Upload
vokien
View
215
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
The Informed Voter Project Don’t just Vote. Select!
PROMISE and PERFORMANCE REPORT 2012-2015
Wards R/N, R/C, R/S, P/N, P/S
WAS YOUR CORPORATOR THE RIGHT CHOICE?
Don’t just Vote. Select!
CONTENT BRIEF & DATA SOURCE
Content Explanation Source
Attendance Total of General Body Meetings and Committee Meetings. Average attendance of 227 corporators = 77%
• www.Praja.org • RTI reply from BMC.
Corporator Fund Expenditure Status
Each corporator is entitled to two funds annually- (1) Corporator Fund, and (2) Development Fund.
• Entitlement- http://bit.ly/1PLOq2N • Corporator Fund Expenditure Data-
http://portal.mcgm.gov.in/irj/portal/anonymous/qlpurordcdetails. Average Expenditure of 227 corporators = 92.97%
• Development Fund info not included in this report.
Financial Year
Corporator Fund annual entitlement
Development Fund annual entitlement
2012-13 60 lakh 40 lakh
2013-14 60 lakh 40 lakh
2014-15 60 lakh 1 crore
Promise & Performance One-liners
Each corporator was asked the following questions in the interview conducted by MumbaiVotes- (1) Performance: Major work done in term so far (2) Promises: Plans for remaining part of term.
Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute video/audio interview with MumbaiVotes.
Contact Details Phone number provided. Find more on website. Affidavit filed for candidature
Don’t just Vote. Select!
PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATORS (CITY LEVEL ISSUES)
URBAN PLANNING EDUCATION ENVIRONMENT ROADS PUBLIC TRANSPORT
POVERTY ALLEVIATION HEALTH ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WATER SUPPLY SLUM IMPROVEMENT
₹
Don’t just Vote. Select!
MUMBAI = 227 WARDS = 227 CORPORATORS
RULING COALITION
NO
. OF
CO
RP
OR
ATO
RS
POLITICAL PARTIES
77
30
53
28
14 11 9
2 1 1 1 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
SHS BJP INC MNS IND NCP SP ABS RPI(A)
BSKP BRKP
Don’t just Vote. Select!
Questions SHS Response BJP Response
A plan will be made for more parking space No Response No Response
Plan shall be made to give concession and encouragement for those co-operative societies who keep their building premises clean.
No Response No Response
Graveyards will be made available with PNG gas (natural gas) to prevent excess use of wood and to stop pollution and bad smell.
No Response No Response
In order to prevent diseases like Thalassemia, AIDS etc., blood testing services shall be provided at the Municipal Corporation's laboratory at very cheap rates.
No Response No Response
All municipal schools will be repaired and have computer labs in the next three years. No Response No Response
Bus services like 'Fort-ferry' shall be started in the many parts of Mumbai city and suburbs. No Response No Response
Policy of developing 'Hawkers ground' shall be accepted. No Response No Response
Project affected citizens of Mumbai due to different municipal projects shall be given houses or compensation as per 'Ready-reckoner' for which 15 years inhabitation shall be the eligibility.
No Response No Response
RULING COALITION PARTY PERFORMANCE A questionnaire* consisting of projects and plans promised in the Shiv Sena – Bharatiya Janta Party (SHS-BJP) 2012 MCGM Manifesto was first sent to the Shiv Sena and BJP spokespersons on April 26, 2015. Despite several follow-ups, this was the response we received-
* Few promises stated here. Questionnaire listed 117 promises extracted from SHS-BJP 2012 MCGM Manifesto.
Don’t just Vote. Select!
PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT PARAMETERS
CORPORATOR’S CONTACT NUMBER
QUALITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – October 2015
QUANTITATIVE Time Period: March 2012 – March 2015
LINK TO INTERVIEW
PROMISE: WORK TO BE DONE
PERFORMANCE: WORK DONE
ATTENDANCE
CORPORATOR FUNDS EXPENDITURE
Don’t Just Vote. Select!
INTERVIEWS TAKEN IN 6 CLUSTERS
COVERED IN THIS REPORT: CLUSTER 3- Constituency Numbers 1-52 R/N: Borivali, Dahisar R/C: Borivali R/S: Kandivali P/N: Malad P/S: Goregaon, Malad
Don’t just Vote. Select!
ATTENDANCE
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AT
TEN
DA
NC
E (i
n %
)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AT
TEN
DA
NC
E (i
n %
)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AT
TEN
DA
NC
E (i
n %
)
R/N Ward Corporators R/C Ward Corporators R/S Ward Corporators
Below Average Above Average
Don’t just Vote. Select!
ATTENDANCE
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AT
TEN
DA
NC
E (i
n %
)
* 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
AT
TEN
DA
NC
E (i
n %
)
P/N Ward Corporators P/S Ward Corporators
Below Average Above Average
*Replaced disqualified corporator. Data unavailable.
Don’t just Vote. Select!
CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CO
RP
OR
ATO
R F
UN
D E
XP
END
ITU
RE
(in
%)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CO
RP
OR
ATO
R F
UN
D E
XP
END
ITU
RE
(in
%)
R/N Ward Corporators R/C Ward Corporators R/S Ward Corporators
Below Average Above Average
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CO
RP
OR
ATO
R F
UN
D E
XP
END
ITU
RE
(in
%)
Don’t just Vote. Select!
CORPORATOR FUND EXPENDITURE STATUS
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CO
RP
OR
ATO
R F
UN
D E
XP
END
ITU
RE
(in
%)
*
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
CO
RP
OR
ATO
R F
UN
D E
XP
END
ITU
RE
(in
%)
P/N Ward Corporators P/S Ward Corporators
Below Average Above Average
*Replaced disqualified corporator. Data indicative of both corporators.
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/N Ward- Borivali, Dahisar Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Abhishek Vinod Ghosalkar
SHS
INFRASTRUCTURE: I have cleared the bottleneck at Kandarpada and completed the CC road.
ECONOMIC AFFAIRS: I have the budget for a mangrove park & fish aquarium.
https://youtu.be/fZgAJah7Eqc
9769539111/ 8879997001
Sheetal Mukesh Mhatre
SHS
INFRASTRUCTURE: Nearly all the roads & footpaths in the ward have been repaired.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct two FOBs at Anandnagar & Dahisar checknaka.
https://youtu.be/BtxOIYrlwus
9870337777/ 8879997002
Sheetal Ashok Mhatre INC INFRASTRUCTURE, ECONOMIC AFFAIR: I have sanctioned Rs. 40 lakhs for maintenance of two big gardens.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will install CCTV cameras as a security measure.
https://youtu.be/YF6nAFC2qHg
9867322422/ 8879997003
Udesh Shantaram Patekar
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I provided the hilly areas with water supply by installing boosters in the water pumps.
INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I will develop the Alakhnanda play ground with sports facilities for the youth such as gym, cricket and different indoor games for which I have got Rs. 3 crores passed.
https://youtu.be/wvebUFllXhE
9821117531/ 8879997004
Don’t just Vote. Select!
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Prakash Yashwant Darekar
MNS MISCELLANEOUS: My ward is known for cleanliness, for all the facilities and services.
*No reply* https://youtu.be/-QbWBOmQkgY
9820164443/ 8879997005
Hansaben Gunvantrai Desai
SHS MISCELLANEOUS: Problems of water, toilets, children's school admission are the day-to-day issues solved thus far.
*No reply* https://youtu.be/zRX4L3fw_pQ
9869019232/ 8879997006
Dr. Shubha Umesh Raul
SHS ENVIRONMENT, HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made a bird park for their protection, two gymnasiums for women, two yoga centres.
SANITATION: Upcoming project for Dahisar river will be along the lines Ganges improvement project.
https://youtu.be/mkalqQyb3dc
9869866978/ 8879997007
AREA: R/N Ward- Borivali, Dahisar Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/C Ward- Borivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Shivanand Narayan Shetty
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have done up all the four gardens in my ward.
INFRASTRUCTURE: The road from Neelam Pride to HD Ground will be done in CC & I will develop Gorai Gaothan.
https://youtu.be/vfvb4vLkxf4
9869142749/ 8879997008
Manisha Ashok Chaudhari
BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got Govind Nagar road made.
*No Reply*
https://youtu.be/T6KkJW-xNn8
9320123413/ 8879997009
Riddhi Bhaskar Khursange
NCP INFRASTRUCTURE: Some slum dwellers have been regularised and I've repaired all the broken non-functional toilets.
ECONOMIC AFFAIR, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got an approval of 2.75 crores for the crematorium.
https://youtu.be/b_5qbh-0HRM
9869664997/ 8879997010
Shilpa Shirish Chogle MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: To reduce pollution of the river, I have got big meshes placed in drains.
*No Reply*
https://youtu.be/sES59_Zik_0
9833888025/ 8879997011
Asawari Anil Patil BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have taken up all the road repairs, CC and asphalt, that were lying incomplete since 25-30 years.
*No Reply* https://youtu.be/agbIJ_Y6Oj8
9322243615/ 8879997012
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/C Ward- Borivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Chetan Chandrakant Kadam
MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made 10 roads and 2 gardens.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will try to upgrade water facilities.
https://youtu.be/U4VrRWtN0mU
9867391966/ 8879997013
Bina Paresh Doshi BJP SANITATION: I have completed unfinished roads in Natakvala lane and Haridas nagar.
HEALTH, OTHER: I will inaugurate the BMC diagnostic centre.
https://youtu.be/j3cpO4Hyy9k
9870479227/ 8879997014
Mohan Ramchandra Mithbaokar
BJP HEALTH & SANITATION: There are no mosquito related problems in my ward.
INFRASTRUCTURE, SEWAGE: I will provide sewage lines to slum areas.
https://youtu.be/WAmy6pyfepg
9869168373/ 8879997015
Pravin Rivakchand Shah
BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I am building a sports stadium in Chikuwadi at the cost of Rs. 190 crores.
INFRASTRUCTURE: Four new gardens will be completed in a few months, by Diwali 2015.
https://youtu.be/l3RTTQHv7qo
9322704829/ 8879997016
Sandhya Vipul Doshi MNS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have developed one big theme garden, 5 small gardens, one big park, and I have done up 27 km of minor roads.
POLITICAL AFFAIR: I'm trying to get the MHADA open plots RP/GP transferred to BMC in my Ward.
https://youtu.be/-s935RHjveo
9821117777/ 8879997017
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/S Ward- Kandivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Shrikant Krishna Kavathankar
SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have provided various facilities such as toilets, footpaths, student scholarships.
*No Reply* https://youtu.be/xUqeEyQeEfg
9967542708/ 8879997018
Neha Vinayak Patil INC *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9769279325/ 8879997019
Shailaja Vijay Girkar BJP INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH: I have got an old dispensary bulldozed and received approval for building a four storey dispensary in its place.
INFRASTRUCTURE: The BMC swimming pool is planned to be enlarged to an olympic size swimming pool.
https://youtu.be/lNtkdRjX-34
9819710844/ 8879997020
Ramashish Gopal Gupta
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have worked on 10 roads.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will make 8 new roads.
https://youtu.be/oez_RWqlTBM
9892907975/ 8879997021
Sunita Ramnagina Yadav
BJP SANITATION: I made my constituency a 'zero garbage‘ ward.
*No Reply* https://youtu.be/s8tmIq9A4OM
8879997022
Prajakta Vikas (Sawant) Vishwasrao
SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* https://youtu.be/xUqeEyQeEfg
9967542708/ 8879997023
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: R/S Ward- Kandivali Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Yogesh Janardhan Bhoir
INC POLITICAL AFFAIR: I fought for 3 years with the Forest Department, went to Delhi for the matter and even courted arrest once and got the NOC to provide basic services for slum dwellers on forest land.
INFRASTRUCTURE: My focus in the immediate future will be now to get a fire brigade station, cemetery and hospital for my ward.
https://youtu.be/uv1pjZ5mgxA
9821087312/ 8879997024
Dr. Ajanta Rajpati Yadav
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have solved the problem of major nullah which used to overflow into the houses of the poor within ten minutes of rainfall.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will redo 13 small roads in slum pockets have received special funds from the commissioner.
https://youtu.be/3AmUt0_C-YY
8879997025
Sagar Singh Thakur INC *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 8879997026
Mukeshkumar Himmatlal Mistry
BJP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have done 4-5 road and replaced 50 year old water pipes.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will renovate Sardar Vallabhai Patel garden and Khajorao garden with amenities for senior citizens and children.
https://youtu.be/mJWVpTJLAV0
9769390993/ 8879997027
Geeta Aashish Yadav INC HEALTH: I've provided water in each of the housing gullies solving all water woes.
INFRASTRUCTURE: Recently a space for dispensary has been alloted by BMC.This will be developed.
https://youtu.be/0If2uhihnLI
9892850871/ 8879997028
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Ajit Damodar Bhandari SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have undertaken the work of building a bridge to Versova.
*No Reply*
https://youtu.be/X5OtKBlQxCI
9820284410/ 8879997029
Vishwas Pandurang Ghadigaonkar
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I am getting a garden and community hall constructed.
INFRASTRUCTURE: The work of installing a chimney at Charkop Naka cremation toilet blocks at Kachpada will begin soonbegin soon.
https://youtu.be/9gOIp13fV-c
8879997030
Parminder Ratansingh Bhamra
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: A project pending since the past 40 years of constructing a road above Link Road has been completed.
INFRASTRUCTURE, SANITATION: Work on toilet blocks at Kachpada will begin soon.
https://youtu.be/ ADcRz7YOgQ8
9820784572/ 8879997031
Anagha Prakash Mhatre
SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869273617/ 8879997032
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Ramnarayan Amtharam Barot
BJP HEALTH: My first initiative for Mumbai was the anti-tobacco campaign
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will construct a jogging track at Ramleela Maidan.
https://youtu.be/FnZaCrNGWEs
9869080789/ 8879997033
Sunil Daulat Gujar SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have done work of gardens and roads.
MISCELLANEOUS: I will work on roads and sewerage line.
https://youtu.be/_rMof-Xtcac
9820333203/ 8879997034
Bhomsing Hirsing Rathod
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got nine new pipelines laid and functional. I have constructed an open gym for women and senior citizens.
MISCELLANEOUS: I will solve ninety percent of the slum dweller’s remaining problems, be it about gullies, roads or water provision.
https://youtu.be/nhQ9oNwcxfc
9969457170/ 8879997035
Prashant Dashrath Kadam
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have constructed an open gym for women and senior citizens.
INFRASTRUCTURE, HEALTH & SANITATION: I will provide facility of lavatory, water and electricity to people living in Sanjay Gandhi National Park.
https://youtu.be/d7HzJoGVOt4
9702597025/ 8879997036
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Manisha Sadashiv Patil SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9320671296/ 8879997037
Rupali Ajit Raorane NCP INFRASTRUCTURE: I have undertaken various works with respect to widening of roads and beautification of gardens.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will install lights at Shantaram Lane Highway.
https://youtu.be/gukew7PjjYk
9869360739/ 8879997038
Sayali Sunil Varise
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got nine new pipelines laid and functional.
MISCELLANEOUS: I will solve ninety percent of the slum dweller’s remaining problems, be it about gullies, roads or water provision.
https://youtu.be/nhQ9oNwcxfc
9969457170/ 8879997039
Gyanmurty Ramchandra Sharma
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have solved water woes in all houses and ensured pothole-free road.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will set up a community hall and a mini sports complex.
https://youtu.be/PRwfJZtj5_s
9702597025/ 8879997040
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/N Ward- Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Vinod Babaji Shelar SHS HEALTH & SANITATION: Mine is the first garbage-free ward in Mumbai.
*No Reply* https://youtu.be/cIUH9Wsnor8
9320671296/ 8879997041
Deepak Pandurang Pawar
NCP *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9869360739/ 8879997042
Qumarjahan Mohammad Moin Siddiqi
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have got passed 80 street light poles whose work has been completed.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I am trying to make the Hindi municipal school a ground-plus-one structure.
https://youtu.be/q8328AOLL2g
9969457170/ 8879997043
Cyril Peter D’souza
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I've got a 6 storey hospital made in Malwani and two BMC schools constructed.
*No Reply* https://youtu.be/U4i5snqTGxM
9702597025/ 8879997044
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/S Ward- Goregaon, Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Sneha Vinayak Zagde INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have completed work of 15 roads- 5 cement concrete and 10 asphalt.
HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I will start a medical dispensary in my ward.
https://youtu.be/9v1xc_Frnoo
9821513340/ 8879997045
Varsha Swapnil Tembvalkar
SHS INFRASTRUCTURE: I have built three gardens near Upper Govind Nagar.
HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I plan to build a speciality hospital for cardiac care on a BMC plot.
https://youtu.be/41Nl57KYP-0
9833261857/ 8879997046
Jitendra Hiralal Valvi
SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9757196595/ 8879997047
Sunil Vaman Prabhu
SHS *Denied Interview* *Denied Interview* ----- 9820702777/ 8879997048
Don’t just Vote. Select!
AREA: P/S Ward- Goregaon, Malad Promise and Performance as declared by the corporator in a two minute interview with MumbaiVotes
CORPORATOR PARTY PERFORMANCE (since election in 2012) PROMISE (until end of term) YOUTUBE LINK CONTACT NO.
Lochana Chandrakant Chavan
SHS
SANITATION, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have successfully installed a water tank for one public toilet in my constituency.
*No Reply*
https://youtu.be/_daEGxzK004
9594989816/ 8879997049
Rajan Vasant Padhye SHS MISCELLANEOUS: I have provided road facilities, solved the issue of gutters and worked towards the provision of water facilities.
SANITATION: The waste segregation plan has also been passed by the BMC and now it will be implemented building-wise so that less amount of waste reaches the dumping ground.
https://youtu.be/nEk-HRZIfbc
9820702709/ 8879997050
Pramila Dilip Shinde
SHS HEALTH, INFRASTRUCTURE: I have provided facilities like CT scan and special ward for children in hospital.
INFRASTRUCTURE: I will provide NIC (Network Interface Controller).
https://youtu.be/Hq_2U3kMko4
9920059494/ 8879997051
Kiran Vinay Patel
INC INFRASTRUCTURE: I have made CC roads in my ward.
*No Reply*
https://youtu.be/upeR-MBbv7o
9967090845/ 8879997052
Don’t just Vote. Select!
What this report won’t do… What can you do? Let them know that you are watching them!
SMS or call your corporator and let
them know- “I have read the
MumbaiVotes Report Card.”
Signup for regular updates for your
corporator’s promises & performance-
http://mumbaivotes.com/pages/newsletter/
You have the Right to Copy
(The MumbaiVotes ‘Copy Right’ Law)
- Share this report
- Share the videos
Make an issue about your issues-
Call/SMS your corporator and request
him/her to address your civic issues.
Like on Facebook: www.facebook.com/MumbaiVotes Follow us on Twitter: @mumbaivotes