Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
23
1 2014
:
(814) :
:
23 1 2014
23 1 2014
23 1 2014
2 .
.
: : : 1992 8 19 : 02048 : : 2014 6 30
(142-728) 419 123() TEL : 02)901-2574, 900-4300FAX : 02)901-2544Homepage : http://www.kinu.or.krE-mail : [email protected]
2014
:
:
: ()
()
()
()
()
()
:
: 10,000ISSN 1229-6112
.
23 1 2014
/ 1
: / 41
(814)
/ 67
:
/ 91
:
/ 129
/ 157
23 1 2014
General ArticlesThe Effects of Work Type in North Korea on North Korean Migrants Employment in
South Korea Wha-Soon Kim
A Feasibility Analysis Regarding Discussion on the Collapse of North Korea and Tasks:
to Recognize and Minimize the Side Effects Hwee-Rhak Park
Evaluation of 814 Agreement and Developmental Improvement of Gaesong Industrial Complex Kook-Yeol Bae
Protection of North Korea Works and Berne Convention Joo-Hyoung Lee
The North Koreas Accommodation of Foreign Cultures and Its Cultural Strategy:
A Focus on the Analysis of North Korean Television Broadcast Mi-Yeong Jeon
A Study on Cognition and Interest toward DPRK among Media Users
Young-Chul Chung, Seok-Jin Lew, Hee-Jung Cho, Hyun-Chin Lim, Tae-Kyoon Kim,
Jong-Won Kim, Han-Na Kim, Hun-A Lee and So-Ra Im
Unification Policy Studies Vol. 23, No. 1, 2014
>>> 1
*
**1
. .
. .
.
,
.
,
,
.
.
(work type)
(employment)
, //
.
413 ,
,
(+)
.
(>>)
.
.
/
.
.
.
,
.
.
: , , ,
, , ,
,
* 2011 ()
(NRF-2011-354-B00042). 2 .
. .
**
23 1 2014pp. 1~40
2
.
1.
?
? 1990 2014
.
. 2000
14 .
, , , ,1
,
.2 ,
(unemployed poor) (working poor)
.
.
3 ,
,
,4 ,
1 2012 12 20 2,355
2013 8 2 ,
141 4000, 56.9%, 90.3%,
51.4% 9.7%. , 2013 , 2013. 2, , 15 2 (, 2010), p. 135. .
,
.
47.0% 3 .
. 3 26 5
. 2007 70% 2010 6
(3S-Net), 54.4%(, 2010. 6. ), 2013 35% . 4, , 2012.1.5.
>>> 3
,
.
(catch-up) .
5
20
.6
,
,
.
(incentive
policy) .
(the
pattern of low efficiency and high expenditure)
?
(work experience)
.
?
,
.
,
5 , , CBS, 2013 11 8. 3 8
(44,) 1 6
1 8 . 11 6 142
50200
. 39 1 6
9 .6 , ,
. 2014 1
21 . . .
,
( 1724 ).
4
.
,
(agent)
,
.7
8
(economic maladaptation)
.
.
,
. .9
,
.
(employment effect)
.
7
. ,
, . 8 (,
: , , 12 2 (, 2005); , , , (: , 2005); , , , 11 3 (, 2008); , : . . (: , 2007); , , ,
2, 71 (: , 2009); , (: , 2012); , 2003 : , , 43 3 (, 2009); , , , , , 46 5 (, 2012); , , 09-16-03 (: , 2009); , 2009 2010 (: , 2009); , (: , 2009); , , , 46 5 (, 2012); , (: , 2010).9S. Castle and M, Miller, The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in
the Modern World, (4th ed.) (New York: The Guilford Press, 2009), p. 20.
>>> 5
(informal work)
. , ,
(work type)
.10
.
(work
type)
.
(One size all fit)
.
() ()
.
.
.
.
, ( , cohort effect) 11
(work experience)
10 , ,
. , , , 22 1 (, 2013).
11 ,
. .
. ,
. George J. Borjas,
Labor Economics, (4th ed.) (Boston: Mc Graw-Hill Press, 2008), pp. 338340 .
6
?
, ( , assimilation effect)
?
.
.
.
2.
.
. 12
,
13
,
.
12
, , . 16 1 (, 2012). 13
, .
>>> 7
:
,
.
,
.
.
1.
. ?
. , ,
( ).
8
.
.
1,073 141.4 (300.0)
, 150 68.1% .14
?
.
(human capital theory)
.
(individual approach) .
(self-selectivity)
. ,
.
.
.
(stigma effect) .15
,
.
.
,16 ,17
18 .
14, 2013 , 2013.12.
15, :
, ( , 2009), pp. 5563.16
, (: , 2003).
17, :
, , 1 2( , 1997).18
, ( , 2003); . (: , 2004).
>>> 9
.19
,
, ,
20 .
2006
1997
400 49.3 41.1 16.8
2007 401 47.9 36.9 22.9
2008 361 49.6 44.9 9.5
20092009. 5. 637 48.6 41.9 13.7
1997 374 54.9 50.2 8.7
20102000 1,200 42.6 38.7 8.8
1997 396 48.0 43.1 10.0
20112010. 12. 19 7,129 56.5 49.7 12.1
1997 394 47.7 41.1 13.8
201219 9.493 54.1 50.0 7.5
1997 403 52.4 41.9 19.9
: (2011), (20062012), (20102012)
.
21
,
,
, (+) .
,
,
. .
19, , , 33().
20, , , 9 1 (, 2007).
21, :
.
10
. : ?
. 2006
74.1% ,
.22
23
, ,
, , .
2010 54% 2011 46.7% 2014 35%
, 2.7%(2012) 14 .
.24
.25
.
. ,
1 (37.7%), (27.1%), 26.3%
.26
. 510
22 2000
. 26
5 ,
1 (
),
. 6 ( ), 6
( ). : 5,
: 3.23
, , , 18 2 (, 2006).
24, :
, , 17 1 (, 2005).25
, .; ,
, (
, 2005); , ,(
, 2011).26
, , p. 144.
>>> 11
27
.
. ?
(assimilation effect)
. 2001
28 . 7
.29
200 106(volunteer)
.
.
,
(quota sampling)
.
2. (informal sector) (informal work)
.
.30
27 , pp. 141142.
28, : 2001 553
, , 7 1 ( , 2003).29
, : 7
, , 17 2 (, 2008).30
, , , 62(2004). , (: , 1994); , (: , 1996); , (: , 1996); , , , (: , 2000); , , , (: , 2000)
. .
12
.
2000 .
(, 200631; , 2004, 2008, 200
932; , 200733) . 2000
.
/
(occupation) 34
.
(formal work))/(informal work))/
(both formal and informal work) ,
.
, . , (: , 2001); . : , , ,( , 1999); ,
, ( , 1996); ,
, ( , 2001); ,
, (2003 , 2003); ,
, (: , 2001). .
.
(, (: , 2004). ,
, : (: , 2000) , 1990
, ( , 2003) .31
, , ( , 2006).32
, : , , 42 (. 2004); , 2000 :
, , 38(2008); , 2003 : .
33, : .
34, .; , .
>>> 13
(work type)
: , , p. 85.
.
/
. /
. ,
,
,
.
, ,
, .
, ,
.
, .
3. (cohort effect) (assimilation effect) :
(cohort effect)
14
(assimilation effect)
,35
(Chiswick) (Borjas) .
.
,
. (Chiswick)
(assimilation effect)
.
.
(cohort effect) (assimilation)
. (Borjas) (Chiswick)
,
36 .
(cohort effect)
(assimilation) .
,
.37
,
.
35Barry R. Chiswick, The Economic Progress of Immigrants: Some Apprarently Universal
Patterns, in William Fellner(ed.), Contemporary Economic Problems (Washington, DC:
American Enterprise Institute, 1979), pp. 357399.36
George J. Borjas, Labor Economics, pp. 336340.37
, :
, pp. 142147.
>>> 15
.
(cohort effect)
.
.
(,
)
,
,
38
39 .
/ (work type) ,
,
, , ,
.
.
1.
,
().
3 ,
, ,
.
38, .
39, .
16
. .
[ ] (work type)
(, ) .
,
.
1. (+)
.
2. (+)
.
3.
(-) .
4. (, ) (+)
.
5. (+)
.
>>> 17
.
.
2.
(work type) , ,
. , , ,
.
.
( )
(work type)
(1), (2), (3).
(4)
(1), (2)
(3), (4)
(1), (2)
()
20002009
3
3
(: )
(1), (0)
(1), (0)
18
.
, , ,
.
(work type)(work type) , ,
, (formal work type)
(informal work type), (both formal and informal work type)
. ,
,
( ).
.
.
(=0), (=1) ,
.
. 1989
2009 20002009 .
.
3 (, ) 3 (=1,
)
>>> 19
.
: . :
, .
: . .
.
(categorical variable), (binary logit analysis)
,
(continous variable), (multiregression analysis)
.
.
2.
413 40
(, , )
. .
4,136 10% 413 , ,
(
). , 20
(34.8%), 30(38.4%) , 50 .
(37.0) .
40 2010
. , , .
20
(raw data)(: )
413
(20002009)
2010.810
/
, 3,
, , ,
413 413
2010.11
(: , , %)
% % %
20 46 34.8 67 23.8 113 27.4
30 36 27.3 108 38.4 144 34.9
40 34 25.8 76 27.0 110 26.6
50 16 12.1 30 10.7 46 11.1
36.73 37.11 36.99
62 47.0 105 37.4 167 40.4
51 38.6 108 38.4 159 38.5
19 14.4 68 24.2 87 21.1
25 18.9 34 12.1 59 14.3
73 55.3 192 68.3 265 64.2
34 25.8 55 19.6 89 21.5
2000 50 37.9 112 39.9 162 39.2
20002004 36 27.3 88 31.3 124 30.0
20052009 46 34.8 81 28.8 127 30.8
20002004 68 51.5 103 36.7 171 41.4
20052009 64 48.5 178 63.3 242 58.6
132 100.0 281 100.0 413 100.0
>>> 21
(=1) 413 .00 1.00 .3196 .46689
() 413 20 59 36.99 9.431
413 1989 2009 2001.79 3.952
413 2000 2009 2005.17 2.584
(=1) 413 .00 1.00 .4044 .49136
413 .00 1.00 .1429 .35035
413 .00 1.00 .2155 .41166
413 .00 1.00 .3898 .48830
413 .00 1.00 .2494 .43319
413 .00 1.00 .0993 .29939
413 .00 1.00 .1332 .34017
413 .00 1.00 .3245 .46874
413 .00 1.00 .3196 .46689
3 () 413 .00 174.00 40.7361 36.55254
3 (=1) 413 .00 1.00 .3656 .48219
413 .00 1.00 .5714 .49547
413 .00 1.00 .5182 .50028
413 .00 1.00 .3632 .48150
413 .00 1.00 .3753 .48479
413 .00 1.00 .1622 .36911
413 .00 1.00 .2034 .40301
413 .00 1.00 .3487 .47713
413 .00 1.00 .6416 .48010
(47.0%) ,
(38.4%) (37.4%)
. (
). 72.9% 10.0%,
, 47.2% 21.0%, 17.2%,
5.1% .
22
. ,
( 55.3%, 68.3%) ,
( 25.8%, 19.6%) 80%
. 2000
( 37.9%, 39.9%) .
, 2004
(51.5%) (48.5%)
, 2005 (63.3%)
.
46.5%(192), 53.5%(221)
7% . (34.7%)
(2.2%) (11.6%) , 34.9%(144)
, 11.6%(48) 3.5
.
.
1.
(, , )
.
, , .
. ,
, , ,
(+) .
.
.
,
, >
>>> 23
.
.
:
0.785 0.223 *** 0.908 0.238 *** 0.853 0.248 ***
0.147 0.12 -0.107 0.139 -0.186 0.146
-0.421 0.244 * -0.219 0.253 -0.193 0.257
0.649 0.43 0.751 0.435 *
1.113 0.489 ** 1.244 0.497 **
0.359 0.383 0.455 0.397
-0.365 0.307 -0.281 0.319
-0.276 0.306 -0.238 0.311
0.729 0.358 ** 0.885 0.367 **
1.06 0.372 *** 1.187 0.38 ***
1.453 0.448 *** 1.614 0.461 ***
3
0.003 0.003
0.009 0.004 **
-1.06 0.346 0.002 -1.863 0.502 0 -2.608 0.591 ***
-2 Log 515.476 486.960 479.963
Cox Snell
R-0.044 0.108 0.123
: 10%, ** 5%, *** 1% .
: , , . , .
24
, 3
. 3 (), ()
,
.
,
.
.
3 . 3
,
(p=0.013
>>> 25
. ,
.
(-) .
:
B Std. Error Beta Sig.
(Constant) 4.393 .190 0.000***
0.311 0.073 0.338 0.000 ***
-0.054 0.047 -0.105 0.254
-0.120 0.082 -0.125 0.146
0.488 0.156 .516 0.002**
0.656 0.165 .654 0.000 ***
-0.124 0.132 -0.134 0.350
0.029 0.131 0.029 0.827
0.028 0.143 0.022 0.843
-0.139 0.114 -0.117 0.227
-0.033 0.098 -0.033 0.737
0.071 0.091 0.072 0.435
3 -0.001 0.001 -0.047 0.571
0.002 .001 0.138 .070*
-0.496 0.088 -0.410 0.000 ***
0.022 0.110 0.025 0.838
-0.235 0.387 -0.044 0.545
R2 0.357
F 5.382***
135
: 10%, ** 5%, *** 1% .
: , , . , .
26
15
. , /
/
.
3.
. 413
.
.
, ,
.
.
,
. ,
.
(-)
.
, 3
.
(-) .
> > .
(-) .
.
>>> 27
:
1
2
3
-0.635 0.215 *** -0.695 0.222 *** -0.591 0.24 ***
-0.08 0.115 0.001 0.132 0.163 0.144
0.18 0.23 0.093 0.237 0.006 0.249
0.083 0.355 -0.156 0.372
-0.003 0.422 -0.285 0.445
-0.234 0.363 -0.433 0.391
0.166 0.285 0.025 0.306
0.167 0.285 0.122 0.299
-0.313 0.322 -0.67 0.345 0.052*
-0.672 0.337 ** -1.001 0.361 0.005***
-0.929 0.419 ** -1.336 0.455 0.003***
3
-0.004 0.003
-0.021 0.004 0.000***
0.602 0.33 0.069 0.736 0.427 0.085 2.397 0.548 0
-2 Log
553.984 545.219 509.209
Cox
Snell
R-
0.024 0.045 0.124
: 10%, ** 5%, *** 1% .
: , , . , .
28
.
1.
. ( ,
cohort effect) ( , assimilation effect)
.
3 .
.
(work
experience)
?.
.
, .
,
. 1
2, 3 .
1. ,
(+) .
2.
(+) .
3.
(-) .
1 (+)
.
>>> 29
(>>) .
, .
, (+)
.
(>>) . ,
,
.
,
. ,
(+) .
,
,
.
.
,
.
4. (, )
(+) .
5. .
(+) .
. (-)
. (+)
, .
2.
,
30
.
,
, .
,
.
413
, ,
(+) .
(>>)
.
.
/
.
(work type)
(employment) ,
//
.
. ,
.
,
.
(One size all fit) .
,
.
.
,
.
>>> 31
,
.
.
.
.
.
. ?
.
.
,
,
.
,
(47.0%), 100
41 .
. (transfer barrier of human
capital) ,
. ,42
41, , pp. 123125.
42
.
.
. ,
, , 2 2 ( , 2010), pp. 106107.
32
()
.
.
.
,
.
.
: 4 20 : 5 15 : 5 21
>>> 33
20 30 40 50
2000 162 90 7218 16 21 27 33 19 18 10
2 2 2 3 3 2 2 1
2001 229 115 11432 22 39 40 31 33 13 19
3 2 4 4 1 9 1 2
2002 439 196 24361 43 58 103 55 67 22 30
6 4 6 10 5 6 2 3
2003 366 134 23248 58 34 78 34 71 18 25
5 6 3 8 3 7 2 2
2004 569 173 39667 79 38 144 49 131 19 42
6 8 4 14 5 13 2 4
2005 368 113 25544 60 24 105 32 71 13 19
4 6 2 10 3 7 1 2
2006 504 126 37848 89 25 173 39 89 14 27
5 9 2 17 4 9 1 3
2007 614 153 46163 121 42 174 36 127 12 39
6 12 4 17 3 12 1 4
2008 465 128 33740 104 39 121 29 85 20 27
4 10 4 12 3 8 2 3
2009 418 109 309 46 98 29 115 26 70 8 26
4,134 1,337 2,7974 10 3 11 3 7 1 3
45 69 34 106 36 80 15 27
20002009 12 31 .
34
(formal work)
:
. , ,
,
.
:
, .
.
(both formal and informal work) =
:
. (both formal and
informal work) , , .
8.3
. 8.3
. ,
.
(informal work)
: .
.
8.3 :
. ,
.43
43, : 2000 , , 14 11 (KDI, 2012.11), p. 83.
>>> 35
.
.
36
1.
. . , 2003.
. . : , 2004.
. . : , 2012.. . : , 2001. . . : , 1996. . . :
, 2011.
. . : , 2009.. . : , 1994. . : . : , 2000. ______. . : , 2010.. . : , 2007. . . : , 1996. .
. : , 2003.. .
09-16-03. : , 2009.
. 2009 2010 . : , 2009.
. . : , 2004. . . : , 1999.
Borjas, George J. Labor Economics. 4th ed. Boston: Mc Graw-Hill Press, 2008.
Castle, S. and Mark J. Miller. The Age of Migration: International Population
Movements in the Modern World. 4th ed. New York: The Guilford Press,
2009.
2.
. . , 2. 71 . : , 2009.
. . . 15 2, 2011. ______. . . 16 1, 2012.
>>> 37
______. . . 22 1, 2013.______. . . 2011.
______. . . 2 2, 2010.
______. :
. , 2009.
. : . . 17 1, 2005.
. .
, 2005.
. 2000 : .
. 38, 2008. ______. 2003 :
. . 43 3, 2009.______. : . .
42, 2004.
______. , , . . 46 5, 2012.. .
, 1996.
. . . 46 5, 2012. . : . . 12
2, 2005.
. : 7
. . 17 2, 2008.. . . 9 1, 2007.. :
. . 1 2, 1997.. . . 33, 1999.. . . 21, 2007.. . .
18 2, 2006.
. : 2000 . . 14 11, 2012.11. ______. 1990
. , 2003.
. . , . : , 2005.. . . :
, 2001.
. : 2001 553
. . 7 1, 2003.. : . ,
38
. : , 2007. ______. . . 62, 2004. . . .
. : , 2000. . . . . :
, 2000.
. : . . . : , 2007.
______. . 2003
, 2003.
. . . 11 3, 2008. ______. : .
. : . : , 2010.______. . 201. 10 2, 2007. ______. : , , .
, 1999.
. . , 2006.
______. .
, 2001.
Chiswick, Barry R. The Economic Progress of Immigrants: Some Apprarently
Universal Patterns. in William Fellner(ed,.), Contemporary Economic
Problems. Washington American Enterprise Institute, 1979.
3.
. . 2010.. . 20062012 .. . 20102013 . . . 2012.1.5.
CBS.
>>> 39
Abstract
The Effects of Work Type in North Korea on North Korean Migrants Employment in South Korea
Wha-Soon Kim
North Korean Migrants poor employment situation in the South Korean labor market including their high unemployment rate and low wage level have raised many debates over the causes of such problems. As the causes of the employment problems, previous studies have pointed out North Korean Migrants inadequacies and weak employment intention, South Koreans prejudice and exclusiveness, etc., but the importance of the cohort effect of North Korean Migrantswork experiences on their current employment has been overlooked.
Recognizing this problem and giving attention to North Korean residents work experiences, the present researcher conducted the third and conclusive study, following the previous studies A Study on North Korean Residents Work Types and Determinants of North Korean ResidentsWork Type in the Period of Marketization. The conclusion drawn from this study is that there is a significant causal relation between work type in North Korea before migration and employment in South Korea after migration, and the probability of employment or the basic livelihood benefit takeup rate is significantly different according to whether one had an formal work, informal work, or both formal and informal work in North Korea.
According to the results of binomial logit and multiple regression with data collected from 413 North Korean migrants living in Seoul and sampled through quota sampling based on the year of entry, etc., both work type and education level in North Korea had a significant positive effect on North Korean migrants employment in South Korea. An interesting finding was that the probability of employment in South Korea was higher in work types with more market economic activities (informal work>both formal and informal work>formal work) in North Korea. Contrary to expectation, the probability of employment was lowest in those who had been engaged in an formal work in North Korea. What is more, work types with more market economic activities in North Korea showed a lower probability of being a basic livelihood benefit recipient, and consequently those with an informal work were less dependent on the government than those with an formal/both formal and informal work.
The most important finding from this study is that work experience in a North Korean market enhanced economic adaptability to the South Korean labor market significantly. This suggests that North Korean migrantsexperience in working at a market in North Korea can be more useful as human resource than experience in an formal work.
40
The government has so far classified North Korean migrants experienced in an informal work into unemployed, but such a job classification system for North Korean migrants needs to be reconsidered. It is expected than future progress in the marketization of North Korea may bring improvement in the development of human resources or market adaptability among North Korean residents.
Key Words: Work Type, North Korean Migrants, Marketization of North Korea, Informal Sectors in North Korea, Employment, North Korean Work, North Korean Labor, Basic Livelihood Benefit
>>> 41
:
*1
. .
.
. 5 .
.
,
.
, ,
,
.
.
,
. ,
,
,
.
: , , ,
.
2010 1 13
. 8
*
23 1 2014pp. 41~66
42
.
. ,
.
,
?
?
2014 1 6
.
,
. 1972 74, 1991 , 2000 615, 2007 104
, , , ,
.
70 .
,
.
, ()
.
,
. ()
(contingency plan) ,
.
,
, ,
. ?
?
? ?
?
. , ,
>>> 43
.
, 1 2 ,
1 1 .
,
, .
.
.
1.
.1 ,
2
.
.
(Bruce Bennett)
(regime collapse) ,
(government collapse) .3
1990
.4
5 7
1 ,
, , 2013-19 (, 2013), pp. 1011 . 2 , p. 11.3Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse (Santa
Monica, CA: RAND, 2013), pp. 56.4Center for U.S.-Korea Policy, North Korean Contingency Planning and U.S.-ROK
Cooperation (San Francisco: Asia Foundation, September 2009). p. 2.
44
2 3 ,6 (Gary Luck)
1996 3 ( )
, , ,
(The question is not will this country disintegrate,
but rather how it will disintegrate, by implosion or explosion, and when)
.7
.
,
. 2000
8
.9
.10 .
(Army War College) (Andrew Scobell)
,11 (Paul B. Stares) (Joel S. Wit)
(Managed Succession), (Contested Succession),
51990 1995
1996 39, 1997 58 , 10
. , , ( ,
2013) p. 20.6, 23 , , 1996 3 25.7 , 1996 3 17.8 ,
3 . , 2010 7 10.92000 1030 2008
2008 4, 2009 66, 2010 65 ,
. , , p. 21. 10
, , , 13 4 (, 2006 ); , , , 4 2 ( , 2006 /); , , , 15 1 (, 2008); , : , , 9 3 (, 2008); , : 1990 2000
, , 12 2 ( , 2008); , , , 16 1 (, 2010).
11Andrew Scobell, Projecting Pyongyang: The Future of North Koreas Kim Jong Il
Regime, A Monograph of Strategic Studies Institute (Army War College, March 2008).
(: 2014.5.25).
>>> 45
(Failed Succession)
, .12
(Asia Foundation) , , 3
.13
.14 2009
5029 .15
(IMEMO) 2020
.16
.
2011 12 19
.
2 2013 12 2
.17 ,18
2014 1 6
. .
.
,19
12Paul B. Stares and Joel S. Wit, Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea, Council
Special Report No. 42 (New York: Council on Foreign Relations, January 2009).13
Center for U.S.-Korea Policy, North Korean Contingency Planning and U.S.-ROK
Cooperation, pp. 620.14
, Peter Hays and David F. Von Hippel, DPRK Collpase Pathways: Implications
for the Energy Sector and for Strategies Redevelopment/Support, The Korea Project:
Planning for the Long Term (University of South California Korean Studies Institute
Conference, 2010.8.20.21. Revised Draft 2010.9.14).15
, 5029 : ,
, , 2009 11 2 (conceptual plan) . 5029 ,
, , , 6
, . 16
, 2020 , , 2011 11 4.17 , 2013 12 4; 2013 12 11; 2013 12 27.18 , 2013 12 30.19
, , KINU 13-03 (: , 2013).
46
(illusion)
.20
(assumption) .21
(very quickly)
(with very little notice) ,22
.
2.
1989
. 1989 12
.
. , ,
, .23
. 1989 11 9 1990 3
18 ,
, 1990 10 3
. ,
, , ,
, ,
, ,
,24
20David Lai, Busting the Myths About the North Korea Problem, (: 2014.5.25). 21
Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse.22 , 2014 4 9.23
Andrew Scobell, Projecting Pyongyang: The Future of North Koreas Kim Jong Il
Regime, pp. 725. 24
, : (: , 2011), pp. 233252.
>>> 47
. ,
.25
,
. 1999 2012
39 25, 7,
3, 4 .26
.
. ,27
,28 ,29
30 ,
(wishful thinking) .31
. 5
.
, ,
.
25, , (: , 2010), pp. 452489.
26, , p. 25.
27, , , 18 1 (, 2012).
28, (R2P) :
, , 55 4 (, 2012 12). 29
, : , , 19 2 (, 2012 ).
30, : , , 19 2 ( , 2011), p. 428.
31, , , 160 (21, 2009 1), pp. 1724.
48
. .
1. ?
1994 7 2011 12
,
. 1984
.
.32
33
.34
(myth) .35
,
,
36
. ,
, , (wishful thinking),
.
, .37 .
. , 2010
,
32Andrew Scobell, Projecting Pyongyang: The Future of North Koreas Kim Jong Il
Regime, p. 25. 33
, :
, , 28 4 (, 2012 ), pp. 151152.34
, , p. 6.35
David Lai, Busting the Myths About the North Korea Problem, pp. 23.36
, (R2P) :
, p. 143.37
. , pp. 45.
>>> 49
,38
.
.39
1990
.
,
,
.
,
,
.
.40
38, , , 16 4 (, 2010), p. 69.
39 , 80%,
100%,
50%,
30%,
40%, 50% ,
, 80%X
100%X 50%X 30%X 40%X 50%, 2%. 2010
7% . , p. 71. 40
1989 9 11 9 22
. 3 ,
45 , 4km
,
.
50
2.
?
1991
,
. 2 4
, 2
7
,
.
,
.41
,
,42
.
.
,
.
( )
,
.
,43
.44
41, , , 15 1 (, 2013), p. 164.
42, (: , 2010), p. 22.
43Paul B. Stares and Joel S. Wit, Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea, p. 7;
Bruce Klingner, New Leaders, Old Dangers: What North Korean Succession Means for
the U.S., Backgrounder, No. 2397 (Washington D.C.: Heritage Foundation, April 2010),
p. 10. 44
, : , p. 225.
>>> 51
, ,
.45
,
.46
. (Responsibility to Protect:
R2P) ,
.47
,
.48
49
.
.50
. 1953
,
.51
()
,
.
.52
45Doug Bando, The Complex Calculus of a North Korean Collapse, The National
Interest, (January 9, 2014). 46Ibid.
47, (R2P) :
, p. 145.48
, , pp. 173175.49
, , , 12 (, 1997 ), p. 202.
50, , pp. 164165.
51Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse, p. 51.
52Center for U.S.-Korea Policy, North Korean Contingency Planning and U.S.-ROK
Cooperation, p. 21.
52
.
53
.
3. ?
.
3 , 5 ,
4km
.
. ,
.
,
, .
1
, .
.
, ,
.
. (Stability Operation) 1,000 13
312,000
.54
144,500 .55
10 ,
53, , pp. 4243.
54Bruce W. Bennett and Jennifer Lind, The Collapse of North Korea: Military Missions
and Requirements, International Security, Vol. 36, No. 1 (Fall 2011), p. 93.55Ibid., p. 96.
>>> 53
.
. ,
, ,
.
, .
.56
,
.
, .
.
, , , 990,000
.57
4. ?
.
,
, .
,
.58
56, (R2P) :
, p. 145.57
Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse, p. 263.58
, : , , 55 1 ( , 2012), p. 20.
54
.59
,
.60
,
.
.
.
5. ?
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
.
.
.
. 2014 3 28 ,
, 3
, 2014 4 12
59, (R2P) :
, p. 146.60
,
.
. . ,
: , , 55 2 ( , 2012), p. 105.
>>> 55
,
.
61
.
,62
.
2008 11 5029
.63 2010
1 13
.64
,
,
.65
.
.
,
61, , 6 (: , 2006), p. 350.
62Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse, pp. 56.
63, , , 15 (, 2009), pp. 67.
64 , 2010 1 15.65 , 2010 8 18.
56
,
,
,
. ,
.
1.
.
.
,
.
.
.
,
.66
,
.
,
.
.
.
,
.67 2014
.
66, , p. 171.
67 , p. 167.
>>> 57
.
.68
,
.
69 .
2.
.
1950
,
, , , ,
.70 1991
,71
.
,
.
,
68, : , p. 428.
69, , p. 8.
70, , pp. 4647.
71 ,
... .
58
.
.72
,
. ,
,
.
.73
. ,
,
. ,
,
,
74
.
,75 ,
.76
.
. 2005 8
()
72, , p. 181.
73Paul B. Stares and Joel S. Wit, Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea, p. 30.
74 . Paul B. Stares and Joel
S. Wit, Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea, p. 22. 75
, : , p. 21.76
Paul B. Stares and Joel S. Wit, Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea, p. 36.
>>> 59
,77 2009 8
3
1
.78
,
.79
,80 2014
1 10
.81
()
.82
. ,
.
.83
,84 85 86
.
,
77, : , , 20 1 (, 2011), p. 113.
78 , pp. 113114.
79 , pp. 122123.
80Julian Ryall, China Plans for North Korea Regime Collapse, The Daily Telegraph,
May 5, 2014.81 , 2014 1 13.82
, (R2P) :
, pp. 148149.83
Center for U.S.-Korea Policy, North Korean Contingency Planning and U.S.-ROK
Cooperation, p. 21. 84
, , p. 89.85
, , , Vol. 20 ( , 2007), p. 81.
86Bruce W. Bennett, Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse, pp. 274277.
60
.87
,
.88
3.
.89
.
,
.
,
.
.
90 ,
.91
,
.
,
.
.92 ,
87, , p. 51.
88Bruce W. Bennett and Jennifer Lind, The Collapse of North Korea: Military Missions
and Requirements, p. 118.89
, : , pp. 271275.90
, , (, 2011), p. 1.
91 , ( , 2009), p. 15.
92, , p. 51.
>>> 61
,
.
4.
.
,
,
. ,
(rules of engagement) .
,
.
.
()
.
,
.
.
,
.
,
.
.
.
62
, 38
.93
.
.
.
,
.
.
(paradox) .
,
.
,
.
.
.
. ,
() (), .
. 70
.
: 4 13 : 5 19 : 5 21
93, (: 21, 2013), p. 161.
>>> 63
1.
. , . : , 2010.. . 6. : , 2006.. . : 21, 2013. . . KINU 13-03, :
, 2013.
. . , 2009.
. . : , 2010. . : . : , 2011.. .
2013-19, 2013.
2.
. . . 12, 1997 .
. : . . 9 3, 2008. . . . 13 4, 2006
.
. : . . 19 2, 2012 .
. . . 4 2, 2006. . :
. . 28 4, 2012 .. . . 16 1, 2010. . . . 16 4,
2010.
______. : . . 19 2, 2011.
. . . Vol. 20, 2007. . :
. . 55 2, 2012 6.. . . 15 1,
2008.
. : . . 20 1, 2011.
64
. : 1990 2000 .
. 12 2, 2008. . . ,
2012.
. . . 15, 2009 3.
_____. . , 160, 2009. . (R2P) :
. . 55 4, 2012 12. . . . 15 1, 2013. . : .
. 55 1, 2012 3.. . .
18 1, 2012.
. . , 2013.
Bando, Doug. The Complex Calculus of a North Korean Collapse. The National
Interest. January 9, 2014.
Bennett, Bruce W. and Lind, Jennifer. The Collapse of North Korea: Military
Missions and Requirements. International Security. Vol. 36, No. 1, Fall
2011.
Bennett, Bruce W. Preparing for the Possibility of a North Korean Collapse. Santa
Monica, CA: RAND, 2013.
Center for U.S.-Korea Policy. North Korean Contingency Planning and U.S.-ROK
Cooperation. San Francisco: Asia Foundation, September 2009.
Hays, Peter and David F. Von Hippel. DPRK Collpase Pathways: Implications for
the Energy Sector and for Strategies Redevelopment/Support. The Korea
Project: Planning for the Long Term. University of South California
Korean Studies Institute Conference, 2010.8.20.21. Revised Draft 2010.9.14.
Klingner, Bruce. New Leaders. Old Dangers: What North Korean Succession
Means for the U.S. Backgrounder (Heritage Foundation). No. 2397, April
7, 2010.
Lai, David. Busting the Myths About the North Korea Problem. (:
2014.5.25).
Scobell, Andrew. Projecting Pyongyang: The Future of North Koreas Kim Jong
Il Regime. A Monograph of Strategic Studies Institute. (: 2014.5.25).
Stares, Paul B. and Wit, Joel S. Preparing for Sudden Change in North Korea.
>>> 65
Council Special Report No. 42, New York: Council on Foreign Relations,
January 2009.
3.
..
Ryall, Julian. China Plans for North Korea Regime Collapse. The Daily Telegraph.
May 5, 2014.
66
Abstract
A Feasibility Analysis Regarding Discussion on the Collapse of North Korea and Tasks:
to Recognize and Minimize the Side Effects
Hwee-Rhak Park
Discussions over the collapse of North Korea began as a hope to connect the possible North Korean collapse to the unification on the Korean Peninsula. However, they made South Korea to divert from a peaceful reunification through co-existence with North Korea. They made the South-North relations more antagonistic than before.
Actually, the possibility of the North Korean collapse seems to be very low contrary to the belief in those discussions. South Korea does not have much legitimate cause to intervene in North Korean instability. South Korea should overcome serious obstacles, before it deploys its military forces into North Korea. South Korea has endured huge side effects for this not much possibile scenario, the collapse of North Korea.
South Korean people should recognize the side effects and minimize discussions on this issue. It should emphasize its goodwill by assisting in North Korean stabilization efforts in case of North Korean unrest. However, as a contingency plan, it can persuade international society for the recognition of its inherent right to intervene in North Korean affairs, strengthen its contacts with North Korean people and take necessary measures to pass the De-militarized Zone as fast as it can, if necessary.
Key Words: North Korea Collapse, North Korea, North Korea Instability, North Korea Stabilization
>>> 67
(814)
*
**1
. . : 3.0
. 814 .
2013
.
,
.
814
(1.5 ), 2007 104
(2.0 )
. 814
.
(3.3km2)
,
10 ,
.
2
,
.
,
.
: , , ,
,
.
166 2013 8 14
. ?
.
** 2013 (, 12 6)
.
**
23 1 2014pp. 67~90
68
, 2013 8 14
( 814 ) .
,
.
814
.
814 . (2013)1 814
.
.
.
(2007)2 3
. ,
, .
.
, 3(, , ) , ,
, .3
2003 6 10 . ,
, ,
.
.
.
.
.
.
1, , , 2013-12 (, 2013).2, (, 2007).3, , , 12 2 (KDI, 2011); , , , 13 5 (KDI, 2011).
>>> 69
814 , 814
.
. ,
.
, , .
. 814
1.
.
,
.
, .
,
. 2000
, 1999 3 33 . 2000 1
3 (,
, ) , .
2003 12 , 2005
10 56 . 2008 ,
, .
2012 19 7 , 2013 166
11 36 ( ).
70
(: )
: , .
, (WIN-WIN) .
,
.
, .
,
, . ,
4.
. ,
.5
(Site) 3.3 6 1/8
4, 3 , Issue&News,
(: 2013.10.14).5
. , 2013 10 25. 6 (13 14) ,
. , (: , 2005), pp. 45.
>>> 71
. (Pilot Project) .
40% ( ). , 10
,
.
, .
(: )
()
( )
331
236 250 185 203 94(126) 99(40%)
195 213 166 178 83(123) 78(37%)
41 37 19 25 11(3) 21(57%)
( )81
2013 4 .
: .
.
.
.
.
,
.7
, 8
.
3 , , ,
7, , ( , 2012), pp. 97
98.8 2()
.
72
.
,
(Global) .
(1) 3
, .
. 9
, .
13 .
(2002.11.20.)
, , (2003.12.11.),
(2004.1.29.) .
,
.
, .
(DMZ)
.
(2003.1.27.)9 .10
,
.
. 2005
12 2013 10 1,300 .11
( 29
2). .
,
9, (: , 2005), p. 47.10
, : , , 9 1 ( , 2013), pp. 4546.
11 , (: 2013.10.15).
>>> 73
. 3
. .
, , ,
4 (Zone) (-DMZ--) .
,
. , () () .
(2)
.
, .
( , , ) . ,
.12
, . 32
.
( )
. .13
. ,
, .
(30%)
(49%60%)
(10%21%)
12 ,
. , 1 (: , 1985), pp. 502503.
13 , , (2007.8), p. 119 .
74
. ,
.
. , 14 ,
15 .
(3) 16
,
.
.
46
.
, .
.
.
, ,
. 2000 12
16 ,
, 2003 10 12
.
.
,
, .
, .
14 (
(2011) 45 ). ,
, pp. 143145.15
,
. , (: , 2011), p. 27.
16, : , pp. 4850.
>>> 75
, .
, ,
.
2.
.
. 2013 3 27 ,
. 4 3
,
. 4 9 5 3,000 ,
.
, 4 26 .
5 3 7 .
6 6
, .
, ,
. 2013 6 21
65 1,946
, 7 3
.
7 7
.17 8 14
, 9 11
.
17 , pp. 4243.
76
2013.3.27. ,
4.3. , ,
4.9. , 5 3,000 ,
4.26. , ( )
5.3. , 7
6.6. , ()
6.12.
7.3. , ()
7.4. , ()
7.5. 7 6
7.6.7.
8.14. (7)
9.11. (2) 814
9.16. :
9 16 .
. 10 30
123 119 ,
83% 4 4 .18 2013
. 123
, 5 2
, 98% .
2013. 2. 2013. 10. 2013. 12.
123 119 122
53,466 44,000 52,329
: , .
18 , 2013 10 25.
>>> 77
.
,
.
(1)
(2003.1.27.)
.
.
7
, , , 7 , ,
.
(2002.12.16.) 2 ,
, ,
(1) (3
) .
2 2
. 8 , .
.19
(2)
22
, , .
6 .
.20
19, : , pp. 5152.
20 , p. 52.
78
(3)
, ( 46).
( )
.
,
.21
3. 814
. 814 :
.
,
.22
(1991)
,
.23
?
.
.
(2005)
, ,24 .
21 , pp. 5357.
22, , , 3727 (2009.3.5).
23 [ 1999. 7. 23, , 9814525, ].
,
,
,
.24
21( ).
>>> 79
(2005) (7,
20, 21, 27 ).25 2
.
814
.
,
.26
, ,
.
.27
.
.28
. 814
814 ,
, , . 814
(9 ),29
,
[(Radio Frequency IDentification: RFID) ],
, .
.
.
.25
, 2013 (: , 2013), pp. 11861188.26
, , (, 2008),
p. 308.27
,
. 28
, , , 3991(2011.11.12). 29
2003 9 30 .
80
(10 31 ),
(13 , 12 ), 9 16
( ).
814
2013 814 (911 )
- ,
,
,
.
- ,
,
( ).
- ,
( ).
- ,
(
).
- ,
.
-
, 9
.
-
.
-
,
.
.
- ,
10
.
-
,
.
-
13 , 4
.
* , 12
.
- 9 16
.
: , .
>>> 81
814 .
, .
,30 ,
.
.
, .
814
, ,
, ,
( )
.
, 1.0 104 2.0 , 814 1.5
. 104
, 814
( )
.
814 2007 104 . , 104
( ),
3 ( ).
30, , p. 2.
82
104
104 (2007) 1 (2007.11.13.)
1
2
-
,
.
1 , 08 2
* , /12
2 / (
- , )
12.11. - , 11.20.21.
* 12 1 ()
- : 0722 ,
- : ,
- :
* 12 ()
: , .
. 814
814 .
.
2013 12
, 2014 3 1
. 3 2014 1 15 28
, 2014 1 7 .
KT ,
. PC
.31
.
3
, .
2013
31 , 2014 2 9.
>>> 83
. 2013
, , 2013
,
, .
,
.
.
,
, .
, .32
814 .
,
,33 .
814 (2014.3.13. )
2013.9.30.
2013.12. ( 5)
2014.3.13. 1 ( )34
3 352014.1.28.
2013.2.7.
2013.12.23. 2013
( )
2013.9.16.
32 2014 3 3 1 5%, 8 1
5% . , 2014 3 17. 5% 25 , 2013
, 2
. , 2013
.33
2014 , 2 .
84
. : 3.0
814 .
(135) ,
2 .
? (Take-off)
. .
10 ,
.
( Project) .
.
, ,
,
.
1. 2
. 3.3
(, , , )
.
(26)
, , .
.
.
. 104
2 ( 5, 3.3)36 .
34 , 2014 3 13.35 , 2014 2 10.36
14 .
, (: 2014.5.30).
>>> 85
2.
,
,
(
). ,
.37
( ) ,
.
.
, .
(two-track) .38
,
.
. 6
.39
, 6 UN .40
.
3.
10
37 1874(2009.6.)
, 2011 4 (CSR)
. , 2013 8 15.38
()
. , 2013 11 7.
396 .
40
.
,
. , , , 6 1 (, 2010), p. 157.
86
. ,
. ,
,
. ,
524
.41
, .42
. (rowing)
,
(enabler) .43
.
4.
(2013.5.29.)
. ( OKP ,
P&T )
(10.18.).44 11
(11.11.) .45
41 ,
(: 524 ) , ,
.42
, 2008
. , , pp. 45.43
(Multi level governance)
.
(Stoker 1998; Goss 2001; Pierre&Peters 2000;
Leach&Percy-Smith 2001) . , ,
( , 2008), pp. 4854.44 , 2013 10 19.
>>> 87
, 2
.46
,
.
.
.
814 1.5 , 104
2.0 , 3.0 .
3.3 ,
10 ,
. 814
. 2 ,
, ,
.
.
.
.
.
.
: 3 20 : 5 12 : 5 21
45 , 2013 11 11.46
3 .
3 .
88
1.
. . : , 2005.. . : , 2005.. . : , 2011.. 1. : , 1985. . 2013 . : , 2013.
2.
. . . 2013-12, 2013. : .
. 9 1, 2013.8.______. .
, 2008.
______. . , 2012.
. . . 2007.8. . . , 2007.
. . ,
2008.
. . . 3991, 2011.11.12.
. 3 . Issue&News. (: 2013.10.14).
. . . 12 2(KDI), 2011.
. . . 3727, 2009.3.5. . . . 13 5(KDI),
2011.
. . . 6 1, 2010.
3.
. .
. .
..
>>> 89
...
90
Abstract
Evaluation of 814 Agreement and Developmental Improvement of Gaesong Industrial Complex
Kook-Yeol Bae
There was an event Gaesong Industrial Complex was suspended and restarted op-eration, in 2013. Through this event, I evaluated the agreement between authorities of North-South(hereinafter referred to as 814 agreement) for re-operation of Gaesong Industrial Complex. Also, I insist Gaesong Industrial Complex has to be improved one step further. I evaluated 814 agreement was for normalization of Gaesong Industrial Complex (version 1.5) and 104 agreement in 2007 was to expand Gaesong Industrial Complex(version 2.0). Furthermore, I prospected implementation of 814 agreement will be completed in the near future. This paper presents that current Gaesong Industrial Complex(3.3) was a pilot project for the formation of inter-Korean economic community. At this point, 10 years have passed since Gaesong Industrial Complex was developed, I insisted Gaesong Industrial Complex should be main project. To do so, the North and South have to promote the second stage of development. Also they have to resolve North Korean nuclear issue and promote the activation of Gaesong Industrial Complex by two tracks. And then, by sharing the role between the government and pri-vate investors, Gaesong Industrial Complex must be operated by the private sector. North and South need to promote the agreement to treaty in order to request the im-plementation of obligations under the international law to the other party.
Key Words: Gaesong Industrial Complex, North-South Agreements, Inter-Korean Economic Community, North Korean Nuclear Issue, Treaty
>>> 91
:
*1
. .
. .
.
.
3
.
,
.
. ,
. .
2003
,
.
,
.
.
: , , , ,
*
23 1 2014pp. 91~127
92
.
.
.
,
.
.
. ,
.
.
( )
.
.
.
.
.1
. ,
.
.
.
.
, ,
1, , , 11 (2002), pp. 323386; , , , 11 2 ( , 2009), pp. 231266; , , , 3(, 2000), pp. 115130 .
>>> 93
. 3
. 3
4
.
.
.
2011 12 8
.
. ,
,
.
, , ,
. ,
.
, , ,
? ,
. ,
.
.
.
1.
.2
2, () (: , 2004), p. 105; , () (: , 2003), p. 124.
94
2 3 .
3
.4 ,
,
,
,
, .5
.
.
6 7 .
.8
.
3 1999.7.23. 993690 ; 2004.11.12. 20044044 ,
.4, , , 228 (, 1989), pp. 59; , 3() 4(), , 12 2 (, 2006), pp. 924; , , , 638 (, 2009), pp. 289333.5, , (: , 2008), p. 106
.6(National Treatment)
.7(Reciprocity)
.8 ,
.
>>> 95
. ,
9,
10 .
2.
.11
.
. 1990
.
.
.
3. () ()
1968 1972
. 1972
( 116 1)
(120)
.
9, , p. 377.10
, , p. 126.11
, , , 6 (1994), pp. 358.
96
.
1972 1989
.
1986
.
.
4.
(1)
.
, ,
. , 1996, 2003
, 12
12(Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works) 1886
.
.
4 . , .
.
,
. ,
. ,
, ,
.
.
, 50. ,
50
50 50
. 50
50
. , .
>>> 97
,
( ) ,
13 . 24
,
24 , ,
.14 , 24
.15 ,
16 17 .
(2)
1
(countries) ,18
(multilateral
treaty)
.19
(, )
. ,
.13
5 2 ,
. , .14
2008.7.8. 200780093 .15
2010.7.1. 200868090 .16
, , , 21 ( , 2003), p. 223.17
. ,
.18
Ian Brownlie, Principle of Public International Law(6th ed) (Croydon: Oxford University
Press, 2003), p. 93; B. R. Bot, Non Recognition and Treaty Relations (Leyden: A. W.
Sijthoff, 1968), p. 133.19
Robert Jennings and Arthur Watts, Oppenheims International Law(9th ed.) (London:
98
,
,
.20
.
,
, 5, 7
( 5 1)
.21 22
Longman, 1992), Vol. 1, pp. 177178.20
, 160(
156), 1991
,
,
,
.21
,
.22
,
- ( 2007 12 14 ) -, , 50 (, 2010) 1 .
>>> 99
.
1.
.
(20.12.2420()10012 [
]) .23
.
X1
,
. X2 ,
2002 9 30, ,
, 3 X1 .
231 (19.12.1418()5640) , , , 58 8 (2008), pp. 10991103; , , , 21 (21COE2008), pp. 263277; , , , 1366 (2008), pp. 172175; , , , 2 (2008), pp. 251254 . 2 (20.12.2420()10012)(10012) , , 5 (2009), pp. 251254; , , Law & Technology 45 (2009), pp. 6071; , , 4 (, 2009),pp. 228229; , , , 36 (2009), pp. 182198; , , 1376 (2009), pp. 321323; , , , 576 (2009), pp. 6569; , , 2 (, 2011), pp. 3435 . 3 , , Law & Technology, 56 (2012), pp. 8286; , , AIPPI, 57 9 (AIPPI2012), pp. 562583; , , , 1437 (2012), pp. 67; , , , 11 (2012), pp. 237240 .
100
Y( TV ) 2003 6 30, 1 TV
TV
027( )
6 28 X
2 11 .
X ,
X1
Y
X1
X2
.
2003 4 28,
4 28 .
.
.
.
. 1
1 (19.12.1418()5640)
. ,
6 3
X .
.
X
>>> 101
X
709
. (20.12.2420()10012) X
X1 , X2
12 .
,
, ,
, ,
.
.
Y X
. 6 3
.
,
.
(3(1)(a)),
(3(1)(b))
.
102
.
,
.
3(1)(a)
6 3
.
X
. X .
2.
2003 4 .24 1975
.
,
.
25 .
. 2003
,
.
.
24 28(2)(c) (3).
25 , 2003 4 22 ()
.
>>> 103
()
.
. ,
. .26
3.
X 2004 5 25 NHK
NHK . NHK
. 5 25
,
. , ,
, NHK KRT
TV
.
X TV .
TV 2003 5 21
. TV ,
, .
,
. 2003
6 30 027
.
26 18 6 27,
,
8 31 .
104
4.
.
. .
, . ,
.
. ,
,
.
.
.
1.
. ,
.27
,
27
( 29).
>>> 105
.
3 1(a)
6 3
.28
2.
29
, ,
.
.
,
( [], []).
30.
24 32
28 , 1366 (2012), p. 94; , 2142 (2012), p. 79.
29 48.6.5 51 p. 197 [], 52.2.14 841 p. 26 [], 19.12.1418()5640 [], []23.9.1521( )417 [] .
30
. ,
. (1959 618
)
, 32
.
, .
106
.
,
.
( 31).
24, 32
. ,
.
.
.
( 6 1), (
6 2), ( 6 3)
.
31 (1921 99) 24
(1921 96) 32
,
.
>>> 107
.32
, ,
.
.
,
( 1). [
1]
,
.
(3
(1)(a)),
(3(1)(b))
.
,
.
.
,
.
32, (, 1970), pp. 239240.
108
(3 1(a)),
(3 1
(b))
, 3 1
.
,
. ,
. 1886
(1886 2)
( 3)
. 1896
,
.
.
. ,
.33
.
(
[ ],34 []).
33, , 51 (2011), pp. 4041; , , (, 2012), p. 523.
34
( 73 2, 3)
>>> 109
(Patent Cooperation Treaty: PCT)
35.
( 73 2, 3)
.
,
.
(2006 8 31)
.
2003 ,
.
( )
.
. , ,
.35
1970 6 19
(, PCT, 1441 (2012), pp. 143146).
110
36 37(
38).
,
( [ 1])
( [ ],
[]) .
3.
.
.
39 . , .40
,
.41
,
36
.37
() 2006 6 8 , ?
2006 6 16
.
.38
. , 1
.
.39, PCT, p. 145.40, , 2(, 2011), pp.
3435.41, () 2 (, 2004), p. 58.
>>> 111
.
.
42 . ,
. ,
.
. ,
. ?
.
.43
44 . ,
,
.45
42 , (Scheldt) 1863 1865
. ,
1910
. , 1924 1929
( )
. (, , pp. 268269.
43, , p. 35.44, 4 (, 2007), pp. 4243.
112
.46
,
.47
,
.48 ,
,
.
,
. ,
.49
.50
45, (, 1994), pp. 175176.46, , pp. 268
69; , : , p. 229; , , p. 174.
47, , p. 85.48
. ,
.49, , p. 40.50, , p. 273.
>>> 113
.
3
51
. .52
.53
,
(free ride)
.
,
.
. , 54
. ,
55 56
51, , p. 252.52, , AIPPI 57 9, pp. 562583;
, , 5, pp. 251254; , , Law & Technology 45, pp. 6071.
53, , (20) (, 2009), p. 13; , INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, 11 (21COE2006), p. 9; , , 20 (21COE2008), p. 1; , (1), 28 (21COE2010), p. 206; , , (, 1996), p. 13; , , 55 (2003), p. 14.
54, , Law & Technology 45, p. 62; , , AIPPI 57 9, p. 567.
55
114
.
.
.
3
.57
( ) ,
( ) .
.
. , , 3 (, 1994), pp. 1314 1 ,
.
,
. , 13 (, 2007), p. 51
. , , 36(2010), p. 103
.
(Regel) (Prinzipien) .
(Regel) (all or nothing) ,
(Prinzipien)
(, (), 133 5 (1993), p. 15; , , 344 (2009), p. 69).
56, ()(), 140 6 (2009), pp. 639687; , ()(), 1411 (2009), pp. 4591 .
>>> 115
,
.
58
. 59 ,
,
.60
3() 61 ,
.62
. , ,
57, , Law & Technology 45, p. 63; , (), 120 6 (1999), p. 959; , , () (, 2003), p. 312; , , 560 (, 2007), p. 6.
58, , () (, 1995), pp. 8693; , (1), 1087 (1996), pp. 126131 ,
.
,
.
.59
.
1975 .60
, (, 1999), p. 51; , , 19 (1998), p. 42 29 .
61 ,
.62, 709, NBL 936
(2010), p. 53.
116
,
( 98 263). ,
WTO 12 1 (State)
(separate customs territory)
. , (State)
WTO , WTO TRIPS 9
164
.65
WTO
,
. ,
.
63 98 2
.64
TRIPS 9 1 1971 1 21
. , 6 2
(, 201123 (, 2011), p. 367).65
TRIPS
. (Marrakesh Agreement Establishing
the World Trade Organization: WTO ) 12 1 (State)
(separate customs territory) WTO
WTO
. , WTO
WTO . WTO 12
1 (State) (Separate Customs Territory
of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu) WTO
(Member) . ,
WTO (Member) WTO
. ( TRIPS )
WTO TRIPS 9
( WTO (Member)
)
WTO (Member) (State) .
>>> 117
.
(1) 1
,
.
.66
, [ 1]
. , TRIPS
(countries)
.67
1
68 (countries)69
.
1 countries
States ,
66, , 51, pp. 2644; , , pp. 228229; , , pp. 263277.
67, , pp. 174175 States countries
.68, 201123, p. 526.69
1 States countries.
States pays 1928
countries .
.
118
.70
.
,
. ,
,
(countries) , ,
, .71 ,
, .
, ,
.
(2) 3 1
. 3
1 .
,
(
) (3 1(a)2 ),72
70, , p. 229.71, , pp. 274
275; E. Lauterpacht, The Contemporary Practice of the UK in the Field of International
Law: Survey and Comment V, ICLQ, Vol. 7 (JulyDecember 1958), p. 93.72
1886
1967
.
>>> 119
(3 1(b)) .73
.
,
,
.
,
.74
3 1
.
,
.
,
3 1
( ) , . ,
.
, []
( 73 2, 3),
73
1896
.74, , pp. 4041.
120
. ,
.
() . ,
.
+( ) .
(2006 8 31)
. , 3 1
.
(3, 4, 6 )
.
.
.75
75
.
( 1)
. ,
.
>>> 121
WTO
.
4.
,
(3(1)(a)),
(3(1)(b))
. ,
( ).
,
.
(
)
.
+ ( ) . ,
3 1 ( [ 1]),
( [ ],
122
[ ])
.
.
3 1
3 1 ,
. + ( )
.
. ,
.
. , TRIPS
.
,
.
.
3
.
,
>>> 123
.
. 3
.
,
. ,
.
. ,
. .
2003
,
.
,
.
,
.
.
.
: 4 20 : 5 18 : 5 21
124
1.
. (). : , 2004.. (). : , 2003.
Bot, R. Bernard. Non Recognition and Treaty Relations. Leyden: A. W. Sijthoff,
1968.
Brownlie, Ian. Principle of Public International Law. 6th ed. Croydon: Oxford
University Press, 2003.
Jennings, Robert and Arthur Watts. Oppenheims International Law(9th ed.).
London: Longman, 1992.
. 201123. , 2011.. . , 1970.. 3. , 1994.. 4. , 2007.. . , 1999.. 13. , 2007.. () 2. , 2004... , (). , 1995.. . , 1994.
2.
. . . 21 2003.. . . 228 1989.. . . 1994.. - ( 2007 12
14 ) -. . 50 2010.. . : , 2008.. 3() 4(). . 12 2 2006.______. . . 638 2009.. . . 3 2000.. . . 11, 2002.. . .
11 2, 2009.
>>> 125
E. Lauterpacht. The Contemporary Practice of the UK in the Field of International
Law: Survey and Comment V. ICLQ. Vol. 7, 1958.
. . (). , 2003.
________. . , . 36, 2010.
________. . AIPPI. 57 9, 2012.________. .
. 560, 2007.________.
.(). . 120 6, 1999.________. . Law & Technology. 45,
2009.
________. . . 5, 2009.. .
. 1366, 2008.. . .
1376, 2009.
. PCT. . 1441, 2012.. ()
. . 140 6, 2009.________. ()
. . 1411, 2009.. . . 1437, 2012.. .
. 2(), 2008.. . (
20). , 2009.. . . 55(), 2003.. INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY. . 11, 2006.. .
. 51, 2011.________. .
. , 2012.________. 709. NBL.
936, 2010.
________. . . 20, 2008..
126
. . 58 8, 2008.. . . 36,
2009.
______. . . 11, 2012.. . .
576(), 2009.
. . . 344, 2009.. . 2. ,
2011.
. . . 19, 1998.. . Law & Technology. 56, 2012.. (1). .
28, 2010.
. (1). . 1087, 1996.________. ()
. . 133 5, 1993.. .
. 21, 2008.________. . 4. ,
2009.
3.
. () .
2003.4.22.
>>> 127
Abstract
Protection of North Korea Works and Berne Convention
Joo-Hyoung Lee
In the cases of copyright of North Korean literary productions in South Korea, South Koreas courts have consistently declared that South Korean copyright law could immedi-ately be applied to such cases based Constitution of South Korea. North Koreas joining of the Berne Convention in 2003 is very meaningful in the respects that another legal basis for protection of North Korean works in South Korea has been added and that we are also able to ask North Korea to guarantee the national treatment principles and the minimum rights principles of the Convention in the case of copyright infringement of South Korean literary works in North Korea. But, there still remain some problems in directly applying Berne Conventions clauses regarding applicable law to those cases because the two parties have never approved each other as a country and Article 3 of the Constitution which has priority over those clauses in South Korea, still has regulatory power in South Korea.
Key Words: Disapproval of the State, Works, Berne Convention, North Korea, Japan
>>> 129
:
*
**1
. .
. .
.
,
. ,
.
,
. TV
, 2009
1 2012 12 4 . 2009
,
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
: , , , ,
TV,
** 2012 ()
(NRF-2012S1A5B5A07036218).
**
23 1 2014pp. 129~155
130
.
,
.
,
.
,
.
.
,
.
.
(reproduction) ,
.
3
,
, .
2010 12 26
.
.
.
.
,
. ,
?
.
. ,
>>> 131
?
,
?
, ,
,
?
?
,
,
.
. 2000,
.
.
.
,
.
,
TV
.
. 2009
1 2012 12 4 . 2009
.
132
.
1.
.
.
, , ,
, , , ,
, .
.
,
, , .
, .
1
. .
. , , , , ,
.
.1
2
, ,
1 , 2 (: , 1992), p. 1762.2 --
.
19321934.
1934 1
. , ,
.
.
>>> 133
.
, ,
.
.
.
.
.
, ,
.3
.
1949 3
. ,
.
1967 525
.4
3
, , , ,
, .4 , (525
) .
.
. , (: , 2000), p. 314.
134
,
, ,
. 1980
.5
6
.
. 2000
,
.
1990
,
. 1991
,7 1997
.8
2000 ,
. 2002
5, , , (: , 2006), p. 267.6
.
,
.7, , 43 (: , 1996), p. 170. 8, , 14 (: , 2000), pp. 326329.
>>> 135
.
2.
,
.
, ,
9
, ,
.10
. ,
.
,
,
, , ,
.11
.
.
, .
, ,
, , .
.12
9, , , 3 (2005), p. 4610
, p. 47.11
, , (), 53 4 (2007), p. 38.
12, , , 3 1 ( , 2011), p. 338.
136
. , ,
,
.
2002 9
.
.
.13
.
2013 6
, ,
.
.14
.
. 2014
15 .
13, , 15 (: , 2005), p. 315.
14 1 2013 3 7
. 2013 8 20 9 9
,
12 .
>>> 137
2014 1 9
.
.16
,
.
.
2000
.
.
1.
.
.
.
. , , ,
, , , , , .
,
138
>, , .17
2009 2010 2011 2012
53 37 57 31
- 3 50 43 24
/ 3 6 39 -
3 3 4 3
6 1 10 19
12 1 28 10
- 1 - -
- - 13 -
33 52 33 -
22 79 44 58
- - 32 27
- - 39 12
- - 3 2
,
/ - 3 - -
2 - 6 1
- - 12 13
- - 6 2
- 5 17 -
1 - - -
138 238 386 202
17 .
,
. ,
.
>>> 139
(: )
,
. . 6
20 .
.
,
(90), (67), (60)
10 .
7.5 50
- 14 11
/ 4 / 12
5.5 13
90 10
67 24
60 13
140
1 , 2009 16.4, 2010 26.2,
2011 37.1, 2012 21.7 .
.
(20092012)(: )
1
2009 468 3,831 1,320 26 13 5,983 16.4
2010 1,018 3,754 4,740 30 120 9,577.5 26.2
2011 1,207.5 6,502 5,122 258 384 13,561.5 37.1
2012 585 2,610 4,497 203 0 7,940.5 21.7
3,278.5 16,697 15,679 517 517 37,062.5
(: )
2009
. 2009
.
2009
2012 . 2012
>>> 141
. 2012
.18
.
, ,
. 5
.
5 10 . 2011 5
.
2011.5.1.() - /
10:4510:50
2011.5.1.() /
10:5911.05
2011.5.8.() - /
10:4210:47
2011.5.15.() - /
10:2711:31
2011.5.15.() /
10:3810:43
. ,
.
18 70,
. 4 , 100
, 4
(4.11.) 12 5 (4.13.) 1
. ,
, (2012), pp. 3334 .
142
.
. 2012 ,
.
2000
.
, 2009 22, 2010 79, 2011
118, 2012 99 .
2012 , 67 18
,
. 2012 1 9 (
) 68 . 106
64% . 2012
78 30 .
.
, .
, ,
,
.
, .
10 2009 2, 2010 3, 2011 24,
2012 16 .
12 19 .
19 6 , 5 , 6 .
>>> 143
2011.08.24.() 20:5121:00
2012.05.06.() 20:2220:32
2012.07.29.() 15:1315:31
2012.08.01.() () 21:1721:34
2012.08.30.()
16:0916:21
2.
TV
, . TV
, ,
,
.
, 27.6,
6.8 . , .20
, 2009 18,
2010 3, 2011 38, 2012 29 , 2009
33, 2010 52, 2011 46, 2012 0 .
202012 1 25 17 68%
.
144
(: )
2009 18 33 51
2010 3 52 55
2011 38 46 84
2012 29 0 29
88 131 219
,
.
2010 .
169(77%), 49(22%), 1 .
(: )
,
.
.
,
, TV .
>>> 145
,
2010.12. (16 ) ,()
2010.08. ( )
2010.12. ()
2010, 2012 (36 ) ,( )
2011 (14) ,(10 )
2011.3. 17 (13) ,( )
2011.4. ,()
2011.5.
2011.10.
,
. 2010 8
. 2009 4 28
, 1930
. 2010
.21
2011
,
. ,
,
,
.
21
.
146
3.
. , ,
.
, .
.
,
.
. , TV
.
.
,
.
.
, TV
TV CD
.22 TV
,
TV .
.
22 , (, 2011), p. 10.
>>> 147
. 2010 7
,
. 2011 12 9
6 28 7 2
TV
8 1 .23
2010 3 61
, 10
. 2011 2012 TV ,
.
,
. 2000
2025 2004
. 2004 10, 2005 10, 2006 4 2007
2, 2008 3 .24
TV TV
.
.
, ,
.
.
.25
23 , 2011 12 9.24
, (: , 2009), p. 185.25
, , 2 (: , 1993), p. 426.
148
. 2000
. 2009
.
TV ,
. 1
.
.
2012 ,
.
,
.26
. 2012 11 2013
, 2013 2 2014 1
.
TV
2012 7
. 2012 7 12 TV 7 6
.
.27
26 2013 1 6 , 2013 3 4
.27
, . 2009
.
, ,
.
>>> 149
. TV
.
. ,
.
.
.
, 20
.
. ,
.
.
2010 M
,
.
, ,
.
.
, , ,
.
,
150
.
193( , ), 195(
, , , , , ) 2 4
.28
.
.
. 2000
, ,
.
2002
.29
,
,
.
,
.
.
.30
28 (2004 ) 6 .
29 (: , 2002).
30 (2008),
(2006), (2006),
(1998)
>>