신사도운동비평 -...

Preview:

Citation preview

), 1900 , 1970
, 1970
1. 1947, (William M. Branham, 1909-65)
.
(impartation,
) ,
.3)
2. 1982, (Paul Cain, 1929- ), (Mike Bickle),
(Bob Jones, 1930?-2014)4) (KCF=Kansas
City Fellowship) .
3. (John Wimber, 1934-97)5) 80
1) , “ ,”
, 2010 5, 41-61; , “ ,” http://
ikccah.org/NAR/2502; . “I.H.O.P.[]
.” , 2012 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
, 12; 2013 1, 2, 3, 4.
2) , (, 2006), 10; , “
,” http://ikccah.org/NAR/2502 .
3) , “”; , “
-- ,” , 2011 7, 92.
4) .

. , , ,
.6) 1989 ,
, , , ,
.
.7)
(Rodney Howard-Browne), (Randy Clark)
(Toronto Blessing) [ ] .
5. 1995
(John Kilpatrick, 1950?- ; )
2008 (Todd
Bently, 1976?- )(
6. 1999, (IHOP=Inernational House
of Prayer) .
7. (Cindy Jacobs, 1942?- )
5) /(,
Kuhlman, 1907-76), (Oral Roberts, 1918-2009) .
.
6) 1990 LA
2 . , “ ,” http://
christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18280; http://christiantoday.us/sub_
read.html?uid=18283; , 2011. 1. 15. 1990 ,
.
7) ( )
, 2008 10, 39.
8. 2001, (Peter Wagner, 1930-2016)8)
(ICA=International Coalition of Apostles)
(New Apostolic Reformation). “
” .
19001, 1960-70
2, 19803
, 2000 1210)
.
11)
/: (ICA=International Coalition of A-
postles)(), (WLI=Wagner Leadership
Institute), (KCF=Kansas City Fellowship)( ,
, ), (IHOP=International House of Prayer)
(), (), (),
8) (1971-2001) 1998 ‘
’(WLI: Wagner Leadership Institute) .
9) , “ ,” http://ikccah.org/NAR/2502.
10) , , , , ,
, , , , . , “
!,” , 2010 2, 29-30.
11) , “ ”; , “
,” http://christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18280; http://christian-
, 30-61.

(HIM=Harvest International Ministry)( =), The Call(
),12) G-12(, ), (
),13) ( ),14) (CGI)(,
, ), CCC(),15) (),
( ) .
(WLI)- ( , 17)),
12) HIM
, , .
, , . , “
,” http://christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18280; http://
christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18283; , 2011. 1. 15.
14) 15 , 6 , , .
“ ” .
, ‘’ .
, , ,
(, , ; ) .
, , ,
, . , “
,” , 2007 1, 44-66.
15) IHOP
CCC. , “
,” http://christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18280; http://christiantoday.
16) ( )
. , , ,
. , “ !,” ,
2010 2, 28-45.
17) 2007 1
‘2007 ’

(),20) -(),21) , HIM
Korea(), (KHOP)(),
(), ( , ), 24

, , , , , ,
. WLI(). , “
18) , , , . ,
“ !,” , 2010 2, 33.
19)
, ‘
’. . “
, 2012 6, 30-45.
21)
. .
.
. , , , , , ,
. . “ .”
http://christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid=18280; http://christiantoday.us/
, “ (: ) !,”
, 2013 2, 22-45.

(KIBI), (IMN), (,
(, ), (), (
,23) ()(), (),
() . 21
,
, , ,
, , , , ,
, , , , ,
. 1996 3 14,
, , , ,
, , . , “ (?),
!,” , 2008 10, 30-31.
23)
.
. , “,” http://christiantoday.us/sub_
, 2011. 1. 15.
24) , (1) , (2) ,
(3) CCM (4)
, (5) , (6)
. ,
, , .

.
(, ), (, ),
(, ), (, ),
( , )
: , , , , ,
WLI Korea, , , , ,

2000 12 2001
‘’ . “
.
25) , “!,”, 2010
2, 32-33.
!” , 2009 10, 28-43.
, ‘ ,’ ‘
,’ ‘ ,’ ‘
’ .
27) , “, !,”,
2011 7, 35.
. ,
. ,
, .
1983 3,
, .
1999 (IHOP) .
.28)

(, , )
, , ,
, ,” “
, , .30)
2. .
,
( , , ),
. , , ,
, , ,
28) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 8, 86; 2013 1, 81; 3, 95-96.
29) , “, !,”,
2011 7, 46-47.
46, 52.

.32)
34)
35)
,
,36)

.37)

, “
31) , “, !,”,
2011 7, 29-36.
2011 7, 43-45.
33) (one thing) 27:4, “ (one
thing) ”, (, real acts)
. ,
, , (Transformation) .

. , “()
, !,” , 2012 6, 32-34.
34) , “() . . . ,” 36.
35) , “() . . . ,” 38.
36) , “() . . . ,” 41.
37) , “() . . . ,” 42.
38) , “() . . . ,” 44.
.40) ()

’ 42)
.43)
3. .
.
() .44)
,
, , .
. “
. .” “
. , .
. .
39) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 55.
52.
41) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 55, 60.
2, 32.
2011 8, 52.
,” , 2012 7, 85; 10, 94-95.

- 11 -
.”45)



. “
.” “
. ,
.”47) . “

.” “ .”48)
. “ .
.” “ .”49)

‘’ ‘ ’,
.
6:13, “
45) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 43.

.” 1:1, “

.”
( 14:4, 14),
9:1), ( 3:13-14 ;
2:43; 5:12; 12:12).
22:18-19
.
. .
2. ,
.
, , 7
,
. ‘
’ .50) ,
.51)
,” , 2012 7, 81-82.
51) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 11, 68-71.



2007 5 . ,
.52)
, 2007
.53)
.
” .54)

. , 1983 5 “ [] 3
8 23 6 3-4
” ,
, 6 , 8 23 0.32
. “1976, 6
30 ”,

.55)
52) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2013 4, 91-92.
53) , “, !,”,
2011 7, 36.
54) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 58.


.56)
,
, 27 1

.
.57)


18:20-22 . “


56) , “ -- ,”
, 2011 7, 91-92.
, 2011 8, 79-81.
58) , “,”
, 2010 5, 60.
(2) ,
.
( 7:11; 8:7). .
.


( 24:24). 13:13, 15, “[]

,” “
[]” .
3. .
,

() ()
. .
, ,

] , .60)
59) , “ -- ,”
, 2011 7, 92.
60) (United Pentecostal Church)
, .

, “ ,
” .62)
“.

.63) .
.64)

11:17-22.
.
CCM. /
, “I.H.O.P.[] ,”
, 2013 1, 83-84.
61) . “I.H.O.P.[]
.” , 2012 7, 82.
62) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 11, 70.
63) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 57.
64) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 41.
65) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 48-51.


.67)
() .
.
.
. HTM
, ‘ . . . ’
.68)
. .
.
.
()(mapping)
,

, .69)
“ ” “
67) , “, !,”,
2011 7, 31-34; 8, 52.
68) , “(: ) ,” ,
2012 8, 57-58.
2011 8, 54.
.
9,71)
2%
.72) .

.73)
. 3
. 8-90% . . . .
.74) ”
” . .

()
.75)
70) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 9, 82-86.
71) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 8, 87.
72) , “ ,” ,
2007 9, 58.
2011 7, 45.

.76)
, 2
,
,
.77)
.
13:1-5, “


.


. .”
8:20, “
76) , “ . . . ,” 53.
77) , “ . . . ,” 41-42.

16:29, “
.”


.”
.



,

4. .
.
7:15-16, 23, “ .
.

” .

. .

2:10, “ []
.”
,” “
.”
(2) .
1991 , .79)
2004(
2008, .
2016,
.
, .
78) , “ -- ,”
, 2011 7, 90.
,” , 2012 12, 72.
80) , “(: ) ,” ,
2012 9, 64; , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 10, 95-96.

() .”
4, 8, 16, “,”
“ ,” “ .”
(3) .
IHOP
.
.81)
34 .
85 40[ 5] .82)
72
.83)
.
2:3, 14, “
() ,” “ .”
11, 16, “,” “
() .”
,” , 2013 4, 92.
82) Pensacola News Journal; BJU's What in the World.
83) Calvary Contender, 1 December 1998.
84) , “I.H.O.P()

(NAE) (WEA)

18:2, “, , ,

.”
. .

,

,
, ,

.85)
85) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 11, 72-74.
86) , “ ,” http://ikccah.org/NAR/2502.

.87)
, 2007/ ), (1995/),
(1998/ ).
(2000/IHOP
.
), (KAPC)(2012/ ).
: (2009/), (2008/; 2009/
, ), (2009/
), (2010/).
(2011/, ), (2011/, , ),
KAPC(2012/ ).
KAPC(2012/).
87) , “I.H.O.P.[]
,” , 2012 11, 70.


. “ .”
, 2010 5, 41-61.
. “--.”
. “I.H.O.P.[]
.” , 2012 7, 79-85; 8, 82-88; 9,
81-86; 10, 91-96; 11, 68-76; 12, 72-77; 2013
1, 81-89; 2, 83-87; 3, 90-97; 4, 90-96.
(Ph.D, Westminster Theological
Seminary).
) .
. “ .”, 2007 1
, 44-66.

. “ .” , 2012 7,
86-92; 8, 89-95.
2007 9, 40-61.
2008 10, 26-56.
, 2010 4, 30-61.
. “ .” http://ikccah.org/NAR/2502.
. (
com) .
, 2012 8, 38-60; 2012 9, 53-69.
. [] (M.Div.),
(Th.M.), Liberty Seminary(STM), ‘’
(good-faith.net) .
sub_read.html?uid=18280 http://christiantoday.us/sub_read.html?uid
. . GNP Books, 2015.
. . , 2012.
. 3 . , 2014.