; evidence frome Zambia”, world development������J��

L���������""�$�%%O&��political culture and democracy in developing country, us, lune rinner publishers.

�#5���E�$J���&��)�������!�?"Q5����+���5��!���������!�'"5'!��5�>"���5���������Russia s democratic transition”, American journal of political science������O��

<�5��!"��U������W5!��W��$�%%�&��)@"X5�����5�"X5������5Q!'����5�Y�''X��"�!+��X����5�of civil and political institutions in post –communist societies”, The journal of politics, Vol. 2.

���!��� +!"#�� $�%��&�� )��'���+!� '�������� �X��X"!6�� ,�������� �X��X"!� ���� '���������!+!�'�!���� [X����� U�'!� ���� ��+!"#�� $!�5&�� ,"���!���� \!?� E!"5!]� ,"���!���^��+!"5���'"!55��'����