103
高雄醫學大學醫務管理暨醫療資訊學系 專題成果報告書 老人衰弱指標系統之建置 組員 劉香妤 楊婕安 蔡亞萍 指導老師:李易蓁 老師 中華民國 102 6

高雄醫學大學醫務管理暨醫療資訊學系專題成果報告書 - 老人衰弱指標系統之建置

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 102 6

  • 101

    375

    Fried

    (data mining techniques)

    :

    IADL()

  • SF36--

    IADLSF36--

    :

    67.5%

    0.605

    :

  • !

    !

    2013.6

  • ..1

    ...1

    ...3

    ...3

    ..4

    ..4

    ...8

    .11

    15

    ...15

    ...17

    ...18

    ...19

    23

    26

  • ...27

    ...35

    ...37

    ...39

    ...44

    ...52

    56

    59

    59

    60

    61

    ...............................................................................63

    ..64

    ...............................................69

    /...90

    /...92

  • 3-1 16

    3-2 18

    3-3.26

    4-5-5 -.51

    4-5-6 -.52

    2-1 ...6

    2-2..9

    3-4-1.22

    3-4-2.23

    4-1-1. ...28

    4-1-2 ....32

    4-1-3 () ....34

    4-2 .......36

    4-3 ...38

    4-4...41

  • 4-5-1.48

    4-5-2 Confidece Factor..50

    4-5-3 M1-1050

    4-5-4 C=0.4M=6.51

    4-6-1 53

    4-6-2 54

    4-6-3 55

    4-7-156

    4-7-2 ...58

    5-1 .61

    5-2 ...62

  • 1

    8265

    9165

    9.01% 44.17% 101 65

    11.15% 76.2 10 32.0

    65R.E.

    Pel-littel(2009)

    Palmer RM(1999)Mark A. Sager(1998)

    (frail)

    65 11%

    34%10 121%

  • 2

    (2005)

    Fried

    (2001)(unintentional weight loss)

    (low grip strength) (poor energy)

    (slowness)(low physical activity)

    (2010)

  • 3

    65( 65)

    ()

  • 4

    "

    Woodhouse KW(1988)

    MacAdamWilliams

    (1989)Rockwood(1994)

  • 5

    Sarlasian(1996)

    :

    Woodhouse(1998) 65

    Bortz

    (2002)

    Markle (2003)

    HoganFriedChinMitnitskiLipsitz

    (1994-2003)

    ()

    HoganFriedChinMitnitski

    Rockwood

    (2002)Song

    Mitnitski RockWood(20022004)

    (2006)(

  • 6

    )

    2-1

    2-1

    ()

    Woodhouse KW

    (1988)

    MacAdamWilliams

    (1989)

    Sarlasian

    (1996)

    John(1997)

    Woodhouse (1998) 65

    Bortz(2002)

  • 7

    Markle(2003)

    Hogan(2003)

    (1)

    (2)

  • 8

    Fried Frailty Index(2001)

    Fried LP(2001)frailty phenotype

    Jones(2004)

    (1)(2)(3)

    (4)(5)(6)(7)(8)(

    )(9)Rockwood(2005) 70

    Ranieri P(1991-

    2006):(1)(2)

    (3)(4)(5)(6)

    (2006)

  • 9

    Rolfson(2006)(1)(2)

    (3)(4)(5)(6)

    (7)(8)Ensrud(2008)

    Vermeulen1

    (2011)

    (1)

    Fried(2001)(2)

    2-2

    2-2

    ()

    Fried LP(2001) (frailty

    phenotype

    Jones(2004) (1)(2)(3)

  • 10

    (4)(5)(6)

    (7)(8)()

    (9)

    Rockwood(2005)

    70

    Rolfson(2006) (1)(2)

    (3)(4)

    (5)(6)

    (7) (8)

    RanieriP

    (2006)

    Ensrud(2008)

    (2010)

    (1)(2)(3)(4)

    (5)(6)(7)

    (8)(9)

    (10)

  • 11

    Vermeulenl

    (2011)

    Fried

    :

    Usama Fayyad

    Fayyad( Pattern Recognition)

    1991(Data Mining) 1996

    Fayyad

    1995Gruppe&Owrange

    1997

    Berry Linoff :

  • 12

    (interdisciplinary field)

    (Artificial Intelligence)

    (computer science)(machine learning)

    (data visualization)(Stastics)

    Berry Linoff (2008)

    1. (Classification)

    :

    2. (Estimation)

    :

  • 13

    3. (Prediction)

    :

    4. (Association Rule)

    :

    Apriori

    5.(Clustering)

    : K-means

    6.Description :

    (supervised) (unsupervised)

  • 14

    :

    Freeman Skapura (1992)

    (Neuron)

    (Leave node)

    (,2009) ID3C4.5C5.0CART

    CHAID C4.5

  • 15

    (2001)

    (2007)(2008)

    MDA

    (2011)

    3-1

    ()(ADL&IADL)

    http://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/cgi-bin/gs32/gsweb.cgi/ccd=Nt1CHr/search?q=auc=%22%E6%9D%8E%E9%9B%85%E9%9B%AF%22.&searchmode=basichttp://ndltd.ncl.edu.tw/cgi-bin/gs32/gsweb.cgi/ccd=Nt1CHr/search?q=auc=%22%E6%9D%8E%E9%9B%85%E9%9B%AF%22.&searchmode=basic

  • 16

    (SF-36)-

    -

    3-1

    Fried

    ()

    (&)

    (ADL&IADL)

    (&)

    (ADL&IADL)

    (GDS-15)

    (AD-8)

    SF36-

    SF36--

    SF36--

  • 17

    3-2

    1:

    2:

    3:

    4:

    5:

    6:

    7:

    8:

  • 18

    3-2

    : 65

    ()(

    )

    2012 10 18

    2013 4 15 375

  • 19

    101

    ()

    3-4-1 Fried

    13

    136

    1.

    2.

    (LSNS-A)

    3.

  • 20

    4.

    5.

    6. (IADL)

    7. (ADL)

    8.

    (MNA)

    9. (AD-8)

    10. (SF-36)

    11. (GDS-15)

    12. (OHIP)

    13.

    16

    MNA(Cronbachs -0.538) SF-36

  • 21

    -(Cronbachs -0.586)

    Cronbachs 0.7

    (2000) Cronbachs 0.5 0.7

    (Cardiovascular Health Study) Fried 2001

    ()

    (frailty) 3-4-2

    (1) (weight loss)(MNA)

    1

    (2) (grip strength)(TTM-YD, Japan)

    20%

    (3) (walk time)

    20%

  • 22

    (4) (exhaustion)(SF-36)

    3-4-1

    (GDS-15)

    0~20

    (AD-8) 0.26

    (MNA) 0~31

    (ADL

    )

    0~100

    () 0~10

    (SF-36) 0~100

    Charlson score 0

    1

    2

    -

    (SF-36)

    0~100

    (IADL)

    ()

    -

    (SF-36)

    0~100

  • 23

    3-4-2

    ()()

    1

    159.97(cm) 8.94(s)

  • 24

    3-5-1

    1:

    (ADLSF36-

    ) Discretize

    2:

    3:

    J48

    Confidence Factor 0.1~1.0

    ()

    Confidence Factor 0.4

  • 25

    (M)1-10

    ()

    (M) 6 10 10-fold cross-

    validation 10 91

    ()(

    )

    4:

    5: 16 375

    16

  • 26

    6:

    7:

    8:

    3-3

  • 27

    375 4-1-1 74.75

    SD 6.893 65-69 26.6%70-74

    24.5%75-79 80 24.5%

    50.9% 49.1% 88.5% 7.2%

    3.7% 35.2% 32.8%

    1.6%()

    64.3%() 35.5% 14.7%()

    21.1% 62.9%

    24.8% 12%

    87.5%

    52.5%

    21.3% 13.6%

    8.3% 46.7%

    41.1% 11.8%

    71.5% 28.5%

  • 28

    4-1-1.

    374

    65-69

    70-74

    75-79

    80

    74.75

    6.893

    100

    90

    92

    92

    26.6%

    24%

    24.5%

    24.5%

    375

    191

    184

    50.9%

    49.1%

    375

    332

    27

    14

    2

    88.5%

    7.2%

    3.7%

    0.5%

    375

    91

    24.3%

  • 29

    132

    15

    4

    4

    123

    6

    35.2%

    4%

    1.1%

    1.1%

    32.8%

    1.6%

    ()

    ()

    ()()

    ()()

    375

    74

    34

    133

    55

    39

    40

    19.7%

    9.1%

    35.5%

    14.7%

    10.4%

    10.7%

    373

    236

    93

    44

    62.9%

    24.8%

    11.7%

    373

    45

    328

    12%

    87.5%

  • 30

    359

    197

    80

    51

    31

    52.5%

    21.3%

    13.6%

    8.3%

    373

    175

    154

    44

    46.7%

    41.1%

    11.8%

    375

    268

    107

    71.5%

    28.5%

    4-1-2 18.7%

    81.3% 12.5%

    87.5% 35.5% 63.5%

    49.6% 50.4%

    6.4% 83.7%

  • 31

    10.4% 89.6%

    71.9% 28.1%

    4-1-3() 1.88SD 2.296

    (ADL ) 96.81 SD 10.964

    3.2% 96.8%IDSL

    85.3% 14.7%

    15.5% 82.1%>=3.0

    2.1% 12.3% 1.0-3.0 11.0%

    1.3 %(GDS-15 ) 95%

    3.6% 1.4% 7.44 SD

    4.636 30.64kg 17.92kg

    SF36 79.15 SD 23.66

    - 86.40 SD 32.00

    - 86.66 SD 17.23

    86.66 SD 17.241

    82.65 SD 21.15 71.50 SD

    20.28 75.14 SD 15.73

    63.01SD 18.75

  • 32

    4-1-2

    Charlson score 373

    0

    1

    2

    230

    117

    26

    61.7%

    31.4%

    7.0%

    375

    70

    305

    18.7%

    81.3%

    375

    47

    328

    12.5%

    87.5%

    371

    133

    238

    35.5%

    63.5%

    133

    66

    67

    49.6%

    50.4%

    338

    24

    6.4%

  • 33

    314 83.7%

    375

    39

    336

    10.4%

    89.6%

    32

    23

    9

    71.9%

    28.1%

    375

    12

    363

    3.2%

    96.8%

    >=3.0

    1.0-3.0

    374

    8

    46

    41

    274

    5

    2.1 %

    12.3%

    11.0%

    73.3%

    1.3 %

    (IADL)

    373

    318

    55

    85.3%

    14.7%

    (AD-8) 366

  • 34

    58

    308

    15.5%

    82.1%

    (GDS-15)

    362

    344

    13

    5

    95%

    3.6%

    1.4%

    4-1-3 ()

    () 348 1.88 2.303

    352 7.44 4.636

    187

    177

    30.64

    17.92

    8.313

    5.855

    (ADL) 365 96.81 10.964

    (SF-36)

    -

    -

    375

    375

    373

    373

    79.15

    86.40

    86.66

    86.66

    23.66

    32.00

    17.23

    17.241

  • 35

    372

    371

    370

    369

    375

    82.65

    71.50

    75.14

    63.01

    23.61

    20.28

    17.02

    15.73

    18.75

    3.250

    4-2

    IADL

    (SF-36) Cronbachs

    0.90 0.9150.9170.931(ADL)

    AD-8 GDS-

    15 Cronbachs 0.80 0.8940.856

    0.8860.8670.880

    Cronbachs 0.70 0.777

    0.7700.758(MNA) Cronbachs

    0.5380.586(2000)

    Cronbachs 0.5 0.7

  • 36

    (Cronbachs )

    IADL 0.915 7

    ADL 0.894 10

    MNA 0.538 18

    AD-8 0.856 8

    SF-36 0.917 10

    -

    0.931 4

    -

    0.886 3

    0.586 2

    0.867 2

    0.777 4

    0.770 5

    0.758 5

    GDS-15 0.880 15

    Cronbachs >0.7

    4-2

  • 37

    4-3 74.08 SD

    6.75 74.08 SD 6.75 73.5%

    32.2% 26.5% 67.8%

    85.9% 90.7% 10.0%

    4.9% 2.9% 4.4% 1.2%

    10.0%

    27.8% 8.8%

    9.3%() 38.8% 32.7%()

    16.5% 13.2%()()

    11.2% 9.8%()() 14.7%

    7.3%

    (P

  • 38

    4-3

    Mean(SD)

    Mean(SD)

    74.08(6.75) 75.31(6.98) 0.095

    ()

    ()

    P

    125(73.5)

    45(26.5)

    66(32.2)

    139(67.8)

    0.001

    ()

    ()

    146(85.9)

    17(10.0)

    5(2.9)

    2(1.2)

    17(10.0)

    15(8.8)

    66(38.8)

    28(16.5)

    186(90.7)

    10(4.9)

    9(4.4)

    0(0.0)

    57(27.8)

    19(9.3)

    67(32.7)

    27(13.2)

    0.432

    0.654

  • 39

    ()()

    ()

    ()

    19(11.2)

    25(14.7)

    20(9.8)

    15(7.3)

    Fried

    (P

  • 40

    2.16SD 2.43(SF)

    (SF)(SF)

    79.88SD 36.89

    1.17SD 2.24

    (IADL)

    (P

  • 41

    4-4

    Mean(SD)

    Mean(SD)

    159.97cm

    ()

    159.97cm

    -

    -

    Charlson score

    ADL

    5.35(2.10)

    6.63(3.20)

    33.88(7.18)

    20.67(7.83)

    1.50(2.21)

    89.14(16.04)

    93.68(21.08)

    89.14(16.04)

    23.91(3.16)

    0.414(0.65)

    98.02(7.38)

    10.54(60)

    10.42(6.30)

    24.55(6.76)

    17.17(4.96)

    2.16(2.43)

    84.63(17.94)

    79.88(36.89)

    84.63(17.94)

    23.37(3.31)

    0.554(0.83)

    95.78(13.19)

    0.001

    0.029

    0.011

    0.006

    0.001

    0.006

    0.096

    0.118

    0.118

  • 42

    0.54(1.69)

    0.28(0.91)

    1.17(2.24)

    1.06(2.43)

    0.001

    0.001

    ()

    ()

    P

    5(3.3)

    148(96.7)

    92(55.1)

    75(44.9)

    13(7.6)

    157(92.4)

    29(17.1)

    141(82.9)

    18(10.6)

    152(89.4)

    44(25.1)

    131(74.9)

    195(95.1)

    10(4.9)

    26(12.7)

    179(87.3)

    41(20.0)

    164(80.0)

    29(14.1)

    176(85.9)

    0.001

    0.001

    0.112

    0.467

    0.300

  • 43

    IADL

    5(3.3)

    148(96.7)

    49(29.2)

    119(70.8)

    0(0.0)

    170(100.0)

    15(8.9)

    154(91.1)

    19(10.2)

    167(89.8)

    84(41.2)

    120(58.8)

    12(5.9)

    193(94.1)

    40(19.6)

    164(80.4)

    0.013

    0.016

    0.001

    0.004

  • 44

    4-5-1

    5 5 320 5

    28 (ADL ) 55 55

    755 358(SF-36)

    56.256.2 3356.2 340

    (SF-36) 5050 5850

    317 (SF-36 ) 56.2 56.2

    3356.2 340

    3.3 6.73.3 275

    3.4-6.7 576.7 16

    (ADL) 40 7040 541-70

  • 45

    670 354(SF-36)

    41.7 70.841.7 541.8-70.8

    5470.8 314(SF-36)

    33.3 66.733.3 4533.4-66.7

    1366.7 317(SF-36)

    41.6 70.841.6 541.7-70.8 54

    70.8 100

    2.557.52.5 244

    2.6-5 775.1-7.5 137.5 14

    (ADL) 32.55577.532.5

    432.6-55 356-77.5 577.5

    353(SF-36) 34.456.3

    78.134.4 234.5-56.3 3156.4-

    78.1 8178.1 259(SF-36)

    25507525 4526-50 13

    51-75 1375 304(SF-36

    ) 34.456.378.134.4 234.5-

  • 46

    56.3 3156.4-78.1 8178.1 259

    24682 2443-4

    545-6 347-8 128

    4(ADL) 28466482

    28 429-46 247-64 2

    65-82 482 352(SF-36

    ) 3047.56582.530 2

    31-47.5 347.6-65 5465.1-82.5

    5582.5 259(SF-36)

    20406080 20 34 21-40 11

    41-60 1361-80 1380 304

    (SF-36) 3047.56582.530

    231-47.5 347.6-65 54

    65.1-82.5 5582.5 25 4-6-1

    C4.5 Confidence

    Factor 0.1~1.0 4-5-2

  • 47

    Confidence Factor 0.4 0.512

    (M)1-10 M 6

    0.566 1010-fold cross-

    validation 4-5-3

    - 50

    IADL

    17

    17

    4-5-4

    4-5-5

  • 48

    4-5-1

    -2 -3

    ()

    0-5 320

    ()

    0-3.3 275

    6-10 28 3.4-6.7 57

    6.8-1.0 16

    (ADL)

    0-55 7

    (ADL)

    0-40 5

    41-70 6

    56-100 358

    71-100 354

    (SF-36)

    0-56.2 33

    (SF-36)

    0-41.7 5

    56.3-100 340 41.8-70.8 54

    70.9-100 314

    (SF-36)

    0-50 58

    (SF-36)

    0-33.3 45

    51-100 317 33.4-66.7 13

    66.8-100 317

    (SF-36)

    0-56.2 33

    (SF-36)

    0-41.6 5

    56.3-100 340 41.7-70.8 54

    70.9-100 314

  • 49

    -4 -5

    ()

    0-2.5 244

    ()

    0-2 244

    2.6-5 77 3-4 54

    5.1-7.5 13 5-6 34

    7-8 12

    7.6-10 14 8-10 4

    (ADL)

    0-32.5 4

    (ADL)

    0-28 4

    32.6-55 3 29-46 2

    56-77.5 5 47-64 2

    65-82 4

    77.6 353 83-100 352

    (SF-36)

    0-34.4 2

    (SF-36)

    0-30 2

    34.5-56.3 31 31-47.5 3

    47.6-65 54

    56.4-78.1 81 65.1-82.5 55

    78.2-100 259 82.6-100 259

    (SF-36)

    0-25 45

    (SF-36)

    0-20 34

    26-50 13 21-40 11

    51-75 13 41-60 13

    75-100 304 61-80 13

    81-100 304

    (SF-36)

    0-34.4 2

    (SF-36)

    0-30 2

    34.5-56.3 31 31-47.5 3

    56.4-78.1 81 47.6-65 54

    78.2-100 259 65.1-82.5 55

    82.6-100 259

  • 50

    4-5-2 Confidece Factor

    C 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

    0.488 0.473 0.483 0.512 0.493

    C 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0

    0.473 0.473 0.473 0.473 0.473

    C 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

    0.429 0.459 0.488 0.502 0.488

    C 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0

    0.483 0.483 0.483 0.483 0.483

    C 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

    0.444 0.473 0.473 0.502 0.493

    C 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0

    0.463 0.463 0.463 0.463 0.463

    C 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5

    0.478 0.454 0.459 0.483 0.498

    C 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0

    0.493 0.493 0.493 0.493 0.493

    4-5-3 M1-10

    M 1 2 3 4 5

    0.488 0.561 0.537 0.537 0.566

    M 6 7 8 9 10

    0.566 0.556 0.556 0.537 0.537

  • 51

    4-5-4 C=0.4M=6

    4-5-5 -

    0.6 0.58 0.54 0.57 0.53 0.59 0.61 0.54 0.56 0.58 0.57

    0.58 0.62 0.58 0.62 0.69 0.65 0.61 0.7 0.69 0.59 0.63

    (%)

    58.9 59.5 56.0 58.9 60.3 61.9 60.8 61.1 61.3 57.9 59.7

  • 52

    4-5-6 -

    4-6-1

    0.674 0.676

    67.5

  • 53

    4-6-1

    (%)

    0.674 0.676 67.5

    0.646 0.619 63.4

    0.646 0.619 63.4

    4-6-2 4-6-3

    ()

    (P

  • 54

    4-6-2

    B

    S.E

    OR

    95%C.I

    Lower

    limit

    Upper

    limit

    0.166 0.506 1.180 0.438 3.182

    -0.369 0.402 0.691 0.314 1.521

    -0.232 0.433 0.793 0.339 1.853

    1.001 0.630 2.722 0.792 9.349

    0.245 0.278 1.278 0.741 2.204

    0.045 0.070 1.046 0.912 1.199

    -20.495 10294.674 0.000 0.000 .

    SF-36

    -0.004 0.009 0.996 0.978 1.015

    SF-36

    -

    -0.010 0.006 0.990 0.980 1.001

  • 55

    * P

  • 56

    SF-36

    -

    -.007 .005 .993 .983 1.002

    .150 .107 1.162 .943 1.433

    *

    .219 .109 1.245 1.005 1.543

    .351 .436 1.420 .604 3.338

    * P

  • 57

    (P

  • 58

    4-7-2

    3 -

    1

    2 1

    SF36-

    -

    2

    0

    2 0

    2

    CCI

    0

    1

    ADL

    0

    IADL 1 0

    SF36-

    1

    0

  • 59

    WEKA

    16

    375 16

    ( 4-7-1)

  • 60

    (4-3) J Woo

    Rockwood

    IADL()

    Fried

    5-1

  • 61

    5-1

    Mean(SD) 0.28(0.91) 2.87(3.15)

    Mean(SD) 1.06(2.43) 7.78(4.48)

    Mean(SD) 23.91(3.16) 26.37(1.88)

    Mean(SD) 23.37(3.31) 23.21(2.51)

    IADL

    Mean(SD) 13.69(1.44) 5.82(1.87)

    Mean(SD) 12.88(2.48) 4.31(2.00)

    ( 4-7-2)

    SF36--

    IADLSF36-

    -

    5-2

  • 62

    5-2

    St John PD, Tyas SL

    Kenneth Rockwood

    (2005),

    Terri Blackwell(2006)

    (2010)

    SF36-

    SF36--

    SF36--

    J. Woo(2005)

    IADL Fried(2001)IADL

    (2010)

  • 63

    (P

  • 64

    67.5% 0.605

    1. Berry &Linoff ,Data Mining Techniques, 2008

    2. Bortz WM: A conceptual framework of frailty: a review.2002

    3. Chin A Paw MJ, Dekker JM, Feskens EJ, Schouten EG, Kromhout

    D.How to select a frail elderly population? A comparison of three

    working definitions. J Clin Epidemiol 1999;52:1015-21.

    4. F. Sebastiani, "Machine learning in automated text categorization,"

    ACM computing

    5. Freeman, J. A. and D. M. Skapura, Neural Networks

    Algorithms,Applications, and Programming Techniques, Addison-

    Wesley,Reading, Michigan ,1992.

  • 65

    6. Fried LP, Tangen CM, Walston J, Newman AB, Hirsch C, Gottdiener

    J,Seeman T, Tracy R, Kop WJ, Burke G, McBurnie MA.

    Cardiovascular Health Study Collaborative Research Group. Frailty

    in older adults:evidence for a phenotype. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med

    Sci.56(3):M146-M156, 2001.

    7. Hogan DB, MacKnight C, Bergman H; Steering Committee,

    Canadian Initiative on Frailty and Aging. Models, definitions, and

    criteria of frailty[review]. Aging Clin Exp Res

    8. Joan Vermeulen,Jacques CL Neyens,Erik van Rossum,Marieke D

    Spreeuwenberg and Luc P de WittePredicting ADL disability in

    community-dwelling elderly people using physical frailty indicators:

    a systematic review2011

    9. Jones DM,Song X,?Rockwood K:Operationalizing a frailty index

    from a standardized comprehensive geriatric assessment..2004

    10. J. Woo,W. Goggins, A. Sham,S.C. Ho :Social Determinants of

    Frailty2005

    11. K Rockwood,R A Fox,?P Stolee,?D Robertson, and?B

    LBeattie:Frailty in elderly people: an evolving concept. 1994

    12. K. W. Woodhouse, Hilary Wynne, Shelagh Baillie, O. F. W. James,

    and M.D. Rawlins:Who are the Frail Elderly? 1988

    13. Kenneth Rockwood, Xiaowei Song, Chris MacKnight, Howard

    Bergman,David B. Hogan,Ian McDowell, Arnold Mitnitski,2005

  • 66

    14. Kenneth Rockwood,Xiaowei Song,Chris MacKnight,Howard

    Bergman,David B. Hogan,?Ian McDowell, and Arnold Mitnitski:A

    global clinical measure of fitness and frailty in elderly people.2005

    15. Kristine E. Ensrud, MD, MPH; Susan K. Ewing, MS; Brent C. Taylor,

    PhD; Howard A. Fink, MD, MPH; Peggy M. Cawthon, PhD; Katie L.

    Stone, PhD; Teresa A. Hillier, MD, MS; Jane A. Cauley, DrPH; Marc

    C. Hochberg, MD; Nicolas Rodondi, MD, MAS; J. Kathleen Tracy,

    PhD; Steven R. Cummings, MD; Study of Osteoporotic Fractures

    Research Group:Comparison of 2 Frailty Indexes for Prediction of

    Falls, Disability, Fractures, and Death in Older Women.2008

    16. Lipsitz LA. Physiological complexity, aging, and the path to

    frailty[review]. Sci Aging Knowledge Environ 2004;2004:pe16.

    17. Margiotta A, Bianchetti A, Ranieri P, Trabucchi M.:Clinical

    characteristics and risk factors of delirium in demented and not

    demented elderly medical inpatients.2006

    18. Mark A. Sager, MD,and Mark A. Rudberg MD. Functional decline

    associated with hospitalization for acute illnesses. Clin Geriatr Med

    1998;14:670-9.

    19. Markle-Reid M: Conceptualizations of frailty in relation to older

    adults. J Adv Nursing 2003;44: 5868

    20. Mitnitski AB, Song X, Rockwood K. The estimation of relative

    fitness and frailty in community-dwelling older adults using self-

    report data. J.Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2004;59:M627-32.

  • 67

    21. Palmer RM: Acute care. In: Hazzard WR, Blass JP, Ettinger WH Jr,

    eds,Principles of Geriatric Medicine and Gerontology. 4th ed. New

    York: McGraw-Hill,1999:482-92.

    22. R.E. Pel-littel1, M.J. Schuurmans2, M.H. Emmelot-vonk1,

    H.J.J.Verhaar1Frailty, Defining and Measuring of a Concept2009

    23. Rockwood K, Mitnitski A, MacKnight C. Some mathematical models

    of frailty and their clinical implications. Rev Clin Gerontol

    2002;12:109-17.

    24. Rolfson DB, Majumdar SR, Tsuyuki RT, Tahir A, Rockwood

    K.:Validity and reliability of the Edmonton Frail Scale.ep;35(5):526-

    9. Epub 2006 Jun 6.

    25. Sarlasian CA, Lachs MS. Failure to thrive in Older Adults. Ann Int

    Med 1996

    26. Woodhouse KW, Wynne H, Baillie S. Who are the frail elderly??Q J

    Med.?1998

    1.

    2008

    2.

    2007

  • 68

    3.

    5(1):36-

    49,2010

    4.

    2001

    5.

    2011

    6. ,,,: 2006

    7. ,,

    ,2005

    8. , 2009

  • 69

  • 70

    A.(NO)

    B.1. 2.

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.1. 2.

    5.

    1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

    6.

    1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.

    7.

    7.

    1. 2. 3.() 4.()

    5.()() 6.()()

    8.

    1., 2., 3.,

    4., 5.

  • 1

    9.a. b.

    10.()

    1.( 11.) 2. 3. 4. 5.

    6. 7.( )

    a.()

    11.

    1. 2. 3. 4.

    12.

    1. 2.

    13.()

    14.()

    1. 2.

    (Lubben Social Network Scale-

    Abbreviated,LSNS-A)

    15. 1

    16.

    17.

    18. 1

    19.

    20.

  • 72

    0=01=12=23=3~44=5~85:9

    ( )

    21.()

    1. 2.

    22.

    a.

    23.()

    24.

    1. 2.

    25.()

    1.( a. b.) 2.( c.)

    a. b.

    c.()

    1.( d. e.) 2.( 26)

    d. e.

    26.()

    1.( a. b.) 2.( c.)

    a. b.

    c.()

    1.( d. e.) 2.( 27)

    d. e.

  • 73

    27.()

    1.( a. b.) 2.( c.)

    a. b.( 240cc)

    c.()

    1.( d. e.) 2.( 28)

    d. e.( 240cc)

    28.

    1.( a. b. c.) 2.( 29)

    a.

    b.

    c.

    29.

    1. 2.() 3.()

    30.()

    1. 2. 3.() 4. 5.

    6. 7.()

    8. 9. 10.

    11. 12. 13.

    14. 15. 16. 3 17.

    17.

    18.

    31.().

  • 74

    1.( a. b. c.) 2.( 32)

    a.

    b.

    c.

    32.

    1. 2.() 3.()

    33..

    1.( a.b.) 2.( 34)

    a.

    b.()

    1.() 2. 3. 4.

    34.(0-10)

    35.?

    1.( a.) 2.( 36)

    a.( )

    36.?

    1. 2.

    37.?

    1. 2.

    38.

    1. 2.() 3.()

  • 75

    4. 5.() 6.()

    7. 8. 9.

    39.? ( 52.)

    0. 1.

    40.

    0.( 41) 1.( a.)

    a.

    0.( 41) 1.( b.)

    b.

    41.

    1. 2. 3.

    4.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    5.

    6

    7. 8.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    9. 10.

    11.

    12.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    13. 14. 15. 16.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    a.1.2.

    17.(

    )

    18.

  • 76

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    19. 20.

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    21. 22.(COPD)

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    23.

    24.(

    )

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    25.()( ) 26.

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    27. 28.

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    29. 30.(AIDS)

    a.1.2. a.1.2.

    31.(DM)

    ()

    42. ( 97.)

  • 77

    (ADL)

    43.

    ()

    10

    5

    0

    44.

    (

    )

    15

    ()

    10

    5

    0

    45.

    (

    )

    5

    0

    46.

    (

    )

    10

    5

    0

    47. 5

    0

    48.

    ()

    50 15

    50 10

    (

    ) 50 5

    0

    49.

    () 10

    5

    0

  • 78

    50.

    10

    5

    0

    51.

    10

    () 5

    0

    52.

    10

    () 5

    0

    (100)

    (IADL)

    53.

    2.

    1.

    0.

    54.

    2.

    1.

    0.

    55.

    2.

    1.

    0.

  • 79

    56.

    2.

    1.

    0.()

    57.

    2.

    1.

    0.

    58.

    2./

    1.

    0.

    59.

    2.

    1.

    0.

    60.( )61.( )

    62.( )63.( )

    Mini Nutritional Assessment (MNA)

    64.

    0

    1

    2

    65. 9.0() 0

    3.1-8.9 0

  • 80

    1

    1.0-3.0 2

    3

    66.

    0

    1

    2

    67.

    0

    1

    68.

    0

    1

    2

    69. BMI( )

    BMI19 0

    19BMI21 1

    21BMI23 2

    BMI23 3

    12()11()

    70.(

    )

    0

    1

    71. 0

    1

    72. 0

    1

    73.

    1 0

    2 1

    3 2

  • 81

    74.

    ()

    (

    )

    0 1 0

    2 0.5

    3 1

    75.

    1

    0

    76.

    ( 250 c.c.)

    3 0

    3~5 0.5

    5 1

    77.

    0

    1

    2

    78.

    0

    1

    2

    79.,

    ?

    0

    0.5

    1

    2

    80.MAC_________()

    MAC21 0

    21MAC22 0.5

    MAC22 1

    81. C.C._________() C.C.31 0

    C.C.31 1

    (30)

    (MNA 24) (17MNA23.5) (MNA17)

    AD-8

  • 82

    ()

    (1 )

    (0 )

    ()

    82. :

    83.

    84.

    ()

    (1 )

    (0 )

    ()

    85.

    :

    ()

    86.

    87. :

    88.

    89.

    (2)

    SF-36

    Copyright 1995 New England Medical Center Hospitals,Inc. All rights

    reserved.(IQOLA SF-36 Taiwan Standard Version 1.0)

    90.()

  • 83

    1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

    91.()

    1. 2. 3.

    4. 5.

    92.

    ()

    1

    2

    3

    a .

  • 84

    1

    2

    3

    b.

    c.

    d.

    e.

    f.

    g.(30)

    h.(15)

    i.(5)

    j.

    93.

    ()

    1 2

    a.

    b.

    c.

    d.()

    94.()

    ()

    1 2

    a.

    b.

    c.

  • 85

    95.

    ()

    1. 2. 3. 4.

    5.

    96.()( 42.)

    1. 2. 3. 4.

    5. 6.

    97.()

    ()

    1. 2. 3. 4.

    5.

    98.

    ......

    ()

    1.

    2.

    3. 4. 5. 6.

    a.

    b.

    c.

    d.

    e.

    f.

    g.

    h.

    i.

    99.

  • 86

    ()

    1. 2. 3. 4.

    5.

    100.()

    1.

    2.

    3. 4.

    5.

    a.

    b.

    c.

    d.

    (Geriatric Depression Scale, GDS-15) ()

    1 0

    101.( 34.)

    102.

    103.,

    104.

    105.

    (5)(2,)

    106.

    107.

    108.( 98aegi.)

    109.

    110.( 98h.)

    111.

    112.

    113.( 98e.)

  • 87

    114.

    115.

    (15)(105-9)

    (OHIP)

    0. 1. 2. 3. 4.

    116.

    117.()

    118.

    119.

    120.

    121.

    122.

    123.

    124.

  • 88

    0. 1. 2. 3. 4.

    125.(

    )

    126.

    127.

    128.

    129.

    130.

    131.

    132.

    133.

    134.Timed up and go test, 46cm, 3m

    a.1. 0.( 135)

    b.

    c.1. 0.

    d.1. 0.

    e.1. 0.

    135.

    a. kgb.1. 0.

  • 89

    c. kgd.1. 0.

    136. a.

    ~~

  • 90

  • 91

    /

  • 92

  • 93

    /

    20-30

    07-3121101#2781#18

  • 94

    07-3121101

    6646 07-3133525

  • 1