TURIIN ONOL


3/75

3

,

,

, 2002 .

. . , , . , , , , ,

. , ,

, .

( , ) . , .

. , , , . , 100 , , . .

, ,

. , . , .

2003 , , , . :

,

. ,

. .

", "

.

", "

.


4/75

4

(Sc.D), , , ,

. 50 , . , , , .

- , , , .

, 20 . . . .

, , , ,

.

- - - , - - . , 6, , 15

, ,

.

- . , 5 . .

, .


5/75

5

, , . , , . , . , , .

90- , . , , . - .

, , . . , , . , . , .

, , , , . , , , , .

XX - , - , . , Rule of Law- . . 90- - , , , .

. , . .

, , , .

- ,

omop (JSD), oop (PhD),.


6/75

6

3

4

5

71. 102. 263. 354.

I .

381. , 402. 423. 1. ? ? 44 , 444. 2. , ,

? 46 , 475. 496. 3. 51 527. 4. 54 558. 569. , 5810. 5. 60

II. . 6211. , 6412. 6. Rule of law & rule law 65 , 6613. 7. 68 6914. 8. 71 7215.

74


7/75

7

1.

: : : 2 : 40 /-24, -16/ : I

: : , , , , ; ,

, , , ; .

: , , , , , , . : , , ,

, , , , /Rule of law/, , .

: , . ,

.: 60 /, , /, / 500 3 /, /20 /- . 40 .

:

, , ,

, ,


8/75

8

, , , ,

, , , /, , .../ , , .

,

1.

I.

1.

2

1. 2. 3.

22. ,

3.

2

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. , , 6.

2

4. , , 2

5. 6.

2

1. 2. /de facto, de

jure/3. , ,4. 5. 6.

2

7.

21. - 2. , 3.

28.

2

9.

2

1. 2. , 3. : ,

4.

2

10.

2


9/75

9

2.

II.

11.

2 1. 2. 3. Rule of law Rule by law4.

12. ,

2

13. ,

21. 2.

14.

2 1. 2. 3.

4. 5.

III. :

2

24 16


10/75

10

2.

1 .

: , ,

1.

: , , , .

, JusLex

, . , , . , .

. /Basic norm/ . .

, , .

?- ?, ? - ? - ? ? , -

? ?- ?


11/75

11

. .. ., 2006.1-5 .1. . .. ., 1998.2.

, .3. .. ., 002.4. . .. ., 20025.. .. ., 2005.6.

2.

: , , , , , .

PolisCivitasImperiumRegnumStateDemokrats

Respublec

, : / / . .

, , , / , , , - , - , -, ./.

: , , ,

-, .. : , , , - , ..


12/75

12

? - ? ? - ? ? . ? 2 - ? .

. . ., 2004.1. . .. ., 2006. 6-23 .2.

. . ., 1903.3.The Western Idea of law. S.C.Smith, Darid N. Weisstub. Buttermorths. 1983.4.

: .

. /, , , ./.

: .

: - . , .

,

, .

3. / /

: , , .

Rule by lawRule of law


13/75

13

. - .

? ? - ?

. .. ., 2006.18-23 .1. . .. ., 2004.2. . . ., 1903.3.

. .. ., 2005.4. . . .5.., 2000.

, , , , . , , , , , , .

. , , . / ,

, , , , /. .

4. , ,

: , , , .


14/75

14

,

, , - ? ? ? ?- ?- . , -. ? ? - ? . , , - .

. .. ., 2006. 37-48 .1. . . ., 1903.2. . .. ., 1998.3.. ... ., 1999.4.

5.

: , , , , , , 1992 .


15/75

15

- ? ? . ? ?- ? . - - ? - ?

: ,

, de facto, de jure- . , , , , .

: , .

, .

: , , , .

. .. ., 2006.77-104 .1. . .. ., 1998.2.Service . Origins of the State and Civilization. N.Y.: Norton, 19253. . . ., 1903.4.

6.

: , , , , , .


16/75

16

, , , , . , , . . , .

/ , , , , , /.

/ , , /.

, /, , , , , , /.

, / , , , , , , , , ./.

. , ,- .

? ?- ?- ? ,- ?

. .. ., 2006. 105-124 .1.

, . .. .,2.2003. . .. ., 2002. IV .3.


17/75

17

4. . .. ., 1990.5. Cicvil Society and Political Theory, The mit Press. Cambridge.

Massachusetts and London. England. 1992.

7.

: , , , .

, , . : , ,

, , , .

: , ,, , . , , .

- ? .

- ? -? .

. .. ., 2006. 149-160 .1. . .. ., 1998.2.

. ..3. ..// . ., 2004.


18/75

18

8.

: , , , .

.

, . : , , , /

, , /.

: , , /

, /.

, - ? - . ?

. .. ., 2006. 161-166 .1. . . ., 1903.2.

9.

: , ,

, , , , .


19/75

19

, - ?.

. .. ., 1998.1. . .. ., 2006.161-166 .2. . ... ., 1994.3. . .. ., 2004.4.

, , . , .

10.

: , , , , , , , , .

,


20/75

20

, , / ,

- , - /. . : /

, , , , /.

: / , , /. , , . .

. : , ,

. , , , .

: , , , .

. , , / /.

, , . .

, - ? . ?- ? - ? -? , -

. ?-

. .. ., 2006.171-201 .1. . . ., 1903.2. . .. ., 1908.3.. ... ., 1999.4.

. . .5.., 1994. . ., .. ., 1995.6.


21/75

21

.

: .

11.

: , , , , , , .

, - ?

?- - ? ? - ? ,- ?

// . . .. ., 1955.1. . .. ., 1998.2. . . ., 20023.

/check and balance/

, , , , .

. , : , , , ,, . .


22/75

22

4. / /. ., 2005.5. , . .. .,

2002. 123-133 .6. . .. ., 2006. 203-217 .

12. ,

: , , , , , .

,- . Rule of law, Rule by law ? ? - ? , - ?

Nulla poena sine lege - ? , , - ?

, ,"Rule of law" "Rechsstaat" , , , "Rule of law" "Rule by law" , .

: /1/ , /2/ , /3/ , /4/ , /5/ , /6/ , .


23/75

23

. .. ., 2006. 218-237 .1. . .,2.

.. . 1994.The Rule of law. Edited by Josef Thesing. 1997.3. : . . .,4.2005.The Morality of Law, New Heaven. Rerised edition. Yale Unirersity Press.5.1964.

?- ... - ? ?- - ? - ?

13. ,

: , , , , , , , .

, , . , . , , . , .

: , , .


24/75

24

. .. ., 2006. 239-247 .1., . ..2.

.,2003. II . . .-. ., 20033.The Rule of law. Edited by Josef Thesing. 1997.4.

, ? - ? - ? ?- , -? - -

? - .

14.

: , , , , .

. , . , , .

. . .


25/75

25

. .. ., 2006. 263-274 .1., . .. .,2.

2003. V .

- ? - ? - ? ? , - ?

15. :

: , , , .

, , , , , , , .

, , , , , .

. .. ., 2006. 249-262 .1., . .. .,2.2003. III .


26/75

26

3.

, , . , , , , ,

,

/Lecture/ .

.

, ,

, . ,, , , , , .

:

, , .

25 70 .

/Jacksaw/

. , .


27/75

27

, , , , .

, . . "" , .

/Socrats Talk/ ,

. , .

, , , . , , , .

, , , . ,

. , , , .

/Each one teach one/ , ,

. ,

.

, .

: , , . . ,, . , . . ,


28/75

28

. , .

,

, , .

, , .

,

/Abstract example/ -

, , , .

, , , , .

: . , . . , , , . . , , , , , . . . . , . . , , .


29/75

29

/Case method/

. , , , , , , , .

, , .

, ,

, .:

, , , , . .

, , ,

.

? , . . , , . , .

, , , , , .

: . . . , //- . . , .


30/75

30

, , , , . . , ,

. . . , , . . , , , .

20- , . / , , /,, . .

: .

, , , , , , ,

:

. .

, . , . :

, 1.. . , ,

, . . / 2.


31/75

31

/- , . .

3. . .

.

/ / ?- , ?- , -

? , , -

.

. , .

, . .

.

, , . .

, .

, ,

, , , , .

, , , , , .

, , . / , / .

.


32/75

32

. .

, , , , . .

, ? ? ? ? , ? , ?

, , , , . , , , , , .

, , , ,

. , , , , .

, . . . ? ? ? ? , .

, . , . , . .

, . , ?

? ? ? ? , ? .


33/75

33

: , .

,

:

. , .

: . . , . . . . , .

. . .

:

" 1. ", " ", " "," ", " " " ","", "", " "

. 2..

1. . . 2. . 3. . .


34/75

34

4. .

, :

, , , , . , , . , , , .

, .

, .

1. :/

: , ,

: :

. . , . . : , , . , . , , .

/

: , , .

:

. . .

, .


35/75

35

2.

: , , ,

: , , .

:

. , , . ,

. . , . , , .

3.

, .

: .

:

. . . .

. , , .

4.

,

. .


36/75

36

: -

, -

.-

, , . .

. . , , .

. , , , , .

, , , ,

, , , .

/, , , / , ,

, , , , , , ,


37/75


38/75

38

I .

1.

, , .

.

,

, ,

. , , . ,

, . .

, " ", " ", "" , , , , , .

. , , . , , , , , , , .

, . , , , , , , , , ,, .

,

(Basic Norm) . , . (Basic Law)-r , .


39/75

39

, , , , .

.

, , , .

. ? ? ?

, :1.a.

b. c. d.

:2.a.

b. c.

d.


40/75

40

2. ,

, , , , .

, ,

.

. . , ,

. , , . :

, , , ,1. , ,2. , , .3.

,

. , () . , .

, , , , ( ) . . " , "civitas"

(any independent community)- . "common wealth" " . ,, , , .

. ,

, . ,


41/75

41

( , , ) . . " , ,

. (civitas) " .

. . .

IX , XX . .

? .

? ? ?

:1.a.

b. c. d.

2.20 ?

. b. c. d.


42/75

42

3.

.

.

: , 1. ;

, 2. ; ;3. , , , 4. .

, , .

, , . , . , , , , , .

, . " - " " - " . , .

, ,

. , .


43/75

43

IX , . , .

.

= ?. ? ?

1. .

. . , c.

d.

2. ? . . b. . c. . d. .

3..

b. c. d.


44/75

44

1. ? ?

, 1. , .

.

.. ...

.. " " ?

. 1215 ,2.1628 , 1679 , 1689

.

?

?

39 1-: " 3., " ? ?

1) 2) 3) 4)

4. , ,

, .

. , ( ) .


45/75

45

.

, , , , (, )

, . ( ,

, ) . " " .

. . :

, 1., 2., ,3. , ,,4. ( ) ,5. , .6.

.

( , , ) , , , .

,

. . .

" " .


46/75

46

. , .

, ., , .

? , ?

.1.a.

b. c. d.

2.a.

b. - c. d.

2. , , ?

,

. .

1.

1.

2.

2.


47/75

47

5. ,

. .

.

, , , , .

" . , , , ,

. ,

3. ,

,

,

,

, ,,

,

, .

3.

1) 2)

3) , ,


48/75

48

, , &, . ,

, .

. , (),, , , ( ). , , , . ,

" " .

, . . "" , , , , , , , , , , , , .

, .

, DE JURE . . DE JURE , . DE FAC-

TO . , AD HOC .


49/75

49

,

. : - -, - -

. , , (

, , ) .

= ? ?1924 , . ?

6.

, . .

. ,

...

, , .

Civicus ( )

?

, , , . , .

, , , , . - , , .


50/75

50

-

, , , , . , , , , , , . , , , ,, , , .

- ,

, , , , .

-

, , , , , , , , , , , .

-

, , , , , , .

-

, , , , , .

- , ,

. ( ) .

(1992)

. , ,, , , .


51/75

51

3.

. ?

- . ?

, .? - . ? - . ? . ? . ? - . ? ?

.

?

. ? ?

12- . 7.7- " "." , "

7.1.3- " , , "." " 6.2.1 " , ".

? ? ?

1) . , .

2) .


52/75

52

7.

,

, , . , , .

, .

-

. : . 1. .

a. . b. .

c. . .2. .3. .4.

, .

- ( , , ) . , . , .

- (), ( ),


53/75

53

. , .

.

. :

, 1. . ,2. , , . , 3. .

.

. , . , .

"" , "" .

. , . , .

. px

, , .

. , (, ) , , .

, ? , ? 20 , px ?

:1.a. ,

b. , c. , d. ,


54/75

54

4.

.

, 1..

a. . .

b. . c. , d.

, ?2..

b. c. d.

1. 2.

.

, .

, .

.

.

.

, . .

(, ) .

, .

.

.

:(1) (, ), (2)

( , , , , , , ),(3) (,, , , , , , , ), (4)


55/75


56/75

56

- . .

()- .

. , . .

- , . , ,, .

- , , ( , ) . , , . .

, . . . ?

9.

, , .

, , , , .

.1.

.2. , ( ) , 3..


57/75

57

4. , , , .

5. .

6. , , .

7. , , .

, .

, , , ,

, .

:

1. . , 2. . , (3.

) , . .4. , .5. , , .6. , , 7. , , ,, .

. ( , ,, , ), ( , ), ( ) .

?1.a.

b. c. d. ,


58/75

58

10. ,

Tp - . , ,

. , . , .

, . , , , , .

,

, , , , "" .

. , (1) ; (2) , , ;(3) , ; (4) , , .

2. ? a. , ,

b. , , c. , , d. , , ,

3. , , :

a. b. c.

d.

4. - : a. b. c. d. ,


59/75

59

. , , , ,, . ,

, .

,

, , , , . , , , , . ,, .

,

,

. , .

,

. 47- 1- " " . . , , , , , .

, , .


60/75

60

.

.

" , " 55 :55.1. , , ,

.

55.2. , , , , .

55.3. , , , .

55.4. .

, , ,

"" 1.

- ? ?

? ? ?

:1.a.

b. c. d.

:2.a.

b. c. m d.

1 , . .., 2006. 26-27


61/75

61

.

.

, .

. , .

. ,

.

1) , 2)


62/75

62

II.

11.

,

...

, ... ,

. , ,

. .

.

,

. , . , . , , . ,

.

, . , , , . , .

, . .


63/75

63

, , .

, , . , , .

, ,

, . , , .

, , .

.

? ? ? ? ?


64/75

64

12. ,

. .

. ?

, , , . . 17, .

Rule of Law Rule by Law

"Rule of Lw" "Rule by Law"-ooc ."Rule by Law . . . . , . "Rule by Law"-rooc "Rule ofLaw" .

, px acaax . " . . , " . " , " .

. , , . 1870

"GOVERNMENT OF LAWS, NOT OF MEN" " , " , .

,

, 1885 . .:

, . .

, . .


65/75

65

, ., .

.

, . , . . .

.

? , ? , .

?

6.RuleofLaw&RulebyLaw

.

Rule of law Rule by law

()

,


66/75

66

. . .

. ( )

13. ,

.

, , . XIX . . " , ,

. " .

(1942 ), 1949 - , .

, ( , , , , , , ) ,, , , .

1) Rule of law, Rule by law . 1960,1992 .

2) Rule of law- , .


67/75

67

, , .

. ( ) .

(, , , , )

. ,, . , , , , " " .

. , , , ,

.

" " ? ? ?

?1.a.

b. c.

d.


68/75

68

( )2.a.

b. c. d. ,

?3.a. .

b. . c. . d. .

7.

.

,

, ,

,

, ,

,


69/75

69

1) 2)

3) , 4)

. , .

14.

, . ( V )

- , , .

, . . , .

, . .

,

, , , , , , , . , ,

, , , .

. , , . , , .

, , ,

. . .


70/75

70

: -

( XII ); (1206-1368);- (1368-1757);- (1911-1924).-

, , , 1992 ,

, . , , , , , .

, ? ? ?

1992 ?

, ?1.a. ,

b. ,

c. d.

?2.a.

b. c. d.


71/75

71

1) ,

2) , 3)

4)

8.

.

. .

,

,

,

-

,

,

(III-II)

, (III-)

,

(XX - ) , (1990 )


72/75

72

15.

- , , ,

(- ) ,

. ( )

() V . . . . , , .

. , , .

, . , , .

. , . , . ,

, .


73/75

73

... .1.a.

b. c. d.

"Laissez - faire" ?2. a. b. c. d.

, :3.a.

b. c.

d.

. " ". , . , .

? ? ?

? . . ? ? . , ? . .


74/75

74

:

:

., , . , , , 20041. , , . - , , 20032. , , , , 20033. , . ,4.. , , 2000 , , . , , 20025. , , . , , 20046. , , , 20017. , , , , 20048. , , 9.

, , 2002 , , , 199810.. . . . .,11.., ., 2007

:

., , , , 19941. , , 2., , 1994 , , 2- , . 2. , 19923. , , , 19564. , , , , 20005. ., , , 20046. , , , 19557. ., , , 20008., , , , , , 19999. ., , , 200010. , , 198411.

., , . 1, , 199512.

:

Cohen Jean L, Aroto Andrew, Civil Society and Political Theory, The IT Press,1.Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England, 1992Cormick D.Neil Mac, Rechtsstaat and Rule of law, The Rule of law, Edited by2.Josef Thesing,1997Dahl R.A, On Democracy, Yale University, Press, New & London3.Freeman M.D.A, Introduction to Jurisprudence, London, 20014.

Fuller L, The Morality of Law, New Heaven, Revised edition, Yale University5.press, 1964Hobbs Thomas, Leviathan, ch. XXVI6.


75/75

Locke John, The Second Treatise on Government (1690), Indianapolis: Naskett,7.1980, chap. 7Lundendorj N, Common and unique features of Eastern and Western states, Cen-8.tre for Asian and Pacic Law in the University of Sydney, Oct. Edition, 1996, N 5

Montesquieu, The Spirit of the laws, 1748, N.Y narpers,1949, I (3)9.Nozic R, Anarchy, State and Utopia, Basil Blacwell, Oxford, 197410.Oxford Dictionary of Law, Edited by Elizabeth A. Martin, Oxford University11.Press, 2001Service E, Primitive Social Organization, New York, Radmon House, p.103, 132-12.169, Origins of the State and Civilization, N.Y, Norton,Siegan B, Separations of Powers and other Divisions of Authority under the Con-13.stitution, Suffolk University Law Review, 1989, 1

:Mohl R.Von, Enzyklopadie der Staatwissenschaften, 1872,1.Mommsen, bria des remischen Staatsrechts, 18932.Radbruch Gustav, Rechtsvergleichende Schriften, bearbeitet von Heinrich3.Scholler, Miller C.F, Verlag, Heidelberg, 1999Restauration der Staatswissenschaften, I4.Stahl, Staatsrechtstehre auf der Grundlage der christlichen Weltanschaung,5.Heidelberg, 1856

Documents

TURIIN ONOL