Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
�������� ��� �� �������
�� �������� ��� �� � ����1398
Quarterly Journal of Economics and Modelling Shahid Beheshti University
:���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� � ����� � ������ �� �����
���� ���� !"� �� #$
�%��� �&'�∗(��) �*��+ �%�,� -∗∗ �. /���� �01�2 -∗∗∗
������ ���� ����� ���
27/09/1397 12/11/1397
34&(�
������� ������ ��� �� ��� �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �+0 � .� .1!� ��
�2�+2 3�4�� �51 ./��� ��� 67%4� ����)��� 89 .� ��) : ���$%&� ;2��� �� .*<�/� ��� �� .'2�
>�9�2!9 ) �%?9 �� '�@�� >�9�2!9 �+� ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� �+0 � ) AB9 �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(�
�� �� & �2� � ��!� C�)� !DEF��� �)� G�2� � A )H� ���2!I<� .� +J F�)� �- ��!� ��!7��� ��
�9���2016-2005 N+0*� �� �)�%"J C+�O� �� F��?%2� �� � +P%� �+� Q��)� ) �2� .% J >�!R
� ��� I9�+� SR�T U��%9 .�2� F'�� J ��)@ � �0%V+2 .%�� �� '�@�� �!) �� �(�9 >�9�2!9 .# �2
.�2� F'�� J �2� � ��!� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 ;1!� �%?9
F)WE�� X�"9 .# ���� �!1) �' �!( ��� � �!) �� �(�9 >�9�2!9 Y� A �# ZE�� �<�� .*2!� ' �
��!� F�)� �- ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � �%?9 �� '�@�� .�2� F'�� J �2� �
*�&�(5����: '(� X�2!9 ��0%V+2 .%�� N+0*� �� �)�%"J �!I<� ��%?9 �� '�@�� X�2!9 ��<�� .*2!�
.���$%&�
�".1�6$ JEL: C23 �G20 �O13.
∗ X��'9��� F�I"9�� ����� ) ���$%&� \!7E F'O"9�� ��$%&� F) J �����%2� [email protected]
∗∗ X��'9��� F�I"9�� ����� ) ���$%&� \!7E F'O"9�� ��$%&� F) J �����%2�[email protected]
∗∗∗ �2��(��#'(�� X��'9��� F�I"9�� ����� ) ���$%&� \!7E F'O"9�� ��$%&�[email protected]
98 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
1 .���"�
X & X� I" )H� ) X�9����$%&�F'�'� ^)_� �2� � �!"# X@ �- .# '9� F'( �� ��
����� ������09 ;7�� �(.9�+��)�a �?9 .� .%V��) �� �!"# .701 ��) X�)� �*+,- '�9�!�
��c� �2� �O0� �%T ) '��# F��?%2� ���$%&� .*2!� ) F�� �51 �� ����� ��� ��
\�!� '�%V �+*&�) ��� �++,� �!1) �V1 �� �59@ .'9!"� d+9 ���$%&� �!#� ) e�� ��
N�� .� � �!"# �� �a � � c .# ��� S�',� .� ���& ��*+,- ����� �� %"+� �� �����!a �
� B ) ���$%&� '(� �� ��+*� ;VT � ) F�!,9 �!a X�'9) 5( �� � F�� .� �9�)�
���$%&� >�+��� �� .'9��� �*+,- ����� '&� �� �!"# .� �,V9 � � ^!7/��9 � O70E
�*+,- ����� �9�)� f#)����� X�!�E �� F'�'� ���19) F'( .%a��( (�*+,- ����� �� ?
�2� � 9��) ) f#�2)1999(2
�<)� ��2� F��� X�"9 .� _��� �!2 �*+,- ����� �� SR�T �� '�@�� �� .# ��� 9 � �'
�� ��) : +� g��$� g R �� � '�@�� ��� F'0E . � �� �h�i� �� � .'��#1970 )
1980 A+� ���0+& A��d� ��+�.��� 2 .� �*+,- ����� ;T�R �� �!"# �� �J�� ��
9 ��+V� �<) �F� %VJ ��!0EX@ � O70E ��� X�"9 X��� �(J ) '9�!09 \�'&� @��#� �
A+� �;7/� ��� .� .1!� �� .�2� F�!� �2���9�� ��+� ����� ;T�R �� ��$%&� �!(
.��� 2 �� ��$%&� ��2 .� �,V9 �*+,- �� ���� ���� .'�(�� .%(�� � %"+� ;2����9 ��
9 '+<!� '(� +V� ��*+,- ����� �!) �� ��$%&� C�"� ��$%&� .� �,V9 �7a�� j<�a� �5��
�2�+2 .#�� h�0E� �� .�+5� �� �+��� �'�# � 9��) ) f#�2) �!� ' �!a �1999 � .(
��� �� �*+,- ����� �!1) �X�)� �*+,- ����� ����� �� �!"# �� �!1!� ^��_� G�2�
�� �� � �!"#�)� � �� �� J 89�� .,<)� +"0( C� X�!�E .� X�!��*+,- ����� �9 ��
�� �7� �� '�@�� A��d� k� - �� g - C� >'( �� ���$%&� .*2!� ) '(� l� @ '9�!�
1. Paradox of Plenty 2. Sachs and Warner
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 99
_____________________________________________________________________________________
.��� 2 A �# �� I�� g - �� ) '"4� A��d� �\�!� ) �I��'B9 A��d� ��O�d+ ���J
���&� A �# ._+%9 �� ) �7� h!� ���� A �# ��9�� ) ��V ��!��9 ) �7a�� ��$%&� � ��
A4� ����)�"# ) �*�R +89 ��$%&� �'+<!� �� �� S%4� �� ��$%&� >'�'�7� '(� '9�!�
� 9��) ) f#�2) '�#2001�J!m� ) X!2�?7+J �1 �2006n!7� ) �#��@ �2 �2011 �#) � �3 �
2010X���O0 ) o)�� �4 �2013 q! ) �I+� �� � )5 �2016.(
�?�� � �� +Y�� � ��,� o! ���!� .� .1!� �� *+,- ����� �9�)� �� ���$%&� '(� �
�?�� �� '��+� ��� A �# �51 ;2��� ���O �� �%�� ������ ��� F'9��� �� �!"# ��
�� 89 .� ��) :f� ���' F!r9 ) ��'9� f� �+0 � ) AB9 .� ����E �� .'2�(�9 ��'9� �
��� '�@��# ) s+rR j+$4� ��*+,- ����� �) �� SR�T �� '�@�� ��dm�T ��+V� F!1)
./2�) .�2� �+0 ��� '�@��# �<�� N%V+2 �7# �!- .� ) @��# �<�� �� +$4� �� '9�!� j
.��� 2 �02 .� �*+,- ����� �) �� SR�T �� '�@�� .�+5� ) s+rR���J '<!� ��
��2 ) ���$%&� '(� � � '�@�� ��� �� SR�T �?�� �� '��+� ���$%&� �*&�) A4� )
� +P%�!_9��9 ) l9!�) ' � A �# �� ���$%&� XW# �6 �2009 X!V9�1 ) !7�� N2�& )7 �
2005 �� .# X@ �0: �!"# C� �<�� A4� .*2!� .( �� �� ����� .�+5� j+$4� '9�!�
.��� 2 k��d� .�+�� �'(�� .%(�� F� 0 .� ��$%&� �� � �7r� ) F� # N � �� ��$%&� .� �
�# ( ���J�)) �%<)� �� .�2� �!"# �� �'+<!� �� 'T�) ��+9 ��!� �<�� ����� �+�t�
�� �<�� ����� �� ���0T ) .*2!� N � �� �59@ '(� .�+�� �����R �� ���0T �0: '9�!�
AB9 �+0 � I�� >��,E .� .' � �� & +Y�� �r� �� �!"# ���$%&� '(� ._+%9 �� ) F�!09
+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� �9��� ��!"# ���$%&� '(� ) (�?9 .701 ��) �*
1. Gylfason and Zoega
2. Arezki and Van der Ploeg
3. Brückner
4. Farooq et al.
5. Moradbeigi and Siong HookLaw 6. Monge and Naranjo 7. Acemoglu and Johnson
100 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Fu) � .� �� �!"# �� '�@�� '9�!%� �!"# C� �� �<�� A4� .*2!� .# �!( �� j4"� ��
.*2!�.��� 2 ) ���+<�* � %VJ .� _�� ) F��� j+$4� ��'�09�!� ��'+<!� �� ���2
F�I���a�2 �� ��_�� ) �!"# �� <�* .*2!� �51 ;2��� �� �+ .�� J ���$%&� ��
.*2!� .1�� .� .%V� ��!"# C� ���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �� ��� ����
.%(�� ���$%&� '(� � �?7%4� >� Y� '9�!� �� X@ >�9�2!9 ) �*+,- ����� �9�)� ��<��
�n! ) �I+��� �) '(�� >)�?%� �X@ 67%4� v!/2 �� )2016 .(
# ��� .� .1!� �� ����� 6"# ) F�!� �?9 X�)� ����� ����� C�)� !DE �� �!"# .
����� ���� �� ++P� .� _�� '9�!� �� ��?9 �0+& �� �9�5J�9 ++P� �� ) �%?9 '�'1
^!c��c �� :�T A )H� �' � A��d� �� �59@ >) Y ��!1!� ) �!( � �!"# ��� �*+,-
X���O0 ) C� �!I<�1 �� �)� � +J��# .� �� )F� X� �+04� ) ��!� ��!7��� ��
�0%V+2 .%�� N+0*� �� �)�%"J2 (SGMM) �� �<�� .*2!� �+0 � ) AB9 �2� � .�
�- � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 ) �%?9 �� '�@�� �9�)� X�2!9 �+� ./���
�9��� F�)�2016-2005 .*2!� ��@ .# �2� h�!2 ��� .� ��!I42�� h�,9� .� ) .%a�� �
w'�# S�'*� �� � �!"# ��� �� �?9 �0+& >�9�2!9 �� �(�9 �� q!( '9�!� �� �<��
.�2� F'( � '9����2 �� >�!R .� .*<�/� ��� �F'( v /� h�!2 .� �2�� ��%2�� ��
.%a�� � �7,& F'( \�_9� >�*<�/� ) � 89 �9�,� �) � .� \)� A4� �� �.�'B� �� f�
� � *� .� A )H� .���� .�!( �� !I<� ��)@ � �� f� .���� x�$%a� A )H� �)� ) !I<
�01 d+9 U��%9 S+7r� ) .'( ' �!a .m��� A )H� >���5�"+� ) �'��
2 .!��B� #C� ���.�
Y�� F!r9+��J � <�� .*2!�� � ./��� �+� �!) �%?9 �� '�@�� ) �� ?9� ) (�?9 '(
��$%&�� ) ���!09 ��1 .�2� F'( F��� X�"9 (
1. Beck et al 2. System General Method of Moment
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 101
_____________________________________________________________________________________
���0� )1.( F� &# ��� ���� � ������ �� G������ #$ ����� ����� � �2�
:�,�� �)@� J� !9�X�J'�V
�!/9�0 � �� .#�� � F' �"� ���!09�<�� .*2!� ��!(� � N �%?9 �� '�@�� �!)
'(� � N )��$%&�� Y��+ � g - �� .�2� ��J� I <�� .*2!�� � ./��� �+� (� '
��$%&�� �!) )�%?9 �� '�@�� 9+d ��Y�� '9�!�+ 9�)� .'(�� ��J� %?9 �� '�@�� � �
��$%&� '(�� 9+d ���!�'9 Y��+ .'(�� ��J.*2!� <��� ��'9�!� ./��� �+� 9�)��
�%?9 �� '�@�� ) '(� ��$%&�� �� '*��S ) �,i� '�# .�� .1!� .� >�*<�/� \�_9� (F'
7,&�� .*2!� <��� ZE�� ���!( .# ����� � '�@�� ) f���'9� �!1!� �� ��$%&� (�9� ��
y� 4%2� ) >����R ����� ,-+*� .� �02 2+N%V <��� �# T F� # ) �� -�k 2+N%V
<���� $4�+j f� � ��'9� ) ����� '�@�� �+� z &J+X�J'9 ) z &X�J'� � >�!R
J+� ) �� �# T f�� ��'9� ) 'B9�I�� (�9� �� ����� ,-+*� .� �02 A4� �+ *&�)�
��$%&� ) �!�� .%?2 ���� J!71+ � ' �!a '( .�� %9+._ .*2!� <��� ���& ' �!a �!�
>�9�2!9 �+� 9�)� � ����� ,-+*(�%?9 �� '�@�� .*<�/� ��� ��)� ) '(� ��$%&�� ��
h %�# ) ,i�+� '�# �2� )) X���O0 1� 2011 � �C�2011 � )+>�!O�%2� 2012 .(�O�
�� � � #��#� N5� 2+N%V <���� $4�+j 5�+.� ����� �!1!� � G�2� *�+� ��� �#@���
) F 5� �)� �2� X�1��)�)�f7I�3� 2003� �!"# .(� ,- ����� F'9���+*� I%V��)�
1. Hassan et al.
2. Bittencourt 3. Rajan and Zingales
���$%&�'(�
<�� .*2!��
�� '�@�� �!)
�%?9) �� ?9 �?9(
102 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
V�+�� ����� ,- ����� y� 4%2� .�+*� � ���� .'9��� �59@ >����R ) X�)� �� $%&�� ����
z *� �� � �!"#>�9�2!9 (�9� & ��+�0 ,- �����+*� ) %9 ��+._ A �# h!� ����
7�� <!� ���� A �# )+>�' ��� .���� �� & � �!"#.*2!� <��� �� ��# ) ��2� � ?7%4��
89+ �d��A #+?+� �� 2�. ��J�� $4�+j ;2��� f� ��'9��� A �# �9�� ) ��V )
�d��A F 5��)� �� '9�!� �� �+� '��� ?��� '��F' ?9�� ����� �� ��$%&� ' �O� ) ��
%9+._ � ./��� �+� ��$%&� '(� ) ����� �!)� Y��+��J '(�� �X���O0 ) d���)2016 .(
�!1) 2+N%V <��� .*2!��.%� �� � �!"#� F'9��� ����� ,-+*�� �� -�k o!2 �X��
� '�@��� SR�T �� ����� ,-+*� .� A4� BT+B� ��$%&� ) $4�+j 5�+.� ������ ��9�
�� Y��+>� ?��� ��� >�9�2!9 � P%�+� � XW# ��$%&�� ���� J. ��$E� ) ��O0 X�
)1387 �(�� .*<�/� �� .� 2� �� AB9 .*2!� <��� � '(� ��$%&�� �� ��# ) ��2 2�� �.
��J� �� � �!"#� �� h�T .*2!� %?9� ) �+%?9 � '�%a�� � . � G�2� �%9�U '��2
F'�@ AB9 ) 0 �+� .*2!� <��� � '(� ��$%&�� �� � �!"#� �� h�T .*2!� �+ ?9%�
V�+�� �+ %" �� � �!"#� %?9� �2� ) <�+S X@ AB9 ) 0 �+� .*2!� <��� ) Y��+��J �
X@ � '(� ��$%&�� �� S9�# �� 2�. ��J� �+X� ���� J .� ������ ��X�!� �?J �.*2!
<��� �� -�k �d��A #+?+� �� 2�.��J� ��'9�!� � ./��� �+� '(� ��$%&�� ) �!)
����� Y��+��J '(�� .C� )2011.*<�/� �� �(�� ��153 �!"# - 67%4�� 9��� F�)��
1980 ��2007 � .��� %9+._ 2�+' .# I%V��)� �+ %" � �!"# .� ����� ,-+*� ;1!�
;BE J��%�� ) \'E .*2!� 2+N%V <��� ��� � �!"# ���� J.
3. � �H �I �6&�&� !��B� �*I��
{!:!� .� Q,� � �7a�� ) �1��a F'( \�_9� >�*<�/� �2� � .� A )H� �� �0V& ��� ��
�� .%a�� � A )H� �7R� � A )H� � 89 �9�,� ) A )H� {!:!� .� .1!� �� .�!(
>�*<�/�) h)'1 �� A4� ��5c �� F'( \�_9�1F'( .m��� ) .RWa ('9�.
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 103
_____________________________________________________________________________________
7��H)1 .(�$ J. #� (�� K�'�� G����L� !��B� M�+��
���$%&� '(� ) �<�� .*2!� �� Q,� � F'( \�_9� >�*<�/�
kBr� \�9
) �9��� F�)�
��!� .9!09
�2� �
A )H� �)� � +J ._+%9
) !2)�)�
)X���O0 2016(1
2011-1989
40;4%�� �!"#
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
.%��2)GMM(
) ���,%E� �� ����� � '� ja�( )�
� �,i� +Y�� \�52 ����� �I��'B9
;4%�� �� �!"# �� ��'��� '(� s/2
�� ���,%E� �� ����� AB9 ) '9���
.�2� %"+� ��'��� '(� .� X'+2�
) ��+_9!�
X���O0 3)2016(
2014-1995
k-���
�� �!"#��d# �
) �& ( ��)��
�& ( ^!�1
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
'(� �1��a ��5O9�� �O9�� >���,%E�
�� A��d� �� ���$%&� ��� � F)WE ' �
�,i� N+B%V� +� Y� �7a�� �� �����
.���� ���$%&� '(� �
) �+2!��)!<)�
X���O0 4)2015(
2010-1960
.� _+9 �!"#
�!a !I<� �"J���
�� .9�%2@5)TAR(
'(� � �?�� +Y�� �<�� .*2!�
.%(�� �2� � ��!� F�)� �- ���$%&�
'T �% J 89 �� �� +Y�� ��� ��� �2�
.9�%2@ �� >)�?%� ��.�!(
) X�+O�
)��d��1394(
2011-1989
;4%�� �� �!"#
��W2�
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
F'( vWR� W��#6
)FMOLS(
+P%� )� .*2!� ) �<�� ��%a�2
ja�( X�!�E .� �<�� \�89 .*2!� ��
'(� � �����*� ) �,i� Y� �<��
�2� � ��!� �� �!"# �� ���$%&�
.%(�� ��%,� �<�� \�89 �+�|0 .'9�
���$%&� '(� � � � �!& Y� ����� �
.����
) �9�/72
)� +��1388(
2004-1960
h�T�� �� �!"#
;4%�� .*2!�
�!I<�F��� ��
X� �+04� ) ��!7���
���Y >� Y�
� ������*� ) �,i� +Y�� �<�� .*2!�
h�T�� �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(�
�2� � ��!� F�)� �- ;4%�� .*2!�
.�2� .%(��
1. Durusu-Ciftci and et.al
2. Generalized Method of Moments
3. Bongini and et al
4. Oluwatosin and et.al
5. Threshold Auto Regression (TAR) 6. Fully Modified Ordinary Least Square
104 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
) ���$E
)X���O0 1387(
2004-1990
�%?9 �� �!"#
) C�)� !DE
h�T�� �%?9 +�
.*2!�
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
.� \'E ) �%?9 �� '�@�� �!1) S+<�
;2��� d+5_� �� �<�� �� ��59 ��@��#
�� �!"# �� �<�� .*2!� ��<�� �����
'(� � �?�� +Yt� C�)� !DE �%?9
.%(�� �2� � ��!� F�)� �� ���$%&�
� �<�� .*2!� +Y�� .# �<�T �� �2�
h�T �� �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(�
���*� ) �,i� �%?9 +� .*2!�2� ��.�
�*+,- ����� �!) ) �<�� .*2!� �� Q,� � F'( \�_9� >�*<�/�
) d���
)X���O0 2016(1
2013-1970
�d<�� �!"#
�� ���� � s+:!� �!a
.?&)
)F� %VJ2(ARDL
��,� �0+B%V� ) ������*� ./��� }+
'(� � �<�� .*2!� ���J +Y�� �
F 5� '(� ) ���$%&� '+<!� S��!E ��)
�� �2� � ��!� F�)� �- �d<�� �!"#
N+B%V� ) �,i� +Y�� �<) '"9 ���
� �?9 .� �I%V��) ) �<�� .*2!�
.��� 2 �� .� J �� & '+m�� ��!� ���J
�����*� ) �?�� ./��� �!1) .� .1!�
��?9 .� �I%V��) ) �<�� .*2!� �+�
'+m�� �!"# ��� �� �?9 �� ?9
���� ) .�� J� A4� �?J X�!� �<�
�� �!1!� �<�� ����� �d<�� �!"# ��
+� �� �+<�* �� ���# +� >�!R .�
.�2� F��� o!2 �) F 5�
)�9)��!#2015(3
2009-1995
128 �!"#
;4%��
F��� �!I<� ��
�+04� ) ��!7���X�
���Y >� Y�
�� ��+9 .� .1!� �� �<�� A4� C�
�� � �2� �O0� F'( S+O"� X����2
!9 �� ��# ) ;V# ^!7/��9 �!5~
) ���$%&� {!�� �9�� ._+%9 �� .'(��
.�2� ����� �� ?9 F'��# ��!B�
d%�
)X���O0 )2015(4 2010-1990
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
)�<!0*�OLS(
./��� C� ����� l�2 h��3 X��*�
) �+*01 '(� >���'&� �� G!O*�
���$%&� '(� ._+%9 �� ) ��� @��#
.����
1. Ramez et al.
2. Auto Regressive Distributed Lag
3. Kurronen
4. Betz et al
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 105
_____________________________________________________________________________________
)g)�'��� 2013(1
2007-1970
;4%�� �� �!"#
����� �����
�*+,-
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
) �<!0*�OLS(
%0# �*+,- ����� �� ��� �� �!"#
.%�� .*2!� ./��� C� �+�|0 .'9�
����� �9�)� ) �<�� .*2!� �+� �?��
.���� �!1)
) �'+� 2
)X���O0 2012(2
2009-1999
36;4%�� �!"#
F��� �!I<� ��
) ��!7��� �+04�X�
���Y >� Y�
+Y�� ��<�� .*2!� 67%4� v!/2 ��
>)�?%� �<�� .*2!� � �*+,- �����
d+9 �E�0%1� .��� 2 .*2!� .�2�
�% J F'���9 �� � �05� NV+9�O�
f#)�����NRC '(��
) l9�2!�
)�c2011(3
2006-1996
�+c �!"#
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
������*� ) �?�� ./��� �9�)� �+�
�� �<�� .*2!� ) �9'*� �����
X�%2� ) ���� �!1) �+c ��59�%2� ���
��� �9'*� ����� ��r< �� .#�%V � '
�+m�� �<�� .*2!� s/2� �,V9 � � .
X�%2�.'9��� +B ��
) �'2�
)X���O0 1392(
2011-1982
36 ) �%?9 �!"#
�%?9 +�
F��� �!I<� ��
) ��!� ��!7���
04��+ X�
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
F'��# �++*� AB9 �<�� .*2!� �� ��
�����# X��� �� & +Yt� �r�
.��� 2 � O70E ._+%9 �� ) ���J
�� �?�� ���$%&� �� ��59 ���9�!� ) '�#
�%?9 +� ) �%?9 �� �!"# �� �<��
X@ I�� N5� ._+%9 .�2� >)�?%�
.��� 2 �e�� v!/2 .# �2�� ���J�
�+��� �+?+# �%?9 �� �!"# � �
.�2� .%(��
���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �9�)� �� Q,� � F'( \�_9� >�*<�/�
) �0< J
)�9��!#2016(4
2010-1990
�!"# F) J )�
+B ) ���
F��� �!I<� ��
�+04� ) ��!7���X�
���Y >� Y�
�'�7 ���0+� ) ����� �� ?9 .+:
�9��� F�)� �-1970 ��1990 ��!�
�� �� & '+m�� ��� .# �<�T �� � +J
�9��� F�)� �- .+: 1990 ��
2010 �09 �� & '+m�� ��!��� � �� � +J
�� �%T '+<!� ) �a�2 A4� F�)� ���
X�)� �*+,- ����� ����� �� �!"#
1. Hattendorff
2. Sarmidi and et al
3. Yuxiang and Chen
4 Gerelmaa and Kotani
106 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
����!a � �,2��� '(� �� N
F'�� J.'9�
)�79��!�2016(1
2010-1985
28 ����� �!"#
�%?9 �����
C+�O�GMM
S&�'T ) �0%V+2
.7T � )� >�*� �
)��2SLS(
+Y�� �*+,- ����� �� SR�T '�@��
�� ���$%&� '(� � �����*� ) �?��
��� ) ���� �2� � ��!� �� �!"#
�)� �% J 89 �� �� ._+%9 ��
,%*� �+04� 67%4� .�2�
) ���:�
)X���O0 1394(
1389-1352
;4%�� � �!"#
�%?9
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
.7T � .2)��3SLS(
(N+B%V� Y�) �%?9 �� '�@�� �!)
+Y�� �<) ���$%&� '(� � �?�� +Y��
.���� � �� ��9 � �,i�
) ����@ F�(
) X���O0 1392(
2008-1970
X� �� �� �!"#
u) 9)
s+:!� �!a �� ���� �
.?&)
)F� %VJARDL(
F��!#�� �!a >�3 �� �*+,- �����
'(� �� � �*9�� >'�'�7� ) >'�
�+�|0 .�V+9 � �!"# ��� ���$%&�
�� d+9 �9�V9� .��� 2 ) ���$%&� ����@
F��!#�� u) 9 ) X� �� �!"# )� >'�
'(� � �����*� ) �,i� Y� >'�'�7� )
.'9���
) ��!,5�
)X���O0 1391(
2010-1996
;4%�� � �!"#
�%?9
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
).%�� N+0*�EGLS(
�!) �2� � ��!� �9��� F�)� �-
) �?�� +Y�� ����� �*+,- �����
Y� ����� ���59 �+?+# d+9 ) �����*�
��� ���$%&� '(� � �����*� ) �,i�
\'E ��0:�� .�2� F�!� � �!"#
� �!) �� �B/�� ) ;2��� ��!a ���� �
.� X@ �� SR�T �� '�@�� ) �*+,-
���59 �+?+# s/2 X'�@ �+���
A �# ZE�� k� - ����� ) F'( _��
F'( � �!"# ��� ���$%&� '(� %"+�
.�2�
) ��)��
)X���O0 1390(
2008-1970
8 !DE �%?9 �!"#
C�)�
�� X� �+04�
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
) .%��GMM
) �*+,- ����� �!) X�+� �?�� ./���
A��d�) ���$%&� '(�GDP (.9� 2
.���� �!1)
1 Youmanli
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 107
_____________________________________________________________________________________
���$%&� '(� ) �*+,- ����� �!) �+� ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� AB9 �� Q,� � F'( \�_9� >�*<�/�
) �I+��� �
)q! 2016(1
2010-2000
63 �!"#
�?9 F'��#'+<!�
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
>�9�2!9 �+� ������*� ) �?�� ./���
�- ���$%&� '(� ) �?9 .<��,� ./���
G�2� � .���� �!1) �2� � ��!� F�)�
��� �� �"4� '9�!� �� �<�� .*2!� � U��%9
�<)� .'�# S�'*� �� �?9 X�2!9 �?�� Y�
���� �!& ��5%2�+2 X��+0-� \'E '9�!�
F�I�� ) � ��!9�a �� ' � A �# �� � )
� O70E ) A��d� �� �<)� ��,%E� ._+%9��
����� '"4� �!,5� �� �<��.
) ��&
)�VT2016(2
2014-1996
!DE �� �!"#
���O0 ���!(
G�� U+7a
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
) �?9 X�2!9 �+� �����*� ) �?�� ./��� C�
%"+� .*2!� ) ���� �!1) ���$%&� '(�
�� �<�� �� ����� �� �?�� ./��� ��� '9�!�
.'�# S�'*�
) �'+*2
)X���O0 2016(3
2013-1983
27 !DE �!"#
���O0 X����2
���$%&� .*2!� )
)52 +� �!"#
!DE
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
)�<!0*�OLS(
�!1) �59@ �+� >'�'�7� ) �,i� �I%V,0
'(� ) .��� 2 ^�VT ���2���@ ) ����
�!"# �� �!"# �� � ���$%&� DE!
) ���O0 X����2 .*2!� �,V9 ���$%&�
+� �� �!"# .�!DE���O0 X����2 )
�� A��d� %"+� ���$%&� .*2!��.'��
) �9�9�5<�
)X���O0 2016(4
1999-1990
2011-2000
m�d_<� �!"#
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
F��� A��d� �� ���$%&� '(� ��<�� .*2!�
�?�� >� Y� A �# �� ���F��1� �?9 ��
�09 C0#.'�#
)G))�u��2016(5
2009-2008
2015-2014
.� _+9 �!"#
N+0*� �� �)�%"J
).%��GMM(
N%V+2 ��)@�!2 � �?9 �0+& q!( +Y��
.# ��� X�"9 ) � # '+#�� .� _+9 �O9��
gWa � N+B%V� �!- .� h�B%9� \d+9�O�
) .9�+��)�a �� �!"# �� .��"� >�*<�/�
h�0( C� �!1) �+�|0 .�2� �B� @
�O9�� N%V+2 �� �!2 ���'��� F'�'�
�� X�"9 �� .� _+9.' �
1. Moradbeige and Hook
2. Gazdar and Hassan
3. Saidi et al
4. Elhannani et al
5. Zacchaeaus
108 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
)��!12015(1 2011-1991
�%?9 �� �!"#
>�*� � S&�'T �)�
)�<!0*�OLS(
k� - �� '(� � �?�� +Y�� ����� �9�)�
��# ) ��2 +Y�� .# �<�T �� .���� X�2!9 ��
'(� � �*+,- ����� N+B%V� � �,i� ��2
'9�!� �� X�2!9 k� - �� X@ .%2�!a�9 >� Y�
'(�� %J�d�
X�J'�V�!9 ��)@� J : �,��
X�0 �� F' �"� e�� h)'1 �� .# �!- �� �!"# �� �?7%4� �� _� >�*<�/� ��!(
) ����� �!) ) ����� �!) ) �<�� .*2!� ����$%&� '(� ) �<�� .*2!� �+� ./��� .�+��
�+� ./��� � �<�� .*2!� AB9 ) +Y�� �� ./��� �� �<) �2� F'( \�_9� ���$%&� '(�
�� X�2!9 ) ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 �!"# Sa�� �� �� .*<�/� }+ X!�#�� �%?9 �� '�@
>�9�2!9 ) ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 �+� ./��� N .*<�/� ��� �� .�2� F'"9 \�_9�) �!
�%?9 �� '�@�� .*2!� AB9 �2� � .� N ) � +J �� �� & �2� � ��!� (�?9 �� ?9)
/� ��� d+9 Z+T ��� �� .# �!( �� .%a�� � ./��� ��� �� �<�� >�*<�/� .� �,V9 .*<�
.'(�� �� d��0%� �7a�� F'( \�_9�
4. ��#&O�� �� #$ � !��B� �:�� �P� �2
�7,& F'( \�_9� >�*<�/� .� .1!� ��) X���O0 ) d��� +892016�VT ) ��& � ( )2016(
) q! ) �I+��� � )2016 ;2��� �!I<� �A )H� � 89 �9�,� G�2� � �+�|0 ) (
X�2!9 �+� ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� AB9 � ��,� A )H� .+: X!��@ �!8�� .� A )H�
.� C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 ) (�?9 �� ?9)�%?9 �� '�@�� '(�
) .<��*� >�!R1�� .m��� (.�!(
����� = �������� + ����� ��� + ��������� + ����� + ������ ∗��� ���� + ���� + ɳ� + �� + ��� )1(
1. Joya
٢ �01 C�)� .9e����2 ����@ �%<!� ) h!� �770<� �+� o)'����R ��9�51 C9�� �� A )H� �� +P%� >�EW-� ) ���@
.�2� F'( ��)@
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 109
_____________________________________________________________________________________
: e�� .<��*� �� .#
SDG C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 I9�+� ) A )H� .%V��) +P%� �
9��� F�)� �- ��� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 .,2�r� .�2� A )H� ��� �� �2� � ��!� �
'(� .9e�2 ���B� ���'9�%2� g� r9� >�!R .� q r%� ��+*� g� r9� �� F��?%2� �� A )H�
.�2� F'( \�_9� ����$%&� '(� � 9 .<�2 }�� q r%� �+I9�+� .� .1!� �� ���$%&�
SDTOTX�"9 �� ./��� '(� X�2!9 F'� � >�*<�/� .� .1!� �� .# �2� �?9 .<��,
) X���O0 ) d��� +89 �7,& F'( \�_9�2016S%��� ) � ����2� ) (1 )2009 X�!�E .� (
.�2� F'( .% J 89 �� !I<� �� (�?9 �� ?9 )�%?9 �� '�@�� �9�)� X�2!9 ja�(
:�2� �� >�!R .� �?9 .<��,� ./��� .,2�r� F!r9
� ��� = ����� !"#
$%&!& )2(
.<��*� ��� ��POILX�"9 � C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� C� �?9 .9e�2 �0+& F'� �
A )H� ��� �� �2� � ��!� �9��� F�)� �- .�2�MUV X�"9 d+9 ���� ja�( F'� �
.9�a��# ����R F�)d� .�2� ��X )M >����) ) >����R N52 Q2!%� �� �� � ;+� � .� d+9
.� C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� �?9GDP X@ d+9 �?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 .,2�r� .�2� �
.�2� F'( \�_9� q r%� ��+*� g� r9� G�2� �
SDINF� X�"9 �2� �2� � ��!� F�)� �- 67%4� �� �!"# \�!� � 9 X�2!9 F'� �
%� ��� X�2!9 .#�2� F'( .,2�r� �A )H� ��� �� F��?%2� ��!� �)� G�2� � d+9 +P.
FD*OTOT �!8�� .� �?9 .<��,� ./��� '(� X�2!9 ) �<�� .*2!� �7��*� +P%� �
.�2� ���$%&� '(� ) �?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 � �<�� .*2!� +Y�� �2� �
FD � A )H� ��� �� F��?%2� ��!� �<�� .*2!� ja�( I9�+� �� A )H� ��� �� .�2�
.�2� F'( F��?%2� h!� �770<� �+� o)'�R Q2!� F'( .m��� �<�� .*2!� ���1 ja�(
�� ��59 ) �<�� �� ����� h!� �770<� �+� o)'�R Q2!� F'( .m��� �<�� .*2!� ja�(
1. Spatafora and Tytell
110 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
) �� � ���9�!�) �<�� �2 %2� �(�I��'B9 X�d+� ) F��'9�) �<�� k0E s/2 .2 �� �� �<��
(�# N � �� �<�� >�V2!� ���9�!�) �<�� ��@��# ) (�<�� >��'a .� �2 %2� �� �
N# �� �<�� >��'a X� # 89 �� (.��� 2 ����� �+<�* s/2 ) ��'��� '�@�� ) .��d �� �
��S��# �� �O� ) � +Jja�( �� � �� � .# �2� �<�� .*2!� �� 180 67%4� �!"#
h�2 �� �+9�1980 >�!R .� .�2� F'�� J .,2�r� .9e�2
Z � I9�+� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � ��J +Y�� ) F��?%2� ��!� �< %�# �� +P%� ��� �
.1�� �� +P%� �� !I<� ��� �� .�2� �7,& F'( \�_9� >�*<�/� ) � 89 �9�,� G�2� �
.� �<)� y��4� �,V9 ) ���_� X�!� ��� GDP .�2� F'( F��?%2�
�++,� �� �2� F'( .m��� ��'*%� >�� 89 ���$%&� '(� ) �<)� y��4� �+� ./���
!� I2�� ) !%2)� .� 89 .#1 G�2� � .�V9�� .�+�� ��� �� \�I"+� >�� 89 �� X�!� �� ��
.+<)� ST� � �� �� �!"# ���$%&� .*2!� ) '(� .9�J U�� ST� � z �� ) .� 89 ���
�4� ������ �VO( �!1) S+<� .� �'(� � %"+� �<�a� �<)� ) '��� A��d� '��� �<)� y�
'(� �<)� y��4� A��d� �+�|0 ) �<�a� A��d� �� ��� ���� '(�� .%(�� ��$%&� ��
C� �� ��!0E y��4� �J�) �F�J'�� ��� S��B� ./B9 �� .'��� �� A��d� d+9 ���$%&�
X�"9 ���$%&� '(� .� �%,i� A�#�) .# '9�� �� ���%� +P%�� ��� ���� .' � ��
�J�) X!9�& G�2�2 .� 89 .���'9 �!1) ���$%&� '(� .� ��!0E y��4� �02 �� �%+7E
��� G�2� � .���� � �� ���$%&� '(� ) �<)� y��4� �+� ./��� �2� � .� d+9 �d�+#
A��d� ._+%9 �� ) F'�� J �%<)� A4� h�P%(� A��d� ZE�� �<)� y��4� A��d� �.� 89
�!2 '+<!� ���� C� .� .1!� �� .7�V� ��� .# ���� F� 0 .� �� ���_� �� �# ( '�@�� )
)��� Q2!� GWJ�� ^�#3 )1990 .�2� F'+2� >�,Y� .� d+9 ( .# ���I� �2� 'B%*� )���
�� e�# .� �!� � S��V� ) � ��$r9� ��,9�1 >� Y� s+r$� ��%2�� �� �<)� y��4�
1. Musgrave Rostow’s Theory
2. Wagner Law
3. Barro
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 111
_____________________________________________________________________________________
_�� '9�!� �� �'(�� ��!0E�!( ���$%&� '(� ��!B� .� �X���O0 ) �9�VT�)1395 .(
A<�c >�E!:!� �� �O� X�!�E .� d+9 ���$%&� '(� ) ���_� X�!���� .1�� �+� ./���
�� � �� �'�'1 ^!c��c �� X)�� '(� ��!�� .�2� v /� ���$%&� >�*<�/� �� d+I9� �
� v /� ���_� X�!� ��� .1�� ) ���$%&� '(� ./��� �2� ���� .'�# � O�)� '�'1
�!I<� �� X�O�� �'(� �!1) ./��� �51 X�+� � +J >��_� ) '(� ���$%&� .�
��5()� 67%4� X�+� F'�� J X�!���� .1�� A��d� �� �� ��!�� ��� G�2� � .�2�
� �!"# ���_� X�O�� �)�) �e�# .��� 2 �� ) �u!<!�O� N � �� �� J ) �� .1!� .�
��d� �,V9�� �!"# 67%4� X�O�� '+<!� �� F��?%2� �� . R G�+B� ) N+VB� ��#
�9�51 N � �� ._+%9 �� .�� J >��_� X���%( ;,2 X'( '(� ���$%&� �� G�+B�
�9�51 �� X�!���� �� �+�|0 .�� J �>����) k� - �� ) ���_� ��8%9� �� �)� �� k� -
>����) �e�# .��� 2 �� �� � ��)@ �.% "+� h�B%9� � ��)@ Sa�� .� A��d� � �!"#
.1!� �� d+9 >�*<�/� �� �a � .'�# N � �� ���$%&� '(� ) '+<!� A��d� .�+�� ) '���
.��!I<� � �9�V9� .��� 2 Y� k� - �� �� >��_� X�!� ��� +Y�� �G�#!< �9�V9� .��� 2
����$%&� .'� � �� �� & S+7r� ) .�d_� ��!� '(� '9'B%*� C+2W#!�9 ) C+2W# X�9
;1!� ) �2� ���$%&� .*2!� ) '(� .# r� �!�!� ���_� X�!���� .1�� A��d� .#
��) F 5� ) ��� J j$4� s/2 A��d� k� - �� � �!"# ��$%&� ��� I0 A��d�
�� ���$%&� '(� ) ��$%&� X�!���� .1�� �+� ./��� �!1) ��� �� .�!( �� � �!"#
� �� �!"# X�VO� SO( .� '+<!� S��!E �� �9�)� ) �u!<!�O� �� >)�?� �7E .� 67%4
�O+9��)�2� .%(�� ���$%&� '(� � �?�� +Y�� � �!"# �� �a � �� �� ) F�!,91 �2003 .(
ŋ� )�� ) (X��� ���_� +P%�) X��� >� Y� ) �*/B� ���Y >� Y� I9�+� ;+� � .�
(� !I<� hWa� d1 d+9 .�2�).<��*� ��1 �( ŋ� .# �2� (�!"#) �*/B� >� Y� .701
F��'9� S��& +� ) F'"9 F' �"� �� +P%� S��( ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � ��J Y� � +J
1. Yanikkaya
112 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
�2� F +� ) �u!<!�O� �� �����!a � ����! ) ^@ Q�� ( �� ��59 �l� �'�9�� � �!"#
.�2� >)�?%� � �!"# �+� .#
1-4. �:�� R&0S T�
'(� X�2!9 ) �?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 �+� ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� AB9 �2� � �!8�� .�
) .<��*� �� A )H� ��� �� C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&�1�� F��?%2� ( .1!� �� .�!(
.# X@ z �� ) !I<� ��� .�(�� >��,E .� �� �'�# �) +� . - C� hWa� d1 !I<� ��
:N���� f� �'(�� �-�B� >)�?� ;1!� S��E C� �5�� I��
(�� = )� + ���
X@ �� .#)� ≈ ����0. �.�� )/�� ≈ ����0. �#�� �/B� �� ) �-�B� �+� �� ) '�%V
.'9 I�'O� �� SB%V� F��� �!I<� �+04� �� Zr� �+<)�.701 ��@ .# �2� X@ ��!7��� ��
)� Y� X�0 �� ��� ���$� >� Y� !I<� �� �7R� z .���$� �� �2� ���Y ��-�B� >�
\W2� .'�%V �r+:!� �� +P%� �� SB%V� ��-�B� >� Y� .# �2�1)1995 �2� 'B%*� (
) �!I<� �+04� �� z ��� X'( �� S+<� .�1 �� � ���$� >� Y� �)� �� F��?%2� �(
� ��,��� �!1) .�!� ' �!49 ;2��� X@ �+04� �� �r+:!� �� +P%� ) �-�B� >� Y� �+
X)�� ��!� SO"� ST .� ���& �)� ��� ��� ��2� �� SO"� ���Y >� Y� �)� ����
�!I<� �� ��!� ��%a�2 �!1) S+<� .� � I�� �!2 �� ��V+9 �r+:!� �� +P%�
!m�+V 2)1986)'9�� ) !9e�@ ) (1991F� # >�,Y� (�+04� ���Y >� Y� �)� .# '9� ��
.��� ' �!a .m��� �� ���J��2�9
) �!I<� X!c1 +P%� ���� X)�� SO"� )� �� ( ��!� ��%a�2 �!1) ) �r+:!� ��
)�1�%<�� >�*<�/� G�2� � )� ��� �� ��2� .1�!�2001)'9!� ) !9e�@ ) (1991 .� '��� �(
.7T � )� >�*� � S&�'T �)� S2!%� .%�� N+0*� �� �)�%"J �)� .� �� ) �� .� .'(
1. Islam
2. Hsiao
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 113
_____________________________________________________________________________________
�?%2� ��!� �� ��d�� {!9 S+<�.7T � )� >�*� � S&�'T �)� �� F� �2� �O0� ���
.'�@ �2'� ���J��2�9 U��%9 ) '9!( ��)@ � %J�d� ��+04� ;�� : f9����).� ./��� S+<�
�+� �I%V,0 ���B� )!I<� .%V��) +P%� .?&) ��0������)�� ���Y >� Y� ) (0��� �(
�)�OLS �+04� d+9) �!I<� ��)@ � �� � �,2��� X�1�+04� ) �!� ' �!49 ( ��
�)� �� SR�TOLS .�!� '� �!a ��J��2�9 ) e�� .� )� ��!� �����;2��� �)� ��� ���� �
F��� ���!� �� !I<� �� � X� �+04��+04� ���!7��� �� N+0*� �� �)�%"J X�
).%��GMM .�!� ' �!a (
7# �!- .��+04� �X�GMM �� N+VB� .%2� )� .��+04� :�!( .,� � S:�?� X�
)'9�� ) !9e�@ Q2!� F'( .m���) h)�1991 N+0*� �� �)�%"J �0%V+2 X� �+04� ) ((
)'9�� ) h'9!7� Q2!� F'( .m���) .%��1998)'9��) !9e�@ .((1991F��� ��5�"+� ( �� .# '9�
!�E .� s/2 �� .%V��) �� +P%� .?&))'9�� ) h'9!7� ��� ��!( F��?%2� ��d�� X�1998 ) (
O+� ) Im�1 �'9!�1)1995F��� X�"9 ( �?+*: �� ��d�� �s/2 �� � +P%� .?&) .# '9�
) '�%V S:�?� �� �9!+2 J� .<��*� �� ��+04� X�GMM .1!� �� h)� .,� � S:�?�
�+04� �� ���d�� +P%� 6*: .� h)� .,� � S:�?� X�GMM S+<� .� �+�|0 )
�+04� ����d�� �� +P%� ���%V���9 h'9!7� �!8�� �+0 .� .�(�� ' �!49 ���J��2 ��
'9�� ) )1998(2 �+04� X�GMM �)�� ) !9e�@ Q2!� .# '9��� .m��� �� �0%V+23)1995 (
)�?%� �� \ �59@ .�!� F'�� J .m��� ���d�� �� +P%� 6*: X� # g - � �!8�� .� )� �
G�2� � .'9��� �� & F��?%2� ��!� �� ���d�� �� +P%� f� ��� �� .?&) �� .%V��) +P%� ��
.+,( �� F'�@ �2� .� U��%9 .� C��d9 .?&)�� .%V��) +P%� ;� : .# �9��� ����21
�+04� ��@��# �'(�� X�GMM �� A��d� �0%V+2 .'�����?J '��� .%,<� ���J��2
�+04� F'�9�GMM � ,%*� .� ��2� F'( ��� �59@ �%2�� .��� � .# �:) G�2�
1. Jaeger and Baker
2. Blundell and Bond 3. Arellano and Bover
114 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
�� .# ���� �I%V� � ��d�� ) �/a >W01 �<�� 2 �I%V,0 \'E z X�!�� '9�!�.
s� $� X!��@ )� .7+2)) '9�� ) !9e�@ Q2!� F'(1991�)!� ) !9e�@ �( )1995 h'9!7� ) (
) '9�� )1998��2 X!��@ ��+<)� .�!( X!��@ (X�J1 ���)'r� �� �++*� A+� �� �� F'(
�� X!��@ �� � ��d�� X�!� ,%*� .# �2�'�# �1�%<��)2 �2005(.
�<�� 2 �I%V,0 X!��@ �X!��@ �+�)�3 .,� � �<�� 2 �I%V,0 �!1) .# �2�
�� \)�AR(2) �� �2� � �� h)� .,� � �7:�?� ��/a >W01 �� �X!��@ ��� �� .'�#
�+04� X�GMM � �� \)� .,� � �<�� 2 �I%V,0 .# �2� ���J��2 ����� �9��
'9��) .'(�� .%(�'9 �!1) h)� .,� � �7:�?� .<��*� �� �/a >W014 �2002.(
4U2. V%�#+ #&W� � �:�� R&0S
�)� �� F��?%2� �� A )H� �!I<� ��)@ � ) �+04� .� A )H� �� �0V& ��� ��GMM
�� .%a�� � �0%V+2.E!0_� �+04� \�_9� �� S,& .�!(X!��@ �� �� �� S,& ��
)��)@ �Pre estimation testX!��@ ) (��)@ � �� '*� �� )Post estimation test( �!1)
X!��@ \�0� A4� ��� .���� �� .����*� ) S,& �$+4"� �� �� .m��� !I<� �+04� �� 'J.��
2U4U1 .���)� X1�"� R&$ �:�W$��
F��� �!I<� ��)@ � �� S,& ��� .�!( \�_9� � +P%� ������ X!��@ �2� \�e ��,+# � ��
F��� ������ X!��@ \�_9� �� S,& �!8�� .� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) X!��@ '��� ��,+# � ��
X!��@ .�!( \�_9� ;2��� 'T�) ."�� X!��@ ^�4%9��?7%4� �� 5 ������ �2� � �51
F��� �� +P%�X@ �+� �� ;2��� X!��@ ^�4%9� .# ���� �!1) �,+# � �� h)� \�J �� �
1. Sargan Test
2. Baltaji
3. Serial Correlation Test
4. Bond
٥ ).%�� N+0*� <! �O�� 'T�) ."�� X!��@ADF)!c ) �+< ���!< �(LIC) "+ .%�� N+0*� <! �O�� �(ADFF (
f�+7+ )- X) �-) "+FPF)X� V�) N�� �(IPS ) l9�%� � ) () X� V� ) ���� 2003X� V� 'T�) ."�� X!��@ ) (
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 115
_____________________________________________________________________________________
�2� �*/B� �I%V��) �!1) �2� � '����+9 ��1�%<��)2005 .(
) X� V� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) X!��@ �� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �2� � �!8�� .�2015 (
) X� V� X!��@ F'( S+0O� .4V9 .#2004?%2� ��2� ( '+��� >�!R �� .�2� F'( F��
F��� �� �*/B� �I%V��)�)� �� F��?%2� ��,+# � �� F��� 'T�) ."�� \!2 � �� ��
!c ) �+< ���!< X!��@ +89 �,+# �1)LIC�+( ) X� V� �N�� �(2)IPS {!&) h�0%T� �(
X!��@ SO"� ��� �� �� � .��� ' �!a A��d� �� ^3�# 'T�) ."�� U��%9 ."�� �� 'T�)
F��� ."�� X!��@ .# �2� F'( ��5�"+� �*/B� �I%V��) �!1) �� ��'*%� �,+# � ��
)X� V� 'T�)CIPSU��%9 .�2� .701 X@ �� (3 �� � X� V� �*/B� �I%V��) X!��@
F��� �� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �!,9 � ��,� ?R .+: .# ��� X�"9 .*<�/� ��!� ��
�� � ��� ���� .�!( �09 '+m�� �59@ �� �a � �� ) '+m�� F��?%2� ��!� �� +P%� �� �a �
�� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �!1) \'E �� �!1) .� .1!� �� 'T�) ."�� X!��@ X!��@ ."�� ��
X� V� 'T�) )2003�� F��?%2� "+ ) ( .�!(
2U4U2. �Y�� ��% ���)�
� +P%� �� �a � �� .# ���_9@ �� .�2� � +P%� ���%V�� �2� � A )H� ��� �� �'*� \�J
'T�) ."�� X!��@ k� - �� � +P%� ��� ���%V�� �2� � �'�� J '+m�� �*/B� �I%V��)
Q2!� F'( .m���)X� V�2003( 4 ��2� F'( .% J 89 �� �*/B� �I%V��) X@ �� .#
1. Levin, Lin and Chu
2. Im,Pesaran and Shin
٣ .m��� .<�B� N_T A��d� �� � +J!71 �!8�� .� 'T�) ." �� �� X!��@ ) �-�B� �+� �I%V ��) �� X!��@ U��%9
G�2� � .# �2� F'"9 .'�(�� �� .m��� S��& �2�!a��
٤ F���@ �+I9�+� G�2� � X!��@ ���t �N�� Q2!� F'( .m��� X!��@ �� �%2�� N ) �/B� <! �O�� .%�� N+0*�
)�+( ) X� V�IPS,2003 F���@ �9� r� ���B� .�2� (t-bar )X� V� .�2� F'( .,2�r� X� V� Q2!�2007 �� (
X!��@ S�',� �� IPS )ADF X�'B �� �!1) �2� � �� � �9!��@ F���@ C���*/B� �I%V��) �% J 89 �� )
X!��@ .� .# �2� F��� ��5�"+� �-�B� �+� �I%V��) �% J 89 �� .� ) 'T�) ."��CIPS .�2� g) *� X� V�
:�2� �� >�!R .� X!��@ ��� F���@
116 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
.<��,� ./��� X�2!9 �� +P%� �� +� .� X!��@ ��� �� SR�T U��%9 G�2� � .'�� J \�_9�
S:�?� C� �� .# ���_� X�!���� .1�� ) �<�� .*2!� ja�( ����$%&� '(� X�2!9 ��?9
�?%2� ��!� �� +P%� ��2 �'�%V �%V�� .'�(�� �� �%V�� s/2 �� A )H� ��� �� F�
3U2U4. ���)�9���0H
.� .1!� ��.# ��� U��%9 �� X��+0-� �!8�� .� �'�%V+9 �%V�� s/2 �� k+Br� �� +P%� �� �a �
�2� � � +P%� X�+� >'�'�7� ��,��� �!1) '��� �^3�# X!+2 J� �� � +J!71 ) F'�@ �2� .�
� 9)�'� X!��@ +89 �?7%4� �� X!��@ .�!(1 )1999)2004' 9e %2) �(2 )2007 ) (
)�#3)1999�,��� �2� � �!8�� .� ( ./��� ) >'�'�7� �N �*01 F��� �� � +P%� X�+� ��
���� �!1) ��!7���4F��� X�!� X��!%��9 S+<� .� A )H� ��� �� .!m�# X!��@ �� ��!7��� �� 5
F��?%2� >'�'�7� ./��� �!1) \'E �� �!1) �2� � �51 .'�� J
1�2���. �� = 1� 4 56
7
�8���. ��
X@ �� .#56 � F���@�!I<CADF 'T�) ."�� X!��@ F���@)ADF �/B� �� � (�*/B� >�!R .� .%�� N+0*�
�� ��� ?9�F����2� �,+# � �� ) F���@ ��'B� .4 >�!R �� ) .V��B� X� V� Q2!� F'( .,2�r� �9� r� ���B� �� (
n�d� X�!� ���%V���9) ?R .+: ��9� r� ���B� �� F���@ ��� X�!� � +P%� �� ( ���%V�� ) +P%� �� ' �!a .%
.O��� .� .1!� �� .'(F����,+# � �� �� X��!%��9 k+Br� ��� �� �2� � ��!� X!��@ ) '(��CIPS QB X� V�
��F����,+# � �� )X� V� X!��@ �� QB k+Br� ��� �� �< ����� � ���# X��!%�2003 .'�� J F��?%2� (
1. Pedroni Cointegration Test
2. Westerlund Cointegration Test
3 Kao Cointegration test ٤ *�;2��� �++�/B� ��'*� .� A )H� �� X!��@ �� �� 2 ) � F��� X�!,9 �� X�!� X��!%� ) �9��� �� ��
� 2 ��'*� J� .���� �I%V� ��!7����/B� �� �9��� �� ) X� V� �*/B� hWB%2� X!��@ �'(�� %0# � J� ��'*�
� 2�/B� �� �9��� �� �X� V�)�2� ;2��� X�J�� ) �) � �*/B� �I%V��) '(�� %"+� � 2004.(
٥ ./��� �!1) \'E �� �!1) >�,Y� � R ) F�!,9 >'�'�7� ./��� �+04� h�,9� .� k+Br� ��� �� .O%�� .� .1!� ��
F��� ) �2� 89 '� >'�'�7� �� �,+# � �� X��!%��9 d+9�� � !m�# X!��@ .�2� F'( F��?%2� !m�# X!��@ �� �'�(
SI9� �)� G�2�-.7T � )� _9 JF��� ��d1� ��I0 ) �2� �� �� �I%(�,9� N X!��@ \�_9� �� �� ��!7��� ��
�� 89 X!��@ �� F��?%2� �� ��I%(�,9� N ./��� �!1) \'E �� �V���,E .# X!��@ ��� �� ?R .+: .� +JADF
� ��� �2�!(
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 117
_____________________________________________________________________________________
7��H)2.( ���)�9���0H (����P�� �%�*$� ��
X!��@ F���@ !I<� 1 !I<�2 !I<�3
Modified Dickey-Fuller t 0793/2-
)0188/0(
3450/3-
)0004/0(
1804/3-
)0007/0(
Dickey-Fuller t 7566/3-
)0001/0(
2900/5-
)0000/0(
8418/5-
)0000/0(
Augmented Dickey-Fuller
t 8529/4
)0000/0(
1304/1
)0292/0(
2669/3
)0005/0(
Unadjusted modified
Dickey-Fuller t 1794/2-
)0147/0(
5200/3-
)002/0(
7814/3-
)0001/0
Unadjusted Dickey-Fuller
t 7869/3-
)0001/0(
3258/5-
)0000/0(
9745/5-
)0000/0(
�2� F'( .m��� d%9� � Sa�� �� � F���@ .� �!� � h�0%T� ���B�
:�,��.%���� A )H�
�� F' �"� e�� h)'1 �� .# �!/9�0 �� !m�# F���@ h�0%T� ���B� G�2� � ��!(
X!+2 J� \�0��� '+m�� >'�'�7� ./��� �!1) ���)@ � �� .�!(
4U2U4. Z%��� #&W�
./��� X�2!9 ) ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 �+� ./��� � �<�� .*2!� ���J +Y�� �� SR�T U��%9
F��?%2� �� �?9 .<��,� �+04� �� X�GMM ) h)'1 �� �0%V+23X�0 .�2� F'( .m��� (
�!I<� G�2� � A )H� �!I<� �+04� �'%�� ��!( �� F' �"� h)'1 ��� �� .# �!-
.��� .���� �� f�2 ��2� F'( \�_9� �7��*� �� +P%� �% J 89 �� X)'� ) A )H� ��
) �<�� .*2!� �7��*� +P%� X'( .�:� �� A )H� !I<��?9 .<��,� ./��� '(� >�9�2!9 )
�� ��)@ � \�!� � 9 >�9�2!9 ) �<�� .*2!� �7��*� +P%� �+�|0 �!(.
118 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
7��H)3.( � ���� ����� � �2� ����� �L$� � ���� ���� !"� � #&F� �� #$
������ �� �����
+P%� !I<�1 !I<�2 !I<�3
���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 .?&)�� +P%�
7588/0
]0787/0[
)000/0(
6782/0
]0785/0[
)000/0(
7585/0
]0929/0[
)000/0(
�?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9
0583/0
]0279/0[
)043/0(
4915/0
]1845/0[
)009/0(
3826/0
]2135/0[
)067/0(
\�!� X�2!9
0013/0
]0008/0[
)153/0(
0009/0
]0008/0[
)283/0(
0047/0
]0030/0[
)114/0(
�<�� .*2!� ja�( N%���I<
0572/0-
]0121/0[
)000/0(
0381/0-
]0122/0[
)001/0(
0297/0-
]0141/0[
)036/0(
�<)� y��4� N%���I<
0595/0
]0118/0[
)000/0(
0541/0
]0110/0[
)000/0(
0531/0
]0113/0[
)000/0(
���_� X�!� ��� .1�� N%���I<
0621/0
]0146/0[
)000/0(
0488/0
]0149/0[
)000/0(
0562/0
]0138/0[
)000/0(
+P%� .*2!� ) �?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 �7��*�
�<��
4458/0-
]1682/0[
)008/0(
3697/0-
]1801/0[
)040/0(
+P%� �<�� .*2!� ) \�!� X�2!9 �7��*�
0038/0
]0028/0[
)185/0(
���Y ;� :
4999/0
]0946/0[
)000/0(
4455/0
]0892/0[
)000/0(
4548/0
]0908/0[
000/0(
X�J��2 X!��@ 1255/42
)2846/0(
57297/43
)2519/0(
43229/39
)3169/0(
'<�) X!��@ 12/229
)000/0(
63/296
)000/0(
23/287
)0000/0(
AR(1) 36/3- 83/2- 48/3-
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 119
_____________________________________________________________________________________
)01/0( )030/0( )02/0(
AR(2) 18/3-
)58/0(
88/2-
)67/0(
91/2-
)97/0(
� �!"# ��'*� 11 11 11
>�' �"� S# ��'*� 100 92 92
h�0%T� .�2� F'( .m��� d%9� � �� d+9 ;�� : .� �!� � h�0%T� ���B� ) �#� � Sa�� �� �+04� ��/a ��+*� g� r9�
F���@ .� �!� �.�2� F'( .m��� d%9� � �� d+9 �I%V,0 �!a X!��@ ) X�J��2 �'<�) ��
:�,��.%���� A )H�
) h)'1 �� .# �!/9�0 3�� F' �"� (�'<�) X!��@ �� SR�T U��%9 ��!( X�J��2 X!��@
X!��@ X�!�E .� �I%V,0 �!a X!��@ ) .�2� F'( .m��� �+04� �� '*� �$+4"� ��
�� X!��@ �� X!+2 J� S# X�!� �����*� '<�) X!��@ �� +P%� ��,%E� X�J��2 X!��@ ) '�#
�� �� & �2� � ��!� �� !I<� �� F��?%2� ��!� ���d�� .� .# X�J��2 X!��@ .' � �!8��
�2� �'T �� A+� �!+& X!��@ ) !I<� �� F'( F��?%2� ���d�� �� +P%� ��,%E�1 ��2�
�,9�_� ���!� G�2� � F'( F��?%2� ���d�� �� +P%� ��,%E� � ��,� ?R .+: �r�
X!��@ ��� �� SR�T U��%9 .���� �� & )� ��# X�"9F'� � ��� �!I<� .2 �� .# �2�
��d�� �� +P%� �F'( ��)@ �F'9�0+&�� ��d1� �� � N !I<� ��� ��� ���� �'9��'9 �I%V�
�� SR�T U��%9 .�2� ��0%E� S��& �51 ��� �� !I<� U��%9 ) F'( ^�4%9� �2�� � +P%�
SR�T U��%9 G�2� � .'�%V F'( ��)@ � X!+2 J� S# ������*� I9�+� d+9 '<�) X!��@
� �I%V,0 �!a \'E d+9 �I%V,0 �!a X!��@ ��.,� � S:�?� h)� .1� >W01 h)�
�� �� hW%a� hWa� >W01 S:�?� \)� .1�� �<�� 2 �I%V,0 �!a \'E ��� � # �� X�!�
�09 ��!I<� ��,%E� ��� ���� .� # �� X�!��� �� & '+m�� ��!� d+9 89 ��� �� A )H� �� .� +J
F'( ��)@ � X!+2 J� .2 �� F'�@ �2� .� U��%9 .� .1!� �� ?&)�� +P%� +Y�� .
) �,i� (���$%&� '(� X�2!9 ���1 s/2)!I<� .%V��) +P%� � ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9
X�"9 ._+%9 ��� .�2� �����*� ��e�� X��+0-� s/2 �� ����@ ��r< .� �2� ��� F'� �
1. Test of the over identifying restrictions
120 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
F�)� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 .# �,i� +Y�� +P%� ��� ���1 F�)� >�9�2!9 � S,& ��
��� .�
X�2!9 � �?9 .<��,� ./��� '(� X�2!9 +P%� +Y�� �F'�@ �2� .� U��%9 G�2� �
��� .�2� �����*� d+9 ����@ ��r< .� ) �,i� F'( ��)@ � �� !I<� \�0� �� ���$%&� '(�
�� �!"# �� �%?9 �� '�@�� �!) X�2!9 .# �2� ��� F'� � X�"9 F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9
�,i� +Y�� C�)� !DE �2� � ��!� F�)� �- � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 �
._+%9 ��� .+1!� �� .�2� � �!"# ��� �� �?9 �� ?9 .+: F'��# '+m�� ) �2� .%(��
�� F'�@ �2� .� F'( ZE�� C�)� !DE �� �!"# ���$%&� ;2����9 ��%a�2 ��?J X�!�
@��) ����� �!) >�9�2!9 �� � �� � �!"# ��� �� �2� A�#�) (� �!"# ��� �� �%?9 �� '�
;+2@ S�e� �� %05� �� �O� .'�(�� .%(�'9 �,2��� >�9�2!9 �� � �!"# ��� � ��
��� �!"# .�2� � �!"# ��� �<!$r� C� ��$%&� �*+,- ����� �� SR�T �� '�@��
��� �%?9 �� '�@�� .� ����� ��+V� �I%V��) �!� /& ) o� E �X�%V� E �X� �� X!|0 9 .'
�0+& ja�( � �%?9 �� '�@�� �� SR�T >�9�2!9 +Y�� ) �'�7 ���0+� F'�'�� � �� �
�� F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� S�e� I�� �*+,- ����� �� '�@�� X�2!9 .� # X�!�E X�!�
�0+& ��!0E s/2 >�9�2!9 �� �!"# ��� �� X'�@ �!1!� ) �(�� ' �!a F� 0 .� �� �
�� SR�T �9��+0-�9 �0+& ��!0E s/2 � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 ZE�� �
���)'r� ���V ) �9�� �!1) X!|0 �7��!E .'( ' �!a ���1 ^�VT �� �!1!� ��
�� F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� � Y!� S��!E I�� �� �� � �!"# ��� �� .��� 2 �� )� X�!
2� .� ._+%9 ��� .� # ��'07& U��%9 �� F'�@ � .*<�/� �� SR�TC57� ) nW��� X)1
)2010 )2009)q! ) �I+��� � ) (2016 .�2� ��J��2 (
F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � �<)� y��4� +P%� +Y��
�� �!"# ���$%&� ��%a�2 .� 89 .�2� �����*� ����@ ��r< .� ) �,i� �2� � ��!�
1. Van der Ploeg and Poelhekke
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 121
_____________________________________________________________________________________
.1�!� �I%V��) ) C�)� !DE �� ) �%?9 �� '�@�� .� �59@ y��4� ._+%9 �� ) � �!"# ���
.� .1!�.# ��� �� ^!Vr� ��$%&� S# ��:�B� �d1� �� � N5� �� �O� �<)� y��4�
��� ��*� ) �,i� +Y�� '9�!� �� �<)� y��4� ._+%9 �� ) �%?9 �� '�@�� X�2!9 ��!(
� .'(�� .%(�� � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 �+� ./��� �?J X�!� �� ��� ��� �
��� �� �<)� y��4� �<�� �+��� F!r9 +Y�� �r� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 ) �<)� y��4�
X�2!9 �� Y�%� �<)� y��4� ��59@ �<!$r� C� ��$%&� .� .1!� �� ) ���� �� & � �!"#
�2� � ��!� F�)� �- � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 ;1!� �%?9 �� '�@��
.�2� F'�� J
�� �2� � ��!� F�)� �- ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � ��$%&� X�!� ��� .1�� +P%� +Y��
F'�@ �2'� ._+%9 ��� .�2� �����*� d+9 ����@ ��r< .� ) �,i� C�)� !DE �� �!"#
��!� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ��$%&� ���� .1�� A��d� .# �2� ��� I9�+�
>�9�2!9 .� �2� ��� .�2� F�� ���� � �!"# ��� �� ���$%&� '(� G�2� � �?J X�!�
F��59 �+?+# �!,5� ) {!�� ��_�� k� - �� ��$%&� X�!� ��� ��d9)�� '(� �� !I<���
./2�)�� .. ) ��# \�_9� �0: � +J��� >� Y� �!,5� ��u!<!�O� ) A9�� ��B��� ���!� '9�
.'(�� .%(�� �,i� +Y�� '+<!� '(� � �� �!"# ���$%&� ��%a�2 .� .1!� �� I�� g - ��
) ������) � $� ��!� �+�|0 ) .+<)� ��!� .� �59@ 'T �� A+� �I%V��) ) C�)� !DE
A �# .� �2� �O0� ��$%&� ���� .1�� A��d� �>����R .� �,V9 >����) %*� 2 '(�
�� ���� .�!( _�� ���$%&� '(� A �# ._+%9 �� ) ���_� �� ��� ��$%&� X�!� ��� � '9�!�
.'(�� .%(�� �� �� �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9
F'( ��)@ � �� !I<� \�0� �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � �<�� .*2!� ja�( +Y��
X�"9 F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� .�2� �����*� d+9 ����@ ��r< .� ) �?�� �2� ��� F'� �
�� >�V2!� ) � ��59 %"+� .c .*2!� .# N%V+2 ��@��# A��d� �7# �!- .� ) �<
�� �<�� .*2!� .�2� Y!� �%?9 �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 A �# �� �<��
122 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
X!|0 �7��!E k� -<!�+' �� 2�. � �� \�_9� �� 2�.��J�� � ��O0� �J@� X���
F����� �� 2�.��J�� ����_ ��+.� ;2��� >��_� ) �|0 +� '�� �� ��CV ) .�
J��#+ � ;2��� f� � ��'9� ��'9�!� P%� >�9�2!9 A �# ��+� � ��$%&� XW#� �� )
%9+._ ��$%&� '(�� .'(�� Y!�
:�; P%�+ 7��*�� <�� .*2!�� 9 �?9 .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 )+d ��)� !I<�� ��)@ �
?�� F'(� ���@ ��r< .� )� �����*� �2� .�����*�� ��� :�; X�"9F'� � ��� ��2 .#
<�� .*2!�� � �!"# ��� - C�)� !DE� 2� � ��!� F�)�� '*� ;1!��S ./��� >�9�2!9
��$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � �?9 .<��,�� � ���� .�2� F'( � �!"#�� .� .1!�!I<�� ��)@ �
F'( G�2� � ) P�++>� ��$%&� '(� X�2!9� P� .� �,V9++>� X�2!9 ,� ./����?9 .<��
� �!"# ��� C�)� !DE )9:;<�9:;=�= = �� + ����� .<��,� ./��� X�2!9 �?J X�!� �� �(
�2� .%(�� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 A��d� � �,i� +Y�� F'( ��)@ � >e��*� \�0� �� �?9
.*2!� .1�� .� .%V� ) '( ' �!a �,i� +Y�� ��� A �# ZE�� �<�� .*2!� �<)� �I%�
�� �� �!"# �<�� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � �%?9 �� '�@�� �!) X�2!9 �"��d� +Y
�� .%2�#)q! ) �I+��� � .*<�/� �� SR�T U��%9 �� F'�@ �2� .� ._+%9 ��� .�!(2016 (
'(� >�9�2!9 � ���$%&� �� +P%� q!( +Y�� S�'*� �� �<�� .*2!� AB9 � ��,�
.�2� ��J��2 d+9 ���$%&�
�7��*� +P%� +Y�� �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � �<�� .*2!� ) \�!� X�2!9
��!� F�)� �- � �!"# ��� �� �<�� .*2!� .# �2� ��� I9�+� ) �,i� d+9 C�)� !DE
;�� : '�c �2� F�!,9 ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � \�!� � 9 X�2!9 A �# .� ���& �2� �
.'�%V+9 �����*� ����@ ��r< .� F'�@ �2� .�
5. !��B� Z%��� �\]I
�%?9 �� '�@�� X�2!9 +Y�� �2� � A )H� ��� �� �7R� g' �'�� J #3 .# �!/9�0
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 123
_____________________________________________________________________________________
!DE �� �!"# �� ./��� ��� �� �<�� .*2!� AB9 ) ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 � (�?9 �� ?9)
��� �� �?9 .<��,� ./��� �� �(�9 X�2!9 +Y�� �A )H� U��%9 .� .1!� �� .�2� C�)�
�9��� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� '(� >�9�2!9 � A )H�2016-2005
��� ) �2� �����*� ) �,i��+2) X�2!9 �%?9 ����� ����� �� �!"# .# �� .+: �� � �
���$%&� '(� � 9 ���� .� _� X�(�� '+mt� �'��#� _� U��%9 .� .1!� �� �+�|0 .'�# ��
'(� X�2!9 � ����� �!) �� �(�9 X�2!9 A �# � �<�� .*2!� �,i� +Y�� �� �' �!(
� ��!� F�)� �- C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� ���$%&� N%V+2 C� ��� ���� .���� �!1) �2�
�� ���# �<�� ��� �� �� ���$%&� '(� � �%?9 �� '�@�� �!) �?�� X�2!9 �� �"4� '9�!�
.'��09 X� ,1 � �!"#
+Y�� �+�|0 ) ���$%&� '(� X�2!9 A��d� �� �<)� y��4� �,i� +Y�� .� .1!� ��
.<��,� ./��� X�2!9 ./��� �� �<�� .*2!� �,i� �<)� ����$%&� '(� ) �?9�� � � '�9�!
�2�+2 h�0E� �� �� ) @��# �<�� N%V+2 C� ��_�� .�+�� ��<�� ) �� .1�!� ;2��� ��
A �# k� - �� .% "+� ) @��# �<�� N%V+2 .'���09 N � �� %"+� �<�� ��,89� ._+%9
F�I�� �9��+0-��9�� o!2 ) �<)� ��,%E� A��d� ) � ��!9�a ) � .� �%?9 �� '�@�� X�
�+<�* �02F 5� �� �� �� ���$%&� '(� � �%?9 �� '�@�� �,i� >� +Y�� �e�� ��)
�� A��d� ���$%&� '(� � �%?9 �� '�@�� �� SR�T X�2!9 �?�� +Y�� .� .1!� �� .' �
�) �� SR�T �� '�@�� '��� � �!"# ��� �� �<�� N%V+2 �C�)� !DE �� �!"# ��
���� �%2�� ��� �� .' � o!2 %"+� '+<!� ) '<!� ���J .��� 2 �02 .� �� (�?9)�
./2�) �����# A��d� ZE�� .# '��# h�0E� �� ��� �2�+2 '��� ���$%&� X���I%2�+2
J � C9�� .701 �� �<�� �� �01 +89 �����'&� h�i� �� � .�� ;2��� >�EW-� ��)@
��/E� ) X�J'9 +J \�) ��!� ��Fu) � G�2� � >W+5V�j+$4� ��'+<!� �� ,%E� >���
.��� 2 .� �O9�����J X���J F� �2 �� �9!9�& ���0T A��d� ��� h�P%(� ) ����� �� ��
�� �<�� >�V2!� ) � C9�� �� ���J F� �2 .� �59@ k�!"� ) �+?+# A��d� �� '9�!�
124 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
.# C�)� !DE �� �!"# �� �<�� >�V2!� ) � C9���� N%V+2 �� �08E� A4�59@ �< �
C9�� ���� S+O"� � .'(�� Y!� �'� �
X$�6�
- Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S. (2005). Unbundling institutions. Journal of
Political Economy.113(5), 949–995.
- Adeniy, O., Abimbola, O., Omisakin, O. & Egwaikhide, F. (2015). Financial
development and economic growth in Nigeria: Evidence from threshold
modelling. Economic Analysis and Policy, 47, 11–21
- Arellano, M., Bond, S. (1991). Some tests of specification for panel data:
Monte Carlo evidence and an application to employment equations. Review of Economic Study, 58(2), 277–297.
- Arellano, M., Bover, O. (1995). Another look at the instrumental variable
estimation of error-components models. Journal of Economics, 68(1), 29–51.
- Arezki, R., vander Ploeg, F. (2011). Do natural resources depress income
per-capita? Review Development Economics, 15, 504–521.
- Asadi, Z., Bahrami, J. & Taleblo, R. (2013). Effect of resource curse on financial development and economic growth in the form of dynamic panel
data model. Quarterly Journal of Economic Growth and Development,3(10)
(In Persian). - Asari, A., Naseri, A. & Aghaei, M. (2008). Financial development and
economic growth: comparing OPEC and non-OPEC developing countries.
Quarterly Journal of Economic Research, 43 (82), 141-161 (In Persian). - Baltagi, B. (2005). Econometric Analysis of Panel Data, Third edition, John
Wiley & Sons Ltd, London.
- Beck, T. (2011). Finance and oil: is there a resource curse in financial
development? European Banking Center Discussion Paper, 2011–004.
- Beck, T., Lundberg, M. & Majnoni, G. (2006). Financial intermediary
development tends growth volatility: do intermediaries dampen or magnify
shocks? Journal of international money & finance, 25(7), 1146–1167.
- Behbodi, D. & Asgharpor, H. & Mahalgo, N. (2012). The Role of
institutional quality on the relationship between natural resources and economic growth in petroleum economies. Quarterly Journal of Economic
Research and Policy, 62, 95-116 (In Persian).
- Brückner, M. (2010). Natural resource dependence, non-tradable, and economic growth. Journal of Comparative Economics, 38(4),461–471.
- Bittencourt, M. (2012). Financial development and economic growth in
Latin America: is Schumpeter, right? Journal of Policy Modeling, 34, 341–355.
- Blundell, R., Bond, S. (1998). Initial conditions and moment restrictions in
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 125
_____________________________________________________________________________________
dynamic panel data models. Journal of Economics, 87(1), 115–143.
- Bongini, P., Trivellato, P. & Zenga, M., (2016). Financial Literacy and Undergraduates. Application of Latent Regression Rasch Model. Journal of
Financial Management, Markets and Institutions, 3(1), 13-30
- Bound, J., Jaeger, D.A., Baker, R.M. (1995). Problems with instrumental
variables estimation when the correlation between the instruments and the
endogenous explanatory variable is weak. Journal of the American Statistical
Association, 90(430),443–450.
- Chudika, A., Pesaran, M. (2015). Common correlated effects estimation of
heterogeneous dynamic panel data models with weakly exogenous repressors.
Journal of Econometrics, 188(2), 393-420. - Durusu-Ciftci. D, Ispir, M. & Serdar, Yetkiner. H. (2016). Financial
development and economic growth: Some theory and more evidence. Journal
of Policy Modeling, In Press, Corrected Proof. - Ehsani, M., Karimi, S. & Jafarisamimi, A. (2016). The Impact of Public
Expenditures Reallocation on Long-Run Economic Growth in Iran. Journal
of Economics and Modeling, 28(7), 55-84
- Elhannani, F., Boussalem, A. & Benbouziane, M. (2016). Financial
development and the oil curse: Evidence from Algeria. Topics in Middle
Eastern and North African Economies, 18(1).
- Farooq, A., Shahbaz, M., Arouri, M. & Teulon, F. (2013). Does corruption
impede economic growth in Pakistan? Economic Modeling, 35(0), 622–633.
- Gerelmaa, L., Kotani, K. (2016). Further investigation of natural resources
and economic growth: Do natural resources depress economic growth? Resources Policy, 50, 312–321.
- Gylfason, T., Zoega, G. (2006). Natural resources and economic growth: the
role of investment. World Economy, 29, 1091–1115.
- Hassan, M.K., Sanchez, B. & Yu, J.S. (2011). Financial development and
economic growth: new evidence from panel data. The Quarterly Review of
Economics and Finance, 51 (1), 88–104.
- Hattendorff, C. (2013). The Natural Resource Curse Revisited: Is There a
Financial Channel? Economic Development and Technological Change, D10-
V3. - Hsiao, C. (1986). Panel Data Analysis - Advantages and Challenges.
Sociedad de Estadistica e Investigaci on Operativa, 00(0), 1–63.
- Morad beige, M., Hook Law, S. (2016). Growth volatility and resource curse: Does financial development dampen the oil shocks. Journal of resources
policy, 48, 97-103.
- Islam, M. (1995). Growth Empirics: A Panel Data Approach. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(4), 1127–1170.
- Kaouther Gazdar., Kabir, H,. (2016). Oil price volatility, Islamic, and
Economic Growth in GCC countries, Public Policy Discussion Paper, Federal
Reserve bank of Boston. 04-6
126 �,$ -7�� 8 �0� -9�� 7�� -)���:�� � ������ ;��6*�21398
_____________________________________________________________________________________
- Kurronen, S. (2015). Natural resources and capital structure. BOFIT
Discussion Papers 10/2016. - Makian, S. N. A., Ezadi, M. (2015). The investigation the relationship
between financial development and economic growth. Quarterly Journal of
Iranian Economic Research, 20(62) (In Persian).
- Ouoba, Y. (2016). Natural resources: Funds and economic performance of
resource-rich countries, Resources Policy, 50, 108–116
- Pesaran, M. (2004). General diagnostic tests for cross section dependence in
panels. Discussion Paper No. 1240.
- Rachdia, H., Saidib, H. (2016). Democracy and Economic Growth: Evidence
in MENA countries. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 191, 616 – 621.
- Raghuram, G., Rajan, Zingales, L. (2003). The great reversals: the politics
of financial development in the twentieth centur. Journal of Financial Economics, 69 (11) 5–50.
- Ramez, A. Lean, H. Smythb, R. (2016). Oil curse and finance–growth nexus
in Malaysia: The role of investment. Energy Economics 57, 154–165.
- Rezai, M., Yavari, K., Ezati, M. & Etesami, M. (2015). The investigation of
Frequency of natural resources (oil and gas) on financial repression and
economic growth from channel affecting income distribution. Quarterly
Journal of Iranian Economic Energy. 4(14), 89-122 (In Persian).
- Sachs, J.D., Warner, A.M. (1999). The big push, natural resource booms and
growth. Journal of Development Economics, 59 (1), 43–76.
- Sachs, J.D., Warner, A.M., (2001). The curse of natural resources. European Economic Review, 45, 827–838.
- Sarmidi, T., Hook, L.S., Jafari, J. (2013). Resource Curse: New Evidence on
the Role of Institutions. International Economic Journal, MPRA Paper, 37206,
posted 9.
- Shahabadi, A., Sadghi, H. (2013). Comparison of the effect of Frequency of
natural resources on economic growth in Iran and Norway. Quarterly Journal
of Economic Modeling. 7(2), 21-43 (In Persian).
- Soltani, B., Amiri, B. (2009). Financial development and economic growth
in case of developing countries. Quarterly Journal of Quantitative Economy (former Economic Investigations). 6(4) (In Persian).
- Spatafora, N., Tytell, I., (2009). Commodity Terms of Trade: The History of
Booms and Busts. IMF Working Paper No. 09/205. - Van der Ploeg, F., &Poelhekke, S. (2010). The pungent smell of "red
herrings": Subsoil assets, rents, volatility and the resource curse. Journal of
Environmental Economics and Management, 60(1), 44-55. - Vander Ploeg, F., Poelhekke, S. (2009). Volatility and the Natural Resource
Curse. Oxford Economic Papers, 61(4), 727–760.
- Yanikkaya, Halit,. (2003). Trade openness and economic growth: a cross-
country empirical investigation, Journal of Development Economics, 7257– 9.
� ����� � ������ �� �����...���� �� �� ��� � ���� ����� 127
_____________________________________________________________________________________
- Yavari, K., Rezagholizadeh, M. & Aghaei, M. (2011). The investigation of
economic growth in countries related to natural resources (with emphasis on oil resources). Quarterly Journal of Economic Modeling. 3(5), 25-64 (In
Persian).
- Yuxiang, K., Chen, Z. (2011), Resource abundance and financial
development: Evidence from China, Resources Policy, 36, 72–79.