10
I.ero Ns2-2032/2011 PEIIIEHIIE If ,\reHeDr Poccufi qcoft <Deaepaqnn Bopryrnucxufi ropo4crofi cyA pecny6anxu Koun t B cocraBe npeAceAareJrrcrByroqero cy4ru Kpyroncxofi A.B., lprr ceKperape cy,.e6noro gaceAasus Eziroxoae 8.H., c ) racrneM ucrrJa CuzosaB.LI., flpetrcTaBzTeflt OTBeTqItI(a COrerxArcOra 8.B., paccMorpeB B orKpBrroM cy4e6nou 3ace*a'Epr B fopoAe fopxyre 1g ceurt6px 207r rorc rpaxAaHCKOe '4eJro rro acry peruoua.nrnoft o6qecmenrrofi opranr,raaqrar.r <Ilinrp garq\arbr norpe6ureneft> B 3arqr4Ty [paB E 3aKOHHbD( r{HTepecoB Cusona Baaepur I{sa'Ornqa x ooo <Kovnanr'r <rloarrrocr<osH'rri aou> - Bopxyro o "i"r"o*r" orrJrarbr ,,o Aoronopy o6 oKaza'au ycnyr, neycroEru, r{HAe(caqEr.r AeHexHbD( c)^4M u KoMrreHcaqrrri MopaJrbHoro BpeA4 ycTarroBtrJI: Perzoranrnar o6rqe-crnennas opra'r.Baq[r <I{enrp saqurrr norpe6urenefi> o6parunacr B CyACIrcKoM K OTBeTqrr(y B 3arqxTy rlpaB Il 3aI(oHHhD( o BsbrcKa'ur "to""o"*''"J""lTl'":::::T:lll1uljenecon crsona Ba.nepzx rlsauosuqa qy:p:sa600pv6.,reft ,:#L::.d":!::,i"f#il'3,:l#*#;J:1,",;;,:;*iilh 497 448 py'rcft, u*reKcaJ\nfi ""u"rn r, ""r"o rro .'roBopy cwM, Harru*arc orrx6pr 2010 .oAa oo Edry BbrFece[ u cyae6noro peureutar, KoMrleHcarlru 3a rroJr*oBa'rrn qy)K,,ME ,qeHexHbrMr4 cpeacrBaMu Haqr4ntur c 17.0t.2010r. no 2a.n.2010i.;;-;"pr;;;;.D.2010r. IIo AeHb BErrreceHwr cyge6noro pemeHar, KoMueHcaqHri Mop:rn6Horo BpeAa B pa3Mepe l0 000 py6neiz, B3lrcKaur.rfl rurpa@a. e oOo""o"*r";;;;;;-r, .rro 05.04.2010r. brasoay B.I4. sa cqer cpeAcrB Muno6ooonrr_poccvru 6au- ""** a,oryoupcrBeHgBrfi xnrurqnrrft ceprn0aKar )l!656910, xoropuft yiocro"epro rpeAocraBJreHue """qy "oqr_"irofi nrmnarrr B pa3Mepe | 4ll 200pylnefr na npro6pereuae il;;;;;;;# *,.pprropau Mocronir<o it o6nacrw. 16.06.2010r. uex4y Cr.rsoauuB.LI. uooO ;K;;;<floauocronnrrfi 4ou>_Bopryra> 6ru ;1XffiH#"TTt"J;]]11, o6 orasaHur y.nl., .,p"s*r.oM Koroporo,Brrrrroc6 "o""p."""" co6crnensocn;;;;*T"#f "#[?#ff :fr:TT.JIJ"f,1:r""iJr6"*h:f": rlcrroJr'3.Ba'rr eMrocyAapcrBaer::o_x[fiuryroro ceprrQur<ara, a raKxe ycnyf, HarrpaBnerr'ED( Ha rorc* npuo6p*a'.er.o:g::y HeABrxcrMocrr{ " oi.*r.uu^ cAerKE no orqyxaeHrno orr6pannoro o6texta c lepeqrlcJreHl,reM cpeAcrB n py6.rrenou 3KBaBajreHTe Ha pacqerHBlfi c.rET 3a*AnquKa conrac'o rapanrufrnoro o6sgat"nctBa. (in rutu y"rry. orBerqrKa B paglrepe g4 600 py6tefi npe4yeuutprrBarracb aoroBopoM nyreM yAepxanus OOO <KoMnaHz.s <flo,nlocrosrrrrfi 4olr>-Bopxy'ra> nrn'eyra:annofi "y"rut rt a"ra*i* aieAcrB, npnqr.rraroqrxc{ ,crrly ,,ocne coBepfleur{Jr cAeroK rro o@opuneuno " aoo"r""rroi o6rexra ""r""*"ro"r". -;;;;;" " j."J:::':"':l:-I4 nocreAlrou{eMy orqyxAeguro 5111'o""- ""p*4,*u-",B3i-u'Tffi;?"#b rumx*;#,"i:i'*n#";*r ttop*yra) 4;rr npuo6pereH" xuroro [oMerrle'[' Ha reppr,T.p[n Mocxorcrofi o6tacra. AoroBop o6 oxasanvra ycryl Jrtb t3z1O, saKrroqe'Hurr-rc.6i;.ZOtOi. ";;;;';;;;; oOO (KoMrra'rrr <rlo'rr'rocxonnuft 40u>-Bopxyra>, o;t ;;"- 40 r6 ceHra6pr 2010 rorc. cornacno rapan:''rftnouy o6-".ut.n""rJy ""t 'rio?Jdio.., ,BrrrrorqeMyc, Heorr,eMneMor ;:nTrj1?%;:?:*"*""narrzx <rro4r,,ro.oo"rrr aoru_nop*y._ ol"*"" o"_" Tr;;;;;;;;;;il?;:frY;.XT#"ffi l"1il jt"t;'"1*6'ste'reHzeo"."*-'s*io" ::: ""' o6rena, yo"p** st Aqd;ffi:T'#;i#ffiffi:tffi#ir;;J; ::1o*""ToI9 9"jlra." Sarr naxox4eur.r, r acrrorrr3oBanr : pa3Mepe 1 4 r1200,00 pfi .' c rc.os.zi t0;. _';;;'-**"'""#,ffi'::I#H#",il"ffi"#nn: d'

Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

  • Upload
    max-k

  • View
    251

  • Download
    7

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

Citation preview

Page 1: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

I.ero Ns2-2032/2011P E I I I E H I I E

If ,\reHeDr Poccufi qcoft <Deaepaqnn

Bopryrnucxufi ropo4crofi cyA pecny6anxu Koun

t

B cocraBe npeAceAareJrrcrByroqero cy4ru Kpyroncxofi A.B.,lprr ceKperape cy,.e6noro gaceAasus Eziroxoae 8.H.,c ) racrneM ucrrJa CuzosaB.LI.,flpetrcTaBzTeflt OTBeTqItI(a COrerxArcOra 8.B.,paccMorpeB B orKpBrroM cy4e6nou 3ace*a'Epr B fopoAe

fopxyre 1g ceurt6px 207r rorcrpaxAaHCKOe '4eJro rro acry peruoua.nrnoft o6qecmenrrofi opranr,raaqrar.r <Ilinrp garq\arbrnorpe6ureneft> B 3arqr4Ty [paB E 3aKOHHbD( r{HTepecoB Cusona Baaepur I{sa'Ornqa x ooo<Kovnanr'r <rloarrrocr<osH'rri aou> - Bopxyro o "i"r"o*r"

orrJrarbr ,,o Aoronopy o6 oKaza'auycnyr, neycroEru, r{HAe(caqEr.r AeHexHbD( c)^4M u KoMrreHcaqrrri MopaJrbHoro BpeA4

y c T a r r o B t r J I :

Perzoranrnar o6rqe-crnennas opra'r.Baq[r <I{enrp saqurrr norpe6urenefi> o6parunacrB CyA C IrcKoM K OTBeTqrr(y B 3arqxTy rlpaB Il 3aI(oHHhD(o BsbrcKa'ur "to""o"*''"J""lTl'":::::T:lll1uljenecon

crsona Ba.nepzx rlsauosuqaqy:p:sa600pv6.,reft ,:#L::.d":!::,i"f#il'3,:l#*#;J:1,",;;,:;*iilh:497 448 py'rcft, u*reKcaJ\nfi

""u"rn r,

""r"o rro .'roBopy cwM, Harru*arc orrx6pr 2010.oAa oo Edry BbrFece[ u cyae6noro peureutar, KoMrleHcarlru 3a rroJr*oBa'rrn qy)K,,ME,qeHexHbrMr4 cpeacrBaMu Haqr4ntur c 17.0t.2010r. no 2a.n.2010i.;;-;"pr;;;;.D.2010r.IIo AeHb BErrreceHwr cyge6noro pemeHar, KoMueHcaqHri Mop:rn6Horo BpeAa B pa3Mepe l0 000py6neiz, B3lrcKaur.rfl rurpa@a. e oOo""o"*r";;;;;;-r, .rro 05.04.2010r. brasoay B.I4. sacqer cpeAcrB Muno6ooonrr_poccvru 6au-

""** a,oryoupcrBeHgBrfi xnrurqnrrft ceprn0aKar)l!656910, xoropuft yiocro"epro rpeAocraBJreHue

"""qy "oqr_"irofi nrmnarrr B pa3Mepe| 4ll 200 pylnefr na npro6pereuae il;;;;;;;# *,.pprropau Mocronir<o it o6nacrw.16.06.2010r. uex4y Cr.rsoauuB.LI. uooO ;K;;;<floauocronnrrfi 4ou>_Bopryra> 6ru;1XffiH#"TTt"J;]]11, o6 orasaHur y.nl., .,p"s*r.oM Koroporo,Brrrrroc6

"o""p.""""co6crnensocn;;;;*T"#f "#[?#ff :fr :TT.JIJ"f,1:r""iJr6"*h:f":rlcrroJr'3.Ba'rr eM rocyAapcrBaer::o_x[fiuryroro ceprrQur<ara, a raKxe ycnyf, HarrpaBnerr'ED(Ha rorc* npuo6p*a'.er.o:g::y HeABrxcrMocrr{ "

oi.*r.uu^ cAerKE no orqyxaeHrnoorr6pannoro o6texta c lepeqrlcJreHl,reM cpeAcrB n py6.rrenou 3KBaBajreHTe Ha pacqerHBlfi c.rET3a*AnquKa conrac'o rapanrufrnoro o6sgat"nctBa. (in rutu y"rry. orBerqrKa B paglrepe g4 600py6tefi npe4yeuutprrBarracb aoroBopoM nyreM yAepxanus OOO <KoMnaHz.s <flo,nlocrosrrrrfi4olr>-Bopxy'ra> nrn'eyra:annofi "y"rut

rt a"ra*i* aieAcrB, npnqr.rraroqrxc{ ,crrly ,,ocnecoBepfleur{Jr cAeroK rro o@opuneuno "

aoo"r""rroio6rexra ""r""*"ro"r".

-;;;;;" " j."J:::':"':l:-I4 nocreAlrou{eMy orqyxAeguro

5111'o""- ""p*4,*u-",B3i-u'Tffi;?"#b rumx*;#,"i:i'*n#";*rttop*yra) 4;rr npuo6pereH" xuroro [oMerrle'[' Ha reppr,T.p[n Mocxorcrofi o6tacra.AoroBop o6 oxasanvra ycryl Jrtb t3z1O, saKrroqe'Hurr-rc.6i;.ZOtOi. ";;;;';;;;; oOO(KoMrra'rrr <rlo'rr'rocxonnuft 40u>-Bopxyra>, o;t ;;"- 40 r 6 ceHra6pr 2010 rorc.cornacno rapan:''rftnouy o6-".ut.n""rJy ""t

'rio?Jdio.., ,BrrrrorqeMyc, Heorr,eMneMor

;:nTrj1?%;:?:*"*""narrzx <rro4r,,ro.oo"rrr aoru_nop*y._ ol"*"" o"_"Tr;;;;;;;;;;il?;:frY;.XT#"ffi l"1il jt"t;'"1*6'ste'reHzeo"."*-'s*io""n*::: ""' o6rena, yo"p** st Aqd;ffi:T'#;i#ffiffi:tffi#ir;;J;::1o*""ToI9 9"jlra." Sarr naxox4eur.r, r acrrorrr3oBanr :pa3Mepe 1 4 r 1 200,00 pfi .' c rc.os.zi t0;. _';;;'-**"'""#,ffi'::I#H#",il"ffi"#nn:

d '

Page 2: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

ycJloBI,It AoroBopa a o'Asa&HocTrr r4cnom{nTerrr OOO (KoMraHr.r,,,flo,q'rocronu'fi aou"-Boprlno) B qacrn npno6pereHr'r xa raru.s cr4gosa B,II. rcnaprnprr neco6nroAa.nncr I'r He ncrro,r'eHhr Ao Hacrorrqero Bperuenz. Hecuorpr Ha HeoAHOKparHBreo6paulenru K OTBerqr.rKy, He IrcrroJrHeH'I B IIOJIHOM O6reue a aeHexHBre o6rsarerEctsaorBerqr.Ka - 24.r2.20r0r- orBerqrr* nepequum'' cuzosy v.B. rolrro qacrr;;;.;;* cpeacrB,'pu*a',oKaro'ux 3a*a3rrr{r(y, B pa3Mepe | 296 600,00 py6. ornervun ,"-*o"o""""po"- ,y6urra, Iro'ece'Hbre Cr'rgogrn4 conrac'o rroJroxeHl,IrM cr.15 fpaNaancxoro roAerca p@,3aroHa P@ <O sarqare npan nor:pe6ur eteit>>, a raxxe rr.5.2 saKJrroqerruo.o ,a*oy

"rno,AdroBopa o6 0r<asaur'rra ycnyr. B c'ny roro, qro orBeFrrrK Hap|*'url cpoKr4 BEmOmre nus pa60.tno AoroBopy' K Ha3HaqeHHoMy cpoKy rre ucnoJr'rJr rlprr'trrbre o6rcirelrcroa, poo <I{eurp3arqr'rrbr uorpe6rzreneft> -cqlrraer npztBoMep''rM rpe6onan np;.;";;

-;;;oyJrorpe"nou

HeycrorKr4, HasMHAt C 17, cenrx'px 2010 roaa, to a"t" flocJre oKoHsaH fix cpoKa AeftcrsrgAoroBopa Ne 13710, - * o,qT:fi cror.rMocrr.r pa6or u ycrryr, o[pe,.enennoft n. 3.1 4ororopa No13710 n p*Mepe 84 600,00 py6. rlocronrry " "o*"rru

rrcreqe'r.{r cpoKa vcrrorrHeH}r,orBerlMKoM O6.qsate*crs npo'ono 3'aqr.rreJr'Hoe BpeMJr, CyMMa, nepeAaHHZU Cnsonm{ ooo<Kounanr,q ,,flo.6rocxoanrrfi 4ou"- Bopryra>, B cr{ny un$nrqnoHxru< npoqeccoBo6ecqeHr'raacr. Hcxo*g' ug r43JroxeH'oro, cr-Bon u.B. BnpaBe paccqr,rr'rBarb Ha pearr'r{oeB.3Merqe'r're y6rm<or. Clnnrra, yrrraverrHas 3ar(a3i[ (oM no AOrOBOpy, 40nxna 6rrrrBo3Bparqe'a eMy c coxpa'eH[eM ee norynarenrnoft "no"o6no"rn

B ycJroBlirxsecta6r'rn'rocru rIeH MexaHrr3MOM, npeAHa3HaqeHH.lM Ans pe',o,gA\UU npa'rlrr,,a no,lrroroBO3MerrIeHar y6urr<on, sBrr'ercfl I,rHAeKCaq[s AeHexH'rX Cymrr. HeoAnorparnrre o6parqenrrcagona no rroBoay BhrrroJrHe'rir ycnyr rro aoroBopy B ycra'oBJreH'Lre aoroBopoM cpoK'orBerrMKoM I'IruopllpoBafl{c6, qro BrBEIBTUIO y Hero HerarItBHBre [epexr4BaHr.r, u fipvqr4's.rtrHp'lBcrBerr'hre crpara*n'', Ta*xe rloAnexauue Bo3Merqe"rro a"""*"ofi norrr*"urr""" "cury cr.15 3arona pO .lrl!2300-l z cr.151 fK p@.

ornerqrx ooo <Kon'rnanr.u <<flo,4rrocxosHbrfi AoM))-BopK)"Ta B or3HBe rra ucKoBoe3airBJre'ae .'poc]iJr orKa3ar6 B yAoBJrerBope'rrlr ucKa B nor'oM O6reue no noBo.qaM,I43JIOXEHH6M B HEM.

onpegerieurelr cyAa or 05.09.201 I roAa K [por*Bo4cray 6ruro [pr4Hrro ]"Torr'e'HoerrcKoBoe 3atBne'r're fipeacraBrrre,Ul perraona.nruofi o6qecrrennofi opralrr.rsaqlrn <qeurpsaqnGr norpe6ETerefi>, B KoropoM oH rlpocrul B3blcrarb c orBerrrr{(a B rIoJrB3y Ircrrla y6rrrr,tB pa3Mepe 114600 py6., neycrofixy 3a Hapyrxe'r,re cpo.oB B'r[OnHeHrir ycnyr B pa3Mepe807084'00 py6, uH.qeKcaqno ae'exHbD( cyr\{M c rpaMer{e'rreM uHAeKcoB pocranorpe6r'rrearcnax II.H' ycraHoBiIeHH'D( B pK, ga xaNarti uonrrrft MecrII flpocporrKu c orcryop,2070 rora ''o Aary Bbr'eceHut cyAoM pe,'e]rst, Ha reHb noAarrr.I 3zurBreHltr cocraBJ'rrorq,/ro26940,60 py6., rounercauzro 3a rroJrb3oBaHr.re qyxr.rMr.r AeHexHErMr,r cpeAcrBzlMu, 3a neprro| c25'12,010 ro.qa ''o Aary BhrHece'r" cyae'noro peue'ris, fia .qe'b [oAaqu ,cKacocraBnrroqyro 5777,75 py6., rcol.rneucaqfirc MopiurbHoro BpeAa B pa3Mepe 10000 py6., urya$B pa3Mepe 500/0 or npucylr<Aennofi n nonrsy rrcrrla clMMEr c nepeqacne'r,reM 500% cymuu erorourpaQa n nonrsy pOO <I{earp :aryurn norpe6urelit>.He couaurascu c yrorrHeH''rM ,"*o""* 3aJrBJIeHr.reM orBerrtr.rK ooo <Koprnana.{<rlo^rocronnufi 4ou>-Bopryra npeAcrnBr.IJr 013618, B KoropoM [pocrrn B yAoBnerBope'nr4 r.IcKa

2llf*":-Y?!"' tlro cpeAcrBa' npeAocraBrreHHue Cu:ory s.ra.

" p;;*; .oJifo.p*nn",obrJrl'r Ha[paBneHEI B CTpOTOM COOTBgrCTBr,ru c rpe60rauuxla" a*ooool"ou"r"uuc(nrorr'TeJrb'o na npuo6pereulre H.ABH'*AMOCTH, KOTOpar 6rrna o{opuneHa B eroco6ctse'rocr'' K y6urxar'r ucreq geo60cuoBa'Ho orrrocl4T CyMMEl, fip[q'Taroqerzc,orBsrrrr*y KoMr.rcct4r,r. Tpe60eanr.rx o B3brcKa'r,r,' B rroJlb3y cusosa B.ri. y6;;;;;epe 114600 py6neft cqrrrruor He3aKoHHErM, ra* KaK Bcr cyMMa no,raparrrnfiuolry o6r:atenrc*y 6rura[orrre'a r'rM B rro,rr]oM o6ser4e. cyuua, nr-rAeneHnar ct:ory B.I{. no .oayrup"*"rro"y

T[nulIHeyI ceprr'r4ur<ary, [oJrgocrbro 6rura nepene4ena c oJroKr.rpoBaHHOfO r{eJreBoro cqeraClrsona B'lI' -Ha cqer fipo,.aBqa KBaprr{pbr, To ecrL uclroJrb3oBa'a IIeJIeBbM o.parou u noHa3HarIeHrrIo. Kpoue roro, ne:*:r cur,rra* y66ITKtMIi CTOI,MOCTb ycJryr. 06qsare*crBa ()00

Page 3: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

-{-

<<Krl[-Bopryra) ucrroJr'eHbr 6es rapy'renur cpoKoB r4x rrclon'e'r.rr. cusog B.v. crpe60nanra.ruu pacropr'yrb AoroBop B nepaoA ero 4eftc,rrrax ne o6patlancr, uperensuft noKaqecrBy oKtIlaHHBrx ycryr He npeAbtBntJr. Taxur*l o6pa":orvr, rpe6oaanne o Bo3Bpare crorlMocrr.rycJlyr tro AoroBopy o6 oraganr'rra ycJlyr or 16 utottc 2010 rola cqr.rrauor He3aKoHHbrM EFeo6ocHosaH'rnr. @a*zqecrne cpo*r' o'.zr3{lHr{r ycnyr ooo <Kll,,{-Bopryro cBr3aHbr cEapyrreHr4eM cragosrnf B.lL ycaowrfi AoroBopa (t. 2.2.2-2.2.4), *orop-r" BErpa3[rrr.rcE Brrpe,{craBneHl'Ill neroctonepnoft nn$oprrraquu v \prrwttrru caMoBoJrbHLD( pemeurfi o6It3MeHeHHIr cqera' IIa Koroprui 4o.rnrcrrr 6rurr.r nocrynratr fipuqllTarourecr IeHe)IoGre cpeAcrBa[ocrs 3aKrroqeHr,tr roroBopa Kynnfi_,'poArDrs,r npuuag.nexarqei eMy KBapr'pbr;neo6xoAuuocrrro npoBeAer{Ar 3uaq rer'Horo o6reva pa60rr1 c60pa aoryueuror,TOCYAAPCTBEHHOfi PCflTCTPAIII4I,T AB)D( AOTOBOPOB KYIIJII4-IIPOAa)IO,I IIE4BTAXIMOCTI{ Pr[poIEBeAeHIrlI Bcex pacrleroB nyreu 6esnanallHoro [eperMcJreH]rt AeHexH6rx cpeAcrB qepe36arroncrue c'rEra. ?IxAercaqr{t HeBhmJraqe'HErx c},I\,rM He Moxer 6rnr np-ozsre4ena nKOMTIeECaUII' 3a rIoJIb3OBaHIte spKllMr,r AeHexHBIMr.r CpeacrBrlMl.l He Moxer 6rrm nsrrcxan4 .t.r.ooo <Kfl,{-Bopryro AeHex}rED( cpeacrB Ha npr.ro6DEreureHe.{Brrxr,rMoro r,rMFuecrBa o'r cvgo.Ba B.}L ne noryra.n o A HMU He pacfloprxanocl. Mopanrnru?npe4 cusona B.lI. ue Nroxsr 6rrrE KoMue'crpoBaH, r.r. ooo <rir,4-nopxyro He coBeprnaloIre3aKoHH6x AefrcrBuir' KoropBte MofJII{ ero noBJreqr. Kpoue roro, aoKa3areJrbcrB npqr114HeH11sMopiurbHoro BpeAa ri o60cEosaHr,re efo pa3Mepa IIe [peAcraBJreHu. IIIrpa{ ne uoxer 6rrrrB3ErcKaH, r.r. OOO <Kll{-Bopr<yro He coBepm wra peftc.rnufi, n apy_uroqrn* opuruuorpe6nrenefi, a ero p:BMep HlrqeM rre o6ocuoran.

B cy4e6norrr gaceaarrrra rtcrerl rrcKoBbre rpe6oranr.ra B yrorruenxoM Br.rAe rroAAepxaJl 11oaoBoAaM' Il3JIoxeErrBM B LcKe rI cKa3aHHEM paHee' ,qorroJrHltreJrBr{o rorcHlUr, rrro ri3 - 3a roro,qro aeEBrE troJryIrrn no3xe He cMor K)'I'ITE ruaprltpy, Koropyro xoreJr ''o*ynar6, rrpfi,onoc'rcynET6 Apyrro,3a}jnMarb 4enrrr. B p*ynbrare se Moxer yexarb v3 Bopryrrr, oo6"i s4"crPACINATIATbC' C AOJITOM. ON Z ErO XCHA HEOAHO4PATHO NP'TXO4,IJIII K OTBETIII-IKY, 3BOH14JIH, ID(yBepfio", rrro Bce 6y4er cgetano, sto 6r'oo noc.ue 16 cerrx6px 2010 ro4a..{o'16 cenrr6px2070 roaa oH 3axo.uiJr B aBrycre, KorAa rrpr.rHec uonyro c6epeiaren"ryo nr"*'"y, 17 aarycra2010 r. oH cpzl3y rzs c6ep6anxa r'o'en K orBerru.rKy nepe,qaJr AeBymKe HoBbrfi c,rer, oHac4enura efo Korrnlo [r cKa3aJra, vro 6ygyr flepeBereHbr aeHbfr.r Ha norrrft cqer r.r npodneu neBo3IrEKEer, MeHtrb nlurT B AoroBope He HaAo. .{eurrlr orrerruKy oH He nepeAaBan, orAaJrcepru@rrar, o cyrue r 30000 py6.nefi nuraroro yroBopa ne 6r'no.3soHroe HHKaKT{X ororBerirEKa se 6rrro r,r Hr.r(aKltx fiepefoBopoB c Hr4M He nenra. A.qBorary oH orAlur AoK]a{eHT6r[ojrroAa Ea3aA, OH AOJTTO foroBr,rJr AoKyr(eHTEt. Tenerpa.uua or orBerqrr1a 6tuta ol1;1a _e.qaEcrBeHuzur, og no nefi He rrotlren, [ocKoJrbKy Bo BTopHrrK AoJrxeH 6hff6 cyA.

rlpe4crannrear orBerq'Ka n cy4e6r.rou gacetarruu c r4cKoM He conracl lct ,,o aoBoAaM,L3jroxer{HbM B [I4cbMeHIroM or3hlBe, or3ErBe Ha yroqrreHHEle rpe6orannr u panee cKa3aHHbrM BcyAe6nolr 3aceaartuu, Aotronultrerbno noflcnur, rrro Hcreq ao no,qawr I{cKoBOfO 3turBrreHajr HeBO3paXiUr' Hrr ycrHbDL Hrr r {cbMeHHbx 40cyle6nrrx npvrenruft ne 6ruro. Kaaprr,rpa IIoAoroBopy 6rura npuo6perena no cepru{rzx {ry v Ae*br-" ,,pumJ,' c 6noruponannoio

"orru, "rlpoAaHa S .qa$HefirueN{ <cepru(br,rrar'.ruKy) r,r roxe AeHbrU flpurrrJrr4 c 6roxrponanuoro cqer4AeH6 r He rlorlaaaJrrl Ha cqer KoM[aHIiLI I.r 3a,Uepx(a BpeMerrrr npor43or[na roJIbKo LI3-sa rofo,.ITO I'CTCII 3AKP6IN CqET I{ HC NPEAOCTABIiJI IIM CBEACHI,Ifi. .{EUCr HI,IKAKI'X HE IICPCAABANOCb,rorrrKo cyMMa ceprn$nxara. cyuua n nornou o6reue 6una no cepralpNrary lepeBeaeHarpoAaBIIy KBaprr.rpEr. 3agepxry cyMMhr B pa3Mepe 30000 py6. ,rprnoar,j fiorcHur,'rrro oHayAepxr,rBaeTcr B KaqecTBe raparrTr\rr, o rreM rrHeHTaM yc"rfuo pa3,b c:flfreTcr, 3TO yonoBrrenI4CEMeHHO He OroBapHBaJIOCb,

Perr'roHa.[rHac o6tqecrrexna-a opfa'r*ar{r r <4enrp 3arrl,nT6r nor:pe6urene'>,[3BerrlerrHEre Haanexaql'IM O6pa:ou o BpeMeHr r.r Mecre cy.{e6noro 3aceaaltut, u

"y4 a"o"ao

lpeAcraBllTert He Ha[paBI4tI4' roKa3arenEcrB )aBulrKI'ITeJIbHocrH nprr\rrr HerBKI{ r.r xo4ataficreo6 ornoxenuu paccMorpenur aeJra cyAy He rrpeacraBl,urrr.

Page 4: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

B coorgercrBfiu co cr.r67 fIIK p.u Aeno paccMorpeHo 6ea yracrnr nuq, He,BxBrrluc, Bcy.4e6Hoe :ace4anr-re.Brrclyman AoBoabr nuq, yqacrByloqux B AeJre, EccJreAoBaB Marepr4:lJrBl .4en4 AorrpocnBcBu4ereJrefr, cya npr4xoAr.rr K cre,qFo[IeMy BbrBo.ry.cy^ou ycrauoueHo' rrro cusony Ba.nepra*- h"uno""ry KaK rracr'r.rKy [oAuporpaMM'r

<<Brmolnenae rccyaapcrBeHnbrx o6sgarerlrcrB no o6ey^cra'oBne'Hbrx o"alp-"ru* 3a*o'o.qarerr6crB"r;"T;H1;ff"i"XT"11?t"JrIffi;x)Kunrarqe> sa 2002-2010 .oA".r

_:1 ̂ c::r cpeAcrB Se4epa.nrnoro 6ro4xera rpeaocraBrreua'corJlraJrEHuu Bbrrrnara B pa3r\4epe 1 411 200 pyfuefi c yverolr oauoro coBMecrgo rrpoxr.Barou{erorureHa ceMEr{ - Cy''py* co-rronrenofi M.A., q:ro [oATBepxaaercr xl4Jrr.rq'6* ceprr$r'rarolr|IC J\b 656910 or 05.04.2010 roaa.16 utotrg 201 0 roaa rraer44y cra:o*ru Ba.nepnerrr rIsa'os'qeM ra ooo <Kounanan<lloAvocrosH'rfi aou> - -Bopxyro 6111 3aKrroqe' aofonop N013710, npeAMeroM KoropoforBJrlrnocr coBeprrreHne OOO <Kounanns <floavocrou"rrft 4oro _ Bop*yru, gefictnuit,

HanpaaneHHED( ua noa60p rn o$opunenr,re s co6crseEHocrr cusona'B.I1. obrercraqeABrr{crMocru s Mocrne r.r.n r Mocroscrofi olr,acru c HcrroJrb3oBanaeM rocyrapcrBerrgoro)rr'rJlr.rq'oro cepru$r,rara, a raKx(e ycJryr, Ha[p.BJreHHbD( B nocneAyrorqeM Ha norrcKnpto6perarenx oorerra ,n - opra'r,Baur,ro oSopvnenur caeJrKrr flo orrryxre'aloClrsonlrl4 B.lI. ru6paunoro o6lerra

" ,ro"naay.rq"l,r [epeqrrcJregrreM cpeAcrB n pybnerorrl3K!IIBaJ]eHTe ra pacverurrfi c'rET Cagosa B.H. B coorBercrBriu c rapanraftnrnr o6rsa.renrcroou,rBJUrIoqzMct Heomeuleruofi qacrrlo Hacrorrqero,qoroBoDa.

B coorsErcrnuz c n. 3.1 4oronopa Ns 13710 or 13.06.20t0r. crorrMocrb pa6or n yc.nyrOOO <Kounanlrr <<Io4uocxornrni 4or, _ Bopoyro cocraBrrrrer g4 600 py6nefi.fapanrzfinrnrr o6ggare*crso^.r or 1 6.06)0 t or. ooo <KoMnan's niio.ryo;no"rurr goro -

Bopryro rapaHrrzpoBana creony B.II. B'mrrarrrrb 1326 600 py6nefi r ,"""o"" a"""r"6aHnoscrnx .{Heft c uouenT a nepequcJreur.rr cpegcrB no AoroBopy or*ry>r(aeHlzs o6texra.Kar 6ruro ycra'oBrerro n- cy4e6nor,l "i""Aunt , Bo r{crroJr'e'ne ycnorraft 4oronopa No13710 ot 16'06'2010r. ooo <Korara'r.rr <rloAuocr<onnrrft 4orvr> - Bopry'ra> 17 cemxlpr 2010ro4a 6ruro npao6pereno n co6crse'Hoc* cusona B.I{. r.r conosresofi M.A. xc.uoe noueqenueno arpecy; Mocxoncras o6nac*, r.Opexoro-3yeno, yn.Mocxoncr_, a.S,

"u.iO, aro^noao,o2 313 630 py6net, nparo co6crne'Hocrr.r Ha y*Lu""y. r*aprr{py 6"'no sap"r"rprpoBarro 3artoK),narer.sMr.r 22.09.20 1 0 ro m.

Ha ocuonasur'r roroBopa KylJrn - npora)Kv KBaprnp.r or 09.11.2010r. y*a3a'Hoe BbrmexE oe noMer{enue 6rrro EpoAaHo .{enrcexro Barenrunl Huronaerne,,p*o "oo"r"a""o"r"Ha xr.rJroe noMerqe'ue 6'no saperrcrpupoBaHo 12.12.2010 roga. I4urepic' cuso*a 8.14. uConos-renoft M.A. no 4onepennocrrM [peAcraBn Jra HoBr.rKoBa A.A.

cornacno AoroBopy KyrrJrn,-[poArDro{ KBaprripbr or 09.1r.2010r., )ro,rnoe noMelrleHr,re IIoaApecy: Mocxoncxas. o6racr4 r.opexono-3yeno, yn-.Mocxoncrar, 4.5, rn.60, 6'.no npo4ano :a2313 630 py6nei. B coorssrcrs{ 14 c yclroBrr,,Mn aoroBopa opexoro-3yercroe ocE l,,rb1556/01556 Eo [op] reHr.rro Bna,qenbrla ceprusnrara repeqficrrer Ae'e)rcr.re cpercrBa c6anxoscxoro cqera rocyAapcrBeH'oro xrrrr. rl'oro ""ptr6""utu ""*;;;;;;d,

usuxaracfieA)'roulnM o6pa:orra: .wru _u- q1^y:p-r 1 296 600 py6ner nepeurn crsErct Ha pac"&r"rr cue,cnsora Barepar vaa*osu'ra Niczsoi.sto.s.zst s.oi 6zstz, orrpn*rfi

" ax do"p".ur.o""o,6anre P<D Bopryraucroe ocE Ne7l2g/0044, cyr,rua B pa3Mepe 1017 030 pyfutreia

l-"9:3:ry"-- Ha pacverrut cqer npeAcraBr.rreru npoAaBrloB Hosqrosoii A.A.Ne42307.810.7.4021.00r3178, orxp'r'ft n AK c6eperare*uon 6asre p<D, Kpa*roropcxoeorgelerIae Jrlb7808/00 1.I'Ie 4onolnnre.uEuoro cgTatrr,e1ri, K AoroBopy Ky[nr4_rpoAarrc.r KBaprr.tprr or 09.11.2010roaa ycMarpr.rBaercr, rrro oAo <c6ep6am poccnr.r> opexono_3yeacroe'ois Ns tjsolotssoIIo floprreHr'rrc BJraAeJrbr]a ceprrasr,rrcara [eper rcrrer .{e"e*""I" Cpe.qcrBa c 6aHKOSCXOTO CqerarocyAapcrBelrHoro xn,r'q'ofo ceprusurara BJraae'Ibr{a cepru(bzxara cireAyrcrqr.rM o6pa30M:c]'r\{Ma B pa3Mepe | 296 600 py6nefi uepeuu cJt',ercfl Ha pac.rsrH'rfi C.rer cHsosa Buepus.

Page 5: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

Lrsa*osn\a Ns42303 'g10'7.2g.15.076171g, orrprrrrrfi r ^A{ c6eperarenrnorrl 6asre p(DBoprvruncroe oc' Ne7^128l00qq. cv"k;';;;;'. I017030 pv6nei nepe.ru cr.'Erc Eapac'rEr''rfi cqer npeAcraBr4rer' rpoAaBrron Hosrroeoft e.e. Nrizi6i-.siiiiqozt.ootstla,or*phrr'rfi n AK c6eperarenrnou 6anre p@, xpu.-ro.op"*oe oraenenr.re Ng7g0g/001 .flpr paccnorpenuv Aena ycraHoBne' o, oo iq.n.zoro ."r"-rir.*i# "o"o"r"u "

pa3Mepe | 296 600 py'teft 6tnu t"p";;;.;;; ^na - .nzr{esofi cqEr Cugosa B.I4., qrorroArBepx.aercr *mucroft rc r*qeuoro cwra Nea*Bsiiliiisoiiiirsl'?""?. ronJ reHniryxa:aunofi clruurr Cnsonrna B,I4. n cyae

"a orrrupr"-rr. Tarau o6pasolr, pa3Mep HeAorrnarbrcocaas,nr 30 000 py6nefi, xoroprrft nog.nexur na"ra'**"a u [oJrE3y 14 crrla.B curry cr. 308,

1oo ipu*aur.*;;;;;;;"y-bHoro KoAeKca p(D o6xsare*crsaAOJTXHbT EcrroJlHrrrSct HaAnexaIqHM O6pa:olr

" aoor"""ao"" c ycJroBr,rrMlr o6ssaTertcrBa It

Ttfffil#":n#l* rpaBoBED( aKroB, u opr or"y..ru nn.taKuxycnoBr.rii z Tpe6oranzfi,p"6oua"'."r,nrn.d;";;;ffi;";ff ;".:,"x:xm"ffi x?x1il:H",;*ff#ff H#:r,r3Menerflre ero ycnonrfi He AouycraJorcg au ,"*

3aKOHOM. _ --, Avr:J w^<!v r vr, ra nsruIloqeHLreM CJrwaeB, npeAyCMoTpeHH6D(

Crarrr 421 fK p(D3aKrroqeHtri AoroBoDa.

npeaycMarprrBasr' qro rpaxAa'e u Pp[.4'IrrecKI'Ie rurqa cno6oAgrr r

.o* fff""#g#;:#"""0" Ne137l0 or 16'06'2010roAa' croporraMrn ue 6'n orpeAeJre'

16.09.2010 roaa. - s Eer4 6rr.lr orpeAeJren cporc ero rciacrius, c rc.0i.i6rc roAa.Eo

flynrrou 5' r ' flororopa npe,qycMorpeHo, wo 4eficrnr-re ^.roB.pa Moxer 6rrrr npoane'oIIo mlcbMeEHOMy conracl4io cTopoH, 3a ncKrroqeH[e]AoroBopa.

'--- -Ler/vLL' J4 ,v Ju(recHreM cnyqall' rrpelycMorpennoro u.5.1,1.B coorsercrsr.ra

" ":i;r.-r:_,::1" AoroBop no nprao6peren nro u*,orrryxAe'uro o66e.ra''oArrnnca' B rlpe,qeJrax cpora 4eficrnru tu"to"q"ro -roaoB.pa,

TO B Cryqae HeAocraTor[rocrr.r:fif#"#ff:ff1#rocvAapcr'e'Hol petrn"tpfrun coorBercrBvrolq"r

"a"** .qoroBopper.Ecrp",+'"o6rexra,";J"Tff ffi H;;"JU:*;1"rT##,.*#*ljH:;ff;:;ocyrqesrBneurrr rrepeBoAa aeHexHED( cp_eAcrB Ha palqerrur c.rer sara3rrrrKa-'{onopr orBerrr.rKa o roM, qro o6-ssarer*crBa ,i 6"-, ucrroJrlrerrhr B coorBercrBrr,r cocr.3l4 rK P@ r pa:yrr,rnrui cpo& cyr;;;;;;;':"crorrerrbH6rM'B cB,r3r c reM, qrorrricEMeurrBrMn MareprruraMv aarru "

o'6"r"""""*rn rro'

;ffiX,#"ffi "ff f ffi ffi#J*#iTffi##, jf1i:":#"iryr.J;"ili j,XiTi#cropouaMl{ tr" ga-rrorano"r, rrcrrly He coo.rqa.nocr o nloo*t"""

cpora geftcrnr'rr ,qoroBopanp"T^":.f_**"_1

";;;;;*""y ucronHeHrno ycn"#T;-JJj;.*axr'rrerbrrED( npurtrrHax,r aKxe He uMerolIHMX-npaBoBOrO 3HaqeHvil ,yo ,*orr" aoBOAbI oTBeTltrn*a o TOM, OTncrrla He rrocrylaJro Hr,rKaKEx flperercnfi ,l ,peOonanrlf- ,

llll^"jpl-'"."".""'.",ooAa''oeo6crosr"r""il;;'"J":?"&?J:iJiff ffi "*HToo{3areJrbcrBa e pauxax 4eficruu cpor(a AoroBopa.

"e#ff[ "."t#:u#-;ru"f"*g;ot.;Lo" E ero cyrpyr.a HeoA'oKparrro

o6ggatenrcts no oo.ouofy io.n. rcreqe'r' f, cpo*u ".o

o"o"JXriri no @arry He'crrorl'e'rrt

,"*#J;; ":t#ffJ*?i;*;;;;q;J#l' """o","n"" co:ronreron M.A.,Tar xe ona He 6rr,l

5:y',1*ii] n,'l"';d1T,"HX"J:iilH";HtrHfl" """o"'""en rraqe'ro rI.B. Hno np€Teu3lifi rl rpe6onaurafi xar ux-nu1o'e 3auIBJUrJr.

epecoBailct t'l cnoJrrIeHI'IeM aoroBop4B coorgerctnq u co c.r.401 fX FO *ui,' He ,ncrroJr'aBr,,ee o6ssare*crn a tn6orrcrro:InrBrlree ero Hena4nexau[4u o6pa:olr, ,"r", oru(y''cra

"*n ""o"ropox<rocru;, KpoMe cnyqae", "T#*fl#"J*#flr"H#;#

Page 6: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

lpenycMolpeHhr r.rHbre ocgoBaurxr orBercrBeHHocrr.r. Jluuo npuguaerc, rreBr.rHoBHEtM, ecnu rrprlrofi creneglr ga60tnr'rnocru r_ ocMorpr.rreJrbrrocr[, raK'l or Hero rpe60na:racr no xapa*Tepyo6xgarelrcrna a yc'oBrrsM o6opora, ouo rp;;;;-;r" MepEr .qrrr HaAnexaqero [crorrHe'zrro6rgarearcrna. otcyrcrnue_ rr,rn'r Ao*a3'rBaerct JrnrIoM, Hap*,,,rB,,ruM o6lgate*ctso.B coorsercrsaa " ]: 1:,

12 fpaNaancxoroipou"..y*"Horo Koaexca p@ nparocylueIIo fpaXAaHcKIrM .4en{ttr,r OcyqecTBn""a"" ttu O""o"" aOcoraac*ro "i.so rnrc po ."*--.,"pi,l ;:ffif";ffi: il%:ii###::?"KOTOpBTe oHa ccBuraeTc,rrpeaycMorpeHo O"o"n-"lT-ti"-tj}liTnt

cBoldx rpe6onannft ra ao:paxenafi, ecJIH Ir'oe HeB cy4 orrervz*oM He [peacraBneno xaxzx-nu'o Ao*a]areJrbcrB orcyrcrBlt BrrHBr BHapylrreuu cpoKa HcrrorrHerrur o6r:arelrcra no 4oroBopy or 16.06.2010 rotal.

---

,{ono4rt orBerqlr(a o roM, rrro o6.ssare6crsa 6rBriHe rcrrra, rorop'ft rBMeHr.rB cnofi nuqeuofi "r., oTX XTr:HHlill';ffil:#THH:

cBoeBpeMeHHo ne coo6qun euy o6 srou, cyA B AaHHoM cJrrrae cqaragr He r4MelorlrMr.r

;3#ffi";ffiff."' rocKorlEKy era o6crosreftcrBa Bo3'n*rur yxe rocrre rrcrerreHnr cpoKa

crarss 28 3arosa pocczficxofi lDe4epaqnr' <o garqure npaa norpe6zrenefi> Ns 2300-lor 07 Qeepanr 1992 roaa npeAycMarpr.rBaer, wro norpe6raren;;rp;;;;;;;;;"" rrorrrroro

ilifi"Tt"" tublr(oB' rrpuqrlHeH'bD( eMy B cBr3r c Hapy re'r{eM cponou n"rnoarrenr.' pa6orn,

flynrr 5 Ea.',oft crartw ycra*aBJrvBaer, n,ro B c,lrrae HapyHeHI.r, ycra'oBJre'H.rxcpoKoB Bbmojlnenr-rr paoorrr (oxasanux ycrryru) wtn Ha3HaqerrHbrx norpe6ureneu uaocrroBalrrl' [yHKTa I nactofiqefi crarbl'I H.BED( cpoKoB rEcnom{lTenb yooaq,nBaer norpe6ratenrosa rax."'fi 4enr (vac, ecJrr cpoK orrpeAeJre' n vacax) [pocpoirKr ,,eycrofiry (neHro) B panMepeTpex nporIeHTOB rreHbr BBmoJrHer {r pa60ru (oxaran H Wny'o), u ""or',rl;;-""r"oJr'e'r.r{pa6o'u (orarauae ycny'-r) 4oroBopoM o nrmomrenr.rr.r pa6

", ri"G"ii"orffi o"6"o"n""u _o6rqeft qenrr sara:a. .{oronopov o BBmoJrHeHrrr pa6oilor<a:annra ycayr) ue>44y uorpe6nrenelr14 ricnorr{rrreJreM UOXer 6rrrr ycralroBJreH 60nee nrrcorr'ft pa3Mep Heycrofircu (nenr),

*"J.J:#:ff3;"JT#** cpoKoB Haqarra Brrrrorrnenu, pu6or", io*** ii y",ryrr1, "".4o Haqarra Bbrro,,."* o"#,xTdil"""llT;ffi r,;::J,Tlffi;iul#xro;n";

:lf:::-::: :ry*cMorpeun6D( nyHKroM 1 'nacro.rrqei

crarra. Cyrrnaa B3ErcKan'otrIlorpeolnTeJleM reycrofixra (nenu) ne Moxer rrpeBrrrtrarb rle'y orAenb'oro Br4Aa BblnoJrrre'wl:::::: t1lTus

yctryru) utu o6rqyro qeny .**u,-.";" rre'a Bbmon'e'r.r.rr orAerrB'oro BrrAapaoor6r (oKanaHus ycrrywr)---H:-onpeAeneHa ,4oroBopoM o BrrrroJrqeH[r{ pa6orrr (oraranr.rzyrllI!_: !*"p

rreycrofirz 1nennl onpeaenx n"",'^"*o* H3 rIeHBr rgnoanen1rr pa6o6r(oxagaHar ycttyru), a ecJrl{ yKa3iururul qena He orrpe.4eJreHa, vcxo/u.lrc o6rqefi qenrr sara:a,cyrqecrnorarruei B ToM Mecre, B (oropoM rpe6onaxr-re norpe6urenr AoJrxHo 6luo 6rrrryaoBnerBopeHo [cnoJr'r'rreJreM e 4enr 406ponLJrLHOrO yAoBJrerBopeHr4.f, raxoro ,rpe60naHrzrHnrr B AeHo- BbrHece'r4r cy4e6noro p"ru""r", ecJrlr lpeooBaHrre norpe.rzre;r.r 406poronrnoyAoBJrerBopeHo ne 6rr.no.

B culy n' 6 srofi xe cra*a rpe60ran ux norpe6aretz, ycra'oBJreHHbre nyrrrolr IHacrotlqeii cra'r.o.,' He [oAJrexar yroBJlerBope'[ro, "aot

tarrontrrer' AoKtD(er, qroHapyrneHrre cpoKoB Bbmonnenr'rr pa60rrr (ixazauux ycrryru) npor{3.uuo BcJreAcrBr4enenpeo.{oalrlroft cr,rJrbr l,rrra ro nuHe uorpe6r.rrenr.B coorsercrs'a c n'HKToM 7 'ocraxonnenua fhenynaa Bepxon'oro Cyla pe or 29centt6pt 1994 r. N 7 <o npaxrwe paccMorpeHr.rs cyAaMU AeJro 3arqr4Te npaa uorpe6rnrenefi>oo o6rqerrry npanutry 6peu, AOKa3hrBaHrr o6croqre*crs, ocno'0xgarorqux ororBercrBeHHOCTr' 3a Helrcno,rHe.'ue ',u60 rre'aA,rexaqee Hcnon'eHl.re o6rearenrc,.ra, Jrexlrr Ha[poAaBrle (Nsroronurele, [crroJt'rirene, yflorHoMorre'H.fi oprannaaquu ruIu ylorHoMoqe'HoMHH'qIrBIr..yiurbHoM npe.rlrrDr,rrr4Marene, r,ruuoprepe) (n. 4 cr. 13, n. 5 cr. 14, n. 6 c.r.2g 3arconaPoccr'ftcrofi <DerepaqfiH'"o 3arq[Te npaB norpe6rrenefi,,). rlcrcmoqeHr.re cocraBjrsror cJrvqar4

Page 7: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

Y

:ffT -roBapa (BbmoJrH ewrr, ycn TLr) HeHaAnexaqero KaqecrB4 Korla pac[peAene'neopeMeHn aoKa3brBaH[r 3aBr'rcr'rr or roro'

, 66rJr rr.r ycrauoB:reu Ha -roBap (pa60ry, ycnyfy)tapaIJT frHbrtr cpoK, a raKxe o:r BpeMeHrr o6napyxenur rreAocrarKoB (n, 6 cr. lg, n. n. 5, 6 cr,19, u. n. 4, 5,6 q.29 3arona poccutcnor O"a'epaq'rr;;O ,u*"r" ,rp* uorpe6ureaeft,,).Paccvarprzrax tpe6oraaux rlcrrla o B3bIcKaHI,rE c o,rporre'roBrrer{BroKa3a'r'r'v"rry^u-:2yn"""0*"""JiTXf*??jJ"fffdt#fr :HHffpa6or no 4ororopy Net37l0 o, i6.06.20t0 *aq ;;;;;;o", ^rcJreAyroqero.B custy roro, .rro cpox 4eficrrr.lr goiouopa onpeAeneu ao 16.09.2010 roa4coorBercrBerr'o' ricreq B[paBe rpe60earr npror""ar".r-r"ycroftru, Haq Has, c tl.os.zllo ,oMlJfril,#ffi :HJ:fiffi oiSlou o'o'"u' aoroBopa Ne i : z t o, i"*ii-',I" p**"pu

Cymrla neycrofi*" no pu"*rry . yaa c 17,09,2010 ro,qa:ro AeH6 BbrHeceHrrr peIu euvr. cynacocrannr:84600/100*3*367=9!.1446 py6',efrt,.rA9p1gO9 irc. _ cro'MocrE pa6ot, 3%o_pazwepneycrofixn, 367 4xefi npocpoq(a 3a rrepr{oA c 17.}g.2lllroaa no 19.09.201 1 roaa.B csxga c reM, qro 3aron <o .rqrr" ,rp*lorp.orr.o"ro ;"-;;o;;;; rar,rx_nr'6ousrfrr'i.l'rs o6qrx paB.'. HA\ttrcne'wt n B3ETCKaHE neycrofiru, cyA B COOTBercrBI,rt co cr.333 fK P<D anpaae yMe'b,rrrr-rb pa3Mep Heycro itxu, rax KaK O'a 'BHO HecopasMep'a[ocJreAcTBltrM uapytueuNx o6rsaTeJrBCTB.Cy4 cw,rraer Bo3Mox(Hl

rroJrr3y ncrrla 12000 py6.. 6IM )MeHBIIrtrTb pa:uep neycrofiKli I'I B3brcrarb c orBerrlr.I*a B

Paccuarpnae rpe6orauax o B36rcKzlur.ru ctroJrb3oBame {rjfln/fr AeHex(HbrMIl cpeAcTBiMricJIeayK)qeMy.

oTBeTlIU(a B non63y ncTIIa flporlerrToB 3ari rrx t4H.qeKcaq i, cy[ npr4xo,u4T K

flocronrry !{creu saJrr'rrrsbD{ Ae'exHbx cpeAcrB B pa3Mepe r4lr2o0py6. orneru.rry ne[epeAaBan, ero Aerrex'6re cpeAcrBa ''o rocyAapcrBe'HoMy xrzJrr_ttrI'ouy ceprr'lprzxary npzupao6pvrem o6terros HeABrDKuMocrI,r s cobcrBenucHarrpaBrre'hr B crporoM coorBercrBrrr.r c 'pe6onanraxur':*"ffiffi:# #"1iffi"1#;rlJffnpzo6perem're HeaBr'rxn{ocrrr, to "ooru"rcru"n

ro, rpe60naxzr o6 raugercaqulr ga',,Ox CyruM6rssr*cflcx geo6ocHoBaHHEIMrl 14 yAoBlerBopeuriro E" no.{rr"xar.Tarcxe seo6oc'oBa'HblMrr rBJrrrrorct rpe6oraar-rr ucrqa o6 HHA.K.aI[4I,L B3ErcKar ,'ilpoqeEroB 3a rloJrb3oBaHrri+aoopye.,";;;;;T*T;Y'"XT""#H'. ji.Hilifli;,I1ffi J:#Tl?.#H'o6s3arer6crBa tro AoroBopy ar.',

"ii*"i, i;; "

3a rpe^erraMr cpoKa Ae[crB'r,:y::T:- 4oroeopa), cyrrMa B pa3Mepe g4600 py6. B cqer orrarbr pa6or npa.uorr.repno anroEura IIoJIyneH4 HerrpaBoMepHo yAepxc.rBarorc, a"*""o,l\g!"ft, *i."p"'L ?"'i" i"p"*"o"r", Ha cqer orBer!M-ff#:ffi##";.ffiH:,138?BroAa no-orqyxAeur.fio rcaprlrpBr, npr{Haane)Kaqeft zcrqy.-

uoorBercr'e'Ho' npoqenrbl 3a [oJ-rl3oBa'I{e 'y*nM AeHexH'IMIr cpeAcrBaMn Moryro6rrb a3brcxaHbr nurub H3 pacqera cynrMbr 30000 py6reii.Itcrerl npocr|Jr B3LIcKarb npoIIeHTbI 3a [onBoBaHHe

25.122010 roxa"o o. 7 ""it"a"Ht4r

cyAe6'oro p er*e'Lrr. qyxltMrr AeHexs{'MIl cpeAcrBaMu' c

*.u"?"i?rffl"t"uu c 'r'3 ct'196 rnK Po rto *;;;"aer perrre'xe rro 3{urBrreHHb* ,crrroM

B coorsercrsufi co cr. 395 fpo44ancxoro npoqeccyan'Horo roAexca p(D 3a rro]rb3oBaH'eiryxltM' AeHexEBII'a cpeacrBaMl BcireAcrBne Ex-HenpaBoMeplroro yAepxa'rxl, y*ro'eHr4s or::^_:::"1:"q

n'oft rpocpo$, B r{x ynnure nn6o Heoc'oBarerr'Horo roryqe'Es rrricoepexeHr'rr 3a crrer ,rlDvroro Jr[qa no.qnexar y[rare npor{e'T'r Ha cwMy 9rr4x cpeacrB,Paauep npoqeuto" o"p}'r*","" cyqeuryroulefi B MecTe xrrreir'crBa KpeAr'ropa, a ecruKpeAlrropoM 'iBlr;.grcfr roDrlruqecKoe rHIIo, B Mecre ero HaxoxAe'ri, yverrofi craB*oi6anroscroro flporle'Ta Ha Aerr' ucnomrcH.tg. .4eHexHoro o6.sgare*crBa vtur erocoorBercrByror{efr' qacrn. flpr nsrrcranr,r n Aonra a cyAednov .ropua*"--"ya """ou,a,

yAoBnerBopnTr rpe6oeanue (pe,qr4Topa, ucxolu us frerrror ctasrv 6aHxogcxoro flpolleHra Ha

Page 8: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

reHb npeAstBneEufl rrcKa fiJrn Ha EeHb BBIHeceHr,uI perrreHl,rr. 3rr.r npaouna npl4MeHrrorcr, ecJrr.rzHofi paauep nporleHToB rre ycrauoBJren 3aKoHoM r,rn[ AoroBopoM.corracuo rocra'oB,reH'ro_rhenyraa Bepxonroro cyru po Ne 13, rlnenpra BAC po I&14 or 08.10'1998 r. ecnr' rpe6onanze y.uo"n*"op""t"" a cyre6nou [oprA.e, ro craB*anpoIIeHTa aonlKHa 6rrrr onpe4enena Ha AeHb IIpeartBJreHLIt xcKa nlr6o Ha aeg6 Brrgece'rrrperrleHrtr.flpn pacvere npoIIeHToB 3a [oJr'3oBa'lre qyxrzMlr aeHex'brMlr cpeAcrBaMlr cyArrpuMe'rer c,arry peoilnancupoBaHr.rr I{enrpaarnoro Sanna po B pa3Mepe g,25 yo,'AeficrBoBaBuyro lra aeHb npeAlrBrenus rrcKa, Tax r{ Ha .qeub paccMorpeu v\ AeJr cy1oM.Pac.rer:

= 1842,50 py6..

Taxarvr o6pa:ou' c orBerllrlKa B rronb3y Ecrqa Cr.Igosa B.II. no4nexar B3ErcKaH[rolporle'T'r 3a rroJr630Ba'r're w)KnMfi ,qeHex'BrMn cpeAcrBaMri B pa3Mepe 1g42,50 py6. sanepuo4 c 25.12.2010 ro4a no 4eH6 B6rueceHr4l pemeHlrr cyAoM.Yu'rrrrax' ,.ro HeBErlJraqeHH&r acrrly caroay 8.I4. ae'ex',ul cyr\{Ma B pa:ruepe 30 000py6' vacrrvno yq)arrrra cBoro rroKyrarerrrcryro cnoco6Nocr6, o'a r";;";;;;; ca\fi HaIiITAeKCEI pOCra norpeor.rreJrEcKrfx rlen r pecny6aure Koulr, Koropbre o6rer<rr.rggo orprDKurrcTyponeur lrnlpnxluu rro Mecry rrp crlrcziBauns ficrr]a.Pacqer nnAercaqwu 3a.flepuol c frHBapr rro anrycr 20l rr. Bx;rrorrrlTerbHo cocr:lBr.rr:30000 * 1,013*1,017*1,013*1,01*1,005 *tpOS*t,OOZ*1,002+l_30000= tn6a,;;;y6.B coorsercrBur{ co cr. r 099 rK p(D lropanu*rfi BpeA, np'',n'e

"n",ia' xefic.rnaxvu(6es4eficrareu)' Hapym oqIzMIl IrMynlecrBeutrre npaBa rpa:{(Aaurrga, noa;rexaT KoMrre'caqu'

B CJrrralrx, [peAycMoTpeHHBD( 3aKOEOM.Crarr.r 15 3axona poccuficrofi @e4epaqrau "O garqure npan norpe6ureneft,,flpeAycMarp'Baer Bo3Mox'ocr' KoMne'caq[u MoparrBHoro Bpera, ,rpr"""e""oronorpe6uremo BcreacrBrie Hapywenur- t3foroBr,rreJreM (ncnorurrreJreM, npoAaBuoM,

Y'OIHOMO'EHHOfi OPTAHI.I3AIIHEII LIJIII Y''OIHOMOqEH,,'IM I,HAI,IBU..YAJI6HB,'npeA[pnHnMareJreM, zunopreporu) Ha ocHoBaHuE AoroBopa c Hrtyl, ero [paB,[perycMorpeHH6rx lpegepaEnrruz 3axoHitMrr n HopMarrrBHLMr [paBoB6rMr arcrrlMlPoccuricroft (De4 epa'diuvr B o6nacrr.r garqr.rrrr npaa norpe6nreneE, TolbKo ,Ipo, H anwfiD, BU,,bl.,.

c'tartx 151 fK po ycraHaBJrr{Baer, qro ecJrri rpaxAaHr.rHy npr.rrrr4rre' MoparbH'ni Bpe.q(Qr'rsrEvecrre Hmr Hp.BcrBe't*te crpaganu-e) gefi,',,un"m, Hapyrnarcql,rMr{ ero nr4rr'hreHeuMyrqecrBe'H're fipaBa ;nE6o nocrrarorqrzu E Ha npv*a*exaque rpaxAa' Hy rpyrveHeMarep'uurb'hre 6nara, a rarc(e B Apyrvx "ayra"i,

flpeAycMorpe'Hrx :axonou. flprnOIIPEAEIIE''LT' PA3MEPOB KOMIIEECAqI ' MOP:UI'HOTO BPEAA CYA IIPI,IHUMAET BO BHI]MAHNCcre[eHb Brrrlbl HapymHTe IIA A :i1,$Ijle 3acJryxriBalloq]re utrflraH"s o6crosrertctna. cyA AOnXeUTaKXe ylrlrr'rBarb crelerr. saauvecrzx ri HpaBcrBeEHbx crpaaanu:"., cBr3aHHED( CnH.qr.rBxAyaJrrrrErMn oco6eunocrrMtz nrqa, KoropoMy npuqurren BpeA.

Y'fl'rrbrBat' qro B cBr3lr c Her,rcrroJrHeHrreM orBerirl4KoM B npeaeJrax 4eftcraux cpoxa3aK:rloqeHnoro AoroBopa o6x3aremcrs rro aoroBopy, ncrqy 6rrm.r npir"r"""i ""ygo6cm4

onIlepexEBrur IIo [oBoay AJr[rreJrbHofo HerlcnorEeHrlq o6r:arellbcrn, urro"ro" -nou"r"rr""

orBerllr'IKa' [pItHIILIrbr cnpaBe.qrlaBocrr'r a pa3yr\{Hocrrr, cyA cqrrraer Bo3Mo)KHBTM B3EIcKa?B Bflonb3y acrrla MopalrHuft ape4 n cyrrnae 3000 py6..flpu perue'r4a Borrpoca o B36rcKarru[ ,orpa.ba 3a HeyroBJrerBopeHre B

Ao6poronrnolr [9prar(e rpe6onanaft, norpe6r.rrenr, cya pyKoBoAcrByerc, nonoxeHn,rM'nyurra 6 craruz l3 garosa po or 07.02.t991rora:ve z:dO_t iio ."rurr;;;;-r;;""6ie.,rer>,conracHo KoropbrM' nprr yAoBJrerBoperrr4r.r cy,40M rpe60nannfi norpe6ureirx, yrr*o"oarr"o3aKOrroM, Cyr B36ICKr4Baer c a3roroBnrent (ucnonnurenx, [poAaBrla, ynonnouovennofiopraflI'Barluu aJII'l ynon'oMorle'Horo u**'Br'ayar''Horo [peArlpt4 Hr.rMareJrr, r.rMnoprepal 3aneco6nroAenre 406pono.nrroro fioprA*a yAoBnerBope'r{rr rpe60nanrft uorpe6nrera ,orpaqp rpa:lMepe rrsrtr4ec''rrr nporIeHTOB OT C),'M6r, npucy44enuofi cyAoM B nOn*y norpe6urenx.

360*100%

Page 9: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

Bgucrar*re 'urpa$a sa neco6aro4enze 'qo6poso*Horo [oprrKa yAoBJrerBopeHr' rpe'oaaHzfinorpe6lrrenr rnnf,erc, Ee npaBolr, a o6rsauroclrro cy4a.Eclu c 3turBJreno6.setunewnndffi r,""":ffi il#fr #ffirff h'T':ffffi ,J:ffi"lT*x1:rrtrb^ecflr npoqesroB cyrlrMBr B3brcKa'Horo urpa@a

""p";;;;; yr(a3a'H6rMo6reAranenra_na (ux accotlna\uslr, coro:aru) vnlr oprarrzu.klz uarepuuron rpax.qa'c*oro ..erra cneAyer, wo 17.12.20r0roAa cusos B.Lr. o'paruncts PeEIoHanbHyIo o6rqeirnen'yro op.*rruq"ro <{enrp sarqr,rrr norpe6ureneft> c 3rurBJrerr,eM

;ffiffJfit"Tff"*b B pa3pellre'Iclr crop4 Bo3HI'rKInero '',-rlp?:oo'Homenr'fi, peryrrr{pyeM.xo0u..,"","*"pi;,;Ttlf :ilh,i":Tffffi :;"r:::l#::,,:,n_i::m;B cyA B 3arqury [paB u 3aKoHHED< rrHTepecoB CusoiaB.LI.

flpn r'*noxennrx o6crorre*;* ; ;;";Ka [o.qrrexr4r narrcranraro rurpa(p Bpa3Mepe 244s4,45 py6":i. Hs nnx 12227,22 pyaiin 6oN1 ;"*;;;;;;;;*iro "

o,oa*",MyHr4rrr{rair'rroro o6pa:onawr.a fopoacKoro o*py.u 'nop*y*,

;-\'r;;i";;;reft (s'vo);:ff:ffi;HKa'rlo

B nonray Peruouarrnofi o6qecreeHnofi opranu:aqrr *i;;rp 3arqrrrbrOreerw{rov 6rrtro sartnero xo4araficmo onor:pe6urenefi>p""";;;;;;;;#:#':::",:-B3Blc*aHrrr c Poo <I{eurp 3arql4rEr

trffi "i#i'#",fr ;'ffi r##*H#i*ffi ::ilfi r:"'"p'l*m'";;[peAycMorpeu'brr 3aKoHoM cJr)4larx c 3rulB,rer reM

) B rrcKe ''rnqy, o6parasmeMyct B cyA BEETepecoB Hcrrla, orBgrqr{Ky Bo3Merqarorc, au

"n", "

3alltrry [paB' cno6o'4 z 3aKoHHbD(ro'ecenHBre LrM r3AepxKH' cBr3a'H6re

" ou""*"x#t#";""Tff"ffi;:r:;"THuponoprtrtonarrno roft rracrt r4cKoB6D( tpeloaauuft.orr(a3auo. , B yaoBnerBopenr.rz rcoropofi acrqy

Couacno 103 lpaxgaucroro [poqeccyzurrnoro KoAeKca poccr,rficr<oft (DeAeparpn, coTBgrqrlKa troArexliT B36rCKaJrItb rocyAapgTBeHHarl IroI

lh#f HH:"#":J:1"-:*;;iliiiiriiE:_#Ff.Hn!:Jf:X:tSiiHaocuo"**u-;;:f#;ff ""ToKl.:""iX:Hfl:"..u".J.Xf ",ino_,nn'.1,,**o*olpoqeccy.urruoro xo4erca p<D, cy4

P e m n . l :

acKoBrre rpe6onaxrr perr.ronanrnofi o6rqecrsengofi opraHrrarlxra <(enrp :aqzrrrffiffffifi|]*r;Hy

rpaB r 3aKoHHErx I'HrepecoB br.o"u-n-rpl""{rr*orrouBsrrcrag c OOO <Korulannr <floTplocronnrrfi Aou> _ Bopxy,ro I no&gy Cr.rgosaBaneput Vlr,a*osu,ra 30000 pyo.nefi il;;-"-"py lG;; rc or-rc.oazj6t6 ,"* ,,.?J*n"y *HapymeHlie cpoKoB BEmoJIHeHIrt ycnyr

" p**"p" 12000 py'neft, Ilpor{eHr6r au .rirr".o"*""YY)KHMI.I IEHCXIIbIMI.I CPC.{C'

pvo.3s -*.,-*;;;;#;;",t"*Ir B pa3Mepe 1842 pv6' 5-0^19*'

lHaexcaq'Io e liipe zo6a

opranr{3aqrrr4 r<I_lenrp sauureL"p,"]"*;,""'#"TJ;fff#::"lii"{ffi #tr#T:;:[##:i1*tr*;:cpoKoB BEIrronHeHvs ycrtyt B palMepe 7gi084 'py6.,

uHAeKcaqa' AeHexHhD( cla{M c[pHMeHeH]reM r'rH'qe*coB po.ru norp.d"reJrEc*x ,iJ",'', y."*o"n"rHrrx s pK, 3a (axr6rrflorHblft Mectq npocporrKn c orr.r6pr 2010 ritrc io -ro"Op"

2010 roaa, (oMrreHcaqsr 3aloJrE3OBaHrIe qyxuMll AeIIe

,H,A:ffi*ff:f:ffi :HTl.nnT,ffi ,ff :%ffi J^i,:]3?i]!^,,1?.ru;:

Page 10: Сизов В.И. - решение 19.09.2011

Bgrrcxarr c ooo <Kolrnanlr-s <rlo.quocxonnrrft 4oru>-Bopryro rocyrapcrBe'Hyronorr[rr'I'y s 6roaxET MyHrrq]r[aJrLHOrO O6paroralrux ropoAcK.r. OXpyra <Boprcyra) B pa3Mepe1777,27 pylneft.Bgucxarr c OOO <KorunaHr,rs <tfloluraocrosnrrfi aou>_Bopryral lrryaQ r pa3Mepe12227py6rrcia.22 KorreeK B nonrsy peruonaarnoft o6rqe;rse'nofi oprann:aqura <I_tenrp 3arrrrrbrnorpe6rareneft>.Bglrcratr c ooo <Kouualrr'rr <flo.qaocroanufi 4onr> -Bopryro rur"paf a paeuep e 12227

ift$ffn;?r.KolleeK B nonrgy 6ioaxeru

"]t"q"n-inro.o oop*o"ur#.6poioorJ o"pnuB y4orrernopennu rpe6onanuft OOO <Kounanrx <Ilo.4.rocronnrrft gou> -Boprcy.ro oB36rcKaHr.M pacxoAoB Ha onnary ycrryr npeAcraBt,rreJur B pacrrere 20000 py6rcfi.o*;;;.

Peruenue lroxer 6rnr o6xanonano e BepxonnrrfiBopryruucxaft roporcroi cyA B Teqeqrre I0 anefi nocnepellreHlrr, Koropoe 6yaer usroroal e:rro 26 .09 .201 1 rona.

Cyarr

Cy4 Pecny6nnrr.r Kour.r veperr,r3foToBJreHr{r MoTLrBItpoBaHHOrO

A.B. Kpy<oncrax

'.\.

W