Upload
others
View
20
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
VALIDATION OF THE TWINSENSOR MILK FOR RAPID SCREENING OF ββββ-LACTAMS
AND TETRACYCLINES IN MILK
Wim Reybroeck and Sigrid OogheT&V-ILVO Melle
5th International Symposium on Hormone and Veterinary Drug Residue Analysis
Antwerp, Belgium 19/05/2006
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
2
TESTING UPON THE DAIRY COMPANY(self control)
CONTROL ON RECEPTION OF THE MILK OR BEFORE PRODUCTION
⇒ protection of the fermentation process
⇒ EEC-Directive 92/46
• self control (own checks)
• >MRL: milk not suitable for human
consumption (destruction)
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
3
WHICH RESIDUES DO WE NEED TO DETECT?• Study of milk samples resulting in penalisation based on a positive
Delvotest MCS result (May & June 2003, Flanders) (Reybroeck and Daeseleire, 2003)
1° penicillin G 2° cloxacillinIn some countries (e.g. France) tetracyclines are also often found in milk
IDENTIFICATION OF INHIBITORS9%
4%
8%
79%
β-lactam, non synthetic penicillins
β-lactam, synthetic penicillins and cefalosporins
combination β-lactam/non β-lactam
non β-lactam (sulfonamides,…)
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
4
TWINSENSOR MILK (Unisensor s.a., Belgium)
Competitive receptor assay in dipstick format for the simultaneous detection of β-lactams and tetracyclines in milk in 6 minutes.
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
5
TWINSENSOR MILK: KIT VALIDATION ACCOR-DING TO COMMISSION DECISION 2002/657/EC
- Specificity / cross-reactivity- Detection capability- Test ruggedness
- Test performance influences- Length of incubation- Influence of waiting time on reader results
- Reagents (under evaluation)- Batch differences- Test kit stability
- Milk parameters- Impact of somatic cells, bacterial count, fat content, protein content, pH- Type of milk (raw, pasteurised, UHT, sterilised)- Milk from animal species other than the cow (ewes, goats, mares)
- Test for false positive / false negative results- International ring trial
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
6
TWINSENSOR MILK: TEST PRINCIPLECompetitive receptor test in dipstick format
1st step: microplate cup with receptor + 200 µl of milk (3 min at 50°C)
β-lactam antibiotics + receptor ⇒ stable non-active complextetracyclines + receptor ⇒ stable non-active complex
2nd step: addition of a dipstick, migration and colour formation(3 min at 50°C)
→ ‘CTRL’ line captures a part of the excess of reagents
→ ‘TEST’ line captures remaining active receptor for β-lactams
‘TEST’ line captures remaining active receptor for tetracyclines→
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
7
TWINSENSOR MILK: VISUAL READING
TEST Tetra→CTRL →TEST β-L →
POS
POS
NEGPOSNEGunvalidResultββββ-Lactams
POSNEGNEGunvalidResult Tetracyclines
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
8
TWINSENSOR MILK: INSTRUMENTAL READINGREAD SENSOR: result = ratio test line / control line+ RAPID software- area or amplitude
> 1.10: ‘neg’> 0.90 & ≤ 1.10: ‘low pos’≤ 0.90: ‘pos’
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
9
TEST KIT SPECIFICITY / CROSS-REACTIVITY
Small interference by clavulanic acid at 2000 µg/kg on β -lactam channel.
⇒ The TWINSENSOR MILK assay is very specific for the analysis of β -lactam / tetracyclines in milk.
trimethoprimdiamino pyrimidine derivates
clavulanic acidβ-lactamase inhibitors
sulfadiazinesulphonamidesenrofloxacinquinolones
neomycinaminoglycosideserythromycinmacrolides
lincomycinlincosamidesoxytetracyclinetetracyclines
chloramphenicolamphenicolscefaloniumcephalosporins
colistinpolymyxinspenicillin Gpenicillins
substancegroup Substancegroup
Milk spiked at 10x MRL (or 10x MRPL) with one compound of the most important groups of antibiotics or chemotherapeutics
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
10
TEST KIT SENSITIVITY• All penicillins, cefalosporins and tetracyclines on the MRL list
tested• Spiked in raw blank milk
– range 1 -10 ppb: in steps of 1 ppb– range 10 - 20 ppb: in step of 2 ppb– range 20 - 50 ppb: in step of 5 ppb– range 50 -100 ppb: in steps of 10 ppb
• 20 Replicates• Blind coded, randomly mixed
• Test kit sensitivity defined as the lowest concentration tested giving at least 19 upon 20 times a positive result.
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
11
TWINSENSOR MILK: TEST SENSITIVITYMRLs and test sensitivities in µg/kg
18
10
6
50
6
6
14
4
3
2
Test Sensitivity
> 200100cefalexine4ampicillin
35125cefacetrile4amoxicillin
14---doxycycline50cefazolin
25100chlortetracycline100ceftiofur
30100oxytetracycline60cephapirin
40100tetracycline30nafcillin
30dicloxacillin
420cefalonium30cloxacillin
350cefoperazone30oxacillin
3020cefquinome4penicillin G
Test Sensitivity
MRLSubstanceMRLSubstance
⇒ The TWINSENSOR MILK detects all β-lactam (excepted for
nafcillin, cefquinome and cefalexine) and tetracyclines in milk at MRL.
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
12
TWINSENSOR MILK : TEST SENSITIVITYIn between brackets: MRLs in µg/kg.
Inner circle = 2 MRL, circle 2 = MRL, circle 3 = 0.5 MRL, outer circle = 0.25 MRL
Beta-lactam compoundspenicillin G (4)
ampicillin (4)
amoxicillin (4)
oxacillin (30)
cloxacillin (30)
dicloxacillin (30)
nafcillin (30)
cephapirin (60)ceftiofur (100)
cefazolin (50)
cefquinome (20)
cefalexin (100)
cefacetrile (125)
cefoperazone (50)
cefalonium (20)
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
13
TEST RUGGEDNESS – TEST PARAMETERSINFLUENCE LENGTH OF INCUBATION PERIODS• Reading T1/C & T2/C after different incubation periods• Blank and doped farm milk (3 ppb pen G & 30 ppb OTC)
1.631.851.400.710.670.574 doped
1.081.291.200.410.630.493 doped
1.211.481.450.680.800.721 doped
1.431.631.610.530.610.552 doped
2.442.571.932.412.522.064
2.012.602.332.202.321.973
1.992.482.322.252.472.262
1.942.202.112.202.442.371
3’ + 2’302’30 + 3’3’ + 3’3’ + 2’302’30 + 3’3’ + 3’
tetracyclinesβ-lactamfarm milk
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
14
TEST RUGGEDNESS – TEST PARAMETERSINFLUENCE LENGTH OF INCUBATION PERIODS• Reading T1/C & T2/C after different incubation periods• Blank and doped farm milk (3 ppb pen G & 30 ppb OTC)
1.911.531.400.550.630.574 doped
1.401.291.200.470.450.493 doped
1.701.441.450.550.540.721 doped
1.861.671.610.420.440.552 doped
3.092.521.932.792.582.064
2.762.392.332.192.231.973
2.722.652.322.502.632.262
2.702.232.112.732.382.371
3’ + 3’303’30 + 3’3’ + 3’3’ + 3’303’30 + 3’3’ + 3’
tetracyclinesβ-lactamfarm milk
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
15
TEST RUGGEDNESS – TEST PARAMETERSINFLUENCE LENGTH OF INCUBATION PERIODS• Reading T1/C & T2/C after different incubation periods• Blank and doped farm milk (3 ppb pen G & 30 ppb OTC)
2.041.891.400.570.640.574 doped
1.581.401.200.440.600.493 doped
1.661.531.450.530.600.721 doped
2.071.891.610.530.590.552 doped
2.922.821.932.692.872.064
2.882.622.332.262.511.973
2.812.682.322.772.652.262
2.442.392.112.662.452.371
4’ + 4’3’30 + 3’303’ + 3’4’ + 4’3’30 + 3’303’ + 3’
tetracyclinesβ-lactamfarm milk
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
16
TEST RUGGEDNESS – TEST PARAMETERSINFLUENCE OF WAITING TIME ON RESULTS• Reading T1/C & T2/C after 0, 100 and 200 seconds• Blank and doped farm milk (3 ppb pen G & 30 ppb OTC)
1.671.461.041.241.121,014 doped
1.841.591.250.770.750.713 doped
0.970.850.590.230.230.191 doped
1.601.361.010.660.650.592 doped
2.912.512.222.832.592.414
2.922.501.822.492.322.013
3.282.781.912.812.662.152
2.652.381.791.501.451.251
t=200’’t=100’’t=0t=200’’t=100’’t=0
tetracyclinesβ-lactamfarm milk
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
17
TEST RUGGEDNESS – MILK PARAMETERSIMPACT OF SOMATIC CELLS• 36 milk samples with SCC > 1.106 / ml7 samples positive for β-lactam (3 positive with βeta-s.t.a.r.)4 samples positive for β-lactam + tetracyclines (0 positive with βeta-s.t.a.r.)
LC-MS/MS analysis (Dr. E. Daeseleire) of 2 positive samples: no presence of β-lactam antibiotics
• 4 normal milk samples + 10 milk samples with high SCC,also doped with 3 ppb pen G & 40 ppb OTC
tetracyclinesβ-lactam
1.240.450.660.730.230.37doped in milk with high SCC
1.230.901.080.630.300.44doped in normal milk
2.951.902.432.951.271.91milk with high SCC (n=10)
2.582.212.362.212.052.14normal milk (n=4)
maxminavgmaxminavg
samples
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
18
TEST RUGGEDNESS – MILK PARAMETERS
The impact of following milk parameters on the TwinSensor results isstill under investigation:
- bacterial count- fat content- protein content- pH- type of milk (pasteurised,UHT, sterilised, milk powder)- milk from animal species other than the cow (ewes,
goats, mares)
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
19
TEST RUGGEDNESS – TEST FOR FALSE POSITIVE / FALSE NEGATIVE RESULTS
• TWINSENSOR MILK integrated in monitoring program (farm milk, truck milk)
• Other screening tests:– Delvotest SP-NT– Bacillus cereus-test (tetracyclines)– Escherichia coli- test (quinolones)
– βeta-s.t.a.r./ Charm MRL Beta-lactam Test (ROSA) (cefquinome)
• So far, no false negative test results, no false positivetest results.
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
20
INTERNATIONAL RING TRIALLIST OF PARTICIPATING LABS (16)
- AFFSA, Community reference laboratory for antimicr obial residues, France- Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Belgr ade, Serbia and Montenegro- Fed. Research Centre for Nutrition & Food, Inst. Hygi ene & Food Safety, Germany- Istituto Superiori di Sanità – CNQARA, Italy- Laboratorio Agroalimentario de Santander, Spain - National Food Administration, Chemistry Division 1 , Sweden- National Milk Laboratories, United Kingdom- Nat. Vet. Research Inst., Department of Hygiene of Food of Animal Origin, Poland- Nestlé Research Center; Switzerland- Scientific Institute of Public Health, Belgium- State Veterinary Institute Jihlava, Czech Republic- Univ. in Ljubljana, Biotech. Faculty, Zootechnical D ep., Lab. for Dairying, Slovenia- University of Veterinary Medicine, Department of V eterinary Public Health, Austria- Univ. Zagreb, Fac. of Food Tech. and Biotech., Resid ue Analysis Center, Croatia
- Unisensor s.a., Belgium
- T&V-ILVO, Melle, Belgium
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
21
INTERNATIONAL RING TRIALCODIFICATION + RESULTS (visual reading)
results (number of labs)
ββββ -lactam tetracyc lines
code substance(s) conc.
(µg/kg)
MRL
(µg/kg)
neg pos neg pos
T1 = T18 c loxac illin 15 30 32x 32x
T2 = T11 blank m ilk --- --- 32x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T3 = T16 cefoperazone 5 50 1x (lab 10) 31x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T4 = T12 penic illin G 4 4 32x 32x
T5 = T20 te tracycline 75 100 32x 32x
T6 = T15 amoxic illin 6 4 32x 32x
T7 = T13 ceftio fur 30 100 32x 32x
T8 = T19 sulfamethazine 1000 --- 32x 32x
T 9 = T17 penic illin G
nafc illin
2
20
4
30
1x (lab 3) 31x 32x
T10 =T14 oxytetracyc line
penic illin G
50
3
100
4
1x (lab 10)
31x
1x (lab 10) 31x
In general very favourable results.4 false negative results (3x lab 10 and 1x lab 3); 2 false positive results (lab 10).
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
22
INTERNATIONAL RING TRIALCODIFICATION + RESULTS (visual reading)
results (number of labs)
ββββ -lactam tetracyc lines
code substance(s) conc.
(µg/kg)
MRL
(µg/kg)
neg pos neg pos
T1 = T18 c loxac illin 15 30 32x 32x
T2 = T11 blank m ilk --- --- 32x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T3 = T16 cefoperazone 5 50 1x (lab 10) 31x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T4 = T12 penic illin G 4 4 32x 32x
T5 = T20 te tracycline 75 100 32x 32x
T6 = T15 amoxic illin 6 4 32x 32x
T7 = T13 ceftio fur 30 100 32x 32x
T8 = T19 sulfamethazine 1000 --- 32x 32x
T 9 = T17 penic illin G
nafc illin
2
20
4
30
1x (lab 3) 31x 32x
T10 =T14 oxytetracyc line
penic illin G
50
3
100
4
1x (lab 10)
31x
1x (lab 10) 31x
In general very favourable results.4 false negative results (3x lab 10 and 1x lab 3); 2 false positive results (lab 10).
Samplewith thelowest stability
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
23
INTERNATIONAL RING TRIALCODIFICATION + RESULTS (visual reading)
results (number of labs)
ββββ -lactam tetracyc lines
code substance(s) conc.
(µg/kg)
MRL
(µg/kg)
neg pos neg pos
T1 = T18 c loxac illin 15 30 32x 32x
T2 = T11 blank m ilk --- --- 32x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T3 = T16 cefoperazone 5 50 1x (lab 10) 31x 31x 1x (lab 10)
T4 = T12 penic illin G 4 4 32x 32x
T5 = T20 te tracycline 75 100 32x 32x
T6 = T15 amoxic illin 6 4 32x 32x
T7 = T13 ceftio fur 30 100 32x 32x
T8 = T19 sulfamethazine 1000 --- 32x 32x
T 9 = T17 penic illin G
nafc illin
2
20
4
30
1x (lab 3) 31x 32x
T10 =T14 oxytetracyc line
penic illin G
50
3
100
4
1x (lab 10)
31x
1x (lab 10) 31x
In general very favourable results.4 false negative results (3x lab 10 and 1x lab 3); 2 false positive results (lab 10).
Samplewith thelowest stability
Lack of training?Language problem?
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
24
INTERNATIONAL RING TRIALRESULTS (instrumental reading) OF 3 LABS
ß-lactam TetraT&V-ILVO UNISENSOR NESTLE T&V-ILVO UNISENSOR NESTLE
RATIO RATIO RATIO RATIO RATIO RATIOBlank 2,46 2,84 3,70 2,10 2,12 3,55
PEN 4ppb 0,34 0,15 0,53 2,59 2,74 3,75T1 0,56 0,35 0,65 2,47 2,28 3,58T2 2,76 2,80 3,66 2,42 2,16 3,55T3 0,53 0,36 0,57 2,27 2,28 3,29T4 0,40 0,26 0,52 2,71 2,56 3,62T5 2,63 2,83 3,38 0,53 0,59 0,82T6 0,58 0,62 0,81 2,79 2,61 3,65T7 0,70 0,59 0,70 2,25 2,27 3,45T8 2,64 2,85 3,42 1,62 2,24 3,14T9 0,87 0,67 0,67 1,89 2,41 2,94T10 0,71 0,31 0,52 0,56 0,66 0,94T11 2,58 2,73 3,43 1,44 1,91 3,43T12 0,49 0,15 0,46 2,06 2,40 3,45T13 0,83 0,56 0,79 1,91 2,29 3,59T14 0,63 0,20 0,52 0,54 0,69 0,89T15 0,75 0,59 0,70 1,77 2,43 3,31T16 0,51 0,19 0,57 2,43 2,51 3,48T17 0,82 0,70 0,65 2,25 2,44 3,18T18 0,62 0,41 0,62 2,62 2,49 3,31T19 2,63 2,97 3,59 2,03 2,26 3,35T20 2,91 2,87 3,41 0,62 0,63 0,93
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
25
CONCLUSION
The TWINSENSOR MILK is a suitable test for rapid screening of milk on the presence ofβ-lactam + tetracyclines
Some ruggedness parameters are still under investigation- Reagents
- Batch differences- Test kit stability
- Milk parameters- Impact of bacterial count, fat content, protein content, pH- Type of milk (raw, pasteurised, UHT, sterilised)- Milk from animal species other than the cow (ewes, goats, mares)
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
26
Thank you foryour attention
β -lactam tetra
ILVO - Technologie en Voeding http://www.vlaanderen.be/ilvo
COPYRIGHTNo part of the material (scientific data, photographs, …) protected by this copyright notice may be reproduced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner.
All rights reserved Tel: +32 9 272 30 11© Wim Reybroeck Fax: +32 9 272 30 01T&V-ILVO 2006 E-mail: [email protected]
Brusselsesteenweg 370 B-9090 MELLE, Belgium
Oral presentation given on May 19th 2006 at the 5th International Symposium on Hormone and Veterinary Drug Residue Analysis in Antwerp, Belgium